Podcast Search

Top Four

Top Four 35: Pies 🥧

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:023.14159

0:00:03yeah two six five three five eight nine

0:00:05seven nine three two three four six wow

0:00:09you're a nerd I think that's yeah Wow

0:00:14are you just realizing this now is this

0:00:16is this new no no it's not it's not it's

0:00:18definitely not new but I didn't I I I

0:00:21thought I had the most digits in my

0:00:22brain and it was hardly any okay

0:00:24honestly compared to other nerds I'm

0:00:27hardly any oh yeah that's like nerds can

0:00:29go pretty far I just thought I would win

0:00:32digits over you but I don't have any at

0:00:36all I need to turn around and start

0:00:37memorizing yeah fail we are talking

0:00:40about pi not on pi day not it's not pi

0:00:43day which i think is kind of BS e yeah I

0:00:47don't want to pile on the pi day right

0:00:49with my PI urban mode

0:00:51we're being innovators our innovators

0:00:56anyway so yeah we're gonna talk about

0:00:59pies because this is the pie season it's

0:01:02really in his pies I mean you can make

0:01:05pies pretty much any time you want but

0:01:07it does feel like they are you know

0:01:09along with other indulgent and dessert

0:01:11foods it seems like pies are seemingly

0:01:14more permitted and more socially

0:01:17acceptable and and for some reason you

0:01:18consider them like oh I have to ignore

0:01:20all health and reasonability for this

0:01:23month or whatever piece of pie right

0:01:26exactly and pie for breakfast after you

0:01:28know because you eat leftover pie

0:01:29obviously and but I always find it

0:01:31strange that holiday season is for pies

0:01:33but most fruit pies are best in the

0:01:37summertime because you have the fruit

0:01:40available yeah that is kind of weird

0:01:42isn't it right but like you I think of

0:01:44pie like making pie for the holiday but

0:01:46I guess like you make apple pie and

0:01:47pumpkin pie and like holiday pie anyway

0:01:52so yeah we're talking about pies we're

0:01:54go we're not eating them right now we

0:01:57don't have 14 pies in front of us that

0:01:59we're gonna taste we're gonna test all

0:02:00these pies actually but for one of these

0:02:03it's kind of oh but one of your

0:02:05birthday's I had that key lime pie party

0:02:07yeah and we have all different key lime

0:02:09pies and if anyone was like what should

0:02:11I bring I'm like bring a key lime pie

0:02:13and so we had a lot of different key

0:02:15lime pies to try that was awesome that

0:02:19was a really fun party I like a good

0:02:20theme yeah can I say

0:02:23turns out my key lime pie was the best

0:02:26pie who knew who knew we knew Arthur

0:02:28Arthur knew anyway so I thought it was

0:02:34actually I had some trouble deciding

0:02:36what counts as a pie so everything

0:02:39counts as a pie that's kind of yeah

0:02:40that's I was gonna lean towards a more

0:02:42permissive attitude here well that's

0:02:43what wikipedia says you should see some

0:02:45of the things they were counting

0:02:46empanadas as pies wells okay so if you

0:02:49go into finishin it's like a hand pie

0:02:51suggestions like I think the British

0:02:53definition of pie is much more broad

0:02:55than the American definition of pie no

0:02:58because we call those things hand pies

0:03:00also sort of but if you ask most

0:03:04Americans yeah I think most Americans

0:03:06don't know what mincemeat pies or hand

0:03:08pies are are you kidding anyone who is a

0:03:10relative of an immigrant of some sort

0:03:13has definitely heard of various I guess

0:03:15that fringe pies you would say because I

0:03:19don't know my grandpa is made meat pies

0:03:21yeah they were like Italian meat pies

0:03:24they waited thirty forty pounds I don't

0:03:26know yeah you just like put like a whole

0:03:29bunch of entire animals in a tray yeah

0:03:32and like but all the salted meat animals

0:03:34from the Italian you know butcher shop

0:03:37so you have various salted meat log

0:03:40animals that go in there exactly but

0:03:45yeah he made those things that's like a

0:03:46meat pie yeah yep all right I guess we

0:03:50should dive into this we should so do

0:03:52you have any honorable mentions I do

0:03:54actually I have two okay

0:03:55I do too all right well but it's a whole

0:03:58category well that's fair because yeah

0:04:00III think the definition of pie here is

0:04:03so broad and and on that note my first

0:04:05honor mention is chicken pot pie whoa

0:04:08honorable mention yeah because if I want

0:04:12pie chances are I don't want chicken pot

0:04:14pie however I do want chicken pot pie

0:04:16well if you want dessert you don't want

0:04:18that however can you just buy again

0:04:20because I really like that when you save

0:04:22up chicken pot pie is really good

0:04:27the best day yes I love my needs I don't

0:04:30know why I think that the word potpies

0:04:32and Marco refuses to say it for me I

0:04:36don't know why because he's holding yeah

0:04:38because you care so much about this one

0:04:39weird word for some reason anyway say it

0:04:41so I think chicken pot pies are amazing

0:04:44I we've had a couple other kinds of pot

0:04:47pies but none of them are as good I

0:04:48think if you're going to talk about pot

0:04:49pies chicken pot pies or the pot pies to

0:04:51be pot pies so like that's day

0:04:55those are great and they definitely

0:04:57deserve a list a spot in any pie list

0:05:00even though they are not desserts and

0:05:02when Americans think pie they think

0:05:03dessert but I think you can't you can't

0:05:06ignore the wonderful wonderful

0:05:07everything about chicken pot pie chicken

0:05:10pot pie is my number two I'm so sorry I

0:05:15was so worried that you would get mad

0:05:16that I included it yeah it's a pie it's

0:05:19it's pot pie like it's a pie it looks

0:05:23like a pie it tastes like a pie it has

0:05:24crust that's made exactly the same as a

0:05:26sweet pie and we didn't say this is like

0:05:28top for sweet pies top for savory pies

0:05:31top for pies like period like three

0:05:33point one four point three point period

0:05:36that's how most decimals have two

0:05:40periods alright so what is your first

0:05:43honorable mention my honorable mention I

0:05:45only have one it's a whole category it

0:05:47is the quiche that's why you know I

0:05:49didn't think about quiches it is kind of

0:05:51like an egg pie right yeah I crust right

0:05:54and it has there are other various

0:05:56breakfast tea egg concoctions that do

0:05:59not have a crust and I would not

0:06:01consider those pies but a quiche is on

0:06:03is on the border and we have a table is

0:06:06not a pie frittata in the rest yeah so

0:06:08the only reason that quiche is a

0:06:11honorable mention and not on the list is

0:06:13because it doesn't have pie in the name

0:06:14like a pot pie so I felt a little bit

0:06:17strange putting it into my pie top for

0:06:20well but I think if you look at the

0:06:23construction in the ingredient I mean

0:06:24they're like the ingredients are not

0:06:26that different from like a custard pie

0:06:28you have milk cream butter and some

0:06:31flavoring things in it like that's

0:06:34cheese the eggs and eggs do yeah and

0:06:36like so you have eggs yeah yes but like

0:06:38that that's many of the same ingredient

0:06:41as a custard pie that you know

0:06:43differently prepared and differently

0:06:45seasoned probably and with different

0:06:46flavor profiles that you're going for

0:06:48but a quiche is like a well-made quiche

0:06:50is I would I would call that a pie by

0:06:53any reasonable definition quiche is one

0:06:55of my favorite breakfasts or meals in

0:06:57general I just love a good quiche it's

0:06:59quite good carmelize onion

0:07:02oh yeah yeah what goat cheese that's a

0:07:04very subtle pick mm-hmm all right my my

0:07:07other on would mention is oreo

0:07:11cheesecake wait is cheesecake up hi-c I

0:07:15thought about this but I think I don't

0:07:17think no I don't think cheesecakes or

0:07:19pies well so why not I'm curious okay

0:07:21cuz it doesn't have a crust her toes

0:07:24no it doesn't it doesn't have that kind

0:07:27of crust it doesn't have like a I've

0:07:28constructed this crust it's like crumbly

0:07:31cookie crust that is packed down it's

0:07:33not up the sides usually you're right it

0:07:36isn't usually up the sides however I

0:07:38would say that the that the crust being

0:07:40packed down made of like crumbly stuff

0:07:42there's lots of pies where they have

0:07:44graham crackers or Oreos as as a crushed

0:07:47down crust like I don't think it needs

0:07:48to be a baked pastry crust for it to

0:07:50count as a pie but a graham cracker

0:07:51crust is a baked pastry crust if you do

0:07:53it right well you can actually bake the

0:07:55graham cracker well but and and

0:07:57cheesecakes can have that too and

0:07:59sometimes do but riddle me this mm-hmm a

0:08:02cheesecake it's more of a the crust is

0:08:05more of a layer of the Cheesecake that's

0:08:08true and also the name says cake

0:08:12well quiche doesn't say pie but we

0:08:13classified it as well that's why it's an

0:08:15honorable mention and this is not

0:08:16mention make it all the way I need just

0:08:19want to make sure that you don't have

0:08:21any cheesecake sneaking into your top

0:08:23four pies because I do not think that

0:08:25cheesecake is a pie I don't have any

0:08:27cheesecake in my top four but that's

0:08:29only because I don't like them that much

0:08:30I like them a little bit now there are

0:08:33cheese pies I'm aware of and they're

0:08:35very different than a cheesecake so you

0:08:39are allowed to pick cheese pie yes you

0:08:42are not allowed to pick cheesecake

0:08:44because I only in classify this as an

0:08:46honorable mention I'm gonna let you have

0:08:47this one but I think the the actual

0:08:49difference between many types of pies

0:08:52and cheesecakes is not that big

0:08:55a difference to the point where I think

0:08:56cheesecakes should be classified as pies

0:08:59even though the rest of the world will

0:09:01you know we'll get you down for that

0:09:03similar to how Tomatoes are clearly

0:09:06fruits even though the entire world says

0:09:09they're vegetables they are by most

0:09:11reasonable metrics fruits yes of course

0:09:15so you don't taste delicious like fruit

0:09:18tastes delicious

0:09:19they're pretty good and yeah but it's

0:09:21biting into a tomato that's that's rough

0:09:25if it's a bad tomato just like like a

0:09:28picket hold a good tomato like an apple

0:09:30all right and not to mention anyway all

0:09:39right I just need to I need you to say

0:09:41this what these cakes are not pies I

0:09:44refuse to agree to this Tim and I will

0:09:46also further derail the conversation by

0:09:48saying within the category of

0:09:49cheesecakes oreo cheesecake is the best

0:09:51cheesecake and that includes both the

0:09:53oreo bits that are throughout the white

0:09:55cheesecake and also the crumbled Oreo

0:09:58crust on the bottom see now are you

0:10:00talking New York cheesecake or are you

0:10:01talking like Italian cheesecake which I

0:10:04which is which I don't really know I I'm

0:10:06calling an Italian because it's made

0:10:07with like the I don't want to say this

0:10:10name of this cheese gotta no matter how

0:10:13I say it someone hates it yes the games

0:10:16that we will so we will call ricotta if

0:10:18you have a problem with how to pronounce

0:10:19we apologize we know that many people

0:10:21have problems with how this is

0:10:22pronounced however you all can't agree

0:10:24on how it should be pronounced so we're

0:10:26gonna go with the one that everyone can

0:10:27recognize and that is simply saying

0:10:29ricotta even though we are so sorry but

0:10:31I cut that yes something like that this

0:10:34episode top floor is brought to you by

0:10:36our friends at Casper Casper Casper are

0:10:39the company that focuses on sleep and

0:10:41they're dedicated to making you

0:10:42exceptionally comfortable one night at a

0:10:44time you spend a third of your life

0:10:46sleeping if you spend a third of your

0:10:47life doing anything you want to make

0:10:49sure it's as best as it can possibly be

0:10:51like eating pies exactly if you found a

0:10:5330 life eating pie first of all that's

0:10:54kind of amazing might not be a very long

0:10:56life but that's kind of amazing there

0:10:59are so many different kinds of pies you

0:11:00can have like pie for breakfast and

0:11:02lunch and dinner and they don't

0:11:03necessarily have to be sweet and awful

0:11:05for you

0:11:06exactly but say you do spend a third of

0:11:07your life actually

0:11:09that's why you need Casper Casper

0:11:11mattresses are designed for humans with

0:11:15incredibly detailed thorough engineering

0:11:17that's gone into this to soothe and

0:11:19support your natural geometry it has all

0:11:21the right support in all the right

0:11:22places so what goes into making a Casper

0:11:25mattress so comfortable they combine

0:11:27multiple supportive memory foams for a

0:11:29quality mattress with just the right

0:11:31sink in just the right bounce and Casper

0:11:33mattresses are designed and developed in

0:11:35the US and their breathable design helps

0:11:38to regulate your body temperature

0:11:39throughout the night and with over

0:11:4020,000 reviews and an average rating of

0:11:424.8 stars Casper is very quickly

0:11:45becoming the Internet's favorite

0:11:46mattress you can be sure of your

0:11:48purchase also with Casper's 100 night

0:11:50risk-free sleep on it trial they deliver

0:11:53directly to your door and if for any

0:11:55reason you don't love it they have a

0:11:56hassle-free return policy we have a

0:11:59Casper it is really excellent we we

0:12:02resisted for a long time we thought Elya

0:12:03the mattress we have is fine the

0:12:05mattress we have is not fine turns out

0:12:07Casper is great it's way more

0:12:09comfortable the one we had was very worn

0:12:12out and it was it was delivered in a

0:12:14very practical box it's it's it's heavy

0:12:17but it's small you can get it upstairs

0:12:19if you're happy you don't have to like

0:12:21you know if you have like go around a

0:12:22corner or anything you can do it it's no

0:12:23big deal

0:12:24which we did which we did and it's it

0:12:26worked out great

0:12:27very tight corners yeah unboxing it was

0:12:29super easy your roll now you cut the

0:12:31plastic it inflates itself and then you

0:12:32have a mattress and then you throw the

0:12:34Box down the stairs exactly and then

0:12:36your kid plays in the box for a few days

0:12:37it's so start sleeping ahead of the

0:12:41curve with Casper you can get fifty

0:12:43dollars towards any mattress purchase by

0:12:45visiting Casper comm slash top-4 and

0:12:47using code top-4 at checkout terms and

0:12:50conditions apply

0:12:51that's Casper comm slash top four and

0:12:54offer code top four

0:12:55we thank Casper for their support of

0:12:57this show all right so time for high our

0:13:02number four it's pie time you want to go

0:13:04first or shall I do you want to do you

0:13:06want to finish last go for now okay

0:13:10now I'm second-guessing right I wonder

0:13:14how many times they say that oh if you

0:13:17actually think that quiche might be pie

0:13:19I would it look if chicken pot pie

0:13:21counts

0:13:22then I think he should count because

0:13:24neither of them are our dessert pies

0:13:26they're both savory meal pies but if

0:13:29that is you know it's up to you which

0:13:32would you rather have would you rather

0:13:33have quiche or chicken pot pie or the

0:13:37other pies re-enlist my number four that

0:13:40I wrote down is peach raspberry that's

0:13:44it yeah because you made that ya choice

0:13:46right yeah I make peach raspberry pie

0:13:48in the end of the summer like when

0:13:50peaches are really good and I like the

0:13:53little bit of raspberry because it

0:13:54brings the tart into the peaches and

0:13:57it's really nice do you don't not a lot

0:13:59of raspberry just a little bit yeah and

0:14:00I really like peach pie because you can

0:14:03like sweat the peaches and get the

0:14:04juices really goopy and make it kind of

0:14:07like a a peach simple syrup and then

0:14:09pour it back into the pie so you don't

0:14:11have a lot of water because if you do

0:14:12that if you don't do that then you have

0:14:14like a pretty watery pie but yeah I

0:14:18really like the peach raspberry pie that

0:14:20I make lattice top for that one it's

0:14:23it's you construct it very similarly it

0:14:25appears as an apple pie yeah I'm also

0:14:28going off of pies I like to make mmm

0:14:30yeah and by the way behind this isoh but

0:14:33I will TIF is really freaking good at

0:14:35making pies like freakishly so

0:14:37especially the cool the kind with all

0:14:38the cool crust work like apple pie with

0:14:40Lilith lattice top and everything so

0:14:42that's that definitely plays in here I

0:14:44think you should be you're really

0:14:46freaking good at pies and it's a great

0:14:48because then I get pie and I get good

0:14:50pie it's fantastic so I really like

0:14:53peach raspberry pie I think that that

0:14:54would be my number4 but if quiche counts

0:14:57I might bump peach raspberry to my

0:14:59honorable mention and bump up quiche but

0:15:02again it depends on the meal so I don't

0:15:03know like what they're tied fair enough

0:15:08yep it wouldn't be topped for if we had

0:15:11a top four yes honestly I don't like

0:15:14most fruit pies yeah actually I had a

0:15:16hard time coming up with four total

0:15:19actually because you know I was looking

0:15:22I I can't believe looking online to see

0:15:23like you know a list of you know

0:15:24America's favorite pies whatever just to

0:15:26see like am I forgetting anything am I

0:15:28missing anything and and there actually

0:15:30were not that many that I really had in

0:15:32contention here yeah there's like I

0:15:34don't really care for blueberry pie

0:15:35honestly

0:15:36because I don't like blueberries that

0:15:39strongly I find cherry pie to be too

0:15:41sweet most of the time I do not care for

0:15:45I don't know what else is there there's

0:15:49like so many other things every rhubarb

0:15:51is a popular one here for strawberries

0:15:54that much I came to that realization

0:15:56pretty recently yeah I felt like you're

0:16:00supposed to like strawberries for so

0:16:01long and I was just so indifferent about

0:16:03them and now I think I'm done I'm done

0:16:06with the lies I think not liking

0:16:08strawberries is kind of like not liking

0:16:10vanilla like in the sense that like

0:16:12there are people out there who don't

0:16:14like vanilla but there aren't that many

0:16:15strawberry I'm like cry about it right

0:16:18but like the whole world kind of assumes

0:16:20that certain flavors are universally

0:16:22liked vanilla is one of them and I think

0:16:23strawberry is one of them too I think

0:16:24pretty much everyone assumes that

0:16:25everyone likes strawberry yeah but if

0:16:27you don't like and I like it so I've

0:16:29never felt this but if you don't like

0:16:30strawberry it's probably really hard for

0:16:32you how do you how does it make you feel

0:16:34I don't know the texture is a little off

0:16:36I prefer raspberries over strawberries

0:16:38any day definitely pick a raspberry or a

0:16:40strawberry I find I I do like the flavor

0:16:43of rhubarb but I don't like the texture

0:16:46of rhubarb so it's really iffy if you're

0:16:49gonna get a good rhubarb pie or not

0:16:50because if they don't properly cook the

0:16:53rhubarb or treat it beforehand it I

0:16:56don't know how to do it I've never made

0:16:58a rhubarb pie but I know it's just too

0:17:01iffy to even put in the effort

0:17:03so what also like oh they're you know

0:17:05making a pie is a good amount of work

0:17:07because it cuz the way you make it you

0:17:08make the crust from scratch you you know

0:17:10easy part well for you anyway so the

0:17:15point I bet if most people tried to make

0:17:17a pie crust with someone who knows how

0:17:19to make pie crust they would see that it

0:17:21literally takes ten minutes don't want

0:17:23the motor built yeah don't let the

0:17:24butter melt but like there's tiny little

0:17:26techniques to learn and as long as you

0:17:29make it with someone who's already made

0:17:30it you will see it only takes ten

0:17:32minutes it has like three ingredients

0:17:33and you are done and you have pie crust

0:17:36and it's awesome and there's no need to

0:17:38buy pie crust from the store anymore

0:17:40because you almost always have the

0:17:42ingredients for pie crust is just like

0:17:44butter flour and water right and so yeah

0:17:47unless you're doing for like

0:17:50more complicated crust that has like you

0:17:52know some cream cheese or something in

0:17:54it for some reason but you don't have to

0:17:56there's lots of things Oh God baking so

0:17:59fun I love how much fun you have baking

0:18:02that way I have all those fun stuff to

0:18:04taste all right well what's your number

0:18:06four

0:18:06all right we're talking about for worst

0:18:08pies my number four you were going to

0:18:11despise this pick but fortunately it's

0:18:13not cheesecake it is cherry cheese pie

0:18:16well that's fine it's disgusting but

0:18:19it's still a pie so cherry this this is

0:18:22a staple of mine growing up so it's a

0:18:24laughably disgusting that's part of it's

0:18:26part of the the value for me a

0:18:28sentimental value but I think it's also

0:18:30really good it's one of the recipes that

0:18:31is on the can of sweetened condensed

0:18:34milk there you go if you buy the

0:18:35candidate gets eagle brand like the big

0:18:37brand of sweetened condensed milk it's

0:18:38like it's on their website it's on some

0:18:40of their cans I think and it also on the

0:18:43cherry can maybe cuz that's all father's

0:18:46yes so you pretty much don't make any of

0:18:49this it's more than that you assemble

0:18:50this pie so so you you get a premade

0:18:53graham cracker crust it has to be a

0:18:55grandpa crust you know so the pre-made

0:18:56ones of those and don't bother making a

0:18:58fresh one to put in these horrible

0:19:00ingredients into the pie because you

0:19:02know know know where the filling is

0:19:04cream cheese sweetened condensed milk

0:19:06and lemon juice blended together and

0:19:09then the topping you pour that into the

0:19:12graham cracker crust and you top it with

0:19:14a can of those red syrupy cherry

0:19:17cherries from cherry pie filling it's a

0:19:19it's literally can of pie filling so

0:19:20it's just like cherries in a really

0:19:23thick goopy sugary red sauce is so 70s

0:19:26it really is and it's really delicious

0:19:28and like is it it's it really delicious

0:19:31it really is mm-hmm yeah so cherokees

0:19:34pie it's very easy you pretty much can't

0:19:36screw it up and it's it's really you

0:19:39know it's already screwed up it's really

0:19:41junky flavors it's all like junk food

0:19:43and and sugar and everything but it's

0:19:45delicious and I love it

0:19:46I don't love it as much as fancier pies

0:19:48but it's definitely my number four this

0:19:50is like the time when I was in school

0:19:53for like first grade or something and my

0:19:55parents came to open school night and my

0:19:57mom cooked us beautiful homemade meals

0:20:00every night it was always something

0:20:02different she

0:20:03very much prided herself in having

0:20:06amazing dinners and being a great mom

0:20:09when it came to pretty much everything

0:20:12but when it came to making dinners for

0:20:15her family and what does her daughter

0:20:18her firstborn daughter the firstborn

0:20:20granddaughter of the family put on the

0:20:24wall of my favorite foods when for a

0:20:27little interview thing that for open

0:20:29school night stovetop stuffing stovetop

0:20:32stuffing was my favorite food I probably

0:20:35had it once right and my mom was

0:20:39horrified I don't have ever had so this

0:20:42is like one of those moments where it's

0:20:44like you're like please it's not your

0:20:46number one no it's my number four it

0:20:47just barely made the list but I do like

0:20:49it I bake a lot I know and to four of

0:20:54you only have four choices you have four

0:20:58slots don't worry the rest is all things

0:21:00that you either make or can make okay

0:21:03but still to lose one of the four to

0:21:06that pie I know it does sting a little

0:21:08I knew you would be upset about this I

0:21:10have been okay I had to be honest it's

0:21:12my number four it's okay

0:21:14I know it's sentimental value yeah and

0:21:16it's also just really good it's I mean

0:21:17it's pure sugar but it's really good

0:21:19anyway what is your number three apple

0:21:22pie really okay and simple apple pie and

0:21:26you and your referring only to the

0:21:28lattice top four already not the crumble

0:21:30top right I don't really mind as long as

0:21:31it's kind of like a brown Betty apple

0:21:33pie I like a lot of brown sugar and

0:21:34cinnamon and you know all those little

0:21:36flavors lately from my mom's recipe of

0:21:39apple pie that I normally make I've been

0:21:40adding a little ginger and I've been

0:21:42really liking that so and when you make

0:21:45I will pie you have to make it with all

0:21:46different kinds of apples if you make it

0:21:48with one kind of apple if you just go to

0:21:50the store and you buy a bag of apples

0:21:52you're doing it wrong don't do that by

0:21:55lots of different apples and have more

0:21:57green apples than any other variety yeah

0:22:00slightly more because they they hold up

0:22:02really well in a pie so yeah my mom's

0:22:05and my brown Betty apple pie

0:22:08it's great crumble top or full top or

0:22:11lattice top that's it to me that is a

0:22:15different pie is like they are but I

0:22:17like

0:22:17all tops of an apple pie that's fair

0:22:20okay I'll give you that because it can

0:22:22it can hold all of those different tops

0:22:24it's okay

0:22:25and your pie is also excellent because

0:22:26you you find a way to have the apples

0:22:29not be too watery like that's often one

0:22:31of the I think the biggest challenge

0:22:32when people make apple pies besides

0:22:33under doing the crust in the middle

0:22:34which is kind of related is if you have

0:22:36just if the inside just full of water

0:22:37yeah I reduce a little bit of the excess

0:22:40apple liquid if I end up letting them if

0:22:42I let them sweat for too long so those

0:22:44of you bakers out there if you are while

0:22:47you're preparing the crust if the apples

0:22:49are sitting in the cinnamon and sugar

0:22:50mixture too long or depending on the

0:22:54temperature outside or in your kitchen

0:22:55you the apples will sweat more or less

0:22:58so if I have a particular day where I'm

0:23:00making a pie and the apples sweat a lot

0:23:02and leave behind a lot of liquid I don't

0:23:05just pour all of that into the pie I

0:23:06reduce some of it on the stove and kind

0:23:08of make a little like caramel syrup and

0:23:11then put that back in the pie but you

0:23:12don't want to do that too much because

0:23:14then you'll get a dry pie so it's very

0:23:16tricky back yeah it's very much a you

0:23:19have to see the day late on the day what

0:23:22what it looks like it took you a couple

0:23:23years to get it right but I think the

0:23:25last year's I didn't have I brought one

0:23:26of those I brought a dry pie once when I

0:23:28just did it too much I know that was not

0:23:30good yeah the last couple years you've

0:23:32been pretty pretty silent thanks all

0:23:34right my number three it's boring but

0:23:36it's good it is the lemon meringue pie

0:23:38yeah I actually I had a little bit of a

0:23:41hesitation when putting this here

0:23:43whether I wasn't sure whether I wanted

0:23:45lemon meringue or lemon tart a lemon

0:23:49tart despite being named tart is clearly

0:23:51a pie and you know and a lemon meringue

0:23:53is very good but I have not had a lot of

0:23:57good meringues I've made a couple that

0:24:00were great but the actual like having

0:24:03someone else's pie or having out at a

0:24:05restaurant oftentimes the meringue part

0:24:07of lemon meringue pie is just like this

0:24:09really cheap flimsy foamy stuff that

0:24:11just falls off and it's it's kind of

0:24:13taste like plastic like well sometimes

0:24:14they over meringue it like it they over

0:24:16whip it and it gets too funny it just

0:24:18breaks down a little bit and gets

0:24:20crystallized a little bit yeah it's too

0:24:23dry sometimes so I didn't have any lemon

0:24:25on mine cuz I don't know I don't really

0:24:26like a lemon curd flavor yeah a bit too

0:24:29strong I really do like I well it's

0:24:31lemon curd but the the the kind of

0:24:33filling that's usually the base of a

0:24:34lemon meringue pie that's usually not

0:24:36very you know bitter or egg yolky at all

0:24:39it's pretty it's pretty sugar yeah I

0:24:41definitely based my picks on consistency

0:24:44mmm based on where you can get it so

0:24:47right if I you know for a peach

0:24:50raspberry I don't really think you could

0:24:52screw that up most of the time it's just

0:24:55peach and raspberry and I like those

0:24:56flavors just as is apple pie I almost

0:24:59like all apple pies there aren't really

0:25:01in any apple pie that I would eat and be

0:25:03like whoo this is terrible who says that

0:25:05that's fair and the same goes for my

0:25:07other two picks all right what was your

0:25:09number three well did you want to finish

0:25:11talking about your lemon pie oh I mean

0:25:13yeah just remembering I'm a big fan of

0:25:15citrus flavors in desserts I really

0:25:18enjoy them and it's just a really great

0:25:21pie you know it's it's basically lemon

0:25:22custard in a crust

0:25:25the crust is often a little bit bland

0:25:28because it's usually not a graham

0:25:30cracker crust ring like that so I that's

0:25:31one of the reasons didn't ring a little

0:25:32bit higher for me but and it's hard to

0:25:36find one that's made well but when it is

0:25:37made well I love love meringue pie and

0:25:41honorable mention for this lot

0:25:43lemon lemon tarts which are basically

0:25:45just the bottom half of a meringue okay

0:25:47well tarts are I would definitely

0:25:49classify tarts as pies they're just

0:25:51skinny pies yeah yeah exactly

0:25:53tarts it's a skinny cousin of pies all

0:25:55right what is your number two

0:25:57so you can pop by we already Popeye you

0:26:02have anything any more say in the matter

0:26:04no love me a pop pie my favorite Popeye

0:26:06ever is Tania's potpie yeah it's really

0:26:10good my best friend down the block shout

0:26:11out to Tania

0:26:12sometimes she listens I love your Popeye

0:26:15please make it very soon it has a lot of

0:26:18time in it it is delicious oh my gosh

0:26:22she makes the best pot pie she like does

0:26:24the whole roofing and every ah yeah

0:26:26every it on all counts it's amazing I'm

0:26:29dreaming over right now I might just

0:26:30call her up tomorrow the show first we

0:26:34just did a show about pies Dania you

0:26:36need to feed the beast

0:26:38give me the Popeye Popeye my number two

0:26:42with a full crust top and bottom

0:26:45oh yeah of course I mean you can't have

0:26:46any like I don't I don't know understand

0:26:48those pot those pot pies that only have

0:26:50like the crusts on top it's like no no

0:26:52there's no pot pie

0:26:54go full pot pie no if the crust is only

0:26:57on top then you've used made a really

0:26:59sad version of chicken and biscuits you

0:27:01have not made Bob I know how flaky pot

0:27:03pie

0:27:03alright my number two related to the

0:27:07lemon meringue category but better in

0:27:08every way the key lime pie hey you know

0:27:12the key like key lime you know for me it

0:27:14doesn't even have to be actually

0:27:15actually made from key limes key limes

0:27:18are pretty hard to find

0:27:19bottled key lime juice is easier but but

0:27:21it's still not that easy to find so

0:27:23pretty much any kind of lime custard pie

0:27:25that now labeled key lime pie this is

0:27:27where you are wrong no because key lime

0:27:29pie is my number one okay so you're

0:27:32gonna you're gonna defend the priority

0:27:33we're gonna talk about key lying lahiri

0:27:35laws yeah key lime juice is very

0:27:38different than lime juice it tastes

0:27:41different and it looks different if you

0:27:43make key if you make pie out of lime

0:27:46it's gonna taste very different than if

0:27:48you make pie out of key lime now you

0:27:51don't need for the flecks of lime bits

0:27:56that go into the pie yeah the zest does

0:27:59not need to be genuine key limes exam

0:28:01very hard to find yeah I've only done it

0:28:04for you like twice once for your key

0:28:06lime birthday party and I think once

0:28:09another time that we happen to find key

0:28:11limes but the juice is important it does

0:28:15not it cannot be substituted so you are

0:28:19making lime pie or you were making key

0:28:22lime pie okay well and there's a bunch

0:28:24of different variations minor variations

0:28:27really on how to make it I think one of

0:28:28the bigger questions is whether it's

0:28:30cooked or not and then how much it's

0:28:31cooked these are all I made my number

0:28:34one because it doesn't matter all key

0:28:36lime pie is good the frozen lime pie

0:28:38yeah yep yes

0:28:42martha stewart's key lime pie super good

0:28:44there is also I made and in kind of like

0:28:48an icebox key lime pie with sweetened

0:28:50condensed milk and like a whipped cream

0:28:53kind of emulation yeah an assembly pie

0:28:55and that was very good key lime pie bars

0:28:58very good there's so many ways to make

0:29:00key lime pie did you basically have like

0:29:03graham quadrats key lime custard on top

0:29:05of a graham cracker crust everything

0:29:07else is optional some people put a

0:29:08little bit whipped cream on top

0:29:09I like a little bit of that to help no

0:29:11rang on there key lime pie I think

0:29:12that's wrong I agree and I like lemon

0:29:15meringue pie

0:29:16however again I will still eat more

0:29:17because I like healing pie yeah I will

0:29:21still I would still eat it too but yeah

0:29:23meringue has no place on a key lime pie

0:29:25anyway my number two is key lime pie

0:29:28made pretty much any way but it has to

0:29:32have a graham cracker crust it has to be

0:29:34I guess since you're telling me all this

0:29:35it has to be made with key lime juice

0:29:37and ideally with a small dollop of fresh

0:29:40whipped cream on top

0:29:41wonderful absolutely love it the colder

0:29:44the better in the fridge is great and

0:29:45the freezer is great absolutely love it

0:29:47yeah I always try to make you key lime

0:29:48pie for your birthday in July which is

0:29:51horrible

0:29:53every time I serve it it just giant blob

0:29:58of Key Lime just is that everywhere it's

0:30:00horrible exactly I try I try so hard

0:30:02all right so number one so your number

0:30:05one is Key Lime you said key limes that

0:30:07we're done with your list right yeah no

0:30:10I just I really love Key Lime Pie you

0:30:14are the one that introduced me to loving

0:30:16Key Lime Pie I think before before you I

0:30:19don't know maybe like six years ago I

0:30:22would have been like what are you crazy

0:30:24I don't like that at all I'm

0:30:25occasionally right but it turns out it's

0:30:28really good and every time that I've

0:30:30like had a spoonful of yours when you've

0:30:32gone for dessert I've loved it and

0:30:34wished I had it for my dessert and

0:30:36usually will end up eating half of yours

0:30:38anyway that's how it works cuz you know

0:30:40you love me like that mm-hmm that's okay

0:30:42with you

0:30:42so yeah it's okie lime Key Lime Pie I

0:30:46just I've never come across one that I

0:30:50didn't like so it has to be number one

0:30:52fair enough

0:30:54all right my number one is something

0:30:57that I would be a lot less willing to

0:31:00share with you that much the New York

0:31:03style fruit tart oh now I figure about

0:31:07fruit tarts right and that does count

0:31:09yes I you figure like if key lime pies

0:31:12can

0:31:12yep or and of lemon tarts can't like if

0:31:15there are so many other things that are

0:31:16various types of tarts that are in pie

0:31:19crust that I have a custard filling that

0:31:21are topped with something sweet that's

0:31:23what a fruit tart is mm-hmm

0:31:24and so by all accounts a fruit tart

0:31:26counts as a pie if all those other

0:31:28things do and then clearly do especially

0:31:29like key lime pie is named pie and is

0:31:32like nobody would ever say key lime pie

0:31:34is not a pie and if a key lime pie is a

0:31:36pie then definitely fruit tarts or pies

0:31:37that's true yeah all right yeah fruit

0:31:39tarts are pies mm-hmm when I was looking

0:31:41at lists of pies and everything I

0:31:43actually didn't for this was one of the

0:31:45very last things added to my list

0:31:46because I also was not thinking of it

0:31:48and I thought well you know I wonder how

0:31:50many tarts count as pies and I started

0:31:52looking a list of tarts and that came up

0:31:53and like oh my god of course that's of

0:31:55course that's number one yes so I've

0:31:58seen a lot of different interpretations

0:31:59of what a fruit tart is so forgive me

0:32:01listeners I'm going to tell you just in

0:32:03case you don't know it for those of you

0:32:04who do know I'm sorry so a fruit tart is

0:32:07a sweet pastry crust in the crust is a

0:32:11usually vanilla flavored custard on top

0:32:15of the custard is fresh pieces of fruit

0:32:18usually strawberries blueberries and

0:32:19raspberries or some combination there

0:32:22may be just two of those sometimes

0:32:23Keeley yeah sometimes Kiwi or like maybe

0:32:26a little a little like peach wedge might

0:32:27be on there sometimes it depends on when

0:32:28you get it and where but almost always

0:32:30they're they're mostly berries

0:32:32blueberries and strawberries and

0:32:33raspberries seem to be like the main

0:32:35ones and then on top of the fresh fruit

0:32:39is a thick glaze made of honey apricot

0:32:43jam and sugar that is to me the the best

0:32:48dessert like if I have to just pick like

0:32:50a one dessert like an half at the end of

0:32:52a meal like give me like an espresso and

0:32:54a fruit tart oh my god that's the best

0:32:56like just I love fruit tarts the only

0:32:58major downside of fruit tarts is that to

0:33:01make them really well takes a lot of

0:33:03work as you know TIFF when you make them

0:33:05Cornish it takes a lot of work cuz like

0:33:08you can you can skip a lot of the steps

0:33:10on pretty much every part of it you can

0:33:12make uh you can get like premade crust

0:33:14you can make a really crappy crust you

0:33:15can get I did and I tried to jello

0:33:18filling or pudding filling instead of

0:33:19instead of like making a whole custard

0:33:21after making it the hard way I tried

0:33:23making it an easy way and they

0:33:26not as good yeah and they're still good

0:33:28but mamatha difference between good and

0:33:31great for fruit tarts and the great ones

0:33:34do take way more effort because you do

0:33:36have to make the custard from scratch

0:33:37when you're like and you're like

0:33:38scratching out the vanilla bean

0:33:40and and like pushing the custard through

0:33:43the through the sieve thing it kind of

0:33:47does feel pretty awesome going through

0:33:49all the steps like you kind of like a

0:33:51mad scientist yeah and making the glaze

0:33:54is not easy usually I make the glaze for

0:33:57us and I've it is surprisingly difficult

0:34:00to get that apricot glaze to be the

0:34:02correct consistency and flavor the

0:34:05spoiler you have to strain it and

0:34:07secondly you you have to use a lot of

0:34:09simple syrup in it as well not like only

0:34:11use a little bit of apricot jelly and

0:34:13most of it is simple syrup and maybe

0:34:15honey if you go that way but anyway when

0:34:18fruit tarts are made well they are

0:34:20wonderful things I first got addicted to

0:34:24them when we were coming home through

0:34:25Ghent through Grand Central every day

0:34:27there's a couple of little markets like

0:34:30in the like kind of off to the side and

0:34:31then in the main area of Grand Central

0:34:33that you can basically get a fruit tart

0:34:35every day like as you go home on the

0:34:37train every day and boy it's that it's

0:34:39dangerous and glorious and and when you

0:34:41make them your easy ones we're not as

0:34:44good as those but your hard ones are

0:34:47even better than those they better be my

0:34:49god I did all the work

0:34:50so yeah look I love of good fruit tart

0:34:53it is definitely my number one as soon

0:34:55as I realized that it should be included

0:34:57in a category of pies it was a

0:34:59no-brainer that's why you were so

0:35:02excited about doing pies I was yeah

0:35:04I totally got I thought you'd be really

0:35:07mad about the cheesecake and the chicken

0:35:09pot pie being included I'm very angry at

0:35:11the Cheesecake yeah it's cake it's cake

0:35:18pot pies is pie I don't it's not

0:35:21marketing it's right there it's totally

0:35:24pie anyway it literally says cake if it

0:35:28were like he should have said nothing

0:35:29that would be up for debate but it

0:35:31literally says cake the other one says

0:35:34pie I don't know what the problem is