Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

264: Every Building Has Bugs

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

1:00:00and Linode is incredibly fast for what

1:00:03you get you have native SSD storage a 40

1:00:05gigabit network backing at all and

1:00:07everything is running on Intel Xeon e5

1:00:09processors Linode is top tier the web

1:00:12hosting business I use them for all my

1:00:14stuff and I've been there for geez I

1:00:17think I think almost a decade now I'm

1:00:19very happy at Linode and they have all

1:00:21sorts of wonderful features backups node

1:00:22balancers long view for stats you can do

1:00:25so much stuff with your Linode server

1:00:27you can run docker containers you can

1:00:29have encrypted disk you can use block

1:00:30storage you run a VPN or of course I

1:00:32need web application that you might want

1:00:33to run check it out today at lynda.com

1:00:35slash ATP see for yourself how good

1:00:38Linode is again there's a 7 day

1:00:40money-back guarantee if you have any

1:00:41concerns or it doesn't work out for you

1:00:43so there's really nothing to lose so try

1:00:44it out today Linode comm slash ATP use

1:00:47code ATP 2018 for a $20 credit that

1:00:50could be for months on that one gig plan

1:00:52for just 5 bucks a month check out today

1:00:54thank you so much to Linode for

1:00:55sponsoring our show there's been some

1:01:01interesting news coming out of Apple

1:01:02Park you know previously known as Apple

1:01:05Campus 2 it seems that it's a hazardous

1:01:08place to work and it seems that people

1:01:10are running into glass walls I don't

1:01:14even know where the genesis of this

1:01:16story was but apparently somebody has a

1:01:18mast I've seen a link at some point

1:01:20somebody has amassed 911 calls that

1:01:23relate to people walking into the glass

1:01:25walls at Apple Park or something like

1:01:27that

1:01:27what's going on here I mean this is a

1:01:30problem that almost every office

1:01:34building that does a glass design or a

1:01:36glass redesign has at some point I mean

1:01:41like when I remember when I interviewed

1:01:43as I was job seeking for the job that

1:01:46eventually ended up being tumblr back in

1:01:492006 I had an interview of Bloomberg and

1:01:52here in New York and they had all glass

1:01:55everywhere and it was very very hard for

1:01:57me to navigate that office like I

1:01:59couldn't fly like like look around the

1:02:01rooms like fine like where's the door

1:02:03out of the room I am in like you had to

1:02:05really look hard to see like which of

1:02:07these walls is a door actually it was

1:02:09very very strange I was part of the

1:02:11interview process this part of the test

1:02:13god I failed so many tests in that

1:02:14interview I felt every test including

1:02:16try to escape the room but anyway and I

1:02:21remember it was a fairly moderate like

1:02:24the building was fairly young at that

1:02:26point and I remember a few the employees

1:02:27telling me that they had to install rows

1:02:31of logo stickers at eye level on all the

1:02:34glass because people kept running into

1:02:36it now as this story has played out

1:02:39today with Apple Park we've heard so

1:02:42many like Twitter responses and people

1:02:44in the chat talking about it about like

1:02:46how this happens in like every office

1:02:48building that that does that goes with

1:02:50all glass for all the walls inside like

1:02:51people always earns them all the time

1:02:53and they always have to end up you know

1:02:55installing some kind of sticker or

1:02:56something you know to make the glass not

1:02:58transparent in a really obvious eye

1:03:00level place so the fact that people are

1:03:04running into glass with apparently no

1:03:06decoration or insufficient decoration on

1:03:08it is not surprising at all that is I

1:03:11think it's a well proven thing that that

1:03:13happens so that isn't surprising at all

1:03:16it the only surprising part of this to

1:03:18me and and the kind of sad part is like

1:03:20did they not know this would happen it

1:03:23this is not a new thing that happens in

1:03:25glass buildings like surely someone had

1:03:28to have told Johnny I've super along the

1:03:30design of this like someone had to have

1:03:33mentioned this like so how did this come

1:03:35how does this how does the building get

1:03:38designed with this ignored that that's

1:03:40what I want to know like again it's like

1:03:41it's almost like the home pod brain

1:03:42thing it's like did they not know like I

1:03:44don't know it it's concerning either way

1:03:46like they should have known and this is

1:03:49again this is a small thing this is not

1:03:51I mean the only reason we're talking

1:03:53about this is because we just fell on

1:03:54the last topic and yeah it's too late to

1:03:56start a new big topic right now

1:03:57so you know this is not a huge topic

1:04:00this is not a huge deal

1:04:01just like the home pod ring not a huge

1:04:03deal but just kind of an embarrassing

1:04:05story that like the the interesting and

1:04:09worrisome part about it is not the

1:04:11actual thing that is happening but that

1:04:14it seems to indicate a pretty

1:04:16substantial failure in process along the

1:04:18way like why didn't they foresee this

1:04:22this is not a new problem everyone who's

1:04:24ever designed or

1:04:26worked in glass office buildings

1:04:27probably knows about this problem so why

1:04:30didn't they accommodate for it here but

1:04:32it looks so nice that's that's really

1:04:35part of it like so every every building

1:04:39has bugs it's not like a software thing

1:04:41but every building especially new

1:04:44buildings large complexes they have bugs

1:04:45whether it's like a particular way that

1:04:49it was constructed that wears out sooner

1:04:51than you thought or people walk in a

1:04:53path that you didn't expect and so you

1:04:55got to move some things around or sight

1:04:57lines that you didn't expect to be a

1:04:59problem when the Sun is at a particular

1:05:00angle and reflects off this particular

1:05:01thing goes into this person's eyes or

1:05:03whatever like but buildings have bugs

1:05:05and so you weren't you expect there's

1:05:06gonna be stuff like that in every

1:05:07building but as you said mark out like

1:05:10for the glass stuff it's not an

1:05:12unforeseen thing and it's not an

1:05:13emergent property of a complex system

1:05:15it's they varied overly picked materials

1:05:18and they didn't just use them a little

1:05:19bit like this is a glass heavy building

1:05:22tremendously glass I feel like it sounds

1:05:24like the Bloomberg thing was it's not

1:05:25like you're just using it as an

1:05:26interface element along with everything

1:05:29else it's very heavily used like the

1:05:31largest pieces of glass in the world are

1:05:33here and it does look really good and

1:05:37like I was tempted to say this is

1:05:39another example of like you know form

1:05:41over function where if I think when we

1:05:43talked about this building for I said I

1:05:45didn't have confidence that Johnny I've

1:05:47really understood what it took to make a

1:05:49functional building although I knew he

1:05:51would make a beautiful one and this

1:05:52might call into that category but I

1:05:54think there is actually a functional

1:05:55aspect to all this glass which is part

1:05:57of the part of the utility of the

1:05:59building is not just you know can you

1:06:02find all the places you want to go very

1:06:04well is there room for everything is the

1:06:06air circulate well all those sort of

1:06:07like what makes good user nice on a

1:06:10building but aesthetics actually are

1:06:12part of like any product but perhaps

1:06:13even more so for a building allowing a

1:06:15natural light in being inspired by the

1:06:17views feeling like you're you know

1:06:19inside indoors outdoors with like a

1:06:21complete glass thing from floor to

1:06:22ceiling gives a different feeling than

1:06:24it would if it was just a window in a

1:06:25wall right so there is I think a

1:06:27functional aspect to all of this glass

1:06:29and unfortunately a lot of the solutions

1:06:31that fix this problem like the stickers

1:06:34at eye level or whatever fly in the face

1:06:37of all the advantages that you're

1:06:38getting you

1:06:39don't feel like you're you're outdoors

1:06:41indoors type of thing when your

1:06:43beautiful wall of glass is marred by a

1:06:45bunch of Apple stickers Johnny I would

1:06:46have a heart attack if you're just a

1:06:47bunch of apple stickers all of these

1:06:49things well that's what they're doing in

1:06:50some cases is like putting you know tape

1:06:52or anything else like it's just it's

1:06:54gaudy it breaks up the appearance that

1:06:56you want it kills the illusion of

1:06:59transparency of the glass it makes

1:07:02everything uglier and worse like I was

1:07:04thinking they do it like they do in the

1:07:06diving pool in the Olympics where they

1:07:08have a constant spray of water agitating

1:07:10the surface so you can see where the

1:07:11surface of the water is you know for the

1:07:12diver as they come down they just

1:07:14something should have constant sprays of

1:07:15water onto the onto the walls and to do

1:07:17some one of those glass waterfall

1:07:19effects without kind of ruined rim the

1:07:21aesthetic as well so I don't know what

1:07:23the solution this is because I kind of

1:07:26understand that the glass stuff is not

1:07:30just an aesthetic so the building looks

1:07:32pretty I really do believe it probably

1:07:34enhances the experience of being in the

1:07:36building in an important way right for

1:07:39the people in the building not the

1:07:40people outside looking at it but I mean

1:07:45maybe there was a little bit of wishful

1:07:46thinking in terms of all right so we

1:07:49know this is a problem we know people

1:07:51run into glass a lot but after a

1:07:53breaking-in period eventually people

1:07:57will develop the flint reflexes or

1:07:59something like people people will will

1:08:00adjust their daily paths to not do this

1:08:03it'll become more aware or this door the

1:08:05people keep running into will make sure

1:08:06we keep it open 24 hours a day to make

1:08:08sure it's not a factor anymore I think

1:08:09they might have been optimistic about

1:08:10how much people will eventually adjust

1:08:13to it and we'll see maybe maybe they

1:08:14don't know you know what they should do

1:08:16when you first walk into the building

1:08:18just slide it a little splash screen

1:08:20tells people hey just so you know

1:08:22there's glass everywhere watch out walk

1:08:24with your hands straight out in front of

1:08:26you yeah so and probably know maybe they

1:08:30will get used to it like this is this is

1:08:31the growing pains of this building its

1:08:32early days maybe people will eventually

1:08:34get used to it

1:08:35but if they don't the solution I think

1:08:39if you want to keep the glasses I think

1:08:42what you have to do is change the non

1:08:45glass parts of the building to

1:08:47essentially herd people to the openings

1:08:51right

1:08:52so you want you want the building to

1:08:55guide you like it should be less work to

1:08:58just go when the building wants you to

1:08:59go and you should find yourself coming

1:09:01to the place where the door is and the

1:09:04door hopefully will have a handle in it

1:09:05so you see that yes this is the place

1:09:07where the door is right you want like

1:09:09the idea of just having a giant

1:09:10expansive glass that sometime is open

1:09:12and sometimes is closed that's like

1:09:13three football fields wide like the

1:09:15cafeteria doors strikes me as a bad idea

1:09:17because there's no hurting of anybody

1:09:19and when the door is closed it looks

1:09:21just like it's open like you know so I

1:09:23think if you want to keep the glass you

1:09:25have to you have to make the building

1:09:27accommodate to us and maybe that's

1:09:29exactly what they've been trying to do

1:09:30everywhere and they just missed a couple

1:09:31spots in that case they just ad need to

1:09:33like rearrange the furniture and put a

1:09:35different pattern on the floor and do

1:09:36all those of the tricks that sort of

1:09:37subtly guide you to where you where the

1:09:40building wants you to go and flow with

1:09:42the traffic especially with large groups

1:09:43of people like it's easy for like one or

1:09:45two people on a house to guide people

1:09:46around but in a giant campus you have to

1:09:49have large apertures to accommodate you

1:09:51know hundreds of thousands of people

1:09:52going to and from lunch or whatever and

1:09:54that is the that's that's the challenge

1:09:56they face I really really hope the

1:09:59eventual solution is not to put a bunch

1:10:01of bloomberg stickers and I love all

1:10:02residents will be weird dead lumpur

1:10:04stickers on Apple's campus because that

1:10:06is just they're just designed failure on

1:10:08all levels it's aesthetically gross and

1:10:10it just it ruins all the benefits that

1:10:14you're supposedly getting from the glass

1:10:15so here's how you do this hold the glass

1:10:19at exactly a 78 degree angle get a can

1:10:22of compressed air turn the can upside

1:10:24down like and spread the constant spray

1:10:27of water just a constant spray of

1:10:28compressed air going on the glass that

1:10:30fogs it up and lets you see all of them

1:10:31or they can do what they do then the ski

1:10:34jumps where they put pine boughs and

1:10:35everything they just you ever see them

1:10:36where they go to the back flips off the

1:10:38ski jump at the Olympics they don't want

1:10:39the slope that they land on to be

1:10:40completely wiped is that I can't again

1:10:42they can't do depth perception to see

1:10:43where it is when they flip to the air so

1:10:44they put like dirt and and other

1:10:46dark-colored junk all over it at least

1:10:49that would be natural it's just just a

1:10:50bunch of pine needles stuck to the

1:10:52windows what if they use like like kind

1:10:54of like fiber-optic style like light

1:10:55guide lighting in the glass panes so

1:10:58that all the panes of glass can eat like

1:11:00each department can pick a different

1:11:01like neon color that all their glass

1:11:03will be lit with all right I got it

1:11:06perfectly not that we're gonna

1:11:07transition to accidental neutral quite

1:11:09at this point but they need driver aids

1:11:11right so if you are approaching if you

1:11:13are approaching a glass wall to speed

1:11:15they feel a collision is imminent the

1:11:17glass wall should change to like in one

1:11:19of those transparent LCD screens and say

1:11:21warning stop wall is in front of you

1:11:23goodness so there's some transcripts on

1:11:26the San Francisco Chronicle website

1:11:28dispatcher tell me exactly what happened

1:11:30patient I walked into a glass door in

1:11:33the first floor of Apple Park when I was

1:11:34trying to go outside which was very

1:11:36silly

1:11:37dispatcher you keep breaking up you

1:11:39walked through a glass door patient I

1:11:41didn't walk through a glass door I

1:11:42walked into a glass door yeah speaking

1:11:47of those big glass doors like the I

1:11:49guess the cafeteria doors though forever

1:11:51like the the the eating place I'm sure

1:11:53they don't call it a cafeteria because

1:11:54that's not fancy enough but like has

1:11:56like what four story or three story high

1:11:58glass doors that way some astronomical

1:12:00amount right and they they slide open

1:12:03like barn doors and they're just huge

1:12:06expanses of glass and I was thinking

1:12:08about this about a month ago looking at

1:12:10the pictures of really you know the for

1:12:11the final building being constructed now

1:12:14I'm sure this building have me haven't

1:12:15been constructing California has all

1:12:17sorts of like earthquake readiness stuff

1:12:19built into it because surely the codes

1:12:20require that and surely Apple would do

1:12:22that right and they consider the

1:12:23possibility that these doors cause

1:12:25earthquakes when they open they're very

1:12:27simple it's very it's very well

1:12:29lubricated mechanism it's almost

1:12:30noiseless it's beautiful but and I know

1:12:34glass bends right but these are very

1:12:37large very heavy pieces of glass and

1:12:40probably the last place I would want to

1:12:41be during an earthquake is near one of

1:12:44these giant sheets of glass because I

1:12:46don't want a chunk of glass falling from

1:12:49four stories up onto my head to run a

1:12:51house budgets like safety grass and

1:12:53breaks into small pieces or just from

1:12:54the sheer weight like forget about

1:12:56sharpness pretended to stay completely

1:12:57dull because it's safety glass and

1:12:59breaks into small pieces it's like a

1:13:01clear Rock landing on your head from

1:13:03four stories up which i think is a you

1:13:06know maybe also problem in skyscrapers

1:13:08were in you're on the outside of them

1:13:09like the glass shatters or whatever and

1:13:11falls down under the street and kills

1:13:12people but it just I would love to know

1:13:15exactly what the earthquake mitigation

1:13:19techniques were to make it safe to have

1:13:21four stories of like inch-and-a-half

1:13:23nate thick glass like 17 tons of it just

1:13:26sitting where people could be right next

1:13:29to it people could literally be touching

1:13:30it or in the process of walking to it at

1:13:32the time it starts to wobble and parts

1:13:34of it crack off and fall down to the

1:13:35ground so seems a little bit scary to me

1:13:38we respond to this week by betterment

1:13:41rethink what your money can do visit

1:13:43betterment comm slash ATP for more

1:13:45information

1:13:46betterment is the largest independent

1:13:48online financial advisor designed to

1:13:51help improve customers long-term returns

1:13:53and lower your taxes for retirement

1:13:55planning building wealth and your other

1:13:57financial goals betterment takes

1:13:59advanced investment strategies and user

1:14:01technologies to deliver them to more

1:14:03than 300,000 customers based on the

1:14:06information you tell them they make

1:14:07tailored recommendations for how much to

1:14:09invest how much risk to take on and the

1:14:11types of investment accounts you should

1:14:13have betterments experts have your back

1:14:16they believe you should be able to get

1:14:18financial advice anytime anywhere so all

1:14:21customers can receive a device from

1:14:22veterans team of licensed financial

1:14:24experts through their mobile apps

1:14:25messaging feature any time and

1:14:27betterment is a fiduciary this means

1:14:30they don't get commissions for

1:14:31recommending certain funds and they

1:14:33don't have any funds of their own they

1:14:34just do what they believe is right for

1:14:36you and they bring you all this with

1:14:38very low transparent advisory fees

1:14:40compared to traditional services with

1:14:43only a 0.25 percent annual fee that

1:14:46includes unlimited messaging access to

1:14:48their team of licensed financial experts

1:14:50if you have a more complex financial

1:14:52situation betterment Premium gives you

1:14:54unlimited phone call access to their

1:14:55team of certified financial planners for

1:14:58only 0.4% annually and bedroom it can

1:15:01give you a clear view of your net worth

1:15:03and all of your assets when you sync

1:15:05your asset accounts if you want - such

1:15:06as bank accounts and other investments

1:15:08they can show you how much you're

1:15:09outside brokerage accounts and maybe

1:15:11costing you in fees and under invested

1:15:13cash as well investing involves risk

1:15:16listeners can get up to one year managed

1:15:18free for more information visit

1:15:20betterment comm slash ATP that's

1:15:22betterment comm slash ATP thank you to

1:15:25Behrman for sponsoring our show

1:15:30so let's do some ask ATP vamsee writes

1:15:33they would apparently like to know all

1:15:35sorts of rules protocol and strategies

1:15:39with regard to windowing in our cars so

1:15:42first how do you use the windows in your

1:15:44car always closed always open I will

1:15:47start and we'll do a round robin I tend

1:15:49to leave the windows and the doors

1:15:52closed almost always unless it is a

1:15:54particularly nice day in which case they

1:15:57will usually be opened all the way it is

1:16:00very rare that I have anything but a

1:16:01binary treatment of my windows one

1:16:03example of when they are cracked however

1:16:04which is very rare is if I have any sort

1:16:07of food in the car in which case I will

1:16:10try to ventilate the outside air by

1:16:12cracking the windows and we will get to

1:16:15Sun roofs in a Sun in a moment so John

1:16:18how do you use the windows in your car

1:16:20does your car have a sunroof I don't

1:16:21recall no can't because I've had to

1:16:23remember that well I thought I knew you

1:16:25preferred not I couldn't remember if it

1:16:26did or not nope ok so with your windows

1:16:30windows I'm almost always an always

1:16:32closed person mostly for two reasons one

1:16:36yes the hair mussing because it is a

1:16:38real thing like if I have my windows

1:16:41open and I show up at work my hair will

1:16:42be crazy yep and to most of the cars

1:16:47that I've owned have required a complex

1:16:50series of baffles to not have weird

1:16:52thrumming noises you got to have

1:16:53alternative windows open one on one side

1:16:55one on the other front end stuff like

1:16:57that it doesn't make for a pleasing

1:17:00auditory environment even if I don't

1:17:02care about my hair so I'm an all clothes

1:17:03person most of the time

1:17:05all right Marco most of the time they're

1:17:09closed because most of the time the

1:17:11temperature outside is not pleasant in

1:17:13one direction or the other

1:17:14but when the temperature outside is

1:17:16pleasant and if I'm if I'm at low speeds

1:17:19like around town like not on the highway

1:17:21I'll open a window here and there

1:17:23sometimes I will just crack the window

1:17:24to feel the cool air cleanse my every

1:17:27pore as I pour my poor heart out but

1:17:29usually I will just open one either all

1:17:31the way or not at all

1:17:32I don't know that song I didn't

1:17:34reference KZ no I did not I could tell

1:17:36it was a reference I had no idea what it

1:17:38was was it is it fish can't be Fisher's

1:17:40too many words No

1:17:41all right and the follow-up of course is

1:17:43how to use the sunroof and then vamsee

1:17:45adds this I really don't get just got a

1:17:47car with one Australian summers boiling

1:17:49so I haven't had a chance to open it

1:17:51again I will start and we'll do another

1:17:54round robin I love my sunroof I will

1:17:57open it in truly absurd well maybe not

1:18:00absurd but in temperatures where I

1:18:01probably shouldn't have a ton sunroof

1:18:02open so as soon as it hits about 50

1:18:04degrees Fahrenheit and I don't care what

1:18:06that isn't Celsius because Celsius is

1:18:07stupid for ambient air temperature don't

1:18:09at me whatever 50 degrees is in stupid

1:18:12units I will start opening my sunroof

1:18:14from time to time and it will be open

1:18:17pretty much until it hits about 80

1:18:20degrees and that's about when I decide

1:18:21that air conditioning is absolutely

1:18:23required and there's no other way about

1:18:25it Marco let's start with you this time

1:18:27I use the sunroof during the winter a

1:18:31lot during spring and fall sometimes and

1:18:33during summer not at all because I

1:18:35believe I previously mentioned I don't

1:18:37have that much hair and I get a head

1:18:38burn really easily if it gets a lot of

1:18:40Sun I keep a hat in my car for mainly

1:18:42for the purpose of being able to use my

1:18:44sunroof but in the summertime sometimes

1:18:47I just don't want to have the liability

1:18:50of the hat blowing off and so I I get a

1:18:53lot of sunroof use in the cooler

1:18:55temperatures when when sunburn is less

1:18:58likely or less of a bless of a concern

1:19:01one of the favorite one of my favorite

1:19:04things to do with the sunroof is to open

1:19:05it during the winter because you could

1:19:08have the heat on in the car but have the

1:19:11sunroof partially or totally open so

1:19:14much for saving the environment am i

1:19:15right compared to what your car is

1:19:18burning compared to what my car is

1:19:19burning I think so I'm turning on the

1:19:21heat and then opening the sunroof well

1:19:23and so and you can also do things like

1:19:25you know just use like the heated seat

1:19:26but not use the air heating so you are

1:19:29kept warm but you have fresh air so

1:19:32there's lots of options of combining the

1:19:33sunroof with heat or you know the lack

1:19:37of heat in the car but is a very

1:19:39pleasant thing to have fresh air coming

1:19:42in but to not be freezing your butt off

1:19:45in the winter that to me is the best

1:19:48reason to have a sunroof is is the use

1:19:49of it in the wintertime I will say that

1:19:52a that a good solid floor he

1:19:54with the with the ventilated roof is a

1:19:56nice thing I don't usually do that it's

1:19:59not something I enjoy often but you know

1:20:02having the heat coming up from the floor

1:20:03rising up and then escaping out the

1:20:05sunroof is actually quite pleasant John

1:20:08if you had a sunroof hypothetically do

1:20:11you ever fancy a time that you would use

1:20:13it my parents cars have had them so I've

1:20:17had them enough to know whether I use

1:20:19them and basically I treated like a

1:20:21window in general no I don't want it

1:20:22open for the same reasons hair mussing

1:20:24and throwing noises I don't and now that

1:20:27my hair is thinning on top I'd probably

1:20:28have the same problem with with head

1:20:31burn so I think I would probably not use

1:20:34it even if I had it head burn is not fun

1:20:36as someone who is far and away the

1:20:39fussiest about his hair I can tell you

1:20:41that I can rock the sunroof reasonably

1:20:44frequently without worrying about my

1:20:46hair getting too messed up whereas that

1:20:48is not typically true with the side

1:20:50windows if I open them more than just a

1:20:52crack

1:20:52you got more product in your hair than I

1:20:54do though oh it's pretty much welded at

1:20:56this point there's so much junk in there

1:20:58you know for if anybody out there feels

1:21:01bad for me that I don't have good hair

1:21:03just know that I don't have to worry

1:21:05about any of that BS like my hair cannot

1:21:09be messed up it's glorious I can I can

1:21:12leave all the windows down and this

1:21:14hundred of open and drive on the highway

1:21:17and yet just tons of wind to the point

1:21:20where like if I have like a loose tissue

1:21:22in the back of my car it might blow out

1:21:24the window so I have to like make sure I

1:21:26like everything is like anchored down in

1:21:29the vehicle but I can I can drive in

1:21:31pure wind like that which is awesome in

1:21:34the summertime when you drive a nice to

1:21:35the beach by the way and it's wonderful

1:21:37and I guess where I'm going and my hair

1:21:40isn't messed up because it can't be it's

1:21:42amazing I go to the shower and it's dry

1:21:44like it's done I just walk out of the

1:21:47bathroom it's wonderful like so yeah

1:21:50don't feel bad for me as these two were

1:21:52talking about comparing the amount of

1:21:54product in their hair and and how they

1:21:55can't enjoy wind movement because it

1:21:58might mess up their hair that's only for

1:22:00going to work I'm glad you broke the

1:22:01beach Beach is the one time where I do

1:22:03open windows and I probably

1:22:04a sunroof just to smell the beach air

1:22:07and because no one should ever care

1:22:08where the hair looks like when they're

1:22:09going to or from the beach and I don't

1:22:10fair enough

1:22:12and finally when do you turn your

1:22:13recirculation on or recirculating the

1:22:16the air conditioning I don't typically

1:22:19mess with this unless there is an odor

1:22:21or I'm in a hurry to get the the car

1:22:24either colder or warmer my car does have

1:22:28an automatic recirculation feature I

1:22:30have no idea if that's like a complete

1:22:32placebo or if it actually does you know

1:22:34flip recirculation on and off and so

1:22:37typically I just leave that on but in in

1:22:39Prior cars I would only ever really turn

1:22:41recirculation on if I was in a real big

1:22:44hurry to reach the temperature I wanted

1:22:46John I think it's your turn now I am a

1:22:48manual control even though my car has

1:22:51automatic climate control I have manual

1:22:53control or I'm a micro manager of

1:22:55climate controls and recirculation

1:22:56different i preemptively turn it on when

1:22:59I know I'm going to be coming to a stop

1:23:01behind a smoker because smokers are

1:23:02disgusting and flickers dependent other

1:23:04windows which they leave cracked open so

1:23:06we're the entire world can enjoy their

1:23:07stupid smoke and then they flick the

1:23:09cigarette that their have done without

1:23:10the window to I put three Sark on again

1:23:14preemptively when I'm you know gonna be

1:23:16stopped behind a big truck that's

1:23:18spewing its stinky exhaust basically I

1:23:19mean I know there's going to be an order

1:23:21from the outside I turned on and the the

1:23:24final time that I do it is yeah in the

1:23:26summer when I want to get the car cooler

1:23:28faster but only after I allow enough

1:23:30fresh air in so the inside and outside

1:23:31temperatures are equalized and in the

1:23:33winter when my cars when my cars pour

1:23:36heating system I can't keep up can't

1:23:40like literally can't make the car warm

1:23:42enough because it is so freakin cold

1:23:43that the air coming out of the vents

1:23:46gets appreciably warmer when I put

1:23:48recirc on like in the really cold spell

1:23:51that we have are it's like below zero

1:23:52for several days in a row the car will

1:23:55eventually warm up and be comfortable

1:23:57enough but if you're on a shortness

1:23:59drive where you don't have time to do

1:24:01that you just got to put on research

1:24:02just to get it just for me to not to be

1:24:04freezing my boat I don't have heated

1:24:05seats I think that would really help me

1:24:06get around with it but that's that's

1:24:07when I do it

1:24:08Wow

1:24:12I used to manually manage recirculation

1:24:16I don't anymore because modern nice cars

1:24:21not only do it for you and and their

1:24:23defaults of when to use it versus when

1:24:25not to seem pretty good but also like

1:24:28the smoker issue I I too like one way to

1:24:31really make me very angry is to make me

1:24:34smell cigarette smoke for some reason

1:24:36and but the good thing is about like and

1:24:38I don't know if it's a Tesla and BMW

1:24:40thing or whatever but like usually the

1:24:42the intake air filters seem to be so

1:24:45good on some of these cars now that I

1:24:48don't usually smell outside smells if my

1:24:51windows are up and my Sun roof is closed

1:24:52now occasionally I will still smell

1:24:55cigarette because my windows cracked or

1:24:56something but that's coming in through

1:24:58the window not the ventilation system so

1:25:00I almost never have any reason to

1:25:02manually adjust whether recirculation is

1:25:05on or off I just let the system handle

1:25:07it and it's fine

1:25:08Peter Gosling writes in there seems to

1:25:11be a lot of disappointment to slack Mac

1:25:12client justifiably so why not stick with

1:25:14IRC like the live show the native Mac

1:25:16IRC clients are joy to use and aren't

1:25:19half-baked like slack is so a little bit

1:25:20of background slack is written using

1:25:23electron which does not by necessity

1:25:25means it's a pile of mean that it's a

1:25:26pile of garbage but it turns out it is

1:25:28in fact a pile of garbage but a little

1:25:31known fact about slack which I probably

1:25:33will not remember to put in the show

1:25:34notes and say you can actually access

1:25:35slack I chat rooms teams whatever the

1:25:40terminology is via IRC there's an IRC

1:25:42front-end to slack so you could use any

1:25:44IRC client in connect to slack and

1:25:48that's what Peters talking about where

1:25:50this falls down is a couple of things

1:25:52one Peter said the native Matt mac IRC

1:25:54clients are joy to use and I must not be

1:25:57using the ones that he's using I use

1:25:58colloquy which is okay whatever Peters

1:26:03using must be much better than that yeah

1:26:05I got agree on that by the way like I IV

1:26:07I used colloquy I've also used textual

1:26:09and there's one more if use ones before

1:26:12I forget what it is and I can only

1:26:14describe any of them as okay yeah but

1:26:17anyway so you can use IRC to get to

1:26:18slack and the reason that I don't do

1:26:22this well there's a couple of reasons

1:26:23but mostly the reason the the biggest

1:26:26reason I don't do this is because one of

1:26:27the better things about slack and one of

1:26:29the reasons why I do understand

1:26:30and if I don't love the fact that they

1:26:32use electron is that so much of their so

1:26:35much of the things you put into a slack

1:26:37chat will like Auto expands so think

1:26:40about what's going on with iMessage when

1:26:41you put a tweet in or a link to a

1:26:44website it will try to grab like a hero

1:26:47image or if there's a tweet with an

1:26:48image it will grab the image and it will

1:26:50put it right in line in that iMessage

1:26:52conversation will slack does the same

1:26:53thing but it does it for all sorts of

1:26:55different data and it's really really

1:26:57nice I mean that genuinely and that I

1:26:59think I would really miss if I didn't

1:27:02have that and so like another example of

1:27:04that is say if somebody pastes in an

1:27:06animated gif or a URL to an animated gif

1:27:09I would want to see that inline like

1:27:11part of what makes slack fun is that

1:27:13kind of shucking and jiving back and

1:27:15forth with gifts and things like that

1:27:17and I think I would miss out on that if

1:27:19it was just in a traditional IRC client

1:27:21but it is a fair point

1:27:23and maybe I should try it just to see

1:27:25but I don't know that's that's my two

1:27:27cents do you guys have anything to add

1:27:28about that so I think in this contest

1:27:33between various applications let you

1:27:36type words to other people even if their

1:27:38various friends to slack in the case of

1:27:40the IRC gateway to slack or whatever

1:27:41I think the slack application on the Mac

1:27:44won fair and square based on its

1:27:47features and ease of use that's what it

1:27:49comes down to like yes IRC is existed

1:27:51forever and yes lots of IRC clients are

1:27:53good but slack offered a combination of

1:27:57functionality and application that gives

1:28:00you a front-end for that functionality

1:28:01that is simply more attractive to most

1:28:04people than all of the alternatives like

1:28:06it's not like slack one accidentally or

1:28:08because it was bundled as part of some

1:28:09monopolistic thing and you couldn't help

1:28:11but have slack forced down our throat

1:28:13slack has lots of warts but it has the

1:28:16right balance of stuff it is a fun

1:28:18interesting easy to use application that

1:28:22provides I think more fun and more

1:28:25features focused on exactly what it does

1:28:27in an IRC client and enough speed and

1:28:30functionality that we all you know grit

1:28:33our teeth and deal with the electron

1:28:35weirdness and everything like this

1:28:37because on balance it is better than all

1:28:39those things otherwise we would still

1:28:40all be using those things I was in tons

1:28:42of IRC channels before slack claimed

1:28:44and most of them have been replaced by

1:28:46slack because that's what more people

1:28:48want to use I can understand being in a

1:28:49situation where it's like yeah but I

1:28:50like the IRC you better sure but I think

1:28:53most people did not like IRC better or

1:28:55didn't like IRC at all which is why

1:28:57slack is as successful as it is so I

1:28:59think the reason we don't use it as

1:29:02because lack is better in general one

1:29:05Pablo Rodriguez writes in John I saw

1:29:08your tweet about the halting problem I

1:29:09would like to hear how you would explain

1:29:11it so the context this was just a couple

1:29:14of days ago and John jump in and cut me

1:29:16off whenever you're ready quote why is

1:29:18this program taking so long to run and

1:29:20quote big milestone today my son's first

1:29:22infinite loop then he asked why the

1:29:24programming courseware website he's

1:29:25using can't just tell him there's an

1:29:27infinite loop instead of trying to run

1:29:28the program as written I introduced him

1:29:30to the halting problem but he wasn't

1:29:31impressed so do you want to fill in any

1:29:33other context or just jump into the what

1:29:36is the halting problem so the context

1:29:38here is that I tried to show my kids

1:29:41both of my kids programming it very

1:29:44early ages say if you're interested this

1:29:46is the thing I can show you how to do

1:29:47but of course me being a father they

1:29:48don't want to have anything to do it and

1:29:50I know how to do so fine or whatever so

1:29:51I just laid off like they were into

1:29:53whatever they're into but my son is in

1:29:56eighth grade now and he's looking to

1:29:58take he wants to take a computer science

1:30:00course in ninth grade which is awesome

1:30:01that it's even offered I didn't have any

1:30:02computer science courses in my high

1:30:04school yes they had computers but they

1:30:05were Apple twos but anyway he's

1:30:08interested in taking that maybe just

1:30:09because his friends are interested it I

1:30:10can't tell if he's really interested in

1:30:11it but he's trying to get into an

1:30:15advanced level computer science class

1:30:16and he wants to have some experience so

1:30:19he's going through this online course or

1:30:20a thing with his friends right this is

1:30:21all is all him right but I'm offering to

1:30:24help him with it so that's why he's

1:30:27doing any kind of programming stuff at

1:30:28all and it's pretty late in the game and

1:30:30the grand scheme of things he's got like

1:30:31five year-olds who are writing iOS apps

1:30:32and a lot of on stage at Apple things

1:30:34and stuff like that and he's you know

1:30:35he's not a precocious programmer but

1:30:37he's getting into it and so I'm trying

1:30:40to help them you know as laid-back way

1:30:42as possible because you don't help too

1:30:44much you know because like becomes

1:30:46uncool if dad's into it whatever and he

1:30:48did write an infinite loop and he did it

1:30:50asked me like the course where it's like

1:30:51running his program for it and like it

1:30:53just was like a spinner on the web babe

1:30:54and he's like why is it taking so long

1:30:55he they write an infant

1:30:57I feel like it really is a milestone

1:30:58like the first time you do that and then

1:31:00don't understand what the hell's going

1:31:01on in your program specifically he was

1:31:03he was iterating over an array and in

1:31:07inside the loop he was adding I am to

1:31:08the end of the array which is a pretty

1:31:10fun way to do your first infinite loop

1:31:11as opposed to just like forgetting to

1:31:13check for termination condition he was

1:31:14iterating over listed he kept growing at

1:31:15the same pace he was iterating over it

1:31:17so that was fun

1:31:18apologies to the courseware website for

1:31:20the for the infinite loop bomb my son

1:31:22invoked on you as he opened up tab after

1:31:24tab and tried to run the same program it

1:31:28wasn't he didn't do a fork bomb but he's

1:31:30not he's not up at that process level

1:31:31yet so I did try to say actually there's

1:31:34a general problem about this the halting

1:31:35problem and to finally get to answer the

1:31:38specific question how would you go about

1:31:39explaining it part of the knowledge and

1:31:43wisdom I'm trying to impart on him as

1:31:45part of this is not the specifics of

1:31:46whatever he's doing about programming

1:31:48which I figure will come on his own but

1:31:50how do you how do you how do programmers

1:31:54do this how do you figure stuff out and

1:31:56early on I want to show them if you have

1:31:58a question about how something works the

1:32:00magic of the Internet you know after me

1:32:02saying you know up hill both ways how I

1:32:04had to do it in my day so on and so

1:32:06forth

1:32:06you can just type your question into

1:32:08Google and every like a Stack Overflow

1:32:09answer like you know how to concatenate

1:32:11strings you know in Python or whatever

1:32:13like the answer is right there you don't

1:32:16have to ask me you don't have to wonder

1:32:17just type it into Google search box so

1:32:20for the halting problem rather than me

1:32:22trying to explain this is what the

1:32:24halting problem is based on like my

1:32:25memory of it from school you know or

1:32:27just like even just in broad strokes

1:32:29just go to the Wikipedia page for the

1:32:31halting problem and there's like a

1:32:33paragraph at the top it does a pretty

1:32:35good job of explaining more or less what

1:32:36the halting problem is in links to

1:32:37examples and so on and so forth but the

1:32:39idea is that you shouldn't ask your dad

1:32:41or ask someone next to you to explain

1:32:43what the halting problem is you are

1:32:44empowered because you have the whole

1:32:46internet at your fingertips to find out

1:32:48the answer to this question quickly and

1:32:49in a much more authoritative way than me

1:32:51trying to you know recite it from memory

1:32:54because if I was gonna recite it from

1:32:55memory if I was gonna talk about the

1:32:56halting problem on this show I almost

1:32:58did it when I saw his question I was

1:32:59like oh I should go to the Wikipedia

1:33:00page and and paste the first bit but no

1:33:02like the lesson is you this is one of

1:33:05those things that you don't have to

1:33:06memorize and even if you know it

1:33:08backwards and forwards it's difficult

1:33:09sometimes to explain something that you

1:33:11no if you haven't like taught a course

1:33:12into five or six times so use the

1:33:15Internet

1:33:15use the tools that are available to you

1:33:16don't rely on other people to explain

1:33:18things I haven't yet explained to him

1:33:20about it Wikipedia being a tertiary

1:33:22source a little crap but here we go one

1:33:25step at a time

1:33:25there's only so much dad that kids can

1:33:27take in one dose all right thanks to our

1:33:30sponsors this week

1:33:32and we'll see you next week now the show

1:33:38is over to be y el asesor that's Casey

1:34:13less and a are Co AR m and T Marco

1:34:18Arment

1:34:20[Music]

1:34:36[Music]

1:34:38all right so last week we what was the

1:34:41the Genesis the question I should have

1:34:43left in the show notes but we were

1:34:44talking about like cars and things and

1:34:47rolling double zero in the chat

1:34:49suggested something that hopefully you

1:34:52guys have at least put two minutes of

1:34:54thought into which I know Marko hasn't

1:34:56and John maybe has oh no I put exactly

1:34:58two minutes of thought into it alright

1:35:00well that works for me what car would

1:35:02you pick for your other hosts now I

1:35:04didn't ask

1:35:06rollin 0-0 nor did I clarify what do you

1:35:10mean by that is it the car you think

1:35:13they would enjoy the most is it the car

1:35:15you would most like to see them in is it

1:35:17the car that you would get to just troll

1:35:19them and I didn't want to give you guys

1:35:23any sort of direction about any of this

1:35:26so I have answered the question in my

1:35:30own way but I don't have to go first

1:35:33this time since I was very aggressively

1:35:35first during ask ATP so which one of you

1:35:37would like to volunteer to tell each of

1:35:40us what cars we should be driving I'll

1:35:43do it if you want all right Marko feel

1:35:45free all right this is fairly easy for

1:35:49Casey you would have the new m3 period

1:35:51well what's that your criteria is what

1:35:54car would I most like to drive I guess

1:35:57yeah my criteria basically I mean if

1:35:59we're assuming that like you know I

1:36:00don't have to worry about how much these

1:36:01cars cost they're just being paid for

1:36:04somehow and that I guess get to decide

1:36:06which car you have then my rationale

1:36:09here is which car would you be most

1:36:12happy with you know what is the car that

1:36:15you should have and so I think it's the

1:36:18m3 done and John a little bit harder I I

1:36:24was kind of thinking maybe the m5 or if

1:36:28he doesn't want to go necessary that

1:36:29large because I know I know like your

1:36:31parking situations a little bit tight

1:36:32over there so I figured maybe you might

1:36:36also go with something in the 3-series

1:36:40range maybe your dad's old 3-series that

1:36:43you like but like a faster one

1:36:44like like it maybe like the 335 of that

1:36:46generation maybe something like that but

1:36:49probably just I think John I think my

1:36:51answer is actually gonna be just the new

1:36:53m5 so new m3 4kc new m5 for John why for

1:36:57me I understand your reasoning for KC

1:36:58what's your reasoning for me like why

1:37:00are you even picking from BMWs for me

1:37:01well I know you wouldn't actually enjoy

1:37:03owning a Ferrari I know that you like

1:37:07Mercedes but I'm too young to know how

1:37:10to select one I went with the brand that

1:37:15I know how to use and how to pick from

1:37:17that gives you what you want which is

1:37:20similar to eylem which is a nice big

1:37:21faster damn like you like those and I

1:37:24know you're not gonna get see here's the

1:37:27problem though I know you like stick a

1:37:28lot and that can't you can't have that

1:37:30in stick so maybe I try to find you an

1:37:33f10 generation in a stick which they

1:37:36probably made like three of those total

1:37:38but maybe that's the right answer

1:37:41people didn't like those those stick

1:37:42shifts they said that the manual was not

1:37:45very good in that car

1:37:46yeah see this it's it's picking for you

1:37:48is very challenging picking for case is

1:37:51easy because I know what he wants it so

1:37:52it's easy picking for you is is harder

1:37:55but you know I don't think Mercedes

1:37:56makes any sticks either that you would

1:37:58want but I don't know no yeah I don't

1:38:01know that but I think so I'm gonna stand

1:38:03by my answer of the new m5 but with some

1:38:05reservations I was proud of KC for

1:38:08recognizing what a terrible question

1:38:09this is saying but I don't care and I'm

1:38:14not gonna clarify so let's just all

1:38:15interpret the question or however that

1:38:17we want this question is terrible

1:38:19because it just has no parameters

1:38:20whatsoever oh just to have a little fun

1:38:24it's not useful anyway so if I had to

1:38:27pick first I'd have to pick the how to

1:38:30interpret this question but I'd say how

1:38:33did you interpret the question I'm

1:38:35mostly interpreting as a car I think

1:38:39that you would enjoy that you wouldn't

1:38:41buy for yourself it's like the

1:38:42gift-giving type thing

1:38:43sure okay I like that interpret um for

1:38:47Casey I think I would go with a caiman

1:38:50slash Boxster whichever one comes with

1:38:52the sunroof or and or convertible 718

1:38:54whatever the hell it's called now or I

1:38:56would actually maybe go with it with the

1:38:59previous generation that's what

1:39:00naturally aspirated because I think you

1:39:02would really enjoy a stick-shift caiman

1:39:04because you get that open-air driving

1:39:05experience I think it would be a more

1:39:07fun dynamic driving experience than all

1:39:09of your like regular car cars and it's

1:39:11just an all-around great car like not

1:39:13super - super fast not too super loud

1:39:16not as small and wimpy as a Miata which

1:39:20I think you would also enjoy by the way

1:39:22I thought I would

1:39:24it's like it's like the big boy Miata so

1:39:25I would I would go with a caiman

1:39:27I like that choice I drove I probably

1:39:30told the story maybe on neutral I drove

1:39:32a Boxster S early on in the life time of

1:39:36the Boxster's this was circa 2005 maybe

1:39:412006 and I think the Box had only been

1:39:44out for a couple of years at that point

1:39:45I might have these dates wrong but you

1:39:46get the idea

1:39:47and I got in that car expecting to hate

1:39:50it oh it's a you know poor man's 911

1:39:53it's just garbage this is gonna be crap

1:39:56and I loved it I couldn't believe how

1:40:00much I loved it and that was you know

1:40:02ten plus years ago so I can only imagine

1:40:04I came in or you know whatever the new

1:40:06Boxster came in like the epic a - the

1:40:09the natural have spread one right before

1:40:10they change to 718 it's just an amazing

1:40:12all-around balance it's fun a not too

1:40:15ridiculous car and you wouldn't buy it

1:40:16for yourself because you're like oh I

1:40:17gotta have a car that can put car seat

1:40:19in it oh yeah but I feel like with the

1:40:21giant shoebox thing that you've got

1:40:23going on for the whole family it would

1:40:27be a nice compromise of like a small

1:40:29small ish fun interesting fast enough to

1:40:33be cool open air kind of car nice and

1:40:36for Marco from Marco a little bit torn

1:40:39on this my my go-to would say and

1:40:41especially if I'm not allowed to pick

1:40:43from like future models because a lot of

1:40:44people coming out with cars that I think

1:40:45you would enjoy more than most of my

1:40:46picks because like everyone else all the

1:40:48other tests the competitors are coming

1:40:49but they're not here yet so I can't pick

1:40:51them agree mom

1:40:52so I would go I would probably shop on

1:40:56the Mercedes range because I truly

1:40:57continuous ADEs perhaps more than he

1:41:01enjoyed his m5 and so I probably go kind

1:41:06of like what I was I'd pick up myself in

1:41:07that preview show like it like an AMG

1:41:09II class if I could find the right

1:41:11balance of options and features to

1:41:13satisfy and if not believe it or not I

1:41:15would probably look at howdy there's

1:41:17another brand that Marco seems to have

1:41:18not wanted to really consider for

1:41:21himself but I think there are models in

1:41:22that range that he would really enjoy so

1:41:24those would be my picks a mid-sized

1:41:26Mercedes and if I can't find the right

1:41:27set of options in car in model year I

1:41:29would go Abby I think those are good

1:41:31choices Marco thoughts it's reasonable

1:41:34yeah I mean I haven't driven a Mercedes

1:41:37or an Audi in a long time

1:41:39when I have driven those cars I have

1:41:42been incredibly unimpressed with their

1:41:45media and navigation systems but you

1:41:48know I would give it a shot and the

1:41:50thing is wouldn't buy for yourself

1:41:52because you're all electric so basically

1:41:53all gas cars are now cars that Marco

1:41:55wouldn't buy for himself there yeah and

1:41:58and he had the 1m right so I feel like

1:42:01if that was a thing that he still wanted

1:42:03he would have gone back to I well but he

1:42:05hasn't so that's why I'm picking like

1:42:07regular normal size

1:42:08you know mid-sized cars I think those

1:42:11are good choices alright so I

1:42:12interpreted this as what do I think

1:42:15would be the best fit for my co-host and

1:42:19they may or may not buy this but my my

1:42:21rule was I couldn't just say like oh

1:42:24well Marco just wants another Tesla so I

1:42:26actually thought it was a little easier

1:42:29to pick for John because the options I

1:42:32came up with were a new mazda6 which I

1:42:35think he would quite like and is

1:42:39basically what you already have just a

1:42:41different manufacturer and and I've

1:42:43always thought the mazda6 is with there

1:42:45was one really crummy generation which

1:42:47is the generation after Aaron so this

1:42:49was like late 2000s early early 2010's

1:42:52which was not attractive at all but

1:42:54every other monster six has always been

1:42:56pretty attractive in my eyes and we

1:42:58loved Aaron's Mazda 6 who treated us so

1:43:00really really well and I think John you

1:43:01would like that but the other thing I

1:43:03was thinking about even though

1:43:07III really think hatchbacks are dumb

1:43:10sorry Europeans I think would love a GTI

1:43:12I really think you would love a GTI John

1:43:15I think that's definitely a car I would

1:43:18not buy for myself

1:43:22but do you like leaving aside the fact

1:43:24that hatchbacks are stupid do you think

1:43:28it with a stick I think the main thing

1:43:31the main thing I would enjoy about a GTI

1:43:33is the small ish size both in length and

1:43:37width but they're not as small as they

1:43:40used to be and they're definitely not as

1:43:41light as they used to be so I'm not sure

1:43:43I would get that much enjoyment out of

1:43:45it fair enough

1:43:46well those were my picks for for John

1:43:48and obviously the you know the the clear

1:43:49answer was the Ferrari which is like

1:43:51Marco said like that would be that would

1:43:53actually probably make John more unhappy

1:43:55than happy exactly if you again this is

1:43:57the question is so vague you could say a

1:44:00Ferrari and and a mansion with the

1:44:02heated garage to start in and say fair

1:44:06enough

1:44:07Marco I actually found harder because I

1:44:09really do think that the Tesla in in in

1:44:11the current iteration of Marco and Marco

1:44:13version 2017 or 2018 I think this is the

1:44:16the Model S is probably the perfect car

1:44:18for you Marco however if I couldn't

1:44:20choose that what would I choose and the

1:44:22obvious answer is a brand new m5 I think

1:44:25you would quite like that it gives you

1:44:26the all-wheel drive that you didn't have

1:44:28last for the last iteration it's just as

1:44:31quick as your Tesla or Daenerys makes no

1:44:33difference if not quicker but then I

1:44:36thought okay what are some more

1:44:37interesting choices and I thought to

1:44:40myself well what about a Prius Prime

1:44:42which is somewhat insulting and I don't

1:44:45mean it to be but my parents have a

1:44:48Prius Prime which I plug-in Prius and it

1:44:51is for what it is thinking like what

1:45:04would you if you're so bent on electric

1:45:06then then what would I mean I guess the

1:45:09Chevy Volt maybe but that seems like

1:45:13you're gonna get a much worse electric

1:45:16slash hybrid car than what he

1:45:18now that's a bad idea and the Prius

1:45:20Prime is that perhaps the ugliest car on

1:45:22the road today

1:45:23none of the Aztec is that function

1:45:29wasn't designed to be a punishment it

1:45:31was taking your insistence on having an

1:45:34electric car in mind but I don't think

1:45:37that's a terribly good answer either I

1:45:38was just throwing it out there very

1:45:39active conversation and then I thought

1:45:42to myself well let me think about Marco

1:45:44less as a driver but more is just like

1:45:48let me think about Marcos personality

1:45:50and disposition Marcos tends to obsess

1:45:53over things and I have this quality in

1:45:55me as well so I can recognize it in

1:45:56others you know tends to obsess over

1:45:58things and get just like really really

1:46:00deep into something and just I'm gonna

1:46:03explore it to the to the most extreme

1:46:05depths and I will explore every avenue

1:46:08of it I will know something front to

1:46:10back in and out left and right what kind

1:46:13of car would Marco be able to do that

1:46:17sort of thing with you would need a car

1:46:19that's like I don't know like an erector

1:46:22set or like a like a like a Lego set

1:46:25what color I know

1:46:28Marco should have a Wrangler because you

1:46:31could have 17 different tops you can

1:46:33have 17 different doors you can have a

1:46:36six-speed if you want it and you could

1:46:38go rock crawling in in the little hills

1:46:41and mountains of New York and you could

1:46:42go driving off-road up you know up in

1:46:45tips parents house you could do all

1:46:47those things you could have different

1:46:48winches it's imagine the fun you would

1:46:50have Marco figuring out the exact right

1:46:52winch you should put on the front of

1:46:54that car and getting the is

1:46:55extraordinarily expensive winch that

1:46:58weighs just 5 pounds left less than the

1:47:00one that's half the cost but you know

1:47:02you're saving that weight and you know

1:47:04it's better off that way imagine

1:47:05deciding exactly how big a gas can you

1:47:08want to put on the rear bumper for when

1:47:10you're going off-road do you want five

1:47:11five gallons oh no no I think I want six

1:47:14this is like your perfect car it is

1:47:17nothing but useless decisions that you

1:47:19can throw oodles of money at this car is

1:47:22made for you you're gonna get a Porsche

1:47:24with Doodles of money and useless

1:47:27the Wrangler is like didn't you hear the

1:47:31discussion of head burns you can get

1:47:35with a hardtop but I know you're not

1:47:37going to agree with this but I stand by

1:47:39this decision it this is what I get for

1:47:41all the mac pro talk I get it I totally

1:47:44well done sir

1:47:46I have speechless I you have done it I

1:47:50commend you excellent job I know you

1:47:57don't have any interest in a Wrangler

1:47:58like I get that but if you just put

1:48:00aside the fact you have no interest in

1:48:01the thing I want you to have interested

1:48:03like there's so many ways you can

1:48:05customize this you could have a soft top

1:48:07you could have a soft top that makes it

1:48:09look kind of like a pickup you could

1:48:11have a hardtop you could have a hardtop

1:48:12with a little convertible section you

1:48:14could have a winch

1:48:15you could have onboard air inflation

1:48:18system you can have different spare tire

1:48:21set up you'll mean all the different

1:48:23things you could do to this car oh my

1:48:25word I think it's perfect for you but

1:48:27anyway the actual answer I have is

1:48:29either an m5 or Hardy 63 AMG oh my god

1:48:32like is it possible to make a custom

1:48:36configuration of the Jeep Wrangler that

1:48:39I would tolerate and I'm pretty sure the

1:48:41answer is no I don't I don't think you

1:48:44do it I challenge you to try I don't

1:48:46think it's possible I think the problem

1:48:50is what I really want is like a Wrangler

1:48:51equivalent that's a sedan that's like a

1:48:54go-fast again you know something where

1:48:55you could mess with the tops and you

1:48:57could have I mean you could put

1:48:58different wheels on any car but like I

1:49:00really stand by that you would just get

1:49:03wrapped around the axle but I'm wrapped

1:49:06around the axle with all these different

1:49:08decisions you can make in all the

1:49:09different tweaks you can make like this

1:49:10is why I think and I feel I get I would

1:49:13guess that you and I would enjoy camping

1:49:15an equivalent amount and the difference

1:49:16is you've actually gone camping and I

1:49:18have not but that's a similar thing

1:49:20where I could see really either of us

1:49:22all these things I'm really just

1:49:23projecting onto you well I could see

1:49:25either of us obsessing over well the the

1:49:28aluminum spoon in fork and knife set

1:49:30ways one else but the titanium spoon

1:49:33fork and knife set weighs a half an

1:49:35ounce and even though it's literally ten

1:49:37times the cost that half an ounce in

1:49:39aggregate and aggregate adds up like

1:49:41it's the same sort of thing right like I

1:49:43could see you going or me going

1:49:44ridiculous about camping equipment in

1:49:46the same way I could see you or me going

1:49:48ridiculous with your Tinkertoys Wrangler

1:49:51so you forgot to expand our silly

1:49:54unconfined question to say okay Marco

1:49:57all of a sudden you live in the middle

1:49:59of nowhere there are no paved roads to

1:50:01your house and you have like hundreds of

1:50:05acres that you have to patrol to hunt

1:50:07for your own food then all of a sudden

1:50:08mark was interested in a jeep wrangler

1:50:10because he has a reason you know a

1:50:14pretty good off-road easy to get into

1:50:17and out of four-wheel drive vehicle to

1:50:20wander around his property with and so

1:50:22we can you know get out when he needs to

1:50:24get to the hospital fifty miles away you

1:50:27can construct a scenario which Marco

1:50:29would want a Jeep Wrangler but the

1:50:31scenario where he lives now is not it no

1:50:33not even close do you know you're not

1:50:36you're not picking up what I'm putting

1:50:37down on this one are you surprised by

1:50:40that no I'm not can we at least concede

1:50:44though can you at least concede that you

1:50:46can see that the tweak enos of it that

1:50:48you can just just dial it in just right

1:50:50like don't know

1:50:51I concede nothing come on I completely

1:50:54disagree because it's tweaking a bunch

1:50:57of things that I don't care about it's

1:50:59like no matter what you tweak about that

1:51:02build I still don't want it and never

1:51:04will like you can like it's like asking

1:51:08me like how do I want to set the EQ for

1:51:10my day of Matthews Band I can take a lot

1:51:14of things look I can I love it I could

1:51:16take a lot of the EQ that's how you

1:51:18every band - 90 decibels that's how I

1:51:23would set it I was proud of my response

1:51:26dammit then I stand by it

1:51:27but that's okay stick with the m5 that

1:51:30was a good response

1:51:30was a good response

0:00:00I kind of feel like I should have just

0:00:01left TIFF here and left the show because

0:00:03we had so much awesome feedback about

0:00:05how not only how great she was but how

0:00:07much better she was than me but

0:00:11unfortunately you guys are stuck with me

0:00:12this week all right let's start with

0:00:15some follow-up and Bradley Davis writes

0:00:17in with regard to hard to hit up/down

0:00:19arrow keys on the new MacBook Pros the

0:00:22bottom hero of the new MacBooks is

0:00:23shorter than the previous generation the

0:00:25bottom really used to be taller than all

0:00:26the other rows now it's the same height

0:00:28huge loss in my opinion especially as a

0:00:30programmer who uses modifier keys more

0:00:31than your average person I didn't even

0:00:34believe this so I measured it at work

0:00:35and he is totally right did you guys

0:00:37both realize that in the right up until

0:00:40the 2016-2017 on the MacBook Pros the

0:00:43like the spacebar and that whole row was

0:00:45taller than all the other rows of keys

0:00:46nope I know I'm curious hold on I

0:00:51thought it's plausible but it can't be

0:00:53that much bigger so I measured it it's

0:00:54it's appreciably bigger you can you know

0:00:56I didn't have I was using the side of a

0:00:58credit card or whatever but you can you

0:00:59know get a ruler and see how much bigger

0:01:01it's but it's at least like 5% bigger I

0:01:03don't know if I believe let me get out

0:01:05my behemoth of Oracle so while you guys

0:01:07get out things to measure the reason

0:01:09this is relevant is not so much that

0:01:10it's hard or actually but are we getting

0:01:12out to measure I'm getting at a digital

0:01:14caliper what are you getting at to

0:01:15measure nevermind

0:01:16wow this look a little bit taller it is

0:01:19so they're saying the reason it makes a

0:01:22difference is not because it's easier to

0:01:24hit the spacebar or the command key or

0:01:25anything but because the arrow keys oh

0:01:27yeah it's a huge difference the up and

0:01:29down our keys are jammed into a single

0:01:31key space and I was complaining it I

0:01:32felt that was a little bit harder to hit

0:01:33the up figure out the up and down arrow

0:01:35keys and the new MacBook Pros even

0:01:37though it's like the same layout it is

0:01:38the same layout but the with taller keys

0:01:41each half the top half and the bottom

0:01:42half are bigger so it makes a difference

0:01:45particularly for the arrow keys yeah so

0:01:46the height of the command key my 2015 is

0:01:4817 point 8 millimeters and then the

0:01:51height of the keys and the row above it

0:01:52are only 15 point 2 that's surprising by

0:01:56the way only tangentially related if you

0:01:58ever have a longing for the 17-inch

0:02:02MacBook Pro which I always thought was

0:02:03just hilariously stupid but I know that

0:02:06there are people that love it I do not

0:02:07need to hear from you I'm just saying

0:02:09it's not for me anyway if you ever want

0:02:11to make your 15-inch feel like a 17 inch

0:02:13from

0:02:13you know the days of the past spend a

0:02:16couple of months using exclusively

0:02:18either a 27-inch iMac or a more

0:02:21importantly a 12-inch MacBook adorable

0:02:24and then bust out your work 15-inch

0:02:26MacBook for the first time in two months

0:02:28holy monkey that thing is enormous it is

0:02:31just gigantic compared to the little

0:02:35MacBook adorable that I'm used to

0:02:36well I'll tell you what I mean like like

0:02:38even you know during during my great

0:02:40laptop shuffle of 2016-2017 when I for a

0:02:45while there owned the 13-inch MacBook

0:02:47escape that that to me is a it's such a

0:02:50great size and I and I do intend to go

0:02:52back to that probably in the next

0:02:53generation whatever comes out but when I

0:02:56was using that even after years of using

0:02:5815 inches a lot of the time I would

0:03:01occasionally see a 15-inch out in the

0:03:03world and it would it would look crazy

0:03:05to me even the brand-new like the the

0:03:07current generation ones that are better

0:03:08you know a little more compact in the

0:03:10old ones once you're used to whatever

0:03:12size you're used to anything above it

0:03:15looks like a monster good but you know

0:03:17by comparison yeah it it's started

0:03:21striking the difference but that's okay

0:03:23but today I did a half day at work from

0:03:25for the first time since January ah half

0:03:28congratulations yeah I was speaking of

0:03:31work in giant laptops I you I had my

0:03:3515-inch 2017 MacBook Pro at about 85%

0:03:39charge and I did a one-hour meeting

0:03:43where I projected during the meeting

0:03:45dream my whole battery the machine

0:03:47shutdown Wow

0:03:49I watched it go down the whole medium

0:03:51its WebEx the magic of WebEx like a

0:03:55single one-hour meeting from 85 percent

0:03:57to basically you can no longer wear in

0:03:59your computer sorry off yeah because

0:04:01that's you say WebEx is I don't I've

0:04:03never used WebEx but I I assume it's

0:04:05pretty inefficient on the CPU right we

0:04:07need to have a special episode where we

0:04:08just make Marco use all software and

0:04:11then I would imagine too that you but

0:04:15that you were plugged in you said to

0:04:16you're projecting I was so that dooms

0:04:19the discrete GPU was forced on the whole

0:04:21time and so it was basically as if you

0:04:23were playing a game and like playing

0:04:25your GPUs on your

0:04:27CPU is probably being maxed out because

0:04:29it sounds like the software is terrible

0:04:30so yeah that's gonna be about one hour

0:04:32battery life it was bad you know I think

0:04:36the most popular advertisements that

0:04:38we've ever run on this show were the

0:04:39ones that cards against Mandy did where

0:04:41we where John was forced to try a new

0:04:43usually garbage toaster each week I

0:04:46think it is possible if the cards

0:04:50against humanity' folks are listening

0:04:51that making Marco use some piece of

0:04:54enterprise grade software once for a

0:04:57once per ad that might be an even more

0:05:00popular even better segment because it

0:05:03would be magical you would probably quit

0:05:06the show just from just from being near

0:05:09enterprise these sort of things that

0:05:11John and I have to deal with every day

0:05:12yeah I would I would make a switch to

0:05:14patreon the trick is though that you

0:05:17have to be forced to use them like that

0:05:20they're mandated by the company or

0:05:21because you have to like teleconference

0:05:23so you need to use the only approved

0:05:24teleconference offer that you know

0:05:25everybody has right that's the part of

0:05:27its not just using the software it's

0:05:29that you have two toasters kind of work

0:05:30because like I maybe I'll be making

0:05:32toast anyway but there's no way Marco is

0:05:34going to even be doing the things that

0:05:35these that's true programs you know are

0:05:37made to do let alone being forced to do

0:05:39them are to be Kendall writes in if you

0:05:42think the MacBooks arrowkey setup is bad

0:05:44check Dells recipe for annoyance and

0:05:46there's a link included so imagine the

0:05:49same arrow key setup that we have in

0:05:53brand-new MacBook Pros but just for

0:05:55funsies let's put page up and page down

0:05:58in the dead space between so I'm sorry I

0:06:01guess it's not like a new MacBook Pros

0:06:02like the previous MacBook Pros and we'll

0:06:03put a page up and page down in the dead

0:06:05space to the left and right of the up

0:06:07arrow key so if you're looking at it

0:06:09it's page up and then below that is left

0:06:12up and down page down and below that is

0:06:15right it looks horrible I'm sure if you

0:06:18get used to it it's convenient but oh

0:06:19man it does not look it's not because

0:06:22like if you accidentally hit like see

0:06:24it's above the arrow keys right so if

0:06:26you accidentally hit the wrong key

0:06:27trying to go for left you don't go more

0:06:29left you go page up which is totally

0:06:32unrelated to left but that's the key

0:06:35that's near there so I would never want

0:06:37to like fumble tooth and and what if you

0:06:39didn't notice you fumble it and then you

0:06:40like didn't think you actually

0:06:41so you hit left arrow you've done left

0:06:43one character or whatever but you don't

0:06:45realize you're a page up from where you

0:06:46were and it's just well it's really

0:06:48terrible and they also overlook

0:06:50brightness the up and down arrow keys

0:06:51what I'm assuming that's a modifier

0:06:52thing but it'd be kind of funny if it

0:06:54wasn't like every time gonna move the

0:06:56cursor up you get a little brighter you

0:06:59can keep moving down the document but

0:07:00eventually you can't see it anymore

0:07:03no this this like I feel like and part

0:07:07of the reason and I swear I'm not gonna

0:07:08make this all about apples dumb laptop

0:07:09keyboards but part of the reason why

0:07:11Apple's keyboard design offenses bother

0:07:15me so much is because we have it so good

0:07:16in Apple and that usually their

0:07:18keyboards don't have horrendous flaws

0:07:19and if you look over in the PC land like

0:07:21I mean you can get a ton of really nice

0:07:25PC desktop keyboards but once you get

0:07:29into laptops especially a mass-market

0:07:31laptops especially small laptops you

0:07:33know like you can get the big gamer ones

0:07:35that have the built-in mechanical key

0:07:36switches but like once you get down to

0:07:37like Nats market small laptops PC

0:07:41designs are all over the place and have

0:07:44horrendous bad design choices about as

0:07:47often as the worst of Apple you know we

0:07:50just we normally are not seeing this

0:07:52from Apple land because we don't buy

0:07:54these things and so if we're kind of

0:07:56spoiled that like when Apple does have a

0:07:58generation where they really stood

0:07:59really terrible keyboard like our heads

0:08:01explode because we can't take it whereas

0:08:04like on the PC side this is a

0:08:06commonplace occurrence it's it's that

0:08:09time so now I have a question you are

0:08:11there in mark oh you wouldn't know this

0:08:13but maybe John would are there like

0:08:15rabid Dell fanboys on the way there were

0:08:17like five ten years ago because you know

0:08:19how like there were the Apple fanboys

0:08:22like well us and then there were all the

0:08:24people on the PC side they were all like

0:08:26devout Dell people and I feel like I

0:08:28haven't run into any of them in years do

0:08:32they still exist I've never met someone

0:08:34who's super into Dell we all know that

0:08:36there are people who love ThinkPads I

0:08:37mean in case you're one of them oh yeah

0:08:40and let me think I mean obviously this

0:08:42this enthusiasm for the specialty brands

0:08:44like Alienware or Asus or even for you

0:08:47know gaming focused stuff but Dell or HP

0:08:50I mean the closest I can get to that is

0:08:52I think there was a lot of brand loyalty

0:08:54behind gateway 2000 yeah back when they

0:08:56had the cow boxes and B and before it

0:08:58was 2000 but that was my first computer

0:09:00same but that but that was more of like

0:09:02a mainstream thing and not like a

0:09:03computer enthusiasts thing but if there

0:09:05are Dell enthusiasts I have not run

0:09:06across their path like my brother-in-law

0:09:08for example was a huge Dale enthusiast

0:09:10as much as one can be up until a few

0:09:13years ago and then he started buying

0:09:15surfaces surface or things I don't know

0:09:18whatever and he's been really

0:09:20enthusiastic about those ever since but

0:09:22and maybe that's what they did is all

0:09:23the Dell people went and bought surfaces

0:09:25but I know I just had occurred to me

0:09:26that I haven't seen anyone that's like

0:09:28really amped for Dell in a long time

0:09:30anyway

0:09:31and our final bit of follow up just a

0:09:33small anecdote from the kitchen in the

0:09:36list household earlier tonight we were

0:09:38Aaron was making dinner and I was doing

0:09:41something with with Declan and oh I was

0:09:44I I was walking around carrying Michaela

0:09:47in a little carrier on my chest and

0:09:50multitasking and playing breath of the

0:09:51wild at the same time because I've

0:09:53started to pick that up again and then

0:09:55Declan caught wind of what I was doing

0:09:57and he was like oh I want to watch and

0:09:58we don't really like giving Declan a

0:10:00whole ton of screen time if we can avoid

0:10:02it so what I decided to do was set a

0:10:04timer for myself and remind me not to

0:10:08play Zelda for more than like five or

0:10:10ten minutes while Declan was watching

0:10:11and I was just gonna put it away this is

0:10:13a hell of a multitask yeah well you know

0:10:15I do what I can so so I asked the lady

0:10:18in a tube to remind me to stop playing

0:10:21Zelda in five minutes or something like

0:10:23that and I think the key is that I

0:10:24phrased it with remind which I'm not

0:10:26sure why I did that but that's what I

0:10:28did and she got really really confused

0:10:30and apparently there's like a whole

0:10:32different reminders versus timers setup

0:10:36which makes sense but I'd never you know

0:10:38experienced this in my week in a day

0:10:40with you know a lady in a tube in the

0:10:42house so anyway so I'm like going back

0:10:44and forth with with the echo trying to

0:10:46get it to just set what amounts it to

0:10:48like a five minute timer and I'm you

0:10:51know this was my fault I phrased it

0:10:52poorly no big deal but

0:10:54what was funny was from the kitchen I

0:10:56hear Aaron say something along the lines

0:10:58of oh come on Siri get your act together

0:11:01knowing full well I was talking to the

0:11:03echo so here it was that she was using

0:11:06like she was she was calling the echo

0:11:09Siri as a not derogatory the sun--the or

0:11:12what I'm looking for but like as a like

0:11:14a put-down you know like she was saying

0:11:16oh this is reminding me of how terrible

0:11:19Syria's in so many words

0:11:20and I thought that was kind of

0:11:22interesting because Aaron is the most

0:11:25normal person in the list household by a

0:11:27far margin and so it was interesting to

0:11:30me to see her kind of associate and

0:11:32equate a crummy voice experience with

0:11:36Siri because you know early on I thought

0:11:39that and I was reflecting on this

0:11:41briefly on Twitter earlier early on I

0:11:43actually thought Siri was extremely

0:11:45impressive like like the first year - I

0:11:47thought Siri was really good and then it

0:11:49seemed like everyone else started to

0:11:51either create their own voices

0:11:52assistance or make their own voice

0:11:55assistance really a whole lot better and

0:11:57ever since the first year or two when

0:12:00series brand new I've really been

0:12:02unimpressed as we've talked about on the

0:12:03show more than once and as we've used

0:12:06the echo for more and more things I've

0:12:08been more more impressed by it so a

0:12:09silly example of that we were listening

0:12:12to vinyl we were listening to the album

0:12:13thriller the terrible song the girl is

0:12:16mine came on which is a collaboration

0:12:18between McCartney and Jackson and I

0:12:20asked I asked the lady a tube something

0:12:23along the lines of how much older is

0:12:25Michael jack all right I'm sorry it's

0:12:27Paul McCartney the Michael Jackson and

0:12:28she knew exactly what I was talking

0:12:30about and gave me the answer and I think

0:12:31was like 16 years and I think I had even

0:12:33asked if I recall correctly I'd asked if

0:12:36Michael Jackson were alive today how old

0:12:38would he be and I thought that was

0:12:40stretching a bit like I was not gonna be

0:12:42surprised if the lady in the tube would

0:12:44not know what the crap I was asking and

0:12:46sure enough she gave me an answer

0:12:48couldn't tell you what it was offhand

0:12:49but she gave me an answer and that like

0:12:51if I haven't tried it but if I ask Siri

0:12:53how old Michael Jackson be today I would

0:12:56be very surprised if Siri had any darn

0:12:58idea what I was talking about and the

0:13:00fact that I don't think even think it's

0:13:01worth trying is itself an indication of

0:13:04my lack of confidence in Siri well

0:13:07next time you ask one of those questions

0:13:09and you're and you're impressed or not

0:13:10impressed by by happy echo does take out

0:13:13your phone rest here the same thing it

0:13:14is it is kind of useful as commentators

0:13:17and enthusiasts in this field to do that

0:13:18and compare like you know how are these

0:13:20things doing with the things that I what

0:13:22that I think I should ask them because I

0:13:24found whenever I do that I do find the

0:13:26echo devices to have better answers

0:13:30faster more of the time but they don't

0:13:34always get them and Siri doesn't always

0:13:36not get them you know it's just it's a

0:13:38series average is worse for me but but

0:13:41the the Alexa devices are actually not

0:13:44perfect either they just have better

0:13:46averages I do I do think they like going

0:13:50back to the to the beginning of the

0:13:51story though I just I wish that these

0:13:55devices handled the the basic like the

0:13:59basic PDA functions like the things that

0:14:02like all computing hardware and stuff

0:14:05have tried to do since the beginning of

0:14:06time that almost everyone needs

0:14:09reminders alarms

0:14:11timers calendar like these are very

0:14:14basic things that everything should be

0:14:18able to do these days and the fact that

0:14:21like you know and the echo devices I

0:14:23think do a pretty good job on a timer

0:14:25front that I think their timer support

0:14:26is excellent their alarms are basically

0:14:28just like timers they're excellent as

0:14:30well

0:14:31iPhones and and you know I stuff as we

0:14:34as we talked about with the home pod

0:14:35long she's not having multiple timers or

0:14:37name time or things like that like

0:14:38that's still so far behind and it just

0:14:40seems like that like that stuff is not

0:14:42that hard from a programming perspective

0:14:44like that isn't that hard

0:14:46it just seems it's it seems baffling to

0:14:49me that anything any of these like a

0:14:52voice assistant services or devices

0:14:53launch these days without totally

0:14:56nailing reminders timers alarms and was

0:15:01your own calendar like those should be

0:15:03easy and at least like calendar I can

0:15:05kind of understand if any of them don't

0:15:08because you have to like connect two

0:15:09different services and maybe you don't

0:15:11they don't support the one you use or

0:15:12you haven't set it up or whatever but

0:15:14like reminders should be local on device

0:15:16if they if they don't have any kind of

0:15:18same thing set up like that that's easy

0:15:19you know remind me at this time too

0:15:21do this like they just they should just

0:15:22treat that as a timer and it's like the

0:15:24fact that anything that is that simple

0:15:26to do doesn't work properly on any of

0:15:30these things it should be kind of

0:15:31embarrassing I think we discussed the in

0:15:33the past on this topic I'm still waiting

0:15:35for like forget about how far beyond

0:15:38Syria may be and its own but I'm still

0:15:40waiting for the next logical step in

0:15:42this well I guess this two one is the

0:15:45advancement of the vocabulary

0:15:46surrounding the things Marco just said

0:15:49echo and Google home are pretty good and

0:15:52as you know as Casey found you just

0:15:53phrase it the way you think and it'll

0:15:55mostly figure it out but the next

0:15:56logical step is some and I think then

0:15:59maybe the reason this is so difficult

0:16:01that are require more Hardware locally

0:16:03is some some context awareness to allow

0:16:06the beginnings of a conversation about

0:16:08things because although these devices

0:16:12are flexible about how we request the

0:16:14things you can phrase it a different way

0:16:15someone somewhere that it ends up being

0:16:17single command single response there is

0:16:20no semblance of a conversation for the

0:16:22most part except for in very rudimentary

0:16:24things will ever ask for confirmation or

0:16:26something or sometimes cereal ask for

0:16:29basic clarification but I would rather

0:16:31be able to speak in him even more

0:16:33offhand manner clarifying with a series

0:16:36of grunts yeah that's necessary right

0:16:39like you interact with people like that

0:16:40there is that there is context like that

0:16:42the thing doesn't entirely forget about

0:16:44the interaction you had three seconds

0:16:46ago when you make some other requests

0:16:48that it can figure out what you mean oh

0:16:49yeah I forgot also blah blah blah that

0:16:52hasn't forgotten the the previous

0:16:54context just basic conversation thing

0:16:57I'm not saying is you know it's got to

0:16:58have deep conversations with me and my

0:16:59name saying has to be like Eliza right

0:17:00but I feel like that's the next logical

0:17:03step into this right if Apple still

0:17:06can't even do multiple timers by the

0:17:08time the competitors get to the

0:17:11beginnings of a conversation phase we'll

0:17:13be lucky if Apple is being able to do

0:17:16the basics of all the things Marco

0:17:18listed in a flexible way a real-time

0:17:22follow-up I did ask Siri you know how

0:17:24old would Michael Jackson be today and I

0:17:25got a web search so no surprise there

0:17:28the trick for it by the way the trick

0:17:31for doing comparisons you got to make

0:17:33sure you were to make

0:17:34exactly the same way to be fair because

0:17:36I think that's the whole thing like I

0:17:37try to when I speak to the various

0:17:39cylinders I tried to just not think

0:17:41about syntax and just say whatever

0:17:42occurs to me because that's the test

0:17:44like a phrase it's a however I wanna

0:17:45phrase it but you have to remember how

0:17:47you phrased it which is convenient

0:17:48because it's recording your voice you'll

0:17:50play it back Casey that's all I hear

0:17:52remember how you phrase that and then do

0:17:55it word-for-word to Siri just to be fair

0:17:57yeah because you may say it a different

0:17:59way to Siri because now you're thinking

0:18:00about it and everything and if Siri gets

0:18:01wrong on one phrasing it's very

0:18:03sensitive to the exact position of you

0:18:04know all the things in the sentences or

0:18:06whatever we respond to this week by

0:18:08hellofresh a wonderful meal kit delivery

0:18:11service from $30 off your first week of

0:18:13hellofresh visit hellofresh comm and

0:18:15enter code ATP 30 at checkout hello

0:18:18fresh is a meal kit delivery service

0:18:20that shops plans and delivers your

0:18:22favorite step-by-step recipes and pre

0:18:25measured ingredients so you can just

0:18:26cook eat and enjoy hello fresh is very

0:18:30very easy to use you can choose your

0:18:32delivery day for when it works best for

0:18:34your schedule if you need to skip a week

0:18:36or even many weeks at a time you can

0:18:38just pause your account for as long as

0:18:39you'd like right in their app or on

0:18:41their website and all hello fresh

0:18:43ingredients come pre measured and handy

0:18:45labelled and meal kits so you know

0:18:47exactly which ingredients go with which

0:18:49recipe all this is delivered right to

0:18:52your door in recyclable insulated

0:18:54packaging and hellofresh offers a wide

0:18:57variety of chef curated recipes that

0:18:59change weekly there's lots of options

0:19:01here as well

0:19:02they also they even have three totally

0:19:04separate plans to choose from classic

0:19:06veggie and family classic of course is a

0:19:08variety of meat fish and seasonal

0:19:10produce veggie is all vegetarian recipes

0:19:12with plant-based proteins grains and

0:19:14seasonal produce and family as quickly

0:19:16easy meals with wonderful flavor the

0:19:18whole family will love hello fresh makes

0:19:21it so easy to cook delicious balanced

0:19:23dinners for less than ten dollars a meal

0:19:26it's wonderful not having to plan dinner

0:19:28every single night or having to spend

0:19:30money on takeout every night or worrying

0:19:32about gathering ingredients and having

0:19:33to waste a lot of them week after week

0:19:35so check out hellofresh today $30 off

0:19:38your first week visit hellofresh comm

0:19:40editor code ATP 30 at checkout once

0:19:43again I look at you $30 off your first

0:19:45week of hell

0:19:46fresh thank you so much - hello fresh

0:19:48for sponsoring our show so apparently

0:19:55there's going to be an onboarding screen

0:19:58for every single damn app on future

0:20:01versions of iOS we've seen a little of

0:20:04this trickle out over the last few

0:20:06months and how do you pronounce this

0:20:08it's a gear may Rambo mr. Rambo mr.

0:20:13Rambo who is underscore inside on

0:20:15Twitter he first jumped into my radar

0:20:19screen by being one of the people that

0:20:21was tag teaming with Steve trout and

0:20:23Smith during the home pod firmware I

0:20:27don't know

0:20:28picking about or you know the hyenas

0:20:31went and and picked at the home pod

0:20:33firmware but anyways he had tweeted

0:20:35earlier Apple is busy adding onboarding

0:20:38screens to every single iOS feature and

0:20:39here's a screenshot of welcome to videos

0:20:41browse your library watch anytime

0:20:43anywhere enjoy extras etc and mr. Rambo

0:20:47if you please has been going through

0:20:48other iOS features and finding similar

0:20:50things I don't get this I don't think

0:20:54it's necessarily bad even though in any

0:20:57time I get asked to make an onboarding

0:21:00screen I always fight tooth and nail to

0:21:02avoid it but I mean for for novice users

0:21:06or new users I don't think that's

0:21:07necessarily bad but what do you guys

0:21:09think about this let's start with Marco

0:21:10as a user when I am when I just install

0:21:14an iOS update and I get these screens in

0:21:18every app I try to use I'm annoyed by

0:21:20them I I don't like them as a user from

0:21:24Apple's point of view though from from

0:21:25the developer point of view like I see

0:21:27that side as well because I'm a

0:21:28developer and I've never had one of

0:21:30these screens in any of my apps but I

0:21:32kind of need them sometimes because when

0:21:36you when you're updating your software

0:21:40it's really hard to communicate to

0:21:43people when things have changed in a way

0:21:45that is helpful and not annoying and and

0:21:50and they will actually you know see or

0:21:51hear or you know remember this is a very

0:21:54hard problem and so there have been lots

0:21:57of times where I

0:22:00make a change and I'll you know mention

0:22:02it on the Twitter account or I'll write

0:22:04a blog post about it or something but

0:22:06the fact is like some tiny percentage of

0:22:08my audience actually looks at those

0:22:10things like most of the users of the app

0:22:12don't know when I've change anything I

0:22:14can put things in the app store update

0:22:16notes which I do but no one sees those

0:22:18either for the most part because

0:22:20everyone Auto updates and no one ever

0:22:21looks at the notes so it's it's really

0:22:25hard to communicate feature changes and

0:22:28improvements and and you know UI changes

0:22:30that aren't immediately obvious it's

0:22:32very hard to communicate that to an

0:22:34existing user base new users it isn't a

0:22:36problem as much because new users you

0:22:38know a they don't care what how things

0:22:39were before they got there so you don't

0:22:41have to tell them what things have

0:22:42changed and be new users tend to be more

0:22:45exploratory they'll like poke through

0:22:46settings screen stuff to select what the

0:22:47app can do so if you just added some

0:22:49settings or added some new features like

0:22:51they'll find them as they poke around

0:22:52the whole the whole rest of the app but

0:22:53how you communicate this to existing

0:22:56users is always a challenge

0:22:57so Apple faces the same problems than

0:23:01any other fail / does which is you know

0:23:03some small percentage of users of Apple

0:23:05devices pay attention when they like

0:23:07announce a new feature in a keynote or

0:23:09on on apple.com or whatever else but

0:23:12most of their customers don't see that

0:23:14and if even even the ones that do don't

0:23:16all remember it by the time they're

0:23:18actually using these things so Apple has

0:23:20the same problem that every other app

0:23:21developer has which is how do they

0:23:23communicate changes to their app or even

0:23:27do they communicate changes to their app

0:23:29which is a valid question to ask or do

0:23:31they just kind of let the app stand on

0:23:33its own and let people figure it out so

0:23:35this is Apple I think trying you know

0:23:39trying a new way of doing this so far

0:23:41they've really not communicated changes

0:23:43to the apps in the app stem cells

0:23:45they've usually just made the changes

0:23:47mention it in you know press events and

0:23:49stuff and that's it and people just kind

0:23:50of find them when they when they update

0:23:52and this is a different approach this is

0:23:55them saying you know what let's put up

0:23:56these little helpful sheets the first

0:23:58time you launch some of these apps

0:23:59saying hey here's what's new in this app

0:24:00in this version of iOS again I don't

0:24:04love these as a user but I see why they

0:24:08do it it solves a problem and it's not a

0:24:12great problem but it's it's a

0:24:14problem nonetheless and it solves it in

0:24:16not a great way but it might be like the

0:24:19least crappy way we've thought of so far

0:24:21so I don't object very strongly I see

0:24:26what they're trying to do it's annoying

0:24:28when I go to do something I have to go

0:24:30dismiss a screen instead of like doing

0:24:32the thing actual into that to do but

0:24:33that's a one-time annoyance and so if

0:24:36overall it helps people you know find

0:24:39stuff I guess I'm okay with that this is

0:24:43part of I mean the screenshots here from

0:24:46a phone right but they might do some

0:24:49other things in the iPad I don't know

0:24:50but part of the problem they're solving

0:24:55here is caused by the fact that the

0:24:58screens are just so darn small compared

0:24:59to a computer screen like in the

0:25:01personal computer world we've always had

0:25:03I mean there's a long history in the

0:25:06personal computer world the splash

0:25:07screen

0:25:07remember those where they were just put

0:25:09up a big box that puts the name of the

0:25:11application and maybe some credits and

0:25:13like some loading stuff for you to watch

0:25:15while your application takes a year in

0:25:16day to launch right that transition on

0:25:20the desktop - well the general move away

0:25:22from loading screens if you see a

0:25:24loading screen you know you're either

0:25:25using like Microsoft for an Adobe

0:25:26product or you're like back in time

0:25:28somewhere most desktop applications on

0:25:30the Mac anyway have moved far far away

0:25:32from any kind of splash screen right but

0:25:34there is a trend that started you know

0:25:36maybe a decade ago probably led by

0:25:38office or some other things to give you

0:25:40that screen I don't know what you call

0:25:41it that's probably a name for it where

0:25:44it shows a bunch of template's or like

0:25:46the first-run experience like tutorial

0:25:48click through next next next thing to

0:25:50show you screen shots of the app it's

0:25:52called ubi the out of box experience oh

0:25:54my god it's not coming out of a box yeah

0:25:58but yeah so that kind of thing and

0:26:00sometimes it doesn't even go away

0:26:01sometimes like in an office it's the

0:26:02preference you have to say every time I

0:26:04launch you know Excel don't show me the

0:26:06thing with a bunch of Excel templates

0:26:07I just don't show me that just open it

0:26:10and like you know I can handle it myself

0:26:12but in all cases in a desktop

0:26:14application on the Mac especially a

0:26:17buddy most desktop platforms there's a

0:26:20place that you can go to learn more

0:26:24about what this application can do

0:26:26whether it's to help make

0:26:27you or like Apple guide in the old days

0:26:29like there's some standard way to say

0:26:31what can I do in this application I know

0:26:34I see a bunch of menus up there but you

0:26:36know help me out and help very some

0:26:38application application sometimes it's

0:26:39just a limited thing that you can search

0:26:42but some applications have really

0:26:43comprehensive help or even if they just

0:26:44Chuck you to a website I think the the

0:26:47main thing that these screens are

0:26:49answering for new users who again they

0:26:51don't have to be told about changes or

0:26:53anything is what can I do in this

0:26:56application so if we look at that

0:26:57welcome to videos thing that in this

0:26:59tweet here it's not really telling you

0:27:01what changes last version it's like

0:27:03where's the video app do because if you

0:27:05just launch it forget the screen what is

0:27:06the first screen you see when you launch

0:27:07videos especially if you actually have

0:27:09no videos that's always the problem on

0:27:10iOS like what do you show when there's

0:27:11no stuff it's not really clear what you

0:27:15would use this application for so this

0:27:16is where you differ

0:27:17you know browse your library I find

0:27:19purchases and rentals you know watch

0:27:20anytime anywhere play videos over Wi-Fi

0:27:22or cell you download to watch offline

0:27:23and enjoy extras right I mean I would if

0:27:29I had to describe what you're doing the

0:27:30videos app I wouldn't have put that and

0:27:31enjoy extra thing but that's an

0:27:32important piece of information people

0:27:34might not know oh there might be special

0:27:37features associated with something I

0:27:39purchased and I can watch them here too

0:27:41and then it's so it's important to just

0:27:44convey that basic information but

0:27:46unfortunately unlike the desktop say

0:27:48what you're like most people and like

0:27:50yeah yeah like Marco said this is

0:27:51generally an annoyance and if you look

0:27:53in the Apple's old you know human

0:27:55interface guidelines they'd be like

0:27:56don't stop your user from doing what

0:27:59they set out to do by interrupting them

0:28:00with the thing that that you know just

0:28:03before you do what you want to do I want

0:28:04to tell you something about the videos

0:28:05that was like men oh yeah yeah I'm not

0:28:07whatever you're trying to tell me I

0:28:08don't care just let me get to the thing

0:28:09I want to do and you reflexively hit the

0:28:11continue button before you even register

0:28:13any words on the page right which I

0:28:15expect that to happen a lot but unlike

0:28:18in a desktop app you know how do you get

0:28:21this screen back if later you're

0:28:23wondering okay something I can do in the

0:28:25videos that were what is this video you

0:28:26happy even for you can't go to the help

0:28:28menu and say show me that first run

0:28:30experience thing again like I don't even

0:28:32know if there is a way to get this back

0:28:33once you've dismissed it other than

0:28:34waiting for the next OS update or

0:28:36something or resetting your ear thing

0:28:38and it's because there's just no

0:28:40standardized place

0:28:41iOS applications probably because the

0:28:43screen is so small to say where do I go

0:28:45to get help about this application or

0:28:47will there ever even be help within this

0:28:49application is it always something I

0:28:51have to do elsewhere and then but but

0:28:53not a thing that happens in the app and

0:28:56the final bit that I think Apple is

0:28:58leaning on here is the wish you were

0:29:01here people down at the bottom of this

0:29:02Apple's new little logo for privacy that

0:29:05shows two people shaking hands with each

0:29:07other part of that is marketing and that

0:29:10Apple wants to emphasize is one of its

0:29:12competitive advantages which is for

0:29:15every application that you launched this

0:29:16an Apple application we care about your

0:29:19privacy we'll tell you exactly how we're

0:29:20not using your information in a creepy

0:29:22way and and implicitly how everyone else

0:29:25is who doesn't have the similar

0:29:26disclosure is using your information in

0:29:28a creepy way so you should use Apple

0:29:29stuff that little logo I think Apple is

0:29:32trying to associate with the good

0:29:34information that you'll find linked from

0:29:36it is like when you see that logo that's

0:29:37Apple reminding you that they're the

0:29:38probably is a company that doesn't do

0:29:40creepy things and tap here on the small

0:29:42text to find out exactly how non creepy

0:29:44we are and the only way you get that in

0:29:46people's faces is if you put that in

0:29:48people's faces otherwise you know in the

0:29:50past Apple has not been doing creepy

0:29:53things with your data but there is no

0:29:55way as a user of these applications that

0:29:57you know that because you launched them

0:29:59they just show whatever their initial

0:30:00screen is and there's no indication in

0:30:01the application of exactly how creepy

0:30:03and applicate it is or isn't

0:30:04and so how Paul is relying on the fact

0:30:06that you trust them enough to believe

0:30:08them when they tell you that by the way

0:30:09we're not doing creepy stuff and they

0:30:11want to remind you of that so I have

0:30:14similar mixed feelings to Marco about

0:30:15the screen and that I understand the

0:30:16reasoning behind it but I but I think it

0:30:20is it is difficult to for it to fulfill

0:30:23its purpose because it's probably so

0:30:25easy to dismiss quickly because there's

0:30:27no way to get it back after you've done

0:30:28that and because it interrupts the user

0:30:32from doing what they wanted to doing yet

0:30:34I think most new users especially would

0:30:37benefit from not reflexively dismissing

0:30:40the screen from actually reading the

0:30:41three little bullet points so they know

0:30:43why you would ever want to launch the

0:30:45videos app or whatever now it can be

0:30:48taken to extremes here we have this a

0:30:50follow-up create from a micro sergeant

0:30:52that shows that what's new in clock

0:30:55yeah we're the only item is this splash

0:30:57screen literally just the splash screen

0:30:58what do you want from us but it still

0:30:59got the privacy bring up the bottom it

0:31:01was that real I assumed that was a

0:31:03Photoshop yeah it's fake but it's funny

0:31:05but like where does it where does this

0:31:08end so similar to the trend of desktop

0:31:10applications all opening up with like a

0:31:12template library create a new document

0:31:14pick from one of these 17 templates like

0:31:16just no just get out of my face right

0:31:17this type of thing can be annoying and

0:31:20if Apple does it it may encourage other

0:31:23people to do it and if every new iOS

0:31:25application you launched put one of

0:31:28these screens up it really amplifies the

0:31:31the you are stopping me from doing what

0:31:33I'm trying to do factor and it makes

0:31:36people even more quick on the draw to

0:31:40reflexively dismiss these things and it

0:31:42further emphasizes the fact that if you

0:31:43do reflexively dismiss it there's

0:31:45probably no standard way to get it back

0:31:47so I think this is a difficult problem

0:31:50that Apple is solving in a not-so-great

0:31:51way but I do understand why they're

0:31:53doing it yeah I mean like it's really

0:31:56hard you know as it's like it's really

0:31:57hard to figure out how to communicate

0:32:00change like this in your app but I think

0:32:03like yeah I think you know what I

0:32:04mentioned initially and what you guys

0:32:05kind of confirmed and clarified for me

0:32:06is like I think the biggest reason why I

0:32:08don't like these things is that it is

0:32:10almost never a good time when I see them

0:32:13it's like no I didn't come here to read

0:32:15what's new I came here to write

0:32:17something down really fast or do

0:32:19something like you know it's it - I came

0:32:21here doing a task that I don't have time

0:32:24right now to explore all the new

0:32:27features that you did for me and get to

0:32:29get through your marking language like

0:32:30the problem is like you know you know

0:32:33what percentage of the time and when

0:32:34people are first seen this is going to

0:32:35be that kind of context or the

0:32:37christendom breeze right by it even if

0:32:39people have time we are so conditioned

0:32:42to dismiss those screens that were not

0:32:43going to remember you know things that

0:32:44are on it you know it's one of the one

0:32:48of the most sad realities of interface

0:32:49design but this has been true forever

0:32:51and will always be true is that nobody

0:32:53reads anything like anything you're

0:32:55explaining by just like a couple of

0:32:56bullet points a text nobody will read it

0:32:59the very small handful to do won't

0:33:01remember it and so explaining things

0:33:05with text is just not very effective

0:33:08it's not you

0:33:08should never rely on that ultimately the

0:33:11best way to solve the problem of how do

0:33:15you communicate changes in your app is

0:33:17with the design of the app itself this

0:33:20isn't always possible this isn't always

0:33:21practical but ideally the changes should

0:33:25either be like not worth mentioning

0:33:27because the user doesn't care if it's

0:33:28like oh we under the hood change it's

0:33:30like well the user doesn't care

0:33:31great dude do the other changes makes

0:33:33you happy it makes your users happy that

0:33:34like things are faster or don't crash

0:33:36whatever else great don't need to

0:33:38mention that or it's like new features

0:33:40in which case like those will make

0:33:41themselves apparent in the interface as

0:33:42the user is using them it's hard these

0:33:45days not only is it hard on touchscreens

0:33:47because as you mentioned like they're so

0:33:48small that makes it hard for a lot of

0:33:51features to be visible because you don't

0:33:54have space on the screen to have like a

0:33:56toolbar button for everything the app

0:33:57can do but also modern design trends are

0:34:03such that you try to hide as much as

0:34:06possible in the main interface you try

0:34:09to make the main interface like as empty

0:34:11as possible everything looks super

0:34:14sparse and open the way Apple would

0:34:16phrase that is maximize your content

0:34:19they wouldn't say you're hiding things

0:34:21they would say you're allowing the

0:34:22content they've said with so many it so

0:34:24many sessions the content maximizing the

0:34:27content not minimizing UI but in effect

0:34:29you are hiding everything else if you're

0:34:31putting the content in front and that I

0:34:34think gets to what you were saying with

0:34:35you you know this is not a good time

0:34:37application to be telling me about your

0:34:38features right that's the beauty of the

0:34:41help menu when the user seeks out an

0:34:44item in the help menu that is their task

0:34:46at that point they're trying to learn

0:34:48more about the application that is

0:34:49exactly the time you should tell them

0:34:50more but there is no standardized

0:34:53interface element in iOS for almost

0:34:55anything like that it's part of the

0:34:57beauty of iOS that each application gets

0:34:58the entire screen back from the single

0:35:00testing model and maximizing the content

0:35:02all those are good trends but the lack

0:35:04of really any standardized interface

0:35:06element aside from the status bar which

0:35:08at least we know you can use to scroll

0:35:09to the top most of the time really does

0:35:12hurt discoverability if there was some

0:35:15kind of standard help widget that was

0:35:17the same across all apps that would be

0:35:20the perfect place to stash this because

0:35:22when people

0:35:22Apted they would be seeking out

0:35:23information about your application at

0:35:25that moment but it in the absence of

0:35:27that even if even if you have a great

0:35:29help widget in your app no one knows

0:35:30what it means or where it is or what it

0:35:32does because it's not standardized right

0:35:33and so we're forced to throw this in

0:35:37people's faces otherwise they will

0:35:38literally never see it oh yeah and and

0:35:40you know and part of that like you know

0:35:42a lot of a lot of I don't know people

0:35:45who haven't been around this stuff that

0:35:47long you know the kids these days or a

0:35:50lot of a lot of assumptions are made

0:35:52about current design trends that people

0:35:55project as universal design rules that

0:35:58have always and will always be the best

0:36:00and and the fact is right now we are in

0:36:04you know I'd say probably the the

0:36:07three-quarters point of a trend of ultra

0:36:09minimalism everywhere and the fact is

0:36:12that's just a style that's it that's

0:36:14been in fact it's been in style for a

0:36:15little while we have a little more of it

0:36:17to go probably that isn't necessarily

0:36:20the only or best way to design apps a

0:36:23lot of the minimalism of iOS apps and

0:36:27interfaces and getting out of the way

0:36:28for the content was born of limitations

0:36:31of the original iPhone hardware being a

0:36:33really small screen but as phones have

0:36:36gotten significantly bigger as also

0:36:39we've added things like iPads and

0:36:41possibly you know Mac through Bridge

0:36:44layers this fall we hope you know as

0:36:46we've added larger screens and more

0:36:48capability and everything the ultra

0:36:51minimalist thing doesn't necessarily

0:36:52work or doesn't carry over as well also

0:36:55the software like iOS started from zero

0:36:58with software I started with like every

0:37:00software gonna be one point out here and

0:37:02so no there weren't a lot of features in

0:37:05most apps for a long time and there

0:37:07still aren't on iOS apps but many apps

0:37:09now are pushing those boundaries and

0:37:11have developed over the last decade into

0:37:13very feature-rich

0:37:15very capable apps and the conventions of

0:37:20ultra minimalist you know hide

0:37:23everything design while they still look

0:37:26very nice they suffer greatly from

0:37:29discoverability and an affordances of

0:37:32like you know showing people what is

0:37:33possible or how to how to use things

0:37:36and this is again this is just a design

0:37:39trend of hide everything that won't last

0:37:43forever you know and and I honestly I

0:37:46think it's almost over because I think

0:37:48it's it's many usability flaws are

0:37:51really piling up and it's resulting in

0:37:54people having to do bad hacks like those

0:37:57splash screens you know like that's

0:37:59those are terrible hacks you know like I

0:38:02frequently tell the story about like

0:38:03when I first made the magazine app I

0:38:05thought it would be a good design

0:38:06principle to not need a settings screen

0:38:08and so I didn't have 11.0 and I tried I

0:38:11tried to get it I was just okay there's

0:38:12no settings anywhere or there's no

0:38:14settings screen right there anywhere

0:38:16let me just design the app to not need a

0:38:18settings screen wouldn't that be great

0:38:19wouldn't that be clean and modern and

0:38:21everything and the fact is to not have a

0:38:24settings screen I had to jump through

0:38:26hoops and the hoops I jumped through

0:38:29were worse than just having a setting

0:38:32screen and this is a very important like

0:38:35you know lesson that I learned at that

0:38:37time and a metaphor that had that I

0:38:40think is widely applicable by the way I

0:38:42still haven't listened every time I mean

0:38:43I have a stoop I have a significant

0:38:46design problem in overcast right now

0:38:48that I need to revert on the Now Playing

0:38:49screen just guess how many emails I get

0:38:52per day from people asking how to change

0:38:54the speed it's I have a significant

0:38:58problem that I need to redesign there

0:39:00but in our efforts to make things clean

0:39:03and simple and minimal usability suffers

0:39:08big time and I think we're finally

0:39:11starting to realize that but it's still

0:39:13an open question of how we are going to

0:39:16solve that going forward I think it's

0:39:19not just a design problem as obvious

0:39:21there's the obvious design thing and

0:39:22Apple isn't emphasizing that you know

0:39:24make make your content give it give it

0:39:27focus make it the primary thing you know

0:39:28it's the thing that people care about

0:39:29most people use all the features yeah

0:39:30I'm mostly good but especially on larger

0:39:34iOS devices which may include phones you

0:39:36know they're getting bigger at least

0:39:37they'll sell the SE but especially on

0:39:39iPads potentially even larger things

0:39:42part of it is up to the OS to provide

0:39:46standardized elements for things and

0:39:49a set of standardized elements you need

0:39:51for a 3.5 inch phone screen is not the

0:39:54same for the set of standardized

0:39:55elements that you need to make a really

0:39:56great application on a 12 point 9 inch

0:39:58iPad and getting back to the help menu

0:40:01not that I'm saying that they should add

0:40:02a menu bar but if you leave it up to

0:40:06even if this trend the design trend ends

0:40:09and everybody stops doing everything

0:40:10minimal and they start adding just

0:40:12toolbars and palettes everywhere if

0:40:14there is no standardization for that the

0:40:18toolbars and palettes in every

0:40:19application will be wildly different and

0:40:21users still won't know where to go for

0:40:23common functions like finding the help

0:40:25or any kind of guide or and you know any

0:40:27trend towards that or whatever may be I

0:40:29think one of the poster children for

0:40:31this was I forget what version it was

0:40:33but a couple of releases ago apples

0:40:35photos application that would launch and

0:40:38it would show like a highlight or mark

0:40:41up with things circled in yellow pen all

0:40:43over the screen with one of those

0:40:44overlays the worst I was at photos I

0:40:47know iMovie did that but it might have

0:40:49been lots of applications do this but

0:40:52because yeah they're they're not they're

0:40:55not going super minimal because a lot of

0:40:57those applications particularly Apple in

0:40:59that I'm thinking of that I can't

0:41:00remember the chatroom will tell me in a

0:41:01second they have tons of controls on the

0:41:03screen there are a lot of buttons maybe

0:41:05the minimalism is like a why aren't the

0:41:07buttons labeled they're all icons which

0:41:08is why they're so damn inscrutable but

0:41:10they were everywhere there was like 50

0:41:12of them on the screen and then they

0:41:13would circle them all with pen and say

0:41:15use this for this use this for this use

0:41:17this for this use this for this use it's

0:41:18like no one's ever gonna remember that

0:41:20no one's ever gonna read that no one's

0:41:22ever gonna be able to figure out how to

0:41:23bring it back and the reason you need it

0:41:25is because without that overlay nobody

0:41:27knows what any of those icons do because

0:41:28there is no standardization for you know

0:41:30toolbars for common functionality and

0:41:32it's somewhat like the Mac had the

0:41:34luxury of not having the sort of

0:41:37Cambrian explosion of applications that

0:41:39iOS did because a lot of the conventions

0:41:42let's say in graphics applications on

0:41:43the Mac it was like seeded by a Mac

0:41:46Paint and evolved slowly through like

0:41:49super paint and the Adobe applications

0:41:51to establish over the course of several

0:41:54important formative years the standard

0:41:57language for tools and design

0:41:59applications if you see a little Mickey

0:42:01Mouse glove

0:42:02everyone knows that's like the grabber

0:42:03thing if you see a paint bucket with

0:42:06paint pouring out of it everyone knows

0:42:07what that does like I'm so glad that you

0:42:10know that those those widgets have you

0:42:12know whoever owned the copyright on the

0:42:14first ones those didn't aggressively

0:42:15pursue it and say you can't use a paint

0:42:16bucket in your application because it

0:42:18wasn't Adobe who did it first it was

0:42:19Apple and you know so anyway there is a

0:42:22design language within graphics

0:42:24applications that even if you use a new

0:42:26graphics app you know where to find

0:42:28things but that's application level

0:42:30beyond that the help menu is a thing

0:42:31that Apple defines as the offender to

0:42:34say there is a menu bar the main user in

0:42:36this order the help system in this era

0:42:39of the Mac is this shape and in this

0:42:41position and here's what you can expect

0:42:43to find on it or the menu bar itself the

0:42:45fact that a menu bar exists applications

0:42:47didn't decide that the OS decided that

0:42:49again not saying that iOS needs a menu

0:42:51bar but that the combination of the OS

0:42:55and the applications develop a an

0:43:00interface language that means when you

0:43:02go from one really complicated

0:43:04application to another really

0:43:06complicated application you have a hope

0:43:08in hell of knowing how the second

0:43:11application works because hopefully it

0:43:13works in some way similar to the first

0:43:14one and the the model of iOS where the

0:43:17application owns the entire screen makes

0:43:19it very difficult to have any kind of

0:43:21consistency yeah maybe the buttons look

0:43:23the same and yeah maybe the little

0:43:24pop-up dialog things look the same and

0:43:26stuff but the application itself is

0:43:27almost like games where they can design

0:43:29their own interface entirely and that

0:43:30leads us down the path of Apple being

0:43:32forced to put a hilarious

0:43:34you know football style telestrator

0:43:37markup illustration covering its

0:43:39interface that no one's ever gonna

0:43:41remember and then having a thing go away

0:43:43and having you look at a bunch of

0:43:44hieroglyphics and go so I guess I'll

0:43:46just tap things randomly and see is this

0:43:48crop tool is this the crop tool is just

0:43:50I mean any crop tool they could just

0:43:53steal the icon from from the desktop

0:43:55applications but even that varies a lot

0:43:56so I think iOS has a long way to go even

0:44:00once we get over the design trend

0:44:02minimalism to have to realize the dream

0:44:06of the Mac that the the interface

0:44:08consistency allows you to understand how

0:44:10a new application would work by reusing

0:44:12knowledge about a previous application

0:44:14I mean I I'm not even sure that we're

0:44:17gonna have that again because the the

0:44:20companies and platforms these days are

0:44:22just so much bigger than they used to be

0:44:24like you know we Apple is a huge company

0:44:27now way bigger than even you know five

0:44:30ten years ago when when they were doing

0:44:33a lot of these like initial iPhone

0:44:34designs and everything they're way

0:44:36bigger now there are way more apps

0:44:37there's way more departments and

0:44:39divisions and services and apps and

0:44:42platforms and everything else like you

0:44:44know the Apple watch looks nothing like

0:44:46the rest of us Apple TV is a total is a

0:44:49whole different ballgame as well even on

0:44:51iOS there there's tons of different

0:44:54design languages like you have Apple

0:44:56music you have maps you have some of the

0:44:59older stuff that wasn't really that's

0:45:00still kind of very iOS 70 like there's

0:45:03there's all these different designs

0:45:05being followed now I'm not sure that

0:45:09modern Apple that that it's realistic to

0:45:11expect design coherency from them

0:45:15they're just too big there's too many

0:45:16things and and I think if there was any

0:45:19chance of design coherency it would

0:45:22happen now when design at Apple runs

0:45:26Apple like there is no more powerful

0:45:29department in Apple right now than in

0:45:31the design department they and they're a

0:45:33company that heavily prioritizes design

0:45:36it like heavily you know funds it with

0:45:38allocations of time and resources and

0:45:40everything else like if anybody could

0:45:42have a coherent design right now it's

0:45:44Apple and they don't I think the problem

0:45:46set is just too big now I don't think

0:45:48we're ever gonna see that kind of

0:45:50coherence like what we used to have

0:45:51again instead it's gonna be mostly left

0:45:55up to I think third parties to slowly

0:45:59evolve standards over over time that

0:46:03just kind of become you know the de

0:46:05facto standards and that's that's a much

0:46:08Messier and slower process but I think

0:46:10that's that's kind of what's gonna

0:46:12happen in reality I feel like the design

0:46:14department lately has not added any of

0:46:16new sort of standardized controls or

0:46:19standard you know standard interface

0:46:20elements they've mostly just been

0:46:21dressing up the ones that are there it's

0:46:24not as if iOS doesn't have these

0:46:25elements it doesn't again

0:46:28the same ones doesn't have a menu bar

0:46:29but just to give an example I don't mark

0:46:31out what tell him at the class name as a

0:46:32UI navigation controller the thing the

0:46:34the right-left thing with the back and

0:46:36done button I'm like that's been around

0:46:38since iOS since since iPhone OS 1.0

0:46:41iPhone OS firmware 1.0 like the fact

0:46:44that you have at the top of the screen

0:46:45you had you know left-to-right sliding

0:46:48transition interface they used to have

0:46:50the little arrow shape on it or whatever

0:46:51that was a standard interface element

0:46:54that you know it was the same way any

0:46:56standard interface element works hey you

0:46:58don't have to write this GUI widget

0:47:00we've actually written it for you and it

0:47:02provides some important functionality so

0:47:04now you don't have to worry about that

0:47:05part of application if you decide you

0:47:06want your application to be like

0:47:07master/detail view and you and you go

0:47:09into the right and out to the left and

0:47:11you want to have cancel and done buttons

0:47:12or slightly like we've provided that

0:47:14control for you so don't bother writing

0:47:15it and by providing it for you we

0:47:17standardized the interface so think of

0:47:19all the applications from the day one of

0:47:20the iPhone that worked that way where

0:47:22the top part of the screen was for you

0:47:24to go back and forth and there was done

0:47:25and cancel buttons and arrows and stuff

0:47:26like that that's a standard element that

0:47:29interface element is still with us

0:47:31despite the fact on top of our phone

0:47:32it's like a mile and a half away now and

0:47:34and in the iOS 7 days they've jammed

0:47:36other crap up there like the little

0:47:38arrow thing which is always look super

0:47:39weird from a aesthetic point of view

0:47:41that little tiny you know go back to

0:47:43Safari we're just super convenient

0:47:44functionality wise but it shows that

0:47:46didn't really anything but still that

0:47:48one interface element does provide an

0:47:51important degree of consistency across

0:47:52all applications not just apples because

0:47:55it generally does look the same and it

0:47:56generally does kind of work the same and

0:47:57people know to look and look up there

0:48:00for stuff but again if there had really

0:48:03been design innovation design being how

0:48:05it works and not just how it looks at

0:48:07some point you have to rethink the fact

0:48:08the top of the phone is really far away

0:48:09and at some point you have to think

0:48:12about are there other standard interface

0:48:15elements that are appropriate and the

0:48:16age of twelve point nine inch iPads that

0:48:18we should introduce standard removable

0:48:21palettes or tab interfaces like in

0:48:23Safari on the iPad or anything like that

0:48:24just any kind of standard interface

0:48:27element that other applications can use

0:48:28that is appropriate for the modern iOS

0:48:31usage the more of those they can produce

0:48:33including perhaps standard icons or

0:48:35widgets for things like help or you know

0:48:37a quick way to get to settings for an

0:48:39application from within an application

0:48:41if they don't want to give up on the

0:48:42whole idea of settings being a separate

0:48:43app which I think it's also a dinosaur

0:48:45of a bygone era of much less RAM usage

0:48:48and also the whole you know we don't

0:48:50want anything in our application so hide

0:48:51all the complexity into another

0:48:53application that never worked by the way

0:48:55yeah a lot of stuff needs to be

0:48:57rethought about the design of iOS and

0:48:59almost none of it has to do with what

0:49:00applications look like I feel like we

0:49:02need we need more we need more help from

0:49:06the the OS and the foundational classes

0:49:09to get to the next level of

0:49:12functionality on iOS applications I

0:49:14think that's mostly true I think to go

0:49:16back a step though part of the reason

0:49:18that I think we haven't standardized on

0:49:20anyone like design or anyone like a set

0:49:24of iconography is because it didn't take

0:49:27long in my recollection starting you

0:49:29know with iPhone OS 2 it wasn't too long

0:49:32after that that it became kind of blase

0:49:372 or maybe that's not the word I'm

0:49:39looking for but kind of gross to use

0:49:40vanilla UI kit for most of your app and

0:49:44I think that there's plenty of vanilla

0:49:47UI kit controls in any app but I mean

0:49:49looking at overcast is a great example

0:49:51there's plenty of Anila UI kit there but

0:49:53so much of it is hidden in so many

0:49:56different custom controls I mean look at

0:49:58the card interface Marco that you were

0:49:59rolling for a long time like that was

0:50:02completely and utterly custom and from

0:50:04what you said on the show and from what

0:50:05I've heard elsewhere you know you bent

0:50:06over backwards to do it and we can have

0:50:08a different discussion another time as

0:50:10to whether or not that was wise but the

0:50:11fact of the matter that I'm driving

0:50:12toward is that for better or worse one

0:50:15way or another in order to stand out on

0:50:17this ever more crowded App Store you

0:50:19need to have a more and more custom UI

0:50:23or at least in most cases that's the

0:50:26case I'm sure you could well actually me

0:50:28to death on this one but it seems to me

0:50:30that your average consumer be it design

0:50:32minded or otherwise tends to like things

0:50:35that are very opinionated and somewhat

0:50:37different I mean look at tweet bot is a

0:50:38great example of that I wouldn't say

0:50:40that I see a whole lot of vanilla UI

0:50:41Canton tweet bot but I would say that it

0:50:44looks like it belongs on the platform

0:50:46and it looks like it has its own

0:50:49personality and I would say the same of

0:50:50overcast actually and so I think because

0:50:52everyone was branching out in their own

0:50:54direction everyone

0:50:54creating their own personal or perhaps

0:50:57company-wide you know conventions and

0:51:00things I think that may be why we've

0:51:02splintered in so many different

0:51:03directions and that kind of bums me out

0:51:06partially because I'm really bad at

0:51:07customizing you like it to do weird

0:51:09things like Marco does but uh but it's

0:51:12it's understandable nevertheless because

0:51:14in this evermore crowded space you need

0:51:16to do something to stand out well you do

0:51:18need to be differentiated but that's

0:51:20separate from do you need to do like

0:51:22super custom controls like I think

0:51:24that's part of the skill of making an

0:51:26application in any platform is use

0:51:29standard controls but add some kind of

0:51:32branding and flair to them and and I

0:51:34think every application also needs at

0:51:35least one or two unique interface

0:51:37elements because it historically

0:51:39advances in the sort of quote/unquote

0:51:41standard UI have very often come from

0:51:43third parties like the first you know

0:51:45just look at pull-to-refresh for crying

0:51:47out loud on iOS but I was gonna do is a

0:51:49bunch of old Mac examples granted Mac

0:51:51paint seeded a lot of the the DNA of

0:51:55graphic applications across all GUI

0:51:56platforms but subsequent applications

0:51:59like you know illustrator and super

0:52:02paint and and Photoshop especially had

0:52:05their own innovations in UI that

0:52:09informed the whole rest of the the genre

0:52:13um and in the best case new interface

0:52:16elements whether they be tabs or

0:52:18whatever you know should eventually be

0:52:20co-opted by the OS and become standard

0:52:25control so I'm not saying Apple has to

0:52:26do it all but I think you can get away

0:52:28with having an application that is a

0:52:30hundred percent standard controls with a

0:52:33little bit of flair plus one or two

0:52:36things that totally don't look like

0:52:37standard controls even if they are under

0:52:39the covers that they give you want your

0:52:41app to have personality right like tweet

0:52:43bot has a personality and you wanted to

0:52:46have some some kind of differentiating

0:52:48thing like oh this is this feature the

0:52:49only this application has this UI

0:52:51element is fun to use flicking the thing

0:52:53away or whatever and if that's really a

0:52:55great idea

0:52:56a couple years down the line Apple

0:52:58should adapt the iOS interface say oh

0:53:01here's a way you can pop up sort of a

0:53:03thing on the screen and people can flick

0:53:04it away in a like physics-based you know

0:53:06fun kind of way

0:53:07if so many applications do that that

0:53:09should be a standard type thing and that

0:53:12that should be the feedback cycle I

0:53:13don't think you need to go even on iOS I

0:53:16don't think you need to go whole hog and

0:53:17say everything I do is custom it's

0:53:20basically a game like every one of my

0:53:22controls awesome because that's like I

0:53:25said it's too much differentiation

0:53:26because maybe like people still do like

0:53:29that but you're in for a world of hurt

0:53:30and I think it's not necessary you do

0:53:33want people to notice you but you don't

0:53:35need to like reinvent everything

0:53:39especially with the flexibility Apple

0:53:41gives you in most modern UI Kate

0:53:43controls you can really customize them

0:53:44to look almost nothing like what they

0:53:45what you would think they look like

0:53:47generic things like the collection

0:53:49abused and stuff where you have a lot of

0:53:50control over exactly what is drawn on

0:53:51the screen like you can make a

0:53:53collection view into something that no

0:53:55longer resembles a collection view at

0:53:56all with some cleverness right so I

0:53:59think I think app developers have the

0:54:04freedom to be differentiable staying on

0:54:05standard controls but I still think it's

0:54:07on Apple to see what's out there

0:54:09see what's popular see what's works and

0:54:11come up with some of their own

0:54:13innovations to give a better pallet of

0:54:16tools in the end the interface builder

0:54:18sense even if nobody uses that in iOS -

0:54:21I wouldn't say that I wouldn't say that

0:54:23well I don't know it's popular these

0:54:24days with the kids but - to be able to

0:54:26say I'm gonna make the next great iPad

0:54:30graphics application of which there are

0:54:31many and but I you know I don't want to

0:54:36have to invent everything from all cloth

0:54:38I want to you know I want Apple to help

0:54:41me here by saying oh are you gonna have

0:54:43floating palettes in your graphics

0:54:45application but we have a standard

0:54:46control for that because everyone seems

0:54:47to be making their own all the way down

0:54:49to all the little experiments speaking

0:54:50of Steve trout and Smith earlier of like

0:54:52floating with quote/unquote Windows or

0:54:53whatever stuff like that if it comes

0:54:56from a third-party application first and

0:54:57its popular fine but that's exactly the

0:55:00type of stuff that Apple should be

0:55:01looking into trying to figure out a more

0:55:04sophisticated bucket of parts for people

0:55:06to build their fancy iOS applications

0:55:09out of yeah and I think it's it's also

0:55:11worth pointing out like the timing of

0:55:13talking about this now I think is

0:55:15interesting because the iPhone 10 I

0:55:18think really changes a lot of

0:55:21how things in iOS should be designed you

0:55:24know again it's this isn't news I'll go

0:55:26boy I'll be quick but like we have now

0:55:28like culminated this this this trend

0:55:31that we've been going on for a little

0:55:32while now with the plus phones we're now

0:55:35a lot of iOS interfaces have critical

0:55:40functions and buttons and things on the

0:55:42top area of the screen which is now very

0:55:45hard to reach for a lot of people a lot

0:55:48of the time on a lot of devices and so

0:55:51this is like a fundamental thing that so

0:55:55much of iOS design has been based on

0:55:58putting important controls in those top

0:56:00corners and now that should be rethought

0:56:03I'm sure Apple is feeling this too

0:56:06I'm sure they are thinking about this

0:56:07and are hopefully working on this but

0:56:12this is also a time where they have a

0:56:14lot of software quality problems that

0:56:15they have to like slow down on the like

0:56:18move forward aggressively side of things

0:56:20to let the quality catch up really we've

0:56:25heard rumblings here and there that

0:56:27maybe there was some kind of iOS 12

0:56:30redesign plan but then maybe that's been

0:56:32pushed to next year and next version of

0:56:35iOS because of the of the quality push

0:56:37that seems reasonable to me

0:56:40and so assuming that either it's coming

0:56:43this year or next year I do expect Apple

0:56:45is probably working on a big iOS

0:56:48redesign to better accommodate the

0:56:51iPhone 10 not to mention that I just

0:56:54think you should need to update the look

0:56:55and feel of it to just be you know fresh

0:56:58and and new and no longer iOS 7 stale

0:57:01but I do expect that to happen soon I

0:57:04hope it does and even if even if it's

0:57:08next year for quality reasons that's

0:57:09fine with me

0:57:09I really would love to see what Apple

0:57:12has in mind for a coherent direction to

0:57:16bring iOS in now I hope we get that I

0:57:20don't think it's a sure thing that we

0:57:22will ever get that because of what I

0:57:23said earlier but I hope we get that

0:57:25whether it's this year next and I really

0:57:27look forward to seeing what they think

0:57:29the direction is I hope it's not just

0:57:31for the iPhone 10 because I think as

0:57:33much as the iPhone 10 needs it

0:57:34because things really are farther away

0:57:36from your thumb they ever have been it's

0:57:37not like the plus ones have been around

0:57:39for a while but I feel like the iPad

0:57:41needs it more because I do see a lot of

0:57:42people I mean a lot of us gravitations

0:57:45use with the pencil but I see a lot of

0:57:46increasingly sophisticated applications

0:57:48on the iPad and they all still look like

0:57:50games to me in terms of the interface I

0:57:51see very little consistency among them

0:57:54everybody having to roll their own

0:57:55controls for everything which increases

0:57:57the barrier to entry for good graphics

0:57:59applications like I just think of

0:58:01something like acorn which I'm sure has

0:58:02some custom interface elements but in

0:58:04general it's using app kit to its

0:58:06fullest effect taking advantage of all

0:58:07the controls Apple gives to design an

0:58:10interface doesn't look like other

0:58:11graphics application interfaces but it

0:58:13looks Mac like you know how it's going

0:58:14to work and the fact that I mean both on

0:58:18the front end on the back end that a

0:58:19corner is able to leverage the

0:58:21frameworks that apple provides for UI

0:58:23and for image processing itself allows a

0:58:26one-person software shop to make a

0:58:28graphics application that is basically

0:58:30like a mini Photoshop that's that's the

0:58:33platform advantage that Apple should be

0:58:34selling come develop on our platform

0:58:36look what a single person can do it's

0:58:37unbelievable on on the iPad I feel like

0:58:41maybe it's the only three people teams

0:58:43but I feel like it just looks like a

0:58:44hell of a lot of work to make a top-tier

0:58:47iPad graphics application and that when

0:58:50you're done you have unless you exactly

0:58:53ape your competitors interface you have

0:58:55little chance of being familiar to the

0:58:57users of your competitors product so

0:58:58your pitches now use my application

0:59:01which has fewer features and by the way

0:59:02the interface looks nothing like your

0:59:03interface and it works totally

0:59:05differently so come learn from scratch

0:59:06it's a tough sell we are sponsored this

0:59:09week by Linode go to lynda.com slash ATP

0:59:13and use code ATP 2018 to get a $20

0:59:16credit to your Linode plan Linode is a

0:59:20wonderful web host they have the fastest

0:59:23most efficient SSD cloud servers and you

0:59:26can get one yourself starting at just $5

0:59:29a month that $5 plan gets you one gig of

0:59:31ram these days that's awesome anyway I

0:59:34don't know of a better value in the web

0:59:35hosting business and you if you know of

0:59:38course you can scale up from there they

0:59:39have all sorts of plans including high

0:59:42memory plans that start at 16 gigs and

0:59:44you know if you need lots of RAM maybe

0:59:46not so much the other stuff you can get

0:59:48for a more manageable price it's

0:59:50wonderful Lin owed you that you can get

0:59:52a server running in under a minute

0:59:54if you need any help at all they have

0:59:5624/7 support they even have phone

0:59:58support if you need that