Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 116: "Smilin' Alligator"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this episode of rock on the line is

0:00:01sponsored by Squarespace the all-in-one

0:00:04platform that makes it fast and easy to

0:00:06create your own professional website

0:00:08portfolio or online store for your free

0:00:11trial plus ten percent off anything you

0:00:13by visit squarespace.com and use the

0:00:16offer code supertrain at checkout a

0:00:18better web starts with your website

0:00:23hello

0:00:26I John I'm Merlin has gone pretty good

0:00:30how are you going

0:00:31we should break the fourth wall we

0:00:34should at least you know Pierce the

0:00:35fourth wall how we gonna do that

0:00:37well I don't know bye-bye being a

0:00:39forward-thinking let's be

0:00:41forward-thinking appears the fourth wall

0:00:43well I you know me I don't talk about

0:00:46the show on the show right now I know

0:00:48other people don't like us to talk about

0:00:49the show on the show but but we're

0:00:51recording episodes because early and

0:00:55second them as you say because because

0:00:57we're both going to be away parts of the

0:00:59summer of this year 1978 and and so I we

0:01:03hope that everything we see on here will

0:01:04still make sense that uh uh as we've

0:01:07done this before where you and I have

0:01:10recorded multiple episodes in one

0:01:13sitting and my dive founded generally to

0:01:18be a success

0:01:19no I agree they're nice and loose and

0:01:20warm right all warmed up

0:01:22ah but I've already blown through all my

0:01:25grateful dead material i prepared

0:01:26problem

0:01:27yeah well I'm the thing I you know I

0:01:28feel like the 800-pound gorilla in the

0:01:30room is really a 450 pound gorilla

0:01:35wearing a gorilla suit

0:01:38I'm listening but you know part of the

0:01:42problem with doing episodes because I

0:01:44you as you have said many times you like

0:01:46to feel like our show is timeless

0:01:48evergreen yeah and you can listen to the

0:01:50show at any time any episode will work

0:01:54but the real world doesn't rude

0:01:58sometimes right and we are recording

0:02:00this show immediately after the

0:02:04electromagnetic magnetic pulse

0:02:07yes destroyed all of civilization and a

0:02:11lot of our listeners are going to be

0:02:12wondering you know did this happen in an

0:02:15alternate universe

0:02:17I'm how did how did they do it it's a

0:02:19lot to explain but also there's a lot of

0:02:23Macintosh talk and all my ears this much

0:02:26mcintosh stock and you and I have very

0:02:28studiously avoiding talking about all

0:02:31that's a shame that we should talk about

0:02:32the Macintosh talk because it's you know

0:02:34because we want our show to be evergreen

0:02:36we don't want to be top

0:02:37all who are the same guys each weapon

0:02:40ghazi open ghazi is all it's on

0:02:42everybody's lips Bergdahl oil a popular

0:02:49brand of motor oil

0:02:51it's that the hostage guy i mean i think

0:02:55we're giving away when this show is

0:02:57being recorded enjoy the Hillary Clinton

0:02:59book uh still reading it still raining

0:03:03pretty dense I'm trying to get into Game

0:03:05of Thrones are all my gosh

0:03:07because I met george RR martin do you

0:03:10know I kind of want to hear about that

0:03:12yeah yeah it's a I mean you know

0:03:15studious rock on the line scholars will

0:03:17know almost exactly when we're recording

0:03:20this now based on this topical

0:03:21information we've given thanks mama

0:03:24partly feels like that is destroying the

0:03:26illusion that we are that we are posting

0:03:29these from the future but but yeah so I

0:03:33so I so I i spent the day basically with

0:03:36george RR martin would you would you

0:03:38forgive me a a slight law here at this

0:03:41point turn

0:03:42ok you are a man who exists out of time

0:03:44correct your man who is not a fan in

0:03:47italics correct right but that isn't it

0:03:50fair to say that that in your studies

0:03:52dark web and otherwise in the past

0:03:54you've read a lot of books

0:03:55yes that's true but you know I mean

0:03:57you've read like you've read some

0:03:58science fiction stuff right

0:03:59I have you talked about it i do not

0:04:02generally I mean and part partly it is

0:04:05you know like I went through a phase

0:04:08many years ago when I read everything

0:04:10that Harlan Ellison wrote wow and i

0:04:14really enjoyed it

0:04:15although his politics were inexcusable

0:04:17like it seems to be kind of things like

0:04:21firefighters right i mean like is just

0:04:24like the Ender's Game move his idea of

0:04:27like what with the proper gender roles

0:04:30were even 25 years ago when i read all

0:04:33those books it was it's just

0:04:36unconscionable you can't you can't

0:04:38endorse it but at the same time great

0:04:41stories great imagination

0:04:43I think it is I think it's ultimately

0:04:45like you know I i talked about this in

0:04:49my i'm not a fan article for the LA

0:04:52weekly which produced what I can only

0:04:54imagine was a very entertaining comments

0:04:57section that I absolutely did not visit

0:04:59or we learned your lesson

0:05:02I expressed I expressed to myself no

0:05:04curiosity about it like oh I'm sure

0:05:07there are people yelling at me on

0:05:09they're not going to give them even the

0:05:11pleasure of thinking about that i would

0:05:12go read it but uh but you know the the

0:05:18complicated thing about reading the

0:05:21product of someone else's imagination

0:05:24for me is always that I absolutely enjoy

0:05:29the experience but but i am always

0:05:33conscious of of occupying like some

0:05:37rented real estate in someone else's

0:05:40imagination for a short period of time

0:05:42it's not a place I i want to buy or

0:05:45build a house it's not a place that I

0:05:47want to I don't want to put my

0:05:51imagination there or I like there are

0:05:56things that I experienced in in in

0:05:59entering someone else's imaginative

0:06:01world that I wanted you know that I

0:06:02absolutely want to borrow or take with

0:06:04me and like put into a cigar box if you

0:06:10will in my imagination right i wanted i

0:06:14want to walk over I want to walk out of

0:06:16harlan ellison's world would be like oh

0:06:17it never occurred to me that for

0:06:20instance incest bias was a cultural

0:06:27thing right i read i read Harlan Ellison

0:06:29story one time where the plot was oh why

0:06:32do we have a prohibition on incest

0:06:34there's there are ancient reasons for it

0:06:38but really it's a cultural bias rather

0:06:41than a necessary one or or an opera or

0:06:45e1 and i was like huh that makes me

0:06:48uncomfortable

0:06:49that's an idea that someone else put

0:06:53into a story and it makes me

0:06:55uncomfortable to think about and that

0:06:56very interesting and that and that story

0:06:59was a success because you know the

0:07:02reveal was like poof out huh i'm gonna

0:07:07take that away i'm gonna chew on that

0:07:08and yet my my first instinct he even

0:07:16when I you know even the star wars

0:07:17universe or anybody else's universe my

0:07:20first instinct is like okay that was fun

0:07:22thank you for having me over and now

0:07:25it's time to say goodnight and goodbye

0:07:28maybe i'll come back and visit you

0:07:29another time

0:07:30it's an Airbnb of the mind you don't

0:07:32want to lead on to move in yeah right

0:07:34because my own imaginative world is is

0:07:39almost completely fulfilling like I do

0:07:43not I do not sit around and and ever

0:07:45feel like while I've run out of things

0:07:47to imagine like I am so bored sitting

0:07:52here imagining things I would like to

0:07:54see what other people are imagining I

0:07:56mean you know every once in a while I do

0:07:58out of just sort of uh I hear people

0:08:01talking about something enough or or but

0:08:05it's never a case of like I'm having a

0:08:07real imagination drought over here and

0:08:10I'd like to go somewhere else and like

0:08:13and just to you know that whole business

0:08:15that people talk about like I just turn

0:08:17off and just you know and have absorbed

0:08:21with someone else's story like i

0:08:24understand the feeling of like turning

0:08:26off but you know turn off and go into my

0:08:30own the playland a library of

0:08:34speculative fiction right and so so I

0:08:40mean all the comments all the angry

0:08:41comments that that made their way to me

0:08:43about that fan article you know just or

0:08:46we're having the same sort of defensive

0:08:49reaction that the that the angry

0:08:51comments about the punk-rock article had

0:08:53which are like this is my world this is

0:08:55important to me why are you attacking me

0:08:57and you know and i think a lot of that

0:09:00is just the tone that I right or am I

0:09:02you know by a know-it-all tone

0:09:04but of course I'm not attacking and just

0:09:06like you really are talking about

0:09:08yourself talking about myself and and

0:09:10and and the best comments i got word

0:09:13that handful of emails from people that

0:09:14were like thank you for writing that you

0:09:16described me perfectly i never thought

0:09:19about it that way before I always feel

0:09:21like an outsider and i'm not a fan and

0:09:24and now i know that a that I'm not alone

0:09:27and then just like oh good I'm glad that

0:09:29I made that connection with you people

0:09:31like to think like you know and I I

0:09:33don't really have a dog in this fight

0:09:34too much but people but people tend to

0:09:37think and I feel that sometimes when I

0:09:39meet people who are really into comics

0:09:41that don't like or not into not even

0:09:44don't like that are into some comic that

0:09:45all of my other friends and she was like

0:09:47we have to stage an intervention

0:09:49it's like you don't understand it yet

0:09:51you know and so I know that I know that

0:09:53feeling that feeling of community that

0:09:55comes out of out of fandom but you know

0:09:57and I don't I didn't get that you were

0:09:59like saying that the other people

0:10:01shouldn't be fans know God why all means

0:10:04be fan like your fans i do i like all

0:10:07fans i like so many people who are fans

0:10:10it's just a I'm just kind of describing

0:10:13like a like my state and it's not really

0:10:18that I mean in some ways nothings and

0:10:19check myself too much but like it's kind

0:10:22of how I feel with me in like politics

0:10:24and current affairs like I don't hate

0:10:26politics and current affairs i don't

0:10:28even hate that people have strong

0:10:30opinions about it's just not my thing

0:10:32and I really feel like it in that case

0:10:33I'm the one saying i'm not a fan like I

0:10:35feel like an outcast I feel like people

0:10:37think I i don't know i don't know what

0:10:40people think but sometimes i wonder if i

0:10:42come across someone who doesn't care

0:10:43about something I care a lot about stuff

0:10:45I just don't feel the need to have that

0:10:47like arguments about it with people

0:10:49well that's the and that's the thing i

0:10:51mean in the form of politics the people

0:10:54who are fans of politics don't describe

0:10:56themselves using fan language they

0:11:00describe themselves using language where

0:11:01if you you know if you aren't interested

0:11:03in politics that you're not engaged in

0:11:06the present world and you don't care

0:11:07about the fate of mankind

0:11:09you know and really you're absolutely

0:11:11right their motivation is is very fan

0:11:16based or or a lot of a lot of the

0:11:18politics groupies are fan-based the

0:11:21people that are writing about politics

0:11:23everyday and writing about politicians

0:11:24like they are stars and you know that's

0:11:29true that's true of any of any of these

0:11:33you know the way our culture is siloed

0:11:36and somebody wrote somebody wrote an

0:11:38interesting so so the the bass player of

0:11:43skin yard who went on to own CZ records

0:11:51one of the seminal Seattle grunge labels

0:11:53he posted he reposted my fan article on

0:11:58his facebook page and typically like his

0:12:03friends on Facebook are all the Krusty

0:12:08grunge era cross towards that that hated

0:12:15my punk rock article 2 and there was a

0:12:17lot of shit talking there and he posted

0:12:19it like this is interesting to me at

0:12:21this that i'm not sure i'm not sure

0:12:23about this but i but I kind of feel like

0:12:26I might even be one of these people

0:12:27that's in this category of like as a

0:12:30difficult relationship to fandom but

0:12:33there was a lot of angry yelling on his

0:12:34facebook page and that was kind of the

0:12:35extent of the angry yelling that I saw

0:12:37that I allowed myself to see before I

0:12:39shut the whole system down

0:12:42yeah yeah but there was an interesting

0:12:44comment from someone on there that said

0:12:46like this the this John Roderick person

0:12:50seems like somebody who is primarily

0:12:54interested in the breadth of experience

0:12:56and not especially interested in the

0:12:59depth of experience and I was like and I

0:13:03you know I walked away and chew on that

0:13:05for a while and feel like that's

0:13:06absolutely true

0:13:08it's certainly a conclusion that could

0:13:10be drawn it's a conclusion that can be

0:13:11drawn it was a hundred percent accurate

0:13:13all the time it's it's certainly

0:13:14interesting thought technology it's an

0:13:16interesting thought technology and I and

0:13:18and what I felt what I feel like is that

0:13:20we all use the power of it

0:13:23extrapolation to to get through life

0:13:26right

0:13:27you don't have to i mean somebody that

0:13:29had a memento like condition where every

0:13:32experience they had to figure out the

0:13:34terms of it a new completely a new with

0:13:39no prior experience you know that what a

0:13:41nightmare that would be yeah like you go

0:13:43through enough situations that when you

0:13:46see a guy when you see a guy who has

0:13:49bleached his goatee you pretty much know

0:13:53what you're you pretty much know that

0:13:55you're dealing with somebody that once

0:13:56jalapenos in their food you know like

0:13:59you that's me and face test it

0:14:02you don't have to think of you have to

0:14:04you don't have to meet this guy and

0:14:05figure it out again right like oh you

0:14:08believe you bleach your facial hair

0:14:09betting that you think that your foods

0:14:12not hot enough i guess if you when

0:14:14you're thinking of asking do you want to

0:14:15hit off of this

0:14:16you don't have to ask you want to hit

0:14:17off of whatever it is exactly he wants

0:14:19to hit off of and he's the pad person

0:14:21who want to get off of everything you

0:14:23want cream cheese on that I bet you want

0:14:25cream cheese on the key so so uh so you

0:14:30know my my experience of depth when it

0:14:33comes to anything kind of culturally or

0:14:36experiential e is that I experienced the

0:14:39depth of things largely through

0:14:43extrapolation like I I i go down a

0:14:48street in a neighborhood and I say okay

0:14:52I got a picture of this neighborhood now

0:14:56because I've gone down this street and

0:14:59maybe I turned and went down a second

0:15:02street and i'm going to extrapolate what

0:15:04the character of this neighborhood is

0:15:06through through that experience now next

0:15:09time I'm going on a trip from point A to

0:15:12point B do i go down this same street

0:15:15again because it was the route because

0:15:17it was the fastest route or do I take a

0:15:20guy take a second route a new route so

0:15:25that i can increase that power of

0:15:27extrapolation

0:15:29I can increase my like my sample size so

0:15:35that again i start to get a picture of

0:15:37this whole part of the town i start to

0:15:39get a picture of this whole community

0:15:40that's interesting instead of being a

0:15:42fan of this particular route and because

0:15:45you like it more than the one other one

0:15:46you tried you're saying I want to see

0:15:48what all these do right and and and that

0:15:51is my experience of culture to like I'm

0:15:53always trying to increase my sample size

0:15:55so i can use the power of extrapolation

0:15:58to know more and and what I what I think

0:16:02is you know like i do not have it i do

0:16:04not have a deep knowledge of of a of any

0:16:10process right like how do you get to be

0:16:13a how do you get to be a great luthier

0:16:15how do you get to be the ultimate sushi

0:16:18chef you know you do the same thing over

0:16:20and over and over until your knowledge

0:16:23of it is like in your hands it's in your

0:16:26bones

0:16:27you are the you are the ultimate

0:16:30practitioner other thing because you

0:16:33have you have turned that experience

0:16:36you've gone through wrote into like body

0:16:41memory

0:16:42uh-huh uh-huh and I don't have that with

0:16:46anything even with guitar like I'm not I

0:16:48i find it very very difficult to

0:16:51practice the same thing over and over

0:16:52again I'm always playing something

0:16:54different and new and other and and in a

0:16:57way that that informs how I how I make

0:17:01music

0:17:01the problem is it's I never do that I

0:17:04never play the link multiple times until

0:17:06i can do it you know and it's you know

0:17:09that's why I'm not a not a real

0:17:12technical musician but but what I what I

0:17:16do instead is always take a different

0:17:17route always trying new food you know i

0:17:20was i was at a restaurant with a friend

0:17:21the other day and they were like I come

0:17:23to this restaurant with you 50 times

0:17:24you've never ordered the same thing

0:17:26and I ordered the same thing every time

0:17:28I i always order the same thing

0:17:30yeah and I think that's true that's true

0:17:32for a lot of people and they were

0:17:34remarking on it and it took them 50

0:17:36visits with me to to realize it like

0:17:39that every time you order something

0:17:42different and I think that that makes me

0:17:44a little uncomfortable like each time

0:17:45you're going to try something new like

0:17:47is it all like it can't always be good

0:17:49and I'm like no sometimes it is not good

0:17:52sometimes it's not but each but a meal

0:17:54is just a moment you know and if you get

0:17:56if you get a bad one like like sweeping

0:17:58into the trash you know tried to try and

0:18:01the new thing the next time so it's a so

0:18:04it's a it's a relationship to phantom

0:18:07that's really part of a larger

0:18:09relationship to experience which is like

0:18:13I don't care to do the same thing enough

0:18:16times that i developed a deep knowledge

0:18:18because deep knowledge of a process or

0:18:23of a of a any any real deep knowledge is

0:18:28a thing i feel like i can approximate

0:18:30through analogy and like I would much

0:18:37rather see the IC increase my breath

0:18:40over right now and but let me let me

0:18:43just help add a note here that I think

0:18:46is important which is I don't hear you

0:18:48saying that means nobody else should

0:18:50have deep knowledge of things or ignore

0:18:53that that's not valuable you're not

0:18:54saying that at all

0:18:56the only way i could be this way is that

0:18:58I is that I'm surrounded by people that

0:19:00have deep knowledge agree though that

0:19:02isn't that something that people here

0:19:03when you use when you say i have chosen

0:19:05to like know enough about these couple

0:19:07things to be able to extrapolate and

0:19:09learn and learn about a new thing I want

0:19:10to know about your you're curious person

0:19:12that doesn't mean that you don't think

0:19:14other people should become experts know

0:19:16and I don't understand how anybody could

0:19:18I mean I guess I feel like it's weird

0:19:20even have the 66

0:19:22yeah I and I feel like when I talk about

0:19:24my experience I talked about it with a

0:19:27with with unnatural pride right like i

0:19:31am proud of how I am I i don't i'm not

0:19:35defending how I am against attackers i

0:19:37just am proud of it because

0:19:40because i feel like that whole modern

0:19:42tendency to apologize for who you are

0:19:44first like hello hi nice to meet you

0:19:46listen I'm sorry that I'm different from

0:19:48you but I'm just gonna I have to express

0:19:51my difference and I know it's bad but

0:19:53please don't hurt me but here I am I

0:19:56hate that I i feel like i I'm I'm proud

0:19:59of Who I am and that that's not

0:20:01something i should be ashamed of but

0:20:03expressing who i am in a way that is

0:20:05that seems like just sort of a contented

0:20:09or happy or or or that I prefer the way

0:20:12that I am is immediately interpreted as

0:20:15judgment of other people and my

0:20:18preference for myself is is somehow an

0:20:21expression that I am better uh want to

0:20:25share the church is categorically

0:20:26disrespectful almost yeah right like oh

0:20:28yes I I don't prefer to be an expert so

0:20:31anybody that's an expert is a fucking

0:20:32idiot like and I don't know where people

0:20:35how people make that leap it's in it's

0:20:37an invisible missed in a culture today i

0:20:41feel i feel it all the time it's bananas

0:20:44it is and it's it's so it's so cocky and

0:20:47self-involved to assume that you can

0:20:49understand that much about somebody

0:20:52who's not who's not even saying anything

0:20:53against what you believe or saying

0:20:56anything against the very idea that you

0:20:58like to believe what you believe it's

0:21:00it's so it's a caustic and unnecessary

0:21:02but I feel like it's everywhere and if

0:21:05you and you really you sound one sounds

0:21:08very self-involved or insulated if you

0:21:12don't excuse yourself for not knowing

0:21:15everything about somebody and you don't

0:21:17mean tennis is such a weird situation

0:21:19well this and again this this this

0:21:22comment section in on the Daniel house

0:21:25facebook page there was a guy and at a

0:21:29certain point of the full disclosure at

0:21:31a certain point I started to comment on

0:21:33his Facebook page no because John the

0:21:36first commenter was a guy that was just

0:21:39like you know what this guy's a fucking

0:21:41asshole i hated his punk rock article i

0:21:43hate his whole attitude he thinks he's

0:21:45better than everybody else he thinks

0:21:47he's smarter than everybody else and

0:21:48that's fucking bullshit

0:21:50his music sucks and he's got a fucking

0:21:52stupid haircut and his glasses are dumb

0:21:54everything about this guy sucks and it's

0:21:56fucking and that he's an asshole and I

0:21:58hate him and you know so that's the

0:22:00first comment and it's known as well you

0:22:03know and it gets like it gets a like

0:22:06five times or something and it you know

0:22:09that but then there's three or four

0:22:10comments from people that are like I

0:22:11don't know this article seems pretty

0:22:12well it seems pretty reasonable i mean

0:22:15i-i don't know if I agree that kiss is

0:22:17no good because I like kiss but you know

0:22:19but you know a couple people defending

0:22:21or at least making that conciliatory

0:22:24facebook like medium post and then the

0:22:30guy comes back and he's like no you know

0:22:32what you guys Bob habitat you're all

0:22:33wrong and another thing about this guy

0:22:35like his she's got bad taste in shoes

0:22:38and he's like Ed perturb and so finally

0:22:40of course I'll III show up here I come

0:22:44through the door in a cape

0:22:47I'm like huh i'm the writer of this

0:22:50article and I'm reading your comments

0:22:52you know I'm reading your comments and

0:22:54I'm and I feel like I'm not trying to

0:22:57attack anybody with this article I'm

0:22:59just expressing who i am i'm just

0:23:00talking from my perspective it's not a

0:23:03bad thing and so angry guy comes back in

0:23:08and now he feels a little bit like o.o

0:23:10the there's an adulterer like bit adults

0:23:13are in the room now so i have to pretend

0:23:15I'm an adult and he's like well I'm it's

0:23:17very I'm very pleased to see that you're

0:23:19here defending yourself but I just have

0:23:21to take issue with the fact that you are

0:23:24such a that you're so arrogant and I was

0:23:28like well I'm not arrogant I'm just

0:23:30talking about my experience and why

0:23:34would I why would I apologize for for

0:23:38you know what i mean and he's and he

0:23:40comes back again a third time with like

0:23:42chastising me about my tone and and so i

0:23:46wrote i would like you sir to read back

0:23:49on your posts on this facebook page and

0:23:53reflect on your tone and then contrast

0:23:57it with my tone and tell me which tone

0:24:00you prefer like my know-it-all tone that

0:24:03is

0:24:04like so offensive to you because I'm

0:24:05because I'm proud of myself right you're

0:24:08an idiot and he's speaking truth to

0:24:09power now or yeah exactly or you're like

0:24:12you are pouring vitriol against someone

0:24:18you don't know and don't understand and

0:24:21your instinct your first instinct is to

0:24:23be butthurt and up and like pissy bitchy

0:24:29so what world you want to live in you

0:24:32know like I'm i and and and that that

0:24:35idea that two to be to not apologize for

0:24:42yourself is the greatest crime is the

0:24:46first crime you know is the is the is

0:24:48the premier crime in in our internet

0:24:53culture now to not begin with a I have

0:24:56no right to speak but now that I've

0:25:00acknowledge that i'm going to proffer my

0:25:02humble opinion and I and now i'm gonna

0:25:06slowly back out of the room bowing and

0:25:09scraping and that and that's what's

0:25:11necessary to not be to not be taken as

0:25:15like a strident combative and ultimately

0:25:21like you know angry troll

0:25:23I don't get it I don't get it it's um I

0:25:27think when you're doing any kind of

0:25:29personal writing when you're talking

0:25:30about yourself when you're talking about

0:25:31yourself it as a member of society which

0:25:33is what a lot of personal sites are in

0:25:35some ways it's um I mean it'sit's you

0:25:37have to be skillful to say something

0:25:39interesting

0:25:39it's be very skillful to say something

0:25:41new and used to be somewhat courageous

0:25:43to say something honest I think it's

0:25:44very difficult to efficiently say

0:25:47anything that's interesting and new and

0:25:49honest without a lot of people getting

0:25:52upset sometimes very little reason and

0:25:55it isn't it isn't a mean people can sit

0:25:57and I think that reads you're right i

0:25:58think that people read that as arrogant

0:26:00but like the thing is though if you

0:26:03don't want it so what do you do to not

0:26:04get that reaction from people you say

0:26:06something uninteresting you say

0:26:07something that's not new and you say

0:26:09something is dishonest you say something

0:26:10that everybody can agree with because

0:26:11they already think that and that's why

0:26:13bother you

0:26:15right thats that's just asking for

0:26:16compliments and that's that's not making

0:26:18anything

0:26:19yea yea it is an enemy and it's part of

0:26:22i think the growing sense of like online

0:26:24life as a as a group think consensus

0:26:29machine where we're we're not we are not

0:26:34trying to invent something new right now

0:26:37in our at this moment in our culture we

0:26:40are not trying to put a man on the moon

0:26:41we are not trying to push the boundaries

0:26:46of what it is to be a you know human

0:26:49animal or 0 or a global culture we are

0:26:52just at least online just trying to

0:26:57round off all the nubs and sand the

0:27:02corners and figure out and and basically

0:27:04like shout people into a consensus that

0:27:08makes us feel like that validates our

0:27:10own prejudices and figure out how much

0:27:14of that is about corralling a temporary

0:27:17tribe of people who categorically agree

0:27:19on who is a bad person and why they can

0:27:22ask yourself how many things that people

0:27:24consider like important conversations

0:27:26all mostly stopped at who's a bad person

0:27:29and why

0:27:29uh-huh and then ask yourself what you

0:27:31get out of that in terms of making

0:27:33something

0:27:34well yeah you're not making any

0:27:36specially if 36 hours you move on to

0:27:38find another tribe that you can agree

0:27:39with and I really do I really honestly

0:27:42do believe that but I mean you know of

0:27:45several years ago 10 years ago we were

0:27:47very worried about the Millennials and I

0:27:50don't want to dump on the Millennials

0:27:52because I some of the smartest people I

0:27:53know are part of that generation is so

0:27:55arrogant and some of the fuck you know

0:27:57some of the funniest stuff that is being

0:28:00bandied about is coming from Millennials

0:28:03who have a who have a a different enough

0:28:06take and a kind of let you know and the

0:28:11power of youth but but ten years ago we

0:28:15were we were all very concerned about

0:28:18this brand new generation that was

0:28:19arriving had never gotten a bad grade no

0:28:23one had ever given them an F no one has

0:28:25ever told them they needed to try a

0:28:27little harder

0:28:28her they were congratulated at every

0:28:30step of the way and now they were 18

0:28:33years old they were entering the world

0:28:35and they were really unhappy to find

0:28:39that they didn't get a round of applause

0:28:41every time they pooped and this was you

0:28:44know this was ten years ago when we were

0:28:45adults and we were like oh there's a new

0:28:47generation arriving on the scene and

0:28:49it's kind of weird interacting with them

0:28:52because they are indignant that you know

0:28:55like and and their indignant is you know

0:29:01we were characterizing it as this as a

0:29:03product of this era of no bad grades k-8

0:29:08if I effective make it worse they seldom

0:29:11seldom analyzed and ignorance but it

0:29:15really felt like something that arrive

0:29:17by fedex one day and that they really

0:29:18completely deserved was this just this

0:29:20constant sense of like explain i don't

0:29:23mean to be negative about it but I just

0:29:25got this sense of-of always looking for

0:29:28bad stuff and everything as a way to

0:29:31explain why your life sucks right and

0:29:33and and and crucially unreflective

0:29:35that's that's exactly right they were

0:29:37not reflecting inwardly they're fine

0:29:40reflecting on other people and we're

0:29:41planning on what they need to be doing

0:29:43differently be more unhappy like them

0:29:45yeah well so here we are 10 years later

0:29:47and we're no longer really talking about

0:29:50Millennials in that way because that was

0:29:52that was the way that we thought about

0:29:54them when they were newly minted adults

0:29:56they weren't kids anymore but they still

0:29:58were very kid-like now that generation

0:30:01is in its thirties and it is it is

0:30:06producing a lot of culture it is really

0:30:09like it is really generating that it the

0:30:13tone of the conversation and and so i'm

0:30:17i'm beginning to try and do what we've

0:30:19done with every generation so far in my

0:30:21life which is kind of slop them in to

0:30:24what the story is you know what the

0:30:27story of our culture is and and

0:30:29Millennials are typically the children

0:30:31of baby boomers

0:30:33and you're in my generation is this this

0:30:37intergeneration that is largely going to

0:30:39be forgotten

0:30:40you know we're a smaller population wise

0:30:44words were much smaller than the Boomers

0:30:47before us or their children after us

0:30:49there fewer of us and we're going to be

0:30:52marginalized we already are marginalized

0:30:55we always were marginalized when we were

0:30:5818 the popular music on the charts was

0:31:02still boomer music and we had our brief

0:31:06moment in the early nineties where our

0:31:08culture poked through for a little while

0:31:11and we were regarded as a sulky entitled

0:31:17generation ourselves and then we just

0:31:21got like we just sort of got dust heaped

0:31:25as the culture moved on like they

0:31:28weren't really interested in hearing

0:31:30from us anymore whatever it was that we

0:31:33contributed was just kind of like ironic

0:31:37and everything every year we're moving

0:31:39more and more out of the target demo

0:31:41yeah right you know we were like the

0:31:43sneer errs who sneered our way right

0:31:46into like a position where we acquiesce

0:31:50to total sellout status which

0:31:53invalidated entirely our prior sneery

0:31:56mentality you know like we we self

0:32:00invalidated ourselves in a way that that

0:32:04it took the Boomers 25 years to do and

0:32:08we just got on it pretty-pretty

0:32:10announced today that the idea of selling

0:32:12out is it is disappearing away we

0:32:15couldn't imagine even five years ago

0:32:17yeah right and and and in it in one

0:32:19sense good riddens because that was that

0:32:21was self-defeating but in another sense

0:32:23everything isn't there everything is

0:32:25marketing now I mean everything is

0:32:28marketing including journalism I mean

0:32:31things that we thought were were

0:32:32unassailable including a personality

0:32:34your personality you're a mean every

0:32:37fucking thing and I say that as somebody

0:32:39who who embraces the fact that you and I

0:32:43have found an advertiser for our program

0:32:45hello

0:32:46like love a love the idea of making a

0:32:52living doing creative work but my god i

0:32:54go on the internet i'm trying to find a

0:32:58thing I want to search for the the I

0:33:00want to search for some information on

0:33:02the thirty years war and the fucking

0:33:05thing pops up and it's like if you like

0:33:06the Thirty Years War you're gonna love

0:33:08the new nissan sentra a team that Carl's

0:33:10jr. you know go click to this BuzzFeed

0:33:13thing and it's and you're just gonna and

0:33:16every time you look for the arrow to see

0:33:17the next picture it's actually going to

0:33:19be an arrow that takes you to a chase

0:33:21credit card and people usually what

0:33:23happens tricks

0:33:24that's like fuck you everybody like

0:33:25everybody fucking but so so we're living

0:33:28in a world now where Millennials have

0:33:31have have melted into the larger adult

0:33:35population and have brought their values

0:33:38into the adult conversation they are

0:33:42adults now and have their have this

0:33:45value system that we perceive to be

0:33:47founded in an untruth which is the

0:33:51untruth being that everyone is special

0:33:53and we feel that to be intrinsically

0:33:58untrue and an unexamined lie but it's

0:34:02now in its in the water that that that

0:34:05draw that you know that LSD is in the

0:34:08water supply now and you cannot you

0:34:11cannot take a 30 year old and segregate

0:34:14them from a forty-five-year-old and say

0:34:16like well you still are you sir are

0:34:19still living in a state of delusion

0:34:21whereas we at 45 have exclusive access

0:34:25to the truth because the baby boomers

0:34:27ahead of us are also living in a

0:34:28delusion like we're the only ones that

0:34:31that step here the claim of

0:34:34metal-on-metal I mean we're all just

0:34:37dummies but I'm you know you you have a

0:34:42kid I have a kid that are part of a jet

0:34:44part of a generation that we have to

0:34:47imagine I i have to start imagining what

0:34:51their viewpoint is kind of pain now and

0:34:54our are Millennials

0:34:57are they the aberration or were we you

0:35:01know our are they establishing what the

0:35:04new tone is and weird i mean in a way

0:35:08absolutely they are we are always from

0:35:11now on going to be living in a world

0:35:13that is somewhat defined by the the

0:35:18group think and you know like

0:35:23rights-based thinking you know kind of

0:35:26justice based thinking of the generation

0:35:30that came after us but somebody's got to

0:35:33come along with a fucking plan for

0:35:35something exciting and new

0:35:36right right we can't human history

0:35:39cannot just turn on itself and bite its

0:35:41own tail for the rest we should have

0:35:42more kids we should have more kids we

0:35:45should teach them science until trail

0:35:47get get them out there get there they're

0:35:50healthy strong bodies building trail in

0:35:51the Sun and then set them loose with

0:35:55tools and math right teach them math

0:35:59which together math and computer maths

0:36:02teach them standard math if they know

0:36:04their maths well enough by computer

0:36:06maths will be easy because computer

0:36:09mouths are just a trade that anyone can

0:36:11learn

0:36:12meanwhile back in santa fe i think if

0:36:16you ask the typical pop quiz hotshot us

0:36:18the typical erotic online listener which

0:36:21one of us had read your me which of us

0:36:26had read any token I have a feeling most

0:36:32people would guess that i have read some

0:36:35token right i've read note okay see

0:36:38that's insane to be right now i'm going

0:36:40to a lot of people i have read all the

0:36:42tools see in this way the silmarillion

0:36:45isn't that the hard one which is that

0:36:47it's impossible to read that's like much

0:36:49that's his metal machine music right

0:36:50it's like reading a hundred years of

0:36:52solitude if all the story was taken out

0:36:54of this episode of rock on the line is

0:36:58sponsored by our very good friends at

0:36:59Squarespace you know Squarespace they

0:37:01are the all-in-one platform that makes

0:37:03it fast and easy to create your own

0:37:05professional website portfolio or online

0:37:07store they make the whole process so so

0:37:10all have an easy drag-and-drop interface

0:37:12and beautiful free templates you can

0:37:14tweak to suit your needs all the

0:37:16squarespace six designs are responsive

0:37:18which means they look great on every

0:37:19device

0:37:20Squarespace also offers free 24 x seven

0:37:23support through live chat and email with

0:37:25dedicated teams in New York City dublin

0:37:27and Portland John and I have u square

0:37:30space to host rock on the line for three

0:37:32years now they have been great to work

0:37:34with

0:37:34we would love it if you would give them

0:37:36a try to remember Squarespace plans

0:37:38start at only eight dollars per month

0:37:40eight dollars a month that includes a

0:37:42free domain name if you sign up for a

0:37:43year

0:37:44please remember to tell Squarespace you

0:37:46heard about it from your positronic on

0:37:47the line listeners of this program get a

0:37:50free trial plus ten percent off any

0:37:52package they choose by using the special

0:37:54offer code supertrain at checkout our

0:37:57thanks to squarespace for supporting rod

0:37:59on the line we could not do it without

0:38:00the one Tolkien I haven't read is his

0:38:06apparently genius translation of Beowulf

0:38:09which went unpublished until very

0:38:13recently that was his like his a cassie

0:38:18is young master work before he did all

0:38:21the other before he did the fantasy

0:38:22writing he wrote this like really

0:38:25translation of Beowulf and then never

0:38:27published it just sat on it huh and

0:38:29Auntie think is a state did that as a

0:38:32state has finally published yeah but you

0:38:35gotta be careful what you leave on your

0:38:36computer yeah I'm shaman know another

0:38:39beer sketches by genre but he he wrote

0:38:45this thing and I think it might have

0:38:46been his leaves of grass he kept writing

0:38:48it or or no monkeying with all didn't

0:38:51think it was ready I don't know

0:38:53but george RR martin very curious

0:38:58character very interesting to interact

0:39:01with him who he is a nerd

0:39:10oh really yes but of the old-school you

0:39:15know like remember when we were young

0:39:17nerds

0:39:19yes and the difference between the Nerds

0:39:24that you know that play Dungeons and

0:39:28Dragons and nerds that were actually

0:39:29trying to learn sword Smith three you

0:39:37remember there were you know they were

0:39:39real nerds even when we were nerds who

0:39:42were just a dimension beyond like the

0:39:45guys who talked about swords there was a

0:39:49good there's a kid in my ninth grade

0:39:51science class who was a friend of mine

0:39:53we talked about we talked about fantasy

0:39:57writing and science fiction together and

0:40:00we enjoyed Dungeons and Dragons culture

0:40:04but he had notebooks full of designs of

0:40:10swords that he was sincere about

0:40:14learning the ancient arts swordmaking

0:40:20222 craft these swords to shoo them out

0:40:25of the metal and i remember at the time

0:40:29feeling like you know that there that

0:40:33that is you are choosing to pursue

0:40:38esoterica down a rabbit hole to the end

0:40:44like swordmaking is never going it's not

0:40:47relevant it's never going to be relevant

0:40:49now it's you are on a siding and i

0:40:54appreciate like that that I appreciate

0:40:58the art I appreciate the history I

0:41:00appreciate everything about it but

0:41:02and I think there was a part of what

0:41:03what what what made it possible for him

0:41:07or what made it exciting was that there

0:41:12was a part of the fantasy where he

0:41:16believed that maybe one day civilization

0:41:20would crumble and swords would be the

0:41:24way we interact with each other again

0:41:26telling a freethinker like you know

0:41:28you're not a political way but I mean

0:41:29like he's definitely he's got his own

0:41:30thoughts about how stuff is going to go

0:41:33he's not he's not doing it to be cool

0:41:35he's not doing it because you know it's

0:41:37the next obvious step given that his

0:41:38father's a swordsmith he's got a larger

0:41:40world view

0:41:41yeah and I feel like there's a there's a

0:41:44part of steampunk culture renfaire

0:41:47culture fantasy culture cosplay culture

0:41:52that is that it the there are under

0:41:58under threads undertones of apocalypse

0:42:02in those things you know people are

0:42:06aware that they are in my charity and

0:42:10they are enjoying these cultures and and

0:42:13I cannot help but feel like they all

0:42:16secretly hope that the grid goes down

0:42:21certainly can read done a little bit

0:42:24that these are red dawn fantasies and

0:42:26that when the grid does go down their

0:42:30swords smithing there uh you know the

0:42:33fact that they can cook a hearty meal in

0:42:35a kettle the fact that they know how to

0:42:38entertain themselves with just a flute

0:42:40and foot bells they've dealt with in

0:42:43period lice and that's right that's

0:42:46right thing in the civil war thing you

0:42:48gotta it's okay if you have please like

0:42:49that makes it more realistic

0:42:50yeah you figure figure out the fleas in

0:42:52the lights you figure out that that

0:42:55though that suddenly those skills which

0:42:57we all thought were laughable are going

0:42:59to be are going to come in very handy

0:43:02and the traveling minstrels and the and

0:43:07the the jugglers and the Juggalos

0:43:10what are all technology just waiting for

0:43:14the apocalypse they are and I and I feel

0:43:16like I mean and this may be the the this

0:43:18may be my cold war childhood speaking

0:43:21but I cannot help but think all these

0:43:23alternative cultures are in some ways

0:43:26secret apocalypse cults and everybody is

0:43:30privately preparing for what they have

0:43:33because this is absolutely true

0:43:34on the flipside like all the gun nuts

0:43:37all the survivalists all the people who

0:43:39are more out about what they call

0:43:44preparing for the race riots or

0:43:48preparing for the water wars are

0:43:50preparing for the when the government

0:43:53comes and what they're really doing is

0:43:55fantasizing about those things they're

0:43:57praying for those eventualities because

0:44:01their preparation is like it's so

0:44:04excited they're so enthusiastic about it

0:44:08they are hoping to God that the grid

0:44:12goes down and that they are defending

0:44:14their homes against hordes and anna and

0:44:20i really feel like like the fantasy

0:44:22world and the and the what we you know

0:44:25what we think of as the nerd world at

0:44:29least the at least the steampunky ran

0:44:31fairy artisanal craftsman side of things

0:44:36it's also like suddenly prepping for the

0:44:41for the end times in and the other did

0:44:43never never thought of that because when

0:44:45you think about somebody you know that

0:44:47the typical thing would be when you say

0:44:49like not even renfaire just like a

0:44:50medieval Middle Ages kind of dressup

0:44:53thinking why would you want to spend

0:44:55your weekend acting like you're living

0:44:57in this really squalid time with no

0:44:59resources and you know horrible health

0:45:03conditions and terrible food and if you

0:45:05look at instead instead of looking to

0:45:07the past and pining is the instead of

0:45:09thinking let's look into the future and

0:45:10preparing yeah thats turkey leg is going

0:45:12to look pretty good couple years I think

0:45:15what they're doing is making apocalypse

0:45:16fun

0:45:17and and you know and its really like the

0:45:23tech people who are right in the middle

0:45:26of the culture who are you know the tech

0:45:30people are betting that everything keeps

0:45:34going you know protect people are laying

0:45:37the groundwork for the fact that the

0:45:40grid does not go down and that really

0:45:42the skill sets that are going to be

0:45:44needed in the future our skill sets

0:45:47built on what we're doing now and it's

0:45:51like that conversation i had with

0:45:53jonathan coulton many years ago when you

0:45:56know when my daughter was born his kids

0:45:59are a little bit older than mine and I

0:46:01was like you know I was expressing my

0:46:03kind of hippie like suspicion of screen

0:46:06time

0:46:06well i don't think i'm going to you know

0:46:08i don't think i'm likely going to let my

0:46:10kid what you look very interesting

0:46:11thoughts on that that really have

0:46:12heavily influenced me

0:46:14yeah and he he was like well why are you

0:46:16doing that like all they're going to

0:46:19have our screens in the future where

0:46:22we're going

0:46:23the future where we're going where

0:46:25that's going to be their lot they're

0:46:27lighter in which we will spend the rest

0:46:29of our lives right and so the longer you

0:46:32deprive her of screens it's like you are

0:46:36it's like you are refusing to let her

0:46:38use a fork because they didn't use to

0:46:41have Forks or something like these are

0:46:43tools things like a even ate like to me

0:46:45this is super productive but might that

0:46:47I walked away with thinking well you

0:46:49know I i want i read so much bullshit i

0:46:52don't like to my daughter but she wants

0:46:55to read it so it doesn't matter if it's

0:46:57barbie or my little pony or green

0:46:59lantern like I will read it to her

0:47:01because she wants to be read to

0:47:03I want her to hear lots of words I want

0:47:05her to read lots of words and if those

0:47:07are the words to get her excited that's

0:47:09good i i music there's a part of me that

0:47:11I really admit this is reductive but

0:47:12after to having that conversation with

0:47:14with you know we have different names

0:47:16John that falling really different sides

0:47:17of the fence about this it's interesting

0:47:18to talk to them about this

0:47:20no yeah they argue with one another and

0:47:23still they still do but you know but for

0:47:25me it's like that's the new literacy

0:47:27like it just doesn't feel like literacy

0:47:28to us I so what I say to my daughter

0:47:31you're only allowed to look at

0:47:32educational books for an hour a day I

0:47:34know it's not exactly the same thing you

0:47:37can look at books but they need to be

0:47:38educational there was a time when people

0:47:40thought books were like or something

0:47:41they're gonna be really upsetting a time

0:47:43with a you know theocracy in place like

0:47:45that's really dangerous information

0:47:46well I mean I feel like even when she's

0:47:48playing monument valley like even when

0:47:50she's trying to buy and failing thank

0:47:52God to buy buy toys for talking a

0:47:54cartoon cat on a screen like at the same

0:47:56time she's learning to manipulate that

0:47:57she's learned that she's learning to

0:47:59type a little bit and I didn't really

0:48:01learn to type until I was like 18 right

0:48:04and Mike my God if you don't have that I

0:48:06mean god bless the people who don't play

0:48:08their kids recorded music and make them

0:48:10play with blocks

0:48:11haha we have a friend who goes to

0:48:13waldorf and water is a very interesting

0:48:15educational program but it on the face

0:48:18of it freaks me out a little bit like my

0:48:20psu group also well I don't know enough

0:48:23about it everybody does what r says it's

0:48:24not as bad as it sounds but you know the

0:48:26idea is it's really all about playing

0:48:27playing play which is great but like you

0:48:29play with fairly simple toys and you're

0:48:31not supposed to listen to recorded music

0:48:32you've never let you never do anything

0:48:34with screens at all until a certain age

0:48:36and anyway I don't be productive about

0:48:38it but like for me like I feel like

0:48:40somewhat my life has been made so much

0:48:42better and frustrating sometimes

0:48:44bye-bye this computer stuff but we have

0:48:46to understand that back to your thing

0:48:47about the Millennials we still think

0:48:48about this computer stuff for them

0:48:50that's just life in the sooner like she

0:48:52gets good at that version of life the

0:48:54more prepared she'll be to make good

0:48:55decisions when that stuff gets weird

0:48:57which it will in a couple years right

0:48:59anyway I've never so far off george RR

0:49:02martin but-but-but but-but-but in what

0:49:05you're saying so I swear I I feel like I

0:49:08feel like it's very interesting how much

0:49:10how how many trends in the popular

0:49:16culture in and sort of every direction

0:49:18of every political stripe can be traced

0:49:22back to a kind of 222 an apocalypse

0:49:27origin story and the mainstream

0:49:33culture just putters along in a state of

0:49:35of like unreflective mass of block step

0:49:42informant even the negative thinking is

0:49:44that things will get worse in a way that

0:49:46will mostly understand

0:49:47yeah right its gonna be like oh but you

0:49:50know it's gonna be hard it's gonna be

0:49:51harder to it's gonna be harder to get a

0:49:53my shade of lipstick in the future

0:49:56because uh because apparently it's not

0:50:00as your Selina Kyle and the dark knight

0:50:02rises like great cosmetics after she got

0:50:06off the electricity

0:50:07she really did and I did I can only

0:50:09assume that she spent all the time she

0:50:11wasn't on screen like up at macys going

0:50:14through the darkened I think it's clear

0:50:16that she moved into account a mac

0:50:17cosmetics store before being shut off

0:50:19all the attack

0:50:20yes and she's just to disappear for a

0:50:22while you'd be like where did you know

0:50:24did you notice that I was like personal

0:50:25and halfway very beautiful woman but

0:50:27like which everybody else

0:50:29it looks like half a Dickens character

0:50:30that she looks amazing

0:50:33well this is the thing I think a lot of

0:50:34the female superheroes what we forget is

0:50:36that their mask is makeup right they

0:50:40don't

0:50:41the female superheroes often do not wear

0:50:42masks because they because they're

0:50:45pretty face is necessary and so Batman

0:50:48and bein have these hideous the

0:50:50appendages on their faces

0:50:53she is you know it's it's a it's a

0:50:57skin-tight bodysuit and a animated face

0:51:00like that's her costume but in any case

0:51:04the tech people are the ones that are

0:51:07curious to me because they are not part

0:51:10of the lockstep mass culture that is

0:51:12just going into the future and

0:51:15reflectively they often trend culturally

0:51:19with with these like apocalypse and

0:51:22modern primitive calls but everything

0:51:26that they do is contingent on if a on

0:51:30faith that technology and technology

0:51:35will survive that progress is linear and

0:51:38always you know always building on the

0:51:42last thing and that

0:51:44that you know that if your kid doesn't

0:51:48learn the swipe gesture across asswipe

0:51:51screen that 10 years from now they won't

0:51:55they won't be able to even read a book

0:51:59because everything will let the swiping

0:52:01is like once but now that we're in a

0:52:04swipe world everything will follow from

0:52:07the swype and that's a that is a curious

0:52:12kind of faith and a curious like

0:52:17whatever the Articles of Confederation

0:52:19are of people that go to Macworld and

0:52:24are like tell us

0:52:26oracle with what what are the new you

0:52:30know are finding his lips

0:52:31yeah what are the new swipes is plural

0:52:33marriage allowed yet in at back world if

0:52:38not it's only a matter of time like that

0:52:41that whole that whole subset of and

0:52:44which makes up a huge part of my world

0:52:46the people that I know and r & m friends

0:52:50with we discuss you at the meetings I

0:52:52know you do online journal like and its

0:52:55allies get see it there's a lot of

0:52:57livejournal talk that's like when is

0:52:59just when are we gonna finally when will

0:53:01jontron into the room when well Jon

0:53:03teach the swipe his negativity has

0:53:08become problematic apocalypse apocalypse

0:53:13george RR martin here here here was the

0:53:19first story that george RR martin told

0:53:21me I said how to you and your wife meet

0:53:24and he said in the early seventies she

0:53:31was she worked for Ringling Brothers

0:53:33Circus and we went to a early convention

0:53:42cut comics convention

0:53:45and because it was the early seventies

0:53:47there was an all like a women-only sauna

0:53:53at the comics convention and I went into

0:53:59the women's only sauna naked to liberate

0:54:04the gender bias inherent you know in a

0:54:08woman's only sana-i I went in there as

0:54:12like a as a warrior men's rights warrior

0:54:17so what's already 1971 or whatever

0:54:20that's very courageous and she it's the

0:54:24real oh she felt like there is no it was

0:54:28very appealing my you know my bolt the

0:54:30seasoning serious this is the real story

0:54:33yeah and I was just like I mean I'm

0:54:38standing on top of like a teetering pile

0:54:42of like under stories or I'm just like

0:54:45okay wait a minute now what will

0:54:47she's she works for Ringling Brothers

0:54:49you guys are at a at a world con there

0:54:52is a woman's only sauna that you were

0:54:55liberating and that's how you met and

0:55:00he's like well I mean I was you know my

0:55:03wife hit bottom of the hill

0:55:04exactly he may your wife of john bands

0:55:08like show he and he's like well and then

0:55:11I married someone else for a period but

0:55:14then we met again always look prettier

0:55:16for Windows but I was like okay this is

0:55:20all happening in 1971 this is a separate

0:55:23thread of the culture that goes back a

0:55:29long long time that he is one of the you

0:55:32know he's one of the early early early

0:55:34he said he you know worldcon was like a

0:55:36big part of his his universe at a time

0:55:43up the where with the the coach culture

0:55:49at large and even the nerd historians

0:55:52like have a hard time going that far

0:55:55back in the culture to a time when like

0:55:58I I so I and I swear to you that that

0:56:03they they absolutely were probably

0:56:05wearing puffy sleeve garments there

0:56:08might have been a good jingle stick gets

0:56:12our apt though and so I'm I'm like I am

0:56:16so enthralled and so elated picturing

0:56:20these nerds at the dawn of what we think

0:56:25of as like fan culture and so his wife

0:56:30is sitting there and I'm like tell me

0:56:32your version of this story and she's

0:56:34like well you know what Iowa i'm a fan I

0:56:37am one of the early fans and we were the

0:56:40first generation of people who recognize

0:56:42that being a fan was its own thing and

0:56:49I've spent my whole life as a fan of

0:56:51science fiction and um and fantasy and

0:56:58it's made a beautiful life for me so

0:57:02that's lovely

0:57:03it was extraordinary extraordinary to

0:57:07hear like that they were they created

0:57:12that culture in the quiet in a way you

0:57:15know what I mean like they were not

0:57:16trying to interact with the larger

0:57:17culture they found one another at these

0:57:20at these comic cons and it was an

0:57:24imperfect it was an imperfect center

0:57:29probably but close enough for the circus

0:57:31people and the burlesque people and the

0:57:34vaudeville people and them fantasy and

0:57:37science fiction people like they all

0:57:40they all found each other in a way that

0:57:42I think we think of we think of that

0:57:44experiencing experience happening really

0:57:47in modern times like that's the nerd

0:57:50narrative but what you just described in

0:57:52some ways is what how people talk about

0:57:54things like Woodstock how you get that

0:57:56mean i mean and i don't mean to sound

0:57:58productive but I mean like in the same

0:57:59sense of going like there was a time

0:58:00when people who are really into free

0:58:02speech and weed and free love and beat

0:58:08poetry and all these things that now we

0:58:10all just slapping the same pile

0:58:12there was a time when the all the people

0:58:13who are if you like outsiders of a

0:58:15certain kind of middle-class you know

0:58:17outsider like found a commonality in

0:58:19that and now that all seems really

0:58:21obvious but at the time it probably was

0:58:23not that obvious

0:58:24not at all and in this case it's even

0:58:26more obscure the nerd thing was

0:58:27contemporaneous with that and and yet a

0:58:30tiny tiny fraction of the size of you

0:58:34know like it was not general interest it

0:58:36was very specific so so it's also like

0:58:40one underground you know that's when

0:58:42your when your body are chrome was

0:58:43started to come out this rod up

0:58:44underground comics were huge then for

0:58:47its the cabs are old you know which is

0:58:49franco is doing with with Marvel stuff

0:58:51was pretty out there that

0:58:53yeah right never then everybody's

0:58:55getting hi to her but so so meeting him

0:58:59and his wife and seeing their connection

0:59:02to this culture and then he has cs4

0:59:04assistance George RR Martin's for

0:59:06systems whom he describes as his minions

0:59:09they describe themselves as his main

0:59:11lights right all four of them are women

0:59:16who are a little zaftig who have dark

0:59:22curly hair but they wear in braids and

0:59:27one of them is British there couple that

0:59:28are like a Americans one of them never I

0:59:32never actually saw only heard spoken of

0:59:36they're all like hilarious super-smart

0:59:40like in their thirties or forties and

0:59:47they act as his intermediaries as his

0:59:50planners as his you know they're there

0:59:54more than assistance you know they're

0:59:56like executive assistants but like there

0:59:58are four of them and they interact with

0:59:59one

0:59:59one

1:00:00another seamlessly like it's a culture

1:00:02night at hand and it's very captivating

1:00:09and been like why and you know when they

1:00:11kind of a flirt with him and he flirts

1:00:13with them like it's a their interactions

1:00:16are very flirty and it and it's exactly

1:00:20the way that people on the jonathan

1:00:23coulton cruise or people at Comicon

1:00:25interact with one another

1:00:27you know I've seen it before I've seen

1:00:29this culture before where it's there's a

1:00:32lot of flirtation there's a lot of

1:00:34sexual energy combination like

1:00:37confidence and lightness sometimes you

1:00:39know what i mean but isn't it kind of

1:00:40like oh I'm I don't know what I'm doing

1:00:42I'm a flighty idiot but now like the

1:00:45smart people but we're very confident

1:00:46and as you like to say like aren't

1:00:48asking for your approval about how this

1:00:50is going exactly and I think if you if

1:00:52you got into a political conversation

1:00:54with anyone of them their politics would

1:00:56be absolutely dead on you know what I

1:00:58mean like there there's no it isn't a it

1:01:02isn't a a patriarchal cult-like all

1:01:05these women are fully empowered and yet

1:01:08they are play-acting a kind of sexuality

1:01:13and george RR martin is the is the Papa

1:01:16figure and everybody's very comfortable

1:01:19with that they're very comfortable with

1:01:21with I mean you know this is a guy who

1:01:24in the early seventies when liberated

1:01:26the women sauna can't forget that you

1:01:28know and and when I think about and a

1:01:30husband and I had a long conversation

1:01:31about this where we were both like you

1:01:34know there were the nerve they were the

1:01:35cool kids over here having sex with each

1:01:37other and wearing polo shirts with the

1:01:39collars up and going to beer parties and

1:01:42then they're they're nerds over here

1:01:43having sex with each other and go into

1:01:44beer parties and wearing their velvet

1:01:47collars popped or whatever and how the

1:01:51fuck did we end up being like right in

1:01:54between in the in the narrowband

1:01:57pinheiro cultural band of kids that just

1:01:59weren't having sex with each other you

1:02:02know we were sitting there silently

1:02:03judging both cultures and in fact uh

1:02:08sleeping the district slept alone every

1:02:11single night

1:02:13it's so I'd love John's describe it

1:02:16might have been in it when the husband

1:02:18interview Martin was a pretty

1:02:21interesting interview but point John

1:02:23Hodgman was describing the way that he

1:02:25dressed when he was in high school here

1:02:27to talk about this like kind of a doctor

1:02:29who thing going on he carried a

1:02:31briefcase he had a ponytail yeah yeah he

1:02:34was you know he was working working a

1:02:37lot of different angles and figure out

1:02:38which one was going to be coming

1:02:39together like a lot of people cobbling

1:02:41together your own idea of what cool was

1:02:43with without you know much outside

1:02:45influenced this dear you want another

1:02:48yeah I i understood that uh I my mom

1:02:53would not buy me an izod shirt because

1:02:56they were $85 or something like that at

1:02:59a time when you could get a shirt with a

1:03:00little fire breathing dragon on it from

1:03:02sears for fourteen dollars right and uh

1:03:06I remember going to the fabric store

1:03:08with her one day when I was in ninth

1:03:13grade or something like that which is

1:03:14already like you're going to the fabric

1:03:15store with your mom in ninth grade loser

1:03:19and I'm walking through the fabric store

1:03:21and there's a little embroidered

1:03:23alligator do but she's he's like he's a

1:03:29happy alligator this island clearly not

1:03:33the look at southgate he's about twice

1:03:35as big as the cost allegorical and he's

1:03:37like looking at the least looking at the

1:03:39viewer and maybe even is giving a

1:03:42thumbs-up and I said you know what

1:03:48that's my alligator and i bought it and

1:03:51I had it sewn on

1:03:53[Music]

1:03:55I had it sewn on actually my Levi's

1:03:57jacket and then like smiling alligator

1:04:03was my little motif and and I I i might

1:04:08even had it i bought a second one and

1:04:10had its own my ski sweater you know like

1:04:12I was I like Laverne with al

1:04:15yeah except there's a smiling alligator

1:04:17pears up and I was like I firmly

1:04:20believed that I would be respected and

1:04:23loved for my hilarious

1:04:26outsider take on being an insider and we

1:04:31will be constant version who made I was

1:04:33just reviled I was reviled by everyone

1:04:37no one liked it no one thought it was

1:04:40good you know and I was so proud like

1:04:42you know smart my smile an alligator

1:04:45check me out

1:04:46I you know I get it right no wrong

1:04:51although you know maybe yes maybe if I

1:04:53just stuck around in my smile an

1:04:55alligator 10 long enough

1:04:58good now you know I'd now be at the at

1:05:02the center of some you know some advil

1:05:06burlesque culture think of all the songs

1:05:08you can deliver haha

1:05:14[Music]