0:00:00I got a bunch of funny stories to start the show. Here's one Saturday afternoon
0:00:04Jonas and I wanted to go see ready player one. He's into video games. We're into Spielberg movies
0:00:10It looks like it's right up our alley. Our favorite theater is one that's outside the city
0:00:15It's about a 20 20 25 minute drive from Center City, Philadelphia
0:00:19Called the AMC Woodhaven 10. It's a great theater
0:00:23Somebody out there when we went to see the the last Jedi there said are you John Gruber?
0:00:29he's a listener of the show. I forget your name, good fellow, but I remember meeting him and his,
0:00:35I think, his girlfriend or wife. It's a really great theater. It's one that you get reserved
0:00:40seats. They're all full recliners. They have a great concession stand. It's not like you'd
0:00:48sit there and wait 10 minutes. It's like they actually want to serve you. They have a bar
0:00:52that serves beer, so you can have a beer, watch a movie. I just love to go there. It's a very clean
0:01:00place. I don't know how many years it's been open, but it still looks brand new.
0:01:03Great projection systems, great sound systems, etc., etc. So anyway, we get there to the AMC
0:01:08Woodhaven 10, and I've got my pre-bought tickets and our perfect seats all picked out from the day
0:01:14before. And it was telling me, instead of putting it in my wallet, which is what I've done in
0:01:20previous times, it didn't have that option. It said, "Just use your credit card in the
0:01:26kiosk." I thought, "Well, whatever. I'd rather just put it in my wallet, but what's
0:01:32the difference?" It says, "Are you sure? It doesn't seem like you have any tickets
0:01:37today." I'm looking at my email or the confirmation thing I have, and it says, "Two tickets
0:01:42for Matt and A. I got the day right, the AMC Woodhaven 10." I think, "Well, I've
0:01:48"Well, I gotta have to go talk to somebody."
0:01:50And while I'm waiting in line to talk to a guy
0:01:53at the ticket thing, I stare closely at the fine print,
0:01:56and it turns out I bought tickets for a matinee
0:02:00of Ready Player One at the AMC Woodhaven 10 in Michigan.
0:02:05(laughing)
0:02:08And so I look up--
0:02:13- All the geolocation services in the world
0:02:15could save you from that one.
0:02:16I look up in the, I was like, oh,
0:02:19maybe I could just buy tickets for the same showing here.
0:02:22Right? Problem solved.
0:02:23No, all I'm just out 18 bucks.
0:02:25And it turns out they didn't have another showing
0:02:29at that theater for like another two hours.
0:02:32And so I was like, well, I guess we're going home.
0:02:35I will say Jonas was an extraordinary good sport about it.
0:02:40It actually made me feel very good about his disposition
0:02:44and his willingness to accept.
0:02:46up disappointing. What are the odds? I mean, and you know what the problem is? Here's the
0:02:53problem I made was I made a couple mistakes, obviously. But the problem was in the past,
0:02:59what I've done is I've gone to I've used the Fandango app. You ever use this app? I searched
0:03:04for a movie. And then from the movie, I searched for the theater. And I've told this app that
0:03:10the AMC Woodhaven 10 is a favorite, but for whatever reason, it still sorts them by location.
0:03:16And like I said, it's 20, 25 minute drive.
0:03:18I don't know how many miles it is, but it's, it's by far,
0:03:20it's not the closest theater by far to us, to our house.
0:03:25And so I always have to scroll.
0:03:26So this time, instead of starting by searching for the movie,
0:03:29I started by searching for the theater.
0:03:31- And that's where everything went south.
0:03:36- And that's where everything went south.
0:03:38- Well, you know, when you,
0:03:39when you launched Safari on Google or anything,
0:03:42I mean, you would have used DuckDuckGo.
0:03:44- I do, for the most part.
0:03:45I've yeah, I just realized I've got at least one device that's still set to Google as the default
0:03:50I forget which one it is might be my MacBook. Yeah
0:03:52So I will I will say this
0:03:56Not not to denigrate your use of duck to go which I appreciate and understand what you do
0:04:01But when you do launch Safari with Google as your default search engine
0:04:07the first thing it does when you do a search is often asked for your
0:04:12access to your location. And obviously it would just do this on an Android device, on an iOS device, at least you get a warning. Like, "Hey, do you want to share your location?" And you're like, "No, I'm searching for food to bring my mistress. I'd rather not." And then hit dismiss. But you hit okay. And then of course, any search you would have done for Woodhaven Cinemas would have probably, most likely, turned up the nearest one.
0:04:36I even said that to Jonas on the way. I was like, you know, I was reviewing the mistakes
0:04:40I made one of them too was not noticing the
0:04:42It should have been suspicious when it wouldn't let me put it in a wallet
0:04:46But I who I just right right should have known something was up
0:04:50but who would I that theater didn't do digital the one the one in Michigan must not have a
0:04:56wallet scanner
0:04:58What if I Michigan's like 10 years behind?
0:05:02Only say that because one of my writers is in Michigan. I'm sure he'll hear this and love it
0:05:06I really could not hate me off on Michigan now. We've you know, we solved the problem
0:05:10We wound up going to a later show that afternoon at another theater closer closer to home and and enjoyed the movie
0:05:16tremendously
0:05:18Really enjoyed it. So you liked it. Oh, I enjoyed it. I really liked it. I liked it a lot and
0:05:23Okay, did you see it sounds like something you would know? I haven't I haven't seen it yet
0:05:28I want to see it
0:05:29But I hated the book so much that I'm trying to like just work myself up to this place where?
0:05:35I could sort of watch the movie. I have to basically have I have to bring two people
0:05:41to movie after bring myself and then I have to bring myself that read the book, huh? And
0:05:45They're gonna have different experiences of it. Well, you know, I'm gonna have to bifurcate my logic about it if it helps
0:05:52I didn't really like the book if it helps though
0:05:54I've seen a lot of complaints that it's too different from the book and Jonas room read and very much liked the book and
0:06:03It was an interesting it was a very interesting post movie conversation with him because he he liked the movie, too
0:06:10But was it was like the first time he was really struggling
0:06:13I think with his disappointment that a book adaptation wasn't as faithful as he wanted it to have been
0:06:19Even though he recognized that he liked the you know, you know
0:06:24We talked about why some of the changes were anyway
0:06:26I won't go on and on about it those mixed feelings that many of us have had over the years many many times
0:06:30you know, he's getting that first brush with that, like, "Oh, the book came alive in my head,
0:06:34and I imagined all these things." And I hear, obviously, that some of the plot particulars,
0:06:41you know, have been movieized as, you know, broadened or, you know, sharp edges,
0:06:47blended down to be more, you know, quick and paced well and stuff. But the minutia is what books are
0:06:53good at, you know? That's, you know. Pete: Yeah, there's a, you know, like,
0:06:56I don't think this is a spoiler. There's lots of stuff I could say about it that would be a terrible
0:07:00spoiler and so I won't. But one of them is that there's a part of the book where our heroes have
0:07:06to solve a puzzle of some sort. And in the movie, it's a car race. You know?
0:07:15Steven: Right. It's like nail on the head, prototypical movie stuff, right? Like when you go,
0:07:21"Oh, why didn't you like the movie? Oh, well, it dumps things down." How? Well, instead of
0:07:26meticulously solving a decades-old puzzle,
0:07:29they smash each other in the face with a board
0:07:31until one of them dies.
0:07:32- Yeah, it's effectively like the cinematic,
0:07:36it's like the cinematic version of Mario Kart.
0:07:38(laughing)
0:07:40Like a more violent version of Mario Kart.
0:07:42It's really good, it's a really good car chase.
0:07:45It is very inventive, it's good.
0:07:47- Well, it's good.
0:07:48- Oh, here's my other one.
0:07:49- Oh, yeah, I'll have to reserve judgment until I see it.
0:07:51- All right, here's my other opening anecdote
0:07:53that I just have to get off my chest,
0:07:54and maybe if this hadn't happened to me today, I wouldn't be so angry about it. But
0:08:02I literally lost a half an hour to this. So I've got a—our family account, we're
0:08:08on Verizon. But I also have a $50 a month prepaid T-Mobile account, which I use in like
0:08:15whatever Android phones I'm tinkering with. Sometimes I'll stick that SIM into an iPhone.
0:08:21I'm always spooked about getting it stuck to iMessage, but you know, it's just so I can have a second phone
0:08:26You know seems like a reasonable business expense given the racket
0:08:29I mean I got a text I don't but I don't check that all the time because I don't you know
0:08:33I don't it's not my daily carry. I don't carry two phones. So I turned it on
0:08:37Over the weekend. It turned out I had a text from last week from t-mobile saying that the credit card
0:08:43I was using for my prepaid account had an expired expiration date
0:08:48And they need to log in and update it. So I could you know, put it on my list is crap to do on Monday
0:08:54I log in and it says your password has expired
0:08:58You have to create a new password
0:09:01Passwords don't expire. That's the dumb
0:09:03Right, and they've got these rules and the rules are you have to have at least one letter
0:09:09You have to have at least one number you are not allowed to use spaces and it has to be between eight and fifty characters
0:09:17Those are the rules. Okay, so I start making passwords that fit these rules and
0:09:24paste them in and the two fields and I hit update and it says nope that's that's
0:09:33no good and I'm like well all the rules have you know they the rules turn into
0:09:37green check marks as you type as you fulfill them like once you write the
0:09:41number it changes and I'm going nuts and it says it it just keeps saying the
0:09:46password provided does not meet T-Mobile's security policy.
0:09:50So I think, all right, maybe it's content blockers.
0:09:51It's like they're verifying this with JavaScript.
0:09:54Reload without contact blockers.
0:09:56Nope, same problem.
0:09:57So I think, all right, maybe it's Safari.
0:09:59I'll go to Chrome.
0:10:00I go to Chrome, log in, and I get the exact same thing.
0:10:04And I think, what the hell is going on?
0:10:06I was like, well, it's gotta work on an iPhone.
0:10:07If I do it on an iPhone, everybody has, you know,
0:10:09they have to make their password thing work on an iPhone.
0:10:12Go on the iPhone.
0:10:13I start searching the web to see if other people
0:10:15have this problem is T-Mobile's website down, but they won't let me do anything else with
0:10:19my account until I set a new password. Like I can't skip this and go to billing. I'm telling
0:10:25you, I spent half an hour on this and I figured out eventually that they also don't allow
0:10:31any punctuation characters.
0:10:33But they don't tell you that.
0:10:36No, they don't tell you.
0:10:37You have to discover that one on your own. It's not like a fun surprise.
0:10:39It's not listed in the rules and it's not given to you as the error when they let you,
0:10:45they'll let you submit a password that contains hyphens.
0:10:48- Right.
0:10:49- I got mine, the passwords I was trying,
0:10:51I tried Safari auto-generated passwords.
0:10:53- The suggested ones.
0:10:54- Which have hyphens.
0:10:55- Yeah, they all have hyphens.
0:10:56- And the other system I use to make passwords
0:10:59puts hyphens between the words
0:11:01because there's so many systems
0:11:03that don't let you use spaces.
0:11:05I literally lost a half an hour to that.
0:11:07And that is the stupidest thing I've ever heard
0:11:09because it's actually less secure.
0:11:11Like they're the ones, the stupid assholes
0:11:13who made me lose 30 minutes.
0:11:15and they're the ones with a password system
0:11:17that won't accept punctuation characters.
0:11:20(laughing)
0:11:22- Yeah, you gotta be extra secure,
0:11:24so we expire this password,
0:11:26and now we're gonna make our passwords easier to guess.
0:11:29- This is just crazy.
0:11:31I really thought that I was gonna have to get a new sim.
0:11:35Just let it expire.
0:11:36- I think I have, I'll be honest,
0:11:40I have had bad experiences.
0:11:42It wasn't the same exact thing,
0:11:43but I've had bad experiences with prepaid and accounts
0:11:46and things like that, so I think I have three
0:11:48T-Mobile accounts, because I have abandoned
0:11:50at least one account before,
0:11:53because I couldn't get it to do it.
0:11:55And in my case, I think it was,
0:11:57I think it was the iPad auto-generated account
0:12:01that really caused my issues,
0:12:03'cause that thing where you buy an iPad,
0:12:06and it comes with, in the US anyway,
0:12:08it comes with free T-Mobile, like 150 megabytes,
0:12:11which is like, you open one webpage these days,
0:12:13That's it. You're done. It's open google.com with a doodle and it's like, well, that's
0:12:20150 megabytes. This flash game in the doodle really bones you on that one. But they create
0:12:28that account and you know, you get an enter an email and password and all that or try
0:12:32to log in with an existing. And it's like one of those things where you try to log in
0:12:35with your existing one and then like as you said, your password is expired, you haven't
0:12:39logged in forever because I have the same thing. I have a prepaid that I bounce around,
0:12:42know. And that system really led me to go like, "Fine, I'll just put in the secondary
0:12:48email address." And now you can't log into that because I've long since gotten
0:12:52rid of that iPad. It was either an Apple demo or one that I sold or whatever. And so you
0:12:57have a bunch of vestigial T-Mobile accounts hanging out. I don't know why it's T-Mobile.
0:13:01I don't know if I'd have the same problem on other networks, but I already have accounts
0:13:05with those. I don't know. But yeah.
0:13:06Tim Cynova Yeah. It's a weird one.
0:13:07Jared Ranere I think they need to work on that.
0:13:09Tim Cynova It makes me so mad.
0:13:11Or not. Maybe they like it. Maybe they think it's fun.
0:13:16People are such bad programmers. I mean, why would you make a system like this?
0:13:22Did you see that T-Mobile tweet chain?
0:13:25No, no.
0:13:26That happened this past week? Forgive me, I'm trying to hang out less and less on Twitter,
0:13:31but I did happen to see it as I was driving by. I don't have the whole odyssey, so if
0:13:36there's some follow-up that's happened in the last day or so, a couple of days, I don't
0:13:39there was basically a chain last week that was started because somebody said something about
0:13:45their password to T-Mobile and they said, "Hey, I was on the phone with your agent and they asked
0:13:52me for my password and were able to verify it." And obviously, as you know, most modern companies
0:13:58don't even ask you for your password over the phone. Even if you call them or whatever, they'll
0:14:04ask for other verification components like maybe social, which is ironic, or other things,
0:14:09but they generally don't ask you for your password. But I guess the agent asked him
0:14:13for his password and T-Mobile was able to verify, the agent was able to verify that
0:14:19that was his password. And so at some point, the password was like in plain text, you know,
0:14:25where they could see it, they could not hash, not encrypted in any way where an agent couldn't
0:14:30just look up your password. But that's too many people to be able to look up your password,
0:14:33You know?
0:14:34And then this thread trembled out and I guess,
0:14:39basically it boiled down to T-Mobile was storing
0:14:42at least some of the password in plain text.
0:14:45I'm not exactly sure or even all of it.
0:14:48And the answer that the T-Mobile rep,
0:14:50and I'm assuming this T-Mobile rep is now canned,
0:14:52unfortunately, not like I wish it on anyone,
0:14:55but they were responding to this thread.
0:14:57You know how they do from the official T-Mobile Australia.
0:15:00It was Australia.
0:15:01T-Mobile Australia account, and then, you know,
0:15:04with the little dash MC or BR,
0:15:07whatever their initials are, you know, for the support rep.
0:15:09And they replied and they said,
0:15:12well, it doesn't matter if your password's zero plate text
0:15:14'cause our security is so awesome.
0:15:16- I did see that, I did see, I thought it was a joke.
0:15:18This is real.
0:15:19- No, I don't, I mean, it's real as far,
0:15:22I mean, unless it's an elaborate parody
0:15:24that I am not wise to, I believe it was real.
0:15:26And people, of course, at that point just exploded.
0:15:29Because at that point, it's no longer about trying to figure out the truth of how much
0:15:34of the password they could see. Can they only see the last four digits? Is that really secure?
0:15:38Is that a thing anybody should be doing? And then, of course, the dialogue then went right
0:15:43on to, "Oh, really? You're claiming to be un-hackable? That's your defense?" This is
0:15:50the classic stuff. They really need to get it together.
0:15:53uh hey i should mention uh before i forget because i keep forgetting every week uh there is going to
0:15:58be a live episode of the talk show at wwdc uh it will be on tuesday whatever day june that is
0:16:06uh at the california theater once again uh top top people are working on this right now
0:16:13uh i literally top men tickets are not yet available uh but they will be soon and i'm i
0:16:23know it's sold out very quickly uh the last few years and that's very exciting uh and in a way
0:16:30makes me proud but it also makes me very sad because i realized that there are a lot of more
0:16:34people who would like to be in attendance than who will be able to be in attendance and i'm
0:16:39We're trying to figure out the best, fairest possible way to make it so sorry. But I have
0:16:47no information to announce yet. And I guess, see, and here's the problem. Here's what I'm
0:16:54kind of stammering around is people know that. And what people want to know is they don't want
0:16:59to know how to get tickets. They want to know where to go to find out when I'm going to announce
0:17:06how to get tickets. Like what is the thing that they should be reloading constantly all day every
0:17:12day? Yeah, exactly. What should they have a monitor on? Right. And the one year I did it by
0:17:17announcing it in the middle of a regular show. And I thought, well, that'd be fun. It would make
0:17:23people listen to the show. But I think that was a bad idea. I don't think I thought that through
0:17:28all the way because I think it made, you know, people started like, you know, they weren't really
0:17:31listening to the show. They were like dancing, you know, quick download the show and like skip
0:17:3615 seconds until you get to the part. And so I don't know what I'm going to do, but I'm very
0:17:42sorry about that. But we will try to live stream it. And I think last year's live stream was pretty
0:17:47successful. So hopefully our experience, you know, with a year of experience under our belt, we'll do
0:17:52even better this year for those who can't attend. And yeah, I mean, the show was great last year.
0:17:57Good venue too. That was a fantastic. I like that venue. The loading was a little bit tight in there,
0:18:02but after that I think everybody had a really good time. Yeah, I have to figure out how to do that too.
0:18:06It seemed like because it's general admission and like if there was a problem with last year's show,
0:18:11it was that everybody quick wanted to stand by the doors waiting for that. You know,
0:18:15we let people into the lobby and then we didn't have the theater doors open and it might have
0:18:21been like a soccer riot or something. So I don't know. I don't know how to deal with that. Yeah,
0:18:26- Yeah, but nerds don't riot, so you're fine.
0:18:28- Right.
0:18:29- It's good.
0:18:30(laughing)
0:18:30They're just used to standing in line.
0:18:33Stand over here, okay.
0:18:33- I always say, I've gotten this,
0:18:36I got this last year from the folks,
0:18:37the fine staff at the California Theater,
0:18:40and I used to get it at Mezzanine in San Francisco
0:18:42when I held it there, is after every show they would say,
0:18:45you have the nicest, politest fans
0:18:48of anybody who's ever been here.
0:18:50So I hope we can keep that up.
0:18:53That makes me very proud.
0:18:55the DF audience. Yeah. Um, you know why I have some,
0:18:59as someone who has some experience in, um,
0:19:02events and live events and ticketing and whatnot. Um, not, I'm nobody's expert,
0:19:06but just a suggestion might be,
0:19:08you might want to release them in batches at different times.
0:19:11Cause I think that's, I mean, I'm sure you know this,
0:19:14but that's like a common thing with dub dub is that people go, Oh, you know,
0:19:17you recently released them at a really convenient time for the West coast,
0:19:20but um, nobody else has a chance. Obviously now it's lottery. So not,
0:19:24none of that is really applicable.
0:19:26But I don't know if you wanna go full lottery at this point.
0:19:28You might end up having better success just to saying,
0:19:31hey, I'm gonna release one quarter of the tickets
0:19:35throughout the day, all day on this day.
0:19:37And that way, hopefully people will be up
0:19:39and have their coffee and maybe get a chance
0:19:41to buy the tickets.
0:19:42- I did that a little bit last year.
0:19:43I think I did two batches.
0:19:44Maybe I should break it up into more.
0:19:46And I made a mistake last year
0:19:47where I broke off the main floor from the balcony.
0:19:53and the main floor ones went first, I think.
0:19:57But then I found out from the staff
0:19:58that they would much prefer just general admission
0:20:01and they'll sort people.
0:20:03And so I shouldn't have done that.
0:20:04- Oh, and yeah, they'll load them.
0:20:06'Cause that way it creates like a log jam
0:20:09with like the people trying to get upstairs.
0:20:11- I will say from people who are in the balcony,
0:20:13I know it sounds better.
0:20:14It would certainly be more exciting.
0:20:15Everybody wants to be in the front row or whatever,
0:20:17but it's a wonderful theater and the balcony
0:20:19is really not like second class seats.
0:20:23It's really beautiful up there.
0:20:25So anyway.
0:20:26- Yeah, it is a true theater.
0:20:28So it is meant so that the people on the balcony
0:20:31can have a great view and great acoustics.
0:20:33- Yeah, it's really a funny thing.
0:20:35I don't even know if I was the first
0:20:38to have a live show at the WWDC.
0:20:40I'm not trying to get bragging rights.
0:20:44But I do think I was one of them.
0:20:49And it's really cool now how many podcasts there are
0:20:53during the week at WWDC.
0:20:55ATP's doing one Monday night.
0:20:59Brent Simmons just announced that his The Omni Show podcast
0:21:05that he does as a marketing person at The Omni Group,
0:21:09they're gonna do one at the, what's it called,
0:21:11the Next Door Conference right after the State of the Union.
0:21:15So right after the State of the Union Monday afternoon,
0:21:17there's gonna be a show.
0:21:19There's a bunch more, the Relay FM guys have, I don't know,
0:21:22probably dozens of shows throughout the week.
0:21:24But I think that's so cool and it gives everybody,
0:21:26it gives people who don't have WDBTC passes a reason
0:21:29to go to San, you know, feel like you got something,
0:21:32you know, you're doing something other
0:21:34than just sitting around drinking and eating, you know?
0:21:37- Yeah, and there's an ecosystem of events
0:21:39that has grown up around it, as you said,
0:21:40like podcasts, you know, the fine folks
0:21:44at the Layers Conference, they post theirs.
0:21:46was right. I don't know if it's going to be at the same spot this year, but it was right
0:21:49across the street from the conference center last year, which must have been convenient
0:21:53for folks who wanted to bounce back and forth.
0:21:55Trenton Larkin Yeah, I don't think that the I know layers
0:21:58is happening and it's going to be in San Jose. Last I spoke to Jesse charred, I don't think
0:22:04they have the venue nailed down. Like I think it's in the you know, possibly at the same
0:22:08venue, possibly somewhere else. I don't know. But it's it's a great conference too. Yeah.
0:22:14Why don't we start by taking a break? I'll thank our first sponsor. The wonderful, wonderful
0:22:24people at Tres Pontas Coffee. Tres Pontas is a family-owned coffee farm in Brazil. And
0:22:36that's been in the family for generations, the Reis family, R-E-I-S, and for decades—here's
0:22:44what it tastes like—for over 100 years and three generations. So this family's been
0:22:50growing premium coffee in Brazil for a very long time, over 100 years. But until very
0:22:54recently in their deal with Tres Pontas, they only sold their coffee in Brazil to local
0:23:00roasters. So this is the first time they've exported, they've begun exporting coffee
0:23:03to the United States. You couldn't get Tres Pontas coffee from this raised plantation until now.
0:23:09It's really, really fresh. It's good coffee, but the big difference between a lot of places where
0:23:16you can get gourmet coffee is a lot of times you buy it and it's a few weeks old already.
0:23:22It makes a difference. Coffee, even after it's been roasted, is a produce. It goes bad.
0:23:28may not go like rotten, but it just loses some of the freshness. It really does make a difference.
0:23:34So when you order Tres Pontas coffee, it's not sitting in a warehouse somewhere and then they
0:23:42go grab your order and send it to you. You place your order and then they roast some beans and
0:23:48stick them in a bag and you get the next batch that goes out. So it's super, super fresh. And
0:23:53it comes with a date stamp on it. When you cut rives at your house, you'll see just how fresh
0:23:57it is. I just got one sat another shipment on Saturday and it was roasted like three
0:24:01days before three or four days. Just crazy, crazy fresh coffee. And there's two ways to
0:24:08buy it. You can go to their website, trace Pontas, T-R-E-S-P-O-N-T-A-S coffee or no trace
0:24:15Pontas.com/coffee. And I'm telling you, it'd be roasted fresh for you shipped out immediately.
0:24:21And you don't have to choose between varieties. What you choose between with them is the roast.
0:24:26roast, light, medium, dark, and French roast. Really, really easy. They have one type of
0:24:32coffee and they roast it to different degrees based on your taste. But the other way to
0:24:37get it is you can go to Amazon and search for tres pontas and it'll be the first thing
0:24:41you see. And the stuff from Amazon, they're just using Amazon as a front end. They still
0:24:46fulfill it so you still get the same fresh roasted coffee right from the tres pontas
0:24:50people. It's not sitting in an Amazon warehouse. Just an easier way for you to shop if you're
0:24:54already an Amazon customer. And all orders in the US. I'm sorry for those of you outside
0:25:00the US, but you get free shipping in the US when you order it. I don't know how they do
0:25:04that. Now here's the special offer they have for listeners of the show. What you can do
0:25:08is you can sign up for a coffee subscription and you get freshly roasted beans sent to
0:25:12you every one, two or four weeks. Your choice. One bag every two weeks is perfect for me.
0:25:17For one, one coffee drinker who drinks coffee just about every day. And when you sign up
0:25:23for a coffee subscription, you always save 10% off every bag. But listeners at the talk
0:25:27show can get an extra 10% off by using the code, the talk show all one word at checkout.
0:25:34So that means you'll save 20% off every bag in your subscription with that code, just
0:25:39enter that code at checkout. So go there, sign up for a subscription. Remember that
0:25:43code the talk show, and you'll save 20% off every bag in perpetuity. So there you go.
0:25:50My thanks to Trace Pontas. Go check him out on Amazon or at tracepontas.com/coffee. You
0:25:57had quite a week last week. We might as well talk about this for a little bit. I guess
0:26:02so. Long story short, you got an exclusive behind the scenes. I don't even want to.
0:26:11It's not a look. I mean, you spent a couple hours at Apple, right? Talking to their product
0:26:16marketing and their Pro Tools group did you do was it last year was last week
0:26:20when you went got it all put us together yes to last Tuesday okay mm-hmm so tell
0:26:29me you know tell the story yeah so the whole premise was that I was gonna be in
0:26:36room for a bit with four people from Apple's, which I didn't know at the time, but learned as I was there from their pro workflow group. The pro workflow group is a new group that they've created inside and literally lives in the building, where a lot of their pro products are being sort of designed and built.
0:27:06And that group is responsible for evaluating professional workflows to figure out ways where Apple hardware or software or a combination thereof is sort of not doing what it should or not being as efficient or as effective or whatever as possible.
0:27:25And so the four people from the group were all basically either hardware or software or oversight or marketing from that group that kind of looked over, oversaw different projects to do with their pro group.
0:27:42their program. And so we talked for a couple of hours and then
0:27:45went on a little tour of the system that basically, you know,
0:27:51got to see like, Hey, where this is, this is how we view how we
0:27:56see pros using logic. And then this is how we see pros using
0:27:59Final Cut Pro. And then some of the actual facilities where
0:28:03they're where the pro workflow group is doing their work
0:28:07following. So
0:28:08John Greenewald So you didn't know in advance that this what
0:28:10did you know it was going to be Mac Mac related? I mean, how much did you know in advance?
0:28:14Jay Haynes Yeah, I mean, I didn't know a ton in advance, besides the fact that yes, it would essentially be some sort of follow on to the year ago roundtable, right? Which you were at, where they basically said, Hey, the Mac Pro is not going to work, you know, out as we knew. Yeah, exactly. At that point. And so we need to restart our thinking on this and kind of start this project over.
0:28:40So, I knew it was going to be a retrospective on that. So, obviously, you know, at that
0:28:45point you kind of go like, "Oh, okay, well, if it's going to be that…" So, they're
0:28:49obviously, you know, hopefully going to be sharing some sort of information about the
0:28:52status of it, which they did. And then also, from there, it's a matter of like, "Okay,
0:28:58what's the rest of the time going to be? Is it going to be philosophy or whatever?"
0:29:01And I ended up finding out who I was going to be talking to shortly before, which is
0:29:06always helpful. I always hate going into a room not knowing who it is because it just
0:29:10like a few minutes to or or sometime hopefully that's it's to think about what good questions
0:29:17are to ask these people it is because they don't they have wildly different jobs a lot
0:29:20of them it is can ask the same question everybody it is standard Apple PR technique not to tell
0:29:25you who you're meeting with. Mm hmm. It's I Yeah, I hate it. But it can be exciting.
0:29:32Yeah, I mean, it's fine. I mean, you got to be on your toes. You know, you got to walk
0:29:35in with, you know, hopefully with your thinking cap on and take the opportunity of the time to
0:29:41do two things. One is, you know, get at the truth of what they're saying and get at the, you know,
0:29:46sort of, you know, read their angle and then interpret it in your own way, hopefully. But then
0:29:51also, theoretically, you're there to act as an advocate and an avatar for the audience, right?
0:29:56Like, that's your job. And you're not there to be like, you know, "Oh, what is, you know, what is
0:30:02Matthew want to know about this, although I do take my time to do that, you know, um, in these
0:30:06interviews, like I'll ask a question. It's like, nobody on earth probably cares about this, but I
0:30:10really do care about this. You know, I find this interesting. I would like to know the answer to
0:30:14this, but then the, a large majority of the time you want to dedicate to, Hey, if, you know,
0:30:20in this case, all these pro users were here, you know, what questions would they ask? What would
0:30:24they want to know about? And you can ask the questions and you won't always get answers,
0:30:30or the answers you get won't always be, you know, as revealing or satisfactory as you want,
0:30:35almost never simply because of the way Apple works. And that's fine. But I have, you know,
0:30:39you ask them, right? You try not to be an idiot and ask intelligent questions, but also don't,
0:30:46you don't shy away from them. Even if you know that the answers may not be super satisfactory,
0:30:51it's important that they're asked. You know? Pete:
0:30:57And did you know it was exclusive that it was you were going to be the only one there?
0:31:01Yes, I did know that. They did tell me it'll just be you this time. And I said, okay,
0:31:09and didn't say anything further in case they changed their mind.
0:31:11I'm curious what they were thinking. I like I've told you, we talked about this offline
0:31:17for quite a while. Yeah. But I think I think you were a fantastic choice. And if there had to be
0:31:23be only one person to get it. I mean it sincerely. I would rather it be you than me because I wouldn't
0:31:30want to be responsible for reporting everything that went on because I'm just not good at it.
0:31:36That's just not what I do. That's not what gets you out of bed in the morning.
0:31:43You're like, "I want to absorb it and then kind of spirit." I think that's your talent.
0:31:50You're like, I don't know. You know, I'm gonna throw my spear right at this point
0:31:54Yes is very interesting right and I don't know how you got that story out from an all-day at Tuesday
0:32:01Briefings with Apple to 8 a.m. Pacific Thursday, you know a very comprehensive story is out
0:32:09Like I know I would have had like three paragraphs written. I'd I would still be like looking
0:32:15There were some typos
0:32:17I'm ashamed to admit at launch but you know, what can you do? I only had one person's name misspelled
0:32:21Many times in the piece, but I fixed it pretty quick
0:32:26But you know it it is rough sometimes with that but you know, you just kind of suck it up and do it
0:32:30I mean the real kink in it is for me like the time that I do that
0:32:35I love it, but it is I am in fact stealing time right from my
0:32:40Hate to say this but like my I don't know
0:32:43I don't actually mean I'm not gonna say that but like I said my ceiling time from my other duties
0:32:47I was going to say real job, but that's not true. They're both my real job. But I do run a site,
0:32:52you know, I have a lot of people ask questions about various important things. I mean,
0:32:55they're working on their own important stories about a variety of other things. So it's a balance.
0:32:59I always have to always find myself stealing time from that. And then I was going to Pixar the next
0:33:03day. So I was like, you know, I'll just write this now at midnight. Well, speaking of Pixar,
0:33:11- Well, hold that thought on Pixar.
0:33:14I'll make a note of this.
0:33:15That we have to talk about the fact
0:33:19that one of the lead takeaways from this briefing
0:33:22was that they confirmed that the new Mac Pro
0:33:26is not gonna come out this year.
0:33:28It'll come out next year.
0:33:30And I think that took a lot of people by surprise
0:33:34and it took even more people
0:33:37to get as a major disappointment.
0:33:39that even people who were like, well, I don't know,
0:33:41I know they didn't say 2018, but I sure hope they do.
0:33:44How hard can it be, you know, blah, blah, blah.
0:33:47So it, you know, obviously got,
0:33:50that aspect of the announcement got a lot of attention.
0:33:52But you and I talked about this.
0:33:55Last year at the round table, who was there?
0:33:59It was me and you and Lance Ulanoff and Ina Fried
0:34:04and somebody else, right?
0:34:08- John Pekowski.
0:34:09sorry, John Paskowski from Buzzfeed.
0:34:11And there was a point, and I believe, I don't know,
0:34:14did you ever look at the transcript?
0:34:16My recollection of this was that you asked a question,
0:34:19like they said, "Hey, blah, blah, blah."
0:34:21We hit the reset button,
0:34:22we backed ourselves into a thermal corner.
0:34:24We've got a very compelling pro version of the iMac
0:34:29for pros coming later this year,
0:34:34which we now know is the iMac called the iMac Pro.
0:34:39but that we're going back to the drawing board on Mac Pro.
0:34:42And they said, and it won't,
0:34:47this is something that will not ship this year.
0:34:49And you asked a question that said something
0:34:51about the Mac Pro and at this point last year,
0:34:54quote unquote, next year.
0:34:55And I believe that we were corrected
0:34:58and the correction was we didn't say next year,
0:35:01we said not this year.
0:35:02And oh, it's like, you know.
0:35:05So, and there've been people on Twitter accusing me
0:35:07of spinning this whole thing in Apple's favor
0:35:10because I've said this overall,
0:35:12your story on TechCrunch about this whole thing
0:35:14is very good news for serious Mac Pro users.
0:35:17The part that I'm saying is good news
0:35:20is not the part that the Mac Pro isn't shipping this year.
0:35:23That's obviously bad news.
0:35:26The part that is good news is all this stuff
0:35:28about the Pro Workflows group
0:35:29and how they're working hand in hand
0:35:31with actual professional film editors
0:35:34and music producers and musicians.
0:35:37in Cupertino, in Apple's, you know, at Apple Park,
0:35:41working hand in hand with them as Apple employees
0:35:43or as full-time contractors, if it's a shorter term thing,
0:35:46so that they can learn and study what these people need,
0:35:49not just from the apps that they're using,
0:35:51but that they're actually, these people are,
0:35:55these true pros are informing the design
0:35:59of the new Mac Pro itself.
0:36:01And I think that is undeniably very good news.
0:36:04But this aspect about it not coming until next year,
0:36:07it's clear in hindsight that they were kind of setting this up for that my bottom line is that I
0:36:13think what they were trying to say is that we're shooting for late 2018 but you know it could be
0:36:192019 so we're not going to say anything other than not this year. Right and you know my and I did go
0:36:26back and look and the the phrasing was definitely clear or not I shouldn't say clear but it was
0:36:32definitely not clear that it was 2018, right? If that makes sense. And then I believe I asked for
0:36:38confirmation. And basically it was like, you know, hey, exactly what was said. And when you
0:36:45read what was said, it said, it's not a product for this year. That's basically what they said.
0:36:51And that was in 2017. And that basically is a means that it may not have been,
0:36:59it may have been a 2018 product, but it also they weren't promising that. And clearly, obviously,
0:37:05it's not. They said 2019. Now, the trashcan Mac Pro is obviously, you know, it's how much do you
0:37:13think that they that they hate that in the product design group, they must love that it's called the
0:37:19trashcan macro. I mean, it must be excited. I'm sorry, go. Well, it's Yes, the trash came back.
0:37:24It's clearly heading towards the trash can of history. The jet turbine super polished awesome
0:37:29mech pro. No, go ahead. In addition to its striking looks, it was in architecture, it was a very
0:37:40unusual computer. It was not like the PC workstations from companies like Dell or
0:37:48or whoever else makes them. And it wasn't like any Mac previously made, you know, maybe
0:37:54in spirit closest to the cube, you know, just in terms of density and being like an artifact
0:38:00that you would really that you want on your desk. I mean, they even said this at the introduction
0:38:06of it, that it's, this is something you're going to want on your desk. You're not going
0:38:09to want to put it on the floor.
0:38:10Yeah, it turns out I want it on my desk. It's just, right. But it turns out, I can do anything
0:38:15with it.
0:38:16You know, the, you know, I, it's simplistic to reduce it to just one thing. But basically,
0:38:25they overlooked the, at the time they designed it, they overlooked the growing importance
0:38:29of GPUs to pro computing. And that just was a Mac, you know, there were just so many GPU
0:38:36problems with people who have these Mac pros, and they couldn't keep up with the state of
0:38:40art and they couldn't massively parallelize by adding more because it was designed for
0:38:46this very specific amount of GPU heat output and that's it. And so they more or less told
0:38:54us this last year, really. I mean, actually no more or less about it.
0:38:58Jared Ranerelle - You used the phrase "thermal corner" specifically.
0:39:00Jon Moffitt - Yeah, that was Federighi, right?
0:39:01Jared Ranerelle - And that was in relation to the GPU.
0:39:02Jon Moffitt - Right, we painted ourselves into a thermal corner. And so it was very,
0:39:08know, and they didn't have anything to say about what will the new Mac Pro look like
0:39:13other than they did use the word "modular" as an adjective, you know, that it would be
0:39:18a modular design. But unsurprising, you know, it's given as it was, you know, extraordinary
0:39:24how much information they gave us. It was extraordinary that they, you know, more or
0:39:28less admitted to a major mistake on a product that sells to very few people, but it is extraordinarily
0:39:35important to them because it's, you know, their livelihood is done on these machines.
0:39:42I think there was an assumption on an awful lot of people's parts that they were just
0:39:45going to, you know, more or less go back to the philosophy of the cheese grater MacPros
0:39:52and we'll just make a big aluminum box and we'll just put the most powerful Intel Xeons
0:40:00that we can buy from Intel in there
0:40:02and have a bunch of slots for other stuff
0:40:05and call it a day.
0:40:09Now I don't think people are expecting it
0:40:11to literally look like the cheese grater
0:40:14that preceded the trash can.
0:40:17I'm sure they love all these terms,
0:40:19cheese grater's trash cans.
0:40:21But if I use these terms, you'll know what I mean.
0:40:24Like somebody on Twitter who is clearly frustrated
0:40:27and I see it as they, somebody tweeted at me
0:40:30I did laugh like they're obviously angry but I appreciated the joke is that they said that they could literally just put it into
0:40:35into old
0:40:38Power Mac g3
0:40:40Boxes that they still have lying around and I would be perfectly happy, you know go back to the old Bondi blue
0:40:46Right our magic three boxes and just as long as you stuff it to the gills with you know, powerful workstation stuff
0:40:53You know it I lost count of the number of people saying how hard can it be?
0:40:59You know, and I think if what they announced next year is just a big big PC workstation box
0:41:05You know, that's more or less just put a big put everything in a big box and cool it I
0:41:12Guess we will have to ask. Hmm. Why did that take two years?
0:41:16I just get the feeling that they've got something else in mind that no they are not, you know
0:41:22They are definitely going in a very different direction from the trash can but that they still have a very ambitious
0:41:28plans for something that is not just the Mac OS running on a workstation you could buy
0:41:38from Dell.
0:41:39Steven: Yeah, like not an officially licensed Tackintosh, so to speak, of just kind of generic
0:41:47parts. I mean, I know everybody wants like Nvidia GPUs and they want them in a box and
0:41:53they want to maybe be able to add one more and then replace it when a new one comes out.
0:41:57I appreciate that and I don't disagree necessarily. I mean, I
0:42:01certainly I have a PC and I use it for gaming. I don't use it
0:42:06for much else to be honest, because I can't stay in Windows.
0:42:09But I is modern Windows, especially like last version of
0:42:13Windows, I like was like 95. It was I use like, like, it was
0:42:17okay. But the the feature of being essentially feature of
0:42:23being able to replace that GPU and get an upgraded gaming experience for me has always led me to,
0:42:29you know, keep a PC around and say, Hey, if I want to play destiny at 60 frames per second,
0:42:35you know, with all of the water droplets and all of the cool stuff turned on, I can do that.
0:42:40And the fact is that I don't, I don't see that as the way that Apple is thinking about their
0:42:50machines at all. And I know, obviously, I'm talking about
0:42:53consuming games, not making games, but people that build
0:42:56games use roughly this, you know, similar hardware. I think
0:43:00that it is the the term modular keeps sticking in my mind,
0:43:04because they did emphasize again, in this chat, I asked, I
0:43:09said, you know, hey, you know, obviously, you know, whatever
0:43:13you want to say about it, or not say about it is up to you.
0:43:16But can you characterize this modular thing? How important is
0:43:19is this still stand in other words? Have you have you changed fundamentally your thought process on
0:43:26the Mac Pro since we last talked? And the basic gist is, no, we haven't changed the fundamental
0:43:31architecture of what we wanted to build since we last talked. Now, of course, I don't know how much
0:43:36of it they had done then. But you know, the the arc of it seems to be continuing on whatever
0:43:42trajectory they had set a year ago. But they said that modularity was absolutely a core part of it,
0:43:50whatever it is. I just don't know if the idea of modular that Apple has in mind is going to be the
0:43:57same modular that, you know, your average pro who wants a cheese grater with multiple slots has in
0:44:05in mind.
0:44:06Yeah. I don't want to put you on the spot, but so I'll just speak for myself and I
0:44:12will say that there are times when people at Apple will answer my questions but answer
0:44:18them off the record or on background or something like that. I will say on the whole iMac Pro
0:44:25and Mac Pro front, everything—and it's extraordinary how much they told us—but
0:44:32Everything that they told me about it was on the record.
0:44:35I didn't know anything about the iMac Pro before it was unveiled at WWDC other than
0:44:41what we wrote about from the roundtable last year, that they have just had a pro-minded
0:44:47config of the iMac, 27-inch iMac in the works.
0:44:52They did say last year it would be later this year and that they think it's going to be
0:44:57the most commonly bought desktop for professional Mac users,
0:45:02for the most number of Mac users.
0:45:05I don't know, I didn't know anything else about it.
0:45:08I don't know anything else about the upcoming Mac Pro
0:45:11other than what is on the record.
0:45:13So I have no inside information.
0:45:15I don't have any little birdies who work on that team.
0:45:17So what I'm speculating here is entirely my speculation.
0:45:23This is not really, there's no background information.
0:45:27My guess is that they decided that the trash can was a mistake a while before the round table,
0:45:38maybe even a year. I mean, because they knew how many hundreds of years that they'd gone without
0:45:44even like a speed bump. I mean, I'm sure that they were embarrassed by that. They certainly didn't
0:45:50let on that they were embarrassed last year. I mean, they're Apple, they're pros. But they knew,
0:45:56I mean, so they must have thought, here's what I think happened is that, you know, obviously
0:46:01when they launched the trashcan, they certainly didn't anticipate that they were never going
0:46:05to do a significant update to it.
0:46:08Um, they, they thought this was the future and we'll update it.
0:46:11And then it turned out that they made a very strong editorial bet on the way compute was
0:46:16going and it just went left instead of right.
0:46:19It went left instead of right.
0:46:21And then at a certain point, I think they started working on this.
0:46:26what we now know is the iMac Pro.
0:46:27'Cause one thing we now know about the iMac Pro
0:46:29is the iMac Pro is not just a slightly faster
0:46:34regular iMac with black anodized aluminum.
0:46:38It is a completely different architecture,
0:46:40totally different thermal architecture.
0:46:42And it uses an entirely different class of CPU and GPU.
0:46:49And the totally different thermal system
0:46:53is exactly why that was necessary, right?
0:46:55If you put the iMac Pro's internals into a regular iMac,
0:46:59it would melt, it wouldn't work.
0:47:01I think that at some point internally,
0:47:07either their official plan or their,
0:47:10this is probably the plan plan,
0:47:12was that the iMac Pro would be the pro desktop.
0:47:17That we'll just stretch,
0:47:19we'll stretch it out with the trash can
0:47:22until we get this iMac Pro out,
0:47:24and then that's our new Pro desktop.
0:47:27And I think what happened in hindsight,
0:47:29you know, I mean, I think at some point last year,
0:47:32probably around March, I think it was probably
0:47:34right before they called us in for the round table,
0:47:37they had like a come to Jesus moment
0:47:39where they were like, you know what,
0:47:40here's the type of Pros who even this, you know,
0:47:43iMac Pro, which is shaping up to be a great device.
0:47:46I mean, I haven't seen a bad review of the iMac Pro.
0:47:48Everybody-- - No, it's very well received.
0:47:50- Very well received.
0:47:51And I think by early last year,
0:47:54I think they must have been far enough along
0:47:56to know exactly how good it was going to be.
0:48:00But I think they had a moment internally
0:48:02where they were like, but wait, here's a use case,
0:48:06here's a use case, here's somebody who this isn't enough.
0:48:09And that we're gonna lose these people to Windows
0:48:13or Linux or other platforms because they need things
0:48:18that even the iMac Pro can't give them.
0:48:21and those machines are out there on the market,
0:48:23they just don't run Mac OS X.
0:48:25I think they had that moment and then thought,
0:48:29well, shit, what do we do?
0:48:30We're stuck.
0:48:31We cannot make that happen in this enclosure.
0:48:34I think that's when they convened the round table.
0:48:37I think that round table was convened
0:48:40very shortly after they decided to make a new Mac Pro.
0:48:43And I think that's why they're still not done
0:48:44because I really think that as of like the round table,
0:48:48entire plan was like the words "New Mac Pro," "mat modular," written on a notepad.
0:48:54I don't know. What do you think about that with the timing? I'm pretty sure that that's the timing,
0:49:02but I don't have any confirmation of that. - So you're saying like, give me a quarter,
0:49:09that you think that this basically, this project started in earnest. You think it started
0:49:13like, get cute cute to have last year. Yeah, I do. Because when
0:49:18was our when was our roundtable March? Or was it? Yeah, I thought
0:49:26April, April. Yeah, either late March or April. Okay. Yeah, I
0:49:29think early. I think that they started putting the band
0:49:32together to make it you know, at like the end of March, you know,
0:49:35they're like, Okay, okay. So I agree. I mean, I and once again,
0:49:40I can't actually tell you in this case, like, you know, it's not like I couldn't tell you if I if I knew right back I don't know, you know, they didn't they didn't tell me they're not very keen on going Oh, well, we started this project this date and edited on that one. I mean, I I one one person that I can't remember who it is, I'm not gonna say the name. So like, I'm afraid to say the name, but one one person one Apple exec said during the iPhone 10 roundtables they had they didn't on the record one with a bunch of
0:50:10international journalists and a couple from the US. And one of
0:50:13the things that they had said they explicitly said when they
0:50:16started, basically when they locked, and one of the PR people
0:50:20there was like, you know, like, they don't want to know when
0:50:23designs are locked, and when they're shipped, not honestly,
0:50:25because the that lock date is all that secret or special,
0:50:29because it's really not. It's just like an arbitrary date
0:50:31where they're like, okay, you know, begin the things we can
0:50:33begin now. We think we have this design pretty much set. And it's
0:50:38more about not giving away competitive information like, Hey, if we lock this, Apple was able to lock
0:50:43this in November, and ship it in December of the next year, whatever, you know, that, that or
0:50:50September the next year, that information is maybe mean nothing to the average person, to be honest,
0:50:55like, even if you were a reporter, and you found it out and put it in the story, the average person
0:51:00may not know or care, you know, who cares, right? It's like, okay, great, you know, it took him
0:51:05like nine months to build this thing. All right. But for another manufacturer or for an analyst,
0:51:11this is incredibly valuable information that they can reverse engineer essentially into a lot of
0:51:16additional competitive advantage, you know, competitive information that can give them
0:51:21advantages, either in purchasing or manufacturing. So that said, there was none of that slippage
0:51:28here. Like they didn't say, "Oh, we started the project in X and, you know, we're gonna ship in
0:51:32in 2019, none of that. So my conjecture basically is the same as yours, also based on just my
0:51:39vibe and not any actual information.
0:51:42Jon Moffitt Yeah. My favorite story like that was after
0:51:47the Antennagate press conference. That must have been 2010, right? Because 2007 was the
0:51:56The iPhone 2008 was the 3G, 2009 was the 3GS, so 2010 would be the iPhone 4.
0:52:04So there's the Intenagate press conference.
0:52:06I'm out there.
0:52:07It's in town hall.
0:52:10And I think they took about a dozen of us on a backstage tour, a lot like the audio
0:52:15tour.
0:52:16I told you this before, but when we took that tour of their audio facilities for the HomePod
0:52:21earlier this year?
0:52:24Where's that last year?
0:52:25well, a couple months ago. They took us on a tour of their antenna testing labs, and
0:52:31it was guided by their head and tenant engineer. Really interesting, really cool stuff, but
0:52:36only about a dozen of us. And then at one point during the tour, somebody asked him
0:52:40and he did a great job. It's like a typical Apple person is both good at their job and
0:52:47able to explain what they do very well. And it's like, I forget whose adage it is, but
0:52:55If you can't explain it in terms that a lay person would understand, then you don't
0:52:58really understand it. I don't know. It might be Einstein. It might be…
0:53:01Steven: Yeah. If you can't explain it to a five-year-old, you don't understand it
0:53:05or whatever the case.
0:53:06Jay Haynes Right.
0:53:07Steven: Yeah.
0:53:08Jay Haynes You know, did a great job, but obviously was
0:53:13not used to talking to the press. You could see a sense of certain nervousness. Apple
0:53:18people, they know. It's their instincts. Their instincts tell them, "You don't
0:53:24to the press. You don't talk to the press." And then all of a sudden, like, Katie Cotton
0:53:28is there and they're like, "Hey, what would you think about leading a tour of the press
0:53:33on the record?" But somebody asked him how long they'd been working on the external design
0:53:40of the iPhone 4 antenna. And he just said, "About three years." And Schiller was on
0:53:46the tour, not speaking, but just walking around with us. And Phil Schiller jumped in and just,
0:53:50he was ready for it. And he just said, "We're not here to talk about timelines." He didn't
0:53:53bark at him or anything. But I noticed that he immediately jumped in and was like, "We're
0:53:57not here to talk about timelines." Because they just, even when they were like, "Let's
0:54:01open the kimono here and let you see how we test these antennas and revealing all sorts
0:54:05of things we'd never revealed before." They don't want to talk about how long they were
0:54:08working on something.
0:54:10Steven: Yeah. And I think that is an expectation thing. Like you don't want somebody to go,
0:54:16"Oh, well, let me count backwards from next September."
0:54:19- I think it's competitive.
0:54:21I think it's competitive.
0:54:22It's all competitive.
0:54:23It's both competitive in terms of letting competitors
0:54:25know how long they work on something.
0:54:27And for anybody trying to look at their strategy,
0:54:30like you just said, like look at the calendar,
0:54:32go back three years, what did it look like then?
0:54:35What would have happened then
0:54:36that would make them decide to do this?
0:54:38- Yeah, and even the layman now,
0:54:41I mean, for instance, the iPhone 10 thing,
0:54:45you know, there was some stuff around that
0:54:46set on the record that basically told you,
0:54:48like we've been working on this for three years.
0:54:50They very explicitly said things like,
0:54:52this year's, that whole context,
0:54:56the context for that conversation was around the FaceTime,
0:54:59or not FaceTime, the Face ID thing.
0:55:03And everybody was like, oh, you just threw Face ID
0:55:05and then at the last minute,
0:55:06like these reports came out and they're like, no,
0:55:09first of all, you can't, it's impossible.
0:55:11And second of all, like we locked this thing way before,
0:55:14like you even published your piece, so you know.
0:55:17know? And like that, that situation, I think, is it allowed us to see a little bit more of,
0:55:24hey, this really is like they're deciding these things three years ahead. And yes, they can,
0:55:30because they're nimble, they can make final decisions on things as late as lock date,
0:55:36right? They could say, hey, this thing. And what I heard basically, and this is this is not on the
0:55:42record is not an official and it's not even off the record. It's just what I heard through people,
0:55:45right, is that they had a phone without the second camera in it when they launched the two camera
0:55:55phone. What was that? Six or seven? They all blur together. Whatever the plus was with the two
0:56:02cameras. They had one without, right? Because, you know, what if it doesn't work? Right? They had a
0:56:08design ready to go. And then at the last minute, they're like, "Ah, let's just do it." Right? Like
0:56:12they felt they could do it and they felt they could get it done. And so they locked that design
0:56:17and essentially stepped off a ledge, you know, and eventually, of course, shipped the twin lens.
0:56:21But you know, that that kind of, you know, takes it takes guts, it takes like a supreme handle on
0:56:28your supply chain, it takes the ability to like, inch that thing, that kind of major decision later
0:56:33and later and later. And I think people that treat that as like, oh, they don't know what they're
0:56:37doing, it really is it does a disservice to like, the engineers
0:56:42actually trying to push the envelope as far as they can, you
0:56:45know, to the bleeding edge of what's possible. And then they
0:56:48ship that thing that's barely possible. And then people are
0:56:51like, Oh, well, you just did this at the last minute, just
0:56:53for giggles. And it's like, No, man, you know, no, we had to try
0:56:57really, really hard to do this. And then we did it. And sure,
0:57:02like, it works like 80% as well as we say it does on stage,
0:57:05right. But then we get it there the next iteration and yada yada. But yeah, I think that's the same
0:57:10kind of thing they're working on with this that if they're making decisions on the Mac Pro, I think
0:57:14that they you know, they would have had to made major architectural decisions a while ago now.
0:57:18But I think they could definitely make some real gutsy calls still late in the game, you know,
0:57:24and I think at this point, those are done. Maybe maybe you got a couple more months to figure that
0:57:27out. If you're shipping 2019, and let's say you assume maximum potential, like in other words,
0:57:34they're going to ship it late 2019. I'm not saying they are, they did not give any indication.
0:57:38But if they're going to announce it, like it's a dub dub and then ship it later in the year,
0:57:42you know, you figure right now, it's not as I mean, I don't know what the design is, maybe it
0:57:47is, but I would imagine it's not as mission critical as like a smartphone to get, you know,
0:57:53that that kind of lineup done where you're doing that really fine tooth like, you know, 16 different
0:57:59components coming together all into one component, which goes into another 250 components. And
0:58:05I'm probably not at that level, but it's still got to be pretty soon that they're locking that down.
0:58:10And if so, if they're locking it down in another four or five months, let's say, or a little bit
0:58:15more than that, they have a few months left to actually make major decisions about what they're
0:58:19going to do. And, you know, if that's not the case, then they figured it out. And they're plowing
0:58:24ahead and whatever, they're just doing manufacturing, testing and whatnot. But I don't
0:58:27think so yet. I think they're not done yet, in other words.
0:58:29Yeah, and I don't think we're going to see a preview of it at WWDC. I could be wrong. I mean,
0:58:36they obviously did it last year with the iMac Pro and shipped later that year. And I guess if they
0:58:42think they're shipping early 2019, they could. But I don't think so. I think it's a different
0:58:50situation this year. I feel like with the iMac Pro, they could show it and everybody knows what
0:58:58an iMac looks like. The iMac Pro looks like an iMac. It's just black and therefore cooler.
0:59:03Whereas I feel like they're doing something with this that they don't want to spoil too far in
0:59:08advance. One thing you have to recognize is when Apple makes a successful hardware product,
0:59:16all of a sudden a lot of other competing products start looking very similar.
0:59:21Even if they have absolutely no reason to do so.
0:59:24Like, have you seen all of these Android phones coming out with a notch?
0:59:27Yeah.
0:59:28It's really like, it's like...
0:59:30It's amazing.
0:59:31It's like a tag. Like, I have like a tag in my...
0:59:33A lot of them don't even have anything special out there.
0:59:36It's just like regular cameras.
0:59:38Like, you can just put a regular camera in the frame. Nobody's gonna kill you.
0:59:43it's they're copying the worst aspect of the iPhone 10. Like in
0:59:48hindsight, now months into it, I'm fine with the notch. I get
0:59:51it. You know, I still think though, it's the worst part of
0:59:54the phone. I can't wait for them to figure out a way to do all
0:59:58this without a notch and just have the screen go edge to edge
1:00:01corner to corner. They're copying the one part of the
1:00:06phone that everybody agrees is actually
1:00:08I don't think anybody Apple likes it either. I never had a
1:00:11single person tell me, oh, the notch is great and lovely. And we
1:00:14love it. Right. It was we the notch needs to be there. We think
1:00:17the the cost of the notch or whatever you want to call it,
1:00:20they don't even call it a notch. They hate it.
1:00:21That's another word that they they call it the same. They call
1:00:25it the sensor. Right.
1:00:26Yeah, whatever it is. Yeah. But that area. That area on the
1:00:33phone is there. Nobody loves that it's there, including the
1:00:38people that had to put it there. They were like, "Hey, we could do this, what we think
1:00:42is a really awesome forward-looking thing. And we could, you know, all of this kind of
1:00:47works. Like the corners could be used for things and we could push the rest of it edge
1:00:50to edge and this is the way we chose to do it." And it makes sense completely with Apple's
1:00:56design language that they're going to utilize those little corners instead of putting black
1:01:00all the way across because they're like, "We don't need black here, so why put it there?"
1:01:05that's their, you know, that's the, gets to the core of what, how they're, they design
1:01:09products and like that, that whole thing was literally just in service of those cameras.
1:01:16It was not by any means because they thought it looked cool and looked awesome. And so
1:01:21for somebody who has no need of it to put it there, it's like, you know, really, I don't
1:01:27know. It's like putting a spoiler on a mini-van.
1:01:28The Android phones that are coming out with notches are both the most like I
1:01:32Slapped my head on the forehead
1:01:35I slapped my forehead on the table like I cannot believe they did this and
1:01:39Simultaneously the least surprising thing of the year. I
1:01:44Love the stories. They had stories the verge had stories I think from
1:01:47Was it mobile World Congress? Whatever the the big cell phone?
1:01:52Conference was that was a couple weeks ago where where these handset makers show off upcoming phones that haven't been seen before
1:01:58And there were several of them.
1:02:00- Right, yeah, MWC.
1:02:01- There were several of them that had fake iPhone 10
1:02:03style notches that didn't even have a version
1:02:06of Android installed that was aware there was a notch there.
1:02:09So it was like drawing underneath of a notch,
1:02:12like all those notifications that line up on the Android.
1:02:16- Right, that's awesome.
1:02:17- And it was one where like the date or time was clipped.
1:02:21(laughs)
1:02:22It's just like, what are you doing?
1:02:24I can't believe it.
1:02:26All right, hold on a second, I'm gonna take a break here.
1:02:27- The fast follow.
1:02:28I gotta take a break here and thank our next sponsor.
1:02:31Longtime sponsor, supporter of the show, Casper.
1:02:35Any of you guys know Casper?
1:02:37Casper makes innovative award-winning sleep products.
1:02:42Well, here's the deal.
1:02:43They've got a new mattress that they call the Wave,
1:02:45and it's their most innovative mattress
1:02:48from the sleep experts at Casper.
1:02:50It's the first mattress of its kind to relieve pressure
1:02:53at 36 different points so you can feel relaxed
1:02:55in ways you never thought possible.
1:02:58It features advanced temperature regulating technology
1:03:00to help you sleep cool and comfortable
1:03:02without overeating during the night.
1:03:04It has five layers of superior foam,
1:03:08including a cushioning top layer for maximum comfort.
1:03:11It's their biggest breakthrough in sleep technology.
1:03:14And one of the things that they studied,
1:03:16and I mean this, they really do have mattress engineers.
1:03:20Casper doesn't just buy mattresses from some Chinese factory
1:03:26and just slap a Casper sticker on them.
1:03:28They really engineer these things.
1:03:29And one of the things they looked at with the Wave
1:03:31is trying to create a mattress that works
1:03:34as well as possible, whether you're a back sleeper,
1:03:37stomach sleeper, or a side sleeper.
1:03:40It works great for all three types of sleepers.
1:03:43Me personally, I gotta tell you, I do all three.
1:03:45I'm a sort of a, every two hours if I wake up,
1:03:49the only way I get back to sleep is to like change.
1:03:51So I'll flip around or turn on my side or whatever.
1:03:54So that sounds good to me because I'm all three.
1:03:57Now the Wave is also designed to keep its original form
1:04:01so you'll be supported for years to come.
1:04:03This is supposed to be a very, very durable mattress.
1:04:06It's just a great product, I love these guys.
1:04:11Now when you buy the Wave, your Wave purchase
1:04:14comes with in-home white glove delivery and setup for free.
1:04:19That's just part of the cost of the mattress
1:04:22is they will just show up with a white glove team
1:04:24and set it up in your bedroom just where you want it,
1:04:27just so.
1:04:28And here's the best deal.
1:04:31If you're a listener of the show,
1:04:32you can save 100 bucks off a Wave mattress
1:04:36by going to casper.com, C-A-S-P-E-R,
1:04:40casper.com/talkshow100.
1:04:44That's talk show 'cause you're listening to the talk show,
1:04:46and 100 because you're gonna save 100 bucks.
1:04:49and then just use that promo code, talk show 100.
1:04:52So casper.com/talkshow100 with promo code 100.
1:04:58Terms and conditions do apply,
1:05:00but you'll save 100 bucks with that code.
1:05:02My thanks to Casper and her Wave mattress.
1:05:05What is your take?
1:05:08What is your take on this angle, before we drop it,
1:05:11of why are they bothering to over-engineer?
1:05:15Are they gonna just make a different type of mistake
1:05:17the trash can Mac Pro by over engineering this and not doing, you know, they have the
1:05:22humility to admit they made a mistake and they're starting over. But is it a problem
1:05:26perhaps that maybe they lack the humility to just do the obvious thing? I guarantee
1:05:32you there are thousands of people listening to the show right now who are saying yes that
1:05:36yeah, just do that thing please. And second, second part, second part of the question is,
1:05:43Okay, if you want to go and have John Ternus and his team go off and build the supercomputer of Apple's
1:05:50ambitious dreams
1:05:53Okay, but in the meantime, how about you just stick a big Xeon in a box call it the Mac Pro and sell it to me
1:06:00Right, right. Yeah, but like put your B team on just
1:06:05popping this thing out while your a team goes off and you know applies quantum mechanics to
1:06:12Aluminium and comes up with something new. I mean, I think
1:06:17there's two major possibilities. One is that they
1:06:20are, in fact, figuring out the best possible way to build what
1:06:24we have considered to be a PC, you know, box like a tower
1:06:30computer, right? There's one possibility. They're just
1:06:33taking every angle of that thing and examining how could this be
1:06:37better? What are the problems? It's like when case
1:06:40manufacturers went from making you screw everything in to like to those member.
1:06:45They moved to those big, I don't know how many PCs you've built over the years,
1:06:48but they moved to those big thumb screws and then I know, I know. Yeah. And then,
1:06:52and then they moved from thumb screws to clip in.
1:06:55So like almost all modern PC cases now you don't, they're called tool this cases,
1:06:59right? You just, you get them, pull them out of the box.
1:07:01You can unclip all of the stuff that you need.
1:07:03You can pull out the motherboard tray.
1:07:05I think some of the,
1:07:06mostly the motherboards still need to be like punched in or screwed in cause
1:07:09they've got the posts for electric insulation and whatnot, and standoffs from the metal
1:07:17cases and stuff. But I think even some of those are clip-in now. And you can clip in
1:07:21pretty much every major component, like a hard drive and all of this stuff. But there's
1:07:27a lot about PCs that are still complete BS. Like, cable routing is dumb. It's so stupid,
1:07:34right? Like that you have to figure out how to route cables inside this case for work for airflow.
1:07:39And I know some people like that's their that's catnip. Right? Like, I had a buddy who would route
1:07:45his cables for weeks before he actually finished his piece. But he's like, he would route it and
1:07:50then like, put it aside to come back to the next day. Like, hmm, yeah, they do a good job. I get
1:07:55all that. It's like people who have a hobby, like painting miniature figurines. Yes, I get it. I
1:08:01I don't I don't I I don't have that hobby, but I don't I don't mock it
1:08:05I totally get how it might be extremely satisfying to spend days at a time on a single tiny little figurine and that you've got
1:08:13This entire army of them ahead of you and I think that for like the people who like building their own PCs
1:08:18Like you're saying the cable
1:08:20Management is you know routing is is sort of like that hobby, you know, yeah
1:08:25Yeah, the air flow the cable management
1:08:27I mean, you know, testing airflow and all that figuring all that stuff out.
1:08:30Like, and those are that's like self built PC PCs. But I think a lot of the
1:08:33same principles apply to when you buy one. So if you buy one, and you say
1:08:37want to upgrade it, it still requires that you open it up that you have to
1:08:40look at a PC slot that you have to look at a motherboard, you know that you
1:08:45have to like figure out these the guts of this thing and say, Okay, well,
1:08:48what do I want to change here. And I know there are some pros that build
1:08:52their own PCs that are very vocal, you know, or have built their own
1:08:55machines over the years that are very vocal on the web about how, you know, they just
1:09:01want this thing, this, you know, let me figure it out, sell me, go buy an NVIDIA card and
1:09:06throw it in if I want to upgrade all this. That's great, but they are also being myopic
1:09:12and they don't want to hear this and I'm sure I'll get an email, but I firmly believe that
1:09:17pros are some of the most myopic consumers out there on an individual level because each
1:09:23one of them is so immersed in their skill. They're incredibly skilled, incredibly good
1:09:31at the thing that they're doing. They've steeped themselves in it. They've made their
1:09:35lives work to figure this thing out. And frankly, usually they're intelligent, they're driven.
1:09:41You know, they have a lot of things that kind of make them that kind of person. But that
1:09:46doesn't necessarily come part and parcel with, you know, any number of other professional
1:09:52pursuits outside of say, software engineering, or even hardware engineering or engineering at large,
1:09:58right? Like, they're definitely pro pursuits that lend themselves to being willing or able or
1:10:05desirous of sort of being able to manipulate the innards of a machine, you know, in that way.
1:10:10And then there are a bunch of pros in other fields who are just as driven and intelligent and
1:10:16capable and, and, you know, just masters of their craft, who couldn't give a flying F about what
1:10:22that what's inside the machine or how it looks, or how to, you know, install a graphics card or
1:10:28want to do any of that, right. And so you I think you have to like one thing that I was told, you
1:10:34know, that they mentioned several times was that pros are an incredibly diverse bunch, you know,
1:10:39that the pros as a group are not a monolith at all. And that some pros may love the iMac Pro, and
1:10:48that'll service them. Other pros do not want that at all. And they want this more modular design.
1:10:53And that's understood. But the fact that Apple sees the breadth of that, and I know that people
1:11:00think, Oh, yeah, just give me this thing that I can throw a card in. And it's good. And it's all I
1:11:04I want is power and all of that. But I believe that it is biopic to think that that is all all
1:11:11pros want. And pros are a very diverse group that utilize computers to create art and to do
1:11:18finance and do all kinds of things that could benefit from from more power and more
1:11:23capability and yes, more expansion and modularity. I just think that there's a
1:11:28discussion to be had about what form that takes. And that maybe, you know, making somebody
1:11:33stick a new PCI card in a PCI slot is not the way to go about it. And I think that's
1:11:39basically the discussion that happened inside Apple, which is why we didn't end up with
1:11:43that or haven't ended up with that yet.
1:11:45Yeah. I guess, you know, I feel like it goes hand in hand with the eGPU revolution. Right?
1:11:57I don't know at some point
1:11:59Not too long ago
1:12:02The idea of an external GPU wouldn't even make any sense
1:12:05It would be like it would be like a line of dialogue on it unlike
1:12:09CIS and you'd be like, oh my god who wrote that external GPU what the hell that wouldn't work, you know
1:12:14It's not that long ago that it would have just sounded like they threw to get you know
1:12:18some screenwriter threw together some words and
1:12:20Thought it made sense, you know
1:12:23But
1:12:26That was a that was a big part of what they were talking about last week with you, right?
1:12:30Yeah, so that okay so that the shape of the discussion went from okay, you know
1:12:36We want to get this out of the way at the top or you know recap
1:12:38We want to get this out of the way at the top Mac Pro 2019
1:12:41You know still a modular design don't have much more to say about it now
1:12:46You know
1:12:47That's what we have to say
1:12:48The second part of the discussion was really about the pro workflows group and the group is designed to literally hire professionals
1:12:55We're talking award winning video editors, award winning musicians slash, you know, mixers, basically producers, audio producers, people that that handle and manipulate and use Apple's products in their workflow.
1:13:14they gave examples, of course, of people outside in the professional world that are still using them. You know, people that are making music for Star Wars movies and cutting commercials and Golden Globe award winning TV shows on Final Cut Pro, you know, etc. Right? Like this, this is their ecosystem that they're thinking about in some ways, because it is in their universe, right? They make software that that these pros, these types of pros use.
1:13:43logic, of course, Final Cut Pro, etc. But they don't, they know that's not the complete universe
1:13:49of pros. That's sort of just where they've begun. And they've also begun a bit with 3D design as
1:13:54well, and 3D work like, you know, AR/VR, 3D gaming, you know, work in 3D spaces, let's call
1:14:02it right. And so that is kind of where they've begun their work to create this group and to have
1:14:09this group create feedback and create, you know, sort of theses that are then incorporated into
1:14:16Mac hardware. And the Mac Pro is absolutely being informed by this group. The iMac Pro was informed
1:14:24by some of the work that this group did early on. And so like the this is it's existed for a while,
1:14:30it's not completely brand new, but they are planning on expanding it to encompass more
1:14:36arenas of professional use down the road. And that as a part of that, I got like basically kind of a
1:14:43tour, just a very small tour of a couple of components of how they use that. And each of
1:14:49you use for everywhere in that. Yeah. I think it goes without saying, although, but it I guess it
1:14:54doesn't go without saying because I got asked by a couple of people after they read your story of
1:15:00Well, that's great. I'm sure that, you know, that's great for movie editors and music producers. But
1:15:06what about developers? You know, why don't you know, and I think what I think goes without
1:15:10saying is Apple is full of developers. You know, they say like, they're probably one of the foremost
1:15:16customers of Apple products, right? They, you know, they don't need to do that. There's one
1:15:21group of pro users, they don't have to set up a specialty team of people to study and work hand
1:15:26in hand with its software developers. They've already got that. They're going to build something
1:15:31that is a great system for developers. And I will reiterate, when the iMac Pro came out in December
1:15:38and they were giving us, you know, had some press in New York and we got to meet, you know,
1:15:44see a whole bunch of use cases for the iMac Pro, software development was a huge aspect of that.
1:15:52that. It was a big part of the tour, and it was in fact presented by an Apple engineer,
1:16:03somebody who works at Apple in software engineering. But they even showed us things on the iMac
1:16:08Pro, and presumably the Mac Pro is going to even be better at this. But even things that
1:16:12weren't just like, "Well, everybody at Apple is using Xcode and building iOS apps and Mac
1:16:18but they were showing us, you know, like the workflow for like a web developer who's
1:16:24running virtualized. Here's three VMs. There's a bunch of running copies of Chrome running.
1:16:30Yeah. Here's like three VMs running windows and running Linux and running another version of
1:16:34windows and running, you know, different, you know, different browsers and different things
1:16:40and doing all these automated tests. And, you know, here's, here's the whisper quiet, not hot
1:16:45iMac handling it with a plum. So they've got developers backs. Any hint?
1:16:51Jay Haynes Yeah, and then other areas, you know, those will come. And so if you're a game developer, and you're like, oh, you know, they don't understand my 3d needs. Well, that's what this is about. They hired literal game developers, they hired literal, literal, you know, technicians that use this stuff to their maximum potential to have them create real projects, to, you
1:17:15know, utilize them in a way that they would in their real life in their real workflows,
1:17:19because engineering test cases often do not catch or do not highlight the problems that come with an
1:17:27organic workflow. And that is the core tenet, I think of this. Yeah, I one of my favorite
1:17:33anecdotes in your story. I think it was john turner's telling you but that they realize after
1:17:39they brought this this these people in and they had one of the groups is a bunch of 3d artists
1:17:45people you know i guess making stuff for games or maybe visual effects people probably similar
1:17:50workflows but 3d artists they're doing real work there at apple and they observed that one of the
1:17:57i don't know what he wasn't going to throw the whatever the software package is under the bus
1:18:01but whatever software package they're using there's a palette that they open and it turns
1:18:05Turns out professional 3D artists open this palette like 100 times a day.
1:18:10And it took like, what do you say, like five seconds every time?
1:18:13Right, six, six seconds to six to 10 seconds or something to open it every time.
1:18:16Right, so that's a six second delay to do what you want to do 100 times a day.
1:18:21And even if he's fudging some of the factors, even if it's only three seconds and maybe
1:18:25you only open it 25 times a day, that still is the sort of thing that it really annoys
1:18:29you.
1:18:30And so they like dug deep into it and it turned out it was all the way down at like the software
1:18:35driver level where it had to get fixed, but they fixed it. And now it's like they hit the key to
1:18:39open the pallet and the pallet is instantly there.
1:18:42Yeah. And I think that's the kind of, you know, the, I was obviously an anecdote. It didn't seem
1:18:48prepared. Maybe it was, but you know, that kind of anecdote is like a, an example of hopefully the
1:18:53things that they're trying to suss out, but it speaks to something larger, which is that,
1:18:57you know, they're when you notice, no matter how many like listening tours you go on, right? Like
1:19:03when you get into a room with Apple, as a developer, or as a
1:19:08inch, you know, software engineer, or yeah, software
1:19:10engineer, or as a audio engineer, or as a as a, an
1:19:15editor, you know, film editor, whatever, if you get into a room
1:19:17with Apple, and they're like, Okay, tell us, you know, what
1:19:19you want, right? You're going to go big picture, right, you're
1:19:22going to go like, Oh, I'd love for you to support this format,
1:19:25or I'd love for you to, you know, to launch a version of it
1:19:29that supported my dream feature or whatever. And that's great. And feature requests are wonderful,
1:19:37and yada yada. It's good to have that input, which is why they do those listening tours. They go
1:19:41around listening to professionals, external to the company. But it cannot give you the same insight
1:19:48into an average workflow and how that workflow is being negatively impacted. Or frankly, it could be
1:19:54just fine. And they could be finding massive ways to improve it, or it could be telling them, "Oh,
1:19:58this is how people use their machines, we can lean into this, you know, for either future hardware or
1:20:03future software updates, bug fixes, features, whatever. But you can't get that in a in a
1:20:09hour long conversation or whatever with some pro randomly, you have to bring them in house,
1:20:14you have to get them to sit down and do their work. And the problem as was brought up to me
1:20:19was with that is that these people are working on proprietary stuff. And you cannot ask them to just
1:20:27bring the footage of the next season of Game of Thrones to
1:20:30Apple and edit it there. He can't do it right. It's not
1:20:34possible. They won't. They are not allowed by any way, shape or
1:20:37means. And so they that's the reasoning they felt for bringing
1:20:41people in. And I don't know exactly what projects they're
1:20:43shooting or whatever, but they're shooting literal movies
1:20:46and stuff at Apple and editing them there. And that that is,
1:20:51you know, informing, of course, their their understanding of the
1:20:53workflows that these people go through.
1:20:56any hint from them because one thing they revealed last year at the round table was that in addition
1:21:01to deciding to work on an all new Mac Pro, they were also at the same time working on an all new
1:21:08pro display, standalone display. Any word on that? I didn't see anything in your story about it.
1:21:16Jared Ranere: No, I didn't mention it simply because I did ask and they basically said yes,
1:21:20that you know, it's coming, which we already knew, you know, or at least they had, they had said that
1:21:25that it was coming a year ago,
1:21:27and there was no major change.
1:21:28So, you know, editing, you gotta leave something out,
1:21:30you know, usually.
1:21:31And so, no, basically yes, but no real additional--
1:21:36- Just confirmation that that's still part of the plan.
1:21:38- Yeah, exactly.
1:21:39- And you don't expect them to give you the details,
1:21:41like, you know, oh yeah, it's gonna be--
1:21:43- No, there was a teleconferencing screen in the room
1:21:45that was like, I don't know, 12 feet across,
1:21:48and I was like, is this the one?
1:21:49(laughing)
1:21:50They're like, no, no.
1:21:52Do you think it's possible that it could be an 8K display?
1:21:56I think it's absolutely possible. I mean, I think the hardware is capable of driving it. I think you could drive an 8K display off of a MacBook Pro with an eGPU. You know, somebody is a film editor and they want to edit 8K. And I will say that they emphasize that Final Cut Pro, the performance improvements after they stripped it to the bolts, right, a few years ago, and have slowly built it back up. The performance improvements, which they
1:22:22demonstrated for me in their edit bay there, one of their edit bays, after
1:22:26cleaning it out, basically, it seemed very sterile for an edit bay. If you
1:22:30know edit bays, they're notoriously dirty with food and everything
1:22:33everywhere. And that but they showed on an AK display, you know, the iMac Pro
1:22:40handling all of these streams of simultaneous footage, you know, AK
1:22:46footage, color graded, non rendered, live, you know, footage, which is
1:22:52I think the new display is really great. I don't know how big it'll be, but I think it's got to be
1:22:558K because I think they just want, you know, 5K, they did that years ago, you know, like,
1:22:59and it's still, it's, I still am using my original generation iMac 5K, you know, like the first iMac
1:23:075K that came out is still my daily, that's on my desk in my office and I love it. But they've done
1:23:14that already, you know, so I kind of feel like, yeah. And they're, I mean, the 8K TVs are out
1:23:19there. You know what I mean? And I'm not saying they're everywhere. They're not abundant, but
1:23:23they are. The displays are out there. I think even Dell has an AK monitor now. And the TV that they
1:23:30showed me was AK. And like, AK HDR is what most people are like editing in, or most modern
1:23:39shooters who have like these red cameras and other high-end cameras. And then everything, because
1:23:45then you can master it down to anything and it looks amazing. You know, you have its future
1:23:50proofing, you know, you have that archive, as it let's say you shoot your movie, your
1:23:55feature film in 8k, you're able to then, you know, in 10 years or six years or five years,
1:24:02whatever, remaster that and offer it as an upgrade. It's the same thing where that happened
1:24:07with 4k. When, you know, Apple said, Oh, hey, iTunes can support 4k now. And all these studios
1:24:12came out with 4K stuff pretty quickly. Well, that didn't happen because they figured out
1:24:18a way to make it 4K. It happened because they shot it or scanned it from film at very high
1:24:23res and then were able to offer that stream pretty quickly.
1:24:26Trevor Burrus I keep thinking in the back of my head that
1:24:29I sort of hope that what they're building is a modern day Mac 2FX. The Mac 2FX was sold
1:24:35from 1990 to 1992. It was the fastest Mac ever made at that point. And it retailed starting
1:24:42recording price was $9,000. It was priced from $9,000 to $12,000 according to Wikipedia,
1:24:49and which is how I recall it. I just recall it with some number that made me want to die
1:24:55because I was picking up my brand new Mac LC. But the basic idea, all I mean by it is
1:25:10let's make the fastest computer we can make, right? And we've got, you know, if $10,000 computer is
1:25:18out of your budget, we have other, we have great iMac systems for the desktop that start at a very
1:25:23reasonable price. You know, let's build a machine for people who have the money and the need
1:25:30professionally to get something truly extraordinary. Like what could we do if we made a $15,000 Mac
1:25:38Pro. I'm not suggesting that would be the starting price. I'm just saying—but what
1:25:43if the starting price was quite higher than the iMac Pro, and that it's worthy on the
1:25:50performance front?
1:25:51The Mac 2 effects, you look at it—and I'll put a link in the show notes—it was from
1:25:56the beige box era at Apple. It didn't really look all that much different, and I wouldn't
1:26:03say it looked better than other Mac 2s in the Mac 2 family, but the performance was
1:26:11extraordinary. For some people, that was worth it.
1:26:15But the other thing that made me laugh is talking about 8K displays. Look at the display
1:26:20on that picture from the Wikipedia thing. I don't even know what display that is.
1:26:26I don't think that's a 13-inch display. It looks like it might be a 12-inch display.
1:26:33And as is big bezel, displays have gotten so much better.
1:26:39It's so bigger.
1:26:40Well, the entire width of the display is 18 inches, so it can't be much more than 12.
1:26:49I think I might be misremembering my timeline, but it might be the case that in 1990 there
1:26:54still weren't such things as 17-inch displays.
1:26:57Or I guess we had 15-inch for a while, too, but 13-inch might have been the most you could
1:27:02get? You could buy a $10,000 computer in 1990 dollars. So it's probably at least like a
1:27:15$15,000, $16,000, $17,000 computer in today's dollars. I don't even care.
1:27:19**Ezra Klein:** Yeah, Wikipedia says that it was equivalent to $16,800 in 2017.
1:27:24**Beserat Debebe-Rice:** All right, there we go. So it's a $17,000 starting price in today's
1:27:27dollars and you'd use it with a display.
1:27:30- Pros, are you ready for Apple's $18,000 Mac Pro?
1:27:35- Right, and the best display you could get
1:27:38was the size of an iPad Pro.
1:27:39(laughing)
1:27:42- Yeah, and about 1/16th the resolution at the most.
1:27:46- Yeah, what, like 640 by 480 probably.
1:27:49- Yeah, not even resolution, technically CRT, but.
1:27:54- Right.
1:27:56- Yeah, I mean, I think that there's,
1:27:58think there's an opportunity here to look at this. And, you
1:28:01know, I digress back to what I said, there was two ways they
1:28:04could go in one way was like, Hey, what's the best way you
1:28:07could build that box? Like, what if what if you could just slide
1:28:09the card in from the back, and it would make contact and it
1:28:12felt beautiful to do and they're able to convince AMD or Nvidia
1:28:16to like, you know, change architecture slightly on the
1:28:19cards that they work better with the machine and, you know,
1:28:22whatever, right, who knows what they could do with their
1:28:24leverage, you know, to make these experiences of having this
1:28:28modern machine feel as good as possible. Just like the modern cheese grater, let's call it, right?
1:28:32You know, can't cut your fingers. It's impossible. Don't have to screw anything in,
1:28:38you know, you can clip everything in. Dead silent, you know, whatever, whatever the case,
1:28:43water cooled, you know, etc. But then you the other way you could think of it as like, hey,
1:28:48what if, you know, the because they were very hot on eGPU right now. And yes, admittedly,
1:28:55it had just shipped, you know, support for it had just shipped. And so they were highlighting it
1:28:59for me just like, hey, we've got you here. So we're going to show you a few things that utilize
1:29:04the GPU, which is totally understandable. One of the demos that I got was this, you know, kind of
1:29:10insane, you know, detailed, I mean, it wasn't that insane. It's like a typical graphics card stress
1:29:16test type thing. But it had like a planet with a bunch of asteroids around it that were actual
1:29:20geometry, not a particle effect. And they pushed that on a Mac, on a MacBook Pro, and obviously,
1:29:26very poor frame rates on a MacBook Pro natively for a stress test like that,
1:29:31using the internal graphics card. And then they did a demonstration, which was fairly impressive.
1:29:38If you know anything about the way that systems recognize graphics cards, if you remove a graphics
1:29:46card from a system, usually the computer crashes just immediately because it's like, I have
1:29:51no idea what you just did to me.
1:29:54Trevor Burrus You've just taken off one of the lobes of
1:29:56my brain.
1:29:57Trevor Burrus Yeah, exactly. It would be like, yeah, you
1:30:00separated. Right. The rest of your brain's like, "Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey," right?
1:30:08So you know, it's immediate shutdown, just falls over like a ragdoll. And it's like,
1:30:11I don't whatever man I'm I quit. And so what the what they demonstrated though was they had two e
1:30:17GPU units, one with the like an AMD 580 or something in it. And then the other one had the
1:30:25Vega part, the one that's in the iMac Pro or something like it. I think they said it was the
1:30:30Vega part. So but that basically is like one of the beefier GPUs you can buy. And so they had those
1:30:37two lined up. You plug in one, it takes over the rendering. Obviously, it hands off any
1:30:44modern application, relatively new application built for OS X. I can't remember whether it
1:30:51works out of the box or whether there's some small change you can make to where it understands
1:30:55this. But they also said, actually, I'll dig it, I'll get to that in a second. But yeah,
1:30:59so that it'll understand the handoff and says, "Okay, I'm going to quit using this GPU here
1:31:05on board. I'm going to start using this one." And then they had a monitor plugged into the
1:31:10back of the GPU, the eGPU, and then of course the monitor comes active and it's pushing
1:31:15that monitor and also pushing the content on the MacBook. So it's actually really
1:31:20clever the way they handle it. Just one Thunderbolt cable, boop, right? Just plug it in. You now
1:31:24have a new GPU. You unplug it and if it's an older application, it just destroyed. And
1:31:32it's a new application, it completely handles it fine. They actually have a dialogue for
1:31:36older applications where it says, "Hey, yo, you know, this if you want to, if there's
1:31:41like, you know, a little GPU icon that appears in the bar and you eject it, you know, you
1:31:45click on the icon and eject it before you unplug it. And when you go to eject it, it
1:31:49says, "Wait, you're going to want to save anything you're doing here because the moment
1:31:53you unplug this, it's going to go into psychosis and just quit, you know, just crash on you."
1:31:58And I told them, of course, nobody has ever removed any peripheral without first ejecting
1:32:03it properly.
1:32:04So this is going to be fine.
1:32:05There's no problem here at all.
1:32:09But newer applications will handle it gracefully.
1:32:11You unplug it.
1:32:12There's a small, essentially a suspend.
1:32:15And then it says, "Hey, I'm on a new machine now."
1:32:18That's literally the thought process of the of the app.
1:32:21It says, "Oh, you just opened me up on a new machine that's configured differently
1:32:26with this new graphics card."
1:32:27then it takes off and unsuspends and goes from there. It's like a safe state. But
1:32:33it happens incredibly quickly and gracefully, from what I observed. But then they did one
1:32:38further, which is that they plugged in two. So they plugged in one that was the 580 and
1:32:43then one that was the Vega. And so you have two Thunderbolt ports, essentially, and utilizing
1:32:49the bandwidth of those, you know, beefier controllers, which is the whole reason they
1:32:54went with 4 thunderbolts and not legacy stuff, which some people will complain, and whatever,
1:33:00I'm not your complaint department. But the, well I got a bunch of flack on Twitter, like,
1:33:06why, you know, I don't use these GPUs, and it's like, well, I don't know, you may, you
1:33:10never know, right? Like, maybe you will. Anyhow, that's the decision that they made to enable
1:33:15this kind of thing. And they plugged in both parts, they fired it up again, and of course,
1:33:21know, you could see that the most powerful one takes over and
1:33:25it says, Hey, this one can handle the most load. But then
1:33:28they loaded up Cinema 4D, which is a 3d rendering application
1:33:33that is used by visual effects people to render scenes for
1:33:37movies or high end commercials and things like that. And you
1:33:40saw that. We saw that together.
1:33:42The iMac. The highest, they were saying, hey, but literally the
1:33:46highest of the high end visual effects. I mean, I'm not saying
1:33:49that there aren't competitors to Cinema 4D. I'm just saying that there are people using Cinema 4D
1:33:54to make movies like Star Wars and whatever else you want to say.
1:33:59Jared Ranere: Right, exactly. And so the way that it worked is you plugged in both GPUs,
1:34:04and you have the machine, and then you told the window, the viewport, which is the way it works
1:34:10in 3D software, you tell a viewport to start rendering, or you tell it how you want it to
1:34:14render. And so you start the viewport rendering. And then what happened is they actually had
1:34:19three little thin green lines that popped up on the screen. And this is a Cinema 4D
1:34:24feature, right? It's not an OS X feature. But the green lines, obviously supported by
1:34:28OS X, popped up on the viewport and it essentially showed you a slice of the viewport was being
1:34:37given to each GPU. And I asked them whether it was, like, this was allegorical, you know,
1:34:45or actual. And I think it's actual, but if somebody out there wants to correct me, that's
1:34:50totally fine. You know, that's all good. But basically, a small sliver of the viewport
1:34:56on the left, which was, this was a car dashboard that they were rendering, a picture of a car
1:35:00dashboard. And so the small sliver on the left, which is just a strip of like pebbled,
1:35:05you know, plastic texture, was being rendered by the GPU of the MacBook. Then a larger chunk
1:35:11was being rendered and it's like, you know, everything to the right of that green line
1:35:15is being rendered by the 580. And then the largest chunk of the viewport was being rendered
1:35:19by the Vega part. So it essentially allowed you to like utilize three GPUs at once just
1:35:25by plugging them in and then it would apportion out the work to whatever, you know, load that
1:35:32those each can handle.
1:35:33I like the idea of the built-in, was it a MacBook? I love the idea of the MacBook's
1:35:4010 GPU, it's like, I can help tell us. Yeah, that was basically it. It was a tiny sliver.
1:35:46Yeah, let me let me help out guys.
1:35:50I'll handle the notifications menu. Give me the notifications. I'll handle those for you boys,
1:36:02if you get an iMessage while we're doing this. But that that was very interesting to me,
1:36:07this philosophy of like, "Hey, how much compute power do you need GPU-wise for GPU-bound instruction?"
1:36:16And you can have that instantly and not have it when you don't want it. When you want to move away
1:36:22from your desk or walk away or carry your work with you or whatever. It's not about like, "Okay,
1:36:26got to transfer files and do all this stuff." If you're doing truly GPU-bound work, you can get a
1:36:32MacBook Pro and still do that work, which is amazing. And if it's, especially if it's not very
1:36:39CPU bound, your two year old MacBook Pro with Thunderbolt, you know, by the time each GPUs
1:36:45really get out there, your two year old MacBook Pro with Thunderbolt three is an immensely capable
1:36:51machine for rendering work and stuff still like the effectively extended the life of people's
1:36:56MacBook Pros massively, or enable them to do things that they wouldn't be able to do otherwise.
1:37:01and it works for everything. It works for gaming. If you got a
1:37:04MacBook Pro and you want to game, there's this company that
1:37:07makes this little puck thing that you can take with you and
1:37:10plug it into your machine in a hotel room and boom, you got a
1:37:12gaming rig.
1:37:13And that works. That works now. That works.
1:37:14Cool. Yeah, yeah, it just the OS 10. The latest update to OS 10
1:37:19enabled the GPU support. Apple has two pages up on the website
1:37:23about it, one that's developer focused, and then one that's
1:37:25consumer focused. So you could check on the website. I don't
1:37:28know what the exact URLs are off the top of my head.
1:37:30put it in the show notes. But yeah, it's basically like, hey, here's, you know, take your machine
1:37:36running the latest version of OS X that obviously has the ports to support it. And you're golden,
1:37:44you know, plug it in, and it'll know what to do. It'll take over that. Obviously, if you have stuff
1:37:48where the CPU is handling a lot of additional computation, it's still being limited, you know,
1:37:55to you and to the age of your computer. But the fact that it can say, hey, give me this beefy ass
1:38:03job, I'll figure out which GPU to throw it to whether it's the one on board or the one off board.
1:38:08And you plug this into your fantastic high resolution monitor, put your MacBook in a
1:38:14clamshell. And it's like you're using a much beefier machine. To me, seeing it live and the
1:38:20way that they're just swapping in and out and all of that. It says a hell of a lot to me about the
1:38:25the way they think about modularity. So I don't know that the new Mac, I mean,
1:38:29don't believe me to be honest, I say all of this and then I'm like,
1:38:33don't believe me because I was the person who were the original Mac pro was
1:38:36coming up. The trash kid thing. My feeling was like, Oh,
1:38:39it's going to be module all modular. Right. And like, they're going to,
1:38:42you're going to plug in your GPU if you want it. And, and hell,
1:38:45maybe even the cinema display will have its own GPU,
1:38:48which that doesn't make any guidance says,
1:38:49cause then you got to replace your CPU, your set of a display, you know,
1:38:52So don't listen to me about this, but I did find it compelling and interesting, you know, to see that happen live
1:38:58I thought it was cool and it does sound
1:39:00philosophically Apple like Apple likes to ship devices that you don't go inside and
1:39:08I'm not saying that you're not gonna be able to open your Mac new Mac Pro. I mean
1:39:12I'm not but I'm just saying if most of the quote-unquote modularity is a
1:39:20Philosophically about plugging in external GPUs and then other external things that sounds more Apple like to me
1:39:27Philosophically then put a card in the case, you know shut that machine down right plug it
1:39:31Put a card in the case hot swap ability. Just plug it unplug it, you know, you're doing this stuff, you know that requires
1:39:39you know the best external GPU money can buy but you're you've got to get out of the office because the
1:39:47Cleaning people are coming through gonna be running vacuum cleaners and stuff
1:39:50So you just unplug go to a coffee shop for an hour and work on something an aspect of the project. That's not
1:39:56GPU intensive, you know, you're like at the wireframe level or something
1:40:00But that you just don't unplug it and pick up your macbook and go that's actually kind of amazing
1:40:06like you don't have to say you said you don't have to save I
1:40:10shuffle the files around and
1:40:13switch to a different machine because now you're on a MacBook and open this thing up and you know
1:40:18You could just go to a different part of the building and you know
1:40:21Just keep using the machine
1:40:24Right and you could do setups like a lot of the stuff they talked about some of it was with logic as well
1:40:28but a lot of the stuff they talked about was
1:40:30You know being able to do setups and things like that. I mean think about it like
1:40:34From a rendering perspective like the MacBook Pro can handle a decent amount of geometry
1:40:42you know, in bare polygonal form, right, or wireframe or whatever. So you could do a lot
1:40:48of setups and play around and all of this stuff. And then when you're ready to render,
1:40:52you have that at your fingertips, but it doesn't mean you need it all the time. And in fact,
1:40:57for bigger units where you have like, you know, two GPUs plugged in and you're rendering
1:41:02or you're basically treating it as a rendering farm, a miniature one. And I was talking to
1:41:06some smart people in and I don't think it's that secret or not, but I was really talking
1:41:14to some smart folks that work at like Pixar and whatnot. And they were saying that there's
1:41:17probably a really nice market in between a company like Pixar that has its own render
1:41:23farm or another VFX house which uses AWS or one of the bigger server services like Google's,
1:41:30which a lot of them do now. And then then all the way down to the person who's just
1:41:35using their onboard GPU. In other words, there's probably a really solid long tail market for
1:41:42people that need GPU bound instruction stuff, work done, that want to build their own miniature
1:41:47render farm. And you could do a render, build a little render farm for yourself with just
1:41:52a few of those GPUs for a few grand and have quite a good time of it, turnaround wise,
1:41:58in getting your proofs out and all of that. Even if you used, for your final render, you
1:42:02used a bigger farm or spun up servers, you could definitely get your dailies out of that,
1:42:08so to speak. So it's very interesting, compelling for certain types of pro.
1:42:13What do you think—this is where I'm going over my head, because I'm not a gamer and
1:42:17I'm not a 3D professional. What is the deal—even the iMac Pro comes with Radeon, the Vega 56
1:42:25and the Vega 64 graphics processor. What's the deal with Apple's relationship with
1:42:30with Nvidia. It seems to me like there's some people who prefer Nvidia for… I don't
1:42:38know if it… But it's like Apple's never really had a good relationship with them.
1:42:42Wasn't there a thing like many, many years ago in the Steve Jobs era where Nvidia blew
1:42:46a… There was like a Mac coming out with an Nvidia card and Nvidia preannounced it
1:42:51before Apple did and they were like, "Screw them!"
1:42:54I don't remember that. I'm sorry. I don't remember that.
1:42:57I could be misremembering, but what do you make of that? Is it a thing or is it not a thing?
1:43:06You mean like the Nvidia versus Apple type thing?
1:43:08Yeah. Or does the new Mac Pro need to support Nvidia?
1:43:13Oh, I see what you're saying. Yeah. I mean, I sure as heck would like it to.
1:43:19I mean, I think that there's a lot of, you know, Nvidia is thinking correctly about a lot of stuff and they are smart. I mean, they, the Nvidia and all GPUs sort of got really kind of blindsided by the cryptocurrency or crypto industry at large, you know, and they really, you know, we're steamrolled in and really skewed the prices and availability and everything of all these cards.
1:43:46And so I think they're still kind of dealing with being that and trying to
1:43:50establish a place for themselves among purpose-built AI processing as well,
1:43:54like AI CPUs, because CPUs that are purpose-built for AI or co-processors
1:44:00that are purpose-built for AI is a huge thing. And it's going to be like the
1:44:03next big wave in chip growth. At least that's the conjecture. But I think that
1:44:08they are, they are in a position of strength when it comes to games and
1:44:12gamers, all of that, because they, but they do support, you know, Mac, right? Like they,
1:44:17and they have for a while, the Nvidia GPUs have supported Mac since, I mean, like early last year,
1:44:24I think there was a nice wave of like additional support for Mac. So I don't think that there's any
1:44:28acromony there. I don't know if it's an absolute must that it should support Nvidia cards, but I
1:44:33sure as hell would hope so. I would say that like, you know, if the GPU that's Nvidia, like, there's
1:44:41no reason that should work any different from an AMD GPU that you plug into your dear machine. So
1:44:49I'd say it's a must that that works. But I don't know whether or not they will use the part if it's
1:44:56of that model where the cards are internal, you know, they may just go with one partner.
1:45:00And that partner at this point will probably be AMD. I mean, it's on the wall, right?
1:45:04The alternative is, of course, is that there have been rumblings forever that Apple wants to build
1:45:09build their own GPUs. But I think that will come very, very, very far down the road for
1:45:14anything but their smartphones, or their small devices, their compact devices, because
1:45:19that's where all of the advantages like power, you know, and battery usage have come into
1:45:26play. That's what they're building it for. They're not building it because they can make
1:45:29the most powerful one. They're building it purpose built. Yeah.
1:45:31All right. Let me take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor of this show,
1:45:35Squarespace now stick with me because the end of this is going to be different than
1:45:40Squarespace ads have been for the last couple of I think a year. You guys know the basic
1:45:46gist with Squarespace. It's the all-in-one in browser website building hosting platform.
1:45:52You need a website. You go to Squarespace. You can get a free trial to start and they
1:45:58do every they have everything. You can get your domain name. You pick templates. You
1:46:03pick what features you want on your site, anything from a catalog with an online store
1:46:09to a podcast or a blog or a catalog with a blog. You know, really, the sky's the limit.
1:46:17It is totally creative. It's not like there's like three preset rigid things that you choose
1:46:22from and that's it. Sky's the limit on design. You can customize it as much as you want.
1:46:28You can make it totally your own brand. It'll look like just your website won't look like
1:46:33like a cookie cutter using the such and such theme from Squarespace. No, it will look exactly
1:46:37like your brand. And you can do it so fast and you don't need to be an expert. And if
1:46:42you do get stuck, you can contact them and get award-winning help. Just talk to somebody.
1:46:48It's really, really great. It's a great product. I highly recommend that the next time you
1:46:54need a new website or the next time somebody you know comes to you for a website, which
1:46:58is even better because then you're just totally off the hook for everything. You don't have
1:47:03to be the person they talk to when the website goes down or whatever. They could just call
1:47:07Squarespace. Everything you do with Squarespace, sites look professionally designed. It looks
1:47:12like you're a total pro web designer, even if you've never designed anything in your
1:47:15life. Intuitive and easy to use. And if you sign up for a year at a time, you get a free
1:47:21domain name registration. So start your free trial today at squarespace.com/talkshow. Now
1:47:27that's the new thing. See, for a while, for a year, they were just doing squarespace.com
1:47:32and then you'd remember the talk show when you pay or something like that.
1:47:36But now they want you to go to a landing page, squarespace.com/talkshow.
1:47:42And when you do sign up, make sure you start there at squarespace.com/talkshow and use
1:47:46the offer code "talkshow" to get 10% off your first purchase.
1:47:51And that's, you could use that 10% to save on a whole year.
1:47:55Save a lot more money because you're buying a year and you get the free domain name.
1:47:59So my thanks to Squarespace for their continuing long-time support of the talk show.
1:48:05All right, you mentioned that there's rumors that Apple is getting into making their own
1:48:10GPUs.
1:48:11They started doing that with the iPhone.
1:48:16The other recent rumor that I think we have to talk about is there was a Bloomberg report
1:48:22a week or two ago that said Apple plans to switch the Mac to their own.
1:48:29in-house chips starting in 2020, which people have inspected. The timing, putting a specific
1:48:38year on it is obviously news, but you'd have to have your head in the sand or be totally ignorant
1:48:44not to have been thinking ever since the Apple A series chips started coming out for the iPhone
1:48:51that Apple might switch to doing their own chips for everything because Apple likes to have control
1:48:57and Apple has different priorities than the rest of the industry. There have been Macs
1:49:03over the years that have been held up by Intel's ability to ship on time. So it makes all the
1:49:11sense in the world as a simple, would they do this if they could? Yes, of course they
1:49:16would. The question is, and I've gotten it from a lot of people, you probably have too,
1:49:23do you think this new Mac Pro that's not coming until next year? Is that the explanation for
1:49:29why the new Mac Pro isn't coming until next year? Because it'll be the first thing that
1:49:34they build in house, you know, but the in house CPUs or whatever. I think the answer
1:49:39to that is a definite no. And here's why. Because 2019 is not 2020. You know, and so
1:49:47So however much faith you put in the Bloomberg story, which Mark Gurman, I forget who else's
1:49:55byline was on it, but I really, really doubt that if that story is completely true, I really
1:50:02doubt that it's going to come out early. You know, like I would guess that if the current
1:50:07plan, if there really is a plan, if that story is completely true, and Apple is planning
1:50:11to ship to in-house designed CPUs for Macs by 2020, I think that that means it'll come 2020
1:50:18at the earliest and maybe 2021 because these things sometimes take longer than you think they
1:50:25will. And if they're already saying, and they started last year on a new Mac Pro, that has to
1:50:33be two separate things. It just doesn't make any sense to me that they would be related. I sort of
1:50:38think this is people just desperately trying to understand the how hard can it be to ship a work
1:50:45station? Like, right, not so much that they want this to be true. It's not so much that they they've
1:50:52thought through all of the technical aspects of it. Like, would these be a series arm chips? And
1:50:56would this you know, all the complications that that would entail of, you know, having a new
1:51:01process, a new architecture for the max?
1:51:04blah, blah, blah. Forget that. I mean, ARM is just not designed for high power, you know, use it,
1:51:10it would basically be a redesign chip completely. I mean, we're talking like, it can't be any
1:51:16iteration of what they built before. Because ARM is specifically Apple went with ARM not because it
1:51:21was different, but because very specifically, it's sipped power. Right. And it's, you know,
1:51:27useful for making devices like iPads and phones and watches, right? Like what makes Apple's
1:51:36in-house design team so good at like, "Wow, this new series three Apple Watch is so much
1:51:41faster than just two years ago." Like that skill set doesn't really translate to, "Let's render
1:51:48a scene from the new Star Wars movie." Yeah. I mean, it doesn't, I will say like the chip
1:51:53on the subject of the chip team,
1:51:55I don't care how many times it has come up
1:51:59or somebody has posted some fluff piece about like,
1:52:02oh, Apple's chip team or whatever.
1:52:04I don't care how many of those you publish.
1:52:05I don't think anybody understands exactly
1:52:07how amazing that team is.
1:52:10And I'm not saying this to blow smoke.
1:52:11I'm talking about the individuals involved.
1:52:13Like Apple has assembled an insane group of talent
1:52:18in that team.
1:52:19And like everybody I've talked to who actually knows
1:52:22what the hell they're talking about
1:52:23is like that team is a beast.
1:52:25Like it is, not only is their output insane,
1:52:28like the amount of improvements that they're building
1:52:31on processors that nobody else has.
1:52:33Like this is not where they can,
1:52:34oh, we'll take this design and improve on it 10%, right?
1:52:37Like they are literally building purpose-built,
1:52:39brand new chips at a very rapid clip
1:52:43and making them better and better and better.
1:52:45It is very impressive output for a chip design team,
1:52:49which is, chip design is like one of the hardest things
1:52:51do in tech, in hard tech. It's like a pinnacle of difficulty on an engineering level.
1:52:58Right. Because somebody, whether if you take your, if you make a misstep as a chip maker,
1:53:03or just start resting on your laurels, somebody else is going to stay. The history of the computer
1:53:10industry is showing that somebody else is going to come in with their pedal to the metal and make
1:53:14a chip that is the state of the art in every aspect, you know, you know, and, and eat your
1:53:22lunch, right? Right. Yeah, I think these are two totally unrelated stories. If it's true that
1:53:29Apple is switching to in-house chips, whether they are ARM or they're their own in-house x86
1:53:35or whatever, I don't think that has any relation to a Mac Pro that started being engineered last
1:53:42year. I mean, I'm sure if they have this roadmap...
1:53:45I have a hard time believing it, for sure.
1:53:47Right. I'm sure that they're, you know, it... I'm sure they're also not happening in isolation,
1:53:52because I'm sure that it's John, you know, John Turnus's team at Apple doing hardware,
1:53:58if this is true, and I have no idea, but if it is true that there is a plan to switch to in-house
1:54:03CPUs in 2020, I'm sure he's already aware of this.
1:54:08Yeah, I think those Venn diagrams significantly overlap.
1:54:12Right. I'm pretty sure. And so I'm sure they're thinking about it, but I don't think that,
1:54:17you know, you know, there's an art to shipping, whether it's software or hardware, right. And
1:54:21it's, you know, to ship one of these in 2019, you've got to, you know, you start cutting things
1:54:26off early, you know, like, okay, we'll use this, we'll use this, we'll use this.
1:54:32using in-house CPUs that don't exist yet isn't something you can do now to ship in 2019.
1:54:39Right. Right. Exactly. Yeah, good luck with that one. I don't believe that either. I think it's
1:54:46definitely something along the lines of, you know, the GPU in their own iDevices thing. That's not
1:54:55theirs either, right? It's not a completely Apple-built part yet by any means. But it is
1:55:00certainly closer to custom, whatever you want to call it. You know, they did a lot of work
1:55:07on that and they will continue to fully I'm convinced that at some point they will be
1:55:12their own in house GPU. Right now I think it still uses a lot of
1:55:16Unknown Speaker 10.
1:55:17templatization and in kind of similar structures as other existing GPUs. But the the fact that
1:55:24they're building that thing is is a given and the fact that they're working on other
1:55:27chips as a given. But like, if you look at that situation, I can imagine that if they chose like
1:55:34a manufacturer, an x86 manufacturer of some sort, to build the CPUs in that, let's say it's Intel,
1:55:40and they're going to build them a chip for that computer, I can imagine them having extensive
1:55:47custom requirements that make it wildly different than a normal off the shelf Intel part. You know,
1:55:54for this release in the future, you know, whatever. But definitely, I don't believe
1:56:00that there's going to be like some anal arm part in this in this pro computer. No.
1:56:05Trenton Larkin I wouldn't be surprised. Now, Apple's gone through two
1:56:11major CPU transitions with the Mac. And the first Macs ran on Motorola 6800 family chips,
1:56:20or 68,000 family chips. And then in the 90s, they switched to the PowerPC platform.
1:56:27And they switched everything, not all at once, but in the course of a year, everything went from
1:56:33being Motorola 68,000-based to PowerPC-based. And gosh, I even forget what it was called,
1:56:41but there was an... But you could run your 68,000 software in emulation for a couple of years.
1:56:48So that's, you know, what apps am I going to use if nothing's been recompiled yet?
1:56:51And then they sort of did the same thing when they switched in 2005 from the PowerPC to Intel.
1:57:01And they had a—I remember the name of that one. It was called Rosetta. And Rosetta would let you
1:57:07run your PowerPC code. And I don't believe it was—I think technically speaking,
1:57:13and I'm sure John Sirquisa will appreciate my exactitude here. It was not an emulator,
1:57:19it was a transcoder. It transcoded 68,000 instructions set to, no, I mean PowerPC
1:57:30instructions set to Intel on the fly. But effectively it's an emulator from the user's
1:57:34perspective. But then again, within a year, the entire product line had been moved to Intel.
1:57:40every single Mac, you know, after the first one shipped a year later, when you'd go in an Apple
1:57:45store, every Mac was on an Intel processor. I'm not 100% sure if they switch to ARM chips,
1:57:52in-house designed ARM chips for Macs. I'm not sure that they would switch all of them. I could see
1:57:58them and I think that I don't think the developer story would be all that complicated by it. I mean,
1:58:05It might be because you'd have to be able to it might have a lot of games for example that only run on the
1:58:11x86 max and don't run on the just plain MacBook that has an Apple designed arm CPU. I
1:58:19Don't know that might be too confusing for people
1:58:22But if philosophically I could see them doing that because the like the MacBook I
1:58:29Think would be a better computer if it had iPad
1:58:33CPU the iPad Pro CPU then the Intel whatever wimpy whatever it has
1:58:39But I don't I
1:58:43could see them saying but then at the high end for like the iMac Pro and for the
1:58:47Upcoming Mac Pro and stuff that you know will just stick with Intel and let them do what they do best
1:58:51Which is the high performance stuff? I don't know. Mm-hmm. I could be wrong
1:58:56It might just be that if they do switch they will switch everything and they'll figure out a way to get high performance
1:59:01I don't know
1:59:03I didn't intend to spend that much time on this rumor.
1:59:08Yeah, I think it's an interesting one and it's compelling every time it comes up because
1:59:15people are like, well, hopefully they're thinking this and it's not just from a shock and awe
1:59:20perspective, right? Which is like, oh yeah, they're switching from Intel and it's going
1:59:24to upset the business world. That's all fine, right? But it doesn't really matter to most
1:59:28users. And I think that the the compelling part of it is what could Apple accomplish
1:59:33if it was freed from, you know, completely from Intel architecture and able to do to
1:59:39build a processor that was part and parcel with every other decision they made on their
1:59:43hardware. And if it's not at a point where that they could do that, and then where that
1:59:47contributes to significant gains in performance, or, frankly, if it's Apple, we're talking
1:59:53about whether the fans turn on or not. You know, if they can
1:59:59feel that they could get a significant lead in that stuff,
2:00:01and users will notice a difference. That is when it
2:00:05makes sense. And I think there's a lot of attention paid to, oh,
2:00:09when will they switch away from Intel without considering the
2:00:13why so much right, you know, like the why would they you
2:00:16know, and, and yes, part of it is fiscal, right? Like if they
2:00:20can, if they can do their own in and have their own whitelist providers make their own chips, they
2:00:26don't have to rely on Intel, there's only so many boundaries in the world, though. And I'm sure
2:00:30they're already getting a pretty damn good deal. And so the financial aspects of it are just going
2:00:36to be relatively speaking, although there will probably be the size of a small company of its
2:00:42own, right, will be a relatively drop in the bucket for Apple. And so I think it would all really
2:00:47hinge on performance-based or experience-based improvements. And, you know, that is where you
2:00:55have to like concentrate your ideas and your thoughts. And just for me, like, there's not a
2:01:00lot of clear ones on a desktop right away, you know, in that regard. And I think we've seen from
2:01:08the coprocessor aspect of the MacBook Pro, that Apple has charted a way forward for them to be
2:01:15be able to do things like utilize stuff purpose built for
2:01:18arm on iOS, like, you know, the face, let's say face ID, for
2:01:22instance, they've charted a course forward for them to be
2:01:25able to do that without switching wholesale. So they
2:01:29bought themselves some time or whatever you want to call it. So
2:01:32I don't know if the transition is as eminent as it seems, or if
2:01:35there's something else going on, where they have another class of
2:01:38compute device that is going to be using an arm computer, all
2:01:41the aka new product lines,
2:01:43Think it's safe to say that all the other high-end phones use Qualcomm Snapdragon processors if Apple's in-house
2:01:51like a series processors weren't
2:01:54Notably superior and had you know many advantages probably cost included since they don't have to you know
2:02:00They're in control of it if they were just roughly equivalent to the current generation snapdragons
2:02:05I don't think I think Apple would shut the effort down, you know, like they're not doing it
2:02:09Just so they can have their own, you know
2:02:12to put a cool name on it like A12 Nitro.
2:02:16I don't know, whatever they're gonna call this year's chip.
2:02:18- Right.
2:02:19- They're not doing it just so they can put a name on it.
2:02:22They're doing it because it's an advantage.
2:02:25We'll undertake this incredible expense and effort
2:02:28of designing our own personal chips,
2:02:30but we're doing it because we're getting,
2:02:32and the end result that the customer has in their hands
2:02:35is gonna be a better product.
2:02:36- Right, and I think that the experience
2:02:41or advantage often expresses itself in ways that are not obvious to users or frankly even
2:02:50analysts in many cases. Once you explain it, you know, everybody sort of, the meme catches
2:02:57on and the, you know, people understand. But like the recent chip, what the hell is it
2:03:02called? It's not fusion. It's not, that's a drives.
2:03:06lives. What's it called? What's the buzzword? A11? So this A11 chip, they said bionic. It's
2:03:20bionic.
2:03:21No, no, no. I thought that was the A10.
2:03:22Is it? I thought it was A11.
2:03:24I think it was A10.
2:03:26No, no, no. It's A11 bionic. Which just goes to show you how dumb these names are, right?
2:03:32names are really just to kind of say, "Hey, like it's, you know, this is a new version
2:03:35of the chip. And we want you to know that there's more going on here than just a new
2:03:39chip." And there is more, right? It is, it does have dedicated sections of the chip
2:03:44that are used for things like security and used for things like processing, specifically,
2:03:50machine learning style instructions. You know, I talked earlier about the AI chips being
2:03:54bigger and bigger things. And by AI, I really mean at this point, machine learning and computational
2:03:59chips that are designed to run these types of instructions very efficiently. And to see a large
2:04:05portion of the reason that Bionic works the way it does or is the way it is, is because it could
2:04:10do things like it can handle instructions that don't need a full cycle and it can run them,
2:04:16sort of more efficiently. Because a lot of these, a lot of machine learning instructions
2:04:22are really low-rent, not high-powered instructions, but you need to run an absolute
2:04:29junkton of them. And so it allows you to run these instructions on essentially a half of what
2:04:36a normal swing would be. It'd be like a batter going up to the plate and you're like, "We really
2:04:40do not want you to hit a home run on this one. We need you to hit it between third and fourth,
2:04:45right? Or between second and third base." Third and fourth, that's hilarious. "Between second
2:04:48second or third base. I just invented a base. We need you to hit it there, out there. And
2:04:55this is going to do wonders for our strategy. It's exactly what we need right now. And
2:04:59you have that hitter who's like, "No problem. I could hit this home run for you, but this
2:05:03is what you want." And so here it is. And so it hits those base hits because the swing
2:05:07is shorter. And you can hit 50 or 100 of those at the time it takes them to hit one home
2:05:11run. And that is what's going on here. So that is then if you spool that out, what it
2:05:17allows Apple to do is run a lot of these instructions on device and do things like
2:05:22figure out whose faces are whose or whatever without popping it up to the cloud and making
2:05:29the cloud run all these instructions instead. And that, of course, dovetails with their security and
2:05:34privacy angle, with their whole philosophy, all of this stuff. And these types of interconnected
2:05:39tissues of the decisions that Apple makes on a hardware level are not only not possible,
2:05:45but not even in the realm of understanding for most companies that build an Android phone or
2:05:51another mobile device. I'm not saying those phones are bad. I'm not saying the people that like them
2:05:56are horrible human beings. I'm just saying that you cannot do this on those devices.
2:06:02Now you will be able to eventually, right? Because usually Apple does the thing and then
2:06:05a year or two later, everybody figures out how to do it. And that's great. But right now,
2:06:10these purpose-built devices each year that come out like chips and all this stuff are built in
2:06:15this way where they're not just saying, "Oh, we built this because X." It's, "We built this
2:06:20because X, Y, Z, alpha, beta, gamma, delta all connect to this." And that, I think, is the way
2:06:27you got to look at their chip design, the way you got to look at the desktop. If they're going to
2:06:31switch to ARM, it's not going to be because, you know, one win, right? It has to be a dozen wins.
2:06:40on different angles. And not all those wins will be evident right up front.
2:06:44Right. It feels like a show. It feels like we've covered this completely. I'll just say,
2:06:50I just feel like this whole thing, and again, I'll go back to what I said before, that I felt like
2:06:54your story was such good news for people who love the Mac and who are really, you know, again,
2:06:59to abuse a term that I sometimes cringe at, but I don't know what else to say, power users of
2:07:04of various sorts, whose big fear is that Apple is moving to this "everybody will use an iPad
2:07:12and like it" mentality. I just felt like your story and this commitment they have to the
2:07:18pro market shows how committed they are to the Mac. And maybe not the Mac exactly as
2:07:23we know it, but the Mac that has these Mac-like aspects that aren't like iOS that we know.
2:07:31I don't see iOS devices moving to support extra external GPUs. It just doesn't make sense. You
2:07:39know, right. I mean, you know, in the near term,
2:07:41Jay Haynes I, you know, I'll be honest. No, probably not. But I, you know, an iPad Pro with
2:07:49an eGPU would be pretty cool. Yeah. You know, and then that's, that's one with like, there's a last
2:07:55addendum to the whole discussion about that, that thing, you know, that, but that story is that one
2:08:00One of the things that they showed me, which was very cool there, and which does also tap
2:08:05into the way that Apple thinks about pros and pro computers and follows along with this
2:08:10eGPU line of reasoning, is that they had an iMac Pro there running Logic, and they had
2:08:17two iPad Pros paired to it wirelessly.
2:08:20I was told you could pair up to five devices wirelessly to an iMac Pro on Logic.
2:08:25know, I think all you know, all of the above work with up to five devices. And, you know,
2:08:31everybody's encouraged to buy four iPad Pros with every iMac purchase, of course. But you could put
2:08:38them together. And what the way they were using them is that they they were up to the left of the
2:08:43right of the iMac. And they had logic displays, they were served by logic. But they were not the
2:08:49same displays that you saw on the iMac, they were purpose built for iPad screens. And they those
2:08:54screens could show you, you know, large tappable buttons
2:08:57that allowed you to do things like time, you know, do like,
2:09:01you know, either metronome metronome timing, jump to a
2:09:04particular portion in a track, do a scratch pad, you know,
2:09:08whatever the case may be, whatever you need to do to, to
2:09:10tweak your stuff that works better by touch. And to do
2:09:14things like reference the manual live, I mean, you could hover
2:09:18over a device or a knob on the iMac, and the manual would live
2:09:23update to that particular section for that knob
2:09:26on the iPad Pro.
2:09:27It was really cool.
2:09:28- That's very cool.
2:09:29And then you could just like pick--
2:09:30- Yeah, and just--
2:09:31- And the iPad's wireless, so you could pick it up
2:09:32and just like, if you wanted to read about that setting,
2:09:36you know, you could just like pick it up
2:09:37and take a stretch and walk around with the iPad.
2:09:39You don't have to like unplug it or unmount it.
2:09:41It sounds pretty cool.
2:09:42- Yep.
2:09:43Yeah, I mean, it was neat.
2:09:44It was just, and I'm not saying this will work for everybody
2:09:46and some people are gonna be like,
2:09:47"Ah, you know, my work does not use, you know,
2:09:49"there's no feasible way I could possibly utilize
2:09:52that set up in my work. But that just goes back to this thing. Pros are diverse. And most of them
2:09:57just want to work in the way that feels right in their workflow. And I think iPad Pros have a lot
2:10:03to do with that and will have a lot to do with that in the future. And it really typified why
2:10:07Apple believes that touchscreen Macs are not in its immediate future, you know, they're not the
2:10:12way it wants to go. It's instead, why not take this touchscreen that is incredibly high resolution
2:10:19and incredibly responsive, that you know, adding to a Mac would
2:10:23not be feasible and or, you know, cost wise effective. And
2:10:27utilize that, you know, if you want to do touch there, you
2:10:29could, you know, activate your your all of your controls you
2:10:34want on there, walk around and control your iMac with it while
2:10:36you're producing music or whatever. And then when you want
2:10:39to walk away from it, you go walk away and use GarageBand,
2:10:41you know, and then come back.
2:10:42I know, I just I'm so glad I thought of it. There's one more
2:10:44point I wanted to make. And you mentioned it explicitly. I think
2:10:48somebody at Apple told you this, but that one of the reasons they wanted to, "Hey, call you in
2:10:51and get this story out that the new Mac Pro is going to be a next year thing," is that they're
2:10:58aware that people are making buying decisions now. And if you've been thinking, "Well, I need a new
2:11:04Pro desktop, and the new iMac Pro looks like I could make do with that, but maybe I'll hold my
2:11:11breath and wait for this Mac Pro." If you need work, you know, something for this year, you know,
2:11:17now you know get them you know rigada iMac Pro and I think that's pretty cool and it's definitely
2:11:22a new Apple thing right like Apple has not in the grass been all that interested in helping people
2:11:28with their buying decisions when there are uh curiously long in the tooth products in the in the
2:11:36you know yeah everybody's got to be the tea leaves and I don't think it makes for a very welcoming
2:11:42environment for institutional buyers. I really don't think that that like, I think you're
2:11:47absolutely correct that it was expectation setting and all of that stuff. But I don't
2:11:52think that it was necessarily even aimed at the individual buyer, you know, because the
2:11:56individual buyer at this point, they're going to take away from this, you know, exactly
2:12:00the same thing. But it really was aimed at those institutional buyers who are like, I
2:12:05have a 2018 budget, do I spend it now? Or wait? That's really their simple question.
2:12:11And they'll find ways to spend it, whether that's on iMac Pros or some other thing that
2:12:16they need to spend it on this year.
2:12:18But it's a message saying, "If you've got a budget set aside, utilize it for other Apple
2:12:26products."
2:12:27Hopefully, obviously.
2:12:29But then in 2019, earmark your budget for the Mac Pros that you've been waiting for.
2:12:34We're talking research.
2:12:36We're talking schools.
2:12:38We're talking R&D departments, these places that really need this raw compute power that
2:12:46buy a bunch at a time, movie studios, whatever you want to call it, and these production
2:12:52houses.
2:12:53Wait, buy it in 2019.
2:12:56Don't worry about saving your budget now in 2018.
2:13:00Spend it on what you got.
2:13:01And then when you get your new budget for 2019, you know what to look for.
2:13:05That's really the major market it was aimed at, I think.
2:13:08- All right, Matthew, thank you so much for your time.
2:13:10Thank you for writing such a great story.
2:13:11I'm so glad you came here to talk about it.
2:13:13Everybody can-- - Thank you for the kind words.
2:13:14- Everybody can get all the panzerino they want
2:13:17on Twitter at @panzer, P-A-N-Z-E-R.
2:13:21And you can read his work and the work
2:13:23of his excellent team at techcrunch.com.
2:13:27- Exactly, and if you want all 100% shoe content,
2:13:31you can follow me on Instagram, @panzer.
2:13:34And he is not kidding.
2:13:36- No, it's all shoes all the time, so.
2:13:38(laughing)
2:13:41I used to have my kids on there
2:13:42and I just archived all my kids.
2:13:44It's just all shoes now.
2:13:45- You don't even put your A material on there.
2:13:46(laughing)