Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

258: Non-Beta Data

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

1:00:00at work yeah that's what I was curious

1:00:02about too and I didn't know if I just

1:00:03hadn't read the right documentation yet

1:00:05or something but the thought of having

1:00:07all of my health records from all of my

1:00:09different health professionals all in

1:00:11one spot all for me to be able to see

1:00:13that genuinely sounds really awesome but

1:00:16Color Me a little skeptical that that'll

1:00:18actually be what ends up happening

1:00:20because I mean look at Apple pay which

1:00:23is a seemingly odd analogy to use but

1:00:25like I feel like in America it's pulling

1:00:27teeth to get an its to get a retailer to

1:00:29use Apple pay and that's to give them

1:00:32money and here it's like what is going

1:00:35to encourage anyone insurance companies

1:00:38or doctors or whomever to share medical

1:00:40records I mean yeah there are records in

1:00:42theory since it's our bodies etc etc but

1:00:45I don't know I don't see any real

1:00:47incentive to get health providers or

1:00:50insurance companies or whatever to

1:00:51provide this information to us well but

1:00:54have them in government incentives to

1:00:55make them adopt some of the things that

1:00:56would make them potentially closer to

1:01:00supporting this type of feature but not

1:01:03anytime soon there won't be if there's

1:01:05one thing that's true and they know

1:01:07there has been in the past like the all

1:01:08meaningful use thing then in past years

1:01:10was to try to get you know medical

1:01:14businesses in the u.s. to adopt

1:01:16electronic health record stuff like who

1:01:19knows how affect it was but anyway this

1:01:21is one thing that's true about

1:01:22healthcare in the u.s. is that getting

1:01:25all of your medical anything anywhere is

1:01:27basically impossible so I would love to

1:01:31have all my medical stop stop right

1:01:32there unless you were very very lucky

1:01:37it's not gonna happen it's hard enough

1:01:39to get any of your medical so if you are

1:01:43astronomically lucky and all of your

1:01:46health records happen to be at the tiny

1:01:48subset of medical institutions and

1:01:51providers that are participating in this

1:01:53program yes you could have all of your

1:01:55medical records in this thing but

1:01:57chances are very very good that some of

1:02:00your medical records will not be

1:02:02participating in this and so it's just

1:02:04an adoption problem so I I like to see

1:02:06Apple tackling this and they're trying

1:02:07to do it in a sort of you know agnostic

1:02:09way using standard

1:02:11protocols for interchange so it's not

1:02:12like some Apple proprietary thing where

1:02:14Apple has to convince everybody to adopt

1:02:16some standards it's just that getting

1:02:18all of any medical things in the US do

1:02:21anything is very difficult because it's

1:02:22a very diverse shall we say environment

1:02:25of providers and technology expertise

1:02:29and motivation and financial incentive

1:02:32to support something like this all right

1:02:34then John in the gifts just keep coming

1:02:36for you you have El Capitan fixes that

1:02:39you're choosing not to install and TV OS

1:02:4211.3 has a new gift for you does it not

1:02:44I really get from me because even though

1:02:46I have an older Apple TV it's not hooked

1:02:50up to a television set that I think can

1:02:52even do 24 frames per second like its

1:02:54cuts up to a crappy TV like a bedroom TV

1:02:57right so anyway the one changed it is

1:02:59most interesting to me in TV OS 11.3

1:03:02which is currently in beta is frame rate

1:03:04matching which was previously only

1:03:06supported on the Apple TV 4k is now

1:03:08supported on the one that looks exactly

1:03:09like the Apple TV 4k but isn't because

1:03:11it doesn't have slots in the box that's

1:03:13mine

1:03:13yeah so now you get that feature too I

1:03:16don't know I also don't know if you have

1:03:17a television that condition was like

1:03:19probably not almost sure I do not yeah

1:03:21but that was the question before is like

1:03:22why isn't this support is it some kind

1:03:24of hardware limitation no they just

1:03:26didn't get around to it software another

1:03:27getting around to it so thumbs up for

1:03:28that alright let's do some ask ATP some

1:03:33guy I've never heard of Todd Vaziri

1:03:35writes with your iPhone 10 experience

1:03:36are there any signs that Apple intends

1:03:39to unify 3d touch and a long press to

1:03:41give the same result or do you feel it

1:03:43that they have every intention of

1:03:44keeping these two gestures separate and

1:03:46distinctive I even looked at gesture

1:03:48recognizers in a while and nor have I

1:03:50really fiddled with 3d touch api's but

1:03:53as far as I can tell and just as a user

1:03:55it seems to me that it's pretty clearly

1:03:58going to be kept separate but I don't

1:03:59know marco have you been looking through

1:04:01these api's more recently to have any

1:04:02thoughts on this I I don't have any

1:04:04thoughts I don't think it's gonna be

1:04:05touched in any meaningful way I think

1:04:08it's gonna stay the way it is now which

1:04:09is basically like you know most things

1:04:11are 3d touch or nothing and occasionally

1:04:15one of the app developers either Apple

1:04:17or third-party

1:04:18will have some good idea oh you know we

1:04:20should make this available with long

1:04:21press eventually and then eventually

1:04:23somebody does it but

1:04:24it's probably gonna always be you know

1:04:263d touch first kind of like how the

1:04:28clear all notifications thing remember

1:04:30wasn't that 3d touch first and then

1:04:32eventually they had a long press it's

1:04:33probably gonna be like that that kind of

1:04:34pattern I'm just like 3d touches first

1:04:37long press if somebody gets to it but do

1:04:40you think like I think part of this

1:04:41question is like are the do the api's

1:04:43make it look like there will ever be a

1:04:44way to like you know coalesce them in

1:04:47terms of you'd write an application to

1:04:48handle one kind of event and both of

1:04:49those things that happen on the screen

1:04:51could funnel into one kind of event or

1:04:53do you think the API still reflect the

1:04:54fact that they are entirely separate

1:04:56entirely separate I mean you could write

1:04:58something like in your app that would

1:05:00you know respond to either one alright

1:05:02and you could write some kind of

1:05:03reusable component to make that easier

1:05:05to do but as far as I could tell Apple

1:05:07has not moved in that direction at all I

1:05:09could be wrong could I couldn't miss

1:05:10something but I don't think so yeah I

1:05:11don't think that we they're just like my

1:05:13impression from the outside not looking

1:05:15at the guys but just looking how they're

1:05:17used is that I would go so far as to say

1:05:19that Apple thinks there actually is an

1:05:21important distinction between 3d touch

1:05:23and long press that should be meaningful

1:05:24in that UI and cases where they merely

1:05:26say long press is just an affordance for

1:05:29people who have devices about 3d per

1:05:31touch are kind of in the minority like

1:05:33it seems like especially as 3d touch

1:05:36spreads to more and more device or at

1:05:37least phones I know because they don't

1:05:38have it on iPads the 3d touch is a

1:05:41different thing than long press now and

1:05:44it may still be an optional thing like

1:05:46oh if you happen to have a device that

1:05:47can support you can get this feature but

1:05:49that is not it's not the same thing as

1:05:51long press despite the fact a lot of

1:05:53people like wish it was that it was just

1:05:54more community long rest and and using

1:05:56the phone from my perspective it feels

1:05:58different to me I wouldn't want it to be

1:06:00just an alternate way to do long press

1:06:01because it just it just feels so very

1:06:04different so I think I'm mostly on the

1:06:05same page for the Apple here despite the

1:06:07fact that it is somewhat confusing to

1:06:08have to explain to people I I don't

1:06:10think they're interchangeable they don't

1:06:11feel interchangeable to me I tend to

1:06:14agree

1:06:15Alex writes what is their play to and

1:06:17why is it so hard for both developers

1:06:19and Apple to implement it so I guess

1:06:22marco jumping whenever you're ready but

1:06:23airplay to is it supposed to be

1:06:26other than multi room stuff which you

1:06:27can't really do with airplay one unless

1:06:29you're using iTunes on a Mac is it

1:06:31supposed to be kind of self-sufficient

1:06:33where it's more like a Google chromecast

1:06:35sort of scenario where you just tell it

1:06:37hey go play this thing

1:06:38over there and it does it all by itself

1:06:40or is that completely wrong

1:06:41that's how about halfway wrong it's so

1:06:43so basically the way our play one worked

1:06:46was kind of like it's not that different

1:06:50from like how Bluetooth audio works just

1:06:52done over Wi-Fi it is you know what they

1:06:54call basically a real-time protocol just

1:06:56a stream that you screaming to the

1:06:58airplay one device there is a fixed

1:07:00latency that all airplay one devices

1:07:02have of two seconds and everything goes

1:07:05over that same stream that same latency

1:07:07audio gets streamed at that rate

1:07:08commands like play pause or seek get

1:07:11streamed at that rate that's why with an

1:07:12airplay speaker if you hit pause in your

1:07:14phone it takes two seconds before it

1:07:15actually pauses and so it was a simpler

1:07:18protocol it was launched forever ago and

1:07:21you know back then things had to be

1:07:23simpler for just technical practicality

1:07:25reasons so airplay one very simple

1:07:28protocol what you're alluding to Casey

1:07:30how how Sonos and the Google cast

1:07:32protocols usually work is basically like

1:07:36the speaker in those cases or like the

1:07:39the casted to device is controlling and

1:07:44and playing the whatever the media is

1:07:47itself it isn't having a device send it

1:07:49a stream of media in most cases the the

1:07:52Sonos speaker or google chromecast

1:07:54whatever is given like a URL and say

1:07:57play play the file here and the client

1:08:01applications are basically giving it

1:08:02commands whenever they feel like it okay

1:08:04pause it now play this thing instead or

1:08:06whatever else but the advantage of a

1:08:08system like that is your phone or

1:08:11whatever is streaming the audio from or

1:08:14causing the audio to be streamed is not

1:08:16actually really involved in the

1:08:18real-time playback so like the example

1:08:20that that look that is often given is

1:08:22like if you go out and take out the

1:08:24trash during a party and your phone is

1:08:26is what's telling Sonos to play this

1:08:28playlist when you leave your houses of

1:08:31Wi-Fi for 30 seconds the music isn't

1:08:33gonna stop it's gonna keep playing

1:08:35because your phone is simply giving a

1:08:36command sometimes when you tell it to

1:08:38it isn't streaming the audio itself the

1:08:40you know the device for so notice in

1:08:42Google class or whatever is is getting

1:08:44the audio itself over the network and

1:08:46only just doing what your phone tells it

1:08:48to when it's time to make changes

1:08:49airplay never worked that way airplay

1:08:51was always

1:08:52real-time streamed from the source

1:08:54device to the speaker question yeah home

1:08:57pod literature or whatever PR literature

1:09:01makes that claim about it that that it

1:09:05you that it's just pulling the music

1:09:07from Apple music not pulling it from

1:09:08your phone but it doesn't currently

1:09:10support airplay - yes so there's there's

1:09:13a few different things here so that what

1:09:16the home pot is doing with Apple music

1:09:17first of all I believe that applies only

1:09:19to Apple music and that is because the

1:09:22home pod does appear from what they're

1:09:23saying to be a native Apple music client

1:09:26in the sense that you can ask it to play

1:09:28something from Apple music I don't know

1:09:30if your phone is involved in the Siri

1:09:32request itself but once it is playing it

1:09:36does sound like I can just keep playing

1:09:37without your phone's presence so that is

1:09:40a separate thing that's not involving

1:09:41airplay too though

1:09:42so what airplay to does is kind of just

1:09:46a halfway point between these are kind

1:09:48of like a better airplay one so what it

1:09:50lets you do is buffer for much larger

1:09:53chunks of data and what Apple said in

1:09:55the UC session about it they said

1:09:58basically think minutes instead of

1:10:00seconds and it lets you buffer faster

1:10:03than real time so you know airplay one

1:10:05was a fixed two-second latency

1:10:07everywhere the streaming device supplied

1:10:09the audio in real time the playing

1:10:11device played it in real time there's a

1:10:12two-second buffer on the playing device

1:10:14airplay to the streaming device is asked

1:10:18to supply the audio as fast as it can

1:10:20faster than real time until the buffer

1:10:22fills up and so your airplay to client

1:10:25program that's playing media has to be

1:10:28able to feed the buffer a lot like you

1:10:31know 5 minutes or 10 minutes or whatever

1:10:32it is of the future audio and then the

1:10:35playing device maintains that buffer and

1:10:38plays it in real time and notifies you

1:10:40of you know what point it has reached in

1:10:43playback and so this changes a bunch of

1:10:46things this is a really big foundational

1:10:50change to how this works there are a

1:10:52number of big advantages so number one

1:10:53is that scenario of taking out the

1:10:55grabbers during a party as long as

1:10:58you're not taking like 20 minutes

1:10:59outside to take the garbage out in which

1:11:00case I would say you have to think about

1:11:02your a home layout that's too much of a

1:11:06trip

1:11:06you know it should be fine you should

1:11:09get back inside in time for that you

1:11:11know minutes long buffer the two do not

1:11:14have to under run itself also you know

1:11:17in as we talked about during Euro ads

1:11:19like a lot of times like places in your

1:11:21house are kind of Wi-Fi dead zones and

1:11:23so the same problem with that was like

1:11:25there's lots of like common scenarios

1:11:27where like if your airplane anybody

1:11:28who's ever done airplay hasn't you know

1:11:30you know this because this has probably

1:11:32happened to you at some point where like

1:11:33you know the person with the phone is

1:11:34walking around somewhere and drops out

1:11:36arrange for a second and the music stops

1:11:37or skips or whatever also another big

1:11:39advantage of this of breaking it out of

1:11:41that like fixed latency model is that

1:11:44commands to change so play pause seek

1:11:47commands those can happen faster than

1:11:50that two-second buffer those can happen

1:11:52basically as quickly as the as the

1:11:53device receives and processes them so

1:11:55like any other Wi-Fi command in your

1:11:57house so it can be really fast so way

1:11:59faster way more responsive playback

1:12:01controls as well as that long super long

1:12:03buffer and it's also airplay one did

1:12:08support multi-room audio in some way I'm

1:12:11not familiar with the details of how it

1:12:13coordinated it but I think only iTunes

1:12:17on the Mac could ever really officially

1:12:19be the source for that there was never a

1:12:21way for it to have an iOS device as the

1:12:24source of multi-room audio with airplay

1:12:26one airplay to that is now possible you

1:12:28cannot do multi-room audio with the iOS

1:12:31device as the source of that so that's

1:12:33another big change I don't really know

1:12:35what has changed by the protocol to

1:12:36allow that but I'm sure it's I'm sure

1:12:37there's a good reason also because the

1:12:41playback buffering and the media supply

1:12:44has been separated from the command

1:12:47interface of like play pause you can now

1:12:50have multiple devices in your house

1:12:52being able to control the play pause

1:12:55type controls of a stream it's playing

1:12:58from not them so like you and your

1:13:01spouse can both have play pause control

1:13:04over the music playing from only one of

1:13:07your phones to the airplay to speaker so

1:13:09also you know fun stuff there's also

1:13:10separation now of phone call status from

1:13:14airplay so you can for instance take a

1:13:17phone call on your phone that is air

1:13:19playing music to a speak

1:13:20and the music continues to play back on

1:13:22that speaker while you're on the phone

1:13:23call that didn't happen before so this

1:13:26and so this is all a lot of major

1:13:28changes and this is I think one of the

1:13:30reasons why this is taking so long - and

1:13:32wide airplay - seems to be the big delay

1:13:34for the home pod this is tons of new iOS

1:13:38api's tons of new background processes

1:13:42and changes to fundamental things in iOS

1:13:44to make all this happen also on the

1:13:49device side on the speaker side you now

1:13:52have this you know long buffering

1:13:55mechanism and that's much more complex

1:13:57than before you know I'm sure Apple has

1:14:00some kind of component or a library or

1:14:02something that they will sell

1:14:03manufacturers to make this easier on

1:14:06them to you know to kind of automate

1:14:08this for them would be like a drop in

1:14:09component or something but it's more

1:14:12complex than airplay one was by a lot

1:14:15and even airplay one the client

1:14:17implementations tended to suck that

1:14:19weren't apples like there was like one

1:14:21airplay chip that every airplay speaker

1:14:22used and it sucked it was unreliable and

1:14:25it was terrible so I'm guessing the

1:14:27delay in the speaker availability is

1:14:29because this is more complex and you

1:14:32know maybe maybe the industry was caught

1:14:33off guard a little bit who knows maybe

1:14:35maybe Apple hasn't actually really

1:14:37finished it yet and they're just not

1:14:38saying that but either way it's a

1:14:40complex protocol and then on the

1:14:42software side on the iOS side and

1:14:45probably the home pod side this is

1:14:48complex III ran into some of this

1:14:50complexity when I started looking at

1:14:51these api's for overcast and the main

1:14:54complexity here is these streaming the

1:14:58music to the buffer is now disconnected

1:15:04from what time stamp or even like what

1:15:07track is actually playing at that moment

1:15:10because you can read ahead by so far

1:15:12like before with the old airplay one

1:15:15model whatever function in your app

1:15:17supplied the audio to the output stream

1:15:20could notify the app as that happened

1:15:23you're now at timestamp one you're now

1:15:25at timestamp two and as soon as it

1:15:27played through a track you can say this

1:15:28track has finished playing you're now

1:15:30playing this next track now it can

1:15:32buffer so far ahead of real time

1:15:34that the production of the audio in your

1:15:37app the thing that is supplying the

1:15:38audio has to be a separate thing

1:15:41entirely from what parts of your app

1:15:44manage what time stamp it's playing at

1:15:47and what track is currently playing and

1:15:49they they've moved all that out now to

1:15:51this new like synchronizer object that

1:15:53you need so like none of this is like

1:15:55difficult to to deal with but it's

1:15:57different it's it's a major change from

1:15:59the way it used to work and there's also

1:16:01things like like for instance if you if

1:16:04your app has like a concept of like a

1:16:05playlist and an item that is coming up

1:16:09it's changed say the user deletes an

1:16:11entry in a playlist or reorder as a

1:16:13playlist and that part has already been

1:16:15buffered you now have to tell the buffer

1:16:17thing oh and everything after this

1:16:19timestamp is now different reload it so

1:16:21there's there's all sorts of big and

1:16:24small changes like that needed to adopt

1:16:25this kind of model and none of them are

1:16:28difficult or impossible it's just a lot

1:16:31of things to deal with it's a lot of

1:16:33change a lot of potential for new bugs

1:16:35or not realizing that old bugs were

1:16:37really bugs and so it's like even doing

1:16:41it for overcast is a is a pretty major

1:16:43undertaking that I'm nowhere near done

1:16:45with I've only done like the early

1:16:48stages of it and now can I put on the

1:16:49back burner because now I know that it's

1:16:51not going to be imminent and I have more

1:16:53pressing things I want to do but it's a

1:16:55big change to audio applications and to

1:16:59these systems in iOS that manage them so

1:17:01I think there's very very good

1:17:04justification for airplay - to be late

1:17:08and for Apple to be running behind I

1:17:10think they should have probably

1:17:11anticipated it better and plan for it

1:17:13better but oh well they're all this is

1:17:15just to say that technically speaking

1:17:16this is a nice improvement it is also a

1:17:19really big job so it's totally

1:17:21reasonable for it to be like you know

1:17:24harder than they might have predicted or

1:17:25taking longer than they predicted you

1:17:28have a fun class of bugs like you could

1:17:29have a bug based on what you described

1:17:31where the speaker is playing a song but

1:17:34but your your player application on your

1:17:37phone indicates that it's playing a

1:17:38different song so I can it goes to the

1:17:40next track you didn't do that

1:17:41synchronization thing that you said oh

1:17:42by the way they've deleted something the

1:17:44your phone will say I'm happily playing

1:17:46song a and you

1:17:47hearing a totally different song comes

1:17:49through the speaker you'd be like this

1:17:50thing is totally broken how does that

1:17:51even happen well now we know how it

1:17:53happens yeah or like as it starts

1:17:55buffering if you didn't do the time

1:17:57stamp you know change of how it reports

1:17:58what time you're playing until then like

1:18:00you can have it if you watch your time

1:18:02thing in the app you started playing to

1:18:04a speaker and your time starts racing

1:18:06ahead by like 10 minutes all of a sudden

1:18:08but you're not hearing at that fast like

1:18:10there's so many or like it races to the

1:18:13end and deletes the file because so it's

1:18:15played already gone like there's there's

1:18:18a lot of potential for big and small

1:18:21bugs here in your application if they

1:18:23change the playback speed midstream you

1:18:25have to invalidate everything that you

1:18:26freeze the uploaded at the other speed

1:18:28yep or if they toggle off smart speed

1:18:31yep anything or if you seek I think if

1:18:34you I don't think it actually does in

1:18:36the current protocol I'm not sure

1:18:37actually does seeking anyway and you

1:18:40know what concern I have too is like

1:18:41this stuff is all so early and so

1:18:43complex and such a big undertaking I'm

1:18:46not sure I want to devote a whole bunch

1:18:49of time to changing my entire audio

1:18:52engine to support this before I know

1:18:54that the API is solid and given that

1:18:58Apple is delaying their own airplay to

1:19:00stuff and I'm kind of worried that maybe

1:19:02the API is not done yet or not baked yet

1:19:04so in it there's another reason why I've

1:19:07kind of paused my work on this for now

1:19:10yeah I could end up like crashing your

1:19:13application in scenarios where their

1:19:14person is not even using airplay to just

1:19:16because of how you had to rejigger the

1:19:17internals which is not a great thing to

1:19:19happen all right what are we in the

1:19:21middle of were in the middle of SKT P

1:19:23right yep okay and rule in limb penning

1:19:27rights could John please detail his

1:19:29method for reading extremely long soft

1:19:31Carver boats without ruining spine where

1:19:33the hell did this even come from what

1:19:35about some other podcast that I'm on

1:19:38that and repair business do I discussed

1:19:40this I think you two should know about

1:19:43it too in the long history of weird

1:19:45things that have anyway I I when I was

1:19:47younger I had a lot of books like paper

1:19:51books before I got on the book bandwagon

1:19:52and I had a lot of paperback books when

1:19:55I was younger and some of them are

1:19:58really thick because I'm big Stephen

1:19:59King fan and

1:20:00books are long and eventually I got into

1:20:03books as a thing that you can buy like

1:20:05sort of a physical object in addition to

1:20:08the words that they contain in fact I'm

1:20:09still like that I read e-books mostly

1:20:11but I still like physical books often I

1:20:13will buy a physical book but still read

1:20:14the e-book anyway we've got a lot of

1:20:17soft covers and I like them I got a lot

1:20:19of series that had cool spines I put

1:20:21them up all on my shelf arranged them

1:20:22they looked nice pretty soon after

1:20:25getting my first collection of

1:20:27paperbacks I decided that didn't like

1:20:28how the books looked when the spines

1:20:30were broken if you opened up a paperback

1:20:31really wide the nice printed spine on it

1:20:35will get a big white you know crease or

1:20:37crack on it and if you read the book

1:20:38eventually you have cracks going up and

1:20:40down the whole spine anyone who has had

1:20:41a big thick paperback book knows about

1:20:44this so I didn't like that so eventually

1:20:46I decided I'm going to read all myself

1:20:48cover books no matter how thick they are

1:20:50without breaking the spine and that's

1:20:53what this question is about how do you

1:20:54do that

1:20:55unfortunately for Andrew the answer is

1:20:57exactly how you would think you do that

1:20:59you don't open the book really wide you

1:21:03support the spine with your fingers

1:21:05behind it and you open it a crack

1:21:07anybody like how are you gonna read an

1:21:08entire literally eight hundred page book

1:21:11peeking into this tiny crevice to read

1:21:14the text out of the you know like it you

1:21:17know there is no secret the secret you

1:21:19know like the technique is put your

1:21:21fingers on the back of the spine so you

1:21:22can feel what's happening at the back of

1:21:24that spine and open it as wide as you

1:21:26can before it greases and just be really

1:21:28really careful and I don't think that's

1:21:30a particularly fun way I read I think

1:21:31people should buy ebooks because they're

1:21:32way better than paper books but paper

1:21:34books you're beautiful so you should

1:21:35still buy them and collect them and

1:21:36display them so how do you use an iPhone

1:21:38without scratching it well you keep it

1:21:40in a small felt pouch every single time

1:21:44you use it you never actually in the

1:21:51pouch ever yeah but what could possibly

1:21:55be more convenient than the pouch is

1:21:59awesome I like here's the thing about I

1:22:01originally I'd started doing it for the

1:22:03reason you you noted for like scratch

1:22:05ability but I have come to appreciate

1:22:06the fingerprint like I don't I don't

1:22:08ever have to clean off my phone screen

1:22:10which is apparently things a lot of

1:22:11people have to do or their phone screens

1:22:12look

1:22:13gusting because every time it goes in

1:22:14and out of my pouch it gets cleaned of

1:22:16course and when it stays in there and it

1:22:18rubs around like it's a microfiber thing

1:22:20it is always cleaning my phone screen

1:22:21that's nice

1:22:23so a year of using my jet-black iPhone 7

1:22:25and you know how much should ever matter

1:22:27how scratched it was not at all

1:22:29you know how much I ever noticed zero at

1:22:32the back I'm talking about talking about

1:22:33the front actually you know what case on

1:22:35that so I don't care about the back I

1:22:36actually do have a small problem with

1:22:38the iPhone 10 I'm getting scratches on

1:22:41my screen really on the front yeah why

1:22:43from what I don't know like they're

1:22:45they're not like deep scratches but you

1:22:47know when the light hits certain angle

1:22:48you can see them and I think I think I

1:22:50heard from a few other people that they

1:22:51were having a similar issue like I've

1:22:53never had I phone screen scratches that

1:22:55noticeable I'm getting scratches on my

1:22:57iPhone 10 like already so I don't know I

1:23:00don't know what's up they like micro

1:23:01like a very micro scratches like maybe

1:23:03they're just scratches in the sort of

1:23:05oleophobic whatever coating and not like

1:23:08actually in the class

1:23:09maybe I mean I get like they they don't

1:23:11look deep like you can't see them at all

1:23:13angles if you turn the screen off

1:23:15they're pretty they're pretty noticeable

1:23:16mm-hmm that's interesting anyway I don't

1:23:18have any online pouch it's an answer it

1:23:24may not be the answer but it is an

1:23:27answer I will concede it is an answer on

1:23:29the back of my jet-black iPhone 7 I'm

1:23:31sure its pristine underneath my leather

1:23:33case good for it I'm sure that's that's

1:23:35gonna really be it's gonna really matter

1:23:37a long term yeah but I've already

1:23:39decided that I'm not speaking of keeping

1:23:41phones pristine I'm not gonna give my my

1:23:45any of my kids this iPhone 7 like I

1:23:48handed down my iPhone 6 and you know god

1:23:51knows what my son is doing to it for the

1:23:527 I'm like no no we'll buy you like an

1:23:55iPhone se use or something but we're not

1:23:57you're not getting my 7 I spent all this

1:23:58time keeping it pristine like this is

1:24:01this I put my iPhone 7 I think is in the

1:24:03category of like my ac30 in my 2008 Mac

1:24:05Pro I really like this phone I mean I

1:24:08grant I've only had two iPhones but this

1:24:09is by far my favorite like there's

1:24:12nothing about it that is bad even the

1:24:15lack of that phone port like I've you

1:24:16know I think as iPhone 7 is great and

1:24:19I'm now appreciating it as my last like

1:24:21pre iPhone 10 not

1:24:23era of Apple phone you know yeah it

1:24:26honestly like you know as we talked

1:24:28about it in our iPhone 7 exit interview

1:24:30segment I like looking back on it like I

1:24:33don't want to go back to it because I

1:24:34like the 10 too much but that really was

1:24:37a great phone like David really it was

1:24:40it was a great phone yeah and it's great

1:24:42too and everything but you know

1:24:43overshadowed by the tensile be like and

1:24:45I didn't get the 8 right so I've got the

1:24:467 and this is my phone that like hit the

1:24:48sweet spot of like the culmination of a

1:24:50long evolution of a particular phone

1:24:51factor before Apple took a hard left

1:24:53turn to iPhone Penland also like the 8

1:24:55doesn't have the jet black finish and

1:24:57that to me was a critical part of why

1:24:58the 7 was so awesome because it so

1:25:00dramatically improved and changed the

1:25:01feel of the phone like it really gave

1:25:04that awesome caseless grip that I miss I

1:25:08you know the iPhone 10 is better than

1:25:11like the previous aluminum ones but it's

1:25:14still not as good as the iPhone 7 grip

1:25:16but I like the rest of it so I'm keeping

1:25:19it I guess even though my screen is

1:25:20scratched anyway thanks to our sponsors

1:25:23this week Casper betterment and SRC and

1:25:25we will talk to you next week now the

1:25:30show is over

1:25:32they didn't even mean to begin as it was

1:25:35accidental

1:25:39[Music]

1:25:41the only research Margaux and Casey

1:25:43wouldn't let him because it was

1:25:46accidentally was accidental and you can

1:25:52find the show notes at ADP CAS pyl ISS

1:26:05so that's Casey less and a are Co a RM

1:26:09auntie Marco Arment SI r AC Syracuse

1:26:23I I really I do this every year I guess

1:26:33this is my my lose weight kind of New

1:26:37Year's resolution even though it's not a

1:26:39resolution it's just something I remind

1:26:41myself of every year and every year you

1:26:43know January comes around I remind

1:26:44myself you know what you should really

1:26:46be less negative Casey up on the

1:26:49internet and stop complaining and

1:26:50moaning about things which I don't think

1:26:51I do

1:26:53overwhelmingly but I do probably more

1:26:55than I should and then something like

1:26:57this happens I see a news report saying

1:27:01BMW is going to charge $80 a year for a

1:27:07subscription of carplay $80 for a

1:27:10subscription of carplay that involves no

1:27:13like cloud services or anything like

1:27:15that of any sort

1:27:16it's just $80 for them to not cut you

1:27:18off for the thing in your car yeah what

1:27:23what huh there's a number of angles to

1:27:28this so like a few people asked when

1:27:30this first came out like well do we know

1:27:32like his Apple charging them dearly and

1:27:33we don't have a firm answer on that

1:27:37apparently somebody heard from some car

1:27:40maker that Apple does not charge fees

1:27:42for car play and there certainly is not

1:27:44an annual fee Apple did say so

1:27:46according to Gruber this is website

1:27:49Gruber says I've now received the

1:27:51following clarification from Apple there

1:27:53is no fee for OEMs for either MFI or

1:27:57carplay integration there never has been

1:27:58and and then every will to my knowledge

1:28:00there are no plans to this change there

1:28:02is no royalty costs or ongoing costs the

1:28:04only cost automakers are those necessary

1:28:06to create the hardware this includes an

1:28:08authentication chip alright that's good

1:28:09okay so anyway so that rules that out

1:28:11but anyway so this does solve a problem

1:28:16I don't think it solves it in the right

1:28:18way but there there is a problem that

1:28:22BMWs as you know case you from having

1:28:24bought them especially I have about them

1:28:26used certain options like this there are

1:28:29options at you know I purchased when the

1:28:31car is new and you can't add them later

1:28:32the car play there's not much reason

1:28:36like it's like a three

1:28:37hundred dollar option normally before

1:28:38this thing there's not a lot of reason

1:28:41that they had to charge three hundred

1:28:43extra dollars they're just doing it

1:28:44because they can because cars like this

1:28:47you know luxury cars especially they

1:28:50charge money for every little thing

1:28:52anything if you want like they've

1:28:54offered for years now they've offered

1:28:56like wireless phone charging where they

1:28:58just put basically a Qi charger in the

1:28:59armrest and they charge you like $700 or

1:29:02some obscene thing for that like that's

1:29:04just the game here when you're buying a

1:29:06high-end car like this many of the

1:29:08brands will nickel and dime you to death

1:29:10over stuff that does not cost them that

1:29:12much to add but they have a captive

1:29:13audience you know it's just like buying

1:29:15a beer at a baseball stadium it's a

1:29:16captive audience

1:29:17you're already spending a lot of money

1:29:18they know that they can get more out of

1:29:21people if they do this so you know that

1:29:24I I don't really fault them for charging

1:29:26separately for this I think it's a

1:29:29crappy luxury experience that not every

1:29:31BMW has carplay like a lot of other

1:29:33manufacturers all of their cars now have

1:29:35carplay or all of certain model lines

1:29:38have it BMWs not doing that that creates

1:29:41a problem if you're looking for a used

1:29:43one and this is a fairly minor feature

1:29:46distinction so if you're looking at used

1:29:48BMWs or if you have acquired a used BMW

1:29:50it might be difficult to find one that

1:29:53has carplay or you might not know until

1:29:55you actually go visit one of the dealer

1:29:57whether the one you're looking at has

1:29:59carplay or not there is a problem that

1:30:01they are now solving that now you can

1:30:04add carplay so I think you can actually

1:30:09like if a car was sold without it and

1:30:10you go buy it use and you want it I

1:30:12think you can add it by starting to pay

1:30:14this fee that's not a great solution to

1:30:16that problem there are way better

1:30:18solutions like honestly you know a

1:30:21decent a well spec BMW cost like over 40

1:30:23grand most of the time you can throw in

1:30:25car play but at no additional charge

1:30:27like there this is this is the kind of

1:30:29thing like you know the brakes aren't

1:30:31optional you know the like that like the

1:30:34air conditioning now comes standard like

1:30:36you know I think car plays is really

1:30:39very quickly becoming one of those

1:30:40features where like people just expect

1:30:42that like it's weird if you don't have

1:30:44it on a nice car these days so they

1:30:48should really include it on all the cars

1:30:50and not

1:30:51charge you this dumphy one of the

1:30:52analogies I heard was like and in cheap

1:30:55to mid price hotels the Wi-Fi is free

1:30:57but in fancy hotels they charge you for

1:30:59it that is definitely not true they

1:31:02charge you for it every no like that's

1:31:06I've heard that saying before and I have

1:31:08experienced some of that where main

1:31:10places I've seen free Wi-Fi are not in

1:31:13the fanciest hotels but kind of in the

1:31:15mid tier ones but once you get fancy

1:31:17they're like well you're already paying

1:31:18so much for the room anyway we'll just

1:31:19add this charge on for the wife yeah

1:31:21well and also like you know

1:31:22see also iCloud storage plans like what

1:31:24we talked about earlier there's this is

1:31:26a captive audience

1:31:27right like iCloud storage cells not

1:31:29because it's a great deal but because

1:31:31you kind of want it it makes the

1:31:33experience way better and what else you

1:31:35gonna do like this is all system

1:31:37integration stuff it's like if you want

1:31:39this experience in the native first

1:31:40party way that works with everything

1:31:42you're probably going to pay whatever

1:31:43they want for it the car plan BMWs is

1:31:45the same thing like you're gonna have to

1:31:47pay whatever they want for it basically

1:31:48so I think the solution here is to stop

1:31:51buying BMWs exactly the problem of like

1:31:54they do have competitors like maybe

1:31:57there's no competitor for car play for

1:31:59you I want integration with my iPhone in

1:32:00such and such a way but you can buy

1:32:02another luxury car that has car play

1:32:05that doesn't charge you this much

1:32:07and one of the points I've seen from

1:32:08people talking about this in terms of

1:32:10pricing it's like well if you get a

1:32:11three year lease and it's 80 bucks it's

1:32:13still cheaper than a $300 up front

1:32:14option which is kind of true and like in

1:32:17the grand scheme of things given like

1:32:19you know like how much they charge for

1:32:21the different paint color it's like an

1:32:23additional twenty five hundred dollars

1:32:24or whatever like if you add it all up

1:32:26the number of absurd things you're going

1:32:28to pay way more for for the life of this

1:32:30BMW that you'll happily pay for it

1:32:32because you want the sparkly red paint

1:32:33or whatever Dwarfs this car plaything

1:32:36but the car everything just just feels

1:32:37punitive because yeah everyone else is

1:32:39giving it to you for free and there's

1:32:41not even a hint of a justifiable reason

1:32:44for it to be an ongoing eternal payment

1:32:46and so just the noise people so I think

1:32:48BMW will is what will either happen

1:32:51either BMW will reverse this or every

1:32:54other luxury car maker will do the same

1:32:55thing it's true it's just I don't know

1:33:00it's just so frustrating because I know

1:33:03like in my

1:33:05that this is a completely unsurprising

1:33:09thing for a luxury car manufacturer to

1:33:11do like the things that BMW charged

1:33:13sport like up until recently and maybe

1:33:15still to this day they they had a

1:33:17tremendous up charge for for xenon

1:33:19headlamps or the high intensity

1:33:21discharge headlamps I guess their LEDs

1:33:23now in all likelihood but for years when

1:33:25when hind in high intensity discharge

1:33:28headlamps were a thing BMWs would still

1:33:32have that as an option like my

1:33:35generation the the early 2010 oh yeah my

1:33:3813 my 3-series that was that generation

1:33:41I didn't get the HIDs they were too

1:33:42expensive

1:33:43right exactly and I will see them

1:33:45constantly to this day they mean you can

1:33:47tell you know what is HIDs and what

1:33:48doesn't but that seemed preposterous to

1:33:51me like I'm not saying that it shouldn't

1:33:53necessarily be paid for but come on it's

1:33:54an option really like you're buying a

1:33:57BMW buying a Mercedes you're buying an

1:33:58Acura whatever the case may be like that

1:34:00that should just be part of the car and

1:34:03I don't know this just seems like such a

1:34:05preposterous absurd thing to nickel and

1:34:08dime people over and it's not as bad as

1:34:10Porsche from what I understand who I

1:34:12guess is the the kings and queens of

1:34:15nickel and diming but it's just gross

1:34:17and I think BMW has been heading more

1:34:18and more this way over time and it just

1:34:21grosses me out and here again I just I

1:34:23don't know what car I should get if I

1:34:25get a new car cuz I'm screwed no matter

1:34:26what what happened to the ultimate

1:34:29driving machine that reviews that slogan

1:34:30anymore I love that slogan I mean to be

1:34:33fair like every be MOU owner has always

1:34:36had this progression with the company

1:34:37and it just rolls into different times

1:34:39it's like yep every BMW owner for the

1:34:41history of BMW has always said whatever

1:34:44happened to the BMW that made you know

1:34:45my first car yeah like now the ones they

1:34:49make today are crap but whatever

1:34:51happened to the MacBook Pros with better

1:34:52keyboards am i right Marco well it's a

1:34:58little bit different when the failure

1:35:01rate changes so dramatically it was a I

1:35:03think your inhaler

1:35:04maybe was him or someone else tweeted a

1:35:05picture of an old power book and all I

1:35:07could think I was looking at that it's

1:35:08like look at the travel on those keys

1:35:11sighs keyboard keys like that was before

1:35:14they even started really flattening them

1:35:15out like they look like just full size

1:35:17and mechanical

1:35:18keyboard key caps right yeah they

1:35:20probably have more travel than the the

1:35:22total thickness of the current proline

1:35:24[Laughter]

1:35:24[Laughter]

0:00:00I was thinking the MacPro design

0:00:01speculation that could be pretty much

0:00:02any time before WTC probably every every

0:00:05time every day is my perspective Asia

0:00:07day all right me I was thinking to like

0:00:11I like I probably like we probably have

0:00:13done too much Mac Pro stuff recently so

0:00:15they could we could use it like a few

0:00:16weeks break from that oh thank god

0:00:18disagree we should start with follow-up

0:00:22Peter van Brookhaven has some thoughts

0:00:26about apples hesitation to do battery

0:00:28replacements and he writes in that one

0:00:32of the reasons that they really don't

0:00:33like to do battery replacements is that

0:00:35if they can't get the battery out

0:00:36cleanly then they'll replace the whole

0:00:39phone but they'll do it for the cost of

0:00:41just that battery replacement so he said

0:00:45he had an older phone I think he said

0:00:47like a 5s or something like that that he

0:00:49still was running on the original

0:00:50battery went to the Apple store he asked

0:00:53them to replace the battery they botched

0:00:55it and so he got himself a brand new 5s

0:00:57for 90 whatever dollars or $30 whatever

0:00:59the cost is now and that that explains

0:01:02to me anyway why they're super reticent

0:01:04to be doing battery replacements unless

0:01:06they're really sure it's necessary yeah

0:01:09and that you know even if you're willing

0:01:11to pay like oh you know just take my

0:01:13money I'm willing to pay for the battery

0:01:14placements like yeah but this battery

0:01:16replacement could change from even from

0:01:18an $80 build with the old price into

0:01:20something that costs Apple you know

0:01:22several hundred dollars to give you

0:01:24basically a brand new phone because they

0:01:26couldn't at the very out but it could be

0:01:28argued well a volt here and stupid fault

0:01:29for making phones that you can't get the

0:01:31batteries out of without destroying them

0:01:32so maybe the next time you design a

0:01:34phone make it easier to get the battery

0:01:36in and out and they probably have

0:01:37because he's talking about a 5s and

0:01:38there's been many phones since then and

0:01:40so designing designing phones for

0:01:43serviceability is I think something that

0:01:45Apple has been he was probably like a

0:01:48narc like the first ones were probably

0:01:49reasonably serviceable just because they

0:01:51were simpler and then they probably got

0:01:53a lot less serviceable as they got

0:01:55thinner and more complicated and I feel

0:01:56like now they go in the opposite

0:01:57direction of yeah we want to make them

0:01:59thin and compact but also try to do the

0:02:03best we can for serviceability so really

0:02:05Apple is you know you're just making

0:02:06problems for themselves they continue to

0:02:08make things that are always glued

0:02:09together and have little ribbon

0:02:11connectors that are all

0:02:13then glued on with adhesives that age

0:02:15and everything like that's that's their

0:02:17own fault so I feel like they have to

0:02:18either just eat this cost or do better

0:02:21about making serviceable phones because

0:02:23they're the ones servicing them moving

0:02:25on we have some news about iOS 11 3

0:02:27which we'll talk about later but one of

0:02:29the things that's come out come out over

0:02:31the last week is that 11 3 will let

0:02:33users turn off the battery performance

0:02:35throttling and I don't really understand

0:02:39this

0:02:40like if the choice is your phone

0:02:42spontaneously dying or just being very

0:02:44slow I'll go with very slow but I say

0:02:47this from the position of not really had

0:02:50a phone that's gotten this performance

0:02:52throttling so maybe I don't really

0:02:53understand how unbelievably unbearable

0:02:56the throttling is but regardless

0:02:5811:3 will add new features to show the

0:03:00battery health and recommend if a

0:03:02battery needs to be serviced so that'll

0:03:03be found in settings battery and are

0:03:05available for the iPhone 6 and later for

0:03:08the more users can now see if the power

0:03:10management feature that dynamically

0:03:11manages maximum performance to prevent

0:03:13unexpected shutdowns which was

0:03:14introduced in 10.1 is on and whether and

0:03:18they can choose whether or not to turn

0:03:19it off this feature can be found in

0:03:20settings battery as well and is also

0:03:22available from the 6 and up yeah this so

0:03:26this is not a great fix to this problem

0:03:29or solution to this need to users it is

0:03:32possible that they needed to do it this

0:03:35way to have that off switch for some

0:03:37kind of legal or a lawsuit or regulatory

0:03:39compliance reason you know they've

0:03:40gotten a lot of crap for this from a lot

0:03:42of different places a lot of different

0:03:43countries but just as a user experience

0:03:46having a switch to let your phone

0:03:48randomly shut down seems very

0:03:51unappetizing and it seems like this is

0:03:59very much a like you know Steve Jobs

0:04:01you're holding your iPhone 4 wrong kind

0:04:03of response from Apple you want a free

0:04:05bumper find take a free bumper we've

0:04:08heard it from a lot of people why don't

0:04:10you just give everybody a case ok great

0:04:15let's give everybody a case yeah like it

0:04:19there there general response and tone

0:04:21with this is not good that interview Tim

0:04:24Cook gave it's better than the Steve

0:04:26Jobs talk

0:04:27you see was actually pretty obnoxious

0:04:29and snarky and everything every

0:04:30communication I've seen about this has

0:04:31been fairly magnanimous and

0:04:34understanding he made the feature itself

0:04:35may seem snarky but I don't think the

0:04:37communication has been Steve Jobs level

0:04:39you want a bumper fine here's a free

0:04:40bumper III thought the the Tim Cook

0:04:43quote about it in that interview a few

0:04:44days ago was pretty bad Oh people people

0:04:47not understanding yet Tim Cook had a

0:04:48couple of statements the media but like

0:04:50honestly Tim Cook should not talk to the

0:04:53media like I really honestly I'm serious

0:04:56like he does not come off well in these

0:04:59kind of interviews whenever he's asked

0:05:00anything of substance it does not come

0:05:02off well well usually his problem is

0:05:04that he's just blinded didn't say

0:05:05anything right so that's but this is a

0:05:07rare case where he showed a little bit

0:05:09of teeth it was like I just think maybe

0:05:11people just didn't really understand or

0:05:13weren't paying attention there was just

0:05:14such BS like that's what you should know

0:05:16STUV the time it's merely what he says

0:05:19has no to information it's just kind of

0:05:20platitude right the platitudes one isn't

0:05:23harmful and I think maybe that's

0:05:24actually a good way to communicate with

0:05:25the people in those venues but it's not

0:05:28like Apple fans you know it's just like

0:05:29whoever is watching you know CNN or

0:05:32whatever whatever you know news network

0:05:34he's on at that moment I think that's a

0:05:35fine communication but it's boring we're

0:05:37not interested in it and he's not gonna

0:05:38say anything new the snark shows a

0:05:41little personality of a nominee he's you

0:05:42know off-base but I think that the

0:05:44strangest bit of communication this

0:05:45actually started and follow up as a

0:05:47story about Tim's communication and

0:05:49changed into now that we have the actual

0:05:50release notes for the 11 3 beta into you

0:05:53know more concrete story but the the

0:05:55original story was Tim Cook was on a new

0:05:57show and yeah he did his normal

0:05:59platitudes that he normally does just

0:06:00sort of saying speaking generalities

0:06:03about stuff that close I'll follow was

0:06:05already new but then he mentioned

0:06:06something about being able to turn off

0:06:07the battery throttling and that's not

0:06:09what Apple's press release said like way

0:06:11back when when they talked about this

0:06:12the press release said oh we're gonna

0:06:13have new battery information and you

0:06:15know old stuff but didn't say anything

0:06:17about being able to turn off so I was

0:06:18like is he like misremembering what they

0:06:21plan to do maybe they talked about

0:06:22having an off switch and he is just

0:06:24misremembering instead it's like no he's

0:06:25much more controlled than that but then

0:06:27he's like essentially breaking Apple

0:06:29news on a random cable news channel like

0:06:32he pre-announced features of the iOS 11

0:06:363 beta

0:06:36like a couple days ahead of time which

0:06:38is weird for

0:06:39Apple so the Riddler who's gonna be was

0:06:41he misremembering or is this a thing

0:06:43they're gonna do but now the story is

0:06:44Tim Cook is breaking news about Apple on

0:06:47cable news shows which is weird well I

0:06:50mean I I think that's his prerogative oh

0:06:51yeah no it's totally up but it's it's

0:06:53it's definitely a change it makes me

0:06:54wonder like it is that like the new

0:06:56version of the controlled leaked to The

0:06:58Wall Street Journal where they just send

0:06:59Tim out and tell him to say that I mean

0:07:01this is not the first time that an Apple

0:07:02executive has like broken some news in

0:07:04an interview like this that that seems

0:07:06pretty clearly you know planned that way

0:07:08okay minor news it's not big news but

0:07:10still honestly that is minor news I mean

0:07:12like the big news was the problem at all

0:07:14the the how they're solving it in these

0:07:16various ways is fairly small news but I

0:07:18do think though just going back to the

0:07:20the actual feature and solution here I

0:07:22don't think this is quite enough what

0:07:26this is basically saying is if this is

0:07:28happening to you we will now display

0:07:30that in this settings battery panel that

0:07:32nobody ever knows better goes to and you

0:07:35know will display it there and so you

0:07:37able to check there to see what's

0:07:38happening that's not good enough because

0:07:40most people will never think to check

0:07:41there or won't know how to check there

0:07:43or won't you know like they just think

0:07:45my phone is slow I need to buy a new one

0:07:47so really I think users need to be

0:07:51notified in some way when their phone

0:07:53reaches a state in which this setting is

0:07:55turned on for them and and I tweeted

0:07:56this earlier a lot of people

0:07:57misunderstood I wasn't clear enough I'm

0:08:00not saying that like every time the CPU

0:08:03gets throttled they should get another

0:08:04notification dialog boxes yeah what I'm

0:08:08saying is that at some point when when

0:08:11your phone has reached some kind of

0:08:12metric as measured by the battery or

0:08:15whatever at some point this setting gets

0:08:17turned on for you without you knowing

0:08:19that needs to be a user notification

0:08:22when that happens and it might be like

0:08:24to be clear we don't know that that

0:08:25that's not happened just the release

0:08:26just say that there's a setting for all

0:08:28we know there is a notification and

0:08:29there is a battery indicator in the

0:08:30status Mart those things could both be

0:08:32true they just you know might not merit

0:08:34mentioning here so the only way

0:08:35unfortunately the only way we'll be able

0:08:36to find out unless is the way you can do

0:08:38this in simulator is there someone to

0:08:40have a phone that's on the threshold

0:08:41between like they'll go to the battery

0:08:43settings screen let's say oh I'm right

0:08:45on the border where it's gonna yell at

0:08:46me if they show some kind of bar graph

0:08:47or something and then just abuse the

0:08:49phone until it crosses that threshold

0:08:50and see if you get

0:08:52and alert of any kind and in a

0:08:55surprising stroke of good news for John

0:08:58your ancient cheese grater is running El

0:09:02Cap is it not it is and you got a little

0:09:06present recently tell me about this I

0:09:08didn't get it because I am installed it

0:09:10but

0:09:10Specter fixes have been backported all

0:09:13the way back to El Capitan and Sierra

0:09:16and of course High Sierra which is

0:09:18extended what they usually do is they

0:09:20back pour it to a few recent versions if

0:09:21you watch are there back in that you

0:09:22don't get the fix I almost don't want to

0:09:25install the fixture so I can get that

0:09:26extra speed which I said best really

0:09:28need in my computer yeah this will push

0:09:31you over the edge yeah but I haven't

0:09:33installed yet but anyway in case you're

0:09:35wondering yes the the fix is backward I

0:09:37already have a safari update which I

0:09:39feel like is you know maybe just as

0:09:40important because the main vector

0:09:42through which unknown software runs on

0:09:44my computer is probably the web browser

0:09:46we are sponsored this week by SRC

0:09:49incorporated engineer new possibilities

0:09:51visit SRC ink.com slash ATP SRC

0:09:56incorporated is a research and

0:09:57development company headquartered in

0:09:58Syracuse New York with offices all

0:10:01around the United States SRC is hiring

0:10:03digital software systems and test

0:10:05engineers along with a slew of other

0:10:07positions you can visit SRC inc i NC

0:10:10comm slash ATP to explore their career

0:10:13options SRC engineers are redefining

0:10:16possible in the areas of defense

0:10:17environment and intelligence their radar

0:10:20and electronic warfare technologies are

0:10:21currently helping to protect war

0:10:22fighters from a variety of threats

0:10:24including roadside bombs enemy artillery

0:10:26and drones in addition to the two

0:10:28competitive salary SRC offers a stellar

0:10:31benefits package such as a 10 percent

0:10:33employer contribution for retirement

0:10:35that's awesome ten percent of your

0:10:37pre-tax salary gets contributed to your

0:10:39retirement fund that is really good they

0:10:40also give employees four or more weeks

0:10:43of paid time off per year that's also

0:10:45amazing and a hundred percent tuition

0:10:47support for continuing education

0:10:49nationally at SRC engineer the life you

0:10:53want for you your family and your

0:10:55community with great benefits and

0:10:57support you'll be able to contribute to

0:10:58something that really matters your ideas

0:11:00are valued be innovative be you together

0:11:03with SRC you can save lives and design

0:11:06better future engineer new possibilities

0:11:08visit SRC inc calm / ATP that's SRC inc

0:11:13calm / ATP thank you very much to SRC

0:11:16incorporated for sponsoring our show so

0:11:21we got some news over the last few days

0:11:24we've gotten some news about iOS 11 3

0:11:26we're gonna talk about that a little

0:11:27later but perhaps more interestingly he

0:11:31says with little confidence the home pod

0:11:33has been officially officially announced

0:11:36it will start shipping on February 9th

0:11:38the pre-orders will open or I guess it's

0:11:41not really pre-orders it doesn't matter

0:11:42anyway the orders will open this coming

0:11:44Friday which at this point may have

0:11:46already happened by the time you're

0:11:47listening to this and we don't really

0:11:49know a whole heck of a lot else this is

0:11:52the kind of product that theoretically I

0:11:54should be excited about many of us I

0:11:56think should be excited about this but

0:11:58it just seems like it's had such a

0:12:00clumsy release cycle and we know so

0:12:04little about it that it's really hard to

0:12:07get excited about it because it seems

0:12:09like it's you know it's coming out late

0:12:11and some key features we're not

0:12:14launching yet they're they're coming you

0:12:15know later this year or whatever and we

0:12:18still don't really know much about it

0:12:20there's still no reviews there are there

0:12:23there's been no like you know hands on

0:12:25or anything there was a very brief press

0:12:27demo last last summer everybody see when

0:12:29they announced it but it was extremely

0:12:31limited there was no speak it was just

0:12:33music playback so it was there's some

0:12:37really big question marks about this

0:12:39product that we just don't know yet now

0:12:41we could we could listen back to this in

0:12:43a few weeks from when people have this

0:12:45and it's amazing and we could listen

0:12:47back to anything we say now and be like

0:12:49well they were so wrong we were so wrong

0:12:51I can't believe that we all thought this

0:12:52product would be weird or suck you know

0:12:55it could turn out amazing we don't know

0:12:56yet but it's just weird that there's

0:12:59this product that I think a lot of us

0:13:02thought would be a major product launch

0:13:04that is kind of just like stumbling out

0:13:06the door been in this clumsy fashion and

0:13:09it's gonna have launched incomplete in

0:13:11its State on launch day there are so

0:13:14many missing features and limitations

0:13:16that I think the potential market for it

0:13:19is

0:13:20not gonna be that big now over time as

0:13:22they lift these limitations we'll see

0:13:24you know it's probably gonna get popular

0:13:26eventually it might not but but I think

0:13:28the chances are more likely than not

0:13:30that it will work long term it's just

0:13:33weird that it's launching in such a in

0:13:35such a clumsy fashion and in such an

0:13:38incomplete state and I still question

0:13:40why that had to be announced last summer

0:13:42I don't question it that much because

0:13:45like this is this was a market that

0:13:48Apple has is late to like its other

0:13:51competitors you know Amazon echo was

0:13:53obviously the first let's all talk to

0:13:54our cylinder and it was out there for a

0:13:56while before Google launched its clone

0:13:58and now Google's been out for a while

0:14:00and finally Apple and O's and those are

0:14:02the big three tech companies and Apple

0:14:04you know it took the longest to decide

0:14:06yes we're gonna make a cylinder that you

0:14:08talk to that connects to our streaming

0:14:10music service right and so everyone else

0:14:13has a big hit start on them everyone

0:14:15else was shipping a couple of companies

0:14:18have had multiple revisions and multiple

0:14:19products and diversify their product

0:14:21lines even Google has a big one and a

0:14:22little one now and an even bigger one

0:14:25that sounds fancy right so other

0:14:26companies have not just done the product

0:14:29for longer but I've had more revisions

0:14:30and this is a case where it just seemed

0:14:33to me that Apple

0:14:36I mean apples very often late to market

0:14:38right but in this case Apple it seemed

0:14:40like it felt self-conscious like we're

0:14:42late but we want you to know that we are

0:14:45we do want to compete in our but we're

0:14:47not ready yet so they had to like

0:14:48pre-announce it no I think they pre they

0:14:51didn't expect it to be this late right

0:14:53so you make your bed you're like oh we

0:14:54can announce this now we think it'll be

0:14:56ready you know not that long from now

0:14:58like within the window of like

0:14:59reasonableness but obviously they

0:15:01they've missed that window and it's

0:15:02pretty darn late at this point and you

0:15:04know how can it be late if they never

0:15:05told you exactly when it would be

0:15:06available just in terms of you know

0:15:08practically speaking if you have a such

0:15:12a limited pre announcement of a product

0:15:13and then say nothing about it for like

0:15:15six months

0:15:16it's that's not good timing it's not

0:15:18good PR you want to get people

0:15:19interested about a product and slowly

0:15:21dole out news building up to a launch

0:15:23not kill people barely anything and then

0:15:25don't say anything about it for many

0:15:26many months that's it's just bad PR so

0:15:28that's why that's why we say oh it feels

0:15:30like it's late that if you had a choice

0:15:32that's not how you do

0:15:33a PR rollout so you know why did they

0:15:36announce it so early if to me my read on

0:15:39that is they felt pressure to get in get

0:15:44their foot in the market ASAP put their

0:15:46quarter on the videogame machine or

0:15:48whatever's I've got next right we're

0:15:50gonna be there and not just like in a

0:15:52vague way but here's the actual thing

0:15:54we're gonna ship it looks like this it

0:15:56sounds like this it probably does other

0:15:57things but don't ask us now right and

0:16:00they had an opportunity to announce that

0:16:02and so they did and I think that is you

0:16:07know it's a sign it's an acknowledgement

0:16:09that Apple agrees with us that they are

0:16:13behind and laid in this market versus a

0:16:15more confident Apple that could say yeah

0:16:17other people have done stuff but we

0:16:20think all the solutions they've done or

0:16:21crappy and we don't feel any pressure to

0:16:23tell you that we're gonna enter this

0:16:25market we're gonna show you our awesome

0:16:26thing I'm ready to see it doesn't matter

0:16:28how late we are that's the other

0:16:30strategy that could have taken and they

0:16:31have with many other things but not with

0:16:33this with this one they said we really

0:16:35feel like we need to tell you that we're

0:16:36gonna be in this market with this thing

0:16:37so that is not a confident move that

0:16:40doesn't that doesn't project confidence

0:16:42anyway and what they had to demo was not

0:16:47like they didn't have anything to say or

0:16:49demo that knocked our socks off either

0:16:50so it was kind of weird and now now that

0:16:53they're gonna roll this thing out it's

0:16:55like a major new product line that will

0:16:58end up rolling out without Apple ever

0:17:00having gone up on a stage and told us

0:17:03all the things that this product can do

0:17:04because they went up on a stage and told

0:17:06us very limited things about this

0:17:08product it's specifically about the

0:17:10audio but not much else

0:17:11and then many many months pass and then

0:17:15here's the product right and people will

0:17:18get you know reviews I'm sure they'll be

0:17:19reviews coming out of the thing around

0:17:21lunchtime or whatever but never did

0:17:23Apple go up in any side of special press

0:17:24presentation or anything and say let's

0:17:26just run down everything about this they

0:17:28do with all the phones with all the

0:17:29iPads even with most of the Macs here's

0:17:31all the features here's all the specs

0:17:32here's all the things about this thing

0:17:33here's what it can do they never did

0:17:35that for this product which is weird

0:17:37even something like a hobby product like

0:17:40the Apple TV they went up on stage and

0:17:42said here's Apple TV you know this is

0:17:45what it does this is what it looks like

0:17:46this is how much

0:17:47it runs you know Mac os10 point for

0:17:50inside don't tell anybody it's mega was

0:17:54ten ten point four enough to many tens

0:17:57they didn't do that this product at all

0:17:59so yeah I'm kind of a salmon Marco this

0:18:03could be awesome and everybody could

0:18:04love it and in particular if I'm trying

0:18:05to think of how ways that this product

0:18:08could be awesome that we are under

0:18:10estimating right now is potentially just

0:18:14the the hardware that this stuff that

0:18:16Apple has shown they've shown like oh

0:18:18it's got speakers and microphones and

0:18:19blah blah blah well and and like they're

0:18:22engineering in regards to audio and

0:18:25sound quality in recent years has been

0:18:27awesome like they have they've

0:18:29dramatically improved the speaker's in

0:18:31most of their products that have

0:18:32speakers including the phones yeah

0:18:35including the phones like like they

0:18:36they've really done a lot in in the

0:18:38areas of audio and speaker engineering

0:18:40recently so I have full confidence in in

0:18:43their proclamations that it is going to

0:18:45sound amazing that it is going to be

0:18:47super advanced in the way it measures a

0:18:49room and and bounce the sound off of

0:18:51walls I bet it will sound amazing but

0:18:53that is just one aspect of this product

0:18:55and there are so many other ones that

0:18:58either sound kind of bad or that are

0:19:01just giant question marks yeah and like

0:19:03the thing about this product is that I'm

0:19:06trying to think of you know it does this

0:19:08track with like the Apple TV they're

0:19:09thinking about the Apple TV is they

0:19:11didn't get the hardware right for a long

0:19:13time they took the wrong approach the

0:19:15wrong OS the wrong size there were you

0:19:17know the really early one was like a

0:19:18little bit too early the puck I think

0:19:20they hit on with everybody else the the

0:19:23better size and price for this kind of a

0:19:26product then they took too long to come

0:19:28up with 4k but now that they've settled

0:19:31down like hardware wise it's reasonable

0:19:34especially now that frame rate at frame

0:19:36rate matching more on that in a little

0:19:37bit with this product I feel like it's

0:19:43possible that they have more or less

0:19:45gotten the hardware right on the first

0:19:46try that the the sound output looks

0:19:50impressive and you know can justify the

0:19:54price because it's got a lot of little

0:19:55speakers and a lot of hardware to be

0:19:57able to do all the magic to make it

0:19:58sound good

0:19:59I think it also has a lot of microphones

0:20:01and it hopefully does a good job with

0:20:04them which is the other important part

0:20:05of this hardware it's clean and clear

0:20:08stand about what it's supposed to be you

0:20:09know not having a screen of any kind

0:20:11it's basically speakers and a microphone

0:20:13the software side is where we we know

0:20:17they have gaps cuz there's features that

0:20:18they they sort of talked about but Arnie

0:20:20and I'm going to ship until later but it

0:20:22is possible that Apple can essentially

0:20:24slowly catch up without actually

0:20:27revising this hardware but merely by

0:20:28shipping regular software updates to

0:20:31make this thing more and more capable

0:20:32and improving Siri and all the other

0:20:34stuff behind the scenes like in other

0:20:36words do you think after the ship's

0:20:38there will be some kind of pressing need

0:20:40for a revised home pod I think this

0:20:42hardware could potentially last a long

0:20:44time they just have to update the

0:20:46software so that's it's not ideal right

0:20:48but it does mean that if they can sell

0:20:51these things and then improve them over

0:20:54time they can build up some loyalty by

0:20:57people yeah I bought this product and it

0:20:58was limited and now it gets better and

0:21:00better as I use it and a year from now

0:21:02they could be selling the quote-unquote

0:21:04exact same home pod and it could be a

0:21:06way better product than it is now

0:21:08because I don't think that there's some

0:21:10essential hardware feature that this

0:21:11doesn't have and especially if the audio

0:21:13is really good it could you know

0:21:15certainly it will have better sound than

0:21:17like the hundred dollar things like an

0:21:18echo or a cheap Google home maybe it

0:21:20will even have better sound then an even

0:21:22more expensive Sonos it's just a matter

0:21:24of them getting their software story

0:21:25together and they can do that not at

0:21:28their leisure but they can do that

0:21:29without revising this product you know

0:21:32essentially so I was gonna get one I

0:21:34don't know I was just about to say like

0:21:37I'm sure knowing me I will end up buying

0:21:40one because this is the moment as always

0:21:42I said I really think it's interesting

0:21:44you have to visit we all have some

0:21:45wonders but you so you're so under lists

0:21:47so you need to also like until I have a

0:21:53way to interact with it as a developer I

0:21:56don't think I'm gonna buy one because

0:21:59there's not a place in my life where

0:22:00this makes sense right now and and of

0:22:03course that might change but right now

0:22:05like given its current limitations like

0:22:08one of the big things is yeah maybe you

0:22:10can replace your TV's speakers with

0:22:12it well you can't have a stereo pair yet

0:22:15right so like because airplay to which

0:22:18we'll get to in a little while

0:22:19airplay to is not yet shipping so one of

0:22:21the things you can't do is have a stereo

0:22:23pair of these things acting as you know

0:22:24two stereo speakers so that that rules

0:22:27out a lot of that already

0:22:28and it also there's no line in like the

0:22:32only way you can receive audio is either

0:22:34via Siri playing things from Apple music

0:22:37or via airplay and right now just

0:22:40airplay one which has some limitations

0:22:42and everything but mmm one limitation by

0:22:44the way has a fixed two-second latency

0:22:46so even if you do some kind of crazy

0:22:49thing where you have something beaming

0:22:50other audio like from your other home

0:22:52theatre components via some kind of

0:22:54airplay bridge to this thing about the

0:22:56latency will be too high even for TVs to

0:22:57compensate for it so there's basically

0:22:59no good way to get the rest of your

0:23:03audio from your TV to this the Apple TV

0:23:07can allegedly airplay to it and use it

0:23:09as speakers and that's probably gonna be

0:23:10nice for you know airplay to when that

0:23:13comes out that's gonna be low latency

0:23:14and everything but that's it so like you

0:23:16could do it if the only input that to

0:23:19your TV if the only source of sound that

0:23:21you want to hear from this is an Apple

0:23:23TV you could theoretically have that

0:23:25kind of setup but if you have anything

0:23:27else a game console other streaming

0:23:29boxes a DVD player blu-ray player like

0:23:32if you have anything else that you want

0:23:34to plug into this you're out of luck

0:23:36a Sonos connect bridge maybe but it's

0:23:38like two people use the computing

0:23:40devices because I would never think

0:23:41about playing my TV through this I will

0:23:43also wouldn't think about playing my TV

0:23:44through an Amazon echo or through a

0:23:46Google home even the big speaker 1:i

0:23:49also wouldn't play my TV through any of

0:23:51the little Sonos things yes so much

0:23:52makes a sound bar that I play you my TV

0:23:55through so almost makes a sound bar and

0:23:57the sound bar can also use the little

0:23:58sono speakers as satellite speakers so

0:24:01you can't stand people do that so Sonos

0:24:04has solutions to this other spirit and

0:24:06like I feel and you know Amazon and

0:24:08Google home I feel like the the kind of

0:24:10speakers that they sell in volume don't

0:24:13really lend themselves to this they're

0:24:14too small but it doesn't really matter

0:24:15cuz like they're more made for like a

0:24:17kitchen or a counter or something like

0:24:18that but if you're gonna have a larger

0:24:21and more expensive speaker that focuses

0:24:23on sound quality one of the big places

0:24:25you put it is in

0:24:26is it is for your TV like you'd replace

0:24:28the speakers for your TV isn't that much

0:24:31bigger though it's not like I'd say it's

0:24:33in between I don't even think it's as

0:24:35big as the Google big speaker whatever

0:24:37they call that one the big rectangular

0:24:38Google one

0:24:39I think it's smaller than that like I'm

0:24:41trying to recall seeing at WWC and I

0:24:43think I was struck by how much smaller

0:24:45was than I thought certainly bigger than

0:24:46an echo and also bigger than than the

0:24:48like traditional little Google home

0:24:52thing not that many but the regular size

0:24:54the air freshener I don't I don't I

0:24:55don't think it's as big as the Sonos

0:24:58play five I don't know when one case he

0:25:00gets as well ask him to measure mm-hmm

0:25:02regardless so like for the market

0:25:04they're selling two which is sound

0:25:06quality and middle come in the middle

0:25:08the price range there I think a lot of

0:25:11people would want it to be that home

0:25:13theater role and it can't do that so

0:25:16again that limits the market it also

0:25:18limits the market that it only supports

0:25:19Apple music and not other human services

0:25:22so far and other streaming services can

0:25:24airplay to it but so far they won't be

0:25:26able to do Siri and now I kind of wonder

0:25:29if I'm ever gonna get overcast Syria

0:25:31intense because anything that would

0:25:33enable overcast but also enable Spotify

0:25:35and maybe they don't want that for the

0:25:37home pop maybe they want to solve a home

0:25:38pod only for Apple music and have you

0:25:40know lock that together and you know to

0:25:41boost the sales of Apple music so this

0:25:43is like the we talked about this before

0:25:45where the cylinders and stuff but this

0:25:46is like the omnivorous box TV problem

0:25:48all what consumers want is a speaker

0:25:52like some kind of speaker thing that

0:25:55they buy that they can talk to that can

0:25:57also play any audio from anywhere right

0:26:00and nobody offers that it's all a bunch

0:26:03of a bunch of islands you know some

0:26:06someone come close like I think the

0:26:07Sonos can play a lot of stuff but can't

0:26:09can you do Apple music by voice command

0:26:10I don't know yes oh wait no I it can do

0:26:14have music I don't think I can do it by

0:26:15a voice command yet yeah it's it's a

0:26:18weird integration that the the the

0:26:19summers product is weird limits but

0:26:21sometimes it's getting closer because

0:26:22some US doesn't have a dog in the

0:26:24streaming service fight so like whatever

0:26:25we'll play Amazon service we'll play

0:26:27google play music will play Apple music

0:26:28if all those companies will let us but

0:26:30everybody else has their own preferred

0:26:32streaming service and is in varying

0:26:33degrees restrictive you know or they're

0:26:36not letting each other play in each

0:26:37other stuff so it's not like you just

0:26:39pick the speaker you like about

0:26:40right and say I'll just gonna pick this

0:26:42figure that looks it looks the best and

0:26:43it sounds the best which would be good

0:26:45for admah like if I was gonna compete on

0:26:47audio I think it said look we we have

0:26:49the best sounding speaker the best

0:26:50balance of speaker performance and price

0:26:52$350 for something it sounds better than

0:26:54a $500 some of us buy it but if it also

0:26:58comes with oh but the only things you

0:26:59can hear over it cause this very very

0:27:01limited set of things we allow you to

0:27:03hear no no like you said no line in and

0:27:05stuff like that although honestly I

0:27:06still think that it's not an intended

0:27:09purpose for this thing to be a TV

0:27:10speaker but a stereo speaker like hey

0:27:12this is the sound system for my small

0:27:13apartment and I could play my music on

0:27:16it that's the thing like if they're

0:27:17gonna promote it as as audio quality you

0:27:20can't connect like a CD player or or

0:27:23even collect your record player yeah

0:27:25like honestly if this is truly going to

0:27:28appeal to people who can drop a $300 on

0:27:30a speaker who want something cool and

0:27:32nice and hip for their for a part of

0:27:33their home that isn't their TV a lot of

0:27:35people would want to connect a vinyl

0:27:37player to it like oh people want to

0:27:38connect other sorry I turned player so

0:27:47this weekend Marcos vinyl Ark they don't

0:27:52have corners so anyway so you know

0:27:57people want people want to connect other

0:27:59components to something to two really

0:28:01good speakers sure not all people but

0:28:04like what I'm saying is basically like

0:28:06this market is being limited by the

0:28:09limitation this device I think pretty

0:28:11severely like that really I think this

0:28:13device is very boxed in right now with

0:28:15limitations like it's appealing to

0:28:18people who like to listen to your music

0:28:20via voice but only Apple music and the

0:28:22voice service is probably gonna be a

0:28:23little bit iffy because that's how Siri

0:28:25has been so it's gonna be probably a

0:28:28mediocre voice service it's not gonna

0:28:31have a lot of integrations with other

0:28:32things that we tend to use these for

0:28:34like you know various smart home devices

0:28:36and everything you have some but it's

0:28:38not gonna have as much as an echo or

0:28:39things like that it's not gonna have

0:28:42almost any third-party services that can

0:28:45integrate with it anything you ask it to

0:28:47do that is not playing music is probably

0:28:49going to fail mysteriously in weird ways

0:28:51because that's how Syrians to operate

0:28:52even if you get it just

0:28:54for the Apple music or for airplane

0:28:56stuff - look who's going to be clumsy

0:28:57for the next six months or so yeah this

0:28:59is for people who are okay spending that

0:29:01amount of money on it who don't already

0:29:03have other kinds of you know speakers

0:29:05that are that also sound good and who

0:29:07don't want a stereo pair because it

0:29:09can't start a repair yet so it's like

0:29:10you care about sound quality but not

0:29:11enough to have a stereo pair and so it's

0:29:14just again it's just more and more

0:29:15boxing in boxing it in boxing box it in

0:29:18so I think it's gonna start out pretty

0:29:21slowly and maybe in a year it'll have

0:29:24all these features and it'll be much

0:29:25better and maybe there'll be another

0:29:26model that's a different price or a

0:29:28different size or something that would

0:29:29expand the market a little bit more but

0:29:31I think it's gonna have a really slow

0:29:34start yeah some of the other Apple

0:29:36specific features are like are you so

0:29:38granted we don't have all the

0:29:38third-party stuff but what can it do

0:29:40that NOAA device can do aside from you

0:29:41know obviously very tight integration

0:29:42with Apple music and of course Siri

0:29:45handing off your phone call the home

0:29:47potter is apparently something else you

0:29:48can do obviously from your iphone only

0:29:50but if you're on a phone call that you

0:29:52start on your iphone you come into the

0:29:53house and you want to hand it off to the

0:29:55ipod for a speakerphone conversation

0:29:57which i think is a good application of a

0:29:59good speaker and a good set of

0:30:00microphone so you can wander around talk

0:30:02and pace like an important executive as

0:30:04you discuss things that's something

0:30:06other devices don't have and of course

0:30:09they're playing up the privacy angle of

0:30:10like we're not going to upload every

0:30:12single thing you say to our servers and

0:30:13keep it there forever and all that

0:30:15business and they do try to tout that

0:30:19anyone can talk to it and that it can

0:30:21play things from Apple music even if

0:30:23you're not there which is something so

0:30:25absurd that I wouldn't even think about

0:30:27it until Apple reassured me that it's

0:30:28not the case like oh I guess they could

0:30:30have done that boy that would have been

0:30:31done but they're not well but there is a

0:30:32big question mark on that though it can

0:30:34play Apple music when you're out there

0:30:35but apparently it does a lot of the Siri

0:30:38processing on the phone on the phone is

0:30:40paired to it and it's only one person's

0:30:42phone of course so the question is how

0:30:45much can I do if that phone like suppose

0:30:47the phone that's paired to it is your

0:30:48spouse's phone and your spouse leaves

0:30:50the house how much does this function we

0:30:53don't know yeah there's also the

0:30:55question that a lot of people had of

0:30:56people like me who are not yet in the

0:30:58streaming music world but who have their

0:31:00own music collections so I have my music

0:31:03collection on my phone that which

0:31:04consists of things from CDs plus things

0:31:06purchase from iTunes my

0:31:08that's our collection my kids have their

0:31:09collections I have my giant fish

0:31:10collection right what if you want to

0:31:13play something from one of those

0:31:14collections that doesn't exist on Apple

0:31:16music is there any mechanism for that I

0:31:18think your only option is to air play it

0:31:20from iTunes or your phone but you can't

0:31:22the home pod can't call it up via voice

0:31:23right but Apple in my case since I'm an

0:31:26iTunes Match described Apple has all of

0:31:28my music in the cloud and it knows it

0:31:30belongs to me but I'm pretty sure the

0:31:32home pod has no idea that I'm talking to

0:31:33it like that that feature is only

0:31:35reasonable you're in the services

0:31:36division that's that's the world of

0:31:38walls and silos that's like your app

0:31:41your iTunes Match silo is over there

0:31:44rotting in the corner with really big

0:31:45thick walls nobody can get into so they

0:31:47built this new silo over here if we wrap

0:31:48the music and other stuff and God knows

0:31:50what's gonna be next and it's you know

0:31:51don't expect any of this stuff to talk

0:31:53to each other yeah so but you know we

0:31:56don't know what all the limitations are

0:31:58but it seems like there's a lot of them

0:31:59but I still keep coming back to if they

0:32:01got the hardware right and of all all

0:32:03the speakers and the microphones are all

0:32:04great there's no reason they can't knock

0:32:06down these limitations one by one and

0:32:08eventually have a competitive product

0:32:10and I keep comparing it to Apple TV

0:32:11because they didn't have the choice of

0:32:12the Apple TV they got the hardware so

0:32:13wrong in the beginning it took them a

0:32:15long time to get it right and now I feel

0:32:19like they're finally at the you know the

0:32:20the fat part of the curve or the Apple

0:32:22TV where they gonna start knocking down

0:32:23the software features and you know

0:32:25becoming competitive yes they're premium

0:32:27price but now they have some you know 4k

0:32:31support they have you know features that

0:32:33video files care about like the

0:32:35framerate matching they have an

0:32:36application ecosystem you know they're

0:32:39they're improving in that area and

0:32:40there's this home pod like best-case

0:32:44scenario it launches it sounds really

0:32:46good but it's super limited and not a

0:32:48lot of people buy it and then over the

0:32:50course of the next year all they do is

0:32:51make the software better and you know

0:32:54it's it might take a while like how long

0:32:56did it take you know Google home just I

0:32:58think the last year or so got the

0:33:01feature where it understands that there

0:33:02are different people talking to it and

0:33:03it can understand who that person is

0:33:06hopefully we won't date but I take Apple

0:33:09as long as it's a Google to do that but

0:33:11I see I see potential as long as the

0:33:14hardware is right but all that said I'm

0:33:16not running out to buy this Hardware

0:33:18only Casey is

0:33:19you know a lot of people are gonna wait

0:33:22until they have the complete story and

0:33:23not just buy it based on the promise as

0:33:25they should so I've been thinking about

0:33:28this a little bit over the last couple

0:33:30of days since this news is broken and I

0:33:32am NOT ordering a home pod immediately I

0:33:35will probably knowing the order one not

0:33:37too long after immediately because the

0:33:39FOMO will get to me but I think the

0:33:43thing that appeals to me in principle is

0:33:45that I do trust Apple to make really

0:33:49clever in good choices with regard to

0:33:52audio fidelity and although I am

0:33:54perfectly happy listening to music or

0:33:56podcasts on speakers that are truly and

0:33:59utterly terrible that doesn't mean I

0:34:01don't also appreciate some really really

0:34:03great speakers as well and the what I

0:34:07have in our home theater is not great it

0:34:10is sufficient I don't even know what it

0:34:11is it was like a Denon Dean on whatever

0:34:13it's called like home theater in a box

0:34:15from probably 10 plus years ago

0:34:17it is sufficient but I have no doubt

0:34:21that one or particularly a pair of home

0:34:23pods would be considerably better

0:34:26sounding and that would be appealing to

0:34:30me but knowing that I won't be able to

0:34:33play Spotify easily without airplane to

0:34:36Marco's point knowing I won't be able to

0:34:38say hey dingus can you play me

0:34:41such-and-such song by such-and-such

0:34:42artist without being an apple music

0:34:44subscriber which I'm not like all of

0:34:46these things make it not terribly

0:34:48appealing and I don't also I don't have

0:34:50anything connected to homekit right now

0:34:52I have several devices that I could

0:34:55connect to homekit via $50 bridges but I

0:34:58have nothing that's natively connecting

0:35:00to home kid at the moment so I have a

0:35:02few you're missing nothing okay fair

0:35:04enough

0:35:05I don't really sitting here now and this

0:35:08is when we'll play this back you know

0:35:09mark will do that to Lulu in like three

0:35:11weeks when I say I just bought one but

0:35:13sitting here now I don't really see I

0:35:15don't really see any draw other than

0:35:18just getting a really great set of

0:35:20speakers and that does that definitely

0:35:22you know intrigues me and it's

0:35:23definitely interesting but I have a div

0:35:26sufficient set of speakers that's zero

0:35:29dollars because we bought them ten years

0:35:31ago I think they were a gift but anyways

0:35:33they

0:35:33we already have them I don't know that

0:35:36one $350 speaker is going to sound

0:35:38better

0:35:39the it's enough better to justify it

0:35:42then our quote unquote free speakers

0:35:44that we have now so I'm curious to see

0:35:47what people like real-world people say

0:35:48after these are in the wild but I don't

0:35:51know I think the reviews would have to

0:35:52be pretty stellar for me to start saying

0:35:54oh wow I really screwed up on this one

0:35:56as with every other Apple product I need

0:35:58one let me reiterate one last time do

0:36:00not connect this to your television it

0:36:01is an inappropriate application we are a

0:36:05sponsor of this week by betterment get

0:36:06up to one year managed free at

0:36:08betterment comm slash ATP betterment is

0:36:11the largest independent online financial

0:36:13advisor it's designed to help improve

0:36:15customers long-term returns and lower

0:36:18your taxes for retirement planning and

0:36:20building wealth and other financial

0:36:21goals betterment takes advanced

0:36:23investment strategies and use the

0:36:24technology to deliver them to more than

0:36:26300,000 customers betterment offers you

0:36:29personalized advice for your financial

0:36:31planning needs so based on the

0:36:32information that you tell them they can

0:36:34make tailored recommendations for how

0:36:36much to invest how much your risk to

0:36:37take on in your portfolio and the type

0:36:39of investment account or accounts you

0:36:41should have they also have great

0:36:42features like betterments socially

0:36:44responsible investing portfolio this

0:36:46gives you the flexibility to reduce your

0:36:48investment in companies that don't meet

0:36:49certain social environmental and

0:36:51governance benchmarks and they do all of

0:36:53this with very low transparent advisory

0:36:56fees compared to traditional services

0:36:57for instance they have only a 0.25

0:37:00percent annual fee for their base plan

0:37:02with unlimited messaging access to their

0:37:04team of licensed financial experts and

0:37:05if you have a more complex situation

0:37:07betterment premium gives you unlimited

0:37:09phone call access to the team of

0:37:11certified financial planners for only

0:37:120.4% annually and betterment users tax

0:37:15saving strategies to help increase your

0:37:17after tax returns everything they do is

0:37:20designed to lower your taxes and

0:37:21increase returns on average their tax

0:37:23coordinated portfolio could increase

0:37:25portfolio value by an estimated 15% over

0:37:2830 years investing involves risk

0:37:30listeners can get up to one year managed

0:37:32free for more information visit

0:37:34betterment comm slash ATP once again

0:37:37it's betterment comm slash ATP thank you

0:37:39to betterment for sponsoring our show

0:37:42[Music]

0:37:44we have some news as I've been alluding

0:37:47to you for a while for iOS eleven point

0:37:49three so in a slightly surprising move

0:37:52Apple has made a kind of sort of PR site

0:37:56it's actually just a news article but

0:37:59it's almost like a mini site about iOS

0:38:02eleven point three so the headline is

0:38:04major updates they are kit messages and

0:38:06more coming this spring and they start

0:38:08off by telling us we're getting a lion

0:38:10an emoji they're getting we're getting a

0:38:13dragon we're getting a skull and I

0:38:15thought there was one other dragon an

0:38:17emoji this is my problem of not knowing

0:38:19what the plural of an emoji including

0:38:20new an emoji does that mean more than

0:38:22one for new iOS eleven point three

0:38:25includes four new an emoji giving iOS or

0:38:27excuse me iPhone ten users the ability

0:38:29to express themselves as a lion bear

0:38:31dragon or skull oh I see it later than

0:38:34later section at the line is up top I

0:38:36see okay yeah that's the most important

0:38:38new feature as far as I'm aware most

0:38:41people I know you're probably snarking

0:38:43and the thing is I actually really do

0:38:45still like an emoji but that being said

0:38:48I haven't sent or received an an emoji

0:38:50in like a month or two it's not like

0:38:53knowing that they exist yeah yeah

0:38:55they're cute they're cute and they're

0:38:56little an emoji drawer they're waiting

0:38:58for me if I need them no I I don't know

0:39:00I was thinking about it even before this

0:39:01announcement that I really do think it's

0:39:03cute and clever but I I don't often find

0:39:06myself in a position that a it's not

0:39:08socially awkward to create and send one

0:39:10and be that I even think to do it in the

0:39:12first place I really do think it's a

0:39:14good idea I don't fault them for the

0:39:15idea and I like that they're adding more

0:39:17an emoji and in fact I think I tweeted a

0:39:19while back that it would be cool if they

0:39:21had like seasonal ones like you could

0:39:22only do Santa when it's Christmastime or

0:39:24something along those lines but it goes

0:39:26back on the Disney Vault you're a

0:39:28terrible person yeah seriously no I mean

0:39:30I hate the Disney Vault but it I do

0:39:33think it would be kind of cool

0:39:34but anyways I'm not using an emoji in

0:39:37that kind of it's a little bit so maybe

0:39:39it's a new audience for your analogy he

0:39:42does get a kick out of them actually

0:39:43just the other day he asked me he asked

0:39:45me if I could show him the video of the

0:39:47Fox singing which is I think the

0:39:48Bohemian rad Bohemian Rhapsody video

0:39:51that had come out like one of the first

0:39:53karaoke ones he really likes watching

0:39:56and so he had had me pull that up on

0:39:59YouTube just a day or two ago but anyway

0:40:03also new and 11.3 a our kit which

0:40:05apparently is now understanding what a

0:40:07vertical surfaces which no snark I guess

0:40:10is a big deal I don't really use a our

0:40:12kit for anything that's actually like no

0:40:15being able to recognize vertical

0:40:16surfaces in addition to horizontal and

0:40:18having some other improvements in the

0:40:20kind of surfaces they can recognize and

0:40:21how it just it broadens the applications

0:40:23of it basically like before it's like

0:40:25alright finds find a big flat table or

0:40:27if the floor or something and then you

0:40:29can do this cool thing and now you can

0:40:31do cool things with walls and other like

0:40:33so it just it broadens the possible

0:40:36applications you can make and it

0:40:38improves existing excuse me applications

0:40:41or it gives them the chance to be

0:40:43improved and there's other improvements

0:40:45to a our kit too but I'm not really

0:40:47qualified to recognize what's good about

0:40:49them but it's it's significantly

0:40:50improved but the main I think the main

0:40:52story around a our kid is that our kit

0:40:56was their first try at this and it was

0:40:57pretty impressive out of the gate like

0:40:59we all tried and it worked I think

0:41:01better than most of us had any right to

0:41:02expect especially if you have tried any

0:41:04of the previous sort of academic type

0:41:06things and seeing what they can do this

0:41:07was a commercial product they ran on

0:41:09everybody's phones that work

0:41:11surprisingly well and it hasn't been

0:41:13that long and they've significantly

0:41:15enhanced it so I feel like the AR kid

0:41:18team is doing well there their initial

0:41:20release was good and they're not waiting

0:41:22then unable waiting does Nebuta receive

0:41:24for new features like this because like

0:41:26Margot said I think Wallis's is a

0:41:27significant new feature and there have

0:41:29been like applications unlike perhaps an

0:41:32emoji which maybe people get bored by

0:41:34the the applications that you would

0:41:36think you could build with a our kit

0:41:37like a thing to try furniture in your

0:41:39room like IKEA has an app like that and

0:41:42guess what it does what they say it does

0:41:45surprisingly well for a thing that just

0:41:48runs on your phone doesn't require this

0:41:50crazy rig with five cameras slapped

0:41:52together by some PhD student so I'm very

0:41:55impressed with a our kit and

0:41:57and Presta they keep getting better all

0:42:00right what else is in this messages

0:42:03thing messages and iCloud is back yeah

0:42:06this is connected yeah that very

0:42:09unexpected but very welcome assuming

0:42:11that it works I haven't tried it yet

0:42:12have you guys know is it actually in

0:42:15this beta is the the some things aren't

0:42:17in this video is in the beta batteries

0:42:20yeah the the messages and I thought I

0:42:23think I know it's prompting people to

0:42:25enable it so I think it is in the beta

0:42:27but it's like for me personally I'm not

0:42:30gonna have much use for this until it

0:42:33also works with my Mac you know it's

0:42:35like that's that that's the big question

0:42:36work for me and and also like if there's

0:42:38any hint that it doesn't quite work it

0:42:41that it isn't fully baked yet then I

0:42:43might be afraid to turn it on for a

0:42:44little while but they did take so long

0:42:47to do it that I I'm confident that they

0:42:49were probably really conservative about

0:42:52this because it's so important to get

0:42:53that right so it's probably gonna work

0:42:56fine yeah but but word of warning to

0:42:57everybody like when you're running beta

0:42:59software like this is the reason I have

0:43:01a whole set of other Apple IDs that are

0:43:03not my Apple IDs for when I was doing

0:43:04Mac OS 10 reviews when you're running

0:43:08betas and there's some feature that has

0:43:10cloud integration that especially if it

0:43:12wants to like take some existing set of

0:43:14data and like bring it to the cloud or

0:43:17I've heard it from one cloud back-end to

0:43:19another their betas like they're not

0:43:22done they might have bugs but that's

0:43:24your non beta data right like that's

0:43:27your real so if you don't want your non

0:43:31beta data to be potentially hosed and

0:43:33you can't restore that like like if

0:43:36something goes wrong with the phone you

0:43:37can restore the phone back to an old

0:43:39version you can't restore your data in

0:43:41the ini cloud back to an old version yes

0:43:44but especially gets scrambled or deleted

0:43:46or hosed in some way so be very careful

0:43:49and it like you know you're probably

0:43:50excited like oh I want to try out this

0:43:52new feature or whatever but beta is not

0:43:55done and yes I said whenever I would

0:43:57test beta asses and do reviews whole

0:44:00separate world of data which it was free

0:44:02to completely hosed and sometimes it did

0:44:04and sometimes I have to wipe all I did

0:44:06and re-enter a bunch of fake data for it

0:44:08or whatever

0:44:10so beware but anyway it looks like that

0:44:12feature is back after basically entirely

0:44:14disappearing from their website and now

0:44:16it's back and like Marco it really

0:44:19doesn't fulfill its promise for me until

0:44:21it has a Mac equivalent which I'm

0:44:22assuming it will eventually but I'm I'm

0:44:24glad it's not waiting until iOS 12 foot

0:44:26it that way

0:44:26what is this really but what does it buy

0:44:29me there's messages in the cloud because

0:44:31I still sort of get everything coming in

0:44:34of kind of obnoxiously you know what I

0:44:36mean like when I start a mag you're

0:44:38you're a lucky person yeah I mean so so

0:44:40basically what it buys you is it should

0:44:43in theory first of all it should fix a

0:44:46lot of the inconsistencies people see

0:44:47like so it's syncing the messages with

0:44:49iCloud rather than rather than depending

0:44:52on this crazy like you know key

0:44:54generation sharing thing between

0:44:56different computers and like the way it

0:44:57works security wise is is really

0:45:00complicated and pretty impressive but

0:45:01unfortunately creates a lot of bugs and

0:45:04practice that cause people to have

0:45:05things like messages appearing on all

0:45:07but one device or messages appearing in

0:45:10different orders and different devices

0:45:11and things like that

0:45:13this should if if done correctly and if

0:45:17done well this should make your messages

0:45:19the same on all your devices and it also

0:45:22brings additional benefits of things

0:45:26like if you set up a brand new Mac from

0:45:28scratch for instance and you log into to

0:45:30iMessage you don't get all the old

0:45:32messages also if you delete a

0:45:36conversation somewhere like if you get

0:45:37spam and you delete it in one place it

0:45:40doesn't get deleted on all the other

0:45:41devices it like you have to delete

0:45:42delete delete conversations in every

0:45:44place separately so like there's there's

0:45:46a lot of big and small benefits to this

0:45:49if it works correctly and completely

0:45:52that is a big if but if they can pull it

0:45:55off the benefits are pretty big yeah

0:45:57like well I think of this is aligning

0:46:00messages with the mental model I've

0:46:02always ended I had in my head about

0:46:04messages that there's one conversation

0:46:06that participate in from different

0:46:09devices but it's always one conversation

0:46:11right in the same way that our show

0:46:13notes document it's one show notes

0:46:16document I can edit it on my phone I can

0:46:18edit on my iPad I can edit on my Mac at

0:46:20work I can

0:46:21I can home and you guys can all do the

0:46:22same from whatever devices you have but

0:46:24wherever I go the document looks like a

0:46:26document that's how I my mental model of

0:46:28iMessage conversations I'm conversing

0:46:31with the person and no matter where I

0:46:32converse with them the conversation is

0:46:34the conversation so it's jarring to me

0:46:36they would be jarring to me like the new

0:46:37Mac setup to set up a new Mac and not

0:46:39see that conversation at all or could go

0:46:42to my Mac at work and not see a bunch of

0:46:44messages that I had sent previously on

0:46:46my phone because my Mac was asleep

0:46:47during that time and they didn't

0:46:48propagate or whatever now people who

0:46:50don't have these problems and

0:46:51everything's in sync if you limit the

0:46:53number of places you converse and and or

0:46:57if you're mess if your devices are

0:46:59always online at the same time to accept

0:47:01the propagations and all the

0:47:02propagations work then maybe you won't

0:47:03notice that but I think that's the

0:47:06mental model most people have that it is

0:47:08that it is a conversation and it's the

0:47:10same conversation everywhere so that's

0:47:11the promise of this one one more feature

0:47:13by the way that Apple touts is actually

0:47:14the first bullet point in their little

0:47:15screen is free up space on your iPhone

0:47:18by keeping photos and other attachments

0:47:19in iCloud which right now like you'd be

0:47:23surprised at how much space your

0:47:24messages thing takes up if you go to

0:47:26this you know because people send you

0:47:28videos and they send you photos and you

0:47:29don't want to delete things who's there

0:47:31Cubans maybe something sometimes you

0:47:32save them to your photo library or

0:47:33whatever and one of the prompts for the

0:47:36Iowa storage screen is like hey if you

0:47:38want to save up some space you can

0:47:39delete some all messages would be like I

0:47:40don't want to delete all that stuff well

0:47:42now apparently it will take the big

0:47:44attachments and put them in iCloud and I

0:47:45guess only when you scroll back to them

0:47:47will it download them on demand or

0:47:48something so anything's it frees up

0:47:50space on our phone by using cloud

0:47:51storage that were already paying for

0:47:52it's good so that's another potential

0:47:54advantage that doesn't speak to the the

0:47:57mental model but it's good that's a huge

0:47:59advantage in practice lots of people

0:48:01have like massive you know multi gig

0:48:03message multi gig messages that are just

0:48:05sitting there taking up space in their

0:48:07phone that they don't want to delete the

0:48:09the upside of this is great you'll have

0:48:11this option iCloud to store this things

0:48:13in to free up space in your phone so you

0:48:15won't be always running out of space the

0:48:17downside is Apple's still pretty stingy

0:48:19with iCloud stores oh you're gonna need

0:48:22one of the paid plans and and possibly

0:48:24even one of the larger plans so that

0:48:27that is going to make this hurt for a

0:48:29lot of people but I I think at this

0:48:32point

0:48:34if you want a good experience using

0:48:36Apple devices you're gonna have to just

0:48:39factor in the price of a you know small

0:48:41to mid-size iCloud storage plan at least

0:48:43like it just as when you're deciding

0:48:45whether to whether to have an iPhone you

0:48:46just plan for this because in reality

0:48:50you're going to need something beyond

0:48:53the free you know five megabytes of

0:48:55space they give you and I I'm that was a

0:48:57joke not a measure and bring the unit it

0:48:59feels like five megabytes right it does

0:49:01right like it might as well be it might

0:49:03as well be five kilobytes like that like

0:49:05in in this day and age with the amount

0:49:06of stuff that's stored in iCloud that's

0:49:08that is kind of insulting but it's at

0:49:11this point I'm also I've given up on

0:49:14like trying to like wish and hope that

0:49:16Apple's gonna raise the free limit on

0:49:18iCloud and make the plans all bigger and

0:49:20super price competitive like no they're

0:49:22not going to they they're making a ton

0:49:24of money the way it is now they're not

0:49:25gonna change that

0:49:26so oh well that you've acted in as the

0:49:29cost of having these devices that if

0:49:30you're going to have this and you want

0:49:32the full experience of having the luxury

0:49:34of iCloud doing all these things for you

0:49:35and doing backups and everything else

0:49:37you're gonna have to pay for an iCloud

0:49:38plan and that's just part of it and by

0:49:40the way the one of my tips for general

0:49:42happiness of using iOS things is like

0:49:44this is a problem a lot of people have

0:49:45like I'm not paying for iCloud storage

0:49:47which I understand it's expensive as

0:49:49Marco said it's not as competitive as it

0:49:51should be and they should give you more

0:49:53and it should be cheaper but in the

0:49:56grand scheme of things it doesn't cost

0:49:58that much money to get more storage and

0:50:00it will like the the amount of the

0:50:04amount of improvement to your computing

0:50:05life that you will get for $10 a month

0:50:07of actually just paying for our cloud

0:50:08storage it's well worth the $10 a month

0:50:11right well as far as I'm concerned well

0:50:13worth it because I hate having to deal

0:50:15with storage problems and running out of

0:50:16room and trying to manage things and

0:50:18like you know especially for things like

0:50:20photos if you used the photos in the

0:50:22cloud feature you're not going to delete

0:50:23your photos but are you gonna do when

0:50:24you're in a storage you're just gonna

0:50:25you know complain and grind your teeth

0:50:28it's like just just pay for the storage

0:50:30I know it's bad and with the family plan

0:50:31by the way though you can pay for

0:50:33storage for your whole family if you

0:50:34have a family and they all have devices

0:50:36the family plan is another good way to

0:50:38not have to have stupid individual bills

0:50:40for like your kids iCloud backup and

0:50:42your other kids iCloud backup and your

0:50:44spouse's iCloud

0:50:45now you can do one bill and that will

0:50:48further encourage you to get the big

0:50:49plan for the whole family

0:50:51and yes it cost money but ten dollars a

0:50:54month for someone who can afford Apple

0:50:56devices is not that much it will really

0:50:58improve your life and it's I think it's

0:51:00mostly a mental barrier like you know

0:51:02people just don't want to pay for it in

0:51:03the same way they don't want to pay for

0:51:04applications but overcome that hurdle

0:51:06yeah I would put it this way you know

0:51:08for like people who do tech support for

0:51:11their families just just by your parents

0:51:14like don't tell them you're doing it but

0:51:15just by them pay them the $10 a month

0:51:18secretly pay for their storage plan like

0:51:20that is another great investment of your

0:51:22money the amount of aggravation you have

0:51:25doing tech support and your parents if

0:51:26you just secretly pay for the one

0:51:28terabyte storage plan and put and put

0:51:30them in a family with together and pay

0:51:31for their storage plan enable iCloud

0:51:34backup on all their devices just don't

0:51:35even tell them just pay for it all just

0:51:36do it yourself you will improve

0:51:39everybody's life oh yeah yeah like

0:51:40because we always advise people doing

0:51:42that on their parents computers to

0:51:44install like Backblaze or your cloud

0:51:46backup of choice and just pay for just

0:51:48yeah just pay just do it for them pay

0:51:49for it because you know you as like the

0:51:52the young adult probably don't care the

0:51:54old people won't pay for it and yeah and

0:51:56so it's like they need this you know

0:51:58that they don't

0:51:59so you just pay for it so on computers

0:52:01that's Backblaze on their phones and

0:52:03iPads

0:52:04it's iCloud storage yeah your your

0:52:07parents who have retired on their

0:52:08astronomical pensions that they only

0:52:11exist for generation after who are

0:52:14taking vacations to Hawaii and living in

0:52:17luxury and buying fancy cars will never

0:52:20pay $10 a month what am I getting for

0:52:23that money I have to pay for storage no

0:52:26thanks I don't need backups it doesn't

0:52:28make sense but that's that's the mindset

0:52:30so you know since you're the one doing

0:52:33tech support just just pay for their pay

0:52:35for that $10 a month they carried you

0:52:36for nine months in their body right so

0:52:38the least you can do we respond to this

0:52:42week by Casper you can get fifty dollars

0:52:45towards select mattresses by visiting

0:52:46Casper comm slash ATP and using code ATP

0:52:49at checkout terms and conditions do

0:52:51apply Casper mattresses and other

0:52:53products are designed by humans for

0:52:56humans these are cleverly designed to

0:52:58mimic

0:52:58human curves and support our comfort for

0:53:01all kinds of bodies Casper's experts

0:53:03work tirelessly to make quality sleep

0:53:06services that cradle your natural

0:53:08geometry in all the right places

0:53:09the original Casper mattress combines

0:53:11multiple support of memory foams for a

0:53:13quality sleep surface with just the

0:53:15right amounts of sink and bounce the

0:53:17breathable design helps you sleep cool

0:53:19and with over 20,000 reviews and an

0:53:21average of 4.8 stars Casper is very

0:53:24quickly becoming the Internet's favorite

0:53:26mattress and now they offer two other

0:53:28mattresses the wave and the essential

0:53:30the wave features a patent-pending

0:53:31premium support system to mirror the

0:53:33natural shape of your body and the

0:53:35essential has a streamlined design at a

0:53:37price that won't keep you up at night

0:53:38Casper also offers a wide array of other

0:53:41products like pillows and sheets to

0:53:42ensure an overall better sleep

0:53:44experience and all of these wonderful

0:53:45products are designed developed and

0:53:47assembled in the US Casper gives you all

0:53:50this at affordable prices because they

0:53:52cut out the middlemen and sell directly

0:53:53to you if you aren't completely

0:53:55satisfied you can return it with no

0:53:57hassle with a 100 night risk free home

0:54:01sleep on it trial a hundred nights sleep

0:54:04on it if you don't like it you can

0:54:05return it no questions asked hassle free

0:54:07it gets delivered right to your door in

0:54:10a remarkably small box and there's free

0:54:11shipping and returns within the US and

0:54:13Canada I have a Casper mattress and I

0:54:16got to say the hype is real it's great I

0:54:18love it and I don't I won't go back so

0:54:20check it out today at Casper calm slash

0:54:23ATP you can get fifty dollars towards

0:54:26select mattresses with that code ATP

0:54:28there at checkout terms and conditions

0:54:30do apply once again Casper dot-com slash

0:54:33ATP and code ATP at checkout to get $50

0:54:36toward select mattress as terms and

0:54:37conditions apply thank you so much to

0:54:39Casper for sponsoring our show all right

0:54:44what else in 11 three iBooks is no more

0:54:47it's just plain books it's not no more

0:54:49yeah they just renamed it I mean this is

0:54:51the most substantial iBooks update in

0:54:52years I think we did something recently

0:54:56I know the updated iBooks Author I think

0:54:57recently but uh yeah iBooks was the

0:55:02second thing to get the iBook named

0:55:05after the old computer and now it's got

0:55:08its eyes stripped away joining what is

0:55:11it joining

0:55:12music what are the other generic ones

0:55:15well numbers I guess maybe pages the

0:55:18generically named applications now it's

0:55:21just called books and as Jason Snell

0:55:24said on Twitter I wonder if there's some

0:55:25other hardware product Apple could use

0:55:27the iBook name for what he's referring

0:55:29to of course is iOS laptops which we

0:55:31talked about last show and yeah that

0:55:33would be a good use and it would be like

0:55:35the iBook name coming back home to a

0:55:37laptop form factor but not a Mac so

0:55:40we'll say I think that would be cool

0:55:41that I don't I don't know how likely

0:55:43that is but that that would be a really

0:55:45cool fun reason for this I think it

0:55:48might be confusing because it seems like

0:55:49iBook is still kind of in living memory

0:55:51so to speak of the potential consumers

0:55:54and like to have someone who previously

0:55:58owned an iBook buy a new look and have

0:56:00it not be a Mac it might be strange but

0:56:02anyway is it this this changes

0:56:04completely explicable by Apple's Drive

0:56:06to name all of its products like Marco's

0:56:08products like the magazine no one

0:56:10product I named that way one I know it

0:56:18seems so significant I can't think of a

0:56:23good numbers pages music books movie

0:56:27tunes iMovie is interesting because you

0:56:32can't just rip off the eye because

0:56:33that's just called movie yeah all right

0:56:38so what's going on in Mac OS 10 dot 13.4

0:56:43probably a bunch of stuff but the only

0:56:45thing that poked out at me is the the

0:56:48long foreshadowed end of 32-bit we're

0:56:53just not happening in ten thirteen four

0:56:55but the foreshadowing continues

0:56:57preparing for the end of 32-bit as

0:56:59Apple says I think this isn't a release

0:57:02notes to prepare for future release of

0:57:04Mac OS and which 32-bit software will no

0:57:07longer run without compromise well no

0:57:13longer run you know not belong wrong

0:57:15without compromises

0:57:16well no long run without compromise

0:57:18starting a mac OS I see are ten thirteen

0:57:20for a user is notified at the launch of

0:57:22an app that depends on thirty bit

0:57:23software the alert

0:57:25is only once per app so this is kind of

0:57:27like I'm look good does an iOS to like

0:57:29for a while

0:57:2932-bit applications would pop up a

0:57:31dialog that says this may slow down your

0:57:34phone or is not optimized or had some

0:57:36message like that yeah yeah that would

0:57:38translate to if you knew what it was

0:57:40talking about this is 32-bit up and then

0:57:41eventually on iOS like yeah no those

0:57:44aren't going to launch anymore this this

0:57:45application needs to be updated for a

0:57:46blah blah blah right so the fun thing

0:57:49about 10 13 4 is that if you're a

0:57:51developer you can reboot your Mac with

0:57:53the Buddha or - no 32 exec and it will

0:57:57stop all 32-bit processes from launching

0:57:59right so then you can try to use your

0:58:01app like you think your app is clean and

0:58:03it's the 64-bit clean that doesn't

0:58:04require any 32-bit frameworks doesn't

0:58:06invoke any 32-bit commands doesn't do

0:58:07anything 32-bit fine reboot your Mac in

0:58:10this developer mode that will forbid any

0:58:1232-bit stuff from running and you'll see

0:58:15if it's broken of course this is a

0:58:16developer mode for people who are

0:58:18developing applications users should not

0:58:20do this because half the stuff that you

0:58:21use from day-to-day will probably be

0:58:23broken including including parts of the

0:58:24OS or other things that you know are

0:58:27command-line programs that have 32-bit

0:58:29parts or you know lots doesn't put it

0:58:31this way I bet there is a surprising

0:58:33amount of 32-bit software lurking in

0:58:35everybody's Mac at this point but this

0:58:37is the only way you get to a 64-bit

0:58:39clean world Apple doesn't say what

0:58:42future version of Mac OS the where

0:58:4632-bit software would no longer run and

0:58:48it also doesn't explain what compromise

0:58:50they're talking about because if they

0:58:51had just said will no longer run I'd be

0:58:53like oh that's just what happened to my

0:58:54I was 32-bit stuff no longer runs fair

0:58:57enough right but compromise makes me

0:58:59think there's going to be some kind of

0:59:01way to still run 32-bit stuff just

0:59:03because it seems like Apple doesn't have

0:59:05as much faith in the Apple developer or

0:59:09the Mac developer community to bring

0:59:11everything to 64-bit like there's just

0:59:13not enough of them and they're just not

0:59:14motivated enough to bring everything so

0:59:16there will always be this really long

0:59:17tail of stragglers where in iOS they're

0:59:19like look we're going 64-bit if you

0:59:22don't care enough about your app support

0:59:23it fine there's a thousand other apps

0:59:24it'll take your place we don't care but

0:59:26on the Mac I don't know if that's the

0:59:28case so I'm very interested to see what

0:59:31the compromise is and how they managed

0:59:33to run 32-bit stuff in an OS that more

0:59:36or less doesn't support they could use

0:59:38some kind of

0:59:38think some kind of weird hypervisor

0:59:40thing who knows but you know my guess is

0:59:44it's the it's 10:14 we'll find out the

0:59:46answer to that question to go back a

0:59:48step I forgot to mention that a health

0:59:50records is also new in 11 3 I think that

0:59:53completely slipped my mind and it's not

0:59:56clear how that works like I see this

0:59:57yeah that seems cool but how does