Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 154: "West Coast Noncommittal"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this episode of Roderick on the line is

0:00:01sponsored by cards against humanity this

0:00:04month they ask paul and storm to help me

0:00:06say hi to john

0:00:09dinner

0:00:15all i need is you

0:00:19I

0:00:26[Music]

0:00:34hello hello how are you today

0:00:38that's right oh that's just swell Bob's

0:00:41your uncle my raccoon hat on and i'm

0:00:46ready to broadcast as a side note we do

0:00:49that for 90 minutes it's rob but you

0:00:52gotta keep moving you gotta get out of

0:00:53the way that's number one and number two

0:00:54what that in your pipe and smoke it

0:00:56take it to the bank and Johnny like

0:01:01nothing I've done this

0:01:02the amazing thing is you know that you

0:01:05know that quality when you look at a

0:01:06really old photographs of people like

0:01:09you look at you find a photograph of an

0:01:10of a whole class of from school

0:01:13you look more like you know but they're

0:01:14adults like a technical school or

0:01:16something you look at their pictures and

0:01:18their faces there there's the

0:01:20physiognomy is just look old

0:01:23oh yeah they don't look like modern

0:01:25people who and then when you listen to

0:01:27recordings of the way people talked in

0:01:30old movies radio I don't talk like

0:01:34normal people either they talk like old

0:01:38only like maybe civilians not like

0:01:40training broadcaster types of you

0:01:42the thing is the difference today

0:01:42everybody wants to be on TV and radio so

0:01:46everybody's already you could do a man

0:01:48on the street a person on the street and

0:01:49they're going to have a bit move back

0:01:51then you hear interviews with people

0:01:53from like the fifties and sixties it's

0:01:54delightful because they they sound like

0:01:56normal people they're normal people and

0:01:58also there's a bit yeah

0:02:00when you look at those classic movies

0:02:01from the from the nineteen thirties or

0:02:03the you know the early talkies there's

0:02:06that kind of almost British quality to

0:02:09the way they speak in their very you

0:02:12know like there's a but but at the same

0:02:14time there's a there's a cut a self

0:02:20awareness of the of their diction right

0:02:23that feels a little bit put on it is i

0:02:27think i think this is god dammit I'm

0:02:29gonna have to not using the internet now

0:02:30this comes up twice a year and I need to

0:02:32find out what this is called but it was

0:02:35I think it's the way that people were

0:02:36trained elocution I bet you're part of

0:02:40it part of it is stagecraft out of being

0:02:44in plays and stuff but then you know in

0:02:47the early days

0:02:47we learned from singing in the rain John

0:02:49you have to speak very clearly your

0:02:51voice you probably you probably sound

0:02:52like a clarinet when you talk you got to

0:02:53have a real resonant voice but I think

0:02:56that's that was the where they called

0:02:59like the received pronunciation of

0:03:01Hollywood yes you know like the BBC

0:03:03english i think that was our version of

0:03:05that with the received Hollywood

0:03:06pronunciation well and this is one of

0:03:08the you know I've said for many years

0:03:10that I believe that the English language

0:03:14has continued to evolve as it has moved

0:03:17away from its form its place of origin

0:03:20and that actually the the most perfectly

0:03:25spoken english is that which is spoken

0:03:29by the educated people of Alaska

0:03:32mhm because it's been through every gate

0:03:36right it's it's it's made its way

0:03:39through all this sort of Midwestern

0:03:41nasal and southern drawl and west coast

0:03:45non-committal and it's made its way

0:03:49isn't that the Jon west coast

0:03:51non-committal west coast non-committal

0:03:52you hear it all the time it's you know

0:03:55it's kind of spoken from your teeth but

0:03:58then you get to Alaska and every you

0:04:00know everyone since Alaska has been so

0:04:03recently settled by Europeans right it's

0:04:06a it's a mishmash of all the different

0:04:08spoken english 'as and we have refined

0:04:11it until it has become perfect and you

0:04:16know it is broadcaster English but even

0:04:19better and when I want to advance this

0:04:22theory to people for instance from

0:04:23England they find it laughable but they

0:04:28are still speaking a kind of archaic

0:04:30english some leftover hodgepodge some

0:04:34steak and kidney pie that's been left

0:04:36out on the counter snap and it

0:04:41meanwhile we have been well right here

0:04:44in Alaska perfecting a language that's

0:04:46right we have we have we

0:04:47we've sent it through a thousand cheese

0:04:49clubs and here it is the best version

0:04:53not some not some Boston you know some

0:04:59Boston baked beans

0:05:01means of English know there's Alaskan

0:05:04English the enemy hate beans and pie is

0:05:06he perfect version food I can I have it

0:05:10the problem is Alaska has a very small

0:05:11population and everyone else is allied

0:05:15against this theory but i really do

0:05:17think there's something to it is it

0:05:19anything that you can demonstrate well I

0:05:21demonstrated only in the perfect way

0:05:24that i speak english you just blew my

0:05:26mind

0:05:27hmm i've been getting the demo the whole

0:05:28time that's right that's right

0:05:31if you can I mean and it and there are

0:05:33some there are some small like glitches

0:05:37write some some brief moment some max

0:05:41headroom moments where you see you see

0:05:43the behind the curtain

0:05:44mm see the see the matrix for instance i

0:05:47do say everybody everybody you know

0:05:51everybody over here you you got you you

0:05:54know i don't like me deal that you got

0:05:55several that i know i've got several now

0:05:57wait a minute you're saying several you

0:05:59have you you can name more than one

0:06:00everybody what's the name of the place

0:06:05where you did you show last year on dude

0:06:07what's goin on the rendezvous

0:06:12yeah how's that supposed to be

0:06:14pronounced i think its rendezvous

0:06:16it's French I like the way you say it

0:06:19but i know i say this because you know

0:06:21i'm being defensive because I have more

0:06:24of these and I realized and then once

0:06:26people start pointing out that become

0:06:27self-conscious

0:06:27yeah you know the people yell at me for

0:06:29saying Sasquatch almost a sasquatch

0:06:32sasquatch

0:06:33what about what your kids put on to go

0:06:35to bed at night cameras pajamas

0:06:38yeah but what do you say well I don't

0:06:41know I'm really come on the horns of a

0:06:42dilemma between pajamas and pajamas

0:06:44pajamas

0:06:46yeah that doesn't settle fancy come on

0:06:48that's like arms

0:06:49ok thank you John god fucking dammit on

0:06:54on is like writing a sentence without an

0:06:57oxford comma mon is on is terrible onto

0:07:00is terrible and it really it really buy

0:07:03and the thing is my wife the thing is he

0:07:05this is you know what it's like to be in

0:07:06a relationship right

0:07:07barely but

0:07:10you don't know what it get the better

0:07:16throw it out the window the better wipe

0:07:19my tears with it you know i have said i

0:07:23don't know i'm not saying i have success

0:07:24with this but I think a big part of

0:07:26being in any kind of a long-term

0:07:27relationship is learning the things that

0:07:29only you were allowed to be right about

0:07:31oh if you can if you can minimize the

0:07:33number of things that only you are

0:07:35allowed to be right about here you

0:07:36thought technology that's a thought

0:07:38technology because i think it makes you

0:07:39a better person and i'm pretty sure even

0:07:42though you may not you may still think

0:07:44in your mind that you need to be right

0:07:45about something

0:07:46there's just so much stuff where I want

0:07:47to really keep my powder dry right and

0:07:50the thing is i also know how desperately

0:07:52fucked up i am so I'm always looking for

0:07:54improvement opportunities right but i

0:07:55have to say there are some things I

0:07:58capitulated on on because everybody

0:08:02well because of my lady everybody in her

0:08:04family says on so I'm the only one in

0:08:06the family that refers to an su instead

0:08:09of on soon they think I'm talking about

0:08:11you know insects or something like that

0:08:12but then sometimes I find myself saying

0:08:14yeah that's right Ellie ya later in the

0:08:16month we're going to your on uncle's

0:08:17house back because I catch myself having

0:08:21to speak it phonetically all all all all

0:08:24alcohol i don't know i guess they see

0:08:26why but i I've got through this with a

0:08:28few people like I was talking to another

0:08:30program about how you take the first

0:08:32name of the guy who is the deputy on

0:08:35Andy Griffith you take the phenomenon of

0:08:38Sun coming up in the morning and I

0:08:39pronounce both of those the same up a

0:08:42bar need on party down and Dawn ok now

0:08:47do you see there's any different

0:08:48dawn and dawn so they're easy i'm sorry

0:08:52are you saying that if you're saying

0:08:53differently right yeah dawn

0:08:55ok this is this is my color this is like

0:08:57me and color blindness and not to be

0:08:58able assist but this is I can't really

0:09:01hear that difference you cannot hear

0:09:03that are being gone and dawn

0:09:07haha this is a prank and that's okay

0:09:10well I no that's no that's because I

0:09:13feel like I feel like the vast majority

0:09:15of our listeners would be able to hear

0:09:17that i was pronouncing a whole different

0:09:19word i'm never gonna be a good idea

0:09:21professional I i know people from the

0:09:22tri-state area i feel like people from

0:09:24the tri-state area will say do one you

0:09:28buy tristate area you mean and you mean

0:09:30New Mexico Arizona and Colorado the

0:09:33original the OG now i'm talking about

0:09:35that and you got your new york new

0:09:36jersey pennsylvania triads yeah right I

0:09:39get you I don't know and you know it's

0:09:41just it's it's funny because like I

0:09:42don't think of myself as being i know

0:09:44people who are very sensitive about the

0:09:45pronunciation and in the same way that

0:09:47you might be sensitive about like a lazy

0:09:50eye or something you know for all people

0:09:52because they feel like they are

0:09:53overcoming some some like regionalism

0:09:56maybe but also we talked about this at

0:10:00phenomenon and I have some very smart

0:10:02people have the same problem where if

0:10:04you're a reader and especially if you're

0:10:06an internet radio I see you know you

0:10:08know where I'm going with this yes and

0:10:09you've read a word you have one of these

0:10:11I remember I can't remember what the

0:10:12word is but you'll have read a name or

0:10:15you have read you know a given word

0:10:17potentially thousands of times you might

0:10:20actually no more than eighty percent of

0:10:22the population about this noun when

0:10:24you've never actually had to say it out

0:10:26loud but wait i said i used one of the

0:10:28very beginning of this program I i use

0:10:31the word physiognomy which allows you to

0:10:34zero physiognomies physiognomies me and

0:10:37I and neither one of them sounds right

0:10:39and I as a writer i have used this word

0:10:43thousand times i think it all the time

0:10:45like that that's an interest is

0:10:47interesting physiognomy but I do

0:10:50actually not know how it is pronounced

0:10:52and every time I start to say the word

0:10:55I've become aware i'm about I become

0:10:58aware that I have gone too far in the

0:10:59sentence to not say it and then i'm

0:11:02committed and that somewhere halfway i'm

0:11:05in the air right doing a Daffy hehe

0:11:09don't have time to think about whether

0:11:10you should have junk you just need to

0:11:11figure out having a land without

0:11:12breaking something and I'm going to land

0:11:14it and I and I either and depending on

0:11:16who the person i'm going to is I either

0:11:18go physiognomy is yummy

0:11:21because yeah I just I just I try and get

0:11:24out of there i try to get to the ground

0:11:26is life cycle through an array of every

0:11:28conceivable pronunciation

0:11:29mispronunciation and here's what you

0:11:31look like you're genuinely damaged yeah

0:11:33the problem is i have gone multiple

0:11:36times two dictionaries and looked at the

0:11:38jumble of upside-down use and other you

0:11:42know diphthongs trying to figure out

0:11:44what the pronunciation of that word is

0:11:46and i get i can't make heads or tails of

0:11:49it even when I really investigate it and

0:11:51I never no one ever uses it no-one ever

0:11:54says it out loud right right right

0:11:56you're traveling sir

0:11:57so I walk through the world waiting for

0:11:59some waiting for someone else to say

0:12:01that word to me so that i can i can at

0:12:03least latch onto their pronunciation of

0:12:05it and say fuck it I know one thing I've

0:12:09heard it once but I'm not no one ever

0:12:11speaks it and I think it's because no

0:12:12one else knows how to pronounce it

0:12:14I think that's I think it's too i think

0:12:15as writerly people we tacitly understand

0:12:19that if you don't know the meaning of a

0:12:21word don't use it to make sure you could

0:12:24you go you go look it up

0:12:26that's good you're improving your word

0:12:28power you know saying improve your word

0:12:30power you want to prove your word power

0:12:32I'm just saying though you might you

0:12:33might want to be careful if you are

0:12:35using the word and don't like the times

0:12:37for example that I have said expendable

0:12:39when I meant flexible

0:12:40ok that was really super embarrassing

0:12:43right I I used to say I used to say

0:12:47momentum when I meant inertia

0:12:50oh no I notice these things a lot more

0:12:53than I used to and I don't think of

0:12:55myself as a word nerd but i really like

0:12:57i really like using the appropriate word

0:13:00and it drives me crazy when i realized

0:13:02i've been using an incorrect or in exact

0:13:04word for a long time

0:13:06yeah yeah the the hardest part of doing

0:13:12that is getting corrected like the

0:13:16momentum and inertia one I knew i was

0:13:18using it wrong

0:13:19I mean I knew I was it was one of those

0:13:21things where you're searching you're

0:13:22doing the Terminator and you're

0:13:24searching your a your pc here heads-up

0:13:27display feet for fuck you asshole

0:13:29momentum asshole and and I and I just

0:13:33didn't have inertia entered into my did

0:13:38my you know my dictionary for that

0:13:40application and it's not that I had

0:13:43learned it I just hadn't gotten it

0:13:45wasn't on the short list and i kept

0:13:47getting to momentum and just saying it

0:13:50because I wanted to get on with the

0:13:52thought right and neat the bass player

0:13:55of the decemberists once in a bar said

0:13:59do you mean inertia and i was like i do

0:14:03mean inertia thank you

0:14:06and then that use of that word is now

0:14:10tied to Nate query and I bet you still

0:14:17think about it i cannot say the word and

0:14:20then I cannot say inertia in the way

0:14:22that I mean it's now without without

0:14:24picturing him picturing his kindly face

0:14:26you know i am and i happen to like him

0:14:29very much and he meant he meant that in

0:14:30a very nice what I mean he wasn't

0:14:31ashamed people I I i still this is a

0:14:35little bit of a call back but now for

0:14:38the last few months every time that's

0:14:39rare that i drink from a water fountain

0:14:41but every time I drink from a water

0:14:42fountain now I think of your friend that

0:14:44I've never met who told me to think of

0:14:47him when i drink from a water fountain

0:14:49that's right oh my god it's it's it's

0:14:51it's a it's a mental virus expanding 30

0:14:54years it's ridiculous and i'll bet you

0:14:56right now there are people listening to

0:14:57the show that are gonna go drink drink

0:14:59from a water fountain they're gonna

0:15:00think of me thinking of your friend that

0:15:03they've never met language is a virus

0:15:05who it's insane

0:15:07he planted that bug knowingly well

0:15:10because you say this

0:15:11what a dick here's the thing and I you

0:15:13know I don't have I feel myself like

0:15:17like slowly grinding into permanent old

0:15:20man mode it's happening to it so fast

0:15:23when we started this podcast we're still

0:15:25young men were a podcast of ideas and

0:15:28now we are just let leibnitz and and the

0:15:33and solar installer here's the thing I i

0:15:40am not one of the i don't think i'm one

0:15:42of those people that feels like the

0:15:43language should be static is obviously

0:15:45it's always evolving

0:15:47you're not a member of the french

0:15:47academy for instance who may know who

0:15:50believes that we should say from a

0:15:52bourgeois instead of cheeseburger about

0:15:56the foremost booze wha

0:15:58we used at least uh like to harass our

0:16:00French literature teacher who is also

0:16:03the French language teacher and so we

0:16:04would just ask him asinine things in the

0:16:06middle class all the time and we say

0:16:09quickly said you know what is a

0:16:11professor was called mr. Hixon just to

0:16:13get on his nerves mr. Jackson how do you

0:16:14sell say my nails salon perfect would

0:16:17you say my maison parfait salon you

0:16:20talking about flow barrage and you would

0:16:24have to say might know my nails are

0:16:25perfect as though I have just come from

0:16:27the salon uh i was explaining to do my

0:16:32daughter yesterday that the actual words

0:16:35of a fresh acha the actual English

0:16:39traditional singing that night

0:16:41yeah and the actual translation should

0:16:44be brother John brother John sleeping

0:16:49are you sleeping on and she was just

0:16:51like what

0:16:53yeah this is insane I was like yeah I'm

0:16:55telling you that's why we're in a very

0:16:58tenuous military alliance with friends

0:17:01that's true yeah yeah no absolutely

0:17:03there's you know there's there's

0:17:04cognates in his cognates you know i'm

0:17:06saying i do my problem is and I you know

0:17:09it's you I i like the evolution of

0:17:11things i do get i'm not a big fan of

0:17:14hella when I hear that I mean hella is

0:17:17kind of the like as hella is to this

0:17:21generation as you know was two hours in

0:17:23some ways just in the sense that it

0:17:25becomes something that you are just

0:17:26you're putting in everywhere its that's

0:17:28ok that's ok here's my general

0:17:30overarching issue it's not really a

0:17:32language problem it's a communication

0:17:33problem i think there are probably think

0:17:35pieces about this on medium right now I

0:17:38think young people don't know how to

0:17:39communicate with other people anymore

0:17:41who talking more old man

0:17:44well I for example I you think about

0:17:48talking to somebody on the phone and

0:17:51nobody likes try not to i know i know

0:17:53nobody likes talking on the phone but

0:17:54there are times when it is the quickest

0:17:56path to communication

0:17:59and I maybe this is just because again

0:18:01because i was a little kid in a

0:18:02different age but I speak very clearly

0:18:05when I'm on the phone I focus very

0:18:09heavily and I risk sounding like I'm

0:18:12being very repetitious by making sure

0:18:13that we all understood what we just said

0:18:15and agreed right just just cuz i think

0:18:18it's really useful to go i do that an

0:18:19email to do that all the time just click

0:18:20just to clarify we're meeting tomorrow /

0:18:23tuesday that dumb stuff you know and

0:18:25rest but I feel like I talk to so like

0:18:28sometimes we get groceries delivered

0:18:29from this place in town they have to

0:18:30call if there's a replacement and

0:18:33they're not even talking into the phone

0:18:36I don't know what they're doing with

0:18:37their phone but they don't they don't

0:18:39know how to communicate they don't know

0:18:41how to pause to let the other person

0:18:43speak they don't have to account for

0:18:44latency and a call it just just kind of

0:18:46meandering like it's just yeah you're

0:18:48talking about you forget this

0:18:50mhm and I've heard it said turns out

0:18:52I've heard it said that a lot of people

0:18:53say a lot of people say that also means

0:18:57not something to eye contact when they

0:18:58talk em makes them uncomfortable ICS

0:19:02mmog an emoji John you should get more

0:19:05into emoji you know I'm really behind on

0:19:09emojis i'm an old enough guy that I

0:19:11can't see what happened emojis are they

0:19:13all look like the turd right somebody

0:19:16sent me like a a a winking devil cat not

0:19:20a turd

0:19:21I look over the top of my classes really

0:19:23setting they occurred and that i'm here

0:19:26today and what is that in that face

0:19:28anxious is it scared what the turd face

0:19:31no wonder people the turd face you get

0:19:33is turn but yeah the other the other

0:19:35thing is also the I refused to stop

0:19:38using sentences and punctuation when i

0:19:41text people and i'm told that that makes

0:19:43me sound angry

0:19:44OIC yeah right you need to end

0:19:47everything with a ! three options at

0:19:50them if you're saying thank you you're

0:19:52supposed to say thanks with an

0:19:53unnecessary ! failing at that you say

0:19:56thanks with no punctuation well oh and

0:19:59if you say thanks for the period it's

0:20:01considered a fuck you

0:20:02alright thanks thanks thanks

0:20:06yeah well I you know I have struggled

0:20:09with this a lot and I that is we have we

0:20:11have really jumped the old man chart but

0:20:14I've definitely struggled with the lack

0:20:16of my socks so hard to put on where does

0:20:19that other one go

0:20:20I put two in the dryer I'm sure don't

0:20:23they know old people like hard candy why

0:20:25the jar so hard to open

0:20:27yeah i do I have succumbed somewhat to

0:20:32the ! a escalation because I I recognize

0:20:39you know I do a lot of texting and I

0:20:41recognize that the thanks with a period

0:20:44is a little is a little bit of a it's a

0:20:50little cold mayonnaise you know a little

0:20:52bit of its like me but i have said hella

0:20:56for 30 years and have hella is one of

0:21:02those things like like dude or like like

0:21:09in the early 90s late late eighties

0:21:12there was a there was that verbal tic

0:21:16that went around for a while where you'd

0:21:18say like you know oh my god today is

0:21:20beautiful and the other person will say

0:21:23yeah it is yeah right and you'd be like

0:21:26yeah it is

0:21:27they're like yeah it is and it's it felt

0:21:30like it was a challenge and then I

0:21:32picked that up and a dude and and hella

0:21:36both were words that i started using

0:21:38initially as that uh I was charity so I

0:21:43was parodied sarcastic yeah like Oh

0:21:45hella and then it just became like I say

0:21:49dude and have said dude I think it's

0:21:52about a week-and-a-half yeah it off to

0:21:54go from doing any better voice is a joke

0:21:56to not being able to stop

0:21:58yep and it was one of those for me and

0:22:00and using a lot though

0:22:02no I'm not like an animal I'm not like

0:22:04some kinda like hella hella dude you've

0:22:07got like it out is it

0:22:09hello amount i do got the other one i've

0:22:11been did I think i actually saw an

0:22:13article somewhere about this recently

0:22:14the the ascendance of no yeah or like

0:22:18that up that moves real

0:22:20good night was great like what happen

0:22:22haha i do i I do it all the time no

0:22:25really it was great

0:22:26yeah I wanted to agree with somebody by

0:22:29starting by saying no you so lately i

0:22:34have really I I know what we're getting

0:22:36at here which is that where relevant

0:22:39well know that we're both very confused

0:22:42because on the one hand we do want

0:22:44language to be useful and meaningful and

0:22:47and follow some rules right that seems

0:22:51normal that seems regular at but then we

0:22:54don't we don't want to stand in the way

0:22:57of the the constant evolution of of

0:23:00communication and be like old and be

0:23:03angry about it but at the same time the

0:23:08entire theme of this podcast for three

0:23:10years has been that standards are

0:23:11declining everywhere

0:23:13yeah and we need to like that but like

0:23:17pull up our pants and and go back to

0:23:19work as at our jobs and so i don't know

0:23:24i i'm talking about personally who i am

0:23:29i'm navigating these these very

0:23:32precipitous hills in my own life and

0:23:36just wondering i cannot surrender right

0:23:38that isn't in my nature to just

0:23:40surrender i need to capitulate to do to

0:23:44capitulate think that's the better word

0:23:46but at the same time it's important to

0:23:49listen and learn

0:23:51you know there's there's there's there's

0:23:52a lot of the I've been seeing this a lot

0:23:54lately where people say like well you

0:23:56just need to listen now and I go I'm

0:23:59comfortable listening and learning i

0:24:02really am I have been doing that my

0:24:03whole life i like it it's a great thing

0:24:05but at a certain point that like you

0:24:08just need to listen is being used as a

0:24:10way of saying you just need to

0:24:13capitulate haha alright and yeah like

0:24:17listening and learning is wonderful but

0:24:19then it will get there there's also some

0:24:21you know there needs to be some

0:24:24back-and-forth or some pushback on some

0:24:25ideas right for some more some asking to

0:24:28clarify right asking to clarify or or

0:24:31you know or just think

0:24:33King churning on it right i mean there's

0:24:35there's and other that little tick that

0:24:38I just did which is to end every

0:24:40sentence with right ? oh yeah super

0:24:43annoying and I was pointed out it was

0:24:46pointed out

0:24:47not that I was doing it but i was at an

0:24:50event where the hubby host you know a

0:24:53very educated an erudite woman who was

0:24:55giving a long presentation said right at

0:25:00the end of every sentence until it was

0:25:04you know until it rub it was like you

0:25:05know you really notice it was like a

0:25:07foghorn in the room and end it and you

0:25:10know it didn't detract from like the

0:25:13real smartness of the presentation it

0:25:16just was like you started to wince at

0:25:19the end of her senses like I'll got

0:25:20ology did it again right

0:25:23and pretty soon so you can notice but so

0:25:25I don't know you know we do have an

0:25:29obligate this is this must be the this

0:25:30this must be be like the the the

0:25:37terrible thing about middle-aged this

0:25:39must be it

0:25:40merlin which is just to stand athwart

0:25:42two areas and to say now hold on wait

0:25:49just everyone hold on justice and that

0:25:52must be why middle-aged people are so

0:25:54uncomfortable and why it's why this why

0:25:58they buy red Corvette why it's talked

0:26:00about is such a difficult time right and

0:26:03we're experiencing it

0:26:05yeah I'm because your enemy it's fine i

0:26:07can't stop thinking this recent episode

0:26:08of louie ck that the live show where he

0:26:11he begins by being mad about the ways

0:26:13treated at this cookware store fantastic

0:26:16episode but you know in the woman

0:26:18basically just confront him she's like

0:26:19I'm 24 I on my own store in Manhattan is

0:26:21this the way you always threatened by

0:26:23being around young people and he's

0:26:24getting his dander up and you know like

0:26:26why don't you want to learn about

0:26:27customer service since i got good wins

0:26:29sonoma they'll treat you nice them look

0:26:31look but you know because this Q 24 year

0:26:33old asian woman who owns her own store

0:26:34one kiss his ass like he's accustomed to

0:26:36and she basically called the shit on it

0:26:38goes like well you're you know you're

0:26:39getting older you're becoming less

0:26:40relevant if you want your kids to evolve

0:26:42become better than you see things are

0:26:43working out fine

0:26:44that but it also makes you think you

0:26:48know I i guess it was a long time before

0:26:49I really thought about this just that

0:26:51distinction between you talk about

0:26:53having two people saying you should just

0:26:55got listen I mean I think the first

0:26:57distinction between listening and

0:26:58hearing that i became aware of is that

0:27:00you can hear stuff just stopped for you

0:27:03have to hear what's going on around you

0:27:05I hear traffic noise outside but i'm not

0:27:06paying a ton of attention to it when I'm

0:27:08listening I'm focusing my attention on

0:27:10what people are saying with the

0:27:12understand with the with the implicit

0:27:14now I'm hearing triangle by I hear these

0:27:16things but when I'm listening to them

0:27:18i'm focusing my attention with with

0:27:20partly the idea that i want to

0:27:22understand it better but that was I

0:27:24think that's a pretty good distinction

0:27:25but a more recent one that's really been

0:27:27occurring to me because internet is the

0:27:29difference between hearing and listening

0:27:30listening means that you pay attention

0:27:35to something for more than content when

0:27:37you I think when you listen to someone

0:27:39you're looking to go way beyond what

0:27:41they think they're saying what you think

0:27:44they're saying to learn more about who

0:27:46they are and what they think and the

0:27:48context for why they're saying what

0:27:50they're saying that you know god damn it

0:27:52you fucking gamergate douchebags it

0:27:54means more than just trying to

0:27:56contradict the facts of what somebody

0:27:57says right means trying to hear what

0:28:00they're saying and then listen to why

0:28:02they're saying it so that you can

0:28:04understand the context for more than why

0:28:06they're not looking for a note from you

0:28:09on how they said it and what they said

0:28:10they're looking for you to have some

0:28:12empathy that sometimes means not talking

0:28:14sometimes that empathy means you just

0:28:16have to you're gonna have to sit here

0:28:17it's like meditation it's not going to

0:28:19take one minute to get good at this

0:28:20you're going to be here for a while and

0:28:21just not talk for a little while in

0:28:23order to really understand what these

0:28:24folks are talking about

0:28:26yeah and all those listen that's listen

0:28:28to me ultimately listening is an

0:28:29emotional exercise as opposed to hearing

0:28:33right and listening is so often right

0:28:37the when someone says just listen to me

0:28:40what their what they mean is don't ever

0:28:43stone ever offer a solution like I'm

0:28:47don't ever offer a critique I just want

0:28:51you to listen as an emotional to be

0:28:55emotionally receptive you know so many

0:28:57people want

0:28:57to just be heard and it's it's it's

0:29:01alien to me because I'm you know I'm

0:29:05from the beginning right I i was that I

0:29:10was at a preschool meeting the other day

0:29:12and then and that teacher got up and

0:29:14said to everybody in the room can you

0:29:17remember the first time that you really

0:29:19felt heard by a teacher and everybody

0:29:23you know knotted thoughtfully and she

0:29:24was like I remember the first time I was

0:29:26ever heard by a teacher i was in 11th

0:29:28grade and the teacher you know really

0:29:30heard my project and it and you know and

0:29:35his response was what made me decide to

0:29:38be a teacher myself you know and we went

0:29:41around the room and everybody told the

0:29:43story about the first time they were

0:29:45ever heard really heard and noticed and

0:29:48seen by a teacher and you know the the

0:29:54problem for me was that there was never

0:29:55a time in my life when I didn't feel

0:29:58hurt by the teachers when I was three

0:30:02years old I assumed I was being listened

0:30:06to by the teachers and all the way

0:30:10through school I never once occurred to

0:30:13me that the teacher didn't know not only

0:30:16you know my name and what I was working

0:30:18on and and was validating my process but

0:30:22was like celebrating me and I see it in

0:30:25my daughter to like there's there's no

0:30:28question in her mind that that that

0:30:32everyone is listening to her and it's a

0:30:36and I was sitting next to a woman who

0:30:38was like well you know I no one ever

0:30:40listen to me I but I got straight A's

0:30:42and that's how I knew that's how they

0:30:44knew me they knew me as the girl that

0:30:47got straight a's but I you know I don't

0:30:48think anybody I never spoke I was like

0:30:51it's very different very different

0:30:54experience that I've had and you know

0:30:58and and in contrast to what what what

0:31:02kind of surprised me was the majority

0:31:04experience which was feeling unheard

0:31:06and so you know that that my whole life

0:31:12I've spent learning to listen without

0:31:16offering a an opinion how boy because

0:31:22you know though because the it was a it

0:31:27was not my instinct right and I have

0:31:30known a lot of strong people who have

0:31:33said over and over since the time I was

0:31:3422 years old i am going to i had a bad

0:31:37day today I'm going to talk about it to

0:31:40you and I would like you to just listen

0:31:42and that was a that was a something it

0:31:46when i was 18 19 20 it was really hard

0:31:48for me to just listen

0:31:49but I've learned I learned to do it it's

0:31:51the it's like you say it's um it's one

0:31:54of the things you do in a relationship

0:31:55I'm trying to avoid the else in the room

0:31:57its i think that what you're describing

0:32:00is absolutely true and i think that for

0:32:02something like 25 years now we looked at

0:32:04it as this Mars and Venus thing where I

0:32:07mean I was all speak for myself it

0:32:09I didn't realize how terrible i was at

0:32:11just listening to people for a very long

0:32:13time i realize i'm still not as good at

0:32:15it as like as I can be but i'm at least

0:32:18aware that i need to just fucking relax

0:32:20and let the other person talk sometimes

0:32:23not just because you know one thing also

0:32:25with with both of us is not an excuse or

0:32:27a to forgiveness but when we say things

0:32:29like right like you don't mean like I

0:32:32think that shows in some ways that where

0:32:34it's not just that we want you to agree

0:32:35with us like I'm constantly doubting

0:32:37whether i said what i was actually

0:32:39thinking whether my thought made any

0:32:41sense and whether i'm really just having

0:32:43if I'm just not realizing i haven't

0:32:45faced yet i'm constantly thinking do I

0:32:47make any sense when I speak to people

0:32:49don't want to hear myself and I say

0:32:50things like that make sense

0:32:51like I know how needy that sounds but

0:32:53part of that is actually me going like

0:32:55ah my brain just runs all the time it's

0:32:59just going and going and going and

0:33:00sometimes it's like little gumball

0:33:01machine your pop little slot open and

0:33:03sometimes stuff comes out and i'm just

0:33:04not even sure if that constitutes

0:33:06anything meaningful so part of that is

0:33:08when you say things like it becomes a

0:33:09tick but it starts out as from that

0:33:11terrible place

0:33:12um I mean to me that's even different

0:33:15from you know what I mean yeah you know

0:33:16what I mean or like you know Walter

0:33:18Sobchak am I wrong like this or does

0:33:20all mean kind of different things yeah I

0:33:21was it was there was a little bit of

0:33:23adjustment when you and I got to be

0:33:25friends when you would get to the end of

0:33:27someone go right and i would hear that

0:33:30means I'm done talking

0:33:31well I was here like that you expected

0:33:33an affirmation and then later later on

0:33:36as time went on I realized that you were

0:33:38seriously asking correct am I correct or

0:33:41sometimes yeah for sure you know do you

0:33:44d-does what I've just said and does my

0:33:46perception square with your perception

0:33:47but beyond that the beyond the beyond

0:33:50the Mars and Venus part it uh it is

0:33:53something that I think most men I

0:33:55probably in America men of our age

0:33:59how are really thinking about this maybe

0:34:02I'm projecting here but i was thinking

0:34:03about it seriously for the first time

0:34:06because we've expected that everybody

0:34:07was going to listen to us and what we

0:34:08had to say and if they didn't they were

0:34:10they were dumber black like that they

0:34:12just couldn't get like how what we're

0:34:15saying should be received wisdom in some

0:34:18ways and I don't know it's uh I'm

0:34:20finding it a very very interesting

0:34:23challenge to get better at that and that

0:34:27was despite back to that other personal

0:34:28example those my nicely the worst like

0:34:30if I had a look at girlfriend who had a

0:34:32bad day i was i was always ready to just

0:34:35be the problem solver before she could

0:34:37even she would exhale start to speak a

0:34:39sentence and i would start coming up

0:34:41with ideas why don't you take a bath

0:34:42want to take a walk should get some

0:34:44dinner

0:34:44oh that probably wasn't what you thought

0:34:46it was and i'm offering all these things

0:34:47to do what to a solve a problem but

0:34:49importantly be just make her feel better

0:34:52and everything is that's not my job like

0:34:55is I'm not there to make her feel better

0:34:57i'm here to shut the fuck up and let her

0:34:58describe what it is clear that what

0:35:00she's feeling

0:35:01although part of your job as being as

0:35:04being a you know in a relationship with

0:35:05somebody is to make them feel better and

0:35:07that's what's now just not always on my

0:35:10terms

0:35:10yeah i think the difference between

0:35:11making somebody making somebody feel

0:35:13better about something versus just

0:35:15trying to make everything go back to

0:35:18this the way that you're comfortable

0:35:19with

0:35:20I mean this is the primary the primary

0:35:23problem in my mother's relationship with

0:35:25my sister which is that my mother is a

0:35:28solver and my sister wants

0:35:31to talk about our feelings and so

0:35:34although they're you know they're

0:35:37mother-daughter bond is is very strong

0:35:41my sister comes in and starts to vent

0:35:44about her day and my mom says well why

0:35:46don't you why don't you talk to your

0:35:49boss tomorrow and tell him that that

0:35:50that's not acceptable and my sister goes

0:35:53the problem you know and she then she

0:35:56starts to talk about heard a little bit

0:35:58more on my mom says well why don't you

0:35:59just you know like it if you just

0:36:02enrolled at the community center how

0:36:04many problems with that and uh it's just

0:36:07my mom's nature to do that because you

0:36:12know it's very hard to because that

0:36:15because the expression might my sister

0:36:18the the way that my sister expresses her

0:36:20frustration about her day is very

0:36:23discomforting right or discomforting

0:36:27yeah where you know where she's

0:36:30expressing frustration by means of

0:36:33saying like it's just it'sit's in just

0:36:35that might be another my boss just

0:36:37doesn't see that it's not you know like

0:36:39I should be able to have a five-minute

0:36:41smoking break and you know my sister's

0:36:43mad and she's and she's venting and my

0:36:46mom says well you know I mean did you

0:36:49think to take your five-minute smoking

0:36:51break you know when you go to the

0:36:52bathroom where my mom's trying to miss

0:36:54it and now at that point she's more like

0:36:55an editor or or a coach where she's

0:36:58trying to like help improve performance

0:36:59yeah a coach and and but part of that is

0:37:02that that like but I think rationally

0:37:05i've been i've been watching this

0:37:07dynamic for 40 years but you know my mom

0:37:10feels like my sister's agitation is

0:37:15something that she wants to help resolve

0:37:18sure that that's the biggest part in

0:37:21some ways right and that that resolution

0:37:23that part of that resolution is that my

0:37:26sister isn't seeing or it you know that

0:37:29that she could change her behavior and

0:37:32resolve this problem or that she could

0:37:34take a different tact and what and my

0:37:36sister is once just to vent her emotions

0:37:41and then the the feeling will pass

0:37:44and then she'll go back to doing the

0:37:48behavior that got her in trouble with

0:37:50her boss you know and and and and and

0:37:53partly my perception of it is that is it

0:37:56is back to introvert extrovert polarity

0:38:02where you know Susan wants to vent her

0:38:07emotions she does not want to solve her

0:38:10problems and my mom wants to solve

0:38:12problems so that emotions do not ever

0:38:15enter into it it's a completely

0:38:18different paradigm the different

0:38:20paradigm and yeah and-and-and watching

0:38:22it over the years be characterized in

0:38:24the press as a as a Mars Venus issue but

0:38:27then watching it play out between the

0:38:29two you know the two primary women in my

0:38:31family I've had been forced to see it as

0:38:33a as part of the either introvert

0:38:36extrovert a paradigm or the emotional

0:38:41rational you know

0:38:42yeah right and and honestly like

0:38:45sometimes I laugh and laugh and laugh

0:38:47because I hear my sister start to go on

0:38:50something and I realized that it isn't a

0:38:52you know she just is she just needs to

0:38:57offload her feelings about something and

0:39:01I look over my mom like please stand

0:39:03this just please stay out of it but

0:39:05there are other times when listening to

0:39:07my sister vent like I also feel like you

0:39:12yell about this every afternoon it's the

0:39:13same problem every time why don't you

0:39:15just stop taking your smoke break right

0:39:17under your bosses window is that so

0:39:19crazy and and it's a big because

0:39:24ultimately like I don't want to hear the

0:39:26same emotional vent everyday like it is

0:39:29in emotional venting of that kind is

0:39:32actually stressful for her to even just

0:39:36to be a passive witness just to be a

0:39:38listener and that's the that's the

0:39:40relationship part of it where you

0:39:42realize and then the thing that

0:39:44emotional Venters maybe don't always see

0:39:46is that listening to them is requires

0:39:51energy also and listen even if the event

0:39:55they're not in the room I mean just kind

0:39:56of preparing for going like wow I

0:39:58today went ok yeah right i mean and at

0:40:02and this is the this is the classic

0:40:03problem that introverts have with

0:40:05experts which is that introverts are

0:40:06very very aware of what extrovert Sneed

0:40:11extrovert are typically not even

0:40:16conscious that there is such a thing as

0:40:18an introvert let alone that an introvert

0:40:21has different needs

0:40:22who and so you know my sister is

0:40:25conscious of the fact that that week you

0:40:29know that we somehow are bad listeners

0:40:31but not aware of how much it takes out

0:40:37of us to listen to a litany of complaint

0:40:42where it seems like the solution is easy

0:40:44and this you know this is a this is a

0:40:46it's and when I say us it's only that my

0:40:49mom and I have a similar nature i got i

0:40:52got out of that game a long time ago in

0:40:54my own family and that's where

0:40:56pretending to read has been a fantastic

0:41:00strategy in Milan my whole adult life

0:41:02pretending pretending to read struggling

0:41:05to actually read while people are

0:41:06fighting in the other room but so that

0:41:09you know that a that communication style

0:41:13like right now we're in an era where

0:41:16listening and talking are very there you

0:41:19know vario courant little different

0:41:22different ways of listening for being

0:41:24you know being sort of challenge to

0:41:26listen better but the but the awareness

0:41:29that listening is also a very active

0:41:32activity and if you are listening

0:41:37actively it is it it is a strain it

0:41:40takes you know not not a not a not

0:41:42necessarily a painful strain but it is

0:41:44an exercise it does take vitamins it it

0:41:48isn't it is if it isn't passive than

0:41:50that means it's if there's not an effort

0:41:52the person's probably not really

0:41:53listening right probably barely even

0:41:54hearing and that effort is also you know

0:41:57that effort is also real and for some

0:41:59for a lot of introverts like that that

0:42:01effort is that makes them need to go sit

0:42:05in a dark room and with a wet towel over

0:42:07their head

0:42:07there's also an element of I guess I

0:42:12always use this word wrong now sensitive

0:42:13about it but there's also an element of

0:42:15having to inertia inertia or momentum

0:42:18velocity torque there's an element of

0:42:21empathy and I think that I don't know

0:42:25not sure that's exactly the right word

0:42:26but i think one way to think about

0:42:28empathy is that it's easy to be

0:42:31empathetic it's easy to feel the

0:42:33feelings or understand the feelings of

0:42:35somebody who has the same feelings as

0:42:36you do it's very you know what i mean

0:42:37when somebody is it has been you know if

0:42:40if you have a god forbid you've got a

0:42:44sibling that died and talk to somebody

0:42:45who recently had a sibling that died

0:42:47you might be really a good person to

0:42:49talk to because you you probably

0:42:51somebody who can understand what they're

0:42:52going through you know it is sure that

0:42:54get even more specific but no matter

0:42:56what it is it's not it's not as

0:42:58difficult to have empathy for somebody

0:43:00that you think a has the same feelings

0:43:02as you and importantly be deserves to

0:43:04have those feelings and right i think

0:43:06where it gets challenging them where you

0:43:08get the real actual idea of empathy is

0:43:10when you start trying to understand not

0:43:14just how somebody feels but why they are

0:43:16how they appear to you whether they

0:43:18deserve that feeling or not that's true

0:43:20empathy trip with the and I must be good

0:43:23at this but is what i'm working toward

0:43:25is to get better at going gosh it sure

0:43:27is easy to chunk everybody into one of

0:43:30these 11 boxes that I've got and that

0:43:32sure makes life a lot easier i can then

0:43:33focus on like one or two of these boxes

0:43:35most the time and you know the rest is

0:43:37garbage people that the difficult part

0:43:39is that to become truly empathetic

0:43:40person and I'm going somewhere with this

0:43:42is really empathetic person you have to

0:43:44get good at understanding what's not

0:43:46just on the surface whether that you

0:43:47think that very good and deserving

0:43:48person to have those feelings whether

0:43:50you think their grievances are

0:43:52appropriate

0:43:55whether you think their ideas about what

0:43:56should change our realistic that you

0:43:59know it's very it's very easy to get

0:44:02shortcuts about those things to where

0:44:03you can just write all those people off

0:44:05but talked before about teachers need to

0:44:07be a good teacher and to be maybe to be

0:44:10a good arm

0:44:11it's a politician because that implies

0:44:13muscle tissue there to election year

0:44:14going to be a good public servant you

0:44:17have to have an element of empathy you

0:44:19have to be realistic about knowing what

0:44:20can be accomplished

0:44:21but it seems to me you have to become

0:44:22very empathetic about listening and

0:44:25hearing from people where you may not

0:44:27even understand where they're coming

0:44:28from you start trying to figure out

0:44:29whether there are chemtrails person but

0:44:31doesn't make sense like the end of the

0:44:32area does that make sense but to me

0:44:34that's the empathy part is empathy is

0:44:36not just feeling for people who you like

0:44:38and agree with empathy is learning to

0:44:40try and understand or at least hear

0:44:43people that you may be absolutely don't

0:44:45agree with you at least hear that

0:44:47mountain figure out like why they're how

0:44:48they are and then live with the fact

0:44:49that maybe you'll just never agree and

0:44:51maybe that doesn't make them the worst

0:44:52person in the world

0:44:53they're just really just fucking

0:44:54different well it's interesting because

0:44:57in Star Trek new generation is that what

0:45:02it's called is a newer next i've been

0:45:05criticized for this criticized or have

0:45:07you just been a mention have you just

0:45:09been listened to on people have heard

0:45:12you say star trek new generation I'm not

0:45:14putting this happens and you're the

0:45:17house is being handed ok so in the

0:45:19second generation of us on track in the

0:45:21in the latest generation not the latest

0:45:23i'm sorry in the original next new

0:45:26generation so what we're talking about

0:45:27is episode to episode negative 2 of the

0:45:33new generation of Star Trek there this

0:45:36is the one professor x in the guy from

0:45:37the cruise Professor X Professor X

0:45:41Professor X that his name that I say

0:45:44that wrong

0:45:45jean-luc Picard jean-luc general ordered

0:45:49jean-luc Picard you know there is an

0:45:53empath character on the ship and that

0:45:57was you know at the time when that show

0:46:00came out it was like oh wow wouldn't

0:46:03isn't that a kind of it that's a cool

0:46:05bit of writing to imagine the future him

0:46:11to imagine a science future which were

0:46:13all geeking on having not just a doctor

0:46:17and a science officer and a navigator

0:46:20and a chemist but also a feelings

0:46:24professional right when that when Star

0:46:28Trek new generation first came out it

0:46:29was the first time that we had ever seen

0:46:31a feelings professional it on a science

0:46:35show and that was that was kind of a

0:46:40little bit of a like a brain tickle is

0:46:42that Troy commander Troi around and so

0:46:49but but but very clearly at that point

0:46:53in time it was and in the writing of

0:46:56that show there were you know there were

0:47:00scripts their storylines where someone

0:47:02needed to go talk to Troy go talk to

0:47:06Commander Troi she was the she was the

0:47:08one who had the the expertise and

0:47:11sometimes you know there would be an

0:47:12alien that they an alien intelligence

0:47:15that they were encountering and at that

0:47:18point they hadn't had any Troy scripts

0:47:20for a while and so they would they'd

0:47:22figure out a way that Troy needed they

0:47:25needed her wisdom and insight to

0:47:27interact with this alien life form but

0:47:29for the most part it was still that they

0:47:32were using science to explore the

0:47:34universe and more often than not the way

0:47:37to encounter an alien life-form was to

0:47:40put the shields up and power up the

0:47:44photon torpedoes right now we're going

0:47:48through a cultural phase where empathy

0:47:51for someone like you is being encouraged

0:47:55by you know the the multiplicity of

0:47:59voices in the in the world to really

0:48:02really focus on empathy but there are

0:48:07empaths in our world and then there are

0:48:11people that will never you know that who

0:48:14are constitutionally really incapable of

0:48:16empathy and empathy is just another one

0:48:20of our talents like sports ball like

0:48:24being able to run or jump and some

0:48:26people are really really good at it and

0:48:28some people need to really train to

0:48:32activate it in themselves and there are

0:48:34there are cultural dampers that

0:48:37we put on it but then there are there's

0:48:39a whole swath of the world

0:48:42twenty-five percent of the people

0:48:43probably just have no empathy and or or

0:48:49or little empathy and so I don't think

0:48:54that empathy is a thing that everybody

0:48:55can have and I think it's something that

0:48:57it's great that where we talked about in

0:48:58are aware of but like there are also

0:49:01many well I've been on the Joe Cruz five

0:49:04times I know what it I know what it's

0:49:06like to be in a world where empathy is

0:49:09the is the language currency but there

0:49:12are a lot of people on the spectrum for

0:49:15whom empathy is a is a distance idea and

0:49:20I don't you know I don't know where

0:49:21we're going to be in 20 years on this

0:49:23but and I'm and I'm glad we're talking

0:49:26about it but there's also like my mom

0:49:28has as much empathy is she can have and

0:49:30it isn't and it isn't enough for my

0:49:32sister and never will be right and over

0:49:37the years I have said to my sister like

0:49:39you're the one that has this deep

0:49:41capacity for empathy can you not show

0:49:44any for your mother who has no real

0:49:47capacity for it and that's where I found

0:49:51the the greater struggle like my mom can

0:49:54say i don't know i don't know how to

0:49:56empathize with this it just seems like

0:49:59complaining to me but I know that about

0:50:02myself and I and I try to not talk i try

0:50:09to you know she's gone as far as to try

0:50:13to bake her way out of it

0:50:16what if I made cookies you know like

0:50:18literally tried to try anything

0:50:21Wow but the the empathetic one the one

0:50:24with all the feelings my sister doesn't

0:50:26has never been able to find the

0:50:28reservoir of feeling on behalf of the

0:50:32person with no empathy that's the kind

0:50:35of ironic part yeah and it and it and so

0:50:37often it is in this conversation where

0:50:40it's like yeah well you know this person

0:50:42has trouble sharing your feelings can

0:50:44you can you feel that

0:50:46do you have feelings can you share those

0:50:48feelings so I don't know you know like

0:50:51uh I think that I'm definitely not a

0:50:56science officer I'm much more really of

0:50:59an impact but not so much of a of an

0:51:03empath that I'm not ready to power up

0:51:05some photon torpedoes

0:51:06no I understand it's part of the job

0:51:07right you know what I mean like a lot of

0:51:09mission la a large steak explore new

0:51:12worlds yes seek out new civilizations

0:51:14yes who hit them with photon torpedoes

0:51:18Roddenberry's dream so I struggle

0:51:24yeah well as long as you talk about our

0:51:26feelings the you know this is that this

0:51:29other thing that I again I i always feel

0:51:31like I'm just saying something it's so

0:51:33obvious but it's something I want I i

0:51:35find very almost impossible to deal with

0:51:38in in my own life and so I find a triple

0:51:41impossible to try to be something that I

0:51:42lightly gently try to impart on my kid

0:51:45which is this really strange strange

0:51:49message about how much you can actually

0:51:52change about stuff at a given time in

0:51:55the world and how much you can change

0:51:56about other people because that you just

0:51:59said in part on my kid instead of in

0:52:02part to my kid and that as a as a dad

0:52:04that it's absolutely what it feels

0:52:05comprised of listen I'm going to impart

0:52:07this on you and high it myself but

0:52:12here's what here's what it comes down to

0:52:14I mean here's an example we get up to

0:52:16the i don't know i'm always talk about

0:52:17crossing the street except it's

0:52:18something we do a lot and so it's

0:52:19something to think about a lot is

0:52:20something where I want her to be

0:52:21actively engaged in the process of

0:52:23crossing the street and talked about

0:52:25this a lot and in other dances across

0:52:27the street you don't go across the

0:52:28street without looking you don't go

0:52:29across the street like you like you're

0:52:30in war like you you you know it but it's

0:52:33such a it's such a delicate operation of

0:52:36trying to explain to a little kid here's

0:52:37what I don't want to there's millions i

0:52:39don't want to I don't make them careless

0:52:40on the one and the other end I don't

0:52:42want to make her scared and so I try to

0:52:44impart something in between which which

0:52:46is that there's something very

0:52:47complicated going on here

0:52:49the basics are things like look left

0:52:50right and left but then keep looking

0:52:51keep making onto my contact keep going

0:52:54across but then the thing that I want to

0:52:57say very gently is even if we do this

0:52:59part

0:52:59quickly things can still go wrong I and

0:53:02we have no control over that and

0:53:04understanding that has a strange and I'm

0:53:06not about to explain this to a

0:53:07seven-year-old cause I barely understand

0:53:08it but there's a certain existential

0:53:09freedom and realizing that things always

0:53:11could go wrong even if you do your best

0:53:13but that doesn't mean you don't still

0:53:15try to do your best and so in in that

0:53:17kind of an instance I guess I'm the

0:53:18larger message I'm trying to impart on

0:53:21her is is that I and the thing that I

0:53:24need to learn all the time is that just

0:53:26because they're let's say I try to be

0:53:28empathetic and I fail I see other people

0:53:31feeling of being apathetic it doesn't

0:53:32mean we can't keep trying and like even

0:53:34if the system is broken we still have to

0:53:36do what we think is right and we still

0:53:38have two and god willing in the right

0:53:39atmosphere we should we continue to

0:53:41learn and get better and we don't just

0:53:42you know dig in around something that

0:53:45may be an old dead or bad idea but you

0:53:48know but part of sanity in life is

0:53:50realizing that on you know let's get to

0:53:53this part of thinking empathetically the

0:53:55empathetic as well I mean justice you

0:53:56put them in a million different ways but

0:53:58I think about more than just your own

0:53:59dick in a given day right and just

0:54:01getting to a point where you can go look

0:54:02I I want to really try to understand

0:54:04where other people are coming from and

0:54:06then except you know what i don't

0:54:08understand what that person is coming

0:54:09from their kind of a dick and then go

0:54:11that's I just gotta move on it doesn't

0:54:13mean I'm going to treat them badly but

0:54:14it means that doesn't mean that the life

0:54:16ends because i can't settle this one

0:54:18relationship that just means that that's

0:54:19just how life is because it all is a

0:54:22question of how well my filter can make

0:54:24me feel like I understand how the

0:54:25fucking world works when I have never

0:54:27understand how the world works well you

0:54:30have a pretty good sense of element

0:54:32works

0:54:33yeah spins in one direction only

0:54:36mmm this is trying to move a little bit

0:54:38toward your torture project because i'm

0:54:41curious how these kinds of the reason

0:54:42I'm bringing these up is first of all to

0:54:44show you that I struggled to be a person

0:54:46but also that like how does this affect

0:54:47you I mean how is your listening to her

0:54:49going it's going really well and you

0:54:53know the that that the danger the the

0:54:57danger of of thinking of progress

0:55:02is that if you're a historian or at all

0:55:05interested in looking back at all in

0:55:08there is a feeling of progress over time

0:55:11right that we're just were not

0:55:13confronting the same problems that we

0:55:16were in 1651 not like the Middle Ages

0:55:20where we actually on the grand scale of

0:55:22things did move backward for a while

0:55:24right well and in some ways like

0:55:27learning moved backward but well yet

0:55:31technology sure like moved where we lost

0:55:36a lot of ground but we were also going

0:55:39through a phase a where we were

0:55:43developing through monotheism a whole

0:55:47complex set of new ideas about what

0:55:52would constitute a person and what

0:55:55constituted are ethical basis right that

0:55:58the idea of the idea of justice that we

0:56:00have today is a product of all that

0:56:04religious churning that happened in the

0:56:08Middle Ages which we think of as the

0:56:10dark ages

0:56:11so although we lost astronomy for a

0:56:14while and maybe lost the Roman concept

0:56:17of the aquaduct for a while and lost we

0:56:20lost a lot of intellectual ground as we

0:56:23moved from a world where from a

0:56:26polytheistic animist world to one that

0:56:30was rooted in this idea that there was

0:56:32one God and you could have a you know

0:56:35you could have a personal relationship

0:56:37with them and not just that you're out

0:56:39in the woods burning sheep bones to

0:56:42appeal to who the god of of of scabies

0:56:47to relieve your suffering but that you

0:56:50you know that your whole life and all of

0:56:52life is like rooted in this central

0:56:54authority that's where the I you know

0:56:58that's where we're all of our

0:57:00contemporary ideas of of the rights of

0:57:05man come from and so it wasn't just a it

0:57:09wasn't that a lot was lost we were just

0:57:12building a new thing for a while

0:57:13and-and-and so here we are and we are

0:57:17we've made tremendous progress

0:57:20there's lots and lots of progress yet to

0:57:22make its all thought technology and

0:57:28we're in a were in a a mode right now

0:57:31that's very active the generation that

0:57:33followed hours and the generation that

0:57:35followed them is just bigger than we are

0:57:37and louder than we are and maybe the

0:57:40biggest loudest generation ever and

0:57:43they're gonna set the tone a lot more

0:57:45than we did or are capable of and

0:57:50there's you know they're the the spigot

0:57:53is wider so not everybody is coming from

0:57:56the same place and that's a very that's

0:57:59a that that's the maybe one of the

0:58:01hardest things to grapple with because

0:58:03there is as you try to resolve

0:58:05disagreement and you realize that that

0:58:09no one even accepts even one basic

0:58:13premise that the person they're arguing

0:58:15with accepts and that's kind of

0:58:17unprecedented I mean there is at even 50

0:58:21years ago the basic premises were all

0:58:25commonly held for the most part or if

0:58:28you if you were an outsider to those who

0:58:30didn't hold those you at least knew what

0:58:31they were and you and you looked at

0:58:35yourself in in opposition to those those

0:58:38common ideas but there are a lot of

0:58:40people now who just don't even know the

0:58:45first thing about what the other person

0:58:47where the other person is coming from

0:58:49not even the first thing and they're not

0:58:51especially interested huh

0:58:54you know I when you think about I don't

0:58:56know if you there was a really cool

0:58:58article in the new york times about

0:59:00Obama's visit to this little South

0:59:03Dakota town to give the commencement

0:59:05speech at their little technical college

0:59:09and I think a big part of the reason he

0:59:12went there was that he had he'd been to

0:59:1449 of the 50 states and kind of letter

0:59:16the letter from that little girl

0:59:18yeah right exactly yeah and so he came

0:59:21to South Dakota to give the commencement

0:59:23speech at this little college but this

0:59:24article was written

0:59:26this reporter just went to the town and

0:59:28talk to a bunch of locals before Obama

0:59:31arrived and South Dakota was

0:59:36overwhelmingly a republican state no one

0:59:39in this little town voted for obama and

0:59:42in the advance of him arriving the

0:59:45reporter talk to all these people are

0:59:46like he wants to make it a Muslim

0:59:48country and and he doesn't even know

0:59:50it's a just all that usual stuff and

0:59:54then Obama came and hundreds of people

0:59:57in the town turned out went down to the

0:59:59airport

0:59:59airport

1:00:00or to watch the plane land as he drove

1:00:02through the town the reporter was you

1:00:05know followed this group of people that

1:00:07had been talking to already here she I

1:00:09don't know actually what I didn't look

1:00:13at the name of the reporter but followed

1:00:15the followed their responses and they

1:00:18were all thrilled that Obama wave to

1:00:21them that they saw the President and

1:00:25then they watched his speech on

1:00:26television and they were moved to tears

1:00:28that he was talking about their town and

1:00:31you know and then he was only he was

1:00:35only on the ground for a couple of hours

1:00:36drove his car back to the airport again

1:00:39you know people crowding the streets to

1:00:41see him off he flies and at least the

1:00:44you know through the narrow lens of this

1:00:47reporters experienced a lot of those

1:00:50people were their opinion about obama

1:00:53was transformed by just that tiny little

1:00:57bit of physical contact where they went

1:01:00from thinking he was the Antichrist to

1:01:05admiring him and thinking that he had

1:01:07given a good speech and like were

1:01:10surprised and astonished and and touched

1:01:14and moved by the whole experience and of

1:01:17course that's true right i mean i was

1:01:19vociferously against Reagan but if I had

1:01:25ever seen Reagan let alone seat been

1:01:29close to Reagan i'm sure i would have

1:01:30swooned over and that that sense of of

1:01:39how much we share and how little actual

1:01:42differences we have you only get that

1:01:46experience by being around other people

1:01:49by you know by traveling thing we talked

1:01:51about this all the time these

1:01:52disagreements on the Internet where

1:01:53people are just screaming at each other

1:01:55and if they were in the same room they

1:01:56would be you know fast friends are like

1:01:58and anyone who has ever traveled through

1:02:02Alabama knows that they're the

1:02:04friendliest people in the world and and

1:02:06terrible racists

1:02:09but-but-but wonderful people in so many

1:02:12other way

1:02:13now as a you know not apology but just

1:02:17as normal human experience and that's

1:02:20what we don't share anymore and so being

1:02:26out on the campaign trail and talking to

1:02:28everybody like I am the focus of a lot

1:02:32of energy directed at me I'm the hub of

1:02:36that wheel and I'm meeting people from a

1:02:38lot of different spheres and all I

1:02:41wishes that they could all meet each

1:02:42other for you know like uh huh i'm i'm

1:02:46seeing this incredible diversity of of

1:02:49thinking I'm meeting a lot of 25

1:02:51year-olds like the like the girl in the

1:02:54louie ck store who at 25 years old

1:02:59already has all the wisdom in it and

1:03:01that she thinks she's ever gonna need

1:03:03and what you know and I whatever that

1:03:06episode is trying to convey what we

1:03:08don't know is six months later is her

1:03:10store closed because she's rude to

1:03:12customers

1:03:13I mean that's the that's the that's the

1:03:16thing that that kind of like well I'm

1:03:18doing fine and you know maybe you need

1:03:20to get with the times because look it's

1:03:22just like well I mean or like so many 25

1:03:27years before you you think you can start

1:03:29a store and be rude to people and you

1:03:31don't need to be nice to old white men

1:03:34because they're irrelevant to you and

1:03:36then your store closes because you're

1:03:37rude and a bad a customer service person

1:03:40and then you learn like so many people

1:03:43have before you that customer service is

1:03:46part of the equation and so I'm eating a

1:03:49lot of very active 25 year-olds

1:03:51politically active 25 year-olds who

1:03:53think they already know everything there

1:03:56is to know about a city about government

1:03:58that's a great great age for that it's

1:04:00incredible and when I was that started

1:04:02that that's really the perfect age to

1:04:03feel like you know everything

1:04:04yeah right you so easily your you you

1:04:07are very smart at that age and maybe

1:04:10smarter than 40 rolls because you still

1:04:12have all your brain cells but what you

1:04:14you know but what you don't know is all

1:04:17the stuff you don't know and so I'm

1:04:21talking to people all the time who are

1:04:22just like well the solution is simple

1:04:23but a bit of it

1:04:25and I and you go well that is a simple

1:04:29solution until you start to become aware

1:04:32that every solution causes 42 other

1:04:36problems you didn't anticipate and they

1:04:39go well no it's like yes I mean I i have

1:04:45i have conversations all the time with

1:04:47with people who seem with young people

1:04:52I'm talking about there who do not

1:04:54understand that they did not invent the

1:04:58civil rights movement and I'm like you

1:05:01know people have been doing this work

1:05:02for a long time and the struggles have

1:05:06been different the challenges have been

1:05:07different but you are here able to speak

1:05:11this way because people have been doing

1:05:13this work for a long time and so the

1:05:18indignation you feel that we're not

1:05:21moving fast enough i would just like to

1:05:23direct your attention back just a few

1:05:25years to where we were then and imagine

1:05:28how indignant you would feel like this

1:05:32is this is you know like Anna and i'm

1:05:35not saying that by way of saying like

1:05:37respect your elders I'm just saying get

1:05:39a little context these ideas just

1:05:42because just because Twitter is new and

1:05:46snapchat is new does not mean that the

1:05:49ideas that are being expressed there are

1:05:50equally new and unprecedented and it's a

1:05:54it's a real challenge and I'd so I the

1:05:57the excitement of the campaign is that

1:06:01I'm talking to people from what we had

1:06:02we had a meeting yesterday of my

1:06:04volunteer squad it was just people that

1:06:08had offered to volunteer for the

1:06:09campaign and 25 people showed up on

1:06:12mother's day and they were all ages from

1:06:172265 and there and it was like a real

1:06:26cross-section of people in seattle

1:06:29people who had only lived here for six

1:06:30months people who live their entire

1:06:31lives

1:06:33people with the Masters in Social Work

1:06:36people that worked political campaigns

1:06:38people that were just artists and I

1:06:40don't mean just artists to say that

1:06:43being an artist is lesser but just that

1:06:45that's you know that they are coming

1:06:47from the arts place and engaging in this

1:06:50campaign out of a like pretty confused

1:06:53about what is even happening here a

1:06:56politically and it was incredibly

1:06:59inspiring just have all these people in

1:07:01the room and listen to all there in a

1:07:03couple of teachers a couple of of the

1:07:05beauty of people from activists

1:07:10background and what I really wanted to

1:07:12do was just just say let's all sit here

1:07:15for hours and just talk about what you

1:07:18know like just start

1:07:19what's the single most important problem

1:07:21facing the city and the a we could it

1:07:24would have been a four hour long round

1:07:25table we didn't have that time but

1:07:28that's what i'm getting every day is

1:07:32this roundtable where it's all being too

1:07:37you know sort of directed at me either

1:07:38people trying to train me over people

1:07:41trying to school me people trying to

1:07:45connect with me people hoping that i

1:07:49will recognize their issue and then

1:07:52broadcast it for them you know and it's

1:07:55all really compelling and like it's

1:07:58moving it's moving my heart and that's

1:08:02that I think the best thing about it you

1:08:04know we get to be 45 and you're like oh

1:08:06maybe I'm you know maybe my heart can't

1:08:08move anymore right but i sat in a I i

1:08:12sat in a meeting where 20 people got up

1:08:15and spoke about the fact that the metro

1:08:18bus system had raised the bus fare 25

1:08:24cents fifty cents and at first it felt

1:08:29like how the I mean I i know that

1:08:34there's always gonna be somebody that's

1:08:35mad about anything but in actually

1:08:39listening to 20 different people testify

1:08:42that they were trying to survive on

1:08:46750 dollars a month and that they needed

1:08:51to take the bus that you know they

1:08:55needed to take five buses every day and

1:08:58that that what seemed like a small fare

1:09:01increase actually was was prohibiting

1:09:07them from getting certain foods at the

1:09:10grocery store and that they had that

1:09:14they were supporting their children and

1:09:16their elderly incapacitated parent and

1:09:20they were the only burger and you you're

1:09:24one of those are like whoa that person

1:09:26has like a really bad scene but when you

1:09:31hear 20 people tell a story like that

1:09:34and you realize that these are the 20 of

1:09:36these people who took another two buses

1:09:40to come to this meeting to talk about it

1:09:43right right so you have to think that

1:09:45they are there a small percentage of a

1:09:48very small percentage of the number of

1:09:50people who are surviving at this you

1:09:52know at a level where 50 cent bus fare

1:09:56change or 25-cent bus fare change is a

1:10:00significant change in their in their

1:10:01welfare and you just go holy shit like

1:10:05this isn't like politics is important

1:10:09work and income inequality is

1:10:12desperately real somewhere in this town

1:10:15right now there are people who are who

1:10:18are you know throwing their xbox in the

1:10:21garbage because somebody spilled some

1:10:24pop on it or somebody spilled a drop on

1:10:26and they don't like it being sticky and

1:10:29you know and over here i'm sitting in a

1:10:31basement listening to these stories and

1:10:33it's just like by while wall you know

1:10:38but at the same time like I've been

1:10:44thinking about Jeff Bezos a lot i know

1:10:47you think about Jeff Bezos I've been

1:10:49thinking about him a lot because he's a

1:10:51piece of a big figure here in Seattle

1:10:53and he's an important key to

1:10:58what that what's going to happen in the

1:10:59city and he kind of keeps himself at a

1:11:03distance but he has a lot of employees a

1:11:07lot of them are like good people the

1:11:10culture of amazon is very circle the

1:11:13wagons but i don't know how much you're

1:11:16aware of Jeff bezos's Blue Origin

1:11:20project I don't know that is jeff is one

1:11:24of a like SpaceX and like Elon Musk Jeff

1:11:29is also a space visionary and he is

1:11:32building a manned space program I had no

1:11:36idea a lot of people don't know because

1:11:39he keeps it kind of is not real

1:11:42publicity-hungry about it

1:11:44he's not a showboater like Elon Musk but

1:11:49he is you know using his own resources

1:11:51to build a space capsule for a normals

1:11:58for regulars to go into space and it is

1:12:02pretty far along is his kids quiet space

1:12:07program like far enough along that they

1:12:11had a launch not very long ago of the of

1:12:14like an actual rocket that they had

1:12:15designed not a rocket that they bought

1:12:17from Russia not a rocket but that not a

1:12:19used rocket but a brand new rocket that

1:12:23they have designed from the ground up

1:12:25and constructed and launched I can i

1:12:28feel kind of dumb that i didn't know

1:12:29this

1:12:29I don't you shouldn't feel dumb because

1:12:31they're very quiet about it it's a

1:12:32rocket that let me let me just put it a

1:12:34let me like put it in a different

1:12:36contract it's a rocket that one the one

1:12:39the the bottom stage is done

1:12:42launching the capsule it actually

1:12:44parachutes back and lands with like

1:12:48retrorocket firing like lands on the

1:12:51ground who doesn't it doesn't fall into

1:12:53the ocean it's like it returns to Earth

1:12:55the rocket and the capsule has like it's

1:12:59a beautiful it's beautiful thing six

1:13:01people can ride on a you know in their

1:13:04plan is in the very near future to start

1:13:07allowing people to buy seats on this

1:13:09rocket to go up and do a like

1:13:12near-earth orbit weightless space

1:13:17experience so here's this guy he owns

1:13:21this company he's he is he's very

1:13:24wealthy he lives in Seattle

1:13:26he's hiring a lot of people and he is

1:13:31also building a space program that's

1:13:35also here in in the Seattle area and as

1:13:40you know I'm a big supporter of space

1:13:43exploration

1:13:44I think that's super great and the old

1:13:49canard that you that we shouldn't pour

1:13:53money into NASA because all that money

1:13:55could go to build low-income housing

1:13:57I've always felt like was a was a was a

1:14:00bad argument or like I understood i

1:14:02understand it from a liberal point of

1:14:04view that it seems like there's a

1:14:07limited number of dollars and why would

1:14:09you spend it going to space when people

1:14:11were poor but space exploration is like

1:14:15this at the soul of what I think we

1:14:17should be doing and we should also find

1:14:20the money to feed and house people and

1:14:24what and where that money should come

1:14:25from is not space exploration but all

1:14:27the people that have gold bathtubs right

1:14:30for some find a way somehow to tap into

1:14:33the the money and the energy that is

1:14:35going to build gold bathtubs for people

1:14:38and channel that money over but now that

1:14:43I'm spending a lot of time listening to

1:14:45people that need an extra twenty-five

1:14:47cents a date just to ride the bus like

1:14:51the context of all this stuff and this

1:14:54whole conversation is just like

1:14:56personally changed for me and I still

1:14:59want Jeff Bezos to explore space i just

1:15:03also want to you know to rope everybody

1:15:08in all the visionaries to to regather

1:15:13them into the conversation around around

1:15:18my town in particular right

1:15:20and try to figure out like we have we

1:15:25have this energy and this exploratory

1:15:26energy is great but I also want to say

1:15:30that it's it's an equal it's equally

1:15:35exciting to explore the idea of no one

1:15:40going hungry and it doesn't seem as

1:15:45exciting it's not as glamorous you don't

1:15:47get a space suit for it but it is also

1:15:51like a part of this feeling of progress

1:15:55her right

1:15:56the part of the feeling of like we keep

1:15:58moving

1:16:00I'm doing better and none of these

1:16:02things are

1:16:03it's not resolved that there will always

1:16:06be people starving

1:16:09why I want to sound cynical but it

1:16:12sounds like a guy i have no idea how

1:16:14somebody like that think somebody that

1:16:16kind of dough which course nobody ever

1:16:18feel like they have as much money as

1:16:19everybody thinks they do but in that

1:16:21case I mean I'll be rounding error like

1:16:23even if they given that look like a

1:16:25hundred thousand dollars right looking

1:16:27like like me you know maybe a day's

1:16:29worth of their time

1:16:30justjust on appearances like the optics

1:16:33of it alone it seems like why would you

1:16:35not do that and that though that's the

1:16:36that is the thing you know when when

1:16:41when you're talking to 25 year-olds and

1:16:43they're like well why doesn't just basis

1:16:44just pay the extra quarter for everybody

1:16:47it's like yes but the number of those

1:16:52things that the the bus fare the housing

1:16:58problem the mental health problem right

1:17:02like what we what we really need every

1:17:05person i talk to us like what we really

1:17:06need and you go

1:17:09we really do need a better mental health

1:17:12system where there are you know we

1:17:15closed the asylums and put all the

1:17:18people that used to be housed in asylums

1:17:22back on the streets

1:17:23yep and really what we should probably

1:17:27do is build some asylums again or go get

1:17:31those ones that we decommissioned before

1:17:33they

1:17:34fall into the ground and paint them and

1:17:37and get them working again and now we

1:17:39think about them differently we don't

1:17:42just one flew over the cuckoo's nest

1:17:44them but there are some people that need

1:17:47a place to be and that and they're never

1:17:50going to be reintegrated into society

1:17:52sites besides nowhere or jail

1:17:54besides nowhere or jail right besides a

1:17:56doorway or jail and it needs to be a

1:17:59thing that society funds and it needs to

1:18:01be a comfortable safe place and some of

1:18:03those people are going to be violence or

1:18:05angry or you know and they're in there

1:18:08need to be trained people there like at

1:18:11every step of the way we need is we need

1:18:15so much right these facilities you think

1:18:19about all the single mothers who are who

1:18:22end up homeless and they end up homeless

1:18:24because it's fucking hard to stay on top

1:18:28of the game and you've got two kids and

1:18:29all of a sudden you're living in your

1:18:30car and you don't even think of yourself

1:18:32as homeless you're just in between

1:18:33places you're living in your car and the

1:18:35kids have got to get to school and

1:18:37you've got to get to work and you're in

1:18:38your car and and that mother isn't even

1:18:43letting on to her kids that she's in

1:18:44trouble she's just like hey we're having

1:18:46fun we're living in our car for a little

1:18:47while mama figures out the next move and

1:18:52what we could do to help her or to make

1:18:55sure that that you know that that that

1:18:59that for a couple weeks she's doing that

1:19:02and then she reached then something else

1:19:04bad happens the car breaks down right or

1:19:07you know and then she really needs

1:19:10there's no wiggle room right then she

1:19:12really needs help and when she really

1:19:14needs help at that point when she's like

1:19:16oh fuck i'm up against the wall she

1:19:19rolls into someplace and they're like

1:19:21sit down and fill out this form now

1:19:23you're on a waiting list six months from

1:19:26now will call you know and it's just

1:19:28like no there's we don't have enough

1:19:31wiggle room for so many people and and

1:19:38yet we have obscene amounts of money

1:19:41right rich kids on instagram is also

1:19:44happening simultaneous to this

1:19:46and that that doesn't flame people and

1:19:51it and and the and the people that would

1:19:52tell us that it's unrelated are wrong

1:19:55and there's you know they're there it is

1:20:00related but what is it what is in our

1:20:03power to do and I think that the era of

1:20:10you know the area of armed revolution is

1:20:15in our past the era of really of using

1:20:18law as a as a cudgel is maybe in our

1:20:25past just because those rich kids on

1:20:28Instagram have the best lawyers you can

1:20:30get I think we're entering in and into

1:20:33an era where we have to wear empathy

1:20:37actually is the agent and where we say

1:20:41hey this is part of this is part of your

1:20:46wealth and success it's an it's and it

1:20:48is ultimately an auntie Tea Party

1:20:53argument or an auntie and Rand argument

1:20:56which is fine random sorry man I'm rond

1:21:01which is that we are all in this

1:21:05together your wealth did not come to you

1:21:07sure a purely by your own ingenuity but

1:21:11because we have provided this incubator

1:21:16which is our whole culture and now you

1:21:20know like you say wouldn't it be cool if

1:21:23in addition to to building a private

1:21:26space station or in addition to building

1:21:29a really cool electric cars we also were

1:21:35able to bolster the the the part of the

1:21:40of the couch where the stuffing is

1:21:42coming out

1:21:44and you know do you start making that

1:21:47argument on said council or do you start

1:21:50making that argument on your

1:21:51award-winning podcast like at what point

1:21:55do we get enough people together into

1:21:58this new way of thinking that's that's

1:21:59less shouty and finger-pointing and

1:22:03that's more just like a bunch of people

1:22:05standing there with compassionate looks

1:22:08on their faces saying hey we we don't

1:22:11begrudge you your success but you know

1:22:17chip in and that that doesn't mean go

1:22:19work for houses for Humanity it means

1:22:21like chip in right here

1:22:23well this is that the the quite

1:22:24interesting question to me is what

1:22:28you're describing it sounds really

1:22:29sensible it sounds like on the face of

1:22:31it that there should be something it

1:22:33let's put it this way it's not one of

1:22:34those things that is a basically

1:22:36impossible problem to solve it there is

1:22:39obviously something that can be done by

1:22:41somebody over some amount of time let's

1:22:43just take that is red so the question is

1:22:45how in your approach or your strategy or

1:22:49however you want to phrase it how do you

1:22:50differ from the other candidates and

1:22:53what you would choose to do differently

1:22:54in order to make something like that

1:22:56happen

1:22:58the exact question that gets asked every

1:23:02day I'm sorry and no it's good it's good

1:23:04it's it returned to be more empathetic

1:23:05it's the good it is a good question and

1:23:08you know ultimately the the first thing

1:23:11I can say is no other candidate is

1:23:14talking about this stuff that all this

1:23:15way right because the because the the

1:23:18conception is that all we have at our

1:23:21disposal is either that we can sue

1:23:24someone or pass a law that that requires

1:23:31that they you know that they and usually

1:23:35requires that they submit to attacks i

1:23:38mean that tax is our is our only model

1:23:42tablet you can also I mean I done it

1:23:46seems like a strange part part of what

1:23:49you do when you bring somebody and I

1:23:50think this is a little bit random but

1:23:51i'm thinking for example of like when

1:23:53you bring people into like a foundation

1:23:54board

1:23:55you might bring somebody into a

1:23:56foundation board because they're rich

1:23:58person and they'll theoretically give

1:24:00you a bunch of money but it could also

1:24:01be more importantly that they're good at

1:24:03getting money from other people that you

1:24:05know through mostly connections that's

1:24:07the wrong word but it seems like you

1:24:10know you can also be kind of a statesman

1:24:12who is good at making that case the

1:24:14people with a goal of course i'd love to

1:24:15help with that and I'll get my buddies

1:24:16to help with that right and Bill Clinton

1:24:19is great at this bill gates is good at

1:24:21it

1:24:22um but it is you know it's so often that

1:24:27the the the what we perceive to be the

1:24:30problem is i mean Bill Gates is has done

1:24:33incredible work providing clean water to

1:24:36people around the world he's saving tens

1:24:39hundreds of thousands of lives

1:24:41it's very much less glamorous to to

1:24:47build a facility in seattle for homeless

1:24:52mothers who have reached the end of

1:24:54their rope there's no glamour in it

1:24:57except except in the in that sort of the

1:25:04big small picture which is what if we

1:25:07built a city that had all of that with

1:25:11that took care of everybody

1:25:12it's also probably have an adventure i

1:25:16guess it's a difference in approach or

1:25:17outlook or composure I guess if you

1:25:23think about think about the people who

1:25:24if you wanna talk about entrepreneurs in

1:25:26particular people who made a lot of

1:25:28money you know through grit and

1:25:30determination and maybe dirty dealings

1:25:32whatever but the point is I you know in

1:25:34the same way that there are certain

1:25:35kinds of investors that are only

1:25:37interested in angel funding there are

1:25:38certain kinds you know I i would imagine

1:25:41that for most biting philanthropist

1:25:44there they're not as interested in the

1:25:48net at the bottom of not this is good or

1:25:50bad that they're not interested in the

1:25:51in a system of nets at the bottom of the

1:25:54building as they are in potentially

1:25:56showing up that top floors of people

1:25:58can't jump or even more deeply trying to

1:26:00fundamentally change why somebody would

1:26:01want to jump off that building and so in

1:26:03that case I i wonder if it's something

1:26:05where they talk about that not being

1:26:06very glamorous it certainly isn't it

1:26:08can the NIMBY stuff and all that I want

1:26:10to be more interested in some kind of

1:26:14programs that try to get get at that

1:26:17problem maybe not as early as John

1:26:19education maybe not as late as a shelter

1:26:21but somewhere in between so kind of

1:26:23intervention type thing you don't mean

1:26:25is it but I bet they'd be more

1:26:26interested in getting the problem

1:26:28earlier on

1:26:29well but that is exactly the way that

1:26:31we've been thinking about it for you

1:26:33know the second half of the 20th century

1:26:35and then just becomes a series of costly

1:26:36experiments

1:26:37well and just a kind of whack Amole like

1:26:39yes

1:26:41education is key and his is proved but

1:26:44you know but who is proved too to keep

1:26:48kids out of jail right later on in life

1:26:51but there's a whole lot of you who wants

1:26:55to fund quality education in seattle

1:26:57schools there any billionaire want to

1:26:59step up and do that

1:27:01hello hello zepp right are you still on

1:27:04the line like the only way we have to

1:27:07fund Seattle schools is through attacks

1:27:09and the only way that we are allowed to

1:27:11apply that tax is to the you know to

1:27:15everybody and we can do it through car

1:27:17tabs or we can do it through property

1:27:19tax or we can do it you know whether

1:27:21there are only so many ways to to to

1:27:24fund it and the rich people have really

1:27:27good excellent ways of avoiding paying

1:27:30their tax and so it falls to the middle

1:27:34class over and over and over and it

1:27:36would be wonderful if someone stepped

1:27:38forward and said I'll fun the Seattle

1:27:40schools with the rounding error on my

1:27:42you know on you I ego project over here

1:27:45and then there would be people that are

1:27:47like but but what about the homeless

1:27:49mothers and you know there's my

1:27:52principle is that if we I mean we all

1:27:56want we all want 40 years from now to

1:27:59have our city look and be a certain kind

1:28:05of pleasant prosperous place huh

1:28:08I can't imagine anybody with nobody

1:28:09would just reject that on the face it no

1:28:12one would reject it on the face of it

1:28:13and everybody's got a different idea

1:28:14about how to get there and a lot of

1:28:17people are like we just need to build

1:28:19taller buildings with bigger fences to

1:28:20keep people from jump

1:28:21off and then there are people that are

1:28:23like well the people that are falling

1:28:24off that building aren't jumping they're

1:28:27getting pushed i'm sorry there's a poor

1:28:28analogy but you know what i mean like

1:28:29your daughter who's living or whatever

1:28:31and there are a lot of technologists

1:28:33that do believe that the technology is

1:28:35just eventually going to make it

1:28:36impossible to be poor but when you look

1:28:39at the way that that actually works

1:28:41there just the they're assuming

1:28:43trickle-down economics they're using

1:28:45george herbert walker bushes philosophy

1:28:48that a rising tide lifts all boats and

1:28:51it just is demonstrable eon true right

1:28:54over the rich are getting richer but i

1:28:59do believe that we can say here's the

1:29:01city we want

1:29:02here's the city that we want and this is

1:29:05what it should look like and get

1:29:07everybody kind of onboard for the for

1:29:11some basic principles 40 years from now

1:29:16there shouldn't be a homeless person in

1:29:18Seattle that has no other options

1:29:22there's always gonna be somebody who's

1:29:24like fuck you i'm going to live in a

1:29:25garbage can

1:29:26but most people don't want to and a lot

1:29:31of the people that are living it that

1:29:33are like fuck you I'm want to live in a

1:29:34garbage can that it comes that night in

1:29:36November where they're like god dammit

1:29:39this was a bad idea right and in and we

1:29:44and where such a punitive society and

1:29:48end up in a moralistic one about about

1:29:52homelessness and drugs and mental

1:29:53illness we spend so much time saying

1:29:56well that single mother with her two

1:29:59kids should have smoked less pot in high

1:30:01school and done a little bit better and

1:30:02gone to tech school you know there's

1:30:05that there's that instinct we are

1:30:07oh we have in a as Americans to be like

1:30:09it's probably hurtful

1:30:11yeah and that judgmentalism keeps us

1:30:16from being able to have a at a real

1:30:20compassionate system because there's

1:30:23always somebody that's going to say i

1:30:25don't want my tax dollars to go to

1:30:27mollycoddle these these whores and it's

1:30:33just like well you know what that's

1:30:35really

1:30:35not how it is and and we and and the

1:30:39most of us here in Seattle recognize

1:30:41that and that's what you need is just

1:30:44the most of us but to get to get that

1:30:47vision of the city and then start

1:30:48reverse engineering practices rather

1:30:51than trying to build that city by each

1:30:55person saying well here's what we need

1:30:56here is what we need is we need to get

1:31:00get the picture first and then say what

1:31:04does that look like you know that what

1:31:05that's the 40 year plan now what did

1:31:07that look like at 30 years what did that

1:31:09look like it 20 years how would we get

1:31:11there and and build backwards from the

1:31:16from the goal and yeah and i think it

1:31:20will surprise us as we get like what did

1:31:22that look like a 10 years

1:31:23oh shit right that's what it looked like

1:31:26it 10 years and so to get to their we

1:31:30have to reevaluate what we're doing now

1:31:32we can't just keep you know keep

1:31:36flopping around like a bunch of a like a

1:31:39bunch of koi whose pond drained we need

1:31:45a we need to like get off get off of

1:31:48this get out of this rut and start doing

1:31:51some some weird and wonderful stuff now

1:31:54that will put us there in 10 years which

1:31:57isn't a solution but it is it's on the

1:32:01path to where we want to be in 20 years

1:32:03ever so that's the story that i'm trying

1:32:07to you know bring to the to this

1:32:10election and and that's what I'm trying

1:32:11to say about Seattle that we've tried

1:32:15all the we tried all this incremental

1:32:19like well what we need is you know we

1:32:22need to hire one more social worker to

1:32:25help fill out the forms at the office

1:32:28where you get in line for the for

1:32:31emergency housing it's like well we need

1:32:34more than that right we need to build we

1:32:37need to build and we need to build

1:32:40across a wide spectrum we need to fund

1:32:43the schools as though we're going to

1:32:45have to keep funding schools and not

1:32:46like the way we fund Seattle schools is

1:32:48we

1:32:49pass a bond for two years as though two

1:32:52years from now maybe there we won't have

1:32:54to pay for schools anymore

1:32:56fine an example if I understand what

1:32:59you're saying it's like well well how

1:33:00did they end up with that is the best

1:33:02solution

1:33:03yes exactly i mean harvard univ Harvard

1:33:06University figured out a long time ago

1:33:08that they needed an endowment right we

1:33:11don't have an in down moment for our

1:33:13public schools and well you know whether

1:33:19that was gutted or whether if you know

1:33:21whether it was it's just in this

1:33:23back-and-forth of like oh now now we

1:33:26don't pay taxes now we do this person is

1:33:28against it this person thinks the

1:33:29schools are full of maggots like how do

1:33:32we how do we go against this but how do

1:33:35we deep politicize things like schools

1:33:38so that the state legislature doesn't

1:33:43decide that this that that because there

1:33:45was one gay art teacher in shoreline

1:33:48that we don't teach art anymore is that

1:33:53even vaguely close to a real world

1:33:55example I mean why the why the why the

1:33:59holy jesus fuck don't we have money for

1:34:02schools in America right

1:34:04why are those things tied to cart abs

1:34:07it's it's bonkers particularly bonkers

1:34:12when you think that the state of

1:34:14California is subsidizing the water for

1:34:18a bunch of raspberry farmers and the

1:34:21City of Seattle has two three billion

1:34:23dollars on tap to build a tunnel under

1:34:26the city that will be obsolete obsolete

1:34:29before the paint is dry right after we

1:34:32do you know how much be frustrating it's

1:34:35really great but if you put three

1:34:37billion dollars in a in an endowment

1:34:39fund and used and never touch the

1:34:42principal and just use the interest to

1:34:44pay for some facet of I mean it wouldn't

1:34:49pay for all the schools but it would

1:34:50sure as shit go a long way to funding

1:34:54the schools in perpetuity right but

1:34:56nobody's thinking about that and so you

1:34:58know every year it's like oh shit we

1:35:00don't have any money for libraries or

1:35:01scream

1:35:02that's why the the business part of it

1:35:04kind of surprises me because I don't

1:35:06know what I'm thinking of a particular

1:35:07but i'm remembering few years back when

1:35:09it seemed very surprising to me to hear

1:35:11about how many leaders at big companies

1:35:16were speaking openly about what the

1:35:20achievement gap in America and basically

1:35:22they realize that it was getting harder

1:35:25to enter my Morsi this happened 20 years

1:35:28ago but I could be remembering around

1:35:29but they basically was it was obviously

1:35:31getting harder to hire into certain

1:35:33kinds of high tech careers that they

1:35:35were already seeing that it was getting

1:35:37harder and they were happy to do much

1:35:38stuff I try and hire people from

1:35:39overseas and I feel like I remember a

1:35:41lot of people saying hey look we need to

1:35:43invest in these kinds of careers for

1:35:45people who aren't even in school yet

1:35:46right these are the kinds of systems

1:35:48like that kind of remember first hearing

1:35:50thinking wow that is really forward

1:35:51thinking and really abstract and a lot

1:35:54of ways no direct benefits to any given

1:35:57company no roi they could put a floor

1:35:59about that whereas something like Jeff

1:36:01basis I don't think he's going anywhere

1:36:03I think he's going or maybe costco any

1:36:06of those companies starbucks that are so

1:36:08associated with that area it seems like

1:36:11kind of a no-brainer

1:36:13I'm sure they know give out bottled

1:36:15water and t-shirts and balloons at

1:36:17festivals and stuff but it just seems

1:36:18like it seems like such a no-brainer to

1:36:20invest in the community has a thing

1:36:23without any let alone trying to be a

1:36:26community that would be a desirable

1:36:27place for people to move you know great

1:36:29is it seems like half a dozen reasons

1:36:31why you would want to find the budget

1:36:33just even just to provide the nice

1:36:34things let alone the essential things

1:36:36well and that is that is assuming that

1:36:40uh that I and it's an assumption that i

1:36:43think most of the people making this

1:36:45argument make which is that a the

1:36:47assumption that our schools are are are

1:36:50basically trade schools right just

1:36:53making the economic impact argument that

1:36:57if we have better schools that makes

1:36:59better employees for amazon like that

1:37:03alone is a blunt instrument but it's a

1:37:05pretty I'll take it

1:37:06yeah right that was the reason for

1:37:08costco or Microsoft or or Vulcan or

1:37:12starbucks or or amazon too

1:37:15take an interest in Seattle Public

1:37:17Schools then you get the opportunity I

1:37:20mean you no way above that a thousand

1:37:22miles above that is the opportunity to

1:37:25be a true a benefactor and say schools

1:37:32need art programs schools need poetry

1:37:36schools need dance schools you know

1:37:40we're not just using schools as a

1:37:42training program for people to work in

1:37:44assembly scenarios or coding scenarios

1:37:48with coding is being the modern assembly

1:37:50but we want to we want our schools to to

1:37:56create citizens because those are the

1:37:59people who are going to really advance

1:38:01the ball in 30 years and you know that's

1:38:05an argument that i think a lot of

1:38:06capitalists would be really interested

1:38:11in right it just doesn't have it's just

1:38:15much easier to show up at the at the job

1:38:17fair with a bunch of balloons and say

1:38:21you know apply for a job as a coder here

1:38:25and you know and then maybe you'll get a

1:38:29chance to join our program where we are

1:38:31we're building windmills in South

1:38:36America that wins all around because you

1:38:38know gosh I don't get to San Francisco

1:38:41but you know just thinking about my

1:38:43friend you are already in the San

1:38:45Francisco I now but we were just talking

1:38:49with my wife about this and how I don't

1:38:52know it was the funny thing about a

1:38:53bubble is that the longer the bubble

1:38:57sticks around and the bigger the bubble

1:38:58gets the irony is that the bubble is not

1:39:02actually getting stronger

1:39:04the bubble is getting weaker as it gets

1:39:06bigger and that's true for soap bubbles

1:39:08and it's true for San Francisco bubbles

1:39:10the bigger it gets the more we feel the

1:39:12huge impact of this bubble here it is i

1:39:14mean it's bad i didn't just been working

1:39:16too much but it's bad here it's really

1:39:17really it's gross

1:39:19there's not a noble gross stuff going on

1:39:21right now in San Francisco because

1:39:23everybody wants to get in on this

1:39:25because you know growing bubble thing

1:39:28but you know again i'm not i'm not an

1:39:29econometrician but i think that public

1:39:32gets bigger it does become a lot easier

1:39:34to burst and you don't have to look more

1:39:37than five or six years in the past to

1:39:38see what happened in a bubble which is

1:39:41that everybody thought the housing

1:39:42prices were going to go up and up and up

1:39:43without regard to how those loans are

1:39:45being made and whether people should

1:39:46have them and look look what happened

1:39:48there so I mean how long is it going to

1:39:50be here before you got a bunch of people

1:39:53suddenly and i'm going to talk about the

1:39:55earthquake scenario I'm just talking

1:39:56about your basic economic tip wear boots

1:39:59and selling the bubbles not there is a

1:40:01bunch of people with leases and

1:40:02mortgages on places that are suddenly

1:40:05within say six months you know thirty

1:40:08percent over market value fifty percent

1:40:09over market value you know what I mean

1:40:11yeah and that's it's the the scary part

1:40:15in some ways you see so much destruction

1:40:16so many businesses that have been in

1:40:19families and artists people have been in

1:40:20town for dozens of years just going away

1:40:22because somebody else's that space

1:40:24go go go shut down all these bars

1:40:26because these condos moved in here now

1:40:27there's all this stuff and like each one

1:40:29of those little things in independent of

1:40:31one another is not like a huge momentous

1:40:34thing like any tragedy doesn't all

1:40:36happen in one day but you know that

1:40:38really starts to add up until there's

1:40:40gonna be a point i think we're more

1:40:41people going and not really sure I want

1:40:43to live there and it's gonna get super

1:40:46expensive until the day it doesn't get

1:40:47expensive and then we're going to have a

1:40:49cultural wasteland where everything was

1:40:51a little bit overpriced few months ago

1:40:53and now what the fuck are we gonna do

1:40:54what more was like when Walmart moves

1:40:56out of town so first shut down every

1:40:58place in walmart moves and you got

1:40:59nothing it's that that's terrifying to

1:41:01me to you know that people are coming in

1:41:03here and treating a little bit like a

1:41:05gold rush town without necessarily

1:41:06investing much and what would keep this

1:41:09place sustainable and desirable for

1:41:12people and this and we've talked about

1:41:13this before but this is the moment in

1:41:16world history I guess where we are you

1:41:23know we're up against the fact that a

1:41:26pure market is just a thought technology

1:41:31fright friend right and the the history

1:41:35of the eighteenth nineteenth and

1:41:38twentieth centuries

1:41:39our histories of political ideologies

1:41:42that attempted to rein in and govern

1:41:45market mercantilism and we saw a lot of

1:41:52different attempts to do it and you know

1:41:55unfortunately some of those attempts

1:41:58were very ideological they came at a

1:42:02time when technology allowed people you

1:42:06know to literally stamp numbers on other

1:42:10people right and mass murder them in

1:42:14conjunction with market reforms and that

1:42:18really discredited a lot of that a lot

1:42:22of the ideology and some of that

1:42:24ideology was way up in the sky and it

1:42:27and it did not reflect the actual truth

1:42:29of people but it doesn't mean that that

1:42:36that or the end result is that we just

1:42:39accept that market is the God and people

1:42:45keep saying to me like what would it

1:42:48mean it's the it's the market you can't

1:42:51make people want to come in they want to

1:42:53buy you can't stop them right and it's

1:42:56like the the markets a lot more comp

1:42:59complex than that and it is governor

1:43:02mobile well yeah I mean it's it seems a

1:43:04little bit i ran a little bit

1:43:06intellectually flabby to just say well

1:43:10supply and demand are these natural

1:43:12forces in the world haha but because

1:43:16been hella hella yes because there's a

1:43:19lot more to it than that i saw an

1:43:21article in the paper in the last six

1:43:24months about it's become very easy i

1:43:28don't know i always think about parking

1:43:29because you know the number of cars in

1:43:31San Francisco versus number of spaces is

1:43:32just as completely bananas and right now

1:43:35there are there it's pretty easy like

1:43:38you can walk down the big Street near my

1:43:39house and CM almost every cannot almost

1:43:41every car but probably third have the

1:43:43cars have a disabled permit if you

1:43:45disable permit you get a parking meter

1:43:46for free very desirable and last I heard

1:43:50the number of disabled permits that have

1:43:52been

1:43:53given out versus the number of spaces in

1:43:55the city this is approximately twice as

1:43:57many just disabled permanent way I think

1:44:00that was accurate here's another fun one

1:44:02of my wife just changed jobs

1:44:04she's going back to like a real career

1:44:07full-time career and so she's going to

1:44:10this new she working on this device new

1:44:11campus on in town but she found out that

1:44:15of course it's impossible to park you

1:44:17know you you could take me but then

1:44:19that's gonna be an hour and half to two

1:44:20hours so she drives a lot and that might

1:44:23be thirty bucks a day she found out that

1:44:25at the main campus where the hospital is

1:44:27for ucsf you know the waiting list is

1:44:30for employee parking 25 years there's

1:44:34two things that are funny about that one

1:44:36thing that's funny about that is that

1:44:37it's a fucking 25 year waiting list to

1:44:40get a parking permit but then what makes

1:44:42it extra funny it's still there still

1:44:44people adding their name to that list

1:44:47that's the market there's the market for

1:44:48you because that same but it's so good

1:44:52well and as I keep saying up here and

1:44:54it's true san francisco right from the

1:44:56from the day that San Francisco was

1:44:58founded until the last 10 years you

1:45:02could be a working-class person and live

1:45:04almost there anywhere i mean you know

1:45:07there are a few neighborhoods you

1:45:09couldn't live in but for the most part

1:45:11you could live in downtown San Francisco

1:45:13as a working-class person and you could

1:45:15do that all the way through until just

1:45:19recently and in Seattle that's been true

1:45:22until just five ten years ago you could

1:45:25be a working-class person and let's

1:45:26choose any neighborhood you wanted to

1:45:27live in and live there and so in the

1:45:33hundred and fifty plus years that

1:45:35Seattle's been a city for us to say well

1:45:39in the last five years you can't be a

1:45:42working-class person and live anywhere

1:45:43in the city and that's the new normal

1:45:44and that's just how it is that's just

1:45:46how markets work sorry market john sorry

1:45:48next that's just how it is i mean what

1:45:50are you some kind of communist what do

1:45:52you want to poop like the markets and

1:45:55that's how it is so figures on I want to

1:45:59change natural law black habla figure

1:46:01something else out because you can't do

1:46:03anything about that and it's like one

1:46:06of those mentalities is crazy you know

1:46:10and I don't think it is that you should

1:46:13be able to live anywhere in Seattle

1:46:14still as we have always been able to do

1:46:18I don't think that that is the crazy 1i

1:46:21think the crazy one is that if you're

1:46:23working class person you should have to

1:46:24you have to drive 45 minutes and pay

1:46:29thirty dollars a day and parking because

1:46:31what we've decided now is that the

1:46:33market has just determined that Seattle

1:46:38land is worth more than diamonds and the

1:46:44reason for that is that that's where

1:46:47people you know that's because people

1:46:50want to walk to people who have $250,000

1:46:53your jobs want to walk to work

1:46:54it's like that is good but we didn't do

1:46:57very good planning right and planning is

1:47:02the is the key and and a sense that that

1:47:07none of these things are set in stone

1:47:10capitalism did not win any any like epic

1:47:15battle of ideologies so that it is just

1:47:19unassailable from here on out and it has

1:47:22its acolytes who are going to argue for

1:47:23it and they will call you a communist if

1:47:27you try and talk about any kind of

1:47:30regulation and there are people who

1:47:32believe that governments are the soul of

1:47:35evil but the fact is this is an ongoing

1:47:39process we're still trying to navigate

1:47:41how to be human beings and govern

1:47:43ourselves and its ongoing and where an

1:47:48exciting moment and and the pressure

1:47:51that's being put on us by this by this

1:47:53insanity is the pressure that's going to

1:47:56develop new thinking and that should be

1:47:59always exciting to us you know

1:48:01yeah new thinking and the people in San

1:48:04Francisco and New York City and in

1:48:06Seattle who are realizing like you know

1:48:12my house was worth 200 thousand dollars

1:48:14in 2002 then it was worth 500

1:48:19some dollars in 2007 that seems crazy

1:48:23yeah then it was worth a hundred and

1:48:25ninety eight thousand dollars in 2007

1:48:27and a half seems crazy and now it's

1:48:31worth 600 thousand dollars in 2015 and

1:48:35I'm starting to see a pattern which is

1:48:38that that is crazy

1:48:39yep and so what do you do

1:48:43lay down did you lay down in your

1:48:45bathtub and eat a meatball sandwich or

1:48:47you run for fucking City Council

1:48:48yeah i agree i translated to my kid like

1:48:53why you know it you know she's drills at

1:48:55school my homeboy welcome welcome

1:48:57welcome to the 2010 xian drills like you

1:49:00mean earthquake drills know they

1:49:02literally giving drills now they have

1:49:04yeah they have different drills to get

1:49:05fire girls you know they have lockdown

1:49:07drills you believe that for a gun cases

1:49:11like a school lockdown but the point is

1:49:13the guy you know you gotta try to

1:49:14explain to a kid like I'm trying to

1:49:15split look I understand that you have

1:49:17made a great Chinese wall of stuffed

1:49:20animals across your room and that's the

1:49:22thing that you don't want to disturb but

1:49:24like it's important for you to leave a

1:49:25space in there so because if there's a

1:49:28fire

1:49:28I don't want to scare you here but if

1:49:29there's a fire you're gonna want to be

1:49:30able to get out of the house without

1:49:32tripping on a pair and it's very

1:49:34difficult to explain why we have to

1:49:37practice these things like a fire drill

1:49:39or any that's why we have to practice

1:49:41them in moments of quiet repose do it

1:49:44until it starts to feel like it's not

1:49:46going to be a panic because when the

1:49:47actual fire happens you don't you don't

1:49:49have time to think the poor analogy I'm

1:49:52trying to make here is that the problem

1:49:54is now we're in the middle of a blaze in

1:49:56our town itself to some extent in your

1:49:57town coming

1:49:59well it's it's kind of it's kind of too

1:50:00late to figure out what this fire

1:50:02strategy is because now we just need to

1:50:03focus on putting out the the blazes yeah

1:50:06right i mean in San Francisco you can't

1:50:09even live in oakland anymore right

1:50:13nope nope shoes and my wife is talking

1:50:15cuz it's certainly sure thought about

1:50:16and yeah just go it's actually not too

1:50:19bad you know it's just only like it's

1:50:21like a two-hour Bart trip pretty much

1:50:23it's like wow talk about quality of life

1:50:26yeah no no it's pretty bad i'm anxious

1:50:28to see you next to see how this

1:50:29continues to evolve and it's going

1:50:31pretty fast

1:50:31I just saw on your Twitter

1:50:32her we shouldn't talk about this

1:50:34probably you know you raise good money

1:50:36it looks like oh uh in my campaign

1:50:40yeah i'm now I'm failing at every on

1:50:42every count here your Roderick Roderick

1:50:45twitter account just retweeted something

1:50:46that says you to pass your competitor

1:50:49and fundraising oh no not-not-not my not

1:50:53the big guy

1:50:54oh this is a little guy yeah he the big

1:50:56guys got got tons and tons of money

1:50:58because he's you know he's got tons of

1:51:01money tons of money because you know

1:51:03because his he has actually fewer

1:51:05contributors than we do but his

1:51:07contributors all give seven hundred

1:51:09dollars right right which is the maximum

1:51:11and our contributors a lot of them you

1:51:13know give 25 bucks and that's what they

1:51:15can afford and that is amazing but it

1:51:17makes you know it makes the makes

1:51:20fundraising more of a challenge and the

1:51:21thing is like I'm a huge supporter of

1:51:23campaign finance reform and now I see

1:51:26how much better it would be even in

1:51:30something as small as the city council

1:51:32race let alone imagining campaign

1:51:34finance reform international skip the

1:51:36Senate race what a difference that would

1:51:37make you know think about the million

1:51:39plus dollars you have to raise and every

1:51:41dollar you take from somebody they

1:51:42handed to you and look you in the eye

1:51:44and go you're not gonna fuck me later

1:51:45when I need you to change the law for my

1:51:48bulldozer company are you and you know

1:51:51you see it everyday like oh Jesus uh no

1:51:54sir thank you know you've got that

1:51:55you've got half the check in your hand

1:51:57and he's like you know one day I'm gonna

1:52:01ask you for a favor that and then at the

1:52:04end this day but make them look what

1:52:07they did to my beautiful boy you get a

1:52:10lot of you could you seek a lot of help

1:52:12from morticians you know you probably

1:52:15grant a lot of favors the morticians you

1:52:16know how this business works

1:52:18you don't you come to my daughter's

1:52:19wedding and you asked me for this

1:52:21this is that's like Marlon fact that

1:52:23something your deck and the only 1i know

1:52:26you know my dad and Marlon Brando once

1:52:29had a confrontation

1:52:31what ya can tell it

1:52:34uh well i mean their protein know the

1:52:39statute of limitations has run out right

1:52:41it's true it's true like in person in an

1:52:45in-person of

1:52:46an in-person confrontation over a over

1:52:53lady here are shitting me

1:52:59I'm not I'm not shitting you what era in

1:53:02the nineteen fifties so my dad was an

1:53:09wasn't an actor

1:53:12what I was one of his like it would you

1:53:16know my dad always wanted to be you know

1:53:21one of them demons

1:53:23yeah and was but in the fifties when he

1:53:26was a lawyer during and drinking he also

1:53:30was a member of a theater group in

1:53:33seattle the Cirque theater that did

1:53:35productions in the round and in the

1:53:42fifties he was doing a play at the

1:53:46Cirque and young actress by the name of

1:53:50rita moreno what was his co-star in a

1:53:57play and my dad and Rita Moreno had a

1:54:01little some sort of little you know time

1:54:10Wow and a one-night my dad came out of

1:54:17the theater with Rita Moreno and Marlon

1:54:21Brando was waiting in the shadows

1:54:24waiting in the in the bushes as my dad

1:54:29described it

1:54:31and he and rita moreno were already

1:54:35acquainted and were also having a fair

1:54:40decor

1:54:41hmm this is you know early fifties and

1:54:48they had a they had a little bit of a

1:54:50you know a confrontation in the bushes

1:54:53didn't you no no no no one raised fists

1:54:57it was just like everybody I retired my

1:55:01dad with her murder and you know that

1:55:03and I was like whatever and then you

1:55:06know I think that she saw that Marlon

1:55:09Brando was of the two of them the one

1:55:12that was probably your dad had to live

1:55:16with that

1:55:16soifer I mean speaking as someone who

1:55:20has had similar sorts of experiences

1:55:24you've been in the bushes

1:55:26I've been in the bushes but not with

1:55:28marlon brando but with you know other

1:55:29younger Brando's you know you take you

1:55:33take you take that away you walk you

1:55:35walk away with that you realize like you

1:55:38know we're all were all just just a

1:55:42couple of kisses away from Kevin Bacon

1:55:43there's you know there's nothing that

1:55:46really special about other people

1:55:49it's just that some of them are really

1:55:50more beautiful and talented movie and

1:55:54and you know what it out what how do you

1:55:58mean basically how you how you deal with

1:56:02that information how you shoulder that

1:56:04burden it determines your course in life

1:56:07I mean you could you could at my dad

1:56:11could it could have dived into those

1:56:13bushes he could grab Martin brand Marlon

1:56:15Brando around there Martin Brando he

1:56:16could've grabbed him Martin Brando

1:56:18around the ankles and said take me with

1:56:20you up here Karl Malden

1:56:25[Music]