Podcast Search

Roderick on the Line

Ep. 65: "Trumpet Discrimination"

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00hello

0:00:05I John hi Merlin how's it going good

0:00:12surely it's early it's literally my

0:00:25daughter's got a persistent cough yeah

0:00:28it's going around everybody's got it

0:00:30yeah it's it's gotten productive which

0:00:32is hard when you're a kid

0:00:33yeah that's bad yeah it's just taking

0:00:36expectorant as much as I'd like I'm

0:00:38totally fine with driving our daughter

0:00:41up in my wife is kind of rude about it

0:00:43OIC yeah but there's a lot going around

0:00:46that introduces school and there

0:00:49everything's going around the edges are

0:00:51hotbeds of sick little sponges I

0:00:55throughout my sponges all the time

0:00:56they're disgusting scott simpson Bobby

0:00:58someone he considered some kind of magic

0:01:01Japanese sponge prices for everything

0:01:03you want to that one store

0:01:04yeah and I and it was it's great except

0:01:07here's the thing

0:01:08it's a white sponge yeah now if you're

0:01:11going to if you're going to make a

0:01:12sponger color don't make a white now

0:01:15that's a terrible color that first time

0:01:17I used it then it looked like i used it

0:01:19on something that was dirty and then I

0:01:21had like a permanently dirty sponge you

0:01:23gotta live with that I gotta live with

0:01:25that I'll every time I go to the sink i

0:01:26turn the water and look down and here's

0:01:28this sponge that's like spoiled well and

0:01:31you know a lot of its breeding I think

0:01:33like we're not from wealthy families and

0:01:36you know certain kinds of things in the

0:01:38home you use them until they're not

0:01:40usable anymore that's my background

0:01:42yeah but scott simpson you're saying you

0:01:45would they use the sponge once and then

0:01:47they threw it out the window and the

0:01:48gardener took it away

0:01:50mm I think that's where he is now

0:01:52absolutely as you know he's extremely

0:01:54rich from a context is rich and but I

0:01:58think he's from a very modest background

0:02:00to with one exception of ever told you

0:02:02this you know his mom had a band and

0:02:05what

0:02:06yeah GD had uniforms like it may be

0:02:08marching band i don't think so i think

0:02:10was a rock band

0:02:11they did you really yeah they played out

0:02:14you know that kind of playing out where

0:02:15you play at your friends events and I'm

0:02:17guessing they probably would just assume

0:02:18you just brought ice

0:02:20I don't know children yeah yeah and so

0:02:22so he was in a amazing situation that I

0:02:25would have killed for which is he could

0:02:26just walk downstairs with his pals and

0:02:29there's a hole in the basement there's

0:02:30like a whole setup we could just walk

0:02:33down there and like play instruments

0:02:34will now hear this

0:02:35this just brings me to an interesting

0:02:37internal dilemma that I have which is

0:02:41that I went to a pop music conference

0:02:44last weekend when I was the keynote

0:02:45speaker

0:02:47haha it took place in Bellingham

0:02:49Washington

0:02:50yeah like where this is going and fat

0:02:53and so I I prepared this speech

0:02:57blah blah blah speech but I got to the

0:02:59top conference early in contravention of

0:03:01my normal method i'm showing up to an

0:03:03event one second before i take the stage

0:03:05it's better for security reasons if

0:03:07nothing else I when I went instead and i

0:03:10attended out maxing out in the green

0:03:13room for five hours

0:03:14well no he did not now he walked in and

0:03:16that was the beginning of a satisfactory

0:03:18could see the door so I go to this thing

0:03:21and I go to all these panels and it's

0:03:23happening in bellingham washington ice

0:03:24is sure to you sure you rather I do not

0:03:28assure to you to her

0:03:29mm-hmm I every one of these panels is

0:03:36blowing my mind and it's blowing my mind

0:03:37primarily because they're talking about

0:03:39pop music and pop news business but

0:03:42there is an element of like the the

0:03:48expectation of the panelists was that

0:03:50they would address some issues they

0:03:52would address the issue of social

0:03:53justice they would address the issue of

0:03:57community building and inclusiveness as

0:04:00they were answering questions about how

0:04:02do i get my band signed and how do I you

0:04:07know like how do i promote my record

0:04:09above via social media but how do I

0:04:11about also how do I further the cause of

0:04:15social justice and increased diversity

0:04:18into Poppins or in in like the music

0:04:22scene in general

0:04:23and and there was and there was a

0:04:25predictable amount of like sort of like

0:04:27mild college like bubbling hostility in

0:04:33that goes along with both the asker's

0:04:36and the answers of questions like that

0:04:37and the whole you know the whole day the

0:04:41premise was like um yeah hi um I'm just

0:04:45wondering why are there not more Inupiaq

0:04:49rock bands as anybody really thought

0:04:52about that and like maybe we should all

0:04:55look at our our playlists and see like

0:04:59that like we don't have any Inupiat

0:05:02bands and is that a problem

0:05:04I don't know i'm not sure my question is

0:05:06M and the end up for the person that's

0:05:09on the panel is like like someone who

0:05:12works in the music business and they're

0:05:14like uh ah I don't you know like like

0:05:20like absolutely flabbergasted at what

0:05:23how to try to answer that question

0:05:24well cast question maybe the were you

0:05:27aware and where the other panelists

0:05:29aware that social justice would be a

0:05:31focus of the bellingham pop conference

0:05:33or howhow prepared were you in your

0:05:37remarks for example

0:05:39yeah well my remarks had no elements no

0:05:43social social justice consideration in

0:05:46them since Ron hey Ron I was up there I

0:05:51was getting ready to give a keynote

0:05:52speech at this bar conference that was

0:05:54basically a hate crime and so on the fly

0:05:58I through my notes in the garbage can

0:06:00and I should recycle that's i did in

0:06:04fact i did in fact recycling and you

0:06:06know

0:06:06and truth be told i was using Merlin

0:06:09Mann three-by-five cards which I never

0:06:12used to do but i do it now and an homage

0:06:15to you thank you so so by the time I got

0:06:19to my by the time we arrived at my

0:06:21keynote speech i had been to 10 panels

0:06:24and every one of them have this kind of

0:06:28like we need to search our souls to see

0:06:31how we can make it easier for everybody

0:06:36in the world

0:06:37to become a rock star and and by that we

0:06:40don't mean like how to make it easier in

0:06:42the world for everybody to be a rock

0:06:43star and then also by the way how do i

0:06:45get my band on the radio and so i got up

0:06:49at things I mean just to be honest I

0:06:51mean being a rock star seems pretty

0:06:53phallocentric and patriarchal well don't

0:06:57you think I mean shouldn't we shouldn't

0:06:58we all be equal i can like I i could not

0:07:02speak to that and and and part of it was

0:07:05just that like being a rock star really

0:07:08i mean that's really that's really still

0:07:11thing that we do what I wanted in your

0:07:15guitar at the spot but I wanted to I

0:07:18wanted to address it because they were

0:07:20there were actually some very thoughtful

0:07:21panelists and and and in general you

0:07:27know I I feel like that I feel like that

0:07:29dialogue of like um hi

0:07:31yeah I I just feel like people with

0:07:34allergies should be allowed to play

0:07:37coachella but there's a lot of dust in

0:07:39the air so how do how do we make

0:07:42coachella accessible to people with

0:07:44allergies like I feel like that kind of

0:07:47question is is almost reflexive in like

0:07:53students now where they're not invested

0:07:57in in the question they are sitting in

0:08:01there sitting in a lecture hall and

0:08:02they're thinking how can i like how do i

0:08:05phrase a question that is going to be a

0:08:09that's going to be kind of a mic drop

0:08:11like nobody thought of that

0:08:14like I i found it i found a a

0:08:17under-represented group of people that

0:08:19nobody thought of and now you're all

0:08:21wishing that you had thought of our

0:08:23music is chella it's kinda it becomes a

0:08:26way of speaking truth to power

0:08:28yeah exactly not that much power there

0:08:30and probably a fairly scant amount of

0:08:32truth

0:08:33yeah that and there isn't and and and

0:08:35and it has become a scenario where

0:08:37people are not actually seeking equality

0:08:40anymore for anybody

0:08:42it is just a it's just a a game of like

0:08:45I have I have exposed

0:08:49the inequality and so gold star for me i

0:08:53asked a question and now I can go back

0:08:55to to facebooking and the professor the

0:09:00professor in every case is forced by by

0:09:03the by the energy or by the by the

0:09:05convention that he has to he or she has

0:09:08to consider that question legitimately

0:09:11you know what I mean like the professor

0:09:12the professor is not in a position to

0:09:14say you know what that's a that's an

0:09:16irrelevant question or or or rather

0:09:18rather the answer which is is ultimately

0:09:23true which is it is impossible to make

0:09:25the world completely accessible to

0:09:27everyone it is simply impossible and so

0:09:29every question phrased within the you

0:09:34know within the umbrella of our end game

0:09:37is to make everything absolutely even

0:09:41and fair is it is the same question

0:09:43basically and it doesn't matter whether

0:09:45you are saying in New Piet's or people

0:09:48with allergies or people with social

0:09:50anxiety disorder it is the same question

0:09:52over and over which is how do we make

0:09:54the world completely fair and we cannot

0:09:56so what we can do is inspire in certain

0:10:00places but it isn't but the game is not

0:10:02to just keep keep finding a smaller and

0:10:05smaller aperture you know

0:10:07yeah anyway so i get up at the pop

0:10:10conference and I say the the reality

0:10:15about making art is that the best art is

0:10:21made in reaction to restriction or

0:10:25limitation that the the the culture in

0:10:30prague in the seventies and sixties

0:10:33produced a whole generation of

0:10:35playwrights and artists that were

0:10:38working in reaction to the regime and as

0:10:43soon as the regime fell all of that art

0:10:47come in name up check play right now you

0:10:51can't really because who knows one and I

0:10:54think he passed

0:10:55well there was that one that became the

0:10:57president of the country you know that

0:10:59is that is the role that are played at

0:11:03that came up in a repressive regime now

0:11:06there are probably 1,000,000 check

0:11:08playwrights and none of them stand out

0:11:09and the reality is we have made making

0:11:12pop music incredibly easy there is no

0:11:15difficulty at all

0:11:16anyone of any age or gender can do as

0:11:21much pop music as they want but it has

0:11:23not improved the quality of pop music if

0:11:26you know what I mean like there are a

0:11:28million bands now and none of them are

0:11:30good because having a barrier to entry

0:11:33having it be difficult is what makes

0:11:37people make good art they make good art

0:11:40almost exactly because they are

0:11:44experiencing the challenge of being

0:11:47forced to make art as their primary

0:11:51voice you know it was me it's like

0:11:53making a diamond like you don't make a

0:11:55diamond by by spreading out the soil and

0:11:57bring it iced tea

0:11:58you know and and you know there has to

0:12:00be a certain for that passion to come

0:12:02out there has to be

0:12:03yeah maybe it's a reaction maybe there's

0:12:05influences but they're happy some some

0:12:07kind of a crucible I think in most cases

0:12:09but like in that the whole thing is so

0:12:11misdirected I don't even know where to

0:12:14begin

0:12:15like if so you're going to create social

0:12:17justice by coming in and talking about

0:12:19pop music in a room I I can't even I

0:12:23can't even begin to address that but but

0:12:25the other thing is like it

0:12:28are they are they people in bellingham I

0:12:30mean so i'm guessing it was an extremely

0:12:32diverse audience of people who had the

0:12:35time to come in and go to a pop music

0:12:36conference about social justice better

0:12:38zinc extraordinarily diverse there was

0:12:40no there was the white kid that was

0:12:42making it pop em there was the highways

0:12:45that was making aI don't know there was

0:12:48a there's a half asian guy but he was on

0:12:50a panel

0:12:51anyway the the the the point of all that

0:12:53was I have been I've been wrestling

0:12:55since the time my daughter was born with

0:12:58the fact that I have a house full of

0:12:59instruments

0:13:01and when i was growing up i bought my

0:13:06first guitar a while i bought my first

0:13:07guitar from my sisters friend who bought

0:13:10it at a swap meet

0:13:13she my sister had a friend who is she

0:13:15she and her friend we're going to start

0:13:16an all-girl duran duran cover band and

0:13:20my sister bought a keyboard and her

0:13:22friend Tracy butter guitar and they set

0:13:26up in the basement and they put their

0:13:28fedoras on and their scarves and their

0:13:32pirate shirts and they put on Rio and

0:13:37plugged in their keyboard in their

0:13:38guitar and and went back like like like

0:13:42like like like and they realize that

0:13:44they couldn't play these instruments and

0:13:46and didn't have a real interest in

0:13:48learning an instrument they just wanted

0:13:50to be in a drain cover band right it's

0:13:53so they say stacked the instruments in

0:13:56the corner where they SAT gathering dust

0:13:59and I walked past him everyday and

0:14:02looked at them and a about a month later

0:14:05I i said to the two girls i was like hey

0:14:08I'm guys gonna do anything with those

0:14:13and Tracy sold me her guitar for 25

0:14:16bucks and my sister course out of spite

0:14:19said don't touch my keyboard and it sat

0:14:22in the corner she went off the ski sat

0:14:25in the corner

0:14:26she never touched it I never touched it

0:14:28it had an inch of dust on it eventually

0:14:30and then at one point she owed me some

0:14:32money and I was like I'll take that

0:14:35keyboard and she was happy to have it go

0:14:38so i ended up with all the duran duran

0:14:40cover band instruments

0:14:42I don't want to really from the daughter

0:14:44thing because I'd love to talk about

0:14:46that but there's this other part of this

0:14:47that obsesses me in the things that I

0:14:49think about which is on the one hand

0:14:51sort of trying to solve the wrong

0:14:53problem and how that's not how the best

0:14:55thing that you can do for somebody it if

0:14:57you had experienced similar experience

0:14:59is to help them understand that as Noble

0:15:02or as theoretically interesting as your

0:15:05goals are if you're trying to solve the

0:15:06wrong problem you're going to Burma

0:15:08screwed because and then you can just

0:15:10dig in further and get deeper and deeper

0:15:12and matter and matter and demonstrate

0:15:13more and more

0:15:14but you know I think our entire culture

0:15:17is trying to solve their own problems

0:15:18but will they sure are there's like

0:15:20three problems with this and then the

0:15:21second one is that you know carpenters

0:15:24who make a lot of furniture don't go to

0:15:26conferences and ask about social justice

0:15:28and carpentry they go out and they build

0:15:30lots of stuff and then they try to be

0:15:32decent human beings and they understand

0:15:34that those are are pretty different

0:15:35things if you don't get your hands

0:15:37around it

0:15:38you're never gonna solve the right

0:15:40problem that was persuaded there was one

0:15:42one panelist who said something very

0:15:44interesting because i am we we

0:15:48constantly hear about institutionalized

0:15:51inequality and I'm for people that are

0:15:54our age we've been hearing about it our

0:15:55whole our whole adult lives I mean this

0:15:58was a this was a concept that was

0:16:00introduced to us first but during the

0:16:03civil rights movement where where we we

0:16:07had to be educated to the fact that just

0:16:10because now blacks had the right to vote

0:16:13did not necessarily mean that they had

0:16:17equal opportunity in the in the country

0:16:20and it was a it was a process of

0:16:22Education of people who had never

0:16:24experienced deprivation that they had to

0:16:27learn like oh I see what you mean if you

0:16:30grow up in a place where there is you

0:16:32know where it where racism is

0:16:35institutionalized even if on the surface

0:16:39of things everybody has the same rights

0:16:41you really are having a very different

0:16:43experience of living in America and it

0:16:45is a tremendous it does present a

0:16:48tremendous disadvantage right so that

0:16:50was a process of Education that happened

0:16:52in America over the course of our our

0:16:57whole lives it's been happening and as

0:17:00time has gone on that franchise of

0:17:03disenfranchisement has been extended so

0:17:07then it was then immediately how you can

0:17:11take the build vocabulary and

0:17:14sensibilities of of really deeply

0:17:17systematically oppressed peoples and

0:17:19then apply to people with bikes right

0:17:22but but when when the when the you know

0:17:26the women's rights move

0:17:27happened it was a say it was a similar

0:17:29process of like oh wait a minute you

0:17:31mean even even well-to-do women who

0:17:35lived a comfortable lives in the city

0:17:37are also write disenfranchised wow

0:17:40that's a new that's a new mental

0:17:42technology and everybody never would

0:17:44have thought of that right yeah and it

0:17:45took years to sink in and again that

0:17:49happen throughout the course of our

0:17:50lives and and so then yeah then the

0:17:53franchise kept getting extended until

0:17:55now it's like people with people with

0:17:58allergies people with a myopia people

0:18:02with social anxiety disorder people with

0:18:05whatever and they are they are it you

0:18:08know making themselves equivalent to two

0:18:13people who have to actually struggle

0:18:15between hates that is people who

0:18:16actually struggled in well and also me i

0:18:20hate it too but but there's an

0:18:23expectancy I think there's a tendency

0:18:25among among everybody and in particular

0:18:28a dare I say it among those of us who

0:18:33who are constantly reminded that we

0:18:37benefit from the structure which is to

0:18:40say white men we benefit from the from

0:18:44the inequality and we benefit from

0:18:46unconsciously and they're there is a

0:18:49tendency on our part to say oh my god

0:18:51we've been hearing about this our whole

0:18:52lives

0:18:53can we can we stop fighting the same

0:18:56battle but I had had a very interesting

0:19:00it right i heard of an interesting thing

0:19:03on one of the panels which was a

0:19:04thoughtful woman who said you know when

0:19:07I was in fourth grade and i joined band

0:19:13i wanted to play the trumpet and i was

0:19:17guided by the hand over to the clarinets

0:19:22and flutes in and as she said it I was

0:19:26like well of course of course you were

0:19:30the clarinet and flute is the girls

0:19:32instrument of the trumpet is a boy's

0:19:34instrument and it it was a it was the

0:19:37most resonant

0:19:38[Music]

0:19:40a example of of of this kind of like

0:19:45ingrained institutionalized gender role

0:19:51based inequality that i had heard in

0:19:54years

0:19:55you know because I because you're so

0:19:57used to being politicized about it and

0:19:59people's talking about like a like a

0:20:01friend of mine came home and said you

0:20:04know quoted the oft-quoted statistic

0:20:06like women are paid 72 cents on the

0:20:07dollar and I said is that true at your

0:20:10at your office or do you feel like you

0:20:13are paid 72 cents to the dollar that

0:20:15your comparably educated and talented

0:20:19co-workers paid and she said what no of

0:20:21course not right and I said does anyone

0:20:24you know work in an environment where

0:20:27that is the case and she said no and I

0:20:31said so what

0:20:32what is I mean I understand the

0:20:35statistic but but when you say it when

0:20:40you say it when you come home and say

0:20:41like women are paid 72 cents on the

0:20:43dollar it is a you say it with with a

0:20:46considerable amount of peak you are

0:20:49angry about it but it isn't something

0:20:51that you or anybody you know is

0:20:52personally experiencing so who are those

0:20:54people who are being paid 72 cents on

0:20:56the dollar if you guys if you if you are

0:20:58making the equivalent of your male

0:21:00counterparts that means in order for

0:21:02that statistic to be true

0:21:03there must be women somewhere in America

0:21:06who are being paid thirty cents on the

0:21:07dollar right and I wonder if they're

0:21:11really if if there if there are two

0:21:14people working the same job and one of

0:21:16them is because of her gender really

0:21:18being paid that much or if it's a

0:21:19statistic that has been massaged and

0:21:23repeated so many times that we take it

0:21:28as we take it as given without examining

0:21:31it i don't know where suffice

0:21:36say that I walked away from this

0:21:37experience both like kind of newly

0:21:42serious about this trumpet the trumpet

0:21:50flute trumpet discrimination the trumpet

0:21:53discrimination and also like and also my

0:21:59feeling was reinforced that that that no

0:22:05one is can no one is really talking

0:22:07about like what's the what is the

0:22:09long-term plan for this movement that

0:22:13has become an institution now it is a

0:22:15revolutionary movement to extend equal

0:22:20rights to all that is that is a Marxist

0:22:25argument ultimately to each according to

0:22:28his need from each according to his

0:22:30ability and we are we are very happy to

0:22:35fight little tiny battles about it all

0:22:39day every day my twitter feed is full of

0:22:41people saying well there's another

0:22:44example of a war on women and and then i

0:22:48click through the link and it's like

0:22:50something that just is it is just an

0:22:55interesting news article not

0:22:56particularly an example of a war on

0:22:59women

0:22:59I mean a you know it is just two parts

0:23:03is that the drive me a little bananas i

0:23:05mean the the metal part is I really I

0:23:08really resent being saddled with the

0:23:12idea that like because i think it's

0:23:15silly to live inside of these

0:23:18abstractions I don't think that these

0:23:19are important things I think they're

0:23:21important if you want to fucking raise

0:23:23want you to ask for one in because that

0:23:25yeah we can point to a million

0:23:26statistics about other people became

0:23:29point is statistics about ourselves but

0:23:31you know at the one on the one hand I

0:23:32understand why you would want to adopt

0:23:34that attitude because it can be very

0:23:37powerful and can help help bring people

0:23:39together but the second part is it

0:23:41always is so frequently seems to be

0:23:42about like legislating a change of heart

0:23:46and people that aren't you using all

0:23:48about like what

0:23:49let's sit around in this room and set an

0:23:51agenda for how we can make other people

0:23:53better you know and and like images

0:23:56ladies change of heart in someone who's

0:23:58not you

0:23:59yeah that's that is perfect that is a

0:24:01perfect description of it

0:24:03well if you if you want social justice

0:24:04want to get off your ass like once you

0:24:06stop treating it as a problem that needs

0:24:08to be solved by a panel of people in pop

0:24:10music and why don't you go out and do

0:24:11something and if you want the Rays ask

0:24:14for you can see if you want to still

0:24:15like hang your head and and talk about

0:24:18how like you know oppressed you are

0:24:21that's certainly something you're you're

0:24:22free to do but you know we've come a

0:24:25long way from the 1960s it if you go and

0:24:28you if you feel like you're getting 72

0:24:30cents on the dollar ask for a fucking

0:24:32raise that's your that's who you are if

0:24:35you want to be going power yourself go

0:24:36get out there and do it and if you can

0:24:38find a way to bring social justice and

0:24:39pop music

0:24:40why don't you leave the fucking

0:24:41conference and go out there and do it

0:24:43get your hands around the problem learn

0:24:45which parts of it you can do something

0:24:46about and quit worrying about how to

0:24:48change the rest of the world because it

0:24:49doesn't work

0:24:50yeah the at I think that is the kind i

0:24:53think that is ultimately the thing that

0:24:54that is the string that resonates most

0:24:57deeply it's good enough women do that

0:24:59then it's not going to be a problem

0:25:00anymore

0:25:01well ultimately all these questions are

0:25:03our questions that are resolved when you

0:25:07raise your kids right and when you raise

0:25:11your kids to think differently and

0:25:14behave differently in the world and it

0:25:18really is a it really is a thing where

0:25:20you you change your own heart you

0:25:23evangelize yourself you are the primary

0:25:27mission field and then your family and

0:25:32really the I had a very interesting

0:25:36exchange of a few years ago on twitter

0:25:38where I when I asked somebody I I kind

0:25:40of asked the the group this exact

0:25:43question like can you through

0:25:46application of law

0:25:49really really changed the hearts and

0:25:52minds of the people or who are you

0:25:58you know i mean i think in America we

0:26:01see a lot of the division that we have

0:26:04now like the clear division between the

0:26:08two halves of our nation a lot of it is

0:26:12the product of trying to use

0:26:16prescriptive law to change the hearts

0:26:20and minds of half the population what

0:26:25what what a legacy of efficacy we have

0:26:27for that

0:26:28yeah so we keep saying I mean the

0:26:31abortion rights issue is a thing that we

0:26:35have been we've been fighting this

0:26:36battle of the bloody cultural battle

0:26:38that takes up all of our you know it

0:26:42takes up the whole center of our

0:26:43national dialogue and the the reality is

0:26:49that the that Roe versus Wade was a

0:26:51badly decided piece of law and that's

0:26:58why it's constantly under assault

0:26:59because they think they can beat it

0:27:03they think it's bad law and they think

0:27:04they have a shot at the the

0:27:06anti-abortion people yeah the Act the

0:27:08anti-abortion people think they can beat

0:27:09it because it's it is bad law and it's

0:27:12just a matter of time before the right

0:27:14combination of supreme court justices

0:27:17decide to look at it you know it in the

0:27:20narrow confines of the of the legal

0:27:24decision and overturn it not be not on a

0:27:26moral basis but overturn it because it's

0:27:29you know because it was kind of a shitty

0:27:31piece of legal thinking but you know the

0:27:35reality i think is that it bro vs wade

0:27:38was overturned there would be there

0:27:42would be an immediate and mad rush to

0:27:45write new law in its place that was

0:27:48better

0:27:49I mean the of the best thing that could

0:27:50happen to the abortion rights movement

0:27:52is that Roe versus Wade be overturned

0:27:55because the next piece of law would be

0:27:56ironclad

0:27:57I mean I feel like the I feel like the

0:28:00Ark of social justice is long are they

0:28:03are the arc of history is long but it

0:28:04points toward social justice

0:28:06I think that's absolutely true i think

0:28:08that that it is inevitable that we are

0:28:11becoming more liberal and more inclusive

0:28:14and more accessible to everyone right

0:28:19but but we keep trying to we keep trying

0:28:24to use the the lever of law to bring all

0:28:30these people that are that are Gina that

0:28:33really all we can do is kind of wait for

0:28:35them to die and wait for their kid wait

0:28:38for their kids to approve gay marriage

0:28:41you know that we could have made gay

0:28:44marriage legal by the force of law 25

0:28:46years ago and it would have it would

0:28:48have sparked a armed insurrection in the

0:28:52South but we suffered those 20 years and

0:28:59now it's happening and it's happening

0:29:01not because we check now because the law

0:29:05forced people and not because which

0:29:07really change anybody's minds but just

0:29:09because the young people came up and

0:29:11they liked MTV and they watched Sheena

0:29:14queen of the desert and they're like

0:29:15yeah that seems reasonable and they're

0:29:18just attitudes changed and this is that

0:29:20you know I remember being great

0:29:23persuaded by by malcolm x and x a martin

0:29:29luther king when they said you know all

0:29:32wherever told by YT is that we need to

0:29:35wait it's not time yet we need to wait

0:29:38and we're done waiting we're tired of

0:29:41waiting

0:29:41that and the time is now and I and and

0:29:45that was very persuasive and it produced

0:29:47it produced real action real motion that

0:29:50had you know where culturally we were

0:29:54stalled in this weird separate-but-equal

0:29:56miasma

0:29:59but there but that mentality like when

0:30:03you say well you know after after fifty

0:30:08thousand years like maybe get maybe give

0:30:11it another ten when you when you say

0:30:14that now what we're talking about sort

0:30:18of any kind of kind of sea change in the

0:30:22culture you say that to a group of

0:30:23people and they're they're so quick to

0:30:26say like that's what every white man

0:30:27says wait don't think about going back

0:30:30to asking for a raise just as a

0:30:32practical example you know if you if you

0:30:35it's obviously it's more related to your

0:30:37own merits but if you've ever had a job

0:30:40you know that there's some really good

0:30:41time to ask for a raise and some

0:30:43terrible times to ask for the Rays and

0:30:45if you really do want to raise I really

0:30:46isn't completely related but if you want

0:30:48to get a raise and it means a lot to you

0:30:50you have to prepare for that you have to

0:30:52have you have to know all of the facts

0:30:55and understand them in context with

0:30:57reality and the truth is there are

0:30:59better and worse time to ask for a raise

0:31:02but if you are prepared when that time

0:31:04does come you're gonna have a much

0:31:06better chance whether or not like have

0:31:08no matter how much you want it doesn't

0:31:10matter what matters is whether you're

0:31:12prepared and and then in context can ask

0:31:14it at the right time where somebody will

0:31:15of course i'll give you a raise not

0:31:17stupid but you know but the fact just

0:31:19doesn't kind of kind of doesn't it can

0:31:21matter how much you want it and

0:31:22certainly there have been things that

0:31:23changed but but i'm with you and you

0:31:27know there's two times that I I feel a

0:31:29little bit p kid from you again things

0:31:32like Twitter but also just the whole

0:31:33world like obviously doing sports events

0:31:35but the other thing is during elections

0:31:36because every election or anytime

0:31:39there's some kind of political tumbled

0:31:41going on everybody's pick their side

0:31:43ec least in my Twitter feed or amongst

0:31:45my friends I see everybody locking arms

0:31:48to make fun of the other side to

0:31:50browbeat them to call them stupid and to

0:31:52talk about all the ways that they're

0:31:54wrong wrong wrong and wrong wrong and

0:31:57this is this is maybe really reductive

0:31:59but this is how I look at it I will ask

0:32:00you exactly one question when is the

0:32:03last time that somebody calling you

0:32:05stupid and saying how little you knew

0:32:07change your mind because people can sit

0:32:09around all day long and

0:32:11funny Fox TV and shoot fish in a

0:32:13conservative barrel but honestly if

0:32:16you're so goddamn smart when is the last

0:32:17time that you sat and watched fox news

0:32:20and heard about how stupid you are and

0:32:21you want you know what I am kind of

0:32:22stupid

0:32:23I don't think people do that i don't

0:32:24think it's effective and all it does i

0:32:27mean on a larger scale obviously it just

0:32:29makes us more you know we start to see

0:32:32the other side is inhuman and as soon as

0:32:34you see that quote unquote other side to

0:32:36begin with let you know what we're all

0:32:37kind of in the same pot and the more we

0:32:40try and find some kind of a common

0:32:41ground and certainly the politicians do

0:32:42the better off there but I'm trying to

0:32:44say is like you know in addition to this

0:32:46being an incredibly complex problem with

0:32:48a million different angles

0:32:49I don't think you change hearts and

0:32:51minds through either legislation or by

0:32:53making fun of people

0:32:54yeah you know and you consider

0:32:56reconsidering around a room all day long

0:32:57and and come up with some kind of bill

0:32:59of rights for people who play mandolins

0:33:01but i'm not sure that's going to make

0:33:02black people any better off when it

0:33:04comes time to go to bonnaroo em whoa

0:33:06there's a lot of impact in that last

0:33:08sound angry there's a thing on there is

0:33:10nothing on out that you know local or

0:33:13the California Public Radio think today

0:33:15that was really got me thinking I think

0:33:17it's related and it has to do with the

0:33:19aging population the last the oldest of

0:33:22the oldest of baby boomers turned she is

0:33:26the youngest baby boomers turn like 65

0:33:28this year the point being that there are

0:33:30fewer and fewer there are more people

0:33:32who are going to need benefits or what

0:33:34benefits that they have coming to them

0:33:35and fewer and fewer people that are

0:33:37going to be able to supply it right and

0:33:39you know what compounds that hugely is

0:33:42that due to things like the bat like bad

0:33:44economies and things like legislation we

0:33:46don't have enough immigrants coming here

0:33:48anymore and we don't have enough illegal

0:33:50immigrants coming here anymore and so

0:33:52all the sudden everything that we did to

0:33:54keep immigrants from coming here through

0:33:56legislation and so forth is now harming

0:33:58california in addition to have a lot

0:34:00less people that does to sit there in

0:34:02the Sun and pick lettuce that no white

0:34:03person was to pick now we also have this

0:34:06bigger problem of we're not gonna be

0:34:07able to pay for all of these things so I

0:34:10mean to me there's unintended

0:34:11consequences to all these sorts of

0:34:12things but it really comes down to

0:34:14getting off your ass

0:34:15get off twitter and could do something

0:34:17about it if it matters to you want to do

0:34:19something about it you know Martin

0:34:20Luther King did not sit around typing a

0:34:23hundred forty characters and try to

0:34:24change the world

0:34:25it's just that you know you're not

0:34:26invested in that you're invested until

0:34:28the next to change a color your icon an

0:34:30angry now and we're going to get us on

0:34:32the next thing comes along I'm less

0:34:34worried about people you know the

0:34:35chattering classes on Twitter and and

0:34:37and but they think they're helping John

0:34:39well I know but I don't contributing to

0:34:41the body politic but I don't care about

0:34:42them but now the real that the the real

0:34:46difference that is that if that's

0:34:49happening among people who really are

0:34:51off their asses and doing things

0:34:53um is that you know the that that that

0:34:57the fundamental liberal project has been

0:35:02since the since the fifties but but

0:35:06really since the sixties to imagine that

0:35:10we are creating a utopia in America and

0:35:16there are a lot of people who who don't

0:35:20want it or don't get it and we're going

0:35:23to help them along by forcing them to

0:35:28open their mind that will try education

0:35:31you know what will try to educate them

0:35:33if it doesn't work we can we get a big

0:35:35hammer here

0:35:35yeah and and through through a lot of

0:35:38like Great Society style like sort of

0:35:42big projects like busing and housing

0:35:47projects and you know of a legislative

0:35:52approach and a social engineering

0:35:55approach liberalism said about to create

0:35:58a utopia by dragging people along

0:36:04kicking and screaming and not not not

0:36:08everybody of course but but dragging the

0:36:10recalcitrant people along who straps and

0:36:14you know there was a moment sometime in

0:36:19the seventies and I and I sense this you

0:36:22know i said at this moment where

0:36:24crackpot conservatism became mainstream

0:36:31was there was this there was just this

0:36:33this overflow point right around the

0:36:37time that that governments were saying

0:36:42well you know you can no longer have an

0:36:46all-male a smoking club like you and

0:36:52your buddies started this club you sit

0:36:54around smoking cigars but it is

0:36:56discriminatory that your that you have a

0:37:01requirement that it be all dude so you

0:37:03have to open the doors and well at the

0:37:07at the moment where we reach down into

0:37:11the culture and started saying in

0:37:15general you can no longer you can no

0:37:19longer be just some dudes in a in a club

0:37:24you have it's against the law now that

0:37:30was the that was the personal moment I

0:37:32think we're conservatism at became the

0:37:38ascendant movement because there are

0:37:40just a lot of people in the world who

0:37:43instinctively do not want to be told who

0:37:51they can hang out with and it isn't a

0:37:54that their response wasn't yet coming

0:37:59from a place of of racism or sexism it

0:38:02was coming from a deeply personal place

0:38:03where some suddenly somebody with a

0:38:06clipboard somebody like that EPA agent

0:38:09in Ghost Busters guy an officious you

0:38:14know government employee with a

0:38:16clipboard was saying thank man shut it

0:38:19down and and people just like the people

0:38:24tell the farmers they can't build

0:38:25skyscrapers right ma no remember thing

0:38:29about land rights and the Holy right

0:38:30exactly exactly that's always somebody

0:38:32and the thing about the thing about the

0:38:34land rights question is it is persuasive

0:38:37to me because we are all we are all

0:38:39using the same water and the same suit

0:38:43and likewise the the the the men's club

0:38:46argument is persuasive in the sense that

0:38:49we are all using the same water in the

0:38:50same sewage but this was the moment

0:38:53where where people who already felt like

0:38:57the this liberal project was pushing

0:39:00them against their will

0:39:02you know what their heels dug in pushing

0:39:04them toward a world that they couldn't

0:39:06see and didn't understand and then it

0:39:09became a precipitate got personally it

0:39:11came down to their streets exactly where

0:39:14it was like wait a minute now I can't

0:39:16even now I can't even higher my

0:39:19brother-in-law because it's one thing

0:39:21for California to come up with a bunch

0:39:23of free stuff for mon or whatever but

0:39:25now you're you really are literally in

0:39:26my backyard

0:39:27you're down you're down here like

0:39:28telling me how to do my business right

0:39:31and from you know from up high

0:39:34liberalism said well this is how it has

0:39:37to happen we have to go around like that

0:39:41scene in Doctor Zhivago where we were

0:39:45all of a sudden post-revolution dr.

0:39:48Zhivago and his family who used to live

0:39:49in a 30 room mansion are now there's a

0:39:53knock on the door and there's a woman

0:39:55with a clipboard and she is moving other

0:39:58dis you know she's moving families into

0:40:00their home and increasingly the

0:40:03Chicago's are now they're just living on

0:40:05one floor their home and pretty soon the

0:40:07whole family is living in one room

0:40:09curtains off with sheets sounds a lot

0:40:12like Warsaw now right yeah well that's

0:40:16exactly right and and and the premise is

0:40:20like how could you jog owes have been

0:40:23living in such luxury while people were

0:40:25poor on the street you know people were

0:40:28dying in the cold and now everybody's

0:40:31living together in a rat's Warren if

0:40:35you're holding the collective of

0:40:36equality in your old family mansion and

0:40:39congratulations now you know we have

0:40:41arrived at a at at ya Marxist equality

0:40:44which is squalor for koala for all but

0:40:48but that you know feeling trying to feel

0:40:52sympathy

0:40:53it's very hard now to hear somebody

0:40:56you from Arkansas or somebody even from

0:41:00Seattle who is who has a large dodge

0:41:06truck that maybe maybe has some truck

0:41:10nuts hanging from the back bumper but

0:41:14those are illegal in California new

0:41:16clothes they are listening to them you

0:41:19know bitch and moan with it with a ton

0:41:21of vitriol about how obama is coming to

0:41:24force them to to accept medical

0:41:29insurance

0:41:30it's very hard for the liberal

0:41:32sensibilities to not feel like what is

0:41:34the matter with you cry babies my god

0:41:36like man up but the fact is that they're

0:41:41expressing their expressing a discontent

0:41:44that's 40 years old that is really a

0:41:48discontent with the with the with the

0:41:50premise of the whole liberal project

0:41:52which is that we are headed toward a

0:41:55utopia and you are coming whether you

0:41:57like it or not and you something that's

0:41:58kind of authentic about that whether I

0:42:00agree with it or not there's this basic

0:42:03thing that I i said this before but i

0:42:05really believe there aren't that many

0:42:06people who think they're stupid

0:42:08I think most people think other people

0:42:09are stupid very few people say you know

0:42:11what I'm really stupid and need people

0:42:14to massage my understanding of the world

0:42:16in such a way that I can be a good

0:42:17citizen but the key thing about being

0:42:20ignorant is that you are first primarily

0:42:23ignorant of how stupid you are that's

0:42:24the difference between to me the dancing

0:42:26stupidity and ignorance ignorance can be

0:42:28cured if if you you know can learn that

0:42:31but you you're onto something i think

0:42:33which is that people i think this is my

0:42:36might be shooting fish in a liberal

0:42:37barrel here maybe going to the whole

0:42:38foods barrel but you know it's funny to

0:42:41me than all of the barrel

0:42:42oh it's hard to say no it's amazing to

0:42:44me like how many people you know you

0:42:47live in pac heights you live in berkeley

0:42:49and you're you're very very comfortable

0:42:52in your surroundings by and large and

0:42:55you're more than happy to institute

0:42:57busting your more than happy to

0:42:58institute you know I'll whatever public

0:43:00housing what you know what we have your

0:43:01house for public housing tweet us your

0:43:03kid across town is that cool with you

0:43:05are you really are you really super into

0:43:07that something some people are i have

0:43:08really good friends here and

0:43:10out that moved here and it's frustrating

0:43:11moved here specifically to be part of

0:43:13the great San Francisco experiment right

0:43:15they use public transit they have a they

0:43:17have their kid go to the school that

0:43:19like it's a sign to them and that's it's

0:43:22difficult sometimes but their values

0:43:24around that are to me much more

0:43:25authentic than people who are going in

0:43:28and you know astroturfing polls on CNN

0:43:31and make sure the right side wins

0:43:33because i don't think i've set again I

0:43:36don't think you care about something

0:43:37until you've sacrificed for it and if

0:43:40you care that much about all that stuff

0:43:42like why don't you put your money where

0:43:43your mouth is you put your life where

0:43:44your mouth is because it's if you agree

0:43:48if you just stipulate for one week that

0:43:50you're stupid and you need other people

0:43:52to tell you what to do your eyes open to

0:43:55how the world operates and you see that

0:43:57there's much more to this persuasion of

0:43:59utopian or otherwise of trying to get

0:44:01somewhere better than telling people

0:44:03that they're stupid and need to be

0:44:04hammered into complicity or into you

0:44:06know submission

0:44:07I just wish that you know liberalism is

0:44:09very self-reflective in some ways narrow

0:44:14corridors but there is not a historic

0:44:18self-reflection that applies to what

0:44:23we've been doing since world war two and

0:44:26if if we were able as a culture to look

0:44:30back and say um we tore down all of the

0:44:36tenement buildings on the lower east

0:44:38side and we built massive brick housing

0:44:42projects and we did it because we were

0:44:48we were so we're solving all these

0:44:50problems hygiene problems we were we

0:44:53were solving the the incredible mess the

0:44:57unruly mess of downtown New York that

0:45:01was full of immigrants and we could and

0:45:04nobody you know everybody was just

0:45:05waiting through sewage and and there

0:45:09were there was a watch shop next to a

0:45:12hat shop

0:45:13how can this stand we're going to we're

0:45:15going to bulldoze it we're gonna pull

0:45:17those block after block and we're going

0:45:18to build these neat and tidy housing

0:45:21projects

0:45:23this giant government undertaking and

0:45:25we're going to provide a clean and

0:45:27secure neighborhood environment for

0:45:31people and it's going to uplift the

0:45:33people that we can social engineer that

0:45:36by design

0:45:37yeah and the to look at that

0:45:41now you see like oh my god what a

0:45:45misguided approach like the

0:45:48cabrini-green projects in Chicago became

0:45:51the most dangerous place in the universe

0:45:53a place where the police

0:45:56well I was driving to Chicago one time

0:45:58in the in the mid-eighties and I was

0:46:01advised by a policeman not to stop at

0:46:03red lights and I said message received

0:46:10like he's that don't you just don't

0:46:12through this part of the city i would

0:46:15not i would not wait for the light to

0:46:16change you know we had this neat idea

0:46:18that we would find a way to take all of

0:46:21the desperate people with nothing to

0:46:23lose and then stack them up like

0:46:24cordwood well and in a place where we we

0:46:27did not have we have the mandate to tear

0:46:29down the old neighborhood and build this

0:46:31but we did not have the mandate to fund

0:46:33it right we did not have the mandated to

0:46:37to follow through on that which is you

0:46:40that you don't just you don't just tear

0:46:42down people's neighborhoods and put them

0:46:43in high-rises and then automatically

0:46:45they have become a philosopher scholars

0:46:48like you then also have to have the

0:46:51money to make those schools in that

0:46:54neighborhood the best schools there are

0:46:55and have job training programs and the

0:46:57and it does not work if if you you are

0:47:01also experiencing a nationwide decline

0:47:04in manufacturing and even though you

0:47:07can't you can't do that and then also

0:47:08closed all the factories and but but but

0:47:12we are it is very hard for us to look

0:47:15back at that and say that was a liberal

0:47:18project with the with the end goal of

0:47:22creating a utopia and what it created

0:47:24was a blight and it created it created

0:47:27in a lot of ways it precipitated the

0:47:29death of the inner-city that took

0:47:32foresters don't was still trying to

0:47:34recover from we're still trying to

0:47:35recover from

0:47:36that's right

0:47:36and you know the story of Detroit is

0:47:40that when they were building the

0:47:42interstate highway system they slammed

0:47:44the interstate right through the heart

0:47:46of Detroit's most vibrant black

0:47:49neighborhood and they just they just cut

0:47:52it in half and and killed it in in one

0:47:56fell swoop and it it produced so much

0:47:59anger in the city of Detroit in the in

0:48:01what was at the time you know a very

0:48:03vibrant and alive black community of

0:48:06music and art that you know Detroit went

0:48:11through 12 40 years where it was

0:48:13recreational to go burn down abandoned

0:48:16houses like that was something that

0:48:18people did on weekends like let's go

0:48:19burn some houses because they had lost

0:48:22badly they could completely lost their

0:48:25feeling that the city belong to them and

0:48:28talk about everybody in Detroit you know

0:48:30because of this

0:48:31what was what was eventually what was

0:48:33ultimately i'm not saying the

0:48:34interstates worse it were just a liberal

0:48:36project they were Eisenhower II and they

0:48:39also support industry it would make make

0:48:42it easier for people in the suburbs to

0:48:43get to their job was it was a big it was

0:48:46a big social engineering concept like

0:48:49here's what we're going to do that

0:48:51instead of being stuck in traffic all

0:48:53day when doing your way into this little

0:48:55neighborhood where the hat shop is next

0:48:57to the watch shop

0:48:59we're gonna just tear it all down we're

0:49:01going to build a big spaceport out of

0:49:02brick everybody's guys need some

0:49:05modernity they really do we need to

0:49:07bring some Brutalism in here and

0:49:09independent is going to improve every

0:49:11the quality of everybody's life and

0:49:13fifty years from now everybody is going

0:49:15to be dancing like in those buck rogers

0:49:18television shows in the early eighties

0:49:20where people are holding onto that their

0:49:23whole holding on to my place your calls

0:49:26or something holding onto ribbons and

0:49:27pleasure balls and they're dancing

0:49:28around to brian eno music and that's

0:49:32going to be the future if we just get

0:49:34rid of all this all up of if we just get

0:49:37rid of the center of the city where

0:49:39people who are living as people

0:49:41naturally do which is frankly like but

0:49:45pigs

0:49:46but that's who we are you know so I wish

0:49:50that I wish that liberalism had the

0:49:52capacity as a as a as a as a

0:49:55forward-thinking like ideology to do a

0:50:01little bit of backward-looking and say

0:50:04we have we have tried to engineer a

0:50:09utopia multiple times where education

0:50:13and government action enlightened the

0:50:18people and expand once it was patiently

0:50:22explained to them that equal rights for

0:50:25all was was beneficial and economically

0:50:29like advantageous everybody got it and

0:50:33then we were living in a we were living

0:50:35in a future world where all the children

0:50:38are Mochaccino colored and we sit around

0:50:41on the steps of our pantheon and reed st

0:50:47louis plays to one another and that is

0:50:50the America that we hoped for and

0:50:51inspire to but everybody and and frankly

0:50:55a lot of things a lot of things we've

0:50:57tried have worked great but but that the

0:51:00the resentment that you feel in America

0:51:03about big government telling you what to

0:51:06do is that there are people that really

0:51:08were and and what's amazing is that the

0:51:12people that were most affected by the

0:51:14liberal bigger big government projects

0:51:17they are still Democrats it's the it's

0:51:21the people that were kind of on the

0:51:22outside looking in and going you know

0:51:25the people that got out to the suburbs

0:51:26that looked back at the city and said

0:51:30you know liberalism is bankrupt and when

0:51:36I when I think about it that way I

0:51:37haven't I have I still I still have a

0:51:41very hard time being yelled at by

0:51:43conservatives but I do sympathize with

0:51:47their with with some of the evidence

0:51:52that they're able to to muster that like

0:51:55this this this mentality which is

0:51:59we are coming into your homes and we're

0:52:02going to explain to you why you're wrong

0:52:04and then we're going to deprive you of

0:52:06your of what you consider to be your

0:52:09rights and it's in service of the

0:52:13greater good and you're gonna like it or

0:52:15not doesn't matter

0:52:18go fuck yourself also god is dead

0:52:23whoo free pot for everybody act like PCP

0:52:28I see why they're bent out of shape I

0:52:30totally do

0:52:32I you know it I want to get back to your

0:52:34teen out in a minute if we can't but you

0:52:36know it reminds me I I think I guess

0:52:39somebody from the north in you know the

0:52:43literal and figurative sense i don't

0:52:45think they really understood a lot about

0:52:47the civil war until I met my friend

0:52:49Richard and read some Faulkner and I got

0:52:51a really different point of view into it

0:52:54and I started to really and what's that

0:52:56well yeah because we think that we're in

0:52:59the north we are top better that

0:53:01everybody in the south is like Bo and

0:53:03Luke Duke well we'll write and and I

0:53:06mean my understanding of it is that part

0:53:09of part of what made things so

0:53:10complicated in the you know beginning to

0:53:13middle part of the 19th century was that

0:53:16you know slavery it would be glib to

0:53:19call it a MacGuffin but it's certainly

0:53:21worth mentioning that it'sit's wasn't

0:53:23just slavery it was a matter of telling

0:53:25us how to live like whether you like or

0:53:27don't like slavery it ends up being

0:53:29Jermaine but the deeper issue is we

0:53:31didn't I guess it seems like the north

0:53:34maybe i don't know i'm not historian but

0:53:36it seems to me that they the North

0:53:37didn't flicks that except the extent to

0:53:39which people in Virginia we're going to

0:53:41be put off by us telling these as you

0:53:44say these you know people from Scotland

0:53:46who are really used to autonomy and and

0:53:50and they've got their own mature culture

0:53:52we animate we may not like they're

0:53:53mature culture and they're doing what

0:53:55what I would personally consider awful

0:53:57awful things and but at the same time II

0:54:00we're going down there in like we're

0:54:02really poking the bowl in the i think by

0:54:05not acknowledging what we were facing

0:54:06from people who thought that their

0:54:10culture was fine just the way it is

0:54:11thank you very much

0:54:12and and we make about slavery because it

0:54:14should be about slavery I'm sure glad

0:54:15it's gone but at the same time one

0:54:17reason that was such a bloody war is

0:54:18that they did not feel it in some ways

0:54:20it wouldn't matter it was certainly

0:54:22bigger their economy but they want

0:54:23people telling them how to make their t

0:54:25you just don't tell people in the South

0:54:28what to do and you know and and I I

0:54:31think that's still I think that's still

0:54:33true today I mean if we don't and I just

0:54:35wanna be clear I'm not saying slavery

0:54:36was a great idea but like that's the

0:54:38problem we can't have these

0:54:39conversations it's a constant production

0:54:41of third rails about all the things that

0:54:44are off-limits because we've all decided

0:54:45that we understand this story and i'm

0:54:48just here to say I don't think we always

0:54:49understand that story and RR amount of

0:54:53certainty about how right we are how

0:54:55wrong everybody else is and how much

0:54:56they need to be rehabilitated to our

0:54:58learning point of view is an affliction

0:55:01especially on the on the left and right

0:55:02coasts that we really feel like we need

0:55:04to salute sweep in and and set these

0:55:08folks straight now by Kennedy goes he

0:55:10goes to Kentucky any he literally cries

0:55:12because he sees what poverty people are

0:55:15living in but you know what

0:55:16he didn't he didn't go back and then

0:55:19post things on facebook he understood

0:55:21that welfare is an incredibly complex

0:55:22problem to solve and it's going to take

0:55:24more than just this one angle to even

0:55:27begin to fix this problem and I I admire

0:55:30that you know he didn't just sit around

0:55:31and he didn't just take photos support

0:55:33people and come back and show it to

0:55:34everybody in Hyannisport he did

0:55:36something about it and but he also

0:55:37acknowledged that it was very

0:55:38complicated

0:55:40yeah he got shot to a really good point

0:55:42so you be the the thing about the the

0:55:45thing about the Civil War is that you

0:55:48know III understanding exactly what

0:55:50you're getting at but the but the Civil

0:55:52War was was just about slavery

0:55:55yeah just the a12 and the other argument

0:55:58that it was about anything else is a is

0:56:00a kind of like yes that's it's

0:56:03everything that they say is true but it

0:56:05is a kind of revisionism too because the

0:56:08United States was fighting a war about

0:56:10slavery for 25 years before the Civil

0:56:13War or 450 years before the Civil War

0:56:16ultimately yeah you can look back and

0:56:20say that was about slavery because that

0:56:23was a that was a thing that we were

0:56:24going to have to fight a bloody

0:56:25pleasantly shot each other about that's

0:56:28what that's what we shot each other

0:56:29about and that and and and the

0:56:30underlying causes which like you're

0:56:33saying is this clash of cultures between

0:56:36the Cavaliers and the and the the

0:56:40Quakers or whatever

0:56:41yes that's all true and it's all written

0:56:43in it but but at and and maybe you could

0:56:48make an argument that all of these

0:56:50liberal projects of the 20th century

0:56:53have been incremental wars that have

0:56:58prevented what could have been a much

0:57:00bigger worse war in 1967 it was it was

0:57:08plausible to people in 1967 that we were

0:57:12headed to a conflict on the scale of the

0:57:17civil war in the sense that people were

0:57:19really like this and watch riots that is

0:57:23exactly like burning cities fighting in

0:57:26the streets insurrection that wasn't

0:57:29such a scary time for everybody really

0:57:31scary and and people you know and and

0:57:35and what I will it hadn't happened was

0:57:37we hadn't had 40 years of talking about

0:57:39it to make it seem to make those ideas

0:57:42seem I mean even even the most the the

0:57:47biggest conservative zealot is familiar

0:57:50with the concept of a sort of every

0:57:56liberal totem but at the at the time in

0:58:001967 I mean here there were there were

0:58:03great swaths of just normal American

0:58:05people that were still wrestling with

0:58:06the concept of of conscientious

0:58:10objectors like wait a minute what it why

0:58:13wouldn't you want to go fight for

0:58:15America in a war like they did it wasn't

0:58:17even they couldn't get their heads

0:58:19around it so so maybe maybe we have been

0:58:23fighting these small battles and it has

0:58:25released the pressure that would have

0:58:28built up

0:58:29would be to be a larger conflict the

0:58:32civil war was inevitable and there

0:58:34wasn't a way they tried they tried for

0:58:37the 4 30 years beforehand to legislate

0:58:40their way around the problem and and

0:58:44concessions were made to the South like

0:58:48you wouldn't believe we were I mean the

0:58:51people in the north and Congress you

0:58:53know they went back and forth just like

0:58:55oh I would you like to have thursday

0:58:58afternoons reserved for mint juleps when

0:59:01we will make that national law if it

0:59:04will it if if you will just concede that

0:59:07that maybe you know free blacks can go

0:59:10across Kansas without being like

0:59:15bullwhipped by children so and it's not

0:59:18starting with like saying an egg and I

0:59:20should watch Lincoln again but it's not

0:59:22starting with saying like tomorrow

0:59:24your daughter has to marry a negro it

0:59:26started with something much more simply

0:59:28like can you just be less of a dick

0:59:29about this is never get horny lives they

0:59:32were I mean they were arguing it in my

0:59:34in the Constitutional Congress something

0:59:36they were arguing that these questions

0:59:38all the way back and the South was just

0:59:40well just contemptuous and immobile and

0:59:44eventually never sending more kicks it

0:59:46was good it was going to be a war you

0:59:48know the the the British outlawed

0:59:50slavery in 1802 or something so so that

0:59:55so that whole like the southern argument

0:59:57that the Civil War was really about

0:59:58states rights or whatever it is that

0:59:59people

0:59:59people

1:00:00want to say it's about it wasn't it was

1:00:02about it was about that this was a thing

1:00:05that needed to be resolved and some

1:00:07people were just going to have to die

1:00:08over it and the reality is looking back

1:00:13in at America for the last 50 years in

1:00:181957 I can't imagine standing in that

1:00:24place and not maybe picturing that we

1:00:28were going to have to have another that

1:00:30we're gonna have to have a a war every

1:00:31hundred years about this stuff and

1:00:35somehow we we fought a terrible cultural

1:00:39war but somehow we avoided taking up

1:00:43arms and I mean other conspiracy

1:00:46theories with theorists would say that

1:00:47it was because the CIA started a crack

1:00:50epidemic but you know and the FBI

1:00:54definitely like worked really hard to

1:00:57get the black panthers to fight

1:01:00themselves but the reality is we we

1:01:03tried a lot of different things to move

1:01:06the move the culture forward so we

1:01:08didn't have to fight a bruising

1:01:11revolution

1:01:13I don't know I don't know how we'd

1:01:15illegal in the United States not in

1:01:18Washington and then California past

1:01:21medical marijuana in the nineties he's

1:01:23an apple in san francisco or you know

1:01:27and in the bay area especially you can

1:01:28go out and you just it's just weed

1:01:29everywhere here we did but here's the

1:01:31funny part so there was you couldn't

1:01:35have had died i can i'm not up

1:01:37I don't know lots of things but but use

1:01:39there's a pretty strong federal law

1:01:40against this and you can agree or

1:01:42disagree with it but then they can with

1:01:43the California Medical Marijuana do this

1:01:46they have this great thing years and

1:01:47years ago where they attached federal

1:01:49highway money to drug policy and if you

1:01:54wanted to make something with having to

1:01:55be 21 to buy alcohol

1:01:57yeah if you wanted to change those laws

1:01:58in your state that was fine but you

1:02:00would sacrifice all of your federal

1:02:02highway money experience turned to shit

1:02:04was it was it was incredible it was a

1:02:06incredible no state dared cross the

1:02:09federal government because they were

1:02:11like yeah sure change your policy all

1:02:13one but but now the beauty part is that

1:02:17they're trying on a local level you go

1:02:19to the next level and now on a local

1:02:20level people are trying to legislate

1:02:22stuff like was owning for things like

1:02:26you know we can have a pot dispensary ok

1:02:30and now the people are freaking out

1:02:31because they say it can be within a half

1:02:34a mile obviously keep your hands keep

1:02:35your hands your hands off my weed law

1:02:38hippie it's like you're ok with the with

1:02:41passing these backdoor laws for the

1:02:43thing that suits you but like as soon as

1:02:45somebody in the neighborhood

1:02:46Oh local make it local you can have its

1:02:48okay its cool you can have bong city set

1:02:50up next to the preschool or whatever

1:02:51fine whatever

1:02:53but now with somebody else in a sauce

1:02:54for the gander now somebody else is

1:02:56getting actually you know what let's use

1:02:57the law and the law is going to be that

1:02:58there's going to be zoning on this and

1:03:00you know luckily I think they're pretty

1:03:01confused hopefully won't be a huge issue

1:03:04yeah I i saw map of like concentric

1:03:08circles around all the schools in san

1:03:10francisco and if you know if you can't

1:03:14build a pot dispensary within 500 yards

1:03:17of the school the closest but Spencer

1:03:19you could build is somewhere like on the

1:03:21road to Sacramento it's also hard on sex

1:03:23offenders

1:03:24alright and i'm gonna live in opa be no

1:03:27I'm peeing outside as you and I enjoy so

1:03:30much you get caught it that you might be

1:03:32a sex offender you know that sounds like

1:03:33a jeff foxworthy bit

1:03:35imagine if you know they're not here

1:03:37Nate on the side of the house might be a

1:03:40sex offender

1:03:41many years ago I was that I was peeing

1:03:43outside with a friend a genetic park as

1:03:45you do and all of a sudden there was a

1:03:49cop car there with its spotlight on and

1:03:51that spotlighted my friend and for

1:03:54whatever reason I'm standing 15 feet

1:03:58away which is which is the this so

1:04:00socially prescribed distance you stand

1:04:04from your friend when you're being

1:04:05together in the dark in a park but that

1:04:0815 feet away I was somehow out of the

1:04:10spotlight aura and the cops are

1:04:15spotlighting my buddy and they're like

1:04:17hey and he's like oh shit and I'm

1:04:20standing right there in the middle of a

1:04:22park they don't see me and I finish

1:04:24peeing and I zip up my pants

1:04:27and I walked around a tree like a head

1:04:30around there's a treat next minute walk

1:04:32around it and come out from the other

1:04:33side and then walk up as these two cops

1:04:36are getting out and arresting my friend

1:04:39and I'm like hey fellas what's going on

1:04:42and my buddy's like hey I made literally

1:04:45handcuffed him and put him in the police

1:04:48car and drove off into the night is in

1:04:50Seattle yeah and I was like oh man shit

1:04:54and my friend was like dude you gotta

1:04:58help me out here and I left nothing i

1:05:00could do we know I wasn't gonna say hey

1:05:03I was pissing to and so I stood there

1:05:07and he was like you know come bail me

1:05:08out and I was like I don't have any

1:05:09money

1:05:10happy now topics and and he was like

1:05:14this are that is civil right he was

1:05:17yelling at me faster think I'm just I

1:05:23was just going from here to there

1:05:26the cops even comes never even looked at

1:05:28me anyway what I'm worried about em

1:05:32ultimately is I have a house full of

1:05:36instruments and I'm worried that that

1:05:39does not present enough challenge to my

1:05:43daughter is efficient

1:05:46that's right so music is all around her

1:05:48she is invited to play any instrument at

1:05:51any time she isn't going to develop any

1:05:55interest in it at all i think about

1:05:57hiding them i'm thinking about making

1:05:59them all off limits to her you know that

1:06:00the famous story about the Jacksons was

1:06:03that that Dad Jackson had a guitar and

1:06:08he said no one touch my guitar I better

1:06:12not see anybody ever touch this guitar

1:06:15and then Jermaine or whatever like

1:06:21taught himself to play the guitar and

1:06:22then little by little all the Jacksons

1:06:24learn to play on this guitar and they

1:06:28hit they had to hide it from their dad

1:06:30and he only discovered it when one day

1:06:32they broke a string and they didn't know

1:06:34how to

1:06:34fix it and he came home and saw that

1:06:37they've been playing his guitar and he

1:06:39was like what's the story here it comes

1:06:41to help that well yeah and I think you

1:06:43probably the shit out of it but then

1:06:44eventually he discovered like oh shit

1:06:46they're all they're all amazing

1:06:48musicians

1:06:50hey wait a minute i might not have to

1:06:52work i should have a keyboard so you

1:06:55know so you think that's what he thought

1:06:57you think he saw him take it

1:06:58yeah but the barrier to entry togo 45

1:07:01net the confined to the trucks ready the

1:07:05barrier to entry there has to be one you

1:07:08know you there has to be something I

1:07:10totally get what you're saying I mean

1:07:11yeah exactly there's nothing there's

1:07:13nothing to it comes like furniture would

1:07:15be like playing the couch right so so

1:07:19and that is why so many like hipster

1:07:21musicians they you know they raise their

1:07:26kids to be to you know to be like group

1:07:30stirs and the kids just end up

1:07:33yeah i was about to say they end up

1:07:34being football players and and

1:07:36cheerleaders but really I have no

1:07:37evidence that's like seventy two percent

1:07:39on 72 cents on the dollar

1:07:41it's evidence that that happens it just

1:07:44seems like a good thing to say your

1:07:46daughter's gonna end up being a

1:07:47cheerleader

1:07:47you gotta get seventy two percent of the

1:07:49guitar give hissing in theaters up there

1:07:50you're missing during the the trailer

1:07:53movie know how we get hissing it's it's

1:07:57a thing here i think some people just do

1:07:59it because you know little things like

1:08:01when you go to that one tunnel by the

1:08:03golden gate bridge Red Hawk so that the

1:08:05tone

1:08:06yeah yeah i think i think you know that

1:08:08the hissing is it really

1:08:10it's aight i can't even tell if it's

1:08:11ironic anymore no there's no he wouldn't

1:08:14in the Northwest you would not make a

1:08:17public display like that without really

1:08:20upsetting people

1:08:22you get into the theater and you you

1:08:26identify which which half of the armrest

1:08:30is included in your personal space right

1:08:33and then you get as quiet as you can so

1:08:37you go to for example in your case you

1:08:38go to a holocaust movie and people just

1:08:41chattering through the whole thing

1:08:42because that there is their civil right

1:08:44with my braids

1:08:47so I need peace in and I'm indoors get

1:08:51Civil War discrimination women's rights

1:08:53trumpets and allergies and so what was

1:08:54the upshot was the upshot of your talk

1:08:56that you do you feel like you did you

1:08:58did you would be able to make a point we

1:09:00have also decided i think so i got to

1:09:02the end and I said you know ask me your

1:09:07best questions like let's hear it

1:09:08because i spent the second half of my

1:09:11talk saying what is the what is the end

1:09:16goal you there like lady with rickets

1:09:18was the end goal of making of of forcing

1:09:23the issue of inclusiveness and rock

1:09:27music what is I mean I understand rock

1:09:29music has for the whole length of its

1:09:31life for though for its entire time

1:09:34rock music has been a a a radicalizing

1:09:40force in the culture right

1:09:42rock music says hey we're going to

1:09:44integrate rock music says hey we're

1:09:46going to move our hips and we're gonna

1:09:48show our belly buttons and we're going

1:09:50to talk about the war and we're going to

1:09:52talk about drugs & rock music has done

1:09:54it in advance of the rest of the culture

1:09:58it's always been radicalizing but now

1:10:00this this new realm in which rock music

1:10:06is its own mission field and people are

1:10:09turning inward and saying how can we

1:10:11make rock

1:10:13how can we make the music world more

1:10:19representative more inclusive more

1:10:23how can we how can we force the music

1:10:26world to be you know more diverse and in

1:10:31a way more of an institution all those

1:10:35all those other people in the business

1:10:37and that was the you know that was the

1:10:40that was the upshot was just like you

1:10:43can't go into the arts and start

1:10:47I mean he then then what you get is

1:10:51marks the start you get art that is that

1:10:55doesn't offend anybody

1:10:56and it doesn't it doesn't it doesn't

1:11:00offend anybody and it isn't

1:11:02representative and people are not making

1:11:04art 222 challenge or overturn they're

1:11:09making art to satisfy requirements and

1:11:13they're making art to a to appease and

1:11:19that is that ultimately isn't art its

1:11:21design or it's you know it's graphic art

1:11:28not to not to piss off any graphic

1:11:30artists that are mad morning and you

1:11:33throw a straightedge a think that they

1:11:37might do an illustration of me that's

1:11:38unflattering your ass is big but you're

1:11:44seeing Rushmore

1:11:45yes I think when in doubt you should do

1:11:48her monthly Herman Blues are they

1:11:50shoulda blew speech in the chapel

1:11:52here's my advice to the rest of you take

1:11:55dead aim on the rich boys get them in

1:11:58your crosshairs and take them down

1:12:00remember you can buy anything but they

1:12:02can't buy backbone you can see you could

1:12:06go and give her speech anywhere and you

1:12:08don't disagree because nobody is there a

1:12:10rich boy

1:12:10yeah take aim at the rich boy that you

1:12:12need a gun for that you

1:12:14I mean maybe it's a philosophical

1:12:15metaphor gun but step take aim at them

1:12:18with with your sarcasm

1:12:20that's right i invented sarcasm alright

1:12:25well let you go pee

1:12:26yeah you anything else no that's it you

1:12:30don't have you don't have any kind of a

1:12:32solution for this you don't have any

1:12:33kind of a tip for somebody what if

1:12:35somebody's out there right now John what

1:12:36if they're looking for your help you

1:12:38certainly created the article itself is

1:12:40a foundation the tip is the you know the

1:12:43the answer is this is the same as the

1:12:46one that you have been propagating which

1:12:48is don't look outward at 22 you know to

1:12:55a rather change yourself first change

1:13:00your immediate family and your your

1:13:02small circle of friends second

1:13:05and if that doesn't occupy you your

1:13:07entire life i will be astonished but but

1:13:12change in office to agree on bagels

1:13:14good luck if you feel like you have

1:13:16completely like change your way of

1:13:19living and your and your families and

1:13:21your immediate circle of friends way of

1:13:23living then write a book about it

1:13:26because you would be an example to us

1:13:28all

1:13:28I don't know that it seems like sympathy

1:13:32and empathy for your opponent is is the

1:13:38thing that's needed most

1:13:39now in them in America at least sympathy

1:13:42and empathy for your opponent and a

1:13:45genuine desire to see what the what the

1:13:48underlying problem is because we are not

1:13:52making the world a better place the

1:13:54liberal project is in within a lot of

1:13:59ways got it is working but i don't but

1:14:04nobody nobody likes the feeling i don't

1:14:07know it's just so early that we

1:14:16shouldn't even post this one is this 7

1:14:19it's it's not fun