Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 137: "Arsenal of Civilization"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this episode of Roderick on the line is

0:00:01sponsored by Squarespace the only one

0:00:03platform that makes it fast and easy to

0:00:05create your own professional website

0:00:07portfolio and online store for a free

0:00:10trial and ten percent off visit

0:00:12squarespace.com and use the very special

0:00:14offer code supertrain at checkout better

0:00:16web starts with your website

0:00:18[Music]

0:00:23hello hi John Admiral mmm yeah I'm

0:00:27Merlin how's it going

0:00:34we got to put that on a shirt i wonder

0:00:37how you spell it lots of peas and bees

0:00:40things are things are good things are

0:00:46good

0:00:47it's a i have not been sleeping enough

0:00:51oh dear I stay up late and then I wake

0:00:54up early and that's the that's a bad

0:00:57combo

0:00:58uh-huh that leads to some five hours of

0:01:01sleep pneus uh-huh five hours of sleep

0:01:05and then several days in a row and then

0:01:08pretty soon you're like huh I wonder why

0:01:11I feel like killing people

0:01:13mm because i have been sleeping enough

0:01:15homicidal of sleep deprivation

0:01:18yeah now it's just the worst i mean you

0:01:21know you can you can do one of those you

0:01:22do a couple of those and you know and

0:01:24also the thing is if your ice

0:01:26I don't know if it's because you're busy

0:01:27you're not busy or you're super busy but

0:01:29like if you're really busy

0:01:31yeah deadline and you do that you get

0:01:33some kind of like an adrenaline thing we

0:01:36get mad at the right thing

0:01:37hmm you don't mean you're like that I

0:01:39work well under those circumstances

0:01:42yeah but last night I was lying in bed

0:01:44and by the way happy happy new year John

0:01:46who is it

0:01:48oh yeah thank you as a few i had a

0:01:50pretty good new year

0:01:51yeah so I picture a pretty good new your

0:01:53time the guy across the street that's

0:01:56living in the van that I realized it is

0:02:00name isn't vani it's gary and of course

0:02:02if you're living in a van behind a hedge

0:02:04question is Gary get married why is that

0:02:10such a perfect name

0:02:11I don't know Gary and he and I have had

0:02:13several encounters lately and gary has a

0:02:16has that thing where you see him and you

0:02:19talked to him for 45 minutes and they

0:02:21see in the next day and and he's never

0:02:23met you before but I so i ended up

0:02:29I've tried to call my across-the-street

0:02:31neighbor several times and it's what

0:02:33it's a thing where the the anonymous

0:02:35voicemail

0:02:36voice answers the phone and says the

0:02:38mailbox is full and then just hangs up

0:02:40on you and it's and it's a weird voice

0:02:42it's not the voice that you normally

0:02:45hear it's like a voice that you might

0:02:47hear if you bought your phone at a gas

0:02:50station

0:02:50yeah i got verizon voice or something

0:02:52some kind of weird voice where it's like

0:02:53up the moist message bell box you're

0:02:56trying to reach is full

0:02:57click and so I was like uh you know

0:03:00Gary's out there is the ellen is yelling

0:03:03into the phone he's yelling at his

0:03:04ex-wife just one o'clock in the morning

0:03:07I don't wanna die I you know I don't

0:03:10want him with the fire hose but

0:03:12something's got you know like when i

0:03:15started that he won't remember the next

0:03:16day likely i started to ask myself the

0:03:19question

0:03:19hey what's the long game here is Gary

0:03:22gonna live in the van in the front yard

0:03:23of my neighbors house for another year

0:03:25or two years or five years like there's

0:03:29a little bit starting to he's a very

0:03:32angry guy and I have a little kid right

0:03:35so I so I called the neighbor went to

0:03:37straight to voicemail but then

0:03:38miraculously she called me back

0:03:41associations she's just for folks who

0:03:43haven't been following this you're

0:03:45pretty worried about her for awhile you

0:03:46haven't seen her in a while there are

0:03:47people moving in and out there appeared

0:03:49to be some parties a lot of corners

0:03:50looking good is coming in and out of the

0:03:52house it was a bad scene for a while and

0:03:55then it calm down and you know and there

0:03:57was a kind of a new normal which was at

0:04:00least it's quiet on the set and the the

0:04:02regular characters are there but I

0:04:03hadn't seen her in a long time but I

0:04:05figured you know I figured if they had

0:04:07if they buried her in a shallow grave

0:04:10they wouldn't just be coming and going

0:04:12with with the like 7-11 bags and stuff

0:04:17you know they'd be hightailing it or

0:04:19they be stripping the copper pipes or

0:04:20something right

0:04:22anyway I called her she called me back

0:04:23as one o'clock in the morning she's like

0:04:25hey I saw that you called and I was like

0:04:26hi haven't talked in a long time

0:04:30she's like hi nice to hear from you it's

0:04:331am and in between our two houses there

0:04:37are two things there's a a laurel hedge

0:04:39that's 25 feet tall and there is a 1968

0:04:45ford van slowly rusting into the ground

0:04:48with four flat tires emulated by gary

0:04:52and in the middle of the van is Gary and

0:04:55gary is and there's an extension cord

0:04:57running from the van to the to the

0:04:59outlet on the front of her house and

0:05:02gary is audible to me quite audible in

0:05:06the van going got tough to get it

0:05:08fuck you to you know just like having a

0:05:13an explosion of Rage 470 Sam that's been

0:05:16lasting for like you know long enough

0:05:19it's been lasting long enough that I did

0:05:21I decided I was gonna like call my

0:05:22neighbor and she's like what's going on

0:05:25i'm like i'm calling about Gary and she

0:05:27was like yeah I mean yeah I couldn't you

0:05:30know I can make it easy for me okay Gary

0:05:33time and even suck air she didn't go

0:05:35yeah Gary no no nothing just like yeah

0:05:38and I think what it is is that there is

0:05:40a place in her house she can go where

0:05:43she doesn't hear Carrie and there and I

0:05:47mean there are places in my house where

0:05:49I can go but what those places are not

0:05:51my living room or bedroom and I'm like

0:05:54Carrie is it Gary I have to be honest

0:05:56with you Gary starting to be a problem

0:05:58for me and she's like yeah and then she

0:06:00does kind of soften and she's like yeah

0:06:02Gary Gary needs to go and I'm like I

0:06:05don't want to be the one to say it but

0:06:07you know Gary I think I really think

0:06:10Gary's got to go and she was like yeah

0:06:12he's really going to be a problem he

0:06:13started to he's cussing me out now and

0:06:16I'm like I know you want to help Gary

0:06:18but I started out is to do you remember

0:06:20right that it started out as her kind of

0:06:22helping rehab him

0:06:24yeah she's talked for a while she was

0:06:26gonna run a little rehab house there and

0:06:27then she got engaged to one of the guys

0:06:29and then the other guy sucking covered

0:06:31in his van for a year at least

0:06:33and so we had a very nice conversation

0:06:36about how Gary needed to hustle up but

0:06:39you know shuffle off to Buffalo and on

0:06:41the one hand i'm thinking you know it's

0:06:43the holidays right around the new year

0:06:46it's a vulnerable time for everybody

0:06:48maybe maybe I should take a softer line

0:06:52on Gary right now and then the other

0:06:55voice in my head was like what

0:06:57well fuck Gary

0:06:59uh everybody hits the bottom and

0:07:01sometimes your bottom is that uh the

0:07:05next door neighbor finally calls and

0:07:07says that you that there that he's going

0:07:09to send a tow truck for your van

0:07:11are you there still no yeah no no I'm

0:07:14listen I'm thinking so is its diff it's

0:07:18so difficult because it's difficult when

0:07:20I have those conversations I'm braced

0:07:22for it to go poorly and you know and I I

0:07:25don't want to be comforted hate being

0:07:26confrontational with people about stuff

0:07:28that is right on the bubble of their

0:07:30business and not my business yeah you

0:07:32have so uncomfortable about I really you

0:07:34know it's whether it's a teenager having

0:07:36a party or somebody parking in the

0:07:38driveway or whatever I just think like

0:07:40how much of this is in my head

0:07:41personally how much this is in my head

0:07:43and I could just be a fucking gentleman

0:07:45and let it go and when you have a nice

0:07:47conversation

0:07:48I don't feel that much better because

0:07:49now I really do feel like a party pooper

0:07:51want to have that conversation one also

0:07:53now we broach the topic so if Gary's

0:07:56still there in a week which he

0:07:57absolutely is going to be then there's a

0:08:01new uncomfortableness which is we talked

0:08:03about Gary getting the Gary getting gone

0:08:06and now there's the there's the there's

0:08:13the implication of a timeline because

0:08:16we've had a conversation about it and

0:08:17she's implicitly agreed that it should

0:08:20happen

0:08:21yeah implicitly that it will happen yeah

0:08:24that it will happen and so then it's

0:08:26like every time I see her now it's like

0:08:28so how's it going with Gary are we where

0:08:31we add on that and that is like not

0:08:33that's not a relationship i want to have

0:08:35with her you know I she she definitely

0:08:37has an uphill climb and I mean for a

0:08:42year

0:08:42I've I haven't said a word about it

0:08:44because it because it does it falls into

0:08:45that category like well it's on her

0:08:47property and it is her business and if

0:08:49gary was her boyfriend and he was in

0:08:52there

0:08:53drunkenly screaming into the phone every

0:08:55night and be like well that's just what

0:08:57happens when you live in a neighborhood

0:08:58right right but gary is it fair to the

0:09:03crucial distinction which is gary is

0:09:06living in the front yard and the front

0:09:08yard is enough of a puppet that it's not

0:09:11it's still on her property but it

0:09:12it is public space in the center and

0:09:15John it is a van

0:09:17it's a van and it's that mean that year

0:09:19is a long time for someone to live in a

0:09:21van it softens front yard and you know

0:09:23that's getting the driveway that's

0:09:24Gary's life choice or whatever but the

0:09:27thing is the van is tucked behind this

0:09:28Laurel head in a way that the cops are

0:09:31not aware it's there nobody's aware it's

0:09:32there I thought about it the other day

0:09:34if the hedge wasn't there and it was

0:09:36just this rusting ass piece of shit man

0:09:39with an extension cord going in one of

0:09:42the windows and a guy in there yelling

0:09:44into his phone

0:09:46like other people would have taken

0:09:48notice but and you know and like health

0:09:51and human services or whatever would

0:09:53have said are you bigger you pissing in

0:09:54a bucket like where how much access does

0:09:58Gary have to the house and have and like

0:10:00that's a crucial especially if your if

0:10:03your chronic alcoholic like sometimes

0:10:05you gotta go to the bathroom

0:10:07I just always think about fires I don't

0:10:09know why as i get older i think about

0:10:11like you know maybe Gary nods off the

0:10:16marlboro red going mmm not so you know

0:10:18next thing you know it's a piece like

0:10:20it's the keys a can of beans and his

0:10:23quarters are just single because my next

0:10:28book my other next-door neighbor Patrick

0:10:30Patrick everybody's feelings Justin

0:10:33Patrick will drop a little science on me

0:10:35every once awhile about Gary's like to

0:10:38hear that guy here that guy out there

0:10:40slamming his van door and stuff in the

0:10:43middle of night and I'm like oh I hear

0:10:44him Patrick go Patrick is is definitely

0:10:48on he he airs on the other side of like

0:10:50what happens on your property is your

0:10:52business

0:10:53Patrick's also the guy that that fired a

0:10:56gun in the air when some teenage kid

0:10:57climbed on the roof to Patrick right

0:11:00talk to the talk to his teenage daughter

0:11:01and so I mean I know Patrick when the

0:11:04chips are down Patrick's capable of like

0:11:06handling a situation if you needed to do

0:11:09of for Gary extraction capture him in

0:11:12his underwear with a gun in the street

0:11:14something something again back and I

0:11:16think I think Patrick's actually you

0:11:17know off the sauce to do so the whole

0:11:19neighborhood's cleaning up but the like

0:11:22carries the last

0:11:24he's the last of the mohicans and uh and

0:11:29I just who i mean i'm going on and that

0:11:32we finally have the conversation but now

0:11:34it's getting now I don't know what to do

0:11:36I don't you know there have been times

0:11:38when I thought that I would just run a

0:11:41hose from Gary's tailpipe right into the

0:11:43back window and then we solve the

0:11:44problem completely but Gary never turns

0:11:46the motor on because the band doesn't

0:11:48run anymore so anyway that's at that and

0:11:53that's not why I'm not sleeping the

0:11:55reason I'm not sleeping is that I set up

0:11:58until five o'clock in the morning

0:11:59looking at ebay on my phone but right

0:12:03but Gary screaming at his ex-wife isn't

0:12:06helping me right and I wonder what the

0:12:10hell she's doing at one o'clock in the

0:12:11morning taking these hour-long phone

0:12:13calls you know what I mean like if if I

0:12:15were her I would have had to hang up the

0:12:17phone after a certain after look like

0:12:20the 40th raged fuck you I'd be like okay

0:12:25Carrie that's the thing about a about

0:12:28eight what I was going to say toxic

0:12:31personality but i'll say let's say an

0:12:33incendiary personality whether that is

0:12:36in real life or on the internet or

0:12:38whatever and I'll speak for myself my

0:12:40reaction is to just not poke at it and i

0:12:42would i would just as soon find some way

0:12:44to just kind of avoid it and that's

0:12:46probably that's kind of what everybody

0:12:47wants to do unless you're somebody who

0:12:49is you know very convert confrontation

0:12:51like if there's if I'm on the train with

0:12:53my kid and somebody's having a meltdown

0:12:57yep which happened I mean you we've

0:13:00we've been on the train where they had

0:13:02to stop it and have the cops pull up

0:13:03because the driver had to call the cops

0:13:04were basically the entire part of the

0:13:07car has emptied out except for you know

0:13:09what one homeless guy like melting down

0:13:11and screaming obscenities and swing

0:13:13things around and so in that case like

0:13:15there's the short certainly there's a

0:13:16part of me that goes like that's a human

0:13:17being is suffering that somebody who

0:13:20like with a little bit of medication and

0:13:21a hot meal might do a little better

0:13:23my inclination is to just get my kid

0:13:25movie other side of the of the training

0:13:26right it's so much easier and i have to

0:13:29say in general I mean you're going to

0:13:31live in a city that is that is a healthy

0:13:34way to be because you can't fix

0:13:36everything right when you

0:13:38take care of yourself you gotta go check

0:13:39your six as you say

0:13:41yep but but you know I don't but there's

0:13:43one guys one guy in our neighborhood not

0:13:46the not the chicken eating rice throwing

0:13:48guy but there's one guy in our

0:13:49neighborhood who like I all I had maybe

0:13:52three years ago I almost came to blows

0:13:53with um I think he's deeply

0:13:56schizophrenic he sleeps in doorways and

0:14:00I and he would just randomly yell things

0:14:03at people and in one particular occasion

0:14:05I have a pretty thick skin for city

0:14:08stuff but he got close enough and loud

0:14:10enough when i was with my kid one time

0:14:11that I kind of stepped him a little bit

0:14:13which as you can imagine this unusual

0:14:15for me

0:14:15yeah I felt like it was a situation

0:14:16where I had to stick out my chest a

0:14:18little bit and get past the fog with

0:14:20this guy because it felt like it was

0:14:21kind of like an imminent thing

0:14:23yeah and after that happened I got

0:14:26really i would avoid him i would I did

0:14:30not like the guy

0:14:31yeah because he had you know I felt

0:14:33menaced by the guy you know of course

0:14:35there's a small part of me that felt bad

0:14:37for him if anything happened like with a

0:14:39year or so later something happened

0:14:41maybe he got picked up and put somewhere

0:14:44for a while but he got what I'm guessing

0:14:46is medicated right and got healthy and

0:14:50he was he would still be sitting in

0:14:51front of the walgreens with his hand out

0:14:53and I mean this guy Demi that we're

0:14:55talking like like just like you know

0:14:58same clothes for four months covered in

0:15:00front of stuff and just filthy and and

0:15:04the thing was though and suddenly I

0:15:07don't say his name but but eventually he

0:15:09started saying like hey any chance you

0:15:10could help me out today and I was like

0:15:12whoa hello

0:15:13he's and I was like oh sorry man not

0:15:15today which is of course what you say

0:15:17but I real and i would hear him having

0:15:19conversations with people and he sounded

0:15:21like a little bit of a crank but he

0:15:23wasn't dangerous anymore and yeah I

0:15:26don't know I felt like shit about it I

0:15:28felt terrible about it because i can't

0:15:30really do that much to help this guy but

0:15:32he is my official adoptive look homeless

0:15:34guy wherever I live this is my this is

0:15:36my policy on giving money that homeless

0:15:38people i pick exactly one person every

0:15:40time I see them I give them five dollars

0:15:41and you show you chose this going to be

0:15:43your have adopted for for like maybe a

0:15:46year and a half now

0:15:47mhm and if I got a little cash or I feel

0:15:49like you know something to say I'm done

0:15:51in awhile just say hey Larry unit and

0:15:56take it easy man

0:15:56and you know but like I I the whole in

0:15:59every part of that makes me feel like

0:16:01shit i feel like shit that I got

0:16:02emotional with him I feel terrible that

0:16:04he is a schizophrenic man living on the

0:16:05streets and you know where I live

0:16:07wearing them

0:16:07we're really in them in the outside

0:16:11lands as they say it's nothing like what

0:16:12you get if you live in the castro or

0:16:14something but I don't know the whole

0:16:16thing makes me feel terrible and of

0:16:17course then it just makes me more filled

0:16:19with self-doubt in the same way that I

0:16:21would be reluctant to call out Jerry you

0:16:23know what I mean it's like there's a

0:16:25part of me that's like me and

0:16:26everybody's fucked up and there hasn't

0:16:28been a fire so I don't wanna be a dick

0:16:30yeah right and and this is the you know

0:16:34the the famous old adage and I don't

0:16:37know whether it was Churchill or Mark

0:16:38Twain or dingus khan or Descartes who

0:16:42said hard heart of the conservative and

0:16:45liberal yeah right yeah right here

0:16:48tonight is not a liberal by the time

0:16:49he's a young man

0:16:50yeah hard-hearted anyone is not a

0:16:52conservative by the time their forties

0:16:54soft-headed yeah was that Benjamin

0:16:56Disraeli who was that I've heard

0:16:57attributed to Churchill yeah it's really

0:16:59more talking

0:17:00it's I think it's probably it's probably

0:17:02Mark Twain talking the Churchill for

0:17:04Remy um but it's one of those it's one

0:17:06of those problems of like when you're a

0:17:08young person it is it's a your

0:17:12sympathies abound and you and you want

0:17:17to live in a world where none of those

0:17:19things you know it's it's not possible

0:17:21for people to fall through the cracks

0:17:23like that you feel it very invested in

0:17:26the social compact why what you know

0:17:30they're there

0:17:30why is this man left to what you know

0:17:34why can't he be helped and then as you

0:17:37get older and older like get the hell

0:17:39off my lawn

0:17:40Rand and you start to feel even mean

0:17:43certainly I have started to feel as

0:17:46someone who has a young person actually

0:17:48slept on park benches quite a bit

0:17:50increasingly as time goes on I feel like

0:17:53some of these problems are intractable

0:17:54mental health problems social the the

0:17:58social compact is not airtight and a lot

0:18:04of these problems you know do not have

0:18:07simple solutions i mean my mom spent

0:18:09years walking around town adopting

0:18:12homeless people to the to the point that

0:18:14she would bring them home with her and

0:18:16reestablish contact with their families

0:18:19and and you know go through these

0:18:22elaborate processes get them on their

0:18:25medication find them work all these

0:18:27things and then six months and the

0:18:30transformation was incredible and you

0:18:32have these you have these moments with

0:18:34her we're just like you are

0:18:35irri absolute angel and look what's

0:18:38happened that this guy used to be a

0:18:41sitting in front of the supermarket like

0:18:43with drool down his face and now he's

0:18:45like wearing a tie he's going to work

0:18:48he's lucid and ended up and and turns

0:18:50out an amazing guy and then nine months

0:18:53later he decided on his own volition to

0:18:58stop taking his medication and and then

0:19:02he lose his job and then a few months

0:19:04later he's living under the freeway

0:19:06again and you get that other sense of

0:19:09frustration of like wow that was a that

0:19:11was a year it was not just a year's work

0:19:14sort of up to end up right back where we

0:19:17started but also the emotional journey

0:19:20of like yeah

0:19:22wow I don't anybody know my mom would

0:19:24come out of those experiences feeling

0:19:25like I don't anymore feel like I can i I

0:19:29don't know how to help

0:19:30it's not that I don't feel like I can

0:19:32help but like giving the guy five

0:19:34dollars for a bottle of wine is one form

0:19:36of it trying to get him in touch with

0:19:38his family back in Ohio is another form

0:19:40of it and and ultimately the thing that

0:19:43most people do which is sorry man

0:19:45or worse is another form of it and and I

0:19:50don't know the solution isn't easy and

0:19:53in particular with my neighbors you know

0:19:56my neighborhood is what we would have in

0:20:00the past referred to as a respectable

0:20:02lower mid

0:20:03class neighborhood everybody there is

0:20:06itself there's a working-class diverse

0:20:08working-class neighborhood the first

0:20:09working-class neighborhood where where

0:20:11people are you know they don't have a

0:20:13disposable income to really care for

0:20:16their yards or houses in a in a in a way

0:20:20that he would drive through and say like

0:20:23wow these this neighborhoods got curb

0:20:25appeal but people are minding their own

0:20:28business and they're making their

0:20:29payments and they are you know they are

0:20:31solid and fair number of people who own

0:20:34their house

0:20:35I think everybody in the neighborhood

0:20:37does with the you know with the with the

0:20:40exception of those houses where there

0:20:42are a lot of people living sexy so

0:20:44unusual today

0:20:45well and that's one of the differences

0:20:47of a of of Seattle and Portland compared

0:20:51to a lot of American cities which is

0:20:54that there aren't really there are there

0:20:57aren't really ghettos here and there

0:20:59single-family homes and there are

0:21:01neighborhoods that are rich in

0:21:02neighborhoods that are poor and there

0:21:03are some housing projects but even those

0:21:06housing projects are built to look and

0:21:09emulate a single-family home

0:21:12neighborhoods winding streets and

0:21:14basketball hoops at that at the

0:21:16cul-de-sac and San Francisco the only

0:21:18way you can tell sometimes is very large

0:21:20signs and very bright lights

0:21:22that's right the the arc lights used to

0:21:25be the way you could tell now in seattle

0:21:27has done away with that like a

0:21:29concentration camp lighting and even the

0:21:33even the poorest neighborhoods in the

0:21:34city kind of just have have have a

0:21:36neighborhood five but but you know the

0:21:39conflict between me and Gary for

0:21:41instance or you know or my interest in

0:21:44the house across the street is also tied

0:21:47up in a lot of class issues where I

0:21:50totally super concerned about being the

0:21:54you know about being someone who's moved

0:21:56into the neighborhood of things I've

0:21:57lived in that house longer than they've

0:22:00lived in that house right i mean it's

0:22:01not like I moved into their neighborhood

0:22:04but but the question of like a ok

0:22:08like here there's gotta be something

0:22:12there's got to be some level of decorum

0:22:13here that doesn't include for instance

0:22:17that party where people were just

0:22:19ransacking the house but at the same

0:22:23time it's like I don't know maybe I've

0:22:25been to a lot of parties where would

0:22:26have looked to an outsider like like we

0:22:29were just stripping the house and it

0:22:32wasn't that at all and you know and and

0:22:36I I no longer have the another thing you

0:22:39another mistake you can make in in youth

0:22:42is thinking that because you slept on

0:22:44some park benches for for a few nights

0:22:46that you have real insight into what it

0:22:50is to be poor and um and I no longer

0:22:54make that mistake of of assuming that

0:22:57like I map you know that with it i'm

0:22:59inside their heads and that we all share

0:23:01like a common life experience right but

0:23:06I'm you know I mean what I'm a homeowner

0:23:08and and and i also feel a little bit of

0:23:11that hit that creeping republicanism of

0:23:15like I'm a homeowner I mean just to say

0:23:17those words in respect to what your

0:23:20neighbors are doing across the street

0:23:21bike as a homeowner I feel like we need

0:23:25to we need to start up having like a

0:23:29homeowner meanings where we we go around

0:23:32go around the room and say like okay

0:23:34who's got a guy living in a van in his

0:23:36front yard anybody right how many people

0:23:39let's see a show of hands but you know

0:23:41there is that the phrase that went

0:23:42around a lot and then one of the many

0:23:44many malcolm gladwell isms that has been

0:23:47kind of or partly or mostly disproven

0:23:50broken windows syndrome

0:23:51yeah you know well i mean the thing is i

0:23:53understand that the part that was

0:23:54disproven about broken windows syndrome

0:23:56was not the part that if there's a few

0:24:00broken windows you get more broken

0:24:02windows the part that seems a little

0:24:03disproven is that fixing those windows

0:24:06does make a substantial difference right

0:24:10but I i mean i'll just say this is

0:24:12totally anecdotal but i think the first

0:24:14part is still very true

0:24:15yeah just like what you put up with

0:24:16becomes ok

0:24:17and then once that's ok then more stuff

0:24:21that's not so great because ok as well

0:24:22yes it is new and look no further than

0:24:24the place where you walk in and put your

0:24:26mail down you come in you put your mail

0:24:27down that used to be a working surface

0:24:29and now it's covered with male like that

0:24:31takes a week and i think it's i think

0:24:33it's true i mean like you know do you

0:24:35want to be in the neighborhood where

0:24:36it's ok for somebody just have a van in

0:24:38the yard and somebody's a little

0:24:39unstable living in it for a year

0:24:41yeah yeah my dad called that that table

0:24:44the magic table because if you put

0:24:45something down on the top of it within a

0:24:49couple of weeks it would be at the

0:24:51bottom of the pile and that seemed to

0:24:52magic to him and then his solution was

0:24:56at a certain point when it because when

0:24:57it was teetering the pile was teetering

0:24:59he would sweep it all into a cardboard

0:25:01box put the cardboard box at the bottom

0:25:03of a closet and then wait and if that's

0:25:07the way you got it yeah then wait 30

0:25:09years and died haha that's hot i still

0:25:12do that idea that with our microwave we

0:25:14open the door the microwave and a

0:25:16leather man and a bill fall off and it's

0:25:18like that's it and I guess I sweep

0:25:19everything into a box and put it in the

0:25:21closet

0:25:22this is my legacy that the stuff with

0:25:24internet this is not good for our Happy

0:25:27New Year episode but you know the stuff

0:25:29about dealing with folks who have like

0:25:30serious you know mental and chemical

0:25:33stuff you know you hear these stories

0:25:34about we need to talk about the family

0:25:36and getting in touch with the family and

0:25:38there are a lot of families who quietly

0:25:40have somebody in their family who is

0:25:42kind of in and out of the system on and

0:25:45off of the streets for decades

0:25:47I mean you don't you don't have to poke

0:25:49around very far to find somebody who has

0:25:51a brother or maybe has a mother for that

0:25:53matter who is just kind of there are

0:25:57definitely part of the family tree but

0:25:59there's no amount of quote-unquote

0:26:03helping them that anybody can can do

0:26:07that will actually fix the problem and

0:26:09they're just in and out of the system

0:26:10all the time and those people are happy

0:26:12people but they there's a certain kind

0:26:14of resolution

0:26:15it's like when the wire I know when

0:26:17bubbles goes to his sister's house is

0:26:18like I cleaned up like here's a key and

0:26:20go in the basement I don't ever want to

0:26:21see you like that's right you fuck me

0:26:24enough times exactly i'm never going to

0:26:26believe you get eventually eventually

0:26:27the time comes off and your back under

0:26:29the bridge it's like it

0:26:31just it's so much more complicated than

0:26:32anybody if you're not around it all the

0:26:35time

0:26:36IES certainly i'm not an expert on it

0:26:39but I do know that something like

0:26:41homelessness is way more it is at some

0:26:44level very much an economic issue but

0:26:46there's a lot more to it than that it

0:26:48might be economics but you know you've

0:26:50been to the haight there's no there's a

0:26:52lot of people living on the street in

0:26:54the hate or like the Panhandle along

0:26:56pretty sure we'll probably be in college

0:26:58in the next five years they've been

0:27:00chosen to be like a skate rat they've

0:27:04joined the proletariat and they who

0:27:05knows they might come out of it a lot of

0:27:07people if it is purely economical they

0:27:09do not want to go to a shelter that's

0:27:10where you get stabbed

0:27:12yeah it's you know anyway i mean the the

0:27:15confusing thing about it is that a on a

0:27:17one-on-one level we've all had

0:27:19experiences where you where you say like

0:27:21oh this and it isn't just mental illness

0:27:24homelessness drug abuse but situations

0:27:27where you go

0:27:28this is an interactive well intractable

0:27:30track to political intractable Thank You

0:27:35intractable problem i've tried you know

0:27:39like my kid is a drug addict I've tried

0:27:41this have tried that I've tried I've

0:27:43tried tough love I've tried love love

0:27:45I've tried help i've tried external

0:27:48training a certain tried ignoring it

0:27:50yeah I've tried all the fins and each of

0:27:54us has had experiences and all families

0:27:57and all individual people have had

0:27:58experiences and and even just with

0:28:00people where like I've been trying to

0:28:02explain to them for five years that

0:28:06living paycheck to paycheck is is like a

0:28:11risky proposition and that they should

0:28:13put 50 bucks in the bank every time they

0:28:16get a paycheck and if they did that for

0:28:18a year then they have a little bit of

0:28:19money and they wouldn't feel so insecure

0:28:20and he try and explain that to somebody

0:28:23for 3 years 5 years and you realize like

0:28:25oh nothing i'm doing here can help this

0:28:29person does not want to know this they

0:28:32don't want to hear it and they keep

0:28:34spending every paycheck they get and

0:28:36then they keep having financial crises

0:28:38and they keep acting like it's a big

0:28:41mystery and that and that there's

0:28:43something unfair about

0:28:44you know that like why does everybody

0:28:46else get to like go on vacation it's

0:28:49like well as some people save their

0:28:51money and you don't and but the the

0:28:53problem is we understand those on

0:28:54personal on a personal level but

0:28:57whenever we start talking as a society

0:29:00in a culture about those problems taken

0:29:04to a larger scale than all of a sudden

0:29:05it becomes much harder to say some

0:29:08problems are unsolvable because we have

0:29:12such faith in ourselves and in

0:29:15technology and in our and in our thought

0:29:18technologies we have such faith

0:29:20particularly in the nineteenth and

0:29:22twentieth centuries that we can solve

0:29:25all problems and it's just a matter of

0:29:28applying the Right theory and the right

0:29:30engine and and things become politicized

0:29:33so then it its it's not just that that

0:29:38these people that there's a problem with

0:29:40drug abuse but it's a problem of with

0:29:42drug abuse and the other political party

0:29:45has the wrong attitude about it and then

0:29:48it's a battle and the implication is if

0:29:52the other if the other side of the coin

0:29:54here wasn't resisting the reforms that

0:29:58we have in mind right we would have

0:29:59solved this problem a long time ago and

0:30:02it's like well every time some a new

0:30:03Congress gets elected we apply all the

0:30:06the new reforms of that the last party

0:30:08was standing in the in the way of and

0:30:12and the problem never get solved

0:30:14it's very difficult as a society to say

0:30:18well all we can do is manage this

0:30:22problem and we're never not and not

0:30:25everyone is always and not everyone can

0:30:27be healthy and not everyone can be not

0:30:30every problem can get solved and so what

0:30:32what's the best management of it and

0:30:34Seattle just started doing a thing a

0:30:37couple of years ago where they built a

0:30:38they built the sort of a hotel for

0:30:42chronic alcoholics where they gave him

0:30:46an allotment of booze every day I've

0:30:48heard about this

0:30:49I've heard about these different

0:30:50programs of like it actually costs less

0:30:53money in the long run to set somebody up

0:30:56somewhere to put them into this

0:30:57system yeah right i mean they're they're

0:30:59just like these are the people bet that

0:31:02the three times a month are getting lift

0:31:05at you know transported to the emergency

0:31:08room in an ambulance and every one of

0:31:11those times across eight thousand

0:31:13dollars and they spend the night in the

0:31:14hospital and that cost eight thousand

0:31:16dollars and we could put him in a hotel

0:31:20and give them a a leader of alcohol a

0:31:23day and that would just cost us two

0:31:26thousand dollars a month and they would

0:31:29be happy and that company cold and

0:31:32started Hamsterdam but that's exactly

0:31:34that's right and there you know and the

0:31:36problem is like the activists classes

0:31:39don't know what to do with that

0:31:40information because on the one hand it's

0:31:42much more humane but on the other hand

0:31:44it seems again like its management

0:31:47no one is suggesting that these people

0:31:49are going to get better right

0:31:51it's just like here's your leader of

0:31:53booze and the key to your room and try

0:31:56not to like try not to bleed on the

0:31:58toilet seat in the morning and it's

0:32:01there's nothing pretty about it but but

0:32:04human beings are our I don't know this

0:32:08is that this is one of the major themes

0:32:09above my life is like yeah how far from

0:32:13animals are we really yeah i mean i-i

0:32:19just have a similar maybe slightly

0:32:21different my if there's anything that I

0:32:23feel like has been both super useful and

0:32:27extremely vexing in my journey to try to

0:32:29figure out whatever you wanna call it

0:32:31productivity creativity just problem

0:32:33solving and there's a lot of things I

0:32:35think we mentioned i mention this to a

0:32:37few weeks going in an episode but you

0:32:40know it's I feel like any solution

0:32:43that's uncomplicated is probably not

0:32:45true and probably not real it's like if

0:32:47you haven't found something complicated

0:32:48yet you are near the truth if you if it

0:32:51seems if it seems simple you're not done

0:32:53looking you have already on happily ever

0:32:55after and so you're or you are or you

0:32:58are meticulously avoiding looking at the

0:33:00things you don't want to look at a

0:33:02hundred percent and that's why I mean

0:33:04now this might be a little bit too neat

0:33:06i might be guilty of my own thing here

0:33:08but you know it'sit's you have to

0:33:10understand

0:33:11and that everything in life is an

0:33:12engineering problem there's probably at

0:33:14least three different vectors to

0:33:15everything and anytime you try to solve

0:33:18one problem one way the one of the first

0:33:21questions to ask yourself especially if

0:33:23you're a lawmaker oars or you know a

0:33:25public person is how much am i doing

0:33:28about this just change the way that it

0:33:30looks

0:33:31yeah because if you want to just change

0:33:32the way something looks there's a

0:33:34thousand different angles you can take

0:33:35you can cook the books you can put

0:33:37people in and moving over to Hamsterdam

0:33:39likes all kinds of ways that you can

0:33:41change the appearance of something it's

0:33:42just that once you try to actually

0:33:44change anything you realize you're

0:33:45actually changing or another way to put

0:33:48it rather than changing is your uh

0:33:49pending you are chaotic sizing probably

0:33:53five or six different things unintended

0:33:55consequences and like these

0:33:56what is it you really want to change so

0:33:58the phrase i always use in this

0:33:59productivity stuff is ask yourself if

0:34:01you're solving the right problem at the

0:34:03right level for the right reasons as if

0:34:05you don't like those up all you're gonna

0:34:06do is it's all optics it's all just

0:34:08changing how it looks and so the thing

0:34:10is if you're mostly sad because you see

0:34:12homeless people on the street your

0:34:14solution one solution might be to give

0:34:15him five dollars for wine another

0:34:17solution might be to put them all into

0:34:18some kind of a camp you know but like

0:34:21are you really trying to solve and you

0:34:23can't ever solve the total problem of

0:34:26class status and economics in America so

0:34:28at what level will you try to solve that

0:34:30yeah and then you have to if you scope

0:34:32that correctly you can have successes

0:34:34but they won't be permanent successes

0:34:35they won't be easy successes and they

0:34:37won't be complete successes and that's

0:34:39what everybody thinks they want they

0:34:40think if we can't do this completely

0:34:42perfectly it's not worth doing and so

0:34:45anyway that's a little bit better and

0:34:46that is computed that that that's what

0:34:48that is absolutely another another angle

0:34:52to it which is that no one wants no one

0:34:55no one is satisfied with that with a

0:34:58half victory right because because so

0:35:02much of the so much of these questions

0:35:04is what energizes the whole political

0:35:08machine in America like if if if a

0:35:12problem if we call a problem solved

0:35:15uh then the the fundraising engine dries

0:35:19up and the and the the outrage engine

0:35:23drives up

0:35:24and so so they're the these these ideas

0:35:29these big ideas and people's lives

0:35:31really ultimately our are pitted against

0:35:34one another in order to keep this big

0:35:38machine of the of the chattering classes

0:35:42and the legislative classes it employed

0:35:45and it what amazes me about the Congress

0:35:48is that they find a way to every year up

0:35:54make a bunch of new laws and hits like

0:35:57there are a lot of laws already

0:35:59the question is so infrequently that we

0:36:02need a new law and that standard

0:36:06applying the standard of like it making

0:36:10a new law should be a last resort and so

0:36:15there's a lot of work that the Congress

0:36:17can do the the big glamorous work that

0:36:20they do is make a new law right and we

0:36:24just keep making new laws and our the

0:36:27old laws are like all these skin flakes

0:36:30carpeting the bed where the Congress

0:36:32lays where they don't they don't work

0:36:35anymore we don't look at the fact that

0:36:36it's that this this legacy of crafty

0:36:38laws go whether remember there were

0:36:40people 100 or 50 or 25 years ago had the

0:36:43same right idea let's go make a law

0:36:44that's right exactly and and and we

0:36:47don't as a we're not very reflective as

0:36:49a people we don't look back at our at

0:36:51our legacy at our recent history even

0:36:54and say were these attempts like let me

0:36:58use the power of metaphor for these

0:37:01attempts that we made 25 years ago 50

0:37:04years ago were they successful and in

0:37:06what ways were they successful but also

0:37:07in what ways where they were they

0:37:10failures utter failures and why would we

0:37:12go down that road again a hundred times

0:37:15a thousand times and it's that we are

0:37:19boy we are imperfect and and unlikable

0:37:23little fucking pig bugs

0:37:27god dammit season games i'm looking out

0:37:30the window right now at the at the

0:37:31freeway on-ramp but I'm just like

0:37:32goddamn you pigs and you know the other

0:37:36part of this that man it's just it's so

0:37:38beyond obvious but man that's the stuff

0:37:40we always miss is like you know what

0:37:42vast percentage of the time do we think

0:37:44laws need to be made because other

0:37:45people need to be stopped from doing

0:37:47something there's nobody there are very

0:37:49very few people out there who are saying

0:37:51that they need a lot past about them

0:37:52there are very few people who say you

0:37:54know what I'm pretty irresponsible in

0:37:56this one area so I should have some kind

0:37:58of threat of criminal or civil law

0:38:01introduced so that I'll become a better

0:38:02person I'd always gets me

0:38:05yeah but we're always were always

0:38:08looking for all these other people who

0:38:09have caused our problems and then we

0:38:11want to live past about them and then

0:38:13there's this entire inefficient arm

0:38:15inefficient arms inefficient limbs of

0:38:17government are expected to sweep out and

0:38:19do that in a way that's going to be fair

0:38:22yeah fucking people oh my god there they

0:38:26are they're all out there they're

0:38:27wandering around over there stopping at

0:38:30stop lights when the light turns green

0:38:33and they go they take the whole width of

0:38:35the walkway just so and you know in a

0:38:40pole at the at the level of being a

0:38:44parent and watching watching a child

0:38:48kind of navigate the the very first sort

0:38:51of human first real human interaction

0:38:54when they're little babies right there

0:38:56just sort of like how there they are

0:38:57look at him go like throw some food in

0:38:59their crate and put a blanket over it

0:39:01and and then we'll see him in the

0:39:04morning but you know when when uh when

0:39:08my daughter has she started now to have

0:39:10interactions at school that I recognized

0:39:12as human interactions and ones that like

0:39:17oh this is her first encounter with this

0:39:19and assigned a certain kind of

0:39:22interaction that she'll have thousands

0:39:24of times that are literally thousands of

0:39:26times and this is essentially it's the

0:39:27first one and she looks mean she goes

0:39:29what's going on here and I think I wish

0:39:32I could tell you because everybody i

0:39:35know myself included once to kneel down

0:39:38and say listen here's what's going on

0:39:39and here's how you deal with it

0:39:41but the reality is i am still in this

0:39:44situation that you're in and I still

0:39:46don't know how to deal with it

0:39:48alright yeah and there's no there's no

0:39:50easy way for me to say this and there's

0:39:53certainly no way for me to say this that

0:39:55it will not be just a dumb cliché but

0:39:59like there's just so much stuff in life

0:40:01that is simply not fair

0:40:03yeah probably every little kid has an

0:40:05innate sense of justice

0:40:07that's what that's what they call the

0:40:08goat nature's president haha every child

0:40:14every child every child has an innate

0:40:17sense that of fairness that mostly leans

0:40:21toward them so it's one of the most

0:40:22powerful instincts that they have is

0:40:25itself a reservation instinct and it's a

0:40:27fairness to them instinct

0:40:29there's there's there's not there's they

0:40:31haven't evolved enough and very few of

0:40:33us have evolved enough to go well let's

0:40:34make sure everybody got something here

0:40:36it was definitely a sense of like that

0:40:37person that they got a balloon they got

0:40:39a balloon they got a balloon

0:40:41I better have a balloon coming yeah you

0:40:43know what we got ice cream like I should

0:40:45get ice cream or just that the yeah i

0:40:47mean one of the things that were

0:40:48experiencing is like well other kids

0:40:51throw tantrums in front of their parents

0:40:53and say no and and push their hand in

0:40:56their parents face and why shouldn't I

0:41:00don't have cancer

0:41:02a hundred percent and I've I've I've got

0:41:04a drumbeat that is such fucking weak

0:41:07sauce but it's the only thing I can

0:41:09always say which is you know like for

0:41:12example we're still standing at the

0:41:13crosswalk and as happens people start

0:41:16walking before the signal has changed me

0:41:19and she starts walking I say no we we

0:41:21walk when it's safe for us to walk do

0:41:24not rely on what other people do or

0:41:26don't do to help you decide what's right

0:41:27and safe so you know we're going to do

0:41:30this in our own way because that's

0:41:31that's who we are

0:41:32there are people that we are is that we

0:41:34do the right thing we don't do this

0:41:36thing because there's a lot we don't do

0:41:37this thing because we know that

0:41:39certainly could be part of it but we do

0:41:40this because this is who we are and I

0:41:43don't and I feel like such a such an

0:41:45idiot like such a such a 00 limp-wristed

0:41:47liberal when I say that but I i hope

0:41:50that that becomes true in the same way

0:41:52that I hope it's true when I say it to

0:41:54my face

0:41:54self to get my I say to myself for that

0:41:57too

0:41:57we could cross you can't cross 50 times

0:41:59and we would go against the light and we

0:42:01probably be fine but that's not who we

0:42:02are going to be it's the core of

0:42:04civilization it i mean that internal

0:42:07governing is the basis of the idea that

0:42:10we should we should all be philosopher

0:42:12Kings that we should live in no I mean

0:42:14the whole premise plus writings fake it

0:42:17till you make it with the whole premise

0:42:19of a civil society is that we each are

0:42:21internally governed and so don't need I

0:42:25don't need restrictive laws i mean both

0:42:28there are versions of that on both sides

0:42:30of the political spectrum which which

0:42:33presumes the best about people and it

0:42:37used to be that there was a lot more

0:42:39energy devoted to that idea in our

0:42:41culture where we where we said to

0:42:45ourselves and to one another like this

0:42:47is not what we do it's not we're not

0:42:49we're not not committing a crime because

0:42:51we're afraid of getting caught or

0:42:53because there's a video camera watching

0:42:55us we're not committing a crime because

0:42:57we do we do not commit crimes right and

0:43:00this is the problem with the the whole

0:43:01of the the whole torture thing the whole

0:43:04bush-cheney doctrine in American

0:43:07politics is that we squandered we

0:43:11squandered that it on a global political

0:43:15level the title of our good deeds and a

0:43:21measure of moral authority just was just

0:43:2450 years that just went out the 60 just

0:43:26mount the window just smoked it

0:43:28everytime everytime we we built a well

0:43:30or rebuild something we blew up like

0:43:33that all went away when people saw how

0:43:34foolish it we were yeah and and that is

0:43:37that's true on a micro level 2 and all

0:43:39around us every day you know this is why

0:43:43this is why we're always harping on this

0:43:45stuff of like the little the little shit

0:43:47like don't take your shoes off on a

0:43:48airplane don't wear your fedora into a

0:43:53restaurant don't stand there with your

0:43:56earphones in and it you know and and

0:44:00piss on my shoes or whatever and it's

0:44:01not because

0:44:03there but it's not because it's illegal

0:44:06right i mean all the people that are

0:44:08like why shouldn't i wear my pajamas on

0:44:10an airplane it's like I mean it's not

0:44:13illegal is true and like that and that's

0:44:17basically like they're starting point

0:44:19like it's not illegal it's a free

0:44:21country and it's like right but like if

0:44:23you don't maintain standards and i would

0:44:25suggest high standards personally then

0:44:29you can key then you're living in a

0:44:31world where if it's not illegal it's

0:44:32going to get done and how would you like

0:44:34it if your neighbors felt that way to

0:44:36you know how would you like it if the

0:44:37people that you're encountering were

0:44:39also just making decisions based on what

0:44:41was legal or not I mean it's your living

0:44:44in your living in chaos and we are

0:44:46descending culturally we really are

0:44:49there there is there is an a we have

0:44:52lost a lot and we've gained a lot up in

0:44:56the last lesson we're losing a lot of I

0:44:59feel this personally as I have to go and

0:45:03be around other people less as a matter

0:45:05of course I noticed in myself as I have

0:45:07to remember to try and do the right

0:45:08thing but you know what level do you

0:45:11want to do you want to attack it out but

0:45:13I think I feel like as a culture just

0:45:15observing people are either becoming

0:45:18less mindful about how to act and how

0:45:23did how to be jostled by other people

0:45:24and be okay how to like just deal with

0:45:27even that whether it's like getting on

0:45:29and off at the train knowing how to wait

0:45:31in line at the store like everybody's so

0:45:34fucking mad all the time

0:45:36yeah and I'm so this is the self

0:45:38contradictory because we are the authors

0:45:40of keep moving and get out of the way to

0:45:41keep moving it out of the way is at the

0:45:43heart of it like that's the most basic

0:45:44like what what greater kindness in the

0:45:46world could there be

0:45:48that's absolutely right that then to get

0:45:50keep moving and get out of the way we

0:45:52really know 100 off don't make huff and

0:45:54puff noises in line don't do that

0:45:56slower traffic moves right not because

0:45:59there's a sign but because not customer

0:46:01mean not because we're mean but because

0:46:03what that what that suggests what that

0:46:05implies is that you are looking in your

0:46:07mirrors conscious that there are other

0:46:09people on the road

0:46:10and you are trying to get out of the way

0:46:12of somebody who's got a different who's

0:46:15got a different tempo and that is

0:46:16courtesy right that's I mean this is the

0:46:19thing about tipping your hat right of

0:46:21what when we talked about that several

0:46:24episodes ago i was reminded about the

0:46:28power of tipping your hat that I had

0:46:30kind of it in the in the the daily grind

0:46:34of the city had had neglected to tip my

0:46:38hat all the time right I had I had

0:46:41resorted to tipping my hat just when I

0:46:43was opening opening the door for

0:46:45somebody in a hotel but for the most

0:46:47part walking around with my hat on my

0:46:49head

0:46:50passing people in the street even

0:46:52looking at them in nodding I was leaving

0:46:54aside that little gesture the fingers to

0:46:58the brim of the Hat and a little like

0:47:00right tada

0:47:01and so we talked about it on the show

0:47:03and I went out into the world and

0:47:05started tipping my hat to people and

0:47:07it's amazing how much better it makes me

0:47:10feel and I say it's nice for everybody

0:47:12and you get the smiles from people you

0:47:15get like the the ipass the guy was like

0:47:18two o'clock in the morning i'm walking

0:47:19on a on a deserted Street and it's one

0:47:22of those streets that's like you're

0:47:23walking along you're in the neighborhood

0:47:24and then all of a sudden there's trees

0:47:26all around and then all of a sudden the

0:47:28trees have kind of grown over the street

0:47:29and you are and you can't see any lights

0:47:33and you're like where the hell what

0:47:35neighborhood my end I would thought I

0:47:36was in the city and now I'm like I'm in

0:47:38a like a scary book and here comes a guy

0:47:42down the sidewalk with his hoodie all

0:47:45the way over shrouding his eyes and he

0:47:49and I are going to meet we're gonna

0:47:52cross paths at the most brambly spooky

0:47:57little part of this spooky little a 200

0:48:01yards and he's got his hands jammed into

0:48:04his pockets and you can see from his

0:48:06body language that like she is these

0:48:10toughening up for this encounter he's

0:48:12taller than I am and he's a black guy

0:48:15and he's like I can see him getting

0:48:19ready for this

0:48:21like

0:48:23pass that we're gonna have to make and i

0:48:25feel myself getting ready like how's

0:48:27this gonna go what are we going to do as

0:48:29we pass in this shadowy little spot and

0:48:34as we get closer so that was somewhere

0:48:37within i contacted each other he makes

0:48:39the choice to look at me and he could

0:48:42have made the choice to not look at me

0:48:44and that would have set a certain tone

0:48:47but he makes the choice to experiment

0:48:50you know he just sends his eye beams out

0:48:52from under from under his hood like

0:48:55looks at me and I tip my hat to him and

0:48:59we both like he stands up a little

0:49:04straighter big smile across his face I

0:49:07stand up a little straighter big smile

0:49:09across my face and he goes hello and i

0:49:11say good evening and we're mirror and

0:49:13I'm for like Adam renfaire you know all

0:49:16of a sudden you're both the monopoly man

0:49:17yeah well they were both balls are like

0:49:19hello good evening good sir

0:49:21and I'm like and and he you know he goes

0:49:25on with his day I go on with my day and

0:49:27both of us had what could have been

0:49:29there there were two or twenty different

0:49:31levels that that could have gone and 18

0:49:34of them were that we just pass in the

0:49:37night and have and carry away from that

0:49:40encounter some it would have reinforced

0:49:44some pre belief about how things are

0:49:47right now you both prepped

0:49:49yeah we want the rapacity rather side oh

0:49:51okay that guy right i mean good thing

0:49:54did you know like I'm thinking a good

0:49:56thing in the UH mug me and he's thinking

0:49:58like a good thing you didn't call the

0:49:59cops and make shot me and all those

0:50:03narratives pre-existing sort of bullshit

0:50:06narratives we could have reinforced in

0:50:08that moment and instead we both work

0:50:10clowns like goofy dorks which is what we

0:50:14all want to be right

0:50:15hello and there's the thing is nobody is

0:50:18watching right so we can be a little

0:50:20dorky there wasn't a third party across

0:50:22the street smoke a cigarette who was

0:50:24gonna shout out like how you guys are

0:50:26dorks right and so we got it we got a

0:50:29moment and it's all in that like I mean

0:50:31I honestly him look

0:50:33at me was was brave and then that little

0:50:37tip of the cap was waiting it was a

0:50:39gesture i had in my arsenal of

0:50:42civilization which is like I receive

0:50:45your eye that you're you know you're

0:50:47brave gesture of looking and I and I i

0:50:53honored sir with a little bit of

0:50:56steampunk airship and he thought to

0:51:01himself John Roderick seems so much

0:51:03nicer than I would have expected haha

0:51:05he's like women if it isn't that the guy

0:51:09on the music council this episode of

0:51:14rock on the line is sponsored by

0:51:15Squarespace the only one platform that

0:51:18makes it fast and easy to create your

0:51:19own professional website portfolio and

0:51:22online store

0:51:23Squarespace makes everything so simple

0:51:25and easy with their beautiful design

0:51:27templates and easy drag-and-drop content

0:51:29spend less time fussing with all the

0:51:31computer maths and more time putting

0:51:33your great stuff in front of your

0:51:35audience ever stuck

0:51:36don't panic Squarespace offers 24 x

0:51:38seven support to live chat and email by

0:51:41their crackerjack teams in New York City

0:51:43dublin and Portland Squarespace plans

0:51:46start at only eight dollars a month and

0:51:48that includes a free domain name when

0:51:49you sign up for a year you can start

0:51:51your free trial today with no credit

0:51:52card required and begin building your

0:51:54own website today when you decide to

0:51:57sign up for Squarespace please make sure

0:51:58you tell them you heard about it from

0:52:00Roderick on the line by using that

0:52:01special offer code supertrain at

0:52:03checkout get you ten percent off your

0:52:05first purchase and it shows your support

0:52:07for Roderick on the line we thank

0:52:09Squarespace very much for their amazing

0:52:11product and for supporting Roderick on

0:52:12the line

0:52:13Squarespace better websites for all

0:52:15counselor counselor not so good to see

0:52:18it I see it but the thing about being in

0:52:21school that I with little kids that I

0:52:24realizes is it's it's a it's a it

0:52:27reinforces the other thing which is that

0:52:29we cannot perfectly understand ourselves

0:52:31and the whole premise that's been in

0:52:34place ever since I was a kid in our

0:52:36culture that the banner is still flown

0:52:39by so many people that we are completely

0:52:43makeable by culture

0:52:46and that weekend that all of these

0:52:48things about our house it's like a

0:52:50recipe if you get the ingredients right

0:52:52and bake it just the right amount of

0:52:53time you become a good cultured person

0:52:55yeah.well or or in particular just like

0:52:57the differences between the genders it's

0:52:59a it's a it's another one of these kind

0:53:02of issues where it's like oh all these

0:53:04things all these character

0:53:06characteristics that people exhibit are

0:53:09in culture ated in us right male

0:53:11violence and a and infamous helplessness

0:53:16female helplessness and all these things

0:53:17that just seemed like if we could

0:53:19perfectly engineer our culture and if we

0:53:24could eradicate these ideas that we

0:53:27could eradicate these systems from our

0:53:29culture that we would be able to achieve

0:53:31again like the end goal of like perfect

0:53:34equality and then you watch little kids

0:53:37and you're like oh my god there's

0:53:38nothing engineered about it like they

0:53:40they're just there are so many of our

0:53:44human traits that are in a tin us and

0:53:48not even I mean a lot of them we

0:53:51attribute to gender and they aren't even

0:53:54there just human traits across a wide

0:53:57spectrum and impossible to to codify

0:54:01impossible to engineer either in or out

0:54:05and all you can do is just create like

0:54:08reciprocating cultures of shame and

0:54:12unhappiness and and dissatisfaction by

0:54:15truck by getting in there and monkeying

0:54:17and trying to intervene him and this is

0:54:19the thing about like little kids hit

0:54:21each other and you can't let him do it

0:54:23you say hey we can't hit each other in

0:54:25here and they look at you like you're an

0:54:27idiot because of course you can hit each

0:54:29other like they just did it they just

0:54:31showed you how to hit somebody did you

0:54:32ever try it it works great

0:54:35that person was trying to get my doll

0:54:36and I him and now that I stopped what

0:54:38are you why are you telling me I can't

0:54:40it's the most effective strategy I've

0:54:41ever devised says 33 year old brain you

0:54:44know you're like well we can't we can't

0:54:47hit each other because we don't allow it

0:54:48because if we allowed it then we would

0:54:53be in a state of perpetual violence with

0:54:55each other because we all feel that way

0:54:57we walked down the street were just like

0:54:58I just wish I could hit all these people

0:55:00and then it's like except I don't want

0:55:02to get hit myself and I it's really like

0:55:05it does come back to a little bit of the

0:55:06fair play on some level I well it in the

0:55:10sense that only in the sense that you

0:55:13don't want to get hit yourself that the

0:55:15idea of fair play being that the smaller

0:55:20smaller kid gets it worse than the

0:55:24bigger kid if everybody's allowed to hit

0:55:26each other

0:55:27I mean that's the beginning of sort of

0:55:28fairness rather than just sort of we

0:55:32don't we don't hit each other because we

0:55:34don't like to be hit but also this other

0:55:36idea of like we can't let the big kid

0:55:38get his way over the little kid just

0:55:40because he's big and you know that's a

0:55:43very human-like I think I think animals

0:55:46don't I mean you know like orangutang

0:55:50four lions understand the concept of

0:55:52don't just bite your friend because he's

0:55:56gonna bite you like that's a pretty

0:55:58simple idea but the human idea of like

0:56:01don't we're not gonna we're all going to

0:56:04agree that it's not fair for the big kid

0:56:07to get his way more often than the

0:56:10little kid that's a thing that the

0:56:12animals don't share with us

0:56:14that's a that's the beginning of human

0:56:16that's the beginning of society and

0:56:20that's so you know so much stuff follows

0:56:23from that that we're going to school

0:56:26were going to intervene and and one of

0:56:30the things is that the little kid little

0:56:35kid do it as traditionally develop

0:56:39strategies to deal with being being

0:56:41swatted by the big kid right the little

0:56:43kid develops other skills and those

0:56:46other skills are part of the part of how

0:56:49culture is built culture is kind of

0:56:51built by little kids who developed other

0:56:54skills to avoid being swatted by big

0:56:56kids and when we intervene

0:57:00I mean this is it's just it's a it's

0:57:02like you're saying it's all an

0:57:03engineering problem

0:57:04and if you intervene to correct correct

0:57:06one thing that you you know one little

0:57:09leaky pipe you see that it's all part of

0:57:12a system and who knows who knows

0:57:16yeah I i guess so i i'm kinda I'm kind

0:57:19of glad it's it's not okay for big kids

0:57:22to hit little kids but personally but

0:57:25I'm what worries me and what I've

0:57:28worried about is the just the necessary

0:57:31hypocrisy of showing a kid

0:57:34hey look here's something i can show you

0:57:36some things we're doing this kind of

0:57:38behavior instead of that kind of

0:57:39behavior is something you'll instantly

0:57:40understand anything right we say to

0:57:42someone there's there's a natural order

0:57:43of things where if you say please and

0:57:45thank you

0:57:46you will make people happy and you will

0:57:47get away with stuff this is a good thing

0:57:49learn to say please and thank you it's

0:57:50just it's a really nice thing and in

0:57:52time you'll learn that that's a nice

0:57:53idea you could say things like it's

0:57:55better to be fair rather than not fair

0:57:57but then we also have to do these things

0:57:59that seem completely unfair

0:58:01last night I had with my daughter got up

0:58:03after she got into bed and my wife and I

0:58:05were watching TV and she came in she was

0:58:08mad because she couldn't watch TV

0:58:09so what what do I say when I say when I

0:58:11say which is like it well it's your

0:58:12bedtime now our bedtimes later we're

0:58:14watching TV like you know should I

0:58:16apologize for that no but that is

0:58:19inherently unfair to a little kid and I

0:58:21don't know but just from their point of

0:58:23view that's absolutely unfair like you

0:58:25guys get to go have fun and I have to go

0:58:26to bed you get to use your iPad whenever

0:58:28you want and I don't like that's really

0:58:30hypocritical on the face of it and it's

0:58:33but you know so I guess what I'm saying

0:58:34is I think what's complicated is we're

0:58:37asking kids on the one hand to see

0:58:38certain kinds of things as being natural

0:58:41law and like is not just a good idea to

0:58:43do it that way isn't it just a good idea

0:58:45to close the refrigerator door so we

0:58:46don't waste energy and stuff like that

0:58:47and then other times we have to say well

0:58:49except there are times when the thing

0:58:51that seems really natural is actually

0:58:53the opposite of that and you just need

0:58:55to learn that right that some of the

0:58:57right i try to you know I don't have an

0:58:59answer to that I think some of those

0:59:00things confusing some of those things we

0:59:01need you to just learn like as in just

0:59:04memorize this rule and and one day it'll

0:59:07make sense and some things it's like we

0:59:09want you to learn the concept that

0:59:11governs this as a thank you but don't

0:59:14get in a white van that i still find

0:59:16that very complicated thing

0:59:17right right well and the thing is that I

0:59:19don't you know I watching watching this

0:59:21experience with kids

0:59:23uh my instinct is to extrapolate it to

0:59:26adults because I feel like ninety-nine

0:59:27percent of adults interactions are kid

0:59:29interactions that are just extrapolated

0:59:31to like interactions plus iphones yeah

0:59:34kid interactions plus the the arrogance

0:59:37of feeling like because you've been

0:59:38alive for 25 more years your spew

0:59:41understand things any better

0:59:43and the thing is that I to believe that

0:59:48the big kids shouldn't be able to hit

0:59:50the little kid like I believe that is an

0:59:53evolution and I don't think that that I

0:59:56think that that rule is true in America

0:59:58and inns in debt

0:59:58and inns in debt

1:00:00mark and in in in germany and in you

1:00:05know like in certain places in the world

1:00:08but i don't think that that rule is

1:00:11necessarily true in Russia or the

1:00:13Ukraine or Serbia right now let alone in

1:00:16a bit places that I haven't been but

1:00:21have suspicions about right and and but

1:00:24but what I don't what I mission using

1:00:26it's unrealistic in some cultures to say

1:00:28that that's a natural law

1:00:29oh I don't think is a natural law and

1:00:31this is the point I'm making the big kid

1:00:33should not hit the little kid is not a

1:00:35natural law it is that it is a thought

1:00:38technology and the problem with us in

1:00:41America is that a hundred years ago we

1:00:43still recognize that that was the

1:00:44thought technology and we were proud of

1:00:47having invented this idea and it was

1:00:50part of you know it was part of our

1:00:52legacy of Western Europe that we had off

1:00:57you know honor and you didn't hurt the

1:00:58little guy and you you know women and

1:01:01children first off the boat like these

1:01:03were concepts that we were justifiably

1:01:07proud of because they were inventions

1:01:10there's nothing natural about that ok

1:01:13and in and if you let human beings go

1:01:18even a little bit that though that you

1:01:21see even in modern cultures that those

1:01:24rules are not that that that's like

1:01:26pretty far down the road you know the

1:01:29big man still is in charge in most of

1:01:34the world still here and we're all

1:01:37sharing the same internet but it doesn't

1:01:40change the fact that he walk into a

1:01:42village somewhere and you see that the

1:01:45big guys in charge and the little guy

1:01:47comes up to me and says hey but I any

1:01:48kind of wax him and everybody goes oh

1:01:51shit you know right thats that is that's

1:01:54the that's the that's the law the normal

1:01:57law so the fact that we have the fact

1:01:59that we've made these advances these

1:02:01cultural advances we have the idea we

1:02:04have in we've expanded the idea of

1:02:06fairness

1:02:07what is it has also happened to us in

1:02:10the last hundred years is that we've

1:02:11stopped

1:02:12recognizing that those are and not even

1:02:16the last hundred years we've stopped

1:02:18recognizing that those are thought

1:02:21technologies and started to talk about

1:02:23them as though their natural rights and

1:02:25if you if you if you start making policy

1:02:27if you start living your own life

1:02:29according to this expanded idea of

1:02:33natural rights that's what causes causes

1:02:37a tremendous amount of confusion a lot

1:02:39of figure you're gonna have a lot of

1:02:41cognitive dissonance have a lot of

1:02:42talking two incidents and a lot of a lot

1:02:44of out it's a lot of outrage because

1:02:47you're standing there saying how dare

1:02:49you

1:02:50and you're saying that because you

1:02:52believe that that somehow the the the

1:02:57intrinsic level of Justice is a lot

1:03:01higher than it is and what you're what

1:03:03you're not doing is giving credit to all

1:03:06the work that went into establishing

1:03:08that bulwark against all against all

1:03:12against a Hobbesian world and all that

1:03:16work is our legacy and I and I

1:03:18understand the culturally there's a lot

1:03:21we spent a lot of effort to kind of tear

1:03:24down the Western European colonial the

1:03:29idea that civilization came from the you

1:03:36know from the english courts or whatever

1:03:38but in in stripping away all of that and

1:03:44saying like no no we need to we need to

1:03:46incorporate all the the traditions of

1:03:48every culture we don't want to live in

1:03:51this sort of dominant mode

1:03:54we've forgotten that some of those some

1:03:58of those traditions of of chivalry and

1:04:01english law were novel only occurred in

1:04:06one place are now widely adopted but are

1:04:09ultimately a an artificial overlay that

1:04:13if we want if we believe in we need to

1:04:16we need to protect

1:04:18and that begins with understanding that

1:04:20it is it's like air conditioning that we

1:04:26invented it it it demonstrable he makes

1:04:28life better but if we don't maintain it

1:04:31then it stops working again and when the

1:04:35air conditioning goes off it doesn't do

1:04:37any good to sit in a hot room and and

1:04:39scream but that the air conditioning

1:04:42went off you have to get up and fix the

1:04:44air conditioning and that is that's true

1:04:46of that's true really of a system of

1:04:49justice to that was that was some really

1:04:53good explaining you know what you get a

1:04:55bell

1:04:56I'm good that's a little bit of

1:04:57mansplaining yeah we get what I want you

1:05:03to mansplain something to me

1:05:04sure I do not oh my god i'm gonna get so

1:05:08many angry letter

1:05:09oh god please I do not have this woman i

1:05:13do not understand

1:05:15Harry Nilsson oh oh you're gonna get a

1:05:18sad letter i'm gonna get so many sad

1:05:21letters

1:05:21well you're gonna get several set

1:05:22letters from one guy could think of I

1:05:24can think of a few guys that are going

1:05:25to send me some settlers on gone

1:05:27head-to-head on Harry Nilsson before we

1:05:28because we've gone we we've gone

1:05:30head-to-head on so many things you have

1:05:32in a civil society and you realize

1:05:34that's a conversation you guys can't

1:05:35even have that but here's the thing i'm

1:05:37not against Harry Nilsson I everything

1:05:40that he does i love obviously love his

1:05:43voice I love is don't get why he's so

1:05:45big i love his hits right but the thing

1:05:49that everybody talks about his

1:05:51songwriting his miraculous songwriting

1:05:53it seems to me that he is just sort of

1:05:57me and ring both is both of both uh like

1:06:03lyrically and melodically meandering

1:06:06down a path where he's kind of singing

1:06:08some some thoughts it with a sort of

1:06:11sing song melody and you know you get

1:06:15halfway through the song you get to the

1:06:16end of the song and it's like huh well

1:06:18yeah i'm sure i like that that was that

1:06:23was good

1:06:23over but but i do not have a i do not

1:06:27have this feeling that he is at that he

1:06:29is at the dawn

1:06:30of a certain kind of pop that didn't

1:06:35exist before I mean maybe I Asia maybe

1:06:37it's that it didn't exist before and I

1:06:39I've grown up since then and so I don't

1:06:42see the novelty that maybe was a parent

1:06:45in 1969 or something

1:06:47I think it's the all Merlin man's

1:06:49playing this to you and part of it is

1:06:50the rise of the documentary mean the the

1:06:54documentary that will almost certainly

1:06:56feature chuck klosterman thurston moore

1:06:58and flee at some point

1:07:00good girl be there good as you know

1:07:02what's up a log was quietly passed in

1:07:05the days after nine eleven that they

1:07:06have to be in every music documentary

1:07:08where you know Martin Scorsese sitting

1:07:11in a theater meaning under me like a lot

1:07:13maybe haha like what's playing

1:07:17I you know it's funny though cause like

1:07:19you know we will i started watching the

1:07:20documentary last night on nas and the

1:07:22making of illmatic which I've listened

1:07:24to about twice or three times i listen

1:07:27to mostly because of jay-z and their you

1:07:29know their feud

1:07:30it's a really really good record I can't

1:07:32like I couldn't wrap it to you the way I

1:07:34could like a public enemy record but I

1:07:36just thinking as I watched that was

1:07:37really well done beautifully made

1:07:39watch the first few minutes of it to my

1:07:40daughter woke up I just want to ask you

1:07:42did I have the option that you would

1:07:43wrap me public enemy records

1:07:45chuckles it if i invite if I had known I

1:07:48had that option I would have asked for a

1:07:49lot sooner 1989 the number or another

1:07:52summer sound of the fucking drama music

1:07:54in your heart because I know you got

1:07:55soul brothers and sisters John Wayne

1:07:58most never meant shit to mean straight

1:08:01up raises that sucker was simple

1:08:02Elvis Elvis was here at the most that's

1:08:04right well done John Wayne to else was a

1:08:07hero to most but he never meant shit to

1:08:08me straight up great stocking stuffer

1:08:10simple and plain by the fucking man John

1:08:12way and i'm hoping bucket on prime x

1:08:14plus I'm am most of my heroes don't

1:08:16appear on no stamps

1:08:17yes boy did I ever listened to that

1:08:19record a lot but you know if you don't

1:08:23understand I got no problem

1:08:24understanding what I'm saying is it's

1:08:27it's funny because think about like okay

1:08:29because the heavily lauded recent

1:08:31documentaries that were that are like

1:08:33you know good like the 20 feet from

1:08:35stardom about backup singers my muscle

1:08:38shoals nom

1:08:40there's been a lot of these like

1:08:41high-profile not netflix created

1:08:43documentaries

1:08:44then our about weed or food that where

1:08:48you watch them and the thing is even if

1:08:49you don't know anything about that

1:08:51person like what other ones the things

1:08:54things about Daniel Johnston like almost

1:08:56nobody's heard Daniel Johnston what they

1:08:58think of them as ask this character but

1:09:00you're talking about him there's

1:09:01something about like once somebody makes

1:09:03a documentary about you like in a

1:09:06well-made documentary you kind of can't

1:09:09help it disappear into that artists even

1:09:10if you've never heard them before

1:09:12wonder if that's part of it I mean

1:09:14sounds to me like you're saying you're

1:09:15saying Nelson maybe he goes somewhere up

1:09:17with an eric carmen look a good pop

1:09:19songwriter but not like well yeah but

1:09:21it's the thing I mean a long time but I

1:09:23mean I understand like the resurgence

1:09:25based on on like like people are looking

1:09:28back in time and try and we're doing

1:09:30kind of a northern soul thing except

1:09:32with our own culture everything like

1:09:35what are some of the great the great

1:09:37songwriters that we never heard of

1:09:39let's go back fine like the good ones

1:09:41but in 1970 like randy newman and but

1:09:46they just the way I say his name randy

1:09:49newman and and Brian Wilson when the

1:09:53plant is still talking very forgiving

1:09:58you baby but here's got to go dive guide

1:10:01internationally civilization that

1:10:04becoming really should but all those

1:10:09guys they all love Nelson let you know I

1:10:12think he is and I'm not slagging here

1:10:15but i think i think of him kind of like

1:10:17Nick Drake or maybe kind of like oh shit

1:10:22i just hadn't lost it

1:10:23maybe to a certain extent Jimmy Webb me

1:10:26where these characters that were very

1:10:27unusual for their time but nick drake

1:10:31what you like two records if you go to

1:10:33records with them about nick drake is

1:10:35Jake's you got it like you know I mean

1:10:37it's he had one sound and this is the

1:10:39thing about a sound right if you make

1:10:41too if you make two records and even one

1:10:43of them just has a sound all the way

1:10:45through it

1:10:46yeah it's like that's all he needed to

1:10:47do he just invented a sound and then he

1:10:49can go or not invented but he he

1:10:53perfected a sound and then he can get on

1:10:55the

1:10:56load and go across the water mhm uh the

1:10:58thing about the thing about Nelson is

1:11:00that every song is different and so it's

1:11:04not clear what the you know what the

1:11:06connection is he didn't invent a sound

1:11:09right he's got a great voice but he's a

1:11:12he and I don't know I i have to spend

1:11:15more time now where do you stand on what

1:11:17do you stand on Sage on deck you feeling

1:11:22try to get some other documentary people

1:11:25or scott walker you gotta feeling on

1:11:26Scott Walker documentary I haven't seen

1:11:30Scott Walker document hello brother you

1:11:32need to see that one guy's got a lot of

1:11:35fucking balls in the air

1:11:36Scott Walker you're saying is not

1:11:37walking from the Walker brothers and so

1:11:39basically in the Walker brothers he did

1:11:41those righteous brothers style songs

1:11:43covers and then like the last Walker

1:11:46brothers record was pretty fucking weird

1:11:48then he went solo and each subsequent

1:11:50record of his has been more like totally

1:11:52bananas in the documentary you can see

1:11:55him recording he recorded about every 10

1:11:57years now and so that the percussion

1:11:59involves like getting a side of beef and

1:12:00stuff and it's harrowing and and

1:12:03delightful you know you know you know

1:12:05the singer the unique you've heard of

1:12:07you know it's yellow area for sure

1:12:09uh ah I feel like I need to I need to

1:12:15watch some more music documentaries one

1:12:16thing we're gonna do this music month

1:12:18you know what we should we should just

1:12:21make this music month we should talk

1:12:22about you like a whole time

1:12:24yeah I i do I feel like I feel like as i

1:12:28am thinking about starting to rejoin the

1:12:33songwriting game and wondering like what

1:12:37my place in it is and what I what I have

1:12:41to contribute to the songwriting a pile

1:12:46get your dienophile you know watching

1:12:50these guys uh and and and gals who do it

1:12:54successfully and find their own way

1:12:58through you know like I mean I I don't

1:13:02understand Joni Mitchell either but i

1:13:05definitely understand

1:13:08that without Joni Mitchell there would

1:13:09be no Sheryl Crow and without show crow

1:13:15where would we be

1:13:18so in that sense thanks i was we keep

1:13:21unknown he's saying a base you coming to

1:13:26college to a more gets up every morning

1:13:31and writes a song that's what he does

1:13:33Randy Newman gets up every morning as a

1:13:35cup of coffee as a bagel when he goes

1:13:38down to the studio and he writes songs

1:13:39until it until it's quittin time went to

1:13:42bid leave now feeling kind of fell to

1:13:45get a good movement bells

1:13:47when you gonna up that he means the

1:13:51sheepdog at the punch-out machine

1:13:54hey Frank during a Randy area

1:14:00ok that's good but Scott Walker 30

1:14:05century man