Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

251: Uninstall Your Water Reminder App!

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

2:00:00they expect a certain level of support

2:00:01for that money and I did not want to

2:00:03offer that level of support for the

2:00:05anticipated very low customer volume

2:00:07that this would probably generate and

2:00:09then secondarily I realized like there's

2:00:11actually like strategic benefits to this

2:00:14for overcast where if I supply the

2:00:17encoder and I and and I'm and I control

2:00:20the encoders UI and features for a bunch

2:00:23of popular podcasts and I also control

2:00:25the podcast app then I can do cool

2:00:28features

2:00:29I can implement new features I can I can

2:00:31extend the implementations of current

2:00:33features so for instance one of the

2:00:34features that observant listeners might

2:00:37have noticed in a TP and an overcast

2:00:39over the last couple of months is that

2:00:42I've had the ability to basically create

2:00:45invisible chapters chapters that don't

2:00:48show up in the chapter list but that at

2:00:50a certain time stamp show a certain

2:00:52image or a link or both and but-but-but

2:00:56just are not in the table of contents

2:00:57not in the list of chapters this is part

2:01:01of the mp3 chapter spec there's actually

2:01:02they actually say like oh not every

2:01:04chapter needs to be a member of a table

2:01:05of contents you could for instance show

2:01:07us just show something at a certain time

2:01:09but no apps implemented that both in the

2:01:12encoding or the playing side because I

2:01:15controlled the encoder and the player I

2:01:16implemented that and so now we have this

2:01:19cool feature that we can do with

2:01:20podcasts where you can have invisible

2:01:22chapters so if you don't if you want to

2:01:25show a certain link like right now or a

2:01:26certain picture right now without

2:01:28disrupting the semantic structure of the

2:01:31chapter that you're currently in or if

2:01:33you want to show links or images at

2:01:36certain times without having the rest of

2:01:38the show even have chapters without

2:01:41having a chapter structure for the rest

2:01:43of the show at all you can now do that

2:01:45that's a cool feature and I'm only able

2:01:47to do that feature because I control an

2:01:49encoder and the player and so I realized

2:01:53like the more people who use this

2:01:55encoder the better it works out for

2:01:59overcast and for podcasting as a whole

2:02:00and so I decided you know what because

2:02:04of the combination of those strategic

2:02:05benefits and the fact that any paid

2:02:08income would probably be pretty small

2:02:10and would probably bring a large support

2:02:12burden for that

2:02:13smallness I decided free was the better

2:02:17approach so it's free but it's not just

2:02:21free you have an interesting business

2:02:23model sort of at the bottom of the

2:02:26forecast page at overcast FM / forecast

2:02:29oh yeah I say something along the lines

2:02:31of like you know if you use this and you

2:02:34find it useful for your podcasts I would

2:02:37appreciate if you occasionally promote

2:02:38it overcast and you don't have to do it

2:02:40it's not a requirement and if it's if

2:02:42it's a show where that doesn't make

2:02:43sense like I was thinking of like you

2:02:45look nice today like I know it's it's

2:02:46not really production anymore but like a

2:02:48show like you look nice today

2:02:50or even like Dubai Friday which I kind

2:02:52of use it's like a spiritual successor

2:02:54it doesn't make sense to promote things

2:02:57in a show like that like that doesn't

2:02:58contextually fit it would sound weird so

2:03:02like I don't want you promoting overcast

2:03:04in a show like that but if you have a

2:03:06show which most people do of like at the

2:03:09end you have like oh please

2:03:10you know rate us on iTunes and subscribe

2:03:12and just it sure whenever else occasion

2:03:15we throw an overcast there that's it

2:03:16that's my business model is like if you

2:03:18feel like it and if you can I'd

2:03:20appreciate if you promoted overcast

2:03:21sometimes but you don't have to where

2:03:25are you hiding this application I've

2:03:26read the web page when you linked on

2:03:27Twitter but now mark org slash apps

2:03:30doesn't list it that seems like an

2:03:31oversight yeah I still have a lot of

2:03:33places I need to update this it was kind

2:03:35of a soft launch I was basically launch

2:03:36it on Twitter the overcast site does not

2:03:38link to it from anyway overcast FM /

2:03:45forecast all right know what the icon

2:03:48looks like the icon is is a

2:03:51tongue-in-cheek joke it was created by

2:03:54this wonderful the wonderful forgotten

2:03:57towel the designer who does all of the

2:04:00relay FM artwork I hired him to do this

2:04:02icon and it's so good point nine come on

2:04:06you're better than that

2:04:08what is it at one point I don't know

2:04:12release hi Sierra - don't you know that

2:04:15semver has weird problems with version

2:04:17numbers that begin with zero you don't

2:04:18know that

2:04:19yeah anyway I should I should probably

2:04:23put the icon on the app page

2:04:27downloaded to see the icon so what is

2:04:29the joke you don't get the joke oh it's

2:04:30so good it's a German flag but an F

2:04:34alright yeah I see I thought it was like

2:04:36some sort of I should have known I

2:04:38should some sports thing like it's a

2:04:39sports logo or something I see the

2:04:41German flag colors now yes

2:04:43yeah and a few Germans got it in that

2:04:44and therefore that made it worth it so

2:04:46how do you look at this application and

2:04:49how do you how do you feel about I mean

2:04:52I know this is like a utility and you're

2:04:54like you don't really care that much

2:04:55about the UI it's very utilitarian

2:04:56applications for all the reasons you

2:04:57listed and even some part of the UI you

2:05:00don't even use but it also doesn't look

2:05:03like you spent much time worrying about

2:05:06what the window would look like like you

2:05:08might have if this was gonna be a

2:05:09commercial application like it just kind

2:05:11of is just kind of there like it's not

2:05:13things aren't badly aligned except for

2:05:15maybe a little bit too much space

2:05:16between the buttons and the rest of the

2:05:18thing but it certainly is not not a

2:05:22particularly showy application let's say

2:05:23no it really isn't at all and and I take

2:05:26full ownership of that that this is not

2:05:28a pretty UI this is not a highly

2:05:30polished UI if you do what I said I

2:05:33never do which is if you manually enter

2:05:35chapters it's really unpolished so it

2:05:39this is not you know something that I'm

2:05:42really proud of the UI this to me is a

2:05:45is a highly functional app you know most

2:05:47of what I like and I mentioned on the

2:05:50show a few times before but I also have

2:05:53a tool that helps align double ender

2:05:55files and and remove drift in them this

2:05:58is not that tool and I understand what

2:06:01people think it might be because I

2:06:02talked about that tool before this is a

2:06:04separate tool that tool is an even less

2:06:06polished command line app that has tons

2:06:10of weird bugs edge cases if you don't

2:06:12use it exactly the way I use it and even

2:06:14then sometimes if you do and so that is

2:06:17nowhere near releasable state and it

2:06:19doesn't even have a GUI at all and even

2:06:21the command line version is really not

2:06:22particularly releasable this is a small

2:06:26step above that you know this has a GUI

2:06:28it is not a good interface it is not a

2:06:31polished interface but this is a tool

2:06:33for pro workflows that are like mine

2:06:38even if no one else

2:06:41every uses it it works great for me and

2:06:43so I'm happy with that it's hard to

2:06:45justify spending a lot of time on it

2:06:48like polishing it up when I also am

2:06:50maintaining overcast and having to

2:06:52update that and move that forward on

2:06:53everything so it's probably never gonna

2:06:56be incredibly polished in the UI I just

2:07:00want to make sure that it's really

2:07:01useful and so you know like many Pro

2:07:04Tools its kind of ugly but just

2:07:06functional you should a drawer I

2:07:09actually had a drawer and one of the bin

2:07:11one of the early versions I was thinking

2:07:14like you know it would be like one of

2:07:16the things that was an obvious next step

2:07:19for features for this app is to have a

2:07:21little player and to have it like

2:07:23preview and simulate like you know how

2:07:25the chapters would look in a player and

2:07:27and be able to seek to them and play

2:07:28them and everything to make sure that

2:07:29they're right you gotta bring back the

2:07:31old visualizer from overcast yeah I

2:07:33still have all that code obviously yes

2:07:36and and so if you're gonna add a player

2:07:37to this a drawer is kind of the obvious

2:07:40way to just deprecated that like this

2:07:47year I probably no I mean I wouldn't do

2:07:49it but I was tempted to do it floating

2:07:53brush metal window is the clear way to

2:07:54do that oh yeah definitely

2:07:56textured sorry it's not brush man yes

2:07:58looks like I sink alright so I have two

2:08:01questions for you

2:08:02number one do you have any kind of

2:08:05analytics anywhere just so you know like

2:08:08was this market as small as you thought

2:08:09or have you had you know eleventy

2:08:11billion downloads and turns out you

2:08:13might have miscalculated I can figure

2:08:16this out now or later I don't need to do

2:08:18this like in the app and so I haven't

2:08:20yet in order to distribute this app

2:08:23outside of the App Store which and

2:08:25honestly like I wasn't trying to make

2:08:26some kind of giant political statement

2:08:27by not being in the App Store there was

2:08:29just no need for me to be in the App

2:08:30Store so I wasn't I did I didn't feel

2:08:32that it was worth the the burdens of

2:08:34being in the App Store for no benefit

2:08:36really so I'm not in the App Store so I

2:08:40had to build in distribution

2:08:42functionality I had to build an auto

2:08:44updating and the way you do are updating

2:08:46in Mac apps is through the sparkle

2:08:48framework this how pretty much everyone

2:08:50does it everyone who used a Mac app that

2:08:52that is not from the App Store has seen

2:08:54the

2:08:55little windows and say like you know if

2:08:56it's available do you want to install an

2:08:57app you know ROM me later or skip this

2:09:00version and you click install now and it

2:09:01shows like a little like you know

2:09:02progress bar then it quits and relaunch

2:09:04is the app there's a reason why those

2:09:06are the same across pretty much every

2:09:08app they all use the same framework

2:09:09called sparkle and so the way sparkle

2:09:12works is once a day or whatever when you

2:09:16launch the app it checks a server's RSS

2:09:20feed and it's a special RSS feed that

2:09:22ink that is four versions of the app so

2:09:25for me to distribute this I had to

2:09:27basically build all that and I when I

2:09:29made quitter I built like a very very

2:09:31basic version of that that's just

2:09:32basically all like shell scripts that

2:09:34would generate static files and then

2:09:36upload them to my server for forecast

2:09:38this is an overcast product I wanted

2:09:40this live to live on the overcast

2:09:41servers I wanted to finally do like a

2:09:43little bit better of a job so I kind of

2:09:45made my own crappy little version of

2:09:47iTunes Connect or hit where like I can

2:09:50upload a build and a script on the

2:09:53server reads the build number and the

2:09:55version number out of that build signs

2:09:58it for for sparkle update mechanism like

2:10:01there's a signature involved so signs it

2:10:04for that and then creates like an entry

2:10:07then I can enter release notes in that

2:10:08entry and I can say whether it's

2:10:10released or not so I can actually very

2:10:12easily add a thing to this system that

2:10:15remembers how many people check that RSS

2:10:18feed every day and important reports to

2:10:19me roughly how many users there are or I

2:10:22can just log like how many downloads the

2:10:24file has which I also don't do I

2:10:26probably should be doing that but I'm

2:10:27not

2:10:28but overall the response I've gotten on

2:10:32Twitter so far has been huge it was it's

2:10:36been way bigger than I expected and I

2:10:39think this is really this is really a

2:10:41good sign there's a lot more podcast

2:10:45producers out there that then the people

2:10:48I know I said it isn't so many that I

2:10:52regret really producing it for free be

2:10:55it I think if it wasn't free many of

2:10:56them wouldn't try it because they don't

2:10:57know me and this is just some random

2:10:58thing but because it's free it is

2:11:02spreading pretty wide wider than I

2:11:04expect it at the spread so quickly

2:11:05especially since I'm linking to it from

2:11:07nowhere on this

2:11:07so so yeah so far it's it's going pretty

2:11:11well good and because it's my favorite

2:11:16thing to ask what was the either hardest

2:11:19or crummiest part of the entire process

2:11:21and I think that you're under the radar

2:11:23episode talked about a lot of the like

2:11:26oh the app is done but there's so much

2:11:29more to do and like you were talking

2:11:30about like you're you're Marco connect

2:11:32you know in order your fake iTunes

2:11:34Connect and all that had to be written

2:11:35but but over the entire process from

2:11:38start to finish including all this

2:11:39administrivia you had to do what would

2:11:41you say was the either the hardest or or

2:11:43the most difficult or crummiest part to

2:11:46deal with by far the hardest part of

2:11:49this app is just learning app kit

2:11:53you know it's learning how to make mac

2:11:54apps you know I had made quitter before

2:11:57and I made a couple of little like

2:11:58experimental dumb crap before that but

2:12:01this is the first time that I really

2:12:03have made a Mac app of any kind of

2:12:06substance now the good thing is you know

2:12:10applicant provides a lot of really rich

2:12:12functionality built in so like the

2:12:14entire document model I don't have to

2:12:16worry that much about like windowing

2:12:19opening saving save as stuff like that

2:12:22like a lot of that comes for free and so

2:12:24that's pretty great but the the way that

2:12:27the actual UI works like the way those

2:12:29table views work and the text fields

2:12:31inside the table views and the for

2:12:33matters and the bindings to an array

2:12:35controller all those weird stuff you

2:12:37know to to an iOS developer mainly it

2:12:40might as well be Android like it's so

2:12:42different from the way iOS works that

2:12:45it's it's like starting over from zero

2:12:48so I'm making mac apps as though I'm a

2:12:52complete novice because for the Mac I am

2:12:54that has been the hardest part is that

2:12:57you know I'm used to working at a

2:12:59certain speed and proficiency and and

2:13:02design proficiency on iOS that I just

2:13:05don't have when making mac OS apps so

2:13:07it's that's been a very very slow

2:13:09learning process and it's also just

2:13:10harder on the Mac because the api's are

2:13:13have a lot more legacy because they're

2:13:15much older so the api's are a lot

2:13:17clunkier they have not gotten nearly as

2:13:20much attention in the last

2:13:21Cady's iOS has so they are in many ways

2:13:25a lot harder to use or have a lot of

2:13:27antiquated or clunky things you have to

2:13:29do to use them and the biggest problem

2:13:32with all of it is that because iOS is so

2:13:36incredibly popular and Mac OS

2:13:38development relatively isn't it's very

2:13:40hard to find answers if you have

2:13:42questions for Mac OS development there's

2:13:44not like with iOS you can search

2:13:46anything in under the Sun and you're

2:13:48gonna get a thousand Google results half

2:13:51of them are gonna be really great

2:13:52tutorials like exactly what you have to

2:13:55do or great Stack Overflow answers on

2:13:57exact exactly the problem you're having

2:13:59and a Mac OS that's not the case most of

2:14:02the time most time what you're searching

2:14:03for you will get either nothing helpful

2:14:06or like one ancient mailing list post

2:14:10that you have to like scan through the

2:14:11web version of a man list to find

2:14:13somebody who might maybe be talking

2:14:15about what you're talking about

2:14:16it's it's a very different world I'm

2:14:18just trying to think of an excuse to use

2:14:20this application maybe I should

2:14:21participate cast it's right you're on so

2:14:25many podcasts you drop artwork here okay

2:14:30why are you yelling at me

2:14:32it looks better I know this isn't like

2:14:34me designing Mac OS apps it's it's like

2:14:37the way everyone designs Windows apps

2:14:39it's like I don't know what the hell is

2:14:40good here like just throw something

2:14:42there that looks good using the guide

2:14:45snap things in interface builder or did

2:14:46you not use interface builder for this

2:14:48at all no I use it I use the guide snap

2:14:50things no I mean like I built most of

2:14:52the interface with cocoa bindings just

2:14:53so I wouldn't have to learn a lot of the

2:14:56intricacies of tableviews and then all

2:14:58the experience Mac developer scolded you

2:14:59for it yeah and then every was like oh

2:15:00yeah I don't use cocoa but yeah thanks a

2:15:02lot it is really nice to do certain like

2:15:05and you know cocoa bindings are great

2:15:07for like really simple stuff like like

2:15:08enable disabled states of certain

2:15:11buttons tracking certain you know

2:15:13properties or things being nil or things

2:15:15like that it's there's a lot of value to

2:15:18cocoa bindings but like for me to fix

2:15:21the main problem the app has which is

2:15:22the manual entry of chapters is very

2:15:24clunky and weird that is going to

2:15:28basically require dumping bindings for

2:15:30the tableview and that's going to be a

2:15:31you know I'm not gonna say it's gonna be

2:15:34a huge pain

2:15:35but it's gonna be a decent mount of work

2:15:36at least especially because I'm totally

2:15:39unfamiliar with it if it was I us I

2:15:41could do it in half a day but because

2:15:43it's Mac OS it's gonna take me a lot

2:15:44longer than that and the good thing is

2:15:46that the app has gotten such a strong

2:15:48reception that I'm actually motivated to

2:15:50do things like this to fix weird bugs

2:15:52that that don't affect me personally but

2:15:54I do have to also keep that in check

2:15:56with like this is not my primary job I'm

2:15:59primary job as overcast and I need to

2:16:00make sure that overcast is not going to

2:16:02suffer for me working too much on

2:16:05forecast the good thing is I don't think

2:16:07it's that I don't that's very likely

2:16:08because like I've been working on a

2:16:10forecast for two years and the way I

2:16:12usually work on it is I fix some things

2:16:15I've wanted to fix for a while like

2:16:18ferla over like a week and then I don't

2:16:20touch it for six months and then I spend

2:16:23another week tweaking it up and then I

2:16:25gotta go to the six months not touching

2:16:26it because it pretty much works like it

2:16:28doesn't need a lot of attention

2:16:30so hopefully this this won't be a huge

2:16:33time second I don't think it will how is

2:16:36forecasts choosing where to put its a

2:16:37window when a command man I don't know

2:16:41like I mean so there's that weird like

2:16:44thing interface builder that little like

2:16:46window graphic thing where you say like

2:16:48all right kind of position it kind of in

2:16:49the middle of the window and the left is

2:16:51like there's there's something interface

2:16:52builder that lets you specify that if

2:16:57this was a conscious choice area it does

2:16:59remember it does remember the window

2:17:01position between quits at which I'm

2:17:02assuming you're picking up for free as

2:17:03part of like the savory store

2:17:05I think same thing but if you close all

2:17:07the windows and hit command in a new

2:17:09window appears in a location that I mean

2:17:11it's not random it's always the same

2:17:13place but it's like off-center to the

2:17:15left Cup the middle vertically yeah I

2:17:17saw that in the thing and interface

2:17:19builder that accident I wasn't aware

2:17:21that was a global I figured it would

2:17:22just use the last one and that would be

2:17:24like the very first time it ever made a

2:17:26window it would create it there no no I

2:17:28see that this is the problem like I

2:17:30don't know how to do this unless you

2:17:32look at that's fine and the other thing

2:17:35that surprised me is that you use a Mac

2:17:36every day but like you know when you

2:17:38laid out like the Preferences dialog

2:17:39that's laid out like no preference

2:17:41dialog in any mac app and you use all

2:17:43the time

2:17:44like you see preference dialogues but

2:17:46there's like three preferences

2:17:48I know I know and yet surprisingly laid

2:17:51out in kind of a weird Marco kind of way

2:17:53and the thing is that this is the thing

2:17:58I never sighs just because you use a Mac

2:18:00application all the time doesn't mean

2:18:01you you consciously know like if I'm

2:18:03making a dialog from scratch and I have

2:18:05like two text boxes to two radio buttons

2:18:07and a button how do I put them so it

2:18:09looks like correct right and I had so

2:18:12like this stuff took me so long to try

2:18:15to figure out because I am NOT a Mac

2:18:18developer and like it was very very slow

2:18:22going like again like it's like I was a

2:18:24novice because I for the Mac I am a

2:18:26novice and even using a Mac yes I'm

2:18:30saying you don't think about it if

2:18:31you're not actually dragging the

2:18:32controls out because when you see like a

2:18:34Mac dialog box like it looks more or

2:18:35less right but then you see one doesn't

2:18:37quite look right there's something off

2:18:38about it but you can't quite place it

2:18:39it's like you know what would fix this

2:18:41is just is just because the button on

2:18:43the bottom is centered is it you know

2:18:44what is the problem with that I don't

2:18:46know anyway it's fine

2:18:48I appreciate your on account your icon

2:18:51does look like a Sports logo though I

2:18:52don't know I keep thinking

2:18:52don't know I keep thinking

0:00:00just as a warning hey I need one more

0:00:02stand hour before I go to bed which

0:00:04means we need to end before midnight

0:00:06you can stand while we podcast a

0:00:09standing podcast desk have you gotten

0:00:11the 9 o'clock hour yet uh no stand up

0:00:15just run or stand up I just want that's

0:00:16true that's fair point

0:00:18Oh God how like what like one or two

0:00:20minutes of activity of standing one

0:00:22minute but I gotta like wiggle around

0:00:24and make the watch think that I'm

0:00:26standing you should run in place you can

0:00:28get if you're under your calorie count

0:00:30for the day you run that's true I don't

0:00:31know how am i doing how am i doing let's

0:00:33look are you finishing all three rings I

0:00:34wanted some kind of streak or you just

0:00:36doing Stan Lee are you still a blue ring

0:00:38stud stand is the only thing I really

0:00:41care about I did have a really good

0:00:43streak going for a long time but I'm I'm

0:00:45ever so lightly sick so I've been

0:00:47skipping my morning runs and so

0:00:49basically I'm just a sloth as I I'm

0:00:52realizing my true form as a sloth

0:00:54blue-ringed sloth the blue ring slide

0:00:56that's exactly it

0:00:58how'd you get the exercise man it's a

0:01:00not get the orange ring because I'm out

0:01:02of shape even despite all the running so

0:01:05kidding exercise minutes is easier than

0:01:07you think

0:01:07wait wait wait ok we're good ok we can

0:01:10start you got it you get like a badger

0:01:12and everything everything is all right

0:01:13now are you in the right time zone

0:01:14who knows I in the right country is this

0:01:18what people to in tune in for well in

0:01:22your preferred date format why don't you

0:01:24put the year first so then it like like

0:01:27sorts properly this is a good question

0:01:29which probably won't make the show but

0:01:31if I were editing would make the show

0:01:33and this is why I don't edit by hey the

0:01:37reason you don't do I so what is it ATIS

0:01:398601 is because if you're doing

0:01:42something where in your handling like

0:01:46just in unbelievable amount of files

0:01:48like let's say for the sake of argument

0:01:50thing you were you had all of your

0:01:52pictures that you've ever taken in one

0:01:56folder because you're weird so every

0:01:59single photograph you've ever taken is

0:02:00all in one folder on your one directory

0:02:02if you will well they never called

0:02:04directories on the Mac John way back

0:02:05when or is that just a DOS thing they

0:02:07were not ok so it's a toss thing anyways

0:02:10what did you do calls in directories

0:02:11right oh that's true

0:02:13yes Oh fair enough anyway I digress so

0:02:17if you had out any photo you've ever

0:02:19taken in one in one folder slash

0:02:20directory then absolutely 8601 that bad

0:02:23boy but in my day to day use of a

0:02:26computer easily ninety percent of the

0:02:29time that I'm looking at any date I know

0:02:31by context that it is the current year

0:02:34so why would I put your first that just

0:02:37gets annoying and redundant there are

0:02:39certain circumstances where years should

0:02:41go first but generally speaking the one

0:02:44true way to store a date is day day

0:02:47month month year year because a day is

0:02:51smaller than a month and a month is

0:02:53smaller than a year 8601 is ridiculous

0:02:56and anyone who says otherwise is

0:02:58preposterous it is day month year so

0:03:02unless you are doing machines in which

0:03:04case yes 86 so the the what I'm arguing

0:03:08for which I guess no one I forget is

0:03:10year-month-day correct that's it so on

0:03:13the reason why this is better is that it

0:03:17is completely unambiguous because that

0:03:20no no where ever uses year day month so

0:03:24if you see a four-digit year up front

0:03:26you know that the next number is going

0:03:29to be the month and then I'm sure that

0:03:30is going to be the day in addition to

0:03:32the benefits of it being like you know

0:03:35alphabetically sorted properly in lists

0:03:37that you know that's a side benefit but

0:03:39the the number one argument forward is

0:03:41that it's unambiguous that you can use

0:03:43that format anywhere in the world and

0:03:46people will know how to read it and the

0:03:48chance of error is very very low so that

0:03:51alone should win it but also you know

0:03:53you're a programmer the lexicographical

0:03:55sorting argument should work on you and

0:03:56you know yes you know right now this is

0:03:58the current year guess what it won't be

0:04:00in a month like next month will be a

0:04:02different current year and if you have a

0:04:05format that sorts correctly no matter

0:04:07what year you are in or what year the

0:04:08stuff you're looking at is from that

0:04:11seems like it would be a win so the

0:04:13correct way to write a date in a file

0:04:15name or in an unambiguous context is

0:04:17year-month-day see I I can't I can't

0:04:21disagree with you because you're not

0:04:22you're not you're not wrong but you're

0:04:26also not right

0:04:27because I just don't like it I don't

0:04:29like it I'm the same person who doesn't

0:04:31put a zero in my in my URL slugs

0:04:33so I mean Who am I to talk but to my

0:04:35eyes I mean well I think we can all

0:04:37agree that Americans get it wrong that

0:04:38month/day/year is just preposterous it

0:04:41is truly an utterly stupid you try to

0:04:44make us all agree on cheese here with

0:04:45this cuz I don't agree on G's only you

0:04:48are agreeing on cheese what does that

0:04:50even mean

0:04:51American cheese is delicious yeah

0:04:53month/day/year is not preposterous for

0:04:54filename sure it's preposterous but for

0:04:57like display purposes which is what

0:04:59we're talking about last time you like

0:05:00oh I said myself to Australia so so my

0:05:02watch can display dates to me in that

0:05:04way I don't want this displayed to me in

0:05:06year month day I want them in the dus

0:05:09system in the US system makes sense for

0:05:11display dates because no doesn't it yeah

0:05:13it does

0:05:13month day is all you need to know almost

0:05:16all the time and for disambiguation

0:05:17hanging out on the right hand side

0:05:19because we read from right to left if

0:05:20you need to look over there

0:05:21yeah there's year we read from right to

0:05:23left all right you know what I mean left

0:05:24right no you always go day month year

0:05:28you always go dimo no not in this

0:05:30country and you shouldn't do it that way

0:05:31because not in this country but we're

0:05:33wrong we use Imperial month day month

0:05:36day makes sense month date makes us

0:05:38pretty split purposes not you shouldn't

0:05:39put that in your file name because that

0:05:41would be for the reasons mark are

0:05:42already outlined no this is preposterous

0:05:44John the reason you say month day is

0:05:45right it's just because it's what you're

0:05:46used to

0:05:47no I'm saying there's an argument for it

0:05:50it's not just like random or wrong like

0:05:51there every each one of these formats

0:05:53has its strengths and weaknesses and and

0:05:54saying that we can all agree that Monday

0:05:57is preposterous is saying that there are

0:05:58no advantages to it there are there is

0:06:00there is a sense there is a mnemonic

0:06:01there is a sensible system for why that

0:06:04date works not just because we're used

0:06:06to it which is obviously a big factor

0:06:07but also there are things to recommend

0:06:09it which is I have what I was just

0:06:10explaining so it's not you know

0:06:12completely it's not a completely

0:06:14write-off it's only clearly right often

0:06:16in file names because that would be them

0:06:18I can get behind I can get behind month

0:06:21day when year is not a part of it so

0:06:24March 17 okay fine but that's the thing

0:06:27like you have that disambiguation like

0:06:29it's month day and then in cases where

0:06:31you feel like you need some

0:06:31disambiguation like during the year

0:06:33changeover or if you're doing distant

0:06:35future just in past dates you can throw

0:06:37in the air see but then if it's months a

0:06:39year how does

0:06:40are you a programmer how are you a

0:06:42basically a robot say for human

0:06:44consumption for display purposes not for

0:06:46naming your files not it's still day

0:06:48month here

0:06:49no you're saying month day year only

0:06:50because it's what you're used to by

0:06:52doing what you're doing it's like I do

0:06:53I'm gonna do all my temperatures in

0:06:54Celsius I can have all my conversations

0:06:56in the United States and Celsius right

0:06:58no Celsius is barbarian no but what I'm

0:07:01saying is like in this country it's the

0:07:02way we do it there's massive advantages

0:07:04to doing a month day in this country

0:07:06because everyone else other that way and

0:07:07if you do it the reverse you will

0:07:08confuse other people and potentially

0:07:10also confuse yourself depending on

0:07:12whether you remember if you wrote it or

0:07:13not no I will I will concede that it is

0:07:16unusual in this country however don't

0:07:18you put that barbaric Celsius Celsius

0:07:21nonsense on me don't you even start sir

0:07:24Seifer sorry for the barbarism of

0:07:27Celsius for human temperatures like were

0:07:29you to use it you'd be swimming against

0:07:31the tide in this country

0:07:32sure and you'd have that same confusion

0:07:34you should just use kelvins you don't

0:07:36have that a degree symbol there's

0:07:37problem solved all I'm saying is all I'm

0:07:40saying is I can see an argument for

0:07:44month to a year

0:07:44you're wrong but I can see it but let me

0:07:47make it plain that using Celsius for

0:07:50human felt temperatures for ambient air

0:07:53temperatures and only ambient air

0:07:55temperatures is utterly ridiculous and

0:07:58all of you heathens in Europe who say

0:08:00otherwise are unequivocally wrong look

0:08:03at the scale zero you're it's it's cold

0:08:06ish a hundred you're dead yeah there's

0:08:09that famous gif

0:08:10right it's not even if it's just an

0:08:12image and Fahrenheit can be encoded as

0:08:14it gets zero zero is really really cold

0:08:18100 is really really hot that's all you

0:08:21need to know for ambient air 10 such a

0:08:23millennial is not animated like triple

0:08:32taken I like breaking my brain sorry

0:08:37John

0:08:38I'm sorry we're kids anyway suffice to

0:08:41say we can be I can I can allow an

0:08:44argument that 80 I can allow the 8601

0:08:46argument I think you're wrong I can

0:08:48allow the month/day/year argument I

0:08:49think you're wrong but we should all

0:08:51agree the official ATP stance on Celsius

0:08:54is

0:08:54it is utterly preposterous and wrong for

0:08:57ambient air temperature you want to talk

0:08:58science e things well you should be

0:08:59using Kelvin but fine use Celsius but

0:09:02for ambient air temperature it is wrong

0:09:05in Europe should be ashamed let's move

0:09:07on and let's start with some follow up

0:09:09the route blog post in the dev forums

0:09:12that was the dev forums not the support

0:09:16forums and one or all of us got that

0:09:18backwards last week that was my bed I

0:09:20think we all start off saying the right

0:09:22thing but I very quickly shifted into

0:09:24talking about the support forums so the

0:09:26developer forums you have to be a

0:09:28registered Apple developer to even see

0:09:30them like they're actually authentic

0:09:31kids they're not open to the public they

0:09:32are still pretty noisy and it's also

0:09:35true that they are not a hey Apple come

0:09:37help me with my problem thing like it is

0:09:39other developers talking to other

0:09:40developers and you have you know DTS

0:09:42support incidents or whatever for actual

0:09:45you know you pay money and then Apple

0:09:47can help you with stuff so some of what

0:09:49we said is true but it's important not

0:09:51to confuse the two types of forums the

0:09:54completely wide open public support

0:09:56forums or high volume and very noisy and

0:09:58people talk about all sorts of things

0:10:00dev warms are less so alright and

0:10:02related apparently Gregory Beatty

0:10:04emailed product security at Apple calm

0:10:07about this bug on November 12th do you

0:10:09want to tell us about this yeah it's a

0:10:12lot of people asking about you know

0:10:13should Apple be poring over their forums

0:10:16or having some one or more employees

0:10:19look at all that both the dev forms out

0:10:21of the support forum so they can see

0:10:22these bugs ahead of times and a lot of

0:10:23people saying uh posting us on Twitter

0:10:25isn't the way you're supposed to

0:10:26disclose this blah blah blah what you're

0:10:28supposed to do is email product security

0:10:30the Apple comm and turns out somebody

0:10:32did actually do exactly the right thing

0:10:34which is the email product security

0:10:35Apple to come about this exact bug on

0:10:37November 12th which was a long time ago

0:10:39and I don't know if they just have a big

0:10:42backlog or didn't get to it or knew

0:10:44about it but we're hoping they could

0:10:46just sweep it under the rug until their

0:10:49fix came out in a later update I don't

0:10:51know what the story is but I thought it

0:10:53was interesting that for all the yelling

0:10:55about the right and wrong way to report

0:10:57bugs in the right and wrong way for

0:10:59Apple to know about them this particular

0:11:01bug long before it was widely publicized

0:11:04and long before I was fixed was

0:11:06submitted to Apple

0:11:07in the correct way excellent the

0:11:11quote-unquote correct way because

0:11:12there's some argument that like oh you

0:11:14have to you know like responsible

0:11:17disclosure or whatever where you tell

0:11:18the the source of the bug about it first

0:11:21secretly to give them a chance to fix it

0:11:23and only if they don't fix it after a

0:11:24long long time do you go into public

0:11:26versus quote-unquote irresponsible

0:11:28disclosure where you just tell it to the

0:11:29public before you know at the same time

0:11:31the vendor finds out the public does and

0:11:34there is some debate about what actually

0:11:36is the the best way to do that because

0:11:38obviously if you hear they she's like oh

0:11:40well of course responsible disclosure

0:11:41where you tell the vendor first that's

0:11:43the way to do it because it protects the

0:11:44most people you don't want the bad guys

0:11:45that'll blah blah blah but the the

0:11:47problem with that approach in the past

0:11:48has been the defenders are like oh thank

0:11:50you for telling us we'll fix it when we

0:11:52get to it and then you're sit there

0:11:54waiting go like how long do I have to

0:11:56wait before you know like maybe the bad

0:11:58guys already know about this just

0:11:59because I didn't tell the bad guys

0:12:01doesn't mean they don't just because I

0:12:02discovered it maybe they discovered it

0:12:03now too and so you're waiting come on

0:12:04come on fix the bug fix the bug then you

0:12:06have to know how long do I wait before

0:12:07it's okay for me to say in public like

0:12:09what this thing is you know and there's

0:12:12was an article about it a couple years

0:12:14ago which was about the much more

0:12:16bureaucratic process of submitting

0:12:17things rather than the informal just

0:12:19email Apple policy but I'm not and I'm

0:12:23not entirely sure that the in in this

0:12:26world where information is you know so

0:12:29widely shared and it's so difficult to

0:12:32know what other people know like how

0:12:35long have you know blackhat hackers

0:12:37known about this bug we don't know and

0:12:39they're not going to tell us and you

0:12:43don't want the one thing we have learned

0:12:44from these type of incidents is that

0:12:46widespread publication of a bug gets it

0:12:49fixed really fast and submitting it

0:12:51through the proper channels does not

0:12:53always get it fixed really fast so I'm

0:12:54not quite sure what the right thing to

0:12:56do here is it's not not clear-cut all

0:12:59right do you want to tell us about what

0:13:00Shawn writes about X protect s protect I

0:13:03think is the either the internal or

0:13:05external both names of the malware

0:13:08system that Apple has on Mac OS where

0:13:10they have signatures of malware and they

0:13:12periodically update that behind the

0:13:14scenes without you knowing about it and

0:13:15I think I mentioned in the show like you

0:13:18don't even know that it's happening like

0:13:19they're updating that malware whenever

0:13:21the heck

0:13:21feel like it and you have no choice in

0:13:23the matter oh I think you can actually

0:13:25disable it or whatever but on a default

0:13:26system you are getting these updates

0:13:28whether you like it or not unless you go

0:13:29into the system preferences turn off a

0:13:31little checkbox that says you get these

0:13:33updates but if you're wondering when

0:13:35they happen people are actually keeping

0:13:37track of it and you can look at this

0:13:38website we'll put a link in the show

0:13:40notes it tells you when the updates are

0:13:43and what things they protect against and

0:13:46there's even a little shell script it

0:13:49will tell you the last time it updated

0:13:50on your computer that you can run

0:13:52excellent all right so Ian Williamson

0:13:56writes in and says that someone who's

0:13:58previously had to join all of our

0:14:00company Macs to Active Directory in

0:14:02order to enforce corporate security

0:14:03policies I wanted to confirm that yes it

0:14:05causes a multitude of issues resulting

0:14:07in these spinnings beat beach ball

0:14:08recently though we're starting to

0:14:10disconnect them all and replace that

0:14:11with an apple tool called Enterprise

0:14:13Connect which communicates with AD in a

0:14:14much looser fashion so in case you're

0:14:17not aware because your name is Marco or

0:14:19you don't really have a real job Active

0:14:22Directory is the I'm sure there's a term

0:14:25for is it LDAP I don't even know but

0:14:26it's it's the system by which many many

0:14:29many many corporate environments manage

0:14:31users and it's a Microsoft system and it

0:14:35does not typically play terribly well

0:14:37with Mac's which i think is slightly

0:14:39Omak written like Microsoft's shoulders

0:14:41but is largely on Apple's shoulders and

0:14:45so I know that my IT guy at my work has

0:14:50been complaining and moaning about

0:14:51Apple's implementation of Active

0:14:53Directory particularly recently because

0:14:55I think they might have redone it or

0:14:56something it has caused him no endless

0:14:59amount of woes and he is actively

0:15:02inquiring about this enterprise connect

0:15:04thing that apparently is only given to

0:15:05the coolest of of clients of apples so I

0:15:08don't know if you guys have anything to

0:15:10add on that I'm sure Marco you do so

0:15:11let's start with you I really don't this

0:15:14is an entire world that I know nothing

0:15:17about and I'm very happy to continue

0:15:20knowing nothing about I wish I could do

0:15:22that too but alas I cannot response to

0:15:25me guessing why my computer was like

0:15:27slow to wake and I got beach balls all

0:15:30the time

0:15:31I was attributing to Active Directory

0:15:32mostly because I had previously had a

0:15:34Mac that was not on the Active Directory

0:15:36network and it was just so it was like a

0:15:38normal Mac like a normal it was a

0:15:39desktop too so that also helps waking

0:15:43from sleep and it was immediately ready

0:15:44to go and anyway I was blaming

0:15:46activators

0:15:47I think it was Marco suggested turning

0:15:50off power nap

0:15:51and and hibernate and I did that it did

0:15:53not really make any change as far as I

0:15:57can tell so I think my computer was not

0:15:59hibernating and power nap was not an

0:16:01issue I still you know I left the lid I

0:16:05close the lid walk to my next meeting

0:16:07sit down open the lid and there's a

0:16:09fairly long period of time sometimes a

0:16:11long period time before I can even log

0:16:12in either with touch ID or otherwise I

0:16:14usually give up on touch ID after I put

0:16:16my finger there for a while and nothing

0:16:18has happened and then I type my password

0:16:19nothing also happens like I don't even

0:16:21see the little dots appear on the screen

0:16:22but very often it has registered my

0:16:25typed password and if I just wait

0:16:27including the return key that I hit and

0:16:29if I just wait and wait and eventually

0:16:31it will unlock and then I'll try to do

0:16:32something that I'll get a beach ball so

0:16:33I blame salon active directory and Ian

0:16:36was writing him to talk about this

0:16:37enterprise connect thing which is turn

0:16:39to make a looser coupling between active

0:16:40active directory here's the thing I

0:16:43don't I don't know almost anything about

0:16:45Active Directory other than the fact

0:16:47that I am subjected to it I don't know

0:16:50if my company my company might already

0:16:53be using Enterprise Connect I might be

0:16:54using the good version like for all I

0:16:56know it is worse for people who are not

0:16:58using Enterprise Connect so I really

0:16:59have honestly no way of knowing whether

0:17:01I'm currently using Enterprise Connect

0:17:03or not if I'm not I would love for my

0:17:04company to use it but somehow I don't

0:17:07think that's in the cards because in

0:17:10general like this time and the grand

0:17:12scheme of things complaining that your

0:17:14computer takes a while before you can

0:17:15use it when you open the lid and you

0:17:16know it's not that long it's like you

0:17:18know maybe 20 seconds that is a

0:17:20complaint that is probably falling on

0:17:22deaf ears in the grand scheme of

0:17:23enterprise IT I just kind of wish I

0:17:25didn't have to deal with it we respond

0:17:29to this week by fracture beautiful photo

0:17:31prints directly on glass visit fractured

0:17:34on me and save 15% off your first order

0:17:36with code ATP 17 fracture prints look

0:17:40amazing you know you should get your

0:17:42photos printed sometimes because

0:17:44if you just post them online like most

0:17:46of us do after 12 hours they're off

0:17:48everyone's timelines you'll never see

0:17:49them again but if you get them printed

0:17:51you have an actual artifact that you can

0:17:53hang up in your house or prop up on your

0:17:55desk or even better give it as a gift to

0:17:57someone who will really enjoy it and

0:17:59this could be something traditional like

0:18:00giving grandparents pictures of their

0:18:02grandchildren and their grandpa peas or

0:18:04it can be something fun that you do with

0:18:06your friends like maybe you send each

0:18:07other pictures that you that are inside

0:18:09jokes to you that you find funny or just

0:18:11pictures and fun times you had together

0:18:13family friends co-workers whoever it is

0:18:16they make wonderful gifts and fracture

0:18:18knows this so do a lot of other people

0:18:20so if you want to get it done in time

0:18:22for the holidays please place your

0:18:23orders now because here's the thing

0:18:25every fracture they care a lot about

0:18:27quality so every fracture is handmade by

0:18:30human beings in Gainesville Florida

0:18:32right here right in the US they are a

0:18:34green company operating a carbon-neutral

0:18:36factory they do things very very well

0:18:37but what this means having all this

0:18:39human you know hand involvement here is

0:18:41that the holidays they get backed up

0:18:42sometimes and so it's pretty close to

0:18:45the holidays now they are already

0:18:47starting to get a large volume of orders

0:18:49in if you want a gift in time for the

0:18:51holidays from fracture with which I

0:18:53strongly recommend because these prints

0:18:54look great they go edge to edge they're

0:18:56printed right on glass you don't need to

0:18:58frame them they fit well with any decor

0:19:00they just look awesome modern clean

0:19:03high-quality great colors great contrast

0:19:05so you want these things but you got to

0:19:08place those holiday orders now please

0:19:10don't wait if you want them in front of

0:19:11the holidays place those orders now

0:19:13they are wonderful so check them out

0:19:16today at fractured me and save 15% off

0:19:19your first order with code ATP 17 if

0:19:21they ask you where you came from make

0:19:23sure to tell them you came from our ATP

0:19:25our wonderful podcast here so fractured

0:19:28on me and save 15% off your first order

0:19:30with code ATP 17 thank you so much to

0:19:33fracture for sponsoring our show last

0:19:38week I got just a little bit fired up

0:19:41with regard to the keyboard behavior on

0:19:44iOS I have two pieces of follow-up about

0:19:48this number one I had assumed it was all

0:19:50me and that I'm just inept and I had a

0:19:54tremendous amount of people write in to

0:19:56say no no it's not just you

0:19:58it's become hot garbage now nobody could

0:20:01agree on when this happened a lot of

0:20:04people said the same thing I did which

0:20:05was right around iOS or I'm sorry it was

0:20:08iPhone 6 ish whatever iOS was around

0:20:11that time some people have said no no

0:20:14it's actually with iOS 11 which I

0:20:15disagree with but a lot of people said

0:20:18no no you are not alone I cannot type my

0:20:22type of my phone anymore that being said

0:20:25I have been mildly browbeat by my curly

0:20:28to try G board which is Google's third

0:20:30party keyboard which is pretty good but

0:20:34I haven't trying that and when I am

0:20:36typing rather than swiping I feel like

0:20:40it's not any better which makes me think

0:20:42this is a KC problem not an iOS problem

0:20:45and apparently it's also a tons and tons

0:20:47of listeners problem all at the same

0:20:49time because if I can't type on on the

0:20:53Google keyboard and I can't type on the

0:20:56Apple keyboard then that makes me think

0:20:59I'm the problem or perhaps it was that

0:21:02Apple was uniquely good at figuring out

0:21:05what I meant and auto correcting things

0:21:08or perhaps the the touch targets were

0:21:11uniquely good at being the way I

0:21:14expected them to be and now they're not

0:21:16like somebody had suggested I don't

0:21:18remember who it was that maybe their

0:21:21touch targets got way bigger when

0:21:24they're predicting what you're gonna

0:21:25type so like let's say I'm typing the

0:21:27word there th e re then as so I type th

0:21:31e and the touch target for the letter R

0:21:34because you know Apple thinks oh my

0:21:36Betty's gonna type in R the touch target

0:21:38for R is just mammoth and if I'm trying

0:21:40to type they then maybe I'll get the th

0:21:44er instead does that make any sense it's

0:21:46a very it's very hard to paint this word

0:21:48picture but what I'm driving at is no

0:21:50predictive touch target enlargement is

0:21:52is a possible explanation though that is

0:21:56completely supposition and I have no

0:21:58facts to indicate that's that's true but

0:22:00in any case one way or another I've been

0:22:02trying G board and it's not really

0:22:04working for me so far so it makes me

0:22:06think it's a KC problem but I don't know

0:22:08if you guys have any feedback on this

0:22:09one

0:22:10that means it's the case problems like

0:22:11you said that G board is a totally

0:22:12different keyboard right so that you we

0:22:15have no idea what if how you how you are

0:22:18typing on keyboard but you like you you

0:22:20have the feeling and many many other

0:22:22people who wrote and also have the

0:22:23feeling that they were previously better

0:22:25typing on the Apple keyboard and the

0:22:27weird thing about the feedback like I

0:22:28put it in here is like basically that

0:22:30you're not alone but incredible variance

0:22:33in the people people some people saying

0:22:34it started two years ago it started with

0:22:36iOS 10 yeah it started when I changed to

0:22:39a bigger phone and start when I change

0:22:40to a smaller phone and I don't know if

0:22:42you just tap into some sort of like

0:22:45deterioration of mass deterioration of

0:22:48typing skills because it doesn't seem to

0:22:50be any common thread like not it's not

0:22:52like everyone agreed that iOS 11 hos

0:22:54that there was not that agreement but

0:22:56lots of people really feel like they are

0:22:57now worse at typing than the use maybe

0:22:59they're just all getting older and it's

0:23:01like one of the first places that

0:23:01they're noticing that they're getting

0:23:03older what the only thing I saw that I

0:23:05think could be attributable to software

0:23:10is people complaining about autocorrect

0:23:13going behind them and changing their

0:23:15last three or something nonsensical and

0:23:18I've noticed that as well and I think

0:23:19that is a new software edition where it

0:23:22previously didn't used to like once you

0:23:23moved on from something that be like oh

0:23:25that's fine but now it has like some

0:23:26kind of thing where reconsiders the last

0:23:28five words you've written and says oh I

0:23:30see you were probably trying to work

0:23:32this write this sequence of nonsense

0:23:33five words and it goes back and corrects

0:23:35them and that people find infuriating

0:23:37and if you're getting so do I yep

0:23:39completely agreed I'm glad you brought

0:23:41that up because I'd forgotten about that

0:23:42and yes I've seen that behavior and it

0:23:45is driving me bananas

0:23:47Marco any thoughts about this point move

0:23:49on I mean iOS changes autocorrect

0:23:51behavior in lots of versions like you

0:23:54know I'm sure iOS 10 changed in one way

0:23:56I always loved and changed at different

0:23:57ways now does like the machine learning

0:23:59to predict difference or privacy

0:24:00Corrections that are resulting in really

0:24:03embarrassing bugs like that you know I

0:24:04turning into the a box thing and and the

0:24:07IT from it thing they're gonna work it

0:24:11out you know I hope they do but you know

0:24:13there's definitely changes here but

0:24:15there's been changed before and they've

0:24:16worked it out the only other thing I

0:24:18could think of it might be a factor for

0:24:19you is that you're also on an iPhone 10

0:24:21now because a different physical size

0:24:22than what you were you

0:24:23for the last few years and so that's

0:24:25also probably contributing to just it's

0:24:27different and your body has to get used

0:24:29to it it could be but I mean this has

0:24:31been happening since before the switch

0:24:33that's what I mentioned last week that

0:24:36are you sure it's not the size in case

0:24:37he said well it could be but there are

0:24:39other factors as well and everyone else

0:24:41was said who complained about it was

0:24:43very adamant that no it's not the size

0:24:44except for the few people who said it

0:24:46was the size but yeah it's it's it's

0:24:48difficult in this type of thing because

0:24:50even if it's not machine learning like

0:24:52yeah the machine learning is the type of

0:24:55thing where it's not like a human

0:24:56program the exact set of rules for it to

0:24:58behave it's supposed to learn on its own

0:25:00and improve so it's very difficult to

0:25:01know exactly how its behaving because

0:25:02it's very much data-driven but even in

0:25:05the rules based ones if the rules are

0:25:06complicated enough and changed often

0:25:08enough it still doesn't really help you

0:25:10nail down

0:25:10is this a better system than the one

0:25:13that preceded it did it did our tweak to

0:25:15this set of static rules help or hurt

0:25:17it's kind of I mean I'm not sure how

0:25:20you'd even measure that it's like a

0:25:22satisfaction what typing satisfaction

0:25:24measurement you just use face ID to look

0:25:26at the person's face and see if they're

0:25:27making a face like they just smelled

0:25:30something gross as they're trying to

0:25:31type Wow

0:25:34speaking of smelling something gross

0:25:35tell me about your touch bar you don't

0:25:40smell the Dutch bar but do touch the

0:25:42globe don't smell the globe smell the

0:25:44glove

0:25:44sniff the glove come on chat room help

0:25:46me I'm old and my brain doesn't work I

0:25:48have no idea what you're talking about

0:25:49yeah I noticed I didn't even bother

0:25:51asking you to yeah well that was wise

0:25:53you know as well smell the glove okay

0:25:55thank you I feel a little bit better

0:26:00final tap yeah still not your scene that

0:26:04I should turn it up to 11 what I do yeah

0:26:07there you go you know something's wrong

0:26:08so I just wanted to mark this this point

0:26:12in time where I got my 20 17 touch bar

0:26:15micro whenever it was a couple months

0:26:17ago and I've been using it and I do

0:26:19despite the fact that's mostly in

0:26:20clamshell on my desk want to go to

0:26:22meetings and travel around the office I

0:26:23do use it as an actual laptop and I

0:26:26really feel like I've given the touch

0:26:27bar you know a fair shake despite

0:26:31continuing day the escape button or lack

0:26:34thereof but I finally

0:26:37did something that I've wanted to do

0:26:39since they want but I've been resisting

0:26:40which has changed that preference in the

0:26:43keyboard settings that tells it to like

0:26:47the default setting is allow

0:26:49applications to change the touch bar so

0:26:50that when you're in Safari you see like

0:26:52safaris thumbnails and when you're in

0:26:53mail you see like the mail buttons and

0:26:54all that stuff right there's actually a

0:26:56setting in System Preferences and the

0:26:58keyboard system preference it says don't

0:27:01do that just show me the like the system

0:27:05controls all the time so the function

0:27:07keys and media control and the sound

0:27:10things basically making it like a little

0:27:11static graphical version of the regular

0:27:14keys that are on the MacBook Escape and

0:27:16I read isn't doing that because like

0:27:18look if you're going to give the touch

0:27:19bar a fair shake use it how it's

0:27:21supposed to be used use it in the

0:27:22default settings allow the applications

0:27:24to do all their stuff with it this who

0:27:25knows maybe there's some application

0:27:26that you use that you'll find the touch

0:27:27bar really useful and that was not the

0:27:30case and so and I was finding it

0:27:33distracting as the touch bar like

0:27:34changed from thing to thing as that like

0:27:36command tabbed around and so I just

0:27:38changed it to be static now so now I'm

0:27:40effectively using little pictures of

0:27:42keys that never change and I still wish

0:27:46they were regular keys so I put me down

0:27:47in the category of I can't say I'm an T

0:27:51touch bar because I just don't like

0:27:52laptops and so if I had to buy a laptop

0:27:55it having a touch bar or not probably be

0:27:57the least of my concerns but I didn't

0:28:00find a place for the touch bar in my

0:28:03life I just don't find myself looking at

0:28:06that part of the machine when I'm using

0:28:08it at all and maybe it's just because I

0:28:10have all habits or whatever but it

0:28:11didn't work out for me you were you were

0:28:15talking with some people in one of the

0:28:17slacks that were in together and you

0:28:20were talking about uh it wasn't window

0:28:23shade but I can't think of what it was

0:28:24so let's just call it window shade and

0:28:26you were talking about you know how you

0:28:28still have window shade enabled again it

0:28:30wasn't literally window shade but you

0:28:32have window shade enabled even to this

0:28:33day because you can't live without it

0:28:35this example people gonna think I've run

0:28:37window shade let's be clear I do not

0:28:39well yeah I know but I can't remember

0:28:41what the hell you talking about a

0:28:43classic Mac window layering that's gotta

0:28:45be it right maybe I don't know it

0:28:47doesn't really matter the point of

0:28:48driving it I think it's

0:28:49like window layering if I remember the

0:28:51conversation Greg there's people don't

0:28:52know what that is but anyway I'm pretty

0:28:53sure that's what it was so do you want

0:28:54to briefly describe what that is then

0:28:56that's just when you when you click a

0:28:57window and classic Mac OS any window on

0:29:00the screen if the window belongs to a

0:29:01different application than the frontmost

0:29:03one like an app when it belongs to an

0:29:06application that's not currently the

0:29:07active one

0:29:08it doesn't just bring that window to the

0:29:10front it brings that window and all the

0:29:12other windows owned by that application

0:29:13to the front and that's how I you know

0:29:17use the Mac for 16 years before Mac OS

0:29:1910 came along that way and that's how I

0:29:21like to use it and so I've during the

0:29:25entire life of Mac OS 10 and on Mac OS

0:29:28there have been various utilities that

0:29:29would change the window server behavior

0:29:31to act that way but in the Mac OS 10

0:29:36timeline not only do you get that

0:29:39feature but you also most of the

0:29:42utilities I've use have allowed you to

0:29:43get back the other behavior because

0:29:44maybe you show it behaviors I'm like oh

0:29:46what if I just want wind one window to

0:29:47come to the front that behavior is it's

0:29:49not what I want at all all right it's

0:29:51just a matter of what you prefer because

0:29:52with the tools that I use you're just

0:29:56changing what the default is so for me

0:29:57shift click brings a single window to

0:29:59the front and just regular click blings

0:30:00all the windows have long to that

0:30:02application to the front and some people

0:30:04may like you to reverse where a regular

0:30:06click just brings that one window and

0:30:07then some modifier click brings all the

0:30:09windows or maybe you never want all the

0:30:10windows to come but how I work based on

0:30:13my habits

0:30:13I want the default to be all windows

0:30:15come to the front so I still do that I

0:30:16didn't even know like yes she

0:30:19shift-click doesn't do it by default it

0:30:21doesn't seem but anyway no no is the

0:30:22utility I think I'm using drag thing to

0:30:24do it right now but it's very I think

0:30:26native like the regular Mac out of the

0:30:29box doesn't have a way for you to bring

0:30:31all the windows to the front other than

0:30:32clicking like a dock icon or whatever

0:30:33like there's no modifier click on a

0:30:35window to noon I think in any case the

0:30:38reason I bring all this up is because it

0:30:41struck me hearing you talk about this

0:30:44that you and many other like old-school

0:30:48Mac people created these habits over the

0:30:51course of years that either because your

0:30:55petulantly stubborn or just used to it

0:30:59and probably both to be honest you just

0:31:02can't break yourself of them and

0:31:03I am glad that the list of things that I

0:31:08have that are like that I feel like is

0:31:10pretty small not to be fair Oh a young

0:31:12child yes you think it's the little

0:31:14small because your world hasn't yet

0:31:15changed wait until everyone's in VR and

0:31:18you're gonna be like I insist on using

0:31:19my fingers because I use my fingers for

0:31:21a really long time and you know what and

0:31:23to that end actually the obvious answer

0:31:25to this is no case you still prefer max

0:31:27so you're old and you're you're relying

0:31:28on old technology so your point is fair

0:31:31but it's just it's striking to me how

0:31:33you don't really like new things John I

0:31:37think you're taking the wrong lesson for

0:31:39this lesson this is like what is the

0:31:41advantage for me changing my habits

0:31:43there has to be an advantage that's to

0:31:44be a reason for me to train myself out

0:31:46of doing something that one reason could

0:31:48be that there is literally no way to do

0:31:49it the old way so guess what like hey

0:31:51that's the stick version you have no

0:31:53choice there is no more of that thing so

0:31:55forget about it and whatever but if

0:31:58there is a way to do it it's you know it

0:32:00strips like what is the cost of like

0:32:02enabling this way is it some hack that

0:32:04destroys your system stability is it

0:32:06something that you have to maintain and

0:32:08carefully like upgrade and compile from

0:32:10open source software or is like

0:32:12jailbreaking where every time a new OS

0:32:14comes out you have to get a new

0:32:15jailbreak or whatever like that would be

0:32:17the cost and the benefit is you just get

0:32:18to continue to use your old habits and

0:32:20it's not just habits in the case of

0:32:22winter layering the way I use Windows

0:32:24like my entire system of you know

0:32:26dealing with Windows like this is an

0:32:29important part of it the fact that I can

0:32:30grab a corner of a window that belongs

0:32:32to an application and bring all the

0:32:34windows of that application to the front

0:32:35like I don't have an alternate way to

0:32:38manage windows in that way like if I

0:32:40want to bring all the windows at the

0:32:41front I've got to go down to the dock

0:32:42icon but that that breaks my whole

0:32:45system of arranging windows you know

0:32:46spatially to have to use them as sort of

0:32:49grab handles and to have locality of

0:32:51cursor and not to constantly have to go

0:32:52down to the bottom of the screen or to

0:32:54the right or to the left or whatever so

0:32:56there are benefits to that system and

0:32:59from for this particular feature the

0:33:02drawbacks in terms of system stability

0:33:04or maintenance of a weird program or

0:33:08anything just haven't been there unlike

0:33:10for example window shade which I ran for

0:33:11a little while but eventually it was

0:33:13clear that Apple was never going to add

0:33:15it and you

0:33:15really add that some really nasty hacks

0:33:17to your system to use it so I I

0:33:18abandoned window shade but this I didn't

0:33:21abandon because it is a very minor

0:33:23change very cleanly implemented by

0:33:25multiple products that don't require any

0:33:28hacks to my system whatsoever and so I

0:33:31keep doing it so the lesson is not never

0:33:33learned new things or don't pick up new

0:33:34habit or whatever the lesson is you know

0:33:36don't don't blindly abandon the old for

0:33:40no benefit if there you know if it

0:33:43continues to work for you yeah but the

0:33:45benefit is not having to do any sort of

0:33:47tweaking right like something that Dan

0:33:49Benjamin said years and years and years

0:33:51ago which I I don't a hundred percent

0:33:53agree with but I understand his point

0:33:55was that like one should embrace the

0:33:58operating system defaults because it's

0:34:00that much less tweaking and finagling in

0:34:02messing about you need to do when you

0:34:05get a new machine you know because you

0:34:07can just accept the defaults and move on

0:34:09and to be fair like I have a not

0:34:11insignificant list of software that I

0:34:13considered completely required for me to

0:34:15use a computer for example Alfred for

0:34:18example one password for example Dropbox

0:34:21but in terms of like tweaking the system

0:34:24I don't feel like I'm that particularly

0:34:27needy I I say that because I'm probably

0:34:30more needy than then I realized but I

0:34:32don't think I'm that bad where is it

0:34:35seems like John and maybe this is just

0:34:37your advanced stage maybe it's your

0:34:40advanced experience but the platform but

0:34:42it seems like you're more needy in this

0:34:44department than I am I think I'm using

0:34:46less stuff than you as evidenced by my a

0:34:48nice clean menubar but like but argument

0:34:53only makes sense if you are forced to

0:34:54live in a hotel environment where you

0:34:56have to sit down in front of a fresh

0:34:57computer every day and start your work

0:34:58like we have migration assistant we have

0:35:00upgrade installs of operating systems

0:35:02like this is not an issue at all like I

0:35:04don't spend time setting up my new Macs

0:35:06like for the people who do that maybe

0:35:08it's a fun thing they like to do well I

0:35:09just wanna have a fresh system and reset

0:35:10it up I never reset up a machine from

0:35:12scratch I just I just do an upgrade

0:35:13install or use migration assistant all

0:35:15my stuff is already there and it's not

0:35:17that much stuff and dragged thing I'm

0:35:19running anyway because I like to have a

0:35:21thing on the screen that I can click on

0:35:23the just has applications in it doesn't

0:35:25minimize windows or folders in it so I

0:35:27use that as a separate application

0:35:29separate from its functionality for the

0:35:32window layering but it just happens to

0:35:33also do window layering so I'm getting

0:35:34two for one out of that particular

0:35:35application but no there's not that much

0:35:38stuff I have my favorite applications I

0:35:39run I think it runs zero system hacks of

0:35:43any kind anymore like like literally

0:35:45zero like nothing is a kernel extension

0:35:49or a symbol plug-in or anything like

0:35:51that

0:35:51I don't I run very few things that even

0:35:54display in the menu bar I run favorite

0:35:56applications I like BBEdit I like drag

0:35:59thing which is the plain old application

0:36:01with no weird hacks you know I run slack

0:36:03like we all do whether we like it or not

0:36:05I was gonna say do any of us really run

0:36:07slack or to slack run us like it's it's

0:36:09a yeah it's a it's a fairly clean set up

0:36:12and as we all know it's not like I get

0:36:14new Mac so often that I'm constantly

0:36:16setting my handles everything for me

0:36:19like honestly I don't I don't see any

0:36:21particular advantage in being able to

0:36:22stone and then in front of anybody's

0:36:25random computer and be able to use it

0:36:27comfortably because first of all it's

0:36:29not true for almost anybody like if you

0:36:30sit down there hit command space and

0:36:31spotlight comes up what are you gonna do

0:36:32where's your Alfred now right now like I

0:36:36don't there's the whole point is it

0:36:38except software you can install things

0:36:40on it to make it nicer to use that's why

0:36:42we like Mac's and so I have I attached

0:36:44no benefit to being able to use a stock

0:36:47Mac comfortably so do you have your

0:36:49squirrel direction as natural or the

0:36:51bogus old one I have the old way and

0:36:55again it's a setting that I said once

0:36:57back when they changed that setting like

0:36:58seven years ago I've never touched the

0:37:00setting again because it just migrates

0:37:01from computer to computer like it's you

0:37:03know how long did you try natural

0:37:05scrolling John no not at all like what's

0:37:07the benefit huh Apple added the option

0:37:09for that why would I try it like they

0:37:12you know it's not Apple at the option so

0:37:14I didn't feel like I had to run in the

0:37:15ax it happily takes away the option

0:37:17guess what I'm gonna switch scroll

0:37:18directions because what the hell choice

0:37:19do I have

0:37:19right but they haven't taken it away

0:37:21it's still there and I can I click that

0:37:22checkbox once many many years ago and I

0:37:25never think about it again so Marco are

0:37:28you natural scrolling or no didn't we

0:37:30talk about this recently I thought we

0:37:31did I thought we did but I couldn't

0:37:32remember the I did but Casey tends to

0:37:34forget yeah I'm also old scrolling

0:37:36because for the same reason that

0:37:38basically like

0:37:39I like I tried I tried natural scrolling

0:37:40when that option came out for like a

0:37:42half a day and I was like nope because

0:37:43god you're both sold for the same reason

0:37:46no because for the same reason I was

0:37:47already used to it and there was no

0:37:48pressure to actually change so it's like

0:37:50why should I go through the hassle of

0:37:52relearning this when I don't actually

0:37:53have to and maybe down the road I will

0:37:55have to but when that happens I'll learn

0:37:57it until then I don't want to and do you

0:38:00spend time click on that checkbox lot no

0:38:01you do it once and that's it even if the

0:38:04frequency I buy new max it isn't a big

0:38:06problem we are sponsored this week by

0:38:10aftershocks bone conduction headphones

0:38:12go to ATP aftershocks calm to learn more

0:38:15aftershokz headphones worked by a bone

0:38:17conduction this means small transducers

0:38:19rest in front of your ears not inside or

0:38:21around them like most headphones and

0:38:23they send tiny vibrations through your

0:38:25cheek bones directly to your inner ear

0:38:27totally bypass in your ears themselves

0:38:29so unlike every other kind of headphone

0:38:31bone conduction leave your ears

0:38:32completely open with nothing plugging

0:38:35them up or going around them so this is

0:38:37great first of all for comfort for me at

0:38:39least I can't wear things that go in my

0:38:41ear they just hurt after socks don't

0:38:43have that problem they're also great for

0:38:45exercise and hot weather because they

0:38:47don't have some kind of giant ear cup

0:38:49making your ear all sweaty because

0:38:51there's nothing actually resting on your

0:38:52ear it's just it's a little tiny thing

0:38:54that touches right in front area and

0:38:55they're also ip55 certified for water

0:38:57resistance in case you get really sweaty

0:38:59or it starts raining and the biggest

0:39:01difference is after shocks and this to

0:39:02me is what defines them this is what

0:39:04defines whether they're right for you

0:39:05and this will either sound great or

0:39:07awful to you is that nothing is blocking

0:39:09your ears at all so you hear all the

0:39:12sound from the world around you in

0:39:13addition to what you're listening to so

0:39:15this is actually not so great in like a

0:39:17very loud place like a subway station

0:39:18but it's awesome if you're doing

0:39:20something like taking a walk outside or

0:39:22walking through a city where you need to

0:39:24be able to hear what's around you for

0:39:26practicality or safety reasons they're

0:39:28also great while jogging or while

0:39:29cycling because you really don't want to

0:39:31be listening to anything that's gonna

0:39:32block out sound when you're doing

0:39:34something where the environment around

0:39:35you matters also just around the house

0:39:37or around the office you can take you

0:39:39you can do things like listen to a

0:39:40podcast or take a phone call while also

0:39:43hearing if say your kid upstairs wakes

0:39:46up from their nap or there's a knock on

0:39:47the door and it's the UPS person or

0:39:49something so they're great for all sorts

0:39:50of situations where you want to hear the

0:39:52world around you

0:39:52in addition to what you're listening to

0:39:54the flagship model in the after Sox

0:39:56lineup is the trek titanium and the new

0:39:59Trek's air these are both great options

0:40:01I've had both now I've had a few months

0:40:03with each one and you really can't go

0:40:05wrong with either wanting to be honest

0:40:06the Trek's titanium is a little more

0:40:08pocketable the treks air is a little bit

0:40:11lighter and a little more comfortable so

0:40:13it's really up to you what your

0:40:14priorities are they're both fantastic

0:40:15you can't go wrong both of them have

0:40:17great battery life they have a two year

0:40:19warranty and honestly either one you're

0:40:23pretty you're pretty well off so check

0:40:24it out today at ATP aftershock to calm

0:40:27once again ATP aftershocks calm and you

0:40:30can also use code ATP if you want to a

0:40:32check out thank you very much -

0:40:34aftershocks for sponsoring our show I

0:40:36[Music]

0:40:38wish to move on from these turf wars

0:40:41that I'm starting I and why doesn't

0:40:42somebody tell me about this link about

0:40:44Johnny I've and him hearing our Macbook

0:40:47criticism yeah this there's many been

0:40:50many Johnny I've article recently most

0:40:51of them live just since the paper didn't

0:40:52haven't read but this one had a quote

0:40:54that I wanted to pull it was some

0:40:55someone asking Johnny I have about you

0:40:57know current Apple stuff and he was

0:41:00actually giving answers and so here is a

0:41:02quote from this article which we will

0:41:04link is Johnny I've saying absolutely

0:41:08all of your feelings and feedback around

0:41:10the MacBook you use we couldn't want to

0:41:12listen more and we hear boy do we hear

0:41:15so this is it's not much of a statement

0:41:17but it's merely merely confirmation that

0:41:19if you think Johnny I've created the

0:41:22current line of MacBook and MacBook Pros

0:41:24and thinks they're perfect and has no

0:41:26idea that people have complaints about

0:41:28them that is not the case he pretty

0:41:31emphatically stated basically yes I have

0:41:34heard complaints about this computer and

0:41:36two things one we want to hear your

0:41:39feedback about it it's not like we're

0:41:40saying we made a perfect thing and screw

0:41:41you if you don't like it and two they're

0:41:44definitely hearing it so I think that

0:41:47was refreshing because there's so little

0:41:48communication inside Apple that you

0:41:50could have a bunch of podcasts were a

0:41:52bunch of people ramble on about how it

0:41:55seems like apples not listening to us or

0:41:57might live in a bubble and don't hear

0:41:58the things that we're saying and that is

0:42:00not the case maybe the the Mac Pro

0:42:03roundtable this past spring was one of

0:42:06the most straightforward honest and

0:42:08almost apologetic statements to the

0:42:11public

0:42:12Apple has ever really given you know

0:42:14that was like the only time they've ever

0:42:16kind of done mea culpa I'm like yeah

0:42:18this this product week we kind of messed

0:42:20up and and we're gonna fix it I don't

0:42:22think we're gonna get one of those for

0:42:24the problems of the current generation

0:42:27of MacBook Pro but this is about as

0:42:29close as you can get I think this this

0:42:32statement to me says like you know this

0:42:34was this was not some like off-the-cuff

0:42:36accidental thing that he let slip out

0:42:38like I'm sure he I'm sure he thought

0:42:40about that before he said it and knew

0:42:42what he was saying and I think this is

0:42:44as close as they're going to come to

0:42:46there's been a lot of negative feedback

0:42:48about this generation of laptops and we

0:42:50hear you yeah and we don't know what

0:42:52they're gonna do about it

0:42:53you know it could be that what they do

0:42:55is still doesn't satisfy satisfy some

0:42:57people don't sighs fellas but but you

0:42:59but you can't say at this point that

0:43:00they have their heads in the sand which

0:43:02is the thing that you could have said

0:43:03was they're so they're so bad about

0:43:04giving any sort of transparency to their

0:43:06thinking because all you hear is like

0:43:08the earnings call and about how many of

0:43:09these things they're selling and how

0:43:11their profits that are great and it's

0:43:12like you have this fear that like maybe

0:43:13they think everything is awesome because

0:43:14they're selling more like and their

0:43:16customer satisfaction they ever sold

0:43:23before like all everything looks good

0:43:25you know and you you worry that that

0:43:27your concerns are irrelevant because who

0:43:30cares what you think about the keyboard

0:43:31if tons of people are buying them then

0:43:33you're wrong and Apple should do what

0:43:35sells more Mac's and makes more

0:43:37customers happy right and that is the

0:43:38fear of being marginalized but to hear

0:43:41this direct feedback that you know and

0:43:43boy do we hear like that not only do we

0:43:46oh yeah we hear still be a lot of

0:43:47problems but like that the Johnny I'm in

0:43:49particular is probably getting an earful

0:43:51about like you know slimline keyboards

0:43:53that he insisted on or whatever who

0:43:54knows but the particular details are but

0:43:56I you know I like I like the idea of

0:43:58communicating to the public something

0:44:01that says we acknowledge you and and

0:44:05merely acknowledging doesn't mean we

0:44:08agree with you it doesn't mean you we're

0:44:12going to do what you want but it does

0:44:15say we're not sticking our head in the

0:44:17sand and pretending you don't exist and

0:44:19also that

0:44:19not disregarding you like they could

0:44:21have said like what kind of already said

0:44:23about Apple Park where's another quote

0:44:25that didn't pull from here which is like

0:44:26I don't understand when people complain

0:44:27about Apple park is essentially like we

0:44:29didn't build it for you you don't work

0:44:31for Apple it's for people who work at

0:44:32Apple and we know how people who work at

0:44:34Apple work and you don't so stop

0:44:37complaining about our building like

0:44:38we're not building a house for you

0:44:40that's a different kind of feedback

0:44:41which is like we hear you but we think

0:44:44you are not what is it you don't have

0:44:46standing we hear you but we don't care

0:44:48yeah you don't have standing you're not

0:44:50a party in this conversation like do you

0:44:52work at Apple then maybe we'll listen to

0:44:54you about how much you like the place

0:44:55where you have to work if you work at

0:44:56Apple or not you don't have to visit my

0:44:58old campus do but anyway but if you

0:45:01don't work at Apple you can have your

0:45:02opinions but we're not gonna listen to

0:45:05it because we're building you know the

0:45:07place where Apple employees right now

0:45:08obviously I feel like if someone was

0:45:11more of an apple never thinking to come

0:45:12back with giant said yeah but Apple

0:45:14employees also have complaints about

0:45:16this spaceship and so you could say

0:45:18these are in my complaints I'm really

0:45:19conveying to you the things that I have

0:45:21heard Apple employees tell me you know

0:45:23anonymously or otherwise about how they

0:45:24want to have private offices and blah

0:45:26blah is everything but clearly Johnny

0:45:28was not ready to to accept that feedback

0:45:32about Apple Park but he seems ready to

0:45:35accept the feedback about the laptops

0:45:38the question is what happens next or

0:45:41what has already happened because as we

0:45:42talked about before the timelines on

0:45:43hardware designs are long and for all we

0:45:46know eight months ago they already made

0:45:48a radical right turn about their

0:45:50keyboard plans for the next line of

0:45:51laptops and we'll find out when they're

0:45:53released here's hoping all right

0:45:57ask ATP and we begin with Josh Keegan

0:45:59who writes I grew up a huge book reader

0:46:01my wife did two combined we have three

0:46:03or four bookcases full of paperbacks on

0:46:04hard covers I recently decided that we

0:46:06should get rid of them they seem archaic

0:46:08to me now in the age of e-books my wife

0:46:09disagrees and so they remain do you guys

0:46:11have a lot of books in the house just

0:46:13keeping paper books seem old-fashioned

0:46:14to you let me start by saying having us

0:46:17adjudicate your marital deliberations is

0:46:20probably not a wise choice but that

0:46:22being said I we Aaron and I are both

0:46:26pretty big readers Aaron more so than me

0:46:29I feel like I just don't have time for

0:46:31it probably because I'm spending too

0:46:32much time on Twitter

0:46:33because I'm an idiot but nevertheless I

0:46:35do enjoy reading novels I do quite like

0:46:38reading a physical book if I if I can I

0:46:42prefer physical book over anything else

0:46:44unless I'm travelling but anyways I

0:46:46don't see a problem with books if you

0:46:49don't need the space for anything else I

0:46:50don't know why you would get rid of them

0:46:51but I am NOT one that is deeply bothered

0:46:54by by I'm gonna say clutter although it

0:46:57doesn't sound like it's clutter stuff

0:46:59contained in a books yes stuff thank you

0:47:01so I say my vote is keep them unless you

0:47:04have a reason for that space but that's

0:47:05just me Marco what do you think we have

0:47:08some books there they're in a bookshelf

0:47:10in the living room it's a nice big

0:47:11built-in thing and it would look weird

0:47:13if it was empty and so we keep a whole

0:47:15lot of books there

0:47:16we don't actually really add or remove

0:47:19or use the books there very often and so

0:47:23most of the books just sit there and

0:47:25look pretty

0:47:25but that is a useful function they look

0:47:27pretty on these giant shelves that are

0:47:29built into our house and if they were

0:47:31gone it would be weird so you know like

0:47:33what you just had case like I don't

0:47:34really I don't see any problem with

0:47:36having them there they're not causing

0:47:37any harm they don't have any needs

0:47:39really and there's nothing else that we

0:47:41would put on those shelves

0:47:43at the moment so if that ever changes if

0:47:46we really need the space or if for some

0:47:48reason we want to tear those shelves out

0:47:49of out of the walls then sure I will

0:47:52push to get rid of to get rid of them

0:47:54then but if they're not causing problems

0:47:56for you I don't I don't see why you'd

0:47:59get rid of them I like books I've

0:48:02collected books since I was very young

0:48:04not just for the words on the pages but

0:48:06to the point where I would buy multiple

0:48:08copies of a book I like because I like

0:48:10the books as objects you know special

0:48:12editions of books leather-bound versions

0:48:15of books books with fancy illustrations

0:48:16or shiny covers a really thick paper

0:48:18stock I like books as objects yeah in

0:48:21addition to liking the words in them

0:48:24when I went to work for what was at the

0:48:26time the largest ebook seller in the

0:48:28world back in back in the early days

0:48:30before Amazon even got into the game I

0:48:32got converted to ebooks pretty much

0:48:34wholesale so I prefer to actually read

0:48:38books in electronic form but I still

0:48:40have a huge soft spot for the physical

0:48:43books I would do the things where I

0:48:45would buy the book and read it

0:48:47a book for him but then by the first

0:48:48edition hardcover just to put in the

0:48:50Shelf that I literally never opened so

0:48:54I'm obviously very Pro book my problem

0:48:58is if you if you were like this and you

0:49:00really like books as physical objects

0:49:01and you're not fantastically wealthy

0:49:04eventually you will run out of room to

0:49:06put books our house is essentially

0:49:08overflowing with books most bookshelves

0:49:10double and triple stacked with books in

0:49:12the Attic and so now I've mostly put a

0:49:14moratorium on buying more paper books

0:49:16because I I can't I don't want to

0:49:18displace any books that I have so right

0:49:20now I mostly only by very large

0:49:23beautiful coffee table books filled with

0:49:25illustrations or like those really

0:49:28gigantic awesome making of Star Wars

0:49:30books that had that I have lots of words

0:49:33and illustrations in them that would be

0:49:35difficult to do in electronic form

0:49:37unless someone gives me my 27 inch iPad

0:49:39pro so I am all for physical books but

0:49:43like so many physical objects if you

0:49:45continue down that path you will

0:49:48probably eventually run out of room for

0:49:49books Craig writes

0:49:51why does Apple refused to make desktop

0:49:53back like keyboards gaming keyboards go

0:49:55crazy with any on lights do you think

0:49:56Apple would ever make a desktop keyboard

0:49:58with just enough light to see your keys

0:49:59I have a hard time answering this

0:50:03question because I can touch type and I

0:50:04have been able to for a very long time

0:50:07so this having lights on my keyboard

0:50:10does not really help me I presume that

0:50:13they don't really have any interest in

0:50:15this because it would you know cause the

0:50:17the battery on your magic keyboard to

0:50:18drain even faster and yes I know it's

0:50:20easily rechargeable you don't have to

0:50:22harpoon a turtle to do it but

0:50:24nevertheless you know it's nice not

0:50:25having to plug my keyboard in but once

0:50:27every month or two and so I don't think

0:50:30they will personally but I don't know

0:50:33that's my two cents mark we went to you

0:50:35first last time so John what do you

0:50:36think even if you touch type the reason

0:50:39they have the light of keyboards and

0:50:40laptop is they think people will be

0:50:42using them in dark places and yeah you

0:50:44can touch type but can you touch type

0:50:45the media keys can you touch type the

0:50:47function keys most people can't like

0:50:49it's just too far of a reach and they're

0:50:50just too weird and you casually have to

0:50:51glance and see you know where is you

0:50:54know f7 or where is the pause key or you

0:50:58know or whatever I mean help with these

0:50:59new keyboards you can't even touch that

0:51:00the air

0:51:01keys yeah well you can eventually if you

0:51:04feel for the little divider and the two

0:51:05halves the key is for top and bottom

0:51:07before you go to the left right but

0:51:08anyway it's annoying so I think there is

0:51:11a place for backlighting on keyboards

0:51:12even for touch typists but for desktop

0:51:15keyboards if you're using a desktop

0:51:17keyboard in a dark place that's kind of

0:51:19your choice probably like it's not like

0:51:21a laptop where you may find yourself on

0:51:23a plane where everybody's sleeping or

0:51:24you know in an environment where the

0:51:26lighting is not ideal and like I said

0:51:28you do have the charging difficulty so I

0:51:30don't think Apple's opposed to back of

0:51:32the keyboards I wouldn't expect any neon

0:51:33ones I feel like it's a thing I can see

0:51:37Apple shipping if they could if they

0:51:39could sort out the battery issues they

0:51:42would probably ship it you know just

0:51:44because someone will get it in an idea

0:51:46that it's at its usual thing to have and

0:51:48they can charge a little bit more Ani

0:51:49for the backup version they would do it

0:51:50but honestly unless someone inside Apple

0:51:53is really passionate about this I just

0:51:56see them leaving it as a third party

0:51:57opportunity as they say because they

0:51:59haven't come out with one by now they

0:52:00obviously don't think it's a big need

0:52:02you know using PC gaming keyboards that

0:52:05are full of LEDs as an example is not a

0:52:08good example of why Apple should do this

0:52:10because things are hideous and I think

0:52:13if you if Apple knows those exist which

0:52:15I kind of hope that no one there knows

0:52:16but if they do know they would use that

0:52:18as an argument and why not to make these

0:52:20things but yeah also as you mentioned it

0:52:23would have to be charged you definitely

0:52:24more frequently also I think that the

0:52:27you know the need for word is less on

0:52:29desktops because desktop screens are so

0:52:32much bigger and you keep them so much

0:52:34brighter usually because there's no

0:52:35battery concern but there's a pretty

0:52:37good chance there's the light from the

0:52:38screen lights up the keys enough to show

0:52:41you where the keys are even in a pitch

0:52:42dark room so I think the need for it is

0:52:44significantly lower it does however just

0:52:47look cool like when it's done right like

0:52:48the way apples are done with subtle

0:52:49white lighting and supposed to blue LEDs

0:52:52when done tastefully like that it can

0:52:55look really cool it just looks like a

0:52:56nice luxury product like on the laptops

0:52:58this isn't to say that they should never

0:53:00do it but I don't think they will just

0:53:02because again charging needs the less

0:53:04actual like physical need for it because

0:53:07you can see your keyboard usually more

0:53:08like in desktops and also that the

0:53:12desktop keyboards are just a pretty low

0:53:13priority for Apple

0:53:14they don't really redesign them that

0:53:16often or put that much effort into them

0:53:17so I even you know from that point of

0:53:20view I think it would be very hard to

0:53:22argue that Apple should you know put in

0:53:25the effort to make that happen on a

0:53:28hardware line that they update what

0:53:30every ten years all right and finally

0:53:33pretend stats have rights how does

0:53:36dynamic ad targeting and podcasts work

0:53:38ad companies say they can target

0:53:39listeners but Marco has said that you

0:53:41can only really know how many downloads

0:53:43the mp3 podcast file gets and that's

0:53:45about it when it comes to data save for

0:53:47proprietary apps and then he added this

0:53:50one is for Casey I'm not sure because I

0:53:53feel like I am deeply in ill-equipped

0:53:55answer this question but this sounds

0:53:58like it's two different things to me all

0:54:01rolled into one or maybe I just would

0:54:03like someone Marco I guess to clarify so

0:54:06when I when I hear dynamic in podcasts

0:54:09what I think is there is there are

0:54:12podcasts

0:54:14I don't know servers for lack of a

0:54:15better description or networks where

0:54:17they know that an ad starts at ten

0:54:20minutes and it is two minutes long and

0:54:23they can run an ad in that spot for a

0:54:27week or two and then change that ad to

0:54:30be something else and they'll Rhian code

0:54:31or I'm assuming re-encode the mp3 and

0:54:34for two weeks it'll be the next ad and

0:54:36then so on and so forth but but what

0:54:38proton is talking about is different

0:54:40than that if I'm not mistaken which is

0:54:42Oh Casey is a white male that is in its

0:54:46mid 30s

0:54:47let's give him these ads as opposed to

0:54:50different ones so Marco can you kind of

0:54:52tell me what this is all about yeah the

0:54:54the latter theory you have is the more

0:54:56correct one so the reason the reason

0:55:00this came up and the reason I put it in

0:55:01here as a question I wanted to answer is

0:55:02that a lot of people are starting to

0:55:05hear what are pretty clearly like

0:55:08dynamically on demand inserted ads in

0:55:11usually popular podcasts this past year

0:55:15there have been a lot of major podcasts

0:55:18like from major producers like some of

0:55:20the public radio producers and some of

0:55:22the big networks major producers are now

0:55:24frequently using dynamic ad insertion

0:55:27and what this is is

0:55:28new ads can be inserted on every

0:55:32download on every request that the file

0:55:34gets every you know download request

0:55:37from a client or a web browser can have

0:55:39different ads in it they don't do every

0:55:41encoding they do it by splicing because

0:55:43the mp3 file format is very very easy to

0:55:45splice which might lead into a future

0:55:47topic if we ever get to it the so

0:55:50basically what they do is your download

0:55:53request from your podcast player or your

0:55:55web browser hits they're basically add

0:55:57splicing server and based on your IP

0:56:01address and anything you can glean from

0:56:03your headers which fortunately for a

0:56:06podcast app is pretty minimal but it can

0:56:07at least tell usually which podcast app

0:56:10you're using what kind of device and

0:56:12what OS version it has and you know from

0:56:17your IP address it can derive your

0:56:18approximate location now if it's a big

0:56:23ad network and if it's integrated with

0:56:24web ads then they can also derive other

0:56:27things that things that a web browser

0:56:29can pick up and they can correlate that

0:56:32data based on your IP address and you

0:56:35know and maybe you know maybe some idea

0:56:37of what your phone model is they can

0:56:39then correlate that with other data they

0:56:40have from other sources like maybe

0:56:42Facebook or Twitter or other big ad

0:56:44networks and they can figure out more

0:56:46about you but all the podcast app is

0:56:48providing is whatever whatever the e

0:56:51they would get if you fetched say an

0:56:53image off their servers which is your IP

0:56:55address and a user agent header that's

0:56:58it but that is enough that you that a

0:57:02lot of people report hearing like an ad

0:57:05for a local car dealership in the middle

0:57:07of a podcast from a national provider

0:57:08and that creeps people out and they

0:57:11wonder what's going on a lot of times

0:57:12they blame overcast or they ask me like

0:57:14hey what's this how did this work but

0:57:16yeah this is just these big publishers

0:57:18are now very very frequently using these

0:57:20dynamic ad insertion platforms and the

0:57:22way it works is pretty simple as is it

0:57:24like you know they derive whatever they

0:57:26can from your IP address and the user

0:57:27agent header and then they they throw in

0:57:31an ad and mp3 is a very forgiving and

0:57:34simple format it's very very easy to

0:57:35take chunks out of and splice in so in

0:57:38their CMS is when they produce the shows

0:57:40they just say you

0:57:42you can put an ad at you know these two

0:57:43timestamps in the show the main problem

0:57:47I have with it as as a listener first of

0:57:49all is it's kind of creepy in the ads

0:57:50are pretty oftentimes pretty low value

0:57:52ads because there are things like car

0:57:54dealerships and it just turns into

0:57:55basically what radio ads were which is

0:57:57not something any of us should ever

0:57:58ascribe or aspire to because they're

0:58:00really you know bargain-basement low

0:58:02price low value ads so hopefully that's

0:58:05not the world we're heading towards here

0:58:07but also it causes other problems so for

0:58:10instance the mp3 file format specifies

0:58:14length in about three different ways and

0:58:16a lot of times these these splicing ad

0:58:20platforms don't update them all

0:58:21correctly so it causes weird problems in

0:58:25players like mine where sometimes

0:58:27certain files will say and two minutes

0:58:31early because that's the amount of AD

0:58:33they injected and they forgot to update

0:58:34the duration or their platform didn't do

0:58:35it right or something like that or

0:58:36seeking will be slightly broken or

0:58:38something like that

0:58:39other the other major problem is even if

0:58:41you get past the technical hurdles there

0:58:43because the ads they insert are not

0:58:45consistent lengths it starts to erode

0:58:49the value of timestamp links so you

0:58:51can't for instance say oh you got to

0:58:53hear you know this you know NPR podcast

0:58:56at at 17 minutes because you're the 17

0:59:00minutes when you download the file might

0:59:02be a different part of the file then

0:59:03then what the person who is telling you

0:59:06that had and their copy of the file

0:59:07because if you had ten minutes of ads in

0:59:09yours and they had seven minutes of ads

0:59:11in theirs you're gonna be three minutes

0:59:12off so it arose the value of sharing

0:59:15timestamps and and of referring to

0:59:18timestamps which i think is very

0:59:20damaging to the spread of podcasts but

0:59:23ultimately I don't have any real say in

0:59:26this they're gonna do what they're gonna

0:59:27do they are doing it and I've tried to

0:59:29argue with some of these producers they

0:59:30shouldn't be doing this but they are

0:59:31anyway so oh well this is where we live

0:59:33in now and that's how it works it's it's

0:59:37pretty basic and I wish it didn't work

0:59:39that way but it does the good thing is

0:59:42that it can't ever get as bad as web

0:59:44tracking you know when you fetch a web

0:59:47page your browser executes code on that

0:59:49page is behalf that has any JavaScript

0:59:51embedded which these days it always does

0:59:53so the amount of data that a web

0:59:55Paige can collect about you is way

0:59:58higher than the amount of

0:59:58higher than the amount of

1:00:00data that a podcast publisher can

1:00:01collect about you because when your

1:00:03podcast downloads the file it's just

1:00:05playing a media file it is not executing

1:00:08arbitrary code supplied by the publisher

1:00:10so they can't add any more tracking or

1:00:14collect any more data or observe your

1:00:15behavior any more than a person at this

1:00:18IP address and using this app downloaded

1:00:21this file that's it that's all the

1:00:23information they have again they can

1:00:25correlate that if they know more about

1:00:27that IP address from other sources but

1:00:30as far as the podcast player and that's

1:00:32all it's giving them but the scary thing

1:00:35though is that anything that people

1:00:35don't think about is that they do have a

1:00:38source for correlation they know so much

1:00:39about your IP address because chances

1:00:42are very good in the recent past you

1:00:44have hit a webpage somewhere that has

1:00:46some Facebook embedded widget they got

1:00:48your Facebook cookies and now knows who

1:00:49you are on Facebook and now is know your

1:00:50entire social graph and your first and

1:00:52last name and the last thing you bought

1:00:53from Amazon and like those ad networks

1:00:55that's all they're doing is correlating

1:00:57a user activity across multiple

1:00:59platforms and just synthesizing it into

1:01:01this you know up-to-date knowledge about

1:01:03a particular person or IP address or

1:01:05combination of IP address and user agent

1:01:07and whatever else they can glean from

1:01:09your device like that's that's all these

1:01:11networks do and so even though the

1:01:12podcast player is not revealing is

1:01:14really the minimum it possibly can about

1:01:16you once they go off to the side and

1:01:19look up all the other stuff that's

1:01:21that's how they know like that you're

1:01:22shopping for toilets and it's now it's

1:01:24time to show you a toilet know where you

1:01:25live they they know who your friends are

1:01:28they know you've been shopping for

1:01:29toilets and they're gonna insert the

1:01:30toilet ad and that seems terrifying but

1:01:32it's because of all the rest of the

1:01:34internet particularly the web not

1:01:36because of the podcast player and that's

1:01:37why these things are creepy the idea

1:01:39that they the aggragate and and

1:01:41centralize this knowledge so that

1:01:42there's almost nothing you can do on the

1:01:45internet where they can't figure out who

1:01:46you are through those kinds of

1:01:49correlations so you know I don't know

1:01:52what the solution is but the the

1:01:56relative purity of podcast doesn't

1:01:58actually save us from anything and even

1:01:59you know for stuff like show notes if

1:02:01you can put HTML and show notes it's

1:02:03only a matter of time before one or more

1:02:06podcast applications pre-render the show

1:02:09notes and are not as scrupulous as

1:02:10overcast about allowing what appears and

1:02:12then HTML and

1:02:13sort of take the easy way out and just

1:02:14throw some content from a feed into a

1:02:16web view and that executes and it has a

1:02:18little tracking you know blip and embeds

1:02:21a Facebook widget and runs JavaScript

1:02:23and who knows what else like so the the

1:02:25web has a way of seeping into many

1:02:27different corners of applications and if

1:02:30you're if you're not constantly fighting

1:02:31against that tide is really easy for

1:02:33creepy stuff to sneak into your

1:02:35application we are sponsored this week

1:02:38by Linode my favorite web host go to

1:02:41lynda.com slash ATP to learn more and

1:02:43use code accidental podcast 10 to get a

1:02:46$10 credit Linode is the best web host I

1:02:50have ever used I have trust me a lot of

1:02:53experience with hosted web servers going

1:02:55all the way back to the year 2000 and

1:02:57I've I've hosted literally hundreds of

1:03:00servers and VPS since then at probably

1:03:0410 or 15 different web posts and Linode

1:03:06just kicks their butts it's so much

1:03:08better on so many levels that's why I

1:03:11move everything there now it is just so

1:03:13much more pleasant to use their pricing

1:03:15is incredibly compelling plans start at

1:03:18just $10 a month littered now offers two

1:03:21gigs of RAM at that $10 a month level

1:03:23this is pretty much unheard of in the

1:03:25web hosting industry I mean the

1:03:26resources you get for $10 a month Linode

1:03:28I used to pay hundreds of dollars a

1:03:30month for not that long ago and they

1:03:32have all sorts of great features they

1:03:34have managed backups they have managed

1:03:35load balancers which I use they're

1:03:37wonderful they have managed stats if you

1:03:40want that they have both managed and

1:03:42unmanaged services for your actual

1:03:43Linode themselves so if you need help

1:03:45that's available to you but it's mostly

1:03:47made for unmanaged people who want to

1:03:48run it yourself and they have all sorts

1:03:50of great documentation and tutorials if

1:03:53you just to learn how to run a Linux

1:03:55server if you have any questions

1:03:56in fact chances are if you've ever

1:03:58googled for some kind of answer on how

1:04:00to run a Linux server you've probably

1:04:01come across their help documentation

1:04:02even if you weren't using Linode because

1:04:04that's how good it is that it ranks

1:04:05highly in the search engine because

1:04:06people keep using it Linode stuff is so

1:04:09great it's so easy to use $10 a month

1:04:11gets you two gigs of ram in a virtual

1:04:13server you have full root access you can

1:04:14install whatever you want it's wonderful

1:04:16so check out Linode today I highly

1:04:19recommend it it is the only web host you

1:04:21should be looking at if what you're

1:04:22looking for is straight up web hosting

1:04:24go to lynda.com slash ATP and use

1:04:27accidental podcast 10 to get a $10

1:04:30credit thank you so much to Linode for

1:04:33hosting all of my stuff and supporting

1:04:35this show Thursday night I'm laying in

1:04:42bed and I'm looking at you know Twitter

1:04:43or what have you and I'm starting to see

1:04:47that that people in the future are very

1:04:51perturbed and they're perturbed because

1:04:54apparently some of their phones are

1:04:56endlessly rebooting and I'm starting to

1:04:59see like text messages or slack messages

1:05:01from friends who live in the future and

1:05:03they're saying oh my god something is

1:05:07deeply wrong change your phone's clock

1:05:10what change your phone's clock because

1:05:13once you hit Friday the air I'm sorry

1:05:16once you hit I guess was Friday night it

1:05:18doesn't matter boy one of these days

1:05:20once you hit overnight at like 12:15

1:05:22suddenly your phone will go bananas I

1:05:26think it was Friday night into Saturday

1:05:28that's my bad yeah it was into December

1:05:292nd yep so change your phone Casey

1:05:33either turn off all notifications which

1:05:35there is no big red you know abort

1:05:38switch for notifications so you have to

1:05:40go into every single app and turn them

1:05:41off or change your clocks such that you

1:05:45will never roll over the very early

1:05:48morning of December 2nd which is what I

1:05:50did and that causes a whole new world of

1:05:52problems that are not terribly

1:05:53interesting but it was it was a pain in

1:05:55the butt that was my first question I

1:05:56was gonna ask you when I was going I'm

1:05:58living backwards in time going through

1:06:00your old Twitter pass and seeing that

1:06:02you and lots of other people not just

1:06:04you went with that option like

1:06:07something's wrong we're not quite sure

1:06:08what it is at this point in time but one

1:06:10of the suggested solutions is to set

1:06:11your clock back and a bunch of people

1:06:13who I felt like should know better said

1:06:15I'll do that I'll set my clock back well

1:06:18will will slow down what are my options

1:06:19so I have three options to my mind I can

1:06:23wait and see and potentially end up with

1:06:25a phone that is not bricked but is damn

1:06:28near useless

1:06:29I can pray that I don't get zapped by

1:06:32this bug or I can set my clock back and

1:06:36just deal with some inconveniences yep

1:06:37but both

1:06:38two options are better than setting your

1:06:39clock back like in general I would say

1:06:42like as a computer user rule of thumb

1:06:46this didn't used to be true but has been

1:06:48true for the past I don't know decade or

1:06:50so since SSL

1:06:51yeah probably but but even actually

1:06:54maybe even before don't change the date

1:06:57on your computer because unbeknownst to

1:06:58you tons of things on your computer and

1:07:01especially on your phone don't work if

1:07:04you're if the date your date is not the

1:07:08real date things like iMessage which you

1:07:11probably care about a lot like texting

1:07:12is a very popular application it was

1:07:15very recent all those things there's

1:07:18nothing they will instantly break but

1:07:19they can break websites the popular

1:07:22websites that you use applications that

1:07:25like many many things depend on the date

1:07:27so like the options you listed like you

1:07:30could cross your fingers and hope you

1:07:32could wait for a different thing another

1:07:34one is you could just shut down your

1:07:35phone and wait with your phone turned

1:07:37also at the very least you know like

1:07:39whatever data is on your phone is safe

1:07:41because the thing is off right and then

1:07:42just find out what the duskiness out but

1:07:44you know for a fact that changing the

1:07:46date is gonna mess some things up maybe

1:07:49a few things maybe a lot of things and

1:07:52the main reason I wouldn't changed in

1:07:54this case is in a sort of an unknown

1:07:55type scenario where you don't know what

1:07:57the deal is like is this a big bug is it

1:07:58a little bug what's the fix gonna be is

1:08:00Apple gonna have a thing there's so many

1:08:01unknowns I wouldn't want to add to the

1:08:04noise with date stuffed and this

1:08:06happened with a lot of people who would

1:08:07set their date back where once the bug

1:08:10fix was out they're like oh the they

1:08:12fixed the bug but now I can't FaceTime

1:08:14with people and it was because they had

1:08:15said the date back and now their face ID

1:08:17or whatever was yeah and now they're

1:08:19suffering from the fallout of their

1:08:20attempted fix so it's counterintuitive

1:08:22if you haven't dealt with any of things

1:08:24but perhaps surprisingly changed in the

1:08:27data on your computer or phone can and

1:08:29will cause all sorts of weird problems

1:08:31that are difficult to attribute or

1:08:32diagnose and won't give you nice error

1:08:34messages that say oh you change your

1:08:35date so I would suggest that if that

1:08:38among all the options that you have pick

1:08:41that one last pick that one after you

1:08:44know prefer the option of simply turning

1:08:46off your phone

1:08:46so I disagree I'd also add to the list

1:08:49of problems that it causes

1:08:51will sink bugs and possible data loss

1:08:53with apps that sink yes because a lot of

1:08:55sink engines are the a lot of sing

1:08:57engines try to resolve merges changes

1:09:00and conflicts using time this isn't

1:09:02always the best approach but this is

1:09:03basically how a lot of them do it anyway

1:09:05so sometimes it salts antennas all

1:09:08you've got depending on how the same

1:09:09service works right and there's all

1:09:10sorts of methods to sync but that but

1:09:11using time to help resolve like who

1:09:14changed what lasts and whose version of

1:09:16there should be the authoritative

1:09:16version is a very very common way to do

1:09:19it so if you change your date back not

1:09:22only are you likely to not only be

1:09:24causing a whole bunch of other weird

1:09:25stuff to happen for instance late you've

1:09:28now created like two copies of December

1:09:311st in your computing environment and

1:09:33like so like things can be written to

1:09:36the to the file system or things can be

1:09:38changed or things can be dated in a way

1:09:39that makes them seem like they were

1:09:41sequential in one direction but they

1:09:43were actually sequential in the other

1:09:44direction or like there's so many weird

1:09:47things that can happen this doesn't

1:09:49usually happen with daylight saving time

1:09:50bugs because a that doesn't actually

1:09:51change the underlying unix time value of

1:09:53the computer and be you're normally

1:09:55asleep between 2:00 and 3:00 in the

1:09:56morning so it doesn't usually affect you

1:09:58and here because you're not usually

1:09:59using a computer at that point but

1:10:01changing your clock backed by a whole

1:10:03day gives you a large opportunity to

1:10:07make a whole bunch of changes and and

1:10:09create data and make edits to things and

1:10:11things like that in a way that will very

1:10:14much confuse software and cause weird

1:10:16bugs to happen that you might not

1:10:17immediately see see and I understand

1:10:19that but I think two different comments

1:10:22in the chatroom kind of sum up my

1:10:23opinion psycho Mac head said tons of

1:10:25things not working is better than

1:10:27everything not working and I agree with

1:10:28that because I your guys aren't wrong

1:10:30you're absolutely right but I didn't

1:10:34know at the time and I knew I was about

1:10:36to go to sleep for the evening and cross

1:10:37into this no-man's land I didn't know at

1:10:40the time how bad the error was like I

1:10:42heard it was just a constant respring

1:10:43but I didn't know if it was a constant

1:10:45ray spring every two seconds every two

1:10:48minutes every two hours and I wanted to

1:10:52leave myself the ability to say I don't

1:10:54know do a software update without having

1:10:56to worry about the respring happening

1:10:58every two seconds now as it turns out it

1:11:01was not every two seconds there was

1:11:02every like two or three minutes but I

1:11:03didn't know at the time and

1:11:04I knew I was about to go to sleep but

1:11:07like Marco said data loss like turning

1:11:09your phone off is still the preferable

1:11:11one like until the dust settles because

1:11:13if you had a sink in just now thinks the

1:11:15server-side version is newer than your

1:11:17than your day old data which is actually

1:11:19updated a second ago and it overwrites

1:11:21your locally edited information with

1:11:23stuff from the server like you haven't

1:11:24actually done anything but you've merely

1:11:25changed the date back so it's confused

1:11:27about what the latest stuff is and it

1:11:29brings that like you could have data

1:11:30loss whereas you know the respring thing

1:11:33or even just restarting there was not a

1:11:36mention of data loss in that and either

1:11:37way if you want to avoid it entirely

1:11:38turn your phone turn your phone off shut

1:11:40it down and wait to find out what the

1:11:42deal is that is that is the safest

1:11:44possible default

1:11:45I don't not saying like you know saying

1:11:46like say it's not the end of the world

1:11:48like it's you you made a call and you

1:11:50probably knew the risks better than most

1:11:51people this is mostly for other people

1:11:53who think that changing the date has no

1:11:54risks associated with it you emphasize

1:11:56that it has lots of risks and the

1:11:59fallout from it can ripple through for a

1:12:02long time and can be hard to distinguish

1:12:05problems caused by you changing the date

1:12:07and problems caused by the bug and

1:12:09problems that still linger after the bug

1:12:11is fixed and like I said I think that

1:12:13happened people who change the date had

1:12:15problems when they tried to apply the

1:12:16software update because they had changed

1:12:18the date see but the thing is though we

1:12:21didn't know or at least I didn't know at

1:12:23the time I made this decision what was

1:12:25gonna happen and and I don't think just

1:12:28turning off my phone in Waiting to the

1:12:30next day and trying on another device to

1:12:32see what the fix was that to me is not a

1:12:35valid option because what if for the

1:12:37sake of discussion it was a respring

1:12:38every two seconds what am i how am i

1:12:41going to accomplish anything at that

1:12:43point so my phone goes off and

1:12:45everything's working like I that I mean

1:12:47I turn it off Friday night everything's

1:12:49working Saturday morning I wake up and I

1:12:52turn it on immediately Rae Springs

1:12:55respring respring now what do I do

1:12:57Wow you don't turn on that you don't

1:12:59turn on the phone until you know there's

1:13:00a fix like or do you know what the

1:13:01decision is because like information

1:13:03came out like we don't know what we

1:13:05don't know now but presumably by the

1:13:07next day you wake up and you read here's

1:13:08what the deal is is there fixes they're

1:13:10not effects how bad is the bug what are

1:13:12the possible workarounds was like you

1:13:14know like waiting for more information

1:13:15to come out of century because more

1:13:16information didn't come out in about a

1:13:17day

1:13:17you learn the shape of this bug you

1:13:19learn what what it actually caused you

1:13:21learn multiple workarounds including the

1:13:23date thing and by then people were

1:13:24learning about the problems about having

1:13:26a date bug like just I'm just saying

1:13:27like patience right and you know know

1:13:29your phone's not gonna fix itself when

1:13:31it's turned off but it's also not gonna

1:13:32get worse

1:13:32so like presumably Apple will fix this

1:13:35Apple is not going to allow that if it's

1:13:36a important bug it's not like Apple's

1:13:38gonna be silent for six months about

1:13:39this bug and and no one could turn on

1:13:41their phones like you're not gonna be

1:13:42stuck with the turned off phone forever

1:13:43there will be a fix and the more series

1:13:45is the the the sooner the fix will be so

1:13:47I was like it's like that is the it's

1:13:49perhaps the most annoying option but

1:13:51it's also the most conservative and

1:13:52probably the safest and that's why I

1:13:53would rank it above changing the date

1:13:55because that is that's that's more a

1:13:56risky option it's a way like can I can

1:13:58take can I do something they'll expose

1:14:00me to a small amount of risk but let me

1:14:01not have to let me continue using my

1:14:03phone essentially yeah that's exactly

1:14:05the math I did and to me being able to

1:14:07still use my phone was was worth that

1:14:10risk and I'm not saying that I'm right

1:14:11I'm just saying I stand by the decision

1:14:14I made at the time but anyway as it

1:14:16turns out it was not as dire as I

1:14:18thought and to be honest John's approach

1:14:20in retrospect was the best answer which

1:14:23would have been to turn off your phone

1:14:25just wait it out see what happens and

1:14:27and as I think I said a moment ago it

1:14:30turns out that I guess something with

1:14:32local notifications was causing an error

1:14:35within springboard and springboard is

1:14:37you know the the home screen among other

1:14:38things and so springboard would crash

1:14:40every two or three minutes and this was

1:14:42only if you had an app that used a local

1:14:44notification and if you're not a iOS

1:14:47developer that may not mean a lot to you

1:14:48and so a local notification to a user

1:14:52looks identical in almost every scenario

1:14:54pretty actually every scenario I can

1:14:56think of to a push notification but the

1:14:58difference is rather than coming from an

1:14:59external tear device server

1:15:01it's coming from your phone itself so

1:15:03your phone is either saying maybe in a

1:15:05background process oh I would like to

1:15:07send a you know have a notification show

1:15:09up or perhaps in the case of like dude

1:15:12eue

1:15:12hey this person has asked for a reminder

1:15:15about this thing they want to do at you

1:15:18know nine o'clock in the evening they

1:15:19the person has asked to be reminded that

1:15:22ATP is being recorded and so they'll

1:15:25schedule our reminder locally on the

1:15:27device for nine o'clock on Wednesday

1:15:29evening

1:15:30and those were the things that were

1:15:32causing the problem and by the time I

1:15:33woke up there was actually a fix

1:15:36available and before we talked about

1:15:39what that fix was do we have any other

1:15:40commentary about the bug itself yeah

1:15:45Marcos commentary the best solution

1:15:48obviously is always luck which is what I

1:15:50had because I was way behind in Twitter

1:15:52so like I said I'm reading about the bug

1:15:54like hours and hours like I'm reading

1:15:56hours and hours old tweets so the whole

1:15:57rest of the world knows how it turns out

1:15:59already but I don't know I'm reading you

1:16:01know five hours ago tweets right in like

1:16:02look at this bug and I'm rolling through

1:16:04and and so I'm learning about it in real

1:16:05time on my phone all the while I'm like

1:16:09ant wait see how this turns out is it

1:16:10gonna turn out that my phone is affected

1:16:11by it I'm like well it's not rebooting

1:16:14to springboard constantly right you

1:16:15won't believe what happens next

1:16:17yeah right so basically I lucked out

1:16:19because I guess I don't have any

1:16:20applications that do local notifications

1:16:21so I got to read the story of my present

1:16:26you know backwards in time and that was

1:16:29fun and so yeah if you can rely on luck

1:16:30I highly recommend it my solution was to

1:16:34be a member of multiple slack groups

1:16:36where Casey was also a member because on

1:16:40the night of December 1st when this was

1:16:41all coming out like right before

1:16:42midnight that it was going to start

1:16:44happening

1:16:44Casey posted in every slack that he was

1:16:47in about this horrible thing I was read

1:16:51his slack things backwards in time to

1:16:52him like oh wow Casey really went all

1:16:54out warning the world about this again

1:16:56at the time like I didn't have a whole

1:16:58lot of facts but what I did know was

1:17:01that people in the future and by that I

1:17:03mean in like Australia New Zealand were

1:17:05we're having serious problems with their

1:17:07phones and so these are all like

1:17:08especially in the slacks you know I

1:17:10didn't really saw it sound the alarm too

1:17:12heavily on Twitter but for for my

1:17:14friends and slack I want you guys to be

1:17:17able to react and do something about

1:17:18this be that turn off your phone be it

1:17:20set your clocks whatever the case may be

1:17:21because the initial reports of course

1:17:24because it was a game of telephone where

1:17:25it was oh my god your phone is going to

1:17:27explode if you cross 11 12:15 on

1:17:30Saturday morning and so yes I was

1:17:32spamming everyone but I stand by that as

1:17:35well because I would much rather roles

1:17:37reversed I would much rather see Marco

1:17:39or John spam me in two or three

1:17:41different slacks and say oh god set your

1:17:43clock back

1:17:44and at least be or make a decision you

1:17:46know what I want to do rather than have

1:17:48Marco or John be like I'm sure it's fine

1:17:51well and I appreciate because that's how

1:17:53I heard about it because like so I you

1:17:55know I had like a night like I think I

1:17:56figured I was doing that I was like you

1:17:57know spending time with family so I

1:17:58wasn't browsing the internet I wasn't on

1:18:00Twitter that night and as I mentioned

1:18:02previously I don't have Twitter on my

1:18:03phone anymore so I don't browse to it on

1:18:05my phone so I was getting ready I was I

1:18:06was brushing my teeth and reading my

1:18:07phone because I'm a hopeless technology

1:18:09addicts and I read my phone while I

1:18:10brush my teeth

1:18:11yep you got to hold the toothbrush like

1:18:15straight down so if face ID will

1:18:17recognize you anyway house you can spend

1:18:21two minutes thinking no so anyway so I'm

1:18:28brush my teeth and I started seeing all

1:18:31these messages from you and I started

1:18:32thinking and and by that time I we we

1:18:34had known by that point this was this is

1:18:36like four minutes before midnight but we

1:18:39knew at that point that it had to do

1:18:42with recurring local notifications only

1:18:44so as I'm sitting there brushing my

1:18:46teeth I'm like oh my god wait okay you

1:18:49know it's a quick inventory of like

1:18:50household devices what's gonna be a

1:18:52problem like all right all my stuff's on

1:18:53the beta so I'm fine

1:18:55TIFF oh no her stuff is not on the beta

1:18:57I'm thinking like what's the fastest way

1:18:59I can solve this problem the next four

1:19:01minutes well let's have strongly agreed

1:19:03her phone in bed like you never read

1:19:04Instagram and like go to sleep and I

1:19:06rush I run into a bit out of her hand

1:19:09I read the bedroom with the toothbrush

1:19:11in my mouth uninstall your water

1:19:15reminder app sometime in the next four

1:19:17minutes like what why like just just do

1:19:20it like why because she could tell I was

1:19:24super freaked out about it she had no

1:19:25idea what the hell I was talking about

1:19:26because I realized that like I was

1:19:28thinking like thinking through the what

1:19:30she would have on her phone that would

1:19:32send recurring local notifications she

1:19:34had some kind of like drink more water

1:19:35reminding application so I knew that was

1:19:38a thing and and I like I you know

1:19:40finished with my teeth Reena ran back in

1:19:42and I had like two minutes left I was

1:19:43like I was like are there any other apps

1:19:45that you have on your phone that send

1:19:47you notifications that are not from a

1:19:49big company because the thing is like

1:19:51every other app from a big company is

1:19:53going to send remote push notifications

1:19:56they're never going to use local

1:19:57there oh they're only gonna ever use

1:19:59your road the only apps that really ever

1:20:01use little notifications at all our apps

1:20:04that really need to for some reason like

1:20:06you know reminding apps or alarm apps or

1:20:09to do apps or overcast for that's an

1:20:11implementation detail and so and I knew

1:20:14because it was recurring little

1:20:15notifications like that that cuts out a

1:20:17lot of of potential app types like very

1:20:22few apps use recurring little

1:20:23notifications so that's why they say wow

1:20:27this was a huge problem it was a huge

1:20:29problem only for people who use a

1:20:31relatively small subset of app types so

1:20:34this was actually not nearly as bad as

1:20:37it could have been I mean this was a

1:20:39problem with anybody who had any other

1:20:40any kind of notifications that would've

1:20:41been a much bigger problem than it was

1:20:44and it was pretty big but it could have

1:20:46been way worse so anyway so she got off

1:20:49okay after we're installing the reminder

1:20:50the water reminder app because I was

1:20:53thinking like can I install a beta

1:20:54informant nope did not the profile

1:21:00install it's not gonna work like yes so

1:21:03anyway how do Apple solve this problem

1:21:05KC so as it turns out and we we've kind

1:21:08of put these pieces not the three of us

1:21:10just in general the communities put

1:21:12these pieces together after the fact as

1:21:13it turns out iOS eleven point two is due

1:21:15to come out this week and and I have

1:21:17heard conflicting reports what day of

1:21:18the week it was supposed to come out and

1:21:20it doesn't really matter to be honest

1:21:22but it probably wasn't Friday night at

1:21:23midnight yeah exactly so you know eleven

1:21:28point two was in the hopper so to speak

1:21:30and it was imminently going to be

1:21:31released and so one would assume that it

1:21:35had been heavily Qaid it was pretty much

1:21:38ready to go and they were just waiting

1:21:39to make sure that their servers were you

1:21:41know up to snuff that that you know the

1:21:43the emergency response team was there

1:21:46and ready to act you know when they hit

1:21:48the Go button or whatever that it is

1:21:50that Apple does when they release new

1:21:51you know iOS point release and so if you

1:21:55think about it Apple had a couple of

1:21:57choices right thank you I'm kind of

1:21:59imagining like Johnny I've in a totally

1:22:02white room with a big white button on a

1:22:05perfectly formed wooden Apple Store

1:22:07table

1:22:09go it wouldn't even be labeled though I

1:22:11know he hates buttons it would just be a

1:22:13spot on the table yeah exactly that he

1:22:16would have to just apply some pressure

1:22:17to and it would be a forced click button

1:22:19he just gives it a meaningful look he

1:22:20doesn't but anyway the point is that

1:22:25that you know Apple all kidding aside it

1:22:28basically two choices they could either

1:22:29put together a fix just for this issue

1:22:32and try to like emergency cue a test it

1:22:35and try to put together an emergency

1:22:37patch and start shipping this patch or

1:22:39it was it was very quickly obvious of

1:22:42people on the beta we're not having this

1:22:43problem like Marco had said and so they

1:22:46could alternatively just say you know

1:22:47what the hell with it

1:22:4911.2 wasn't supposed to go out like

1:22:51Marco said at midnight Eastern on a

1:22:54Friday evening and gosh knows that if

1:22:56you've ever done anything with software

1:22:58you never want to deploy on a Friday

1:23:00night because that means you're really

1:23:02on a Friday at all because that means

1:23:03your weekend is all but assured Lee

1:23:05screwed but at this point they were

1:23:06screwed anyway so we why not and what

1:23:09they ended up doing was releasing 11.2

1:23:11early which I think was the smart choice

1:23:15I mean it's easy for me to armchair

1:23:16quarterback but hey that's what we do it

1:23:19to me I think that was the best choice

1:23:20they could have made but it certainly

1:23:22had its own set of penalties in in no

1:23:26small part because say you know the

1:23:28release notes for example if I'm not

1:23:30mistaken mentioned Apple what does it

1:23:32Apple pay cash is that what it's called

1:23:34basically peer-to-peer Apple pay Apple

1:23:36venmo Apple venmo slash Apple Square

1:23:39cash well anyways so that was mentioned

1:23:41in the release notes and then all of us

1:23:42including me went to go find it and it

1:23:44wasn't there and we were like well what

1:23:45what's going on here and as it turns out

1:23:47there was a server side switch they

1:23:48needed to flip which I think they did

1:23:50Monday or it was early this week

1:23:52regardless but you know it was it was

1:23:54clear that this was not their intention

1:23:56but given the the hand they had in front

1:23:58of him I think this was the best

1:23:59decision they could have made I mean

1:24:01Marco do you would you say that you

1:24:03would do the same thing in their shoes I

1:24:04mean I don't really have enough

1:24:05information to know what their options

1:24:06really were here but probably I mean see

1:24:09it like I was using the 11.2 beta for a

1:24:11while and it was seemed fine to me but

1:24:13that's you know that's just one person

1:24:15if it was truly just like a couple of

1:24:17days from release then yeah that seems

1:24:20like a totally fine solution

1:24:22the problem is is embarrassing the the

1:24:24fact that they keep having problems with

1:24:27iPhones with related to date and time is

1:24:30concerning for things like you know

1:24:33alarms not going off in certain days for

1:24:34people and weird daylight savings bugs

1:24:37like it like I am definitely concerned

1:24:39the number of Prague's that iOS

1:24:43specifically has about local local date

1:24:47and time issues I thought we were done

1:24:49with those a few years ago and

1:24:50apparently we're not and that I think

1:24:52could use some investigation on Apple's

1:24:56part maybe maybe some auditing and some

1:24:58you know really making sure that code is

1:25:00solid because we shouldn't be having

1:25:02those kinds of bugs in 2017

1:25:03you know Apple's better than that but as

1:25:06for the actual fix they did to fix this

1:25:08horribly embarrassing bug yeah it seems

1:25:11fine you know and I should also mention

1:25:13there was something going on with Mac OS

1:25:15as well and I never really got a clear

1:25:18read on what it was but like you guys

1:25:20heard that month thirteen is that about

1:25:24thirteen tell me again why I should

1:25:27update the High Sierra this one thirteen

1:25:29is it is it in bounds or is it out of

1:25:32bounds I forget you'll never know no but

1:25:34it wasn't even the month thirteen thing

1:25:35there's something to do with like

1:25:37spotlight I think or something like that

1:25:38I forget exactly what it was but there

1:25:40was a a not widespread but medium spread

1:25:44I don't even know if that's really a

1:25:45phrase but a medium spread bug that was

1:25:48affecting I believe High Sierras well

1:25:51and I can't remember what the hell it

1:25:52was but it was something to do with like

1:25:54your menu bar or spotlight or something

1:25:55like that I haven't seen that one I mean

1:25:59I'm afraid to look at my console for the

1:26:01month thirteen messages but still going

1:26:04on isn't it did ten point whatever point

1:26:06to fix it I would I looked at the

1:26:08release notes for briefly and I thought

1:26:10the very first item would be month

1:26:11thirteen is now no longer balanced we've

1:26:14added a new month thirteen to the

1:26:15calendar to fix this bug so far has to

1:26:19find like the the code in corefoundation

1:26:20that runs this assertion that is

1:26:23printing printing this message and like

1:26:25I know and then the grand scheme of all

1:26:27things we talked about with the you know

1:26:29springboard crashing repeatedly and you

1:26:32know the whatever the the problem was

1:26:35last week that I've already forgot

1:26:36like 1:13 being out of bounds but to be

1:26:38clear what we're talking about is a

1:26:39message that appears in the console on

1:26:41your Mac that repeatedly tells you that

1:26:44month 13 is out of bounds like multiple

1:26:45times per second like slowing down your

1:26:47Mac yeah it depends on where it's coming

1:26:50from what applications you have running

1:26:52but but it sounds like you know whatever

1:26:54your Mac still works you just got a

1:26:55bunch of noise in the console not a big

1:26:56deal but something about the sort of the

1:27:00you know the hygienic programmer in me

1:27:03finds that one all the more bothersome

1:27:06because it hasn't been fixed and sort of

1:27:08knowing that your computer is as

1:27:10emitting 10 or 20 of this identical log

1:27:14message per second every second every

1:27:16day that you're using it and Apple

1:27:19hasn't fixed it

1:27:19kind of like gnaws at the back of my

1:27:21mind like it is it doesn't it doesn't

1:27:24sit well with me regardless of the

1:27:27actual implications like no they use a

1:27:28database format and it coalesces

1:27:31duplicates and really it's just

1:27:32incrementing a counter and you're not

1:27:34actually storing duplicates in Bob a Bob

1:27:35like whatever the I don't care about the

1:27:37technical things like it's just you know

1:27:39and maybe also as a server-side para

1:27:41programmer noise and logs is bad noise

1:27:44and logs rent you from seeing signal

1:27:46stop spewing stuff to logs like it's the

1:27:49thing that makes you go around the

1:27:50company with the big virtual stick and

1:27:51about people I stopped stop filling the

1:27:55logs with crap if you're debugging fine

1:27:56debug and then turn off your log

1:27:58messages like keep the logs clean so I

1:28:01really hope that my 13 well no longer be

1:28:04out of bounds yeah that's that's the one

1:28:07big thing like that when they Channing

1:28:08introduces new login framework I think

1:28:10it was what last year or the year before

1:28:11when they introduced the new logging

1:28:13framework like they tad like oh it's so

1:28:15lightweight you can just leave you know

1:28:17incredibly verbose logging enable at the

1:28:19time and the system will handle it

1:28:20because like oh it's so efficient and

1:28:22like if no one's looking if no one's

1:28:24looking at the log it doesn't get

1:28:25written anywhere or something like that

1:28:26like there's all sorts of details that

1:28:28make it super efficient but like yeah

1:28:29I'm with you like like first of all

1:28:31looking at console or even the Xcode

1:28:33developer log is nearly useless since

1:28:37this change because the the apparent

1:28:40message with an apple when when they did

1:28:41this was now that we've made logging

1:28:43really cheap we can just dump diarrhea

1:28:46in the logs constantly from everything

1:28:48and it makes it

1:28:50really hard to actually look at the logs

1:28:53when you're having a problem and find

1:28:55anything useful at all or to run

1:28:57anything on a tethered device with Xcode

1:29:00and even if you do the whole like you

1:29:01know OS whatever iOS disabled mode

1:29:04disabled whatever that macro is you're

1:29:06supposed to set doesn't actually work it

1:29:07doesn't actually do want and it's just

1:29:10like the every part of iOS and Mac OS

1:29:13now just dumps so much crap to the log

1:29:15that it has made the log useless and not

1:29:19only for developers but also just for

1:29:20users like sometimes some form answer

1:29:22will be like hey go look at console dot

1:29:24app for the for something like this and

1:29:26that might tell us an answer

1:29:28III really strongly disagree with the

1:29:32Apple you know way of doing this now

1:29:34we're logging tons of unnecessary crap

1:29:36all the time is considered ok because

1:29:38they made logs really cheap yeah and and

1:29:41for the developer it's like I think is

1:29:42actually more reasonable to say oh just

1:29:45whitelist your application like use our

1:29:46filtering features to just see logs from

1:29:49your applications but for for users like

1:29:52console has historically been granted

1:29:53one of the last resorts but like when

1:29:55you're really desperate to see what the

1:29:57deal is you will probably find yourself

1:30:01launching console and saying maybe

1:30:03there's a messaging console that will

1:30:04let me know what the problem is and in

1:30:07that case you can't run any filters

1:30:09because you don't know what you want to

1:30:10filter you don't know what application

1:30:12or what part of the system you don't

1:30:13know what to filter for you can't

1:30:14whitelist you could selectively

1:30:16blacklist if you had eliminated sources

1:30:18of things but like sort of an overview

1:30:21of like hey is anything weird going on

1:30:23in my system that's why in server-side

1:30:25application is that the general best

1:30:27practices did not have noisy laws to

1:30:29have at least one log that it basically

1:30:30when everything's okay then the log is

1:30:33relatively quiet or there's only one

1:30:35kind of log message there we're like in

1:30:37some way where you could say look if

1:30:38anything other than this normal state

1:30:40appears here we have a problem and the

1:30:42normal state may be total quiet so which

1:30:44would mean that every single line to

1:30:46this log means there's a problem or the

1:30:48normal state could mean log messages of

1:30:50this type are fine but if you see any

1:30:51other kind of log message that that's an

1:30:53indicative of a problem that's what you

1:30:55need if you just have a big dumping

1:30:56ground no matter how good your filtering

1:30:58facilities are no matter how good you

1:30:59are keeping up your whitelist or

1:31:00blacklist of filtering it's very

1:31:02difficult to

1:31:03especially in the case of an emergency

1:31:05hat you have no place to look anymore

1:31:07where a human being can look at it

1:31:09inside it's not like normal to you it's

1:31:10like I don't know it's just a bunch of

1:31:11butts just a bunch of crap it's is it

1:31:13more crap or less crap than we were

1:31:15before and then finally like month

1:31:17thirteen of that bounce it represents

1:31:19some kind of error is that a programming

1:31:20error is it a data error whatever the

1:31:22source of the error is is an assertion

1:31:23that's failing and we all agree that

1:31:25there is no month thirteen in the

1:31:27calendar that we all use

1:31:28so something somewhere is wrong cuz

1:31:29someone should fix it so we don't have

1:31:31to see that message twenty times a

1:31:32second should this be a long message

1:31:34shouldn't this be an assertion shouldn't

1:31:35it crash like that's you know by the way

1:31:38also for the record I I have ten

1:31:40thirteen two on my laptop I just booted

1:31:43it up this looked it I'm still getting

1:31:45month 13 is out of bounds errors in the

1:31:46console so 10 13 2 does not fix this bug

1:31:49it also doesn't fix my font smoothing

1:31:51bug because the unchecking the use font

1:31:54smoothing when available box still is

1:31:56completely broken now

1:31:58what three months after the release of

1:32:00this OS to major point releases in if

1:32:02you if you have that box off everything

1:32:05is still completely broken

1:32:06so thanks Apple I why am I being pushed

1:32:09so hard to use this OS why is this being

1:32:10pushed forcibly through my App Store

1:32:12like well it promote it when it's ready

1:32:15it's not ready sorry that month 13 thing

1:32:20I don't think crashing is probably

1:32:21perfect is this of a date if it's a data

1:32:22driven error the data is bad the code is

1:32:24not the code is just telling you the

1:32:25video is bad and in the verbose way in

1:32:28the tradition that you just said of like

1:32:29oh if you find something wrong and

1:32:30you're not going to throw an exception

1:32:32just log it so you'll know about it

1:32:34but if it happens 20 times a second

1:32:36that's not great so I'm assuming this is

1:32:38some sort of data bug where some piece

1:32:40of data somewhere either from the

1:32:41network or on the system has a bad date

1:32:43in it or some bad date math added one to

1:32:46a 12 and got a 13 not a reason for the

1:32:50coding question to throw an exception in

1:32:52that case because it could be inside

1:32:54some important subsystem that doesn't

1:32:55want to like take down the whole system

1:32:56just because it got some bad data or

1:32:57whatever I'm just saying find where the

1:32:59bug is and fix it and obviously it is

1:33:01less urgent than everything else we've

1:33:02talked about but you know the

1:33:05irrationally

1:33:06like I said hygiene wise for me if it

1:33:08feels mentally urgent to me that this

1:33:10stop being on in the console so not a

1:33:16good week for Apple

1:33:17streak between the root bug in this bug

1:33:20it's just not not good but not actually

1:33:23I'm gonna say not you know so it's not

1:33:25good lots of bugs but not actually that

1:33:26bad either because in the grand scheme

1:33:28of things Apple like either through luck

1:33:30partially through luck but also

1:33:32partially through things working the

1:33:34ways they're supposed to Apple got fixes

1:33:36out in a timely manner the fix is more

1:33:40or less work plus or minus some minor

1:33:42fixes to the fixes the user base in

1:33:45general you know could have been it

1:33:48could have been much worse but it wasn't

1:33:50I mean the reasons marco said local

1:33:51notifications only the fact that the

1:33:54fixes came out pretty quickly I'm not

1:33:56sure if any of these things even made it

1:33:57out of the little tech nerd circle onto

1:33:59like the evening news or whatever into

1:34:01the wider world like was their front

1:34:03page New York Times story about

1:34:04everybody's iPhones bricking like that

1:34:05would be worse right so it was

1:34:07unfortunate and there was definitely

1:34:09some bad luck involved but there was

1:34:10also some good luck and I think Apple

1:34:12more or less functioned the way it's

1:34:14supposed to oh you've got an emergency

1:34:16and a bug all hands on deck let's fix

1:34:19the problem and they fixed it so you

1:34:22know you can get you can get pessimistic

1:34:23about the fact that there's all these

1:34:24bugs and we've talked about that at

1:34:26length but I'm I'm mostly satisfied that

1:34:29Apple handled the situation the way you

1:34:31would expect a professional good

1:34:33organization to handle the situation

1:34:35yeah yeah I mean they they're not like

1:34:39as angry as I am about how crappy

1:34:42they're treating hi Sierra right now and

1:34:45how it should not be it should not have

1:34:46been released period like this at this

1:34:48OS is still a beta and should not have

1:34:51been released and if they insisted on

1:34:53releasing it they should not be

1:34:54promoting it as hard as they are they

1:34:55should not be automatically pardoned

1:34:57people to install it as much as they are

1:34:58but all that being said they are making

1:35:01software bugs happen they are fixing

1:35:03them you know bugs happen on both

1:35:05platforms and alack this isn't just a

1:35:06Mac thing like iOS has problems Mac has

1:35:09problems as long as they fix the

1:35:10problems they're doing their job yeah

1:35:13but high sierra is not ready I mean I

1:35:15don't know why you say that it's I have

1:35:17it on every one of my machines and it's

1:35:18been fine it's just very upset about

1:35:21fonts moving apparently well and root

1:35:23and month 13 like this it's not that it

1:35:26has one problem I Sierra has lots of

1:35:29problems

1:35:31like I don't know I mean it depends on

1:35:33if you encounter the problems like if

1:35:35it's the example you said I was had all

1:35:38these trepidations about installing it

1:35:39right and then eventually I just did

1:35:40install it on my wife's computer and

1:35:42it's been fine I mean I'm sure it's

1:35:43console her consoles filling right now

1:35:45with Mon 13 being out of bounds but

1:35:47beyond that it's more or less works I'm

1:35:49it's hard for me to gauge like what is

1:35:51the stability of this thing across the

1:35:52entire user base some people have more

1:35:55problems with than others

1:35:56none of us have the Windows Server

1:35:58crashing bug which would certainly be

1:35:59something that we make us all screaming

1:36:01that we shouldn't have upgraded right

1:36:02because if your computer crashes every

1:36:0530 to 60 minutes like morning crashes

1:36:08kernel panics that's bad

1:36:11but I don't know I'd like I feel like

1:36:13Apple probably knows but the stability

1:36:14is like certainly it feels shaky er then

1:36:17we wish the Mac operating system ever

1:36:19would feel but early early releases of

1:36:23all major updates are like and certainly

1:36:24as we said in last show it doesn't live

1:36:26up to the billing as a stability release

1:36:29like as it was pitched but it's hard for

1:36:32me to gauge exactly how dire it is and I

1:36:34still remember the bad old days of 10 5

1:36:370 and even 10 6 zero and the zero

1:36:39releases back in the old days we're just

1:36:41we're just so much worse like like you

1:36:44may we'll make you computer unusable but

1:36:46mark goes right in that they didn't push

1:36:47though so they didn't automatically

1:36:48download those and throw things in your

1:36:49face to tell you to upgrade like no one

1:36:51even knew leopard was out until most of

1:36:53us had suffered through 10 5 0 10 5 one

1:36:55and 10 5 2 so it's a different world

1:36:59yeah tell us about your iPhone John we

1:37:03have time but I guess we do my iPhone is

1:37:05full what is that so wait what size did

1:37:08you get

1:37:08I didn't here's the thing when here we

1:37:12go we've all seen the Google ads where

1:37:14they they're like part of their

1:37:15advertising campaign is they show up

1:37:16that little dialogue that says like

1:37:18never see this again and it's a little

1:37:20iOS style it comes up and says like

1:37:22whatever says your iPhone is full or

1:37:23you're out of storage and remember the

1:37:25exact wording but that's that's been an

1:37:26ad campaigns for Android devices

1:37:28specifically for Google Android devices

1:37:30I think for a while now and I had never

1:37:33seen that and so when it appeared my

1:37:35first question it was how big is this

1:37:38phone because I'd forgotten I said

1:37:39iPhone 7 I bought it a long time ago I

1:37:41don't remember what size I got I was

1:37:43surprised to learn that I got

1:37:451:28 which I normally don't do like I

1:37:48normally get the smaller size I'm like

1:37:49oh I don't have that much stuff on it

1:37:50and it's not a big deal I used to be

1:37:52that you know back back in the old days

1:37:56when the cameras on phones and iPod

1:37:58Touches really sucked the biggest thing

1:38:00on your phone or iPod Touch which I keep

1:38:03saying because that's what I had at the

1:38:04time

1:38:04where was your music and I was like oh

1:38:07I'm not gonna put my home music

1:38:08collection on there I'll just put my

1:38:09three star plus playlist on there which

1:38:12is like the songs that I like from my

1:38:13music collection essentially I'll just

1:38:15put them in there and that's not that

1:38:16big and that's the biggest thing that's

1:38:17gonna be on my phone and my music

1:38:19collection doesn't grow that much so I

1:38:20can go I need to do is get a phone or

1:38:22iPod Touch did fits my music collection

1:38:24I'll be fine

1:38:25but now the cameras on phones and maybe

1:38:27iPod Touches are super awesome

1:38:29and we all take lots of pictures with it

1:38:31and the pictures are big and I filled my

1:38:34128 gig phone with yes my music

1:38:37collection which doesn't get that much

1:38:38bigger

1:38:38very often but with photos I filled it

1:38:42with photos so you know you go to like

1:38:44the dialog box offices go to manage

1:38:45storage you look at what's taken up all

1:38:46this room and you're like guess what

1:38:47photos and then second place music and

1:38:50then third place everything else right

1:38:52so now I'm in this situation and I'm

1:38:54like I still has that game hey it's Mike

1:38:56yeah but if your phone fills up like you

1:38:58could fix that right it's pretty easy to

1:39:00fix and to its credit iOS has this

1:39:02pretty nice storage management screen

1:39:04where it will suggest a whole bunch of

1:39:06things you can do to get space back and

1:39:07it will tell you exactly how much space

1:39:09you'll get back in priority order the

1:39:10biggest things first you can do the

1:39:13thing where you let the operating system

1:39:14offload apps that you don't use and it

1:39:16tells you what the consequences of that

1:39:17are and it tells you how much space

1:39:18they'll stay you can get rid of

1:39:20attachments on messages and it tells you

1:39:21how much space you'll save you can

1:39:23delete old messages all over than a year

1:39:24and it tells you how much space that

1:39:25will save but all sorts of stuff like

1:39:26that I was really impressed with that

1:39:28see that screen which I'd never seen

1:39:30before my problem was I didn't want to

1:39:33do any of those things what I wanted to

1:39:35happen was iCloud forward library to say

1:39:37I am now going to eject photos that you

1:39:40haven't looked at in a long time and

1:39:42save only the tiniest of thumbnails for

1:39:44them and I'm gonna do that across your

1:39:45entire photo library shrinking it

1:39:47dramatically and I should have done that

1:39:4917 hours ago when I saw you were running

1:39:52out of room on your phone but I didn't

1:39:53instead I waited if you're trying to

1:39:54completely fill up and stopped you in

1:39:55the middle filling a video of your cute

1:39:57dog and popped up

1:39:58literally in the middle of filming a

1:40:00video of my cute dog I'm pop the

1:40:01dialogue that says your phone is full

1:40:02like well make it unfold like the whole

1:40:05panel pops in my storage on my phone

1:40:07get rid of photos that I haven't looked

1:40:09out like I have thousands of photos that

1:40:11I have never looked at on my phone get

1:40:13them off my phone that's the whole point

1:40:15of optimized storage right and I know

1:40:17people have had the same frustration on

1:40:18their Mac they're like they set their

1:40:20Mac top to my storage and the max disk

1:40:22fills up and they're like come on photos

1:40:24optimized like the whole point is

1:40:26they're stored in the cloud I don't need

1:40:28the full res ones here download them on

1:40:31demand get the full res ones off of my

1:40:33system so I didn't know what to do so

1:40:35I'm like I guess I'll try to leading

1:40:37some big apps I guess I'll find elite

1:40:39GarageBand that I never used cuz it's

1:40:40like six hundred Meg's or whatever you

1:40:42know like I deleted some stuff thinking

1:40:45maybe it's just a lag maybe you know i

1:40:48the the photos thing will just takes a

1:40:49little while to catch up and it'll flush

1:40:51stuff out but sure enough like a couple

1:40:53hours later phone's full again I deleted

1:40:56some more stuff next day phone photo

1:40:57yeah and like every time I try to take a

1:40:58picture it would happen literally when

1:41:00I'm taking pictures in videos just like

1:41:01on the ads because that's when like the

1:41:03thing would fill up or hit some

1:41:05threshold so I was like oh you know I

1:41:08have no choice I have to basically turn

1:41:10off iCloud photo library to convince it

1:41:13to delete these photos off my Mac

1:41:14because it's just not doing it so I

1:41:16turned off iCloud photo library it said

1:41:18do you want to keep these photos in your

1:41:20Mac if you want to trash them I said go

1:41:21ahead and trash them because they're all

1:41:23safe in the cloud they're all safe on my

1:41:25Mac like you know there are many million

1:41:27different places I don't need them to be

1:41:28on my phone I never look at them on my

1:41:29phone anyway and by the way remember the

1:41:32the photo is on my photo library is not

1:41:35the family photo library it's just my

1:41:36photos the family photo the library

1:41:38belongs to my wife so I'm only talking

1:41:40about a tiny subset of the vast amount

1:41:43of photos I have and I import all of my

1:41:45photos into the family photo library

1:41:47like Mac painfully manually there's no

1:41:49good way to do this so I wasn't really

1:41:53worried about the data right because

1:41:55it's not it's not the real photos and

1:41:57they're all NATO thing so I told it to

1:41:58delete my photo library and and I click

1:42:02delete and it went through and now it's

1:42:03like it's removing space and I'm seeing

1:42:05space come back I got many many gigs

1:42:07free I'm like I gotta solve this problem

1:42:10and then I found myself in the in the

1:42:12managed storage screen I guess I was

1:42:13just trying to look up at the progress

1:42:14or whatever and I noticed in the managed

1:42:16storage screen it said here's some

1:42:19things you can do to save space and one

1:42:21of the top items was you should enable I

1:42:24cut photo library cuz that'll save you

1:42:25fifty days I was like what icon photo

1:42:31library saved me 50 gigs is it thinking

1:42:34well I see on your phone you've got gigs

1:42:36and gigs of photos but if you enable I

1:42:39cut photo library I can upload all those

1:42:41to the cloud and then dump the full res

1:42:43versions leaving only the thumbnail

1:42:44saving you 50 gigs like that's the only

1:42:47way I could reason about that like

1:42:48that's how it was telling me you would

1:42:49think was save space and I would say

1:42:50look let me tell you I had it enabled

1:42:53and that's when my phone filled and

1:42:54didn't seem like it's a new space but

1:42:55anyway because because it offered that

1:42:58to me I said alright I'll take that bet

1:43:00phone you're beating me up about setting

1:43:07my clock back these photos are all safe

1:43:12and sound somewhere else like this is

1:43:14not the real family photo library like

1:43:16this is just me versus the phone to see

1:43:17like you know if you're gonna tell me

1:43:19that I'm gonna say 50 geeks but I'm

1:43:21unable it

1:43:22and so I enabled it and I think what I

1:43:24did was I enable it so quickly after I

1:43:26had disabled that it hadn't deleted all

1:43:28the photos on my phone it just deleted

1:43:30many many gigs of them and and I rien

1:43:33abled it and it went through this thing

1:43:35that said you know I'm uploading photos

1:43:37and I was like oh no is it is it

1:43:38uploading like duplicates of these

1:43:40photos Shirley knows that that has

1:43:41already uploaded all these like and it

1:43:43did it figured it out it said it's like

1:43:45I gotta upload like 9,000 photos and it

1:43:47was like up I'm all done because you

1:43:49know all those tourists were already

1:43:50uploaded so it didn't actually reload

1:43:52them no duplicates and then it just sat

1:43:54there in a steady state so I'm like well

1:43:56this this technique worked disabled I

1:43:58got a photo library tell it to delete

1:44:00wait a short time for it delete several

1:44:02gigs then re-enable it let it figure out

1:44:05that everything that's on the phone has

1:44:06already been uploaded and let it just

1:44:07say but nothing for me to do I guess

1:44:08everything's fine on this phone so that

1:44:12is my update on my my full phone I'm not

1:44:14sure if I deal with it and dealt with it

1:44:16in the right way I'm not sure what the

1:44:18right way really would be and and just

1:44:22to go through the things that I didn't

1:44:23want to do

1:44:23I didn't want to delete message

1:44:25attachments just because I'm stubborn

1:44:26and I'm wearing that stupid iCloud

1:44:27message sync thing to happen so that all

1:44:30my all my messages would be in the cloud

1:44:32and I could delete them locally like I

1:44:33didn't want you know people semi cute

1:44:34videos I don't want to save them to my

1:44:36video library I don't want them to be

1:44:38gone right I didn't want to lead a bunch

1:44:40of applications especially ones that I

1:44:41might not be able to redownload from the

1:44:42store all those fewer of them these days

1:44:44because a 64-bit thing that kills a lot

1:44:47of my cool 32-bit apps all right be

1:44:49flight-control

1:44:50yeah I didn't want to delete any big

1:44:54games and stuff that I play cuz that may

1:44:57not play them that often but I do want

1:44:58to play them I like the fact that's

1:44:59there and I can just launch it and play

1:45:01with it I do mind delete any of my music

1:45:04because I already had a minimal set of

1:45:05my music on there and I didn't want to

1:45:07stream music like it was just another

1:45:08option that I could have done but I like

1:45:10the fact that music is on there what I

1:45:12did want to happen was for the photos to

1:45:13flush out so anyway I took the phone up

1:45:15on its BET and it sure didn't save me 50

1:45:17gigs but my phone is no longer full

1:45:20again and I guess what this means is the

1:45:21next time I get a phone I'll be sure to

1:45:23get the 256 or whatever the biggest size

1:45:24they offer is because now apparently one

1:45:26of those people who fills this phone I

1:45:28will say a useful tip that I that

1:45:30somebody told me somewhere or I found

1:45:32somewhere I said I got my laptop last is

1:45:35you know I Wes you're screwed you're up

1:45:38to the you know the iCloud gods to do

1:45:40what they need to do with optimizing

1:45:41storage which they seem to not do

1:45:42reliably but on the Mac I strongly

1:45:47recommend this this tactic where you

1:45:49know if you're gonna have like your main

1:45:51Mac download all the files and download

1:45:52originals fine do it normally if you're

1:45:55gonna use iCloud photo library and have

1:45:57it optimize storage on a Mac if you have

1:46:00an idea of how much disk space you want

1:46:02that to use at most create a sparse

1:46:05bundle disk image and locate your photos

1:46:08library on that and you can just have it

1:46:11automatically on item in your logon

1:46:13items and so I have a disk image called

1:46:16photos that I set as a maximum size of I

1:46:18think it was like 20 gigs that Ike that

1:46:20I chose or something like that that's

1:46:22what I'm doing on my on my on my new old

1:46:23laptop and it is wonderful because it

1:46:27filled that up maybe 2/3 of the way and

1:46:30then just stopped and so now I can

1:46:33control exactly how much disk space it

1:46:36uses

1:46:37and it will never exceed the limit on

1:46:40this sparse bundle it's glorious I don't

1:46:44know why this isn't a setting they

1:46:46should just have a setting you know I

1:46:48can you imagine some other way to

1:46:49implement that feature that doesn't

1:46:50involve this image imagine that they

1:46:51just yeah maybe an action a storage

1:46:54limit setting that would be amazing but

1:46:57they don't have that so in the absence

1:46:59of them being willing to add such an

1:47:01incredible useful obvious setting that

1:47:03everyone needs on a laptop because the

1:47:04SSDs are expensive and small make a

1:47:06sparse to a sparse bundle disk image in

1:47:08Disk Utility and you can locate the

1:47:10photo library on that add it as a log

1:47:12and item and it automatically mounts and

1:47:13everything just works except you have a

1:47:16defined limit to how big your photos

1:47:17library can be and it will stay under it

1:47:19it is wonderful I was gonna make fun of

1:47:21the inefficiency of solution because now

1:47:23you go like another layer of pseudo file

1:47:25system that all your i/o is going

1:47:26through which you know can't can't be

1:47:28efficient but I do something even worse

1:47:30for Time Machine Network Time Machine

1:47:32backups and I probably should be doing

1:47:34is I think what both of you use as

1:47:36quotas on Synology though you set the

1:47:38quotas per user it works great yeah I

1:47:40think actually do have the quota set but

1:47:42I think I'm slightly over provisioned in

1:47:44typical fashion so usually I just think

1:47:48start to fill up I use the TM util thing

1:47:50to delete historic backups because at

1:47:51least at least in the case of time

1:47:52between there is a physical way for me

1:47:54to do what the system should be doing

1:47:55anyway we're just cleaning up old

1:47:56backups but sometimes it gets cranky

1:47:58when you get close to too much space so

1:48:00I have on my network time machine volume

1:48:03a non sparse disk image as a

1:48:06space-filling placeholder like like many

1:48:10gigs super full and a time machine means

1:48:18like too much need scratch space to get

1:48:20it out of it's fine guess what I take

1:48:22the space filler chuck in the trash and

1:48:23you know it delete it resolved a time

1:48:26machine thing and put back the space

1:48:28filler which is you know it's disgusting

1:48:30it reminds me of that awesome story I

1:48:32hope it's not a park row because all my

1:48:34favorite internet stories of the the

1:48:37experience game developer who has some

1:48:39mandate to fit all some I figure I'm

1:48:42gonna messing up is easy else but to fit

1:48:43all the assets for this game in a

1:48:44certain amount of memory and it's like

1:48:46getting to be crunch time and they have

1:48:47to ship and they're like you

1:48:50200k is the old days of PC gaming like

1:48:53200k over their RAM limit and I can't

1:48:55figure out how to ring any more RAM out

1:48:56and at the beginning of project he'd

1:48:58made a 2 mega by Ram buffer as a static

1:49:00variable and then some C file they just

1:49:02comments that line out and says done

1:49:03ship it anyway my thing is obviously

1:49:07much worse than that and not clever at

1:49:08all but it is it is a thing that I do

1:49:10and it has actually come in handy I want

1:49:12to make so much fun of you John but that

1:49:14is actually very very clever it's not

1:49:16it's stupid I use quotas but I'm just

1:49:17saying it's I mean is that that much

1:49:20worse than my crazy sparse bundle heck

1:49:22yeah well you know the sparse bundle

1:49:24like this first of all thing just makes

1:49:27me so angry about how the automat these

1:49:29automated systems like for version 1

1:49:30fine but this is obviously a thing that

1:49:32people want they want more control over

1:49:34how much space your thing is taking and

1:49:35if the optimize saying really worked the

1:49:37way it was supposed to where you don't

1:49:38have to worry about will take care of it

1:49:39no one would complain like that's a

1:49:42great goal but many years later on all

1:49:44their systems they're sort of optimized

1:49:46storage thing does not work the way

1:49:48people expect like theirs it lets it

1:49:50fill up it doesn't catch it before it

1:49:52fills up in scenarios where you're it's

1:49:54not like I'm not like I'm flooding I

1:49:55mean I suppose video I'm kind of

1:49:57flooding the phone with lots of data but

1:49:59like it's not unforeseen Bowl by the

1:50:01system that we're getting close to the

1:50:03disk storage limit and when it does hit

1:50:05the limit it seems like no part of the

1:50:07system scrambles to get your space back

1:50:09there like yeah you've hit your limit

1:50:10now we're not gonna do anything about it

1:50:12like maybe maybe that Dean will wake up

1:50:14and consider thinning some but maybe it

1:50:17won't like we're not in a hurry is there

1:50:19some urgency about this perhaps you

1:50:21should go to the Settings app on the

1:50:22manage storage screen so you can clear

1:50:23that Red Badge will make it makes you

1:50:25look at that by the way it makes you

1:50:26look at that managed storage screen to

1:50:28clear that badge every time it tells you

1:50:29that message I know that because it

1:50:31would tell me that message a lot and

1:50:32there's no way to get rid of it until

1:50:34you go into that screen and let it grind

1:50:35away and say here's all the things you

1:50:37can do to save space like you know what

1:50:38you can do to save space get some

1:50:40innocent photos goodness

1:50:42thanks for sponsors this week fracture

1:50:44aftershocks and Linode and we will see

1:50:46you next week

1:50:50now the show is over they didn't even

1:50:53mean to begin cuz it was accidental oh

1:50:57it was accidental

1:51:01Johnny research Marco and Casey wouldn't

1:51:04let him cuz it was accidentally was

1:51:09accidental and you can find the show

1:51:13notes at a CAS pyl ISS so that's Casey

1:51:26less ma RC o AR m auntie Marco Arment SI

1:51:33r AC Syracuse

1:51:41[Music]

1:51:50how's the weather up there Marco cold

1:51:53rainy how's the forecast though oh there

1:52:00we go

1:52:02it's overcast nicely done nicely done

1:52:06we'll be here all week kids anyway oh

1:52:08wow so you've released you've released a

1:52:11madcap congratulations yeah my second

1:52:13Mac up don't forget quitter that's true

1:52:17day when I was like command spacing and

1:52:19I think I mistyped and quitter came up

1:52:21I'm like oh yeah I remember that

1:52:22yeah so I released for cast it's a Mac

1:52:24app it's for producing your own podcasts

1:52:27it is an mp3 encoder and chapter tool

1:52:29and lets you input some of the mp3

1:52:32metadata right in the app and this I

1:52:35mention this one on this show a number

1:52:38of times over the last two years or so

1:52:41that I've been developing it

1:52:42it is a parallelized version of the lame

1:52:45mp3 encoder under the hood the

1:52:49parallelization is actually done fairly

1:52:51boringly it's an entirely outside of

1:52:53lame the lame is a terrible name that's

1:52:56kind of like an ableist problem name now

1:52:58but this was named a very long time ago

1:53:00before we were as aware of these things

1:53:02and I didn't name it but it happens to

1:53:04be the best mp3 encoder so I apologize

1:53:06for the terrible name but it is called

1:53:07the lame mp3 encoder it is the pretty

1:53:10much the only way you can encode an mp3

1:53:15legally today without using software

1:53:18that had a pre-existing deal with the

1:53:20front Hoffer Institute that was the

1:53:22creator of the mp3 originally back in

1:53:25like the late 80s and it was them whose

1:53:28patents expired this past spring when

1:53:30their patents expired they stopped

1:53:32licensing their encoder at any price

1:53:35believe me I tried so the only way to

1:53:37encode mp3 is legally today if you don't

1:53:39already have a copy or a license of the

1:53:41lame mp3 encoder like Apple does with

1:53:43the iTunes and logic is to use the lame

1:53:47open source project so anyway that's

1:53:50what forecasts does and the

1:53:53parallelization happens outside of that

1:53:54I basically split the file into chunks

1:53:57send them each to a copy of the regular

1:54:00standard live mp3 lame that comes with

1:54:02the source distribution from homebrew

1:54:04rejoin those chunks after they are

1:54:06encoded into one could you can mp3 file

1:54:09because as I mentioned earlier in the

1:54:10show during the question about dynamic

1:54:12ad insertion mp3 file format is easily

1:54:15spliced and easily rejoined and hacked

1:54:18up like that without causing too many

1:54:19problems as long as you're a little bit

1:54:20careful so that's what it does and it is

1:54:25optimized for the workflow that me and

1:54:29some of my podcasts or friends have

1:54:32which is we create mp3 chapters as

1:54:37markers in Logic Pro you can also do

1:54:40this from Adobe Audition and I don't

1:54:42think there's a good way to do it from

1:54:44audacity unfortunately I know people are

1:54:46trying I'm not yet aware of a way to do

1:54:48it but anything that can export markers

1:54:52as metadata in a wav file forecasts will

1:54:56try to import that as chapters you can

1:54:59also create them manually but I wouldn't

1:55:00recommend that because the interface for

1:55:02doing so is awful because I don't do

1:55:03that

1:55:05also it's all a tableview with cocoa

1:55:08bindings and that makes a bunch of weird

1:55:11little behaviors and inconsistencies and

1:55:13bugs that I need to get rid of by

1:55:14dumping cocoa bindings but that's a lot

1:55:16of work and I haven't gotten there yet

1:55:17anyway so I released this app and I

1:55:21released it for free for lots of reasons

1:55:22that I don't talk about if you want to

1:55:24if you care I've talked a little bit

1:55:26about some of the stuff went under the

1:55:27radar but I don't know what do you guys

1:55:29want to know where should I start here

1:55:31so what was the motivation it was simply

1:55:34just efficiency yeah pretty much it was

1:55:36you know III wanted first of all the way

1:55:40I was encoding this show before was by

1:55:43using the command line version of lame

1:55:45and I was doing that you know I wasn't

1:55:49using the built-in mp3 encoder and

1:55:50logical because the front offer encoder

1:55:51which is actually a little bit better

1:55:53quality for low bit rate speech and also

1:55:56a little bit faster but I wasn't using

1:55:58that because I wanted as part of my

1:56:01workflow to automate things like putting

1:56:03in the right artwork for the show

1:56:05putting in the right podcast title and

1:56:08episode number and everything so I had

1:56:09like some shell screw

1:56:11to do that before and I would shell out

1:56:13to the lame mp3 encoder on the command

1:56:15line and encoding an episode of the show

1:56:18would take like four or five minutes it

1:56:19was and you know that's to an impatient

1:56:22programmer that's just death like this

1:56:24have to sit there and wait and every

1:56:25time like if I wanted to change the file

1:56:28WestEd then wait another five minutes

1:56:30for to re-encode and it was a pain so I

1:56:32and I've always loved hacking audio

1:56:35stuff and as you can tell from some of

1:56:37my career choices always loved it always

1:56:39loved dealing with audio and so I

1:56:41decided you know what I there has to be

1:56:44a way to make this parallel I have all

1:56:47these cores sitting around doing nothing

1:56:48on my computer while one core works its

1:56:51butt off for five minutes

1:56:53this is incredibly offensive to me okay

1:56:55let me let me figure out a way to solve

1:56:58this and in addition I realize like if I

1:57:01control like a GUI version of the

1:57:03encoder I can save myself some time in

1:57:06other ways for instance we host this

1:57:08podcast on Squarespace but we host the

1:57:10website and the feed on Squarespace the

1:57:12files are hosted libsyn and that's a

1:57:14setup I recommend by the way but anyway

1:57:16the Squarespace requires that you paste

1:57:19in the file size and the duration of the

1:57:24podcast file that you're hosting

1:57:26elsewhere it doesn't just fetch that it

1:57:28requires that you paste it and so I

1:57:30figured like oh if I could have a tool

1:57:31that like helps me easily copy those

1:57:33things to the clipboard I can save a few

1:57:34steps there if I have a tool that can

1:57:36maybe pre-fill certain things based on

1:57:39what I did last for that same podcast I

1:57:41can save some time there I also wanted

1:57:44to get involved with chapter my show our

1:57:48show and you know the Germans kind of

1:57:50convinced me to do it the Germans are

1:57:51frustratedly right a lot of the time and

1:57:55man I love the Germans anyway so they

1:57:58convinced they convinced us all overtime

1:57:59they wore us down and convinced us all

1:58:01that we should probably have chapters in

1:58:03our show and wanted to do that and and I

1:58:05was not happy with the state of the

1:58:06tools to do that two years ago they they

1:58:08were pretty minimal and and almost

1:58:10non-existent and so I wanted to

1:58:12basically solve all these problems at

1:58:14once and so I did I made an app that was

1:58:16basically my ideal app for podcast

1:58:20encoding and post-production work I

1:58:22basically made it for myself too

1:58:25save myself time and it does

1:58:26dramatically so it saves me tons of time

1:58:28every week now that I produce multiple

1:58:30shows and even even if I just produce

1:58:33this one it would still be worth doing

1:58:34so and I had a private beta with many of

1:58:38our podcasting friends you know probably

1:58:41most notably that the people are real a

1:58:43you know Mike Steven Jason snow they

1:58:46were wonderful beta testers and they

1:58:48uncovered lots of little bugs over the

1:58:50years and we've hopefully fixed them all

1:58:53and here we are

1:58:55so why free and I know you talked about

1:58:58this on under the radar but what's the

1:59:00kind of short short version the main

1:59:02reason is that my expected number of

1:59:06paid customers for this like if I would

1:59:08have charged money for this the the

1:59:11total number of paid customers I would

1:59:13expect to get is maybe a hundred like

1:59:16there aren't that many podcast producers

1:59:18relative to other professions among

1:59:20podcast producers there aren't that many

1:59:23of them who are willing to try some

1:59:26random tool like this from me and

1:59:28because the volume would be so low I

1:59:31would have to price it at like 50 bucks

1:59:33or so or more to make it worthwhile and

1:59:36I just figured the market would be so

1:59:39small that you know if there was a paid

1:59:42app the market would be so small that

1:59:44the total amount of money I would make

1:59:46from this is you know not that great and

1:59:50the cost of supporting an app that was

1:59:53paid to that level is very high like if

1:59:56someone pays 50 bucks for an app or more