Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

228: I Never Cancel a Drag

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00why is chrome using a hundred percent of

0:00:02my CPU because Chrome oh I know why I

0:00:04have an apple tab open that's why you

0:00:06know when they added that thing where

0:00:08they put like a little speaker icon

0:00:09which by the way this is kind of like a

0:00:11telephone icon it's one of those things

0:00:12that I wonder about people how people

0:00:15recognize it except just by like pattern

0:00:17matching like you know the you know the

0:00:19speaker icon looks like a paper cone

0:00:22with a little magnet coiled like but in

0:00:25profile show you like which tab is

0:00:27making sound yeah with the sound wave

0:00:29coming out of it do people even know

0:00:30that that's supposed to be a speaker do

0:00:32they just think that's the sound symbol

0:00:33anyway because who the hell knows what a

0:00:37speaker looks like these days right

0:00:39certainly the speakers in our phones and

0:00:41iPads don't look like that I mean they

0:00:42have the same part maybe they have

0:00:44similar parts fulfilling similar look

0:00:46like anyway they have that thing where

0:00:48you can find oh what tab is making the

0:00:50noise like Safari has it in chrome has

0:00:51it they have some way for you to find

0:00:53the tab that's making the noise which is

0:00:55like oh that's great this is a good

0:00:56feature they recognize this this need

0:00:58it's annoying when you can't find the

0:00:59tab that's making noise then you find it

0:01:01and you know kill it or close it but

0:01:03then we when you relaunch the browser

0:01:05and it like restores the state of your

0:01:07previous session all of the tabs that

0:01:11were they could possibly make noise like

0:01:12everything you start to autoplay yeah

0:01:15you have seven seven YouTube videos and

0:01:16they all start playing it's like whoa

0:01:17you're so close you're like you've given

0:01:20the information to stop one when they

0:01:21start spontaneously or lose track and

0:01:23you don't autoplay when tabs load in the

0:01:25background but when i rewatch from you

0:01:27note and restore a state it says you

0:01:29know what I bet this person wants seven

0:01:30YouTube videos all play at the same time

0:01:32let me do that and then yes I can find

0:01:34them and stop them all one by one you

0:01:37know what a solution of this problem is

0:01:39John having fewer tabs couple of tabs

0:01:41open that is a completely reasonable

0:01:44solution doesn't say it doesn't make

0:01:46many like I think I only had four tabs

0:01:48playing but you know because I had a

0:01:50bunch of YouTube videos up you know

0:01:51doing YouTube research right and you

0:01:53have a bunch of videos open in tabs

0:01:55which is fine you watch them one at a

0:01:56time you leave them open some of them

0:01:57are like pause in the middle but then

0:01:59you launch your browser for whatever

0:02:01reason and they all start playing

0:02:04alright so I have some follow-up about

0:02:06my MacBook / MacBook one slash Mac look

0:02:09adorable

0:02:10you've made it already don't no no no

0:02:13there are people that are very perturbed

0:02:15about the MacBook adorable nickname and

0:02:17I think your monsters not really but I

0:02:20don't understand why people are so upset

0:02:21by this a lot of people wrote in to

0:02:24recommend a particular kind of port

0:02:26replicator that apparently will solve

0:02:28all of my problems because it has power

0:02:30in it has a thorough net it has USB

0:02:32ports it has an SD card reader and on

0:02:34the surface they are correct but the

0:02:37reason I didn't buy this was a couple

0:02:39one it was very expensive although the

0:02:42sum total of the other dongles I got was

0:02:43probably at least as much if not more

0:02:46than this is and we'll put an example on

0:02:47the show notes but there appear to be

0:02:49like seven different manufacturers at

0:02:51all white label or excuse me sever

0:02:52different several different companies

0:02:53that all white label the same thing

0:02:55that's manufactured by gosh knows who

0:02:56yeah but anyway the main reason I was

0:02:59not in terribly interested in this is

0:03:00from what I had seen when I did a little

0:03:04bit of research in order to get the

0:03:06Ethernet port to work you have to

0:03:09install a kernel extension like a

0:03:12specific driver or whatever it was like

0:03:15nope I'm out and that was problem number

0:03:18one and problem number two is it looks

0:03:20very small and it appears on the surface

0:03:25to be very small but in actuality it is

0:03:28quite large or larger than I would want

0:03:31and like when I went to Chicago last

0:03:33week with the adorable I didn't bring

0:03:34the ethernet / USB

0:03:36I almost said hub I guess it is kind of

0:03:38a hub but anyway I didn't bring that

0:03:40dongle I only brought the HDMI dongle

0:03:42which I actually used more than a couple

0:03:45of times and it worked out very nicely

0:03:46but uh but my point is that I do like

0:03:49the flexibility of only bringing the one

0:03:51or ones that I absolutely need and not

0:03:53bringing the one or ones that I don't

0:03:54need so I thought I would just mention

0:03:58that but I do appreciate the feedback I

0:03:59honestly do because sometimes I don't

0:04:01see everything and then finally I just

0:04:03wanted to point out that I also wrote a

0:04:07blog post a review of my MacBook

0:04:08adorable so if you want many more words

0:04:11than we've already spoken on this

0:04:12podcast about the MacBook feel free to

0:04:15check that out

0:04:16I enjoyed the review thanks thanks I

0:04:19appreciate it it was actually a lot

0:04:20longer than I intended and for a while I

0:04:22thought maybe I'll go through and try to

0:04:24cut what I can and then I thought you

0:04:25what I'm just gonna leave it because I'd

0:04:27love to say because I really like this

0:04:28thing anyway we will put links in the

0:04:31show notes but uh yeah I really like

0:04:34this adorable it is not the fastest

0:04:35thing in the world but it is quick

0:04:37enough for me and that's all that

0:04:39matters

0:04:39speaking of these sorts of things Connor

0:04:41Brooks writes in and says here's some

0:04:43comparison pictures of the 27 excuse me

0:04:462016 vs. 2017 key caps there have been

0:04:49there's been a small revision this

0:04:51Connor says I've heard that the retrofit

0:04:53is known internally as a shim kit and to

0:04:57be honest with you I can't really see

0:04:59the difference which probably means I'm

0:05:00completely missing it I'm sure this

0:05:02picture is completely fine I couldn't

0:05:03see it either okay good that makes me

0:05:05feel a little better yeah I wish there

0:05:07was like red arrows or circle like look

0:05:09here here's the back and forth and I'm

0:05:11like I could not speak am I looking at

0:05:14the underside of the key caps I will say

0:05:16though I have had a chance to I got a

0:05:18chance to try typing on a 2017 MacBook

0:05:21Pro in a store and and it really is

0:05:24actually a different feeling they they

0:05:26it is not like a dramatic difference it

0:05:29doesn't feel like a whole different type

0:05:31of keyboard but it does feel a little

0:05:34softer at like almost as if they put

0:05:36like a rubber mat under all the keys so

0:05:38like your like your your when you bottom

0:05:40out the key it feels like you're

0:05:41bottoming out on something rubbery

0:05:42instead of something flat and it sounds

0:05:45different as well so I think that

0:05:47actually is a nice improvement is it

0:05:49quieter slightly yeah it's it's a little

0:05:51more dull sounding and a little more

0:05:53dull feeling like it really does feel

0:05:55like they just added some rubber

0:05:56somewhere which i think is actually what

0:05:58they did but it it is it seems like it's

0:06:02better I still would not describe this

0:06:04as a good keyboard but they are

0:06:06incrementally making it more tolerable

0:06:08and if this if they also took this

0:06:10opportunity to fix whatever was causing

0:06:12the keys to stick and fail then I get

0:06:16too aggressive I know so but yeah I hope

0:06:18yeah it's and maybe this is it maybe it

0:06:21maybe it needed some kind of you know

0:06:23rubber o-ring around a certain part or

0:06:25something I don't I don't know the

0:06:27details but the the 2017 s do definitely

0:06:29feel slightly but noticeably different

0:06:33yeah I gotta tell you and I talked about

0:06:35this in my review so I'm not gonna

0:06:36belabor it but when I first got the

0:06:38keyboard

0:06:39I was like oh I mean I knew what I was

0:06:41getting into but at the same time no and

0:06:43then I kind of got into like the little

0:06:45work I actually kind of liked it now

0:06:49that's it I don't I don't know if I like

0:06:51that I like it though because I love my

0:06:54magic keyboard I I can never come back I

0:06:59know so I I do prefer the magic keyboard

0:07:02and I think in no small part because I

0:07:03prefer a deeper throw and when I when I

0:07:06is that the right term for it basically

0:07:08I want I want more travel when I push

0:07:10the travel on the key I want the key to

0:07:12depress whatever amount I don't know

0:07:14what the amount is on the magic keyboard

0:07:15but I find that to be perfect and on the

0:07:16on the MacBook it does not travel into

0:07:20the into the MacBook as much as I would

0:07:21like and that still frustrates me a

0:07:23little bit but you know wait and I

0:07:26couldn't figure out how to describe it

0:07:27in and only you guys in you know a

0:07:30handful of people that read the review

0:07:32will truly understand what I meant but

0:07:33the only way I can describe it is the

0:07:35difference between like a proper shifter

0:07:38on a rear-wheel drive car you know we're

0:07:41like the shifter is sitting directly

0:07:44over the transmission so there's like

0:07:45rods that are connecting the shifter

0:07:48that you hold in your hand to the

0:07:49transmission itself like that feeling of

0:07:52sturdiness and notch enos and just good

0:07:54feeling that's what the adorable

0:07:57keyboard feels like

0:07:58whereas especially the the on-board

0:08:01keyboard on my older macbook pro so

0:08:03before they went to the these and new

0:08:04style keyboards that feels like I've

0:08:07actually understood Honda's to have very

0:08:09good shift linkages but like my Saturn

0:08:11which admittedly yes it's a Saturn haha

0:08:13I get it but the Saturn had the

0:08:14sloppiest worst most disgusting shift

0:08:17linkage in the world where he could

0:08:18shimmy the stick left and right like an

0:08:20inch either direction while the thing is

0:08:22in gear it was terrible and that's what

0:08:24like the old MacBook Pro feels like and

0:08:26the magic keyboard is closer to the

0:08:29adorable z' keyboard but not quite as

0:08:33sturdy and that sturdiness is actually

0:08:36really really really nice and I really

0:08:38enjoy it and it seems so silly and and

0:08:41if I was listening to this not having

0:08:42really had this for a while I would

0:08:44think you are bananas that sturdy

0:08:47keyboard what but that's the best way I

0:08:50can think of to describe it and I don't

0:08:51know if this is your

0:08:53Macbook what are we calling yours the

0:08:55quick escape yeah

0:08:56that has the same keyboard that this

0:08:58does doesn't it well probably not

0:09:01because you probably have the new 2017

0:09:03keys on that oh right yeah yeah yeah

0:09:05right okay but it's very similar mm-hmm

0:09:08so you find it to be more sturdy is that

0:09:10a decent adjective for it can you figure

0:09:12out a better way to describe it I know

0:09:13what you mean it's it's basically like

0:09:15what Johnny I've and his white world

0:09:16video described as precise or stable and

0:09:20so I know the feeling unfortunately I

0:09:22hesitate to use the word sturdy because

0:09:23it's unreliable in the 20 and I haven't

0:09:28gotten it replaced by the AppleCare bar

0:09:30yet because I just don't I haven't at

0:09:33the time then I need to use this

0:09:35computer but yeah so i assuming that i

0:09:39can get this fixed it'll it'll then be

0:09:41probably the same keyboard and then it

0:09:42will be precise and stable and sturdy

0:09:44and everything else but until then i

0:09:46can't agree with the the specific words

0:09:48thirty because it keeps failing fair

0:09:50enough so coming back to the actual

0:09:52point we're trying to make none of the

0:09:54three of us can see the difference in

0:09:55these two pictures no but there is a

0:09:58different hundred out there right back

0:09:59in and like mark up these diagrams or

0:10:02you know tell us what we're supposed to

0:10:04be seeing cuz i've looked at them for a

0:10:06long time and i I'm not I'm not getting

0:10:09it I I don't doubt that that this this

0:10:11is accurate and you know I'm not trying

0:10:13to say that this is fake news it's just

0:10:15that for my eyes I cannot tell the

0:10:17difference I'm sure there's a difference

0:10:19but darned if I can see where it is

0:10:21alright moving on

0:10:23Joseph writes a very very fascinating

0:10:27email about USBC yeah this was awesome

0:10:30because like his last episode we I had

0:10:32complained that one of the problems with

0:10:35the USBC lifestyle is that you kind of

0:10:37can't go all-in on it yet because see to

0:10:40me the one thing I just didn't really

0:10:42ever come around to saying but I should

0:10:44have said is like my goal here is okay

0:10:46if I have a laptop that has all USB C

0:10:48ports on it let me go to Amazon and just

0:10:51buy all new cables for everything the

0:10:52end in USB C and then I can totally

0:10:56avoid having to use weird adapters a

0:10:57liver the place for almost anything

0:10:59I'll just get USB C cables for all my

0:11:02stuff and if I need to and I can get a

0:11:03couple of new things like a USB C card

0:11:05reader and

0:11:06a couple of things and then I'm

0:11:07converted and I can just bring USBC

0:11:10cables with me on trips that is the

0:11:12dream and that is pretty much impossible

0:11:14to do in practice or it's hard to do in

0:11:17practice because my complaint last time

0:11:19is basically there are no USB C hubs

0:11:21that multiply USB C ports two more USB

0:11:25seaports the only one I knew of was the

0:11:28one that's inside the LG 5k display

0:11:30which converts one to three and those

0:11:34are D and those are just USB C 3.1 not

0:11:37you know Thunderbolt or DisplayPort

0:11:39which we'll get to in a second all week

0:11:41people have been sending me hubs and

0:11:44they say oh I think this does it almost

0:11:46none of them actually do almost every

0:11:50other hub that people sent me this past

0:11:52week the only thing it did was it had

0:11:54USB C import and and a single USBC out

0:11:58port so the best it could do is not lose

0:12:00you the port but but it still would not

0:12:03create more the only product I found

0:12:05that actually created more there's a

0:12:08Belkin hub for like 30 bucks it has one

0:12:12star reviews everywhere because it's

0:12:15it's totally passive and unpowered it

0:12:17converts one USB C port to two USB C

0:12:20ports and two USB a ports and actually

0:12:22bought one I have one right here it's

0:12:24fine

0:12:25it is unpowered so it can't like really

0:12:26charge anything meaningfully and you

0:12:28can't plug in like high draw current

0:12:30things to it but and and the reason it

0:12:33has one star reviews everywhere is that

0:12:34nobody expected that when they bought it

0:12:37and it also does not do power

0:12:38pass-through so Casey wouldn't help you

0:12:40at all because you couldn't charge your

0:12:41bank adorable while you while this will

0:12:43slow down but if you have anything but a

0:12:45macbook one so if you have any more than

0:12:46one USB port you can plug this into one

0:12:48of the second ones that's not being used

0:12:49for power and you can you can turn more

0:12:51important so - so this is the only thing

0:12:53out there and everything else does not

0:12:57do this and and so Joseph C mail which

0:12:59is full of wonderful information about

0:13:01us PC spec that he's very familiar with

0:13:04basically tells us why it's so what

0:13:07basically why aren't their hubs out

0:13:10there that multiply USB seaports in two

0:13:13more USB sea ports with the same

0:13:14capabilities as the ones built into the

0:13:16laptop right and so I'm going to read

0:13:18most of the scene

0:13:20it's a little bit on the long side

0:13:21especially for feedback email but it's

0:13:22fascinating and I think it's worth it so

0:13:24go on go on this journey with me kids

0:13:26the problem this is Joseph now the

0:13:28problem with doing USBC hubs is the spec

0:13:30USBC has alternate modes there's

0:13:33Thunderbolt and DisplayPort when you go

0:13:35into thunderbolt mode the wires are

0:13:36completely disconnected from the USB

0:13:38controller hand it over to the

0:13:39Thunderbolt controller when you go into

0:13:41the DisplayPort mode the wires are

0:13:42completely disconnected from the USB

0:13:44controller and handed it over to the

0:13:45display controller the key here is that

0:13:47this is all done at connection time so I

0:13:49think you can see the problems with hubs

0:13:50if you plug in a hub and nothing's

0:13:52plugged into it from below then what is

0:13:54it well to USB hub right so now the

0:13:57upstream lanes from that hub or USB and

0:13:59this is connected inside the PC or Mac

0:14:00as USB but those ports below the hub

0:14:03haven't changed there's still the same

0:14:04USBC connector which can have

0:14:06Thunderbolt or DisplayPort devices

0:14:08plugged in so now you go to plug in a

0:14:10display to the downstream hubs ports

0:14:12well it can't be a display because that

0:14:14would mean you need to the upstream port

0:14:16to be renegotiated as a display you can

0:14:18force the rego renegotiation but if you

0:14:20did that then none of the other ports

0:14:22downstream from the hub can now be USP

0:14:24USB ports because the upstream port is

0:14:27no longer USB it's DisplayPort and you

0:14:29can see a similar issue for Thunderbolt

0:14:31now there's an interesting thing here

0:14:33and I'm sure somebody at Apple's thought

0:14:34of it

0:14:35Thunderbolt itself can carry DisplayPort

0:14:37it's a Time multiplex bus and since

0:14:39Thunderbolt is really just PCI Express

0:14:41over a cable with the same multiplexing

0:14:42ability of a display you can build a

0:14:45Thunderbolt hub or dock that has a USB C

0:14:47capable host controller in it and thus

0:14:50the upstream is Thunderbolt but the

0:14:52downstream ports can still be USB C

0:14:54because those ports are now quote

0:14:55unquote route ports I think Thunderbolt

0:14:58adopting the u.s. PC connector here is

0:15:00like a Trojan horse call it USB C but

0:15:02instead it's really thunderbolt and

0:15:04Thunderbolt takes over the world from

0:15:06within the USB C spec by making the

0:15:09default behavior of USB C to be the

0:15:11thunderbolt alternate mode that is

0:15:15fascinating I read this email and was

0:15:17like wow this is a lot of text this is

0:15:19the sort of email I would normally be

0:15:20like okay whatever I am so glad I hadn't

0:15:23spent the time because we actually did

0:15:25cut some of it this was one of my

0:15:27favorite team feedback emails ever it

0:15:28was and it tells you basically

0:15:30everything you need to know yes I have a

0:15:32feeling however the

0:15:33that you guys have some thoughts on this

0:15:35yeah yeah I mean basically to summarize

0:15:36like because of the way it works you you

0:15:39basically can't make a hub that is

0:15:42reasonably good that multiplies the

0:15:44port's that are on the laptop that have

0:15:46all the same capabilities so you it's

0:15:49you're basically never gonna get one

0:15:50that has that can multiply to like more

0:15:53displays or more high very high speed

0:15:55Thunderbolt peripherals the the problem

0:15:59is that you know you buy USB C stuff you

0:16:02don't really unless you're painting

0:16:03really close attention and you're a huge

0:16:04nerd you don't really know which

0:16:07alternate mode if any it needs to work

0:16:09like I have I have this card reader I

0:16:12have some Ethernet adapters and it's

0:16:14like well are any of these Thunderbolt

0:16:16devices or are they all us PC devices I

0:16:18don't actually know and as a nerd I can

0:16:21figure out well the problem not the

0:16:22normal devices because that would be you

0:16:24know overkill but like how are regular

0:16:27people supposed to navigate this weird

0:16:28world like they tried to make this

0:16:30connector this one unified thing and

0:16:33this will solve all of our problems but

0:16:35in reality this is a world of hurt and

0:16:38it's it's complicated by things like you

0:16:40know by these alternate modes well yeah

0:16:41it's nice that you can put displays and

0:16:43Thunderbolt over you know over the same

0:16:46connector and stuff but like Casey's

0:16:49MacBook one doesn't have Thunderbolt it

0:16:51only thing it's just I was just about to

0:16:54interrupt you and say exactly right

0:16:55because that reminded me one of the

0:16:56things that people were one of the

0:16:58common themes amongst what people

0:16:59suggested for alternate dongles for me

0:17:02is Oh use this thing that has everything

0:17:04you want and a lot of the times it did

0:17:06but it was Thunderbolt and not USB see

0:17:09and it wasn't until I got the adorable

0:17:11that it was really made clear to me that

0:17:12that just like you said Marco this this

0:17:15machine does have USB see but it does

0:17:17not support Thunderbolt via that

0:17:19connector so so I have a very small

0:17:22subset of things that I can use that are

0:17:25all on the same physical connector but

0:17:27internally are very very different yeah

0:17:29and so this whole that this these

0:17:31connectors are kind of a mess like the

0:17:33whole the whole spec the way the

0:17:34standard works it's kind of like if you

0:17:37just look at USB see as USB 3.1 as the

0:17:39protocol and you only connect USB 3.1 or

0:17:433 devices to it that's great then it is

0:17:45just a smaller connector for the

0:17:46standard

0:17:47already had before with usb3 and it's

0:17:49great because there's lots of USB

0:17:50devices out there and USB 3 is a great

0:17:52standard relatively speaking and and we

0:17:55can connect everything that's fine the

0:17:57problem comes like that there's all

0:17:59these little asterisks on it and that's

0:18:00going to just end and those asterisks

0:18:02apply to devices computers cables and

0:18:05hubs all four of those things can screw

0:18:08this up in some way and make something

0:18:10that you bought just not work for a

0:18:12reason that to most people would be a

0:18:14mystery and and even though the computer

0:18:16can put up some kind of weird dialogue

0:18:18of it smart that's still not really

0:18:20helping the problem so it's it's nice

0:18:22that they unify this all into one

0:18:23connector but the implementation details

0:18:25make it kind of a mess so the idea of

0:18:28the Thunderbolt being like you know the

0:18:31catch-all or the Trojan horse like

0:18:32everyone's gonna put these ports in

0:18:34their machines but they'll eventually

0:18:35learn that you know it's neat that you

0:18:37can connect display and also USB device

0:18:40to that thing but really the only

0:18:42protocol that can tunnel everything over

0:18:43it and multiply stuff out is Thunderbolt

0:18:45so a thunderbolt will take over the

0:18:47world because it's the it's the superset

0:18:49of everything like won't everybody just

0:18:50make everything Thunderbolt because once

0:18:52they learn oh you know if you give you

0:18:55like this email says if you plug in a

0:18:56hub you if the thing has to decide

0:18:59whether it is and you know sending

0:19:01through DisplayPort a USB or Thunderbolt

0:19:04and why wouldn't everybody just a

0:19:05thunderbolt and the reason everyone

0:19:06won't do thunderbolt is because it's

0:19:07more expensive it's more expensive

0:19:08everywhere it's more expensive in the

0:19:10cables in the in the hardware that's in

0:19:12the hubs and the purpose like at USB is

0:19:15just cheaper to implement so it's going

0:19:17to be very difficult for Thunderbolt to

0:19:20take over everywhere and maybe Intel

0:19:21opening up with Thunderbolt spec will

0:19:22help with this because people can make

0:19:24like knockoff controllers legally

0:19:26knockoffs but like legally they can

0:19:28implement their own spec router but I

0:19:29think it's just more expensive to

0:19:31implement even if you don't have to do

0:19:32the active cables with the chips in them

0:19:34because you have a low speed device or

0:19:35whatever I'm not entirely sure that you

0:19:38we're gonna get the Thunderbolt everyone

0:19:39I think it will help for the high end

0:19:42devices where people are spending gobs

0:19:44and money on the you know upcoming Mac

0:19:46Pro and there's a bunch of Thunderbolt

0:19:48peripherals that you can attach to it

0:19:49and there's tons of you know PCI Express

0:19:51Lanes inside the box and you know but I

0:19:53think it will probably live on the high

0:19:55end but for the medium to low end like

0:19:57people just using their laptops

0:19:58around it's almost like this is yet

0:20:02another problem the more port solve in

0:20:03theory again I'm not sure how many lanes

0:20:05there are but if you know if you've got

0:20:06this port of like oh this one is

0:20:08connected to redisplay so it has to be

0:20:10display and this one is USB so it's

0:20:12connected by USB hub like if if you can

0:20:14have more ports and have each individual

0:20:16port beside what it wants to be

0:20:17independently but you probably can't do

0:20:19completely independently once you

0:20:20register a number of ports because

0:20:21there's just not enough you know

0:20:23controllers on the inside but surely you

0:20:26know in Casey's case if you had one more

0:20:28port that one port could decide well

0:20:31he's gonna burn one in power so one is

0:20:33power and then USB and then one is

0:20:36display so so you had a 3 port computer

0:20:38those three ports and those 3 ports

0:20:40could decide individually what they

0:20:41wanted to be if there was sufficient you

0:20:43know controller hardware and

0:20:44independence inside the box maybe maybe

0:20:46forget about KC's thing sorry adorable

0:20:47you're stuck go to Markos computer

0:20:50surely Markos computer you could put 4

0:20:53ports in that thing one of the D power

0:20:54and three other ones and then those

0:20:56three ports can decide what they want to

0:20:58be and then you get the advantage of

0:20:59having a bunch of uniform ports in your

0:21:01computer that are all the same shape and

0:21:03size and you just plug display in this

0:21:05one and put your hub and this one and

0:21:07put your power in that one and they all

0:21:08just work but once a daisy chains that

0:21:10it's like well what are you even daisy

0:21:11chaining like you can't you can't sweep

0:21:14that under the carpet because it's not

0:21:15like there's one magic protocol that

0:21:17does everything well there kind of is

0:21:19its Thunderbolt but it's the most

0:21:20expensive one and that isn't a lot of

0:21:22all your peripherals so every time you

0:21:24plug something in you're sort of

0:21:25deciding what this port is going to be

0:21:27and plugging in a box that has a bunch

0:21:31of other ports on it you basically just

0:21:32decided that the thing has to be

0:21:33Thunderbolt and now everything is

0:21:34expensive yes okay uh definitely on the

0:21:39Hall of Fame for me for a great feedback

0:21:41emails really what that yeah Marco you

0:21:44have some home pod follow up according

0:21:46to the night news Oh tell me more okay

0:21:49so this is this is probably my second

0:21:51favorite follow up in the history of

0:21:52follow up my favorite follow up in the

0:21:55history of follow up is there is an old

0:21:56episode of it was either connected or

0:21:58the connected predecessor show the

0:22:00prompt one of those shows

0:22:02Mike had misstated his own age he was

0:22:05off by one and a listener wrote in the

0:22:08next episode to correct him on his own

0:22:10age

0:22:10that's my favorite follow-up ever this

0:22:13is my second favorite follow-up ever we

0:22:15spent about a half hour and a couple

0:22:17episodes ago speculating about whether

0:22:19the home pod had a screen or not and one

0:22:23guy even wrote in to say like it was

0:22:25somebody basically like a tipster about

0:22:27it saying here's how it's actually

0:22:28implemented there's this diffuser and

0:22:30there's these LEDs below it and it's not

0:22:31really a screen and but it might be a

0:22:33screen later on and we talked about this

0:22:35for like a half-hour it turns out none

0:22:37of us thought to check Apple's site but

0:22:40Rob buck house did and Rob buck house

0:22:44writes in to say Apple site clears us up

0:22:46pretty well there's a section on the

0:22:48home pod page that says tap the top of

0:22:52home pod to play pause or adjust the

0:22:53volume it also shows you when Siri is

0:22:56listening with an LED waveform that

0:22:58animates with your every word yeah I had

0:23:00read that when we did the show that's

0:23:01why we talked about the idea of it being

0:23:03like okay well maybe this is just a

0:23:04temporary one and they'll put the real

0:23:06screen on it later so who knows I

0:23:08thought we had all read the website at

0:23:09the time we were discussing it yeah but

0:23:11I think if Apple is putting this on

0:23:12their product page saying this is what

0:23:14home pod does and this is the thing it

0:23:16has that's it that's final yeah that's

0:23:18what they're doing if you read the text

0:23:20there's no screen describe something as

0:23:22an LED waveform even if it's a screen

0:23:24because you know they have like LED TV

0:23:26they wouldn't say LED I know LED TVs

0:23:28aren't really LED right and if it was

0:23:31old I said it would say it would say

0:23:33OLED like it's not and it's if it was a

0:23:35if it was an LCD screen it would say LCD

0:23:37or it would say anything I said it fits

0:23:40within if they wanted to change this to

0:23:42a screen they wouldn't have to change

0:23:43that copy but but either way as I said

0:23:46on the show it this is not the type of

0:23:48thing that you would do as a stopgap

0:23:50right because it's just too complicated

0:23:53it's too complicated and too polished to

0:23:56have in there as a stopgap if they if

0:23:58they were gonna make it a bitmap display

0:24:00they would already have done that they

0:24:02wouldn't have spent all this time on

0:24:03this weird thing yeah I fix it well show

0:24:07us exactly how many colored LEDs are

0:24:09inside there but it's probably fewer

0:24:12than her in the Google home because I

0:24:13think Google home like I said Google

0:24:14them it's like a ring of them so it's

0:24:17got a lot this probably just has I don't

0:24:18know maybe 20 who knows

0:24:21we are sponsored this week by fracture

0:24:24who prints vivid color photos directly

0:24:26on glass visit fracture maqams / podcast

0:24:30for more info fracture is a photo decor

0:24:32company that's out to rescue your

0:24:34favorite photos from the digital either

0:24:36they print photos directly on to glass

0:24:38with a laser-cut rigid backing so it's

0:24:41ready to hang up right out of the box

0:24:42they even include the wall anchor all

0:24:44you have to do is upload a digital photo

0:24:47and pick your size it is that simple and

0:24:49the fracture printing process makes the

0:24:51color and contrast really pop and the

0:24:54sleek edge to edge frameless design of

0:24:57these wonderful pieces of glass lets

0:24:59your photo stand out and it matches

0:25:01pretty much any decorating style and

0:25:03again you don't have to get these frame

0:25:04they are their own thing already so you

0:25:07hang it up it's ready to go and it looks

0:25:08great with fracture you can bring a

0:25:11special memory to life and they also

0:25:13make fantastic gifts if you want to get

0:25:16them for their special people in your

0:25:17life maybe you take a photo of your kid

0:25:19or your dog and give it to you know

0:25:21their grandparents like they really

0:25:22appreciate that these make wonderful

0:25:23gifts we've given lots of them over time

0:25:25we have our our house is filled with

0:25:27fractures they're amazing they look

0:25:29great we get compliments on them all the

0:25:30time

0:25:31Tiff's are actually recently ordered a

0:25:32giant one eye it's something like 2 feet

0:25:35wide and it looks fantastic and then it

0:25:38comes in a massive box

0:25:39it's pretty great and they scale up from

0:25:41like the size of a CD cover all the way

0:25:43up to that and it looks great fracture

0:25:45comes with a 60-day happiness guarantee

0:25:47on all prints so you're sure to love

0:25:49your order and each fracture is handmade

0:25:51in gainesville florida from us source

0:25:53materials and a carbon-neutral factory

0:25:55for more information and 10% off your

0:25:57first order visit fracture me comm slash

0:26:00podcast and in there give you a

0:26:02one-question survey basically just ask

0:26:04you what podcasts did you hear about

0:26:05this from so make sure you put a teepee

0:26:07in there so that they know you came from

0:26:09here it helps support us and it helps

0:26:11tell them where their ads are working so

0:26:12it's great for everybody once again to

0:26:14get 10% of your first order go to

0:26:16fracture me.com slash podcast and make

0:26:19sure to tell them that a teepee sent you

0:26:21thank you very much to fracture for

0:26:23sponsoring our show

0:26:24[Music]

0:26:27speaking of new family members Marco you

0:26:30have welcomed a new family member to

0:26:32your house can you tell us about this

0:26:34well there's master risks on that

0:26:36did you already return it is that the

0:26:38essence today I received my my pre-order

0:26:42of the echo show the new Amazon echo

0:26:45device with the screen and the the

0:26:50reviews had come out yesterday or the

0:26:52day before and their reviews showed it

0:26:54in different angles and in real life

0:26:57before this when we were pre-ordered we

0:26:59were only shown like the product shots

0:27:01which were taken at a very careful angle

0:27:03and even at that very ideal flattering

0:27:06angle this looks like a pretty ugly

0:27:08product but I thought okay but you know

0:27:10the echos I love the echo cylinder it's

0:27:12really useful we use it all the time and

0:27:15there are contexts in which it would be

0:27:17nice to have a screen you know there you

0:27:19know there is you know the timer is

0:27:21especially timers the big one you can

0:27:23watch the timer countdown or like a lot

0:27:24of like Tiff's will ask it about the

0:27:26weather in the morning it would be nice

0:27:27to see that so as opposed to you know

0:27:28just having to sit through this like

0:27:30four sentence long description of the

0:27:33weather you know so a screen would be

0:27:36helpful we thought and I convinced if

0:27:39despite the way it looked

0:27:40- - let me preorder one and try it so we

0:27:43get it here set it up plug it in and boy

0:27:47the thing is hideous in person I mean it

0:27:49is really ugly in person and and if you

0:27:52look at all the reviews and we got the

0:27:53white one - I figured that would be a

0:27:55little bit less hideous no it's just as

0:27:57hideous is it is it uglier than the

0:28:00original Kindle no but it is larger all

0:28:04right like I think it is it can't be

0:28:07uglier but it does it doesn't pose the

0:28:11obvious that it has it doesn't pose that

0:28:13more in your face than the original

0:28:14Kindle that is it right there and so let

0:28:18me expand on that so basically so it

0:28:23would plug it and now like because I

0:28:25hadn't opened up the Alexa app in a long

0:28:27time I had not yet connected it to being

0:28:31a try to do it's like FaceTime or

0:28:33calling thing so I open it up in order

0:28:35to set this up I'm required to give the

0:28:38Alexa app

0:28:39real name and confirm it and then it

0:28:42really tries hard to get me to give it a

0:28:44phone number and access to my contact

0:28:46list so we can periodically sync it with

0:28:47us at the gammas on service and i say no

0:28:49no no and there's no that you can skip

0:28:51that part you can skip the contact and

0:28:52phone number part but you can't skip the

0:28:53name part and you I don't see any way to

0:28:56opt out of calling completely I don't

0:29:00want people calling me on my echo

0:29:02I know Amazon just launched the service

0:29:03where they you know they are doing that

0:29:05they had like their own like FaceTime

0:29:07network I could not possibly care less

0:29:09or be less interested in using it like

0:29:12we have a million other ways to do that

0:29:13now that are all better and not run by

0:29:15could be companies like Amazon so that

0:29:17the whole idea of being forced to set

0:29:19this up and not having a clear opt-out

0:29:21really put me off so I was already kind

0:29:23of unhappy and maybe that colored my

0:29:26later reaction so we set the thing up

0:29:28the first thing that's to do is the

0:29:29software update okay fine

0:29:31software B takes forever no can't walk

0:29:34away you know obviously they couldn't

0:29:36update the software you know before they

0:29:38ship to me two days ago but okay and

0:29:41then the thing finally boots up and the

0:29:45screen is super bright and I know we can

0:29:48probably change that but the screen is

0:29:49super bright and it's just blaring news

0:29:54headlines at you that you that lates and

0:29:57it the frit it's like you know some

0:29:58celebrity baby thing I don't care at all

0:30:01like the last thing I want is for this

0:30:04screen to be blaring visually blaring

0:30:07news headlines at me and we tried a

0:30:10couple things okay I guess we'll set

0:30:12this up like we don't have calendars

0:30:13paired yet so the counter screen is not

0:30:14usually yet but I really want to give

0:30:16Amazon access to my calendar well maybe

0:30:18not me okay I won't judge it on that

0:30:20let's try playing some music so the

0:30:24first thing is it completely fails to

0:30:26recognize my Amazon music whatever

0:30:29whatever the subscription is that is on

0:30:31the echo that like the premium thing for

0:30:32the echo there's like four bucks a month

0:30:34we have that and it totally failed to

0:30:36recognize it I don't know why it

0:30:38eventually started working the sound

0:30:41quality on it is really poor it is only

0:30:45a very small improvement over the echo

0:30:48cylinder and I don't care for that like

0:30:51they had all this time

0:30:53this device costs two hundred and thirty

0:30:55dollars and granted yes it has a screen

0:30:57and everything so that's that's a pretty

0:30:58good price for order is but they

0:31:00couldn't improve the sound quality like

0:31:01that think that's like the one major

0:31:03problem with the echo cylinders sound

0:31:04quality and they they really I would say

0:31:07they almost didn't improve it at all

0:31:09it's it's very very close to the old one

0:31:11and and it just like it just keeps

0:31:15blaring this this screen at us and I and

0:31:19TIFF was very quickly out of love and I

0:31:22and I very quickly followed because what

0:31:24I realized was regardless of what anyone

0:31:27else thinks of this product I had made a

0:31:29mistake in thinking it was right for us

0:31:30because one thing that I now realize in

0:31:35retrospect that we like about the echo

0:31:37cylinder is that it is it does not take

0:31:40visual attention away from anything it

0:31:42is this you know it's not pretty but

0:31:44it's discreet you know it's this black

0:31:46cylinder you put somewhere they had to

0:31:47come in white to now so it's the

0:31:49cylinder you put somewhere and you don't

0:31:51really ever have to look at it it

0:31:53doesn't draw attention to itself so the

0:31:56the echo cylinder fits into your life in

0:31:59a more discreet way the echo show with

0:32:02the screen draws attention in it draws

0:32:06your eyes and it takes attention out of

0:32:08the room and it does it for something

0:32:12that really doesn't deserve that kind of

0:32:13attention it is it is just this the

0:32:15screen in your kitchen that's telling

0:32:17you about Kanye's baby or whatever and I

0:32:20could not possibly like and yeah I'm

0:32:23sure I can figure those things in in

0:32:26some different way but just like this

0:32:28thing draws your eye and it's designed

0:32:30to do that it's Amazon stuff is not good

0:32:34enough to make it worth using they're

0:32:35they're gooeys and I kind of knew that

0:32:38already I don't I don't know why I

0:32:39thought those would be any different

0:32:41but for some reason I thought this would

0:32:42be different and that was a mistake so

0:32:44this thing is not for us at all so I'm

0:32:47returning it well that's disappointing

0:32:49but maybe you got the Amazon echo show

0:32:52with special offers paid 50 bucks more

0:32:55without special offers yeah and and and

0:32:59what one of the things that makes me sad

0:33:02about this is I realize like what

0:33:06there is a future where they make their

0:33:09app even worse and they make me and they

0:33:12require my calling information or

0:33:14whatever else or they require more stuff

0:33:16I don't want to give them or if there's

0:33:18a future in which all echos have screens

0:33:21and and there is no more option to get

0:33:23on that or or that the ones without

0:33:24screens start sucking because they

0:33:26because the service assumes you always

0:33:28have one or something like that

0:33:29you know like it made me realize I quite

0:33:31how fragile this ecosystem is because

0:33:34this was depending on Amazon doing this

0:33:35one cool thing just just keep doing it

0:33:37like there's one thing they made it's

0:33:39great this the cylinders like they're

0:33:40great just keep doing that but instead

0:33:42they're broadening outreaches weird

0:33:44creepy things like the look and and the

0:33:46show that are going in a direction that

0:33:48I really don't like and again if you you

0:33:51know if you listeners like this stuff

0:33:54that's fine

0:33:54all I'm saying is this was dramatically

0:33:57not for us and not but not the kind of

0:34:00thing we were looking for even though I

0:34:01probably should have no not going in but

0:34:02I didn't oh well sometimes it happens

0:34:04but it made me think for a second like

0:34:07I'm actually gonna be really sad if this

0:34:11ecosystem goes south in a way that ruins

0:34:15the cylinder for us because I really

0:34:17like the cylinder the way it has been

0:34:19and if that goes away like I mean I

0:34:24guess we could try the the Google air

0:34:26freshener but I'm not a big fan of that

0:34:28the home pod might be great but we don't

0:34:31really know yet and honestly the more I

0:34:34keep trying Syria I keep giving it the

0:34:36benefit of the doubt and it keeps making

0:34:38me not want to try it anymore

0:34:40I don't have a good luck with Siri so so

0:34:43I'm not incredibly optimistic about that

0:34:45and and the home pod is also larger and

0:34:49much more expensive and so it'll be hard

0:34:51to justify buying you know more than one

0:34:53of them or I don't know home pod is a

0:34:55big question mark

0:34:56I hope Amazon does not screw up what

0:34:59they have that's really great with the

0:35:01echo cylinders with the new weird creepy

0:35:03stuff they're trying to do now so what

0:35:05did you think you were going to get from

0:35:06from the echo show when you bought it

0:35:09like I don't mean that in an in a nasty

0:35:12way I'm genuinely asking like did you

0:35:14think oh it'll be really nice to have I

0:35:17don't know a visible view of your

0:35:19grocery list

0:35:20you'd made mention of your calendar like

0:35:22what sorts of things did you think this

0:35:24was going to help out with that it seems

0:35:28to either not or do a crummy job of it

0:35:30the only reasons I really wanted the

0:35:32screen were to show me timers and

0:35:34whether that's about it and and I and we

0:35:38don't I didn't need the screen like we

0:35:41get along just fine with a cylinder but

0:35:43it would just be nicer to be able to

0:35:45like just glance at timer statuses and

0:35:47just and just you know see the weather

0:35:48presented without having to listen to

0:35:50the full you know three sentence

0:35:51description with all the words in it

0:35:52like that would be nice and this is

0:35:55again like everyone out there is yelling

0:35:57at me to just you know we're an Apple

0:35:58watch because then it really does solve

0:36:00many of these problems and Siri even

0:36:03occasionally works on that so that that

0:36:05that could be nice but it but it's just

0:36:07not the way I want to do things so you

0:36:10know this is all really nitpicky stuff

0:36:11and this technology is all really

0:36:13amazing so it feels weird to complain

0:36:14about any of it really because in like

0:36:16absolute terms this is all amazing and

0:36:19we should be thankful we have any of it

0:36:20but in relative terms I never want to

0:36:24use an Amazon GUI if I can help it and I

0:36:27think what I was what I was hoping for

0:36:29is more like what we thought the home

0:36:34pod might be before we read Apple's site

0:36:36which is like just a very small discreet

0:36:41screen output for small amounts of

0:36:44information to be presented subtly that

0:36:47I that I think would be nice

0:36:49it could even still be an echo cylinder

0:36:52just with like a little like like an

0:36:55OLED strip around the top to do like a

0:36:58Time Square kind of like you know

0:36:59scrolling marquee kind of size something

0:37:01like something small and discreet that

0:37:04does not draw your eye that that like if

0:37:07there's no timers and if there's nothing

0:37:09that you've asked for recently it would

0:37:10just be blank that would be nice

0:37:13but that doesn't that is terrible by the

0:37:15way nobody I know that actually is that

0:37:17but like okay a small screen like like a

0:37:19watch sized screen right you could have

0:37:21like two timer stack they're counting

0:37:23down and it would be fine you know like

0:37:25something small on the screen is what I

0:37:27wanted and this is not that this is like

0:37:31this becomes the center of attention in

0:37:33your kitchen

0:37:34or wherever you put it it's like a tea

0:37:36it's like having a TV on and I'm the

0:37:38kind of person that if I'm in a

0:37:39restaurant that has TVs and there's one

0:37:42in my field of view I'm constantly

0:37:44distracted by it and I don't want to be

0:37:46but my eyes just drawn to it that's how

0:37:49this is even though it's not always like

0:37:51moving and stuff all that sometimes is

0:37:52but like it just constantly drew my eye

0:37:55to it and I couldn't ignore it and it

0:37:59really deserves to be ignored most of

0:38:00the time so if if what you want is more

0:38:03TV like screens that are always on in

0:38:06your life this might be for you but

0:38:08that's not what I want it feels like you

0:38:10could have gotten this thing quieted

0:38:13down so to speak get it to the point

0:38:15where I mean I don't even know if it

0:38:17displays the time or in the weather

0:38:18stuff but in theory one of the things

0:38:20that Amazon might have a leg up over

0:38:22Apple on is just saying oh we'll just

0:38:25make everything configurable like you'll

0:38:26just be you know turn things on turn

0:38:28things off whatever and then you can get

0:38:29it to the point where all it ever

0:38:30displays is your three timers in the

0:38:32weather and you start looking at it more

0:38:35like like an old-style clock radio where

0:38:38yeah the light that's constantly on but

0:38:40doesn't change much it just shows the

0:38:41time all you know I mean yeah it's

0:38:44probably wise to wait for a

0:38:45second-generation device instead of this

0:38:48hideous thing but on the other hand look

0:38:50at your cylinder they haven't made great

0:38:53strides with that cylinder they did I

0:38:55wouldn't worry too much about the

0:38:56ecosystem going all screened because

0:38:57they still got the the dot and then they

0:39:00got the cylinder and then they got this

0:39:01and now they've got like a three Park

0:39:02family not even counting all the weird

0:39:05buttons that you pressed to get paper

0:39:06towels and stuff so I think Amazon will

0:39:09keep making one of everything but I also

0:39:12think if they actually iterate on this

0:39:14which remains to be seen it they will

0:39:16but if they do iterate on it I think

0:39:19this this approach is better than the

0:39:21hey just give me cylinder with a tiny

0:39:23screen because so whatever the tiny

0:39:24screen is just has more limited use

0:39:26cases what you really want is instead of

0:39:28this this thing looks like like a

0:39:30speaker grille housing apparently some

0:39:31crappy speakers and then a screen on top

0:39:34of it what you really want is for it to

0:39:35be and what people are going to suggest

0:39:37so why don't you have an iPad in your

0:39:38kitchen because then you can run

0:39:40whatever app you want you figure out

0:39:41whoever you want use hey Siri to do

0:39:43everything you want and won't that solve

0:39:45your problems and you already hear our

0:39:46discuss no it won't biggest seer

0:39:47doesn't listen to me and does dumb

0:39:49things but having a big giant screen

0:39:53that can do anything is much more

0:39:56flexible than having a small screen that

0:39:58can do the three things that you want to

0:40:00do with it

0:40:00provided you can make the big screen you

0:40:03know quiet down not show you special

0:40:06offers by the way if people don't know

0:40:07what that's a reference to the Kindles

0:40:09for many years perhaps they still do

0:40:11this you get a Kindle cheaper if you're

0:40:13willing to have ads displayed on it when

0:40:16you're not using it and Amazon had a

0:40:18euphemism for this they called it Kindle

0:40:20with special offers that way of saying

0:40:22buy this Kindle for less money and will

0:40:25constantly show you ads and if you want

0:40:26the as they go away give us a little bit

0:40:28of more money and let me tell you that's

0:40:30the best money you'll ever spend in your

0:40:31life their book to show the special

0:40:34offers yeah it was only it was only 25

0:40:36bucks it wasn't a massive amount of

0:40:38money

0:40:38yeah like get the one by all means get

0:40:40the one with special offers and then

0:40:41just say every quarter that you're fine

0:40:43like in the laundry just keep saving

0:40:44that until you get 25 bucks and then

0:40:46spend it it's great yeah use your money

0:40:47but anyway I'm still a believer in a big

0:40:52screen thing that is stationary and

0:40:55plugged in and has cameras and

0:40:57microphones and good speakers in it but

0:40:59apparently this is not yet it but I also

0:41:01think that Marco didn't quite give this

0:41:02a long enough chance to know exactly how

0:41:04much he would hate her like because I

0:41:06feel like if you had kept it for a

0:41:08couple weeks you could probably come to

0:41:10some uneasy truce with this super bright

0:41:13screen and get it settled down and then

0:41:15then you really know whether like it's

0:41:18untenable and this needs to go or

0:41:19whatever but it's probably easier for

0:41:22all involved if you don't add more of

0:41:25these devices to your house so maybe

0:41:26just start buying cylinders and

0:41:28stockpiling them now yeah it'll be Marco

0:41:31with the cylinders Gruber with his

0:41:33keyboards john steven hackett with

0:41:36everything well see the thing with the

0:41:39keyboards is you can probably keep

0:41:41getting this to work but the cylinder is

0:41:43like if Amazon gives up on the cylinders

0:41:47the cylinder is useless without the yak

0:41:49and services that feed it so numbers

0:41:51have a bunch of useless and market you

0:41:53would know to have they ever revised the

0:41:55cylinder no that's that's not a good

0:41:57sign they've already they revised the

0:41:59dot already there's been two dots

0:42:01and there's been the other ones that no

0:42:02one buys that the the tap and oh god

0:42:06what's the other one called

0:42:07there's two other ones that nobody buys

0:42:08but the tap and the spud and the da yeah

0:42:11but but yeah like there's been two dots

0:42:12but there's only ever been one

0:42:14full-sized cylinder all right anything

0:42:17else on the echo show hopefully not we

0:42:21are sponsored this week by Harry is

0:42:23giving you a great shave at a fair price

0:42:25go to harrys.com slash ATP for more info

0:42:28and to get a free trial set Harry's is

0:42:31all about giving you a high quality

0:42:34great shave and they do this with these

0:42:37wonderful five bladed razor cartridges

0:42:39and if you've ever seen a five blade

0:42:40razor cartridge in a store before you

0:42:42know roughly what they cost

0:42:43Harry's blades are half the cost of the

0:42:46leading other razor out there that you

0:42:48probably know of and have probably

0:42:49bought if you ever need to shave and I

0:42:50probably regretted how much you paid for

0:42:51it Harry's blades are an incredible

0:42:53value because they bought their own

0:42:55factory it's a wonderful German factory

0:42:57with over a hundred years of blade

0:42:59making experience they give you high

0:43:01quality blades backed by a hundred

0:43:03percent quality guarantee they are so

0:43:05confident you're going to love their

0:43:06blades they want to give you a trial set

0:43:09for free here's what you do you sign up

0:43:11at Harry's comm slash ATP you just pay

0:43:14three bucks for shipping and they will

0:43:16give you the trial set which is a 13

0:43:17dollar value just for free all you gotta

0:43:19do is cover the shipping three bucks for

0:43:20the shipping and you get the trial set

0:43:22that includes a razor handle it includes

0:43:25five blades in the cartridge with the

0:43:26lubricating strip and a trimmer blade

0:43:28rich lathering shave gel a travel blade

0:43:31cover which is also when you travel all

0:43:33that just $3.00 for shipping at Harry's

0:43:36comm slash ATP it's all about a great

0:43:39shave at a fair price and they know

0:43:42you're gonna love it so try out the

0:43:43trial set today harrys.com slash ATP

0:43:47thank you very much to Harry's for

0:43:49sponsoring our show

0:43:49once again ok moving on we wanted to

0:43:56talk a little bit about iOS drag and

0:43:58drop and I have not really experienced

0:44:01this yet I don't have a new iPad I

0:44:03haven't put the beta on my iPad Mini but

0:44:06there's there was a little bit of

0:44:08discussion that I think all of us had

0:44:11had overheard when we were in San Jose

0:44:14for W

0:44:15DC and it was a really fascinating

0:44:17conversation that I'm gonna try my best

0:44:20to summarize so dr. wave Michael Johnson

0:44:23of Pixar had an interesting use case

0:44:26that he didn't feel like the existing

0:44:30drag-and-drop API would work with and

0:44:33his specific examples slightly different

0:44:36than this but I heard him talk about

0:44:38this a couple of times with a couple of

0:44:40people and I'm gonna use his example

0:44:44that is not really for Pixar but just a

0:44:46general example so let's say you had a

0:44:48photograph that you were dragging from

0:44:51say photos into pages vo the Apple word

0:44:54processor app what what dr. wave was

0:44:58saying was in general like say on a Mac

0:45:01you would expect that as you're dragging

0:45:05this photo over the text that's in pages

0:45:08say you're dragging it into the middle

0:45:09of like an essay or something you would

0:45:11expect that the text would flow around

0:45:15the image such that it's hugging the

0:45:19borders of the sandwich presumably this

0:45:20image is some sort of rectangle and you

0:45:23know it's it's trying to hug the four

0:45:25edges of that image as best as possible

0:45:27so as you drag it up all the text moves

0:45:29down as you drag it down all the text

0:45:30moves up etc I'm trying my best to paint

0:45:33a word picture here so what he was

0:45:35saying was that's not really allowed the

0:45:40way things work today and now I'm

0:45:43talking a little outside my comfort zone

0:45:44so feel free to interrupt me but

0:45:46basically you're given a bare minimum of

0:45:49I guess metadata about what's getting

0:45:52dragged if any and it's not until the

0:45:56user releases the drag and thus commits

0:46:00yes this is the app I would like to

0:46:03receive this thing I'm holding on to

0:46:05that's the moment at which the the

0:46:08destination app gets all kinds of

0:46:10information including actual object

0:46:12that's being dragged but the theory from

0:46:14Apple was until you have released your

0:46:18finger and you know taking it off the

0:46:20screen and thus dropped what you have

0:46:22quote-unquote in your hand what if you

0:46:25drag across some other app that you

0:46:28don't want to see

0:46:29anything about that informations let's

0:46:30say you have you know one of those

0:46:31situations where you have three apps

0:46:33open you're going from photos and you're

0:46:35going across Twitter and because you're

0:46:38a maniac you don't use Tweetbot you use

0:46:40the official Twitter app don't at me

0:46:42okay so you drag across Twitter app but

0:46:45you don't want Twitter to see that

0:46:47photograph and then you go into pages

0:46:49and that's when we release so that's why

0:46:51they don't want to give a not final

0:46:55destination any sort of real information

0:46:57about what's being dragged but that's a

0:47:00real bummer for cases where you want to

0:47:01do things like reflow text around an

0:47:04image so it was a very very interesting

0:47:06use case and I actually witnessed a

0:47:08couple of conversations between dr. wave

0:47:10and a couple of people including some

0:47:11Apple employees one of which was

0:47:14extremely fascinating about what are the

0:47:16pros and cons of Apple's approach and

0:47:18you know what what could or should they

0:47:21do about it and there's a lot of gray

0:47:24area here that I'm kind of fluffing over

0:47:26as an example if they're - if the source

0:47:29and destination apps are from the same

0:47:31developer you know say comics are not

0:47:34whatever then there's I believe more

0:47:37information available to you than there

0:47:39would be otherwise but I don't recall if

0:47:42that's enough to get through this

0:47:43particular problem or not but it was

0:47:45just a really really fascinating news

0:47:46case and I don't know if I should go so

0:47:49first to say edge case but it's

0:47:51certainly it's not one of those things

0:47:53where I heard this was like wow this API

0:47:56sucks it's actually wow they really

0:47:59really thought about this API they made

0:48:01a decision that may or may not have been

0:48:03the best but I think that makes sense

0:48:06and I understand why they did it so I

0:48:09don't I have not experienced this myself

0:48:11I've kind of summarized as best I can

0:48:14mark oh you have a new iPad and you do

0:48:17have the beta on it right so anything to

0:48:19add on this I thought you're wrong but

0:48:22now I'm questioning it I thought that

0:48:24there was a whole thing in DC sessions

0:48:26which I haven't I haven't finished

0:48:27watching the dragon drop ones yet but

0:48:29yeah I've seen them either yeah but I

0:48:31thought that that they actually did

0:48:33provide for photos they provided

0:48:35dimensions and there was even some way

0:48:38to to like to tell the drag agent

0:48:43how to render a preview to see like show

0:48:45a thumbnail of the image here like and

0:48:47and didn't figure federighi talk about

0:48:48that on the talk show like I for some

0:48:50reason I think you might be wrong about

0:48:51this entire this entire concept like I

0:48:54think they're like you are right that

0:48:55that they get that the apps don't

0:48:58receive information I don't receive the

0:49:00data that's being right unless it

0:49:02dropped for security concern reasons but

0:49:04I think there's this whole API in place

0:49:07for like previewing that allows the like

0:49:10the Windows Server to the the basically

0:49:13the app can tell the server like well if

0:49:14you happen to have an image let me know

0:49:16its dimensions and render it you know at

0:49:19this kind of alpha of level at this

0:49:21scale here you know I think there

0:49:23actually is waiting that you're both

0:49:29right Marco you you ever calling this

0:49:31and actually there's even more than that

0:49:33there's other places where you can stash

0:49:34a limited amount of actual data like an

0:49:368k buffer or something and a case he's

0:49:38right about the not friend apps but like

0:49:40app groups and stuff they're all those

0:49:42things are true but the specific use

0:49:45case and the case that Apple has

0:49:47specifically protected against is

0:49:49getting it the actual data that is

0:49:52behind that dragged item they have all

0:49:53these things surrounding it to give you

0:49:56some way to let the destination know

0:49:59stuff about your thing without getting

0:50:02it the actual data and there's a couple

0:50:03reasons that one is the thing the case

0:50:05you talked about which is privacy and it

0:50:07kind of makes sense in in in the in the

0:50:10iOS ecosystem in the modern computing

0:50:12ecosystem the idea of dragging an image

0:50:15across the Facebook app and the Facebook

0:50:17app extracting all the image data and

0:50:20like analyzing it and uploading or

0:50:21whatever like that sounds crazy you're

0:50:23just paranoid no we've seen we've seen

0:50:26we've seen worse from other applications

0:50:29on iOS this is you know this is why

0:50:31Apple did this if they can't give you

0:50:33the data and so if they if they're not

0:50:35gonna give you the data then all these

0:50:37problems you're talking about well what

0:50:38do I do for you know for a preview what

0:50:41should it look like what I'm dragging it

0:50:42can I give some metadata can I give some

0:50:44limited amount of other data of my

0:50:47choosing you know a couple kilobytes of

0:50:49information and a lot of times that can

0:50:51be enough for example if the thing that

0:50:53you're dragging is representable by URL

0:50:55for example and you

0:50:56jam that URL into that you know 8

0:50:58kilobyte field then your destination

0:51:01application it's like oh hi you're

0:51:04dragging this thing but I can't get it

0:51:05the real data it's like yeah but I my

0:51:07date is just a URL and I'll put in a

0:51:08little area and then you can read the

0:51:10URL and then you can hit the URL and

0:51:11pull down the data and get it but in

0:51:13other cases when you're dragging

0:51:14something very large like a large data

0:51:17file or something like that

0:51:18they don't want the application to get

0:51:20at that actual data and all the preview

0:51:22stuff you can do is never going to

0:51:23represent the thing I don't want to get

0:51:25into I know some more specific details

0:51:26about the use cases the Pixar thing but

0:51:28I don't want to talk about them but

0:51:29there are situations where a preview is

0:51:32not sufficient a thumbnail preview

0:51:34dimensions all of which are not

0:51:36sufficient you can imagine things that

0:51:38Pixar does that may not be adequately

0:51:40represented are nicely representable as

0:51:43merely some dimensions in the thumbnail

0:51:46right because picsArt of stuff in 3d so

0:51:48just feel free to extrapolate from there

0:51:50and that's that's a user experience

0:51:53thing where you would just expect on the

0:51:56Mac or on a PC type operating system

0:51:58that the destination has access to the

0:52:01full set of data and can do whatever it

0:52:03wants with it and not just say give me a

0:52:06little placeholder because sometimes a

0:52:08placeholder especially if the

0:52:10placeholder just a thumbnail or

0:52:11something or a kilobits is not adequate

0:52:13and so I think Apple made the right

0:52:15decision for the environment because

0:52:17especially since it's so hard to ensure

0:52:20that you don't drag across something you

0:52:23know that you like because everything is

0:52:26you know it's a tiling window manager

0:52:28essentially there is no dead zone

0:52:31there's no demilitarized zone between

0:52:32the quote-unquote windows all right so I

0:52:35guess if you invoke the multitasking

0:52:38switcher you've got you're sort of out

0:52:39of dragging across things until you pull

0:52:41it back but maybe when you pull it to

0:52:42the front to maybe you know you're not

0:52:43hovering over the right side of the pane

0:52:45as it zooms and like it's it's difficult

0:52:47not to accidentally hover over something

0:52:49and I don't know if it's just iOS or

0:52:51just modern computing in general but iOS

0:52:53grew up in an environment where it is

0:52:55not it is not overly paranoid to think

0:52:59that applications will try to extract

0:53:02any piece of information they can

0:53:04because they can do stuff with it they

0:53:05can upload to a server they can analyze

0:53:06it they could figure out how to sell ads

0:53:08against your thing they can

0:53:10you know like that that is real stuff

0:53:12that happens so I have to protect

0:53:14against it and but after hearing these

0:53:17specific use cases I think there is

0:53:19there is a situation that Apple needs to

0:53:21address and I think the best way to

0:53:22address it is probably by you know the

0:53:25same thing with the app group stuff of

0:53:26like opening the floodgates between

0:53:29applications that that know each other

0:53:31right and I'm sure this use case beyond

0:53:34that was like all right well what about

0:53:35you know third-party company that wants

0:53:38to sell an application into professional

0:53:39environment and they're not the same

0:53:41company they want to share things so

0:53:42there needs to be some sort of secure

0:53:44way for applications even across

0:53:47companies to agree that it's okay that

0:53:49we show that we share each other's full

0:53:51data instead of doing a lot of this

0:53:53stuff but I mean this this is what

0:53:55software design is about that you know

0:53:57you make the best decision for everybody

0:53:59and then everybody who's who doesn't

0:54:02fall into that you know that 80% the the

0:54:04fat part of the bell curve sends you bug

0:54:06reports and you try to find some way to

0:54:08accommodate them so I don't know what

0:54:09the outcome of this conversation is

0:54:10other than I was fairly convinced that

0:54:12this is a legit use case and I think

0:54:14Apple was as well on it hopefully

0:54:15they'll do stuff to address it but I

0:54:17still think they made they made the

0:54:20right decision for the majority of users

0:54:22you know it's sort of safety first

0:54:25security first privacy first approach

0:54:28with many allowances to let you know

0:54:30your average application do something

0:54:32reasonable and then the more demanding

0:54:34applications have to find another

0:54:35solution

0:54:36anything else on drag-and-drop so

0:54:38there's a subsection here about dragging

0:54:41on a drag and drop on the phone this was

0:54:43all this is all older notes but it was

0:54:45like right after the key knows like wait

0:54:47does drag-and-drop work on the phone or

0:54:48does it work in the bay there's it's

0:54:50supposed to work or no there they're

0:54:51gonna intentionally make it not work

0:54:53because they don't want drag and drop

0:54:54could be on the phone I don't have iOS

0:54:56lovin on a phone so I don't know the

0:54:58current status is this mark oh do you

0:54:59have it yeah can you drag between

0:55:01anything on the phone can you drag

0:55:03between apps no you can drag within your

0:55:06own app though I'm not entirely sure why

0:55:09they impose this limitation like I can

0:55:11see why somebody might have argued for

0:55:12this but you know on the iPad you can

0:55:15drag and drop within an app and also

0:55:18between apps on the iPhone you can only

0:55:20drag and drop within an app however

0:55:23if you if the argument is the screen is

0:55:25too small and so you can expect people

0:55:27to like you know cram their fingers on

0:55:29or whatever that doesn't work because

0:55:32there's this awesome system that they

0:55:34built where you can you can you know

0:55:37pick up some items in a drag and then

0:55:38with another finger from an you know

0:55:41maybe from your other hand with another

0:55:42finger you can navigate the interface to

0:55:45a different screen and then drop the

0:55:48drag items somewhere else like not just

0:55:50within the same list or within the same

0:55:52screen but you can actually like go to

0:55:53like a different level in the navigation

0:55:55hierarchy and drop them there or you can

0:55:57drive them through the whole different

0:55:58app entirely and that's great that's an

0:56:00incredibly powerful system but if you're

0:56:03gonna allow navigation within an app to

0:56:06happen while you're in mid drag on the

0:56:08phone why not also allow you to kick out

0:56:12to a different app and along something

0:56:13else you know so the only thing I can

0:56:15think of is on the iPad you have the

0:56:17screen space to have two apps side by

0:56:19side or you know more than one app side

0:56:21by side so you have that ability on on

0:56:23the iPad and you don't have that in the

0:56:25iPhone and that's that's fine I think

0:56:26that makes sense given given the screen

0:56:28sizes in the in the app environment but

0:56:30I don't see why there's a limitation

0:56:32that you that you can't do it between

0:56:35apps by like holding down your dragged

0:56:38items on the phone and then hitting the

0:56:39home button and go into a different app

0:56:41and opening up a different apps like you

0:56:42already enabled it within the app so why

0:56:44not that yes Steve drone Smith

0:56:47responding some people offering them

0:56:50maybe it's because you know that the

0:56:53phone's not powerful enough where they

0:56:55want to save as an upsell feature for

0:56:56the next iPhone or whatever and from

0:56:59what he heard WWC is they just wanted to

0:57:02this to be an iPad only feature for now

0:57:04maybe it will come to the phone

0:57:06eventually a lot of by the way related

0:57:07to this both on the phone not on the

0:57:09iPad one of the things that kept coming

0:57:11up during the keynote and afterwards is

0:57:14the idea of a shelf which is a concept

0:57:16that pretty sure existed in next step

0:57:18but certainly they were there were like

0:57:20copycat products on the Mac they

0:57:22probably still are on the Mac these days

0:57:25it's just I think even Quicksilver has

0:57:27something like good it's a region of the

0:57:30screen like a shelf like a little

0:57:31rectangular area that comes out and it's

0:57:33like hey put stuff here and when you put

0:57:36things there does

0:57:36actually move them to there that is

0:57:38proxies like oh it's like if you start

0:57:40dragging something just put it on the

0:57:42shelf here and it's as if you continued

0:57:44the drag but you don't have to you just

0:57:45drop it on the shelf then you can go do

0:57:46whatever it is you want to do go find

0:57:48where you're gonna dress or we're going

0:57:50drop that drag thing then you open up

0:57:52the shelf again you're like all right

0:57:53take the thing back off the shelf and

0:57:54put it in so it's it's a multi-part drag

0:57:58operation with like a rest stop in

0:57:59between you could have multiple things

0:58:00on the shelf so you could but it's

0:58:02imagine it's like multiple clipboards

0:58:03there's lots of things in the current

0:58:05interface that are equivalent to that

0:58:07the tricky bit in iOS and maybe the

0:58:09reason that Bowl hasn't committed to

0:58:11anything like a shelf yet is where do

0:58:12you put the shelf how do you activate it

0:58:13do you want to hog the whole screen edge

0:58:15with it how do you get it to appear and

0:58:18disappear do you feel like you're

0:58:19burning are you burning parts of the

0:58:23interface of this now you use entire

0:58:24applications as a shelf you can make a

0:58:26shelf application and dock it on the

0:58:28right side of your thing and like this

0:58:29there's lots of ways you can work around

0:58:31this but all the demos in the keynotes

0:58:33and a lot of the stuff that I've seen

0:58:34online is people showing multi finger

0:58:37drags with the thing I think I referred

0:58:39to at the live show is that holding your

0:58:41breath operation where you begin doing a

0:58:44bunch of stuff and now you got stuff in

0:58:46flight like fingers are on the screen

0:58:48and maybe and basically you can't let go

0:58:50like you you're dragging stuff and you

0:58:52can't let go you haven't gotten to your

0:58:53destination yet you're getting there

0:58:54your other hand is navigating somehow

0:58:56you're you're doing this with one hand

0:58:58wrapped around your little phone or you

0:59:00have two hands on the phone it's resting

0:59:01it whatever those type of operations

0:59:05that's kind of the same reason that you

0:59:08guys don't remember this but that on the

0:59:10Mac originally the menubar worked like

0:59:13the thing at the top of screen you'd

0:59:15have to hold down the mouse button so

0:59:17you go up to the file menu you click and

0:59:19hold down the mouse button and you have

0:59:21to keep holding down the mouse button

0:59:22until you mouse over the menu item you

0:59:25wanted and you would release and that is

0:59:27like the the smallest version of a

0:59:28breath-holding maneuver because you did

0:59:31mouse down and you've had to keep

0:59:34holding it down while you looked around

0:59:35the menus you'd go to the next menu go

0:59:37down go into a submenu try to find the

0:59:39thing you want but you're holding the

0:59:40mouse button down this entire time which

0:59:42is a more difficult operation especially

0:59:44back

0:59:45Mack wasn't even knowing knew how to use

0:59:46a mouse it's a more difficult operation

0:59:48than you might think like okay hold down

0:59:50the mouse button but keep moving the

0:59:52mouse you know what but I have to I have

0:59:54to keep pressing the button so do I just

0:59:56rest my finger on it and press it into

0:59:58the table or do I push upward on them

0:59:58the table or do I push upward on them

1:00:00Allisyn things we take for granted now

1:00:01that it sounds crazy I mean the

1:00:03suggestiveness but believe me this was a

1:00:04manoeuvre that was difficult for people

1:00:06to do much more difficult for people to

1:00:08do than the equivalent which is what

1:00:10Windows did which is go to the file menu

1:00:12and click Mouse down mouse up no you

1:00:14know you'll have to hold anything down

1:00:16anymore the file menu will fall down and

1:00:18now you're free to navigate and the

1:00:20flipside of that and the windows roll

1:00:22okay well I did this click on the file

1:00:24menu and I decided I don't want anything

1:00:27in the phone on you but now the file

1:00:28menu was stuck down like how do I get

1:00:30rid of it I think you move your cursor

1:00:31around the other menus come down and you

1:00:33try to move your cursor off the end and

1:00:35it's like I just want to get rid of

1:00:37these menus how do I make them go away

1:00:38you can drill on your Mac now click the

1:00:40file menu and then just move your mouse

1:00:41around it and pretend you're a novice

1:00:43user it's like how the file menu is down

1:00:45I don't want it to go and then you hit

1:00:47the edit menu now the Edit menu is down

1:00:48your shake you have to find a safe place

1:00:51to click to deactivate it where is it

1:00:52with the old Mac's table when you hold

1:00:55down you just release the mouse button

1:00:57anywhere that's not on the menu item and

1:00:59you have canceled the operation

1:01:01eventually Apple came around to the

1:01:03Windows way of doing things because it's

1:01:05a list of a breath-holding maneuver you

1:01:06get to click and now you need to think

1:01:08find the menu item scroll around or

1:01:10whatever and eventually people learn the

1:01:12safe areas to click to deactivate the

1:01:13thing or whatever so on iOS all these

1:01:17drag operations you're just holding your

1:01:18breath that whole time until you can

1:01:20find a place to put these and worse this

1:01:23is my question after the Kuna and I

1:01:24still kind of have this question even

1:01:25though I do have I always love it on my

1:01:26iPad now is how do you safely cancel a

1:01:30complex drag operation you've got seven

1:01:32things in flight you're swiping around

1:01:34and you're like you change your mind

1:01:35you're like no never mind if I was in

1:01:37the Mac I would hit the Escape key which

1:01:38nobody knows because uh people aren't

1:01:40old-school Mac users and it would cancel

1:01:42the drag off I didn't know that but on

1:01:46in iOS I'm like what what do I do with

1:01:50all scrappy I've got in my hand I'm

1:01:51holding my breath I gotta get rid of

1:01:53this like a hangar and I gotta get rid

1:01:54of stuff safely I don't want to

1:01:55accidentally drag all this stuff into it

1:01:58so like you go off the screen edge maybe

1:01:59I mean there's a million places we know

1:02:02is you probably go to springboard it's

1:02:03probably safe you that's you're dragging

1:02:05applications in which case maybe you'll

1:02:06move them to there you can go to a thing

1:02:08they have different cursors of like

1:02:11canvas drag potentially

1:02:13happen in this location at all one of

1:02:15them is like the forbidden cursor which

1:02:16they tell you're not supposed to use but

1:02:17at least tells you like look you can't

1:02:19drag this here ever it's never gonna

1:02:20work don't bother like oh now it's safe

1:02:22to drop I can drop it there like they

1:02:25don't show demos like that but having

1:02:28having a safe way to change your mind

1:02:31mid-flight and also having a way to to

1:02:36think about what you're doing

1:02:38mid-flight without the pressure without

1:02:39the literal pressure of having to hold

1:02:41your fingers down on the screen or the

1:02:43mental pressure of knowing that you have

1:02:45this thing in flight those are problems

1:02:47that can potentially be solved by a

1:02:49shelf because then you have a two-part

1:02:51maneuver I'm gonna do something with

1:02:52this thing and this other thing chuck

1:02:54them on the shelf and now I'm free I'm

1:02:57not holding my breath animo I'm not

1:02:58holding my fingers on the screen I'm

1:02:59free to figure out what I'm gonna do

1:03:00with that stuff if I decide I'm not

1:03:02gonna do anything with it it's over like

1:03:04I can just leave it on the shelf it or I

1:03:05could delete it from the shelf or it has

1:03:07led to each other stuff or whatever but

1:03:09eventually do find the thing I want to

1:03:10do I can bring the Shelf back onto the

1:03:11screen take the thing off the shelf put

1:03:13it where I was going to put it so I

1:03:15think there's room for that type of

1:03:17interface element in iOS and I think a

1:03:20lot of these multi-finger drag things

1:03:22are cool to look at an impressive but

1:03:26are way above the the physical mental

1:03:31dexterity of most people most of the

1:03:34time and even people who can pull them

1:03:36off I think they are they're less

1:03:38comfortable than a more relaxed multi

1:03:42part operation the same way that holding

1:03:44down the mouse cursor on a menu is less

1:03:46comfortable for people on the original

1:03:49Mac and why we're all used to just

1:03:50single clicking if you want to get a

1:03:52feeling of this by the way just fire up

1:03:53an old Mac emulator everybody even

1:03:55old-school Mac users like me you fire up

1:03:57one of those old Mac emulators and you

1:03:58go to go to go to menu and you click on

1:04:00it and then you briefly flickers on the

1:04:02screen and you go oh yeah yeah I

1:04:04remember this or if you're not an

1:04:06old-school Mac user like this thing is

1:04:07broken and just quit so there was an app

1:04:10there was an app that I loved that is

1:04:13not being made anymore and I think there

1:04:15was like an API change or they got

1:04:17booted from Mac App Store I don't

1:04:18remember what it was it was called drag

1:04:20and drop that's dragon is in the animal

1:04:22dry

1:04:23and it was a play obviously on the

1:04:25phrase drag and drop yeah yeah funny huh

1:04:30anyway but it did was on the Mac if you

1:04:34start a drag and then wiggle your mouse

1:04:37the same way you wiggle your mouse to

1:04:39get the huge cursor in ceará what it

1:04:42would do is it would pop up I'm sure

1:04:44there's a term for this kind of pain but

1:04:46whatever the term is it would bring up

1:04:49one of those like I don't know how to

1:04:52describe it but it's like a little

1:04:53temporary window basically and you could

1:04:55drag or you could drop I should say

1:04:58whatever you have in your in your drag

1:05:01onto this drag and drop pane and it

1:05:04would stay there then you couldn't you

1:05:06know mouse around and do whatever you

1:05:08needed maybe get to a different path on

1:05:10your on your desktop you know or you

1:05:12know and your harddrive whatever and

1:05:13then you could go back to drag and drop

1:05:15and drag out of that so it was basically

1:05:17a shelf like you were saying and dragged

1:05:19out of that and onto finder or what have

1:05:21you and it was amazing and it made the

1:05:23computer so much better and easier to

1:05:25use and maybe there's another equivalent

1:05:28of that and if there is that actually

1:05:29kind of like to know it but unlike 20 of

1:05:31those apps for the Mac the drag and

1:05:33drops innovation was the Wiggly cursor I

1:05:34think that was the first app that did

1:05:35that one

1:05:36most of them use screen edges like I

1:05:37said Quicksilver has one I'm sure yes

1:05:39cursor yeah oh you want the wheely

1:05:42cursor out of them here's a copy copy

1:05:44drag and drop but yeah I'm trying to

1:05:46think if the next shelf was the original

1:05:48one of these that I'm mostly coming from

1:05:49Mac world and even in classic Mac OS

1:05:52there was a ton of these things some of

1:05:53them are really good sorry I I love this

1:05:56thing and I also did know you could have

1:05:58some hit escape to cancel drag by the

1:06:00way and I you lived this long not

1:06:03knowing this part what are you doing yet

1:06:04to cancel a drag I never cancel a drag

1:06:06never cancel I've committed to this drag

1:06:08I'm seeing it's pretty good to the end I

1:06:10gotta find someplace to drop this thing

1:06:12damn it I know I'm doing Oh sick burn

1:06:15yeah let's go to the Mac you can only

1:06:18grab well you know I grabbed either one

1:06:21thing at once or multiple things all at

1:06:23once it is more difficult than most Mac

1:06:25programs do not allow you to do this to

1:06:27add to your drag well as an iOS that's

1:06:29all the demos look like I've gone into

1:06:30another app and you know what I'm gonna

1:06:31add more crap to this drag add add add

1:06:33I'm running out of fingers but it's okay

1:06:36you keep going oh one more thing on this

1:06:39since we got to have an AP FS section

1:06:41every shown out as my legal agreement

1:06:44with Apple another one of the things you

1:06:49know I keep brings up like why do I care

1:06:51about a BFS then snapshots everything

1:06:53last time dragging a large thing but

1:06:58there'd be a photo or a giant audio file

1:07:00or a video file or you know a 3d model

1:07:02or whatever from some iOS application to

1:07:06another one when you drop it and you've

1:07:09committed to have all the data appear

1:07:11over there sandboxing is still a thing

1:07:13in iOS and despite app groups and all

1:07:15the things with the data sharing or

1:07:17whatever especially if it's across

1:07:18applications from different vendors it

1:07:21has to get you all that data if this is

1:07:23a three gigabyte video file it can't

1:07:26just say oh you can just read that three

1:07:28gigabyte video file out of that other

1:07:30application sandbox because you can't

1:07:31that's the whole point of sandbox you

1:07:32can't get to that other application

1:07:33stuff but you also don't want to wait

1:07:35and like throw up a progress bar of like

1:07:37now copying three gigabytes of data from

1:07:39application eight application B which is

1:07:41what would happen on the Mac if you drag

1:07:44this huge thing someplace you know that

1:07:45in the Mac progress bars are everywhere

1:07:47you know everyone gets a progress bar

1:07:49it's it's part of thematic experience

1:07:51progress bars are less a part of the iOS

1:07:53experience massively less a part of the

1:07:55iOS experience the best forget our

1:07:56stupid little spinners in the App door

1:07:58store that never actually terminated but

1:08:00anyway those are circular those aren't

1:08:02progress bars those are progress of

1:08:03rings so the solution to this

1:08:07good old API FS to the rescue because

1:08:10drag and drop is only available in iOS

1:08:1311 and in the way that we're talking

1:08:15about and because iOS 11 comes with a

1:08:17PFS for everybody when you drag that

1:08:21three gigabyte video file from one

1:08:22application to another you get an

1:08:24instant clone of it in the other

1:08:26application sandbox it doesn't actually

1:08:28actually copy any data it doesn't matter

1:08:29how big it is that clone takes the exact

1:08:32same amount of time doesn't take it any

1:08:33more space on disk it's copying right so

1:08:36if that application starts modifying it

1:08:37it will start to become unshared I'm not

1:08:40gonna say the a BFS makes drag-and-drop

1:08:42possible but it almost makes Drive

1:08:44because if you didn't think of what you

1:08:45would have to do like what where would

1:08:47the progress bar everything appear what

1:08:48it would be

1:08:48at modal would it be like a progress bar

1:08:51just underneath a little thumbnail icon

1:08:53of the thing is it slowly copy 300 bytes

1:08:55it would be terrible ap FS is saving the

1:08:57universe once again Oh John although I

1:09:04kind of think it's enabling like it's

1:09:06enabling them not to think about Sam

1:09:07boxing like Sam boxing but then how we

1:09:09can have drag and drop between

1:09:10applications oh don't worry you don't

1:09:11have to rethink your sandboxing model

1:09:13notice me him instant clone I kind of

1:09:15wish they had to rethink their

1:09:16sandboxing model or have come up with

1:09:18some other sharing sirens they were

1:09:20saying it's alright everyone will have

1:09:21their own copy of this data in their own

1:09:23sandbox and we can make as many clones

1:09:24we want instantly so it's no problem

1:09:26right and I still think it actually is a

1:09:28problem we are sponsored this week by

1:09:32betterment investing made better go to

1:09:34betterment comm slash ATP to learn more

1:09:37betterment is a smarter way to invest

1:09:39your money providing investing advice

1:09:41through smart technology automated

1:09:43investing and human advisers they have

1:09:45changed the industry but isn't the same

1:09:47strategies that financial advisors use

1:09:49with clients who have millions of

1:09:50dollars but making that available to

1:09:52everyone this includes smart rebalancing

1:09:55global diversification tax harvesting

1:09:57and so much more betterments mission is

1:10:00to help you manage and grow your

1:10:02investments to build your financial

1:10:03future all with low fees so you lose

1:10:06less of your money along the way because

1:10:08if you do the math

1:10:09typical investment fees and costs really

1:10:11add up over time and betterment fees are

1:10:14a fraction of the cost of other

1:10:15financial services and betterment is so

1:10:17easy to use that they've won awards for

1:10:20their customer experience you can even

1:10:21see for yourself by logging into the

1:10:23demo account they have right on their

1:10:24website if you're curious a TV listeners

1:10:27can get up to six months managed for

1:10:29free for more information visit

1:10:30betterment comm slash ATP Terms &

1:10:34Conditions do apply an investment

1:10:35involves risk once again to learn more

1:10:38visit betterment comm slash ATP that's

1:10:40betterment comm slash ATP betterment

1:10:43investing made better

1:10:45[Music]

1:10:48John tell me about dilled 3 it's not one

1:10:53of those sneaky things that Apple does

1:10:55every once in a while that maybe it's

1:10:57not sneaky maybe because people don't

1:10:58care about it used to write about them

1:11:01on my OS 10 reviews the canonical

1:11:04example is launch D where or actually

1:11:07more recently we've had discovery D lots

1:11:09of things at nd so does the wild e where

1:11:14their core parts of the mac brings us

1:11:17some sometimes the core parts of the

1:11:18underlying base operating system darwin

1:11:21is underneath you know iOS and mac OS

1:11:23you never hear that name anymore these

1:11:25days and apple will decide they need to

1:11:29rewrite it and that can be exciting but

1:11:33also scary discovery d last time that

1:11:36happened was a little bit scary because

1:11:38they what was the thing that was replace

1:11:40can't forget mdns responders yeah and so

1:11:43that was a problem because like

1:11:46endianness Runner was a mess and had

1:11:48tons of bugs but the thing they replaced

1:11:51it had more bugs and was even a bigger

1:11:54mess and so they wrote back that change

1:11:57but things like launch d where they

1:11:59replace the the process that spawns off

1:12:03all the other processes and duns it

1:12:04doesn't million other things rewrite

1:12:07that from scratch and replace the old

1:12:08init process that worked out pretty well

1:12:12did we ever find out whether it was bono

1:12:15that rescued us from rescuing us from

1:12:18discovery d remember they're like like

1:12:20with that well there was some celebrity

1:12:23complained of Tim Cook I think it was

1:12:24like I know like you know doesn't know

1:12:28how to use computers there was it was

1:12:30some big celebrity and like imagine like

1:12:31you know of all the like the world peace

1:12:33things that Bono has done but like also

1:12:35rescuing us from Discovery D that would

1:12:38that would rank pretty high up on that

1:12:39list John Mayer I'm trying to think

1:12:41maybe yeah it was something it was some

1:12:43celebrity that that allegedly complained

1:12:46to Tim Cook about this thing and got it

1:12:48faced like the next week

1:12:50well fixes in rolling rolling it back to

1:12:53whatever it was it was fixed yeah oh for

1:12:58some people so

1:13:02in the upcoming operating systems in

1:13:05high sierra and iOS 11 Apple's core OS

1:13:09group I'm assuming or some other people

1:13:11who work down in the guts of stuff have

1:13:12decided there's another part that needs

1:13:15to be replaced and that's the dynamic

1:13:16linker which is a thing you probably

1:13:19don't know about if you're not a

1:13:20programmer but it's the thing that

1:13:23figures out where all the other code

1:13:26that you're going to be calling into is

1:13:27and so you can call it from your

1:13:29application you can PI your applications

1:13:31that how to call this method in this

1:13:33framework here in this function in this

1:13:34library there and when you launch your

1:13:37application the operating system needs

1:13:39to connect all those dots because you

1:13:42know maybe that library has changed and

1:13:44these libraries aren't part of your

1:13:46application they're somewhere else in

1:13:47the system directory and the address of

1:13:50all the functions in them might be

1:13:52different from when you compile your

1:13:53application so this is dynamic linking

1:13:55it's not static linking where at the

1:13:57time they can build your application it

1:13:58knows where everything is and writes all

1:14:00that information it's dynamic linking it

1:14:01says I'm gonna call this function in

1:14:03this framework and you're gonna tell me

1:14:05where it is because it's gonna move

1:14:07around and there's also address based

1:14:08randomization a bunch of other stuff for

1:14:10security reasons which means is that

1:14:11dynamic linking really has to figure out

1:14:13where everything is the title of the

1:14:16relevant WWDC session is app startup

1:14:20time : past present and future which

1:14:23seems like it's very innocuous like oh

1:14:25I'm gonna learn how to make my app

1:14:27startup faster but surprise session 4:13

1:14:30we will put the link in the show notes

1:14:31this session is really about how Apple

1:14:33is rewriting it in that dynamic linker

1:14:35again for the third time and as you

1:14:38might imagine the dynamic linker is a

1:14:40really really really important part of

1:14:42the system because if it's broken

1:14:43like nothing works because everything is

1:14:47dynamic linked to everything and it's

1:14:50super important it's kind of like when

1:14:52they change the compiler but worse

1:14:54because they compiler like they left the

1:14:56old compiler around and the new dynamic

1:14:58linker is gonna be used to link like

1:15:00everything in the operating system

1:15:03itself and probably eventually all your

1:15:05third-party applications so here's the

1:15:08the skinny on this the old version dy

1:15:11ld2 will be completely replaced but

1:15:15nudee way ld3 and it's not me have you

1:15:17heard this one before hopefully this

1:15:18will go well and not gonna be a repeat

1:15:21of this get ready situation it will be

1:15:24the default for all system apps and this

1:15:27is their phrasing for 2017 Apple OS

1:15:30platforms so I guess that means the

1:15:33watch the home pod the Apple TV the Mac

1:15:36and all iOS devices for system apps

1:15:39which means Apple's own applications or

1:15:41mean I guess third party applications

1:15:42will keep still be using dld 2.0 anyway

1:15:46the reason this session is called app

1:15:49start time past present future is

1:15:50because what they're pitching developers

1:15:52on is this will let your application

1:15:54launch faster and there's been a lot of

1:15:56WABC sessions about that and you might

1:15:58think this is like oh great my app is

1:15:59slow and startup this D way ld3 will

1:16:02make my app lunch faster well maybe but

1:16:06probably not because as the session says

1:16:09in the beginning to try to you know

1:16:11level set what they're talking about

1:16:13making startup time faster is everything

1:16:17that happens before they call main

1:16:18you're like well wait a second my code

1:16:21doesn't even start until they call main

1:16:23but you know if your application is slow

1:16:25on startup because you're doing a bunch

1:16:27of stuff in your code this will not help

1:16:29you because this all the time they're

1:16:31trying to remove is before main is

1:16:33called right you're like oh well nothing

1:16:35happens before you call main right it's

1:16:37not like the first thing that happens

1:16:38and from a dynamic language super second

1:16:40it's like no no no you think your

1:16:42program starts at main really we have to

1:16:44do a bunch of crap to find all your

1:16:45stuff before we can even call main and

1:16:47so this team is like we are everything

1:16:49that happens before developers think

1:16:51there is zero time before main is called

1:16:53but that is not true at all and so

1:16:55they're working in a much smaller level

1:16:56obviously in most non-trivial

1:16:58applications I would imagine the time

1:17:01required and you know after main is

1:17:03called and before like your application

1:17:05are usable Dwarfs all this time but for

1:17:08very small simple applications or system

1:17:10demons or stuff like that maybe not

1:17:12sorry I'm not gonna repeat everything

1:17:15that's in the presentation but the

1:17:16summary is that they are taking a

1:17:19dynamic linker and moving it out into a

1:17:22daemon process which might be terrifying

1:17:25to people like wait how can how can a

1:17:27clinker be a daemon process

1:17:28and as I don't like demon processes and

1:17:30D well the RTA ends in D which is

1:17:32convenient for them it's a call to dy LD

1:17:34d I don't know they tried to it's simple

1:17:39caching mechanism there's a bunch of

1:17:40stuff that has to happen before you call

1:17:42me and of like figuring out where all

1:17:44your stuff is and the addresses of

1:17:46everything and finding all the

1:17:47dependencies and stuff like that and

1:17:49doing symbol lookups that doesn't change

1:17:52unless the library has change and so

1:17:54they're gonna do all that in an external

1:17:56process and catch the results of it if

1:17:58someone subsequent launches they don't

1:18:01have to redo that they could say oh I've

1:18:02launched you before I know where all

1:18:04your crap is and so we can skip right to

1:18:06the part where we start doing stuff and

1:18:09executing and having it in a separate

1:18:10process even though it sounds terrifying

1:18:12like from a security perspective like oh

1:18:13that if you can hack that process you

1:18:15own the system it's actually better than

1:18:17having in the process because if you're

1:18:20gonna try to mess with dynamic linker a

1:18:21dynamic linker is running in the same

1:18:23process as you if you can corrupt that

1:18:26process you have access to all the stuff

1:18:28that I'm Ankur is doing because you were

1:18:30in the same process whereas if it's in

1:18:31an external process and a program is

1:18:33corrupted it's gonna have a harder time

1:18:35leaping across the barrier to a whole

1:18:38separate process that it hasn't yet

1:18:39corrupted I don't know we'll see how

1:18:41this works out security wise I can see

1:18:43the argument for it that it is harder to

1:18:45hack with things in a separate process

1:18:46than in your own process but on the

1:18:48other hand this is now a very attractive

1:18:51target for all sorts of hack so I'm sure

1:18:53they're doing a good job with it and

1:18:54they made a pitch from a development

1:18:56perspective of like developing this as a

1:18:59separate process makes it easier for

1:19:02them to test like it's not a bunch of

1:19:03code running inside a bunch of other

1:19:06people's applications right inside other

1:19:08people's memory spaces or who knows what

1:19:09the heck is going on it is a separate

1:19:11process and it's in its own memory space

1:19:13that other processes aren't messing with

1:19:15because of memory protection and that

1:19:16makes it more reproducible and reliable

1:19:18everything like that so I think this is

1:19:21a fascinating presentation one most

1:19:23people probably haven't watched session

1:19:24439 encourage everyone to watch

1:19:26everybody see videos are free for

1:19:27everybody you don't have to have

1:19:28developer account you can just click on

1:19:30the link in our show notes and watch it

1:19:31right away I think this stuff is super

1:19:33cool I love it when Apple replaces the

1:19:35guts of operating systems I hope they

1:19:37don't screw it up because this is super

1:19:39important and terrifying but I really

1:19:41like that they're doing

1:19:43yeah one of my favorite sessions this

1:19:46year so there are a few people in my

1:19:48life who are not programmers but listen

1:19:52to this show anyway and there are a

1:19:53number of people who write in and and

1:19:55comments that effect sometimes they are

1:19:57gonna love this chapter of the show I

1:19:59didn't go to that much detail but let's

1:20:04put it this way here for regular people

1:20:06like again with a PFS like why do I care

1:20:07this happening in theory things could

1:20:11launch faster on your Apple platforms in

1:20:16theory will that be perceptible to you I

1:20:17don't know maybe maybe not but anyway

1:20:21the other and the potential downside is

1:20:23everything is broking and nothing works

1:20:25so if that doesn't happen consider it a

1:20:28victory so you got a little bonus

1:20:31surprised at WDC Marco you also got a

1:20:35little bonus surprised at WWDC did you

1:20:37not I did last summer as I was writing

1:20:42my mp3 encoder I ran into an issue you

1:20:47know mp3 has had for a very very long

1:20:49time has had the option to have VBR or

1:20:52variable bitrate files the idea being

1:20:55that you know if different different

1:20:57parts of a file of like an audio track

1:20:59could have different complexity levels

1:21:01you know in a podcast all of the gaps

1:21:04that are between all the words that

1:21:05we're speaking that you don't need that

1:21:07many bits to encode what's mostly

1:21:09silence to a level that most people

1:21:10would not even notice right and then you

1:21:14can use more bits to encode complex

1:21:17passages like music and a variable

1:21:20bitrate file allows the encoder to just

1:21:22decide like you know for this for these

1:21:24few milliseconds I'm gonna use this

1:21:25bitrate and then for the next few

1:21:26milliseconds I'm gonna use a different

1:21:27bitrate and and so on and it's a much

1:21:30more efficient way to encode audio and

1:21:34the problem is that the mp3 format does

1:21:38not have great ways at least it did not

1:21:41start out having great ways to know

1:21:43ahead of time before you've read the

1:21:46entire file if you want to say jump to

1:21:49an hour and 10 seconds in what byte

1:21:53position is that if it's a constant

1:21:55bitrate file you can

1:21:56calculate well each second is this many

1:21:58bytes so therefore jump to you know

1:22:00offset times bytes per second and that's

1:22:03where you go if it's a VBR file you

1:22:06can't guarantee that because you don't

1:22:07know what the average bitrate is across

1:22:09the whole file and so in order to jump

1:22:11to a precise point you have to have some

1:22:12kind of lookup table or something to say

1:22:15you know for every second or for every

1:22:17half second or for every tenth of a

1:22:19second this is it's a byte position and

1:22:21maybe put that at the beginning of the

1:22:23file in the mid the metadata section or

1:22:25something and then you can jump to it

1:22:26and there were a few standards on how to

1:22:28do this but Apple supported none of them

1:22:30so if you would load a very long file

1:22:35like a podcast in something that was

1:22:37using an apple decoder which is every

1:22:40podcast player on iOS or Safari or at

1:22:43you know any pretty much anywhere on app

1:22:45on Apple platforms that could play an

1:22:47mp3 would have this problem you would

1:22:50jump ahead like if you were trying to

1:22:52seek and within that file you jump ahead

1:22:54and you would actually not be at the

1:22:55right point because it was it was not

1:22:58having any kind of intelligence about

1:22:59VBR filed and how to seek within them so

1:23:02it would just try to estimate based on

1:23:03file size and it would say well you know

1:23:06you you this file is you know 100

1:23:08megabytes and it's I can read from the

1:23:11duration header upfront that it's two

1:23:12hours long and you told me to jump to

1:23:14one hour so I'm gonna jump to the 50

1:23:17megabyte mark and just assume that's

1:23:18correct and that could be off by like

1:23:21two minutes or more like that that could

1:23:22be off by a lot depending on the content

1:23:24on the content of the file like how the

1:23:26variable bitrate stuff was allocated

1:23:27between different parts of it and so

1:23:30that's sucked so it basically meant that

1:23:31it was it was impractical for podcasts

1:23:35or a lot of any kind of long-form audio

1:23:38content to really ever use VBR encoding

1:23:41and I filed a bug report it's the best

1:23:44like a Dorota blog post to draw

1:23:46attention to it and heard nothing for a

1:23:49very long time well for a year and then

1:23:52in iOS 11 and in High Sierra that's

1:23:56fixed iOS 11 and High Sierra now

1:24:00properly seek VBR mp3s that have the

1:24:05seek tables at the beginning of them

1:24:07there are three different formats of

1:24:09those that I know that exist

1:24:10they support all three of them they

1:24:12prioritize is the highest part the

1:24:14highest precision one first which is the

1:24:16ML LTE id3 tag they prioritize that

1:24:19first forecast my encoder now writes

1:24:22those tags so now we will soon you know

1:24:27there's always gonna be issues the VBR

1:24:29files on like random like car head units

1:24:32and stuff and you know like things that

1:24:33aren't you know advanced computer

1:24:35platforms but it will soon become more

1:24:40reasonable like you know once iOS 11 and

1:24:42High Sierra are widespread it will

1:24:45become more reasonable for podcasters to

1:24:47potentially use VBR encoding on their

1:24:50mp3s and what this means for you the

1:24:52listeners is better sound quality for

1:24:55things like dropped in music like if we

1:24:57drop in a clip for music or if we play a

1:24:59theme song whatever like you will hear

1:25:01better quality on that and also you can

1:25:04maintain the same level of quality for

1:25:06the whole file for just basic speech

1:25:07like what we're doing now and have it

1:25:09take up like 25 to 50 percent less space

1:25:13and therefore also download faster use

1:25:15less battery while downloading you know

1:25:17less space burn on your phone etc so

1:25:20it's a pretty nice gain it's like a 25

1:25:22to 50 percent gain depending on the

1:25:23content it's a pretty nice gain and you

1:25:26can get better quality for dropped in

1:25:28clips and stuff all because now Apple

1:25:32will seek this properly now again like

1:25:35there are gonna be non Apple platforms

1:25:37is gonna be ways in which like you know

1:25:39Android listeners for instance are kind

1:25:41of a problem for this so you know

1:25:43podcasters like us will have to decide

1:25:45like what percentage of our audience is

1:25:47on platforms that don't support proper

1:25:49VBR seeking and are we willing to let

1:25:51them live with miscalculated durations

1:25:54or miscalculated seek points as they

1:25:57seek throughout the file and so you know

1:25:59that that's gonna be a trade-off for you

1:26:01know any podcaster trim so I what format

1:26:03to encode their audio in but having it

1:26:06in the Apple platforms is by far the the

1:26:10biggest gain like it is like that's the

1:26:13big one we needed like overcast already

1:26:15supports it because I use Apple's

1:26:17decoder so like overcast already

1:26:19supports all this stuff iOS 11 and high

1:26:21sierra well I don't have a Mac App sorry

1:26:22Casey but if I'm able it

1:26:24support the High Sierra and and every

1:26:26other app that uses Apple's decoders

1:26:28which is as far as I know all of them I

1:26:30don't think any pond guys have some

1:26:31funnel they're on mp3 decoders so you

1:26:34know it's it

1:26:35this basically makes all I oh s apps

1:26:38suddenly support this without any

1:26:40changes whatsoever so that's really

1:26:42great I'm incredibly happy about this it

1:26:45might be a while you know it might be

1:26:46another year or two before we should

1:26:48practically use that but this is the

1:26:51start of that like this is this is the

1:26:52first step and that's really great

1:26:54spoiler alert

1:26:56audience Marco will make a VBR episode

1:26:58of A to B way before you think he's

1:26:59going to oh yeah definitely he's dying

1:27:03to do it the episode you're listening to

1:27:04right now might be VBR that's what I'm

1:27:06saying I wouldn't do during the the beta

1:27:10if I was sure he would you wouldn't tell

1:27:13anybody either I'll just be like you

1:27:14know what that last episode that was VBR

1:27:16you didn't even know it yeah notice how

1:27:18good the theme song sounded want to add

1:27:21more music clips like yeah explicably

1:27:24lots and lots of symbols and syncopated

1:27:27rhythms that trip up depression

1:27:30algorithms the funny thing is to Apple

1:27:33also added in very few places but they

1:27:36did add rudimentary support for the Opus

1:27:39audio codec also which is very

1:27:41interesting the open audio codec is kind

1:27:43of the successor to OGG Vorbis it's by

1:27:46the same people and it's it's this you

1:27:48know it's open source and as far as

1:27:50anybody knows patent free other that's

1:27:52you know that's that's always open to

1:27:54like whether it's really been challenged

1:27:55or not but it's a very good codec very

1:27:58advanced very modern it have in a very

1:28:00small number of places iOS 11 and high

1:28:03sierra support that now so if there

1:28:06might be a future in which mp3 might not

1:28:09be the most practical solution anymore

1:28:10it might become you know if everywhere

1:28:13support start supporting opus you know

1:28:15this is step one towards that

1:28:16possibility that's probably not gonna

1:28:18happen in reality you just you know it's

1:28:20probably always gonna be more practical

1:28:21to just ship mp3s because everything

1:28:24supports them but you know maybe in the

1:28:26future I get together with some other

1:28:28podcast app makers and we figure out

1:28:30like how to advertise multiple formats

1:28:33of the same show and if you're using a

1:28:35compatible client that maybe maybe it

1:28:37sends a

1:28:38etter that said that that lets it say to

1:28:40the downloading server you know what you

1:28:41can send me opus if you have it and

1:28:43maybe you know maybe publishers then can

1:28:45publish files that are automatically

1:28:47transferred to multiple formats or

1:28:49something you know if this would take a

1:28:50lot of a lot on the tooling side to make

1:28:52this to make anybody actually do this

1:28:53but this is this is the the start of

1:28:58making better quality podcasts that take

1:29:01up less space and I love that I remember

1:29:04having to make multiple video tags

1:29:06because with the whole was that a VC 1

1:29:09or vp9 I forget the web of me would ya

1:29:13WebM and all that other stuff because

1:29:14they wouldn't do h.264 and so all my

1:29:17always 10 reviews I had to have multiple

1:29:20versions of every video so all devices

1:29:22could see them but but anyway that's

1:29:24from a current production perspective

1:29:26it's annoying but it is nice to be able

1:29:28to do a cascade and say here's seven

1:29:30versions of this thing and just you know

1:29:32browsers and between the browser and the

1:29:35server you figure out which one you want

1:29:36but I rank them like what kind of like

1:29:38Apple did with the algorithms for the

1:29:40VBR thing rank them and or from best to

1:29:42worst then you just go down the scale

1:29:43until you find the one that you can read

1:29:45thanks much for three sponsors this week

1:29:47betterment fracture and Harry's we will

1:29:49see you next week now the show is over

1:29:55they didn't even mean to begin as it was

1:29:59accidental accidental

1:30:06Marco and Casey wouldn't let him cuz it

1:30:09was accidentally was accidental and you

1:30:15can find the show notes at ADP CAS UIL

1:30:27is esta that's Casey list and a are Co

1:30:31AR m and T Marco Arment

1:30:35are

1:30:37[Music]

1:30:53so I was not entirely clear about why I

1:30:57had experience with a 20-17 laptop

1:30:59keyboard earlier Oh God

1:31:02I I lied I said I used it in a store I

1:31:04didn't use it in a store I use it in my

1:31:06house and yeah so so here's here's the

1:31:11situation

1:31:11oh and a week's vacation I know come on

1:31:20I'm trying to I'm trying to do the

1:31:21nineties references for you guys your

1:31:23generation

1:31:24so you know how I'm the chief summarizer

1:31:26in chief Marco is the chief justifier in

1:31:29chief yes what did you buy and how did

1:31:32you justify it my MacBook escaped as I

1:31:36mentioned it you know I need to send it

1:31:39and get the keyboard repairs that

1:31:40started me thinking like alright when's

1:31:42a good him to do this and everything

1:31:42else I'm going away for a week we also

1:31:46will be at the beach for a month later

1:31:49this summer I have sent a I have placed

1:31:53an LG 5k display at the at the beach

1:31:56house so I can work for a month because

1:31:58you know the summer time I record I work

1:32:00a lot in the summer because as an iOS

1:32:02developer you do make your upgrades

1:32:04using the new beta OS and new

1:32:06capabilities and everything and of

1:32:08course I'm still gonna be recording with

1:32:09you guys gonna be podcasting awhile

1:32:11there it's gonna be you know a work

1:32:13month for the most part is it but I work

1:32:15a lot during the summer would be a great

1:32:17title for this episode so my plan was to

1:32:24bring the MacBook Escape and connect it

1:32:28to the LG 5k and work on that all summer

1:32:31long wait on your on your LG 5k before

1:32:34you go on yeah do you did you get it

1:32:36replaced with the one that doesn't like

1:32:38this draw it doesn't flicker off when

1:32:39Wi-Fi is nearby cuz then they like fix

1:32:42that yeah as far as I know cuz I bought

1:32:43it on the very last day of the discount

1:32:45mm-hmm because we were we were starting

1:32:47to plan our summer and we were thinking

1:32:49we would probably you know do a whole

1:32:50month out there and so and I was like

1:32:53you know I should have some big monitor

1:32:55to plug into and on the very last day

1:32:57that discount before I even had the

1:32:59MacBook Escape I decided you know what

1:33:01I'm probably gonna do this you know and

1:33:03this was this was after they had like

1:33:06selling them to fix the problem so as

1:33:08far as I know mine design have the

1:33:09problem all right

1:33:10all right so anyway so this was my plan

1:33:14bring the escape up there and and just

1:33:16you know work of it work on that all

1:33:18summer long and I knew it would be

1:33:19slower than my iMac but fine you know

1:33:23it's it's still you know it's a

1:33:26compromised situation but you know I

1:33:28would deal with it because I love the

1:33:29escape in so many other ways then the

1:33:32escape keyboards are having problems

1:33:33then I went on to WTC and hated having

1:33:38only two USB ports as we discussed last

1:33:40episode like that that got in the way

1:33:42a lot and even now the keyboard is fixed

1:33:47on the new ones probably that is still

1:33:49the one thing that I can say I didn't

1:33:51like about the MacBook Escape overall in

1:33:53my use of it so far I really don't like

1:33:56having only those two ports which if

1:33:57you're powered is really only one port

1:33:59but that was that's not a big enough

1:34:01problem to make me dump it but I had

1:34:03this other problem now my iMac keeps

1:34:06having problems and these are problems

1:34:08that I don't think we're gonna get

1:34:09easily fixed my iMac is not only does it

1:34:13have the image retention that it's that

1:34:16I complained about months ago and and

1:34:18that's still getting worse and worse and

1:34:19worse

1:34:20I'm also getting what appear to be i/o

1:34:22stalls on a pretty regular basis my

1:34:25performance is actually getting

1:34:26noticeably worse I'm having weird pauses

1:34:28logic is giving me that wonderful disk

1:34:30disk too slow or system overload

1:34:32dialogue if you see a resume that I love

1:34:34it so much I've never seen that dialog

1:34:36before two months ago and I'm having

1:34:39problems with my iMac is what I'm saying

1:34:41now I really want either an iMac pro or

1:34:45probably a Mac Pro my plan has always

1:34:49been you know let me ride this iMac out

1:34:51the AppleCare on my iMac is up in a few

1:34:55months in October I think we know

1:34:56whenever or whatever three years after

1:34:57the 5k came out is which I think it's

1:34:59October

1:35:00let me just last till then and then I

1:35:02can like sell it and get the mi Pro you

1:35:07should make a run at to getting the

1:35:08screen takes like before your thing runs

1:35:10out just bring it in just be like look I

1:35:12have stalls on the screen has image

1:35:13trends and blah blah blah do something

1:35:14and who knows I'm going to but the thing

1:35:17is there's never a good time to do that

1:35:18like they

1:35:20there's never really or the beach for a

1:35:22month but but you can't like you can't

1:35:24have Apple send it back to you and have

1:35:26it sit in a store for a month I think I

1:35:28think that would be a problem you know

1:35:29so like that or likes it like on my

1:35:31porch for a month so basically I'm

1:35:36having problems it with my iMac but this

1:35:39is a terrible time for me to want to

1:35:41replace my desktop because I want to

1:35:44wait even if the iMac Pro ends up being

1:35:47for me what I should really do is wait

1:35:50for the Mac Pro to come out before I

1:35:53decide that just so I can see what the

1:35:55Mac Pro is and I can weigh those

1:35:57decisions equally and and whatever

1:35:59they're Pro display is etc I already

1:36:02have this LG display so my new plan is

1:36:06let me use a laptop full time with the

1:36:10LG display after vacation month this

1:36:13summer I'll bring the display home I

1:36:15will use it on my desk full time I will

1:36:19send in my iMac to get serviced the new

1:36:21laptop plus display will become my iMac

1:36:24you know effect it'll become like my

1:36:26desktop my main computer and that can

1:36:29bridge me over until the Mac Pro comes

1:36:32out presumably like probably about a

1:36:33year from now and then I can buy a new

1:36:36desktop with all the options available

1:36:38to me and decide then T de passe in the

1:36:40chat room has a good suggestion for you

1:36:43it sounds like what you need is a Mac

1:36:45subscription service and Apple just

1:36:49sends you every computer it makes just

1:36:51all with all of them whenever they have

1:36:53a new computer you they just send them

1:36:55to you and you just you just keep paying

1:36:56the subscription and the ones you don't

1:36:58like you return and it's like blue apron

1:37:00if you want to cancel a Mac you don't

1:37:01want the back to have to come this month

1:37:02that's fine and if you don't like one of

1:37:05the Macs you have you just send it back

1:37:06to them they send you a different one

1:37:07that they actually have leasing for

1:37:09business customers and I am a business

1:37:11customer at my local store so they

1:37:13actually started offering me the leasing

1:37:14option which is not that different from

1:37:16that the only reason I didn't take it

1:37:17was that it's not that great of a deal

1:37:19like it's like it's it's it's a two-year

1:37:21it's you know two or three years fixed

1:37:24of course you know because of the lease

1:37:25and it's like a fixed time scale and I

1:37:27don't love having my computer purchases

1:37:30be tied to a fixed time scale like I

1:37:31care less of a car

1:37:33that's like a big deal to change and you

1:37:35know when new minor revisions come out I

1:37:36don't really care but like to have to

1:37:39tie a laptop to a two-year schedule that

1:37:42that that can't be slower or faster than

1:37:44that that I don't like that much and

1:37:46also the way it was priced is you get a

1:37:49pretty nice discount for doing the least

1:37:51like if you add up all the payments you

1:37:53end up paying something like 20% less

1:37:56than the retail price but then at the

1:37:59end you have nothing on that like you're

1:38:01not paying it off at the end you can buy

1:38:05it out for fair market value at the time

1:38:07but you're basically paying 80% of the

1:38:10retail price over two years to at the

1:38:13end have nothing whereas if you just buy

1:38:15it and then sell it later

1:38:17you might only lose twenty to fifty

1:38:20percent instead of 80% and you can sell

1:38:22whenever you want to so you got these

1:38:24these sticky keys and you had your image

1:38:26retention yeah your IO stalls we're

1:38:28having a lot of problems the computer

1:38:30reliability if you're interested in a

1:38:32couple years I may have a very reliable

1:38:34computer market if you're interested

1:38:38this this is a proven track record I can

1:38:41give you all the repair history totally

1:38:43solid

1:38:44everything works you know one owner only

1:38:47drove it to church on Sundays it's great

1:38:50I've never been in an accident but it's

1:38:54been full of browser tabs the whole time

1:39:00yeah so basically I did have a chance to

1:39:04use the LG display we went we went to

1:39:07the to the beach couple of weeks ago or

1:39:09days ago whenever it was and and I tried

1:39:12to do some stuff on it with the MacBook

1:39:14Escape and the GPU and the Escape is

1:39:17really not great at fairly basic

1:39:20operations on a 5k display and in all

1:39:23fairness that's not what it's made to do

1:39:25that like that's a hefty GPU load to put

1:39:28on an intel integrated GPU there's a

1:39:30reason why like Apple does not really

1:39:33advertise much with like the 13-inch

1:39:35class of laptops on the big 5k display

1:39:38they always show with a 15-inch because

1:39:40the 15-inch has a discrete GPU which is

1:39:42way more powerful than the Intel one and

1:39:44when you plug your 15-inch into just

1:39:45into a display

1:39:46the discrete GPU locks itself on like it

1:39:50always uses that it forces it on if it's

1:39:52ever kind to an external display because

1:39:54it knows like you kind of need that so

1:39:57the MacBook escape while awesome for

1:40:01everything I needed before now with this

1:40:04summer need that I need to have a nice

1:40:06big monitor and do big development in

1:40:07the open sometime I now have a need that

1:40:10it does not cover very well it really is

1:40:12quite poor at it actually like even if

1:40:14things like resizing windows is like a

1:40:16sluggish like that's because it isn't

1:40:19made to be doing that I decided now that

1:40:22my needs now that my iMac has caused me

1:40:26to have different needs and I now need a

1:40:27desktop replacement to last me a year

1:40:29until the Mac Pro comes out presumably I

1:40:31need something powerful so I got a 15

1:40:35inch again

1:40:36I got a 20-17 almost maxed out 15 inch

1:40:40and I see how this goes I mean I'm sure

1:40:42I'm still the return period business

1:40:45represent I can return however I want

1:40:47this yeah he's a big pile in his office

1:40:51it just says Marco well technically I

1:41:00feel like this is oh I have a 15 inch

1:41:02again but you don't you have the 2017

1:41:05keyboard that will make all the

1:41:06difference I'm sure honestly it does

1:41:08feel dramatically better but I don't

1:41:10know yet how reliable it is like I I got

1:41:14fairly accustomed to the MacBook Escape

1:41:16keyboard like I didn't you know I still

1:41:17don't love the butterfly keys but I got

1:41:20used to it enough that I could operate

1:41:22but I can't operate when the keys fail

1:41:26so that's I hope they have fixed that

1:41:29I'll tell you because how know there's

1:41:33not a lot of grit in the beach house so

1:41:34you'll be fine

1:41:38nice I mean I don't use it in the sand

1:41:41but yeah there's a you know what they

1:41:44say about sand

1:41:46what neither one kind of correction you

1:41:50two don't know if that's fine there's

1:41:55one time I'm glad you didn't get a

1:41:56reference mmm anyway so yes I know this

1:42:02is totally ridiculous yes I know this is

1:42:04completely wasteful but you know my

1:42:08requirements changed well it's not

1:42:10wasteful I thought you're throwing these

1:42:11computers in the garbage like you're

1:42:13turning or selling them so other people

1:42:14are getting use of them yeah and and and

1:42:17you know when they're this new like the

1:42:18resale is not too bad it's a shame

1:42:20because I really do love everything else

1:42:22about the escape and and in the future

1:42:24you know once once my desktop situation

1:42:27settles back down again once I get a Mac

1:42:29Pro probably or an iMac Pro next year it

1:42:33wouldn't surprise me if whatever laptop

1:42:34I buy next after that I might then go

1:42:37back to the escape form factor because I

1:42:39really do like it as a travel laptop but

1:42:42it is not what I want for a like desktop

1:42:45replacement you know I want more power

1:42:47for that you're gonna get an adorable

1:42:48you're gonna get a two-port adorable

1:42:50you'll see if that exists maybe but I

1:42:53really do like the escape over the

1:42:55adorable honestly it the adorable I find

1:42:57a little bit too small to comfortably

1:43:00use in my lap like the way it sits on my

1:43:03legs like I need a little bit more width

1:43:04and and the 13 inch line offers that so

1:43:08I'm a big fan of a 13 inch size overall

1:43:10I think it really is I think for for

1:43:12almost everybody the 13-inch is the

1:43:15right choice it is really great and it

1:43:18is a wonderful balance I will say though

1:43:20another I've used the escape for you

1:43:22know three months or whatever whatever

1:43:23it's been the 15 days looks like an

1:43:25aircraft carrier by comparison so big

1:43:30now I mean Casey from even worse for you

1:43:32right because you're like bouncing

1:43:34between the the adorable and the old 50

1:43:36nation well right so I've got the

1:43:38adorable that I used from Wednesday

1:43:42through Sunday when I was in Chicago

1:43:43then I came home to the 27-inch iMac and

1:43:46then I needed to do something specific

1:43:48for work so I got out the 15 and the

1:43:50iMac is a little different because it's

1:43:52kind of an it's like an external display

1:43:53I so to speak and that it's it's it just

1:43:57occupies a different part of my brain

1:43:58you know it's like oh that's a

1:44:00a desktop but holy smokes when I grab

1:44:04that 15-inch looked enormous an aircraft

1:44:08carriers a perfect description and I li

1:44:10remember having handled 17-inch

1:44:11computers back when they were yeah those

1:44:13were I kind I kind of want to just use

1:44:16the adorable for a while and then have

1:44:17somebody hand me a 17-inch and I I would

1:44:21I can't imagine what it was what it

1:44:23would be like because the 15 just looked

1:44:26obscenely large and I'd had 15s four

1:44:29years before the adorable probably six

1:44:32or so years by now and godly it just

1:44:36looked massive I've got a Mac portable

1:44:38if you're interested how do you feel

1:44:42about a 16 pound portable Macintosh with

1:44:45a lead-acid battery somehow I think

1:44:48that's gonna have trouble driving the 5k

1:44:49display active-matrix

1:44:52LCD display that's the thing I can't

1:44:54communicate to you youngsters adequately

1:44:57like the the idea that back in the day

1:45:00every Mac had something amazing about

1:45:02even this giant disgusting portable

1:45:05computer and an active-matrix LCD

1:45:07display and all of the like that typical

1:45:11PC laptops had passive-matrix screens

1:45:14and I don't know if you remember what

1:45:15those were like awful you know

1:45:17ghosting like you'd you would move the

1:45:19cursor remove a windows and you would

1:45:20see like 17 ghost images of the things

1:45:23was terrible active-matrix

1:45:24yeah yeah transistor behind every pixel

1:45:27and you can move your cursor and the

1:45:28cursor would actually move and it was

1:45:30like it was like a portable a flat

1:45:31screen can't do that because everyone

1:45:33knows what a flat screen looks like it

1:45:35says ghosty mess

1:45:36and yes it was monochrome I think yeah I

1:45:39think the first backwards my room but

1:45:41active-matrix it was like well first

1:45:42it's like it was it was the promotion of

1:45:44its day it was the 120 Hertz of its day

1:45:46it's like well once you see active

1:45:48matrix you can't go back my dad had a

1:45:50had a think pad and I don't remember the

1:45:53model number but it was black and white

1:45:55or well I should say it's grayscale it

1:45:56was grayscale and and I remember running

1:46:00Wolfenstein 3d on it and it was

1:46:02unplayable because of all the ghosting

1:46:04it was ridiculous however I believe at

1:46:06dads house right now is an IBM PC

1:46:09convertible in John you don't know

1:46:11anything about these because you didn't

1:46:12believe in pcs so let me tell

1:46:14about old hardware John the PC

1:46:18convertible came out in the early 90s

1:46:19and it had two low-density

1:46:22three-and-a-half inch drives as a matter

1:46:25of fact according to Wikipedia it was

1:46:26the first IBM computer to use the three

1:46:28and a half inch floppy disk format which

1:46:29went on to become the industry standard

1:46:30you're welcome John anyway it was a

1:46:34complete piece of garbage anyway it

1:46:35wasn't IBM that made it the industry

1:46:36standard it was Apple mm-hmm

1:46:39it weighed 13 pounds according to

1:46:40Wikipedia and it was an amazing machine

1:46:43and I loved it and it's a total piece of

1:46:45garbage if I'm really honest with you

1:46:47but it's worse than the Mac portable

1:46:48we're just saying something yeah

1:46:50so the if you look at the image in Wow

1:46:52and you close so imagine you close the

1:46:56lid if you look at the very front of the

1:46:59keyboard you see how there's like a grey

1:47:00bar going across the front and the side

1:47:03of the it's a handle you know that's

1:47:11being okay so yeah the thing would slide

1:47:15out is you grabbed it and you can carry

1:47:16this 13 I mean granted I am NOT the

1:47:19strongest man in the world but I I

1:47:20actually saw this thing than the last

1:47:22year dad's and and I picked it up I'm

1:47:24just like oh god this thing is heavy

1:47:26like it is uncomfortably heavy at

1:47:28apparently 13 pounds which for those of

1:47:30you who believe in units that make sense

1:47:32that's almost 6 kilograms lighter than

1:47:35the the Mac portable by almost an entire

1:47:3915 inch like the the current 15 inch is

1:47:47very light it's only 4 pounds but it's

1:47:50about the weight of the previous 13-inch

1:47:52models of the of the old retina

1:47:53generation and and so it really is very

1:47:57light it's just large it has a big

1:48:00footprint so it feels like you're waving

1:48:02around a lunch tray you know but you

1:48:05know I do like a lot of that like if if

1:48:07you're if you want a really powerful

1:48:09laptop that's a great one to have and

1:48:12that's far the best one to have and it

1:48:15really you know all my complaints about

1:48:17battery life aside and I haven't had

1:48:19time to test this one really yet I

1:48:20haven't really used my battery yet it's

1:48:22only a few days old but the form factor

1:48:24of this current 15-inch is really

1:48:26remarkable because

1:48:28if you put it in a bag you know it's

1:48:29like you it's like all the previous 13s

1:48:32like it you it doesn't feel any heavier

1:48:34than that but you have the power and

1:48:36massive screen size relatively of the

1:48:3915-inch so it's a great computer and it

1:48:43wasn't for me before but my requirements

1:48:46changed dramatically so and that's

1:48:48that's why I have it now ok save

1:48:51something that you're a convertible PC

1:48:53can't do and didn't do which is it Auto

1:48:57eject a floppy disk in space in space in

1:49:01space like it no gravity you mean well

1:49:04this gravity but you're falling on the

1:49:06earth

1:49:06it's called orbit anyway if you brought

1:49:10to a geostationary orbit satellite can

1:49:13you reject yeah Auto inject and eject

1:49:16drives on the max we're we're great but

1:49:18this is a the word for that

1:49:21auto-injectors is the feature yet

1:49:23another feature that made apple

1:49:24computers superior to pcs for I love you

1:49:28John but but you being smug about old

1:49:31have Apple hardware auto auto inject and

1:49:35eject will never die will never get old

1:49:37it they will live forever did though

1:49:40they will live forever no cuz the floppy

1:49:42disk so just went away I mean on the

1:49:44other hand like you know you look at

1:49:46this IBM monstrosity like you think you

1:49:48know what's better than a laptop with a

1:49:50floppy drive a laptop with two floppy

1:49:53drives well there was no our tribe what

1:49:56are you gonna do you had you know one

1:49:58floppy for like Das or whatever and then

1:50:00the other floppy for actually doing so

1:50:02it wasn't enough room in a 13 pound

1:50:05package for them to fit the hard your

1:50:09snarking but there wasn't

1:50:10Welbeck portable had a 40 megabyte hard

1:50:12drive so there you go 40 megabytes it

1:50:15was also forced at $14,000 in 2016 money

1:50:18by the way