Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

265: Simon Says Volume Five

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

1:00:00Apple APIs for a long time that certain

1:00:01points on one side are better than the

1:00:03ports on the other side that's been true

1:00:04for many laptops in Apple's history yeah

1:00:06it's always kind of annoying but we

1:00:07understand why it is the way it is and

1:00:09we accept it I don't think it's a source

1:00:11of ridicule all right I just feel like

1:00:14all I can imagine is all of us going

1:00:15haha those idiot PC P plate it's an Emmy

1:00:18we have talked about that as an inherent

1:00:19problem with using the same connector

1:00:21for all these things I think the I still

1:00:22think that the advantages are using the

1:00:23same connection for all them outweigh

1:00:25the disadvantages but you know as marker

1:00:27just that your laptop has a port as a

1:00:28whole that's exactly the same shape is

1:00:30the ones at Marcos and yet it is not

1:00:31capable of the things that Marcos Marcos

1:00:34okay it's both the same cables fit into

1:00:38both of them but if you plug in a thing

1:00:40that expects Thunderbolt endears it

1:00:41won't work and there's no indication for

1:00:43that physically speaking I don't even

1:00:45know if there's a little lightning bolt

1:00:46thingy next to them anymore no so I mean

1:00:49that's just that's just the nature

1:00:50wouldn't be next to yours so I you know

1:00:55I think the implicit assumption I'm also

1:00:58thinking of my own feelings about

1:01:00underlyings discussion is that I still I

1:01:02still believe I'm still hoping I guess

1:01:04that when Apple does you know make a

1:01:07bigger vision as a laptop line that one

1:01:12or more of the new laptops the

1:01:13introduced will have more ports than the

1:01:15thing that it's replacing and that's why

1:01:17I keep getting to like what do you think

1:01:18they'll add or whatever if if I'm wrong

1:01:20about that and if they introduced a

1:01:22whole new laptop line that's like the

1:01:24next generation after like this current

1:01:25crop of 2016 2017 like I've had time to

1:01:27process the the feedback from the market

1:01:30and you know someone and so forth and

1:01:31none of them have any more ports I will

1:01:35be extremely disappointed like I

1:01:37realized in myself like I've just been

1:01:38assuming basically since the Apple

1:01:39roundtable about the Mac when they

1:01:41talked about the Mac Pro from that point

1:01:43on I you know I read into what they said

1:01:46would imply hopes and dreams of saying

1:01:48yeah I know you're talking about the Mac

1:01:49Pro and the iMac Pro like I know that's

1:01:51what this is really about and about a

1:01:52rededication to the Mac but the few

1:01:54sentences they said about the laptops I

1:01:56latched on to really hard and said that

1:01:59means eventually you know after you know

1:02:00two year cycle whatever takes a long

1:02:02time like not not immediately but

1:02:03eventually when they do the next big

1:02:05laptop revision one or more of them will

1:02:07have more ports and I don't know what

1:02:09I'm going to do if that turns out not to

1:02:11be the case like my faith and

1:02:13I'm already a laptop hater I guess but

1:02:15my faith in Apple's laptops will be

1:02:17fundamentally shaken because so far it's

1:02:18still just like they made a wrong turn

1:02:20and things were already in the pipeline

1:02:22and they couldn't really do much about

1:02:24the revision for 2017 all they did was

1:02:27that the rubber gaskets and stuff and

1:02:28it's like hopefully they know it's wrong

1:02:30next time they do the big revision

1:02:32that'll be the time to make more

1:02:33different fundamental decisions but if

1:02:35the next ones come along and they're

1:02:36exactly the same set of just USBC only a

1:02:39MacBook one is still the MacBook one the

1:02:41the other one still just have two ports

1:02:42and you know and there's no changes and

1:02:45no max a4 no SD card no HDMI and nobody

1:02:48gets any not even an additional USB C

1:02:51port nothing I don't know I'm gonna be

1:02:53super disappointed

1:02:54I'll probably you know I probably can

1:02:56stall myself by hugging my new Mac Pro

1:02:57but but I you know but I don't know what

1:03:01you have you did you guys like have you

1:03:04internalized that as a thing you expect

1:03:05and so now you're set up to be

1:03:07disappointed by not being there or are

1:03:08you still like pessimistic and you'll be

1:03:10pleasantly surprised if they do anything

1:03:11that I will be stunned if there's any

1:03:14sort of and not really Maricopa but like

1:03:17if they add any sort of ports to any of

1:03:20these laptops I will be flabbergasted

1:03:22I'm not saying it's it's unreasonable

1:03:25but I do think it is a what did you say

1:03:28like egg on the face sort of admission

1:03:30that oh maybe we didn't get this exactly

1:03:32right if they had a USB C or a

1:03:34thunderbolt like it's not an admission

1:03:36of anything is just they added a more

1:03:37port even that will be something it'll

1:03:38say look we realize us PC is great but

1:03:41when you only get two of them one's

1:03:42taken with power it really limits things

1:03:43so now you got one more so you got three

1:03:44yeah I mean and let's be realistic here

1:03:47also like if you look at if you look at

1:03:49the side one of these things and you

1:03:49look at like the height of ports I think

1:03:53it's very unlikely that we will see the

1:03:55return of USB a or even MagSafe because

1:03:58I don't think they fit I think they're

1:03:59too tall I don't think they could

1:04:01reasonably fit those it would have to be

1:04:03a pneumatic safe yeah it had to be

1:04:05MagSafe three yeah right because I don't

1:04:07I can't see them doing that and I'm

1:04:10honestly I'm totally okay with USB C

1:04:13charging

1:04:13I wish the charger was nicer I wish it

1:04:15had things like the charging light and

1:04:17some kind of version of MagSafe would be

1:04:20nice but other than that actually like

1:04:24USB C charge because you can get

1:04:25third-party chargers that have like you

1:04:27know like

1:04:27like the wonderful anchor one that has

1:04:29the built-in USB charging also like the

1:04:31in you know it makes the charging

1:04:32situation much more flexible and then

1:04:34you couldn't you can travel a little bit

1:04:36lighter and stuff like that so I like

1:04:37that

1:04:38but if you look at what can actually fit

1:04:41in this new super thin case design not a

1:04:45lot can USBC you know you can fit more

1:04:49of them and maybe you know what Apple

1:04:51maybe you could put them a little

1:04:51further apart because they're really

1:04:54close to each other and it makes it a

1:04:56little bit annoying to use also the

1:04:58headphone jack should move back to the

1:05:00left side where it belongs because

1:05:03there's a reason why headphones were

1:05:05always on the left side of laptops

1:05:07before it's because when you have a

1:05:09headphone cable that only has a wire on

1:05:11one side historically that has been

1:05:14conventionally on the left ear cup so

1:05:16your headphone cable goes down the left

1:05:18of your cup down your left arm into the

1:05:19left side port of the laptop when it's

1:05:21on the right side you have to cross your

1:05:22headphone cable over your laptop which

1:05:24sucks so that's wrong anyway you can

1:05:26wrap it around the back oh oh by the way

1:05:28speaking of ports on different sides I

1:05:29do that's another thing I appreciate

1:05:30about USB power that you can connect the

1:05:33power to decide so depending on like

1:05:34where you are on the couch or wherever

1:05:36if you're in someplace that you can do

1:05:37it like that's why I think they should

1:05:39always keep that and I really don't

1:05:41never expect them to make MagSafe 3 but

1:05:43I've been musing on it lately yeah

1:05:45anyway so I think if we look at like

1:05:48what kind of ports we might

1:05:50realistically actually get I wouldn't

1:05:53expect USBA I wouldn't expect MagSafe SD

1:05:56cards are actually plausible that I

1:05:58think could fit if I'm not sure if they

1:06:00want to but again I think that would go

1:06:02a long way towards addressing a lot of

1:06:04people's complaints HDMI almost

1:06:07certainly won't fit they could do mini

1:06:09HDMI but they won't you know they're

1:06:12gonna rely on Thunderbolt USBC for that

1:06:14but ultimately I think the most

1:06:17realistic option is to either get no

1:06:20port changes at all which like John I

1:06:23would be very disappointed by or to get

1:06:26more USB C ports which I would be very

1:06:28happy with so we'll see ya more USB

1:06:32supports is the most likely I'm still

1:06:35rooting for SD I think back when we

1:06:36talked about this originally I said just

1:06:38add an SD card and they'll be fine but

1:06:40the more I think

1:06:40about the port being taken up by power

1:06:41and experiencing myself the more I think

1:06:43more or USBC would be good idea and by

1:06:45the way for our magazine three design

1:06:47again not that they're doing this but if

1:06:49you give up on the notion that the

1:06:50magnet is on the side of the computer

1:06:52you can do lots of interesting things

1:06:53imagine if MagSafe look like a little

1:06:54shovel and and it was a large surface

1:06:56area magnet sort of on the bottom like

1:06:59in an L shape like it clipped onto the

1:07:00corner and tucked underneath a little

1:07:02curve like there are things you could do

1:07:03to add much more magnet surface area

1:07:05while keeping it very thin like we don't

1:07:07have to think inside the box defined by

1:07:09MagSafe as it previously existed manic

1:07:11magnetically detachable charging cables

1:07:15for trip proof nests is I still think a

1:07:18good idea and an idea that could

1:07:19manifest in a way they will work with

1:07:21the thinnest possible laptops still so

1:07:24in the chat room expressly asked an

1:07:26interesting question they said which you

1:07:28prefer second USB see on the adorable or

1:07:31a headphone jack and and I presume the

1:07:33genesis of this is that on the opposite

1:07:35side of the laptop on the right hand

1:07:37side and mark oh you're right to say

1:07:38that that is bananas but on the right

1:07:40hand side the laptop of the of the

1:07:41adorable

1:07:42there is a headphone jack and I would

1:07:45absolutely without a shadow of a doubt

1:07:47trade in that headphone jack for another

1:07:49USB C port without question because

1:07:51you've you've got air pause that's right

1:07:53yeah I mean you know and all sorts of

1:07:55other bluetooth headphones and in yeah

1:07:57there are occasions that I have plugged

1:07:59in headphones to this laptop but they

1:08:01are extremely rare and I would get much

1:08:04more maybe not daily but much more

1:08:07frequent use out of a second USB C port

1:08:09then I would the headphone jack that's

1:08:11there today there's no reason to make

1:08:13that trade though we already did 20

1:08:15shows about complaining about there's no

1:08:17room for another USB port there is that

1:08:20phone it will be fine we are sponsored

1:08:24this week by Jam now create your free

1:08:26account today at Jam comm

1:08:28slash ATP to start securing your

1:08:30business today

1:08:32jammed now let's you help set up manage

1:08:35and protect your Apple devices on demand

1:08:37it's pretty easy to keep track of say

1:08:39your own devices your own Mac your own

1:08:42iPad or your own iPhone but what about

1:08:44the other Apple devices in your

1:08:45organization as a business grows it gets

1:08:48harder to manage everybody has iPads

1:08:50iPhones and Macs and this is especially

1:08:52true if employees are indifferent

1:08:54locations with jams now that the JAMF

1:08:57now you can check real-time inventory

1:09:00you can configure Wi-Fi and email

1:09:02settings deploy applications protect

1:09:04your sensitive company data and even

1:09:06lock or wipe a device from anywhere

1:09:09jammed now helps you manage and protect

1:09:11your devices so you can focus on your

1:09:14business instead and you don't need any

1:09:16IT experience or expertise to be able to

1:09:19use jams now it's super easy to use

1:09:21start securing your business today by

1:09:25setting up your first three devices for

1:09:27free and you can add more for just $2 a

1:09:29month per device create your free

1:09:31account today and see for yourself it's

1:09:32pretty great at Jam comm slash ATP

1:09:36that's JAMF comm slash ATP secure your

1:09:40business today with Jam for now thank

1:09:42you so much to camp now for sponsoring

1:09:44our show WTC is announced it is in San

1:09:52Jose again it is the 4th through the 8th

1:09:55of June which is phenomenally great

1:09:57because that's what the three of us

1:09:59guessed it would be and that's what we

1:10:01booked hotel tickets for a long time ago

1:10:03so that's great news it is going to be

1:10:07apparently about marzipan or whatever

1:10:10it's being called today if you believe

1:10:12what people are looking at on the

1:10:13invitation which i think is a exercise

1:10:15in futility because the invitation never

1:10:17use anything but also of interest on

1:10:21that Monday which is the fourth all

1:10:24three of your hosts will be there to do

1:10:25another episode in addition of ATP live

1:10:28which is part of a what are they calling

1:10:30it like a podcast fair or something like

1:10:32that festival festival that's what I was

1:10:33looking for thank you which means to

1:10:35live fought cast at all calm we so yeah

1:10:39so we're going to be doing a kind of a

1:10:41joint thing between us alt conflict like

1:10:46Marco said and relay they're going to be

1:10:48doing an episode of connected in

1:10:50addition to some other things that I

1:10:53genuinely don't know what's happening

1:10:54but I know enough to know that it's

1:10:55going to be an extravaganza so if you

1:10:58are interested in coming to see ATP live

1:11:01in San Jose on Monday June 4th you can

1:11:04get tickets at alt con Fissel alt cuffs

1:11:07website

1:11:07we'll put a link in the show notes they

1:11:10are five dollars a piece if they're

1:11:11still available I honestly haven't even

1:11:12looked that money goes to alt conf which

1:11:14is good because all conf is free so we

1:11:17don't see any of that money but I don't

1:11:18think that's a bad thing at all and

1:11:20additionally you can get tickets to the

1:11:21relay thing as well or to all con and

1:11:24it's worth noting that even if WDC lot

1:11:27if the if the lottery doesn't work out

1:11:29well for you in addition to alt con

1:11:31there's also layers that will be going

1:11:33on the same time run by friend of the

1:11:34show jesse char and a couple of other

1:11:37lovely women actually I think it's just

1:11:38Elaine and she but anyway they are

1:11:41awesome they are super super awesome and

1:11:44the the conference is super super

1:11:46awesome and the snacks at the conference

1:11:47are super super awesome so no matter how

1:11:49you slice it later layers is great all

1:11:51conf is great W DC is great plenty of

1:11:53options if you can find yourself in San

1:11:55Jose that week is that it well that was

1:11:58fast

1:11:59you covered it pretty well go team

1:12:01raised in chief yeah chief summarize our

1:12:03and cheap chief actually do my job for

1:12:04once you talk about the WWC graphics

1:12:07which you alluded to earlier I think

1:12:10some of the commentary about those are

1:12:12commentary tweets whatever about this

1:12:14have kind of combined to things that are

1:12:17not really related one is the artwork

1:12:20Apple puts on the email invitations to

1:12:23select press when they are gonna have an

1:12:25event come hear us talk about whatever

1:12:28we you know like iPhone announcement

1:12:30event or you know Mac update a bit press

1:12:32events right and traditionally they make

1:12:34a little graphic and usually sometimes a

1:12:35little phrase underneath it right and

1:12:38then there is what we're actually

1:12:39talking about here which is every year

1:12:41when they do WWDC there's some kind of

1:12:43graphical motif or theme it's used like

1:12:46in the banners that hang in the

1:12:48exhibition halls and the rooms where

1:12:50they have things that's used in all the

1:12:51websites and the materials and the

1:12:53emails and it started off pretty generic

1:12:56many many years ago but it has evolved

1:12:58so that now each WWC has kind of like a

1:13:02branding theme or flavor so for the

1:13:06press invitations

1:13:08sometimes those have been intentionally

1:13:11pointing to something they're gonna say

1:13:13like the one with a little rotating

1:13:15Apple with the like back to the Mac

1:13:17thing behind it where they were going to

1:13:18talk more about the Mac and guess what

1:13:20they talked more about them

1:13:21some of them are only explicable in

1:13:25hindsight where you can tell some of the

1:13:26graphic treatments on the invitation

1:13:28were the same ones they would use when

1:13:29they announced a particular product

1:13:30whether it's the iPhone or whatever but

1:13:33sometimes it's just a fun graphical

1:13:35theme that has to do with hey we have an

1:13:36app store and you make apps or it and

1:13:38absurd these little rounded rectangle

1:13:39things so we use lots of lot of rounded

1:13:41rectangles in our and our stuff but I

1:13:42would say that there is a fairly solid

1:13:46track record of some of the time the

1:13:48press invitations do in fact

1:13:50intentionally indicates something that

1:13:52they're going to talk about in a vague

1:13:53way WWC art on the other hand has a much

1:13:57worse track record of communicating

1:13:59anything about what's going to breathe

1:14:01Zenta to other than the fact that it's a

1:14:02developer conference where they tell you

1:14:03about developing crapple platforms as

1:14:05far as I can recall there has never been

1:14:07a WWDC website that hinted strongly at

1:14:11the specific nature of a specific thing

1:14:13they're going to announce probably

1:14:15mostly because at the time this artwork

1:14:17is commissioned they're not even

1:14:18entirely sure what's going to be

1:14:19presented at WWDC and things that you

1:14:21know are going into and out of the

1:14:23keynote and into and out of the sessions

1:14:24for a long time so I feel like this

1:14:29route trying to read the tea leaves in

1:14:31sort work it's probably about as useful

1:14:34as trying to read the tea leaves in last

1:14:36year's artwork which is all those top

1:14:37views of of people yeah a little bit

1:14:40which was like it's a particular artist

1:14:42who does that style of stuff and it was

1:14:44that that aesthetic theme was all over

1:14:46WWC yesteryear but it had nothing to do

1:14:49with anything that was presented it was

1:14:50just a cool fun marketing style that

1:14:53talked about you know people developers

1:14:55are people and they're doing developing

1:14:57things and it's fun and interesting

1:14:58forever

1:14:59all right this one looks super cool and

1:15:01it's got these cool 3d representations

1:15:03of like you know UI elements from iOS

1:15:06and the Mac it's because and it's got

1:15:09curly braces and other weird shapes it

1:15:13communicates like hey these are things

1:15:15you use when you're developing for our

1:15:16platforms and this is a conference about

1:15:17developing for our platforms it's really

1:15:19hard to read anything into it but people

1:15:21are so they so want to see something in

1:15:25it those things see how these are all 3d

1:15:27it's a showing that they're moving away

1:15:28from flat design because nothing is flat

1:15:30in this to get it man

1:15:31there you know and like it's really

1:15:35reaching and I have to admit when I saw

1:15:37this and I thought was nostalgia because

1:15:39one of I tweeted this one of the

1:15:41elements in this very cool looking like

1:15:43there's an animation that goes along

1:15:44with very cool looking 3d rendered

1:15:45things showing a bunch of controls one

1:15:48of the elements in the lower left corner

1:15:49are three translucent spheres with with

1:15:54symbols in them an X a minus and then

1:15:56two little arrow e things like a box

1:15:58with a slash through it and I I tweeted

1:16:02about it with a one-word tweet said

1:16:04memories dot a lot of people didn't know

1:16:08they responded and thought I was

1:16:10referring to things in like iOS 10 or

1:16:12something or you know or pre iOS 7 or

1:16:14whatever what I was actually referring

1:16:16to was the window control widgets what

1:16:19we used to call the stoplight widgets

1:16:21red for window clothes yellow for

1:16:23minimizing green for what used to be

1:16:24zoom and is now or the fullscreen arosa

1:16:26hell it does now they used to be

1:16:30rendered as if they were glossy spheres

1:16:32and when you brought your mouse near

1:16:35them or hovered over one of them you'd

1:16:37see these symbols appear in the spheres

1:16:38and they were glassy spheres just like

1:16:40these spheres all this is just viewing

1:16:42them from a different angle later in the

1:16:44life life of the Mac operating system

1:16:46they became flatter and eventually they

1:16:48just became like what they are now which

1:16:50is like you know flat colors of red

1:16:52yellow and where they're not they don't

1:16:53even look like their spheres at all

1:16:54right even though they still have the

1:16:56symbols in them but floating in this

1:16:58thing are not the flat window widgets of

1:17:00today's high sierra floating in this

1:17:01thing are the window widgets of you know

1:17:03cheetah puma and Panther Mac os10 I

1:17:07forgot about mr. Jaguar sorry Mike OS

1:17:10ten point zero one two and three I think

1:17:13is how long these things last before

1:17:14they start getting really flat and that

1:17:16I thought was a nice nostalgic nod or an

1:17:19indication that the Mac is considered

1:17:20legacy but it's a nice nod towards the

1:17:24past because most of the other controls

1:17:26that you see here are clearly elements

1:17:28from iOS or elements from applications

1:17:30that are popularized by iOS like the

1:17:32little dot dot when someone's typing in

1:17:33messages right I think it's the same

1:17:35graphic they use in in messages on the

1:17:37Mac but I associated with iOS just

1:17:39because that's where you know text

1:17:41messaging first came to the Apple

1:17:43platforms

1:17:45my take is that you should not read into

1:17:48these type of graphics I think this is

1:17:49an awesome graphic I love the aesthetic

1:17:51theme and I'm just enjoying it as cool

1:17:53branding for WWC yeah I agree with

1:17:57everything inter said so we'll all be

1:18:00there and I'm excited for it it's one of

1:18:02my favorite times a year and it's really

1:18:04really fun I don't really care at all

1:18:08about textures so I don't know which one

1:18:10of you added this to the show notes but

1:18:12do you want to take it away

1:18:13apparently magazines are a really hot

1:18:15business right now they're it's really a

1:18:17growth industry apples getting into the

1:18:18air you really messed that one up Marco

1:18:19mm we should explain what this thing is

1:18:23I hadn't heard of it before today

1:18:24surprised because really popular anyway

1:18:29Apple as an apple press release end or

1:18:32PR person would say Apple acquires small

1:18:34companies all the time you know it

1:18:36actually is really a high number every

1:18:37time they say like did you know the last

1:18:39year Apple acquired 35 companies or some

1:18:40some huge entry like really they you

1:18:43know it's mostly small like Apple

1:18:44doesn't want to buy them when they're

1:18:46attending dollar company they want to

1:18:47get them before that sometimes they buy

1:18:49companies just for the people sometimes

1:18:50for the technologies or patents rarely

1:18:53do they buy them for complete working

1:18:55businesses but that does happen to like

1:18:57beets they bought beets and continue to

1:18:59sell Beats headphones as Beats

1:19:00headphones right pickets maybe the one

1:19:02of the most recent full-fledged

1:19:04businesses they purchased so texture

1:19:05seems like one of the small ones it's

1:19:06not clear to me whether they bought it

1:19:07for the business or the people or the

1:19:08tech or anything like that but it what

1:19:10it is described as is Netflix for

1:19:13magazines where you play a flat fee and

1:19:14get access to a bunch of magazines in

1:19:16the same way you pay a flat fee every

1:19:17month for Netflix and you get access to

1:19:18a bunch of movies

1:19:20why does Apple need to buy this I'm not

1:19:24sure why they might want to buy it but

1:19:27Apple has in the past shown that they're

1:19:30interested in being some kind of a

1:19:34platform aid to periodicals we all

1:19:37remember newsstand Marco I'm sure most

1:19:38fondly mmm

1:19:40that was an attempt to do something like

1:19:42this newsstand did not work out so well

1:19:44newsstand is now gone but it signals

1:19:47apples interest in this texture strikes

1:19:50me as all right the approach with

1:19:52newsstand of making this weird app slash

1:19:54folder where a bunch of things go and

1:19:56putting weird limitations on them a

1:19:57giving

1:19:57you know of recurring structures like

1:19:59the whole newsstand thing didn't work

1:20:01out having individual applications for

1:20:02individual things but having them be

1:20:04newsstand savvy that that model didn't

1:20:05work for us let's try this model and

1:20:08this model seems a little bit more like

1:20:10Apple News where Apple itself could

1:20:12potentially make an application and

1:20:13within that application you see a bunch

1:20:16of magazines just like within Apple news

1:20:17you see a bunch of news and other

1:20:19content you know content providers can

1:20:21participate in Apple News not by

1:20:23launching their own application that is

1:20:24Apple News powered but rather by getting

1:20:26their news into the one and only Apple

1:20:28news application texture is an

1:20:31established business that works in a

1:20:32certain way so I'm not sure if Apple's

1:20:34gonna rebrand it or just put it out the

1:20:35way it is or just scrap texture entirely

1:20:37and take those people and tell them to

1:20:39make newsstand version 2 this time it'll

1:20:41be better but as Marco or maybe Casey

1:20:45pointed out it's great that they're kind

1:20:48of into that but I'm not sure magazines

1:20:51on computers or otherwise they're really

1:20:53where it's at in terms of a growth

1:20:56industry but I you know I I would give

1:20:59Apple full credit for recognizing the

1:21:02newsstand didn't work out Sun setting in

1:21:04a fairly graceful way you know as I

1:21:06think Marco said the best time to cancel

1:21:08something is when no one notices that

1:21:09you cancel it and many people don't

1:21:10realize newsstand is gone now because if

1:21:12you never really news it like isn't it

1:21:14thank God or if you remember what news

1:21:16thing was yeah it's gone and no one

1:21:18really kicked up a fuss about it

1:21:20so that was that was good and I think

1:21:22it's worth taking another on it I know I

1:21:23read magazines and I do have individual

1:21:25app you know I have like the edge

1:21:26magazine application like I read

1:21:30magazines on my iPads I don't I'm not

1:21:31totally offended by that idea I read

1:21:34e-books on my iPad too and so if Apple

1:21:36wants to make a really nice service

1:21:38application thingy for reading magazines

1:21:41sure give it a shot why shouldn't they

1:21:43be allowed to give that a try yeah no

1:21:45argument here it just this was not on my

1:21:48radar before and as soon as we cease

1:21:50talking about it it will not be on my

1:21:51radar yeah do either one of you read

1:21:53magazines at all on any iOS device no I

1:21:56don't read magazines at all on anything

1:21:57ever yeah no I mean I still recon driver

1:22:02on paper and I read edge on paper and

1:22:04also in iOS I think there iOS app I mean

1:22:07it's not great but it's not the bad old

1:22:08days of like the original Zinio for

1:22:10I know this is the new Zinio behind

1:22:12these I have no idea what the technology

1:22:13powers it is but it's not just a bunch

1:22:14of PDFs they throw under your screen

1:22:16although with today's retina they could

1:22:18probably do that it would probably be

1:22:20okay especially on the twelve point nine

1:22:21inch because it's a practically magazine

1:22:23size and what the brightness screen it

1:22:24would look great I'm mostly doing it for

1:22:26edge and card driver because I like the

1:22:28content but the presentation in Iowa

1:22:30isn't bad and it's nice like not to have

1:22:32to carry around you know if you're going

1:22:34on vacation you want to read through

1:22:35your last three issues of edge magazine

1:22:37to have them all on your iPad rather

1:22:38than three paper things yeah it's

1:22:40convenient so I'm I will probably

1:22:44download this and try it and see how

1:22:46good the app is and if there are any

1:22:47magazines that I care about in there I

1:22:48doubt I'll subscribe to it though cool

1:22:51I have nothing to say about this I know

1:22:54I just say I don't care and maybe I

1:22:56should care but I think Apple buy is

1:22:58leading manufacturer of fax machines

1:23:01yeah I mean here's the thing with

1:23:03magazines like we were making fun of

1:23:05them because magazines is the old world

1:23:06or whatever but websites most websites

1:23:08are not that different from magazines

1:23:09and once you have a magazine that

1:23:11publishes through an application it's

1:23:13like is this just like a closed version

1:23:14of the web and a closed version of a web

1:23:16browser maybe but I you know websites

1:23:20and magazines still seem slightly

1:23:22different like magazines have websites

1:23:24but I don't know maybe I'm just

1:23:27nostalgic for the old days of magazines

1:23:28and there's lots of legacy businesses

1:23:30that are tied to the magazine format

1:23:34that I'm glad to see allowed to live

1:23:37another decade or two through an effort

1:23:39like this alright so time for skc p m--

1:23:42at Wallin writes my mac pro does not

1:23:44have a Wi-Fi card

1:23:45wait this is a Mac Pro question I don't

1:23:47care bill Balinor writes I'm just

1:23:49kidding I'm kidding my Mac Pro does not

1:23:52have a Wi-Fi card my wife and son both

1:23:53of accounts in the Mac Pro and I was

1:23:54thinking of using migration assistant

1:23:55copy stuff from the old machine to the

1:23:57new can I connect them via ethernet for

1:23:59this purpose does or will it matter that

1:24:01the new machine will be running on High

1:24:02Sierra and the old machine is El Capitan

1:24:04I've looked for specific documentation

1:24:06on this online and haven't found a

1:24:07satisfyingly definitive answer no I

1:24:09don't think I have ever used migration

1:24:13assistant ever

1:24:14I'm not saying it's bad I'm not saying

1:24:15that I'm doing things the right way it's

1:24:17just I like to kind of start fresh each

1:24:19time I know that this is also a little

1:24:21bit different because you're talking

1:24:22about other people and they may not want

1:24:24to

1:24:24heart fresh even though you do but I I

1:24:27don't really have any good answers with

1:24:29regard to migration assistant have you

1:24:31guys to use that I thought both of you

1:24:33have I definitely have I'm a big

1:24:35proponent of migration system I think

1:24:38there are a couple parts this question

1:24:39starting at the very end I've looked for

1:24:41specific documentation haven't found

1:24:43anything I almost guarantee that there

1:24:45is satisfying definitive documentation

1:24:47related to this on Apple's website but

1:24:48yes sometimes it can be hard to find the

1:24:50beginning of the question go back to the

1:24:51beginning I can connect by all these

1:24:53there are things I don't have Wi-Fi does

1:24:56it matter I can tell you that you do not

1:24:59want to use my gray decision migration

1:25:01assistant over Wi-Fi if you can at all

1:25:03help it so the fact that your Mac Pro

1:25:05doesn't have a Wi-Fi card don't worry

1:25:06about it I would never recommend doing

1:25:08it

1:25:08it was worse when Wi-Fi was slower it's

1:25:11better that with now the Wi-Fi is faster

1:25:13but I have not had good luck with using

1:25:15migration assistant over Wi-Fi the good

1:25:17news is that most reasonably modern Macs

1:25:20can do migration assistant through

1:25:23almost any of their ports like I don't

1:25:24know if they can do it over the

1:25:25headphone jack yet but like the old iPod

1:25:29shuffle syncing over the headphones yeah

1:25:31I used to do it through firewire you can

1:25:34do it through Ethernet you can do it

1:25:36through Thunderbolt you can do all

1:25:38there's all sorts of ways that migration

1:25:40and system will work the bad news is

1:25:42figuring out how to get it to work with

1:25:44especially with the more obscure ports

1:25:46can be tricky so what I would recommend

1:25:49is finding going back to Apple's website

1:25:51and digging through this stuff and

1:25:52finding the documentation for your

1:25:54specific computer and it will usually

1:25:56tell you and by the way from your

1:25:58computer you can only a migrate to this

1:26:00set of computers through these

1:26:01interfaces like there are there is like

1:26:03sort of a matrix of what connected ins

1:26:04kind of use and how is known as the

1:26:06computer and you can unfortunately find

1:26:07yourself in a situation where you're

1:26:08trying to migrate from like a really old

1:26:11computer to a really new one when

1:26:13there's no great way to do it except for

1:26:15maybe Ethernet but then you need even an

1:26:16adapter or whatever but I have never as

1:26:19someone who keeps computers for a long

1:26:20time I've never kept one long enough

1:26:21that I was unable to run migration

1:26:23assistant so I was just using the

1:26:25fastest connection you can Ethernet is

1:26:27probably sufficient and it's probably

1:26:29the sort of the baseline so try to do

1:26:31that if you possibly can find the docs

1:26:34for it and just give it a try I think

1:26:36you will be mostly

1:26:38these were the results I always have

1:26:39been I find like that mobile migration

1:26:41assistance really does migrate my stuff

1:26:43and yes it does take a long time but the

1:26:45amount of time it takes when I do the

1:26:47math works out to be roughly a matter of

1:26:49data it has to transfer you know divided

1:26:52by the the transfer rate or whatever I

1:26:54have had almost similar look as that the

1:26:58only differences i would suggest are

1:27:00when you connect the old mac by a target

1:27:03disk mode it tends to be a significantly

1:27:06faster migration justin has an a pretty

1:27:09big problem that i think it's had

1:27:10basically forever in that it is terrible

1:27:13at estimating how much time you have

1:27:15left and it will frequently get into a

1:27:17state where it appears as though it's

1:27:19making no progress at all and it could

1:27:21stay there for hours or even days and

1:27:25that's very frustrating it's very hard

1:27:27to tell often what it's doing whether it

1:27:29is still going to go how long it's still

1:27:31going to go for that's why I said do the

1:27:33math like if you know you have you know

1:27:35a one terabyte hard drive is mostly full

1:27:37and you know your connection is one

1:27:38gigabit like do the division figure out

1:27:40how long you think it's gonna take and

1:27:41use that as you're outside you know like

1:27:43to get an idea of how long you think

1:27:45it's gonna take if it takes 10 times

1:27:46that thing something is probably gone

1:27:48wrong but it don't you know don't

1:27:50believe the progress bar because it

1:27:51doesn't know well anyway I I have had

1:27:54significantly better luck with doing it

1:27:57via target disc mode on the on the

1:28:00sending machine rather than like having

1:28:02both machines run the migration

1:28:03assistant app this would probably also

1:28:06if there's any problems with the old one

1:28:08being El Capitan target is mode would

1:28:11probably avoid those problems a little

1:28:12bit more likely or more easily than then

1:28:15running the migrate just an app on both

1:28:17sides but also yeah it's just I've found

1:28:20the disk method to be way faster and way

1:28:23more reliable and I have never had it

1:28:25reach one of those states where it seems

1:28:27like it's gonna just take forever

1:28:28whereas over Wi-Fi and even Gigabit

1:28:32Ethernet I've had that happen so if I do

1:28:34in target this mode you have most of the

1:28:38options that John suggested on the old

1:28:40Mac Pro you probably see the Mac Pro's

1:28:44that had Wi-Fi are optional would be

1:28:452006 to 2008 I believe it was standard

1:28:48after that so it's pretty old

1:28:50it will definitely predate all

1:28:52because thunderbolt came after the mac

1:28:53pro so your best port is probably

1:28:56firewire 800 assuming you have well you

1:28:59definitely have that assuming it still

1:29:00works then I would suggest you know if

1:29:03you have any problems trying to do this

1:29:05over Ethernet

1:29:05I would suggest assuming the new machine

1:29:08has Thunderbolt

1:29:10go to the Apple store get a thunderbolt

1:29:12- well let's see you're gonna need two

1:29:15dongles all right now if I were 800 that

1:29:17is what I've got on the iMac right now

1:29:18isn't it suggest if you like target us

1:29:20moment he doesn't go firewire 800 to USB

1:29:223 then our mold or does it hat do you

1:29:24have to adapt 2 to 3 and then 2 to 800 I

1:29:27only have one adapter in the back of my

1:29:295k iMac

1:29:31it's like firewire 800 into this adapter

1:29:35and this adapter into the back of the

1:29:36iMac but I confess I do not recall what

1:29:38exactly it's going into the back of yet

1:29:40so you know it so assuming that your he

1:29:43doesn't actually say what he's going to

1:29:44write no ok so assuming let's say that

1:29:49it's a current generation machine that

1:29:51only has Thunderbolt 3 ports you might

1:29:54need two dongles to go once from 800 to

1:29:57Thunderbolt 2 and then once again from

1:30:00Thunderbolt 2 to 300 3 so that might be

1:30:02like $80 worth of don lows because

1:30:05Thunderbolt ones like 50 bucks

1:30:10practically speaking the reason I find

1:30:13myself using Ethernet is because I'm

1:30:14doing two desktops in the far away from

1:30:15each other and it's kind of a pain to

1:30:17like yeah disconnected that top and lug

1:30:19it over and put it close enough so your

1:30:20little firewire or Thunderbolt or USBC

1:30:24cable can connect to the right ports

1:30:25just then you're like look you know

1:30:27Ethernet is easier even if your home

1:30:29isn't wire everything in it so just get

1:30:31on your feet of Ethernet cable and plug

1:30:33it in and snake it over and leave it

1:30:34there for a day for you to do the

1:30:36transfers that of course encourage you

1:30:37to wire your house or Ethernet like a

1:30:39civilized person yeah well I mean it to

1:30:41me if they have a Mac Pro that doesn't

1:30:43have Wi-Fi they probably have this

1:30:44covered anyway so yeah that I agree try

1:30:48Ethernet first and only go by the $80

1:30:52worth of dongles and cables if for some

1:30:53reason you can't always sales and backup

1:30:56before you do anything

1:30:57backup make a bunch of backups take the

1:30:59backups disconnect them from all your

1:31:01computers put it you know put it

1:31:02someplace else and then

1:31:04have fun screwing through computers

1:31:05worst case scenario you screw everything

1:31:06up you erase everything you restore from

1:31:08backup and then you're back to your

1:31:09initial stage again also wait if you can

1:31:12back up to like a USB 3 hard drive your

1:31:15old my protists must be 3 migration but

1:31:18yeah you could just then plug that into

1:31:19the new computer and just do it that way

1:31:23all right

1:31:24Bill Balinor writes is it ok for

1:31:27developers to force flight interactions

1:31:29on their users such as labeling the ok

1:31:31button and a prompt yes please or the

1:31:33dismiss button in a confirmation dialog

1:31:35Thanks these things make me cranky

1:31:37you're wrong

1:31:39this is absolutely acceptable and I like

1:31:41it Oh God know what's right ok so ok

1:31:44there's if done in a non-intrusive non

1:31:50suggestive not putting words in my mouth

1:31:52kind of way it can be fine unfortunately

1:31:56that's not what happens in practice in

1:31:57practice you have things like no I don't

1:32:01want to subscribe to the newsletter and

1:32:02get all these special deals because I'm

1:32:03cheap like or like somebody that like

1:32:05they make you so often the words they

1:32:09use are passive-aggressively condemning

1:32:12yourself for making a choice that does

1:32:15not benefit the developer's business

1:32:17interests and it's really obnoxious

1:32:19oftentimes other than that it just you

1:32:22know it tries to sound human and hip and

1:32:25cool but it's from like a big

1:32:27corporation and we know that's fake and

1:32:29it comes off as just insincere fakery

1:32:32trying to appeal to be more human from a

1:32:34company that is anything but so it's

1:32:37very it's very hard and very rare to get

1:32:40this kind of thing right in a way that

1:32:42sounds both sincere and non offensive

1:32:46III think you're reading too much into

1:32:48this or maybe I'm not reading enough

1:32:49into it to me like having a having a

1:32:52dismissed button that says things I

1:32:54don't have a problem with that having a

1:32:55dismiss button dismissed button that

1:32:57says no I'm too cheap or even if it's

1:32:59passive-aggressively saying no I'm too

1:33:01cheap and not using those literal words

1:33:02that yes I agree with you that's total

1:33:05garbage but something as simple as yes

1:33:07please or thanks or no thank you like I

1:33:09don't have a problem with that at all

1:33:10you I think you would have a problem

1:33:12with the thanks because thanks is

1:33:13putting words in your mouth like you

1:33:15just want the box to go away so there's

1:33:16there's two aspects of problem one is

1:33:17the giving your you know press thing

1:33:20personality and putting words into the

1:33:22mouth of the user because what if

1:33:22they're annoyed at your application

1:33:23right now and are forced to hit a button

1:33:25that says thanks and they don't want to

1:33:26thank your application at all because

1:33:27they're frustrated with your application

1:33:28the thanks button makes them hate your

1:33:30application even more because you're

1:33:31forcing them to pretend they're saying

1:33:32thanks right but the second reason

1:33:34independent of all this stuff is people

1:33:37are accustomed to the dialog box is

1:33:38alerted in a certain way yes no okay

1:33:40cancel like there are interface

1:33:41standards that they're accustomed to and

1:33:43if your application deviates from those

1:33:44standards in any way there should be a

1:33:47reason for it maybe your carrot weather

1:33:49and you have a personality type thing

1:33:51and that's part of the selling point of

1:33:52your application fine but if your

1:33:53application is selling point it's not

1:33:55like there's a cost to defying

1:33:58expectations it causes people to pause

1:34:00and have to look at it and think about

1:34:01what the hit-and and like read it causes

1:34:04them to have to read where it's no one

1:34:05reads yes no or okay cancel if they see

1:34:06them a million times they just you know

1:34:08it becomes like a visual macro you just

1:34:10like oh I recognize that I don't know

1:34:11which thing I want to hit or even just a

1:34:14single button dismiss thing in iOS where

1:34:16the button is always labeled is okay and

1:34:18now suddenly that button has different

1:34:20text on it you're forced to read it you

1:34:22find out it says thanks you don't feel

1:34:23like thanking anybody and now you're

1:34:25annoyed so I would I would in general

1:34:28say there is no 100% safe way to inject

1:34:32personality into labels like that there

1:34:34are a lot of downsides and the only

1:34:36potential upsides are if your

1:34:37applications value proposition is based

1:34:41on its personality and whimsy which can

1:34:44be done but it's much trickier than you

1:34:46think it also be very careful when

1:34:50you're writing dialog text if you're a

1:34:51developer or if you're Apple mm-hmm

1:34:53that attributes malice or actions to the

1:34:56user or if they're in tributes its

1:34:58intent or actions to the user that may

1:35:02or may not be the case one of the most

1:35:04infuriating pieces of text and all of

1:35:06Mac OS is the dialog that comes up after

1:35:09it has a kernel panic and shuts down and

1:35:11reboots that says you shut down your

1:35:15computer because of a problem and a lot

1:35:17of times no you shut down my computer

1:35:20because of your problem it doesn't say

1:35:23that

1:35:24totally that it says your computer shut

1:35:27down doodles you shut down your computer

1:35:30yeah I agree with John that is not how I

1:35:33remember this are you sure I am Not sure

1:35:35I would check because ever I don't see

1:35:38it often but every time I see it I'm

1:35:41like oh I'm on fire you shut down my

1:35:43computer I didn't shut down my computer

1:35:45so so here's what the kernel panic you

1:35:48know the overlay the overlay that comes

1:35:49on in five languages when you get a

1:35:50kernel panic yeah it's not that it's

1:35:52it's the dialogue that shows up on the

1:35:53first boot after right okay but so

1:35:55anyway the overlay says your computer

1:35:58restarted because of a problems that may

1:36:00be what I'm remembering for that wording

1:36:01all right now the after your computer

1:36:03restarts marker was right I'm looking at

1:36:05this thing in Apple's website it says

1:36:07you shut down your computer because of a

1:36:09problem it's really it sets me on fire

1:36:12if I ever system run apple's website up

1:36:14we will put it in the show notes i'm

1:36:15assuming this is the current dialog but

1:36:17it's a Apple support document looks like

1:36:19it might be an old theme but yeah that's

1:36:21that's definitely at the current wording

1:36:22yeah maybe I was reading that as your

1:36:24because you know the the kernel panic

1:36:26one does say you're but the dialog

1:36:28versus you shut it doesn't even make

1:36:30sense

1:36:30it how would you shut down the computer

1:36:33like spontaneously because of a problem

1:36:35like is it just like all of a sudden you

1:36:37saw a problem and you reach for the plug

1:36:39in the wall and yanked it out like how

1:36:41is that even the thing that you could do

1:36:43because if you if you found a problem

1:36:45and you selected shut down you would

1:36:46never see this dialog box you know it's

1:36:48kind of like putting words in my mouth

1:36:49and it's like putting actions in my

1:36:51mouth it's like no I didn't do this you

1:36:53know you did this you know it like and

1:36:56it's like you know so when you're you

1:36:58know when you see an app that's like you

1:36:59know forcing you to say thanks or no I

1:37:03don't want to see your great deals

1:37:05I don't like great deals like that that

1:37:09is it seems like it might be cute or

1:37:12helpful or something and trust me it's

1:37:14not at all like it you have to be so

1:37:17careful with that stuff that you know

1:37:19and there is a there is an additional

1:37:20dollar by the way that says your

1:37:22computer was restarted because of a

1:37:24problem and then that one it says the

1:37:25you know ignore more info and move to

1:37:30trash for like an application they

1:37:32crashed like we see that one when an app

1:37:34crashes so there is one that is more

1:37:37you know let's blame me but the fact

1:37:39that there exists any dialog says you

1:37:41shut down your computer because of a

1:37:42problem but it's the dialogue that's

1:37:44asking whether you want to restore all

1:37:46the applications that were open so your

1:37:48choices are please reopen everything

1:37:49like it was before it canceled I'm sorry

1:37:53what reopen everything please reopen

1:37:55everything yeah I'm not a dialog box I

1:37:57don't have to put that like the button

1:37:58is not saying please the button says

1:38:01open and the cancel button says no

1:38:02thanks comma cancel oh I'm sorry it

1:38:04doesn't say no thanks comma cancel it

1:38:05says cancel because that's what cancel

1:38:06button say on them I'm not a button on

1:38:09person um yeah that's that's what it's

1:38:12asking you and so again if it's asking

1:38:14you that it means the entire thing

1:38:17abruptly stopped functioning and it

1:38:19realizes that abruptly stopped

1:38:20functioning because it didn't do all

1:38:21like the nice shutdown clean up stuff so

1:38:23the next time it starts up it says I

1:38:24don't see the nice shutdown clean up

1:38:25stuff which means things ended abruptly

1:38:27last time and I honestly don't think

1:38:30there's any user action that you could

1:38:32take other than if it knew somehow

1:38:34because of cameras that you had yank the

1:38:36cord out or flick the power switch the

1:38:38hard yourself even if it sees you do it

1:38:41it still shouldn't say that it's just

1:38:44it's just setting you on fire

1:38:45unnecessarily and how would it know it

1:38:47was because of a problem maybe you shut

1:38:49down your computer because you couldn't

1:38:51figure out any other way like you know

1:38:52you're you're in an experienced computer

1:38:55user and the only way you know how to

1:38:56turn it off is to hold down the power

1:38:57button for five seconds

1:38:59maybe you shut your computer as a

1:39:00statement yeah because of a problem

1:39:03wasn't a problem with your computer was

1:39:04just like a problem in the world I think

1:39:08you might be reading too much into this

1:39:10I think what the way I've always read

1:39:11this and why I haven't been perturbed by

1:39:14it is because the computer well I guess

1:39:17I can turn itself off but in this

1:39:19scenario of a kernel panic it doesn't

1:39:20turn itself off it is you that is

1:39:22physically turning the computer off and

1:39:23restarting it not always no default

1:39:27every boot itself doesn't it doesn't

1:39:28reboot it I didn't think it did I think

1:39:30it does now I think that's been the case

1:39:32for the last few years

1:39:33oh no you're right you know press a key

1:39:34you're wait a few seconds to continue

1:39:35starting oh no I guess you're right I

1:39:37guess you're right all I know is you

1:39:38guys are clearly from the Northeast or

1:39:41have lived there too long because you're

1:39:42employed assholes moving on before you

1:39:47move on like oh yeah and I want to

1:39:48iterate it's not it's not about

1:39:49politeness it's about the

1:39:50there are conventions for the user

1:39:52interface and anything that deviates the

1:39:53convention it's like whatever bill maybe

1:39:55things work like anything that deviates

1:39:57from the convention requires thinking

1:39:59and processing time and it's it's

1:40:01cognitive load for no benefit unless

1:40:04there is actual benefit of the

1:40:05personality application otherwise every

1:40:07time we look at dialogue we'd have to

1:40:09parse each person's you know politeness

1:40:12and phrasing and preambles stuff when we

1:40:14just want okay cancel or you know

1:40:16there's some standard buttons that say

1:40:17standard things that fit in a standard

1:40:18amount of space and we don't want to

1:40:20have to read them I actually do

1:40:21completely agree with you on that

1:40:22Chadd supports key rights when it comes

1:40:24to video games how much of a

1:40:26completionist eve each of you consider

1:40:27yourselves to be how much does it depend

1:40:29on the type of game scope of the game

1:40:30and your level of interest in it I will

1:40:32start by saying I am not at all a

1:40:34completionist and obviously I am I think

1:40:37mark when I fight over who is the least

1:40:38video game II person of the three of us

1:40:41but but I I do play video games from

1:40:44time to time as I think we mentioned

1:40:45last week the week before I've been

1:40:47getting back into breath of the wild but

1:40:49there whenever it is I beat Ganon at the

1:40:52end of breath of the wild if I don't

1:40:53have all 120 whatever it is shrines and

1:40:56if I don't have all 80 gazillion Quora

1:40:58Corki rock or whatever they're called

1:41:00seeds I am NOT gonna care I will be

1:41:02putting that game down and probably

1:41:03never playing it again and that's just

1:41:05me Marco since you are all so useless

1:41:07like me how do you treat this kind of in

1:41:10between you and a normal person I will

1:41:14try to be fairly complete as I'm playing

1:41:17but then I will usually reach a point at

1:41:19which my interest just Falls you know

1:41:22for a game that that can be quote beaten

1:41:25or that has like a main storyline that

1:41:26can be completed I do really want to

1:41:28compete that main storyline but like you

1:41:30I you know once I and on my way there I

1:41:33might be you know collecting as much as

1:41:36I possibly can like true like like like

1:41:38when playing mario odyssey i

1:41:40I really tried to get as many of the

1:41:43moons as possible like yeah you know as

1:41:45I'm going through each world

1:41:46I don't just fly away as soon as I can

1:41:48but then after you complete the main

1:41:51storyline you can go back and get a

1:41:52whole bunch more and I started doing

1:41:54that and I just haven't really continued

1:41:55yet and and I I intend to go back and

1:41:58play it I don't know when I will exactly

1:42:01cuz now I'm up I'm playing other games

1:42:03I don't know when I actually will but I

1:42:05do intend to still go back and do that I

1:42:07don't stop because I like decide I'm

1:42:12done with this game forever it just kind

1:42:14of happens like like stardew valley I

1:42:16plates already Valley very heavily for a

1:42:18long time and I intend to go back to it

1:42:22but the last time I played it was

1:42:23probably three months ago you know and I

1:42:25just haven't gone back to it yet but I

1:42:27do intend to I haven't had a kid yet I

1:42:29want to see you how that works so like

1:42:30you know I you know there's more I want

1:42:32to do in that game but like once I reach

1:42:34a certain point where I feel like I've

1:42:36done mostly everything there is to do I

1:42:39find it hard to motivate myself to go

1:42:41back and get like the last 10% you did

1:42:45have an actual kid what you mean is a

1:42:46pixelated kid yes all right just just to

1:42:50make that clear like I had a kid yet in

1:42:53stardew valley the game I was talking

1:42:54about during that sentence I just named

1:42:57the context freely where's Adam he's

1:42:59upstairs asleep so this this question

1:43:03doesn't really define what completionist

1:43:05means but I'm kind of with Marco and

1:43:07that like there's there's two strains oh

1:43:09I like Marco if I'm playing a narrative

1:43:12game that is trying to tell me a story

1:43:13and if I like the game well enough like

1:43:17you know that like I'm having fun

1:43:19playing it I do want to see how that

1:43:21story turns out but the modern practice

1:43:25of video games of basically said

1:43:27providing a tremendous amount of things

1:43:31to do outside the main story means that

1:43:34for me to actually 100% clear game by

1:43:37getting all the things that you can get

1:43:39and doing all the things that you can do

1:43:40has actually become a lot harder over

1:43:42the years both in terms of time

1:43:43investment and skill it used to be that

1:43:46if you finish a story then there'd be a

1:43:47couple of ancillary things to do but

1:43:48Mario Odyssey is like this story is like

1:43:50one-eighth of the game and then like if

1:43:52you really wanted to complete it in

1:43:54terms of hours spent and effort required

1:43:55the real game begins after you finish

1:43:58the story mode so I did finish the story

1:44:00mode of Mariotti

1:44:01and I did enjoy it and I do like the

1:44:03fact that there's a lot more after that

1:44:04and then you can do it kind of in any

1:44:05order that you want but I don't think I

1:44:07will 100% clear Mario does he ever

1:44:10contrast that with mario sunshine which

1:44:12was not as good at Mario game but any

1:44:14stretch of the imagination is Odyssey

1:44:15and yet

1:44:16under percent cleared sunshine because

1:44:18the amount of stuff that you had to do

1:44:20beyond the main story in sunshine seems

1:44:22so much more tractable to me and because

1:44:25the things they had you doing we're like

1:44:26one annoying collection quest and a

1:44:29bunch of levels that were hard but of

1:44:31the variety that they'd already had that

1:44:33I really enjoyed and so it seemed like a

1:44:35thing that I could do and lo and behold

1:44:36I did do it

1:44:38similarly with Zelda games uh you know I

1:44:42will always finish the story enemies

1:44:43Elda game i love zelda games 100%

1:44:45cleared a couple of Zelda's but not all

1:44:47of them because some yeah especially as

1:44:49time goes on when I start adding even

1:44:51more and more collect it was like I'm

1:44:52never gonna get all the coal Rock seeds

1:44:53and in breath of the wild I won't I just

1:44:56it's never gonna happen right but I

1:44:57probably will do eventually all the

1:44:59shrines and that's kind of and that's

1:45:01that's a game that I love it's not a

1:45:03game that I love I'll do the story and I

1:45:05feel like it done with it what if the

1:45:06game has no story the game has no story

1:45:08I just play it when it's fun and it

1:45:09stops being fun I'll stop playing it

1:45:10like I I feel like I will actually

1:45:12continue to play a game after it stops

1:45:14being fun to her I'm really close to the

1:45:15end of a narrative story just because I

1:45:17want to see how it ends that's kind of

1:45:18true like movies and books too we

1:45:19sometimes you're like well I'm invested

1:45:22and I know there's only three chapters

1:45:24left and even those books kind of

1:45:25knowing me I still want to see how it

1:45:27ends and so you'll power your way

1:45:28through so that's that's kind of my take

1:45:29on completion ISM anybody games thanks

1:45:32to our sponsors this week aftershocks

1:45:34Backblaze and jammed now and we'll talk

1:45:36to you next week now the show is over

1:45:42they didn't even mean to begin as it was

1:45:45accidental oh it was accidental

1:45:51Johnny research Marco and Casey wouldn't

1:45:54let him cuz it was accidentally was

1:45:59accidental and you can find the show

1:46:02notes at ADP FM and if you're into

1:46:07Twitter you can follow them

1:46:11CAS URL is s so that's Casey less ma RC

1:46:17o AR m auntie Marco Arment SI r AC

1:46:25Syracuse

1:46:39Casey you're back at work now yeah tell

1:46:42us about that so you're you're full-time

1:46:44back now brightly no that's normal

1:46:46no no no no I'm spending the month of

1:46:50March easing my way in so as we record

1:46:53this last week I did a sum total of one

1:46:56day of work and I did two half days

1:46:59which basically means I went in when

1:47:00Declan was a preschool and then this

1:47:03week I did full-day Tuesday but only

1:47:07half of it at work I did the rest from

1:47:09home so you can guess where this is

1:47:11going I went to work when Declan was a

1:47:13preschool then I came home and was here

1:47:14working on my iMac for the remainder of

1:47:17the day and then tomorrow I am doing

1:47:21sort of kind of the same we have an

1:47:23appointment to get Mikayla's passport

1:47:25for some events that are happening in a

1:47:27couple of months that I believe I'll be

1:47:29seeing both of you at so we need to get

1:47:31that squared away but this week I'm

1:47:34doing two days next week I'm doing three

1:47:35whole days and I think the week after

1:47:37that I'm actually ramped up to full-time

1:47:39now I might be doing some of that from

1:47:40home here and there which is not what I

1:47:42usually did I usually pretty much only

1:47:44worked in the office but it's a week

1:47:47after next that I will be a real real

1:47:50adult worker again and it's going fine

1:47:53it's a pretty understanding job letting

1:47:55you ease back into it I've never even

1:47:57heard of a company doing that this is

1:47:58the second time yeah like the last time

1:48:00I took less time easing my way into it

1:48:03and I also didn't take an unpaid leave

1:48:04but they were fairly cool about it both

1:48:07both the last job and this job so that's

1:48:09good

1:48:10that's pretty cool yeah that's I don't

1:48:13think I've ever had a job that would

1:48:14give me that usually and most of my jobs

1:48:17I had trouble of taking vacation days

1:48:19let alone like doing this yeah I mean

1:48:22and to be fair I didn't as much asked is

1:48:24said this is what I was planning to do

1:48:26and waited for somebody to say no and

1:48:28nobody said no and that that's been nice

1:48:31and I mean the place I work it's it's

1:48:33pretty no I was gonna say chill but I

1:48:35sound like a tool I don't know it's very

1:48:38relaxed and and it's I think in part

1:48:41because it's not consulting like most of

1:48:43the last few jobs I've had

1:48:45there's a lot less urgency and it's kind

1:48:48of okay if I'm gone that being said you

1:48:51know my I'm easing back in terms of

1:48:53hours worked I am not easing back in

1:48:55terms of stress level and need for me to

1:48:58be paying attention to things again the

1:49:02staff that I work with is excellent but

1:49:04at least on the iOS side but is very

1:49:07young and that's not a bad thing at all

1:49:09but that means that they've kind of been

1:49:12queuing up a whole band a whole bunch of

1:49:14questions to ask and and how do I do

1:49:16this what should we do here what are we

1:49:18gonna do about this other thing and and

1:49:21so I have been in high demand in the

1:49:24little bit of time I've been working

1:49:25which is a good problem the elementary

1:49:27school students what the hell is very

1:49:28young man when you're one is one is she

1:49:32started as an intern and is still in

1:49:34school in his part-time so she is what

1:49:36major version of pearl were they born

1:49:38during it so are you at the stage now or

1:49:43anyone in their twenties counts is very

1:49:44young getting there I mean my birthday

1:49:47Saturday for goodness sakes I'm turning

1:49:49I'm getting old John gettin old hey I'll

1:49:51be that old in a couple more months so

1:49:53the 29 year olds at work are very young

1:49:56no no one of the intern just turned 21

1:49:59at the end of last year she she was born

1:50:01in 96 I guess which is bananas oh my god

1:50:05she's younger than Weezer

1:50:06yeah so so yeah so the the intern who is

1:50:12now part-time was born in 96 and we just

1:50:14hired a guy who I don't know how old he

1:50:18is but I would guess 25 or less so and

1:50:22that's that's the whole staff as me and

1:50:24in these - well the whole i/os staff

1:50:26that is it so it's me in these other two

1:50:28so and they're great they really are

1:50:32great and I'm really really lucky to

1:50:34have them as my co-workers but they're

1:50:36they're young and that's not a bad thing

1:50:37it's just you know is the there are

1:50:40things that you only get from being in

1:50:42the trenches in any sort of code base B

1:50:45it iOS or otherwise for a long time and

1:50:47so I am the old man in every measurable

1:50:50way and and that's just my life I need

1:50:53to adjust you so here's a question do

1:50:55you have anybody yet who is either so

1:50:58young

1:50:58or just so new to iOS programming that

1:51:02they have no objective-c experience that

1:51:05the only has 50 experience I'm trying to

1:51:07think if the if the part-time person did

1:51:11I think she had done some Objective C in

1:51:14the past if I'm not mistaken but it was

1:51:15a toss-up cuz I almost wonder like that

1:51:17might make things easier right like if

1:51:19you had if you if you have like if you

1:51:20try to maintain an all Swift code base

1:51:22or mostly Swift code base and you have

1:51:24somebody who doesn't have any mental

1:51:27baggage of Objective C that actually

1:51:29might be a good thing right

1:51:30I don't know I I totally understand

1:51:33where you're coming from and I'm not at

1:51:35all saying you're wrong I really don't

1:51:37know because it's one of those things

1:51:38like do you really need to understand

1:51:42what a pointer is to be able to write

1:51:44code today and I know you're both

1:51:45probably gonna jump all over me but like

1:51:47if you think about it on a surface level

1:51:49in a lot of cases you don't really need

1:51:52to know what a pointer is now I I

1:51:54strongly believe that you do so that's

1:51:57all I'm like um I'm presenting an

1:51:58argument I don't actually believe in but

1:52:00you could make an argument that you know

1:52:02you don't totally need a pointer to

1:52:04understand what what the concept of a

1:52:06pointer is in order to be able to write

1:52:07Swift yeah I would totally argue that

1:52:10actually yeah and and I still think it's

1:52:12important to understand what a pointer

1:52:14is it's important to understand these

1:52:16sorts of things and I think to some

1:52:18degree you get a lot more of that from

1:52:20objective-c and not only because you

1:52:21have stupid asterisks everywhere but

1:52:24what I'm what a meandering toward is I

1:52:26think having an understanding of what

1:52:29makes Objective C Objective C helps you

1:52:31understand what makes cocoa and cocoa

1:52:33touch cocoa into cocoa touch does that

1:52:36make any sense at all yeah I can see

1:52:38that although I I would also suggest

1:52:40that like like I mean in my time working

1:52:43around other programmers I was fortunate

1:52:46enough that to usually work around

1:52:48really smart people but not a hundred

1:52:51percent of the time and and I was always

1:52:53sometimes really surprised how little

1:52:57somebody could know about programming

1:52:59and be working full-time as a programmer

1:53:01oh yeah and I think and I'm not saying

1:53:03this till I say like oh they're so dumb

1:53:05like that just there are a lot of

1:53:08programming jobs out there

1:53:11that are pretty forgiving of having a

1:53:13very shallow understanding of it or

1:53:15pretty forgiving of bad coding or

1:53:17mistakes or a leaking memory or things

1:53:19like that Len and iOS is a huge sample

1:53:21that like you know the when the App

1:53:22Store was this huge explosion gold rush

1:53:25thing back you know ten years ago and

1:53:28you know in the interviewing year since

1:53:29like a lot of people learned objective-c

1:53:33just enough to get an app out there and

1:53:36just like kind of stumbling through and

1:53:38I mean heck that was basically me when I

1:53:40first started to and I mean I had to see

1:53:42background so I knew I knew that kind of

1:53:43stuff but like there was a lot of people

1:53:46who start knowing a lot less and can get

1:53:48an app in the store because if they

1:53:50leave memory all over the place it

1:53:52doesn't matter at the scale they are or

1:53:54like you know like if their app gets

1:53:55kicked out of the background cuz it

1:53:56crashes in the background you don't even

1:53:58notice you launch it again and there it

1:53:59is especially it's actually yeah it's

1:54:02actually a fairly forgiving environment

1:54:05and and the tools now protect you so

1:54:09much from doing things that are too

1:54:10horrible that you can actually get by

1:54:13pretty far without having knowledge of

1:54:16things like pointers and memory and

1:54:17stuff like that yeah so and it's also

1:54:20you know to some degree like what what

1:54:22level are you hiring right like when we

1:54:24hired our newest developer you know we

1:54:27were hiring somebody we were intending

1:54:29to hire someone that was a bit junior

1:54:31and and so I don't recall how this went

1:54:34during his interview I did interview him

1:54:36but like I

1:54:37I'm sure asked him you know what's a

1:54:38retain cycle how do you create it why

1:54:40would you well how would you

1:54:41accidentally create it and you know how

1:54:42would you find it how would you fix it

1:54:44and if I'm hiring a junior developer

1:54:47they can get that wrong and I

1:54:48potentially would be okay with it like

1:54:51you know I would hope that they would at

1:54:52least somewhat understand what I'm

1:54:53talking about but they can have a wrong

1:54:56answer and as long as they have a vague

1:54:57understanding and I feel like they're

1:54:59coachable and which is a very corporate

1:55:01thing to say well yeah exactly we can

1:55:05have a coaching opportunity in the

1:55:06parking lot after we stand up all right

1:55:08you say you have worked with me you see

1:55:13what I'm driving at like I I don't think

1:55:15that that beings I'm agreeing with you

1:55:18and roundabout way you know I don't

1:55:19think being super experienced and having

1:55:21a deep deep deep knowledge of like the

1:55:23history of objective-c and

1:55:24and why is message-passing different

1:55:26than calling a method you know why is

1:55:29well I don't think you need all of that

1:55:30but I do know it is fair enough but I do

1:55:34think it is assistive in understanding

1:55:36like I said earlier you know what makes

1:55:38what makes Coco the way it is it's

1:55:40because it's it's in large ways because

1:55:43of what made Objective C what it is and

1:55:45I don't I don't think it's necessary

1:55:49what is the thing that's it's necessary

1:55:52but not sufficient provided I screwed

1:55:53that up didn't I sufficient but not

1:55:54necessary you get what I'm driving at is

1:55:55it sufficient but not necessary

1:55:57that's what Johnson always says yeah

1:55:58totally but anyway so the point is that

1:56:03you know it's it's useful to have but

1:56:04would not require John given very quiet

1:56:07any thoughts about this this is a

1:56:09specific instance of the more general

1:56:13question of whether not whether you

1:56:17should have but what the value is of

1:56:19having a background in the fundamentals

1:56:22when it comes to the everyday craft of

1:56:25doing a thing like so can I do a

1:56:28particular task without knowing the

1:56:33history cultural baggage and all the

1:56:36other lower levels of abstraction that

1:56:38I'm building upon the answer is yes you

1:56:39can you can be a craftsman at a higher

1:56:41level of abstraction without knowledge

1:56:43of detailed knowledge of history and

1:56:45culture and all the lower layers but

1:56:48there is most certainly value in knowing

1:56:52all that stuff I mean you could take it

1:56:53just auto mechanic right there's lots of

1:56:55things that you can be trained to do to

1:56:56a car without knowing the details of the

1:56:59levels of abstraction that you're not

1:57:01dealing with without knowing the history

1:57:03of internal combustion engines

1:57:05particularly the history of the features

1:57:07of the internal combustion engine for a

1:57:08particular make of car you don't need

1:57:10that background to be really good at

1:57:12doing the brakes changing the oil even

1:57:16disassembling and reassembling a

1:57:17particular model of engine if you know

1:57:19how to do that at that level you're fine

1:57:21there you know but you know so the gave

1:57:23a computer programming the question is

1:57:25do I need a computer science background

1:57:26and a knowledge of algorithms data

1:57:29structures electrical engineering

1:57:31circuit design basics of electronics

1:57:34like so you need to have all that to

1:57:36write an IRS

1:57:37hell no you do not but having that

1:57:40background is valuable and makes you

1:57:43better at the job of writing an iOS

1:57:45application particularly when as

1:57:47inevitably happens things go wrong and

1:57:50you have to figure out why they're going

1:57:52wrong

1:57:52that's when whatever level of

1:57:54abstraction you're working at starts to

1:57:55fall apart and you find yourself looking

1:57:57at memory addresses in a debugger

1:57:59assuming you even know enough to

1:58:01navigate a debugger and if you don't

1:58:03know what a pointer is it just feels

1:58:05like gibberish and it feels you feel

1:58:07lost right but if you understand all

1:58:09those lower levels you can drop down a

1:58:11level and drop down a little further and

1:58:13like and if you're really good to know

1:58:14the whole stack in your omigosh type

1:58:16person you can look at machine code and

1:58:18figure out what the hell's going on

1:58:19right and even if you're not though even

1:58:22if you're not like someone who really

1:58:23can navigate the whole stack just

1:58:25knowing how in general computers work

1:58:27from top to bottom lets you understand

1:58:30at least what parts you don't know and

1:58:32where you might go to look up something

1:58:33and to understand I know what I'm

1:58:35looking at here I just don't know

1:58:37specifically what it says but I

1:58:38understand where it came from and I

1:58:40understand if there's a part of it that

1:58:41I need to figure out I know where to

1:58:44look for it or you know and all the way

1:58:46down to like hopefully none of us get

1:58:47down to the hardware level or you got to

1:58:48figure out what what's wrong at the

1:58:50hardware level but I still feel like

1:58:51even that which probably won't come up

1:58:53in debugging a program is useful to know

1:58:55because it explains many of the features

1:58:57higher up just as you were saying

1:58:58knowing about objective-c explains a lot

1:59:01of the weird features of Swift like if

1:59:03you don't know about objective-c it may

1:59:04be seem weird that that Swift has these

1:59:06things and what the hell is a table C

1:59:08mean and why is that even there and what

1:59:10is it what do you mean by an object

1:59:12being backed by the objective-c runtime

1:59:14versus one that isn't and like what is

1:59:16that you know you can get by without it

1:59:18but there is most certainly value for it

1:59:21and I think the question when people ask

1:59:22about this whether it's should it have

1:59:23to know pointers are doing you have to

1:59:24have a computer science background is

1:59:26they want to know if it's like a gating

1:59:28factor and I don't think it is I think

1:59:29you can actually be a successful a good

1:59:31programmer but I think all that

1:59:33background that you're like do I have to

1:59:35know this there is value for it it's

1:59:37just a question of how much value does

1:59:39it have for the thing that you are doing

1:59:40if you are working at Apple and

1:59:43frameworks it's probably more important

1:59:45than you have

1:59:46background if you're working it up on

1:59:47the compiler team yet more important if

1:59:50you are designing a hardware and

1:59:51software system from top to bottom

1:59:52really really important so you just kind

1:59:55of have to decide how much how much of

1:59:59the

1:59:59the

0:00:00as we've already discussed I have my

0:00:01paneled setup of Windows and in the one

0:00:05accent come from it's not a Connecticut

0:00:07thing I wasn't aware I had one the word

0:00:09the word for the thing you cook in and

0:00:12the first syllable for your intrument of

0:00:14windows PA ne l vs. PA in Tamil right

0:00:18what how do you pronounce it not the

0:00:21same way as the as the thing that you

0:00:23cooking he says panel yeah exactly

0:00:25what do you cook in a pan oh not a pan i

0:00:31I'm you say them both the same you say I

0:00:34cook in a pan and I have a bunch of

0:00:36panels yeah so how would you say it I

0:00:38cook in a pan I have a bunch of panels

0:00:39that sounded these are you trolling

0:00:42sounded exactly the same analyze the

0:00:45waveforms and panels pan panels Marco

0:00:51you said what do you have I cook in a

0:00:55pan yeah and I have panels mmm

0:00:58interesting middle ground they're

0:00:59slightly different from each other I

0:01:01don't understand what it's just what

0:01:07being colorblind feels like all right so

0:01:14we talked a lot last week about

0:01:16onboarding screens and why they're there

0:01:19what is their purpose whether they're

0:01:20good whether they're bad etc and I was

0:01:23informed that the reason that these

0:01:26screens are happening is because of gdpr

0:01:30which I know almost nothing about and

0:01:33I've been a little busy and so I am a

0:01:34poor chief summarizer in chief but

0:01:36nevertheless GPG DPR is a general data

0:01:41protection regulation which is something

0:01:43that the EU passed recently and has come

0:01:45into effect or is coming into effect

0:01:47very very very soon it becomes

0:01:48enforceable from the 25th of May 2018 so

0:01:51we are coming up on it now I guess this

0:01:54doesn't apply to Britain too soon anyway

0:01:56the point is Faline is sorry everybody

0:02:00the point is apparently it's it talks

0:02:02about how companies store your data and

0:02:05tries to give you more control of your

0:02:07data and I've been told that that is the

0:02:10genesis of all of these onboarding

0:02:11screens

0:02:13sure if I buy that because I bet that

0:02:15screen is gonna be everywhere not just

0:02:16in Europe and it's not like Apple is

0:02:18above doing a region-specific you eyes I

0:02:20do a bunch of stuff I think it's only

0:02:22visible in China for instance

0:02:23interesting maybe yeah on the other hand

0:02:26I feel like this gdpr thing which I'm

0:02:29basically just learning about now

0:02:30because I didn't actually follow your

0:02:31link in the show notes

0:02:31reminds me of the European cookie

0:02:34regulation stuff do you remember that oh

0:02:36yeah remember I think it's throne effect

0:02:37like if you go to they got a throw up a

0:02:40pop-up it says just so you know this

0:02:42website is gonna you know use cookies to

0:02:43keep track of you agree or disagree

0:02:45right there's another example of

0:02:48properly motivated but ill-conceived

0:02:51legislation where the motivation is pure

0:02:54like there's these computers and they

0:02:56potentially could be storing us personal

0:02:58information and tracking us which by the

0:02:59way they totally do let's do something

0:03:02with the law to deal with that but this

0:03:06you know the impulse to do this comes

0:03:08really early on in the history of the

0:03:10web when the scariest thing out there is

0:03:11a cookie right and the legislation is I

0:03:15know let's make every website in the

0:03:17world annoying forever

0:03:18and let's never do anything else related

0:03:21to other kinds of tracking that'll be

0:03:22much much worse than cookies and you

0:03:25know like so many other laws like it

0:03:26just sits there until someone you know

0:03:28who's gonna have the motivation say you

0:03:29know we should stop doing that because

0:03:30it's dumb or like we should realize the

0:03:34folly of this particular technique of

0:03:36trying to get people to grapple with

0:03:38privacy because if you if you say this

0:03:42is the this is the way we should deal

0:03:43with everything then you gotta have

0:03:44stuff like that for all forms of

0:03:46JavaScript every kind of local storage

0:03:48all the flash based super cookie

0:03:50whatever thing it just it never ends and

0:03:52you know you'd have to plow through 50

0:03:54layers of click-wrap as they call it to

0:03:57get to the website that you want so if

0:04:01there's some new kind of legislation

0:04:03says by the way every time you launch an

0:04:04application go throw a thing in someone

0:04:05sites which I don't think that's what

0:04:06this gdpr thing says but if there were

0:04:08such a thing I think that would be sort

0:04:10of the modern equivalent of the cookie

0:04:13legislation perhaps motivated by a noble

0:04:18intent but ill-conceived badly

0:04:21implemented and sure to age

0:04:24so we'll say maybe when these things

0:04:27roll out and Apple talks about them on

0:04:29stage maybe they will make it pitch in

0:04:31that direction but as far as I can tell

0:04:33it looks a lot more like what we talked

0:04:35about last show a way for Apple to

0:04:37advertise one of its competitive

0:04:38advantages and to provide some

0:04:40reassurance and to explain what the

0:04:41applications do in a more clear way than

0:04:44just showing a nebulous view yeah we'll

0:04:47see but supposedly that is that is kind

0:04:50of the genesis for this there's also

0:04:51going to be a link in the show notes

0:04:52Smashing Magazine has how gdpr will

0:04:56change the way you develop which talks

0:04:59about you know kind of how how all this

0:05:01will affect developers and the rumblings

0:05:04I've heard through various sources is

0:05:06that this is a bigger deal than any of

0:05:07us Americans are realizing because it

0:05:10doesn't seem to apply to us but it

0:05:12applies to any of us that have you know

0:05:15code that reaches more than one country

0:05:16in more than just America so and by the

0:05:18way I think it is possible to make good

0:05:20legislation to protect consumers privacy

0:05:22it's just really hard to do when it

0:05:23comes to tech because you know the

0:05:26tendency is to pick whatever the

0:05:28specifics of the technology are at the

0:05:30moment and attack them and demonize them

0:05:32one really it's a much more general

0:05:34concern and historically speaking

0:05:35legislative bodies I had a good track

0:05:37record with legislating technology

0:05:41essentially like understanding what the

0:05:42underlying issue is rather than

0:05:44attacking a specific technology as the

0:05:46one and only vehicle through which this

0:05:49issue will manifest and that's never

0:05:51true like maybe that you know cookies

0:05:53were how privacy manifested a long long

0:05:54time ago privacy issues manifest in the

0:05:58following decades in so many more

0:06:00important ways than cookies and yet the

0:06:02legislation is just sits there staring

0:06:04at cookies which is why you can't really

0:06:06legislate too technical details you have

0:06:09to figure out what it is that we're

0:06:11really concerned about and make a law

0:06:12such that it applies in a useful way to

0:06:15any future technology but also at the

0:06:18same time doesn't preclude future

0:06:20technologies that may run afoul of the

0:06:22letter of law if not the spirit making

0:06:24laws is hard making laws about

0:06:25technologies doubly hard one way to help

0:06:27with this by the way I'm saying this

0:06:28most from a u.s. perspective I have no

0:06:30idea Europe is perhaps take the advice

0:06:33and consultation of people who know

0:06:36things about

0:06:36technology a vested interest in one way

0:06:39the other like kind of like talking to

0:06:41mathematicians and cryptographic experts

0:06:43when you when you make any laws related

0:06:44to cryptography which the u.s. seems

0:06:46completely incapable of doing or they

0:06:48talk to them and ignore what they say

0:06:49and said I think I'll listen to industry

0:06:52lobbying groups instead they have all

0:06:53the money so they must know what they're

0:06:54talking about I mean to be fair like we

0:06:57can't even agree that facts are facts

0:07:01I'm thinking back to a you know more

0:07:04naive time when we could simply just

0:07:07complain about how technologically

0:07:09illiterate our legislative bodies are

0:07:11now we have much more pressing concerns

0:07:12and now I'm sad thanks for that John

0:07:15alright last week we talked about how if

0:07:19you are a member of one or thirty slack

0:07:22teams you can actually a little no in

0:07:25fact you can access slack via IRC

0:07:27I don't know when this announcement

0:07:29actually happened but as it turns out we

0:07:32got word within moments of releasing the

0:07:35episode that that's going away now

0:07:36though it has been disabled for slack

0:07:39teams that haven't enabled it and I

0:07:41think it will be the it will be phased

0:07:43out in the next some duration of time so

0:07:45whoops

0:07:46I'm not surprised by this because it it

0:07:50totally seems like a thing that slack

0:07:52might do early on as part of it let's

0:07:56let's make sure you have no excuse not

0:07:57to use slack right and then as slack

0:07:59becomes more successful and as they can

0:08:01compare the statistics of how many

0:08:03people use our IRC gateway versus how

0:08:05much does it take to maintain it versus

0:08:06how much does it help our you know

0:08:08strategic intent of the company it you

0:08:11know it's probably used by a vanishingly

0:08:13small percentage of slack's customers

0:08:15they no longer are in that mode where

0:08:16they need to convince people to use

0:08:17slack because the ball started rolling

0:08:19and it probably does take some amount to

0:08:21maintain and it's just a distraction so

0:08:23kind of make sure it makes sense that it

0:08:24goes away but I bet if you use it you're

0:08:26probably pretty annoyed by that indeed

0:08:28so that happened coincidentally right

0:08:30around the time we were bringing up on

0:08:31the show its head hey you can do this

0:08:33too

0:08:34moving on Amazon's Alexa is gaining a

0:08:36new follow up mode which no longer

0:08:38requires a trigger word after every

0:08:40request so what'll happen is Alexa will

0:08:42listen for five seconds after your

0:08:44previous request to see if you're

0:08:45wanting to ask another question the blue

0:08:46ring on your echo will remain lit and it

0:08:49will indicate the cheese to listen

0:08:50in this time period you can ask her

0:08:52another question otherwise she'll go

0:08:54back to sleep mode that's cool

0:08:56see this to me this is it sounds cool

0:09:00until you actually think about how that

0:09:02works in practice and I think you can

0:09:04actually label it now but the problem

0:09:06with that is it's not addressing what

0:09:09you actually want which is what you

0:09:10actually want is to say cylinder play el

0:09:14Scorcho by Weezer and turn the volume to

0:09:16five you know like you want to be able

0:09:18to do multiple commands in one sentence

0:09:20or in one command and they can't do that

0:09:24right now none of them can as far as I

0:09:25know and that's what you actually want

0:09:27what this feature does is hey cylinder

0:09:30play Oh score sure by Weezer and then it

0:09:32says okay and then it starts playing

0:09:36like you don't want that like that is

0:09:40not like I don't think it's stopping on

0:09:42the command I think all it's doing is I

0:09:44mean it's my reading of this article is

0:09:46all it's doing is it will immediately

0:09:47start playing the song that you asked

0:09:49for but for the next five seconds

0:09:51anything else you say will try to

0:09:53interpret as a command as if you had pre

0:09:54fixed it with a cylinder right but I'm

0:09:56like I'm pretty sure then the volume

0:09:57still stays ducked and it's just like I

0:09:59feel like the the percentage of the time

0:10:02that's going to actually do what you

0:10:04want versus the percentage of the time

0:10:07that it's going to either keep listening

0:10:09something you say afterwards that you

0:10:10didn't intend for it to be a command or

0:10:12just delay what you were trying to do or

0:10:14do something or like you thought it was

0:10:17still listening give it another command

0:10:18but the five seconds had just ended like

0:10:20I feel like the failure rate of that to

0:10:24do what people actually want is going to

0:10:26be way way too high to be acceptable

0:10:29like it's just it's not going to be good

0:10:31enough enough of the time whereas what

0:10:33like and it's also like to me that's not

0:10:35smart

0:10:36that's just like a very small

0:10:38implementation detail that's not

0:10:40actually making the service smarter but

0:10:42we actually need is for all these voice

0:10:44assistants to become smarter and to

0:10:46recognize compound commands that's what

0:10:49people actually want play el Scorcho by

0:10:51Weezer and turn the volume to five set

0:10:54of rice timer for 10 minutes and a pasta

0:10:56timer for seven minutes this is what

0:10:58people actually want to do and so you

0:11:00know little trees like this like that's

0:11:03a dumb hack

0:11:04really what we need is for the the for

0:11:06the voices isn't to get better to

0:11:07actually recognize multiple commands the

0:11:09way humans will actually give them so

0:11:11this is also not what I was asking for

0:11:13last week I think that's why I was sent

0:11:14to us as follow-up what well I was

0:11:16asking for was context awareness such

0:11:18that follow-up commands could be aware

0:11:19of what you asked for previously

0:11:21interpret your subsequent commands in

0:11:23light of what you had just asked it

0:11:25based on like like the way a person

0:11:26would if you say something to a person

0:11:28an hour later you see something else

0:11:29there's no way they're gonna connect

0:11:31that to the context of the last thing

0:11:32you said to them but if you say

0:11:33something to them and then add an

0:11:34addendum two seconds later they have of

0:11:36the context of the first command you

0:11:39know to understand what you mean and the

0:11:41the key part of that is that the second

0:11:42thing that you say is not itself a

0:11:45complete command it relies on the

0:11:47knowledge of the context that's why I

0:11:48said last week that it probably requires

0:11:50some more local hardware because you

0:11:52would want I'm at least for privacy

0:11:54reasons or whatever you'd want some some

0:11:55of that local context awareness to

0:11:57happen you know locally you don't need

0:11:59the server to keep track of like your

0:12:00session or whatever so we can understand

0:12:03that I think we keep some of that

0:12:04locally compound commands would also be

0:12:07good and actually seems much easier to

0:12:09me than what I'm asking for because like

0:12:10it's two commands and there's a joiner

0:12:12and you can figure it out and break it

0:12:14up into pieces but I think it's more

0:12:17natural to have a conversation to hone

0:12:19in on what you want because that's what

0:12:21you do with other people then to

0:12:23formulate even a single command let

0:12:26alone a compound command as if as I said

0:12:29a couple weeks ago you're playing a

0:12:30verbal text adventure where maybe you

0:12:33don't have to get the syntax just right

0:12:34but you understand that you're issuing a

0:12:36command and now you maybe even issue

0:12:37compound commands but it's not the way

0:12:39you would yell them to have the room for

0:12:41Marco to add something to your shopping

0:12:43list you would you don't you don't have

0:12:44to formulate a command for Marco you can

0:12:45basically say it in any way that you

0:12:47want including addendums and revisions

0:12:50and you know what never mind about i

0:12:53just get the other thing that you can

0:12:54say stuff like that and it knows what

0:12:56the heck you're talking about and the

0:12:57cylinder does not and that is a really

0:12:59tall order delay mode or follow-up mode

0:13:03or whatever is not close to that but it

0:13:06least shows then the next shows that

0:13:10they understand that the current mode of

0:13:12wake wake wake word or wake phrase

0:13:16followed by single command

0:13:18followed by I forget you exist is pretty

0:13:21primitive also like I feel like this is

0:13:24this kind of has like a Simon Says

0:13:27problem where like if you if you get

0:13:30accustomed to not saying the wake word

0:13:32before every command you give that

0:13:35doesn't work all the time like you can't

0:13:37say cylinder play out square by tweezer

0:13:39and then 10 seconds later say volume 5

0:13:43because it won't recognize it yeah yeah

0:13:44say Simon Says volume 5 you gotta say

0:13:46cylinder volume right and it's like but

0:13:48but sometimes you don't have to say that

0:13:50like if you say it within 5 seconds of

0:13:53the previous command being completed

0:13:54then you can omit the word cylinder and

0:13:57it's like well that's like that's just

0:13:59gonna be confusing like that's what you

0:14:00know it's gonna trip you up when you're

0:14:01like it's gonna increase your error rate

0:14:03like this is okay this is this is just

0:14:05one of the reasons why this isn't a

0:14:06solution I I feel like in at a high

0:14:09level I think what kind of makes me sad

0:14:10about the voice assistant market is that

0:14:13all of us like Apple fans are accustomed

0:14:16to somebody being you know historically

0:14:19Apple being really good at designing

0:14:22really smart software and really good

0:14:25software experiences and the rest of the

0:14:28industry has always been pretty crappy

0:14:30overall if there's been a couple of

0:14:31bright spots here there but not many and

0:14:34I feel like like we're all having to use

0:14:36like the like Amazon and Google stuff

0:14:39and Amazon and Google have always been

0:14:40pretty rough especially Amazon pretty

0:14:43rough at user interaction design and and

0:14:47software usability design and what we're

0:14:49seeing here is just like you know tech

0:14:53companies making stuff that's mediocre

0:14:54which is what we've always seen an apple

0:14:56is always the one who could save us from

0:14:58that but unfortunately in this

0:15:00particular market they just seem not

0:15:03capable of that for whatever reason and

0:15:05that just makes me sad like it's like

0:15:06usually Apple will be the ones to save

0:15:08us and to make like the really good

0:15:10thing for people like us who cared about

0:15:12good experiences and all the details and

0:15:14everything and invoice systems they they

0:15:16just aren't capable of doing that for

0:15:18whatever reason oh it's kind of sad I

0:15:19continue to think that this is much more

0:15:21in Google's wheelhouse than apples

0:15:22because yes it's a part of user

0:15:24interface design but specifically this

0:15:26this realm of translating words that a

0:15:31human comes up

0:15:31up with into an intent is what the

0:15:34Google search box is all about it

0:15:36frustrates some of us because it no

0:15:37longer works like AltaVista where you

0:15:39can formulate like a boolean query with

0:15:40exact substring matching and and get

0:15:42predictable results but that Google

0:15:44search box is all about saying people

0:15:47just type lots of stuff there and you

0:15:49can type things there and concise I'm

0:15:52still amazed that the Google search box

0:15:53I type things there and it finds what I

0:15:55meant for it to find and I don't even

0:15:57know how it's doing it like I didn't

0:15:59it's not it's you know how did you get

0:16:01what I was trying you know you go to the

0:16:03page or whatever like none of those

0:16:05words are on this page like you somehow

0:16:08figured out what I meant I granted it's

0:16:10still a single command in response and

0:16:11it's not a conversation but Google was

0:16:14founded on that strength of going beyond

0:16:17the sort of simple direct computer

0:16:19search to intelligent interpretation of

0:16:22human generated words and translating

0:16:25that to an intent and satisfying the

0:16:28request

0:16:28despite spelling errors weird phrasing

0:16:31you know the foibles of humans right and

0:16:34the verbal one of that now that

0:16:36speech-to-text is as good as it is it

0:16:39Maps very well on to the search problem

0:16:43in that you have to figure out intent

0:16:45and you can get the words from it pretty

0:16:46well and you have to figure out intent

0:16:48and same thing with spelling errors same

0:16:49thing with like you know homonyms or

0:16:51whatever that google is good at figuring

0:16:52that that's always been google's

0:16:53strength so I totally look to them to be

0:16:55the ones to figure to figure out this

0:16:58aspect of user interface before Apple

0:17:00and I think they are doing it better

0:17:01than Apple but I agree that all of them

0:17:04are are not not as good as I could help

0:17:07like Apple is way behind and Amazon and

0:17:10Google have been ahead but I'm waiting

0:17:13for them both to take like the next

0:17:14small step we are sponsored this week by

0:17:17Backblaze go to Backblaze comm slash ATP

0:17:21for a fully featured 15-day free trial

0:17:23start backing up your data Backblaze

0:17:26offers you unlimited cloud backup for

0:17:29your Macs and PCs for just $5 a month

0:17:32per computer back please backs up

0:17:34documents music photos videos drawings

0:17:37projects everything and you can access

0:17:39all of your data anywhere in the world

0:17:40on the website or on the go using your

0:17:43phone and you can restore

0:17:45as much as you want you can restore your

0:17:47entire drive if you want to if you have

0:17:49a major data loss or if your say on a

0:17:51trip and you just need access to a file

0:17:53that you forget to bring with you you

0:17:55can restore just one file once again on

0:17:57the website or on their apps for mobile

0:17:58phones it's your choice you can also

0:18:01restore by mail so for instance if you

0:18:03have a whole bunch of files or like a

0:18:05whole drive to restore and it's gonna

0:18:06take an unreasonable amount of time to

0:18:08download all that stuff you can buy a

0:18:10hard drive with all your data on it that

0:18:12gets overnighted to you via FedEx and if

0:18:14you return the drive back then when

0:18:16you're done you get a refund Backblaze

0:18:18is used by tons of people they have over

0:18:20500 petabytes of data under management

0:18:22including about I don't know 10

0:18:25terabytes or so of data from my house

0:18:27it's wonderful I use them I've used them

0:18:29for a long time since before they were a

0:18:31sponsor of any of my stuff and I'll tell

0:18:33you what back place is the best

0:18:34they really are if you you want online

0:18:36backup trust me on that

0:18:38and if you're gonna get online backup

0:18:39I've tried a lot of services and I stick

0:18:41with back plays for lots of good reasons

0:18:43I highly suggest use back plays back

0:18:46plays is gimmick free there's no

0:18:49additional charges just five dollars a

0:18:51month for full backups unlimited space

0:18:54no upload throttling or anything like

0:18:56that you can upload as fast as your

0:18:57connection will do it and of course you

0:18:59have control of that if you want to it's

0:19:00wonderful go to back plays comm slash

0:19:03ATP to see for yourself and start a

0:19:0515-day fully-featured free trial go

0:19:08there play with it start protecting

0:19:10yourself from all the risks that can

0:19:12happen if you don't have your data

0:19:13backed up in the cloud and they also

0:19:15have now business backup so if you

0:19:17already have back plays at home tell

0:19:19your system in at work or if you are the

0:19:20system at work tell yourself to go to

0:19:21back please calm slash a TV and hit the

0:19:24business backup link in the top of the

0:19:25page the same awesome service with more

0:19:27admin tools using back please groups see

0:19:29for yourself once again 15-day free

0:19:31trial at Backblaze comm slash ATP start

0:19:35backing up your data right now trust me

0:19:37you will not regret it thank you so much

0:19:39to back pleas for sponsoring our show

0:19:41[Music]

0:19:43what did you guys see there was some

0:19:46sort of like drama about Siri that

0:19:48happened today I did not get a chance to

0:19:50look up what happened but apparently

0:19:52someone was like Oh series garbage and

0:19:55it's not my fault do you know what I'm

0:19:56talking about

0:19:57it's a story on the

0:19:59information which when I see that

0:20:01website I always think of Marco and I'm

0:20:02like thank someone the website it's much

0:20:06worse much worse than the magazine ever

0:20:08was because the information is like

0:20:10anyway you know the information is

0:20:11really spammy I really don't like like

0:20:13they signed me up to their man list when

0:20:15they launched as if I had signed up

0:20:17saying I was interested and as a result

0:20:19even though I have never responded to

0:20:20anything never sign up for anything

0:20:22they still incessantly spam me and I

0:20:25really like you know I know it's kind of

0:20:28low to call them up publicly for this

0:20:30but that is not okay for anybody to do

0:20:33it just drives me nuts you can

0:20:35unsubscribe I just unsubscribe today

0:20:37speaking of them I did it because I

0:20:39finally drove me that nuts but I'm just

0:20:40like like I never signed up for this and

0:20:42all you're doing is promoting articles

0:20:44that I can't see because I'm not gonna

0:20:47pay 40 bucks a month to a spammer and so

0:20:50like it just it drives me nuts I just

0:20:52people play fast and loose with mailing

0:20:54lists all the time and on the maleness

0:20:56companies like MailChimp everything

0:20:58they're all complicit in this because

0:20:59they don't require a double opt-in when

0:21:00you import am analyst from another

0:21:01service allegedly and so like they're

0:21:04all complicit because they all make

0:21:05spamming people in in Mass really easy

0:21:07and as a result I get on all sorts of

0:21:10spam lists that appear like I signed up

0:21:12for them and you know it's just it's

0:21:14it's a dirty scammy trick when you're

0:21:17launching something like this to use

0:21:18like a PR list you find somewhere or you

0:21:20buy somewhere and the information was

0:21:22one of the companies that does that's

0:21:24one of the many companies that does this

0:21:25and so I just have zero respect for them

0:21:28zero and I know it's a dumb reason but

0:21:30that's how nuts does drives me well

0:21:33anyway this explains why I know I was

0:21:34actually read the article because none

0:21:36of us have paid for the information but

0:21:38we know about it because there exists it

0:21:42was I think summarized on nine to five

0:21:44Mac which is also kind of a scummy

0:21:46practice of like taking a paywall the

0:21:47article and then basically rewriting it

0:21:50worse on your site so that people read

0:21:52your site instead of the paywall thing

0:21:54yeah I love this business it's such a

0:21:55great basis I should really go back to

0:21:58publishing web content that sounds like

0:22:00a lot of fun I mean I can understand

0:22:02like a paragraph and a link seems

0:22:04reasonable but once you've gone on for a

0:22:06page and a half with laborious the

0:22:07summarizing an article that you didn't

0:22:09write anyway

0:22:09the story as far as I could tell was a

0:22:11bunch of a bunch of reports from people

0:22:14inside Apple or X Apple people who know

0:22:17about the environment workings of Syria

0:22:19over the years is saying how and where

0:22:21things went wrong with specific quotes

0:22:22from specific people assigning blame

0:22:24to other people not to themselves

0:22:26explaining the situation and it's just

0:22:28the typical you know things aren't going

0:22:31great inside a big company you know

0:22:33product launches and it's not scalable

0:22:35and it's band-aided and everyone points

0:22:37fingers about who set the priorities or

0:22:39what they should be doing and how often

0:22:40it should be updated I mean it's it's

0:22:42mostly details that may be like

0:22:44interesting you know or like from a

0:22:48business case perspective if you're

0:22:50learning about how businesses run

0:22:52interesting but like practically

0:22:53speaking I care less and less about the

0:22:56internal political goings-on in Apple

0:22:59and and mostly just say like that's

0:23:03Apple's job to figure out like I'm not

0:23:04running Apple I'm not an executive there

0:23:06I'm not a high-level manager that's

0:23:08their job as a company to figure out how

0:23:10to corral the people to produce results

0:23:14and if it doesn't go well I'm not that

0:23:17interested in why didn't go well who was

0:23:19to blame which person was more difficult

0:23:20which person made the big wrong

0:23:22strategic decision at what point they

0:23:24just need to figure that out but on the

0:23:26outside of they say look how's the

0:23:27product doing and the product is we've

0:23:28discussed in the past not doing that

0:23:30great and they've had a long time so I

0:23:31hope they get it sorted out I don't even

0:23:34want to get angry about Siri again so

0:23:35let's just move on and instead let's get

0:23:37angry about keyboards Marco this is your

0:23:39cue Apple apparently has a patented a

0:23:43keyboard that cannot be defeated by

0:23:45crumbs Marco I know you have been

0:23:48celebrating you are swinging from the

0:23:50rafters you're so excited so I don't

0:23:54know when we're gonna expect to see this

0:23:55but hopefully it will mean that I don't

0:23:57need to invest in compressed air anymore

0:23:59I mean this is a problem I don't have

0:24:01because I have a laptop that has a

0:24:02functioning keyboard I walked right into

0:24:05that one but why do you think Marco

0:24:07would be excited by this this seems like

0:24:08Marcos nightmare to me because Marco

0:24:10loves the fact that the keyboard he

0:24:12hates also has a terrible reliability

0:24:14problem that allows him to righteously

0:24:15rail against it imagine if they made

0:24:17that keyboard hundra's i'm relying

0:24:19this keyboard works all the time but I

0:24:21hate it I mean to be

0:24:23fair when it first came out before we

0:24:25knew how badly it would break all the

0:24:26time that is what I did and also the

0:24:29arrow key placement is still horrendous

0:24:31and not having the not having the gap

0:24:32above the arrows as a both the left and

0:24:34right is unforgivable

0:24:35but anyway look I I'm of two minds of

0:24:40this you know number one John's right

0:24:42you know I I in a way I don't want to

0:24:45see this keyboard succeed and be fixed

0:24:47I'm not gonna lie that's that is part of

0:24:49my motivation because I don't like it so

0:24:51much but also like keep in mind I had

0:24:54those keyboards for what about a year

0:24:56before I finally gave up across 13

0:24:58different laptops three and and so and

0:25:00it's so I had the keyboard and it's like

0:25:03I got used to it enough like I never

0:25:05liked it but I was able to function with

0:25:08it until it stopped working reliably and

0:25:11so the reality is I know you know I got

0:25:15a I got to choose my battles here I know

0:25:17that a lot of people out there don't

0:25:19care or even like this keyboard I know

0:25:21that I'm that Apple is always going to

0:25:24press to make these things thinner and I

0:25:27think Apple has shown it across multiple

0:25:30years and multiple products that they

0:25:33only care about making the keyboard

0:25:35thinner and they will make some efforts

0:25:38to make the thin keyboard tolerable but

0:25:41they are no longer interested in keeping

0:25:43it a good keyboard if that means they

0:25:46can't make it thinner and so I just have

0:25:48to kind of resign myself to accept that

0:25:51III don't I'm not gonna round this for a

0:25:53half hour like I usually do because I

0:25:55this battle I lost this battle and I'm

0:25:58going to continue to lose this battle

0:26:00into the future the last thing I think

0:26:02Apple's gonna do in the next MacBook

0:26:04revision is to make the keyboard thicker

0:26:06I it just not gonna happen

0:26:08and I I fundamentally don't believe that

0:26:12they can make a keyboard with this

0:26:14little travel good I give to one that

0:26:17they can do it good as far as you're

0:26:19concerned though because lots of people

0:26:20do really like the keyboard I mean Casey

0:26:21and I included it basically being

0:26:23converted to this new keyboard this is

0:26:25just the reliability issues and as you

0:26:27said the key layout right and so

0:26:28basically if they can fix the

0:26:31reliability problems yeah I would love

0:26:34if they made the keyboard a different

0:26:35style

0:26:36if they can fix the reliability problems

0:26:39that that's the best I can hope for the

0:26:42key layout is just sitting right there

0:26:43too because there can be divisive

0:26:45opinions about do you like how this

0:26:46keyboard feels or not like some people

0:26:47like it some people don't find but I

0:26:49feel like key layout changes there are

0:26:51certain key layout changes that would be

0:26:54universally praised from the perspective

0:26:56of using the keyboard and the only

0:26:58naysayers would be aesthetic for example

0:27:00inverted t full-size breaking the

0:27:02rectangle of the keyboard

0:27:03aesthetically people would hate that it

0:27:05would be like the notch on the keyboard

0:27:07it would be like an asymmetrical notch

0:27:08on the bottom of your keyboard and those

0:27:10people would yell about it but from the

0:27:12perspective of people who type how does

0:27:13it feel to type on I don't see anybody

0:27:16saying please bring back the half size

0:27:18our keys with or without the gaps above

0:27:20them I mean are there fans out there

0:27:21who'd say please bring them back again

0:27:23yes I can imagine it but not from a

0:27:27functional perspective did you just say

0:27:29that you would bring asked to bring back

0:27:30the half our keys the what would you

0:27:33mean the way I have them only 2015 where

0:27:34the left and right are half height now I

0:27:36mean Brett make a full height and have

0:27:38that have the rectangular shape the

0:27:40defines be broken so basically have the

0:27:43up key in line with the other ones now

0:27:44but have the down left and right like

0:27:46you know a look in their own row below

0:27:48us exactly I have all them be full sized

0:27:50and have gaps above them I mean that

0:27:51would be cool but there that's never

0:27:53gonna do that so yeah no I'm just saying

0:27:55like like the our key outlet he layout

0:27:57changes that I think would be

0:27:58universally praised for our functional

0:28:00perspective but derided only from a

0:28:01static perspective I'm not even saying

0:28:03that wrong because I understand thinking

0:28:05that's ugly but boy would that be nicer

0:28:07for people use air which is I think

0:28:10everybody like who doesn't use the arrow

0:28:12keys a lot like my son these days he's

0:28:19using the mouse to move his insertion

0:28:20point one space I'm just like yo case

0:28:23use them like stop he goes from the

0:28:26keyboard to the mass of the keyboard

0:28:27when he can't reach him he can't figure

0:28:29out where they are because they're all

0:28:29the same height as everything else

0:28:31oh he's using a full-size Apple extended

0:28:33keyboard sighs are you kidding we're not

0:28:35using not my Hanson yeah increase in

0:28:38real keyboards here and like I even

0:28:41showed him the modifier for moving a

0:28:43word at a time and beginning of end of

0:28:44line but just for a single character

0:28:46like see take the mouse and steer it to

0:28:48go to the left

0:28:49of you know the place where he needs to

0:28:51insert a quotation mark to match the

0:28:53other one and it's like just just hit

0:28:54the left arrow once I swear to you it

0:28:56will work and he's just not he's not on

0:28:58that page this is what happens from not

0:28:59using computers and only using like

0:29:01iPads and iPhones like your whole

0:29:02formative years you have no idea about

0:29:04moving the cursor with arrow keys well

0:29:07anyway yeah I don't I wouldn't expect

0:29:10Apple to do anything that's gonna make

0:29:11the keyboard less attractive to the

0:29:15current Apple design teams aesthetic I

0:29:18agree unfortunately they're just not

0:29:20gonna do it like you know it's this is

0:29:22not not like a rare thing with Apple

0:29:23these days like look at the Apple TV

0:29:24remote look at I mean look even look

0:29:26they're right they're regular like

0:29:27keyboards and mice and everything like

0:29:29if they were willing to make it a little

0:29:31bit ugly they could make it better

0:29:32economically or feel better or work

0:29:34better or whatever else but they're not

0:29:35and it's easy to see both sides of this

0:29:37argument like we all argue like these

0:29:39things should work better design is how

0:29:40it works they argue we are printing

0:29:42money and this is how we like to design

0:29:44things and this is what looks good and

0:29:45people buy our stuff in part because it

0:29:47looks good it is ascetically better I

0:29:49think we would all agree it does look

0:29:50better when the keyboard is just a

0:29:52rectangle like it just does like as a

0:29:53piece of art as a you know but yeah and

0:29:56look Apple these days is really good

0:29:58designing beautiful things that kind of

0:30:00suck to use like that's that's good it

0:30:03could even be argued that the uniformity

0:30:05is the reason the right and left our

0:30:06piece became full height because those

0:30:08little gaps were an asymmetry it I

0:30:10guarantee you that's the reason because

0:30:12there's no there's no other reason to it

0:30:14it doesn't make them easier to use the

0:30:16same reason that the bottom row of keys

0:30:17is now the same height as all the other

0:30:18rows again uniformity yeah Oh totally

0:30:21yeah it's you know because it's its

0:30:22design it's designed purely to

0:30:24aesthetics it's egotistical design it is

0:30:27indulgent design for the designers to

0:30:29indulge themselves and what they think

0:30:31looks the best without regard to how

0:30:33things work someone I think I'll also

0:30:36point out that even on the like the

0:30:38external keyboards for desktop computers

0:30:41the bottom row of keys is now the same

0:30:43high as all the Owens I didn't actually

0:30:44check this because I don't have one of

0:30:46those new keyboards to compare with but

0:30:48I wouldn't be surprised to that were the

0:30:50case if only for parts sharing reason

0:30:51suppose you all know Apple likes to use

0:30:54the same keyboard across all of his all

0:30:56of its laptops from 12 inches to 17

0:30:58which I will you know forever remember

0:31:00as a ridiculous thing and now

0:31:02there's only slightly less ridiculous

0:31:03that's shared between the 15 and the 13

0:31:06and the 12 I guess oh so I'm this before

0:31:10we leave this this bit of fall pair on

0:31:11this this pen the date of his patent is

0:31:13uh 2016 which makes me think like just

0:31:17as the original Mac books were coming

0:31:19out about 2016 or was that they came out

0:31:22in early 2015 a year before and a half

0:31:25before they brought this keyboard to all

0:31:27of their laptops during which it was

0:31:29very clear during that year and a half

0:31:31that it failed a lot yeah so so but they

0:31:34but in 2016 they introduced the MacBook

0:31:36Pros with the same keyboard at the same

0:31:37time they filed this patent so it shows

0:31:39that they had been thinking about at

0:31:41some point you know before 2016 they had

0:31:45been investigating these different ways

0:31:47to seal up the bottom of the thing no I

0:31:48I think I brought this up when we talked

0:31:50about the original slimline keyboard and

0:31:53maybe was when we talked about the touch

0:31:54bar but I think this is oh use this

0:31:57opportunity to once again promote the

0:31:59idea that I think Apple would benefit

0:32:01from on all of its laptops this idea of

0:32:03sealing up the key caps with little

0:32:04membrane so that stuff can't get in

0:32:06there just take the next level and make

0:32:07these damn things waterproof right if

0:32:09you can waterproof a phone if you made a

0:32:11waterproof keyboard included which will

0:32:13also obviously include as a side effect

0:32:14the inability to get crap underneath the

0:32:16keys I would imagine I mean doesn't have

0:32:18to necessarily but I would imagine that

0:32:19would be that could be part of it people

0:32:21will love you for it

0:32:22how many people KC spill things on their

0:32:24laptops if you like is it beyond us

0:32:28technologically speaking to make a sort

0:32:31of sealed keyboard that feels good I

0:32:32mean maybe these patterns are just

0:32:33patents because Apple figured out if you

0:32:35do this it makes the keyboard feel even

0:32:36worse I don't know we'll see if they

0:32:38ever produce something like this but

0:32:39well no I mean we we kind of know that

0:32:41from the smart Keyboard the the iPad pro

0:32:43smart keyboard has I think but the same

0:32:46butterfly switches or at least similar

0:32:48feeling switches but it has like a

0:32:50membrane across the whole thing and so

0:32:52it is I think roughly a water resistant

0:32:55at least but it doesn't get it doesn't

0:32:58get stuff under the keys it doesn't do

0:33:00that so we kind of know like this is

0:33:02possible to do with just a membrane and

0:33:04I know that one of the Microsoft Surface

0:33:05notebook lines does it too and they have

0:33:08issues with it like you know getting

0:33:09dirty and looking really grimy and gross

0:33:11really fast but like that's not to say

0:33:13that it has to go that way like maybe

0:33:15different materials choices could

0:33:16different different results they're like

0:33:18that's not actually that bad of a thing

0:33:21to try I don't know if it would feel

0:33:23better or worse than we have now but

0:33:24like the smart Keyboard like I use the

0:33:26smart Keyboard all the time on the iPad

0:33:28I wouldn't call it great but it's

0:33:31tolerable and that's about what I can

0:33:33say for the notebook one as well so it's

0:33:36just tolerable in slightly different

0:33:37ways but you know what the smart

0:33:39keyboard keys never failed on me not

0:33:40once because stuff can't get in there so

0:33:42it's not a ridiculous idea do you have

0:33:45the problems of the smart Keyboard with

0:33:46like I think it was iOS 11 or something

0:33:47people complaining the smart Keyboard

0:33:48doesn't work reliable anymore due to

0:33:50like some change and in a debouncing

0:33:51firmware some crap oh yeah no I mean

0:33:53it's it's not I haven't had I don't know

0:33:55if it's related to deep bouncing or not

0:33:57no I definitely is less reliable that

0:34:00seems like a like an iOS software thing

0:34:01like just like the way the apps behave

0:34:03with the keyboard attached to detached

0:34:05it has been more buggy rotations been

0:34:07more buggy yeah it's it's been kind of a

0:34:09mess but I attribute that to iOS 11 but

0:34:13I don't know anyway I think one

0:34:14challenge you might have with the idea

0:34:15of waterproofing a laptop is ventilation

0:34:17and cooling yeah no it mean is obviously

0:34:21the MacBook is your easiest one right

0:34:22because the reason I bring up this whole

0:34:24idea of waterproofing now is that Apple

0:34:27has slowly been sealing up its laptops

0:34:29not for the purpose of water performing

0:34:30but just for the purpose of Apple being

0:34:32Apple like getting rid of moving parts

0:34:34and seams and making them unibody and

0:34:35then the battery is not removable then

0:34:37another would look at this as D

0:34:38contenting I mean it's a simplification

0:34:41it's moving towards this Platonic ideal

0:34:43of like this is a featureless you know

0:34:45smooth they are certainly featureless

0:34:48all right and so the MacBook no vents

0:34:51right you still have to deal with the

0:34:52ports which I think might be challenging

0:34:54because Apple doesn't get to define all

0:34:55those ports you have to come up with the

0:34:57sealed but still repairable e internal

0:34:59or replaceable USB C port or whatever

0:35:02but there's not a lot of holes in a

0:35:0312-inch MacBook right so I feel like

0:35:05that is that is a good candidate if you

0:35:07can steal an iPad or an iPhone you know

0:35:10it has similar number of holes to to a

0:35:13MacBook adorable the 12-inch

0:35:16Apple laptop for the ones with with

0:35:18vents and fans I granted us a lot harder

0:35:20but even on those if you say look it's

0:35:23not waterproof but the top surface the

0:35:26keyboard surface if you do a spill on it

0:35:28you'll be okay

0:35:30the water will shed away and not be

0:35:32sucked into the vents and the top is

0:35:35sealed so that it's waterproof so we can

0:35:37take a spill you can't dunk the thing in

0:35:39water but it's better than it was before

0:35:41because if you spell on the keyboard you

0:35:43doom didn't Apple would never repair

0:35:44everything again and if this membrane

0:35:46keyboard like if they do this for chrome

0:35:48reasons I said while you're in there see

0:35:50what you can do about water let's call

0:35:52it water resistance or something you

0:35:54know I I just think it's it's kind of

0:35:58silly as time goes on that our phones

0:36:02can be dropped into a glass of water and

0:36:04come back out okay but are much more

0:36:06expensive laptops like a pin drop of

0:36:11water fan falls on the keyboard and

0:36:13filters down to the inside and starts

0:36:14corroding things and it's all over one

0:36:16speck of dust $700 one speck of wet dust

0:36:20$1,200 yeah no more that's like total

0:36:22replacements like sorry well it's like

0:36:24they probably the phone's water got in

0:36:25this and that we don't cover water

0:36:27damage I don't know that's true of

0:36:29laptops but I know the phones have those

0:36:31little water damage sensor thingies on

0:36:33them that they yell at you about if it

0:36:35turns out your thing has water damage no

0:36:36it is also true of laptops right use

0:36:39desktop kids they don't get wet they

0:36:41don't get wet in those cases around I

0:36:43bet everybody good friends challenge

0:36:45accepted I would say hold my beer but

0:36:48I'm gonna need it we are sponsored this

0:36:51week by after socks bone conduction

0:36:52headphones go to ATP aftershocks calm

0:36:55and use code ATP 30 to get $30 off the

0:36:59wonderful new treks air their new

0:37:00flagship headphones bone conduction

0:37:02headphones rest next to your ear not on

0:37:05it not around it not in it and they send

0:37:08small vibrations through your cheek

0:37:10bones that reach your inner ear so it

0:37:12feels like you're wearing nothing at all

0:37:14really and especially the new Trek's air

0:37:15are so light they have a full titanium

0:37:18wraparound band weighs just 1.06 ounces

0:37:21it's incredibly light it's incredibly

0:37:23comfortable and it feels like you were

0:37:24nothing at all but you hear the sound

0:37:26from the headphones and you also hear

0:37:27the sound around you which just can be

0:37:29very useful for practicality and safety

0:37:31reasons in various conditions and the

0:37:33best thing is there's nothing in your

0:37:34ear so if your ears hurt like mine do

0:37:37when you when you put in like regular

0:37:38earbuds you won't have this problem with

0:37:40the Trek's air because they're not

0:37:41resting in your ear or they're not

0:37:43squishing against your ear there

0:37:44resting next year with a very small

0:37:46contact patch so it's also ip55

0:37:48certified to repel sweat dust and

0:37:50moisture so it's very good for bad

0:37:52weather or workouts or anything like

0:37:54that battery life is great on these they

0:37:56have over six hours of battery life for

0:37:58continuous music and phone calls a

0:38:00twenty days standby time and they can

0:38:02charge fully in just two hours

0:38:04the tracks are also features EQ options

0:38:07so if you want a boost bass or reduce

0:38:09vibration you can do that there's of

0:38:11course microphones dual noise cancelling

0:38:13microphones to make incredibly clear

0:38:15phone calls with the new tracks air they

0:38:17are wonderful if you have any problems

0:38:18they are they have a two-year warranty I

0:38:20use the tracks air myself and I love

0:38:23them I absolutely love them they're

0:38:25wonderful for hearing the world around

0:38:27you which is something that most

0:38:28headphones really don't offer very well

0:38:30if at all with these they're great for

0:38:31if you're like walking outside and you

0:38:33want to hear so you don't get like hit

0:38:34by a car or something terrible like that

0:38:36or even more practical stuff like if

0:38:38you're in your house and you want to

0:38:39hear somebody knocks on the door or if

0:38:41your phone is ringing somewhere else

0:38:42it's very very useful check it out today

0:38:45ATP aftershocks calm and you can get $30

0:38:49off the treks air model which is the

0:38:51model I highly recommend ATP's of

0:38:53aftershocks comm code ATP 30 for $30 off

0:38:57the treks air thank you so much two

0:38:58aftershocks bone conduction headphones

0:39:00for sponsoring our show what do you guys

0:39:05think I know this has been very well

0:39:07covered especially on the talk show a

0:39:08few days ago but what do you guys think

0:39:10of the rumors of a potential MacBook Air

0:39:13update this this to me I think is

0:39:15potentially very interesting yeah I

0:39:17heard that was the talk show with the

0:39:20Jason us now Snell was on yeah Jason

0:39:21Snell and John Gruber were talking about

0:39:23that I kind of agree with Jason about

0:39:25his consternation of this like somehow

0:39:28we can't kill this laptop and I'm mostly

0:39:30I'm also coming at it from a sort of

0:39:32Apple should be embarrassed angle not so

0:39:34much of the MacBook Air is a bad machine

0:39:36but there's one part of the machine I

0:39:38think is inexcusable that's the screen

0:39:40now because it's not in retina like they

0:39:42made all the points in the show some

0:39:43people don't care about retina some

0:39:44people can't even see the difference but

0:39:46because it has such incredibly bad

0:39:48viewing angles brightness and color

0:39:51reproduction right it just it's just at

0:39:53this point when it was introduced fine

0:39:55at this point it is just a bad

0:39:57looks worse than basically any new PC

0:40:00laptop screen you could buy at any price

0:40:02we hold an honest question have you seen

0:40:04a 12-inch MacBook screen yeah sure

0:40:07because they like if you look at the 12

0:40:09inch compared to the other higher end

0:40:11ones the 12 inch screen is also

0:40:13noticeably worse at things like viewing

0:40:15angle color everything it's it's not a

0:40:16good screen but it's better than it's

0:40:18better than the air that's true I'll

0:40:20give you the head but but but it's not

0:40:22it's still like a crap screen it is not

0:40:24Oh a slowdown it is not a cracked screen

0:40:27wouldn't compare it to a MacBook Pro

0:40:29screen of an even the old ones I do that

0:40:32every day I know yeah the MacBook

0:40:35adorable one any day its retina so it's

0:40:38like way better than that but but I just

0:40:39I'm just saying for color reproduction

0:40:41of viewing it were a thing that Apple

0:40:42you surprised itself andhe they never

0:40:43really had crap monitors that they

0:40:44always had pretty much the best monitors

0:40:46and then they wouldn't let a really old

0:40:48monitor stay around for a long time that

0:40:49they would that they would refresh and

0:40:50they have been refreshing the MacBook

0:40:52Air like ripping out the you know

0:40:53changing the internals and everything

0:40:54like that but leaving that screen like

0:40:57it just it just boggles my mind because

0:40:59I feel like at this point I would never

0:41:02want to buy a thousand dollar laptop

0:41:03with that screen on it it seems

0:41:05inexcusable so if they had been updating

0:41:08the MacBook Air to keep it limping along

0:41:10on life support and had also updated the

0:41:12screen I would be like well this is not

0:41:13ideal but they're you know they found

0:41:16themselves in a weird place with their

0:41:17product line so let's see what they do

0:41:18with it like I think Jason and Gruber

0:41:21had a good analysis of that as they they

0:41:23somehow it's conceivable they somehow

0:41:25found themselves in the scenario where

0:41:26any move to replace it would result in

0:41:31reduced margins on one or both lines as

0:41:33the as the pyre shifted and then Tim

0:41:36Cook philosophy is like it if it ain't

0:41:38broke people are still giving us money

0:41:39for it don't fix it which is a terrible

0:41:41from a like coherent product line

0:41:43directive and if there is another live

0:41:44talk show with Apple executives on it I

0:41:46really hope John asks them there I hope

0:41:50you doesn't ask them because if you ask

0:41:51them it seems like your laptop line has

0:41:54no coherent story you can make like well

0:41:57the errors would be able to like blah

0:41:58blah blah and then you have the MacBook

0:41:59of people all you're doing is like wrist

0:42:01listing the pros and cons of your models

0:42:03but there there is no coherent story to

0:42:05the naming features or pricing of the

0:42:06current Apple laptop

0:42:07it is a mess and so I would state that

0:42:09and say you know that there's no

0:42:12coherent story to the naming features of

0:42:14pricing of your hub line why is that and

0:42:17if they want to contest that I would

0:42:18push back pretty hard to set con one of

0:42:20them is called air but it's not the

0:42:22lightest but it's super old it's got a

0:42:24mag safe on it but the element don't

0:42:25have MagSafe one's called macbook pro

0:42:26but it's got the internals of the air

0:42:28and it's your brain explodes so I think

0:42:32their line is in disarray and I think

0:42:34they can make I think the MacBook Air

0:42:37was a great model of laptop but that we

0:42:41have the technology now to make a line

0:42:44of computers that spans the exact same

0:42:46price range that offers a better

0:42:49computer at the thousand dollar price

0:42:50point than they current offer now and

0:42:52also there's a better computer at all

0:42:53the other ones and you know depending

0:42:55how you want to do it hey put on MagSafe

0:42:57and USB see you let people charge from

0:42:58both let's see which one people like

0:42:59better right because then you get the

0:43:01advantages of cases and his his switch

0:43:03charger and the advantage of you trip

0:43:04over my card you won't break it and you

0:43:06can maybe you can choose when you order

0:43:07it whether you want the MagSafe or not

0:43:08because maybe you just want to be able

0:43:10to use all your same chart anyway or put

0:43:11a SD card slot on the side of it of

0:43:14these computers or maybe you have an

0:43:15HDMI port on one model like I know I'm

0:43:17gonna live a crazy here but I long for

0:43:20the days when you could look at the line

0:43:22of Apple laptops and say I see how it

0:43:24goes

0:43:24big small low price high price lot not a

0:43:27lot of features a bunch of features and

0:43:29have them all look like a family and

0:43:31that's not the case not the case at all

0:43:35so one one

0:43:37I think curiosity that I that I had but

0:43:39thread the other nice discussion of it

0:43:41again I think listen to the talk show

0:43:42this week it's a really good discussion

0:43:44about this from a lot of different

0:43:45angles but one one thought I had was

0:43:48like if they make a retina MacBook Air

0:43:53if they literally change nothing else

0:43:56about it except a Retina screen and

0:43:58maybe replacing the two Thunderbolt 2

0:44:02ports it has I have one or two replacing

0:44:04its Thunderbolt 2 ports with USBC ports

0:44:06and then of course you know a modern

0:44:09chipset of the same type that we that's

0:44:11currently the MacBook Escape would

0:44:13anybody still buy the MacBook escape no

0:44:16like that that that's the problem we

0:44:19talked about if you improve the

0:44:21MacBook Air why would anyone buy a

0:44:23MacBook or MacBook why would I not know

0:44:24- sorry a MacBook Pro rather not a

0:44:26MacBook the MacBook escaped a 13-inch

0:44:28MacBook without touch bar is by many

0:44:32measures a MacBook Air it has the

0:44:34MacBook Air Class processors the MacBook

0:44:36Air Class chipset and everything else

0:44:37it's it's the same approximate size and

0:44:41weight it's a little bit you know it's

0:44:42slightly different but it roughly the

0:44:44same size and weight as the 13-inch

0:44:46MacBook Air but if you put it if you put

0:44:49a Retina screen in the old ancient

0:44:51MacBook Air body that was designed in

0:44:542010 I bet it would sell better than the

0:44:5713-inch MacBook Escape it would be a

0:44:59better laptop it has an SD card slot it

0:45:02has you know MagSafe the option for mac

0:45:05safe it has legacy USB ports which apple

0:45:08acknowledges is a thing that some people

0:45:09want otherwise they wouldn't have put

0:45:10them on the I of Mac Pro right yeah if

0:45:13you could show the regular person which

0:45:14one of these laptops do you think is

0:45:16better which one do you want and didn't

0:45:17tell them about the price and they

0:45:18weren't sensitive to styling cues that

0:45:20clearly indicate for the MacBook Air is

0:45:21super old right they would say oh that

0:45:23one's got more stuff it's got more

0:45:25features it's got more things and this

0:45:27magnet power cable is really smart right

0:45:29why should you ever pick the other one

0:45:31if we tell you guess what that one's

0:45:32three hundred dollars more you like well

0:45:34who would pay three hundred dollars more

0:45:35to have no ports on the side for a

0:45:37computer that is basically the same size

0:45:39and weight and it perceptibly seems

0:45:41thicker because it doesn't taper right

0:45:43like the MacBook Air is thicker on one

0:45:45end but thinner on the other but it

0:45:46seems smaller because it gets skinny

0:45:48just for the perception type thing like

0:45:49that that's the and and it's fine if

0:45:52they do that like if they want to remake

0:45:53their line and in that way you'd have to

0:45:56sort this type of thing out but instead

0:45:58they they leave it in the current

0:46:01scenario where the old one is clearly

0:46:03old that has serious downsides versus

0:46:06the regular one in terms of that

0:46:07terrible screen they have on it right

0:46:08the new one is expensive for no

0:46:11perceptible reason and you trade off a

0:46:12bunch of stuff and then they gets even

0:46:14more super expensive and you still don't

0:46:15get your ports back and you still have

0:46:17no magic say from the keyboard is weird

0:46:18and breaks all the time so they need to

0:46:21they need to do something I really want

0:46:22to just clean house on the laptop line

0:46:24and say all new line one nice family

0:46:28unified in appearance features and has a

0:46:30coherent ramp from from expensive than

0:46:32expensive and by the way at all

0:46:35point centered all sizes every one of

0:46:37them is better in some way whether it

0:46:38has more features or better reliability

0:46:40or you know faster or whatever yeah I I

0:46:44suspect we're gonna see some kind of

0:46:46major movement in the laptop line this

0:46:49year I really hope we do the current

0:46:52line has so many of these like weird

0:46:54issues not to mention you know some of

0:46:56the problems it has but like just like

0:46:57these like weird things about like that

0:46:59make it you know more or less compelling

0:47:01or seemingly weirdly priced in certain

0:47:03ways or really segmented in other ways

0:47:05like it needs help and I have a feeling

0:47:09Apple knew that two years ago at like

0:47:11shortly after it launched and I have a

0:47:13feeling they've work to fix it and so

0:47:15the only question is how they're fixing

0:47:17it and I don't expect this to be you

0:47:19know giving me all my hopes and dreams

0:47:20or anything but but I do expect change

0:47:23and hopefully improvement and so we'll

0:47:25see what that means speaking of hopes

0:47:27and dreams this is a tough question in

0:47:31the style these recent ones that to

0:47:32listeners have been sending us for the

0:47:34high end laptops which is where we're

0:47:36all shopping well you two are shopping

0:47:38cos I don't buy laptops I'm getting

0:47:40towards that point if you had to pick

0:47:43one port to add to the current crop of

0:47:49MacBook Pro ports I suspect the 15-inch

0:47:51MacBook Pro visit as the most would you

0:47:52can only pick one for your own personal

0:47:55purposes not for like what would make a

0:47:56better laptop for Apple to sell what

0:47:58would you pick on a 15-inch no question

0:48:01an SD card reader jay-z I'm torn between

0:48:06ancient USB and SD card reader

0:48:08I would probably h TM I would also be

0:48:11convenient I know I'm thinking I see and

0:48:14like to me like if you if it's less if

0:48:16it's not the 15-inch like if you ask me

0:48:18what what port I would add to the

0:48:19MacBook Escape it would be a third of

0:48:21anything like a third USB C port just

0:48:23one more of anything because that's what

0:48:25it most desperately needs like the 12 X

0:48:272 right yeah the same thing I would kill

0:48:28for a second USB C port in my but that's

0:48:31my big the 15 just just to see like you

0:48:33know you feel like there's enough USB

0:48:34seasoned on the 15 but you can add one

0:48:36more thing you know what would it be

0:48:38I I am very torn between SD between old

0:48:42USB and between HDMI but I think if I

0:48:44had to pick

0:48:45I think I would probably I would

0:48:48probably come down on SD card reader

0:48:49because I don't find a need for plugging

0:48:53in the Aged HDMI that often and I have a

0:48:55dongle for it I don't have a need for

0:48:57plugging in Legacy USB stuff that often

0:49:00and I have a dongle for it but I do have

0:49:03an SD card reader that I would like

0:49:04quite a lot but it would be more

0:49:06convenient to just be able to slot that

0:49:08thing right in the computer

0:49:09yeah it to me is like you can solve a

0:49:12lot like a lot of the annoyances of the

0:49:15new of the new laptop ports are solved

0:49:18by just having a lot of them like you

0:49:19know like when you have four of them

0:49:20well technically really you have three

0:49:22of them because one of them have a power

0:49:23plug in it but we know when you have

0:49:25three you pass through like your diiii I

0:49:29hear your point a hundred percent and

0:49:30you're in dongle town and it like okay

0:49:32regardless yeah I know well that's part

0:49:35of the problem were all landowners in

0:49:36dongle town my friend but I feel like

0:49:40you like the other ports you know you

0:49:42can you can fix a lot of the

0:49:43inconvenience of USB ceiling laptops

0:49:45with getting new cables for old devices

0:49:48like you can you can you can go on you

0:49:50know mana price grammars or whatever and

0:49:51get inexpensive cables that have USB C

0:49:54on one end and whatever your peripheral

0:49:56needs on the other end and you can just

0:49:57replace their cables and and you know

0:49:59there's some issues with hubs and

0:50:00multiplying those that I talked about

0:50:01before which is still annoying but but I

0:50:03feel like you can reduce a lot of the

0:50:04annoyance with just like new cables but

0:50:07if you if you need SD cards as part of

0:50:09your workflow there's no way to reduce

0:50:11that annoyance you're always gonna have

0:50:13like an SD card hanging out of the side

0:50:15of it through a cable or something like

0:50:16that's that sucks and when it's built in

0:50:18it sucks less so like other problems can

0:50:20be solved with either time or cabling

0:50:22choices or peripheral choices but not

0:50:25having an SD card reader if you use SD

0:50:27cards is always a pain so the reason I

0:50:30asked this question is because I've been

0:50:31thinking about it a lot lately and I can

0:50:33tell you if you if you surveyed all the

0:50:34people in my office at work they would

0:50:36all say HDMI because every time

0:50:38increasingly when we we land in a

0:50:40conference room and someone needs to

0:50:41project never mind the fact that they

0:50:43should really with the number of Macs

0:50:45and it's all of us they should really

0:50:46have Apple TVs connected to every single

0:50:47thing so we could airplay to them it

0:50:48would solve this problem in a much nicer

0:50:49way Steve Jobs would approve you don't

0:50:51need an HDMI port you just need to be

0:50:53able to airplay to everything I agree

0:50:54Steve but you can't fight the IT

0:50:57department anyway they would all save

0:50:59steam

0:50:59because it's so frustrating we all sit

0:51:00down there and it's like we look around

0:51:02for the one person with with the 2015

0:51:04laptop who can actually plug in because

0:51:06everyone forgot their dog and it used to

0:51:09be there was just one person with the

0:51:10new laptop and we would laugh at them

0:51:11and now there's like one person left

0:51:13with the old laptop and once the old

0:51:14laptop disappears just gonna be a bunch

0:51:16of people sitting around unable to

0:51:17project I don't understand why they

0:51:18don't put the adapters for this but

0:51:19anyway that's what people work would say

0:51:21but that's not what I would say because

0:51:22in my regular life if I was buying ops

0:51:23for myself I don't need to connect the

0:51:25HDMI so I never pick HDMI but work

0:51:27totally would I would have said in the

0:51:30past SD right because I do have cameras

0:51:33that have SD cards when I go on vacation

0:51:34I like to offload pictures from my

0:51:36camera to my thing without a dongle it's

0:51:38gonna be and build it in its small its

0:51:39skinny it'll fit fine but the more I've

0:51:41been thinking about it the more I've

0:51:42been getting attached to the idea of

0:51:45taking a 15-inch MacBook Pro and adding

0:51:47MagSafe and still having the ability to

0:51:50charge by any of the USB see things like

0:51:52not removing that ability but adding mag

0:51:55save as an addition because I feel like

0:51:57you get the twofer you get MagSafe which

0:51:59is better to trip over and stuff you get

0:52:01as I think it was a the Jason snow and

0:52:03maybe it was a Gruber saying you get the

0:52:05indicator light which i think is a

0:52:06useful feature when you have your

0:52:07clothes laptop and you plug in to make

0:52:08sure you see the little light that shows

0:52:10grip up amber or green show whether it's

0:52:12floyd charge Jerry's charging right yeah

0:52:14it's a great feature it's not like an

0:52:16Apple had that what fifteen years ago

0:52:18like it's not a new thing and left up

0:52:20this right and you also get one of your

0:52:23ports back now you really do have four

0:52:25ports instead of three if you want to be

0:52:27convenience if I just have USB C charger

0:52:29with me on vacation it could charge

0:52:30everything you've got it but also you

0:52:33could have the Mac safe and then the

0:52:34only question is what are you ship in

0:52:35the box you should MagSafe to ship USB

0:52:37or you should both and probably Apple

0:52:38would make you pick or something and I

0:52:40know are we backsliding and I know max

0:52:42they've had problems too and that's why

0:52:43I feel like ship them both let let

0:52:46people decide what they want to use how

0:52:48Apple can collect stats about what they

0:52:50use and anonymously send them back with

0:52:51its differential privacy for how often

0:52:53the laptops are charging via Mac save

0:52:55versus how often they're charging by a

0:52:57USB see I probably would get more

0:52:59benefit out of SD but I I'm finding the

0:53:03Toofer of getting a getting a port back

0:53:05and having the option of MagSafe

0:53:07irresistible and so now I'm envisioning

0:53:09before I was envisioning Apple

0:53:11it's laptops by adding an SD card slot

0:53:12and now envision them adding back Mac

0:53:14safe which i think is astronomical

0:53:16that's likely the netting SD card slot

0:53:17because it just it would be like egg on

0:53:19face of like Oh Romero MagSafe we're

0:53:21bringing it back that would be a tough

0:53:23sell whereas SD not there's so much room

0:53:26alongside the the edges of those 15-inch

0:53:28laptops right it's just a giant expanse

0:53:30with these two little tiny USBC holes an

0:53:33SD card slot even Johnny I could

0:53:35tolerate the Aesthetica marring of a

0:53:38very skinny discreet SD card slot in

0:53:40there how it looks fine on Marco's 2015

0:53:42MacBook Pro I think it would be fine on

0:53:45a by 2018 model one thing also they

0:53:48could do that that I think it probably

0:53:51goes against their sensibilities but but

0:53:53I think it probably shouldn't because I

0:53:55think it's one of the biggest

0:53:55engineering flops of the numa of new

0:53:57lineup is that the the number of USB

0:54:01like its it to me like one of the

0:54:03biggest problems with these as I've said

0:54:04numerous times is just there aren't

0:54:06enough ports like if you're going to

0:54:08sell us on an all USB see world ok we

0:54:11can adapt to that over time with dongles

0:54:13and stuff and new cables and everything

0:54:15there still aren't enough ports

0:54:16especially with one of them being lost

0:54:18to power as you said like you basically

0:54:20lose one during most practical usage for

0:54:23most people most of the time so you know

0:54:26like the MacBook Escape basically has

0:54:28one port Kasey's MacBook one has no

0:54:30ports pretty much so like and you know

0:54:34the and the 15-inch has three and if you

0:54:36look at and any no.13 pearls and if you

0:54:39look at like you know what the previous

0:54:41ones had like you could connect more

0:54:43than that amount of things to them

0:54:44without adapters and I feel like one of

0:54:48the if you look at the engineering

0:54:49behind this one of the challenges for

0:54:51example one of the reasons why the

0:54:52MacBook Escape only has two ports is

0:54:55because of limitations of how many

0:54:58Thunderbolt channels you can deliver

0:55:00because Apple decided to make all of

0:55:02these USB C ports also Thunderbolt three

0:55:05ports except for the morning KC's

0:55:07macbook one and that's a choice that

0:55:09they made they didn't have to it is

0:55:12possible to have a USB C port that does

0:55:15not support Thunderbolt 3 like the one

0:55:17in KC's might pick one hmm and so Apple

0:55:20no trust me this is in many ways a good

0:55:22thing it used me more of them and so hey

0:55:24I feel like you know one of the biggest

0:55:27ways to solve the the anoints these

0:55:28laptops is to use if you're gonna insist

0:55:30on USBC okay but we need more of them to

0:55:34total including your power hole is not

0:55:37enough if you can't make them on certain

0:55:40models if you can't make them full-blown

0:55:42Thunderbolt 3 ports which you already

0:55:45can't they're already not Thunderbolt 3

0:55:47the MacBook one and the ones on the

0:55:48right side of the 13-inch MacBook Pro

0:55:50are half bandwidth or whatever it is so

0:55:52there's already exceptions the cable

0:55:55that comes with it that charges from the

0:55:58brick to the computer is a USBC cable

0:56:00that is not a Thunderbolt cable in fact

0:56:03it's a USB 2.0 USBC cable which

0:56:05shouldn't even exist but they do and

0:56:08that's what it is

0:56:10you know there's already all these

0:56:12exceptions to what the ports can and

0:56:14can't do in addition Thunderbolt usage

0:56:16in practice is pretty low and it is not

0:56:21the common case what most people are

0:56:23plugging into these things it needs

0:56:25either just power or power and USB it's

0:56:29you know most of the peripherals being

0:56:31plugged into these ports do not need

0:56:32Thunderbolt 3 and so by Apple taking

0:56:35taking these ports on the on mostly

0:56:37stops except for Katie's and saying we

0:56:39can only have as many as a Thunderball

0:56:41controllers allow us to with this

0:56:42chipset or whatever that's very limiting

0:56:44to the number of ports you can have if

0:56:46they had if they had like you know two

0:56:49to four of them that could do

0:56:52Thunderbolt 3 and 2 more that couldn't

0:56:55maybe on the other side or whatever that

0:56:58you know that's not ideal but I think

0:57:02that's better than not having enough

0:57:03ports to do basic things that you need

0:57:05so I know be more complicated I know

0:57:08they wouldn't be able to put a little

0:57:09thunder bolt lightning bolt symbol next

0:57:11to all of them but I think that is the

0:57:14best compromise that we have if we're

0:57:16gonna do in all USBC world we need more

0:57:19of these ports and it is a waste to

0:57:22suggest that they all need to have

0:57:24thunder both three I mean look one of

0:57:25them most of the time is used for power

0:57:28and nothing else no data at all you're

0:57:32wasting Thunderbolt 3 bandwidth on a

0:57:33port that transfers nothing except power

0:57:37so like obviously like you know there's

0:57:39there's a there's a major engineering

0:57:41inefficiency in tying Thunderbolt 3 to

0:57:44USBC for all these laptops if you can

0:57:46separate them you could give us way more

0:57:47ports and when I weigh more you can give

0:57:50us a to more ports at least some close

0:57:51to these without having any bandwidth

0:57:53challenges you could give away more like

0:57:55they have they have USB inside these

0:57:56cases you could give you could give 6

0:57:58USB seaports along with 4 Thunderbolt

0:58:00ports like I felt like they have the

0:58:01controller capacity or space inside the

0:58:03case to put it controller they can

0:58:04support that like USB connections are

0:58:07cheap in the grand scheme of things yeah

0:58:09I mean it becomes I think more

0:58:10complicated like with like the wiring

0:58:12and stuff if if the other ones could

0:58:13also do some of the other alternate

0:58:15modes like if they can take power input

0:58:17or if they can do certain video output

0:58:19types but because I know Thunderbolts

0:58:21required for some of the alternate modes

0:58:23but not all of them or it is one of

0:58:24those Ramon's I don't know something

0:58:25like that but like tying this to

0:58:26Thunderbolt 3 made these ports very

0:58:30limited and in number and probably

0:58:32fairly expensive to implement but that

0:58:34was an unforced error they didn't need

0:58:36to do that I understand why they did but

0:58:38I think that was the wrong move and I

0:58:39hope they fix it ok a couple of things

0:58:42first of all you just said unforced

0:58:44error and to my ears it was the correct

0:58:46usage of the term and I'm really

0:58:48uncomfortable with my reality right now

0:58:50wait so I it's not a sports term because

0:58:52I learned it from John it is a sports

0:58:54term okay to me it's a Syracuse a term

0:58:57Wow well that and then now my reality is

0:58:59back to being reality so I appreciate

0:59:01that let's let's go on a adventure

0:59:05together a little mental exercise

0:59:06together it is 2016 or whatever year it

0:59:09was that the USBC MacBook Pros came out

0:59:12it doesn't matter what it was but

0:59:13whatever whenever they debuted it's that

0:59:15that year that moment and within a few

0:59:18weeks of each other the new MacBook Pros

0:59:20come out and let's pick on the 15

0:59:22specifically there's a new MacBook Pro

0:59:23it's 15 inches it has four USB C and

0:59:26thunderbolt ports simultaneously lenovo

0:59:29or dell or somebody else comes out with

0:59:31effectively the same thing as they are

0:59:33off to do and it has the same for

0:59:37physical USB C ports but only two of

0:59:40them are Thunderbolt do you know what

0:59:43the three of us would be doing at that

0:59:44moment we would be saying oh haha these

0:59:46idiot PC vendors now that you have to

0:59:48worry about whether or not you're

0:59:49plugging in to the right

0:59:51what a ridiculous mess that is we did we

0:59:53didn't say that on the MacBook we're

0:59:55with marketers point out it's a

0:59:56situation now where you have to know one

0:59:58side is special Neal that's been I think

0:59:58side is special Neal that's been I think

2:00:00background knowledge do I need to do my

2:00:04job

2:00:04well and what is the cost of me

2:00:07acquiring an apple in terms of time and

2:00:08money I think you said something smart a

2:00:11minute ago with regard to it becomes

2:00:14important when things fall apart you

2:00:17know in general in my experience like

2:00:19I'm a relatively novice iOS developer I

2:00:22mean I've been doing it casually for a

2:00:24fairly long time but I've only been

2:00:25doing it professionally for two years

2:00:26now and it's when things fall apart that

2:00:30I start really getting stressed and I

2:00:33have to start kind of reaching way

2:00:36outside my comfort zone trying to figure

2:00:37out what is broken and why and so I

2:00:42think in some ways if I was a more

2:00:45experienced developer I would get

2:00:46through these problems a lot more

2:00:48experienced iOS developer I would get

2:00:49through some of these problems more

2:00:50quickly but it's my experience in

2:00:53general as a developer and in general

2:00:55it's my experience of understanding most

2:00:56of the stack and in and that's what

2:00:59keeps me you know kind of level-headed

2:01:02and that's what gives me the the

2:01:03patience and tenacity to figure out a

2:01:05lot of these problems and I wish I had a

2:01:06specific example offhand and I and I

2:01:08don't which is good I guess because that

2:01:10means things haven't finally died

2:01:11recently but but you know I I do think

2:01:15it's valuable that that I have not only

2:01:18a CS background but a computer

2:01:19engineering background which to me is a

2:01:21combination of CS and electrical

2:01:23engineering and I'm sure a lot of people

2:01:24will take offense at that I don't care

2:01:25that's the way I look at it and when

2:01:28that means you know where where CS from

2:01:32my experience and I'm not trying to say

2:01:34this is fact this is just way I look at

2:01:36it CS tends to stop with code usually or

2:01:41maybe memory whereas computer

2:01:43engineering goes all the way down to

2:01:44logic gates and that isn't helpful in a

2:01:46day to day time but it is helpful just

2:01:49like John said a minute ago it's it's

2:01:50helpful to understand what at least

2:01:52vaguely what are all these abstractions

2:01:54and how do they relate to each other

2:01:56it demystifies it like it like you know

2:01:58I don't know the details of how

2:01:59anything's works but I know how a CPU

2:02:01works and I have built CPU from the

2:02:03logic you level up and I have built a

2:02:05logic gate with solid state electrical

2:02:07components and you know like that that

2:02:08whole thing it doesn't mean suddenly you

2:02:10know how your computer works but there's

2:02:12no more magic

2:02:13like you know from top to bottom you

2:02:15know the magic starts basically at the

2:02:16quantum level where my physics courses

2:02:18ran out like that's where the magic

2:02:19starts that's pretty long that's pretty

2:02:20low down everything else is like I'm not

2:02:22scared of it it doesn't seem magical the

2:02:24other thing I forgot to mention about

2:02:25having a background in the fundamentals

2:02:27is it also gates how high you can go so

2:02:32if you want to make an iOS application

2:02:35chances are good that you won't need any

2:02:39sort of in-depth knowledge about data

2:02:41structures and you know fundamental

2:02:43computer signs the algorithms or even

2:02:47things like neural networks and stuff

2:02:48like that because the frameworks do a

2:02:50lot for you and probably your

2:02:51application is not a complicated as you

2:02:53think it is like probably it's just a

2:02:54fairly basic application right but if

2:02:57you are building a more complicated

2:02:59application games are a great example

2:03:01because they employ a lot of things

2:03:02where you know the first approach that

2:03:05occurs to you is terrible and will work

2:03:06well that's the time where you're like

2:03:08if I had a background in computer

2:03:10science I might know some algorithms

2:03:13that would do this in a more efficient

2:03:15way if you don't have a background in

2:03:18that very often you will find like

2:03:20you'll find yourself deriving from first

2:03:23principles a sort of half-assed version

2:03:26of a well known algorithm like you you

2:03:28know I'm not saying you can figure it

2:03:30out yourself but it's like you're

2:03:31wasting your own time if you just had a

2:03:33background in data structures and

2:03:35algorithms you would have immediately

2:03:36narrowed down to a couple of choices and

2:03:38maybe recall off the top of your head

2:03:40the big o-notation for all these

2:03:42different things and known which one

2:03:44works best and then just you know you

2:03:47know implemented that yourself most of

2:03:49the time again most time you don't have

2:03:50to do this most time libraries implement

2:03:51these things for you if you have some

2:03:52sort of associative array or dictionary

2:03:55or hash structure or NS array under the

2:03:57covers is doing all sorts of smart

2:03:58things with all sorts of smaller

2:03:59algorithms switching from hash buckets

2:04:01to a linear search when the size it

2:04:03dictates that it's smart like you don't

2:04:04have to know what that the magic happens

2:04:05behind the scenes for you but if you are

2:04:06building a structure like that yourself

2:04:08to manage your own data again maybe in

2:04:10games where efficiency is paramount it

2:04:12really really helps to have that

2:04:14background knowledge so not just

2:04:17figuring out the lower layers above you

2:04:19but being able to do for yourself the

2:04:21things that for most developers are done

2:04:23for them by the frameworks in the OS and

2:04:25everything

2:04:26give you the ability to do more

2:04:28complicated things and if you don't have

2:04:31that background you can still do it but

2:04:33you will essentially be figuring out

2:04:35things that people figured out tens or

2:04:37hundreds of years ago as you derive from

2:04:39first principles basic old mathematical

2:04:40concepts and data structures which works

2:04:42fine but it's it takes more time there

2:04:46is a truly phenomenal series of YouTube

2:04:49videos that PBS made in association with

2:04:52I think a few other groups

2:04:53it's called crash course computer

2:04:54science and Mike and I talked about this

2:04:57a little bit on analogue and we were

2:04:59trying to do like a you know we'll watch

2:05:01one each week and it turns out that it's

2:05:03it's not very entertaining as a podcast

2:05:05but I cannot recommend enough watching

2:05:08this series there's 40 videos of which

2:05:11each of them is like 10 to 15 minutes

2:05:13and it brings you from the abacus all

2:05:17the way to modern computing and I've

2:05:19only watched the first maybe quarter of

2:05:21them but it is step by step going from

2:05:24an abacus all the way up to cloud

2:05:27computing and machine learning and stuff

2:05:28like that and what you learn by watching

2:05:31these even if you don't totally

2:05:32understand the the ins and outs of what

2:05:35they're talking about the thing that I

2:05:38think is most important that you can

2:05:39glean from these videos is that

2:05:41everything is just one abstraction on

2:05:44top of another and it's abstractions all

2:05:46the way down and it is impressive and

2:05:49fascinating to see this broken out in 40

2:05:53different chunks in little bite-sized

2:05:55pieces and you see like especially once

2:05:57you get into like how memory actually

2:06:00works and how you know these logic gates

2:06:01are held together ever put together I

2:06:03should say in order to make memory even

2:06:06I sort of kind of have my eyes glaze

2:06:09over a little bit but the point that I'm

2:06:12that that you get from this isn't

2:06:13necessarily that oh you need you know 13

2:06:15NAND gates or whatever in order to you

2:06:17know store eight bytes of data and I'm

2:06:19obviously making this all up but the

2:06:21point is just that oh you take a bunch

2:06:23of transistors hook them up that makes

2:06:25gates you take a bunch of gates hook

2:06:27them up that makes memory you take a

2:06:28bunch of memory hook it up that makes a

2:06:30hole you know water or block of memory

2:06:32and it's just you you build upon what

2:06:35happened before you so if you happen to

2:06:37have roughly 400 to 500

2:06:40minutes to spare I cannot recommend

2:06:41crash course computer science enough and

2:06:43we'll put a link in the show notes

2:06:44well I'm behind an analog so you Mike

2:06:47just bailed on that yeah we did I knew

2:06:49that already

2:06:50that's disappointing I was excited for

2:06:51that series I was too I couldn't get him

2:06:53to get into it I tried and I don't blame

2:06:56him like it the problem I think he

2:06:57enjoyed it to some degree but there

2:06:59isn't a lot for us to say about it

2:07:01because there's little interpretation

2:07:02involved right and and that's that's the

2:07:05bummer behind it but I really I hope

2:07:08that he why he won't but I hope that he

2:07:10watches it he's just not that into

2:07:12computers well he'd use he uses a fake

2:07:14computer all the time what do you expect

2:07:16yeah can you make them a video series

2:07:17called how iPads work and maybe yeah

2:07:20open it up it's just a bunch of unicorns

2:07:22and elves dancing around well just two

2:07:27at a time one maybe hovering over