0:00:00I'm fired up tonight in the sense that I
0:00:03i love hate my phone and we're gonna
0:00:06have to talk about this later there are
0:00:08some parts i really really really love
0:00:10in some parts that are driving me
0:00:12freakin crazy and we should talk about
0:00:17that later that that's what the that's
0:00:19what we in the business like to call a
0:00:20teaser mmm if this stays in the show i
0:00:23guarantee someone will write in and say
0:00:24so that's actually not a teaser that's
0:00:30actually a sting preview the blast
0:00:35reference god it's a miracle that anyone
0:00:38puts any content on the internet by
0:00:39choice ever ever well if we ever want to
0:00:42get to that i do want to talk about the
0:00:45feedback to my laptop article oh I have
0:00:48feedback I would like to file actually
0:00:49unfortunately siracusa covered it pretty
0:00:51well today no I didn't talk about and I
0:00:55purposely didn't try and not to talk
0:00:57about your article we have still plenty
0:00:59of things to talk about on your article
0:01:01with you specifically alright good
0:01:03yeah and I have plenty of complaints to
0:01:05levy so I would like my chance let's
0:01:10start with some follow-up about the
0:01:11multitasking Jax gesture on the iPhone
0:01:1310 it was funny because as a podcast
0:01:17listener I have listened to every Apple
0:01:21related tech podcast that I listened to
0:01:22yet all of the feedback about the one
0:01:27true way to do the multitasking gesture
0:01:29the one true way that is flawless and
0:01:32will never ever fail it just so happens
0:01:36that there are about 75 one true waste
0:01:39multitasking gesture on the iPhone 10
0:01:42and I had thought by the time we had
0:01:44covered it
0:01:45perhaps the internet will have gotten
0:01:48this out of their system oh no my
0:01:51friends the internet is not done so one
0:01:54of you has comically put in the show
0:01:57notes and I'm guessing this is John the
0:01:59tyranny the tyranny tyranny tyranny the
0:02:02the the angst of the pause tyrany the
0:02:04digit or an e the tyranny of the pause
0:02:07tell us about this yeah this was the
0:02:11implied context of all of my calm
0:02:13the multitasking gesture last year we
0:02:16talked about how I had difficulty doing
0:02:17it from the home screen but how was as
0:02:19far as I can tell the same gesture is
0:02:20elsewhere and why I had difficulty doing
0:02:22it the home screen and at one point I
0:02:24rattled off a bunch of gestures that I
0:02:26had tried things that people had
0:02:27suggested and things that work elsewhere
0:02:29the implied but not stated part of that
0:02:33conversation was that all the things I
0:02:36was describing I was doing instead of
0:02:39the one where you you drag up and then
0:02:42pause for a little bit and then you know
0:02:44like like basically what I think of as
0:02:46the sort of standard one I think it's
0:02:48the one they demoed in the keynote where
0:02:50you know pull up from the bottom but
0:02:52don't take your finger off the screen
0:02:53and then wait a little bit and then the
0:02:55multitasking thing comes and and the
0:02:57reason that was my implied context is
0:03:00because I hate pauses I hate you know
0:03:04tap and hold I hate anything where I
0:03:05have to do something for a set amount of
0:03:07time and there's no way I can speed it
0:03:08up that's why I was interested in the
0:03:10you know j-turn 45-degree angle swipe
0:03:13all sorts of other little things
0:03:15so everybody who wrote in to tell us why
0:03:19are you doing all these strange gestures
0:03:21just pull up from the bottom and then
0:03:23wait a second and it will come up I
0:03:25definitely knew that I don't want to
0:03:27wait the second category of people are
0:03:31saying you actually don't have to wait
0:03:33if you pull up a precise amount from the
0:03:35bottom and immediately remove your
0:03:36finger from the screen it will bring up
0:03:37the multitasking gesture and I guess
0:03:41that gets rid of the weight but I find
0:03:44it more difficult to exactly get that
0:03:46distance right than I do to do one of
0:03:49the j-turn or a 45-degree angle x-ray
0:03:50over so anyway so it wasn't clear and
0:03:52you didn't know you can pull up from the
0:03:54bottom
0:03:55pause her on with your finger on the
0:03:56screen and the multitasking thing will
0:03:58come up and that is probably easier to
0:04:01pull off than any of the gestures that I
0:04:03was describing and what you don't have
0:04:04to do that but you do have to wait and I
0:04:07don't like waiting I had no idea it's
0:04:11like you grew up in the New York area we
0:04:14got a little bit of feedback about the
0:04:17refund request for Apple Care Plus I
0:04:19could have sworn I had put this in the
0:04:21show notes but I was wrong for that for
0:04:23the past episode so will be in the show
0:04:24notes for this episode and John him was
0:04:27the
0:04:27first person I saw to write in with a
0:04:29link to K base article hello Stephen
0:04:31Hackett we're in its entitled how to
0:04:34request a refund for an Apple care plan
0:04:36blah blah blah there are a few important
0:04:38things to keep in mind when you cancel
0:04:39in return now care coverage plan if your
0:04:40if you can't see your plan within 30
0:04:42days your purchase date you'll get a
0:04:43full refund minus the value of any
0:04:45service already performed if you cancel
0:04:46your Apple care plan more than 30 days
0:04:48after purchase we'll get a refund based
0:04:49on the percentage of unexpired Apple
0:04:51care coverage minus the value of any
0:04:53service already provided and so it's the
0:04:56thing which I didn't know and we even
0:04:58heard a couple people say that they told
0:05:00geniuses or perhaps on geniuses and
0:05:02perhaps it was salespeople one way or
0:05:05they're not one way or another told
0:05:07Apple retail employees that this was the
0:05:09thing and they didn't even know it was
0:05:10the thing as it turns out so yeah it's a
0:05:14thing we'll put a link in the show notes
0:05:15alright who is it that put this weird
0:05:17Kickstarter that I'd never heard about
0:05:19before in the show notes it was me it's
0:05:22always me last week about the advantages
0:05:29of face idea for touch ID especially if
0:05:31you're of things wrong with the tips of
0:05:32your fingers or they're dirty you're
0:05:34scratched up stuff like that and also if
0:05:37you're wearing gloves and I mentioned
0:05:38that they had gloves that will let you
0:05:40use your touch screen but those gloves
0:05:41don't let you activate touch ID well
0:05:43someone sent me it's linked to a
0:05:45Kickstarter for gloves that let you
0:05:48touch your screen you know with with
0:05:51gloves on like they work with a
0:05:52touchscreen but also they provide not
0:05:55your finger prints through the gloves
0:05:57like I was suggesting last show like
0:05:58there are no gloves it's magically
0:06:00surface your finger prints but instead
0:06:02give you a bunch of stickers with
0:06:04ostensibly unique fingerprints on every
0:06:07single sticker they work with touch ID
0:06:09so what you do is you'd put on these
0:06:10gloves or put on these little stickers
0:06:12on your gloves right and each one is
0:06:14unique like every single person who gets
0:06:15one I guess yeah unique fingerprint
0:06:17thing train it on your gloved
0:06:20fingerprint thingy and then you can
0:06:22unlock your phone and use it with that
0:06:25glove of course what that means is that
0:06:26if someone's unlock your phone they just
0:06:27need to steer your glove instead of
0:06:28cutting off your finger
0:06:29lifting your prints off a glass of water
0:06:31or whatever mission impossible type
0:06:33thing they're gonna do but anyway it's a
0:06:35Kickstarter all the normal caveat set by
0:06:36Kickstarter but
0:06:38you know this someone's always got an
0:06:41interesting idea and here's another one
0:06:43unique fingerprint stickers I had no
0:06:46idea this was the thing well it's a
0:06:48Kickstarter so is it a thing a few
0:06:52shades there well played uh yeah yeah
0:06:54alright so apparently we have some
0:06:57things to talk about with regard to
0:06:58iCloud restores during iPhone 10 setup I
0:07:01spoke too soon last week we all spoke
0:07:03well maybe you didn't but I did about
0:07:05like oh I cloud restored during setup
0:07:07it's much faster now everything works
0:07:09great that was all true up until the
0:07:11point where my wife's phone wanted to
0:07:15update to whatever I think it's like the
0:07:16the iOS update that gets rid of the
0:07:18weird funny character thing you tried to
0:07:20have capital I whatever whatever update
0:07:22that was and she normally updates her
0:07:25phone and eventually tried to do the
0:07:27update and it said something to the
0:07:30effect of oh yeah no this this OS update
0:07:33will run as soon as your iCloud restore
0:07:34finishes and it said that for about two
0:07:37weeks now and that's bad Oh lovely and
0:07:40whatever questions to me it was like can
0:07:43I just cancel this iCloud restore and
0:07:46it's like oh no like it's another one of
0:07:49those iCloud things where reboot your
0:07:52phone as far as I'm aware the iCloud
0:07:55restore finished the day we set up your
0:07:59phone like all the apps are there what
0:08:01what remains to be done I don't know
0:08:04it's not like I have some view into the
0:08:06system that tells me what the iCloud
0:08:08restore process is doing so I find this
0:08:10mildly upsetting and I don't as yet have
0:08:12a solution I assume what I'm just gonna
0:08:14do is Google the error message because
0:08:15that's the level of debugging we're at
0:08:17in the iOS world these days especially
0:08:18as it relates to iCloud things so you
0:08:20can find how many other people have this
0:08:22problem but in the end yeah it's like
0:08:24reboot the phone step zero and see if
0:08:26that magically changes something we got
0:08:30some bad news from Apple and I'm quoting
0:08:33now we can't wait for people to
0:08:36experience home pod apples break through
0:08:38wireless speaker for the home but we
0:08:39need a little more time before it's
0:08:41ready for our customers we'll start
0:08:42shipping in the US UK and Australia in
0:08:45early 2018 this was not given directly
0:08:47to ATP but it was given to a couple of
0:08:49news sites or bloggers or what-have-you
0:08:52the home pot is indeed delayed so I
0:08:53guess next week or perhaps later this
0:08:56week we'll hear the same for the iMac
0:08:59Pro because what we're both promised
0:09:01this year is that right yeah but my pro
0:09:03is gonna make it is it because like five
0:09:07people will buy them and it doesn't
0:09:08really matter and it will probably make
0:09:09it I mean technically the 2013 Mac Pro
0:09:12was available in December 2013 but if
0:09:16you actually wanted to try to order one
0:09:17you weren't gonna get until February
0:09:20so the iMac Pro might follow a similar
0:09:22path I I don't really know if anything
0:09:26in particular is holding up yeah my pro
0:09:28they have their reasons but I'm sure
0:09:30they have nothing to do with whatever's
0:09:31holding back the home pod the home pod
0:09:33seems like it's just very like it seemed
0:09:37like it was in such an early state when
0:09:39they announced it last June that it's
0:09:42slipping a few months now is not that
0:09:45big of a surprise and it's all new you
0:09:48know all new hardware more importantly
0:09:50probably all new software relying on
0:09:52they're fairly shaky service back-end
0:09:56for Siri so lots of possible things
0:10:00could have gone wrong here or could have
0:10:02missed deadlines here to make that get
0:10:05delayed by a few months so this is not
0:10:07at all a surprise and and I hope you
0:10:11know from what we've seen from the home
0:10:12pod so far which is admittedly very very
0:10:14little it sure doesn't seem like it's
0:10:17that competitive with the other products
0:10:19in that market so maybe they're making a
0:10:22little bit better that that's kind of my
0:10:23hope here is like maybe this will be a
0:10:25little bit more competitive against the
0:10:27echo line of products especially and
0:10:29then also against things like Sonos and
0:10:30Google whatever yeah maybe it will be
0:10:34done is more like what I think this is
0:10:35getting they showed the hardware but
0:10:38they had so little of the software done
0:10:40that all they would let people do with
0:10:41it is play music but this is ostensibly
0:10:44something you can talk to and they were
0:10:46demonstrating none of that which makes
0:10:48me think that the hardware is was at
0:10:50that time much farther along than the
0:10:52software and software is much harder to
0:10:55predict when it will be done and I feel
0:10:56like it's not done and that's why it's
0:10:58delayed and as I said on upgrade today
0:11:02with Jason when they announced that the
0:11:04home pod would be yeah
0:11:06really send me I'm a crow for that
0:11:07matter in December it like they announce
0:11:09that it's so in September when they had
0:11:11the iPhone offenders that was it in June
0:11:14I heard June when everyone's went anyway
0:11:15when they announced the announced
0:11:16December then right yeah in June during
0:11:19the WC keynote is the only time you've
0:11:21ever heard about the home pod and then
0:11:22they said December yes oh wow
0:11:27anyway right soon as soon as they
0:11:29announce December they pre announced
0:11:32that they would not make the holiday
0:11:33season right so now when they're
0:11:36delaying it until you know early 2018 is
0:11:39not as if suddenly they're missing the
0:11:40holiday season they already pre
0:11:42announced they were missing the holiday
0:11:43season this is not a new change all they
0:11:45have done is crusted over the year
0:11:47boundary and it's probably because you
0:11:51know I think we can make it by the end
0:11:53of year that's our stretch goal team and
0:11:54they didn't make it so it gets pushed
0:11:56out right but but the nice PR side
0:11:58effect is if they had announced home pod
0:12:01and said this isn't coming till 2018
0:12:02there would be all these groans because
0:12:04you cross the year boundary but if you
0:12:05say December 31st like oh but you know
0:12:07it'll be here in 2017 and that's a
0:12:09better PR story and then as December
0:12:11approaches and it becomes clear that
0:12:13you're not gonna do that and people just
0:12:14want to go home and get their vacations
0:12:15then they can ounce that had too late so
0:12:17I think they were shooting for the end
0:12:20of the year and they just didn't make it
0:12:22and that's fine don't release a product
0:12:24that's not done at no point was this
0:12:25going to be a holiday purchase and it's
0:12:27still not a holiday purchase so it'll be
0:12:29fine so one possibly worrying thing
0:12:32about this is that nobody seems that sad
0:12:35about this is that a concern well what
0:12:39are you gonna be sad about I want that
0:12:40amazing demo that they show they didn't
0:12:42show demo they showed of playing music
0:12:43and it sounded good
0:12:44like they we don't even know what to
0:12:45expect other than it will play your
0:12:47music and some people said it plays
0:12:49music nicely and sounds good right there
0:12:52is no wow factor to this especially with
0:12:55the Sonos announcements right if you
0:12:58want a speaker that sounds good that you
0:12:59can talk to Sonos tells you that and
0:13:02this is just like oh it sounds good and
0:13:04you could talk to it and you can talk to
0:13:06it and make a play it make it play Apple
0:13:07music whereas on this will play Apple
0:13:09music but not when you talk to it right
0:13:10now like yeah this this is Apple trying
0:13:14to enter a market that it's currently
0:13:16not in but if they have something
0:13:19special
0:13:20to to show this market here's Apple's
0:13:22entry and this is the special Apple
0:13:24magic they haven't shown that yet so
0:13:26what is there to really get excited
0:13:28about I don't know all I know is I feel
0:13:32less and less confident in Siri as time
0:13:35goes on and there was actually a really
0:13:37really tremendous crossover between
0:13:38welcome to Macintosh and 20,000 Hertz
0:13:41both of which are phenomenal podcasts
0:13:43that you should be listening to and I
0:13:46think it was Mark Graham Hill of welcome
0:13:47to McIntosh had said he was of the
0:13:51opinion that as Siri sounds more in more
0:13:56in more lifelike and less robotic we as
0:14:00human beings and I think I certainly
0:14:02fall into this are less and less and
0:14:05less tolerant of it being anything but
0:14:08perfect because the voice is getting
0:14:10eerily close to to maybe not perfect but
0:14:14really good and so you expect the best
0:14:17out of this and man III don't know if
0:14:20it's me or what I just feel like serious
0:14:23been garbage the last few months but you
0:14:26know what isn't frustrating kids me
0:14:27being vindicated in a boy am i
0:14:31vindicated we have some follow-up about
0:14:33the great dust-up of November 2017 the
0:14:37chili cook-off the chili cook-off if you
0:14:40recall I had put an ask ATP question
0:14:45into the show notes that John had tried
0:14:47to move out of the episode and then
0:14:50obnoxiously I'd pretty much forced all
0:14:52of us to drag it back in and we quickly
0:14:55discovered that John had built himself a
0:14:57beautiful mind style conspiracy theory
0:15:00as to what the actual intention of this
0:15:03questions author was during the
0:15:05recording of that episode I tweeted at
0:15:07the author whose name is Jonathan
0:15:09bowling I said to him was this an honest
0:15:12question or were you making an in-joke
0:15:13about Jon Merlyn etc to which he replied
0:15:15at the time on his question but I was
0:15:17betting something pretty funny might
0:15:18happen in the answers and I believe we
0:15:20brought all this up during the show and
0:15:21John said see it's he's thought
0:15:24something funny would happen he's
0:15:25setting his heart go cut that part out
0:15:26of the episode did he fly yes wait did I
0:15:29yeah that's why I put it back in this
0:15:30one because it was like in the after
0:15:32half
0:15:32after after show this response did come
0:15:36in and so it's honest question but I was
0:15:37betting something pretty funny might
0:15:39happen and my reading of that question
0:15:40was but I was betting something pretty
0:15:41funny might happen and Casey's reading
0:15:44is there but anyway go ahead so we got
0:15:46an email from Jonathan I will not read
0:15:48all of it but I will read some of it
0:15:50episode 248 chili cook-off turned out to
0:15:52be more fun than I could have imagined
0:15:54I was just hoping that you would include
0:15:56my question so I had no idea that it
0:15:58would cause him any siracusa rant TM
0:15:59that would backfire and make the
0:16:01question stay in the show Thank You
0:16:03Casey for defending my good intentions
0:16:05I've been a big fan of hypercritical
0:16:06build and analyze in a teepee longtime
0:16:08listener first-time quote close to the
0:16:09medal or quote John suspicions were
0:16:11unfounded
0:16:12I do enjoy reconcilable differences
0:16:14which by the way is a tremendous program
0:16:15which he should listen to but I didn't
0:16:17have anything from reqtest in mind when
0:16:19I asked the question I'd be curious to
0:16:21know which episode or episodes he
0:16:22thought I was referencing Casey I look
0:16:24forward to hearing you point out to John
0:16:25that he was wrong in the next episodes
0:16:27follow-up copy right John Syracuse of
0:16:292011 I should note that's in the email I
0:16:31also look forward to his continued good
0:16:33humoured suspicions with a winking emoji
0:16:35John would you like to try to defend
0:16:38yourself at this time well there's not
0:16:41really much to defend here because well
0:16:44first of all I would say that my hope
0:16:46after last week's episode was that you -
0:16:49based on the feedback from everyone else
0:16:51would come to a better understanding
0:16:54what my objection was because if you
0:16:57recall I'm more confused than ever maybe
0:17:01I can help you I'm saying what my hope
0:17:04was if you recall the idea was there was
0:17:07this question in there I moved it down I
0:17:09said I don't like this question in case
0:17:10he asked me and then he asked me on the
0:17:12show why don't you like this question
0:17:14and I explained why I don't like this
0:17:16question and Casey said that my reasons
0:17:19were dumb please tell me why don't you
0:17:26like this question I feel like I tried
0:17:28my best to explain why I don't like the
0:17:30question there's no being right or wrong
0:17:32about why I don't like the question but
0:17:34obviously you two have not come to a
0:17:36deeper understanding why I didn't like
0:17:39the question and I don't know why this
0:17:40example didn't occur to me but I think I
0:17:42have a better example to hopefully bring
0:17:44you to that understanding
0:17:46if someone had written into the show ask
0:17:48ATP say should I buy a white car
0:17:51if Casey said I don't like that question
0:17:54I would understand why he doesn't like
0:17:57that question that's it okay right I
0:18:01wouldn't understand now imagine that
0:18:03person had never heard the show before
0:18:05except like friends said that we talked
0:18:07about car sometime and was legitimately
0:18:09thinking about buying a white car and
0:18:10you know they talk about cars all the
0:18:12time and maybe in the F she'll talk
0:18:14about white cars maybe I'll just ask
0:18:15them should I buy my car because you
0:18:16know they're hard to keep clean and so
0:18:17on and so forth right still still if you
0:18:20said that like that question I would say
0:18:22I understand well you don't like that
0:18:24question right and if that person wrote
0:18:26and said I don't know what this thing
0:18:27you're talking about the white cars they
0:18:28just for you I heard you guys talk about
0:18:29cars sometimes something gonna get in
0:18:31one and white is hard to clean the stuff
0:18:32set for you you have an opinion even if
0:18:34there were 100 percent honest I would
0:18:36still understand why you don't like that
0:18:37question and it wouldn't say it was
0:18:38Syria now imagine further still that
0:18:41Marco and I said Casey I don't know what
0:18:43you're talking about this person is just
0:18:44asking about white cars I have no idea
0:18:49because this was like seven years in the
0:18:52future and we didn't remember this white
0:18:53car gag oh I assure you I will never be
0:18:57allowed to forget the white car gag but
0:18:59I'm with you to principle I'm with you
0:19:01this is the situation I find myself in
0:19:02because believe me
0:19:04the closer the metal thing was as real
0:19:05as the white car as evidenced by all the
0:19:07people who wrote in to say that person
0:19:09is 100% trolling and John is right I
0:19:11mean they don't know what's in this
0:19:12person's heart any more than I do right
0:19:13but that it is legitimately a thing as
0:19:16much a thing as white cars bar and you
0:19:18two have no recollection of it and this
0:19:21person claims to have no recollection I
0:19:22would despite listening all the way back
0:19:24to hypercritical which is where this is
0:19:25from not reconcilable differences anyway
0:19:27all this is to say I hope you now
0:19:30understand where I was coming from and I
0:19:32hope you can use the white car example
0:19:34as instructive to say maybe you wouldn't
0:19:39mind that question maybe you a bomb
0:19:40saying as if you said you didn't like it
0:19:42I would understand why and I think Marco
0:19:44would too because we both have the
0:19:46shared context without the shared
0:19:47context would you seem like a conspiracy
0:19:50theory person what is this about white
0:19:51cars what are you even talking about
0:19:53imagine how frustrating it would be for
0:19:54you to explain to me and Marco what the
0:19:57deal with the white car thing
0:20:00I do think okay I am laughing but I do
0:20:02think I understand your point better
0:20:04I think the difference for me and we can
0:20:07move on but the difference for me is
0:20:09that I it the white car thing is is for
0:20:11better or worse like the defining gag
0:20:14about me it's it's that and who the
0:20:16hell's your suppose you'd only have one
0:20:18Casey well - but I'm with ya again I'm
0:20:22with you what's the second one water on
0:20:23the computer no well okay three I said
0:20:25who the hell is Casey in the computer
0:20:27yeah in the computer if I say I'd
0:20:29forgotten about that one you've got to
0:20:30explain that context and I would say
0:20:31you're crazy everyone knows who you are
0:20:33fine
0:20:38[Music]
0:20:46who the hell is Casey but my point is
0:20:54just that there there are a handful of
0:20:56things that I feel like all of us upon
0:21:01hearing them would say yes of course
0:21:03who the hell is Casey I remember and
0:21:05this one to my eyes anyway was way more
0:21:08esoteric in in Wayne it's an older I
0:21:11mean it's older like it was we traced it
0:21:13back it was like episode 50 of
0:21:15hypercritical that's like six years ago
0:21:17so you know me I guess you can forgive
0:21:19infer Cleaver getting about it I was
0:21:20just very surprised that neither one of
0:21:22you could even vaguely remember that it
0:21:23was a thing and we're just starting from
0:21:24whole cloth as if I was just making this
0:21:26up I assure you I am NOT no I never
0:21:29really thought you were making it up it
0:21:30just seemed it seemed kind of bananas to
0:21:32me that you were so unequivocally
0:21:34convinced that this was that this was
0:21:36trolling I thought you would remember I
0:21:37thought I mean obviously it's not as
0:21:39recent as a white car but I thought one
0:21:41or both of you would certainly remember
0:21:43it and either way by the way I will
0:21:44point out like at the end of this thing
0:21:46I also look forward to John's you know
0:21:47continued good-humoured suspicions I
0:21:49mean obviously if someone was trolling
0:21:50the trolley thing to do is not to tell
0:21:53you they're trolling people on the
0:21:57internet like it's it's really easy to
0:21:59type words into a text box but I'm I'm
0:22:00sure this person is being honest and
0:22:02like you too has just completely
0:22:03forgotten about this from labor critical
0:22:05days cuz that was a long time ago
0:22:06although to be honest so when did we
0:22:08record neutral that would that started
0:22:10in January of 13 is that right I think
0:22:12that's right yeah that's better so that
0:22:13was almost five years ago in
0:22:17hypercritical was six or seven years ago
0:22:19so I mean the white car thing is far
0:22:22closer to hypercritical than it is to us
0:22:23today you know what I mean like that's
0:22:25which is weird right because I feel like
0:22:26that was yesterday in so many ways but
0:22:29anyway it was I was I was very punchy
0:22:32when we recorded but I was never like
0:22:34genuinely upsetting you I just thought
0:22:35you were being utterly preposterous I
0:22:38wasn't that's what I'm getting at but
0:22:39just because you don't have the context
0:22:41doesn't mean there isn't a context and
0:22:42it's and it's completely irrelevant
0:22:44whether he was being honest or not
0:22:45that's why I was trying to get with the
0:22:46white car think is legit someone could
0:22:48listen to the show that's a that's a
0:22:49real question the people asked should I
0:22:50get a white car I've had that question
0:22:52asked to me before I even came in the
0:22:53show but it would be a hell of a
0:22:54coincidence if they asked that on s KDP
0:22:56wouldn't it why would any
0:22:58you ask if they want to get a white card
0:23:00on yeah exactly why would that matter
0:23:02but why would they ask at ATP maybe this
0:23:04just of legitimist quite honest question
0:23:06but I would understand if Casey if Casey
0:23:08gave it a little bit of side-eye and
0:23:10maybe said maybe I'm not I mean it seems
0:23:14to me that white car has just happened
0:23:15to Casey he never has to actually have
0:23:18you exactly you've owned like 17 white
0:23:20cars have you ever had to ask anybody if
0:23:22you should get a white car or not no
0:23:24I've never asked anyone if I should it
0:23:28doesn't seem like he had a choice right
0:23:29yeah one of them one of them was a
0:23:31choice I guess fall from from this guy
0:23:33into your driveway and then their
0:23:34engines break
0:23:35can you just dubbing like the first 15
0:23:37minutes of the first neutral where we
0:23:38discussed this one of them was
0:23:40absolutely unequivocally my choice I
0:23:42specifically requested white for one
0:23:45every other one happened to me I'm
0:23:46sticking with and for the record I'm
0:23:48pretty sure Marcos are the only one he
0:23:51obviously originated the white car thing
0:23:53and I think he's the only one who really
0:23:54cares my first car was a white car too
0:23:56and I think all I said under trouble is
0:23:57that if you have a really nicely shaped
0:23:59car then you can get it in a white but
0:24:00in your car isn't ugly don't get in a
0:24:02white because it highlights how badly
0:24:03shaped it is but beyond that I have no
0:24:05objections to white cars we are
0:24:08sponsored this week by simple contacts a
0:24:10convenient way to renew your contact
0:24:12lens prescription and reorder your
0:24:13contacts from anywhere in minutes go to
0:24:16simple contacts comm slash ATP to learn
0:24:19more and enter code ATP at checkout for
0:24:21$30 off your lenses so here's how simple
0:24:24contacts works you take a five-minute
0:24:26vision test from your phone or computer
0:24:27it's carefully reviewed by a licensed
0:24:29doctor you receive a new prescription
0:24:31and then you order your brand of lenses
0:24:33they have all the brains you're familiar
0:24:34with at great prices making Vision Care
0:24:37simple accessible and affordable to
0:24:39everyone with simple contacts you never
0:24:41have to leave your home to get your
0:24:43prescription renewed or to order more
0:24:44contact it's that simple
0:24:46you don't have to wait around in doctors
0:24:47offices and waiting rooms and everything
0:24:48else and it's fast the vision test is
0:24:51self-guided and it takes less than five
0:24:53minutes this is way faster than making
0:24:55an appointment somewhere it uses your
0:24:56camera and microphone to capture the
0:24:58same information as an office visit
0:24:59would and then a licensed
0:25:01ophthalmologist reviews every exam
0:25:03carefully to make sure your eyes look
0:25:05healthy and that your vision hasn't
0:25:07changed from your prior prescription
0:25:08although this is not a replacement for
0:25:10your periodic full health I exam
0:25:12simple contact offers all the brands of
0:25:14lenses you're familiar with including
0:25:15options for astigmatism multifocal
0:25:17lenses colored lenses and more the exam
0:25:20is only twenty dollars this is much
0:25:22cheaper than a typical I otter
0:25:23appointment and standard shipping is
0:25:25free and the contacts are priced very
0:25:27competitively and if your insurance is
0:25:29an HSA expiring dollars can be used by
0:25:32the end of the year so check out simple
0:25:34contacts today to renew your
0:25:35prescription and reorder your contact
0:25:37lenses in minutes from anywhere go to
0:25:39simple contacts comm slash ATP and inter
0:25:42code ATP at checkout to get $30 off your
0:25:45lenses that simple contacts comm / ATP
0:25:48code ATP for $30 off thank you so much
0:25:51simple contact for sponsoring our show
0:25:54[Music]
0:25:56speaking of ask ATP let's just mosey
0:25:58right on in Shane booze lo writes do you
0:26:02think using chi chargers everywhere and
0:26:05topping off the iPhones batteries all
0:26:08the time will impact battery health I
0:26:10have no idea but I've had the same
0:26:12question so I think this is probably
0:26:16similar to lots of different like
0:26:19battery health questions and theories
0:26:21and best practices that we've heard over
0:26:24the years with computers there is
0:26:26probably some truth to the fact that
0:26:28charging lithium batteries all the time
0:26:30you know does actually shorten their
0:26:32lifespan if they're if they're not kept
0:26:33within their ideal long-term charging
0:26:36health range which is usually not fully
0:26:38charged usually it's closer to like
0:26:40middle of the battery charge like if you
0:26:43want it looking better to last as long
0:26:44as possible keep the source level
0:26:46somewhere near the middle or something
0:26:47some kind of range near the middle and
0:26:49that tends to keep them lasting longer
0:26:51the reason I added this and what I
0:26:53thought was kind of worth talking about
0:26:54is like I feel like with with your phone
0:26:56that you're using every day that you are
0:26:58charging every night then you are using
0:27:00it throughout the day you know you're
0:27:02putting like a good part of a full cycle
0:27:05on the battery every day sometimes more
0:27:07if you use it heavily I feel like your
0:27:10battery is not going to be very useful
0:27:12for more than about two years maybe
0:27:16three years if you if you're more gentle
0:27:18on it but like no matter what you do
0:27:20this is really hard on a battery to be
0:27:23used to be basically cycled a full side
0:27:26meaning like you know full charge to
0:27:27nearly empty to have to be going through
0:27:29flows like almost every day you're gonna
0:27:32wear out that battery pretty much no
0:27:33matter what you do and so the
0:27:35alternative which is you know topping it
0:27:37off on these little charges all over
0:27:39your house and car and workplace all the
0:27:40time I don't think that's that much
0:27:43worse you know it might actually be
0:27:44better even like what's worse for a
0:27:47lithium-ion battery
0:27:47keeping it at a full charge for a day or
0:27:49going through a full cycle I don't know
0:27:51but it's probably not gonna be that
0:27:54different either way you're using it
0:27:56heavily you know like if you have a
0:27:57laptop and you use it on battery for its
0:28:00full range every day that's going to do
0:28:03the same thing at the laptop if you keep
0:28:05it plugged in all the time that's gonna
0:28:06be better for it but you know again like
0:28:08maybe not that much better because of
0:28:10the full charge being bad thing so I
0:28:13think the answer here is keeping them
0:28:16uncharged all the time will probably
0:28:17impact battery health but the
0:28:20alternative would probably impact it
0:28:21more and in the grand scheme of things
0:28:24your phone battery no matter what you do
0:28:26is gonna be is gonna have a not that
0:28:28useful amount of charge after two or
0:28:30three years no matter what you do there
0:28:32are other factors here as well that make
0:28:34it I don't know what the answer is just
0:28:36muddies the water even more of whether
0:28:38this is better worse or the same but to
0:28:41start like I bet people are not going to
0:28:43buy such a tremendous number of t
0:28:45chargers that they are now charging
0:28:47their phone appreciably more than they
0:28:50used to if only because T chargers
0:28:51charge your phone so much more slowly
0:28:53and one of the things that shortens
0:28:54battery life is really fast charging so
0:28:56if you have a big iPad charger the at
0:28:58your desk that you plug your thing into
0:28:59to get as much juice as possible when
0:29:01you're at your desk versus putting in on
0:29:03a Qi charger the charger is much more
0:29:04slowly the slower one is going to be
0:29:06kinder on your battery and if you but it
0:29:09won't charge as much obviously in the
0:29:10same amount of time but if you have a
0:29:11bunch of key charges around in the house
0:29:12what you're instead doing instead of
0:29:14charging very quickly in one location
0:29:16you're charging more slowly in multiple
0:29:17locations which again I think is better
0:29:19for the battery so there's you know
0:29:21you'd really need to come up with an
0:29:23exact regime of where you're going to be
0:29:25and what you're going to charge to
0:29:27compare exactly this pattern of use to
0:29:30exactly this pattern of use but in
0:29:32general I would say don't worry about
0:29:34this don't don't worry about the battery
0:29:36life being affected because there are
0:29:37just so many variables and
0:29:39depending on how they're each weighted
0:29:41in this giant equation you could get
0:29:42better worse of the same battery life
0:29:44but like Marco said either way if you
0:29:47chart if you use your phone the same
0:29:49amount every day that's in the end
0:29:51you're using your phone that amount it's
0:29:53got two or three years of that many
0:29:55cycles even if you don't psyche although
0:29:57by two or three years or just that much
0:29:58putting energy into the battery and
0:30:00taking energy out even if you could
0:30:01always do it in the fat part of the
0:30:02curve where it's all good
0:30:03your battery's gonna be a lot worse than
0:30:06it was when you bought it and you're
0:30:07probably gonna want a new phone and
0:30:08that's just the way things are indeed
0:30:11all right JT you would like to know what
0:30:14are your thoughts and feelings on Apple
0:30:15TV remote redesigned for air power into
0:30:17fix other issues you know a lot of
0:30:20people have been writing in about what
0:30:21about this for air power our air power
0:30:23what about that for air power I don't
0:30:26get it like I think I said this last
0:30:28episode but I will be very surprised if
0:30:31anything else gets air power support
0:30:33except maybe the pencil anytime soon I
0:30:36don't think this is going to be like the
0:30:37catch-all you know cover your all of
0:30:40your desks and all of your you know uh
0:30:42kitchen counters and air power sort of
0:30:44thing I think this is only going to be
0:30:46for iOS devices and you know the air
0:30:49pods and and and I guess watch OS is
0:30:52strictly speaking different OS but you
0:30:53know what I mean like I don't think it's
0:30:54gonna be keyboard and mouse and Apple TV
0:30:57remote in any of those send MacBook in
0:31:00MacBook yeah exactly and especially like
0:31:02the Apple TV remote I've charged that
0:31:05thing probably four times or feels like
0:31:07I've charged it four times in the year
0:31:09I've had it I mean that may not be
0:31:11accurate but it just at my point is just
0:31:12it almost never needs a charge same with
0:31:15my keyboards and my mice mouse's nieces
0:31:18they almost never need a charge so what
0:31:22are you really solving if it's at worst
0:31:25a you know momentary inconvenience if
0:31:28you know once a quarter or something
0:31:30like that but I don't know what do you
0:31:31think Marco I pretty much the same I
0:31:33mean I I have not you know we use our
0:31:35Apple TV almost every day at least we
0:31:37did before he got stuck in stardew
0:31:39valley and yeah I think I've charged it
0:31:42yeah maybe maybe three times you know
0:31:45it's it's not a high drain device so the
0:31:48need to make charging especially
0:31:49convenient is is not that high
0:31:52also that tends to be a different place
0:31:55in your house or your office or you
0:31:57might have when your office and you tend
0:31:59not to travel with it so like if if the
0:32:01benefit of an air power mat is like the
0:32:03thing that you stick on your nightstand
0:32:04table that you put all your stuff on at
0:32:05night well you're probably not going to
0:32:08have your Apple TV remote you know in
0:32:09your in your bedroom if you if your
0:32:10Apple TV is not there
0:32:12similarly you know if the appeal of this
0:32:14thing ends up being those really
0:32:15convenient while traveling you're
0:32:16probably not going to travel with your
0:32:17Apple TV remote either and if you do you
0:32:19probably won't need to charge it on the
0:32:21trip so you know it's it's a nice theory
0:32:24but I don't think it matters that much
0:32:27the Apple TV remote has so many other
0:32:29problems that they refuse to address so
0:32:32if they aren't even gonna bother making
0:32:33it usable while it's charged I don't
0:32:36think they're gonna care that much that
0:32:37it's slightly inconvenient to charge it
0:32:40when you do it you know every six months
0:32:42I frequently forget that the Apple TV
0:32:45remote has a battery and it's not like
0:32:49there's a battery door and it like I'm
0:32:51not sure if I have ever charged my
0:32:54applet I think I replaced my Apple TV
0:32:56before I charge the battery on it it
0:32:58lasts or I don't use as much as mark
0:33:00obviously it lasts a really really long
0:33:02time although I have a too quick Apple
0:33:04TV remote stories the last time I lost
0:33:07it I'm always losing the Apple TV remote
0:33:09because it's skinny and it goes down
0:33:10couch cushions stuff like that you know
0:33:13my kids use it and so it's not like who
0:33:15knows but like they carry it into the
0:33:16kitchen they you know they it's in the
0:33:18bathroom who knows where they're taking
0:33:20this road it's just everywhere right and
0:33:21there's no as far as I'm aware please
0:33:23tell me if I'm wrong there's no like
0:33:24fine your remote function where you can
0:33:25make it make a beeping sound I would
0:33:26love that that they that hence the
0:33:29feature they should add but anyway I
0:33:30lost my remote and I thought like this
0:33:34is it I've well and truly lost it I know
0:33:36I was thinking like boy I'm glad they
0:33:37reduced the price to $60 down from 80
0:33:39because I'm gonna have to buy another
0:33:40remote and even though you got the
0:33:43remote on your iOS device where you can
0:33:44use that instead of the thing as far as
0:33:46I'm aware you can't can you wake your
0:33:48thing from sleep with that I don't know
0:33:50and I didn't try it but I was like well
0:33:52I'd like do I think I can't use my Apple
0:33:54TV until I get a replacing remote
0:33:55because I don't think you can wake the
0:33:57little black cube from sleep without the
0:34:01real remote yeah you can if you gotta
0:34:03airplay to it I believe it'll wake
0:34:05itself up
0:34:05yeah that's good yeah I was thinking
0:34:08like I would guess the RemoteApp would
0:34:09let you do it but I can't I haven't
0:34:10tried it so I don't know one way or the
0:34:11other but I can tell you I'll L airplay
0:34:14to it from time to time and that will
0:34:15wake it up right anyway
0:34:17I was halfway through that thought when
0:34:18I looked up at my little black thing and
0:34:20the little white light was on so like
0:34:23you know I don't have to wake it up it's
0:34:25already awake and I'm like but how can
0:34:27it already be awake I've been looking
0:34:28for this road for 15 minutes and I know
0:34:30it goes to sleep like no one has been in
0:34:31his room for a while and based on that
0:34:34information I realized I must be sitting
0:34:36on the remote somehow and that's what's
0:34:40waking up and sure enough I took yet
0:34:42another run at the couch cushions and
0:34:44the little things that are between them
0:34:45it's like a sleeper sofa or whatever and
0:34:47eventually I found the remote somewhere
0:34:49underneath my butt where I was squishing
0:34:51it and turning it on the second story is
0:34:52about someone had realized there was a
0:34:55bunch of iTunes purchases going through
0:34:56where they'd purchased like every
0:34:57episode of Seinfeld and a bunch of TV
0:34:59series
0:34:59I'm a or you know it was like a husband
0:35:02and wife and they were asking each other
0:35:03did you buy these did you buy these
0:35:04things turns out it was the cat the cat
0:35:06would lay on top of the remote and buy
0:35:08things for them on the turned off
0:35:10television through their Apple TV remote
0:35:11so I don't know if that makes us a
0:35:14better motor a good remote it's bad
0:35:15because it's lost easily it's probably
0:35:19bad because the cat can buy things but
0:35:21maybe not like cats are very devious all
0:35:27right
0:35:27and Kent eken Gore writes how can a
0:35:31polemic ated things with software like
0:35:34face detection and they are yet still
0:35:37get so many simple things consistently
0:35:38wrong like 1 plus 1 or 1 plus 2 plus 3
0:35:41on the iowa's calculator and UI bugs
0:35:43related to device orientation such as
0:35:46the attached we'll put a link in the
0:35:47show notes and it's a picture of what
0:35:50appears to be the phone or iPad I think
0:35:54phone in portrait mode yet
0:35:57the volume indicator is shown in
0:35:59landscape whoops with regard to rotation
0:36:04I can say that rotations are pain in the
0:36:07bud yeah yep any eye any iOS developer
0:36:10will tell you that so that I give them a
0:36:12buy on although it does seem that there
0:36:13are a lot more rotation bugs in iOS 11
0:36:16than there were before there's a lot
0:36:19more
0:36:19everything bugs every weapon in a while
0:36:22but yeah you're right I don't have a
0:36:26good answer for this I I guess in to
0:36:29some degree it's easy to get amazed by
0:36:31the new and shiny and and it's hard to
0:36:35it's hard to build software reliably and
0:36:38predictably that's why you know agile
0:36:42software development became a thing was
0:36:44it was an attempt to be better about
0:36:47building up be better about predicting
0:36:49when software would be complete right
0:36:51and in the whole shtick of it was that
0:36:53you wanted to be able to predict future
0:36:56the future based on your performance in
0:36:58the past rather than oh well I should be
0:37:00able to get that done in two weeks you
0:37:02can look at your past history and say no
0:37:04actually that'll take you a month and a
0:37:05half and you know it all of the stuff
0:37:09around enterprise level software
0:37:11development which I know Marco doesn't
0:37:14understand but John and I all it's hard
0:37:17it's hard work it's hard to figure out
0:37:20the balance between how much you know
0:37:22how many unit tests you should write in
0:37:23how many shouldn't and what your
0:37:24continuous integration story is like all
0:37:26of the stuff is hard and it's not to
0:37:29most people it's not very sexy and so
0:37:31what is sexy face detection what is sexy
0:37:34augmented reality what's not sexy
0:37:36Jenkins oh it's it's understandable if
0:37:40not necessarily excusable that this
0:37:42would be the case but I don't know John
0:37:43as my fellow boring old man when it
0:37:46comes to writing software how do you how
0:37:47do you describe this I'm not sure you
0:37:51need to bring software methodologies and
0:37:53software in general entry even if they
0:37:54weren't talking about software even if
0:37:56this was talking about like you notice
0:37:57that dudes car analogies that's the
0:38:00other thing we go to like how can they
0:38:01get this amazing you know engine new
0:38:04engine technology working but their
0:38:07climate controls suck and it's you know
0:38:11it's just human nature and priorities
0:38:14and with anything were you especially in
0:38:16a business like Apple's where you're
0:38:18it's not that it's a hit driven business
0:38:20but that you you're only as good as your
0:38:22last success things like the calculator
0:38:26the iOS calculator bug where like some
0:38:28animations in the calculator caused it
0:38:30to be less responsive right
0:38:32how many people are scrutinizing how
0:38:35good the calculator is from release to
0:38:36release it's not a head lighting feature
0:38:38there are not a lot of resources put
0:38:40towards the calculator when it was first
0:38:41made there was probably more than there
0:38:43are now
0:38:44but there is an inclination in companies
0:38:46that have to make money to say we'll put
0:38:49time and resources and people into this
0:38:51thing because it's the thing that we
0:38:53need and then when we're done with it
0:38:55we'll be like great we did that what's
0:38:56the next thing move on to the next thing
0:38:58right and take people off of that and
0:39:00say those people are working and you
0:39:01have to leave somebody there but this
0:39:02some poor maintenance engineer is
0:39:04responsible for the calculator and seven
0:39:05other like neglected iOS applications
0:39:08and you know people are human and you
0:39:11don't notice that maybe the animations
0:39:12you're adding are making the thing less
0:39:15responsive because like you know do you
0:39:17have a test where it's something some
0:39:20automated thing presses the buttons
0:39:21really fast to make sure you know it's
0:39:22just it's just less important it's lower
0:39:24priority there are fewer people on it
0:39:26and that's just the nature of the nature
0:39:28of humans the nature of work and the
0:39:30nature of a business so many many things
0:39:33are explicable by the boring answer that
0:39:37you know that that we did that and we
0:39:41can't afford to leave our very best
0:39:44engineers maintain the calculator for
0:39:46the rest of their careers because
0:39:47they're not going to like that they're
0:39:48going to leave the company and it
0:39:51wouldn't be efficient use of our
0:39:52resources so we get our best people
0:39:54working on the next hard problem and
0:39:56everything else gets less priority and
0:39:58because humans do humans sometimes those
0:40:00things mess up everything after that
0:40:03that's like the easy thing to explain
0:40:04everything after that like why is iOS
0:40:05love and have more bugs does it seem
0:40:07like it actually has more bugs is your
0:40:08perception different than their metrics
0:40:09are they measuring the wrong thing all
0:40:11the way down to software is hard and
0:40:13software methodologies and all that
0:40:15stuff so from the outside it might seem
0:40:18inexplicable but as Casey I think was
0:40:21trying to express software and any large
0:40:24enterprise including making a car or any
0:40:26sort of thing is much more complicated
0:40:27than you think it is as a consumer of
0:40:29that thing and complicated systems are
0:40:32hard to predict and hard to manage and
0:40:35you know that's it there's no you know
0:40:38it's not it's not the apples being mean
0:40:40or it's still people who don't know what
0:40:43they're doing
0:40:44nobody knows what they're doing there
0:40:45there are no adults there is no silver
0:40:47bullet
0:40:47yada yada Apple has for a very long time
0:40:51shown that they are not very good at
0:40:54multitasking and that whatever is the
0:40:56current hotness gets all the attention
0:40:59and whatever isn't gets either complete
0:41:02neglect or at best like drive-by updates
0:41:06O'Hare they like you know like like Disk
0:41:09Utility on Mac OS is like a great
0:41:11example of it where like you know the
0:41:13met the entire Mac is pretty neglected
0:41:16much of the time and when things do get
0:41:18updated on the Mac they tend to get
0:41:20updated in these drive-by fashions where
0:41:22like someone seems to be assigned like
0:41:25hey wait
0:41:26rewrite this whole thing this app that
0:41:27nobody would really need to be rewritten
0:41:28rewrite at all and then they're given
0:41:30enough time to rush together an almost
0:41:32complete version and then it ships and
0:41:35then it seems like no one's allowed to
0:41:37fix any bugs in it ever again or they're
0:41:39not on the project anymore or they don't
0:41:41have time or they're assigned to other
0:41:43things and have moved on and so things
0:41:45get updated or created from scratch on
0:41:48these low in these low priority areas
0:41:50and then whatever is released as like
0:41:531.0 which was probably rushed to meet a
0:41:55very tight deadline those bugs basically
0:41:59stick around for a very long time or
0:42:00forever anything that is not the current
0:42:02hotness that tends to be the case of
0:42:04Apple as John said there are lots of
0:42:07good reasons for that involving money
0:42:08and priorities I think Apple standards
0:42:12should be higher you know Apple
0:42:14standards are higher than average in
0:42:15most other ways I think their standards
0:42:18for how to deal with they're not as
0:42:20quite high priority products should be
0:42:22also similarly high but they're not and
0:42:26that's not a new thing even you know
0:42:28even that that isn't even Tim Cook thing
0:42:30like even under Steve that was always
0:42:32the case we're like whatever was was not
0:42:34the current hotness got pretty badly
0:42:36neglected and there's also a secondary
0:42:41divide here where Apple's frameworks
0:42:44have almost always been really really
0:42:47good like in in the entire era of modern
0:42:50Apple I don't know what it was like
0:42:51before you know before I was tanner like
0:42:53in the entire era of modern Apple the
0:42:56frameworks have always been amazing
0:42:58you know things like you know the AR kit
0:43:00you know things like court makes core
0:43:02audio the foundation like all that stuff
0:43:03they make amazing frameworks and that
0:43:06stuff has been solid pretty much you
0:43:09know the vast majority of the time and
0:43:11very advanced the applications on that
0:43:14they that Apple ships at the OS and the
0:43:15built and the table on top of that on
0:43:16top of this frameworks have had a much
0:43:18spottier past and a much spotty record
0:43:21the applications definitely seem like a
0:43:23lower priority for them then that also
0:43:26seems like an area where in recent years
0:43:28applications have struggled way more
0:43:30than the foundation stuff so it might
0:43:34just be Apple is not has not figure out
0:43:37how to manage this well it certainly is
0:43:39certainly that that's what the results
0:43:40seem to indicate but it's like that for
0:43:43everybody like you there is no you can't
0:43:45just say oh let's keep all the best
0:43:47people working on the things that they
0:43:48originally create because they don't
0:43:49want doing that and now it's a retention
0:43:50issue like they don't want to work
0:43:52forever on this one thing they helped
0:43:54create they want to move on to the next
0:43:55thing because they're smart ambitious
0:43:57people and if you don't let them you
0:44:00know then you'll have a retention
0:44:02problem in if you even if you you know
0:44:05it's a hyper competitive world where
0:44:07everyone is scrutinizing what Apple does
0:44:09so closely that if they actually did
0:44:11leave significant sort of standing
0:44:14armies attached to everything they ever
0:44:15made to make sure the thing that
0:44:17everything they make is continuously
0:44:19improved and maintained
0:44:21that's an inefficient use of resources
0:44:23with like why are you spending all this
0:44:24money why are your margins going down oh
0:44:26we needed to leave a team of seven on
0:44:28the calculator forever and multiply that
0:44:31by every piece of software we ever make
0:44:33so I was in the calculator done what
0:44:34needs to be updated on it's like well if
0:44:36we just leave one person on it then
0:44:38there's a chance that that one person
0:44:40can make a silly mistake and make us
0:44:42look bad and so everything has to be
0:44:44higher quality so you know we'll leave
0:44:46this team of seven on calculator in it
0:44:47and no matter what team of seven guy
0:44:50said they won't want to do it and like a
0:44:52lot of these things you feel like
0:44:53they're a training program for less
0:44:57experienced people like before you get
0:44:58to be in the Big Show and you know work
0:45:00on a super important new feature in UI
0:45:02kit or work on a major new feature in
0:45:04the OS maybe you have to maintain disk
0:45:06utility for a few years and that's how
0:45:08you learn right like there's no there's
0:45:11no easy solution
0:45:12people are not interchangeable cogs
0:45:14programming is a complicated endeavor
0:45:16and Apple doesn't actually have
0:45:19unlimited money and does actually have
0:45:22people scrutinizing every cent that it
0:45:24spends and at telling them that they
0:45:26should have margins that are higher than
0:45:28they do so you know I don't know there's
0:45:32you know it is a spectrum it's not as if
0:45:34a saying Oh a blow everything apples
0:45:36doing they're doing as well as they can
0:45:37they can and should adjust things right
0:45:39they can and should pay more attention
0:45:41to things that you know they shouldn't
0:45:44let as much slip as they do and they
0:45:46should be not be Pennywise pound-foolish
0:45:49where are we saved a couple bucks here
0:45:50by moving some people around what is
0:45:53what are the potential downsides for the
0:45:54image of the company all the way up to
0:45:57what are the potential downsides if we
0:45:59invest a lot in a feature and spend a
0:46:01lot of time and energy on it and it
0:46:03doesn't turn out that well how do we fix
0:46:05that or burn you know insert your
0:46:07favorite feature there whether it be the
0:46:08touch bar or the new keyboard
0:46:09reliability or any other thing whether
0:46:12they really did dedicate a lot of
0:46:13resources and doesn't turn out as well
0:46:16as they wanted like software's hard life
0:46:19is hard yeah but I think there's also a
0:46:22middle ground here like the the
0:46:24impression I I have gotten from reports
0:46:26from people within over the last many
0:46:28years this seems to always be a
0:46:31consistent story that we hear from
0:46:33people at Apple is that it's not like
0:46:36there were seven people on the
0:46:37calculator team and they reduced it down
0:46:39or they couldn't have those people
0:46:41forever or that it was done none of
0:46:43those things were true what was probably
0:46:45true is the calculator had zero people
0:46:48working on it for a very long time then
0:46:50when a new system design or style or
0:46:53marketing heavy feature was being added
0:46:56to iOS or new hardware somebody was
0:46:59somebody who was already very busy was
0:47:00tasked with update updating this app
0:47:02along with probably as you mentioned
0:47:04probably seven other apps to the new
0:47:06animation style or the new design style
0:47:08or with or take advantage of the new
0:47:10feature of the phone or just the new
0:47:11size of these phones or whatever else so
0:47:13that was someone's job they had enough
0:47:15time to do a two-thirds complete job so
0:47:18they because they had to rush to meet
0:47:19the deadline for when this OS and phone
0:47:21shipped and then after it shipped the
0:47:24staff was returned back to zero
0:47:26so that we have heard that story so many
0:47:30times from people inside so it isn't
0:47:32that it isn't that things are just done
0:47:35and that the markets demanding that they
0:47:36you know or that you know that all of a
0:47:39sudden they're undone like it's
0:47:40following marketing features they have
0:47:42to keep things updated and they had and
0:47:44they keep seemingly very very small
0:47:46staffs available to do things that
0:47:50aren't high priority apps or features or
0:47:52platforms like the calculator app or
0:47:54like you know the Mac head and then as
0:47:57soon as that thing is is done the am at
0:48:01the budget of time allocation for that
0:48:04that's available to fixed bugs in it
0:48:06literally drops to zero not some zero
0:48:10that is a management problem that needs
0:48:13to be adjusted
0:48:14other perverse and perverse incentives
0:48:17too and and yeah and and that's and
0:48:19we've heard that too like we've heard a
0:48:20lot of reports also from people that one
0:48:25of the issues that causes this kind of
0:48:27thing that leads to this kind of thing
0:48:28is the incentive structure in the
0:48:30company seemingly favors rewriting large
0:48:34projects are being on high profile
0:48:35platforms and doesn't favor doing more
0:48:38boring things that's something to be
0:48:40done and that's also a management
0:48:42problem like that's like they need to
0:48:43find ways to to adjust their internal
0:48:47structures and policies and workflows
0:48:50and incentives to make high quality
0:48:53platforms and apps happen more often
0:48:56than they do the incentive that I was
0:49:00thinking of was if you're on if you're a
0:49:03cast with doing something with
0:49:04calculator or if you're one person who
0:49:06is responsible for seven applications
0:49:08and the max utility folder or something
0:49:10you're not particularly incentivized to
0:49:14slowly make the thing better by adding a
0:49:17feature here and a feature there because
0:49:19like you know take the terminal for
0:49:21example terminal it don't it always
0:49:22amazes me when the terminal gets any
0:49:23features because the downsides are big
0:49:25if you mess up the terminal it's a thing
0:49:27that a lot of people use and they're
0:49:28going to yell at you and if terminal is
0:49:30working fine like why add any minor
0:49:33features to it because all you're doing
0:49:34is adding a new more bug surface like oh
0:49:38I added
0:49:39silly feature two-terminal and now I
0:49:41have 17 bug reports on it and I don't
0:49:42have any time to work on it because I'm
0:49:44off doing other things now and I'm the
0:49:45one person who's responsible for
0:49:46terminal in seven other applications I'm
0:49:49not motivated to add features to
0:49:50terminal and justify them and say why I
0:49:53had to spend engineering time on them
0:49:54because every feature I add is a new
0:49:56thing that people can file bugs against
0:49:58and if you know if we just leave it the
0:49:59way it is we've got our existing bug
0:50:01backlog that we're probably just
0:50:02ignoring forever if we haven't fixed it
0:50:04by now and there's nothing new to do and
0:50:06what you were getting as the you know
0:50:08being on the glory projects like no one
0:50:10ever notices bah this guy's great he's
0:50:12slowly improved the terminal over the
0:50:14course of eight years and has had very
0:50:16few bugs and every new feature that he
0:50:17added versus this person worked on
0:50:19worked on the first version of watchkit
0:50:21right one of those probably helps your
0:50:23career inside Apple more than the other
0:50:24but from the outside perspective
0:50:26especially if you never buy a watch I
0:50:28would love a slowly improving terminal
0:50:30that had like the equivalent of one or
0:50:32you motivated indie developers working
0:50:34on it who like terminal was their entire
0:50:36livelihood and they had that kind of
0:50:38motivation but that doesn't exist inside
0:50:39Apple no one inside Apple is going to
0:50:42work on terminal the same way like the
0:50:44the I term authors are going to work on
0:50:45their thing as if their entire
0:50:47livelihood depends on constantly
0:50:49improving and maintaining the terminal
0:50:50application which you know is a shame
0:50:53but there's that's not really I don't
0:50:57know everyone always says everyone we
0:50:58were making like a start-up inside a big
0:51:00company but I've never seen that done
0:51:01successfully well I mean the thing that
0:51:03is is that my limited understanding of
0:51:07what the culture is like with an apple
0:51:09is that they still fancy themselves the
0:51:12plucky upstart and they're not they're
0:51:15just not and how do you maintain and
0:51:19both we've got both of you guys have
0:51:21said this how do you maintain any sort
0:51:22of talent at the company when part of
0:51:24being good at what you do is being good
0:51:28at the boring stuff and it's just it's
0:51:30hard we are brought to you this week by
0:51:33Squarespace start building your websites
0:51:35a day at squarespace.com and enter offer
0:51:37code ATP at checkout to get 10% off make
0:51:41your next move with Squarespace
0:51:42Squarespace makes it so easy to make a
0:51:45website you will wonder why you ever did
0:51:47it any other way
0:51:48there was a time when you should have
0:51:50done in other ways that time was before
0:51:51Squarespace but
0:51:53these days now that Squarespace is here
0:51:54and is wonderful why would you spend
0:51:56time messing around with a custom CMS or
0:51:59installing your own software on a server
0:52:01somewhere
0:52:02Squarespace makes all those problems go
0:52:04away it's so easy and they take care of
0:52:06all the hosting and the support and all
0:52:09the technology stuff behind the scenes
0:52:10so all you have to do is focus on your
0:52:12content your website it's wonderful
0:52:15whether you're making a portfolio a
0:52:17store a blog a Content site for any
0:52:20other kind of thing that you can do so
0:52:21much with Squarespace
0:52:22you'll be shocked what you can do with
0:52:24all the built-in functionality if you
0:52:26actually want to get in there and start
0:52:27hacking things around you can not only
0:52:29inject CSS and JavaScript if you want to
0:52:31but they even have an API if you want to
0:52:33mess with that but almost nobody will
0:52:34actually have to do that because no
0:52:36matter what your skill level is
0:52:37Squarespace offers an incredible
0:52:38functionality with very little time
0:52:41investment on your part it's so easy to
0:52:43use anytime you need to make a new
0:52:45website just go to Squarespace and try
0:52:47it their first give it an hour to see
0:52:49how far you get I bet after an hour or
0:52:51two you're gonna be so far or you're
0:52:53gonna be done that you seemed like all
0:52:55right I guess that's it and then you can
0:52:57log in you can check out you can pay you
0:52:59can do all that without paying but you
0:53:00can log in you can check out your pay
0:53:01once you're done and it is awesome you
0:53:04will see for yourself how great it is to
0:53:05learn more visit Squarespace calm start
0:53:08a free trial see for yourself when you
0:53:10want to sign up make sure to use offer
0:53:11code ATP to get 10% off your first
0:53:14purchase
0:53:14Squarespace make your next move so last
0:53:21year I'm pretty sure single-handedly
0:53:23Marco came up with a with a genuinely
0:53:24brilliant idea to do a little bit of a
0:53:28Thanksgiving special and ask and have
0:53:30each of us describe what tech stuff we
0:53:33are thankful for this year and I really
0:53:38really loved how that turned out and so
0:53:39did a lot of listeners and so Marco you
0:53:41were good enough to remember to talk
0:53:43about it again this year so Marco what
0:53:46text offer you thankful for this year I
0:53:47wanted to keep the list pretty short
0:53:49this year and I'm just super running low
0:53:51on time but you only got four items but
0:53:53there's a tie for number three
0:53:57all done sir yeah I actually do it four
0:54:00times so one of them is my wonderful
0:54:04beloved 2015 MacBook Pro we will get to
0:54:07that in more detail later oh my god I
0:54:09you know look I just love it I wrote a
0:54:12whole blog post about how much I love it
0:54:13it's great and it's it is exactly what
0:54:17text should be which is it just works it
0:54:21delights me and I don't really have to
0:54:22think about it if I don't want to it
0:54:24just works
0:54:25also in the world of Apple hardware I am
0:54:28incredibly happy with the 10.5 inch iPad
0:54:32pro and the smart Keyboard that I bought
0:54:35with it you know I'm I don't use my iPad
0:54:38for very complicated things but I do use
0:54:41it frequently every day I use it it's
0:54:43always in the kitchen or on the table or
0:54:46on the couch and every day I use it to
0:54:49only play podcasts in the kitchen and
0:54:52dining area but then I will often then
0:54:54use it as my couch browsing device and
0:54:57things of that and it's it's just very
0:54:58pleasant to use I'm not an iPad power
0:55:01user by any means I still bring a laptop
0:55:03one night when I'm working
0:55:04but I'm doing anything that's not really
0:55:06work especially you're on the house the
0:55:07iPad is wonderful and the 10.5 inch was
0:55:10such a great update in so many ways the
0:55:12screen size is great and especially once
0:55:15you see it next to and 9.7 again you
0:55:18realize that quite have much of an
0:55:19improvement it was it seemed like a
0:55:20pretty small improvement at the time but
0:55:22it's really nice so it's a great device
0:55:25I always have it propped up in the smart
0:55:27Keyboard so text-entry is nice and fast
0:55:29on it if I need that and it's just it's
0:55:32great I'm very very happy with my iPad
0:55:34pro 10.5 third I will add the general
0:55:38category of power and charging gear by
0:55:42Ankur this is you know it's not that new
0:55:45of an opinion to like anchor gear the
0:55:48world of dealing with our tech these
0:55:50days especially iOS devices with
0:55:53lightning ports and everything else
0:55:54things become a lot more convenient and
0:55:56easier and more pleasant when you can
0:55:59get plentiful charging and power and
0:56:02gear for not that much money and that's
0:56:05pretty high-quality an anchor is not the
0:56:07only brand that does this but I think
0:56:09they are the brand that does the most of
0:56:10it and the most consistent
0:56:12and so very very happy with anchor gear
0:56:14both like the the multi USB port wall
0:56:17chargers their standalone batteries are
0:56:20also great and of course they're they're
0:56:22like heavy-duty braided cables lightning
0:56:24cables are great and they cost so little
0:56:26relatively speaking that you can have a
0:56:29bunch of them and you can put them all
0:56:30over your house you can carry extras
0:56:32around and bags and you can set up like
0:56:34you know different charging stations at
0:56:35different different rooms in different
0:56:37places like your office in your house in
0:56:38your car and it's just really really
0:56:40nice to have all that stuff become
0:56:41inexpensive and good it really it really
0:56:45makes art digital lives with all these
0:56:47charging things a lot easier and finally
0:56:49a special honorable mention to
0:56:52everything I have ever bought from the
0:56:54company sound devices this is very
0:56:57specialized if you are not a sound or
0:56:59video pro you probably have never heard
0:57:01of this company and you probably
0:57:02shouldn't ever hear about this company
0:57:04but if you work with sound or video gear
0:57:06well haven't used their video stuff if
0:57:08you work with sound gear at all the
0:57:10devices by sound devices are not cheap
0:57:13at all but this is truly ProGear is I
0:57:17use a USB pre - for recording here for
0:57:21our live show and for my increasing live
0:57:24and multi port needs
0:57:25I recently splurged and bought one of
0:57:27their 6 Series mixers their stuff is
0:57:30just so damn good and it just works this
0:57:34is true Pro gear and it's total overkill
0:57:37for most podcasters but it's the exact
0:57:40definition of like if you have a problem
0:57:42and you are willing to just throw some
0:57:44money at it to make that problem
0:57:46completely go away sound devices trust
0:57:50me anyway that's it all right so we can
0:57:53go in either surname or age order either
0:57:57way that makes me next and so I will run
0:58:00through my list I will try to do this as
0:58:02quickly as possible in no particular
0:58:05order air pods
0:58:07I freaking love my air pods and I was
0:58:10just thinking a couple hours ago about
0:58:12how as far as I can tell I haven't
0:58:17noticed any particular degradation in
0:58:19battery quality despite the fact that
0:58:21these things have been in my ears for a
0:58:23probably
0:58:25concerning amount of time particularly
0:58:27during the work week and I think that's
0:58:29partially because anytime I take them
0:58:31out of my ears there immediately
0:58:32charging so although I said no
0:58:35particular order I lied because that is
0:58:36definitely number one the remainder
0:58:38however is not in any particular order
0:58:40carplay believe it or not in this
0:58:42surprises even me
0:58:43it's got a lot of problems it is not
0:58:45perfect by any stretch but it is very
0:58:48very nice and I like that I can take
0:58:52pretty much any iOS device plug it into
0:58:54Aaron's car and immediately I have the
0:58:58entire devices experience in her center
0:59:01console so that's really convenient
0:59:03because my caller my phone isn't maded
0:59:06paired to her car via bluetooth but I
0:59:09can try to find an address to somewhere
0:59:12in Apple Maps and get the directions
0:59:15ready to go plug in my phone and
0:59:17suddenly she's got my navigation on her
0:59:19car which is super cool I believe in in
0:59:23laptops that were built in this century
0:59:25so I love my macbook adorable again it's
0:59:28got problems but I love it and the
0:59:31problems it has slower than my ancient
0:59:33laptop by quite a margin that that's one
0:59:35of the problems coincidentally you could
0:59:37but yeah I mean it is not perfect and
0:59:40and as I think I've said many times in
0:59:42the past if this was my only computer
0:59:44I'm not sure I would have such fond
0:59:46feelings for it but in the same way you
0:59:48have such fond feelings for your 10 inch
0:59:50iPad pro I have tremendously fond
0:59:53feelings for this macbook adorable
0:59:56because it is to me anyway the ultimate
0:59:59travel can
0:59:59travel can
1:00:00computer and that can mean the couch or
1:00:02it can mean a cross-country trip and I
1:00:04just love this thing
1:00:06also on the list I in in the process of
1:00:11filming the Alfa Romeo video which I
1:00:14have a first draft complete and I'm now
1:00:17refining it anyway in the process of
1:00:19filming that I borrowed a GoPro from
1:00:20work which I think I mentioned in the
1:00:21past
1:00:22turns out GoPros are really cool and if
1:00:26you're in a situation where you want to
1:00:27have a pretty decent camera that if for
1:00:30some reason it broke you wouldn't be
1:00:31financially ruined and you want to do
1:00:34something with that camera like mounted
1:00:35to the outside of a car or put it
1:00:37somewhere there that's there's not a lot
1:00:39of room the GoPros are really really
1:00:42cool very much a niche use case but man
1:00:45are they agree it's like your sound
1:00:47devices right you know it's it's a very
1:00:49niche thing but holy cow does it work
1:00:52out well for those for those little
1:00:54niches and finally I love my LTE Apple
1:00:58watch I had already started taking
1:01:01Fitness a lot more seriously before my
1:01:04LTE Apple watch but it is much more
1:01:06pleasurable to go for a run without
1:01:09having to carry anything on my person
1:01:12and and still know that I can call for
1:01:15help God for if God forbid something
1:01:17really bad happened and so I am super
1:01:20thankful for my Apple watch even though
1:01:22it is about 50% more expensive on a
1:01:24monthly basis than it should be yeah
1:01:26maybe even a hundred that's okay anyway
1:01:29that's my list a mega list but I can go
1:01:33off the top of my head for the show
1:01:36yeah well Casey stole my first one with
1:01:39air pods my name problem with all these
1:01:41things I can never remember what
1:01:42happened this year like it's this you
1:01:44know what things were thankful for this
1:01:46year was that we're apart this year I
1:01:47don't even know but since Casey listed
1:01:49them I'm gonna say they were but they
1:01:51they were since Thanksgiving
1:01:53ah shoot I'm saying so I received mine I
1:01:57think lately late December and so I'm
1:02:00counting it as Thanksgiving to
1:02:01Thanksgiving thing yes certainly for
1:02:03most people they were this year yeah so
1:02:05they have definitely just changed I
1:02:07think I was thinking about this the
1:02:08other day just how much they've changed
1:02:10my my life
1:02:12because I'm constantly singing to
1:02:13podcasts inside and outside of the house
1:02:14and maybe it's not as big a deal I know
1:02:18I know the air pods everybody likes them
1:02:21like if you ask someone who has the
1:02:22motive great or whatever but for me I
1:02:24think I there's a little bit of extra
1:02:26attraction to them because I'm I don't
1:02:28know how to describe this but I'm the
1:02:29kind of person I'm one of those people
1:02:33who's like disturbed by disorder I think
1:02:35I described it to Merlin once bird like
1:02:37there was some pictures on the internet
1:02:38that show like a bunch of pencils all
1:02:40lined up but one pencil is poking out
1:02:41right or like just things that are a
1:02:44bunch of physical objects that look like
1:02:45they you know they could be nicely
1:02:48arranged but there's just something
1:02:49wrong with them this is Aaron's
1:02:51kryptonite yeah and whatever that is
1:02:53people say OCD but that isn't incorrect
1:02:56use of that term it's not what is it all
1:02:58that's a whole different thing but if
1:03:00you're just generally like disturbed by
1:03:02disorder and headphone chords for me are
1:03:05were always a big source of disorder
1:03:07they're tangled in your pockets you have
1:03:08all these techniques for coiling them
1:03:10they get caught on things I think as I
1:03:12tweeted one of the other tweets that I I
1:03:15think back on every time this happens to
1:03:17me nothing makes me more instantly
1:03:20enraged than having my headphones yanked
1:03:22out of my ears
1:03:23that just makes me want to immediately
1:03:25kill right like easy going through a
1:03:30door and your headphone cord gets caught
1:03:31on something and the earbud is yanked
1:03:33out of your ears the worst right and
1:03:36it's not a big deal like whatever all
1:03:38the cords bother you oh it's just too
1:03:40crippling you know it really is ruining
1:03:42your day that you have cords it wasn't a
1:03:44big deal but it was always there and I'm
1:03:46the type of person who was bothered by
1:03:48this kind of disorder who was bothered
1:03:49by having to deal with it and having to
1:03:51have all these techniques for dealing
1:03:52with it now and be aware of it and being
1:03:54careful within threading the cords
1:03:55through my clothes and doing all of this
1:03:56stuff earpods get rid of all of that
1:04:00there is no more cord and despite being
1:04:04annoyed by not being able to change the
1:04:05volume and all the other things and
1:04:07having to be able to charging and all
1:04:08that other stuff boy they have really
1:04:09just ambiently increased my quality of
1:04:13life by a tiny amount but the tiny
1:04:14amount is spread through like the whole
1:04:16day so I really love them I'm gonna give
1:04:19a slot to the Apple TV the new Apple TV
1:04:22now that the beta OS does the
1:04:25the frame matching stuff mostly because
1:04:28I hadn't realized how much I had written
1:04:30off the Apple TV as sort of a video file
1:04:32audio file like whatever like a sort of
1:04:35device in which I can indulge my love of
1:04:38beautiful movies and stuff is like yeah
1:04:39that's a thing that we use it to watch
1:04:42TV shows and the kids play with it but
1:04:44that's outside the realm of my sort of
1:04:47TV nerd experience but suddenly it's
1:04:49it's right back in now it's back in the
1:04:51mix because now it can actually show
1:04:53things of the correct frame rate and as
1:04:55hgr support and its 4k and its back on
1:04:58the board and so I'm excited by that
1:05:00because I never really dislike the Apple
1:05:03TV and I dreaded having to go to a
1:05:05geekier device like a build-your-own
1:05:07Raspberry Pi and you can make your own
1:05:09thing or use the Nvidia shield and don't
1:05:11worry you know like I I didn't want to
1:05:14deal with all that so I was just you
1:05:16know stuck with my plastic blu-ray discs
1:05:17in my TV and everything but now I'm more
1:05:20optimistic about the future of the Apple
1:05:21TV in my life not just this a thing that
1:05:24my kids used to watch stuff sometimes
1:05:26what was my third one oh yeah my camera
1:05:30which I don't think was this year either
1:05:31but going through my pictures I've been
1:05:35printing books from the Apple photo book
1:05:37thing and so I've been going through a
1:05:39lot of old pictures and everything and
1:05:41it's so clear where the dividing line is
1:05:44between my old cameras and my new one
1:05:46which is the sony a6300 not that it's
1:05:51the world's best camera but it was a
1:05:53significant leap in image quality and
1:05:56sensor size over my old superzoom
1:05:57cameras and i notice it when i'm going
1:05:59through the pictures and I'm much
1:06:01happier with the pictures I'm taking
1:06:02with my new camera then I was in my old
1:06:04ones I got some good ones at that one
1:06:06too but I see the difference and now of
1:06:09course I wish I could go back in time
1:06:10and you know take take pictures of my
1:06:12son it was born 13 years ago with a
1:06:15camera from 2017 that's not the way the
1:06:17world works
1:06:19but I really I really do enjoy my camera
1:06:22and it's making me as making me think
1:06:25that maybe like oh wait I'll wait for a
1:06:28Parkers review of the of the bigger Sony
1:06:30that maybe I should start cranking up
1:06:32the size of the camera I'm willing to
1:06:34carry just to see if I can go all the
1:06:37way up to
1:06:38a larger sensor size and make it
1:06:41worthwhile but anyway I really enjoy my
1:06:42camera let's see the final thing I guess
1:06:44I have to give a shout out for the Mac
1:06:46Pro how can I be thankful for a thing I
1:06:47don't actually have I'm thankful that
1:06:49this year again I'm pretty sure this
1:06:51year is the year that Apple said you
1:06:53know what we should make it a Mac Pro
1:06:55and I agree Apple you should and I'm
1:06:58waiting patiently I haven't had enough
1:07:04to drink
1:07:05to handle the Mac Pro conversations so
1:07:07let's just move on and let's talk about
1:07:10how I did not bring up the iPhone 10 and
1:07:14in fact none of us brought up the iPhone
1:07:1610 as one of our things that we're
1:07:19thankful for
1:07:19to be fair John doesn't really have one
1:07:21eye I've had it for two weeks it is
1:07:24really good so far I really enjoy it
1:07:26it's just a little early for me to say
1:07:29for sure that it's like a clear positive
1:07:32win in all fronts but I think it's
1:07:34heading in that direction for me but
1:07:35apparently not for you so I I'm having
1:07:41some troubles and I feel like it is
1:07:46clear that Apple has done something that
1:07:50they have no bin I think I said this
1:07:51originally when we reviewed the iPhone
1:07:5310 iPhones 10 they've done something
1:07:56that they have no business doing and
1:07:57brought technology that really should
1:07:59not exist in 2017 and and ripped it from
1:08:01the future and put it in 2017 so in a
1:08:05lot of ways I am delighted and
1:08:09mesmerized by this device and certainly
1:08:12every time I look at any other devices I
1:08:14think I described last episode any time
1:08:16I look at any other device that has the
1:08:19big chin and forehead I look at it and
1:08:21it just feels friggin ancient like I'm
1:08:24poking fun at your laptop but really and
1:08:26truly that these old devices look just
1:08:28ancient by comparison in a way that your
1:08:30laptop actually doesn't although I'll
1:08:32deny that in about 10 minutes they're so
1:08:36in so many ways this thing is is
1:08:38wonderful and my goodness when face ID
1:08:42works right boy does it feel amazing it
1:08:45feels like back in the day when I didn't
1:08:47put a passcode in my 3GS because why
1:08:49would you there's no need for it
1:08:51so in so many ways the these phones are
1:08:54so great but I am getting more and more
1:08:57and more infuriated about the fact that
1:09:00I feel less and less and less able to
1:09:03use my phone at night or potentially in
1:09:07the morning and let me tell you why
1:09:08so well I think I described last episode
1:09:12that I have a very peculiar eye problem
1:09:15it's called keratoconus which means that
1:09:17I wear hard contact lenses and it means
1:09:20that if I were I glasses which I do have
1:09:21a pair of eye glasses they get me from
1:09:24unable to do almost anything to somewhat
1:09:29functioning human being but I would
1:09:31never drive with my eyeglasses it's very
1:09:33difficult to work on a computer with
1:09:34eyeglasses I need my contacts and so at
1:09:37night when I'm in bed or in the morning
1:09:39when I'm in bed and I don't have my
1:09:41contacts in I have to keep the phone
1:09:44uncomfortably close to my face well it's
1:09:46not uncomfortable to me but you know it
1:09:48probably looks just completely weird to
1:09:50anyone else I would guess that it's 2 to
1:09:533 inches away from my nose and my nose
1:09:55is about 800 feet long so that's
1:09:58actually not as close as it seems I
1:09:59suppose but it's close and the point is
1:10:02that what I feel like is happening I
1:10:06don't know this is true but what seems
1:10:07to be happening is that I'm close enough
1:10:10that face ID can't see my eyes and it's
1:10:13assuming that I'm not looking at the
1:10:14phone and so the symptom is that I will
1:10:18be actively using my phone often times
1:10:21having scrolled in like Twitter or
1:10:23something within the last 15 or 20
1:10:25seconds and the phone just suddenly
1:10:28decides to lock itself and turn the
1:10:29screen off and this is happening a lot
1:10:33it's not dimming before the screen is
1:10:35turned off I'm not in low-power mode I
1:10:38am usually and do not disturb but I'm
1:10:40not in low-power mode and often times I
1:10:42expect it would dim I would you know
1:10:44touch the screen to remind it don't know
1:10:46I'm here don't don't go away I'm here
1:10:48but off it happened this morning like
1:10:51two different times I'm sitting there
1:10:53I'm reading something and next thing you
1:10:55know all of a sudden the phone turns
1:10:57itself off well I shouldn't say turns
1:10:58itself off are you sure you're not a
1:10:59ghost I know I'm not sure is this real
1:11:02life there's just a bit see I don't
1:11:04No okay sorry did you mention whether
1:11:06you what's your auto lock timeout set to
1:11:08whatever the default is but I will stall
1:11:12for time and I will tell you but I'm
1:11:14pretty darn sure it's whatever the
1:11:15default is and I feel like that's like
1:11:1730 seconds or something yeah which
1:11:18should be the default with the OLED
1:11:20screens
1:11:20well I'd argue it shouldn't because it
1:11:22sucks well Touche
1:11:26it is absolutely unequivocally set for
1:11:2730 seconds yeah that's bad but you said
1:11:30it doesn't dim first no that's the thing
1:11:33that's driving me bananas because if it
1:11:35was dimming and what I shouldn't say
1:11:37that occasionally it will dim and then
1:11:39I'll touch the screen and everything
1:11:40will be fine but there have been times
1:11:42where I will be looking at the screen
1:11:44and again in the defense of the phone my
1:11:47devices is very close to my face and all
1:11:52of a sudden will just turn itself off
1:11:53and yes I do have a tension detection on
1:11:55and no I have not tried turning it off
1:11:56but I want attention detection on I like
1:11:59it in every other circumstance but when
1:12:01I have my phone so close to my face it
1:12:03just suddenly decides no you're done now
1:12:05in turns itself off and I I don't know
1:12:09what to do to fix it other than I mean I
1:12:11I suppose I could turn attention
1:12:13detection off but my goodness is is
1:12:16frustrating and it's grating on me like
1:12:19it's it's that thing that when you hear
1:12:21somebody else talk about like like
1:12:22John's phone or headphone cables like
1:12:26okay yeah that's annoying but whatever
1:12:27get over John know like I can't get over
1:12:30this it's killing me you know like this
1:12:32is my headphone cables and I don't know
1:12:35what to do about it and it's getting to
1:12:36the point that it's kind of ruining a
1:12:38phone that I otherwise really really
1:12:40really really love did you put the RAM
1:12:42from your iMac into your just turn it
1:12:49indeed is the phone also just rebooting
1:12:52itself like every few hours and you
1:12:54weren't telling us that because you
1:12:55figure that's fine but he's complaining
1:12:56about his progress he's complaining
1:12:58about his look I'm using my features
1:12:59turns off whereas before he's like
1:13:01sometimes when I use my iMac it turns
1:13:03off whatever I mean it seems like you
1:13:06know step one is try turning off
1:13:08attention detection yeah you're
1:13:10absolutely right why haven't you tried
1:13:11that yet that's my question like so you
1:13:13have this problem what's been stopping
1:13:14you from saying oh I'm going to
1:13:15that obvious setting and flippant
1:13:17because I don't want to turn it on and I
1:13:19think that more of the stories I need to
1:13:20try but I don't want to turn it off I
1:13:22don't wanna have to flip that switch
1:13:23every morning either because why don't
1:13:25you want it off permanently like what
1:13:26it's what's stopping you from saying why
1:13:28don't you want it off because I like the
1:13:30whole like the phone knows when I'm
1:13:32looking at it and will show me the
1:13:34details of my messages now the next
1:13:35question you're gonna ask me is did I
1:13:37ever bother with that before no I did
1:13:39not my text messages could be seen by
1:13:41anyone who had access to my phone I
1:13:43don't think that's mutually exclusive I
1:13:45think it's as soon as the phone is
1:13:47unlocked it will show you the content
1:13:49your text messages and it's unlocked
1:13:50whether attention detection is enabled
1:13:52or not just it uses face ID for that
1:13:53interesting point okay that makes me
1:13:56feel a little better that's okay that's
1:13:58an interesting point I didn't think of
1:13:59it that way I see what you're saying
1:14:00though so attempt number one
1:14:01turn off the engine detection and then
1:14:03if that doesn't do it enough for you
1:14:05raise that auto walk time out be above
1:14:07thirty seconds and that should
1:14:08significantly reduce the chances of this
1:14:10this problem affecting you yeah but the
1:14:13interesting the interesting life lesson
1:14:15here is I don't view this as my fault
1:14:20and the chat room is already saying it's
1:14:22my fault I'm sure if you're listening
1:14:23you're saying it's my fault but I don't
1:14:25view this isn't that is my fault I'm
1:14:26just trying to use my phone the way I
1:14:27want to use my phone and although by any
1:14:29normal metric I am in no way differently
1:14:32abled or whatever the correct phrasing
1:14:35is that I'm looking for but this is this
1:14:37is the first time perhaps in my entire
1:14:39life that an ailment of mine has caused
1:14:44me to have a problem with the way
1:14:47something's designed because I don't
1:14:49think apples designers I I don't think
1:14:52had ever really had to worry about well
1:14:55what happens if somebody has really
1:14:56really poor eyesight and is basically
1:14:58touching their nose to this phone like
1:15:00then what do we do and and so I feel I
1:15:04feel neglected and that's a weird
1:15:06feeling for me because as a able-bodied
1:15:08person by any other metric this is the
1:15:10first time I've really have to have to
1:15:13deal with this and it's been a really
1:15:16good and useful lesson that it's easy to
1:15:20feel marginalized that's prob about the
1:15:22word I'm looking for it but I can't
1:15:23think of a better one it's easy to feel
1:15:24marginalized just by being overlooked
1:15:27the littlest tiniest bit
1:15:29and that's been kind of interesting too
1:15:31it's a glimpse of your future as I think
1:15:34we've said many times when we talked
1:15:35about accessibility features your
1:15:38choices are you will eventually use
1:15:40accessibility features or you'll be dead
1:15:42and in general I think people will
1:15:45choose the accessibility features like
1:15:46it's not a question maybe you'll need
1:15:48accessibility features no you will these
1:15:51the only way you won't need
1:15:52accessibility features is if you die or
1:15:53if they cure aging I suppose but don't
1:15:55hold your breath for that
1:15:56sorry CGP grey yeah yeah we're all gonna
1:16:00need these features in everything that
1:16:02we do if we just keep living and our
1:16:04bodies keep deteriorating you may be
1:16:05perfectly healthy now and everything
1:16:07works but eventually it won't and then
1:16:10you are suddenly a customer for all the
1:16:12features that you are not using in all
1:16:14your electronic devices and all of the
1:16:16appliances in your home and all the
1:16:18places you go and your car and
1:16:20everything else and so there's it's not
1:16:23speculative and it's not likely there's
1:16:25some chance you might need accessibility
1:16:26features you will need them and I also
1:16:29some obviously I don't have I content
1:16:32but I also do exactly what Casey does I
1:16:33don't have his exact vision problem but
1:16:35I have terrible vision and when I use my
1:16:37phone without my glasses in my bed it
1:16:40might as well be touching my nose like
1:16:42is that's when I get really intimate
1:16:43with the retina screen and be like look
1:16:44I can see the subpixels my close-up
1:16:47vision is still pretty good although
1:16:49maybe not true for Casey but bad news
1:16:52for other young people who think that
1:16:53yeah you know I need glasses to see far
1:16:56away but I can see close up real great
1:16:57well guess what when you get old that
1:16:58goes to so that you have that to look
1:17:00forward to but yeah and I think I would
1:17:02have the exact same problem as you and I
1:17:04think I would be the same situation
1:17:06where I'd have to be considering turning
1:17:08off the attention thing just because I
1:17:10don't want to give up like that and you
1:17:13know it's not a long time but I do use
1:17:15my phone in my bed either before going
1:17:17to bed or just after waking up and I
1:17:20don't want to have to toggle setting to
1:17:21do that and I don't want the screen to
1:17:23turn off while I'm doing it so yeah it's
1:17:26a thing so I'm looking at the settings
1:17:28right now and in face ID and attention
1:17:31there are two settings require attention
1:17:33for face ID and then separately
1:17:36attention to where features and then the
1:17:39the footer under that says treat up the
1:17:41camera will check for attention before
1:17:43the display or lowering the volume of
1:17:45alerts I am bummed to give away the
1:17:49lowering the bar the volume of alerts
1:17:51thing because although it doesn't happen
1:17:52but once or twice a day that is a super
1:17:55nice feature that when I look at the
1:17:56phone it will duck the audio or maybe
1:17:58that's not the right term for it but
1:17:59it'll lower the volume of the the the
1:18:01alarm or the timer what-have-you and you
1:18:03know the thing that I I guess really
1:18:05grinds my gears about this the most is
1:18:07that one of the coolest like Wow things
1:18:10for me anyway about the iPhone 10 is
1:18:14that it is attention aware in that it is
1:18:17capable of making decisions based on
1:18:19whether or not you're looking at it like
1:18:20that's so cool me I I'm seriously it's
1:18:22super cool and now I feel like I'm
1:18:24giving up on a little bit of that and
1:18:26that bums me out because I like my new
1:18:28toy otherwise and it's a really nice new
1:18:30toy and I don't want and I want all
1:18:31parts of my new toy to work not just
1:18:33some of them we are sponsored this week
1:18:36by betterment rethink what your money
1:18:38can do visit betterment comm slash ATP
1:18:41to learn more betterment is the largest
1:18:43independent online financial advisor
1:18:45designed to help improve customers
1:18:47long-term returns and lower your taxes
1:18:50for retirement planning building wealth
1:18:52and other financial goals betterment
1:18:54takes advanced investment strategies and
1:18:56uses technology to deliver them to more
1:18:57than 270,000 customers betterments
1:19:01experts have your back they believe you
1:19:04should be able to get financial advice
1:19:05anytime anywhere so all betterment
1:19:08customers can receive advice from their
1:19:09team of licensed financial experts
1:19:11through their mobile apps messaging
1:19:12feature and betterment is a fiduciary
1:19:14this means that they don't get
1:19:16commissions for recommending certain
1:19:18funds to you and they don't have any
1:19:19funds of their own they only do what
1:19:21they believe is right for you and they
1:19:23deliver all this with incredibly low
1:19:25fees compared to traditional services
1:19:27they have only a 0.25 percent annual fee
1:19:30that includes unlimited messaging to
1:19:32their team of experts and if you have a
1:19:34more complex situation and you want
1:19:35unlimited phone call access to their
1:19:38team of certified financial planners
1:19:39they do that for only 0.4% annually
1:19:42these are incredible rates and now
1:19:45veterans offering a free five minute
1:19:47investment review helping you assess
1:19:49your investment accounts tax strategies
1:19:51fees and risk exposure with no signup
1:19:53required investing involves risk
1:19:56a TV listeners visit betterment calm /
1:19:58ATP that's betterment calm / ATP to
1:20:02start your review today betterment
1:20:04rethink what your money can do do we
1:20:09have time for your best laptop ever
1:20:11discussion we sure do
1:20:13it's the best done yeah that's that's
1:20:15exactly how this is going to go all
1:20:17right so tell us tell us this may or
1:20:20tell if you and I are gonna hate each
1:20:22other buy into this or if we're just
1:20:23gonna shrug and say yeah okay that makes
1:20:25sense but tell it tell us make your
1:20:26pitch tell us about the the supposed
1:20:29best laptop that's ever been made I
1:20:31actually already did tell you a few
1:20:33weeks ago on this show I basically I you
1:20:37know as listeners of this show know I
1:20:38have lots of complaints about the
1:20:40current generation of MacBook Pros and I
1:20:43switched back recently to a 2015 model
1:20:46that I got off eBay for a pretty good
1:20:48price and I just loved it I absolutely
1:20:51loved it you know the the the wonderful
1:20:54design of it just resonates well with me
1:20:56it fits my needs incredibly well even
1:21:00though it might not fit more modern
1:21:01needs in certain ways if it's my you
1:21:03know fairly low laptop needs incredibly
1:21:06well it's incredibly convenient to have
1:21:08all the nice old ports on it that I
1:21:10don't need dongles for I can have only
1:21:12USB a cables in my travel bag and be
1:21:15able to plug my phone into either
1:21:17chargers or my laptop with the same
1:21:19cable and not have to worry about two
1:21:20different kinds the keyboard is
1:21:23wonderful it just works its reliable
1:21:25it's the kind that I like the trackpad
1:21:27is wonderful it's just a great the
1:21:29battery life is wonderful and the
1:21:33biggest thing I was afraid about when I
1:21:34went back to it was that it would feel
1:21:36old or that it would that I would miss
1:21:38some of the advances the new stuff and
1:21:40in fact that didn't happen at all it
1:21:41doesn't feel old to me at all it doesn't
1:21:43look old to me at all and I don't miss
1:21:45the advances of the new stuff at all so
1:21:47it basically was all good switching back
1:21:50to it and I've been thinking for a while
1:21:53about whether I wanted to write a big
1:21:55blog post about just how much worse I
1:21:58felt the the new generation of MacBook
1:22:00Pros is and I decided to take a more
1:22:05positive approach and not even not do
1:22:07that at all I do that enough here
1:22:09but to instead really celebrate quite
1:22:12how good this laptop is and in the
1:22:15entire post while some of the things I
1:22:17point out are kind of you know
1:22:20subtly in in comparisons to the current
1:22:24model I never actually call out the
1:22:27current model I never actually named it
1:22:28I'm just talking about the context of
1:22:32how great this laptop is and that's
1:22:33really how I meant it you know the you
1:22:35know certainly it's going to serve the
1:22:37function also of serving as a critique
1:22:39of the new ones but I didn't want this
1:22:42to be a negative article I wanted this
1:22:44to be a positive article about just how
1:22:45much I love that generation of laptops
1:22:49and the great thing is you can still buy
1:22:51them if you if you if you agree with me
1:22:52Apple still sells it still sells them
1:22:55brand new if you score onto the bottom
1:22:57of the 15-inch MacBook Pro by page they
1:22:59still have this model brand-new you can
1:23:01get them plentifully on ebay and other
1:23:03resellers if you want to pay use instead
1:23:05and so it's I just love this laptop a
1:23:09lot and so I brought this big blog post
1:23:10I took some pretty pictures of it and I
1:23:12hire it's big blog post about just some
1:23:15of the things about that I love so much
1:23:16some of the good design decisions and
1:23:17some of the things that just resonate
1:23:19with me and just how nice it is and I
1:23:21named it best laptop ever or something
1:23:25like that and I thought well I had a
1:23:28hard time coming up with a title for
1:23:30this and I and when I decided to go with
1:23:31that I thought boy am I gonna get hell
1:23:35for this I like you put something on the
1:23:38internet that says best ever and you're
1:23:41gonna hear from a lot of people who
1:23:43disagree with that
1:23:44hey especially especially when the thing
1:23:49you're saying is the best ever is not
1:23:52the current thing and the people who
1:23:56bought the current thing you're kind of
1:23:58implicitly telling them you made a
1:24:00mistake you made a bad buying decision
1:24:02although I'm telling them from the
1:24:03perspective that I too made that mistake
1:24:04and I too bought the new one twice three
1:24:08times if you count the escape and so I
1:24:13expected this to be a highly
1:24:16controversial article and I also thought
1:24:20I must be the only person who cares as
1:24:23much
1:24:23about this generation of MacBook Pros is
1:24:26no one's really talking about them
1:24:27anymore and everyone's just kind of
1:24:29swallowing the new ones and so I really
1:24:33didn't I thought that this wouldn't go
1:24:35that far and wide and that if it did the
1:24:39response would be really really mixed
1:24:42and I'd get a lot of complaints and a
1:24:44lot of flaming and a lot of disagreement
1:24:46about what was the best ever that was
1:24:50totally not what happened it immediately
1:24:52went very far and wide even like you
1:24:56know top a hacker news immediately it
1:24:58got you know all over the place even Mac
1:25:00firm referred about it for some reason
1:25:01even though it was not news at all
1:25:03whatever and it went far and wide very
1:25:08very quickly and the shocking thing to
1:25:11me is that the response even on Hacker
1:25:15News which is horrible the response
1:25:18pretty much everywhere was nearly
1:25:22universally positive and with very very
1:25:25strong agreement not a hundred percent
1:25:28agreement but like I can write the sky
1:25:31is blue and I will get more disagreement
1:25:32than what I got from saying this was the
1:25:35best laptop ever and that's really
1:25:38saying something like if Apple has any
1:25:40reason to be concerned it's not that I
1:25:42wrote this article they don't care about
1:25:44that it's how many people agree with it
1:25:47I have gotten I'm still every day still
1:25:50responses from this but I got hundreds
1:25:54of responses hundreds of comments on
1:25:56other sites tons of inbound links and
1:26:00almost all of them agreed and that to me
1:26:04is shocking even the people who like and
1:26:07I thought for I thought like maybe the
1:26:09MacBook Air people would have a problem
1:26:11with it or maybe the 13-inch MacBook Pro
1:26:14people would have a problem with it and
1:26:15they largely didn't even the people who
1:26:19like those most of them said but you're
1:26:22right so I am just blown away by how
1:26:27much people agree with this and I got I
1:26:31heard from lots of people both who have
1:26:32the old laptops who you know who had the
1:26:352012 through 2015
1:26:37book pro who I've heard it from tons of
1:26:40them
1:26:40who said I'm holding on to mine I love
1:26:43it I see no reason to upgrade I hope it
1:26:44never dies tons of them who were like I
1:26:46don't know what I'm gonna get when it
1:26:47does die who I guess didn't know that
1:26:48there still make these tons of people
1:26:51who have the new ones and who regret it
1:26:55and who wish they would have kept the
1:26:57old one or have been thinking about
1:26:58switching back to the old one a handful
1:27:00of people who did what I did and who did
1:27:01switch back to the old one and are very
1:27:03happy having done that again I can't
1:27:05underestimate I can't understate how
1:27:07many people supported this this point of
1:27:10view in their responses also I think
1:27:13worrisome for Apple is pretty much no
1:27:17one cares about the touch bar and in any
1:27:19of these responses that the big
1:27:21headlining feature of this laptop touch
1:27:23bar not a lot of people care the few
1:27:26people who disagreed with it
1:27:28most of them decided that the best left
1:27:30I've ever was actually a think pad I
1:27:32disagree that wasn't me surprisingly
1:27:36yeah like so you know the most of the
1:27:38disagreement was once it's spread beyond
1:27:40the Apple crowd that the PC people
1:27:42really good though it's not it's the
1:27:44best I've ever is not it's not an apple
1:27:46you know but but they think they can
1:27:48have that I guess no no that that is is
1:27:51a die-hard I think Pat fan you are way
1:27:55closer to right than they are so anyway
1:27:58so if you if you rule out the windows
1:28:00people the the biggest counter-argument
1:28:05was that was was more theoretical it was
1:28:08more like well someone needs to push the
1:28:11industry forward and that's why Apple
1:28:13needed to go all USB see what about the
1:28:15original iMac going all USB blah blah
1:28:17blah and most of those arguments were
1:28:19honestly pretty bad I don't I disagree
1:28:22with many of those arguments I don't
1:28:24think we have time to talk about that I
1:28:25don't really care but if we do I will
1:28:26but for the most part the the response
1:28:29was just so positive and almost none of
1:28:32the people who disagreed even mentioned
1:28:34the touch bar well I guess it wasn't a
1:28:36surprise honestly but it was damning I
1:28:38would say how few people cared about the
1:28:40touch bar people to care about touch ID
1:28:42sometimes even that not not as often as
1:28:45I would have expected but for the most
1:28:47part the touch bar didn't get much of I
1:28:49mentioned
1:28:50the the new keyboard does have some fans
1:28:53people who said you know I prefer it and
1:28:54that's fine I get that if you prefer it
1:28:56that's fine I think we can all still
1:28:58agree that it's unreliable for a lot of
1:29:00people and that's a big problem but you
1:29:02know for the people who like it you can
1:29:04like it that's fine but I think the
1:29:05whole package of the old one I just
1:29:07loved so much and it just is a workhorse
1:29:10it just works and works and works for
1:29:12years and and some people did that did
1:29:15point out that that generation has had
1:29:17its issues you know the first one I got
1:29:18in 2012 had image retention that was a
1:29:21common thing that's why I made my little
1:29:22grid page it was for the 2012 right I'm
1:29:24a pro and over the years they seem to
1:29:26have fix that so that had some issues
1:29:28with some of those really screens if
1:29:29they were made by algae instead of
1:29:30Samsung that it had it has this
1:29:34continued screen delamination problem
1:29:37for some people that hasn't ever
1:29:39affected me but well and the ones with
1:29:42discrete GPUs as every MacBook Pro with
1:29:46a discrete GPU has had in the last
1:29:48probably decade or so those GPUs tend to
1:29:51die at a higher rate than an average and
1:29:54so that causes problems for people but
1:29:55we but not only have they all done that
1:29:57but we don't even know yet if the
1:29:59current generation will also do that I
1:30:01think it probably will so the overall
1:30:04the response was great and pretty much
1:30:07everybody agrees with me I guess except
1:30:08casing so I think your point is fair and
1:30:16I think part of the reason why you got
1:30:18such good coverage of this is because
1:30:21you did take the high road and said hey
1:30:22rather than telling you about why
1:30:23everything else is garbage let me tell
1:30:25you why this is good and if that
1:30:26implicitly means that other things are
1:30:27garbage then so be it
1:30:29the problem I have with it is that it is
1:30:34far more absolute or it reads is far
1:30:40more absolute then then I think is
1:30:42really true you know this the best
1:30:44laptop ever made period I mean it's not
1:30:46the best laptop for Marco it's the best
1:30:48laptop ever made and this is it yeah you
1:30:51know the look at your opening paragraph
1:30:52Apple has made many great laptops 15
1:30:54inch retina MacBook Pro 2012 2015 is he
1:30:56epitome of usefulness elegance and
1:30:57practicality and power for an overall
1:30:59package that still hasn't been and may
1:31:00never be surpassed
1:31:01like it's number it's not an
1:31:04unreasonable thesis but it's I feel like
1:31:08just some degree this entire article was
1:31:09that's fine for Marco and then and
1:31:11that's okay
1:31:12I mean it's Marco org it's not it's not
1:31:13people that are like Marco org it's
1:31:16Marco to work so I mean to some degree I
1:31:18really need to give you a bye on this
1:31:20but that's that's I think we're my
1:31:21primary complaint lies is that there are
1:31:24there are other uses for Mac laptops
1:31:26besides what you need to do as an
1:31:29example a lot of people and I think you
1:31:32were one of them had had many many
1:31:36beehives full of bees and their bonnets
1:31:39about the removal of the SD card slot in
1:31:42your right and and you were particularly
1:31:45perturbed about the removal of the SD
1:31:47card slot obviously I have no idea how
1:31:50many people do or do not use the SD card
1:31:52slot but I can tell you that I had never
1:31:56ever ever used an SD card reader ever
1:31:58until 2014 when I bought our big camera
1:32:02and I would argue that most people that
1:32:07I know anyway don't have big fancy
1:32:09cameras that take SD cards so to me if
1:32:14you were to lament the loss of the SD
1:32:17card slot that's fine for mark oh really
1:32:20I guess the loss is not fine for mark oh
1:32:22but you know what I mean like for you
1:32:24that's a big friggin problem and I'm not
1:32:26trying to patronize you like it for you
1:32:27that is a big friggin problem that's a
1:32:30big deal but for me it may not be as it
1:32:33turns out it actually is but do you see
1:32:37what I'm driving at and so I think I
1:32:40think that the thing is is that I have
1:32:44one of these computers that I use every
1:32:47single day because that's my work
1:32:48computer and you know what it's a damn
1:32:50fine computer it really really is but
1:32:53there's a lot that I wish was different
1:32:55about it as a perfect example I wish it
1:32:58had the new keyboard until it inevitably
1:33:01breaks but until that moment I wish have
1:33:03had the new keyboard because when I type
1:33:04on this thing when I go from my magic
1:33:06key my beloved magic keyboard to this it
1:33:09feels like I've gone from a steel roller
1:33:12coaster to a wooden roller
1:33:14everything is creaky and loose and just
1:33:17mushy and just just gross and I I can't
1:33:24it's not fair of me to just hand wave
1:33:26away the reliability problems are the
1:33:28new keyboards and I recognize that
1:33:30that's not fair but for me I'd love the
1:33:33feel of the new keyboards if they could
1:33:35only make a reliable version of it it
1:33:36would be tremendous well and they have
1:33:40that's not a great counter-argument like
1:33:41until they don't is until they can make
1:33:43that keyboard without pretty horrible
1:33:46side effects then you can't say well I
1:33:50wish they had that keyboard everywhere
1:33:51because trust me you don't you're right
1:33:53in now in my defense my beloved MacBook
1:33:58adorable has yet to have any keyboard
1:34:00problems that compressed air couldn't
1:34:03fix it but I haven't had and to be fair
1:34:07to you I didn't have compressed air in
1:34:10the house I had to buy myself compressed
1:34:13air to fix my six month old laptop what
1:34:16year is this pretty freakin preposterous
1:34:17and like and how often did you have to
1:34:19use compressed air to fix your keyboard
1:34:21I'm the one that you could that you
1:34:22don't like I never write but it feels
1:34:25like mush though right I really do it
1:34:29and I do I I also I want to push back a
1:34:32little bit on what you said about the SD
1:34:33card slot also because you know it seems
1:34:35like one of the counter arguments to
1:34:37this or one of the general arguments in
1:34:39support of the new direction Apple's
1:34:41taken is you know the whole thing about
1:34:43moving forward and everything people
1:34:45always say well if we dabble didn't move
1:34:46forward we'd still have VGA ports and
1:34:48guess what the world does still have EGA
1:34:50ports I believe I made that exact
1:34:51argument right you're not the only one
1:34:53but like the there there seems to be
1:34:56like a few like like brain virus themes
1:35:00among defenders where they repeat back
1:35:04some kind of dogma that doesn't actually
1:35:07apply very well or is not a very good
1:35:08argument and you know the the imac going
1:35:12all USB is a great one which doesn't
1:35:13apply at all because that was one
1:35:15desktop going all USB a consumer level
1:35:18one no less in a lineup that had plenty
1:35:21of other options that didn't go all USB
1:35:23and also it went all us being it was a
1:35:25big problem
1:35:27hidden away and then future versions
1:35:30added back a lot of ports that weren't
1:35:31you that's B so that's that's of one bad
1:35:35example there were you know other ones
1:35:38you know things like like VGA ports you
1:35:41know well VGA ports like people still
1:35:44complain well yeah you know what VGA
1:35:45ports are still around because they're
1:35:46still unwanted projectors and stuff and
1:35:47that's reality that's fine you know
1:35:49there's all sorts of bad examples but I
1:35:51think one of the thought viruses that
1:35:54that is common among Apple defenders is
1:35:56that if something is not used very often
1:36:00but or by a large percentage of people
1:36:03it should be removed that that the
1:36:04removal in and of itself is progress and
1:36:09that's not always the case you know
1:36:13there like every Apple product every
1:36:16desktop every laptop every phone I have
1:36:18ever owned has features on it that I
1:36:21have never used for instance on my
1:36:25macbook pro on all MacBook Pros
1:36:27including the current ones I never use
1:36:30the front-facing camera for anything
1:36:32ever I don't take selfies and if I'm
1:36:35going to use FaceTime I use it on my
1:36:38phone or my or an iPad I never use the
1:36:41front-facing camera on a Mac for
1:36:43anything but it has them should they
1:36:47remove the front-facing camera because I
1:36:49don't use it
1:36:50no because its presence there doesn't
1:36:53affect me in any way it's an inexpensive
1:36:55part very expensive example never
1:36:57updates them in there they're always
1:36:58terrible oh it's an inexpensive part it
1:37:02doesn't add a meaningful amount of size
1:37:04or weight or technical complexity in a
1:37:06way that gets in my way at all and for
1:37:08the few people who do use them it's
1:37:11there and if I ever really need it it's
1:37:15there for me too so even if I think I'll
1:37:17never use it it's there similarly I
1:37:19never use video output on my laptops
1:37:22because that's just on how I use laptops
1:37:24I don't have to connect into projectors
1:37:26really ever and I don't use it at home
1:37:28like that and so I don't need I don't
1:37:30need I never used the HDMI port on my
1:37:32laptops before when they still had those
1:37:34and with the new ones I never use video
1:37:36output on them either should they remove
1:37:38it because not a lot of people use it
1:37:40because it doesn't get in the way at all
1:37:42it doesn't matter at all that I never
1:37:44use it it's not a problem in my life at
1:37:46all if I ever need it it's there and
1:37:48it's there without me having to buy
1:37:50anything so like if I happen to be like
1:37:53in a hotel room or something and all of
1:37:55a sudden oh crap I have a quick need to
1:37:58show something for my laptop on this TV
1:37:59that has an HDMI port I can just take a
1:38:02regular HDMI cable it's probably already
1:38:03behind the TV unplug it from whatever
1:38:06garbage DVD player that's already there
1:38:07and plugs my laptop and haven't and I
1:38:09didn't need to go to an Apple store and
1:38:10buy a dongle I can use what I already
1:38:12have and that will probably suffice that
1:38:15is called versatility so when you when a
1:38:19computer has things on it that you might
1:38:22not think you need it there is still
1:38:25value to have them be available just in
1:38:27case you do need them sometime and as
1:38:30long as they are not really getting in
1:38:32the way like it was not necessary when
1:38:36designing the 2012 MacBook Pro to get
1:38:39rid of all these ports for like fitness
1:38:42or lightness reasons or anything else
1:38:43they're all pretty thin they're all
1:38:45pretty light they don't add a lot of
1:38:46cost or complexity or anything else that
1:38:47left them in because people use them
1:38:50sometimes on the new ones I don't know
1:38:54the details of exactly what would have
1:38:55fit in the slightly thinner case by the
1:38:58way using the old one don't notice the
1:39:01thickness difference at all don't notice
1:39:02the weight difference at all but that's
1:39:03fine you might that's good for you in
1:39:06the new ones wouldn't have killed them
1:39:08could they have included an SD card slot
1:39:11for people who use that and need that I
1:39:13think they probably could could they
1:39:16have included any other ports I think
1:39:18probably yes
1:39:19they didn't as a feature because this
1:39:22the thinking that removing things is
1:39:25itself a feature has infected Apple to
1:39:27the highest levels in addition to the
1:39:29Apple defenders so now Apple views it as
1:39:32progress or courage whatever word they
1:39:34want to use and all the defenders
1:39:36support this that removing things is
1:39:39itself a commendable thing and it's
1:39:42quote moving forward which is a
1:39:44meaningless phrase moving forward only
1:39:46means doing what we did this year like
1:39:47it's not there is no such thing like
1:39:49moving forward suggests there's like a
1:39:51certain like there's one future that
1:39:53you're moving towards inevitably
1:39:54that's not true at all like you create
1:39:55that future anyway that's that's a BS
1:39:57phrase it bothers me but the idea that
1:40:00removing things is itself something that
1:40:03we should do as soon as we can we should
1:40:04drop things as soon as we can that's not
1:40:07true for everything and I think the more
1:40:09high-end and pro you get with computing
1:40:13gear the less true that becomes because
1:40:16what pros need is not only for their
1:40:18gear including their keyboards to work
1:40:20incredibly reliably as reliably as
1:40:22possible but also pros need that
1:40:25versatility pros need the idea that if
1:40:27you're gonna be traveling somewhere with
1:40:29your gear or on some are honest set or
1:40:31instrument production environment and
1:40:33something comes up that you didn't
1:40:35foresee and because you didn't foresee
1:40:38it you probably don't have the right
1:40:39dongle if it's true Pro gear it will try
1:40:43to accommodate as many of those
1:40:44situations as possible
1:40:46that's what pros actually need an apple
1:40:49has been great at doing that in the past
1:40:51and now they're really taking I think a
1:40:55pretty quick nosedive in that area and I
1:40:59really really love so much of the old
1:41:02one because it has so much of his
1:41:03versatility and the new one took us such
1:41:07a stark change such a rapid turn in the
1:41:11other direction that's why I bugs me so
1:41:13much see you know I understand
1:41:17everything you just said and I can't
1:41:20with an honest heart sit here and say
1:41:21you're wrong but I can say I look at it
1:41:24differently you said just a moment ago
1:41:26if it's true boat ProGear it will try to
1:41:29accommodate as many of these situations
1:41:30these basically oh crap situations as
1:41:33possible there is a very compelling
1:41:36argument that you just made that the
1:41:39best way to do that is to have as many
1:41:40ports as possible on that device and as
1:41:43many different kinds of ports as
1:41:45possible on that device but another
1:41:48approach is what if you had one port
1:41:51that can do anything in which case yes
1:41:54you're right Marko that I would have to
1:41:56carry an HDMI dongle with me full-stop
1:41:58there's nothing I can do to argue that
1:41:59fact and buy one for $80 and by oh I
1:42:02didn't pay 80 for mine but you're still
1:42:04more right than you are wrong yeah I
1:42:05would have to buy one
1:42:06but the fact of the matter is for any
1:42:10situation that I Casey could possibly
1:42:13face any situation that I would that I
1:42:16would want to be prepared for I have
1:42:20three different USBC things that I would
1:42:23need to carry with me none of which are
1:42:25particularly large one of them is triple
1:42:27old USB and Ethernet one of them is HDMI
1:42:30and pass through USB C and by the way
1:42:32has a old usb on it and what was the
1:42:35other one shoot
1:42:36oh they the USB Sita lightning adapter
1:42:39which truth be told I could just use one
1:42:42of the dongles and in a traditional
1:42:44cable so I think the problem is is that
1:42:48your perception of versatility is
1:42:53requiring nothing but the device in my I
1:42:57shouldn't say that that I don't agree
1:43:00with that I'm implying I don't agree
1:43:01with you I do agree with you but another
1:43:03perception of versatility is we have one
1:43:07port that can do friggin anything it can
1:43:11do anything so if you need an SD card
1:43:14reader Marco and actually I do and come
1:43:16to think of it maybe that would be
1:43:17number four dongle number for like cats
1:43:21you think you have two and then
1:43:22eventually it may be more like rabbits
1:43:25than cats but but you know what I mean
1:43:29like a finding this SD card reader then
1:43:31fine I pay ten dollars or 12 or whatever
1:43:32wasn't mana price to get one but for
1:43:35Aaron who doesn't need one she doesn't
1:43:39have to have one her computer has one I
1:43:41know you know what I'm saying though you
1:43:46know what I'm saying and so it what was
1:43:49the other one oh like Ethernet ports
1:43:51like no normal human needs Ethernet
1:43:53ports anymore I do because I'm a weirdo
1:43:55you do because you're a weirdo but no
1:43:58normal human needs Ethernet ports
1:43:59anymore this is where the entire in its
1:44:01gonna write into actually you really do
1:44:03new teeth reports for the Ethernet ports
1:44:04for this then okay fine whatever
1:44:05but I would say most people who buy
1:44:08MacBook Pros don't need Ethernet ports
1:44:09and I think the problem that you and I
1:44:11have is actually the same problem and
1:44:13although we disagree on the best
1:44:15possible mechanism for fixing the
1:44:17problem I think I share most
1:44:20of your complaints and I think that by
1:44:23and large were of the same mind even if
1:44:25we're arguing about the particulars and
1:44:26I think the real honest-to-goodness
1:44:28problem and I read this I'm parroting
1:44:30somebody maybe it was you for all I know
1:44:32but somebody said to me Mary was John
1:44:33somebody said recently the problem is
1:44:35the lack of diversity in the lineup that
1:44:38Jason's no there oh is that who it was
1:44:40okay thank you there's no like 17-inch
1:44:44aircraft carrier option and I bring that
1:44:47up not because I think 17 inches is the
1:44:48right answer although here again all the
1:44:50fanboys for the 17 are gonna come out of
1:44:51the woodwork but there's no way for you
1:44:54to get the Mac Pro god help me laptop's
1:44:59right there's no way for you to say
1:45:01money be damned maybe even portability
1:45:05be damned maybe I want the most flexible
1:45:10versatile device I can get by both
1:45:13definitions I want a couple of USB C
1:45:14ports I want a couple of USB whatever
1:45:16the hell the old one is I want a seat I
1:45:19want SD card reader he'll give me a
1:45:22thicker computer so I can have onboard
1:45:23Ethernet I'll take it whatever and I
1:45:26think the problem is that there's no
1:45:28option for that and so I think it would
1:45:32make all of us feel better if there was
1:45:35an option because at least then we could
1:45:37say you know what I really don't want to
1:45:41have to buy the aircraft carrier laptop
1:45:43but it's worth it to me because I want
1:45:46all of these things and that's what
1:45:48stinks and I think that and it might
1:45:50have been you that said months ago the
1:45:53problem with one of the problems with
1:45:54MacBook Pro is that pro implies things
1:45:57but the reality of the situation is the
1:45:59MacBook Pro is the every person computer
1:46:01unless you want an adorable which I
1:46:03would argue is a much more niche device
1:46:05or a MacBook Air of course but does that
1:46:08make sense like the MacBook Pro is
1:46:10covering college students who are doing
1:46:12nothing but Google Docs all the way up
1:46:14through you know people are doing Final
1:46:17Cut Pro on film sets in and doing 3d
1:46:20rendering your VR development like
1:46:22spoiler VR people can't expect right now
1:46:26with the external GPUs yes I know okay
1:46:29right so I think the problem is what's
1:46:32now had
1:46:34I think a little while ago now was that
1:46:36there are there is no choice and that
1:46:39means that if I want to choose to have
1:46:44more ports or if I want to choose to
1:46:46have a laptop that is actually reliable
1:46:48or a keyboard that's actually reliable
1:46:50I'm screwed because I got nothing it's
1:46:52then I'm good buying a think pad and
1:46:54that's not a fun place to be
1:46:55or 2015 which is still a valid choice
1:46:57they won't be in forever but right now
1:46:58adays yeah no I mean that's that's all
1:47:02very very fair and and I will say also
1:47:04you know to to defend to refute
1:47:06something which you didn't quite argue
1:47:07but that people will hear in your
1:47:08argument and will argue with me against
1:47:10it
1:47:11sorry USBC can be great you had the the
1:47:16idea of having versatile USB seaports on
1:47:19a laptop is is great and you're right
1:47:22that USB C port scan offer a great
1:47:24degree of versatility my problem with
1:47:27USB C one of my problems the USB see a
1:47:29whole article about some other ones but
1:47:31one of my problems with USB C is that I
1:47:34don't think that I don't think the
1:47:37ecosystem is ready for that to be our
1:47:38only port I think I think the the last
1:47:42year or so has has really supported that
1:47:45view that the ecosystem just is not
1:47:47there and it's going to be maybe be a
1:47:49few more years before it's there and one
1:47:51of the counter-arguments I've heard over
1:47:52the last few days about this is Apple
1:47:55needed to do this because it would push
1:47:56the industry to finally make more USB C
1:47:59peripherals just like the iMac push them
1:48:01to make USB peripherals to things a the
1:48:04iMac didn't push them to make USB
1:48:06peripherals the iMac wasn't that popular
1:48:07relative to the entire world of pcs the
1:48:10entire world of pcs was already making
1:48:12USB peripherals they were going to make
1:48:14them anyway and it just so happened the
1:48:15Mac benefited from some of them with the
1:48:17iMac secondly the the the idea that
1:48:21Apple going all USB C will push the
1:48:24energy to make USB C peripherals that's
1:48:27a great theory so far that hasn't
1:48:29happened
1:48:30the original USB see MacBook the map
1:48:33book 1 slash adorable slash 12-inch came
1:48:36out now but two and a half years ago
1:48:37that would that was the first Mac with
1:48:39you it with USB C port and MacBook Pros
1:48:42went all USB C now a little over a year
1:48:44ago
1:48:45and we still have a fair
1:48:47immature fairly incomplete and fairly
1:48:50unreliable selection of USBC gear out
1:48:53there it's still a really immature and
1:48:56inconsistent market that has a lot of
1:48:58big holes in it I don't think that the
1:49:01industry has been forced by Apple to
1:49:03make great stuff the reality is there's
1:49:07a lot of media crap and some of its good
1:49:09most of it isn't
1:49:10I think if Apple would have continued to
1:49:14ship old ports alongside USBC basically
1:49:17like if you SBC ports became the new
1:49:20Thunderbolt ports where most Apple
1:49:23laptops would have two of them along
1:49:25with other ones you know maybe it meet
1:49:27you know me and maybe you can keep maybe
1:49:28even have for them on the on a MacBook
1:49:30Pro on the fifth the big ones you know
1:49:32and and because you know you can do that
1:49:35there they're pretty small there you
1:49:37know they have very high technical needs
1:49:39you know the idea that all of them can
1:49:41be charging ports and Thunderbolt ports
1:49:44means that Apple pretty much can't make
1:49:47say a 15-inch with six of them are eight
1:49:49of them because they can do too much you
1:49:52know whereas like the old ones you can
1:49:56connect a total of more devices before
1:49:59you have to go to dongles or hubs
1:50:01because some of those ports are pretty
1:50:04simple to add there you know that
1:50:05they're pretty low needs dumb ports on
1:50:08the old ones but when every single port
1:50:10you add has to be able to charge the
1:50:12computer and be a thunderbolt port by
1:50:14your own design you can't have as many
1:50:16of them that you know that you run into
1:50:18issues with maximum bandwidth on the
1:50:19Thunderbolt controllers you know
1:50:21chipsets costs running wires etc so I
1:50:24think the better way to do this
1:50:26transition would have been you know have
1:50:30an actual transition happen not just
1:50:32like jumping to the deep end with all
1:50:33USBC to have an intermediary generation
1:50:36or at least like a high-end model like
1:50:38at least the 15-inch where there's more
1:50:40room for things and more budget for
1:50:42things have an intermediate where like
1:50:44you basically have some of the old ports
1:50:47and an SD card reader and some like that
1:50:49and then you you have replaced
1:50:51thunderbolt ports with USBC ports that
1:50:54would have been great if that laptop
1:50:56would ever exist from Apple that would
1:50:58have a high chance of being the best
1:51:00laptop ever be
1:51:01because then you have all the
1:51:02versatility of USBC you have the higher
1:51:04bandwidth for the higher you know needs
1:51:05of it for things like 5k displays that
1:51:07would be awesome but then you don't have
1:51:10to I don't think I think in this world I
1:51:12don't think you have to give up the
1:51:14versatility of having one or two USB a
1:51:16ports on there also and having an SD
1:51:18card reader and maybe an HDMI port
1:51:20because these are things that are either
1:51:23difficult clunky or unreliable to do
1:51:25with adapters and dongles so far that
1:51:28would have been a very different
1:51:29reception to this machine I think than
1:51:31what we actually got John you've been
1:51:34quiet I did already talked a lot about
1:51:37this today's episode of upgrade I
1:51:41haven't more in-depth commentary for me
1:51:43on this but I did one thing I didn't
1:51:45talk about specifically about this
1:51:46article is and I just scroll through it
1:51:48again to see if I was mistaken
1:51:50I seem to have recalled something in the
1:51:53article it's not actually there but I
1:51:54think it's kind of implied and this is
1:51:57not really the substance of what you're
1:51:59talking about so I apologize but like
1:52:01the title is the best laps I've ever
1:52:03made and the the implied thing that I
1:52:05thought was there but doesn't seem to be
1:52:06is that part of what makes it the best
1:52:10is what Marco has talked about before
1:52:12they're like it's not actually that much
1:52:14slower than the current ones because
1:52:16Intel's progress on their laptop CPUs
1:52:19hasn't been that great and because you
1:52:21know like think it's not it doesn't feel
1:52:23like you're using an old computer and
1:52:25part of that like that's what I'm
1:52:27wrapping up this like okay well I can
1:52:29see where you come from this article
1:52:30because if that's part of your
1:52:31definition what that does is it excludes
1:52:35all the other laptops it excludes the
1:52:38power book 101 70 it excludes the wall
1:52:40street's it excludes the Thai book it
1:52:42excludes the 13-inch MacBook Air because
1:52:44all those are really old and really slow
1:52:47by modern standards or don't have Retina
1:52:49screen so don't have color screens or
1:52:50whatever the case may be right and if
1:52:54you narrow your definition in that way
1:52:58the only real contenders are the other
1:53:01laptops that can kind of hang with the
1:53:03modern ones so that's basically just
1:53:05this generation which Apple still sells
1:53:07and maybe one generation before you can
1:53:10make some arguments for depending on how
1:53:12you're going to do trade-offs or
1:53:13whatever and
1:53:14I think that narrowing of the definition
1:53:17is lessens the idea that this is the
1:53:21best laptop ever made because if I'm
1:53:23thinking of the best laptop I read I'm
1:53:25not going to put that qualifier on I'm
1:53:26not gonna say I don't by the way it has
1:53:27to be like something that is that I
1:53:29could reasonably use today and it
1:53:31wouldn't feel slow because that includes
1:53:33too many great laptops and then you know
1:53:36if and I think most people took that
1:53:38implicit framing right because if they
1:53:40didn't everyone would be you know bullet
1:53:42coming out of the woodwork and saying
1:53:43that their old favorite laptop from like
1:53:4420 years ago or something right it's the
1:53:46best one arguably to think that people
1:53:48are actually doing that but modern thing
1:53:50pads are really as great as whatever one
1:53:52they're trying to decide I have no idea
1:53:53they're not even though I would probably
1:53:55go for like the 2011 ish 13-inch MacBook
1:53:58Air as a better overall laptop this one
1:54:01big is this 15-inch like you know you've
1:54:04heard my complaint said before but like
1:54:05design wise like the keyboard is too
1:54:06small the the arrow keys should be
1:54:09full-sized not like the current ones but
1:54:11like an actual inverted T that Dix tends
1:54:13downward from the keyboard like it is
1:54:15very wide at large and not particularly
1:54:19portable as far as portables go and I
1:54:21just feel like the 13-inch air is a
1:54:22better laptop but you're not gonna use a
1:54:2413-inch air to get your job done today
1:54:25it is slower and it's worse and it's
1:54:28non-retina and it's just you know it's
1:54:29not a better laptop in this but if you
1:54:31do best ever made you know so that is
1:54:33anyway that is more of a meta issue that
1:54:35I think you know I think most people
1:54:39took it in the spirit that Marko
1:54:40intended it but the the title doesn't
1:54:42doesn't reflect that and that the spirit
1:54:45Marko intended it excludes
1:54:47uh you know saves him from a lot of
1:54:50criticism that would be warranted if the
1:54:54scope was widened up because honestly I
1:54:56don't think this laptop in the in the
1:54:58pantheon of Apple laptops is the best
1:55:02one or two or three like it's maybe in
1:55:04the top five really but you know it
1:55:07really depends like I was never I was
1:55:10never in love with this model of laptop
1:55:12and I there are a lot of things about it
1:55:14that are suboptimal it only really
1:55:17shines when you consider that hey it's
1:55:19still a pretty great laptop and when and
1:55:22when you you know whether again implied
1:55:24and that supposedly stated when you
1:55:26start to compare it to
1:55:27the 2016-2017 months because I don't
1:55:31think those laptop struck a good balance
1:55:32and I don't think a lot of people really
1:55:34love them and I think the touch bar is
1:55:35kind of a dud and all the things that we
1:55:37talked about a million times that that's
1:55:39sort of the opposite of reflected glory
1:55:41like you know as compared to the current
1:55:44line suddenly this 2015 looks a hell of
1:55:47a lot better and I feel like that sort
1:55:48of the opposite of the basking in the
1:55:51reflected glory like I'd be basking in
1:55:53the reflected crappiness of the the
1:55:56modern ones is what makes this laptop
1:55:58seem so great so I think this is more
1:56:00like how Marco has found love with it
1:56:03with an older computer it's really not
1:56:07that much older but is less about in the
1:56:10pantheon of all laptops or even just all
1:56:13Apple portables how great this one
1:56:14particular model is because there there
1:56:17are many things to not recommend this
1:56:19model and when I look at it all I can
1:56:20see is all the things I've always
1:56:21complained about it that I just feel
1:56:23like this exact laptop could have been
1:56:25better with all the same features but
1:56:26but that's not what we're talking about
1:56:27here that sometimes already get hung up
1:56:29on that but that's this that's what I
1:56:30came away from sorry the larger point
1:56:32about the balance being struck what I'm
1:56:34you know the mark I said before that so
1:56:37many people agree with it the main thing
1:56:38I am i I kind of can't get past is the
1:56:43idea that like so many so many of the
1:56:47people so often when you complain about
1:56:48a product like I don't know what Apple
1:56:51should have done instead but I don't
1:56:53like this one and it's not really
1:56:54helpful and it's kind of apples job to
1:56:56figure out like you know it's not it's
1:56:57not customers job to tell Apple exactly
1:56:59what to do they just can be satisfied or
1:57:01not satisfied and their customer sad
1:57:03about their but in the case of the new
1:57:05laptops I think people who have
1:57:09complaints know exactly what they
1:57:13specifically want that like that it
1:57:14would be so easy to make a laptop that
1:57:17was satisfied all the people who were
1:57:19dissatisfied with the current one like
1:57:21and maybe it's 17 different laptops from
1:57:2417 different people but there's no
1:57:26mystery like and you know just you know
1:57:28experience of dealing with this input
1:57:29and going conference rooms if you're in
1:57:31a conference room every single day and
1:57:33you constantly have to deal with that
1:57:34dongle to plug in HDMI all people are
1:57:37not there's no mystery they say put an
1:57:38HDMI port on right yep I would be
1:57:41I you know can you make this computer
1:57:43better put max iPhone app an HDMI port
1:57:45an SD part like and throw that in front
1:57:47of all these people actually that would
1:57:50probably be enough it really and they'll
1:57:52be like well you know I don't use the
1:57:54HDMI but I care about the SD I don't use
1:57:56the SD but I care about the HDMI I don't
1:57:58really care about mac safe but I would
1:58:00like it's so easy to just say you like
1:58:02it's not a mystery what you need to do
1:58:04Apple make it slightly different
1:58:06slightly different feature set like
1:58:07Marco said you don't have to have all
1:58:08the ports but like everyone loves all
1:58:10the USB C and Thunderbolt notes are all
1:58:12great and everything just a few little
1:58:14tweaks here in there and don't make the
1:58:15keyboard so damn small to make me happy
1:58:17and make it more reliable right there
1:58:19close but everybody knows every it's an
1:58:22open secret like how can you make these
1:58:24Wow I wonder how we can make these more
1:58:26appealing we all know how to do it more
1:58:28for the better ports like bigger
1:58:30keyboard arrow keys that are easier to
1:58:33find reliable like it's it's right there
1:58:35and touch bar you know do you need it do
1:58:38you not lead it no one really loves it I
1:58:39don't even know how to go with that and
1:58:41that's what's frustrating normally if
1:58:42people don't like something or it's
1:58:44unsatisfactory in some way they don't
1:58:45know like exactly how to fix it and this
1:58:48the solutions just seems so obvious and
1:58:50not to say that that's what Apple should
1:58:52do because we're always asking up like
1:58:53don't do the obvious thing that people
1:58:54know that they want do the thing they
1:58:56didn't even know they wanted right
1:58:57that's apples job well so I'm not saying
1:58:59how to do it right exactly but but I'm
1:59:02not saying Apple should like oh just
1:59:03just do what people expect right they
1:59:05have to do what people don't expect they
1:59:07have to try to go above beyond they have
1:59:09to you know push the limits with you
1:59:11know touch ID and face ID and all the
1:59:12things they do but when they miss then
1:59:17it starts to feel like oh I wish they
1:59:18had just on the obvious thing all right
1:59:20so what's the solution should they
1:59:22now backpedal into the obvious thing or
1:59:24this should make should they make try
1:59:26number two at the transcendent thing and
1:59:28I think Marcos criticized them a lot in
1:59:29the past of like Apple don't feel like
1:59:32you always have to like every single
1:59:34time be transcendent because we wait too
1:59:36long these big transcendent things and
1:59:39so if you miss one of them nobody wants
1:59:41to wait around for another five years of
1:59:43unsatisfying unreliable laptops that are
1:59:47shaped like this backpedal and do the
1:59:50obvious thing while you regroup you know
1:59:52like
1:59:53and and as I think I said an upgrade
1:59:56they could be doing that right now
1:59:58hardware timelines being
1:59:58hardware timelines being
2:00:00they are there's only so much they can
2:00:01do in response to dissatisfaction and
2:00:04the final thing like we've done in this
2:00:06novel coil but before we get off it is
2:00:07like Apple just reported its results and
2:00:10they're selling a ton of Max and I think
2:00:11they're selling a ton of these laptops
2:00:12and we're just we're back to success
2:00:15Heights problems yeah people have
2:00:16complaints but look at the numbers if if
2:00:18the metrics you're looking at don't
2:00:20reflect the supposed to dissatisfaction
2:00:22then either we're all wrong and we're in
2:00:24the minority and Apple is on the right
2:00:26path and everything will be fine or
2:00:27they're measuring things the wrong way
2:00:30so I I you know I think based on vague
2:00:35hints from the roundtable that I
2:00:37continue to read things into that Mac
2:00:38roundtable that and the fact that they
2:00:40did try to adjust the keyboard and the
2:00:41fact that the keyboards really do appear
2:00:43to have reliability problems that Apple
2:00:45will do something and make different
2:00:47decisions about the next major revision
2:00:50to the laptop line not just putting
2:00:52rubber gaskets in the keys because
2:00:53that's all they can do in the time
2:00:54allotted to them but in whatever the
2:00:58next round of MacBook Pros that come out
2:01:03that actually get to meaningfully
2:01:06incorporate the the feedback that we
2:01:09feel like we're all providing and that
2:01:11people may be providing with all their
2:01:12lives in different services whatever
2:01:13that I think Apple will make different
2:01:15choices and I think they will make
2:01:19adjustments that make these more
2:01:20satisfactory and perhaps will make Marco
2:01:22revisit whether this 2015 computer is
2:01:25indeed the best laptop that Apple ever
2:01:27can make because like he said he really
2:01:30hopes that that's not the case and I
2:01:32think it won't be the case he just needs
2:01:33to wait a little bit longer all right
2:01:35thanks for sponsors this week simple
2:01:37contacts Squarespace and betterment and
2:01:39they will see you next week
2:01:43now the show is over they didn't even
2:01:46mean to begin because it was accidental
2:01:50oh it was accidental
2:01:54johnny research Marco and Casey wouldn't
2:01:57let him because it was accidentally was
2:02:02accidental today CAS II WA L is s so
2:02:19that's Casey less and a are Co AR m and
2:02:23T Marco Arment SI r AC Syracuse
2:02:40I think we have one obvious choice for
2:02:45the after show what is up with this
2:02:49Tesla Roadster yeah
2:02:52actually honestly I think the semi it
2:02:54might be the more interesting one but
2:02:55you're wrong about that the semi is now
2:02:58this morning I mean maybe more impactful
2:03:03or maybe they're both vaporware but the
2:03:05Tesla Roadster is obviously much more
2:03:07exciting
2:03:08so no snark or joke intended can you set
2:03:12up for me what this event was because I
2:03:14had heard that there was going to be a
2:03:15Tesla event but I really honestly didn't
2:03:17know much about it and I don't follow
2:03:20Tesla that closely so I don't I don't
2:03:22have a good feel for what the
2:03:23significance of this event was John D I
2:03:26mean I I don't honestly I don't follow
2:03:28them that closely I don't I never watch
2:03:31their events live because I find them a
2:03:33little bit insufferable that's oh I just
2:03:37kind of see we know what news comes out
2:03:38of them afterwards so this was as far as
2:03:42I know this was an event ostensibly to
2:03:44reveal the Tesla semi truck and then the
2:03:47Roadster I think was the one more thing
2:03:49even though it has been kind of teased
2:03:51for a little while but no one really
2:03:52knew anything about it yet yeah that's
2:03:54my impression do I also don't follow
2:03:55that closely but yeah this was a semi
2:03:57event but I wasn't shocked to see the
2:03:58Roadster because has been like an open
2:04:00secret for such a long time the Roadster
2:04:01was their first car and you know they're
2:04:03gonna revisit that it seemed like an
2:04:04obvious thing they were going to do and
2:04:06guess what they did it and yeah so I
2:04:08didn't watch it live you there I just
2:04:09caught the news after the fact but I
2:04:11think it's I think it's interesting
2:04:12because if you said oh Tesla is gonna do
2:04:14a roadster that makes perfect sense they
2:04:15make a big four-door sedan and they make
2:04:17a smaller four-door sedan and the
2:04:19original car was the Roadster and it's
2:04:21obvious that there's probably a market
2:04:22for a sporty car and so here is their
2:04:25sporty car but I was surprised at
2:04:27exactly the form this sporty car took in
2:04:33many respects like so it's called the
2:04:36Roadster but yeah it's it's not a t-top
2:04:42but there's not much air above your head
2:04:46like just before I even think about what
2:04:48this car does if you look at it
2:04:50more like a coupe with a section of the
2:04:52roof that comes off and I feel like the
2:04:54sort of open air that's not unusual
2:04:56that's like Porsche was huge into that
2:05:01think of even thinking I know it's more
2:05:03like a targets Leslie even the Boxster
2:05:05has more open air let alone like a you
2:05:07know a proper convertible right so it is
2:05:10it feels less open than I would have
2:05:13expected it to be it looks just more
2:05:14like a coupe and so it'd be have to call
2:05:16it roadster because you know the first
2:05:17thing was called the roadster and
2:05:18there's like the family thing or
2:05:19whatever but what they've essentially
2:05:20made is like you said like a target type
2:05:23of thing which is fine it just doesn't
2:05:25match with the name and the second thing
2:05:28I was surprised by was like it's not
2:05:32just like oh here's a sporty er you know
2:05:34it's a two-door sporty version so you
2:05:37don't have to have a big family sedan
2:05:38it's a kind of a fun sporty car seem
2:05:41like in typical Tesla fashion they were
2:05:44going for the jugular and saying no no
2:05:46you don't understand we're making a
2:05:48hyper car look at these numbers right
2:05:50250 mile an hour plus top speed which is
2:05:54pretty impressive even for hyper cars
2:05:56because they generally then tend to go
2:05:58for a downforce and the cost of top
2:06:00speed unless you're talking about the
2:06:01Veyron or something or the cheer on or
2:06:04whatever the new one is 0c in 1.9
2:06:07seconds which is a very typical Elon
2:06:09Musk II kind of number that I don't
2:06:11doubt this car can hit but you know they
2:06:14just wanted to have a number with a 1 in
2:06:15front of it for the shock value is it
2:06:20necessary and then the price like is you
2:06:22know 250 grand or whatever it is like
2:06:24it's not like oh it's a sporty car it's
2:06:27like no here's our competitor - you know
2:06:30the p1 or the laferrari or all you know
2:06:34the the Porsche 918 only it's and it's
2:06:38got an open top on it and the range by
2:06:40the way is 600 miles it's like it's like
2:06:44they I'm almost surprised it doesn't go
2:06:46faster than their era I put it that way
2:06:47I mean something surprising to me that
2:06:48they didn't say and by the way top speed
2:06:50is 327 miles an hour because why not
2:06:52like Indian must fashion this must be
2:06:54the best car human beings have ever made
2:06:58it is faster goes longer you know this
2:07:00is everything you know like pulls 3.0
2:07:03G's
2:07:03detaches your retinas goes off the line
2:07:06and I feel like that's Oh like I don't I
2:07:11don't know I'm not sure like this
2:07:14this car is writing checks that Tesla
2:07:18probably can't cash because oh but it
2:07:22gets worse though Elon Musk on the 18th
2:07:24of November should clarify that this is
2:07:26the base model performance there will be
2:07:27a special edition pack a special option
2:07:29package that takes it to the next level
2:07:31yeah and I think I complained in the
2:07:33neutral thing of like all right so see
2:07:35you want to make a hyper car maybe not
2:07:37the way I would have gone I would've
2:07:38just made a sporty car they cost 80
2:07:39grand and you sell a lot of those and it
2:07:41would be great and people would like
2:07:42them but fine you want to make like a
2:07:44hyper car type thing there's more to
2:07:46hyper cars than these particular numbers
2:07:49you put down most again most of the
2:07:51reason the hyper car is that you know
2:07:52top gear whatever had competing tow the
2:07:54reason they don't go as fast as the
2:07:55Veyron they consciously trade that for
2:07:59downforce and handling because they're
2:08:01trying to go around a track quickly and
2:08:03when I see a 620 mile range I think is
2:08:05this a five thousand five hundred pound
2:08:07hyper car because once you start trying
2:08:10to turn five thousand five hundred
2:08:12pounds around a track suddenly all the
2:08:14power in the world is not really helping
2:08:17you because you've got this big problem
2:08:19this huge amount of momentum going into
2:08:21every single turn
2:08:23and so I I feel like this car is not
2:08:26going to be able to compete with a
2:08:28Porsche 918 our life or our ear p1 it's
2:08:30gonna get left behind on anything except
2:08:32for a straight line and then so what is
2:08:35the market for this car people who only
2:08:37care about numbers but who never turn
2:08:38like do you just want to make an
2:08:39electric dragster because you can make
2:08:41one of those it it seems like a a
2:08:45strangely misguided car in a way that
2:08:48both the Model S in the model 3 are not
2:08:50the Model X is kind of misguided because
2:08:52of the stupid doors but I'm not sure I'm
2:08:56not sure they've even if they hit all
2:08:58their numbers and this car is exactly
2:08:59what they say it is I'm not sure it is a
2:09:02car that makes sense in the price point
2:09:06and market in which it competes like if
2:09:08I had 250 grand and I had to choose
2:09:10between this and any of the other hyper
2:09:12cars I would choose any of the hyper
2:09:13cars and heartbeat even if this is you
2:09:15know faster on the dragster
2:09:17or whatever just because it doesn't it
2:09:20doesn't seem to deliver what is required
2:09:23to compete in in that price range and
2:09:27that stretch and you know I like I said
2:09:29in furthermore I don't think Tesla
2:09:30needed to compete in this price range
2:09:32seems like it seems like an ego exercise
2:09:34they should have just made the you know
2:09:37yeah exactly it's it's on brand but like
2:09:39but the Model S is so sensible
2:09:41it's got it's got some so much room it's
2:09:43so like the packaging is so efficient
2:09:46it's got the seats in the back it's you
2:09:48know it's got all the safety stuff even
2:09:49the model three so so reasonable you can
2:09:53make a really good sporty electric car
2:09:56for 80 grand Porsche was gonna make one
2:09:58like it all there's gonna be a hundred
2:09:59and forty five but Debbie's gonna make
2:10:02them like people are gonna make sport
2:10:04that Tesla's just gotta go know like
2:10:06this will destroy your body and liquify
2:10:08your organs just don't turn so much so
2:10:13you're unimpressed no I'm impressed
2:10:16technically or whatever it just seems
2:10:18like such a weird like I would not have
2:10:20predicted this if you said what do you
2:10:21think it's gonna be like there's no way
2:10:23in hell I would have said oh it's gonna
2:10:25be 250 grand have a six hundred mile
2:10:26range go over 250 miles an hour because
2:10:28none of those specs I
2:10:30I wouldn't even target them like why
2:10:32even target them the base model 0-60 in
2:10:351.9 seconds like oh god I don't and
2:10:39maybe maybe the eel Hans goal is
2:10:42eventually to make a car that will kill
2:10:43him like literally kill him like he'll
2:10:47as he ages and his cars get faster it
2:10:49would just you know press his heart
2:10:51against the back of his ribcage until it
2:10:53explodes and then finally he will have
2:10:54achieved what you know yeah so Marco has
2:10:58an owner what is this does this Rev your
2:11:00engine hahaha or are you kind of
2:11:03whatever about it well when I when I
2:11:05first like was aware that they were
2:11:07teasing a new roadster I thought that
2:11:09might be kind of fun like as a future
2:11:11car but I don't want to pay this amount
2:11:14of money for a car ever like this this
2:11:19is not anything I would get at all your
2:11:22family can fit in the I'm sure very
2:11:24spacious back seats because it does have
2:11:26four seats I'm not sure where those four
2:11:28seats are and all the pictures I can't
2:11:30imagine where
2:11:30they might be but yeah that might be
2:11:32hard getting the car seat back there in
2:11:34the truck yes I this like so I I kind of
2:11:39see where they're going with this I
2:11:41think what you have to realize here is
2:11:43that you know what Tesla can do that
2:11:46almost no one else can do yet is just
2:11:49obscene speed from from a stop like I've
2:11:53seen zero to sixty times with their
2:11:56electric drivetrains that that like
2:11:57that's how they are able to compete with
2:12:00supercars right now is that stat there's
2:12:02a reason why they keep pushing that with
2:12:05the Model S and their there is probably
2:12:08a market of people who are buying the
2:12:11Model S just because it's so damn fast
2:12:14but who don't actually need it to be
2:12:16this big full-size sedan people who
2:12:19actually want something more sporty and
2:12:21small and then hopefully nimble like
2:12:24this right now those people are buying
2:12:26the Model S because that's what they
2:12:27have to buy to get the speed but I think
2:12:31there is probably a market of people who
2:12:32would rather have this and I'm sure John
2:12:35is right that you know the the range
2:12:38suggests this is probably going to be a
2:12:40heavy car we don't know what you know
2:12:43what that means actually how heavy the
2:12:46the reason the range has to be so high
2:12:48is probably because in order to dump out
2:12:51so much current at once to get that
2:12:53insane acceleration it probably needs a
2:12:55ton of battery modules wired up in
2:12:58parallel to be able to dump all that
2:12:59current out and so they probably achieve
2:13:02the range not as a goal in itself but
2:13:05just as the smallest amount of batteries
2:13:07they could put in here to get the
2:13:09simultaneous current out to push those
2:13:11motor so hard to get that acceleration
2:13:13so I'm guessing the the range and the
2:13:17weight of those batteries is actually
2:13:18more of like an annoyance in the design
2:13:20that then a goal yeah but the goal is
2:13:23probably like under two seconds right so
2:13:25if they just said 2.5 seconds instead
2:13:27suddenly the car gets much lighter 2.5
2:13:29seconds is still plenty fast and maybe
2:13:32the price can go down because most of
2:13:33the cost is in the batteries in these
2:13:34cars and it's just everything cascades
2:13:36from like the desire to have these
2:13:38numbers these three numbers up here to
2:13:40be so fantastical and yeah so the range
2:13:42probably wasn't a primary going and
2:13:43maybe is
2:13:44side effect but it's up there with one
2:13:46of the three numbers and top speed like
2:13:48that makes no sense like where are you
2:13:50gonna be able to drive at that fast and
2:13:52the fact that it does have that come out
2:13:54so he makes me wonder exactly how stable
2:13:55it is at that speed because you need a
2:13:58lot of downforce to keep your car from
2:13:59becoming a kite at that speed but if you
2:14:02have a lot of downforce it's very
2:14:03difficult to get above 250 miles an hour
2:14:06so I just yeah probably a lot of weight
2:14:10cars the weights very low you know so
2:14:12like it does have some advantages there
2:14:14but you know I think ultimately you know
2:14:17that there's there's a pretty big
2:14:19portion of the P of the market of people
2:14:22who would buy this kind of car who will
2:14:25never ever ever take it on a track who
2:14:28will never take a turn at very high
2:14:29speed and who don't care how it handles
2:14:33going around a competition track you
2:14:36know they there's a lot of people who
2:14:38buy super cars because they like the way
2:14:42they look like in their neighborhood and
2:14:43on the highway and when they go shopping
2:14:45and people see them like that's a huge
2:14:47part of the market for these things I
2:14:49would say probably a very small
2:14:52percentage of owners ever actually take
2:14:54them on a track I think this falls down
2:14:56in that area too though because it looks
2:14:57less exotic than all of the hyper cars
2:15:00that it is competing with due to its
2:15:01price range I mean it looks fine I don't
2:15:03think it looks bad it looks good but it
2:15:05if you saw that next to a la Ferrari
2:15:07it's clear which one of those looks more
2:15:10like it's more impressive right
2:15:12especially these people who don't know
2:15:14car it's like this looks fine but it's
2:15:17all of the hyper cars have I feel like
2:15:20more aggressive and more exotic styling
2:15:22than this which just looks like a you
2:15:24know a fairly nice sports car like this
2:15:26this looks to me like it should be
2:15:27competing with with the Porsche and BMW
2:15:30equivalents right that are going to be
2:15:33less expensive probably have slightly
2:15:35less performance but we'll look about
2:15:37the same as this like they won't it
2:15:39won't look like the 918 they'll look
2:15:41like oh you know like a a really cool
2:15:43futuristic electric came in it's not
2:15:45exactly what it looks like but you know
2:15:46it's not it doesn't even fulfill I feel
2:15:49like the impress a bunch of teenage boys
2:15:53driving down the road
2:15:55let us they know what it is they know
2:15:57what it is obviously they're impressed
2:15:58but they don't know what it is and I saw
2:15:59it rolling up next to a p1 and laferrari
2:16:02they're all gonna stare at the p1 in a
2:16:03laferrari and this is gonna be looking
2:16:05like like Top Gear whenever they take
2:16:06like an Audi with them along with a
2:16:08bunch of other cars no I don't know man
2:16:11cuz Tesla is their company where's the
2:16:14you know the they know what it is but
2:16:16for non car people you look at it like
2:16:18all the wings of flares this is a very
2:16:20smooth it's a fine looking car but it
2:16:22doesn't look like this even even the let
2:16:26me pull up the Porsche thing you know
2:16:27what I'm talking about even the Porsche
2:16:28one looks more you tree and stuff and
2:16:30yes I think Tesla huh does have brand
2:16:32cachet especially over people who know
2:16:34but for non car people the caches ooh
2:16:38that's the electric one not oh that's
2:16:39the one that does 0-60 in 1.9 seconds
2:16:41another problem they have is that a lot
2:16:43of the market who buys these kind of
2:16:45cars wants them to be really loud this
2:16:50won't be that big a pipe that in just
2:16:52like your amp live up to the outside now
2:16:55let's just have really great recordings
2:16:57there was this hell you could use the
2:17:00same recordings that were in your m5 I
2:17:02mean it would be perfect I pasted a link
2:17:05to the Porsche mission ething I mean it
2:17:08various very similar it's very kind of
2:17:10rounded you know styling cues probably
2:17:13you know more or less derive from Tesla
2:17:14say this this car looks electric like
2:17:16what do you how do you style a car on
2:17:18the outside to make it look electric and
2:17:19I feel like all obviously all the
2:17:22Tesla's look like that and when I look
2:17:23at the Porsche I think oh that looks
2:17:25like I can kind of tell that's electric
2:17:27was it styled differently than their gas
2:17:28tanks and it's not just because it
2:17:29doesn't have big exhaust and a giant
2:17:31grill in the French you know gulping in
2:17:33air or whatever
2:17:34honestly this mission I I don't think as
2:17:36an attractive vehicle and I think the
2:17:38Roadster is I would agree also that John
2:17:43you can't talk about attractive vehicles
2:17:45because you hated the Alfa so we can
2:17:46just move on you know I think that I
2:17:49think the Tesla and this Porsche are
2:17:52yeah they're similar like there are
2:17:55things that annoy me about both of them
2:17:57and this this is not a parking car by
2:18:00the way I think this is like their their
2:18:01concepts of who knows what the real one
2:18:02will look like but I like the front end
2:18:04of this portrait it looks to me it has
2:18:07the family resemblance but it also looks
2:18:09that is you know the same thing with the
2:18:12the roadster it looks it as family
2:18:14resemblance it looks better than all the
2:18:15other Tesla's as it should but it is a
2:18:20little bit not I don't know I was gonna
2:18:23say dumpy it's a little bit awkwardly
2:18:29proportioned it looks a little bit like
2:18:30a not an ugly duckling but it's a little
2:18:33stunted maybe because the wheelbase is
2:18:34short you know like it's or the back
2:18:38overhang is so it just doesn't it feels
2:18:40kind of like a more like that toy car
2:18:43right I mean it looks more like the
2:18:44Lotus Elise the the you know or the the
2:18:47tiny Lotus chassis the original roadster
2:18:51is based on it doesn't look like the big
2:18:53long wide supercar that you would expect
2:18:56based on these performance numbers well
2:18:58they already have a big long white car
2:18:59it's called a Tesla Model S and it's
2:19:01also really freakin fast and like
2:19:03supercar levels of fast it's not low
2:19:05it's not you know what I mean like well
2:19:08they made this to be like a much smaller
2:19:11faster version well it's like it's like
2:19:14a really fast Miata turns out that that
2:19:19would be really fun really fast me
2:19:20thought it would be awesome yeah but
2:19:22that doesn't compete in the same thing
2:19:23it's like when you see again when you
2:19:25see it next to a la Ferrari or p1 those
2:19:26don't look like really fast Miatas they
2:19:28look like big hyper carry things I mean
2:19:31all I get to me like as someone who
2:19:34mostly doesn't pay attention to hyper
2:19:36cars and supercars or any cars for that
2:19:38matter but like I mostly am NOT in that
2:19:40world I I'm mostly unfamiliar with it
2:19:43and I like if you if you put you know
2:19:48all the cars you've mentioned like the
2:19:49Ferraris and the Porsches and the P ones
2:19:52and all the weird things that were
2:19:53always on top gear if you put those in a
2:19:56lineup and took their badges off and you
2:19:58ask me which one was which I probably
2:20:00wouldn't be able to identify any of them
2:20:01I have to imagine that's true of a lot
2:20:04of people including many people who
2:20:06would be buyers of these things you stop
2:20:07being a car person when you have your
2:20:09stick shift and your gasoline engine
2:20:10that's true but but I haven't feeling a
2:20:13lot of potential customers of these
2:20:14kinds of cars might not even recognize
2:20:17things like a p1 if they saw like you
2:20:19are you are because you are not only a
2:20:21car nerd
2:20:22but you are you are also a car nerd who
2:20:24specifically loves supercars and I think
2:20:29most people aren't and including many of
2:20:31the people who buy them like so many
2:20:35people buy them just as a as a money or
2:20:38prestige symbol and or just to have fun
2:20:41you know and and I think that meant for
2:20:45many of those people the the downsides
2:20:48that you are citing of this and the
2:20:50comparisons you're making of it to other
2:20:51supercars just won't apply noticed felt
2:20:54like the Model S never really got its
2:20:58due in all the car magazines and car
2:21:01websites because and maybe it's again
2:21:04because of track performance reasons
2:21:06that like it's not even not even
2:21:09considered when they have these
2:21:10performance tests of like sports sedans
2:21:12it's always like oh it's BMW versus the
2:21:14Alpha and the Alpha is on top this year
2:21:15whatever no one ever includes the Model
2:21:17S and in some respects it's like unfair
2:21:20because it's like oh that will be in the
2:21:21electric test and of course it'll be the
2:21:22best electric car because it's not much
2:21:24competition so you know the Model S
2:21:26versus the Chevy Volt which one
2:21:27obviously liked but when it comes to the
2:21:31sport sedans and like there is a
2:21:33practical reason and it's like look if
2:21:35we brought on the tester with Lewis
2:21:36because it's just too damn heavy
2:21:37right it's never gonna win and all the
2:21:39performance tests that involve turning
2:21:41it's never gonna win so it's not even
2:21:42fair to include it and but the other
2:21:46thing is just such an oddball and I
2:21:48think that will start to change when
2:21:50everybody else essentially comes out
2:21:52with their Tesla competitors and
2:21:54suddenly it will make sense to the test
2:21:58that will be included all these tests
2:21:59and it'll be a more they'll be less bias
2:22:03against it to say oh that's the weird
2:22:04electric one and has such weird
2:22:05trade-offs that we don't even know how
2:22:07to measure it against the other ones
2:22:08it'll just become par for the course and
2:22:09that's where Tesla will really have to
2:22:11prove itself this car specifically based
2:22:15on Tesla's you know the Tesla modifier
2:22:18of like when they say they're gonna make
2:22:20a car at how much - when you'll actually
2:22:21be able to get the car it's conceivable
2:22:24that by the time deliveries start
2:22:27happening for this car that its
2:22:28competition will have arrived and that
2:22:30it will no longer like these these
2:22:33numbers are great and impressive because
2:22:34you can't buy this car now I
2:22:36have no idea what the numbers are gonna
2:22:37be for the BMW Porsche and Mercedes and
2:22:39whatever else full electrics that are
2:22:41all inevitably coming and so unlike the
2:22:47Model S which got to enjoy this time is
2:22:49like the uncontested king of electric
2:22:51cars this may not enjoy that time might
2:22:55this this may arrive at the same time as
2:22:57everybody else and it may be much
2:23:00tougher to be impressive now and that
2:23:02may also mean that all those other cars
2:23:04have exactly the same things that I'm
2:23:05complaining about they're all big and
2:23:07heavy because they have to be because of
2:23:08the battery packs or whatever or it
2:23:09could be that those cars make different
2:23:11trade-offs and those only get to 60 in
2:23:123.2 seconds but they trade that for
2:23:15being much lighter weight and we'll see
2:23:17how that shakes out of you know what
2:23:18kind of things you one don't want or
2:23:20maybe they could be more aggressively
2:23:21styled or half the price or double the
2:23:23price that's where I think it'll be more
2:23:26interesting but right now this looks
2:23:27like this is like a category in unto
2:23:30itself
2:23:31in much the same way that I guess the
2:23:32Model S was in the beginning but unlike
2:23:34the Model S which makes sense both on
2:23:36paper and in reality this car does not
2:23:39yet make sense to me so send me want to
2:23:42test I'll tell you what I think well
2:23:45though insanity that's entered to Casey
2:23:46because he's our car journalist yep I
2:23:48have dibs oh he only does I guess in
2:23:50cars videos is the engine note he's
2:23:55gonna put a microphone next to the
2:23:57tailpipe of this thing and it'll make no
2:23:59noise its wine you have not seen my
2:24:02video but that is slightly just record
2:24:04like the tire noise that's right let's
2:24:07crunch is over gravel