0:00:00What a week. What a week.
0:00:02God. So I thought that we would be talking about my interview with
0:00:08Craig Federighi and Eddy Cue and Apple Software Quality and we can get to that later
0:00:13but obviously this is this is a week when there's actually a very clear... I can't wait to get to that later.
0:00:19So let's I mean for anybody who's had their head in the ground all week
0:00:25Or anybody who I guess is listening, you know
0:00:28I guess you always have to preface these podcasts because who knows when somebody's gonna listen to you know
0:00:32Go back and listen to old episodes, but this was the week
0:00:34where
0:00:36Tuesday night Apple published an open letter from Tim Cook
0:00:39Revealing that the FBI had obtained a court order to compel Apple to
0:00:46Long story short supply the FBI with a custom version of iOS that would help them
0:00:54break the passcode of an iPhone 5C that was owned by,
0:00:59or wasn't really owned by, was used by one of the shooters
0:01:06in the San Bernardino incident a few months ago.
0:01:10- Right.
0:01:11- And Apple is saying that they have helped
0:01:15and cooperated with law enforcement many times in the past,
0:01:19and I think they might still in the future,
0:01:21but in terms of what they're willing to do,
0:01:23supplying, you know, more or less writing malware for iOS is a line that they
0:01:28don't want to cross. And then all hell broke loose.
0:01:34Well I have a lot of respect for Apple for standing up for it, you know, for
0:01:40what they believe in. They could just as easily have, you know, gone along
0:01:46with it and kept quiet, but they didn't. Yeah, I wrote it, you know, it's a
0:01:52- Funny thing, we can write about this too.
0:01:54It's an interesting, I took an interesting strategy
0:01:59this week on "Daring Firebolt."
0:02:00I've been very active, I have a lot of posts on this,
0:02:02but I didn't write like a feature of a column or article.
0:02:05It's all just links and my commentary interspersed in there
0:02:09without really writing one big article.
0:02:11And I expected, like when I woke up Wednesday morning,
0:02:14I thought, well, I gotta write,
0:02:15I have to write like a big piece about this.
0:02:17And as I started like reading everything that was out there,
0:02:21I was like, you know, one way to put it would be that
0:02:24I spent the week blogging, not writing.
0:02:26- Yeah. - Right.
0:02:27- You know what I mean?
0:02:28And in a way, I feel like it was a better use of my time
0:02:31and a better service to the readers of Daring Fireball
0:02:35because I found so many good articles
0:02:37that other people had written
0:02:39that were making the points I wanted to make
0:02:40that rather than remake them myself,
0:02:43why not just point them to them
0:02:45and then add my two cents on this?
0:02:47But anyway, one of the points I did make,
0:02:49And I really think it's important for people who listen to our shows or read our websites because I think
0:02:53overwhelmingly the people who like read during fireball or the loop and listen to the talk show are
0:02:58already on our side and that they they and that they have a basic enough grasp of the way encryption works that they
0:03:04See apples point
0:03:07But I really can't emphasize enough how many you know how I
0:03:11Don't we're in an echo chamber here with the people who agree with this and if you get outside it and go to the real
0:03:17world where people don't understand encryption, the support for Apple is not as clear-cut or
0:03:23blanket. And it's dangerous for Apple politically that they really are going out on the limb.
0:03:29>> Yeah, they really are. And it's not funny, I guess, but it's...
0:03:37When you look at the case that the FBI chose to use this on, I mean, they were very deliberate.
0:03:46They wanted something that would fire up the public so much against Apple.
0:03:51And in some ways that's worked. You know, people are saying, in some circles, people are saying
0:04:00that Apple should comply because these were bad people and we need to stop bad people. But there's
0:04:07bigger issues than that. It's not just this one issue. Yeah, it's not so much maybe fired up
0:04:13against Apple is the wrong way to put it. Not to quibble with your words, but it's a
0:04:17little bit more that people would universally side with the FBI and say, "Well, the FBI
0:04:23has got to be able to get at these people's phones." And it really is a just perfectly
0:04:29crafted case from the FBI's perspective because it was a terrible incident. Everybody agrees
0:04:34with that. I mean, Apple goes out of its way to say, "This is a terrible incident and we'll
0:04:39do anything we can that we think is within the law and within our the
0:04:45interest of maintaining overall security for our users to help but let's just
0:04:49face it I mean the fact that these were people from a Muslim background it it
0:04:56makes it even worse there's there's an element to and there's a lot you know as
0:04:59opposed to if it was the guy remember it was just like a week or two prior to
0:05:04that if it was the guy from Colorado who shot up Planned Parenthood, that wouldn't do it
0:05:11at the way that having it be suspects of a Muslim descent, just because that's the way
0:05:18it is, that's human nature.
0:05:20Yeah.
0:05:21And that's what they're banking on.
0:05:24Right.
0:05:25That it's just that the politics of that and the emotional dynamic of that are just overwhelmingly
0:05:32powerful. And I don't know that it is. I think Ann Apple is saying, maybe not.
0:05:38Well, and I think if you look at Tim Cook's letter, it's very compelling. I think it was well thought out, very well written, and he brings up some really great points.
0:05:55I mean, that was written, I mean, you could see Tim saying that.
0:06:00And I think by now we all can believe what Tim says. He stands on principle,
0:06:10and he does what he says he's going to do.
0:06:14Tom Bilyeu (01;01;01;01)
0:06:17Matthew Panzareno had a good article pointing out the differences, that there's one of the
0:06:24cynical takes on this is, and it's definitely not just from one source and
0:06:30Matthew Panzareno's story had a couple of links to it, but I'm gonna paraphrase it,
0:06:34but that more or less claiming that Apple is showboating and trying to gain
0:06:40publicity for being, you know, having these super secure phones and, you know,
0:06:46getting people to say, "Wow, iPhone is so powerful the FBI can't even crack it," and
0:06:50and using that as a positive thing.
0:06:52And in the past, Apple has helped the FBI 70 times
0:06:56to do the same thing.
0:06:58And, you know, if you wanna be cynical like that
0:07:03and say that Apple is trying to make this a thing
0:07:05that brag about the iPhone security, you're welcome to.
0:07:08But I really think that that's,
0:07:10I don't think that's the case.
0:07:13I think it's so risky because now you've got
0:07:15like presidential candidates, like don't, you know,
0:07:17ridiculous, ridiculous that I'm talking about
0:07:20seriously, but he is the lead, the leading Republican presidential candidate is saying flat
0:07:26out Apple Apple should absolutely who do they think they are? Where his actual words? Who do
0:07:30they think they are? He'd be you know, they absolutely should comply with this court case
0:07:33that it's become part of our, you know, political debate. And to say that this is a sure win,
0:07:38you know, PR wise for Apple is to me, I think you're looking for the cynical angle. But the
0:07:45bigger difference is that what Apple has done in the past when they've helped law enforcement
0:07:48is very different. And I know saying very might you might say,
0:07:53Oh, it seems, you know, just like one little step. It's
0:07:55different. It's, you know, in the past, they've helped them,
0:07:58you know, without modifying the software, help them use the
0:08:01software as is to get data off the phone, right. And in times
0:08:06past, in years past, a lot less of the information on the phones
0:08:09was encrypted. It's really only in recent years that the entire
0:08:15disk of the, you know, storage volume of the iPhone is full disk encrypted. Let me ask you something.
0:08:21Why do you think the other tech companies haven't taken a stronger stand?
0:08:28Well, I think it's multifaceted, but I think one of them is that, and I think it was
0:08:39was Panzareno again who had the, was it the why Apple piece and more or less, no
0:08:44it wasn't Panzareno, it was Kieran Healy who I linked to, that's right. I'll try to
0:08:50put that in the show notes, but Kieran Healy, his argument was to
0:08:55again to paraphrase, Apple's the only company that still makes hardware, that
0:08:59really is a hardware company and because of that, you know, none of these other
0:09:03companies, you know, Google, yes, Google makes Nexus devices and yes Microsoft
0:09:07makes the Nokia phones, which have literally no exaggeration,
0:09:12like 1.1% market share.
0:09:16It's not as important to them, whereas Apple's fundamental business is selling
0:09:19hardware to people.
0:09:20And that there's a trust issue there that puts Apple in a position
0:09:27that no other company really is, where this is a big deal.
0:09:31Secondarily, I think that there are other-- and again,
0:09:34this is starting to be a little cynical.
0:09:36but I think that, you know, and the New York Times
0:09:38has even mentioned this in articles,
0:09:39but that Apple doesn't depend on government sales
0:09:42to a large degree, whereas Microsoft just signed,
0:09:45for example, a huge deal to get the entire
0:09:48Department of Defense to upgrade all of their PCs
0:09:51to Windows 10, and that they don't wanna anger them.
0:09:56I'm not quite sure why Google doesn't take a stronger stand,
0:10:00but they clearly don't.
0:10:02- Yeah.
0:10:03- What do you think?
0:10:04Well, I was talking to Peter Cohen last night,
0:10:08and Peter said,
0:10:10maybe they don't want everybody to know
0:10:15that they've already cooperated with the government,
0:10:17which is, you know, really cynical, Stan, but,
0:10:21I don't know, I mean, obviously they don't want
0:10:28the FBI sites turned on them.
0:10:31- Right. - You know, they're just
0:10:31trying to keep their head down.
0:10:33that's an obvious point, but is there something else in there?
0:10:38I mean, if they take a big stand,
0:10:42is the government gonna come back and say,
0:10:43well, what are you talking about?
0:10:45You've already given us lots of info.
0:10:48- Right, that in some way, however, to whatever degree
0:10:51they've already cooperated with the government in the past
0:10:52is something the government can hold against them,
0:10:54publicity-wise.
0:10:55That might be a good argument there.
0:10:57And I'll just emphasize, one of the things that's,
0:11:00I think, overlooked in this,
0:11:02if you just look at it in broad terms that,
0:11:03wow, Apple won't cooperate with the FBI
0:11:05on this San Bernardino case.
0:11:07They have already, like they, and just for example,
0:11:10the suspect in this case apparently was using
0:11:13iCloud backup until a certain point.
0:11:16And I actually think this is one of the things
0:11:20that I've been looking around.
0:11:21I don't know that we on the outside
0:11:23have a very good understanding of just how available,
0:11:27what is the encryption on the stuff
0:11:30that's backed up from iCloud, like when they come.
0:11:34But anyway, Apple did comply with the FBI
0:11:37and supplied them with access to some,
0:11:40some, some subset of their,
0:11:42whatever is the unencrypted part of the iCloud backup
0:11:45from the San Bernardino shooter.
0:11:47The reason the FBI wants the phone
0:11:49is that there was like six weeks
0:11:51after the last backup to iCloud,
0:11:53you know, between the last backup and the incident.
0:11:58And they're concerned,
0:12:00And it seems like a reasonable concern that maybe there's some actionable intelligence in that interim.
0:12:07But it's not like Apple hasn't done what they can. They're just saying, "Here's a line we're not going to draw."
0:12:11Or, "We are going to draw."
0:12:13I want to read this one bit from Tim Cook's letter. There's a whole thing that's really good, but I really like this part.
0:12:19"The government is asking Apple to hack our own users and undermine decades of security advancements that protect our customers,
0:12:26tens of millions of American citizens from sophisticated hackers and cyber criminals.
0:12:29And here's the, to me, the really compelling part of this.
0:12:33The same engineers who built strong encryption into the iPhone to protect our users would,
0:12:39ironically, be ordered to weaken those protections and make our users less safe.
0:12:45And I, to me, that is really compelling.
0:12:46I, you know, if you're an engineer at Apple who works on this security stuff, you're more
0:12:52less your career is devoted to only in one direction making things more secure
0:12:59for users and then to be compelled to do the exact opposite is I honestly I think
0:13:05it's something that some people would object to do that some people would say
0:13:08you know you can court order me to do it but I'm not gonna do it and would they
0:13:12be right in some sense I mean maybe not Lee I'm not a lawyer I can't I can't say
0:13:17legally that they could object but certainly morally great
0:13:22i i mean i i i don't know where this goes
0:13:28what if
0:13:31apple is compelled to do this what do they do
0:13:36well i mean we know what's going to the supreme court either way
0:13:42I guess. I honestly don't know how stuff works its way through the Supreme Court though.
0:13:49In a case where the FBI might be saying, "Time is of the essence. We want to get this information while it's still warm."
0:13:58There's no point to getting it. They're not building a case. One thing to note, just in case anybody has forgotten the details of it,
0:14:04they're not using this to build a criminal case against the San Bernardino shooters because they're dead.
0:14:10So, it's really just trying to find actionable intelligence that might lead them to discover
0:14:16if there was anybody else involved, if there's anybody else they know who they ought to be
0:14:21looking at who might be planning something in the future.
0:14:26So in that case, time is of the essence, so I don't know.
0:14:30I would guess it's going to, though?
0:14:35the FBI obviously you know in the Justice Department has some sort of path
0:14:39to expedite you know a case to the Supreme Court. But aren't they using this
0:14:43more as a precedent so that they can say okay you you've been ordered to do this
0:14:49and by the way we have these other five phones that we need it done on. Right I
0:14:54think I think that this is all about precedent I think it's less and again
0:15:00you can accuse me of being cynical and maybe I'm wrong but it it seems to me
0:15:04from what I know of the case, that the two San Bernardino suspects didn't don't really
0:15:10seem like they were part of, you know, a widespread terrorist group. It wasn't like they were
0:15:17really part of like a al Qaeda or ISIS or whatever, you know, other groups are out there.
0:15:23That they were just two kooks, you know, and, you know, mentally ill and and poisoned by
0:15:30this ideology, but it doesn't really seem like they were any kind of masterminds.
0:15:35I mean, it wasn't really a very—I mean, it was a terrible tragedy, but it really seemed
0:15:39a little bit more bitterly personal that they went and shot up a place where they worked,
0:15:42and they had personal beefs with the people who shot it up.
0:15:46So I think, logically, that the FBI making a big case of this isn't really about getting
0:15:55information that's going to save people and that they really need it. I think it's
0:16:00about the precedent. I mean, and that once you've got what if they win this, and they
0:16:05get this, they have a precedent that says we can come now we can use this precedent
0:16:10to compel tech companies, not just to give this give us information that they have access
0:16:16to, but to force them to write software that gives us the access that we want to write.
0:16:23I mean, and it's all sorts of there's all sorts of implications that this if you take
0:16:28precedent is as logical that all sorts of things could happen could they compel apple to re-engineer
0:16:34iMessage to to uh to so that it's not end-to-end encrypted anymore right and the the fallout from
0:16:44this is endless could be but okay so let's look at it the other way what if apple wins
0:16:54I think that nothing bad happens.
0:16:58I think.
0:16:59I mean, and I guess other than the fact that it's possible that in the future case there
0:17:05would be one where there's information on a phone that law enforcement has and they
0:17:11can't get to it and if they could, it would be better for society.
0:17:15but that sort of situation is,
0:17:20that's the price of liberty, right?
0:17:25Like you can't take,
0:17:25I don't think you can take the absolute,
0:17:27I personally feel very strongly,
0:17:29you can't take the absolutist position
0:17:31that law enforcement should be able to get anything
0:17:33and everything they want.
0:17:35- Let's say that the FBI wins,
0:17:37and now Apple has to write the software
0:17:41and break into the phone,
0:17:43but what's stopping people then just not using Apple's built-in things and using another
0:17:51form of app and strong encryption?
0:17:54Right.
0:17:55Do they, does the FBI then need to sue that company to open it up?
0:17:59Right.
0:18:00That's one of the reasons that I feel, I honestly feel that the FBI is being driven,
0:18:06and part of this is really driven by the public statements of like FBI director Comey and
0:18:10others is that a large part of this is, I hate to say it, because I'd like to think
0:18:17that we'd have better people in there, but people who genuinely don't understand the
0:18:21technology.
0:18:22And they don't understand that either everybody has security through encryption or nobody
0:18:30does, and that there is no way to have security.
0:18:35And again, a couple of people have emphasized this.
0:18:38privacy angles on this but there's I think the security angle is is more
0:18:45compelling and you know it's a little you know some of its conflated but it's
0:18:49you know what happens if somebody steals your phone or you leave it in a cab and
0:18:56somebody gets it and it's it's not it and it's relatively easier there's some
0:19:01sort of known way to get to the contents of it well there's that's genuine
0:19:06security problem given the information that a lot of us have on our phones. You know,
0:19:10financial information, you know, and the personal information, you know, the photos we have
0:19:15and stuff like that. It's definitely a security thing, but I feel like that the FBI clearly
0:19:23doesn't see this properly, that they're looking, they're somehow looking for some kind of magic
0:19:28solution, but it would really, like a law that crippled Apple's ability just to pick
0:19:35one company, or any US company though, but a US company to not have secure encryption
0:19:42on these devices would really harm them in the worldwide market. It truly would because
0:19:49there's absolutely nothing. It wouldn't keep people, bad guys, from having encryption.
0:19:53It would only keep them from having encryption out of the box on a US-made device. Right?
0:20:00Isn't that what, I mean, that's more or less what you're saying, right?
0:20:03Yeah, and okay, so the US government wins this
0:20:07Then every other government is gonna come and say yeah, we kind of want to look at this fellas phone
0:20:13Absolutely and you know that there's this funny thing and who knows by the time the show airs
0:20:20Maybe the times will have a separate story about it. But there was this weird thing. I linked to yesterday where it was actually
0:20:29Edward Snowden was the one whose Twitter account and he's been all over this on Twitter for obvious reasons
0:20:35but Edward Snowden noted a passage in a New York Times story on this that was about China and
0:20:42Like within an hour that whole segment of the article was edited out of the New York Times article and it still isn't back
0:20:49But basically here's what it said. I'll just read it
0:20:51This is from a New York Times report China is watching the dispute closely analysts say the Chinese government
0:20:56does take cues from the United States when it comes to encryption regulations and that it would most likely demand that
0:21:02multinational companies provide
0:21:04accommodations similar to those in the United States. Last year Beijing backed off several proposals that would have mandated that foreign firms provide
0:21:11providing encryption keys for devices sold in China after
0:21:14heavy pressure from foreign trade groups.
0:21:17A push from American law enforcement agencies to unlock iPhones would embolden Beijing to demand the same.
0:21:24I think it's clear.
0:21:28I mean, China is just one country.
0:21:29I mean, why wouldn't every country?
0:21:31- Right, and then what?
0:21:32Is Apple's gonna need to open up a brand new company
0:21:35just to deal with all of this stuff?
0:21:38- Right.
0:21:39- I mean, does Apple give the software to the FBI
0:21:44in order to hack it themselves,
0:21:47or does the FBI give the device to Apple and Apple does it?
0:21:51- I believe from what I read of this case
0:21:53FBI has offered either way that they've said whatever you want if you want to
0:21:58give us the software and have us do it we'll do it if you want us to bring the
0:22:03device to you and do it at your facilities we'll do that they just want
0:22:06the code but it's a slippery slope either way I really do think so I
0:22:11absolutely and I know that slippery slope arguments it maybe they're
0:22:16overused you know overall just in our debates about all sorts of stuff but I
0:22:21but I think in this case, it really is a slippery slope.
0:22:26- Isn't the government's position
0:22:29that they just want this one device?
0:22:33That's all we want, we just want this one device.
0:22:36But once that's done, there's no turning back.
0:22:40- Right, because that's how the law works.
0:22:42It's one case sets precedent for future cases.
0:22:45- Yeah, which is why Apple has to take a stand on this one.
0:22:48And that's why I think what the government did
0:22:52in choosing this case was so strategic for them.
0:22:57- Yeah, I think, and again, the basic,
0:23:01just about it with, if you really wanna talk
0:23:04about good guys and bad guys,
0:23:06is that even reasonably smart and well-organized bad guys
0:23:11are going to use their own encryption software.
0:23:14Not necessarily that they wrote, but that they're going to,
0:23:17It obviously is out there and the US can't stop
0:23:21the rest of the world from writing
0:23:23good secure encryption software.
0:23:25- Right.
0:23:27- They're just going to use third party software
0:23:30if the first party software can.
0:23:32And maybe for reasonable reasons,
0:23:34maybe the smart ones already don't trust
0:23:36anything written by Apple or Google
0:23:39or any other US company and they're already doing it.
0:23:43And the dumb bad guys--
0:23:45(laughing)
0:23:48They're dumb, right?
0:23:49So why do you need to make everybody's software insecure?
0:23:53Do your job, right?
0:23:55And I guess part of it is that there's an entitlement
0:23:58in the US, like law enforcement gets so,
0:24:01in the US is in such a privileged position
0:24:04in terms of what they get and the way that they're,
0:24:10you know, they have access to so much stuff.
0:24:13But that there's a sense of entitlement
0:24:15that not only should they be able to get stuff,
0:24:16but they should be able to get whatever they want easily.
0:24:19And there is, you know, that's not necessarily the case.
0:24:21If the truth is that it's really,
0:24:23really mathematically difficult,
0:24:26or even to the point of calling it impossible
0:24:28to break the encryption on a device,
0:24:30well, tough noogies, you know what I mean?
0:24:31You've got that's, you know, you guys have a tough job.
0:24:34I mean, I'm not saying that glibly,
0:24:36and I realized that the stakes can be high
0:24:38in a criminal case or in an investigation,
0:24:41but that's just the way it is.
0:24:43It's really, it's not that different than arguing.
0:24:48And I go, these analogies sometimes to the real world can get difficult, but it's like,
0:24:58sometimes people will say, you know, how would you feel if somebody kidnapped a family member
0:25:05and the police knew where they were,
0:25:10but they couldn't break down the door.
0:25:12That's a rough, that's a tough analogy
0:25:15because I don't think there exists a door
0:25:18that the police can't break into.
0:25:19- Right.
0:25:20- But that's sort, but what if you could make one?
0:25:22What if somebody invents a door,
0:25:26you could build a house that the police can't break into?
0:25:30Would that be illegal?
0:25:31Not with, there's no law against it now.
0:25:33you'd have to pass a law specifically against it, right?
0:25:36It's just that the math is such that we've been able
0:25:38to make virtual locks through encryption
0:25:42that are actually unbreakable.
0:25:44- The government of all organizations tells us to be safe
0:25:52and tells us to, you know,
0:25:54not necessarily encrypt everything,
0:25:58but do everything that you can to protect yourself
0:26:01your identity and protect all of this stuff. But as soon as they make a backdoor, then
0:26:07that backdoor is there for everybody. And I don't know what they don't understand
0:26:13about that. I mean, you mentioned it earlier about these people not understanding the technology,
0:26:18but do they not care that they're making a backdoor? Or do they really not understand
0:26:25that once a backdoor is there, it's there for all?
0:26:27Well, I'll just mention Trump before. I'll pick someone from the other side.
0:26:31But I've listened to Hillary Clinton talk about this several times.
0:26:36And her argument is, "We'll put enough smart people in a room,
0:26:41and I'm sure they'll be able to come up with something."
0:26:44And I genuinely think she believes that.
0:26:48But what they're looking for and what they claim that
0:26:54Smart people at Apple and Google ought to be able to make is is
0:26:57Something that the FBI can use and no one else can use and that's just not that's not possible
0:27:01And there's just we keep talking in circles about it, but there's just no way that it could happen
0:27:08so
0:27:10Doesn't the government have enough smart people of their own that are telling them?
0:27:15This is impossible. I don't know there must be at it at a certain level
0:27:21Right, but that maybe that they're not because they're not at the you know
0:27:25Executive ranks that they're you know, they're it's treated as well. That's your argument, you know, here's our argument
0:27:33we want the information and
0:27:36It seems to be kind of a you know, they've got the blinders on and they can see
0:27:42Beyond Apple is the information they just have to get through Apple to get it
0:27:48Yeah, this all fits with something and I think Apple is not surprised by this
0:27:53I think Apple as I don't you know, I know a couple of these articles have really put this as a
0:27:58Lynch pin of the Tim Cook era at Apple and I'm not quite sure how much that has to do with the difference between Tim
0:28:05Cook and Steve Jobs and how much it has to do with just the timing of
0:28:08you know when jobs got ill enough to step down and
0:28:13Cook took over, you know, which is when this issue became hot, you know that
0:28:18that, you know, it just coincides, you know, that the transition from jobs to Cook coincides
0:28:26with when this, you know, the cell phones as objects of desire from law enforcement really
0:28:32heated up. But the gist of it is, I heard this years ago from a couple people at Apple, was that
0:28:39the edict came down from the top, from Tim Cook on down, that anything new that we create that stores
0:28:47data, we should store in a way that even we can't see it. So that when we get
0:28:55requests for it, we can say we can't give it to you. And that
0:29:02anything we already have existing systems that maybe don't comply with
0:29:06that, they need to be identified and we need to rewrite them in a way that
0:29:12that protects the data so that even we can't do it
0:29:16and that that's the only way that we can object.
0:29:19And the purpose of this isn't to obstruct law enforcement,
0:29:24it's that if we don't take that philosophy
0:29:27that even we can't get the data, then it's not really safe.
0:29:31- Right, and I think that goes back a lot
0:29:35to where Apple makes its money.
0:29:38They don't want your data.
0:29:39They don't care about your data.
0:29:41and others do.
0:29:44So, you know, it's reasonable,
0:29:47I mean the argument that we talked about with Peter,
0:29:50it's reasonable to consider the fact
0:29:53that other companies have cooperated in the past
0:29:58because they do look at the data, you know?
0:30:01- Yeah, one of the things, and another one,
0:30:04I know I mentioned earlier that I'm really curious
0:30:06about what, let's just say,
0:30:09if you're a iCloud backup user,
0:30:11and the FBI comes to Apple and says,
0:30:15"We'd like to see Jim Dalrymple's iCloud backup."
0:30:18What do they get?
0:30:19I would love to know that.
0:30:21And if there's an answer that Apple has given,
0:30:23I couldn't find it.
0:30:24So if anybody knows, I would love to know.
0:30:26The other question I have this week,
0:30:28and it gets back to your original question
0:30:30of why is it Apple that's in this fight?
0:30:33How come we never hear about,
0:30:34they're not, I get none of them are US companies
0:30:39except other than Microsoft,
0:30:41but like we never hear about Samsung or LG
0:30:44or any of these other companies.
0:30:45Like what do they do when a suspect has an Android phone?
0:30:48Why is this not in the news at all?
0:30:50Like what happens?
0:30:51Is it that it's,
0:30:53is it just one of those things where Apple gets headlines
0:30:58and so people only write about it
0:30:59when it's Apple and the iPhone?
0:31:01Or is Android different?
0:31:04And it's like trivial that even when you have a passcode
0:31:08there's some way that they can get the information they want? I don't
0:31:12understand why nobody's writing about that. And I don't have the, you know, I
0:31:16don't have the perspective on it. Well, there must be some requests from the
0:31:22government to Google for information. There must be. Oh, definitely. And the
0:31:30thing about Google, but that's online content. And who knows, maybe
0:31:33it's because if you use an Android phone everybody who uses Android phones signs
0:31:39up for Google and going to Google is enough that they don't need to go to the
0:31:43right that's what I'm saying you know that they they have I don't know though
0:31:47because there's things like text messages right so Android users send a
0:31:51lot of SMS text messages they don't go through Google right so if the FBI wants
0:31:56to see those they need to get them off the phone I can't help but think that
0:32:01that they would want to still want to access the phone.
0:32:03And you know, does, what percentage of Android users
0:32:07back up all of their photos to Google?
0:32:10I mean, it must be some percentage, but is it all?
0:32:12I don't know.
0:32:13- Okay, I'm gonna throw something out there
0:32:15that may be funny, but maybe as we know
0:32:20from the things that we see,
0:32:22maybe Android is just so full of holes
0:32:26that the FBI can hack it themselves.
0:32:28- Yeah, that's sort of what I'm hinting at.
0:32:31I don't know.
0:32:32(laughing)
0:32:34- You know, iOS is a very secure operating system
0:32:39and a lot of it because Apple doesn't really care
0:32:42about your data, they care about your security
0:32:47and your privacy and I'm trying not to be too
0:32:53Fanny here, but I believe that to be true and we've seen the malware and things that can infect
0:33:04Android phones. So what's, I mean, I tend to think that the FBI just sat down with some of
0:33:10its smart people and said, "Hack this thing." And they can. Yeah, I don't know. Let me take a break
0:33:19here and we come back to it but I'll take a break here and thank our first
0:33:23sponsor and it is our good friends at Harry's go to harry's.com and use the
0:33:28promo code talk show just talk show and you will save five bucks off your first
0:33:34purchase Harry's offers high quality razors and blades and other shaving
0:33:38products for a fraction of the big razor brands they make their own blades in their
0:33:45own factory. They bought it in Germany. It was an old razor blade factory in Germany
0:33:49and they liked it so much they just bought the factory. And it's fundamentally this is
0:33:53how they sell their stuff for less because there's no middleman. They own the factory,
0:33:58they make the blades, they make the products, and then you buy it from them and they just
0:34:02ship it right to your door. And so there's no distributor, there's no markup for a retail
0:34:08store. So you get a better price, you get a high quality product, and you get the convenience
0:34:15of just having this stuff show up at your house and you don't have to go buy it.
0:34:18Their starter set is an amazing deal.
0:34:19For $15, you get a razor, moisturizing shave cream or gel, and three razor blades.
0:34:23And when you need more blades, they're just $2 each or less.
0:34:26An 8-pack, for example, is just $15, and a 16-pack is $25.
0:34:31I love their packaging.
0:34:33I love their style.
0:34:34I love the way they write.
0:34:35A couple of months ago, they sent me this.
0:34:37They have a new thing here, a daily face wash.
0:34:40So this is what I use in the shower when I wash my face.
0:34:42and it's sort of like a gritty type thing. I like it. It feels, you know, it's got like
0:34:47some kind of grit to it. But I read the instructions because I'm an idiot and I
0:34:51actually always look for stuff like this. These are the instructions. These are their instructions.
0:34:56Here's how they, this is how they tell you to use the face wash. Wash as only you would.
0:35:00A little bit goes a long way. Caution not in the eyes. That's it.
0:35:06Lovely.
0:35:09Right, because you don't really need... it's in other words, "Hey dummy, you know how to wash your face and be..."
0:35:15And my favorite part is a little bit goes a long way, you know, just you put a little bit, a little bit, there you go.
0:35:21And, you know, again, "Hey dummy, don't put it in your eyes." There you go, that's it. So, great stuff, great style.
0:35:27Good, even the hardware handles on everything, on the razors, all great stuff. Go there, go to harrys.com
0:35:35And I remember that promo code talk show and you will save five bucks off your first purchase
0:35:40Well, if I if I can tell you something I actually use Harry's
0:35:45As big of a beard as I have, you know, I get to trim up the sides and stuff
0:35:50I have I have the full Harry's kit. So there you go
0:35:54True true story
0:35:59Well, I don't is there more to say about the FBI Apple case at the moment. Maybe not
0:36:05Do you believe what the FBI says and do you believe what Apple says? I believe what Apple
0:36:14says and I think they're very careful. I think they are and it's just a hallmark of Tim Cook is
0:36:21is a and and I would say without question the biggest difference between Cook and Jobs is that
0:36:31Jobs would would fly off the handle and
0:36:36You know just a small example, but remember in 2007 when
0:36:43It was people the first iPhone came out and people hey
0:36:47How come we can't write native apps and he said ah you don't you know you're bad you write a bad native app
0:36:52We'll bring down the whole West Coast phone network
0:36:54Now I
0:36:59There's an argument to be made that it's you know
0:37:01Like what if it was a super popular app like Facebook and what if there was a terrible bug that you know?
0:37:07Kept the data connection on full-time if the app was installed
0:37:11There's some you know, it's not it's completely ridiculous, but it wasn't a good answer, but that's jobs right whereas Tim Cook
0:37:18Tim Cook is is so he's like a surgeon with every word out of his mouth in public. Yes, and
0:37:26I do I believe that I don't think there's anything that Apple said at least in that open letter that I
0:37:33even raised an eyebrow
0:37:36me neither, I mean the only thing that I think is up for debate is whether it qualifies as a backdoor and
0:37:42The only reason I'd say that and Tim Cook says, you know, and he even admitted says in the letter
0:37:47The FBI is using different words. I call it a backdoor, but he's even acknowledging
0:37:52He's careful enough and fair enough that he even acknowledges that there's a debate over whether
0:37:57backdoor is the right word. And I think that argument that it's not a backdoor is that a
0:38:01backdoor, maybe you could argue, is something that Apple ships to everybody. And it's in the
0:38:07phone that you buy from Apple. It's already there. You know, that this is something that the FBI,
0:38:15you know, that's not what the FBI is asking for. They're not asking, the FBI is not asking Apple to
0:38:19push a software update to every iPhone out in the world that would let them bypass the
0:38:24passcode. They're saying, "Do this, just one." But, you know, given the providios that Tim
0:38:29Cook said, I believe him. With the FBI, I don't know. And I think the one argument a
0:38:34couple people have made, including John McAfee, is that, "Come on."
0:38:40The show ends right now.
0:38:43Come on.
0:38:45Come on.
0:38:46It's either the FBI is lying and they have hackers on their staff who could break in
0:38:51to get this passcode right now, or they're incompetent because they should be able to.
0:38:56Like why can't they go right down the street to the NSA and have this thing unlocked?
0:39:02And I find it very difficult to believe that the NSA couldn't do this.
0:39:06And that if it was, if this one phone really was that important that they would do that.
0:39:11And I find that disingenuous.
0:39:13And it's also what makes me think it's about the legal precedent, not the actual information
0:39:17on the San Bernardino suspects phone.
0:39:20So you you think that the NSA could hack this iPhone on their own?
0:39:26I don't have any reason to believe that are not that I don't have reason to believe it.
0:39:30I don't have proof.
0:39:32I can't prove that for the obvious reason that, you know, the NSA keeps everything all
0:39:37of their capabilities secret.
0:39:39if I had to bet, oh, I would bet heavily that the NSA could access the information on this
0:39:45phone. So why bother going through all this? Why not just go get the precedent? But does the
0:39:51precedent actually matter if they can hack it? Well, I think because going forward in the future,
0:39:56they're concerned about the ever escalating security of these phones. And I guess that's
0:40:02one area where we could talk about where, you know, one of the aspects of this is whatever
0:40:08happens to Apple in the courts on this case, I think it's only going to motivate them to
0:40:17further cleverly design the encryption mechanisms on the iPhone to make it impossible in the
0:40:24future to even comply with a request like this.
0:40:31So here's something we don't know, and it's a little technical and hopefully I will keep
0:40:35this straight enough that I'm going to be accurate. But the phone in this case is an
0:40:41iPhone 5C, the San Bernardino phone, and the 5C is before the Secure Enclave and before
0:40:46Touch ID. And that makes it a simpler case cryptographically to get. Starting with the
0:40:57iPhone 5s and going forward the phones, iPhones with the touch ID and the secure
0:41:05Enclave. Now touch ID is sort of irrelevant but it's the phones that have
0:41:09touch ID that have the secure Enclave. They use the secure Enclave in the path
0:41:15of encryption to enforce it and so one of the things that limits the rate of so
0:41:23mathematically and you don't really have to I even I really I have a computer
0:41:27science degree and I did really well in math and I really this stuff really
0:41:30boggles my mind. But basically one of the keys used to encrypt the data on the
0:41:36phone is on the secure enclave and so as you know the the phone iOS verifies that
0:41:43the passcode is correct it goes through the secure enclave and this your secure
0:41:48enclave adds its key and there's no way to get that key from iOS it just says
0:41:53"Okay, secure enclave, here's the passcode that was sent. Now, output of that, you give me the thing that lets me decrypt this."
0:42:02And it's the secure enclave that enforces this 80 millisecond time between brute force attempts,
0:42:10which isn't that long, except that if you want to do millions of them to get like a six digit passcode,
0:42:1680 milliseconds means it takes a lot longer to go through all of them than it would otherwise.
0:42:21And if you use an alphanumeric password,
0:42:24if you're really concerned about security on your phone
0:42:26and you use letters and numbers on the passcode,
0:42:28it really does make it,
0:42:30the 80 millisecond attempt between decryption attempts
0:42:33really does make it time-wise impossible.
0:42:36The question is,
0:42:39can Apple be forced to put like a Flash update
0:42:44on the secure enclave
0:42:46to eliminate the 80 millisecond time between attempts.
0:42:51And I think Apple hasn't said publicly,
0:42:56but reading between the lines,
0:42:57I think the answer right now might be yes.
0:43:01And what somebody has said was that, for example,
0:43:04like the iPhone 5S shipped with the Secure Enclave
0:43:07and it didn't have that 80 millisecond enforcement
0:43:09between attempts.
0:43:11And then a software update later on added it.
0:43:15So if they could add something like that to Secure Enclave,
0:43:18they could obviously take it away.
0:43:20The question is, and I don't know that Apple's,
0:43:25and I don't think they wanna say,
0:43:27is can those flash updates to the Secure Enclave today,
0:43:31can they happen while the phone is locked?
0:43:34Because that's, you know,
0:43:35the whole point is if the phone is already locked,
0:43:38maybe they can't flash update the Secure Enclave
0:43:41to change the passcode, right?
0:43:43It's like a catch-22.
0:43:47But if you can, that might be something
0:43:50that Apple is very strongly looking at in the future
0:43:52to say, well, now we're going to engineer.
0:43:54We're going to have Johnny Suruji's team engineer
0:43:57at Secure Enclave, where this 80 millisecond attempt
0:44:00between passcode attempts is hardwired into the silicon,
0:44:04and there's nothing we can do about it.
0:44:07And there's got to be other things that they're
0:44:09looking at going forward.
0:44:10Like, I don't think we are at the end of Apple's
0:44:13we secure your data on the phone. I think that every single year, in the last five years, the
0:44:19system has gotten more clever and more completely sealed up so that even Apple can't do anything
0:44:27with it. What if Apple said they lose this case and they say, "Okay, we will give you
0:44:36this information," but then they lock up the next operating system even tighter so that
0:44:40there is no possible way. I don't even know if that's possible. Right. No, I think it has to be,
0:44:46though, I definitely think it's possible to lock it up tighter. I think that that they could,
0:44:51you know, create definitely create a system where the the the flash, you know, the ROM,
0:45:00whatever you want to call it, the code that runs on the secure enclosure, where it can't be can't
0:45:06be updated while the phone is locked. I think that's definitely technically possible.
0:45:10I mean, I could be wrong, but I think it is. So what does the government do then? Does it go
0:45:16to court and say you can't make your OS any stronger? Right. And at that point,
0:45:25I, you know, I guess they could try to pass the law, but you really do start running up against
0:45:32issues like A) that would cripple US tech companies competitively worldwide.
0:45:40Absolutely, it would be crippling.
0:45:42I mean, who would want a US tech product if they knew that by mandated by US law that
0:45:48it had to be insecure?
0:45:51And B) I think that there's a very strong constitutional argument that that's a violation
0:45:55of free speech.
0:45:57that code is speech and saying you can't write code
0:46:00that does this is, you know, it's more or less saying
0:46:04that this, you know, this form of mathematics is illegal.
0:46:08- Oof, what a case.
0:46:11- I really do think it comes down to a sense of entitlement
0:46:13on law enforcement, that they feel like any information
0:46:15that exists, they should be able to access.
0:46:17And they're unwilling to wrap their heads around the idea
0:46:19that we're coming to a point where there will exist
0:46:23information in the universe that they simply can't get.
0:46:26I mean, and I keep thinking, and again,
0:46:29this isn't really a legal argument,
0:46:30it's just sort of a philosophical argument.
0:46:32But they've never had a right
0:46:35to the information in your head.
0:46:37And in fact, the US Constitution has the Fifth Amendment,
0:46:42which means that you have a right
0:46:46not to incriminate yourself.
0:46:49And so if you invoke it, even if you committed a crime,
0:46:56you cannot be forced to admit it in court.
0:46:59In some sense-- again, I'm not speaking legally,
0:47:05but philosophically, the information on your phone
0:47:09is in some way an extension of what's in your head.
0:47:12The pictures you've taken are things
0:47:14you've seen that you want to remember.
0:47:15the notes you've written to yourself are your notes.
0:47:20I just don't think it's that outlandish, philosophically,
0:47:23that you could have a phone that is so securely encrypted
0:47:27that if law enforcement takes it,
0:47:31that they can't access it, any more so
0:47:33than that they don't have a right to read your mind
0:47:37or force you to testify against yourself.
0:47:40How long will this case go on?
0:47:43I don't know.
0:47:44can't help but think it's I this particular case who knows but I feel
0:47:49like the argument isn't going to stop like even if this case gets resolved
0:47:53somehow quickly it's the next one coming is is is going to be the same I believe
0:48:00that this will go all the way to the Supreme Court because I don't think
0:48:03either side will just let it fall.
0:48:11But if they lose, if the government loses this case, will they try a different tact?
0:48:21Is there another legal way for them to say, "Okay, well we argued this last time, but
0:48:28now we're arguing this."
0:48:30Is this going to go on forever?
0:48:34I don't know.
0:48:37One thing we didn't mention is that the foundation of the FBI's request and the judge granted
0:48:44against Apple is based on the All Writs Act of 1789.
0:48:51Basing this on a law from 1789 would suggest that the law really didn't have encrypted
0:48:57cell phones in mind.
0:49:01Unless Nostradamus did it.
0:49:05Two of the things that I've taken away this week is that one, if the FBI
0:49:09wins, this sort of grants them, under this All Rits Act,
0:49:13precedent that says we can get whatever we want. We can use this ancient law to get
0:49:17whatever we want. We have this very powerful ability to
0:49:21force tech companies to help us
0:49:25by writing new code and and stuff like that so that would be good for the FBI
0:49:30from their perspective I don't think that's good public policy I think
0:49:33that's terrible but from law enforcement's perspective that would be
0:49:36they would see that as a win and I think if they lose this is why I almost feel
0:49:40like the FBI might see this as a no-lose situation is if they lose then they go
0:49:46to Congress and say look the law on the book we just tried it we have to you
0:49:51know, they go to they go to Congress, and they say, we have
0:49:55to be able to get this stuff to keep people safe from these
0:49:58crazy terrorists. That's very compelling to a lot of
0:50:01politicians who either believe it or be cowardly, you know, it
0:50:07just don't want to be seen on the wrong side of terrorism,
0:50:12right, of being, quote, unquote, strong against terrorism. And
0:50:17they go to Congress and say, Look, we just tried with this
0:50:19law that's on the books and it we lost so we need you to pass a new law that
0:50:25says blah about you know encryption and stuff like that and I think the only
0:50:31good solution for us publicly would be if if that fails too but I feel like the
0:50:36FBI might suspect that they've got the the support on in Congress to do that
0:50:44here's a question for you I wanted to ask before we move off it is does being
0:50:50a Canadian give you a different perspective on this because I feel like
0:50:55Americans are often too insular and we see these things as u.s. only issues and
0:50:59just simply being on the other side of the US Canadian border does it give you
0:51:04a different perspective you know it's we don't really have a lot of things like
0:51:12this that would come up. You know, I can't see the Canadian government suing Apple. You know, it's
0:51:23just not something that... Does it give... do you have a sense that you don't have like an
0:51:31implicit trust of the US Department of Justice? No, I don't think it's that. I think
0:51:42we're more we're more trusting than what you guys are of your government we may
0:51:51not like it like you know our government will put in new taxes which they do all
0:51:56the time and we just say oh gosh darn it that's awful but you know we pay it
0:52:04that's fine you know whereas you guys may riot oh like no no you're not gonna
0:52:10to do that. The thing I keep thinking about too is just that the stuff is also
0:52:14new. It's only 20-25 years that anybody really, you know, public, you know, typical
0:52:19people had access to computers and computer networking. And law enforcement
0:52:23worked just fine before that. It's just, it's not like everything that they used
0:52:27to be able to do before there were cell phones that they can't do anymore.
0:52:31It's just new information and new, a new source of evidence that they have had
0:52:37access to. But if they don't have access to it, if they can't get anything they want off an iPhone
0:52:43that has a strong passcode on it, I don't think that that means that law enforcement can't do its
0:52:48job. Well, and but the difference between then and now is that then the bad guys weren't using cell
0:52:56phones either. So there were they were recording information in different ways that that the
0:53:04government could have access to. So if they're now using the cell phones to record all of their
0:53:11information and the government can't access it, then there is an argument that they don't have
0:53:16access like they used to. But I'm still drawing back to what you said about the NSA. If the NSA
0:53:26has access. This seems like a dangerous move for the government to do for a precedent that they
0:53:34might not need. You know, I don't know. It could be a bad move if they can get it. I mean,
0:53:44I don't understand why they just wouldn't say, "Eh, whatever. You know, you don't need to give
0:53:49us that. We've got access anyway to anything that we want." I really don't think that they do.
0:53:54Could the iPhone be that good that they don't?
0:54:00You never know if the NSA knows of a flaw in the scheme, they're going to keep their mouth shut about it.
0:54:09But it does seem to me that Apple is moving towards creating a complete system that can mathematically be shown that it can't be broken.
0:54:19with the combination of you know with the secure enclave and when and with all
0:54:27the various ways that the keys are stored to get everything in encrypted or
0:54:31unencrypted oh boy we're in for how long do you think that this initial part will
0:54:39take is this like a month thing or I don't know I yeah I guess I know Apple's
0:54:46been given till February recording on February 19th and I know they have like one week to
0:54:53file their response. So I think you know a couple of months I'm guessing. I'll take a
0:55:04break in the show and thank our second sponsor and it's our good friends at Squarespace.
0:55:09can go to squarespace.com/the-talk-show and find out more. You guys know what
0:55:16Squarespace is. It's all-in-one hosting and design and template type stuff for
0:55:23your website. They've recently launched three different new website products
0:55:29because they know that people's needs vary. So here's three of the new things
0:55:36that they've launched. Cover pages are single page websites that are perfect for when your
0:55:40idea is just starting out. You know what a single page website is. Something that you
0:55:43have a new thing to announce and you have a big headline at the top and all the information
0:55:47goes right down the page on one big scrolling thing. They've got that set up. So if you
0:55:51ask the type of site you need, Squarespace already has you covered. Squarespace Commerce
0:55:56is robust enough to be both your online storefront and business manager. So if you want to keep
0:56:01track of inventory and you want to have a whole variety of products that you show people
0:56:06and let them sell and have all of the e-commerce stuff and the security stuff
0:56:10and the credit card processing go through.
0:56:12Squarespace Commerce already has you covered.
0:56:14Squarespace Websites is another one that helps you provide beautiful,
0:56:19versatile templates that help you create the online home that you've always wanted.
0:56:23That's a multi-page, deeper website.
0:56:27They have so many templates to choose from.
0:56:29It's ridiculous.
0:56:29They look so professional.
0:56:31Any kind of new website that you want to create, you really ought to look
0:56:35at Squarespace first and give it half an hour, give it an hour and see how far you
0:56:39get and you'll find out a lot of the cases most of the time you're already
0:56:44most of the way done to just being finished in launching. So go there and
0:56:48check it out if you have any kind of need for a new website. You can start
0:56:52with a free trial it's squarespace.com/thetalkshow and remember this use
0:57:00Use this code Daring, D-A-R-I-N-G, and use that when you pay.
0:57:07See, here's the problem.
0:57:08You can go there now, get a free trial, use it for 30 days, and then when you go to pay,
0:57:12maybe you don't remember the code.
0:57:13Just remember the code Daring, D-A-R-I-N-G, and you will save 10%.
0:57:18So you'll save big bucks and you'll get a beautiful website.
0:57:21My thanks to Squarespace.
0:57:22All right.
0:57:23What about my interview last week with Federighi and Q?
0:57:27Do you listen to it?
0:57:28>> I did.
0:57:29I did actually. It was great. I thought it was a great interview.
0:57:34You know, you got some scoops in there too. It was awesome.
0:57:39Yeah, I wasn't expecting that. It's like they didn't say, "Hey, we're going to give you some
0:57:43stuff." It's like when Eddie first started saying that, I really kind of expected it.
0:57:48I was like, "Am I hearing this right? That you're giving me this information that I'm pretty sure
0:57:54never came out before." I was ready to hear him get a punch in the shoulder from like...
0:57:58I thought it was really good interview they were they were very open and and it
0:58:10you know it kind of seemed like just three guys sitting around chatting well
0:58:17that's definitely the case I mean in the argument against it would be and it seemed
0:58:21like you know I worried afterwards that maybe I didn't ask good enough questions
0:58:26Hard questions is maybe the wrong term to use, but maybe I didn't press quite hard enough.
0:58:32I really was worried afterwards. And then the show came out and I read all the reactions,
0:58:36I read all the emails, I read all the tweets, and most people seemed to really like it.
0:58:40But there were definitely some people who were like, "Dude, you asked this question,
0:58:43and they didn't give a straight answer, and you didn't press them on it."
0:58:46And you're always gonna have that, though. I mean, you and I have been doing this long enough to
0:58:52know that no matter what we ask that people are gonna react like that and my
0:58:59take on it is well at least I asked and I thought even the ones that they didn't
0:59:05answer straightforwardly they at least they weren't there the answers weren't
0:59:09completely empty you know and and I know that they're you know they're both
0:59:17surprisingly good this is the thing that blows me away it's it's for two people
0:59:21who don't do podcasts regularly. I mean, I know Federighi was on the show back in
0:59:25December to talk about Swift. I don't know that Eddie Q. I don't know that he's
0:59:29ever done a podcast before. I've seen him on interviews like at Recode or
0:59:32something like that, but he doesn't do it a lot. But it's... they came across as like
0:59:38naturals, right? Yeah. And I know that there's no way that if they're not going
0:59:42to answer it the first time, they're not going to answer it if I reassert it.
0:59:46and then all of a sudden it the discussion loses the the flow yeah well
0:59:55I I think that you got a lot of great information I think that yes I mean I
1:00:01texted you when I listened to it last week and and said you know it was great
1:00:09interview. It was informative, it was, you know, entertaining. So you actually got a
1:00:18lot more than what I would have suspected. The one thing that I think is
1:00:24interesting is the... it goes beyond any words that actually came out of either
1:00:30of their mouths, is the fact that the interview happened at all shows that
1:00:35that Apple definitely cares about this whole perception
1:00:41of Apple software being in decline,
1:00:45or having less care and thought put into it
1:00:49than their hardware.
1:00:51And that Apple-- the fact that the interview happened at all
1:00:54shows that Apple wants to counter that,
1:00:57which I thought was interesting.
1:00:58And so any sort of thought that Apple doesn't pay attention
1:01:02to these discussions on the outside,
1:01:05I think it's clear that they do,
1:01:10up to the very highest levels of the company.
1:01:12- Yeah, I agree.
1:01:14I've interviewed Eddie before.
1:01:19I never interviewed Craig,
1:01:21but interviewed Eddie before,
1:01:23and he's a great guy.
1:01:26I really like Eddie.
1:01:31I think their personalities came across in the interview that you gave.
1:01:36I mean, yeah, it's great to get the information,
1:01:38but they could have been wet blankets in the interview too,
1:01:42and it would have been very difficult.
1:01:44And then maybe that's when you start asking the questions just to--
1:01:49no, answer this.
1:01:52One question, if there's one-- and it's always the case
1:01:55that there's always at least one.
1:01:57It's like, it's all over.
1:01:58We were like, hit stop and the recording is over and I think that's great.
1:02:02And then immediately I'm like, "Oh, I knew the one question I wanted to ask."
1:02:06Is I really wanted to ask Eddie and I can't believe I forgot it or just-- it was in my
1:02:11notes but it just never seemed to come up in the flow.
1:02:14I wanted to ask Eddie if he himself has ever hit the bug where your iPhone or your iOS
1:02:21device, could be iPhone, could be iPad, but your iOS device starts asking you for your
1:02:26iCloud password and you enter it and then it like a second goes by and then
1:02:32it comes the same dialogue comes back up and then you enter it and it goes away
1:02:36just long enough that you think okay it's stuck and then it comes back and it
1:02:41doesn't say your password was incorrect and like when when it when I hit this
1:02:46you know and I think everybody's part of the same way where you can kind of enter
1:02:50your iCloud password pretty fast and you do it and then it's when you hit this
1:02:55bug which I know exists I've you know I've seen it firsthand I know other
1:02:59people talk about it but then like by the third time you start entering your
1:03:02password very very carefully yeah are you like me like can you do it one
1:03:06character at a time with one finger and you actually look at the pop-up letters
1:03:11as they come and then you hit return and then it goes away and you think oh that's
1:03:16all and then it comes back up I wanted to ask Eddie that and I didn't and damn
1:03:21I really regret it. Were you satisfied with the
1:03:24With the way that the conversation went. I mean, yeah, I really was I I worry deeply about it because I I don't feel like
1:03:31Being in that role of interviewing people like that. It is comes naturally to me
1:03:37So, I mean I stressed I don't I hope it didn't sound that way, but I stressed greatly about it before
1:03:42No, it didn't sound that way
1:03:45Like I said, I thought it was a really
1:03:48entertaining interview
1:03:50I think that implicit in their response to the issue of the software, you know, being in decline is that
1:03:57I thought one of the most interesting answers to that was Craig Federighi said that the bar is being raised, it's higher than ever.
1:04:08And that's in terms of expectations that we have for how reliable everything will work and how polished everything will be.
1:04:15I thought that was, you know, again, it's sort of a non-answer, no, maybe, but I think it's an interesting way of looking at it,
1:04:24and that we collectively see these as problems now, simply because we have higher expectations.
1:04:32- Okay, so let's look at that though.
1:04:36Why do we have higher expectations?
1:04:41I think it's because Apple gives us higher expectations.
1:04:46You know, we're not, I don't think that we as consumers
1:04:51are saying to Apple, you know, your software is awful.
1:04:56It seems to me more that Apple is saying, you know,
1:05:01when they do events and stuff, our software is great.
1:05:05And 99% of the time, it really is great.
1:05:09But then when that 1% hits,
1:05:13it's like, okay, this isn't so great.
1:05:18So are we just holding Apple up to their own words
1:05:25and what they say about their software?
1:05:27Or are we being unfair and saying,
1:05:31No, I don't think we are being unfair.
1:05:33And I think that it is central to the entire,
1:05:37Apple's own, you know, there's a lot of times
1:05:42where in other cases where Apple seems to be held
1:05:47either by a publication or just one individual pundit
1:05:51or somebody to an unreasonably high standard
1:05:53that other companies aren't held to.
1:05:55And I call them out sometimes, you call them out,
1:05:59other, you know, and Macalobe calls them out all the time. This is a case, though, where
1:06:06I think Apple itself asks to be held to a higher standard, right, that Apple itself
1:06:12proclaims that our products because we do the whole, you know, this is their story that
1:06:17because we do the whole thing, we control the software and the hardware and the integration
1:06:21between them, we provide an overall better experience than our competitors who don't
1:06:27have that whole software and hardware story to tell.
1:06:32They say that, that's Apple's story.
1:06:35And I've long thought that that's the,
1:06:37can Apple succeed in the long run?
1:06:44Yes, but I think that the only way they succeed
1:06:47in the long run is by continually providing
1:06:50a better overall experience.
1:06:55and blurring the lines between hardware and software.
1:06:58- And I think that overall,
1:07:00they've done a great job with that.
1:07:01Even when you look at the integration between devices,
1:07:06I mean, not just the integration
1:07:08between hardware and software,
1:07:10but the integration between iPad, Mac, iPhone,
1:07:14that handoff and iMessage being everywhere
1:07:20and all that kind of stuff,
1:07:23that makes the devices more useful for me.
1:07:26- Oh, tremendously for me.
1:07:27But I feel like that's one of those things though,
1:07:30where there's, you know, for so many,
1:07:32a handoff works great for me.
1:07:33And I do it all the time,
1:07:34where I'll be like walking around the house,
1:07:36making coffee or something,
1:07:37and reading something on my phone,
1:07:40and I wanna link to it from Daring Fireball,
1:07:43but why not, I'll just wait till I get to my desk
1:07:46and do it from my iMac where I have a nice keyboard.
1:07:48And all I do is just sit down at my desk
1:07:50while the phone is still open.
1:07:51And right there at the side of my dock
1:07:52is the little handoff Safari thing.
1:07:56So I click one button and a second later,
1:07:59the webpage that was on my phone is now,
1:08:01I click one button on my Mac
1:08:04and the thing on my phone is now on my Mac.
1:08:09And it works great for me.
1:08:09But with 700 million iCloud users,
1:08:14are there a million of them for whom that doesn't work
1:08:18for reasons they don't understand?
1:08:21Is 99.9% of people having it work good enough?
1:08:26And then how do you solve it for the last 10th percent?
1:08:30- Well, I think one thing that we all know
1:08:34is that there's always gonna be problems
1:08:36and bugs with software.
1:08:38And we're accepting of that.
1:08:41I really believe that we are accepting of that.
1:08:45And if you look at something like iCloud,
1:08:48iCloud is a favorite,
1:08:50one of the favorite whipping horses of people.
1:08:54For me, iCloud works great.
1:08:58iCloud services work great.
1:09:00And I think a lot of it comes down to how we use it.
1:09:02So I use iCloud more like,
1:09:05more like a consumer, you know?
1:09:12- Yeah.
1:09:13- And I--
1:09:14- Well, I'll give one example that I know I'm not alone with
1:09:17is the syncing of the text shortcuts. So in other words, like if you set up, you know, like a text,
1:09:26the way that OS X and iOS have like a simple text expander like system where you can have a little
1:09:33shortcut like you type "addr" and then it expands to your full address. I was bedeviled for months
1:09:43with an inability, they're supposed to sync between devices.
1:09:47And for months, I was absolutely bedeviled by
1:09:51syncing problems between them, where just all sorts of craziness would happen,
1:09:56where they'd be doubled, where they all of a sudden none of them
1:09:59were on my phone, and sometimes on my, I mean, anything that
1:10:03could go wrong went wrong. All of a sudden my Mac went back to, or
1:10:06one of my Macs would go back to like the default ones
1:10:10that ship when it's brand new.
1:10:12And I think that what happened was that
1:10:18the problems initially happened for me
1:10:20when I was running the iOS 9 beta last summer on my phone.
1:10:24And that something got corrupted in my iCloud account
1:10:28that even after iOS came out of, iOS 9 came out of beta,
1:10:32that something was wrong with those keyboard shortcuts
1:10:36or text shortcuts, whatever they call them.
1:10:39And then for months afterwards, it was all messed up.
1:10:41And eventually though, it just got fixed.
1:10:46And knock on wood, but for the last few months,
1:10:51it just works.
1:10:53And I've even doubted myself and just gone there
1:10:56and painstakingly held my phone up to my Mac
1:10:59and scrolled both lists to make sure that there's not like,
1:11:02oh, I just know there's gonna be one missing.
1:11:04And I'd get to the bottom and be like,
1:11:06damn, they're all there and they're all the same.
1:11:08And so, you know, I don't know who knows how that happened. Who knows if it fixed itself?
1:11:13Who knows if somebody at Apple fixed a bug, figured it out, and did it?
1:11:17But even when stuff like that happens, and again, I don't want to be seen here as
1:11:22wholly on Apple's side of this argument, but I do think though that
1:11:28it's easy for somebody
1:11:31who's experienced the same thing to look at the
1:11:34syncing between those text shortcuts is buggy because it was buggy and to overlook the fact that it's not buggy right now. I
1:11:40know Syracuse is always talking on ATP that he can't get his addresses to sync.
1:11:47And I gotta tell you, I have not had a problem with address syncing in iCloud
1:11:52ever. I mean, and I've been using it since it was called, you know,
1:11:57iTools or whatever it used to be before Mac.com.
1:12:01Maybe back then maybe back then I had some I don't know. I didn't even have an iPhone back then
1:12:05So I don't even know what I was sinking it, too
1:12:07So maybe I wouldn't even know what if I had sync problems
1:12:09But at least in recent years, my address is definitely sync and they sync fast. Yeah, I don't have problems with calendars with contacts
1:12:17I don't have problems thinking any of that stuff. I don't have problems with iCloud Drive, you know, it sinks
1:12:24I mean you could you could
1:12:26reasonably make the argument should iCloud drive be more like Dropbox and sure but looking at the
1:12:33service as it is I don't have problems with how it works and you know when the the problems that
1:12:43we do have like this password thing just seem to be so bizarre is it is it something that's
1:12:53you know it can't be unique to to just one person obviously because a lot of people have it but is
1:12:58it unique to a setup yeah i don't know you know so i you know i think that they're getting there
1:13:05i think that's the gist of it um i do worry i do worry that one of the reasons and and i i just
1:13:11don't think it's deniable i mean this is like when the whole thing that started this new round
1:13:18of apple software is is not as good as it used to be or not as good as it should be however way you
1:13:22you want to phrase it. It started with Mossberg's column, and then the same day you and I both
1:13:27wrote about it. And my take is that my angle was that one thing I think is undeniable is
1:13:33that it is true that their software is not as good as the hardware. But maybe that's
1:13:36just the way it has to be, because the hardware is in some ways simpler, and certain aspects
1:13:45of the hardware have to be bug-free. Like, you can't, there's no way that they can do
1:13:51do a software upgrade of the camera lens.
1:13:53Right?
1:13:53Right.
1:13:54Yeah.
1:13:56And so the requirements of that-- and so here's
1:13:58another argument.
1:14:00Does the ability to do software updates make Apple--
1:14:04and anybody else who can do them-- make them lazy
1:14:07about shipping B-quality software,
1:14:10because they know they can make it
1:14:11A-quality software over the air, or they think they can?
1:14:14Whereas is it different than in the old days,
1:14:16where the software had to be printed on a CD or a DVD,
1:14:20or if you want to go back further, floppy disks.
1:14:22And if there was a bug, the bug might never
1:14:25get fixed by the consumer, because software updates
1:14:29were so hard to distribute.
1:14:32It used to be a big, big deal to ship the gold
1:14:35master of a piece of software.
1:14:37Oh, yeah, it was huge.
1:14:39And not that an OS update still isn't taken seriously,
1:14:42or that there's all sorts of rigorous quality control
1:14:47that it goes through.
1:14:48but it's not like it used to be when hard software went through an actual,
1:14:53you know, effectively it'd be turned into hardware when you put it on a disc.
1:14:57That's right. Yeah. Well, I, and I think that, you know,
1:15:02for a lot of developers,
1:15:03they do think I'll release this now and I can fix it.
1:15:08But I mean, we,
1:15:11we know too that there are,
1:15:14you can't account for every configuration.
1:15:18And the Mac App Store, I think, has done a lot
1:15:22to help with every app is going to work.
1:15:26At least you have that feeling.
1:15:28These are tested, we know they're good,
1:15:34and we put them out there for sale on the Mac App Store.
1:15:37So that helps a lot.
1:15:39The App Store helps a lot.
1:15:40I think it's great that Apple has the review process
1:15:44they do with all of the stuff. I wonder if some of the Apple software would make it through the
1:15:49review process sometimes. Well, it wouldn't. A lot of the stuff that doesn't, you know,
1:15:55doesn't follow the sandboxing rules wouldn't. Although a lot of Apple, I say that, but I know
1:16:01that a lot of Apple, most of Apple's, you know, own first-party apps are sandboxed, so it's not
1:16:06entirely, but they don't, you know, if they need to, they don't mind giving themselves an exemption.
1:16:14I thought an interesting angle and I don't know if I was satisfied with the
1:16:19answer from Craig but on the issue of is Apple shifting away from monolithic
1:16:24feature updates for OS's. In other words I think for the last few years all the
1:16:30major new features of OS X and iOS have been announced at WWDC and then they all
1:16:36ship in the fall when the release versions come out and every once in a
1:16:41while there'll be one that maybe waits till the next release like remember
1:16:45there I think like two years ago there was a keychain something related to the
1:16:50keychain and it wasn't in the initial versions of either OS but it came out
1:16:55like in the November updates and it was something there was some kind of bug
1:16:59with like a keychain feature but for the most part they're all announced at WWDC
1:17:03and then they all come out in the fall at once and then Apple spends the next
1:17:06six months fixing bugs in those OSes and before they turn their attention to
1:17:11next year's OSes and are they moving away from that sort of let's do all the
1:17:16features at once to a more let's keep working on these features in parallel
1:17:21and then when they're ready then we'll ship them like with the seemingly
1:17:26imminent iOS 9.3 which is now in public beta which has maybe not huge features
1:17:32but some significant features.
1:17:33- Yeah.
1:17:34- The F-Lux thing with the,
1:17:36the F-Lux like feature with the night shift color palette,
1:17:41and maybe the most significant one
1:17:44for a smaller number of users,
1:17:46but for those who it applies to,
1:17:47it's a really major update to the OS
1:17:50is the way that for education purposes,
1:17:52iPads can have multiple users now,
1:17:53and you could have any student sign into any iPad.
1:17:56That's the sort of feature
1:17:58that you typically would only come in a major,
1:18:01you know, dot o release of the OS. I can't help but think that
1:18:06common sense says that while marketing wise, that's less
1:18:11powerful, because you can't just announce all this stuff at once,
1:18:14that from a quality perspective, letting these features come out
1:18:19naturally when they're ready, even if it's in the point three
1:18:22update to the major version of the OS is is, you know, common
1:18:26sense is that just seems like it's a better process for
1:18:29quality.
1:18:31And I don't mind smaller feature updates.
1:18:36I really don't.
1:18:37I just want things to be secure and stable.
1:18:42That's my main thing.
1:18:45That's what I want from them.
1:18:47- Yeah, and I wonder how much, you know,
1:18:51how much do they need the major OS updates
1:18:55to have big marketing type features?
1:18:58I mean, obviously they're always gonna have some,
1:19:00But how much do you need 10 tentpole features in an OS update?
1:19:07Maybe that's an outdated way of looking at an operating system.
1:19:09I think it is.
1:19:12That it's really more--
1:19:14it's enough to just say, come this fall,
1:19:20and they're announced new iPhones,
1:19:21to just talk about what's new in the iPhone itself.
1:19:23Here's this new camera that does blah, blah, blah.
1:19:26And here's how much better it is than the old camera.
1:19:28And here is how much faster graphics performance is
1:19:33compared to last year,
1:19:34which lets you do these amazing things like play this game
1:19:38and do this stuff.
1:19:39Like, isn't that enough?
1:19:41Like rather than, you know,
1:19:44and let the engineers who are working on iOS
1:19:46focus on just continually crossing off
1:19:49every little niggling little bug that's bothering people.
1:19:53- Well, I think that we need something.
1:19:56You know, it's always nice when Apple announces a new iPhone
1:20:00that you can now do panoramic pictures
1:20:05and we have this great camera.
1:20:07And the fact is people rely on that camera.
1:20:12- But that's tied, that's a good example though.
1:20:13It's obviously the panoramic camera thing
1:20:15is obviously software because it's,
1:20:17but it's also hardware, right?
1:20:20It wasn't like they could have done it without any camera.
1:20:23It was tied to it.
1:20:25it's very specific to the camera and the phone.
1:20:28- So I brought up three points
1:20:32in the article that I did on the software
1:20:35of why some of the bad software or bad things happen.
1:20:41One was that they knew about it and released it anyway.
1:20:48Two was that they didn't know.
1:20:51they were given a date released by March 1st, that's it.
1:20:56What do you think it is?
1:21:01- Well, I definitely think that it's part of the,
1:21:03it's part of why I think the monolithic release schedule
1:21:06is problematic is that the iPhones have to come out
1:21:11in September and I mean, I say have to in a way
1:21:18that if they didn't, if something truly catastrophic
1:21:20happened to the supply chain, a natural disaster in Asia,
1:21:27something truly catastrophic.
1:21:29And Apple literally calls a meeting in late August
1:21:34and says, wow, we have to postpone the iPhone 7 launch
1:21:38until January.
1:21:41It's not going to sink the company.
1:21:42I mean, it would definitely be bad for the company.
1:21:45I'm sure it would be bad for their stock.
1:21:49But to keep everything according to plan,
1:21:52the iPhone has to come out in September.
1:21:55And if the new iPhone comes out in September,
1:21:58iOS 10 has to come out in September,
1:22:00because the new iPhone are always engineered
1:22:03such that they need the newest version
1:22:04of the operating system.
1:22:07And therefore, iOS, whatever this year's new version number
1:22:13is, come hell or high water,
1:22:15is shipping in the middle of September.
1:22:19and that's how it is and that's why i feel like
1:22:21the more features you're promising for that release the
1:22:26more risk there is that some of them are not going to be
1:22:29you know fully baked
1:22:31well and and didn't we see that and you talked about it
1:22:35last week with with craig and eddie about apple tv i mean there are new
1:22:38features coming out for apple tv that just
1:22:41didn't make it
1:22:42right in the in the software
1:22:45Yeah, and you know, does that mean that they should have postponed the release of the app with the new Apple TV?
1:22:50I think definitely not I think right as they released it. It was a compelling upgrade and a compelling device
1:22:56But that's just the nature of it, you know, but isn't I think there's the big difference
1:23:01between
1:23:04releasing software that's
1:23:06Missing features and Apple never says it can do this and it can't to releasing software
1:23:14that Apple says it'll do this and it doesn't. Right, yeah I definitely think so.
1:23:23Here's an example, so maybe this is the way that I if I could bend Phil Schiller
1:23:29and Tim Cook's ear and Craig's ear on on this. Take a look, compare it to the
1:23:35release of Photos for Mac which was announced at WWDC but without they just
1:23:40said early next year. And I think it had a very good launch. I think Photos for Mac
1:23:46to complete the circle and iCloud photo library and complete this circle of, okay
1:23:51now if all of your photos are on all of your devices that are signed into iCloud
1:23:56in a in a storage sensitive way so that you know if you have thousands of
1:24:03photos you have the option of whether you want the full version on any
1:24:06particular device. It all worked really well but I think part of that was that
1:24:10didn't promise a date and say that come hell or high water it's going to ship on this date.
1:24:14Right. Like I would like to see more features that WWDC and APIs announced as this is coming
1:24:21within the next year. You know, and if it's not in iOS 10.0, if we have to wait till 10.1,
1:24:30so be it. I agree. And I do think you had a strong point. I definitely think you had
1:24:34a strong point that there are some cases where Apple has shipped stuff where it's, it just
1:24:39seems inexcusable. Like you had to know that this was not ready to ship.
1:24:42Right. And, and that's, that's where I wonder, you know,
1:24:48it seems obvious that you knew that this didn't work. And if,
1:24:54if you want to release software like that, then release it as, as beta say,
1:24:59you know, we have this,
1:25:00this new thing and we're going to release it today as public beta.
1:25:06we're looking forward to your feedback.
1:25:10And if that's the case,
1:25:13then I think the whole conversation changes
1:25:17on whether the software is good or not.
1:25:22Because I've been running beta software for OSs
1:25:29and for things like that.
1:25:29I never write about it because it's not fair
1:25:32to write about beta software like that.
1:25:37But as soon as you come to me and say,
1:25:39this software is ready,
1:25:43you can do all of these great and wonderful things,
1:25:47and we're proud to announce it and release it today.
1:25:51And then it doesn't?
1:25:52Or not just that it doesn't, but that it has major bugs?
1:26:00Which brings us to the next segment of the show where we should talk about iTunes and Apple Music.
1:26:04Which I will get to after thanking our final sponsor.
1:26:12And it's our good friends at Fracture. You guys know Fracture. They're the company that prints
1:26:17your photos directly onto glass. You've got photos in your iPhone. You've got photos on whatever the
1:26:23cameras you have, you put them on Instagram, you put them in photos on your Mac, send them
1:26:30up to Flickr. Well, how about getting them somewhere where they're not just ones and
1:26:34zeros and putting them onto a real analog print that you can hang on the wall that you
1:26:39can put on your desk. There's no better way to do that than through Fractr, where instead
1:26:43of printing them on paper and then you've got this piece of paper that you've got to
1:26:46somehow perfectly align within a rectangular frame and the pain in the ass of opening those
1:26:53little clips on the back of the frame and getting them back in there without
1:26:56having the photo fall two degrees off parallel forget it with fracture your
1:27:03picture is printed right on the glass itself and it looks super cool it's
1:27:08super beautiful it goes edge to edge and they ship with everything you need to
1:27:16hang them on the wall including a screw to put in a wall right there in the
1:27:20package, really clever packaging, really high quality printing, and a really, really just
1:27:27super cool effect when you actually see them on your wall.
1:27:31People who know you, when you start hanging these up, if they've ever heard of fracture,
1:27:33they're going to say, "Is that a fracture?"
1:27:34And if they don't, they're going to say, "How did you do that?
1:27:38What is this?"
1:27:39And then you're going to end up giving a pitch like this on fracture to your friends.
1:27:43And it's all really affordable too with prices starting at just $15 for the small square
1:27:49size.
1:27:50They've got all sorts of sizes, all sorts of shapes, and they've got a really cool team
1:27:54that hand assembles every single order down in Gainesville, Florida.
1:27:59And if you need any other reason to buy one, besides them being our sponsors and them being
1:28:03really cool things to buy as gifts, to buy for yourself, to hang on your walls, here's
1:28:08the even better.
1:28:09You can save 10% off with the code "Talkshow10."
1:28:14Talkshow10 will save you 10%.
1:28:17go to fracture me.com to check it out online and remember that code talk show 10 and you'll
1:28:22save some bucks. So that brings us to iTunes, which was again, I think that's one thing
1:28:33that on Twitter people called me out for not pressing eddy cue hard enough on but on the
1:28:38other hand, I felt like he acknowledged that it's on the table that may be on the desktop
1:28:42that iTunes should be broken up like it is on iOS and have separate apps for playing
1:28:48music, for managing device updates, for, you know, I mean it's just kind of ridiculous
1:28:54what iTunes on the desktop does, you know, how much stuff it's required to do.
1:28:58Well, and you can see why they don't want to mess with it because it processes, you
1:29:05know, billions of dollars in transactions.
1:29:07Right.
1:29:08Well, and it's actually used a lot.
1:29:09I think one of the numbers that was dropped
1:29:11in that interview last week was that
1:29:14there's 100 million people who still update
1:29:16and sync their device through a USB cable to iTunes.
1:29:20So I mean, 100 million users is a real number.
1:29:23- Yep, I can understand that.
1:29:26And for the record, I know that I've been very outspoken
1:29:31about Apple Music and the problems that I've had with it.
1:29:37I use Apple Music all the time.
1:29:40Every day I use Apple Music
1:29:43and it has gotten really, really good.
1:29:47It really has.
1:29:48Eddie and his team, I think have done a tremendous job
1:29:54in fixing a lot of the errors and problems
1:29:59that Apple Music had,
1:30:02which brings me back to the point of,
1:30:05at what point does Apple release software knowing that it's,
1:30:09it doesn't work that well, you know, was Apple music one of those,
1:30:13because when you start using it,
1:30:16you can see where all the flaws were.
1:30:21All right. Did it, did it,
1:30:22was it really dictated by the quality of the software was the release dictated
1:30:25by when the negotiating rights opened up.
1:30:28And I tend to think that it was
1:30:34The release was based on a date,
1:30:37not on the quality of the software.
1:30:39Because what we see now with the quality of the software,
1:30:42I would have been extremely happy with.
1:30:44- Well, what specific things do you think are better now
1:30:47than in the past year?
1:30:49'Cause you've been, I mean, without,
1:30:50I would say almost without question,
1:30:52one of the leading critics of Apple Music
1:30:55in terms of bugginess and inconsistency and confusion.
1:30:59- Well, and it's, the bugginess and inconsistency
1:31:02isn't just on iPhone.
1:31:03it's on Mac, it's on Apple TV, you know, and I think if you look at the service overall,
1:31:14everything has gotten better. The app has gotten better, the stations, the algorithm that they use
1:31:22for their radio stations has gotten better, the curated stations have gotten better,
1:31:29everything has gotten better. There are still bugs in the software and people have accused me of
1:31:37looking for bugs. I don't have time in my day to look for bugs. I really don't. So I've told
1:31:47Apple that the reason that I'm able to find these bugs is because I use it so much. That's it.
1:31:54That's the only reason that I find them. And when I find them, I tell them about them.
1:32:01It's funny. I know it's got to be the same for you, but it always amuses me when like
1:32:08two emails in a row or maybe two tweets in a row, just back to back. And it's the fact that they're
1:32:12back to back that makes it so amusing. Where there's one accusing you of being in Apple's
1:32:16pocket and one accusing you of unfairly criticizing Apple and just looking for things to say over the
1:32:23exact same thing that you wrote. Yeah, it's true. It's true. It happens. And what I'm not even sure
1:32:31that Apple recognizes this, but the reason that I'm so upset or I was so upset about Apple Music
1:32:40is because I care about it so much. Well, and it also seemed like some of your initial problems
1:32:44were data loss, which is sort of the cardinal, you know, like there's all sorts of things that
1:32:48that are forgivable and bugs and data loss is like high up on the list of ones
1:32:53that are unforgivable.
1:32:55Well you auto designed systems ideally such that data never gets lost.
1:33:00And to be, to be fair and open to Apple here,
1:33:04the data loss came from a misunderstanding of what I knew iTunes matched to do.
1:33:14So apparently I deleted the song, some of my own songs,
1:33:19and not knowing that the way that iTunes match worked
1:33:25had changed.
1:33:26So the songs weren't there, but they were there.
1:33:32And then some of the other ones I deleted,
1:33:35but I just, I don't think that the way that they implemented
1:33:42iTunes Match as a service in Apple Music
1:33:45was a good thing to do
1:33:49because they, before you could turn,
1:33:52you could see with iTunes Match,
1:33:54you could see your purchased music
1:33:55and your uploaded music and your matched music.
1:33:59So I could turn off Apple Music
1:34:01or I could use iTunes Match on all my devices
1:34:07and basically see all my music.
1:34:09But when they implemented Apple Music,
1:34:11They made iTunes match part of iCloud Music Library.
1:34:14So if I wanted to get rid of iCloud Music Library
1:34:17and just see my iTunes match,
1:34:21there was no way to do that, but I didn't know that.
1:34:23- And it gets to my complaint with it,
1:34:27is that in some ways,
1:34:29I think what makes me an astute critic of software
1:34:31is that I'm kind of an idiot
1:34:33and I really have cognitive problems with complex software.
1:34:38I really think I do.
1:34:39I just need it to be obvious,
1:34:41Not necessarily simple, but I need it to be obvious.
1:34:45And I really feel like, and I tried to get there last week
1:34:49with Federighi and Q, but that I really like what they did
1:34:54with Photos for Mac.
1:34:55And I say this knowing that I know that there are people
1:34:58out there who really miss some features from iPhoto
1:35:01that aren't in Photos for Mac.
1:35:03But I really like it because I really,
1:35:06when I open Photos for Mac, it's not that there aren't
1:35:09other features I wish that they would add back.
1:35:11And it's not like, I feel, especially in terms of editing images, I really, and I, you know,
1:35:16I just feel like it's coming and that this is how it's going to evolve in the years to
1:35:19come.
1:35:20But I really like that I open it up and I understand where everything is and in a way
1:35:26that if they had tried to glom it into iPhoto, I don't think it would have worked.
1:35:31Whereas with iTunes, I just really feel like by continuing to build on the same foundation
1:35:38that was the original iTunes from a decade ago, they've wound up with something that's
1:35:44just confusing. And iTunes Match is a perfect example of that. When they first came out
1:35:48with iTunes Match, I understood what it was meant to do and it sounded appealing and I
1:35:52paid for it and I guess I still do pay for it. But now that they have Apple Music, I
1:35:57just feel like it's too much. I feel like there should be just like two things. Here's
1:36:02your music which you have copies of right here on your on your computer and
1:36:07you can sync them to your other devices if you want and then if you want to pay
1:36:12us to have access to you know music like a subscription basis that's Apple music
1:36:20like I kind of feel like iTunes match should just go away well see I I really
1:36:25liked iTunes match because then I could have one copy of my music on on my
1:36:31computer and then I could just use iTunes match and not take up space on my
1:36:37device you know on my iPhone or my iPad I could just use the iTunes match and
1:36:41get a whole cloud library but when they when they changed that and rolled it
1:36:47into iCloud music library I'm basically paying for a service that it doesn't do
1:36:53what it did you know in my mind they kind of took away a feature but are
1:36:59still charging me for that feature. But if I look at Apple Music today, right now, I
1:37:09was using it this morning before we did this. And if I look at the app and the service,
1:37:18it's something that I would recommend. I think it's great. And I use the radio more now than
1:37:26what I've ever used radio before. I mean I was a big fan of Pandora because I think Pandora had
1:37:32the best algorithmic radio service out there. Better than Spotify, better than Apple, better
1:37:39than everybody. But Apple's is getting really really good. So the way that I use radio is
1:37:48I'll pick a song like Guns N' Roses. So pick Sweet Child of Mine or Welcome to the Jungle.
1:37:52[MUSIC]
1:38:06I'll say, make a station based on this song.
1:38:09What I expect here from that station is basically hit after hit after hit,
1:38:17nothing but hits
1:38:19for as long as I play that station and
1:38:22I I'll use that when I go for a drive or you know what I'm doing something that I just want to hear
1:38:29You know, I have people over and I pick a song
1:38:33I want to hear other songs like that and nothing but hits and for a while what you were getting from
1:38:40From the radio stations was and this is even before Apple music you were getting
1:38:47kind of like the the best of the b-sides that nobody ever wanted to hear and I would just
1:38:54be skipping through songs saying what is this why why are you playing and you know that's
1:39:03that's what you ended up with that's not the case anymore now I'm hearing a lot of great
1:39:08songs you know just and and that's great so what I also use the hard rock channel the
1:39:16pre-done curated hard rock channel on Apple Music and it's gotten really really really good.
1:39:24And I use that for discovery and I have added so many songs to my library from the hard rock
1:39:32channel that you know I'll be listening to songs and hearing new music and say yeah that's pretty
1:39:39good and I'll reach over and tap the the heart button so I'll heart that and then
1:39:45you know two or three days later I'll be you know listening to the hard rock
1:39:50channel and that song will will come on again and I'll say geez that's pretty
1:39:53good I'll reach over to hit the heart button and I'll have already hearted it
1:39:57so I said well I need to add that to my library and I'll go in and add that song
1:40:02sometimes I'll add the whole album but I'll add that song to my library and
1:40:05And then I also rate it with stars.
1:40:08So then it goes into my playlist of,
1:40:13you know, I have a playlist done of four stars or higher.
1:40:18So if I'm going on a long drive,
1:40:21I'll put on that playlist of all the songs forever
1:40:24that I've rated four stars or higher.
1:40:26And you know, I could have a couple thousand songs in there
1:40:29and I know that I'm gonna love every single one of them.
1:40:34It sounds like you you're having a much better experience with it than you used to
1:40:37Well, yeah, I mean it but see that's why I need my library right as as part of this because people have said
1:40:45You know like I added uh, and this was this was a couple months ago. I haven't tried it since but I added uh,
1:40:52Led zeppelin one and two
1:40:54To from my music to my itunes library
1:40:58and it changed the names of those those classic albums to Led Zeppelin Mothership, which is their
1:41:04greatest hits album. And it just it just pissed me off, you know, I'm saying come on, no, no, no,
1:41:12it's not, that's not it. Right, and it's even worse that it was those albums because those,
1:41:17it's wrong in any case to botch the album name, but they're so canonical, you know, iconic,
1:41:24you know what I mean? Like Led Zeppelin, every Zeppelin album, but especially to me,
1:41:28one, two, three, and four. Well, I can't, Houses of the Holy, they're all, they're all,
1:41:33you just know which album it is, right? But things like that I don't find happen much anymore.
1:41:40There are, and see, that's why I want my own music, because I've spent the last, you know,
1:41:46what 15 years rating songs in iTunes and and using those playlists for ratings and also for plays
1:41:59you know what are what are my uh my top 500 songs played of all time in my iTunes library I have a
1:42:06playlist for that right so if I want to narrow down you know the stars and to just what I've
1:42:12actually played, then I guess it would be all Aussie songs, but you know, then I can take that playlist.
1:42:20And people have said, you know, when I posted a picture of Led Zeppelin 1 and 2 being changed to
1:42:27Mothership, and people said, "Why would you add it from your own songs when you can just add it from
1:42:36from Apple Music and be done with it.
1:42:38And my argument was, well,
1:42:42then you're admitting that it doesn't work.
1:42:46I mean, you're basically admitting defeat and saying, fine.
1:42:49It doesn't work, I'll just do what Apple wants me to do.
1:42:53No, I have valid reasons that I want this stuff on my own.
1:42:58And do I wanna spend like a year going through all my music
1:43:02updating the stuff from Apple Music with all the ratings and everything I had? No, I'm
1:43:08not going to do that.
1:43:09So, while we're talking about Apple Music, have you seen a story about, I think it was
1:43:13Hollywood Reporter that broke it, but that Apple is backing a TV series, maybe a limited
1:43:22run TV series about and starring Dr. Dre?
1:43:26Yeah, I did see that.
1:43:29And to me, the interesting part was, so anybody who's been waiting for a while for Apple to
1:43:35start having their own exclusive content, because they're sort of the last ones to the
1:43:40game.
1:43:41I mean, I don't know, I guess Microsoft doesn't really, but YouTube, you know, through, you
1:43:44know, Google through YouTube has YouTube Red only content.
1:43:49Hulu, obviously, it's all about their own content.
1:43:52Netflix has their own content.
1:43:56And Amazon has exclusive content if you're an Amazon Prime number.
1:44:01So the question is, if Apple, if it's true, and it seems like it's definitely true that
1:44:06they're shooting this Dr. Dre thing, like the Hollywood Reporter had reports of who's
1:44:11in it and what the content is.
1:44:14I'm fascinated by the idea of how are they going to release it.
1:44:21Are they going to sell it through iTunes?
1:44:23pay $1.99 an episode like you do for shows from networks? Are they going to make it so
1:44:30that if you are an Apple Music subscriber you get it for free? Would they do both so
1:44:35that if you're not an Apple Music subscriber you can buy it? But if you're, you know, if
1:44:40you do, is it like, sign up for Apple Music and you can watch this Dr. Dre show? And if
1:44:44so, isn't Apple Music a bad name for Apple Music? It's also, right? Like, it's less than
1:44:51a year old but it's already you know in the way that itunes got this name that with tunes you know
1:44:58the root word of itunes is tunes and it evolved in all these ways that eventually had nothing to do
1:45:03with music is apple music already about video content and don't forget that uh itunes uh itunes
1:45:11was itunes music store and they they dropped music right you know like uh ios was iphone
1:45:18Right. Is Apple ever going to stop naming things music and then going on to make them go in other ways?
1:45:23And just it would be like if Amazon Prime had been named Amazon Free Shipping.
1:45:27The Amazon Free Shipping Club. No, it's like they had the foresight when they named it Amazon Prime
1:45:33that, "Hey, we might do all sorts of cool stuff for people who sign up for this. So let's just
1:45:38give it a name that just sort of means, you know, Amazon Premium customer."
1:45:42But I think I think they they did such a good job with with iTunes over the years that people know
1:45:48You know, you just go to iTunes to get everything which may be part of the problem in trying to split it up
1:45:54You know, I but you know with your your question
1:45:58I mean it would make sense for Apple because they have the money to be able to say yes sign up for
1:46:04Apple music and get dr. Dre's show for free
1:46:10- Yeah.
1:46:11- You know, they could very well do that.
1:46:13I think it's interesting that they are getting into it,
1:46:16and I think it's a good thing, and they need to do it.
1:46:21- Yeah, what if, I mean, it could, I don't know,
1:46:23I mean, they have so many options, but it could,
1:46:25could just say if you have any Apple device,
1:46:29you can watch it for free, you know?
1:46:30Any iPhone, iPad, Apple TV can watch this show for free.
1:46:35I don't know.
1:46:37I'm very curious what they would do,
1:46:39or what they're going to do.
1:46:40I've been thinking about it for a long time
1:46:41'cause I've long, everybody's long suspected Apple
1:46:44might get into original content.
1:46:46But now that they are, I'm excited to find out
1:46:48how they're actually gonna go to market with it.
1:46:50'Cause I don't think it's clear.
1:46:52- It is gonna be, well, and let's not forget
1:46:54that they grew from, what, six million subscribers
1:46:59to 11 million, they told you on the show last week.
1:47:05I mean, that's huge.
1:47:07funny because it's not huge by Apple standards. Like on the same show, you know, they mentioned
1:47:12that they have 700 million users, 700 and some million total users, and they've only got 11
1:47:19million on Apple Music, but it's, you know, it's in comparison to other streaming services, and it is
1:47:25sort of a slow and steady wins the race type thing. Right, and like by huge I meant huge increase in
1:47:32in a relatively short period of time.
1:47:35I mean, they almost doubled it.
1:47:37So here's the question though.
1:47:39Did they double it because of this Taylor Swift thing?
1:47:43I mean, for a while it looked like
1:47:44Taylor Swift had bought Apple.
1:47:46- Right.
1:47:47- Because she was just everywhere.
1:47:48You walk into a retail store,
1:47:49the stores were just plastered with Taylor Swift.
1:47:52The iTunes store was plastered with Taylor Swift.
1:47:56I mean, every banner was Taylor Swift.
1:47:58Is that why it grew?
1:48:01And I've also said before that--
1:48:05- I don't think it hurt.
1:48:06- Well, it certainly didn't hurt.
1:48:08I mean, is it because the service over that time got better?
1:48:13I understand that there are a lot of people,
1:48:16a lot of people that never had a problem with Apple Music.
1:48:20I get that, I've talked to those people, you know?
1:48:25And I envy those people, I really do.
1:48:28But if you came to me today with Apple Music and said,
1:48:33here it is, I'd be 100% behind it
1:48:38and I can't see saying a bad thing.
1:48:41Like I said, there's still a couple of niggly little bugs
1:48:44in it, but nothing that I would say,
1:48:47oh, this is terrible.
1:48:49I mean, it's just a software bug, I don't care.
1:48:52- Well, I think the music industry is going,
1:48:55clearly kind of going the same way as the TV and video world, where exclusives drive
1:49:07the subscriptions. Netflix isn't Netflix without the Netflix original content at this point,
1:49:16even though a lot of what people watch on Netflix are their whole library of movies and stuff like
1:49:20that but it's the fact that they have some stuff that you can only get on
1:49:23Netflix that is you know if you're only going to subscribe to one or two monthly
1:49:28services you know it's the exclusive stuff that makes you pick which ones it
1:49:32is and just as the you know another example so the and it just seems like
1:49:36you know Taylor Swift having original stuff on on Apple music like the movie
1:49:42they made and stuff like that is exclusive yeah and then you've got
1:49:46Kanye West who has a new album out that's only on Tidal and he said for whatever reason you know
1:49:52that it's never going to be on, he called it Apple, but it's never going to be on
1:49:55yeah and I for one am thankful that he's not going to be on Apple Music so
1:50:04I saw him on Saturday Night Live last week I thought it was like incomprehensible
1:50:09I mean, I'm a little old and I'm definitely not in the demo, but it was a very bizarre performance.
1:50:17He's an interesting guy. But again, though, it's just... but you just never used to see that in the
1:50:22old days. There was never like an album that came out from a major act that was only at
1:50:26Tower Records. Right. Right? It just wasn't how the industry worked. And it just seems like now,
1:50:33especially from the perspective of the the the the superstar music acts that
1:50:40it's all about exclusives and Apple is in a strong position in my opinion in
1:50:45that regard because they can a pay for it and be I think that from them you
1:50:52know in addition to just the fact that Apple has the money to pay for it they
1:50:55know people know that Apple has the marketing ability to to really help you
1:50:59know that if Apple is behind you in the marketing you know you've got a really
1:51:03marketing partner. Yep, I agree and I love the fact that they are getting into this original
1:51:12content. I can't wait to see where that goes. But there's a lot of things that they can do.
1:51:20They have a lot of connections and you know what I think is really funny? Remember the whole thing
1:51:26with Jimmy Iovine talking about women and playlists.
1:51:30(laughing)
1:51:32That women are sitting around talking about boys
1:51:36and listening to music and they need help with playlists.
1:51:39The latest commercial were three women
1:51:41sitting around talking about breaking up
1:51:43and listening to music.
1:51:45I thought that was kind of ironic.
1:51:47- Oh, and I guess that brings us to the last
1:51:50and final scandal of the week,
1:51:52which is that in the, I think that was the commercial,
1:51:54There's one of the new two new iPhone commercials Apple at the narrator young woman pronounces the word
1:52:01Jeff as
1:52:03GIF which is how I pronounce it is it you know the GIF image format is it a soft?
1:52:07Soft G or hard G and Apple has come out strongly on the hard G side
1:52:12Which is where I've always been me too, so but there we go, but I know people are losing losing their shit over that yeah
1:52:20Well, we have we have so much time in our hands these days that we can we can lose their shit over something like like that
1:52:28But I don't what is the right way? I've always said gift
1:52:32This is why it's the long story short the controversy is that the I think it was one guy
1:52:38I mean, I guess I can look it up in the show notes, but whoever it was who created it
1:52:42If you remember it was a unisys
1:52:44Image format that they had a patent on and that they never enforced it
1:52:49But then when the and and it was like a sort of obscure image format in like the late 80s early 90s
1:52:56But then when the web happened and we needed really tightly, you know, very small
1:53:02byte count image format and then all the browsers supported the format and it exploded and then Unisys was like hey, dude
1:53:10We still own a patent on that and really kind of made a stink about it
1:53:15Anyway, the the team or the guy at unisys who invented it and stands for graphics interchange format and the guy who invented it
1:53:22says it they've always pronounced it with the soft G Jeff like the peanut butter and
1:53:27Therefore the that side of the argument says the guy who invented it says it's Jeff. Therefore. It's Jeff
1:53:33Whereas
1:53:37Everybody else is like if it's graphics interchange format. It's a hard G. It's gif and
1:53:43Who cares what the original guy said language evolves naturally and the natural way that this has evolved is that it's a hard G
1:53:50okay, so
1:53:52The big question doesn't matter
1:53:55People but there was like when that video came out there was like an hour or two on Twitter where that's all anybody was talking about
1:54:02I mean, do you go to anybody and say gift and they don't know what you're talking about?
1:54:07No, no, I just I just think it sounds better great
1:54:11I'd be very curious to know like whether readers and listeners of the show if
1:54:16how they fall it seems like
1:54:19it's a little bit like the vodka versus gin martini thing where there's
1:54:25The the one side cares a lot and the other side is like hey you pronounce it. However you want
1:54:31Yeah, you know like with martinis the people who like vodka martinis other people, you know, and somebody else's well
1:54:37I think a real martini has to be made with gin and the vodka person says, okay
1:54:40Enjoy your gin martini. But the gin martini person is like, "You're not drinking a real martini. That's not a martini. You're..."
1:54:46And I feel like the hard G gif people are like... I say gif, you say gif. Alright.
1:54:52But the soft G people really get bent out of shape about it. Apparently because the guy who created it says it's the other way.
1:55:02Anyway, Apple says it's hard G, so I say it's hard G.
1:55:05I always said hard G.
1:55:08anything else before we wrap up? I don't think so. I guess I have a correct I
1:55:17guess most podcasts do their corrections at the beginning. Two episodes ago I said
1:55:26and I think that was with Ben Thompson I I was we were talking about the new
1:55:31four-inch iPhone that's supposedly coming next month and I think I said
1:55:34that it's gonna have the A8 processor that's a year old from the iPhone 6. And Mark Gurman
1:55:40has reported that it's an A9. I think a couple other rumors have said A9. I misspoke on the
1:55:46air. So the rumor is, I don't know if it's true or not, but anyway, I should correct
1:55:49it that the rumor as reported by Mark Gurman and I think others is that the new 4-inch
1:55:54iPhone is gonna have an A9 processor which would put it at the, you know, six months
1:56:02behind the iPhone 6s and 6s plus in terms of specs and that is exactly why when I was on the
1:56:08show with Ben that I said I think that it's a phone that Apple intends to keep on the market
1:56:12for 18 to 24 months because they're putting the top of the line a9 in there and that makes a lot
1:56:17more sense I misspoke when I said a8 though and I regret the error well anything else clearly you're
1:56:23not trustworthy anymore I mean can I ask you one question before you can ask me anything Joe all
1:56:31Do you use Apple Music? Not a lot. I don't listen to a lot of music, to tell you the truth.
1:56:36I haven't in a long time. I can't work with music playing.
1:56:42Well, I could. I shouldn't say I can't. But I'm a little princess in a pea. I like to...
1:56:46with a pea under my mattress. I like to work in silence, so I don't listen to music
1:56:51when I'm writing or reading. If I do want to listen to music, though,
1:56:56I would. Yeah, okay. I was just wondering. I think where I will eventually use Apple Music the most
1:57:02and I need to get a new car to make it work better, but I anticipate, you know, that getting a car
1:57:12where instead of using Sirius, which we have in our car, I would much rather have Apple Music
1:57:18and just go over the LTE connection on my phone because it would be a much higher quality. Even
1:57:25Even my shitty ears can hear the horrible compression on current satellite radio.
1:57:32So it would be way higher fidelity.
1:57:34And obviously, I think I would just rather go through the Apple Music stations and the
1:57:38Apple Music algorithms and have the complete access to my personal library at all times,
1:57:43rather than just choose from the stations that Sirius offers.
1:57:48The car is where I would listen to music, but I don't drive much, so it's not that much.
1:57:52Even there, it's not much.
1:57:55Like when I go out on a walk in the city or something like that,
1:57:57I listen to podcasts instead of music.
1:57:58I don't really listen to it much.
1:58:00But if I do listen to music, I do use it.
1:58:01But I don't use it enough that I have strong opinions on it.
1:58:04So that's why I don't really write much about Apple Music.
1:58:08Well, give it a try.
1:58:09I think you'll like it.
1:58:12Everybody can check out Jim's work, of course,
1:58:14at loopinsight.com.
1:58:17That's Jim's website.
1:58:18And on Twitter, he's--
1:58:20I'm going to guess.
1:58:21My guess is your username is jdalrimple.
1:58:25That is it.
1:58:26- And you can enjoy his plight, his plight on, you know.
1:58:31(laughing)
1:58:37- No, there's no plight anymore.
1:58:39It's all good.
1:58:40- It's polite tweets.
1:58:42All right, Jim, thanks a lot.
1:58:44It's good talking to you.
1:58:46- You too, man.