0:00:00this episode of Roderick online was
0:00:01recorded on Tuesday January 23rd 2018
0:00:06[Music]
0:00:10I'm Merlin how's it going how did you
0:00:26missing yeah all right in a week no I I
0:00:38feel like we should come clean no no no
0:00:40I never come clean the dentist I should
0:00:51have done it today it's okay it's all
0:00:53right it's all right be fine I'm sure
0:00:55it'll be fine - it's a it's a big
0:00:57rainstorm today here big rainstorm yeah
0:01:00you know in the morning it it was it was
0:01:03clear and and almost almost sunny and
0:01:07now the big storms coming in a storm and
0:01:09I have a I don't know if you are
0:01:12interested in the weather my family
0:01:15really cares about the weather your
0:01:17memory serves your mom goes pretty deep
0:01:19on weather oh my sister's even worse oh
0:01:21really
0:01:22yeah just all they want to talk about is
0:01:25the freakin weather and I thought I
0:01:29thought that Susan was more like looking
0:01:31at the stars kind of situation oh she
0:01:33loves looking at the stars - yeah yep
0:01:35stars stars are kind of weather
0:01:37stars are yab that stars are like or
0:01:39what we call old web we're seeing we're
0:01:42seeing we're seeing a star what a star
0:01:44look like millions of years ago is that
0:01:46mind-blowing
0:01:47you know the entire universe could be
0:01:49just a molecule in the end of your
0:01:51finger whoa
0:01:52so what's oh wait a minute so you're
0:01:55saying could be in my finger I'm saying
0:01:56it could be in your finger universe does
0:01:58not know where that thing has been MGM
0:02:02cr-v we could we could right now be a
0:02:06molecule in the thumb Oh some giant
0:02:08being who has his thumb up do you think
0:02:11kids still get tripped out when they
0:02:13think about things like that when you go
0:02:14through that like stony like first time
0:02:17you really contemplate the idea of
0:02:19infinity the first time you wonder if
0:02:21we're all seeing this
0:02:22color green you think kids these
0:02:24millenniums you think they still have
0:02:25those kinds of reveries oh yeah I worry
0:02:27that they don't you have to you know I
0:02:30bet you get Netflix and you got the
0:02:32snapchat you know they don't have to
0:02:34contemplate things that are that are
0:02:36recursive and hurtful to the brain it's
0:02:38not you know I think that we didn't have
0:02:41them in the popular culture and so when
0:02:44you heard when you heard something like
0:02:46that in in Animal House
0:02:51well when Donald Sutherland is passing
0:02:53adjoin around and they're like you know
0:02:55it actually had the force of novelty
0:02:58sure and I think if you grew up you know
0:03:01soaked in stuff it would be a little bit
0:03:04harder to get to that place but
0:03:05absolutely the moment it actually occurs
0:03:08to you I think it still got to be like I
0:03:12have a terrible time blowin my
0:03:13daughter's mind I've tried so many times
0:03:15I've been I've been trying to get her
0:03:17freaked out about infinity for years and
0:03:19she still she still hasn't freaked out
0:03:20by it by infinity
0:03:22I mean I still struggle with with string
0:03:30theory think about it all the time and I
0:03:32just can't there's just some things I
0:03:34can't resolve yeah I mean does does P
0:03:37equal NP is a big question let's check
0:03:40reddit but we I mean you know multiple
0:03:45universes I mean you could sit and think
0:03:47about it at great length
0:03:49still still mind-blowing I think it's
0:03:52one reason I was so attracted I had very
0:03:55little exposure to philosophy before
0:03:57college and then I read up I read some
0:03:59existentialist stuff in my my gap year
0:04:02and I got very interested in philosophy
0:04:05because it seemed like kind of like you
0:04:08know universe in a finger with a
0:04:09graduate degree kind of thing like idea
0:04:11of epistemology was very fascinating to
0:04:13me like how do we know what we know but
0:04:16that would just turn my brain maybe I'm
0:04:18just a simple farm boy from Cincinnati
0:04:20but like that kind of thing would just
0:04:21bend my brain you you think therefore
0:04:24you are I did a paper on Descartes I
0:04:29remember had then the final paragraph is
0:04:31maybe second less paragraph it had this
0:04:32very memorable line
0:04:34so who is this guy we call God that's
0:04:38kind of work I was doing that you need
0:04:39you know don't put Descartes before day
0:04:42horse oh come on
0:04:43Oh God dad I really put that I put that
0:04:51in a paper oh no because so I had a
0:04:55professor who allowed us to be creative
0:04:58hmm and and I did eh this is in the
0:05:02history of ideas history of ideas and I
0:05:04did a song about Descartes like the
0:05:09style like Jonathan Richmond I think I
0:05:11could really get into it it was pretty
0:05:12good yeah we the the the other students
0:05:35were like yeah that's fun yeah yeah oh
0:05:42yeah you know there are a lot of things
0:05:43that that that constitute an education
0:05:46aren't there oh yeah don't don't let
0:05:48your school get in the way of your
0:05:51education oh thank you thank you don't
0:05:55let your ontology recapitulate your
0:05:58philosophy said the 30 year old guy the
0:06:0030 year old townie with the bong things
0:06:03change lessons that went here they my
0:06:12tape guy hey you want to buy my CD
0:06:16let me guess is it almost all reggae
0:06:19yeah I went to the I went to the women's
0:06:22March the other day and one of the great
0:06:24things about big marches I mean this is
0:06:25a while back sure this is a how many
0:06:27weeks ago at this point but uh but one
0:06:29of the great things about those rallies
0:06:31is that there is always a kind of
0:06:35there's always a sort of a gray area I
0:06:38don't I wouldn't personally consider it
0:06:40a gray area but some people clearly do
0:06:42where they want to use that opportunity
0:06:48to also pitch their their big program oh
0:06:54yes and every demonstration whatever is
0:06:58of any size I've ever been to you could
0:07:02maybe call them fringe characters but
0:07:03you can get you got people with a very
0:07:05important message and they're gonna use
0:07:06that as a platform yeah like you know in
0:07:09a big rally like that like of course the
0:07:10labor unions are there and they're
0:07:13saying you know we want you to support
0:07:16the labor union because we have a lot of
0:07:18women in the Union yes you know and and
0:07:21you can make a case like oh okay right
0:07:23this is a you know absolutely absolutely
0:07:27right it's still a co-optation of the
0:07:32idea but you can kind of go with them
0:07:35but there was there were a group of guys
0:07:36standing there all men by the way
0:07:38holding a banner that said support the
0:07:43freedom struggle of Palestinian women
0:07:46and then they had a bunch of material
0:07:50about how Israel was committing a
0:07:51genocide okay and it was like boom all
0:07:54right I mean maybe if there were some
0:07:56women that were holding that banner it
0:07:58might go a little bit further but it
0:07:59seems like he just tacked the word woman
0:08:00on to the end of that right sure yeah
0:08:03but they slather not some woman sauce
0:08:06they put some woman sauce on there and
0:08:07then there was a group that was like
0:08:09protecting the elephants especially the
0:08:12women voices like that's a that's a
0:08:15that's another iteration and then at a
0:08:17certain point oh my god I really just
0:08:19wanted to because there was a certain
0:08:20kind of corner where the March was
0:08:23turning that a lot of these people had
0:08:24had a raid and I just wanted I wanted to
0:08:27be in a kind of like knee-length
0:08:30leather car coat from Costco standing
0:08:34there going you want to check out my CD
0:08:37[Laughter]
0:08:46I'm so much respect for women I can only
0:08:50get it out on the Philips Compact this
0:08:52format it's all in there
0:08:56respect women women women are somebody
0:09:01sometimes they confuse but they know the
0:09:05news women break my heart and make me
0:09:15fight their women this episode of
0:09:19Roderick on the line is brought to you
0:09:20in part by Casper you can learn more
0:09:22about Casper right now by visiting
0:09:24Casper comm slash supertrain Casper is
0:09:27the company focused on sleep and they
0:09:30are dedicated to making you
0:09:31exceptionally comfortable one night at a
0:09:33time you spend a third of your life
0:09:35sleeping if you spent a third of your
0:09:37life doing anything you'd want to make
0:09:39sure it's the best that can possibly be
0:09:40and that's why you need Casper Casper
0:09:43mattresses are perfectly designed for
0:09:45humans with engineering to soothe and
0:09:47support your natural geometry it's got
0:09:50all the right support in all the right
0:09:51places so you ask yourself what goes
0:09:53into making a Casper mattress so
0:09:55comfortable well I'll tell you they
0:09:57combine multiple supportive memory foams
0:09:59for a quality mattress with just the
0:10:01right sink and bounce Casper mattresses
0:10:04are designed and developed in the US and
0:10:06their breathable design helps to
0:10:08regulate your body temperature
0:10:09throughout the night and with over
0:10:1120,000 reviews and an average rating of
0:10:134.8 stars Casper is very quickly
0:10:15becoming the Internet's favorite
0:10:17mattress good for you Casper you can be
0:10:19sure of your purchase with Casper's 100
0:10:21night risk-free sleep on at trial they
0:10:24deliver your mattress directly to your
0:10:25door and if for any reason you don't
0:10:27love it Casper has a hassle-free return
0:10:29policy we are a Casper family I know
0:10:32whereof I speak my wife and I sleep on a
0:10:34Casper my daughter sleeps on a Casper we
0:10:36just love them any time I travel I'm so
0:10:38looking forward to getting home to my
0:10:39Casper mattress so join me please start
0:10:42sleeping ahead of the curve with Casper
0:10:44you can get 50 dollars towards select
0:10:47mattress purchases by visiting Casper
0:10:49com slash super trade and using the very
0:10:51special offer code supertrain at
0:10:53checkout terms and conditions apply our
0:10:56thanks to Casper for supporting Roderick
0:10:58on the line and all the great shows yeah
0:11:01yeah you know it's it's true it shows
0:11:03you how fractured things are things are
0:11:06fractured things feel very fractured
0:11:08right now there
0:11:09so fractured a very fractured you
0:11:11remember a few problem with the
0:11:14Cochran's I remember how long ago it was
0:11:17and I was telling you I was telling you
0:11:20in the after show in the dark dark show
0:11:23show yeah through tour yeah you can't
0:11:27you can't you can't listen to dark
0:11:29Roderick on the line Roderick on the
0:11:31line after dark because it's only
0:11:33available to subscribers but but I was
0:11:39counseling you not to not to not to fret
0:11:42not to fret about the Congress not to
0:11:45fall not even to follow that story yeah
0:11:47but I know it's hard I know it's hard
0:11:49it's hard it's hard yeah what did you
0:11:54know okay so you went to this mark did
0:11:56you go to the big one last year last
0:12:00year I have a little bit of a
0:12:01complication that kept me out of the
0:12:03March okay but you went this year what
0:12:05are your impressions of the of the March
0:12:16once the March got going I was you know
0:12:20it's it's really exciting like there's a
0:12:22lot there's a lot about that March
0:12:25moving forward that felt exactly how you
0:12:28would hope it would feel empowered
0:12:31little girls with signs their dad made
0:12:33for them well you know there are those
0:12:36there's the there's the comedic aspect
0:12:37of it which is kind of fun is marching
0:12:39behind like several women that were
0:12:43wearing hardhats and they all had
0:12:44jackets on from the Carpenters Union and
0:12:46they weren't marching as part of a union
0:12:49they were just carpenters you had their
0:12:51hard hats on were like here we you know
0:12:53like fuck yeah this is exactly kind of
0:12:57the story that they're telling a story
0:12:59by their presence and that story is a
0:13:02story that that often gets neglected
0:13:04like you don't we don't as a we don't
0:13:09typically look at a construction site
0:13:10and and see into it it's just a
0:13:15buildings are getting built and we don't
0:13:17see who's there and we don't see the
0:13:19inner politics and when we talk about
0:13:22equal pay for equal work or we talk
0:13:24about the workplace we kind of typically
0:13:25picture of an office environment yeah
0:13:28but I mean also I mean at first I want
0:13:30to stipulate I am NOT making fun of
0:13:32these movements or of this March I mean
0:13:33merely groaning about the situation in
0:13:36life but you know you think about go
0:13:38back to Flashdance and was like oh it's
0:13:39a sexy lady with long hair who's a
0:13:41welder it was my back that kind of story
0:13:43you know I mean part of the part of the
0:13:45stop your story but part of it is that
0:13:47like it feels like so many of the
0:13:49amazing and wonderful and overdue
0:13:52changes that have happened in the last
0:13:53five to 15 years are widely adopted and
0:13:59loved by 90% of the people on our side
0:14:03of the aisle and so many of those
0:14:04changes are are so threatening as to be
0:14:08deniable to people on the other side of
0:14:11the aisle but this is a good example of
0:14:14one that I feel like there's no one in
0:14:17America on either side of the aisle
0:14:19ninety-eight percent of the people in
0:14:21America I think would look at one of
0:14:24these women in her heart hat with her
0:14:26Union jacket on and go yeah fuck yeah
0:14:29right there's no one in America anymore
0:14:32that thinks there shouldn't be female
0:14:34carpenters right and I think that
0:14:38everyone in you know the most
0:14:41conservative voter in Alabama is not
0:14:45going to I mean there there are gonna be
0:14:47people they're gonna be dicks and and
0:14:50like they're gonna be dicks who no
0:14:53matter what their political affiliation
0:14:55when a when a woman shows up to do the
0:14:57work on their kitchen they're gonna go
0:14:59oh a woman's doing this job you know
0:15:03they're and and they're gonna be dicks
0:15:04that are both men and women that do that
0:15:06I mean I'm sure that there are women
0:15:07that opened the door to their house and
0:15:09there's a woman carpenter standing there
0:15:11and they say oh I expected a man mm-hmm
0:15:15you know that kind of thing is just a
0:15:17sort of cultural like ignorant or not
0:15:20ignorance it's just a like a culture so
0:15:22probably the lack of exposure I mean
0:15:24like if you've got if you've got some
0:15:25Richard Scarry idea in your head from
0:15:28the late 1960s it's understandable that
0:15:30that's a little bit shocking it doesn't
0:15:32mean that you hate it but it's certainly
0:15:34at least be shocking
0:15:35Yeah right it's like lowly worm yeah
0:15:37shows up to do your kitchen work and
0:15:39you're like you're a girl worm whoo
0:15:41that's that mr. frumble drive she's got
0:15:45a lot of problems there are plenty of
0:15:47cops in Richards Gary's world I don't
0:15:49know why they don't but sergeant Murphy
0:15:51chases careless he literally rides a
0:15:52motorcycle onto a Plane full of people
0:15:54you're right you're right but but the
0:16:00other thing that I saw in this rally
0:16:02that I'm talking about just people that
0:16:03were marching very close to me there
0:16:05were two women in their 60s and they
0:16:08were both about five feet tall and they
0:16:11were at first not clearly a couple they
0:16:16were just too diminutive ladies in their
0:16:2060s but one of them is holding a small
0:16:23hand lettered sign that said that wasn't
0:16:26like us it wasn't even a sign it was
0:16:27just kind of like a piece of notebook
0:16:29paper that she had written on and
0:16:31laminated and it said we're not going
0:16:34back and as the as the March progressed
0:16:38I realized oh my god they're they're
0:16:42married and they give every indication
0:16:47of having been together for 40 years you
0:16:50know they're they have the comfort with
0:16:54one another that just is like it seems
0:16:56like they've probably been together for
0:16:58a long long time and they're not
0:17:00demonstrative they're not even really
0:17:02holding hands they're just walking
0:17:05together with this sign we're not going
0:17:06back and it was you know so so powerful
0:17:12and I and I honestly believe having
0:17:15traveled as much as I've been lucky to
0:17:19do in America and around the world that
0:17:22most people on either side of the
0:17:26political aisle confronted with these
0:17:28two actual human beings are not going to
0:17:32be against it the people that are
0:17:35against gay marriage are against it
0:17:37because they're against an idea that
0:17:41they think and they're against a notion
0:17:44that we're trying to cram it down their
0:17:46throats or I feel it feels like a like a
0:17:48threat to their
0:17:49idea of what a family is which which
0:17:51they would say d legitimizes there it's
0:17:53again it's like Ghostbusters it's like
0:17:54you're ruining my childhood by being
0:17:56married right but if they were living in
0:17:59a place where they knew these two and
0:18:01there are couples like this in Alabama
0:18:05just like there are in Seattle a hundred
0:18:07percent when confronted with actual
0:18:10people pretty much everybody with the
0:18:13exception of a few crazy zealots is
0:18:16gonna look at them and go oh well I mean
0:18:19I make an exception for my for my aunt
0:18:21and her friend you know like and it's
0:18:24not especially because they're they're
0:18:26not too vocal about it maybe yeah sort
0:18:28of like well there's well there's this
0:18:29one guy I work with who's really nice
0:18:31and he's nearing retirement age and I'm
0:18:33pretty sure he's you know special but he
0:18:35could he gets a pass because he's real
0:18:36low-key about it it's not in my face
0:18:38about it and it's not the perfect world
0:18:40that we would that we I in the left like
0:18:45idealize where everyone is absolutely
0:18:47like completely forward-facing about who
0:18:52they are and accepted broadly by
0:18:54everyone you know it it is a kind of on
0:18:59the right side of the aisle there is
0:19:01this there's all this tremendous kind of
0:19:03like what we what we think of as a
0:19:06prehistoric social thinking but
0:19:09confronted by actual people yeah pretty
0:19:12much everybody is like you cannot deny a
0:19:17thing like that you can't look at them
0:19:18and say to their face like no you're not
0:19:22you should not be entitled to this you
0:19:24should not be entitled to this happiness
0:19:25you do it's nobody would ever stand in
0:19:27front of those people I mean the way you
0:19:29get the idea some kind of Richard
0:19:30Spencer type like yelling at them but
0:19:32like after having a ten minute fifteen
0:19:33minute conversation maybe you're on a
0:19:35plane or something like that you would
0:19:36never you would it would be a hard
0:19:38harder person to turn to them and say
0:19:39well I understand what you're trying to
0:19:41do here but this is antithetical to
0:19:42everything that America is and I think
0:19:44you're evil yeah I mean and you do see
0:19:46that I mean there are definitely parents
0:19:49that reject their own children fewer and
0:19:53farther between
0:19:54I think what's I think what's crazy
0:19:57about Trump I know we never talk about
0:20:00politics
0:20:02I think what's crazy is that he has
0:20:06finally given the lie to the idea that
0:20:09the that conservative politically
0:20:12conservative people are the scolds and
0:20:15the moralizing like finger wag they're
0:20:20gonna hold privately and publicly
0:20:22they're gonna they have a standard that
0:20:24they will hold people to for a long time
0:20:27you would see that played out in terms
0:20:28of like what you have to make this cake
0:20:30you know you know you don't have to make
0:20:31this cake for gay people or you do not
0:20:33have to provide women's health care
0:20:36services because right I mean there's
0:20:39there's those sorts of things but then
0:20:41when you see what's happening with the
0:20:43fairly well documented allegations
0:20:45against the president it just doesn't
0:20:48seem to matter and Mike Pence is totally
0:20:49cool with it it just doesn't matter
0:20:51right I mean it's not like it's not even
0:20:53that I had that Trump had relationships
0:20:56with sex workers while he while his wife
0:20:59was pregnant we had a four month old son
0:21:02duh Trump is famous for for riding on
0:21:06that private jet
0:21:08but with that pedophile guy yeah who you
0:21:12know would like teenagers like and I
0:21:16mean he was the source of a lot of the
0:21:17New York Post stories about Marla maples
0:21:20I mean he was the one that encouraged
0:21:22her to go on say was the best best sex
0:21:24I've ever had he drives in that
0:21:26environment of people thinking he's a
0:21:27very competent horndog but I think it's
0:21:29really interesting because during the
0:21:33Clinton years when when Bill Clinton was
0:21:35being pounded for his for his like
0:21:40dalliance ah's and his indiscretions and
0:21:44his predatory behavior we I think
0:21:48assumed that that was being motivated by
0:21:52this religious right that we've been
0:21:55talking about for for 40 years and that
0:21:57they were that they were pretty and they
0:22:01were pursuing this out of a sense of
0:22:03this sort of moral like overactive moral
0:22:08indignation about post moral majority
0:22:09whether you agreed with them or not and
0:22:11I happened very much not to agree with
0:22:13them you'd at least given the creditors
0:22:15well you know whether or not this is
0:22:17something that they enjoy doing they
0:22:18feel by their faith and ethics they are
0:22:21obligated to call these things out on
0:22:23anybody where they see it right right
0:22:26it's a good it's a mr. kind of mission
0:22:28and that gave some clarity to the
0:22:33division between left and right because
0:22:36we on the left could look at them and
0:22:39say and see like okay they are bound by
0:22:42a code that includes their religion it
0:22:46includes their culture and it is
0:22:48internally consistent so they are they
0:22:52are an understandable and worthy
0:22:53adversary even if we don't agree I mean
0:22:57we don't agree with a lot of the
0:22:59fundamental premises but they are acting
0:23:01at least they're not inconsistent as far
0:23:04as we can see I'm avoiding the word
0:23:06hypothetical but but at least at least
0:23:09on the face of it they may be in prison
0:23:11I utterly disagree with them but there
0:23:13was an internal consistency to their
0:23:15their mass hattery
0:23:16but it also contextualized us right
0:23:19because as live liberals we were
0:23:21progressive we were it
0:23:23empathetic we were we were the ones that
0:23:28were open minded and now or maybe
0:23:34relativistic there's another word
0:23:35relativistic sure you can see you would
0:23:37see the context in something and this
0:23:39liberal arts II thing of saying like
0:23:40well yes but yes but so we wouldn't
0:23:43necessarily see it as a zero no one
0:23:45right and we were multicultural we were
0:23:47able to say like well we you know we
0:23:50need to incorporate things from around
0:23:53the world and sometimes these cultural
0:23:55differences can be advantageous you know
0:24:00it was a kind of m'as how we saw the
0:24:05social aspect of left and right and that
0:24:08wasn't always the case you know back in
0:24:10the back before World War two back
0:24:14before the civil rights movement the
0:24:16Republican Party was mostly focused on
0:24:19economics and they had a pretty liberal
0:24:23view about what a person should be able
0:24:25to do in the
0:24:26to their own home I'm from a certain
0:24:28libertarian standpoint it was a temple
0:24:30yeah and it was the Democrats that were
0:24:33all about segregation and they were all
0:24:36about you know the Democrats before
0:24:39World War two were not like socially
0:24:42progressive looks sort of the opposite
0:24:45mm-hmm but now we're in a situation
0:24:49where the where the right side of the
0:24:51aisle has pretty much for the most part
0:24:53said you know although we're Christians
0:24:56and although we you know we believe in
0:24:59God and country we think Trump's doing a
0:25:01great job and although he is like a
0:25:04coke-fueled like prostitute abusing like
0:25:10I mean he's basically he personifies
0:25:12everything that we would normally hate
0:25:15disparity at the late 80s yeah we just
0:25:18love what he's doing he's just sticking
0:25:19it he's sticking it to the Liberals and
0:25:21that's what we love but what's crazy is
0:25:24the Left have become the scolds like we
0:25:28are we are in an era right now where the
0:25:31left is extremely moralizing and very
0:25:35very much like driven by a by a kind of
0:25:39collective energy that is you know
0:25:45that's using shame and using a lot of
0:25:48the sort of things that we would have 40
0:25:50years ago called moral majority tactics
0:25:54I guess in service of a different
0:25:56ideology but but but it's it's a very
0:26:01strange role reversal because that's the
0:26:04thing when I went back to my high school
0:26:05reunion in Anchorage right before the
0:26:08election and I talked to a bunch of my
0:26:11pals who were all golf pros and
0:26:17snowmobile salesmen and and diehard sort
0:26:23of Trump people yeah they were like you
0:26:28don't you don't see what's coming bro
0:26:29and I was like yeah I see what's coming
0:26:32a Hillary Clinton administration where
0:26:35the world moves into the future and they
0:26:37were like no no no that's not what's
0:26:40gonna happen Trump's gonna win and I was
0:26:43like there's no way in a million years
0:26:45Trump's gonna win he didn't accuse
0:26:46anyone yeah and they were like no no you
0:26:49don't see you don't get it you don't see
0:26:51what's happening and in talking to them
0:26:54over the course of a long reunion
0:26:56weekend I realized oh they think they're
0:27:01the fun ones they think they think
0:27:04they're hilarious they think they're the
0:27:05ones that know how to party they think
0:27:08they are the ones who have the real
0:27:10temperature of what America is all about
0:27:12the sort of Ted Nugent version of what's
0:27:17fun and cool and they looked at me and
0:27:22my culture I mean they know I'm fun
0:27:23right but they look at that liberalism
0:27:25and they think you guys aren't fun you
0:27:28don't have fun anymore you just are so
0:27:30uptight and you're so you know this this
0:27:33careless caricature of the left as being
0:27:36sort of what we used to say about the
0:27:40moral majority just like no fun and
0:27:44caught up in in our cane and archaic
0:27:49ideas about what people are and I was
0:27:54just like that was kind of that was kind
0:27:56of when I got off Twitter I realized
0:27:57like oh shit I don't know anything
0:27:59anymore
0:27:59I'm in the upside down now yeah I heard
0:28:07something on a political podcast I was
0:28:09listening to you this morning and guy
0:28:10said something that I thought was it's
0:28:13one of those things where once you you
0:28:14can't can't unhear it get such a useful
0:28:17paradigm is there are certain kinds of
0:28:19issues where people rarely go back to
0:28:24their original feeling people tend to
0:28:27only go one way and he said he was
0:28:30talking in particular about daca and how
0:28:32like once you know these people who are
0:28:37daca recipients and like once you've
0:28:39once you've met them once you've talked
0:28:41to them
0:28:42you're very rarely going to become more
0:28:44strident about thinking they should be
0:28:46thrown out of the country you know I
0:28:47mean and
0:28:48he also used the example of gay marriage
0:28:50where honestly if a big part of it and
0:28:53in addition to certainly obviously I
0:28:54mean this is sounds so stupid but stuff
0:28:56like you know maybe Ellen DeGeneres but
0:28:58stuff like seeing more gay people like
0:28:59on TV and knowing more gay people were
0:29:02out there that weren't dangerous
0:29:03pedophiles that was certainly a part of
0:29:04it but another part of it was like once
0:29:06you it isn't like you know once you meet
0:29:08two women who've been together since the
0:29:101960s yeah and it can be and are very
0:29:14smart and charming you don't go oh boy
0:29:17you know this makes me even madder about
0:29:18this you know I mean there aren't that
0:29:21many people who start out Pro gay
0:29:22marriage and then go the other way
0:29:24there aren't them people who start out
0:29:25Pro daca and go back the other way I
0:29:27don't I don't have a huge filter for
0:29:28this it's a two-hour old idea to me but
0:29:30I'm really interested of this idea like
0:29:32how many issues are there like that
0:29:33we're once people get enough exposure to
0:29:36the actual people they look at the thing
0:29:39really differently I'm reminded of that
0:29:41peanuts comic where Linus is arguing
0:29:43with Lucy and he says I love humanity
0:29:47it's people that I hate I I think I
0:29:52think that's absolutely true and I think
0:29:53it is about abstract thinking you know
0:29:57the once you are once you're capable of
0:30:02seeing things at one abstraction which
0:30:06by which I mean like not the people
0:30:09immediately in front of you but you meet
0:30:11you meet that couple that's been
0:30:12together since the 60s and then
0:30:14extrapolate that to imagine that there
0:30:16are more of those that level of
0:30:20abstraction because we here in southern
0:30:22Washington you know that there was that
0:30:23McSweeney's article the other day that
0:30:25that parodied the the journalists that
0:30:29are like going around talking to Trump
0:30:30was just literally the next thing I was
0:30:33going to say yes but there was one of
0:30:37those here in Washington where some
0:30:39reporter went down to the conservative
0:30:43like southwestern corner of Washington
0:30:46where they grow a lot of cranberries and
0:30:49said like you know how does it feel down
0:30:52here now that you know now that we're
0:30:56cracking down on immigrants and the
0:30:59sheriff and almost everybody they talked
0:31:02to was
0:31:02like well we want to crack down on
0:31:06immigrants because they are their
0:31:09rapists and criminals coming into the
0:31:11country but what that law has done is it
0:31:14like they came and got my neighbor Pablo
0:31:18who's a great dude and he's he's gonna
0:31:22raper he's been here four years he was
0:31:24like he was invaluable to the community
0:31:26and then they came and got those guys
0:31:28that have been working on them but they
0:31:31might say every single talking point
0:31:33that everybody on the Left has been
0:31:34saying right I mean right down to like
0:31:37like this like this polish doctor in
0:31:39Michigan who doesn't know polish because
0:31:41he's been here since he was three right
0:31:44that's like you how could you send it
0:31:46back there there's not even any place to
0:31:47send him back to he's never been there
0:31:48and you're like yeah that's that sucks
0:31:51that's kind of why we think this is a
0:31:52bad idea they know but everybody has
0:31:55their Pablo right but they don't extend
0:31:58it right they don't extend it to the
0:32:00abstraction of of and that's why
0:32:04statistics are so interesting like I I
0:32:08follow this guy on Twitter named Max
0:32:09roser ro ser who is a statistician and
0:32:14he really stays kind of above politics
0:32:18he just puts in numbers
0:32:20I think he's German and he you know not
0:32:24to not to stereotype no but he's a
0:32:28German statistician mm-hmm and and he is
0:32:32you know he's always posting these
0:32:34graphs and sort of very interesting
0:32:37takes on on things just just crunching
0:32:40the numbers but you look at the numbers
0:32:43and it's like well I mean my mom sent me
0:32:45something the other day that was like
0:32:47immigrants from sub-saharan Africa have
0:32:51such a greater percentage of graduate
0:32:54degrees I mean they're like a moderator
0:32:57college graduation rate then people who
0:32:59are born in the United States yeah and
0:33:01it's just impossible to argue with the
0:33:05statistics but it is but again that is
0:33:09an abstraction that it's I think much
0:33:13easier for people to
0:33:15- to see the abstraction in the other
0:33:18direction which is well I watch cops
0:33:20every week and every single person they
0:33:22pull over an arrest is black used to
0:33:25watch that show therefore every criminal
0:33:28in America is black right because that's
0:33:30what's on cops and that's that's much
0:33:36easier to apprehend then wait a minute
0:33:39the people that are immigrating to the
0:33:40United States from other countries are
0:33:42the best educated and best qualified
0:33:46people because it's really hard to
0:33:47immigrate to America you have to put up
0:33:50with so much shit
0:33:51it's insane yeah and you know and even
0:33:54people that are entering the country
0:33:56illegally are people who are aspiring
0:34:00you know they are people that are
0:34:02seeking something great and not people
0:34:07that are complacent or lazy or dumb you
0:34:10know
0:34:11nobody makes it all the way to America
0:34:13and gets a shitty job from wherever
0:34:17they're coming from because they are
0:34:18just lazy you know they're enterprising
0:34:22but it's you know I don't know speaking
0:34:27as someone who's a liberal it's very
0:34:35hard for me not to feel like it's not
0:34:40just that my views are better it's that
0:34:45my views are more accurate and that's
0:34:48all maybe that at least in your own head
0:34:50is slightly better tested well or I mean
0:34:54just just there's so much there's just
0:34:56so much reckoning going on about
0:34:59strangers there's just so much reckoning
0:35:01going on about millions of people who
0:35:04are disadvantaged culturally in a way
0:35:08that so many of that 32% are 36% are not
0:35:13and yet they have found some way to find
0:35:16a grievant in every cultural improvement
0:35:18in the last 50 years every every time
0:35:21somebody who's not them gets something
0:35:22it's a zero-sum game like everything
0:35:24everything that somebody who has always
0:35:26been treated like shit for their and
0:35:28our life gets is necessarily one less
0:35:31thing that they get in their mind that
0:35:33tends to be the yeah it tends to be the
0:35:36feeling but then like today oh sorry
0:35:39a couple couple weeks ago the president
0:35:41has decided you know because he's saving
0:35:43coal so now he's gonna put a tariff on
0:35:46imports of solar energy things so energy
0:35:49one of the one of the bright spots if
0:35:50you like to coin a pun
0:35:52one of the bright spots in growth like
0:35:54one in five new jobs suppose something
0:35:55like that as it is in solar it's going
0:35:57way way up while Cole's was going way
0:35:58way down and now they're making it more
0:36:00costly to have this this huge exploding
0:36:02growth growth area that actually could
0:36:04benefit the people who still think
0:36:05they're gonna be back in the mind any
0:36:07day now but and that's an example of a
0:36:11band I think is really intriguing about
0:36:13the cultural divide that we're
0:36:15experiencing right now which is that I
0:36:19think that there are a lot of people in
0:36:22America that will celebrate that event
0:36:28based exclusively on this idea that it's
0:36:35a it's a big middle finger to the
0:36:39hippies and I mean I drove across the
0:36:42country a couple of years ago when I
0:36:44bought my suburban which admittedly is a
0:36:47hilariously like old janky American
0:36:54truck and through the whole center of
0:36:57the country I encountered many many
0:36:59times those guys who are burning coal
0:37:01which is they they put a giant
0:37:05smokestack on their diesel truck and
0:37:07they adjust B the mixture so that when
0:37:14they slam on the gas it just sends huge
0:37:17black clouds of smoke out of their
0:37:20tailpipes with no purpose other than to
0:37:26give you that Ted Nugent fuck you and
0:37:29they're not driving those trucks in the
0:37:32middle of San Francisco they're driving
0:37:33them in Nebraska they're saying fuck you
0:37:35to the idea of a liberal
0:37:40there aren't any around them they're
0:37:42just doing it as like as a middle finger
0:37:45to people who aren't even watching and
0:37:47that that conviction that that strong
0:37:53strong feeling that the real enemy is is
0:38:00this caricature of someone kind of not
0:38:06unlike you or I but certainly like we're
0:38:10we are closer or more adjacent to this
0:38:12caricature than we are to the to to like
0:38:18the audience and a Darius Rucker concert
0:38:21but but this idea of someone with a
0:38:28college degree who thinks they're
0:38:30smarter than you who wants to quote
0:38:33unquote ram down your throats these
0:38:38ideas that that really have nothing to
0:38:41do with the fact that you get along
0:38:43pretty well with your gay neighbors but
0:38:45have everything to do with the idea that
0:38:47we are we have a vision which is of this
0:38:52to this future universe where where
0:38:58there's no manufacturing in America
0:39:01anymore that it's all been outsourced
0:39:03and the government is in charge of
0:39:06everything take your guns away take your
0:39:11guns away except that the government
0:39:13allows you to do whatever you want
0:39:18include including be a pedophile or a or
0:39:22like sex with animals or whatever it is
0:39:25that they extend this this criticism out
0:39:29to you know like this weird this weird
0:39:32idea of a liberal as someone who both
0:39:35wants to have complete like lawlessness
0:39:41on one side what they considered
0:39:43lawlessness on one side of the world
0:39:45they want to be this like Caligula n--
0:39:48Bacchanalia on the one side even as
0:39:50they're taking away everything that
0:39:52gives your life meaning enjoy
0:39:53right so you're no longer allowed to
0:39:55worship your god you're no longer
0:39:57allowed to salute your flag we don't
0:40:00support the troops we don't allow you to
0:40:01have guns we tax all your money away to
0:40:05give it to undeserving poor people the
0:40:09abortion having trans people abortion
0:40:11having trans people who are just living
0:40:12on welfare and this is the vision of the
0:40:16world that we that that that they
0:40:19perceive us desiring and a lot of us are
0:40:23dupes right we are leftist dupes of we
0:40:28have taken the red pill we haven't taken
0:40:30the red pill that's right the Jews are
0:40:32controlling our government and and we
0:40:36are just like enthrall we're in this
0:40:41kind of days of of almost like romantic
0:40:47thrall to the idea of inclusiveness that
0:40:51is going to create a world where we're
0:40:54under Sharia law so it's almost like
0:40:59some kind of like a 50s movie where
0:41:02there's a there's a working ranch and
0:41:04some sissy dandy in a suit comes to
0:41:08visit and then wants to tell them how to
0:41:10run a ranch mm-hmm right or like yeah is
0:41:14sitting in the sitting in the scenic
0:41:16carriage Fanning himself with that with
0:41:18a lace hanky and then telling you how to
0:41:20run the ranch while he's sitting on his
0:41:21ass mining Bitcoin well you know in a
0:41:23way it's almost it's closer to the
0:41:26character of the environmental
0:41:30protection guy in Ghostbusters movie
0:41:35that movie you know yeah he's the only
0:41:39good guy this man has no dick when you
0:41:46watch that film you hear everything
0:41:50about it is like this guy is the worst
0:41:52version of a Carter Administration
0:41:55bureaucrat mm-hm and the the only way he
0:41:59makes money is by causing trouble and
0:42:01hardship for hardworking Americans for
0:42:04hardworking Americans who are just
0:42:05trying to bust just trying to
0:42:06to go so it makes them feel good and
0:42:07it's a politically a weird movie because
0:42:10though because the Ghostbusters are our
0:42:13academics and they're like
0:42:16devil-may-care but they're really I mean
0:42:20when you look at it now sure there they
0:42:22are you know they're kind of politically
0:42:26pretty Trumpy in terms of of how they
0:42:30approach dealing you know dealing with
0:42:34government people I'm watching almost
0:42:35any thriller from the last 30 years so
0:42:39the bad guys always the administrator
0:42:41right well no but also just the good
0:42:43guys I mean certainly you go would you
0:42:45go back to something like Charles
0:42:45Bronson Klee nice wait but I'm talking
0:42:47even like I rewatched taken which is a
0:42:49movie that I like a lot I hadn't watched
0:42:51it since the last election and I just
0:42:53watched it the other night and I was
0:42:54like wow this is really it's kind of a
0:42:57testament to how dads are right and and
0:43:00by any means necessary we do what we
0:43:02need to do because daughter it's like I
0:43:04mean it's really it is it is in some
0:43:06ways very much like a death wish
0:43:09kind of moving in a lot of ways I mean
0:43:12you mean just like that they're just
0:43:13like the the non authoritarian what's
0:43:16the word I'm looking for
0:43:17but like oh like in that movies just
0:43:19like he keeps worn everything taken no
0:43:22is this is this retired like ops guy is
0:43:28you know now he's away from his his wife
0:43:30and daughter the daughters gonna go to
0:43:31Europe and he's like no no you can't go
0:43:33and if you go you got to take this phone
0:43:34and answer my calls a spoiler alert she
0:43:36gets abducted he has to go and find her
0:43:38they've now drugged her and turned her
0:43:40into a prostitute she and her friend and
0:43:42he's got to go rescue her from all these
0:43:44Eastern European baddies and of course
0:43:46he just beats it's great movie he beats
0:43:48the shit out of everybody kills
0:43:49everybody and saves them and then like
0:43:51you were shown that once a fraud dad
0:43:53always knew what was right and finally
0:43:55that violence that he has had inside of
0:43:58him all that time was there for a good
0:43:59reason
0:43:59yeah yeah I mean that's the best lesson
0:44:02to be gleaned that's the cookie cutter
0:44:04thriller lesson right the yeah the this
0:44:08the the quiet Stern dad has just been
0:44:13pushed a little too far yeah had had the
0:44:16truth about the world the whole time
0:44:18and I bet that libertarianism combined
0:44:22with that sort of I guess what what now
0:44:26we would just describe with with no
0:44:29other with no other conditions we would
0:44:32just call it patriarchy or patriarchal
0:44:34mentality I mean that's like it's a
0:44:38ribbon through everything yeah and there
0:44:41there was a time until recently where
0:44:47where our take on that was a lot more
0:44:51complex than it is now and it doesn't
0:44:54feel like this is a time when we can
0:44:56afford to be complex this is another
0:44:59thing that has caused me to to feel
0:45:03personally like it this is just a time
0:45:04for me to sit out and and it's because
0:45:09it's very hard for me to look at things
0:45:11and not look at them and try to see the
0:45:15complexity in them and when you want to
0:45:18talk at least publicly now about ideas
0:45:20that are complex you're immediately
0:45:23challenged because it doesn't because
0:45:26complexity just doesn't want a
0:45:28revolutionary yeah that's right if we're
0:45:30living in a bicameral world now that
0:45:33feels very black and white and so you
0:45:36can't say like you can't really approach
0:45:40anything at least publicly at least in a
0:45:43public-facing way without taking a
0:45:47pretty dogmatic side and I just can't I
0:45:49just can't swallow it but yeah but you
0:45:52know in in our history a lot of the
0:45:56things that we look at and say that's
0:45:58what is American you know that's what
0:46:01made made us exceptional that is what we
0:46:04have always talked about as the American
0:46:06spirit and it isn't it isn't
0:46:10inextricably connected to white
0:46:12supremacy or to patriarchy there there
0:46:15are attitudes that are distinctively
0:46:17American that we have made us proud for
0:46:20200 years and that those ideas are like
0:46:23individuality individualism I guess more
0:46:27than individuality and that can-do
0:46:31spirit and
0:46:32[Music]
0:46:34I mean all that all that sort of go
0:46:37get'em USA rah-rah stuff but there's a
0:46:40lot of there's a lot interesting about
0:46:42it there's a lot that's true about it
0:46:43and and I think on the right side of the
0:46:47aisle they feel like they are the ob
0:46:51inheritors or the protectors of some of
0:46:53those enshrined ideas and and on the
0:46:59Left I mean the you know there are a lot
0:47:01of liberal Patriots and I and I include
0:47:05myself like when I see people on the
0:47:08left say America is a garbage country
0:47:11and always has been I'm like I'm sorry
0:47:14you're wrong like you're just deeply
0:47:17profoundly wrong and that might feel
0:47:19good to say and that might feel like a
0:47:21like year on their side of the room I
0:47:24mean Jimmy but it was an evolving
0:47:25garbage fire like the the strides were
0:47:28taken every few years where things got a
0:47:30little better in one way no they were
0:47:31not always good and sometimes it does
0:47:33take a miniature revolution but that's
0:47:35that's what is it the long arc of
0:47:36history right is that like things really
0:47:38have gotten better in many quantifiable
0:47:41ways for a lot of people and it's taken
0:47:43a long time to get around to other
0:47:44people who need that and that progress
0:47:46was being made for a time it's it's that
0:47:50progress is still being it's weirdly
0:47:52Puttanesca though to find this both
0:47:54sides ISM and going oh well you know
0:47:56unless you were this kind of person so
0:47:57yeah that was true but like we're
0:47:59working on that that actually is that
0:48:00actually is getting better it's yeah
0:48:03it's I mean I know that's super easy for
0:48:05me to say but I think there's evidence
0:48:07out there that until fairly recently
0:48:08things really were on a pretty
0:48:12interesting upward incline and now now I
0:48:15think it's just a waiting I mean hate to
0:48:16cut to the chase but a lot of there's
0:48:17just no demographics King demographics
0:48:19game it's just a matter of waiting to
0:48:21age out the assholes well it is but I
0:48:24mean I don't think it's easy for you to
0:48:25say I think it is I think it's a
0:48:27challenge to remind ourselves that if
0:48:30you watch the news every day and if you
0:48:33see you know if you see the bad things
0:48:36that are being reported in the way that
0:48:37the in the way that they are like yeah
0:48:39this feels like a time where we're
0:48:41falling back or whether it
0:48:42evil is ascendant but actually things
0:48:45are getting better everyday in everyway
0:48:48and the you know the rule of law is
0:48:52gonna triumph and I mean what you don't
0:48:55think of is ten years ago all the things
0:48:57that all the terrible things that were
0:48:59happening all the people that were
0:49:00getting deported all survived 1968 we
0:49:03can survive almost anything well sure
0:49:05would survive 1985 but I mean I think
0:49:09yeah good you're breaking up a little
0:49:12bit oh I'm sorry
0:49:15hello hey are you BitTorrent hello hello
0:49:18I hear you do you know I'm I hear you I
0:49:21think you fire me yeah keep going I'll
0:49:23put a marker here and take this out okay
0:49:26I think you're all right
0:49:27I just I mean I believe in the American
0:49:31experiment I don't believe that the
0:49:33United States is a trash fire I think if
0:49:35you go back to 1780
0:49:38and you look at every other nation on
0:49:40earth and compare our founding to theirs
0:49:44or to their status then and if you go
0:49:47back to 1900 if you go back to 1865 if
0:49:51you go anywhere in history and do a line
0:49:54by line comparison to what was happening
0:49:56in the United States you're gonna find
0:49:59that there aren't very many places that
0:50:01you can look at and say oh wow the US
0:50:05was really evil compared to right I mean
0:50:08the United Kingdom abolished slavery a
0:50:11lot sooner than America did but sooner
0:50:16by a factor of 40 years like it's not
0:50:20like it's not like Britain had outlawed
0:50:22slavery in 1500 and we were some kind of
0:50:25South Africa that persisted like it was
0:50:29an evolving process and you know to look
0:50:32back at the history of American say that
0:50:34we're we have blood on our hands is only
0:50:38to fail to look back at the history of
0:50:40the world and see that everyone has
0:50:42blood on their hands that no one there's
0:50:45no nation on earth that is absolved if
0:50:50the nation of Belgium continued to
0:50:52exploit their colonies in Africa until
0:50:56the fifties and exploit them in ways
0:50:59that would would you know burn your
0:51:02eyebrows oh is that like Congo yeah it's
0:51:05a dozen colony yeah the Congo which is
0:51:08an enormous the the entire Central
0:51:13Africa and they you know they were I
0:51:16mean they were brutal there but nobody
0:51:18looks at Belgium and says like oh what a
0:51:20knee I mean I guess the Belgians do and
0:51:22people in Europe that know that story
0:51:24but the whole idea that like America is
0:51:27a terrible place it's just it's just
0:51:28wrong we have been in we have been
0:51:30setting the tempo for 200 years for the
0:51:35extension and expansion of rights to the
0:51:37greatest number of people and political
0:51:41rights and social evolution like it's
0:51:43been happening here and other people
0:51:47have other countries have been following
0:51:49in our wake and I know there are a lot
0:51:50of Europeans who want to who want to
0:51:52point to their their own country's
0:51:56contributions to that but I think you
0:52:00would have a hard time making a case
0:52:01that certainly that that many countries
0:52:06in Western Europe have been working on
0:52:09that project any earlier than about 1960
0:52:12you know what I mean like I mean so and
0:52:15and the United Kingdom obviously like a
0:52:17separate they have a sort of separate
0:52:21dispensation but they're it's not like
0:52:23they've been a liberal democracy this
0:52:25whole time but you know it's I'm just
0:52:29I'm rehashing something that everybody
0:52:31has said every day for over a year now
0:52:33but the part the part and why I've read
0:52:35about Congress in particular is that you
0:52:38know whether or not what James Buchanan
0:52:43you know Herbert Hoover warren g harding
0:52:45you know you got you got these
0:52:47characters that you run into the maybe
0:52:49aren't the best example of American
0:52:51exceptionalism but like by and large
0:52:53most people who were in the White House
0:52:54at least bought the best lies about you
0:52:58got it you got to bring Harding into
0:52:59this at least most most people whether
0:53:05or not Bill Clinton is the best human
0:53:07being or
0:53:08you know George I mean I'm not here to
0:53:11rehabilitate the reputation of george w
0:53:12bush but boy by comparison but i mean at
0:53:16least i mean george w bush may have been
0:53:18a not very bright dry drunk but i think
0:53:21in his heart he probably believed a lot
0:53:23of the better truths and and some of the
0:53:25more interesting lies about america that
0:53:26let's we'll be able to get through it
0:53:27from week to week and certainly think
0:53:29brock obama believed it big time do you
0:53:31remember two years ago we still said
0:53:34things like george bush was the worst
0:53:36president i know i know two years and
0:53:38now he just seems like uh if we could
0:53:40only go back to to a day when the
0:53:43president knew which side of his body
0:53:45his heart was on right right but but
0:53:47that's on the one hand though you've got
0:53:49somebody in there who clearly i mean
0:53:53setting aside all the narcissism and all
0:53:54that kind of stuff but it's somebody who
0:53:55clearly does not like the actual the
0:54:00real stuff that has made America great
0:54:01and has no respect for the agreed upon
0:54:04lies that made America pretty good he
0:54:06just doesn't care he's fine to burn it
0:54:08all down I'm even gonna set aside the
0:54:10mental stuff for now but just even just
0:54:12the ability to like as they say you know
0:54:14he's gonna be persuaded by the last you
0:54:16know general that he talked to as far as
0:54:18what he thinks from now on that's not
0:54:20bad enough like I actually think we
0:54:22could survive that fine if the check on
0:54:24that should be people who know better in
0:54:26Congress never side you're on and the
0:54:29fact that this is I mean I understand
0:54:30the whole basis of there's a reason they
0:54:31call it politics it's not Paul a friend
0:54:33like I get that but like there's just
0:54:36there's something so upsetting to me
0:54:37about how you brought to you in part by
0:54:49squarespace you can learn more about
0:54:51Squarespace right now by going to
0:54:52squarespace.com I'm a huge fan of
0:54:54Squarespace as a listener of this show
0:54:56you are using Squarespace right now
0:54:58because that is where we host the
0:54:59Roderick on the line podcast thank you
0:55:02to Squarespace it's not just for podcast
0:55:04there are so many things you can do with
0:55:05Squarespace you can create a beautiful
0:55:06website to turn your cool idea into a
0:55:08new website you can showcase your work
0:55:10you can have a blog or publish other
0:55:12kinds of text content you can even sell
0:55:14products and services of all kinds you
0:55:16can promote your physical or online
0:55:18business you can announce an upcoming
0:55:19event or projects so much more it's
0:55:22all part of Squarespace Squarespace
0:55:24that's all this by giving you beautiful
0:55:26templates created by world-class
0:55:27designers they have powerful ecommerce
0:55:29functionality that lets you sell
0:55:31anything online the ability to customize
0:55:33the look and feel of your site the
0:55:34settings the products and more all of
0:55:36that with just a few clicks everything
0:55:38is lost optimized for mobile right out
0:55:40of the box they have a new way to buy
0:55:41domains and choose from over 200
0:55:43different extensions the analytics that
0:55:46will help you grow in real time
0:55:47built in search engine optimization free
0:55:50and secure hosting and nothing to patch
0:55:53or upgrade ever Plus they've always got
0:55:55that 24 by 7 award winning customer
0:55:57support we're encouraging folks to make
0:56:00it you make it yourself you can easily
0:56:02stand out with creating a beautiful
0:56:04website all by yourself it's beautiful
0:56:05you make it yourself it's all in there
0:56:07you don't need another person you can
0:56:08just do it all take it dreaming make it
0:56:10with Squarespace so please right now go
0:56:12to Squarespace comm for a free trial and
0:56:15when you're ready to launch use the
0:56:16offer code supertrain to save 10% off
0:56:18your first purchase of a website or
0:56:21domain our thanks to Squarespace for
0:56:23supporting roderick on the line and all
0:56:25the great shows you know you just keep
0:56:28hoping you know you guys you know what
0:56:31is it I posted up I posted a really cool
0:56:35painting of Cthulhu the other day with
0:56:38two guys in a rowboat running away from
0:56:40it and the New Yorker stock caption I
0:56:42gave to it was well that's not diagnosed
0:56:45from a distance it's like how how how
0:56:49far is it gonna go before we say this is
0:56:51I mean is it gives it gives it the worst
0:56:53thing that keeps us all up but is it
0:56:55gonna be little Rocket Man shooting at
0:56:56us what's it gonna be before people go
0:56:58dude you got a fucking toilet down like
0:57:00you've got away please learn to pretend
0:57:02like you're the fucking president and
0:57:03like whoo there's just nobody doing that
0:57:06and and that and so I guess what I'm
0:57:08trying to say is it like I am NOT here
0:57:10to whitewash and I choose that word
0:57:13carefully whitewash over the very
0:57:14problematic history of the United States
0:57:15but like there is us there is a self
0:57:19fixing nature to America that takes a
0:57:21long time that I do believe in I don't
0:57:24know if I'm always right but I do at
0:57:26least believe in that it's just that I
0:57:27don't believe that's happening right now
0:57:29and just even just look at the EPA
0:57:31people are saying it might take 30 years
0:57:33to undo what's already happened to the
0:57:35EPA there's stuff like that that is just
0:57:37like at a time when everything's just
0:57:39the environment is just crumbling and
0:57:41the numbers are there for all of this
0:57:44stuff and nobody's standing up I'm sorry
0:57:46I'm just screaming into the wind that's
0:57:47like it's so maddening to me that there
0:57:49are not the everybo keeps talk about the
0:57:51grown-ups in the room well you know you
0:57:52got 100 grown-ups over here and over 400
0:57:54on this other side like why why aren't
0:57:56they being the grown-ups why aren't they
0:57:57it's because well some of them some of
0:57:59them benefit greatly by being able to
0:58:01not get this guy mad at them on the
0:58:03internet and then there are other people
0:58:05I guess they just they just don't have
0:58:07the political will or votes to be able
0:58:11to do anything of substance but like
0:58:13seriously like what does it gonna take
0:58:15you know to get anywhere to with near
0:58:18back to where we could be to just even
0:58:20even get back there's stuff that is as
0:58:22bad as the 50s and 60s right now
0:58:24happening that's like we lost like 50
0:58:27years somewhere the thing is that all
0:58:31any of us have is the news and and one
0:58:36of the things that we always said about
0:58:37the Internet from the very beginning was
0:58:39that I mean and this was all this was
0:58:41often talked about as a strength in the
0:58:43early days you would be able to tailor
0:58:45your news feed so that it fit your
0:58:49interests you have met your interests
0:58:51and now we are living in a world where
0:58:53you can tailor your news feed and
0:58:55everybody's watching their own
0:58:56individual news feed and the one that
0:58:58that people like us are watching is in
0:59:03full-on panic mode all the time and so
0:59:07it looks like a doomsday scenario that
0:59:11isn't an accurate picture right this
0:59:14whole like the EPA or the the damage to
0:59:16the environment is going to take 30
0:59:18years to correct well no it's it's it
0:59:22depends on how you read what's going on
0:59:25like there is damage being done yes but
0:59:27there has been there have been a lot of
0:59:30improvements the the damage even during
0:59:34the Obama administration we were still
0:59:36doing a ton of damage it's not like we
0:59:38went from from Avatar to
0:59:42to Bladerunner in two weeks and then
0:59:45we'll never get back to avatar like it's
0:59:47a continuum and and progress is being
0:59:50made so on the one hand I just I always
0:59:53caution like you get into a new cycle
0:59:56and it news is built on creating panic
0:59:59and
0:59:59and
1:00:00people mm-hmm it's very very hard to
1:00:03take one big step back and not be in a
1:00:06state of panic because in fact panicking
1:00:09feels like action you know it feels like
1:00:12you're engaged it feels like you're
1:00:14doing something to be in a state of like
1:00:18anxious like but like anxious stress all
1:00:24the time yeah but like my I do believe
1:00:30that with Trump there there is no
1:00:34putting that genie back into the bottle
1:00:36like something has changed like
1:00:44irrevocably but what Trump and the
1:00:48Congress are I think is a product of
1:00:53basically 50 years of ground game that
1:00:58the Conservatives have been playing that
1:01:00the Liberals have failed at and it
1:01:04partly it is in the nature of the two
1:01:07animals like liberalism thinks of itself
1:01:11as an over arching worldview that we are
1:01:16the people that believe in the
1:01:19philosopher-king we believe in the idea
1:01:22that if people are educated they will
1:01:24make good choices and that we need to
1:01:27bring education to places if people only
1:01:30were educated if they could only see
1:01:33then they would naturally be liberals
1:01:36and so that's been our focus for ever
1:01:41since the civil rights movement we need
1:01:44to for instance busing is an example of
1:01:48a program where we just wanted people to
1:01:51to interact with each other we were we
1:01:54were attempting to combat the the kind
1:02:02of the separatism of the races bite like
1:02:05almost force wedging them together and
1:02:10this was based on an idealistic
1:02:14that we could educate people by showing
1:02:17them and that that was going to create
1:02:20this world and on the right they had a
1:02:25very much more pragmatic approach to
1:02:28American politics which was they said
1:02:32we're going to get people elected to the
1:02:37local school board and to the County
1:02:40Council and once we get somebody in
1:02:43there then we're going to Gerry manned
1:02:46the districts so that the district okay
1:02:50once you get into the tree house we're
1:02:52gonna pull up the ladder that's right
1:02:53we're gonna draw the line now so that
1:02:56this district and no longer includes any
1:02:58black neighborhoods and the district is
1:03:00going to look like a like a paint
1:03:02splotch but that doesn't matter because
1:03:04we're not trying to create a world of
1:03:08egalitarianism we're not trying to work
1:03:11according to a premise that all people
1:03:15aspire to their highest selves we're
1:03:20trying to get political power in the
1:03:22Congress and we're gonna do that
1:03:24methodically we're gonna do that with a
1:03:26kind of military like strategy and when
1:03:30people were getting you know this is 25
1:03:32years ago we started talking about like
1:03:35wait a minute all these school boards
1:03:36are denying evolution who are these
1:03:42ding-a-lings but from the leftist
1:03:45perspective we were like well that's
1:03:46just some small-town dumb little
1:03:49Oklahoma problem and evolution is a
1:03:53widely accepted theory any smart person
1:03:55believes in it and so we're not gonna
1:03:58worry about it we're not gonna go try
1:04:00and put our own people on those school
1:04:02boards we're going to assume that things
1:04:05are you know that that our higher selves
1:04:08will win and now we're living in a world
1:04:12where the the Congress is not made up of
1:04:17people who you know who went to college
1:04:23started a successful business had an
1:04:26altruistic
1:04:27sense of American political process
1:04:31fought in the good war you know and go
1:04:35to go to Washington trying to make a
1:04:37difference we're looking at a Congress
1:04:40that is full of people that were
1:04:42strategically sent there to accomplish a
1:04:45pretty narrow mission which is basically
1:04:51hamstrung the government limit its power
1:04:55and return the right to decide whether
1:05:01evolution is true or not to the local
1:05:04school board which we've already stacked
1:05:09with people and that's the that has been
1:05:12the Republican game for 50 years and
1:05:14they it's just it's just a strategy and
1:05:18on the Left we considered ourselves
1:05:21above that kind of of like college
1:05:25football like ground game and we had
1:05:27none our ground game was all devoted to
1:05:32[Music]
1:05:33to to again this this basically long
1:05:39history premise which is the more
1:05:42educated people are the more affluent
1:05:44they are and educated they are the more
1:05:47they will take an interest in civics the
1:05:49more they will as you were saying you
1:05:53know once you have a complex idea you
1:05:56very seldom go back to a simple one
1:05:59but what we didn't understand was you
1:06:01can't just go in someplace hand them a
1:06:04complex idea handsome kid a complex idea
1:06:07and all of a sudden that idea Trump's
1:06:10his parents and his grandparents and his
1:06:12church yeah yeah yeah so anyway we've
1:06:16done a very bad job of playing football
1:06:18and the political situation we're in
1:06:23right now is is a product of that and I
1:06:28think that and the Republicans have done
1:06:30or the I'm sorry the conservative side
1:06:32of the country has done a very good job
1:06:36of characterizing us as shrill out of
1:06:40touch because because every time we've
1:06:43advanced a really great fairy we also
1:06:47it's very easy to pick and choose among
1:06:50the theories promulgated by the left and
1:06:53find one that seems bonkers to a
1:06:57church-going person in Ohio mm-hmm and
1:06:59then all you have to do is put that on
1:07:01your brochure and say look what the
1:07:03Liberals want us to do you know they
1:07:06believe that they believe that all kids
1:07:08should have sex change operations it's
1:07:11like what's what where did you get that
1:07:13you know but that but there are a lot of
1:07:16grandmother's in Ohio that that's all
1:07:18they need to hear yeah so how do we get
1:07:21our ground game back I don't think that
1:07:25it's in the nature of liberals to have a
1:07:27ground game because we're because we
1:07:31that's not how we think but weird we
1:07:35have to acknowledge that we're losing in
1:07:39a battle between like you know in a
1:07:43battle between a team that has a ground
1:07:45game we're not doing a good job of
1:07:47convincing and I don't know how to
1:07:51improve on that I don't know how to how
1:07:56to get Neil deGrasse Tyson out to the
1:08:01world and and I don't think that an
1:08:06Oprah presidency is the way but like I
1:08:10do like how many women are running for
1:08:12office oh it's fantastic Seattle has our
1:08:15first female mayor in a hundred years
1:08:17basically yeah I mean I could just think
1:08:20of half a dozen reasons why that is a
1:08:22good and encouraging sign even in
1:08:25conservative places I mean you can't you
1:08:29can't argue with
1:08:32female legislators I think they
1:08:34particularly in Congress I think a
1:08:38majority female Congress would be such a
1:08:41different animal oh my god yeah
1:08:43wouldn't matter whether they were all
1:08:44Anita Bryant's I think you would see I
1:08:48think you would see a justice just a
1:08:52different mentality yeah but I don't I
1:08:57don't know what to I don't know what the
1:09:00antidote to the present moment and the
1:09:02feeling that we are on the constant
1:09:04verge of war famine catastrophe signing
1:09:09our government for three weeks at a time
1:09:10I mean that's it's it's insane but you
1:09:13know again it's not unprecedented and as
1:09:15you were saying it's not just in 68 in
1:09:2072 in 1972 George Wallace ran for the US
1:09:24presidency on a recent like a struggling
1:09:28like a racism but I mean you see I've
1:09:30been silvered through the 90s Strom
1:09:31Thurmond right it's bananas right I mean
1:09:35there's there's there have there have
1:09:37been crazy crazy crazy times before and
1:09:42I mean obviously like I was talking to
1:09:45somebody the other day like movies in
1:09:49the future who want to cast someone in
1:09:52the role of the President of the United
1:09:53States what are they gonna do now like
1:09:57it used to be that if you wanted the
1:10:00president even if it was like a science
1:10:03fiction movie or a future movie he found
1:10:07someone that seemed serious and now how
1:10:12do you cast the president it could be it
1:10:13could be Bobcat Goldthwait ghost like
1:10:15you could have anybody straight so that
1:10:19definitely is like a that's a trip but I
1:10:23I mean every time I every time I see a
1:10:28bunch of young lawyers sitting
1:10:31indian-style on the floor at an
1:10:33immigration building like frantically
1:10:37doing pro bono work to file injunctions
1:10:42I'm reminded that this is a fucking
1:10:44great country
1:10:45oh yeah look at what happened the at the
1:10:47airports when the travel ban came down
1:10:50yeah I mean that's as horrible as
1:10:52everybody felt about that that was that
1:10:54was an amazing moment that hadn't
1:10:57happened
1:10:58imagine if the presence of that kind of
1:11:01pushback had not been in evidence at
1:11:03that time where we might even be now
1:11:04well and that if it hadn't happened
1:11:07that's where you look at your country
1:11:10and say this this place is full of decay
1:11:13and rot but it did happen and you and
1:11:17then you're able to say like I have
1:11:19faith in this I have faith in in who we
1:11:22are and what we're doing I need to not
1:11:27be sad we went to see um you know an
1:11:29okay movie who is not a fantastic movie
1:11:31although it's a movie my daughter has
1:11:33now declared it was definitely her
1:11:34favorite musical and might be here
1:11:36all-time favorite movie which is the
1:11:38greatest showmen starring wolverine and
1:11:41it's the very very heavily fictionalized
1:11:43story of PT Barnum but long story short
1:11:46one of the kind of goofy narratives in
1:11:48this is like how good he was in some
1:11:50ways too like kooky Barnum yeah giving
1:11:53like humanity to his oddities and like
1:11:55how they made this family out of the
1:11:56bearded lady and General Tom Thumb and
1:11:58and I swear to god this is an actual
1:12:00thing that happened that made me feel so
1:12:02good and I don't know I can't tell she's
1:12:04just doing this to make me feel good but
1:12:05there's this moment where like they're
1:12:07they so they're outside the Barnum
1:12:09theater and they're being confronted and
1:12:12like menaced it's like something out of
1:12:15x-men it's all these little you know all
1:12:17these local hoods with Donegal caps in
1:12:19dirt on their face I'll kick their ass
1:12:21for being creaks and it's like a shot of
1:12:23like bearded lady Chang and Eng bunker
1:12:25or the Siamese twins it's you know it's
1:12:27in the bearded lady and then it's like
1:12:29Zac Efron and zendaya the the beautiful
1:12:33slender actress and and she's kind of
1:12:36like what what is what is what why is
1:12:39that a problem and I was like well you
1:12:40know what do you think she's like I
1:12:43don't I don't understand because he's
1:12:44rich I was like no no because they're of
1:12:48different races and she she actually
1:12:50made this face like hmm and I said up
1:12:54until the 1960s
1:12:56was illegal to marry somebody of a
1:12:58different race she looked like I just
1:13:01told her that like you know that there
1:13:04was a secret chocolate fountain in a
1:13:05room she didn't know about like she's
1:13:07like you've got to be kidding me like
1:13:09yeah I loved it for her and I really
1:13:11admitted Lee I'm looking for my happy
1:13:13place in this sad story but this is such
1:13:15a real thing it's not a perfect thing
1:13:18their kids are still dicks but like it
1:13:20is just it's pretty fucking cool to me
1:13:21that she's never had a thought that
1:13:23anybody regardless of their race or
1:13:26sexual orientation or gender is they're
1:13:30all cool to her and that feels
1:13:33encouraging that feels and I wonder if
1:13:37you have similar stories like that where
1:13:38it's no longer a case where like you
1:13:40know when I was in first grade my black
1:13:42friend was skipper because there's one
1:13:44black friend at my school I had a black
1:13:45friend I was like Stephen Colbert
1:13:47hey there's my african-american you know
1:13:49and that's not the case anymore
1:13:51there's not one kid from Africa there's
1:13:53not like that one kid there's not even
1:13:54that one development developmentally
1:13:56disabled kid like he's just a whole
1:13:57bunch of different kids and like if they
1:13:59want kissed that's gonna be okay
1:14:00and that feels like a pretty big move
1:14:05over Cincinnati Ohio in 1976 to me I
1:14:09mean in my dad's elementary school there
1:14:13was a black kid whose name was John and
1:14:15there was a white kid whose name was
1:14:16John Oh God and so the teacher said well
1:14:20okay from now on you're Felix as in
1:14:24Felix the Cat Oh God and I mean this is
1:14:291927 and my dad ran into him I mean they
1:14:35were friend you know they were like
1:14:37black John white John no no it was
1:14:39feeling they were they were my dad and
1:14:42he were tight throughout school and then
1:14:44they hadn't seen each other and in 40
1:14:46years or something and they ran into
1:14:48each other on the street when they were
1:14:49both in their 70s why my dad said John
1:14:52and he said it's Felix Davis well and he
1:14:57had been Felix he'd been Felix his whole
1:14:59life until he finally just accepted it
1:15:01because that's what everybody called him
1:15:03no he didn't finally accept it I mean
1:15:05that from the time he was 7 years old he
1:15:07was Felix and he just I mean it
1:15:09never occurred to him to not be Felix
1:15:13but I mean he was my dad knew him and
1:15:16had known him as John but hit the the
1:15:19Felix identity he had taken over him at
1:15:22probably when he went to high school and
1:15:27he was just like you know let's just not
1:15:32I was about to say let's call a spade a
1:15:33spade but that white issue I don't think
1:15:49it's encouraging that your daughter
1:15:50doesn't can't comprehend it I think it
1:15:54is the truth of the matter yeah like my
1:15:56daughter has never and she's almost
1:16:00seven now she has never referred to
1:16:02someone by their color did you imagine
1:16:05that I mean not maybe maybe not people
1:16:08were twenty they here they go oh gosh no
1:16:10I mean just how you would talk about
1:16:15people sure and partly it is because we
1:16:19have because we're modern people also
1:16:22yeah I have never said oh it's the black
1:16:24guy over there or yeah yeah well you
1:16:27know the reason that they you know the
1:16:29reason that they're using chopsticks is
1:16:32because they're Asian well yeah I mean
1:16:34everybody I mean to just put up put a
1:16:35big cherry on it we were raised to
1:16:38believe that the easiest way to identify
1:16:39people was how they were different from
1:16:42the normal thing which is me my equals
1:16:44equals normal and and and my daughter
1:16:48does cannot classify people and her
1:16:54primary way is boy-girl but then within
1:16:57girls like she has two little friends
1:17:05and one of them is almost albino she's
1:17:09so light and one of them is from India
1:17:12and the two of them are very close
1:17:16friends and Marlo sees them as
1:17:20indistinguishable from one
1:17:22they're almost because they're both the
1:17:24same size they're both small mm-hmm and
1:17:28although you know to me they look like
1:17:31the black and white chess queens of a
1:17:35very small and interesting chess game -
1:17:39to my kid they are classed the same
1:17:44because they're both littler than her
1:17:48but so she has never even come to me and
1:17:51said what's weird about this situation
1:17:53like she doesn't when so much credit
1:17:56must also go to the teachers staff
1:17:58faculty but it but it is this is the
1:18:01thing where I don't I think like I don't
1:18:04find it encouraging I find it fait
1:18:06accompli like we are better and that can
1:18:10only produce they're they're better well
1:18:14no we are too but I mean but I still
1:18:17have I still have the memories and
1:18:20knowing my even my own behavior
1:18:21Cincinnati was very I'm going to use the
1:18:24code word conservative town is a very
1:18:27nice word for wet wet honest and said
1:18:30more than Larry Flynt but glam
1:18:33headquarters oh we had all kinds of
1:18:36things going on you cross the border
1:18:37over Nene Indiana and it's like whoo
1:18:39it's it ain't no Berkeley over there
1:18:42but yeah yeah I don't know it's it's
1:18:45it's strange though it's getting back to
1:18:47the Descartes and the fingernails I mean
1:18:48it is it's super interesting for like
1:18:50I'm not saying that they can't see that
1:18:51difference but I mean how different
1:18:53would that be from like deciding who
1:18:55your friends are based on like what
1:18:57color their hair is or like the length
1:18:58of their hair or like which backpack
1:19:00they have it's like it would seem so
1:19:02arbitrary well but that mean kids are
1:19:05assholes like you see they're such
1:19:06assholes yeah but you know my dad's
1:19:08teacher called the black kid Felix but
1:19:11my dad didn't did my dad had friends of
1:19:16all races my dad's friends the best of
1:19:17all the Japanese guys that's right you
1:19:19play basketball the Japanese and his
1:19:20best friend was black his whole life but
1:19:23my dad didn't the it would never have
1:19:27occurred to my dad to say about somebody
1:19:30to describe somebody without describing
1:19:33them by their primary characteristic
1:19:35which was their skin color
1:19:36race huh you know he would never have
1:19:38said like oh it's the tall guy over
1:19:40there it's like you mean which one well
1:19:44the one over there in the red shirt you
1:19:45know he would have been like it's a
1:19:46black guy well so that then then to you
1:19:51and I who grew up in her - you and me -
1:19:55you and me mm-hmm the object the object
1:19:58of the preposition to me who grew up in
1:20:01in that world like now when we're
1:20:05teaching our kids we don't talk like
1:20:07that
1:20:07and they don't that's just not how they
1:20:11order the universe so when they talk to
1:20:13their kids they're gonna figure out a
1:20:14new ordering that somehow register got
1:20:19by the color of his backpack yeah the
1:20:21incredible mistakes that you and I make
1:20:23every day when saying whatever terrible
1:20:28thing you know that that they're gonna
1:20:30roll their eyes at us at my terrible
1:20:32debt what I'm gonna say don't put the
1:20:34cart before the horse they're gonna say
1:20:35I'm never gonna say that to my child
1:20:37it's so racist I really want to create a
1:20:39new world for them
1:20:42[Music]
1:20:44Felix