Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

216: Thermal Corner

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:02can't innovate anymore my ass

0:00:27thank you

0:00:29today we're going to talk about

0:00:33important things like me driving my dads

0:00:351970 Dodge Dart yesterday yep yeah

0:00:38that's that's a good idea what about um

0:00:39I was wondering John do we have any

0:00:42follow-up we actually do not actually do

0:00:46it is only the morse only two oh okay

0:00:52bark bark the timestamp kids it's only

0:00:55two items in it by my clock were seven

0:00:58and a half minutes into the call so

0:01:00after follow-up we can also talk about

0:01:01t-shirts I suppose okay dad wants to

0:01:07kick us off dad can't we just eat her

0:01:08dessert first not only you know I

0:01:12support I all snark aside we should get

0:01:14through the follow-up it shouldn't be

0:01:15very long hopefully all right last week

0:01:18we talked for the second time about a

0:01:21PFS filename encoding and you wouldn't

0:01:24think there would be more to say about

0:01:25it and yet here we are to talk about it

0:01:28for the third possibly fourth are you

0:01:30serious yes because Apple has posted

0:01:33official documentation on their website

0:01:36answering the question hey what's the

0:01:40deal with thought Lima coating on a PFS

0:01:42and so to summarize and this is a little

0:01:45bit weirder than I would have expected

0:01:47they say a PFS has case sensitive in

0:01:50case insensitive variants we kind of

0:01:52assume that would be the case but really

0:01:54here you go they set it right out right

0:01:55the case insensitive variant of a PFS is

0:01:58normalization preserving but not

0:02:00normalization sensitive which is pretty

0:02:03weird like that basically if you send it

0:02:06a file name normalized however the hell

0:02:08you want to pick your own Unicode

0:02:09normalization the a PFS will preserve

0:02:13that but it's not normalization

0:02:16sensitive this is the case insensitive

0:02:18variant it's not normalization sensitive

0:02:19in that if you try to look something up

0:02:21and you say hey do you have a file

0:02:22called cafe with little yo with the

0:02:24accent and my reading of this is that it

0:02:26you feed it that string in any

0:02:29normalization you want and it doesn't

0:02:31matter what normalization it is in the

0:02:32file system it will find it because the

0:02:35file system is not normalization

0:02:37sensitive but it preserves what you give

0:02:40it really confusing so anyway we'll have

0:02:42to get

0:02:43a case-insensitive variant of this on

0:02:45the mac and do some tests to see what

0:02:46the deal is but the case sensitive

0:02:48variant is both normalization preserving

0:02:50and normalization sensitive so that is

0:02:52straightforward it's the case sensitive

0:02:54on iOS is just exactly what we said it

0:02:58takes what you give it and that's it and

0:02:59they do clarify here file names and a

0:03:02PFS are encoded in utf-8 and aren't

0:03:05normalized so it wants you so it's not

0:03:09as if you read a directory structure and

0:03:10a P of s and user I have no idea what

0:03:12encoding this is assuming everybody's

0:03:13following the rules and I'm not sure if

0:03:15this is enforced at the file system

0:03:16level or not they all have to be utf-8

0:03:19and the file system itself is not going

0:03:23to take your utf-8 string and normalize

0:03:25it like H of S Plus that it's like

0:03:27whatever you give it in your GF 8 that's

0:03:28what it's going to stick in the file

0:03:29system both variants will do that but

0:03:31it's interesting that they're saying you

0:03:33know no utf-16 no utf-32 know anything

0:03:36like that I suppose if you use the

0:03:39lowest level API as you could just jam

0:03:41would have that you wanted into there

0:03:42but they're they're documented here

0:03:44utf-8 and they compared with the HFS

0:03:47plus which has all of its weird rules

0:03:48and they say that in Mac OS 10 12 for

0:03:54the apos Developer Preview was updated

0:03:56to include the case insensitive variant

0:03:58so this is the first time the case

0:03:59insensitive area native API fuss has

0:04:01been available in any version of the

0:04:04operating system and an iOS of course in

0:04:0710 3 we get the case sensitive variant

0:04:08and they give some advice for avoiding

0:04:11bugs I bet there will be wwc sessions

0:04:13about this exact issue because I think

0:04:16it's going to come up a lot they want

0:04:17you to use the high level API is they

0:04:19want you use NS file manager nsurl and

0:04:21they want you to use the filesystem

0:04:22representation property of nsurl we're

0:04:25in creating an opening files with lower

0:04:27level filesystem API is like the POSIX

0:04:29tough so there are high level API is to

0:04:32give you you know a character buffer or

0:04:35whatever to feed into the lower level

0:04:36api's so I'm glad they have some

0:04:39documentation on it it's still pretty

0:04:40weird this is definitely a case where

0:04:42we're going to need to see a lot of

0:04:43sample code and a lot of sort of best

0:04:46practices and Andy patterns and still I

0:04:49believe when the when the Mac operating

0:04:52system ships with a non developer

0:04:54preview version as operating system we

0:04:55will all get to find out

0:04:56which are on our applications are making

0:04:59assumptions that no longer hold in an a

0:05:01PFS world as they slowly break i'm gonna

0:05:03bet on adobe i don't know about you guys

0:05:05I think that's a pretty safe bet oh my

0:05:08goodness all right we should do a quick

0:05:11bit of follow-up and talk about the

0:05:14situation report for WOD see we spoke

0:05:17last episode marco was one hundred

0:05:19percent dedicated two layers which as

0:05:21far as i know is still had that still

0:05:23has availability so you might want to

0:05:24check that out john and i had put our

0:05:26names in the hat for WWDC john did you

0:05:31win the lottery and win the opportunity

0:05:33to give Apple sixteen hundred dollars of

0:05:35your money I did I'm a winner Oh Brad

0:05:38congratulations I was are excited yeah I

0:05:41remember the interminable wait in years

0:05:45past for you know when other people are

0:05:46getting their emails and this time I was

0:05:48distracted enough that about time I

0:05:50looked at my email there it was success

0:05:52very happy delightful I also won the

0:05:55lottery this year which is very exciting

0:05:57because I did not win the lottery last

0:05:59year so I will also be at WABC which I'm

0:06:03very very excited about before we're

0:06:06asked since all three of us will be in

0:06:08town we are not going to do a live in

0:06:13front of people ATP we never really have

0:06:16the closest thing we came was when we

0:06:18were on the talk show we don't do that

0:06:21because even though some of us would

0:06:25enjoy doing so absolutely zero of the

0:06:28three of us want to have anything to do

0:06:30with planning it and so that is why it's

0:06:32not happening but all three of us will

0:06:34be in town I'm sure we'll talk about

0:06:36this more before the on the episode

0:06:39before WV DC but if you see us please

0:06:42say hi we always enjoy it we may not be

0:06:43able to talk for very long depending on

0:06:45the situation but we always enjoyed if

0:06:46you could say hi any other quick

0:06:48thoughts about wdc kids no good talk

0:06:51everybody where are your ATP shirts yeah

0:06:54well oh and where your ATP shirts it is

0:06:55all but guaranteed you will get a

0:06:57high-five hug or some other interaction

0:06:59from at least me if no one else if I

0:07:02spot an ATP shirt and if i remember i'll

0:07:05have some ATP stickers printed which

0:07:07i'll probably forget but if i remember

0:07:09i'll have some printed in if I

0:07:10in a t-shirt you're getting a sticker

0:07:11and then finally on a very very brief

0:07:15but somber note I just wanted to quickly

0:07:17recognize that a member of our community

0:07:20Jason Seifer who was a fellow podcaster

0:07:22a ruby developer and for a long time a

0:07:25teacher treehouse passed away unexpected

0:07:28and unexpectedly tragically over the

0:07:31weekend and I just wanted to acknowledge

0:07:34that and say that that I know I'm in and

0:07:37I'm pretty darn sure I speak for

0:07:38everyone the three of us are very sad to

0:07:41hear and we were really bummed about it

0:07:42Mike and I talked about it on the

0:07:45forthcoming episode of analog that won't

0:07:46be out until the weekends are probably

0:07:48several days after this episode but

0:07:50we're really bummed out and we're really

0:07:53sad about it and we just wanted to take

0:07:55a pause to to say that all right big

0:08:00week a little bit think it's been some

0:08:03things have happened so this morning

0:08:07there appears to have been some sort of

0:08:09an embargo that had dropped about a

0:08:12meeting that happens sometimes I guess

0:08:14in the last day or two with regard to

0:08:18the mac pro of all things yeah i mean

0:08:21who had this on the bingo card for this

0:08:23week right like that certainly certainly

0:08:24not me oh my god this this was a quite a

0:08:28big surprise a pleasant surprise but

0:08:31certainly a sizable one yeah so there

0:08:35were a handful of people that were

0:08:37invited to cupertino to discuss I i

0:08:41believe it was phrased as a round table

0:08:43to talk about the mac yes a small round

0:08:46table discussion about the max so as per

0:08:48john gruber it was he matthew panzer ii

0:08:51know lance ulanoff ena free how did I

0:08:53shoot i pronounce our own deny you're

0:08:55asking the wrong people alright well

0:08:57that's right I'm so sorry if I got that

0:08:59wrong anyway and John pegs I'll ski I

0:09:01believe that's pretty close to right I

0:09:03should have made somebody else read

0:09:05those names so I didn't have to anyway

0:09:07the the group of them went to cupertino

0:09:11to have a roundtable discussion about

0:09:13the mac and including about the mac pro

0:09:18so not even including the map i would

0:09:21say it was primarily about the mac pro

0:09:22that's absolutely

0:09:24interesting how they phrase this like

0:09:25come out come out to cupertino will have

0:09:28a roundtable discussion about the mac

0:09:30who knows what they actually told the

0:09:32people about what they're going to do

0:09:33but their their characterization we're

0:09:35just gonna hang out we're gonna talk

0:09:36about the mac a little bit right guys

0:09:37and yeah like Margot said no they're

0:09:42going to talk specifically about one

0:09:44particular Mac this near and dear to all

0:09:46of our hearts except for Casey and

0:09:48that's entirely what the thing was about

0:09:50but I guess they can't come out and tell

0:09:51people hey fly out Cupertino so we can

0:09:55tell you stuff about the mac pro they

0:09:57always want to have a little bit of a

0:09:58surprise yeah I guess they did talk

0:10:01about the imac I mean they talked about

0:10:02a lot of things because you could ask

0:10:03them any questions you want it and then

0:10:04they could answer them however they

0:10:05wanted but what the big takeaway from

0:10:07this and most of the headlines with the

0:10:09exception of a couple that did mention

0:10:11the imac we're all about the mac pro

0:10:13right so I'm going to do my best to

0:10:16summarize and then I will probably get

0:10:18interrupted and that's for the best so

0:10:20let me start by meeting a little for a

0:10:22little from what Gruber had written and

0:10:25he says here's how she'll or broke the

0:10:26news on the Mac Pro it's worth quoting

0:10:28him at lengths and let me now quote

0:10:30Gruber quoting Schiller with regard to

0:10:33the mac pro we are in the process of

0:10:34what we call completely rethinking the

0:10:36mac pro we're working on it we have a

0:10:39team working hard on it right now and we

0:10:40want to architect it so that we can keep

0:10:42it fresh with regular improvements and

0:10:44we're committed to making it our highest

0:10:46and high-throughput desktop system

0:10:48designed for are demanding pro customers

0:10:50as a part of doing a new mac pro it is

0:10:53by definition of modular system we will

0:10:54be doing a pro display as well john

0:10:57siracusa it is your lucky day that's me

0:11:00not sure anyway now that would be easy

0:11:02that would have been amazing yeah you

0:11:05won't see any of those products this

0:11:07year we're in the process of that we

0:11:08think it's really important to create

0:11:10something great for our pro customers

0:11:11who want a mac pro modular system and

0:11:13that'll take longer than this year to do

0:11:15in the interim we know that there are a

0:11:16number of customers who will continue to

0:11:18buy our current mac pro's to be clear a

0:11:20current mac pro's metha needs of some of

0:11:22our customers and we know that clearly

0:11:24not all of our customers none of this is

0:11:27black and white it's wide variety of

0:11:28customers some it's the kind of system

0:11:30that they wanted others it was not in

0:11:32the meantime we're going to update the

0:11:34configs to make it faster and better for

0:11:35their dollar this is not a new model

0:11:38a new design we're just going to update

0:11:40the configs we're doing that this week

0:11:42we can give you the specifics on that

0:11:44the CPUs we're moving them down the line

0:11:46the GPUs down the line to get more

0:11:48performance per dollar for customers who

0:11:49do need to continue to buy them on the

0:11:51in the owner in the interim until we get

0:11:54a newly architected system so there is a

0:11:58new mac pro it is not happening in 2017

0:12:01there is a small spec spec bump on the

0:12:04existing mac pro but things are

0:12:07happening and the fact that Apple is

0:12:10addressing this at all I think is really

0:12:13exciting and in really really good news

0:12:15i can continue to summarize but i think

0:12:18at this point we should take a moment

0:12:19and start talking so Marco let's start

0:12:23with you what do you think I have like

0:12:25four pages of notes here where to begin

0:12:28I mean so we will get into some of the

0:12:33specifics but just high level overview

0:12:35I'm incredibly happy to hear this this

0:12:39is awesome because what this means you

0:12:42know for for a long time it has seemed

0:12:45you know the the neglect of the Mac Pro

0:12:47has been going on for three years if you

0:12:51measure it from the trash can but

0:12:53actually the neglect of the mac pro

0:12:55started in 2010 the the well the last

0:12:58like basically in 2010 was the last new

0:13:02cheese grater revision they officially

0:13:04did one in twenty twelve but it was

0:13:06really the same thing with like one more

0:13:08processor option at the top end it was

0:13:10actually very similar what they just did

0:13:11today but actually with it it today was

0:13:13even less because there are no new

0:13:15options but the 2012 Mac Pro really

0:13:18wasn't a thing the 2010 one was the was

0:13:21the last cheese grater update that

0:13:23mattered and if you ever seen the old

0:13:25logo of our show by the way yeah it was

0:13:27a cheese grater Mac Pro with a little

0:13:29new label stuck on it and sarcastically

0:13:31because we were waiting for the Mac Pro

0:13:33that the new mac pros to be announced at

0:13:35WABC we had been waiting for a while and

0:13:37they did announce new mac pro's all

0:13:38right maybe it was like a press release

0:13:39updated not even a stage I forget but

0:13:42they were only knew you know

0:13:43conceptually like technically yeah

0:13:45there's one new configuration is one new

0:13:47cpu that was the I think that was the

0:13:49very first icon this podcast ever had

0:13:51it was right and so the show was founded

0:13:55on dissatisfaction with the with the

0:13:58offerings of the Mac Pro see it so the

0:14:00people who dated back to the trashcan

0:14:01yeah the trashcan has had problems and

0:14:03we'll talk about that but even as far

0:14:04back in the cheese grater it seemed like

0:14:05they took everybody off the cheese

0:14:07grater and said you know we've been

0:14:08steadily updating this cheese grater for

0:14:10a while you know every time there's a

0:14:11new cpu upgrading the GPUs every year

0:14:14just like clockwork but we're not going

0:14:16to do that anymore and maybe they all

0:14:18went off to make the trash can which is

0:14:19really weird and complicated or maybe

0:14:21they were just you know pulling back a

0:14:23little bit and slowing down the updates

0:14:25again it's hard to know what goes on

0:14:26inside Apple but this phenomenon of the

0:14:29Mac Pro no longer being updated steadily

0:14:33is as Marco said not a phenomenon that

0:14:36goes back to 2013 it goes all the way

0:14:39back to 2010 so it's a long time exactly

0:14:41and so when you know clearly one of the

0:14:45reasons why there is a long delay

0:14:46between the 2010 one and 2013 redesign

0:14:49which was really it was announced in

0:14:51mid-2013 but it wasn't really available

0:14:53it went for sale in late December of

0:14:552013 and wasn't actually shipped to

0:14:57anybody until the first couple months of

0:14:592014 so it was you know a good three and

0:15:03a half years between like July 2010 when

0:15:05that other one came out and this new one

0:15:07I'm that was presumably because they

0:15:09were doing this big redesign and

0:15:10everything and also by the way they they

0:15:13pre announced the 23rd yeah Mac Pro

0:15:14mostly because we felt like or Apple

0:15:17felt like it like they had to because we

0:15:19were waiting like what's the deal what's

0:15:21the old Mac Pro you did this update and

0:15:22it was barely an update it was like you

0:15:25know that you call that an update where

0:15:26is the real new Mac Pro and we were

0:15:29waiting what it then seemed like such a

0:15:31long time for they felt like they need

0:15:33to say at WWDC here's the new Mac Pro

0:15:36ins this amazing thing we're like yay

0:15:38finally is it all by the way not really

0:15:39like shipping for a long time but but

0:15:41still they like why didn't they hold it

0:15:43until it was it was somewhat close to

0:15:46shipping because they felt but you know

0:15:47that whatever dissatisfaction there was

0:15:49among that customer base they had to

0:15:51reassure them by saying alright we're

0:15:53going to announce a thing we're going to

0:15:54show you the pictures of it here it is

0:15:55we're going to put it in a little glass

0:15:57tube outside of the Presidio at Moscone

0:16:00and so you can look at it and see that

0:16:02it's a real thing but you're not getting

0:16:03one

0:16:04months but we all felt better because

0:16:06it's like well at least we know now that

0:16:08the Mac Pro isn't dead that is not there

0:16:10the reason they weren't operating the

0:16:11cheese graters could have been because

0:16:13they were working on this and this is a

0:16:14fancy new thing and it will be coming

0:16:16soon and I think we all basically felt

0:16:18better about that even though there was

0:16:20a delay and this current announcement is

0:16:22like everything will happen before but

0:16:24stretch all the time lines out even

0:16:26farther you know at the time we thought

0:16:28they don't care about Mac Pro users they

0:16:31don't care about the Mac Pro and then

0:16:32they release the you know the 2013 one

0:16:34and we thought okay great they released

0:16:37a new one and this is awesome however it

0:16:40doesn't need a lot of people's needs in

0:16:42a bunch of ways that we'll get into in a

0:16:44minute and so then that was now that

0:16:47it's been now like about the same delay

0:16:49between 2010 on that one and between

0:16:51that one and now you know about three

0:16:53and a half years or so the assumption

0:16:55that we've all been making and I totally

0:16:58owned this I have been number one on a

0:17:01list of complainers on this show at

0:17:03least the assumption that we've all been

0:17:05making is that Apple is being run really

0:17:09just by the numbers by Tim Cook and that

0:17:12you know it is this fairly small product

0:17:17line that is you know something like one

0:17:19percent of mac sales was just not enough

0:17:23of a blip on the radar for Tim Cook to

0:17:25care about updating ever again that is

0:17:29how it seemed until this morning to to

0:17:32all of us Mac Pro users and that has

0:17:34manifested itself with a number of side

0:17:37effects one of which which I think might

0:17:39have contributed to Apple finally you

0:17:41know getting into gear on on doing an

0:17:42update here is that when the macbook pro

0:17:45was updated last fall the 2016 macbook

0:17:49pro with the touch bar and everything

0:17:50else it was clearly not as well received

0:17:53as Apple thought it would be there was

0:17:56quite a lot of outcry and part of that

0:17:58is because of legitimate downsides of

0:18:00that product part that's temporary part

0:18:03of it won't be temporary but I think a

0:18:05big part of the of the angst over the

0:18:062016 macbook pro is also that pros had

0:18:10been neglected on the desktop for so

0:18:12long that they're not only were they

0:18:15kind of already mad

0:18:17Apple not serving their needs but it

0:18:20sure looked like they were going to have

0:18:22to now wedge their needs into these

0:18:24other products that weren't very good at

0:18:26serving them and so I if I had to guess

0:18:30it was during the 2016 macbook pro

0:18:33launch with all this kickback that Apple

0:18:36finally decided to go ahead with the new

0:18:38Mac Pro project you know Craig federighi

0:18:41made some comments during these

0:18:42interviews that it was it's been longer

0:18:44than six months they've been working on

0:18:45it but that doesn't mean it had it had

0:18:47the green light to go ahead as a product

0:18:49for more than six months I don't think

0:18:51it was long as much they've been working

0:18:52on it was they were trying this

0:18:54roundtable was a bunch of journalists

0:18:55right so the journalists are asking

0:18:56questions and one of the big questions

0:18:58that everyone wants to know is you know

0:19:02we we out here in the community who are

0:19:05interested in the mac pro have been

0:19:06upset about it for a long long time how

0:19:09how did it come to pass that so much

0:19:12time elapsed between the 2013 mac pro

0:19:16and now and there was nothing literally

0:19:18no updates no price changes no

0:19:20announcement or anything and then just

0:19:23now you call a roundtable so everyone

0:19:25want to know the timeline how long ago

0:19:26did you decide that this is the thing

0:19:30you were going to do and they didn't

0:19:31like well it's not like there's anyone

0:19:32decision or one meeting and each of us

0:19:34went through her own journey of like

0:19:36deciding what was a quick video so we

0:19:39went through like denial and acceptance

0:19:41so I can imagine there are people like

0:19:43well-made like the denial thing would be

0:19:45like well the new Mac Pro was weird and

0:19:47all and people complain but I bet if we

0:19:49just leave it out there people will come

0:19:50to accept it as the new way then pro

0:19:53hardware is going to work on the desktop

0:19:55and then eventually have to say you know

0:19:57looks like they're not really accepting

0:19:58it and so the six-month things seemed to

0:20:01be more of a timeline of like when when

0:20:04did you come to this realization they

0:20:05never actually answered how did you go

0:20:07so many years with like basically your

0:20:09heads in the sand right because that's

0:20:11why I mean just two shows ago I was

0:20:13asking us all if we had consensus that

0:20:15basically there's not going to be

0:20:17another new mac pro this is just going

0:20:18to be an imac pro which by the way there

0:20:20will be and they talked about it you

0:20:22know basically an imac bent towards pro

0:20:24people because look if there was going

0:20:25to be a new mac pro they wouldn't have

0:20:27left this one there for like four years

0:20:29with no update

0:20:30right like surely they wouldn't do that

0:20:32just yet with no no communication or

0:20:35whatever and it's like the certain point

0:20:36they're communicating to you by saying

0:20:38we update the imac you know we we don't

0:20:41but drop dropping the the apple monitor

0:20:44and sort of back-channel communicating

0:20:46to some journalists somewhere that hey

0:20:48apples not doing monitors anymore and

0:20:50offering the LG one that's another big

0:20:52sign like the imac it's it's the future

0:20:54right and so we were just all like we

0:20:57were in the acceptance phase or at least

0:20:59i was like well you know no more mac

0:21:01pro's and we all we all want to know

0:21:03that because we all come wanna like be

0:21:05you know vengeful and say how could you

0:21:07have made this mistake because on one

0:21:09hand we're all ecstatic that the

0:21:11announcement they made was not hey by

0:21:13the way we just want to let you know

0:21:15we're not making the mac pro anymore

0:21:16like we want to make it official that

0:21:18could have been what they said at this

0:21:19meeting they this meeting could have

0:21:21also been you know where we've just were

0:21:23just given up on the mac like they're

0:21:25the most pessimistic ideas of what could

0:21:27it mean to go to a mac roundtable and

0:21:29ominous sounding mac round table if you

0:21:31were accepting there was going to be no

0:21:32mac pro could have been like terrible

0:21:34bad news instead it was good news but

0:21:35the good news is just immediately makes

0:21:37you ask the question what well what took

0:21:40you so long like and that's the question

0:21:42that you know when when did you figure

0:21:43it out like what was your plan before

0:21:45six months ago what what were you doing

0:21:47like what another year guys this this

0:21:49current mac pro that we never update

0:21:50will will will you know it's gonna set

0:21:54the world on fire just wait yeah right

0:21:56I'm so they didn't they're not going to

0:21:58go into like you know their deliberation

0:22:00process and discuss you know is they

0:22:02don't realize stuff but they did go into

0:22:03a couple of aspects of like why why is

0:22:07the current trashcan why didn't you ever

0:22:09update it and so Craig federighi had

0:22:13said this is a quote from him I think we

0:22:14designed ourselves into a bit of a

0:22:16thermal corner and there he was talking

0:22:18about the design of the trash can which

0:22:20is a big cylinder and inside the

0:22:22cylinder is kind of like three boards

0:22:23three vertical boards that make a

0:22:24triangle shape if you're looking down on

0:22:26top of it two of them are GPUs and one

0:22:27of them is the CPU board he was saying

0:22:30that that this is quoting from my pants

0:22:32Reno's argyll the unique triangular

0:22:34design of the Mac Pro thermal core

0:22:35provided proved to be the limiting

0:22:37factor it wasn't built to have for one

0:22:39of the three sides of the triangle to

0:22:41get super hot so if they if they want to

0:22:42have a really hot GPU on one side

0:22:44and then cooler parts are supposed to be

0:22:46like equal distribution of heat from the

0:22:47two mid-range you know mid heat GPUs and

0:22:51the CPU on the other side but basically

0:22:52I think the problem is the little

0:22:53cylinder with the one fan on top there

0:22:55were just not enough cooling capacity

0:22:57unless you probably crank that fan up to

0:22:59the point where they didn't like it that

0:23:00but the story they gave was we they

0:23:04couldn't update it like they the faster

0:23:06GPUs they could have put in there it

0:23:08couldn't handle a thermal load maybe

0:23:09even also the CPUs and federighi also

0:23:12emphasized that this wasn't like someone

0:23:15had an idea to make a trashcan shaped

0:23:17computer and then they just put all

0:23:19their marbles in that basket that thing

0:23:20missing is another quote from federica

0:23:22federighi we didn't start with shape and

0:23:24say well here's the fastest machine we

0:23:26can put in that box we actually started

0:23:27with a target for performance and came

0:23:29up with what we think was a very clever

0:23:30design for that thermal core thermal

0:23:32architecture so they they had a target

0:23:35of like two GPUs with lots of cores and

0:23:39one cpu and then they tried to figure

0:23:42out which again you could say this was

0:23:44their one of their mistakes what is the

0:23:46smallest quietest thing we can get it

0:23:49and they emphasize that in the 2013 Mac

0:23:51Pro lunch look how much smaller this

0:23:53trashcan mac pro is than the giant

0:23:55cheese grater I remember when they put

0:23:56up the image of the two things next to

0:23:58each other the cake it was like it was

0:24:00like what what is that an airport hub

0:24:03next to and I felt like no that's the

0:24:05new Mac Pro it seemed impossibly small

0:24:06compared to the size of the cheese

0:24:09grater and they did they made like

0:24:10packaging wise it is super quiet and

0:24:13super small compared to a at our

0:24:15computer and of course you know the

0:24:16sacrifice all the internal storage and

0:24:18all the other stuff but that basically

0:24:19by making that design and all the

0:24:21tooling and all that fancy factory in

0:24:23the u.s. that makes all this stuff and

0:24:24you know all the money they put into

0:24:26that the story they gave was that

0:24:28basically they couldn't update it

0:24:30because none of the better stuff that

0:24:32they could fit in there could be cooled

0:24:34inside that case so they had to design a

0:24:37new one but they didn't they just say I

0:24:38don't know what they did just sat on

0:24:40their hands for several years mulling

0:24:42over what to do all the while continuing

0:24:44to sell that thing until he finally came

0:24:46to this realization so I don't you know

0:24:48again we have to wait for people to

0:24:50retire and give the tell-all books but

0:24:51something went wrong inside apples were

0:24:54saying so they go wrong but with the mac

0:24:56pro because it is

0:24:58not a good look to sell the same

0:25:00computer for the same price for so many

0:25:01years and it's also not a good look to

0:25:03only realize your mistake many many many

0:25:07years later way way too late so late in

0:25:10fact that you are forced to do a thing

0:25:12that Apple never ever does which is call

0:25:15bunch of journalists together and tell

0:25:17them about computer you're going to

0:25:19release in the next year like not got

0:25:21this calendar year like hey let me tell

0:25:24you about something it's not released

0:25:25yet we can't even show you a picture of

0:25:27it and be it's not going to be released

0:25:28this year they also by the way didn't

0:25:30say as far as an able to determine that

0:25:32it's going to be released next year all

0:25:34they said is not this year and

0:25:35everybody's like oh that totally means

0:25:37next year probably does but they're

0:25:39covering their bases and so that means

0:25:41that says to me that they decided very

0:25:44very very recently on the serve the no

0:25:48go no go on the mac pro because if they

0:25:51had come and said guys we just want to

0:25:53tell you there's not going to be another

0:25:56mac pro that would make perfect sense

0:25:58because it's like well we debated for a

0:25:59long time while we debated we kept

0:26:01selling this thing but in the end where

0:26:03you know is down the toilet download

0:26:06over to the trash can no more mac pro's

0:26:08the imac is the future we just want to

0:26:10let you know and let's talk about it and

0:26:12love this explain to why we think pros

0:26:14can use this other stuff or whatever

0:26:15because at least that would make sense

0:26:16for the trajectory instead they hemmed

0:26:20it hard for four years realize the error

0:26:22of their ways which is good but realized

0:26:24it's so late that they have nothing to

0:26:26say to us except we will we will make

0:26:29good and i'm glad they what course i'm

0:26:32glad that they're they're going to do

0:26:33this to love to mac pro i'm glad they

0:26:35went into specifics instead of saying

0:26:37we're going to make new pro hardware

0:26:39they went into specifics by saying this

0:26:41new pro hardware will be modular in

0:26:43their parlance there will be a separate

0:26:45monitor and a separate computer so it's

0:26:48not going to be like oh there's going to

0:26:49be an awesome i like you like no dope

0:26:50they said that is a separate thing we

0:26:51are going to do a new or imac with fancy

0:26:53of stuff that pros my like but also

0:26:54there's this thing which is modular and

0:26:57we're going to make our own displays

0:26:58which so recently they seem to be moving

0:27:01away from and i guess because they want

0:27:03me not to wake in the middle of the

0:27:05night and tremble in fear of having to

0:27:07get a non apple monitor they're going to

0:27:09make an apple monitor

0:27:11the final point they made is whatever

0:27:13this design is which they can go into

0:27:15details about we're going to make sure

0:27:17the with this design we can ink we can

0:27:20upgrade the internals on on some kind of

0:27:23schedule other than never ever upgrading

0:27:25them right so those are the few bits of

0:27:27information they gave about this I get

0:27:29the impression that the same brief that

0:27:32they gave these journalist was given to

0:27:33apples newly formed team not too long

0:27:36ago say we need a mac pro needs to be

0:27:38modular we need new apple monitor and we

0:27:41don't want the same thing that happened

0:27:42with the trash can to happen with us we

0:27:43need the internals to be upgradable on a

0:27:45reasonable schedule all that is music to

0:27:47my ears because those are all the things

0:27:48I want to hear like the only thing they

0:27:50could have said more was like we're

0:27:53going to have multiple internal drives

0:27:56and multiple internal slots they didn't

0:27:59say that and I doubt they will do that

0:28:00but that's the only other thing that I

0:28:02could have even asked for my wildest

0:28:03dreams so I am very very happy but also

0:28:06very disappointed in Apple because they

0:28:08know what they did they dun goofed yeah

0:28:12they they did not do well on this old

0:28:15Mac Pro thing I'm glad I'm glad they

0:28:18came well you know I they messed up like

0:28:22they even said themselves they

0:28:23apologized they said sorry when does

0:28:25Apple ever do that because it's not a

0:28:28coherent thing like it would be coherent

0:28:31if they said we slowly phase out the mac

0:28:33pro and it disappeared and let me tell

0:28:35you why we're not going to be in that

0:28:36business I'm your butt to neglect the

0:28:39mac pro like that and then have a change

0:28:41of heart at the very last minute

0:28:42certainly better from my perspective not

0:28:44having a change of heart that's not good

0:28:46for the company it's not good for the

0:28:47image not good for the pros it's not

0:28:49good for Apple that they have to

0:28:50pre-announce this product which is not a

0:28:51comfortable position for Apple to be in

0:28:53so this was this was kind of a of Apple

0:28:59being humble and coming hat in hand and

0:29:02saying we're sorry we mess up this Mac

0:29:05Pro thing let us make it up to you by

0:29:07doing all the good things for you and

0:29:09that's why everybody's happy because you

0:29:12know happy and also curious about Warren

0:29:13long but but happy to see that the

0:29:16result we all wanted is the result we're

0:29:17going to get if we just wait a little

0:29:20bit longer

0:29:22we respond to this week by Casper an

0:29:24obsessively engineered mattress at a

0:29:26shockingly fair price go to Casper calm

0:29:29/ ATP and use code ATP for fifty dollars

0:29:32towards your mattress Casper created one

0:29:35perfect mattress sold directly to

0:29:37consumers eliminating Commission driven

0:29:39inflated prices the award-winning Casper

0:29:41mattress was developed in house with a

0:29:43sleek design and delivered in a

0:29:45remarkably small box you can get it up

0:29:47narrow stairs and now in addition to the

0:29:50mattress Casper also offers an adaptive

0:29:52pillow and soft breathable sheets the

0:29:55mattress industry has so long forced

0:29:57customers into paying incredibly high

0:29:59markups and doing all sorts of crappy

0:30:01sales tricks Casper is revolutionising

0:30:03the industry by cutting the class of

0:30:05dealing with all these mattress stores

0:30:07and past net savings directly on to you

0:30:09an in-house team of engineer spent

0:30:11thousands of hours developing the

0:30:12catcher mattress with supportive memory

0:30:14foam for a sleep surface that has just

0:30:17the right sink and just the right bounce

0:30:18and the breathable design sleep school

0:30:21to help you regulate your temperature

0:30:22throughout the night and you might think

0:30:24buying a mattress online sounds crazy

0:30:26but Casper has made it completely easy

0:30:28and risk-free they have a free delivery

0:30:30of course and free returns and you can

0:30:34sleep on it for a hundred Knights to

0:30:36decide whether you want to keep it or

0:30:37return it a hundred night home trial if

0:30:40you don't love after a hundred nights

0:30:42they will arrange for it to be picked up

0:30:44at your house and give you a full refund

0:30:47Casper understands the importance of

0:30:49truly sleeping on a mattress before you

0:30:51commit to spending a third of your life

0:30:52on it we've heard so many things from

0:30:55our friends and listeners who love the

0:30:57cats or mattress it has gotten Awards

0:30:59gotten great reviews see for yourself

0:31:01you'll see if you look around it people

0:31:03love this thing it's a great mattress

0:31:04get yours today and try it for a hundred

0:31:06nights in your own home free delivery

0:31:08and free returns with home pick up all

0:31:11this completely risk-free go to casper

0:31:14calm / ATP and use code ATP for fifty

0:31:18dollars towards your mattress terms and

0:31:20conditions do apply thank you very much

0:31:22to cash for sponsoring our show

0:31:26so here's the thing like on the whole I

0:31:30agree with you and even as someone who

0:31:33sitting here now doesn't foresee ever

0:31:36buying a mac pro I'm excited about this

0:31:38I really am like I joked a lot on

0:31:40Twitter about oh god this episode's

0:31:42gonna be terrible but no I'm actually

0:31:43excited to talk about it because this

0:31:46this is good for everyone when Apple

0:31:49commits to the the professional market

0:31:52it's good for me as buy some definition

0:31:55a professional because I think they

0:31:56actually cited Xcode is one of the apps

0:32:00they consider to be a professional app

0:32:01and one of the apps they look for in

0:32:03there like analytics to see who is a

0:32:05professional and who isn't but anyway I

0:32:07I definitely unequivocally think that

0:32:11this was way way way too late but I

0:32:16don't know a lot of people on Twitter

0:32:18we're jumping straight to like Oh Apple

0:32:21is just you know they weren't doing

0:32:23anything until yesterday and then they

0:32:26finally decided to do something and I

0:32:27know I think it's unfair for us to

0:32:30assume how long it takes to build an

0:32:33entire new computer with an entirely new

0:32:36design from the ground up like I agree

0:32:39that they should have started on this a

0:32:40while ago I agree that we should never

0:32:43have gotten to this point but I think

0:32:46it's a bit presumptuous for us to just

0:32:48assume they can go to some parts bin

0:32:50somewhere throw a few things together

0:32:51and call it good I think that were

0:32:54perhaps assuming the worst where it may

0:32:57not be necessary this should have

0:32:59absolutely happened at least a year ago

0:33:00if not two but it doesn't mean that they

0:33:03didn't start work on it a year ago if

0:33:05not to what if they just didn't feel

0:33:07compelled to tell us about it until now

0:33:10because a bunch of whiners like those

0:33:13guys on ATP god what a bunch of whiners

0:33:15the three of em are what if a bunch of

0:33:17whiners just got to the point that they

0:33:19felt like they needed to address it once

0:33:21and for all now I you know where that we

0:33:26think the decision was made to do

0:33:28something different but it's got to be

0:33:30pretty recent I mean just use the LG

0:33:32monitor as an example the monitor for

0:33:35most people as a sideshow here for me

0:33:36it's like the main show because I can

0:33:38tell you that

0:33:38if they if they had said we're gonna

0:33:41make a new mac pro but we're still not

0:33:43making apple monitors I would still be

0:33:45like maybe I'll get an imac right that's

0:33:47just me personally right but very

0:33:49recently as recently as one was it like

0:33:50october i don't know whenever they they

0:33:54came out with the the the new MacBook

0:33:56Pros with the LG display right and they

0:33:58talked to the press about it and the

0:34:00press would ask them so you know should

0:34:02we get an apple monitor River like no we

0:34:04this this LG monitor is the one we want

0:34:06it's on our store we're fully behind it

0:34:08so on and so forth and then through

0:34:10back-channel communication to someone on

0:34:11Twitter to say basically apples out of

0:34:13stand-alone display business this is

0:34:15recent stuff if as you suggest in case

0:34:18you that perhaps they've been working on

0:34:19this new Mac Pro for over a year there's

0:34:21no way they would have told everybody

0:34:24that Apple's out of the standalone

0:34:26display business through whatever back

0:34:28channels they did maybe they still would

0:34:29have said by the lg1 anyway because the

0:34:32new apple honor isn't coming up for a

0:34:33long time but yeah there are long lead

0:34:35times these things uh but not it doesn't

0:34:38take three years to make a monitor right

0:34:40like time was when Apple would make new

0:34:43products every year and yeah they have

0:34:44overlapping schedules and stuff like

0:34:45that which by the way is why i think the

0:34:48time that Apple needs to start making

0:34:49the next trash can is before the

0:34:51previous one is released like that's

0:34:52usually how these things overlap like

0:34:53that the new iphone is in the works at

0:34:56the time the current iphone is released

0:34:58that's the only way you could have

0:34:59usually releases of anything right so

0:35:01it's not as if you can release the trash

0:35:02can right and 20 late 2013 and then

0:35:07after the trash cans really start

0:35:08working on the next one you're already

0:35:10late at that point let alone release the

0:35:12trash can wait a year or two and then

0:35:14start working on the successor that's

0:35:16just too long if you're one of the

0:35:17things that the commitments of the pro

0:35:19market and it's what they talked about

0:35:20is you have to have some product that

0:35:24you can update because the whole point

0:35:26of this product is the biggest fastest

0:35:29computer apple sells and if you don't

0:35:34update it eventually your phone has

0:35:36faster single threaded performance than

0:35:37that they handle me like in the most

0:35:38extreme case you you have to update it's

0:35:41the role of this computer the only

0:35:43reason it exists is to be the biggest

0:35:44fastest thing as soon as it's not big as

0:35:46fast as people like well why am i buying

0:35:47this why don't I buy a 13-inch laptop

0:35:49that has a better cpu speed or faster

0:35:52d or has you know Thunderbolt 3 and this

0:35:55top end thing doesn't like it loses its

0:35:57purpose without updates so they were

0:36:00super duper late and it seems to me that

0:36:02if they can't even promise a 20-18

0:36:05release of this thing they started

0:36:07sometime you know in in the past year

0:36:12alright easily you may maybe in the past

0:36:14six months because is it it's not like

0:36:16the thing we're asking about when did

0:36:18they make the call when did they make

0:36:19the decision because they seem to make

0:36:21no decision for really really long time

0:36:22and then they made a decision and part

0:36:24of that decision was given that we made

0:36:26this decision look at our timelines when

0:36:29will we actually be able to show a

0:36:30product it will hurt us a lot to just do

0:36:33the normal apple thing which is not tell

0:36:34anybody until the product comes out

0:36:35because by then everyone will completely

0:36:38a written off Apple as a pro hardware

0:36:41vendor so we need to make the decision

0:36:44and then the even harder decision we're

0:36:45just now we have to tell people we have

0:36:47to tell people that we kind of started

0:36:48this new project because if we don't by

0:36:50the time we release it they'll all be

0:36:51gone they all will have left the block

0:36:52hey guys we have a new Mac Pro we didn't

0:36:54wanna tell you about it for the past

0:36:55year and a half that we've been

0:36:56developing it but we totally have a new

0:36:57one it's like too late we all left you

0:36:59neglected us right so they had to come

0:37:01out and tell us that at some point in

0:37:03the future defined as not this year

0:37:06there will be a new Mac Pro which was

0:37:08the right thing to do but it is it is a

0:37:10is them coming from a position of

0:37:11weakness and it makes me think that this

0:37:13decision was not made and that the team

0:37:16to make this new Mac Pro was not tasked

0:37:18with doing so any time longer than maybe

0:37:23like 12 months ago and I would guess

0:37:25maybe six months ago yeah I would say

0:37:27that's because like you know we we know

0:37:29from various like tips and rumblings

0:37:31here and there that like there were

0:37:33occasional efforts in Apple to

0:37:36investigate news eons and stuff but that

0:37:39there was never any suggestion by

0:37:42anybody any rumors any tipsters anybody

0:37:44that that was actually becoming a

0:37:45product for you know it anywhere close

0:37:48to a product I really do think that this

0:37:51probably became a priority six months

0:37:53ago and that's how they determined by

0:37:55the way that's how they determine

0:37:56probably their thermal limits like they

0:37:58have the cylinder and we kept hearing

0:38:00rumors from all sorts of weird sources

0:38:02like I looking at this chip all looking

0:38:04at that chip but look at this GP

0:38:06like maybe they tried all sorts of like

0:38:08component upgrades the trash can and

0:38:10every time they tried it it was either

0:38:12not a big enough win or they couldn't

0:38:14deal with the thermals right and it was

0:38:16just kind of like well do we want to

0:38:17bother through going through with this

0:38:19should we make it a product maybe wait

0:38:20for next year maybe it'll be better we

0:38:22have this prop like federighi federighi

0:38:25explanation is basically like they

0:38:26couldn't put better stuff in that

0:38:27cylinder did they you know they had

0:38:30designed ourselves into a bit of a

0:38:32thermal corner and the fact that they

0:38:36continued to try to tinker with that

0:38:38every time there was a new cpu or GPU

0:38:40but never actually released anything

0:38:42fits with that idea that it wasn't like

0:38:45they were you know opposed to making new

0:38:47Mac Pro's is they couldn't make new

0:38:49macro that a major investment and they

0:38:50come back and say okay well we can't put

0:38:52new stuff in the cylinder sorry about

0:38:54that oops can we make a whole totally

0:38:56new Mac Pro and then it was like well

0:38:58that seems like expensive and not a lot

0:39:01of people buy this and they just kept

0:39:02doing that and doing that and you know

0:39:04externally we see nothing we just you

0:39:05know we have the same mac pro as always

0:39:07in just a bunch of you know rumors and

0:39:10eventually has to come to head say look

0:39:12are we in this business are we not in

0:39:14this business in the decision they made

0:39:16which I'm very happy with this yes we

0:39:18are in this business we're going to

0:39:19rededicate ourselves and we're not going

0:39:22to make the same mistake twice nobody

0:39:24pokes new mac pro in a corner in a

0:39:25thermal corner that's like that since

0:39:29acknowledged yeah reference that

0:39:30knowledge so boy it's I would not want

0:39:35to been in these meetings but I am so

0:39:37glad so glad they they made I can't even

0:39:39say it's the right decision I don't know

0:39:40if it's the right decision for ample but

0:39:42its decision that I wanted actually yes

0:39:43I think it is the right decision travel

0:39:45because if Apple's not going to be in

0:39:47the Pro market then what the hell's the

0:39:49point of Apple like we're just going to

0:39:50be a phone company I think that's not

0:39:52that's not the Apple we all believe in

0:39:54and it's clearly not the apple of it all

0:39:57the people who come to these meetings

0:39:58and profess undying love for the Mac

0:40:00believe in either well and I think it's

0:40:02it's more than that it's that like if

0:40:03Apple decides that iOS is the only OS

0:40:07and their future then that's one thing

0:40:09but if the mac as a platform is going to

0:40:12continue they need to keep building pro

0:40:14hardware yeah I mean but but is the imac

0:40:18pro enough and i think we'll talk about

0:40:19that

0:40:20later but the one thing that that

0:40:22strikes me about this late I suspect you

0:40:24guys are right and that it was very

0:40:25recent him in the last 12 months or so

0:40:28that that Apple got really serious about

0:40:31replacing the mac pro but it seems a

0:40:34little disingenuous to me for us to say

0:40:36Oh surely they have mac OS running on

0:40:39arm you know surely they're doing that

0:40:41why would they not I mean I I know

0:40:43hardware is different but don't you

0:40:45think they would have been doing more

0:40:47than just piddling with a a new mac pro

0:40:50for all this time maybe there were only

0:40:52a handful of people on it maybe they

0:40:54weren't taking it too seriously but if I

0:40:56feel like why wouldn't you at least have

0:40:58that in the hopper just in case now to

0:41:01your point a minute ago both of you

0:41:02maybe that didn't start until like two

0:41:05years ago or one year ago or what have

0:41:07you but I feel laughs a year ago well

0:41:09and that's not going to be not going to

0:41:10be two years ago they would be they

0:41:12would be done by now those two years

0:41:13especially since this like in the I know

0:41:15so here's the thing there's attention

0:41:17with that bowl between make an amazing

0:41:19new thing which I think traffic and

0:41:21qualifies out like you haven't seen a PC

0:41:23like this before look at this thing

0:41:24isn't it weird and crazy and awesome

0:41:25like they want to do that but then

0:41:28there's schedule pressure so as many

0:41:29people pointed out they can make a

0:41:30rectangular box with nice finishes on it

0:41:32shove a bunch of crap in and be done but

0:41:33they don't want to do that so they're

0:41:35going to take longer than it would take

0:41:37to just slap together some basically a

0:41:38pc that runs mac OS right the question

0:41:41is how much longer will he take and if

0:41:43they had started two years ago even with

0:41:46the most obsessive you know a paul

0:41:49craftsmanship they could they could have

0:41:52had something to show today right so

0:41:54that makes me think again they had to

0:41:56have started this in the last calendar

0:41:58year at you know that's the longest i'm

0:42:01going to say this goes back and probably

0:42:02even closer yeah and so i think it's

0:42:05also worth kind of putting the 2013

0:42:08trash can in context a little bit to

0:42:12figure out like why they still care and

0:42:14and maybe what they can do to avoid

0:42:17another problem like this so in addition

0:42:20to the reasons that that John always

0:42:22likes to say about like you know the

0:42:24halo car knowledge intervals which I

0:42:25agree with so it actually sells better

0:42:28than I thought thanks so one of the

0:42:30things that came out in this meeting

0:42:31what they said that desktops are twenty

0:42:33percent

0:42:33of mac sales which that alone is higher

0:42:36than I would have guessed you know

0:42:38laptops are most people's computers

0:42:40these days so the fact that desktops

0:42:42still have twenty percent is pretty good

0:42:44I think they said that met the Mac Pro

0:42:47is in the low single-digit percentage of

0:42:50those mac sales if that's one percent

0:42:53which is the lowest that their estimate

0:42:56would really mean that is about 200,000

0:42:59mac / as a year now that i think is like

0:43:03one percent of mac sales and two hundred

0:43:05i think that's actually really good for

0:43:08because that's not the sales of the mac

0:43:10pro in its launch year when it's updated

0:43:13that's the sales of the mac pro now like

0:43:16this three year old like lame duck

0:43:18machine like that's the sales of that

0:43:20now so i think it's remarkable that it

0:43:23still sells that well i didn't that says

0:43:26that the the market for these things is

0:43:27probably bigger than a lot of us were

0:43:29were and were estimating because if this

0:43:32machine that's three years old and

0:43:34wasn't even that compelling when it was

0:43:36new very free talking to in a second if

0:43:38that can still sell 200,000 units a year

0:43:41that's amazing italy and so i decided to

0:43:45look up a couple stats i did some

0:43:47homework that is reflect that that is

0:43:51roughly equivalent i translated this

0:43:52into term to understand kc to the sales

0:43:54volume of the BMW x5 so well done yeah

0:44:00that's roughly what the x5 cells every

0:44:02year worldwide and that's a fairly

0:44:04popular model in their lineup so the

0:44:06fact that like you know that a car cans

0:44:09and oh and by the way it's also double

0:44:11the total sales volume of Tesla so like

0:44:15you know if if it's selling in this kind

0:44:18of volume if like a car company can

0:44:20justify having a car an entire car model

0:44:23with all the customization that goes

0:44:24into that and supporting everything else

0:44:25Apple can justify having a machine that

0:44:28only sells to this relatively small

0:44:30audience for you know compared to their

0:44:31whole product line well but what's the

0:44:33profit off of each of these devices Leo

0:44:36the profit off of an x5 one would hope

0:44:37would be many many many thousands of

0:44:39dollars what's the profit off of a

0:44:41trashcan Mac Pro oh no I mean no

0:44:44questions the the raw alone actually I

0:44:46wouldn't assume that the

0:44:47it's our that massive on cars maybe Im

0:44:49lugged your cars especially if you get

0:44:51like the floor mats but I think they're

0:44:54the costs of developing a new mac pro

0:44:57line especially if it's kind of

0:45:00reasonably done are probably low enough

0:45:03compared to developing a whole car you

0:45:05know that I think that's they're

0:45:06probably they're probably okay there but

0:45:09anyway I did want to briefly go into

0:45:12exactly what went wrong with 2013 mac

0:45:15pro 2 so that we can kind so that we and

0:45:18as commentators and hopefully if anybody

0:45:20at Apple is listening I assume you know

0:45:22they're all smart people they're

0:45:24considering these things too but I just

0:45:25want to say it just in case because I

0:45:27think there's important lessons to learn

0:45:28here and I really hope they have learned

0:45:31them so quick summary when the 2013 came

0:45:34out it costs more than the previous

0:45:37model but it accommodated fewer people's

0:45:39needs and so that'll even when it was

0:45:43brand-new that on day one once all the

0:45:45configs and pricing were up a lot of

0:45:48people did not like it very much and a

0:45:50lot of pro said oh never mind because it

0:45:52was so much more limited than the

0:45:54previous ones and it gave up all the

0:45:56drive bays all the slots a lot of the

0:45:58RAM expansion capabilities GPU replace

0:46:01ability GPU options CP dual cpu dual

0:46:05socket options like there was so so much

0:46:07stuff that was given up so it really did

0:46:10a lot less and it cost more and so

0:46:13that's like whatever Apple does next

0:46:16they have to learn a lesson from that

0:46:18wasn't they choose to follow it or not

0:46:20that's something to learn also it also

0:46:23suffered from just kind of bad market

0:46:25timing relative to the rest of the

0:46:26industry so almost immediately the 5k

0:46:31screen right you know revolution

0:46:32happened it was like it was like nine

0:46:34months into the mac pro when when 5k

0:46:37screens came out in the imac and the Mac

0:46:39Pro has no good way to drive a 5k screen

0:46:41and an apple doesn't sell one step ahead

0:46:44and and when they did finally get around

0:46:46to launching one last fall it doesn't

0:46:48work with 2013 mac pro at least i think

0:46:50we keep hearing random hacks about how

0:46:52it the stores are kind of hacking it to

0:46:54work but basically it doesn't work and

0:46:57so it missed the 5k revolution by a very

0:47:00short time

0:47:01and a lot of pros like myself

0:47:04prioritized having that Retina screen

0:47:07over having those additional cores and

0:47:08everything also right after that model

0:47:11came out the next generation of

0:47:13processors that Apple of course didn't

0:47:14use increase single-threaded performance

0:47:16noticeably and so what happened was

0:47:18within a very short time of the Mac Pro

0:47:20being released within about a year it

0:47:23was unable to drive the best screens

0:47:25that the highest end buyers wanted and

0:47:27it was defeated in a lot of like

0:47:30single-threaded performance tasks and a

0:47:32lot of benchmarks it was it was there

0:47:34beaten completely or in the case of like

0:47:37the six core like it could it could

0:47:39barely edged out in multi-threaded but

0:47:41you know that wasn't all work so it was

0:47:44it badly timed in the market and they

0:47:46don't forget about us bc one more

0:47:48revolution that has about the product

0:47:50line USBC also came along and guess who

0:47:52didn't get that then I felt like

0:47:54terrible timing in terms of peripheral

0:47:56like it wouldn't have been terrible

0:47:57timing if it was on the yearly update

0:47:58schedule be like Oh next year the Mac

0:48:00Pro will get updated it will get the new

0:48:02chips it will get us bc if we get

0:48:04Thunderbolt 3 it will be able to drive a

0:48:055k display that but but again the

0:48:09thermal corner uh apparently they just

0:48:11plain couldn't do that exactly and then

0:48:14also by by limiting it to a single CPU

0:48:18and dual GPU configuration you know they

0:48:22were making a big bet that this is going

0:48:24to be the future of pro computing

0:48:26unfortunately it wasn't the present of

0:48:28pro computing at the time and the the

0:48:30future took a different direction and

0:48:32and they were betting that just having

0:48:34this one set of trade-offs this one cpu

0:48:38to workstation GPUs that was going to

0:48:41solve all pro needs or all needs of the

0:48:43Mac Pro customers at least that was

0:48:45wrong even in 2013 and it never became

0:48:48correct you know they were betting big

0:48:50on opencl and that really didn't pan out

0:48:52beyond a very small number of

0:48:54specialized uses and they were also they

0:48:57never really supported it very well in

0:48:58mac OS either and so i think another

0:49:01lesson to learn here is that whatever

0:49:04direction the Mac Pro takes it can't

0:49:08rely on highly specialized OS features

0:49:12very much because chances are it's never

0:49:14going to have the

0:49:15priority with an apple and the

0:49:17engineering priority to devote a lot of

0:49:20engineering time to optimizing the OS

0:49:22for this machine that sells to one

0:49:24percent of the user base like they're

0:49:25never going to do that so it can't

0:49:28depend on weird like you know edge case

0:49:31technologies like opencl has turned out

0:49:34to be you know if it can handle it well

0:49:37that's one thing but that can't be the

0:49:38main focus of the machine if they did do

0:49:40a lot of OS changes to support the dual

0:49:43GPUs because remember one of them was

0:49:44like oh you can you could address them

0:49:45individually and use one for compute and

0:49:47one for graphics and they have that

0:49:48whole demo of the 3d application that

0:49:50Pixar was using so they they actually

0:49:52added OSAP eyes to make it so that

0:49:55people could write programs to take

0:49:56advantage of this machine but the only

0:49:58way anybody like any pro app vendor is

0:50:01going to change their program to take

0:50:04advantage of this new fancy hardware is

0:50:07if doing so gives them some kind of

0:50:09advantage like okay well this is weird

0:50:11hardware and we you know but Apple gives

0:50:14us API is and we can address these two

0:50:16GPUs and control them and do interesting

0:50:18things if we do this if we make this big

0:50:20investment and rejigger our application

0:50:22and use these new ApS what is the payoff

0:50:24and if the payoff is performance that

0:50:26still doesn't match a plain old windows

0:50:29pc with a big stonking single GPU in it

0:50:32well why would we do that why would we

0:50:34spend all this time we're rewriting our

0:50:36thing to get worse performance that we

0:50:38get if we just leave our application

0:50:39exactly the way it is and get you know a

0:50:42geforce 1080 whatever the the

0:50:45top-of-the-line thing was at the time

0:50:47why don't you why would we bother doing

0:50:49it so people didn't rewrite their

0:50:51programs even though there were api's

0:50:52and those api's themselves didn't get

0:50:55expanded and supported and everything

0:50:57because there was no one writing for

0:50:58them so it was it was an ecosystem that

0:51:00never materialized for hardware that was

0:51:02never good enough to justify the

0:51:04investment and very quickly became

0:51:06embarrassingly not good enough as as you

0:51:08mentioned as every other standard and

0:51:11peripheral and the capability just

0:51:13passed it by on even on Apple's on in

0:51:15frequently updated machines right and

0:51:17then and they also had execution flaws

0:51:19even with this one model like the GP

0:51:22like you know they're talking now about

0:51:24how the thermals prevented them from

0:51:26updating it very very well

0:51:28the thermals were a problem then to it

0:51:30this machine anybody who's ever owned

0:51:32one of these or especially anybody who's

0:51:34had to manage more than one of them like

0:51:35certain you know developer studios or

0:51:37visual effects places that have had

0:51:39multiple 2013 Mac Pro's the GPUs die all

0:51:42the time Apple's doing tons of warranty

0:51:45replacements on those the only reason it

0:51:47hasn't become like a big known scandal

0:51:49or thing is because this is a you know

0:51:51relatively unpopular product so not a

0:51:53lot of people have them but anyone who

0:51:55does have it knows that there's tons of

0:51:57GPU overheating problems and they die

0:51:59all the time and on top of that to make

0:52:03a GPU focused machine that's that takes

0:52:07us huge bet on GPUs be in the future and

0:52:09then not updating it for three years

0:52:11like GPUs change like every nine months

0:52:13like it's it's a pretty fast moving part

0:52:16of the hardware development so it was a

0:52:19huge design flaw even then to design

0:52:23something that could barely cool the

0:52:25GPUs it had and then with not only

0:52:27apparently no Headroom to cool future

0:52:29ones but also to not update this machine

0:52:32at all for three and a half years at

0:52:34least and prop what's probably going to

0:52:35end up being four and a half to five

0:52:37that's a massive just error in just how

0:52:41it was an execution flaw simple as that

0:52:43I will say though like as much as I bag

0:52:47in this machine like redesigning the

0:52:50tower like the cheese grater typical pc

0:52:53tower I mean it was more than tip it was

0:52:54a really good one but redesigning the

0:52:57tower in 2013 was a good idea and it

0:53:01remains a good idea today they should

0:53:03not just put new components in the old

0:53:06cheese grater and ship that as the new

0:53:08thing because there's lots of like old

0:53:11baggage that is no longer necessary in

0:53:14the pc tower so doing a design doing a

0:53:17redesign is the right move it diggers

0:53:20did the bitches didn't to the right one

0:53:22like they chose a battery design they

0:53:23went the wrong direction when they

0:53:25admitted that yeah those like my blog

0:53:27post back in before the new mac pro 2013

0:53:29begging for them to make a new Mac Pro

0:53:32the case for new Mac Pro successor like

0:53:35everything you said about the the trash

0:53:37can I agree with and you know

0:53:38was kind of you know you could have

0:53:41predicted these mistakes at the time

0:53:42because it didn't suit our needs but

0:53:43like well maybe there's other audiences

0:53:44for them it could have worked out but

0:53:46either way to where they worked out it

0:53:47didn't they made mistakes they were

0:53:48there were a bad time with 5k displays

0:53:50in the USBC and Thunderbolt 3 you can't

0:53:53say that we make fun of the can innovate

0:53:56anymore my ass the phil schiller thing

0:53:58but that was mostly because they failed

0:54:00to update it this was like an innovative

0:54:03machine they tried something new and

0:54:06bold and daring and they were trying to

0:54:08make the best mac that there could be it

0:54:12was so different from any other max if

0:54:14they're ever had been before and there

0:54:17have been since so different in so many

0:54:19ways that I give them full marks for

0:54:21doing what I asked him to do which is

0:54:24try to do your best turns out this

0:54:26wasn't a good idea but you can't say

0:54:28they didn't try you can't say like and

0:54:29again I would have you know been more

0:54:31disappointed to say oh here's another

0:54:32cheese grater right like because that's

0:54:34not that's not really trying this is

0:54:36kind of business as usual status quo

0:54:38which is better than nothing but I I do

0:54:42give them full marks for for introducing

0:54:45it which is why even though I didn't buy

0:54:46one I was very happy that it existed I

0:54:48was pinning my hopes on okay they're

0:54:50either going to keep updating this and

0:54:51I'll buy the one that can drive the

0:54:52retina display remember those days when

0:54:53I was talking about that and same thing

0:54:55for this new one in the same way it's

0:54:57like well they could make some kind of

0:54:58rectangular box and sell it and they

0:55:01could get that out sooner I'm willing to

0:55:03wait for them to try something

0:55:04innovative they just need to make a

0:55:07different set of trade-offs with this

0:55:08design building on what they've learned

0:55:10but I totally like the idea of them

0:55:12because if they're just going to make a

0:55:13box i know people want them to do that

0:55:15just make me like a rectangular pc that

0:55:18I can run mac OS on which i'm sure some

0:55:20people would like but I I want more than

0:55:23that from Apple I mean even even the

0:55:24cheese grater is like you said market

0:55:26it's not just at our case it is a really

0:55:28cool really good really interesting

0:55:30tower case that has many innovations

0:55:32inside and out and turned out to be a

0:55:35good design that they kept for a long

0:55:36time just just do that again Apple

0:55:39that's a hard just be successful all the

0:55:40time yeah well liked and I think you

0:55:43know looking back you as you said like

0:55:45they did something you know as federighi

0:55:47sevens interview he said we wanted to do

0:55:48something bold and different with the

0:55:502013 one and he said it's good for

0:55:52but it does not address the full range

0:55:54of Mac Pro customers and I think this is

0:55:56the nut right here like Apple is really

0:56:00good at being bold and different and

0:56:02they pride themselves on that they they

0:56:05really try to do that with with muck

0:56:08with much of what they do the problem is

0:56:10that if you only make bold and different

0:56:13product line joyce's then the overall

0:56:16product line will suffer because you

0:56:18need general-purpose products to fill

0:56:21the gaps and satisfy the most needs and

0:56:24the Mac Pro the hole the purpose of this

0:56:26machine is to serve a bunch of those

0:56:29edge cases and you can't just make one

0:56:32super focused design like this you know

0:56:34one cpu 2 pro GPUs no slots nothing else

0:56:37like you can't do that kind of like bold

0:56:40and different design for this particular

0:56:42product line because all of the

0:56:43different edge cases that the Mac Pro

0:56:45needs to satisfy are all different from

0:56:47each other so no single narrow design

0:56:50like this can satisfy them the old Mac

0:56:52Pro cheese grater could be configured in

0:56:54completely different ways for depending

0:56:57on what the customer needed and there

0:56:59was a huge range of what that could do

0:57:01and that's the kind of flexibility this

0:57:03product line needs Mac Pro buyers they

0:57:06don't need cool and bold and different

0:57:09they need versatile powerful and kept up

0:57:12to date and it can be innovative to like

0:57:14like the Yosemite case before Yosemite

0:57:17was the name of an operating system it

0:57:19was a code name for a tower case

0:57:21designed by Apple that was like a tower

0:57:23it's like a vertical rectangular solid

0:57:25like but Apple did its thing hey ours

0:57:27has handles on all four corners NRS has

0:57:29a side panel that folds down and the

0:57:31motherboard was on the side panel at

0:57:33that point look how easy it is to open

0:57:34this thing up and here's the ram mandir

0:57:35is the GPU and you can change your hard

0:57:37drives and they use that design for two

0:57:40generations the g3 in the g4 and well

0:57:42more if you can't like your drive door

0:57:44and the wind tunnels and all the other

0:57:46stuff and then came the cheese grater

0:57:47with the power mac g5 still four handles

0:57:50but a different design aluminum and look

0:57:52how easy it is to slide the hard drives

0:57:54in and out and there's a little panel

0:57:55that comes off the side and look how

0:57:56much room we have her fans and the

0:57:58computer-controlled fans and all those

0:57:59other stuff like both of those designs

0:58:01were innovative and interesting but like

0:58:03marker was saying they were they could

0:58:05be there were

0:58:06modular they could be configured to

0:58:08different needs you could choose what

0:58:10you wanted to put in them and make the

0:58:11computer that you needed if instead they

0:58:14had made an innovative like the g4 cube

0:58:16is a good example like the g4 cube is

0:58:18basically a trash can before its time

0:58:19here's one computer with one specific

0:58:21set of trade-offs and you can't change

0:58:23those trade-offs at all and if it

0:58:24doesn't suit your needs you're out of

0:58:26luck the g4 cube did not do well in the

0:58:29market despite being a cool cute little

0:58:31computer to it you know to address the

0:58:34pro market you either need to have a

0:58:36bunch of different models each of which

0:58:38satisfies a need or some kind of system

0:58:40that you can configure to serve

0:58:42different people's needs via they can

0:58:44configure themselves with their party

0:58:45things that they can configure on your

0:58:46store by picking from pop-up menus how

0:58:49much storage how many drives how many

0:58:50GPUs what kind of GPUs how much memory

0:58:52all those things and I think too like

0:58:55it's important to recognize when they

0:58:59were designing the trash can in 2013 I

0:59:01don't think they necessarily forgot what

0:59:04pros need I think they were they were

0:59:07swayed by both a bit of hubris and also

0:59:11the times you know back then the reason

0:59:13why Phil Schiller said can't innovate

0:59:16anymore my ass and the reason that got a

0:59:18huge applause besides the fact that

0:59:20hilarious hearing that from him is that

0:59:22at the time there was a huge

0:59:24overwhelming press and analyst narrative

0:59:27of Apple not being able to innovate

0:59:29anymore and that Samsung was doing all

0:59:32the innovation this was a huge thing in

0:59:342013 that Samsung was taking the

0:59:36innovation crown and of course you know

0:59:38we were all trying to get like what do

0:59:39they mean by innovation exactly but like

0:59:40that was a massive thing that everybody

0:59:43was saying about Apple the press the

0:59:45stock people every thought every one

0:59:46saying Apple can't innovate anymore

0:59:48Samsung's innovating and it turned out

0:59:50that all that was was big phones because

0:59:52Apple didn't have to pick folks yet that

0:59:54turns out all Appling need to do to it

0:59:56to out-innovate samsung was to make the

0:59:58same size phone to sams nice

0:59:58same size phone to sams nice

1:00:00but that pretty much solve that problem

1:00:02for them but I feel like that narrative

1:00:05really got to them and that helped sway

1:00:07their decision into taking a much bigger

1:00:10risk with this product than they should

1:00:11have I think apple and maybe this has

1:00:14changed now I'm not sure it has Apple

1:00:17needs to be confident enough in itself

1:00:19to release boring products sometimes

1:00:22when that's actually what certain types

1:00:24of customers need and the Mac Pro is the

1:00:27biggest example of that like they can

1:00:29totally do not only can they they should

1:00:31probably do a relatively boring line of

1:00:35mac pros because that's like what comes

1:00:38along with boringness is what pros need

1:00:42yeah I I'm struggling because I it's so

1:00:47clear to me how right you are in

1:00:49retrospect but if your Apple and you're

1:00:52looking at what's coming in 2013 which

1:00:55here again I 2013 feels like forever ago

1:00:58and that's when this thing was that was

1:00:59released oh my god this is so bad but

1:01:01anyway when you're looking at the future

1:01:03in 2013 and you're looking at like

1:01:05opencl and all these different options

1:01:07it makes sense to me to bet that maybe

1:01:11not at the house that's probably a

1:01:12little aggressive but bet big on opencl

1:01:16in and say you know what this is

1:01:17probably the future and we're going to

1:01:20give you the best possible machine that

1:01:22will be as fast as it possibly can for

1:01:25that future that is so obviously coming

1:01:27unfortunately the future never came but

1:01:30city is sitting where Apple presumably

1:01:33was sitting in 2013 I I think it does

1:01:37make sense to do what they did but

1:01:40unequivocally looking at it in hindsight

1:01:42you are absolutely correct that the

1:01:44boring machine was the writer machine

1:01:46and maybe the cleverness is what John

1:01:48was talking about and having a

1:01:49motherboard on the door or whatever or

1:01:51what have you are making it easily

1:01:52upgradable or whatever the case may be

1:01:55but I don't think we could necessarily

1:01:57fault Apple for the way they were

1:01:59thinking in 2013 given the facts they

1:02:01had in front of them well I think you

1:02:04can fault them the saying like if they

1:02:05thought if they thought opencl was the

1:02:07future wouldn't they have to release a

1:02:09machine that the next year they could

1:02:11make it run opencl faster and the year

1:02:13can make it run opencl faster even if

1:02:16they had kind of an idea of what the GPU

1:02:19compute future was going to be like they

1:02:20didn't have doesn't seem like they had a

1:02:21roadmap of like it when this future

1:02:24arrives we should be poised to make the

1:02:27the fastest thing that you can run

1:02:29opencl on year after year they weren't

1:02:30even poised to do that even if it hadn t

1:02:32realized they were not like his the bent

1:02:34like by the time this machine step like

1:02:36I said you can get a single GPU pc that

1:02:39did beat it right in the things that

1:02:41people cared about right and people

1:02:43didn't have to rewrite their

1:02:44applications and they seemed to have no

1:02:46plan I mean it's a surprise to me

1:02:47because this type of chimney design

1:02:49where you pull in cool air from the

1:02:50bottom and exhaust the hot air at the

1:02:51top with it with a really big fan that

1:02:53goes slowly I would think that would

1:02:56have more capacity than it apparently

1:02:58has so we're taking what they send a

1:02:59face value that like bad that you know

1:03:02thermal problems with it and they

1:03:03couldn't get new stuff in it that's

1:03:04that's pretty darn bad and I have a hard

1:03:07time envisioning any good plan for the

1:03:10Mac Pro that does not include the

1:03:12ability to make it faster next year and

1:03:13faster the year after that and fast of

1:03:15the year after that in that in an

1:03:16incremental way because again the whole

1:03:17point of this product is to be the

1:03:19fastest thing out there and I know what

1:03:21Mark was saying with the boring updates

1:03:23I wouldn't use that word to characterize

1:03:24it because as far as I'm concerned

1:03:25having the best performance in the

1:03:28product line is not boring even if it's

1:03:30not in a in a spiral-shaped underwater

1:03:33case right you know or whatever you want

1:03:35to say is like oh we can put it in a

1:03:37sphere and it rolls around your desk

1:03:38like whatever if every year it gets

1:03:41faster and faster speed is not boring

1:03:43capability is not boring like you know

1:03:46my renders are compiled sucks X amount

1:03:48of time if i buy a new one in a year or

1:03:50two years they should take x divided by

1:03:53some number amount of time it's

1:03:55something or greater than one all right

1:03:57i want i want to see things happen

1:03:59faster and that's not boring i think

1:04:01what you gettin of the boring is like be

1:04:03innovative but don't don't try to change

1:04:07things for the sake of changing them and

1:04:08i think what they tried to do is kind of

1:04:10what they try to do with a Final Cut Pro

1:04:1110 which is let's not be constrained by

1:04:14what defines pro computers today it

1:04:18could be that we are holding onto

1:04:19baggage that is not actually necessary

1:04:20anymore if we start basically from a

1:04:23clean slate and say what do our Pro

1:04:26users really need what can we

1:04:27eliminate what is just there because

1:04:29like Oh everyone expects to have floppy

1:04:31drives and parallel ports and whatever

1:04:33like what could if we drop things and

1:04:35just leave the essence can we get it a

1:04:38simplification and they dropped too many

1:04:41things on the wrong things right if they

1:04:45had found the correct essence and drop

1:04:48some things but left others like you

1:04:50know that they could have come up with a

1:04:51better balance and it still could have

1:04:53been a cylinder case for all we know and

1:04:54it still could have had no internal

1:04:56store like some of the bets i think

1:04:57we're reasonable like no 3.5 inch

1:04:59internal bays no optical drive obviously

1:05:02like all those thing all those things

1:05:03that they removed from the mac pro as

1:05:05compared to the cheese grater those were

1:05:07correct things to drought it's like you

1:05:09don't have to keep having three and a

1:05:11quarter inch drive bays you don't have

1:05:12to have any kind of drive bays you can

1:05:13you know we see the future as being PCI

1:05:15Express SSDs or you know obtain whatever

1:05:18things from Intel that is an example of

1:05:22a simplification that is it possible if

1:05:24you say super boring which is basically

1:05:26like well Pro computers got to have a

1:05:27bunch of PCI slots and a bunch of 3.5

1:05:29inch bays and a bunch of five and a

1:05:30quarter you'll never you'll never make

1:05:32anything interesting there it's just

1:05:33that they dropped other things as well

1:05:35and it didn't work out and I think to to

1:05:39try to make different trade-offs we can

1:05:41start talking about what we think a new

1:05:44mac pro as vaguely sketched by apple's

1:05:48words in this meeting would look like

1:05:50your sponsor this week by indochino go

1:05:55to indochino calm and use promo code ATP

1:05:57to get a premium suit custom fit for you

1:06:00for just 389 with free shipping

1:06:02indochino makes it easy to get a

1:06:04perfectly tailored suit and an

1:06:06incredible price you choose from

1:06:09hundreds of top quality fabrics and you

1:06:11personalize your suit just the way you

1:06:13want you can get custom linings custom

1:06:15lapel styles all sorts of cool options

1:06:17they have their inscriptions on and

1:06:18whether it's for your work a wedding or

1:06:21another special occasion you will be

1:06:22shocked how good a custom design suit

1:06:26can fit you indochino suited up hundreds

1:06:29of thousands of men and now the largest

1:06:30made-to-measure menswear brand in the

1:06:32world so here's how this works you visit

1:06:35a showroom they actually have real-life

1:06:36stores or you shop online at indochino

1:06:39calm

1:06:40take your fabric you can shoot your

1:06:42customizations and then you measure

1:06:44yourself and they have these great

1:06:45videos to show you how to measure

1:06:47yourself you submit your measurements

1:06:49and then you place your order and you

1:06:51just wait for it arrived in just a few

1:06:53weeks and this week you get an

1:06:55incredible deal get any premium

1:06:57indochino suit for just 389 @ indochino

1:07:00calm entering code ATP at checkout this

1:07:04is fifty percent off the regular price

1:07:06this is for a made-to-measure premium

1:07:09suit it's a cook a custom suit made just

1:07:11for you at that price I don't think you

1:07:13can find anywhere else and shipping is

1:07:15free once again it's indochino calm and

1:07:18you can get a premium class suit at

1:07:21anoche no for just 389 by using code ATP

1:07:25at checkout that's an incredible deal

1:07:27for a suit that will fit you better than

1:07:28anything off the rack ever could once

1:07:31again indochino calm thank you very much

1:07:33to indochino for sponsoring our show I

1:07:35wanted to talk a little bit about the

1:07:40imac because they had some interesting

1:07:42things to say about that too you know to

1:07:44me what's what was probably one of the

1:07:48most interesting parts of this briefing

1:07:50is that it sounds like they're not

1:07:52working on one Mac Pro that they're

1:07:55working on two different pro desktops

1:07:57one of them is new like higher-end

1:08:01configurations of the iMac which is

1:08:03probably why they seem to have

1:08:05apparently cancelled the imac revision

1:08:08that's been like mostly done and you

1:08:10know like the USBC kb leg revision it

1:08:12seems like they're now just going to

1:08:13hold that maybe until the fall whenever

1:08:16because what they said was that they're

1:08:17going to be new like more pro

1:08:20configurations of the imac this year so

1:08:23i'm guessing like that maybe gets

1:08:25announced emergency but probably the

1:08:27fall and that probably you know that

1:08:29whatever I max we're going to come out

1:08:30this this past you know winter or spring

1:08:33have probably been delayed to just make

1:08:36one big update then which I'm not sure

1:08:38that's necessarily the right move but I

1:08:39see you know that is typical of Apple so

1:08:40that's possible right but anyway I

1:08:42wanted to kind of get an idea of if

1:08:46they're going to do like a pro pro

1:08:48configurations of the imac and also do a

1:08:51modular Mac Pro and we'll talk

1:08:54what that might mean also what would the

1:08:57imac configurations actually be like so

1:09:00I was thinking like you know they could

1:09:01put Zeon's in there for to get higher

1:09:03core counts and more pci lanes and

1:09:06everything but i figured that might

1:09:07become like a Mac Pro only thing so

1:09:10maybe the Intel Extreme series like we'd

1:09:11like we kept we keep it and told about

1:09:13like the x99 boards and the extreme

1:09:16edition processors that have like 6 to

1:09:1710 cores they're basically Zeon's but

1:09:21you know not in not an official name and

1:09:23so they don't have ECC ram support they

1:09:26don't have quite as high of course as

1:09:28Zeon's do and they don't usually max how

1:09:30to quite as high o clock speeds but that

1:09:33would be one way like if they want to

1:09:35keep these two different things this you

1:09:38know they have the regular iMac which

1:09:39the regular imac already has usually the

1:09:42fastest like typical desktop processors

1:09:45that Intel sells GPUs they have more

1:09:48headroom GPUs they usually use like a

1:09:50like a low-power desktop GPU because the

1:09:53big honkin like you know if the 1080

1:09:55kind of equivalents like the big like

1:09:57things with like the big green plastic

1:09:59fans from the overclockers like those

1:10:02GPUs don't fit in the imac enclosure

1:10:04like space or heat wise so if they make

1:10:07the enclosure you know thicker and have

1:10:10bigger heat capacity maybe you know

1:10:13larger slow our fans with massive heat

1:10:16sinks somehow if they do that kind of

1:10:18thing then they could increase the

1:10:21capacity enough to maybe have at least

1:10:24mid-range desktop-class GPUs and that

1:10:27could also add more but again like how

1:10:30high would that actually be able to go

1:10:32before it questions the need for the Mac

1:10:35Pro tower right so I'm guessing you know

1:10:37it would probably be obviously limited

1:10:39to just one GPU but maybe it maybe again

1:10:42like limited to like like the PC mid

1:10:44rings at the kind of pc GPUs you can

1:10:45usually get for like 200 bucks like that

1:10:47kind of class you know and so and maybe

1:10:50it might have a higher ram ceiling you

1:10:53know cuz right now the imac is 32 maybe

1:10:56the imac pro in finger quotes goes to 64

1:10:59and the macro goes to 128 you know stuff

1:11:01stuff like that the imac pro probably

1:11:04wouldn't have all of the Thunderbolt

1:11:06bandwidth and

1:11:07like you know the Mac Pro has like three

1:11:09Thunderbolt buses you know you know the

1:11:12new one probably have a different

1:11:13arrangement but suffice to say that they

1:11:15would max out however many pci express

1:11:17lanes and Thunderbolt however much

1:11:19Thunderbolt BAM what they could get the

1:11:21mac pro would have the most and the imac

1:11:23pro would probably have closer to a

1:11:24consumer level of them and you know

1:11:27maybe and maybe die mac pro would retain

1:11:30older ports for longer maybe like if

1:11:32they drop ethernet say or the SD card or

1:11:35whatever i think he turns a better

1:11:37example if they drop ethernet off the

1:11:38imac in the consumer line maybe they

1:11:41keep it in the imac proline or if they

1:11:43drop upgradable ram out of the consumer

1:11:45line maybe that gets kept in the

1:11:46purloined so like I think there are ways

1:11:48they can do the imac pro that doesn't

1:11:51interfere with the mac pro but not only

1:11:55am I very surprised that they're doing

1:11:58to but I'm very excited to see what the

1:12:00imac pro is because that might end up

1:12:02being the computer threat for me because

1:12:04i actually don't need a lot of what the

1:12:05Mac Pro offers I just I really just need

1:12:07the massive CPU power nap being said as

1:12:10I stare at my 5k imac with the horrible

1:12:13image retention but i i'm starting to

1:12:15wonder maybe maybe i would still go that

1:12:17way anyway the big question with the

1:12:20imac pro for me is was this product plan

1:12:24before or after they decided they're

1:12:26doing the new mac pro because that

1:12:28really dictates the design because if i

1:12:29think about it in this in the new world

1:12:31where they're saying hey we're going to

1:12:32have a new modular mac pro i think oh

1:12:34well then this imac with stuff for pro

1:12:37people just going to be like a little

1:12:40bit faster internal SSD you know

1:12:43Thunderbolt 3 a little bit faster GPU a

1:12:47little bit faster cpu all the same

1:12:49classes just like better components all

1:12:51around a new high-end what we used to

1:12:53call a plain old speed bump right but if

1:12:57this new imac was planned and you know

1:13:00it because this new i like is coming

1:13:02this year right so this is not like a

1:13:03distant thing it's coming this year if

1:13:05this new imac had been planned at a time

1:13:07when apple's like we're not doing the

1:13:09mac pro anymore and this was going to be

1:13:12their replacement to satisfy everybody

1:13:13then i start saying well maybe they

1:13:16could put izzy on it you know maybe they

1:13:18could put a slightly higher end

1:13:21all the things that you said like my

1:13:22news x99 series and use a desktop class

1:13:25GP like that's the only reason I think

1:13:28we would get that and that machine I

1:13:29think makes less sense for Apple to

1:13:31invest in in in in a situation where

1:13:34they really are making new Mac Pro

1:13:35because who in the world would buy that

1:13:37when they have the option to buy a new

1:13:39modular Mac Pro like if you need that

1:13:41stuff if you feel like you need tons of

1:13:42cores and you need a faster GPU and

1:13:45stuff like why wouldn't you go with the

1:13:46modular one it's it's so much better you

1:13:48know because then if your monitor does

1:13:49have image retention you can just you

1:13:50know ship the monitor back or get a

1:13:51different monitors that have chuck in

1:13:53the whole machine like all in one is not

1:13:55pro friendly in terms of how to

1:13:57configure a system to your specific

1:13:59needs right so really this machine

1:14:03depending on when it was when it was

1:14:07created and what Apple's planned for it

1:14:09was it could've not being this weird

1:14:11one-off where somehow by some miracle we

1:14:14get an imac with a Z on in but then that

1:14:16goes away as soon as the new Mac Pro

1:14:17comes because like what the hell's the

1:14:18point of an imac with Izzy on it when

1:14:20you've got the mac pro but for the most

1:14:22part I'm thinking that this new imac

1:14:25will basically be like the current

1:14:27top-of-the-line 5k imac but every

1:14:29component of it just be a little bit

1:14:30better and also a thunderbolt 3 and I

1:14:32think they they could sell that is

1:14:34saying this is this is a mat imac that

1:14:36has more appeal to Pro users than the

1:14:38previous one but to me it would just be

1:14:41a speed bump in the old style where we

1:14:44just took it for granted that every year

1:14:45the computers the Apple sells at the

1:14:48very least would have all their

1:14:49components upgraded to be Sully better

1:14:51and every couple of years they would get

1:14:52a new generation kind of my car so

1:14:54though they don't tend to get horsepower

1:14:56bumps but you know there's a generation

1:14:57of car and they improve a year after

1:14:59year after year and there's a new

1:15:00generation they used to happen with max

1:15:02to every year they would get a little

1:15:04bit faster we used to be disappointed in

1:15:06speed mouse remember that it was like oh

1:15:07they just did a speed bump word now we

1:15:09would kill for speed bumps please just

1:15:10make everything fine make every

1:15:12component a little bit faster make you

1:15:14know the just just make everything a

1:15:16little bit better and that will hold us

1:15:18over until next year and so they just

1:15:19don't update stuff at all anymore so

1:15:22yeah my for the imac I'm interested in

1:15:25what it will be as well but the promise

1:15:28of a real new Mac Pro is probably going

1:15:31to keep me away from

1:15:33no matter what a new real new Mac Pro

1:15:35with an apple monitor the only way i'll

1:15:37end up with that imac is if my computer

1:15:39dies i will get it i will get an imac

1:15:40and then i will get the new mac pro

1:15:42after that but if my little 2008 Mac Pro

1:15:45can hold out as I've said a joke about

1:15:47in many past shows if we can go for the

1:15:48full decade two thousand eight to twenty

1:15:51eighteen 10-year the service life of the

1:15:53computer if I can make it I will and if

1:15:57not I'll get an imac yeah I think I

1:16:00think you guys are right that and I'm an

1:16:02imac pro would just be more of whatever

1:16:05the top of the line a 5k imac is it

1:16:08would potentially have more ports I

1:16:10think Marco your example of ethernet is

1:16:12a phenomenal one because i think apple's

1:16:14itching to get rid of that for the most

1:16:16part but what Pro users the kind of

1:16:18person that would want to move humongous

1:16:20bits of data around then they already

1:16:22get rid of it I don't think my 5km I

1:16:23know all the imax still have it yeah the

1:16:26imax i think the mini still does too but

1:16:28who's who cares what the me I gotta go

1:16:30look I don't think one does continue

1:16:32talking I'll be back in a second John I

1:16:34of the most modern 5k imac I believe and

1:16:36it absolutely has anything it definitely

1:16:39still has if you want to check yeah I

1:16:41think would have more ports like Marco

1:16:43said potentially more ram the other

1:16:45thing I wanted to bring up though is and

1:16:48I don't know anything about this so

1:16:50maybe this is completely bananas but

1:16:52what about like VR so I know the VR is

1:16:55super intensive and in it requires just

1:16:58tremendous GPU power but is it feasible

1:17:01to have a 5k I Mac Pro that maybe does

1:17:05VR because vr is kind of that in between

1:17:07right where you need tremendous hardware

1:17:10but you don't necessarily need to go all

1:17:13the way to a mac pro for that sort of

1:17:15thing do you so maybe like maybe that's

1:17:17the target is you could use an oculus

1:17:20with an imac 5k or something i

1:17:22understand that at last i heard our key

1:17:23lock euless isn't supporting mac OS but

1:17:25just for the sake last example doesn't

1:17:27make any harbor this fast enough and

1:17:28right exactly I don't think you can fit

1:17:30a VR capable with current to be our

1:17:33standards we are capable GPU inside the

1:17:36imac right unless again unless unless

1:17:38this is the imac we're talking about was

1:17:41the one that was designed and planned

1:17:43and executed for an age without the mac

1:17:46pro because there's plenty of room back

1:17:47they're to add stuff to the back of that

1:17:48monitor they could put much more capable

1:17:50cooling like they have a lot of area

1:17:52especially between the 5k one there's a

1:17:54lot of area behind that monitor to put

1:17:55stuff you can spread it out far away

1:17:56from each other you can get lots of air

1:17:58flowing over things and you have tons of

1:18:00options but the only way such a thing

1:18:03would exist as if it was if it was

1:18:04something that was supposed to be in a

1:18:07lineup that doesn't include the mac pro

1:18:09and in which case I think it would be a

1:18:10one-off so you think you think apple's

1:18:13official message is if you ever wanted

1:18:15to do vr we have an answer for you and

1:18:17it's a five-thousand-dollar Mac Pro

1:18:19maybe I mean it depends like I think VR

1:18:21is you know right now in even in the pc

1:18:25world vr requires like the highest and

1:18:27hardware because it's really new and

1:18:29it's incredibly taxing on GPUs but you

1:18:33know everything that comes out that's

1:18:36like a new type of thing you can do with

1:18:39GPUs requires the best GPUs and if you

1:18:41look at like you know gaming and you

1:18:43know which is what VR is obviously

1:18:45involved with typically what happens is

1:18:48you know in a few years more pedestrian

1:18:51GPUs will be able to handle VR in the

1:18:54same way that today you can run a 3d

1:18:56game on a macbook pro but you may be

1:18:58just can't turn all the settings up so

1:19:00you can't have like all the super

1:19:01high-resolution super-high detail levels

1:19:03things like that so VR is going to be

1:19:05the same way like right now it requires

1:19:08these massive things but you know in two

1:19:11years you know because you know an

1:19:12apples patient you know it's like

1:19:13they're not going to design a whole new

1:19:15product line with this i Mac Pro that

1:19:17would be only be able to do VR with this

1:19:20massive thing on the back of it but then

1:19:22in two years that wouldn't be necessary

1:19:23anymore like so I don't basically I

1:19:26think that by the time the new Mac Pro

1:19:29comes out and we see you know the kind

1:19:32of stuff that you know what whatever the

1:19:34new Mac Pro balance with the pro iMac

1:19:36and the regular imac is I think by the

1:19:38time I'll get settled settled out vr

1:19:40will run fine on mid-range hardware and

1:19:43so this that question will be kind of

1:19:45moot now if you want like a really good

1:19:47VR set up you're probably going to want

1:19:49you know a high end gaming PC or the

1:19:52equivalent hardware in a mac pro but

1:19:54that's a different story we're still

1:19:55early in VR because there is so much

1:19:58Headroom Justin resolution like it's so

1:20:00grainy it's like

1:20:01not going back to doom where the pixels

1:20:02are the size of boulders but like you

1:20:05need a high-end rig just to get the

1:20:08current best VR you know goggle setups

1:20:11to show you something that looks

1:20:13incredibly grainy from the perspective

1:20:15of what you would expect from like a

1:20:17modern 2d regular PC game so there is a

1:20:21huge amount of capacity for new GPU

1:20:23power that will purely be absorbed by

1:20:25making things less ridiculously dotty

1:20:28and it doesn't mean like you can be able

1:20:30to do VR as it exists today on a

1:20:31mid-range system so at least it will be

1:20:33possible right so you're right about

1:20:34that like suddenly it's possible on a

1:20:36mid-range systems but the appetite for

1:20:38high-end bull will not go away for a

1:20:40long time just because you know at the

1:20:42very least you're doing twice the work

1:20:44for VR because you have two different

1:20:45images are two different eyes and it

1:20:46just goes up from there in terms of

1:20:48sensor fusion and response times for

1:20:50getting things to your eyeballs as fast

1:20:52as possible in a very very demanding

1:20:55environment where every millisecond

1:20:57counts so that's why I feel like you

1:20:58always need a high-end rig to rig to

1:21:00ring the best attitude see their

1:21:02high-end rig or something like PS we are

1:21:03where it is a purpose-built system that

1:21:05is not a general-purpose computer but

1:21:07that is designed specifically do VR and

1:21:09it has strict constraints on latency and

1:21:11frame rates and all that stuff we

1:21:14respond to this week by betterment

1:21:16investing made better go to better

1:21:18mint.com / ATP to learn more betterment

1:21:22is a smarter way to invest your money

1:21:23providing investing advice through smart

1:21:25technology automated investing and human

1:21:28advisors they've changed the entry by

1:21:30using the same strategies that financial

1:21:32advisors use with clients who have

1:21:34millions of dollars but now available to

1:21:36everyone including smart rebalancing of

1:21:39your investments global diversification

1:21:40tax efficient strategies and more

1:21:43veterans mission is to help you manage

1:21:45and grow your investments to build your

1:21:47financial future all with low fees so

1:21:50you lose less your money along the way

1:21:51if you do the math typical investment

1:21:53fees and costs really add up over time

1:21:56and veterans fees are a fraction of the

1:21:58cost of other financial services and

1:22:00betterment is so easy to use and

1:22:02pleasant they've won awards for their

1:22:04customer experience you can log into a

1:22:06demo account right on their site if

1:22:07you're curious to see it investing

1:22:09involves risk for a limited time so I'm

1:22:11to betterment and you may qualify for a

1:22:13free Canary home security system to help

1:22:15cure your home terms and conditions do

1:22:17apply learn more visit betterment calm /

1:22:20ATP that's betterment calm / ATP

1:22:23betterment investing made better so

1:22:29let's talk about the whole idea of what

1:22:32what is this modular design that they

1:22:35say they mentioned you know they were

1:22:37very clear on a number of number of

1:22:39times during this briefing that the new

1:22:41Mac Pro is coming out sometime after

1:22:44this year is going to have a quote

1:22:47modular design what does that mean one

1:22:51of the things that that people online

1:22:53have been thinking about and asking

1:22:56about and suggesting and even predicting

1:22:57for the future for years now is a kind

1:23:01of set of stacked components that would

1:23:03look kind of like Mac minis that you'd

1:23:05like stack up and like one would be your

1:23:07CPU module and one would be your GPU

1:23:09module and stuff like that right here's

1:23:11a storage one you kind of like build

1:23:13your own like assembled stack of parts

1:23:16each one of which is its own independent

1:23:18box that you could buy an upgrade and

1:23:20customize as needed the more I thought

1:23:22about this kind of thing the more I

1:23:24think that this is not only not what

1:23:27Apple probably has in mind but that it

1:23:29actually might be terrible and

1:23:31impractical in reality I can't believe

1:23:34you a ver entertaining it enough to

1:23:35discuss it at the show topic because all

1:23:37right people have been talking about

1:23:39this for year because it sounds like a

1:23:40cool sci-fi thing kind of in this is the

1:23:42modern incarnation of this the people

1:23:44may be more familiar with is like the

1:23:46project era whatever was those phones

1:23:48like we're going to make a cell phone

1:23:49rather having a bunch of modules that we

1:23:51snapped together and you can pick your

1:23:52camera you pick your CPU and your GPU

1:23:54and how much storage at how much battery

1:23:56and you'll just be able to build your

1:23:58phone from a bunch of these little

1:23:59modular capsules that snap together to

1:24:01build a phone it's like know that it's

1:24:05an interesting idea but the tech for

1:24:07that simply does not exist and so with

1:24:09the advent of number ball 3 everyone

1:24:11says what boy for the tech for that does

1:24:12exist everything you just described I

1:24:14can get a bunch of Mac many type things

1:24:15and they snap together with the cool

1:24:17Thunderball 3 thing and I have my GPU

1:24:18and my cpu my storage and it just snaps

1:24:20together but it's like what is that

1:24:23buying you versus just having a regular

1:24:26computer that you can pull things in

1:24:28out of like what what do you get by

1:24:30putting them in separate little nodules

1:24:32what does Apple get what do you get that

1:24:34like its it has always been a pipe dream

1:24:36and as the technology comes closer and

1:24:38it goes from pipe dream to potential

1:24:40reality then you have to say if we could

1:24:42feasibly do it what is that what do I

1:24:44get out of it and other than it being

1:24:46really cool and Future II i think we

1:24:49don't get enough out of it with today's

1:24:51technology for it to be worthwhile for

1:24:52able to even consider this approach well

1:24:55and even if you even think about like

1:24:56what it would actually be like if you

1:24:59think through like okay what would these

1:25:00things actually require how would this

1:25:03be sold how would it be supported so one

1:25:06of the number you know number one

1:25:07obviously is like how do they connect to

1:25:10each other like over what kind of

1:25:11interface do they talk to each other

1:25:13that is actually fast enough to do this

1:25:15stuff and if you're talking if you're

1:25:16putting like you know a disk on there

1:25:18thunderbolts fast enough but if you're

1:25:20putting a GPU or a cpu or sora you know

1:25:23things that really need lots and lots of

1:25:25bandwidth then you're gonna need you

1:25:28know either you're going to have to deal

1:25:29with the the limitations of Thunderbolt

1:25:31because Thunderbolt is PCI Express over

1:25:35a cable but it is not nearly as much

1:25:38bandwidth as the as the internal slots

1:25:41for like a GPU and desktop have and

1:25:44furthermore the standards for you know

1:25:48pci express itself and the Thunderbolt

1:25:50standards those change every few years

1:25:52so you'd have like the set of like pods

1:25:55I guess that's the word i'll use you'll

1:25:58have like the set of like component pods

1:25:59we're like they're all be different

1:26:01speeds if you mix and match over the

1:26:03years and if you're not going to mix

1:26:04match over the years there's no point in

1:26:05doing this not to mention like every one

1:26:08of those pods would need its own power

1:26:10and cooling it's silly maybe you could

1:26:14have some interface where the big honkin

1:26:17one on the bottom has a giant power

1:26:19supply and powers all the other ones you

1:26:22still need to put fans in all of them so

1:26:24that's going to be more noise more size

1:26:26they're all going to have their own

1:26:28metal casing and whatever hardware isn't

1:26:30involved with the inter connection

1:26:31between them and keeping them securely

1:26:34mounted so your GPU doesn't pop out of

1:26:35the socket the middle of using it if

1:26:37you'd nudge the desk or your cat walks

1:26:38over whatever like it is so challenging

1:26:41to bill

1:26:42system like that that works at all and

1:26:45it would end up these these pod things

1:26:47would end up being so cumbersome and

1:26:51expensive and loud and it would and then

1:26:55not to mention like imagine the support

1:26:57nightmare of like you know you think

1:27:00it's bad now when we have to know like

1:27:02well if you have a 13-inch MacBook Pro

1:27:05the two Thunderbolt ports on the right

1:27:06side are a little bit less bandwidth and

1:27:08those two Thunderbolt ports on the left

1:27:09side you think that's bad imagine a

1:27:13system where like well you can you can

1:27:15stack like three GPU module that only if

1:27:18you have this one high powered CPU

1:27:20module only from this year forward and

1:27:22not if you have a disk module between

1:27:23any of the two GPU modules like it would

1:27:25be crazy to support and it would be

1:27:27crazy as a user to figure out what would

1:27:29work with what else and whether you

1:27:31could do things and it would just be a

1:27:32nightmare and if there were be weird

1:27:34limits of like how many is something you

1:27:36could have what order they'd have to be

1:27:38stacked in what what the certain like

1:27:41main module would have to be the support

1:27:43that one's its it would be a mess so

1:27:45that entire idea of stacking these these

1:27:49external boxes that you could just

1:27:51combine into whatever you want I don't

1:27:53think that's ever going to happen it

1:27:54just in practice it just doesn't work I

1:27:57completely agree with you and I think

1:27:59that that that reading of modular is

1:28:02grossly over complicating what Apple's

1:28:06probably talking about yeah they're just

1:28:08going to sever monitor that's all I mean

1:28:09yeah that's it just separate monitor

1:28:11well and I think what they mean you know

1:28:14it turns out if you if you can describe

1:28:16the configurability of a pc tower that

1:28:19we've had for decades like that is

1:28:22modular like well I think what they mean

1:28:24exactly what I was gonna say yeah I

1:28:26think it just means like

1:28:26user-replaceable ram you maybe use a

1:28:28replaceable CPU maybe user replaceable

1:28:31graphics card it's basically a cheese

1:28:33grater mac pro but presumably done in a

1:28:36much more modern fashion but with the

1:28:38same amount of upgradeability and i

1:28:40would say it doesn't even necessarily

1:28:41need to be user replaceable on these

1:28:43parts I think what Apple means by

1:28:45modular is they can configure the same

1:28:49general case in different ways to suit

1:28:53different types of needs at purchase so

1:28:55the old

1:28:56macpro tower could be configured with

1:28:58the one or two CPUs you know three or

1:29:00six ram slots any number up to five I

1:29:04think of PCI Express cards two books

1:29:06have GPU or three of which could have

1:29:07GPU bandwidth I think four discs to

1:29:10opticals like there were all these

1:29:11different configurations and this one

1:29:13product that Apple you know this one

1:29:16case with this one power supply with

1:29:18this one set of supporting components

1:29:20could be configured by Apple in a

1:29:22modular fashion to solve a bunch of

1:29:25people's needs differently in one

1:29:27product that's what the pc tower gave

1:29:30Apple that's what the Mac Pro had until

1:29:322013 and so when they say modular I'm

1:29:35pretty sure that's the kind of thing

1:29:37they're describing as opposed to the

1:29:392013 which is with this model you get

1:29:42one cpu and two mid-range GPUs and

1:29:44that's it like there was it was one

1:29:46configuration you could make with that

1:29:47one so that is what i would expect by

1:29:50the word modular so I wouldn't get your

1:29:53hopes up anybody out there about the

1:29:55stacked components idea or even as as

1:29:58you were saying even like user

1:29:59replaceable stuff like you know I'm sure

1:30:01like the RAM probably will be storage

1:30:04maybe processors probably not i mean

1:30:08like cpu upgrades haven't really been a

1:30:12practical thing for quite some time

1:30:13because basically like sockets that the

1:30:17cpu plug into and like the motherboard

1:30:18chipsets and everything those changed so

1:30:21frequently that you can't really upgrade

1:30:24to a processor that is newer than the

1:30:26one you have you can you can move

1:30:28laterally like within the same family

1:30:30like if you bought the low-end one in

1:30:32the family and then two years later you

1:30:34can find the high-end one for sale

1:30:35somewhere you could put that in but the

1:30:37gain usually isn't that big the

1:30:38difference between the low and the high

1:30:39end within a single family like in a

1:30:41single year isn't that big it like five

1:30:43percent most of the time you could get

1:30:45more cores with the mac pro but again

1:30:47it's like it's a it's not as big of a

1:30:50game as just buying a new one would get

1:30:52you and doing a cpu upgrade on a modern

1:30:56computer especially a mac pro with these

1:30:57giant Zeon's in it involves so much like

1:31:00messing with delicate and very important

1:31:03thermal management things giant heat

1:31:05sinks moving the fans around dealing

1:31:07with these little fragile sockets and ow

1:31:09pins the bottom of them like it would be

1:31:11such a a crazy ordeal to put most people

1:31:14through I would not expect anybody today

1:31:17to consider the CPU in an average

1:31:20person's computer to be user replaceable

1:31:21so I definitely would not expect that to

1:31:24ever happen again with Apple that's you

1:31:26know it wouldn't surprise me to see

1:31:27pubis tower to the board probably not

1:31:29for component management reasons but

1:31:30wouldn't surprise me so I don't want to

1:31:32poo poo the the external stuff too much

1:31:34because you're just like Oh nothing's

1:31:36ever going to be external it's probably

1:31:37the right choice for the mac pro but

1:31:39Thunderbolt 3 does let you have things

1:31:44that were previously inside the case

1:31:46outside the case and so it is

1:31:49conceivable but it advisable that Apple

1:31:51could say hey we've solved the GPU

1:31:54upgrading problem by putting it in a

1:31:56separate box and already talked about

1:31:58the Thunder ball three does not have

1:32:00enough bandwidth to fully satisfy the

1:32:03very very very top end cards in a

1:32:05specific application where they need all

1:32:07the PCI Express lanes that they could

1:32:09have internally because the external

1:32:10does not have as many lanes as

1:32:12internally maybe you could gang tables

1:32:13together or something like that but they

1:32:16could do that but as you said another

1:32:19external power supply cooling like it's

1:32:21awkward the role of that is to make a

1:32:23laptop have a decent GPU if Apple was

1:32:27ever going to do something like that

1:32:28they would do it for a laptop because

1:32:30you can't put it inside the case

1:32:31wouldn't it be cool if you could put

1:32:33your laptop down and then connect it

1:32:35with Thunderbolt 32 GPU that is not the

1:32:39highest of the high end but it's so much

1:32:41faster than the GPU that's inside your

1:32:43case that it's a win so my hope my first

1:32:46hope with the modular thing which I

1:32:48interpreted this is the same as Casey

1:32:50which is basically I'm just saying it as

1:32:51a separate monitor I'm not even talking

1:32:53about the internals interesting if

1:32:54there's a box that doesn't have a

1:32:55monitor it and as a monitor connected to

1:32:57it that's my interpretation of modular

1:32:59that's not modular that's no different

1:33:00than the current mac pro right but it's

1:33:02not the imac it's that's what to say

1:33:04like we're going to make a new mac pro

1:33:05and that's their way of saying and it's

1:33:07not going to be an imac fro like that's

1:33:09how I read yeah at their statement the

1:33:11broadest level right so what what I hope

1:33:13my first hope is that they do not have

1:33:16an external GPU connected with

1:33:17Thunderbolt on the new mac pro because

1:33:19again the whole point of this computer

1:33:21is to be the absolute

1:33:23fastest thing that money can buy and if

1:33:26you connect the GPU with a thunderbolt

1:33:27three cable you are ready down behind

1:33:29all the people who have internal stuff

1:33:31forget about having a CPU connected

1:33:33separately from this and that you like

1:33:34just plain old taking on the GPU outside

1:33:37the box is a bad idea from packaging and

1:33:39it's a bad idea from performance

1:33:41perspective really that I think to me as

1:33:44we think through like what the new Mac

1:33:46Pro should be and what it's likely to be

1:33:48the question of whether the GPU is

1:33:51internal or external I think decides a

1:33:54lot of it for us and and I'm with you

1:33:56John I think once you think it through

1:33:58and think through the realities like no

1:34:01question that Thunderbolt is great and

1:34:02you can do external GPUs or thunderbolt

1:34:04now but and they actually if you look up

1:34:07like I know bare feet scom did a bunch

1:34:09of tests a few months back and it turned

1:34:12out that external GPUs for a lot of

1:34:14applications it didn't really involve

1:34:16tons of transfer to and from main memory

1:34:18they actually did pretty well in the

1:34:21external boxes yeah they can be just as

1:34:23fast if you're not constrained by

1:34:24bandwidth they're exactly as fast as if

1:34:26they were internal but again the whole

1:34:28point of this computer is to be the

1:34:30absolute fastest at everything and say

1:34:32you're doing some work load that does

1:34:33take advantage of all those lines now

1:34:35you're down some number of PCI Express

1:34:37lanes now you're down bandwidth why why

1:34:39take that hit for what advantages like

1:34:40oh well if its external we can upgrade

1:34:42easily well guess what if its internal

1:34:44you can upgrade easily through this

1:34:45amazing technology we call cards no but

1:34:49without that I was gonna get into the

1:34:50upgrade business but like like you like

1:34:52you both said Apple can upgrade it maybe

1:34:54they'll never let you upgrade it but

1:34:55next year they can swap out one of the

1:34:57GPUs and put in a new one and say here's

1:34:59the speed bump to mac pro now with new

1:35:02GPU options because we built them with

1:35:04enough cooling capacity that's that's

1:35:05what we're talking about here not even

1:35:07like oh you'll be able to take your GPU

1:35:09out and put in new and yourself which

1:35:10you probably will be able to do by

1:35:11taking PC GPUs and flashing them and all

1:35:13the other stuff but in terms of apple

1:35:15support and stuff that in internal

1:35:18versus external does not give Apple any

1:35:20more flexibility in terms of modularity

1:35:22right and I also like I like kind of

1:35:25like product wise i cannot see Apple

1:35:28shipping a portion of a computer that

1:35:31does not contain a GPU like their

1:35:34contain the internal one and they were

1:35:35just switching yep

1:35:37God like a computer these days needs a

1:35:41GPU to do anything all right like you're

1:35:42not gonna use me people that GPU sorry

1:35:44linux people or you know in bed of

1:35:45routers but you know for that I'm not

1:35:47talking about that and so they're not

1:35:49going to sell you like the the base Mac

1:35:51Pro box that doesn't have a GPU they're

1:35:55going to put one in there like that's

1:35:57not the way Apple would do things

1:35:58without that so if you're going to have

1:36:00a GPU that comes with the computer it

1:36:02might as well be internal like that they

1:36:04would make no sense to put external so I

1:36:05think once you have kind of realized

1:36:09like okay there's going to be an

1:36:10internal GPU and they've already talked

1:36:13about modularity and they've talked

1:36:14about upgrades easily in the future you

1:36:17know for them updates I should say

1:36:18updates easily in the future they're

1:36:21basically going towards a pc tower right

1:36:24so what other parts of a pc tower are

1:36:27still needed today you know we mentioned

1:36:29earlier they needed there's lots of

1:36:32things like you know optical drive bays

1:36:33that you don't really need anymore right

1:36:35upgradeable ram is an easy one that's

1:36:38going to be in there but we already have

1:36:39that you don't need to make a tower to

1:36:41have you know you have it in the imac

1:36:42you had it in laptops until very

1:36:43recently so we already have upgradeable

1:36:46ram you know you can just have a little

1:36:47time the door somewhere and have that be

1:36:49it so you don't need a tower for that

1:36:50you don't need optical bays you John you

1:36:55said earlier that you don't need three

1:36:57and a half inch bays I think you're

1:36:58probably right but I'm not a hundred

1:37:00percent confident in that because here's

1:37:03the thing when I first when I was first

1:37:04trying to think about this I was

1:37:05thinking you know you don't really need

1:37:07three and a half inch drive bays anymore

1:37:09because you can today you can get a four

1:37:12terabyte SSD all right and it's not it

1:37:14isn't even that ridiculously expensive

1:37:15and the two terabyte ones which is about

1:37:18as much space as most people need on the

1:37:19desktop see most of the time two

1:37:21terabyte SSDs are actually inexpensive

1:37:23now they're actually like only a few

1:37:25hundred hours and by the time this thing

1:37:27comes out in you know 2018 or beyond

1:37:30that'll be even cheaper and so at first

1:37:33I was like well you don't really need

1:37:34three and a half inch base because what

1:37:36if SSDs can be that cheap they can put a

1:37:39couple of like the stick kind and I'm

1:37:40not even saying like you know if you're

1:37:43a building computer to have a bunch SSDs

1:37:44in it you might use 2.5 inch drive base

1:37:47which is like a little one that SSDs and

1:37:48laptop hard drives use but

1:37:50that's starred skeuomorphism right there

1:37:52215 and jess's these come on right like

1:37:55you don't even need that anymore because

1:37:57not only are the SSDs a lot smaller but

1:37:59also like the interface standards like

1:38:01the the SATA standard PCI Express you're

1:38:04not coming through SATA that's not a

1:38:05spinning disk exactly so like you're

1:38:08going to have some kind of directly

1:38:09connected PCI Express SSDs and whether

1:38:11they're on little slots like a little

1:38:12like em to stick things whatever they

1:38:14are they're probably going to be on

1:38:16slots where I at least for Apple to

1:38:17surface and replace them when they die

1:38:18so and it would be nice to have more

1:38:21than one of those it'd be great to have

1:38:22to SSD slots maybe so you can configure

1:38:25it at purchase time probably with more

1:38:27stories that be awesome but I wouldn't

1:38:30expect more than that for ssds however

1:38:32you can kind of make an argument that

1:38:35you know if they would just put like one

1:38:37or two three and a half inch bays in

1:38:39there you know a ten terabyte hard disk

1:38:43is just four hundred bucks right now but

1:38:46it's just too slow it is really slow to

1:38:49be your to be your boot drive right but

1:38:51like put Pro users so many Pro users

1:38:54need to work with very large files that

1:38:57they almost all of them use these these

1:39:00you know incredibly expensive

1:39:02complicated loud giant external raid

1:39:05boxes and stuff if you would put two

1:39:07three and a half range Bay's inside this

1:39:09machine that could accommodate lots of

1:39:11that in a really nice way now I'm not

1:39:13saying necessarily that this is

1:39:14definitely one Apple should do and I'm

1:39:16almost certainly not saying that this is

1:39:18what they will do I bet they there's no

1:39:19I really want this any chance they would

1:39:21they would do this but a three and a

1:39:24half inch day inside something that's

1:39:26big enough to have a GPU on a slot is

1:39:28nothing it's like three and half days

1:39:30aren't that big right and so you know it

1:39:33wouldn't take a lot for Apple to fit

1:39:36this into whatever shape this is going

1:39:38to take that that being said though

1:39:39again I don't think they will I don't

1:39:41that's very realistic but I would go the

1:39:43reverse of what you said I would say

1:39:44that I don't think they should do it but

1:39:48i can actually envision them doing it

1:39:50because they really are having this this

1:39:52self reflective moment about the man

1:39:55marrow and atoning for mistakes i think

1:39:57they would actually entertain the idea

1:39:58which is you know inconceivable from the

1:40:01perspective of the trash can

1:40:03they would entertain this idea but I

1:40:04think they should not do it like my my

1:40:07vision of what if I had advised them

1:40:08both what they should make him but what

1:40:10I want which coincidentally are very

1:40:11close to the same thing did I think all

1:40:16they need to do to atone is all the

1:40:17things there he said they're going to do

1:40:18which is make it so that you can change

1:40:20the parts year-over-year to make them

1:40:21faster which necessitates a certain

1:40:24amount of cooling and power structure

1:40:25and honestly for the past since the

1:40:29power mac g5 the probe apple desktop

1:40:34line has you know Dave Johnny I've even

1:40:37said in his own intro video for the

1:40:38power mac g5 has been basically making a

1:40:42box to extract heat from components like

1:40:45that is modeled after a heat exchanger

1:40:47like that's why the cheese grater looks

1:40:49the way it does he actually talked about

1:40:50heat exchangers like you know up and up

1:40:52in a room or whatever take air one

1:40:54temperature in and extract heat from it

1:40:56and you know like that's what these

1:40:58boxes are all about the cheese grater is

1:41:00about that the the the trash can is

1:41:02about that it's a chimney right so

1:41:04megabox or doesn't to be a box make it

1:41:07make a case that can support the thermal

1:41:09load of all the parts that you could

1:41:11possibly put in it that means you have

1:41:12to support two really hot cpus maybe

1:41:15also two really hot GPUs or some

1:41:18combination thereof so you can upgrade

1:41:19them year-over-year you have to have

1:41:21excess capacity and one great thing

1:41:22about cheese grater is it has excess

1:41:24cooling capacity like it was made for

1:41:27chips on such an old process that we're

1:41:29so incredibly hot like I mean they made

1:41:31a water-cooled one at one point you know

1:41:33there was room for that in there there's

1:41:34so much you know you can cool almost

1:41:36anything in this box it is huge it has

1:41:38direct airflow from back to front you

1:41:40know works great you have plenty of room

1:41:42for different arrangement of fans not

1:41:43that I'm saying they're gonna make

1:41:44something that big but so make a box

1:41:45with adequate cooling and you know

1:41:48upgradable and the next thing I think

1:41:51that we need to do is get what you were

1:41:52getting at it's like what things can we

1:41:54remove obviously you need to have tons

1:41:55of ports all Thunder both free and all

1:41:57that other stuff you know high-speed

1:41:58Ethernet put 10 gig Ethernet on put two

1:42:01separate Ethernet buzzes like do

1:42:02everything you can use all those pci

1:42:03express lanes on the back of the thing

1:42:04and then for storage i think it would be

1:42:08the right thing to do to have more than

1:42:10one internal storage thingy more than

1:42:13one internal SSD because they are so

1:42:15small to be able to support not

1:42:173.5 inch drive for bulk storage again I

1:42:19think they might consider especially if

1:42:20they have a lot of room in the case

1:42:21because well for all the reasons you

1:42:23said but I think they should not do

1:42:24instead they should let me have three or

1:42:26four internal SSDs which they will

1:42:28charge an arm and a leg for but that I

1:42:31think gives all the advantage you're

1:42:32looking for which is like you know what

1:42:34if I don't want to have a giant raid

1:42:35array I just want to have adequate

1:42:36internal storage and SSDs you know you

1:42:40can only get them so big but if I could

1:42:42have 42 gig internal SSDs that are super

1:42:48fast because their internal right like

1:42:50that's what you want out of it I think

1:42:51there's plenty of room for one to two

1:42:54GPUs one to two CPUs and one two three

1:42:58or four very fast PCI Express SSD thinks

1:43:02and that to me looks like in whatever

1:43:04shape they put it a modern Mac Pro

1:43:07especially if you're saying those SSDs

1:43:08eventually be replaced with obtain you

1:43:10know three crosspoint whatever thing

1:43:13Intel's coming up with it's even faster

1:43:14still is that how you say that I don't

1:43:16know X point but you know anyway like

1:43:19that's the point of this machine very

1:43:21very fast storage and yeah external

1:43:23storage is great for bulk storage and

1:43:24everything but it'll never be as fast as

1:43:26internal storage and I don't want to

1:43:28just have oh my boot drives internal and

1:43:30everything else their work with his

1:43:31outside mistakes of the past don't make

1:43:34it so darn small that you only have room

1:43:35for one tiny little SS deep as the

1:43:37things are like the size of a thumb

1:43:38drive practically inside there they're

1:43:39so small you have plenty of room to put

1:43:42four of those inside there and no five

1:43:44and a quarter bay is no three and a

1:43:45quarter bay has no 2.5 inch base but you

1:43:48have room for that if they made that

1:43:49machine with that combination of things

1:43:51that would be upgradable by Apple and

1:43:54upgradable by industrious Packers and

1:43:56having more than one internal storage

1:43:59thingy all which are SuperDuper fast and

1:44:02that third parties could sell into I

1:44:04think that would cover all their needs

1:44:06and all the sins of the past while not

1:44:09looking backwards and while foregoing

1:44:12the 3.5 inch straight even though like

1:44:13using like this this could keep people

1:44:15from having to go for the big array even

1:44:17longer because I just I just think any

1:44:20spinning thing inside this case is a

1:44:22non-starter and is not forward-looking

1:44:24so I would not save space forward and I

1:44:26would use the space that I get from that

1:44:28to put that other stuff in that's a

1:44:30reasonable

1:44:31the only thing I will say though is that

1:44:32all of these super awesome PCI Express

1:44:36SSD systems need a good amount of PCI

1:44:40Express Lanes to make them fast and one

1:44:42of the issues with the current mac pro

1:44:44is that there actually aren't enough pci

1:44:46express lanes to really add anything

1:44:48more to it than what it has now and so

1:44:50in if you have the slots inside you know

1:44:54if you have like you know for you know

1:44:57em to wherever they are SSD slots then

1:45:00you have to have allocated the pci

1:45:02express lanes to assume that those are

1:45:05going to be in use and then you maybe

1:45:08you don't have enough to also have two

1:45:09high-power GPUs and the ethernet port

1:45:11and you know stuff like that's like

1:45:12that's what makes it a configurable

1:45:14system you could say hey if you want to

1:45:16have four really fast internalized it's

1:45:17easier to give up something you can't

1:45:18have two GPUs and like like in other

1:45:20words out be able to configure the

1:45:22machine or Apple just let Apple can

1:45:23figure not you like it's a built the

1:45:25water where you get to pick and choose

1:45:26everything but Apple can make different

1:45:27configurations here's the one for people

1:45:29who need a single modest cpu one really

1:45:33fast GPU and tons of fat storage and

1:45:35here's the people who need two of the

1:45:37fastest GPUs but storage is less of a

1:45:40concern and a moderate CPU like you're

1:45:42right that the lanes have limit but

1:45:43again the whole point is machine is

1:45:44stable they will choose the chips and

1:45:46chipsets from Intel they give the

1:45:48maximum number of PCI Express lanes that

1:45:50money can buy and then it's up to Apple

1:45:52to allocate those in arrangements that

1:45:55serve all the different needs that's

1:45:56fair I'm just saying one of those needs

1:45:58may be the one that says hey I want to

1:46:00have more than one internal storage

1:46:01thingy because if you don't you just

1:46:02then it's going to be like a sand over

1:46:0410 gig Ethernet like you can't datas got

1:46:06to get into the system somehow anyway

1:46:07like you're just going to go through a

1:46:09bridge chip and get into the hole you

1:46:10know like it's all it all ends up in the

1:46:13same place only is to get into the

1:46:14computer somehow so it's not as if by

1:46:16not having internal storage you suddenly

1:46:18get more bandwidth for storage you don't

1:46:20just you know it zips through a smaller

1:46:22hose outside the computer and then I'm

1:46:24curious to know your thoughts about

1:46:27whether we think they would actually use

1:46:30like standard PC slot GPU sized things

1:46:35or whether the GPUs would take it would

1:46:38be like a custom smaller Apple slot

1:46:40because to me that there's there's clear

1:46:42advantages to both I mean

1:46:45number one like if it's if it's a PC

1:46:47like standard one like the old Mac Pro

1:46:49use like the pc the GPUs in the in the

1:46:51cheese grater were really just pc GPUs

1:46:54like with apple firmware and custom

1:46:56apple driver support but they you know

1:46:57they weren't that different if you go

1:47:00that way then it's easier for Apple to

1:47:03keep updated and I really do think you

1:47:04know they they said you know a number of

1:47:07the apple deck use in that meeting

1:47:08seemed to say this over and over again

1:47:10which is they want the new Mac Pro to be

1:47:12something they can keep updated

1:47:14frequently and so if the GPUs are not

1:47:18something crazy custom that's you know

1:47:20just for Apple but if they're just

1:47:21regular slot GPUs then that could

1:47:25probably help them achieve that goal a

1:47:27lot on the other side of it though like

1:47:29if they do the slot GPUs then you know

1:47:32assuming that that there that there at

1:47:33all user replaceable then they're not

1:47:37going to be like integrated with the

1:47:38system's cooling thing so they're gonna

1:47:40have to have like you know 16 different

1:47:41fans in there because the GP is gonna

1:47:43have its own fan that by the way GPU

1:47:44fans die constantly so they're going to

1:47:46the GPUs can have its own little stupid

1:47:47fans gonna be loud and filled with dust

1:47:49and die all the time and then the rest

1:47:50of the system's going to have all these

1:47:51different heat sink all over the place

1:47:52like the old one did if they do

1:47:54something custom it would be harder to

1:47:57keep updated it would be more work

1:47:59they'd be more likely to neglect it like

1:48:01the current one but also like the

1:48:03current one they could integrate the

1:48:05GPUs cooling needs into some kind of

1:48:07larger combined cooling system and so

1:48:11and that would therefore probably be a

1:48:13nicer product as it would be quieter and

1:48:15it would be you know easier and more

1:48:16reliable to cool if they gave it enough

1:48:19capacity but let the current one so I

1:48:21can kind of see both sides of this if

1:48:24you make it the custom apple thing you

1:48:27have I think more flexibility to design

1:48:30a really cool new product books as we

1:48:32mentioned we're not actually sure that's

1:48:34what they should do but if you do it the

1:48:36pc way the more you think about like

1:48:39what's going to be in this new Mac Pro

1:48:41the more it seems to me that it's

1:48:44basically just going to be like the

1:48:47bottom half of the cheese grater like

1:48:49and maybe you know they can tweak

1:48:50certain things a little bit it within

1:48:52that design but if it has to accommodate

1:48:54regular PC graphics card slots and

1:48:56especially presumably would accommodate

1:48:59more than one and even if it maxed out

1:49:01at two unlike the old when I think you

1:49:03could put for low powered ones and but

1:49:04even if it maxed out at two big honkin

1:49:07GPUs just to design something that could

1:49:10accommodate that even if they didn't

1:49:13even even even if they didn't offer dual

1:49:14cpu options which I hope they do but I

1:49:17wouldn't bet on that that it very

1:49:21quickly becomes a pc tower you know and

1:49:23whether it's just like really short and

1:49:25doesn't have any drive base or not is a

1:49:26question but it doesn't really matter if

1:49:29it has to accommodate those standard GPU

1:49:31sizes and more than one of them it's

1:49:33going to basically look like a small pc

1:49:35tower right well the question is whether

1:49:37what is the what is the barrier to them

1:49:42updating the GPU it's like that if they

1:49:43went with a custom thing it would be

1:49:44harder for them to upgrade the GPU i I'm

1:49:46not entirely sure that's the case

1:49:49because updating the GPU like they can

1:49:53get the chip and like the chipset and

1:49:56the reference board that goes with it

1:49:57the packaging of what you're talking

1:49:59about is like pcs like they have all

1:50:01this cooling and then this is other fan

1:50:02that's facing a totally different

1:50:04direction like 90 degrees that the whole

1:50:05rest of the airflow that's cooling the

1:50:07car because they're sold module and

1:50:09usually and set his own slot on the back

1:50:11because it has that you know the double

1:50:12width slot cover thing to blow the air

1:50:15at the back and fill of dust it it is

1:50:17his own it is his own little cooling

1:50:19universe because it's modular right but

1:50:21I think Apple can can actually use like

1:50:25the work of the pc industry hey we have

1:50:27a new chip and you chip set a new

1:50:29reference design new card a new like the

1:50:31whole nine yards but not take their

1:50:34cooling solutions it would still be in

1:50:36some kind of slot but that apple would

1:50:38have their own cooling soldiers because

1:50:39again i don't think apple cares that you

1:50:41can upgrade it after that they're not

1:50:42going to sell new cards for it if you

1:50:44want to do some weird third party thing

1:50:45in hacking in like apples not supporting

1:50:47you it's not a thing that they've done

1:50:48in years and years so I I have to think

1:50:52that no matter what they even if they

1:50:53make a rectangle that they are going to

1:50:55do their own cooling solution because I

1:50:57think I think they're off the train of

1:50:58doing like a card with its own like you

1:51:01said terrible you can't tell or what we

1:51:03used to call them video coolers or that

1:51:06they had a weird name that people used

1:51:08to call them for the those horrible fans

1:51:10that would be attached to your GPU there

1:51:11would always be the first thing to die

1:51:12your system I think those days are gone

1:51:14for Apple even if they use an actual

1:51:18card you know full length or half like

1:51:20card like in a slot that looks like a

1:51:24plan I think they will still do custom

1:51:26cooling because I think to design a good

1:51:28case with thermal capacity the apples

1:51:32recent designs and even even on the Mac

1:51:34Pro's to some degree like they're all

1:51:35working towards let's design the airflow

1:51:39as one like one system for maximum

1:51:42capacity and takings other little island

1:51:44of cooling and chucking it in the middle

1:51:46I've got my own fan I'll put my intake

1:51:47here and like first of all they pull

1:51:49their intake from inside the case and

1:51:51that they do exhaust the outside through

1:51:52their back little slot thing right but

1:51:53like that is so so not how to

1:51:57efficiently design you know a system

1:52:00like an apple style system for cooling

1:52:02which is why that you know the the

1:52:04trashcan Mac Pro wasn't like that and

1:52:06why in from the g5 until today it has

1:52:09always been so incongruous to open up

1:52:10these machines and see the carefully

1:52:12planned air flows and channels and then

1:52:13see the cooler the video cooler sitting

1:52:16on its thing doing its thing often and

1:52:18the side of the world so it really

1:52:20depends I think on like does that will

1:52:22think that doing that doing custom

1:52:24cooling or even a custom form factor for

1:52:26the card is that too onerous that will

1:52:28actually stop them from updating gb was

1:52:30like oh we would love to upgrade the GP

1:52:31but we can't just take a new thing and

1:52:32slap it in there or will they say well

1:52:36you know we just need to have cooling

1:52:37enough cooling capacity and a way to

1:52:39design a cooling solution and we will

1:52:41take your board and your chip and plug

1:52:43it into a standard slot and then slaps

1:52:46on to it alien facehugger style will be

1:52:50our cooling solution that indicated that

1:52:51integrates with the whole rest of our

1:52:53cooling flow inside the case so if I had

1:52:55if I had to bet I would say they are

1:52:57going to go with custom cooling even if

1:52:59the cards themselves are standard now on

1:53:01the trash can the cards themselves are

1:53:03not standard they're not in standard

1:53:04slots they're you know they're they're

1:53:06on the outside of a weird triangle thing

1:53:08which is no arrangement than any pc

1:53:09motherboard they like that is custom

1:53:11head to toe and that didn't work out so

1:53:13I don't think they need to go that

1:53:14extreme I totally think they can have

1:53:16cards but I'm thinking the best bet is

1:53:18to go with custom cooling which means

1:53:19you will not be able to yank that thing

1:53:22out go by envia car off the shelf

1:53:26shove it in without doing some you know

1:53:28pretty fancy hardware hacking to get

1:53:31their giant cooler in there because I

1:53:33I'm just have trouble envisioning a box

1:53:35that would accommodate that that isn't

1:53:36literally the size of the cheese grater

1:53:38maybe with some parts of it lopped off

1:53:40the top and Bob because those cards are

1:53:41huge the coolers to come with a huge

1:53:43they're noisy it's just it's just gross

1:53:45so basically we we've basically

1:53:48redesigned the mac pro for apple in two

1:53:50hours yeah that was so easy what's

1:53:52taking them so long yes yeah so and I

1:53:55think you know to to to close out I

1:53:58think for now what I think they're going

1:54:00to do with this sort isn't they should

1:54:01do with this you know as you work

1:54:04through what this machine should be I

1:54:07think it's a lot more like the cheese

1:54:09grater than like the trashcan and even

1:54:11though the cheese grater was definitely

1:54:13outdated and should have significant

1:54:16editing done to it and significant

1:54:17change is done to it I think what we've

1:54:19ended up with is to make a good Mac Pro

1:54:22you need to go more towards that style

1:54:25whether it's just the bottom half of it

1:54:27lopped off or whether it's you know more

1:54:29design and this is not going to be a

1:54:33sexy high PR product for Johnny I've to

1:54:38feel really good about it's not it's

1:54:40because it's going to be a some form of

1:54:42pc tower of something you know it's

1:54:44going to be utilitarian more than it's

1:54:47going to be a fashion object but this if

1:54:50Apple has to do that this is the one Mac

1:54:53in the entire Mac lineup that must

1:54:56sacrifice appearance for functionality

1:54:59if that choice is necessary to make if

1:55:01they come to a point where they have to

1:55:04decide whether to make this thing cooler

1:55:07and prettier or whether to make it more

1:55:09utilitarian every other mac you could

1:55:12make a case maybe they should go to the

1:55:13direction not the mac pro it has to

1:55:16always go to functionality first because

1:55:19it has to satisfy the widest range of

1:55:23pro needs possible that are not

1:55:25satisfied by the imac the imac already

1:55:29has the high end nicely designed

1:55:31computer covered the imac is that it is

1:55:34it is great at that the mac pro must be

1:55:37utilitarian even if it comes to the

1:55:40expense of the coolest tiniest you know

1:55:42smallest thinnest thing they could make

1:55:44the more tower like that it gets the

1:55:47more the design they choose for it

1:55:49resembles a tower the more it offers

1:55:52above the imac and the easier and

1:55:54cheaper it is for Apple to keep it

1:55:56updated I just don't agree with the way

1:55:58you're characterizing that because I

1:55:59think the g3 g4 and power mac g5 cases

1:56:04were awesome looking they were fantastic

1:56:07they were the best looking things Apple

1:56:09had made I don't think they sacrificed

1:56:12the beauty and design of those cases at

1:56:14all and they also delivered amazing

1:56:17utility right so I get what you're

1:56:18saying like I think the way to phrase it

1:56:21would be more like what federighi said

1:56:23where we came up what we wanted which

1:56:25was like two GPUs and a cpu and then

1:56:28they they pulled in like they basically

1:56:30said how small and quiet and elegant a

1:56:34case can we get this exact amount of

1:56:35power like they pulled in the edges as

1:56:37far as they could go like they shrink

1:56:38wrapped it down that's the wrong

1:56:40approach right instead of saying here's

1:56:43what we want to build now let's put it

1:56:44in a beautiful case that has like ten

1:56:47times that cooling capacity right so

1:56:49that we have so much Headroom that no

1:56:51matter what comes down the line we have

1:56:52places to put all that stuff and I think

1:56:55there is tremendous freedom to make it

1:56:57should be the sexiest looking computer

1:56:59that makes because it can be

1:57:00fantastically weird like no other

1:57:02computer you just have to make sure you

1:57:04don't like you said make those

1:57:06trade-offs where you're like oh I have a

1:57:07great idea let's make it shaped like a

1:57:09corkscrew and we can fit the pieces in

1:57:11the corkscrew and they can go in a

1:57:12little so it's like no wait a second you

1:57:15know you may think corkscrews are cool

1:57:16or maybe we could fit these parts

1:57:18exactly in a corkscrew but that

1:57:21corkscrew has no Headroom that corkscrew

1:57:23is the wrong choice for this you know so

1:57:24don't or whatever making it super duper

1:57:26flat like yours a mac pro that's like

1:57:28it's like an imac with no monitor it's

1:57:29so incredibly flat and thin right just

1:57:32lays I don't know underneath your feet

1:57:33and you put your feet on it keeps them

1:57:34warm like stuff like that is where your

1:57:37where I get what you're saying like

1:57:38don't make that trade-off right but I

1:57:40disagree that this shouldn't be sexy I

1:57:42think it should be the sexiest computer

1:57:44that Apple makes and I think there you

1:57:46have the flexibility to make it sexy

1:57:48because it doesn't have to have a

1:57:49monitor in it it can be insanely

1:57:51expensive and

1:57:53you have don't have the size limits of

1:57:55portability so by all means make this

1:57:58thing awesome-looking make it look like

1:57:59i don't know make make it you can make a

1:58:01look a Death Star as long as the sphere

1:58:02is big enough to support tremendous

1:58:04amount of cooling like go nuts it can be

1:58:06black and shiny and chrome and you know

1:58:09whatever you want to do to it I I

1:58:10picture in my head something that even

1:58:12just a rectangular solid but the right

1:58:14surface finishes right would would be

1:58:17really cool like a couple of well-placed

1:58:19white LEDs you know not saying has to be

1:58:22have ground effects on it and have water

1:58:24bubbling through it or whatever I Lily

1:58:26did that with the g5 I was at the g5

1:58:29that the water cooled when I forget

1:58:30anyway yeah I am I want this to be

1:58:33exciting and sexy just you know and

1:58:37again i point to the the whole the

1:58:40Yosemite el capitán line of cases that

1:58:43all sorts of weird surface finishes with

1:58:46in the same basic but also very weird

1:58:48and cool shaped hiding the fact that

1:58:50guess what inside it was a gigantic

1:58:52rectangle with with reasonably good

1:58:53cooling and the g5 the same thing I

1:58:55think it looks pretty cool to buy now

1:58:57we're bored with it because it's ancient

1:58:58right but it did its job and it did it

1:59:02with style and pizzazz and elegance and

1:59:06it wasn't is cool but it was also a

1:59:10workhorse and so on I want it all I want

1:59:12sexiness and utilitarian this and I

1:59:15think I think it's possible i think

1:59:16apples proved as possible yeah i agree i

1:59:19mean you know the other funny thing is

1:59:21like by by going from the big

1:59:26utilitarian silver rectangle that

1:59:29weighed fifty pounds and sat on the

1:59:30floor to the little black cylinder it

1:59:33had to come off the floor it had to sit

1:59:35on your desk as a question do you want

1:59:37this on the desk of the floor the new

1:59:39one right and honestly I really greatly

1:59:41prefer it on the floor because it allows

1:59:44for like neater cleaner cable routing if

1:59:46there's any noise produced by it it's

1:59:48further from your ear and your

1:59:49podcasting microphone and it just to me

1:59:52it gets everything out of the way and it

1:59:56is with you the only thing is though to

1:59:57be on the floor it does have to be huge

1:59:57be on the floor it does have to be huge

2:00:00and fairly heavy to be stable there like

2:00:02there was nothing saying that you

2:00:03weren't allowed to put the trash can on

2:00:05the floor it was just unwise you just

2:00:08can't you just kick it over all the time

2:00:09right exactly like you you just

2:00:11shouldn't put on the floor and the only

2:00:14thing is like I deserves to be up on the

2:00:16desk but that's an interesting thing

2:00:17like socially speaking I had my g3 and

2:00:20g4 on my desk because I thought they

2:00:22deserved to be up there because they

2:00:23were beautiful but the g5 i also had on

2:00:26my desk but it was just too damn big

2:00:27yeah please you just was on the desk it

2:00:29was like it was gonna fall on me and

2:00:30crush me to death it's all I had it on

2:00:32my desk for a long time and I said you

2:00:34know what this is inappropriate and it

2:00:36went to the floor and you know my g5

2:00:38imac pro have been on the floor ever

2:00:40since so i'm not opposed to putting

2:00:41something that other people would put on

2:00:43the floor that could be put on the floor

2:00:45on the desk just because i think it's

2:00:46really cool and looking at it makes me

2:00:48happy but at a certain point it becomes

2:00:50ridiculous so i'm i'm thinking this one

2:00:52should be and will be small enough that

2:00:55you could put it on the desk but i think

2:00:57a goal should be also it works

2:00:59underneath the desk so that it gives the

2:01:00people the choice of where they want to

2:01:02put it which means like you said it

2:01:04can't be so small that it like it tips

2:01:06over from a stiff Thunderbolt cable in

2:01:08the back or whatever yeah exactly but

2:01:10i'm just guessing just by the way things

2:01:12are like the direction technology is

2:01:14going you know if you actually do take

2:01:16that cheese grater case and subtract all

2:01:18the stuff you don't really need any more

2:01:19i think it actually might be too small

2:01:21to go on the floor i put lead weights in

2:01:23the bottom like high-end audio equipment

2:01:24there you go so Casey what what do you

2:01:29want them to make anything or you you

2:01:32want to make Nothing right so we'd stop

2:01:34talking about though or do do we talk

2:01:36about it more when they make nothing

2:01:37Utah a you talk about it more when they

2:01:39make nothing and be and I want them to

2:01:41make something I said that at the

2:01:42opening the show I want them to make

2:01:44something I just want I want it to be

2:01:46here because I I don't want to do 50

2:01:49some weeks of us pontificating about

2:01:51what it will be could be more than that

2:01:53oh they only said not this year yeah

2:01:57that leaves the whole rest of time

2:01:59future right on an infinite time scale

2:02:03kids so there is a new mac pro there we

2:02:05go no so you know overall if I could

2:02:09summarize how I feel about this one more

2:02:12time

2:02:13to kind of close out my thinking on it

2:02:15so far looks of course but I'm sure we

2:02:17will follow up next week with all the

2:02:18stuff we forgot about but I'm incredibly

2:02:21happy to see this because it really does

2:02:24show for the first time in a long time

2:02:27that Apple is really taking pros needs

2:02:31very seriously and they might have done

2:02:34that for a lot of time and you know in

2:02:36the middle here but we weren't seeing a

2:02:38lot of signs of that from the outside it

2:02:40was always questionable from the outside

2:02:43whether they really care about

2:02:46addressing pro needs or whether they

2:02:48whether proteins were kind of like this

2:02:50nuisance they had to deal with you know

2:02:52and and that they were kind of

2:02:53reluctantly supporting very minimally

2:02:56until the pros just all went away and

2:02:58none of us wanted that as prose or as

2:03:02fans of Apple trying to be the best that

2:03:04it can be none of us wanted that and for

2:03:07a while it really did seem like that's

2:03:09what we had and whether that was true or

2:03:12not this shows us that they are taking a

2:03:16serious effort now and really putting

2:03:18themselves out there publicly to show

2:03:22that that's not the case and whether

2:03:25that we at whether that was the case two

2:03:27years ago and and they had a change of

2:03:28heart in the last six months I don't

2:03:29know it doesn't matter honestly right

2:03:30now it doesn't matter what it matters is

2:03:33that they are getting back on the right

2:03:35track and maybe this new imac will get

2:03:39halfway there and that's only a few

2:03:40months away and then maybe the new Mac

2:03:42Pro is only a year away a years went

2:03:45that long and it's gonna feel like an

2:03:48eternity but it but it isn't that long

2:03:49especially for some of us yes and so I'm

2:03:55I'm very III I kind of I kind of just

2:03:59feel relieved today thinking like you

2:04:03know reading all this stuff seeing like

2:04:04all the things that that the apples I

2:04:06could have said I feel relieved that

2:04:09they clearly care as much about this as

2:04:13I do right now possibly even more so

2:04:16which I kind of hope because it's their

2:04:17job to and that's really a very nice

2:04:21feeling and I feel very good about that

2:04:23right now and actions do speak louder

2:04:25than words you know group

2:04:27in the dispute something some smelling

2:04:28these lines of he's a better version

2:04:30what I'm about to say you know actions

2:04:32do speak louder than words and these

2:04:33aren't necessarily actions and in the

2:04:36sense that we don't have any new

2:04:37shipping products today but the fact

2:04:41that they put themselves out there so

2:04:42publicly it talking about future

2:04:45products which Apple almost never does

2:04:47they really did commit to two doing this

2:04:50and you know they they could decide in a

2:04:54few months oh you know what nevermind

2:04:55not gonna do that but that would be

2:04:56really bad PR like they that's unlikely

2:04:58right the fact they made such a deal out

2:05:04of this and gave so much info about why

2:05:07they can't update or won't update the

2:05:102013 Mac Pro kind of why it's been so

2:05:14long although that's you know k that

2:05:16that wasn't they weren't doing

2:05:18everything they could have done in the

2:05:19meantime but that's behind us now now

2:05:21you know they're doing it now right

2:05:23that's what matters so we now know that

2:05:26they care they're being honest with us

2:05:29about what has gone wrong about how long

2:05:32it might take and that they're actually

2:05:34planning on apparently one and a half to

2:05:38two pro desktop lines depending on what

2:05:40the imac pro ends up being that to me is

2:05:44awesome and I'm just incredibly happy

2:05:47and relieved as a user of this platform

2:05:51and as a fan of this company and its

2:05:53products and everything like so much of

2:05:56my life is in the Apple universe and

2:05:58most of it is in the mac universe

2:06:01specifically to know that Apple is that

2:06:05committed to it it really means a lot

2:06:08and it's something that we've been

2:06:10lacking for some time in at least being

2:06:12shown to the public and so I'm very

2:06:15happy here's my hope for this new macro

2:06:18because as we've just got some many

2:06:21shows in the past despite this

2:06:23recommitment people are understandably

2:06:25wary because even when they come out

2:06:26with the new Mac Pro people are going to

2:06:29say well that's great no but you did

2:06:31this once in 2013 fool me once right why

2:06:33would I buy this machine you know if I

2:06:37have no faith that you're going to

2:06:38update it but if everybody takes that

2:06:42attitude when the new Mac Pro comes out

2:06:44Apple is going to be like well maybe we

2:06:46misjudged this because we come up with

2:06:48this new Mac Pro and people aren't

2:06:50excited about it and a lot of people are

2:06:51buying it despite the fact that there's

2:06:53got to be pent up demand so I think it's

2:06:56important for when the new Mac Pro comes

2:06:58out for it to be successful in the

2:06:59market and my hope for the way that it

2:07:02could accomplish that is the

2:07:05old-fashioned way because then you can't

2:07:06you can't prove that you're going to we

2:07:08promise to update this next year in the

2:07:09year after the you wrap you can say that

2:07:10all you want but people people aren't

2:07:12going to trust you at this point right

2:07:13you have you have a trust issue the way

2:07:15you can get people to buy this thing and

2:07:16get them to be excited about it is the

2:07:18way Apple used to get people to buy and

2:07:20be excited about almost all of its

2:07:22computers but certainly it's top end

2:07:23ones show me that this new thing you're

2:07:26going to sell for thousands of dollars

2:07:27is the fastest thing money can buy show

2:07:30me that it can do things that not only

2:07:32no Mac could do but like that for a

2:07:34brief moment probably really really

2:07:36brief it is like the fastest thing in

2:07:38the world at a bunch of tasks show me

2:07:41that it runs Final Cut Pro faster than

2:07:42any other computer has ever run it show

2:07:44me that it runs 3ds stuff fast like

2:07:46whatever pic VR like I don't care what

2:07:48it is specifically but you have to show

2:07:50me to get me excited about this computer

2:07:52that is not just finally a Mac that I

2:07:55can use to do my job get me excited

2:07:57enough that I forget about the fact that

2:07:59you introduced a fancy new computer and

2:08:01didn't update it for four years right

2:08:02make me just say I just got to have that

2:08:04because it's so darn cool or fast or has

2:08:07some capability even if I'm never going

2:08:08to do that they used to do that with

2:08:09their laptops for crying out loud i buy

2:08:11this laptop it's the world's fastest

2:08:13laptop or it has the best screen or you

2:08:15know it's got to be the best or look at

2:08:18the the throughput on the storage

2:08:20whatever it is that's that is a thing

2:08:24you know it's not appropriate for you to

2:08:25do on the imac or the macbook and even

2:08:29on the phone they show those little

2:08:30graph to show how much faster it is and

2:08:32stuff like that but like this is the mac

2:08:34pro get us excited about it do not

2:08:37release it and say yay aren't you

2:08:39excited that we are now remotely

2:08:41competitive no I want you to crush

2:08:43everything is going to cost thousands of

2:08:45dollars I know it's the next week it's

2:08:47not going to be the best thing and I

2:08:48know the benchmarks will be contrived

2:08:50and probably isn't really the fastest

2:08:51and you can still build a pc for less

2:08:52and yadi

2:08:53avianna but you just if you're going to

2:08:55go through all this trouble and make

2:08:57this product and you want to convince

2:08:59enough of us to buy it despite our

2:09:00veterans thinks about the fact that it

2:09:02won't be supported going forward make it

2:09:04awesome in at least a couple of ways so

2:09:06that we come out of the presentation

2:09:08drooling they say I don't even think I

2:09:10need this thing but I want it because

2:09:12it's awesome that is the feeling that I

2:09:14want I think we even had that feeling

2:09:16for the for the trash can because it's

2:09:18like who knows what this thing can do to

2:09:20workstation GPUs what does that even

2:09:22mean what the hell is the d500 there's

2:09:24not a part number that i right i mean we

2:09:25we learned it wasn't as cool as you

2:09:27thought it was or anything but but yeah

2:09:30that's that's my hope for this product

2:09:32and i think that would be a good

2:09:33strategy to get people off their butts

2:09:35and into the apple store is plunking

2:09:37down there thousands of dollars for this

2:09:38stuff and after that all you got to do

2:09:40is execute next year updated next to

2:09:41your updated next year updated and

2:09:42everything will work out yet this I feel

2:09:46like is the the first step in a in what

2:09:51is going to have to be a multi-year

2:09:53series of actions by Apple to regain

2:09:57that trust and to show all of us Pro

2:10:00buyers and just Mac fans in general to

2:10:02show us that they that they are

2:10:04committed to this after all and it's

2:10:06going to take not only the release of

2:10:07this product but then also an update or

2:10:10two to know to show like yet we really

2:10:12are going to keep sup date at this time

2:10:13thanks a lot to our sponsors this week

2:10:16Casper betterment and indochino and we

2:10:20will talk to you next week now the show

2:10:25is over they didn't even mean to begin

2:10:29it was accidental oh it was accidental

2:10:33John did any research Marco and Casey

2:10:38wouldn't let him cuz it was accidental

2:10:41it was accidental and you can find the

2:10:46show notes at ATP FM and if you're into

2:10:52twitter you can follow them at KS e yl

2:10:58ISS so that's Casey list ma our CEO a RM

2:11:03aunty Marco Arment Li are they see us a

2:11:10Syracuse

2:11:17tech

2:11:22so did I win the bet or rather I guess I

2:11:27didn't win yet did I lose the bet it's

2:11:30it's iffy I think you put a lot of

2:11:33qualifiers on like if these exact models

2:11:35are on sale come January and technically

2:11:37these exact models won't be on sale even

2:11:39though they just shifting configuration

2:11:40in prices that's not the exact models

2:11:42with the exact specs so I we're going to

2:11:43go back to the tape and see exactly how

2:11:45you're phrasing yeah because i think i

2:11:46said like is the 2013 mac pro still for

2:11:50sale at the end is here and that is

2:11:52almost certainly going to be yes but

2:11:53then i think i might have said

2:11:54unmodified and that is the question do

2:12:00you think on january first 2018 the 2013

2:12:04back / will still be for sale no

2:12:06absolutely not I vote yes I I would if I

2:12:12had to pick I would vote no but it's not

2:12:13as big of a it's not as sure of things I

2:12:16I would hope it would be as I think

2:12:18about it I'm like you want about five

2:12:19bucks betting you any money i'm guessing

2:12:23january first 2018 it's still for sale

2:12:25I'll take your five dollar bet yeah all

2:12:28right it's a deal if I said I'd modified

2:12:33it's arguable whether it has been

2:12:35modified or not because here's the deal

2:12:37that what they did today was it used to

2:12:41used to have you know four six four and

2:12:44six core you know skus and then you

2:12:47could custom build them up to eight and

2:12:48twelve they eliminate it and also the

2:12:51d300 500 and 700 GPUs what they've done

2:12:54is they've eliminated the four core and

2:12:56the d300 so they got rid of the lowest

2:12:59end parts and they they basically mood

2:13:01everything down a notch so now the

2:13:03low-end skew gets the six core and the D

2:13:07500 and the high-end skew gets the eight

2:13:09core and the d700 now these are all

2:13:12parts that were available from since

2:13:142013 these are all the same parts and

2:13:16like nothing else has changed except for

2:13:19the options that come pre-configured

2:13:21with the two SKUs in the store so does

2:13:27that count as whether the computer has

2:13:30been still available at the end of this

2:13:32year unmodified or not so I think

2:13:36there's some

2:13:36ambiguity here and I think the one clear

2:13:39resolution to this problem is when you

2:13:42or someone else I'm assuming you because

2:13:45this is your mo bhai a a mac pro in a

2:13:49week or two what does the mac pro se is

2:13:53it Mac Pro comma early 2017 then it's a

2:13:58new computer but if it still says Mac

2:14:00Pro comma prehistoric it i mean 2013

2:14:04then it is the same computer commas

2:14:08parenthesis right yeah right sorry comma

2:14:12print is you know what I'm saying that

2:14:13is probably right like I think I would

2:14:17consider that I would consider that the

2:14:18authoritative source as well and I can

2:14:20almost certainly guarantee that it's not

2:14:22gonna get a new model identifier I

2:14:23cannot see that happening wait I'm sorry

2:14:26so you're saying it would still read

2:14:282013 yeah because I'm guessing that that

2:14:31whatever whatever they have changed it

2:14:34does not get a new model ID and it does

2:14:36not get a new name and apple support

2:14:39system like you know Mac Pro late 2013

2:14:41like I'm guessing there isn't it is that

2:14:43what you're saying right like that

2:14:44though yeah yeah yeah yeah I don't think

2:14:45they've ever changed the cusp of the

2:14:48support facing english-language name

2:14:51without also changing the internal

2:14:54identifier like that so if they you know

2:14:58whatever the model is you know Mac Pro 6

2:15:00comma 1 or whatever the hell that trash

2:15:02can is I can't imagine them changing the

2:15:06external name to say Mac Pro 2016

2:15:09without also change the internal one but

2:15:11there's no way they're changing the

2:15:12internal one because the hardware is

2:15:13literally the same exactly so I see I

2:15:16think they're not going to change it the

2:15:17internal or external name because they

2:15:19go they come in a pair so then you win

2:15:23right because if it would win if it's

2:15:27still for sale on on january first oh

2:15:29that that part i'm pretty confident so

2:15:31unless they and we didn't talk about

2:15:33this in the main part of the show but

2:15:35there is the slim chance that they are

2:15:36deeply under promising with the hope /

2:15:40intention of over delivering so you

2:15:42never know what will happen but if we

2:15:45take up with their word then you will

2:15:47not see a new new Mac Pro until at least

2:15:50one

2:15:5018 which means if it still reads Mac Pro

2:15:54comma paren late 2013 or whatever it was

2:15:56then I owe you five dollars look comma

2:16:00yeah and I think now that they've

2:16:01announced pre ants the upcoming one I

2:16:04think they are free now to stop selling

2:16:07the trash can as soon as you think not

2:16:09enough people are buying it anymore

2:16:10because presumably sales will tail off

2:16:12even more now I know there's always

2:16:13people who just need to replace it cuz

2:16:15they're you know that they just need

2:16:16more of them period right but come

2:16:18January they could say all right well

2:16:21we've drained all our existing inventory

2:16:22and sales have slowed to a trickle and

2:16:24we know although we're not going to tell

2:16:26you yet the new one is coming in next

2:16:28month's and so we're discontinuing in

2:16:30that grown it is continue and no one's

2:16:31going to be upset but still like you

2:16:32already told us the replacements coming

2:16:34like it's you know is it's there for

2:16:37what I'm saying is there are now free to

2:16:39stop sign a trash can anytime they think

2:16:41it is a reasonable thing to do and so we

2:16:44have to wait until January before any

2:16:45money changes hands because it is not

2:16:47inconceivable they could just plain stop

2:16:49selling it because we all know no one's

2:16:51coming oh yeah I'm definitely not going

2:16:52to declare victory or loss until January

2:16:54first but it's still night it's on my

2:16:57calendar we will see do we want to

2:17:00mention t-shirts oh yeah we launched

2:17:02t-shirts that's the thing that's a thing

2:17:05go to our site ATP that FM / shirt or

2:17:08just go to the shirts item in the nav

2:17:11bar on our site and we'll put a link in

2:17:13the show notes as well and probably have

2:17:15some kind of promotional artwork and

2:17:17link at a chapter marker at this point

2:17:19in the podcast as well because we are

2:17:21really good at self-promotion that's how

2:17:22we do things so we had a couple of minor

2:17:25glitches if you saw it when we first

2:17:27launched it there were a couple of

2:17:28issues with certain sizes being sold out

2:17:30which we didn't even know was a thing

2:17:32aunty spring but apparently it is so we

2:17:34fixed that now thank you John for fixing

2:17:37that very quickly before the show always

2:17:39we think we fixed that I'm pretty sure

2:17:41it fix that if you yeah if you don't see

2:17:44a size option listed just send us an

2:17:46email and we'll do something we're

2:17:50trying to we're trying to get you the

2:17:52shirts in the sizes that you want the

2:17:55the website is fighting us on that yeah

2:17:57and the shirt design it's an interesting

2:17:58story it so it was actually about a week

2:18:02ago that

2:18:04I had the additional concept and then

2:18:05John did a lot of work on it and came up

2:18:08with something way better but the

2:18:09initial concept that led to this shirt

2:18:11was basically mac pro's and it was like

2:18:15it was like the first mac pro the trash

2:18:17can and then like a dotted box with a

2:18:19question mark in like what comes next

2:18:21where is the new mac pro and that kind

2:18:23of evolved over over a week of design

2:18:25and into what we have now which is more

2:18:27of a a celebration of the of the pro mac

2:18:30desktops over time right from the very

2:18:32first one all painstakingly illustrated

2:18:35by the artist on the show John siracusa

2:18:37and are involved at his trace things it

2:18:40forgot to credit it was artist seriously

2:18:43well I'd take more credit for for the

2:18:45design concept because in the channel

2:18:47was like hey Mac Pro mac pro ? and I

2:18:49thought the question mark was a little

2:18:51bit too snarky but like a where is the

2:18:52new mac pro like I didn't want to be

2:18:54didn't want the shirt to be accusatory

2:18:56because people want to you know where it

2:18:59and feel good about it not like here's

2:19:01this angry protest shirt that I'm

2:19:03wearing and one of the in-between

2:19:05designs was like well what about this

2:19:06what about the evolution of the mac pro

2:19:10like doing like the whole evolution from

2:19:12like you know monkey to to Homo Sapien

2:19:15you never seen that thing they are we

2:19:16showing like textbooks of like starts

2:19:18off all hunched and gets up right in at

2:19:19the end there's like the human being

2:19:20holding the spear or whatever you know

2:19:22that that was the idea trying to pull

2:19:25that off with computers because they're

2:19:26not tall and slender like humans are

2:19:28doesn't really work that well tried a

2:19:30whole bunch of different iterations on

2:19:31it we couldn't quite get it we'd already

2:19:33eliminated the question mark there are a

2:19:35couple times I still think had some

2:19:37likes them but someone who's a better

2:19:39designer than I am could maybe make it

2:19:40work well then you know we banded that

2:19:43instead we'll look let's just make it

2:19:44know ? let's just make it about promax

2:19:48and me being the old person that I am I

2:19:50have the long view of promax it's not

2:19:52cheese grater trash can ? there have

2:19:56been many we didn't include them all but

2:19:57there have been many many pro mac

2:19:59designs at the beginning every mac was

2:20:02the top-of-the-line Mac because first

2:20:03there was only one and when there was to

2:20:05the new one was faster than the old one

2:20:07and when there was three the third one

2:20:09was faster than the first in the second

2:20:11and like so early in the pc industry and

2:20:13especially in the history of the mac

2:20:14every mac was better than all the

2:20:16previous ones in like every

2:20:17possible way like one of them came out

2:20:19with color and it was like the other

2:20:20ones are black and white is this one

2:20:21color it wins right so what we put on

2:20:24the shirt is the classic Mac and there

2:20:27are many of these obviously the first

2:20:28one was the fastest but then the SE was

2:20:29faster and then you know or the plus was

2:20:31faster than the SE and SE 30 and so on

2:20:33and so forth men then the color max the

2:20:35mac 2 2 X 2 FX and then I skipped a

2:20:38whole bunch of weird-looking towers

2:20:39don't look good in profile because

2:20:40something somewhat remember the shirt

2:20:42and then I skipped to the g3 and g4

2:20:45design which i think is fantastic and

2:20:47then the g5 cheese grater which lasted a

2:20:49really long time and then finally the

2:20:51trash can so we have a nice progression

2:20:53of promax and not pictured is every

2:20:56other mac that was not a pro mac all the

2:20:58laptops aren't there because FM hoping

2:21:01all the boring towers that were like

2:21:05mid-range the LC is not there the you

2:21:08know the what other weird like the tooth

2:21:12is not there the emac is not on the list

2:21:14none of the imax are shown in this

2:21:16silhouette this show this shirt and so

2:21:20many episodes of the show are all about

2:21:22pro desktop max max was there like the

2:21:25least popular most uninteresting than

2:21:28most people max in the lineup and yet we

2:21:31spend as much to casey's regret so much

2:21:34time in the show part talking about it

2:21:36it is the logo of our show as discussed

2:21:38was originally the cheese grater with

2:21:40the snarky new badge on it and then the

2:21:42later logo of our show that you may be

2:21:44looking at right now assuming out

2:21:45driving a Tesla and seeing some crazy

2:21:46artwork that is unrelated is a depiction

2:21:49of the front of the current trashcan

2:21:52macro so this show is all about the Mac

2:21:54Pro and the shirt is all about the mac

2:21:56pro so by one they'll be on sale for the

2:22:00next well 21 days from the time we're

2:22:02recording this and by the time you hear

2:22:04it less than 20 days and thus far we

2:22:08have never repeated the design so don't

2:22:12think well I don't want to buy the shirt

2:22:13now we'll buy next year you probably

2:22:14won't if you want to sure it buy it now

2:22:16oh yeah and shipping last year we had a

2:22:20lot of complaints about it was super

2:22:21expensive to ship these outside the US

2:22:23we've gone with a different vendor this

2:22:25time that has fulfillment from the EU so

2:22:27hopefully the shipping will be cheaper

2:22:29for people who are not inside

2:22:31the US and we have many many many

2:22:33choices of colors it's not even obvious

2:22:36sometimes from the store pages how many

2:22:37choices if you want to see what kind of

2:22:39color choices you have almost all the

2:22:41shirts have only one color choice except

2:22:43for the shirt with white ink that has

2:22:45like seven color choices and a couple of

2:22:48all the ones have like two choices where

2:22:49you can get a black or a white shirt so

2:22:51if you look at the shirts and they all

2:22:52look boring to you or you just see two

2:22:53blue ones you like well I don't want

2:22:54black or gray or blue I'm not going to

2:22:56get a shirt click through to the ones

2:22:57that have white ink on them and they

2:22:59will have how many choices do we have

2:23:01one two three four five six at level up

2:23:03to seven color choices of the shirts and

2:23:06unfortunately the college courses are

2:23:08not the same in the US and Europe and

2:23:09then not the same on men's and women's

2:23:11because they're just not we did we tried

2:23:13to make them as consistent as possible

2:23:14but we are limited by the offerings

2:23:17through the t-shirt vendor so take some

2:23:20time click through the things try to

2:23:21find the best shirt for you we apologise

2:23:23for inconsistencies we apologise for

2:23:25regional and gender inconsistencies that

2:23:27we did the best we could indeed and

2:23:30special thanks to John for doing the

2:23:31vast majority of the work this year

2:23:32indeed yep that was extremely awesome

2:23:36and I'm glad we have you on the show

2:23:38John for many reasons but that's that's

2:23:40the primary one right this very moment