Podcast Search

The Incomparable

229: Divorce Mode

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00hello and again welcome to the

0:00:02comparable podcast number 229 we hope

0:00:07your brief detention in the relaxation

0:00:09vault has been a pleasant one

0:00:11it is January 2015 quit now and k will

0:00:17be served immediately

0:00:19this was a triumph i'm making a note

0:00:24here huge success

0:00:27it's hard to overstate my satisfaction

0:00:32that your science we do what we must

0:00:40because we can have all of us except the

0:00:48ones who are dead but there's no you

0:00:54just keep trying until you need to the

0:01:02people

0:01:05welcome back everybody to the

0:01:06uncomfortable podcast I'm your host

0:01:08Jason L it's time for us to take another

0:01:09trip into the world of video games and

0:01:11I've got an excellent panel here to talk

0:01:13about a couple of games that we've been

0:01:14claiming we're going to talk about for I

0:01:17don't know a couple years now and we

0:01:18finally got around to it so this is not

0:01:20on the cutting edge of gaming but it is

0:01:22a couple of old favorites that people

0:01:24kept asking when you're going to talk

0:01:26about portal and portal 2 and the answer

0:01:28is now right now you are so if you're

0:01:31just tuning in randomly to this podcast

0:01:32hoping in vain that finally we might

0:01:35cover portal you are really lucky person

0:01:37and haven't read your podcast app

0:01:39because this is our portal episode let

0:01:41me introduce my panel was going to talk

0:01:43about Porter with me in the standing in

0:01:46the blue portal Tony sindelar hello

0:01:48hello

0:01:50I think we can put our differences

0:01:51behind us for science you monster

0:01:54I I appreciate that standing in the

0:01:57orange portal

0:01:58oh that's like the back side of Tony

0:02:00step out of the way Tony it sorry John

0:02:03siracusa hello Jason

0:02:05the only thing you've managed to break

0:02:06so far as my heart we have returning

0:02:09this is like a little last of us episode

0:02:11reunion standing on the orange gel it's

0:02:14tiffany Arment hello hi i am beyond

0:02:18excited you have no idea

0:02:19well maybe twitter has an idea yeah

0:02:21you've been yeah you've been going out

0:02:22it's very excited i like this game like

0:02:24I like Star Wars like people like Star

0:02:26what I'll also excited and bouncing up

0:02:28and down on the blue gel its Brianna Wu

0:02:30hello what's crackalackin portals i had

0:02:34i know i had a whole portal quote ready

0:02:37but these two guys stole it thanks

0:02:39well i'm just going to default back to

0:02:41crackling already took the obvious one I

0:02:42took obscure I was nice i'm glad nobody

0:02:45said the cake is a lie that's a little

0:02:48too you know it's getting weird sounds

0:02:50solid cast without saying that but Jason

0:02:52blows and immediately got to do it yeah

0:02:53that's gonna get out the way you clear

0:02:55it just clear the room and then yeah

0:02:57we're desperate everybody gets the

0:02:59harmon yep exactly have a theory of

0:03:02comedy got here you need me to the chaos

0:03:04anyway do not look into the operational

0:03:07end of the device i first discovered

0:03:10these games completely backward in the

0:03:12sense of I had not heard of this game

0:03:16until india not co put

0:03:18still alive on his holiday playlist

0:03:20which is not holiday feet what year was

0:03:23this case about 2008 something like that

0:03:26not that bad then

0:03:27no but I didn't play the game for

0:03:29another couple here is probably i don't

0:03:32know i played this game it's been awhile

0:03:33i I didn't play this last week or

0:03:36anything

0:03:37and.and you who are all much better at

0:03:39games and i am correct me but it sounds

0:03:42like this was a small part of a game

0:03:46package and and it's not that long a

0:03:48game the original portal but it became a

0:03:51phenomenon because then i kept on

0:03:53hearing people talk about portal and and

0:03:55and then I had to play it so it seems

0:03:58like what was this kind of an accidental

0:04:00hit that it was meant to just be playing

0:04:01because I spend it was so the original

0:04:04version of it for those who aren't

0:04:05familiar was packaged with this thing

0:04:07called the orange box which was valid

0:04:09collection of you know half-life 2 and

0:04:11some half-life two expansions that never

0:04:14got finished and the new version of team

0:04:15fortress and then they have this portal

0:04:17game that was kind of talked on there

0:04:18and was sold as the orange box for you

0:04:21know the last generation of consoles and

0:04:23you know it's kind of contact on there

0:04:26and I it seems like probably they were

0:04:27not prepared for it to be as huge a

0:04:29success i mean i think everything valve

0:04:30makes it is pretty good and you know

0:04:32they have a pretty consistent hit

0:04:35delivery system but but yeah portal kind

0:04:37of really took off it was really

0:04:38exciting i remember playing it on a

0:04:39friends xbox 360 in a dark time before i

0:04:42had an xbox 360 and it was you know one

0:04:45of those friends was like you need to

0:04:46play this game come to my house and play

0:04:48it in one sitting and i did that and

0:04:50then I went and bought an xbox 360 and

0:04:52my own copy of portal not that long

0:04:53after that you played on the console i

0:04:55watch out for the pc first and i didn't

0:04:58get looking at with the UH the wikipedia

0:05:01page says they both came out the same

0:05:02time windows and xbox i would recommend

0:05:04not playing this on a console really

0:05:06like any first-person shooter it is much

0:05:09easier i would probably buy it via Steam

0:05:10right now is how i would do it if you

0:05:12have a Mac or a windows computer or a

0:05:14linux computer you could just do that if

0:05:15you don't want to concentrate we should

0:05:17establish what devices we played this on

0:05:19then I played I played both of them on

0:05:20my mac that that's what I did these the

0:05:23I didn't use a console for either of

0:05:24them

0:05:25i also did Mac for both and all I played

0:05:29on everything ok

0:05:31yeah fair enough i had win they'll beat

0:05:34us everything i'm not trying to win i'm

0:05:36just saying like about anything you

0:05:38don't like people people have complained

0:05:40about like the controls on console you

0:05:43have been like okay well let's evaluate

0:05:44this so I beat no it's not a long game

0:05:47like it's a it's an afternoon Nina stop

0:05:49beating them on console and also pc i

0:05:52played on the 360 and I play a lot of

0:05:54pipe laid a lot of first-person shooters

0:05:55on the 360 I don't really have any

0:05:56trouble with the controls it for me my

0:05:59the first person shooters that I've

0:06:01always played you know when I was when I

0:06:03look start playing them where I'm on the

0:06:05macbook marathon marathon to the whole

0:06:07marathon series and and and unreal

0:06:10tournament and some other stuff like

0:06:11that and so when when portal came out

0:06:13and and then many years later i bought

0:06:16it i want to play it on the mac because

0:06:17I felt like I actually had the muscle

0:06:19memory from that and I struggle with

0:06:20first-person shooters on consoles

0:06:22because I learn how to play them on the

0:06:24keyboard and pointing demise and so it

0:06:28was a great nostalgia trip for me

0:06:29because I had that all immediately

0:06:31snapped back the whole you know wasd

0:06:33move kind of thing man i was that was so

0:06:37that was great so on one level portal

0:06:39was just a a wonderful just hit a

0:06:42nostalgic because i hadn't played a

0:06:43first-person game on my back in a long

0:06:47time and not that many on consoles at

0:06:49that moment I think it's also as far as

0:06:50a first person goes it's pretty

0:06:52forgiving right i mean there's obviously

0:06:54some stuff that's timing involved but

0:06:56not a lot and it's not a lot of that

0:06:58kind of twitch reaction it's not like

0:07:00playing counter-strike or something like

0:07:02that word

0:07:02it's you know it's all about the

0:07:03milliseconds of clicking or anything

0:07:05like that it's it's pretty forgiving and

0:07:07fact if you overthink it as i did when i

0:07:09was playing it for a lot of the sections

0:07:11where you're flipping through portals

0:07:12and and you doing lots of momentum moves

0:07:14if you just don't touch the mouse it

0:07:16will realign your viewpoint in like

0:07:18based on the new based on the current

0:07:20new gravity but if you're a first person

0:07:22shooter player you don't expect your

0:07:24viewpoint or especially on a pc you

0:07:26don't expect your viewpoint to ever be

0:07:27realigned unless you move them out so

0:07:28the first time i played one of the

0:07:30board's important woman to take

0:07:31platforms i always constantly as soon as

0:07:33I came out of a portal I was readjusted

0:07:34in my view to be facing the right

0:07:36direction and at the same time the game

0:07:38was trying to readjust my view

0:07:39yeah and it was like why is this so hard

0:07:41until I said oh just don't touch the

0:07:43mouse and just realize you to the new

0:07:44girl

0:07:4530 and you're fine and yeah it's very

0:07:47easy to overthink it even i even i did

0:07:49that because I remember that that was

0:07:51the case with something like marathon

0:07:52you would have to reorient and and I

0:07:54would go through a portal and be like

0:07:55wait a second wait a second if I do

0:07:57nothing i'm looking in the right

0:07:59direction

0:08:00yeah it's made to its the bar is low but

0:08:02if there is there is still a bar because

0:08:04as I've tried to get other people to

0:08:06play this game thought oh this is a

0:08:07great game you can play it in like an

0:08:08hour to part of one that is and and it's

0:08:11fun and it's got a narrative and it's

0:08:13very interesting and we'll talk about

0:08:14all the good quality so I'd say out you

0:08:16you may not be a gamer but try this game

0:08:18and then just to watch people really

0:08:19fail to orient themselves in a

0:08:21first-person shooter because even though

0:08:23it seems natural for us it is a fairly

0:08:25alien concept

0:08:27no matter what maybe it's probably

0:08:28easier on the console but I think even

0:08:29then people just look at the screen and

0:08:31a bunch of thumb sticks and or you know

0:08:33look at the screen and a mouse and a

0:08:34keyboard and just don't understand how

0:08:36to navigate that world that's it

0:08:38everyone real big barrier to enjoying

0:08:40this game because you do need some basic

0:08:41ability to conceptualize the space and

0:08:43move through it

0:08:44yeah I mean I think anyone who's watched

0:08:46somebody try to play a first-person

0:08:47shooter for the first time maybe whether

0:08:50it's a you know a child or that person's

0:08:52parent or something like that it's

0:08:53there's not all that kind of natural

0:08:55take to it i mean i think we kind of

0:08:56take for granted if you can you kind of

0:08:58grew up on it that there's no you don't

0:09:01just instantly jump in and are able to

0:09:02navigate 3d world with you know wasd and

0:09:05a mouse right let's learn skill for me

0:09:08portal was kind of an easy transition on

0:09:10the mac from playing half-life I mean

0:09:12because it was just all yeah and it was

0:09:14exactly the same like the controls are

0:09:16all the same and the world's extremely

0:09:18similar and yeah so that from for me it

0:09:21was kind of just that how it happened I

0:09:23can't even imagine playing it on a

0:09:24console i can't do it i have to say I'll

0:09:27you know i was i was really impressed by

0:09:30how much better the console controls

0:09:35were between portal one in portal to you

0:09:37can tell they took a lot of time

0:09:39particularly with the light momentum

0:09:41puzzle algorithm and I i have to say

0:09:45like I thought I I understand where

0:09:47people are coming from with it being

0:09:49walking on for portal one but I thought

0:09:52portal 2i played on console and just

0:09:55enjoyed it greatly

0:09:57honestly like portal is such an easy

0:09:59game to begin with I didn't think it was

0:10:01that hard even on you know 360 or you

0:10:04know

0:10:05yeah we're plated yeah the guy i try to

0:10:10explain this bill I think you're right

0:10:11that there's this fundamental literacy

0:10:12about about first-person shooters and

0:10:14moving into 3d World and using abstract

0:10:17controls to control you know your

0:10:19perspective and that we can take for

0:10:21granted as being something that that you

0:10:23know well of course it's a shooter it's

0:10:24fine it makes sense beyond that though

0:10:27one of the things I really like about it

0:10:29is as somebody who's not you know you

0:10:32like I struggled with the last of us it

0:10:34is easier this is true but i also love

0:10:37that it was as people always say the

0:10:39first person puzzler i love that it used

0:10:42the the skills i had built up such as

0:10:45they were the literacy of first-person

0:10:46shooters to solve puzzles i'm really

0:10:49interested in like how games teach

0:10:50things and portal does a great job of

0:10:53teaching you how to play Portal alright

0:10:55it builds really incremental II um I

0:10:57mean the puzzles are all really nicely

0:10:59designed and you know they're not too

0:11:01hard and you still get that kind of

0:11:02satisfying aha moment but it does a

0:11:05really good job especially I think

0:11:06portal to it doesn't even better job let

0:11:08things unfold and they still they keep

0:11:10adding new mechanics to a portal to all

0:11:13throughout portal 2 and there's so many

0:11:14games where it's like the mechanics are

0:11:16front-loaded right we're going to teach

0:11:18you everything you need to know how to

0:11:19play the game in the first two hours and

0:11:21then you're gonna do that over and over

0:11:22again for 6 to 10 more hours right

0:11:24portal to keep adding to that he keeps

0:11:26teaching your new things and new ways

0:11:28that things are going to intercept it

0:11:29and it doesn't equate the way thats you

0:11:31know really fun to play a little bit

0:11:34like school though because if you miss a

0:11:36lesson again having watched people and

0:11:38try to get people to play this game and

0:11:39appreciate if you miss a lesson like

0:11:40you're absent today or you don't pay

0:11:42attention because of your 4runner 12

0:11:45teachers particular concept and if you

0:11:47never really get that concept and just

0:11:49fumbled through level or forget that

0:11:50concept you can be just sitting there

0:11:52and stuck not on the navigating 3d world

0:11:55but like that's the other aspect of this

0:11:56game like so 3d worlds one thing if

0:11:58you're good first-person jersey have no

0:11:59problem with the second aspect of this

0:12:01game is do you have any aptitude for

0:12:04enthusiasm for puzzles and figuring out

0:12:08how to do that

0:12:09puzzles realize on you remembering the

0:12:11very simple you know steps that are laid

0:12:12out before this is out portals but they

0:12:14don't even give it a second portal for

0:12:15all the second part works as a memento

0:12:17marks in portals there's a few

0:12:19strategies you can do that through

0:12:20elements in is the buttons work this out

0:12:22the turrets were you know all three

0:12:24things like Tony said portal to just has

0:12:26a million of those throughout the whole

0:12:27game but even portal one if you forget a

0:12:29single one of those and like the first

0:12:31couple levels it can be you can be like

0:12:33that adventure game where you just back

0:12:35in the old days we'd said you'd spend

0:12:36months stuck like in a room 100 venture

0:12:39game because there was no internet and

0:12:40you can figure it out and when you did

0:12:42you just felt like a dunce it i don't

0:12:44think that will happen to anybody who is

0:12:45remotely good at puzzles but a

0:12:47surprising number of people who are good

0:12:49at first person shooters have no

0:12:51interest in puzzles whatsoever when I

0:12:53think this game is as a weird mix of

0:12:55like I mean there are some very specific

0:12:56type of puzzle in that they're all these

0:12:58kind of spatial reasoning puzzles right

0:12:59now so i mean i think a lot of people

0:13:01who are familiar with first-person

0:13:03shooters build up some spatial reasoning

0:13:04abilities and their ability to kind of

0:13:06navigate 3d space but you know there's

0:13:07some people who that's gonna probably

0:13:09not really resonate with they're not

0:13:10going to enjoy that the big conceptual

0:13:12hurdle is the fact that you have a

0:13:13portal gun and that is the elbow they I

0:13:16mean you would think that like that is

0:13:17the most obvious thing about the game

0:13:19like the hammer discount like is then

0:13:21the name is the main mechanic of your

0:13:23game and yet i will see people looking

0:13:25at a puzzle and not being able to figure

0:13:27out how to get from point A to point B

0:13:29it's like her you have a part of like

0:13:31what you learn which walls you can put

0:13:33it on which ones you can't like if you

0:13:34can see it at this line of sight you can

0:13:36get there how can you get there but

0:13:38bored there and then like they'll be

0:13:39they'll be stuck for an hour on it even

0:13:41after playing the game a second time I'd

0:13:42have definitely come into those rooms

0:13:44where I was like oh crap how am I

0:13:46supposed to do this and then I like

0:13:47women have reported like he did you

0:13:49forget for a second in certain levels

0:13:51that you have the ability to do that

0:13:54even though that's like the basis of the

0:13:56gamepad magic thing that goes against

0:13:58the laws of physics yeah but you're like

0:13:59okay I'm in this room going to solve

0:14:01this puzzle it's getting complicated now

0:14:02especially later in the game and then

0:14:05office and you're like oh right i could

0:14:06just do this and back up in here and

0:14:08then it's done and that was the easiest

0:14:09thing ever and i just thought about it

0:14:11too much

0:14:11so if you like just like John said

0:14:13earlier if you think about it too much

0:14:14it's over you know you you're trapped

0:14:17I'll never forget when I kind of you

0:14:19know like stumped for like 30 seconds on

0:14:21like the second puzzle and portable one

0:14:23and it's like you can shoot one portal

0:14:24and I see the portal far away and shoot

0:14:26a portal next to me to get there and now

0:14:29it's like well I'm already next to the

0:14:30fixed portal i'm stuck right and it's

0:14:32like wait wait wait

0:14:33oh I can shoot another reporter way and

0:14:35then step back into the portal I just

0:14:37get in and you know everything just

0:14:39built from that so seamlessly it's great

0:14:41it's also really nice how even on a

0:14:42second playthrough or even a third

0:14:43playthrough for some people it is still

0:14:46you can still make challenges for

0:14:48yourself you have already solved the

0:14:50puzzle and you kind of know the basic

0:14:51physics of everything and how everything

0:14:52works and how the puzzles are our work

0:14:55but you can kind of challenge yourself

0:14:57to be like okay have few steps going to

0:14:59take how few portals can I throw it

0:15:01makes it really it makes it fun again

0:15:03but so is ok I feel like we're kind of

0:15:06missing the forest for the trees a

0:15:08little bit in this discussion

0:15:09I mean you know portal is portal is a

0:15:14breath of fresh air in an industry that

0:15:17is almost completely lacking in

0:15:21innovation at times and you know this

0:15:24comes from half-life which is a game

0:15:26that you know is a first-person shooter

0:15:29but has just enough of the twist on it

0:15:31to make it an interesting and

0:15:33significant game you know like the the

0:15:35physics mods for for half-life two are

0:15:38actually some of the most important

0:15:40mechanics have ever been introduced into

0:15:42the game industry and i think that you

0:15:44know like the reason people are really

0:15:46passionate about portal is it was this

0:15:50amazing mix of an innovative different

0:15:53mechanic that is just unlike anything

0:15:55ever get a game this ever come before

0:15:58it's not a game that's about mindlessly

0:16:00destroying things yeah which practically

0:16:03every game in this industry is about

0:16:05including my own and you know and it

0:16:08also has this wicked sense of humor and

0:16:12we're we're we're living in this

0:16:14industry where you know we just kind of

0:16:17all not a wink at the lie you know like

0:16:20we're all drowning and BS all day long

0:16:22and we know it we here in commercials

0:16:25and you know in the systems of authority

0:16:27around us and we're just living in like

0:16:30a very insincere society and here's a

0:16:33name that comes along and does this

0:16:35wickedly brilliant satire about it and

0:16:39it was just such a fresh experience and

0:16:43I think it's like like we don't love

0:16:45portal because like the pc controls are

0:16:47better than the console like we love it

0:16:49because it's so innovative well you know

0:16:52I i'll be honest one of the reasons why

0:16:54i am not attracted to a lot of games

0:16:57they come out and I do have many

0:16:58consoles and I you know and I i do like

0:17:02games but and this is how i felt a

0:17:03little bit about the last of this is

0:17:05like I get bored with shooting bullets

0:17:10at stuff especially if it's people like

0:17:13stuff like my favorite things in Halo

0:17:16are like driving the vehicles around and

0:17:19all that and there's there's and I mean

0:17:20really talk about both games anyway

0:17:22there is a point in Portal 2 we're just

0:17:25not only do I enjoy the fact i should

0:17:27close this point I'm not only do I enjoy

0:17:29the fact that i I've got a gun in this

0:17:31game but I don't I don't I create with

0:17:33that I don't destroy with it and i use

0:17:35my intelligence and and I get away from

0:17:38that fire firing bullets and and having

0:17:41the splash of a dead body of an alien

0:17:43hitting the floor or some other kind of

0:17:45enemy but then late in in Portal 2 there

0:17:48are several there are several levels

0:17:50where you're basically painting with the

0:17:53level the 3d level you open portals on

0:17:56drips of goo and then open them up

0:17:58somewhere else and they're kind of

0:18:00shooting out and just kind of splashing

0:18:02everywhere and you're doing a tactically

0:18:04and yet i found find myself really

0:18:06enjoying just the effort of painting

0:18:10these two these beautiful 3d levels with

0:18:12these drops of goo just for fun just

0:18:15because it was enjoyable and and that

0:18:17I'd ever Mary sunshine you might like it

0:18:19interesting

0:18:20yeah about so I i'm totally with you

0:18:22there that I I totally get the first

0:18:25person shooter metaphor and I've enjoyed

0:18:27playing shooters and yet you know is

0:18:29I've gotten older I've gotten gotten it

0:18:31just seems kind of old to me and portal

0:18:33was that breath of fresh air of like oh

0:18:35I can use these skills and have a good

0:18:37time and yeah there's some peril and

0:18:39there's something shooting at me but

0:18:40it's not i'm just outwitting them in it

0:18:42in it I really appreciate that's the

0:18:44thing that made me play there are not

0:18:46that many

0:18:46games that I played you know all the way

0:18:49through in the last 10 years and the

0:18:52portal games were not hard to play all

0:18:54the way thru like I really wanted to

0:18:56play them all the way through i like how

0:18:58in Portal to portal 2 you're constantly

0:19:00berated for being a murderer even though

0:19:02it's do a relatively nonviolent game

0:19:04compared to show the number of murders

0:19:06are committed many other that's right we

0:19:09take a break to tell you about our

0:19:10sponsor this week it is Casper you may

0:19:14have heard of them before

0:19:15Casper you know it's an internet

0:19:17mattress and I say that you're thinking

0:19:19internet mattress sounds like something

0:19:20crazy but it's not it's actually really

0:19:22awesome these our tech guys who got

0:19:25together and tried to figure out a way

0:19:26to take two amazing bed technologies

0:19:29latex foam and memory foam and stick

0:19:32them together and also make it as easy

0:19:33to order a bed as anything else you

0:19:36might get on the internet and that's

0:19:39what they did

0:19:39so these mattresses are made in America

0:19:41they are obsessively engineered and they

0:19:45have a shockingly fair price it's five

0:19:47hundred dollars for a twin 954 a king if

0:19:50you compare that to industry averages

0:19:52for premium mattresses that is an

0:19:55impressive price point

0:19:57Casper will ship direct to your door it

0:19:59comes in a box and then you open it up

0:20:01and it expands once it gets out of the

0:20:04box which is very cool and they've got a

0:20:06risk-free trial and return policy you

0:20:08could sleep on Casper for a hundred days

0:20:10free delivery painless return if you

0:20:13don't like it in the first hundred days

0:20:14they will take it back for you

0:20:17so there's really no risk here you need

0:20:19to try it out

0:20:20I've had a Casper in my house for the

0:20:23last two months i have been sleeping on

0:20:25it every night and you know what it

0:20:27really is great i enjoy it a lot the

0:20:29memory foam is there so what they say is

0:20:32just the right sink just the right

0:20:34balance and that's exactly right

0:20:35it's super soft and nice on top but it's

0:20:37supportive beneath that you were nice

0:20:40when I sit on my bed I don't feel like

0:20:42I'm sitting on the edge of a trampoline

0:20:43like on my old mattress it's really

0:20:45comfortable super nice my house

0:20:49definitely was full of people who are

0:20:51skeptical about mattresses from the

0:20:53internet with the foam technologies come

0:20:56up the there were thought by geniuses

0:20:57with crazy texts ideas and

0:21:00know what it's actually really great and

0:21:02everybody is convinced down and I think

0:21:04you might like it too

0:21:04so check it out get fifty dollars off

0:21:07toward any mattress purchase by visiting

0:21:09www.castleconnolly.com Casper like the

0:21:13ghost cas pr.com / incomparable and use

0:21:18promo code and comfortable that will get

0:21:20you fifty dollars toward any mattress

0:21:22purchase and thank you Casper for

0:21:24sponsoring the uncomfortable and for

0:21:26making the very pleasant mattress that i

0:21:28sleep on every single night in

0:21:31additionally what Briana say about how

0:21:32it being this just wickedly brilliant

0:21:34satire were her exact words since the

0:21:36chatroom loves it

0:21:37title sure but it just the way that even

0:21:40in portable one to start the way the the

0:21:44story came in to play and how everyone

0:21:47say you guys are saying that it teaches

0:21:49you how to play the game very well

0:21:51without feeling like it's teaching you

0:21:53how to play the game but it also kind of

0:21:54brings in the story without you

0:21:56realizing that there's a story coming

0:21:58you know all of a sudden Gladys's you

0:22:01know her you hear her voice you don't

0:22:03know anything about her but she'll start

0:22:05you know saying things about like oh

0:22:07you're going to be missed you know and

0:22:09you're like wait when it

0:22:10what did you know you're like hold on a

0:22:12second and then the music changes and it

0:22:15starts you know feeling a little bit

0:22:16ominous and you're like what am i

0:22:18walking into here you know it's person

0:22:20look you feel like it's just this puzzle

0:22:22game you're playing this person and

0:22:23you're walking through and i'm going to

0:22:24solve some puzzles puzzles with this

0:22:26cool gun but then it very very

0:22:29seamlessly and and slowly becomes you

0:22:32know this this intense thing that you

0:22:34and then you start finding the dens and

0:22:36you start seeing what's going on and she

0:22:38starts talking to you in a weird way and

0:22:40I just I find that so intriguing and

0:22:42like you say it's so funny and the width

0:22:44that they use and the language that you

0:22:46use you just can't help but enjoy it and

0:22:49keep going but also have a little bit of

0:22:51fear which is great the way they tell

0:22:53that story so brilliant because you know

0:22:56you're talking about her voice and like

0:22:59for the first part of the game if you

0:23:01listen to the way that they edited

0:23:02Gladys's voice they would have her like

0:23:05read three lines and they would pull

0:23:06individual words out of it and make it

0:23:08sound very disjointed and

0:23:10computer like and if you listen to that

0:23:13effect as you go deeper and deeper into

0:23:15the game they start rolling that back

0:23:18and taking it away

0:23:19so what you have like when like you're

0:23:21talking about this sinister earnest like

0:23:23start coming out then they would not do

0:23:26that affected she'd be so it was lesson

0:23:29to lesson to lesson so she becomes more

0:23:32and more human now and more and more of

0:23:35a villain until you get to like the

0:23:37final level where she's doing actual

0:23:39evil soliloquies towards you and it's

0:23:42just so awesome I mean we all agree that

0:23:44Gladys is one of the greatest villains

0:23:46and a video game right it's such a great

0:23:48character might get it yeah we already

0:23:50saw the first two lines for my notes you

0:23:52got the clever gameplay mechanic mix

0:23:54with narrative which was my over

0:23:56everything and then and then that my

0:23:57very first note was the super robotic

0:23:59voice in the beginning of portal one

0:24:00that's slowly is where you really see it

0:24:02if you go play portal what portal two

0:24:03back-to-back because portal 2 she's all

0:24:05smooth silky evil the whole time right

0:24:08versus portal 1

0:24:09well then remember the Aperture Science

0:24:11bring-your-daughter-to-work day is the

0:24:13perfect time to have protested you know

0:24:15it that the game portals is from was

0:24:18basically like an idea for a gameplay

0:24:20mechanic this poll portals mechanic and

0:24:22you can make a game with just a mechanic

0:24:24what makes it special is the head

0:24:25mechanic lots of games have cool

0:24:27mechanically you could say something

0:24:28like Three's has I interesting

0:24:31mechanically you know combine these

0:24:32tiles and the slide is interesting way

0:24:34that's a mechanic you can make a great

0:24:36game like that but putting narrative on

0:24:37top of it is you know it's like

0:24:39chocolate and peanut butter combined

0:24:41here and it's not like if you just have

0:24:43a narrative you have been a bad game

0:24:45it's not like you just have a great game

0:24:46blipping how to get back and make great

0:24:48games either way but portable such an

0:24:49oddity because it was like look you know

0:24:51it's it was made by a few people with a

0:24:53small you know tie-in type game it's

0:24:56never going to be this grand narrative

0:24:58like like a big huge triple a narrative

0:25:00game and it's never the gameplay

0:25:01mechanic was like yeah alright i guess

0:25:03it's kind of interesting but the

0:25:04combination of the two is way more than

0:25:06the sum of the parts land I i think i

0:25:08think also what kind of game it is plays

0:25:10into it brilliantly in that the way the

0:25:12way it starts you know you you almost

0:25:14expect it's like oh I get it

0:25:16they've got a clever mechanic and they

0:25:17have a series of puzzles and it's

0:25:19literally going to be I mean and you

0:25:20were led to believe that's what

0:25:21everybody thought is I'm gonna leave

0:25:23in part of all this is one of 16 right

0:25:26no yeah I guess we're just gonna do some

0:25:28things and then you get to that moment

0:25:30where it all falls apart and you flee

0:25:31and you're going down the side the

0:25:33passageways outside the things that is

0:25:35such that is one of my favorite moments

0:25:37in any game I've ever played because

0:25:39you're like what is happening now how it

0:25:41out you know i'm going to want you to

0:25:42feel that fleeing a general adrenaline

0:25:44yeah it's really like my god i really do

0:25:47have to get out of here like I have no

0:25:48usage and even at that point you you

0:25:50know that she's probably going to kill

0:25:51you at that point like this the great

0:25:53thing about you know sort of the the

0:25:55mute protagonist and half life on this

0:25:57game as well by time you get up to

0:25:59whatever that level is when the the fire

0:26:00is there and everything and they're

0:26:02going to incinerate you I you're so mad

0:26:05Gladys but she's just been needling you

0:26:07and the only the only way you have to

0:26:10take revenge on this voice that's been

0:26:12in your ear that you're pretty sure now

0:26:14wants you dead is through your actions

0:26:16in the game because you can't yell back

0:26:17and there's no like there's no

0:26:19interaction is no dialogue

0:26:21it's like you you feel like you're in

0:26:23this conflict with what is essentially a

0:26:24voiceover like again it's a small game

0:26:26and economical way to do it is just make

0:26:28the game with the mechanic and just a

0:26:30voiceover like what do you mean just

0:26:31added that it is that your whole

0:26:33narrative is just going to be voiceover

0:26:34how taking and pull it off it's it's

0:26:35very economical and the trick is have

0:26:38really really good writing and really

0:26:40really good voice acting and then all of

0:26:41a sudden this entire world and star

0:26:43conflict in your head with what is

0:26:44essentially a voice happening while you

0:26:46play puzzles like her voice she doesn't

0:26:48even affect the game just dropped you in

0:26:49and then you mean you play out each room

0:26:51and you know talk to you in the elevator

0:26:52right and you know but during the

0:26:54loading screen results you in the

0:26:55elevator and out of that doesn't like

0:26:58reading it's like reading a book this

0:26:59entire world has spun out in your mind

0:27:01like the entire game is taking place in

0:27:03your mind while like your hands are

0:27:04solving a puzzle just like I'm gonna get

0:27:06her whenever you know checking your like

0:27:08escape haha free you know

0:27:10yeah I usually find games with the

0:27:11silent protagonist like kind of

0:27:13frustrating and feel like it's kind of

0:27:14from a certain area of video games but

0:27:16it works so well in this I mean it to me

0:27:19it's weird and half life when you go

0:27:20places they're like scientists talking

0:27:22to you and you just sit there and don't

0:27:24respond

0:27:24um but it works really well in portal

0:27:27with with with glasses the main

0:27:29character with the other characters that

0:27:30they added portal 2 and it's all women

0:27:32that's true that

0:27:35don't even talk about like

0:27:37bring-your-daughter-to-work day

0:27:37self-esteem fun for girls clad is said

0:27:41in the beginning of portal 1 like how do

0:27:43you show who the character is the first

0:27:45person shooter and the very first as

0:27:47soon as you wake up in portal one you

0:27:49are forced to see your player character

0:27:51which almost never happens in any other

0:27:52game unless you shove a mirror in the

0:27:54face because going through the portal

0:27:56you see yourself entering you know to me

0:27:58like it's it's a clever way to without

0:28:01without putting a mirror right in front

0:28:02of you or without having like a readout

0:28:03over the screen saying who you are

0:28:05whatever it's totally clear that you are

0:28:08this woman and for the rest of the game

0:28:10you'll be seeing yourself going through

0:28:11portals you know I wanted to say one

0:28:13thing about the silence which is just

0:28:15you can read it as being I'm not gonna

0:28:18I'm not gonna feed the trolls right I'm

0:28:21not going to give Gladys the

0:28:22satisfaction of talking to her I'm just

0:28:25gonna ignore and roll my eyes and she's

0:28:27just she can hold the whole conversation

0:28:29by herself

0:28:29I don't need to participate instead of

0:28:31it being that why am i i'm not saying

0:28:33anything and they can't even then poke

0:28:35fun at it and portal 2 window when they

0:28:38ask you to say stuff and you you hit a

0:28:39button that makes you jump in it

0:28:41yeah maybe you have brain damage or

0:28:43maybe you don't want to talk to any of

0:28:44these annoying robot think she calls you

0:28:46a mutant monster at some point later

0:28:48later and then I think some kind of some

0:28:51kind of crazy mute or whatever but and

0:28:53then you showed up you dangerous

0:28:56mute lunatic yeah like you're playing

0:29:00the entire game and you're all your

0:29:02actions are your only revenge and even

0:29:04though everything like you know how it

0:29:05works is the game like when you get

0:29:07through a certain sequence certain audio

0:29:08is triggered but it seems like

0:29:10especially because the amount of time

0:29:12you spend solving a puzzle is variable

0:29:13depending on whether you get stuck or

0:29:15not

0:29:15and very often you'll spend a long

0:29:17period of time without hearing anything

0:29:18say because you don't trigger any other

0:29:20events like putting a portal behind the

0:29:22security cameras and hearing the little

0:29:23voice tell you have to do that or

0:29:24whatever you struggle to a puzzle and in

0:29:27your moment of triumph immediately her

0:29:28voice comes in and cut you down again

0:29:29and then you just hate her even more

0:29:31it'll calm even her just parading you

0:29:33when you're in the elevators is kind of

0:29:35its like that's a really nice take on

0:29:37like where this is here so we can have a

0:29:38loading screen right but we're going to

0:29:40you know we're going to amuse you

0:29:41well you know between puzzles so I I

0:29:44have to say I've heard

0:29:46a criticism I hear a lot from people are

0:29:48people that they don't like games that

0:29:52basically plays movies like they hate

0:29:54metal gear for instance because they

0:29:56they don't watch a story they want to

0:29:59play a story and they're they're really

0:30:00big fans of like the first person like

0:30:05you exist in this world and you just see

0:30:06it and story happens around you i

0:30:08usually don't like that i think in

0:30:11Portal I think that this game could not

0:30:14have worked if you had heard shell

0:30:16talking in the reason i think that is it

0:30:19Jason coming back to your comment about

0:30:20like you know how you felt when the

0:30:23world started you know like Gladys tries

0:30:25to kill you and you leap out the

0:30:26incinerator and like you've broken the

0:30:28fourth wall and suddenly you're behind

0:30:30the the scenes of aperture science and

0:30:33yeah you're seeing all these mechanics

0:30:35and like that just broken down scaffold

0:30:38tree and going from room to room and

0:30:39that experience is so much about what

0:30:42you the player are feeling and like do

0:30:47you remember when you incinerate your

0:30:48companion cube that was freakin horrible

0:30:51that her you kill your faithful

0:30:53companion cube and then they they twist

0:30:56the knife by saying you were the races

0:30:57her time you use a nice your face little

0:31:00companion cube by quickly than any test

0:31:03subject on record

0:31:04congratulations you do they always say

0:31:06that no matter what you know pretty sure

0:31:07yeah but from the me if it was so much

0:31:10about what you yourself felt from that

0:31:14like maybe you're a monster and you felt

0:31:16nothing

0:31:17considering your companion cube and I

0:31:19think if you had like shells speaking

0:31:22right throughout the whole game i think

0:31:23it would just be here exactly because

0:31:26the Wonder portal is exploring and

0:31:29figuring it out in your own thoughts in

0:31:31your own journey in your head is the

0:31:33reward of portal so I think this is like

0:31:36the rare edge case like it's really true

0:31:38this this criticism please and I don't

0:31:41think there are any cutscenes and portal

0:31:421 like with the exception of maybe the

0:31:44very ending of the game like it there

0:31:46are loading screens in which you are you

0:31:47know elevator and entertained by voices

0:31:49but you make everything happen and so it

0:31:51is a right is a conversation between

0:31:53voiceover audio and your actions that is

0:31:56the conversation obviously your actions

0:31:58always gonna be the same

0:31:59always going to complete his room and go

0:32:00to the next room and get it feels like a

0:32:01conversation even though you are

0:32:03essentially being led through a linear

0:32:04thing of cards and triggering a linear

0:32:07series of events that's what good

0:32:08writing can do can make you forget like

0:32:10a book like the book's gonna unfold the

0:32:11way it's going to unfold but you feel

0:32:12like it's a living breathing thing when

0:32:14you're reading because whatever you've

0:32:15got in your head as the platform is like

0:32:18going out over that fire and then you're

0:32:19running through the back hallways like

0:32:20whatever you have in your head is gonna

0:32:21be a lot more meaningful than like a

0:32:23voice actor saying like I gotta get out

0:32:25of here right i mean that no yeah and

0:32:27then we've got right to the music use

0:32:29that they have you are really really

0:32:30good really led to everything in the

0:32:32game for free in addition to the hell i

0:32:34love it just a little radio plain

0:32:36annoying on

0:32:37oh yeah I do

0:32:47i also like somebody who tends to not do

0:32:50the obsessive exploring of every single

0:32:53crevice of every single 3d area of a

0:32:57game I like that in Portal the original

0:33:01when you go behind-the-scenes I felt

0:33:03really motivated to do that partially

0:33:06because the game was leaving me there

0:33:07but also partially because of the story

0:33:09the story made me feel like as Chelle I

0:33:12need to figure out what the hell is

0:33:13going on here and then you get rewarded

0:33:15by the scenes scrawled things on the

0:33:17walls and stuff like that but I liked

0:33:20how it made me feel like oh well of

0:33:22course I need to do this thing that you

0:33:24know most gamers would probably be doing

0:33:25anyway which is trying to figure out

0:33:27what's going on by looking down all

0:33:29these weird different locations behind

0:33:31the scenes in this game and they put

0:33:33arrows on the wall to like as I organic

0:33:36way to integrate like this is applied a

0:33:38place where some people might get stuck

0:33:39so you've been seeing how long on the

0:33:41wall already anyway so if we put a

0:33:43scroll Darrow it there's a gameplay

0:33:45reason for there to be essentially hint

0:33:47in the game reminding people who might

0:33:49not be sure

0:33:50oh by the way you should go this way

0:33:51because there are places in the game

0:33:52especially when you're going through the

0:33:53mechanicals where again if you're if

0:33:55you're level first-person shooter

0:33:57awareness is not good you could get

0:33:58yourself turned around I quite

0:34:00understand especially since uh since the

0:34:01Gladys is going you're not even going

0:34:03the right way like all the time

0:34:05yeah i can imagine people believing that

0:34:06began to get lost in that type of thing

0:34:08and you've got the you know the arrows

0:34:10pointing you towards the to continue the

0:34:12game i want to talk about some of the

0:34:15other characters in the game and this

0:34:18may not be what you expect me to say but

0:34:20I maybe we can talk about the turrets

0:34:22yeah because they are just won the

0:34:25Turner care gasps I don't hate you can

0:34:28keep and I'm delightful because they

0:34:31talk and they say very strange things

0:34:33and when you when you are going to shoot

0:34:35you so you have to do bad things to them

0:34:36and then it's very sad because they yelp

0:34:39and they say sad things facebook weekend

0:34:41I love that I love that the turrets and

0:34:44they look you know interesting and

0:34:47almost you know like a more like a

0:34:49person than a or or a person robot I

0:34:53love coming across that the special ones

0:34:55and especially in portal to where they

0:34:56have like the end the ones in the den

0:34:58that sing the little song here he did

0:35:01you come across that one

0:35:06the background you hear this music and

0:35:19you're like what is that and you like go

0:35:20through and you find one of the rat dens

0:35:22and you're in there and then all of a

0:35:23sudden you find this area where there's

0:35:25three or four of them just singing a

0:35:27little song to themselves like in this

0:35:29little warehouse and it's adorable and

0:35:31then the one that you find on the

0:35:32platform right that like tells you all

0:35:34kinds of a life-affirming slightly

0:35:37religious jargon because you saved it

0:35:40from being incinerated you Robin you

0:35:42don't talking about I do from looking

0:35:44screaming vocals for keeping the merge

0:35:47to me he was cast into the balance of

0:35:50here and pick things that affected the

0:35:53defective ones are add more than the

0:35:55regular one yeah it's like I different

0:35:57save me o beautiful one I feel really

0:36:02bad for the Franken the Franken cubes

0:36:03that are the turrets the get go to

0:36:05solution and they're all messed up and

0:36:07like it's got to stick their little legs

0:36:10i try to square the trial on the ground

0:36:12until you can almost they tuck their

0:36:13legs and the cubes the robot that turns

0:36:16the turn into cubes horrible idea

0:36:18it's a phone oh right right off the bat

0:36:20and on the very first the very first

0:36:22level of portal one they try to give the

0:36:24giant whatever the Aperture Science

0:36:26whatever giant red button they try to

0:36:28give that like a personality which

0:36:30obviously the buttons don't have a

0:36:31person I by giving by giving ridiculous

0:36:33aperture science names each one of these

0:36:35things you start to get a picture what

0:36:36this company is like they're not just

0:36:38about shower curtains anymore they do

0:36:40all sorts of things science so you have

0:36:43the original script portal 2 was going

0:36:46to have you and rich it ends up being

0:36:49very much Wheatley whatley how to

0:36:51pronounce weaving really yeah weekly so

0:36:54it was like you spend a lifetime with

0:36:56weekly but the original version of it

0:36:58was going to have different levels with

0:37:00like the the space fear and the radius

0:37:03fear was the third one

0:37:05I'm

0:37:05montresor learning adventures fear

0:37:07adventures fear for food courts here or

0:37:11is it adventure two or more facts fear

0:37:14the spac the facts fear yes shredded

0:37:17carrots don't like the situation in

0:37:19which a cat in a box must be considered

0:37:20for all intents and purposes

0:37:21simultaneously alive and in short entry

0:37:24created this counts as a justification

0:37:25for killing cats

0:37:26yeah oh my god i wish i did just had so

0:37:30much personality like especially the

0:37:32space fear so I want i will whole

0:37:34spin-off game with Justin spear oh this

0:37:38is base means be made minute we need it

0:37:41but I like the adventure one because he

0:37:43was a nice

0:37:44he was a nice match for cave johnson

0:37:46came down so we got longer be the

0:37:47adventure core do you hear that make

0:37:50something just exploded

0:37:51man we are in a lot of danger this is

0:37:53like Christmas

0:37:54no it's better than Christmas should be

0:37:56its own holiday explosion all right

0:38:00let's talk about let's talk my cave

0:38:02johnson and another in the fifties worry

0:38:05we're getting a portal to hear but it's

0:38:06all kind of gets all goes together man I

0:38:10i loved i love that whole section of the

0:38:12game and we can talk about that too how

0:38:13we we start portal 2 and it's pretty

0:38:16familiar

0:38:17although we've got wheelie as our

0:38:18companion and then we've got at the end

0:38:20it's pretty familiar although its kind

0:38:21of skewed and and it's undercutting sort

0:38:23of what we expect but it also is what we

0:38:25expect portal and they did that great

0:38:27thing of building that familiarity by

0:38:28having you play the first couple

0:38:30Taylor's from portal again except now

0:38:32they're all your message i did an

0:38:33overgrown and probably they do like

0:38:35three flips because you start the game

0:38:36and you're like wow okay because glass

0:38:39in this game or not because i got this

0:38:40court thing and hit the you know

0:38:42Wheatley is has enough personality can

0:38:44be like I wouldn't be offended by

0:38:46playing a game with we have here is my

0:38:48domain because he's charismatic in a

0:38:49different way we are none of that's 192

0:38:52twist of like all glad she's still here

0:38:53big surprise but anyway she is that's

0:38:55number two and number three is all you

0:38:58thought you were it was going to be

0:38:59another game where you just you versus

0:39:00glass actually this whole thing you know

0:39:02and then you fall down the big shaft and

0:39:04then there's the cave johnson and it all

0:39:05comes together so they they they kind of

0:39:07do it

0:39:08I don't say do it too many times but

0:39:10they do I think just enough twists where

0:39:12it's kind of like two three or four

0:39:14games in one and each one gives you a

0:39:16different look just when you think

0:39:17you're getting a little bit tired

0:39:18alright so I'm just gonna go through a

0:39:19series of levels Julio Gladys back or

0:39:21item I just going to go through a series

0:39:22of levels are no actually I'm not and

0:39:24that cave johnson has its own

0:39:26progression and then it all comes

0:39:27together in the end it so it's a

0:39:28surprisingly rich structure for what is

0:39:31not very long games only long compared

0:39:33to portal 2 but you can get through to

0:39:35get part of one rather they find a lot

0:39:37of ways to reinvent that formula right i

0:39:40love that I love the cave johnson

0:39:41section for lots of reasons I love that

0:39:43it's such a change in terms of the

0:39:45palette and the and the set design and

0:39:47everything and we've got and and the the

0:39:49cut the loading screens change so that

0:39:52you know you end up with the history of

0:39:54logos of aperture science through

0:39:56history through the decades which is

0:39:58fantastic got seventies aperture science

0:40:00logo is a thing of beauty and horror but

0:40:03beauty and then we get the story cave

0:40:06johnson played wonderfully by JK Simmons

0:40:09and I really enjoy hearing his and

0:40:12stretch it strains credulity a little

0:40:13bit that it's like guess we'll take this

0:40:15recording when he will occasionally have

0:40:16a side and mark them at people

0:40:18we'll just load that one in that part

0:40:19we're not going to edit it or anything

0:40:21you're not part of the control group by

0:40:23the way you get the jail last four

0:40:25son-of-a-gun got blue paint all joking

0:40:28aside that did happen broke every bone

0:40:30in his legs tragic but informative or so

0:40:33I'm told

0:40:34the lab boys just informed me that I

0:40:36should not have mentioned the control

0:40:37group they're telling me I gotta stop

0:40:39making these pre-recorded messages that

0:40:41gave me an idea make more pre-recorded

0:40:43messages I pay the bills or i can talk

0:40:45about the control group all damn day but

0:40:47still it's it's telling his story and

0:40:49it's also giving you that kind of

0:40:50amusing like Oh apertures been around

0:40:52for awhile how did it get started what

0:40:54you know why is it the way it is now and

0:40:56while you're going through the kind of

0:40:58decrepit you know the underbelly of what

0:41:01was aperture back at the beginning and I

0:41:03just I love that section JK Simmons is a

0:41:06riot and I was really happy the entire

0:41:09time I was playing in their third like

0:41:11the retro portal section is a just was

0:41:13really enjoyable as my favorite part of

0:41:15the game every packs i go to i hope i

0:41:18can find like some exploding lemons to

0:41:20behind and keep their my desk like that

0:41:23would be awesome

0:41:24alright I've been thinking when life

0:41:26gives you lemons you make lemonade make

0:41:29life take the

0:41:30image back get mad I want your damn

0:41:33lemons what am I supposed to do with

0:41:35these demands to see life's manager make

0:41:38life through the day and thought it

0:41:40could give came Johnson lemons do you

0:41:42know who i am i'm the man is gonna burn

0:41:46your house down with the lemons

0:41:48I'm gonna get my engineers to invent a

0:41:50combustible lemon that burns your house

0:41:53down

0:41:55we're like we're like have my people GS

0:41:58accident throw throw 11 ZAPPIN just to

0:42:01just to psych the know now that the

0:42:03whole monologue was great and finding

0:42:04out plateaus his backstory and it

0:42:06doesn't let us say explicitly who she is

0:42:09but it sure doesn't into it but it

0:42:11doesn't the very at the very end it does

0:42:13because at the very end

0:42:15she says that uh Carolyn has made me so

0:42:19for those who had just I don't know why

0:42:22they're listening if they haven't played

0:42:23the game but but but

0:42:25k Johnson's assistant who he says in the

0:42:28end he's like she needs to run the

0:42:29company and you should put her in the

0:42:31computer instead of me if I die before

0:42:33you can put me in the computer

0:42:35Carol Carolyn Carolyn Caroline at the

0:42:38end GLaDOS says you know being Carolyn

0:42:42taught me a valuable lesson

0:42:44I thought you were my greatest enemy

0:42:45when all along you were my best friend

0:42:49the surge of emotion shot through me

0:42:51when I see if your life taught me and

0:42:53even more valuable lesson where Carolyn

0:42:56lives in my brain

0:42:58goodbye Carolyn

0:43:00that's a that's a nice moment and then

0:43:03of course in the song in a once you're

0:43:05gone it says that too so she's she's

0:43:07always Carolyn is always a there but it

0:43:09takes awhile for to dawn on you of

0:43:12what's of what's happening i think i

0:43:14mean you can read ahead maybe a little

0:43:15bit and figure it out but that's a

0:43:16really nice thing to as he's dying from

0:43:19moon dust poisoning i thought it was

0:43:22nice that the net the narrative that

0:43:24takes place in Portal 2 with a review

0:43:25all these things like it was one of the

0:43:27few games where I didn't have to after

0:43:29completing portal to go to a site and

0:43:30look up like what you know to what

0:43:32happened to look up and look up what the

0:43:34real story because there was i was

0:43:36interested enough in the game to like

0:43:38look at every little thing is not too

0:43:39many things to look at right so you see

0:43:40the science fair you see the potato you

0:43:43see the names and stuff like that and

0:43:44just through sort of the emotional arc

0:43:47or not so much the like the little

0:43:49little hints they give you but just the

0:43:51emotional are being made it very clear

0:43:52to me what the relationship between

0:43:53Caroline GLaDOS and she'll was at least

0:43:56as far as I was concerned and then I was

0:43:58just looking up to see if the end the

0:44:00actual evidence on the wiki pages and

0:44:02all the fan sites confirmed what I would

0:44:04I in my heart believe to be true with a

0:44:06connection between them and neither did

0:44:08didn't it either agree with it or the

0:44:10very least didn't disapprove it so I

0:44:12definitely have my headcanon for this

0:44:13game and I think that cameras probably

0:44:14pretty coat close to what the real

0:44:16Canada's you know I just like i like the

0:44:18realization and and the best part of it

0:44:20is that i love that that all happens

0:44:22while GLaDOS is with you stuck to a

0:44:25potato field because she's like not

0:44:28unite oh my god i figured out the origin

0:44:30of GLaDOS it's like no she's right there

0:44:32going like home that sounds familiar

0:44:34I don't know and that adds a whole other

0:44:36layer to it that she the potato Gladys's

0:44:39is you know stuck on your on your portal

0:44:42gun while you're learning her origin

0:44:44story that's and it's retroactive

0:44:46continuity like the line i said at the

0:44:48opening of the show I chose it because

0:44:49that's a line from portal one but it

0:44:51makes it clear as far back at portal one

0:44:53that there is an emotional relationship

0:44:55between Chell and GLaDOS which doesn't

0:44:58make sense in the context of the part of

0:44:59one universe because you don't have any

0:45:00of the backstory but once we heard it

0:45:02important to sort of in in perhaps you

0:45:05know fun coincidental retroactive

0:45:07continuity you're like oh that the stuff

0:45:09she said in part 1 Tony's makes sense

0:45:11because why would

0:45:12why would shall be breaking glados's

0:45:14heart by defeating her like there's

0:45:16obviously a relationship between these

0:45:18two personalities or entities and by the

0:45:21end of portal 2 there is you know

0:45:22there's a present relationship in the

0:45:23past relationship is revealed and it all

0:45:25starts to make sense and you know the

0:45:27beautiful ending of portal 2 that will

0:45:28get to just sort of nails at all home &

0:45:31wraps the series thus far up into a nice

0:45:34little bow have you did you see the did

0:45:37anyone find the secret

0:45:38portrait of a cave and Carolyn together

0:45:43I don't know where that is i had i

0:45:44hadn't come across that I knew about it

0:45:46from reading about the game but not i

0:45:49didn't find it in real life so it turns

0:45:51out of the UFC there's like one of the

0:45:53giant rooms there's a place where you

0:45:54can pull up to it there's just like this

0:45:56little side office with their and you

0:45:57get a little bit of extra dialogue from

0:45:59from Gladys when you're in there about

0:46:01like this being more and more familiar

0:46:03and I don't think it's a coincidence of

0:46:04what a karen looks like so yeah yeah I

0:46:07think you hop on a on a on a box and

0:46:10there's like a door that you can you can

0:46:12open from up on a box or something but

0:46:14because i did see that there's more

0:46:16dialogue there

0:46:16I like also kind of all the little jokes

0:46:18along the way about I mean after having

0:46:20played all the half-life games with with

0:46:21you know spending how many hours

0:46:23exploring all the like a sprawling Black

0:46:26Mesa kind of bland corporate complexes

0:46:28it slick but all the like repeated

0:46:30little jokes about how aperture sciences

0:46:32you know basically black mesas you know

0:46:34little runner-up secondly one out of

0:46:36Mike yet on the slides in the games room

0:46:38like how do you know him with black mesa

0:46:40yep that's all their other plaques and

0:46:42you know and they're just it's they have

0:46:44so much more character to them compared

0:46:46to you know and some of that is the

0:46:47technology that was available in terms

0:46:48of their level design but you know

0:46:50aperture science click more fun place to

0:46:52work for ya if you read the backstory

0:46:54that is on the wiki pages and perhaps

0:46:55not as well expressing the game the idea

0:46:57was like they're they had heard about

0:46:59something that black mesa was making

0:47:01they said I forget what it was like

0:47:03drainage ditches or do something to eat

0:47:06grains they said we should make one like

0:47:08that but also give it AI and that was

0:47:11needed a class project was like we could

0:47:13take something that it should never have

0:47:15artificial intelligence can we also make

0:47:16artificial intelligence that we should

0:47:18remember ordered us some of the chatroom

0:47:19should look it up but it like the

0:47:21absurdity of the idea like that the way

0:47:23we compete is to do these crazy things

0:47:25fits perfect

0:47:26with Kay Johnson once you once you meet

0:47:27the man through his recordings that yes

0:47:29that is essentially what they would do

0:47:30and it is really terrible idea as

0:47:33everyone would find out once the

0:47:34neurotoxin started flowing I want to

0:47:36talk about Wheatley briefly just to give

0:47:38people in all yeah I so I have loved my

0:47:42first podcast that i have really love

0:47:43with the Ricky Gervais show and one of

0:47:45the things that I really love about

0:47:46everybody talks karl Pilkington was kind

0:47:48of a breakout character being himself

0:47:49very strange person I always loved

0:47:52Stephen Merchant in the region based

0:47:54show because what I loved about him was

0:47:56he didn't talk a lot but whenever he

0:47:58would say something it was just insane

0:48:00and insanely funny and I just I always

0:48:02liked I always enjoyed Stephen Merchant

0:48:05so to have him be a character and having

0:48:07me this bumbling helpful but not very

0:48:10helpful turned you know turn to the

0:48:12villain of the story for awhile bumbling

0:48:15still but villain

0:48:17i I just I that infused so much humor

0:48:20into into the whole story and I just I

0:48:23thought it was a great bit of casting

0:48:24and when we were talking a couple

0:48:27episodes ago I think we mentioned I i

0:48:30think it was maybe even the last episode

0:48:31we mentioned destiny and that wizard

0:48:35came from the moon and things like that

0:48:36i just i want to appreciate a really

0:48:38nice bit of casting that having stephen

0:48:40merchant is weakly I really enjoyed him

0:48:42alway always one hour then I'll come

0:48:44back and assuming like to locate your

0:48:46dead body for burial

0:48:48alright brilliant go team see you in an

0:48:52hour hopefully if you're not dead

0:48:55I thought he was really into playing and

0:48:58I hate him he is intentionally annoying

0:49:01right i found out of sight right but but

0:49:04but then you see him breaking down but

0:49:06he's entertaining don't you think

0:49:08oh yeah I thought I guess what I'm

0:49:10saying is my my gut reaction to him like

0:49:13good performances are nuanced and you

0:49:15can you can watch them again and

0:49:17understand subtleties my got reaction to

0:49:20Wheatley was black she felt like you

0:49:23just seemed really annoying and then

0:49:26like as you go through the game and you

0:49:28like learn about his psychology and how

0:49:31like you know it feels like he can never

0:49:34you know get beyond this one single task

0:49:37and then you see him

0:49:39fail and like have a very human response

0:49:41to not being able to live up to a job

0:49:43and you see him breaking apart and this

0:49:46darkness like come over him i thought

0:49:48it's just a wonderful performance was

0:49:52not your bullet-riddled building for my

0:49:53other room he wouldn't know there's the

0:49:55crop targets were like yeah well no

0:49:58matter because I'm still holding all the

0:50:01cards I guess what they're all full

0:50:04houses never actually played cards

0:50:06meaning to learn

0:50:07I mean he's meant to be i mean that

0:50:09character is meant to be bumbling an

0:50:10annoying at the beginning so that it has

0:50:12a bit has a place to go and it and it

0:50:14does it but i do love I do love that

0:50:16character of my ego big dreams that they

0:50:20cannot live up to who

0:50:23that's right that's a nice higher i like

0:50:25the idea but also that he like they do

0:50:27again I they get away with a lot of

0:50:29twists in this thing because in it like

0:50:31but they don't do the the easy way which

0:50:33is have someone who's with you in the

0:50:35beginning who you later find out the

0:50:37entire time was plotting to be the bad

0:50:39guy and as it turns out the bad guys

0:50:41actually the good guy that is not what

0:50:43happens in Portal 2 he didn't intend to

0:50:46be a good guy

0:50:47it's just that when he got into that

0:50:48chassis it's like a all this power

0:50:50yeah and I'm very smart now so that was

0:50:52not his plan from the beginning and the

0:50:53good guys like oh actually Gladys is my

0:50:55friend or whatever

0:50:56no not really you know when she gets

0:50:59back in that thing like that that's what

0:51:01makes the ending point because you know

0:51:03Caroline deleted right you you think you

0:51:06think you know what's up with these AIS

0:51:07but you don't because glad us is it's

0:51:10never gonna be your super duper friend

0:51:12and Wheatley really was trying to be a

0:51:14good guy but just you you put them into

0:51:16that robotic frame and give him all this

0:51:18information and just things things go

0:51:21wrong so how it's gonna corrupt yeah and

0:51:23and it's it's a greater those few turns

0:51:26again and like I like a two-hour game

0:51:28they do those terms you normally get

0:51:29those number of turns like a you know

0:51:31hundred our final fantasy that game they

0:51:32cram them into two hours it's just a

0:51:34fairly good density of interesting and

0:51:37somewhat unexpected plot twists all

0:51:40which feel honest and sort of human

0:51:41which is weird to say when you think I

0:51:43I but can somebody make me a t-shirt

0:51:45that says Gladys is never going to be

0:51:47your super duper fresh and expansion

0:51:49that that's a title that is what she may

0:51:51not kill you would be like you're not

0:51:54going to the house

0:51:55let's not let's talk about we've been

0:51:57talking a lot about upside and we should

0:51:59talk about what the WHA RR maybe our

0:52:02criticisms and negative feelings about

0:52:04about portal are Breanna you wanna jump

0:52:06in

0:52:06yeah yeah I mean look this game is a

0:52:09masterpiece if I our call correctly I

0:52:11think it got a 10 back on gamespot when

0:52:14it came out I may be remembering their

0:52:15room but we we all agreed that this game

0:52:17is a masterpiece

0:52:19so yeah this is this is just nitpicking

0:52:22um I think portal two is a much stronger

0:52:27game from a narrative point of view I

0:52:30think mechanically portal two is a

0:52:34weaker game than portal 1 i'm a portal 1

0:52:38the mechanics of it basically came from

0:52:41an indie game that you know valve saw

0:52:44they saw the potential in it and you

0:52:46know basically bought it and turn it

0:52:48into part of the orange box and

0:52:49basically expanded the idea and if you

0:52:52look at portal to the new gel mechanic

0:52:56is something very similar to that the

0:52:59day they saw on in the game and they

0:53:01kind of took that mechanic and put it on

0:53:03there you have to say I thought those

0:53:05puzzles are fun i enjoyed portal to but

0:53:10I felt like that particularly did not

0:53:12it didn't feels organic with it

0:53:16I and I actually think the later half of

0:53:19portal 2 is actually kind of weak

0:53:22because i think most of the puzzles come

0:53:26down to this this frustration factor we

0:53:29find yourself with the portal gun and

0:53:31you're going ok what is the part of this

0:53:33room this covered in moondust paint so

0:53:37you find yourself shooting portals

0:53:39everywhere just waiting for something to

0:53:41stick very often way way way way out in

0:53:45the distance just like hoping to find

0:53:48this one little tile and it's it was to

0:53:50me was very reminiscent of this you guys

0:53:53remember in the the eighties when you

0:53:55play these are

0:53:56you adventure games that would very much

0:53:57be a pixel hunt here I to find the exact

0:54:01with the hospital i can click on that

0:54:03exactly and I i still think this was was

0:54:07well done but I feel like it was it was

0:54:10weaker let me double up on that uh one

0:54:13of the things that struck me in and i

0:54:14know this is again funny for me to say

0:54:16this is somebody who doesn't play a lot

0:54:17of games and doesn't mind that this was

0:54:19easier and i totally get the conceit of

0:54:22the fact that these are test levels so

0:54:25the whole point of them is that there's

0:54:26a solution but after a while I did find

0:54:31myself being disappointed that every

0:54:33time there's an angled wall you you drop

0:54:37through a portal on to a portal on the

0:54:39angled wall and will be flung exactly

0:54:41where you need to go and I started and I

0:54:43start to think i get i get why they

0:54:46explain why this is because these are

0:54:48test portals but it didn't it didn't

0:54:51feel organic to be in it and it felt not

0:54:53dangerous enough i like I wanted there

0:54:55to be angled walls that didn't fling me

0:54:57anywhere or flung they don't give you a

0:54:59lot of falsely right or that were three

0:55:01wide and you if you put it on the the

0:55:03left side you would be safe but on the

0:55:05right as i may be a little bit of

0:55:06alignment but that everything the main

0:55:08challenge that portal 2 has is can you

0:55:10make a longer game especially for

0:55:12players who have played portal one where

0:55:14they don't get tired of doing the same

0:55:15thing that's what gets into the tony was

0:55:17saying is like throughout the whole

0:55:19length of portal to the way they're

0:55:20trying to stave off boredom or

0:55:22repetition is by it's gradually adding

0:55:24new mechanics and when you when you

0:55:27gradually add this new mechanically

0:55:28don't remove the old one so like the

0:55:30angled walls with with you know putting

0:55:32a portal on them

0:55:33those are still there just because it

0:55:34assumes you've learned that and it's a

0:55:35given but hopefully on that level

0:55:37there's something new like something you

0:55:38know you're doing with the gel or

0:55:39something new we're doing with those

0:55:40little by little glowy walls yeah

0:55:43whatever

0:55:43I mean it's a little weird from a puzzle

0:55:45design because like in every chamber

0:55:48it's like you're going to use every kind

0:55:50of interactive part of it right you're

0:55:51going to use every angled wall and every

0:55:53laser beam and things like that there's

0:55:54no extra pieces like it on some of the

0:55:57levels though it does give you a fairly

0:55:59wide open white space and with the

0:56:01portal and you do have to be someone

0:56:02like portal 2 got better about letting

0:56:04you place portals on walls and sort of

0:56:06like

0:56:06non-integral positions such as never

0:56:08like buttons you don't need or but you

0:56:10like working together there's a there's

0:56:12a level late in Portal 2 where there's

0:56:14one angled wall and that's the one you

0:56:16have to obviously slingshot yourself

0:56:17through to get to the part on the other

0:56:19side it is exactly time for that and

0:56:21that's how it works and there's a ramp

0:56:23and it's very end there's orange gel and

0:56:26you're like well I know how this works

0:56:27and a one-level it's like great I know

0:56:29how this works i need to figure out how

0:56:30to spray the orange gel on the ramp and

0:56:32I can jump over it and the ramp is the

0:56:34ramp is not that the puzzle the ramp is

0:56:36the what you're solving for that and yet

0:56:39I I kept feeling like really every

0:56:41single item that is out of whack here

0:56:43slightly is is going to be used in the

0:56:45solution like I never had a question the

0:56:47ramp was going to be part of the

0:56:48solution the you know the egg wall was

0:56:51going to be part of the solution

0:56:52yeah but that's the type of type of game

0:56:54it doesn't mention i can see it supports

0:56:55that but like the other thing is they're

0:56:57trying not to give you a dead end it's

0:56:59like that the directive in Mariano games

0:57:01that basically like this should be there

0:57:03should be no way that you can get

0:57:05yourself into a situation where the only

0:57:06way out is to restart the level you're

0:57:08going to die and i get that when you

0:57:09someplace in order to or I did actually

0:57:11that did actually happen and what that

0:57:13but that's what they're trying to

0:57:14prevent by sort of the conservation of

0:57:16items or something that is like never

0:57:18let the person get into a situation

0:57:20where they can't finish level either by

0:57:22activating something like and now you

0:57:23can't take it back or now you have no

0:57:25way to wash off your gel or anything

0:57:26like that that's part of just you know

0:57:28good puzzle designed for to avoiding

0:57:30frustration sort of the modern age of

0:57:31gaming hell didn't carry a screw you get

0:57:33stuck start the ballgame over and I like

0:57:35I'd like an extra angled wall or two so

0:57:38i have to actually look and think that

0:57:41which one of these is going to point me

0:57:44in a place i want to go but I literally

0:57:46I didn't have to do that because I knew

0:57:48it would put me somewhere there are

0:57:50weaker levels and stronger level i got

0:57:51some of the levels where you just kind

0:57:52of passing through sort of like an

0:57:54atrium where there is kind of a minor

0:57:56puzzle to make progress really the thing

0:57:58that's happening there is like some long

0:58:00voiceover and like not it's not like

0:58:02test chambers because once you get into

0:58:03the cave johnson part it's not like

0:58:05you're in for one chamber that the test

0:58:06chamber is easier to layout and

0:58:08satisfying puzzle in this sort of

0:58:10traveling through the underground

0:58:11sometimes you just traveling through and

0:58:13sometimes it's you know all right well

0:58:15there's some minor possible to have to

0:58:16do to move on to the next thing but this

0:58:18is not a chamber

0:58:19and like especially those parts with the

0:58:20put the gel is flowing everywhere i'm

0:58:22not entirely sure of this but i'm pretty

0:58:24sure the very first time I place which

0:58:26was a long time ago i saw some of those

0:58:28puzzles and sort of the the non the

0:58:31non-standard way often making it harder

0:58:34for myself and the actual solution is

0:58:35but there are multiple ways to solve

0:58:37levels because once you have the gel and

0:58:39you can spray everywhere you can solve

0:58:40them in ways that don't involve for

0:58:42example the one random angle wall

0:58:43hanging out there because you can pull

0:58:44these gels over here and we went out put

0:58:46the whole room yeah riots want to paint

0:58:49those rooms the gels change the formula

0:58:52for a little bit in a way that I think

0:58:53some people might feel weird about

0:58:55because I think a lot of the really good

0:58:56portal puzzles like figuring out the

0:58:59solution and implementing it like

0:59:01there's not a big gap there right like

0:59:03implementing it is pretty easy and it's

0:59:05not relying on on timing

0:59:06whereas with the gel ones it's like the

0:59:09solution is not obvious i'm just going

0:59:11to start kind of throwing stuff at the

0:59:12wall by spraying jello everywhere and

0:59:14stumble across but there's more than one

0:59:16solution like it if I do see what the

0:59:17solution is it's like well now i'm going

0:59:19to you know put gel everywhere and put

0:59:21paint everywhere for a while

0:59:22whereas other places it's a little bit

0:59:23more kind of like rapid to kind of get

0:59:25from solution to implemented solution

0:59:27what would have the observing scientist

0:59:29was that if you were actual test subject

0:59:31in those chambers just flinging paint

0:59:33everywhere like a lunatic

0:59:34you know the only times you've got a

0:59:36little easy with sticks ya talking with

0:59:38water after it's what they use human

0:59:40test subjects now and not and not the

0:59:42Apes that they previously used I have to

0:59:44say I was a little disappointed in

0:59:45Portal 2 in terms of the level of

0:59:47challenge right i mean i never really

0:59:49felt really stuck or challenge and I

0:59:51think they they do a good job with kind

0:59:53of the co-op part of portal 2 is I think

0:59:56a lot more challenging because the

0:59:57complexity is increased because now you

0:59:58have two characters

0:59:58have two characters

1:00:00and you can have your puzzles that

1:00:01require for portals and lots of timing

1:00:03and things like that but it's this kind

1:00:04of tacked on like there is kind of a

1:00:07story to the coop but it's not the same

1:00:09you know engaging interesting story that

1:00:12you have for the campaign so I'm

1:00:13guessing there's probably a lot of

1:00:14people that play Portal 2 and I've never

1:00:16played the co-op part of portal and you

1:00:18know you're not missing out on a lot in

1:00:19terms of story but you are missing out

1:00:21on some interesting challenges far as

1:00:23the puzzles go there are videos of

1:00:24people solving all the different rooms

1:00:27in portal to an extremely exotic ways

1:00:30either by for example not using items

1:00:32that seem to be necessary but really

1:00:33aren't or using momentum in ways sort of

1:00:36not intended by the game designer and

1:00:38that is sort of the metagame within

1:00:39portal and portal two especially once a

1:00:40jealous come in because you can solve

1:00:43level without without doing the

1:00:44prescribed things involving very

1:00:47difficult first person moves like

1:00:49throwing cubes through things and

1:00:51flinging yourself through a series of

1:00:53portals and there is that extra level of

1:00:55the game is just that that isn't

1:00:57required like you can do it the easy way

1:00:58and it works

1:00:59the only reason you're doing it the hard

1:01:00way to make it harder for yourself I

1:01:02mean portal and portal two are crazy for

1:01:04people who do speedruns but that's like

1:01:06that's not kind of the game that's there

1:01:08that's a game you can play with portal 2

1:01:09but that's not the game as intended

1:01:11I i think that co-op mode of portal 2 is

1:01:15is well done for what it is but I think

1:01:19it I think it really betrays the the

1:01:21spirit of portal and I I think you have

1:01:24to really look at that era of gaming

1:01:27when portal two came out and kind of get

1:01:29put into some historic context yet this

1:01:32is a time where I in order to combat

1:01:34used game sales a electronic arts had

1:01:38started Institute five dollar fee to

1:01:40access multiplayer too kind recruit

1:01:43these fees and you know a lot of games

1:01:45had had a multiplayer mode kind of

1:01:48tacked on in order to you know like oh

1:01:51no don't take my game back don't sell it

1:01:53like keep me I promise there's gonna be

1:01:54content coming which be a portal to

1:01:57follow it up with um I know you Jason I

1:02:00have to push back and disagree with you

1:02:02a bit on the difficulty level just

1:02:04because i know so many people whose kind

1:02:07of gateway drug into gaming was portal

1:02:09and um i would actually i think it was

1:02:13pretty

1:02:13just the perfect difficulty I really

1:02:16create concedes yeah I feel like at the

1:02:18end of portal to having it be a little

1:02:22bit more or less of a converse a a

1:02:26conservation of features in a room that

1:02:28you have to think about it a little more

1:02:30is probably not

1:02:31upping the difficulty too much at that

1:02:33point because it felt I I felt kind of

1:02:36seeing me

1:02:36believe me i think i can't believe i'm

1:02:37making this argument because i love your

1:02:39level of difficulty portal but what is

1:02:42there for me it was like this again a

1:02:44few times right guy all the way to the

1:02:46end like it should be getting harder

1:02:47here shouldn't have to guess about

1:02:49whether this is the right thing to jump

1:02:51through but it says I don't just jump

1:02:52it'll take you somewhere good and it

1:02:54would share and that's fine

1:02:56like I don't agree but that's er that's

1:02:58fine but but where it feels in Congress

1:03:01to me is with portal to co-op which my

1:03:04husband and I called divorce method

1:03:06because it's it is so unbelievably like

1:03:11portal is a game it's one of these rare

1:03:13games i really look for with for Frank

1:03:16who isn't up late let's destroy

1:03:18everything like BB i got captain toad

1:03:21Frank and I need to hang out more

1:03:23I think Franklin and wait going oh my

1:03:25god just 14 watch watch some Star Trek

1:03:28will play some gentle cases multiple

1:03:30yeah yeah but it's the difficulty spike

1:03:33is so high where it's really a game that

1:03:37only expert players can get through

1:03:40because like you're not just dealing

1:03:41with like suddenly have four portals and

1:03:45you're trying to communicate with people

1:03:47across an internet connection and there

1:03:49are many more speed puzzles and I just I

1:03:54i think that it's a great game for what

1:03:57it is but I think it lacks the

1:04:00accessibility that makes portals such a

1:04:02beautiful perfect example of game decide

1:04:05yet think it really could betrays that

1:04:07casual audience and I think it's sad

1:04:09that there's an entire layer of portal

1:04:12that you know a lot of the audience is

1:04:14just simply never going to get to

1:04:16explore and I I think you can look at

1:04:19some examples of game design like the

1:04:22last lara croft in the temple of Osiris

1:04:25this is a game that

1:04:26you know how they got a lot of press but

1:04:28it is a really really good example of

1:04:31multiplayer where the puzzles change for

1:04:34one two or three players and because of

1:04:37that it's accessible to players of

1:04:39vastly different levels of skill and I

1:04:42just think that this masterpiece of a

1:04:44game did not handle that most

1:04:46particularly skillfully know you played

1:04:48the combo didn't you

1:04:49yep what you'd what what do you think

1:04:52about it I mean I think you know it it

1:04:55means you can only play it with one

1:04:56other person that's right flexibility

1:04:58right it doesn't remember is one you

1:05:00still want it by yourself right you know

1:05:03you can't play it with two other people

1:05:04i mean i think it does an okay job in

1:05:07terms of like we're gonna throw some

1:05:08more complicated puzzles at you

1:05:10um I think a lot of people's experiences

1:05:12will be shaped by what that person

1:05:15they're collaborating with is because

1:05:16for example if you know if you're

1:05:19playing with somebody who is more

1:05:21comfortable with portal than you and is

1:05:22going to kind of run ahead and tell you

1:05:24what to do for everything like that's

1:05:25not going to be a satisfying experience

1:05:27right i mean i think you know I i played

1:05:29it with I think different parts of it

1:05:31with different people they didn't think

1:05:32it was like an add on to the second the

1:05:34multiplayer that got released at some

1:05:35point I played that with a different

1:05:37person that I played the first part you

1:05:38know in the ideal experience like it's a

1:05:40good collaboration and i'm really into

1:05:42puzzles and work on a lot of puzzles you

1:05:44know they're not video game-related it's

1:05:45fun to work with somebody else but it's

1:05:47fun when it's a collaboration and when

1:05:49people go back and forth and you know

1:05:50somebody's able to contribute something

1:05:52and somebody else is able to you know

1:05:53build on top of that but I mean I played

1:05:55lots of collaborative games you know

1:05:58that have not gone well I'll never

1:06:00forget a particularly bad experience

1:06:02where I was playing a game of

1:06:04Neverwinter and like I got lost and I

1:06:06showed up at the big boss fight and like

1:06:08the big boss was dead and my friend had

1:06:10like already opened a portal back to

1:06:11town and like it is like so i just

1:06:13showed up at the murder scene and all

1:06:15the loot is God and it's like I don't

1:06:17know what I'm doing so you know but

1:06:18that's more about the you know who

1:06:20you're playing with and how that's kind

1:06:21of facilitated than the game itself

1:06:23alright but you know its weak as far as

1:06:26you know it's the stacked on kind of

1:06:27side story right and you know there's

1:06:29you play as they too funny little robots

1:06:30and that's kind of fun and they're a

1:06:32little bit more more Gladys but the you

1:06:34know the heart is not there is a lot

1:06:35more about

1:06:36the puzzles in the mechanics of the

1:06:38puzzles which you know pales compared to

1:06:41the you know the delightful story that

1:06:42you get portal 2 but you're not invested

1:06:44in the in the two robots though like now

1:06:46they really didn't have a story and

1:06:49there is a plot point revealed the end

1:06:50of the coop thing but you're not you

1:06:53don't embody them in the way that you

1:06:54embody channel when you place even kind

1:06:56of the juke they get disassembled and

1:06:58reassembled at the beginning and end of

1:06:59every level right there like they're

1:07:01totally disposable was like a Star Trek

1:07:03transporter yeah I i completely agree

1:07:06about there's not being a lot of heart

1:07:08in it but the same time it is really

1:07:09nice to play because you're like i just

1:07:11want a little bit more portal sometimes

1:07:13you know because things are so short you

1:07:15need a little bit it's like this one get

1:07:17that last chocolate from the fridge you

1:07:19know that's what it feels like so I

1:07:21played with them

1:07:22somebody from I think he's from Germany

1:07:24underscore and d underscore he just like

1:07:26answered my call out on twitter i'm like

1:07:28i need to play this quick get over here

1:07:30while the other score family is a it's a

1:07:31serious i don't know if they're related

1:07:35it underscores German cousin with us

1:07:39call it ok little bit now it was it was

1:07:44really fun playing with him and we've

1:07:45had both never played before even though

1:07:46it's like you know years later since

1:07:48it's been released so like it is just

1:07:51it's a it's portal dessert that's pretty

1:07:53primitive

1:07:53yeah it's a really different experience

1:07:55right because when you're playing the

1:07:56single-player like you're alone with you

1:07:58know Wheatley Gladys and and Cave

1:08:00Johnson whereas you know I would admit

1:08:02when i played the multiplayer it's like

1:08:03kind of non-stop back and forth banter

1:08:05and like what if we put a portal over

1:08:07here what if we pour it's a very

1:08:08different game experience me

1:08:10yeah it's not the meat and potatoes of

1:08:11portal is a little you know something i

1:08:15just want to mention my son is no longer

1:08:18obsessed with portal but for a long time

1:08:20he was obsessed with portal and he was

1:08:21not obsessed with portal from playing it

1:08:23and he plays minecraft he placed her

1:08:25area and and you know he in

1:08:28he's good now 3d game literate and I

1:08:30think if you played portal now he would

1:08:32have no problem with it at all although

1:08:34you'd have to maybe scratches headed at

1:08:36some of the puzzles but i think i think

1:08:37he would he would enjoy it here my

1:08:40daughter tried to play the coop and they

1:08:41got like three levels and they're like a

1:08:43forget this then went to Minecraft but

1:08:45he was obsessed with portals because he

1:08:47loved the concept

1:08:48there was maybe when he was in third

1:08:51grade everyday walking him to school the

1:08:54entire conversation was about how much

1:08:57easier would be to get to school if we

1:08:59could only make a portal and we would

1:09:02talk about various ways you could use

1:09:04the portal and other places you could go

1:09:05with the portal and do you put the

1:09:06portal outside the school or do you put

1:09:08it inside if you put inside people walk

1:09:10into our house from the other side of

1:09:11the portal we had long conversations I

1:09:14will always think about portal and think

1:09:16about the fact that my son really wants

1:09:19a portal gun and unfortunately you know

1:09:21there isn't one yet maybe he'll invent

1:09:24one but we have a plan to mine moondust

1:09:26that would be the hardest part of that

1:09:29they don't need it i just know it's so

1:09:31the last the last the last boss battle

1:09:35and portal 2i i really enjoyed it but I

1:09:38i especially enjoyed the very end as the

1:09:41ceiling comes down and the moon is

1:09:43exposed and you can see outside for the

1:09:45first time and the last act you have to

1:09:47perform is to shoot a portal gun on the

1:09:51moon and and there's a delay as it goes

1:09:55before it engages i I just I thought

1:09:58that was such an awesome kind of

1:10:00thinking outside of all the scope of

1:10:03this game up to now so simple a moment

1:10:06and yet such a wonderful moment i really

1:10:09i really enjoyed that last day as a

1:10:10great example of a game on rails because

1:10:12oh yeah it shoves your viewpoint up

1:10:15there

1:10:15it puts the thing in your face it is

1:10:17like it is in a many ways taking away

1:10:20player agency and yet it does not feel

1:10:22like the takeaway player agency because

1:10:24they have so masterfully constructing a

1:10:26game and universe to engage you that

1:10:28that as soon as you get knocked

1:10:30backwards and the ceiling comes open

1:10:31it's not it's not unreasonable for the

1:10:34moon visible because in the game they

1:10:35want to put something interesting you

1:10:36know like the same reason complex in the

1:10:38moon lander because they won't have some

1:10:39visual address right and it immediately

1:10:41cursed I've never heard of someone

1:10:43getting up to that point and not knowing

1:10:44what to do like and it feels like it

1:10:46feels like it occurred to you as our and

1:10:49I clever that you know aren't I clever

1:10:52isn't the game clever like you feel

1:10:53satisfaction of having solved someone

1:10:55reality what happens they shoved your

1:10:56cursor onto the moon right like and they

1:10:59give you no other

1:11:00options like it is it is such a

1:11:02subversion of taking away player agency

1:11:04while the same time making the player

1:11:05feel like they figured it out and it is

1:11:08a clever idea and it is done in a nice

1:11:10little animation in some ways I do feel

1:11:12like it's a little bit of a cheap we're

1:11:14like it you know once you see the

1:11:16strings you're like boy that really just

1:11:18you know rubbing my nose in it but the

1:11:20first time I played I just felt like

1:11:21that's brilliant and I'm brilliant and

1:11:25this game is real and its story payoff

1:11:26to I mean it's you know and the whole

1:11:28game is about making you feel clever or

1:11:30brilliant right and so they're gonna

1:11:31really put a cherry on top of it with

1:11:33that last night haha the best the best

1:11:35thing is they set it up so that you have

1:11:36to put a portal underneath you know that

1:11:39won't we

1:11:40you have to do that to do the earlier

1:11:41part of the game which sets you like you

1:11:43can't get into as far as i know you

1:11:44can't get into a situation where the

1:11:46other portal isn't already said at the

1:11:48time you're pointed at the moon so you

1:11:50never get into a situation where you're

1:11:51like well if you've forgotten to put

1:11:52that portal there then your revelation

1:11:55is undercut by the fact that you realize

1:11:56you need to put a second part underneath

1:11:57i'm pretty sure it's always underneath

1:11:59by that point

1:11:59yeah you got you got to that's how you

1:12:01that's how you do the last thing with

1:12:03him so I think we have to talk about one

1:12:06last thing with this game which is I get

1:12:09the ending songs by Jonathan haha so I

1:12:13had someone who I only like electronica

1:12:17EDM and i got like some rap but

1:12:20generally speaking was kind of like

1:12:22folks say like one dude with guitar

1:12:24playing something it's like maybe

1:12:26because I grew up in Mississippi but

1:12:28just like it's some part of my being you

1:12:29hate it I hate it I don't know so it was

1:12:33like watching a play he's a little idea

1:12:35what are you talking about what the top

1:12:37yeah yeah the desktop site like this

1:12:40both of these songs on Jace actually

1:12:42have the same experiences you that went

1:12:45on this game came out I said arch box on

1:12:48the first person shooter I don't give a

1:12:50crap

1:12:50he now and i actually just skip or

1:12:53completely despite all the accolades in

1:12:55a claim and just like nope I and then I

1:12:58heard someone singing ah the the portal

1:13:02song in rock band because they released

1:13:05as a free tract and I'm like that's a

1:13:06really moving fine track i want to know

1:13:09more about that game and then your steam

1:13:12came to OS 10 and you know download it

1:13:15and it was as black as a wonderful gate

1:13:18these things

1:13:20you too

1:13:30people

1:13:34so um I just I think that these songs

1:13:38both of them are districts something

1:13:42about them that is is so emotional and

1:13:46moving but they're also really catchy

1:13:48and well done

1:13:49it's like I downloaded other albums of

1:13:51his helping like it hate their home but

1:13:54they feel like the new smaller just so

1:13:56awesome 6 plus laughing

1:14:03circumstances

1:14:09three

1:14:18is it

1:14:24I don't know i just i think they're part

1:14:27of what makes this a masterpiece because

1:14:30you get to the end and then like you

1:14:32have this really touching musical number

1:14:35with like turret singing to you and it's

1:14:36magical

1:14:56anything in the first one like you beat

1:14:58Gladys and then she seems to you right i

1:15:00mean that that is there's so many things

1:15:02in video games where it's like I'm doing

1:15:04this thing that I've done before I've

1:15:06never beat a boss that have a boss sing

1:15:08to me over the end credits that was new

1:15:10and it continues the story it's not like

1:15:12yeah and it's not like oh here's a song

1:15:14reviewing what you've done in the game

1:15:16know the song continues the game the

1:15:17song reinforces the game and informs the

1:15:20game at like it is as integrated into

1:15:22the game

1:15:23i I don't know what the creative process

1:15:24was I imagine that he played through a

1:15:27rough cut of the game first and then

1:15:28made a song about it but there's any

1:15:30information is added in the songs i

1:15:32didn't have a summary of the story

1:15:34because yeah i think i read an interview

1:15:35with him about it and content and

1:15:37emotion is added by the song so it's not

1:15:39like you know I like a good credit

1:15:42sequence to a lot of times it's just

1:15:43like a kind of reviewing what you've

1:15:44done in the game this continues the

1:15:46especially still alive which is just

1:15:47again another not another jab and aside

1:15:50from Gladys like great victory haha and

1:15:53then it's like no I'm still alive when

1:15:55you're dying I'll be still alive when

1:15:57you're dead I will be still a lot of you

1:15:58know like it means she's like exactly

1:16:00you know starting with this was a

1:16:01triumph refusing to admit defeat

1:16:03despite the fact that she is blue up and

1:16:05I want you gone with something you know

1:16:07capping off the emotional note of the

1:16:10end portal to which it i'm talking but i

1:16:12do want to talk about the song the song

1:16:15is part of the ending you can't say well

1:16:17now i'm not interested I'm not gonna

1:16:18watch the credits and it's over you have

1:16:19to want and not because there's some

1:16:21little scene at the end with each meow

1:16:23indian food or whatever but it's like

1:16:24very appears yes

1:16:25yeah yeah it's no it's a captain and

1:16:28ended there in character and they've got

1:16:29the same humor that's in the in the game

1:16:32and and I love them both

1:16:35I i love them both and in I enjoy

1:16:38listening to the various versions of

1:16:39them the game versions and other

1:16:40versions that have been done at and and

1:16:42what you gon is great because first off

1:16:44it's tough act to follow to to follow

1:16:47still alive which you know it became

1:16:49quite a little hit in some circles and

1:16:52yet because of the way it's done and it

1:16:55addresses the story points and it's so

1:16:57perfectly glad us to that it's you know

1:17:00it's not even you win it's just look

1:17:03okay i won't kill you go away which is

1:17:07your victory right your victory is she's

1:17:09not even try to

1:17:09will you know just go away but the

1:17:11underlying my something that's something

1:17:13that we talked about at the update my

1:17:15theory of how these all are all

1:17:17connected is very obvious to me is that

1:17:19you know Caroline was put into the

1:17:20computer Chelle is caroline's daughter

1:17:23probably adopted and the whole hang up

1:17:26the glass as with channel is a

1:17:28mother-daughter relationship where the

1:17:30AIS malevolent wants to kill all humans

1:17:32but something in her field an attachment

1:17:34to this girl because it was her daughter

1:17:36and so the whole thing of like you know

1:17:38Caroline deleted but then why not kill

1:17:40challenge like well the easiest thing to

1:17:42do is really let you go because every

1:17:43time I try to kill you it's really hard

1:17:44no it isn't like and as soon as he sends

1:17:47up you think like well that makes some

1:17:49kind of logical sense she does this

1:17:50little speech like well maybe this is it

1:17:51does make sense she deleted Carolina

1:17:53National of lunches decided the best way

1:17:55to get rid of me to a movie but as you

1:17:57go up the elevator the turret sing to

1:17:59you in Italian with lyrics that call you

1:18:01know talk about my baby and my little

1:18:03girl like it is the only imagine the

1:18:06mechanical manifestation of aperture

1:18:08science expressing the emotion that the

1:18:10little you know curved head of GLaDOS

1:18:12can't say which is actually you're my

1:18:14daughter and I love you and I can't kill

1:18:16you

1:18:17I just need to remove you and want you

1:18:19gone is kind of like a I'm never going

1:18:22to admit to you that I'm not killing you

1:18:23because I love you really are going to

1:18:24tell you is like really now I just want

1:18:26you gone

1:18:27it's kind of like that the the Gladys

1:18:29yourself can't say these things to tell

1:18:32but the whole of aperture science can

1:18:35say it through you know through the

1:18:37singing and through the removal and

1:18:38everything that you guys checked out the

1:18:39door and the door is closed behind her

1:18:40and she's out to the strange world it's

1:18:43and you and then you get the credit song

1:18:45which which you think is saying I just

1:18:47want to get rid of you i deprived you

1:18:48feel anything for really just you know

1:18:50and just need to get ready which is not

1:18:51you know that I think the little you

1:18:54know with the giant animal striped

1:18:56turned away in the background which is

1:18:57great singing that little song to you is

1:19:00that one that one of the most memorable

1:19:02moments of any game i think it's a

1:19:03cutscene you know just the just that

1:19:06ending trip up the elevators and

1:19:07realizing that the glads really does

1:19:09love me Mommy

1:19:11oh no someone said the chat which I

1:19:14totally agree with once that door is

1:19:15closed after you know you're kicked out

1:19:17of the facility and you're in the big

1:19:18field of wheat and everything you turn

1:19:20around you're like I just kind of want

1:19:22to go back

1:19:23like you do have that feeling someone

1:19:25totally nailed it in the chat room and

1:19:27said that and I was like yes that is

1:19:28exactly how I felt like you kind of want

1:19:30to go

1:19:30you're like oh thank god freedom but i

1:19:33have a choice now and i kinda want to go

1:19:35back in but that's maybe as me just look

1:19:38at the combine devastated the earth so

1:19:39you don't hang out there anyway i like

1:19:41throwing the cube out at you and

1:19:43slamming the door is is that and stay

1:19:45out well here's how i read that one the

1:19:48Cubans thrown out here like and stay out

1:19:50but when I read it as is and I know you

1:19:52have an attachment to this cube so you

1:19:53had your your mom sending your teddy

1:19:56bear trying to make need to think that

1:19:58real trying to make it seem like go and

1:20:00take your stupid tour too but really

1:20:02it's like I know you're gonna need your

1:20:03teddy

1:20:03do you guys ever wonder how they're

1:20:05gonna start portal 3 because I wonder

1:20:07about that life is not a better because

1:20:10i don't think you need to have a portal

1:20:113 I think you think he'd have half life

1:20:143 first at the very least I here to

1:20:16development for friends so that's what

1:20:19does yeah I'm sure we're mill right

1:20:21how could that would be into ok right

1:20:23exactly except so my theory is it's

1:20:26gonna be like the movie aliens

1:20:28we're like chalice waking up in the

1:20:29middle of the night and she's having

1:20:31flashbacks and then like her companion

1:20:33cube is there on the floor she strokes

1:20:35it she says in you you little blank

1:20:38you're staying right here and then like

1:20:39she and the Marines from half-life like

1:20:42go back to go back take over at first I

1:20:44have to go back to you have to shave her

1:20:46head because of lice are no force in

1:20:48origin story and it's like baby child

1:20:50she's like going around Chronicle you

1:20:52can make the potato battery the science

1:20:55fair

1:20:55yeah it's like an extra season on your

1:20:57favorite show you're like really you

1:20:58don't need to do that right

1:21:00maybe she could go and rescue Gladys

1:21:02Gladys like you know gets into a jam

1:21:04with having to do with the events of

1:21:06half-life 3 interesting class doesn't

1:21:08need to be rescued

1:21:09I know will you think it's the rescue

1:21:11and you get her and should try to kill

1:21:12you again

1:21:13no only from Chile needs to be rescued

1:21:15from birds maybe there's another AI

1:21:16problem in you know somewhere else or in

1:21:19space or something like that then you

1:21:20just a play space and you apply the

1:21:23portal you know technology to another

1:21:25another setup and don't go back into so

1:21:29how do you add a new mechanic if you do

1:21:31portal 3 like portal won was very simple

1:21:32and it

1:21:33energy mechanics portal 2 added pretty

1:21:36much every mechanic they could think of

1:21:37a 22 to pad out a two-hour game you

1:21:41can't add you can't like now double

1:21:43again the number of my candles because

1:21:44we're mechanics that they cut so there

1:21:46are other mechanics that you know they

1:21:47tested and didn't you know didn't like

1:21:49so maybe they can polish that off there

1:21:50was in the original like indie game that

1:21:52the game portal there was the mechanic

1:21:54where you could shoot portals through

1:21:57portals I was going to ask jason when

1:21:58you have conversations with your son did

1:22:00he ever ask why can't you or would it be

1:22:02cool if you could shoot because I'm are

1:22:03playing portal 1 and being frustrated

1:22:05that you couldn't shoot at the order to

1:22:06portal to portal i think probably a lot

1:22:08of users probably got confused with oh

1:22:11you know I I exactly i understand both

1:22:13from a technical perspective why they

1:22:14didn't do that in terms of the draw

1:22:16distances and you know in that the time

1:22:19that portal 1 you still want to and from

1:22:21a mental perspective like if you let me

1:22:23do that i can break these levels into a

1:22:25million pieces cuz i would build this

1:22:26shatter and a hall of mirrors and I'll

1:22:29you'll never find your way back it'll be

1:22:30like the end of interstellar i don't

1:22:32know i think i think if you look at the

1:22:33the indie game seem like you know

1:22:36there's more innovation on ideas than

1:22:39their there was when either this games

1:22:41came to fruition

1:22:42I if it were me I would scrap the gel

1:22:44mechanic and what I would look forward I

1:22:46think I think it didn't work well I i

1:22:49thought it was good i thought was I

1:22:52think it's something you should probably

1:22:53revisit for maybe a level you know I i

1:22:56think it's it's really going to be key

1:22:57to find something new you know like the

1:23:01it would be very sad if portal became a

1:23:04call of duty need help you don't want to

1:23:07poorly here forever just for all right

1:23:09oh yeah it is not the mechanics are

1:23:12enough to support that but like I think

1:23:13you could take advantage of modern

1:23:14technology and do more things that rely

1:23:16on on the more better physics that we

1:23:19have these days better fidelity physics

1:23:21you could probably do a whole series of

1:23:23levels with weird gravity right yeah or

1:23:26early time he rolls airplane swapper any

1:23:29you guys what yeah this is the swapper

1:23:32was an interesting mechanic that seems

1:23:33like it's right now obviously it's after

1:23:35portal so it's from chirps partially

1:23:37inspired by part of a portal was kind of

1:23:38not the dawning of a of a a

1:23:41an upswing in indy creativity but like

1:23:44like preset now I indie games with very

1:23:47clever interesting mechanics is there

1:23:49they're all over the place compared to

1:23:51where they were that's what that's why

1:23:52portable so amazing it's like everything

1:23:54was just you know quake 1 2 3 doom half

1:23:57life you know

1:23:58yeah battlefield 1942 whatever and then

1:24:01you know portal was like this shining

1:24:03light and now there's tons of games like

1:24:04that and a lot of them implemented

1:24:06mechanics that would have fit right in

1:24:08in portal two or three but of course now

1:24:09somebody else did them so I'm not

1:24:11correctly you're saying John about the

1:24:13the technical problems your source

1:24:16I'm not as big an expert in sources

1:24:18unreal obviously but your sources and

1:24:21engine is really showing its age and you

1:24:24know i was actually very surprised with

1:24:27the amount of Polish they managed to get

1:24:29on it for a portal to look as good as it

1:24:32does so you know I think that there's

1:24:36you know I don't know if the answer for

1:24:38portal 3 would be to take source apart

1:24:41and give it like yet another coat of

1:24:42paint to you knew you know a whole new

1:24:46ability to do shaders and modern

1:24:48techniques for for surfaces you know

1:24:50even though portal is it really a a game

1:24:53that depends on snazzy graphics but um I

1:24:56think your your your point about

1:24:57technical limitations for the first two

1:25:00games i think that's very well set my

1:25:02only idea i'm going to throw out for a

1:25:05portal 3 is actually think you know I

1:25:08some of the gel stuff I could live

1:25:09without but i would love a paint gun

1:25:11that paints the white the white moon

1:25:14dust paint so that you have so that you

1:25:17have to think about where to put your

1:25:20portal in someplace so we're just going

1:25:23to paint the whole room

1:25:24yeah well if you're crazy but I said I

1:25:26like limited that's right i enjoy

1:25:28painting things I could paint the whole

1:25:30damn room and be like this is a

1:25:31beautiful room and then I would win the

1:25:33level and move on that could happen that

1:25:36there's nothing wrong with that I they

1:25:37could be interesting but if they gave me

1:25:39like a machine gun and then there's like

1:25:40guys shoot maybe there's an idea Nazis

1:25:43there you have to run with that one that

1:25:44I feel like that's something i have even

1:25:46gotten to do that yet that sounds

1:25:48exciting well Jason can play as a rat

1:25:50men and just like go around planting all

1:25:51the murals one of my guns good game

1:25:53experience and I get

1:25:54upgrade the guns new level but i have

1:25:57special tables where I can only do it in

1:25:59certain areas which is completely unreal

1:26:01or program the turrets that's what I

1:26:02want to do for the next game just

1:26:03program the turrets send them out see

1:26:06what they do it'll be like a tower

1:26:07defense game with the dungeon keeper

1:26:09I like the fact that a is full of

1:26:11paradoxes that's a star star trek isn't

1:26:14yeah yeah yeahs resist paradox that

1:26:17beautiful moment where classes whole

1:26:19plan defeating wheelie is doing a

1:26:20captain kirk on weekly how I gotta pick

1:26:31up my god now i'm sure i know i'm not

1:26:36taking into the park

1:26:38yeah that was a beautiful moment as a

1:26:40fan of of confounding start tricking

1:26:43androids I thought that was really good

1:26:44i think the final thing output send

1:26:47these alterations for the show notes but

1:26:48pretty much every line they glad I

1:26:50sweetly in the chorus and Cave Johnson

1:26:52say are available on the portal wikidot

1:26:56com with audio files and as two things

1:26:58about that one there are so many good

1:27:00lines and if you only play through the

1:27:02game once you probably don't hear all

1:27:03these you check these out and two if you

1:27:05play the audio for them you realize how

1:27:08much the line readings lose when they're

1:27:10not played over the top of the music

1:27:12it's like you know star wars without

1:27:13Williams type thing where you watch a

1:27:15movie without the soundtrack and you

1:27:16realize boy the soundtrack is carrying a

1:27:18lot of the way to this thing you mean

1:27:20you might think back and say portal did

1:27:22that even happen music in the background

1:27:23it totally did because soon as you hear

1:27:25these lines read without music they

1:27:26sound like they're missing something

1:27:27because you you remember tone to there's

1:27:30a lot of room tone lot of echo in these

1:27:31chambers lot of reverb yeah especially

1:27:34in the final battle I can portal one

1:27:35love it the same she's sending at you

1:27:37with the music is like you weren't I'm

1:27:39very well with the pacing of like

1:27:41removing the course and dumping them

1:27:42incinerator and then she says the

1:27:44particular lines she has some great

1:27:45lines that weekend on picking favorite

1:27:47lines that Gladys says you can have

1:27:50horrible persons that's what it says

1:27:54here a horrible person we weren't even

1:27:55testing for that love

1:27:58alright well I think we have reached the

1:28:01end I feel like I feel like we were very

1:28:04comprehensive i'm going to be covered

1:28:06that i'm going to portal everybody into

1:28:07space now

1:28:08space why it uh that would like to thank

1:28:12my excellent panel this was a lot of fun

1:28:14and I was fun

1:28:15retesting portal to Tony sindelar thank

1:28:18you so much for being here

1:28:19this was a triumph years you know you

1:28:23calling him first their mommies takes

1:28:25the obviously yeah right

1:28:26yep Brianna with pleasure to have you

1:28:28back we should have you back again soon

1:28:30and make a note here huge success

1:28:32excellent tiffany our men thank you so

1:28:36much for being back on it was great i'm

1:28:38not prepared to the quote alright and

1:28:40available person horrible person will

1:28:42cut all this out no one knows what this

1:28:44there's no recording of it

1:28:45no it's just for us and John siracusa

1:28:48thank you as always

1:28:50okay look we both said a lot of things

1:28:52that you're going to regret and thanks

1:28:55everybody out there for listening

1:28:57we will see you next time

1:29:07but believe me I am still alive two plus

1:29:14two is ten in base far I'm fine

1:29:18that was my favorite line from portal

1:29:21one I can't do it justice you should put

1:29:24in the recording of it you think you're

1:29:25doing some damage 2+2 is in baseball

1:29:32I'm fine that's that's easy for me to

1:29:35believe that's easy for you because I

1:29:38left that when i was playing because you

1:29:39know there's the stutter with the static

1:29:41and everything i think my first laughs

1:29:43at line is when i believe about you

1:29:46subject name here must be the pride of

1:29:49subject from tall yeah one and replaying

1:29:52portal to one of my favorites was a

1:29:54you're navigating this test chambers

1:29:56faster than I can build them so feel

1:29:59free to slow down and do whatever it is

1:30:01you do when you're not destroying this

1:30:03facility lots of you know semi fourth

1:30:06wall breaking understanding like it

1:30:08seems like all you do channel is pretty

1:30:10much destroy this facility

1:30:11I have to fix it and that's our

1:30:13relationship there's a great moment

1:30:15we're in one of the Chamber's toward the

1:30:17end if you step on the catapult by

1:30:19accident your flung up against the

1:30:22monitor that weekly is looking at you in

1:30:24and he said something like da bless you

1:30:27little primate brain actually the room

1:30:30with you I'm like technology complicate

1:30:32we can hurt the big old gold face even

1:30:35weekly but I love what that was a

1:30:37wonderful book I just stepped on it by

1:30:38accident got slung up to the monitor

1:30:40that was a nice moment like the one

1:30:42where she explains the metaphor intended

1:30:44that the zinger lines actually gives you

1:30:46insulting you going to the elevator and

1:30:47she's like remember before when I was

1:30:48talking about smelly garbage standing

1:30:50around being useless

1:30:52that was a metaphor I was actually

1:30:54talking about you and I'm sorry you

1:30:57didn't react at the time so I was

1:30:59worried it sailed right over your head

1:31:01which would have made this apology seem

1:31:03insane that's why I had to call you

1:31:06garbage a second time just now I think

1:31:08the best one is assumed the party as for

1:31:11its submission position or you will miss

1:31:13the party

1:31:14yes there was and as f1 related one kind

1:31:19of turkey you stealing 20 majestically

1:31:22like an eagle piloting a blimp middle of

1:31:27that like all the weight comments in in

1:31:30the second one again you know with the

1:31:31whole sort of like finding ways to hurt

1:31:34you emotionally

1:31:36we're just not something you would think

1:31:37in a i would do right we're gonna make a

1:31:40statue of your corpse and show people

1:31:42how not to eat over there had not how

1:31:44not to be like oh and in the end of

1:31:49portal one where she just gets into like

1:31:51just where I think it's towards the end

1:31:53when she's really falling apart what you

1:31:54gonna leave me here I'll put you on

1:31:56that's you have done sound getting it

1:32:00done like second-grader level and salts

1:32:02you can't think of anything clever

1:32:03anymore i do the one visual joke that

1:32:06always gets me is when you're going in

1:32:08in Portal 2 and you're going down into

1:32:10the deep places there's that you see the

1:32:11giant vault door and you have to look

1:32:13after things fall apart the vault door

1:32:15swings open there's like a little

1:32:17folding chair and like a tiny door

1:32:19that's just no just because not a lot of

1:32:21visual longer in it the fake door that

1:32:22you have to be tipped off to the

1:32:24screenshot of the fake doors like

1:32:25honestly truly didn't think involved

1:32:28with that when you have things you have

1:32:30to close the game you have to you know

1:32:31to make to make a person the game and

1:32:33then it makes you feel bad like you feel

1:32:35injustice like but i had to open that to

1:32:37make the game progresses yeah i really

1:32:39enjoy all of the lines when she's

1:32:41insulting Wheatley as they're trying to

1:32:43shut him down including just one point

1:32:46saying you moron haha she's not happy

1:32:52but she's so angry it's and it's weird

1:32:54to hear glad I was angry at someone who

1:32:56is me right it's like oh yeah you get

1:32:58him especially when she's in her little

1:33:00little potato voices yeah yeah because

1:33:03using the potato yeah yeah this is the

1:33:04physical humor of like when you're into

1:33:06that place with all the buttons any kind

1:33:08of see it coming by the wheels like okay

1:33:09we just gotta find the button too light

1:33:11so just don't touch

1:33:12I think the thing starts going up and

1:33:13hitting all the buttons click like that

1:33:15that's good i mean again you don't have

1:33:17any agency there I did first I played I

1:33:19did look for the button a little bit i

1:33:21mean granted it's kind of a texture and

1:33:23you're like well I'm not gonna be able

1:33:24to actually find a button because it's

1:33:25not one of the mechanics game but look

1:33:26for it briefly i also like um I like

1:33:30that moment where you get redirected to

1:33:32be the the chamber where he's gonna

1:33:34smash you with all the things and Gladys

1:33:36says oh this is the part where he kills

1:33:38us and he says he'll ok this is the part

1:33:40where I kill you and then the chapter

1:33:41titles up we have a temporary kills it

1:33:43yeah the see if steve was here he would

1:33:47do adventure car lines for us the whole

1:33:49for an hour you should get him to do

1:33:51some adventure carlines you know

1:33:52quick what's the situation oh hey pretty

1:33:56lady named Rick so you have yourself a

1:33:59little adventure we are again it's so

1:34:06such a pleasure

1:34:08remember when you tried to kill me try

1:34:12we accept

1:34:19the circumstance

1:34:28that's what counts

1:34:40these things welcome ok you in good