Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 98: "A Mastiff of Spinach"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00hello hey John I Merlin how's it going

0:00:12oh it's so early yeah it's really early

0:00:17it's early i I've never seen you use

0:00:21your phone so early

0:00:22I don't think well they say sick I i am

0:00:28sick

0:00:29god I have a kind of sickness that is

0:00:33that is a drug sickness who i am on my

0:00:41third day of caffeine withdrawal

0:00:45oh my god and hear the real girl and I

0:00:51oh no i woke up at seven in the morning

0:00:55with shippers and I feel like I was in a

0:00:59car wreck

0:01:00I feel like I feel like I rolled a car

0:01:02that's at every every muscle and joint

0:01:06in my body

0:01:07it's like really really protesting oh my

0:01:11goodness this is you sure you're up for

0:01:14this

0:01:15no yeah my god you know I like to I like

0:01:18to get into the center of the pain

0:01:20explore all I am I am the I'm the the

0:01:24seven blind men describing an elephant

0:01:26and pain

0:01:30Wow uh so when was the last time you

0:01:39quit caffeine just cold turkey

0:01:42well um my gosh i have i've tried to cut

0:01:48down but net I it's been awhile since I

0:01:51just said I'm not going to have any

0:01:53caffeine at all this morning

0:01:57yeah and I its

0:01:59I've done in the past and its really

0:02:03hard and a little crazy

0:02:06[Music]

0:02:07are you feeling any psychological

0:02:08effects oh yes oh very irritated i am

0:02:15very irritated

0:02:17it's the thing is it's a i like it so

0:02:20well documented i guess but there are

0:02:24all kinds of effects you know it's gonna

0:02:27be with caffeine to begin with even on

0:02:29the best day is a balance even when you

0:02:31go pro still got you have good days and

0:02:33bad days and what's what's funny to me

0:02:36about caffeine is the like the effects

0:02:39of having too much coffee can be kind of

0:02:42similar to the effects of having no

0:02:44coffee but minus the energy like

0:02:47irritability little bit little bit of a

0:02:50headache

0:02:51yeah yeah yeah well let me bit you know

0:02:56I'm a caffeine ranger and I i use

0:02:59caffeine to explore all the universes

0:03:02and I i have quit a few times over the

0:03:07years and I and I know what's in store

0:03:09you know when I say like okay like i've

0:03:12got i've been to the edge and I steps

0:03:15student look down and I need to cut it i

0:03:20need to cut it out and I and i know i'm

0:03:23looking forward to like a solid three

0:03:26days of gotten it out and each day has

0:03:30its phases and the you'd you would think

0:03:36that by the third day it would be

0:03:38tapering off but really the third days

0:03:39the is the toughest one for me and then

0:03:42on day four like you you you walk out

0:03:44into the clear like you're right you're

0:03:46out into the day again but but i don't

0:03:50know whether it's my age or whether i

0:03:52was using come i was using a well over

0:03:57the prescribed dosages of of Captain for

0:03:59a long time but I fucked really woke up

0:04:02this morning

0:04:03in a title match with with my nerve

0:04:08ending this but I'm laughing but I'm so

0:04:11sorry I I know what you're talking about

0:04:14I mean there's a reason that excedrin

0:04:15puts caffeine in with the aspirin in

0:04:19that that's what they recommend when you

0:04:20got a migraine because i think it fits

0:04:22your capillaries or whatever but it's it

0:04:24it definitely can help you get rid of a

0:04:26headache and if you don't have it as

0:04:28little fella just close right up

0:04:30yeah yeah whoo so can we explore this a

0:04:34little bit you pulled up your

0:04:35three-legged stool

0:04:37yeah absolutely you're sitting in the

0:04:38center of it all the lights are on

0:04:42oh how well so this caffeine withdrawal

0:04:49is a part it's a component of a larger

0:04:53project a larger three-day project which

0:04:56is that I am honored choose fast thing

0:05:05which i find ridiculous on its pace

0:05:07through the tickets have you been really

0:05:09Family Circle no wednesday was never

0:05:13about that even the limit is the lemon

0:05:14juice recoup alot i have no idea why I'm

0:05:17doing it

0:05:18what the point of it is but it was

0:05:21suggested to me and I said oh sure i can

0:05:24do a three day juice fast once i love

0:05:26juice unless I mean let's just let's

0:05:29start with an obvious one you you're

0:05:30working on your body you got some body

0:05:32work and and you enjoy a challenge

0:05:35that's right you're not against juice

0:05:38no I dived i was reading it i was

0:05:41reading Martha Stewart's living about

0:05:42all the healthy juices that you can make

0:05:45from your from your orchards and I i own

0:05:50a juicer because at one point of the

0:05:54long winters did did some some extensive

0:05:57touring with the band keen and they

0:05:59always had a juicer in there backstage

0:06:03area and we would get we would get off

0:06:05of these like long brutal drives across

0:06:09Europe and we would roll into these

0:06:11stadium shows and there would be this

0:06:13juicer

0:06:15waiting as soon as we got out of the van

0:06:16and we would make these complex chooses

0:06:19with ginger and lemon

0:06:21we just felt like superstars and so when

0:06:25I got done with that too i was like i'm

0:06:27gonna get a juicer that's how and that's

0:06:29how a man lives if you are if you're a

0:06:33real like operator if you're a guy that

0:06:37is that knows how to tie a tie you

0:06:39should have a juicer at your house and

0:06:40make you feel vital it just fills you

0:06:42with nutrients it goes you with

0:06:44nutrients well or it fills you with

0:06:46sugar water I mean I what I can't figure

0:06:48how about juices like so I'm making

0:06:51these juices and they are very

0:06:53complicated i went to the store I bought

0:06:55all this spinach and kale and and and

0:06:59carrots and move ginger and you know

0:07:03garlic and basil and all this stuff and

0:07:06beets beet green definitely miss the

0:07:09coffee at all that sounds wonderful

0:07:11well and I'm so I'm throwing it all

0:07:13looks legit she could pick up the day at

0:07:16we kick off the day with some hot lemon

0:07:18water

0:07:19hmm now that the pipes movement m and

0:07:25I'm better but I'm throwing this stuff

0:07:27into the juicer i'm watching all the

0:07:29actual food just get shunted off into

0:07:33the garbage bag and what's left is this

0:07:37concentrated like purple sugar water

0:07:40basically and I it's like the only bill

0:07:43it's like build you put it i mean if you

0:07:45want to make spinach juice it takes an

0:07:47extraordinary amount of spinach to make

0:07:50a tiny little you know you know when you

0:07:51cook spinach it just all kind of

0:07:52disappears but when you don't use it

0:07:54I mean that doesn't it take like what

0:07:55like a whole giant basket to make like a

0:07:57half a cup

0:07:58yeah I put in the equivalent of what of

0:08:00a mastiff into the juicers like a

0:08:04mastiff of it a basket of spinach and

0:08:09and yeah it produces like 22 ounces of

0:08:11wheatgrass juice that's like six bucks

0:08:15and I go okay i mean i guess that I'm

0:08:18getting some but but but i'm really not

0:08:21getting much out of it i mean it's i'm

0:08:24probably it's probably what 600 calories

0:08:27a day of of juice just because i think

0:08:31part of the part of the juice fast part

0:08:34of why it works is that it's so fucking

0:08:36complicated to make the juice and clean

0:08:38the juicer you don't want to do it more

0:08:41than a couple of times a day and so

0:08:44you're basically just you're just

0:08:45starving yourself and taking some sugar

0:08:47water in the interim

0:08:49you're not gonna believe the timing on

0:08:50this here you're not going to believe

0:08:52how simpatico it makes me because you

0:08:55need you texted me this morning and I

0:08:56was like obviously someone attacks on

0:08:58two counts because he's using his phone

0:09:00at something like eight in the morning

0:09:01and i was i was sleeping in a little bit

0:09:04and i have recently been awakened by a

0:09:07horrific almost medieval grinding sound

0:09:10coming from our kitchen

0:09:11oh because my my family had decided to

0:09:14make some juices this morning why it's

0:09:16real real loud isn't always very loud

0:09:19that machine is a it's a plant killer it

0:09:22is it takes them right out

0:09:23it's phyto killer int a and anyway the

0:09:26point being that then my the the 12

0:09:29punch was then my daughter came in with

0:09:31a small glass of like a caramel colored

0:09:37liquid and she goes drink this and I was

0:09:40like I heard the noise i'm not thinking

0:09:42that but just like no drink it it's

0:09:44really good and had a little her other

0:09:4614 little straws in it and it was so

0:09:51gross

0:09:52it was it was well i think it was

0:09:53primary was there are some spinach and

0:09:55there was some carrots and but it really

0:09:59really tasted like celery

0:10:01oh that's right they say celery is the

0:10:03juice ruin our oh is that right that's

0:10:05good to hack yeah you put any put celery

0:10:08of any juice and it just ruins because

0:10:09it makes it taste like somewhere like

0:10:11cilantro

0:10:12right exactly yes so I'm feeling it for

0:10:15you I I and I said really i said Elinor

0:10:18that's terrible that's an awful thing to

0:10:20put in my mouth while still laying in

0:10:21bed until spilled on the bed background

0:10:23but and so so what I mean okay seriously

0:10:29though what what led you did you just

0:10:32decide it was just a fun project or you

0:10:34said yeah yeah just my project

0:10:36yeah there's no that you know I the the

0:10:38wall when I think back to the the time

0:10:41that i decided i was going to stop

0:10:43eating wheat and sugar

0:10:44I honestly even a day later could not

0:10:47remember what I was what was motivating

0:10:50me you know like I don't remember the

0:10:53idea that came into my head and I

0:10:54usually remember my motivations but

0:10:58looking back I was like I don't remember

0:11:00why i decided to do this what I'm what

0:11:02is going on with me and it's the same

0:11:04with this juice fast i cannot i cannot

0:11:07tell you how the idea got lodged in my

0:11:08brain I think I read something on and on

0:11:12an airplane

0:11:14I think it was a date with something so

0:11:16many terrible projects start reading by

0:11:18running on an airplane i think i was

0:11:20reading at the in-flight magazine and

0:11:23then i was reading and then there was

0:11:26something snarky in The New Yorker and

0:11:29it just got this idea going like juices

0:11:32huh juices maybe New York magazine had

0:11:35an article about a guy who was running a

0:11:38gym that also was a juicer and it just

0:11:41got in there just the worm got in there

0:11:44and all of a sudden Here I am three days

0:11:47into a juice fast and everything every

0:11:50joint in my body is aching and what I

0:11:53want is I mean name of food I wanted

0:11:57yeah but what I have available to me is

0:12:00like beaches basically it seems like one

0:12:04of those things that they would do like

0:12:05you know i don't know like in the maze

0:12:08in Ireland like this some kind of a

0:12:09prison thing like when they give you the

0:12:11the punishment loaf like they were put

0:12:13on a juice diet because i was just i

0:12:15would have to be honest with you first

0:12:16launch want to applaud you and if this

0:12:18sounds like it could be really good for

0:12:19you but I would find it so hard to look

0:12:22forward to anything in life if I knew it

0:12:24was going to be a day filled with juice

0:12:26well this is the thing when you when you

0:12:28when you stop eating food you realize

0:12:30how many of your projects how many of

0:12:33the reasons that you're going out how

0:12:35many

0:12:35you have the how many come to things

0:12:37that the like pylons that demarcate the

0:12:41obstacle course of your day are just

0:12:43food it's like what do you want to do I

0:12:46don't know what's going downtown well

0:12:47what should we do

0:12:48well let's go to that restaurant well

0:12:50we're not eating food we're eating i'm

0:12:52drinking juice right now I'm sorry to

0:12:54say oh well we could go to that smoothie

0:12:57place

0:12:58yeah but those are smoothies they're not

0:13:01juice really like already i'm already

0:13:04are the most boring person alive i

0:13:06mislike it was bad enough when you when

0:13:07he couldn't have french fries or

0:13:09something but now I mean it's I was

0:13:12gonna say it's like being on a salad

0:13:13dressing diet but it's not it's not even

0:13:15it's not even I I could see myself

0:13:17waking up in the morning go I you know

0:13:18nice cup of like a couple shots of

0:13:20Thousand Island could get me going

0:13:22yeah but it's all it's a lot of work

0:13:24it'sit's it's pretty costly too i think

0:13:26it is as well so I was so the other

0:13:29night

0:13:2922 days into my juice fast the

0:13:32presidents of the united states of

0:13:34america played their annual president's

0:13:36day concert here in Seattle and I got up

0:13:39with them and sang sang a song is on

0:13:42their new record with them and so I got

0:13:44up and sang songs and then they then

0:13:47they launched into new girl

0:13:49well so what we get done singing the

0:13:52song like yeah that was great and then

0:13:54they just like launched into new girl

0:13:56and they're only go go do it do it sing

0:13:58it sing it and so we saying new girl in

0:14:03front of their sold-out crowd which was

0:14:04super fun and then we get off the stage

0:14:09we're hanging out backstage and I'm like

0:14:11oh man I thought that was really amazing

0:14:13but I'm a little bit freaked out a

0:14:16little bit tweaking right now because

0:14:18i'm i'm on a juice fast when you think

0:14:20of that guy's and Chris blue as a very

0:14:26complicated theory about food and he was

0:14:29like well you know actually juices

0:14:31garbage food because it was you know but

0:14:34most of those most of those foods were

0:14:37developed by

0:14:40by human intervention and we've we've

0:14:43robbed all of our foods of their

0:14:45nutrients over the course of the

0:14:48millennium is he a million conspiracy

0:14:50theorist started this he tried to he

0:14:52he's a knowledgeable eating well guy I

0:14:54chris is both things he is extremely

0:14:57knowledgeable and you know and also like

0:15:00he goes on it goes on intellectual

0:15:05journeys where he discovers a new thing

0:15:07and then it becomes kind of like it's

0:15:10tense central to his his way of thinking

0:15:14for example again like nutrition buff

0:15:16yeah he ratings read some interesting

0:15:18books and now he's really interested in

0:15:20in the topic but then Jason

0:15:22fence-sitting are your life good friend

0:15:24Jason been sitting on the couch says

0:15:25yeah well you know i i've done a

0:15:29seven-day Master Cleanse which is that a

0:15:35pooping 17 days of lemon and cayenne

0:15:40pepper but i think it's just lemon and

0:15:43and molasses maybe in the hot water or

0:15:48not no he said not hot water room

0:15:50temperature

0:15:50I'm like seven days of and he's like oh

0:15:53yeah yeah by the fourth day you're

0:15:55really you're here really see and you're

0:15:59seeing dragons you know and you're and

0:16:02yeah he you know he talked about the

0:16:04poop for a little while and I i was i

0:16:08mean certainly I was impressed that my

0:16:10three day juice fast got one up so hard

0:16:13i was i was there was the first time

0:16:15i've even gone out in public and I

0:16:17already just got Smackdown like that's

0:16:19like he didn't even eating and get the

0:16:21high five for electronic bean and cheese

0:16:23fast 03 juice fast that's cute you

0:16:26should try seven-day Master Cleanse we

0:16:27just drink lemon water so it was a it

0:16:32was a little bit like I went home tail

0:16:34between my legs but I stuck with my

0:16:36juice fast I didn't go home and start

0:16:37drinking lemon water molasses and I

0:16:39didn't have a hamburger either so here

0:16:43it is day three and I've got this class

0:16:44here that is full of juice and it's

0:16:48it's really it's it's bright red is the

0:16:50color of cows blood

0:16:52mm it's like I'm drinking a glass of

0:16:54cows blood

0:16:55well you know I think about a nutty

0:16:59system is that sometimes he just kind of

0:17:01stick with the nutty system

0:17:03yes thank you hello that's it's not you

0:17:05know i mean the thing is if you

0:17:07overthink it i mean with any kind of

0:17:08diet or anything like that i think that

0:17:10the way two if by succeed we mean make

0:17:13it through the amount of time that we

0:17:15say we're going to do it and hopefully

0:17:16that same I mean you're gonna do this

0:17:17for months probably but if you said you

0:17:19introduced 45 days seven days something

0:17:21like that then I think you gotta it

0:17:23helps me anyway to get to a place where

0:17:25I'm not thinking about it too much

0:17:27I'm not you know I'm doing what I gotta

0:17:28do but to make it sustainable even for

0:17:31more than two or three days even more

0:17:32than a day we have to get to someplace

0:17:34where it's just kind of routine and

0:17:36you're like well this thing I'm doing I

0:17:37don't know what makes sense you know

0:17:39Jason Finn has given me some things to

0:17:40think about but i'm going to just stick

0:17:42with this and do this thing and then

0:17:43maybe not maybe another time i'll do the

0:17:45lemon diet

0:17:46well that's exactly right and what's

0:17:47amazing about this is that the side

0:17:50effects that usually when I quit

0:17:51caffeine it is that I get super sick

0:17:54like that's how I quit really honestly

0:17:56that's your body responds to a lot of

0:17:58things that's how I quit drinking and

0:17:59drugs

0:18:00it's how I quit smoking cigarettes it's

0:18:03how I like and most my relationships I

0:18:05get really sick and I just go off into a

0:18:08corner to die and then when I when I

0:18:11come back I'm phoenix rising from the

0:18:13ashes

0:18:14I was going to say it's like your body

0:18:16has to burn itself down so it can rise

0:18:17from its own ashes

0:18:18that's right and so what this what's

0:18:20happening right now is this this

0:18:22caffeine withdrawal is just a byproduct

0:18:26of it but but honestly the first thing I

0:18:29thought about when somebody said three

0:18:31day juice fast I was like ooh that would

0:18:33be a tough caffeine burn you mean

0:18:36whatever else was going on no matter how

0:18:38hungry where he your your knees would

0:18:41hurt your fingernails would hurt but

0:18:45when it's over then I'm then I have

0:18:47accomplished this what is actually a

0:18:49pretty daunting task which is this

0:18:51caffeine withdrawal and then I'm gonna

0:18:53like try and stay off of the coffee

0:18:56which is actually a better way to live

0:18:57it really is what I'm not when I don't

0:18:59drink the coffee i am you know you're

0:19:03you're living in the light so so if

0:19:05you're going to go through all this i

0:19:06just don't want to repeat what you're

0:19:07saying but just so I understand you're

0:19:09gonna try and stick with us for a while

0:19:10the juice thing is a temporary thing

0:19:12you'll enjoy you will enjoy your many

0:19:14blood-red juices for a while to get

0:19:16through it but you're thinking you'll

0:19:18probably having gone through this dark

0:19:20night of the soul with coffee you're

0:19:22going to try and just stay off it after

0:19:23this

0:19:24yeah i think so for a while at the right

0:19:26time yeah because I don't like

0:19:33dependency it's the it's the overarching

0:19:38theme of my life I cannot abide

0:19:41dependence and I am dependent on

0:19:46caffeine what makes me uncomfortable

0:19:51I think arguably I don't know in my

0:19:54cultures I think that like historically

0:19:57like smoking cigarettes and drinking

0:19:59coffee

0:20:00it's more than something that everybody

0:20:02does it's kind of like almost like a

0:20:04default like you described with food

0:20:06like what you want to do well let's just

0:20:08meet its kind of like just the thing

0:20:10that you do and if you don't know what

0:20:11to do you have a cup of coffee or smoke

0:20:13cigarette and you don't notice how often

0:20:16that becomes the default not trying to

0:20:18say one way or another good bad or

0:20:19otherwise but you know with coffee you

0:20:21don't notice it

0:20:23I mean once it's gone you really notice

0:20:24how often you had that little hankering

0:20:27and then just knowing you can't have it

0:20:29makes it's so much worse and weird to

0:20:32wear if I'm trying to stop something

0:20:33like long lines of a coffee which I'll

0:20:35do sometimes you're trying to cut down

0:20:37but now but especially from stopping

0:20:39I'll i will want coffee

0:20:41more than anything in the world and i

0:20:43would even want coffee before I would

0:20:45want coffee

0:20:46uh-huh like the idea of waking up and

0:20:48going like oh this is my first day

0:20:50without coffee

0:20:50that's all I'm gonna think about right

0:20:52you know or I remember especially when I

0:20:55was doing the you know the Atkins diet

0:20:56like I never wanted french fries so much

0:20:59in my entire life

0:21:00[Music]

0:21:02I go like a go-to place and I get this

0:21:04giant and really honestly

0:21:06physiologically completely satisfying

0:21:08like big bacon burger with no bun with

0:21:11lettuce

0:21:11yeah i mean that's all the food a person

0:21:13needs throughout its like you'll be

0:21:15talking about like you how can have a

0:21:16state without noodles it just doesn't

0:21:17make sense

0:21:18like why would you not have noodles with

0:21:20your steak is just a thing you should do

0:21:21is a gentleman but like and when you

0:21:23know you can't have that it's it's so

0:21:25strange how your brain at least my brain

0:21:28can cook up this this

0:21:30oh I guess anxiety or or kind of like

0:21:33unease about about the possibility that

0:21:35i can't have that it makes me feel very

0:21:37scared

0:21:38oh it's a profound anxiety and this is

0:21:40the this is the this is the number one

0:21:42mind game of quitting all drugs is that

0:21:46the it isn't really the physical

0:21:50addiction that defeats you it is them

0:21:53it's that anxiousness that comes into

0:21:56your mind that says I'm never going to

0:21:58have another french fry

0:21:59I can't live like this right like and

0:22:02what you do with your time right if you

0:22:03spend if you spend a third or half your

0:22:05day drinking and then you don't like how

0:22:07would you do to fill that time you just

0:22:09suddenly go and start volunteering I

0:22:11mean it's a lot of time to fill well I'm

0:22:14you and you can only I had a

0:22:15conversation last night with a guy

0:22:18the middle-aged guy let's say kinda like

0:22:21this one it's kind of like this

0:22:22conversation

0:22:24well I should preface this by saying

0:22:27that I went to see miley cyrus last

0:22:29night was she performing yes I want to

0:22:33see a Miley Cyrus concert last night at

0:22:35the tacoma dome because i got an email

0:22:40from a friend of mine who is working at

0:22:44a sort of a high level in her production

0:22:46and he said you'll never guess what i'm

0:22:49doing now I'm doing you know X for the

0:22:53production of this Miley Cyrus concert

0:22:55do you want to come and i said yes i

0:22:59will come and see this my Miley Cyrus

0:23:02concert because I think mainly because

0:23:08everything that I had everybody every

0:23:12little post-it note in my head that i

0:23:14had about my

0:23:15Cyrus was negative like I don't think I

0:23:19like Miley Cyrus is just as a thing i

0:23:22didn't like hannah montana didn't like

0:23:25that all you think it was catchy i don't

0:23:27well I didn't know anything about it but

0:23:28it's intense

0:23:30I just instinctively didn't like it

0:23:31because when i go into thrift stores i

0:23:33see these little plastic guitar that

0:23:35have hannah montana stickers on them and

0:23:38I go oh that's garbage and I don't think

0:23:40I liked Billy Ray Cyrus although i don't

0:23:42know what that sounds like either but I

0:23:44don't like what it represents

0:23:46even though i don't really know what it

0:23:47represents I just don't like it i didn't

0:23:50like it i didn't like his haircut I

0:23:51didn't like that brand of what i think

0:23:56is that brand of country music people

0:23:59get using that phrase boot scoot it made

0:24:00me uncomfortable

0:24:01I don't like that boot scoot I don't

0:24:02wanna hear that now and so Hannah

0:24:06Montana disney creation just kind of you

0:24:09know it's not like i hate it i just

0:24:11don't like it I don't know anything

0:24:12about it I don't like it I'm going to

0:24:14say about the evidence mounts that like

0:24:16I'm not seeking out information about

0:24:18this enterprise but every new as you say

0:24:21post-it note of information about this

0:24:23is not making me feel positive about

0:24:25this and that accumulates right it does

0:24:27it accumulates and then then Oh Miley

0:24:30Cyrus is reinventing herself now she's a

0:24:32bad girl well I don't like that i don't

0:24:34like that the disney girl is now

0:24:36reinventing herself as a bad girl i just

0:24:38dont thats I don't care about it but I

0:24:40don't I don't

0:24:41it is don't like it and then that

0:24:43performance where she twerked at the

0:24:46finest where she she did a little dance

0:24:49with the finger

0:24:50yeah from finger and stuff yeah right at

0:24:54and she was with the blurred lines guy

0:24:57yes I didn't even see it i just saw it

0:25:01talked about in the in the the

0:25:04chattering culture it was very

0:25:06uncomfortable watch but I didn't like it

0:25:09i didn't like the conversation about it

0:25:11i didn't like the pictures that I saw of

0:25:13it it made me uncomfortable so going

0:25:18into all of that this friend of mine is

0:25:22like you're not going to believe what

0:25:23I'm doing right now i'm working on the

0:25:25miley cyrus tour

0:25:27and i said i will go to this and he said

0:25:31great you got two passes see you at the

0:25:33show and so I spent the afternoon trying

0:25:38to get somebody to go with me to the

0:25:40show and I asked at a handful of friends

0:25:45that are usually game if I want to go

0:25:49see Michael Schenker or if I want to go

0:25:51see a monster truck rally or if I want

0:25:54to go to it you know a motocross race

0:25:57and all of my like go to show buddies

0:26:03were like what no way like it'll be fun

0:26:07it'll be funny we'll go see my Miley

0:26:09Cyrus will be like hilarious and they

0:26:11were like no action absolutely not

0:26:13and there was a different kind of

0:26:15pushback like no I draw the line here

0:26:18there's nothing funny about this and it

0:26:23was this like I can go to a Klan rally

0:26:25or something yeah right like if there

0:26:27was an end and an increased my

0:26:29perception that there was this negative

0:26:33this kind of knee-jerk negative feeling

0:26:38about her this take on her that

0:26:41everybody has that increased my desire

0:26:46to go so that if it was a stormy night

0:26:48last night there was a there were a lot

0:26:50of reasons why it's a you know 45 miles

0:26:54to tacoma lot of reasons why i normally

0:26:56would have said i'm not sure i'm just

0:26:58not going to do this but I was like no

0:27:00you know what I'm going to go see this

0:27:01Miley Cyrus concert because now i'm

0:27:05suspicious i'm suspicious of my own bias

0:27:09against this person because I'm seeing

0:27:12it reflected in all these other people

0:27:13and I'm and I realizing like I don't

0:27:16know anything about miley cyrus why do I

0:27:19feel so strongly that this that this

0:27:22girl who stick your tongue out is like

0:27:24this thing then isn't just bad it's like

0:27:27it's like a despicable and cultural

0:27:32Anathem yeah right so I get in my car

0:27:35and I Drive down there and I and I

0:27:37parking I'm I'm

0:27:39I'm walking to the show and it's just

0:27:40sheets of rain and all around me on the

0:27:43streets are girls dressed very

0:27:50provocatively and they are all I mean I

0:27:56was expecting it to be a bunch of

0:27:57ten-year-olds and you know like hannah

0:27:59montana ten-year-old type of thing and

0:28:02and some and some preteens or whatever

0:28:04but everybody is 20

0:28:08everywhere I look everyone is 20 years

0:28:10old and they're all dressed like ready

0:28:15sexy but but it's a sister rainstorm a

0:28:21cold rain storm so there's a lot of

0:28:25shrieking and soar high heel running to

0:28:28get to the venue everybody's covering

0:28:30their hair with their plastic bags and

0:28:34I'm walking up i'm in my life I'm well

0:28:37protected in my raincoat and dad hat

0:28:40I'm like I am really I'm really wrong

0:28:45here like this is going to be weird and

0:28:49wrong but i did I made no attempt to

0:28:52look like Claire that your buyers is

0:28:56myself

0:28:57ok by myself actually I was carrying a

0:29:00walking stick that some bells on

0:29:04at first I was worried about that yet in

0:29:09the Hat notice that a jolly little

0:29:12pockets too many Reynolds jingle stick

0:29:15at me and said ah

0:29:18so i get to the venue and I walk in just

0:29:24as she takes the stage and there's a

0:29:28giant you know 10-story tall picture of

0:29:31miley cyrus and the mouth opens on the

0:29:35picture somehow like the the jaw opens

0:29:38in a kind of almost Monty Python right

0:29:42way and a giant tongue unfurls out of

0:29:47the mouth and reveals itself to be a

0:29:50slide and then miley cyrus appears in

0:29:54her own mouth waves to the crowd and

0:29:59then slides down her own giant tongue up

0:30:02to the stage and I'm I'm standing I died

0:30:07i'm standing in a wet raincoat watching

0:30:10this and I'm thinking oh ok

0:30:14what the fuck is this like that is a

0:30:17that's kind of a bad trip almost like

0:30:20that's a that's a heavy that's a heavy

0:30:22trip if I were if this were 20 years ago

0:30:26and and i took my usual regimen of

0:30:31pre-concert hallucinogens I would be

0:30:35really freaking out right now that's a

0:30:38heavy image a lot a lot for the mind to

0:30:42to take in and she starts walking around

0:30:44the stage and I go looking for my

0:30:45looking for my seat and I realize I'm in

0:30:49a stadium and both the average age and

0:30:53the mean age is 24

0:30:55there's no variation there's no one I

0:30:59mean that i can see no one that is 30

0:31:03and no one that is 15

0:31:06it's like I've never I i can't i can't

0:31:09think of a time that I've ever been in a

0:31:11room with with the eight to ten thousand

0:31:16twenty year old girls

0:31:19and they are uh you know really like

0:31:24digging the show and like i said so i

0:31:27get to my seat and it turns out I'm i

0:31:29have a front-row seat you have reserved

0:31:33seating

0:31:34well yeah the myoga she compu a really

0:31:36good see ya my friends just like you

0:31:38here here's your tickets and it's like

0:31:40I'm front row of the of the seating give

0:31:43a beard right now I do have a beer that

0:31:45and i have sort of went uncut hair i was

0:31:51wearing my kim jong ill glasses so I my

0:31:55you know by like north korean

0:31:57functionary classes and then every other

0:32:00aspect of my attire was like basically

0:32:04stern dad they may be checked my jingle

0:32:09stick and i watch this entire show in

0:32:16other amazement at how I mean because my

0:32:21my first instinct every new thing that

0:32:24came out every new set piece every like

0:32:27thing she was pushing my first instinct

0:32:30was oh my god no

0:32:34and then in the course of the tune it

0:32:38was revealed that in fact Miley Cyrus is

0:32:43completely in control of the of every

0:32:46aspect of her presentation in her career

0:32:49she is like overwhelmingly positive

0:32:55everybody in the place is having an

0:32:57overwhelmingly positive time and the the

0:33:02takeaway from the show was like this was

0:33:05the most like in culturally interesting

0:33:11and and dare I say it empowering kind of

0:33:16show of its type that I could ever

0:33:22remember seeing I don't think there was

0:33:23ever a Madonna concert that was that was

0:33:25this casually empowering you know it was

0:33:30extraordinary

0:33:31and I came out of there just I mean

0:33:33really like now not just with the whole

0:33:36new impression of what Miley Cyrus is

0:33:38and represents but like a real push back

0:33:43on my own cultural instincts now through

0:33:48like two and i think i feel i feel like

0:33:51the entire culture is the kind of lined

0:33:53up to dismiss her and as a result she

0:33:57has this she has this real credibility

0:34:01with 20 year old girls who she is a 20

0:34:06year old girl and she has a she has a

0:34:10direct line to them and is talking to

0:34:13them directly and they are responding to

0:34:16her directly and there's no no one else

0:34:19is allowed in almost you know her show

0:34:22is too dirty for teens so like the katy

0:34:27perry show make sure not to be too scary

0:34:32because she's trying to get all the

0:34:33tenants it's very--it's saucy but it

0:34:36doesn't inhabit that level of like back

0:34:39in aliens spectacle right exact sounds

0:34:42it sounds like it like that like a

0:34:43spectacle

0:34:44it's an absolute spectacle and like

0:34:46there are there are just way more

0:34:48vaginas in miley cyrus show then you are

0:34:52going to see in a normal presentation

0:34:56but they but it's not as that's like

0:35:00elements of set design or just yeah yeah

0:35:03it's just like I mean the beastie boys

0:35:05come out with the giant set of

0:35:06inflatable boobs or Mick Jagger's

0:35:09bouncing around on a huge blow-up

0:35:11microphone and Miley Cyrus effectively

0:35:14has no there are a lot of blow up

0:35:17animals in her show and some of them are

0:35:21I mean some of the visuals were fully

0:35:24into the realm of this is that this is

0:35:29trippy trippy shit that is I could I

0:35:35kept coming back to like if I had taken

0:35:37some mushrooms before the show I would

0:35:39be weeping

0:35:40[Music]

0:35:41but left process with no coffee well a

0:35:44lot of processes with that with no copy

0:35:46and also this like cultural mash of

0:35:50japanese anime punk rock metal rap a

0:35:56country and YouTube culture photoshop

0:36:03little gerbil they're less kind of sex

0:36:06worker stuff to the right hold total

0:36:08pole-dancing seen all the time like

0:36:12every every physical gesture is derived

0:36:16either from pole dancing working or uh I

0:36:21mean but like a 21 year olds sense of

0:36:25what sex is

0:36:26and I mean I would have walked into that

0:36:27is not a modern 21 year olds idea right

0:36:30if you if you would put a microphone in

0:36:32front of me as I'm walking in there been

0:36:34a reporter that was like you there with

0:36:36the jingle stick c'mere

0:36:38what are you going into the miley cyrus

0:36:40show you know what do you think she's

0:36:41sexy

0:36:42I would have said the 21 year old girl

0:36:45is not sexy she's skinny and she doesn't

0:36:48know like what you don't know how to

0:36:49have sex

0:36:50she's a she's a she's a child but coming

0:36:54out of that show i'm like 'oh 21 year

0:36:56olds know how to have sex what was I

0:36:58thinking

0:36:5821 year olds I mean they don't uh maybe

0:37:04they aren't like all experts at it but

0:37:06they're not she's not a child she's 21

0:37:09you know she's she is a lot older than

0:37:13me a pharaoh was when she married stank

0:37:16Sinatra so so yeah we're coming so

0:37:21coming away from but that but but but

0:37:23but my mind was trying to process this

0:37:26torrent of images that was a complete

0:37:33like well basically if you allow me a

0:37:37fruit juice of all of basically

0:37:42everything the culture has produced you

0:37:45know African drumming uh-uh-uh

0:37:50enough videos when do Williams uh you

0:37:54know like and it's all happening like

0:37:56boom boom boom and I don't think

0:38:00everybody in the audience knows what

0:38:03every references to but in a way they do

0:38:07in a way they're much more attuned to

0:38:10this this tour this torrent of micro

0:38:14image and you anymore more comfortable

0:38:16with that like a mirage of iconography

0:38:18knowing that is iconography yeah very

0:38:20comfortable with it not you know they

0:38:23are not sitting there like borderline

0:38:25grand mal seizure like like I was but

0:38:29also i don't and this is maybe part part

0:38:32of what's interesting about it to me

0:38:34like they are trying to parse every

0:38:35image and part of what is making it

0:38:38overwhelming to me as I'm like whoa and

0:38:41I'm like I'm looking at every image and

0:38:43I'm I'm its igniting this part of my

0:38:46brain that has a cultural association

0:38:47with it so I'm like what

0:38:49oh hey what was that doing there were

0:38:51Dirk and they're not doing that they're

0:38:55just taking it in as a from a place of

0:39:01like people pure sensation and and and

0:39:03honestly unmitigated joy so the whole

0:39:10the whole event was like a completely on

0:39:16ironic no irony about it at all

0:39:19there was no cynicism to it and this is

0:39:25the net result was total positivity and

0:39:29looking around the room at the eight to

0:39:32ten thousand twenty year old girls all

0:39:34dressed like sex workers you realize

0:39:40that they are not dressing like that for

0:39:42the male gaze because there are no men

0:39:45here who they're dressing like this for

0:39:48one another for their own pleasure and

0:39:53in homage to Miley and she's dressing

0:39:58like that for them

0:40:00and and the the other amazing thing was

0:40:04not a single person ever looked at me

0:40:06like I was a creep like every single

0:40:09person every single girl that made eye

0:40:11contact with me which was hundreds and

0:40:14hundreds of them they were they all

0:40:17smiled and we're like high or excuse me

0:40:20or you know like everyone was was polite

0:40:22and I and I'd I never for a moment had

0:40:26that feeling of like oh my god what are

0:40:28you doing here like that that was absent

0:40:32from the from the place

0:40:35no booze no like no Satan worship I mean

0:40:41it was I mean unless it's a very complex

0:40:44and subtle Satan worship that that

0:40:47everybody has read everybody read a

0:40:49pamphlet before they went in explaining

0:40:52that this was all in service of Satan

0:40:53but I I didn't see it i saw just to

0:40:58prove you know kind of joy

0:40:59miley cyrus's joy of being 21 years old

0:41:01rich and able to just do whatever she

0:41:05wants i haven't been to many things like

0:41:09that in my life

0:41:10they were there are much clearer poles

0:41:13to almost everything that I've ever gone

0:41:16to that were about some kind of

0:41:17differentiation or you know it certainly

0:41:20punk rock shows but I'm maybe flaming

0:41:22lips i'm trying to think of you know

0:41:23like when they were first getting into

0:41:25their I'll the spectacles that they will

0:41:28put on a very positive and you know

0:41:30freak friendly kind of stuff but this a

0:41:33I I'm glad you went

0:41:35it sounds like this is a good experience

0:41:36for you it was i'm still I'm still

0:41:38chewing on it you know and I and I did

0:41:42not live tweet it as i was walking and I

0:41:45was like I'm gonna live-tweet the shit

0:41:46out of this Miley Cyrus concert it's

0:41:48gonna be really hilarious on Twitter and

0:41:52I got it and immediately I was like this

0:41:54is so over my head that up to live tweet

0:41:58it would be to do it and myself a

0:42:00disservice like I'm not going to be I'm

0:42:03not going to be out of this experience

0:42:04i'm going to just be rooted in this

0:42:08experience and try and like

0:42:13figure out where it's coming from

0:42:15because when I was that age when I was

0:42:17her age or her fans age I was at

0:42:20scorpions concepts and punk rock shows

0:42:24and we were all dressed for one another

0:42:28to in denim and leather and but the

0:42:34average eight there was no average age

0:42:36and scorpions concert it was me and you

0:42:38let us see burnouts in their fifties and

0:42:40you're stuck in that are way too young

0:42:42to be there

0:42:43sure it was mostly dudes or or almost

0:42:47entirely dudes but but i love the whole

0:42:51age range and what the Scorpions

0:42:54represented what their message was i

0:42:59mean i was i was forced to ask myself

0:43:00last night was the Scorpions message

0:43:03oh and they just essentially wanted to

0:43:06know if you're ready to rock and roll i

0:43:07think that's right yeah baby say we were

0:43:09we were ready I was ready i was ready to

0:43:12rock and roll look at me and I so you

0:43:17know I was going to shows all the time

0:43:18then and they were profoundly important

0:43:22to me and I'm not and and they were a

0:43:26lot less there was a lot less sensory

0:43:28experience that there was last night at

0:43:31the Miley Cyrus concert but that but

0:43:35then of course you know I'm reflecting

0:43:36like on the fact that my own daughter is

0:43:44not even a member of this generation at

0:43:46all these people

0:43:48miley cyrus is going to be a mature and

0:43:53legendary artist by the time my my

0:43:56daughter is going to her first concerts

0:43:58like Miley Cyrus will at that point b 25

0:44:01years into her career and so so this

0:44:06experience does not even give me a

0:44:08toehold on understanding what the

0:44:11culture is going to be like and and the

0:44:14degree to which I'm going to need to be

0:44:16at least capable of experiencing

0:44:19understanding the culture 15 years from

0:44:22now

0:44:24you're making me think of something that

0:44:28is probably useful for me to think about

0:44:29you know we talked a lot and use

0:44:31especially talked a lot about this whole

0:44:33the authenticity problem and how that

0:44:37you know we've talked about and plenty

0:44:39right i mean this whole thing of like

0:44:40especially in rock-and-roll there's

0:44:41always concern about you know who's

0:44:44truly authentic who has more

0:44:46authenticity you can you know display

0:44:48that I mean who's closer to the blues

0:44:50who's more rock and roll and it's funny

0:44:53because I'm oh this is kind of a big

0:44:56thought but you think about you know no

0:45:00excuse me think about what happened in

0:45:02like a post Dylan post Beatles era and

0:45:06even if you were not doing your own

0:45:08songs there was still a primacy to

0:45:11creator to like artists created rock and

0:45:14roll it was the idea that like I'm not

0:45:16up your mouth and something that some

0:45:17tin pan alley guy didn't less i'm doing

0:45:19that for some kind of ironic point like

0:45:21I'm here because I am the person who

0:45:23made this show on the person who made

0:45:25this song this is about my life and even

0:45:28if it's not really about my life it

0:45:29still is works in the service of a

0:45:31certain kind of authenticity then

0:45:33somebody's going straight back to Dillon

0:45:34i think that's that's been I think it's

0:45:36one because I'm trying to say is in

0:45:38brief is that one reason a lot of stuff

0:45:40like this is so confusing and weird to

0:45:43people like me and presumably you is it

0:45:45it's it's a this really is

0:45:46generationally one of the first really

0:45:49one of the first major generational

0:45:51changes in popular music in quite a

0:45:53while maybe even up through indie-rock

0:45:55any rock is still heavily even today

0:45:58still so heavily rooted in that

0:46:00singer-songwriter tradition absolutely

0:46:02in fact that I'm up here and I may be

0:46:03playing the drums on somebody's a

0:46:04motorcycle helmet but that's authentic

0:46:06because we made this mean you know i'm

0:46:08not going to put too fine a point on it

0:46:09but i don't think that the way that you

0:46:12and I have historically looked at the

0:46:13way that our generation looked at that I

0:46:15don't think that matters to people today

0:46:17and that's not a judgment at all it's

0:46:19just an observation

0:46:20I think this is this is a it's it really

0:46:24is its own thing she has put this team

0:46:25together that or somebody put a team

0:46:28together for her that is really

0:46:29brilliantly leveraging the way things

0:46:31have changed

0:46:32in music and culture so like you know

0:46:35we've talked so much before again about

0:46:37like you work you put all this money

0:46:38into making out and you talk about this

0:46:39on when you're on my curly show you put

0:46:41all this money into like making an album

0:46:43and put it out

0:46:44used to be you could you know if you're

0:46:45Steve Miller you could ride on that for

0:46:47a year to right or if you were you know

0:46:51the Eagles or anybody you can get four

0:46:53singles off an element or off it for a

0:46:55year or two like you put out two hours

0:46:56and 20 for two years

0:46:58yeah and now today like people want this

0:47:00constant dribble of culture that does

0:47:03not facilitated by putting a hundred

0:47:05thousand dollars into an album putting

0:47:06it out and then just sitting around

0:47:07waiting for the checks to arrive ok it's

0:47:09a big it's a big issue but like it seems

0:47:11like there are people today that are

0:47:12much more comfortable going like hey I'm

0:47:13putting out of a pop-culture product and

0:47:16that doesn't make me a worse person than

0:47:18you

0:47:18I I this is this is a job that I do and

0:47:20people love this and I'm going to

0:47:22narrowcast this to these 20 year old

0:47:23girls who love this and if you don't

0:47:25like it that's okay but that's not gonna

0:47:27make me do this differently and your

0:47:28concerns about my about my authenticity

0:47:30are going to are going to fall short of

0:47:32their target because that's not even

0:47:34what i'm trying to do i'm being me and

0:47:37and me is this team of people in

0:47:38production designers and songwriters and

0:47:40musicians and lighting people that make

0:47:42this kind of product that you know i'm

0:47:44not going to make a quality but you know

0:47:46what i mean i think that DVD see that

0:47:47difference like you know it when are you

0:47:50so much pushback on the punk-rock

0:47:51article you so much pushback on the

0:47:53whole I kind of authenticity thing like

0:47:55you know and you know all along we've

0:47:58all been trying to find the product that

0:48:01like meets our needs and it sounds like

0:48:04she's getting that two people here

0:48:06well what was the last stop sucking up

0:48:09to X no no that's that that's right in

0:48:12line with exactly like where my mind was

0:48:14going and where my mind is going trying

0:48:16to trying to process it for myself

0:48:19because also authenticity is a huge it

0:48:25is is is a huge and maybe the singular

0:48:28like cup criteria of hip-hop right like

0:48:35hip-hop's whole trip is is it real are

0:48:41you real

0:48:43and I mean I don't know enough about

0:48:45that culture to to critique it deeply

0:48:49but the the the the gangster and sort of

0:48:56authenticity trip that that is a heart

0:48:59like the heart the hardcore nature of

0:49:01this sure that scene has been you know

0:49:03caught up in for almost its entire life

0:49:07of me when you think about the original

0:49:08hip-hop it was so Mary it was so pretty

0:49:13like I was like party music party music

0:49:16right and it was it was only not mean it

0:49:20was only sort of run DMC is like tougher

0:49:24than leather vibe that started to

0:49:27establish that that eric b and rakim

0:49:31direction where it was like no no this

0:49:34is righteous and for a long time there

0:49:37were those two sides of hip-hop right

0:49:38the della soul over here that are

0:49:41intellectual at but also fun and then

0:49:44NWA just pushed it in well and Public

0:49:48Enemy really pushed it in this thread i

0:49:50mean like let's let's remember there was

0:49:52a time when there were articles about

0:49:54the feud between kool Moe Dee and MC

0:49:58hammer huh

0:49:59but I was more real who's more real I

0:50:01think I think history will record that

0:50:04in as much as that was a contest I guess

0:50:06kool Moe Dee one but who was more real

0:50:09than Hammer hammer was a ball boy for

0:50:12the Oakland a right

0:50:14like come on the right guy was like as

0:50:16real as they come it's just that he's

0:50:18wearing a Sinbad pants but you needed

0:50:21but in all this cases with hip-hopper

0:50:23anybody else but it is especially

0:50:24hip-hop not really with all alone like

0:50:26it's important that that that you that

0:50:28that that be authentic so that you can

0:50:30be authentic right you don't want to

0:50:32follow somebody who's like a big poser

0:50:34knows now there's a poser but last night

0:50:36at the show

0:50:37miley as part of the show hasn't as a

0:50:41there's a middle section where she goes

0:50:44out to a little stage that's way at the

0:50:47back of the arena so she's playing for

0:50:49the people in the cheap seats and this

0:50:52is a little pop-up stage

0:50:54it wasn't evident to anyone was there

0:50:56and she's putting on this in enormous

0:50:57spectacle and then all of a sudden she

0:50:59disappears and you know multiple times

0:51:02in the show she disappears in a little

0:51:03elevator beneath the stage to change

0:51:05costumes and there's and in the meantime

0:51:08there's a big video show that's it in

0:51:11some ways like the craziest part of the

0:51:12show but all of a sudden she pops up at

0:51:15this little mini stage dressed in a

0:51:19total like glitz bboy outfit like a

0:51:24glitter hat glitter baseball hat kind of

0:51:28turned to the side giant sir Justin

0:51:30Bieber t-shirt except instead of Justin

0:51:33Bieber's face its miley's face

0:51:36Sarah sure she's there with a giant

0:51:38picture of herself on her shirt and like

0:51:43dressed in a costume that immediately I

0:51:48like again my instinct was I don't like

0:51:51that i don't like that costume

0:51:53it looks like something the fly girls

0:51:55would wear on living color and I don't

0:51:58like it it's at its appropriated from

0:52:01something that I I didn't like the thing

0:52:04initially and now I don't like the

0:52:06appropriation of but she gets out on

0:52:09this little stage in this outfit and

0:52:11does two covers she does a downtempo

0:52:15acoustic cover of hey who that was for

0:52:22the most part like a very cool indie

0:52:28rock cover if I if I had heard tegan and

0:52:31sara do it before if i had heard st.

0:52:34Vincent do this cover of hey yeah i

0:52:37would have been like that's great great

0:52:40great sad song and it was very sad too

0:52:43and frankly watching Miley Cyrus I had

0:52:46to say that's amazing

0:52:48like that's great that she is cease

0:52:50singing hey yeah right now and it's

0:52:53making me sad and that's tremendous

0:52:57I mean she's doing it in an arena and

0:53:00she's got a picture of herself on her

0:53:02shirt and i'm i'm i'm genuinely moved

0:53:06and then her second cover is a

0:53:08full-throated just straight ahead honest

0:53:13cover of Jolene that the belly part in

0:53:17song

0:53:18yeah wow just at the top of her lungs

0:53:20just Jolene job and I'm like let's

0:53:25fucking incredible like that's it

0:53:27that isn't that is an amazing tin and

0:53:30sung by someone who obviously has been

0:53:33singing it since she was a little kid

0:53:34and there's no there's no reference made

0:53:40there's no wink in it it's like sad

0:53:45country version of Hey Ya full-throated

0:53:48version of Jolene and then back to the

0:53:52stripper show and at no point does

0:53:58anyone stop for a millisecond and go see

0:54:04what we did there because it's because

0:54:08that element of it is gone and that

0:54:10whole see what we did there

0:54:12impulse is still tied to this

0:54:15authenticity question that you or

0:54:18problem that you pose is a slideshow of

0:54:20poor kids in Mississippi or vintage

0:54:22photos of Dolly Parton nope there's no

0:54:25there's no like we are putting country

0:54:28and hip hop together we are put in we

0:54:31are doing these things because we are we

0:54:34are smarter than these things and we are

0:54:37able to manipulate these building blocks

0:54:40of culture and art we and appreciate us

0:54:44for that as the you know and that's the

0:54:47authenticity argument ultimately is like

0:54:51I know I'm a white kid playing the blues

0:54:54but I'm but I'm my acknowledgement of it

0:54:57my recognition that I'm doing it is

0:55:00makes it forgivable makes me miss you

0:55:04know you should admire me not because

0:55:07not just because of what I'm making but

0:55:09also because of my intention myself

0:55:12knowledge my my purpose my

0:55:16you know all of these secondary

0:55:18questions that are that are threaded

0:55:22through the question of authenticity and

0:55:25their-their wasn't any of that there's

0:55:27no there's no you or if your if that's

0:55:29in there it's just now

0:55:31it permeates the culture to the degree

0:55:33that no one has to do it anymore

0:55:35we all know that we all know everything

0:55:37we all know that there's no difference

0:55:39between you know like the message of her

0:55:41show is uh there's no difference between

0:55:43people and there's no difference between

0:55:46things there's no like african drumming

0:55:50in Japanese imagery belong together

0:55:52because everything is possible all the

0:55:55time so look what I made and I can't

0:56:03find fault with it

0:56:04yeah anyway I'll something I think about

0:56:09a lot on what you know drag this out i

0:56:11think it's it's it is fascinating and

0:56:12I'm glad you talked about it because

0:56:15it's and I'm glad you went

0:56:17what do you think about a lot when I'm

0:56:20watching a TV show or a movie that I

0:56:23think also applies a lot to pop music is

0:56:27for example if you're watching doctor

0:56:28who you're watching star wars you're

0:56:29watching any kind of a show i think it's

0:56:31always interesting to watch for sort of

0:56:33like who were supposed to sympathize

0:56:35with to the point where maybe better

0:56:38like who we want to be in this thing so

0:56:40i can doctor who

0:56:41a lot of people talk about Doctor Who I

0:56:43usually has a companion often a woman

0:56:44somebody's with them who's sometimes as

0:56:46little as just the doctor what's

0:56:48happening here and give them reason to

0:56:50explain it but can also be very an

0:56:52emotional connection that's just short

0:56:54of romantic a lot of the time but

0:56:56there's something we're like there's

0:56:57some character in this where you're

0:56:58supposed to see yourself right there

0:57:01that you are you are the person on this

0:57:03journey I think this is probably with

0:57:04Lord of the Rings and Star Wars maybe

0:57:06that's look Skywalker an episode for you

0:57:09know what I mean there's always somebody

0:57:10that you're supposed to sympathize with

0:57:12you just say episode 4 and I'm sorry

0:57:14that's what's officially what's called

0:57:16come on it's officially called a new

0:57:18hope

0:57:18dude this is a safe space here okay we

0:57:22don't have to you don't have to like

0:57:24talk to cult language here it's this

0:57:27this is not a couple more just

0:57:29star wards Star Wars is what it's called

0:57:32she's like some values it's called Star

0:57:34Wars the Justicar or consent but the

0:57:37story's gets really interesting in pop

0:57:39music because like Who am I supposed to

0:57:42obviously you're there because you buy

0:57:44larger there unless you really are at

0:57:46some gritty you know british punk rock

0:57:47show

0:57:48you're there because you like that

0:57:49performer you like what they do you

0:57:52probably you kind of want to be them

0:57:55sort of writing i mean you want to be

0:57:57the more you want to be with them maybe

0:57:58you want to kiss them but like there's

0:58:00something to it where like you see

0:58:02yourself and I think this is where the

0:58:03authenticity thing on its authenticity

0:58:05thing has been such a bugbear in the

0:58:07past is it's difficult for us to want to

0:58:09be close minor if we feel like class my

0:58:11name is not authentic right well you

0:58:14know what I'm saying

0:58:14and in this instance it you know it

0:58:16sounds like she's pretty unabashed about

0:58:18saying like you want to be me and I want

0:58:20to be you like we're realize you say we

0:58:23are doing this for each other which I

0:58:25think to do that in a way that is guy

0:58:27listen again I I don't overstate this I

0:58:29wasn't there but to do that in a way

0:58:31that it's guyless is is pretty unusual

0:58:33for stuff that I've been to in the past

0:58:35they would be a little fruity for me to

0:58:37say Oh John John Roderick is so dreamy i

0:58:39wish i could sink our parts or you know

0:58:42I guess Jagger or whatever but i think

0:58:45that's that's such a big piece of this

0:58:47is like wanting to see ourselves up

0:58:49there and wanted to see see what it

0:58:51would be like to be that person so I

0:58:53don't need to get our own bars but I

0:58:55mean like for her to be up there in the

0:58:57equivalent of like what somebody would

0:58:59wear in a hip-hop caprisun commercial

0:59:01with her being that guy right with her

0:59:04shirt with their own face on it

0:59:06well that's because that's that that

0:59:07could be you you want that to be you

0:59:09so when you go out and you wear that

0:59:10shirt you doing the same thing that she

0:59:11did and it's it's it's got like a

0:59:14one-to-one relationship i don't know i

0:59:18don't that make sense but again that's

0:59:19the kind of thing where like the last

0:59:20thing in a million years that you would

0:59:22say as a cool rock fan is like man I

0:59:26really want to be Michael Stipe that

0:59:29would have not been a very cool thing to

0:59:31say in 1984 probably although I probably

0:59:32would've set it to be honest but you

0:59:35know what i mean it sounds like those

0:59:36you felt like the least from your

0:59:38perspective with your with your paycheck

0:59:40jingle stick

0:59:41that that the those barriers or not

0:59:43they're in a way they were 20 years ago

0:59:44for us

0:59:45well I and a so much of it is is in the

0:59:49visual culture now that the watching the

0:59:53watching the this ponopolis of images

0:59:58unfold at

0:59:58unfold at

1:00:00realizing that that like we are living

1:00:06in a selfie culture now I was having a

1:00:07conversation with somebody on the phone

1:00:09the other day and I realized that they

1:00:12had never taken a selfie because they

1:00:15were an old person and I said you really

1:00:19need to really need to get past the

1:00:22barrier here and i took a picture myself

1:00:25and I was like see here's a selfie i'm

1:00:27just i'm driving in my car i'm taking a

1:00:29picture here's a picture of me what how

1:00:31do you feel about that and they were

1:00:32like I you know I'm it's really nice to

1:00:35see a picture of you I'm really like

1:00:37they they had all psychological barriers

1:00:41to taking a selfie that were all related

1:00:44to shame about self-aggrandizement she's

1:00:51antithetical to pretty much everything I

1:00:53I grew up with you don't take your own

1:00:55picture right right it's really that's a

1:00:58very weird thing to do that for a long

1:01:00time not to beat this to death but

1:01:02people who look like they wanted to be

1:01:04perceived as sex workers with two for a

1:01:06long time it used to be that that was

1:01:07just the domain of girls who took 45

1:01:09pictures of themselves in the bathroom

1:01:11mirror until they got the one that they

1:01:12like and now today everybody John

1:01:14Hodgman can't stop

1:01:15well anyone stop Frank frankly frankly

1:01:19no one can stop now like it we we have

1:01:22crossed the Rubicon and selfies are our

1:01:28up of form of art selfies are part of

1:01:32our awareness of ourselves and I mean I

1:01:36knew people who would get a roll of film

1:01:39back from the drugstore and like throw

1:01:42away the pictures of themselves just

1:01:44because even owning a picture of

1:01:46themselves taken by somebody else was

1:01:49too much vanity for them it's like it's

1:01:52like it's like it's like asking for your

1:01:54own autograph it it doesn't you need a

1:01:57second party for that to make sense yeah

1:01:59right and you you take the pictures of

1:02:01you and you give them to other people

1:02:03because why would you want to look at a

1:02:04picture of yourself but now the the

1:02:09culture has you know completely embraced

1:02:12the idea that

1:02:13pictures of yourself that taking

1:02:16thousands of pictures of yourself is a

1:02:21like is a way of exploring your identity

1:02:25and and understanding your ego and and

1:02:28basking in it and what's missing is the

1:02:33shame that we used to feel about it and

1:02:36so watching this watching the show last

1:02:38night in this cascade of images and a

1:02:40lot of pictures of miley cyrus in her

1:02:43own show including on her own t-shirt

1:02:45and including at the beginning when she

1:02:47literally slides out of her own mouth

1:02:49[Music]

1:02:50it's still can't get over that in and I

1:02:52don't and I'm not sure when they were

1:02:54thinking about when they were thinking

1:02:55it up it was like yes that's amazing but

1:02:57they're obviously either they have an

1:02:59incredible do they have no on staff

1:03:02theorists or they have an incredible on

1:03:03staff the earliest was just like yes

1:03:05definitely slide down your own tongue

1:03:08that is fucking great

1:03:10you know like somebody is that I think I

1:03:13feel like maybe her choreographer and

1:03:16her show runner are both like art phd's

1:03:22or something I mean it really feels like

1:03:23there's that much

1:03:25there's that much intention behind some

1:03:27of this stuff that's just like that

1:03:29couldn't be an accident but but this

1:03:32cascade of images is being received by

1:03:38an audience of people who are who are so

1:03:43much more comfortable with images of

1:03:46themselves and like I mean one of the

1:03:51best bits in them in the miley show was

1:03:53she's added out on the runway and she's

1:03:54just grabbing people's phones and like

1:03:56video taping herself for a second and

1:03:58handing the phone back to them and which

1:04:00is kinda like an autograph right and an

1:04:03amazing gift to give to somebody who

1:04:05you're a Miley Cyrus fan enough that you

1:04:06are right up against the stage and she

1:04:08grabs your phone and touches it with

1:04:09their own hand and like makes a little

1:04:11personal video for you and hands it back

1:04:13and so it's just like fan for life but

1:04:16also like what is that

1:04:20like I I do feel like every everyone in

1:04:23the audience is putting themselves in

1:04:25her shape because they all can make

1:04:30videos of themselves they're making

1:04:32videos of themselves right now and those

1:04:36videos are part of the unassisted I

1:04:40guess this is what I walked away with we

1:04:43always thought at the dawn of the

1:04:45Internet that I i think a lot of us

1:04:50could see that here was the potential

1:04:53for all of human knowledge to come to

1:04:57one central clearinghouse we could

1:05:01compare and contrast finally you didn't

1:05:04have to go get lost in the stacks with

1:05:06seven books open trying to figure out

1:05:08like where the Koran and the Bible and

1:05:12the bugger all the all the existing

1:05:14stuff without whether mental model right

1:05:16so we're going to mental model of the

1:05:17library like you don't get to go in and

1:05:20like scribbled a note book and put it on

1:05:21the Shelf right we were going to this

1:05:24was here was the internet and it was

1:05:26going to be this place where we finally

1:05:28had a consensus place and if we had and

1:05:34this is kind of the this is the liberal

1:05:35mentality like if we just get all the

1:05:39information in one place then the truth

1:05:42will be no and once we have all the

1:05:46information and we have the truth that

1:05:49we will be well then we will have

1:05:51achieved Nirvana or you know then strife

1:05:53will disappear because the truth is

1:05:55available and the only reason that we

1:05:58have wore the only reason that there is

1:06:00you know that there is so much anger in

1:06:03the world is that we don't we are

1:06:06confused we don't know the truth this

1:06:08person's angry he doesn't see the other

1:06:10person's side etc etc and the internet

1:06:14had this this enormous possibility

1:06:17well what what we're in now i think is

1:06:21this like post internet where yes all

1:06:26the information is available

1:06:27it's or or if you want

1:06:30look for I mean it's all here and what

1:06:34it has created is not this like this

1:06:39intellectual underpinnings for this this

1:06:42consensus in fact the culture is gone

1:06:45the other direction and and all things

1:06:47are equal and there is no consensus but

1:06:49what it has produced is this art culture

1:06:52where every single thing that's ever

1:06:56been made is cut up and paste it back

1:07:00together and there isn't a

1:07:04differentiation between like the like

1:07:08anime and tribal drumming and punk rock

1:07:14group none of those things all just sit

1:07:17is not just comfortably beside one

1:07:20another but but as if they had always

1:07:22been together and so in a sense it is

1:07:26the achievement of like the sum total of

1:07:29human knowledge all brought together but

1:07:31it's happening in this mashup of music

1:07:37and image rather than in this like sort

1:07:43of bookish theoretical place and it's a

1:07:48and I I guess I I it's not what I

1:07:52expected but it is but it it it bodes I

1:07:57guess it i guess it bodes well

1:07:59like I'm excited to see what it produces

1:08:05what I mean what I'm so excited to see

1:08:07what that means

1:08:09what is especially talking about your

1:08:10daughter my daughter you know what it

1:08:12means for somebody who didn't grow up

1:08:14with this as a transitional thing or as

1:08:16a new thing for somebody who for him

1:08:20like somebody born today for whom Miley

1:08:21Cyrus Cyrus sliding out of her own mouth

1:08:24on her own tongue

1:08:26is it something that's a mean it's not

1:08:28like that's the craziest thing but no

1:08:30although you have to see it really deny

1:08:32I just now I it's really disturbing me

1:08:35I've made Mick Jagger had done it at any

1:08:38point it would I mean if he done it 25

1:08:41years ago we would that image would be

1:08:43burned in my brain I'm thinking it's

1:08:44just a 60 so then what I mean if you

1:08:47think about this like somebody from

1:08:49western China comes comes into the the

1:08:54world now and says like I i play the one

1:08:57string violin it is our it's that our

1:09:00instruments the instrument of my uh my

1:09:04people here in western China and it's

1:09:07the you know it's it's our traditional

1:09:10instrument and i am the master one

1:09:11string violinist until very recently the

1:09:19the response to that would have been to

1:09:22give this guy show at carnegie hall or

1:09:24or you know his record would be the new

1:09:26NPR the kind of favorite or he would do

1:09:30if he would do a world tour like look

1:09:31what we found

1:09:33look what what has been introduced to us

1:09:35like you would have done something with

1:09:37any better or if like when the monks

1:09:39came to lollapalooza it would have been

1:09:40some kind of like you know we're

1:09:42sponsoring this culture

1:09:43yeah look at this but this is this new

1:09:47miley cyrus culture would just instantly

1:09:51assimilate that may be like oh cool one

1:09:54string violent guy you know like you're

1:09:58his one string violin sound would be

1:10:02automatically appropriated and like he

1:10:05would he would get up and do a song with

1:10:07miley cyrus but it wouldn't be like

1:10:09they're what they wouldn't have that um

1:10:12the reverence that we used to Accord

1:10:18that kind of like here he is now going

1:10:20to play his traditional music but

1:10:22instead it would just be like that's a

1:10:23cool sound that guy's cool looking

1:10:26and in a way that's more I mean in a way

1:10:32that just see that seems like a true

1:10:35kind of globalism or like more in line

1:10:38with the idea that all of humanity is

1:10:40one that we are all on one course

1:10:44together and that you know that I guess

1:10:48that's my takeaway from this show is

1:10:50like they're it

1:10:51her message if there is one is that I

1:10:57mean one planet one people almost and

1:11:01and you should make some coffee job