Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

208: Your Face Is Your Face

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00that is going to make an awesome

0:00:01after-show it's not really because it's

0:00:03going to be just a white dude and

0:00:05moaning about his expensive car it's

0:00:07gonna be terrible at show and we're

0:00:08gonna keep it in and people are going to

0:00:10like it and that the water to people who

0:00:12don't like it have long since stopped

0:00:13listening

0:00:16alright so people have suggested that

0:00:20this phantom version of the mac which

0:00:25includes an arm coprocessor if you will

0:00:28maybe that's used for power nap i still

0:00:30skeptical that would be a reasonable use

0:00:31case but be that as it may their people

0:00:35have used an example of apparently

0:00:36there's something in the playstation 4

0:00:38which apparently is a console that

0:00:40people apparently play video games with

0:00:42I didn't realize that was still thing

0:00:43but anyway it has a rest mode that I

0:00:45guess work similarly right John

0:00:47yeah so this is the last show we are

0:00:50talking about the arm CPU actually being

0:00:53able to function and do useful work when

0:00:55the intel cpus off which would mean that

0:00:57the arm CPU would need access to all the

0:00:59same stuff you know all the i/o and

0:01:02networking and all the other stuff

0:01:04regardless of what software runs rather

0:01:06runs just you know a bunch of apple

0:01:08software that Apple supplies as part of

0:01:10the OS or other third parties can ship

0:01:11arm compiled binaries to it that it

0:01:13would be a full fledge cpu able to do

0:01:16useful work and I was saying how that is

0:01:19pretty complicated if the only benefit

0:01:22you're getting out of it is we can do

0:01:24power nap on the arm CPU instead of the

0:01:27intel cpu and it remains to be seen if

0:01:31they win the next involved we have some

0:01:32more suggestions of things this thing

0:01:33can do to justify that complexity but

0:01:35the ps4 is actually an example of this

0:01:39actual thing in practice because ps4 is

0:01:42an x86 cpu and when you put into rest

0:01:46mode it's basically like the thing is

0:01:48turned off the fans are often everything

0:01:50it doesn't make any noise just sits

0:01:51there but it's not completely off off

0:01:54and what it does in this mode is it will

0:01:56like download update giant updates your

0:01:58games it will charge your controllers

0:02:00ubel and do other sort of background

0:02:03tasks that don't require to be on but

0:02:06still mean it's doing useful work it

0:02:08will do obviously with downloading is

0:02:09using stuff over the network and in that

0:02:12rest mode

0:02:13it's according to this feedback we've

0:02:15gotten much i'm i'm perfectly willing to

0:02:17believe I haven't looked into it huh

0:02:18extensively it's not using the Intel CPU

0:02:21is using a separate arm chip just to do

0:02:24this stuff and that's an example the

0:02:29next day 26 and arm CPU in a box and

0:02:31when the the x86 CPU is turned off the

0:02:34arm CPU is able to do all that stuff is

0:02:36able to do you know manipulate stuff on

0:02:38the hard drive its able to use

0:02:40networking is able to do all the you

0:02:41know things and that is an additional

0:02:43complexity that is worth it for the ps4

0:02:46because it is fixing all the sins of the

0:02:49ps3 that every time you want to turn the

0:02:51thing on and play a game you have to

0:02:53download 50 update since I want you to

0:02:54do that for 12 hours i wasn't home ps3

0:02:56wouldn't even charge your controllers

0:02:58when it was turned off the ps3 you plug

0:03:00them in you know like I'm playing the

0:03:01game like the worst so the ps4 fixes all

0:03:04this and so it's an obvious one on the

0:03:06console and it's you know it's down to

0:03:10the instructions that exactly what a the

0:03:12they were talking about for this rumored

0:03:14apple laptop question remains is that

0:03:17additional complexity and i'm sure it's

0:03:19additional complexity worthwhile for a

0:03:21mac and so we had one of the suggestion

0:03:24for something that the arm CPU could do

0:03:26that is useful that doesn't require

0:03:29third-party developers to make

0:03:31extensions that with armed code compiled

0:03:34to it and ship it off there and you also

0:03:35stuff like that

0:03:36David Barton ski suggested good old

0:03:39photos and face recognition in her like

0:03:42when you first get your mac or at any

0:03:43point like we're wandering over your

0:03:45photos finding all the faces do it or

0:03:46doing the image recognition nowadays

0:03:48like figure out everything that the

0:03:50house or whatever so you can do searches

0:03:52later that would be perfect thing to do

0:03:54when your mac is in rest mode or asleep

0:03:57or whatever and it will require maybe

0:04:00networking access depending on how much

0:04:01cloud stuff they do for the image

0:04:02recognition but certainly would require

0:04:04disk access is that worth the added

0:04:08complexity of making a mac that can run

0:04:10either on an x86 CPU or arms if you're

0:04:13depending on Moton maybe after that

0:04:17first of all the photo recognition thing

0:04:19like I hope they fix that in this fall

0:04:22software updates like make that sink

0:04:24already everything else about photo

0:04:25sinks

0:04:26like the fact that every device has to

0:04:28do that is not only a terrible hack with

0:04:30awkward results sometimes but it just

0:04:34destroys the battery life and

0:04:36performance of the computers & ipad iOS

0:04:39devices for the first like three days

0:04:42that you get them and that is that's

0:04:43just a bad initial user experience for

0:04:45everybody but somebody's gotta do it

0:04:47like I know people might have multiple

0:04:49devices but one one of the devices has

0:04:51to do it and that device is the victim

0:04:53no matter it's great that will be shared

0:04:55like all just you know but i thought i

0:04:56would imagine for a lot of people like

0:04:57the phone would be the victim because

0:04:59that's where they take the pictures and

0:05:01who knows people even have photos

0:05:02thinking on their my ayaat I feel bad

0:05:05that any device has to be subject to

0:05:08this I mean the only they could change

0:05:10change the policy by saying we won't do

0:05:13a image recognition unless nobody is

0:05:17using the computer nobody's using the

0:05:19device and it's plugged in like this the

0:05:20only do it when you're sleeping and it's

0:05:22plugged in all that they already attempt

0:05:24to do that and like it does it it does

0:05:26stop when you are unplugged on the

0:05:29laptops most of the time however its it

0:05:33takes forever to the point where like

0:05:35you never know when you plug in like is

0:05:36it has been the fan up and then you

0:05:38unplug it like how long will it take

0:05:40before it pauses and use the discrete

0:05:42GPU with exaggerated any kind of GPU

0:05:44sticking on bugs

0:05:45it's it's just kind of a mess on iOS

0:05:47even worse than like your phone is

0:05:48really hot for the first while that you

0:05:50have any likewise my phone so how did

0:05:52something wrong with it is gonna catch

0:05:53fire like eh it's just really in elegant

0:05:56and and really sets up very bad user

0:05:58experiences for anybody who's setting up

0:06:00and iOS Mac device that isn't their

0:06:03first one ever

0:06:04and that's they really really need to

0:06:06address that in this year's updates like

0:06:08that cannot wait

0:06:10yeah so i'm not sure would be better if

0:06:13instead did it

0:06:15wall here while I was asleep because

0:06:17obviously will take away longer to do it

0:06:19was sleeping i really only Apple knows

0:06:22for sure but like what are the usage

0:06:24patterns for devices that are plugged in

0:06:28not iOS devices because they're they're

0:06:30never asleep awake like when the screens

0:06:33off basically that's a no sleep like

0:06:34when they're plugged in overnight in

0:06:35charging that's when they should be

0:06:37doing the photo stuff it that's the only

0:06:39device

0:06:39from max I don't know the defaults are

0:06:42but i imagine if you walk away from your

0:06:44Mac it will be on for some period of

0:06:45time and then I think the default is to

0:06:47go to sleep after like not that long

0:06:50time and if you can't do any photo

0:06:53recognition stuff in the background and

0:06:56sleep mode normally like a power nap

0:06:57doesn't do any of it now that's always

0:07:00the time so all the only time your mac

0:07:02has to do photos is when it unattended

0:07:04is like the one hour between when you

0:07:07stop using it and when it goes to sleep

0:07:08according to the default energy saver

0:07:10settings or whatever

0:07:11whereas it could have had 12 hours just

0:07:13plinking away with his little arm CPU so

0:07:14maybe that would help a little bit but

0:07:15again i have to you know the complexity

0:07:18of having a second full-fledged cpu with

0:07:19access to all the same things as the

0:07:21intel cpu is significant and i'm still

0:07:24so far i'm still on the page that a it's

0:07:27much smarter to use that cpu for

0:07:30auxiliary functions that have to do with

0:07:32the hardware is the last time a

0:07:34proximity sensor camera microphone you

0:07:38know sort of like a a glorified m1 m1 or

0:07:41m7 what was that the original motion

0:07:44detecting step counting thing and the

0:07:45iphone the enemy eat

0:07:48still we're going to be a BMW on the

0:07:49brain at m7 fm7 there you go

0:07:53the 1m because the m1 was a totally

0:07:54different car anyway yeah huh yeah just

0:07:58having dedicated hardware / functions

0:08:01related to the hardware and that's

0:08:04perfect for a little CPU and the only

0:08:05reason we're talking about this at all

0:08:07this is already there to run the touch

0:08:08bar it's like it's already there and

0:08:10you're just saying how can I get more

0:08:11bang for my buck from this thing that i

0:08:12already have to put it's not like we're

0:08:14looking through a bunch of new chips

0:08:16into think it's already in these this

0:08:18laptop so I believe that the next

0:08:23version or version after that of this

0:08:25they'll find new things to do is ship

0:08:26they should because they're paying for

0:08:27the chip and it's there and when it's

0:08:29not doing anything fancy on-screen give

0:08:31it something else to do they have they

0:08:33have they have good arm chips and they

0:08:34have a good Oster on them so why waste

0:08:37it

0:08:38speaking of face recognition windows

0:08:41hello

0:08:42whatever that may be does some really

0:08:44weird and fancy stuff with their face

0:08:46recognition

0:08:47yeah I made a joke about a

0:08:48face-recognition not being good for

0:08:50security because that will just print

0:08:52out a picture face and holds it up

0:08:53and they unlock your laptop didn't

0:08:56specifically say that that was the

0:08:57vulnerability of windows hello because

0:08:58they didn't know much about it but many

0:08:59people wrote in to say that windows

0:09:01hello actually uses depth maps too so

0:09:04you can just hold up a picture because I

0:09:06want something that not only looks like

0:09:07your face but is contoured and shaped

0:09:09like your face so people would have to

0:09:12make a basically a mannequin of your

0:09:13face instead of just a picture which is

0:09:15harder and interfaces vs fingerprints

0:09:20think a lot of people bring up like well

0:09:21it's just like it's just like

0:09:22fingerprints like people can lift your

0:09:24finger prints pretty easily

0:09:25I feel like it's still look at the apt

0:09:27comparison is local versus remoto

0:09:29exploit local exploits like this a

0:09:31million basically if someone has

0:09:32physical access your computer in most

0:09:34cases game over as far as security for a

0:09:37variety of reasons for fingerprints they

0:09:40need to have physical access to either

0:09:41you or something you've touched to list

0:09:43your fingerprints and there's been many

0:09:44demonstrations the web like how you can

0:09:45love someone fingerprint you can unlock

0:09:46their iphone because you know

0:09:48fingerprints just series of ridges and

0:09:49we can get them out and make a little

0:09:50plastic mold of it and you're going

0:09:52right now

0:09:54usually you can't get fingerprints from

0:09:57a normal photo of people like if you're

0:09:59walking down the street and someone

0:10:00snaps a picture of you

0:10:01they can't lift your fingerprints from

0:10:03that fixture or if they go you

0:10:05they probably won't find closeup

0:10:07pictures of your fingerprints or

0:10:08anything you've touched a resolution

0:10:09where they can lift your fingerprints

0:10:11but for most people you can find plenty

0:10:13of pictures of their face and you could

0:10:17fairly that not easily but much more

0:10:19easily remotely without ever being

0:10:22anywhere near that person or anything

0:10:23they've touched reproduce their face in

0:10:26the 3d manner from a series of photos

0:10:27that are taking out all under different

0:10:29angles and make it use a 3d printer to

0:10:32make a little mold and then print out a

0:10:34picture that face and slap it on to the

0:10:36mannequin and it should rule the depth

0:10:38sensors and fools the the camera and you

0:10:41unlock their saying with their face

0:10:42again this is kind of like mission

0:10:45impossible whatever stuff if someone is

0:10:47this determined to attack you it's

0:10:48probably much better just to call you

0:10:50until and tell you there for microsoft

0:10:52and they want to reset your password

0:10:52because that's much easier way to get

0:10:54into stuff but thinking about this and

0:10:57how easy it is to pull your fingerprints

0:11:00vs make a 3d model of your face versus

0:11:02whatever has reminded me once again

0:11:05of the trouble we'll all biometric

0:11:07security which we all be seen like the

0:11:09future you know

0:11:10sci-fi movies they always put their

0:11:12hands on things are doing retina scans

0:11:14or where you know we're living in the

0:11:15future now with fingerprints i use my

0:11:17fingerprint to unlock my phone all the

0:11:18time I love it's awesome but the trouble

0:11:21with all biometrics is if they are

0:11:24compromised in any way if people have

0:11:27your fingerprints or have a nice 3d

0:11:29model of your face you can't change

0:11:32those things you can't say well i'm

0:11:33gonna use a new set of fingerprints

0:11:34always rotate your fingerprints don't

0:11:36use the same fingerprints and multiple

0:11:37sites guys

0:11:38your fingerprints are your fingerprints

0:11:40and for the most part your face is your

0:11:41face so once compromise their compromise

0:11:43forever

0:11:44you can't use your fingerprint in the

0:11:46whole world has hi-res images of your

0:11:47fingerprints

0:11:48your fingerprints are useless never mind

0:11:50that this country anyway law enforcement

0:11:52can make you put your stupid thing on

0:11:53the thing anyway but just in general

0:11:55biometrics there unlike passwords that

0:11:59you can change the rotator whatever you

0:12:00can't change them even your retinas if

0:12:02you do a retina skin and someone has

0:12:03like a detailed map of your retina makes

0:12:05a little thing I've all of the retina

0:12:06scan it you can't use retina scans

0:12:07anymore it's bad and if it became

0:12:11commonplace it's the definition of

0:12:13repeating your password you only have

0:12:14ten fingers right getting able with

0:12:16different finger on each secure thing

0:12:18and yeah so internal biometrics are

0:12:21great convenience but if we get in in

0:12:23sci-fi movies are you anyway they always

0:12:26presented as a much more secure way like

0:12:28how you can't get in because you don't

0:12:30have my eyeball my finger and then

0:12:31didn't take long for the movies to have

0:12:33to shift into gouging people's eyeballs

0:12:35out and cutting off their hands to get

0:12:36their fingerprints

0:12:37there's another downside of biometrics

0:12:39but in general I think biometrics

0:12:41settling in to be the casual convenience

0:12:44feature is the reason i unlock my phone

0:12:46with it because who wants to type in

0:12:47some big long password every time your

0:12:49unlock your phone but not for increased

0:12:52security very security we're still stuck

0:12:56with for now big giant passwords and

0:12:59multiple factors i love that ripping out

0:13:02somebody's eyes and cutting off the

0:13:04fingers is is described by you john is a

0:13:06downside i mean it is it's a pretty

0:13:10significant downside my book though no

0:13:12one's gonna do that unless you're in a

0:13:14year ago you know a sci-fi movie like

0:13:16this no one cares that much about

0:13:17crap and again it's not there much

0:13:18easier ways to get your crap like just

0:13:20forcing you to put your finger on it

0:13:21because you're not a big tough guy but

0:13:22in the movies to get into your villains

0:13:25lair that you know you cut off the guy's

0:13:27hand cut off the entrance and then you

0:13:29just showed on the panel didn't uh Tom

0:13:32Cruise's character do that Minority

0:13:34Report you got two eyes been done so

0:13:35many times so many times we are brought

0:13:39to you this week by set appt the

0:13:41revolutionary new service for

0:13:43discovering and using the best apps for

0:13:45your mac what if there's a way to know

0:13:47that every app you installed was safe

0:13:49always updated and of the highest

0:13:50quality that is what set appt is here to

0:13:53do that was developed by Mac paw they've

0:13:55actually been previous sponsoring the

0:13:57show with a clean my mac a lot of

0:13:59products and they've created many

0:14:01successful apps for the mac they've been

0:14:02mapped developers themselves for years

0:14:05and they know the market really well

0:14:07they know what customers want and they

0:14:09know what developers want developers

0:14:11want a way to make consistent stable

0:14:14revenue from their products without

0:14:15having to mess with the complexity of

0:14:17things like upgrade pricing and trials

0:14:19and everything else and customers want

0:14:21to know that they can go to a storefront

0:14:24or a collection that has the best apps

0:14:27they can they don't have to like worry

0:14:28about looking through the looking

0:14:30through million reviews and trying to

0:14:32figure out which apps have hidden in app

0:14:33purchases or ads or anything like that

0:14:35they just want someone else to pick for

0:14:37them to curate this collection for them

0:14:38to give them what's best mac Paul has

0:14:41done this with set appt setup gives you

0:14:43easy access to their curated library of

0:14:46quality mac apps like Ulysses

0:14:48rapidweaver cleanmymac ultimate player

0:14:51and many many more

0:14:53and you get all this as a user for just

0:14:55a flat monthly subscription fee you get

0:14:58access to the entire library no matter

0:15:00how many apps use you can use all of

0:15:01them if you want to and you just pay

0:15:03this low monthly rate it's a huge

0:15:06library of prime mac apps that you get

0:15:09for one fixed rate per month with no ads

0:15:11no paid upgrades when a new version

0:15:13comes out you just get it did give you

0:15:15the best collection of helpful useful

0:15:17high-quality mac software right at your

0:15:19fingertips try today at set app.com once

0:15:23again that set appt setiap set app.com

0:15:26to try out setup see for yourself

0:15:29thank you very much to set up for spot

0:15:30during our show ah alright so there's

0:15:36been a little bit of a sort of kind of

0:15:39back and forth between our show and one

0:15:43host across to other shows which is a

0:15:46friend of the show my curly he is talked

0:15:50on his to podcast upgrade and connected

0:15:52about some arguments or counter

0:15:56arguments about whether or not the ipad

0:15:59is worth apples attention and you really

0:16:01should listen to both upgrade connected

0:16:03in wealth in general but particularly

0:16:05the latest episodes will put links in

0:16:07the show notes i'm going to try to

0:16:11unfairly summarize Mike's points and

0:16:14then I anything to hear this

0:16:17yeah and hen Marco can add his two cents

0:16:20about about all this

0:16:22I what I got from what Mike said was hey

0:16:25if you look at modern iPads and modern

0:16:30max where you define modern slightly

0:16:33arbitrarily but basically can run the

0:16:35most recent versions of iOS and mac OS I

0:16:39don't remember the exact numbers but you

0:16:41know modern max by that definition go go

0:16:43back like between five and ten years and

0:16:46modern iPads go back i think around five

0:16:48years something like that the particular

0:16:49numbers don't really matter that much

0:16:51the conclusion that my came to was hey

0:16:55if you look at the sales and thus

0:16:58assumed install base of modern max and

0:17:03modern iOS devices are excuse me iPads

0:17:06there like twice as many ipads as there

0:17:09are max so if there's that many ipads in

0:17:12the wild

0:17:13shouldn't that be where Apple puts most

0:17:16of its attention because presumably all

0:17:19of these ipads are still in use and

0:17:21presumably at least a subset of these

0:17:24owners your ipad owners are using them

0:17:26for and I'm doing scare quotes here work

0:17:28stuff so shouldn't that be where Apple

0:17:31puts all of its attention maybe not all

0:17:33but a lot of its attention and that's a

0:17:35super super super summarized version

0:17:37again listen to connected and upgrade

0:17:39actually the reverse order listen okay

0:17:41first but anyway list of them to get the

0:17:43longer

0:17:44students but that that's kind of what i

0:17:46got from it is that fair to say yeah I

0:17:48think so I mean and this was this was in

0:17:50response to what a lot of people were

0:17:53talking about after the earnings came

0:17:55out what do we do now about about how

0:17:59ipad sales continue to drop and many

0:18:01people commented on this with theories

0:18:03myself included both on my blog and then

0:18:06we talked about on the show last week

0:18:07and you know many many people at every

0:18:10time there's quarterly earnings that

0:18:12come out and it shows the ipad sales are

0:18:13going down which happened a lot in the

0:18:15last few years everyone has these

0:18:18theories about well here's why the ipad

0:18:20has failed his failing or you can get

0:18:22real work on honor or whatever else and

0:18:24so if you are an ipad pro heavy user

0:18:28like Mike and Federico and and some

0:18:31other friends are then this makes sense

0:18:34to be defensive about because it's it's

0:18:38very hard to separate out these

0:18:40arguments into like individual things to

0:18:43talk about a lot of times people are

0:18:45arguing past each other because they're

0:18:47not quite hearing what the other

0:18:50argument was or they're responding more

0:18:52to a general feeling or to a general

0:18:54kind of trend of where the commentary is

0:18:57or has been rather than what somebody

0:19:00actually said or what people are

0:19:01actually trying to figure out there's

0:19:03there's nuance to all this stuff so part

0:19:05of what Mike and Jason on upgrade were

0:19:08responding to was not just what we said

0:19:11but i think a lot of it was based on

0:19:13awesome what we said and what i wrote my

0:19:15blog post about what if the ipod is in

0:19:17the future of computing and and so I do

0:19:19want to address this so hopefully

0:19:21briefly here and I'm actually I'm

0:19:24working with Mike we actually might do a

0:19:25little special with me and Mike arguing

0:19:27about it and maybe next week sometime

0:19:28will do i get not to get to participate

0:19:31in that

0:19:32who says I'm right about everything you

0:19:33guys at argue about which one who were

0:19:35all who will have another these episodes

0:19:39but it seems like it was like mike vs

0:19:41Marco but like I said stuff to didn't

0:19:43anyone disagree with stuff I said you

0:19:45had hit you don't worry I you and I were

0:19:47kind of lumped in together anyway so

0:19:49that's unfair

0:19:50yeah that's right haha i do that would

0:19:53get you

0:19:53anyway so here's here's my actual

0:19:57position here obviously people are

0:20:00getting real worked on ipads not every

0:20:02ipad owner of course but as Mike

0:20:04accurately pointed out

0:20:06not every mac is sold and used to do

0:20:08quote real work whatever that means

0:20:10Mike's main point was was also that you

0:20:12know the ipad obviously even even with

0:20:15the downward slope of its sales curve is

0:20:17still selling like two two-and-a-half

0:20:19times unit sales of what max you're

0:20:22selling and and there are still way more

0:20:25ipads out there then max and and so

0:20:27therefore this is this really is your a

0:20:29serious platform and I'm not arguing

0:20:32against any of that actually my main

0:20:35argument with with my post and hopefully

0:20:39if I express a property last week is

0:20:41that the ipad is presented in so many

0:20:47views both from apple and from analysts

0:20:49and fans as quote the future of

0:20:52computing and what I interpret that to

0:20:53mean is a replacement ultimately or

0:20:57largely a replacement for the pc in the

0:21:00back but were mostly seeing is that you

0:21:03know pcs of them have been a little bit

0:21:04contracting for a while but mac sales

0:21:07have been pretty solid the rise of the

0:21:10ipad / it's been seven years now and

0:21:13it's been popular the whole time so it's

0:21:15selling a lot the ipad selling a lot but

0:21:17during that entire arise sales of Max

0:21:19haven't gone down so if the ipad were

0:21:22really like the future of computing in

0:21:24quotes and found doing finger quotes

0:21:26here sorry in hit in the way that that

0:21:28means replacing pcs and macs for a lot

0:21:31of people i think the numbers are

0:21:33showing otherwise that I'm and I and I

0:21:34made the case last week that for a lot

0:21:37of people if you're going to choose

0:21:39between only being able to afford only

0:21:41wanting to own either and ipad or a

0:21:44computer

0:21:45they're still picking the computer i

0:21:47think the sale show that and there's

0:21:49lots of reasons as we get into last week

0:21:50about why that might be you know things

0:21:52about things like the limitations of

0:21:54doing things in the ipad and and how

0:21:57many limitations you have there versus

0:21:58the what limitations intend to be on PCs

0:22:01and and you know different usability and

0:22:03everything we know we are getting better

0:22:04so I'm not going to repeat the whole

0:22:05thing all this is not to say that you

0:22:07can

0:22:08to get worked on an iPad or the ipad

0:22:10you're only for consumption

0:22:11I never said that there is this is also

0:22:13all not to say that nobody is replacing

0:22:17their their pc or mac with an ipad i

0:22:20didn't say that either but i think very

0:22:22clearly my argument my argument here

0:22:25that I'm clear right now again

0:22:26my argument is that on a large scale it

0:22:31doesn't appear that tablets are

0:22:33replacing pcs and the windows world is a

0:22:37little bit Messier because the cans

0:22:38combo things but on the apple site i

0:22:40think it's very very clear that the ipad

0:22:42is not replacing the mac it seems that

0:22:45most people who buy the ipad are buying

0:22:48it as the third device however they

0:22:50ordered in their minds they still have a

0:22:53phone and a computer and the ipad is

0:22:56added to that mix again not everybody

0:22:58not all I've had but this is added to

0:23:01the mix for so many people and so while

0:23:04everyone can name someone who who got an

0:23:07ipad and doesn't use the computer

0:23:09anymore

0:23:10a lot of people also use computers and

0:23:12don't buy iPads so I think the sales

0:23:15reflect the reality here the ipad like

0:23:17so many things in technology has not

0:23:20destroyed what came before it is added

0:23:22to it and so in a world where it is one

0:23:25of many devices that people used to

0:23:27computing on as opposed to the device

0:23:31that is replacing the computer I worry

0:23:33about the direction that Apple is taking

0:23:36between the the mac and the iPad because

0:23:38it sure looks like apples point of view

0:23:41and able to look into this crazy flasher

0:23:42rumor in a little bit but it sure looks

0:23:45like for the most part we see from apple

0:23:46is that the mac is kind of like i said

0:23:48last week it's kind of like in

0:23:49maintenance mode it seems like they're

0:23:50not really putting a lot of like a huge

0:23:52effort into like moving the mac paradigm

0:23:55forward it seems like they they consider

0:23:56the mac basically done and they're doing

0:23:59fairly minor things to it touch bar

0:24:01hardware engineering side yes okay but

0:24:03the software model seems like it's been

0:24:04fairly minor and not seeing a lot of

0:24:07meaningful changes are or engineering

0:24:09effort put into it could be wrong but

0:24:11this is what we're seeing me outside

0:24:13whereas the ipad if that if that were to

0:24:16be the future of computing than that

0:24:17which that needs more investment but

0:24:19we're seeing instead is that that's not

0:24:21it

0:24:21your computer and apples kind of

0:24:23neglecting both of these plans but

0:24:25that's a story for another day I guess

0:24:26but a text I just wanted to clarify my

0:24:29argument this is not that the ipad is

0:24:31useless or dead or not possible to get

0:24:33worked on simply that it is showing

0:24:37itself through sales to be in reality a

0:24:40third device for a lot of people and to

0:24:42not be replacing the back while you're

0:24:45talking about that I was thinking about

0:24:46often comment i think was the last show

0:24:50that apple doesn't make bestbest anymore

0:24:51and thinking about mac sales now that

0:24:56they're declining but as as the mac has

0:25:00become over many years proportionately

0:25:03less of what apple sells mostly because

0:25:05the iphone honestly you know because

0:25:07they saw brazilian iphones right but

0:25:08even though the ipad has pointed out

0:25:10that sells as much or more than the mac

0:25:12these days at to go back to our favorite

0:25:16well the good old car analogy in the car

0:25:19world if you sell a small number of cars

0:25:23and you are a going concern in the car

0:25:25business

0:25:26chances are good that the small number

0:25:28of cars you sell our extreme in some way

0:25:31no one sells a small number of Toyota

0:25:34Camrys but you can't run a car business

0:25:37by selling 5,000 Toyota Camrys a year

0:25:40that's not a thing right but you can

0:25:42sell 5,000 Ferraris a year and be ok you

0:25:46can sell 5,000 Humvees maybe and be okay

0:25:49or that's a bad example this GM but

0:25:51anyway if you sell in small volume you

0:25:54specialize and very often you charge

0:25:57tons of money like way out of proportion

0:25:59to the quality of the car you're selling

0:26:01you know Jaguar whatever sorry

0:26:03let's maybe that's not true these days I

0:26:05know they're better anyway if the mac

0:26:08again not low volume proportionally

0:26:10lower volume if the mac becomes the

0:26:14minor player in the world of the iphone

0:26:17which is the toyota camry right and even

0:26:19maybe even the ipads is selling more

0:26:21than it uh you know ongoing basis that

0:26:25would be the perfect time for them to

0:26:26look at that lines they will who is

0:26:28still buying max why would someone want

0:26:30him a call

0:26:30and I've had all that they have more

0:26:32demanding me the more sophisticated

0:26:34tasks go back to the old world apple

0:26:37which was perfectly willing to have a

0:26:40machine that we could be configured with

0:26:42an obscene amount of ram with a

0:26:44ridiculous number of the most expensive

0:26:46cpu's with a very large hard drive in a

0:26:50very big hot expensive GPU and

0:26:52overcharged for all of it that's the

0:26:54whole help away chart make a machine

0:26:56that i had can configure to be as much

0:26:58as an apple watch edition like should be

0:27:00able to configure you used to even with

0:27:02the old 2013 mac pro 15

0:27:05twenty-thousand-dollar Mac it's not

0:27:07worth that much money it's like it's

0:27:09overpriced in the same way that a

0:27:10Ferrari is not worth that much more than

0:27:11a Corvette that has almost the same

0:27:12performance but for people in certain

0:27:15markets whether it's because you need

0:27:16the absolute biggest best and you're

0:27:18willing to pay for it like it's a blip

0:27:20on your radar or just because you want a

0:27:22Ferrari because you think it's cool as

0:27:24your volumes get lower proportion the

0:27:26rest of your business that becomes a way

0:27:28to extract more money from this product

0:27:30line and so it seems that they are

0:27:32losing interest in the matter i wish

0:27:33they would have enough interest to say

0:27:34can we release those people because at

0:27:36this point like I'm I'm begging to be

0:27:38placed camp can't we

0:27:39you know like how have you priced out of

0:27:42touch bar macbook pro x and yeah I know

0:27:44I know like minutes that's going to but

0:27:46like it's still it's still within the

0:27:48realm of reason like you can't even get

0:27:49with 32 gigs ram right like and and if

0:27:52there are people who have those demands

0:27:53like there's nowhere to go in the

0:27:55macworld for them and take regardless of

0:27:59how we're going to draw the line between

0:28:00where is the line between people who

0:28:02really need a personal computer style

0:28:04thing and people who need an ipad and

0:28:05people just need a phone like it doesn't

0:28:07continuum there but at a certain point

0:28:09like we all agree that the mac is it

0:28:11that one end of that spectrum right it's

0:28:14not no one's arguing like the mac is in

0:28:15between the ipad of the phone or

0:28:16something it is one end of that spectrum

0:28:18you just need to extend that line out

0:28:20and make sure that if someone is forced

0:28:23into a mac or has to use a mac because

0:28:26of their work that they can go all the

0:28:28way up and you know because it's a

0:28:31low-volume relative the phone market

0:28:33charge tons of money gets super high

0:28:35margins maybe maybe less into the

0:28:38five-hundred-dollar increases on your

0:28:40own

0:28:40your laptop model which is more of a

0:28:43mainstream thing and just all that money

0:28:44into i don't know like a like a Mac it's

0:28:46for professionals like you can shorten

0:28:48the name but whatever i know we're at

0:28:50circles here but i was just the sad part

0:28:52is they have been doing that to the mac

0:28:54pro every mac pro generation is more

0:28:56expensive than the last one I know but

0:28:58then we're going to give you want to see

0:29:00be using it right a nice little is the

0:29:02properties i know but like it just seems

0:29:05like it's frustrating when at any price

0:29:08you you can't throw your money at apple

0:29:09and say just give me as much ram as well

0:29:12physically fit in the machine because

0:29:14i'm doing some weird application that i

0:29:15don't care how much it costs like nope

0:29:17not not interested in selling you that

0:29:19and you should be because it's a good

0:29:21way to make money off suckers like us

0:29:23and also a judge to bring back a little

0:29:26bit just to the ipad discussion i did

0:29:28want to also mention a great post that

0:29:31our friend David Sparkes made over at

0:29:33max Sparky about you know his his

0:29:36interpretation he is also a very like

0:29:38ipad pro user and his interpretation

0:29:41basically of trying to explain away the

0:29:43ipad sales dip is in short home some

0:29:47reason is accurately in short that

0:29:49basically it most people aren't pushing

0:29:52the idea ipad harlot that's why so many

0:29:55people are are able to eat people who

0:29:58decided to to make the ipad a part of

0:30:00their life or part of their workflow or

0:30:01or both

0:30:02they're still perfectly ok using like a

0:30:05four-year-old ipad and the main reason

0:30:07why it that he's saying which i think is

0:30:10is right on is that they're just not

0:30:13pushing it hard enough because the

0:30:15because what people do on ipads what the

0:30:19software does what is possible to do

0:30:22well on it is usually pretty light

0:30:24workload kind of stuff but it isn't the

0:30:26hardware is not getting better the

0:30:28harbor is getting way better but which

0:30:30is what most people are doing the ipad

0:30:31doesn't need better hardware and that

0:30:33the the blame for that and do to fix

0:30:36that or try to push that forward mostly

0:30:38and apple because a lot of that has to

0:30:40do with the OS and the way it's

0:30:41structured and various limitations a lot

0:30:44of it has to do with the app ecosystem

0:30:45which is all too much that is on Apple

0:30:49to to try to fix or or to enable fix us

0:30:53to happen

0:30:53we've seen this theme from a lot of a

0:30:56lot of ipad users responses over the

0:30:58last two weeks to this people love the

0:31:00ipad people want to use it for more they

0:31:04want to be able to be able to do more of

0:31:06their work on if they can't currently do

0:31:07all that on that but iOS needs to move

0:31:12forward in a way that lets people get

0:31:14more work more efficiently I mean there

0:31:16are so many really basic things that are

0:31:19that we consider basic format the PC era

0:31:21of just things like you know managing

0:31:23like multiple emails and attachments and

0:31:25you know it's like moving photos around

0:31:27the document around like things that are

0:31:29very hostile to do in iOS that are very

0:31:33clunky or some or sometimes even just

0:31:35impossible without crazy you know Jax or

0:31:37sometimes just outright impossible

0:31:39simple stuff like moving like moving

0:31:42media around and get dealing with

0:31:44people's files like iOS really fights

0:31:47people a lot of basic moment of

0:31:48multitasking stuff movies and

0:31:49implementation now is very limited and

0:31:52could really use some enhancement and

0:31:54weather that's coming down the road this

0:31:56year not we'll see i hope it does but

0:31:58the point is there's still tons of room

0:32:00to improve iOS and the ipad and I I hope

0:32:04Apple tries to do that in some way it

0:32:07because tons of people want that and it

0:32:10just seems like it seems like regardless

0:32:13of which side of the future of computing

0:32:15you fall on what do you think it's the

0:32:17ipad or the mac it seems like there's

0:32:21plenty to complain about Apple

0:32:22neglecting your platform either way I I

0:32:25hope Apple cares enough about the food

0:32:26the actual future computing to invest

0:32:29very heavily at least one of these

0:32:30platforms because it seems right now

0:32:31that the mac is in maintenance mode

0:32:33indefinitely and the ipad gets

0:32:35occasional updates from from iOS when

0:32:39it's convenient for them

0:32:41we're sponsor this week by a betterment

0:32:44investing made better to learn more

0:32:46visit betterment calm / ATP and get up

0:32:49to six months of no fees it is never too

0:32:52early to start saving for retirement or

0:32:54other financial goals betterment helps

0:32:56you manage your investments the same

0:32:58strategies the financial advisors you to

0:32:59clients with millions of dollars but

0:33:01brought to everybody at a much lower

0:33:03cost the financial services industry has

0:33:06embraced technology

0:33:07innovation to the creation of automated

0:33:09investing this means that you keep more

0:33:11of your money with fees are fraction of

0:33:12what you would pay for traditional

0:33:13financial services and betterment is the

0:33:15largest independent automated investing

0:33:17service out there managing more than 5.5

0:33:20billion dollars for over a hundred and

0:33:22eighty thousand customers you might have

0:33:24heard about them in the press they

0:33:25recently been talked about in the wall

0:33:26street journal Bloomberg and techcrunch

0:33:28and with betterment excess cashier

0:33:30investment generated automatically

0:33:31reinvested so every dollar you invest is

0:33:33put to work in your portfolio is

0:33:35automatically rebalance as needed

0:33:37investing involves risk to learn more

0:33:40visit betterment calm / ATP and you can

0:33:43get up to six months of no fees that's

0:33:45better mint.com / ATP betterment

0:33:48investing made better on the idea that

0:33:54the ipads like people keep using them

0:33:56because it still does what they want to

0:33:57do even though they could buy a much

0:33:59better one I think is another situation

0:34:02where Apple probably has data about this

0:34:04but trying to think about it

0:34:07actually there's two things that make

0:34:09you the 22 things that come to mind

0:34:10immediately that make you buy a new

0:34:12whatever one is the usual tractor of

0:34:15software basically if you have a vibrant

0:34:17software ecosystem eventually your old

0:34:20phone doesn't run the cool new app that

0:34:21all your friends are talking about

0:34:23so the more the more vibrant ecosystem

0:34:24is the more apps take advantage of new

0:34:28hardware or being dragged along by the

0:34:29platform by like not supporting 32-bit

0:34:32apps anymore whatever you know the more

0:34:35that is a thing it will make you say oh

0:34:36I don't like my phone anymore because

0:34:39all my friends are using a pecs and I

0:34:42can't use that because it says doesn't

0:34:44run on my phone or something right

0:34:45so software ecosystem which again is

0:34:48lacking on the ipad like there's more of

0:34:50that on the phone in there isn't on the

0:34:52ipad in terms of social pressure and

0:34:55software you know action in the software

0:34:58market to put it along and the second

0:34:59one and this is where Apple have the

0:35:01data is how many people replace the

0:35:03phones because they break them

0:35:05I see a lot of broken phones and I see

0:35:09fewer broken ipad i do see cracked iPads

0:35:11you see them in airports and stuff but I

0:35:13also see kids in airports with iPads

0:35:15dropping them like they're a juice box

0:35:18and his boundless in the giant robbery

0:35:20cases there

0:35:21alright so i'm going to say probably

0:35:23percentage-wise phones and their lives

0:35:27because they break more often than iPads

0:35:30just based on my personal experience and

0:35:31anatoly but again Applewood know because

0:35:33they probably in all the servers say why

0:35:35are you buying a new phone

0:35:37it seems to me that those two tractors

0:35:40are making the phone replacement cycle

0:35:43notice that didn't list is one of the

0:35:45things that that's making people replace

0:35:46the phone is that their phone feels slow

0:35:48in general I think I phones don't are

0:35:51like Windows computers were used them

0:35:53for two years and they're soaked wrapped

0:35:54up that you just need to get a new one

0:35:56again this is based on my experience and

0:35:57talking to other people that doesn't

0:35:59happen with phones as much not say it

0:36:00doesn't happen at all sometimes your

0:36:02phone does get slow and you know i

0:36:03upgraded the OS and my phone feel slow

0:36:05and that is another that is another

0:36:06factor in it but I feel like it is far

0:36:08beyond behind software ecosystem

0:36:11pressuring you into upgrading your phone

0:36:14and just plain dropping it and you have

0:36:16none of those things are true for the

0:36:17ipad then it is protected and it kind of

0:36:19makes me fear for the day when Apple

0:36:21makes an iphone you can drop all day

0:36:23long and never breaks will the phone

0:36:25suddenly become like the ipad if it

0:36:27again if this theory is correct that you

0:36:29know the people aren't buying new iPad

0:36:31because the one that has working just

0:36:32fine i think people's phones will be

0:36:34working just fine if there wasn't

0:36:36something that they want to play they

0:36:37didn't keep dropping know maybe I'm

0:36:39overestimating the dropping and maybe I

0:36:40noticed cracks too much because i'm

0:36:42always amazed at the vast percentage of

0:36:45people I see like on the train or

0:36:46whatever just swiping thumbs along

0:36:49totally shattered phones you know I'm

0:36:50iOS or not because people drop them and

0:36:53they're made of glass and it's a problem

0:36:54so I don't know you don't really need to

0:36:57get a product marketing for apple on the

0:37:00show now that we're mad with power and

0:37:02say what are your percentage of white

0:37:04people replace their phones it because

0:37:06they have an android phone it's getting

0:37:07old and slow because they drop their old

0:37:09one or is it because they want to play a

0:37:10new game I first of all that that's okay

0:37:15that'll be question number one for when

0:37:16we get filled question number 2 question

0:37:181 will be about the mac pro out okay i

0:37:20have many other questions earlier the

0:37:22killer sorry folks that's fair but i do

0:37:26think you are under estimating how many

0:37:28people replace their phone because it's

0:37:29old and slow because you think it's just

0:37:32always upgrades like yes I I

0:37:34brought that up and i have heard that

0:37:36from a lot of people and it is a real

0:37:37thing but I was gonna say no one's

0:37:39forcing you to upgrade your your phone

0:37:41button apples pretty pushing these days

0:37:42aren't they yeah they Apple really

0:37:44really pushes the upgrade pretty hard

0:37:46and a lot sometimes like a nap a

0:37:48critical app that for people will

0:37:50require it to that kind of forces i'm

0:37:52terry they push you on the ipad 2 like I

0:37:53had iPads that I regret upgrading the OS

0:37:56four because they just sold in your you

0:37:58upgrade to the very last thing like I

0:37:59should have stayed one version back so

0:38:01why wouldn't that make people replace

0:38:02their iPads in the same way

0:38:03well that that's a good question were

0:38:05thinking about i think one of the

0:38:07reasons for that may be one of the

0:38:08biggest reasons for that is the the

0:38:11types of apps that you use on the ipad

0:38:14vs types you absolutely that use enough

0:38:16on the phone and like like is there an

0:38:18app that's pushing you to upgrade or not

0:38:19on the ipad I i think i think the data

0:38:24shows that despite this despite the

0:38:27community of people who get a lot of

0:38:30work on the ipad a lot of ipad users are

0:38:33using it mainly for video watching web

0:38:36browsing and email me at facebook like

0:38:38bait the basics basics like email web

0:38:41video kind of workflow and for that

0:38:43probably nothing really going to push

0:38:46you to really upgrade your OS like you

0:38:48can still use apples mail app and

0:38:49whatever else you have you can still use

0:38:51the web browser you can probably like I

0:38:53would imagine like Facebook and netflix

0:38:54and stuff probably keep their inversion

0:38:56pretty low pulled up the upgrade the OS

0:38:58but you don't doesn't matter if you're

0:39:00crazy or is it just using to play video

0:39:01it really doesn't matter exactly how

0:39:03close to the animation is on springboard

0:39:04when you launched it for example you

0:39:06care about is once the video starts

0:39:07playing it's fine

0:39:08that's fair but anyway regardless I i

0:39:11think the way most iPads are used it

0:39:15probably has a slower upgrade cycle from

0:39:18this office I'd simply because they're

0:39:20not often using a lot of apps that

0:39:22require the newest version of the OS

0:39:24where's the phone

0:39:25you have a lot more like you know new

0:39:27games that come out new cutting-edge

0:39:29have to come out usually come on the

0:39:30phone first or only and you have more

0:39:32early adopters that it seemed like more

0:39:34driving that but also just like there's

0:39:36like this consistent narrative with the

0:39:38ipad that explains a lot of this that is

0:39:41probably correct and there is some data

0:39:42to back it up that basically

0:39:45while you can get work done on it a lot

0:39:48of people do use it for mostly

0:39:50consumption

0:39:51that's not a judgment that's just what

0:39:52people do that's also true computers

0:39:55that's also true phones however that is

0:39:56true hi pads and that people's needs on

0:39:59ipads are so are fairly simple most of

0:40:03the time whoever's fault that it doesn't

0:40:05really matter the point is people do

0:40:07pretty simple things that I've had most

0:40:08of the time you know it's only one data

0:40:11point but I feel like it's relevant the

0:40:15aforementioned ipad3 that we had after

0:40:20we stopped using it because we found it

0:40:23to be too old

0:40:24it was collecting dust for months and

0:40:27then just a couple months back i had my

0:40:30ID I you know reset it all and i had my

0:40:34dad bring it to my grandparents they

0:40:37live in Pennsylvania i'm in Virginia and

0:40:39although they come down from time to

0:40:41time we haven't been up there in a long

0:40:43time and you know they're they're not

0:40:46that young at this point because i'm

0:40:49turning 35 pretty soon and these are my

0:40:51grandparents but I'm but we gave them

0:40:53this ipad 3 mostly so they could face

0:40:56time with us and Declan and you know I

0:40:58guess my parents from time to time as

0:40:59well from what I understand they were

0:41:04beyond overjoyed to have received it not

0:41:08only because of facetime but because

0:41:12it's a much easier device for them to

0:41:14use their pc and I think it's a

0:41:15reasonably modern PC but they were

0:41:18overjoyed to receive an ipad 3 it late

0:41:24in 2016 was the ipad 3 new like 2012 or

0:41:27something like that probably before that

0:41:29actually so 12 it wasn't 20 ok yes they

0:41:35were beyond excited to receive this old

0:41:37device which for them is more than

0:41:39enough now obviously they have nothing

0:41:41to compare to

0:41:42obviously in a perfect world i'm sure

0:41:45they would prefer brand new one but four

0:41:48for someone who hadn't had one before it

0:41:52was way more than enough and not every

0:41:56ipad users going to be like that and i'm

0:41:58sure that there's

0:41:59there's tons of ipad users that upgrade

0:42:01regularly that are not using it for work

0:42:03they just really love the ipad but to

0:42:06speak of the longevity the ipad this is

0:42:07a device that's you know nearly five

0:42:10years old now that brought genuine joy

0:42:14to their household when they received it

0:42:16because it's a thing like that this is

0:42:19why pads are so useful and so many of

0:42:21them are still in use because most

0:42:23people's needs are pretty low-end most

0:42:25people just want a thing that they can

0:42:27browse the web and send emails and see

0:42:29facebook on like that's pretty much what

0:42:31most people do with any of their

0:42:32computing devices phone laptop or tablet

0:42:34and so this device is delightful for

0:42:38that again but that but I i think that

0:42:41that doesn't preclude you know people

0:42:43doing really work on it and also my

0:42:46theory that that I'm putting forth with

0:42:48this the sales graphs that like this is

0:42:50mostly just added to the world

0:42:52technology i mean there aren't any real

0:42:54answers here like the the data that we

0:42:57have is shallow and we have to

0:43:01extrapolate a lot from it and and so

0:43:04because of that it's there's so much

0:43:05judgment involved and there's no clear

0:43:07right or wrong and I think that's why

0:43:09we're going to talk about it in its

0:43:11across 17 different podcasts for a

0:43:15little while the item is so let's talk

0:43:18about something that's indisputably

0:43:20awesome we are brought to you this week

0:43:23by Squarespace start building your

0:43:25website today at squarespace.com enter

0:43:27offer code ATP at checkout to get ten

0:43:29percent off

0:43:31Squarespace is platform is incredibly

0:43:33powerful but it's so easy to use you can

0:43:36make a beautiful website with no time at

0:43:40all

0:43:40you can take less than an hour and see

0:43:43what everything it can do you don't even

0:43:44have to pay because you can start a free

0:43:46trial and when you do want to pay use

0:43:48code ATP of course but you don't even

0:43:49have to pay you can see what it is

0:43:51without ever giving them a credit card

0:43:52you can get a free trial site you can

0:43:54build out what you want to see and you

0:43:56can see for yourself how incredibly good

0:43:58it is gonna tell you what

0:43:59once you've made a site with squarespace

0:44:00you will wonder why anybody does it any

0:44:02other way because most other ways to

0:44:05make websites are way more complicated

0:44:07way more time-consuming much harder to

0:44:10support overtime

0:44:11and people ask us to make this all the

0:44:13time and people who listen to the show

0:44:15probably probably a lot of you have

0:44:17people in your life who asked you to

0:44:18make websites for them you don't want to

0:44:20support that you don't want to do that

0:44:21you don't have to like patch that or

0:44:23upgrade that ordeal with them whenever

0:44:24there's there you know server goes down

0:44:26whatever else you want someone else to

0:44:28take care of that and Squarespace can do

0:44:29that whether it's for your site or for a

0:44:31site someone else wants you to help to

0:44:33help them setup setup on Squarespace

0:44:35because their platform takes care of

0:44:37everything hosting you never even have

0:44:40to think about software updates and

0:44:41patches obviously support which is a

0:44:43huge thing if you're so excited for

0:44:45somebody else and you and they need help

0:44:47with something they ask where space not

0:44:49you you want to get yourself out of that

0:44:50business let Squarespace take care of it

0:44:52and no matter what you're making whether

0:44:54it's for you or somebody else you'll be

0:44:56surprised how fast it is to make

0:44:58everything with squarespace you just put

0:45:00things up there and just done eat you

0:45:02can mess with the design if you want to

0:45:03you don't even have to the stock stuff

0:45:04is beautiful if you want if you want to

0:45:06belittle customizations you can like two

0:45:08seconds

0:45:09try it just try it next to me to make

0:45:11anything make your next move with

0:45:13squarespace see for yourself when you're

0:45:16ready to check out use offer code ATP to

0:45:18get ten percent off your purchase a

0:45:20Squarespace make your next move at

0:45:22Squarespace so there was this crazy

0:45:29dammit sorry up there was this crazy

0:45:32rumor are sort of rumor that was posted

0:45:35on slashdot as a comment and this was a

0:45:41in / top parlance an anonymous coward

0:45:44which is to say somebody that didn't

0:45:46want to leave their name but they went

0:45:47on and on about how there are several

0:45:50armed powered laptops that are drifting

0:45:52around internally at apple and this

0:45:55individual claims to have seen several

0:45:56with my with their own eyes and they had

0:46:01a lot to say about it i don't know the

0:46:03best way to summarize it partially

0:46:04because i read this days ago and I

0:46:06haven't looked back since

0:46:07which was in part because it seemed kind

0:46:10of bananas to me right but I'm but it

0:46:14seemed like the the short short version

0:46:16was yeah there's some apps that that run

0:46:20on arm and the OS is really iOS

0:46:23fish even though it is an iOS like a lot

0:46:26of things that that we like to control

0:46:29as a as you even not even necessarily

0:46:33power usage users on Mac OS not a lot of

0:46:36that is available on these supposed

0:46:38phantom our max I didn't think this is

0:46:42something about this didn't feel right

0:46:44to me like i'm not sure i can point to a

0:46:46specific passage and say yes this is why

0:46:47it's bananas but a lot of it just didn't

0:46:50feel right to me and from what I

0:46:51gathered from people that I've spoken to

0:46:53it didn't feel right to a lot of them

0:46:55but we wanted to acknowledge its

0:46:57existence and we'll put a link to the

0:46:58show notes and I'm sure that the two of

0:46:59you have some thoughts on it as well I

0:47:01don't do more than just technology

0:47:03yeah I don't want to entertain it as a

0:47:05as a possibility because that you know

0:47:08this is not a credible source but let's

0:47:09just pretend like hypothetically let's

0:47:11talk about this thing if it existed

0:47:13right because I again that they don't

0:47:15think the sourcing is enough to say that

0:47:16this does exist but i would say in fact

0:47:19the the incredible shadiness of this

0:47:21post and so many of the like weird

0:47:23things that don't really sound very

0:47:24Apple II or don't reflect how to

0:47:26actually work

0:47:27I i would say this is very unlikely to

0:47:29be true but I but I'd the reason I want

0:47:32to talk about this too i was very happy

0:47:33to see the note is that this is an

0:47:35interesting idea for where the mac could

0:47:38plausibly go because while the details

0:47:40of this are very suspicious admit that

0:47:42make you discount the validity of this

0:47:44of this report i do think the overall

0:47:47idea of such a product is plausible and

0:47:50the idea that apple would take in this

0:47:52direction is very plausible that was

0:47:54plausible this is like this is the as

0:47:57soon as iOS appeared this is basically

0:48:00the exact not an exemplar but like like

0:48:03this is the prototype of this rumor the

0:48:05very second the first person said iOS

0:48:08Mac merge like the very second someone

0:48:10said that many many years ago this is

0:48:11exactly what they were talking about is

0:48:13a mac running arm CPUs can only get apps

0:48:16from the app store everything locked

0:48:18down all binary sign can restore from

0:48:21the internet like a phone like it there

0:48:23is nothing in this that is even outside

0:48:25the realm of the things that mean the

0:48:26only reason is you know it's interesting

0:48:29again it's because being presented as

0:48:30truth is kind of the same way when you

0:48:31tell a joke you pretend it's a real

0:48:32story that happened to make the joke

0:48:34funnier

0:48:34that's exactly how this is working here

0:48:36but because we haven't had like the of

0:48:39the reasons we're talking about again is

0:48:41because we haven't revisited this idea

0:48:43of the iOS and mac merge totally locked

0:48:46down Mac thing again and in light of the

0:48:49actual appearance of arm CPUs inside max

0:48:51with the touch bar mac pros and in light

0:48:53of all the Intel stuff and so on and so

0:48:54forth in our own revisiting of what is

0:48:57it going to be time to flip them back

0:48:58over to harm i think it's worth

0:49:00revisiting this old the rumor of the

0:49:02merged you know that emerged iOS Mac not

0:49:06so much the merging of the u.s.

0:49:08interface wise but of literally

0:49:10buttoning down the mac in all the same

0:49:12way that iOS button down as an example

0:49:15of what we talked about last show like

0:49:16you know either

0:49:17expand the capabilities of iOS or making

0:49:21the mac easier this would be an example

0:49:22of taking all the sharp edges in the mac

0:49:24and following them down as much as

0:49:26possible to make something that is

0:49:28hopefully almost as easy to use an iPad

0:49:31but so much more capable

0:49:32yeah and so I i think it's worth going

0:49:34over some of the details he's our chief

0:49:36summarizer in chief failed to that's

0:49:38what it's ok if you've had a long day

0:49:41look at the after show but true

0:49:44yes sorry it is so basically the the

0:49:47idea before this comment basically is

0:49:50that it is a it is like you know the

0:49:53next generation of laptop presumably or

0:49:56possibly have all max it is an ARM

0:49:58processor all custom app alarm harbor

0:50:00just like the iPads and phones but it

0:50:02only boots the signed os os images that

0:50:06that come from that come over the

0:50:07internet i assume that every time that

0:50:09not even that but like it only boots

0:50:11it's similar to iphones and ipads like

0:50:12there is no like physical install media

0:50:15there's no like downgrading it just

0:50:17here's the software update for you hear

0:50:19that you get you can't downgrade you

0:50:21can't choose what version you run just

0:50:22here's what you get period it said like

0:50:25you know a lot of the OS 10 legacy

0:50:27utilities and stuff are missing

0:50:29there's no more x11 there's no audio

0:50:31MIDI setup we know a lot of that stuff

0:50:33no disk utility no terminal which is

0:50:35interesting system preferences and a lot

0:50:37of functionality has had to move into a

0:50:38new app called settings to match iOS the

0:50:42app store is mandatory including even

0:50:45things that require hardware drivers

0:50:46Senate sounds kind of similar to when

0:50:49you plug

0:50:50and like it when you connect the

0:50:51bluetooth or Lightning device to a phone

0:50:52and it can associate itself with an app

0:50:54on the App Store app that lets it work

0:50:56similar to that but for drivers on the

0:50:58mac so you get a new like you know

0:51:00scanner something you plug it in and it

0:51:02downloads the door it launches you to

0:51:04the Mac App Store to download the driver

0:51:06for that

0:51:07similarly all drivers would be like you

0:51:09know kind of like iOS sandbox ified

0:51:11where something could install one of

0:51:13these drivers like that at the deep

0:51:14level system but then you could just go

0:51:15into a system pref pain and like delete

0:51:18it and it's gone it doesn't like Lee

0:51:20files behind you know it's a very iose

0:51:22in that way of like a night with iOS you

0:51:24can delete an app and you know

0:51:25everything about that is gone like it is

0:51:27there's no there's no like remnants of a

0:51:29left on your phone or anything and of

0:51:30course the maximum work that way now you

0:51:32know max get gummed up over time those

0:51:34crap and yet you have like all this junk

0:51:36in your library folder and everything

0:51:37else and so and then a couple of things

0:51:41but yeah basically that the land and the

0:51:43the file system is a kind of like it he

0:51:48pronounced chroot in linux world is at

0:51:51route after but is it really that

0:51:53basically the file system is like

0:51:54Troodon so basically like you like what

0:51:57appears to be at route is your home

0:52:00directory and you don't even see the

0:52:02system files they're just don't even

0:52:04they're like that they're there they

0:52:06exist in the file system but you don't

0:52:07see them from your point of view from

0:52:09your user space you see at root your

0:52:12files and nobody elses and they said

0:52:14there's like no concept of seemingly of

0:52:15multi stuff but I don't want to get too

0:52:18much into the specifics of this post

0:52:20because again i think the credibility of

0:52:21it is is pretty low but as a future

0:52:25direction of mac OS and and of the mac

0:52:28hardware platform i do this we're

0:52:31talking about not only because it's so

0:52:32plausible based on what Apple's seems to

0:52:34want to do but also i think i will have

0:52:37the seemingly in this community very

0:52:40unpopular opinion that I think this

0:52:44could be really good with a few minor

0:52:47exceptions i think this could be really

0:52:49good

0:52:50the only things about this that give me

0:52:53a lot of paws are that it said that

0:52:57everything to come to the mac app store

0:52:58that's number one and i think you know

0:53:00the mac has this wonderful gatekeeper

0:53:02system and has the

0:53:03this kind of like code-signing without

0:53:06app review system called developer ID if

0:53:09that if the developer ID and gatekeeper

0:53:11come forward into whatever this is a

0:53:13look again assume this is real even

0:53:15though it probably isn't thought

0:53:17experiment time okay if this were if

0:53:20this were to have some kind of like

0:53:21developer mode where you could build

0:53:23open source stuff and you know it would

0:53:26however its container if it's in your

0:53:27little true jail fine but if you can

0:53:29build open source stuff if you can

0:53:31develop code if you can like compile

0:53:33code with with your c compiler whatever

0:53:35else and just running on this thing

0:53:37without the os's coat is interfering

0:53:39badly with that if that's possible to do

0:53:42here and you know and and if if you can

0:53:44do if you can distribute software

0:53:46developer ID which would bypass the at

0:53:48the mac app store then I think this is

0:53:52not only plausible and could be good but

0:53:56it might be great because a lot of this

0:53:58solves real problems with the mac and

0:54:01with peaceful oasis one of the biggest

0:54:03problems is like how its spread that all

0:54:06over the place all over the system you

0:54:07know they they they are like it isn't as

0:54:09it without with iOS you know is you

0:54:11delete the app it's gone on the macula

0:54:13the app and it's their garbage

0:54:14everywhere and you have to use like Matt

0:54:16cleanup utility is to clean up the

0:54:18garbage out sometimes you have to go

0:54:19find these files of the spread of your

0:54:21system and you can't be sure what

0:54:22happens do when you install it all the

0:54:24stuff like the the pc and mac style of

0:54:29of app security is outdated we know

0:54:32we've talked with before how they like

0:54:34to hold the unix idea of like anything

0:54:36you've run so that has access to your

0:54:37entire user account and everything you

0:54:40have a ready-made on user account all

0:54:41your files and it can delete files it

0:54:43will I can you can read everything of

0:54:44yours like that is an outdated model

0:54:46that that that is not great for the

0:54:48future computing and one of the things

0:54:49that makes iOS so appealing to a lot of

0:54:52people fraud of reasons is the

0:54:54additional simplicity and security that

0:54:56the sandboxing model that it has

0:54:58enforces I think there it is possible to

0:55:01do this well a lot of mac diehards are

0:55:05really against this idea when I saw this

0:55:08commented and assuming it might be real

0:55:09and I can see why that why you would be

0:55:13so against this but I think

0:55:15if again which is like that's very

0:55:17slight tweak of like a developer mode

0:55:19and being able to distribute software

0:55:21developer ID that's pretty much all i

0:55:25would need for this at you know it like

0:55:27it sounds like it would be really good

0:55:29in a lot of other ways either the mac is

0:55:32in maintenance mode as i keep saying it

0:55:34seems that way and nothing ever changes

0:55:36and it's fine

0:55:37or if it is going to change if Apple

0:55:40really is working on like the next the

0:55:43next generation of os not just 10 dot

0:55:47something else

0:55:48the entire next generation like when

0:55:50they went from classic to OS 10 if they

0:55:53are indeed working on such a thing for

0:55:54the mac which I would argue they should

0:55:57be because it would be ridiculous to

0:55:59complete to continue computing platform

0:56:01for but no plans to ever do that then I

0:56:04think this is exactly the kind of thing

0:56:07they would do and we should be prepared

0:56:09for it and we can see a preview of what

0:56:12it's like by looking at iOS iOS is even

0:56:15more restrictive than this and so if if

0:56:18this is plausible and and if this

0:56:20happens and if it's done well with with

0:56:23with those couple of little holes

0:56:25puncture the wall for developers and for

0:56:26distribution through developer ideas i

0:56:28said i think this could be a great move

0:56:32forward

0:56:33this could be the simplicity and

0:56:35security of iOS but with windowing and

0:56:39file management and access to your files

0:56:42in it in a traditional paradigm and

0:56:44stuff like that and yes it would require

0:56:46a lot of apps to be written some things

0:56:49that works in the old system wouldn't

0:56:50work anymore but a lot of this stuff is

0:56:52ancient like I don't need x11 anymore i

0:56:55don't like there's a lot of this stuff

0:56:57is so ancient mac OS is very old it has

0:57:00a community craft over time because

0:57:02everything does this new way of doing

0:57:05things

0:57:06sounds like it could really be the

0:57:09actual future of computing that blends

0:57:12together the greatness of iOS with ap

0:57:14style paradigm to a lot more types of

0:57:16work to get done for more people

0:57:18this sounds really good to me the actual

0:57:22future computer i spent all this time

0:57:23explaining myself and you just ignore me

0:57:26last week we talked about the ipad was

0:57:30like was making progress in terms of

0:57:31expanding its capabilities with

0:57:33multitasking and the pen and the bigger

0:57:34size and stuff but like what kind of

0:57:36slowly the mac has been doing that same

0:57:40thing but in the other direction but

0:57:42even more slowly because if you think

0:57:45about the Mac the Mac trying to try to

0:57:48simplify itself trying to be friendlier

0:57:50this has been a process the process took

0:57:53a pretty big leap with classic taurus

0:57:56ten actually because many things that

0:57:59were way more complicated and classic

0:58:01we're massively simplify the doc is the

0:58:03best example of that all the ways that

0:58:04you could manage the same stuff the doc

0:58:07is supposed to do on classic mac OS at

0:58:10the time we transitioned doctors just

0:58:12like the most dumbed down version of all

0:58:16the other options about not even

0:58:17including third-party things of which

0:58:19there were many this was this one first

0:58:20party thing

0:58:21no you can't use the private api's to to

0:58:24make your own doc type thing will we

0:58:26will fight you on that and it is way

0:58:28simpler and don't worry about it that's

0:58:30all everybody needs right and sandboxing

0:58:33another example a long slow painful slog

0:58:36trying to get some of the benefits that

0:58:38you get in iOS all your crap in one

0:58:40place protect applications protected

0:58:42from each other blah blah it's been slow

0:58:45going

0:58:45we haven't been able to get there

0:58:48because sandboxing is incompatible lots

0:58:50of cool things that the mac apps have

0:58:52done and still want to do and it's very

0:58:56difficult for Apple to ever get slowly

0:59:01incrementally get to the point where mac

0:59:03applications our sandbox in the same way

0:59:05as iOS applications instead they've been

0:59:07saying you can be a mac app and your

0:59:10stuff can still be in seven different

0:59:11places because it kind of has to be but

0:59:14we'll put some constraints on you and

0:59:16it's a this weird mismatch between

0:59:18having to do that but also having to be

0:59:21protected from yourself and isolated

0:59:23from other applications even so far as

0:59:26like how many machs have struggled with

0:59:27the sandbox because the the integration

0:59:30point on pc cell operating systems is

0:59:32very often the filesystem and that's how

0:59:35that's our application share things with

0:59:37each other is I right thing here and

0:59:39you open that same thing over there and

0:59:41we make that the user is allowed to make

0:59:42little folders and put stuff in them and

0:59:44you're trying to sandbox things to each

0:59:45application only see his own files but

0:59:46like it's it's been difficult and so

0:59:49this this description of the the iOS

0:59:52ified mac which again has been in

0:59:54people's minds and talked about for many

0:59:56many years now the question is always

0:59:59how do you get

0:59:59how do you get

1:00:00from where we are to there is it's a big

1:00:03leap it and trying to do it

1:00:04incrementally has been very difficult

1:00:07it's been taking a long time

1:00:09it hasn't been particularly successful a

1:00:10lot of things efforts have stalled out

1:00:12despite a lot of effort put into it you

1:00:15know it gets back to the question from

1:00:17the last week's show it easier to make

1:00:20the ipad more capable and make the mac

1:00:21friendlier and simpler and I one

1:00:25question I think it's still easier to

1:00:26make iOS more capable because if you try

1:00:29to make the mac simpler everything about

1:00:32the system and the users and the

1:00:34developers fights you with every step

1:00:36because there's so much entrenched

1:00:37tradition and software and conventions

1:00:40and capabilities and attitudes and just

1:00:42like and crafts like Marco said just

1:00:44plain old craft that it's it's difficult

1:00:49together so this this though post here

1:00:52is almost kind of like wishful thinking

1:00:53like wouldn't be great if we could snap

1:00:56my fingers and be there and like Marco

1:00:58said one way you can do that to say okay

1:01:00well it's not mac OS anymore it's a new

1:01:02OS called something else you know like

1:01:03people would have said Mac OS 11 back in

1:01:05the days before the 10 got dropped right

1:01:06but this really it would be a leap of

1:01:09that size if it appeared wholesale you

1:01:12can still get their piecemeal it's going

1:01:15to take a long time you might have to

1:01:17wait for some people to die and there

1:01:19may be there are many places where you

1:01:20can go terribly wrong for example like

1:01:22it's obvious to us on this program has

1:01:25rabbit mac users that of course you'd

1:01:28have to have some load that most people

1:01:30wouldn't use but that would give you

1:01:31access to the terminal they will let you

1:01:33build or because your software

1:01:34developers we know any software

1:01:36developer who uses a mac no matter what

1:01:38kind of development and even if you're

1:01:40doing everything in xcode i would

1:01:41imagine but it's definitely for doing

1:01:42development you know friends have

1:01:44server-side software you're used to

1:01:46being able to install and run software

1:01:48like that is not signed with apples

1:01:51developer ID thing at all the units open

1:01:52source stuff it's not signed with

1:01:54developer ID and if you could literally

1:01:55can't run binaries that are not that are

1:01:58not signed if you don't have that final

1:02:00option gatekeeper to launch applications

1:02:02with another right click on the open and

1:02:04all that you know just launching it from

1:02:05the command line like if that option

1:02:07like literally does not exist as it

1:02:08doesn't on iOS unless you jailbreak and

1:02:10I really don't wanna be jailbreaking my

1:02:11mac

1:02:12that eliminates just so many users this

1:02:16is not even an edge case anymore is like

1:02:18a large percentage of people who you

1:02:20know whole professions who use max at

1:02:23their desks need the ability to do that

1:02:25type of stuff and are going to need it

1:02:27for the foreseeable future of you if you

1:02:29cut them off then you're just

1:02:31marginalizing the mac too much i think

1:02:32because it would be there will be eaten

1:02:33up by us on one side and you abandoned

1:02:35everybody else was using those features

1:02:37in the mac and so that the danger zone

1:02:38as well but the general idea of like let

1:02:42me just close my eyes and open them

1:02:43again and the mac at the very least

1:02:46solves a one or two or three of the

1:02:49biggest problems still wouldn't be

1:02:50solving the file system problem even

1:02:51with the chroot stuff and everything but

1:02:54at least you solve app install

1:02:56management drivers regularly uses

1:02:59wouldn't have to see disk images anymore

1:03:01and settings and preferences would be

1:03:05more coherent and familiar because they

1:03:07used to iOS like just those winds would

1:03:09be huge and if you can get those wins

1:03:11while also allowing people to do their

1:03:14work in the old way if they want to like

1:03:16that's talk about progressive disclosure

1:03:18like knowing if it's a developer mode

1:03:20over it like no believe me people are

1:03:22gonna be like I wish I want to have

1:03:23developer motor not know nobody wants

1:03:25that they wanted to be simple and nice

1:03:27like Casey's grandparents their

1:03:28overjoyed when it's like oh this is

1:03:30simple i just do this to this and it all

1:03:31makes sense to me is no place i can get

1:03:32into trouble

1:03:33they're not going to go looking for the

1:03:34thing to turn on developer mode that's

1:03:36for power users quote-unquote and yes

1:03:38there is a class of person who will go

1:03:39looking for it and turn it on and you

1:03:42know that because they're interested out

1:03:44there you know they're geeks they're

1:03:44nerds that's fine but regular people

1:03:46trust me do not want the complexity like

1:03:48all of us when we go into a preference

1:03:50screen and we see an advanced button we

1:03:51clicked immediately

1:03:52most people don't even want to go to

1:03:54preference screen like any one of the

1:03:55perfect screen exist they probably don't

1:03:57know the parents like it doesn't need to

1:03:59exist they just wanted to work and work

1:04:01fine so I'm pretty much with Marco that

1:04:04I would love a mac that work like this

1:04:05as long as I had the option to to you

1:04:09know that the developer motor the way to

1:04:11do stuff i just i'm not sure how long it

1:04:15will take to get there whether Apple has

1:04:18the will and the wants dedicated

1:04:20resources to get there because it just

1:04:23seems like still a much more

1:04:24straightforward path

1:04:25to continue to hand to enhance iOS I

1:04:27feel like iOS is getting this right

1:04:29iOS is still getting more sophisticated

1:04:31at a faster rate than the mac is getting

1:04:33simpler just fine with me as an old Mac

1:04:35user but if I start drawing lines on

1:04:37grass and seeing how this ends up it

1:04:39just seems to me that unless Apple has a

1:04:42massively renewed interest in the mac

1:04:45that iOS will eventually overtake it

1:04:47because for whatever their interest is

1:04:50in the mac they're interested in iOS

1:04:53seems much stronger on the phone and

1:04:55still even a little bit stronger on the

1:04:57ipad and who knows what other weird

1:04:59devices they're planning and you got the

1:05:01watchtower on the mix there to like iOS

1:05:03as a legacy free basis for innovation

1:05:06seems like a much easier path then

1:05:08continuing to bang my head against the

1:05:10mac you know the by and large I agree

1:05:13with you guys but I can't help but think

1:05:16a couple things one it almost sounds

1:05:19like you're saying I want the good parts

1:05:22of iOS and and none of the parts that

1:05:24bother me and that's okay

1:05:28like I mean yeah that does sound good to

1:05:29know itself but but I mean 442 people

1:05:34that really don't seem to be too

1:05:35terribly interested in in the ipad it's

1:05:38interesting hearing you say oh I'd love

1:05:40all that stuff in the ipad whose people

1:05:42as i used ipad everyday so what is the

1:05:45ipad more than I use my Mac like answer

1:05:47that but I do use that back at home i

1:05:49use definitely i obviously I were called

1:05:51animax so that that's that's the

1:05:52majority of my time but in my house I

1:05:54use my iPad literally every day and many

1:05:57days ago when I don't wake my mac from

1:05:58sleep most but I i think to clarify this

1:06:02it's not that all of iOS is bad there's

1:06:04tons of great stuff and iOS there's tons

1:06:06of there's tons of advantages of iOS

1:06:07there's a between the way iPads work and

1:06:12the way Mac OS works there's a huge

1:06:16difference in interaction paradigm the

1:06:19file you know the whole different

1:06:20between being you know Mac OS is very

1:06:22file centric like most PCOS is where

1:06:25whereas you know iOS is absent Rick

1:06:28these are massive differences in just

1:06:30the way the systems work of course you

1:06:33can take some of what's good about one

1:06:35and apply to the other

1:06:37the only question is you know where your

1:06:38starting point and and where are you

1:06:40going and you know like as you know as

1:06:42Johnson it's a lot easier to make the

1:06:43make iOS more capable than to make mac

1:06:46OS simpler however no matter what you do

1:06:49to Iowa it's still going to feel like a

1:06:52big phone that's AB centric and and not

1:06:54file centric and everything else because

1:06:56that's just like the entire amount of

1:06:57the system whereas on the mac if what

1:07:00you want is the pc style of computing it

1:07:05is totally possible with something like

1:07:08this crazy scheme that this crazy

1:07:09comment that is probably be s it is

1:07:11totally possible to to take the best of

1:07:14pc start computing make it still work

1:07:17the way the people who want that are

1:07:19accustomed to but bring in the modern

1:07:22advantages of iOS the other that

1:07:25somebody makes a lot more sense to me

1:07:27imagine if you gave your grandparents

1:07:29this mac described in here i think with

1:07:34the possible exception of the keyboard

1:07:35being intimidating they could be just as

1:07:38delighted because from their perspective

1:07:39if it's simple and they can figure out

1:07:42how to use it like like if it was

1:07:44basically as simple as the only way you

1:07:45could launch applications is Launchpad

1:07:47is Launchpad was always visible in the

1:07:49thing would probably have to be touch

1:07:50which is another issue entirely in terms

1:07:53of bridging that divide but like if they

1:07:55were never faced with the complexity of

1:07:58an open save dialog box or never had to

1:08:00look at a bunch of files or little

1:08:02documents on the desktop and never even

1:08:04looked at the desktop and it was just

1:08:05basically have the simplicity of an ipad

1:08:07what happened to be a mac they would be

1:08:10just as delighted because they just want

1:08:11to accomplish a task the task is video

1:08:14you know video conference with the with

1:08:17my family and be able to send emails or

1:08:19whatever and you and I could say oh if

1:08:21you had a macbook door what you can do

1:08:22just fine but the difference between a

1:08:24macbook adorable ipad that to them is

1:08:26huge so all you need to do to delight

1:08:29them with a mac is make it so that when

1:08:31they use it is just as simple as an iPad

1:08:33you can still have lurking under the

1:08:35covers all all the other complexity the

1:08:38filesystem stuff is a place where we

1:08:41continue to punt apple continues to

1:08:42point I I hold out hope that there is

1:08:44still a better way to collaborate on

1:08:46things than the completely absent

1:08:48require island model of

1:08:49iOS and the complete file central world

1:08:52of the pc but considering no one has

1:08:54figured out yet you know we'll just

1:08:56leave that off to the future but again

1:08:57we are talking about the future of

1:08:58computing at the present but anyway like

1:09:00that that's why I think this this mac is

1:09:03a this type of mac is appealing because

1:09:05it it will start to blur the lines that

1:09:08we're all thinking in terms of because

1:09:09once i like this appears on on the scene

1:09:11it's not we can't have the same

1:09:13conversation anymore it's a different

1:09:15conversation entirely you know the thing

1:09:17that I'm that I'm curious to see if this

1:09:22becomes real one day and it's the three

1:09:24of us who are still blathering on the

1:09:27show is what are the restrictions in and

1:09:30how egregious are they and I mean marco

1:09:32talk about this some but like the evo is

1:09:34if there's a developer mode what does

1:09:36that really give you and do you have a

1:09:38BF file system access just to your

1:09:40change rooted root area can you get all

1:09:44the way to the root can i install a

1:09:46colonel extension what I want to I just

1:09:49I can't help but feel like let's say

1:09:52this dropped in our laps tomorrow and

1:09:55you know Mark over you or me or all

1:09:57three of us by 1i think inevitably what

1:10:00would happen is it would put roadblocks

1:10:02in our way in ways we find frustrating

1:10:05and what I'm not sure about is would

1:10:08your average developer when looking to

1:10:11his or her left in seeing the touch bar

1:10:13macbook pro and then looking to his or

1:10:16her right and seeing this phantom

1:10:17arm-based mack i mean certainly I would

1:10:20choose them the touch bar macbook pro

1:10:22because it doesn't limit me at all and

1:10:24in in this hypothetical new mac while it

1:10:27does fix a lot of problems for people in

1:10:29general I don't think it solves any

1:10:32problem that I'm seen today and so i can

1:10:35just see I visions of this being like a

1:10:38less extreme version of of me saying

1:10:40well I don't like working on the iPad

1:10:42because i feel like it constrains me and

1:10:45I feel like the mac is free because that

1:10:46is how i feel and i think that this

1:10:48hypothetical new arm Mac would be a lot

1:10:52of the same in that regard if perhaps a

1:10:54little bit less of it a lot of what we

1:10:57what we would want as developers could

1:10:59be accomplished through VMS true you

1:11:02know it is

1:11:03if it was still possible to have virtual

1:11:05machines running on this in some form a

1:11:07lot of this could be solved by container

1:11:09and my virtual machines of like you know

1:11:12right like LG's that i just lost a day

1:11:15this week on monday i spent a whole day

1:11:17finally fixing my local apache and PHP

1:11:21mysql installations between my my imac

1:11:25and my laptop both of which my laptop

1:11:27never had a working one because i did a

1:11:29clean install when I got it I just never

1:11:31finished setting it up and fixing

1:11:33homebrew and fixing PHP and fixing the

1:11:35built-in Apache to use the right version

1:11:37of PHP and all this crap and the tried

1:11:40ma'am and i didn't i didn't like it so I

1:11:42stopped trying map and like filling with

1:11:45all this stuff that's like all over the

1:11:46file system all the stuff that homegroup

1:11:48puts and different other package

1:11:50managers do it at home brew complaint

1:11:52another package managers exists and it's

1:11:54like dealing with all this crap all over

1:11:56the file system that gets upgraded when

1:11:57the system is upgraded that I'm trying

1:11:59to put my own stuff into an edit the

1:12:00config files and everything else like I

1:12:03during a lot of that I'm like you know

1:12:04why don't you install VirtualBox and

1:12:07just make a Linux VM had just run the

1:12:10stuff in there and be fine

1:12:12try docker you've got a modern enough

1:12:14Matthew can run docker i know i should

1:12:16know about docker I know nothing about

1:12:18dr. I know you I know these the general

1:12:21high-level concept of what it is I've

1:12:23never seen it never use it no idea what

1:12:24have our how it works but try to dry

1:12:27before you go the the full vm route and

1:12:29in the meantime you can follow

1:12:30everything everything from source

1:12:31installing user local like I do well and

1:12:34I did I did actually I eventually moved

1:12:36to the the full homebrew setup took me

1:12:40awhile to realize at home brew install

1:12:41its own version of apache but but but

1:12:43but it did finally do that but it just

1:12:46it was so much messing around so much

1:12:48crap i know that that future updates

1:12:50will probably break in and never has

1:12:52never touched system files you can only

1:12:55messing user local do not touch anything

1:12:57else pretend it doesn't exist

1:12:59yeah and I did eventually move the

1:13:00system but my point is that is not that

1:13:03different from what if on this on this

1:13:05hypothetical you know next-generation

1:13:08mac OS lockdown mode which would be the

1:13:10only month will what what is OS

1:13:13developer mode existed which i think i

1:13:15do think that

1:13:17developer mode needs to exist where you

1:13:19can just compile stuff or you can run

1:13:21open source software that is compiled

1:13:23from sort through package managers or

1:13:24whatever else something you can open

1:13:26source stuff you can build yourself and

1:13:27just run it and somehow there needs to

1:13:30be a way to you know to to distribute

1:13:33software out of the app store with

1:13:34developer ID gatekeeper whatever that's

1:13:36so given those two exceptions it

1:13:39supposed developer mode is a rooted in

1:13:41such a way that you know you you

1:13:43basically get your own version of your

1:13:44local in this little virtualized

1:13:46environment within your home directory

1:13:47that's not that different we have now

1:13:49and that's totally fine

1:13:51we could totally work with that it would

1:13:52be fine as long as there's still a way

1:13:55to have a terminal and a way to have to

1:13:57compile software you get from other

1:13:59places all these workflows don't break

1:14:01just the file paths my change slightly

1:14:04that's it that could be done well like

1:14:06to so that you don't feel constrained

1:14:09Casey like that you don't feel like

1:14:11you're suddenly traffic is it would just

1:14:12be a matter of commands in the sheet and

1:14:13flipping switches like I back to normal

1:14:15but really that the the ultimate cure

1:14:17for this is the same thing that solve

1:14:20the exact same situation in the change

1:14:21from classic mac OS to OS 10 which was a

1:14:24big you know increase in simplicity and

1:14:27downgrade and customizability with the

1:14:29elimination of whole categories of

1:14:31interfaces and ways of working and lots

1:14:35of third-party things being replaced by

1:14:361st party things that could not be

1:14:38enhanced or replaced in a supportive

1:14:41manner

1:14:42the solution is guess what there is no

1:14:45more classic Michael is sewn it like

1:14:47this that was the solution is like well

1:14:49did you

1:14:49you know go use windows or linux or this

1:14:52is the future of the mac like I don't

1:14:53envision the mac described in this is a

1:14:57comment here existing alongside the

1:14:59other max for any appreciable amount of

1:15:01time there would be a transition and

1:15:03you're on board or you're not and you

1:15:05know like take it like that's exactly

1:15:07how it would have to work and especially

1:15:08if they go there by immigrants but again

1:15:10if you could blinken and you know open

1:15:12your eyes and this thing was here they

1:15:13wouldn't keep them both around the whole

1:15:15thing would go away so that would

1:15:16basically solve the problem for you and

1:15:17hopefully I said you wouldn't feel

1:15:18constrained maybe to like to cook we

1:15:20keep some of the old thing for 10 more

1:15:21years after yeah well you know the

1:15:24software that little better but they do

1:15:25have great but like yeah he that you

1:15:28wouldn't in the same way I

1:15:30you know initially a lot of classic mac

1:15:31users felt constrained always 10 because

1:15:33it was very young and slow and was

1:15:35missing a lot of things were simpler and

1:15:36in some respects i still feel

1:15:38constrained by some of the interface

1:15:40things in OS 10 but you get used to it

1:15:42eventually becomes the new normal and

1:15:44you accept that it comes with many other

1:15:46benefits so I would imagine that this

1:15:48type of mac would be powerful to you if

1:15:51not immediately then in short order as

1:15:53again as long as they didn't screw up

1:15:55because like one of the ways that Apple

1:15:56especially today's Apple could massively

1:15:58screws up is by going too far and

1:16:01cutting off all those other avenues

1:16:02because if the mac can't support that

1:16:05type of user like why bother having the

1:16:07mac now I'm saying that's the only

1:16:08reason for the max existence but it's

1:16:11like then what are you even doing you're

1:16:12just you're squeezing the mac from both

1:16:14sides until it's basically like a really

1:16:17weird iOS position the IRS would still

1:16:19be advancing so it's like it's really

1:16:20weird iOS version that can't do the

1:16:22things that used to do but isn't as

1:16:24simple as iOS and with all the resources

1:16:26into morphing the mac into this thing

1:16:28and it's like what's the point that

1:16:30point you you have to concede that back

1:16:32and had the right approach and that

1:16:33you've just been wasting your time this

1:16:34duel a strategy as you shave one of your

1:16:37oasis from both sides until all that's

1:16:39left is a little skinny spindle just

1:16:40topples over when and if they did this

1:16:43again like I said earlier like that you

1:16:46know this we haven't had a major OS

1:16:47tradition in awhile from Apple not since

1:16:49you know tonight or whatever it was

1:16:51John I'm sure has some idea when that

1:16:52was huh 2001 was 10.1 there you know

1:16:56they have some I guess yeah so you know

1:16:59we have a tradition says that in the

1:17:01windows world they have them a little

1:17:03more often but this those come that

1:17:05often and when you have a major OS

1:17:08transition like that one of the one of

1:17:10the luxuries of this it is painful no

1:17:13question it's painful it it's time

1:17:15consuming for a while there's like

1:17:17there's a transition period that that

1:17:18just sucks for everybody

1:17:20however it is an opportunity to

1:17:23modernize app frameworks to add new

1:17:26capabilities to do things it's basically

1:17:30take the opportunity that that you have

1:17:33that your kind of forcing at makers to

1:17:35do something new to do like a major

1:17:37update or to order to even do a rewrite

1:17:40to take the opportunity to make it

1:17:43better for everybody so for instance

1:17:44some of the things they could do with

1:17:46the mac and if they did this and if they

1:17:48presumably broke a lot of old apps the

1:17:51fight they could finally make like a

1:17:52more unified UI framework for one like

1:17:55make UI kit for the mac and i don't mean

1:17:58make everything look like navigation

1:17:59controllers and make it all function the

1:18:01same way in the UI but you know this

1:18:03like some of the simple low hanging

1:18:04fruit like like unify the way like table

1:18:06views of your load their data and making

1:18:10sure we don't have NS color and you I

1:18:11call her anymore and stuff like that

1:18:13like there's a lot of they could do to

1:18:14unify those two frameworks they could do

1:18:16things like as i mentioned previously

1:18:18cellular max because they could

1:18:21implement better control over networking

1:18:23and and do all this to like it would be

1:18:26given the opportunity to it it would

1:18:30force us to to live for a while with

1:18:32incompatible software with all we can't

1:18:35do this in the US yet because this

1:18:37hasn't updated or whatever we have to

1:18:38drag along Microsoft and Adobe or

1:18:40whatever else but then we got there it

1:18:42could be so much better because at

1:18:45makers have been forced to update right

1:18:46now the mac software ecosystem is is you

1:18:49know there are some bright spots but a

1:18:51lot of its just a graveyard because most

1:18:54people who make mac apps it's it's a low

1:18:56priority for them because they can keep

1:18:58making the same old app over and over

1:19:00again it's fine and they can focus their

1:19:01efforts on iOS and stuff if the mac

1:19:03changes

1:19:05yes some of them we will some of them we

1:19:06lost but the ones that want to stay in

1:19:09the mac will have to put effort into it

1:19:10and that will make their ass better that

1:19:12will make it better for all of us like

1:19:13it there there would be a substantial

1:19:16silver lining

1:19:17not to mention all the all the benefits

1:19:19of the OS itself as a set of things like

1:19:21the better security better sandboxing of

1:19:23the apps like not having a crap call

1:19:25over the system

1:19:26this could be really good in a number of

1:19:29ways if something like this were to

1:19:31happen it would definitely be painful

1:19:34and some stuff that you could do now in

1:19:36mac OS you'd never be able to do on this

1:19:38but look at this to talk about together

1:19:42look at how many people do everything

1:19:45they need to do on phones and I'm and

1:19:47iPads this can do more than that

1:19:50everyone who says like they can't do

1:19:52stuff on iOS

1:19:54sometimes it's because of the capability

1:19:56to iOS just never able to get a bit of a

1:19:58security model but sometimes it's just

1:20:00because it doesn't have a very good

1:20:01multitasking model or a very good file

1:20:02system model or very you know that

1:20:04things that the bed this would actually

1:20:05have so I think it would be a painful

1:20:10transition to go to something like this

1:20:11but it wouldn't be impossible we would

1:20:14all grumble we all complain but then we

1:20:16get on board a few things would be

1:20:19possible anymore forever and we deal and

1:20:21we deal with that we'd find new

1:20:22solutions like if I couldn't use audio

1:20:25hijack anymore to record this phone call

1:20:27from skype then we'd probably either

1:20:29stop using skype or we will you know we

1:20:32could switch to one of those like

1:20:33web-based podcast recording things

1:20:34already like five of those and there's

1:20:36only gonna be more about time this thing

1:20:37ever exists so like it like there's

1:20:40there's always work around there's

1:20:41always things like time was time would

1:20:43solve any pain that would be there so i

1:20:45think even though this is probably all

1:20:48wrong and based on this one weird post

1:20:51on slashdot that's probably BS this kind

1:20:54of sounds cool and if it happened

1:20:56assuming had those the did those two

1:20:58exceptions developer mode and developer

1:21:00ID distribution I think it'd be really

1:21:02nice to throw cold water and this we

1:21:05have to bring back to our old refrain

1:21:06anytime we discussed anything radical

1:21:08happening to the mac is like yeah but

1:21:10that would cost a lot of money and take

1:21:11a lot of time and resources and does

1:21:13Apple want to put that much money into

1:21:14its legacy platform or are you want to

1:21:17describe the mac because sales volume

1:21:19wise you can justify almost any

1:21:21investment in iOS can you justify that

1:21:24same and the ipad is along for the ride

1:21:26because even though the ipads volume is

1:21:28similar to the mac guess what it's got

1:21:30the same as the phone so congratulations

1:21:32you get a lot of development stuff

1:21:33quorum court for free but this would be

1:21:35a hell of an investment like it would be

1:21:36on the scale of the classic colors 10

1:21:38transaction release close maybe not that

1:21:40big but it would be closed and it would

1:21:42be the biggest investment in the mac

1:21:44software wise in many many many years

1:21:46and so I think it could you know i'm not

1:21:50saying it couldn't be that the right

1:21:51people pitch it it could be sold within

1:21:54the company but it would be a departure

1:21:55from the historic investment mac which

1:21:59has been good and it's you know it

1:22:00hasn't been as high since the transition

1:22:02from always as you know as is

1:22:03appropriate or even the transition for

1:22:05cpu architecture

1:22:06this would be an architecture transition

1:22:08and a nice transition that is the second

1:22:11biggest one that Apple has ever done and

1:22:14you know where we're all on board for it

1:22:16and would be ready for but i'm not

1:22:17entirely sure that Apple is ready to put

1:22:21that money into the mac which now that

1:22:23is the that is the most dubious thing

1:22:25about this random / comp again I got it

1:22:28I wouldn't characterize it as novel

1:22:30understand what characterizes it as it

1:22:32really reiteration of the the

1:22:35prototypical idea of a mac merge with

1:22:37iOS resurfacing now in a new context a

1:22:40new context is the new apple and the new

1:22:43state of Intel vs arm and the new sales

1:22:47figures for ipad and almost new people

1:22:50being older and wiser and having seen

1:22:51more than tech world reconsidering the

1:22:53same thing

1:22:54well in that case I will put it in terms

1:22:56they will understand you can sell ipad

1:22:58hardware for $1,500 already do

1:23:02that's not including all the cases and

1:23:06that's our end thanks to our three

1:23:08sponsors this week betterment

1:23:09Squarespace and set appt and we will see

1:23:11you next week so I've got harder for

1:23:13macbook pro prices 2600 there you go now

1:23:20the show is over they didn't even mean

1:23:23to be in because it was accidental

1:23:27it was accidental Jonathan

1:23:31acer Marco in kc would

1:23:35because it was accidental was accidental

1:23:39and you can find show know today cp/m

1:23:44and it for twitter follow them

1:23:50[Music]

1:23:51yes eyl ISS so that's Casey list and a

1:23:56co-pay rm20 Marco Arment are see you at

1:24:05Syracuse

1:24:13what

1:24:17so Casey I hear you're having some car

1:24:22trouble

1:24:23yes indeed so I brought my car in to get

1:24:28the oil changed as I don't care that you

1:24:31think that's preposterous don't care I

1:24:33don't the time I why was that

1:24:35preposterous is because you're talking

1:24:37to also the audience was nothing the

1:24:39audience I'm hopefully preventing your

1:24:41he's talking about not changing your own

1:24:43oil

1:24:43oh you ok you can set to tweet to

1:24:46absolutely nothing about how angry you

1:24:47are that I'm not changing my own oil

1:24:49even people who change their own oil I

1:24:51feel like now realize that they are

1:24:53outliers probably so I had a coupon i

1:24:57was very excited and coupon so my BMW

1:24:59oil change is supposed to be ninety

1:25:01dollars which I understand this expense

1:25:03when you're getting into the dealership

1:25:04now it's time for me to school gym

1:25:06yeah that was going to the dealership

1:25:08now you're gonna hear from them

1:25:09yep it's so okay i understand i am not

1:25:13innocent in and I haven't I have made

1:25:16mistakes mistakes have been made

1:25:17yeah i do the same thing well you don't

1:25:20get your oil changed anymore but I did

1:25:22if you're going to the dealership anyway

1:25:24ok but if you're going to the dealership

1:25:26to get your oil changed no don't do

1:25:28bottle I don't trust like a jiffy lube

1:25:31or anything like that no GC I guess you

1:25:34don't have a Ferrari we have to go to

1:25:35this special little Italian person with

1:25:37a wire synthetic it doesn't matter the

1:25:39point noted for the record I think it

1:25:41might be covered when you have a lease

1:25:43i'm not sure but just for the record

1:25:44there and it's pretty then yes yes by

1:25:47all means but I believe they are and it

1:25:49was free for me when I first on the

1:25:50carcass told some of the maintenance

1:25:52program yeah like five years right side

1:25:54forget it was for I think it doesn't

1:25:56really matter but anyway so I had my $90

1:25:59coupon am all excited with myself

1:26:01well I had the wherewithal to ask for

1:26:03loner which I was very glad for will see

1:26:05why in a moment but here's my tiny doll

1:26:07coupon i should expect to see you later

1:26:09today I probably didn't even need to

1:26:11bother getting a loaner i'm going to

1:26:13drive it the handful of miles to work

1:26:14and then probably immediately later the

1:26:17you know handful miles back and that'll

1:26:18be that

1:26:19I get a call as i'm out to lunch and

1:26:22they say and so many words

1:26:24oh ye things relating to the drivetrain

1:26:28in the front

1:26:29I have an all-wheel-drive BMW before you

1:26:30get

1:26:31angry I things related to the drivetrain

1:26:33the front like tie rods and bushings and

1:26:35things of that nature and the adjustment

1:26:38screw that you use in order to do an

1:26:40alignment has seized things are breaking

1:26:42that will be a thousand dollars please

1:26:44when you'll get your car back tomorrow

1:26:45because we don't have all the parts fine

1:26:48so in and of itself ok fine the car has

1:26:51almost 70,000 miles on it if i remember

1:26:53correctly it is not unreasonable that

1:26:57things would be going wrong but in the

1:27:00last see Rand change i had a five or six

1:27:06thousand dollar repair the van Gogh

1:27:07system i had a thousand-dollar a water

1:27:12pump issue that was almost last month it

1:27:15was just barely in december and now I

1:27:17have this thousand-dollar issue and I

1:27:19think this is the universe giving me a

1:27:21sign that this car is not long for this

1:27:23world so I'm getting some pressure from

1:27:26erin and i think it's completely

1:27:28justified to unload the thing because

1:27:30it's just me I can't keep the damn thing

1:27:31on the road and I at first I was

1:27:34resisting but now I'm to the point that

1:27:36I'm like screw it this thing is not

1:27:38worth my time anymore i want to get rid

1:27:40of it now on paper the right answer is

1:27:43get a brand-new 3-series maybe an m3 if

1:27:45I want to spend too much money

1:27:47maintenance will be covered at least in

1:27:48the beginning it will have a nice big

1:27:50fat warranty

1:27:51problem solved except I feel like I've

1:27:53been burned by BMW i think new ones are

1:27:56as I think we talked about recently new

1:27:58ones are just unaffordable so and then

1:28:02that becomes okay well define get a

1:28:04pre-owned one well I just did that and

1:28:05yes this one that this hypothetical new

1:28:07pre-owned one would be with a with the

1:28:10cpo warranty which goes to like a

1:28:12hundred thousand miles and yes that's

1:28:13possible but even if i'm not paying

1:28:16out-of-pocket constantly for my car to

1:28:18be in the shop

1:28:18my car stalled the damn shop all the

1:28:20time and in and I feel like the moment

1:28:23to BWW gets past like least time things

1:28:28start falling apart and I have been

1:28:29friends have had that have had similar

1:28:31experiences i just want to be bothered

1:28:33by it so i have many options in front of

1:28:37me if you recall my requirements which

1:28:41are somewhat loose our I don't want

1:28:43front-wheel drive

1:28:44I wanted to get to 60 in under six

1:28:46seconds I don't care that that's not

1:28:49necessary on regular roads that's what i

1:28:51want i want three pedals and that's

1:28:55mostly it so what are my options

1:28:59I'm only thinking about new right now

1:29:02and then i'm going to start trying to

1:29:04Rack my brain for used because i'm not

1:29:06opposed to going used but looking at it

1:29:10I think every single one of my options

1:29:14has problems

1:29:16a friend of mine actually just written

1:29:18in cadillac ats great call but the

1:29:21infotainment is from everything I've

1:29:22ever understood unusable just utterly

1:29:25unusable and I don't know if it has

1:29:28carplay I'd have to check that out so

1:29:30that is a potential if I'm also hideous

1:29:35yeah it's too early to be three we've

1:29:37seen in saree great car

1:29:39don't let that fairly hideous i'm not

1:29:40arguing fairly hideous

1:29:42ok so let's just lie I it sounds like

1:29:44the the brain trust has eliminated that

1:29:45so if i'm going to have wrong wheel

1:29:48drive focus st the problem with that

1:29:51other than it being a fortune of itself

1:29:53is fine but it's front-wheel drive which

1:29:56I don't particularly care for and then

1:29:59the RS is also is the RS whatever the

1:30:02super Pavarotti one is that one is just

1:30:05to 18 year old for me i'm turning 35

1:30:08next month just no way the st is a

1:30:10reasonable compromise but wrong wheel

1:30:12drive if i'm going to go back to

1:30:14deutschland i have the volkswagen GTI

1:30:16the Golf R which is the thing that I

1:30:18think I'm most interested in the a4 and

1:30:20the s3 which is basically a go far but

1:30:22in today and former from that mistake

1:30:23that come on what which what what he

1:30:27wasn't a series of little euro

1:30:29hatchbacks and you lump the a4 on the s3

1:30:31and then like no it's the same thing now

1:30:33therefore is wildly different the s3 i

1:30:35thought was basically a drivetrain of

1:30:37the Golf R I am I am onday you under the

1:30:39under the covers sure but it's a whole

1:30:41like from the outside it's 2 difference

1:30:43between driving around in a rabbit

1:30:44driving around got a car you're dating

1:30:47yourself well and he doesn't mean i

1:30:50could rule out all fours right now for

1:30:52you because 84 you can go it's a little

1:30:55boring but i think they should try

1:30:56before he decides to boring

1:30:57it's nice-looking it has the features he

1:30:59wants is reasonably nice inside and out

1:31:01the main slam against it is that it's

1:31:03more boring than the BMW's but i think

1:31:05we should test drive is the a4 even

1:31:07available in stick

1:31:09yes it is okay and I thought it was

1:31:11anyway I don't know it is alright so the

1:31:14a4 is basically a 3-series that's

1:31:18slightly worse like I depends on what

1:31:21you want if you want if you want less if

1:31:23you want it smoother kind of nicer even

1:31:26keel explicates if you want a crappier

1:31:29interior and higher prices

1:31:31yeah you know i deserted nice they look

1:31:33nice don't feel nice i am not so sure I

1:31:37agree with you there

1:31:38also i drive is way better than their

1:31:39window system i drive is lightyears

1:31:42better than mi mi at least as of about a

1:31:45year ago I didn't know there's

1:31:46definitely a more updated whatever its

1:31:48toll on the old one

1:31:49yes yeah I don't know either i thought

1:31:51it was it had the new hotness one which

1:31:53i have yet to try but they but the a4

1:31:57supports carplay I don't think it's

1:31:59wireless carplay but it's carplay the s3

1:32:05is basically a call far although body-

1:32:08saying it might be dsg only which might

1:32:10eliminated from contention then the Gulf

1:32:13are obviously all of these are appealing

1:32:16because they are not front-wheel drive

1:32:17but that's going back to Germany and I

1:32:22can't tell if this is a German car

1:32:24problem or if it's a BMW problem it so

1:32:27it's it's a expensive car problems every

1:32:29car around 60,000 miles especially if

1:32:32you live in the northeast which you

1:32:33don't really but if you did like around

1:32:3560 or 70,000 crap starts falling apart

1:32:38and breaking or whatever the problem is

1:32:39that crap falls apart brakes on a BMW

1:32:41cause a billion dollars to fix that's

1:32:43that's where your problems like any car

1:32:44you keep for that number of miles you're

1:32:46going to add like if you have a car

1:32:48400,000 ultimately replace the water

1:32:49pump is not a surprise because nothing

1:32:51that happens right that's part of the

1:32:53water pump cost you fifteen hundred

1:32:54bucks then you're you know you're

1:32:57driving BMW right that's the thing is

1:32:59that in and of itself any one of these

1:33:00repairs fine whatever well maybe not the

1:33:02vanos exploding but generally and I got

1:33:05the engine stuff I feel like you got a

1:33:07Honda would still be fine you

1:33:08not need to put that much money into the

1:33:11india the entire body would rust off the

1:33:13car before the engine when you work in a

1:33:15Honda so yeah so I could go back to

1:33:18Germany go far a for s3 apparently is

1:33:23definitely dsg only from what I'm being

1:33:26told so that's eliminated from

1:33:28contention

1:33:29it's also really overpriced for what

1:33:30you're buying that's probably true i

1:33:32forgot to mention the GTI i think i

1:33:35mentioned the GTI I've heard the

1:33:36performance pack is phenomenal the GTI

1:33:39performance pack however that is also

1:33:40wrong wheel drive so so far still in

1:33:44contention focus st wrong wheel drive

1:33:47GTI performance pack wrong wheel drive

1:33:49our German a for German a little bit

1:33:52boring and then now i get into like the

1:33:55real Slim Pickens if I'm willing to go

1:33:57extremely slowly i could get an accord

1:34:00which I cannot I cannot option the way I

1:34:02want or a mazda 6 which I cannot option

1:34:04the way I want and then if I'm willing

1:34:06to live inside of my car because I will

1:34:09be divorced and never get to see my wife

1:34:11or child again I could get a Tesla so no

1:34:14so here here's one of the one of the big

1:34:16questions here is do you want to be a

1:34:18car that can comfortably hold your kid

1:34:20sitting here now yes that's probably

1:34:23ruining everything but yeah we're gonna

1:34:26go with us on this one because then your

1:34:27only options on this list that can go

1:34:30fast on the model s that's it like the

1:34:32center of the a4 goes pretty fast

1:34:35it's it's about the same speed as my

1:34:37cards a little slower but not too much

1:34:38load onto the Endor if already galant

1:34:41vr4 I think you need to go to dealer and

1:34:44Casey needs to go to a dealer and for

1:34:46now you're not buying just going there

1:34:48to look at it maybe take a test-drive

1:34:49poke around you're not even thinking of

1:34:51buying just check it out because I feel

1:34:53like you're the Marcos aunty aunty

1:34:55biases is hot out he's my right-hand

1:34:57warranted out is great but being buddies

1:34:59better

1:34:59it's simple as that like out he makes

1:35:00great collar current ones not the

1:35:02current 3 series with a weirdo electric

1:35:04steering and the ugly outsides and the

1:35:06bazillion dollars for the options

1:35:08well but I mean talk about Brazilian I

1:35:09was options out he is also the same way

1:35:11about the option pricing and the repair

1:35:13losses and everything else like that

1:35:14basically in in most of the downsides

1:35:17they're the same or roughly the same and

1:35:20and I think BMWs upsides are better

1:35:22basically I think out these are it get

1:35:24there nice cars and some of them are

1:35:26really nice cars but the interior I've

1:35:29always thought felt noticeably cheaper

1:35:31than w's I the media system is is a

1:35:35major step backwards

1:35:36I agree yeah and and they actually kind

1:35:41of surprised they saw first because i

1:35:42think most of the cars they don't even

1:35:44offered as an option anymore although to

1:35:45be fair but he's not that different in

1:35:46that regard so yeah you can get you can

1:35:49get in a for premium plus with all-wheel

1:35:53drive and actually the only available

1:35:56transmission is the six-speed it does

1:35:59have carpet by the way I just flipping

1:36:00through their website they got a big

1:36:01screen shot again it's not wireless but

1:36:04data is it is carplay nevertheless so

1:36:07that would be so if we were on the a4

1:36:09which one the premium plus just a plain

1:36:11all day for I'm just walking through the

1:36:13things with extreme front-wheel drive or

1:36:15all-wheel drive now all-wheel-drive okay

1:36:17to have that a stick

1:36:18yeah that's what I think it's easily my

1:36:21car I mean it's well it's a

1:36:22four-cylinder turbo but otherwise it's

1:36:24basically my card six-speed all-wheel

1:36:26drive etc I wasn't aware they were still

1:36:27making novel drive with stick that's

1:36:29pretty well in i think this is new I

1:36:31think they just added the manual

1:36:34transmission option like this model year

1:36:35even though i think the Refresh happened

1:36:37months and months ago maybe that's not

1:36:39the thing about dude about the time to

1:36:41get ready required it's not so much the

1:36:43point of your car is falling apart is

1:36:44that the longer you wait the less chance

1:36:45you have to get any car with a stick a

1:36:47temperature but I mean you aren't you

1:36:50you would have some morning when that

1:36:51was going to happen anyway that is in in

1:36:54broad strokes that is true so i would

1:36:56say for you I'm telling you as a friend

1:36:59Casey I'm just find the damn test this

1:37:02is this

1:37:02no no I'm telling you as a friend this

1:37:04is my intervention here i would rather

1:37:07you buy an overpriced German hatchback

1:37:10then the whole night I had listened I

1:37:13would rather you buy it now price German

1:37:14hatchback then to have you compromise on

1:37:18what's really important to you and to

1:37:20have you get a quarter mazda well that's

1:37:22the thing is like I I the accord is a

1:37:24nice but what about versus the a41 to

1:37:27just eliminate that one I can understand

1:37:29what you're saying like I'd rather have

1:37:30you get a sporty hatchback that boring

1:37:31stand fine right

1:37:33while have you got a sporty hatchback

1:37:34than a sporty sedan

1:37:35like me for no I the a forest is fine

1:37:39you know it you you know you've driven

1:37:41one before kc you know you know what

1:37:43they are yes but I haven't driven one of

1:37:45the new ones that was the last 1i drove

1:37:47was the pre refresh version and my

1:37:49understanding is a lot changed with this

1:37:53refresh president then it's worth it's

1:37:55definitely worth seeing because as we

1:37:56know BMW has had some some shortcomings

1:37:59with the new 3-series i completely agree

1:38:01with you guys a for absolutely

1:38:03absolutely worth a look

1:38:04I think the Gulf are would probably be a

1:38:07more exciting car I and certainly i'm

1:38:10pretty sure to be considerably quicker

1:38:12but the a4 I think would be sufficient

1:38:14in every metric that I can think to

1:38:18throw at it also expensive to repair and

1:38:20maintained by the way

1:38:21well and you're still shopping and

1:38:23german luxury sedans and so but you but

1:38:25if you get especially if you got it so

1:38:26here's having a question would you

1:38:28consider either new financing or leasing

1:38:31which would then take care of the

1:38:32maintenance issue for the most part of

1:38:34it entirely

1:38:35yeah see I mean financing whatever

1:38:37that's the the oven whatever but it do

1:38:40it just leaves i hope i don't want to

1:38:41lease a car like I don't think places of

1:38:44you can get a model 3 if you're lucky

1:38:46well that's true so the thing with

1:38:48leasing is is that in a perfect world

1:38:51what I want is the situation we have a

1:38:54parent's car errands car has been in the

1:38:56shop for repairs fewer times in the 10

1:38:59years we've owned it well

1:39:01nine-and-a-half at this point then my

1:39:02car has in the last 10 months and what

1:39:05is it a boring reliable japanese koto

1:39:07boring reliable japanese place boring

1:39:09slow and reliable that you don't want

1:39:11that that would crush your soul that but

1:39:13I bought something but it will crush my

1:39:15soul but i want something that will last

1:39:16more than 10 freaking minutes you have

1:39:18it's called Aaron's car that's called

1:39:21all my honda accords yes no look if you

1:39:24want if you want to have a board

1:39:26reliable car there's lots of great

1:39:28options

1:39:29pretty much everything hot from honda

1:39:30toyota is lots of good odds are born as

1:39:33bar comas exciting is it going to be

1:39:35given a horsepower em right i'm not

1:39:37saying this is this is a powerful engine

1:39:39in it but it is ok but the thinking

1:39:42man's BMW racecar driver not know

1:39:47ok but anyway test drive one of those

1:39:49anyway you won't be able to find a stick

1:39:51to test drive but you should well I

1:39:52don't know maybe next time you visit you

1:39:54can test drive mine and see what it's

1:39:55like

1:39:56I mean I the thought has crossed my mind

1:39:58that maybe it is worth testing it

1:39:59because my god it's just it's bananas

1:40:02that that all I I mean I ok I understand

1:40:05that what I'm about to say is a bit

1:40:06preposterous but all i want is a

1:40:09six-speed not front-wheel-drive car with

1:40:13four doors that gets to 60 in less than

1:40:17six seconds that will last for more than

1:40:1960,000 miles is that so much to ask how

1:40:22fast as they for

1:40:24I think five and a half ish something

1:40:26like that it's actually much quicker

1:40:27than one would think i'm even go to the

1:40:29s4 if you want more out of it but i

1:40:31wanted to write I wouldn't do I

1:40:33certainly wouldn't be doing that knew

1:40:34for sure

1:40:35so here's the thing look I mean this is

1:40:37one of those like you know project

1:40:38management triangle situations like it

1:40:40is it for what you want

1:40:42there's basically you have to either

1:40:44pick like fast but crappy or like you

1:40:49know slow but nice or use an expensive

1:40:53to maintain like he you have to pick

1:40:55apart these things or you raise the

1:40:58budget and you get divorced I mean it

1:41:00one of those like one of these things

1:41:03has to budge for you you have to be

1:41:05willing to tolerate something that you

1:41:07don't want to tolerate right now so when

1:41:10that is the shame of driving an Audi or

1:41:13its weather is shameful whether it's

1:41:16spending more than you wanted to spend

1:41:17or whether it's having more high price

1:41:20maintenance down the road or giving up

1:41:22your entire soul and and driving an

1:41:24accord and I say this is somebody who

1:41:26fought in the court at one time and

1:41:28enjoy it for a couple years opportunity

1:41:30cost to think about how much of what you

1:41:32could buy with the money you say buying

1:41:33the accord and how much happier that

1:41:34would make you is there anything that

1:41:36would make Casey happier than a fast car

1:41:37John yeah that's the place I understand

1:41:41what you're driving at but this is casey

1:41:43were talking about my college education

1:41:44for your children just saying this is

1:41:47not going to make or break declan's

1:41:48college education from students right so

1:41:50therefore I i think basically you have

1:41:53you have a tough decision to make

1:41:55John push you towards the accord John

1:41:58percent of the audi understand he should

1:42:00the court isn't as bad as you make it

1:42:02out to be but nobody wants something

1:42:04faster so the quarters in it so tragic I

1:42:06mean basically since none of the three

1:42:09of us have driven the current generation

1:42:10apparently the newest a4a yeah I guess I

1:42:14come around I think you should try that

1:42:15because i do find the the f generation

1:42:19of bmw's the f30 generation of people

1:42:21used to be pretty underwhelming a lot of

1:42:23ways and as you mentioned quite

1:42:26expensive for you get that being said so

1:42:28is the audi however think it's really

1:42:31worth trying but let's let's go build

1:42:33one as well we can keep talking about

1:42:35let's build an ally i started down that

1:42:36path and I guess I just wasn't there is

1:42:38currently no s4 is it is like between

1:42:41update update generations like just a

1:42:43day for I think that's correct

1:42:45what color would i get me turn off locks

1:42:47wine myself I I don't know what color

1:42:50you would get me i'll be a primary

1:42:52teacher III don't know how to even

1:42:54consider picking a color for you you've

1:42:56got to get with the program it's it's

1:42:58the year of the red car so you gotta do

1:43:00what you gotta do right now is it ok we

1:43:02can go read I tomorrow right car I got a

1:43:04red car

1:43:05come on i'm not sure how this looks in

1:43:07red it looks ok but I and I wonder if I

1:43:09see what else

1:43:10howdy howdy historically makes a very

1:43:11good premium black that is a nice black

1:43:14actually I can't do a black car stop

1:43:16stop I can't do what I mean look at him

1:43:18like four different shades of white this

1:43:19literally they have let's see there's

1:43:22there's glacier white metallic there's

1:43:24Florence silver which is so light it's

1:43:25basically matt is basically white bears

1:43:27QB silver which is kind of champagne but

1:43:31almost white

1:43:31there's ibis white which is another

1:43:33white and there's monsoon gray which is

1:43:35a pretty like Ray almost white

1:43:37so this is this maybe this actually is

1:43:38your brand maybe maybe all these years

1:43:40talking about BMW that we have been

1:43:42wrong all this time and you actually

1:43:44wanted a brand that has five different

1:43:45shades of white on every every new car

1:43:47to choose from the 19-inch wheels

1:43:50because i'm an idiot i gottayou gotta

1:43:52pick the sport plus package go with 18

1:43:54is the 19 that I 890 don't look that

1:43:56much better than 18 that they ride with

1:43:58veteran 18 you're such an old man

1:44:00no seriously right well you was one inch

1:44:03difference you're not going to build the

1:44:04eyeball it's not like you just have to

1:44:06deal with the fact that your wheels are

1:44:07smaller than

1:44:08it'll be fine no listen this pussy and

1:44:12here's the thing that I like

1:44:12performance-wise you're roughly in like

1:44:15the 328 category of performance here but

1:44:18you're spending like 45 thousand dollars

1:44:20at least 47 875 that's the thing like it

1:44:23price-wise it's not eight I think it's

1:44:25pretty much the same as BMW like once

1:44:27you option it up the way you want it

1:44:28you're like they're both very expensive

1:44:32for what you're getting that doesn't

1:44:33mean you shouldn't do it as you know I i

1:44:35often argue on the other side of this

1:44:36but but i'm just pointing out that like

1:44:39this is not a great value compared to

1:44:40mw2 it's gonna be about the same like in

1:44:42the same ballpark doesn't get of course

1:44:44it doesn't mention 0-60 time I would it

1:44:46I could swear I 17 seconds in the temple

1:44:48days i was gonna say okay I thought it

1:44:50was around five and a half

1:44:51I mean like that's good but like is that

1:44:53is that like 50000 dollars in 2017 good

1:44:56mmm yeah see now i'm coming back to the

1:44:58Gulf are let's say where is that that

1:45:03you're too old for this car

1:45:04no not golf r yeah you're too old for

1:45:06this no bread love their friend brad has

1:45:09one in it it's like he's not too old for

1:45:11people were all the same age but he

1:45:13pulls it off of that we wouldn't pull it

1:45:14off

1:45:15you make a good point actually it is

1:45:18also a lot cooler than us that he was in

1:45:20California like it he can pull that off

1:45:23we can't let you know you if you want to

1:45:26go to door speaking of German you're

1:45:28kidding about you know the accord coupe

1:45:2920 16 5.6 seconds i do not want to go to

1:45:33door wasn't his fault i can state not

1:45:35working for you or my paramus volkswagen

1:45:37doesn't work try and come out I'll stop

1:45:40you

1:45:40what about the last item on this list

1:45:42which one is that the voice option yep

1:45:45yes it's not it's a hundred thousand

1:45:48dollars market by 2a fours about to use

1:45:51the model s you can get a useful model

1:45:53answer 50k that's where things get

1:45:56interesting him but inviting mkbhd I

1:45:58don't think you want to say when we talk

1:46:01about you know maintenance costs i would

1:46:03definitely not want to keep model s past

1:46:06the like big battery power train

1:46:08warranty but i think that's a hundred

1:46:09thousand miles so if you if you get one

1:46:12that's like right off least like you

1:46:13know thirty 30 ish k miles then it would

1:46:18probably need almost no work for the

1:46:21next

1:46:22five years until you really wanted to

1:46:24you know until then I'll start getting

1:46:26really high and then you would probably

1:46:27be a trade-in for something else at that

1:46:29point but because like you know that

1:46:32there are used model s there aren't a

1:46:34lot of them because three years ago they

1:46:36weren't selling that many so we know

1:46:38that there are many of them to choose

1:46:40from but they do come in they are

1:46:41usually like you have to call the dealer

1:46:44sometimes like they're not using baby is

1:46:45okay there you go with that I put in the

1:46:47chat but the problem is there's no 90 DS

1:46:51which is what you an underscore have and

1:46:53I think would be a perfectly reasonable

1:46:54well the nineties only existed for like

1:46:57a year and a half

1:46:58ok well there you go so you won't be

1:46:59looking at maybe it would be the 85

1:47:01d but it but all the DS all the dual

1:47:04model the dual motor ones have only just

1:47:05for I think about two years or so so the

1:47:09problem is i would want the dual motor

1:47:10for the acceleration not because I

1:47:12necessarily need to drive it is better i

1:47:14mean just in general too much but the

1:47:15new motor was a substantial improvement

1:47:17to the car so you do know that he 85 d

1:47:20the cheapest one they have is 80 grand

1:47:23so i could buy the P model that's the

1:47:25one that's new 430,000 on it that's just

1:47:27the first entry they have that has dual

1:47:30motor is the p85 d 4 80 grand with

1:47:3215,000 miles that's kind of awesome

1:47:35that's kind of Awesome actually thousand

1:47:38dollars so fast that is but that's the

1:47:41one that I test drove and I felt like I

1:47:43was gonna smack in the face and notices

1:47:44too fast you can just stand there was a

1:47:47p85 you're talking about

1:47:48I could almost buy in a 4 and a goal far

1:47:51for one of these

1:47:52yeah well I can't just 25 the cords or

1:47:55five and hordes III can't justify it i

1:47:58can i buy i'm not saying there's a7 ID

1:48:00on here for 67,000 you could drive a

1:48:02different corner and every day of the

1:48:04week

1:48:05haha oh my god that 70 is a hideous

1:48:12color though

1:48:13yes it isn't that weird like champagne

1:48:14it's like it's like you

1:48:17you spilled some champagne and into some

1:48:19snow slush I've seen more of the little

1:48:22mustache Model S's and they really grown

1:48:24on me and I like it better than the fish

1:48:26mouth what get out of here

1:48:28did they look less hideous to me now but

1:48:30they still look weird like I I'm sure

1:48:32out like by the time it's time for me to

1:48:33renew my lease

1:48:34I'll be okay with

1:48:35but it's still weird right now yes I

1:48:39mean it's worse than white obviously

1:48:40right but are in lighter colors but its

1:48:43turnaround having seen them to now when

1:48:45I see one of the old ones i know who i

1:48:47mean i never really liked the big ball

1:48:48gag but the defense knows depends on it

1:48:51looks pretty looks better in real life

1:48:53than doesn't photos

1:48:55oh man I disagree i've seen it a couple

1:48:57times it's not good

1:48:59the point is over this is a lot to

1:49:00choose from already and because the dual

1:49:02model versions have only existed for

1:49:05like a year and a half or two years

1:49:07there's probably about to be lots of

1:49:11them coming in like an inventory over

1:49:14the next year is certainly worth

1:49:17considering heavily I would I'm not

1:49:20gonna necessarily say that you should

1:49:21definitely do this but it solves a lot

1:49:24of problems it's not a lot of problems

1:49:27it is faster than everything else you're

1:49:28looking at first of all it is way lower

1:49:32maintenance it all in all likelihood

1:49:34especially like the newer you go like

1:49:36once you into the degeneration they

1:49:38ironed a lot of the early problems and

1:49:40one anyone you're still covered under

1:49:41the warranty you know that solves

1:49:43everything right there you pay something

1:49:44like I think it's like 500 bucks a year

1:49:46for like this giant big inspection they

1:49:49do every year but thats it thats that's

1:49:50your entire total maintenance costs

1:49:51until I need to spend twenty thousand

1:49:54dollars to replace all the batteries

1:49:55because that whatever 1 i'm

1:49:57hypothetically buying has between 15 and

1:49:5930 thousand miles on it

1:50:00I think it's like 10 years it's it's

1:50:02really far into it's basically you don't

1:50:04really keep the car that long is the

1:50:06answer to that question remember that

1:50:09I'm telling you that Aaron's car is nine

1:50:10and a half years old almost everything

1:50:13you're looking at you're all these pics

1:50:15you're not going to keep those pics for

1:50:1710 years like not none of them you're

1:50:20gonna hear you will you will own none of

1:50:21those when they are 10 years old over

1:50:23the record obviously one of those when

1:50:25there 8 years old how old how old is

1:50:26your car now like six or something not

1:50:28even that old right it was delivered to

1:50:32the original owner in December of 2010

1:50:34if i remember right yeah so it's six

1:50:36mhm and it's already so expensive to

1:50:38maintain that you're trying to get rid

1:50:39of it

1:50:40yeah but that's because I didn't buy a

1:50:41boring Japanese car that's the problem

1:50:43where and so that's my point is you're

1:50:45going to have high maintenance costs on

1:50:47all the cars in this list any car that

1:50:49you're going to

1:50:49be happy driving is not going to crush

1:50:51your soul and running with a person you

1:50:52are going to have high maintenance costs

1:50:54if you're if you want to keep it past

1:50:56year like you know six or seven

1:50:58basically is probably about as far as

1:50:59you can go without things getting a

1:51:01little too crazy

1:51:02you're gonna have to pay a lot for every

1:51:04car none of them are like particularly

1:51:07good investments or values

1:51:09no matter how you own a car you're gonna

1:51:11pay a lot because you want a fast car

1:51:15you're gonna pay more simple as that no

1:51:18matter how you slice it matter how you

1:51:19arrange it matter whether you buy new or

1:51:21used or lease whether you get bitten by

1:51:24like bad maintenance lucky with this one

1:51:26or whether you don't

1:51:27no matter what there is no way to

1:51:30constitute continuously drive fast cars

1:51:33without spending a ton of money on them

1:51:37this is this is a place you have chosen

1:51:39to spend your money you are an adult you

1:51:42are a good person you make a decent

1:51:44living but you can do that it's totally

1:51:47fine you don't indulge yourself in very

1:51:49many other things

1:51:50this is what you do it's okay this is

1:51:53the sign of the devil that Marco

1:51:54shoulder i do right

1:51:56you are the boy and we're not even with

1:51:58the shoulder doesn't have an angel on

1:51:59except yeah a little saying that some

1:52:01are constantly yeah you know but

1:52:03seriously like influence in the world

1:52:04like this is this matters a lot to you

1:52:08you get a lot of joy out of this you you

1:52:10take a lot of your life happiness from

1:52:12driving a nice fast car which actually

1:52:16maybe makes me wonder if my priorities

1:52:18are screwed up but i understand all say

1:52:20look everyone has something like this

1:52:21you know I'd be happy the years is

1:52:23something relatively harmless like this

1:52:25and not like drugs or you know I get

1:52:26like a lot of people devices are way

1:52:29worse than drugs drugs or mac pros on

1:52:35the plus side i don't i don't like

1:52:36expensive watches yet

1:52:38yeah we don't exactly at that anywhere

1:52:40says they could be so much worse than

1:52:41just like Marco exactly like it could be

1:52:44way worse

1:52:45so what I'm saying is really as he pens

1:52:47for crying out loud

1:52:49so basically like what I'm saying is

1:52:51don't don't feel guilty that you like

1:52:55nice fast cars and don't try to talk

1:52:57yourself down from what you really want

1:52:59is a car it's a long-term it

1:53:02interment choice you have to make this

1:53:04decision you have to be driving whatever

1:53:06you pick that's gonna be your car for

1:53:07the next at least few years and so it

1:53:10matters a lot

1:53:11you shouldn't talk yourself down out of

1:53:14like you know Casey self-doubt like let

1:53:19your friends encourage you at least this

1:53:21one don't listen to that one talking

1:53:22about something for in Japanese listen

1:53:24to this friend you're just driving a

1:53:26four

1:53:27that's what i told them i think that's

1:53:28fair i think test driving a four is

1:53:30reasonable i think if I were a betting

1:53:31man I'd probably get the Golf R because

1:53:34it's the it's the least amount of

1:53:35compromise all-in-all basically the only

1:53:38thing I'm compromising on is I don't

1:53:40really want to hatch back although there

1:53:42is some convenience that comes from

1:53:43that's a big thing but interior always

1:53:47gonna be worse than the a4 by a lot i

1:53:49don't think it'll be a lot now i have

1:53:51not sat in a mini golf in a long time

1:53:53but people that are friends of mine that

1:53:56that are also card nuts swear by

1:54:00Volkswagen interiors and by proxy audi

1:54:02as well I happen to like BMW interiors i

1:54:05happen to like the way BMW think because

1:54:08i think the same way and i'm trying to

1:54:11think that I'm trying to figure out what

1:54:12it like a specific thing I can cite I

1:54:15don't have any off the top of my head

1:54:16but I Drive has always made sense to me

1:54:19and stuff like that but but everything

1:54:22I've understood is that Volkswagen gets

1:54:24interiors right that you can debate the

1:54:25exterior is you can debate a lot of

1:54:27things that you can debate whether or

1:54:28not they make diesels that get more than

1:54:31four miles a gallon but they they do

1:54:34they do interiors right from what I'm

1:54:35told and I mean it i think the plan is

1:54:37if I'm really serious about this which i

1:54:39think i am the plan is first to get in a

1:54:42car because she's cheating needs one

1:54:44worse and she's next in line but after

1:54:47that test drive a golf are test driving

1:54:49a four that's probably the entire may I

1:54:51probably test-drive focus st just to see

1:54:54but it's probably one of these so may I

1:54:58suggest an alternative

1:54:59mhm so you are you are prepared to spend

1:55:03probably fifty thousand dollars on a

1:55:06nice day for potentially as potentially

1:55:10ok the a4 is pretty much what you have

1:55:14now it's moving you to the the newest

1:55:18version of what you're already driving

1:55:19with a different shape logo on the front

1:55:21it is it is not an upgraded is not

1:55:24probably a downgrade in any meaningful

1:55:26way slightly it's gonna be a little bit

1:55:28slower if that's where I end up ok so

1:55:29we're actually getting slower okay right

1:55:31okay you're losing a couple cylinders

1:55:32etc okay that's about 50 thousand

1:55:36dollars to do that for 55 you could have

1:55:40a brand-new fully loaded em to stop stop

1:55:45with that noise problems the waiting

1:55:46list for them to is the way this for him

1:55:48to is like two years

1:55:49my car will be exploded by then they get

1:55:51the m235i close enough look at bmw's are

1:55:54really nice cars when you don't pay to

1:55:56maintain them

1:55:57well that's true but i'm doing is

1:55:59punting my problem down the road and

1:56:01kicking ESO look I mean I i know you as

1:56:05much as I want you to drive a Tesla I

1:56:08know that your left foot would fall off

1:56:10and you'd be upset as much as I want you

1:56:14to have something nice and fast that is

1:56:17a little the that's fast in other ways

1:56:19like you know your little like you know

1:56:21GTI and our and focus options

1:56:24I can't let you do that I just can't let

1:56:26you drive hatchback you too old for that

1:56:27it that's your dump that you realize all

1:56:31of Europe at any age grades denver

1:56:33hatchback Europe is different

1:56:35California's different we live here on

1:56:36the East Coast and we are boring geeks

1:56:38in our thirties you can't have a

1:56:39hatchback I can drive you have a kid for

1:56:41Christ's sake you get not so that's out

1:56:44the a4 is is a great car i'm sure it

1:56:50doesn't does it does not have a

1:56:51six-cylinder option anymore is that not

1:56:54a thing does not

1:56:55ok maybe when the s4 comes back

1:56:56presumably probably less but that's that

1:56:58that would then be more money than this

1:56:59about what you really want in it deep

1:57:04down in your heart what you really want

1:57:05is a 6-speed rear wheel drive BMW and

1:57:12it's it's all I want until the moment

1:57:14that that the warranty runs out and then

1:57:17I need to get something different again

1:57:18if only there was a way to have a car

1:57:21where you always under warranty that God

1:57:24the white m2 is hideous get eaten a blue

1:57:27one right

1:57:28that you absolutely what I when I first

1:57:30yours out here just now I I picked the

1:57:33blue one for you because I also

1:57:34surprisingly i also think the widest

1:57:36hideous and I think black is a little

1:57:38bit boring for that car

1:57:39so yeah I think I think blue is the only

1:57:42option for that car

1:57:43you also do the m240 I which is very

1:57:46good in itself

1:57:47I've driven the m235i friend at work has

1:57:50one and it was thin nominal variable

1:57:53drive m235i m240 I is only 46 it's like

1:57:5810,000 less that is interesting

1:58:00that's actually pretty good compromise

1:58:02if I don't mind never being able to put

1:58:04Declan in the car

1:58:05I mean you could it is a sure it would

1:58:07suck

1:58:08you could but you wouldn't want this if

1:58:10you were going to do that a lot but it

1:58:13really what you would be happiest with

1:58:15it's probably something like this it's

1:58:18probably not settling for a volkswagen

1:58:21group made hatchback and the a4 would be

1:58:24fine except it's pretty much a sideways

1:58:27step it's you you're getting what you

1:58:29already had and actually slightly slower

1:58:32because you're losing couple cylinders

1:58:33BMW makes good cars that you like a lot

1:58:35they just suck to maintain you know this

1:58:39thing is the thing that pisses me off so

1:58:40I just price my m2 and I came up 55-200

1:58:43you but the thing that really pisses me

1:58:45off about in the summary page says

1:58:46you're on to coop and there's you know a

1:58:48panoramic view that you can smaller

1:58:50quasi panoramic view of the car and man

1:58:53does it look good but right under that

1:58:54estimated least a hundred twenty-nine

1:58:56dollars on a star p is Bill 2520 to the

1:58:58next item on the list their 64.1 second

1:59:02it's like you get me BMW you guys get me

1:59:06can't I can't do another BMW I'm so

1:59:09angry about it right now it's can come

1:59:12over it

1:59:12wait cool off run some numbers and

1:59:15consider all your options really late

1:59:17don't don't rule anything out unless it

1:59:20wouldn't make you happy to drive then

1:59:22ruled out so goodbye a chord

1:59:24goodbye mom sorry truth i'm not sure the

1:59:28a4 would make me terribly happy but it's

1:59:29worth a shot right

1:59:30exactly you're actually getting slower

1:59:32than your current car like this one

1:59:34saying like when when you during the

1:59:37good days of what when you've been

1:59:39owning your wonderful white BMW

1:59:42during these good days were you ever

1:59:44thinking that your next car would be

1:59:45slower I'm certainly not right

1:59:48exactly you're thinking man this is a

1:59:50great car and my next is going to be

1:59:52even faster you're thinking of getting

1:59:53them three next and i totally agree with

1:59:55you that the current m3 is ridiculously

1:59:58expensive and is priced

1:59:58expensive and is priced

2:00:00probably not the right move but and also

2:00:02it sounds just disgusting

2:00:04it's what I I've that there's now

2:00:06finally enough of them in the world i'm

2:00:08starting to like see and hear more of

2:00:09them in real life my goodness is that a

2:00:12hideous sounding car but the m2 isn't

2:00:14the m2 sounds nice and is kind of like

2:00:17what the m3 should be but isn't the

2:00:20attempt

2:00:20it's a good offer I really think that

2:00:24you should consider it and if not the m2

2:00:26then the m240 which is very it's also

2:00:29very good i'm not gonna do that I'm not

2:00:31gonna get a coupe it's not gonna happen

2:00:33I mean it's kind of like a sedan just

2:00:35with the doors removed but like it's

2:00:38like you're writing a sedan height you

2:00:39know like on the floor you are looking

2:00:41on in like an s2000 looking like you're

2:00:43writing a sedan height your roughly

2:00:44sedan shaped you have similar like sedan

2:00:47weight distributions or say screw and

2:00:50get an m3 and and just be done with it

2:00:51and just never driving near my house

2:00:53want to hear it

2:00:55well I there's no way again three no

2:00:58freaking way

2:00:59not a chance i I'd i'm pretty much

2:01:01telling myself I will not buy another

2:01:02BMW at if ever at least next I'm just

2:01:05not going to do it and you can often you

2:01:08can get a worst car for you that's fine

2:01:10but until what is this about a gold bar

2:01:12what is worse this the size the

2:01:16refinement the Interior and the only

2:01:19thing that's worse about the the big

2:01:21office the four people who hate

2:01:23hatchbacks but which island is he

2:01:25doesn't and that'll just come but I

2:01:27don't let it happen X and so by that

2:01:29eliminates my main objection to that the

2:01:31Gulf is it is at back every other aspect

2:01:33of it sounds like a case you would have

2:01:35fun with it and he's somehow not

2:01:37bothered by driving around the rabbit so

2:01:39that's fine

2:01:40Casey look you need to forgive yourself

2:01:43later so get something nice

2:01:46we need to forgive him for getting a

2:01:48hatchback so we need to do here is to

2:01:50forgive himself for getting a hatchback

2:01:5140,000 472 dollars for a brand-new go

2:01:54far

2:01:55you could also although if you do get

2:01:57that will have to have like a seminar on

2:01:58how to pronounce the name of the car

2:02:00what are you a gulf person would be

2:02:02going out he keeps saying likely of

2:02:04Mexico blank of Mexico that's what he

2:02:06keeps saying that's not the name of the

2:02:07car to know