Podcast Search

The Talk Show

226: ‘Cut That Mustache With Scissors’ With Marco Arment

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00All right, this is unfamiliar.

0:00:01I don't know if I sound right.

0:00:02I'm not using my microphone.

0:00:04I'm not using my headphones,

0:00:06although they are identical to my headphones.

0:00:08And I'm not even using my own computer.

0:00:11I have a review unit, 15-inch Core i9,

0:00:15the most controversial computer in the world in front of me.

0:00:18And I'm not even in my house.

0:00:21I'm here with Marco Arment at his

0:00:24bizarre summer home in New York.

0:00:29And not coincidentally, our guest this week is Marco Arment.

0:00:33Marco, welcome to the show.

0:00:35- Thank you very much.

0:00:36- I love recording shows with somebody in the room,

0:00:39although I can't, I can see you,

0:00:41but I do feel like the dynamic is always a little better.

0:00:45And I say that knowing that 98% of my shows

0:00:48are entirely over Skype.

0:00:50- You're just throwing the rest of your shows under the bus.

0:00:52- I am.

0:00:54- We're gonna tell you why all the other episodes

0:00:55of this show are less good than this, really.

0:00:58But I have no concerns over audio drift,

0:01:01no concerns over Skype dropouts,

0:01:03so it should be pretty good.

0:01:05So I guess that the biggest story,

0:01:09I haven't done a show in like four weeks,

0:01:11so it's been a long hiatus over the summer.

0:01:14I've been vacationing in various ways.

0:01:18Biggest story clearly to have dropped since last

0:01:20I recorded a show is that Apple has come out

0:01:23with an all new lineup of Touch Bar Mac OS,

0:01:27touch bar MacBook Pros.

0:01:29Every MacBook Pro with a touch bar has been updated,

0:01:32and the one MacBook Pro without a touch bar,

0:01:36the--

0:01:38- The MacBook Escape.

0:01:39- The MacBook Escape, for lack of a better term,

0:01:41is as yet untouched,

0:01:43and the regular MacBooks are untouched.

0:01:46Presumably updates to those will be coming in the fall.

0:01:50- Do you think they're finally,

0:01:52like there's been these rumors about like, you know,

0:01:54new MacBook Air replacement or something like that.

0:01:56My theory is that the MacBook Air replacement is just going to be a new configuration of the MacBook escape

0:02:01But do you think they're finally gonna give it a different name?

0:02:04So we can stop all this nonsense about like this is the touch bar MacBook Pro versus the touch button versus the MacBook Pro with two

0:02:10Thunderbolt 3 ports versus like it's the naming is such a mask

0:02:14Can we just finally like hopefully get rid of that this fall? I hope so. I don't know anything about it. I

0:02:19Hope so, though. I actually the there's to me

0:02:24The naming of the entire MacBook line is it sounds superficial and and like for example this it is

0:02:30Superficial the whole leg should we call it iPhone X or iPhone 10?

0:02:34Should they have even called it that because there wasn't at least as yet there is no iPhone 9

0:02:39Doesn't make it that's superficial. It doesn't really

0:02:42So confusion in my opinion. I think the MacBook lineup naming

0:02:49Sows confusion I've mentioned this before but it's madness that they continue to sell the MacBook Air

0:02:54With the name that implies that it is thinner and lighter when it is way thicker and way heavier than the just plain MacBook

0:03:02it makes absolutely no sense and I

0:03:05Guess that the logic behind it is they want to drop the name air and they've successfully done that on the iPads

0:03:12Because they've they iterate faster. So there's no more iPad air. There's just plain iPad and then there's iPad Pro

0:03:18So the iPad has a perfectly logical naming structure in my opinion just playing iPad

0:03:24It's cheaper has less fewer features

0:03:27iPad Pro it's more expensive and has more features like support for the pencil and stuff like that

0:03:33The air thing and the just plain MacBook thing

0:03:37I mean, I don't think they're gonna change the name of the just plain MacBook, which still

0:03:41Makes me I that's how I always write it. I write just plain MacBook. I know on your show. It's the MacBook one

0:03:47- Well even then, not enough people recognize that,

0:03:49so I'll usually just say the 12-inch MacBook.

0:03:52But even that, that was a weird name to give it,

0:03:55you know, the name MacBook without anything else

0:03:57because that suggests that it's the bottom of the line model

0:04:00and while that's true in performance,

0:04:02that's not true in specs otherwise or in battery,

0:04:04or sorry, in price.

0:04:06- Right, right.

0:04:07- Like it is not, it is far from the cheapest one.

0:04:09The cheapest one is the MacBook Air

0:04:11and that seemed to be for legacy reasons

0:04:13when the 12-inch MacBook was released in 2015.

0:04:17But it's been a while now that we've still,

0:04:19it's like, it would be one thing if this was

0:04:23like a problem for like one year or six months,

0:04:25like while they're between cycles,

0:04:26but we've had for three years now this confusion

0:04:29of the MacBook is not the lowest end or cheapest MacBook.

0:04:34The MacBook Pro includes some pretty different capabilities

0:04:38between its different models, and the MacBook Air

0:04:41is not the thinnest and lightest one,

0:04:44but it is the lowest end, like, I don't know.

0:04:46I just, please Apple, fix this naming scheme this fall

0:04:49with whatever you're doing.

0:04:50- Yeah, so here's, let's see what Germin said back in March.

0:04:54Something about a lower priced MacBook.

0:04:57I don't think they're gonna call it an Air.

0:04:58I don't think, I'd be very, very surprised

0:05:01if they update the Air as we know it.

0:05:03Like in just, you know, the thing that everybody wants,

0:05:05the oh God, why can't you just put a retina display

0:05:08in the MacBook Air and don't change anything else

0:05:10and I'll just buy that.

0:05:12And I know that there are people who would,

0:05:13that would make happy, or at least they certainly would have

0:05:17within the last two years.

0:05:18I don't know at this point if that still

0:05:20would make people happy, but that's not gonna happen.

0:05:23- Like, I would love if they just,

0:05:25if their low-end computer was still basically

0:05:29the MacBook Air looking thing, but with the retina screen

0:05:32and with the Thunderbolt port replaced

0:05:33by a single USB 3 Thunderbolt 3 port.

0:05:36Like, that would be fine, but they're not gonna make it.

0:05:39There's no way they're gonna make it, but it's funny.

0:05:41Like it is kind of sad that here we are talking about how like, you know, a lot of people

0:05:47would be very happy if they just made this thing, but Apple won't do that.

0:05:52Apple's not going to do what their customers actually are asking for.

0:05:55And in some cases that works.

0:05:56Like in some cases, you know, they do something better that we actually like better and that's

0:05:59usually how it plays out.

0:06:01But in this case, I don't like, I think what they're actually going to do is just make

0:06:04a de-specced, lower priced MacBook escape

0:06:09and call that the new MacBook Air or whatever,

0:06:11like make that the replacement for it,

0:06:13just like take this machine that they positioned

0:06:16when it was released, they positioned it as

0:06:18this is the replacement for the MacBook Air,

0:06:20but then of course it was too limited and too expensive.

0:06:23I think they're just gonna try to address that,

0:06:25they're not gonna make it less limited,

0:06:26they're not gonna like add ports back to it or anything,

0:06:27but they will try to make a version of it

0:06:30that is less expensive without sacrificing

0:06:32their massive margins.

0:06:33Yeah, I don't know. It's such a popular product. It is clearly, if you have subscribed to any

0:06:42belief whatsoever that Apple really still is serious about and cares about the Macintosh

0:06:48as a whole, the MacBook lineup from lowest to highest end is entirely, it's their bread

0:06:55and butter. And as much, you know, the iMac Pro, which I have yours right in front of

0:07:00It's a great computer shows their dedication to the niche pro market

0:07:05You know, they've promised and talked about in advance which is unprecedented an all-new Mac Pro

0:07:12which is an even smaller niche, you know supposedly coming a

0:07:182019 thing quote unquote 2019 thing so next December, right? I don't think so. I think it'll be early next year. I hope

0:07:29And and they're still popular right? I mean we they report how many max are sold every quarter it is

0:07:35It is a completely safe it's guaranteed to assume that most of them are Mac have the name MacBook in them somewhere

0:07:43But the lineup is a mess naming wise and spec wise, you know

0:07:50Like the fact that the most popular one by far has to be the still the MacBook Air

0:07:54simply because of price and they're selling I think the light time you were on my show we were

0:07:59talking about the madness that they're selling a non retina display let alone that a non retina

0:08:05display in their most popular product makes some degree of sense in the common sense way just that

0:08:10of course the lowest price one is the one least likely to have a retina display because a retina

0:08:13display is more expensive obviously than whatever you you know the crummy display in the macbook air

0:08:19But it's just preposterous that they're, you know, here we are in 2018 and it's late July and people

0:08:26are sending, you know, buying the computers for their kids going to college. And surely the most

0:08:31popular one they're sending the kids off to if they're getting a brand new computer is a,

0:08:35is a what, two or three year old MacBook Air?

0:08:37At least, I think three or four at this point. And, you know, and it actually,

0:08:42it's not that these people are like being, you know, dumb or cheap. The MacBook Air is still

0:08:47actually pretty compelling if you can just overlook that it's, you know, that the guts

0:08:50are a little bit old and that it has an ombre on the screen. But if you can overlook those

0:08:53two things, which a lot of people do, it's still a really compelling computer. It's,

0:08:57look, the MacBook Air is awesome. Like when that, when that generation is, like this is

0:09:01like the second body style of the MacBook Air came out in 2010, it was, or 2009, it

0:09:07was amazing. Like remember like even back then, it felt like you were getting away with

0:09:11something because it was like you can look at all the other MacBooks in the lineup at

0:09:14at the time, all the MacBook Pros, and you're like,

0:09:15you know, actually, this MacBook Air gives me like 80%

0:09:18of what I need in a much nicer and more attractive

0:09:22and easier to carry package, and it remained that way

0:09:25from that generation, like, you know, 'cause SSDs

0:09:27basically gave it the performance it needed,

0:09:28and it remained that way really until like two years ago,

0:09:32where the MacBook Air was pretty much like the one

0:09:34most people should get most of the time,

0:09:37and it happened to also be one of the, if not the,

0:09:40least expensive model most of that time.

0:09:42So it did kind of feel like we were getting away

0:09:44something all this time and maybe now Apple's like correcting that in some way but I don't know it's

0:09:48it's the low end of the lineup is still such a mess. Here's I'm gonna read a little bit from

0:09:54Gurman's report from March which came out before that education event in Chicago. A new cheaper

0:10:02this is quoting Mark Gurman at Bloomberg a new cheaper MacBook like lineup laptop is in the

0:10:08works and likely replace the MacBook Air at a price less than $1,000. Probably $9.99.

0:10:17Yeah, right.

0:10:18But it probably won't be ready in time for next week, the people said.

0:10:22This was in March?

0:10:24Yeah, this was in March.

0:10:25Well, he was right. It probably wasn't.

0:10:28(laughing)

0:10:30Like, I just love, I love that because,

0:10:36and again, I'm not saying that he's wrong,

0:10:39I'm not saying that his sources were,

0:10:41they're, you know, like you just said,

0:10:44they're technically, they were right,

0:10:46but I love that his sources were far enough away

0:10:48that they could only say it probably wasn't going

0:10:50to be coming in March and here we are in July

0:10:52and it still hasn't come out.

0:10:53- Yeah, you know, my secret sources say

0:10:54that the Mac Pro is probably not coming out

0:10:56next week either.

0:10:57- Yeah, as much as iPhone stuff leaks in advance,

0:11:02just because of the insane interest in it

0:11:08and the insane scale,

0:11:13how many of these things they have to have ready to go

0:11:16on opening weekend,

0:11:18and the Mac operates at an entire order of magnitude,

0:11:23lower, maybe even more,

0:11:27It does seem like Apple is able to keep Mac hardware stuff

0:11:31under wraps from leakers.

0:11:33- Oh yeah, remember, so right now we're right after

0:11:36the release of the 2018 MacBook Pros.

0:11:38They came out, what, about two weeks ago?

0:11:41A few days before they came out,

0:11:43there was this big report from Ming-Chi Kuo

0:11:45about how Apple's gonna refresh basically

0:11:47all the Macs this fall, and on that report,

0:11:50he didn't mention this at all,

0:11:52even though it was gonna happen literally three days

0:11:55after this report, and all he said about the TouchBar models

0:11:59was that they will be updated this fall.

0:12:02He had no other information about it.

0:12:04So clearly, here this was, this update that was happening

0:12:07right under his nose, right at that time,

0:12:09and he didn't even know.

0:12:10And he's very well-sourced and usually knows

0:12:12about such things.

0:12:14Clearly, the secrecy is way more effective

0:12:16on the Mac side than on the iOS side.

0:12:20- Yeah, so I think it's reasonable,

0:12:22even though there's near radio silence on any details

0:12:26of what new MacBooks of various price points

0:12:29might be released this fall,

0:12:31I think it's very reasonable for us,

0:12:32as interested people in the market,

0:12:35to be optimistic that in September or October,

0:12:39Apple will have a lot to show us and say

0:12:42about the entire lineup,

0:12:43including some kind of modern update

0:12:47to their entry-level machine.

0:12:50- I sure hope so, and I think they will.

0:12:52I think what they're showing us,

0:12:53I've said this in ATP before,

0:12:54it does seem like we're in an upswing for the Mac.

0:12:57We're in a good time where they had,

0:13:00they're talking about the Mac Pro

0:13:01and the Pro Display coming up soon.

0:13:03I hope those are awesome, and they probably will be.

0:13:06The iMac Pro is awesome.

0:13:08The 2018 MacBook Pros,

0:13:11I still have a lot of problems with them

0:13:12because there's still this body generation,

0:13:15the touch bar, all the stuff I don't like,

0:13:16the keyboard I still don't like.

0:13:17But I give them credit,

0:13:19they do seem to be moving in the right direction

0:13:23in the last couple of years.

0:13:24I think they have course corrected on the Mac.

0:13:27And the software side too, there's tons of motion there

0:13:30with things like Marzipan, those are major efforts

0:13:33and those are gonna be majorly pushing the platform forward

0:13:36and I cannot wait for that kind of stuff.

0:13:38And so obviously, on the hardware side,

0:13:41you look at things like the T2 chip

0:13:43and how this is this pretty advanced controller

0:13:47that they have in there that's doing all sorts of stuff

0:13:48They didn't need to do that.

0:13:50So I do think they're on the right path now.

0:13:53But we still need to see, what does that mean on the laptops?

0:13:55We still have no idea.

0:13:57And maybe this fall, maybe whatever the new cheaper one

0:14:01is, maybe I'm totally wrong.

0:14:03My theory, as I said a few minutes ago,

0:14:05is basically that they're going to half-ass it,

0:14:07that they're going to cut out some specs from the MacBook

0:14:10Escape as it is now to make a new 999 configuration.

0:14:13Maybe give it a 128-gig disk or something.

0:14:17Basically, skimp out as much as possible,

0:14:18on everything to get that price down with still a margin that Apple will accept. Right.

0:14:24But maybe I'm wrong. And maybe what they're going to do is do what the original MacBook

0:14:28Air did, which is debut a new body style, like without without coming out and saying

0:14:32so like, maybe what maybe they're actually doing an original design for this new cheap

0:14:37laptop. And maybe that design will be a preview of what's to come for the rest of the lineup.

0:14:43Yeah, and I always took it as a hint when they when they came out with the just plain

0:14:47MacBook and it was just called just plain MacBook and it I forget what the starting price was originally

0:14:52But I think it was like 1600 or something 15 14. I think there might have been like a 1400 config

0:14:56Yeah, but it was bad you kind of you very quickly got over 1500 configuring one

0:15:02I mean to be fair that first generation were all bad, right?

0:15:04It's just I think that last year it barely became usable right because that that original atom processor was

0:15:12really. Yeah, and the SSD was slow and everything like that. The 2017 model really improved

0:15:17a lot. But I always thought that the name was a very strong signal that it would become

0:15:22the new entry level model because of it just makes product marketing sense that the one

0:15:27without any modifier, just plain MacBook would be the entry level, but it couldn't be when

0:15:32it debuted because they made it so crazy thin and light that they had to use, you know,

0:15:40expensive components, even though they were slow, etc.

0:15:44It's just the only way to make it so insanely thin

0:15:46compared to everything before it.

0:15:48I don't know.

0:15:49- That's possible, but I think maybe that was their goal,

0:15:51I don't know, but I don't think that's ever going

0:15:53to really be successful.

0:15:54I don't see that product, the 12 inch with the one port,

0:15:57I don't see that being the one that becomes

0:16:00the new entry level mass market thing,

0:16:01because there are so many trade-offs.

0:16:04When the MacBook Air first came out,

0:16:06it was $1,600, I think, or $1,700 for its base,

0:16:09And it was very limited in the first one,

0:16:11before the nice 2010 revision.

0:16:14It couldn't be the bottom of the line,

0:16:17because people buying the bottom of the line

0:16:19still have needs, they still,

0:16:21they're buying to hit a price point often,

0:16:23but they still have practicality needs to worry about.

0:16:26So with the MacBook Air originally,

0:16:30that couldn't serve that purpose even if it were cheaper,

0:16:32because it didn't have things like a DVD drive

0:16:34that everyone needed, right?

0:16:35And with the 12-inch MacBook today,

0:16:39You could make an argument that like, well, it gives up all this stuff, it gives up a

0:16:43lot of performance compared to the 15 watt chips that are in the MacBook Air and the

0:16:46MacBook Escape.

0:16:47It gives up all these ports, you know, even if you set aside things like the keyboard

0:16:51that are controversial.

0:16:53It gives up so much, but I don't see people ever saying, you know what, I only need one

0:16:57port for my entry level laptop.

0:16:59Like some people who are, you know, some people can choose that and say, you know, for my

0:17:03travel laptop or whatever, I'm fine with that.

0:17:06But people who are buying the entry level model

0:17:08are the mass market.

0:17:09And one of the reasons the MacBook Air keeps selling so well

0:17:13is that compared to the MacBook,

0:17:15it does have a whole bunch more ports and everything,

0:17:17and it is more versatile and everything.

0:17:18Before that, before the MacBook Air became

0:17:20the role in the lineup, it was that MD101,

0:17:24the 13-inch non-retina MacBook Pro

0:17:27that still had the DVD drive.

0:17:29Remember, they only stopped selling that,

0:17:30like what, a year or two ago?

0:17:31It was very recent, that 2012 model or something like that.

0:17:34And before the Air, that was a suspiciously large seller

0:17:39for the exact same reason, that it was very inexpensive,

0:17:44it was also inexpensive to spec up,

0:17:47'cause it had a spinning disk and RAM slots,

0:17:50so you could buy third-party stuff,

0:17:52or even the stuff from Apple, you could get a lot of storage

0:17:53for not that much money, and it had the optical drive

0:17:56and had all the ports, and so people who didn't care

0:17:58about retina, who didn't care about newness,

0:18:00and who just wanted something very versatile

0:18:02for like a thousand bucks or less,

0:18:04they had that option with the 101.

0:18:06Now optical drives are out of favor enough

0:18:09that people don't need that anymore,

0:18:10so they went to the MacBook Air.

0:18:12But I don't see like 90% of your ports going away

0:18:16being a thing that's gonna be so easily moved

0:18:18into people's minds for that bottom of the line laptop.

0:18:21- Yeah.

0:18:22Yeah, so what do we think Apple should do?

0:18:26Like if you and I had been secretly recruited

0:18:29to Apple's MacBook development team 18 months ago

0:18:33so that we could have a lineup for the fall of 2018

0:18:37ready to go.

0:18:38I kind of-- (dog barks)

0:18:41- [Nathan] Bob, come on, man.

0:18:42(both laughing)

0:18:42- I kind of-- - We have a guest

0:18:44in the room. - I kind of think we have,

0:18:45we're on a similar page where the default machine should,

0:18:49you know, at a 9.99 or even ideally,

0:18:52if they could get back to 8.99 like they did

0:18:56when they, thank you, when they had the 11-inch error

0:19:01for $8.99 for a while.

0:19:05And I think the reason they felt like they could do that,

0:19:07'cause that's a rare thing for any company to do,

0:19:10is to raise the minimum price as significantly.

0:19:13It used to be you could walk in

0:19:14and get an $8.99 MacBook, the 11-inch,

0:19:17and then they did away with it,

0:19:18and the cheapest jumped $100 to $999.

0:19:23And I feel like the reason they could do that

0:19:24was that the 11-inch MacBook Air,

0:19:26even though it was cheaper,

0:19:27was always sort of a niche product.

0:19:29Like-- - Yeah, it was so small.

0:19:30- It was only for people who really,

0:19:32and I had mine for years and truly loved it

0:19:34because it was always a secondary machine for me,

0:19:36and I truly loved the size and portability of it.

0:19:39It's really one of my favorite machines I've ever owned.

0:19:41But I think people who,

0:19:43the typical person who's buying a laptop to be their PC,

0:19:47that's it, this is the thing that's a real computer for them

0:19:51don't want to sacrifice the screen real estate

0:19:54and have a slightly smaller keyboard, et cetera.

0:19:56- Yeah, the 13-inch air was always the mass market one.

0:19:58- So I feel like the default machine

0:20:00should be bigger than the 12-inch MacBook.

0:20:03Should probably have a 13-inch screen.

0:20:05It should have a few more ports,

0:20:07but they're not gonna include USB-A ports,

0:20:10even though I feel like they should.

0:20:12I mean, we should only do a whole segment

0:20:14on the failure of the USB-C market.

0:20:17- I do want it on ATP almost every week.

0:20:19- I know, I know. (laughing)

0:20:23But I think it really shows with people's,

0:20:24as the clamor, we're recording this

0:20:26after the software update that fixed

0:20:28the throttling gate with the Core i9.

0:20:32So the people--

0:20:33- Aren't you lucky that you missed that on the show?

0:20:35Like you didn't have like,

0:20:36if you had an episode like last week,

0:20:38you would have had to like do what we did on ATP.

0:20:40It was like, look at all these YouTube things

0:20:42and Reddit things and try to figure out what's going on

0:20:44and try to speculate.

0:20:45I mean, we were wrong about like half of what we said.

0:20:47- Well, I skipped it on Daring Fireball.

0:20:49I just didn't, I don't even think I linked to it.

0:20:51And I got a lot of people asking,

0:20:54most of the feedback I got was just,

0:20:56what do you think about this?

0:20:57And I answered by email to some people.

0:21:00But I just didn't link to it.

0:21:02And then of course the accusations

0:21:04that I wasn't linking to it

0:21:05'cause I'm in the bag for Apple

0:21:06and I'm covering up this outrageous scandal.

0:21:11My thought was,

0:21:12we're sort of segwaying into the specific thing with this,

0:21:17but my thought on that whole thing was,

0:21:19there's just not enough evidence yet.

0:21:20It just sounds to me like it's probably a bug,

0:21:23and we'll know soon enough whether it's a bug

0:21:25that can be fixed or a genuine serious engineering flaw.

0:21:28And I'll decline to comment until there's more evidence

0:21:31than one YouTube guy using one app, Premiere Pro,

0:21:36which probably, the nature of which is probably

0:21:40not that optimized for Macs, and evidence that's come out

0:21:44since has shown that to be true.

0:21:46- I mean, Adobe makes that, right?

0:21:47So it's not optimized for anything.

0:21:48- Right.

0:21:49No, but I think, going back to your question a minute ago,

0:21:51I think what would Apple need to do

0:21:53to make the new MacBook Air replacement?

0:21:56I think the MacBook Escape can almost be that.

0:21:58It just needs a few changes.

0:21:59And I know we're never getting USB-A back.

0:22:02I'm not even arguing for USB-A anymore.

0:22:04If you can fit one on the side of a laptop,

0:22:06it is really nice for convenience.

0:22:07But I know that's a lost battle,

0:22:09so I'm not even saying they should do that.

0:22:12I do argue for the SD card to be included

0:22:15in the higher-end models.

0:22:16I don't necessarily think it needs to be

0:22:18in a MacBook Air replacement.

0:22:19But I think what it does need, which it almost has,

0:22:22is four ports and a lower price.

0:22:26That's about it.

0:22:27That's all it needs.

0:22:29And I know they're probably not gonna give you

0:22:31the four ports.

0:22:32There's probably some limitation with Thunderbolt lanes

0:22:34that are on the 15 watt, or PCI Express lanes

0:22:36available on the 15 watt CPU line from Intel that it uses.

0:22:40Like, it's probably something like that.

0:22:42I still, there's so many problems with USB-C

0:22:45that like, that this is even a problem.

0:22:46Like, USB-A was never limited by Thunderbolt lane,

0:22:49or by PCI Express lanes,

0:22:50'cause they didn't build Thunderbolt into every port,

0:22:51because most people don't need that.

0:22:53So here you are wasting one of your ports on power,

0:22:57and wasting another one on charging your iPhone,

0:23:00and you can't have more ports,

0:23:01because they need all the bandwidth

0:23:02for the Thunderbolt 3 lanes that you're not using.

0:23:04So that's a weird engineering trade-off

0:23:06they made to begin with,

0:23:07but I think that's all it really needs,

0:23:09and I think that's plausible.

0:23:11The four port thing is a risk,

0:23:12but just making a version of the escape

0:23:14that has cheaper pricing somehow,

0:23:18somehow with market segmentation that they can do it,

0:23:20I don't know, but the current laptop line,

0:23:24like the new generation, if you exclude the old models

0:23:26they're still selling, like the Air,

0:23:28the new line is so expensive compared to the old ones.

0:23:31That's a problem for them, I think,

0:23:35in the way their products look, the way they're perceived.

0:23:37I mean, they've always been perceived as being expensive,

0:23:40but I think this is getting to the point of being egregious,

0:23:43and it's getting more and more distant

0:23:45from what people expect to pay for such a thing.

0:23:48And then the low end kind of rotting out here

0:23:51and being neglected for so long is not helping that at all.

0:23:54So they need to make a good low end play.

0:23:57And you're gonna have people who make

0:24:00like the $200 iPhone argument a bit,

0:24:02oh they don't have to do that,

0:24:03they're just serving the market.

0:24:04But like a huge part of Mac market share

0:24:06is those like $1,000 MacBook Airs.

0:24:08And those are getting really long in the tooth.

0:24:11They have to replace them with something

0:24:12and it really should be as soon as possible.

0:24:15- Yeah, and I think it comes down to naming again,

0:24:19just to go back to where we started,

0:24:21is the MacBook Escape should not be called a MacBook Pro,

0:24:26in my opinion, and it's not.

0:24:30I mean, it is a cut below,

0:24:33other than the fact that the aluminum frame

0:24:36is exactly the same as the 13-inch MacBook Pros,

0:24:42touch bar versus actual physical function keys aside,

0:24:46and it has the same display, but internally,

0:24:49you know, it's got a lower, a lesser CPU,

0:24:52it has lesser graphics, it costs less.

0:24:55It's not a MacBook Pro, it should be called something else.

0:24:59I guess I see why they called it a MacBook Pro,

0:25:02because it does look the same,

0:25:03and it was introduced alongside them.

0:25:05- It's also a great computer.

0:25:06Like, I have one for a little while.

0:25:07- Right.

0:25:08- I love that escape.

0:25:09The only reason, the only things I hated about it

0:25:11were that I did have keyboard problems with it.

0:25:13I had a bunch of like stuck keys

0:25:14and weird popping and everything.

0:25:15And so I did have keyboard problems with it

0:25:17and the two ports were really annoying on trips.

0:25:19Like when I would travel, I'd wanna like

0:25:21do travel podcasting or charge stuff on my laptop

0:25:23and only having two ports was pretty limiting.

0:25:26But other than that, I loved that computer.

0:25:27It was great and that's why I ordered a 13 inch

0:25:29of the new one but I ordered the Touch Bar one

0:25:31because I wanted the ports.

0:25:32But like, I think the reason they called it Pro

0:25:35was I think more, you know, because it visually

0:25:38resembled the other 13 inch Pro just fine.

0:25:41and also I think because they wanted to help justify

0:25:44the cost increase, because it really was just a MacBook Air,

0:25:47but they increased the cost so much,

0:25:49I felt like they, that was my guess of why they did it.

0:25:51But ultimately, if I was in charge of this product line,

0:25:54of naming this product line,

0:25:55I wouldn't want any responsibility,

0:25:56'cause they would fire me immediately.

0:25:57But if I was in charge of naming this product line,

0:25:59and I guess I'd be fired from that too,

0:26:01but I don't think they would call it the MacBook One

0:26:03or the MacBook Escape, but I think I would say

0:26:07The MacBook Air brand is too strong to throw away

0:26:11when this generation stops being sold.

0:26:13I think something should always be called the MacBook Air

0:26:15because it's such a good name

0:26:17and it has such brand equity among consumers.

0:26:20So what I would say is rename the 12-inch MacBook

0:26:24MacBook Air with its next generation

0:26:26and say this is the new MacBook Air,

0:26:28it's the 12-inch MacBook.

0:26:29Rename the MacBook Escape to simply MacBook.

0:26:32- I could see that.

0:26:34I mean, there is some sense to that,

0:26:35especially if they could get a 12-inch MacBook down to $999,

0:26:39which I kind of think it might be their plan.

0:26:41- Well, that doesn't even mean what I'm arguing.

0:26:42I'm saying bring the escape, bring the 13-inch

0:26:45down to that level. - Deny it again.

0:26:46- Call it the MacBook.

0:26:48And because right now you have this conflation

0:26:51of the lowest end product is also the smallest,

0:26:54thinnest, and lightest.

0:26:56But that requires such trade-offs

0:26:57that a lot of the low-end buyers aren't willing to make

0:26:59that that shouldn't be the lowest end product.

0:27:02It should be, the low-end product should be

0:27:04to hit a price point, not to hit a size.

0:27:06And so that's why the Escape should be the low end product,

0:27:09it should be called the MacBook.

0:27:10The MacBook Air should be the little 12 inch

0:27:13super thin one, and then MacBook Pro

0:27:15is the higher priced, higher powered one.

0:27:17- And the 13 inch MacBook Escape,

0:27:19well all the 13 inch, my current MacBook Pros are,

0:27:22and Apple themselves emphasized this

0:27:25when they introduced them,

0:27:26only like two sheets of paper heavier than a MacBook Air.

0:27:30- Yeah, it's about the same.

0:27:32They are technically an ounce hot,

0:27:35heavier or something like that.

0:27:36- But I think it's grams.

0:27:37It's like it's so small.

0:27:39- Right, like you could probably even it up

0:27:42just by getting some sweat and some crumbs

0:27:45on your MacBook Air and then they'd be the same.

0:27:48The one where the keyboard would still work.

0:27:50- Yeah, just keep the crumbs away from the new one.

0:27:52- Yeah, well, we'll keep going on this.

0:27:56Let me take a break and thank our first sponsor.

0:27:58This is gonna be good.

0:27:59I think the sponsor's, it's coincidence,

0:28:01sort of, but it's kind of fun.

0:28:04There's, every single one of them is actually in use today.

0:28:08Our first one is Tres Pontas Coffee.

0:28:11I'm drinking it right now.

0:28:13Marco can vouch for it.

0:28:15This is in the Arment household.

0:28:17There is Tres Pontas Coffee.

0:28:18- And I didn't order it because you were coming.

0:28:20I ordered it like long before

0:28:22I knew you were gonna be here.

0:28:23I ordered it by my own volition.

0:28:25They aren't a sponsor of my show.

0:28:26I ordered it only because they were a sponsor of this show.

0:28:28- And we, you know, I've been here a few days

0:28:30and we have been drinking some of Marco's own,

0:28:34Marco roasted coffee, but it was all gone.

0:28:37(laughing)

0:28:38And the only other coffee in the house.

0:28:40- Turns out the groupers drink a lot of coffee.

0:28:42- No. (laughing)

0:28:44One of the groupers drinks a lot of coffee.

0:28:47I am drinking it right now.

0:28:49It comes from a single family farm in Tres Pontas,

0:28:53in the town of Tres Pontas in Brazil,

0:28:57hence the name Tres Pontas.

0:28:59They only have one variety of beans.

0:29:01And it's very simple.

0:29:03They have four roasts, light, medium, dark,

0:29:06and then French roast.

0:29:07What are we drinking?

0:29:08I don't even know.

0:29:09I'm guessing light.

0:29:10- No, I think it's medium.

0:29:11It's either medium or like the slightly dark one.

0:29:13'Cause usually I like my coffee a little dark,

0:29:15but not too dark.

0:29:16So I would've gotten one of those too.

0:29:18- I prefer the medium, I think, at home,

0:29:20'cause they've sent me all of them.

0:29:21And I'm just not a French roast person.

0:29:24I find the French roast to be terrible.

0:29:26But people who like French roasts might like it because--

0:29:28- Spoiler, every French roast is terrible.

0:29:30(laughing)

0:29:32- That's my opinion as well.

0:29:33- Yeah, I'm pretty sure this is the medium.

0:29:34- But it's kind of a neat thing,

0:29:35where you don't have to select the beans,

0:29:37you just select the roast style,

0:29:38which in a lot of cases, in my opinion,

0:29:40is really the biggest difference.

0:29:41If you're starting with good beans,

0:29:43which is half the battle,

0:29:46but then just get it roasted the way you like it.

0:29:48That's your choice.

0:29:49- People always ask me, where do you get good beans?

0:29:51And what it really comes down to is not what brand name

0:29:54is on them or anything, what it really comes down to is,

0:29:56how well is it roasted?

0:29:57and they give you the option for that,

0:29:59and how freshly is it roasted?

0:30:01And they solve that problem as well.

0:30:03- Right, their coffee is very fresh.

0:30:06That is their main thing.

0:30:07They ship all the stuff out themselves.

0:30:10Marco can vouch for this.

0:30:11I say it every time Trace Ponta sponsors the show.

0:30:13Coffee is a perishable item.

0:30:16This is why it is good to buy whole beans.

0:30:18This is why it's good to get a nice grinder.

0:30:21And this is why it is great to get something

0:30:25like a coffee subscription, which Trace Pontas offers,

0:30:29to just keep fresh beans coming to you at a regular basis.

0:30:33Now, it's not like, I don't know, like an avocado

0:30:36or something like that where it can quickly go bad.

0:30:38It's not that perishable, but you don't want stuff

0:30:40that's been sitting around on shelves for weeks and weeks

0:30:43or even months like you might get in the supermarket.

0:30:45So, here's what you can do to get Trace Pontas.

0:30:47You can go to their website, tracepontas.com,

0:30:53and just order a bag or a couple of bags

0:30:55or something like that to give it a shot.

0:30:57You can also go to Amazon and search for it,

0:31:00and you can get it there if it's more convenient

0:31:02because then you can do the old one-click thing.

0:31:04And when you buy Tres Pontas coffee on Amazon,

0:31:06they're just using Amazon as a storefront.

0:31:08They still fulfill it themselves.

0:31:10It's not coming out of an Amazon warehouse

0:31:12somewhere where it's been sitting on the shelves.

0:31:13Tres Pontas still fulfills it.

0:31:14They just go through Amazon for the convenience of it.

0:31:18And the other thing they have

0:31:19is you can get a coffee subscription,

0:31:22and you get fresh-reroasted beans sent to you every one,

0:31:25two, or four weeks, your choice when you sign up

0:31:28for the subscription, and you save 10%

0:31:31when you get a subscription compared to the regular price

0:31:34of the coffee, but listeners of the talk show

0:31:36get an extra 10% off by using the code "THETALKSHOW"

0:31:39at checkout when buying a coffee subscription.

0:31:43So you save a total of 20% off every bag with that code.

0:31:47- I hope I used your code.

0:31:49- I don't know, enter the code at checkout,

0:31:51That's where you do it if you're looking for it.

0:31:53And again, their website is traspontas.com.

0:31:57T-R-E-S-P-O-N-T-A-S.com.

0:32:02Picking up where we dropped off.

0:32:06So I think that Apple has fallen too in love

0:32:08with the name MacBook Pro to obsess on naming.

0:32:11And I think it's exemplified with the iMac Pro.

0:32:16Like what is the difference between a 5K,

0:32:1927 inch regular iMac and the iMac Pro?

0:32:24Well, there's the cosmetic difference

0:32:27where it's space gray, which also, of course,

0:32:30makes it run a little faster.

0:32:32And you get the black mouse and the black keyboard.

0:32:37- Maybe some racing stripes might make it

0:32:39even like 10% faster.

0:32:40- But joking aside, but it is the same display.

0:32:43But the regular iMac has a great display

0:32:46that is great for totally professional use,

0:32:48graphic designers, all sorts of people,

0:32:49or photographers and stuff like that.

0:32:52All the real difference,

0:32:53the reason it's so much more expensive

0:32:55than a regular iMac has to do with technical details

0:32:57that are genuinely professional components.

0:33:00Xeon processors versus whatever the retail,

0:33:05I don't even know what they're called.

0:33:06- i9s and i7s.

0:33:07- Right, whatever they are, who cares?

0:33:11and that's like about 40% is just Intel marketing BS.

0:33:15- The iMac Pro, I've already forgotten,

0:33:17but I'm pretty sure it uses the different kind of RAM.

0:33:20- Yep, ECC.

0:33:21- ECC RAM, all sorts of stuff like that,

0:33:23that truly are pro components.

0:33:26And all sorts of other industries

0:33:30have similar type distinctions.

0:33:32Like one I'm vaguely familiar with

0:33:34as a amateur photo enthusiast is like when you buy,

0:33:40get into the canon ecosystem of cameras and they have their L series of lenses. I don't

0:33:45even know what L stands for. Do you know? I don't I have no idea. All I know is that

0:33:49it means expensive, right? Bring in good, right? Well, and the white some if they're

0:33:53not entirely black, though L series often has like a white part to it there. You know,

0:33:58if you know what to look at the telephotos are all white, right? The telephone, the big

0:34:01long telephotos on sticks that you see at sporting games are all very intentionally

0:34:05white with a red ring on the outside. And if you're just looking, you know, a typical

0:34:09punter, as they would say in the UK.

0:34:11Just looking for a nice camera and you're willing to spend

0:34:15up to like $2,000 on the whole kit,

0:34:18you're not looking at L series lenses.

0:34:20They're for pros.

0:34:21And there's just no ifs, ands, or buts about it.

0:34:24- And it isn't just about price.

0:34:25It's about like they add features that a lot of consumers

0:34:29wouldn't care about that pros really need.

0:34:31- Right, well, and they also add downsides

0:34:35that amateurs would be annoyed by.

0:34:37So like they're big and heavy, they're expensive.

0:34:39- Everybody always says, so famously, everybody says,

0:34:42you wanna get serious about photography

0:34:44and you have an interchangeable lens camera,

0:34:46you gotta get a 50 millimeter,

0:34:48or equivalent if you're using different sensors.

0:34:50If you're talking in 35 millimeter sensor size,

0:34:53get a 50 millimeter fixed lens

0:34:54and stick that on your camera for a few months

0:34:57and don't even take it off

0:34:59and just learn to shoot with that one lens.

0:35:01So, and the quote unquote nifty 50 is like $100.

0:35:07You get an F and it's way better lens, you know, optically because a 50 millimeter fixed

0:35:13lens.

0:35:14Anyway, there's also a like three or $400 50 millimeter lens, which is just made out.

0:35:19It's less plastic.

0:35:21It's sturdier.

0:35:22It's, it's better, but it's not that heavy.

0:35:23And then there's the L series one, which I bought because I'm an idiot because it goes

0:35:28all the way down to F 1.2.

0:35:31So it's, you know, even more, even better in low light and it weighs like six times

0:35:36more. It is a very, very heavy piece of glass. You know, it's a pro-level 50mm lens, but

0:35:44you pay a price that a typical consumer wouldn't. And a photographer of my abilities, I'm not

0:35:51really capturing better images with that lens than I would be with the $400 50mm lens. That's

0:35:58a lot lighter. I was just an idiot.

0:35:59- Yeah, and yeah, we have that 1.2L as well.

0:36:04Tiff bought it because you bought it, thanks a lot.

0:36:06- Well, I got it 'cause of Dr. Wave.

0:36:09- We can all blame Dr. Wave, thanks a lot.

0:36:11But yeah, and we also, before that, we had the 1.4,

0:36:15which was a $300 one, and it was totally fine.

0:36:18And in fact, in some ways, the Pro one was worse.

0:36:21'Cause not only is it bigger, heavier,

0:36:22and like four times the price,

0:36:24but it also, I think, focused a little bit more slowly.

0:36:27'Cause there was so much more glass to move.

0:36:29everything about it, it was worse in some pretty key ways,

0:36:33but the reason why pros would want that

0:36:35is because it was optically noticeably better,

0:36:38it could go down to 1.2 if you actually needed that,

0:36:41although almost nobody does.

0:36:42It was probably at least slightly weather sealed,

0:36:45which is another thing that the consumer lenses don't,

0:36:47they hardly ever are, and most people don't need that,

0:36:51but if you're shooting a sports game,

0:36:55you wouldn't be using a 50 millimeter prime,

0:36:56but assuming you were, a lot of pro contexts

0:36:59need, you know, weather sealing, more rugged abilities, different warranties, stuff like that.

0:37:03Trenton Larkin The big one on weather sealing for

0:37:05for pros are pros who go out in the field where there's dirt, sand, and things like that. And the

0:37:10weather sealing keeps stuff like that out. When you cannot, you're on assignment from

0:37:15National Geographic, and you're in the middle of desert in Africa, you can't get your lens fixed

0:37:22until you're gone. And it's, you know, you can't just like, oh, zip over to the camera shop and get

0:37:27a replacement. You need that reliability. Yeah, that example is a wonderful reason why this

0:37:33MacBook Pro keyboard is so problematic. I shouldn't speak so poorly of that 50mm lens,

0:37:38because what I should do is sell it, and here I am telling the people who are most likely to buy it,

0:37:43the listeners of my show, that I kind of think it's a waste of money. Because the other reason

0:37:46I regret it in hindsight is that the sensitivity of the ISO sensitivity of digital sensors continues

0:37:56to get so much better, so much faster,

0:38:00that even in just like 18 months after I bought that lens,

0:38:03like five or six years ago,

0:38:05I could get better low-light pictures

0:38:07with the lighter weight camera just by getting a new camera.

0:38:11(laughing)

0:38:12- Yeah, like I haven't shot anything below f/2.8 in years.

0:38:16- Right, well.

0:38:17- And even that, usually I'm up around like 4, 5.6

0:38:20because I'm much more likely to miss the focus slightly

0:38:24than I am to need the higher speeds.

0:38:27And so for me, it's much more important

0:38:30to set the aperture a little bit narrower

0:38:32to increase the chances that my subject will be in focus.

0:38:34- Anyway, to get back to MacBook Pros.

0:38:37MacBook Pros are being used by people in totally,

0:38:42like the iMac of the MacBook lineup

0:38:45are the lower end 13-inch MacBook Pros, right?

0:38:49They're the standard, just like a really nice

0:38:52retina display, fast MacBook computer,

0:38:57but they're called MacBook Pros,

0:38:59and I kind of feel that's boxed Apple into a corner.

0:39:03To go to this specific machine that I'm touching right now,

0:39:07the Core i9 highest end, 15-inch MacBook Pro,

0:39:11there is no real, there's no iMac Pro

0:39:15of the MacBook lineup anymore.

0:39:17There is no big jump like the way,

0:39:21in technical ways, the ways that the iMac Pro

0:39:24is truly remarkably capable compared to a high-end,

0:39:29regular iMac, there is no jump like that

0:39:32in the MacBook Pro lineup.

0:39:34- Well, maybe there kind of is.

0:39:35So there is no real equivalent to the iMac Pro

0:39:38in things like the Xeon CPU,

0:39:40like using a workstation grade processor and everything.

0:39:43Yeah, there is none of that,

0:39:44but in some ways you could argue that the 13 inch

0:39:48and 15 inch are much more like the 5K iMac.

0:39:51in the iMac Pro in the sense that they use high-end

0:39:54but mostly still consumer parts.

0:39:56But I wonder if things, obviously the touch bar,

0:39:59if Apple's keeping it around,

0:40:01honestly I still hope they don't,

0:40:02but if they are keeping it around,

0:40:04that is probably gonna be maintained as a Pro feature,

0:40:06although I honestly think that makes no sense as one.

0:40:09But what about things like the T2?

0:40:11'Cause the T2, they introduced it in the iMac Pro,

0:40:13now it's in the 13 and 15 inch touch bar with this ear.

0:40:17Maybe that doesn't go down the line.

0:40:19maybe the T2 is only like, you know, it has that, it has that faster disk controller,

0:40:26it has more advanced encryption and security, things like FileVault are like quote free

0:40:30now. So what if the T2 is the segmentation since like the Xeon can't be anymore? But

0:40:37you know, they still, if you're going to draw that distinction, I think the place you draw

0:40:41it right now is clear. The place you draw it right now is TouchBar and above is pro

0:40:46and escape and MacBook are not,

0:40:48which is just all the more reason why I think

0:40:52renaming the MacBook escape to MacBook,

0:40:55(laughs)

0:40:56that makes so much more sense than what they're doing now.

0:40:58Because right now, by having almost all of the laptops

0:41:03that are recent models be named MacBook Pro,

0:41:06it's like what would anger Merlin would be like

0:41:10if all the items in a to-do list were marked high priority.

0:41:14That's kind of how it is.

0:41:15It's like, these are all the best MacBooks.

0:41:17Well, no, they're obviously not.

0:41:18That's not how that works.

0:41:20You have to draw that line somewhere.

0:41:22And just saying that the bottom end one you have,

0:41:25this 12 inch one, just saying that is not pro

0:41:28makes no sense at all.

0:41:29- Right.

0:41:30To get into the specifics of this model,

0:41:35the thing that still has people,

0:41:38has, what is it, a Beezerner bonnet,

0:41:40is this idea that the Core i9 in this machine

0:41:44is not, even post bug fix, is not running,

0:41:48is not maintaining its highest base level of performance

0:41:52as long as it theoretically could,

0:41:55and as long as the same processor does

0:41:58in certain PC laptops that are typically described

0:42:02as gaming laptops because they're like five or six pounds

0:42:05and very thick because they have it,

0:42:07just cooling systems, it's all about cooling

0:42:10and to have a cooling system that can let it run

0:42:14at clock speeds that it's capable of,

0:42:18it is impossible in today's world

0:42:20to do it in this form factor.

0:42:21So in theory, what some people obviously

0:42:25are dying for Apple to do, and I don't think

0:42:27they're going to do, is make a thicker 15-inch,

0:42:29or go back to 17-inch, or something like that,

0:42:32to make a bigger, heavier system that can just,

0:42:34all I want is for it to run as fast as it can.

0:42:38- Yeah, and back when this controversy

0:42:42was erupting last week, I was more perturbed than I am now

0:42:46about the fact that it wasn't maintaining the base clock.

0:42:48Now I know more about how this stuff works

0:42:50than I knew last week, and now I know things like

0:42:54how modern Intel CPUs in the high-end laptop like this

0:42:58almost never can maintain their base clock

0:43:00for long periods of time.

0:43:01Almost all of them, even last year's models,

0:43:03like ever since Kaby Lake and now Coffee Lake,

0:43:06these processors are, because of Intel's problems

0:43:08moving away from 14 nanometer, these processors

0:43:11are cramming way more transistors

0:43:14and way higher clock speeds

0:43:15into this old manufacturing technology

0:43:18than what it was ever intended for

0:43:19and what these laptops were intended for.

0:43:21So Intel is really pushing the boundaries

0:43:23to try to get better performing chips out every year

0:43:27when they can't move forward on their process yet.

0:43:30That the laptops are having to deal

0:43:32with higher and higher thermals.

0:43:34And so part of my easing on my anger on this

0:43:39was just learning that, yeah,

0:43:41is actually not new, that many of the laptops recently can't maintain max base clock under

0:43:46parallel workloads for more than a half hour or something like that. But also I've learned

0:43:51that the PC world is having the exact same struggles. That like, it is, and this doesn't

0:43:55necessarily make it okay, but it is nice to know, like it isn't just Apple messing up

0:43:58here, that other PC laptops that are considered like thin lights that have these processes

0:44:05in them are actually in worse shape usually, that usually that either they cool it worse

0:44:10they're cooling these same chips at two roughly the same performance level, but with more

0:44:15noise. And so the only thing that Apple is not competing well against here is what you

0:44:21mentioned, basically, the gaming laptops, which are really like, they look ridiculous.

0:44:25I mean, I've never even seen one in real life. But I've seen like the pictures of like, they

0:44:28they're basically like an inch thick on the bottom. And they have these giant vents on

0:44:32all the sides. And they're apparently very loud, because of course, they'd have to fit

0:44:35it like a big fan. They have to be very loud. And so like, that's something that like, what

0:44:39- What aspect of that description

0:44:41is the most offensive to Apple?

0:44:44I don't know if Johnny Ive is a noise nut,

0:44:48but he probably is.

0:44:50That's one thing I don't know if I can say about him.

0:44:52We certainly know what his aesthetic tastes are.

0:44:55And thicker, heavier, big grill type vent.

0:45:00- Yeah, Apple's been doing very well

0:45:02for years on keeping their stuff quiet.

0:45:05They've been great on fan noise,

0:45:07and they'd be getting better and better at it.

0:45:09And so, that's why one of the reasons I'm so impressed

0:45:11by the iMac Pro is that it is silent

0:45:14with everything I throw at it.

0:45:16I've only heard of people saying if you max out

0:45:18the CPU and the GPU, then you can hear the fan.

0:45:21I've never done that.

0:45:22I just max out the CPU and the GPU sets mostly idle.

0:45:24So you can do whatever you want to the CPU and the iMac Pro

0:45:26and you won't hear it, it's fantastic.

0:45:28And so, yeah, those giant gaming laptops,

0:45:31that's not a product Apple's ever gonna make.

0:45:32Even if the market demands it,

0:45:34they will never be able to swallow their Apple-ness

0:45:37and make that, they would not do that.

0:45:40- I don't know if Johnny Ive in particular is a noise

0:45:42and I suspect he is,

0:45:43but I know that Apple institutionally is,

0:45:46and that's part of, one of the most fun things I've done

0:45:49in recent years was the behind the scenes tour

0:45:51of their audio testing lab,

0:45:53either right before or right after HomePod came out,

0:45:57I think right before.

0:45:58But you guys remember, it was earlier this year,

0:46:01like March I think, maybe February,

0:46:04a bunch of us in the media were invited to Apple and they gave us this tour of an entire building

0:46:10on, you know, right across the street from the old infinite loop, where all they do is test. I mean,

0:46:18they had all new rooms just for the HomePod, amazing new rooms that they built specifically

0:46:23and only for HomePod. But the whole room, the whole team started as a place where they took

0:46:31all of their products. They even tested the ambient noise that an iPod made back when

0:46:37the iPods made noise because they had hard drives, these little tiny microwave-sized

0:46:43anechoic chambers where they'd put an iPod and have it play and test to make it quiet.

0:46:48So the idea that they're going to make something that, fan noise aside, it'll run a Core i9 as fast

0:46:56as theoretically possible, that's never going to happen.

0:46:58- Yeah, basically, I think one of the conclusions

0:47:01I've come to with this whole i9 throttling thing

0:47:04is that laptops, if you want a very high performance laptop,

0:47:09it's a bigger compromise than it's ever been.

0:47:12Because you can't, in what people want in laptops,

0:47:16which is they want them to be as portable as possible,

0:47:18they want them to be reasonably lightweight,

0:47:20they don't want them to be super thick

0:47:21and covered in vents unless they're gamers,

0:47:22but that market is well served elsewhere.

0:47:25So what people want in a laptop is completely at odds with what a high performance system

0:47:30needs in terms of thermals, battery, power, and noise. And so the path to happiness in

0:47:38a laptop is either to go lower spec, I think, like make it not need to be so powerful and

0:47:46go with something like an eGPU if those are good. Although honestly, I can't back to that

0:47:49yet because it's too early to know whether those are actually good or whether there's

0:47:52annoyances or big limitations or bugs or whatever else.

0:47:55So who knows?

0:47:56But hopefully that'll pan out well.

0:47:58Or if you need all that power, really consider a desktop.

0:48:03'Cause desktops are so good now.

0:48:06And I feel like trying to,

0:48:08like the machine you have in front of you here,

0:48:09there's like maxed out i9 15 inch,

0:48:12has so many crazy compromises and limitations.

0:48:15If you actually need to use all the power it has,

0:48:18it's not fun.

0:48:20Like the only advantage it has

0:48:21as you can take it anywhere.

0:48:23And you can just have one computer

0:48:25and you can bring it on a plane

0:48:26and have all that power with you.

0:48:27And a lot of people need that

0:48:28and that's why they buy these things.

0:48:29But to me, the path to happiness on a laptop

0:48:31is closer to the middle of the lineup.

0:48:34- Yeah, tell your boss you need to upgrade to first class

0:48:36because you need to work on your 15-inch MacBook Pro

0:48:39while you're on the plane.

0:48:40It requires a business requirement.

0:48:42- And I hope you have seat power.

0:48:43- Right. (laughs)

0:48:46I guess if you need the power, yeah, you probably will.

0:48:49- I mean, battery life on these,

0:48:50like there was that controversy when they came out

0:48:51consumer reports and everything, but battery life

0:48:54on the modern laptops, what we have,

0:48:57we have laptops getting thinner and lighter

0:48:59and the batteries are shrinking because

0:49:01if you're just sitting around typing email

0:49:03and browsing the web, they're getting more efficient

0:49:04than ever, but if you're actually pushing that power,

0:49:07if you're actually using that processor, using the GPU,

0:49:10if you're pushing it, they have worse battery life than ever

0:49:13because they're designed for this low idle envelope

0:49:16and once you push it, once you're doing something with it,

0:49:19you're really having a problem with that battery

0:49:21if you're on a long flight with no power.

0:49:23- Yeah, although I will say in terms of battery life,

0:49:26this machine in front of me,

0:49:27I've been running on battery power

0:49:28ever since we came into Marco's office to record this show,

0:49:32and the battery meter still says 100%.

0:49:35Now I'm not pushing the limits of this.

0:49:37The show is being recorded into audio hijack

0:49:40over on Marco's iMac Pro.

0:49:42But I've got my, you know,

0:49:43I've got all my regular apps running,

0:49:46mail, Safari, lots of tabs, you know,

0:49:48and the display is on and fairly bright.

0:49:51and it still says 100%.

0:49:52- Yeah, because what you're doing there is typical,

0:49:55a light productivity workload, web browsing, email,

0:49:58stuff like that, and you're barely interacting

0:49:59with it at all, so that's even lighter.

0:50:02It's optimized for that, and the chips now

0:50:03are so good at power management when they're being

0:50:06lowly utilized, I guess, minimally utilized,

0:50:09then they're great at that, and it could probably

0:50:11last 15 hours like that.

0:50:12But if you try to export something from Final Cut,

0:50:16we'll have a very different story.

0:50:17- Yeah, and it's funny, we were talking about this

0:50:19off the show earlier, but in the days

0:50:21that I've been testing this machine here

0:50:23and seeing how the battery performs,

0:50:25I've rethought an assumption that I came up with

0:50:28a few years ago.

0:50:29So the last time I personally bought a MacBook

0:50:31was my mid-2014 13-inch MacBook Pro,

0:50:36and I just maxed out everything.

0:50:39I got the most RAM I could get,

0:50:4116 gigabytes, sounds terrible today.

0:50:43- That's still pretty good.

0:50:45- I got the fastest processor they sold at the time,

0:50:47and I think the max SSD, which was one terabyte.

0:50:52And it was all money well spent

0:50:54because here I am four years later still using it,

0:50:56still not really thinking about replacing it.

0:50:58That's my style of Mac, I buy a new iPhone every year,

0:51:01but my style of buying a Mac is to get one,

0:51:04only when I really feel like I need it,

0:51:05and then max it out and hopefully use it for many years

0:51:09'cause I just hate configuring a new machine just so.

0:51:13And I love having one,

0:51:15Like once I'm past like that year 18 month mark

0:51:18where I feel like any kind of lemon component might blow,

0:51:21I feel like this thing is reliable.

0:51:25And my 2014 MacBook Pro I've been raving about

0:51:28has never needed service for anything.

0:51:30Not one case of anything has anything ever gone wrong in it.

0:51:34So I love that.

0:51:35But I was thinking when I bought it,

0:51:38and battery life has been good,

0:51:40it's good enough that I'm still happy with it,

0:51:42but I never really pressed the CPU,

0:51:44and my thought was, I don't know why I maxed out the CPU.

0:51:47I don't do anything CPU intensive,

0:51:49or else I do it so seldom that it's not worth buying

0:51:54and getting what I presume to be worse battery life

0:51:58because I'm running a faster CPU than I need,

0:52:02whereas the baseline CPU,

0:52:03like I need the SSD versus the hard drive.

0:52:06I need the extra RAM because I'm such an idiot

0:52:09and keep dozens and dozens of Safari tabs open at all times.

0:52:14I don't need CPU. But I think you're right looking at this, that even with this Core i9, which in

0:52:19theory as a CPU could burn battery faster than any other CPU in the lineup just because it's got

0:52:26extra cores, you know, that's the nature of the fastest CPU. But here, when I'm doing my typical

0:52:31workload, here I am literally 55 minutes into running on battery, and the battery meter still

0:52:37says 100 percent. It still hasn't dropped to 99. So I think you're right, you know, that the power

0:52:43Power management when they don't need it is crazy.

0:52:46- Yeah, and I wouldn't worry that you're burning

0:52:48extra power when you're doing stuff like this,

0:52:50'cause I think the power management's good enough

0:52:51that you don't have to worry that if you buy

0:52:53the high-end CPU that your idle power will be much worse,

0:52:56'cause it won't be.

0:52:57But I think what we've seen a lot in the recent generations

0:53:01is we're limited so much by thermals

0:53:03that the difference between whatever comes

0:53:06in the base model of a given size laptop

0:53:09and whatever the highest CPU is

0:53:11is not as big of a performance difference

0:53:13you might think. Like usually it's within maybe 10, 15% from the base model to the highest

0:53:19end CPU, even if the advertised clock speed might be big, like it might say it might go

0:53:23from like 2.2 to 2.9. And so you'd think that would be a much bigger than 15% improvement.

0:53:29But in fact, you know, because of turbo boost, and you know, everything's so complicated

0:53:32now. Ultimately, if you're buying a new laptop, if you are concerned about bang for your buck,

0:53:39I would say get the most storage you can first,

0:53:42and then RAM is second priority,

0:53:44and only upgrade the CPU if you really are okay

0:53:48losing that money, because it matters so little.

0:53:50Most of the laptops I've had for the last decade,

0:53:53I've just had the base model CPU, and it's been totally fine.

0:53:55- I totally agree with that, and one thing

0:53:57that I probably would have said differently

0:53:58five or six years ago is five or six years ago,

0:54:01I probably would have said RAM first, storage second.

0:54:04But one of the differences between SSD and spinning disks

0:54:08is that if your machine does need to swap,

0:54:12which is when it starts writing stuff in memory to disk.

0:54:16Yeah, I say disk, but you know.

0:54:18With a hard drive, it was just awful.

0:54:22As soon as you went to swap, I could tell right away.

0:54:27I would just be like, oh, I need to quit Safari

0:54:30and relaunch it because I can tell it's swap.

0:54:32Whereas with SSD, of course SSD is not as fast as RAM,

0:54:36But it is fast enough that it's,

0:54:40I think you're right, prioritize SSD storage first,

0:54:43then RAM.

0:54:44- And also, I think the calculus changed also

0:54:46because back 10 years ago, if your hard drive was filled up,

0:54:49you could upgrade it.

0:54:50(laughing)

0:54:51For not that much money.

0:54:52And today, you can't upgrade any of these specs anymore.

0:54:56So to me, and because I've occasionally been impatient

0:55:00and just walked to an Apple store and bought the base model,

0:55:04then I've often had that 256 gig SSD.

0:55:07And man, it's like that killed the laptop for me.

0:55:11Like over time, what was the limiting factor

0:55:13that made me the most unhappy with it

0:55:15or made me have to jump through the most hoops

0:55:17or have the most limitations was disk space.

0:55:20And you can never upgrade it.

0:55:22So I kind of learned that lesson

0:55:24over two different laptops that I got that way

0:55:26and realized, okay, I'm now getting the 512 at least

0:55:29with whatever I do.

0:55:33All right, let's take another break here

0:55:34and thank our next sponsor.

0:55:36And our next sponsor is Mack Weldon.

0:55:40Mack Weldon's mission is simple,

0:55:41to make sure all of your basics and beyond

0:55:43are smartly designed and shopping from them

0:55:45is easy and convenient.

0:55:46What kind of basics are we talking about?

0:55:48We're talking about stuff like underwear, socks, T-shirts.

0:55:52They founded Mack Weldon because they wanted more

0:55:55out of the basics and they always questioned

0:55:57how something so essential could be such a pain

0:56:00in the ass to buy.

0:56:01The frustration was real in there.

0:56:03Eureka moment happened in an apartment store aisle full of brands that dominated their top drawer

0:56:09You know that the big-name ones the ones that advertise on TV

0:56:11Surrounded by a mind-numbing assortment of underwear and socks. They realized that consistent fit and quality

0:56:18We're really a game of roulette

0:56:20You could buy a pack of t-shirts and like one of them like the collar starts fraying like two times after your ward

0:56:25so they took matters into their own hands and they started from scratch and

0:56:30engineered even their own fabric.

0:56:32Mack Weldon stuff is not like white label stuff

0:56:35that they buy and just stick a Mack label label in,

0:56:37a Mack Weldon label in.

0:56:40They even engineered their own fabric.

0:56:43I've been wearing their stuff for years.

0:56:46I'm actually wearing a pair of Mack Weldon underwear

0:56:49right now, literally, as I record.

0:56:51- Me too, and I got one of their shirts on.

0:56:53- I do not have one of their shirts on,

0:56:55but I am just wearing a novelty T-shirt.

0:56:57So it's, I don't have an under,

0:56:58If I had an undershirt on, it would be one of theirs.

0:57:01And I love, I don't like V-neck t-shirts,

0:57:03but I love V-neck undershirts

0:57:05because then you don't see the shirt

0:57:07when you unbutton the top button.

0:57:09So I have an entire drawer

0:57:11full of white Mack Weldon V-neck t-shirts.

0:57:15I bought enough so that I would never have to worry

0:57:18that I don't have one on, or don't have one ready to go.

0:57:22Really great stuff.

0:57:24I have a ton of their socks.

0:57:26I don't even know if I could count

0:57:28how many of their socks I have.

0:57:30And I know it sounds stupid.

0:57:32There are just things that I've gone through life

0:57:34and I just never thought about.

0:57:35And I spent decades of my life never thinking about socks.

0:57:39But it's crazy because every single thing about,

0:57:43every single thing I own,

0:57:45I always want something that I think is excellent.

0:57:48Like I like nice watches.

0:57:50I like, I care about what brand hat I wear.

0:57:53I, you know, last time I bought a car,

0:57:55I spent an inordinate amount of time researching it.

0:57:59Well, why did I not think about socks?

0:58:01Having nice socks is so much more comfortable

0:58:05than having ratty old socks that are worn out.

0:58:08I don't know why I was like 40-something

0:58:12before I began caring about socks.

0:58:14- It's one of life's great pleasures

0:58:15to have really good socks and underwear.

0:58:17- It is amazing.

0:58:18And I spend large parts of my life

0:58:21typically not even leaving my house,

0:58:23and I just walk around wearing socks.

0:58:25It's the thing that's on my foot

0:58:26more than anything else in the world.

0:58:28Why not?

0:58:29It's really great stuff, and it really is easy to buy.

0:58:32So I think it's great products.

0:58:35Literally, they're being worn right now.

0:58:37I didn't even know Marco was wearing them.

0:58:38I didn't run this by him before I am, but there you go.

0:58:40- It's literally, the underwear is all I wear anymore,

0:58:43period, and the shirts, I'm probably wearing

0:58:45one of their t-shirts in the summertime,

0:58:48nearly 100% of the time, and in the wintertime,

0:58:50maybe half the time.

0:58:52If I could only keep one of their products,

0:58:54'cause there's a lot of places to buy socks,

0:58:56even though their socks are nice,

0:58:57but to me, the undershirts are the best.

0:58:59If I could only keep one,

0:59:00if you said you have to get rid of everything,

0:59:02it would be the V-Neck white undershirts,

0:59:04which are so comfortable.

0:59:06And I realize this now as I think about it,

0:59:09I haven't ordered them in quite a while.

0:59:11So the ones I have, and they all look brand new.

0:59:13- They hold up, yeah.

0:59:14- Yeah, so I'm thinking about that right now.

0:59:16I can't remember the last time I bought new stuff there.

0:59:17I should actually go to their website

0:59:19and see if they have anything new.

0:59:20but the white v-neck undershirts,

0:59:23they hold up tremendously.

0:59:24They, mine all look brand new.

0:59:25They hold their shape, really terrific stuff.

0:59:28So that's my very favorite product.

0:59:30Here's what you gotta do.

0:59:32You can get 20% off your next order with the code TALKSHOW.

0:59:37Know the, just TALKSHOW at the macweldon.com website.

0:59:43So there you go, macweldon.com.

0:59:48At checkout, the code is talk show,

0:59:50and you save 20% off your first order.

0:59:54I would use that code.

0:59:54I would load up if you need t-shirts and socks.

0:59:56Just load up, trust me, get a bunch,

0:59:59save 20% on your first order.

1:00:01You'll thank me later.

1:00:02My thanks to Mack Weldon.

1:00:04Let's get into specifics about this machine.

1:00:08I can't really do a full review.

1:00:09I think I've had a, I forget when I got this.

1:00:11I think Friday.

1:00:15So I've probably, this is probably my seventh day

1:00:17of using this machine.

1:00:19I did something new with this machine

1:00:21that I haven't done before out of what I think

1:00:23is an irrational fear.

1:00:25But for all of my years of testing MacBooks and stuff,

1:00:29I never used migration assistant to move stuff

1:00:34from an old machine.

1:00:35Nope, because--

1:00:36- How do you do it?

1:00:37Do you set up new every time?

1:00:38- Yeah, I have like this whole checklist in an Apple.

1:00:41So I have an Apple Note with what to do with a new Mac.

1:00:45and you get the new Mac and I'd set it up factory refresh

1:00:50and I'd sign in to iCloud.

1:00:52And so once I'm signed into iCloud

1:00:54and I'd go through the, you know,

1:00:56do you wanna send a developer information,

1:00:59all the things you gotta do.

1:01:00And you know, you wanna turn on Siri,

1:01:01you wanna set up touch ID, blah, blah, blah.

1:01:03Okay, and then it spins for a little bit.

1:01:05And then boom, you're at a default desktop.

1:01:08Right away, because you're signed into iCloud,

1:01:10your notes start filing in.

1:01:11And then I would go to Apple Notes, find that note,

1:01:14and start going through the list of things

1:01:16to install side by side.

1:01:18And I think that's partly explains why I hate

1:01:22getting a new Mac because it's a lot of work.

1:01:25So this time I was like, well, I'm going,

1:01:27this is gonna be great, I'm gonna be using,

1:01:28I'm going to Marco's for a couple of days next week,

1:01:32but I don't have a lot of time,

1:01:34so why don't I try migration assistant?

1:01:36And if I don't like it, I can wipe it clean.

1:01:37So I tried migration assistant.

1:01:39And I have to say, I'm pretty dumb

1:01:41for not having used it before.

1:01:42It's kind of amazing how much stuff moved over.

1:01:45Not everything, one thing that I'd noticed,

1:01:48or at least for me, I don't know if this is by design or not,

1:01:50but nothing that's a login item moved over.

1:01:52Like when it was done, it took like,

1:01:54and I just did it over WiFi at home,

1:01:56and it took about four hours

1:01:58with the two machines side by side.

1:02:01And when it was done and I logged in,

1:02:02this looks like almost identical to my 13,

1:02:07my personal 13-inch MacBook Pro, just on a 15-inch display.

1:02:11and almost all of my apps moved over.

1:02:14At least one of them, when I first,

1:02:17Fantastic Al for some reason, when it went to launch,

1:02:19said this app is damaged, move it to the trash

1:02:22and redownload from the app store,

1:02:23which I did and then it worked.

1:02:26I don't know what happened there.

1:02:28The only thing I noticed was that nothing

1:02:30that was a login item, the things that I have

1:02:33that launch automatically when I log in,

1:02:34none of them came over.

1:02:36I don't know if that's a security,

1:02:37I don't know if that's a bug,

1:02:38or if it's like a security thing or something.

1:02:40Could it be like a cruft reducer? Right? Over time that those things get all crazy?

1:02:44one of the things that moved over that I'm blown away by is a bunch of

1:02:49Pearl modules that I have installed non-standard pearl modules from the CPAN archive. I

1:02:56Couldn't believe that they moved over. I've got some services that do things automatically and some of them I know

1:03:01Rely upon modules you have to download

1:03:03And I don't do the thing like Syracuse if he's listening to this episode is going to cringe

1:03:09I don't do the thing that people Rex pearl experts recommend which is leave system pearl as it is and

1:03:17Use homebrew or something to install your own

1:03:20Personal version a second version of pearl or any other open source scripting language that you use

1:03:26Install your own and any kind of custom stuff you want to set up do it there and leave system pearl alone

1:03:31I don't do that. I just install CPAN levels in the system, but maybe I don't even remember

1:03:38Maybe when I set up my personal MacBook years ago, I did the thing where

1:03:43When I install CPAN modules at the terminal, they are still being put somewhere in a dot

1:03:50Directory in my home folder and so that migration assistant when it moved over my whole home folder

1:03:57It included all those weird Unix II

1:04:00dot whatever in

1:04:03quote-unquote invisible directories

1:04:06- Yeah, maybe.

1:04:07I mean, 'cause I don't think it moves over things

1:04:08that are in user local or anything like that.

1:04:11- Right.

1:04:11- I will say, I have had really good luck

1:04:14with migration assistant before.

1:04:16The only thing is, if you try to do it over Wi-Fi

1:04:19or over the network, it's usually terrible.

1:04:21But if you can find a way to do it over a cable in some way,

1:04:23like if you must wire Ethernet,

1:04:26but even better than that is Thunderbolt

1:04:28to target disk mode.

1:04:30If you can do that, it's usually pretty reasonable,

1:04:33time-wise, it usually finishes without problems.

1:04:35It's pretty good.

1:04:36I've had very few failures.

1:04:38- It did move over user local bin.

1:04:41- That's interesting.

1:04:42- 'Cause I have not installed Homebrew on this machine

1:04:44and I just typed which brew

1:04:45and it says user local bin brew.

1:04:48So it did move over that.

1:04:49It's amazing.

1:04:50- So yeah, so maybe it moves over user local

1:04:52but just not user, you know, so that way like,

1:04:55maybe that's why you're supposed to use your local

1:04:57on Mac for stuff like that.

1:04:58- So I don't know if this is a recent thing.

1:04:59I don't know if I've been missing out on this for years.

1:05:02I don't know if the,

1:05:03But whoever inside Apple is responsible

1:05:06for migration assistant, moving over so much of this stuff,

1:05:10I thank you sincerely because I really spent

1:05:14almost no time whatsoever configuring this machine

1:05:17before leaving for this trip.

1:05:18And it's done everything I've needed to.

1:05:21I brought my personal MacBook Pro as a backup

1:05:25just in case I got here and I needed it for some reason

1:05:27and I haven't needed it for anything.

1:05:29It's really remarkable.

1:05:30So anybody else out there with my same irrational fear

1:05:34that migration assistant is going to leave me

1:05:37with more work to do than doing it all by hand,

1:05:40give it a try next time.

1:05:41I mean, the worst that happens is you just wipe it

1:05:43and start over, but I was blown away.

1:05:45- Yeah, I think a lot of that comes from,

1:05:47like, and because I've used migration assistance for years,

1:05:49and I've only done a very small number

1:05:52of clean installs on my Mac ever.

1:05:54Like, it's probably like less than four

1:05:57in the 12 years or 14 years I've been using Macs full time.

1:06:02And so it almost always means migration

1:06:05is just to move stuff, and it's great.

1:06:07I think a lot of that fear comes from Windows switchers,

1:06:10like me, because Windows always had upgrade install

1:06:13versus clean install, and the upgrades and migrations

1:06:16for Windows were, at least back when I was using Windows,

1:06:19horrible, incredibly unreliable.

1:06:22It was almost always a bad idea to do anything

1:06:24but a clean install.

1:06:26Yeah, but Windows even had the or still has I don't even know but had the reputation that

1:06:30even if you're not moving to a new machine, your existing installation is going to dissolve

1:06:35over time. Oh, yeah, I read like, just part of like a thing that computer geeks had to

1:06:39do and probably still do like, I had to reformat and start my windows installation clean, I

1:06:45think about every year or so. Right. So why would you move an installation to a new machine

1:06:49when you're going to have to reinstall on your regular machine anyway? Exactly. It was

1:06:53it was like recreation, like you defrag your disk

1:06:55and then every once a year you reformat

1:06:57and reinstall Windows for fun.

1:06:58- I don't have any experience with Windows.

1:07:00I mean, I've used Windows, seriously,

1:07:03well over a decade ago now, so it's ancient.

1:07:06But even back then, I never was a regular Windows user,

1:07:09never owned a Windows machine.

1:07:11I just think, I think it's based on the fact

1:07:13that maybe even going back to the classic Mac OS era,

1:07:17the migration assistant didn't work well,

1:07:19or wasn't good enough for me.

1:07:21I don't think it's completely without some experience

1:07:26trying Apple's, okay, you have a new Mac,

1:07:28let's copy stuff from your old Mac.

1:07:30I don't know if they always called it Migration Assistant,

1:07:32but at some point I tried it,

1:07:34but literally it might be 15, 20 years ago,

1:07:35and it might even be back in the classic era,

1:07:39and it just was completely unsatisfactory.

1:07:42- Yeah, I mean, my experience with it

1:07:44has been basically like, if you want a clean install,

1:07:47just like for organizational purposes,

1:07:48or to try out new ways of doing things, or whatever,

1:07:51Go for it, that's fine.

1:07:52But migration assistant is so good

1:07:54that you don't need to really ever do that.

1:07:56It's totally optional.

1:07:58If you don't want a clean install,

1:07:59you never have to do one.

1:08:01- Yeah, and you know what, I'm thinking about it.

1:08:03Even things like my shell.

1:08:04So I've never really learned a bash.

1:08:09I can use it, but I'm not a bash expert.

1:08:12I never had a super complicated bash RC file.

1:08:17So I switched to Fish at some point in the last year.

1:08:22And I find it to be very fun,

1:08:24and I love that it doesn't have all these

1:08:2650-year-old Unix conventions.

1:08:29And it's my default shell on this machine.

1:08:33So without me doing it, when I opened Terminal,

1:08:37it still is the same default as the last machine.

1:08:39So somewhere within Apple,

1:08:41somebody cares about the 1% of Mac users

1:08:44who do things like install stuff and use their local bin.

1:08:47I bet it's actually well less than 1%.

1:08:49Right, I'll bet it is.

1:08:51But because I'll bet that 1% includes the sort of people who are engineers on the migration assistant team,

1:08:58there's a high likelihood somehow somebody did the work for that, and I appreciate it.

1:09:03It's a lot of pros. A lot of pros are developers.

1:09:07A lot of developers put their, especially web developers, put even more stuff there.

1:09:11And that's a pretty big market for the MacBook Pro and Macs in general.

1:09:15That's actually, you know, that's something

1:09:17that they should do, so yeah, I'm glad they do.

1:09:19- Other than that, I love the machine.

1:09:22Right now, it's still, it has dropped below 100%.

1:09:25We're at 98% battery life.

1:09:29It is-- - Thrilling.

1:09:31- It is absolutely cool to the touch,

1:09:34even right at the base of the display

1:09:36where it gets hot faster.

1:09:38It runs very cool when you're doing minimal work.

1:09:41The display is lovely.

1:09:43True Tone works exactly as I expected it to,

1:09:47which is I've already forgotten it's there.

1:09:49(laughing)

1:09:50But then when I look, like my son brought his laptop

1:09:52on vacation, when I look at his screen

1:09:54in certain lighting conditions here,

1:09:55I'm like, oh my God, that looks terrible.

1:09:58(laughing)

1:09:59So I'm already ruined by True Tone.

1:10:02That's probably gonna be the single hardest thing

1:10:04about going back to my machine from this,

1:10:06and probably the single thing that might tempt me to update.

1:10:09- Yeah, I mean, why go back?

1:10:11Because now you know Migration Assistant works.

1:10:12You're gonna be buying every laptop. I know I know I know I might get on like an iPhone like year over year system

1:10:18You know with the iPhone I'm still running my iPhone right here in front of me has been updated

1:10:24Ever since the original iPhone 10 years ago, or I guess 11 years ago at this point, right?

1:10:302007 so like starting with my original iPhone in 2007

1:10:34I've bought a new iPhone for myself every year and every time I have updated from what it was

1:10:42which is kind of amazing in terms of old school experience.

1:10:47Even on the Mac side, it just didn't seem like

1:10:49that was a good idea to just keep buying new things

1:10:51and keeping a system going from 11 years ago.

1:10:56- Yeah, although I think I kept my first installation

1:10:58going for like seven or eight years, it was something crazy.

1:11:01But, and with iPhones it makes more sense

1:11:03because with iPhones, you get a lot more

1:11:04year over year change.

1:11:06And even though that's in some ways,

1:11:08and like some years that kind of is a little bit slower

1:11:10than others in recent times,

1:11:11it's still way more year over year change

1:11:13than you get on the Mac side.

1:11:14You know, like these, like if you have a,

1:11:17like you know, 2016 MacBook Pro,

1:11:20you know, then the 2018s, it's two more years on the iPhone,

1:11:24that would be a really big, nice jump.

1:11:26On the Mac, the 2018s are gonna be, you know,

1:11:2950% better at most on certain tasks,

1:11:32and in some ways, on most tasks,

1:11:35not nearly that much better,

1:11:36like it'll be a little bit better, a little bit nicer,

1:11:38but you know, largely the same experience.

1:11:40So single thing I like most is the display because it has true tone

1:11:46The single thing I like least is the keyboard because I just it just feels weird

1:11:52I can't get used I can I don't hate it

1:11:55And I remember from when I tested when the when these MacBook pros first came out in 2016 November 2016

1:12:02I I got Apple it sent me like three of them. I said I got like the escape

1:12:07I got a 13 inch with touch bar and then a 15 inch with touch bar

1:12:11which

1:12:14was

1:12:15Discombobulating to my simple mind. How do I how do I test three laptops when they were staggered?

1:12:20Like everyone got right escape first to review the touch bar ones weren't ready even for reviewers

1:12:24Yeah, and then the tuckler came out like a couple of weeks later, right?

1:12:27Are you and but because there were three of them I spent longer than usual using it, you know

1:12:33And and I remember then I was like this is unfamiliar

1:12:37I don't like the keyboard feel wise and I kind of got used to it and I think I'm sure I would get used to this

1:12:43I'm sure I would but I one week in

1:12:46My fingers still feel like they're in a foreign country or something. It's it's it, you know

1:12:52Like I'm driving on the wrong side of the road. It doesn't feel right but

1:12:55There are other people here who have similar keyboards and I in terms of the volume, you know that this issue with hey

1:13:04This one's quieter because of the silicone membrane that they've added. There is no doubt in my mind that it's quieter

1:13:09It's quieter from my memory of using the keyboards in late 2016

1:13:14I mean, I know Joanna Stern and I did a podcast at some point where she she she really hated the noise that those keyboards made

1:13:22I can't wait to talk to her was really bad

1:13:24It was it was like it was like tapping on an upside-down bucket

1:13:27Yeah, it was so just like cheap and crappy sounding and the other keep in mind. They did change it in the 2017 also

1:13:34Yeah, I didn't say anything but the 2017 were a little bit quieter

1:13:37I didn't get one of those to test but I had I did do the typical

1:13:42Apple podcaster thing which is wander into an Apple store and

1:13:46Just start typing on one

1:13:48Yeah

1:13:49we're very good at that right and it's weird because I go in and I realize I look like a crazy person because I'm

1:13:53Not looking at the display. I'm like, you know like just so that I can concentrate on what it sounds and feels like

1:13:59I'm just sort of staring into space and I'm staring straight ahead

1:14:03Yeah, you know because it's like I'm just you know, looking at one of the white spaces in the Apple Store, you know

1:14:09Into the Johnny into the Johnny I've void where my visual field isn't really I'm just it's all about the feel and the listening

1:14:17But it was said that was a subtle change. Whereas this is clearly a new keyboard and I think it's better

1:14:24I definitely do I think it's quieter and I think it even feels better. So

1:14:29I

1:14:31You know one of my questions was with this silicone thing everybody of course you know

1:14:35There's this whole thing about the egress. You know it that that little pieces of dust would get into your keyboard

1:14:42You know this is one of the biggest Apple scandals of the last year

1:14:45a little bit of dust gets in your keyboard and all of a sudden one of the keys get stuck and

1:14:49Apple you know it's to me embarrassing

1:14:52I mean everybody knows this is embarrassing that Apple even has commissioned

1:14:56You know a nice Apple style professional illustrators

1:15:00to draw a diagram of the exact 43 degree angle you should hold the MacBook with while you

1:15:09spray it with a can of compressed air. Right? Like the fact that this wasn't just like a

1:15:16word of mouth thing, like you go in the Apple store and they tell you know, like zapping

1:15:20PRAM or something like that all these, you know, little bits of tech tech support advice

1:15:25that float around and say, Oh, yeah, just try a can of air or whatever, like Apple had

1:15:28to actually make it a major illustrated support document. The fear that common sense would say,

1:15:36"Well, what if they added this silicone layer specifically to combat this egress thing

1:15:43that was getting these keys stuck and was turning into a support and publicity nightmare for the

1:15:49the company. Surely, they've spent way more money than they wanted to on repairing these

1:15:58keyboards. And publicity-wise, it's probably even more of an expense. It's one of the

1:16:04worst cases of bad publicity that they've had in recent years. Well, what if they added

1:16:07the silicone layer to keep out the dust and keep the keyboard working, but what if it

1:16:13makes the keyboard worse?

1:16:14- Right, I mean, that was a, you know,

1:16:17and I still haven't spent meaningful time

1:16:18with One Yacht 'cause mine's on here yet,

1:16:20but like, it's, the keyboard is already just like,

1:16:24barely good enough feeling for most people.

1:16:28Most people either like it or don't care,

1:16:32but it's dealing with such tiny tolerances of like,

1:16:35these keys barely move, it barely feels like

1:16:38you're pushing something down.

1:16:40Like, if they reduce that, there's not a lot of room

1:16:42to reduce that, and so certainly a big risk of this

1:16:46is that it makes it feel worse at the expense

1:16:49of making it more durable.

1:16:50So you're saying you don't think it feels worse?

1:16:52- No, I think it feels better.

1:16:55I think it feels better than the ones without the membrane.

1:16:58So there's three generations.

1:16:59There's the first generation.

1:17:01I think that that includes the MacBook One,

1:17:05or maybe they're only talking about MacBook Pro.

1:17:06- The MacBook One, well, so the 2015 MacBook One

1:17:10had a version of this keyboard that basically,

1:17:12Like they all have the exact same travel.

1:17:15But the very first one had like no kickback on the keys.

1:17:19And so it felt even worse than these.

1:17:20- Yeah, it felt like dead.

1:17:22- Yeah, the 2016, when they put the MacBook Pro generation

1:17:26with this keyboard, it added this big, strong

1:17:29kickback feeling which also made that horrible noise.

1:17:32But it did make it feel less crappy.

1:17:35- Well, what I'm questioning is Apple describes

1:17:38this keyboard, this one with the silicone layer,

1:17:40as third generation.

1:17:42but are they only counting MacBook Pro keyboards,

1:17:45as in 2016 was first generation?

1:17:48- No, no, no, when they introduced 2016s,

1:17:50they called this the second generation butterfly keyboard.

1:17:52- Okay. - 'Cause the first generation

1:17:53one, by their naming, was the one in the 2015 MacBook.

1:17:56- All right. - Then the second generation

1:17:58is technically 2016 and 2017 MacBook Pros,

1:18:01even though they're different,

1:18:02and then the third generation is the 2018 one.

1:18:04- Right, so to go to software numbering lingo,

1:18:07it would be like the 1.0 was the 2015 MacBook One,

1:18:122.0 is 2016 MacBook Pros 2.1 was the 2017 MacBook Pros and this is 3.0

1:18:19Yeah, yeah, I like this one better. I just no question in my mind one weekend. I like it better and

1:18:24the things that I don't like are are

1:18:29Endemic to it. I don't like the less travel

1:18:34But that might just be that I'm not used to it yet

1:18:38I'm willing to concede that if given enough time with it as my main machine

1:18:41I might grow to appreciate it because I you know

1:18:44I remember thinking the same thing every single time Apple makes their machines thinner every single time

1:18:49They radically changed their laptop keyboards

1:18:52I don't like it because there's always less travel because they're always making them thinner and so they have to reduce the travel because

1:18:58You you have to reduce the travel on the keyboard to make the machine thicker. It's just simple

1:19:03three three-dimensional spatial reality

1:19:08You know in terms of feel I still like the way like, you know, like a 15 year old power book feels

1:19:14Because it's you know, got some click

1:19:17So I pretty you know, but I'm realistic. I don't expect a Apple extended keyboard to

1:19:23Mechanical keyboard on a laptop. I realize it's physically impossible. So I realize there's less trouble and every time you would totally buy it

1:19:29If it was oh, yeah

1:19:31So the travel, you know the travel is the travel there's nothing they can do about it I

1:19:37- I find, well. - Okay.

1:19:39I'll let that go for this.

1:19:42- Right, well, there's nothing they could do

1:19:43other than to make the machines thicker, in theory.

1:19:46Although-- - Well, maybe not.

1:19:48Honestly, maybe not.

1:19:49Maybe they could just,

1:19:51'cause there are a lot of PC laptops

1:19:53that have a similar overall thinness and profile

1:19:57where the Keytrap,

1:19:58where it has more traditional style keyboard.

1:20:01- Yeah, I guess I shouldn't say that.

1:20:02And I also know that there are people who prefer this.

1:20:07- A good amount of them, actually.

1:20:08- Right, a good amount of people genuinely prefer it.

1:20:10The thing that I find hard to get used to,

1:20:12and I remember this from 2016 too,

1:20:14is that the key caps are physically bigger.

1:20:17So the keys are bigger, and there's less space between keys.

1:20:22The keyboard itself isn't bigger.

1:20:24They've just reduced space between keys

1:20:26and used that extra space to make the keys bigger.

1:20:29And for some reason, even though it shouldn't,

1:20:32because the center of every key

1:20:34is still in the same position,

1:20:36it feels to me like I have to spread my fingers wider.

1:20:40And my hands feel weird right now

1:20:43because before we started recording the show,

1:20:45I was writing a bunch of emails

1:20:47and posting a few things to Daring Fireball,

1:20:49so I was typing.

1:20:50And my fingers feel like I've spread them out,

1:20:53like webbed out my fingers.

1:20:55They just feel a little sore like that.

1:20:57And that doesn't make any sense

1:20:58because the center of every key

1:21:00is still the same distance apart.

1:21:01And I think it's something

1:21:03that I would clearly get used to.

1:21:05If I used this for a month and then went back

1:21:07to my 2014 MacBook Pro, I would think,

1:21:10oh my god, why are these keys so close to each other?

1:21:13- So I've gone back and forth with this generation

1:21:15of laptops.

1:21:16(laughing)

1:21:19- That's a euphemistic way of describing your history.

1:21:21- Understatement maybe.

1:21:23But so when I've spent meaningful time with them,

1:21:25I have gotten used to the travel.

1:21:26I've never liked it, but I've gotten used to it.

1:21:30What gets me is the arrow key layout,

1:21:33not having the gaps above the left and right arrow keys.

1:21:36And 'cause like, so a combination of that

1:21:39and what you just described of like the margin

1:21:41between the keys being thinner basically,

1:21:43that it makes it for me, for my hands,

1:21:45it makes it harder for me to orient myself by feel

1:21:49on the keyboard.

1:21:50It has, it feels closer to just a flat piece of glass.

1:21:55- The arrow key thing I'll never get used to.

1:21:57And it seems like this is, was not a temporary blip

1:22:02on Apple's design tastes, like they're all in

1:22:06on full-size left and right arrow keys

1:22:08and half-size up-down keys, but not having

1:22:12that upside-down T shape to orient by feel,

1:22:15I don't know that I'll ever get used to it.

1:22:16- Yeah, I make tons of mistakes on that.

1:22:19- I am literally thinking, and I swear to God,

1:22:21I am thinking, even if this were my machine that I owned,

1:22:25I might do it, but I'm seriously thinking

1:22:27about making half-height strips of gaff tape

1:22:32and putting them on the bottom of the left and right keys.

1:22:35I really am.

1:22:36- That's not a bad idea.

1:22:38- That's, gaff tape was--

1:22:39- It's just not a review unit.

1:22:40- Gaff tape is how I solved my problem

1:22:42with the orientation of the Apple TV remote,

1:22:46is I just put a belt of gaff tape

1:22:49around the bottom part of the Apple TV remote,

1:22:54and then I could run my fingers along the side,

1:22:57and when I feel the tape, I know which way it goes

1:22:59in the dark or without looking at it.

1:23:01And I kind of feel, you know, gaff tape,

1:23:04Marlon Mann introduced me to gaff tape.

1:23:05Gaff tape is one of the most amazing,

1:23:07anybody out there who doesn't have a roll of gaff tape

1:23:10in the house, go out, just go to Amazon

1:23:12and buy one right now, you'll thank me later.

1:23:14It is the most, it's the most amazing tape in the world.

1:23:17The name comes, I believe, from the movie industry.

1:23:21Gaffers are, I think, the people who like adjust the lights

1:23:24and stuff like that, like the lighting stands.

1:23:27And so they use this black tape.

1:23:29Once they get the light in the right position,

1:23:31they'll tape it down on the set so that it can't move.

1:23:34But gaff tape, unlike something like duct tape

1:23:38that's supposed to be permanent,

1:23:39when you peel, gaff tape is very strong and it holds.

1:23:43- It's cloth-like and field. - And it is cloth-like.

1:23:45And so you can rip it perfectly straight.

1:23:47- You can rip it by hand, you don't need scissors.

1:23:48- Right, you don't need scissors.

1:23:49You rip it straight.

1:23:52It's easy to rip and it holds as much as you want,

1:23:56but then when you unpeel it,

1:23:57there's almost no residue or no residue.

1:24:00- So my concern on putting it under the arrow keys

1:24:04is that you might get some on the screen.

1:24:05- Right, exactly, I would have, but it would be,

1:24:08well, it would kind of be in the middle of the screen.

1:24:10So there'd be, that's exactly my thought,

1:24:12'cause it would absorb finger oil

1:24:14and then there'd be two little oily spots on the screen.

1:24:17But I clean my screen regularly

1:24:19because I'm very sensitive to,

1:24:22I'm actually appalled at how many tiny little smudges

1:24:25I've gotten on this machine in the last week.

1:24:28- Maybe one of those people who has those

1:24:29like microfiber cloths that you put over the keyboard

1:24:31when you close the laptop?

1:24:32- I used to use one of those.

1:24:33I forget when I stopped, but it used to be,

1:24:36I forget what generation of,

1:24:40it was probably in the PowerBook era,

1:24:41but up until a certain point in the PowerBook era,

1:24:44it was inevitable that you would get keyboard-shaped marks

1:24:48on the display.

1:24:50- Well, no, see that was--

1:24:51- Just by closing the display.

1:24:52- It wasn't inevitable because,

1:24:54I just talked to this on ETP last night.

1:24:57So if you put it in a bag where there was something

1:25:02on top of it where you'd carry it

1:25:03so that it would compress it slightly,

1:25:05if there was any pressure applied to that top screen lid,

1:25:08it would contact the keyboard.

1:25:10But if there was no pressure squeezing it closed more,

1:25:15it wouldn't touch, 'cause I had a G4 aluminum power book,

1:25:18and I heard about this and so I basically constantly

1:25:20arranged my bags such that it would never get pressed on

1:25:24and I never had those marks.

1:25:25And everyone else I knew had them and mine was perfect.

1:25:27- I didn't know about that, but back in that era,

1:25:29I didn't worry about it 'cause I just used

1:25:31the microfiber cloth that covered the keyboard

1:25:33every time I shut the device.

1:25:36I guess I kinda knew that 'cause I guess I only used that

1:25:38when I put it in a bag.

1:25:40I guess in two, I had never really thought about it

1:25:42consciously, but if I was only closing it to keep it

1:25:44on a desk, just closing it for privacy reasons

1:25:46or just to shut it down, I wouldn't do it every time.

1:25:50I would only use that go-between-the-keyboard-in-the-screen

1:25:54rag, 'cause that's basic.

1:25:56We get fancy at all microfiber cloths.

1:25:59It was a rag.

1:25:59- Yeah, it's a really thin rag.

1:26:01- It was a nice rag, a very nice rag.

1:26:03- Probably a very expensive little nice rag.

1:26:05- Right.

1:26:06- No, I always want to be one of those people.

1:26:07I never actually have the dedication to the idea

1:26:10to actually do it, but I always kinda envy

1:26:13how good people's computers end up looking

1:26:15when they are those people.

1:26:17But so I'm curious, so the AirKey thing aside,

1:26:22as the keyboard picky individual that you are,

1:26:25would you ever, like, would you be okay

1:26:28with this keyboard long-term?

1:26:29Like, you know, basically where we are now in the lineup,

1:26:32it looks like this is, we're kind of,

1:26:33you're kind of stuck with this forever now, so.

1:26:35- Yeah, I could live with it.

1:26:36And there are parts that I like,

1:26:37I genuinely admire and appreciate at a mechanical level

1:26:41and the way it feels, the way that with these

1:26:43butterfly switches, no matter where on the key you press,

1:26:47the entire key moves down completely flat, right?

1:26:51That's new, and no other laptop keyboard

1:26:56I've ever seen does that, and when I do use this

1:26:59for a while and go back to my previous generation keyboard,

1:27:03I still am not used enough to this

1:27:05that I don't appreciate the other one overall,

1:27:08but I'm blown away at how wiggly the previous

1:27:11generation keyboard feels.

1:27:12It's like I cannot believe how these keys wiggle

1:27:14on an Apple laptop.

1:27:15- See, I can see that and I can feel that,

1:27:18but to me I just don't care at all.

1:27:19Like it's like they solved a problem

1:27:20that I would never have cared about.

1:27:22But I'm also here, it's like the arrow key thing to me,

1:27:25like it's, you know, the shape of those arrow keys

1:27:27not being full height, like it's unnecessary

1:27:30as far as I can tell.

1:27:30Like I don't think there's any structural reason

1:27:32why they can't have more metal there

1:27:33to make that just the T-shape.

1:27:35It seems like it's purely an aesthetic choice.

1:27:37And honestly, that would make me like 50% happier

1:27:42with this keyboard if they just return the inverted T shape

1:27:45to the arrow keys.

1:27:46- Absolutely, if there's one thing I could change

1:27:47on the keyboard, it would be the upside down T.

1:27:51Even the touch bar, I don't really mind the touch bar

1:27:53as much as, I don't really like it, I can't say I use it

1:27:55a lot, but I've never owned one on my personal machine

1:27:58and really gotten into a workflow with it.

1:28:00But I don't use function keys much either.

1:28:03- Once I remapped escape to caps lock on all my keyboards

1:28:06everywhere, which took about a week to get used to,

1:28:08the touch bar stopped bothering me.

1:28:09I still don't want it, but I'm gonna have it now

1:28:13and I know that it'll be fine.

1:28:15- Yeah, I don't know, I guess I could think about that.

1:28:19- It's really, it's not that bad.

1:28:21- How did you ever do that?

1:28:21Did you do that in a system preferences?

1:28:23- Yeah, it's in the modifier keys window,

1:28:25so you would never know 'cause you use Apple keyboards.

1:28:27But if you ever wanna use a PC keyboard on a Mac,

1:28:29you have to usually swap command and option on one of them

1:28:32'cause like, use the Windows key.

1:28:34- When I plug my extended keyboard too into a new machine,

1:28:37I don't have to switch anything,

1:28:39but I have to identify it in the way that they're like,

1:28:42I don't know what this is.

1:28:43Type the key next to the left shift key and Z.

1:28:46And they're like, oh, okay, I got it.

1:28:47I see where I am.

1:28:48- Now this is different.

1:28:49Like PC keyboard, basically they use the Windows key

1:28:52to be what command is on the key code map.

1:28:54So you gotta switch those.

1:28:55But in that same window in system preferences,

1:28:57keyboard modifier keys, you can set caps lock to be escape.

1:29:01- See, what I would be tempted to wanna do,

1:29:03and I'll bet it doesn't support it,

1:29:04as I would be tempted to turn the back tick key to escape

1:29:09and turn caps lock into the back tick tilde key.

1:29:13'Cause I almost never type back lock or tilde,

1:29:16but my instinct to go top left for escape

1:29:20is impossible to override.

1:29:21I think it would take me forever

1:29:23to get used to caps lock as escape.

1:29:25But turning-- - Honestly, try it.

1:29:26It's super fast, 'cause one thing that's great about it

1:29:28is that you can hit it with your pinky.

1:29:31Like, you don't have to move up the home row to hit escape,

1:29:32so it's like, if you're like, you know,

1:29:33quickly dismissing a dialogue or something,

1:29:35it's really nice.

1:29:35- Right, well that's like those people who,

1:29:37the people who are used to the old Unix convention

1:29:39of where caps lock is, making that the control key.

1:29:42- Yeah, exactly, same reason.

1:29:43- And the way that all the, there's a whole slew of,

1:29:46move the insertion point, cursor,

1:29:49whatever you wanna call it, with control, whatever,

1:29:51that having it just one little thing away

1:29:54from the A key for your pinky is super convenient.

1:29:56- Yeah.

1:29:57- Yeah, I can't believe I'm thinking about

1:30:01solving a problem on a,

1:30:03This is literally like what like a $5,000 laptop.

1:30:06'Cause it does--

1:30:07- I mean look, if you're gonna try the tape trick,

1:30:08try it on Apple's laptop, not yours.

1:30:10- The machine that they sent me is the Core i9

1:30:12with the fastest processor, 32 gigs of RAM,

1:30:16and the only thing that's not tippity top, tip top shape

1:30:19is they gave me a measly two gigabyte.

1:30:22- Two terabyte. - Two terabyte SSD,

1:30:24not the four terabyte SSD.

1:30:26- Only the $2,000 one instead of the $4,000 one.

1:30:30- Right, that's the only thing missing from this.

1:30:33Here's my rationale for this.

1:30:34Number one, Apple won't care.

1:30:36Number two, I'm guessing when they get a review unit back,

1:30:40they probably treat it the same way as they should return,

1:30:42which means it's sent for refurbishment.

1:30:44- No. - No?

1:30:45- No, well, I don't know this.

1:30:48I can't verify it 'cause I haven't seen it,

1:30:50but I believe for, I don't know if it's tax purposes,

1:30:55I don't know if it's accounting purposes, some kind,

1:30:57I don't know if it's really legal, if it's just policy,

1:30:59but I've been told that when they get a review back,

1:31:03I don't know, do they trash it?

1:31:05I just, I've been told that they wipe it

1:31:07and then treat it like a prototype.

1:31:11I don't know.

1:31:12- That's interesting, because normally,

1:31:14if you return one to a store,

1:31:16they don't go resell that to somebody else.

1:31:18As far as I know, they send it in for refurbishing,

1:31:20and refurbishing, they usually, I think they have to

1:31:24replace any component that people touch

1:31:26on the outside of it.

1:31:27So I think, this is right into John if I'm wrong,

1:31:31I think they actually replace all the casing

1:31:34and keyboard and everything,

1:31:35and I think the only parts they refurbish

1:31:36are like the internals, right?

1:31:37And so if that's true, you can put as much tape

1:31:40on this keyboard as you want.

1:31:41- I guess now that I think about it,

1:31:43I don't, I shouldn't say that they don't refurbish.

1:31:45All I know is they do promise that the first thing they do

1:31:48when a review unit gets sent back is wipe it clean.

1:31:52You know, and they say this in a way like,

1:31:54you don't even have to worry about wiping it.

1:31:55Trust us, we'll wipe it.

1:31:56I still wipe 'em before I send it back, but.

1:31:59- Yeah, 'cause that would also, you know,

1:32:00So if it is refurbishment, that's gotta be a part

1:32:02of the same process, right?

1:32:03- Yeah, yeah.

1:32:03But I still can't believe that on a 5,000,

1:32:06I think this is a $5,000 config.

1:32:08- Something like that, yeah.

1:32:10- That I'm thinking about solving a problem with gaff tape.

1:32:13But it really does drive me nuts.

1:32:15And 'cause I just, and I don't look.

1:32:17I mean, who looks?

1:32:18You just go, like part of the reason the arrow keys

1:32:20are down there in the bottom right is it's like this super,

1:32:23it's like a Fitz's Law thing, you know?

1:32:26- Yeah.

1:32:27- By putting it in the corner, you just,

1:32:29It's so easy to get your fingers there,

1:32:30and all of a sudden I'm like, what key is this?

1:32:32Even the new gap between the up and down keys

1:32:36is harder to feel the difference between.

1:32:39- Because it's shallower.

1:32:39And even for me, where the keyboard ends

1:32:43and the rest of the case begins,

1:32:44the corners and the edges around the keyboard,

1:32:47where it's kind of sunken in slightly

1:32:49to accommodate the keyboard depth,

1:32:51because the keyboard depth has changed,

1:32:53that little sunken in area around the keyboard

1:32:56is now shallower.

1:32:57And so even that is harder to feel,

1:32:59like at the corner of the keyboard.

1:33:01So when you're reaching for that right arrow key,

1:33:03you used to be able to kind of just move your hand

1:33:05until you could feel that edge of the keyboard.

1:33:07- But it's not just shallower between the up and down.

1:33:10There's no longer a strip of aluminum between them either.

1:33:12- There hasn't been for a while.

1:33:13- Oh, I thought there was.

1:33:14- No, but they kind of bend down.

1:33:16They form like two little valleys

1:33:17between the up and down. - All right.

1:33:18Well, then it's just the shallower.

1:33:19- It's a shallower, yeah.

1:33:20- Even that is harder to feel, and it drives me nuts.

1:33:22And I'm never going to enjoy that.

1:33:24And I really, really wish they would go back

1:33:27to the upside down T and just accept

1:33:29the aesthetic unpleasantness of the half key height

1:33:33pieces of aluminum that are just naked

1:33:35above the up and down keys.

1:33:37- Yeah, if I was able to fix either,

1:33:40like if they would give me my magic wish

1:33:41and give me either more travel or inverted T arrows,

1:33:46I would pick inverted T arrows.

1:33:47- All right, what about inverted T arrows

1:33:49or a row of function keys instead of the touch bar?

1:33:53- Same decision, inverted key arrows.

1:33:55- Yeah, same here.

1:33:56Touch ID is nice to have, but I've been wearing my Apple Watch all week, so I don't even need it.

1:34:05And I can't help but feel, and I suspected it would feel the same way, after an entire,

1:34:12almost an entire year now, 10 months with an iPhone X in my pocket, I still feel like Touch ID on the

1:34:19MacBook Pro feels like I'm using ancient technology. Like, why can't this camera just look at me?

1:34:25You know, there's there's a very nice. There's doesn't even need a notch. There's a whole strip up here. They put whatever they want up there

1:34:32Why in the world doesn't this have face ID?

1:34:35Yeah

1:34:35The MacBook Pro still has substantial screen bezels like if you look at like the that that Huawei mate book X that they met

1:34:42The MacBook ripoff right I when I saw one in a Microsoft store

1:34:45I was actually very it kind of struck me like how cool it looked how futuristic it looked

1:34:50Because and that's the one like you saw like everyone saw on the verge a few months ago

1:34:54that's someone that has the webcam is in a pop-up function key really like hit

1:34:59like the middle key in the function row and it's actually like pop-up webcam

1:35:02that pops up so like it's it's it's it's ridiculous on a number of fronts like

1:35:06that but they did succeed in getting an edge to edge yes but the display you

1:35:11know they basically crammed like a roughly 14 inch display into a 13 inch

1:35:14body and it looks incredible and it's like otherwise it's the same dimensions

1:35:18is roughly in same weight roughly as the 13 inch MacBook Pro and it really does

1:35:23look great and I would love them to reduce the bezels at all in any way in the MacBook

1:35:27line because what you want, same thing with the phone, you want the biggest screen and

1:35:31the smallest laptop, right? And so any progress towards that would be great for the future.

1:35:35Well, and that brings me to one of the things that I genuinely dislike about this machine.

1:35:40And I've disliked it ever since they came out in 2016, which is that it now again, says

1:35:46MacBook Pro on the bezel. Yeah, when they and I was just talking, I had a Twitter discussion

1:35:52with some people today and some of them are like,

1:35:54I've never had one without that.

1:35:56And that's because you skipped

1:35:57the initial Retina MacBook Pros.

1:36:02So the-- - 2012s.

1:36:03- Yeah, the 2012s when the Retina MacBook Pros

1:36:06went to Retina, they no longer printed MacBook Pro

1:36:10on the bezel, it was just black, just black,

1:36:12more like an iPhone, like in a way that

1:36:15every other competitor, and it's always been baffling to me

1:36:19that Samsung would rip off, especially in like

1:36:22the iPhone 3G, 3GS era when the whole patent lawsuit came about and they had the phone

1:36:28that was held up in court and a Samsung marketing person couldn't tell whether it was an iPhone

1:36:333G or a Samsung phone. They tried to make their phones look so much like an iPhone,

1:36:37it was absolutely embarrassing for somebody who's not claiming to make counterfeit products.

1:36:44But they always insisted on printing their ugly-ass Samsung logo on the forehead or the

1:36:50chin. I don't know where they printed it, but somewhere on the front of the phone, they'd put

1:36:53a big old Samsung logo, and Apple never printed anything. And of course, never allowed the carriers

1:37:00to print anything on the actual face of the phone. I like that on my personal MacBook Pro so much,

1:37:07and I find this so distracting. And it's not like shiny, it's not white, it's gray, but my eyes just

1:37:14keep looking at it, and I just keep thinking, "Why? Why would you know?" Once you've got away

1:37:18from it and you just had that nice perfect black border, why would you do that? Like,

1:37:21it's just like with TVs, like, when you see a big screen TV and the way that bezels have shrunk on

1:37:29TVs, it's similar to the phones now where they couldn't, you know, even Samsung has stopped

1:37:33printing their name because they can't because they've got doesn't fit. It doesn't fit. Right.

1:37:37And TVs have gotten to that point. But having a distractive manufacturer name on the bezel of a TV

1:37:43is incredibly distracting. And you know, Apple wouldn't do it. I don't know why they went back

1:37:46to this on the MacBook Pro, but my theory is that it coincides with the fact that the top,

1:37:53the display is so thin now that they can't backlight the Apple logo.

1:37:56So it's--

1:37:57- Yeah, which, honestly, I kind of miss that still, but when I see now, when I see a mixed

1:38:03company laptop party going on, you see some that have the glowy one and some that don't.

1:38:07I do admit the glowy one does look old now, just 'cause that's what the old models have,

1:38:11but I do kind of miss that.

1:38:13- I miss it too, but I asked about it

1:38:16and it really wasn't like a,

1:38:19it was something that people from Apple seldom admit

1:38:25to anything like this, but they even said

1:38:27it wasn't really that we didn't want it

1:38:29or preferred not having it, it's just too thin,

1:38:32that we couldn't make the top that thin and backlight it.

1:38:35- Yeah.

1:38:36- You know, you need a light here for this and this.

1:38:38- Well, and like the extreme thinness of these,

1:38:42you know, the display lids on laptops now,

1:38:45I think that might cause problems

1:38:47for ever having Face ID in these things.

1:38:48- Yeah, that is possible. - You mentioned Touch ID

1:38:49earlier, and I kind of have a mixed opinion

1:38:53on Touch ID versus Face ID.

1:38:55Like, whenever I use Touch ID for something,

1:38:57now that I'm also accustomed to Face ID,

1:38:59like whenever I use Touch ID, I both think,

1:39:02oh, how quaint it's the past, and also,

1:39:04oh, that was fast and easy.

1:39:05(laughing)

1:39:06So I'm slightly torn on, 'cause like,

1:39:09I do, Face ID's mostly fine,

1:39:11but I do like with Touch ID not only how fast it is,

1:39:14but how the permission granting step

1:39:19is the same step as the authentication.

1:39:22With Face ID, it authenticates you,

1:39:24and then you have to confirm somehow,

1:39:25well, you know, double tap the side button

1:39:27or whatever else.

1:39:27With Touch ID, that's one thing.

1:39:29You put your finger on it,

1:39:30and that is both authenticating you

1:39:31and saying, I approve this transaction.

1:39:33- Have you used an iPhone with Touch ID recently?

1:39:35Did you install beta on it?

1:39:37- Yeah, it's fine.

1:39:38- I couldn't stand it. - It does feel old

1:39:40in the iPhone sense, but in the sense of

1:39:42authorizing purchases, it still feels nicer

1:39:46to me than Face ID.

1:39:48- The last few years, I have, every summer,

1:39:50I've done the same thing, which I've taken my,

1:39:53before I installed the iOS beta on my main phone,

1:39:59which I'm probably on the cusp of doing,

1:40:01because I feel like the betas have been really stable

1:40:03this year. - Oh yeah, it's fine.

1:40:05- But in the early betas, I would install them

1:40:07on a year old iPhone and put my SIM card in that

1:40:11and use that as my daily phone to see how the thing is.

1:40:14I tried that this year and the lack of Face ID

1:40:17drove me nuts and just, I've gotten so addicted to things

1:40:20like being able to look without unlocking it,

1:40:22just look and have my notifications go from

1:40:26not showing the text of the notifications to,

1:40:28okay, we see it's you, here's the text of the notifications

1:40:31and I can just read them.

1:40:32Like that feature alone, I can't live without.

1:40:35- No, I don't need that, I don't need that.

1:40:35I don't even know, 'cause like, my stuff is not that secure.

1:40:37Like, I don't need--

1:40:38- Oh, so you have the full text just right there

1:40:40when you wake it up?

1:40:41- I turned off attention detection also,

1:40:42'cause it made face ID more reliable and faster.

1:40:44Because again, it's like, I don't, it's never,

1:40:47the first time somebody like holds my phone up

1:40:48to my like sleeping face and it authorizes,

1:40:50then I'll turn it off.

1:40:51- I should think about that, 'cause I still--

1:40:53- It's never happened.

1:40:53- I still have the problem where my favorite sunglasses

1:40:55don't work with that.

1:40:57I should think about that.

1:40:58Maybe I'll turn off.

1:40:59- Yeah, I don't know if it'll fix that or not,

1:41:00but it certainly-- - I think it might.

1:41:01- It certainly makes it more forgiving.

1:41:02- Yeah, I think it would, 'cause I think the only thing

1:41:05the sunglasses block is the ability

1:41:06to see what you're looking at.

1:41:07I think that they get enough other data points

1:41:10from your nose and your cheeks and chin and et cetera.

1:41:13- What I miss, whenever I have to use Tiz's phone

1:41:15or something, 'cause she has an eight plus

1:41:17and I have the 10, and whenever I have to use her phone,

1:41:19what throws me off the most is not touch ID,

1:41:23but tapping the screen doesn't wake it up.

1:41:26- Right, right, oh, that drives me nuts.

1:41:28I can't use it, yeah.

1:41:29So I'm addicted to the 10, but I want face ID in this,

1:41:32but I think you're right that the thinness

1:41:33might be a problem.

1:41:34It might take longer than I fear for them

1:41:37to get the sensor array to be thin enough to fit there.

1:41:39- Well, and ultimately, they might never put Face ID

1:41:41in the MacBook. - Maybe.

1:41:42- Like Touch ID is fine for the context

1:41:46of unlocking a MacBook.

1:41:46In fact, in some ways, it's actually better.

1:41:49And it's also, you know, it's possible

1:41:51that they could put the Face ID camera and sensor

1:41:54in the Touch bar.

1:41:55It doesn't have to be in the screen lid.

1:41:57- Right. - You know,

1:41:58I don't think they would.

1:41:59I don't think they would want to spend the space,

1:42:00and I don't think they want to have

1:42:01a separate sensor area above the keyboard row there.

1:42:03But it doesn't necessarily need to be in the screen lid.

1:42:07But if it ever does go in the screen lid,

1:42:09that would be a heck of a feat of miniaturization

1:42:11because these things are so,

1:42:12like the screen lids are so thin.

1:42:13- Right. - And there's really

1:42:14no reason to make them thicker than they need to be

1:42:16just for a Face ID camera.

1:42:17- Yeah, I think the original story,

1:42:19I could be getting this wrong,

1:42:20but I think I'm right that the original glowing apple

1:42:23on the back of a PowerBook was sort of a,

1:42:28hey, why don't we?

1:42:30because the LCD technology at the time

1:42:33generated a lot of light, and they realized that,

1:42:35hey, if we just put a translucent Apple logo there,

1:42:39we could just let the light from the display

1:42:40shine through the Apple, and the Apple logo will light up.

1:42:43I'm pretty sure that was the explanation for how it worked.

1:42:45And the current displays don't work like that anymore.

1:42:47I don't know at what point the technology changed,

1:42:50but the screen only glows in one direction now.

1:42:52And so they added, but they loved the feature so much

1:42:56that they put a separate lighting system in

1:42:58to keep the Apple logos lighting up,

1:42:59And that's why--

1:43:00- Oh, I didn't know that.

1:43:01- Yeah, well that's why,

1:43:02'cause if they could still get the light from the display,

1:43:04the thickness wouldn't be a worry.

1:43:06They would just, you know,

1:43:07they just don't put anything in between the display

1:43:10and the Apple logo.

1:43:11But--

1:43:12- That would also probably cause like a brightness drop

1:43:14in the middle of the screen,

1:43:15like as things get more sensitive

1:43:17and thinner and everything.

1:43:18Like, I could see why that would be challenging

1:43:20to do technically.

1:43:20- It is possible that I'll have to do follow up

1:43:23on the next episode and somebody will tell me

1:43:24that I'm nuts, that it was always a separate lighting thing.

1:43:27But I seem to recall that when they first did it,

1:43:28Like if you made your display,

1:43:30as you dimmed your display, the Apple logo would dim,

1:43:33and as you brightened your display,

1:43:34the Apple logo would brighten.

1:43:36- Yeah, I assumed it was always that way.

1:43:38Like I assumed that it was always just leaking light

1:43:39from the backlights, basically.

1:43:40- No, if you look at like the modern ones,

1:43:43the Apple doesn't change brightness with the screen.

1:43:46- Oh man, I'll take a look after the show.

1:43:47- I don't know.

1:43:47What else are my personal thoughts on this?

1:43:51The SSD, the SSD is so fast.

1:43:54I haven't run any benchmarks,

1:43:55'cause so many people with these reviews,

1:43:57And the YouTube crowd does such a great job with Benchmark.

1:44:01I mean, they, like too good of a job.

1:44:03It's like, oh my God, just shut up

1:44:04and tell me how fast it is.

1:44:05So I'm not running tests. - Hey guys.

1:44:08But make sure to like and subscribe.

1:44:09Here's 15 minutes of preamble before I actually tell you

1:44:12the one frame you wanna see in the video.

1:44:13- But the new ones, and I think that it's true.

1:44:16You might know, you memorize stuff like this better

1:44:18than me, Marco, but I think all of the new MacBook Pros

1:44:22have this new SSD that's super fast.

1:44:24It's not just a 15-inch thing, the 13-inch has it too.

1:44:27- That's correct, that comes along with the T2.

1:44:29So the T2, among the list of things it does,

1:44:31it's also the disk controller now.

1:44:33But like the T1 that was in the previous generation

1:44:34touch bars wasn't that advanced.

1:44:36It started with the iMac Pro, and Apple is basically,

1:44:40they've written their own controller,

1:44:41and it's integrated into the T2,

1:44:43and it is directly addressing the flash chips.

1:44:45And so this gives a number of performance improvements.

1:44:49It happens to be a really good

1:44:51and really competitive disk controller.

1:44:52So if you compare it to, if you would have just put

1:44:55Samsung SSD in your computer, then there's one,

1:44:58there's a Samsung controller on that SSD

1:45:00that controls the flash and everything.

1:45:02So that's kinda how this is.

1:45:04It's Apple's controller there instead of somebody else's,

1:45:08and it's really good.

1:45:09And on the iMac Pro, they were using dual SSD modules,

1:45:14in parallel, kinda like a RAID 0, but at a lower level.

1:45:17So they were using dual modules in parallel

1:45:19to get even better performance.

1:45:21And on the MacBook Pro, it appears that they're hitting

1:45:24those same numbers.

1:45:25So I think they're using the same thing

1:45:27where they're just like, you know,

1:45:27they're running multiple flash modules in parallel,

1:45:31and which is kind of always the case with SSDs,

1:45:33but they're doing it to a larger degree, I think,

1:45:35than is typically done.

1:45:37And their controller's excellent.

1:45:39And as far as, to the best of my knowledge,

1:45:40it applies to every configuration of the new 13 and 15 inch.

1:45:44- So, but it actually is weird.

1:45:49So like, it's so fast that the other day

1:45:54I needed to install a beta version of BB edits.

1:45:59I just measured, I just weighted, it's 39 megabytes.

1:46:02So it's, by today's standards, 39 megabytes is not much.

1:46:05But I had a disk image, and so there's definitely a copy.

1:46:10This isn't like an APFS thing.

1:46:12It was like the whole thing where you open the disk image,

1:46:15and then in the disk image, there's a little arrow saying,

1:46:17here, point it to this, you know,

1:46:20SimLink to your applications folder.

1:46:22I drug it over and let go.

1:46:24and nothing happened.

1:46:25And I was like, oh, and I blamed it on the trackpad,

1:46:28which I guess I should get to because the trackpad,

1:46:31I'm not used to this no physical click trackpad.

1:46:34- And its size.

1:46:36- And the size and the fact that it has force touch.

1:46:39So I've, and I've, so I've had miss clicking things in,

1:46:42you know, earlier in the week where there's, you know,

1:46:45things that I thought I was dragging,

1:46:46I've dropped before I was ready and stuff.

1:46:49So I figured I miss clicked, but it was actually there.

1:46:51It just happened so fast that the finder didn't even

1:46:53to have time to show the dialog box.

1:46:56And I realize 38 megabytes isn't that big,

1:46:58but I've never seen that before.

1:46:59Like, I just, I got no feedback whatsoever

1:47:02that it actually copied this application

1:47:04to my applications folder.

1:47:06It was so fast.

1:47:07It is absolutely astounding.

1:47:09- Yeah, I think like we're lucky in that

1:47:11in the last few years, as Intel's having all these troubles

1:47:13moving the CPUs forward, there's been not that much progress

1:47:16in CPU performance, but computers keep getting faster

1:47:20because there's been huge leaps in GPU and SSD performance.

1:47:25And increasingly, the GPU is increasingly being used

1:47:28by lots of things, and the SSD is used

1:47:29by pretty much everything.

1:47:31So almost every workload can be improved

1:47:33by increasing SSD performance,

1:47:34and Apple's been really, really good at that recently.

1:47:36- Right, I mean, you know, and SSDs have been great

1:47:38even since we first made it into consumer technology,

1:47:41even when they, by today's standards, they recruit.

1:47:44They've always been great,

1:47:45and they're so much more reliable,

1:47:47and they're dead quiet, et cetera.

1:47:49But it really is like we're living in the future,

1:47:52like 20 years ago we imagined,

1:47:54like where you would make a RAM disk,

1:47:56you'd make a disk image in RAM,

1:47:58then tell Photoshop, use this,

1:48:00or some kind of disk-intensive application,

1:48:02here, here's a quote-unquote disk

1:48:05that's really using up very valuable RAM,

1:48:08but to have real fast read-write--

1:48:11- Yeah, where everything just happens instantly,

1:48:12and there's no waiting. - Right, like,

1:48:13we're living with an SSD performance like this,

1:48:16we're living in the future where literally,

1:48:18Persistent storage is like having a RAM disk, it's crazy.

1:48:21- Yeah, and like a lot of people,

1:48:22you're looking at your old laptop from 2012 through 2015,

1:48:25maybe, or even earlier, and you're thinking,

1:48:28what do the new ones get me?

1:48:30And the answer is, on the processor side, not much.

1:48:33But this is the kind of thing where if you upgrade,

1:48:35honestly, I think if your old laptop

1:48:38still works fine for you, I don't think it's that pressing

1:48:40of a need to upgrade, but if you upgrade,

1:48:43what you would be getting for that is

1:48:45some more CPU performance, but a lot more

1:48:48SSD and GPU performance. Yeah, it's absolutely nuts

1:48:51All right. Let me take another break here and thank another sponsor

1:48:55That is who is being put to use this week in this house and it's our good friends at away

1:49:02away

1:49:04makes

1:49:06luggage

1:49:07and they make fantastic luggage out of

1:49:11Some kind of fancy German polycarbonate plastic blah blah blah blah

1:49:16Just trust me, it's really, really nice stuff. And again, one of my favorite things that keeps me I

1:49:23swear, like, there's this whole industry of like, hey, we sell direct to you companies, and they

1:49:28advertise on podcasts. And it's great, you get these great products, they've high quality,

1:49:33and you get them at a low price because they cut out middlemen, blah, blah, blah. But the thing

1:49:37about these companies in a way exemplifies is that you don't get overburdened by choice. Like,

1:49:42I hate making decisions where there's 13 different

1:49:46Lines of luggage from the same company or something like that now

1:49:51You don't you just pick what size you want you pick what color you want and that's it. It is fantastic. It is so easy

1:49:57And they're just absolutely great. They have a lifetime guarantee

1:50:01They have a hundred day trial where you can just use it Paul it, you know

1:50:05Get one now for your August vacation haul it around the world wherever you're going and if you don't like it just send it back

1:50:11They'll, you know, it doesn't matter if it's all banged up.

1:50:14Send it back to them, they'll give you your money back

1:50:16so you can try it.

1:50:17It's really, really great.

1:50:19And so they, what I have, over 10 colors, five sizes,

1:50:23and the sizes are self-descriptive.

1:50:25It's not like Starbucks where you go in there

1:50:26and the small one's called Tall, you know,

1:50:29nonsense like that.

1:50:30Look, they've got the carry-on, the bigger carry-on,

1:50:32the medium and the large.

1:50:33And then there's also the kids carry-on.

1:50:36You know immediately, I've already told you,

1:50:39you know exactly how big these things are.

1:50:41I have the carry-on, not the bigger carry-on, I believe.

1:50:45I think that's the one I have, I don't know.

1:50:46But whatever I have--

1:50:47- It's the one that used to be the only one.

1:50:48- Yeah, so I think it's the carry-on.

1:50:50It fits in every overhead, I've had it for years now.

1:50:53It fits in every single overhead bin on every plane.

1:50:56I've been on the wheels, still feel brand new.

1:51:00Literally today, this week, I've got it upstairs.

1:51:04I had to drag it through a parking lot

1:51:06full of little grit and gravel and stuff like that.

1:51:09indestructible wheels. They're the best wheels. Great handle. The handle moving up and down.

1:51:14Won't name the brand, but a friend who's here with us has a piece of luggage,

1:51:17handle of which is like the plastics peeling off and he's only had it a couple of years.

1:51:22Mine seems like brand new. It is absolutely great stuff. They've got,

1:51:27man, people advertise patent pending and my eyes start to roll. They have a patent pending

1:51:32compression system helpful for overpackers? Well, I don't know about the, whether the

1:51:39patent system should support patents for such things, but I'll tell you, they've got a really

1:51:42nice system for keeping your stuff in there. And I've never owned a suitcase where I can

1:51:46pack folded shirts and when I get to a place, open it up and the shirts are still perfectly

1:51:53folded at like, like they came out of the drawer. It's a great system. It's simple.

1:51:57It's not like I didn't, there's no, maybe there is a manual. I didn't read it. I figured

1:52:01it out on my own. You just put your shirts on the right side. You put the thing over

1:52:05it. There's these little buckles that straighten it up. Now, John, what if I have my dirty

1:52:09clothes when I'm traveling? What I don't want to mix those in with my regular clothes. Is

1:52:14there anything away can do to help me out? Yeah, they've got like a little bag, some

1:52:18kind of special fabric, I think even that's supposed to keep odors out, but they have

1:52:22a little like dirty laundry bag right there. Takes up no space before you get there. And

1:52:27you get there, you just start stuffing your dirties in there keeps them away from all

1:52:31of your clean clothes. And so if you're making a multi stop trip, or if you've overpacked

1:52:35and you still have like three clean shirts, as you're coming home, your clean stuff that

1:52:40you take out of the suitcase, you can just put right back in the closet because it hasn't

1:52:43been rubbing up against your dirty Mac welding underwear. It's just great luggage lifetime

1:52:51warranty, 100 days money back guarantee. I've got one we've got a couple of them here in

1:52:56the house actually for this trip. Really, really great stuff. And oh, the built in cell

1:53:03phone charger built in little I don't know how many thousand mega amp or whatever you

1:53:09measure those things by but two USB ports. You can sit there at the airport any seat

1:53:14in the airport don't look you no longer hunt for seats at the airport or no longer fish

1:53:19through your bag for the pocketable battery pack. Just find a seat at the airport. Keep

1:53:24your carry-on in front of you flip the little thing and you can plug your iPhone right in

1:53:29right there. I use that every time I go to the airport now. I can't remember the last

1:53:33time I haven't used it and it's such a great feature.

1:53:36Actual capacity might be less than 10,000 mega amps.

1:53:38Yeah, whatever. It's enough to charge a bunch of phones. And the other thing too, it's enough

1:53:43that you don't have to like charge your suitcase every time you get somewhere when you go.

1:53:48I charge mine like once a year and every time I get to the airport, there's still juice

1:53:52in there for me to plug, uh, you know, to, or even two of us to plug our iPhones in for the,

1:53:57however long we're waiting for our flight to be called. Uh, it's really fantastic. And you don't,

1:54:01that's the big, I should mention that because when I first heard about this, I thought, well,

1:54:04who the hell wants to have to charge your suitcase everywhere you go? Uh, it's not like that at all.

1:54:09So it's really great. Here's their special offer. You can save 20 bucks off a suitcase by going to

1:54:15away travel.com/talkshow away travel.com/talkshow and use promo talk show know the during checkout

1:54:27so go to away travel.com/talk show remember that promo code talk show and you will save 20 bucks

1:54:34off your suitcase really this is another one of those products where even if they weren't a

1:54:39sponsor i would i would tell you to go buy one because it's a great product really is

1:54:44You know, I see them everywhere now like when you're traveling like I see more and more away suitcases rolling through airports with people

1:54:48Yeah, like they're they're you know, they're they're spreading they're popular for for good reason. Well, they're popular enough

1:54:53so and i'll mention this there's a new like certain airlines now have a rule that if um,

1:54:59If your bag goes into

1:55:02the under, you know, the the

1:55:05Check bags. Yeah

1:55:07It can't have a lithium ion battery in it anymore

1:55:11So the battery that's built into away suitcases,

1:55:14this wasn't the policy when they made it,

1:55:15but they obviously had the foresight.

1:55:17It's very simple to remove it.

1:55:18You just unscrew two things,

1:55:20and there's a little screwdriver

1:55:21that you can just keep right there.

1:55:23They give it to you so you don't have to happen

1:55:25to have a Phillips head screwdriver with you.

1:55:27So if you were planning to carry your bag on,

1:55:31and they were like, "Oh, the overheads are full.

1:55:32"You have to check it."

1:55:33And they see, "Hey, that's a battery.

1:55:36"Now you're in trouble.

1:55:37"What's gonna happen?"

1:55:38It'll take you like a minute,

1:55:39and you could unscrew this thing.

1:55:41It would take you longer to open the suitcase

1:55:43than it would to remove it, so it is easily removable.

1:55:45But the popularity is such that when you're going

1:55:48through the airport, TSA people will see it,

1:55:51and they'll be like, hey, is that a battery?

1:55:52And I'll just say, oh, it's removable.

1:55:53And they're like, okay.

1:55:55But they definitely are used to seeing them.

1:55:57There's definitely a ton of them out there.

1:55:59So what else?

1:56:02A track pad I wanted to talk about.

1:56:04I'm getting used to it.

1:56:06I do miss the clickability.

1:56:09I feel like my physical, there's nothing beats

1:56:12a physical click.

1:56:13- Agreed.

1:56:14- It is uncanny how much this trackpad

1:56:17feels like it's clicking, even though it actually isn't.

1:56:19It's absolutely uncanny.

1:56:22And I do turn up, like there's light, medium, and firm,

1:56:25I think they describe it as.

1:56:27- Yeah, yeah.

1:56:27- In terms of how much click do you want to feel

1:56:31when you're getting these fake clicks.

1:56:33What do they call it?

1:56:34Light, medium, and firm, yep.

1:56:35I bump it up, medium is of course the default.

1:56:38I bump it up to firm just because I'm, you know,

1:56:42retro, I'm an old person who wants it to feel

1:56:46the most like the old ones.

1:56:47- Do you think the keyboards will ever have an option

1:56:50to emit fake keyboard sounds to sound like your keyboard?

1:56:53- No, I don't think so.

1:56:55'Cause they make enough sound as is.

1:56:56- Yeah, that's true.

1:56:57- And I don't use it for the sound.

1:56:59The sound is a byproduct of the feel.

1:57:02It's the feel that matters.

1:57:04- I found my recipe for happiness

1:57:06with the Force Touch track pads.

1:57:08'Cause I too really miss the old ones.

1:57:11And the new ones I don't think are as good.

1:57:15But I have reached the point where I think

1:57:16they're good enough that I stopped caring.

1:57:19And my recipe for happiness is not only to put it

1:57:22on the firm kickback mode, but also to disable 3D touch.

1:57:27- I'm on the cusp of that.

1:57:28I'm absolutely on the cusp of disabling 3D touch

1:57:31because I never seem to want it.

1:57:33And the only reason I haven't so far

1:57:35out of a knee-jerk frustration of when it's kicked in

1:57:37and I didn't want it, is just that I don't want

1:57:40to disable it just because I'm not used to it.

1:57:42I don't want to be that old man who wants to get rid

1:57:45of all the new stuff as quickly as I can.

1:57:47I want to give it a shot.

1:57:48- I will be that old man because I'm telling you

1:57:49it's so much better.

1:57:51Because the problem with the 3D touch on the trackpad

1:57:54is like, so on Macs the way this works,

1:57:56for anybody who somehow doesn't know,

1:57:58who's been living under a Mac rock,

1:57:59is that you basically have two simulated levels

1:58:03of pressure on the track, but to the first pressure level

1:58:06is the regular click, and then if you kinda click harder,

1:58:08like if you push further in on your, you know,

1:58:10in like the virtual depth of it,

1:58:13you get the secondary function,

1:58:14and it's not, it doesn't do a right click,

1:58:17it does some kind of third option

1:58:18that is supported by not that many things,

1:58:21and it provides some kind of shortcut,

1:58:23and ultimately I have found, when I've had it on

1:58:25and when I've tried using it, I have found it,

1:58:28I never want the thing that it offers me on the second level

1:58:32but I frequently accidentally invoke it,

1:58:34especially when I'm trying to drag things.

1:58:36- So that's exactly it.

1:58:37So the one where I almost like in a rage turned it off

1:58:40was I went to drag something from the Finder

1:58:43and instead got Quick Look.

1:58:46'Cause that's what you get in a Finder

1:58:47when you 3D click on an item in the Finder.

1:58:50You get a quick look of it.

1:58:52Well, why in the world do I want a quick look

1:58:53of an application?

1:58:55Just shows you the application icon big.

1:58:57- Well, like the space bar isn't that hard to hit.

1:59:01- Right, right.

1:59:02especially with these new ones,

1:59:03it's like a millimeter away from the track pad.

1:59:05- Right, it's not far away.

1:59:07It's not, your hand has to move far,

1:59:09especially if your hand is already on the keyboard

1:59:11and you're using your thumb for the drag,

1:59:14which is very typical for me, but is also less precise.

1:59:16Like if I use my index finger, I never do it by accident,

1:59:20but my thumb is a clumsier digit than my index finger

1:59:24and my thumb is often, most often,

1:59:26what I'm using on the track pad

1:59:28and I'm more likely to trigger it.

1:59:30I'm also unconv, I remain unconvinced

1:59:33that the bigger trackpad is in any way an advantage.

1:59:37There are downsides where you can get

1:59:39touches you didn't intend more often,

1:59:41and I don't see what I do where having the trackpad

1:59:46be this much bigger is actually better.

1:59:48I'm unconvinced.

1:59:50I don't get tons of false touches,

1:59:52and I see that there's all these three fingers

1:59:56and your thumb in a pinching out thing

1:59:59exposes the desktop.

2:00:01You know, I can see how some of these gestures

2:00:03are so complicated, or use so many fingers, I should say,

2:00:06that having the extra space might be helpful,

2:00:09but I'm unconvinced that this is actually better.

2:00:11And I wonder if they did it

2:00:13because somebody thinks it looks better.

2:00:15- Or I think, you know, keep in mind,

2:00:16like when this body style was, you know,

2:00:19was released in 2016 with the Touch Bar,

2:00:22this was kind of Apple saying, like making a statement

2:00:26that no, the trend of literally everyone else's laptops

2:00:29going touch screen hybrid, that's wrong.

2:00:32What you want is the touch surface to be

2:00:34on the same plane as the keyboard.

2:00:35Like that was Apple, that was the statement

2:00:37they were making to the world.

2:00:38So I think it was part of like,

2:00:40in making that statement as strongly as they could,

2:00:43not only do they ship the touch bar on the top,

2:00:45you know, above the keyboard, but then below the keyboard,

2:00:47they have this massive touch area to say,

2:00:48look, this whole thing is touchable,

2:00:50you don't need to touch the screen.

2:00:51By the way, I think they're wrong on that.

2:00:52But regardless, you know, I think it's,

2:00:56the real world problem with this is very similar

2:00:59to what I just described with force touch,

2:01:00or 3D touch on the trackpad,

2:01:02which is the occurrence of accidental input

2:01:06and unintended or failed attempts to do basic things

2:01:11like type without mousing around,

2:01:13the accidental input happens more often

2:01:17than the intended use.

2:01:19If the intended use is to allow a lot of those

2:01:21big multi, four-finger gestures,

2:01:23do people really use those much more often

2:01:26than they accidentally brush the trackpad

2:01:28was trying to type, like probably not.

2:01:30So this is another example to me,

2:01:32and I think it's also telling that when I went back,

2:01:35after having one of these for like eight months,

2:01:37when I went back to my 2015 MacBook Pro,

2:01:41and therefore I went from bigger tripod to a smaller one,

2:01:44I didn't notice at all.

2:01:45I didn't even notice for a second.

2:01:46I wasn't missing the extra space,

2:01:49even after being used to it pretty well.

2:01:50Like it was just like, well that was unnecessary.

2:01:54- Well, I kind of agree.

2:01:56- And the fact that it causes the accidental input,

2:01:57I think that to me is the damning thing.

2:01:59It's like if it didn't have any major downsides,

2:02:02fine, make it as big as it can be

2:02:04without causing major downsides.

2:02:05But I think they went too far.

2:02:06They made it too big and it does have major downsides

2:02:09with accidental input.

2:02:10And so to me, it's not worth it.

2:02:13- Hasn't been too big of a problem for me in the last week.

2:02:15I think way less about the trackpad being all new

2:02:18than I think about the keyboard being new.

2:02:20The keyboard is something I'm thinking about

2:02:21every time I type.

2:02:22And the trackpad, it's like a couple of times a day,

2:02:24I'm like, ooh, what was that?

2:02:26And the Force Touch thing is more than the size.

2:02:29- Agreed.

2:02:30- I kind of wish, I think I wish that the keyboard

2:02:32was still the same size as it used to be,

2:02:34but I know that so far I don't care for the 3D Touch

2:02:37or Force Touch, whatever.

2:02:38Yeah, trackpad.

2:02:39What else?

2:02:41I had Jonas play Fortnite on it,

2:02:45which is a very GPU-intensive thing

2:02:50and is notoriously bad on Macs.

2:02:53And it was pretty good.

2:02:56He said, you know, he had to turn the graphics down from the default high to one click down,

2:03:01but he said it still looked good. It looked good to my eyes. And he was getting not quite

2:03:0660 frames per second, but it was it seemed never to drop below 50 and it tended to be

2:03:11in the high 50s.

2:03:12So you don't need a gaming PC, you should have $5,000 MacBook Pro.

2:03:17Right exactly. But that I thought that was an almost

2:03:19360 frames a second.

2:03:21As a side note on that story though, I thought the weirder thing, and to me it's a very telling

2:03:27anecdote about how important Mac gaming is to the gaming industry, is I installed Fortnite.

2:03:36Number one, this sucks.

2:03:37This is really a boo-his thing where to launch it, you have to get it from Epic.

2:03:44They don't sell it on the App Store and they don't have it in Steam because the whole game

2:03:47goes through in-app purchases and they don't want to do a 30% split with anybody. I don't

2:03:52blame them for that. But you can't just download Fortnite and install Fortnite.app. You have

2:03:57to install this thing called the Epic Games Launcher. And then every time you want to

2:04:01play, you have to like start the Epic Games Launcher and then launch Fortnite from there.

2:04:07And then once you install it, it like the Epic Games Launcher somehow without asking,

2:04:12I don't know how they did it. I it's weird, but I haven't quite figured it out, but they

2:04:15somehow I think maybe I'm wrong. Maybe it's just that I logged out and had the setting

2:04:21to relaunch everything that was there. But when I log back in, I logged out and log back

2:04:25in and the epics games launcher launched again and wouldn't quit. I had to force quit it.

2:04:31And I'm allowed to say epic fail. You are. That's awful. But here's the weird part. The

2:04:37really weird part was the first time we launched it and Jonas signed in with his credentials

2:04:43and got ready to play and everything loaded.

2:04:47And then it made, it's like finding a match,

2:04:49finding a hundred people for him to play against.

2:04:50And then it said, loading dot, dot, dot,

2:04:52and a progress bar marched across.

2:04:54And the progress bar was like 98% of the way there,

2:04:58and then just didn't go any further.

2:05:00And it wasn't frozen 'cause the dot, dot, dot

2:05:02next to the word loading continued to animate.

2:05:05And it just kept waiting and waiting and waiting.

2:05:08I mean, minutes, literally minutes.

2:05:10And we were like, "What the hell?"

2:05:12And it was like, "I don't know what to do."

2:05:13and you couldn't quit at that time.

2:05:15So we had a force, we force quit, did it again,

2:05:17and it just got that far and waited.

2:05:19Like, easily, definitely minutes.

2:05:21I was like, give it a couple minutes,

2:05:22and minutes and minutes and minutes,

2:05:24and like way more minutes than it could possibly be normal.

2:05:28And it certainly wasn't waiting on the internet.

2:05:30The internet speed here is absolutely fantastic.

2:05:33It's like 150 megabits per second up and down.

2:05:36Marcos, mm-hmm.

2:05:41So Jonas and I started searching the web for solutions.

2:05:44And I found, there were a couple of these,

2:05:46like infinite loading and some of them date back years.

2:05:48But then I found a thread just from June

2:05:53where somebody said, you know, said they had this problem.

2:05:56And then somebody else said, wait about 10 minutes.

2:06:00It takes about 10 minutes for the first match

2:06:02and then you'll be in.

2:06:05And then after that subsequent matches

2:06:07will start up automatically.

2:06:09Epic has known about this since April and he had like a link where he pointed to a thing where this exact problem

2:06:15Was reported to epic in like early april and it's just on mac just on mac

2:06:19Uh, and I think just some max it seemed like everybody was saying macbook pro

2:06:23um

2:06:25So I don't know, you know it

2:06:27It may not be every mac, but it's certainly enough. It's certainly it's it was once you start googling it. It's it's wide enough

2:06:33Uh, is it too soon to ask if it was throttling?

2:06:36No, but what a weird bug like the first match you play you have to wait 10 minutes and weird enough

2:06:42So the way fortnite works is you're in a hundred person battle royale hundred people

2:06:46Uh free for all last person standing wins and you try to shoot everybody else

2:06:51Uh on a big map by the time jonas got in on the one where he waited 10 minutes

2:06:56There were only 30 people left

2:06:58So like the game had the match had been going on and so in a weird way

2:07:03it was sort of like a cheat because he got to start playing after 70 people had already been

2:07:09eliminated. It's sort of like jumping into a marathon at the 18th mile. It's like, "Hey,

2:07:14I'm winning." And as promised in the thread, he was eliminated and he said, "I'll play again."

2:07:21And it loaded him. Everything was normal at that point. But I think that's so telling that a bug

2:07:26so glaring has existed in the Mac version of Fortnite since April. And they've had several

2:07:31update since you know, it's not like they have an update, they

2:07:34update all the time. And they haven't fixed it. Like clearly,

2:07:37if this was an issue on the PlayStation, or Xbox or the PC,

2:07:40it would it would be a, you know, priority one bug defects.

2:07:44And you know, the Mac, it's like, yeah,

2:07:47you hit the max like half people in the company like we have a

2:07:50Mac version, right? This is why people install boot camp to play

2:07:55games on their Mac. And this and that in turn, is the biggest

2:07:59Hmm, I think we collectively might be

2:08:02Underestimating the problems that might happen if and when Apple switches the max to arm CPUs and

2:08:09Either boot camp goes away or

2:08:13If if somehow boot camp still works and you can install like the arm version of Windows

2:08:18It certainly isn't going to work with the Intel based games

2:08:21Well, I think maybe too like there's you know Apple has been

2:08:25losing gamers for a while.

2:08:26I mean, to a lot of degrees,

2:08:28they never really had the gamers.

2:08:29- Well, the Mac is losing gamers.

2:08:30Apple's not losing gamers. - Well, right, yes.

2:08:32Yeah, good clarification.

2:08:33Yeah, iOS is doing great gamers.

2:08:35But yeah, the Mac has never prioritized gaming, really,

2:08:38and it seems to only be getting more and more distant

2:08:41from it as gaming is getting even more sophisticated.

2:08:45Like, the GPUs for gaming are getting even more powerful,

2:08:48and the difference between a gaming GPU

2:08:51and what Apple puts in its Macs is just getting,

2:08:54I think wider and wider over time.

2:08:56And so Apple's solution to gamers on the desktop

2:08:59is like buy an iMac Pro or a Mac Pro,

2:09:03that's not gonna work.

2:09:04And as VR comes in with gaming too,

2:09:08that becomes even less doable on Mac GPUs and Mac hardware.

2:09:12So I'm guessing that problem is just gonna work itself out

2:09:15that way where Macs will just become so bad

2:09:19as gaming platforms that gamers will just use gaming PCs

2:09:22and maybe have a Mac laptop on the side also,

2:09:25but like separate those rules.

2:09:28- Yeah, so I think what Jonas wants,

2:09:30and it's weird, it doesn't break my heart,

2:09:32liking Apple stuff is not a religion for me.

2:09:37He wants a gaming PC.

2:09:38I don't think he wants, and we've told him,

2:09:40well, let's be serious about it.

2:09:42This is a serious, this is a lot of money,

2:09:45but he's still using a 2014 MacBook Pro,

2:09:51which is nice for an eighth grader in my opinion,

2:09:55but it is four years old.

2:09:56- And it's less nice for games.

2:09:58- It is not nice for games at all.

2:09:59It's really irrelevant to most of the games he wants to play.

2:10:02There's a, but you know, he plays so many games,

2:10:04but like there's a game he plays,

2:10:06I don't know what it's called,

2:10:06but it's sort of like Risk, and you can play it online,

2:10:10and you can play it with your friends and stuff like that.

2:10:12But because it's like a map-based God view game,

2:10:15it's not graphically intensive at all.

2:10:17And it still makes his fans roar,

2:10:21Absolutely roar so yeah, it's it but for stuff like for like fortnight even tells you if you have Intel Iris graphics that it

2:10:28It'll just die, you know, it just refuses to run

2:10:31I mean and that's what a four-year-old MacBook Pro has that every member Pro has if it's smaller than 15 inches, right?

2:10:37Right idea. So I think even a brand new 13 inch MacBook Pro couldn't run for tonight

2:10:41You're probably right because it does have Irish it might try but there the epic is very explicit that if you have an Intel Iris

2:10:47Graphics that you're you're you're asking for trouble

2:10:50But the Mac the 15-inch MacBook Pro at least this one runs it with you know it again

2:10:55You have to turn it graphics down like one click from their default, but they still look good

2:10:59Jonah said he'd be you know, he was happy to play it

2:11:01he thinks it compares very well to what his PlayStation 4 is capable of

2:11:04but it's really hard to tell because a

2:11:071080p TV is very that you're sitting a few feet or from and in front of it's very different than a retina

2:11:13display that you're sitting a few inches in front of

2:11:17But, you know, it runs, and I thought that was a pretty cool test.

2:11:20Also though, it makes the machine egg cooking hot.

2:11:24- Yeah, that's the wrong tool for the job.

2:11:27I mean, like, what you, I mean--

2:11:29- It really gets hot.

2:11:31And as I sit here, as I brag about the battery life,

2:11:34I'm getting here doing nothing just looking at the screen.

2:11:36Right now it still says 88%, and we're over two hours.

2:11:40Over two hours of me staring at the screen

2:11:42at almost top brightness.

2:11:44Am I, what level am I at here?

2:11:45about 80% brightness. I'm at 88%. Jonas played one round of Fortnite, well two.

2:11:52There was the one where he had the 10-minute wait and then he played one

2:11:56normal match and the battery dropped 26%. Yeah and this and with with these

2:12:01laptops too, with with very high power components when you have like the top

2:12:05end GPUs, the top end CPUs, it is often the case with modern laptops including

2:12:10apples that if you max them out like crazy sometimes they can even if they're

2:12:14plugged in, they can slowly discharge their own battery

2:12:16because they're using more power

2:12:18than the power adapter can supply.

2:12:21And so you actually have limited amount of time

2:12:24'cause they will eventually drain their own battery

2:12:26while plugged in and need to be shut down.

2:12:28So like this is, when I was like going through puberty

2:12:32and I started getting a mustache,

2:12:34for the first couple of months,

2:12:35my mom didn't want to admit to herself

2:12:38that I was growing up.

2:12:39And so she made me just occasionally trim it with scissors.

2:12:44And like eventually, it was ridiculous,

2:12:46and like eventually after a couple of weeks

2:12:48or months of that, my uncle was like,

2:12:50you gotta get this boy a shaver.

2:12:53I feel like this is the wrong tool for this.

2:12:55You need to get your Sonic gaming PC.

2:12:57That's the real answer here.

2:12:57- But he doesn't want a gaming laptop.

2:12:59He wants a desktop PC.

2:13:01- That's the way to do it.

2:13:02- Right, and you know, he doesn't need it.

2:13:04He could just take the Switch with him

2:13:07when he wants to play his perfectly,

2:13:08or he plays lots of games on his phone.

2:13:11I think that's a reasonable trade-off.

2:13:12I think he's actually making the right decision

2:13:14where he's optimizing to have the best experience

2:13:16most of the time, which is when he's home,

2:13:19and just forget about PC gaming period

2:13:21when he's on the road, and use something like the Switch

2:13:25or just an iPhone that is actually meant

2:13:27for mobile gaming for mobile gaming.

2:13:29I actually, I think he's got his priorities in line.

2:13:33- Yeah, and that's, you know, like,

2:13:34there was a series on back to work

2:13:37over the last like six months or so

2:13:38where our friend Dan Benjamin built a gaming PC

2:13:40his son for his son. And then more recently, our friend Mike Hurley built one. And and

2:13:46like, I gotta say, like, it sounds really fun. Like if I was into PC gaming, I would

2:13:50have a lot of fun building a gaming PC. And it's so here's the thing. You have to it's,

2:13:56it's like going to McDonald's, like, everything is so like, tacky. And it's it's like junk

2:14:02food for PCs. Like, everything's covered in colored lights, and everything. It's like,

2:14:07It's crazy, but it's all in service of the love of PC gaming,

2:14:11which can be really awesome, and you just can't do it

2:14:13on laptops. - Were those guys actually,

2:14:15quote, unquote, building one by ordering components

2:14:17separately and assembling?

2:14:18See, I'm leaning more towards just paying Alienware.

2:14:23- I mean, you can do that too, but if you or Jonas

2:14:26have an interest in that, Mike did it for a fun project

2:14:30for himself and his podcast, and Dan Benjamin did it

2:14:34as a fun thing for him to do with his son,

2:14:35and they both said it was like,

2:14:37Dan hadn't built a PC in years,

2:14:39Mike had never built a PC,

2:14:40they both just followed online guides

2:14:42and it was really easy.

2:14:43Like, it's a fun activity,

2:14:45but regardless of how you get it,

2:14:46I do think like a desktop gaming PC

2:14:47is the right move for this,

2:14:48because like, you can struggle trying to, you know,

2:14:52cut this mustache with scissors,

2:14:53or you can get the actual right tool for the job,

2:14:55and the actual right tool for the job is a gaming PC.

2:14:57- What else on this machine?

2:15:00I can't think of anything else on the MacBook Pro.

2:15:04- Have you found, I mean,

2:15:04I know you haven't had it for that long,

2:15:06but what do you think about the port situation?

2:15:07Has that been a problem for you?

2:15:08- No. - Are you mostly okay?

2:15:09- No, the only thing, 'cause I haven't had a need for it.

2:15:13And I don't really use ports anyway.

2:15:15I use very little USB stuff, especially when I'm traveling.

2:15:20The one thing we did run into was that to play Fortnite,

2:15:24Jonas wanted to use his gaming mouse,

2:15:26which he did bring along, and the gaming mouse, of course,

2:15:28has a USB-A plug, and this doesn't have USB-A.

2:15:31and I thought I had a USB-C to A adapter in my backpack,

2:15:35and I know I own one somewhere,

2:15:36and I usually keep all of those little fiddly adapters,

2:15:40even when I use them at home when I'm done,

2:15:42I put them in my backpack, not on my desk or shelf,

2:15:44but I didn't have it.

2:15:46- Yeah, even like a dedicated travel set

2:15:48with all these things. - Right.

2:15:49But there was one in the house, thankfully, shockingly.

2:15:53- No thanks to me. - Right.

2:15:54But somebody else had one, so problem solved.

2:15:58That was the only thing that we ran into.

2:16:01You know, I'm the wrong person to ask about it

2:16:05'cause I just don't need it.

2:16:06And even with like, I shoot, I still use a Fuji X100S

2:16:11that shoots on an SD card and in theory, you know,

2:16:15someday instead of waiting 'til I get home

2:16:18and going through the photos on my iMac,

2:16:20I might wanna do it on this.

2:16:21But I have, I do have the SSD to USB-C adapter with me,

2:16:25I think.

2:16:27- Yeah, that weird like SanDisk, like flat one.

2:16:28I have one of those, it's really weird.

2:16:30I think I have it with me.

2:16:32I don't know, I do know I own one.

2:16:35But I don't need it on this trip,

2:16:36so I'm the wrong person to ask about it.

2:16:38I guess, ATP covers it, I'm assuming that most people

2:16:41listening to this also listen to ATP,

2:16:43but you've talked about it.

2:16:44But I guess the bigger picture thing about the MacBook line

2:16:46in general is that USB-C has not worked out

2:16:50the way Apple envisioned.

2:16:52And they don't have to admit it for us

2:16:53to know that it's true.

2:16:55There's just, there can be no doubt that this many years,

2:16:58three years after the 2015 MacBook appeared

2:17:01with only a USB-C port, three years is way long enough

2:17:06for it to be clear that it just has not worked out

2:17:10the way they clearly thought it would.

2:17:11And almost everything you buy that's USB-C still is USB-A.

2:17:16And when you buy the USB-C stuff, it doesn't work.

2:17:20A lot of it is junk.

2:17:22- It's very flaky.

2:17:23Like that to me was the biggest problem

2:17:25when I was using these full-time that I ran into

2:17:27was a lot of my stuff, it was unreliable.

2:17:30Like the dongle would be unreliable

2:17:32or it would work in a port on the laptop

2:17:35but not on one of the ports in the LG Ultrafine monitor

2:17:38or something like that.

2:17:39Like there were all these little exceptions.

2:17:41Like well this USB device, like the keyboard dongle

2:17:43would work in this adapter but not that adapter

2:17:46and it was just so flaky and it makes it really difficult

2:17:49even if you're willing to go all in on USB-C.

2:17:52You're saying okay fine, I'll buy all new cables,

2:17:54I'll buy hubs, whatever I have to buy, sure I'll go all in.

2:17:57But the ecosystem still makes it pretty difficult

2:17:59to do that reliably.

2:18:00- And it's funny, I haven't had any incidents

2:18:02with this machine that I've been using for a week,

2:18:05but about 10 days ago, somewhere around there,

2:18:09after I talked to Apple and they were like,

2:18:11"Hey, we'll send you a review unit,"

2:18:12and I was waiting for it.

2:18:14And while I was using my other machine,

2:18:16I had a prototypical mag-safe thing

2:18:20where I was working with my personal 13-inch on a table

2:18:24I didn't usually, I forget where I was even,

2:18:26I must not even have been at home.

2:18:28I was somewhere working in a weird, unfamiliar spot,

2:18:31and I stood up, and me personally,

2:18:33I can't blame anybody else,

2:18:34just totally kicked the power cord,

2:18:36'cause I, oop, forgot it was there,

2:18:37and just, bloop, little perfect MagSafe just came out.

2:18:41Because it was on my mind that this machine was coming

2:18:44and I knew I'd be using it, I was like,

2:18:46"Wow, I'm glad that happened with this and not with that."

2:18:49- Yeah.

2:18:51- So that's another one that I'd add to the list

2:18:54of things that they've changed

2:18:55that I see it, I understand it to some degree,

2:18:58but boy, it's two steps forward and at least one step back,

2:19:02if not two steps in one good direction

2:19:05and two entire steps in a bad direction.

2:19:07- Do you miss the other things that have changed

2:19:09about the power being like no longer having the little wings

2:19:12and the power brick and not having the light

2:19:14on the end of it?

2:19:16- I miss both of those things tremendously.

2:19:18- Yeah, me too.

2:19:19- Just because, especially when you travel,

2:19:21there's unfamiliar ports in the one.

2:19:24You never know when your hotel, it's unusual,

2:19:28but when you travel to somebody's house,

2:19:30who knows which adapters or plugs in the wall

2:19:33are hooked up to a light switch or not.

2:19:35- Oh yeah.

2:19:36- Right?

2:19:37- Or if you accidentally, if you have one of the old,

2:19:40loose outlets and your brick has slid out

2:19:42from it a little bit, you kinda don't know.

2:19:44- Right, I'm addicted to the confirmation

2:19:47in a way that an iPhone, if you plug it into power

2:19:50and it is getting power, the screen will always come on

2:19:53and just show you a little green lightning,

2:19:55like okay, I'm getting some juice,

2:19:57and then you can just walk away.

2:19:58When you have a clamshell closed MacBook

2:20:01and you plug it into power and you assume

2:20:03that when you come back from dinner

2:20:05or when you wake up in a more, whatever the period is,

2:20:08that this'll be nice and charged, I wanna know it.

2:20:12I wanna see that green light.

2:20:13I miss that terribly.

2:20:14- 'Cause it just, it makes the little sound,

2:20:16but only if it's not muted.

2:20:18- Right. - And also,

2:20:19you might not be able to hear the sound

2:20:20depending on the environment.

2:20:21And also there's no way to glance at it

2:20:24from across the room and see is it charging

2:20:26or is it charged?

2:20:27- Right.

2:20:28- Yeah, and the wings-- - It's a great distinction.

2:20:29- The wings on the adapter, I complained about that

2:20:31in my review in 2016 and it still stands

2:20:33because it was a great design and I use them all the time.

2:20:37I mean, there might be people who don't know it

2:20:39'cause it is a weird little thing,

2:20:40but if you have an older MacBook Power Adapter

2:20:43and those two little plastic,

2:20:45I can't think of anything better to call it than wings

2:20:47that pull out on the one side.

2:20:49they're meant for you to wrap the skinny part

2:20:51of the power adapter around.

2:20:53And they are absolutely amazing.

2:20:56They do the job better than anything I can imagine,

2:20:58other than if it could actually retract.

2:21:01- Yeah, that would be better.

2:21:01- Right.

2:21:02- But I can't see Apple doing that.

2:21:04- Right, because they'd have to make it bigger.

2:21:05- And also it's kind of like a crappy,

2:21:07it's kind of like a low class mechanism

2:21:10to have a little retracting thing.

2:21:11But I actually would kind of like that.

2:21:13But yeah, the new ones, I feel like

2:21:14when I'm carrying them around,

2:21:15I have this mess of power cable in the bag,

2:21:18no matter how nicely I try to wrap it up,

2:21:20it's nothing compared to having the old brick

2:21:22just where I could wrap it around the brick

2:21:24and have it hold there and have it all nice and compact

2:21:27and organized.

2:21:28- All right, let me take one last break here.

2:21:29I've got a fourth bonus sponsor

2:21:32for this extra long special edition of the show,

2:21:34and it's our good friends at Squarespace.

2:21:37Squarespace is where you go to make your own website.

2:21:41And this has come up, maybe we'll talk about it

2:21:42after this break briefly,

2:21:45but there's been people talking about just the way,

2:21:49like centralized podcast hosting and what should you do,

2:21:54should all podcasts, should there be like a YouTube

2:21:56for podcasts, that sort of thing.

2:21:58I'll tell you what, if you care about your online presence

2:22:02and whether you're a company,

2:22:04whether you're just an individual,

2:22:06whether you've got a portfolio or something like that,

2:22:07of course you have to participate in certain social networks

2:22:10and some of them are centralized,

2:22:11but you should own your own personal website.

2:22:14Nothing can beat it for permanence and independence.

2:22:18And you don't have to worry,

2:22:21like if you had a big MySpace presence

2:22:24or something like that,

2:22:25and all of a sudden MySpace goes away,

2:22:27now you got nothing.

2:22:28Like nobody can take your website away.

2:22:30And if you need your own website,

2:22:31there is no easier, more reliable,

2:22:34just all-round excellent, low friction,

2:22:40don't worry about it.

2:22:41Like if the whole point of,

2:22:42ah, just do everything on Facebook

2:22:43or whatever, is that you don't wanna do all the work

2:22:46of creating your own website.

2:22:47Squarespace makes it so easy.

2:22:50It is as easy as configuring your profile

2:22:53on like a social network type thing

2:22:55to just create your entire custom owned website

2:22:59with your own domain.

2:23:00Everything you can do through Squarespace,

2:23:02from registering the domain, to picking the template,

2:23:05to adjusting the template, to deciding what style of,

2:23:08you know, what features you want.

2:23:10Do you need a store?

2:23:11Do you wanna host a blog?

2:23:12if you wanna host a podcast, all of this,

2:23:16and so you could do all of that on Squarespace,

2:23:18and you don't need any coding experience.

2:23:20You don't have to ever look at HTML,

2:23:22you don't have to look at CSS,

2:23:23you don't even have to know what JavaScript is.

2:23:26None of that.

2:23:27You get everything.

2:23:28You get analytics.

2:23:29You can find out who's coming to your website from where,

2:23:32and it's a really good analytics interface.

2:23:35Most analytics interfaces are inscrutable.

2:23:38Squarespace, like almost everything they do,

2:23:40is obviously designed by talented designers

2:23:45who know information design.

2:23:46The analytics thing is worth it alone.

2:23:48It is so amazing.

2:23:49You would be shocked if you do view source

2:23:51on websites you go to every day,

2:23:53like restaurants, things like that.

2:23:55How many of the websites you use on a daily basis

2:23:58are hosted and built on the Squarespace platform?

2:24:01They're everywhere, and with good reason.

2:24:03It's truly amazing.

2:24:05Marco always says it when he talks about Squarespace on ATP,

2:24:08But the next time you think you need a website

2:24:10or someone you know needs a website and they come to you,

2:24:13try it at Squarespace first and just give it a half hour,

2:24:17give it an hour and see how far you can go.

2:24:19And you will think, my God, this is nuts

2:24:21that I ever did this any other way.

2:24:22They have amazing technical support, everything you can want.

2:24:25I can't think of anything else that you would want.

2:24:28So go to Squarespace the next time you need a website.

2:24:31And here's the deal, you get 30 days free

2:24:34to just use it with full featured.

2:24:37You don't have to pay them anything.

2:24:39So when you do pay, just remember this,

2:24:42remember the code talk show.

2:24:44If you want, you could even use the code ATP.

2:24:47Either way, you're gonna get 10% off your first purchase

2:24:51and they'll know where it came from.

2:24:55One of these two great shows.

2:24:56Squarespace.com/talkshow is where you go

2:24:59and that code, which you remember

2:25:01when you start paying is talk show.

2:25:02You could also use ATP if you're here for Marco

2:25:05and not for me.

2:25:06Either way, it's a great product.

2:25:08Again, anybody comes to me,

2:25:09whether they sponsor it or not,

2:25:10privately says, "Hey, I need a website."

2:25:12I send them to Squarespace, I really do.

2:25:14So my thanks to them for their continuing support

2:25:17of this show and obviously many other fine podcasts.

2:25:20Last but not least on this new thing,

2:25:26Apple gave me the leather sleeve that goes with it.

2:25:29They've started, this is new to the MacBook Pros.

2:25:32They've made leather cases for iPhones for years.

2:25:35They've made leather sleeves for the iPad for a year.

2:25:40- Something like that.

2:25:41- Yeah, and now starting about two weeks ago

2:25:43when these new MacBook Pros come out,

2:25:45they have leather sleeves for them.

2:25:47It's 180.

2:25:48- You can't even get to the price.

2:25:52- It's $180 for the 13 inch model

2:25:56and $200 for the 15 inch model.

2:26:00And it's just a sleeve.

2:26:03It is leather.

2:26:05They sent me the black one. It was nice. I don't know what material it is inside, but

2:26:09some kind of like microfiber type thing. Very soft. It has a very subtle Apple logo on it.

2:26:14I don't, I, I do use a sleeve type thing with my 13 inch MacBook pro. I forget what brand

2:26:21it is, but it's sort of like a padded thing because I use a backpack that doesn't have

2:26:24a padded area for a laptop. But it is more than just a sleeve. It's padded. It has a

2:26:31zipper and it has a zipper compartment where I keep a bunch of certain essential things that

2:26:36I want to have with me at all times. I personally have no interest in a sleeve of any sort,

2:26:42leather or not, that doesn't have like a compartment that I can do things in because

2:26:48if I really just, if I don't need anything else with me, I would just take the bare MacBook,

2:26:54you know. I showed it to my wife, Amy, who knows, has experienced and more opinions on fine leather

2:27:04goods like handbags, that sort of thing, wallets and things like that than I do. And I showed it

2:27:10to her and she knew what it was. And I just said, "What, how much do you think this cost?" And she

2:27:15felt it, took a, you know, a couple of seconds looking at it and just rubbed the leather. And

2:27:20And she said, and I think this was her including

2:27:24what she perceived to be Apple's premium pricing,

2:27:26she said, $60.

2:27:27(laughing)

2:27:29And I said, it's 200.

2:27:31And we were in the kitchen and she yelled, no!

2:27:36(laughing)

2:27:37So loud that our son Jonas, who's on summer vacation,

2:27:41he's upstairs in his bedroom's right above our kitchen.

2:27:44He thought, and he's used to it every once in a while,

2:27:47that she'll discover that, you know,

2:27:48let's say he left like an empty bag of chips

2:27:51in the table or something,

2:27:52did some kind of gross violation of family protocol,

2:27:55she'll yell, "Joe!"

2:27:57Or even if she yells, "Jonas!"

2:28:01That first syllable is what he hears,

2:28:03so she yelled, "No!"

2:28:05And Jonas goes, "I'm coming!"

2:28:07(laughing)

2:28:09So I would summarize her reaction to it

2:28:16as it being not worth $200.

2:28:19- That seems like a fair summary.

2:28:21- It is possible, I don't know.

2:28:23It is possible that the reason,

2:28:26her thought is that this is not high quality leather.

2:28:29It is possible though that she's comparing it

2:28:31against something like a nice handbag,

2:28:34which has, maybe this is treated for water resistance

2:28:38or something that makes it less supple and undesirable

2:28:42for something like that and more desirable for this.

2:28:45I don't know, but the person in our household

2:28:48who has stronger opinions on leather bags

2:28:51definitely was not impressed by the $200 price point.

2:28:55- Yeah, I was able to feel one of these as well.

2:29:00- Well, I've got mine here.

2:29:01- Yeah, I wasn't sure if you were allowed

2:29:02to share your review unit with other people

2:29:04outside your family. - Oh, yes, yeah.

2:29:06There's no embargo on it.

2:29:07- But, yeah, but suffice to say,

2:29:08I was able to experience one of these products.

2:29:11- Did you type on his keyboard yet?

2:29:14briefly I think.

2:29:15- You wanna play with it?

2:29:16- Let me see.

2:29:17(laughs)

2:29:19Let me see.

2:29:20- That's just the end of the Apple note with the show notes.

2:29:23So you can type whatever you want.

2:29:25- Yeah, anyway, so I was able, this feels,

2:29:28it feels slightly like stickier than the old one.

2:29:34Like it feels like the keys,

2:29:37it feels like they're like,

2:29:38they don't pop back like as readily as the other ones,

2:29:41but not by a huge margin.

2:29:42It's a small,

2:29:43I'll have to really just use mine for a while

2:29:44to say really no, but--

2:29:45- Yeah, the silicone layer definitely adds

2:29:47a sort of organic feel that's not there

2:29:49from a purely, I don't know if these words

2:29:52quite make sense, but without the silicone layer

2:29:55where it's purely mechanical,

2:29:57everything involved is either metal or plastic,

2:30:00there's a mechanicalness to the feel,

2:30:03and the silicone layer adds an organic feel to it

2:30:07that I find pleasing, but--

2:30:09- Yeah, I'll have to take the time with it, but--

2:30:11- Right.

2:30:12So the leather thing, I think,

2:30:15if you're familiar with their leather cases for iPhones,

2:30:18it's nothing like that.

2:30:19If you're familiar with the leather case they made

2:30:21for iPad that we mentioned earlier,

2:30:22it's really nothing like that either.

2:30:24Like that's what I was kind of expecting.

2:30:25The iPad case is a much thicker,

2:30:27more supple, more soft leather.

2:30:30The MacBook Pro leather case barely feels like leather.

2:30:34It feels more like a plastic composite kind of thing.

2:30:37- It does. - Because I think,

2:30:39I'm sure, if they say it's leather, I'm sure it is, but--

2:30:42- I'm sure too. - I think the leather is,

2:30:43it's probably a very, very thin layer of leather

2:30:46because any thicker leather layer would probably

2:30:49be pretty bulky and heavy at that size.

2:30:51But regardless, the iPad mind I think feels pretty good

2:30:55and provides a nice utility of having that pencil pocket

2:30:57for the Apple Pencil.

2:30:58This does not offer any, neither the good feel

2:31:03nor the additional utility of a pocket.

2:31:04- Yeah, if you came to me without telling me it was leather

2:31:08and said, "Do you think this is leather or not?"

2:31:10I think I might even guess no.

2:31:11What's that material that Microsoft started using

2:31:14and they use in the inside of cars?

2:31:15- Akatera. - Akatera.

2:31:17I might, I would think like,

2:31:19maybe what's that stuff that Microsoft,

2:31:21I would say the same thing and you'd say Akatera.

2:31:23I bet this is Akatera or something.

2:31:25- Yeah, I mean, 'cause it doesn't feel cloth-like.

2:31:27It feels like plastic gear or rubber,

2:31:30'cause it just, it feels like a very thin,

2:31:33like fake leather, basically,

2:31:34because it just, again, whatever the reasons were,

2:31:37whether it was cost, probably not.

2:31:39it was probably like thickness and weight at that size.

2:31:42It just doesn't feel good.

2:31:43I would, if you are a laptop sleeve person,

2:31:47which I've never been,

2:31:48so I don't really know the market that well,

2:31:50but if you are, I imagine the reason

2:31:53you would get a laptop sleeve would be what you said,

2:31:55which is like if you're putting it in a bag

2:31:56that does not have a padded compartment,

2:31:58you want like some padding,

2:31:59or you want like a dedicated thing,

2:32:00so other stuff in the same compartment

2:32:02doesn't scratch it up or something like that,

2:32:04this can provide some of that,

2:32:08but pretty much no other value.

2:32:10It doesn't provide, it doesn't give you a nice feel.

2:32:12I didn't think it looked very good either.

2:32:14And I just, I don't see why you'd want it, honestly.

2:32:18- Even the Syracuse types who want to fanatically maintain

2:32:23the exterior in as close to mint condition as they can,

2:32:28avoiding any and all fine, quote unquote, microabrasions,

2:32:32et cetera, I think the fact that it doesn't zip shut

2:32:34would be unappealing to them.

2:32:36Like, I can't see, even if Syracuse,

2:32:38in a $200, which I can't see him buying.

2:32:42I cannot see John buying a $200 leather sleeve.

2:32:45But even if it was free, I don't think he would use it

2:32:48'cause I don't think it would satisfy his,

2:32:50I need to feel like I can throw this anywhere

2:32:53and it's never gonna come into contact with anything.

2:32:55'Cause it's got an open end.

2:32:57- Not to mention, if you're putting stuff in and out of it,

2:32:59it's gonna get scratched from grit.

2:33:00- Right.

2:33:01- And especially because there was the open end.

2:33:03Then when the laptop is not in it, or even when it is.

2:33:05- And it's a very snug fit, right?

2:33:07So if any kind of grit got in there, it's not easy to get in.

2:33:10I mean, not hard either, but it is sort of like, you know,

2:33:13you know, like when you just put a check in an envelope, it's nice and easy.

2:33:21It's easy because an envelope is way bigger than the check.

2:33:23But when you put a greeting card in the greeting card envelope, it's like,

2:33:29shimmy it in.

2:33:30Yeah, you got to shimmy it in. That's exactly what it's like.

2:33:32This is like, when I put my 13-inch MacBook in my padded case up there,

2:33:36It's like putting a check in an envelope. It just goes in and out when I put this in the leather sleeve

2:33:41It's like putting a birthday card into the envelope and it's like you've got this envelope. That is exactly

2:33:461/16 of an inch bigger than the card. Yeah, I'm I'm guessing that after this trip of you having this one here

2:33:55I'm guessing I never see another one of these in the wild again. Oh

2:33:58The sleeve yeah, I can't imagine because I can't I don't know no

2:34:03It just doesn't seem like anything that would appeal

2:34:05to our friends.

2:34:06I mean, it might, well, I wonder.

2:34:09It just does not seem like an idea that has legs, you know?

2:34:12- I think it requires different execution

2:34:15than what they've done here.

2:34:16It requires, if you're gonna have something that size

2:34:19and that high market, it's gonna need to be better leather,

2:34:21it's gonna need to feel better,

2:34:22it's gonna need to be more supple,

2:34:23it's probably gonna need like an exterior pocket

2:34:26or something, like some additional utility

2:34:28in addition to nicer grade leather.

2:34:29- And it also seems like almost most people,

2:34:32typical people don't want to spend a lot on a case.

2:34:36And most people, you know, the whole side thing

2:34:38we can go on about how 90, at least seemingly 98%

2:34:41of iPhone users use a case.

2:34:44- We live in dark times.

2:34:46- But almost nobody, I see almost nobody

2:34:47in the real world with an Apple case.

2:34:49It's almost all third party.

2:34:51And I guess part of that is, you know,

2:34:53the way that people express their individualism

2:34:55and you see all sorts of, you know,

2:34:58just thousands, literally thousands of different designs

2:35:01in the iPhone cases is you walk around, you know,

2:35:04like a mall or an airport and you see people

2:35:06or Disney World and you see all these iPhones

2:35:07out taking cameras, you could go all day

2:35:09and never see the same case twice.

2:35:11But I very seldom see people using Apple cases.

2:35:14But when we're together, like at WWDC

2:35:17and our group of friends are together,

2:35:19among the people who use a case on their phone,

2:35:21we also see a disproportionate number of people like me

2:35:23who don't use a case, but we also see,

2:35:25I also notice clearly a disproportionate number of people

2:35:28who use the Apple case.

2:35:29- Yeah.

2:35:30I think part of it, I think the biggest part is that

2:35:34us, me, you, we're the sort of people like,

2:35:38Casey List, I think uses an Apple leather case,

2:35:42willing to spend $59 on a case for the iPhone

2:35:46because we really, really like the way it feels.

2:35:49- Yeah, the Apple leather case for the phone

2:35:50is really nice, I'm using one now

2:35:51'cause normally I'm caseless, but during the summertime,

2:35:54it slides out of my shorts pockets,

2:35:56and I'm sitting down, like every time I sit down,

2:35:57so I really like the Apple leather case.

2:36:00They've always been really nice.

2:36:01- Yeah, and sweaty, the last few years of iPhone designs

2:36:04have been very, very poor for sweaty hands

2:36:07and humid weather, and I don't have one on right now,

2:36:10but I actually packed one in my bag for this trip

2:36:12out of thinking, like, if my phone starts feeling slippery,

2:36:14I'm gonna put it in that case,

2:36:16and I like the way the leather feels,

2:36:17and I love the way that the buttons

2:36:19still feel like actual buttons,

2:36:21and not like I'm pushing the outline of a button

2:36:24on a case that is pushing a button on the case.

2:36:26It feels like I'm still pushing a button.

2:36:28- Yeah, a couple years ago, when they,

2:36:29I think it was the 6S generation

2:36:31where they switched the buttons in the case

2:36:33from just like dimples in the leather

2:36:35to actual like additional metal buttons

2:36:37and it made a huge difference in how it feels.

2:36:40- But I don't see that happening.

2:36:43So I think Apple does very, very,

2:36:46even though the majority of people

2:36:48with iPhone cases don't buy the Apple case,

2:36:50I still think Apple sells enough of the cases

2:36:51that it's a very, very successful

2:36:53little accessory business for them.

2:36:55I don't anticipate the leather sleeve being one.

2:36:58'Cause I feel like some people want a sleeve

2:37:01and they want a pocket and they want to carry

2:37:03other stuff in it.

2:37:04Other people want a sleeve and they just want

2:37:06something cheap to protect the laptop.

2:37:08And I don't think anybody who really likes

2:37:11fine leather goods and is willing to spend a premium for it

2:37:13is gonna like the feel of this case.

2:37:15I don't see who the market is.

2:37:17- Yeah, and I think we've probably spent more time

2:37:19talking about it than anybody else ever will.

2:37:21- This is your go-to podcast for discussion of Apple's

2:37:26$200 leather sleeve for the MacBook Pro.

2:37:29- Do you think any of the Apple executives

2:37:32that are on the leadership page on the site,

2:37:34so like the SVP level, the C level,

2:37:37do you think any of them have talked about this

2:37:38for this long with anybody?

2:37:41- I wonder, I don't think so.

2:37:42- I'm guessing not.

2:37:43- I suspect the one who would have the strongest,

2:37:47the two who would have the strongest opinion

2:37:48would be Angela Ahrendts, because she certainly knows

2:37:52her fine leather goods after having been CEO of Burberry

2:37:57and her experience in the clothing industry

2:38:01and fashion, whatever, whatever you'd like to describe

2:38:04her pre-Apple career as, and then maybe Schiller,

2:38:08just because Schiller cares about everything.

2:38:09- Yeah.

2:38:10- But I can't see Schiller using one.

2:38:13I just, I don't know.

2:38:17- Well, and they would, like an Apple person

2:38:18would never be seen using one of these cases.

2:38:20Like the same reason they always carry their iPhones

2:38:22without cases around there.

2:38:23Like that famous press Q&A where like,

2:38:27was it Steve, Phil, and Tim were up on stage?

2:38:29- And I'm the one who asked the question.

2:38:30- For Antennagate.

2:38:30Oh, that was you?

2:38:31- Yeah.

2:38:32- Oh, that's great.

2:38:33- You didn't know that?

2:38:34- I think I forgot.

2:38:35I think I knew it back then, but I forgot.

2:38:35- For those who don't know,

2:38:36when they held the special press conference

2:38:38in town hall for Antennagate,

2:38:40and if you'll recall,

2:38:42it was actually Apple's first owned cases.

2:38:44Like for the original 3G and 3GS,

2:38:47Apple didn't make any cases.

2:38:49And when the iPhone 4 came out,

2:38:51they still didn't make cases,

2:38:52'cause I think Apple was still opposed to the idea

2:38:55of putting phones in cases,

2:38:56but they made the quote unquote bumper,

2:38:59which was meant to be, as designed,

2:39:02it meant to be protection so that you could put it face down

2:39:04and the glass wouldn't hit the surface of the table

2:39:07and it would offer some sort of shock per, you know.

2:39:10But it was like a case that left the entire back exposed

2:39:12along with the front.

2:39:13- It was a case designed by people who clearly hated cases.

2:39:17- Yes, and the flat sides of the sort of rectilinear nature

2:39:22of the iPhone 4 and 4S design made it very amenable

2:39:26to that sort of thing.

2:39:27Like, I'm not sure that a bumper would work

2:39:30with the last few generations of round edge.

2:39:34- Nah. - I don't think so.

2:39:35I think it needs to be flat.

2:39:37But anyway, part of their solution to the publicity

2:39:40around Antennagate and the attenuation that some people

2:39:44who were holding their phones wrong experienced

2:39:46in low cell signal areas was, okay,

2:39:51we'll make the bumpers free.

2:39:52Everybody who buys an iPhone 4 can get

2:39:54an Apple bumper for free.

2:39:57And the bumper completely eliminated the problem

2:40:00because the whole problem was if your skin bridged a gap

2:40:04in the external steel antenna frame,

2:40:07that's what caused the problem because your skin

2:40:09would allow a signal to transfer from one antenna piece

2:40:13to another that it shouldn't.

2:40:15and if you had the bumper on,

2:40:16then your skin couldn't touch that gap.

2:40:19And then they did a Q&A, and people, which I think--

2:40:23- That was unheard of.

2:40:24- Oh, I think it's the last,

2:40:25still think it's the last time.

2:40:26It's the last time I was at a thing,

2:40:28at a press event where there was a Q&A,

2:40:30and I'd never been at one before.

2:40:31It was very, happened many more years ago, maybe more often,

2:40:35but this was truly unusual.

2:40:37And a couple of the initial questions from other people,

2:40:41other people in the media, seemed to be,

2:40:44I could sort of see a narrative emerging

2:40:47that wasn't, I didn't think was what Apple meant,

2:40:49but I could tell from the other questions

2:40:51that other members of the media

2:40:53were starting to form a narrative

2:40:55where Apple's answer to this antenna issue

2:40:58is that everybody, they're gonna give everybody a bumper

2:41:00and everybody should use it.

2:41:02- Like a software patch almost.

2:41:03Like you should install this.

2:41:05- Right, like to properly use this phone

2:41:07and maintain a cell signal,

2:41:08you're gonna put this free bumper on.

2:41:10And so my question was, and it was Schiller,

2:41:15well, a guy named Steve Jobs.

2:41:17- Was it Tim, I assume? - No, I don't think

2:41:20it was Tim. - Was it Jaws, maybe?

2:41:22- Nope, I think it might have been,

2:41:24Bob Mansfield was up there.

2:41:26- Oh, okay, 'cause I think it was only three of them total,

2:41:28so that must be it.

2:41:29- I don't think Tim Cook was up there,

2:41:31so it would have been 2010, it would have been July of 2010.

2:41:35And I think, I know Schiller and Jobs

2:41:37and big Bob Mansfield were up there,

2:41:40and I don't think Tim Cook was, I think it was just the three.

2:41:42Four would be too many.

2:41:43And I raised my hand, I think it was Jobs who called on me,

2:41:48but he just pointed and I said,

2:41:52I think there's video of it, but I think I just asked,

2:41:57does everybody need to use, or I just said,

2:42:01I don't know, I formulated it very well.

2:42:03I'm usually very poor, I'm doing a very poor job

2:42:05of re-grading the question right now,

2:42:07but I think I just asked, do you guys use a bumper

2:42:10or do you just carry it without one and have no problem?

2:42:12And instead of answering the question,

2:42:14all three had this, without even saying anything--

2:42:16- It was perfect, it was like the perfect PR move.

2:42:18- They all three reached into their right jeans pocket

2:42:21and pulled out a naked iPhone 4.

2:42:24And the crowd laughed, and I was like,

2:42:27ah, that worked out really well.

2:42:28I'm really glad I got my question asked.

2:42:30- Yeah. (laughs)

2:42:32So yeah, I think it does seem like the official position

2:42:35that Apple tries to express,

2:42:37like in their executives' public appearances,

2:42:39is that you don't need a case for their phones.

2:42:41- Right.

2:42:42And you don't need a leather sleeve for your MacBook Pro.

2:42:46Well, we've been going on long enough.

2:42:49- This is short for us.

2:42:50- Yeah, it is short for us.

2:42:51I was gonna go on a whole thing

2:42:53about this whole podcast hosting thing,

2:42:55but I don't know that we need to.

2:42:56- Nah.

2:42:57- I don't know, you might have opinions.

2:43:00Do you have any opinions on podcasting?

2:43:02(laughs)

2:43:03- Never.

2:43:06How's it going with the watch version of Overcast now

2:43:11that you can actually play audio in the background?

2:43:14Can you talk about that?

2:43:14- Oh man, yeah, I mean it's in development still,

2:43:16but the development version's pretty much done.

2:43:18I hope to be in beta pretty soon.

2:43:21And yeah, when this fall,

2:43:22when WatchOS 5 and iOS 12 come out this fall,

2:43:25Overcast has full standalone watch playback,

2:43:28and it's great.

2:43:29It's finally doable.

2:43:31The OS finally gives app developers what we needed

2:43:35to make that compelling at all,

2:43:37to make it even barely functional at all.

2:43:38And it turns out, it turned out really great.

2:43:40I use it all the time now, and I can't wait to ship it.

2:43:44- Yeah, and it's an interesting combination

2:43:46of a couple of finalies where, I mean,

2:43:49and I've been doing this for years

2:43:50in my sporadic jogging habit of somehow trying to get by

2:43:55with the least amount of kit while I can still

2:43:59either listen to music or podcasts.

2:44:02And I did the thing for a while where I had

2:44:04the little square iPod Nano on a,

2:44:09what was it called, the TikTok wristband?

2:44:10- Oh yeah, that Kickstarter wrist strap for it.

2:44:12- It was like one of the first Kickstarter sensation

2:44:14projects, it was like a watch band for the square iPod Nano

2:44:19that in hindsight was humongous as a watch,

2:44:22but allowed you, but as Tim Cook famously said

2:44:25before the watch, the wrist is an interesting place.

2:44:28And it's an interesting place,

2:44:29it was always an interesting place to put a little thing

2:44:31like that for the reason that it for over a century now has been an interesting place to

2:44:36put a carry-on timepiece and the biggest problem with it wasn't the wristband it was a fine

2:44:42wristband and it wasn't you know looking at it which was great it was a great place to put it

2:44:47because you could see it like when you clipped it on your shirt you couldn't really see it the

2:44:52problem was for audio having a cable go from your wrist to your ears was often awful because that

2:45:00before Bluetooth was really—

2:45:01- Oh, yeah, it was definitely before Bluetooth.

2:45:03And you'd have this, you know,

2:45:04and it always sort of felt like you had an IV

2:45:06hooked up to you, you know?

2:45:07(laughing)

2:45:09Like, it's just, like, in a way that it just never feels

2:45:11good to be tethered to an IV when you're in the hospital

2:45:15or, you know, drawing blood or whatever, you know,

2:45:17is going on.

2:45:18It just never felt good to have a cable

2:45:20connected to my wrist and my head, you know?

2:45:24But I feel like we're finally at the point

2:45:26where we will finally be this fall

2:45:27when WatchOS comes out with this support

2:45:29where a combination of AirPods and Apple Watch

2:45:32with audio support, good audio support,

2:45:36will actually give us a thing that we've,

2:45:38I've been looking for for, you know, 15 years.

2:45:41- Yeah, they finally gave it to us.

2:45:43And again, I have been using it.

2:45:45I've been testing with it, doing lots of dog walks

2:45:47with just my watch and everything, and it's great.

2:45:50And I think, you know, ultimately,

2:45:52I don't think people are gonna use it that much

2:45:54compared to using their phone,

2:45:55because your phone is still better if you have it with you.

2:45:58but if you don't have it with you,

2:46:00or if you don't wanna have it with you,

2:46:01this now gives you the option.

2:46:02- Yeah, it really exemplifies, to me,

2:46:05an unusual pattern for Apple.

2:46:07In the old days, Microsoft was famous for this pattern

2:46:11of doing an absolutely dreadful 1.0,

2:46:15that even at a point where they were a successful company,

2:46:18or maybe the most successful company in all of technology,

2:46:21whatever they came out with as a 1.0 would be terrible,

2:46:24and even the might of, marketing might of Microsoft

2:46:26couldn't make it, it was both bad, technically,

2:46:31and a failure in the market.

2:46:34But then, rather than abandon it,

2:46:36keep their nose to the grindstone

2:46:37and do a 2.0 that still wasn't any good,

2:46:40but was clearly better, and still not give up on it,

2:46:45and spend another 18 months at it,

2:46:47and come out with a 3.0,

2:46:48and it is best exemplified by Windows, right?

2:46:50Nobody even, most, there are very few people of any age

2:46:53who remember any version of Windows prior to Windows 3.1,

2:46:57really, but that 3.0, look,

2:46:58when you show people screenshots of Windows 2,

2:47:00and especially Windows 1, I never saw Windows 2 or 1, never.

2:47:03- Neither did I.

2:47:04My first computer had 3.1 on it.

2:47:06- I was a nerd, and I had friends who had PCs,

2:47:08and I don't even know that we knew Windows existed.

2:47:13They just never left, they never used anything but DOS.

2:47:15But Windows is the,

2:47:17but there are all sorts of Microsoft products like that.

2:47:19And I don't know that the watch was quite that bad,

2:47:21but it's a similar,

2:47:23Apple's better known for coming out with a sensation.

2:47:26You know, like the way that, oh, there were so many problems

2:47:28with the original iPhone and it edged networking

2:47:31and didn't even shoot video

2:47:32and the still photos were terrible

2:47:34and it was really kind of underpowered CPU-wise.

2:47:38- Didn't have GPS either.

2:47:39- Didn't have GPS.

2:47:40It was missing all sorts of ridiculous things.

2:47:42Didn't even have an app store, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

2:47:43But it was still, it was just a sensation.

2:47:45It was absolu--

2:47:46And you know, and in hindsight, sensation,

2:47:49it's like it only sold like 11 million in the first year

2:47:51or something like that.

2:47:52It was way more millions than they promised to sell,

2:47:56but it was just a great product.

2:47:57Apple's known for stuff like that.

2:47:58The watch is almost evolving more

2:48:00in like a Microsoft-like fashion,

2:48:02where the first one was really like--

2:48:05- Real rough. - Really rough,

2:48:06and you really didn't see a lot of them out in the field,

2:48:09even among our friends, you know, or our crowd even.

2:48:14And here we are, you know, what, four years later?

2:48:18- Three, four, yeah. - Yeah.

2:48:20And it is a really compelling,

2:48:22And I see them all over the place, you know, here in the beach town everybody they're all over the place

2:48:26Yeah, I see them everywhere, right and it just really seems even all rumors of you know

2:48:32Design refresh possibly coming at later this year. That'll make it thinner or whatever

2:48:38but finally sort of like a new look after

2:48:41Forged three or three generations of sort of the identical industrial design actually even getting thicker actually year over year

2:48:51But just the software side of it is it really seems like there's a couple of final is in there that it's really becoming a compelling

2:48:57product

2:48:59And finally really the first time really becoming interesting for third-party apps

2:49:03Yeah

2:49:04That's you know

2:49:05The the the hardware has been fairly decent on the watch since since long with the exception of the first one just being super slow

2:49:11But but the software it was really like prohibitively

2:49:16limited for third-party apps especially

2:49:19until really until watchOS 3 and 4 at least and

2:49:23watchOS 5 makes a number of

2:49:25Seemingly small changes but changes that make or break certain uses like audio

2:49:30So anyway, that's good to hear

2:49:33It was actually a loaded question because I've I've played with the beta running on Marcos watches

2:49:38They're a little behind the scenes in type for you. I actually totally cheated knew the answer that question before I asked

2:49:45Yeah, I also knew the way suitcases have washed the laundry bags, but here we are

2:49:49Like I said, there are numerous advantages to recording a podcast in the same room as opposed to two or three hundred miles apart Marco

2:49:57Thank you so much. Do you?

2:49:59Can thank you for tons of things this week, but taking the time out to do this is

2:50:04Truly truly tremendous. Thanks for having me. My pleasure. It's always a joy. All right, my thanks to our sponsors

2:50:11We had Squarespace where you can go to build a website. We had a way where you can buy

2:50:16excellent luggage

2:50:19We had trace Pontus who made the coffee that I finished over an hour ago and wished I had remembered to bring the pot in

2:50:25Yes, I have three more pounds in the kitchen

2:50:28So I think we're all right for at least a day so that I could go have more and last but not least

2:50:33Mac Weldon makers of excellent daily essentials things like underwear t-shirts socks

2:50:41a very stylish long-lasting and so easy to buy my thanks to all of them and of course

2:50:47to Marco Arment

2:50:49For his time. Thanks

2:50:51All right. There we go. That was good. Yeah short for us

2:50:56Yeah, it really was. That's kind of funny, that really was.