0:00:00my lunch today consists of a handful of
0:00:03spinach a couple of slices of cucumber
0:00:05one hard-boiled egg and 24 flavors of
0:00:09ice cream are you ready all right we're
0:00:11trying to group them into groups we're
0:00:14gonna start with the lightest group
0:00:15which we believe is the fruit and nut
0:00:18group but not all right so so we should
0:00:26be four as we start and as tip start to
0:00:28opening up all the ice creams we should
0:00:30discuss that we are we are doing top
0:00:32four Ben and Jerry's ice cream flavors
0:00:34oh yeah that's what we're doing guys
0:00:35you're not here with us and you can't
0:00:37actually see what we're doing you can't
0:00:39see our table full of ice cream
0:00:41tablecloth so we're doing we're gonna do
0:00:44them in groups because ice cream melts
0:00:45quickly and it's summertime and so we
0:00:47are starting out we have 24 flavors
0:00:49total these these were our criteria were
0:00:52basically no limited batch stuff cuz you
0:00:55know we that this podcast wouldn't age
0:00:57well if we did limited batch stuff we we
0:01:00left out all of the non-dairy flavors
0:01:04because I've tried a couple of here in
0:01:07there and they're okay but I would say
0:01:09the nothing to write home about
0:01:09would you agree I don't I didn't even
0:01:11see them in the grocery store so I don't
0:01:12even know yeah actually haven't I saw
0:01:14them only only on the website this year
0:01:15last year I tried a few of them when
0:01:17they first came out and they're fine
0:01:19if you can't have dairy they're a good
0:01:21option but if you can't have dairy the
0:01:22dairy ones are better we went to three
0:01:24different grocery stores to find the
0:01:25selection that we have today and I think
0:01:27we did pretty good we left out a couple
0:01:29of big ones that I think that people
0:01:30might or might not be well they might be
0:01:32upset about but it would they would
0:01:34never make our list so we didn't include
0:01:38them like I'm sorry chunky monkey but if
0:01:40you happen like I have I can't eat
0:01:43banana due to a stomach allergy and so
0:01:44that rules out anything banana for me so
0:01:46the rule is like if TIFF doesn't like it
0:01:48which tip doesn't like walnuts so that
0:01:50ruled out the banana for her we also
0:01:51didn't include any discontinued flavors
0:01:53primarily because we can't get them but
0:01:56I would like to pour one out here well
0:01:58two one outs to slowly melt one out for
0:02:01Bonnaroo buzz Bonnaroo buzz is a
0:02:04wonderful flavor and the little
0:02:05spin-offs that have come off of it like
0:02:06urban bourbon I do not think are as good
0:02:08and all right so this is unlike a lot of
0:02:11our other top four episodes everyone
0:02:13snow
0:02:13we do do a big tasting episode like this
0:02:15because we're just not sure of what our
0:02:17top four is because you know you get ice
0:02:19cream sometimes here and there or or
0:02:21more often like all the time like we do
0:02:23but you aren't really sure when you're
0:02:26talking about comparing flavors because
0:02:27there's so many like chunky brownies
0:02:29surprise sundae swirl tastic you know
0:02:33hardcore yeah I don't even know but it
0:02:37the the adjectives just keep on coming
0:02:39with Ben Jerry's so we decided to
0:02:41actually get as many as we could and
0:02:44compare them to each other also one
0:02:46other disclaimer we did not include any
0:02:49of the core flavors the horns the ones
0:02:52that have like the the center cylinder
0:02:55of some kind of rich pasty stuff with
0:02:57the ice cream circle around it I have
0:03:00mixed feelings about the core flavors
0:03:02they seem to go nuts with them like two
0:03:04years ago when they first invented that
0:03:05or whatever and it seemed like every
0:03:08flit every new flavor that came out for
0:03:10for like a year was a core flavor and I
0:03:13honestly didn't find anything
0:03:15particularly noteworthy about any of
0:03:17them that they did have a hazelnut one
0:03:20that seems to be no longer in production
0:03:22that was okay but the problem with the
0:03:24core is to me is they have like the
0:03:27Neapolitan ice cream problem where you
0:03:29have hey hey hey don't knock me upon ice
0:03:31cream well but kind of love Neapolitan
0:03:33ice cream but it you'd but if you don't
0:03:35really care for any one of those parts
0:03:38it's kind of it kind of sucks to eat and
0:03:40that's the problem with with the core is
0:03:42that they put like two or three totally
0:03:44separate elements just kind of next to
0:03:46each other in the tub and you have to
0:03:48like all two or three of them for it to
0:03:51really be good if there's one thing you
0:03:52don't care for like the hazelnut one I
0:03:54loved the the hazelnut chocolate core
0:03:57and the hazelnut flavored ice cream but
0:03:59next to it was just a boring chocolate
0:04:01ice cream that was taking up a third of
0:04:03the container that I didn't really care
0:04:04for and I would just kind of plow
0:04:05through like like really wasting those
0:04:07calories for this thing I don't really
0:04:08care for just to really keep it even and
0:04:10not be a jerk and get to the two things
0:04:12that did like but the whole point of New
0:04:14Holland ice cream is eating it all
0:04:15together and that's why it's so good
0:04:16right but the problem is that's very
0:04:18challenging to come up with like a
0:04:19flavor combination really you like all
0:04:21three of these things like Neapolitan
0:04:23chocolate vanilla and strawberry even
0:04:25that is controversial like Eva
0:04:27people even don't like one of those
0:04:28things because why you always get the
0:04:30you know if you have one of the little
0:04:31like rectangular big tubs of Neapolitan
0:04:33out at a party there's always gonna be
0:04:35like you know the chocolate ones gonna
0:04:37be two feet high and the vanilla and
0:04:39strawberry are gonna be down at the
0:04:40bottom that's because people are animals
0:04:41right so anyway so we left most of the
0:04:44cores out corn partly just to narrow it
0:04:47down a little bit and probably because
0:04:48we've never really found any that really
0:04:50seemed worth it to us I'm glad that you
0:04:52have feelings about course I do
0:04:55all right let's get in this before they
0:04:57become little puddles first so we have
0:04:59we have seven out right now yep seven so
0:05:03two of them are actually the same but
0:05:06different versions we have a Froyo
0:05:08version because I think my number one is
0:05:11going to be a possible Froyo yes and
0:05:14this is also the only Froyo variety that
0:05:16we have here yeah Frio has I think a
0:05:19similar problem is the non-dairy ones
0:05:20which is most of them are fine but the
0:05:23dairy ones are better that this is my
0:05:25said moose no okay you so TIFF disagrees
0:05:28on the one we have here okay so what we
0:05:30have here is I think my favorite one of
0:05:33all of the ice creams we're gonna start
0:05:35off big people because you only live
0:05:37once right and summertime and we're a
0:05:39living large so we're gonna be logs are
0:05:43a little large we're gonna get larger to
0:05:45get larger yeah okay well and to be fair
0:05:47on that point as a general statement I
0:05:50would rather like be very responsible in
0:05:54the rest of my diet and exercise just to
0:05:56make room in the budget for Ben and
0:05:58Jerry sometimes because I we love ice
0:06:00cream everyone lets ice cream we love
0:06:01ice cream and I would say if you're
0:06:03going to eat ice cream you might as well
0:06:05eat the best ice cream like it's not
0:06:07worth the calories to eat crappy ice
0:06:08cream but Ben and Jerry's even though it
0:06:10is quite high calorie is awesome ice
0:06:13cream and we've tried so many others we
0:06:15went through a tell NT gelato phase and
0:06:17we even thought about doing a top four
0:06:19on those and it's just not as good like
0:06:22it's fine like other ice creams can be
0:06:24good but Ben & Jerry's is better simple
0:06:27as that
0:06:27Thank You PSA okay so what I was going
0:06:30to say is alright I love Cherry Garcia
0:06:34it is my favorite but it yeah I like it
0:06:38better in the Froyo version which is the
0:06:40frozen you
0:06:41one because it's less grainy if you have
0:06:44the ice-cream version versus the frozen
0:06:46yogurt the frozen yogurt is a lot
0:06:48smoother and the ice cream one is much
0:06:50more grainy in the main ice cream area
0:06:54okay yeah you know like it's not about
0:06:59the it's not the berries aren't grainy
0:07:01or anything it's the the main holding
0:07:05liquid yeah all right let's crack these
0:07:09suckers open all right let's do it
0:07:14the logistics of trying to taste 24
0:07:17flavors of ice cream on a podcast are
0:07:19quite something
0:07:21especially cuz we're not doing it at our
0:07:22kitchen table because the room there is
0:07:24incredibly echoey I'd make for terrible
0:07:26audio so we're trying to do those all in
0:07:28the office on this little tiny table
0:07:33this is not the things we do for for you
0:07:36are our wonderful audience
0:07:39this is really something else oh this is
0:07:41just a mess okay okay so now we're
0:07:43facing this direction all right so all
0:07:47right well we got here we are calling
0:07:49this the what was it fruit and nut group
0:07:51yes which also includes the Cheesecake
0:07:54group you know sometimes the weird
0:07:59breeds get in some group and you're like
0:08:01why why is the pomeranian working I
0:08:04don't know what it's working for but it
0:08:05no it's not really in a working group
0:08:07but when we tried to separate these into
0:08:09groups of like you know five or so so we
0:08:11could do it do without them all melting
0:08:12it's very hard to to make coherent
0:08:15groups of Ben and Jerry's later because
0:08:16there's a lot of overlaps like well once
0:08:18you include you know she's cake and what
0:08:21about red velvet cake is that cheese
0:08:23cake and then the cinnamon buns were
0:08:24kind of cake like it yeah okay start out
0:08:27okay for it we have red velvet cake we
0:08:29have strawberry cheesecake we have two
0:08:31types of Cherry Garcia we have
0:08:32cheesecake brownie we have pistachio and
0:08:36cinnamon buns I'm starting out with a
0:08:38red velvet cake okay I really like the
0:08:41strawberry it really melds the alright
0:08:45go for the middle in the middle it's not
0:08:48okay what I really like about strawberry
0:08:51cheesecake ice cream
0:08:51it's from Ben and Jerry's
0:08:54is it has the graham swirl in it which
0:08:57is oh we should have had the s'mores out
0:08:59I'm a sucker for Graham swirls I love
0:09:01Graham swirls and ice cream so this has
0:09:03like that little fruity kind of acidic
0:09:06flavor from the strawberries which is
0:09:07really nice and light vanilla ice cream
0:09:10well it says cheesecake ice cream but so
0:09:13it's just extra flavor right angle cake
0:09:15by the way is awesome
0:09:16I just dripped it on my pants okay and
0:09:18it also has the graham in it so it's
0:09:19really good the very first flavor you
0:09:21are you driven your pants it's okay stay
0:09:23you're due for a wash strawberry
0:09:25cheesecake versus red velvet cake all
0:09:27right I have a lot of feelings about red
0:09:29velvet in general not this ice cream
0:09:31which I haven't tried yet
0:09:32oh my it's good right
0:09:37it tastes like cake batter yeah the red
0:09:39velvet cake is way better than I thought
0:09:40it would be the strawberry cheesecake I
0:09:42do love that Graham element really does
0:09:44it for me too
0:09:45okay I'm having way more than one
0:09:47spoonful of each another
0:09:49I'm gonna be hell to sustain this level
0:09:51of ice cream eating okay I'm trying to
0:09:52be like a spoonful and a half at most
0:09:53for the most part I think that red
0:09:56velvet cake is a lie because it's a
0:09:59total fraud of a cake cuz it's just
0:10:00chocolate cake with a whole bunch of red
0:10:02dye in it and it doesn't make it any
0:10:04kind of special it's chocolate cake with
0:10:06cream cheese icing which i think is as a
0:10:09cake it is the most live a cake if there
0:10:11ever did cake but it didn't Ben and
0:10:15Jerry's ice cream right now this is
0:10:17delicious because it is it has the rich
0:10:21cakey flavor it tastes like you're
0:10:23eating cake batter so wet cinnamon buns
0:10:26is also surprisingly good it's almost
0:10:28like cinnamon cookie dough like they
0:10:30have these little chunks of what
0:10:32basically is cookie dough and it's it's
0:10:35surprisingly good I did not think this
0:10:37along with the red velvet cake I don't
0:10:39have high hopes for the the cinnamon bun
0:10:42I figured it would be a little bit
0:10:43boring but it's green yeah I was really
0:10:45good to do it isn't that me so hard
0:10:48that's what she said moving on to the in
0:10:50the cake room now moving on to
0:10:52cheesecake brownie this is the cinnamon
0:10:56bun wise says dough and cinnamon
0:10:57streusel swirl I am really into anything
0:11:01that has kind of like cakey cookie
0:11:02pieces in it she's a brownie to me is
0:11:05kind of a letdown it
0:11:08as advertiser I'm ready to be let down
0:11:09let me see I need to not let just feel
0:11:12like the other cake flavor is totally
0:11:14out classic all right if this were like
0:11:16the only ice cream I can get my hands on
0:11:18it's very good yeah but it doesn't stand
0:11:21out in a memorable way right and the
0:11:23others really do the others are great
0:11:25this just kind of falls into the
0:11:26category of vanilla ice cream with stuff
0:11:28floating in it
0:11:30which we should that should have been
0:11:32another group that would have been like
0:11:34half the ice creams all right so now I'm
0:11:35trying I'm moving on to the Cherry
0:11:37Garcia family the regular one is quite
0:11:40awesome all right let me try it again
0:11:42maybe I got some bad batches so I detect
0:11:46no difference in greenness between the
0:11:48two I also though detect very little
0:11:50difference at all between the two
0:11:51between the between the Cherry Garcia
0:11:53ice cream versus Froyo so in that way I
0:11:56would say did you go for the Froyo then
0:11:58it's less calories okay I also do not
0:12:00detect a difference in the graininess in
0:12:02this batch so maybe I had a bad batch
0:12:04and that's why I got scared away from
0:12:05the ice cream version but I feel like
0:12:08the the cherry the the cherry frozen
0:12:12yogurt is more flavorful than the cherry
0:12:14ice cream I feel like the cherry ice
0:12:16cream gets overtaken with like all the
0:12:17dairy and the richness of the cream
0:12:20whereas the Froyo it keeps that really
0:12:23light cherry flavor and it stands out a
0:12:25lot more so it is still bangin hmm
0:12:29okay I would also then move on to
0:12:31pistachio pistachio and I like any
0:12:34pistachio ice cream really from like the
0:12:36cheap like bright green crazy stuff in
0:12:38the generic flavors to the fancy one
0:12:40here and pistachio pistachio is awesome
0:12:43I will however say that you know like
0:12:45the the she that she has brown anyone
0:12:48with it like she's cake brownie
0:12:50pistachio pistachio doesn't really stand
0:12:52out like is nothing where those things
0:12:54were like if we have if it's all we have
0:12:56I will greatly enjoy it okay but do you
0:12:58not agree no I do not agree because
0:13:00pistachio pistachio has this really
0:13:02beautiful light flavor again another
0:13:04thing why I really like the Cherry
0:13:06Garcia
0:13:06because sometimes ice cream with a whole
0:13:09bunch of stuff in it it's so heavy and
0:13:11at the end of a big meal or especially
0:13:13in the summertime you have a barbecue or
0:13:15a cookout or something and you're ready
0:13:16for some ice cream I really like a light
0:13:18ice cream at the end of the day I don't
0:13:21want to feel
0:13:21like I'm eating a pile of cookies and
0:13:23brownies and fudge and caramel and all
0:13:26that stuff that's just so it's like a
0:13:28meal in itself so I feel like both
0:13:30Cherry Garcia Froyo and pistachio
0:13:32pistachio have that really nice light
0:13:34element in addition to the actual red
0:13:37velvet cake which I'm surprised be this
0:13:38red velvet cake is must be chocolate
0:13:40cake but in this ice cream it is not
0:13:41chocolate at all but it's just red cake
0:13:44yeah so I just read tasted small amounts
0:13:47of my three top cakes the these cinnamon
0:13:49buns the strawberry cheesecake and the
0:13:51red velvet cake I would say red velvet
0:13:54cake wild is delicious I think
0:13:55strawberry cheesecake out does it for
0:13:57what for me
0:13:58so are we ranking these in groupings
0:14:00well I have to I'm kinda I'm figuring we
0:14:02do like a like a two-stage thing like
0:14:04you take the finalists after each round
0:14:05and if you like a finalist tasting I and
0:14:09I would say cinnamon buns has a similar
0:14:10issue like all three of those are
0:14:12delicious but strawberry cheesecakes
0:14:15extra little tangy eNOS an extra graham
0:14:17swirl I think do it for me so strawberry
0:14:19cheesecake is my top pick in the cake
0:14:20family and the rest of these I think you
0:14:23know Cherry Garcia is good you know it's
0:14:24it's fine but the rest of these none of
0:14:26them I don't think are gonna make my top
0:14:27four but strawberry cheesecake might
0:14:29well I I'm definitely Cherry Garcia
0:14:32Froyo is still way up there for me I
0:14:34just really really like it um I'm
0:14:37stashing a pistachio it might even be a
0:14:39contender and strawberry cheesecake - oh
0:14:40I just really like this group oh this is
0:14:43like ice cream yeah I think I think I'm
0:14:46learning that I think I just really
0:14:48scream okay all right let's put these
0:14:50back in the freezer and prepare the next
0:14:51group all right well TIFF is doing that
0:14:53we are brought to you this week by
0:14:55Casper Casper as a company focused on
0:14:58sleep I'm making the perfect premium
0:15:00mattresses and selling it online for a
0:15:02fraction of what it would cost in a
0:15:03store Casper's award-winning mattress
0:15:06was developed in-house with a sleek
0:15:07design and it's delivered an ax possibly
0:15:10small box you need to get it upstairs
0:15:11you can do that in addition to the
0:15:13mattress Casper also offers an adaptive
0:15:15pillow and soft breathable sheets
0:15:17an in-house team of engineers spent
0:15:19thousands of hours developing the Casper
0:15:21mattress
0:15:21he doesn't accessable engineer mattress
0:15:23a shockingly fair price so it's no
0:15:25surprise that they have an average of
0:15:264.8 stars across more than 30 thousand
0:15:29online shopping reviews the San
0:15:31Francisco research and development team
0:15:32at Casper have developed a proprietary
0:15:34foam that
0:15:35leaves pressure and increases airflow so
0:15:38it doesn't sleep too hot at night and
0:15:39they combine it with a springy comfort
0:15:41layer to contour to your body so that
0:15:44Casper mattresses have just the right
0:15:46sink and just the right bounce without
0:15:48being hot
0:15:49Casper makes quality mattresses at great
0:15:51prices and they've designed developed in
0:15:53America they've cut the hassle and cost
0:15:55of dealing with showrooms and there's
0:15:57annoying mattress stores and they pass
0:15:59those savings directly on to you and
0:16:01they're also completely risk-free there
0:16:03for free delivery and free returns to
0:16:05the US and Canada and now they just
0:16:07launched service in the UK as well so
0:16:10for the first time UK people you too can
0:16:12have a Casper and they have this great
0:16:14try out program so you can actually
0:16:16sleep on the mattress before you make
0:16:18your final decision try it for a hundred
0:16:20nights and decide of it to right for you
0:16:22that's a three month trial and if you
0:16:24don't love it they will pick it up at
0:16:26your house and refund you everything you
0:16:28paid so you can get $50 towards any
0:16:30mattress purchase my visit in Casper
0:16:32calm slash top four and using the code
0:16:34top four at checkout terms and
0:16:36conditions do apply thank you so much to
0:16:39Casper for their support of this show
0:16:40and relay FM and I have to wash my hands
0:16:43because they're very sticky already
0:16:46alright we're amping things up here next
0:16:49we have the cookie group and showing in
0:16:52the cookie group we have half baked out
0:16:55of this swirl chocolate chip cookie
0:16:57dough
0:16:58mint chocolate cookie cookies and milk
0:17:01and cookies and s'mores should s'mores
0:17:05really being aigis is a smaller sandwich
0:17:09that's gonna be another show can't we
0:17:13just take a second while these all melt
0:17:14too to pause and think about how melty
0:17:17Margo is you're chatting Machat stirs
0:17:19how happy is our life that somebody's
0:17:21paying us cash the wonderful people at
0:17:23Casper are paying us to do this Thank
0:17:25You Casper we will enjoy sleeping our
0:17:27fat butts on your we're gonna have to
0:17:29spend some time when I catch my mattress
0:17:31I have to reheat all this ice cream I
0:17:32know I'm already not feeling so well you
0:17:35see you you took too big of a spoon well
0:17:36okay I have a freezer confession as I
0:17:42was putting them away I tried some again
0:17:45you're gonna regret that in about 20
0:17:47minutes
0:17:48I said solidify at my brain as the you
0:17:52know ice cream was unsolicited like
0:18:03reaching anymore is a mint chocolate
0:18:05cookie it should be a good palate
0:18:08cleanser min cello's cookie
0:18:10it's just Oreos in mint ice cream see
0:18:14s'mores is fine it I'm not really a
0:18:17chocolate ice cream person I'm gonna
0:18:19dislike chocolate ice cream I just I
0:18:21would if given the chance to have a
0:18:23chocolate ice cream full of stuff or
0:18:24vanilla ice cream full of stuff I will
0:18:26choose the vanilla one every time I do
0:18:28wish the s'mores was made with vanilla
0:18:29ice cream and said because I love a
0:18:31marshmallow sorrel in my ice cream Unni
0:18:34and yeah I did not like this as much as
0:18:37I thought coz to be yeah it does the
0:18:40chocolate just berry like that also
0:18:41claims to have a graham swirl I found no
0:18:43trace of that hold on I'm digging I'm
0:18:44gonna dig oh that's dangerous it's not
0:18:47dangerous this is science we have our
0:18:50safety goggles on I'm still not finding
0:18:53any I'm now gonna try your mint and
0:18:54cookies I'm deep down in the court
0:18:57nothing nothing yeah so the mint cookie
0:19:00one yeah it's fine but to me this is
0:19:03like a basic mint chocolate chip slash
0:19:07cookies and cream anybody could do this
0:19:09you don't need Ben and Jerry's to do
0:19:10that I feel like if you're if you're
0:19:12going for Ben and Jerry's I feel like
0:19:13you can get a more interesting flavor
0:19:14than that alright I found some I found
0:19:16some stuff in here I'm gonna eat it I'm
0:19:20still digging through the s'mores yeah
0:19:23even when I'm eating the prime location
0:19:25of all the stuff it's still totally
0:19:28overpowered by the chocolate so if you
0:19:29love chocolate ice cream this is pretty
0:19:32good but again I don't think this is
0:19:34gonna make the list and we went to a
0:19:36special store for this one - yeah the
0:19:39milk and cookies I would say is a really
0:19:43good version of cookies and cream they
0:19:44they add that whenever that like that
0:19:46brown stuff is with the light brown
0:19:48stuff in there it's a chocolate chip
0:19:50cookie oh okay it's chocolate chip
0:19:52cookies oh there's more chocolate
0:19:54cookies as opposed to like a minty Oreos
0:19:56okay yeah that makes more sense that's
0:19:58the best kind of like the cookie dough
0:19:59part of it
0:20:00I really enjoyed milking cookies
0:20:02but I would say it has the same problem
0:20:04as the Mint cookie one which is I think
0:20:07if you're with Ben and Jared you can do
0:20:08better yeah
0:20:10if I wanted a cookie and cream ice cream
0:20:12this is better than like a standard
0:20:15cookie in cream yeah it agree with that
0:20:17all right gonna go to standard cookie
0:20:19dough that there's one lump right on top
0:20:21and I'll go with half baked while you're
0:20:23doing that well that's a pretty big lump
0:20:24too again cookie dough ice cream you
0:20:28don't have to buy Ben and Jerry's get
0:20:29cookie dough ice cream I would say it's
0:20:32not worth it coming to you from experts
0:20:35at a tough war not worth it man this
0:20:40grip is disappointing me so and then
0:20:43here I have half baked which is
0:20:44essentially cookie dough with fudge
0:20:47brownie dough or fudge brownies I agree
0:20:51with you on the regular cookie dough not
0:20:53worth it oh really big Peter brave yeah
0:20:56the half baked I think is more
0:20:59interesting but it's also I think it's
0:21:01more for chocolate ice cream lovers it's
0:21:03not doing much for me it a lot of that
0:21:05stuff gets buried
0:21:05I literally just ate like a full brownie
0:21:08with some ice cream melted next to it I
0:21:12mean a grant like that is kind of the
0:21:17point like so I understand why people
0:21:18like it but yeah it doesn't do anything
0:21:19for me mm-hmm doesn't do it okay last is
0:21:21um
0:21:22out of this world out of this world it's
0:21:25not you know cookie flavor my hand is so
0:21:28cold from passing around these pints
0:21:29okay first of all problems hashtag
0:21:32buttery brown sugar ice cream with fudgy
0:21:34flakes and oatmeal cinnamon cookie
0:21:36swirled it tastes just like Cinnabon but
0:21:40with chocolate chips in it nope nope I'm
0:21:45feeling nothing from this group I had
0:21:48very high hopes for odorless rogues I'm
0:21:50a huge fan of oatmeal cookies and I
0:21:52didn't do it for me
0:21:53it just it's fine it's not bad I mean
0:21:56it's hard to make a bad tasting ice
0:21:57cream that's just not good it's just not
0:22:00it's not enough there's not there's
0:22:01nothing special about it it's kind of
0:22:03it's all it's almost bland
0:22:04Wow I feel like we started on such a
0:22:06high where I couldn't even pick which
0:22:07ones I like the best and now this whole
0:22:09group that's what how many ice creams
0:22:10six ice creams now that I have no
0:22:12feelings about I would rather have any
0:22:14of the previous groups ice creams then
0:22:16the top pick of these I agree I'm really
0:22:20happy we have similar ice cream tastes
0:22:22because it allows us to share a pint on
0:22:23the couch instead of having to have two
0:22:28okay cookie group kind of a bust
0:22:31sorry cookies you're out all right
0:22:33that's two groups down two to go
0:22:35and I'll take this halftime chance to
0:22:37tell you our Ben and Jerry's factory
0:22:39story we went on a hike the only hike
0:22:43slash camping trip we've ever gone on my
0:22:46wonderful all Eagle Scout friends from
0:22:49high school convinced us that we should
0:22:51go hike on the long trail with them in
0:22:53Vermont this was not a good idea it went
0:22:56quite poorly and halfway through the
0:22:58trip about half the group just decided
0:23:01we can't and won't to continue it's like
0:23:04three days in and so half the group
0:23:07decided they wanted to keep going so the
0:23:10half that left the group went to the Ben
0:23:12Jerry's Factory and a Benihana and
0:23:14texted the still camping group pictures
0:23:16of our wonderful things and we got
0:23:18ourselves pint cozies and had a
0:23:20wonderful time at the Ben Jerry's
0:23:21Factory in Burlington Vermont and we
0:23:23still use those pint cozies today which
0:23:25but we're not using them now because
0:23:26it's a pain to shift them yeah quite
0:23:30gross oh yeah they're super gross
0:23:31although we will not call them koozies
0:23:33no that's illegal New York all right so
0:23:36this we kind of now as mentioned earlier
0:23:38we've had some trouble grouping these
0:23:40into coherent groups this is kind of
0:23:42like the the like everything else group
0:23:44because we have we have a final group
0:23:45that makes more sense so this is kind of
0:23:47like the leftovers group we have two
0:23:48coffee flavors two chocolate heavy
0:23:52flavors and peanut butter cup so we
0:23:57figured that we separate yeah we
0:23:58separated these because they had fewer
0:24:00ingredients and more strong flavors and
0:24:03we also wanted to pit the coffee's
0:24:04against each other
0:24:05and the chocolates against each other so
0:24:07yeah I'm gonna start with peanut butter
0:24:09cup because it's a different one I'm
0:24:13gonna need some water after those we're
0:24:14getting us fresh spoons every time for
0:24:16every grouping well I mean we're
0:24:17professionals here Larry like don't want
0:24:19to contaminate flavors or have like a
0:24:21you know wet spoon or to warm spoon so
0:24:25many factors
0:24:26no I don't need your spoon all right
0:24:30we're starting with peanut butter has
0:24:31strong it's different see peanut butter
0:24:34is one of my favorite ice cream
0:24:35ingredients there's a whole weight I
0:24:38wish you creating a full cup it looks
0:24:40there's a full peanut butter cup in here
0:24:42like cracked because for like stomach
0:24:47control reasons like I'm not eating it I
0:24:49already ate that full brownie
0:24:49accidentally found its way in I don't
0:24:52know at any other time when I mean I
0:24:54would go right for that but there's
0:24:55lokay it says it says peanut butter cups
0:24:58and they literally mean entire peanut
0:25:01butter cups yeah and so peanut butter I
0:25:04love and Ben and Jerry's has had many
0:25:05wonderful peanut butter for actually
0:25:07disappointed it seems like what used to
0:25:10be called cluster fluff and then was
0:25:12renamed to what a cluster that appears
0:25:14to be gone and I really missed that was
0:25:15so good that was amazing does that hit
0:25:18my mark of having the swirl of it was a
0:25:21marshmallow and a peanut butter swirl
0:25:23through relic if given the choice
0:25:25between peanut butter cups buried in the
0:25:27ice cream or a peanut butter swirl
0:25:29throughout I'll take the swirl every
0:25:30time oh yeah you have to take the swirl
0:25:32every time especially if it's with
0:25:33marshmallow balances it's nice I really
0:25:35miss cluster fluff / what the cluster or
0:25:38what a cluster and that's a Shana that
0:25:40appears to be gone hopefully they'll
0:25:41replace it with something good but I
0:25:43don't peanut butter cup it's fine it
0:25:45tastes like other peanut butter cup ice
0:25:46creams yeah I mean it's really similar
0:25:49to like the cookies and creams that we
0:25:50had last time like yeah it's a good ice
0:25:51cream but I don't think it's I would say
0:25:54though I think if you like pistachio I
0:25:57think this is the same level of goodness
0:25:59as the pistachio one if there was
0:26:01nothing else that I liked in in a dairy
0:26:03case and I wanted to my ice cream I'd
0:26:04buy this one I mean I do like peanut
0:26:06butter ice cream I used to think that I
0:26:07didn't and then Marco started having
0:26:08peanut butter ice cream and then I
0:26:10started stealing spoonfuls of his peanut
0:26:11butter ice cream even though I kept to
0:26:13saying that I don't like it even though
0:26:14I kept eating it and so now I guess I
0:26:16have to officially say that I like
0:26:17peanut butter ice cream and again this
0:26:20is it's good but I said I very good I
0:26:23miss the other one though I miss the one
0:26:25with the swirl off that would that was
0:26:27way better it was way better sorry Ben &
0:26:29Jerry's bring back cluster fluff please
0:26:31alright moving on to you think we'll do
0:26:33the chocolate ones and then we'll finish
0:26:35with some coffee for dessert yeah yeah
0:26:37she's out chocolate pretty good sure
0:26:40right we have two chocolates here we
0:26:41have chocolate therapy and chocolate
0:26:43fudge brownie brownie okay it's very
0:26:46small to read we got the tiny chocolate
0:26:48fudge brownie one yeah chocolate fudge
0:26:50brownie okay chocolate therapy has fudge
0:26:54swirls putting ice cream and chocolate
0:26:57cookies and chocolate fudge brownie has
0:27:00chocolate brownies chocolate ice cream
0:27:02with fudge brownies yeah so chocolate
0:27:04fudge brownie I would say is incredibly
0:27:06boring yep
0:27:08tastes like chocolate ice cream yeah
0:27:10yeah it's like if you want a chocolaty
0:27:13Ben and Jerry's flavor you can do better
0:27:14than that mm-hmm yep yeah that's fine
0:27:19moving on to chocolate therapy so what's
0:27:22different about this one therapy has
0:27:25three wheels of chocolate pudding ice
0:27:26cream are also in there and choc cookies
0:27:28instead of chocolate fudge yeah there's
0:27:31no brownies in this one just putting in
0:27:34chocolate and chocolate and another
0:27:36chocolate I would say those are almost
0:27:38indistinguishable from each other and I
0:27:39don't know why they're two separate
0:27:40flavors and they're both very boring to
0:27:42me I disagree on principle because I
0:27:46feel like I they need to be different
0:27:47cuz I really like this company and they
0:27:50do wonderful things for the world but
0:27:53yeah they pretty much taste the same
0:27:59actually yeah let's do a blind taste
0:28:01test okay
0:28:02no I actually feel like the chocolate
0:28:03therapy is a little bit richer and it
0:28:06has it does you do taste like the
0:28:10chocolate pudding this a little bit more
0:28:12let me see oh it's on my pants
0:28:15oh gosh key pops away I'll just spoon it
0:28:18up it's fine I'm gonna have to change my
0:28:21clothes yeah I find no reason to really
0:28:26eat either of those unless you just love
0:28:28chocolate ice cream yeah I feel like it
0:28:30also if you're shopping and you were
0:28:33looking for chocolate ice cream
0:28:34grabbing either one of these would
0:28:35satisfy your craving looking at them the
0:28:38chocolate fudge brownie is lighter brown
0:28:41color than the chocolate therapy which
0:28:43is much darker it tastes the same I
0:28:45think the chocolate therapy tastes a
0:28:47little bit richer yeah I think having
0:28:49that having the chocolate pudding in
0:28:50there helps a little bit but it does if
0:28:52you're looking for chocolate ice cream
0:28:54I would buy the chocolate therapy over
0:28:56the chocolate brownie yeah I guess I
0:28:58would too but in reality I would buy
0:28:59neither of them yeah all right now let's
0:29:01move on to the coffee group this this
0:29:03includes what used to be called coffee
0:29:04heath bar crunch now it's called coffee
0:29:06toffee bar crunch and coffee coffee buzz
0:29:08buzz buzz we left out the vanilla toffee
0:29:12one
0:29:13yeah the vanilla what used to be called
0:29:14mental heath bar crunch now vanilla
0:29:15toffee bar crunch we left that out
0:29:17because it we've we've had a lot of
0:29:19these before they used to be like our
0:29:20go-to flavors and I would say if you
0:29:24know if you you could just try one of
0:29:26them like I don't think they're that
0:29:28different from each other with the
0:29:29exception obviously one of them is
0:29:30coffee flavored if you like coffee ice
0:29:32cream I'm a big fan of the coffee toffee
0:29:35bar crunch however as I have gotten more
0:29:38into drinking black coffee as I've
0:29:40gotten older since I first discovered
0:29:42ice cream I actually don't like coffee
0:29:44ice cream anymore because it tastes to
0:29:46me like coffee with too much milk and
0:29:49sugar in it I mean it is coffee and
0:29:52sugar in it right it makes total sense
0:29:53and the aftertaste lingers in my mouth
0:29:56the same way I get like aftertaste if I
0:29:58if I ever drink coffee with stuff in it
0:29:59okay well one has is coffee with
0:30:02chocolate pieces the other is coffee
0:30:04with fudge and chocolate no sorry for
0:30:10toffee bar toffee and fudge they look
0:30:14exactly the same
0:30:15so coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz has a
0:30:17very nice strength of espresso flavor
0:30:20like because the the chocolate bits
0:30:22almost taste what they have ground up
0:30:23espresso beans in them do they yes this
0:30:24is espresso bean fudge that's it so if
0:30:27you like that if you like the taste of
0:30:29chocolate espresso beans I would say
0:30:31that is the ice cream version of that
0:30:32almost two years you actually almost get
0:30:34a little bit of the grain from the bean
0:30:35in the chocolate you do yeah mmm that's
0:30:38a really nice detail good touch yeah the
0:30:41coffee toffee bar crunch oh my god why
0:30:44am i picking up the biggest pieces we
0:30:47used to eat a lot of these I would say I
0:30:50think they've developed better flavors
0:30:52now if you're looking for coffee flavor
0:30:55coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz is a better
0:30:57one yeah the coffee ice cream and this
0:30:59is a little bit mild it's very I'd say
0:31:01it's very weak yeah yeah it's much
0:31:02weaker and some of the toffee tastes a
0:31:05little bit
0:31:07honestly I would actually say the coffee
0:31:09coffee buzz-buzz it I actually like that
0:31:11enough that I might actually have that
0:31:13yeah I prefer coffee coffee buzz buzz
0:31:15over this coffee toffee bar crunch which
0:31:18I thought would have been the opposite
0:31:19me too
0:31:20but yeah I think now that are they
0:31:23actually using heath bar or they make
0:31:24their own bars now and they had to take
0:31:26the heath name off I'm guessing it's the
0:31:27latter that's probably why they change
0:31:28the name because I could be totally
0:31:31wrong and in a blind taste test I can
0:31:33completely fail just like the everything
0:31:35they did the big big just like the egg
0:31:37bagel situation but I'm feeling like
0:31:40that the heath bar one tasted a lot
0:31:43better yeah yeah I'm not really into
0:31:46that one I'm I think I'm gonna try the
0:31:48toffee bar I'm just gonna bite it go for
0:31:50it
0:31:50yeah it has kind of a weird flavor to it
0:31:52you should bite it too
0:31:53it actually kind of tastes a little bit
0:31:55stale I wonder if this is just not a
0:31:57good pint I don't know I think it was
0:31:59pretty much always that way I think it's
0:32:01similar in consistency and Tony I just
0:32:03don't like it anymore I think I might
0:32:05not like anymore
0:32:06Wow what's happening to us yeah the
0:32:09coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz is a much
0:32:11better coffee flavor yeah it's like the
0:32:14coffee buzz one is it has enough of like
0:32:19the savory parts of coffee flavoring
0:32:21that I actually enjoy it
0:32:22as compared to most coffee
0:32:23esterification as I mentioned I find I
0:32:24find too sweet and milky this one
0:32:26actually balances it pretty well yep I
0:32:28agree
0:32:28alright final group coming up oh we're
0:32:31gonna need some water here some water Oh
0:32:34one-way Water Street it's cold man do we
0:32:39have enough spoons to keep going
0:32:41alright we have the final group here
0:32:45which we are lovingly calling the whole
0:32:47bunch of crap group these are the ones
0:32:50where the description of what is in the
0:32:52containers are it barely fits on the top
0:32:56of the lid they usually have to wrap it
0:32:58to three lines on the bottom and it's oh
0:33:00you should call it the description three
0:33:02lines or more group this is basically
0:33:05the group that can be best described as
0:33:07ice cream full of candy and stuff like
0:33:10hey it's not it's just like up a whole
0:33:12bunch of candy a side of ice cream
0:33:13alright you want to read off what we
0:33:14have here all right so all right we have
0:33:15fish food we have the tonight dough
0:33:18every
0:33:19but the Chubby Hubby new york super
0:33:22fudge chunk and american dream and our
0:33:24cone dream oh I'm sorry I couldn't see
0:33:26the e from here there's so many ice
0:33:27creams alright it was probably a poor
0:33:32decision to see these four last cuz I'm
0:33:33already pretty full oh this is a bad
0:33:35idea we should have we should have
0:33:36closed with the simple stuff like palate
0:33:38cleansers like I can really go for some
0:33:40nice cream this is we made a huge
0:33:44mistake alright well I think I need to
0:33:47start out with fish food because I'm the
0:33:48fish fan of the family even though I
0:33:50almost never buy this because again I'm
0:33:52not that big of a fan of chocolate ice
0:33:53cream what that's pretty chocolatey
0:33:54what's that business book where you're
0:33:56supposed to eat the eat the frog first
0:33:57or something yeah that's that I'm pretty
0:34:00sure that's it yeah frog first yeah
0:34:01whatever should have we should have
0:34:04eaten the fish food first because it's a
0:34:07really dense let me see
0:34:09alright fish food is chocolate ice cream
0:34:10with gooey marshmallows swirls caramel
0:34:13swirls and fudge fish which is super fun
0:34:15why wouldn't you like I like when
0:34:17there's animal shapes in my ice cream
0:34:19yeah the fudge fish I would say are the
0:34:21highlight of this flavor oh and of
0:34:22course marshmallow so BAM you you had me
0:34:24at marshmallow but other than that
0:34:25though I would say it doesn't do much
0:34:27for me I feel like I think this is one
0:34:30of those flavors that Ben and Jerry's
0:34:32this is a very old flavor I think Ben
0:34:34and Jerry's has gotten better more
0:34:36sophisticated and they're in their newer
0:34:37efforts so along with the coffee toffee
0:34:40bar crunch I would say this is kind of
0:34:42almost a little bit boring now and I
0:34:45don't know maybe maybe if I like
0:34:46chocolate ice cream more I would like it
0:34:47more but to me the only reason to eat
0:34:49this is the fudge fish which are
0:34:50delicious but the rest of it doesn't do
0:34:52much for me okay I really like this
0:34:54because I like the marshmallow and I
0:34:56like the caramel swirl I think it's
0:34:58really good they have just condensation
0:35:02and I like the fun little fish and it's
0:35:05fish food like pH like Marco likes and
0:35:07tortures everyone with so I'm super into
0:35:11this I like it it's a classic flavor it
0:35:14reminds me of some original Ben and
0:35:15Jerry's good eats and I'm really happy
0:35:18with fish food really among their
0:35:20classic well known flavors I would say
0:35:22one of the one of the ones that holds
0:35:23the best is your favorite the sherry
0:35:24Garcia
0:35:25very well well yeah even though the fish
0:35:28is better than Grateful Dead come at me
0:35:29because I
0:35:30about me I mean I have really good taste
0:35:33though but do you have to try the New
0:35:35York super fudge chunk next this is
0:35:37chocolate ice cream with white and dark
0:35:39fudge chunks pecans walnuts and fudge
0:35:42colored covered almonds I'm least
0:35:44favorite I'm least excited about this
0:35:46one because we are not big fans of
0:35:48pecans or walnuts so this could be
0:35:51interesting but I'm honestly I be
0:35:53surprised if I was trying enough of it
0:35:54to actually get a big nut chunk here
0:35:56I'll try to get one here I mean you have
0:35:58to get the nut chunk this whole point of
0:35:59this we really should have not eaten
0:36:02these last that's just a piece of
0:36:04chocolate the round ones are the nuts oh
0:36:08here's a piece of another nut oh it's
0:36:12just oh there's so much there's so much
0:36:14stuff a white chocolate there's white
0:36:16chocolate white and dark chocolate fudge
0:36:17chunks yeah there's a lot going on in
0:36:20there
0:36:20I actually do like it I thought I
0:36:22wouldn't because of all the nuts I
0:36:23actually do like it but I wouldn't
0:36:25choose it over other flavors you chew
0:36:27this ice cream more than anything
0:36:29yes it's very chunky this is a chewing
0:36:31ice cream a lot I'm still chewing this
0:36:34ice cream what part of it is New York
0:36:37I'm still chewing it is it just the fact
0:36:38that we eat it in New York or what um
0:36:41let's see okay it says it right here on
0:36:47the pipe in 1985 to make a name for
0:36:49ourselves in New York we picked a New
0:36:51York kind of name and wait there's
0:36:53freezer burn and created a flavor packed
0:36:56with more kinds of chunks than ever
0:36:58before we figured if the flavor was
0:37:01euphoric in New York it would be
0:37:03everywhere oh I'm not feeling so good
0:37:06I'm moving on to the tonight dough the
0:37:08Jimmy Fallon flavor this is caramel and
0:37:11chocolate ice creams with chocolate
0:37:13cookie swirls and gobs of chocolate chip
0:37:16cookie dough and peanut butter cookie
0:37:18dough so this is kind of amazing this
0:37:24category is like what can we like
0:37:26legally get it like what is the most
0:37:27crap you can legally put in a pint of
0:37:29ice cream this is like watching one of
0:37:31those little tasty videos that are all
0:37:33over Instagram and Facebook where they
0:37:36just pour in a whole bunch of candy and
0:37:38chocolate and mix it around with some
0:37:39other chocolate and stuff and then say
0:37:41like Tuesday all right tonight dough
0:37:44I like it really I I'm not sure again
0:37:49it's one of those things like I like it
0:37:50I'm not sure I would remember it like
0:37:52tomorrow but but I like it it's good
0:37:55okay what this has going for it is it
0:37:59has instead of vanilla ice cream it does
0:38:00have caramel ice cream instead of the
0:38:03chocolate ice cream right this week it's
0:38:05chocolate and vanilla mm-hmm but you
0:38:06don't feel like you're eating like a big
0:38:09dollop of like full of caramel and but
0:38:12you know like that yeah yeah yeah
0:38:14gooeyness so it's still more ice cream
0:38:17flavored wait what else is in here
0:38:18everything there's there's chocolate and
0:38:20peanut butter cookie dough and chocolate
0:38:23and vanilla ice cream and gobs of
0:38:26chocolate it's okay it has a lot of
0:38:28stuff in it but it's not a chewing ice
0:38:30cream it's very smooth or blend mm-hmm
0:38:33it has more the grainy elements to it
0:38:35because of the cookie dough bits but
0:38:37it's more dispersed throughout yeah so
0:38:40it's much more pleasant to eat than
0:38:41something like super fudge chunk so if
0:38:43you like to chew your ice cream which I
0:38:46don't
0:38:48New York super fudge changes for you if
0:38:51you like more smooth ice cream with a
0:38:53whole bunch of stuff the tonight dough
0:38:54is a really good choice oh my god how
0:38:57many left three so obviously after doing
0:39:00the Jimmy Fallon flavor I think we need
0:39:02to do the late-night themed continuation
0:39:04and go with the Stephen Colbert flavor
0:39:06called Americone dream this is vanilla
0:39:08ice cream with fudge covered waffle cone
0:39:11pieces and a caramel swirl I'm excited
0:39:14about the cone bit
0:39:15all right so finally it's not just
0:39:18chocolate ice cream pretty much
0:39:19something guess lighter I don't know the
0:39:22comb bits are good but it's slightly
0:39:24soggy like I feel like some of the
0:39:26potential of them is a little bit lost
0:39:27but overall very good I like that yeah
0:39:30that I would say I like the Chilean
0:39:32Colbert wins the late-night Wars whoa
0:39:34really you know I've never seen either
0:39:37show what yes you have we watch clips
0:39:40all the time from YouTube clips don't
0:39:42count all right I like this I like the
0:39:44slightly soggy slightly crunchiness of
0:39:46the cone I think it's a really good
0:39:49balance it's it's it's not a their stuff
0:39:51in it but it's not a heavy to ice cream
0:39:53there are pieces but they're small like
0:39:57it isn't you don't
0:39:58like excavate them out you did like you
0:40:00do with some of the big chunks of the
0:40:01other flavors I like that yeah that's
0:40:03very nice I think I like that more than
0:40:05fish food oh no poor fish food well then
0:40:09I got to write this down okay
0:40:15we're just oh there's so much sticky in
0:40:17here okay as you write down I'm going to
0:40:18move on okay hey so I'm gonna try now
0:40:21the everything but the dot dot and
0:40:24flavor so it's arrived as this is a four
0:40:26liner it's described as a collision of
0:40:29chocolate and vanilla ice creams with
0:40:31peanut butter cups fudge-covered toffee
0:40:33pieces white chocolate chunks and fudge
0:40:36covered almonds it is four lines of
0:40:39description yes is a four liner there is
0:40:41a I'm actually kind of worried I'm not
0:40:44going to get every element in my tasting
0:40:45spoon phone charm everything but so I
0:40:48guess it should have the most lines of
0:40:49content maybe chewiness till tomorrow I
0:40:52haven't found anything mine the top
0:40:54layers all ice cream you dug it out that
0:40:57that is similar in chunkiness to New
0:41:01York super fudge chunk oh they're like
0:41:04chewing a lot
0:41:05I had to excavate and I found it a chunk
0:41:08cavern there's a lot going on there it's
0:41:11good but I it almost seems like I mean I
0:41:15know you know the name like everything
0:41:16but the it almost seems like it could
0:41:18use some editing like it's hard to like
0:41:20focus on any one part of it mm-hmm yeah
0:41:23this is definitely for the person that
0:41:25can't decide what kind of ice cream they
0:41:27want and they just want it all in one
0:41:29bite yeah I don't really like it yeah I
0:41:32mean it's too much yeah I'm not reading
0:41:35yep all right and then the last one that
0:41:38we have to try today is Chubby Hubby
0:41:40which is ironic as me eating it so I am
0:41:44eating my wonderful ice cream here
0:41:46Chubby Hubby it is vanilla malta
0:41:48flavored ice cream which I tend to like
0:41:49with peanutty fudge covered pretzels
0:41:52with fudge and peanut butter swirls this
0:41:56is one of the few ice creams left in the
0:41:57lion that has peanut butter swirl in it
0:41:59which I always appreciate let me try go
0:42:02try to get a pretzel piece here but
0:42:04they're a little hard to get these ice
0:42:08creams are looking quite ravaged as we
0:42:10try to dig out all the flavors
0:42:12to give you the listener and accurate
0:42:14representation of what we're actually
0:42:15eating here oh my goodness
0:42:18see I liked Chubby Hubby a lot but it's
0:42:22I wouldn't I'm not sure it makes my top
0:42:24four it's really good yeah I agree with
0:42:27you I like the I like the peanut butter
0:42:29swirl the pretzel the large pretzel
0:42:31pieces first off I wish they were
0:42:32smaller and and whenever we buy this
0:42:35sometimes and whenever I bought it I've
0:42:36had very inconsistent results with
0:42:38whether the pretzels are crunchy or kind
0:42:40of mushy - empty okay yeah good science
0:42:46there yeah so like when the pretzels are
0:42:50good it's good
0:42:51oh they have the crunch level on eight
0:42:53yeah yes this is this is a good point
0:42:55that we got here eight to nine really I
0:42:56do like Chubby Hubby a lot but I'd say
0:43:00out of this group honestly I think
0:43:01Americone dream out class is it the cow
0:43:03on the pint is sitting in a lazy boy
0:43:04with a remote and it is it is nice that
0:43:08they have that malt flavor ice cream
0:43:10even I know you weren't a big fan of
0:43:11malt but you can barely taste it with
0:43:13all that stuff going on though I've
0:43:14tasted quite a bit but it's it's nice to
0:43:16have it to have like a difference like
0:43:17it isn't just vanilla or chocolate with
0:43:19salt in it okay the pretzel is really
0:43:22salty oh my goodness I'm the predominant
0:43:26flavor in my mouth right now is salt
0:43:29spoonful of ice cream well the solution
0:43:32you eat more ice cream there we call not
0:43:37chunk chubby happy Chubby Hubby sorry
0:43:38because the pretzel pieces are so big
0:43:41you don't really get them very often so
0:43:44it is kind of nice that it's special
0:43:45when you do get one but it's it the
0:43:47whole rest of the ice cream is kind of
0:43:48now my void of them I feel like I might
0:43:51as well just dipped a tortilla chip in
0:43:53there and makes it like dip can I have
0:43:58some water yeah well over it's over
0:44:03season all right so that is the end of
0:44:06the whole bunch of crap group okay I
0:44:08need to take a picture of this and then
0:44:10I want to take a moment to deliberate so
0:44:12I think you should play a little bit of
0:44:13deliberation music which I think should
0:44:15be fish
0:44:15honestly they have a song about ice
0:44:18cream or stomachaches
0:44:22be more fun in love in the skyline baby
0:44:26I scream snooze
0:44:30what I think is the most surprising of
0:44:32all of these taste testings with them
0:44:35right back to back with each other cuz
0:44:37usually when you go out and you buy a
0:44:38pint of ice cream you buy one right you
0:44:42just kind of like pick the flavor and
0:44:43you're happy with it and pitting them up
0:44:45against each other I'm really surprised
0:44:47how little difference there is between a
0:44:51lot of them yeah and again they're all
0:44:54good ice creams Markus so don't worry
0:44:57who we really do like Ben and Jerry's
0:44:59we love them as a company and we like
0:45:02all their cool flavors but oh I feel out
0:45:06of breath eating all of this ice cream
0:45:09and there are chocolate fingerprints all
0:45:12over most of our kitchen so sorry about
0:45:15that I'm actually having a hard time in
0:45:19my deliberations I'm ranking these
0:45:20because like if they still made the
0:45:24cluster fluff flavor that would be my
0:45:26number one no questions but they they
0:45:29currently do not make a very good peanut
0:45:32butter flavor like they just missing
0:45:35from the lineup right now I hope they
0:45:36resolved that soon they have a few that
0:45:38are okay like peanut butter cup is great
0:45:40a for you know for peanut butter ice
0:45:42cream lovers like me but it is but the
0:45:45other peanut butter like whenever they
0:45:46had another peanut butter option it was
0:45:48always better than peanut butter comes
0:45:49mm-hmm so I am kind of disappointed in
0:45:52the lack of that slot being very well
0:45:54filled right now I would say the among
0:45:58the basic flavors pistachio still stands
0:46:01out as a really good one Cherry Garcia
0:46:03also still really holds up as adversely
0:46:06yeah
0:46:08many of the new flavors are excellent
0:46:10the cake ones I think the cake group had
0:46:12by far the strongest showing this year
0:46:14oh yeah I was most I was most excited
0:46:16for the cookie group and I was most
0:46:18disappointed by them they really let me
0:46:20down but the cake the fruit and nuts
0:46:23group was uh was really great I liked it
0:46:26a lot fruit fruit nuts and cake is that
0:46:28what we're calling it something like
0:46:29that yeah and Ellie I saw them like the
0:46:33red velvet cake
0:46:34we would never have bought that if not
0:46:36for doing this test and it was one of
0:46:37the very last ones we bought we thought
0:46:39we're like do we really need that yeah
0:46:40we weren't we looked at the list before
0:46:42we went to the store and I immediately
0:46:44dismissed
0:46:45red velvet because I was like you know
0:46:47what red velvet cake is a lie so I'm not
0:46:50even going to want my ice cream and then
0:46:52lo and behold it is delicious because
0:46:55you know what it's not just chocolate
0:46:56cake in the ice cream like I said before
0:46:58it is it's more of like a pink cake
0:47:02piece than anything else all right you
0:47:06ready to do the rankings you still
0:47:07deliberating oh I have some honorable
0:47:10mentions yeah I think I'm ready because
0:47:12I'm gonna go with my gut in like what my
0:47:15classic flavors are that I really like
0:47:17in addition to what we've gone through
0:47:19tasting and I hope that well I'm sure
0:47:22that it's affecting me a little bit and
0:47:24how full I feel right now and that I can
0:47:27imagine eating some of those really
0:47:29heavy ice creams but in general I'm not
0:47:31a heavy ice cream person so I think it's
0:47:35gonna be okay I I won't make too many
0:47:37mistakes in my ranking yeah so as of
0:47:41right now this is how we feel about Ben
0:47:43& Jerry's ice cream flavors and where
0:47:46they stand all right which way do you
0:47:48want to go from the bottom as usual okay
0:47:50honorable mentions first let's do it
0:47:53yeah
0:47:53all right honorable mention I'm gonna
0:47:55put coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz as my
0:47:57main honorable mention that is the very
0:48:00first one on my list is honorable
0:48:01mention really yeah yeah I really like I
0:48:04expect to like it as much as I did yeah
0:48:05I really like it has a great coffee
0:48:07flavor just like you said it tastes a
0:48:09lot like coffee with too much cream and
0:48:11sugar but sometimes I really do feel
0:48:12like a coffee ice cream especially like
0:48:15late in the afternoon if I haven't had
0:48:17my afternoon coffee yet a good off
0:48:18coffee ice cream feels like a nice
0:48:19substitute and also it tastes in my
0:48:22opinion it tastes the least like coffee
0:48:24with too much milk and sugar and
0:48:25compared to any other coffee ice cream
0:48:26I've ever had yeah because it has that
0:48:28really sharp flavor of the espresso
0:48:30beans yeah very strong savory flavor of
0:48:34that yes really bounce it out so yeah
0:48:36that's my honorable mention in my second
0:48:38honorable mention which was a surprise
0:48:40can well what's it called when someone
0:48:42just sneaks in I'm sure the subscribe to
0:48:45them for that yeah sports term for super
0:48:50fill-in-the-blank is red velvet for me
0:48:52so mm-hmm
0:48:53I would also put that up there is really
0:48:55good very good and and if not for the
0:48:57other cake flavors I might even be on my
0:49:00ranked list me too I'm really shocked
0:49:02but again I didn't put it on my ranked
0:49:04list because it was the first time I've
0:49:05had it and I feel like we haven't had a
0:49:07gut we haven't had a chance to bond yet
0:49:09yeah we need to get we need to get to
0:49:11know the red velvet cake better yeah I
0:49:12need to finish an entire pint first
0:49:14before I I can really put it on my list
0:49:18oh yeah definitely I would also say in
0:49:21the honorable mentions category for me
0:49:23would be Cherry Garcia aye I know you
0:49:27like it better than I do but I still do
0:49:29really like it I would say it it's
0:49:30better than because it's getting them
0:49:32this part of the list you know out of 24
0:49:33ice creams that we try I would say it is
0:49:35better than almost almost all the
0:49:37flavors honestly like overall
0:49:39and my final honorable mention is
0:49:40tonight dough I really like I really
0:49:43enjoyed that one yeah it was good it was
0:49:44okay I would I would actually say for
0:49:47that type of ice cream to kind of like
0:49:48blended with like cookies and vanilla in
0:49:51it I like milk and cookies better for
0:49:53that slot and that's milk cookies is on
0:49:55my honorable mention list for that
0:49:56reason see I feel like the milk and
0:49:58cookies yeah it was better but I feel
0:49:59like the tonight dough took those milk
0:50:02and cookie ones to another level and
0:50:04really amped it up you know a volume
0:50:08notch and I think I really like that and
0:50:09to me that says very much Ben and
0:50:11Jerry's like I'm getting a kind of a
0:50:14cookie and cream ice cream experience
0:50:16but with that Ben and Jerry twist and I
0:50:18feel like the tea the tonight dough
0:50:20gives it that extra level of twist that
0:50:24beats the other flavors fair enough all
0:50:28right all right number four number four
0:50:30for me is the American dream I really
0:50:33liked it
0:50:34for a stuff filled ice cream I thought
0:50:36it was very bunch of crap ice cream yeah
0:50:39for ice cream full of crap it was pretty
0:50:42great it had a nice balance I didn't
0:50:44feel like I was just eating gobs of
0:50:46things I felt like I could really
0:50:47distinguish the flavors and the textures
0:50:49from each other and I really enjoyed and
0:50:50appreciated that if I would even say we
0:50:52might have miscategorized it I thought
0:50:54it was going to be a whole bunch of crap
0:50:55ice cream but I would say it has roughly
0:50:58the same density of stuff in it then as
0:51:00things like
0:51:02like coffee coffee buzz buzz buzz with
0:51:04those fudge chunks or maybe like the the
0:51:06heath bar one or peanut butter cup well
0:51:08the coffee toffee also had a whole bunch
0:51:10of stuff so that's about the same levels
0:51:11America as the American dream right
0:51:15right right
0:51:16all right my number four is pistachio I
0:51:19was kind of you know giving her a hard
0:51:22time earlier but when I when I come back
0:51:23to it on it when I draw these flavors
0:51:24together I realize like it is it is
0:51:27frustrating how good pistachio is it
0:51:30shouldn't be as good as it is pistachio
0:51:32is my number three yeah it's like it's
0:51:36such a good like clean pure flavor and
0:51:39we've tried so many pistachio ice cream
0:51:40because they're usually really good and
0:51:42it's just a really good implementation
0:51:44well a lot of pistachio ice creams are
0:51:46died like bright green like a lot of bad
0:51:48mint ice creams and I feel like this
0:51:50particular pistachio it has a really
0:51:53crisp flavor that comes through very
0:51:57delicately and nicely it doesn't taste
0:51:59like if you have ever had instant
0:52:01pistachio pudding where that just tastes
0:52:02like a whole bunch of fake pistachio
0:52:05flavoring it just I don't know what's
0:52:08going on in that but it doesn't really
0:52:10taste like what a pistachio tastes like
0:52:12when you're eating it this ice cream
0:52:13tastes like a pistachio and it has full
0:52:16bright green pistachios in it but the
0:52:19ice cream itself is just a light it's
0:52:22almost morning with ice cream yeah so
0:52:23I'd I would say it even areas that it
0:52:25has an almost gelato like smoothness of
0:52:28the texture yeah it is a very very nice
0:52:30pleasant like refreshing ice cream yeah
0:52:33so pistachio my number four and your
0:52:35number three yeah all right my number
0:52:38three is peanut butter cup I say that
0:52:42reluctantly though because as I said
0:52:44earlier like if I wish they would bring
0:52:46back one of their better peanut butter
0:52:48flavors or replace them with with
0:52:49something you know of that caliber I do
0:52:52altima till really love peanut butter
0:52:55ice cream and peanut butter cup is a
0:52:57really good version of peanut butter ice
0:52:59cream I just wish it was cluster fluff
0:53:02again yeah I feel like the peanut butter
0:53:04cup didn't even make my list because I
0:53:06don't like peanut butter ice cream
0:53:07enough to ever get to ever buy it for
0:53:09myself
0:53:10I do enjoy stealing a spoonful or two of
0:53:12yours when you're eating it but for you
0:53:15oh you always take the big chunks well
0:53:16yeah and I was just going to say I
0:53:18really don't care for the big chunks of
0:53:20peanut butter cups in the ice cream
0:53:22because I feel like I'm like even there
0:53:29I'll take them I like them no I like
0:53:32them but I prefer swirl yeah as opposed
0:53:35to like let me chew this piece of ice
0:53:37cream yeah agreed
0:53:38I agree all right what was the see that
0:53:41was my number three yeah I'm gonna do my
0:53:43number two
0:53:43yeah what's your number two my number
0:53:45two is the strawberry cheesecake nice
0:53:47which is funny because I normally don't
0:53:49really like strawberries that much but
0:53:51what cheesecake
0:53:53I like cheesecake just fine but it's
0:53:55like cheesecake I make a good cheese I
0:53:57like cheesecake I oh yeah of course yeah
0:53:58it's like red sauce right my sauce you
0:54:05don't like other people's thoughts
0:54:06I'm so happy you sewed up that way all
0:54:07right I mean how else can you say it
0:54:09yeah anyway so I'm not a tremendous
0:54:14lover of strawberries or cheesecake but
0:54:17together in this ice cream it's really
0:54:20good and refreshing cuz a lot of times
0:54:22for me the reason I don't like a really
0:54:25full hearty chocolatey rich ice cream as
0:54:29I've mentioned before is I feel like ice
0:54:32cream should be refreshing and that's
0:54:34how when I eat ice cream I feel like I
0:54:36want to be cooled off and I want to be
0:54:37refreshed and those heavy flavors just
0:54:39don't do it for me so these lighter
0:54:41flavors really make me feel refreshed
0:54:44and I'm tasting something delicious and
0:54:46light and creamy some strawberry
0:54:48cheesecake
0:54:49great job Ben Jerry my number two is
0:54:52Americone dream this is a good thing
0:54:57that we're getting a very similar list
0:54:59here yeah now you can narrow down your
0:55:00shopping list by a lot yeah I mean yeah
0:55:02marek own dream is I think I've only had
0:55:06it maybe once before if ever cuz I
0:55:08always just assumed like it'd be fine
0:55:10but I think it would be that great it's
0:55:11great like it's it's one of those things
0:55:13that it's it is as we said many we're
0:55:16talking about like it's it's simpler
0:55:17than I thought it would be and it's
0:55:19almost deceptively simple but when I
0:55:21think about like if for some reason I
0:55:23ever wanted to eat ice cream again like
0:55:25right now and feeling like I don't but
0:55:26if I everyone eating ice cream again
0:55:28that is the one I would that is really
0:55:30high in the list of what I would go to
0:55:31first which is why it's my number two
0:55:33look she makes total sense that's pretty
0:55:34great because we've never really gotten
0:55:36that one before we have it and now we
0:55:37will cool along with red velvet I think
0:55:41yeah bread cheesecake probably no we've
0:55:44gotten strawberry cheesecake we've
0:55:46forgotten the red valves right we still
0:55:47to bond with it right yeah I feel like
0:55:49we do need a bonding session but maybe
0:55:50like a week and a half from now yes not
0:55:53not today or tomorrow all right you're
0:55:56number one it's holding strong Cherry
0:55:58Garcia Froyo still love you babe you are
0:56:02my fav so yep Cherry Garcia Froyo it is
0:56:06always my go-to I let it taste summery
0:56:09to me cuz cherries come out in the
0:56:10summer it has a little bit of that light
0:56:12chocolate it doesn't have the heavy
0:56:15cream of regular ice cream it has that
0:56:18lighter Froyo flavor and I just love it
0:56:22thank you for existing you are my go-to
0:56:25you know I will always get a pint of
0:56:27this no matter what and I feel like I
0:56:29feel the way about that that you feel
0:56:31about the peanut butter ice creams which
0:56:32is I would never choose Cherry Garcia
0:56:34for myself but whenever you have it I
0:56:36will I will gladly take a few spoonfuls
0:56:38out of your out of your pint when we're
0:56:40on the couch together with our points
0:56:41when we were doing our research we were
0:56:43look we Ben Jerry's on their site has a
0:56:45list of like their top ten ice creams
0:56:47the most popular selling ones right yeah
0:56:49and they did one from like two thousand
0:56:51six miles really pleased to see that
0:56:52Cherry Garcia the regular one but
0:56:54regardless was still up there for a big
0:56:57contender in the flavors because I feel
0:56:58like a lot of times it's very easily
0:57:00overlooked but I am happy to see that a
0:57:02lot of people in wherever they you know
0:57:05do their demographic testing are it's
0:57:08still super into Cherry Garcia so it's
0:57:10around to stay and my number one is
0:57:14strawberry cheesecake
0:57:16hey very surprised but about this I mean
0:57:18and and I will mention again to red
0:57:21velvet cake and also to the cinnamon bun
0:57:23one which I thought was among the same
0:57:25quality as these it was just didn't
0:57:27quite do it for me the way the other two
0:57:29did cinnamon what was a little too spicy
0:57:30for me because sometimes I don't I don't
0:57:32really those mulling spices they're
0:57:33they're a little too harsh on the tongue
0:57:35and I enjoyed cinnamon bun as we were
0:57:38tasting it but then if I got a really
0:57:40heavy cinnamon area
0:57:42it was a little too harsh that's fair
0:57:44yeah I mean I mean and I mean I'm only
0:57:46had the two spoons of it so maybe I will
0:57:47cheat my wine later but the strawberry
0:57:49cheesecake one I I bought my first pint
0:57:52of that and I think my only point so far
0:57:53before this a few weeks ago and I'm like
0:57:56that and it was like I was kind of like
0:57:58settling for it because the flavors that
0:58:00I really wanted weren't there and we
0:58:01ended up eating so much of that right
0:58:02were the very first spoonful I had I was
0:58:05like that's interesting and then like
0:58:08that was among the other flavors that we
0:58:11had in our rotation at the time that one
0:58:13was just gone the faster it was the
0:58:15first go to pipe like it was gone
0:58:19because you have one bite and you're
0:58:21like hmm interesting
0:58:22I want more of that and then you keep
0:58:25going and you keep digging around for
0:58:27the gram swirls which I love and again
0:58:28grams pearls are a very fast path to my
0:58:31heart and hopefully not to do some
0:58:38exercise yeah but yeah grams pearls are
0:58:43great the the Cheesecake flavor in
0:58:45general is great the strawberry is done
0:58:47very nicely very subtly overall just a
0:58:49great flavor and I would not again I
0:58:52would not say it's my number one
0:58:54Barringer's flavor I've ever had but it
0:58:56is my number one that's currently in
0:58:57production I also want to say so in
0:59:00terms of Ben and Jerry's here now that
0:59:01we've ranked are all of our flavors and
0:59:03we've talked extensively about how all
0:59:05these things taste when we sit on the
0:59:07couch and we enjoy a pint of Ben and
0:59:09Jerry's ice cream or really a pint of
0:59:11any ice cream which is the quantity in
0:59:12which we purchase ice cream of any sort
0:59:15any kind of frozen dessert we usually
0:59:17purchase it in the pint variety because
0:59:19they're nice to hold and sit on the
0:59:20couch with it takes us about three tv
0:59:23washing sessions to get through a pint
0:59:25unless it's a really good flavor that it
0:59:27might be two and a half but still that's
0:59:29pretty close to three I mean come on any
0:59:31right rounding up here I mean yeah I
0:59:34think it's it well it depends on who's
0:59:36sneaking spoonful from who and who
0:59:38brings the ice cream back to the kitchen
0:59:40and sneaked spoonfuls when they're in
0:59:41the kitchen and who has the better
0:59:42flavor yeah but it takes us around three
0:59:46sittings to finish a pilot switch it
0:59:48feels pretty reasonable I don't think
0:59:50it's having about a third of a pint
0:59:53which is more than the serving size I
0:59:55think but
0:59:55by a huge difference I don't think yeah
0:59:57yeah because I know pints it seems like
0:59:59you
0:59:59you
1:00:00you'd just devour them really quickly if
1:00:02you're not careful and it has happened
1:00:04but it takes a lot of self-control to
1:00:06make that last three settings yeah but
1:00:08you know we do and I'm curious how many
1:00:10how long it takes other people to finish
1:00:12a pint like if someone is there anyone
1:00:14out there who takes like five sittings
1:00:16to finish a pint because if so that
1:00:17that's I would say enjoy an ice-cream
1:00:19enough or maybe they're enjoying it just
1:00:21right I don't know there's different
1:00:22ways to enjoy ice-cream so that's true
1:00:24yeah I just want to put that out there I
1:00:26wanted to give everyone our base mine
1:00:28consumption rate yeah cuz I feel like
1:00:30that that's appropriate we're sounding
1:00:32like we you know just pop on out to the
1:00:34markets and buy 25 pints of ice cream on
1:00:37a normal day what are we gonna do with
1:00:40all this we're gonna put some friends
1:00:42over yeah we're gonna have an ice-cream
1:00:43party we're gonna have two employees and
1:00:45I see that we don't go to an ice cream
1:00:46social
1:00:47where oh yeah of course the serve ice
1:00:49cream to everyone that's perfect yeah I
1:00:51don't want to have ice cream any time
1:00:53soon we could put it out on the curb
1:00:54with a little sinuses free oh it looks
1:01:01so gross I could take pictures of it it
1:01:03would be art too is like like it I had a
1:01:08couple of friends who worked in ice
1:01:09cream stores in high school and like
1:01:10it's the kind of thing like ice cream is
1:01:12great when you have it like once every
1:01:13so often and not all the time and you're
1:01:15not working in it ice cream in mass is
1:01:18disgusting like the amount of stuff that
1:01:20goes into it that's unhealthy first of
1:01:21all and then like you know if you're
1:01:24like in an ice-cream shop like the
1:01:25you're trashed like having all that like
1:01:27melted ice cream in there like it it's
1:01:29sticky and it smells bad and it turns
1:01:32into B's immediately if it's outside
1:01:34like you're just taking out these bags
1:01:36of sticky B's like they just smell like
1:01:38rotten milk like ice cream is best enjoy
1:01:42it's some distance like I would not
1:01:46recommend anyone else do these flavor
1:01:47tests or work in an ice cream store
1:01:49however if you're gonna go buy some ice
1:01:51cream before some occasional enjoyment
1:01:53these are the best flavors to get yep
1:01:54thanks Ben and Jerry