0:00:00little bit there is worth adding no well
0:00:03it wasn't bolded I got scolded earlier I
0:00:05should hi sorry alright we'll just we'll
0:00:08just have to edit all this out let me
0:00:10take a note John gets angry at Casey you
0:00:15gotta be you gotta be serious with these
0:00:17bowls John I already did trim this down
0:00:18you realize it's not like I just copied
0:00:20and pasted the thing you know this is
0:00:21the trim version the bowls just to let
0:00:23you know which parts are important
0:00:26alright so let's get started as we have
0:00:28to with follow up we have another
0:00:32instance of a fairly long email that I'd
0:00:36like to read most actually a couple
0:00:38instances of this that I'd like to read
0:00:39pretty much in their entirety because I
0:00:41think they're really really fascinating
0:00:42I would never generally do this but now
0:00:45I'm making the exception the rule
0:00:46because he's a really good email you do
0:00:48like every two weeks and ever and I
0:00:50always and I have to edit it in some
0:00:52ways it's like nothing is more boring
0:00:55and harder to follow then listen to
0:00:57somebody read like a six paragraph email
0:00:59in a podcast alright alright I'll try to
0:01:03I'll try to make this as quick as I can
0:01:05since John has done us the service of
0:01:07bolding certain sections in the show
0:01:09notes so we got some feedback from an
0:01:12anonymous Microsoft employee on the
0:01:14facial recognition in Windows and they
0:01:16said all the surface devices since the
0:01:17surface pro 4 which is the last two
0:01:19generations apparently have supported
0:01:21Windows hello this is different than
0:01:23High Sierra this is Windows hello which
0:01:25uses an infrared LED infrared depth
0:01:27camera and RGB webcam to authenticate
0:01:30via your face this technology's derived
0:01:31from the Kinect and in has in general
0:01:34been super well received it's fast very
0:01:35reliable and works in the dark and this
0:01:37includes a link to a video which we put
0:01:39in the show notes it's also tricky to
0:01:41fool arguably more secure than a
0:01:42fingerprint and you can it can even tell
0:01:44twins apart and we'll put a different
0:01:45link in the show notes for that when
0:01:47Microsoft tried to scale this down to
0:01:48mobile devices in the Lumia 650 and 650
0:01:51XL the same technology didn't work for a
0:01:52number of reasons including power cost
0:01:54and constraints size constraints it is
0:01:56the Lumia devices shipped in 2015 and
0:01:59while the surface solution didn't scale
0:02:00down effectively then I have no
0:02:01difficulty believing Apple could scale
0:02:03down to a full face solution like
0:02:05Windows hello in 2017 that said most
0:02:08good solutions I've seen require at
0:02:09least two cameras I are in our GP RGB to
0:02:13get depth
0:02:14why it's a fleshie 3d object that's such
0:02:15a funny word fleshie but anyway and
0:02:17capture enough identifier x' as well as
0:02:19an ir LED to function and mix lighting
0:02:21conditions heavy backlighting and bright
0:02:23sunlight are especially challenging it's
0:02:25hard to see how these would fit into the
0:02:27quote unquote forehead of Abbas L I'm
0:02:29sorry bezel free iPhone without
0:02:31significant cutouts in addition to
0:02:33what's already required for the
0:02:34front-facing camera and proximity sensor
0:02:36blah blah blah all that to say it is
0:02:40fast dependable delightful face
0:02:42recognition that is absolutely possible
0:02:44and is in fact par for the course on
0:02:46some high-end Windows devices like the
0:02:47surface yes it does introduce some UI
0:02:49requirements for explicit confirmation
0:02:50of intent for example with purchases
0:02:52it's just a matter of time before
0:02:53someone makes it work on a phone I
0:02:55wouldn't be at all surprised if it to
0:02:57hear Apple had done that this isn't a
0:02:59thread of feedback with all the people
0:03:02all the windows users telling us about
0:03:03Windows hello many months ago and as
0:03:07this person point the reason I picked
0:03:08this email out is it is a Microsoft
0:03:10employee and they talk specifically
0:03:12about the challenges of getting it down
0:03:14into a phone because obviously you have
0:03:15luxuries on even just a laptop for in
0:03:18fact that you don't have on phones you
0:03:19got a lot of space to put sensors in
0:03:21there you got a lot more power a lot
0:03:22bigger battery usually you have more
0:03:24computing power these days the phone was
0:03:26probably faster than half of the things
0:03:27they listed so so we'll see so yes the
0:03:31face recognition on Windows hello is
0:03:32there we got varying reports some people
0:03:34say it's amazing it already exists that
0:03:36it's wonderful that people said I can't
0:03:37get it to recognize my face it takes
0:03:38like three to five seconds then it
0:03:40doesn't work half the time and I hate it
0:03:41so mixed results but in general I think
0:03:44mostly people like Windows hello and
0:03:46think that it works well there's just a
0:03:48question of can you get this in a phone
0:03:49I love that like the new like Windows
0:03:53did it is a lot like the old opera did
0:03:55it like that Windows is now so
0:03:58marginalized that like the cutting-edge
0:04:00features of like the surface hardware
0:04:02and like the stuff that's like the whole
0:04:04pure of Microsoft stack hardware
0:04:05software like so few people relatively
0:04:08speaking are using that and enjoying
0:04:11that to the point especially like around
0:04:13these parts around like you know Apple
0:04:15II tech podcast circles that we have no
0:04:18idea what they're doing and they're so
0:04:21like and they're doing important stuff
0:04:22and innovative stuff and they just want
0:04:26everyone to know that so much and
0:04:27meanwhile
0:04:27we're all like no one's ever done this
0:04:29before like it's it's exactly what
0:04:31exactly why the Opera people have were
0:04:33always so mad because opera was doing
0:04:36all these great features that other
0:04:38browsers would add five years later and
0:04:40act like no one had ever done them
0:04:41before and everyone else believed the
0:04:43reason people didn't know about it
0:04:44because opera in the case of operas that
0:04:46opera was would fall down on like the
0:04:48basics like that it was people didn't
0:04:50use it not just because it was obscure
0:04:51and weird but because it just wasn't as
0:04:53good a web browser in most cases those
0:04:55other ones for like boring practical
0:04:57reasons Windows is not as good of an
0:04:58operating system that's what we use
0:05:00these things anyway certainly doesn't
0:05:04have the mind sure but like Windows
0:05:05hello like I said we talked we talked
0:05:06about it on this very podcast it's not
0:05:08like we didn't know that it existed and
0:05:10a lot of these features and I think we
0:05:11talked about the Samsung face
0:05:12recognition we a lot of these features
0:05:14we do know have even been tried in foam
0:05:15for it foam form factors before but you
0:05:19know the reason we don't like have them
0:05:22in front of mine is because I mean I
0:05:24mentioned the Amazon fire phone last
0:05:26time we like the five cameras and all
0:05:27the sensors and everything is like if
0:05:28they don't work really well it's like oh
0:05:30well yeah they tried to do a thing but
0:05:32they essentially failed and so it will
0:05:34rise to the level of public
0:05:35consciousness
0:05:36if it becomes popular and everyone
0:05:40agrees that it works really well and
0:05:41because if we're every where and every
0:05:44phone would be using it and so like no
0:05:45one has really cracked it kind of like
0:05:46fingerprint centers that essentially
0:05:47work really well everywhere now and so
0:05:49they're very very common so that's why
0:05:51everybody knows unlocking the phone with
0:05:53your finger as a thing whoever was first
0:05:56with that and getting it to work
0:05:57obviously we know about it from the
0:05:58Apple world but for all we know Android
0:06:00was doing it you know years before but
0:06:02anyway that technology is kind of
0:06:03settled and it works just fine face
0:06:05recognition is still in the realm of
0:06:06maybe on some desktop computers and some
0:06:09operating systems some people think it
0:06:10works great but no one has really nailed
0:06:12it on the phone to the point where it's
0:06:13better than fingerprint unlock or you
0:06:16know typing in a code or whatever I also
0:06:18do still do think that there are
0:06:20significant challenges with face
0:06:21recognition as an unlock method around
0:06:24the issues of how do you confirm the
0:06:27authentication and what do you do if you
0:06:29don't want to authenticate something you
0:06:31know and one one person I think it was
0:06:32on Twitter pointed out the example of
0:06:34like what if someone takes your phone
0:06:36out of your hand and hold it up to your
0:06:38face and then it like if the only come
0:06:41from
0:06:41thing is recognize your face and then
0:06:44tap a thing on screen to say okay then
0:06:47somebody can take your phone and just
0:06:49authorize it right there in front of you
0:06:50and then walk away we're gonna make
0:06:52another Indiana Jones reference but a
0:06:54writ is lost our current so you know
0:06:56that one like the the watch
0:06:59authentication where once you unlock
0:07:01your watch as long as it's on your wrist
0:07:03it's it's you know it stays unlocked but
0:07:05if someone is to steal your watch it
0:07:06automatically locks when it leaves your
0:07:08wrist so I can imagine a similar feature
0:07:10where the gesture of picking it up and
0:07:14putting your finger on part of the
0:07:15screen your finger has to be there then
0:07:18then the camera recognizes you then you
0:07:20press the screen or slide in a direction
0:07:23or whatever and if any point in that
0:07:25chain like that your finger leaves the
0:07:27phone surface oh wherever you're
0:07:29supposed to be holding them then then
0:07:31it's all over so some pull the thing out
0:07:32here out of your hand and you know I
0:07:38don't know it's a difficult problem
0:07:39you'd have to incorporate you'd have to
0:07:40incorporate the fingerprint sensor I
0:07:41guess but right like and the thing is
0:07:47like the more complex that the gesture
0:07:49is or the more requirements it has to
0:07:52succeed in to unlock the phone and to
0:07:54keep the phone unlocked the more often
0:07:56that it won't work in legitimate use you
0:07:58know the more legitimate use cases I
0:08:00have were like okay well what if I want
0:08:01to often to keep my phone while it's
0:08:02sitting on a table and I could put my
0:08:03thumb on it now but you know if you have
0:08:05to have your hand on a certain part like
0:08:06touch ID is so good I feel like it
0:08:11solves so it solves or avoids so many of
0:08:14these other weird little problems that
0:08:16it would it would really take a lot to
0:08:19make it worth not using touch ID anymore
0:08:22I don't know I'm glad this is still a
0:08:25rumored feature so don't even know if
0:08:26shipping at all we won't have to
0:08:27consider this but oh I guess we'll all
0:08:29find out I still think it would be neat
0:08:31to like just have it sort of work by
0:08:34magic and just pick up your phone and
0:08:35using it's just automatically unlocked
0:08:37because you're you I would probably
0:08:39sacrifice that for for the security of
0:08:42like oh what if someone rips the phone
0:08:44out of your hand because you know that's
0:08:46not that common enough occurrence and my
0:08:49circles that I travel in but for other
0:08:52people I mean obviously if you have an
0:08:53option to turn this on or off
0:08:54really help let people decide what their
0:08:56security profile is and we said in the
0:08:59last show if you're in a situation like
0:09:01in an airport or you're going through
0:09:02immigration in some country you'd want
0:09:04to avoid both touch ID and deface
0:09:06recognition because you can be you know
0:09:08compelled to unlock your phone in that
0:09:09way there are other ways where you can
0:09:10lock down your phone so that you have to
0:09:12enter a big long password which they
0:09:14would have to you know use what was it
0:09:17rubber-hose cryptography pipe wrench
0:09:19retiree tog Rafi this depending on what
0:09:21version butters from the xkcd comic or
0:09:23from the idea that the ask a CD comic is
0:09:25derived from they just beat you with a
0:09:27pipe wrench until you tell them the
0:09:28password this reminds me also of the the
0:09:32watch unlock on the desktop so if you
0:09:37have an Apple watch that is actively
0:09:39unlocked you're I forget the exact
0:09:40requirements I think you're all on the
0:09:41same like iCloud account or something
0:09:43like that and you've enabled everything
0:09:45on every device then what you can do is
0:09:46if your watch is physically close to say
0:09:50your iMac or something like that and you
0:09:53tap a keyboard button or a mouse button
0:09:55to wake it up then it's it will see if
0:09:58your watch is nearby and if it's nearby
0:09:59and it's authenticated etc then it will
0:10:03go ahead and unlock the Mac for you and
0:10:06that seems perfectly reasonable until
0:10:09you think about say in office where you
0:10:11know most of us work in cubicles and so
0:10:14what if I'm a couple cubes down or maybe
0:10:17it the next cube over and somebody goes
0:10:20up to my work machine and neo smacks the
0:10:24keyboard and it feels like my watch is
0:10:26close enough then guess what that
0:10:28thing's getting unlocked and on the
0:10:30surface that's terrible but in reality
0:10:32you should in theory be close enough
0:10:35that you can hopefully see what is going
0:10:38on with your device and if you're not
0:10:41close enough to see what's going on it
0:10:42hopefully wouldn't allow itself to be
0:10:43unlocked but it's a similar kind of
0:10:46problem right where there's a pretty
0:10:48reasonable explanation or expectation I
0:10:51should say that you are close and that
0:10:53is the intended results for your device
0:10:55to unlock but you don't know for sure
0:10:57now the difference is which I didn't get
0:11:00a chance to talk to you before the chat
0:11:01rooms started yelling at me that you get
0:11:03a notification on your watch hey
0:11:04such-and-such has been unlocked
0:11:05but it to me rings a similar set of
0:11:10potential problems and for me it's been
0:11:12working out really well and it's super
0:11:13convenient so I kind of agree with you
0:11:15John that in the circles I travel in
0:11:17yeah I'm not too worried about it
0:11:18by the way Casey as the person who knows
0:11:20that they've seen Raiders can you do you
0:11:23know what reference I was going to make
0:11:24before I bail no I definitely
0:11:27I've seen Raiders many times but I do
0:11:29not know they're a beginning bit with
0:11:30the idol I gotta take the idol off but
0:11:33put a sandbag of equal weight like
0:11:34someone maintained at the part that
0:11:38you're it's kind of like stealing your
0:11:39watch while keeping something touching
0:11:41the sensor on the bottom so it stays
0:11:43unlocked you know I bet Apollo Robbins
0:11:44could do that yeah that's I was just
0:11:46about to ask who's that guy that can do
0:11:48that unbelievable like stealing stuff
0:11:51while you're talking to that but that's
0:11:53his next level you gets an Apple
0:11:54sponsorship like he can remove people's
0:11:55watches without them knowing but can you
0:11:57do it while at the same time like
0:11:59keeping something touching the proximity
0:12:01sensors underneath the watch so it
0:12:02remains unlocked that's the trick all
0:12:05right moving on before I get stuck in
0:12:07some Apollo Robbins videos they are
0:12:09mesmerizing all right an anonymous Apple
0:12:12source familiar with mdns responder has
0:12:14also written in they said now I'm
0:12:17quoting you said mdns responder was a
0:12:19mess and had tons of bugs John said that
0:12:21we didn't say that
0:12:23I couldn't let that pass without a
0:12:25response the reasons for the Bonjour
0:12:27rewrite were entirely political nothing
0:12:30to do with mdns responder if your
0:12:32manager looking for something for your
0:12:33team to do rewriting some extra software
0:12:35seems much safer much existing software
0:12:37excuse me seems much safer much more
0:12:39predictable than thinking of something
0:12:41new for yourself rewriting something
0:12:42from scratch as we all know is that
0:12:44terrible idea and there's a link to the
0:12:46seminal Joel and software blog post
0:12:49about this very thing coming back to the
0:12:51email if you measure it in admittedly
0:12:53crude simple numerical terms of number
0:12:55of devices deployed mdns responders
0:12:57arguably the most successful piece of
0:12:58software ever to come out of Apple as
0:13:00well as being on an almost every Apple
0:13:02product it's also many other devices
0:13:03almost all network printers TiVo network
0:13:05cameras etc and in every Android device
0:13:08which is not just Android phones and
0:13:09tablets but also Android based
0:13:10accessories if you consider the quality
0:13:14and robustness of the mdns responder
0:13:17code is illustrated by the fact that
0:13:18even after being neglected for five
0:13:20years finding an old copy of mdns
0:13:22responder from a previous OS version and
0:13:23installing it on Yosemite still worked
0:13:25better than discovery d software Apple
0:13:27brief briefly shipped before reverting
0:13:29back to mdns responder I'm amused that
0:13:32you heard that the return to UM DNS
0:13:34responder was instigated by celebrity
0:13:35emailing Tim Cook you're right about
0:13:37that part except it wasn't Bono
0:13:39wasn't Bono was Vint Cerf fair enough
0:13:42and who is Vint Cerf can you explain to
0:13:44the audience that's why we have link to
0:13:45the Wikipedia page one of the fathers of
0:13:47the internet an old guy who did a lots
0:13:49of important work on the early internet
0:13:50is that you know I'm not that old so
0:13:55well first getting back to the part of
0:13:57this of NBS responder being a buggy
0:14:00there's a basis for that like first of
0:14:03all being neglected for five years it's
0:14:04never good for any piece of software
0:14:06second as a regular user it was not
0:14:09uncommon to have weird problems with
0:14:12your Mac and to have the solution be
0:14:13killing em DNS responder right I think I
0:14:16don't know if you guys remember that but
0:14:17I certainly do right so whether you want
0:14:20to consider it a buggy mess or whatever
0:14:22it is something that would be a
0:14:24candidate for hey this this essential
0:14:28piece of the system seems like it might
0:14:29be getting a little creaky and if
0:14:31someone has a good idea about how to
0:14:32vastly improve it by all means do it the
0:14:35Jones software thing about you should
0:14:37think you should never do you should
0:14:38never rewrite suffer a law that's been
0:14:40hashed out to death I mean it's it's a
0:14:42good presentation of a particular of one
0:14:44side of a particular issue but of course
0:14:46sometimes you do have to rewrite things
0:14:47so many good things that we love came
0:14:49from the decision to rewrite things you
0:14:51just have to know when to do it and when
0:14:52not to do it was basically Joel's point
0:14:53but it was expressed in a very
0:14:55hyperbolic way of like oh you should
0:14:56just totally never do this let me tell
0:14:57you all the great things that are about
0:14:58like software that already has all the
0:15:00corner cases and you know all the
0:15:04education all the things that you've
0:15:06learned over the years right baked into
0:15:08it but on the Mac we have examples of
0:15:11rewrites that are great and a lot of you
0:15:14know important things that we have on
0:15:15the Mac today are because someone
0:15:17decided to abandon some old code and
0:15:18rewrite it and we have some cautionary
0:15:20tales so I think there's a reasonable
0:15:21mix and I think it's not you know out of
0:15:24bounds to say the mdns responder as it
0:15:26was a candidate because it did cause
0:15:27real-world problems for regular people
0:15:29to the
0:15:30it wasn't exactly the P Ram point but it
0:15:32was the point at a certain point in the
0:15:33history of the Mac that killing him DNS
0:15:36responder to fix a whole host of
0:15:37problems it became like one of those
0:15:38things you might just want to try
0:15:39because it could be what's going now
0:15:41politically speaking who knows maybe
0:15:43this because they said oh just don't
0:15:45ever fix MDS respond over five years
0:15:47whoever this person who wrote it seems
0:15:48to think the project was neglected but
0:15:51obviously discovery D was not a
0:15:54successful rewrite and whatever reason
0:15:55that the rewrite was undertaken and the
0:15:58people who did it and whether that the
0:16:00expertise are really understood what
0:16:02mdns responder was doing and how it did
0:16:03it and all the decisions that led to its
0:16:05design all the things they learned it
0:16:07just seems like it was not it was not a
0:16:10project undertaken with the right
0:16:11attitude and by the right people but
0:16:14anyway this as to the idea of MDS
0:16:18responder being on lots of different
0:16:20systems this is news to me as well I
0:16:23suppose it's got to be an open-source
0:16:26component or maybe it's part of some
0:16:28wider like I don't whether it's part of
0:16:30Darwin or something even bigger
0:16:32open-source component I don't know I
0:16:33mean I only know it because it's that
0:16:34process that I had to kill my Mac
0:16:35sometimes it was super important and
0:16:37then most people know because it's the
0:16:38thing that came back to your place
0:16:39discovery didn't make your max work
0:16:40again well I did some very very quick
0:16:42research sorry for everyone who knows a
0:16:44lot more about it than this but so
0:16:45Bonjour is the is the zeroconf
0:16:48networking protocol that Apple
0:16:50popularized under that name and
0:16:52basically if you wanted to you know use
0:16:54like a network printer or I use network
0:16:56shares that were just listed by their
0:16:57names automatically find each other
0:16:59there's there's a very good chance it's
0:17:00using this Bonjour protocol part of the
0:17:03Bonjour software is M the NS responder
0:17:06which is like the daemon on the systems
0:17:08that manages that that apparently MDX
0:17:11responder itself is open-source under
0:17:13the Apache License and and so it
0:17:16apparently went into all sorts of things
0:17:17that had to support zeroconf networking
0:17:20and/or bond the Bonjour protocol I think
0:17:23you mean rendezvous right what a better
0:17:26name rendezvous it was like so zeroconf
0:17:28is the techie nerdy tech nology and then
0:17:31rendezvous was how Apple branded it but
0:17:33then in one of the rare cases or Apple
0:17:35lost or decided not to fight someone
0:17:37challenging their I figure what
0:17:39situation was whether they just said oh
0:17:40never mind
0:17:40in your name or they actually lost the
0:17:42court case they have to change it so
0:17:44they changed upon her which is not bad
0:17:45but boy rendezvous it was better exactly
0:17:47so anyway so it appears that like lots
0:17:50of different operating systems and
0:17:51devices like printers and stuff all
0:17:53embedded ambience responder because it
0:17:56was open source so apparently that's why
0:17:59it kind of went in all these different
0:18:01things and went everywhere and is
0:18:03apparently in Android as well which is
0:18:04pretty pretty impressive that's that's
0:18:05you know that is okay I gotta give this
0:18:08guy credit for pointing out the stuff
0:18:09like that is really quite widespread and
0:18:13I always just assumed it was just an
0:18:15apple thing but nope
0:18:16oh I would add the idea of it being
0:18:18successful in it being deployed
0:18:20everywhere two very different things
0:18:21there's lots of software that's deployed
0:18:23everywhere the success if your success
0:18:27is just measured by how far and wide you
0:18:29spread all sorts of terrible things can
0:18:31be quote unquote successful Windows that
0:18:34many but even if you just take some
0:18:37terrible code in the core of UNIX that's
0:18:40just been passed around because it's
0:18:42sort of unimportant but it's just that's
0:18:43where a lot of bugs and buffer overflows
0:18:45come from some really old library and
0:18:48some BSD UNIX variant that just gets
0:18:52passed around and no one ever looks at
0:18:54it and it's just gross crusty little
0:18:55corner and yeah anyway I don't know
0:19:00exactly why mdns responder was chosen as
0:19:05a victim for a rewrite but I think it
0:19:07was it was a reasonable decision but it
0:19:11was followed up by terrible executions
0:19:12so you gotta you get both parts of it if
0:19:14you if you identify the parts of justice
0:19:16and that could benefit from rewrites
0:19:17then you do a bad job you have not
0:19:19succeeded what it's worth open-source
0:19:22not Apple comm slash source slash mdns
0:19:24responder oh and by the way now that we
0:19:28know more about the open source nature
0:19:29of this maybe it wasn't such a good
0:19:30candidate because when there is a
0:19:32project like an open source project that
0:19:33lots of other people use that is sort of
0:19:35being worked on like other people have a
0:19:37stake in this like if mdns responder
0:19:39really is broken or whatever presumably
0:19:40there's lots of people from lots of
0:19:41different companies that are motivated
0:19:43to make it not suck right and you say
0:19:45you know what we're gonna write our own
0:19:47thing it's like saying we've been using
0:19:49WebKit which everybody helps update but
0:19:51we would like our own engine so we're
0:19:52just gonna start our own from
0:19:53scratch again it's probably not a great
0:19:54idea now I'm DNS responders house same
0:19:56things web kid obviously in terms of
0:19:57complexity importance but if everyone
0:19:59else in the industry is using endianness
0:20:01responder and presumably updating it and
0:20:02fixing it and you decide to go to on
0:20:04your own boy you better have the best
0:20:05team available with lots of people on it
0:20:08to equal the effort and smarts and
0:20:11experience of everyone else who's
0:20:12maintaining in the as responder so
0:20:14perhaps it wasn't actually such a great
0:20:15candidate this episode is brought to you
0:20:18by Squarespace start building your
0:20:21website today at squarespace.com and her
0:20:24offer code ATP at checkout to get 10%
0:20:25off make your next move with Squarespace
0:20:29pretty much any project you want to do
0:20:31today you need a website and there's
0:20:34lots of different ways to host websites
0:20:35but most of them are incredibly time
0:20:37consuming or incredibly difficult or
0:20:40need a lot of maintenance over time with
0:20:43Squarespace they handle everything for
0:20:46you they handle the hosting the security
0:20:48you don't have to deal with software
0:20:49updates anything like that handling big
0:20:51spikes and load Squarespace handles it
0:20:53all for you and you don't have to worry
0:20:56about it you can focus on the actual
0:20:58reason you make your site in the first
0:20:59place your business your project your
0:21:02hobby your portfolio your store your
0:21:04blog your podcast you can host all of
0:21:07these wonderful site types on
0:21:08Squarespace and so many more and that
0:21:10there's some hardwoods in there remember
0:21:11I said store podcasts like these are
0:21:13hard things to host and Squarespace can
0:21:16do it all start a free trial today at
0:21:18squarespace.com to see for yourself when
0:21:20you need just try it see what you can do
0:21:22in like an hour or two when you need to
0:21:24make a website for something maybe you
0:21:26don't need it today but next time you
0:21:28need to make a website
0:21:28try squarespace first you'll be shocked
0:21:30what you can do in so little time and
0:21:32then it's done and it looks amazing it
0:21:35looks professional these are
0:21:36professionally designed templates you
0:21:38can customize them to your heart's
0:21:39content with drag-and-drop it's so easy
0:21:42even if you have no skill whatsoever
0:21:44making websites you can use Squarespace
0:21:46to make something beautiful
0:21:47so check out today go to Squarespace com
0:21:49start that free trial when you sign up
0:21:51make sure to use offer code ATP to get
0:21:5410% off your first purchase make your
0:21:57next move with a beautiful website from
0:21:59Squarespace
0:22:02all right Syd Polk writes I was at Apple
0:22:05when do you ILD to was developed and
0:22:07released there was a guy who worked on
0:22:10linkers he was bothered one day by how
0:22:12slow do LD was so he spent the weekend
0:22:14writing a new one from scratch because
0:22:16why not it was eventually released in a
0:22:17software update during the 10.3 cycle
0:22:20but the release notes for it were
0:22:21included in the 10.4 release the
0:22:23engineer who wrote dild 2 also wrote
0:22:25dild 3 I trust Kim's specifically also
0:22:30this is what public betas are for we did
0:22:32not have those in 2003 which is kind of
0:22:34funny I think people are surprised at
0:22:37exactly how few people are responsible
0:22:40for such important part so this isn't
0:22:41like they always assume is like hundreds
0:22:43of engineer and is like I figure what
0:22:45Twitter's employee count was some was
0:22:47something obscene like 3,000 employees
0:22:49or something like what are all those
0:22:51people doing and then you learn like how
0:22:52many people work on you know the dynamic
0:22:55linker for the Mac operating system and
0:22:58iOS and TV Oh us and watch OS and you're
0:23:01like boy that's probably a team of a
0:23:02couple hundred people it's like five
0:23:03people it's like five you know and
0:23:05really like like two or three of them
0:23:07are doing the bulk of the work and the
0:23:08guy who did the D way LD you know is
0:23:10largely responsible for the do LD three
0:23:12also was responsible to do lb 2 and he
0:23:14did it in a weekend and an earlier more
0:23:16innocent time push it out in a software
0:23:18update in the middle of the ten point
0:23:19three point next cycle you know this is
0:23:22a different time but even today like the
0:23:24teams are teams at Apple are smaller
0:23:26than you think
0:23:27and that gets back to the whole like how
0:23:29money can't solve your your talent and
0:23:31retention problems like if you could
0:23:32mold money into the shape of people
0:23:34Gollum style or Gollum style and or how
0:23:37to pronounce it in this context Apple
0:23:39would do it but they can't they actually
0:23:40have to hire people and keep them happy
0:23:41and give them interesting things to do
0:23:43and you need the right people and very
0:23:45often some of the best software is
0:23:46written by very small teams of people
0:23:48who really know what they're doing and
0:23:49are very enthusiastic rather than
0:23:51hundreds and hundreds of people being
0:23:53directed by seventeen levels of
0:23:55management fair enough
0:23:57also it's Gangnam style actually I
0:24:00probably even pronounce that wrong there
0:24:01you go all right anyway please cut that
0:24:04from the show so I don't get a million
0:24:05pieces of feedback no anyhow hair in
0:24:08Kirkland writes in on my Mac to FX I had
0:24:12that is not a very good name of him
0:24:14honest but
0:24:14on my Mac what's not good about 2fx
0:24:18that's one of the best Mac names ever
0:24:20one of the best Mac's everyone FX who
0:24:23does like FX it's pronounced effects
0:24:25it's got an accident so it's cool that's
0:24:27a it's a pun for effects it was the name
0:24:30of a movie in the 80s about special
0:24:31effects they don't make those anymore
0:24:33now you get now you see them which is
0:24:35about magic or something terrible
0:24:37remember movie magic that was a great TV
0:24:39show effects the whole yeah neither one
0:24:41of you is probably seeing that effects
0:24:43and that's probably a terrible 80s movie
0:24:44but Casey might like it don't you make
0:24:53fun of fun for October no I'm just
0:24:54saying like you're not gonna turn up
0:24:56your nose at a movie with like slightly
0:24:58dated sort of tropes or whatever anyway
0:25:00FX was a great movie to get movies
0:25:03terrible in case you would like it I
0:25:04know right great movie to catch on a
0:25:08Saturday when you're 12 years old I
0:25:11don't know if I love you John or both on
0:25:14my Mac two effects horrible name or not
0:25:17right snare in Kirkland I had a floppy
0:25:18disc or a little while why are we still
0:25:20talking about this i poppy disc
0:25:21autoloader that would hold 25 discs for
0:25:24unattempted retrospect backup and it
0:25:27relied on auto inject this is the
0:25:29discussion actually I was having with
0:25:31Merlin at some point oh I think it was
0:25:32off the air about I had this
0:25:34recollection that there were devices
0:25:36that would do the floppy swapping for
0:25:39you I'm like that's probably just
0:25:40something I was thinking of when I was a
0:25:42kid I don't think those things ever
0:25:44existed because when you're swapping
0:25:45floppies manually you're like surely I
0:25:47can make a machine do you know some sort
0:25:48of Rube Goldberg machine to do this for
0:25:51me right but this person says that
0:25:55apparently such thing actually existed
0:25:57so my I convinced myself that it was
0:25:59like a false memory but then I asked you
0:26:01remember the make and model and he
0:26:03didn't I would love to if anyone anyway
0:26:06if anybody has knows more about these
0:26:08can provide like a picture or a name or
0:26:10something to Google so we can find one
0:26:12of these things and see what it looked
0:26:13like I would love to see such a thing
0:26:14you can always you can't rely on the
0:26:16world of large-scale backup hardware
0:26:19like tape drives and everything else for
0:26:21the weirdest stuff out there you do a
0:26:24large-scale backups on to 3.5 inch
0:26:26floppy disks that sounds great right
0:26:28well you know and and because like there
0:26:30was a need for that like not everybody
0:26:32needed that at that time but someone
0:26:33needed it and someone was willing to pay
0:26:35thousands of dollars for that probably
0:26:36yeah retrospect whether it was a Mac
0:26:39backup program which someone the chat
0:26:41room was saying was terrible but I think
0:26:42had some kind of neat features I used it
0:26:44for many years all right any other
0:26:46follow-up kids we're still in follow up
0:26:49I know this was a long one those emails
0:26:52were good though so that's true
0:26:54they were pretty good I'll give I'll
0:26:55give John a bye on this one because we
0:26:57all know good follow-up is our fault but
0:26:59bad follow-up is John's fault that
0:27:01sounds right all right so chief waffler
0:27:08in chief what'd you buy these days this
0:27:12was not a waffle this was just straight
0:27:13up narrower down that question Casey
0:27:18what did you buy in the last four
0:27:21biggest thing physically speaking that
0:27:23you purchased recently what what impulse
0:27:27buy what multi-thousand dollar impulse
0:27:29buy did you just do so we've had our our
0:27:34wonderful plasma 42-inch Panasonic 85u
0:27:38TV for about ten years and it's fine
0:27:43it's great but you know in in the room
0:27:46that we have it in like we we have a
0:27:49pretty large like first floor great room
0:27:51in our house when I first got this TV I
0:27:53was still in apartments and it was great
0:27:55for apartment for apartments in the room
0:27:57we had it in it was a little small for
0:28:00like the setup we had in that room but
0:28:01it was still fine so I was just waiting
0:28:03for it to die before I replaced it I
0:28:05didn't want it to die for a long time
0:28:08because a nice 1080p plasma was still
0:28:14kind of the best thing you could get for
0:28:15a while and I often wanted to die for a
0:28:18while because over time like when I
0:28:20bought it you could get a 42 inch screen
0:28:23that was like the highest quality type
0:28:26of screen today if you want a great
0:28:29image quality TV the smallest you can
0:28:32get them in is usually 55 inches and for
0:28:36a long time I was I was kind of hoping
0:28:38that my TV would hold out long or long
0:28:40or longer because
0:28:42a 55-inch plasmas were huge like you
0:28:46know because plasmas still retained
0:28:48quite a bit of thickness and bezel with
0:28:50you know even even until the end of
0:28:52plasmas compared to the other
0:28:54technologies and so a 55 inch plasma was
0:28:57a pretty big thing and I thought that
0:28:59would be too big for the room and for
0:29:00the TV stand and everything else so I
0:29:02really didn't want to upgrade to that I
0:29:03also like 1080p was great and like i
0:29:06already had 1080p with great color great
0:29:08black levels like great you know great
0:29:10brightness everything else because
0:29:11plasmas are awesome so I was basically I
0:29:15didn't want to have to replace my TV
0:29:17until he got a really great 4k HDR OLED
0:29:22TV because I hate LCD like LCD is a
0:29:26terrible TV technology the only thing
0:29:28good about it is that it costs almost
0:29:29nothing that's it
0:29:31everything else about LCD TVs is
0:29:33terrible so I wanted to use go from
0:29:36plasma to OLED and don't don't even give
0:29:39me anything about LED TVs because we all
0:29:41know that's fake that's a wonderful
0:29:42marketing sleight of hand I can't
0:29:44believe they pulled it off but they did
0:29:45anyway
0:29:46when we were at the beach last week the
0:29:49house had a really big cheap LCD TV that
0:29:54was about 50 inches and TIFF messaged me
0:29:56one night saying ok we can get a bigger
0:30:00TV I said nothing and within 45 seconds
0:30:05it was already ordered in on its way why
0:30:08was she saying that because she was
0:30:09watching the cruddy LCD TV in there it
0:30:13was like why does that mean we can get
0:30:14AB it was the one in the house 2 small
0:30:17fir
0:30:17I think she was fine I think seeing the
0:30:20cruddy one finally convinced her that a
0:30:22bigger TV can look really nice oh it was
0:30:26this one bigger it's 50 you said yeah
0:30:28it's 50 and I was compared to 42 and so
0:30:31she was like wow this 50-inch does it
0:30:33feels so much bigger sitting closer to
0:30:35it then yeah she also was sitting closer
0:30:38to it yes but anyway I've been dying to
0:30:40get a know a 4k OLED TV ever since I saw
0:30:44one and Best Buy like last year and I
0:30:47already had all the research done that
0:30:49like you know that if I had the reason
0:30:51to get a 4k TV this year that I would
0:30:54get an LG
0:30:56you know whatever the LG 4k OLED series
0:30:59of the year was because all the reviews
0:31:02seemed to be in pretty wide agreement
0:31:04that that's basically the best one out
0:31:06there
0:31:07so finally TIFF said okay we can get a
0:31:12bigger TV and I said absolutely nothing
0:31:15about it until it arrived because I did
0:31:20not want to bring the conversation back
0:31:22up to have it maybe be back down or have
0:31:25her mind changed this I'm not sure if
0:31:28this is indicative of you having
0:31:30mastered marriage or you having a real
0:31:34and true problem with buying shit or
0:31:37maybe both to be honest with you TIFF
0:31:40did not appreciate this strategy where
0:31:50are you sleeping tonight are you
0:31:53this resulted in a she to get me back
0:31:57for it she pairs got me undoing all the
0:31:59wires and stuff with the old one which
0:32:01is basically used to periscope of my
0:32:02butt leaning over the TV stand for like
0:32:05an hour and now we are even but by the
0:32:09way the small TV problem remains we have
0:32:12a small TV in our bedroom and it was so
0:32:13hard to find a small television they
0:32:17forget about like the best picture
0:32:19quality just like not the worst picture
0:32:21quality because small televisions are
0:32:24like Oh someone's gonna use in the
0:32:25kitchen so put the crappiest thing you
0:32:28can it hasn't gotten better over time as
0:32:30everything's crept up it used to be the
0:32:31good TVs were 42 that new go TVs were 50
0:32:34this is the minimum size now like you
0:32:36said the good TVs are 55 minimum size
0:32:38everything's creeping up so to try to
0:32:41find like now it's a choices kitchen TV
0:32:43or 55 inch and in between the bill mans
0:32:46land of crap yeah basically it's so I'm
0:32:49sorry what model did you order Marco so
0:32:52I I did what I had been researching to
0:32:54do I did a quick double-check before
0:32:56just make sure nothing have changed
0:32:58but everyone seemed to agree so I got
0:33:00the LG 2017 4k OLED series that has
0:33:04sevens in the names and they have they
0:33:06put a number in front of or a letter in
0:33:08front of them to indicate
0:33:09as far as I can tell nothing except like
0:33:11the soundbar that's included so you can
0:33:14pay like a small or you well no no no
0:33:16these are small amounts you can pay a
0:33:17smaller amount to get one with just like
0:33:20regular TV speakers in it like on the
0:33:21back and then you can pay like a
0:33:23thousand dollars more to get a little
0:33:24sound bar in the bottom and I hate sound
0:33:26bars anyway so that that was not gonna
0:33:28be a thing and then you could pay a
0:33:29thousand dollars more than that to get
0:33:31like even better of a sound bar on the
0:33:33bottom or something and and so the one I
0:33:36got is the base model of the 2017 one
0:33:38which is the LG c7 TV so it's amazing
0:33:43that 55 inches yeah 55 yeah so why
0:33:47didn't you go to 65 well first I knew I
0:33:51wanted I knew I had to like sell this
0:33:52when it arrived and and now that we see
0:33:56it in the room I think I actually
0:33:58probably could have pulled off 65 but
0:34:01the reason why I'm glad I'm pretty sure
0:34:04I'm happy enough with the 55 now is that
0:34:06first of all it is a substantial upgrade
0:34:08from 42 but the good thing is the TV
0:34:11itself does not look that much bigger on
0:34:13the shelf because there's such a
0:34:15difference in bezel width like the the
0:34:17new one has almost no bezel at all and
0:34:19the old one the bezels were like you
0:34:21know three inches on all sides it's a
0:34:24huge difference in bezel width and
0:34:27thickness like the new one looks really
0:34:29sleek and has a screen that is more than
0:34:3210 inches bigger but it doesn't look
0:34:34like that that much bigger of a TV which
0:34:36is nice because we we don't want the TV
0:34:39to like dominate the look of the room
0:34:41like when you get a TV that's too big
0:34:43for the room or this even just like kind
0:34:45of big for the room that is like your
0:34:47eye is drawn to that even when it's off
0:34:49like it's you just have like this big
0:34:50black wall in your room like it's
0:34:53something that is very dominant and
0:34:54because like our TV is not like in some
0:34:58like back room of the house it's like
0:35:00the main room like we walk into our
0:35:02house and you're in this like main room
0:35:03that has the TV in the living room and
0:35:05dining room all like in one big room to
0:35:08make the TV substantially bigger I think
0:35:10would would look too big for the room
0:35:13but now we have the actual screen size
0:35:15of the bigger TV without it looking that
0:35:17much bigger so it's almost like we've
0:35:19got the extra screen size like for free
0:35:21visually but the head about the touch
0:35:23idea
0:35:23the back though the only thing is TVs
0:35:28have gotten a lot more full of crappy
0:35:30software since I last bought a TV 10
0:35:32years ago or worse products through
0:35:34software yeah exactly green like this TV
0:35:37takes a good 20 seconds to boot I don't
0:35:41know why a TV has to boot but
0:35:42fortunately if you just put it in like
0:35:44standby mode instead of turning it
0:35:46because it's got away boss you have to
0:35:48say it like yeah all software on TVs is
0:35:50terrible but everyone agrees this is the
0:35:53best software on TVs or close to the
0:35:55best I mean there is there's some
0:35:57disagreement but if you want any kind of
0:35:58quote-unquote Smart TV features the
0:36:00webOS things that that LG uses are the
0:36:04least disgusting let's say that because
0:36:06nobody does what Panasonic used to which
0:36:08is completely utilitarian minimal like I
0:36:12remember my first Panasonic Plasma had
0:36:14like the volume the little volume bar
0:36:16that appears and screaming you change
0:36:17the volume mm-hmm
0:36:18was really small and was jammed against
0:36:21the bottom edge of the screen so it
0:36:22obscured its little like nobody does
0:36:24that now now you change the volume and
0:36:26it's like a giant fairy comes out and
0:36:27waves a magic wand that sparkles fly
0:36:30from it and this bar from a bubbling
0:36:32liquid moves forward in this pulsing
0:36:34past I know my god just change the
0:36:36volume the good thing is it's actually
0:36:39you know even though that the software
0:36:41is really kind of overbearing it is it
0:36:44doesn't seem like it's horrible software
0:36:47it's just it's software where I don't
0:36:50really need there to be software but the
0:36:52good thing is it also has built-in apps
0:36:54for Netflix and Amazon video so every TV
0:36:57has that excite no III this is this is
0:37:00again like the offer people it's like
0:37:01yes we know we invented those years ago
0:37:02yeah I know but so it's new to me and
0:37:05it's actually kind of nice and it's got
0:37:07the the little accelerometer remote with
0:37:11a little mouse cursor thing which I
0:37:12thought would be terrible but having
0:37:13used it it's it's actually pretty good
0:37:15we have different opinions about that no
0:37:17you know like it I mean the alternative
0:37:19is using like a five-way pad to move a
0:37:22little thing around I like the little
0:37:23accelerometer of course we're thinking I
0:37:25have not found it to be to have the
0:37:28precision I want maybe that's just me
0:37:29maybe I don't have the precision I want
0:37:31but would you prefer to go tap tap tap
0:37:33tap tap tap because I find it I find it
0:37:36put it this way
0:37:36I find it
0:37:37more precise than the other main thing I
0:37:39use to navigate stuff on TV which is a
0:37:41stupid Apple TV remote where I'm forever
0:37:42trying to swipe vertically and
0:37:44horizontally and that's true it's
0:37:45misinterpreting me yeah yeah so for the
0:37:48listeners who might have missed what we
0:37:49were talking about here the remote to
0:37:51this behaves a lot like a Wii mote where
0:37:53the TV somehow senses I don't know if
0:37:56it's only solar ometer or if it's also a
0:37:58division based thing like the Wii mote
0:37:59head with a little IR bar but somehow
0:38:01they're remote you just wave it around
0:38:03and it moves a little mouse pointer
0:38:05thing on screen and it doesn't I don't
0:38:07I'd say it does not work as well as a
0:38:10Wii mote does in that way is it isn't as
0:38:13precise or stable so it's fine
0:38:16ultimately you know it I'm assuming that
0:38:19there's gonna be a 4k Apple TV update
0:38:22this fall once we have that 4k Apple TV
0:38:25I don't expect to ever use the built-in
0:38:26software on this TV again it's the kind
0:38:29of thing I'm just like setting it up
0:38:29once going through all the pictures
0:38:31having trying to find out how to make it
0:38:32look normal and then you just leave it
0:38:34after that so I I don't expect the
0:38:37software of this TV to matter at all to
0:38:39me you know after this way except for
0:38:41potentially the boot time and whatever
0:38:42the volume control looks like when you
0:38:44move it up and down that's well I'm not
0:38:46I don't use the vine control the TV who
0:38:48uses TV speakers animals that's who we
0:38:52are sponsored this week by betterment
0:38:54investing made better go to betterment
0:38:56comm slash ATP to learn more betterment
0:39:00is a smarter way to invest your money
0:39:01providing investing advice through smart
0:39:04technology automated investing and human
0:39:06advisers they have changed the industry
0:39:08by using the same strategies that
0:39:10financial advisors use with clients who
0:39:11have millions of dollars and making it
0:39:13available to everyone this includes
0:39:16smart rebalancing global diversification
0:39:17tax harvesting and more betterments
0:39:20mission is to help you manage and grow
0:39:22your investments and build your
0:39:24financial future all with very low fees
0:39:27along the way you lose less money over
0:39:30time if you do the math typical
0:39:32investment fees and costs really add up
0:39:34over time and betterments fees are a
0:39:36fraction of the cost of other financial
0:39:38services betterment is also so easy to
0:39:41use they've won awards for their
0:39:43customer experience you can see for
0:39:45yourself with a demo account right on
0:39:46their website if you want ATP listeners
0:39:49can get up to one year man
0:39:51for free for more information visit
0:39:53betterment comm slash ATP terms and
0:39:56conditions apply and investing involves
0:39:58risk from to learn more visit betterment
0:40:01comm slash ATP that's betterment comm
0:40:05slash ATP betterment investing made
0:40:08better watching you briefly on the
0:40:15periscope try to adjust the picture I
0:40:16have some advice here we go this is how
0:40:22TIF gets you back it's not the butt cam
0:40:242017 edition it's giving John insight
0:40:27into how you set up the TV just come to
0:40:29our house and do it for me I mean it's a
0:40:32periscope and he's under the public eye
0:40:34and he's just fiddling around with
0:40:35things but in general what you were
0:40:37doing is exactly what people shouldn't
0:40:38do when they adjust the TV which is play
0:40:40with the settings and try to see it try
0:40:43to think does it look right turn this on
0:40:44turn this off what does this mode mean
0:40:46blah blah blah so you're never gonna
0:40:49you're never gonna arrive at anything
0:40:50that way so to first of all the thing
0:40:52that Marco knows and that everyone else
0:40:54should know is when you buy TV no matter
0:40:56where you get it from almost all the
0:40:58time it is configured badly it might
0:41:03still be in showroom demo mode where
0:41:04everything is like super saturated and
0:41:06super bright with all the effects on but
0:41:08even if it's not the sort of standard
0:41:10default modes on most TVs is not quote
0:41:13unquote accurate it's not what what the
0:41:16people who created the content we're
0:41:18expecting you to see because they're
0:41:19sort of creating it and you know
0:41:21mastering it in in a particular color
0:41:23space with the expectation things look a
0:41:25certain way the only way to get the
0:41:27television configured correctly is to
0:41:29use some sort of calibration thing
0:41:31whether it's an app or a blu-ray or
0:41:33whatever and the tricky part is the the
0:41:37place where your configuration thing
0:41:40comes from like the source affects how
0:41:43you're configuring it like if you can
0:41:46get a configuration thing to run on your
0:41:48Apple TV that will and your and your
0:41:51adjustments are per input that will
0:41:52correctly adjust the Apple TV input but
0:41:54then how do you correctly adjust the
0:41:56input that is you know if you use that
0:41:58same setting and apply it to your other
0:42:00inputs or some TVs don't even let you do
0:42:02like how do you apply that to the
0:42:03blu-ray
0:42:04and how do you applied to one of the
0:42:05cables in or whatever that's something
0:42:06you have to sort it out in every TV but
0:42:07he did right you have to get a
0:42:09calibration thing and there's tons of
0:42:10calibration things that are out there
0:42:11they give you grayscale things they tell
0:42:13you what it should look like and then
0:42:14all sorts of color patterns and then you
0:42:17have to basically mess with the menus of
0:42:21your television to get the test patterns
0:42:23to look correct to do that to figure out
0:42:26I don't know what all these words mean I
0:42:27don't understand but what these you know
0:42:29the settings are like auto you know
0:42:32dynamic fresh dank like you know
0:42:41sometimes if you look in the manual
0:42:42they'll translate them to like the
0:42:45actual meaning but most of the time what
0:42:46you want to do is seek out on the
0:42:47Internet
0:42:48one of those forums where people spend a
0:42:50million years adjusting their TVs and
0:42:51people have like basically Settings
0:42:55lists for the televisions say in order
0:42:57to get this particular exact make and
0:42:59model of television to pass a reasonable
0:43:02calibration test here's all the things I
0:43:04had to change it to and sometimes
0:43:06they'll hopefully say here's what these
0:43:07settings actually mean and this sounds
0:43:09like a long video or like I got to go to
0:43:10internet forums and scroll through like
0:43:12web bulletin boards like it's like 2003
0:43:14and just find setting packs for people
0:43:17and and download them sometimes and it's
0:43:21like here's the thing you only have to
0:43:23do this essentially once and then just
0:43:24to it you know just over every few years
0:43:26right once you get it set up and
0:43:29calibrated according to the calibration
0:43:31app and you and you kind of know what
0:43:33the settings do and you know which ones
0:43:34to how to turn everything off and what
0:43:36the different things mean mostly all you
0:43:38need to do is it just like contrast
0:43:40brightness and a few other things as the
0:43:42screen ages in it and it drifts a little
0:43:43bit and that's really the only way to do
0:43:47it you can't do it by looking at
0:43:48people's faces things that skin look
0:43:49right to you you will never do it that
0:43:51way you can't do it by looking at video
0:43:52and saying does that motion look right
0:43:53to you need to use a calibration app and
0:43:56there's tons of them out there or or you
0:43:58know calibration DVD or calibration
0:44:00blu-ray or whatever the hardest thing to
0:44:02do is cadence which you probably don't
0:44:04care about did you see if you're you
0:44:06didn't even have a blu-ray player do you
0:44:07like to see if you can have the ps4 yeah
0:44:10well do you ever watch it do you ever
0:44:11watch anything that you care is showing
0:44:1324 frames per second kids if you don't
0:44:14care about that you don't need to do it
0:44:15the hardest one to do the only way I've
0:44:17found to do that one is to use a camera
0:44:19and configure to use a shutter that's
0:44:21open for a second and run a pattern that
0:44:23you know does something over the course
0:44:25of a second and you can see if you see
0:44:26even lighting in the one second exposure
0:44:29if you don't see even lighting that
0:44:31you're seeing three to pull there pull
0:44:32down because one frame was on three
0:44:34times the frame was showing two times
0:44:35and the three times when it's brighter
0:44:37the entry times one so you get this sort
0:44:38of checkerboard bright dim bright dim
0:44:40thing that's how you know you're getting
0:44:42the wrong cadence true 24 frames per
0:44:44second cadence everything will be
0:44:45exactly equal brightness because it was
0:44:4724 frames in each one of them as shown
0:44:48you know for the same amount of time
0:44:49that's the hardest to calibrate I don't
0:44:51know how to do that with an app I just
0:44:52know I'd do it with a camera in an app
0:44:54but the other ones just you know get an
0:44:57app and easiest for you you have an
0:44:59Apple TV there are apps on the App Store
0:45:02like thx apps or whatever like go climb
0:45:04on download doesn't really matter which
0:45:06one it is they all kind of have a
0:45:07similar test pattern some of them might
0:45:08be better than others and just spend a
0:45:11day with it and it's important to
0:45:13calibrate it both during the day time at
0:45:14a night time and figure out the balance
0:45:16of brightness especially for televisions
0:45:18I don't know that oh it's not as bright
0:45:20as a LED backlit LCD but I think it's
0:45:23brighter than most plasmas but sometimes
0:45:25you have to make a trade-off between
0:45:26does this look right at night time
0:45:28versus does it look right in day and
0:45:29your television and I believe most
0:45:30televisions have an ambient light sensor
0:45:32they can be like don't worry about it
0:45:33you just calibrate it and I'll use the
0:45:35ambient light sensor to adjust the
0:45:37brightness for you sometimes you want
0:45:38that because it's helpful but other
0:45:40times it'll just screw with your
0:45:41settings so you calibrate it and then
0:45:43night comes and the ambient light sensor
0:45:44screws with all your settings and you
0:45:45can't see anything in the dark scene so
0:45:47if it's up to me I would pick a good
0:45:50medium setting and turn off all the
0:45:53dynamic stuff that this TV is gonna look
0:45:54like exactly like this all the time
0:45:55please do not dynamically adjust
0:45:57anything but anyway it's it's a lot
0:46:00harder than just let me go through the
0:46:01menus and try a few things and I think
0:46:04it's worth while I think it's worth
0:46:05adjusting because if you do if you spend
0:46:07the day adjusting it and you know maybe
0:46:09like three months later or six months
0:46:12later run through the adjustments again
0:46:14just to make sure the thing hasn't
0:46:15drifted and then like save the original
0:46:17setting and like in the middle and when
0:46:19we switch back to the other setting and
0:46:20be like oh god it's just it's terrible
0:46:22it's like it's like suddenly everything
0:46:24was you know you know that it's like a
0:46:26festival in India or something we use
0:46:28colored powders
0:46:29everything something everything is like
0:46:30super oversaturated it's like it doesn't
0:46:33it doesn't look right it doesn't look
0:46:34natural it looks like someone has thrown
0:46:36festive colored powders over everything
0:46:38in your television you don't want that
0:46:39just ask Merlin you know what the
0:46:40powders so did you did you just fiddle
0:46:46with controls and you like act good
0:46:48enough and that you're never gonna
0:46:49revisit it I at least did just finish
0:46:51fiddle with controls and say good enough
0:46:53I don't know if I will ever revisit it
0:46:55or not I probably will cuz we only been
0:46:57we only had like one night with it so
0:46:59far to really play with it so we will
0:47:02probably still be messing with some
0:47:03stuff I will say though that this is
0:47:06probably going to be an area of my life
0:47:09that I choose the kc path add a boy the
0:47:14path of not being very picky just one
0:47:18it's just one day pride in your case one
0:47:21day over the next ten years that you're
0:47:22going on this television just spend the
0:47:24time yeah you said it would also be one
0:47:26day doing bootcamp on Windows to set up
0:47:28the gaming fort if so come over you know
0:47:33take a day off for work that's the other
0:47:35option you can pay someone to calibrate
0:47:37it for you but I think it's a remor you
0:47:38just do yourself with an app but if if
0:47:40the next time I am at your house if you
0:47:43give me some time I will do this to your
0:47:45television because it's a service I
0:47:47provide how busy could you be just come
0:47:49tomorrow at the very least make sure you
0:47:51have the size set correctly can I at
0:47:52least convince you to do that you mean
0:47:54like I like instead of like fake over
0:47:55scanning and then uh exactly like make
0:47:58sure that it's actually showing I think
0:47:59I have it correct I haven't like tested
0:48:01anything like they can verify on the
0:48:02edges but you know how you can tell
0:48:04whether you have it correct calibration
0:48:05now this is like the first thing they're
0:48:07gonna do is like hey can you see all all
0:48:10the pixels of a 1080 in the 4k picture
0:48:12or is it cutting off the stuff around
0:48:14the border because you have fake
0:48:15overscan on alright send me send me the
0:48:19name or a link to an Apple TV app that
0:48:21do you think I should try and I will
0:48:23give it a shot yep but I really can't I
0:48:26don't think I'm gonna spend a day on it
0:48:28that seems like a lot well I I say a day
0:48:30cuz you know whatever you people but it
0:48:33could turn into a day depending on how
0:48:34obsessed you get about it let me guess
0:48:37not terribly obsessed also Marco there's
0:48:39an easy way to fix this problem stop
0:48:41caring well
0:48:42that's the most easy way to the second
0:48:45most easy way and by the way I highly
0:48:47recommend that it's it's wonderful
0:48:48ignorance is list like AC where you
0:48:52can't tell what's going on anyway that's
0:48:53also that's also an easier fix but it
0:48:56also affects other parts of your life
0:48:57take your glasses off that's great but
0:49:00no the the second easiest way to fix
0:49:02this is to tell John that you have three
0:49:05dozen bagels of various varieties that
0:49:08are all on the approved bagel list and
0:49:10all he has to do is come pick them up
0:49:11from your house oh and by the way fix
0:49:13the TV
0:49:13John is free time you can do it yeah
0:49:15that seems reasonable I would do it for
0:49:17three dozen bagels problem solved
0:49:19alright so you happy with it again I've
0:49:23only had like one night to watch it so
0:49:24far but so far yes it is not as dramatic
0:49:28of a change as I would have guessed you
0:49:31know maybe if we don't if we went all
0:49:33the way to 65 it might have been it if
0:49:35you went from a crappy LCD to this it
0:49:37would be you're just used to black
0:49:38levels that are reasonable anyway but I
0:49:40mean I feel although I obviously have
0:49:42many more sense into this than most
0:49:44people but when I went from my previous
0:49:46Panasonic Plasma to my current Panasonic
0:49:48Plasma I was startled by how much better
0:49:50the black levels improved Justin like
0:49:52when you turn it on it's not like a logo
0:49:53like or whatever on a black background
0:49:54and I could tell wow this is you know in
0:49:58my opinion quote unquote dramatically
0:50:00better than my previous plasma but if
0:50:02you had gone from LCD to OLED and you
0:50:04turn on the LCD and it just you know
0:50:05like whatever Samsung and then a black
0:50:07background and this thing it turns it on
0:50:08that says LG and a black background you
0:50:10would be startled by exactly how black
0:50:12it is but going from plasma maybe not as
0:50:14startling to maybe you don't notice much
0:50:16although I have to say your plasma is
0:50:17old enough that it is you know still
0:50:20several generations behind the best
0:50:22plasmas got before like plasmas went
0:50:24away so right because because I got so
0:50:26big I could I couldn't upgrade yeah yeah
0:50:29but but like yeah and also like I've
0:50:31seen very little 4k content on it so far
0:50:33because there just isn't that like right
0:50:35now the only way I had to get 4k in
0:50:37there is the built-in Netflix and Amazon
0:50:38apps the Amazon app I had a very hard
0:50:42time getting it to show me anything in
0:50:434k the Grand Tour no it showed me Grand
0:50:47Tour in HDR but 1080p for some reason
0:50:50like I couldn't get it to set me up to
0:50:514k I don't know I don't know why maybe
0:50:53it's the settings I couldn't file it in
0:50:54the settings couldn't find anywhere
0:50:56I did I was able to see real 4k with
0:51:00Netflix and well I watched a little bit
0:51:03house of cards and so that was nice but
0:51:05house of cards is a pretty dreary gray
0:51:08show it's like like there's so many ways
0:51:11yes so III wasn't able to really see
0:51:16like you know what is like a beautiful
0:51:18nature scene like I want like the stuff
0:51:21they show on the demo reels and Best Buy
0:51:22like all the beautiful nature scenes you
0:51:24need Planet Earth just go good Wow
0:51:27I have Planet Earth but I don't know how
0:51:29to get it in 4k yeah the other thing is
0:51:32that you should look go to one of those
0:51:33viewing distance calculators it could be
0:51:35that your viewing distance and your
0:51:38television size is such that you're
0:51:40gonna have difficulty discerning 4k vs
0:51:431080 at that combination so you're
0:51:46saying I should have gotten the 75 yeah
0:51:48well you have to use one of those
0:51:50calculators to see but I was too proud
0:51:51when I did the tape measure thing to see
0:51:52like here's where I sit on my couch in
0:51:54here so far away my television is yeah I
0:51:56would have to step up to bigger than 55
0:51:59- to really get the benefit of 4k I mean
0:52:02not that it matters like you don't have
0:52:03a choice anymore essentially you're
0:52:04really had a 4k TV whether you want or
0:52:07not we're just fine but I'm saying is
0:52:08that don't don't get hung up on the 4k
0:52:10too much until you've done that
0:52:12measurement to see can my eye even
0:52:14resolve the difference in dot pitch
0:52:17essentially between 1080 and 4k at this
0:52:19size television of this distance well
0:52:22and isn't it isn't just about like being
0:52:24able to resolve individual pixels you
0:52:26know like you can you can look at the
0:52:28screen of an iPhone 7 and then next to
0:52:31it on iphone 7 plus the 7 plus screen
0:52:33has a much higher dpi and the 7 plus
0:52:36screen looks better and you might not be
0:52:39able to identify like oh that I can see
0:52:41pixels on this one on this one I can't
0:52:43like you can't I can't really see them
0:52:44on either of them but 7 plus is non
0:52:46native res though maybe you're just
0:52:48responding to the blurring yeah maybe
0:52:52who knows probably not but anyway so
0:52:54like and there's also HDR the different
0:52:56contrast ratios so like there's a huge
0:52:59amount of improvement to picture quality
0:53:01here that was not just the resolution
0:53:04yeah the framerate and color range
0:53:06potential framerate and color range
0:53:08differences are what you want although
0:53:094k content especially like on Netflix is
0:53:11also very heavily compressed so you know
0:53:14you're gonna run out and buy a blu-ray
0:53:16player but if you really wanted to see
0:53:17what this television can do blu-ray is
0:53:19your highest quality the highest quality
0:53:21video that you can bring to your home
0:53:22still comes on a plastic disc which is
0:53:24sad but true but is there 4k blu-ray is
0:53:27that a thing
0:53:28mmm really I didn't know that can the
0:53:31ps4 non-pro do that I have no idea I
0:53:36don't even know this is one of these
0:53:40teeming away from 4k as I realize I have
0:53:41to just rip out my old set up because
0:53:43I'm pretty sure my receiver maybe it has
0:53:454k passed through on like one of its
0:53:47inputs or whatever I just have to like I
0:53:49have to start over like 40 people in the
0:53:50chat just said no no no no none of the
0:53:53ps4 do this no please don't
0:53:55oh my god no no no so apparently I have
0:53:58to get an Xbox one s x1x
0:54:00but I don't know what that is don't you
0:54:03or you could just get a blu-ray player
0:54:04they're pretty cheap and you can get
0:54:06players or pieces of crap I hate them so
0:54:08much I hate like blue just the the
0:54:10blu-ray spec is the worst thing that has
0:54:12ever happened to movies you know
0:54:13everyone hates it but it still if you
0:54:16want to get like a hundred and something
0:54:18gigabytes of the highest quality video
0:54:19of your favorite movie okay the very
0:54:22least you got to get the blu-ray then
0:54:23rip it on your Mac and then find a way
0:54:25to play it losslessly off of whatever
0:54:27device you put it on which I also still
0:54:29haven't mastered because of the 24
0:54:31frames per second cadence problem as
0:54:32previously discussed although someone
0:54:34did mention this Plex valve for the ps3
0:54:35and when I revisited it and I saw Plex
0:54:38was already installed on my ps3 I think
0:54:39I already tried it but Plex changes fast
0:54:41so maybe it got fixed I don't know maybe
0:54:42the thing is like again like this fault
0:54:44when the Apple TV 4k presumably exists I
0:54:46have a feeling that's going to be my
0:54:48answer to this I think I'm just gonna
0:54:49like by 4k stuff on iTunes and call it a
0:54:52day
0:54:53yeah you hope they have it for sale I
0:54:54know I really hope they have and I also
0:54:56I kind of hope that I can like maybe
0:54:58upgrade some things I've already bought
0:55:00like I bought Planet Earth 2 on iTunes
0:55:02and I know that is available on 4k
0:55:04somewhere and you know if I I would hate
0:55:08to have to like rebuy the whole thing at
0:55:10and like a none discounted new price to
0:55:13just get that but I probably would
0:55:15anyway because it's so good that that's
0:55:18on it like - if you really want to show
0:55:19off 4k you need like you know bright
0:55:21nature scenes but
0:55:22I uh or even just I want to see the
0:55:24Apple TV screen savers in 4k I was
0:55:27thinking look amazing
0:55:28I don't think the source video is 4k
0:55:30though it's like I've watched them so
0:55:33great I think this is 1080 like when
0:55:35you're on Ariel the screensaver on your
0:55:37Mac I'm always struck by how on the 5k
0:55:39iMac anyway I'm like ooh that's blurry
0:55:40like this looks much better I might lose
0:55:42my TV is 1080 in my 5k iMac because you
0:55:44know whatever giant resolution it is
0:55:46well that doesn't mean that the source
0:55:48is not 4k that just means that Apple is
0:55:51not publishing more than 1080 worth of
0:55:53you know stream yeah I understand like
0:55:55are they are they gonna quote they're
0:55:57gonna remaster is they gonna go back to
0:55:58the red 8k footage or whatever this
0:56:00stuff was taken from and and remake all
0:56:02those videos also if you happen to see
0:56:06the back of a truck roll by Marco from
0:56:09what I can tell Grand Tours between 20
0:56:11and 30 gigs for 4k and and there are
0:56:14trucks that haven't but how do I get
0:56:16them onto my TV in a way that actually
0:56:18can play 4k 4k content please don't make
0:56:21it the Grand Tour I know for 4k old man
0:56:26wrinkles no no I agree I agree I'm just
0:56:28trying to think of something that that
0:56:30you would potentially at least slightly
0:56:32enjoy and typically as well shot and
0:56:35pretty yes I understand your point about
0:56:36the old man wrinkles and you're right
0:56:38but I mean generally speaking it's it's
0:56:40it's visually a nice-looking show well
0:56:43anyways to get it on your TV well why
0:56:46not do can you do or you can do 4k over
0:56:50HDMI although usually it's 30 frames per
0:56:52second except in this case that'd be
0:56:53fine I mean I'm pretty sure that there
0:56:55is a new HDMI spec that this TV supports
0:56:57that does 4k 60 I think there you go I
0:57:08spent the money on it instead of after I
0:57:12got approval that I believed I had a
0:57:16narrow window of opportunity well here's
0:57:18the thing but what Marco did is like
0:57:20look if any TV is gonna support all the
0:57:22things make it the most expensive one
0:57:25and it's essentially what you did you
0:57:26didn't get the most most expensive only
0:57:27afforded that weird sound bar crap and
0:57:29everything which I agree is not a good
0:57:31idea but that's that's really all you
0:57:33can do the problem is though like
0:57:34sometimes you look at them
0:57:36most expensive one whose still doesn't
0:57:38have support for the latest whatever
0:57:39that's just about to come out and so
0:57:41you're like okay I can't I can't buy a
0:57:42TV this year I wait till next year but I
0:57:43think you're probably safe yeah because
0:57:45it seems like that the the 4k world has
0:57:49has pretty much reach like the point
0:57:52that it's safe to buy it like we'd use I
0:57:55mean isn't a lot of people give better
0:57:59views of this TV it's like well it's the
0:58:00best picture Pali we've ever seen but it
0:58:02costs a whole jillion dollars so
0:58:03obviously it's not a barrier for you but
0:58:05for other people's like maybe maybe wait
0:58:07like maybe wait one more year or two
0:58:10more years for the same quality
0:58:12television to come down from the middle
0:58:14of the pack or whatever right and the
0:58:16other thing with the Smart TV stuff is
0:58:18over the over the years a lot of that LG
0:58:20Smart TV stuff like I don't know if they
0:58:21weren't using enough RAM or slower
0:58:23processors or whatever but that has
0:58:25gotten faster too and it's like when it
0:58:27first came out well it kind of works but
0:58:29in two years presumably they'll put
0:58:31better chips and their TVs and it will
0:58:32get faster and it has so I think you
0:58:35bought the you know the earliest you
0:58:37could possibly buy and still get all the
0:58:40things and all you had to sacrifice for
0:58:41it was you know a little bit of money
0:58:42and some yelling from your spouse we are
0:58:46sponsored this week by audible with an
0:58:48unmatched selection of audiobooks
0:58:50original audio shows news comedy and
0:58:52more get a free 30-day trial at
0:58:55audible.com slash ATP if you want to
0:58:58listen to it audible has it they have
0:59:01audiobooks virtually every genre and you
0:59:03can listen anytime anywhere phones
0:59:06tablets computers any device you have
0:59:09you can probably play an audible audio
0:59:11book on it audiobooks are great for
0:59:13flights long road trips or even your
0:59:15commute to work every day because you
0:59:18might you might think you don't have
0:59:19time to read books and that might be
0:59:20true but you'd be surprised how many
0:59:22audiobooks you can hear each year if you
0:59:25start listening every day on your daily
0:59:27commute and on various trips and things
0:59:29you will see it really adds up and
0:59:30audiobooks bring books to life you can
0:59:33take risks and you can try new authors
0:59:36and genres without regret without risk
0:59:38because audible offers they're great
0:59:40listen guarantee if you start an
0:59:42audiobook and you don't like it
0:59:43you can trade it for another one for
0:59:45free so see and listen for yourself
0:59:48start your free 30
0:59:50trial and you will get a first audiobook
0:59:52for free and there's no stress or
0:59:54obligation because you can cancel your
0:59:56membership at any time
0:59:57so with audiobooks and spoken word
0:59:57so with audiobooks and spoken word
1:00:00audio product you will find what you're
1:00:01looking for it audible get a free 30-day
1:00:04trial today by signing up at audible.com
1:00:06slash ATP that's audible.com slash ATP
1:00:11thanks to audible for sponsoring our
1:00:13show before we leave the TV topic one
1:00:19I'll take one other brief brief run at
1:00:24trying to convince you / you / the
1:00:26audience to invest in a multi-channel
1:00:31audio solution no you think Sara's just
1:00:33fine I know you think you don't need a
1:00:36subwoofer and left her my channel is
1:00:38fine I mean the way I was gonna try to
1:00:42convince you was like to think about how
1:00:43how concerning it is when viewing an LCD
1:00:47screen and non-native res but that is
1:00:49now an outdated analogy because as you
1:00:52were just saying with the 7 plus if you
1:00:54make the pixel small off doesn't matter
1:00:55but there's no equivalent to making the
1:00:56pixel small enough in the world of audio
1:00:59so lots of these shows that you like
1:01:02including probably house of cards have
1:01:055.1 mix like they have the six channels
1:01:09of audio maybe they have seven I don't
1:01:10know but they have they have
1:01:11multi-channel audio that's what they're
1:01:13putting out and some of them don't have
1:01:16a stereo mix so you have to take that
1:01:185.1 and down mix it through some voodoo
1:01:20into you know you don't be Pro Logic or
1:01:23something into a stereo mix and that
1:01:25that adds stuff it adds artifacts and
1:01:28weirdnesses that are not there like
1:01:29you're taking someone did what doesn't
1:01:32have a stereo mix I like whenever I've
1:01:34like rip DVDs and stuff there's always a
1:01:36stereo track the things that fall off
1:01:39the back of trucks sometimes on that
1:01:40stereo mix is to give this one example
1:01:42like most of the stuff I watch is legal
1:01:45like almost everything I watch is on the
1:01:47Apple TV and do I when I rip my own
1:01:50blu-rays I don't put a stereo mix on
1:01:52them sometimes they anime thinks nice
1:01:53don't have stereo sometimes they'll be
1:01:54like stereo Japanese in 5.1 English but
1:01:57no stereo English I don't know about
1:01:59iTunes but I'm saying it's like the 500x
1:02:01is available right and a reasonable 5.1
1:02:06set up with a 5.1 mix going straight to
1:02:09it sounds better than stereo and may if
1:02:12you don't have places
1:02:13speakers I can kind of understand that
1:02:15we don't but I think you do you've got a
1:02:17big room it's great that room let me
1:02:20tell you about your house marker I I
1:02:22think you can find I mean I found places
1:02:25in my totally awful should never have
1:02:28any kind of television a carriage house
1:02:30weird thing it it it makes I didn't
1:02:33think it would be a big deal here I held
1:02:35off doing it forever I have some fairly
1:02:37cheap cruddy 5.1 speakers it sounds so
1:02:42much better to have dedicated left right
1:02:44back you know center channel it's a big
1:02:49difference I would encourage you to if
1:02:52you I mean I know you don't care that
1:02:54much about movies and but but these days
1:02:56TV shows have five phone line mixes it
1:02:58makes a difference five point I mean
1:03:00it's like games of Thrones or something
1:03:01a five point one mix with a subwoofer of
1:03:04a good TV show is just plain better than
1:03:06stereo considerate is now like you
1:03:08you've done nothing to preclude it you
1:03:10didn't buy a TV with a weird sound bar
1:03:11which is like the worst of like let's
1:03:13just forget about multi-channel and just
1:03:15do some weird stuff up front and try to
1:03:16fake it out I think you have the room
1:03:18especially these very tiny speakers like
1:03:20mine are very small like I don't know
1:03:22big they are they're like the size of a
1:03:24big iPhone kind of speak you're like oh
1:03:26those can't possibly sound good they're
1:03:28wired their passive wired you know they
1:03:30don't need to be plugged in anymore
1:03:31they're not Bluetooth or any sort of
1:03:33other weird thing you can get those
1:03:36speakers for a reasonable price and and
1:03:38hide the subwoofer for somewhere in the
1:03:40corner and it sounds awesome consider it
1:03:41you know I don't think that either mark
1:03:44Ori is denying that it's better it's not
1:03:47that we're saying it's not better it's
1:03:49just and I'll now I'll speak for myself
1:03:50I I I would love to have that set up but
1:03:55it's not worth the energy to me to make
1:03:58it happen because to do it right I would
1:04:00have to put like wires under the floor
1:04:01and you know you don't always have to
1:04:04you just have to be a little bit
1:04:05creative like I don't have wires under
1:04:07my floor or through my ceiling right but
1:04:10you can you can find ways to make like
1:04:12the wires are smaller than you think
1:04:13they are and you can be creative with
1:04:15where you route them and I don't think
1:04:17Marco would even have to be that
1:04:18creative and worst case Marco can throw
1:04:20money at this problem and actually get
1:04:22wireless ones because
1:04:23then you know what to worry about it
1:04:24like if you if you want to spend more
1:04:26money than I was willing to spend on it
1:04:27cuz I was I was like I'm not gonna
1:04:29spending a lot of money on a 5.1 system
1:04:30I don't even know if I like this but
1:04:31since we're getting all this stuff I
1:04:33might as well try and I bought like the
1:04:34cheapest one I possibly could it was
1:04:35well rated you know if you don't want it
1:04:37if you'd want to spend a couple hundred
1:04:38bucks and get six speakers and a
1:04:41subwoofer do this and I did that and I
1:04:44was amazed and they're very small and so
1:04:46I'm not planning on replacing them with
1:04:47fancier more expensive ones but Markos
1:04:50excuse was he was tired of hooking up
1:04:51all that stuff moving from apartment
1:04:53apartment he's been in this house for a
1:04:54long time now so that excuse doesn't
1:04:55work doesn't work doesn't work in his
1:04:58room but you know again this would take
1:05:01more than a day I feel awesome so why
1:05:04are routes where to put them in places
1:05:06where you wouldn't notice them and hops
1:05:08wouldn't eat them and it would be just
1:05:10fine doesn't eat speakers my dog eats
1:05:14everything so now I'm mapping my dog on
1:05:17to all dogs
1:05:18you can't put wires and a house dog
1:05:19leave them hops don't lick them yeah
1:05:23house will look at them and back away
1:05:25slowly because he's scared of them so
1:05:28yeah I mean and in case he's right I
1:05:31never said that surround is not good or
1:05:34better like surround I had surround for
1:05:37a long time granite this was a long time
1:05:39ago
1:05:40you know I stop hooking up the surround
1:05:42speakers at least 10 years ago and the
1:05:46the speaker set that they were part of I
1:05:48don't even own anymore so it died long
1:05:52ago
1:05:53so I know it's I know it's good but
1:05:56again I'm gonna have to pull a KC here
1:05:58and say like I just don't care like
1:06:01because most of the benefit is for
1:06:04movies but TV shows are in 5.1 now so
1:06:07I'm saying no I know but like what I
1:06:11care about is the sound should sound
1:06:14good and clear and it should be usable
1:06:18to make to fill the room with music when
1:06:21I want music in the room and a standard
1:06:23stereo set works great for that I should
1:06:26also point out I don't have a receiver
1:06:30I Drive the speaker's currently with a
1:06:32stereo with a little tiny stereo speaker
1:06:35amp that is about the
1:06:37size of like four decks of cards stacked
1:06:39like it's a really small speaker ramp
1:06:41one of these little like class D things
1:06:43and it's great and it's it has a remote
1:06:47support so the Apple TV controls the
1:06:49volume on it like there it's remote
1:06:50Clare on the IR thing like it's a great
1:06:53simple setup the TV stand that we have
1:06:56is a non-negotiable piece of furniture
1:07:00with the Historical Society discussions
1:07:03are ongoing with the Historical
1:07:04Commission receiver there is no receiver
1:07:08that exists that I have been able to
1:07:10find that will fit in this stand what I
1:07:12make a receiver the same size and shape
1:07:14as say an old Bell Telephone even the
1:07:19low end receivers have these giant cases
1:07:22now because they use the same case
1:07:24design whether you have like two or
1:07:26seven channels they just put like
1:07:27different numbers of cards in them so I
1:07:29think the solution here that we've
1:07:31learned is I just need to install a
1:07:33surround system and a receiver in the
1:07:35beach house and then have Tiff's watch a
1:07:37movie on it late at night and then
1:07:38she'll send you a text it says okay we
1:07:39can get a receiver maybe yeah well but
1:07:43but yeah so yeah I am totally fine with
1:07:48our basic stereo setup it's a really
1:07:51good stereo setup because the speakers
1:07:53are my one of my favorites the paradigm
1:07:56Adams
1:07:56I love the paradigm atom speakers
1:07:59because they're like 200 bucks each so
1:08:01it's like about 400 bucks a pair and
1:08:02they are the best bookshelf speakers I
1:08:05have ever heard and I've heard many that
1:08:07it costs way more than that and they
1:08:09don't sound better like the the Adams
1:08:11embarrass everything else I've ever
1:08:13tried like they were just so damn good
1:08:15you can use them as your left and right
1:08:17channel and then only by the backs and
1:08:19the center and it's up over here's the
1:08:21problem now the new TV is just bigger
1:08:24enough that the Adams no longer fit on
1:08:27the stand next to us so I have to either
1:08:31get those you know a little pole speaker
1:08:33stands for them which I don't love that
1:08:35at that option because that seemed like
1:08:37it would be you know to me to get
1:08:39something top-heavy in a house that
1:08:41often has children running around and it
1:08:42does not seem like a good idea so I
1:08:45don't love that option also those stands
1:08:47are really expensive like and you can
1:08:49get
1:08:50get new speakers for not not that much
1:08:52more money than those stands
1:08:55so I'm looking into for standing options
1:08:57now but it's very early in the search
1:08:59just screw some tiny little wings on to
1:09:02the edge but yeah right well if I can
1:09:08somehow like drag them behind a truck
1:09:10for a while first and like spray-paint
1:09:12them in weird ways it might distressed
1:09:14yeah yeah distress it in like the most
1:09:16hipster way possible and then it'll look
1:09:18right
1:09:18learned about that on the upcoming
1:09:20directives just for you awesome but yeah
1:09:23so I'm now looking into like floor
1:09:25speakers but I'm probably just gonna get
1:09:27more paradigm you know paradigm makes
1:09:30floor speakers too and they're similarly
1:09:32from what all the reviews say they are
1:09:33amazing values an amazing sound quality
1:09:36foot for what you're paying so so I take
1:09:38it you didn't like measure the top
1:09:40surface of your table and the width of
1:09:42the television you didn't do this math
1:09:43beforehand so you got it you put took it
1:09:45out of the box you put it on there okay
1:09:46let me put the speakers back on you're
1:09:48like oh they don't fit pretty much I I
1:09:50did the math a year ago like with the
1:09:52TVs that were out of your eye when I
1:09:54first started when I was research I did
1:09:56it then and I knew then that I could get
1:09:59a 55 inch TV and that it would intrude
1:10:02roughly halfway into my speaker than
1:10:04either side so I knew this was never see
1:10:09I've seen this in a lot of people's
1:10:10houses to possible solutions I've seen
1:10:13in real life one put the speaker
1:10:15slightly behind the television to put
1:10:17the speakers in front of the television
1:10:18I seen both those solutions both of them
1:10:20boggle my mind those are both terrible
1:10:22solutions everything like this is fine
1:10:24like and I can't decide which is worse
1:10:26blocking the television or having
1:10:28speakers firing directly into the back
1:10:31that's I don't have a hard time figuring
1:10:33that out too I think I mean either way
1:10:36you're making something stuck terribly
1:10:38so yeah I don't know these bookshelf
1:10:41speakers that you love are they super
1:10:42expensive let me look at them no the 200
1:10:44bucks each so a pair of four bookshelf
1:10:50speakers made by a company that had that
1:10:53is like respected in the world of
1:10:54speakers 400 bucks for a pair is not
1:10:57incredibly expensive my whole set of
1:10:59speakers was like four hundred dollars
1:11:01it's six speakers for that price
1:11:04speakers our speakers are kind of like
1:11:06watches unfortunately we're like you
1:11:08think if you're not like a watch person
1:11:11you don't really know how expensive
1:11:12watches are and speakers or licensed
1:11:14because how much could they cost like
1:11:15what just filled with diamonds I don't
1:11:18yeah and those you're right those are
1:11:20cheeping the grand scheme of things but
1:11:21I was thinking bookshelf speakers and
1:11:23Marco likes them maybe they're you know
1:11:2550 bucks each nope nope sorry
1:11:28but they're come on first four good
1:11:31speakers that is not ridiculous it's not
1:11:34you're right it's not it's not like
1:11:35they're $900 each but like when I hear
1:11:37bookshelf speakers I start thinking like
1:11:39oh this is for people who don't want to
1:11:41spend big money on fancy speakers so no
1:11:44because I and I have I've I've had two
1:11:46pairs over the years the second pair of
1:11:47them is on my desk these are like my
1:11:49computer speakers because computer
1:11:51speakers are the biggest ripoff in the
1:11:52world they are the worst like my entire
1:11:55time using a computer ever since I have
1:11:57had a sound card I have used regular
1:12:00speakers instead of computer figures
1:12:02every time I've tried computer speakers
1:12:04I have been dramatically disappointed by
1:12:06how crappy they sound compared to how
1:12:08much they cost
1:12:08regular even cheap regular speakers like
1:12:11the firt when I first started doing this
1:12:13I just had like it was like a little
1:12:15pioneer integrated stereo thing that I
1:12:17just had like in my room like like you
1:12:19know with like the two speakers and the
1:12:21big unit in the middle that has like the
1:12:22cassette deck and the CD player
1:12:23all-in-one and the whole thing was
1:12:25probably like 200 bucks I just used
1:12:26those speakers as my computer speakers
1:12:28and that sounded a million times better
1:12:30than it has I've ever heard going
1:12:33through the big receiver ething yeah the
1:12:35big yeah and the ones my desk now I have
1:12:38a second one of those tiny little like
1:12:40Class D desktop amplifiers and that
1:12:43amplifies them just fine like there are
1:12:45better ways to amplify speakers but
1:12:47they're all much larger and so you know
1:12:49but you can you can do it
1:12:51i-i've tried powered monitors and
1:12:53powered monitors sound okay but these
1:12:57paradigm atoms again they just kick
1:12:59their butts like it's not even close
1:13:00they think you sound a million times
1:13:02better and like a pair of powered
1:13:05desktop speakers is not that much
1:13:07cheaper than then these paradigms like
1:13:10you're getting into the 400 our
1:13:12territory pretty fast with those and
1:13:14they really don't sound good
1:13:16I have never I even good one
1:13:17like like from brands like like clips
1:13:19and KEF and and bows and B and O like
1:13:23you know brands that like have a lot of
1:13:25fans and I know I know I shouldn't put
1:13:27Bozeman list I'm sorry but it has a lot
1:13:29of fans like I've tried a lot of these
1:13:32at some in some cases I've bought and
1:13:33returned them cuz they were so bad like
1:13:35for whatever reason there there seems to
1:13:38be very little correlation between how
1:13:41much you pay for a set of speakers and
1:13:43how good they sound and you know
1:13:45everyone has like their one thing that
1:13:47oh I bought this one pair of these like
1:13:4960 years ago they sound great and and
1:13:51that's like once you find that it's
1:13:53really hard like to try anything else
1:13:55because you know you try something else
1:13:58and you get and it's and it's on the you
1:14:00know worst end of the spectrum I get the
1:14:02feeling you can you know anybody can
1:14:04slap together some drivers into a box of
1:14:06particle board and say they're a speaker
1:14:08manufacturer and it shows I've got I've
1:14:12been surprised by the speaker system i
1:14:14got some logitech speaker you know
1:14:15typical desktop speaker computer
1:14:17speakers for my playstation 4 and i've
1:14:20gone through a series of quote-unquote
1:14:21computer speakers on my mac and they all
1:14:23sound terrible including the ones that
1:14:24i'm currently using but like I don't I
1:14:25don't use them for anything they're fine
1:14:27like it you know they're they were cheap
1:14:29and they're okay
1:14:31but for the ps4 again I'm playing games
1:14:33there which is mostly like gunfire and
1:14:35explosions I was surprised that how good
1:14:39the two point one set up like you know
1:14:42two stereo speakers and a comically
1:14:44large subwoofer to get that all those
1:14:47explosions to sound good
1:14:48makes a big difference when you know for
1:14:50a ps4 that you're not playing on a TV
1:14:52you have a gaming monitor you know 4k
1:14:54gaming monitor 2.1 logitech speaker
1:14:56system and a ps4 so much more impressive
1:15:00than just a ps4 hooked up to someone's
1:15:03car DLC DTV playing through the TV
1:15:05speakers I don't like an wholeheartedly
1:15:09recommend the product because it's kind
1:15:10of expensive and the power button flakes
1:15:12out but I did buy a second when I got my
1:15:15ps4 Pro and I shifted by old ps4 up to
1:15:18my son's room I got a second one of the
1:15:21exact same speaker size even knowing
1:15:23that the power button is going to
1:15:24eventually flake out you just have to
1:15:26wait at the right way and then it's
1:15:28but that is saying something that like
1:15:29if you're willing to like rebuy the same
1:15:31thing a second time that that that does
1:15:33say a lot yeah and and again this is
1:15:35after years and years of terrible
1:15:37computer speakers often by Logitech
1:15:39often by the same exact company and I
1:15:41you know I realize how much I like them
1:15:42and I went to get speakers I'm like oh
1:15:44no what if they don't make these anymore
1:15:45that's always the problem with computer
1:15:46speakers like if you find a set that you
1:15:47like and they break you they don't make
1:15:49them anymore so but they do still make
1:15:51them and I bought a second one and you
1:15:54know one mind eventually break I will
1:15:55scavenge the the new ones from my son's
1:15:58room and use them you know it's awesome
1:15:59about buying regular speakers first of
1:16:01all they're for sale for more than like
1:16:02a year and then second of all they last
1:16:05forever they really you know you can get
1:16:07you can get speakers that last 50 years
1:16:09like you know eventually the cones often
1:16:11dry out and have problems but like they
1:16:13last a long time because they're just
1:16:16passive devices with that they don't
1:16:18they don't at least if they're usually
1:16:20if they're really good there's no
1:16:21electronics in them you know they're you
1:16:24know there's a there's a there are
1:16:25circuits inside of them there's like the
1:16:26crossovers and stuff but there's not
1:16:28much there and they just last and this
1:16:32it's it's like the Mac Pro thing like
1:16:34you know like my iMac is having all
1:16:36these problems now I'm gonna have to
1:16:37like upgrade the entire computer if I
1:16:40want an upgrade but like you got to do
1:16:41some pair of speakers and if the amp
1:16:44flakes out you can just replace the amp
1:16:46if you want like bigger speakers but you
1:16:49already have an awesome amp you can
1:16:50replace the speaker it's like having
1:16:52components is turns out really nice
1:16:54which like all of our parents discovered
1:16:5640 years ago yeah speaking of my dad who
1:17:00is a huge stereo file and you know this
1:17:03because he believes in vinyl anyway
1:17:04he he has a set of Dahlquist speakers
1:17:07that I he tells me were in his dorm room
1:17:10when obviously he was effectively a kid
1:17:13now I'm sure the cones have been
1:17:16replaced on these you know and
1:17:17presumably whatever minimal electronics
1:17:19are in there have been replaced from
1:17:21time to time but to your point Marco I
1:17:23mean these are 40 ish year old speakers
1:17:26that he is still using to this day not
1:17:29as not as his primary speakers on his
1:17:31nice stereo but as as kind of as the
1:17:34surround sound system in his accessory
1:17:36setup if you will his his second setup
1:17:40yeah this stuff lasts forever nothing I
1:17:43find about speakers as I was there very
1:17:45often ugly like that I wouldn't want
1:17:48them sitting next to my computer for TV
1:17:50usually you can hide them but some of
1:17:51them especially the the fancier they get
1:17:54like even the boring ones they're just
1:17:55too just plain ugly I don't I don't know
1:17:57why speakers need to look like anything
1:18:00except for like the world's most
1:18:01understated understated rectangular
1:18:03solid like why do they need to be weird
1:18:05shaped or have things poking out of them
1:18:08or be shiny or draw any attention to
1:18:10themselves at all so and even the ones
1:18:14that are supposed to look like boring
1:18:15little cubes always have some little
1:18:17flourish or chamfer or other thing to
1:18:21make the boxes look weird and I wish
1:18:23they didn't do that well there's another
1:18:26reason why I love my paradigm atoms
1:18:27because they come with you know they
1:18:30like the black cloth grills that you can
1:18:33just stick on there and then it just
1:18:35looks like a boring speaker like it's a
1:18:38black cloth rectangle sticking on the
1:18:41front of a wooden rectangular solid like
1:18:43that's it it's very simple it comes in
1:18:45like four different colors like it is
1:18:48again it's possible to do great speakers
1:18:50it's got the wood grain if I'm looking
1:18:52at the right one here I can't cuz I
1:18:54wouldn't I would not put that next to my
1:18:56computer I have it next my computer it
1:18:58looks great and you can also get it
1:18:59without you can get it in different
1:19:00colors different finishes
1:19:01yeah they look nice with them without
1:19:03the speaker converse in the front very
1:19:05simple that would be fine but and they
1:19:07are just normal rectangular solids but
1:19:09the wood grain I don't like that's part
1:19:12of the reason my current what do they
1:19:13use I don't know what the hell they are
1:19:14they're probably like creative yeah they
1:19:16are Korea this is terrible creative
1:19:18speakers I have hooked up to my computer
1:19:20they look nice no sounds right but they
1:19:23look okay I will say one of the most
1:19:27attractive speaker things I've ever seen
1:19:29was computer speakers it was what what
1:19:31was John you would know like the those
1:19:33clear plastic carbon-carbon sticks with
1:19:35the big like lamp thing as the
1:19:37subwoofers sound sex with the big
1:19:38jellyfish subwoofer yeah yeah I like the
1:19:41subwoofer yeah that looked cool like the
1:19:44subwoofer did look like a jellyfish and
1:19:46it was really neat and clear or whatever
1:19:47but the sound sticks
1:19:50and like I said like too many holes well
1:19:55I still don't see I'm not even sure I've
1:19:58ever even heard those so I have no idea
1:19:59how they sound but I honestly think like
1:20:00that should go down in history of
1:20:03computer industrial design like that was
1:20:05so it's such a great design
1:20:07I like the cube speakers better in terms
1:20:09of visuals like you remember the g4 cube
1:20:11came with like these two little round
1:20:14balls they were just a single single
1:20:17little cone and the same kind of the
1:20:19visual language of clear but yeah and
1:20:21you can see the electronics I thought oh
1:20:23I think I mean yeah they nicely match a
1:20:26thing to sound sick so we just seemed
1:20:27seems so they look like giant octopus
1:20:30tentacles on it I know people I think I
1:20:32think is Dan Morin I think some people
1:20:34we both know got those back in the day
1:20:37and still use them as laughing to your
1:20:38point about component stuff it's like oh
1:20:40you know what other stuff do you have
1:20:42from the era of the g4 cube that you're
1:20:43still using but if they're just plain
1:20:45old speakers you can just keep using
1:20:46them because their speakers and they
1:20:48work with every Mac that you buy and
1:20:49everything works out it something like
1:20:52so many so many of like and even you
1:20:54know getting back to receivers and stuff
1:20:55so many of the receivers these days like
1:20:58the receiver is integrating certain HDMI
1:21:01standards that go out of date quickly
1:21:03certain like you know maybe it has like
1:21:05network streaming standards maybe it has
1:21:07Bluetooth or airplay or integrates with
1:21:11like Pandora I mean even even my my new
1:21:13TV now has dedicated hardware buttons in
1:21:16the remote for and ones on video and
1:21:18Netflix and that's where we're not gonna
1:21:20age that well in the grand scheme of
1:21:21things if TV still last 10 years and you
1:21:25know it's it's nice to keep things you
1:21:26know it you give up on some of the cool
1:21:29integration of like having things all in
1:21:31one that this one this one box does all
1:21:33these different things and has
1:21:34integrated you know Bluetooth Wi-Fi all
1:21:36this stuff you give up on some of that
1:21:38if you go the separate component route
1:21:39there's usually still the way to achieve
1:21:41it use many like multiple parts but I
1:21:44feel like long term you're setting
1:21:46yourself up for a better outcome and
1:21:48this is again why I really want to wait
1:21:51for the Mac Perot tower rather than
1:21:53buying the iMac Pro this this winter
1:21:56because I like having separate
1:21:58components because most of the time in
1:22:00my life I have done things that way and
1:22:02the few times I had
1:22:03I usually come to regret it but you
1:22:06won't you buy that like from so the
1:22:07sound sticks are still available by the
1:22:09way they're still for sale this sounds
1:22:11six finally up to three sound sticks
1:22:12three by Harman Kardon really 170 bucks
1:22:15you can order them right now that's
1:22:17actually not that expensive for what
1:22:19that is yeah I mean I think they look
1:22:21cool I've never heard them so I can't
1:22:22vouch for how good they sound compared
1:22:24to anything I mean you can look at I
1:22:26mean you can see the components like
1:22:27well there's that size driver for the
1:22:29subwoofer and there's these little tiny
1:22:30drivers for the left and right speakers
1:22:33and it is what it is the other thing is
1:22:35I have a feelin this is probably a
1:22:36design that looks better in pictures
1:22:38than it does like in real life covered
1:22:40in dust and with a thing with the
1:22:41plastic faded and cracked and scratch
1:22:43the plastic holds up pretty well but I
1:22:45just don't like how it even looks in
1:22:46pictures like I like the subwoofer I
1:22:47think that's a cute design but the sound
1:22:49sticks they look like octopus tentacles
1:22:51and I don't like the little cheerio
1:22:52life's a life preserver bass thingies
1:22:55don't like it yeah I guess those little
1:22:57bases aren't that great either yeah you
1:22:59know you're ruining this for me this is
1:23:00what do I do if I can just get the
1:23:02subwoofer and keep on your destiny
1:23:03curiosity but filled with M&Ms pour it
1:23:05down the little you know the other funny
1:23:08part two is like you put subwoofers
1:23:10usually out of sight but the floor like
1:23:13you're not supposed to have is anywhere
1:23:15where it's visible but anything about
1:23:16some horses you can put them anywhere
1:23:18who's to say you know you put them out
1:23:19of cycles you know these big black you
1:23:21know cubes that you just want to get rid
1:23:23of but this one is so nice put it on
1:23:24your desk and you know because humans
1:23:26cannot localize low frequency sound as
1:23:28well as high frequency sound does matter
1:23:32where you put it I will say on that
1:23:34though I greatly prefer just big
1:23:37speakers that have their own woofers
1:23:39that can produce the low frequencies
1:23:41well enough to the sound of little
1:23:44satellites and then one sub woofer
1:23:45somewhere in the room like I've heard
1:23:47this frame before and I also I think
1:23:49your opinion this is based on some very
1:23:51terrible 5.1 setups early on I don't
1:23:53know my opinion this is based on liking
1:23:55music that's what it is really like if I
1:23:57totally agree with you that if what
1:23:59you're optimizing for is movies and TV
1:24:01sound then having a subwoofer is cooler
1:24:05like it sounds cooler that way like you
1:24:06get more like the big booms from
1:24:08explosions and stuff like that but I
1:24:10don't like the way music sounds through
1:24:12that kind of setup I think it sounds
1:24:14weird and unnatural and not how that was
1:24:16in 10
1:24:17I would rather have speakers that are
1:24:19pretty good at TV and movies and and
1:24:23also really great at music then the
1:24:25opposite we gotta get you yeah I mean
1:24:28you can choose your left and rights to
1:24:29be standalone left or right channels
1:24:31that can reduce all the frequencies I
1:24:33mean your receiver usually controls like
1:24:34you can control like the crossover like
1:24:36what you know you could shift the cutoff
1:24:39of which frequencies go to the subwoofer
1:24:40for mixes that don't separately address
1:24:43it but if you've got left and right
1:24:44channel speakers that can handle all the
1:24:46frequencies you don't have to send
1:24:47anything does that whatever in the case
1:24:49where you're just playing music although
1:24:50multi-channel music is a thing over
1:24:52Jason Snell's house I heard was a
1:24:54crowded house 5.1 mix it's not
1:24:57everybody's thing but it is a thing
1:24:59thanks folks for three sponsors this
1:25:01week betterment audible and Squarespace
1:25:03and we will see you next week
1:25:12[Music]
1:25:18johnny research
1:25:21BC would
1:25:23[Music]
1:25:32[Music]
1:25:38[Music]
1:25:42i SS see you
1:25:49[Music]
1:26:01[Music]
1:26:08[Music]
1:26:10we have a multi-channel vinyl 5.1 well
1:26:14they don't even have stereo you just get
1:26:16yours and you play them all at the same
1:26:18time like it was The Flaming Lips did a
1:26:22thing where you buy wasn't it you buy
1:26:24two vinyl albums and you play them both
1:26:25at the same time anyway let me like what
1:26:33I like
1:26:34mm-hmm let people enjoy things John I'm
1:26:37telling you you might enjoy a thing
1:26:40where you get to play two records at the
1:26:41same time double the fun
1:26:43right it's like Doublemint gum yeah is
1:26:45that part of the challenge is that it's
1:26:46a you know you like the ceremony now you
1:26:48have a physical challenge where you have
1:26:50to drop the needle hit the drop the
1:26:52needle on the beginning track and
1:26:53exactly the same spot exactly the right
1:26:55time because you don't want the music to
1:26:56be out of sync was it uh waves arica was
1:27:01a double dare that had physical
1:27:02challenges they actually phrased it as a
1:27:04physical challenge that was that was
1:27:05double dare I was gonna make that
1:27:07reference but I didn't bother but there
1:27:08you go you got it you proud of me John I
1:27:10am all I want is for you to be proud of
1:27:12me daddy did you read it story by the
1:27:14way uh the world out there and and there
1:27:17was the big like you know inside story
1:27:20of double dare I think there was a
1:27:21separate story about like the video
1:27:22phone that you get as a prize and double
1:27:24their I know exactly the video phone
1:27:27you're thinking of I don't recall having
1:27:29seen the story about that but I did read
1:27:33and freaking loved the oral history of
1:27:37double dare which was which was actually
1:27:39written which is a little weird I mean I
1:27:41guess was it was um it was a real
1:27:44mystery do you exactly but nevertheless
1:27:46it was I think there might have been an
1:27:49Associated like brief podcast which I
1:27:50never bothered listening to me that's
1:27:52what it was it doesn't matter if you are
1:27:54a child or if you were a child of the
1:27:5680s and watch Doubleday or on
1:27:57Nickelodeon this is absolutely worth
1:28:00your time it was a fantastic read and
1:28:03now you have to find that link for the
1:28:04show notes I already have it this is my
1:28:07other job other than being chief
1:28:08summarizer in chief I love double dare
1:28:10the old air was the best and that's the
1:28:13thing like I've actually said to people
1:28:14I don't think I've ever said it on the
1:28:15show but I've said to people in in real
1:28:18life because apparently this isn't real
1:28:20but anyway do you remember
1:28:22that when you were a kid the grand prize
1:28:25from double-dare was as already
1:28:28mentioned a video telephone where you
1:28:30would get two of them I believe and he
1:28:32could put one in one person's house and
1:28:33one in the other person's house and you
1:28:35would get like a postage stamp and
1:28:37that's not much of an exaggeration a
1:28:39postage stamp-sized image that had a
1:28:42frame rate of like one new image every
1:28:44five to ten seconds in that blew my mind
1:28:49when I was ten or whatever and now in my
1:28:53pocket I can have an HD call with anyone
1:28:57on the planet anywhere I am I mean the
1:29:00future is amazing you know what else is
1:29:02amazing about the Future speaking of net
1:29:04neutrality that neutrality is pretty
1:29:06mean isn't so easy for it I think it
1:29:08would be amazing if we maintain it I
1:29:10think I'm not sure the future is gonna
1:29:11be so amazing in that department so true
1:29:14so what's going on with this why are we
1:29:16why do we care about that today as we
1:29:18record on Wednesday the 12th I go
1:29:20through a net neutrality all over again
1:29:22I think people who don't know what it is
1:29:25or what we're talking about there is a
1:29:29video it's a video from vihart
1:29:31explaining the neutrality in her in
1:29:34their unique way
1:29:35it's actually an updated version of an
1:29:38older video which goes gets us more
1:29:41towards Bart we're talking about this
1:29:42again where she just took her old video
1:29:44and then bookended it by a preface and
1:29:46then the things that have changed this
1:29:48is a a battle that we thought we had if
1:29:51not one of these sort of got things
1:29:53moving in the right direction but for a
1:29:55variety of depressing reasons things are
1:29:57moving back in the wrong direction in
1:29:59these parts I'm seemingly all fronts and
1:30:01that rally is no exception so you get
1:30:04someone who used to be obviously a
1:30:07lawyer for a Verizon or whatever you get
1:30:10some industry person in to come in and
1:30:12do something that most people the United
1:30:14States don't want which is rollback net
1:30:16neutrality to make it so that big
1:30:18corporations can charge different
1:30:21amounts of money for different customers
1:30:22of the internet instead of just being a
1:30:25common carrier blah blah blah watch the
1:30:26video to have explained the the annoying
1:30:30thing about this is like you get
1:30:32fatigued like how much do I have to here
1:30:35I didn't care about net neutrality like
1:30:36didn't we go through this all where we
1:30:38all got all up in a tizzy and everyone
1:30:40write your congressperson and that seems
1:30:42like we're doing that all the time and
1:30:43how many things can I possibly care
1:30:44about and I don't you know I've heard
1:30:47about net neutrality too much I don't
1:30:48even care anymore just don't bother me
1:30:50or if you do want to do something about
1:30:53you're like well what do I do I did a
1:30:54bunch of stuff last time do I do that
1:30:56same stuff again arts Technica has a
1:30:58good article here entitled how to write
1:31:00a meaningful FCC comment supporting net
1:31:02neutrality now the depressed person in
1:31:05me who sees everything falling apart in
1:31:07this country these days thanks it
1:31:10doesn't matter how meaningful your
1:31:11comment of the FCC is because the stupid
1:31:13Verizon lawyer who's running a thing is
1:31:14going to ignore it and do whatever the
1:31:16hell big corporations want because he
1:31:17doesn't care what people want he doesn't
1:31:19care what's good for a long term
1:31:20anything all he cares about is screwing
1:31:22everything up and that's exactly why he
1:31:24was going to do his position anyway but
1:31:26if you are not in that type of dark mood
1:31:28at the moment that you read this article
1:31:29this will help you do the best that you
1:31:33can possibly do instead of just clicking
1:31:34a bunch of buttons and filling out this
1:31:35thing or how can you write a meaningful
1:31:37comment that has a chance of influencing
1:31:40things and who knows it kind of sort of
1:31:41work last time before everything started
1:31:44moving backwards again and it might work
1:31:45this time so to two links in the show
1:31:48notes one watch my hearts video for it's
1:31:51not the best explanation net neutrality
1:31:52because it's a many-faceted and she
1:31:54particularly you know a lot of times
1:31:55they pick an analogy like it's kind of
1:31:57like if this happened and you know in
1:31:59some ways it's better just straight-up
1:32:00explain it without analogy but the
1:32:02analogy huge uses is reasonably
1:32:04representative even if it does gloss
1:32:06over a lot of things and there are other
1:32:07aspects there but anyway watch that to
1:32:09have explained and it's fun and
1:32:10interesting and if you already know what
1:32:12it is but you feel fatigued by the idea
1:32:14of trying to battle against this again
1:32:17give the how to write a meaningful
1:32:20comment thing a read to see if you can
1:32:22do more than just check a box or put
1:32:24your name on a list or whatever but
1:32:25actually pour out a little bit of your
1:32:27heart and your angst and even your anger
1:32:29in the most constructive way possible
1:32:32and you know do what you can do to fight
1:32:36the same fight that we continue to be
1:32:38fighting over and over and over and over
1:32:40and over again there's also a great
1:32:42video it's only about three and a half
1:32:44minutes from CGP grey that was from the
1:32:46last
1:32:47we were all at this exact same rodeo
1:32:51this one's from 2014 so maybe it wasn't
1:32:53the last time but you get my point
1:32:55that is also very good I've seen this by
1:32:57heart video or at least the original
1:32:58iteration thereof probably also from
1:33:012014 which it is excellent as well yeah
1:33:04this it's it's important I think and
1:33:08well I was gonna say I think that anyone
1:33:10who really has any inkling as to what's
1:33:13going on that isn't paid by one of these
1:33:15big corporations will say net neutrality
1:33:17is the only way to go but you know then
1:33:19we elected who elected so obviously
1:33:22people think differently so anyway if
1:33:24you care about things like this podcast
1:33:26and you want to get it reasonably
1:33:28quickly and not have people get in the
1:33:30way of it maybe talk to your
1:33:32representatives about net neutrality all
1:33:34right on that by the way a lot of the
1:33:35examples they give you of like here's
1:33:36what could happen if we didn't have net
1:33:38neutrality the the difficulty is if you
1:33:41wanted to be like if you wanted to
1:33:44actually extrapolate like you get to put
1:33:46money on it like what would actually
1:33:47happen if robach neutrality it's such a
1:33:49sort of systemic boil the Frog kind of
1:33:53thing that we're already halfway through
1:33:55- that is difficult to convince people
1:33:58exactly how bad it'll be like that like
1:34:00the things that we describe are like oh
1:34:01your podcasts will download slowly right
1:34:03yeah that could happen but in general
1:34:05the powers that be that the powers that
1:34:08are lobbying behind this that want this
1:34:10you know they want to you know they want
1:34:12the net not to be neutral they're not
1:34:15that dumb they would do it in the same
1:34:17way they've done everything else like
1:34:18how do we all of a sudden wake up and
1:34:19find ourselves with only one ISP choice
1:34:21and like half the country right they did
1:34:23that slowly and insidiously by merging
1:34:25and lobbying to allow larger and larger
1:34:27companies to merge together and it's
1:34:28kind of like a thing like what do I care
1:34:30if Time Warner is purchased by whatever
1:34:33or this cable company buys out I don't
1:34:34care whatever I just want my TV like
1:34:36people don't care at that level and
1:34:38slowly these giant giant companies are
1:34:41doing things behind the scenes that is
1:34:42making people's lives like that is
1:34:44closing the door and things that can
1:34:46make people's lives materially better
1:34:47you could have faster internet access
1:34:49for less money they're like they're
1:34:52essentially taking away something that
1:34:53you've never had the Beck Progress
1:34:55essentially like and you don't know how
1:34:57cheap broadband is in the rest of the
1:34:59world and how other people have choices
1:35:01if you have a common carrier that people
1:35:02can actually compete based on price and
1:35:04features like if you've never
1:35:05experienced that it's like it's a lack
1:35:07of something like I've never known it
1:35:09could be this way therefore the lack of
1:35:11it doesn't make me feel like I'm losing
1:35:12anything but you are right that's how
1:35:15they do it and so if they made the net
1:35:17non neutral and cut all these deals and
1:35:19extorted money from as they've already
1:35:20done from Netflix to get their bits to
1:35:22carry over the wires and and startups
1:35:24that you've never heard of and never
1:35:25will hear of are not allowed to enter
1:35:27it's the big like you will not notice
1:35:29that most people will not notice the
1:35:30lack of things that you could have had
1:35:32but that is really the worst-affected
1:35:34this stuff stuff that that people that
1:35:37you will never get because competition
1:35:40has been eliminated and you know people
1:35:43in the middle are extracting value from
1:35:46everybody else and it's like you may
1:35:49have like a mid-level malaise or like Oh
1:35:51Comcast is all I can get and I hate
1:35:52Comcast but it's like oh you know I
1:35:54airlines you know I don't have a similar
1:35:56problem of monopoly and consolidation
1:35:58but anyway it's it's usually not as
1:36:01comically evil as like I was watching my
1:36:03show and they turned it off and they're
1:36:04not gonna do that right they're going to
1:36:06do it in a much more insidious way and
1:36:09they're gonna end up you know finding a
1:36:11way to continue to charge you more for
1:36:13worse service and make you feel
1:36:15powerless against it and you were like
1:36:16had it how did we even get here and like
1:36:18net neutrality is like the last bash
1:36:19literally the last one because they've
1:36:20already got everything else that I've
1:36:22subscribed there's like if we could just
1:36:24get that one last little bit and be able
1:36:25to be the gatekeeper for all Internet
1:36:28content for the last mile for everybody
1:36:30and we've already chased that all
1:36:32competition and consolidated our power
1:36:34structure we just need this last little
1:36:36bit that's why I'd like everyone is
1:36:37fighting for this to them now because
1:36:38it's not as like we're fighting for some
1:36:39sort of YouTube utopia we're just trying
1:36:41to hold on to the last shred of what we
1:36:43have in this country and I'm sure people
1:36:45listening other countries it's better
1:36:47where you are but as with many things in
1:36:49the US for historical reasons and stupid
1:36:52governmental reasons many things are
1:36:54terrible and internet access is one of
1:36:57them and so send help yeah
1:37:05that's I can't say I can't add anything
1:37:07to that
1:37:08that wouldn't be just dark and
1:37:09depressing I mean if you want to if you
1:37:11want to be optimistic as people pointed
1:37:13out like the previous head of the FCC
1:37:14was also an industry person and I mean
1:37:18and you know all we did all the public
1:37:20comment and we'd almost rallying or
1:37:21whatever eventually we did you know we
1:37:25didn't get the result we wanted of
1:37:26course that was a very different
1:37:27administration and that's where Margo
1:37:28gets depressed again and we all get the
1:37:29prostate like that was a different
1:37:31administration but anyway but the fact
1:37:33that we have made progress on this in
1:37:36the past means it is not 100% impossible
1:37:38that we can make progress on the future
1:37:40and as we've learned administration's
1:37:42change right
1:37:43every 48 years so even if we lose this
1:37:48one we could still win the war unlike
1:37:51things like supreme I can talk about
1:37:53Supreme Court justices like this these
1:37:56are things that can change with the
1:37:57administration so anyway this is this is
1:38:03a great will be great rallying people to
1:38:05political action by telling them exactly
1:38:06how useless everything positive we have
1:38:09to do it it's like it's like all we can
1:38:11do we can vote and we can register to
1:38:14vote we can vote we can be active
1:38:17politically and we can do when they call
1:38:19for Hublot comment on things in the FCC
1:38:21does publicly comment you're part of the
1:38:23public comment that's what it's for even
1:38:25if you think you're gonna be ignored do
1:38:26you think the FCC gives a crap about
1:38:28public comments like do you think like
1:38:33who in what part of the population is
1:38:35asking for any of these laws that the
1:38:38trying to shove through like no one's
1:38:39asking for this big companies big
1:38:42companies with a lot of money that's
1:38:43right there's like four companies asking
1:38:45for it zero part of the population
1:38:46asking for it you know just like so much
1:38:48else that's going on there's like no one
1:38:50is asking for this except the people
1:38:52passing the laws well there you have it
1:38:58another rousing episode of a TV enjoy
1:39:01[Laughter]