Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 96: "The Beautiful Thing About an Idea"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00hello hi John who is it who's me at

0:00:11hello hello faddah have sex but soaked

0:00:20candygram for Mongo candygram for Mongo

0:00:24I'm Merlin by John uh-huh

0:00:30he's not awake yeah well I am awake i

0:00:35woke up a while back and been busy doing

0:00:42important high-level work here

0:00:44no you're going to high-level today I'm

0:00:46adjusting well you know i'm working at a

0:00:48high level and the work I'm doing is

0:00:50high-level work

0:00:51wow that is a good monday yes it is

0:00:54yes i'm hosting a show tonight which is

0:00:58in the family of shows where i guess

0:01:03that i mean i think when they pitch the

0:01:06show to me they were like oh you don't

0:01:07have to do any work you have to do

0:01:08anything justjust to be up onstage and

0:01:11and you know host whatever that is I

0:01:16don't even know who they are but I'm

0:01:18just gonna tell you they always say that

0:01:19yeah but you know it seems like if

0:01:21that's what they say

0:01:23then I'm just gonna go to go on on their

0:01:26say-so and could just show up but you're

0:01:29gonna have to dress and get there and it

0:01:31will probably remember things

0:01:33mhm don't tell you that i do have to

0:01:35remember a few things i do have to tell

0:01:37you and MC yeah i think you know when I

0:01:42was in high school I couldn't think of a

0:01:44better job than MC like that seemed to

0:01:49me to be the absolute pinnacle if you

0:01:52had achieved everything in life you were

0:01:56asked to be the MC

0:01:58mhm because the MC is not the talent

0:02:01he's not the is not the rookeries not

0:02:05that he doesn't own the club AMC shows

0:02:09up in a tuxedo he leaves in a tuxedo

0:02:12but he's there he's at the center of

0:02:15everything I really believed that MC was

0:02:18the greatest job and as I got older and

0:02:22put away childish things

0:02:24mm I started to realize that MC is not

0:02:28the greatest job i think it can be a

0:02:31really good job first of all I know from

0:02:33mutual friends of ours that it can be

0:02:35weirdly lucrative given me once you get

0:02:38good at it like given the amount of work

0:02:40you actually have to do in terms of

0:02:42preparation but you gotta do what you

0:02:44gotta be careful for the first of all I

0:02:45agree with you I think being an MC is is

0:02:47awesome and I think it's more pressure

0:02:48than most people realize

0:02:50yeah because you have to be at least

0:02:51familiar enough the pill go ladies and

0:02:52gentlemen your master of ceremony is

0:02:54draw in like yeah right there who all

0:02:58right so they gotta know who you are but

0:03:00then also you got to be careful i have a

0:03:02friend who he got roped into it like

0:03:06being like organizing the benefit for

0:03:10his kids school and I think it was

0:03:12presented to him is our friend we were

0:03:14talking about that yesterday but you

0:03:16know and they're like hey you're funny

0:03:17you know funny people can you do this

0:03:20benefit and of course nested in that job

0:03:24on the one hand at the AMC job of like

0:03:25show up

0:03:26read something off a card and riff if

0:03:29you have to fill time right and seem

0:03:31enthusiastic about everything that

0:03:33happens and then have a pithy remarks

0:03:35about what just happened

0:03:36that's kind of being an MC right yeah

0:03:37yeah that sounds right about right but

0:03:40have you know but as usual in in

0:03:42everything including entertainment

0:03:43there's a lot nested in that that

0:03:45basically came down to like can you put

0:03:47together a show

0:03:48yes right things right get your get your

0:03:51bigshot celebrity TV friends to come and

0:03:54do this

0:03:54yeah and it ends up being eight giant

0:03:57unpaid project for people who are not

0:03:59used to doing that kind of work you have

0:04:02the the Big Show's I've MC the big

0:04:04benefit shows that I'm emceed all fall

0:04:06into the category as I've as I have

0:04:09outlined elsewhere of that phenomenon

0:04:12where the the people that put on 250

0:04:16shows a year send you one email and it

0:04:19has all the information you need about

0:04:21the show the people who put on One Show

0:04:24a year said you 200

0:04:2550 emails and not a single one of them

0:04:28has any information it's usable and so I

0:04:32have emceed some big show some big

0:04:34benefit galas for some worthwhile

0:04:38organizations but but they end up being

0:04:42such a clusterfuck of of too many piano

0:04:47too many stage managers too many ideas

0:04:50you know that i showed up I showed up to

0:04:52one and they handed me a script that

0:04:55they had written when I was old

0:04:58yeah and I was like wow I would have

0:04:59liked to have seen this yesterday

0:05:01this is a full script this isn't just

0:05:05like somehow this isn't an outline this

0:05:06is like a full script so basically what

0:05:09you have asked me to do is stand up on

0:05:11stage and read this from this paper

0:05:13because i have i have an hour and not in

0:05:16your words

0:05:17oh no you know just like Hello ladies

0:05:19and germs and speaking and speaking of

0:05:23troublesome plumbing problems you know

0:05:25but tonight I think they are hiring

0:05:28event tonight they have hired me to be

0:05:30me which is a good that's a good gig but

0:05:34you get that too often you can start

0:05:35getting after it are getting hired to be

0:05:38able to you know like to a certainty

0:05:41like which you they think they're

0:05:43getting well that's the thing i've done

0:05:46a pretty pretty a work worthwhile job of

0:05:51calibrating the people's idea of the

0:05:55fake me you know like there's there's

0:05:58there's a pretty good fake me out there

0:06:01that everybody thinks is the real me and

0:06:04so when somebody when somebody hires me

0:06:07to be me

0:06:09I assume they mean fake me uh-huh that I

0:06:12have been carefully crafted fake me and

0:06:15I show up as fake me if they think that

0:06:20their iron me this section here about

0:06:23the children tap-dancing can we switch

0:06:25that out for about two-and-a-half hours

0:06:27of me talking about united airlines

0:06:28they're the people who who really are

0:06:34hiring me and one actual mean I don't I

0:06:36chooses there's not enough money in the

0:06:38world

0:06:39it reminds me a little bit of I haven't

0:06:42had a whole lot of experience with you

0:06:45know programming and development stuff

0:06:47but certainly enough over the period

0:06:49that I was doing it to know that they

0:06:51are similar in one way which is people

0:06:53have a really good idea in their head of

0:06:55what the finished product looks like you

0:06:57like you know an iOS app like a good i

0:07:00OS app looks like you know how to really

0:07:01good

0:07:02well but you know like what a good stage

0:07:03show looks like but you absolutely no

0:07:06idea what goes into making that thing

0:07:08oh right right no you don't want to see

0:07:10this one through this we made your

0:07:12website you you haven't really well and

0:07:13you participated very aggressively in

0:07:16handsomely and you and Sean both wrote a

0:07:18lot of stuff you understood that it was

0:07:19going to be I think if one thing one

0:07:21small success i had with that site was

0:07:22getting you understand that the Site was

0:07:24going to be as good as what you

0:07:25personally put into it otherwise it

0:07:27would be just another bunch of files on

0:07:28the internet and I think that actually

0:07:31turned out really well I'm proud of that

0:07:32site but you know when you go into

0:07:33something like like this like you say

0:07:35somebody who does it somebody if you

0:07:37work with someone who's like you know a

0:07:39production of producer type person you

0:07:41something actually like deals with

0:07:43people all the time knows what happens

0:07:44knows what for knows what questions

0:07:46people ask for used to afford me an

0:07:48email you got it recently that was I

0:07:52mean it was it was like it was like

0:07:55heart of darkness

0:07:56it was really really really long it was

0:07:59kind of hard to tease out exactly the

0:08:01information that they should have known

0:08:03that you would want out of it

0:08:05yeah well it's like that first time I

0:08:06went to South by Southwest and I thought

0:08:08though we were but we got done with our

0:08:10our show and there was this huge crowd

0:08:13of people standing right at the foot of

0:08:15the stage like I'm trying to load my amp

0:08:17off the stage and they're all these

0:08:18people like waving their business cards

0:08:21at me and I was thinking this is it I've

0:08:23hit I like I'm just going to plug these

0:08:26business cards and they're all going to

0:08:28say

0:08:28sony BMG and/or you know half of them

0:08:32are probably going to be cashier's

0:08:34checks this is like Obama at the

0:08:36democratic convention in many years ago

0:08:39that's right this is what your moment

0:08:40this is here John's I have a dream

0:08:42speech that's right this was a

0:08:43career-making turn your first time at

0:08:45South by back when south by really man

0:08:48nerd and this was going to be the moment

0:08:50and I and so I get off the stage and I'm

0:08:51like Hello

0:08:52nice to meet you all you know i'm i'm

0:08:54like taking my time with each person I'm

0:08:56looking at their business cards and

0:08:58little by little it starts to dawn on me

0:09:00after a half an hour that every one of

0:09:04these business cards is like billion

0:09:06francs record label out of Mobile

0:09:08Alabama you can see the perforation

0:09:10something car engine and you know and

0:09:13that realization that like oh they came

0:09:15to South by Southwest looking for the

0:09:17band that was going to make their record

0:09:20label viable not this isn't a moment

0:09:23where I am you know where actual suits

0:09:26are here to give me opportunities this

0:09:28is like but it but it looks close enough

0:09:30to that huh that I i see how people get

0:09:35to see how people get rooked into

0:09:37business relationships all the time

0:09:39where it's like oh wait no you are gonna

0:09:41help me right and I so I get emails like

0:09:44that all the time where it's like we

0:09:45would love to give you a big show and I

0:09:48go okay well what's the deal and they're

0:09:50like we'll all we need you to do is

0:09:51promoted and devised it and sell it and

0:09:57be the man of it and tell us how to do

0:10:00it and also find the money for it and

0:10:04just like you are not offering me

0:10:06anything it's not like it's gonna get

0:10:08going up to somebody and it love your

0:10:11elevator pitch being i would like to

0:10:13why would she would give me the honor of

0:10:16letting me take you out to a really

0:10:18really fancy dinner

0:10:20that's kind of what the pitch feels

0:10:21thanks but then you realize they don't

0:10:23know how to cook

0:10:24it's really that basically they want you

0:10:26to have them over for dinner but never

0:10:28been to a restaurant before you don't

0:10:29know what happened is now now i know it

0:10:32happens all the time now I feel like

0:10:34that in my family

0:10:36historiography there is at the core of

0:10:42my father's family there is a similar

0:10:45situation where like my grandmother was

0:10:50my grandmother's family was an old

0:10:54Seattle family that didn't have any

0:10:56money they were the White Russians of

0:10:59Seattle

0:10:59all their friends were rich they lived

0:11:03in a big house in the right neighborhood

0:11:04but they didn't but they were uh how do

0:11:08you say not rich and a grand

0:11:13great-grandfather was a judge you know

0:11:16that I think they they they said they

0:11:18seem successful

0:11:19yeah they they had prominence without

0:11:22any money and I think it's looking at

0:11:26myself and my father's family it is

0:11:28because no one had any business acumen

0:11:30but they raised their daughter to be a

0:11:35real catch for a prince and she was an

0:11:40opera singer and she had toured Europe

0:11:42before the war and she was you know

0:11:45cultured and elegant and all these

0:11:48things and in world war one she went to

0:11:52Europe to sing for the soldiers in the

0:11:56trenches back when soldiers in the

0:11:59trenches wanted to hear opera and in

0:12:03between because the way that war was

0:12:04fought they would then she would sing

0:12:07for the soldiers up by the front and

0:12:08then they would drive her back to Paris

0:12:10and wine and dine you know for a week or

0:12:14two and then go back up and sing for the

0:12:16soldiers again it was not there was not

0:12:17a tremendous amount of hardship but she

0:12:20was being squired around by generals and

0:12:22you know she wrote a book called a

0:12:24nightingale in the trenches which is

0:12:26which is a terrible book

0:12:29but it tells these fascinating stories

0:12:33about like oh well and here comes John

0:12:35Pershing in the back in the back of an

0:12:38open car and they they go off together

0:12:41to you know to the Moulin Rouge and

0:12:46plates etc you know it's all very

0:12:48glamorous but then she meets my

0:12:52grandfather David Roderick senior who is

0:12:59the son of a Welsh immigrant coal miner

0:13:03and who had been raised to succeed in

0:13:08America to banish all the the ugliness

0:13:13of being immigrants and so he had

0:13:16memorized Shakespeare and he had

0:13:18memorized all the you know he'd

0:13:22memorized Whitman and he was a cultured

0:13:25he could quote that length from the

0:13:28Bible and he spoke with a haughty manner

0:13:31and was a young lieutenant and he'd made

0:13:37up a backstory for himself that he was

0:13:38descended from scottish kings and their

0:13:42family still thought it was Scottish

0:13:44that's when we still thought we were

0:13:45Scottish he knew he wasn't Scottish but

0:13:48he was the one that started this this

0:13:50alignable anyway they meet they meet in

0:13:54world war one in the glamorous heady

0:13:57days at the end of the war when the you

0:13:59know the far-off cannon fire and yet

0:14:03they are drinking champagne here at the

0:14:05in the rearward area and each one of

0:14:08them was actually they're totally full

0:14:11of shit like Miss representing

0:14:15themselves as a member of America's

0:14:17aspirational class they were each one

0:14:21teach one knowing who they are thought

0:14:22they were getting a catch

0:14:24that's right they were people at

0:14:26Gatsby's party and they saw one another

0:14:32across a crowded dance floor and i'm

0:14:34sure you know either one of them could

0:14:36have used their line you know what what

0:14:39they're carefully crafted line

0:14:41they could have used that to to meet and

0:14:43marry someone who had money who was

0:14:48perhaps culturally impoverished but

0:14:51maybe the heir to the singer sewing

0:14:53machine family fortune or maybe the

0:14:57heiress of the you know the like my

0:15:02grandmother's brother did marry the

0:15:06heiress of the buster brown shoe fortune

0:15:09but that money never made it to me in

0:15:13any case it wasn't until they were

0:15:16married and back in the states that they

0:15:18finally realized that they had could

0:15:22wing to one another with their Bologna

0:15:25at the exact same moment but it said I'm

0:15:28gonna need a little money this month

0:15:30yeah they're like oh what but and here's

0:15:33the real tragedy here is the American

0:15:35tragedy they were in love and so it was

0:15:40unthinkable to them that they would not

0:15:41that they would separate for such course

0:15:44reasons as that they were but their

0:15:47entire mutually fraudulent yeah their

0:15:50entire founding myth was was a was a

0:15:52blatant lie

0:15:54and so here we are that's ok sorry

0:15:57ancestry they just they just shot the

0:16:00lie down the pipeline they were like

0:16:02let's just keep telling this lie on both

0:16:04sides and just you know raise their kids

0:16:07to believe that their kids were

0:16:09descended from the Scottish Lords and

0:16:12that there was money waiting in a trunk

0:16:14is this day when you find yourself

0:16:18looking up in the trees wondering could

0:16:20there be a bag of money hanging there

0:16:22I do I go I i go it's your birthright is

0:16:25there a trunk in the Attic somewhere

0:16:27that I haven't seen it's gotta be a

0:16:28false bottom here somewhere that's right

0:16:30i'm looking for the false bottom

0:16:32everywhere I go I'm not knocking looking

0:16:37for the hollow space in the what is such

0:16:39an American story though it really is a

0:16:41sweet story it's a very American story

0:16:43because there is an element of fake it

0:16:44till you make it in america i mean look

0:16:46at how many people anglicized their

0:16:47names when they come here

0:16:48it really is such as a chef such a

0:16:50chance for a fresh start and you get one

0:16:52good suit

0:16:54you know a haircut and I feel like if

0:16:56either one of them had this mysterious

0:16:58talent which is business acumen like

0:17:02they had all the opportunity in the

0:17:04world and they have this backstory if if

0:17:09only a little business acumen had

0:17:12entered the picture and they had

0:17:14succeeded then the the success in

0:17:19America validates the the bullshit story

0:17:24in so many families so that all of a

0:17:27sudden

0:17:27well that's why everybody in America is

0:17:29descended from robert e lee that's why

0:17:31everybody you know like everybody in

0:17:34America has a great you know has some

0:17:38some part of their family story that

0:17:41where they arrived on the Mayflower and

0:17:43it's all baloney but it but at some

0:17:46point somebody had success and then

0:17:48their version of the story was accepted

0:17:50and what's funny about my family is that

0:17:52half of my half of my relatives have

0:17:56actually become successful they have

0:17:58married well and you would if you if

0:18:02they were sitting here right now their

0:18:04version of my grandmother and

0:18:06grandfather story would be very

0:18:08different from mine because they will

0:18:12they not only do they accept the kind of

0:18:16a geography but like its kind of crucial

0:18:21its kind of crucial to their own

0:18:24identity that some of those stories be

0:18:29true

0:18:29yeah well I think it's really i'm

0:18:34thinking about my own family and people

0:18:36I've known and it's you know it's like

0:18:39everybody anything for a long time it's

0:18:42been critical to maintain the family

0:18:45secrets

0:18:46I mean for some reason I can't help

0:18:48thinking of like William Faulkner and

0:18:50like you know and learning these

0:18:51different sides of the story and

0:18:53learning what really happened and you

0:18:56know sometimes that shared familial lie

0:18:59is can can be like a great bond em don't

0:19:03you think

0:19:04hell yes well I don't you know

0:19:06I at the beginning of the grunge years I

0:19:10remember being here in Seattle kind of

0:19:13walking around the bars and the times in

0:19:17the towns and listening to people tell

0:19:21their family story in their backstory

0:19:24and realizing that i was in a new world

0:19:26because in the grunge ears every kid was

0:19:33telling a story about how his family was

0:19:36garbage like the fashion at the time was

0:19:42to say I'm white trash

0:19:44I'm descended from losers I I don't have

0:19:48never had anything I've ever had to

0:19:50raise myself and maybe my sibling since

0:19:52I was young I've always been independent

0:19:54that's right and it was part of that you

0:19:57know in 1991 like in 1986 every town had

0:20:01a a small handful of punk rockers who

0:20:03you know who who smoked clove cigarettes

0:20:07under the under the statue in the town

0:20:10square and they were you know they

0:20:13unless you lived in a fuse and a few

0:20:16rare environments like you know

0:20:19somewhere in southern california and

0:20:21washington DC New York I mean there was

0:20:23there was not if you were growing up in

0:20:25hiawatha in the early eighties like

0:20:27anywhere punk rocker you were you want a

0:20:30very small little group of people but by

0:20:331991 1992 every single person our age

0:20:36had some story about themselves that

0:20:41they had been punked that whole time and

0:20:44part of that story was that they were

0:20:47they had been abused they'd raise

0:20:48themselves they had they had nothing

0:20:51nowhere to fall back

0:20:53it was they were from you know they were

0:20:55from this garbage strain of American

0:20:58nobody's and all you have to do is go

0:21:01look at their high school yearbook and

0:21:02you realize oh no that's not true at all

0:21:05like your pictures in the yearbook but

0:21:08yet you like showed up for school

0:21:10yeah that's the first sign that you're

0:21:12not a garbage person whatever I think

0:21:15the garbage person is but I mean

0:21:17I heard the word white or the phrase

0:21:19white trash so much in ninety-three

0:21:23ninety-five like it

0:21:24everybody was claiming to be it in

0:21:27Seattle especially and up until that

0:21:31point it had never occurred to me that

0:21:33anybody would have a a backstory that

0:21:36didn't include some at some point that

0:21:39you had come over on the Mayflower

0:21:39because you know because my family was

0:21:43so invested in this in in that what was

0:21:48effectively a dying version of american

0:21:52middle class social aspiration my my

0:21:56cousins were still worried about getting

0:21:58into the Daughters of the American

0:22:00Revolution and having enough

0:22:02documentation to prove that they could

0:22:03be members and all of a sudden around me

0:22:07all my peers were like my dad's in

0:22:09prison and I'm you know my mom was a

0:22:11whore like wait a minute your dad worked

0:22:14for hewlett-packard and your beer mom uh

0:22:18you know has only had sex with two

0:22:21people in her whole life like what are

0:22:22you talking about it was it was just as

0:22:25much Bologna but but but the the

0:22:28aspiration had had flipped entirely i

0:22:32still see that I mean you know I still

0:22:33see that a lot in my generation you

0:22:35don't see it in the kids but people

0:22:38you're in my age if you if you sit down

0:22:41and hear their family story you still

0:22:44here a lot of you still hear them

0:22:46struggling to took to put across this

0:22:51this tale this like Wild West hillbilly

0:22:55tail

0:22:56well yeah and I mean I think part of it

0:22:59is trying to manage expectations and

0:23:01like set a certain bar so you know it's

0:23:04sort of like the kid always turns paper

0:23:06and label course it's often we do it

0:23:07took me two minutes

0:23:08you know like if you can create this

0:23:10world where like you have him probably

0:23:12succeeded against all odds and you

0:23:15obviously are you trying to get yourself

0:23:16the credibility of having more tenacity

0:23:18more intestinal fortitude than the

0:23:21people around you but also like I think

0:23:23this happens to this day

0:23:24I mean somewhere talking about the other

0:23:26day too is doing this kind of like kind

0:23:29of weird weird version of social

0:23:31climbing the people do and could I think

0:23:34it happens most commonly with people

0:23:35where you try to like canoodle up to

0:23:38somebody who's a little more famous than

0:23:39you in order to canoodle up to the next

0:23:42level from them and you basically get

0:23:43the you want to get the equivalent of a

0:23:47recommendation letter of recommendation

0:23:49from from that person but it also it

0:23:53also the reason it reminds you of the

0:23:54fucker stuff is like it's also like you

0:23:56can decide which parts of your life that

0:23:58are really maybe even eighty percent

0:23:59true you choose to tell people about

0:24:01yeah like I can you know I can talk

0:24:04about like you know punk rock shows i

0:24:05went to bed at a certain time or i could

0:24:08talk about being like most talented

0:24:10senior depending on what suits me

0:24:12that's right you were most talented

0:24:14senior yeah I'll i technically i was

0:24:15also class clown but you can only win

0:24:16one most talented mustache

0:24:18eighteen-year-olds I think you should

0:24:21have won it took me like two years to

0:24:23get that letter about that I think about

0:24:25who this generation that's coming up and

0:24:27particularly and I i'm not sure the

0:24:29twitter world in the internet world that

0:24:31I live in I'm not sure how

0:24:32representative it is of the world at

0:24:34large

0:24:35you're not but that the mom butt we

0:24:40joked about this at at at our Roderick

0:24:42on the line live shell which is the the

0:24:46idea of like if you if you were 16 years

0:24:50old right now and you were getting us

0:24:52the steady input of check your privilege

0:24:56check your privilege and and the the

0:25:00presumption being that the more

0:25:03privileged you are the more the more

0:25:06other people can point to you and call

0:25:08you privileged the actual that the less

0:25:10authority you have to speak that this

0:25:15notion the right like you're the the

0:25:17group that you represent in my mind has

0:25:19had more than ample opportunity to be

0:25:21represented in the public forum right so

0:25:23now your turn to shut up and ended feel

0:25:26bad about it right and so authority to

0:25:29speak is becoming in the in the certain

0:25:33segments of the world which I which I

0:25:35don't

0:25:36when I meet people in their early

0:25:37twenties I don't see them as

0:25:40overburdened they generally seem like a

0:25:43pretty happy generation but then online

0:25:47there's this there's this simultaneous

0:25:50dialogue which is which is basically

0:25:53like shut up shut up shut up like you

0:25:55all have to shut up even though telling

0:25:57people to shut up is bullying and bad

0:25:59but the but the effect of the effect of

0:26:02this check your privilege

0:26:04firstworldproblems constant sort of wave

0:26:09after wave of of attempts to censor

0:26:13anybody that doesn't have like a perfect

0:26:16backstory

0:26:18where where where their story deserves

0:26:21to be heard whatever I can't imagine

0:26:23that it isn't creating a similar kind of

0:26:27identity wave in people where they're

0:26:30searching their family histories they're

0:26:33searching their own stories for ways in

0:26:36which they are victims of history or

0:26:42victims of of oppression such that there

0:26:46that their opinions matter or such that

0:26:48they that they no longer have to

0:26:50self-censor self apologize and that they

0:26:56can that they can actually speak with

0:26:58some Authority some Authority earned by

0:27:02your forefathers or earned by the burned

0:27:05by your victimization and I can't

0:27:08imagine what what kind of tangled the

0:27:10stories people are telling about

0:27:12themselves in bars where it's not enough

0:27:16anymore to just say like oh my people

0:27:19were white trash like you have to say my

0:27:21people were my people were also

0:27:27brutalized by history and although i

0:27:32might appear to be did I retired this

0:27:34story i was at that this is so funny of

0:27:36its recurring it's occurring to me now I

0:27:38was in a bar and a guy six-foot-seven

0:27:41guy with bright red hair

0:27:45red eye lashes like red guy freckles

0:27:49whose name was like Sheamus McKinnon he

0:27:56and I are talking in this bar and I make

0:27:59some reference to to being a Celt like

0:28:02well you know at as a Celt I'm sure you

0:28:05feel here you use something something

0:28:08something something I don't remember

0:28:08when i said to the guy and he stopped me

0:28:11very serious and he said I I look

0:28:14celtic but I'm native american and i

0:28:19wasn't sure if he was kidding and I was

0:28:21like tell me more

0:28:23and he was like you know my grandmother

0:28:25was a chop saw and my on my

0:28:28grandfather's side you know she was he

0:28:32was a a you know an Iroquois and so you

0:28:38know I'm I mean I look I guess Irish if

0:28:44thats it to you but but I'm to a breeder

0:28:49like you

0:28:49yeah but i'm a native american and i was

0:28:52like wow okay all right i mean i don't

0:28:55know i didn't press him for like what

0:28:57percentage of top saw was your

0:29:00grandmother I mean it's not important

0:29:02because now all the sudden all of a

0:29:03sudden you're like the East you like

0:29:04star Z you right now it's not my job to

0:29:07to like it too to do that but maybe just

0:29:10maybe all you have to do is declare that

0:29:12you know and and now you know it so

0:29:15there's one part of this and this is

0:29:17only like saying this but you know it

0:29:19seems like there are so many Lauer

0:29:21strong voices right now that are very

0:29:23very angry and the part about it that I

0:29:26think it's kind of a bummer is that

0:29:27people people are being actively

0:29:32encouraged to only find a strong voice

0:29:35if they can do it to immediate out

0:29:37immediately ally themselves with a group

0:29:40of people there's not that there's not

0:29:42that much encouragement that icy out

0:29:44there to be a singular voice anymore

0:29:46because singular being a singular voice

0:29:48will get you like really smack down at

0:29:50this point and I think you can

0:29:52controversial eyes what almost anybody

0:29:54says

0:29:55it's like it was like you're straying

0:29:56too far from the pack i wouldn't want to

0:29:58stay politically correct that's that's

0:29:5922 over simplified but there's there's

0:30:01so much identity politics right now that

0:30:03I think it's becoming almost

0:30:05irresistible for people to ally

0:30:07themselves even if they don't if you

0:30:09like belong with that group you can have

0:30:10all the sympathy in the world that you

0:30:12want for and it's certainly I mean in an

0:30:15ideal world we would just have sympathy

0:30:16for each other for being human beings

0:30:17but that doesn't really count anymore

0:30:19now you actually have to you have to

0:30:21show your bona fides that you are you

0:30:23are you are for all practical purposes

0:30:25Native American there for you now have

0:30:27your so closely allied with this that

0:30:29you can we can get you past the

0:30:31privilege bar that you're allowed to

0:30:32have some kind of an opinion at this

0:30:34point because otherwise you're just

0:30:35you're just another part of the problem

0:30:37yeah well I'm gonna be part of that

0:30:39group if I feel like it's like it when

0:30:41anybody who strays too far from the pack

0:30:43or whose gets too far off message is

0:30:46really kind of shouted down as being

0:30:48part of this this you know

0:30:50amorphis blob of the problem the one

0:30:54percent that whatever all this other

0:30:56this other nurse other pneus and you can

0:30:58just find some group that will that you

0:30:59can kind of such sidle up to that is the

0:31:03opposite of the other niggas then then

0:31:04you're allowed to be all mad and you're

0:31:05allowed to talk if you get off that

0:31:07what's confusing is that if you get off

0:31:09message for them the message being like

0:31:13the you know the whatever this the

0:31:18perfect storm we're talking about that's

0:31:21happening in the culture now the message

0:31:23which is very very focused on rights on

0:31:30on the rights denied on the elderly

0:31:34overdue writes the the rights that are I

0:31:37mean it's at the chomsky world where the

0:31:40where the if you get off if you get off

0:31:43Chomsky message it doesn't matter what

0:31:46you're saying

0:31:47outside of that message whatever it is

0:31:51you are on the other message right i

0:31:54mean as soon as you get off the the

0:31:56dialectic

0:31:58whatever you're saying even even

0:32:01presumably still like an innocuous

0:32:03material you are you are you are being

0:32:08accused of speaking on behalf of the big

0:32:11problem you're automatically a

0:32:12reactionary you're automatically part of

0:32:16the the counter revolutionary movement

0:32:18yeah i wrote I I philip seymour hoffman

0:32:21died and and not somebody pointed out to

0:32:23me that I had written a few years ago an

0:32:25article about about creativity and drugs

0:32:30and so i reposted it just saying like

0:32:34this is a thing I wrote about rock and

0:32:37roll about the relationship between

0:32:39creativity and drugs and how it how

0:32:42would have been that some of the

0:32:43mistakes we make thinking that the two

0:32:45are connected and I get you know I

0:32:50people replied to me and said thank you

0:32:52for doing that or a nice article and

0:32:54then somebody and obviously a fan a fan

0:32:57of me and a fan enough to go retail

0:33:00click a link and go read an article I

0:33:02wrote wrote me and said I really liked

0:33:04your article except for the part where

0:33:06you said wives and girlfriends

0:33:09contribute to the problem because that

0:33:14implies that women can't be musicians

0:33:16and all of this is in a tweet right and

0:33:22what wasn't overt in the article that I

0:33:27wrote was that i was writing it in

0:33:30response to the plight of a female

0:33:32musician i know in Seattle who was

0:33:35drinking and drugging herself to death

0:33:38and everybody in town knew it she's a

0:33:42famous musician she was killing herself

0:33:45with drugs and I had I had an encounter

0:33:50with her in a bar and watched as people

0:33:53all around her including a lot of rock

0:33:56stars who had seen their friends die

0:33:58they were all facilitating this drug

0:34:04problem because everybody's too

0:34:07embarrassed to address it

0:34:10and also it's not cool and also oh

0:34:15that's just how how she is how blank ins

0:34:20whatever and so I wrote this article

0:34:23like no don't sit and watch your friends

0:34:26die that's not cool her drug problem and

0:34:30her creativity are not connected your

0:34:33drugs and creativity are not connected

0:34:35like can we not save this person and the

0:34:38article was obvious enough to people in

0:34:40Seattle that I got a few phone calls

0:34:42from also other rock musicians who were

0:34:46like thank you for doing that we really

0:34:48need to do something about her she's

0:34:50gonna die etc etc and it ended up that

0:34:52she went to rehab and his eye and his is

0:34:55has survived but so I get this tweet

0:35:00from this concerned reader whose like

0:35:05I'd I like the article except for this

0:35:10and and obviously this is a this is a

0:35:12fan and somebody who appreciates where

0:35:15I'm coming from right

0:35:17she already knows what I'm on about but

0:35:21she felt and I have no idea how old this

0:35:23person is she could be 20 she could be

0:35:2450 but she felt her job as a reader was

0:35:32to detect the two was too

0:35:38was it her antenna were so sensitive

0:35:42that she found this moment in the piece

0:35:46where I said wives and girlfriends and

0:35:49her alarm bells went off and she needed

0:35:51to alert me to that and needed basically

0:35:56to say I see this and you need to be

0:36:00re-educated a third that's the word to

0:36:03never use wives and girlfriends again

0:36:06without also saying husbands and

0:36:07boyfriends or without also stipulating

0:36:10that that females can be musicians to or

0:36:12without also you know like you didn't

0:36:14you didn't adequately prepare

0:36:17you did not you were not being careful

0:36:22enough in predicting all the ways that

0:36:24could need to be corrected for emotional

0:36:27person and so this reader in with her

0:36:33hyper zeroed in sensitivity failed to

0:36:37recognize that the entire article was

0:36:39about a female musician and that the

0:36:42degree to which I masked that was

0:36:46because I did not want to slam for like

0:36:50trying to shame and out that right i

0:36:53mean writing this article for a general

0:36:55audience all the people that know her

0:36:58and noemi knew it was about her and knew

0:37:01it was a a new the article was meant for

0:37:04a for an audience of people that were

0:37:06supposed to recognize themselves in it

0:37:09and stop helping this woman killed

0:37:13herself but but the so this close reader

0:37:18failed to read the big article and

0:37:21failed to see that it was that you know

0:37:25that I had worked long and hard to make

0:37:28it to to take gender out of it in order

0:37:31to spare this person the embarrassment

0:37:35but also even if that weren't the case

0:37:38wives and girlfriends do facilitate the

0:37:41are a problem like wives and girlfriends

0:37:43are problem and it and I don't need to

0:37:45say husbands and boyfriends because the

0:37:51husband's that our problem for female

0:37:53rock musicians are wives basically you

0:37:55know I mean random but suffice to say

0:37:58that that this that the idea that if you

0:38:02are not exactly on language message that

0:38:06you are actually actively working on

0:38:09behalf of forces of conservatism and

0:38:13revanche ism like to be to be off msgs

0:38:17not to be neutral it is to be it is to

0:38:20be immediately working on behalf of evil

0:38:23forces

0:38:25is is a crazy is a crazy place to be

0:38:30it is crazy to be challenged to justify

0:38:36the political message of every message

0:38:40will have to show that you into show in

0:38:43a way that is frankly most of the time

0:38:46extremely hand fisted and not very

0:38:48elegant and certainly not very subtle to

0:38:50prove to everybody through three to five

0:38:53paragraphs that you have done all of

0:38:54your math and can show it that you have

0:38:57that you know it's I feel like there's

0:38:59so much pressure right now in the public

0:39:00discourse for everything to be about

0:39:02everything

0:39:03there's there's there's really I feel

0:39:05like as soon as somebody starts to say

0:39:07if I say something as simple as you know

0:39:09what I just don't like arguing with

0:39:10people on the internet

0:39:11well then then if i'm not arguing with

0:39:13somebody about what it is that they want

0:39:14to argue about that means that i don't

0:39:17want to agree on anything I don't you

0:39:18want to argue about whether i agree with

0:39:20you i just think it's unseemly and it's

0:39:22a thing i don't like doing but by

0:39:24choosing not to do that it makes it seem

0:39:25like I'm a mute member of this class of

0:39:28people who really just actively enjoy

0:39:30seeing people put down and I will not

0:39:31raise my voice that's not the case at

0:39:33all right I i do think i do think that

0:39:36people are really complicated problem

0:39:37and to say something interesting about

0:39:39anything you have to have the right

0:39:40amount of introspection and specificity

0:39:45and you have to talk about a thing at a

0:39:46time when there's a sense what's so

0:39:48confusing about this curl is that she or

0:39:50her a woman whoever it was that that

0:39:52that sent me this tweet that she

0:39:56immediately also felt empowered at to

0:40:01challenge me as though she were my

0:40:04thesis advisor you know she was not she

0:40:09wasn't coming from a place of her of

0:40:13intellectual humility or a place of even

0:40:15like I admire you

0:40:18her her her tone and her her approach

0:40:21was immediately like for lack of a

0:40:25better term matriarchal or or like she

0:40:29was coming to me with superior wisdom

0:40:31right that she had read something that

0:40:34no one else perceived or that i was

0:40:36unaware she was revealing

0:40:38cataract he didn't know you had yeah she

0:40:40was here now to as you as as we agree

0:40:44that the the operative term she was here

0:40:46to reeducation me from a place i mean

0:40:49and i think backed up by the by the

0:40:52authority of the party when i whenever I

0:40:57hear that word I because i used to use

0:40:59that word in that same kind of context

0:41:02it was a very common thing in the

0:41:03liberal community to say for many many

0:41:05years is that really this is just a

0:41:07problem of education we the thing is

0:41:09people would be better about not wasting

0:41:11natural resources if they're just more

0:41:12educated was promised in education and

0:41:15the thing is what what people said that

0:41:17about you

0:41:18like what if people said the problem is

0:41:19the thing that you need to understand

0:41:21about everything that's wrong with your

0:41:22political beliefs is it or you're

0:41:24whatever you're wherever your beliefs

0:41:25are is just a little it's just a

0:41:27question of Education yeah you just

0:41:28don't you just don't have the

0:41:29information that we have real and so all

0:41:32the times you get into an argument at a

0:41:34sports bar with some jackass who's

0:41:36trying to tell you that the kids

0:41:37shouldn't kids shouldn't be immunized

0:41:38and you know and for that matter women

0:41:41should be in the home or whatever it is

0:41:43chemtrails well it but really just

0:41:45anything that you believe when you as

0:41:47soon as you start telling people that

0:41:48it's a matter of education I think you

0:41:50lose a little bit of your intellectual

0:41:51authority because at that point you're

0:41:53what you're saying is I will sit here

0:41:55and and patiently listen to what you

0:41:57have to say until I get the opportunity

0:41:59to show you how you are fundamentally

0:42:01wrong and that you will never be able to

0:42:03advance intellectually until you accept

0:42:06what it is that I know is true it's just

0:42:09a matter of education but 22 sounds like

0:42:11fucking Pol Pot the 20 books that i have

0:42:13read from the age of sixteen to twenty

0:42:16eleven by the same author the sum of

0:42:20some of which were in a my high school

0:42:22syllabus some of them were my college

0:42:24syllabus some of them i found through

0:42:27friends but those you know 20 to 30

0:42:29books that i have really your red and

0:42:32digested are the sum total of human

0:42:34knowledge and the 20 or 30 books that

0:42:37you've read some of which overlap mine

0:42:39probably a lot of them do we both

0:42:42probably read The Great Gatsby

0:42:46so let's say you know the thirty percent

0:42:49of the books of the 20 to 30 books that

0:42:51you've read uh and and also your

0:42:54intellectual process in digesting them

0:42:56somehow led you so astray

0:42:59whereas the 20 to 30 books that I've

0:43:00read have given me this like this like

0:43:03diamond tip insight into the whole human

0:43:06condition

0:43:08I I let me do one of the things that

0:43:11there with what that person said which I

0:43:13mean I can understand that

0:43:14I mean if I have somebody I mean as much

0:43:16as we kid and stuff on here when people

0:43:18say like super like racially offensive

0:43:19things and are obviously like just

0:43:21dropping dropping science on you about

0:43:23how the world is and that bugs me you

0:43:25know i don't want to be around that

0:43:27sure but you know first of all I'm not

0:43:29sure what I can do to necessarily turn

0:43:31that person around that I've never met

0:43:32but you know what with what that woman

0:43:34said i would be even though i would

0:43:36never do this publicly but I would be

0:43:38inclined to say so you decided you don't

0:43:40want to write songs for being a band

0:43:41because of what i said well no of course

0:43:43not

0:43:43okay why is that well because I'm

0:43:45smarter than that I know okay so you

0:43:47assume that all these other people that

0:43:49you theoretically care about this mass

0:43:51of people that are so stupid and

0:43:53malleable that these words that I chosen

0:43:55this ese are going to make them not want

0:43:57to start a band is that is that the case

0:43:59that you're going to make because all

0:44:00the sudden now you're the one who's

0:44:02smarter than all these other people

0:44:03because you see you see through the

0:44:05matrix right you that they live thing

0:44:07where you've got the sunglasses right

0:44:09and that's what i think is actually it's

0:44:11a little it's a little bit offensive

0:44:12because you get to pick and choose like

0:44:14who you get to decide you're smarter

0:44:15than and it's really just a question of

0:44:16going in educating everybody about all

0:44:18these little people that need to be

0:44:19looked after in this completely

0:44:20paternalistic way this is what's so

0:44:23interesting about what's happening in

0:44:24France right now with the with the guide

0:44:28on the lady a guy doctor lady in front

0:44:31of I think the president was having

0:44:33intercourse with someone who wasn't his

0:44:34wife

0:44:35Oh see that happens a lot there no that

0:44:37doesn't interest me at all know that so

0:44:41the whole the whole notion of French

0:44:44identity in sort of the the whole

0:44:48history of France post-revolution was

0:44:52the french said we don't see race

0:44:56we don't know if you come to France and

0:44:59adopt the french language and learn the

0:45:01French culture you are a Frenchman and

0:45:05it doesn't matter if you were born in

0:45:07Algeria or in Vietnam we the the idea of

0:45:11a Frenchman of a other of a citizen of

0:45:14France is that you adopt the these these

0:45:19the following premises that you know

0:45:24that the the the citizen has life

0:45:28liberty and the gala tea and that we are

0:45:32all equal under the law and you know a

0:45:35lot of notions in France that came from

0:45:37the American Revolution a lot of notions

0:45:39in France that are internal to France

0:45:40but that there is a French identity that

0:45:46supersedes all other cultural racial

0:45:52economic identities and that for 200

0:46:02years has been the core of the of what i

0:46:06meant to be French and and and in a way

0:46:09it was the most democratic notion of

0:46:13citizenship you think most people

0:46:16believe that I think in France they

0:46:18really do including people who are not

0:46:21Gallic white people absolutely i mean

0:46:24this is this is a this is the and this

0:46:26is francis version of the melting pot

0:46:29you know America's version of the

0:46:30melting pot is show up now you're an

0:46:33American and you and anybody can become

0:46:36a million work hard and play by the

0:46:37rules

0:46:38that's right and all over and

0:46:39everybody's vote and it's fair here and

0:46:42so you can be anybody could be President

0:46:45you know that's the american version the

0:46:48French version is is maybe

0:46:51understandably more identity-based like

0:46:54it isn't just that you that anybody can

0:46:58be President it is that we are all now

0:47:03equal under the idea that we are that we

0:47:06are Frenchmen like we are brothers and

0:47:09sisters brothers and sisters right and

0:47:13political politically brothers and

0:47:15sisters you know I it's a very it's it's

0:47:19a super seductive idea to them and it's

0:47:22the core of the whole idea i mean when

0:47:24we we only look at it from outside and a

0:47:28lot of it seems a lot of it is kind of

0:47:31the the French pomposity and the that

0:47:34the arrogance like the this is the this

0:47:39is the sunny side of that you know that

0:47:41this is the this is what's beautiful

0:47:44about being French but as in the last 20

0:47:48years there have been these massive

0:47:50waves of immigration to France and the

0:47:54French have been wrestling with how to

0:47:57maintain this thing that is so key to

0:48:01them and it's like it is it's like a

0:48:03religion to them which you would you

0:48:06also include the things like language

0:48:08and trying to lock down on things like

0:48:10love facts i mean the effect of running

0:48:12the French language to stay intact as

0:48:13part of that for sure

0:48:15languages key is is the is the heart of

0:48:18it it's the key to and so their approach

0:48:21to immigration has always been welcome

0:48:24thank you for coming to France here is

0:48:27your book of becoming French it involves

0:48:33you now speaking French and thinking

0:48:35French and at home I suppose if you want

0:48:40to keep eating couscous here that is

0:48:41fine here are here is a recipe book of

0:48:44how to make your couscous taste more

0:48:46french but in the meantime we are happy

0:48:52to have you here and we are going to do

0:48:54everything we can to create a a a racist

0:48:58society

0:48:59assuming of course that you're not a

0:49:01gypsy or a Jew but let's leave that

0:49:03aside but actually we welcome the Jews

0:49:06now still a little weird on the gypsies

0:49:08but

0:49:12as as successive waves of people have

0:49:14emigrated from North Africa now all of a

0:49:17sudden they're these gigantic ghettos

0:49:19where the population is largely arab and

0:49:26muslim and so the French have been going

0:49:30through this whole uh this this

0:49:33incredible identity like the national

0:49:36cultural identity problem where they're

0:49:38like well we can't have people walking

0:49:39around in burkas because it's not French

0:49:42it isn't a question of that we are a

0:49:46racist against Muslims or anti-muslim

0:49:50but but the goal in France is that we

0:49:52all be French it is how we manage

0:49:57equality it is our whole idea of

0:49:59equality that we all be not the same but

0:50:04that we share the same values that but

0:50:07that we all be primarily French right

0:50:09now

0:50:09well that we share these cause these

0:50:12core values which are you know this is

0:50:18kind of it that there's a similar

0:50:20argument happening in America except we

0:50:22don't share core values here but there

0:50:26they have these core democratic

0:50:28post-revolution values they they think

0:50:32they do or they it's their values are

0:50:35are are closer to the heart of the idea

0:50:40of themselves this shared sense of

0:50:43values and it's you know it is a at well

0:50:48so it has driven them now to pass a law

0:50:50against wearing burkas and from an

0:50:53American sensibility we're you know that

0:50:57law that that you can't wear a burka in

0:50:59France and in a public school or in a in

0:51:02an office like a government office we

0:51:08just Americans freak out at the notion

0:51:13and it seems very paternalistic and it

0:51:15seems very racist

0:51:18it seems i want a paternalistic it's

0:51:21totalitarian right to tell taryn but

0:51:24from the French standpoint it is like

0:51:30they are trying to us it its full from

0:51:33the French idea it is a very liberal

0:51:35idea this is what's confusing the

0:51:38liberal notion of like French liberalism

0:51:41requires that everybody aspire to be

0:51:45part of this family and to be outside of

0:51:50it seems to them to be a active

0:51:56totalitarianism or to be an act of

0:51:58hostility that threatens the whole that

0:52:05threatens the safety of their of them of

0:52:11their melting pot right if you don't if

0:52:13you don't want to melt into being French

0:52:16like being French is at is at the key of

0:52:21having all the rights of man that that

0:52:25that that you can bend therefore not

0:52:27expect like you can't expect the rights

0:52:30if you don't also perform the duties and

0:52:36so they're so their culture is at war

0:52:41with itself right now it's tearing

0:52:42itself apart and it is it it's it is a

0:52:46it's very interesting to look at it from

0:52:49here to look at it from the United

0:52:51States and see that that that there i

0:52:56mean obviously like the lepen people the

0:53:00be a cultural xenophobes in France are

0:53:03are on this issue too but there's a

0:53:07whole stripe of people that you know

0:53:10that are coming at this question from a

0:53:13liberal democratic perspective there

0:53:16that is that's that's very confusing to

0:53:20watch from here and very I think

0:53:22instructive informative

0:53:25yeah I mean I all the lofty ideas are

0:53:30it's easy enough to agree on something

0:53:32like do you believe in freedom of speech

0:53:34of course everybody agrees and freedom

0:53:35of speech and so you get into the

0:53:36specifics of what that really means

0:53:39are you allowed to say things that

0:53:40aren't true are you allowed to say

0:53:42things that are unkind are you allowed

0:53:43to say things that startup hate when

0:53:45people are you you know do I you know

0:53:48the shot fire in a crowded theater

0:53:49yea yea or you know or I think some

0:53:52people would say this could go on really

0:53:54any end of the spectrum versus the other

0:53:56should I be expected to pay to publish

0:53:59speech that I definitely think is is

0:54:01hateful or untrue

0:54:03for example do i right you should we be

0:54:06paying should we be paying to have

0:54:07textbooks in our schools that say

0:54:11evolution is true

0:54:12should we be paying to have textbooks in

0:54:14our school that say that evolution is

0:54:16wrong

0:54:17I mean you know that's right that is i'm

0:54:19probably splitting hairs here but I

0:54:20think anybody agrees on those big issues

0:54:23its just its implementation details but

0:54:25there where you get all the truth

0:54:27well this is why the Supreme Court of

0:54:29the United States and the Congress and

0:54:32the presidency were such a what were

0:54:35such a brilliant idea and you know the

0:54:37idea that the Supreme Court could take a

0:54:41law and set limits on aspects of it you

0:54:48know that that that that that boat the

0:54:50Congress made law it went past the

0:54:52President and he got to you know he got

0:54:55to take a swipe at it if he could but

0:54:59then the citizens to challenge the law

0:55:02and the court could make a well could

0:55:08the court could rule on beat you on

0:55:12behalf of us like the idea that there

0:55:16was an us survived until not very long

0:55:22ago and it's it's a it's a thing as a

0:55:26historical us

0:55:28well yeah and that that where I mean

0:55:30like when it is not kind of what the

0:55:31Supreme Court is it speaking of us but

0:55:33its its kind of to say like is this is

0:55:35this what was intended

0:55:37oh no I mean well you know it that is a

0:55:39modern problem that the Supreme Court

0:55:42was always meant to be in it was always

0:55:45meant to evolve and the idea that the

0:55:48founders didn't intend that the court

0:55:50would interpret the conversation in

0:55:52modern terms is a crazy conservative

0:55:55reactionary nut story that the same kind

0:56:00of people think the Bible was written in

0:56:02English yeah right i mean has always had

0:56:04the same 66 books it if you've read

0:56:07anything about the founders the Scalia

0:56:09notion that they meant that this you

0:56:12know that that that that that the

0:56:15founders meant that we should try and

0:56:17get inside their minds and think about

0:56:19what they meant instead of that they

0:56:21meant exactly you know that they met

0:56:23what they wrote and that we should be

0:56:25like interpreting that but based on the

0:56:28fact that we now have handheld computers

0:56:31in our eyeglasses or III health

0:56:33computers are hey al computer it's um

0:56:36like it it seems crazy to me but no I i

0:56:39mean the the evolve and ever-evolving

0:56:42notion that there was an American soul

0:56:46of a kind or that there was an American

0:56:48identity that we were all aspiring to

0:56:54melt into was a notion that was still in

0:56:58place in a largely in place at least in

0:57:02the school's when you and I were kids

0:57:05and it was it was fraying and there were

0:57:07obviously there was a there were whole

0:57:09segments of the population that said

0:57:12we're not even included in that you

0:57:14never included us in that and we want we

0:57:18want entry into it at the time even then

0:57:23that it was only the fringe voices that

0:57:26said we don't want entry into it we want

0:57:29to burn it down

0:57:30we want to tear that identity of park

0:57:33like the vast majority of the

0:57:35disenfranchised only wanted to be

0:57:37franchised

0:57:39and it's only in the last time you have

0:57:42said the same have the same rights that

0:57:43anybody else already had to have to have

0:57:45the same rights and to be included in

0:57:47that notion of American and to be and to

0:57:50have their voices considered and to be

0:57:53to just expand the franchise to include

0:57:57everybody that really was already in it

0:57:59which is something that the French did

0:58:01much better than the Americans did it in

0:58:05the sense that they headaches that they

0:58:07that that franchise was expanded I mean

0:58:10and obviously like the Dreyfus Affair

0:58:11whenever the that they up through the

0:58:15war they were still pretty bad on Jews

0:58:18and and and Roma but the the French of

0:58:26it have sought to expand that franchise

0:58:28a lot more liberally than the Americans

0:58:30did but it's only in the last 20 years

0:58:33that that the idea that that this

0:58:39american-ness even that that that are

0:58:42shared aspirations that a commonality

0:58:45would be something that we would

0:58:48disparage and something that an educated

0:58:52liberal person would want no part of and

0:58:56would would want would instead choose to

0:58:59mock and dried you know that that to sit

0:59:03and talk about a like a an American

0:59:11identity to talk about that as something

0:59:16that is inherently oppressive

0:59:19intrinsically oppressive rather than

0:59:23something that is of a framework that we

0:59:26can make that and we should be trying to

0:59:29make better always and that making it

0:59:32more inclusive is our goal rather than

0:59:37to you know to destroy them to destroy

0:59:42the framework in favor of who you are

0:59:47implying who are you saying once that or

0:59:50has been doing that

0:59:51I don't like the far right wing nut

0:59:53types

0:59:54well like going to the compound kind of

0:59:56people I feel like that I feel like

0:59:58there is a huge go to the cops

0:59:58there is a huge go to the cops

1:00:00pound thread in liberalism now although

1:00:04it isn't to the compound it is to a

1:00:07place of like a place of hyper

1:00:12multiculturalism to the point that all

1:00:15that it is that it's like george bush's

1:00:18thousand points of light except that

1:00:20thousand points of light is a thousand

1:00:22equal viewpoints none of which can be

1:00:24privileged over any other so that it is

1:00:28a so that every voice is heard in equal

1:00:32volume and in that constellation of

1:00:37voices there will be some collected

1:00:40wisdom there will be some there were

1:00:43there will be a common knowledge or

1:00:45understanding that we can we cannot know

1:00:48yet we cannot know the result of this

1:00:51experiment until it we have achieved it

1:00:54and to guess at it is to second-guess it

1:00:59which is which is to stand in the way of

1:01:02it and that are that the only valid goal

1:01:05can be a time when all voices are

1:01:09represented with with no privilege and

1:01:14this is the idea of this of the word

1:01:15privilege can and and and and flinging

1:01:18privilege at people as an epithet that

1:01:22this is this is the liberal side of this

1:01:24yeah that only when we arrive at a place

1:01:26where no voice has pride of privileged

1:01:30no voices heard more loudly than any

1:01:32other can we fully know ourselves or

1:01:37have a tour or be close to achieving

1:01:42like a understanding human understanding

1:01:46or collective wisdom and it's a it's the

1:01:50what I think is the under girding idea

1:01:54of this you know this this like

1:02:00Quasimodo axis to move on up on the part

1:02:04of the intellectual world in American

1:02:08Left intellectual life

1:02:11to always be attacking privilege to

1:02:13always be second-guessing language to

1:02:16always be equalizing voices the the only

1:02:24premise and it's an unspoken premise no

1:02:26one ever discusses it openly but the

1:02:28only premise I can see at the heart of

1:02:31it is the idea that only once all voices

1:02:34are heard only was all voices are equal

1:02:37can we know can we even know what our

1:02:40project is & big because as you as you

1:02:45as you see any time someone stands up

1:02:48and says i have an opinion the first

1:02:53question is what right do you have to

1:02:55speak who are you are you are going on

1:02:57his on his billiard behalf key to speak

1:02:59right are you just another middle-class

1:03:03white person because we've heard what

1:03:07you have to say and it you know it is a

1:03:12blanket dismissal of antenna and the

1:03:15reality is what any one person has to

1:03:17say is in a lot of ways

1:03:19irrespective of what their races or

1:03:21their classes right i mean the world of

1:03:25ideas the whole premise of it is that it

1:03:28can exist in one's mind that yes is

1:03:32influenced by its by its culture yes is

1:03:35influenced by its experience but also

1:03:37that's the beautiful thing about an idea

1:03:40you can have an idea that is in conflict

1:03:42with how you were raised with how you

1:03:45were how you other the culture in which

1:03:48you live it's how ideas

1:03:51advertise themselves like I can think of

1:03:56opposite of me and that's what makes it

1:04:01a thought right and to to argue that my

1:04:05thoughts are are all water stamped with

1:04:10my race and culture is to be

1:04:15anti-intellectual I guess

1:04:18at its core and what thats whats in

1:04:20that's what's insane about about this

1:04:23notion is that ultimately it is it is

1:04:28anti thinking and it you know it becomes

1:04:33like it it's seeking to kill this idea

1:04:38that you can be that there's something

1:04:41about being French or about being

1:04:43American that is that's worth preserving

1:04:47or that is an identity that that has

1:04:51responsibilities as well as rights

1:04:54attended to it that every right has a

1:04:57has a concomitant responsibility that

1:05:01goes along with it

1:05:02hmm i don't know i'm john pretty I'm

1:05:08pretty skeptical about first of all I I

1:05:11I feel like if you look at any anytime

1:05:15that people who are in a minority and RB

1:05:17being treated poorly end up getting out

1:05:20of that there has to be a period along

1:05:22what did stalin calling you know there's

1:05:25that period where you at the the shit

1:05:28was called the dictatorship of the

1:05:30proletariat what they called it there's

1:05:33a period like okay we have the

1:05:34dictatorship of the proletariat there's

1:05:35going to be this period i gotta let you

1:05:37guys know things are going to be a

1:05:39little bit rough here in the Soviet

1:05:41Union while we make sure that we get

1:05:43good and Soviet Union

1:05:45yeah let's say 30 million dead but ok no

1:05:49no i'm not i'm not trying to draw that

1:05:51line exactly what I'm saying that I

1:05:52think if you look at any group you have

1:05:53to be radicalized at some point in order

1:05:55to get noticed and in order to be heard

1:05:58in order to attract people to

1:06:00understanding hangs this is kind of this

1:06:02is real screwed-up people are people

1:06:04getting lynched like innocent innocent

1:06:06people are being lynched for no reason

1:06:09and like that's it that we have to stop

1:06:11this guy's this is that this is a

1:06:13terrible thing and so there's a period

1:06:14where you have to set yourself apart and

1:06:16and be heard and but I don't know and

1:06:19this is maybe this is the privilege

1:06:20talking but I feel like there are there

1:06:21are so many people who cannot wait to

1:06:25lose their own identity inside of some

1:06:28bigger group because that's where they

1:06:29feel like they did the identity that

1:06:31they seek

1:06:31fine ironically enough is by being in

1:06:35the group that's shouting everybody else

1:06:36down and you know is 011 him while I

1:06:40understand I understand I understand and

1:06:41respect the need to be heard and have

1:06:44your needs redressed however you decide

1:06:46to do it

1:06:47I've always I'm always a little bit

1:06:49skeptical of people who seem to be

1:06:51getting addicted to being the underdog

1:06:53because i'm not sure that is an

1:06:56empowering approach to life

1:06:57well my people were super white trash so

1:07:00I don't know what you're talking about

1:07:02oh you have people to my super white

1:07:05trash people just like basically had to

1:07:08do it all themselves well look both my

1:07:09parents were addicted to super fun and I

1:07:12had to raise myself inside of my own

1:07:14diaper super fun you know about you guys

1:07:17probably had cocaine we can do for

1:07:19cooking we had super fun super fun

1:07:21yeah yeah there's a pencil shavings and

1:07:23coop you snorted it or I shot it didn't

1:07:26matter didn't do anything to ruin their

1:07:27lives

1:07:28you know there are 300 million Americans

1:07:30and that is a tiny tiny tiny fraction of

1:07:36the people in the world really a small

1:07:40number of people like two percent so my

1:07:43point now

1:07:44no I can't be right I'm not doing math

1:07:46well there's a six billion people right

1:07:49yeah I think closer to seven and in all

1:07:56of in a it and I and I really think that

1:07:59that at least right now that we America

1:08:03has stopped manufacturing cars really

1:08:06except for chrysler i don't know i think

1:08:09about the possibilities let's extract

1:08:11some for Christ's yeah I heard her I

1:08:13heard the measure radiant and I thought

1:08:16I was having a stroke they put their

1:08:17potential is there something more

1:08:18American than America but i don't think

1:08:20so i don't think so how the turnout was

1:08:22a dignified ah he looked a little

1:08:25plastic surgery but his face was and he

1:08:29can space was super init bobtailing and

1:08:32his face we're talking about chrysler in

1:08:34a commercial

1:08:34yeah he looked like his face looked like

1:08:37a change purse that simple

1:08:39why don't you remember when he wouldn't

1:08:43even let people use his songs first up

1:08:45yeah that those days are gone but but I

1:08:48mean even with that

1:08:49yeah like calendar let's make your car

1:08:52because will is anything more American

1:08:54than America even that is really what

1:08:57we're exporting his ideas and the Act

1:09:01the ideas and the the the bullshit that

1:09:05we are coming up with in terms of energy

1:09:08entertainment infotainment and this

1:09:12amusement and the info musn't and this

1:09:15huge fire hose of ideas that we are just

1:09:18spraying into the air like being the

1:09:21entirety of it is a product of the

1:09:26privilege that we have scraped and

1:09:29stolen from the rest of the world like

1:09:31we have created hey a salon in this

1:09:36country out of some some shit we found

1:09:41on the ground when we got here that we

1:09:43that we that we killed the people that

1:09:46were here already and took and then all

1:09:49the raping that we do the daily daily

1:09:52cultural raping that we do we have

1:09:55created a salon where we are producing

1:09:57chrysler ads angry birds and a like

1:10:06Sheila booth movies when you put it that

1:10:11way and I'm so like criticism from

1:10:19within here seems so like so much a

1:10:25product I mean it's all still in the

1:10:29ship down like all all of the cultural

1:10:34criticism all of the angry Twitter

1:10:35yelling it's all in the same fountain of

1:10:39of like language culture we are

1:10:43we are deriving me where we are we are

1:10:46producing on behalf of the world right

1:10:49now in this moment in time and a hundred

1:10:54fifty years from now we may be speaking

1:10:56Indonesian here and that all may be gone

1:10:59up and right now it seems like we

1:11:02ourselves to be digesting it as

1:11:06open-mindedly as possible the stuff that

1:11:10we're making the ideas that we're having

1:11:12it seems like an incredible missed

1:11:15opportunity to not be adopting and

1:11:18espousing the most open-minded possible

1:11:22way of thinking as a group of people and

1:11:24as a culture because we are you know

1:11:28where we're in a rare moment we're all

1:11:32we're being asked to do is generate

1:11:33ideas all we are responsible for is

1:11:38making words and ideas and games and

1:11:43plays and to be to be turning on

1:11:49ourselves and you know hyper nitpicking

1:11:53looking for a grammar of of equality

1:12:00when every idea could be in play every

1:12:06single notion is up in the air its it is

1:12:10a it's a strange impulse and one that I

1:12:14don't know it's very human but and and

1:12:18when you have them we spend your day

1:12:20looking for that grammar of equality

1:12:21something else is gonna happen when you

1:12:22talked about before which is the bad

1:12:24words problem and so we all we all agree

1:12:27or are compelled to agree that there are

1:12:29is this increasing corpus of bad words

1:12:31these things we must never use or we

1:12:33must always use Oh bad ideas are are the

1:12:36are the real scary thing right but the

1:12:38bad ideas and the problems I'm trying to

1:12:40get at though is you can continue to to

1:12:43your southern sheriff speak around your

1:12:45buddies and that's not gonna do a damn

1:12:47thing except you make you feel more and

1:12:49more like you're the one who's

1:12:50marginalized now it's for everybody

1:12:52are all of our friends over here on the

1:12:54left side of the dial there are just as

1:12:56many people on the other side who are

1:12:58just as incredulous about how they've

1:13:00been left behind

1:13:01yeah and and that just we just keep we

1:13:03just keep making that split like broader

1:13:05and broader when we keep saying which

1:13:08ideas are ok to think the idea that's

1:13:11curious to me right now is that football

1:13:14is this terrible crime that we are

1:13:19inflicting on football players right

1:13:22that football is violent which is like a

1:13:25new idea i guess to some people that had

1:13:29permanently like well yeah and that

1:13:31these and that these football players

1:13:32are being for our amusement

1:13:38this is the beginning of every one of

1:13:39these sort of screens for our for the

1:13:42amusement of some rich corporations

1:13:44these football players are being paid

1:13:48millions of dollars to hit each other

1:13:50really hard and then 20 years later they

1:13:52have parkinson's disease and this is a

1:13:54thing that should be outlawed and it the

1:13:59the premise of that argument that this

1:14:03is what this is what confuses me it is

1:14:06like threaded throughout these arguments

1:14:12is a kind of weird it's the same

1:14:14argument that the catholic church uses

1:14:17to fight abortion and the death penalty

1:14:21it is the idea that human life is

1:14:24somehow sacred above and beyond any

1:14:28individual human life and what that

1:14:30human life actually is or represents but

1:14:34that the I that the that human life

1:14:37capital H capital L is somehow sacred

1:14:41and more important more valuable than it

1:14:46might appear to be in any one instance

1:14:48and so the fact that these football

1:14:52players are hurting themselves and that

1:14:55they do it knowingly

1:14:57and that they do it for great reward and

1:15:01that they are heroes and champions but

1:15:05then later on the they suffer and maybe

1:15:08when maybe when somebody said to them

1:15:10when they were sixteen or twenty like

1:15:12you know someday you're going to suffer

1:15:14maybe they didn't know exactly what that

1:15:16meant and they agreed to something that

1:15:18they couldn't I couldn't possibly have

1:15:20understood all the way implying that the

1:15:23people who gave him that money new to a

1:15:25pretty good certainty that they were

1:15:26going to get right the head injuries are

1:15:28some of the people that give him that

1:15:29money were like actually relishing that

1:15:31one day they were going to have

1:15:33parkinson's disease but that you know

1:15:37and I think about this in terms of

1:15:38Muhammad Ali one of the great champions

1:15:40of Human of the 20th century and human

1:15:43life and human Muhammad Ali is suffering

1:15:45from from a tremor from Parkinson's and

1:15:48a tremor that that we that that kind of

1:15:51shames us and that we wouldn't have

1:15:52wished on him he is our hero but would

1:15:56anyone have had Muhammad Ali not fight

1:16:01would anyone have asked Muhammad Ali to

1:16:04have fought one fight fewer like

1:16:09Muhammad Ali fought he was a hero to the

1:16:11world he's the most recognized name on

1:16:14the planet and and in his later years he

1:16:18suffers the battle damage and the the

1:16:25idea that we would put a stop that the

1:16:27other that we would do anything other

1:16:28than celebrate every aspect of it you

1:16:31know because the fact is we don't know

1:16:33if Muhammad Ali had never boxed whether

1:16:36or not he would have gotten Parkinson's

1:16:37anyway because we don't understand

1:16:40Parkinson's hoo keek you know my my

1:16:43grand aunt died of Parkinson's and she

1:16:45was never in a boxing match

1:16:48so wait now is you're saying so I'm part

1:16:50of that is that we've got information

1:16:51that we didn't have 4050 years ago I

1:16:55sorts of things

1:16:56yes you complete using you're saying it

1:16:58retroactive continuity let's go back and

1:17:00sort of let that's all collectively

1:17:02disparage what boxing has done over the

1:17:05years in order to make sure it never

1:17:06happens again

1:17:07are you saying it so

1:17:09I'm but yeah you don't think that we

1:17:11should take the information we know

1:17:12about things like traumatic brain injury

1:17:14and try to prevent it

1:17:15well I don't have heavier guys hitting

1:17:19harder you know I would see what seems

1:17:22to me is that I me know when i'm in

1:17:25brooklyn now and every kid under the age

1:17:29of 14 is wearing a bicycle helmet to go

1:17:32to the store and not even on a bicycle

1:17:35the parents are just putting their

1:17:37putting helmets on him just to go out

1:17:38the door because of what we think we

1:17:41know about traumatic brain injury and

1:17:43how dangerous the world is like

1:17:46ultimately the world is dangerous human

1:17:50life is nasty brutish and short we not

1:17:53one of us dies the way we would want

1:17:56there is no way for us to live forever

1:18:01there is no way for us to escape disease

1:18:04there is no way for us to escape injury

1:18:08and yet in these certain pockets of of

1:18:15what it is to be human

1:18:17we suddenly described all this injustice

1:18:20to certain kinds of injuries to certain

1:18:24kinds of disease to certain kinds of

1:18:27misfortune and by ascribing injustice to

1:18:32it it doesn't mean that those things

1:18:35actually are in just it's just that

1:18:38we've described injustice to them and

1:18:40and so the traumatic brain injury that a

1:18:44football player receives is now a source

1:18:47of all this this conversation to the

1:18:51effect that maybe we should ban

1:18:53football-playing but the traumatic brain

1:18:55injury of all the US soldiers that are

1:18:57just receiving brain injury as a result

1:19:00of bombs going off around them all the

1:19:02time

1:19:03that's a conversation that we're tabling

1:19:05for now and the fact that people get

1:19:09traumatic brain injury all the time just

1:19:11driving in their cars or playing on the

1:19:13playground

1:19:15is a thing that we cannot describe an

1:19:17injustice to so we just accept as part

1:19:21of life and the reality is we all die so

1:19:27soon and that human life actually is not

1:19:32that precious you know and that every

1:19:36death is a tragedy to the people

1:19:37standing immediately in the vicinity of

1:19:39it but as you get further away from any

1:19:43one particular death in either time or

1:19:46geography that death recedes and

1:19:49importance until right now there are

1:19:52hundreds of thousands of people dying

1:19:53all around the world of various causes

1:19:55some of them incredibly in just but none

1:19:58of us are thinking about them or have

1:20:01the capacity to think about them and

1:20:04what what what confuses me is that

1:20:06sometimes we will decide that one

1:20:11person's life or a small group of

1:20:13people's lives have this sanctity all of

1:20:17a sudden and that their deaths are so in

1:20:21just because we imagine that the that

1:20:28the there's injustice in the prematurity

1:20:31of their death that their debt their

1:20:32lives could have been prolonged or that

1:20:35that the you know that the the deaths

1:20:39are the product of some conspiracy and

1:20:45it's never a question of like that

1:20:47person's you know like James

1:20:48Gandolfini's death is a tragedy because

1:20:50of all the movies he didn't make and I i

1:20:54saw a movie with him the other day and I

1:20:55was like that makes me sad his death is

1:20:57a tragedy i wish i had seen some movies

1:20:58he made but some more movies that he

1:21:02made but really no James Gandolfini died

1:21:05when he died and he did what he did and

1:21:10there isn't a tragic element to it

1:21:13ultimately its it is a it in a way there

1:21:18is no tragedy because

1:21:23all things are happening as they are

1:21:26happening you know it's it is a trick of

1:21:29the mind to think that really that there

1:21:35is such a thing as injustice and it

1:21:40isn't to say that that trick of the mind

1:21:42isn't real and that we don't live in a

1:21:44world where that trick of the mind is as

1:21:47real to us as anything but it is a

1:21:53technology of the mind it's an it's up

1:21:56it's an idea a mental process that we

1:22:02don't investigate we we just think we

1:22:08accept the notion that but there are

1:22:12tragic deaths and the more boxes we can

1:22:17take off prevent to bowl a violent

1:22:22uncool somebody else profited you know

1:22:26we're checking up all these boxes in on

1:22:28the injustice checklist and we will

1:22:32check out enough of them and it's like

1:22:33this is an injustice and this other one

1:22:36is more just and then that one is a

1:22:39righteous longer whatever and it's just

1:22:40like it's all part of a it's all part of

1:22:45a game we're playing with ourselves that

1:22:47we're not that we don't reflect on my

1:22:51guess is my only comment on it and I

1:22:54wish we did

1:22:58is this another one

1:23:05not gonna put out yeah but this 1i have

1:23:10to be so bad