Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 206: "The OG Haoles"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00[Music]

0:00:04LOL hi John

0:00:08I'm Merlin how's it going so good so

0:00:12SuperDuper super mm-hmm a different day

0:00:19different time

0:00:20yeah right it's not it's not too early

0:00:24it's not to monday

0:00:26oh it is just what it is I'm always

0:00:28ready for you is that right huh

0:00:31that can't be true I'm treating myself

0:00:32today to add this new thing i'm doing

0:00:35called the taste of my youth when I go

0:00:37and I revisit case of my youth so right

0:00:39now I'm having a a 6 ounce can of dole

0:00:44pineapple orange juice

0:00:46mmm god is good all from concentrate

0:00:51yeah right no comes in a can see no it's

0:00:54healthy

0:00:55is that something that you you actually

0:00:57had as as you this time

0:01:00this is the my Madeline mighty is a in

0:01:03gym class in tenth grade we had a drink

0:01:07dispenser you know i got like a pop

0:01:09machine but it dispensed juice and there

0:01:12was this brain was called Bluebird

0:01:14Bluebird orange juice which I've never

0:01:16heard of anywhere else and was orange

0:01:19juice that mostly tastes like pineapple

0:01:20and I always enjoyed it but I think when

0:01:23you get the concentrate

0:01:24you know you get a lot of get a

0:01:25pineapple aspect to it well that's the

0:01:26thing what is a pineapple concentrated

0:01:28orange oh my god

0:01:30move move move I never thought of it

0:01:33that way

0:01:33yeah sure you take a bunch of orange

0:01:35well this is what God did ya oranges was

0:01:38the fourth day third day and scrunched

0:01:40it scrunch it into an armadillo he's

0:01:43goes it goes into the pineapple yeah and

0:01:45then took a cactus and stuck it in the

0:01:47armadillos but I learned so much from

0:01:48you every week

0:01:49yeah well that's the thing about science

0:01:50me mhm

0:01:52you know you don't die encounter

0:01:54pineapples like you used to

0:01:55I think pineapples like like people &

0:01:58gorilla suits quicksand I think it might

0:01:59be a thing with the seventies

0:02:00well you know in the seventies I spent a

0:02:02lot of time in hawaii as we've talked

0:02:04about probably either many times or

0:02:06Never and in hawaii in the seventies

0:02:12there were pineapple fields as far as

0:02:15the eye could see

0:02:16fields forever it was by him fields

0:02:18forever living was easy with eyes closed

0:02:22and it was like one of the great things

0:02:26about going to Hawaii it was sugar cane

0:02:28and pineapples this kind of this i mean

0:02:31their plantations but but it's a big

0:02:35part of the culture there and all of

0:02:37that stuff is gone now you go to Y in

0:02:39there no there's no sugarcane there are

0:02:42no pineapples really really because it's

0:02:45just so much cheaper to grow that stuff

0:02:47elsewhere you know in China or well I

0:02:50don't think they grow pineapples and a

0:02:51well they will but not getting enough

0:02:54they found you know dole pineapple

0:02:57conglomerate inc gbh who found enormous

0:03:05places in Central and South America i

0:03:07think in Africa probably where they just

0:03:09set out what we'll just we'll grow

0:03:11pineapples here and now those a lot of

0:03:14those fields and why are either fallow

0:03:17or I don't know I don't

0:03:20it's kinda weird to go there and not see

0:03:22that stuff and I don't even understand

0:03:26why they just didn't let the back

0:03:27pineapples grow wild although i don't

0:03:29know what wild pineapples like this is

0:03:31that this is an interesting thing it's a

0:03:34digital turns out because for a long

0:03:36time we we heard about talked about peak

0:03:38oil and we be talking about the idea

0:03:40that there would be a point when we

0:03:43would reach more than fifty percent of

0:03:45the oil that could be gotten from the

0:03:48earth and then after that point it would

0:03:49become much more cost much more

0:03:51expensive which led to a lot of

0:03:52interesting discussions I'm just

0:03:53basically paraphrasing what's-his-name

0:03:55counselor but great look but the idea

0:03:58that like this little hustler magazine

0:04:00represent our i was injured his legal

0:04:02career back on select yeah good old

0:04:05counselor Cody look with the glasses on

0:04:07the glasses on top of his head and then

0:04:08the third pair of glasses yeah the other

0:04:10glass that cool hair

0:04:11let's go look at but you know if you

0:04:15read that stuff which I found very

0:04:17absorbing in the 2,000 there's the idea

0:04:20that so well setting aside slavery so

0:04:23much of what happens in America in the

0:04:26last hundred fifty at least years is

0:04:28based on

0:04:29on incredibly cheap energy that you

0:04:32don't mean just the idea that you know

0:04:33we could not you cannot have walmart be

0:04:36walmart without ships running on you

0:04:39know relatively cheap fuel and so must

0:04:42have changed

0:04:43actually i'm reading a book about

0:04:44walmart so i kind of have walmart on the

0:04:46brain right now but that's changed now

0:04:48walmart has become extremely interested

0:04:49in environmental sustainability not

0:04:51least because it's cheaper now and but

0:04:54but then the fuel prices went down so so

0:04:56like like what happens i mean there is

0:04:58our economy going to get all wackadoodle

0:04:59just continue to be wackadoodle based on

0:05:01these kinds of prices of fuel and like

0:05:03how could you not get pineapple from a

0:05:05way that just seems weird i'm not sure

0:05:07if this question here i'm just i'm

0:05:09concerned i think that i think that the

0:05:11other factors are labor is more

0:05:13expensive in Hawaii and there's a lot

0:05:16more regulation in Hawaii because it's

0:05:18America and you know grand land is more

0:05:21expensive and got increasingly more

0:05:23expensive and it's just you know when

0:05:26you're talking about a multinational

0:05:27corporation that's like how do we get

0:05:29how do we make 10 million pineapples as

0:05:33cheaply as we possibly can and and if

0:05:37fuel prices are low and we can fill up a

0:05:39exxon valdez for pineapples

0:05:41that's my drinking and true when you

0:05:44know because it's already expensive to

0:05:45get pineapples from Hawaii to anywhere

0:05:47yeah it's not that much more expensive

0:05:49to get them from nicaragua or you know

0:05:52probably from Nigeria I don't know I you

0:05:55know I keep throwing these I'm look I

0:05:56know I'm looking right now he's on his

0:05:57own we're going pineapples room but what

0:06:00you need you need water you need hot you

0:06:03can have high and you needed any ground

0:06:06costa rica costa rica there are

0:06:08different beans and then Brazil as of

0:06:102013 costa rica produces 2.7 million

0:06:14tons of pineapple a year huh lot of tons

0:06:19of pineapple yeah it looks like it is a

0:06:21pretty tight race between the

0:06:22Philippines Brazil costa rica i found a

0:06:26hawaii a I i was i was not a good match

0:06:30for a way i like the way that you

0:06:32pronounced hawaii hawaii hawaii you know

0:06:35we we west coasters for a long time you

0:06:38know we just like

0:06:39we angle sighs everything why Hawaii why

0:06:43but you you put that little extra like

0:06:46Hawaii life into the patchouli sounds

0:06:51good sounds good

0:06:52so you went to hawaii hawaii and did not

0:06:56you didn't you didn't bond with it

0:06:59well here's the thing first of all I

0:07:01think you know this about me sometimes I

0:07:04have trouble relaxing

0:07:05mhm and slightly separate from that i

0:07:08have i sometimes I'm a difficult

0:07:11acclimate er I don't always acclimate

0:07:13well or quickly like you seem like the

0:07:15kind of guy you got a bag you're on a

0:07:16plane you go somewhere and like you're

0:07:17already part of the culture here you try

0:07:19it try but like it takes me awhile to

0:07:21get into I've gotten better over the

0:07:23years but there was a time when we take

0:07:25me like three days to enjoy anything

0:07:27that wasn't being at my house

0:07:28uh-huh just shake off the like change

0:07:31yeah yeah yeah but I mean why else ye

0:07:34also i felt very very foreign not least

0:07:39because the people of Hawaii um don't

0:07:44love people coming there it's not an

0:07:47understandable it's not the warmest

0:07:48welcome and also I didn't like the food

0:07:50i couldn't get with the food i think

0:07:53you're either the kind of person it's

0:07:54like Scottish food either all about it

0:07:56you're like I can't believe this is food

0:07:58yeah I couldn't shave ice in the this

0:08:01BAM

0:08:02I but that's right up your alley oh well

0:08:05what's wonderful a about Hawaiian food

0:08:09is it really is kind of a like made out

0:08:14of the worst elements of like four

0:08:15different kinds of food right it's like

0:08:17the worst kind of japanese food and the

0:08:20worst kind of portuguese food hit the

0:08:22worst sort of american food and i love

0:08:25it right a pile of rice with breaded

0:08:29chicken

0:08:30mhm with a fried egg covered in gravy

0:08:35no you know what i should give another

0:08:36try up where I was just like this is a

0:08:39thing and they're like oh yeah it's

0:08:40called loco moco I've been that i am

0:08:44feeling loco moco mhm but Hawaii doesn't

0:08:49feel foreign to me because we went there

0:08:50a lot

0:08:51what were you why are you going there

0:08:52like remind me well because in the

0:08:54seventies the forty-ninth and fiftieth

0:08:58states had a very special relationship

0:08:59because right Alaska entered the united

0:09:05states in 1959 and hawaii in 1960 so

0:09:10they came in and I don't know in my head

0:09:12I always imagined they came in on the

0:09:13same time bill know there-there's a

0:09:16brief period where there was a where

0:09:19they made flags us flags with 49 stars

0:09:23I don't think it was for very long and

0:09:25it might we might have even been in a

0:09:27pit with in 1959 to buy but there was a

0:09:31brief period where there were the u.s.

0:09:33at 49 states

0:09:35I don't you you can double-check this

0:09:37but but uh so you know by nineteen

0:09:43seventy what both both places had been

0:09:45US states for 10 years and it was still

0:09:49very new

0:09:50it was also very exotic I mean Hawaii

0:09:53like do you think about why 50 or the

0:09:54Brady Bunch

0:09:55it was like us it was from my whole

0:09:57childhood that was the idyllic location

0:10:00Sherman my mother's entire life she all

0:10:03she ever not all she wanted but she

0:10:05really wanted to go on a vacation to

0:10:07Hawaii it was one of those things like

0:10:08that was her dream

0:10:09yeah sure you get a vacation to Hawaii

0:10:12exactly right it just just the just the

0:10:15term has all this all the smell of

0:10:18colitas rising up through the air

0:10:21I don't think they have colinas there i

0:10:23have that I've all sort of colitas yeah

0:10:25i know that's that's painful and it's

0:10:26information i'm alright thank you thanks

0:10:28for thanks for asking but when you think

0:10:30about magnum p.i that you know that's

0:10:33only 20 years after why I became a state

0:10:36well you less than that right so it's

0:10:38still very much like new new turf and so

0:10:42anyway all by way of saying that the

0:10:44alaska airlines and hawaiian airlines

0:10:48which were both sort of new ish

0:10:51newish carriers that were making a play

0:10:55to be bigger than just regional airlines

0:10:58they had this like a hundred dollar

0:11:02ticket hundred-dollar reciprocal ticket

0:11:05Anchorage to Honolulu damn and it was

0:11:08that's crazy and this understand now for

0:11:11the youngsters for the millenniums my

0:11:13name's don't know from travel it used to

0:11:15be you were not going to go anywhere for

0:11:17less than seven hundred thousand dollars

0:11:18he's welfare expensive to fly it was

0:11:21ended up in Alaska was you know it's

0:11:26such a different animal and it was hard

0:11:30to know like what

0:11:31because alaska airlines had these things

0:11:33a hundred-dollar tickets that were the

0:11:34river they had a hundred dollar ticket

0:11:36at one point when I graduate from high

0:11:38school ask airlines gave every scene

0:11:40every graduating senior in Alaska a free

0:11:44ticket to anywhere in Alaska chimney and

0:11:50so you could use this ticket to go visit

0:11:52somewhere like a barrow or Unalakleet or

0:11:57something where you would never

0:11:59otherwise go right you're not going to

0:12:01go to Unalakleet for probably as part of

0:12:04your job but if you got a free ticket

0:12:09why not go there and so all I left

0:12:11Alaska immediately after graduating and

0:12:13I didn't come back until after my free

0:12:16ticket to anywhere in Alaska had expired

0:12:19but all of my friends my high school

0:12:22friends all got together and flew to

0:12:24Kodiak which is like okay that's not

0:12:29exactly the most exotic place to go

0:12:31Kodiak you find out where they were they

0:12:33make the snuff it

0:12:34well you write or find out where they

0:12:36use the snow and they went down to

0:12:39Kodiak and they already had some big

0:12:41hotel room not nice hotel room I mean

0:12:44there i don't think there are any nice

0:12:45hotel rooms and Cody actually they got

0:12:47hotel rooms in some shitty hotel and

0:12:50they SAT and drank here you know drink

0:12:53like a keystone and inept Keystone then

0:12:56it would have been

0:12:57it would have been Stroh's Frank Stroh's

0:13:01in their old shitty hotel room wall

0:13:04trained outside for three days and then

0:13:06they flew home and I was like that was a

0:13:08waste and they were like yeah it was a

0:13:10waste like they should have gone

0:13:11it could have gone anywhere you know

0:13:13gnome yeah how many times you gonna say

0:13:16in your life you want to know I don't

0:13:18know I mean maybe maybe two maybe

0:13:20yeah 22 plus probably zero but maybe two

0:13:23I don't think i'm gonna say seven but we

0:13:24went to hawaii all the time because of

0:13:28this hundred dollar ticket and it was a

0:13:29direct flight Anchorage Honolulu so it's

0:13:31just like you didn't even have to go to

0:13:32America damn and Hawaiians came to

0:13:35Alaska and at the time like a Waikiki

0:13:38still had most of the stuff on Waikiki

0:13:42was still like grass roof like like you

0:13:46know like little little shacks with no

0:13:50windows that were bars and they had

0:13:54those little Tiki lanterns out front you

0:13:57know the streets kind of if you want if

0:13:59you want five or six blocks off of

0:14:02waikiki you know the streets would kind

0:14:05of dirt

0:14:06I mean it was very still just like felt

0:14:10like a small town they're obviously

0:14:11there were no the royal hawaiian was

0:14:13there they were that big Hilton was

0:14:14there there were some hotels along the

0:14:18strip but if you got if you got down the

0:14:21road a little ways it was just beer you

0:14:26know it was so hawaii and so chill and

0:14:31at that point there wasn't that

0:14:32hostility to outsiders because it was

0:14:36you know outsiders were sort of

0:14:38contained you know it was like yeah if

0:14:40you came to why you went to hear but you

0:14:42didn't go if you we went to my way back

0:14:45then and it was now it was nothing

0:14:47because all is all if memory serves it

0:14:49was always Honolulu and Waikiki and now

0:14:52he was like even in the late seventies

0:14:54now he was the hidden gem like if you

0:14:56really want to go to Hawaii gotta go to

0:14:57Malik's nobody threw into yet the

0:14:59streets were dirt for most of most of it

0:15:02on Maui had little little towns right

0:15:05you drive in and it's just a little it's

0:15:06like a little town kind of carved

0:15:08out of the out of the wild and oh my god

0:15:13it felt like a it felt like it was it

0:15:16was it was a paradisiacal who and now

0:15:20you know me as a constant traffic jam

0:15:23it's still incredible don't get me wrong

0:15:25but it's a traffic jam

0:15:26that's why we went to we went to Kauai

0:15:28Hawaii yeah which seems like there's

0:15:31like a few outposts around the rim and

0:15:33it's been a lot of land

0:15:36yeah and I think probably your

0:15:38experience of of Native Hawaiians being

0:15:41like less than aloha about you don't get

0:15:45me wrong now I mean in the same position

0:15:47I would feel the same way

0:15:48well you know who knows but they but

0:15:50they probably now increasingly I mean

0:15:53everybody there feels encroached upon

0:15:55even the you know even the Howley's that

0:15:59have been there 15 years feel like

0:16:01they're the OG Holly's and they don't

0:16:03want a new Howley's that's just the you

0:16:06know that's true very this is true at as

0:16:09i sit and think about it

0:16:10do I know a person that lives anywhere

0:16:13in the world who isn't mad about new

0:16:15people coming

0:16:15no no decisions have been there for a

0:16:17couple nights you're entitled to talk

0:16:19about how things are changing

0:16:20I'm trying to think I read something the

0:16:22other day oh it was an article about New

0:16:24Zealand saying that there were all these

0:16:27towns in New Zealand that were really

0:16:31encouraging people to move there and I

0:16:34think that they are like the you know

0:16:36the show old sheep farming towns kinda

0:16:39like I think I feel like there are towns

0:16:41in Nebraska and Kansas that everyone all

0:16:47the young people have moved away and i'm

0:16:49not entirely sure whether the residents

0:16:51of those towns are encouraging people to

0:16:53move there as much as they're just

0:16:54surrendering their just like taking deep

0:16:58breaths of their oxygen machines and

0:17:00hoping that the Lord comes soon but in

0:17:03right at in New Zealand I feel like a

0:17:06lot of i read this whole article about

0:17:09like they're in currently actually like

0:17:12incentivizing people to move to these

0:17:15small towns

0:17:16[Music]

0:17:17just because because they're losing you

0:17:21know and then the end and and the

0:17:23pictures of these places they seem

0:17:24idyllic but anybody that's read a real

0:17:27estate magazine knows that you can you

0:17:30can take a pretty good picture of a

0:17:31place

0:17:32sure but yeah maybe that's the future

0:17:35maybe maybe maybe maybe we should move

0:17:39to New Zealand in New Zealand flight i

0:17:44have used in the New Zealand i'm here to

0:17:46tell you it took me uh maybe 48 hours to

0:17:49seriously contemplate moving there

0:17:51did you did you go as a result of some

0:17:54sort of thing where they had some tech

0:17:55thing where they wanted you to come talk

0:17:57about their inboxes it something I did

0:18:01you go did you take all 43 folders there

0:18:03so tired attack now I went there for a a

0:18:10really cool conference and I did talk

0:18:14and I cried onstage and long people

0:18:15liked it it's kind of one of my famous

0:18:17talks and but I you know you know it's

0:18:22hard to tell until you've been somewhere

0:18:23two or three times it's hard to really

0:18:25make any kind of a saying reckoning of

0:18:27what's happening there but there are

0:18:29certain things about you you go

0:18:31somewhere you get a vibe and the vibe

0:18:33there is crazy

0:18:34I mean first I mean the one of the

0:18:36primary things is that people there are

0:18:37unknowingly and ironically friendly and

0:18:43kind unknowingly friendly and kind like

0:18:46people are nice they're not nice and

0:18:48like an annoying way there they are

0:18:52neighborly in some ways but not in like

0:18:55in-your-face way second like at like

0:18:59every cup of coffee i had there at every

0:19:01mcdonalds I had their the only thing

0:19:03that I had there was like just about the

0:19:06best of that I ever had

0:19:07it takes some fucking 20 minutes to make

0:19:09a cup of coffee and new zealand no

0:19:11maddening it's mostly copy this is what

0:19:13I got into espresso because they do the

0:19:14espresso drinks there but like the

0:19:16craftsmanship of what people do there is

0:19:18really palpable and and there's a lot of

0:19:21like the same one again this unit I like

0:19:23and I think about it

0:19:25nice people and a lot of civic pride

0:19:27that's this not annoying America is kind

0:19:29of ruin civic pride for

0:19:31a lot of countries but it's like to go

0:19:33somewhere like you're walking around

0:19:34Canada and everybody's got a papi

0:19:35because its remembrance day that's

0:19:36really nice and it's not to like you

0:19:38know have something to put on facebook

0:19:39it's because that's what people always

0:19:40do there you go there you go there and

0:19:42like you know what you get for she's the

0:19:44best she's ever gotten you know America

0:19:47has ruined civic pride for America to

0:19:49write me I used to put and I still kind

0:19:53of try like to pep civic pride and now

0:19:56she can get it sometimes you go watch go

0:19:59back to watch the video of Whitney

0:20:00Houston singing the star-spangled banner

0:20:01at that super bowl i'll still give you a

0:20:03little bit of a goose

0:20:05yeah I feel like yeah America I mean I

0:20:07say that shit I said that yesterday

0:20:09it's a great experience we're still

0:20:10trying yay american educator store

0:20:12buying we're still trying

0:20:14yeah USA but then you know and then

0:20:18somebody like an throws a can of school

0:20:21at me and then feel like I donk I don't

0:20:24you know this is what I was just saying

0:20:27that nothing to do with guns for the

0:20:29love of Christ how I know I know I know

0:20:32I I with the twitter in particular you

0:20:34know you I know you're on the facebook

0:20:35i'm not on the facebook twitter like I

0:20:37feel so inoculated because I don't go

0:20:40much outside my circle but then when I

0:20:42do I'm just I'm stunned I mean this is

0:20:46part of my brain that likes to think the

0:20:48whole like me man

0:20:50men's rights white power

0:20:53anti-immigrant that whole cluster I like

0:20:56to imagine that that is still the fringe

0:20:58I'm not persuaded that that is so much

0:21:01of the fringe as it used to be and it's

0:21:03kinda everywhere and it's awful and and

0:21:06they're like they're like some kind of

0:21:07science fiction creature where they just

0:21:08go find they find people with a good

0:21:10heart and try to try to destroy them and

0:21:12through and through school after school

0:21:14yeah I mean there's millions of millions

0:21:16and millions of people that that share

0:21:19that that cloud of ideology so much so

0:21:26that i'm i'm intrigued now that the

0:21:30liberal media if you will hurl our

0:21:33rather let me call it you know the

0:21:36intelligence of the thinkers are step

0:21:39progressive thought leaders progressive

0:21:41thought leaders are trying now

0:21:44to write think pieces and I know how you

0:21:48feel about think pieces and you know I

0:21:49feel about things I loved the think

0:21:50piece boy you know what couldn't have

0:21:52you know paper the ground with think

0:21:54pieces when I say a direction at work

0:21:56for three hours here's what I learned

0:21:57that but there are now increasingly

0:22:01those think pieces it's sort of atlantic

0:22:03magazine style long-form articles saying

0:22:06wait a minute if a hundred million

0:22:10Americans share a cosmology in which

0:22:17these ideas you know these these uh

0:22:21these ideas are like some kind of

0:22:25foundational underpinning of a worldview

0:22:29yeah i mean where it's not something

0:22:31people tolerate quietly like certain

0:22:33kinds of racism in the past things like

0:22:35that it's not just something is

0:22:36tolerated it something that helps people

0:22:37bond together people who formerly have

0:22:39seemingly nothing in common and what we

0:22:41thought of as civil discourse there are

0:22:43people who are finding common cause with

0:22:45other people that in a way it's kind of

0:22:46mind-blowing well and I think a lot of a

0:22:49lot of those cases right the what we see

0:22:52as the as the like overt deal killing

0:22:58racism implied in what in a lot of what

0:23:02gets said they see as like I rolling Lee

0:23:06unimportant small are racism that you

0:23:10should just get over because base what

0:23:13they're seeing in some of that action

0:23:15and some of those theories some of those

0:23:17philosophies is something else and a lot

0:23:21of and the liberal side stops at the

0:23:24racism wall and says whatever's on the

0:23:27other side of this i'm not interested in

0:23:29because the because the racism in

0:23:31inherent in it like blocks me from going

0:23:34further into this idea and the and the

0:23:38hundred million people who are able to

0:23:40get through that wall who live on the

0:23:42other side of that wall are like yeah

0:23:45racism racism but X or Y and there are

0:23:50so many of those so many of those

0:23:53different languages right with the the

0:23:57gun right stuff where you know we're

0:24:00from the left we have just arrived at a

0:24:02place where it's like if you speak

0:24:05positively about guns

0:24:07i I just I stopped at that fence because

0:24:10that because on the other side of that

0:24:12fence i expect to hear rationalization

0:24:15and justification for machine-gun

0:24:17killings of kids in schools and the

0:24:20hundred million people on the other side

0:24:21of that fence like yeah I got you know

0:24:23like guns symbolize and represent this

0:24:28other stuff and they just sort of I

0:24:30there's this I rolling about the things

0:24:34that matter to either side of it and

0:24:38that end I think that there is a lot of

0:24:41what we do cast one another in the most

0:24:45exaggerated possible role that we can

0:24:49think as an antagonist you know that and

0:24:52I was i I am on Facebook unfortunately

0:24:57because I because I don't know why I

0:25:00mean NEVER for your career

0:25:02it gives me as much it gives me as much

0:25:04pause as as Twitter does because you

0:25:09know I'm I don't curate either thing

0:25:11very well and so I just get this i just

0:25:13get tons of of evil all the time from

0:25:16both places and mostly the facebook evil

0:25:20is in the form of a really really really

0:25:24long essays about people's um like the

0:25:27current medical treatments not really

0:25:30evil it's just like the info and I you

0:25:34and I feel like looking at pictures of

0:25:36people's dogs on instagram is maybe the

0:25:38most people

0:25:39hmm but you can't say that because now

0:25:41i'm going to get 50 tweets from people

0:25:43of their dogs is it does sweet precious

0:25:45for babies but but I i'm on I i know a

0:25:48lot of people from high school and this

0:25:50is how the conversation always starts

0:25:51right you know a bunch of people from

0:25:53high school yeah and support Donald

0:25:54Trump and so I go over onto their

0:25:58threads and lurk i'm not i'm definitely

0:26:02not trying to argue with anybody i'm not

0:26:04really even comment

0:26:05the only if i do comment it will only be

0:26:07a law because I feel like law there

0:26:11three laws divorce the Rorschach test

0:26:14right three laws right there's the

0:26:16there's the capital L lowercase o

0:26:18lowercase L period that's that's law the

0:26:25sort of like grammatically correct law

0:26:27there's law capital all caps LOL caps

0:26:32law and then there's all work a slaw

0:26:35l.o.l law

0:26:37oh and that's almost like act well or it

0:26:41can be all three of those can be

0:26:42deployed in different ways but like I

0:26:44routinely will carry on a conversation

0:26:46with someone else where they are just

0:26:48just screaming at me and i'll reply with

0:26:52throughout the conversation all three of

0:26:54those loans right like you deploy your

0:26:57laws and then I'm like law and then at

0:27:00the enemy wall and it's fucking amazing

0:27:03law is I know there's a lot of people

0:27:06that that still have not gotten on board

0:27:08the law train for a full and the

0:27:11wrongful train kept it on the raffle

0:27:13trick but ruffle kind of went away

0:27:16didn't it

0:27:16roffle was so great for so long roll on

0:27:19the floor laughing yes absolutely and

0:27:21ruffle ruffle ruffle because it sounded

0:27:23like the Hamburglar but now but so are

0:27:26you love lamb burger ruffle butt so i'm

0:27:32working on these facebook threads of of

0:27:36high school friends and there are and

0:27:41there's this like there's a lot of humor

0:27:46in there in this group of guys who are

0:27:51supporting Donald Trump guys and gals

0:27:53right i mean it's very much like its its

0:27:56cultural rather than gender there are a

0:27:58lot of oh yeah woman who a massive Trump

0:28:02fans and there's a there's a ton of

0:28:04humor and a light heartedness about the

0:28:08way they talk but the humor right away

0:28:10is of a style of humor that we on the

0:28:14other side of the cultural fence have

0:28:18and we characterize that now is punching

0:28:19down right its humor at the expense of

0:28:22other people it's a no and so much of

0:28:25the humor is like why can't you take a

0:28:26joke style but the people who feel that

0:28:29they're they are aggrieved it's anything

0:28:31but punching down

0:28:32yeah exactly right i mean they're

0:28:34they're under assault because you know

0:28:37because there are good god bless I wish

0:28:39you get again have the days where that

0:28:40was considered punching down but now

0:28:42there's blocks everywhere in lying lying

0:28:44dishonest Hillary well and you know and

0:28:46also like there are only whatever a

0:28:50billion Christians in the world some of

0:28:52course there are minority and when you

0:28:53look at growth that curve what killing

0:28:55Jesus but you know the thing is that the

0:28:57that all of those people on my facebook

0:28:59page would probably identify as

0:29:02Christian but they're not they're not

0:29:04bible thumpers they are very different

0:29:07from like an eighties feel ya there do

0:29:09beer-drinking hellraisers right there

0:29:11are Alaskans who got big trucks and they

0:29:14like to shoot guns and fuck the world

0:29:15and you know and they're fun they think

0:29:17of themselves as fun and their support

0:29:21of Trump only other fun and they can

0:29:23take it they can't take a joke

0:29:24exactly and and the thing is you know

0:29:26you and I were raised in in a culture

0:29:29where the why can't you take a joke

0:29:32style of bullying was the norm and

0:29:37somehow through the course of our lives

0:29:39we've arrived at a place where hey you

0:29:43know why can't you take a joke style

0:29:44bullying is sort of like a pretty bad

0:29:49way of socializing people it is but is

0:29:52also but if i remember correctly

0:29:53especially amongst family members and as

0:29:56a young person's young man i think they

0:29:59meant to be helpful

0:30:00where is like a poli aside thing Hey

0:30:02look man you learn how to take a fucking

0:30:03joke

0:30:04sticks and stones will break your bones

0:30:05yeah like maybe don't keep bugging the

0:30:07cabdriver about racist jokes like

0:30:08fucking dial it down

0:30:10well and so all of my facebook pals

0:30:12which is to say my friends from high

0:30:15school I mean the only people online who

0:30:18follow me who avidly disagree with me or

0:30:21my high school friends are trolls right

0:30:24and indexes and well know that my none

0:30:27of my ex-girlfriends are on social media

0:30:30was that was that part of the the

0:30:32agreement

0:30:33no I for many many years every woman I

0:30:37dated was growing and you don't get the

0:30:39lens that didn't it had nothing to do

0:30:42with me it was just like I was attracted

0:30:44to lights and and and i don't know why

0:30:48right i mean every girl I ever dated had

0:30:51the thing that attracted to me a

0:30:52attracted me to her from across the room

0:30:55was something on the order of like that

0:30:58girl have leaves in her hair done just

0:31:04got strong bones returns veteran she

0:31:07knows how to take a fucking joke

0:31:08yeah why why does she have leaves in her

0:31:10hair and I walked over to my sleeves and

0:31:12she'd say fuck you can a bad can it be

0:31:16should we take this is full now on you

0:31:19take a third location and good life

0:31:22intrigued by you tell me more about your

0:31:25leaves so i can't be on to something

0:31:27there some girls if in my past some ex

0:31:30girlfriends that I would just like to

0:31:32talk to because it's like a it's been 15

0:31:35years just checking in the only way I

0:31:39the only even like way I have of knowing

0:31:42anything about their continued existence

0:31:44is that some friend of a friend of hers

0:31:47is on facebook and every once in a while

0:31:49there are some something float by where

0:31:52it's like oh that's you know i'm

0:31:53following her friend of a friend I see

0:31:55some picture of the back of her hair and

0:31:57I'm like I know those leaves

0:31:58that's right somebody put photo Tammy

0:32:01anything about Tammy Tammy but but yeah

0:32:04so that so what what I find over there

0:32:07in that world is like there is a

0:32:10tremendous feeling of togetherness and

0:32:13lightheartedness and feeling like

0:32:15they're the only people left in the

0:32:17world who have even a reasonable outlook

0:32:20on life and that over here in the

0:32:23liberal like we're all a bunch of in the

0:32:27on the liberal side of the fence

0:32:28we're all a bunch of thumb suckers and

0:32:32concern trolls basically like what are

0:32:34we so been added

0:32:36about wellness and again the implicitly

0:32:39i'm going to keep making this about

0:32:40perceived status but what do we have to

0:32:43be mad about especially because we're on

0:32:45the ascent we're the ones who get to

0:32:47redefine the idea of you know gender not

0:32:50being digital and things like that

0:32:51where's your fucking everything up like

0:32:53we're not allowed to be mad yeah we are

0:32:55the ones imposing an agenda

0:32:57yeah and and the and the and that

0:33:01informs their narrative about the things

0:33:03that are on their agenda are either

0:33:05status quo things that they would like

0:33:07to maintain or things that they

0:33:09perceived to have been traditional

0:33:13things which have been encroached upon

0:33:15that they would like to regain that turf

0:33:18but they think about themselves as just

0:33:21holding the line of what normal is

0:33:24and they they see us on the other side

0:33:27pushing what and you hear this term all

0:33:29the time radical agenda

0:33:30yeah but it is you know it is an

0:33:33encroaching agenda so when I when I you

0:33:37know when i hear that litany of

0:33:38descriptions of the of people that

0:33:41represent now millions and millions and

0:33:44millions and millions of millions of

0:33:45people I i have to resist my own like

0:33:51knee-jerk reaction to say like they're

0:33:54all idiots right and try and get inside

0:33:57that culture a little bit and be like

0:33:58what is it like from in here and if you

0:34:02think about all those people are the

0:34:03Trump rallies that we look like to look

0:34:05at and just go like oh my god they're

0:34:06the worst

0:34:07they're the worst with their you know

0:34:10that the only thing missing is a

0:34:12baseball hat with two beer cans in it

0:34:14and fuckin straws coming down but from

0:34:18within that trump rally they think of

0:34:20themselves as having a blast

0:34:23yeah and Trump is having a blast that's

0:34:25it's a monster truck show

0:34:27it's a monster truck show and we and and

0:34:29from the outside we look like a bunch of

0:34:31just joyless grave like can't take a

0:34:36joke don't appreciate this is this is

0:34:38people whose lives have been until it's

0:34:41a little bit like the whole states

0:34:42rights things kind of played out again

0:34:44was like hey we have all this worked out

0:34:46you're going to stay off our ship we

0:34:47start your shit and of course that

0:34:49never the case and so you know we not

0:34:51only are we the aggrieved party if we

0:34:52should choose to look at it that way but

0:34:54like we have a sense of humor we see

0:34:56like you sit there and like you have I

0:35:00just listened to three episodes of a

0:35:01podcast about how horrible life will be

0:35:03at Donald Trump becomes president is

0:35:05very good podcast called the truck cast

0:35:06but i highly recommend very good it's

0:35:08very opinionated and it's very well done

0:35:10but like people look at that and go on

0:35:11my god and but what they think what they

0:35:13also see is they see how scared we are

0:35:15they see how how terrified and powerless

0:35:21so many people feel and like that's all

0:35:24the more reason to start pulling for

0:35:25that particular pro wrestler

0:35:27it's like holy shit somebody finally put

0:35:28a scare into John Roderick a that fucker

0:35:31up all the dog the dog can smell your

0:35:33fear

0:35:34yeah right but you know i was on a

0:35:35conference call earlier today within a

0:35:37city agency and it was a group of

0:35:40probably 20 people talking into a

0:35:42probably 18 of them were sitting around

0:35:45a conference table and I was laying in

0:35:47bed talking to them with a with my

0:35:50podcast and that is all around that's it

0:35:51that's it to rip this a terrific way to

0:35:53get a lot of stuff does just get but

0:35:55people are really the speakerphone

0:35:56yeah and at one point there someone

0:36:00spoke up and said our you know we're

0:36:03looking for people to participate in

0:36:06this event it's you know the event is

0:36:09targeted at you know young women of

0:36:14color and so and as the perfect

0:36:18describing it

0:36:19she sort of says as an aside to the

0:36:22people in the room like so anyone here

0:36:24that wants to get involved in this

0:36:26please you know talk to me after the

0:36:28meeting and sorry we're not really

0:36:31looking for any sis males mhm and within

0:36:37the context of this conversation that

0:36:41was you know like yeah

0:36:43self-evidently right you're looking for

0:36:45people that can identify and though and

0:36:49in particular people that these young

0:36:50women can identify with right that's the

0:36:53that that is the element that's missing

0:36:55that's why this event is even happening

0:36:58because these young women of color are

0:37:01not represented they don't see they

0:37:05don't have role models the same way and

0:37:07and we're trying to now build these

0:37:09institutions where there where there are

0:37:12these mentoring relationships but from

0:37:16from within a Donald Trump rally

0:37:18what is the answer to that what from the

0:37:20men's rights organizations or the gamer

0:37:22Gators to what you two huge problems

0:37:25problem number one is you're excluding

0:37:27the people who are never allowed to be

0:37:28excluded in second you're using a term

0:37:30that they find unnecessary and

0:37:32potentially offensive exactly right i

0:37:34mean it is kind of more than one thing

0:37:36it's not just roll your eyes over this

0:37:38neologism it's that oh my god I can't

0:37:40believe you have the temerity to leave

0:37:41us out and then to use this faggot name

0:37:43for us

0:37:44well that and and and the way that that

0:37:46would then the way that they would the

0:37:48way that argument would coalesce is well

0:37:50what would happen if I said that we were

0:37:53having a meeting and no women color

0:37:55right and it's what we have when we have

0:38:00a men's government clock right like the

0:38:03flow you mean every meeting and

0:38:05everything that's ever happened 453

0:38:07there's a lot of cooking for 50 years

0:38:10but but that is there is a you know

0:38:15there's a libertarian logic to that

0:38:17which is no regulation of any kind is

0:38:22the purest form of life and as soon as

0:38:27you start instituting rules then you're

0:38:30already on the way to talat arianism

0:38:32especially if those rules are about me

0:38:35right if those rules affect me or or

0:38:38three reasons it's amazing how rarely

0:38:39people who self-identify as libertarians

0:38:41are fighting to have things lifted from

0:38:44people aren't them well yeah right

0:38:48because if there were no rules about who

0:38:49could go to meetings uh then it would

0:38:53just be back to a question of their

0:38:56ethnic bites you never think that's

0:38:59exactly right like like and then it and

0:39:02and i think i think affirmative action

0:39:04as an ocean was the moment at which

0:39:09some number of of some number of

0:39:15carriages on the train of progress just

0:39:17got unhooked because it was a leap of

0:39:20logic a leap of of of like like a kind

0:39:30of faith or a an understanding the

0:39:36understanding that redress is even

0:39:38possible and that redress would be

0:39:41beneficial to all that is that's a

0:39:45that's oh right right to not frame it as

0:39:48like a handout to get these people off

0:39:50our back but rather something that could

0:39:52improve the culture and society for

0:39:54everybody

0:39:55yeah that that that the the benefits of

0:39:57affirmative action the benefits of equal

0:40:00rights for all are not a they're not a

0:40:04machine to two newly privilege another

0:40:08group over you they're they're not

0:40:11taking anything away from you

0:40:13it's it is an attempt to continue to

0:40:18perfect to the notion of the American

0:40:21experimented that can it's a

0:40:22continuation of a of a of progress that

0:40:26we've made throughout time that benefits

0:40:29everyone because progress benefits

0:40:32everyone and the the more you know we

0:40:36have watched well disseminate and we

0:40:40were so were so consumed with how wealth

0:40:43is concentrated right now and it is it's

0:40:47it's like it unfairly grossly

0:40:49concentrated in the in the one-percent

0:40:52but the fact is compared to even 60

0:40:56years ago when people were still

0:40:59routinely starving to death around the

0:41:01world in you know number in numbers that

0:41:05would astonish you even now to look at

0:41:07you know we have we as a as a human as a

0:41:10human race through technology and

0:41:12through democracy have turned to the

0:41:15earth truly into a

0:41:18into a garden of Plenty and people now

0:41:23live life expectancy has doubled and the

0:41:27and education has doubled in or you know

0:41:30like people are are so much more

0:41:32educated and cared for then maybe I'm

0:41:35just think about medical care for old

0:41:37and young people

0:41:38yeah then the amount of things that we

0:41:40know to avoid doing so we don't die as

0:41:42young and you know something does happen

0:41:44we have ways to treat stuff that didn't

0:41:46exist 50 years ago a life expectancy of

0:41:48people in 1900 was about 40 but it

0:41:52wasn't meant for fifteen yeah you know

0:41:54and so so with that in mind you know you

0:41:58can just make this this case that this

0:42:01combination of science and philosophy

0:42:04science on the one hand you know

0:42:07improving them are material life and and

0:42:11philosophy on the other sort of

0:42:12improving our like agency our political

0:42:17agency are belonging and I mean by that

0:42:22political philosophy and also you know

0:42:24the philosophy of the mind and that case

0:42:29that you know that case of affirmative

0:42:33action in that case of social justice

0:42:36which in the context of like reparations

0:42:43just naturally a defends the people who

0:42:50aren't making a philosophical lead it

0:42:53offends them because they say well my

0:42:56grandfather had hard migrate

0:42:58nobody-nobody i mean we had a

0:43:00hardscrabble life nobody ever gave me

0:43:02for money

0:43:02yeah where's my parade right like my

0:43:05great-grandparents came over from

0:43:06Ireland and they didn't you know they

0:43:11didn't riot or whatever that that logic

0:43:14of the logic where you're only seeing

0:43:16reparations in in terms of like a

0:43:22cash-out or or an unfair advantage being

0:43:26afforded to you rather than seeing it as

0:43:29like part of this grand experiment how

0:43:31are we try

0:43:32to create what are our theories about

0:43:35political science where we can we can

0:43:39raise the bar for everybody and now

0:43:42we're at a place where that has been so

0:43:44poorly explained that we've lost we've

0:43:48lost half the country and I and I do put

0:43:52the blame on the Intelligencia the

0:43:56Academy for lack of a better description

0:43:59for having done such a poor job of

0:44:02articulating what the project and i

0:44:07think within academia because within

0:44:11academia they also perceived themselves

0:44:14to be a threatened minority who write

0:44:17the the college life and the and the

0:44:21ivory tower folks saw themselves as

0:44:25revolutionaries 20 at war against a a a

0:44:30you know a majority of dummies and so

0:44:35they you know they used the the same

0:44:38inflammatory language of resistance and

0:44:42and and war that we were we were under

0:44:48siege and we were going to we were going

0:44:52to take it to the level of like we were

0:44:56going to him in in a lot of ways impose

0:44:59these theories because if people didn't

0:45:01like it they could suck it right like if

0:45:04you didn't like it too bad for you this

0:45:07is what's right

0:45:08this is what's right for you and no and

0:45:11the and the and trying to get people to

0:45:14rally which is what we need

0:45:16trying to get people to understand and

0:45:18and get on board that crucial step the

0:45:23Academy stop even pretending and so now

0:45:27we fit we failed utterly failed to to

0:45:30get everybody to understand what what

0:45:36we're trying to accomplish and and you

0:45:38know and and it's and a lot of that is

0:45:40understandable

0:45:41that but you and I have talked about

0:45:44this a lot every single group of people

0:45:46feels like they are the money minority

0:45:48yep and they all feel like they have to

0:45:53defend they have to defend themselves

0:45:55and then I think the many people really

0:45:58do it let's put this way there's not

0:46:01that many people one of my old saws is

0:46:04like I don't think there's that many

0:46:05people in existence today that would

0:46:07describe themselves as stupid and I

0:46:10don't think there's actually that many

0:46:11Americans who would describe themselves

0:46:12as being one commonly fortunate and

0:46:16privileged that's changing a little bit

0:46:18but i think this they're still

0:46:19everybody's got their reasons for why

0:46:22they think the way they think and do the

0:46:24way they do and based on strong feelings

0:46:26and anecdotes and traditions and things

0:46:28like that there's the minutes but that's

0:46:30that's always been the case it's just we

0:46:32we always see the log in somebody else's

0:46:34I but the other part of this that i

0:46:37think is another failing of benefits the

0:46:40academia but the failure of all people

0:46:43but im gonna have it fall harvest on the

0:46:44Liberals is our inability he described

0:46:48how old is getting racist shut it down

0:46:50like this is getting like you're

0:46:51obviously you have done so you're an

0:46:53idiot shut it down like there's a

0:46:55failure of imagination i think on the

0:46:57liberal side and failure of empathy to

0:46:59understand why people are saying what

0:47:00they're saying in the way that they are

0:47:02saying it and the fact that we disagree

0:47:04strongly with the very top level of how

0:47:07they present themselves and what the

0:47:08rhetoric is and choosing not to play by

0:47:10the same rules that we do in terms of

0:47:12you know online discourse or discourse

0:47:15in general I think that leads to a very

0:47:17dangerous lack of empathy of not

0:47:19actually listening to what these people

0:47:20are saying because when you actually

0:47:22read these pieces about people who go

0:47:23into a Donald Trump rally for example

0:47:25it's frequently extremely interesting

0:47:28where you want this person meets people

0:47:30they genuinely like like weirdos that

0:47:33they like inside of a Donald Trump rally

0:47:34but you know what gets reported fairly

0:47:37is the one person who yells hang the

0:47:39bitch in clinton is named the problem is

0:47:41you hear that often enough and you're

0:47:44gonna get the feeling that that you're

0:47:45gonna make all this and try to defend

0:47:47Donald Trump what i am saying there's a

0:47:49lot more going on than just we love

0:47:50Donald Trump Donald Trump is the

0:47:52figurehead for 4,000 different hydras

0:47:55and like to think that that's all the

0:47:56same people with the same for you and

0:47:57you just put this this and this big pile

0:47:59of dumb people who don't get it and I

0:48:00don't like you're missing out on a lot

0:48:02of stuff did you read that New Yorker

0:48:03article III think I've read all the

0:48:05articles and there's one with a guy when

0:48:08there's the the one guy there who was

0:48:10into chemtrails it was handing out

0:48:11bottles of water that while i'm sorry

0:48:13you're reading my blog

0:48:15no no this guy from the New York did one

0:48:19of those wonderful new yorker pieces

0:48:20where he was just like I'm just gonna go

0:48:22to this Trump rally and see if I can

0:48:23make any friends and he did you know

0:48:25what I see and he had that thing where

0:48:27he's where he would say because he was

0:48:29only want to build a wall and he would

0:48:31say well what about this one a situation

0:48:34where this gal was born or you know i

0:48:37was born in America or well I'm sorry

0:48:39was born in Mexico but brought to

0:48:40America when she was three months old

0:48:42and uh and got a parking ticket and now

0:48:45she's being deported and almost

0:48:47everybody he asked was like oh well I

0:48:49mean and the first thing they said was

0:48:50issued a good person

0:48:52yeah right well she's a good person then

0:48:53we should figure out it means there

0:48:55should be exceptions certainly you know

0:48:56like in each case there their initial

0:49:00their initial argument of like build a

0:49:02wall keep them out but your but when you

0:49:04do that your problem tising something

0:49:06that seems very simple which is hey

0:49:07we're here at this rally to talk about

0:49:09Matt we are like you think in a year

0:49:11people get fuck all for Donald Trump

0:49:12they're there because he represents a

0:49:15very very deep anger and discontentment

0:49:17what has happened in America some of

0:49:19which a lot of people might surprisingly

0:49:21want to agree with a lot of stuff

0:49:22happened between 2008 and 2010 in this

0:49:25country that a lot of people are mad

0:49:26about on every side of every aisle

0:49:29that's a lot of it there's a lot of the

0:49:31losing jobs and I'm not trying to defend

0:49:33any of this but but I think I guess what

0:49:35I'm trying to say is that like I think

0:49:36it's it's uniquely on smart liberals to

0:49:41be such dealings about trying to put

0:49:43people in a box that they can understand

0:49:44and hate at scale

0:49:45instead of trying to actually listen to

0:49:46what somebody is saying so in that case

0:49:48what you just described somebody goes

0:49:49into that rally and goes from goes from

0:49:52being a bunch of rapist from Mexico to

0:49:53here's this one girl that I could

0:49:55imagine my kid knowing that changes

0:49:57everything because now it's not about

0:49:58people it's about eight person but we

0:50:00rarely do the same thing with people we

0:50:01disagree with and that's on us we are

0:50:04making it worse when we try to demonize

0:50:08demon eyes on the people who are we

0:50:11don't agree with what we we don't have

0:50:12the empathy to try to hear what's

0:50:14happening behind what they're saying

0:50:15we're because it's a culture that's

0:50:17foreign to us it's like watching

0:50:18bullfighting remembers when i'm sure we

0:50:19can be mad about I well I know what

0:50:21could be bad about because the Sun but

0:50:23ain't no yeah this is the just and just

0:50:26as you see no i was reading The Guardian

0:50:29an article by dave eggers your daddy

0:50:32Dave Eggers goes to a Donald Trump rally

0:50:33see that the man in front of me said he

0:50:36was pointing to a jets white trail in

0:50:38the sky above us

0:50:39that's the air force is playing shit in

0:50:41the sky bigger says i'll call this man

0:50:44Jim oh good

0:50:46any like jim was buying bottled water

0:50:48for everybody and being eventually i I'm

0:50:51sorry to dissemble and to be such an

0:50:54unloyal uh you know fellow traveler at

0:50:57such an important time but fucking

0:50:58everybody

0:50:59well yeah I'm mad about Donald Trump to

0:51:01like i think is a dangerous man but like

0:51:03just yelling across the aisle is not

0:51:05going to make this better

0:51:06the more things that we do to show how

0:51:09we're right in there wrong

0:51:10the further we dig ourselves into a

0:51:12completely untenable situation that the

0:51:14unit on an interesting thing a second

0:51:16ago which was thank you mean you know

0:51:19it's rare moment that's very that's

0:51:21three for me that fuckin 206 episodes a

0:51:24rare diamond in the horse shit I don't

0:51:27know how the horse ate the diamond don't

0:51:29ask somebody for a diamond in a banana

0:51:32fed to a horse like introduction and

0:51:35then I saw it come out of the poop poop

0:51:37chute know the idea i mean way up the

0:51:41idea of privilege right now whenever

0:51:48whenever someone speaks about privilege

0:51:50there's a there's an aspect of

0:51:52recrimination an apology in it

0:51:54no one talks about their own privilege

0:51:56you know it with any pride certainly on

0:51:59our side of the fence right if you say

0:52:01the word privilege you are saying it now

0:52:03like I mean you know in terms of white

0:52:06privilege you have this thing and you're

0:52:08sorry for it and you're trying to amend

0:52:10for it you know that you that this has

0:52:13become a term of art for a kind of

0:52:17[Music]

0:52:19for a form of shame at your privilege

0:52:24and I think it gets the second but I'm

0:52:26not interrupt the first of all I think

0:52:28it's a little bit like acknowledging the

0:52:29air is free and we get it yet part of it

0:52:32is just acknowledging that is actually a

0:52:34thing that rather than my emotions about

0:52:35how might I feel but heard about

0:52:37somebody calling me that then i have to

0:52:38really stop it you know what you're

0:52:40actually really fucking right I can walk

0:52:41anywhere I want and I'll be fine but the

0:52:43but the issue i think in our culture at

0:52:47large is that no one is acknowledging

0:52:49that they are in charge

0:52:51it's always somebody else did everyone

0:52:54select right and and and i say this

0:52:57about about the Liberals at as much or

0:53:01more than anyone else

0:53:03this this sense of being under siege

0:53:06means that there's no intellectual

0:53:09tradition or cultural tradition that

0:53:13doesn't that doesn't describe itself as

0:53:16under siege including all of the rich

0:53:19preppy guys at the Yale Club in in New

0:53:24York City who are kind of circling

0:53:26around their gin and tonics and saying

0:53:28you know they're coming at us from all

0:53:30sides where the last of a dying breed

0:53:33so no one in America will acknowledge

0:53:36that they are the establishment and in

0:53:40that in everyone's failure to

0:53:44acknowledge that they are the

0:53:45establishment

0:53:45no one is in charge no one has to take

0:53:48responsibility and so right now

0:53:52effectively the liberals are the

0:53:56establishment we really are like our

0:53:59candidate is going to win the presidency

0:54:01and our candidate has been the president

0:54:05for the last eight years and liberal

0:54:07ideas are ascendant and have been for a

0:54:10long time now we feel under assault

0:54:13because there are hundreds of millions

0:54:15of people or you know a hundred and

0:54:18fifty million people on the other side

0:54:20of the aisle who are throwing a spit

0:54:24wads at us right and who want guns to be

0:54:28unregulated and who want abortion to be

0:54:30illegal and etc etc etc

0:54:32and they are the there the other side of

0:54:37the of the aisle but really they benefit

0:54:39from liberal ideas to and the degree to

0:54:42which they acknowledge that or don't is

0:54:45just a failure of of language or you

0:54:48know it's a failure of of comprehension

0:54:50more than anything but at some point the

0:54:55people with privilege who are for all

0:54:58intensive purposes every American

0:55:00listening to this podcast regardless of

0:55:01race or gender you have electricity in

0:55:03the computer we yeah and you are smart

0:55:06enough to be listening to me and tony

0:55:08award-winning broadcaster on the line

0:55:11yeah right you are the intellectual a

0:55:1410-percent we are your the reason we do

0:55:17it you know what it's all for you and

0:55:19the kids for the kids but 22 to accept

0:55:24that mantle and to say i am part of the

0:55:28leading one part of the leadership and I

0:55:31have a responsibility not to think of

0:55:33myself constantly as a victim and

0:55:35constantly under siege

0:55:37I have a responsibility to be the adult

0:55:39in the room and to say here are our

0:55:42ideas and why they make sense

0:55:45here's the larger world we're trying to

0:55:47cut to construct it's a world where

0:55:50fairness does predominate it's a world

0:55:53where a rising tide does lift all boats

0:55:55and it's some version of you know

0:55:59socialistic capitalistic Democratic you

0:56:05know uh like a like a secular whatever

0:56:09this this cloud of ideas that we all

0:56:13sort of bathe in and pick and choose

0:56:14grapes from took two to create a world

0:56:19view that we can proudly hold up and say

0:56:22you know I do have privilege it is the

0:56:25privilege of being a person in this

0:56:28culture who is responsible for for this

0:56:33world home trying to me

0:56:35yeah and that a that shouldering of the

0:56:37burden and refusal to think of yourself

0:56:41as

0:56:42as someone who is who's constantly in a

0:56:46posture of defense is also a leap like a

0:56:51like a intellectual and spiritual lead

0:56:54and it isn't to say you don't say the

0:56:58word privilege with with a tonne of

0:57:01apology you say I'm privileged to be

0:57:03able to say the following things right

0:57:06I'm privileged to be able to come to you

0:57:08today and described the world i imagine

0:57:12and the world we collectively are trying

0:57:13to imagine and I I feel like over time

0:57:17the way to to to have this experiment

0:57:22not devolved into what it is you know

0:57:25what we're all afraid it's doing right

0:57:26now which is just this like two nations

0:57:29scenario where in order to get from

0:57:33Seattle to Minneapolis you're gonna have

0:57:36to fly over hostile territory or have a

0:57:39passport right to go up to code frost

0:57:42red state land before going into cloak

0:57:46mode you know and like Minneapolis and

0:57:48and and chicago or kind of up there and

0:57:51it's weird like lake Lake down town

0:57:55country that goes up to ontario um in

0:58:00order to in order to not have that

0:58:02happen we we just and we're the ones

0:58:04that have to do it we have to make a

0:58:06better case we have to articulate a case

0:58:09that isn't from our own our own state of

0:58:13victimization but a case that is

0:58:15encompassing that says listen you guys

0:58:18we're not trying to be humorless drudges

0:58:22here we're not trying to force you to

0:58:24all be gay that it sucks we don't want

0:58:28you to be getting really don't want you

0:58:29to because we just want the game ones of

0:58:31you to be happy

0:58:33that's good friends right come on

0:58:37yeah but they're gonna be three students

0:58:40interested in this idea though the the

0:58:42tickle taking leadership just kind of

0:58:44grabbing it you know being the one's

0:58:46gonna love you know let it begin with me

0:58:48i'm gonna run this meeting

0:58:49yeah very very interesting idea you know

0:58:52acknowledging that you already have that

0:58:53you're already

0:58:55kind of running the meeting that's

0:58:58that's a strangely existential i like it

0:59:00i gotta i was i I tweeted out a an ex of

0:59:05mine is the gal that spearheading the

0:59:09shout your abortion movement and i

0:59:13retweeted one of her tweets and I got a

0:59:19reply on facebook from a guy that I went

0:59:23to college with and i went to a Catholic

0:59:24College for a couple years and this

0:59:26friend of mine is a big big burly kind

0:59:29of you know Irish Catholic I taller than

0:59:31me bigger than me like a bit many i know

0:59:34right well that's his name Jimmy Jimmy o

0:59:38O'Shaughnessy not attracted and he has I

0:59:41should you not eight kids

0:59:44hope is a clean a nap and he has a

0:59:48little darling kids ranging in age from

0:59:51Lee 24 comes from 0 to 11 and he's uh

0:59:59he's a what

0:59:59he's a what

1:00:00the guy hilarious guy he comments on my

1:00:03facebook page all the time he's a

1:00:06liberal guy he's a funny guy but he is

1:00:09anti-abortion mhm and he's anti abortion

1:00:12because every life is sacred and that is

1:00:16that is a worldview right it's alex katz

1:00:19got their reasons I mean it's an

1:00:20accompanying worldview and it begins at

1:00:22up at an initial premise which is every

1:00:25life is sacred and that sacredness comes

1:00:29from its from the fact that there is a

1:00:31soul to where we are we are essentially

1:00:33stewards of those lives right and from

1:00:36their perspective like like just as we

1:00:40just as we look back at our founding

1:00:42fathers and go how could they possibly

1:00:44have had slaves and simultaneously been

1:00:47writing these you know these like

1:00:49Florida and beautiful dark it's almost

1:00:51like they're from a different time it's

1:00:52like they're from a different time that

1:00:54different values so we Catholics are our

1:00:57there's a large proportion of the

1:00:59philosophical Catholics whoo-hoo imagine

1:01:02some future day when people will look

1:01:04back in time and say how could we have

1:01:06sat how could our forefathers of SAT

1:01:08idly by during this genocide of souls

1:01:13but also at the same time if I may

1:01:15compare the amount of volunteer time

1:01:18five of your ne5 your friends spent vs

1:01:20in average sampling of five people from

1:01:23your local parish people who are like it

1:01:25tremendously involved in good causes and

1:01:28like trying to be Stewart's of trying to

1:01:30trying to fit a certain New Testament

1:01:32idea of good works right right well and

1:01:34and and again i say i'm saying they're

1:01:37not bad he's up an end up in a tower

1:01:38with some sandwiches and toilet paper

1:01:40taking shots of people you know

1:01:41no they're not bad you know there and

1:01:43and I and I and this guy is just one of

1:01:45thousands of people i know on that side

1:01:48of the fence you know who and some of

1:01:50them are really really philosophical but

1:01:52it begins at this initial premise and so

1:01:55he wrote on my facebook page you know

1:01:57can I please ask you to take this post

1:02:01down in respect of the millions of souls

1:02:07that are you know that and then and he

1:02:09used some inflammatory language at that

1:02:11point

1:02:12you know a few a few adjectives like it

1:02:15but equivalent to you putting up a

1:02:17picture of Auschwitz on an elie wiesel

1:02:19page

1:02:20yeah like you come onto that that's not

1:02:21cool but he's he's a friend of mine he

1:02:25respects me he follows me he is you know

1:02:27he's one of what i would consider to be

1:02:31my or season in my orbit and this and I

1:02:35and I got into his sandbox right and

1:02:38he's a supporter of obama and hillary

1:02:41but this is his mhm yeah you know his

1:02:44little like core issue at the center of

1:02:48his world at the center of his vision of

1:02:51the world and and I wrote him back very

1:02:53bright

1:02:54I didn't write him back because we're

1:02:57living in this shit world where all I

1:02:59did was comment on his golf ball that's

1:03:02like David well I didn't write him back

1:03:04on market center taper like they should

1:03:07wall said I gave him all three laws no i

1:03:12didn't know it's like be the Holy

1:03:13Trinity that he lost the Father the Son

1:03:18of the nominee domini time fav by

1:03:21running back and said listen you know

1:03:23like in all honesty we have a different

1:03:29different foundational idea of the value

1:03:32of human life and I do not share your

1:03:39view that every life is sacred and so

1:03:43forth at the second s of that life

1:03:44Trump's this other right now should I

1:03:48consider pretty important but within

1:03:50that like you have to acknowledge you

1:03:53have to just if you're if you're going

1:03:55to if you're going to get into that wait

1:03:57until you have to just say like I

1:03:59because if you say that like there is a

1:04:02small amount of sacredness to a life and

1:04:05it doesn't and it's not equivalent to

1:04:08the right and is a spectrum of sacred

1:04:10yeah make your own choices

1:04:12there's not really it's like you have to

1:04:14say good to yourself sacred sacred

1:04:17you're pulling the sacred card when you

1:04:19say it's sacred

1:04:20like that'sthat's taking it from like em

1:04:22don't curse on Sunday don't masturbate

1:04:25after

1:04:25911 this is more like no sacred that's

1:04:28that's a different kind of thing

1:04:29yeah well and it's and it's equivalent

1:04:31to like why do we why if we kill

1:04:33somebody when they're one-month-old is

1:04:35it murder and when that when there 8

1:04:37months old in the woman's not murder

1:04:39we have in we have within us we have

1:04:43made within our laws and within our

1:04:44minds some uh honestly some pretty

1:04:50arbitrary decision about what almost

1:04:53everything is there are many spectra in

1:04:55life in there are hard decisions to make

1:04:58about spectrum but if you act like

1:04:59there's not a spectrum not sure

1:05:02science is gonna hold up so well and so

1:05:04but they're so there's a spectrum right

1:05:06and a lot of that is is legal and a lot

1:05:09of it is moral and your point of view

1:05:12almost every decision anyone has ever

1:05:13made is arbitrary they well they

1:05:16certainly they are because in a natural

1:05:18state

1:05:19we're just I mean we're just pray for

1:05:22tigers right but where you know it like

1:05:24if you think about think about humans in

1:05:27their natural state or whatever I mean

1:05:29that's where we're so far down the river

1:05:32from that but yeah we're in our

1:05:34decisions are predicated on prior

1:05:37decisions and the whole idea of

1:05:38secretness is predicated on a condom on

1:05:43monotheism which is evolved from those

1:05:47there that there is there is a God whose

1:05:49will is knowable and it's our

1:05:50responsibility as the Stewart's of that

1:05:53truth to make sure that that is enacted

1:05:56in every conceivable way on earth then

1:05:58that there's there's a lot of you're

1:05:59making a lot of lily pad leaps to get to

1:06:01and it's just like you know what is God

1:06:02he's a silverback gorilla who's jealous

1:06:05of the smaller girl that's from Monday

1:06:08cards first meditation so so I wrote him

1:06:12and I said you know we're just this is

1:06:14we're just foundationally going to be

1:06:15work we're never going to come to an

1:06:18accord on this because I don't share

1:06:21your view that human life is sacred and

1:06:23and the problem is that you that the

1:06:28people who who have a belief that human

1:06:30life is sacred they believe that all a

1:06:33all laws and morals that that we live

1:06:38live according to proceed from that

1:06:40initial premise why be good to each

1:06:42other as human life is sacred

1:06:44why do we not kill and rape and Eve

1:06:47because life is sacred you you proceed

1:06:51from that initial idea i get the

1:06:53chickens involved with the pig is

1:06:54committed

1:06:55mm you know think that see that seems

1:06:58like a like a Garfield quote you know

1:07:00that saying no chicken the chicken then

1:07:03goes the tickets hey you know what we

1:07:05should start breakfast restaurant and it

1:07:07takes is no way in the the hands like

1:07:10why not

1:07:10and then the pics as well you know

1:07:12you're involved but I'm committed

1:07:14yeah that's right you're involved but

1:07:16i'm committed hands exactly right so so

1:07:18the harder case actually falls to the

1:07:22liberal in that situation to say i do

1:07:25not believe i do not have a foundational

1:07:28belief that every life is sacred and yet

1:07:30I believe in morality and law and those

1:07:35things stem from some costume case some

1:07:39initial case that we have we have yet to

1:07:43describe em like why in it if if you

1:07:47take away the idea that life is sacred

1:07:49and that we have that there's a

1:07:50monotheistic God why be good to each

1:07:53other and the liberal case is constantly

1:07:56to say no we are making this argument

1:07:59from the rights of man that that that

1:08:02are that are operatory that these are

1:08:06self-evident rights and you know and

1:08:08this is all this all proceeds from from

1:08:12a card and lock and jefferson and

1:08:14Augustine or whatever you know like like

1:08:17it so it is the theory it's the

1:08:20philosophy of history and it's happened

1:08:23simultaneously with you know with the

1:08:27sort of theistic approach which is that

1:08:31you cannot divorce these ideas from

1:08:34there from the the source the fountain

1:08:37which is

1:08:39which is a loving God and so the

1:08:44innocent secret source where I mean this

1:08:46is going to this is eight admittedly a

1:08:47stretch where let's say even if you were

1:08:50super into the idea of abortion as a

1:08:52thing you wouldn't let yourself because

1:08:54of the sacred law that passed on to you

1:08:56that basically to extend that kind of I

1:08:59don't know jurisprudence of God that

1:09:04that if this is the law it must be

1:09:06followed down the line every single way

1:09:08like a but I'm not gonna pick and choose

1:09:10which of these things no matter how

1:09:11strongly i may be personally for or

1:09:13against anything the laws law right you

1:09:15can't pick and choose and that's what

1:09:17gives the law Authority

1:09:18mhm because it represents something

1:09:20that's real and not something that you

1:09:22just drenched or something that you that

1:09:26you believe maybe today and not a year

1:09:28from now when you've read a different

1:09:29book is where there's a shabbat

1:09:31elevators

1:09:32it's a shabbat elevate like it was it

1:09:36went when they went in the Declaration

1:09:39of Independence Jefferson and and Ben

1:09:41Franklin collaborating or whatever came

1:09:43up with this like we hold these truths

1:09:45to be self-evident that all men are

1:09:47created equal

1:09:48that's an egg's that's a moment where

1:09:50they're kicking the ball down the field

1:09:52you know they are they are saying we

1:09:57hold these truths to be self-evident

1:09:59well that's nice how do you hold these

1:10:01truths to be self-evident

1:10:03I like to show your work sir exact show

1:10:05you an F and what they what they were

1:10:07playing off of was the you know was the

1:10:11intellectual tradition of the as they

1:10:14saw it of their immediate forebears and

1:10:19of the of thomas mann and so forth

1:10:21obviously I'm talking about John Locke

1:10:23here know like um sometimes man but but

1:10:27you know that they are they're playing

1:10:29off of this this deist sort of Rights of

1:10:34Man but d ism was you know was a leap

1:10:37that that maintained the existence of a

1:10:40god so so here we are now 200 years

1:10:45later

1:10:46oh my god 204 most 50 years later yeah i

1:10:49know i was just introduced to remember

1:10:51them by

1:10:51centennial quarters how you want to

1:10:52collect those still have them i still

1:10:54have the clichéd yeah we are still

1:10:59kicking that ball down the field from

1:11:00the liberal side

1:11:02yeah and we continue to do a poor job at

1:11:05this yesterday where were we really into

1:11:07Hamilton in our house and there's so

1:11:09many lines so many great lines and we

1:11:11end up talking about and she's like no

1:11:12time just like my darling to tell me

1:11:14again like which one is the one that had

1:11:16slaves and I was like tell us jefferson

1:11:18and things as much as I love the

1:11:20Alexander Hamilton musical I'm I think

1:11:21I'm more on kind of Jefferson side on a

1:11:23lot of issues with but with that said

1:11:25yeah the guy who wrote that he totally

1:11:27had slaves well had slaves and had sex

1:11:30with his lips I mean they all had I mean

1:11:32Hamilton didn't have slaves because he

1:11:34was poor

1:11:34that's right but how does a bastard

1:11:36orphan son of a whore and a Scotsman

1:11:39ones that was Angelica Skylar said we

1:11:41hold these truths to be self-evident

1:11:42that all men are created equal and when

1:11:44women sequel

1:11:48yeah I worked in the mammal to decide

1:11:54you're so we got Thomas man we got

1:11:57deists we got to abortion facebook

1:11:59yeah abortion facebook i don't know how

1:12:01i didn't comment on this episode please

1:12:03send to rock on the line at example.com

1:12:05one of our operators will be standing by

1:12:09this episode will never air

1:12:11uh-huh I really really really want i I

1:12:14really want the I want those of us that

1:12:17share this world this liberal world to

1:12:21do more self-examination to join the

1:12:23club Johnny I know man I I you know and

1:12:26like and the thing is there's so much i

1:12:28am not going to fucking talk about on

1:12:29this podcast because i don't think i

1:12:32heard about technology

1:12:33mhm think about this one I'm not saying

1:12:35I have a feeling about this but i'm just

1:12:36going to toss this out i happen to be

1:12:38very much on I'm very simpatico with the

1:12:41people say you know what can we please

1:12:43stop killing the black people i think we

1:12:45need to stop killing black people i

1:12:47agree i think we should start with the

1:12:49black people i know that i know it's

1:12:52it's a bold bold stance on my very brave

1:12:55bold stance when I say I stand before

1:12:57you today today gives you a chance we

1:12:59could stop killing black people now

1:13:01here's the thing

1:13:03follow me on this and and don't don't

1:13:06kill me

1:13:06uh the leap from let's stop killing

1:13:09black people to guns are playing for

1:13:11this is a leap that is not even a leap

1:13:14for most of my friends and I personally

1:13:16I I'd like to see fewer of the guns to

1:13:17write but then the leap from let's stop

1:13:20killing by people so maybe not so many

1:13:22guns you are actually at this point

1:13:24strangely close to saying to a lot of

1:13:26people in America you're responsible for

1:13:28black people being killed

1:13:29whether you realize it or not when you

1:13:31say that not again I don't have a dog in

1:13:33this fight i'm just here to say that i'm

1:13:35telling you if you go and read what

1:13:36people on the other side here when

1:13:38people say that something i happen to

1:13:39agree with what they are going to hear

1:13:41is like not only are you trying to take

1:13:44our guns away but you're essentially

1:13:45accusing me of murder because I I have a

1:13:49gun that's what it sounds like those

1:13:51people i'm going to say that's right

1:13:53wrong or otherwise I just want you to

1:13:54think about it i will know the harder

1:13:56the harder even thing to get your head

1:13:59around is that even if you take the guns

1:14:01out of the equation and you just say

1:14:04listen the cops the white cops in the

1:14:07South do not see blacks as full-humans

1:14:12the evidence that we see is all I can

1:14:15almost guarantee you is just barely even

1:14:18the tip of an iceberg for a much deeper

1:14:20cultural disconnect about how these

1:14:22folks treated and what what what ends up

1:14:24happening is that the left takes on a

1:14:27very lecturing tone volume on your exit

1:14:31John you know a lot of people came

1:14:32brexit experts for experts

1:14:33dude i'm up for expert i got to be a

1:14:35break but really fast i know it took me

1:14:37almost eight hours you want you want to

1:14:38you want to read some of my tweets their

1:14:40top shelf week he sound like Donald

1:14:43Trump my tweets on this is going to be

1:14:45huge people are gonna love it

1:14:47my people at making friends on the

1:14:51internet today the left the left has

1:14:55this culture right where we take we take

1:14:57in this is the biggest women stuff and

1:15:01we say we say very briefly something

1:15:05about our own privilege to indicate that

1:15:09we are on the on the good side we're on

1:15:12the right way we got ourselves a Hall

1:15:14Pass

1:15:14yeah we say you know as someone

1:15:16and you know as a white ally or we say

1:15:19something we said say something that

1:15:20mitigates our our our experience just

1:15:24enough that we absolvo ourselves of

1:15:26complicity and then we immediately

1:15:28adopted hectoring lecturing tone to ward

1:15:31everyone else that we presume it are

1:15:35less enlightened right didn't you go

1:15:37back and read my timeline and what I had

1:15:38to say about this I can't believe we're

1:15:39still talking about this

1:15:41right right but in the meantime largely

1:15:44living in white enclaves largely

1:15:47benefiting from systems that are you

1:15:51more or less a like systematized

1:15:56segregation and there isn't enough real

1:16:03reckoning and it doesn't have to

1:16:05it doesn't have to take this form of

1:16:08like prostration it doesn't really

1:16:11involve even like being apologetic fake

1:16:14or otherwise it's like a real

1:16:17acknowledgement of and and you know and

1:16:20hopefully an acknowledgement of your of

1:16:21your power without shame

1:16:24exactly you know like shame does not not

1:16:28empowering it isn't empowering for

1:16:29anybody and it doesn't accomplish

1:16:31anything except to make you to continue

1:16:33making it all about you

1:16:34yeah exactly and so to acknowledge your

1:16:37privilege in your power and then try to

1:16:40find a but to acknowledge it in some

1:16:42ways even with pride and say how can I

1:16:44now use this privilege map and that's

1:16:47mean that the people who are who resist

1:16:51the black lives matter narrative Roger

1:16:56that are terrific terrific example you

1:16:58know it's not just that that they feel

1:17:00like they're they feel like their guns

1:17:02are I mean that that's that's way down

1:17:04the line they're afraid that we're

1:17:07saying the cops are you know just the

1:17:13only independent depends on how you

1:17:14choose to finish that statement that

1:17:16doesn't really need to be finished black

1:17:17lives matter and to a lot of people here

1:17:20that I don't happen to agree but to them

1:17:22that statement is all black lives matter

1:17:24to the exclusion of other people right

1:17:27black lives matter more

1:17:28or or lack lives the the fact that black

1:17:31lives matter is going to is going to

1:17:33translate into more entitlements for

1:17:36them who that are not afforded to me and

1:17:40I'm also poor so what you know where it

1:17:43and I so I how to how to get out of this

1:17:48reflective state of liberal apology

1:17:51where every where every statement is

1:17:55preceded with a caveat that that you

1:18:00know that you acknowledge your you

1:18:03acknowledge that your voice isn't the

1:18:06voice that's needed here or whatever you

1:18:07know to to proceed from that into a

1:18:10place where we are where we are actively

1:18:12trying to make a case and actively

1:18:15trying to be articulate about it and

1:18:17that begins with us acknowledging what

1:18:20our case is huh

1:18:22and I don't know how I mean I've spent

1:18:24my entire life trying to figure out what

1:18:27those words we hold these truths to be

1:18:29self-evident mean I mean I really have

1:18:32my whole adult life I have turned those

1:18:35words over in my head because they are

1:18:37that's its Jefferson's way of going uh

1:18:39right well I mean like no I'm sorry I'm

1:18:42being glib but it's a way of saying

1:18:43self-evident is all the in that case

1:18:45that's that is his supernal sanction is

1:18:48that there's nothing even even beyond

1:18:50God and law this is self-evident that

1:18:53this is the age of the Age of

1:18:54Enlightenment this is something that we

1:18:55can look at and and go this equals

1:18:57equals this like this is truth

1:19:00well and that the thing is that my that

1:19:03the founders were really at odds with

1:19:06one another about this mm and Jeff and

1:19:09my understanding my understanding of it

1:19:11is that Jefferson actually his first

1:19:19draft actually used a lot more sort of

1:19:23quasi religious language and it was it

1:19:29was Ben Franklin who sort of made the

1:19:32suggestion of the term self-evident

1:19:35because you know Jefferson was maybe

1:19:38more of a

1:19:40more of a DSS and and initially said we

1:19:46hold these truths to be sacred and

1:19:49franklin was the one that said that

1:19:53implies too much that introduces too

1:19:57much God and let's let's change it and

1:20:02so that collaboration between them

1:20:04Jefferson the sort of scientific New

1:20:07Englander I'm sorry Franklin the

1:20:10scientific New Englander vs Jefferson

1:20:12was sort of scientific southern

1:20:15philosopher you know I mean just the

1:20:18just those two the push and pull between

1:20:21between those two you know interacts but

1:20:27it'sit's such a kick the can down the

1:20:29road moment like so bad i mean if he had

1:20:31said sacred we hold these truths to be

1:20:32sacred we would be in a bit I think

1:20:35would be a different country and I think

1:20:37we'd be arguing it from a different

1:20:38place because we would be people that

1:20:41share my world view would be at a

1:20:43disadvantage right now we would be

1:20:44saying like if it I you know like if it

1:20:47isn't sacred then what is it then the

1:20:51whole than the the whole edifice starts

1:20:54to crumble and Franklin just got this

1:20:56little he just planted this pole there

1:21:00with self-evident undefined and it's

1:21:07given us this it's given us 250 years to

1:21:10debate it and here we are still

1:21:15I'll put it out don't worry I wouldn't

1:21:28why would why would you not

1:21:29of course it would where are you going

1:21:31to end it there with the lip-smacking

1:21:32all feedback goes to Roderick online and

1:21:36example.com its mark on the line at

1:21:40example.com whatever you do people get

1:21:42out there and folk holy shit

1:21:50oh my goodness oh it was good