Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 164: "In Your Face, Paraguay"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this episode of Roderick online is

0:00:01sponsored by cards against humanity this

0:00:04month they asked Jonathan man to help me

0:00:06say hi to john terms time was it

0:00:23hello hello Marilyn Rajic online

0:00:31hello hello hello rather gonna live Bob

0:00:36Robert online bomb that's good bump to

0:00:40cover you know is that right yeah that's

0:00:43our song this month

0:00:44oh I love it already it's pretty catchy

0:00:46it is M some candy songwriter figured

0:00:51out a good cadence for our name em it's

0:00:54a gift

0:00:55I've come online i got hello hello

0:00:59that's what we say that's what he says

0:01:01he's he said something about grabbing

0:01:03your turpentine we look a little bit of

0:01:04a throwaway wait a minute

0:01:06well you know we have never talked about

0:01:09turpentine I slugging percentage how r

0:01:11use the big week huh oh yeah that's

0:01:14right to you tomorrow is election day

0:01:16oh my god em how even in this is what

0:01:21may

0:01:22no no I mean you know is let's see I

0:01:25mean obviously you've been preparing

0:01:27your whole life but well I don't know

0:01:29about that either but up but I so i

0:01:31started talking about it is two people

0:01:39probably in january and then bye-bye

0:01:43March it was fully you know people

0:01:46people were rallying i was i was

0:01:50rallying and then we declared in second

0:01:54week of april so when did the super PAC

0:01:57get formed super PAC is still forming

0:02:00the thing is you know you're not allowed

0:02:03to be directly involved with that right

0:02:04i cant and unlike other super PACs this

0:02:06one truly is super because a the number

0:02:10of nerds that support my campaign

0:02:12actually form a kind of Hall of Justice

0:02:15if you will and Hawkman yeah yeah does

0:02:21and they're working on their invisible

0:02:23plane right now

0:02:24they have to build a crystal cathedral

0:02:27m1a1 man she gets all the good stuff she

0:02:30does yeah and the crystal cathedral also

0:02:33great that was for sale at some point

0:02:35they turned into a mall what happened

0:02:37that is that right i can't imagine that

0:02:39they wouldn't that they would

0:02:40deconsecrated well there were problems

0:02:43there were problems leaky roof anymore

0:02:47well you know nobody said crystal is

0:02:49going to be waterproof mm I don't know

0:02:50but in the Reverend Schuler past

0:02:53yeah and then I think his son took over

0:02:54and i think it turned into like an

0:02:56orange julius oh i see i'm not sure i

0:02:59haven't kept up and read the trades

0:03:00actually you know no one said crystal

0:03:03was going to be waterproof was actually

0:03:05that was the that was the working slogan

0:03:07for a sex worker and you as a fact that

0:03:10rose McCaskey Paul oh I think about the

0:03:14same person

0:03:15it's wrong my friends oh man big week

0:03:18big week and welcome back it's been so

0:03:21long since I talked to you I missed you

0:03:23and you were gone I was worried about

0:03:26you and what you're talking about that I

0:03:28wasn't replying to your text so then I

0:03:31was worried that you were worried all

0:03:34those two so much worried you know you

0:03:37were out of your comfort you were out of

0:03:38your ears place you were somewhere else

0:03:41and I was just I was anxious for you

0:03:43oh thank you thank you there's good

0:03:45reason um ya know I IE had to go to

0:03:49three different to three different

0:03:50places don't like throw-up excited

0:03:53travel and do you know what my inner

0:03:56Merlin is already rejecting this

0:03:58possibility you know i just got a notice

0:04:01less i got it i just got notice things

0:04:04less than i do fine you know now he was

0:04:06fine i am you know it was pretty good we

0:04:09had some family time with the you know

0:04:11family on the East Coast and they're

0:04:13great i had to go to pdx is back in town

0:04:15for 36 hours and then went to pdx for my

0:04:18days

0:04:18mmm got Pendleton shirt pretty excited

0:04:21about just let's go yeah is it a is it

0:04:23doesn't picture

0:04:23no I got it big may say the Pendleton

0:04:27board shirt is wool and yet it is

0:04:29machine washable

0:04:30that's right and I want this to be I

0:04:32want this to be a 20-year shirt so I got

0:04:34a big because i figure i'll watch it

0:04:35sometimes

0:04:36yeah well

0:04:37that you've got it you've gotta you

0:04:38gotta get a penalty shot a little bit

0:04:40that's the tradition but you actually

0:04:42can wash those things and put them in

0:04:45the dryer and the shrinkage is minimal

0:04:47understand anything anymore between

0:04:49sous-vide and washable wall completely

0:04:51lost but I look like Harry Potter in the

0:04:53first movie like wearing his step

0:04:55brother is a you know adopted brothers

0:04:57clothes and if you just huge on me i

0:04:59never saw the harry potter movies never

0:05:01seen any of them know is that something

0:05:03I should do is it twice

0:05:05well you know I learned from the 16

0:05:08hours of programming did with dan I'm

0:05:10didn't learn i'm reminded about how much

0:05:13you're interested in the magics yeah

0:05:16that's right

0:05:17proof that we should let's wait till the

0:05:19primary server but I won't talk about

0:05:21that more

0:05:21abracadabra I think about it a lot but

0:05:24uh you know I'm there they're all good i

0:05:26would say if you want one and only one

0:05:29watch the third one

0:05:31wow so just go right into the third one

0:05:34I don't even need to learn the rules of

0:05:36Quidditch i'll figure that out along the

0:05:38way which is the biggest scam inclusive

0:05:41including stadium deals all we're going

0:05:42skating history of sports

0:05:44we're gonna get so many angry technology

0:05:46about this book which is it's a total

0:05:48scam it's a scam am so I'm on my way

0:05:51down here i was thinking about this

0:05:52movie project that I've been working on

0:05:54for a long time

0:05:55ok screenplay that I've been you know

0:05:58they're mowing over which is a which is

0:06:02basically it is its neighborhood stick

0:06:05fights as a which we've talked about

0:06:08many times

0:06:09oh yeah neighborhood stick fights as a

0:06:11as a an organizing principle of the

0:06:16future society it's like the kind of

0:06:19games meet the warriors

0:06:20yeah well in the sense that you know

0:06:22hunger games is the reason that I guess

0:06:25that it's popular well is that it's you

0:06:27know it's populated with cute people but

0:06:31but you know how hungry there's a blurb

0:06:34Hunger Games turns on the idea that

0:06:38people are forced by a controlling and

0:06:42dystopian future society to fight in

0:06:45this arena against one another and the

0:06:48and and the heroine is always

0:06:50protecting the weekend shot you know and

0:06:52use in fighting they're fighting off a

0:06:54certain kind of municipal original sin

0:06:56basically they are there any these kids

0:07:00have to fight as tribute because they

0:07:03there was rebellious at one time that's

0:07:05right that's right this is their

0:07:06punishment and this is how they keep the

0:07:08beekeeper rebellion down in the

0:07:10provinces or whatever but but but my

0:07:12premise is that neighborhood stick

0:07:14fighting is something that a free

0:07:17society would willingly and

0:07:19enthusiastically enter into ok this is

0:07:23what kind of games meets your company

0:07:25softball team

0:07:26yeah or like you know or the longest

0:07:28yard

0:07:29what was the football game that took

0:07:31place in prison that was the longest

0:07:32yard

0:07:33there we go against mr. Burt Reynolds

0:07:35that's right so it's I mean that may be

0:07:37the longest yard is a bad example but

0:07:38you know but but they are but but the

0:07:41idea being that people would would

0:07:43self-organize into tribes they already

0:07:46do like on the weigh-in today so the

0:07:49blue angels and all the Seafarer

0:07:51airplanes are all getting out of Dodge

0:07:53today they're all kind of you know like

0:07:54the party's over and Boeing Field justly

0:07:58yeah okay

0:08:00boeing field two days ago was just like

0:08:03a it was a menagerie of all the

0:08:06different kinds of airplanes that were

0:08:07three different performing air show

0:08:10squadrons there was a there was a Marine

0:08:15Corps osprey there were biplanes and you

0:08:19know just the whole just the camp train

0:08:22of followers that chase the blue angels

0:08:24around and they're all getting out of

0:08:26here and so the like all weekend long

0:08:31all along boeing field there's been a a

0:08:33collection of airplane nerds who park

0:08:36their trucks and basically tailgate next

0:08:39to the airport just to watch the plane's

0:08:43take off and land in some ways the most

0:08:46exciting part of any flight is the

0:08:49take-off of the landing but also in

0:08:52another way

0:08:53not at all is that the most exciting

0:08:55part and suddenly NASCAR is that when

0:08:58you're most likely have a rack

0:08:59yeah that's right that's where all the

0:09:00that's where all the other tracks

0:09:01happened on the ground but you know

0:09:03watching a bunch

0:09:04airplanes coming and flair and touchdown

0:09:06it's like we got there but you know in

0:09:09seattle city of of let's say the general

0:09:12areas got a million people are so that's

0:09:15enough to put 50 people down a million

0:09:18people will generate between 1,500

0:09:20people who just want to watch planes

0:09:21take off and land and some of them are

0:09:23those people with the big white lenses

0:09:25on their cameras who are obviously

0:09:26taking pictures to sell em to James

0:09:30aircraft manual if they still make that

0:09:33but as I'm driving in so i'm driving

0:09:37along and i see that i see the airplane

0:09:39people who it's now it's just the drip

0:09:41drip sand drags of them maybe there's 15

0:09:45or 20 left

0:09:47who are the blue angels are gone now

0:09:49they're just watching like that there

0:09:51will be there watching the experimental

0:09:53ultralights take off and the end and I'm

0:09:56thinking like there's a self-selecting

0:09:58group of people who care about a certain

0:10:01aspect of airplane culture and this is

0:10:05how they're spending their monday

0:10:06morning and then I i drove through

0:10:08georgetown and pass the bus stop and at

0:10:11the bus stop there were there is a small

0:10:13group of people who looked like they had

0:10:16wandered out of a comic con right they

0:10:22had the whole have the whole look but

0:10:24one of them might have been in a utility

0:10:25kilt there was a guy with a sort of

0:10:28dishwater blonde ponytail their their

0:10:34jackets had lots of buttons and badges

0:10:36on them

0:10:36somebody might have had a stuffed animal

0:10:38on a lanyard around their neck pretty

0:10:44sure there was a there was a my little

0:10:47pony component to someone's socks and

0:10:52I'm like okay now there's another group

0:10:53of people self-selecting into a little

0:10:57tribe

0:10:58I don't know why they're here why

0:10:59they're waiting at this bus stop where

0:11:01they would have come from where they're

0:11:02going and then I started thinking about

0:11:04my stick fighting screenplay

0:11:07mhm is the way like the Warriors part I

0:11:10like the idea of the year whatever group

0:11:12you're coming together with there's a

0:11:14strong brand presence strong brand

0:11:15that's exactly right the warrior

0:11:17is it is a perfect example right you

0:11:19don't fuck with the Wong's that's right

0:11:21for you get those baseball guys baseball

0:11:23furies yeah the guys in the in the in

0:11:25the silca the like the silk suits up and

0:11:31so I'm thinking but here's the here's

0:11:33the question for you and this is this is

0:11:35this is something I feel like we should

0:11:37pose to our to our listeners there have

0:11:42to be some combat rules right you don't

0:11:45want to just be because if there weren't

0:11:48any combat rules right the snipers would

0:11:50win every time

0:11:52oh right right now right you can't just

0:11:54have each kid just like it's it can't

0:11:56just be a free-for-all

0:11:57let's never was never intended to be a

0:11:58fight to the death that's why it's a

0:12:00stick fight stick fight that's right but

0:12:02like but so there needs to be combat

0:12:05rules that those combat rules need to

0:12:07also incorporate modern technology

0:12:11because some of the tribes are going to

0:12:14be technologists oh IC right so if you

0:12:17just like ups are you can only fight

0:12:18with sticks

0:12:19there's going to be some group of people

0:12:21that work as engineers for blue origins

0:12:24for instance who are going to be like

0:12:26we've invented a better stick and our

0:12:29stick is made out of this and it

0:12:31performs the following way and this way

0:12:34it becomes a little bit like the robot

0:12:35wars like the road was the weather

0:12:37wouldn't make a little robot find

0:12:38another robot em right you but their

0:12:40rules their together gotta be rules you

0:12:42can we could be a weight thing it could

0:12:44be a material thing but they're gonna

0:12:45hack on that with technology to make a

0:12:47better stick that's right and they're

0:12:48going to be some people that you know

0:12:50they're gonna be like i imagine one

0:12:52component of the of the of the the nerd

0:12:54stick fight quadrant are going to be

0:12:58like the dwarves or whatever like the

0:13:00there gonna be a bunch of bearded guys

0:13:02who like to dress like dwarves in Lord

0:13:04of the Rings not that little people not

0:13:06miners and forgers yeah right and

0:13:09they're gonna be they're gonna be like

0:13:10uh probably

0:13:12normal normal size adult people but who

0:13:14really admire the dwarf aesthetic ok

0:13:17right they get the kind of chainmail

0:13:20leather long braided beards long hair

0:13:24right you and what strange to me as i

0:13:27never have seen a group of six or seven

0:13:30fully grown adult men rocking that look

0:13:34traveling together as a tribe a clutch

0:13:37of dwarves like that i cannot clutch i

0:13:39guess but a handful of dwarves

0:13:41yeah but would you call a group of of

0:13:43fighting dwarves a teacup no no a

0:13:49tempest I'm frustrated whoops yeah I

0:13:52have to think about it but I either so

0:13:54much to like about this this is

0:13:56something that this is something else

0:13:57get this way more thought the night then

0:13:58I realized well you know it's a bit

0:14:00it's a 15-minute drive in i mean there's

0:14:02a lot of time to think so but then it

0:14:04occurred to me if I'm writing a

0:14:05screenplay right I wanted to be

0:14:07realistic and so I would what we would

0:14:09have to do is we would have to establish

0:14:10a set of rules for combat and then

0:14:13imagine through the course of the

0:14:16history of this neighborhood stick

0:14:19fighting culture where different groups

0:14:22had hacked the rules and corollary rules

0:14:27had been imposed to accommodate you know

0:14:30or 22 like Raina min and so you know you

0:14:33want you want the rules of combat to not

0:14:35be to not be too arcane but they also

0:14:38have to reflect you know they have to

0:14:42kind of reflect the evolution of the

0:14:44game right something specifically about

0:14:46baseball and how the game has changed

0:14:48over time as they change the ball there

0:14:50was a time when I guess it was probably

0:14:51going to do a spitball and they said you

0:14:53know what you know I'll do that anymore

0:14:54that's not that that's not fair

0:14:56that's right can't do that what do you

0:14:57have to level it or you know you change

0:14:58like you know the higher the goalposts

0:15:00you standardize things for neighborhood

0:15:01stick fight to really catch on to become

0:15:03viral if you like it has to be some

0:15:05consistency between the different

0:15:06neighborhoods right i mean when they

0:15:07change the height of the goalposts and

0:15:09baseball that really altered the way the

0:15:10game was hard to get a hat-trick so I

0:15:13feel like I feel like that's something

0:15:15that you know I would i think i would

0:15:17call Neal Stephenson or something and

0:15:19say like how would you imagine could you

0:15:22imagine could you imagine ate the

0:15:25assuming that neighborhood stick

0:15:27fighting was something that we were 80

0:15:29years into right we've been we've been

0:15:31doing this for a while I guess the

0:15:33world-building yeah that's right in the

0:15:35web and the stick fighting had been

0:15:36happening in the early days were scrappy

0:15:38and there were some people some fans

0:15:40that were like it's not like it used to

0:15:42be boy stick fighting you

0:15:43to be really awesome before they put in

0:15:46you know the onside fly rule or whatever

0:15:49but now you know it become more and more

0:15:51professionalized I keep imagining

0:15:52backstage at the neighborhood stick

0:15:56fight championship where all the

0:15:57different groups you know there's the

0:15:59there's the monks semester it's really

0:16:02like the one that's when I look at that

0:16:04link i sent you haha I'm just rewriting

0:16:06the yeah check out that link it is a

0:16:08page dedicated to all of the gangs of

0:16:11the Warriors oh my god so I'm so happy

0:16:14already the electric eliminators you got

0:16:16the gladiators I think you might be

0:16:17thinking of poppers they were purple

0:16:20hats and that's what's that's right the

0:16:22barbers that's right that is all furious

0:16:23and what I always forget it forget about

0:16:25the hi-hats all the hi-hat come on their

0:16:28minds they're so good they're so good

0:16:32watching them go through the turnstile

0:16:34watching the hi-hats go through the

0:16:35turnstile and then the yeah the baseball

0:16:38furies inhabit hons that the 17 hundred

0:16:41from chinatown em so let me let me ask

0:16:45you this though

0:16:46so for instance taser let's say you take

0:16:50a Taser in taser doesn't kill people at

0:16:53a distance really it doesn't hurt him at

0:16:55a distance that's one of the things like

0:16:57I don't want I don't want I don't want

0:16:58weapons that allow you to 2 is no

0:17:01there's no room for snipers and

0:17:02neighborhood stick fights that's right

0:17:03but a Taser could you could you get away

0:17:05with a kind of a modified taser I'm know

0:17:07Neal Stephenson but I i think when you

0:17:09think I think it's got to be I think we

0:17:11can some ways use baseball as a template

0:17:14because baseball started out as being

0:17:15this thing where all the fields are

0:17:16different and I guess they're still kind

0:17:18of different but I mean you know the

0:17:19difference distance between the bases

0:17:20and stuff could be really random and

0:17:22there's two major areas to focus on

0:17:24which are the logistics materials and

0:17:28construction of the sticks and then how

0:17:31you're allowed to attack so like in

0:17:33soccer if you something decided to start

0:17:34grabbing the ball and run around that's

0:17:35a dickhead put down the ball that's not

0:17:37cool right so what I mean I think we do

0:17:39have to start with the stick i'm

0:17:40thinking you have things like material

0:17:42weight length and circumference is a

0:17:44uniform length can be tapered my

0:17:47medicine have to be found stick can you

0:17:48lay their own thing is you can't sharpen

0:17:50them because then it's a spear kind of

0:17:54you know like so there's gotta be

0:17:56and I guess ultimately like you can kill

0:17:58somebody with a stick pretty easily so i

0:18:01do feel i feel like for this

0:18:03science-fiction story to really to

0:18:07really capture what I'm what I'm trying

0:18:10to say about humanity i think it does

0:18:12have to be fatal and at times

0:18:14oh sure i don't think it always has to

0:18:16be there in my head I'm imagining and I

0:18:18know this will change once Stephenson is

0:18:20it a little bit but i think it's a bunch

0:18:21of people on the field with essentially

0:18:23like broomsticks so you can use it like

0:18:25a staff you can use it like a sword or

0:18:28you can use it like a casual day or all

0:18:30of those things you never liked you can

0:18:32send it there's no ammunition not to

0:18:33spin that's right no you absolutely

0:18:34spend you could even throw but you're

0:18:36gonna been mean you know what they say

0:18:38about neighborhood stick fights when you

0:18:40know you throw your stick and then you

0:18:42gotta stick that's right then that your

0:18:44that sticks going to get stick stuck

0:18:45right up yeah that's one of the that's

0:18:48what that's one of us there you know

0:18:50because they're going to be

0:18:51sportscasters and they're gonna have

0:18:52their own sayings one stick for the team

0:18:55or does everybody have a stick

0:18:57well or there's a hunger game situation

0:18:59where they're kind of stick some cuddles

0:19:00and chalets and stuff all like it might

0:19:03be when you actually pitched this idea I

0:19:05imagined it the way it would have

0:19:06happened when your kids which is you're

0:19:08out in the woods and you find a stick

0:19:10and then you start hitting people with

0:19:11it

0:19:12thank you that's right there's something

0:19:13there's something to that but I think

0:19:15when what you professionalize this and I

0:19:16assume it will have some aspect of if

0:19:18not even maybe it'll be more like a like

0:19:21a football thing where nobody gets paid

0:19:22but you get for education and but you

0:19:25can have a you have a sticker bespoke

0:19:27stick that you make as long as it's

0:19:29within the good like a baseball bat

0:19:30right you can have your old i was called

0:19:32golden boy that's because you never you

0:19:34never golden boy who you and your dad

0:19:36can craft it out of the out of a tree

0:19:37that was hit by lightning like Brian a

0:19:39you can rewind your own pickups or or

0:19:42out of your out of your the mantelpiece

0:19:45of your childhood fireplace oh it was

0:19:47burned down by two are so now you got a

0:19:49reason so here's a question so

0:19:51originally the idea was that it was kind

0:19:54of a gladiator contest where it was

0:19:56taking place in a in a Coliseum and

0:19:59people you know the the the bread and

0:20:01circuses people were up in the stands

0:20:03kind of you know hurling encouragement

0:20:06and epithets down

0:20:08but then as as the game involved in my

0:20:11mind I realized that that so

0:20:14surveillance culture has to play into

0:20:17any kind of future games sports right

0:20:22we're seeing surveillance culture GoPros

0:20:24Oh engine eyes the the the like

0:20:31experience of sports and ever since

0:20:34football got those strange cameras that

0:20:37track the action overhead you know

0:20:40watching football is very different now

0:20:41than even a few years ago and it won't

0:20:43be long i don't think before there are

0:20:46cameras embedded on football players so

0:20:49that you're really was having super

0:20:52slo-mo GoPro action but with that

0:20:55enables us to do is have a sort of

0:20:58stadium but you know you know where

0:21:03special forces and and like SWAT teams

0:21:05train they have those fake cities

0:21:08oh yeah a little villages out in the

0:21:10country where it's a bunch of cinder

0:21:11block buildings and may and they

0:21:13practice like going into buildings and

0:21:14it's kind of like a like like paintball

0:21:17or laser tag sure like we're a little i

0:21:19like I wouldn't thing pops out the

0:21:21building and you gotta shoot the burger

0:21:22but not the baby

0:21:23yes thank you exactly shoot the burglar

0:21:26not the baby that's if I were

0:21:28sportscasting this that would be one of

0:21:29my adages when your catchphrases right

0:21:32somebody would whack like will actually

0:21:34walk their friend and I be like that

0:21:35they're yo Marlon there is another god

0:21:37why saying over and over shoot the

0:21:39burglar about the baby right then that

0:21:42the t-shirts will get made

0:21:44yep people would know me as that guy but

0:21:46it's on the one hand it's a very very

0:21:48primitive in many ways it's civilized in

0:21:51the sense that there are rules but

0:21:53there's also a high-tech component and

0:21:55that's that's where you really get

0:21:56people excited about it but I

0:21:57participants and as as viewers so we

0:22:00could build in the center of the stadium

0:22:01a kind of Cinderella's castle meet SWAT

0:22:06team training ground a big you know

0:22:09multi-layered set of buildings and laser

0:22:12tag you know ramps and all this stuff

0:22:14with gopro cameras all around it and

0:22:16then the tech aspect of it of course is

0:22:18that you're watching

0:22:20you're watching on multiple screens

0:22:22you're watching replays and and you can

0:22:25see you can see you can see more than

0:22:29the players can see okay and maybe I

0:22:32don't know exactly how this works with

0:22:33you figure there's what people on the

0:22:35field know and what their teams know

0:22:36when they've got their own surveillance

0:22:38means you get with the people in the

0:22:39crowd now and then you got with the

0:22:40viewers at home now and that information

0:22:42could potentially become passed around

0:22:43maybe there's a cache of sticks you know

0:22:46hidden somewhere inside Cinderella's

0:22:48castle or maybe the old lady could like

0:22:51in our games maybe she could buy you a

0:22:53nice fleece and have a melty as a

0:22:54sponsorship yeah sure and and there's a

0:22:57you know there's that kind of like oh

0:22:58you know like a like horror movie aspect

0:23:01where it's like don't go in their own

0:23:03don't go in there like people are you

0:23:06know really that they are participating

0:23:09you know people in the stadium having a

0:23:11different experience of course the

0:23:12people at home but there's a there's

0:23:14that that a the tension of of of having

0:23:19our missions

0:23:20oh yeah and also i mean i don't like to

0:23:22bring into pro wrestling too much

0:23:23because I know go on about it but to me

0:23:25thats that's a big component of this

0:23:26where thinks you never know what's gonna

0:23:28happen there might be another

0:23:30neighborhood stick fight team inside the

0:23:31castle and you just don't know it yet or

0:23:33maybe somebody from your neighborhood is

0:23:35in the audience they jump in

0:23:37they grab a stick and start helping out

0:23:38so now once we've established the actual

0:23:41you know like the combat who now the

0:23:43next part of this world building that we

0:23:45have to do is how exactly are our social

0:23:51problems how are we feeding this stick

0:23:56fighting like socially globally what are

0:24:01we

0:24:01resolving their ok you know like for

0:24:04example me I'm not saying I'm just

0:24:06tossing out like is it cause based well

0:24:09I mean if you're if you are if you are

0:24:12from Brazil and your team wins the world

0:24:14cup you have a lot of smack to talk to

0:24:20people from Uruguay for for a while

0:24:23right

0:24:23a nice i said i drive around seattle all

0:24:26uh

0:24:27every day let's be honest and the number

0:24:30of people who are still crowing about

0:24:32the superbowl two years ago in the form

0:24:34of some kind of logo on the back of

0:24:38their escalade yeah right sorry but it's

0:24:42always nice to Paraguay little bit of

0:24:44shade you know what Paraguay has got a

0:24:46lot to answer for who

0:24:48but so what I'm saying is escalating

0:24:50that or or rather turning them turning

0:24:52the dial up on that a little bit so that

0:24:55it's not just bragging rights it's not

0:24:57just like in-your-face paraguay like

0:25:01actual disputes are resolved by by the

0:25:07neighborhood stick fighting teams

0:25:08because i feel like as you ramp up the

0:25:10violence

0:25:12you also have to have a corresponding

0:25:13increase in mistakes not just the stakes

0:25:18for the team right those guys are going

0:25:20to get more hurt then big you know like

0:25:24voluntary are volunteering to get more

0:25:26hurt than in a football game but they do

0:25:30that because the pot the prospect is

0:25:33greater that their success will change

0:25:36people's lives also could be tied to

0:25:40something like the passage of a

0:25:41insurance bill right that would be sort

0:25:44of a regional becomes kind of referendum

0:25:46like in California like if you don't

0:25:48like the way ppl park you can go and

0:25:49start your own initiative get people to

0:25:51sign out right now and get people to

0:25:53sign on it gets on the ballot you can

0:25:55vote

0:25:55maybe this becomes a kind of public

0:25:57primary for certain kinds of big ideas

0:25:59precisely so people are like you know

0:26:00what I don't like rail transit in I

0:26:04think it's a bad idea i think it's too

0:26:06expensive than the other people are like

0:26:08rail transit is the only solution to

0:26:10modern urban expansion in cities i think

0:26:14if you take it even smaller I mean even

0:26:16even on your local high school football

0:26:17field you could work out whether or not

0:26:19there should be a stop sign somewhere

0:26:21who I mean kind of right on the football

0:26:25field

0:26:26well I mean I to stop someone be there

0:26:27by me like if you're looking I know

0:26:28you're not across the board a giant fan

0:26:30of four-way stops oh no I don't like

0:26:32them so i can guess which side you

0:26:33beyond that's right oh so you're saying

0:26:35like let's you know let's mount some

0:26:37teams

0:26:38yeah you've got to stop stoppers so then

0:26:40this is the

0:26:40this is how the league's workout right

0:26:42you start down at the at really the

0:26:44neighborhood level where it's like I i

0:26:46think that we need to spend the that you

0:26:50know we need to float up to

0:26:51million-dollar bond to paint all the

0:26:54fire hydrants in the port a bright color

0:26:57so they don't get back over and your

0:27:00opposition is like that is the ludicrous

0:27:02way to spend that money it's like stick

0:27:04fight yet be any pushback from big truck

0:27:06and then it work you work your way up

0:27:08the you work your way up the ranks so

0:27:10then your then you're basically on the

0:27:11county stick fighting team and your your

0:27:13adjudicating like the school board

0:27:15budget and then just imagine how much

0:27:19zoning stuff you get settled that way

0:27:20rights and net but then all the way up

0:27:22to like I'm on the Palestinian team and

0:27:26we are deciding with this match whether

0:27:30or not they're going to be any more

0:27:31subtle I get everything on this tank

0:27:34that's right and it's like everybody

0:27:37agrees this is an intractable problem

0:27:39we've been trying to solve it with

0:27:41diplomacy we've been trying to solve

0:27:42with war we've been trying to solve it

0:27:44with you know terrorism and it we have

0:27:48failed to solve it so does everybody

0:27:50agree stick fighting is stick fighting

0:27:52is the way that we solve all these other

0:27:54problems now it's like when subtlety and

0:27:56civility and adult conversation fails

0:27:59maybe it's time to pick up a stick maybe

0:28:00it's time thank you to pick up a stick

0:28:02and see that's another great catch

0:28:04phrase and I feel like that maybe is a

0:28:05league that at some point that was the

0:28:08phrase for the league got the stick

0:28:10yeah you know what at a certain point

0:28:12you gotta pick up the stick huh

0:28:14so but this is a lot of world-building

0:28:17in order to then distill it down temp to

0:28:21you know to write a script for a

0:28:23romantic comedy publisher is our

0:28:25meet-cute maybe people on different

0:28:27sides of the stick fight me course at

0:28:29the core of the movie there's got to be

0:28:30this changes everything I don't know is

0:28:32a rom-com this is this that's terrific

0:28:34well what other kind of movie is there

0:28:35right i don't want to the problem with

0:28:37hunger games is there's it's so

0:28:39hysterical and yet there's a rom-com at

0:28:42the center of it right i mean

0:28:43everybody's just like oh that's so weepy

0:28:46and I think that's a tenant of of young

0:28:49adult fiction maybe you're thinking more

0:28:51like old adult fiction

0:28:53I mean when you and I were uh one when

0:28:55we were young adults was that was our

0:28:57young adult fiction that weepy i don't

0:29:00know i think it's got a lot more energy

0:29:02over time you got a lot more vampires

0:29:04and implicit intercourse

0:29:05hmm there's no refresher course on the

0:29:08stick field although I have to say the

0:29:10original Red Dawn film em and I'm sorry

0:29:13that I even had to appellate isn't that

0:29:15a shame the original but you know that

0:29:19there was that was pretty histrionic

0:29:21there was a lot of like there are there

0:29:24a lot of young men over emoting in that

0:29:27movie I see if so many directions you

0:29:29can go and i know you're pretty busy

0:29:30right now but I mean you know I'll i

0:29:32think it helps also think in terms of

0:29:33the franchise right like they knew there

0:29:36was gonna be a whole bunch of this

0:29:37entire game films you know they

0:29:39discovered in time they want to make

0:29:40more star wars movies if you're going to

0:29:42build a world then you you get to decide

0:29:44how that story is told so maybe the

0:29:46first one the one that really get some

0:29:48of the Avengers of stick fighting is

0:29:50like there's just the one big movie with

0:29:52lots of big fights and stuff like that

0:29:53but you could also have stuff like then

0:29:55go to a prequel that explains the

0:29:58genesis of stick fighting and but from

0:29:59the sprint from this primitive simple

0:30:01days before GoPros right i see so I see

0:30:03so we start somewhere

0:30:05Waverly Graham and John you gotta grab

0:30:07an early on with the dwarves and the

0:30:08hi-hats and all the other yea big

0:30:10characters in the stick fights yeah the

0:30:11yo-yos the xylophones the stevedores

0:30:14they're only have to get that got the

0:30:15ding-a-lings you got the backups

0:30:17shanghai Sultan's that's right that's

0:30:19right and and so those guys are all we

0:30:22like we fade in on the scenes yeah the

0:30:27interview with the way i originally

0:30:28imagined this was that that

0:30:30yeah I think I was backstage at madison

0:30:32square garden or something i'm walking

0:30:33around there's all these different

0:30:34tribes of people wandering around

0:30:36backstage in this cavernous environment

0:30:39and i kinda just started to see them my

0:30:42eyes kind of unfocused and I was like

0:30:44you know what if that group of people

0:30:46and I think we talked about this in the

0:30:48original stick fighting episode where it

0:30:49was like the night that that girl that I

0:30:51met with the nike swoosh tattoo

0:30:53alright

0:30:54I was like the Nike that curl is

0:30:56branding herself for the rest of her

0:30:58life with a nike and and so I was but I

0:31:03was watching these people walk by and I

0:31:04was like now what if every one of those

0:31:06people walking past was wearing a kind

0:31:11of a tunic that that Kennedy was a was a

0:31:20call out to the Crusades right like here

0:31:23come here come the Christians they've

0:31:24all got a ball got a big cross on their

0:31:27chest and then here you know here are

0:31:29the only this big dressing gowns like a

0:31:31big dressing gown with my with it like

0:31:33it with your emblem on it and so like I

0:31:36said instead of instead of a a lion

0:31:39rampant you you got you got you got a

0:31:41tide logo

0:31:42yeah and exactly but but in the future

0:31:45right like like Islam is a killer brand

0:31:50but show but so is coca-cola slightly

0:31:55different kind of killer and so what if

0:31:57that would have team Islam is pitted

0:32:00against team coca-cola in the regional

0:32:01finals I don't think there's any reason

0:32:02that can't happen i think as you advance

0:32:04to advance to higher levels you know i

0:32:06think you're going to see some really

0:32:07unusual pairings exactly i see like

0:32:09Portland hog butchers vs former

0:32:13congressman mhm

0:32:14here come the Nebraska Methodists who

0:32:17and they are in a they are in a pitch

0:32:19battle with the Chevy Volt right coming

0:32:23off a huge huge win against the the

0:32:25ladies trying to use expired coupons of

0:32:26walgreens precisely so I would not want

0:32:29to face those ladies they are you know

0:32:30what their top they do not stay down

0:32:33well I murder should they're absolutely

0:32:35should be some kind of I mean this is

0:32:37the thing how do you handicapped because

0:32:40you don't want to put the cue the coupon

0:32:42ladies up against like the modern war we

0:32:46do this by i would i would love to see

0:32:48that but what you do in boxing right you

0:32:50do it by in that case by weight

0:32:51yeah I guess it's my way and then you

0:32:53but you still figure out like who is the

0:32:54greatest pound-for-pound stick fight

0:32:56team right

0:32:58ok here's my question and I I really

0:33:00this is so critical to to the to the

0:33:03whole narrative but i'm still not

0:33:04exactly sure I mean

0:33:05I have a good idea of what a stick fight

0:33:07is for or how it ends when it was a

0:33:09bunch of a 11 year old boys hitting each

0:33:11other

0:33:12what is the goal or how do you win the

0:33:15neighborhood stick fight

0:33:17well that's the thing it because because

0:33:19we are talking about really worth

0:33:21talking about solving really weighty

0:33:23disputes the the end has to be this

0:33:28there has to be satisfaction right the

0:33:31we have to get we the people have to get

0:33:33satisfaction if I am pitting if I if I

0:33:38am watching nike go up against I mean

0:33:43because it's not just nike against

0:33:45adidas it's nike against no no that

0:33:48that's the kind of narrow thinking that

0:33:49neighborhood stick fighting is gonna is

0:33:50gonna just get rid of right this is

0:33:52mikey against apple or Nike against

0:33:55against paraguay and it's like what are

0:33:59the stakes right between nike and

0:34:01paraguay and if nike wins

0:34:03nike tennis shoes beats paraguay the

0:34:05country

0:34:06what does paraguay after seed to them

0:34:10oh yeah kinda like when the two cities

0:34:12go up against each other in the mayor's

0:34:13have a playful yet about sending oranges

0:34:16or or you know philly cheese steak or

0:34:18something like that to the other guy

0:34:19right so but it has to be you know like

0:34:22that but something has to be selling I

0:34:24get you're saying this works on two

0:34:25levels is what gets settled on the field

0:34:27with sticks and was consequently by

0:34:30extension being settled by that victory

0:34:32that's right and so we the adjudication

0:34:34of the stick ball was a stick fight so

0:34:36what ends up deciding the match in the

0:34:40ring is does this does this result

0:34:44deliver satisfaction to the parties

0:34:48involved do they feel satisfied so if

0:34:52it's a case where it's like whack whack

0:34:54ow ok I quit

0:34:56it's like wait a minute no a like

0:35:01hundreds of miles hundreds of square

0:35:03miles of forest just were transferred

0:35:07from one organization to another 00 and

0:35:10this brings up another interesting point

0:35:11then so can you hire out can you be like

0:35:15the the Yankees and hire out like the

0:35:18best team

0:35:19based on money or does it have two

0:35:21people people who have a stake in that

0:35:22so this is that this is my feeling and

0:35:25this is why I call it neighborhood stick

0:35:27fights and not professional stick fights

0:35:29because my feeling about professional

0:35:32sports is as soon as it became free

0:35:35agency and sports were disconnected from

0:35:38their region right it's all just

0:35:41metaphor now you know you just this

0:35:43beeping these baseball players just play

0:35:45for everybody at the end of their career

0:35:47they you know and they show up I mean

0:35:49Ichiro shows up at Safeco Field when

0:35:52they Yankees uniform if you can use the

0:35:54phrase Utah Jazz without laughing Thank

0:35:57You a utah jazz I so i do feel like i do

0:36:01feel like the point of the stick

0:36:03fighting is your group you're vested

0:36:07group puts up your best fighters from

0:36:10within the group and if you know and the

0:36:12put the problem with that of course is

0:36:14that there are lots of groups who by

0:36:17definition are not going to have as good

0:36:19of Fighters right like the like team

0:36:22coder is not going to put up its gonna

0:36:26probably have a lot of like big guys huh

0:36:29but not a lot of like em tough guys I

0:36:32get you and so so you have to also be

0:36:35able to use the strength of your group

0:36:37right like the coupon ladies who all the

0:36:39way there they are strong they have to

0:36:41end it and they have to be able to work

0:36:42as a you know as a group strategy they

0:36:45have to use their strategy right to like

0:36:49this old so the game would have to be

0:36:51modified in the coupon ladies thing the

0:36:53point of the game might be that you have

0:36:55to get through the checkout and back

0:36:57home before the ramen boils over

0:37:00mmm using a neighborhood level it could

0:37:02be something really lonely too

0:37:04on-the-nose it could be something as

0:37:05simple as the ladies trying to use

0:37:07expired coupons at walgreens vs let's

0:37:09let's just say it walgreens employees

0:37:12Oh interesting I mean there's just so

0:37:14many ways that this world couldn't find

0:37:16them here i'm saying this helps me too

0:37:17because the thing is if they if they

0:37:19really toss and it's a sanction sanction

0:37:22neighborhood stick fight and just for

0:37:24the sake of argument let's say the

0:37:25ladies with the expired coupons win

0:37:27right i mean i've really hope that

0:37:29doesn't happen but if they win then from

0:37:31now on

0:37:32and a corporate level walgreens has got

0:37:34to take expired coupons

0:37:36end of story if you wanna rematch

0:37:37there's gotta be some kind of stakes

0:37:39where the you know some skin in the game

0:37:40but I guess you're saying this goes way

0:37:42beyond the field and this I right now i

0:37:45would say there are a lot of things

0:37:47where I would say listen stick fighting

0:37:49is my idea but it's not that I'm not

0:37:51actually gonna get down on the field and

0:37:52stick fight I mean I'm up in the head

0:37:54office

0:37:55I'm up there counting the money i'm not

0:37:57a stick fighter right I'm an impresario

0:37:59your steak lover but if you pitted value

0:38:05village management against an ad-hoc

0:38:10team of value village customers who are

0:38:12tired of filling out there who are tired

0:38:15of collecting 20 stamps on their stamp

0:38:18card to to get twenty-five percent off

0:38:22only to arrive with their filled out

0:38:24stamp card and find the promotion is

0:38:27over and the and the dates you know that

0:38:30it was only good for three weeks and now

0:38:33you're now now the time that you took

0:38:35and all the effort the carrying the

0:38:37stamp card around and pulling it out and

0:38:39getting it stamped you got set 20 stamps

0:38:41or something and it's like oh we're not

0:38:43honoring those anymore

0:38:44value village does that every they do

0:38:46that 15 times a year they also did your

0:38:51switcheroo they do a switcheroo they

0:38:53offer they're like hey are you filling

0:38:54out our stamp card and you're like no

0:38:56thanks we're like really I mean I'm

0:38:58gonna put three stamps on it for this

0:38:59this purchase they're like okay go ahead

0:39:01give me the stamp card and they put

0:39:02stamps on it and then for like three

0:39:04weeks every time you go into value

0:39:05village like I got a stamp card they're

0:39:07like great and they stamp it and then

0:39:09you finally get to 23 go in the next

0:39:12time you're like twenty-five percent off

0:39:13and they're like oh we that that

0:39:15promotion ended my first on cheese so

0:39:18it's not like a coffee cart thing where

0:39:19the stamp card you could go into your

0:39:21coffee car with a stamp card from four

0:39:23years ago and they'll still give you

0:39:24that espresso it's some kind of it's

0:39:28some kind of bullshit trick and so i

0:39:30have written that I don't you talk about

0:39:31demanding satisfaction I would be livid

0:39:34now if I guess I had to look on the

0:39:35google for this this is a value village

0:39:37is a thing it'sit's used clothing is

0:39:40that right that's right it's through its

0:39:41a thrift store but it's a for-profit get

0:39:43what you get

0:39:43yeah but I noticed on the sciences

0:39:45donations

0:39:45dinner you can donate this is that what

0:39:48so they value village is a is a funny

0:39:50business model they do a little

0:39:52switcheroo on you

0:39:53they do a lot of switches on you but the

0:39:55but the big one is like goodwill takes

0:39:59your donations and they employ people

0:40:03and they have training centers and they

0:40:06you know they are a nonprofit

0:40:08organization they're kind of a good will

0:40:11it seems to me the Goodman goodwill the

0:40:13more I learn about goodwill more

0:40:14fascinating they seen because they seem

0:40:16like a charitable pyramid scheme where

0:40:18they want people to come and go oh

0:40:20there's a lot of value to be had here

0:40:21this is a nice vintage stationary and

0:40:23say oh well you know if you're somebody

0:40:25who has a disability

0:40:26you could also work here so they're

0:40:28training people isn't it a little bit

0:40:30like not a Ponzi scheme but a little bit

0:40:31of a pyramid scheme you you can i come

0:40:33in as a customer leaves an assistant

0:40:34manager

0:40:35it's a and B and beginning helped there

0:40:37is so much going on behind the walls at

0:40:40a goodwill that I don't understand i met

0:40:43a woman the other day who was like

0:40:45chairwoman of the Northwest Goodwill's

0:40:49and I was like I really love your stores

0:40:51and she was appreciative but you could

0:40:55see in her eyes that the stores were

0:40:59just a small fraction i totally buy that

0:41:03I totally by tip tip of the iceberg

0:41:06yeah that is what's really going on a

0:41:08goodwill is like oh the store you like

0:41:10to come into the store is how nice

0:41:11that's very nice and that and and then

0:41:14there was just that sense where I go I

0:41:17suddenly felt like I was talking to

0:41:18somebody from skull and bones

0:41:20it's like oh I don't know anything about

0:41:22goodwill do I and she was like no not

0:41:24really but that's great that's wonderful

0:41:26keep coming in I was like whoa Jesus

0:41:30asked a question about that

0:41:31related okay because there's 1 i'm

0:41:33always thinking about you get that you

0:41:35got you check your mail and there's

0:41:37something in your mailbox and there's

0:41:38something that vaguely sounds like a

0:41:40charitable group for veterans are you

0:41:42talking about your email or your mail my

0:41:45p-mail we think we go out and get your

0:41:47actual postal mail and to be something

0:41:48in it like a bag and a plastic wrapper

0:41:50imploring you to help someone so if you

0:41:54have old clothes or there's going to be

0:41:56a big pickup of your old and broken

0:41:58electronics

0:41:59x and something something is going to

0:42:01help veterans for people with

0:42:02disabilities now my wife actually does

0:42:04this I i don't feel right about I think

0:42:06there's something weird going on I don't

0:42:08understand how they're making money by

0:42:09picking up broken computer monitors do

0:42:11you have any idea what these places are

0:42:13and how they're making money and how i'm

0:42:14pretty sure i'm being scammed

0:42:16so what what I have learned I guess is

0:42:19that there are secondary and tertiary

0:42:21markets for old junk there's a whole

0:42:28like sub economy and good will not only

0:42:33processes your material and cells in

0:42:37their stores but they also now have a

0:42:40very lucrative online business where

0:42:43they take the cream they used to just

0:42:45end up out on the shelves

0:42:47yeah and now they sell it online but

0:42:49they also sell material that they

0:42:52collect to other organizations and and

0:42:56now they are collecting material they're

0:42:58saying like no item of clothing is to

0:43:01shite to donate to Goodwill because they

0:43:05can weave it into a bathmat yes right

0:43:07they take all the old garbage fabric and

0:43:11that goes into some other economy they

0:43:14send that somewhere sell it you know

0:43:17I've told you anybody who spent much

0:43:19time travelling overseas you know you

0:43:21come you're walking down a path and here

0:43:23comes a little lady from some village

0:43:25out in the middle of nowhere and she's

0:43:28wearing a Chicago Bulls t-shirt or a no

0:43:32or a superbowl t-shirt with an XML cat

0:43:36yeah or scary especially with the with

0:43:38the name of the team that lost that year

0:43:41I'll because they make them and they got

0:43:43to go somewhere you gotta get your

0:43:44secondary or tertiary markets but value

0:43:46village is an actual for-profit company

0:43:50that lives in this nonprofit space

0:43:52competing against salvation army and

0:43:55goodwill which are which are like chair

0:43:58nominally charitable organizations

0:44:00valley village is just making a profit

0:44:02for some people in a in the boardroom I

0:44:05couldn't their webpage really makes them

0:44:07sound a little like a charity

0:44:09yeah but they're not they're just making

0:44:11money and so

0:44:12all the time people like backup to value

0:44:14village and drop off all their stuff and

0:44:15feel good about it and i'm not exactly

0:44:17sure if you can deduct that or not but

0:44:21uh but the value village a culture

0:44:25business culture pretty sure it's just

0:44:28like it's basically the next level of

0:44:32target see putting out an old CRT

0:44:37monitor that hasn't worked for years and

0:44:39is broken and legitimately trash that's

0:44:42actually dangerous to put in a dump

0:44:44I don't see any way you make money off

0:44:46that unless you put it on a barge and

0:44:48send it to China and have people be like

0:44:50children tear apart with your fingers I

0:44:51understand how you make money from that

0:44:53and I think that is exactly what happens

0:44:54is copper right i mean there are there

0:44:56are there are whole villages their whole

0:44:58provinces in China where it they're just

0:45:01they're just children that lived there

0:45:03there are no adults it's a kind of a

0:45:06kind of over the Flies situation they're

0:45:08living in a world constructive old CRT

0:45:11monitors and you know and there's the

0:45:14one kid that has kind of a monocle that

0:45:17he flips down in front of his eyes to

0:45:18see and check the quality of the

0:45:20material quality and there's a kid that

0:45:21was a top because it gives a confident

0:45:24thumbs up in an odd number and there's a

0:45:26bunch of ragamuffins their kind of

0:45:27indistinguishable from one another and

0:45:29then there's like the heroic girl as

0:45:32like Mad Max meets Dickens meets Dickens

0:45:34Mad Max meets think that's how well

0:45:36that's how pula will picture i see this

0:45:39franchise going to add Max meets Dickens

0:45:42and then and I'm sure that they are

0:45:44yeah they're harvesting the copper and

0:45:46and all the you know all the memories

0:45:48right that's what they're really harvest

0:45:50harvesting operand memory step in

0:45:54getting the data out well and the

0:45:56memories right i mean you don't know how

0:45:58many your memories are stored in there

0:46:00this part of it this is part of the

0:46:02computer maths that they don't teach a

0:46:03man i'm no donating another monitor

0:46:05that's what I'm saying have so many

0:46:07memories in that monitor well not

0:46:08anymore they're all there on China that

0:46:10there's some kiddo that it wearing a top

0:46:12hat in China that's like sorting through

0:46:14them got to pick a pocket or two and

0:46:17he's a he's going to employ them in the

0:46:19next and the next

0:46:21well probably their neighborhood stick

0:46:22fights over there already

0:46:24there and that's where they started

0:46:26right that they started in the in the

0:46:28CRT minds

0:46:29oh is that right that's the case the

0:46:31cradle of stick fights

0:46:33yep well spotted there's so much going

0:46:35on and understand John I have so many

0:46:37questions

0:46:37well me too and not particularly when

0:46:39supertrain technology starts ramping up

0:46:41and all that that hard impact plastic

0:46:44that all that stuff is made of can be

0:46:46converted back into cooking on you can

0:46:49just just just send people in each gram

0:46:51and just say congratulations you've been

0:46:53acquired your dick ends in china village

0:46:55of CRT monitors has been acquired

0:46:57oh so I so I feel pretty strongly that

0:47:05that all this is happening with you and

0:47:09that you know I kind of want to get out

0:47:11ahead of it not just for me but for my

0:47:13family

0:47:14it's everything is getting harder to

0:47:15understand you know i mean to go back to

0:47:18your example of the thrift store

0:47:19i mean i-i don't know if this is true

0:47:21but my sense was I think this is

0:47:23probably mostly true that when i was

0:47:25spending a lot of time in three stores

0:47:26in the early to mid eighties I think it

0:47:28was probably mostly as simple as this

0:47:31people would die and their family would

0:47:34collect all their belongings and drop

0:47:37them off at Goodwill because what are

0:47:38you gonna do with all these old tiny

0:47:39shirts somebody maybe laundries them

0:47:42maybe and then put some on a hanger two

0:47:45dollars shirts or two dollars all the

0:47:46shirts two dollars long sleeve shirts

0:47:47three dollars whatever but their shirts

0:47:49and they're all from problem guessing

0:47:51from people in the community

0:47:52my sense is it has not been that way in

0:47:53years i think this collection centers

0:47:55jet that up to somewhere else they pluck

0:47:57out some of the stuff here to send the

0:47:58kindergarten people in New York this

0:48:00other stuff here gets turned into bath

0:48:02mats and but it all gets redistributed

0:48:03there's a lot of trucking involved in

0:48:05the donation business there's a lot of

0:48:07trucking and a tremendous amount of

0:48:09sordin that I don't fully understand

0:48:12like I always imagined we need a monocle

0:48:13they're seeing something we don't see ya

0:48:15anyway that's why that's a garment or or

0:48:17CRT monitor you cannot possibly have

0:48:21enough ppl highly-trained that they can

0:48:28that mean it has to be like

0:48:30it has to be like a sluice box right

0:48:33seven different increasingly small

0:48:36layers of likely the finest of a screen

0:48:41in like mining yeah exactly like here's

0:48:43the big screen

0:48:44we're just gonna take everything that

0:48:45smells like vomit stops here doesn't

0:48:48mean it can't be used for something

0:48:49that's right but it's but it stops here

0:48:52and we're gonna funnel all the vomit

0:48:54stuff over here and then at the next

0:48:56level are all the things that we plug in

0:48:58and they start immediately to smell like

0:49:00smoke and we're going to find all those

0:49:02over here and then on the other side of

0:49:04that all right now all all the clothes

0:49:07at least have been bombing tested and

0:49:09all the electronic stuff at least

0:49:12doesn't catch on fire so then that goes

0:49:15to another special group that can look

0:49:18at stuff more closely and say alright

0:49:20this doesn't smell like vomit but it

0:49:23definitely has vomited on it uh-huh

0:49:25and so then maybe like this something

0:49:27like you and me we're looking at sighs

0:49:28we're looking at color

0:49:29we're looking at brand we're looking at

0:49:31the quality but we we may not be seeing

0:49:33the memories that are literally being

0:49:34mined out of old men shirts

0:49:35that's right and the thing is by the

0:49:36time that it by the time that the

0:49:38millions and millions of items are are

0:49:42filtered to the level that we can be

0:49:44worried about size and color who think

0:49:46about all of the thing about all the

0:49:49tons and tons of materials and memories

0:49:54that have been that have been like

0:49:58screened and where did all that stuff go

0:50:01I mean it onto a barge to CRT town or

0:50:06alternately to what I imagine is some

0:50:09kind of garment village high up in the

0:50:13Vulcan mountains of Romania her foo

0:50:15where they are taking all that garment

0:50:17all that vomit garment and weaving it

0:50:22online also memories don't weigh a lot

0:50:24and you think that even while some

0:50:27memories can be pretty heavy but you but

0:50:29you take the corpus of data and that

0:50:30probably goes into some kind of an AI I

0:50:33don't know if we're at that level yet i

0:50:35mean i don't know how we even know for

0:50:37at that level yet I feel like that

0:50:38goodwill does not make any sense it

0:50:41doesn't make any sense and I do I feel

0:50:42like they're they're probably filled and

0:50:44filled

0:50:44in fields like the plum st a coil fields

0:50:49but instead of like oil derricks and and

0:50:53Blake burning pit fires there are just

0:50:57like The Velveteen rabbits with one

0:51:00broken leg of people's memories just

0:51:04sort of limping hobbling across this

0:51:06plain have you ever seen a rabbit with a

0:51:08broken leg me a living one

0:51:12yeah live rabbit that's like you know

0:51:13that sounds horrible it's terrible

0:51:15because the thing about a rabbit bunny

0:51:17wants to hop everybody wants to hop and

0:51:19also rabbit legs are that's a big part

0:51:22of a rabbit their hind legs and they're

0:51:25making way the ears in the legs

0:51:26anybody's got a fat rat

0:51:28well yeah and a you know rabbit's foot I

0:51:30mean remember to remember when everybody

0:51:32had a rabbit's foot

0:51:33it's just what she did I and I wanted

0:51:36one and I never I never had 1i think

0:51:38they used to be real feet from rabbits

0:51:39they were and my mom didn't want me to

0:51:42have a rabbit's foot it was something

0:51:43you got at the state fair

0:51:44no no it's got a bad juju feeling to it

0:51:47yeah right but people had rather their

0:51:48key chains were rabbits feet

0:51:50what is that about I'm just about that

0:51:53for the first time now

0:51:54yeah yeah a lucky rabbit's foot

0:51:59yeah that's what they were called I

0:52:01don't I test something like that now

0:52:02today you get a dreamweaver not a dream

0:52:04people it's called give me a catcher now

0:52:07I don't think you do get a dreamcatcher

0:52:09I mean you know back then you would get

0:52:10a Pepsi bottle that had been an

0:52:12elongated oh sure you melt it down

0:52:14really long Pepsi bottle but anyway but

0:52:17the thing about a rabbit is its foot and

0:52:19its leg is a big part of how big it is

0:52:21but the rabbit knows when it's what is

0:52:24fully functioning the rabbit kind of

0:52:26keeps its feet kind of tucked underneath

0:52:27itself

0:52:28yeah so when a rabbit is just kind of

0:52:30sitting there is justly with his little

0:52:31nose going you don't realize how how big

0:52:35his coiled haunches are but when a

0:52:38rabbit has been injured and one of those

0:52:40legs is is askew or dragging well then

0:52:44it's like oh my god this read that

0:52:46that's a big part of that rabbit that's

0:52:48not working right now and that is how i

0:52:50imagine most people's dreams are once

0:52:53they've been removed from

0:52:55the vomit garments or the CRT what's the

0:52:58most the memories have been liberated

0:53:00from clothing or context there like a

0:53:02limp limp rabbit there like a wounded

0:53:04rabbit and then just wandering around a

0:53:06baked plane that smells like oil there

0:53:09and maybe they're just hanging onto

0:53:11those because they know it's gonna be

0:53:12useful for something they're just not

0:53:14sure yet they haven't built the AI yet

0:53:16and they don't want to get rid of all

0:53:17these rabbits unless and until they have

0:53:20like fully mind the markets not ready

0:53:23for that

0:53:24oh my goodness that's a different

0:53:27screenplay much worse shape play

0:53:30yeah I'm sure thinking about it though

0:53:31I'm thinking about I'm yeah yeah you

0:53:35know what I gotta quit thinking about

0:53:35the second-hand market it's a it's too

0:53:38strange and then like you got the whole

0:53:39recycling thing that's not to beat the

0:53:41recycling thing to death but like I've

0:53:43read a couple of things lately that make

0:53:45me think that recycling is not as simple

0:53:47to understand as we've been led to

0:53:49believe I don't think it is at all i

0:53:51think it's basically garbage plus i

0:53:52think it's like the premium garbage

0:53:54where the way I understand it is like

0:53:56you know like when you go to the airport

0:53:58or you go to the food court or you go to

0:54:00wherever and now there's like three four

0:54:02five different barrels they're all

0:54:03labeled differently it's on credit I

0:54:05someone the other day where it was food

0:54:07only plastic bottles and trash and it's

0:54:11whatever whatever happened to

0:54:12compostable cups like that's really

0:54:14weird but you know sometimes at the

0:54:16airport that will stay right there

0:54:18put all your junk in here will be sorted

0:54:19off-site trust me right

0:54:21and so I don't know I want to be I want

0:54:23to be a game or about it but you know

0:54:25the thing is like it apparently it turns

0:54:27out there's not always a market that

0:54:30benefits groups say saving green bottles

0:54:33you heard this

0:54:34yeah what up you go on well what what

0:54:37I've heard I don't know if that's true

0:54:38but I mean I think there's I don't know

0:54:40that there are some things that are kind

0:54:41of perennial like there's a increasingly

0:54:43small amount of money you can get for

0:54:45for example like cans i think the way

0:54:48they make money from Kansas mostly is

0:54:49the deposit in a place like San

0:54:50Francisco ditto ditto for bottles but

0:54:53supposedly I mean it was like to clean

0:54:55those bottles and reusing them they're

0:54:57not like coke bottles for not anymore

0:54:58right right and so but the story goes

0:55:02and you tell me if you've heard the same

0:55:03thing you know how you know entrées

0:55:05into the corridors of power it's my

0:55:07understanding that maybe this month

0:55:09hey you know what it's actually there's

0:55:10there's not enough money for us to

0:55:12transport all these green bottles so

0:55:13we'll take him to the dump

0:55:14wow I don't know if that's true but

0:55:16that's what I hear I don't think it's a

0:55:18job because all the money is in scale

0:55:20and arbitrage like so many things in

0:55:22life so I when I reflect on the way that

0:55:25I use my own recycling compost and

0:55:28garbage bins which now Seattle has

0:55:30extended to recycling compost and

0:55:36landfill garbage and well let that we

0:55:40just we just introduced a new 24

0:55:43yeah we have for now oh my god and man

0:55:46like mandated if you put food and food

0:55:50waste in the garbage now it's against

0:55:53the law they I get frustrated sometimes

0:55:57with our neighbors well that they've

0:55:59gotten better but the the previous

0:56:00person who lived there and since moved

0:56:02out I think she took a certain amount of

0:56:04joy and willfully I'll i hate this is I

0:56:08think she was deliberately pushing my

0:56:09buttons that she would take you the

0:56:10thing about the computer and it's got a

0:56:12sandwich of styrofoam you got like two

0:56:14different pieces she would go in and

0:56:16just stuff to giant pieces of styrofoam

0:56:18into the compost like that was a thing

0:56:21Wow now what she doesn't know or doesn't

0:56:23care about is like I i use the compost

0:56:25like we compost a lot

0:56:27yeah and we recycle a lot and here's the

0:56:29thing the guy with the mustache that MPs

0:56:31are trash or you know puts are all of

0:56:33our different buckets into his truck on

0:56:36Tuesday mornings he's watching although

0:56:38he is rather he's watching us that you

0:56:40know what I think he gets ding if a

0:56:43bunch of plastic goes into the into its

0:56:45own homes

0:56:46I think I think he's going to get notes

0:56:48if he doesn't get it right and then so

0:56:50then he just put it down you know new

0:56:52dealer and then he puts up

0:56:53passive-aggressive sign on that says you

0:56:55check off what what I'm not taking

0:56:56because you did it now I'm stuck with

0:56:58styrofoam in the compost for a week so

0:57:00so this is the thing when i think about

0:57:02my own relationship to all these bins

0:57:04yeah I realized that I am I am presuming

0:57:08that on the other end there is someone

0:57:14with a master's degree who understands

0:57:17my intention

0:57:19and hand sorts each thing that I send

0:57:23their way with the same care and thought

0:57:27that I have put into which bin to put

0:57:29them in and how to arrange them who was

0:57:32behind of the refugees correspondence

0:57:35yeah exactly because it's like there's

0:57:36some rule where I lids go in the garbage

0:57:40unless a lid is eight inches or six

0:57:43inches across and then those lids go in

0:57:47the recycling well I can't leave me like

0:57:51I like a soldier's coffee lid

0:57:53yeah like a lid from a jar food so if

0:57:55your lid it's it's basically like

0:57:57halibut fishing you know i had never

0:57:59heard this if your lid is under 6 inches

0:58:01yet to throw a wetback but if your lid

0:58:05is over six inches then it it's in a

0:58:07special category of lids that go to it

0:58:09get that and I imagine at the recycling

0:58:12plant the lids go by and there's someone

0:58:15there paid

0:58:16I you know with again with a like a

0:58:19jeweler's loupe and a and a and a

0:58:23yardstick that's grabbing lids off the

0:58:25conveyor belt is like the lids are mine

0:58:27I'm the lid the lid person and they are

0:58:30all they have a separate kind of man

0:58:31they're sorting lids and they have plans

0:58:33for all the lids and that because the

0:58:34thing is it's not by MIT it's not by

0:58:37composition write a plastic lid that's

0:58:39over six inches and a metal lid that's

0:58:41over six inches both fulfilled the

0:58:43six-inch rule but they are made of

0:58:45completely different stuff and so as as

0:58:50far as I read the instructions both of

0:58:52those lids are recyclable whereas a

0:58:554-inch lid that's made of aluminum and a

0:58:574-inch little that's made a plastic both

0:58:59go in the garbage and so when I picture

0:59:02the recycling center i think of it as a

0:59:05miraculous place it literally is where

0:59:07the idea of super train came from a that

0:59:11this like this temple where hundreds of

0:59:15trained people are going through our

0:59:18garbage and turning that garbage into

0:59:21the Diamonds of remade repurposed like

0:59:30basic materials but i but as you as you

0:59:34say and as I think about it now of

0:59:37course that's not happening it's all

0:59:38just going into the it's all going into

0:59:40a freight car and just being dumped in

0:59:42the ocean because the truth is if this

0:59:46whole process is not confusing though

0:59:49the more confusing this process is the

0:59:51more likely it is they're actually doing

0:59:53something with any of the stuff if you

0:59:55use everything called recycling and

0:59:56every throw stuff in there but that's a

0:59:57pretty good chance a lot of stuff gets

0:59:59thrown away

0:59:59thrown away

1:00:00right and I think about when we started

1:00:01doing recycling at my college circa

1:00:03nineteen eighty-six we clean up after a

1:00:05party and we would have different

1:00:06garbage cans

1:00:07this one is for aluminum cans right this

1:00:09one's for clear bottles this one's for

1:00:11green bottles this one's for brown

1:00:12bottles because no reset back to make

1:00:14sure the technology's changed or I

1:00:16imagine it has but back then that if you

1:00:18wanted to go get the stuff recycled you

1:00:19do the sorting yourself right there was

1:00:21just just just pure acceptance at that

1:00:24place it did that but you had to like

1:00:25bring the right stuff that's right i

1:00:27delete things perplexing to me because

1:00:29what do you do what what do they do with

1:00:31plastic to recycle it they melted

1:00:34I keep thinking that that's what happens

1:00:37that they that they melt it down and get

1:00:39it back to its pure essence which is you

1:00:41know they make dinosaurs out of her and

1:00:42you're like a playground equipment

1:00:44Yeah right there they make they make our

1:00:46higher our nation's highways something's

1:00:50not right

1:00:51something something something feels

1:00:53weird about this and this is why I this

1:00:55is why i feel like the next technology

1:00:56and if I were Elon Musk

1:00:59I would stand boy if I were here lon

1:01:02must boy where would we start but one of

1:01:04the things i would be building i would

1:01:06stop building a spaceplane i think that

1:01:10the spaceplane thing like every

1:01:13billionaires got a space program right

1:01:14now and no billionaire it seems to me

1:01:17has is working on cool public transit

1:01:21and I think what we need are

1:01:23billionaires that are working on public

1:01:25transit and affordable like housing and

1:01:27the solution to the homeless problem and

1:01:30fewer billionaires that are working on

1:01:31space programs like one or two

1:01:34billionaire driven space programs i feel

1:01:38like we're covered in that area but the

1:01:41fact that there there's not a single

1:01:42billionaire that's working on like

1:01:45shelters for homeless families feels

1:01:51like grains balance but if I were Elon

1:01:53Musk I would be working on an a counter

1:01:55we have really feel like this is this is

1:01:58first principles of Roderick on the line

1:02:00yeah like a countertop recycling thing

1:02:05that's about this it's maybe bigger than

1:02:07a sodastream smaller than a than a pony

1:02:12keg

1:02:13and it's the opposite of a 3d printer

1:02:15everyone's doing 3d printing now look at

1:02:17that you can make it a gun or a keychain

1:02:19we're saying the opposite that we're

1:02:20saying that's right take what's already

1:02:22there make it go away

1:02:23that's right using 3d on printer you put

1:02:25anything literally anything in the slot

1:02:29anything that will fit in the slot you

1:02:30put in the slot the Machine analyzes its

1:02:33composition and then goes about whatever

1:02:36process it

1:02:37it requires to either melt the metal or

1:02:40or the the hydro floor fluorocarbon sue

1:02:44for the chlorofluorocarbons apart

1:02:48cooking oil in their absolute well why

1:02:50would you because that's what rate

1:02:51between coffee I don't drink and you

1:02:53know coffee when I was a kid you always

1:02:55put your grease into a folgers can my

1:02:57wife won't let out that allow that into

1:02:59the house because she's fancy well yeah

1:03:01yeah you with your grease boy we it

1:03:04becomes like a rabbit hutch like we have

1:03:06to wait for it to cool off a little bit

1:03:07and then you put my wife will cut the

1:03:09top off of a Salter can pour it into

1:03:11their like an animal and then what did

1:03:12you do

1:03:13I don't know she wants me to throw it

1:03:14away but in this case you're saying

1:03:16maybe if I understand that this gets to

1:03:18the right level of sophistication it's

1:03:19somewhere between the opposite of 3d

1:03:21printer in a microwave and let's be

1:03:22honest to dispose all but like you could

1:03:24put grease in there because that could

1:03:26be running somebody's car in your

1:03:27neighborhood because there's a local

1:03:28collection center that decides what to

1:03:30do with it based on area neighborhood

1:03:32allocations well so ultimately yeah

1:03:34right at the end of the at the end of

1:03:36the the week you'd have a little brick

1:03:39of carbon probably a big brick of carbon

1:03:42you have a little brick of silver a

1:03:44little brick of platinum a little brick

1:03:46of a plutonium a little brick of my very

1:03:49small break of plutonium you have a you

1:03:52have a jar of cooking oil you have a jar

1:03:54of motor oil and and then you can either

1:03:57sell those on the market or you could

1:03:59put them you can plug them into your 3d

1:04:01printers where you would then use all

1:04:04those materials again to to build your

1:04:07own you know

1:04:09garter belts or or sure or whatever it

1:04:12was you're like an on-demand garterbelt

1:04:14yeah because what are the building

1:04:15blocks of things oil right carbon value

1:04:21well yeah nursing

1:04:25right right family damn that's right

1:04:28love love love love is always missing

1:04:31ingredient right and so you so you just

1:04:33you think about you you look over here

1:04:35like hear the things i need this week

1:04:36and I need the following materials to

1:04:40make those things and then here are the

1:04:41things i'm throwing away this week and

1:04:43these are the component elements of

1:04:45those like I didn't have the

1:04:46neighborhood thing that we're almost

1:04:48like you like right now we think nothing

1:04:49about having a place in Florida where

1:04:51all the water drains off into a pond

1:04:53like where there's also a way that all

1:04:54the resources of your of your small

1:04:57neighborhood your block could be

1:04:59reallocated on an on-demand basis so you

1:05:01talk about to take a penny leave a penny

1:05:03two a penny penny if you need if you

1:05:04need an on-demand aluminum garterbelt

1:05:06that could be delayed deliveries you get

1:05:08this get this guy over here is taking

1:05:09all the course light maybe you got an

1:05:12automobile that can run on french fries

1:05:13and that could be sluiced out of this

1:05:15guy here plays a lot of online games

1:05:17right so the colors like guys like Oh

1:05:19what am I gonna do with all these cans

1:05:21and two doors down

1:05:23there's somebody that's like what am I

1:05:25gonna get the aluminum to build my my

1:05:28own myspace looking ongoing existential

1:05:30swapmeet leave a penny take a penny

1:05:31leave a penny take a pen mhm and I think

1:05:34it's important to a lot of people say

1:05:35take a penny leave a penny I say leave a

1:05:37penny two a penny you say leave a

1:05:39paycheck upending it starts with leaving

1:05:40a penny you know em you know here's

1:05:45another thing about me hard it's gonna

1:05:46be to build I feel like you on must

1:05:48should be thinking about by comparison

1:05:49not difficult it's going to take some

1:05:51resources it's going to take some time

1:05:53it's going to take some adjustment is

1:05:54going to take some retrofitting but

1:05:56people are always doing stuff like

1:05:57getting new windows or air conditioning

1:05:58like how hard it'd be you get a tattoo a

1:06:00sluice and maybe that could be a 3d

1:06:02printer too so people are always coming

1:06:04up to me at at Comic Cons and such as

1:06:07yeah what is super train coming and I'm

1:06:09like you know what I'm starting to say

1:06:11to people like you know make your own

1:06:13supertrain yes right

1:06:16like when wet when is super train coming

1:06:18what about now like super train starts

1:06:20at home super super train is it's like a

1:06:23last-minute party you know the thing is

1:06:25it's a last-minute party in the sense

1:06:27that it's going to be as good as what

1:06:29everybody brings so if you show up the

1:06:31last minute party like this is losing

1:06:33its like fuck you go out and buy some

1:06:34ice like do that brings something to the

1:06:36party

1:06:37you're saying supertrain is Stone Soup

1:06:39it's no I'm not

1:06:42ah here's one thing I've been thinking

1:06:44about it and I don't get too serious but

1:06:45i have been thinking about this a little

1:06:46bit that like when I think i read what

1:06:49you say in your campaign and hear what

1:06:51you saying your campaign and like we

1:06:53have the conversation probably not a

1:06:54couple months ago about stuff like I

1:06:56mean I'll put this in my words and then

1:06:58you tell me if it's even near right but

1:06:59like okay there's stuff coming right now

1:07:01we are on the verge of a lot of

1:07:03Technology going from m2 like wow we

1:07:06don't know what that's gonna be

1:07:08but what are the smart things we could

1:07:09do to start preparing the way for what

1:07:12could come along and what the example I

1:07:14gave i think was having to deal with

1:07:15like we're not sure

1:07:17here's what we know what we know is that

1:07:19we kind of want to use less oil and have

1:07:21less people driving a single

1:07:23gas-guzzling car around that we've

1:07:25reached peak that shit like now what is

1:07:28next

1:07:28is it self-driving cars maybe isn't

1:07:30publicize it makes it like you said

1:07:32every sidewalk you put down will be torn

1:07:34up someday like how do you how do you

1:07:36make that easy to deal with in the

1:07:38future so i'm trying to think more about

1:07:39like what does that mean in like 125

1:07:43years is it something that you can do in

1:07:44125 year terms how do you start making

1:07:46fewer dumb decisions and more scalable

1:07:48roll packable fixable decisions

1:07:51yeah and and in particular it's really

1:07:55hard especially when you're campaigning

1:07:59for office but really hard in general to

1:08:02see your cell and we talk about this all

1:08:04the time but to see yourself or to see

1:08:06ourselves as in the middle of the stream

1:08:10you know between hither and thither and

1:08:14so everybody wants a everybody wants a

1:08:17solution based on where we are right now

1:08:20because it seems like this is always the

1:08:22end of history and to to be running for

1:08:27office and advocating in some respects

1:08:31for like hey what we should do right now

1:08:34I mean with what we should have done in

1:08:36seattle was build a transit network 40

1:08:39years ago we didn't do it and we should

1:08:42have built 20 years ago and we didn't do

1:08:44it and we shouldn't even built a 10

1:08:45years ago and we didn't but now we're at

1:08:48a place where

1:08:49everywhere you look there's a new

1:08:51transportation technology about to come

1:08:55online i mean really in every in every

1:08:58aspect is I mean top of my head you have

1:09:04the self-driving cars which is something

1:09:05that one or two years ago I looked at

1:09:07what are you even kidding me and now I

1:09:09can't believe we're not doing it

1:09:10I mean just the data on how much better

1:09:12decisions something like that could make

1:09:14you've got stuff like drones right

1:09:16you've got not necessarily kind of

1:09:18killed people in other countries but

1:09:19you've got smaller like kind of personal

1:09:21sighs you know remote controllable

1:09:24aircraft heavily unregulated right words

1:09:28from the other things

1:09:29ok magazine what you can do with

1:09:30electric it right the ability to store

1:09:33electricity has vastly changed in the

1:09:35last five years and that's ultimately

1:09:36the whole game because five years ago it

1:09:39was like electric cars what if you want

1:09:41to drive 10 miles and now it's like no

1:09:44they're electric-powered things are

1:09:47going to electric power things already

1:09:49work 99 percent of the trips that we

1:09:52take would already be electric power and

1:09:54so you have all these other things that

1:09:56electricity can do like all those weird

1:09:58bicycles that people use to retrofit

1:10:01little motors to like you

1:10:04we're very quickly going to see bicycles

1:10:08that if you that our electric augmented

1:10:12powered up hills so you ride your bike

1:10:15you're having fun on your bike and then

1:10:17you come to a big hill and you engage an

1:10:20electric motor that runs you up the hill

1:10:22and it's not you know that that

1:10:24technology exists now but it makes bikes

1:10:26really heavy and awkward and you know

1:10:28and it's just going to be it's going to

1:10:31be kind of seamlessly integrated and all

1:10:33the people running around town on

1:10:35segways that we look at and mock and say

1:10:38like oh my God look at you with this you

1:10:39know on the one you're silly a Segway

1:10:41like really that was a technology that

1:10:44was 10 or 15 years ahead of its time but

1:10:48all the different permutations of that

1:10:51the the kind of personal mobility a

1:10:55scooter platform skateboard

1:10:59as the as batteries get better and

1:11:03motors get more efficient and all that

1:11:05stuff gets better they're going to be

1:11:07incredible innovations in terms of

1:11:10people just like hopping on a little

1:11:12platform and it's whisks them two here

1:11:15and two there that always happen but

1:11:19then there's also all these advances in

1:11:21rail that are I mean either you know the

1:11:25big excitement of this train that people

1:11:27keep saying they're going to build and

1:11:28they're not building of the you know the

1:11:31vacuum tube train or the maglev train

1:11:34from San Francisco to Los Angeles the

1:11:38technology actually is there it's just

1:11:41how do you get the political will in the

1:11:43money to build a this link right but you

1:11:47could build it and have a train that

1:11:49goes from LA to san francisco in one

1:11:51hour

1:11:52haha that would be so amazing and so

1:11:55it's so it's a question of like all

1:11:57right here we are we're at the

1:11:58technological level and is that the

1:12:01direction that we're going are we going

1:12:03to build that are we not

1:12:04are these little scooters that i

1:12:06imagining and little skateboards and

1:12:08little electric-powered kind of mobility

1:12:10devices with what direction are those

1:12:13going to take i can see that i can see

1:12:16it but that doesn't necessarily mean

1:12:18that that's where people i mean you

1:12:21definitely know that if tony hawk can

1:12:26invest in an electric skateboard that

1:12:30goes up hills that is still that still

1:12:33functions as a skateboard for a while at

1:12:35least you know like that's app that's

1:12:38gonna happen and so so from from the

1:12:41standpoint of like we we need to make a

1:12:43huge investment in transportation it's

1:12:47it's really unusual and weird to be in a

1:12:50position to say like what we actually

1:12:51should probably do right now is put our

1:12:57finger in the dike make the short term

1:13:01investments to keep stuff running so

1:13:07that we don't really scare

1:13:10you up this transition and then

1:13:12everybody put their heads together and

1:13:16try and start seeing like what's what

1:13:18what is the future really gonna look

1:13:19like because I know at uber I know up in

1:13:22the boardroom at huber those guys when

1:13:25they're not playing nerf basketball and

1:13:27like sexually harassing one another they

1:13:31are imagining in the very near term a

1:13:35world where there are no drivers when

1:13:38we're sober is in control of a vast

1:13:42network of of centrally controlled

1:13:45autonomous vehicles who and we all pull

1:13:49out our phones and uber become

1:13:51synonymous with transportation and we

1:13:55plot the phone and the car whisks up we

1:13:58get in it takes us where we're going it

1:13:59hit it subtracts a certain amount of

1:14:02bitcoins from are you know from our

1:14:05online account we never even think about

1:14:07it it's not even a thing that you have

1:14:09to it's not a transaction you have to do

1:14:12it's all just happening you pull out

1:14:13your phone you just say out loud to your

1:14:16google glass I need a car and there's

1:14:18one there in two seconds and it's run by

1:14:20uber that's absolutely what they are

1:14:23imagining they don't want drivers they

1:14:26want to eliminate drivers and they will

1:14:28and for most of us consumers we're going

1:14:33to be like this is great i just started

1:14:36just walk over and sending a car and one

1:14:37appears and it takes me there and I

1:14:38don't have to talk to anybody and then

1:14:40and I don't have to do a transaction it

1:14:42just takes it just at the end of the

1:14:45it's just another eel that's sucking on

1:14:46me and at the end of the month my bill

1:14:48gets paid automatically and and i'm just

1:14:52working for the company store whatever

1:14:53but how do city's plan for that and how

1:14:56do cities say like winter we don't want

1:14:58to Bert ubi the we don't want them

1:15:01controlling that infrastructure but but

1:15:04they are working hard to build it if we

1:15:07don't want them to do it we would have

1:15:10to get involved we would have to

1:15:12envision it and do it ourselves or

1:15:15or regulated and the results the results

1:15:17are mean with uber in particular the

1:15:22results are so fast the results are so

1:15:25immediate and the results have such a

1:15:28high positive impact on influential

1:15:32people with money

1:15:33mhm right and i don't mean to make this

1:15:35you know overly political but I am I saw

1:15:37blood poster of an article the other day

1:15:39where none of it the nut is basically

1:15:42it's difficult it's difficult to be

1:15:44punctual when you're poor like how hard

1:15:46it is just how much more friction there

1:15:48is to everything if you like the more

1:15:50you have your own control over your time

1:15:52and in this case your transportation

1:15:53like the more options for convenience

1:15:56and punctuality that you have I mean you

1:15:59can get there early and get a coffee

1:16:00unless you're getting two buses that may

1:16:02or may not have you know time transfers

1:16:04and stuff like that right well yeah

1:16:06unless you have to figure out who's

1:16:08gonna watch your kids all right yeah

1:16:10exactly yeah but you know the other

1:16:14thing I keep thinking about 9i I campus

1:16:16I can't just thinking out loud is that

1:16:19you know if you think about the stuff

1:16:20that the infrastructure stuff that

1:16:22succeeds over time I mean at some point

1:16:25it starts out being completely bananas

1:16:27and maybe even proprietary and then

1:16:29eventually it becomes adopted and then

1:16:31at some point it becomes you know

1:16:32wasteful or obviated inefficient out of

1:16:37out of the times but you know I'm

1:16:38thinking about stuff along the lines of

1:16:40railroads and then the gauge of tracks

1:16:44right like at some point i don't know

1:16:47i'm sure you know way more about this

1:16:48than i did but at some point in order to

1:16:49have railroads where everybody's cars to

1:16:51go everywhere we had to agree on a

1:16:53certain age of track in order to have

1:16:55rifles where you could have replaceable

1:16:58parts and having a assembly line to

1:17:00standardize things like what those parts

1:17:02are in and the level of quality and each

1:17:04of those things

1:17:05shit I mean look at the bricks in a

1:17:06building like what if half the bricks

1:17:08broke or the CAF the bricks were an

1:17:11eighth of an inch bigger on one side or

1:17:12whatever it there has to be some way of

1:17:14standardizing whose lego set we're going

1:17:16to use for this I can go to any place in

1:17:20America that has electric plugs and plug

1:17:22in a 1 10 you know the device and it'll

1:17:24just work unless something's very very

1:17:26wrong

1:17:27it seems like that's the part that's

1:17:28trickiest it isn't that we need another

1:17:30billionaire to figure out what to build

1:17:32with the existing LEGO sets we need

1:17:34somebody who can create open lego sets

1:17:36that will let new kinds of flexibility

1:17:38emerge and I literally cannot think of a

1:17:40better analogy than that but whatever

1:17:42ends up happening with roads

1:17:44it can't be suddenly just caters to the

1:17:46people who moved to town in the last

1:17:47three years and have a nice car that

1:17:49they like to drive like that's that

1:17:51doesn't feel like the future that feels

1:17:52like the past

1:17:53well and this is where this is where

1:17:55like I the other day I was driving along

1:17:56and I and a mini van drove by me and it

1:17:59was an apple maps minivan an apple maps

1:18:05is now finally sort of getting around to

1:18:08the three-dimensional mapping

1:18:11three-dimensional photographic mapping

1:18:14of the world that Google's been doing

1:18:15for a long time and it it a bit rattled

1:18:21me because I remember the moment in my

1:18:25own life where Apple decided that in

1:18:28their relationship with google because

1:18:30remember the original iphones all had

1:18:33google maps absolutely and then Google

1:18:35decided that they weren't sharing all

1:18:38the metadata they were collecting with

1:18:40apple and google was like no no all that

1:18:43metadata is our proprietary stuff there

1:18:46was a time when the head can google is

1:18:48on the board apple right and and those

1:18:51were those were heady days but then

1:18:55Apple decided at from a business

1:18:58standpoint it made more sense for them

1:19:00to build their own mapping program from

1:19:03the ground up rather than just seed to

1:19:06google all of the data that Google was

1:19:10collecting about where people went and

1:19:11what it was tied to and so what that

1:19:14meant for us the consumers was that all

1:19:16of a sudden our iphones no longer had

1:19:20google maps functionality and we were

1:19:23now all millions of beta testers for

1:19:28apples garbage map program that it took

1:19:31them six years to get to the point where

1:19:34now it only directs me to the wrong

1:19:36address one out of seven asking Brooks I

1:19:39know real talk

1:19:40you've you've been

1:19:41you've had bad experiences with Apple

1:19:43maps like like demonstrable a bad that

1:19:46was flatly wrong experiences with a few

1:19:48apps

1:19:48yup where somebody says hey come to the

1:19:50here's the event and here's the here's

1:19:53the the address and i click on the

1:19:55address and apple loads their map

1:19:58program and puts it puts up in somewhere

1:20:00and I go to that pin and it is though it

1:20:04is completely on the other side so

1:20:05interesting i I've had a handful of bad

1:20:09experiences but at reason i ask is

1:20:10because I i can have to say that of all

1:20:14the things like all the Apple scandals

1:20:16and pseudo scandals over the years the

1:20:18antenna gate and stuff like that amongst

1:20:20normal people like in my family people

1:20:23in my family who are still five within

1:20:26the last three to five years users of

1:20:28apple products that is the one thing

1:20:30that pretty much everybody seems to

1:20:32agree on is that the maps the maps were

1:20:35total shit and now they're mostly shit

1:20:37and they would they actually will go and

1:20:39get and use google maps on the phone

1:20:40yeah i mean i had to because I I because

1:20:43I showed up a half hour late to

1:20:45important appointments right i remember

1:20:48i remember that recent one where you

1:20:49respect as a candidate you're gonna

1:20:51appear somewhere inside you totally

1:20:52wrong place yeah was supposed to it was

1:20:54my first meeting with the Chamber of

1:20:55Commerce and I role in 45 minutes late

1:20:58drenched in sweat apologizing to him and

1:21:00I'm like listen I'm serious candidate

1:21:02I'm not just a goofy musician that

1:21:03doesn't know how to find his way to a

1:21:05building in the center of town my phone

1:21:07misled me

1:21:08yeah i'm going to my whole life yeah my

1:21:10phone told me that your office was on

1:21:12this the south slope of queen anne hill

1:21:15in a in a in a flophouse rather than in

1:21:18the reindeer tower but thanks

1:21:22Apple ID materially but that that's an

1:21:24example yeah but so you know and what

1:21:26that ultimately is its beta vs VHS and

1:21:29and where we are right now is Apple and

1:21:32Facebook and uber and presumably all the

1:21:35the big-three car companies although

1:21:37they're really lagging in this but all

1:21:40the tech companies recognize that this

1:21:41that the self-driving car and the

1:21:44intricate oh and the point of it isn't

1:21:45the car the point of it is that once all

1:21:48cars are connected to one another in a

1:21:51grid of central control

1:21:54then there are no more accidents and

1:21:56then it's than the efficiency of

1:21:58Transportation everything just goes fast

1:22:01and it's connected to the the

1:22:05fundamental premise of why Google Maps

1:22:08my google was collecting that

1:22:09information in the first place if you

1:22:11know where people are where they're

1:22:12going

1:22:14you know and what their history of going

1:22:16places is you have massive knowledge

1:22:20about them and not only that but your

1:22:23you also are charging them to move you

1:22:25around like it's a it's a incredible

1:22:29system of of knowledge and control and

1:22:33every one of those companies is trying

1:22:35to envision that future and and build

1:22:37that system and when they roll it out

1:22:41but that he's my analogy they want to be

1:22:43there Lego set

1:22:43I want to be there lego set and when

1:22:45they roll it out from the consumer

1:22:47standpoint it's it's just going to be

1:22:49like hey uh any cars zip all this is

1:22:53great the future is amazing and the fat

1:22:56we've already acquiesced to these

1:22:58companies knowing you know the

1:23:01geo-locating are photographs and

1:23:04connecting it all to everything you know

1:23:07to our amazon accounts and everything

1:23:08they know about us everybody's just

1:23:10completely rolled over on that privacy

1:23:13stuff that we were so terrified about 15

1:23:15years ago because of the convenience and

1:23:17the fact that oh it's fine you know when

1:23:19I go into amazon it just knows what I

1:23:21wanted when I put to perturb and when

1:23:23that is when that is true of

1:23:25transportation also i mean it's it

1:23:29there's a lot to philosophize about it

1:23:32right but from the standpoint of a city

1:23:34and the way a city runs you know what's

1:23:37amazing to me is that out that I've gone

1:23:39in and sat in the boardroom of the

1:23:41Teamsters Union here several times and

1:23:43talked to several different groups of

1:23:45Teamsters and in the short term they're

1:23:49very interested in unionizing huber

1:23:51drivers and and because drivers are the

1:23:55that's what the Teamsters are they must

1:23:58see that as a stopgap though

1:23:59well but that's not a thing that they

1:24:01want to talk about they do not want to

1:24:04talk about the fact that all of the

1:24:06technology

1:24:07groups right now are all working

1:24:09furiously to eliminate drivers to

1:24:14eliminate all kinds of drivers and that

1:24:16millions of jobs will disappear

1:24:19truck drivers bus drivers taxi drivers

1:24:22drivers

1:24:23I mean it's a it's a major job for

1:24:26middle-class people right it's all going

1:24:30away and teachers don't want to talk

1:24:33about it and they don't want to think

1:24:34about it right now they want to they

1:24:36want to unionize uber drivers they want

1:24:39to you know get out ahead of of what is

1:24:42the short-term problem which is taxi

1:24:46drivers are unionized but uber drivers

1:24:49aren't but the near term problem which

1:24:52isn't even that far out which is all

1:24:54y'all jobs are going away to be replaced

1:24:59by a you know a massive overarching grid

1:25:07and that is undeniably the future in our

1:25:13lifetimes and we're not talking about

1:25:17who controls it or or how it integrates

1:25:23and and as far as i can tell right now

1:25:26there's like all these companies are be

1:25:28furiously beavering away because nobody

1:25:31wants to be the Betamax so they end up

1:25:33being kind of like the early railroad

1:25:36barons who saw the benefits of having

1:25:38lines that only their cars could go on

1:25:40right so what do you think I mean I mean

1:25:42getting that wrong but I mean they're

1:25:44rather than having a policy that pushes

1:25:45us forward their kind of forcing the

1:25:47hand of all these different groups and

1:25:49making better progress very quickly on

1:25:50all the stuff they want to have happen

1:25:52uh who are you talking about now Oh in

1:25:55the case of somebody like uber I mean I

1:25:56you know how he really put it this way i

1:25:58have i might be on mixed feelings about

1:26:00uber you know where I live

1:26:01yep um there's a lot of nights and days

1:26:04where I just don't get a cab and I've

1:26:06tried for years that's what there was

1:26:08and so I mean I have to admit that I you

1:26:10know I don't remember but it's driven me

1:26:12nuts for years that like on we have

1:26:15hired a babysitter

1:26:16it's date night 143 date nights a year

1:26:17and literally in over three hours we

1:26:20cannot

1:26:20a cab you keep calling you keep calling

1:26:22for getting mad because you keep calling

1:26:24but the thing is every single person

1:26:26that dispatcher is sending them a

1:26:27message that says go way the hell out

1:26:29into the western part of town where you

1:26:31will probably even get a fair back if

1:26:33they see one person on the street on

1:26:35polk street they're gonna pick that

1:26:36person up before they even make it make

1:26:38it to the Panhandle so I mean the part

1:26:40of my frustration is like I'd hate using

1:26:43over but like there's not that much

1:26:44better stuff

1:26:46well I'm not to be somewhere on time but

1:26:47i but I hate what they're doing and I

1:26:49can't believe what they get away with

1:26:50and in the short term like as a

1:26:52politician I have to be confronting uber

1:26:56right now and the fact that

1:26:58yeah they're better service in a lot of

1:27:00ways and and the cab companies are

1:27:05playing catch-up and they're mad and

1:27:06uber is not regulated the same way the

1:27:08cab companies are and that's unfair and

1:27:11uber drivers are treated badly relative

1:27:14to other professional drivers and that

1:27:15has to be regulated and changed the

1:27:18setting aside all the safety stuff and

1:27:20yet the privacy stuff that they've been

1:27:21horrible about to yeah and this is all

1:27:23as a as a as a as a aspiring politician

1:27:27this is all stuff that's right on the

1:27:28table in front of us that we have to

1:27:29deal with in the next year or two but

1:27:32uber uber corporate does not is not

1:27:38playing the short game they don't care

1:27:41they are just they're just trying to

1:27:43keep us all off balance until they can

1:27:48eliminate drivers completely and so we

1:27:53are we're down here you know fighting

1:27:55over bread scraps and the and the big

1:28:01technology companies are our way way out

1:28:05ahead of this and they do they are not

1:28:07worried about you know that they're not

1:28:10worried about the unions and they're not

1:28:11worried about this kind of regulation

1:28:13because they are planning to roll out

1:28:15this massive other thing and the big

1:28:18question is going to be in the in the in

1:28:2210 years when you walk down and you have

1:28:27an apple product

1:28:29on your person and that Apple product is

1:28:33your gateway you your your chip is

1:28:39apple-branded rather than google-branded

1:28:42and you want a car are you going to have

1:28:48access to every car or just the apple

1:28:51branded cars and are not so different

1:28:55from music in some ways like if the

1:28:57stuff you wanna listen to is not on your

1:28:58streaming service here and you're not

1:28:59going to hear it and that should be that

1:29:02should give us pause because that is how

1:29:05these companies have chosen to to handle

1:29:10the world of music or the world of the

1:29:12movies are a lot of the other services

1:29:14that we want like we we have the

1:29:17absolute the technology right now to

1:29:19watch any movie ever and any TV show

1:29:22ever

1:29:23but we can't because the because the

1:29:25apertures are controlled by these

1:29:28different companies and they have

1:29:29different rules and they you know and so

1:29:31so we there is one possible future where

1:29:35you walk out there and whatever whatever

1:29:37the brand on the chip that's your portal

1:29:41is it doesn't matter because it's some

1:29:44are you familiar with the idea of of

1:29:47common carrier so the railroads for

1:29:51instance are what's known as common

1:29:53carriers which means that they have a

1:29:59they have to carry whatever people want

1:30:06to move around right the the railroads

1:30:08are private companies but but you can't

1:30:14let the railroad can't say like well

1:30:16we're not going to carry that boxcar

1:30:18full of stuff because we don't believe

1:30:21you know a woman's right to choose and

1:30:23that boxcar has birth control in it huh

1:30:26right so they have the railroad if you

1:30:28are if you're a business and you need

1:30:31stuff moved around the railroads can't

1:30:33pick and choose within you know within

1:30:37pretty general guidelines they have that

1:30:40this is why this is why when when

1:30:42environmentalists go to Burlington

1:30:44Northern and say stop carrying those oil

1:30:46trains like Burlington Northern can't

1:30:49choose to do that or or maybe to put

1:30:51sharper point on it you couldn't say we

1:30:54refuse to carry replacement parts for

1:30:56our competitors trains right that's them

1:30:59in some kind of specific antitrust II

1:31:00kind of aspect of this right yeah they

1:31:03have to kind of move frayed around

1:31:05that's that that's part of the public

1:31:07trust and you know it ultimately and

1:31:11then this is the thing we've seen with

1:31:12with cab companies over the over the

1:31:15decades right cab companies routinely

1:31:18did not pull over and pick up people of

1:31:22color who were hailing cabs and that was

1:31:24a big thing you know that continues to

1:31:25be a problem but was a major major

1:31:27problem and you know and it's a and it

1:31:31violates the law but what all of this is

1:31:34done by bleeps and bloops right like

1:31:39let's say uber I mean because uber

1:31:41drivers rate their passengers to right

1:31:44yeah so let's say that you have a bad

1:31:48rating and all transportation you know

1:31:53then and and and and basically we we go

1:31:56into this world where you where its

1:32:00autonomous cars everywhere and you can't

1:32:04get a car where it but also it could be

1:32:07something even more subtle than that

1:32:08right where it could be something where

1:32:10it's like it isn't it isn't simply just

1:32:11that we there's not a particular reason

1:32:13but there is an aggregate to the

1:32:15algorithm of deciding who's the most

1:32:17efficient person overtime and best

1:32:19person to pick up em like this is like

1:32:21this is this is a common user this is a

1:32:23VIP this is somebody has a high rating

1:32:25this is somebody who tis good let's look

1:32:27at the most obvious one

1:32:28this is somebody who's leaving a

1:32:30high-traffic area to go to another

1:32:32high-traffic area

1:32:34mm that's very desirable for anybody who

1:32:36drives so for action so that stuff so as

1:32:40we look at the future of Transportation

1:32:42and we think well a lot of our

1:32:44transportation systems are going to get

1:32:46replaced supplanted by this private

1:32:50infrastructure that's being privately

1:32:53developed and is going to roll out on

1:32:55the

1:32:55terms of these private companies we're

1:32:59in a way entering into and the week

1:33:03potentially are entering into a new

1:33:04realm where transportation is privileged

1:33:08and all of the all of the the potential

1:33:12of it which is like true mobility for

1:33:14people true equitable mobility provided

1:33:19by this amazing technology of on-demand

1:33:21cars we squander because we let it be

1:33:27rolled out on a for-profit basis based

1:33:31on these pre-existing like what's your

1:33:34you know do you have a five star rating

1:33:36do you have an almost almost like a like

1:33:38a credit score and there isn't any form

1:33:40of redlining some ways yeah right and

1:33:41cars are you standing there trying to

1:33:43get a car in the rain and they're just

1:33:44going by you going by you because

1:33:46they're going they're off to pick up VIP

1:33:48customers and you're waiting for the you

1:33:51know the ramshackle you're waiting for

1:33:55the intel car or whatever you're waiting

1:33:58for the car that's branded right well

1:33:59branded by chick-fil-a to come get you

1:34:04because it's the only one that will

1:34:06accept uncredited on you know one star

1:34:10past like that the chinatown bus like

1:34:11you you go to this court of last resort

1:34:13that's really consistent in its way but

1:34:16is is not the most convenient thing so

1:34:18that's terrifying to me and that is the

1:34:20thing that I feel like only city's only

1:34:22municipalities only governments can

1:34:25intervene and say no we are going to

1:34:28control this grid we are going to

1:34:30control this system this is a public

1:34:31utility not a private enterprise because

1:34:36it has to it has to serve the public

1:34:39good and that is more important than

1:34:42rewarding investors early investors

1:34:46because what we can see now is that this

1:34:49is inevitable

1:34:50this is a this is where this is our

1:34:54transportation future and transportation

1:34:56is a public good and not it's one thing

1:35:00to sell cars into a thing but private

1:35:04companies don't own the roads and that's

1:35:07what ultimately

1:35:09our future is going to look like they're

1:35:11going to say like oh yeah we'll pay for

1:35:13pay for the roads with taxes but the

1:35:15actual transportation system is going to

1:35:17be privately owned by these tech

1:35:20companies in competition with each other

1:35:21and so cities have to get out of it and

1:35:23they aren't no one is talking about it

1:35:26and we're all arguing about whether or

1:35:28not to unionize uber drivers and we're

1:35:31arguing about what are you know whether

1:35:33to put expect more express buses on the

1:35:35road and it's like you guys we have to

1:35:38be smarter than this but now i'm

1:35:42thinking i guess and I'm I'm merely

1:35:44playing devil's advocate but I think

1:35:46about the position of pharmaceutical

1:35:49industry who you know well you know

1:35:52they're in the business of trying to

1:35:54provide pharmaceuticals that help people

1:35:58have better health but in the interest

1:36:00of doing that they get things like a

1:36:02patent where the only know only and only

1:36:04they can produce this allergy pill for

1:36:07whatever it is 10 years and they say

1:36:09okay well now we're going to change

1:36:11slightly change the capsule on this with

1:36:12a different delivery mechanism a week

1:36:14another 10 years out of that eventually

1:36:16that goes to generics now their case is

1:36:17going to be that there's a huge amount

1:36:19of R&D in that is a huge amount of

1:36:21testing is a huge just ridiculous amount

1:36:23development so you know do we set aside

1:36:26that the argument that in that case they

1:36:28feel like that innovation is what

1:36:29enables them to make those things do we

1:36:31take into account how much of that is to

1:36:33make your Peter hard versus how much it

1:36:34is to really help people with diabetes

1:36:35like where does what where are the lines

1:36:38in deciding what at municipal level

1:36:41we're deciding what private interests

1:36:43can do in a common carrier kind of

1:36:46environment

1:36:47I mean that thing I think there are a

1:36:49lot of cases to be made that the

1:36:50pharmaceutical and industry

1:36:52I like a lot of our medical practice is

1:36:55deeply broken and the and the capitalism

1:36:58that is rife in it it like it not only

1:37:02gives us poorer outcomes are our

1:37:06medicine is worse or treatment is worse

1:37:07that the time factor is you know is a is

1:37:14extended by decades like you could make

1:37:18that case and and and we should be

1:37:20making that case

1:37:22but i think that transportation is in a

1:37:24very different realm then Medicine just

1:37:28in the sense that like pharmaceutical I

1:37:33mean there is a huge difference between

1:37:35boner pills and and heart medicine

1:37:38yeah but the thing part of over success

1:37:40I think has come out of the fact that

1:37:42make just repeat myself that they were a

1:37:44product that people didn't even know how

1:37:47much they wanted people who could afford

1:37:48it and it makes it must make it harder

1:37:51to regulate them since they are so over

1:37:53servicing the people who are in a

1:37:55position of power to decide what's gonna

1:37:57happen with it isn't that part of the

1:37:58struggle

1:37:59yeah well and also its I mean the big

1:38:02part of the struggle is how do you get

1:38:04how do you get governments to have this

1:38:08kind of elasticity and smartness but i

1:38:10think i think a better cop a better

1:38:12comparison is that when electricity was

1:38:15first invented there were probably 10

1:38:20different people trying to string up

1:38:24independent elect electric utilities in

1:38:26San Francisco who I mean there was

1:38:28Edison and Tesla arguing about whether

1:38:31or not it should be AC or DC there was

1:38:34like that's to an elephant

1:38:35that's right look what it does to an

1:38:36elephant there was a lot of private

1:38:38enterprise and there was a lot of that

1:38:39argument of like well this was expensive

1:38:41and when this is our proprietary

1:38:42knowledge but at a certain point cities

1:38:45realized that providing electrical

1:38:47service was a common good and that it

1:38:51couldn't be

1:38:52we couldn't have 10 different electrical

1:38:53networks we needed one and you know

1:38:56originally there were a lot of different

1:38:58people bringing water to the city and

1:39:01then we had to make that a utility so

1:39:05there-there there's plenty of there are

1:39:08plenty of models where you see where

1:39:10something transitions from a competitive

1:39:15environment and this is why this is the

1:39:17argument for municipal broadband right

1:39:19that a certain point internet high speed

1:39:23internet service passes beyond a

1:39:27threshold where it is just a where where

1:39:32it's a luxury and it becomes a necessity

1:39:35and at the point at which it becomes a

1:39:38necessity than city's needs to step in

1:39:40and make sure that because right now in

1:39:41seattle for instance comcast provides

1:39:44much better much faster and more

1:39:46reliable internet service to the rich

1:39:48neighborhoods into the poor

1:39:49neighborhoods and and you yell at them

1:39:54about it and they go oh we definitely

1:39:57are upgrading as we go and all this

1:39:59stuff but they're not because they have

1:40:01no incentive to write and so what you

1:40:05see is more and more of our life is

1:40:07going online and those companies exhibit

1:40:11less and less of a and and innuendo the

1:40:15the libertarian argument is like why

1:40:21should they

1:40:22you know what why should they provide a

1:40:25public service there are for-profit

1:40:26company and when you come up against

1:40:28that attitude in a thing that becomes a

1:40:31necessity then you say like well then

1:40:33we're going to take that away from you

1:40:35no one had no business has an intrinsic

1:40:37right to the airwaves or really an

1:40:40intrinsic right to any thing that's you

1:40:45know that's just a that is just another

1:40:47argument right it's just capitalism

1:40:50isn't nature any more than anything else

1:40:53and so I mean my argument in seattle is

1:40:57we need a municipal broadband the city

1:40:58should the city should supply internet

1:41:01service the same way supplies

1:41:03electricity and water because internet

1:41:05service is becoming equivalent to those

1:41:07things in terms of that that it needs to

1:41:11be equally provided to every which

1:41:12sounds a little dramatic until you

1:41:14really think about it but if you really

1:41:16if you think about the case of comcast

1:41:17you can see those graphs on how I don't

1:41:20know if it's something that might be

1:41:21revenue enough subscribers but basically

1:41:23in this past month the number of comcast

1:41:26cable the cable cable revenue cable TV

1:41:30revenue has now been equaled by the

1:41:32broadband revenue so do you want to be

1:41:35in our case like that you can have

1:41:37comcast or you can use your phone

1:41:40basically that's it's comcast that

1:41:41that's really all there is in my

1:41:43neighborhood period

1:41:44yeah so I mean do we want to be subject

1:41:45to the to the the

1:41:47with the whims of that a company who's

1:41:50gonna be effective on a national level

1:41:51by different kinds of disruptions in

1:41:54service would you want your local of

1:41:55electricity to you know be insensitive

1:41:58to what's happening and all these other

1:41:59places that might and if the company is

1:42:01running at something has a terrible time

1:42:02in the Northeast so now your service

1:42:04goes bad or something like that I think

1:42:05you want to in October sort of like

1:42:07firewall that service that is now it's

1:42:10become so much more than just a fun way

1:42:12to put people on facebook it's how

1:42:14people conduct their business right it

1:42:16is i mean it's it's absolutely a

1:42:17necessity for rich and poor and the

1:42:19poorest person in seattle is still going

1:42:21to have to log onto the internet to how

1:42:24do you get off its I mean how do you how

1:42:26do you do apply for jobs how to do any

1:42:28of that stuff

1:42:29yeah at the more stuff that we put

1:42:30online the more it becomes a public need

1:42:33a public good and and I think you'll see

1:42:35it with drones to there's there's an

1:42:37argument that like what do you mean that

1:42:39you know I invented this technology

1:42:40drones and then five years from now when

1:42:44our skies are full of unregulated drone

1:42:47traffic your we're going to have to

1:42:50recognize that it's a municipalities

1:42:52it's ultimately like government job to

1:42:56step in and say here are the regulations

1:42:57on drones and all of the drone

1:43:01entrepreneurs are going to scream bloody

1:43:03murder about it but if the drone of

1:43:06entrepreneurs are not regulated then we

1:43:08will be living in a in a Victorian

1:43:11environment

1:43:14except instead of coal smoke its drone

1:43:18noise as every you know as every

1:43:22different you know amazon's running

1:43:24their drones around and UPS has got

1:43:26their drones and and the city of

1:43:28Seattle's got their drones and the news

1:43:31camera drones and then all the private

1:43:33drones and it's just like wait a minute

1:43:35no no no that's not we're not just gonna

1:43:38it cannot be chaos

1:43:42it's like it so much like being able to

1:43:44ride your horse through somebody's yard

1:43:46yeah it's like I no no there has to be

1:43:48some boundaries for like where that's

1:43:49okay and that and and we're coming out

1:43:52of many many decades of lays a faire

1:43:55economics and many many decades of kind

1:43:58of like

1:43:59ratcheting back big the idea of what

1:44:01government does but ultimately

1:44:04government is there to protect us and to

1:44:07make collective decisions and as this

1:44:11and there's a reason that the tech world

1:44:14is libertarian it you know there's a

1:44:17reason that libertarianism is at the

1:44:18core of the tech world

1:44:20well at least of the entrepreneurial

1:44:21part of that the entrepreneurial part

1:44:23yeah um and the and the pushback there's

1:44:26all kinds of hippies making the code but

1:44:28for sure but if you want to be the first

1:44:30to market and get the funding and be the

1:44:32gorilla and you know the same way

1:44:34blu-ray beach HD like you know what my

1:44:36railroad my computer railroad to be the

1:44:38one that wins

1:44:38yeah and and what that's going to do i

1:44:40think is push us into a climate where

1:44:43there's a new brand there's a new

1:44:46understanding of the importance of

1:44:47government and the power of government

1:44:49and and technology is also going to

1:44:53reform government and make it better at

1:44:55what it does and and we're you know

1:44:59we're probably entering into a few

1:45:00decades of of real tussle between

1:45:05between company like tech companies and

1:45:11government as government seeks to assert

1:45:14that a lot of these technologies yes

1:45:17were developed in your laboratories but

1:45:19now they constitute a public good and

1:45:21now they need to they need to conform

1:45:24and and that's exciting

1:45:28it's very exciting because the prospect

1:45:30of autonomously driven electric cars

1:45:33that truly are that truly have a kind of

1:45:36equitability based in Brook baked into

1:45:39them like that is that's truly a social

1:45:43justice issue right people can finally

1:45:45move around without the owner's expense

1:45:50of maintaining and parking and and

1:45:54operating their jalopies I don't think

1:45:58that's what those folks have in mind

1:45:59no I don't think it is what they have in

1:46:01mind at all but that is really the

1:46:04exciting possibility of it and we need

1:46:08to ensure that that's how that that's

1:46:10how it rolls

1:46:11out because I you know I mean if you

1:46:15look at the if you look at the

1:46:16autonomously driven cars that are that

1:46:18are rolling out right now there's a

1:46:20mercedes-benz got one that's just like

1:46:22oh man this is really nice really luxury

1:46:26item these first cars that drive

1:46:29themselves but really in a very short

1:46:33amount of time we're going to realize i

1:46:35think as a group of people that their

1:46:36taxi caps that all of them are taxi caps

1:46:39and nobody's going to own their own one

1:46:42they're all going to be no I mean not to

1:46:44push the analogy but no more than you

1:46:45would own your own private train tracks

1:46:48exactly you don't owe you don't own your

1:46:50own Street you just you know it's it's

1:46:56all owned collectively part of value is

1:46:58that the streets connect with other

1:47:00streets and if you're a super rich dude

1:47:03and you only want to travel around in a

1:47:04super luxury version of of the

1:47:08autonomous car then sure man

1:47:10maybe you have one that's your special

1:47:13one that's great for you but 99% of us

1:47:16are going to be so grateful to never

1:47:18owned a car again

1:47:20I mean honestly the car driving right

1:47:22now and and the cars in my family what

1:47:24we're all talking about this in my

1:47:25family a lot and and the consensus is

1:47:28can we milk these cars until we don't

1:47:33need them and that's that's totally on

1:47:34my mind we have a leased car right now

1:47:36and I i would love for it to be the last

1:47:38Carwyn yeah and and i think we're

1:47:40looking at

1:47:41I mean when I Drive by a car lot right

1:47:42now I'm like these are the last of these

1:47:44or you know there they'll keep making

1:47:47them but but people applied that are

1:47:50like it's going to vary so much by area

1:47:52though because for example

1:47:54ok like two places i've just been

1:47:55recently Boston providence portland I

1:48:03mean boy the needs of those cities can

1:48:05be served in such different ways like

1:48:08the idea of not having a car is a

1:48:11Providence is its mental like you you

1:48:13it's like you know it's maybe not as

1:48:15much as in Florida in Florida is

1:48:17completely mental like you have to have

1:48:19a car period that's the way the whole

1:48:20state is set up whereas here I mean I

1:48:23will

1:48:23the reason we did this my wife needs it

1:48:25to get to work in an efficient way to

1:48:26still have a life but boy I we were

1:48:29right on the bubble

1:48:30I mean we you know if you suck it up a

1:48:32little bit you can make it with public

1:48:33transit and a little bit of lyft and

1:48:34uber but it's it's not it's not there

1:48:37yet but i think it may be way closer

1:48:39than a lot of people you know in a place

1:48:41like Florida or you know Missouri maybe

1:48:43it's coming some places faster than a

1:48:46lot of people realize really i mean san

1:48:49francisco and seattle and portland will

1:48:51be in la will be the first places

1:48:54well maybe for example since I was just

1:48:55going to mention this that I I should

1:48:57track down my reference on this but you

1:48:59know we have a huge problem in san

1:49:00francisco i think it's problem of people

1:49:02basically it's very easy i don't know if

1:49:05it's money or its influence or it's just

1:49:06lying but it's not that hard to get a

1:49:10disabled permit alright in san francisco

1:49:13at which means a you get to park where

1:49:15you want and be you don't have to pay

1:49:17for parking

1:49:18you can park in a meter space with a

1:49:19disabled tech are the people who need

1:49:21those absolutely but the one count i

1:49:24heard is that's there's something like

1:49:26twice as many disabled permits as there

1:49:28are extant metered spaces in San

1:49:30Francisco

1:49:31wow I mean how does that scale up I mean

1:49:33there's so much wrong with that I don't

1:49:35even know where to begin but like that

1:49:36it doesn't add up

1:49:38I mean if it's it's sort of like you

1:49:39said with the like the train between LA

1:49:41and San Francisco like what are your

1:49:42options drive for six to eight hours

1:49:44yeah you can you can take a flight but

1:49:47you end up spending more time in

1:49:48airports and you do in the sky

1:49:49yeah it's completely inefficient when

1:49:52really there's there's these two places

1:49:53here the solution

1:49:54these are two cities that people want to

1:49:55get get from one to the other pretty

1:49:57often more so than other cities is it as

1:50:00fast can you get to burbank that fast

1:50:01no but once you get to LA you go to

1:50:03burbank you'll be good that smile can be

1:50:05accomplished lots of different ways we

1:50:06don't need a train between every city

1:50:08but like there's somewhere like a

1:50:09no-brainer and I feel like I feel like

1:50:11all of this is late-stage capitalism

1:50:14right if you zoom out just a little bit

1:50:18and say okay let's not presume that

1:50:20capitalism as currently practiced is a

1:50:24natural system that that God imposed

1:50:29upon its just you know what it's a

1:50:31thought technology let's just assume for

1:50:33a minute yeah we know is really we know

1:50:35it really is but let's act

1:50:37it's not for just a second yeah let's

1:50:38zoom out and see it for what it is which

1:50:42is at an overlay it's an attempt to

1:50:45resolve a problem with a system and now

1:50:50you can see all of the ways that it is

1:50:52currently failing it is failing to solve

1:50:57the problem of getting from San

1:50:58Francisco to LA for instance that is a

1:51:00problem and it is a problem that

1:51:03technology's there are a lot of

1:51:05technologies we could employ but

1:51:08currently the technologies and the

1:51:10regulatory environment and our concept

1:51:13of private property and the and all that

1:51:16stuff working together is making it very

1:51:19very increasingly difficult not easier

1:51:23it is harder to get from San Francisco

1:51:24to LA now than it was in 1964 because

1:51:30imagine if you'd said that the people

1:51:31back then i can read a bunch era if

1:51:32you'd said it's actually going to take

1:51:34longer and be more resource intensive

1:51:35like all of the highways that we just

1:51:39completed here here we are nineteen

1:51:40sixty all of these highways that we just

1:51:42completed that make it easy to get from

1:51:44place to place and these brand new jet

1:51:45airplanes that are allowing us to get

1:51:47from place to place

1:51:48let me give you a little glimpse of 2015

1:51:51the highways will be exactly the same

1:51:53and the airplanes will be exactly the

1:51:56same except there will be hundreds of

1:52:00thousands of more people using them

1:52:02we're not going to be using the planes

1:52:03you invented this year we're going to be

1:52:05using planes you invent we're gonna

1:52:06still be using the 757 Yeah Yeah Yeah

1:52:08right like like the the brand-new

1:52:11playing the top-of-the-line jet airplane

1:52:13of 2015 is a minor series of minor

1:52:18improvements over this plantation as

1:52:20Eastern in pain points while you can and

1:52:22you know and the highways to and the

1:52:25internal like you could drive your 1959

1:52:28Chevy from San Francisco to LA in 1959

1:52:32and and now and it would take you longer

1:52:34now it would be worse even if the car

1:52:36was pristine and so if you zoom out a

1:52:39little bit and you say ok let's start

1:52:41thinking a little bit bigger and say

1:52:43capitalism is gross okay fine it's great

1:52:47everybody calm down it's fine i'm not a

1:52:48communist I'm not trying to take away

1:52:50your

1:52:50fuckin house I don't want to make a

1:52:52doctor zhivago apartment out of your out

1:52:55of your family home just hush-hush but

1:52:59can we can we step back and say

1:53:02capitalism is an idea it's a thought

1:53:03technology and a lot of irregular a lot

1:53:06of the government regulation we have

1:53:07that is also badly designed is badly

1:53:11designed in conjunction with

1:53:13capitalistic problems like the the

1:53:16regulation responded to the capitalism

1:53:19and the capitalism response to the

1:53:21regulations and that's an unholy

1:53:22relationship and like let's zoom out a

1:53:25little bit and just start to think about

1:53:27some of this stuff a little bit more

1:53:29calmly and purposefully and imagine what

1:53:35a better system we could make with some

1:53:38minor modifications and some of that is

1:53:40like some of that is we have to put caps

1:53:44on how much people can make we really do

1:53:47you can't just invent an app that you

1:53:52can't just invent angry birds and become

1:53:54a billionaire I don't care i understand

1:53:58how it works

1:53:59I understand that you write angry birds

1:54:01and it becomes a smash and then you're

1:54:03cutting you sell your company for a

1:54:05billion dollars but you zoom out a

1:54:08little bit and you realize that's busted

1:54:11that's busted angry birds is great it's

1:54:14fine but it is it isn't worth a billion

1:54:17dollars of our collective resources we

1:54:21should not pay that to you and the fact

1:54:25that we do is crazy and so there has to

1:54:27be some kind of sense of of of

1:54:35equitability by and I don't just mean

1:54:38like a guaranteed universal income but

1:54:41just a sense of like what is your actual

1:54:43contribution what is what what what does

1:54:46this really do and what is this really

1:54:48worth in there and and take this like

1:54:50Wall Street a casino mentality and see

1:54:56it for what it is and and recognize that

1:54:58it doesn't help us

1:55:00and the idea and the argument that that

1:55:02money that the money orgy is the best

1:55:08and most efficient way of directing

1:55:10resources to innovation and directing

1:55:13resources to you know to experimentation

1:55:17and and and that's how you know the

1:55:20money follows at the success and

1:55:22generates success

1:55:24it's just like no no that's crazy that's

1:55:26crazy

1:55:28it's create we are living in a crazy

1:55:30world and we do have the brains and we

1:55:34have the knowledge we have the data we

1:55:36have the instruments to measure how

1:55:39crazy it is and to see it and do better

1:55:43and to do better regulate tomorrow i

1:55:50guess i'm running for public office

1:55:53oh you're kidding yeah tomorrow is

1:55:55election day