Podcast Search

Top Four

Top Four 37: Valentine's Chocolate Boxes

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00hi everybody welcome to a new episode of

0:00:02top 4 this is our special Valentine's

0:00:03Day love episode anyway so um I thought

0:00:14we should go back to eating things

0:00:17because why not I mean we we are pretty

0:00:20good at it I mean yeah we are all right

0:00:22and nothing says Valentine's Day more

0:00:25than cheesy heart-shaped boxes of

0:00:28chocolates so my idea originally was to

0:00:34go pick up one of the you know Russell

0:00:36Stover is whatever brand you know the

0:00:38big heart-shaped box and we sampled the

0:00:41different flavors and rank the flavors

0:00:43that are inside the box well when we

0:00:45went to the grocery store today we saw

0:00:48that there were many types of boxes and

0:00:50Marco thought you know what

0:00:52we should buy all of them of course so

0:00:55yeah as usual we have in our head to to

0:00:59rank some kind of food thing we arrive

0:01:01we arrive at the food location and

0:01:03realize there are way too many choices

0:01:04and rather than cut back the ambition of

0:01:07what we were doing we just bought all of

0:01:08them you know and we're working through

0:01:10these you know individual chocolates

0:01:12themselves you know that everyone's

0:01:15preferences vary and everything I think

0:01:17it will be more productive instead of

0:01:18trying to rank the individual flavors of

0:01:20the chocolates to rank of the boxes

0:01:22themselves like which brand box of

0:01:25chocolates should you get is it the

0:01:26Russell Stover's is it the Dove is it

0:01:28the other one like you know that we have

0:01:29all these all these different brands and

0:01:30different tiers within the brands like

0:01:32Russell Stover's makes like nine

0:01:33different options yeah but I'm pretty

0:01:35sure inside it's all the same but

0:01:37basically if you haven't seen these

0:01:38heart-shaped boxes it's pretty much the

0:01:40heart-shaped box that a you know

0:01:42thirteen year old would give to the

0:01:45lover of their choice in school so yeah

0:01:50have you ever actually gotten one of

0:01:51these as a gift do men receive them

0:01:54usually I not I don't know I've never

0:01:56far as I know I've never gotten one as a

0:01:58gift I've given one or two I think to

0:02:00like high school girlfriends because

0:02:02they're super cheesy like okay so we got

0:02:04two different ruffle Russell Stover's

0:02:06boxes one is um wrapped in this red

0:02:10cellophane it's the same like like if

0:02:12you buy a Christmas cactus

0:02:14like the the pot is wrapped in that yeah

0:02:16yeah yeah yeah like a poinsettia yeah

0:02:19yeah and then we also got the Russell

0:02:21Stover's elegant collection and that's

0:02:23in kind of a red velvet box there was

0:02:26also the same collection you could have

0:02:28the lace black lace variety so I guess

0:02:30depending on what you want to say and

0:02:32was that one that came with the American

0:02:35flag and military camo oh no that was

0:02:38another Russell Stover his one yes there

0:02:39was an American flag and camouflage were

0:02:42a military like the digital America yeah

0:02:46so you know if your lover is into that

0:02:51then that's the box you get we also have

0:02:54a dove which is in kind of a nice tin in

0:02:57it's an unconventional heart shape it's

0:02:59kind of like a sushi heart like a it's

0:03:01like if you it's like the italics

0:03:03version of a heart it's like if you blew

0:03:04a bubble of the heart or if the heart

0:03:06was melting slightly yeah or a melted

0:03:08heart okay melting or italics or a

0:03:10bubble heart then we also have a much

0:03:11more any kind of pink and red striped

0:03:15standard heart box with a gold bow and

0:03:17that's by Hershey's it's called pot of

0:03:19gold and then the piece de resistance

0:03:22which looks like an old lady's sofa

0:03:25living room cushion more than the

0:03:27Russell Stover premium velvet one yeah

0:03:30because this has like the satin bow with

0:03:31the with the roses that are all curled

0:03:34up the ribbon roses on the front and

0:03:35it's all padded so it's really funny

0:03:37it's the white man sampler that's

0:03:42pronounced I believe so I think it's

0:03:45missing an e oh yes I'm sorry the

0:03:48Whitman's Wow all right so cheesy it's

0:03:57the one yeah I mean I got to say like

0:04:00there Russell Stover velvet one though I

0:04:01mean that's that's really something like

0:04:03I was like I was like heading it in this

0:04:05store like we should get this I reached

0:04:08over to get it that's why we got it so

0:04:10you could pet it this is kind of a night

0:04:11spot it feels really good yeah I think

0:04:14collection if I was to receive one of

0:04:16these I would probably want to receive

0:04:17that one from their Private Reserve of

0:04:20chocolates actually has it says a

0:04:22decadent nineteen piece Private Reserve

0:04:25chocolate assortment now

0:04:27what is that what does Private Reserve

0:04:28really mean for Russell Stover's Brando

0:04:31maybe they used a little bit extra cocoa

0:04:33in some of them because all right

0:04:34everybody make their Private Reserve

0:04:36until they ship out of the factory I

0:04:38don't know what's the regular Wednesday

0:04:41he doesn't say Private Reserve

0:04:42it just says fine chocolates handcrafted

0:04:45in small batches but they both were

0:04:47there both handcrafted in small batches

0:04:49I especially love that there's so much

0:04:51small batches there's so much of this

0:04:53chocolate there's no way this is a small

0:04:54badge yeah I think maybe small is a

0:04:57relative term relative to the entire

0:05:00output of the Hershey's corporation like

0:05:02maybe I don't know that our Russell

0:05:03Stover is part of Hershey's I don't know

0:05:05just guessing but yeah cuz they have a

0:05:06different box this one's made in America

0:05:08that's why it had the American flag oh

0:05:09one of the problems with the Russell

0:05:11Stover is that the one with the red

0:05:13poinsettia wrapping around it is that

0:05:15you can't see the labeling on the back

0:05:18so you can't see like ingredient lists

0:05:21or like anything about it yeah there's

0:05:23nothing the red film around it is so

0:05:26tall just has a big sticker that says

0:05:28assorted well that's okay isn't alright

0:05:31I'm gonna open this up alright so we're

0:05:32starting out with the Russell Stover's

0:05:35yeah this is like oh the box is even

0:05:39better okay so after you remove the

0:05:42layer of fresh red red colored trash

0:05:47then you kind of have like a shiny what

0:05:52would you call this it's like a no like

0:05:55glossy cardboard right yeah yeah like

0:05:57kind of metallic looking board with an

0:05:59embossed rose on it so there we go oh

0:06:02wow

0:06:04okay I gotta say it looks really nice

0:06:06when you open it up like the

0:06:07presentation of all those chocolates is

0:06:08really nice as Mel's good it smells like

0:06:10a valentine's job it does it smells like

0:06:11found hoods do we have any kind of key

0:06:13oh we do oh thank god

0:06:15okay they have some sort of key here so

0:06:17we have all kinds of different things

0:06:18like peanut butter crunch maple nut

0:06:20maple

0:06:21okay there's lots of maple nut butter

0:06:22coconut cream orange cream yeah it just

0:06:25kind of repeats so we can shout out to

0:06:27any chocolate maker that gives you a map

0:06:29or a key of what's what so you don't

0:06:31have to use guess based on how they look

0:06:32that is a huge wonderful feature

0:06:35advancement that as far as I know when

0:06:37we were younger didn't seem to be done

0:06:39really and now

0:06:40seems a lot more common and anybody who

0:06:42does that gets extra points in my book

0:06:43because as somebody who occasionally

0:06:46likes to eat such things I always like

0:06:48to know what I'm getting beforehand cuz

0:06:50like I'm you know I'm an adult I'm not

0:06:52gonna have a million chocolates unless

0:06:54I'm doing a podcast about eating

0:06:55chocolates and you know in other cases

0:06:57like I only want to have like one or two

0:06:58and so I want those to be really good

0:07:00flavors that I actually really enjoy if

0:07:03I'm only gonna have one or two I don't

0:07:04want one of them to be like coconut or

0:07:06one of those like big gross cherry

0:07:08liquid bomb hey now I love both of those

0:07:10things okay

0:07:11things differently but we're not ranking

0:07:13the chocolates we're putting these boxes

0:07:15against each other yes okay so let me

0:07:18can I see the map or the flavor key

0:07:19whatever it is what's Roman nougat I

0:07:21don't know I know what nougat is I know

0:07:24what Rome is I don't know what Roman

0:07:27nougat is anyway I'm gonna go for the

0:07:28maple nut butter alright first

0:07:30appearance it is defective oh wait

0:07:33there's maple nut butter and there's

0:07:34also maple in a cream which one do you

0:07:36want

0:07:36Oh creme maple nut cream is the one in

0:07:38the very center right about 12 o'clock

0:07:39they look the same

0:07:41the maple nut butter one is defective

0:07:42and oozing out well that's pretty big

0:07:45strike again for us to like what does it

0:07:46say about your relationship or your

0:07:48intense with somebody if you give them a

0:07:50box of defective Valentine's chocolates

0:07:52I mean it's not really your fault

0:07:54it's it's not your fault if it's

0:07:56defective but I guess is it then you

0:07:57sprung for like the cheap one no fault

0:07:59but it is your problem

0:08:00is your problem Russell Stover did had

0:08:03the biggest box available that's true

0:08:05yeah we didn't get the app we got the

0:08:07second biggest box we got the one that

0:08:08was like fifteen dollars instead of 20

0:08:10all right the maple one doesn't taste

0:08:12very good alright I will try I love

0:08:17peanut butter but I don't know how

0:08:19common that's going to be maybe I'll try

0:08:20out the vanilla cream that's that's nice

0:08:22and basic yeah I'd try that this is

0:08:27impressively mediocre like it's just

0:08:31like cheap basic after eating one of

0:08:35these I would never in a million years

0:08:37think I would like another one of those

0:08:39okay I've gone I've gone ahead I have

0:08:42taken bites have a lot of these

0:08:43chocolates already haha just kind of

0:08:45plowed through I'm gonna go for a peanut

0:08:47butter crunch because in general the

0:08:49fillings don't seem to matter much I

0:08:51mean it changes the taste slightly but

0:08:52it's not extremely great chocolate

0:08:54but I'm curious I think we should put

0:08:58this directly against their private

0:08:59reserve I agree yeah this yeah the the

0:09:01regular Russell Stover I give it a

0:09:03thumbs down really it's really like just

0:09:07like cheap bland yeah it's very romantic

0:09:13to open no I could I could take off the

0:09:16velvet box also has a key it's covered

0:09:22in chocolate for freshness okay the

0:09:23little um the chocolate paper guard this

0:09:27one is dark brown with gold writing Yeti

0:09:30so the the interior like plastic like

0:09:32kind of rack that holds them all in is

0:09:34shinier and that there are there are

0:09:37fewer larger chocolate pieces in this

0:09:39one and they are much more fancily

0:09:42finished with different like colors and

0:09:44like icing squiggles on the outside and

0:09:45so yeah it's definitely it's visually a

0:09:48noticeable step up I would say generally

0:09:50you know assuming that these turns to be

0:09:52better if you're giving a gift for

0:09:55somebody like this I think a a smaller

0:09:57box of better chocolates it's probably a

0:10:00better option

0:10:00oh absolutely big box of the cheap ones

0:10:03alright let's see if we have any common

0:10:05flavors oh no we have like Oh some of

0:10:08the I don't I don't even know these

0:10:10words I think they were French they're

0:10:12in French to be fancy oh really

0:10:14I don't know do we get like the wrong

0:10:18sheet the wrong key does a key count for

0:10:22bonus points if you can't okay

0:10:23so there I think they gave them all like

0:10:25weird names so that they sound fancier

0:10:26okay so the signature almond cream

0:10:29all right that's that's Collazo

0:10:31raspberry cordial the monogram almond

0:10:34mousse comp Anjali

0:10:37that's all you I know when I speak

0:10:40French I don't even know what that

0:10:41saying alright which one is the Sigma

0:10:43cream creston refined hazelnut praline

0:10:46ooh I do like the Monaco raspberry

0:10:48caramel look at these names I want to

0:10:50try the the almond one signature almond

0:10:56cream right there in the middle did you

0:10:57seriously get yourself water and not me

0:11:00you one way street in the water oh I

0:11:03think I might as well make carried in

0:11:04the water this is our romantic episode

0:11:08and you don't even get me water let me

0:11:09try this than I'll get Susan this is the

0:11:11signature almond cream from the Russell

0:11:13Stover elegant collection Private

0:11:15Reserve

0:11:15there's curdled what happened in here

0:11:18yes it isn't a smooth cream it's it's

0:11:20very like grainy

0:11:21I wouldn't say kernel I just say badly

0:11:23made the chocolate is a little bit

0:11:25better it's better than the base Russell

0:11:28Stover thank for sure okay this one's a

0:11:30grainy - this is the mocha cream let's

0:11:33see say that word say the word above

0:11:35mocha cream I think it's Amalfi I'm

0:11:38trying the hazelnut praline which is in

0:11:40the shape of a giant hazelnut kind of

0:11:42nice okay so the flavors are a lot more

0:11:45nuanced than the standard Russell Stover

0:11:49chocolates a little bit better so that

0:11:51is legit

0:11:53but in general it's still not really

0:11:56really great chocolate I've had much

0:11:58better chocolate yeah I really enjoy the

0:12:01flavors in this one but the like they're

0:12:04very they're pretty heavy-handed on the

0:12:06flavors like they kind of hit you over

0:12:07the head like the hazelnut one tastes a

0:12:10lot like artificial hazelnut flavoring

0:12:12and not a lot like actual like good

0:12:13refined hazelnut flavor

0:12:16these are definitely better than the

0:12:18base Russell Stover and I would way

0:12:19rather have this box then than the basic

0:12:22roasted over box for sure but yeah I'm

0:12:24not sure this earns its Private Reserve

0:12:26designation and velvet box

0:12:28I think the velvety box cover is nicer

0:12:31than I just tried the coconut cream it

0:12:34was really good on the chart which one

0:12:36is that oh I'd really like some of that

0:12:37water looks really good you're drinking

0:12:39it over there how about you get someone

0:12:44to the sponsor read okay all right we

0:12:46admit this romantic we have brought to

0:12:48you this week by Squarespace enter offer

0:12:50code top for a checkout to get 10% off

0:12:52your first purchase make your next move

0:12:54with a beautiful website from

0:12:56Squarespace Squarespace lets you easily

0:12:58create a website for your next idea with

0:13:00a unique domain award-winning templates

0:13:02and much more whether you want to create

0:13:04an online store or a portfolio or a blog

0:13:07or a podcast or any other kind of

0:13:09website Squarespace is the all-in-one

0:13:11platform that lets you do just that

0:13:13there's nothing to install no patches to

0:13:15worry about no upgrades needed you don't

0:13:17worry about any of that stuff

0:13:18Squarespace has it covered and if

0:13:21anything goes wrong

0:13:22if you need any help they have

0:13:23award-winning 24/7 customer support

0:13:26Squarespace lets you quickly and easily

0:13:27grab a unique domain name and all those

0:13:30award-winning templates they have for

0:13:31you to choose from and customize to your

0:13:33heart's content our beautifully designed

0:13:34for you to show off your great ideas

0:13:37Squarespace plans start at just twelve

0:13:39dollars a month and you can start a free

0:13:41trial with no credit card required by

0:13:44going to Squarespace calm when you

0:13:46decide to sign up make sure to use the

0:13:47offer code top-4 to get 10% off your

0:13:50first purchase and to show your support

0:13:51for top four we thank Squarespace for

0:13:53their support Squarespace

0:13:55make your next move make your next

0:13:56website ID to save more of those

0:13:59chocolates where's this coconut cream

0:14:01one and it from the Private Reserve one

0:14:02further and there's a lemon - I ate half

0:14:05of it this is labelled the Kon lemon

0:14:07souffle all right I'm gonna preemptively

0:14:10say I think this box might be the best

0:14:12out of all the boxes I don't have high

0:14:15hopes for the others the lemon and

0:14:17coconut that I just tried they're both

0:14:19good they're not great they're good I

0:14:23they're both again very very like heavy

0:14:26hand like hit you in the face flavors

0:14:28like the lemon cream was very very

0:14:29strong and very very sweet the coconut

0:14:32was like really like intense and the

0:14:33flavoring so if you like very intense

0:14:35like fillings and creams this is a

0:14:38decent pick so far this at least feels

0:14:41like you're eating something special ish

0:14:43yeah yeah like the basic four also

0:14:45Stauber box it just tastes like gift

0:14:48basket chocolate that's been like

0:14:50sitting in a gift basket warehouse for

0:14:52six years and it looks like gift basket

0:14:54chocolate there's nothing it's all just

0:14:56so monotone I mean they have a dark and

0:14:58a light chocolate and the original

0:15:00Russell Stover's ones but it's not

0:15:02anything special the shapes are kind of

0:15:04like mmm yeah kind of like poured a

0:15:07little sloppily the Private Reserve ones

0:15:09appear to have come out of a mold or

0:15:13they've been dipped in a special way so

0:15:15they're a little bit smoother yeah they

0:15:17still seem mass manufactured there's

0:15:19some white chocolate involved in them so

0:15:21that's nice yeah

0:15:22yeah like they're there it is a

0:15:24noticeable step up and I think it was

0:15:26like five dollars more it was not a big

0:15:27price difference so I would say no

0:15:29question go for those even the plastic

0:15:30that's in between them is a little nicer

0:15:32exactly all right what's our next box

0:15:35we have the Hershey's pot of gold but

0:15:38it's not a pot it's shaped like a heart

0:15:40box it's a heart of gold why do why

0:15:42wouldn't they say heart of gold missed

0:15:44opportunity totally missed opportunities

0:15:46wrong with them

0:15:47I think they're just trying to double up

0:15:50on their marketing for st. Patty's Day

0:15:52and Valentine's Day big ears like didn't

0:15:55want to change the template when they

0:15:56yeah they got the labels printed they

0:15:58just put the card on here let's change

0:16:00the color okay now this one has the key

0:16:02printed on the underside of the box it

0:16:04doesn't have a special little paper like

0:16:05the Russell Stover's did well I see I

0:16:08respect that move because then you can't

0:16:09lose the key oh that is a good point you

0:16:11know it's like if you still have the box

0:16:13which you almost certainly will cuz

0:16:14that's how these are eaten then you have

0:16:16the key yes that's nice after taking off

0:16:18the layer of garbage yes I mean that

0:16:21really the first rows disturber with

0:16:22with the point set of wrapping that was

0:16:24like clearly wrapping garber you throw

0:16:25these are just like you know excusable

0:16:27amounts of plastic wrap okay so these

0:16:29are a lot fancier these are definitely

0:16:31poured molded chocolates they have some

0:16:34striations of different colors they have

0:16:38colors of the chocolate they have some

0:16:40swirl patterns that are nice that

0:16:42definitely look like they came out of a

0:16:43mold they're much prettier and the

0:16:45plastic around them although thin is

0:16:48also styled nicely the only thing that I

0:16:52would that I would call them out for is

0:16:54that they are very monochromatic

0:16:55compared to the private the private

0:16:56reserved ones there's enough use of

0:16:58white chocolate here and there but

0:16:59either as like a zigzag icing or as the

0:17:02base layer for some of them that you get

0:17:03a nice like you know mostly brown with

0:17:05like spots of white and stripes look

0:17:08from the Private Reserve whereas this

0:17:09one it's just all brown so it's like I

0:17:12could use a little a little bit more

0:17:13visual variety on this one although I

0:17:15suppose Hershey's is known for their

0:17:17brown chocolates because it can't be

0:17:19that's a price but still a little bit of

0:17:21white chocolate even like some white

0:17:22chocolate drizzle just makes the

0:17:23chocolate look a little bit more special

0:17:25this is Valentine's Day after all yeah

0:17:26all right so let's see the key what what

0:17:29kind of flavors do we have like kind of

0:17:30like a fancy name for usual stuff for

0:17:32dark chocolate truffle almond cream milk

0:17:35chocolate truffle let me see the almond

0:17:37cream where's Carmen oh there's a pecan

0:17:39caramel cluster so like a turtle I guess

0:17:41but yeah there's not a lot of variety in

0:17:43here it repeats a lot

0:17:44the Russell Stover has more variety in

0:17:46both the Private Reserve and

0:17:49regular box but this her she's one does

0:17:52not have tons of variety going for the

0:17:54caramel and almonds option Hershey's

0:17:56chocolate tastes like nothing to me

0:17:57it always does the caramel and almonds

0:18:00option literally looks like a Snickers

0:18:01bar is the vanilla caramel just tastes

0:18:06like caramel here I tried the almond

0:18:08creamy but it didn't maybe that's better

0:18:09yeah the chocolate the Hershey's

0:18:11chocolate is just like it's just like

0:18:13hard crunchy nothing like there's no

0:18:15there's no depth of flavor there's no

0:18:17flavor to it whatsoever it's literally

0:18:19like eating I don't even know it's just

0:18:21it's holding together the filling

0:18:23there's nothing going on outside it

0:18:24doesn't add to it at all

0:18:26well that tastes like nothing yeah the

0:18:28almond cream is all is similarly like

0:18:30you don't say the cream tastes like

0:18:31nothing it's very it's very like hard it

0:18:33almost looks like styrofoam when you

0:18:34bite into it like there's no flowing of

0:18:35the cream it's like it just like a very

0:18:37like dry dense like you know you bite

0:18:41through it and it you get a perfect

0:18:43slice right there yeah I rather have the

0:18:46over flavored almond cream

0:18:47yeah and that whatever that was I feel a

0:18:51the Hershey's she's like I feel like I'm

0:18:53not eating much of anything yeah doesn't

0:18:55feel like a thumbs down for the hers it

0:18:56doesn't feel worth it yeah it's I would

0:18:58say the Hershey's it might I would we'll

0:19:00see we'll see how he into breaking them

0:19:01I think I might rank it slightly above

0:19:02the base line Russell Stover's but it's

0:19:05certainly in the ballpark of the same

0:19:07thing and so much of it is caramels like

0:19:09it's just caramels over and over yeah

0:19:10thumbs down this is supposed to be their

0:19:12variety box no you know they're their

0:19:15box with their box was pretty on the

0:19:16outside much more modern and the visuals

0:19:20of the chocolate are better than the

0:19:22original Russell Stover's but man they

0:19:24fail on taste agreed alright next I'm

0:19:26gonna open up the dev this is like a

0:19:30hard hard tin situation remove the layer

0:19:34of garbage and bow now this one also

0:19:36doesn't advertise much variety ah

0:19:38oh man the ribbons not even all the way

0:19:41around it's like fake glued to the cover

0:19:46that's hilarious day they couldn't maybe

0:19:47the rest of the ribbon that goes around

0:19:48the back of the lid Wow

0:19:52alright this essentially has creamy

0:19:54caramel caramels dark chocolate peanut

0:19:58butter truffle hearts and dark chocolate

0:20:00truffle hearts that's it

0:20:03it's only those like so at least of

0:20:05those four flavors in the tag it's only

0:20:06those though yeah but it says assorted

0:20:08chocolate so it only has three varieties

0:20:10of a sordidness yeah there's the tin

0:20:14situation I guess you could reuse that

0:20:16if you're a weirdo I think the the

0:20:19minimum number of distinct flavors for

0:20:22it to qualify as assorted should

0:20:24probably be something like six or eight

0:20:25yeah I don't think for qualified so we

0:20:28got stuff branding all over it it is

0:20:30nice that the tag has a two from on the

0:20:32other side so you can make this really

0:20:35gift tastic very minimal effort should

0:20:38when you are sieving one of these should

0:20:42should you need to label it or should it

0:20:44be obvious to the recipient who its

0:20:46affirming isn't it kind of a problem if

0:20:47they don't if they can't remember or

0:20:48don't know there appears to be no guide

0:20:50as to what these are is it just like the

0:20:53tag that has the guide oh yeah actually

0:20:55it is the tag that has the guide the

0:20:57plastic that they're all sitting in is

0:20:59clear so that's kind of nice and then

0:21:01you win

0:21:01this is a little cheesy you lift up the

0:21:04chocolate and underneath there's a nice

0:21:05little saying laughs often dove live

0:21:09passionately dove just seemed create

0:21:13passion dove we all love the small

0:21:16things dove a look a smile a touch it's

0:21:22just the same company as the soap or is

0:21:23that a different dog I don't know be

0:21:24mine dove that seems kind of weird for a

0:21:26company being it to be known for soap

0:21:28and chocolate here's a fail this heart

0:21:31isn't in its little pocket in the right

0:21:32direction share a secret now let me try

0:21:35the milk chocolate peanut butter truffle

0:21:37which is the light colored heart all

0:21:39right I'm trying to tidy up here a

0:21:40little bit and the Russell Stover box

0:21:41already broke so the Dove one to me the

0:21:44fillings are a little bit boring but the

0:21:47chocolate is significantly better than

0:21:49the other ones that we've had so far the

0:21:51peanut butter doesn't taste very good

0:21:52it's fine it's not it's not amazing the

0:21:54the the caramel was better it is

0:21:57unfortunate that there are literally

0:21:58only three only three varieties here I

0:22:00would like more than that

0:22:02but the chocolate itself I would say is

0:22:04very nice I think very is a very strong

0:22:09word

0:22:09I wouldn't say that relatively nice okay

0:22:15it's the nicest chocolate itself that

0:22:17we've had so far I don't know I think I

0:22:19like the Private Reserve better but I

0:22:22think maybe ice because the feelings are

0:22:23more interesting yeah the dove just does

0:22:26not you might as well just get a bag of

0:22:28chocolates

0:22:29yeah the dove one like the chocolate is

0:22:31great but for the purposes of a

0:22:33Valentine's box of chocolates unless you

0:22:36know that the person only likes these

0:22:39three very basic flavors I love

0:22:42chocolate yeah and then you need to

0:22:45teach those people that they need to

0:22:47like better chocolate and get them

0:22:48something good from like a chocolate

0:22:50place yeah these are good but they're

0:22:54not particularly memorable the chocolate

0:22:55is very nice the fillings are just

0:22:57really boring yeah and again and I

0:23:00really want more variety than three

0:23:02flavors out of a box like this this is

0:23:05um oh this this franking is going to be

0:23:09like I think maybe one clear winner and

0:23:12the rest just I I'm forming some some

0:23:15rankings in my head alright is that it

0:23:16or is there one more there is one more

0:23:17that's what the white man chocolate yeah

0:23:19right mm-hmm all right let's see let's

0:23:20see that one when you put away this

0:23:23heart tin put on this pile of other art

0:23:27tins and box

0:23:28I'm keeping the Private Reserve near me

0:23:30this funny that's the only one that's

0:23:32been really great there's not even great

0:23:34just like less correct I think if you

0:23:36were to purchase a heart-shaped box of

0:23:39chocolate for your lover on Valentine's

0:23:42I think that so far that's gonna be my

0:23:45choice oh yeah it's so it's my it's

0:23:47definitely my number one and it comes in

0:23:49the black lace variety which is very

0:23:50nice that was a little weird but the

0:23:53soft velvet box you know you can like

0:23:55use that as a pillow afterwards oh this

0:23:56one is like alright so it's the white

0:24:01man sampler I can't quite get the cover

0:24:05off oh it's taped on there's like a few

0:24:07spots of taper on the this is basically

0:24:09grandma chocolate and grandmas are great

0:24:13maybe they like this chocolate they

0:24:14could always use some tape yep

0:24:17even the box is kind of like this red

0:24:20crisps like dated fifties Christmas

0:24:23color yeah it's definitely it's a very

0:24:26dated look for sure yeah basically

0:24:29like it's a made of dress remnants from

0:24:31the 1950s all right very similar okay

0:24:36the white man key and the Russell Stover

0:24:39key is basically identical let me see

0:24:41that do you think maybe it's the same

0:24:42company and is just like a different

0:24:43like brand of him

0:24:44we'll have to inspect it's it does look

0:24:46identically printed really similar yeah

0:24:49well this is suspicious because it looks

0:24:51very simple it's just like it alright so

0:24:53let's see so what other white man

0:24:55chocolate with flavors that we have here

0:24:56whoa okay opening this up it has gold

0:25:00plastic around it not really much color

0:25:04variety but still better than the

0:25:06Russell Stover's and they have very

0:25:09different types of chocolates in here

0:25:11you have some like chocolate-covered

0:25:12almonds and chocolate-covered it looks

0:25:15like they might be raisins they have

0:25:18there's a fruit and nut caramel there's

0:25:20a there's cherry cordial there's one in

0:25:22the middle called milk chocolate

0:25:23messenger boy which is a little scary

0:25:24yep there's a boy on it yeah chocolate

0:25:29buttercream is that a post made it sound

0:25:31like the original post made me I think

0:25:34it supposed to meet but maybe it's also

0:25:36Whitman all right you mean it's not it's

0:25:41not the white it's not wearing it post

0:25:43mate so close all right there's a lot to

0:25:47choose from here I think I might try the

0:25:49let's see maybe among lasses choo a

0:25:51peanut butter cream well I got to try

0:25:55almond cream to be consistent it passed

0:25:56me the Russell Stover

0:25:57because they have some sort of like cup

0:25:59cluster thing in here - yeah I'm gonna

0:26:02compare those oh my gosh oh very hard

0:26:08the Russell Stover ones very hard yeah

0:26:11alright let's not open this box anymore

0:26:14you know they passed me them the Whitman

0:26:16as you say this ruffles the whore box

0:26:20every time I open it's falling apart

0:26:21even more it's structural integrity is

0:26:24just shot the women's are very chewy

0:26:27like there's a lot a lot of like thick

0:26:30sticky fillings I tried like three or

0:26:32four of them so far oh my god I bit into

0:26:34the cherry cordial and there is just

0:26:38kind of this neon your hands are red and

0:26:41dripping pink lick

0:26:43you tripped on your pants oh gosh I mean

0:26:45it's everywhere you should go on the

0:26:49floor oh god no I don't want the dog to

0:26:51get it why is this so pink it's it it

0:26:56looks like I spilled ink on my hands

0:26:57it really does yeah why is it this color

0:26:59it's a scary amount of dye oh can you

0:27:01get my headphones off all right so while

0:27:13two free covers from that yeah the the

0:27:16so far the Whitman's is the flavors some

0:27:21of the flavors are actually pretty good

0:27:23but each one of them has some kind of

0:27:26weird execution like the filling is too

0:27:29stiff and sticky or like the almond

0:27:31cream had a really good almond flavor

0:27:32but there was also like a raw dry almond

0:27:35in there you'd like get through this dry

0:27:37almond and it'll otherwise good cream

0:27:39the little peanuts were equally dry yeah

0:27:41everything's very dry and chewy but okay

0:27:43I think that this box was actually made

0:27:46in 1950 mm-hmm but all right so my

0:27:52theory is that this box appeals to older

0:27:56people of a certain generation where

0:27:59don't have dentures because if they did

0:28:01they would rip right out but so with the

0:28:05decor on the box and the gold gaudy

0:28:10decor inside and the dryness and the the

0:28:16types of flavors and the little post-boy

0:28:18on there it's really making me think

0:28:21that this is a I don't know either

0:28:25extremely dated and and the white man

0:28:28company does not understand modern times

0:28:30or it's just made to appeal to people of

0:28:35a certain age that would find this good

0:28:39people who have mistreated as white man

0:28:41I think that's a feature on a bug

0:28:42yeah I'm thinking this is very I don't

0:28:47know because it's it's definitely not

0:28:48quirky nostalgic it's just a little bit

0:28:52sad nostalgic is definitely the

0:28:54chocolate that you would have bought a

0:28:55million

0:28:56years ago and it would have been great

0:28:58because it would have been the only ones

0:28:59that you had but now we have others so

0:29:02I'm thinking not with this one yeah I I

0:29:06do like the flavorings of it better than

0:29:10the cheap Russell servers oh I don't

0:29:12know because have you did you retry the

0:29:16cheaper stores like after trading rooms

0:29:17try it again it's it's surprisingly

0:29:19crappy mmm well let me see the chart for

0:29:22the Russell Stover cuz I feel like at

0:29:25least their flavors are a little bit

0:29:26better like maple nut cream butter cream

0:29:30caramel where's the Whitman chocolates

0:29:33you just have like oh wait maple nut

0:29:35cream butter cream really the the

0:29:41Russell Stover standard one every flavor

0:29:44I've tried has been disappointing in

0:29:46pretty big ways the Whitman some of

0:29:49those actually tasted a lot better they

0:29:53the Whitman ones are worse better are

0:29:57they Russell Stover just tastes like

0:29:58garbage plastic and sugar like it's just

0:30:01there's no refinement there like there's

0:30:03nothing really you know smooth or

0:30:05decadent or advanced about them at all

0:30:07whereas the the Whitman one there's at

0:30:09least like somewhat like every one of

0:30:11those bites like oh this is kind of nice

0:30:12oh except for that dry part but like

0:30:14before before the dry part it was pretty

0:30:16nice

0:30:16like I so I think my ranking I think I'm

0:30:19pretty good on my ranking I think I'm

0:30:21ready

0:30:21um wait can you open up the Hershey's

0:30:22again it's kind of got a pic which least

0:30:25bad I do enjoy the care that was put

0:30:29into creating those chocolates the

0:30:31Hershey's ones yeah compared to the

0:30:33regular Russell Stover box

0:30:34alright well my number one easily is the

0:30:37Russell Stover Private Reserve the

0:30:39limited limited batch limited edition

0:30:40what was the official name of it and

0:30:41under that it's a private reserve the

0:30:44Russell Stover is in the velvet box that

0:30:47was definitely the best out of this

0:30:49showing although I got to say it like if

0:30:52you have anywhere near you like a nice

0:30:54like fancy cause a fancy chocolate shop

0:30:57yeah like a chocolatier oh yeah like if

0:31:00you have some point that near you

0:31:01chances are whatever you get from them

0:31:02would probably be more expensive but

0:31:05would also be a lot better even than

0:31:06this Private Reserve one that said the

0:31:08private ruler won for I think it was 15

0:31:10books that's that's pretty good for that

0:31:12and we did just go down to our local

0:31:14grocery store two days before

0:31:15Valentine's Day and we got to pick up

0:31:17everything was in stock so we just kind

0:31:20of picked up a box of everything um so

0:31:22it is all available so that's a benefit

0:31:24yeah yeah it's easy to get you know it's

0:31:27gonna be available everywhere so yeah

0:31:29Russell Stover Velda box

0:31:30Private Limited Edition reserve whatever

0:31:32it is that's the best for me yeah me

0:31:33it's my number one as well

0:31:35my number two I think would be the dove

0:31:39because even though I wanted more

0:31:41variety out of it and the and the

0:31:43fillings were boring the chocolate was

0:31:45pretty nice my number three is gonna be

0:31:49the white man Whitman whatever it is

0:31:51because again that the flavors were good

0:31:55even the executions was pretty bad on

0:31:57those and then my number four is going

0:31:59to be the her she's nowhere on my list

0:32:03is gonna be the Russell Stover basic box

0:32:05that I never want to eat those again but

0:32:07the Hershey's one is you know just

0:32:09crappy chocolate but decent fillings but

0:32:12mostly they just seem like candy bars

0:32:14but ultimately a if if the show was not

0:32:17called top four I wouldn't have even had

0:32:20a number four not that it stopped me a

0:32:21lot in the past but like like I dislike

0:32:24the Hershey's almost as much as I

0:32:26dislike the the basic Russell Stover if

0:32:28I was going with the typical top four

0:32:30rules

0:32:31I would only pick the Russell Stouffer's

0:32:33Private Reserve to put on my list at all

0:32:35anywhere because M everything else is

0:32:39just there's so much wrong with so many

0:32:42the other ones that it's really hard but

0:32:45guess if I had to rank them I would put

0:32:49Hershey's second hmm I would put the

0:32:52Dove third because they're just so

0:32:54boring

0:32:54and oh it's just such a toss-up between

0:32:57what's bad between them Russell Stover

0:32:59regular and the Whitman's the Whitman's

0:33:03just feel I don't know they're just too

0:33:07chewy nuts like I don't like a lot of

0:33:11nuts in my chocolate

0:33:12there's too much nut happening it's a

0:33:14fair criticism of them I'd say in the

0:33:16Whitman chocolate so I will put the

0:33:18Russell Stover regular as my fourth

0:33:21choice just because they're more cream

0:33:23heavy

0:33:23and that's the chocolate I prefer but

0:33:26the creams like have you tried it but

0:33:27they're so ugly did you throw the

0:33:28strawberry cream it's awful yeah no I

0:33:31it's my fourth it doesn't there was only

0:33:35five boxes and yeah this this Whitman

0:33:40sampler man this is this is special

0:33:44listen to a hat well we'll try to get

0:33:47this episode out fast enough so that you

0:33:48all can go out there and buy the Russell

0:33:50Simmons what is it just go out buy the

0:33:55Russell Simmons private velvet box yep

0:34:00avoid the white man and yeah but if you

0:34:04have a neighborhood chocolatier go to

0:34:05them and sticks it's gonna be way better

0:34:06than one yeah you see is a shop local

0:34:08yeah and happy Valentine's Day I'm not

0:34:12feeling very romantic right now no let's

0:34:14let's go have something better like ice

0:34:16cream or better chocolate no no more

0:34:17sweets but ice cream who are you here

0:34:20husband coffee yeah that sounds nice

0:34:23let's go for a cuddle