0:00:00this episode of Roderick on the wine is
0:00:01sponsored by cards against humanity this
0:00:04month they asked the double clicks to
0:00:06help me say hi to john reading this John
0:00:09what you've been eating two day
0:00:17[Music]
0:00:21hello hey John beep-boop-beep-boop-beep
0:00:25art would you like to begin a
0:00:27conversation online
0:00:31how're my pops and buzzes hows about
0:00:34buzzing buzzing crackle and pop listen
0:00:36pop crackle crackle did you change
0:00:39something
0:00:40crackle bows bows mmm on athletics it
0:00:43turned it turned out that my that's
0:00:46right those are on it you know I used to
0:00:47have a college teacher that never tell
0:00:50you this now he he pronounced that word
0:00:54on amanha pay ya is that's a little kid
0:00:58because he had a ligature well he felt
0:01:01that he felt the Greek letter that is a
0:01:04and E squished together or I think it's
0:01:08is a date its Zoe and then finally it's
0:01:11a diphthong
0:01:12but yeah he he wanted it pronounced he
0:01:14felt that that was the correct
0:01:15pronunciation on a mono pay and he and
0:01:19he used that word all the time in the
0:01:21class i don't remember what the class
0:01:23was but now I cannot say it any other
0:01:25way it is it is not the artist anal of
0:01:29of 1990 onomatopoeia a I don't want to
0:01:33take you off your tech talk buzz crackle
0:01:35but but but i do idea want to talk about
0:01:38for announcing something or doing
0:01:41something a certain way correctly even
0:01:43when it sounds wrong I like the single
0:01:45back to that ok so what turns out turn
0:01:48all turns out all that buzzing and
0:01:50crackling was just in my voice only need
0:01:54to clear throat a little that was just I
0:01:56had a little bit of I had a little bit
0:01:58of AI don't 88 big bite
0:02:01oh yeah yeah roll off on the ground
0:02:04switch yeah exactly
0:02:05that was the problem I i was i was what
0:02:08I was doing was I was dumb I was 8 bit i
0:02:12was told you were doing eight bit like a
0:02:15new window will pop someone like the
0:02:18beginning of a lot of psyche songs we
0:02:20get the deliberate fucking in of the
0:02:22guitar cable Kingsley's where it's gone
0:02:25and i'm thrilled array well start
0:02:27getting those tips from people
0:02:29it was an anomaly i think it was a
0:02:31gravity anomaly
0:02:33if you uh if you know anything about
0:02:34gravity anomalies you know that they can
0:02:37be used to communicate across time by
0:02:41Matthew McConaughey is that right okay
0:02:44the flat circle
0:02:45mhm i was a flat circle this is exactly
0:02:47where he was a scientist is that correct
0:02:49I'm so mad I'm so mad I you know I was
0:02:53barely aware of interstellar as it was
0:02:55happening as it was when it was coming
0:02:56out and I remember there being some talk
0:02:58I think Neil deGrasse Tyson had some
0:03:00just a long string of tweets about the
0:03:03science and it but I was just ignoring
0:03:04it all
0:03:05yeah and then I was in a hotel room and
0:03:08and it was on the TV and i watched it
0:03:12and I was just I was just fist clenching
0:03:15Lee mad the entire time
0:03:17you know i'm not i'm not be and probably
0:03:20the fifth-best physicist that you know
0:03:23we're here
0:03:24I mean you know your take right well we
0:03:28might be the only physicist I now so I'm
0:03:31not in a position to say there are all I
0:03:33think there are a lot of people that you
0:03:34and I know who it turns out our
0:03:37physicists closet with is business
0:03:40yeah that we just don't know like i
0:03:41would i would say grant Balfour is
0:03:43probably pretty good physicist yeah you
0:03:46probably just John syracuse said grant
0:03:47Balfour we've got a physicist friends
0:03:49for sure i would say that they would say
0:03:51that they probably weren't physicists
0:03:53and technical the physicist that's right
0:03:55and i'm going to probably agree with
0:03:56them and i'm not saying about you know
0:03:59what I'm not the fifth-best I'm in the
0:04:01top five business right but you because
0:04:03I'm gravity anomaly that changes a lot
0:04:04that's right gravity anomalies can often
0:04:07take one that could take a group of
0:04:09physicists and andrey sort them and then
0:04:13do it again right it's called lensing
0:04:15lensing and that's just part of the
0:04:17parallax effect is that gets well it's
0:04:19closed it's closed you're on you're on
0:04:20to something to doppelganger effect
0:04:22that's what it sounds like the bridge
0:04:23sirens going by me and me
0:04:26dinner that's it that's a that's a whole
0:04:28different category the doppelganger
0:04:29effect huh
0:04:30and it's actually pronounced do to gain
0:04:32triple-triple Gungor there for longer
0:04:34than even nerd in a team movie devil
0:04:38gauger now there's a little guitar thing
0:04:45that happens when he comes in
0:04:46ok now its doppelganger but I don't want
0:04:51to off music Paulette expects
0:04:54yeah you want to actually do want to
0:04:56talk about physics but you should say
0:04:57that because I whatever that was over
0:04:59pronouncing i'm gonna skip that and now
0:05:01i'm going to willing suspension of
0:05:02disbelief which I wrote down because
0:05:04isn't it interesting it's super
0:05:06interesting to me like what I will
0:05:07willfully suspend my discipline
0:05:09disbelief about like I got the thing is
0:05:11here's my thesis and I'm not a physicist
0:05:13like you but I can as I sit here today I
0:05:15can't tell you what it is about a film
0:05:17or TV show or novel that makes me go
0:05:19sure right and otherwise you know em
0:05:23right it's really hard to say
0:05:27all i know is i know that John Woo
0:05:29movies are not realistic but i'm totally
0:05:32in
0:05:32I know a great movies are not realistic
0:05:34but i'm totally in
0:05:35how do you feel about it when people are
0:05:38are performing karate while standing on
0:05:42top of bamboo shoots totally talk just
0:05:46briefly once before I don't have a
0:05:47problem with it on because I think
0:05:49that's part of the the universe the
0:05:51Cinematic Universe you know it's just
0:05:53you know the biggest problem if I had to
0:05:55say one big thing and I don't have any
0:05:57specific examples this in mind I know
0:05:59this happens a lot and a lot of movies
0:06:01in particular the first act set up is a
0:06:04lot of world-building the others the
0:06:06first act as a lot of establishing the
0:06:09ironclad rules that will lead to much of
0:06:12the drama that unfolds over the next two
0:06:14hours in 30 minutes
0:06:15I really like the way you're saying this
0:06:17thank you and then stuff happens in the
0:06:20second act rite stuff happens
0:06:22virtually every rule ironclad rule that
0:06:25was established in the first third kind
0:06:28of gets thrown out the window without
0:06:29explanation and that's frustrating and I
0:06:31feel cheated and I feel duped
0:06:32well in this case in this in this movie
0:06:35the DRL ever Oh interstellar right in
0:06:37this interstellar movie the first act is
0:06:40the problematic act because the first
0:06:43act is both boring
0:06:45well it's boring and implausible but
0:06:46also dumb poorly thought out and it sets
0:06:50up the plot for the rest of the film
0:06:52like this the the stuff happens part of
0:06:54the movie where the spaceships are going
0:06:57and people are spinning around in space
0:06:58is very quiet
0:06:59mhm and and keira knightley or whoever
0:07:04the the female lead is not keira
0:07:06knightley it's a it's a some that's an
0:07:11unactivated actually actually an actress
0:07:14that I have danced with haha can't
0:07:18remember her name had a wedding if I was
0:07:20at a wedding she was there at three and
0:07:24i thought to myself I'm going to ask her
0:07:26to dance and then it was more of sorts
0:07:28of more of a group dance you know what I
0:07:30mean like it was sort of like government
0:07:31asked her to having a lot of Martin
0:07:33causal gonna they're gonna want to start
0:07:35out with that with a friendly group
0:07:36dance yeah so it was like five of us
0:07:38kind of group dancing and it turned out
0:07:40he just got back from best stone and
0:07:42you're going to really earn it
0:07:43that's right yeah you don't just grab
0:07:45somebody and kiss them in Times Square
0:07:46anymore you can have a group dance there
0:07:48was a group dancing with those and that
0:07:50i was actually that was the moment that
0:07:52I realized that even famous actors are
0:07:58first desbiens em right right this was
0:08:03that this was kind of a this was a
0:08:05moment for me because you have us give
0:08:08us a sense of famous actors that they
0:08:12are very move their only stars movie
0:08:16stars they're actually they're in a
0:08:18different category but of course there
0:08:20are not they started out as lesbians as
0:08:23high school thespians yeah and then they
0:08:25became college lesbians and then they
0:08:27became a movie stars but they are still
0:08:29in their heart says be anak and so we we
0:08:34were doing this this this group dance
0:08:36and there was so much does be anak hands
0:08:42and face and body work
0:08:46that by the way in real time people were
0:08:49out there jazz hand around it was really
0:08:50happening and there was just a lot of
0:08:52like a everybody's looking at us and I
0:08:58was already too old and grouchy to to
0:09:05really enjoy it i was enjoying it more
0:09:08from a standpoint of like I'm watching
0:09:10this but I walked away feeling like
0:09:12outright I bet you I bet you even
0:09:16Harrison Ford is like this right i mean
0:09:18when you get them like it when you get a
0:09:19better wedding you think so is by like
0:09:21wow I have never happened
0:09:24I don't know where is it is it i'm
0:09:26trying to get this right so there's a
0:09:27drama to it there's definitely an
0:09:28element of performance there dancing
0:09:30like people are watching
0:09:31yeah you remember you remember being in
0:09:35high school huh yeah and your vaguely
0:09:39you remember the people that were in
0:09:42theater and how they were there was a
0:09:45little bit in theater but I definitely
0:09:46know what you mean
0:09:47yeah and and that that that thing that
0:09:52thing and so yea even back then a lot of
0:09:55dancing in a big circle and then kind of
0:09:58suggesting a gesture that everybody
0:10:00could do together
0:10:01yep it's it's sort of like a goth conga
0:10:03line yeah yeah well yeah well yeah I
0:10:07mean anyway so suffice to say that I
0:10:10know this act or dress and I don't
0:10:15remember her name because i have a very
0:10:16hard time which is probably on the
0:10:17community show
0:10:19nope nope no I think she's a more famous
0:10:22actor than that
0:10:23wow she was into movies I you know what
0:10:28it'll get a little it'll come to you in
0:10:29any case she was there
0:10:31matthew mcconaughey was there neither
0:10:32one of them did I for a moment believe
0:10:34was a scientist but that didn't matter
0:10:36during the space part because who knows
0:10:39who they're going to put in space right
0:10:41yeah you know what I mean like it 50
0:10:44years from now who knows who the
0:10:46astronauts are going to be like I didn't
0:10:48buy that ethan hawke could get into the
0:10:51spaceship with his bad eyes
0:10:53in the other speaking but you can I get
0:10:56what you're saying no I mean things can
0:10:57be kind of it used to be you had to be
0:10:59an engineer and a pilot and you have to
0:11:04be at NASA you know something that could
0:11:05be apt developers yeah that's right
0:11:07that's exactly right it could be elon
0:11:09musk with the with the leather but a
0:11:12biplane pilots helmet on the front of
0:11:15the spaceship that he designed to
0:11:16actually look like his own face spur you
0:11:21know shooting up into space the biggest
0:11:23penis of all
0:11:24yeah so I that part I didn't have a
0:11:26problem with but the part of the part
0:11:28that it was establishing like the that
0:11:32but it does feel free to spoil it for me
0:11:37know in Hathaway and half away you dance
0:11:40with Anne Hathaway in a group a small
0:11:42group five people dancing around at the
0:11:47time I was like you know I was
0:11:50entertaining the idea that maybe our
0:11:53eyes would lock across a crowded dance
0:11:55floor
0:11:56mhm but looking back at photograph of
0:12:01myself at the time i was missing a tooth
0:12:05and I did have like hair down to the
0:12:09middle of my back and just a difference
0:12:14with that video series on the YouTube of
0:12:17you
0:12:17the 13 songs with John yells yet some
0:12:20real long hair
0:12:21yeah really long hair it got even longer
0:12:23and i think at this wedding it was as
0:12:25long as it was going to get and so I can
0:12:28only imagine i mean i'm talking about
0:12:30and hathaways artistic lesbionic dancing
0:12:35i can only imagine what she was seeing
0:12:38looking back across the circle maybe
0:12:41that's why the group dance right
0:12:43safety in numbers little bit of that
0:12:45little bit of like huh
0:12:46this is interesting how did this guy get
0:12:49in here stay away from the biker um
0:12:51anyway I don't blame her
0:12:53and I've seen her in some movies where I
0:12:55thought she was great and she was
0:12:56actually a well no she wasn't very good
0:12:58in this movie but that's not the point
0:13:00the point is science as a
0:13:04as a narrative motivator right if you
0:13:09see if you go to a movie and you're like
0:13:10science is going to motivate this movie
0:13:12there is going to be somebody's going to
0:13:13use science to tell a story it's going
0:13:16to turn on science and I and a sense of
0:13:20sense watching the film i have looked it
0:13:22up and I've read all the talk about like
0:13:25all the science is really good in this
0:13:27movie they made sure that the science
0:13:29had any like call people in yeah yeah
0:13:32consultants and people's this there yeah
0:13:35that was that and so the science like
0:13:38the black hole that appears in the movie
0:13:41looks like a black hole is going to look
0:13:44if you ever seen a black holes
0:13:45apparently right and so I don't object
0:13:47to that
0:13:48ok but the but the part where the dad
0:13:53out of love for his daughter goes into
0:14:00the black hole to communicate with her
0:14:02by knocking books off of the shelf in
0:14:06her bedroom in the past was not decide
0:14:11what happened
0:14:12not a thing that arm i don't think that
0:14:16you i don't i'm not complaining about
0:14:18the science not going to work out a
0:14:20system where she know what to watch out
0:14:22for falling books this is the thing yeah
0:14:24she you know the movie starts she's in
0:14:27her bedroom books are falling off the
0:14:29shelves moon
0:14:30I wonder if that's gonna play into the
0:14:32family taking more more poltergeist that
0:14:34right i mean sure that anyone would
0:14:36unless your father was a science farmer
0:14:40let's see what this gentleman farmer who
0:14:45used to be a scientist is that what it
0:14:46is I'm saying jet pilot retired jet
0:14:48pilot science farmer and he says books
0:14:52for follow-up there's no such thing as
0:14:53ghosts does this is like the first hour
0:14:55of the movie where you're like wasn't
0:14:57supposed to be some space in this movie
0:14:59no no we're talking about the books
0:15:00falling off the shelves and some other
0:15:02stuff none of it how IC IC so the books
0:15:06falling off the shelf that he's trying
0:15:08to explain away or actually later on
0:15:10turns out caused by him all within this
0:15:13space forming future
0:15:15manipulating the past through a multiple
0:15:18universes scenarios for the
0:15:20controversial ending John there's no
0:15:23more controversial ending after this
0:15:24ending I i think if there was if there
0:15:27were people that had that we're creating
0:15:29a controversy about this film about some
0:15:31element in it i dismissed them with a
0:15:35with a with a Scott because the
0:15:39controversy about this film is that it
0:15:40is a garbage barge
0:15:42hi i know is divisive it's a good film
0:15:46is a garbage barge starring the ultimate
0:15:49like overt and tanned leather captain of
0:15:53garbage barge Matthew McConaughey and he
0:15:56recruited this poor keira knightley
0:15:58person I and Hathaway and have the way
0:16:02to a she play someone called brand
0:16:06yes she does some very she does a very
0:16:08bad acting on it and there are some
0:16:12other there some other actors in it that
0:16:14do fine fine acting jobs but the entire
0:16:18thing is a garbage barge and it's a 10
0:16:20and I and I cannot help but compare it
0:16:23to them to the more recent film which
0:16:26used science to create a robot raccoon
0:16:30that had a smart mouth for and a been a
0:16:32big machine gun
0:16:33yeah shouldn't work and think everything
0:16:36in that movie I believed
0:16:37yep one hundred percent and loved and
0:16:39this garbage barge of a movie which was
0:16:41supposed to be smart and which multiple
0:16:44multiple film reviewers praised for its
0:16:46smartness people were for this is why a
0:16:48divisive because i haven't seen the film
0:16:50but I heard a lot of people were just
0:16:52coming out of the theater freaking out
0:16:53and talking about her life changed and
0:16:55other people were like to be watched the
0:16:56same movie
0:16:57mm-hmm you know I learned this i'll
0:17:00probably get this wrong i'm doing this
0:17:01from memory but I learned a couple
0:17:02distinctions in the last few years that
0:17:03I think are interesting and you probably
0:17:05know these but won't admit it you know
0:17:07like in John Rizzo forget science
0:17:09fiction and fantasy right now are you
0:17:12can I know I know I know the difference
0:17:15between modes okay okay that's a start
0:17:17and Lord of the Rings is fantasy fantasy
0:17:20well no here's the thing but in fantasy
0:17:22don't you have like there's like high
0:17:23fantasy and like low fantasy high
0:17:26fantasy is where it really it's like a
0:17:28whole different
0:17:29world like a different universe or
0:17:32something like that and forgive me
0:17:33everybody in the world is going to get
0:17:34mad at this but it is the distinction
0:17:35being measured high fantasy well but
0:17:39then also i dunno there's hard science
0:17:40fiction
0:17:41oh okay right so there's a kind of
0:17:43science fiction where every conceivable
0:17:45detail is sweated to be as accurate as
0:17:49possible but also even in a speculative
0:17:51fiction universe to really cater the
0:17:54sort of person who like you know ask the
0:17:57question of william shatner at the
0:17:59convention like that you know it isn't a
0:18:01distinction because there's some kind of
0:18:02science fiction where you got a fucking
0:18:04robot raccoon and nobody minds right and
0:18:07this is the end this is the thing I love
0:18:10hard science fiction and generally I
0:18:12find that it works best when it is like
0:18:15Blade Runner a plausible world where
0:18:18where you eat you have you've posited
0:18:23the future based on like one or two one
0:18:28or two minor changes and it is produced
0:18:31this future world righty meaner or it
0:18:34like you take a lot of elements that we
0:18:37all sort of except and know to be true
0:18:39and you introduce one fantastical
0:18:42science development
0:18:44okay and I can handle I can handle those
0:18:46even the ones that are like hard science
0:18:48except fantasy right like the like ones
0:18:52where time travel is possible or
0:18:54something like that where where they
0:18:55don't they don't take or what was the
0:18:57one where the guy was coming back into
0:18:59the yet they were people in the future
0:19:01we're sending people back in the past to
0:19:03get killed
0:19:04oh yeah the night inception but rooper
0:19:09looper right i mean at as if you sit and
0:19:13worry about time travel like don't talk
0:19:15about time traveling and they covered it
0:19:17right in the film and it's hilarious
0:19:18that moment right here just like okay
0:19:20except that and then you then you go
0:19:23along with the plot right and what what
0:19:25this movie did was that it tried to get
0:19:28the hard science right except they're
0:19:31there nobody had done any thinking about
0:19:33a about like the human element right
0:19:38they had they had they gone toward the
0:19:41hard science and they had forgotten
0:19:42different
0:19:42about people John they forgot about
0:19:44people they forgot to make the human
0:19:46motivation plausible-like although the
0:19:50whole of the whole emotional core of
0:19:53this film depends on the idea that a
0:19:59daughter of a father who is a who is a
0:20:02space farmer a Kappa science farmer gets
0:20:06an opportunity to go into space
0:20:07uh-huh and his ten-year-old daughter
0:20:09says had it don't leave and he says I
0:20:12must go into space
0:20:14I am a time-space farmer this is what
0:20:18science farmers do with science farmers
0:20:20do they go into space right so that's
0:20:21the that is the that is a thing from a
0:20:24from basically every novel every movie
0:20:27that the father says goodbye daughter i
0:20:30am called out to the I'm riding out into
0:20:33the West I am blasting off into space
0:20:36and i will i will be back or I will
0:20:39bring you and he's either saying it to
0:20:40his daughter or his wife or you know
0:20:42somebody but in this film the daughter
0:20:46is so betrayed by the fact that her
0:20:49father would blast off into space even
0:20:52though she is herself a science
0:20:54she's a science farmer herself she
0:20:56becomes a science farmer is that right
0:20:58it runs in the family to it's a family
0:20:59science farm right but despite being a
0:21:01science farmer she cannot ever forgive
0:21:04him for this decision to go into space
0:21:06nominally to save humanity and the whole
0:21:11film is it is all of all the drama in it
0:21:15is about the about the about Matthew
0:21:19McConaughey being primarily motivated to
0:21:24get back to earth to his daughter and
0:21:27she still even as an adult devastated
0:21:31obviously never been in love obviously
0:21:33never like falling off her bike
0:21:35the worst thing that ever happened to
0:21:36her and the only thing that ever
0:21:37happened her is that her father left and
0:21:40like she doesn't forgive him for it and
0:21:42he doesn't and he can't say like a man
0:21:46uh a space farmers got to do a space
0:21:48farmers gotta do like there's no it
0:21:50isn't a science phone to keep in touch
0:21:52so he's gotta throw books
0:21:53well this is the thing
0:21:54you know what happens is they get down
0:21:57close to the gravity of the black hole
0:22:00and time moves more slowly for him out
0:22:03here and I like this part this is this
0:22:05is interesting science right this is the
0:22:07part of the movie that I wanted to watch
0:22:08all day which is like an hour on this
0:22:10planet is seven years back home and so
0:22:13he's like women i can't spend you know
0:22:15like they got down on the planet there
0:22:17but an engine flooded or whatever like
0:22:20hurt however come on we gotta start the
0:22:23fucking ship
0:22:24I gotta get back that's another year
0:22:26that just went by Remy room and by the
0:22:29time they get out of the black hole
0:22:32uh everybody on earth is grown-up gosh
0:22:36and it's like that is one of the great
0:22:38that's a great idea right that's a great
0:22:40plot point that's a great thing and also
0:22:44the open the door to a lot of humanity
0:22:46and storytelling for stride rite for
0:22:48fantastic and the end the one you know
0:22:50and and what your mind wants to do is
0:22:51like they do you think can't get their
0:22:53motor started and by the time they do
0:22:56they come back out of the black hole
0:22:58gravity field and earth is 400 years in
0:23:03the future right that's what's
0:23:04interesting
0:23:05yeah that would be an interesting story
0:23:06but instead like they get off the planet
0:23:09and like his daughters grown-up and she
0:23:11spent the last 40 years like sucking her
0:23:13thumb while becoming a genius scientist
0:23:16but sucking her thumb because her dad
0:23:17didn't come back
0:23:18ok and it's like seriously dad's don't
0:23:20come back all the time
0:23:21dad's go out for a pack of cigarettes
0:23:23and don't come back like if every kid in
0:23:25the world whose dad didn't come back
0:23:27suck their thumb and became a genius
0:23:29physicist well we have a better space
0:23:31program but it sounds like the story
0:23:32needs her to feel that way in order for
0:23:35the and again i have not seen a movie
0:23:36but in order for the drama from the
0:23:38McConaughey guy to work rise to be that
0:23:41feeling from this is my objection this
0:23:44the movie needs her to behave in a way
0:23:46that is not not human right and needs
0:23:50him to behave like whatever whatever
0:23:52their bond is like people have those
0:23:55bonds but but anybody anybody with
0:23:57normal human feelings watches that and
0:23:59says you know what my dad I'm 10 years
0:24:00older than 12 years old I love science
0:24:02my dad is a space ship captain he's
0:24:04gonna go and I'm I'm gonna be sad but
0:24:07like
0:24:07we're all gonna we're gonna get on with
0:24:09our lives right that's the north that is
0:24:10what up any human would do that isn't
0:24:13like emotionally broken i'm confused I I
0:24:16thought it was the science of three off
0:24:18no I liked the science it was the
0:24:20relationships the people part well so so
0:24:22then so so this is so that this is the
0:24:25problem right
0:24:26he is in he has access somehow to up to
0:24:34some sort of crossroads place created by
0:24:40future humans for reasons that are not
0:24:44explained he is in a crossroads where he
0:24:48can go from he can go across multiple
0:24:53universes he can go across time I guess
0:24:56right
0:24:57he's in a season and he ends up in this
0:24:59black hole in her room sort of a lot
0:25:012001 a Space Odyssey where you can go
0:25:04across time and he is using that
0:25:07incredible power not to kill Hitler not
0:25:12to go back to a time before he was born
0:25:16and give his parents a riddle right that
0:25:23only he can solve not not a not to do
0:25:26anything interesting her except to
0:25:28communicate to his daughter by knocking
0:25:31books off the shelves in the past two
0:25:34contradictory messages one because that
0:25:37because the because the gravity field
0:25:38this so boring the gravity the gravity
0:25:42field and the and all of that is how he
0:25:45and his daughter found the NASA people
0:25:47in the first place so he must have done
0:25:49that he must have signaled to her to go
0:25:53find the space people which is what
0:25:56produced the situation where he flew
0:25:58into space right so he sent that message
0:26:00and then spends a lot of time knocking
0:26:02books off the shelves in a coded order
0:26:05so that she receives the message stay
0:26:08and the message stay is meant to be
0:26:11communicated to him in the past through
0:26:13his daughter all telling him not to go
0:26:16typically turned it but if he didn't go
0:26:19none of the been mad at ya
0:26:22it's like the writing by doing what he
0:26:25actually stay
0:26:25no you didn't stay because that's
0:26:27idiotic if he had stayed then he
0:26:30wouldn't have been naughty right now I
0:26:31know we're gonna have a problem that's
0:26:33the killer problem but they didn't even
0:26:35address that killed Hitler we wouldn't
0:26:36know Hitler is today they didn't address
0:26:38the fact that in an infinite number of
0:26:41other possible multiple multiple verses
0:26:43he did stay right there
0:26:46they didn't address any of that they're
0:26:48using all of that interesting physics
0:26:51and crazy like you know Einstein me in
0:26:55like brain fuckery to tell the dumbest
0:26:59dumb story featuring two dummies that
0:27:05you don't care about in the first place
0:27:07like if you do care about their
0:27:09relationship if you do care about this
0:27:12father and daughter you are a dummy
0:27:13because they are such dummies and all of
0:27:17the physics becomes this like that it
0:27:19becomes like all this window dressing on
0:27:23a on a on a story on a pretty pedestrian
0:27:25on a pedestrian and sentimental story
0:27:28numbnuts sentimental story like if you
0:27:31took the science out of that movie and
0:27:32it was just like here's the story here
0:27:34the people that you're going to end up
0:27:35caring about others his father the
0:27:37daughter some other people and like do
0:27:40you care about their lives to care about
0:27:42whether they succeed in their quest for
0:27:45you care if they are reunited you care
0:27:47about any of that
0:27:49and the answer is no you couldn't
0:27:51possibly because I'll and ultimately
0:27:54this is this is I think the key then
0:27:56Hollywood this is the message that
0:27:58Hollywood needs to receive you cannot
0:27:59care about Matthew McConaughey can't you
0:28:05can watch him
0:28:06it can be interested in his call all I
0:28:08know you could be interested in him he
0:28:10can walk across the stage and you can be
0:28:11like uh-huh
0:28:12you think because you can't be trusted
0:28:14no because you cannot care about him
0:28:16think about this
0:28:17look at his face think about his role
0:28:19this is an hour into some hard science
0:28:21fiction think about it is it possible to
0:28:23actually care about Matthew McConaughey
0:28:24could you write a film where Matthew
0:28:26McConaughey was the actor playing any
0:28:28part i challenge you any part and you
0:28:31are watching him and looking into his
0:28:33space in his eyes and you care about
0:28:34what happens yeah the Dallas buyers club
0:28:36did you care about him I didn't finish
0:28:39it right there were people in that movie
0:28:42that you cared about it seemed like a
0:28:43good movie
0:28:44it was a very interesting movie and it
0:28:46was an act early experience where you
0:28:50watch these actors really really act the
0:28:52shit out of what they were doing
0:28:54I thought he was getting out of the
0:28:55first part which i watched I nothing
0:28:57against the the second two parts but he
0:29:00seemed to really inhabit the role
0:29:02yeah i really put him as a scrunchie
0:29:04squirrely drug I he absolutely did and a
0:29:07guy that you enjoyed watching but did
0:29:11not personally care about now and a good
0:29:12role for Matthew McConaughey fantastic
0:29:15role and then at the end what you care
0:29:18about is the tens the hundreds of
0:29:21thousands of people who are suffering
0:29:23from aids that this particular guy his
0:29:27actions I hit up me helping them right
0:29:30you cared about the people that starts
0:29:33out as barfly turns in gandhi turns into
0:29:35Gandhi right you can't you cared about
0:29:37the people but he you did not care about
0:29:40and i cannot i cannot think of a single
0:29:43and you know what my objection to
0:29:46Matthew McConaughey started in a
0:29:48science-fiction role which was to
0:29:52remember you know I dazed and confused
0:29:56no messy Matthew McConaughey was great
0:29:57and amazing views and in fact that maybe
0:29:59the one example where I actually kinda
0:30:01did
0:30:02now I didn't care about but I sure liked
0:30:04him now what movie
0:30:06matthew mcconaughey and I could have
0:30:08gone through life perfectly fine with
0:30:11each other right he's on one path I'm on
0:30:13another he's playing he's playing most
0:30:15of the roles that he plays and I am
0:30:17enjoying watching him but not caring
0:30:19about him but in that god damned Jodie
0:30:22Foster movie where she built a space
0:30:25machine based on a carl sagan is desert
0:30:29schools she doesn't meet your father she
0:30:31goes and meets well-spaced she made
0:30:33meets the aliens who have masqueraded as
0:30:36her father because they because she
0:30:37wouldn't be able to groc spoiler alert
0:30:40she would be able to groc what they look
0:30:43I'll IC or shoot or or not they're not
0:30:45that just looks but
0:30:46their whole form I can I get it so they
0:30:49could appear to her
0:30:50they could have appeared to her as a
0:30:51swarm of bees Coke machine they appeared
0:30:54as a talking Coke machine belt buckle
0:30:56but instead they chose to appear to her
0:30:57as her as her father which is a fucked
0:30:59up thing for an alien consciousness to
0:31:01do typically that's even allowed in the
0:31:03alien ethics if they know enough to
0:31:05impersonate somebody's dad they
0:31:06shouldn't be allowed to do it right and
0:31:07if I don't panic but I I just gotta draw
0:31:10a line in the space
0:31:11exactly if I were a Jodie Foster space
0:31:13scientists and I got out into into like
0:31:17a space world and my dead father arrived
0:31:21and started talking to me in like I
0:31:24would feel it talking to me in his like
0:31:26a it is fatherly way and it's definitely
0:31:28I would feel very manipulated by these
0:31:31UFOs I would instance i would instantly
0:31:34not trust them I what I wouldn't want to
0:31:35talk to somebody else
0:31:37yeah right like okay alright I've seen
0:31:39what you can do it's a nice parlor trick
0:31:41can you appear to me as Richard Nixon
0:31:42now right i could that could have been
0:31:45somebody who is new there and they were
0:31:48abusing the technology and we're not
0:31:49fully aware you don't mean maybe it was
0:31:51maybe there's a new alien on the job but
0:31:53that's the thing i really i do are they
0:31:55contacting so many in sentient races
0:31:58around the around the universe that
0:32:00there that this is something that
0:32:02they've assigned to an intern well what
0:32:04about Clarence the angel and now it's a
0:32:06wonderful life
0:32:07I mean you gotta start somewhere I've
0:32:09never seen it's a wonderful life I'm not
0:32:10seen that I've seen that it's a it's got
0:32:12some multi first time traveling anyway
0:32:15in this movie with Jodie Foster
0:32:18yeah where the where the swarm of bees
0:32:20is appearing to her as her father
0:32:22Matthew McConaughey plays a role uh
0:32:25where he is some kind of spiritual
0:32:29leader
0:32:30yeah this is again a fantasy future
0:32:33world where he is a how would you
0:32:37describe him a young Billy Graham
0:32:40who has a lot of moral authority that
0:32:44charismatic spiritual figure charismatic
0:32:47spiritual figure that's exactly right
0:32:48like a young Billy Graham a young
0:32:50diagram but with a lot of like a deep
0:32:53soul wisdom so that he is again i can
0:32:57imagine that right so yeah butBut I can
0:33:00imagine playing that but such that he is
0:33:02consulted by presidents and heads of
0:33:06state like a young Billy Graham like a
0:33:08young Billy Graham and he like gets him
0:33:13he's on one of these advisory boards
0:33:15he's a central figure he is the voice of
0:33:18he is the voice of faith and religion in
0:33:22this science movie and he is and he so
0:33:26i'm watching this movie and I'm like I
0:33:28like Jodie Foster like carl sagan i like
0:33:31the idea of a science a movie i love the
0:33:35idea how this is gonna be terrible
0:33:36spoilers if you haven't seen this movie
0:33:38i love the idea that you that that space
0:33:43travel is basically time travel and this
0:33:48and that and the whole spaceship design
0:33:50is just that at that we on earth
0:33:53perceive it to be like that she just
0:33:56fell through a hole and came out the
0:33:57other side you couldn't protect you from
0:33:59time for a while
0:34:00yeah she was gone she was gone for a
0:34:02long time in her world and in our world
0:34:04and appeared that the Machine didn't
0:34:05work and nobody believed that she went
0:34:07because it's like the eye like the eye
0:34:09so good that such a nice nice a nice
0:34:12touch a nice device this device although
0:34:15again I feel like a panel of scientists
0:34:18would be able to understand this concept
0:34:20if she explained it to them and then
0:34:22nobody when she got back nobody believed
0:34:24her and she was disgraced so what
0:34:25happens with the look on his characters
0:34:27he learned lesson about love full
0:34:28sentence that's exactly that is probably
0:34:30what happens i don't i was evident it
0:34:33every time he came on the screen i close
0:34:34my eyes and I when mmmnn mnnn because
0:34:38he's so callow so like so unbelievable
0:34:43in the role of somebody that anyone
0:34:45would care about that and to put him as
0:34:50the like heart of the film like the like
0:34:53the emotional part of the movie was such
0:34:57a was such a terrible casting decision
0:35:00that's a lot of weight to carry for any
0:35:01actor but it sounds like you're saying
0:35:02he wasn't up to it see what you want in
0:35:04that role is a chubby guy if somebody's
0:35:08gonna be the emotional heart of a
0:35:09science movie i like that way night
0:35:11Seinfeld's Newman thank you know if you
0:35:15put a guy if you put a guy with a little
0:35:17bit of a chunky guy if in the center of
0:35:20a roll like that
0:35:21now that's the thing you're going to
0:35:22believe that a chunky guy's got heart
0:35:25right you're gonna believe you don't
0:35:29give that a guy like Matthew McConaughey
0:35:30who who who appears to be carved out of
0:35:33mahogany that guy's got no heart seems
0:35:36like you want to do stuff to your
0:35:37panties or maybe get into your bank
0:35:39account
0:35:40yeah you know what he wants to do he
0:35:41wants to make some fish tacos and he
0:35:43wants to go boogie board
0:35:45he's a bad man that's what he wants he
0:35:47does he wants to go he wants to have him
0:35:49Sammy Hagar over they're gonna make some
0:35:51fish tacos he's gonna make his famous
0:35:54fucking salsa and then they're going to
0:35:57go putting her it's pretty high
0:35:58he's not he does not want to be the be
0:36:03the emotional heart of the film you
0:36:05don't believe it not for a second LTE
0:36:07you consider a stretch role for him
0:36:09anything where he's so so in that in
0:36:12that TV show where he was playing
0:36:14against the guy from cheers yeah sure
0:36:17that was what he was very convincing in
0:36:20that movie because he was a gacked out
0:36:23like bad cop he was Abby was good at
0:36:27like drug in laconic yeah he was a dumb
0:36:29philosopher and that maybe with a lot of
0:36:31dumb philosophy but it was exactly the
0:36:32kind of dumb philosophy that I gacked
0:36:34out cop would would spew right you
0:36:38should be a consultant on this thing he
0:36:40was not the chubby guy that should have
0:36:42been at the center of both the be
0:36:44science fiction movies that seinfeld
0:36:45away night
0:36:46well you know he's only have to be him
0:36:48but maybe shave his head he might
0:36:50likewise i would even by seth rogen in
0:36:52those roles i think he'll I think just
0:36:53for which were also nothing I don't mean
0:36:55to go on a chubby thing here i think i
0:36:57think one night lost a tremendous amount
0:36:59of weight he had one of those two
0:37:00transformative weight loss experiences
0:37:02do you think that it was a do you think
0:37:03he got a lap belt
0:37:04oh that's what the dot leopard leopard a
0:37:07gossipy thing
0:37:08yeah I could be could be or they give
0:37:10you the time tell me i think is John
0:37:12he'll also had a big go weight loss
0:37:14thing
0:37:14oh I saw that but easy seems to begin
0:37:16its hard the yo-yo thing is real you
0:37:18know my mom believes that that people
0:37:21who lose a lot of weight
0:37:22uh by any method of exercise and and
0:37:27diet she believes that those people will
0:37:31always tell you what they did at always
0:37:36so that someone who loses a lot of
0:37:38weight sudden now who does not tell you
0:37:41in exhaustive detail the method by which
0:37:45they did it invariably have had some
0:37:48kind of gastric bypass
0:37:50oh you okay not that there's anything
0:37:53wrong with that but there's
0:37:54extraordinary medical surgical means
0:37:56involved actually a commitment that she
0:37:59believes she believes that that anyone
0:38:02who has used a system of like changing
0:38:05their diet and exercise is going to bore
0:38:07the shit out of you about it it's almost
0:38:09like if you had a bunch of people
0:38:11sitting around left with four people
0:38:13sitting around the room for any gender
0:38:15really like anybody and like one person
0:38:19starts talking about their kids another
0:38:21person starts talking about their kids
0:38:22are you talking about and just talk
0:38:23about how their kid used to be adorable
0:38:25and is now I dick mean the second one
0:38:27comes in third one comes in EM there's a
0:38:29pretty good chance if you had a kid
0:38:31well let's be honest they probably
0:38:32turned out to be a dick you're gonna
0:38:34jump into that conversation the only
0:38:35people who don't jump into that
0:38:36conversation or someone who doesn't have
0:38:38a kid god bless them and goes and goes
0:38:39how that's really it sounds like a pain
0:38:41right thing here if you've done
0:38:43something people are proud of what
0:38:44they've done and you know and especially
0:38:46with the things like pregnancy or weight
0:38:47loss or you know AAA or whatever he's
0:38:51there are people who are going to give
0:38:52you they've got their story I try very
0:38:54hard not to talk about my diet and I
0:38:57cannot help
0:38:59oh I cannot help but not talk about it
0:39:02because as soon as somebody like so many
0:39:04things I swore to myself I would never
0:39:06ever do nothing to feel bad about it
0:39:08that's the second part that's the
0:39:09painful part is it doesn't bother me it
0:39:11doesn't really talk about my bowel
0:39:12movements and cassette tapes two years
0:39:15ago when somebody was talking about how
0:39:16they were gluten
0:39:17yeah I was like oh my god you're so
0:39:19boring stop it stop talking and then
0:39:23when I went gluten-free I was like well
0:39:25you know I went gluten-free recently and
0:39:27lot of water supply and I was so proud
0:39:28of myself and I had completely forgotten
0:39:31completely blocked out that i had
0:39:33formerly found at people like that
0:39:36boring so anyway that is that that's
0:39:39that's my mom's theory but my mom has a
0:39:41lot of theories have to take them all
0:39:43the grain of salt
0:39:45yeah but in the aggregate she's right a
0:39:46lot of the time I don't have a dog in
0:39:48this fight
0:39:48thank you think she is did you ever talk
0:39:50about there's one episode of this
0:39:51american life called the seven things
0:39:52you're not supposed to talk about
0:39:53everyone was that one here we talked
0:39:55about that no I think that might've been
0:39:56one of your other programs yeah but I
0:39:59want to find me the it's basically that
0:40:04the notion the show it's kind of a silly
0:40:05idea but the idea is Sarah cainnic I
0:40:07went on to do Dean being being being
0:40:09cereal her mother i believe it's her
0:40:12mother is has this list of seven topics
0:40:15no one should ever talk about
0:40:16oh and they are you get this right
0:40:19you're period what your diet and what
0:40:22you eat your health in general
0:40:24yeah i was just doing some tennis club
0:40:28rules ok here we go keep going lost
0:40:29three tennis balls
0:40:30I don't just toss these out so wait
0:40:32let's go back to get pot we gotta get
0:40:34your period we got a diet number four we
0:40:39have Sleep Number five your dreams
0:40:43oh don't talk about your dreams but
0:40:45don't talk about sleep either huh i'm
0:40:47just getting there
0:40:48I love this one number six I love number
0:40:496 root talk what's that how you got
0:40:53there
0:40:53oh man we were gonna take 280 but then
0:40:57it turned out there is a we have to take
0:40:58a cut over and go down the 1010 you just
0:41:01took that you just took away eighty
0:41:02percent well when I talk about I know
0:41:04exactly but but you know I think those
0:41:06are the I'm just I'm just saying that if
0:41:08we don't have these things to talk about
0:41:09nothing i agree with this but that
0:41:11sounds like all stuff that like if we
0:41:13didn't have those things to talk about
0:41:15it how your kids eventually become dicks
0:41:16there would be no much to talk about if
0:41:18you don't you know what for me diet and
0:41:19sleep like right about that and sleep
0:41:22when i'm going to say at this point that
0:41:23when someone is introduced into our
0:41:25family you know when somebody like gets
0:41:27to be friends with the with the
0:41:29Roderick's
0:41:30one of the one of the things that they
0:41:32have to sort of a custom themselves to
0:41:35is that any time my mom and i arrived at
0:41:39a place or depart we're going to spend
0:41:41two minutes talking about the route but
0:41:45you know she's like okay I'm taking off
0:41:47and going a little bit right it's where
0:41:48you going and she goes on you haven't
0:41:50done that then it and if we're both in
0:41:52one location and we're going to a
0:41:53separate location we will absolutely
0:41:54take different routes and compare and
0:41:58deaf and we're very interested in who
0:42:00gets to the place where I think it
0:42:03varies i think it varies a great deal
0:42:05especially as people get older and you
0:42:07can compare and contrast your different
0:42:09dietary problems and also just like to
0:42:10say if anybody out there's any producers
0:42:12I i would like to see a cable reality
0:42:15show called getting to be friends with
0:42:17Roderick's haha very it would be a 10
0:42:22season show at the end maybe you'll be
0:42:24friends now I could be like things that
0:42:26could be a contest though it could be an
0:42:28elimination thing right could be like a
0:42:30hidden-camera you know as he has more
0:42:32and kind of thing at the end of every
0:42:33episode
0:42:34my mom and I would sit down and be like
0:42:35I kind of like this one and she'd be
0:42:37like mm no be nice if you left now up
0:42:42um I went skiing this past weekend on
0:42:48hill i went scheme for the first time in
0:42:52a long long time
0:42:55uh probably well the first time in many
0:42:59years I went skiing in this yeast in
0:43:01your family
0:43:02this was a thing yep just like a
0:43:05big-time skier right well I was too we
0:43:08were that's right yeah you said that
0:43:09yeah and and it was really it was very
0:43:12it was very weird a melon
0:43:17because it's a thing that I haven't done
0:43:22in a lot in a long time and it probably
0:43:25in the last 20 years I've done three
0:43:29times but it's a thing that I know how
0:43:33to do really well I'll you still have it
0:43:38is like a ride a bike as they say oh
0:43:40yeah because between the ages of 8 and
0:43:4323 i skied constantly i raced I train
0:43:50mostly in Alaska it but I was i skied in
0:43:54college too but you know in the summer i
0:43:57trained i would late we would we would
0:44:00go for a long run and then we would lay
0:44:02down in the park and our coach would
0:44:04walk around we all be laying on the
0:44:06grass with our eyes closed and our coach
0:44:07would walk around between us really
0:44:09slowly
0:44:10this is on a beautiful sunny summer day
0:44:12and in Alaska and he'd be like you're at
0:44:15the top of the course and you're you're
0:44:18checking your bindings and and then you
0:44:20hear that you hear the buzzer babe
0:44:22Bam Bam and then year then you're out
0:44:25you're on the course and you're making
0:44:26that first turn and you're just carving
0:44:28perfectly visualizations and we would
0:44:30sit and lay in the park while he would
0:44:32he would visualize an entire slalom race
0:44:37really even back then I mean I think
0:44:39this is being a modern invention but
0:44:41that you really get it back then 1980
0:44:43this is 84 probably well clean golfer
0:44:47student exchange top don't call first do
0:44:48that a lot too big they say like
0:44:50visualizations like ninety percent or
0:44:51something or forty percent or so yeah I
0:44:53think it's a big sports thing and i
0:44:54think i remember at the time being told
0:44:57or feeling like this was really new and
0:44:59really innovative and it was really
0:45:02effective like you would lay there after
0:45:04a long run you'll be like you know
0:45:06feeling your body and the Sun is beating
0:45:09down and you're thinking about this ski
0:45:11race and you're imagining yourself just
0:45:14skiing so well through this course and i
0:45:17absolutely the following year during ski
0:45:21season like at made a real leap
0:45:24inability and had started to and i was i
0:45:27I started winning races
0:45:30I I got a couple of gold medals that's
0:45:32amazing people were starting to talk
0:45:34about me like I was a comer it all ended
0:45:38badly but but it was a it was a it was a
0:45:44big part of my teen life and and it's
0:45:50not something I haven't done in years so
0:45:51I so is it just on athletics it touches
0:45:54on like social stuff right obviously
0:45:57like people it's like a thing people
0:45:58would do for fun I think people would do
0:46:01for fun it's also a very expensive sport
0:46:03so there's this other aspect of it where
0:46:07it ties into it so it's a it's a very
0:46:11class oriented thing like skiing is is
0:46:17like horse it's like horse people right
0:46:19you it's kinda like it is like golf in
0:46:22in that sense right i mean where you've
0:46:23got there's lots of ongoing expenses
0:46:25there's lots of costly equipment you
0:46:27could take lessons forever loon and and
0:46:29like a lot of things that are tied to
0:46:31social class there's the kind of
0:46:34confusing a misattribution of like skill
0:46:40in skiing that skill and skiing is is a
0:46:46sign that you are a superior person kind
0:46:49of you know like skill in golf or or or
0:46:52tennis or horse riding a is a sign that
0:46:56you are especially if you make it as
0:46:58they say look easy right
0:47:00that's a very high-status things it's
0:47:01one thing to take a main classes and
0:47:03everybody know it but people who can
0:47:05cook in golf or ski or boat with
0:47:07apparent ease i think that's super high
0:47:09status
0:47:10yeah it's there's a lot of status
0:47:12involved but also for me like to be up
0:47:15on the ski mountain but it's also a
0:47:18solitary sport but it's a solitary sport
0:47:22where as you're making a run you are
0:47:24conscious of being visible to people
0:47:27there are people standing all around the
0:47:29ski hill watching uski there are people
0:47:31up on the lift watching uski like
0:47:33they're it's it is it's a solitary
0:47:34performance of a kind of ballet if
0:47:37you're skiing well
0:47:39I because when i'm writing the lift or
0:47:42standing on the side of the hill and
0:47:44someone skis by and his skiing well i
0:47:47will stop stop what I'm thinking and
0:47:50watch them and admire them
0:47:51it's a they're there every day and the
0:47:54course of of being on a ski mountain
0:47:56there are multiple times where you see
0:47:58somebody and you just admire their
0:48:01skiing and it's a form of love your
0:48:04beauty know i-i-i don't feel that in
0:48:07very many other things as much as I do
0:48:10watching somebody do watching somebody
0:48:13perform a sport that I know what it
0:48:15feels like to do well
0:48:17mhm and as I watch them do it well I
0:48:19don't know them I don't know anything
0:48:21about them but i'm watching them ski
0:48:22well and I think I like this I like
0:48:24watching this and so when you're skiing
0:48:27you're also aware that like and ninety
0:48:29percent of the people around on the ski
0:48:31mountain are not watching you and don't
0:48:32care and don't wouldn't recognize that
0:48:35you were doing it well but there's this
0:48:38small percentage of people on the lift
0:48:40or on on the hill that you know that
0:48:43you're aware of are going to recognize
0:48:45that you are performing at a higher
0:48:47level and they're gonna appreciate it
0:48:49one way that it seems a little bit like
0:48:51skateboarding even before there was
0:48:53snowboarding right i mean in that sense
0:48:55that you you would sit there and you
0:48:57practice you do this thing all day long
0:48:58over and over and over and when you see
0:49:00somebody who's really capable of
0:49:01something you know is extremely
0:49:02difficult kind of can't help but stop to
0:49:04admire them
0:49:05that's right that's right and a lot of
0:49:06things like I mean I millions of people
0:49:10love watching basketball highlights
0:49:12because there are these feats of
0:49:14incredible athleticism that we all
0:49:17recognized as a tremendous right but
0:49:21very few of us can also play basketball
0:49:23that well and imagine watching
0:49:26basketball highlights if you were
0:49:28somebody who was an incredible
0:49:30basketball player i get that that's it
0:49:31that's a great distinction its you can
0:49:33you can appreciate just based on the
0:49:35history of it but you've never actually
0:49:36you know suck a 3-pointer yeah or like
0:49:40jumped up and around the back of you
0:49:43know jumped over somebody's head and and
0:49:45dunk the basketball
0:49:46and so I i was having this incredible
0:49:48experience all weekend when I was like
0:49:50it's this is one of the few things that
0:49:56I am genuinely good at and there are
0:50:00very few of those things right
0:50:01I do not consider myself to be genuinely
0:50:04good at playing guitar I am i'm good at
0:50:08guitar impassable guitar but in a room
0:50:11full of people that are great at guitar
0:50:13you know nobody's gonna be like now
0:50:15let's loss sit and watch Roderick right
0:50:18I'm gonna kind of smile and make a joke
0:50:20and play a joke solo I've heard you say
0:50:23that a lot of a lot of time a lot of
0:50:24places that you'd feel like you didn't
0:50:27even get you always see to things that
0:50:30you never you never really got bothered
0:50:34to try and get good at guitar until
0:50:36you're in your late twenties and even
0:50:38then you're just as good as you need to
0:50:39be to do what you want to do you never
0:50:41saw it as this application to aspire to
0:50:43greater and greater rock
0:50:45yeah something like that yeah and and
0:50:47part of it maybe is that a that skiing
0:50:51is something that I started to do when i
0:50:52was ten or or I'm sorry aight and I
0:50:56didn't start playing guitar when I was
0:50:58eight and I didn't start really i didn't
0:50:59really do much else at eight
0:51:02like I didn't get good at baseball I
0:51:04didn't I wasn't good at Dungeons and
0:51:06Dragons I wasn't good at all those
0:51:13things that I wanted to do i I didn't
0:51:16practice drawing i didn't i didn't get
0:51:21the this I didn't develop a skill to
0:51:25this to the degree that it was
0:51:27unconscious but with skiing after not
0:51:31having been in 10 years I get up on a
0:51:33pair you know I go into the pro shop and
0:51:36I'm like look I'm a 46 year old guy but
0:51:38and I haven't been skiing in 10 years
0:51:40but I'm gonna want your best gear and
0:51:44they're like okay and they bring out the
0:51:48they bring out this gear and they put it
0:51:49out there and I'm like yeah no not not
0:51:51this stuff I want that stuff you know
0:51:54when I point up to the thing and they're
0:51:55like okay man and they put me in this
0:51:58stuff and I get up on the hill and I'm
0:52:02as i'm writing the ski lift I'm like you
0:52:03know this is pretty technical gear like
0:52:08i hope that i'm not i hope i didn't
0:52:09overestimate my need for it you know i
0:52:14hope i don't get up there and penske has
0:52:16changed so much and this year's so
0:52:17radical that I'm gonna be just about 10
0:52:23years since i went last night and that
0:52:26was the first time I'd gone in five
0:52:28years and I went one day and then there
0:52:30was I went one day five years before
0:52:33that I would not be surprised if
0:52:34adequate this really better
0:52:36it's changed a lot but the art of skiing
0:52:39hasn't changed and I got off the lift
0:52:41and I made a couple of turns and I was
0:52:42like all right this is the appropriate
0:52:43gear and I understand how it works and
0:52:47then the rest of the day I was just in
0:52:49this place of a in this place of like
0:52:52kind of training again where every turn
0:52:57i made i was thinking about and I was
0:52:59like that was a good turn and now we're
0:53:02gonna set up the next turn and here we
0:53:04go and then for the cardiovascular
0:53:06standpoint you could do it seems very
0:53:08athletic one so I was after the first
0:53:11couple of runs i was super tired my legs
0:53:13hurt everything about me her and and I
0:53:17recognized a few things that I was 46
0:53:20and so I could not I could not get air
0:53:23anymore I was not going to get I was not
0:53:25gonna go off any jumps probably ever
0:53:27again and there were you know in any
0:53:32kind of skiing in any ski run where
0:53:35you're really pushing yourself you're
0:53:38going to arrive at a moment where you're
0:53:39like okay I'm at the threshold now right
0:53:44I'm on that I'm on the outside of my
0:53:47ability and I think that's true of
0:53:50anybody no matter how good they are if
0:53:52they're pushing their envelope they get
0:53:55to the edge of it it it seems like every
0:53:58i always keep once when I was a kid very
0:54:00young kid but like you with the way you
0:54:02watching somebody doing the way you
0:54:03described it really sounds like not only
0:54:05is that true that you're always pushing
0:54:07it but that you didn't need to push that
0:54:09in a way you might not expect could come
0:54:11up with like almost any second and that
0:54:13could be something of meeting a certain
0:54:15amount of velocity you didn't expect I
0:54:17certainly imagine we talk about things
0:54:18like even small just jumping around how
0:54:21hard that must be on your joints but
0:54:23then also just anything like one false
0:54:26move and you're just gonna tear some
0:54:27part of your body really really hard
0:54:29right yeah you're going super fast down
0:54:32a place and even if you are very
0:54:34familiar with the terrain which like the
0:54:37resort i grew up on I knew every inch of
0:54:39it but even so every day is different
0:54:43right because its nature and the weather
0:54:47and the snow i mean it's always
0:54:48different so an area that you know
0:54:50really well you can come across it and
0:54:52it's been this the situation has changed
0:54:54completely
0:54:55but as it was happening this past
0:54:57weekend I was on completely unfamiliar
0:54:59terrain and every time I came over arise
0:55:02I had no idea what was on the other side
0:55:03it could be a it could be a mile-long
0:55:05groomed run or it could be a cliff into
0:55:10a waterfall every time you know every
0:55:11time you come over a a horizon and so
0:55:15the other thing I being 46 really
0:55:19pointed out to me was that i needed to i
0:55:23needed to bring my the the edge of my
0:55:25envelope in considerably because the
0:55:28really the last time I skied very much
0:55:31at all
0:55:32I was still young enough that that that
0:55:36the my boundaries were way way out
0:55:39mhm and I needed to bring those weigh-in
0:55:43and there were a couple of times on the
0:55:44hill where I was standing on the edge of
0:55:45some double black diamond run and
0:55:48looking down and like is this doable yes
0:55:50should i do it
0:55:54no I should not I should not do this
0:55:57because I can do it but I don't need to
0:56:02prove that and I and the risk of of
0:56:08doing this and and making even just a
0:56:10normal error is that i will hurt myself
0:56:13and then then today will be
0:56:16characterized by my injury rather than
0:56:19by the fact that I'm having a really fun
0:56:20time
0:56:21yeah and so that was it that was new to
0:56:23me I'd never I'd never stood at the top
0:56:25of a run before and look down and said
0:56:27can I yes should I know and I did that a
0:56:30few times and I was I was pretty proud
0:56:33of that I think that's pretty smart
0:56:34child is as good as you may still be
0:56:37like it's just the stakes are higher
0:56:39oh I'm old I mean I you know and and
0:56:41what was great was feeling like feeling
0:56:44after a couple of runs that i was so
0:56:46tired that maybe I had made a terrible
0:56:49mistake in buying an all-day pass maybe
0:56:53I should go down and take a bath and and
0:56:57then skiing through that pain and
0:57:00loosening up and getting my you know and
0:57:04and finding reserves of strength and by
0:57:06the end you know and then i skied until
0:57:08the last run and was was sad too sad
0:57:12that they didn't have night skiing you
0:57:14know but it was very weird to feel like
0:57:18this was a thing that I then I I know
0:57:21how to do and then I think that is such
0:57:24a big part of my life really and i have
0:57:27chosen not to do it for 20 years for
0:57:30reasons that are all about
0:57:33well it's really expensive and it's kind
0:57:35of paint has to get up there so anyway
0:57:37it's better you know what I I'm gonna go
0:57:40to the cafe this morning and read the
0:57:42newspaper instead and everyday sort of
0:57:45making that decision for 20 years and
0:57:48and leaving this side of me where I
0:57:53actually know how to do something that's
0:57:55really gratifying that's physical and
0:57:57that's in this other realm and I just I
0:58:01just don't
0:58:02it's not a part of my life who and it
0:58:05was it was aight i'm still kind of like
0:58:08grappling with it
0:58:10grappling with how it how it how it is
0:58:16that i could go so that i could go year
0:58:19after year and not even want to do it
0:58:21once or
0:58:22want to do it but never have that desire
0:58:25to do it be enough to like overcome the
0:58:29inertia of of sitting around
0:58:36I mean doesn't question kinda sorta
0:58:38answer itself which was that you just
0:58:40you hadn't having not done so long i
0:58:42guess the question some ways like when
0:58:44do you start to not do something when
0:58:46does it start to count as you're not
0:58:47doing something cuz then once you did
0:58:48you were like oh this is great huh
0:58:50but like it used to be a huge part of
0:58:51your life so it seems strange that you
0:58:53didn't at least kind of check back in
0:58:54with it
0:58:55well yeah I mean it was a butt but it's
0:58:57sort of related to you know it's related
0:59:00to my well it's a relationship to action
0:59:03right if you like when I talk about this
0:59:07a lot i'll be on the freeway and AG i'll
0:59:09drive by me in a truck and he's pulling
0:59:11a trailer and it's got two snowmobiles
0:59:13and to dirt bikes and and and a boat all
0:59:17on the same trailer right and he's
0:59:19pulling this thing up into the siskiyou
0:59:21use and you just know that this guy's
0:59:25and his whole family's in the truck and
0:59:28he's got a cabin up there somewhere and
0:59:31he lives for this
0:59:33he's we work for his he works at his job
0:59:35but he's always thinking about getting
0:59:37up to the lake and you know my dad was
0:59:41like that with his freaking airplane his
0:59:43goddamn fuckin 182 and he just poured
0:59:47money into it and he every time the sun
0:59:50came out he's down at the airport
0:59:52monkeying with his airplane and you know
0:59:56every spare minute he's like let's go
0:59:58let's let's get a hamburger up
0:59:58let's let's get a hamburger up
1:00:00talking now let's fly up to nil chick
1:00:02and and then you're you know and then
1:00:05anything he would we get in the plane
1:00:08and he'd have his sunglasses on
1:00:10he'd have his reading glasses on top of
1:00:12his head because he needed them to where
1:00:13to look at maps and then he had a third
1:00:16pair of glasses on top of that to see
1:00:18long-distance had like three pairs of
1:00:21glasses on at all times when he's in his
1:00:23plan and work when we're puttering along
1:00:25and I'm looking out the window and I'm
1:00:26like you know this is a this is another
1:00:28thing I was raised doing right if that
1:00:30if you put me behind that if you put me
1:00:32in a 182 and said fly me somewhere I
1:00:34could i do it without thinking but it
1:00:38has never it never has interested me to
1:00:41have a habit of jet ski or a lake cabin
1:00:48or an hour a small plane because i have
1:00:51a different kind of relationship to
1:00:53action
1:00:54I don't care about action in a in a in a
1:00:58week in a way we do you do care about
1:01:01action
1:01:02I'm not sure I understand the question
1:01:05I don't think how do you mean I mean
1:01:10what I had to do with the guy with the
1:01:11jet skis
1:01:12I mean the guy with the jet skis is
1:01:18making such a personal investment right
1:01:20right
1:01:21he's such he's so its console costly to
1:01:25have that fun and that's what it always
1:01:28seems like to me like it seems like the
1:01:30kids a cost-benefit analysis I guess
1:01:32oh yeah sure and especially when you
1:01:34take into account the time the time and
1:01:36the and the getting up early and the
1:01:38just the gasoline
1:01:41I think everybody has such interesting
1:01:45differences and what they gravitate
1:01:46towards in terms of which you can very
1:01:48loosely call hobby
1:01:49yeah because there are so many the way I
1:01:52look at it anyway and every edit you
1:01:54just talked about in passing or
1:01:55in-person reflects the many vectors to
1:01:58that because you have things like should
1:02:01this be a largely practical thing or do
1:02:03I kind of like the fact that it's
1:02:05frivolous it for if you like or if it's
1:02:08something something that is you know
1:02:09doesn't have a practical purpose
1:02:11some people like making furniture cuz
1:02:13then
1:02:13they can make beautiful furniture and
1:02:15give it away you know some people like
1:02:16the fact that they're building something
1:02:17on a minecraft server that's just for
1:02:19fun
1:02:20is it something where I really want this
1:02:24way how much it does doing this expose
1:02:27me to other people and how do I feel
1:02:29about that because I really think a big
1:02:31part especially historically men's
1:02:32hobbies is there's the one kind where
1:02:34you hang out with other people and
1:02:36there's the other kind where you kind of
1:02:37have to be left alone
1:02:39I think those knocked her into it I'm
1:02:41and I mean I can go on there's things
1:02:43like I think there is an element I don't
1:02:45know not in the people that I like I
1:02:46hope this isn't always an element but
1:02:47there is the element then of conspicuous
1:02:49consumption like do I want to have three
1:02:52boats or do i want to have in that guys
1:02:54Casey's he's a little over transported
1:02:56in terms of the number of things he has
1:02:57but and then there's just stuff like in
1:02:59my family I think about how much the men
1:03:01love and my uncle my uncle my father me
1:03:06just so many people on and and I don't
1:03:09need to just talk about man but I think
1:03:10that's kind of the direction we're
1:03:11talking about here enjoy the
1:03:13paraphernalia of the hobby which could
1:03:17be stuff like reading magazines it could
1:03:18be things like going to the bike shop to
1:03:21look at wrenches or whatever and then
1:03:24you get into stuff like I guess this is
1:03:25kind of the social thing but shoptalk
1:03:28like getting the chance to go fly out to
1:03:30the guy who fixes your dad's plane and
1:03:31shoot the shit with himself and i don't
1:03:33know i think every one of those is so
1:03:35different and it could be something like
1:03:36could be me read a comic book myself at
1:03:39midnight or it could be you you know
1:03:42arranging the ski trip
1:03:43that's more money than you would
1:03:44normally pay and like what makes
1:03:46somebody find that attractive let alone
1:03:49real relaxing is is so different like
1:03:52the idea of going skiing to me is not
1:03:53appealing nothing it's bad but that's
1:03:56very much not something that I would go
1:03:58out of my way to do because it'll take
1:04:00my doesn't take my boxes has no
1:04:02practical application well you even
1:04:04still just like a little brother was
1:04:05trying to say that all these things men
1:04:07women and children whoever there's
1:04:10something that feels a little part of
1:04:12your personality what the nice thing
1:04:13about a hobby if you want to call it
1:04:15that it's kind of like this spring spray
1:04:17foam insulation you can shoot in your
1:04:19life that fills this important part that
1:04:21needs to be filled in for some people
1:04:23that's the social social part for other
1:04:24people's like I just need to be left
1:04:25alone for
1:04:26hours a week mowing the lawn great
1:04:27chance to listen to podcast and not talk
1:04:29to anybody you know I was that responds
1:04:32really what you're saying but I think
1:04:34that part partly explains you had a lot
1:04:36of your social intercourse coming from
1:04:37rock and roll for a long time and you
1:04:39know I mean I'm not trying to say
1:04:40there's like a one-to-one explanation
1:04:42but like I think it's actually sadly
1:04:45easy to understand why we fall out of
1:04:47things like that over time because other
1:04:49stuff takes its place and then the
1:04:50inertia
1:04:51now favors the new things you're doing
1:04:52rather than the old thing which is
1:04:54admittedly an expensive pain-in-the-ass
1:04:56I was what i was driving in and I was
1:04:58driving past the railroad which is how I
1:05:01get here every day I Drive past around
1:05:03and look at the railroad and today I was
1:05:06like railroad right the railroad it's so
1:05:12it would be it would have been to me so
1:05:17easy to talk about multiverses like
1:05:21there's a version of me that this is
1:05:24your sliding doors good one yeah and
1:05:26she's gonna make a difference
1:05:27yeah there's a version of me that just
1:05:29stayed in the ski resort town where I
1:05:30grew up and is still there
1:05:32there are dudes like that in every I
1:05:33mean I brought up the lift with the guys
1:05:35like i've been i've been at whistler for
1:05:3732 years I was like right I could have
1:05:40been incurred for 32 years and that
1:05:44would have died like that's an
1:05:45interesting version of me
1:05:47the one that stayed in Girdwood but
1:05:48there was there was a there is a version
1:05:50of me that really wanted to work for the
1:05:52railroad
1:05:53oh really yeah i mean look at the ski
1:05:57resort has a young adult as a kid in a
1:06:00unit okay like that i get i'm getting
1:06:02fire we drive around the Truman car I
1:06:04mean that sounds pretty fun pretty fun
1:06:07but like as when i was a kid looking at
1:06:09the future i really wanted to be a ski
1:06:11lift operator that seems like a great
1:06:13job and I wanted to be a so many jobs at
1:06:18the resort i wanted to be the the person
1:06:20that I want to be on the ski patrol I
1:06:24wanted to be one of those people that
1:06:26walks around the resort with a
1:06:27walkie-talkie and a baseball hat and is
1:06:30like taking care of business at the
1:06:31resort you know and and that was a thing
1:06:34I could have I could have pursued that
1:06:35job I never ended up having a job at the
1:06:37resort but my sister worked at the
1:06:39resort for years
1:06:40and but then with the railroad like to
1:06:44be I I was friends with the guy who was
1:06:46a conductor I bet this was a grunt rock
1:06:48friend of mine and he was one of those
1:06:50grunge rock people that had a straight
1:06:52job that was kind of fascinating i mean
1:06:56most rock-and-roll people have a
1:06:57straight job that's not fascinating your
1:06:59part bartender somewhere in order to
1:07:02make it go
1:07:02you kind of have to have something
1:07:03uneventful that yeah but is this guy had
1:07:06he his job was that he had started as a
1:07:08brakeman working for Amtrak and it
1:07:11worked his way up by the time he was 30
1:07:13years old to like conductor on routes
1:07:17leaving seattle and he had one of those
1:07:19jobs like being on an airline pilot
1:07:21where you worked you were on two days
1:07:23off three or something and then he did
1:07:26the most amazing thing I was pretty good
1:07:29friends with them at this time and I
1:07:32understood enough about railroad culture
1:07:35to know that there are two separate
1:07:39tracks you are on the conductor track or
1:07:41you are on the engineer track and
1:07:44there's no crossover if you're on the
1:07:47engineer track you start at the bottom
1:07:49and work your way up and you're an
1:07:51engineer and if you're on the conductor
1:07:52track you become a conductor but that
1:07:54you're different worlds and he got to be
1:07:56a conductor and gave it all away and
1:08:00started as started to as an apprentice
1:08:02in on the engineer track started over 30
1:08:06years old because he wanted to be up in
1:08:10that engine on those three day trips
1:08:14across the plains whatever end and he
1:08:18has sent sort of disappeared from my
1:08:19life he he became an engineer and and
1:08:24literally drove that train high on
1:08:27cocaine now
1:08:29probably not yeah but like a you know
1:08:32drove that train off into the tunnel of
1:08:35of the future and watching those trains
1:08:39this morning I was like wow what if i
1:08:41just got to work for the railroad like
1:08:43it's so elegant their tracks literally
1:08:48you're on a track
1:08:50you don't have to worry about if you're
1:08:52on the right track
1:08:53you are on the right track or you're on
1:08:58the wrong track and that's terrible you
1:08:59you're gonna figure that out pretty fast
1:09:01too
1:09:01[Music]
1:09:03yeah we all learned about this thing so
1:09:05that's a particularly interesting one
1:09:06I mean I guess there's world where I was
1:09:08playing still playing any rocker being a
1:09:10waiter but i like the idea of the the
1:09:11the train thing but what other than
1:09:14playing indie-rock what was what was
1:09:16that what was the fantasy job that you
1:09:18had that like you think back and go what
1:09:21if I had been a hot air balloon
1:09:25well I mean the ones that were there
1:09:29called the world's supply / surprisingly
1:09:30in reach because I i did I wanted to be
1:09:35a writer i wanted to do design of
1:09:38different kinds and i think at the time
1:09:39I maybe in retrospect it's kind of
1:09:42surprising how much more in reach these
1:09:44things were than I expected
1:09:46I never in the modern age had anything
1:09:49like I want to be a baseball player or
1:09:52anything like that but i don't know i
1:09:55don't know it's strange though because
1:09:57there's a funny thing that happens I
1:09:58think you kind of address in the past
1:10:00but it's kind of funny were like you
1:10:01watch somebody for a while you watch the
1:10:03doing you turn away from me you come
1:10:04back you're like whoa that guy's an
1:10:05engineer on the road now or whatever you
1:10:08discover these people who have been like
1:10:09quietly building this super interesting
1:10:11career and you kind of never noticed it
1:10:13because they were doing something else
1:10:14or you're you're more focused on there
1:10:16maybe the music part contains certain
1:10:17point but i think people are are are are
1:10:19super interesting and of course as
1:10:21always I'm very envious in a weird way
1:10:23of people who join the army when they're
1:10:26young
1:10:26oh god so my i have but all of this I
1:10:29feel like comes back to the fact that i
1:10:31can i am i'm still just now even just
1:10:35now grappling with the fact that that i
1:10:38do not have access to a multiverse right
1:10:41like I'm not even get like the
1:10:43newsletter
1:10:44I've always lived I lived my whole life
1:10:46as though them as though the the
1:10:50multiverse a like exchange station was
1:10:55going to be open to me and i was going
1:10:56to be able to walk in and say now I'd
1:10:58like to be an army man for 25 years I
1:11:00think that's probably less silly
1:11:02sounding then you realize because I bet
1:11:05that's true
1:11:06because no because I mean it pulls
1:11:09together several threads about your life
1:11:12and your self assessment that I find
1:11:14very interesting I mean one of them
1:11:15being that you are in some ways more
1:11:18interested in breadth and depth you'd
1:11:19like to learn a little bit about many
1:11:21many things I think that kind of matches
1:11:23up with that it matches up with the way
1:11:26that you know life kind of pinballs us
1:11:27around and we end up going into this
1:11:29place we never expected and wasn't that
1:11:31interesting thought it would be nice to
1:11:33have a little view into what that would
1:11:34have turned out to be
1:11:36that's a scary idea right i mean i and
1:11:38and part of that is that I I'm more
1:11:40interested in breadth and depth but now
1:11:42now that is why i put that kind of like
1:11:44no I think that's I think that's
1:11:46generally true but now that we're in our
1:11:48forties and we see all these people that
1:11:50have tremendous step
1:11:51yeah i would really like a breath of
1:11:53depth oh brother I'm not yeah i mean i
1:11:56don't know mostly I i have to deal with
1:11:59other adults because i have a child and
1:12:01select the parents of other kids over
1:12:04there they feel terrible about my life
1:12:06there's one guy who's a scientist and
1:12:09he's not just a scientist he's a
1:12:10biologist he's not justify it he works
1:12:12on a very very specific kind of frog he
1:12:15does very specific frog work and he
1:12:17loved that he's like the go-to guy for
1:12:19that kind of frog
1:12:20yeah oh yeah yeah and I got ya I don't
1:12:23want to know it but i guess for the envy
1:12:25that
1:12:25yeah yeah well that's and that is B
1:12:28that's the Matthew McConaughey in a
1:12:31contact problem to bring it around which
1:12:35is that part of what made that role so
1:12:37infuriating is that he is this person
1:12:40with this like this sort of global
1:12:44religious wisdom but he's like a young
1:12:48surfer asshole
1:12:50mm and that fantasy that you would be
1:12:55that you would be young and yet already
1:12:59be this is the thing that Hollywood does
1:13:01to us all the time like oh here comes
1:13:03the world expert on frogs and it turns
1:13:05out it's a 24 year-old actress right i
1:13:09mean we see if it's the james bond can
1:13:11be the key honorees movie with the with
1:13:13the dolphins
1:13:14Johnny mnemonic no I didn't see it well
1:13:17I mean it'sit's this and this is I don't
1:13:19mean this
1:13:20sounds quite the way it sounds but you
1:13:21know there's a lot of incredibly
1:13:23talented men and women out there playing
1:13:24many roles but there used to be a thing
1:13:26I think especially in the nineties of
1:13:28taking a certain kind of very attractive
1:13:31young actress and trying to sell her as
1:13:33a as like the science person and it's I
1:13:38won't even always say was the actress i
1:13:39think a lot of it was the material
1:13:41wasn't up to it and so you end up
1:13:42everybody sounds silly and that was like
1:13:45such a thing for a while just in this
1:13:46case it's matthew mcconaughey who's the
1:13:48young woman was that Timothy Dalton
1:13:50movie where Timothy Dalton James Bond
1:13:53where the hour without ya get the girl
1:13:56with the eyes from the movie you have a
1:13:57galaxy note she's she's the one with the
1:13:59nose from starship troopers yes and I
1:14:02know exactly who you mean and she says
1:14:04she's she's like the the China
1:14:07torrington or something you have that
1:14:09all known scientist but she's a
1:14:11scientist or a nuclear of prison system
1:14:13sometimes denise richards ah who who was
1:14:18who a very very very handsome woman but
1:14:21she was a yeah she was like a national
1:14:24lab coat John she may have had a lab
1:14:27coat I'm trying to think wasn't she
1:14:29married to the guy from two and a half
1:14:30men think she was married to Charlie
1:14:32Sheen yeah Charlie Sheen everybody was a
1:14:34tiger and anyway yeah her her roll her
1:14:38commanding role as like the super
1:14:40scientist in that james bond movie was I
1:14:43think the that was the example that was
1:14:45the peak moment that's about a big peak
1:14:47wow really this is the this is the one
1:14:49this is the butt but I feel like this I
1:14:52feel I felt like in a way that sneaks
1:14:55into all of our minds and we all have
1:14:56this this idea that like well there are
1:14:59some twenty-five-year-old super
1:15:01scientist who also happen to be models
1:15:04and surfers and uh and so I'm comparing
1:15:07myself against them somewhat but at this
1:15:10point in my life I'm not the expert on
1:15:11the frogs yeah and that and being and so
1:15:15it that such as it's so seductive
1:15:18can you imagine like what do i do i do
1:15:21this frog what what am i doing tomorrow
1:15:24this frog what a what am I going to be
1:15:26remembered for this frog I know
1:15:27everything about this from gonna be easy
1:15:30to explain but it is simple to explain
1:15:31like
1:15:32to describe exactly what I do with these
1:15:34frogs gonna take some time but you can
1:15:36just all you need to know is I'm the
1:15:37go-to guy for this one kind of frog got
1:15:39a question about this frog
1:15:40yeah I also know about other frogs but
1:15:43this guy is my this is my guy
1:15:45yeah I you know but a lot of his work
1:15:49with work you know what and it maybe it
1:15:53maybe Maryland that one day when they
1:15:55look back and they say two guys talking
1:15:58podcast right guys talking podcast
1:16:02have you heard of this two guys talking
1:16:03podcast who's the expert who's the
1:16:06expert on the two guys talking podcast a
1:16:08track that's going to be Merlin Mann
1:16:11science farmers were there idea right
1:16:13paper but whoever said who said that
1:16:16technology first
1:16:17oh well I think that's yes if history
1:16:20goes a certain way i think our future is
1:16:22going to be fine and the thing is we
1:16:24can't that's something we're inside it
1:16:26right now we can't see it we cannot see
1:16:28we're too close to it we can't see the
1:16:30forest for the frogs
1:16:31mmm yeah that'll do you think the
1:16:36president's ever didn't want to meet
1:16:38with billy graham and i don't think a
1:16:41single president wanted to meet with
1:16:43billy graham every president since
1:16:44truman met with Billy Graham and I
1:16:47wonder for a certain point they're like
1:16:49okay what's your week look like well you
1:16:50know we gotta go we gotta talk to you
1:16:52Gorbachev about about this dinner and Oh
1:16:55doing only looks like it's about time to
1:16:59talk to Billy Graham again
1:17:00well here's a question for you which
1:17:01presidents do you think were actually
1:17:03religious people of faith who governed
1:17:07in part based upon their faith and
1:17:10beliefs
1:17:11i mean i-i think a question yeah I think
1:17:13Jimmy Carter was oh yeah and i think i
1:17:16think probably ronald reagan was really
1:17:18pretty opportunistic I don't know he
1:17:22said he's an onion he's tough to peel
1:17:24but like LBJ no not at all right well
1:17:30yeah but are you mean like I don't also
1:17:31would not want to imply that you cannot
1:17:33be a cynical tough you know person in
1:17:39governance who doesn't also have faith
1:17:41Yeah right right I'm gonna be a little
1:17:42bit you know broad but but get Jimmy
1:17:44Carter for sure
1:17:45I mean I think I think price
1:17:46he when he when he when he drinks he
1:17:48probably genuinely felt bad
1:17:49yeah right and and despite George a bush
1:17:54juniors george w bush's like despite him
1:17:58being so terrible you genuinely did get
1:18:01a sense that he that he believed in his
1:18:05that he believed in his religion and he
1:18:06believed in and he was little I kind of
1:18:09get that I get that he has like in our
1:18:11church they had all different like when
1:18:14the kids were in Sunday school so you
1:18:15get the unit sanctuary think everybody
1:18:17goes to then you got sunday school and
1:18:18all the little kids would go to Sunday
1:18:19school for their grade the grown-ups got
1:18:22to choose different groups study groups
1:18:25if you like your classes based upon our
1:18:28demographics based upon partly like what
1:18:31their interest was and so there was like
1:18:32a hip young singles bible study group
1:18:36are there was the like I don't they have
1:18:39had fantastic names like remember
1:18:41lamplighters was one of them they had
1:18:44these great you know New Testament kind
1:18:46of names but but then I remember this
1:18:48one
1:18:49dr. Russell Cottle was the leader of
1:18:51this one and it was like the MIT of
1:18:54adult church classes and he went in
1:18:57there you didn't read the Bible you
1:18:59studied this shit out of the Bible and
1:19:00you brought a fucking concordance like a
1:19:02gentleman and you have to really sit
1:19:04down and talk about in turnover big
1:19:06ideas about you know the stuff that
1:19:09people even outside Christian enjoy
1:19:10talking about the paradox the Trinity
1:19:12like how does that actually work is
1:19:14there is the Holy Spirit really did I
1:19:15mean is he get really one-third of the
1:19:16credit how does this work
1:19:17there's all kinds of fascinating stuff
1:19:19when you get into like you know as I'm
1:19:21sure you must be on some level the
1:19:23discussion of Christianity can be
1:19:24extremely interesting
1:19:26yeah um and so what do i say that
1:19:28because I see jimmy carter going to dr
1:19:30Cotterill's class and I see George W
1:19:33Bush maybe just hanging out by the miss
1:19:36pac-man I don't wonder if he really
1:19:39thought a lot
1:19:41oh i think it's i think i think it's a
1:19:42difference in i think it's a it's the
1:19:45transformation of Christianity right i
1:19:46mean Jimmy Carter was practicing that
1:19:49what we always imagined was the
1:19:52Christian spirit and by the time George
1:19:55Bush got into the church it was much
1:19:57more of this prosperity gospel
1:19:59wasn't his mostly you know what this is
1:20:01so awful to talk about
1:20:03I field now I feel bad but wasn't his
1:20:05partly an arrival out of the drying up
1:20:08well yeah but I mean you dry up and then
1:20:11there if you if you are interested in
1:20:13going the religion route than your you
1:20:15just you dry up and it's like you came
1:20:17up the escalator into the job fair of
1:20:19religions at the convention center you
1:20:21can pick whatever resonates with you
1:20:23right
1:20:24you see he's got the best tip back yeah
1:20:26right and there are plenty of people
1:20:27that dry up and become Buddhists or dry
1:20:29up and go back to being Catholics like
1:20:31they were when they were kids actually
1:20:32there must be a special appeal to a
1:20:34certain kind of slightly moist I'd
1:20:37american christian and i think there is
1:20:39for sure and i think you know i w-was
1:20:44was in every way already pointed at this
1:20:48version of sort of Southern Baptists but
1:20:52whatever that whatever that has morphed
1:20:54into yeah well it's just like if you if
1:20:58you follow the force you know the four
1:20:59steps of like give yourself over and so
1:21:02forth and so on then everything good is
1:21:05going to happen and you don't have any
1:21:07doubt anymore and that's so different
1:21:08from the one that Jimmy Carter practices
1:21:10where they're like really cheering
1:21:13full-time lifestyle guy
1:21:15yeah let me out i'm not doing a lot
1:21:17right are we doing it right or we you
1:21:19know how do we help people i mean that's
1:21:21so different you get such an i mean i
1:21:23don't want to see him just lyin eyes
1:21:24Jimmy Carter but uh fuck that guy but
1:21:27like you know you also really do get the
1:21:29sense that like whatever kind of human
1:21:30he is that he does there's something
1:21:33inside of him where it's probably
1:21:34virtually impossible to tell how much of
1:21:36his personal generosity comes out of his
1:21:38faith and beliefs which comes out of his
1:21:39ethics how much it comes out of his
1:21:41heritage but is something to all of
1:21:42those things that make this vulture on
1:21:44of kindness that I i find very admirable
1:21:48say what you will about the guys
1:21:49presidency and you know reckon the
1:21:51chopper or whatever but like I he just
1:21:53seems like a genuinely good guy
1:21:55yeah and then that's what that's what I
1:21:56mean like like JFK nominally a Catholic
1:22:00we were all terrified of his Catholicism
1:22:02rapist you don't you don't look at paint
1:22:05this in the White House you don't really
1:22:06look at the way he conducted his own
1:22:08life and think well here there's
1:22:10somebody who they're really like really
1:22:12cares
1:22:13about Catholicism yeah i got that I get
1:22:16the feeling rosaries were not on his
1:22:18mind when he was doing what he did and
1:22:20so I look at all the US presidents and
1:22:22all they all saw Billy Graham they all
1:22:24profess to be practicing more or less
1:22:27the same version and i do not see I do
1:22:32not see much evidence of it except in
1:22:38those two cases right Carter as the
1:22:41completely thoughtful Christian and
1:22:43george bush's that completely like
1:22:45unreflective Christian and that's pretty
1:22:48that's pretty phenomenal it's hard to
1:22:51know somebody's heart it's hard to know
1:22:52and you know I don't necessarily feel
1:22:54like we're being kind of unkind but I I
1:22:56don't know I I don't know the answer to
1:22:58that but you know in one of our many
1:23:00lost episodes at the guy I said
1:23:02something to you one time that really
1:23:03means a lot to me which is that I you
1:23:05didn't disagree with this but like
1:23:06there's I i feel like i have these
1:23:08friends where you could be friends with
1:23:10this person for 10 years and kinda only
1:23:14came up once or twice that they even
1:23:16quote unquote go to church but there's
1:23:18something about the way they conduct
1:23:20themselves not is really admirable and
1:23:24kind and gentle and sometimes funny and
1:23:27maybe they drinking playing bands and
1:23:29stuff but there's nothing to what they
1:23:30do that this was about like
1:23:32proselytizing or judging but they're
1:23:34always the ones who show up to help
1:23:36people offer stuff and that's the strain
1:23:38that I seen something like Jimmy Carter
1:23:40and I saw like in the people i want to
1:23:41church with are getting into that topic
1:23:43here no not at all i remember hilarious
1:23:46McConaughey have but we know we had a
1:23:49disagreement one time you and I long
1:23:51time before we started doing this
1:23:52podcast it was one of the it was one of
1:23:54those times when you called me on the
1:23:55phone to yell about the Beatles and we
1:23:57started talking about something else
1:23:59here comes the third rail and it was a
1:24:02it was a it was a it was a real telling
1:24:04moment where I said something like
1:24:06listen I don't think if you're a
1:24:09Christian I don't think you should smoke
1:24:10pot and you said we're talking about and
1:24:14I was like practice what you preach and
1:24:17you were like it has nothing to do with
1:24:18it that another one thing has nothing to
1:24:20do with the other thing sounds like me
1:24:22yeah and I was like I think it has
1:24:24everything to do with that if you if you
1:24:25are if you
1:24:26a Christian you can also be an alcoholic
1:24:27and you're like your bananas two things
1:24:33are unrelated and that we had this we
1:24:35will you yelled at each other for like a
1:24:37half an hour we did
1:24:38yeah i was like no no if you're a
1:24:40christian you god damn drive you should
1:24:42drive the speed limit and you should you
1:24:45know it's kind of a walk the walk to
1:24:47talk to type thing right yeah we're
1:24:49saying like if you're gonna be this you
1:24:51should you should
1:24:52it seems to seem to you that you should
1:24:54also have to be all these other things
1:24:55well I already should show right yeah
1:24:57and it should show in all these other
1:25:00things that you do it in a way it's a
1:25:02kind of it's the argument it's the
1:25:04predestination argument it's the
1:25:05Calvinist kind of like well you can't
1:25:08know whether you're going to have it or
1:25:09not but if you are one of the chosen it
1:25:12would be exhibited in your action and
1:25:14now that's a good time travel movie
1:25:16right then finish
1:25:20they will know we are Christians by our
1:25:22guns by argon