Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

269: Cooled by Jellyfish

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

1:00:00they're beings for harbor today but

1:00:01assuming that they are cuz this was kind

1:00:03of weirdly tied to the macro and this PR

1:00:04thing they should just make the kind of

1:00:07computer that has the most you can

1:00:09possibly have in it for this role like

1:00:12for like the Mac Pro it's a tower

1:00:14there's no limitations really on power

1:00:17consumption or price or size so give it

1:00:22the most you can get when you're making

1:00:23a laptop you want to have something

1:00:25that's portable presumably thin and

1:00:27light if you can get it there has a good

1:00:28battery life but within but other than

1:00:30that make it as versatile as possible

1:00:33this is an argument I always have with

1:00:34people who are like well you why do you

1:00:37need the SD card slot I never used mine

1:00:39so I'm glad they removed it that's these

1:00:42are versatile general purpose machines

1:00:44they should have commented as much as

1:00:46possible removing anything should not be

1:00:49considered a feature except wait that's

1:00:52the only thing that should be considered

1:00:54a feature of removing like everything

1:00:56else like these should accommodate as

1:00:58much as possible so to try to pick like

1:01:02a few certain narrow use cases or a few

1:01:06certain industries or types of quote Pro

1:01:08users which is meaningless to say like

1:01:10we're gonna optimize it or we're gonna

1:01:12design it to accommodate these things it

1:01:15makes like a like a spiky or peaky

1:01:18design instead of something that is more

1:01:20versatile that can accommodate a

1:01:22well-rounded group of things people

1:01:24might want to do with these computers

1:01:25the way to properly design computers is

1:01:27to cover as much as possible not as

1:01:31little as possible and I and this is

1:01:34that this has been a design conflict

1:01:37between me and Apple for a long time

1:01:40well for recent years especially I wish

1:01:43that the products we were getting out of

1:01:44Apple were just more general-purpose

1:01:47more versatile the 2013 Mac Pro went in

1:01:51the other direction and flopped

1:01:53miserably the 2013 Mac Pro is saying

1:01:56let's take all the different things

1:01:57people can do with the old Mac Pro

1:01:58towers so many different configurations

1:02:00possible for so many different kinds of

1:02:02uses and priorities and budgets and

1:02:03everything else and then they made this

1:02:06little trashcan thing that was optimized

1:02:09for like one use case and one type of

1:02:12customer they replace this in

1:02:14credible versatile broad-reaching

1:02:16product with a very narrow one and it

1:02:19flopped I can make many parallels to the

1:02:23laptop lineup right now I hope that they

1:02:27have learned some lessons from the 2013

1:02:30Mac Pro and from the negative reactions

1:02:32to 2016 MacBook Pro and I hope they're

1:02:35gonna start giving us more broad

1:02:38products the iMac Pro is a pretty good

1:02:41start in that direction I want to see

1:02:43more from the Mac Pro so it really

1:02:46depends on how they're using these

1:02:47people because they don't go into that

1:02:48much detail I think said I didn't tell

1:02:50you when they were formed they just like

1:02:51oh they're right down the hall and yes

1:02:52they're influencing the Mac Pro and so

1:02:54on so I can think of lots of good users

1:02:56these people this gets to the to my

1:02:57point earlier about it's apples job to

1:03:00make a good product the people they

1:03:02consult aren't making the product aren't

1:03:05dictating the product design like

1:03:06they're just one input and you have to

1:03:08know what what input do you actually

1:03:12want from these people you don't want

1:03:14them just to just go in there with a

1:03:15blank sheet of paper and say here pros

1:03:17what kind of computer would you like us

1:03:18to build and they all draw a picture of

1:03:19their home or car and you go great we'll

1:03:20build that and then you build it as

1:03:22terrible no one likes and you can't

1:03:23figure out what you did wrong like an

1:03:25apples not doing that I'm sure right

1:03:26right you but there is valuable feedback

1:03:30to be harvested from them to your point

1:03:32markup to make a general-purpose

1:03:34computer that that doesn't have doesn't

1:03:37have stupid limits right so to give to

1:03:40give some examples that might sound

1:03:41silly but I think is is hopefully

1:03:43exactly the kind of feedback they're

1:03:45getting from these people for the Video

1:03:46Editor examples I'm going to make up

1:03:47stuff by video wedding cuz I don't know

1:03:48anything about it right but say the

1:03:50video editors say that they they never

1:03:53put their computers on their desk they

1:03:54always have it like underneath there in

1:03:56like a some standard cabinet or Bay or

1:03:58something or whatever right and for it

1:04:02to be there the cords that connect from

1:04:05the monitor to the computer have to be

1:04:07some length and they could say the last

1:04:10monitor you made the cords are never

1:04:12long enough so we have to buy extenders

1:04:14and extenders are flaky or the you know

1:04:17the bus doesn't doesn't support cords of

1:04:19that length and it's kind of annoying

1:04:20and same deal with the input devices

1:04:23because of the distances if you just

1:04:25made all your cords like a foot longer

1:04:27there would be so much less frustrating

1:04:29that's valuable feedback because it's

1:04:32just saying look this is how people like

1:04:33to arrange their stuff it seems like a

1:04:35minor issue but if we don't do this if

1:04:37we make our codes like Accords the

1:04:39normal length it's gonna be annoying to

1:04:42these people in the same way the

1:04:43five-second long Final Cut Pro Windows

1:04:44it is annoying like they can get around

1:04:46it the product is not dead on arrival

1:04:48but it's a thing we wouldn't have

1:04:51thought of have we hadn't if we hadn't

1:04:53talked to real people who use them in a

1:04:54certain situation and it's a thing we

1:04:57can do it's not dictating the design of

1:04:59the computer just make the cords a

1:05:01little longer I have to think that they

1:05:02had a similar type of reason for the

1:05:06ridiculously long charger cord for the

1:05:07the Apple watch you know the core for

1:05:11that thing is like well sometimes the

1:05:12outlet is like behind the headboard of

1:05:15the bed in the middle and to reach the

1:05:16nightstand it has to be pretty darn long

1:05:18and yeah people can use an extension

1:05:19cord but that's kind of annoying so

1:05:23we're just gonna include a really long

1:05:25cord stuff like that is exactly the kind

1:05:31of hardware feedback that you can get

1:05:33without saying oh whatever hardware you

1:05:37need for your three specific specialties

1:05:40we're just going to build something that

1:05:41does that and then leave someone out in

1:05:42the cold who wants to do like MRI

1:05:43imaging it's like well I don't want

1:05:44about any of those people want I want

1:05:46something else entirely so they should

1:05:48be making a general-purpose flexible

1:05:50computer but if they can you know to the

1:05:53the goal of accommodating more use cases

1:05:55is you have to talk to all sorts of

1:05:57people these people want to for longer

1:05:58record these people don't want any

1:06:00lights in the front or you have to be

1:06:02able to disable the lights like stuff

1:06:03like that but you can just do that it

1:06:05when you look at the whole computer like

1:06:07why are the cords so long and who cares

1:06:09about turning off the lights I certainly

1:06:10don't care about turning off the lights

1:06:12and why does it have like slots in front

1:06:14end and back or why are they a why are

1:06:15they on the side instead of over here

1:06:17it's like you shrug your shoulders and

1:06:19say whatever it's fine for me but to

1:06:21make a machine that accommodates the

1:06:23most possible use cases that's

1:06:25worthwhile feedback on a hardware level

1:06:27you still you don't want it to be the

1:06:29Homer and have everything that everybody

1:06:30wants because it stops being coherent at

1:06:32some point but that kind of feedback in

1:06:36the feedback I mentioned before of like

1:06:37please don't make something that like

1:06:41is cooled by gel and magnetically

1:06:43levitates and you know is a bunch of

1:06:46boxes that snap together with magnets

1:06:48like we don't nobody wants that like

1:06:50nope I know you think it's cool but I

1:06:53guess you know but I mean say we as

1:06:54professionals talk to everybody talk to

1:06:56the video better talk to the audio

1:06:57editors talk to the scientific people

1:06:58nobody wants that and and the people who

1:07:01think it's cool they're not the ones

1:07:03buying matter exactly otherwise we're

1:07:05gonna complain the to expense and so so

1:07:08I think you know that feedback is is

1:07:11good to consent on the right path but

1:07:13after that it's just a matter of finding

1:07:14out all the little little things that

1:07:17are easy for Apple to do that can go a

1:07:18long way that I mean and that's perfect

1:07:21for Apple to brag about like in their

1:07:22presentation say and we've learned that

1:07:24you know again I'm making up all this

1:07:25stuff because I don't use them as

1:07:26contacts it was like and we learned that

1:07:27in certain studios people don't like to

1:07:29have lights so if you want to turn off

1:07:30all the lights on you on your thing you

1:07:32turn them off and the audience would

1:07:33applaud if they were if they also knew

1:07:35about this whole light thing right

1:07:36that's that's the type of feedback

1:07:38they're getting is that it for now III I

1:07:44don't know what to do

1:07:45don't worry there'll be more don't worry

1:07:47yeah they didn't actually release that

1:07:50much new information so all we can do is

1:07:53speculate oh and I guess related to this

1:07:56and how I got on this topic but I was

1:07:59wandering YouTube looking at fancy PC

1:08:03towers and there are some cool ones

1:08:06because I you know this is sort of I

1:08:08don't know like Mac Pro methadone right

1:08:11I'm just I can't I don't have any news

1:08:14about a Mac Pro so I can just go look at

1:08:15other things and say if the Mac Pro was

1:08:17like this it would be neat like I saw

1:08:19one recently that was a tower like a

1:08:22mini tower PC with no fans like

1:08:26passively cooled but with reasonably

1:08:28modern hardware in it like no fans that

1:08:31is a certain appeal doesn't it right and

1:08:33you know it obviously outperforms any

1:08:35Mac ever sold right because it's a PC

1:08:37you know with the real video card and

1:08:39everything it's not the fastest video

1:08:42card you can get an anna bc but it was

1:08:44fast

1:08:44I was like no fans really it wasn't even

1:08:47that big it didn't even get that hot I

1:08:49was like wow if Apple and this by the

1:08:51way Apple don't do this none of your

1:08:53pros are asking for No

1:08:54but if if this was like an avenue of

1:08:58weirdness that they made like instead of

1:09:00making the trashcan they instead decided

1:09:02you know Steve Jobs still odd this is

1:09:04that the thing I can imagine him getting

1:09:06it being his butt about and saying let's

1:09:08try and make it with no fans he'd like

1:09:09but Steve nobody wants that bit I said

1:09:11no fans like the original Macintosh by

1:09:15the way I had no fans in it right and

1:09:17like that's more difficult and it got a

1:09:20little bit too hot inside there and they

1:09:22eventually put fans in the max

1:09:23eventually they're like Steve we kind of

1:09:25really need to like fine all right fine

1:09:27put fan sent fine make the Rama seat

1:09:29really expandable to phyto kilobytes I'm

1:09:30you don't think you're ever gonna need

1:09:31it but anyway sometimes it's not great

1:09:34to listen to Steve Jobs but if they made

1:09:36a Mac prototype thing where the design

1:09:39goal was for no no no good reason to

1:09:42make it have no fans I think they could

1:09:45still make a good one it would be stupid

1:09:46it would be less flexible to having fans

1:09:48but it put it this way it would be

1:09:50better than trashcan you can make

1:09:51actually a pretty good conventional

1:09:53tower looking fanless thing that it has

1:09:56much more flexibility than the trashcan

1:09:58which is more of a condemnation that a

1:09:59trash can than endorsement for something

1:10:01the Apple could do it yeah but to do it

1:10:03it would have to be really big and

1:10:05really ugly things that Apple would

1:10:07never do not that big you should I'll

1:10:08send you a youtube link it's smaller

1:10:10than the regular is way smaller than my

1:10:11cheese grater it's pretty amazing the

1:10:14amazing things you can do we if you

1:10:15apply large amounts of metal in large

1:10:17amounts of surface area so tell me this

1:10:21is gonna come across really snarky and I

1:10:23don't mean it to but I do the same sort

1:10:28of thing that Marco does for a living

1:10:30and if you exclude gaming I do the same

1:10:34sort of thing that John does for a

1:10:36living I can do my job on a MacBook on a

1:10:4215-inch MacBook Pro on an iMac and I

1:10:45have done and will continue to do my job

1:10:48on any of those things there is no part

1:10:52of me that feels like I need or even

1:10:54really want a Mac Pro because presumably

1:10:57if the iMac Pro is something like five

1:10:59grand the Mac Pro is probably going to

1:11:02be one and a half that twice that three

1:11:04times that

1:11:05I I don't really understand why someone

1:11:11who writes code the kind of code that

1:11:14the three of us write anyway why does

1:11:16one need a MacPro

1:11:18unless you want it to last 40 years and

1:11:22for Marco you go through that you go

1:11:24through computers as quickly as you go

1:11:26through underwear so that's not a

1:11:27concern for you and I'll give you a

1:11:30cop-out which which I can't argue with

1:11:32and it's that I am the most impatient

1:11:35human alive and damn it I will wait as

1:11:38little time as possible for anything to

1:11:39happen on my computer and that is I

1:11:41don't personally think it's worth 5 or

1:11:4310 or whatever grand to to be that

1:11:47impatient but you know if you do that's

1:11:49fine that's that's your math that's your

1:11:50business that's fine but do you know

1:11:52what I mean like it seems kind of silly

1:11:54like why does any of the three of us

1:11:56need a MacPro

1:11:57why do you need a fancy BMW to drive

1:12:00yourself to work you could take a moped

1:12:01or you could walk walk would be a

1:12:05stretch moped would probably end up with

1:12:07me dead the right answer you're looking

1:12:09for the right answer you're looking for

1:12:11is with a Chevy Volt

1:12:13or just like the cheapest you know you

1:12:15could you could get by with like you

1:12:16know it's a little like you know the

1:12:18cheap cheap little two-door you know

1:12:19ikana box like why do you have a nice

1:12:22car why you know why you have a car that

1:12:24is fast as opposed to like you can still

1:12:26we're driving the same places right like

1:12:29this car analogy definitely has some

1:12:30legs looking at an article right now

1:12:36from 2013 that has the picture of a

1:12:39beautiful matte finish LFA here we go

1:12:43case you're back for a successor this is

1:12:46exactly the reason because we're car

1:12:47guys that's why that's why that though I

1:12:50don't buy that well I mean it isn't a

1:12:53perfect analogy because you know there

1:12:55are certain capabilities that you know

1:12:57higher-end computers offer you that you

1:12:59know that aren't necessarily always the

1:13:01case are always available on lower end

1:13:02ones yeah it's it's even more

1:13:04justifiable than right yeah exactly but

1:13:06it's you know it's it's almost kind of

1:13:09like saying like you know why like why

1:13:10get a pickup truck

1:13:11if you don't usually haul stuff you know

1:13:14but some people just like pickup trucks

1:13:15a lot and they're and that's you know

1:13:17they get pleasure out of that and

1:13:19like who cares right and maybe sometimes

1:13:21they do occasionally have to haul stuff

1:13:23and it wouldn't have fit in their Civic

1:13:24like buying more than you technically

1:13:27need is something to consider if you're

1:13:29you know outfitting a business with

1:13:3110000 pcs when you're an individual

1:13:34who's a computer enthusiast and you have

1:13:36a little bit of extra money and you can

1:13:37buy yourself a really nice computer

1:13:38there's nothing wrong with buying more

1:13:41computer than you need yes we do the

1:13:43same job in a lot of ways and by the way

1:13:47development is a very big and diverse

1:13:50field that many people have many

1:13:53different needs and as I was spouting

1:13:55off on Twitter earlier about I think the

1:13:58true developer computer is the MacBook

1:14:00Pro like the MacBook Pro is by far the

1:14:02more commonly used computer for

1:14:04developers than the Mac Pro the Mac Pro

1:14:06is much more commonly used by non

1:14:09developers for you know things like

1:14:11video farms and stuff like that like

1:14:13it's really not frequently used by

1:14:16software developers in my my knowledge

1:14:18and experience the MacBook Pro really is

1:14:20is that but you know I could do my job

1:14:24on a map a pro I have done my job on a

1:14:26MacBook Pro I spent years do my job

1:14:28groans it's fine I'm happier and I think

1:14:33I'm more productive and at least certain

1:14:35things are much faster using my cool new

1:14:37iMac pro before this I use an iMac which

1:14:40is basically a MacBook Pro that's

1:14:42stationary that was also really great

1:14:44for years and that was good enough but I

1:14:47can get a better one and I really you

1:14:49know in the same way that you really

1:14:51value having a nice fast car I really

1:14:54get a lot of pleasure out of having a

1:14:55nice fast Mac to do my work on we don't

1:14:58need any of these things in the in most

1:15:01senses we get them because you know some

1:15:04people really do need the extra

1:15:05horsepower we're like you know if I was

1:15:08actually encoding video all day and my

1:15:10encodes could be like four times faster

1:15:13than they could on a MacBook Pro or on

1:15:15an iMac I'm burgler iMac then yeah I

1:15:17think I could justifiably say you know

1:15:19this is worth it to my job because it's

1:15:21it's saving a vast amount of time

1:15:23throughout the day for me the game isn't

1:15:26that big between this and something a

1:15:27little more pedestrian but there is

1:15:29still a gain like every time I build and

1:15:32run

1:15:32in Xcode like I'm doing this a lot

1:15:33throughout the day and it is faster on

1:15:35this than it was on my old iMac not by

1:15:37hours faster it's not our faster but

1:15:40it's seconds faster and I do that I do

1:15:41it a lot so it's better this this

1:15:44computer is able to do things basically

1:15:48anything I ask it to do in near silence

1:15:50I have yet to hear the fan spin up I was

1:15:53maxing out all ten cores the other day

1:15:55importing a big lightroom import and I

1:15:57didn't hear the fans at all the entire

1:15:59time I've encoded video I have encoded

1:16:014k video didn't hear the fans at all

1:16:04it's wonderful and so none of us Orwell

1:16:07few of us actually quote need these

1:16:12machines but that's not to say this on a

1:16:15market for them just like nobody needs a

1:16:17car that can go zero to 60 in 2.5

1:16:19seconds but there's a whole lot of

1:16:21people who would sure like one I were

1:16:24going further to further away from

1:16:26trying to justify it although there are

1:16:27definitely justifications basically the

1:16:29same justification says anybody who uses

1:16:31a tool to do a job like Parker was

1:16:32saying you could edit video on a MacBook

1:16:34Air but you're gonna be miserable

1:16:35compared to if you had a bigger faster

1:16:37computer if you do it for the living so

1:16:39I mean anytime you do anything for a

1:16:40living you want like the best tools for

1:16:41it even if it's not a straight time as

1:16:43money thing so there is that

1:16:44justification but I think the more

1:16:46important thing in that the pitch I was

1:16:48trying to make in this old article from

1:16:49before they introduced the trash can was

1:16:51that it's important to the company to to

1:16:56reach for this particular star uh you

1:16:58know for to try to make the biggest best

1:17:02fastest most powerful whatever they're

1:17:07doing that with the phone every every

1:17:09year they try to make the best most

1:17:12powerful phone like the iPhone 10 like

1:17:15it's not kind of like we think this is a

1:17:18pretty good phone like it's kind of fast

1:17:20like it's the best fastest coolest thing

1:17:23they know how to make with all the best

1:17:25specs it's better than everything you

1:17:27know they're they're always reaching for

1:17:28the stars there and that's that's a good

1:17:29Sumer product but for the pro stuff it's

1:17:31you know the hella car analogy right

1:17:33you're not gonna make a lot of money

1:17:35from it you're not gonna sell a lot of

1:17:36them most people don't need one nobody

1:17:40needs one but having it exists not even

1:17:44buying it like please I'm I'm in

1:17:46karzai by honda chords right but just

1:17:49people knowing that it exists that that

1:17:52these cars are out there and that this

1:17:54is the company that makes them raises

1:17:56the prestige of that company and is

1:17:58interest interesting from a sort of

1:18:02human achievement perspective yes it's

1:18:03not the same as the space race but it's

1:18:05it's similar like it you did someone is

1:18:08out that you know Ferraris out there

1:18:09making Ferraris even if I never buy one

1:18:11certainly I don't need one and even if I

1:18:13never buy one I you know spend hours

1:18:16reading about them in magazines and

1:18:18looking at them and get excited when I

1:18:19see one and it changes my opinion of

1:18:23what cars can be and you know like it

1:18:26gives me a different view of Ferrari

1:18:28than if they just made SUVs and Apple

1:18:32I think should always continue to push

1:18:35up against this envelope regardless how

1:18:37many people buy it just because for the

1:18:39same reason I use the Viper and then in

1:18:42the thing because it was a direct quote

1:18:43from the magazine I've been reading

1:18:44where that you know the car guys wanted

1:18:45to make the Viper because it's it's cool

1:18:47essentially and they're into cars and

1:18:49the people who deal with the money like

1:18:50why would you ever make that it's a

1:18:52terrible idea it's not gonna make you

1:18:54money and it's stupid and no one's gonna

1:18:56buy one but that's that's bad decision

1:18:59making so I got your question Casey was

1:19:03why do you want to get a MacPro

1:19:04but I would take it even farther back

1:19:06and say why do you care if a MacPro

1:19:08exists if you're not gonna buy one and I

1:19:10do

1:19:10I cared that for our existing they'll

1:19:12never going to get one and I care the

1:19:13Mac Pro exists even if I wasn't gonna

1:19:15buy one but I totally am probably and

1:19:19I want Apple to be reaching for the

1:19:24stars pushing the limits you know going

1:19:26farther and faster than they've ever

1:19:28gone before and I want them to keep

1:19:30pushing that because I think that an

1:19:32apple that does that is an apple that

1:19:35makes better products overall yeah I

1:19:37don't debate that Apple needs to reach

1:19:40for this it's just again like you

1:19:43neither of you has to answer to me and

1:19:45you know I'm not the boss of you and you

1:19:48can do it just because damn it I want to

1:19:50and that's a perfectly acceptable reason

1:19:53but I look at my what is it like two

1:19:55year old iMac right now and when I write

1:19:58code on this thing like

1:20:00the screen is beautiful with the

1:20:02exception a little bit of burnin the

1:20:03screen is beautiful it still two years

1:20:06on feels crazy fast like I don't feel

1:20:09like I'm waiting for more than a moment

1:20:11for anything when it comes to

1:20:13development not obviously if I'm doing

1:20:14transcodes or something like that that's

1:20:15a different discussion yeah Asian aliy

1:20:17the fans spin up but I'm I'm okay with

1:20:20that I know that makes me a monster but

1:20:22I'm okay with hearing a fan from time to

1:20:23time and I look at the iMac Pro and then

1:20:29I look at the Mac Pro and I feel like

1:20:31there are on paper anyway deeply

1:20:36diminishing returns for both I item to

1:20:38me it's like yeah okay if you're gonna

1:20:40use the car analogy like yes I spent a

1:20:43bit more to have a nicer experience when

1:20:47I Drive two miles to and from work each

1:20:48day a hundred percent and on the surface

1:20:52it's not really that different from what

1:20:54put either you guys are talking about

1:20:55but I feel like what work but a more apt

1:20:59analogy is like well why did you get the

1:21:03regular Ferrari instead of the hyper

1:21:05lightweight Ferrari

1:21:07you know like or it's such diminishing

1:21:10returns like why even bother or or maybe

1:21:13a more apt analogy would be you know a

1:21:15Hellcat will get you somewhere just as

1:21:18quick as a Ferrari will as long as there

1:21:20are no turns as long as there are no

1:21:21turns but I mean I guess it's analogies

1:21:23falling apart as well it's just it seems

1:21:25like it's it's way more money to get you

1:21:28not that much more speed that's true of

1:21:31you BMW - over my court over your record

1:21:34it's considerably more speed over

1:21:35brand-new Accord no it's not not

1:21:38proportional to the money that's always

1:21:39it's always diminishing returns and you

1:21:40get over the top it's always by the way

1:21:42if you're doing parallel tasks it

1:21:44actually is that much more speed yeah

1:21:47don't go like the practical

1:21:48justifications I want this whole I think

1:21:50a totally an impractical justification

1:21:53alone it would be worth it but there are

1:21:54in fact actual practical justification

1:21:56that's worth it just it's it's again

1:21:59like you don't have to answer me I'll

1:22:00let it go it's just it's really hard for

1:22:01me to understand why any human who lives

1:22:04in Xcode needs a MacPro like I can see

1:22:07final cut I could see Lightroom remark

1:22:09oh you brought up Lightroom earlier I

1:22:10can make I can make a pretty good

1:22:12argument that light

1:22:13could justify MacPro but for someone who

1:22:16lives and breathes Xcode or even even

1:22:19more like you know 90 year old

1:22:21programming languages like Perl I don't

1:22:24get why one would want a Mac Pro and and

1:22:27I'll let it go it's just it's don't um

1:22:29and Swift yeah you should be dying for a

1:22:32Mac Pro it's not that bad it's not the

1:22:35gaming angle that you mentioned before

1:22:36though actually is one of the more

1:22:38irrelevant

1:22:39pratik ones because if you reel a lot of

1:22:40it if you really want a Mac like the

1:22:43your they force you to buy this gigantic

1:22:47be incredibly get the the good cheap you

1:22:51know I mean I Pro is a good deep you but

1:22:52presumably this one will have a better

1:22:54one and so if you really are stuck on a

1:22:56Mac and you really want to play games on

1:22:58it which you know people said why would

1:22:59you in the other one I just get a gaming

1:23:00PC blah blah like it's you know it's we

1:23:04are we are oddballs to understand that

1:23:06we have to explain the practical reasons

1:23:11why people want them like that's what

1:23:12all those pros are doing like if you do

1:23:14it for a living

1:23:15and it will make whatever you're doing

1:23:16twice as fast or twice as reliable at

1:23:18the same speed then that's the that's

1:23:22the reason to get them and it's the

1:23:24reason professionals by a professional

1:23:25stuff period like snap-on tools why do

1:23:27they cost so much more than craftsmen

1:23:28are they that much better no they're not

1:23:30that much better but they're better and

1:23:32if you all you do all day is turn a

1:23:33wrench get a good one well but on top of

1:23:37that they also had a ridiculous warranty

1:23:39do they not craftsmen used to be

1:23:41guaranteed for life guarantee forever

1:23:42before like Sears went into business or

1:23:44whatever that's true I don't I'll let it

1:23:47go but it's it's it's it's an odd thing

1:23:48to me again I am a hundred and fifty

1:23:50percent on board with Apple pursuing

1:23:52this I completely agree with you and

1:23:55again gaming is a pretty good reason

1:23:57because I friggin want to leave me alone

1:23:59Casey is a good reason which is what I'm

1:24:00mostly hearing Lightroom is good reason

1:24:02but if you're just living in Xcode or

1:24:04terminal or Visual Studio code or

1:24:05what-have-you it seems a little weird

1:24:06well I mean this is my home computer

1:24:08though I'm not getting it for work you

1:24:09realize like I would never be able to

1:24:10just try to work why they should give me

1:24:11a Mac Pro I can't even justify work for

1:24:13them to get me an iMac for crying out

1:24:14loud it's gonna be stupid laptop right

1:24:17like it's a hobby computer like it's the

1:24:19same you know if you if you had a taxi

1:24:21business you're like how can you justify

1:24:22a BMW if your taxes like don't it's

1:24:24gonna break down and cost you too much

1:24:25money like

1:24:26for your taxi but for your home car I'm

1:24:29gonna BMW because I like cars we are

1:24:33sponsored this week by betterment get up

1:24:34to one year managed free for more

1:24:36information visit betterment comm slash

1:24:38ATP betterment is the largest online

1:24:41financial advisor designed to help you

1:24:43build wealth plan for retirement and

1:24:45achieve your financial goals so put

1:24:47simply betterments mission is to help

1:24:49customers make the most of your money

1:24:51they do this by taking complex investing

1:24:54strategies and use technology to deliver

1:24:56them to everyone and to make them more

1:24:58efficient they also provide access to

1:25:00unlimited personalized advice from

1:25:02licensed experts when you need it it's

1:25:04tax season which means this is a great

1:25:06time to think about your finances as a

1:25:07whole are you ready for all the

1:25:09deadlines are you saving as much on

1:25:10taxes as you can and are there any

1:25:12accounts that could be working harder

1:25:14for you for instance if you have an old

1:25:16401k sitting around high fees on that

1:25:18can really put a damper on your savings

1:25:20according to an independent study done

1:25:22on average 401k fees rolling over to a

1:25:24betterment IRA could mean 60% lower fees

1:25:27and that really could add up over time

1:25:28betterment is a modern solution to an

1:25:31age-old problem how to save for a better

1:25:33retirement they're licensed experts will

1:25:35help you develop a personalized plan to

1:25:37make sure you have the retirement you

1:25:39deserve and are you on track for this

1:25:41you can find out with betterment they

1:25:43host a suite of tools to help you know

1:25:45whether you're on track to hit your

1:25:47savings or investing goals and when you

1:25:49need it their tools and guidance can

1:25:51help get you on track roll over today to

1:25:53one of their IRAs and you can get up to

1:25:54one year mannix free investing involves

1:25:57risk 8tp listeners can get up to one

1:25:59year manage free for more information

1:26:01visit betterment com slash ATP that's

1:26:03betterment comm slash ATP betterment

1:26:07rethink what your money can do let's do

1:26:12some ask ATP we have a twofer with

1:26:15regard to evil addicting juice bosey

1:26:18Moncrief writes hey Marco what's your

1:26:20go-to hand grinder for those of us who

1:26:22don't want your fancy powered instant

1:26:24coffee tubes for travel hand grinding

1:26:27hmm I've had to both hereo first like

1:26:31the skinny one I forget what it's called

1:26:33and then I later got the I'm kind of

1:26:35stubby or one which is called the

1:26:37Skerton I can

1:26:40recommend either of them really if you

1:26:43if you insist on hand grinding coffee

1:26:45the hereos curtain is the much better

1:26:47one like the little skinnier one it's it

1:26:50was useless it was very hard to get

1:26:52anything out of it thus curtain is

1:26:53bulkier but substantially faster the

1:26:57problem is there's a reason why coffee

1:27:00grinders are all electric because you

1:27:03need to do a lot of hand cranking to

1:27:05really get a meaningful amount of coffee

1:27:07especially if you're doing something

1:27:08that needs a finer grind like a narrow

1:27:11press this is one of the many reasons

1:27:13why I decided after only like one or two

1:27:16tries that travel coffee setups are not

1:27:19for me so the only thing I can say is

1:27:23please try not to do this at all but if

1:27:26you're going to do it

1:27:27the hereo Skerton is the one to get and

1:27:30additionally dog oh boy II would like to

1:27:32know what is your coffee setup hike I

1:27:34just found out that you like coffee how

1:27:37do you just find out that Marco likes

1:27:38coffee

1:27:39his blood is coffee that's right anyway

1:27:42I just found out you like coffee would

1:27:43like to know more about your setup yeah

1:27:48alright so basically I'm a crazy coffee

1:27:51enthusiast if you think I care a lot

1:27:53about macbook keyboards you haven't seen

1:27:56me try to make or brew coffee I'm a home

1:27:59roaster i roast my own coffee on a hot

1:28:02top roaster I get the unroasted beans

1:28:05from sweet Maria's I tend to get kenya

1:28:09beans the vast majority is my favorite

1:28:11being sweet Maria's is the best resource

1:28:13I've ever seen

1:28:14for not only getting unroasted beans but

1:28:17getting roosters and learning how to use

1:28:18them so I suggest sweet Maria's calm

1:28:21they've been doing this for a very long

1:28:23time and they've been wonderful and if

1:28:25you're going to start out on a coffee

1:28:26roaster you can start with the cheap air

1:28:28popper or a the Dame or 1300 I think our

1:28:321,600 yeah that's that's the one I had

1:28:34first it's decent the hot top is about

1:28:38three times the price but is three times

1:28:41better so it's up to you how you how you

1:28:43want to deal with that but coffee home

1:28:46roasting is something that nobody should

1:28:49really do but I do it because I care a

1:28:52lot about things that people don't care

1:28:53and I'm very happy with that and I'm

1:28:55content with that so that being said

1:28:57when I'm out I mentioned last time I've

1:29:00been recently trying these these cool

1:29:03new sudden coffee instant coffee things

1:29:05like when I'm traveling or on an

1:29:06airplane or something

1:29:07it's Southern Coffee is surprisingly

1:29:09good I also in the meantime have been

1:29:12recommended to other ones

1:29:13voilá spelled like viola you-know-who

1:29:16wallah

1:29:16coffee and Swift cup coffee both of

1:29:19which are also like kind of pricey

1:29:22high-end instant coffee packets both of

1:29:26them are good Swift cup I think might be

1:29:28my favorite of all three so far I have

1:29:31to try a little bit more of it but I'm

1:29:32very impressed by the Swift cup flavor

1:29:34but southern coffee is actually more

1:29:37practical because you can use the tube

1:29:38as a stirrer which is nice anyway at

1:29:41home when I'm using my home roasted

1:29:43beans I grind them with a Bharat's of

1:29:47virtuoso and I put them in a narrow

1:29:49press and I use a fairly imprecise

1:29:52inverted Aeropress method and I use a

1:29:56electric kettle to pour hot water into

1:29:58it that's about it that's my coffee

1:30:00setup I pour I press the coffee into a

1:30:03mug and then I drink it usually I'm

1:30:07making coffee for me and TIFF at the

1:30:08same time so I use two air presses in

1:30:10parallel one in each hand and it's

1:30:13totally fine I've tried pretty much

1:30:16every way I know of to brew coffee I had

1:30:21way I've tried French presses drip pots

1:30:23good drip hot bad drip pots butters

1:30:26right I have I have tried the butter

1:30:28that's terrible I have tried the what's

1:30:32the big expensive oh the clover machine

1:30:33I've tried the clover machine both at a

1:30:35real coffee shop and then later at

1:30:37Starbucks I've tried lots of different

1:30:39brew I've tried a vacuum brewer I have

1:30:42tried so many different ways to brew

1:30:43coffee and what it comes down to is the

1:30:47best way to brew one cup of coffee or

1:30:49two if you're going to operate two in

1:30:51parallel is that is the Aeropress the

1:30:53best way to prove more than that is the

1:30:55Hario v60 pour over cone into whatever

1:30:57vessel you feel like that's it all right

1:31:01Bryce minty would like to know you know

1:31:04I'm finally getting around to replacing

1:31:05that awful file set-top box at my house

1:31:07which TiVo are you using John and not

1:31:09sure if the $750 for a new bolt and

1:31:12lifetime service is really worth it

1:31:13kind of like apples laptops TiVo line is

1:31:16not in a great place right now because

1:31:19all of their newest machines are using

1:31:23this incredibly stupid bent box design

1:31:26like it looks like a regular set-top box

1:31:28would imagine you bent it like and not

1:31:30even in the middle so it makes this kind

1:31:31of like weird inverted V shape the bend

1:31:35is stupid and you can't stack stuff on

1:31:37half of it but worse than the bend much

1:31:39worse is the fact that the thing is very

1:31:42small and so they have a you know low

1:31:46diameter fan and if it has to spin very

1:31:47fast and makes a very annoying

1:31:49high-pitched noise so all of the bent

1:31:51box TiVo's are noisier than the much

1:31:55larger flat box TiVo's that they

1:31:57replaced which is a shame because the

1:32:00top end TiVo the top end bent box TiVo I

1:32:03have one that well actually not

1:32:05toughened that anymore now I have that

1:32:06Fox thing but I think it's basically

1:32:08same sort of voice control they are

1:32:11otherwise very good they are fast

1:32:14they're small the interface has not been

1:32:19entirely ruined by this new interface

1:32:20that they're trying to roll out I still

1:32:22haven't gotten the new interface but it

1:32:23looks pretty gross but the old one is

1:32:25good like it is a good product it is a

1:32:27good TiVo except for the fact that the

1:32:29box has been and it makes awesome noise

1:32:31if you can find a Romeo Pro which I also

1:32:34have one of it is not quite as fancy as

1:32:38the latest bent box ones but it's still

1:32:41plenty fast it is way bigger

1:32:42ridiculously bigger which is kind of a

1:32:45shame but it is quieter so there is no

1:32:48perfect TiVo to get I would say that if

1:32:51you have like an entertainment center or

1:32:52some place where you're not going to

1:32:53hear the fan or you don't care about fan

1:32:55noises or whatever then the stupid vent

1:32:58box top-of-the-line TiVo's are still

1:33:00pretty good t-bo's but if you care about

1:33:02the noise or want to save some money

1:33:03look into a romeo pro if you can find

1:33:06one because they are much more

1:33:07conventional and straightforward and

1:33:10flat and slightly quieter excellent

1:33:13and finally kg writes what kind of

1:33:15clipboard management apps are you using

1:33:17if any on your Mac

1:33:19I use Alfred as my both app launcher as

1:33:22well as you know kind of do everything

1:33:24machine and it includes some very basic

1:33:27clipboard like history and management

1:33:29and stuff like that that has been great

1:33:31it is exactly what I want and nothing

1:33:34more and that that has worked really

1:33:37well for me I did beta test pastebot

1:33:40which is by the same folks that do tweet

1:33:44BOTS and net bot r.i.p and that was

1:33:48really good but more powerful than what

1:33:52I personally wanted it can do things

1:33:54like you know filter or like you know

1:33:56modify what you've copied and and maybe

1:33:59if I spent the time I would end up

1:34:00deciding oh I actually really do like

1:34:02this but for my needs it was it was

1:34:05overkill for what I'm looking for from

1:34:07it Marco do you have any sort of

1:34:09clipboard management setup yeah I I

1:34:12actually really really love clipboard

1:34:15management like it I came fairly late to

1:34:18it like I think I was like most of the

1:34:20way through my job at tumblr before I

1:34:22started using a clipboard manager and I

1:34:23wish I had done it earlier once I got

1:34:25into it because you know programming and

1:34:27just general computer use there is a lot

1:34:29of opportunities to like stack up a

1:34:32couple things in the clipboard then

1:34:33paste them down somewhere like it's the

1:34:35kind of thing like having multiple

1:34:37clipboards or multiple levels to a

1:34:40stacked clipboard is really really nice

1:34:43in so many types of work on computers

1:34:46and it's one of the biggest things that

1:34:47I think it's kind of a shame that iOS

1:34:49not only doesn't have it but probably

1:34:50never will have it when you're working

1:34:53on iOS one of the biggest things I miss

1:34:54but I've tried a lot of them I think

1:34:58I've tried almost all of them started

1:35:00out on one called jump cut which was

1:35:02like just a clipboard manager it's open

1:35:03it was open source back forever ago I

1:35:05don't know where it is now and then I

1:35:07later moved on to launch bar and you

1:35:11know I've also you know back in the day

1:35:13I used Quicksilver as my like fast

1:35:14launcher than for awhile I just did

1:35:16spotlight as the launcher as they as an

1:35:18almost fast launcher and then launch bar

1:35:21kind of combines everything into one app

1:35:23for me it is a super fast launcher and

1:35:24also my favorite clipboard manager and I

1:35:28know like you know Alfred and there's a

1:35:30bunch of other ones out there now

1:35:32I'm sure they're all great just launch

1:35:33bar happens to be the one that meshed

1:35:36best with me and the way I like it to

1:35:38work and the way I like it to look and

1:35:40behave and everything else so I use

1:35:42launch bar for that and and kind of like

1:35:45what you said Casey I'm I'm a heavy but

1:35:48shallow user of it like yeah yeah yeah I

1:35:51use it constantly very I heavily use I

1:35:54use the crap out of it but I only scrape

1:35:57the surface of the available features I

1:36:00literally only use it to like launch

1:36:02apps find emoji to paste into things

1:36:05which is a fairly recent thing and use

1:36:09multiple clipboards that's it I don't do

1:36:10anything where you can like you know hit

1:36:12a different key and send it to another

1:36:13workflow or sent it to a script or

1:36:15capitalize it in this way like I don't

1:36:16do any of that it's only an app launcher

1:36:19and I click on a clipboard manager for

1:36:21me and that's how it's whatever it cost

1:36:23it's like 40 or 50 bucks whatever it

1:36:25cost it's totally worth it just for that

1:36:27because it is such an incredible part of

1:36:29my workflow doing pretty much everything

1:36:32because that clipboard manager it's so

1:36:34good that being said if you don't want

1:36:35to spend that much there are

1:36:36alternatives as I as you know as both of

1:36:38us said but I highly suggest whatever a

1:36:42clipboard manager you end up with if you

1:36:44don't use one try one if you do anything

1:36:48on a Mac ever try a clipboard manager

1:36:50because once you get into the habit it's

1:36:53like you know so I mean so much of

1:36:55modern work is copying and pasting stuff

1:36:56like from one place to another and it's

1:36:58so nice to people to like copy three

1:37:01things and then go to a go to the other

1:37:03app and paste one paste to paste three

1:37:06like to have tinnitus to go back and

1:37:08forth so much it's it's such a

1:37:10revolution and how you how you use your

1:37:12clipboard you will wonder how anything

1:37:14ever doesn't use like how anyone gets

1:37:17around not using a clipboard it's almost

1:37:19as big of a change as having a clipboard

1:37:22versus not having a clipboard like at

1:37:24the very first time you were like when

1:37:26you were we were all learning how to use

1:37:27computers that first time you discovered

1:37:29the clipboard and that you could copy

1:37:31and paste things like it like it's

1:37:33almost that big of a deal

1:37:34once you can have like a little history

1:37:37or a stack John so I use jump cut for

1:37:41years because I just wanted basic

1:37:43functionality and

1:37:45I use pay spot and I don't use much of

1:37:48the fancy functionality but it like jump

1:37:50cut was fine but pay spot it just has a

1:37:51little bit more polish you know like all

1:37:53the all the Bott things is just nicer so

1:37:55I'm gladly paid for it to have a Polish

1:37:57and hopefully more well supported think

1:37:59of this Marco covered most of the

1:38:01benefits of of a clipboard manager let

1:38:06me tell you about a couple of the

1:38:06dangers one danger as Marco pointed out

1:38:09is that it will change your mental model

1:38:12of how computers work and I've done this

1:38:14a couple of times where I've been on

1:38:15someone else's computer even even just

1:38:17like I'm on my wife's computer and one

1:38:19of my kids accounts where they don't run

1:38:20a clipboard manager like it's the same

1:38:22computer but they don't have been don't

1:38:23run pay spot or whatever and I will be

1:38:27doing stuff in the computer and I will

1:38:30not realize way too late that I just

1:38:33thought I was queuing up three things in

1:38:34the clipboard and in reality I was just

1:38:36overriding and the all the things except

1:38:41for the most recent one don't exist

1:38:43anywhere else like I will I will like

1:38:45copy something out of a document close

1:38:47the document without saving it go to

1:38:49another document copy something out

1:38:50close without saving it and like and

1:38:51then you know copy another thing and

1:38:53then go to the destination expecting to

1:38:54paste in all three of those things and

1:38:55guess what two of them are gone like

1:38:57gone gone like as in data loss gone as

1:39:00in I didn't write them down anywhere and

1:39:01they're gone why because my mental model

1:39:03is that copy and paste is like a cue and

1:39:05it's not it's just one place and that

1:39:07makes me sad the other thing is some of

1:39:09these clipboard managers have a way to

1:39:11synchronize your clippings either like

1:39:13through iCloud or across other machines

1:39:15or whatever and applications also have a

1:39:20way to blacklist something and those two

1:39:22features should make a tickle in your

1:39:24mind because one of the things that I

1:39:27think they put in a blacklist by default

1:39:28is like keychain access or one password

1:39:30yeah if you copy and paste the password

1:39:33and have any kind of cloud

1:39:35synchronization on and don't have that

1:39:37app blacklisted guess what you just

1:39:38spread your unencrypted password to our

1:39:40possibly encrypted either way you just

1:39:42spread your password through cloud

1:39:43storage and possibly to other computers

1:39:45that you may or may not control so be

1:39:48careful with your clipboard manager they

1:39:50the good ones have tools for you to not

1:39:52have that happen you have to use those

1:39:54tools which is kind of the reason I can

1:39:56imagine why Apple doesn't build this in

1:39:58right like what does an apple just build

1:39:59in multiple clipboards they put a clock

1:40:01in the menu bar after all that's a

1:40:03pretty old reference there but they're

1:40:06done so many things since then there are

1:40:08dangerous to this and I'm not sure which

1:40:11is the worse the these the possible

1:40:12security danger or the fact that you get

1:40:14so used to it that trying to use a

1:40:16computer without it the computer feels

1:40:18broken yeah those are bad reasons I'm

1:40:23not saying that's the reason you

1:40:24shouldn't use it like I will I will use

1:40:25it forever like I have to use it like I

1:40:27can't go back yeah right exactly but but

1:40:30just keep in mind that once you get on

1:40:32board this train which you should get on

1:40:34board and it's good keep those other

1:40:35things in mind when you're using a

1:40:37foreign computer keep in mind that the

1:40:39clipboard is no longer Q and just

1:40:41disable the synchronization thing if you

1:40:43don't wanna use it like that's the

1:40:43easiest solution to that like do you

1:40:45really care that your clipboard is

1:40:46synchronized across whatever if you

1:40:47don't just turn that stuff off I have

1:40:49never used any kind of syncing like that

1:40:51I like that that to me sounds like a

1:40:53recipe for pain with iOS in the Mac now

1:40:58right yeah and it works like 70 percent

1:41:01of the time yeah I know actually works

1:41:04at your past one won't actually sync

1:41:05across or you hit paste on the other

1:41:08device and it just blocks for like eight

1:41:10seconds well it tries to figure out what

1:41:12the heck it should be pasting delightful

1:41:15huh between that and drag-and-drop it's

1:41:17like man everything on iOS has made

1:41:19slower by progress yeah oh no think the

1:41:23configure is that most of these

1:41:24clipboard history apps have a way for

1:41:26you to limit the size of things if you

1:41:28like me occasionally find yourself

1:41:30copying and pasting 500 megabytes of

1:41:31text from your awesome text editor you

1:41:34don't really don't want your clipboard

1:41:37manager to be like oh let me hold on to

1:41:38that 500 Meg's for you

1:41:40that's so that most don't have a

1:41:41threshold to say look if it's bigger

1:41:43than 50 Meg's just let that one just let

1:41:45that one slide I'm not gonna be I don't

1:41:47want to paste that an hour from now

1:41:48alright thanks to our sponsors this week

1:41:51betterment hellofresh

1:41:52and molecule and we'll see you next week

1:41:57now the show is over they didn't even

1:42:00mean to begin as it was accidental oh it

1:42:05was accidental

1:42:08johnny research Margo and Casey wouldn't

1:42:12let him because it was accidental he was

1:42:16accidental you can find the CAS pyl is

1:42:32Esther that's Casey Liz and a RC o AR m

1:42:37auntie Marco Arment

1:42:39SI r AC Syracuse

1:42:55I was like no but more things I've been

1:42:59looking at in YouTube I'm looking at

1:43:01YouTube videos I had I find some video

1:43:06that was talking about straight cut

1:43:07gears and race transmissions and why

1:43:09they're better I was so frustrated at

1:43:11the video not explaining to me why the

1:43:12adequately explained to me why they're

1:43:14better that I was just like googling for

1:43:15like race transmission straight cut

1:43:17gears on you to I'm like what does

1:43:19YouTube think of what I ended up here

1:43:21but then I ended up in on this rat hole

1:43:23of like explainer Technology explainer

1:43:26videos and I found a lot of them very

1:43:28frustrating like popular videos that are

1:43:32very poor quality like you you start

1:43:34going into the the dark corner of

1:43:36YouTube is the completely incorrect

1:43:39bogus how planes fly videos right it's

1:43:43kind of like I feel like that you know

1:43:44the the conspiracy theories about how

1:43:45the earth is flat and stuff and like

1:43:47kids are finding them like kids don't

1:43:48watch this video that's not how planes

1:43:49fly and there are videos out there

1:43:53explaining why all the other videos

1:43:54telling you how planes fly are wrong but

1:43:56I don't they're not as high in the

1:43:57search results as the bogus one it's

1:43:59very upsetting anyway but that's like

1:44:03both a fun corner of YouTube technology

1:44:05explainer videos but also just filled

1:44:08with garbage like really bad low res

1:44:10computer animations that they probably

1:44:12didn't make with like a computer voice

1:44:13talking over it like like the old fred

1:44:16voice not like siri but like the old

1:44:18fred voice talking over it like they

1:44:19couldn't even get a human i guess these

1:44:21might be machine generated i don't know

1:44:23or from like yeah i I don't understand

1:44:27it I don't understand who's watching

1:44:28them but they they seem to have like

1:44:30they come up high in the search results

1:44:32I wish I it was like it's like both them

1:44:34down and say hide this and never let

1:44:36another human see it because it's bad

1:44:38but they're good wants to remember the

1:44:39classic good one is like you've I think

1:44:41we've all seen this that one from the

1:44:4250s or 60s explaining how like a

1:44:45transmission works or that was I forget

1:44:48was explained it was like from GM or

1:44:49something and it's like that black and

1:44:50white it's kind of like filmstrip from

1:44:53school and in the 60s but it was the

1:44:56first thing that I ever saw that

1:44:57explained to me how

1:45:00like a traditional gear differential

1:45:02works despite having like assembled and

1:45:05used many of them on a remote-control

1:45:06cars it never quite clicks in my brains

1:45:08like yeah but how did this work and this

1:45:10one did it from like first principles

1:45:12with like to tinker toys I'm like oh now

1:45:14I get it and it finally all came

1:45:16together like this is our every

1:45:17engineering explainer but I gotta go

1:45:19find that one

1:45:19find that one

0:00:00you just starting him out Casey huh

0:00:02carries he's rebooting he said it

0:00:04momentarily I mean that was a few

0:00:06minutes ago

0:00:07you know I mixed a reboot it takes a

0:00:08while not that long

0:00:10not on my shiny new macro mm-hmm all

0:00:13right hello

0:00:14sorry rebooting your slow computer I'm

0:00:17gonna be like that it's faster than

0:00:19John's that's probably true at the

0:00:22reboot already running my reboot is for

0:00:25system updates I didn't have to I just

0:00:27had this sneaking suspicion that I

0:00:29needed to the king I have empathy for

0:00:31the Machine John you've got that reboot

0:00:33feeling my god

0:00:36that's a I was Top Gun wasn't it

0:00:40that's not where that song is from but

0:00:42yes that movie did feature that song

0:00:43take me home or lose me forever John

0:00:45siracusa you know uh fun fact

0:00:51deysa thunder was the better movie

0:00:52between the two of them because of the

0:00:54same movie I'm pretty sure they're not

0:00:56Days of Thunder was the better one why

0:00:58why do you think that because well a

0:01:01everyone is going to tell me I'm wrong

0:01:02and they're probably right but I don't

0:01:03care because planes are not as fun as

0:01:05cars what I figured you know you had

0:01:11some no no reasonable foundation for

0:01:13your opinion but no no that's not now

0:01:15let's talk about vinyl after this

0:01:17high-definition vinyl yes I love I love

0:01:20that story so much like they're like if

0:01:22only there were some other you know

0:01:23round music medium that was longer than

0:01:26a vinyl record and could allow for more

0:01:28precise audio right yeah so I read it I

0:01:32thought it was gonna be like a high

0:01:34definition vinyl but instead it seemed

0:01:36like it was just a way to more precisely

0:01:39make vinyl but everything else about it

0:01:41was the same like it wasn't higher

0:01:43definition it was like if we can really

0:01:45carefully carve grooves in vinyl like

0:01:48more carefully than usual it's like

0:01:50alright I guess I mean sure like it's

0:01:53not okay

0:01:54I don't understand like I thought I was

0:01:58gonna be like a higher density or I was

0:02:00gonna do like it was gonna I was kind of

0:02:01imagining that it would make little pits

0:02:03for like ones and zeros like it would be

0:02:05like final but CDs on vinyl you know I

0:02:06mean there's lots of things you could do

0:02:08to make high to actual high definition

0:02:11vinyl but instead they're just more

0:02:13careful

0:02:13carving grooves in vinyl yeah I've got

0:02:16I've got I've been sent that a couple

0:02:17times already I guess things like you

0:02:19know as somebody who has now seen you

0:02:20know all the sides of this like the

0:02:23appeal of vinyl has nothing to do with

0:02:25its sound quality or fidelity or dynamic

0:02:29range or any the things they're

0:02:30proposing to to increase like it if you

0:02:34want those things you shouldn't be using

0:02:37vinyl at all we're using digital sources

0:02:40this is this is just crazy to me anyway

0:02:44we should start with follow up iOS

0:02:45eleven point three has a new battery

0:02:48throttling notification which we were

0:02:51made aware of sometime in the last week

0:02:53Stephen Devine was the first that I

0:02:55noticed to send us an image it reads as

0:02:57follows this iPhone has experienced an

0:03:00unexpected shutdown because the battery

0:03:01was unable to deliver the necessary peak

0:03:03power performance management has been

0:03:05applied to help prevent this from

0:03:06happening again like a passive voice

0:03:09performance management has been applied

0:03:10who applied it what happened experienced

0:03:13shutdown it experienced it well that is

0:03:16kind of true we did yeah the phone did

0:03:18experience didn't blame you

0:03:19there's no actor in that situation the

0:03:21phone did experience something you shut

0:03:23down your iPhone because of a problem

0:03:25no I this I you know I'm very happy that

0:03:29they are notifying the user when battery

0:03:32throttling happens that in a big picture

0:03:35wise that's good they they should have

0:03:37been doing this all along and that would

0:03:38have made the problem a lot less severe

0:03:40I don't think the wording they've chosen

0:03:42here is particularly helpful or even

0:03:46honest you know performance management

0:03:49has been applied I don't think a lot of

0:03:51people are going to correctly know that

0:03:54that means your phone will now be slowed

0:03:55down like that that's a pretty big

0:03:58difference then performance management

0:04:00has been applied that is a like you know

0:04:03dark pattern euphemism that is

0:04:05intentionally written to mask the truth

0:04:09to mate to confuse and kind of hide

0:04:11what's actually going on in this huge

0:04:14paragraph that they know most people are

0:04:17not going to read and if they do you

0:04:18read it they're good they're not really

0:04:18going to understand what it's really

0:04:20doing I wish that we've been a little

0:04:22more clear in the language but at least

0:04:24they're under firing people it I just

0:04:26wish they around if I

0:04:27in a more honest way they don't offer

0:04:30any remedies like the dialogue should

0:04:31say okay like here's what happened and

0:04:34what is there anything I can do about it

0:04:36actually in this case there is the way

0:04:37you can do about is get a new battery

0:04:38for your phone right all right offer

0:04:39something like it's not even as far as I

0:04:41can tell it's not even a place like a

0:04:43you know tap here for more information

0:04:44like if a user is interested enough in

0:04:47this very confusing vague goodbye he

0:04:50could mean a lot of different things and

0:04:51you I want to know more Gaz it sounds

0:04:53like something bad might have happened

0:04:54to my phone presumably they knew

0:04:55something bad happened to the phones

0:04:56they were using it two seconds ago and

0:04:58then the screen went black and had to

0:04:59wait for it to reboot right so if that

0:05:02happened to me and then my phone came

0:05:04back and it said this I would be like

0:05:05what what can I do about that

0:05:07and Apple has answers there are easy

0:05:09answers hey go get a new battery but

0:05:11they don't offer that in this dialogue

0:05:13anyway yeah they could be a little more

0:05:15video they can say like your battery

0:05:17cannot can no longer run the phone at

0:05:20full speed like that it is more direct

0:05:23that is telling them like your phone

0:05:25won't be slow it's the batteries fault

0:05:27it's something that you can therefore

0:05:29you know have some control over you need

0:05:31to replace the battery like that you

0:05:32know using language that is more honest

0:05:35and accountable I think would do a lot

0:05:38of good here the whole point of this

0:05:41notification is to fix the problem they

0:05:43had before which is they were slowing

0:05:46down people's phones without telling

0:05:47them this kind of sort of fixes that but

0:05:52if the people don't really know what's

0:05:53going on and they later find out oh my

0:05:56phone has been slowed down by Apple you

0:05:59know because of this thing I don't think

0:06:02they're gonna feel better

0:06:03necessarily than they would if they

0:06:04weren't told at all because if this is

0:06:06all they saw and they didn't really

0:06:07understand what was going on then they

0:06:09effectively weren't told about so it

0:06:11doesn't really solve the problem I'm

0:06:13glad that they have a notification I

0:06:15think you nailed it Marco that you know

0:06:16it may not be perfect there's certainly

0:06:18you know issues that we can and just

0:06:20have taken with it but I do think that

0:06:22telling the user what the hell is going

0:06:23on is a good first step in and I welcome

0:06:26this improvement yeah but you need to

0:06:27subtract some of the California from

0:06:29this dialog and apply a little bit of

0:06:30East Coast to it good friggin luck my

0:06:34friend I agree with you but good luck it

0:06:36mean how can how can you expect people

0:06:38who don't live in the real world to

0:06:39communicate with people who live in

0:06:41wordid by Apple in California oh well

0:06:48done all right moving on Mac OS this is

0:06:52actually breaking news and I mean that

0:06:53genuinely this is just breaking in the

0:06:56last like hour or two so we're recording

0:06:57this in the evening of April 11th on

0:06:59Wednesday night and apparently a few

0:07:03people are reporting all at the same

0:07:04moment that Mac OS ten point thirteen

0:07:08point four is now going to warn users

0:07:11about 32-bit apps this is a quote from

0:07:13Jason Snell Apple's long transition away

0:07:16from 32-bit software takes another step

0:07:17beginning April 12 when the clock

0:07:19strikes switching our local time Mac's

0:07:21running Mac OS ten point thirteen point

0:07:24four will display a warning the first

0:07:25time any non apple app that isn't 64-bit

0:07:29compliant is opened interesting I mean

0:07:33this isn't that surprising they're

0:07:34clearly you know like they have not been

0:07:37that secretive that like 32-bit support

0:07:39is on its way out this is it's just like

0:07:41what they did in iOS when iOS 11 I

0:07:44believe was the one that dropped right I

0:07:46think so yeah and so like for iOS 10

0:07:48like ten point for whatever temp with

0:07:50you whatever the last version of ten was

0:07:51they started showing this alert then

0:07:53began you know the over iOS apps and

0:07:55they added a little section in settings

0:07:57where you could see which of your apps

0:07:58was 32-bit and so that's that's nice you

0:08:01can do this I think it's gonna be more

0:08:03disruptive on the Mac like you like we

0:08:05mentioned briefly last week but you know

0:08:08telling telling users what's about to

0:08:09happen before it happens in you know six

0:08:11months to a year or whenever it would be

0:08:13is certainly a good thing this dialogue

0:08:16I think is better worded this one

0:08:18actually tells you what's what the

0:08:19problem is I don't know I've always

0:08:21found these apps like when when the one

0:08:23happened on ten point whatever nobody I

0:08:25knew who was who didn't already know

0:08:27where the dialogue is about guess

0:08:29correctly from a thing and I don't know

0:08:30how they should have worked because

0:08:31people don't care about 32 or 64 but but

0:08:34what it actually says is though it's a

0:08:37two line dialogue guys got the bold line

0:08:38and then the longer non bold sentence

0:08:40underneath it says whatever the

0:08:41application name is not optimized for

0:08:43your Mac now yeah this actually is a

0:08:45terrible dialogue now about now is not

0:08:47optimized for your Mac that's not really

0:08:49true like I know what they're trying to

0:08:51get at but but it makes it seem like the

0:08:53same app that

0:08:54running fine yesterday now somehow like

0:08:56because people read optimized and think

0:08:58it means slower or something and right

0:08:59it's the same speed as it was yesterday

0:09:00right and then the other part says this

0:09:02app needs to be updated by its developer

0:09:04to improve compatibility that's that's

0:09:06closer to true because yeah but what the

0:09:09remedy is developer of the app needs to

0:09:11do something like you user can't do

0:09:13anything about this the developer needs

0:09:14to do it and why isn't it to be updated

0:09:16to improve compatibility compatible what

0:09:18compatibility with an OS that Apple is

0:09:20going to release sometime in the semi

0:09:22near future that's what they don't say

0:09:24that that's what it's about so it's

0:09:26tough to word this one I kind of get

0:09:27that but that's actually really bad so

0:09:30like you know so not your are not

0:09:32optimized means it might be slow which

0:09:34is very different from it's going to

0:09:36stop working in six months if you update

0:09:38your your Mac OS and when the iOS dialog

0:09:40came out if I remember correctly I think

0:09:42it's a summons of that it won't work in

0:09:45future versions of iOS or in a future

0:09:47version of iOS but this like to improve

0:09:50compatibility that's pretty euphemistic

0:09:53too that's like you know what they

0:09:55should say is this appease me related by

0:09:58its developer to work on a future

0:09:59version of Mac OS something like that

0:10:02that's even a little more vague about

0:10:03the timeline but just to say like you

0:10:06know improve compatibility doesn't mean

0:10:07anything not optimized means that are

0:10:10run slowly the truth here is this is

0:10:12going to stop working completely soon

0:10:14and the iOS 11 dialogue said app name

0:10:18needs to be updated which i think is

0:10:19better than app name he's not optimizing

0:10:22she's now optimized where it needs to be

0:10:24updated it's much more clear and then

0:10:25the the subtext was the developer of

0:10:27this app needs to update to work with

0:10:29iOS 11 so not only was it clear that's

0:10:31pretty nice to be updated so it will

0:10:33work we're like a future OS but it tells

0:10:34you the name iOS 11 so yeah the iowa's

0:10:37dialogue was definitely better yeah that

0:10:38is perfect

0:10:39oh wait before we move on so the so that

0:10:41dialogue has buttons it has an OK button

0:10:44which is just like ok whatever nothing

0:10:45happens

0:10:46your app will launch them by the way

0:10:47like it doesn't stop your app from

0:10:49launching it just shows this the first

0:10:50time you launch it maybe you say ok just

0:10:51launches and it's just like it was the

0:10:53day before the style I hear there's a

0:10:55learn more button and learn more button

0:10:57takes you to Apple's

0:10:58knowledgebase article about this which

0:11:00is pretty good and it explains you know

0:11:02what's going on in more detail than the

0:11:04dialogue obviously which by the way this

0:11:06is

0:11:06you know the iOS thing lacks this it

0:11:09doesn't there's no place to get more

0:11:10information as far as I can tell it and

0:11:11I should try it I try to get that to

0:11:13come up and tap it or something anyway

0:11:15the part that stuck out to me in this

0:11:17knowledgebase article is when it gets to

0:11:20the point where like explains to you

0:11:22like you can't do anything about this

0:11:23developer needs updated this is why I

0:11:25blah blah near the end there's a section

0:11:28that says how do I get in touch with the

0:11:30app developer which i think is a good

0:11:32question

0:11:33so you telling me you know people see

0:11:35this out log and I say the developer

0:11:36needs to update and they're like

0:11:36developer like I don't do I even know

0:11:40what that is let alone who it is how

0:11:41would I find the developer of this app

0:11:43and if I was a tasked with writing this

0:11:48I would find myself writing like seven

0:11:51paragraphs about like well so sometimes

0:11:56it's not an individual sometimes it's a

0:11:58company sometimes the company that used

0:11:59to make the application is gone you know

0:12:00like how would you find the person maybe

0:12:02they've moved on maybe they don't have

0:12:03that job anymore maybe no one is

0:12:05maintaining this software you know

0:12:07there's no 100% sure way to find the

0:12:10person who wrote this but like of course

0:12:12they can't do that like they're not

0:12:13gonna go on for 20 pages so they have a

0:12:15very short bit of information that like

0:12:18I don't know I can't think of much

0:12:21better but this seems bad to me the

0:12:23easiest way to contact a developer is to

0:12:25look them up on the web to find the name

0:12:28of the developer of an app open the app

0:12:30click the app name and the menu bar and

0:12:31choose about so they're saying to the

0:12:32about that is two sentences right first

0:12:34one says look them up on the web what if

0:12:36the developer is John Smith look them up

0:12:38on the web the about box maybe it will

0:12:41have link to their website but maybe you

0:12:42will just have a name or maybe it'll

0:12:44just say my cool software company

0:12:45incorporated you know 2010 right it's

0:12:50that's really just throwing people into

0:12:51the deep end I don't know do Google

0:12:53search they figure it out maybe you'll

0:12:56find somebody this is gonna cause people

0:12:58with the same name as a 32-bit app

0:13:00developers to get a lot of bad email my

0:13:03favorite part of this entire page is the

0:13:05very first sentence in the body text

0:13:07state of the art technology is what

0:13:10makes a Mac a Mac that was written years

0:13:12ago though has been updated as

0:13:14knowledgebase article yeah I was gonna

0:13:15say like look at the Mac's that are for

0:13:17sale today and tell me which of them

0:13:19have state of the art technology

0:13:20all of the maksud are for sale not just

0:13:23the most recent models let's see does

0:13:25the MacBook Air have state of the art

0:13:27technology how about the Mac Mini it is

0:13:30still a product in their lineup we are

0:13:32sponsored this week by molecule a

0:13:34complete reinvention of the home air

0:13:36purifier this is not just an improvement

0:13:39on existing outdated technology like say

0:13:42HEPA filters which you might have heard

0:13:43of molecule is a breakthrough science

0:13:46that actually is finally capable of

0:13:48destroying air pollutants at a molecular

0:13:50level and this includes not only you

0:13:52know mold allergens even bacteria and

0:13:55viruses which I found kind of amazing

0:13:57this sounded to me when I first heard

0:13:59about it sounded really out there and

0:14:00kind of too good to be true but it's

0:14:02actually been extensively tested and

0:14:05verified by third parties and it was

0:14:07even backed and funded by the EPA this

0:14:09is the real deal and they sent me one it

0:14:12is pretty nice I got to say it's yeah I

0:14:14can't say whether it's like fixed my

0:14:15allergies yet because I've only had it

0:14:16for about a week but I'll tell you one

0:14:18thing this is the time to try it because

0:14:20I think the pollen season is about to

0:14:21kick in in full force over the next

0:14:23couple of weeks so I'm really glad I

0:14:24have this right now and molecule has

0:14:26actually been personally effective and

0:14:29verified by science but most importantly

0:14:31it's been tested by real people it has

0:14:33already helped allergy and asthma

0:14:35sufferers around the country better cope

0:14:37with their conditions and significantly

0:14:39reduce their symptoms one of their

0:14:40customers even told them she was able to

0:14:42breathe through her nose for the first

0:14:43time in 15 years I totally understand

0:14:46how you can get there and this thing I

0:14:48got to say it's really nice it's pretty

0:14:51big at the higher speeds it's a little

0:14:53loud but the lower speeds is actually

0:14:54very quiet and I'm very very happy with

0:14:57it I keep mine in my bedroom now and I'm

0:15:00thinking about buying a couple more for

0:15:01the rest of the house so far I like it a

0:15:03lot I'm really very impressed by it it

0:15:06it leaves the room smelling like nothing

0:15:10or like fresh air not just like ozone or

0:15:12some scent it's really quite nice I

0:15:14suggest you check it out if you are an

0:15:16air filter person or if you feel like

0:15:18you need an air filter or you suffer

0:15:19from allergies or asthma

0:15:20check out molecule you can get $75 off

0:15:23your first order with code ATP and you

0:15:26do this at molecule comm it's spelled

0:15:28like the word but switch out the c4a k

0:15:30so mo le k you le MA

0:15:34Kuehl with a kid it's molecule comm $75

0:15:37of your first order with code ATP thank

0:15:38you so much to molecule for sponsoring

0:15:40our show Shawn Harding writes hey I had

0:15:47one of those Pro clip mounts that went

0:15:48into a gap in the dash for my Audi s5 it

0:15:51not only went in the gap but also had

0:15:53adhesive I was hesitant but gave in and

0:15:56I lost my desktop hello sorry things are

0:15:59happening on my computer where the fuck

0:16:00did that go while you were reading did

0:16:02the window disappear out from under your

0:16:04eyeballs well because I was opening a

0:16:07new window in before this all before I

0:16:10started reading all this and then it

0:16:11opened and then things disappear your

0:16:13computer is slow Oh would you stop

0:16:17you're opening a window then you had

0:16:19time to read two sentences then the

0:16:21window finally opened I was opening up

0:16:22in the nCWIT window leave me alone now

0:16:24let me reboot this whole fuckin thing

0:16:26what are using VNC for what are you

0:16:29remotely controlling I'm remotely

0:16:31controlling the laptop that's sitting

0:16:32like 2 2 inches away from me because I

0:16:34am trying to to look at something for

0:16:37work real quick so I don't have to worry

0:16:39about it

0:16:39are you doing air traffic control during

0:16:41this podcast what's going on are you

0:16:42trying to land planes with us we are

0:16:47talking with the Mac Pro yet you can't

0:16:48we be paying your bills and stuff yeah I

0:16:49know I know I know I'm we're getting

0:16:51there right so let me just reboot this

0:16:52whole damn thing

0:16:53Sean holding lights I'm rebooting

0:16:56nothing not literally repeating no just

0:16:58segments he's trying to keep that out of

0:16:59the show but I'm pretty sure he's going

0:17:00in no it's not going on please now Sean

0:17:03Harding writes I had one of those Pro

0:17:05clip mounts that went in the gap in the

0:17:06day it went into a gap in the dash for

0:17:08my Audi s5 and not only one in the gap

0:17:10but it also had adhesive I was hesitant

0:17:12but gave in and now I have a big gap in

0:17:13the trim and adhesive residue two thumbs

0:17:16down so the pro clip mounts that I was

0:17:18talking about last week if I go in your

0:17:19car like they're made for each

0:17:20individual car model certain you know

0:17:23the design of certain dashboards and

0:17:24stuff like the you know certain ones are

0:17:26gonna be easier or harder to fix

0:17:28something very securely to than others I

0:17:30lucked out in that mine just uses the

0:17:33air vent and just kind of uses like a

0:17:34pressure fit inside the air vent top and

0:17:36bottom so that it doesn't leave anything

0:17:38behind and there's no like permanent -

0:17:40damage should buy it but if your car is

0:17:43one where it has to do something a

0:17:44little more aggressive then you know

0:17:47that makes

0:17:47to to have that be a problem for you you

0:17:50know I just it isn't a problem for me

0:17:52also its Elise maybe you don't want to

0:17:54mess with the - because who knows what

0:17:56they'll say about that when you try to

0:17:58give it back the thing about the vent

0:17:59ones that some people wrote in about is

0:18:02they're like oh isn't it bad to keep

0:18:04your phone there like in the winter with

0:18:05heat blowing out of the vent on it and I

0:18:08just assumed that every car has like

0:18:09that little dial or whatever that lets

0:18:11you turn off the vent and I would

0:18:12suggest that if you in the winter if you

0:18:15have your phone an event clip turn the

0:18:17vent behind the phone off so heat isn't

0:18:19constantly belong in the back of your

0:18:20phones that's terrible and the summer

0:18:21air conditioning blowing the back that's

0:18:23probably great because it gets pretty

0:18:24heat hot in the car with the Sun beating

0:18:26down on your phone so that'll probably

0:18:28even out but if you have no dial because

0:18:30your car as a weird super modern thing

0:18:34where there's no way to control the air

0:18:36vents except for a tiny dot in the

0:18:38middle of a giant field that you drag

0:18:41around as a vague way to suggest in the

0:18:43car where there might come out yeah that

0:18:45sounds pretty cool to be honest I

0:18:47haven't seen it yet but it sounds pretty

0:18:48cool

0:18:48yours doesn't have that I thought that

0:18:49was on although it's only the mile three

0:18:51which I haven't seen in real life yet

0:18:53but I was like if you just want to turn

0:18:55off the vent that your phone is attached

0:18:56true though I'm not sure how you can do

0:18:57that by dragging a puck around a little

0:18:59ice hockey rink

0:18:59I actually no I don't think I can turn

0:19:02off event like they have a little like

0:19:04slider things you can redirect it but

0:19:06there's no I don't think I can turn that

0:19:07vent off I don't have the little dial no

0:19:09but but this isn't a problem in reality

0:19:11because automatic climate control never

0:19:14has the heat blowing out of the center

0:19:16vents it's always blown in the feet vent

0:19:18the defroster vent or both but it's

0:19:21never blowing out the front vents that's

0:19:22not how you're supposed to heat a car

0:19:23why wouldn't you want out of the front

0:19:25vents because you don't need heat

0:19:27blowing in your face you look at your

0:19:29feet sometimes my face is cold I'll tell

0:19:32you where I want the air I I would not

0:19:35consider this a big problem in reality

0:19:37for almost anybody because the way

0:19:39you're supposed to be climate managing

0:19:41your car you shouldn't really be blowing

0:19:43a lot of hot air through the front fence

0:19:44anyway and also if you're using your

0:19:47phone in a doc and running like waged

0:19:48something it's already running so hot

0:19:50that you know it actually might improve

0:19:52the heat efficiency of your car to be

0:19:53blowing it across your phone on the way

0:19:54to your face okay because because the

0:19:56phone is you know 150 degrees but the

0:19:58air coming out of the vent 275 so it's

0:20:00actually cool

0:20:01exactly all right with regard to my

0:20:05beloved blue towel speaking of car

0:20:07related things indeed five rights at the

0:20:10surgical rag that I use is called a huck

0:20:12h uck it's a sterile towel used to dry

0:20:15hands after a surgical scrub before

0:20:17operating and apparently he has a

0:20:19million of them and then Eugene fries in

0:20:21writes in that they're actually

0:20:22available on Amazon so I'll put a link

0:20:24in the show notes I was not aware of

0:20:25this which is super good news because I

0:20:26kind of need some we also got some

0:20:28feedback about whether or not it's

0:20:30plastic ventilating onto the interior of

0:20:33your windshield John do you have any

0:20:35thoughts on that or do you not care yeah

0:20:37no it's true I'm guessing from them you

0:20:39know that new car smell and various

0:20:41other things that you smell in cars of

0:20:42outgassing from carpets and from plastic

0:20:44and a lot of that crap gets all over

0:20:45your windshield and makes it gross fun

0:20:48finally our almost finally actually car

0:20:50subscriptions Zach a friend of mine

0:20:53asked why not have like a lyft

0:20:55subscription you know like insurance the

0:20:58light users would subsidize the heavy

0:20:59ones that sounded like a brilliant idea

0:21:01and then fast-forward like three days

0:21:04after I heard this feedback from my

0:21:05buddy Zach and I somehow saw an article

0:21:08or a headline or something like that

0:21:09about how lyft actually is or will soon

0:21:12be offering subscriptions which I didn't

0:21:14know was the thing this is the kind of

0:21:16thing that like it's it's nice in a lot

0:21:19of situations and it might even it might

0:21:21even prove to be nice in the majority of

0:21:22situations for some people but the the

0:21:25great flexibility of having your own car

0:21:27parked in your driveway or in your

0:21:29garage or nearer in front of your place

0:21:31is that it's always there ready for you

0:21:34it's it's dedicated capacity just for

0:21:37you if you're relying on not public

0:21:40transit but if you're lying on like

0:21:41services like lyft or uber or other like

0:21:43kind of car share services there's only

0:21:45a certain number of cars out there in a

0:21:47given time and they're only in a certain

0:21:49number of places and they're there a lot

0:21:50you know less densely available once you

0:21:53get out of the major cities when you

0:21:55have your own car it's always there

0:21:56ready for you no matter when you want to

0:21:58use it with zero weight or close enough

0:22:00to zero weight when you're relying on

0:22:02something like this it might work nine

0:22:04times out of ten but then the tenth time

0:22:06you go to use it oh there aren't any for

0:22:08the next 45 minutes or it's a spike

0:22:11because of demand or the nearest one is

0:22:14no too far away and doesn't want to take

0:22:16your ride or you keep getting the same

0:22:18one over and over again that's some

0:22:20driver that's terrible that you don't

0:22:21want that you know their car smells like

0:22:22smoke and cats and stuff and it's like

0:22:24when it's yours when it's your car it is

0:22:27always there ready to go and so

0:22:30depending on how important that car and

0:22:32the mobility are to you anything for

0:22:35most people in most of America it's very

0:22:37important because the public

0:22:39infrastructure just isn't there for most

0:22:40of us having that car be dedicated to

0:22:43you having your own that's always ready

0:22:44to go that's always right there that's

0:22:46always yours and you can put your stuff

0:22:48in it and you can you can know that's

0:22:50always gonna be there and be ready

0:22:51that's gonna have a pretty big advantage

0:22:53for a lot of people so I don't see

0:22:55service it I don't see personal car

0:22:59ownership of some form going away like

0:23:02lyft and uber that's not that that's

0:23:03something else the subscription is just

0:23:05another way to have cars that are yours

0:23:07so that I think makes some sense maybe

0:23:09in the future but it's never going to be

0:23:11totally replaced in America unless our

0:23:13density radically changes which I don't

0:23:16see happening this is a psychological

0:23:18pricing ploy like for for city dwellers

0:23:21who are never gonna own the car because

0:23:22they can't afford a parking spot for it

0:23:23or whatever you use lift all the time

0:23:25anyway you can convince enough of them

0:23:28to subscribe essentially paying more

0:23:30like like Zak said most people will say

0:23:32oh it's just easier to pay a

0:23:33subscription and not have to worry about

0:23:35the hassle of you know paying each time

0:23:37and everything and maybe that'll make me

0:23:38feel like oh I'll use it more I have a

0:23:40subscription I'll use it more right

0:23:41and maybe they won't use it more you

0:23:43know and so this will end up making more

0:23:46money from the people who thought they

0:23:48were gonna really totally use that

0:23:49description all the time but actually

0:23:50take the same number of rides as they

0:23:51always did it ends up being a bad deal

0:23:53for them but the few heavy users get a

0:23:56really good deal because now they can

0:23:57just ride as much as they want for a

0:23:58flat fee so lyft will figure out the

0:24:00economics of it I'm sure and try to but

0:24:02that it's the type of pricing psychology

0:24:04that can make everybody involved feel

0:24:08like they're getting a good deal even

0:24:09though obviously you know they're not

0:24:11right so lyft would be happy if they

0:24:13make more money and the users would be

0:24:15happy if they perceive the the

0:24:20subscription as a good value regardless

0:24:22whether it's actually a good value

0:24:24finally somebody and I don't have the

0:24:26scene out in front of me somebody was

0:24:28very grumpy about the fact that we

0:24:29called San Jose not very big and John

0:24:32did you put this in here would you like

0:24:33to happen that happened last year too

0:24:35and we were talking about San Jose we

0:24:37got so much feedback about I forget we

0:24:38ever even did fall about it but we

0:24:40should and because I've totally forgot

0:24:42about the fallout from last year already

0:24:43we're like Oh San Jose like nobody's

0:24:45there it's empty it's not like Samer so

0:24:47it's not a big city like San Francisco

0:24:48and any time we said anything like that

0:24:49someone from San Jose or near San Jose

0:24:52right st. to tell us mean well you know

0:24:53San Jose is bigger than ther an cisco

0:24:56has a bigger population in San Francisco

0:24:58you know all the things about how San

0:25:00Jose it's just massive compared to

0:25:01everything that we be you know we're

0:25:04saying it's small but it's not right and

0:25:06to that I would say Texas has more

0:25:08people than San Jose but if I drop a pin

0:25:11anywhere in Texas chances are good I'm

0:25:13gonna look around not see that much all

0:25:14about density San Jose is bigger San

0:25:18Jose has more people but practically

0:25:21speaking if you are a person you could

0:25:23drop down and WWC and you look around

0:25:24you'd be like where all the people as a

0:25:27tumble beat tumbleweed goes by right

0:25:28like it is very different experience

0:25:31from the vastly higher density of where

0:25:34Moscone is San Francisco so that's what

0:25:36we meant we know it's a big city we know

0:25:38there's lots of people somewhere also I

0:25:41was interested

0:25:41not a single person refuted my Truman

0:25:44Show theory about everybody who works

0:25:46there but they're just writing your name

0:25:49down a little book of a little you know

0:25:51picture of you says do not serve this

0:25:53person or serve this person even more

0:25:55slowly than usual I'm not sure I'd be

0:25:57able to tell the difference like oh here

0:25:59we go you wanted to order something I

0:26:02don't know if I can do that I'll just

0:26:03check with my boss to see if you can

0:26:04order something well I'm gonna laugh

0:26:06when you get says so PO or whatever it's

0:26:08called and and they are like oh wait

0:26:11you're Marco yeah we're not serving you

0:26:12what would you do you would have nowhere

0:26:14to go you would have you would have no

0:26:16court to rule over I'd go to the beer

0:26:18and sausage place up the street

0:26:21we are sponsored as week by hellofresh

0:26:24for $30 off your first week visit

0:26:26hellofresh comm and enter code ATP 30

0:26:29hellofresh is a meal kit delivery

0:26:31service that shops plans and delivers

0:26:33step-by-step recipes and pre measured

0:26:35ingredients so you can just cook eat and

0:26:38enjoy with hellofresh there is something

0:26:41for everyone

0:26:42they have three plans to choose from

0:26:43classic veggie for vegetarians and

0:26:46family for picky eaters in your family

0:26:48each box is made up of responsibly

0:26:50obtained fresh ingredients from

0:26:52carefully selected farms and high rated

0:26:54trusted sources you can look forward to

0:26:57your hello fresh delivery knowing that

0:26:59dinner just got that much easier and

0:27:01even if you're a novice home chef

0:27:03you can still figure out hello freshest

0:27:05ingredients coz they had these excellent

0:27:06recipe cards they have pictures

0:27:08step-by-step instructions you it's

0:27:10really clear what you're supposed to be

0:27:11doing and they really explain it well

0:27:12and you can really enjoy not having to

0:27:15plan dinner for every single night of

0:27:17the week or just kind of chickening out

0:27:19and going for take-out it's so much

0:27:21easier to do hello fresh hello fresh

0:27:23ingredients are delivered right to your

0:27:25door and recyclable insulated packaging

0:27:28unpacking is super easy because

0:27:29everything is in its own bag all the

0:27:31meals are separated so you can really

0:27:33tell what everything is unpacking it

0:27:34takes like two seconds everything all

0:27:36the ingredients inside each bag are pre

0:27:38measured in handy little little

0:27:40containers so you know which ingredients

0:27:42go with which recipe and there's not a

0:27:44lot of food waste because you have

0:27:45exactly what you need so you can spend

0:27:47less time meal planning and grocery

0:27:49shopping each week and get that time

0:27:50back

0:27:51to do more of what you love get

0:27:52delicious filling meals delivered right

0:27:54to your door every week for less than

0:27:56$10 per serving and free shipping and if

0:27:59you're gonna be out of town or just too

0:28:01busy one week you can always pause or

0:28:03suspend at any time for $30 off your

0:28:05first week of hellofresh visit

0:28:07hellofresh comm editor code ATP 30

0:28:10that's hellofresh comm with code ATP 30

0:28:13thank you so much - hello fresh for

0:28:15sponsoring our show all right it's time

0:28:21I'm gonna go to sleep now guys there's

0:28:25been some Mac Pro news I love that

0:28:27you're bringing this up you're just you

0:28:30could have just moved on you should

0:28:31summarize the Mac Pro news that's what

0:28:33you should do yeah chief summarizer in

0:28:34chief I'm going to attempt to so friend

0:28:36of the show and said with no sarcasm

0:28:38friend of the show Matthew piensa Reno

0:28:40was invited by himself which is actually

0:28:43kind of interesting in and of itself I

0:28:44don't know if we need to unpack that

0:28:46right now or not but Matt Pan's Reno was

0:28:47invited to Apple and was put in front of

0:28:51several different both executives and

0:28:53engineers and

0:28:55to talk about hey what's going on with

0:28:57Mac Pro and my summary which I'm sure

0:29:00both of you will take issue with and

0:29:01that's fine but my summary is Apple

0:29:04wanted to give a little more insight

0:29:08into what's going on with the Mac Pro

0:29:10you could we can and surely we'll

0:29:12pontificate about why that is but one

0:29:16can assume and I think I actually said

0:29:17that hey we don't want you to make

0:29:19purchasing decisions on the hope that

0:29:21the Mac Pro is coming out later this

0:29:22year so they made it plain that it will

0:29:25not be out until 2019

0:29:26they said 2019 but we don't know when in

0:29:31they said that and this was what I found

0:29:34most interesting they've created a

0:29:37workflow group as I believe what they

0:29:38called it and what that basically means

0:29:40is they have contracted and/or hired

0:29:42creative professionals to sit literally

0:29:46next to the people who work on say Final

0:29:50Cut Pro and work on the Mac Pro as well

0:29:52in order to better understand what their

0:29:55workflows are and they cited an example

0:29:56and I think it was Final Cut Pro it

0:29:58doesn't really matter but they said in

0:29:59an example of oh these creative

0:30:01professionals there's they open this one

0:30:03dialogue and Final Cut Pro all the time

0:30:06and it takes like 10 seconds to open

0:30:08this dialogue and nobody at Apple

0:30:10somehow knew this and so because they're

0:30:13now sitting next to each other you know

0:30:15the the creative professionals walk down

0:30:16the hall and said hey guys can we do

0:30:18something about this dialogue because

0:30:19this sucks

0:30:20and sure enough it turned out there was

0:30:22like an error in some driver somewhere

0:30:24or something like that and they were

0:30:25able to fix it so the point of all this

0:30:27is Apple is trying to engage with the

0:30:31broader professional community people

0:30:32like us in say hey you know you need to

0:30:36buy an iMac Pro go buy an iMac Pro we

0:30:39don't wait for the Mac Pro because

0:30:40you're not getting it for a while

0:30:41additionally they're they're engaging

0:30:42with with the broader professional

0:30:44community in the sense that they've

0:30:45asked some of these people to come in

0:30:47house and help them understand what

0:30:49their workflows are which III think you

0:30:52can argue both that that's great and

0:30:54that's terrible and I'm sure we're about

0:30:56to do exactly that

0:30:57but one way or another it is it is more

0:31:00insight than we've had into the Mac Pro

0:31:02in a long long time and it shows us that

0:31:04it's still a thing which is exciting it

0:31:07tells us rough

0:31:08FLE with an emphasis on roughly when

0:31:10it's going to be released and they also

0:31:13said that no no it's going to be modular

0:31:14and I am happy to report John siracusa

0:31:18that they are making it plain or perhaps

0:31:21reiterating that they are making a

0:31:23display for it still I know you're very

0:31:28excited and I am happy that you're happy

0:31:30that is I think my summary and as much

0:31:33as I'm snarking about this this is

0:31:35actually pretty fascinating even for me

0:31:37I don't see a MacPro in my future but

0:31:40this is really really really interesting

0:31:41and a very different approach than

0:31:43apples taken in the past and whether or

0:31:46not I view a Mac Pro is something I need

0:31:48to buy and honestly I don't think it's

0:31:50something that any of us need to buy but

0:31:52we can argue about that another time I

0:31:54said too that this approach I still

0:31:57think that this approach is really

0:31:58fascinating so with that in mind I will

0:32:00open the floor perhaps we can start with

0:32:02Marco what are your thoughts I mean to

0:32:05me like you know this is this has been

0:32:08positioned and summarized by many

0:32:09including she's summarized here in chief

0:32:11in part as a Mac Pro you know round

0:32:15table successor from last year but

0:32:18there's really no new information here

0:32:20about the Mac Pro the only thing that we

0:32:22know about the Mac Pro we didn't know

0:32:24before is that it's definitely not

0:32:26coming out this year that's the only

0:32:28thing that's new here what this was

0:32:31really about I think is you know setting

0:32:35expectations for that or to be able to

0:32:37seat it to come and go and for the rest

0:32:39of the year to come and go without Pro

0:32:41is saying hey where the heck's the Mac

0:32:42Pro you know that that's really what I

0:32:44think this was about on that side and

0:32:46then to kind of paper over that or to

0:32:50offset that with something that's

0:32:52positive by showing off that they have

0:32:55this new you know kind of like in-house

0:32:57study of pro users in you know in their

0:33:01natural environment and geometrically

0:33:04speaking this announcement was an

0:33:06open-faced shit sandwich that fell face

0:33:08down on the floor

0:33:09[Laughter]

0:33:14we're news bad news good news you just

0:33:16get the bad news and then you get the

0:33:18good news so the bad news is no MacPro

0:33:21this year and the good news is I look at

0:33:23the pro workflow team isn't that cool

0:33:25and you know honestly I mean this is you

0:33:27know heavy on the PR puff obviously and

0:33:31you know not from Pantera but from Apple

0:33:33and there's not a lot of new information

0:33:37really here but it is interesting that

0:33:40this Pro you know group thing was

0:33:42created there and and is is you know

0:33:45being observed and being worked with

0:33:46that is that is the more interesting

0:33:48part of this announcement by far the

0:33:50actual like again there's no information

0:33:52with the Mac Pro we don't know anything

0:33:53at the Mac Pro except it's not come in

0:33:55this year I can speculate on why you

0:33:58know we all can many of us have honestly

0:34:01I don't think it's that interesting yet

0:34:03because again we have no new information

0:34:05except that you know that big hole in

0:34:08the timeline of it's gonna be next year

0:34:10which I'm glad they said it's going to

0:34:12be 2019 as opposed to it's not going to

0:34:15be this year you said that it could be

0:34:162025 or Never

0:34:18so at least they committed to a year you

0:34:21can also speculate as many people have

0:34:23why is it taking Apple so long to

0:34:25develop what should probably just be a

0:34:27fairly straightforward like tower or

0:34:29something tower like the answer to that

0:34:32that's most likely is that last year

0:34:35like about a year ago when they had that

0:34:37roundtable I think it is very likely

0:34:39that they literally had not even started

0:34:41yet that it was like it was decided

0:34:43within a very short time before that

0:34:46that they that they were going to do

0:34:47this and that means that from 2013 until

0:34:54they were probably not doing any work at

0:34:57all on a Mac Pro they were probably

0:34:58assuming the iMac Pro was it and they

0:35:00were only working on the iMac Pro so

0:35:03it's not that they couldn't do a new

0:35:05tower in you know five years or whatever

0:35:08since the last Mac Pro it's that they

0:35:10can't do it a new tower in a year and a

0:35:12half that's I think what we're really

0:35:13seeing here the even that is slightly

0:35:16concerning because even that's like you

0:35:18know what pros want is new hardware in

0:35:21some kind of expandable box we don't

0:35:24need

0:35:25fancy designs we don't need you know a

0:35:27lot of different types of quote

0:35:28innovation we just need new guts in a

0:35:32box and for Apple to be you know kind of

0:35:36taking their sweet time and trying to

0:35:38work on probably something that's like

0:35:39really you know highly designed highly

0:35:41custom that's nice I'm sure that

0:35:43satisfies Apple but that's not really

0:35:46what pros are asking for for this

0:35:47product but I don't think we can talk

0:35:50Apple out of that kind of design anymore

0:35:52I think that's kind of just what they do

0:35:53and from that point of view the the time

0:35:57scale seems reasonable that they just

0:35:59started last year and they're not just

0:36:01doing something basic even though many

0:36:03of us want them to do exactly that for

0:36:04this product because they can save the

0:36:06innovation for all of the rest of their

0:36:09products including the iMac Pro which is

0:36:11fairly innovative in a few ways and it's

0:36:13really nice I really like the iMac Pro

0:36:15but anyway they're they're not doing

0:36:17that so oh well I do think it's

0:36:19interesting also to think now maybe one

0:36:22of the reasons they're taking a little

0:36:24bit of time on this is you know what I

0:36:27expected was the iMac Pro guts in a box

0:36:30with a couple of GPU slots and maybe it

0:36:33may be you know space for a few m to

0:36:36drive modules I don't think that's what

0:36:39they're doing and and when the iMac Pro

0:36:42came out and and when we saw how awesome

0:36:45it was and how few downsides it had and

0:36:47had few restrictions it had one of the

0:36:49things that that we said at the time was

0:36:52what the heck is left for the Mac Pro to

0:36:54address like how much Headroom above

0:36:57this can the Mac Pro really achieve you

0:37:00know are they gonna go dual processor

0:37:01maybe have many graphics cards you know

0:37:04support it or different types of slots

0:37:05or whatever who knows what right we were

0:37:07trying to figure out like what else what

0:37:09is left for the Mac Pro to do that the

0:37:11iMac Pro doesn't do so maybe in order to

0:37:13create more Headroom in that area maybe

0:37:17I took a bit of you know special

0:37:19engineering maybe they're doing

0:37:20something they haven't done before like

0:37:21for instance if they if they're working

0:37:23from the road map of the old Mac Pro of

0:37:26the 2013 Mac Pro that one had this rigid

0:37:29GPU arrangement that only supported

0:37:31these two GPUs and this one kind of

0:37:32weird arrangement with this kind of

0:37:34weird integration with the Thunderbolt

0:37:35bus and it only supported one CPU and

0:37:38you know the whatever it is four or six

0:37:40RAM slots and and one SSD module maybe

0:37:44they're doing dual socket CPUs and that

0:37:47dramatically complicates things and and

0:37:49how you have to you know layout the

0:37:51internals how you have to cool things

0:37:53maybe they're doing a box that can

0:37:55accommodate lots of different

0:37:57configurations like the old towers could

0:37:59so maybe you could have one or two CPUs

0:38:01one or four GPU is like you know they

0:38:04did all sorts of crazy things back with

0:38:05the old cheese graters and stuff the

0:38:08difference now is that the cheese

0:38:10graders were all before Thunderbolt

0:38:11there was a lot less internal PCI

0:38:15Express bandwidth and things like that

0:38:17that had to be allocated to external

0:38:19storage and GPUs were lower bandwidth

0:38:22and everything was lower bandwidth back

0:38:23then and so to design something now you

0:38:27have to really consider like how you

0:38:28balance like PCI Express allocations and

0:38:31lanes and speeds between internal and

0:38:33external stuff how you route video

0:38:35signals over the thunderbolt and and how

0:38:37you like do you route the output to the

0:38:38GPU to a thunderbolt port on on the back

0:38:41like how do you do that it's fairly

0:38:43complicated to design a really good mac

0:38:47pro tower with modern features and

0:38:51modern bandwidth and everything else

0:38:53that's also that also has like

0:38:55interchangeable slots like that's a hard

0:38:57thing so if they're doing something like

0:38:58that taking two years to do it seems

0:39:01reasonable I don't know what else what

0:39:03they're doing but I hope so so like the

0:39:05the people were saying wanted there just

0:39:06to give us a box and slap things

0:39:08together like I think there's a minimum

0:39:10there's a minimum bar of not even

0:39:13innovation but just quality or attention

0:39:16to detail or thoughtfulness that we

0:39:18expect from a lot of people a lot of

0:39:19people look at the cheese graters and

0:39:21say oh it's just a tower case yeah it's

0:39:22an it's a nice looking tower case but

0:39:24whatever is just a tower like it's not

0:39:25it has a door but it's just got a bunch

0:39:27of slots and a motherboard and RAM it's

0:39:29like cool it's not much different this

0:39:30from pcs our eyes evidence piled the PC

0:39:32Tower clones that came after it but I

0:39:34think that the very first one the Power

0:39:37Mac g5 I think that probably took them

0:39:42longer to design that plain and boring

0:39:45tower case and everything that goes into

0:39:47it then they're spending there they're

0:39:49gonna end up spending on this macro but

0:39:50I Pro like

0:39:52it's not because they're insisting on

0:39:55doing something really weird like the

0:39:57trashcan right because the the Power Mac

0:40:00g5 was not really weird it was a tower

0:40:01like straightforward like there wasn't

0:40:03it wasn't it wasn't weird at all but if

0:40:07you look at it it's like well it's very

0:40:08carefully designed they you know the

0:40:11case is has very you know simple design

0:40:16with a big curved piece of aluminum

0:40:18wrapped around a minimum number of seams

0:40:21the door giving you access to the

0:40:24insides you know the way the door fits

0:40:26in and that whole mechanism how they

0:40:28route all the ribbon cables so they're

0:40:30not that you know to make it look nice

0:40:32on the inside so the ribbon cables are

0:40:33all tucked behind the motherboard and

0:40:35they're just the right length and stuff

0:40:36like that

0:40:37the way the motherboard is laid out I

0:40:38mean all the various custom chips that

0:40:41might go into it that aren't in any

0:40:42other Mac it's not rocket science and

0:40:45it's not like the thing that people are

0:40:47afraid of like oh there it's gonna be

0:40:48shaped like a squid and it's gonna have

0:40:50you know Thunderbolt 3 connecting

0:40:52everything and like all sorts of just

0:40:55make me a box say Apple is doing that

0:40:57we're just making you a box it is

0:40:58literally a tower it is the air comes in

0:41:01the front and out the back it is totally

0:41:03straightforward but doing that the Apple

0:41:05Way takes longer than people think and I

0:41:10kind of want them to do it the Apple way

0:41:13like if you're in a super big hurry I

0:41:14can understand like you're like we need

0:41:15towers yesterday we can't use the iMac

0:41:18Pro for whatever reasons just you know

0:41:21slap it together like they like people

0:41:23who would be happy with the hackintosh

0:41:24right I don't I don't care what it looks

0:41:26like how nice it is I don't care how

0:41:28nice the seams are or whatever just slap

0:41:30it together but I don't think Apple is

0:41:33really capable of doing that like even

0:41:35even its products that we you know it's

0:41:37quote-unquote worst products like the

0:41:39products that we complain about like are

0:41:40you still selling the MacBook Air or

0:41:41whatever MacBook Air is still nice like

0:41:43industrial design why is the screen is

0:41:45gross but like everything else about it

0:41:47you know it looks expensive and

0:41:50carefully designed like it's not falling

0:41:52apart and has weird seams and things

0:41:54poking out of it and doesn't look

0:41:56slapped together it looks old but it

0:41:58doesn't look slap together Apple

0:42:00generally just is not you know

0:42:02institutionally capable of making

0:42:05hardware that looks like it's been

0:42:07slapped together like on a speedy

0:42:09schedule like we didn't have time to

0:42:10actually design this we just use a bunch

0:42:12of stock parts and we screw them

0:42:13together like the way the bed wrap of

0:42:15you know American cars or any car maker

0:42:17that use like a parts bin dashboard

0:42:19where we have a bunch of things that we

0:42:22use in all our cars like the window

0:42:23switches or whatever and we're not going

0:42:24to design custom onto this car because

0:42:26it's too much trouble so just slapping

0:42:27the same switches that we use on all

0:42:28other cars very American car markets

0:42:30used to do stuff like us all the time

0:42:31these days there's more custom parts in

0:42:34cars than you would expect but that type

0:42:36of thing it's just not how Apple does

0:42:39things they're not aside from trying to

0:42:41share the same stupid keyboard and all

0:42:43their laptops they like I don't think

0:42:45this this thing is gonna you know if

0:42:48it's as it could be as boring as bread

0:42:51and butter and it's still gonna take

0:42:52them two years to make it that's just

0:42:54how long the stuff takes and like you

0:42:56were saying marker with like you were

0:42:57thinking that it would just be the iMac

0:42:59Pro internals I still think that III

0:43:02thought that from the beginning that

0:43:03look don't get your hopes up for the

0:43:06insides of this Mac Pro to be anything

0:43:07other thing than the insides of that in

0:43:09terms of specs like obviously things

0:43:10will be rearranged and there'd be a new

0:43:11board and and you know different slots

0:43:14and stuff like that but fully expected

0:43:16to have a t2 and to have the same class

0:43:18of Xeon and so on and so forth

0:43:19now with a delay I still more or less

0:43:23expect it to be rearranged iMac pro

0:43:26internals like I don't expect it to have

0:43:27a t3 chip I expected that of a t2 chip

0:43:30right because they don't have time to

0:43:31make a whole other one of those in this

0:43:33in this timeline right unless they were

0:43:35already making it for the iMac processor

0:43:37which I think they are not right so I

0:43:38expect iMac pro internals maybe with

0:43:42with the newer Xeon if it's a drop-in

0:43:43replacement right more slots for

0:43:46everything more RAM slots more storage

0:43:48spots possibly more room for internal

0:43:53storage right just like capacity you

0:43:56know start from the design sort of the

0:43:58design brief of this thing should be

0:43:59like more thermal capacity than an iMac

0:44:02Pro and every other feature flows from

0:44:04that because if you don't do more

0:44:05thermal capacity than an iMac Pro then

0:44:07the only thing you're the only benefit

0:44:09you're getting is well as the screen

0:44:10breaks you don't lose your whole

0:44:11computer right so I feel like this thing

0:44:13is going to have higher thermal ceiling

0:44:15than the iMac

0:44:16and then you can do lots of stuff with a

0:44:18thermal sailing and it's then then it

0:44:20becomes a question of talking to these

0:44:21pro people like a writer like what do

0:44:23you want do you want two CPUs would you

0:44:25rather have more PCI Express let's do we

0:44:27have to offer you're both if we just

0:44:29made all them have one CD would that be

0:44:30okay

0:44:31how much internal storage you want

0:44:32versus external like but it's all like

0:44:34how you spend your thermal budget but

0:44:37the budget has to be way higher than the

0:44:39iMac Pro and all anybody capacity how

0:44:42much storage can you put in how much RAM

0:44:44can you put in it right and then of

0:44:46course how much heat can it dissipate

0:44:47how many GPUs can you put it how big can

0:44:50the GPUs be and then finally like use on

0:44:53the iMac Pro one of the reasons you like

0:44:54it is because it doesn't sound like a

0:44:56hairdryer all the time and this to make

0:44:59a big tower computer that has high

0:45:02thermal capacity but it's also

0:45:04reasonably quiet is tricky like I think

0:45:08about all the pcs I see and sometimes

0:45:10lust after that have these you know

0:45:12nicely designed pcs that have big

0:45:15cooling capacity and try to be quiet

0:45:17that doesn't happen if you just take a

0:45:19box and slap a bunch of fans in it like

0:45:21you have to be thoughtful in some ways

0:45:23to make sure you don't have any weird

0:45:25hotspots because you didn't think about

0:45:26this component over there like I know

0:45:29people bill Caesar like just get a

0:45:30really big diameter fan and put a whole

0:45:31bunch of them in there and it's like

0:45:32straightforward you just put pieces

0:45:33together but and assembling a PC like

0:45:37that unless you have lots of experience

0:45:38and know exactly how everything's gonna

0:45:39work with a bunch of custom parts can

0:45:42lead to weird things where the heat

0:45:45gradients that you didn't expect there

0:45:47or a particular component that is not

0:45:48getting adequate cooling because there's

0:45:50just no way to route air to there and

0:45:51you it's just it's hacky and it's not

0:45:53it's not up the apples quality so I

0:45:56think that even if Apple is making the

0:46:00most boring box we could possibly think

0:46:02of that they have to they are going to

0:46:06do a better job then then I think some

0:46:09people would want those to those

0:46:10hackintosh type customers and as far as

0:46:11I'm concerned as someone who doesn't

0:46:13need this thing right now although you

0:46:15may disagree when you think to how old

0:46:17my Mac is but I'd rather like spend the

0:46:19time spend the time to make even if it's

0:46:21a boring tower spend the time to make a

0:46:22boring tower that's as nice as a cheese

0:46:24grater spend the time to make it look

0:46:25nice it's been in time to make sure that

0:46:28is super reliable

0:46:30that it's quiet figure out a way to make

0:46:31it quiet and yes spend the time talking

0:46:33to people the various prose and saying

0:46:35what do you what do you want out of this

0:46:37machine like do we have to make two

0:46:39slots or CPUs or is that something that

0:46:40nobody wants and we don't have to do

0:46:41that

0:46:42because I don't think they're gonna have

0:46:4417 different configurable versions of

0:46:45this right and I also don't think

0:46:48they're going to make it some magic

0:46:51modular snapped together a future

0:46:53technology Thunderbolt 3 powered octopus

0:46:55thing I know lots of people think that

0:46:57you know 2019 this is gonna be some

0:46:59crazy trashcan but I don't I don't think

0:47:01that I think it's gonna be a fairly

0:47:02straightforward machine I just want to

0:47:03be nice I just um

0:47:05I I'm struggling because I I do see both

0:47:08sides of this like on the one side just

0:47:10like you guys had said you know why not

0:47:12just make take the old cheese grater

0:47:14you know form-factor slap new bits in it

0:47:17and call it a day

0:47:18but there's been a lot of changes to the

0:47:22Mac in the last couple of years you know

0:47:23what used to be for the purposes of this

0:47:26conversation when it used to be just

0:47:28vanilla intel motherboards with vanilla

0:47:29intel chips on them now or not quite so

0:47:32simple we have the you know the tea to

0:47:34that that one of you guys mentioned

0:47:35earlier we have all these different you

0:47:37know coprocessors we have a touch bar

0:47:39that we have never seen be external to

0:47:41the device we have a secure Enclave

0:47:43there's so many different things that

0:47:45make this so much more complex than

0:47:46before and when when you also add

0:47:50modularity into this because there's

0:47:53basically no Apple computers sold today

0:47:57that is as modular as we are expecting

0:48:00and being told that this will be and I

0:48:02can't imagine it's easy to keep up with

0:48:06these extremely stringent security

0:48:07requirements while also doing this mod

0:48:12you know this modular thing so as an

0:48:14example like this phantom Apple display

0:48:15this new cinema display if you will

0:48:17presumably that's going to have a camera

0:48:20in an iSight camera in it or FaceTime

0:48:22camera or whatever they're calling it

0:48:23now presumably they're going to want

0:48:25that to be controlled by you know the t2

0:48:27or whatever it is it controls in these

0:48:29days how do you do that when it's not

0:48:32part of the device itself how does that

0:48:34work so yeah I mean you could just say

0:48:37yes screw it if somebody can hack your

0:48:40camera well tough nuggies you made this

0:48:42bed yourself if that's not apples

0:48:43so I understand all the angst about Oh

0:48:46we'll just you know use a cheese grater

0:48:47put some new bits in it walk away and I

0:48:50could make a pretty good argument that

0:48:52they should do that and then do the real

0:48:53Mac Pro afterwards but just like you

0:48:56said John like that's not Apple's way

0:48:58apples ways to make this interesting and

0:49:00innovative and and smart and I think and

0:49:03I hope that's what they're doing oh nice

0:49:05I like it doesn't have to be innovative

0:49:07because it's like as the cheese grater

0:49:08is it innovative like what's innovative

0:49:10about the cheese grater the only things

0:49:11innovative about it is how nice it is

0:49:12like it's not it was just it's just a

0:49:15tower case like the there was the CPUs

0:49:17weren't arranged in an octagon it wasn't

0:49:19cooled by like jellyfish like it was

0:49:22just a tower case with fans and had hard

0:49:25drives and RAM and slots and like it was

0:49:26very straightforward but it's nice that

0:49:30the trash can was innovative wow this

0:49:32tube shape thing with a chimney design

0:49:34and a little triangle motherboard and

0:49:35two GPUs and like that that was an

0:49:38innovative design and that's what people

0:49:40are afraid is happening and I I mean I'm

0:49:42assuming talking to the pros that pros

0:49:44are not saying please make it you know

0:49:46really weird like they they don't care

0:49:48what it looks like they hoping that the

0:49:50influence talking these people will

0:49:52cause it to be more will push back

0:49:55against any unconventional thinking that

0:49:57Apple may bring to the table what what

0:49:59if we gave you something like this I

0:50:00hope the pros go that might work but I

0:50:03know this will work so why don't you

0:50:04just make me this and by the way this

0:50:05article honest I'm mistaken does not say

0:50:08that this pro workflow team was created

0:50:10for this it just tells you about the pro

0:50:12work for the team I have no idea how

0:50:13long the pro workflow team has been an

0:50:15apple maybe they'd been there for a

0:50:16decade advising the Final Cut Pro team

0:50:17and every Pro Mac that they've ever made

0:50:19right this is just part of to soften the

0:50:22blow of the of the macro not being this

0:50:24year will tell you about a thing that

0:50:26previously we had no reason to tell you

0:50:27about because what do you care what we

0:50:29do internally right but to make you feel

0:50:31like we're really paying attention will

0:50:32tell you about this which i think is

0:50:34fine like if someone snarkily tweeted

0:50:36congratulations Apple you've discovered

0:50:38user acceptance testing which hasn't

0:50:42discovered it like I said I think this

0:50:44has always existed maybe it's been

0:50:45ramped up maybe they've been given

0:50:47closer access to machines instead of

0:50:48just being giving weird you know

0:50:50disguised boxes and saying what do you

0:50:51think of this but this this is the type

0:50:55of thing

0:50:56then you would hope any company's doing

0:50:59but that the sort of The Legend of Apple

0:51:02the the face that they present to the

0:51:04world doesn't include this like the The

0:51:08Legend of Apple is we don't need to talk

0:51:11to people to know what to make we don't

0:51:13do focus groups we don't ask you what

0:51:15you want because you don't know what you

0:51:16want will tell you what you want we know

0:51:18it's like we we just go off to the

0:51:21mountain and we come down with a thing

0:51:22and trust me you'll love it right and

0:51:24that's how we got the touch bar yeah

0:51:26maybe not I think maybe that's more of

0:51:28the focus group thing or someone has an

0:51:30idea and you tell people do you think

0:51:31this is a good idea and everyone goes

0:51:32yeah that sounds like it might be a good

0:51:33idea but people are dummies like this

0:51:35like it's a steve job the steve jobs

0:51:37school of thought of like you know don't

0:51:40ask people like we are smart enough on

0:51:42our own to figure it out if we ask

0:51:43people we'll make mediocre stuff because

0:51:45that's that's true of any product focus

0:51:48groups are death it's like the you know

0:51:49the homework are from from the simpsons

0:51:51right just everyone has ideas about what

0:51:53they think they want but everyone is not

0:51:55a product designer it's your job as a

0:51:56product designer to you no synthesize

0:51:58their desires and figure out what it is

0:52:00that they really want so on and so forth

0:52:01but the more company is perceived to be

0:52:05allowing the customer to lead them the

0:52:08more it is likely to make mediocre

0:52:11products and to lose sight of true

0:52:14innovation result innovators dilemma

0:52:15things like you know just keep talking

0:52:17to your best customers they'll

0:52:18continually ask for like we do on the

0:52:20show essentially it you just listen to

0:52:22your mainframe customers they keep

0:52:23telling you about how they want you to

0:52:24make better and better mainframes and

0:52:25you miss the PC revolution right because

0:52:26you're like because you just like well

0:52:28are all of our biggest customers say

0:52:30they want this and they want that and

0:52:31you will never make the PC if you keep

0:52:34talking to your mainframe customers you

0:52:36have to say well actually there's

0:52:37another thing we should be doing and

0:52:38those customers will never tell us to do

0:52:40that there's a million business books

0:52:41about this right but Apple we don't

0:52:43perceive as saying we're not really sure

0:52:45how to make a pro computer can we get

0:52:47some pros and here to tell us what do

0:52:48you like do you like this do you like

0:52:49that like it's if strong position like a

0:52:51weakness and we want them to just know

0:52:53everything automatically and just make

0:52:54beautiful things that everybody loved

0:52:56reality of course is neither extreme is

0:52:58true Steve Jobs is Apple still took

0:53:01customer feedback and like that's always

0:53:02been a part of the process and this

0:53:05whole Pro work ball team I'm sure it

0:53:06does have some influence but in the end

0:53:08of Johnny Arizona

0:53:09it's not going on there so I think you

0:53:14know this is one of the reasons you

0:53:16don't talk about your process because

0:53:18once people out something company start

0:53:20thinking about your process it it loses

0:53:23some of the magic and you start worrying

0:53:26about is that really the best process to

0:53:29do this I'm not on that fair workflow

0:53:30team what if they're not talking to me

0:53:32in fact we got some feedback about that

0:53:33from other people saying yeah they're

0:53:35talking to pros in film and video and

0:53:38whatever industries but they're not

0:53:39talking to pros in my industry whatever

0:53:42that may be you know academics R&D you

0:53:46know scientific stuff I don't know I

0:53:51figured what the calories outside of

0:53:53what they have listed that are on the

0:53:56pro work with and for all we know the

0:53:57protein does include all those they

0:53:58didn't tell us everything about them but

0:54:00either way if you don't feel like your

0:54:02views are being represented and you buy

0:54:05into the idea that it's that small group

0:54:07of people that's essentially dictating

0:54:09what this machine will look like that

0:54:10doesn't feel good either because now

0:54:12when the machine comes out you could be

0:54:13like oh great that business is a great

0:54:15machine for video editors but for me

0:54:17doing medical imaging it sucks they

0:54:19should have had medical images in there

0:54:20for a murkrow team that's you know

0:54:21that's the difficulty of making any

0:54:24product they are not gonna make an

0:54:25entire line of Mac Pro's to suit

0:54:28everybody's needs they're gonna make one

0:54:30that suits most people's needs where

0:54:33most is defined as people Apple things

0:54:35will buy a Mac Pro and at that with the

0:54:37asterisk we hope it will suit most

0:54:39people's needs we hope yeah maybe

0:54:41they'll be wrong about that maybe you

0:54:42know that's again what the process like

0:54:45wouldn't it be for all you know Apple if

0:54:48you made this kind of computer a whole

0:54:49new class of people would want to buy it

0:54:51and ignore the pro video people because

0:54:53your real market is you know like makers

0:54:56but their 3d printers and they need to

0:54:57do CAD on it I don't know like that's

0:54:59kind of apples job to figure out but if

0:55:03you start if your starting point is a

0:55:05more or less conventional tower with a

0:55:07separate monitor that's really nice and

0:55:09that has the same capabilities and

0:55:11performance profile as the iMac Pro but

0:55:13with more capacity that's a pretty good

0:55:15starting point for most people know they

0:55:16can ask for things here and there but I

0:55:20don't think that that Pro work

0:55:22is going to do anything other than have

0:55:26minor suggestions about a very

0:55:30conventional design and best-case

0:55:33scenario that team was able to dissuade

0:55:35Apple very early on like last year

0:55:37sometime to not make you know a weird

0:55:40octopus thing right say yeah don't go

0:55:43down that path like we have some

0:55:45sketches I hope everyone involved would

0:55:47say that might be good it might be bad

0:55:50but it's an unknown and you already did

0:55:51that with a trash can so let's just reel

0:55:53this back in let's let's start with a

0:55:54box I feel like - like there's there's

0:55:58different levels at which this kind of

0:56:01like user focus group or work group is

0:56:04useful or needed it makes total sense to

0:56:07have people who use say the pro apps

0:56:11work with Apple on some level and have

0:56:14Apple asked them like what they need and

0:56:16watch what they need and and you know

0:56:18we're we're closely with them to tailor

0:56:20the pro apps to the needs of the people

0:56:22who buy them but as you go kind of

0:56:25further down I guess the stack of the

0:56:29platforms the operating systems and then

0:56:32eventually the hardware it gets less and

0:56:34less specific the whole appeal of

0:56:37personal computing is that these

0:56:39machines are generalists they can be

0:56:42used to do anything lots of different

0:56:45tasks can be done on these machines and

0:56:47so the the hardware and the platforms in

0:56:50the OS have to be able to support

0:56:53anything because you never know what

0:56:56people are going to do you know you can

0:56:58you can pick a few use cases and say

0:57:00let's make sure you know that it works

0:57:01well for these use cases because we've

0:57:03heard that a lot of people use it for

0:57:04that or something but you can never

0:57:06accommodate everything via user testing

0:57:09that people are going to want these

0:57:10computers and operating systems to do so

0:57:13as you go down like it yeah have the the

0:57:16team that makes final cut work with

0:57:18video editors that makes total sense

0:57:20but even that is like kind of hard to

0:57:22describe like I guarantee you no one on

0:57:25the logic team has ever watched somebody

0:57:27had on a podcast and logic and maybe

0:57:30it's a pretty light use case I don't

0:57:32know but I'm telling you it's never

0:57:33happened but anyway the OS and the ha

0:57:36we're have to be as versatile as

0:57:38possible so this is why this is kind of

0:57:41like a like I don't think this has a lot

0:57:43to do with the Mac Pro like this this

0:57:45user I think this is purely like a PR

0:57:47thing to cover up they the information

0:57:50they wanted to communicate was don't

0:57:52expect a Mac Pro this year and as John

0:57:53said you know they they gave you this

0:57:55Pro workflows group thing as like

0:57:58something good to stick on top of that

0:58:00and that's nice but I don't think

0:58:02they're that related and the design of

0:58:05the of a Mac any Mac even you know a lot

0:58:08of people have been arguing about like

0:58:09the definition of Pro what counts as a

0:58:11pro I think this is a totally useless

0:58:13distinction it doesn't matter Pro is

0:58:15marketing that's all it is it Pro just

0:58:17means the bigger one of the more

0:58:18expensive one any other any other

0:58:20focusing of what this definition is is

0:58:22is not productive all of the computers

0:58:24in the lineup should be as versatile as

0:58:27possible the OS and the platforms and

0:58:30everything should be as versatile as

0:58:31possible to accommodate any kind of work

0:58:33any kind of workflow any kind of

0:58:35workload the only reason that you

0:58:37shouldn't be able to do something on a

0:58:39MacBook Air that you can do on a Mac Pro

0:58:42is if the MacBook Air doesn't have

0:58:45hardware support for what you're doing

0:58:48if it doesn't have enough RAM or if it's

0:58:50just too damn slow or if it doesn't have

0:58:52enough Thunderbolt bandwidth that should

0:58:54be the only difference between these

0:58:55products and when computers are properly

0:58:58designed which they have been for

0:58:59decades that is the only distinction if

0:59:01for most types of applications unless

0:59:03there's like a specific GPU requirement

0:59:05something like you don't quote need a

0:59:08MacBook Pro to edit video you couldn't

0:59:11edit video in a MacBook Air it'll just

0:59:13be slower and stuff like that like when

0:59:15you buy or if you sell computers you try

0:59:17to make these distinctions you try to

0:59:19say oh well this you need to go to this

0:59:21model if you need to do this or this way

0:59:23if you're only doing this you should

0:59:24only be using this cheapo crappy model

0:59:26over here but these distinctions are all

0:59:29just for sales and marketing and for the

0:59:30most part the only thing that matters is

0:59:32does it have the tech specs to do what

0:59:34you need at all and then you can argue

0:59:36about how fast to bring in user testing

0:59:40groups like it like this to influence

0:59:43hardware decisions I think is

0:59:45questionable because for a long time

0:59:50to the best of our knowledge these kinds

0:59:53of people being brought in and for

0:59:54Hardware decisions were not necessary or

0:59:57weren't happening and we don't we still