Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 158: "My Citadel Is Irrelevant"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this very special clothes and emotions

0:00:02edition of rock on the line is brought

0:00:04to you exclusively by need need is a

0:00:06curated retailer and lifestyle

0:00:08publication for men to learn more about

0:00:10needs just released volume 2.7

0:00:12collection

0:00:13please visit need edition com

0:00:21hello I jaan hai Berlin how's it going

0:00:26good although i just looked down and

0:00:28noticed that i have a 'shmock it's on my

0:00:30pants are no way

0:00:32yeah i got all the way down here sat

0:00:34down feeling good feeling strong and

0:00:36then schmutz on the pan our crime EP 10

0:00:38mm you know you because you're sure

0:00:41you're sure officer studio HQ no hmm you

0:00:45should probably get this happens to lots

0:00:47of like rich famous guys you should get

0:00:49a rack of clothes that you can have

0:00:51around you know maybe after if you have

0:00:53a closet there but yeah i'm thinking you

0:00:54need to start having a couple shirts

0:00:55today and maybe some chemistry pants at

0:00:57the office I do you know I I don't have

0:00:59a closet but i do have clothes here left

0:01:02over from the time period when I

0:01:05imagined that I would start of like a

0:01:08thriving ebay company

0:01:13mhm where the the thing that the ebay

0:01:17company sold was my old clothes so i

0:01:20have a bunch of stuff i have i'm looking

0:01:22right now at that I think a tangerine

0:01:25colored linen sport coat and a pair of

0:01:29heavy wall hunting pants that it would

0:01:33have to be 20 below zero and you would

0:01:35have to be spending a night outside to

0:01:37wear

0:01:39that's what that's what my iphone oh

0:01:41there's a corduroy vest so so I Corey

0:01:45best I could dress myself I could wear a

0:01:49John Roderick for City Council t-shirt

0:01:51the hunting pants it's just cute you

0:01:54look like Ignatius roughly exactly like

0:01:57nature's all my valves

0:01:59oh my plural Val anyway that's where I'm

0:02:04at I mean I can't talk about like talked

0:02:08about like needing to be ironed and I

0:02:11need to be ironed and spot pressed em

0:02:13and spot dabbed you know the thing is

0:02:16you know you kind of this eid a thing

0:02:18has been a presence in your life on and

0:02:21off it sounds like the last few years

0:02:22like it's always comes in it goes out

0:02:24like you think about like findings on

0:02:25ebay think about putting things on ebay

0:02:26i'm still very interested in an idea for

0:02:30a few years ago about you

0:02:31curating some kind of museum of your

0:02:32life but like it's me

0:02:34because like you go to the store and you

0:02:36see all those tiny little clothes don't

0:02:38fit you

0:02:39it's like somewhere out there i don't

0:02:40see the doppelganger but it would be

0:02:42great if you could find like a few guys

0:02:44who was calling bears let's see if you

0:02:46can find a few guys like you

0:02:48they have your interests where you could

0:02:49like do things like swap clothes as part

0:02:51of it is that you're a tall guy like

0:02:53you're a big fella

0:02:54yeah you know yeah you were if you were

0:02:56like if you know if you were like a

0:02:57little guy you could you could probably

0:03:00swap clothes with more other guys but

0:03:01like you need to find there should be

0:03:03some kind of a matching service for

0:03:05people based on interest and you know

0:03:07what's the word I'm looking for you know

0:03:10yeah shape yeah shape right i mean i

0:03:13think that there are enough just based

0:03:15on the touring that I've done and the

0:03:18traveling and the number of people that

0:03:21come up with up to be in airports and

0:03:23other places and say mr. Roderick i am

0:03:29guessing that out there are a large

0:03:31number of my people who are interested

0:03:34in the things that I make who also are

0:03:36my size and shape and I that and so the

0:03:40interest in having ebay store was mostly

0:03:42to just take these clothes and deliver

0:03:44them to a group that was standing there

0:03:46with a big catcher's mitt already just

0:03:49waiting for the used hunting pants

0:03:51thinking to themselves I want used

0:03:55hunting pants and can't find them

0:03:56anywhere and John Roderick has something

0:03:59he's my size and we share a anesthetic

0:04:02you know what it's not bespoke it's me

0:04:05spoke em think that's the answer that's

0:04:07very big smoke

0:04:08whoa thats nice bespoke it's sort of

0:04:10like it's like a dating service but for

0:04:12shape-based pairings are not based on

0:04:15interest

0:04:16well but you know there's there's

0:04:17something there's something to this that

0:04:19that gets at the heart of something else

0:04:22as all things on our program

0:04:23mhm where you know your natural

0:04:26inclination when you think about like I

0:04:28would like to curate a store of my

0:04:30former belongings is to your inclination

0:04:33is to look at that desire that impulse

0:04:36and say that is narcissistic you know to

0:04:38to reduce it to its basis like you are

0:04:41an egotist I'm talking now to the

0:04:44imaginary me you are an egotist and this

0:04:46is narcissism

0:04:48in its in it and it's but like most

0:04:51reduced form you actually want to take

0:04:53your things and put them up on the

0:04:55Internet as though they are valuable but

0:05:00you know the desire to like curate your

0:05:04desire to have a curated life is one

0:05:07thing but the desire to have a curated

0:05:09history of years of your life and of

0:05:13yourself is a different impulse and I

0:05:15and in a tangle with it all the time you

0:05:18know like four years I i was so i was so

0:05:22pleased when I found my father's clothes

0:05:25from the sixties and fifties and I found

0:05:29them in the eighties a long time after

0:05:32my dad had stopped being interested in

0:05:33them he couldn't wear them anymore and

0:05:36they you know and he was not like a

0:05:39trendy guy but but they were dated suits

0:05:42you know and and I found these things

0:05:46and they the only reason they were there

0:05:47and the only reason that they an enemy

0:05:49that they were the they were the

0:05:51sourdough starter mix of my whole

0:05:55fashion sense

0:05:57my dad's fifties suits hanging in his

0:06:00closet and so my whole life I've

0:06:02imagined that because I because i had

0:06:05that experience I was aware of it and I

0:06:07was saving things in order that my

0:06:11future child son or daughter would

0:06:17discover this this starter kit again

0:06:21this sourdough and that it would be

0:06:24useful to them but I don't know how much

0:06:28me discovering that you know how much of

0:06:31it how much of the fact that my dad just

0:06:33absolutely left that stuff around

0:06:35because he never got around to throwing

0:06:37it away

0:06:38how much of that but but but I mean I

0:06:41was aware of my dad's history i put on

0:06:44those clothes conscious of the fact that

0:06:46these were the suits he wore during the

0:06:48Kennedy administration I mean I only

0:06:50tell me I wasn't blind to that but he

0:06:53didn't keep them for me he just kept

0:06:55them because yeah and so I've been

0:06:58keeping stuff my whole life thinking

0:07:00that one day I would

0:07:01seed you know it would it would

0:07:03regenerate that that excitement and that

0:07:06like putting on your dad's clothes you

0:07:10know like the spoon song your dad's

0:07:12fitted shirt

0:07:14uh-huh um it's so it sits there scoffs

0:07:17is really got me thinking there's so

0:07:19many different levels to this i mean

0:07:21only you know the the anecdote I have to

0:07:23share as you know my dad died when I was

0:07:25really young and I discovered over time

0:07:27like little caches of his clothes and he

0:07:30was a little taller than me and a little

0:07:31skinnier than me but uh i mean i still

0:07:34have a jacket of his from the early

0:07:36seventies that I we're increasingly less

0:07:38because I i do want to keep it but like

0:07:40you're on something so super interesting

0:07:42i don't want me to make this all

0:07:43intellectual because something very

0:07:44emotional to what you're describing but

0:07:46like when you first when i made the

0:07:47crack haha like you know what you like

0:07:49some random july kind of project we open

0:07:51a shop and saw your own clothes and be

0:07:53like a cute little like Portlandia

0:07:54sketch but like that's the thing is that

0:07:56there's there's such a distinction

0:07:57between like how you would choose to

0:07:59frame that to the public like the way

0:08:01you afraid that to the public and I'm

0:08:02taking this kind of seriously because

0:08:04what is art anyway you know aren't a lot

0:08:07of ways it has to be kind of

0:08:08narcissistic it has to be a soft money

0:08:10ven diagram on tumblr the day were

0:08:11somebody saying like you know the nexus

0:08:13of total narcissism and complete

0:08:16self-doubt is where you find her

0:08:17haha yes it's kind of true but like

0:08:21there's one way of saying like okay

0:08:22here's all these objects from my life

0:08:24that I'm putting a frame around in order

0:08:27to highlight how pointless and ephemeral

0:08:30they are and there's another way of

0:08:31saying well I putting a kind of frame

0:08:33around it to show like how important was

0:08:34how emblematic it was how this is this

0:08:36strange connective tissue between

0:08:38generations like you know in the same

0:08:41way you use its it's considered very

0:08:42normal to say like oh you know i love

0:08:44the beatles because my parents loved the

0:08:45Beatles it's another kind of thing to go

0:08:47like who knows what kind of

0:08:47sensibilities i developed based on

0:08:49wearing the suit you know and how much

0:08:51like I I you know you know it's just

0:08:53then there's the whole aspect of like a

0:08:55little kid like you never know what your

0:08:56little kid wants a question answered

0:08:58about like finding like a cigar box full

0:09:00of old stuff is like so many answers to

0:09:03questions you didn't know existed

0:09:05yeah absolutely and you know and like

0:09:08there are lots of people who would be

0:09:11interested in

0:09:13seeing the original handwritten lyrics

0:09:17to scared straight right i mean there's

0:09:20a lot of fans that like that song when

0:09:22it because when they become aware that

0:09:24there is a paper that has the original

0:09:26handwritten lyrics to that song that I

0:09:28was scribbling out as i was writing it

0:09:31in the studio there there are plenty of

0:09:33people that go

0:09:34oh I would be interested in seeing that

0:09:36and then there's a much smaller group of

0:09:38people that would say i would be

0:09:39interested in owning that right i mean

0:09:41when you think about the original

0:09:43handwritten lyrics to like a rolling

0:09:45stone there are millions of people who

0:09:48would be interested in seeing it and

0:09:49probably you know many tens of thousands

0:09:52who would bid on it if it came up for

0:09:54auction quite if you know it's a much

0:09:56smaller group of people that care about

0:09:58scared strange but for me the the

0:10:03handwritten lyrics of like a rolling

0:10:05stone are interesting to look at but i

0:10:09would be much more interested in the

0:10:10shirt that Dylan was wearing when he

0:10:12wrote it

0:10:13uh-huh and dylan probably doesn't

0:10:18remember the shirt he was wearing and

0:10:20doesn't ever didn't think that way when

0:10:23he see so like a peculiarly but so

0:10:26uniquely wired to find something like

0:10:29that like kind of repulsive

0:10:31yeah remember DJ weathermen the guy that

0:10:33used to go through his trash and write

0:10:34about it like he's Bob Dylan particular

0:10:37is particularly wire to go like I'm like

0:10:39I'm sure way to care about the song let

0:10:40alone my shirt but whatever he would he

0:10:42would burn it all or at least he would

0:10:44burn it as be just so you can have it

0:10:46yeah right and at them and the big

0:10:48question of dylanologists is like it

0:10:51yes he yes he finds that repulsive but

0:10:53also that is his persona you know like

0:10:55he's an acting finding that repulsive to

0:10:58at the same time

0:10:59ok but maybe you know i think i think

0:11:02you're right i mean guide it's the

0:11:04criminology around that guy's just

0:11:05anywhere right are getting when you

0:11:07think about but you think about him

0:11:09Dylan constructing his personality out

0:11:11of Lego blocks and at which you know at

0:11:14which point he grabbed the block that

0:11:15was like a the kill your idols and and

0:11:20set it there is one of the foundational

0:11:2110 who knows but um but

0:11:26there's something about me that I

0:11:29remember pretty much like I know the

0:11:32shirt I was wearing and there's maybe

0:11:36only a handful of people that are

0:11:38interested in that connection like

0:11:41that's the shirts that I was wearing at

0:11:46that point and I got that shirt from my

0:11:48dad and that's the shirt I was wearing

0:11:51when i when i wrote scared straight and

0:11:53that through line is meet you know maybe

0:11:57we'll never be interesting to my kids or

0:11:59my grandkids but it is interesting to

0:12:02somebody and that connection is

0:12:06interesting to me and I don't know I I

0:12:09can't separate out like I think I've got

0:12:11it i think i got it and this is this is

0:12:13the inevitable party like we you know we

0:12:15joke forever about the dumb stuff we say

0:12:16for our kids that they want because

0:12:18again it's the the part that's so

0:12:19interesting is like you know what you

0:12:21care about and you know what you found

0:12:23interesting but you know that's what you

0:12:26found interesting about that particular

0:12:27person or you know obviously the clothes

0:12:30have become like kind of a touchdown for

0:12:31you I guess what I'm saying is like

0:12:32there's no we didn't know what your

0:12:33kid's gonna care about right that you

0:12:35know the idea of saving a shirt for

0:12:36somebody is pretty weird like to to

0:12:38anybody who's not into in the same way

0:12:40as you don't mean it

0:12:42yeah like but there still is part of me

0:12:44that's like it this is this is not a

0:12:46narcissistic but there's a part that

0:12:47goes like i know that if i try to save

0:12:49everything i'm going to be a garbage man

0:12:51i'm not going to be a curator I'm not

0:12:53gonna be a collector I'm going I'm going

0:12:55to be a kind of emotionally damaged

0:12:57order like I don't know what special

0:12:58things to keep but the idea of this

0:13:00particular thing going into the trash

0:13:02because you know any other normal person

0:13:04would look at 15 items in a room is like

0:13:06the end of indiana jones and the and the

0:13:08you know 30 the engines but we gotta

0:13:10pick out the right holy grail you know

0:13:12the right we will raise the real Grail

0:13:14yeah we like up with the carpet nobody

0:13:16know exactly that's the kind of

0:13:18carpenters cup that's such a great line

0:13:19but you know nobody could look at all

0:13:21these shirts and go obviously this is

0:13:23the important one

0:13:25you know what I mean it is completely in

0:13:27intrinsic in some ways there's nothing

0:13:29extrinsic or somebody go that's the

0:13:31nicest one that's the one of the best

0:13:33condition right it's a great thing is

0:13:35getting really weigh on me now like of

0:13:37all of these dumb

0:13:38you know hardback books like who's to

0:13:41know which one of these is the one that

0:13:43made a huge difference they're all just

0:13:44a big pile of paper house how's anybody

0:13:45gonna care about that the same way that

0:13:47I did but you know so how do you make

0:13:49this decision it's hard to know what to

0:13:50keep on that rack it's hard to know

0:13:51first of all not sure who would ever

0:13:52want a quarter or invest in your size

0:13:54but I guess you did at some point

0:13:56can you pull off a vest this episode of

0:13:59Roderick online is brought to you by

0:14:00need need is a curated retailer and

0:14:03lifestyle publication for men each month

0:14:06need curates and sells a limited

0:14:08selection of products clothing

0:14:09literature furniture and otherwise for

0:14:12the discerning gentlemen rather than

0:14:14offering an overwhelming amount of

0:14:15selection need only sells 10 to 15

0:14:18exclusive products per month while also

0:14:20offering an ongoing array of essentials

0:14:22need just launched its latest collection

0:14:25vol 2.7 featuring clothing and

0:14:27accessories ideally suited for the

0:14:29summer months

0:14:30there are no subscriptions services

0:14:32boxes stylus or other such gimmicks

0:14:35instead you just come to need once a

0:14:37month see if there's anything that you

0:14:38like and choose to buy leave or just

0:14:41hang out to read some of the wonderful

0:14:42feature articles for Roderick online

0:14:45listeners need are offering twenty

0:14:46percent off anything on the site

0:14:48including their brand-new collection and

0:14:50fathers day gift God just use the

0:14:52entirely appropriate and bespoke offer

0:14:54code clothes at checkout visit need

0:14:57edition calm and redeem the code during

0:15:00last stage check out and as always

0:15:01please do feel free to say hello to our

0:15:03friend Matt Alexander via the live chat

0:15:06our thanks to need for making the world

0:15:07so much more handsome and for supporting

0:15:09Roderick on the lines

0:15:11morning blowing okay the internet just

0:15:19went away and now we're back i don't

0:15:21know how long we were both each just

0:15:22talking there i'm pretty sure i'd like

0:15:26to thank comcast for all their support

0:15:29i'm pretty sure that i was talking for a

0:15:30full minute and a half i was looking for

0:15:32at least two minutes yeah and then I was

0:15:34like Merlin right you haven't said

0:15:35anything you haven't granted and nothing

0:15:38I was afraid unless let's praise out of

0:15:40my mouth was can you pull off a vest

0:15:43can you pull off a vest and then there

0:15:44was silence and I couldn't reconnect and

0:15:46i thought i offended you

0:15:47haha you know it's a good question i

0:15:50have i have several vests but i have

0:15:54never I don't I can't think of a time I

0:15:57ever walked out of the house wearing

0:15:58only a vest it's you know it seems like

0:16:00it's kind of up there with the cowboy

0:16:01hat and the leather pants m in the like

0:16:05wow you know a good if you can do it

0:16:07good on you yeah right that's right you

0:16:09have to be if I think you have to be a

0:16:10thin guy i think all those things it

0:16:12helps if you're a lanky cowboy type

0:16:14yeah if you're wearing if you're a

0:16:15heavyset guy then your best is I think

0:16:18properly a waistcoat but you know what i

0:16:21was talking about that whole time was

0:16:23that I have sitting on a shelf in my

0:16:26living room i have a broken speedometer

0:16:28have broken speedometer from an

0:16:32automobile a broken speedometer from the

0:16:34motorcycle that i crashed in a Kansas

0:16:36field in 1986 and I was so devastated

0:16:42because this motorcycle represented

0:16:44basically my only asset in the world

0:16:48it was a it was only a

0:16:50five-hundred-dollar motorcyclist honda

0:16:521981 honda cb650 and erected in this

0:16:56field and it was a total wreck but I had

0:16:59it I had a friend come put it in the

0:17:02back of his pickup truck and drive it to

0:17:03denver and I took it to a place called

0:17:05denver used motorcycle parts or dump and

0:17:11I was like you gotta give me some money

0:17:12for this bike it's the only thing I own

0:17:14in the world I don't have anything else

0:17:15and I was like it's 81 honda it's not

0:17:18worth any money i was like come on

0:17:20something anything in the guy was like

0:17:21twenty bucks

0:17:23and I was like really what this was the

0:17:26first time in my life I had ever

0:17:28well obviously the first time I never

0:17:30crashed a motorcycle in Kansas field and

0:17:32I didn't know how to deal with it every

0:17:34every boy has his first time

0:17:36yeah and so the guy wrenches off the

0:17:39broken speedometer which is broken and

0:17:41still stuck at 80 miles and that you

0:17:45know the pits like broken like like

0:17:47cracked he goes here's a souvenir and i

0:17:53still have it still is it still second

0:17:5580 miles per hour feel stuck at 80 miles

0:17:57an hour and I you know and it's like

0:17:59what good is that to anybody you know

0:18:01what what possible good is that

0:18:05well okay but this locates the picking

0:18:06up on the thread and you know god damn

0:18:09comcast that whatever we're really

0:18:10getting somewhere with that arm cast

0:18:12like I think there's lots of little

0:18:13things I feel like you can tease out

0:18:16little distinctions that to me are very

0:18:17important

0:18:18I mean there's the things that we save

0:18:20and we know why and we know it's for

0:18:22ourselves and that's okay there's the

0:18:24things we say we're not really even sure

0:18:26why

0:18:27and we think it might be for us you know

0:18:29what i mean i think i think there's all

0:18:30kinds of different levels to this

0:18:32there's some stuff people save think

0:18:33about the classic sort of medals and

0:18:35trophies kind of thing right where it's

0:18:37about like you say that because you want

0:18:38to show the people that you've got you

0:18:40know you've got wounded in world war two

0:18:42or what-have-you somebody handed me a

0:18:44facebook challenge coin the other day

0:18:47they snuck out their hand and I was like

0:18:49oh hi nice to meet you like mr. red

0:18:52river and shake his hand and I feel this

0:18:54thing between us and I'm like oh god

0:18:56what the fuck I'm like oh it's a

0:18:57challenge coin i'm looking at the guy

0:18:59i'm trying to think what challenge coin

0:19:01could this guy possibly be handing me

0:19:03it's going to be amazing whatever it is

0:19:05and it's a facebook challenge coin

0:19:07nothing tracking your movement and he we

0:19:10had a look on his face that was justjust

0:19:12shire cat you know like you're gonna

0:19:14like this of facebook challenge going um

0:19:18and so the thing that I thought I've

0:19:21anyway the thing i found interesting

0:19:22about what we're getting at is this you

0:19:24know that are there are those

0:19:25distinctions like why am i saving this

0:19:28am i saving this for me to remember on

0:19:30my saving it for someone else to

0:19:31remember my saving this because i think

0:19:33it's going to be useful in a way that I

0:19:36understand

0:19:37could this be useful in a way that I

0:19:38don't understand you know because I

0:19:40think there's a continuum here or a

0:19:42spectrum if you were on the one end like

0:19:44if the only if you know it the like you

0:19:48know I don't be morose but like you know

0:19:50eight a deceased child's blanket like

0:19:53that might be something that you would

0:19:54want to keep like you get that but

0:19:56overhear your like you know I can't keep

0:19:58all the blankets I've ever had right

0:20:00well I like this like there's there is a

0:20:02continuum like there's this emotional

0:20:04continuum between like you know somebody

0:20:07who's incredibly emotionally healthy and

0:20:10has a understand why they're doing this

0:20:11downloads all the other end we're likely

0:20:13your you know it's like working

0:20:15yeah I don't feel it is a sign i do not

0:20:17feel that my keeping things is a sign of

0:20:20emotional health

0:20:21let's be quite frank about that right i

0:20:24think that can you say that across the

0:20:25board there's some things where it

0:20:26totally makes sense don't you imagine

0:20:28that that the most emotionally healthy

0:20:30doing right now is sitting somewhere in

0:20:34Big Sur and all he has it is the only

0:20:38thing has on is a vest and it's a board

0:20:42short and it is minimalist desk and he's

0:20:45just like whatever man but it don't like

0:20:47hang onto stuff man

0:20:49and then you know and then I'm sitting

0:20:50here you know in my in my hunting pants

0:20:53with a broken speedometer from 81 honda

0:20:56I think he's sounds healthier than me

0:20:58i'm not sure

0:21:00yeah I you know I guess so or some

0:21:03people are more emotionally raw or

0:21:06emotionally available or unavailable

0:21:07than others but I mean I ice

0:21:09I see it you know like in my family like

0:21:13my wife is way I don't even think of

0:21:16myself as being that into like the

0:21:18objects that I say I'm not like i can

0:21:20just have the whole boxes of stuff flood

0:21:22like I just right I would be okay oh

0:21:24that's a bummer but like I wouldn't I i

0:21:26also maybe that's partly because I know

0:21:28that I'm wrong enough that if I really

0:21:29thought about it I'd be sad forever but

0:21:31however one day one day I was about to

0:21:33take out the trash in the kitchen and I

0:21:35looked in the trash and if I just have

0:21:37to tell you my wife is she loves

0:21:39throwing things away even you know like

0:21:41I'm a purge guy sometimes i really want

0:21:43to push my wife is like day today she

0:21:44loves throwing things away or recycling

0:21:46but you know getting useless things out

0:21:48of her life and look in there

0:21:49as pair of shoes in there and I was like

0:21:52my heart sank and I i picked up this the

0:21:55this old gross pair of her shoes and

0:21:58held them up in the air and was like

0:22:00what are you doing she said there's a

0:22:02disgusting i have 19 years I said this

0:22:05is the shoes you were wearing when i met

0:22:06you

0:22:06yeah oh I might as well have said like

0:22:11this is the turn I made the morning

0:22:13after we met

0:22:14if one of the want to throw your wedding

0:22:15dress you better

0:22:17but like they were exactly what she they

0:22:21were like old shoes she did not want to

0:22:23wear anymore they were out of fashion

0:22:25they were they were dirty old groceries

0:22:27and she threw them away but like my

0:22:29first reaction of course because you

0:22:30know I'm so good at instantly making it

0:22:32about me

0:22:32you want to come to garbage but it's

0:22:37funny though because like sometimes my

0:22:38daughter and I will go like to get our

0:22:40scooters you know will notice walk by

0:22:42the trash and we'll go like what like

0:22:44discovered things in the trash and be

0:22:45like hey you either way this popsicle

0:22:48stick and then she'll go to shoot their

0:22:50way my popsicle stick

0:22:53well now let me ask you where you were

0:22:56you I i know there's a there's a term

0:22:58for this or a word for it even i'm not

0:23:00sure what it is but like I when I was a

0:23:02kid if if I took a banana banana off a

0:23:07bunch of bananas there was a part of me

0:23:09that felt sorry for the the other

0:23:12bananas

0:23:13uh-huh because i had chosen the one

0:23:15banana and I felt I felt like I was I

0:23:19had to comfort the remaining bananas

0:23:22that it wasn't about them

0:23:25it was just that i picked this one

0:23:28banana you know what I mean like either

0:23:29i feel so much emotion and always have

0:23:33from the time I was a little kid about

0:23:34inanimate objects

0:23:36I man right here and you know reduced to

0:23:38tears feeling sorry for a a chair with a

0:23:46broken leg or i mean i remember i used

0:23:49to have a flag that like one of those

0:23:52orange safety flags that they attached

0:23:57to the back of my bike

0:23:58so you could see me around corners or

0:24:01yeah that was a really big pennant a big

0:24:03penetrate a big orange Pentagon on upon

0:24:05a little of our flexible pole on the

0:24:07back of my bike and somehow I I crashed

0:24:10the bike and it and my penance ripped

0:24:13our and I was in consolidate all not

0:24:18because like because the pendant was

0:24:21less useful or because you know but

0:24:23because that because I felt sorry for

0:24:25the Penans and I've carried that into

0:24:29adulthood in a way that you know I don't

0:24:32now apologize to things that i use i

0:24:35don't feel like broken things I don't

0:24:38cry for broken things the same way but

0:24:41but objects do have like they have an

0:24:46emotional valence they do yes and and

0:24:49it's and it's very hard for me to you

0:24:52know in a way like throw things away

0:24:54that have that have served me well i

0:24:57guess because I want to honor their

0:25:00service

0:25:01okay I hate to admit it but I'm not

0:25:04nearly as much that way they used to be

0:25:05but i was so that way and I I think it's

0:25:08because i am and always have been a

0:25:10little broken inside and so I mean like

0:25:12the little here's the thing when i get

0:25:13back to the continuum I don't think

0:25:15there's that many examples of this you

0:25:16can come up with examples of this than

0:25:17almost anybody you know crying that your

0:25:20wife threw out an old pair of shoes not

0:25:22crying but like going hey yeah that's

0:25:23pretty weird

0:25:24this always sells shoes end up in the

0:25:26garbage yeah totally yes young i want

0:25:28you how many how many pairs of shoes

0:25:30will we save this becomes a question

0:25:32like what and how do we honor some how

0:25:34do we honor the shoes she doesn't know

0:25:36what it's weird

0:25:37yeah but now but like for example like

0:25:40there's all the obvious kinds of things

0:25:41like you know I i used to have a lot of

0:25:44attachment to stuffed animals were at

0:25:46plushies as they're now called my kid

0:25:48loves him now I think she got it i love

0:25:50my stuffed animals when I was a kid

0:25:5222 until I was like pretty old and like

0:25:54so stuff like seeing a stuffed animal on

0:25:57the street still makes me melancholy I

0:25:59think that's a pretty clear one right no

0:26:02matter how much no matter how many pork

0:26:03chops you jam in your mouth hole every

0:26:05month watching the first few minutes of

0:26:07babe home it will tug on your

0:26:08heartstrings and you go oh my god

0:26:09totally eating a pig

0:26:10there's all kinds of the

0:26:11as we're like things you are generally

0:26:13think of as an inert object you suddenly

0:26:15feel very emotional about for all kinds

0:26:17of reasons and so you know in but maybe

0:26:20you're right maybe it maybe does come

0:26:21down to be a little being a little bit

0:26:22you know broken inside

0:26:25in some ways yeah I used to isolate feel

0:26:27really bad for my feel positive we've

0:26:29had this conversation before but I used

0:26:31to feel bad i used to have feel bad for

0:26:33my clothes I used to like feel like if I

0:26:35didn't wear them often enough or like

0:26:37you know I didn't want my socks be

0:26:38separated and I didn't I didn't want I

0:26:41didn't want my shirt to get their

0:26:42feelings hurt i have about that very

0:26:43strongly absolutely and and and there is

0:26:46something I i got a Valentine one time

0:26:50in about third grade and the valentine i

0:26:56may have talked about this a long time

0:26:57ago with you but the Valentine was a

0:26:59little girl and she was crying and she

0:27:01was holding a flower and she'd obviously

0:27:05been playing the he loves me he loves me

0:27:08not

0:27:09game for plucking the pedals off the

0:27:12flour and she had plucked the pedals

0:27:15down to the last petal there was one

0:27:18petal remaining on her flower and it was

0:27:20clear from the narrative the of it the

0:27:23unwritten narrative of the Valentine

0:27:25that she had arrived at the last panel

0:27:27that the pedal was he loves me not

0:27:31and she could not pluck it and was

0:27:35crying holding the flower imagining

0:27:38imagining that she could go back in time

0:27:41imagining another world an alternate

0:27:43reality where the last petal was that he

0:27:46loves me and the Valentine was this

0:27:48little cartoon of a girl crying and and

0:27:51it said i will be so lonely if you

0:27:55aren't my valentine or something like

0:27:59that and all of this was that it was it

0:28:00wasn't explicit it was just in the

0:28:02drawing and has a third-grader I could I

0:28:05understood the story that it was that

0:28:07was being told and this valentine

0:28:10destroyed me and I and and I I openly

0:28:15cried at receiving and I don't remember

0:28:18who was from comic-con

0:28:19but I it was just you know it was one of

0:28:22those things like everybody in the class

0:28:23has to give everybody a Valentine

0:28:25situations but here this thing popped up

0:28:27in the newspaper somebody about a store

0:28:29ya popped up in a stack of Valentine's

0:28:31and the it was so fraud and and and i

0:28:35felt so acutely for this little cartoon

0:28:37girl that she had started out probably

0:28:40plucking these pedals full of excitement

0:28:43and hope and fun like he loves me he

0:28:45loves me not he loves me and then she

0:28:47and then it started to get darker as she

0:28:49was running out of pedals on this she

0:28:52got down to that last petal and she

0:28:54couldn't pluck it and I wanted and I

0:28:56wanted to do anything in the world to

0:28:58change this girl's life to change the

0:29:00story to change the reality to put an

0:29:02extra pedal on that flat fucking flower

0:29:05and I i would sit so I kept this

0:29:08valentine and I tucked it away and I

0:29:11would take it out sometimes and look at

0:29:13it like it was pornography because it

0:29:17could put me in this place of like

0:29:19emotional just absolute darkness you

0:29:24never get didn't diminish over time you

0:29:26know had that power and i would i would

0:29:28draw it sometimes I would sit and end

0:29:31and either trace it or actually do

0:29:32drawings of it on a separate piece of

0:29:34paper I guess trying to unlock it trying

0:29:38to unlock the story or or change it in

0:29:42some way and I so i think that i still

0:29:48have the valentine i think i may even

0:29:50still have some of the drawings i did of

0:29:52the Valentine God and I don't instead

0:29:56still sitting and thinking about it

0:29:58right now i can i can picture everything

0:30:00about it and i am and i still feel for

0:30:04that little girl haha

0:30:06and what's what's crazy is that I've

0:30:09only just started exposing my daughter

0:30:13to to media that is complicated right up

0:30:18until now it's you know all of her books

0:30:19and all the stuff that she's been

0:30:21exposed to is pretty much on the line

0:30:23ambiguous kids stuff

0:30:24yeah it's just like little apple boy

0:30:27puts the letter a on his apple basket

0:30:29but heat is good supper

0:30:31that's right little apple Boyd never

0:30:33complains about going to bed but he's so

0:30:35big but I've started you know I'm

0:30:38started introducing her to you know we

0:30:41watch Dumbo

0:30:42oh and i forgot i was like Dumbo the

0:30:47flying elephant

0:30:48oh my i was sat down and what had

0:30:50started watching tempo and I'm like

0:30:52Dumbo and sees a funny funny funny often

0:30:54but i often we just need self-confidence

0:30:56with the flappy ears at the flower and

0:30:59number on the trunk of sex look

0:31:01okay Dumbo is like it's like basically a

0:31:05it is full of a minute it's it's a it's

0:31:11basically the the story of precious the

0:31:16that whatever that movie was from a

0:31:18couple years ago however long the night

0:31:20with the name of the person in it

0:31:22yeah um based on sapphire or something

0:31:25yeah but that's right it's you know like

0:31:27Dumbo was born everyone rejects him

0:31:30because of his birth defect and his

0:31:32mother trying to defend him is a is

0:31:35taken away by the authorities and put in

0:31:37sale insane asylum dumbo is rejected by

0:31:40the tribe and his only friend is a

0:31:42wisecracking mouse he's surrounded by

0:31:45evil clowns he is he's forced into you

0:31:50know essentially like a is forced into

0:31:52being up like a freaking slideshow yeah

0:31:55right

0:31:56a professional freak and only in the

0:32:01only in the last minute of the film is

0:32:03there any redemption and it is when he

0:32:05discovers he can fly oh oh and then

0:32:07there's you know they're the like the

0:32:08the tribe of racist the crows are ready

0:32:13you know the crows themselves are racist

0:32:15but their portrayal is races

0:32:16yeah and and so i'm watching this movie

0:32:20and she is just she's like yelling at

0:32:25the screen like no Jake can take depose

0:32:29mom and she's just like so her emotional

0:32:34response to this stuff is like so

0:32:40intense and I'm sitting there I'm like

0:32:42I'd do i right

0:32:44right do I turn this off because you

0:32:46don't want you don't mean the thing is

0:32:47though you get every kid sits with that

0:32:49and they turn out mostly ok but like you

0:32:51just hate seeing your kid like now

0:32:52you're sitting there you you put your

0:32:54child in this situation are you positive

0:32:56this monstrosity I much i mentioned babe

0:32:59we made about three minutes into babe

0:33:01and then she started sitting upright now

0:33:02I know what that means when she was

0:33:03little she would always say this is

0:33:04boring right this is this is boring that

0:33:07means like this is horrifying me please

0:33:08take off and started to kind of look

0:33:10down a little bit and I could tell me

0:33:11about 30 seconds from tears like what am

0:33:13i doing what if I done and so she really

0:33:15she feels it too huh you feel stuff

0:33:17super hard everything is I was talking

0:33:19to my mom about it and dumbo came out in

0:33:221941 yes for early 45 40 41 and my mom

0:33:29was six years old in nineteen forty six

0:33:32or seven years old she was like oh i

0:33:34remember going to see Dumbo in the

0:33:36theater when it came out I was like wow

0:33:40how did you feel about it and she said

0:33:43oh I mean it was you know kids movie

0:33:47like all those movies and as I started

0:33:50to unpack it I realized that the

0:33:52experiences that dumbo was having in

0:33:56comparison to be experiences my mom was

0:33:58actually having dinner in her own

0:34:00real-life right

0:34:01dumbo was some light-hearted shit to her

0:34:03right you know like like my mom was

0:34:07actually you know was was actually an

0:34:10orphan laboring on a farm right and

0:34:16dumbo was you know at least getting a

0:34:18fun farm that one don't like it when you

0:34:20say four people going to go dude like

0:34:23turkey in the straw kind of think it's

0:34:24like no really a million more like me

0:34:25think coal miners that land right a farm

0:34:28where you where there was an outhouse

0:34:30and we're grinding poverty the way you

0:34:33drive your clothes in winter was that

0:34:35you hung them up outside they froze and

0:34:38then you beat them with a rod until the

0:34:41ice broke off of them and that was how

0:34:43that and then took them inside and

0:34:44ironed them dry so my mom was like oh I

0:34:48you know dumbo shrugged it off and I was

0:34:51like oh my god a so of course I didn't

0:34:54turn it off

0:34:55and I you know and I held my little girl

0:34:58and said you know like and talk to her

0:35:01about it you know I didn't like say it's

0:35:03ok it's ok I I said he had Dumbo's mom

0:35:06is really in trouble she was trying to

0:35:08help him wasn't she

0:35:09and you know and we walk we talked our

0:35:12way through the movie and I was like oh

0:35:15jesus that was emotionally fraught for

0:35:17me

0:35:17oh yeah i think it would have been if I

0:35:19had just watched by myself really like

0:35:22about what a terrible time dumbo had and

0:35:24i'm not sure what I watched it in 1972

0:35:28what their I mean it was dumbo had a

0:35:32worse time that I did but you know

0:35:33jumbled and ER like on ir near the top

0:35:37of the list of like they're canonical I

0:35:39mean in terms of like my disney hates

0:35:41parents and consequently kind of hates

0:35:43kids like we are going to make you feel

0:35:45so low and here's the thing these disney

0:35:48movies this is the thing to keep in mind

0:35:49is you know what you're talking about

0:35:51like you know people with certain

0:35:52generation they all Disney movies

0:35:53they're like these fun things and

0:35:55there's lots of a wackadoodle animals

0:35:57singing songs and stuff like that

0:35:58I've been thinking about this a lot

0:35:59lately is the what is it that really

0:36:01sticks with you about a movie and the

0:36:04thing is some people might really they

0:36:06might remember like Mary Poppins for

0:36:09let's go fly a kite

0:36:10I remember it for the woman feeding the

0:36:12birds oh yeah and it's well experienced

0:36:15very it's so depressing and like in like

0:36:18an in these cases these movies were

0:36:19talking about like it may have you like

0:36:21Robin Hood and like putting children in

0:36:23jail

0:36:24it's like how you explain a little bit

0:36:26by these children are in jail

0:36:27well it's friendly and is the princess

0:36:30corrupt and he's a lion man and it's

0:36:32like but what you really remember that

0:36:33there are these just stuff that I think

0:36:36the impact that sticks with least mean a

0:36:38lot of people i know was the incredibly

0:36:39intensely sad stuff and then in fact

0:36:42when you want to have this kind of

0:36:43tacked on happy ending it kind of makes

0:36:45it worse because you're like who like

0:36:48there's this thing I don't understand

0:36:50i'm kind of pushing this bruise now

0:36:51about how sad this made me and all this

0:36:53all this kind of you know baggy pants

0:36:56humor at the end is not making me feel

0:36:58better but it feels it feels really

0:37:00false

0:37:01it feels really fake and emotional

0:37:04impact you're trying to create it's like

0:37:05everything turns out great the parents

0:37:06are back yeah

0:37:07or whatever it's like it's so it doesn't

0:37:10not only doesn't offset how sad you were

0:37:12at the end of the first or second act

0:37:14but like how it makes it kind of you

0:37:16know I'm saying it kind of makes it

0:37:17worse that like you're trying to like

0:37:19make me happy now when I know the

0:37:21profundity of that sadness that I felt

0:37:23is so much more important than seeing

0:37:25the end of Technicolor production or

0:37:27whatever

0:37:28yeah the the end of Dumbo I'm not sure I

0:37:30ever

0:37:31I mean I haven't watched any advil and

0:37:33do not remember well he I mean that

0:37:36device he flies and then he's the star

0:37:39and the last scene of the movie is that

0:37:42dumbo has his own super cool art deco

0:37:47styled train car the tacked onto the end

0:37:51of the Train it's very modern and

0:37:54there's a balcony where his mother is

0:37:57sitting watching him fly high above the

0:38:01train i think maybe the crows are there

0:38:03they're all friends huh and but the

0:38:06thing is like watching it now I did very

0:38:09much have the experience of thinking

0:38:11Dumbo's mother is never gonna live that

0:38:13down

0:38:13she's never going to feel safe again and

0:38:15never again I mean if terry gilliam made

0:38:17an honest version of that it would all

0:38:19turn out to have been a dream what

0:38:20number was being tortured and was like

0:38:21dehydrated and I'm imagining it would be

0:38:23like you know flying flying with Jill

0:38:25through the air in Brazil no no no that

0:38:27didn't really happen

0:38:28you're just sitting there getting

0:38:29tortured by the guy from monty python

0:38:30it's all good yeah it was it was I mean

0:38:32it was the end of innocence but when you

0:38:35go back to the beginning of Dumbo when

0:38:37Dumbo's mother is waiting

0:38:39I mean Dumbo's mother is waiting for the

0:38:42stork to deliver her baby and everyone

0:38:44else in the circus has already had a

0:38:46baby and Dumbo's mother than the stork

0:38:50like was late or was it was a a stumble

0:38:53bomb and what they chose to pull punches

0:38:56about is so bananas like we don't talk

0:38:58about coitus but the fact that she might

0:39:00be barren and she's incredibly lonely

0:39:01front and center

0:39:03yeah and on and all the other elephants

0:39:05all of whom i might add have

0:39:07mid-atlantic accents are not that I'll

0:39:12speak like this

0:39:13yes they do wow she's Shelby a terrible

0:39:17matter about your uncle and they're all

0:39:21like

0:39:21already at the start of the movie you

0:39:23can tell that Dumbo's mother is a an

0:39:25outcast be maybe a little slow and none

0:39:34of the other like none of the other sort

0:39:37of a quickie elephants like her at all

0:39:42they're mocking her before the before

0:39:44the baby even arrives God and so it's a

0:39:47there's no there's no happy ending to

0:39:50that movie like even if dumbo is written

0:39:53in part of it as the American ending

0:39:55right where dumbo gets rich and that is

0:39:57the triumph right that now they have

0:40:00their own railcar but they're still in

0:40:01the freaking circus they're not back in

0:40:04that they're not back in the Savannah

0:40:06dumb bowed and his mother didn't free

0:40:07themselves but they're still there still

0:40:10in Chains

0:40:11I you know I don't know I i feel like

0:40:13i'm gonna be my little girl and I are

0:40:15going to sit and we're going to digest

0:40:17dumbo for a while but I but seeing her

0:40:23emotional reaction to you know that

0:40:27thing that you're describing where she

0:40:28sits up straight

0:40:29all of a sudden movement and and all he

0:40:31is trying to avert our eyes and you go i

0:40:36can i'm not just gonna keep broadcasting

0:40:38happy fluff to her right but but uh but

0:40:44if she shares my emotional nature like

0:40:47there are so many more land mines in the

0:40:50world than for a normal person you know

0:40:53and i'm not just want to say like I I'm

0:40:56glad with a kid can still have feelings

0:40:59I mean in a way when it be it would be

0:41:01even weirder if they were sitting there

0:41:02and like laughing at home no feeling

0:41:05like that means that she's not dead

0:41:06inside you know and that makes me happy

0:41:09but I totally get what you're saying

0:41:10where it's it's it that's not that yes a

0:41:13minefield yeah and-and-and you know if

0:41:16there's a part there's a part of my life

0:41:20that I absolutely would not trade you

0:41:22know the the the the degree to which I

0:41:27see the world through emotions even

0:41:30though i think over the years I have

0:41:32been accused by a lot of people of being

0:41:34cold or of being you know emotionally

0:41:38distant from them in particular

0:41:40emotionally distant from other people

0:41:42and yet

0:41:44like I it i walked through a world that

0:41:48is you know not just a rainbow of

0:41:51emotions but also like into the infrared

0:41:54and x-ray up of emotion right I like I'm

0:42:00seeing I'm seeing emotions in things

0:42:03that do not have emotions and I'm having

0:42:05an emotional response to things that do

0:42:06not require one you have a promotional

0:42:09response that maybe I say inappropriate

0:42:11things out of out of line with what a

0:42:13typical person we have about something

0:42:14but and and and what that has always

0:42:17what I've always imagined is that it is

0:42:19that it's a kind of dimensional

0:42:21perception or something i'm seeing

0:42:22another overlay or not seen it's not a

0:42:25seeing thing I am experiencing another

0:42:28overlay almost like somebody somebody

0:42:30who could imagine somebody who's like

0:42:31see themselves as a medium or a psychic

0:42:33like having no no you know honestly

0:42:35somebody who feels like you know what I

0:42:37knew this was gonna happen I i had a

0:42:39strong vision of exactly what happened

0:42:41before it happened

0:42:42yeah right something you can see

0:42:43something that other people don't see I

0:42:45was at a party this weekend in somebody

0:42:47we're talking ghost stories and

0:42:48somebody's like to believe in ghosts

0:42:49John and I was like well I do not

0:42:52believe in ghosts however i have been

0:42:55terrorized by ghosts and so in being

0:42:59terrorized by them i absolutely believe

0:43:02in them but i do not believe in them cut

0:43:04it's so great and you know and they were

0:43:06like what it would do what do you mean

0:43:08and I was like well for instance i do

0:43:09not believe in God and yet I do not know

0:43:11whether or not i believe in god and so I

0:43:14cannot say that i do not believe in God

0:43:16but I don't believe in God but I do very

0:43:20much believe in god I mean how much

0:43:22clearer could I be and that is it's

0:43:28perfectly consistent from within but uh

0:43:33but like not only impossible to explain

0:43:37but also like why would I bother

0:43:39what was right what what am I trying to

0:43:41communicate like it was sometimes I will

0:43:43come downstairs

0:43:45ashen faced because all my pillows turn

0:43:49towels

0:43:50it doesn't mean that i believe that my

0:43:52that my or anyone elses pillows upturn

0:43:55towel if you believed it would be more

0:43:56plausible if that's the thing that's

0:43:58what people aren't getting it's like

0:43:59it's like that's the thing about reality

0:44:01is it doesn't need you to believe in it

0:44:02like if something if you know or feel

0:44:04that something is happening

0:44:05knowing that it's not real makes it

0:44:07worse not better we're making the line

0:44:07worse not better we're making the line

1:00:00a feeling that's a kind of fearful well

1:00:02kind of thing versus to like oh my god

1:00:05vibrating feeling of like what is

1:00:09happening all the time

1:00:10yeah yeah what I mean what I didn't used

1:00:12to feel it what I now feel is I wake up

1:00:15in the morning and already I am I am

1:00:17struggling to catch my breath and just

1:00:20all day 1 i'm just like just struggling

1:00:23to catch my breath like I have a little

1:00:26like I have an i'm having a mild asthma

1:00:29yeah and I never used to have that

1:00:32feeling at all I mean justjust it was

1:00:35basically it

1:00:36it was the feeling that I had an hour

1:00:39before I went on stage you know like not

1:00:42just like butterflies in your stomach

1:00:43kind of thing you have described this

1:00:44before right that but it when somebody

1:00:47says hey we want you to play a show i

1:00:48always say great and then immediately

1:00:51start to pretend that I didn't say that

1:00:54and a month or two go by and they sent

1:00:58me emails like that shows coming up and

1:00:59I'm like I just like delete but as the

1:01:03show starts to loom i start to wish that

1:01:07I had not agreed to do it even if I know

1:01:09it's gonna be a great show

1:01:11even if it's like the beginning of a

1:01:12tour I start to think like why did I say

1:01:14that I would think this and as the show

1:01:16gets closer I start to feel like I

1:01:18really hope that there's a storm and I

1:01:22hope there's a storm and the show's

1:01:23canceled

1:01:24I telling you that feeling yeah and then

1:01:26the night of the show

1:01:27I'm like what if the wheel came off of

1:01:29my car and I had a mild accident where

1:01:31no one was hurt but enough of an

1:01:34accident that I had a plausible reason

1:01:37for naught but a lot of people think

1:01:39that's like Dylan's motorcycle accident

1:01:41was he just like laid down and said

1:01:43sorry

1:01:44oh yeah I me now we're back to 80 women

1:01:46and dylanologists but a lot of people

1:01:48think that like he was he really had

1:01:51just kind of reached the end of it and

1:01:53that he you know kinda took a dive and

1:01:56was not hurt nearly as bad but like just

1:01:58needed that time to like just not have

1:02:00to deal

1:02:01yeah I have no I have no doubt about it

1:02:03and I've told you about right the one

1:02:05time that that did happen when I I'd put

1:02:07together a show with david bazan and

1:02:09Kathleen Edwards

1:02:10and my friend Laura my radkin and we had

1:02:13booked the triple door in Seattle and

1:02:15we'd all learned each other songs and we

1:02:18were going to get up on stage and we're

1:02:20gonna play for of Kathleen's all I saw

1:02:23the videos that we've got something in

1:02:24the video you guys rehearsing

1:02:25yes my god that was exquisite so that

1:02:28was so so we had this we have this show

1:02:31that we had worked out and it was all

1:02:35just this imagination of like what if

1:02:37Dave and Kathleen and I and Laura all

1:02:40just were a band and we did four five

1:02:44songs of each other students and and and

1:02:46it was a crazy idea but once we got in

1:02:48the room there was real energy and we

1:02:52and the song sounded incredible that way

1:02:54and we went we were it was a summer

1:02:57weekend that we were sitting in my house

1:03:00but the windows open and the doors open

1:03:03just playing our music and it was one of

1:03:06those sort of pure musician experiences

1:03:08where it's just like I just I don't want

1:03:10this to end I mean this is hard it's

1:03:12hard to learn this music but like it's

1:03:15the best kind of hard and then we went

1:03:17down to the triple door there was a line

1:03:20of people out the door to see the show

1:03:22we were Hearst on stage we ran through

1:03:25four five songs it was like and they

1:03:27sounded incredible and this was exactly

1:03:29the room for it and we were just looking

1:03:32at each other like it's going to be a

1:03:34magical night this is already a magic

1:03:36night and then it started to rain in the

1:03:40theater and we're standing on stage

1:03:43we're playing like we're playing our

1:03:46song still we're in the middle of a song

1:03:48and throughout the theater it's just

1:03:52rain and not a light rain like storm

1:03:56rain and we're where we continue the

1:04:00song and we're all looking out at the

1:04:03seats as they get drenched and it's so

1:04:08surreal that like we don't stop we don't

1:04:12stop playing and all of a sudden like

1:04:14the staff of the restaurant is screaming

1:04:17and running around and and we're still

1:04:19playing and thinking like

1:04:24this is weird and we get to the end of

1:04:27the tune and we stare out at the at the

1:04:31theater which is now a scene of complete

1:04:34devastation and i'm standing on stage

1:04:39still thinking like well we better get

1:04:42this cleaned up and there's like four

1:04:44inches of water on everything and it

1:04:48dawns on us suddenly that like it's over

1:04:52what what happened was the restaurant

1:04:54upstairs

1:04:55somehow the drain had plugged and all of

1:05:00the drainage water from a night of from

1:05:05a from a big dinner service all of the

1:05:07greywater uh from the dishwasher in the

1:05:10kitchen had pooled in the floor but you

1:05:18know underneath their floor but above

1:05:19our ceiling until it was God eight

1:05:23inches of dirty water and then it just

1:05:25all at once just fell just soaked

1:05:31through the soaked through the material

1:05:33of the ceiling and then just storm it

1:05:38was surreal and it came down not as

1:05:40falling ceiling but as rain dirty rain

1:05:45and and we were we were playing the last

1:05:50song before doors were opening right if

1:05:53that had if it had taken a half an hour

1:05:55longer that dirty rain would have fallen

1:05:57on a on a full house and the end of the

1:06:01line of the crowd down the street and

1:06:03what had happened was I had probably two

1:06:06hours before would have been so glad if

1:06:10to to imagine that happening right

1:06:15because of that pre-show anxiety but I

1:06:18had crossed the threshold and was into

1:06:21the show like doors are doors are in

1:06:24five and all of us onstage had crossed

1:06:27that threshold we were we were over the

1:06:30hump and were in show mode and it was so

1:06:34incredible the experience of

1:06:36that show being canceled right in front

1:06:38of us and we had all put our energy on

1:06:42the table and I'd never had that

1:06:47experience before where the energy was

1:06:49out it was on the table and it was ready

1:06:52to go and then there was no where to put

1:06:54it and we none of us had had that

1:06:58experience before and we were we were

1:07:00sitting backstage in a complete days

1:07:02like our our whole show energy was out

1:07:06of us but had not gone anywhere and was

1:07:10not being reciprocated or you know there

1:07:12was nowhere for it to go to live and it

1:07:16it was seriously like like we had

1:07:18survived like we'd all been struck by

1:07:20lightning and their what it was we were

1:07:26nervous could talk it was it was very

1:07:29confusing our feelings were outside of

1:07:33our body already

1:07:34and so the next day somebody who had

1:07:37been it who had one of the people who

1:07:40had had meant to come to the show

1:07:41contacted us and said hey I'm one of the

1:07:44directors of the woodland park zoo would

1:07:46you guys like to come feed the giraffes

1:07:47and we were like yes we would

1:07:52and so all of us together went to the

1:07:54zoo and spent a couple of hours inside

1:07:58the giraffe enclosure just hand-feeding

1:08:00giraffes and it was a it was a brilliant

1:08:04insight that this person at the zoo

1:08:08somehow recognized either saw or just or

1:08:13or we just got lucky or God was watching

1:08:16out or something but somehow going and

1:08:19having this singular experience

1:08:20hand-feeding giraffes for a couple of

1:08:23hours

1:08:23was it allowed us to collect all that

1:08:26emotion back and you know that and feel

1:08:31like it had been used or or it's very

1:08:35hard to explain but what I mean for a

1:08:38month afterward I think we all just sort

1:08:40of walked around in a in a very strange

1:08:42state not an unpleasant one but like a

1:08:46singular one where you're where you're

1:08:48ready your ear

1:08:49off your actually on stage ready to go

1:08:51and and the show is cancelled my

1:08:56emotions are real emotions are real

1:08:59holy shit that must have been so strange

1:09:04yeah I still you know you can hear it

1:09:07just been describing it that I go back

1:09:09into a place of like profound confusion

1:09:14about what the Iran I'm like I'm feeling

1:09:17it again remember that feeling just like

1:09:19what does one do with what does one do

1:09:23when there is no climax and so you have

1:09:28the energy and maybe i'm repeating what

1:09:30you said but it's almost like there was

1:09:31no different receptors there's no

1:09:33receptacles right energy just it didn't

1:09:35exactly dissipate but like where did it

1:09:37go because it was kind of still didn't

1:09:40really you know it's you just extend of

1:09:43real emotion you load up the torpedo

1:09:46tubes and then you know nothing you

1:09:51surface and go back home and it's just

1:09:53like whoa whoa that's it there's a lot

1:09:57of danger

1:09:58it feels very dangerous to be like

1:10:01sailing into port with with full torpedo

1:10:04tubes right

1:10:07yes I'm sorry this is this is so such a

1:10:10wonderful topic and i get i'm hearing

1:10:12dick jokes in my head haha alright but

1:10:15so as far as now today

1:10:18yeah are you can you can you and do you

1:10:24choose to locate what this with any

1:10:28specificity with those emotions are when

1:10:30you walk out from talking to

1:10:30firefighters and you feel like a boy

1:10:32something's going on like it is it

1:10:35are you aware of like how that evidence

1:10:37is in your feelings thoughts and and

1:10:39maybe even physicality are but can you

1:10:41locate what it is that you've that's

1:10:43making you feel that way what that

1:10:44feeling is one this is the thing that

1:10:46this ultimately is is the actual

1:10:49learning experience of this of this

1:10:53undertaking the thing i have to learn is

1:10:56not what this you know what the state

1:11:01policy

1:11:03is on red control right because that is

1:11:06just interesting and easy to learn and

1:11:10not emotional

1:11:12that is just policy but the thing i have

1:11:15to learn is what is going on and what is

1:11:20going on inside me and how can I turn

1:11:23that energy to be more useful to people

1:11:27and less you know like my anxiousness

1:11:31and my my anxiousness is a sign that i

1:11:34really think that this is important

1:11:36absolutely and that if you don't think

1:11:38about like stage fright or whatever you

1:11:39want to call it right there are those

1:11:40butterflies like you and I think we've

1:11:42talked about this but like if you didn't

1:11:43feel anything before you went onstage

1:11:44for two years like that should tell you

1:11:47something you're not challenging

1:11:48yourself or you stop caring you know

1:11:50right but how do i turn that energy so

1:11:53that I am a more effective public

1:11:55servant so that I am somebody who is

1:11:58more useful to people as an agent of of

1:12:04getting things happening and and and

1:12:08making good policy right and not get it

1:12:13it isn't about my comfort in and of

1:12:18itself it is about like my discomfort as

1:12:21another as another lever and and so i'm

1:12:30i'm very aware of it and and and I

1:12:33realized like when up when I am asked to

1:12:37write policy about things that I feel

1:12:43like our out of my out of my world of

1:12:48interest

1:12:52I i don't really support me i don't

1:12:55really have a I don't have an emotional

1:12:58block about like reading about stuff i

1:13:00don't understand asking people who know

1:13:03better about stuff

1:13:05who can explain what i don't understand

1:13:07to me like that stuff is just that's

1:13:09just exciting and something that says

1:13:12you say that he feels like that's the

1:13:13work that's the work that part that part

1:13:15is is not that ambiguous it's there's a

1:13:17thing over here that has to be dealt

1:13:19with and then when you're done dealing

1:13:21with it there's other things to deal

1:13:22with

1:13:22I think it's much more to do with the

1:13:25fact that i am a person who it you know

1:13:31i am i am a personality characterized by

1:13:33self-doubt and a certain amount of it is

1:13:36healthy self doubt and a certain amount

1:13:38of it is unhealthy self-doubt and I

1:13:40almost always trying to move the needle

1:13:42back to healthy self down right um but I

1:13:46am in a world where where you the

1:13:50expectation is that you express no

1:13:52self-doubt and right and the other

1:13:57candidates do not show very much self

1:14:00down i happen to know that the other

1:14:03people in my race hat do have

1:14:04considerable self-doubt they are human

1:14:07beings and I and I like them and there

1:14:09are there you know all three of the guys

1:14:11I'm running against do have like

1:14:14emotional lives but when I walk into the

1:14:19firefighters union this afternoon and

1:14:22they start talking to me about their

1:14:24pensions and I start answering questions

1:14:27about you know my feelings about the

1:14:29firefighters pensions and how important

1:14:31those are that there is no room in that

1:14:36conversation for me for my self-doubt

1:14:39because they don't have time for it you

1:14:42know they just want to hear whether or

1:14:45not i support their position and so

1:14:49being in in those were in those rooms

1:14:51because as a as a musician and as an

1:14:54artist and as somebody who was living in

1:14:56the world that I had made for myself I

1:14:58brought that self-doubt with me

1:15:00everywhere and I used it as a

1:15:02there if I were if I was in a

1:15:04conversation with somebody and they had

1:15:05no room for myself down I left that

1:15:08conversation and said you are a monster

1:15:12I'm not you know I'm not here to I'm not

1:15:16here to perform for you done to yourself

1:15:17down i mean i think it's slightly

1:15:19different than the well stroll but i

1:15:20think the self-doubt can be a companion

1:15:22in some ways it keeps you keep the kind

1:15:24of honest it jumps you it keeps you

1:15:26practical in some cases and maybe

1:15:29something that doesn't help you every

1:15:30single time I mean that becomes like a

1:15:33companion in some ways that an easy

1:15:35companion but I I don't think that's a

1:15:37horrible thing but it's more it's more

1:15:40it's more effective than normal when

1:15:43you're walking around being a musician

1:15:44mhm well and the thing is i can

1:15:46introduce that little friend of people

1:15:48at the firefighters union yeah I and

1:15:50that thing is I can't live without it

1:15:51that it that is a that is one of a part

1:15:54of my character and it will I think make

1:15:56me a better public servant but I'm being

1:16:00asked to perform in a circus where that

1:16:07is not one of the that's not what people

1:16:09paid the ticket price for right you

1:16:14don't you don't sit in front of the in

1:16:16front of a an executive board and say

1:16:20you know that question has played me and

1:16:24not because I worry about your pensions

1:16:27but more because pensions are emblematic

1:16:30of a of a deeper question of that the

1:16:35role that the state plays and providing

1:16:37for you know and that's just their

1:16:38already like King right there looking

1:16:41for their bail

1:16:42they're like that's not where we don't

1:16:44you know we this what we didn't sign up

1:16:46for a class we signed up for a 30-minute

1:16:51interview with you where you tell us

1:16:53either what we want to hear or you couch

1:16:56or give us an idea what we have to fight

1:16:59oh yeah that's right and I've described

1:17:01this to you before right that I've heard

1:17:03from several people like people come up

1:17:06to me and say I don't like your opponent

1:17:08but I know where he stands and the fact

1:17:12that I know where he stands allows me to

1:17:14make plan

1:17:15and i have a 40 million dollar hole in

1:17:18the ground downtown that I'm two days

1:17:20away from pouring concrete into and the

1:17:24fact that your opponent is either for or

1:17:26against it is less important to me than

1:17:29that I know exactly what he's going to

1:17:31do and so although i don't like him and

1:17:35I might like you

1:17:37the fact that I don't know what you're

1:17:38going to do is scarier to me then that I

1:17:41do know that he is against me and it's

1:17:44incredibly fascinating and I just go

1:17:46because from you know from where I stand

1:17:49like the first time somebody said that

1:17:51to me I was like that they said you know

1:17:53it's really kind of scary to us that we

1:17:55don't know what you're going to do and I

1:17:56was like I know right

1:17:58isn't that great you're the agent of

1:18:01chaos and they're like it is not at all

1:18:03great and I'm like but but you mean you

1:18:06have a sense that i'm going to support

1:18:07you know like it was an environmental

1:18:10group talking to me and I was like you

1:18:11have a sense that i am like 1,000% an

1:18:14environmentalist and they're like what

1:18:16we do have a sense of it and we also

1:18:19know the not sure who you gonna deliver

1:18:21the built-in how yeah they're like we're

1:18:24very excited about it but your opponent

1:18:26has been a reliable and like gray

1:18:30colored vote on behalf of the basic

1:18:33environmental package he's he doesn't is

1:18:38not inspiring but he is reliable and I'm

1:18:43like but I mean don't you want inspiring

1:18:45and they're like well what we want is

1:18:47reliably inspiring and I was and and you

1:18:51know and facing that and being when well

1:18:54reliably inspiring that's like you're

1:18:56talking about lawful good they described

1:18:59it the hole in the ground situation you

1:19:01describe this before but i really get

1:19:03get it now I get it sits in a way you

1:19:06know it reminds you of this is kind of

1:19:07obscure but it's almost like finding out

1:19:10what judge you've been assigned like

1:19:12when you're when you're on one side of

1:19:13the of the of the case or another

1:19:15like when you find out what judge has

1:19:17been assigned to your case and there may

1:19:18be some judges that are way more

1:19:20favorable to your particular point of

1:19:22view than others but like once you find

1:19:23out the judges you have to craft a

1:19:25certain kind

1:19:26of offense or defense depending on who

1:19:28that person is right so even if it's the

1:19:30hanging judge and you're the defense at

1:19:33least now you you it's a noble thing is

1:19:36like it seems like i may not be

1:19:38preferable but an officer's even the

1:19:40rain analogy but like it's you know you

1:19:41wouldn't want some some new cat coming

1:19:43in there who's like a real freethinker

1:19:45you'd be like well i know i need to know

1:19:47like how much just got a case going to

1:19:48cost to defend like who do I have to

1:19:50bring it is that where expert witnesses

1:19:52look let me look at your track record

1:19:53and see how you tend to adjudicate these

1:19:55things given certain conditions right

1:19:58that's much more desirable than going

1:19:59like here somebody who really believes

1:20:01in justice like okay great thank ya like

1:20:03what is this great one that's and the

1:20:05thing about a city council from the

1:20:06perspective of all these groups is what

1:20:11they're looking for is five out of nine

1:20:13votes

1:20:15they're not you know they did a the the

1:20:19vast majority of these groups do not

1:20:20look at individual council people in as

1:20:28much as they look at where that

1:20:29individual council person is going to

1:20:31fall in a in a split decision and so

1:20:35everybody wants five reliable votes the

1:20:40environmentalist 15 reliable votes the

1:20:42transit nerds 15 reliable votes the cops

1:20:45want five reliable votes and so an

1:20:48election like this is there that it's

1:20:50for them it's much more of a scorecard

1:20:53and they say okay we've got this person

1:20:57and this person they are you know where

1:21:00the incumbent they're doing well in the

1:21:02race and we know that their vote for us

1:21:04and now there's these other seats where

1:21:07it's unclear who's going to win and we

1:21:10need to know like where the weather the

1:21:14candidates are vote for us or not and in

1:21:15my case I'm running against the

1:21:17incumbent and everybody knows exactly

1:21:20where he fits into their scorecard right

1:21:24and and unfortunately for me of everyone

1:21:30in the race in the you know of all 65

1:21:33people or whatever who are running for

1:21:34seattle city council right now

1:21:36I'm the one that is the most unknowable

1:21:40for everyone for the cops and ru

1:21:44accounting for how higher profile is

1:21:47compared to the longtail candidates for

1:21:50you think generally straight up like

1:21:51you're the most like I noble I'm the

1:21:53most noble not only because I don't you

1:21:56know I don't come from a siloed

1:21:58background i'm not you know if you are

1:22:00good people couldn't read your resume

1:22:01and gas exactly what you'll do exactly

1:22:04and so you know I'm trying to populate

1:22:06my campaign with writing that that lays

1:22:12it out but even that you know I don't

1:22:16have a voting record right it's very

1:22:18easy in a campaign to say when elected I

1:22:21will put a baby in every pot but unless

1:22:24you have unless you have voted for a

1:22:29baby in every pot five times or

1:22:32conversely voted to not put babies in

1:22:35pots it's all the kids that are my big

1:22:39pot you know

1:22:40yeah I'm not that's right i'm not you

1:22:42know bump I'm not inside not in service

1:22:44to big baby either

1:22:45oh my god keep going oh my god we could

1:22:57stop there that's so good buddy i wanna

1:22:59hear more

1:23:00yeah so i imagining an actual large big

1:23:06where you gonna go on this boat but

1:23:08that's where you're gonna go babysit

1:23:10pops or not so yeah so emotionally right

1:23:14I I because there are a lot of things at

1:23:19stake here you want to be everybody

1:23:22who's running for office wants to be

1:23:24liked by everybody except for the people

1:23:26who are running for office specifically

1:23:27because they hate a certain kind of

1:23:29civic leader the guy wears a boot on his

1:23:32head but like unless you're like did

1:23:35they be the deliberate like outsider

1:23:36candidate or no or allow the insiders

1:23:39are insiders but are like i am here to

1:23:43fight big developers looks like what

1:23:46does that mean yes

1:23:48yeah dude who are they and what you know

1:23:50but that's not but that's not politics

1:23:53to say what does that mean what's

1:23:54politics is to say I'm here to fight big

1:23:56developers and then everybody in the

1:23:57room goes yeah a big developers are bad

1:23:59hole here's the thing for the hole in

1:24:01the ground person like getting somebody

1:24:03in there who's incredibly incompetent

1:24:04that holds that point you might actually

1:24:06be kind of good for them

1:24:07absolutely i mean i'm not being extreme

1:24:09not all you plan around that stuff it's

1:24:11you know it's the supreme court stuff

1:24:13it's not you don't have to get a

1:24:14unanimous verdict you are trying to win

1:24:18and if you know that four people on the

1:24:21council are against you and you know

1:24:25that for our for you then you can just

1:24:29focus your attention on the one which is

1:24:32Victor which is which feels very

1:24:34efficient to a lot of political

1:24:37operatives you know it's like I think

1:24:40it's super interesting way to look at it

1:24:41like the swing thug

1:24:42yeah we don't have to we don't have to

1:24:44expend any energy on those four people

1:24:45that we know are against us and the fact

1:24:48that they are you know that one of them

1:24:50is really smart and one of them is

1:24:51really dumb

1:24:52you know one of them is a Scalia and one

1:24:54of them is Thomas like wall then wait a

1:24:58minute so but it's something let's say

1:24:59that the evil John Roderick okay

1:25:02somebody with a mustache comes in here

1:25:03who literally mustache no but like in

1:25:05that case doesn't that kind of benefit

1:25:07the we don't know what they'll do person

1:25:10because now they can leverage that if

1:25:12they were that sort of person

1:25:13well yeah except if they get the sense

1:25:17that that person is a person of

1:25:19principle

1:25:20you know if I were running for office

1:25:23and all of these groups smelled on me

1:25:25that I was someone who was corrupt

1:25:28someone who is capable of being coerced

1:25:31or bought or you know and this is why

1:25:34people say like wheel of a situation

1:25:36where it's a dumb candidate and a smart

1:25:38staff because you can go talk to the

1:25:41staff and say what do you guys want you

1:25:43guys want out of this like if we give

1:25:47you if you give us this and we give you

1:25:48that

1:25:49how does that feel in the staff goes

1:25:50well that benefits my career and I'm not

1:25:53the one out front

1:25:54who's going to get caught with his hand

1:25:57in a bag so you know the staff makes the

1:26:00deal and then they say to the

1:26:01their candidate like here's what we

1:26:03should do on this is the candidate goes

1:26:04oh really great i can edit he's got a

1:26:08big hair and he goes out and and people

1:26:10vote for his hair and a and that's how

1:26:14politics goes but so these groups you

1:26:17know they if I were malleable and they

1:26:21didn't know what I was going to do sure

1:26:23they be like great here's a and there

1:26:25are people absolutely at every level of

1:26:28politics that walk into every room and

1:26:31say what can I do for you

1:26:34uh-huh the problem is that they smell on

1:26:37me that i am not that I that they don't

1:26:40know what I'm going to do and also they

1:26:41are not confident that they can reach me

1:26:43through the normal back door and I am I

1:26:48had a few people in my life where I

1:26:51didn't realize until too late how

1:26:53important it was to them that I owed

1:26:57them a favor

1:26:58oh yes there are many people like this

1:27:00and they are perpetually they seem so

1:27:01nice and so dad like in some ways but

1:27:04there are these people who want to make

1:27:05sure you owe them at least a couple

1:27:07favors all the time and sometimes don't

1:27:10insert them like kind of like oh here's

1:27:12the thing i did for you and then she

1:27:14gets like I'm magic sound like playing

1:27:16pool and like extending the queue and

1:27:18like moving a little clicker down the

1:27:20string i think you must run into that

1:27:22there must be people who are just always

1:27:23like I just I will always just keep

1:27:25doing these like little things for

1:27:27people and that will accumulate

1:27:28eventually on the day of my daughter's

1:27:29wedding at the heck did they may come i

1:27:32will come to you and ask a favor of here

1:27:34that's right that's right that's how it

1:27:36works

1:27:36put my boy back together they did my boy

1:27:39um uh it's absolutely how it works and

1:27:43at every stage of the campaign there has

1:27:47there have been moments and I've after I

1:27:49think describe this before but like the

1:27:51path to corruption is not a big bag of

1:27:54money it is a tiny little incremental

1:27:56failures to make failures to stand on

1:28:04your own principal and people come up to

1:28:07me every single day and there's nothing

1:28:09dishonest about it is not it is not a

1:28:12it's not a process

1:28:14uh of organized deceit it is not a

1:28:17conspiracy

1:28:18it is just people saying hi I see you're

1:28:21running i like what i see i would like

1:28:24you I'd like to give you an opportunity

1:28:26to be my friend and in exchange for that

1:28:30I will do what I can to help you and it

1:28:34feels very natural it feels very human

1:28:37and humane and year and when you're on a

1:28:39campaign you're struggling you want

1:28:42friends you want people to say we are

1:28:45here to support you and we're not asking

1:28:49anything except very small thing which

1:28:52is just that you be our friend and

1:28:55remember this moment and you go wow that

1:28:58seems like such set that's so easy

1:29:00they're going to support me and all i

1:29:02have to do is remember that there my

1:29:03friend I will take that deal thank you

1:29:07so much and you're just trying to put

1:29:08together enough friends to get into

1:29:11office but you realize that every one of

1:29:15those people is remembering that favor

1:29:17and that's their job to do and if you if

1:29:23you don't have a a core if your values

1:29:27aren't your own then in the course of a

1:29:32campaign it only takes one campaign to

1:29:34get to the end and realize like oh I

1:29:37promised everybody I promised everything

1:29:40to everybody and now and and now I'm in

1:29:43office and I'm excited about that and so

1:29:45you know if each person who walks in

1:29:47here i'm going to try and accommodate

1:29:51and not because i'm looking for the best

1:29:54solution that helps everybody but just

1:29:58because I've already know because I've

1:29:59already given a little piece of myself

1:30:02to everybody and it's uh it's

1:30:05astonishing how easy it is to be to be

1:30:11corrupted and let alone when you get in

1:30:14there and somebody comes and says

1:30:16remember when I remember when we

1:30:19endorsed you and I got 70,000 members of

1:30:22my organization to come out and fight

1:30:25for you like you would not be here

1:30:27without

1:30:28me uh-huh and that's hardball politics

1:30:31and you know it's what I love about the

1:30:34Sierra Club like they sat down with me

1:30:35and and we talked and they were like you

1:30:38know why would we endorse you like we

1:30:39have endorsed her opponent in the last

1:30:41three elections it would be it would be

1:30:45a nail they don't want to change and

1:30:46only sources to be a real violation of

1:30:48policy and I was like wouldn't you like

1:30:49to have somebody on out there that

1:30:50really was like really on your team and

1:30:54they were like you know what yes we

1:30:55would

1:30:56and they endorse me and they have not

1:30:57like they didn't ask me for anything

1:31:00then and they really have not made a big

1:31:02deal of it sense they were just like you

1:31:04know what he's our guy and now I run

1:31:06into them and they're just like they

1:31:08seem happy to see me and there's no

1:31:11sense of because I because I already was

1:31:13ahead of them on like the Sierra Club is

1:31:16never going to come to me and say we

1:31:18really need to do this thing that you

1:31:20find distasteful right like I'm already

1:31:22i was just like listen you guys draft

1:31:25off of me on this because I'm you know

1:31:27like I got this part of it but but the

1:31:31the you know there's a there are so many

1:31:33issues where any reasonable person

1:31:37what kind of fall somewhere in the

1:31:39middle you know and it really is

1:31:45difficult to know where you to know

1:31:48where you land and that is normal and

1:31:52that should be part of good government

1:31:53that should that should be part of the

1:31:55discussion like there's there's nine of

1:31:57us up here and seven of us think that

1:31:59this is kind of this is sort of a guinea

1:32:02or their seven of seven of us up here

1:32:04that don't even understand the question

1:32:06or there are you know there are six of

1:32:09us who feel like group a has a good

1:32:11point but they're kind of overplaying

1:32:12their hand a little bit and Group B has

1:32:15a weaker point but they're they're being

1:32:16kind of noble you know like that stuff

1:32:19that's just like that's people business

1:32:22but there's no real there's no real

1:32:27place for that in a campaign in a

1:32:31campaign you are your four against stuff

1:32:34right and if you start to have nuance

1:32:36just like then they ring the bell

1:32:40like 30 seconds are up thank you for

1:32:43your time