0:00:00You gotta let go of this Jeopardy thing, Glenn.
0:00:02Hey, I got my ticket for the rest of my life.
0:00:05It's the gravy train.
0:00:06Super nice guy.
0:00:07I was hating the fact that people were giving him
0:00:09all this crap for actually playing the game well.
0:00:11Have you seen the backlash?
0:00:12Oh, I have actually seen this, where he is sort of--
0:00:17this is actually interesting.
0:00:18Yeah, he's sort of like a money ball.
0:00:21He's playing Jeopardy like money ball is to baseball.
0:00:25Yeah.
0:00:25Right.
0:00:26And I asked him, I was like, how much did you spend on strategy
0:00:29how much of memorizing ahead of time, he's like, totally strategy. Like, he memorized
0:00:32some stuff, but he basically figured out how to play the Daily Doubles during the games,
0:00:38which is the, the, people miss that. You can win during the game, you don't have to win
0:00:42at Final Jeopardy, and so he basically wins during the game, and the most, the highest
0:00:47grossing winners have all essentially played the game that way. I mean, Ken Jennings was
0:00:52a little different, but he was early after they changed some of the rules and so forth.
0:00:55But I actually who's the new guy's name? What's his name Arthur Chu Arthur Chu? I actually became aware of him because I saw a piece that
0:01:02Jennings wrote about him defending. It was great. It was really nice
0:01:06All right
0:01:06so like there's sort of a like the traditional way to play jeopardy the gentleman style if you would is
0:01:13you you pick a category if you have control of the board you pick a category that appeals to you and you pick the
0:01:20The lowest did not you know go from the top down?
0:01:23so in the first round you'll pick $200 than the $400 if you keep getting it right and work your way down to the
0:01:30Higher money and you know that I guess there's some correlation between the higher money and harder questions
0:01:36Yeah, well a little bit. I think that it's actually weird. They do make that they do
0:01:40Make the questions a little harder as it goes down as it goes down the board not always but typically and the producers ask you
0:01:48To go from top to bottom and they don't tell you to do it and it's not a rule, right?
0:01:51But they say, "Look, most people do best this way. It's less confusing. The audience
0:01:56prefers it. It's probably a better way to play. We're not going to make you do it."
0:02:00And it's just, in the heat of the moment, it's really hard to make the right judgment.
0:02:04But Daily Doubles occur predominantly in predictable locations.
0:02:07Right. They're not randomly located. If you study the game and look at where they've
0:02:13been, you can, you know, there's some spots that are higher percentage, significantly
0:02:18higher percentage chance of being a daily double than others. And if you have control
0:02:23of the board, it is to your advantage to hunt for them.
0:02:27Yeah, and he's just killing it. He's got the right combination of buzzer timing, domain
0:02:31knowledge that's fairly broad and deep in trivia categories, and this strategy, I think
0:02:37he's winning against sometimes stronger overall players who can't master this strategy because
0:02:41he's throwing them out. So yeah, it's very Moneyball, and it's great. And I think the
0:02:44The thing is, he comes across as a little affectless on screen because, you know, I
0:02:49do this when I'm thinking really hard, I go slack, and he is playing the game.
0:02:53So there is this, like, this geeky and often, you know, Asian guy, so there's been some
0:02:57racism is winning the game.
0:03:00And it's like, no, he's really, he's very funny.
0:03:02So his Twitter handle is @Arthur_affect.
0:03:07And I think it's hilarious because he's clearly making fun of, like, the affectless, you know,
0:03:11thing about it.
0:03:12funny on Twitter. He's very personable in the interview and, and you know, for all we
0:03:16know he's just won like 20 more games because it's, you know, he taped months ago so he
0:03:21can't talk about it. But he's, it's very, it's enjoyable. I just like watching people,
0:03:25"He's playing the game wrong!" It's like, the point of the game is to win, it's not
0:03:28to, you at home may not like what he's doing. But I thought it's great.
0:03:32Pete: Right. The other thing that Ken Jennings pointed out in his piece on him is, in addition
0:03:37to the fact that it's to your advantage to get the, huge advantage to get the Daily
0:03:40doubles. It also, by skipping around the board from category to category, it gives you an
0:03:48advantage over your opponents because you know if you get it right where you're going
0:03:52next and you're ready for that category, whereas your opponents don't even know which category
0:03:56to be thinking about. Whereas if you play that traditional way and somebody picks potent
0:04:03potables for 200, even if you don't buzz in and get it, you're ready for the next one
0:04:07to be potent potables for 400.
0:04:10- Yeah, it's totally true.
0:04:11But it's interesting, it plays into the game theory thing
0:04:14and people have their own preset notions
0:04:17about what they want, but I'm enjoying watching them.
0:04:22My boys and I are watching them play, it's very fun.
0:04:24- Yeah, it reminds me, it's like anything with game theory,
0:04:28but one of my favorites is the history of Blackjack.
0:04:32- Yeah.
0:04:34where blackjack
0:04:36it's kind of funny because it's like the rules state at least back to the
0:04:41eighteen hundreds
0:04:43and were apparently you know the
0:04:46came about without the help of any sort of computer modeling whatsoever and
0:04:49without computer modeling there's really no way to tell
0:04:53what the the
0:04:54perfect strategy is and whether the house actually has an advantage or not
0:04:59and so for decades decades and decades you know through the until the nineteen
0:05:041960s, typical players in a casino, like what was considered "here's the right way to play,"
0:05:11actually were playing at a tremendous disadvantage to the house.
0:05:16The basic gist of the way most people played in a casino, and if you sat down and were
0:05:21unfamiliar with the game and were sitting next to somebody who was clearly a seasoned
0:05:26blackjack player and asked for help from him, this is the way you would learn to play, is
0:05:30that you should never bust.
0:05:32you get to 12 or 13, you just stop because you could bust, and busting is an automatic
0:05:40loss.
0:05:41And it's, you know, the dealer just takes your chips, and it doesn't matter what the
0:05:44dealer does.
0:05:45You know, that's part of what makes the game a little complicated is if you bust, the dealer
0:05:50takes your bet, and it's gone.
0:05:52And even if the dealer subsequently goes on to bust, you don't, you know, there's no tie
0:05:56in that situation.
0:05:59Even though in theory it's a tie because you both busted.
0:06:02And so that's so devastating that players develop this, it was just a traditional strategy.
0:06:09Never take a card if you can bust.
0:06:11With the pot, and then some people would play, well maybe if they had a 12, maybe they would
0:06:14hit on 12 because it would take a 10 to bust.
0:06:18But it ends up that's a horrendous, horrendous strategy for the player.
0:06:22And this guy, Edward Thorpe, who worked at IBM, he was like the first guy to beat the
0:06:27And he did it with not by like working it out
0:06:30Through formulas, but just through brute force computation that he just programmed
0:06:36You know a simple game of blackjack and just ran it millions and millions of times, you know given this hand
0:06:43You know if you play this way what if you know what happens and came up with you know
0:06:48The basic strategy and it's you know, it's very different from that
0:06:51But what happened then is players who had read Thorpe's book and Thorpe also, you know invented card counting
0:06:57Which gave the play actually gave the player, you know an advantage of two three percent, which yeah, which is huge
0:07:03But even without the counting part even just the basic strategy
0:07:06where you could just learn these simple rules if you have a
0:07:0914 and the dealer has a 16 you stay if you have a
0:07:1215 and the dealer has a 10 card showing you have to hit
0:07:15The players who had that strategy would do very well and before the casinos sort of adjusted the game
0:07:22you could maybe even have a slight advantage in the '60s. You could actually play the game
0:07:27without counting cards to have a slight advantage. But it was like a social thing, though, where
0:07:33if these other guys at the table were playing the traditional way, and then there's a guy who's
0:07:38actually playing the mathematically right way, they would—some of them would get angry. You know,
0:07:42they'd be like, "What the hell are you doing hitting a 15?" You know?
0:07:45Right, because it would seem to be random, it would seem to be—since it's counterintuitive,
0:07:49it seems like you're playing the game wrong, even though, I mean, this is the Indiana Jones
0:07:54moment when he shoots the guy, when he's got the whip. Like, you're like, "Wait a minute,
0:07:59that's not fair!" It's like, "Oh, wait a minute, the point is to come out ahead, the point
0:08:02is not to, you're there to play the game!" This is reality TV, you know, I watched some
0:08:06seasons of Survivor, and that was the thing that was fascinating, I think it all developed
0:08:11into a pattern eventually, but it was fascinating to watch somebody like Boston Rob, who was
0:08:14much reviled. He figured out a new way to play the game a few seasons in, and it transformed
0:08:20the game dynamics, and everyone watching him had to play the game differently after that.
0:08:24But it pisses you off if you're in the middle of the situation.
0:08:26Dave: Right.
0:08:27Because it's an evolving game dynamic in which everything in your head that you've built
0:08:31your strategy around is suddenly wrong, and you hate that other person because they've
0:08:34changed—you're not playing the same game anymore.
0:08:36Dave Yeah, because I've watched—I haven't watched
0:08:39Survivor in a couple years, but I did watch the first couple years, and I do remember
0:08:43Boston Rob.
0:08:44Uh, he was great.
0:08:45He was the best villain.
0:08:46He was exactly who he was.
0:08:48I mean, I think of all the people, and I think I watched four or five seasons.
0:08:52Who is the guy that, it was like the guy on the very first season.
0:08:55Oh, Richard Hatch?
0:08:56Richard Hatch.
0:08:57The guy who thought he didn't have to pay taxes.
0:08:59Yeah, exactly.
0:09:00He really thought it cause he didn't take the plea deal.
0:09:02He went to jail cause he thought he was right.
0:09:04I know.
0:09:05It's hilarious.
0:09:06I'm like, it's really straightforward tax situation.
0:09:08Right.
0:09:09But he, as the winner of the first series, and seemingly played it pretty smart, became
0:09:15like the, "Well, that's how you play the game."
0:09:17Yeah.
0:09:18You know, Richard Hatches.
0:09:19Yeah, then he came back, and in whatever the tournament was, the All-Stars thing, a few
0:09:25seasons into it, he comes back, he tries to play the game the same way, and he is knocked
0:09:29out like a few days in.
0:09:31And his favorite statement was, "I was bamboozled!"
0:09:34And it was like, "No, the game changed.
0:09:36The game changed, and you're out, buddy.
0:09:38You can't just walk around with your Wing Wang flicking at people and win again.
0:09:42Right.
0:09:43Well, any other thing, yeah, he seemed unprepared for the fact that the first season, nobody
0:09:47knew, A, nobody knew the game, and B, nobody knew what he was doing.
0:09:52Yeah.
0:09:53Whereas, when he came back for the, you know, what was it, like, it's like the Jeopardy
0:09:57Champions thing, like Survivor Champions thing.
0:09:59It was, clearly everybody there, you know, as a Survivor player had watched the first
0:10:04season of Survivor and was well aware of his, you know, he really needed like a new strategy
0:10:09and did not have it.
0:10:10Pete: Well, you know, there's this thing called the Markov Chain and I found out about
0:10:14it because of the game Shoots and Ladders of all things, because someone wrote this
0:10:18hilarious, I think Shoots and Ladders or Snake, sort of it's called, Snake's Ladders,
0:10:22someone years ago wrote this hilarious review/analysis of that kid's game, looking at it from this
0:10:27mathematical standpoint.
0:10:29A Markov chain is, it's, listen to me,
0:10:32the Wikipedia thing, a mathematical system
0:10:34that undergoes transitions from one state to another
0:10:36in the state, on a state space, it's random things.
0:10:39So the next action is not followed upon
0:10:43because of the previous action.
0:10:45And there are games that are,
0:10:48the games that are most interesting
0:10:49are the ones in which it is,
0:10:51there's not a predictable outcome
0:10:53based on the sequence of things in which you do.
0:10:55So in Chutes and Ladders, the dice are everything.
0:10:58It's really a game that teaches kids how to play games.
0:11:01But in poker, the number of possibilities are too huge,
0:11:04even with card counting, they still become too huge
0:11:08to be predictable as an outcome from starting states.
0:11:11And so there's this issue about the tension
0:11:14between games that have Markovian properties
0:11:17and non-Markovian properties about which ones are fun or not
0:11:20because as a parent, you know,
0:11:22Chutes and Ladders sucks and Candyland sucks
0:11:24because they're, what is it called,
0:11:28chain non-Markovian. Right. Candyland is the worst. Candyland isn't even really a game
0:11:33because it's entirely deterministic. You know, there's a deck of cards. Once the cards have
0:11:38been shuffled and you've decided what order the players are going to play in, the outcome
0:11:42is already determined. That's right. There's a dice component to it which is ostensibly
0:11:46Markovian but the chained Markovian action is the each card is played in sequence. So,
0:11:52right. It's just it's horrible, but it teaches kids how to it's simple enough that it teaches
0:11:57kids how to play rules and follow the game and that there's winners.
0:12:01It's a horrible thing.
0:12:02I don't think it is.
0:12:03Yeah.
0:12:04Horrible.
0:12:05Yeah.
0:12:06I think you can get a lot of those lessons out of a better game.
0:12:07We never-- we lucked out.
0:12:08Jonas never fell for Candyland.
0:12:10We played for Candyland for too long.
0:12:11But now we're the settlers of Catan, which is much better.
0:12:15If anything, Candyland, you have no choices and there are devastating bad cards.
0:12:25know, like the, you know, get the candy cane and send you all the way back to the beginning.
0:12:29Like--
0:12:29Oh my god, we hate that so much.
0:12:31You know, I don't know. It doesn't seem like you get any good lessons out of it.
0:12:34You don't learn any strategy. And you learn that, you know, something terrible can happen
0:12:40to you at any moment. It doesn't--
0:12:42It teaches you the essential hopelessness of life and what the working world is like as well. That's
0:12:46what it does.
0:12:49Yeah, it's sort of a-- full of-- philosophically, it's a depressing game because it's sort of like--
0:12:54Oh my god.
0:12:55You know, it's like going back to college philosophy 101
0:12:59and you know, is there such a thing as free choice?
0:13:02You know, and in candy land there isn't.
0:13:03There is no free choice.
0:13:05- It reinforces that.
0:13:06It's like this is, yeah, here's your elementary school
0:13:08and college and the job and here's the housemate
0:13:11of Tiki Taki you bought up on the hill
0:13:12and this is your life, kid.
0:13:15This is the future.
0:13:16- Right, it's you know, like with sufficient knowledge
0:13:18you could already, you know, you could predict exactly
0:13:20when and where you're gonna die.
0:13:22- And you're never gonna get the gumdrop.
0:13:24it's only a piece of paper.
0:13:25(laughing)
0:13:27- Do you ever play Blackjack?
0:13:29Do you ever gamble?
0:13:31- A little bit.
0:13:32I like the instinct to wanna win.
0:13:34(laughing)
0:13:35- No, it's a deficiency.
0:13:36- So I enjoy it intellectually, but I kinda,
0:13:38I just lose interest.
0:13:38I'm like, "Ah, this is fun, but I don't have any,"
0:13:40I don't have any, and weirdly, I mean, playing Jeopardy,
0:13:43Jeopardy is a different kind of battle,
0:13:44but I just never have, I don't have the,
0:13:47I can't stick to it.
0:13:48I'm kinda, "Oh, this is fun.
0:13:49Now I'm gonna wander off and look at that other thing."
0:13:51So it doesn't hit me for some reason.
0:13:52- When you were on Jeopardy,
0:13:54Did you get daily doubles?
0:13:57- Yeah, I think I'd never, I didn't get a lockout.
0:14:01So IBM researchers did this, they built Watson.
0:14:06One of the things they did is they did this,
0:14:07one group did all this game theory and analysis
0:14:10and they found that people who win Jeopardy
0:14:12fit into three categories.
0:14:13There's sort of regular champions,
0:14:15masters and grandmasters.
0:14:17And I was clearly in the regular champion category.
0:14:20Like I eked out a couple wins, I'm happy that I won,
0:14:23but I wasn't like a natural player like some people are.
0:14:26So I did okay, I did okay.
0:14:28- Well, that's the daily double, you know,
0:14:30it ties in with Blackjack 'cause it is,
0:14:33it's the one part of Jeopardy that's,
0:14:35well, the final Jeopardy is a bit of a gamble,
0:14:38but you know, it's a gamble
0:14:39where you don't know the question, you know,
0:14:42whereas the regular questions, it's a combination of skill,
0:14:46like your actual ability to recall the answer,
0:14:49know the answer and physically to hit the buzzer first. But you do, you know, you get the question.
0:14:56So it's not, you're not gambling. I mean, you do, and you can maybe say you are if you're only half
0:15:02certain of the answer and you're going to buzz in anyway and take a chance you got it right because
0:15:05you lose the money if you get it wrong. But the daily...
0:15:09The better strategy is to never buzz in when you don't know the answer for sure because you then
0:15:13both lose the money you have and someone else is most more likely to get it and they gain it back.
0:15:17you almost double the difference. Because they've had the time to think about it.
0:15:21Oh, I saw a heartbreaking one where someone misspoke and then the other person just buzzed
0:15:25in and got it. And they said almost exactly the right thing. Oh, I remember as a kid when it was
0:15:28newer, when it wasn't so ingrained in the culture. I mean, I don't watch regularly anymore, but it's
0:15:35been years since I've seen one where somebody forgot to put the answer in the form of a question.
0:15:39Whereas when I was a kid, that happened fairly regularly and inevitably somebody else would buzz
0:15:45in with the same answer in the form of a question
0:15:48to take the dollars.
0:15:49- I know, it's sad.
0:15:50There's actually a tiny rule which is in regular Jeopardy
0:15:53in the first half of the game.
0:15:55They will alert you and you can restate it.
0:15:57In double Jeopardy, you cannot.
0:16:00If you say it without it being a question,
0:16:02it's just automatic wrong.
0:16:04- Is that a new rule?
0:16:04I don't remember that.
0:16:05- It's been kicking, well, it's at least for a couple years.
0:16:07I played a couple years ago.
0:16:08I know, it's funny, they just, because then they're like,
0:16:09by the second half, you're like, if you can't get it,
0:16:12like that's your problem.
0:16:12You're just gonna buzz in and lose.
0:16:15- But you have to have the heart of a gambler though
0:16:17to really play aggressively on the daily doubles
0:16:20like this, is it Richard Chu?
0:16:22What's his, Arthur Chu?
0:16:23- Yeah, he's, because if you can,
0:16:25it's more likely you already know the category,
0:16:27you may have answered questions in the category,
0:16:30so you know the kind of direction they're taking,
0:16:32and then you could go all out.
0:16:34And so Roger Craig, who is now the number four winner,
0:16:37'cause Arthur has displaced him so far,
0:16:39number four all-time regular season winner, Roger Craig,
0:16:42he won $77,000 in one day
0:16:44because he did one Daily Double and then got another and did it. And it made sense because
0:16:49he knew the category and he could have lost, because he did two Daily Doubles twice in
0:16:55a row. But it didn't, it's funny, it didn't, I don't think it was a bad game decision because
0:17:01he was confident enough and he could have, he'd already won a bunch of money at that
0:17:04point. So there's a point where you've already won enough money, you've won enough days that
0:17:08like you know you're going to be in the Tournament of Champions, for instance, you're going to
0:17:11come back.
0:17:12psychologically want to win more than you're afraid to lose.
0:17:17- Yeah, that's exactly it.
0:17:19- Right?
0:17:19- And there's something about that, like, well, you're sitting
0:17:20in that position and you're like, I could get the highest
0:17:23score ever, I'm gonna do it. - Right, like let's say you've
0:17:25got 13,000 and I've got 8,000 and you get the daily double.
0:17:30A normal conservative person is gonna think, well, I'm up
0:17:34by 5,000 already, I don't wanna risk it, I wanna stay up
0:17:36even if I get it wrong.
0:17:38Whereas it's probably a better game theory strategy
0:17:41to just go for it, you know, put-
0:17:44- Yeah, you already know, you know
0:17:46what the other players play, you know how you're doing,
0:17:47you look at the board, if there's time left-
0:17:49- Because you can win the game right there on that play.
0:17:51- Yeah, I mean, I lost, I did a true daily double,
0:17:53the game that I lost, I had five grand
0:17:56and I was getting close to the end,
0:17:57it was a terrible game, we were all playing it,
0:17:58we were all off, and I bet all five grand
0:18:00and I said George Sands instead of George Sand,
0:18:04I will never forget, and I lost it all,
0:18:06but I still came back and if I'd been,
0:18:07I got another daily double,
0:18:08I got two daily doubles in a row.
0:18:10And if I had said sand, I would have won the game.
0:18:14So it was the right choice.
0:18:15It was a category I knew I'd answered,
0:18:17I think the other three or four questions correctly.
0:18:20So it was absolutely the right choice
0:18:21and I lost in exactly the right way.
0:18:23- It's never the right way to lose.
0:18:28- I know, somebody has to lose, two people have to lose.
0:18:31- The thing that, just to finish the thought
0:18:36from five minutes ago on Blackjack.
0:18:39The thing that drives the blackjack players nuts,
0:18:42if they think that they know the right way to play
0:18:44and somebody else is playing differently,
0:18:46is that then after the guy plays wrong, according to them,
0:18:51whether it's the modern era,
0:18:53if you don't play the mathematical basic strategy
0:18:56or back in the '60s when people started to,
0:18:58and then the next card comes out
0:19:00and if it had been the other way around
0:19:02would have busted the dealer
0:19:05and everybody would have won or whatever,
0:19:07they blame the player.
0:19:08as opposed to, as opposed to, you know, like, so,
0:19:13you know, let's say I've got a 15,
0:19:17and I'm the last player to go,
0:19:19I've got a 15 and the dealer has a 20,
0:19:22and it's 1968, and everybody thinks I should just stay
0:19:25because I could bust, but I know that I should,
0:19:27what I should do is hit, because 15 against a dealer's 10,
0:19:31I'm probably gonna lose anyway, it's a terrible hand,
0:19:34but I'm gonna lose less if I hit.
0:19:36I'll lose less if I play the same hand a thousand times.
0:19:39I'll lose fewer times.
0:19:41So I hit and I take, let's say, a seven
0:19:44and I bust 'cause I have 22.
0:19:46Now I'm out.
0:19:47Then the dealer turns over their cards
0:19:49and ends up, the dealer has a 16.
0:19:52And so the dealer has to hit and pulls a four
0:19:56to have 20 and the dealer wins.
0:19:58Whereas if I had just done what everybody thought
0:20:00I should do and stay, on this particular hand,
0:20:03the dealer would have busted and everybody else
0:20:05who is still in the game would have won.
0:20:06- Oh, I see.
0:20:07So statistically, you're gonna annoy people
0:20:08because that's gonna happen frequently enough,
0:20:10even though you come out ahead.
0:20:12- Right.
0:20:12- In specific games, you're gonna be peeving people
0:20:15as a result.
0:20:15- And most people don't, you know,
0:20:17they don't have any concept of, you know,
0:20:20statistical, what's the phrase?
0:20:24A large enough sample set to be statistically valid, right?
0:20:28You know, one hand, anything could happen, right?
0:20:31Some asshole could have a 20 and hit
0:20:33and get an ace to make 21.
0:20:34I mean, it's like the stupidest thing you could do,
0:20:36but you know, sometimes it's gonna work, right?
0:20:39One out of 13 cards in the deck is an ace.
0:20:41It doesn't make it the right play,
0:20:44but then somebody will say, "Well, see, if you won,
0:20:46"it's proof that you did the right thing,
0:20:48"and if you lost, it's not."
0:20:50- Well, this is where you get into insanity
0:20:51is people develop their theories,
0:20:53and the theory is if they're not statistically valid.
0:20:56I mean, it gets back to the Moneyball thing, right?
0:20:57Moneyball is a battle between people going by their gut,
0:21:00which is often wrong, and by the statistics,
0:21:03which are statistically correct, right?
0:21:06I mean, we ran this piece in the magazine,
0:21:08and Philip Michaels wrote a great article,
0:21:11we called "Three Strikes You Shout,"
0:21:13about 10 years after Moneyball
0:21:14and what had changed in baseball.
0:21:16And there's tons of people who still reject
0:21:1910 years later watching the results of it.
0:21:21They still think everything is a fluke
0:21:22'cause their gut's right.
0:21:23They were in the big game, you know, the big show.
0:21:25They know what's going on.
0:21:25And so, and you obviously don't know
0:21:28'cause you didn't play baseball and whatever.
0:21:30It's like, well, I'm sorry if the statistics are right.
0:21:32- They are, and it kinda sucks,
0:21:34but they are actually correct.
0:21:36- Yeah, absolutely.
0:21:38- Less romance in statistics.
0:21:40- Yeah, you still hear about that,
0:21:41that there's still like old-time baseball scouts
0:21:43who just don't really look at the numbers
0:21:46and just look at how the guy looks,
0:21:48judging that way. - Eventually they will be out.
0:21:51- And there's little things too,
0:21:52like there's a surprising,
0:21:54it's one of those things that's kinda hard to measure
0:21:56because it's effectively subjective,
0:22:00but that better looking players,
0:22:03handsome or young men, tend to be scouted higher
0:22:06than homelier players.
0:22:09- Sure. - Right?
0:22:10And it's just one of those ways
0:22:13that good looking people just have better fortune
0:22:18in all aspects of life.
0:22:19But even in sports, they end up getting better
0:22:22scouting reports than homely players.
0:22:25- It's a cross I haven't been forced to bear.
0:22:27(laughing)
0:22:29- There's a site called Jeopardy Hotties, which cracks me up.
0:22:32But I wanna tell you what's funny about it is,
0:22:34it is, I went to this site and I was like,
0:22:38all right, I'm not on it, so screw you.
0:22:39Actually, there's a link to my Boing Boing article,
0:22:41which is funny, there's no picture of me,
0:22:43there's a link to my Boing Boing article.
0:22:44But I looked through it and I gotta say,
0:22:46one of the nice things about it,
0:22:46it was non-heteronormative and it was non-gender-normative.
0:22:51So the people that, the person who had posted these pictures
0:22:53for years now, it goes back for years,
0:22:56It is not only a certain aspect of society,
0:23:01the attractive blonde women.
0:23:04It's all kinds of people.
0:23:06And I agree, the men, the women,
0:23:07the people that are clearly of different orientations
0:23:10and so forth, it's awesome actually as a celebration
0:23:13of beauty across a lot of different norms.
0:23:17But I'm not in it, god damn it.
0:23:19So it's obviously a terrible sight.
0:23:21- I'll put you on a list of the talk show hotties.
0:23:24So, you know, talking about Markov
0:23:28and all these statistics and whatever,
0:23:30I know you had some Bitcoin questions.
0:23:32When I was on last, we were talking about,
0:23:34we hinted around it.
0:23:35- Yeah, let me do the first sponsor read
0:23:36and then we'll dig into it,
0:23:38because that's really why I have you here.
0:23:39I feel like it's, the whole Bitcoin thing
0:23:41has reached the breaking point, and I need--
0:23:43- This is all buildup.
0:23:44We have to establish credibility in talking about numbers.
0:23:46- Yeah.
0:23:47Yeah, it is kind of related.
0:23:49It's an awful lot of math.
0:23:50- There's a lot of, there's gambling.
0:23:53Our first sponsor is our good friends at Igloo.
0:23:56Igloo is an intranet you'll actually like.
0:24:00I love that slogan.
0:24:02It's built with easy to use apps
0:24:03that help you work with your teams.
0:24:05Shared calendars, private Twitter-like micro blogs,
0:24:10file sharing, and more.
0:24:13It's all on our website.
0:24:14You can go check it out.
0:24:15But what they want me to talk to you about is SharePoint.
0:24:19So Igloo partnered with Osterman Research
0:24:23to study the challenges businesses face when implementing SharePoint. SharePoint is the
0:24:27Microsoft internet product that dates to like 1983 or something. They built a whole page
0:24:35about it and you can go see it. Go to this site igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow and they'll
0:24:42know you came from the show and then they have the white paper linked to there and the
0:24:45research. But there's five main points that they got from their research. Number one,
0:24:50doesn't work well on mobile. Igloo has responsive web pages for all the aspects
0:24:56of Igloo. So everything looks great on any kind of mobile device. Any kind of
0:25:00cell phone with a WebKit browser is going to work great with Igloo.
0:25:06Second thing, SharePoint is too expensive. Third, it requires too many people.
0:25:14You've got to license it for a lot of people just to get started using it. And
0:25:18And then the last point is that it ends up no one actually uses it.
0:25:23It gets put into place from top down orders from IT department.
0:25:29And then it's such a pain in the ass to use.
0:25:31What happens is the teams end up using other products anyway or going around the system to share just to get stuff done because nobody actually uses it.
0:25:40Igloo is a thing that your team will actually use.
0:25:45They show you, just go to their website, they'll show you exactly how they do these things
0:25:49better with actual case studies from actual igloo customers and reports from analysts
0:25:55that prove it.
0:25:57They just won a product leadership award from Frost and Sullivan and IDC picked igloo to
0:26:03power their own customer community.
0:26:05So go check them out.
0:26:06And here's the last thing you need to know.
0:26:08It's free to use with up to 10 people and very affordable after that.
0:26:14So you can get started.
0:26:15Try it out with up to 10 people.
0:26:17If you only have fewer than 10 people, you can just keep using it for free.
0:26:21It's amazing.
0:26:22So go to igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow and check them out.
0:26:28OK.
0:26:29Bitcoin.
0:26:30Bitcoin.
0:26:31So I've been putting it off.
0:26:33I'm vaguely familiar with it.
0:26:34But what I need you to do, I really do, I need you to explain this to me like I'm a
0:26:39dummy because I kind of am.
0:26:42And I was good at math.
0:26:43I really, you know, I mean I think I'm more mathematically, I kind of, kind of get the
0:26:48basics of the math, but I don't know.
0:26:52I feel like, and it's clearly, I mean it's, maybe even with the criminal stuff going on
0:27:00at the Mt. Gox and the other place now, it would still be in the news more and more.
0:27:07You know, it seems like it's a rising tide, regardless of those things.
0:27:15But then, you know, let's talk about that too.
0:27:16So let's start from the top.
0:27:18Okay, I think there's three things.
0:27:20I think I can break it down to three things that you have to understand, all of which
0:27:24are relatively easy to understand, I think.
0:27:27Okay, so Bitcoin has like, I guess it's, there's, let's see, three different aspects.
0:27:33One is that the Bitcoins themselves are just a bundle of cryptographic information of which
0:27:38the person who possesses it ostensibly has a secret that only they know about whatever
0:27:44quantity of Bitcoins are in a particular wallet, particular address as it's called.
0:27:49The second is that you only transfer Bitcoins to other people.
0:27:52You don't receive them, you only send them.
0:27:56And that is again a cryptographically signed transaction and that becomes permanent in
0:28:01a way that I can talk about.
0:28:02Wait, but so you have a bitcoin and you want to give it to me, so I never receive it?
0:28:07You, not technically. What's interesting is transactions are all one way. A transaction
0:28:13sends money from one address to another, and the bitcoin addresses and wallets are sort of
0:28:17an interchangeable term. It's like the address is just like the destination and it contains some
0:28:22of bitcoins from, you know, one Satoshi, which is the tiniest current unit up to whatever
0:28:27quantity you have. So I've got an address and you send me money and I send you money, but I don't
0:28:35receive money per se, but I can explain that. So there's the Bitcoin address, there's a transaction,
0:28:41and then there's this issue of how transactions become permanent, which is Bitcoin mining.
0:28:47Those are sort of the three pieces. And I think each of them, like when you lump it all together,
0:28:52It's like, what the hell? So, fundamentally, what Bitcoin is about is decentralized trust.
0:28:59So, no two parties in a Bitcoin transaction or in any aspect of the Bitcoin ecosystem
0:29:04need to have any implicit trust in each other. Like, the system itself handles trust by using
0:29:10public key cryptography, which essentially assures that once you create a—so, you create a public
0:29:17key pair. And a public key pair uses one of multiple different formulas, but let's say it
0:29:21It uses, you know, Whitfield Diffie is one of the people, is the Diffie-Hellman key system that works.
0:29:28And what you do when you create a public private key pair is you're using very, very large prime numbers and you wind up with two pieces at the end.
0:29:35So I don't have to, I mean, you can look up the details in Wikipedia, but you wind up with two pieces and one piece is a private key that you possess and you need to keep it absolutely secret and no one else may ever have access to it.
0:29:46You don't want to store it anywhere anyone has access because this private key proves your identity the possession sort of the possession
0:29:53Part of it like you being able to deploy the key gives you all the power over any
0:29:58Transactions that involve that particular public key public private key pair
0:30:02If public in other words if you if you got your hands on my private
0:30:07key
0:30:09You could send my bitcoins to somebody else
0:30:13- Exactly, and this is true,
0:30:14like public key cryptography is used all over the place.
0:30:17It's the basis of SSL TLS used for web encryption.
0:30:21It's used in SSH transactions.
0:30:23- In the same way, so for example too,
0:30:25if you had my private keys for SSH,
0:30:28you could log into Daring Fireball over SSH.
0:30:33- Exactly.
0:30:34- And get on the command line on daringfireball.net
0:30:37if you had my private keys.
0:30:39- Yeah, and the notion with public key cryptography
0:30:41is that the public part of this,
0:30:43You can freely distribute it,
0:30:45and there's not enough computation power in the world
0:30:49over, I forget how many years,
0:30:51if it's the heat death of the universe still or not,
0:30:54that would allow you to use any known technique
0:30:58to reverse engineer and brute force attack
0:31:00and recover the private key.
0:31:01So that's why it's so resistant.
0:31:03It's an asymmetrical key system.
0:31:05And so the public key gets used broadly,
0:31:08like in any system, this is how you can sign something
0:31:13So you take your data and you sign it with the public key
0:31:16and the result is a cryptographic hash
0:31:19that only the recipient with the private key,
0:31:22only the owner of the private key can decrypt that.
0:31:25So it's a one-way method for someone
0:31:27to send you something securely that only you
0:31:30or the possessor of that private key can read.
0:31:33So that's how it gets used.
0:31:34A lot of the time, that's true with web pages,
0:31:36when you do a web transaction, the first thing that happens
0:31:39is this whole digital certificate thing
0:31:40of which we've now found there have been some things
0:31:42been some flaws recently, last few days, not just go to fail, but there's a new one that
0:31:47dates back many years and is also suspicious and how it hasn't been discovered.
0:31:51Let's save that. Let's just remember, keep that in mind. Let's come back to that after.
0:31:55We'll come back to that. But the idea is that you have information you want to pass. So
0:32:00in general, the way cryptography is used is to secure a secret. And in Bitcoin, it's not
0:32:05securing a secret, it's proving ownership and identity. So in the Bitcoin system, there
0:32:12is no inherent value. What's the value is that a set of numbers representing some quantity
0:32:18of bitcoins can only provably belong to a person who owns the private key that corresponds
0:32:25to that address that contains that number of bitcoins. So nobody else, so no one else
0:32:30can do anything with those coins. They cannot prove ownership because they cannot, because
0:32:35Because the private key can be used to sign transactions that, by using the publicly available
0:32:42key, can be proven to only have been signed by someone who possesses the private key.
0:32:46So there's an absolute way to prove that you own a thing because you have the private
0:32:50key.
0:32:51And there's, I don't think any other, I mean there's some other cryptographic systems,
0:32:54I should say, that have things that are parallel, but there's no method in the real world that
0:32:58corresponds to that.
0:32:59There's no physical method, you know, biometric identification is one of the things, but there
0:33:04And you can do the Kurt Vonnegut method and cutting off and pickling people's thumbs and so forth.
0:33:09You know, it was joked about with the iPhone 5S.
0:33:12So Bitcoin, the idea is that there is no way to, because of the process by which they're made,
0:33:18there's no way to forge a Bitcoin.
0:33:21You can't counterfeit it and you can't fraudulently transfer it from one party to another without the access to that first party's private key.
0:33:32So that fixes a bunch of problems with--
0:33:34- So if I had a copy of a Bitcoin that belonged to you,
0:33:38now I can copy the Bitcoin and I can have it on my computer.
0:33:43I can't do anything with it 'cause I don't have
0:33:45your private key.
0:33:47- That's right. - All right.
0:33:48- I mean, what's weird is Bitcoins are not stored anywhere
0:33:51at some level, like the weird thing is,
0:33:52so let's get to the transaction part,
0:33:54'cause this explains the next thing.
0:33:55So Bitcoin at some level is, it's a series of transactions.
0:34:00It's not actually, like, let's look at it this way.
0:34:04The current banking system is ridiculous, of course.
0:34:06But so, you know, I do things as weird as like,
0:34:08when I was sharing office space with Jeff Carlson,
0:34:10he would send me a rent check,
0:34:12'cause I paid the rent for the whole office,
0:34:14and he would go to our credit union,
0:34:16he would fill out a thing, it would make a check
0:34:18and ship it from like the Midwest in an envelope.
0:34:21It would wind up at the office, I would take it,
0:34:23I would scan that check in a scanner,
0:34:25electronically deposit and destroy the check.
0:34:27And that's our banking system, right?
0:34:29system, right? So like—
0:34:30That's the US, though. The US—I mean, the US is—I mean, people are—our listeners
0:34:35in Europe are like—
0:34:36Like, what?
0:34:37Yeah, they can't believe it. I don't think most people in Europe—most people our age
0:34:41in Europe have never even, like, sent a check.
0:34:43Yes, right. And so, yeah, exactly. Like, checks—and this is true in America, checks have now—the
0:34:48volume of checks has gone way, way down because—for a whole bunch of reasons, including electronic—a
0:34:54deposit being encouraged for employers.
0:34:57But so let's do wire transfers easier case.
0:35:00So because my credit union has added free wire
0:35:03transfers a couple of years ago from person to person stuff.
0:35:06So when I do a wire transfer, it's just a ledger transaction
0:35:09is my bank has a record that it owns a certain amount of money.
0:35:14And it transfers that to another bank.
0:35:16And that bank agrees that yes, and that value is transferred.
0:35:19I know I forget.
0:35:20I think the federal reserve is involved.
0:35:23I forget.
0:35:23There's like some weird thing.
0:35:24but like they're just transferring money,
0:35:26numbers around, right?
0:35:27But there's no security in that process
0:35:28and it's abused all the time.
0:35:30You hear all these stories about money being transferred out,
0:35:32people's bank accounts, especially companies being hacked
0:35:35and money being transferred and Western Union things
0:35:37and checks being cut.
0:35:38The system isn't secure, but in essence,
0:35:40it is just that is a decrement occurs in one bank's ledger
0:35:44and an increment occurs in another
0:35:46and that's the transaction.
0:35:47Bitcoin doesn't work that way.
0:35:49Bitcoin has this thing called the public blockchain
0:35:52And this is distributed worldwide,
0:35:54and it's gigabytes in size now.
0:35:56And it is a record of every single transaction
0:35:58that has occurred since Bitcoin went live
0:36:01like over five years ago now.
0:36:04And the transaction ledger,
0:36:05if you wanna figure out who owns a Bitcoin,
0:36:07you can trace back the address to its origin.
0:36:10And the current owner is the person
0:36:12who has most recently signed it with their private key.
0:36:15That they have, or I should say the person
0:36:16who has most recently received it
0:36:18by virtue of the coin being signed over
0:36:22with the previous owner's private key.
0:36:25So, and so I have an address.
0:36:28My address is, you know, 1234-ABCDEF, right?
0:36:32And you can transfer money to me at that address
0:36:36by signing a set of Bitcoins with your private key
0:36:40that corresponds to those Bitcoins.
0:36:42That transaction occurs, it's locked into the blockchain,
0:36:45and now I own those.
0:36:46there's no transfer from two points.
0:36:49It's recognized globally by analyzing the chain
0:36:52that I now possess those and have the authority
0:36:54to spend them in some way.
0:36:55And that's wild, that's very, very different
0:36:57than any monetary system or transaction-based system
0:37:00has worked before.
0:37:00- Right, it's definitely novel.
0:37:02- Yeah, it's almost like a central ledger,
0:37:04except that it's not recording deficits and additions,
0:37:06it's only recording transfers,
0:37:08and that's what's baffling.
0:37:09So you have to have the entire sequence of transfers,
0:37:11and the most recent transfer wins, essentially.
0:37:14That's what proves ownership.
0:37:15So this is where you get into the third part,
0:37:17which is like, how are transfers made permanent?
0:37:20How do they become a permanent record?
0:37:22And that's where you get into Bitcoin mining,
0:37:23which defeats some people because it seems,
0:37:25so it's so weird at some level.
0:37:29And mining is the process of finding a,
0:37:32so miners run now extremely specialized hardware
0:37:36that all they do is they generate tons
0:37:37of SHA-1 cryptographic hashes based on specific numbers.
0:37:42So the system works like this.
0:37:45Let's see if I can do this part.
0:37:48People are constantly engaged in Bitcoin transactions
0:37:51and they generate these transactions.
0:37:53They say, John, I'm gonna send you one Bitcoin.
0:37:55So I use my software.
0:37:57It signs over one Bitcoin to your public address,
0:38:00sign it with my private key.
0:38:02That transaction is then broadcast
0:38:04on the global set of peer-to-peer nodes
0:38:06that are used by Bitcoin miners
0:38:08and other people involved in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
0:38:10miners are constantly grabbing a set of transactions
0:38:14and they get a small fee, small to large fee,
0:38:16sometimes no fee, for each transaction that they grab.
0:38:19So they'll take, let's say, I forgot the number,
0:38:20I think it's like 1,000 transactions.
0:38:22They'll take those and they combine that
0:38:25with some other information that's unique
0:38:28and something that's randomly generated
0:38:29and they start churning away on creating SHA-1 hashes.
0:38:33So a SHA-1 hash is a cryptographic hash
0:38:36is where you take an input, it runs through this algorithm
0:38:40that performs a number of transformations on it,
0:38:42and the number that comes out the end is predictable.
0:38:45It's always the same based on the same input,
0:38:47but any change to the input, no matter how slight,
0:38:50results in a non-deterministically highly variant output.
0:38:55So if I put in John Gruber into SHA-1, I get one thing.
0:39:00If I put in John Graber, the result is
0:39:02you cannot predict what it will be.
0:39:04It'll be so vastly different,
0:39:06and there is no known way to easily predict
0:39:08how to reproduce the same hash from different inputs.
0:39:12So I can't just create a slightly different record,
0:39:14create the same hash.
0:39:16So the act of hashing proves that I did it
0:39:19because you can take the same inputs,
0:39:21run it through the same algorithm
0:39:22and produce the same result.
0:39:24So, here's what mining is.
0:39:27Mining is you're trying to find a certain hash,
0:39:31but you don't know how to create a hash
0:39:32that matches that pattern.
0:39:33You just have to create billions upon billions of them.
0:39:36In Bitcoin, you're looking for a hash
0:39:38that has a certain number of starting zeros.
0:39:41And the more computation power that enters
0:39:44into the Bitcoin ecosystem,
0:39:46'cause it's now a ridiculous amount,
0:39:48the harder the level of finding that number is,
0:39:51they keep increasing the difficulty.
0:39:52It's a dynamic thing that's reset every two weeks
0:39:54by the system.
0:39:55And you have to find like a hash that's less than,
0:39:59the number's incredibly long, it's however many bits long,
0:40:02and you have to find a hash that has a certain number
0:40:05of leading zeros.
0:40:06and you could churn for, you know,
0:40:08you could churn through a trillion transactions
0:40:10and you might not find one that meets those parameters.
0:40:13- Right.
0:40:14- Does that make sense?
0:40:15- I think so.
0:40:15I've heard it described, not mathematically similar,
0:40:20but in layman's terms, similar to looking for prime numbers.
0:40:24- It's a needle in a haystack search.
0:40:26- But in the same way though,
0:40:27that like if you're looking for prime numbers,
0:40:29each one gets harder and harder to find because it's--
0:40:33- Yeah, except, well, this is random is the problem.
0:40:35Like prime numbers, you know what you're looking for,
0:40:38like, and you don't, there's no, I think at this point,
0:40:40they don't know where the next prime number is, right?
0:40:42There's no prime number space.
0:40:44In this case, there's a space of all possible hashes,
0:40:47and because you don't know which inputs will,
0:40:50there's two parameters.
0:40:51One is you don't know which inputs produce which hash.
0:40:53So you don't know how to predict getting one
0:40:55with a bunch of zeros.
0:40:56And the other is that you're taking a whole bunch
0:40:59of material as a miner and sticking it together,
0:41:02and it has to be, that material isn't set by you.
0:41:05you can't define the starting point of the transactions
0:41:07that you're mining.
0:41:08So, but it involves a ridiculous amount
0:41:11of computational power.
0:41:13The last time I checked it was, I think it was 200 times
0:41:17the computation power of the top 500 supercomputers
0:41:20in the world combined.
0:41:21- To find-- - Are used for Bitcoin.
0:41:22To find, to mine Bitcoins worldwide.
0:41:24- And at this point, I've read that it's more expensive
0:41:34to power the computer that's doing it.
0:41:38Like you said, most of the people doing it now
0:41:40have specialized hardware.
0:41:41But like if I just put software on my,
0:41:43like a brand new Mac,
0:41:46and just had it start mining for Bitcoins,
0:41:48my expectation is that I would spend more on electricity
0:41:52running the computer than the value of the Bitcoin
0:41:54it might eventually find.
0:41:55- That's right.
0:41:57I don't know what it is exactly at this moment,
0:41:58'cause the price of Bitcoins has fallen.
0:42:00But this thing about difficulty,
0:42:02So Bitcoin started on PCs, right?
0:42:04And then people got more powerful PCs
0:42:06and stuck more, the mining, I'm sorry,
0:42:08and stuck more processors in.
0:42:09Then they started using graphical processing units,
0:42:13of course, 'cause GPUs are very efficient
0:42:14at certain kinds of calculations.
0:42:16Then they started using what these things call
0:42:18programmable gate arrays, I think,
0:42:20I've forgotten the name for them.
0:42:21There's a specialized term that are like
0:42:23a programmable silicon chip that you could program
0:42:26and get even more speed.
0:42:27Then they went to ASICs, you know,
0:42:29which are custom circuitry designed specifically
0:42:33to do SHA-1 calculations.
0:42:35Then the ASICs went from 110 nanometer process
0:42:38to I think they're down to 29 or something,
0:42:4025 nanometer process now,
0:42:42whatever the smallest thing is at that level.
0:42:44It speeds up and speeds up the efficiency ratio
0:42:47of power to calculations.
0:42:49Not only can you calculate faster,
0:42:50but the power per calculation gets lower.
0:42:53You cannot compete on a PC
0:42:55or even a field programmable gate array,
0:42:57I think it's called.
0:42:58can't, against custom, like 29 nanometer ASICs.
0:43:02Right. In other words, though, that in just four years, we've gone through several generations
0:43:09of computer engineering, hardware computer engineering, devoted specifically to Bitcoin
0:43:17mining.
0:43:18Yeah, and it's non-generalizable too.
0:43:21Optimizing the hardware for this one specific purpose.
0:43:24Oh, yeah. So, here, I just found the number. Here's the number. So, at this exact second,
0:43:28There are 355,000 petaflops, this trillion,
0:43:33no I'm sorry, that's quadrillion operations per second.
0:43:38355 quintillion floating point operations per second
0:43:42are being used globally to mine bitcoins.
0:43:46And the top supercomputer in the world has,
0:43:50God, what is it?
0:43:51It has like under 100 teraflops.
0:43:53So this is, if you add them all together,
0:43:56I think you get 500 or, no I'm sorry,
0:43:58you get like a thousand teraflops.
0:44:00So this is hundreds of times more than the top 500
0:44:03supercomputers in the world combined being used
0:44:06for this specialized purpose consuming God knows
0:44:09how many gigawatts of energy just to find this needle
0:44:13in the haystack that lets them emit a kind.
0:44:15So when a miner mints a coin, when they find this number,
0:44:18they broadcast their solution, their proof of work
0:44:21worldwide across the peer-to-peer network.
0:44:23It happens on average in less than 10 minutes,
0:44:25every 10 minutes.
0:44:26Every 10 minutes a new Bitcoin is found.
0:44:28Yeah, because on average somebody finds it.
0:44:30In fact, there are these consortia,
0:44:32because it was too hard for any individual to bear this.
0:44:35So there are groups of miners worldwide that band together,
0:44:38no one of which has more than, I think,
0:44:40still 20 or 30% as a consortium of all worldwide capacity,
0:44:44which is a whole other, there's another issue there.
0:44:46And so some miner in this consortium goes,
0:44:49"Yeah, I found it, woo!"
0:44:50And they broadcast it and get it out there.
0:44:52They need to get it out there as fast as possible,
0:44:54'cause someone else in the next microsecond
0:44:56might find a different needle in the haystack.
0:44:58The moment that's broadcast, they broadcast a block,
0:45:02and the block is a brick that's placed on top of the wall,
0:45:05and you're mortaring it in.
0:45:06And the brick includes a reward to you as a miner,
0:45:09which is 25 Bitcoins, and that's still,
0:45:11at current exchange rates, is not horrible.
0:45:14Right now, what's the exchange?
0:45:15It's like 600 bucks, now where is that?
0:45:18- So you get 25 of them when you find one of these blocks?
0:45:20- 25, yeah, and every four years, on average,
0:45:24that reward halved.
0:45:26So it was 50 Bitcoins for the first four years or so,
0:45:28now it's 25, it'll be 12 and a half in a few years.
0:45:31And this is part of the decreasing money supply.
0:45:34There's a finite number of Bitcoins that will ever be mined
0:45:36in the current protocol system, about 21 million.
0:45:39So you're a miner, you go, "Woo, I found one!"
0:45:43But that's still, you don't win.
0:45:44You don't win when you find a Bitcoin, it's great.
0:45:46But then you have to broadcast this out,
0:45:48your block that has all the transactions
0:45:51that are in your block,
0:45:53and some other numbers and information,
0:45:55and it has to be accepted by nodes all over the world
0:45:59who then immediately begin calculating the next block,
0:46:02and each block is cryptographically tied
0:46:05to the one before it.
0:46:06This is the wonderful secret sauce of Bitcoin.
0:46:09This is actually almost more important
0:46:11than the public key cryptography
0:46:13that lets you protect each Bitcoin quantity's identity
0:46:16and ownership.
0:46:18The blockchain is, it builds upon each transaction,
0:46:22each block. So, if you, so what can happen, and this happens frequently, is a miner in,
0:46:30you know, Africa finds a Bitcoin, they transmit their block out, and it's sent out worldwide
0:46:35simultaneously within some short period of time. Another miner has also found, based
0:46:39on the same previous block, they have found a new magic number, right? And they broadcast
0:46:46theirs. So now you have two different chains, which have, each have different ending blocks,
0:46:51the rest of the same, going back to 2009 and Mr. Satoshi's initial deployment.
0:46:56But this, they have variants.
0:46:58And what can happen though is different nodes on the Bitcoin network, because they're decentralized,
0:47:02can accept different chains.
0:47:05So you can have two different chains that are growing parallel, but one of them, but
0:47:09they don't have the same information for the last block.
0:47:11And this can go on sometimes for one or two blocks.
0:47:14And at a certain point, one of them has provably shown to do more work.
0:47:18it's clear that it happened faster and more work was consumed. And then there'll be this
0:47:23reconciliation, which I believe is automatic, in which all the nodes in the world accept the
0:47:29longer chain, that is the chain that has more blocks on it faster. When that happens, all the
0:47:34variant chains, which may have one or two blocks that are not the same as the one that's been
0:47:40accepted, those are discarded. All the transactions that were exclusively in those blocks and did not
0:47:46get minted into these new blocks have to be committed again into new blocks. And you see
0:47:52why this gets complicated.
0:47:53Jared: So, somebody who found one of those blocks ends up with nothing.
0:47:57Pete: Exactly, right. It resets.
0:47:58Jared; Because theirs was rejected because it was a smaller chain.
0:48:01Pete; Precisely. And this is a process that's, actually, and this is part of the elegance of it,
0:48:06is, you know, it's a little crazy at one level, but it is also a really beautiful idea that
0:48:12no one has to agree on anything. You don't have to go into a reconciliation, be which block,
0:48:17whatever. It's like, no, the longer block wins. And I think, yeah, I think whatever anybody would
0:48:21think about Bitcoin, whether you think it's really super, it's going to revolutionize all of digital
0:48:26commerce, and maybe real world commerce, and, and that it's, you know, maybe you think it's a great,
0:48:31even with the recent stuff, it's a great place to invest your money or any, or, or you think the
0:48:36the whole thing is a goddamn ridiculous scam. I think everybody would agree that mathematically
0:48:43it's beautiful. It's a beautiful system.
0:48:45Pete: It's gorgeously designed. If you disregard any of the currency or speculation part of it,
0:48:51you can just admire it. And the paper that, you know, so-called Satoshi is maybe a composite
0:48:55of multiple people but is still preserved his or her or their anonymity, that paper is actually
0:49:03incredibly legible. I've read it and I am not a cryptographer and my math background
0:49:09is not deep enough to really, I don't know, maybe if I really studied it I could get it,
0:49:13but it's actually a model of clarity about what's going, about what the intent is and
0:49:17how it works and all of the attributes in that paper have persisted. And the idea is,
0:49:23so now you understand Bitcoin now. This is Bitcoin, you have a quantity of currency that's
0:49:29protected in a public key, which we all understand now, but public-private keys work, and so
0:49:33only the owner of the private key can do it.
0:49:35A transaction transfers value from one party to another.
0:49:40Miners make their money by doing these fiendishly large number of calculations, but they have
0:49:46to be on the winning side if multiple blocks are being minted at once of the longest chain
0:49:51for it to be perfect.
0:49:52So here's the other part that's beautiful, and again, doesn't really relate to whether
0:49:55it's valid as a currency or anything else.
0:49:58But Bitcoin is a fantastic transaction system if you don't care about the value at all,
0:50:04there's no contradicting it.
0:50:05It is a beautiful transaction system.
0:50:07So here's the deal, the amount of computation I've described is ridiculous, right?
0:50:12After a few blocks go by, you would need more computational power than exists in the Bitcoin
0:50:18network to go back a few blocks and create a new chain.
0:50:21So if the longer chain always wins, if any entity like a consortium controlled more than
0:50:2750 percent, and some people say the threshold is lower, but let's say just at the, not
0:50:32the practical level, but the theory is if you own under control more than 50 percent
0:50:38of the Bitcoin mining capacity worldwide, you will always win.
0:50:42You will always have the longest chain because you can always calculate faster.
0:50:46You can outpace everyone else put together.
0:50:49So this would let you do things like distort the system and double spend and mess up transactions.
0:50:53You could do all kinds of bad things.
0:50:55The consortia don't like this.
0:50:56And so when any one consortium has reached a point where they're worried about having
0:51:03too much capacity, they voluntarily split off and break down or halt things or do all
0:51:06sorts of stuff because it's not in the benefit of the system's integrity, even for them
0:51:12to wield that much control.
0:51:13They think it would destabilize the validity of the system.
0:51:17it also means that, let's say a government entity, let's say Iraq says, "We hate Bitcoin,"
0:51:21or Russia, Russia's probably a better example. Let's say Russia says, "Bitcoin is terrible,
0:51:25let's destroy Bitcoin," and you know, Putin, maybe he's got, whatever. They would have to spend
0:51:29an enormous amount of money, a ridiculous amount of money, to build up the capacity just to match
0:51:34the current system. Then they would have to be out there minting like crazy and, you know,
0:51:40and be able to overtake everyone else in the world and continue that for a period of time. And also,
0:51:46Also, people would notice this isn't an anonymous process.
0:51:49They know where the traffic's coming from.
0:51:50They know what the addresses are.
0:51:52So there's really, it's not that there's no way for someone to subvert the system by
0:51:56gaining control of more than 50% or even a lower threshold of mining capacity.
0:52:00More that the bar is so high and it's so expensive now, it's just very, very unlikely.
0:52:06Um, one, I want to keep going, but here's one last question I have about this before
0:52:14we do the next sponsor break which is that my understanding I mean I think
0:52:18this is I think it's common knowledge is that the one of the other things about
0:52:23the Bitcoin system from the gecko is that there's an upper bound on the
0:52:27eventual total global bitcoins that will exist that at a certain point that's it
0:52:32the last Bitcoin block will be mined is that right yeah this is um this is the
0:52:39the I think it's 21 it's approximately 21 million it's just below 21 million
0:52:44And this is, you know, Bitcoin is clearly influenced by Ludwig von Mises, right?
0:52:49He was the Austrian economist that affects a lot of people with specific Austrian school of economic views.
0:52:55And Bitcoin at one level is a test of economic theory by not allowing, there's no inflation in Bitcoin per se, and you can't print new money.
0:53:06The money gets released at regular intervals by the miners.
0:53:10And, oh, I should also point out,
0:53:13there's this thing I was mentioning that as,
0:53:15as more computational capacity enters the system,
0:53:19the difficulty factor is adjusted
0:53:21because it's the system rebalances
0:53:23to try to take about 10 minutes
0:53:24between each block being minted.
0:53:27And if, because computational capacity
0:53:30has been increasing so fast,
0:53:31it's more like seven or eight minutes.
0:53:33But if, for instance, like everybody involved
0:53:37in Bitcoin mining said, ah, this is stupid.
0:53:3999% of the people shut their equipment off, the difficulty factor then reduces. So everyone
0:53:45could be using CPUs again or whatever. So you're not dependent on ever increasing computation.
0:53:49Pete: We could just use papers and pencils.
0:53:51[Laughter]
0:53:52Pete: Exactly. You could sit there and be calculating a SHA-1 thing by hand. So, I mentioned
0:53:56that in part because the coin creation isn't a factor of computation. The computation is
0:54:02intended to keep production at a steady pace instead of having an inflationary thing where
0:54:08someone could suddenly be creating coins every five seconds and exhaust the system.
0:54:12Jared Is there a layman's explanation for how there
0:54:16can be an upper limit? Like how there can be a last Bitcoin mined?
0:54:19Ben Yeah, the algorithm actually, or I should
0:54:23say, see there's the original paper that Satoshi wrote. There's an implementation that he or
0:54:29they created in the first couple of years. I, my understanding is very deeply involved before he
0:54:34And then there's the Bitcoin Foundation,
0:54:36other parties that engage in protocol improvements
0:54:40and software updates.
0:54:42So I forget what it is.
0:54:44If it's 80% of the nodes in the Bitcoin network,
0:54:46or is it 50, not 50, I think it's 80,
0:54:48have to agree to a software upgrade
0:54:50and then they roll it out and deprecate the previous version.
0:54:53So there have been changes and improvements over time.
0:54:55So right now, the way the protocol works
0:54:58is that mining delivers 25 Bitcoins every,
0:55:02every, you know, say 10 minutes on average or less.
0:55:06And the protocol states that on a certain point
0:55:08after a certain number of coins are generated,
0:55:11and you can see a table,
0:55:12you can go to like a Wikipedia as a table of it,
0:55:14and we'll show you what the point is
0:55:15and actually estimate the date for when this happens.
0:55:18Suddenly, instead of 25, 12 and a half,
0:55:20and then in the equivalent of roughly four years
0:55:23or a certain number of blocks, it's measured in blocks,
0:55:25go by, it'll be 6.25, and then it will be 3.125,
0:55:31And dividing down, yeah, exactly, it's an infinite thing.
0:55:34And so you'll get closer and closer to 21 million
0:55:36and never quite achieve it.
0:55:37But most coins will be mined within, I think,
0:55:40was it 12 or 16 years, almost all the coins will be mined.
0:55:43And the question then is-- - Got it.
0:55:44So in other words, it's sort of like a calculus thing
0:55:46where, you know, there may never exactly be a last Bitcoin,
0:55:49but eventually it'll approach this limit of 21 million
0:55:54or something, and it'll get ever and ever closer
0:55:56and there'll be ever so fractionally less value
0:56:00in getting a new Bitcoin.
0:56:03- And here's the last thing before you this much, Biggs.
0:56:05So here's the thing, what the system,
0:56:07people involved in the system suspect will happen
0:56:09is every transaction can have a mining fee attached.
0:56:13And I think some must have a mining fee attached
0:56:15and others can be done for free.
0:56:17However, miners preferentially take transactions
0:56:20that have fees attached.
0:56:21They're not required to take empty transactions
0:56:24and typically those get queued and they wait longer
0:56:26before they're permanently committed.
0:56:28So this is an interesting bit of microeconomics,
0:56:31I don't know if it's microeconomics,
0:56:31but it's just a bit of like a microscale thing
0:56:33that goes on is, I'm sending you money, John,
0:56:35but I don't wanna pay a mining fee,
0:56:37so I mark zero on that.
0:56:39It might take like a couple hours for it to get baked in,
0:56:42or maybe even longer sometimes,
0:56:43and until it's baked in,
0:56:45and then more blocks are added after it,
0:56:46it's not really permanent.
0:56:48So that idea of instantaneous transfer is true,
0:56:51except that until the transaction is permanently
0:56:55baked into a block,
0:56:56and at least a few blocks have been added after it
0:56:59to ensure that the chain is the correct chain,
0:57:01we can't really count that it's true.
0:57:03There are some ways around it
0:57:04and some predictability for it,
0:57:06but what the idea is that over time
0:57:07those mining fees will increase
0:57:09so that as the reward decreases
0:57:11people will have to pay more per transaction fee,
0:57:15which right now is kind of the argument
0:57:16that Bitcoin has no transaction fees.
0:57:18It does not have required ones in most cases,
0:57:21but transaction fees will be likely much smaller
0:57:25compared to say credit card transaction fees
0:57:26or wire transfers or other,
0:57:28especially international money transfer.
0:57:30But there will be an increasing number of transaction fees
0:57:32that are given to miners to keep them
0:57:34actually engaged in the system and making new blocks.
0:57:37Even when the reward is 0.00001 Bitcoin,
0:57:40you need miners to make blocks.
0:57:42- It's like a working example of free market economics.
0:57:47- Yeah, yeah, because if you can't get your transaction
0:57:51put into a block, you have to raise the fee.
0:57:53mandatory fees. You can just put it out there and if somebody wants to, they can verify it and put
0:57:58it in the chain for free or, you know, with no fee. But if you want to motivate people to
0:58:03prioritize your transaction, you can offer them a fee. And if it's high enough, they'll choose
0:58:12to do it and then you'll get priority. So, it really will be some, there will be some mandatory
0:58:16fees very likely, but there'll be exceedingly tiny, the mandatory ones when those kick in.
0:58:20And this sort of pure free market economics at work, you could see how this draws
0:58:28libertarian minded people to the whole Bitcoin world.
0:58:33Yes.
0:58:34Right. Let me take a break. We'll come back. There's more I want to talk about Bitcoin.
0:58:38But I want to thank our second sponsor, and it's our good friends at Hover, H-O-V-E-R.
0:58:47Hover, quite simply, is the best way
0:58:49to buy and manage domain names.
0:58:51You have a great idea.
0:58:54You want to get a domain name for it.
0:58:56You want a catchy, memorable domain name.
0:58:59Hover gives you everything you need to get the job done.
0:59:01They'll let you search.
0:59:03They have a whole bunch of top level domains to choose from.
0:59:07It'll help you find the domain you're looking for,
0:59:09maybe give you suggestions on something close to it.
0:59:12Everybody knows when you search for domains,
0:59:14it's hard to find a good one.
0:59:16Hover makes it easy.
0:59:19All sorts of domain registrars, of course,
0:59:21have search like that.
0:59:23The difference between Hover and typical domain registrars,
0:59:26you just have to see it to believe it.
0:59:28Because everybody else, they're trying
0:59:30to make money every other way other than just by selling you
0:59:33the domain names.
0:59:34There's upsells on all sorts of scammy stuff, checkboxes
0:59:39you have to uncheck to get out of these add-ons and follow-ups,
0:59:44all sorts of nonsense.
0:59:45The worst sort of business, just,
0:59:48it's, a lot of them are just scams, honestly,
0:59:50and anybody who's ever used them will know it.
0:59:52Hover is just straightforward.
0:59:54Just go, I mean, just go check out their website
0:59:56and you will see right away that they just,
0:59:59it just doesn't even look like other domain registrars.
1:00:01No nonsense.
1:00:02They make money by charging you for domain names
1:00:06and that's it.
1:00:07They have great, great, great customer support,
1:00:11including something called Valet Transfer Service.
1:00:14So if you've already got a domain at another registrar
1:00:17and you're unsatisfied with that registrar,
1:00:20and there's a very good chance that you are,
1:00:22because most registrars stink,
1:00:24you can go to Hover, sign up,
1:00:27and their valet transfer service will help you,
1:00:31or just do the work for you.
1:00:32You just give them access to your other registrar
1:00:34and they'll take care of all the DNS stuff,
1:00:37all the stuff you need to do to move or transfer a domain
1:00:42from one registrar to another.
1:00:44It's a great service, and for most of us,
1:00:47it's because we're not experts.
1:00:50Even, I don't know, I have a bunch of domain names,
1:00:51but I almost never move them
1:00:53or change anything to do with them.
1:00:54So I'm not a DNS expert.
1:00:56The people at Hover are.
1:00:58This is what they do all day, every day.
1:01:01So you're in great hands.
1:01:03Everybody I know, and I know,
1:01:04I have a bunch of friends who've used this valet service.
1:01:06They swear by it.
1:01:07It sounds too good to be true,
1:01:09that you just sign up and let them do all the work for you.
1:01:12But that's actually how it works.
1:01:16Where do you go to find out more?
1:01:18Easy.
1:01:19Go to hover.com, H-O-V-E-R dot com slash talk show.
1:01:25And they'll know you came from the show.
1:01:27So happy to have them as a sponsor.
1:01:31Really, just go check them out and you'll be happy to.
1:01:37All right, back to Bitcoin.
1:01:38A couple of things I want to ask you about still.
1:01:44We should talk about why Matt Cox went dead too.
1:01:48Yeah, that's part of it.
1:01:50Tell me about, so you mentioned that there may not even be one individual name set.
1:02:01The credit for creating Bitcoin goes to, ostensibly, a Japanese mathematician named Satoshi Nakamoto.
1:02:13Mm-hmm.
1:02:14Nobody knows—and at the very least, it's a pseudonym, if it is one person.
1:02:21If it is the work of one person, Satoshi Nakamoto is apparently a pseudonym.
1:02:26Yeah, it's, I mean, that's the, well, it's weird because they're not anonymous, I guess it has to be a pseudonym, or they're not anonymous.
1:02:33No one has, no one has proved, proven who this person is, or if a single person did it. There's a suspicion, and you know, when you read stuff, you know often when it's the work of one person the way it's written.
1:02:46And, you know, I've read the paper, the paper reads like one person wrote it. So if it's a group, one person drafted it. It does not have the feel, it's got a very specific style.
1:02:55have a feeling of a committee.
1:02:56Pete: Yeah, I mean, there's not, and the statements aren't vague, they're very specific,
1:02:59there's a style to it, and this person posted, I mean, and someone has, I mean,
1:03:04this is why it's suspected to be just an individual, because this person was actively
1:03:07participating in the early Bitcoin discussions for years. And, you know, there's this typical thing,
1:03:12this is what happened with the guy who was arrested for Silk, what the heck is it called?
1:03:18Ted, off screen.
1:03:18Ted, off screen.
1:03:18The Silk Road.
1:03:19Pete.
1:03:19Silk Road, yeah. The guy was arrested in the Bay Area. He had posted something.
1:03:24Man, what a nut job that guy is.
1:03:25I know! But you know, and this is funny, this is like, this is apparently a very common forensics technique, and I heard about it.
1:03:32I was like, "Oh, this is so brilliant. Why, you know, I should have guessed, and I feel like an idiot."
1:03:36What they do is they look at the first time someone posts under an identity on some online thing, and then they trace back and see who, you know, it's like who followed them on Twitter, who referenced them, who linked to a website, who favored, like...
1:03:48So, they went back and they found the Silk Road guy because there were fingerprints all
1:03:51over him pointing to the entity that, you know, he eventually became. And so, that's
1:03:57how, really, a big part of how they found him was that. And you have to be very careful
1:04:01about that. So, anyway, no one's found that kind of thing with Nakamoto. Even though the
1:04:08guy posted, you know, we assume it's a guy, probably.
1:04:10So, in other words, you're saying like if somebody wanted to uncover the Macalope, go
1:04:14and actually the Macalope I think predates Twitter, but let's say or if somebody else
1:04:19created a Macalope like, you know, pseudonymous column, you know.
1:04:24Yeah, who's the first person who retweeted it? Who's the first person who linked to it?
1:04:28Did you go to Tumblr and give it love at Tumblr? Which is very clever. So no one has found
1:04:33those fingerprints and a lot of people have looked and some very clever journalists have
1:04:37looked. I forget, is it Wired? Someone did a piece where they looked through a lot of
1:04:40They talk to a ton of people and they're pretty sure it might be this one person, but it's just, there's not enough evidence to show that it's them.
1:04:49The reason people care who Satoshi Nakamoto is, is because Satoshi Nakamoto has like 5 million Bitcoins, I think. Something like that. Is that the amount?
1:04:57It's some huge, or no, I'm sorry, is it 5% of outstanding Bitcoins? It's a huge number because they were the only person mining initially.
1:05:04And so whoever that is has a ton of money.
1:05:09Like even with the current, you know, the drop to $500 a Bitcoin, this person conceivably has like, I don't know what it is, like a billion dollar, $800 million, some huge amount of money if they wanted to convert it slowly into cash.
1:05:20Now because Bitcoin, all the addresses are public, people can watch those early Bitcoins and see if they get transferred, you know, to exchanges or cashed out or used for things.
1:05:31things and apparently they're all very static. So that's another aspect of
1:05:35Bitcoin is that all the transactions are done in public. The identities are not
1:05:39tied to the bitcoins, a person's identity isn't, but the bitcoins you can see them
1:05:44move through time and that's an aspect people both like and hate about it.
1:05:49So you can tell though, somebody who owned, like you said, maybe it's not five million,
1:05:54maybe it's five million is probably too big a number if there's only 21 million total.
1:05:57- I forget what it is, it's a big percentage though.
1:06:00- Right.
1:06:01Let's just call it a million.
1:06:04- Yeah, it's a lot of money.
1:06:05- Somebody could watch those million,
1:06:07look at the early Bitcoins
1:06:08and if a bunch of them start moving,
1:06:10you could safely assume that it's the ones
1:06:14that were owned by Nakamoto,
1:06:16whether Nakamoto is a group or some sort of entity
1:06:20or something like that.
1:06:21- Exactly.
1:06:21- But this is the part that to me makes it seem most like
1:06:25a science fiction novel or film, probably a novel,
1:06:29because I think that the math is not as cinematic
1:06:33as like a novel could make it.
1:06:35But either way, it's like a science fiction story,
1:06:39is that there's a sort of heroic mystery figure
1:06:44at the top of it, an individual who wrote this paper
1:06:49and made this system and then disappeared.
1:06:53- I know, it's very cinematic in that sense.
1:06:54Right. And it's almost now like a mythic figure.
1:07:00Yeah.
1:07:01Not to exaggerate in the least, right? That there's this mythic figure who created this beautiful
1:07:06system, stands to be enriched personally, tremendously by it if they so chose. And then,
1:07:15like you said, very, very active at the outset. It wasn't just like the white paper dropped and
1:07:22the system went into place, there's, you know, I guess, what was it, mailing lists? I don't know,
1:07:26but there's a lot of, you know, online communication from Satoshi Nakamoto,
1:07:32but then just disappeared. Yeah, and they handed it off.
1:07:36Did he write like a, "Okay, I'd say that I'm out of here," or did he just, you know, is there like
1:07:43a goodbye letter or a, "Now I'm done"? I am trying to remember. I think they just stopped
1:07:49- Posting, isn't that funny?
1:07:50I think I would know that it's,
1:07:52I think that they just, hmm.
1:07:56What is the, oh man, it's so funny.
1:07:58I don't think they actually said goodbye.
1:08:00I think they basically stopped posting and then,
1:08:03but it anointed, there was somebody,
1:08:05the person who's the, what's his name,
1:08:07Gavin Edwards, may Gavin something,
1:08:10who's the head of the Bitcoin Foundation.
1:08:13Gavin Andresen, he's chief scientist
1:08:15at the Bitcoin Foundation.
1:08:16So Gavin Andresen, as I understand,
1:08:18I believe he was sort of anointed as the person
1:08:20to carry on the software work.
1:08:21But my recollection is that,
1:08:23is that it wasn't like a,
1:08:27"Okay, and now I've done my work and I'm leaving."
1:08:29It was more like, like just stop posting.
1:08:32And I found the numbers, 1.5 million Bitcoins.
1:08:36And so that's, it's like $800 million
1:08:38in today's exchange rate.
1:08:39And it was over a billion dollars.
1:08:40- And it's not 5% of the ones outstanding,
1:08:42it's about 5% of the ones that will ever exist.
1:08:44- Yeah, it's a little, right, a little more,
1:08:46it's like seven or eight percent, right?
1:08:48So it's a big chunk.
1:08:50And there's, you know, one of the rumors is that,
1:08:52so here's the thing with Bitcoins,
1:08:54you have to keep that private key secure,
1:08:57but if you lose the private key,
1:08:59your Bitcoins are gone forever.
1:09:00You can't spend them, you can't transfer them.
1:09:02I met a Bitcoin miner and he, we were chatting,
1:09:05and two interesting things.
1:09:07One is I did not know initially,
1:09:10but he was, a few months before he and I met,
1:09:12he was generating a significant single digit percentage
1:09:15of all Bitcoins worldwide.
1:09:16did not realize how highly placed he was,
1:09:18which was interesting.
1:09:19And the other was, he said, oh, I've got a drive over there.
1:09:22It's completely dead, it has 400 Bitcoins on it.
1:09:24I'll never recover those.
1:09:25And that was at a time when I think it was,
1:09:26I don't know, a couple hundred dollars a Bitcoin.
1:09:28So he had like a drive that has like $2 million
1:09:30with their dead coins on it by today's,
1:09:32and he'll never get them back.
1:09:33There's no, I mean, he's tried everything.
1:09:34He could spend, you know, $3,000 on drive savers
1:09:37or whatever, and so when you lose the key--
1:09:39- I wish you were dead.
1:09:41They're not a sponsor this week, but--
1:09:43(laughing)
1:09:44- Do we keep talking about them?
1:09:46- Too bad Backblaze isn't a sponsor this week.
1:09:49Back up your hard drives, people.
1:09:51- You know, there are issues about storing private keys
1:09:54for Bitcoin, so this doesn't get us entirely to Mt. Gox,
1:09:57but there's something called cold storage.
1:09:59And you transfer your private key,
1:10:01either you've never had it on an internet connected machine,
1:10:03you sign all your transactions on a not ever connected,
1:10:07you know, a glue in the USB port,
1:10:10wifi radio removed, whatever.
1:10:14you generate all your stuff on a non-connected machine
1:10:16and then you sign transactions and you copy them out
1:10:19or you type them in, you do have a USB key,
1:10:21but you're extremely careful
1:10:22and you move those to the public internet.
1:10:24And this is critical because if your private key is stolen,
1:10:27as has happened on a mass scale over and over again
1:10:30the last few years at multiple online wallet services
1:10:33and exchanges, if someone steals your private key,
1:10:36they can transfer your money to anywhere they want to.
1:10:39And the same thing happens.
1:10:40So the cold storage is in some cases,
1:10:42I understand some are actually printed out
1:10:45the key information.
1:10:46There's like a pile of paper as an additional backup
1:10:48in case the spinning media or SSDs fail.
1:10:51- It makes sense.
1:10:54- It's hilarious.
1:10:54Well, one of the coin services went down,
1:10:57I'm forgetting which one, another one shut down
1:10:59and they did lose some number of coins,
1:11:02but they said almost all of their coins
1:11:03were in cold storage and they will be transferring them back
1:11:06to their owners.
1:11:07The ones they lost that were in live storage was modest
1:11:09and those are gone forever for whatever reason.
1:11:11I don't think they've said yet.
1:11:12But the ones that are in cold storage
1:11:14are totally preserved and okay.
1:11:16- So tell me about these exchanges.
1:11:20What's the point of them?
1:11:25- Well, this gets in the basic nature of like,
1:11:26so John, what is money? (laughs)
1:11:29Have you tried to explain this to Jonah?
1:11:30I mean, like, Jonas, have you said,
1:11:32has he said to you, I mean, he's old enough.
1:11:33Has he, yeah, like, what is actually money?
1:11:35I try to explain to my kids sometimes.
1:11:38And they know that money buys things
1:11:40that could be exchanged for-- there's a great line from--
1:11:43there was a Beatles parody group called The Rutles that
1:11:45had Eric Idle and some other people involved.
1:11:48And someone said, you're just in it for the money.
1:11:50And their joke response was, no, no, we're
1:11:52not in it for the money so much as the goods and services
1:11:55that money purchases, right?
1:11:56You know, Jonas is still at the point
1:11:59where money is like gravity.
1:12:03And it's something he accepts and understands the gist of,
1:12:08but that it's sort of, it's at the bottom of,
1:12:13those why, kids are so,
1:12:18the greatest thing about childhood
1:12:20is the natural inclination of almost all children
1:12:24to just keep asking why, why, why.
1:12:26And it gets, parents of course, you get sick of it,
1:12:29but it's actually, it shows how,
1:12:33what a fantastic state their brains are in,
1:12:36that they're seeking answers,
1:12:38they're coming up with, you know, why, why, why. Gravity is one of those things that he's never
1:12:42asked me about. Like, how exactly is it that we stick to the earth? And money, I think, is exactly
1:12:50the same sort of thing. It's just there and he accepts it and never has gotten to the point where
1:12:54you wonder why. Well, I don't think, I'm not sure if the kids ask or we volunteer, we like to,
1:12:59as part of the series of parental lectures. No, but we've, at some point, I can't remember what
1:13:03came up and I tried to explain it and money sounds ridiculous when you explain it. Why
1:13:09does this piece of paper have value? I'm giving you a piece of paper with George Washington's
1:13:13face on it and you can go anywhere and exchange it for something and people will always accept
1:13:17it as legitimate and that's ridiculous. It's completely ridiculous, right? So when
1:13:22you start to explain Bitcoin to people about why there's value in it, you're like, "All
1:13:26right, this is just crazy." Bitcoin is crazy but then money is crazy too.
1:13:30It was a little bit less crazy when you—and I, you know, again, not to get into the political
1:13:35aspects of it, and I guarantee you with, you know, a technical-minded show, somebody out there is
1:13:40gonna be offended by what I'm about to say. But it was a lot easier to explain when the
1:13:46U.S. was on the gold standard. Yeah, yeah, 'cause you could say it corresponded to a
1:13:51specific amount of gold that had an— The U.S. government owned a tremendous,
1:13:54or still does own it, but owned this tremendous amount of gold. Gold has, you know, a true
1:14:01real value on, you know, because it's a rare mineral that people consider to be beautiful and
1:14:06etc. And Dollar Bill was the US government promising that this Dollar Bill represents
1:14:13a dollar's worth of gold. You could always exchange it if you wanted to for that amount of money.
1:14:17And then I, you know, my understanding, you know, and there's a whole bunch of, there's a,
1:14:21you know, always been a political fringe that thinks the US made a mistake getting off the
1:14:27gold standard and that we should get back onto it. And not that I think that that's actually a
1:14:31good economic theory, I think the explanation is that it appeals to many people because it's
1:14:35understandable. And--
1:14:37Pete: Well, it supposedly prevents inflation. There's a lot of reasons why people like it.
1:14:41It's inflation, it's a real thing, it prevents printing money, it controls governments,
1:14:45governments can't go to war as easily, necessarily, because they can't print money.
1:14:49Ted, so all these things that a lot of people
1:14:51hate and they think that the gold standard could be an answer to them returning to it or having never.
1:14:56- I just think a big part of the appeal is that it's, there's no yada, yada, yada, dot,
1:15:03dot, dot step in the middle, which is what you have with our current system.
1:15:07- Right. Well, so here's the thing, fundamentally what fiat currency or like,
1:15:12what's the word for it? It's like cash money. What money printed by governments, backed by
1:15:17governments has is that you can pay your taxes in it and the government pays its bills in
1:15:22it. And I've talked to a bunch of people when I was doing The Economist articles about Bitcoin
1:15:26and fundamentally that's what a lot of them said was it's the government's use of legal
1:15:31tender as a means of exchange, not just that it establishes value, you know, and there's
1:15:37the extra angle that some people want to talk about coercion. The reason we accept money
1:15:41is because the, you know, governments have militaries and they force us to. If you didn't
1:15:44accept money, you know, you're backed by the police and above the police, the military,
1:15:48and you can go to jail, there's a penalty, you know, for how you use it. So, you know,
1:15:53you can get to a political argument about that, but fundamentally it's when you pay
1:15:59the American government, or most governments, you have to pay in the currency that they accept,
1:16:04and they issue that currency to pay all of their bills. And so…
1:16:08Jared: That starts a virtuous cycle that gives it value.
1:16:11Right, it's a barter system in which the government is the, you know, I mean, dollar bills are,
1:16:15it is a form of barter. We just accept the value that the government puts on it and the
1:16:19US government at least, with some intervention, allows the dollar to float to represent what
1:16:24the market actually thinks it's worth as a means of exchange. So Bitcoin is weird because,
1:16:29and so that's where you get into the Mt. Gox and these other exchanges as one aspect of
1:16:33the ecosystem of Bitcoin is that moving money in and out of Bitcoin. So it's one thing if
1:16:38you were a miner. In the early days, you could run like, you could have been running like
1:16:41a Mac Pro and making coins and actually having coins to spend. And they might not have been
1:16:46worth that much each, but you know, there was some people accepting them. You could
1:16:50use it to exchange debts with some people. But you need to move money in and out of the
1:16:53system. So there's no inherent value as more and more merchants accept Bitcoin, which is
1:16:58still going on. Like Overstock will accept Bitcoin through an intermediary that establishes
1:17:05for it, but the more you can buy within the system, the less you have to transact in and
1:17:09out. But the exchanges exist as a way to take dollars and turn them into Bitcoins or any
1:17:13currency and vice versa. And I set up with—so Mark Andresen and I had this wonder—so Mark
1:17:18Andresen, founder of Netscape, really interesting guy, a guy I think was seen as not very bright
1:17:25for a while about how he invested and what he did, and then it all started to pay off.
1:17:29And then everyone thinks he's brilliant, and I actually kind of think he's brilliant.
1:17:31I think he was so far ahead of his time as an investor that it took a lot, like with
1:17:36Paul Allen, where everyone thought Paul Allen was an idiot for about a decade, and then
1:17:40everything he thought would happen happened.
1:17:43You know, satellite television and everything.
1:17:45Paul Allen, just about.
1:17:46And so—
1:17:47And so, hell, the Seahawks even won a Super Bowl.
1:17:49I know!
1:17:50I mean, he spent—
1:17:51[laughter]
1:17:52Exactly!
1:17:53So, so I love—
1:17:54I mean, you can make a lot of money going back to like 1985 and betting people that
1:17:57the Seahawks are gonna win a Super Bowl eventually.
1:18:00So you could, so you could say this.
1:18:01you could say like in 2000, people thought Mark Andreessen
1:18:03and Paul Allen were not very smart.
1:18:05And in 2014, it's like pretty damn smart
1:18:08in terms of where technology went and how they made money.
1:18:10So Mark Andreessen wrote this piece
1:18:12'cause he's involved with, before I say it,
1:18:14I think it's Coinbase.
1:18:16And Andreessen Horowitz, they invest in Bitcoin companies
1:18:20and it's part of their, you know, what they're into.
1:18:24And let me make sure, I think it's,
1:18:26I'm pretty sure it's he's invested in that one.
1:18:28I hate to say the wrong company
1:18:28'cause there's so many BitCoin, yeah Coinbase,
1:18:32yeah Andreessen Horowitz put in $25 million
1:18:34as a part of the, or sorry,
1:18:36that was part of the lead investment was them,
1:18:39but it was $25 million a few months ago.
1:18:40So I go to Coinbase and I say,
1:18:42"All right, I wanna buy $50 worth of Bitcoin."
1:18:45And they're like, "Great, okay, verify some information,
1:18:47"do this, we're gonna text you this thing, you should."
1:18:50And all right, so I'm like, "This is okay,
1:18:51"it's like setting up a banking thing, whatever."
1:18:53And they're like, "All right, your Bitcoins
1:18:55"will be available in like three to five business days."
1:18:57I'm like, "Wait a minute, this is an instantaneous system, what's going on?"
1:19:01And the problem is Bitcoin, despite a lot of claims, and I hear this from people who
1:19:05say it's incredibly liquid.
1:19:07Bitcoin is not very liquid when you want to go in and out of legal tender.
1:19:12And so exchanges exist to make that happen, but between banking regulation, where a lot
1:19:17of these exchanges, the amount of gawks fell afoul of this, they actually have to deal
1:19:21with certain banking laws, in some cases, not all, depends how they construct themselves.
1:19:25there's like reporting requirements and whatever between that and just some aspects of like how many
1:19:31people participate in the system, how you move the coins around to be able to exchange that value
1:19:36without being too heavily, you know, an exchange can't take so many Bitcoins and pay out so much
1:19:41cash that they don't have actual legal tender on hand, right? That would be bad because then there
1:19:45could be a change in the volatile price of Bitcoin and they could be caught short and there'd be a
1:19:50run on the exchange, which has happened essentially in multiple cases.
1:19:53Right, the same way Nevada state law says that a casino must have the equivalent cash
1:20:01in the building as they have casino chips in circulation.
1:20:07Which makes sense, right?
1:20:08Right.
1:20:09It makes perfect sense because—
1:20:10If everybody in the casino all at once wanted to cash in the chips that they have in front
1:20:14of them, the casino is legally obligated to have enough cash to cover it.
1:20:18And this is why the wonderful, the FDIC is one of the best agencies we have in America.
1:20:25I'm confident the former head of the FDIC, I am confident, even though she did not get
1:20:29her role extolled as much, she was not one of the boys in the room.
1:20:33Sheila, what was her name?
1:20:34I'll find this, but she is the reason that the entire American economy, Sheila Bair,
1:20:39which she's left the FDIC now, she cut deals that prevented the US economy from falling
1:20:44apart by keeping banks open.
1:20:47And she made that happen.
1:20:48and the FDIC said-
1:20:49- You're talking about like at the end of 2008.
1:20:51- Sorry, end of 2008, right.
1:20:52She, despite everyone talking about Geithner
1:20:56and all these other people,
1:20:57she is actually the reason our banking economy
1:20:59did not collapse and we did not actually
1:21:01go into a depression.
1:21:02I'm confident history will prove that
1:21:03because the top of the name,
1:21:06the people in the top name are all these guys
1:21:08who did all kinds of crap and she actually just did the work.
1:21:10So anyway, the FDIC exists as an entity
1:21:13because we had bank runs and the right,
1:21:15the depression happened, banks did not have enough money.
1:21:17Your money's in, you know, Mr. Thompson's house,
1:21:20and it's the Bailey Savings and Loan scene.
1:21:24No, what's my money doing over there?
1:21:26So when you have a run of the bank,
1:21:27banks are not obliged to keep 100% of their deposits on hand.
1:21:30They lend them out, and that's how they make money.
1:21:32The FDIC is the backstop.
1:21:34I know this is basic for most listeners.
1:21:35The FDIC, the Federal Deposit Insurance Commission,
1:21:38they take premiums from banks,
1:21:40and they use that to have a fund
1:21:41that backstops a certain amount of loss if banks go under.
1:21:46and the FDIC is out there closing banks down.
1:21:48It's kind of cool.
1:21:49Have you ever heard of the FDIC?
1:21:50They close banks down?
1:21:52- No.
1:21:53- It's cool.
1:21:53I think Planet Money did a piece on it.
1:21:55They basically, they show up on a Friday,
1:21:58they're all dressed in plain clothes
1:21:59and they show all their credentials
1:22:01and they shut the bank down and they take it over
1:22:03and no one at the bank is allowed to talk about it.
1:22:05They spend the weekend on the books, whatever,
1:22:07and it opens on Monday.
1:22:09And it's like, it is like a spy operation
1:22:12because they do not want to, you know,
1:22:14they'll come into town.
1:22:15I understand that like rent rooms and motels not at the same motel.
1:22:18They do not want to panic people.
1:22:19They do not want to run in the bank.
1:22:20- It's the accounting version of like what a gangster movie
1:22:24would call the cleaner, right?
1:22:26- Exactly, the FDIC and that's what they do.
1:22:28And they do it.
1:22:29- Harvey Keitel in Pulp Fiction, right?
1:22:31- Yeah, you know, you got your sulfuric acid here.
1:22:34- We don't want any attention, you know?
1:22:36No, no, not Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction.
1:22:38When they got shot in a car and you know, it's like, look,
1:22:40we just want to clean this mess up.
1:22:41Nobody's gonna know none the better, right?
1:22:45- But it's, yeah.
1:22:45- It's with numbers, numbers and ledgers.
1:22:48- We're cutting the bank apart into small pieces
1:22:50and we're melting them in the tub
1:22:51and no one's gonna know about this bank.
1:22:53So I don't mean to make a huge digression,
1:22:55but the FDIC backstops banks.
1:22:57So if banks don't have enough money on hand,
1:22:59the FDIC is there to pay depositors up to a certain amount,
1:23:02which is huge, I know.
1:23:04So small depositors never get, and so people don't panic.
1:23:09There's no, we don't have runs on the bank
1:23:11because people believe that the US government
1:23:13in the form of the FDIC will backstop banks.
1:23:16And we saw that in the 2008 crisis.
1:23:18There is no FDIC for Bitcoin,
1:23:20and maybe one will be created.
1:23:22But when there's a run on an operation,
1:23:25an exchange has some amount of Bitcoins
1:23:26and some amount of cash,
1:23:27and they cannot cash everything out at once,
1:23:30and they're not obliged to the way they're run.
1:23:32So this gets us around.
1:23:33So now--
1:23:34- It's like you said that it's the government,
1:23:37and it really does annoy me,
1:23:38and Marco had a good piece last week about it.
1:23:40It doesn't make any sense to talk about the government
1:23:42as a single entity and complain that the government is always
1:23:45in the way and whatever, that the government is comprised
1:23:48of thousands of individual organizations
1:23:55from the federal to the state to your municipal level.
1:23:57FDIC is a great example of the government at work.
1:24:00Because the main point of it is if you see a bank
1:24:03and you see that the bank is in FDIC--
1:24:07and I believe it's probably not even legal to open a bank
1:24:10that's not part of the FDIC.
1:24:11you can't just, like you and I can't just open a
1:24:13thing and call it a bank.
1:24:14Yeah, there's all the, you have to, there has to
1:24:16be like a governing regulator, there's
1:24:17different choices, the FDIC, you have to pay
1:24:19them insurance.
1:24:20But it means that all of us, every single citizen
1:24:23can just, you don't have to worry about doing
1:24:25the research and figuring out is this bank legit
1:24:28is, you know, if I go in there and put my paycheck
1:24:31in deposit, you know, create a checking account
1:24:33and put my whole paycheck in there, is that money
1:24:36safe?
1:24:36You don't have to worry about it.
1:24:37It just is.
1:24:38You really, I mean, all you have to do is have
1:24:40in the US government.
1:24:42- And at one point, you remember for a long time,
1:24:44the FDIC said, you know, deposits,
1:24:46you hear a commercial on TV for a bank,
1:24:48deposits are insured up to the maximum $100,000
1:24:50by the FDIC, and then during the crisis,
1:24:52they lifted that amount, I forget to what,
1:24:54and I don't remember what it's at now,
1:24:56because there are enough people who like,
1:24:58you know, this just happened, my parents sold their house,
1:25:01and they had hundreds of thousands of dollars
1:25:02from the house, which they plan to live on
1:25:04for the rest of their lives, in the bank.
1:25:05And you know, so they had more than 100 grand
1:25:07in one account, and if a bank fails,
1:25:10you were only insured.
1:25:11In some other countries,
1:25:12they immediately lifted it to unlimited
1:25:14because they did not want any depositors
1:25:16to not be made whole.
1:25:17They felt it was a better risk to prevent a run of the bank,
1:25:19especially by high net worth individuals
1:25:21who might have a million bucks in an account,
1:25:23than to worry about the problem
1:25:27of reclaiming that money later.
1:25:28And it worked out correctly.
1:25:29It was the right move.
1:25:30- And the limit, I think that that limit was pretty old.
1:25:33It, you know-- - It was.
1:25:34It was inflation adjusted.
1:25:35- Right, it was like $100,000 in,
1:25:37you know, I'm gonna pull the number out of my hat,
1:25:39but 1950 dollars, I don't know, which is a far cry
1:25:44from 100,000 dollars and 2,008 dollars.
1:25:46- It's very easy for people who are in the age range
1:25:49from 50 to 80 to wind up with more than 100 grand
1:25:52in the bank because of house sales, basically.
1:25:53They downsize.
1:25:54You live in the Bay, I mean, 90 people whose parents
1:25:56lived in the Bay Area, and they got a million dollars
1:25:59for their house, they didn't ever expect a windfall,
1:26:01and they might have a tiny pension or whatever.
1:26:04They don't even know how to handle that.
1:26:06So there is nothing, there's no backstop.
1:26:08And so with Mt. Gox, so Mt. Gox has all kinds of weird things.
1:26:12You may know it started as a site called
1:26:16Magic the Gathering Online Exchange, M-T-G-O-X.
1:26:20Did you know this?
1:26:21- I did know that. - This is a funny story.
1:26:22Yeah, so it's funny.
1:26:23So they thought they were going to be,
1:26:25and what I read the other day pointed out
1:26:27that if they'd actually invested in
1:26:29Magic the Gathering coins back when they started,
1:26:31they would, or cards rather,
1:26:33they would probably have had a better return
1:26:34than what's happened.
1:26:36'Cause some cards are worth like $2,000 now.
1:26:38But so, anyhow, so Mt. Gox, people have been documenting for years the deficiencies in
1:26:45their programming, their security, their response.
1:26:48They had, they didn't file the right paperwork or act in the correct way in the United States.
1:26:52And the U.S. seized, I think it was $5 million from them because they didn't have, they were
1:26:58operating as essentially a kind of entity that they weren't, and they just didn't do
1:27:02the right work.
1:27:03Like, I think they could have been operating as an entity.
1:27:05There are Bitcoin exchanges that operate in the United States that have filed the paperwork
1:27:09correctly and Mt. Gox did not.
1:27:10So the, it's still totally unclear what happened because they haven't released enough information.
1:27:19They claim they've lost, what was the number, it's a crazy number, it's like 7% of all outstanding
1:27:25It is 750,000, yeah, over 750,000 coins owned by its users and 100,000 of its own.
1:27:35And the issue is we don't know what lost means yet because they haven't done a forensics
1:27:39thing in Japan.
1:27:40They're based in Japan.
1:27:41That's where their offices were.
1:27:44It could be they lost all the private keys.
1:27:46Maybe they didn't do a good job and they're just unrecoverable.
1:27:48And gone from the system.
1:27:49Right.
1:27:50Yeah.
1:27:51suspicion that there are potentially hundreds of thousands or maybe even as many as millions
1:27:56of Bitcoins that will never be recovered because the private keys are lost. There's
1:27:59no recovery process where they can be reclaimed. So that's one concern. The other is it might
1:28:04have been theft, someone got access. You know, one party was saying, there was an article
1:28:08recently a couple days ago about how Mt. Gox encoded all of its SSH keys, like its private
1:28:14keys, in its server code.
1:28:17[Laughter]
1:28:18things like that. So, yeah, so it's crazy. So like, there's, they just are not, you know, they're clearly without, you know, alleging anything, it's clear, they were not a rigorously running institution.
1:28:32The other thing I saw was that, and again, I can't verify it, but I saw the other day that they
1:28:36apparently, you know, the whole system, the computer system, they
1:28:40were not using any sort of source control software.
1:28:44So, I saw that and I was like,
1:28:48so, right, so they have all kinds of technical deficiencies. But, so one suspicion
1:28:52is, there's this problem called transaction malleability that is suspected
1:28:56might be the cause, although I read a really good analysis a couple days ago, and I
1:29:00Although I read a really good analysis a couple days ago that suggested that at the scale
1:29:05of what happened it couldn't be.
1:29:06So there is a flaw in Bitcoin, in the Bitcoin software clients and some of the implementations
1:29:13as I understand it.
1:29:14It's not a protocol flaw, but well I shouldn't say that.
1:29:18So this transaction thing I was talking about, what should happen is I'm sending you one
1:29:22Bitcoin, John, and the transaction that my software generates, which probably uses a
1:29:26a standard Bitcoin library that the Bitcoin Foundation
1:29:29essentially maintains, even though it's open source.
1:29:32That transaction has a transaction ID
1:29:34and some unique information, and I've signed it, and boom.
1:29:37So what should be impossible is for someone else
1:29:40to generate a transaction that looks like mine
1:29:43and is validated and even has the same destination.
1:29:48So it doesn't hijack who the money is going to, right?
1:29:50It just looks valid and has the same recipient and sender.
1:29:54That should not be possible,
1:29:55and it is in fact possible to create fake transactions
1:29:59after a legitimate one is created.
1:30:01So other parties can illegitimately create bad transactions
1:30:06and there have even been denial of service attempts
1:30:08where many bad transactions are created for each good one.
1:30:11If the bad transactions are taken up first,
1:30:14they get baked into the record.
1:30:16And the problem is some software didn't validate
1:30:20whether the transaction ID had changed.
1:30:23And if they'd note or think it was just the ID.
1:30:25And if they'd noticed it had changed, it would have invalidated that transaction or some
1:30:31other aspect there.
1:30:32So the coins are actually transferred, but the exchange, for instance, in this case,
1:30:37would not recognize it because the transaction ID didn't match.
1:30:41So I've done everything right.
1:30:42I've sent you a coin and you say, "Hey, I never got it.
1:30:44My exchange says it didn't go through."
1:30:46And I look and I'm like, "My software says it does.
1:30:49I'm looking in the block.
1:30:50The block says it was minted."
1:30:52And you say, "No, my exchange says it never went through."
1:30:54And you go, "Oh, okay."
1:30:55And Mt. Gox apparently had an automated system that when a transaction appeared to not go through, they would send it again.
1:31:01And it's unclear how often it would send it again.
1:31:03So, if you were a malicious party, you could concoct a way in transactions with Mt. Gox to create false ones and get the same money multiple times.
1:31:12But because you can't change all the parameters, you can't just steal the coins, it's more a way to leak money out from transactions that are, um,
1:31:20that had some legitimate basis to start with and then you can sort of suck money out or people unintentionally
1:31:25Send more money than they meant to and the recipient doesn't even know that more money was sent
1:31:30So that was one suspicion. It does not appear like that the scale of it would make sense
1:31:34It's more likely their bad security led to someone stealing all the private keys
1:31:38well, what's the solution to this, you know how if somebody wanted to get involved and and
1:31:45Buy some bitcoins and have these
1:31:48I mean, I guess the solution is to find a reputable and technically competent exchange.
1:31:55But how is a normal person supposed to figure out to determine what is a reputable and technically
1:32:02competent exchange?
1:32:03Well, I think this is what the market's trying to do now.
1:32:07Even though the valuation of Bitcoin is arbitrary, there's enough people involved in the system
1:32:11using it that even with Mt. Gox failure and all this stuff happening, the value has not
1:32:17I don't know what we're talking right now. I should say those six. It hasn't crashed. I'm talking in the values of zero, but
1:32:23Be bad
1:32:27but the the the market didn't go from you know a thousand dollars a Bitcoin to
1:32:31To zero, you know, it went from yeah
1:32:34Like I'm looking right now the current exchange rate as we talk is somewhere in the $600 range. I actually think and again I am a
1:32:41Bitcoin dummy, but as an a you know, and I've never
1:32:46put a nickel into it and
1:32:48It's still I'm not tempted to but just as a curious observer
1:32:51I would actually say that that what's happened to the value of Bitcoin in the last few weeks actually
1:32:57Shows a significant amount of stability, you know like going from a thousand to six hundred is a pretty significant crash
1:33:03But not what I would have expected when I first heard about the Mt. Gox thing. I thought well there it goes
1:33:08That's the toilet flush
1:33:10You know bitcoins gonna drop down to you know
1:33:14dollars a bitcoin. It should have happened if it had actually been a fatal event or a
1:33:18near fatal event is the value shouldn't have just gone off by like 50 percent. What should
1:33:22have happened is people would be trying to get liquidity out of it. They would have been
1:33:25unable to and they would have accepted lower and lower amounts until it was like ten dollars
1:33:29a bitcoin and the market collapsed. Instead it went down to like I don't know 500 and
1:33:34it's rebounded a bit which means that there are people who believe they have enough value
1:33:39in the system in retaining their bitcoin in the system that they weren't panicked and
1:33:42try to exchange it out. Right, and I know, you know, and I've sort of avoided linking
1:33:46to a lot of the Bitcoin stuff because I just don't understand it, but I know that there's
1:33:49a lot of, you know, a sort of, "Hey, this is actually a good thing for Bitcoin," and
1:33:54then there's, you know, the skeptics, which I kind of agree with, which is, "No, this
1:33:58is not, Mt. Cox is not a good thing for Bitcoin." You can't argue that. I think it's sort of
1:34:04halfway in the middle, which is, no, it's not good that it happened, I mean, and no
1:34:08No matter whether it was crime or just incompetence, it's bad either way.
1:34:11But the fact that after this bad thing happened, which was bad, that it was relatively stable
1:34:18value-wise, I think is a good thing.
1:34:20It shows that, you know, there's a certain stability to it.
1:34:24Pete: Yeah, after all the volatility, I think this was actually pretty remarkable.
1:34:28And some of that comes now because you have people like the Winklevoss twins who have
1:34:33put a pile of money in and they own, I forget what it is, they own a single digit percentage
1:34:37of bitcoins and there are other parties.
1:34:41I mean, so this is one of the things,
1:34:43Stat came out the other day, I think it was,
1:34:45was it, a few hundred people own 50% of all bitcoins.
1:34:49And which isn't strange, but bitcoin
1:34:52as a democratizing thing, you're like, oh, okay.
1:34:54You know, and then like, I think it was like
1:34:56a few thousand people own 75%.
1:34:59So there's this issue about, oh, I was mentioning earlier,
1:35:03so Mark Andreessen, so one of the companies
1:35:05you could look at, and I have no connection to it,
1:35:06In fact, might even be seen as a skeptic,
1:35:08because I had all this back and forth with Marc Andreessen,
1:35:11who is incredibly funny on Twitter,
1:35:13and a really great sparring partner, by the way.
1:35:15He is really a good sport,
1:35:17and will talk about all this stuff,
1:35:19which is impressive,
1:35:20'cause most people who have piles of money,
1:35:21and think they know everything,
1:35:23and they don't wanna talk to anybody,
1:35:24and they don't listen.
1:35:25He listens, he talks, and he's very funny.
1:35:26And so, he wrote this op-ed-ish piece
1:35:29for the New York Times at the Dealbook section
1:35:31about why Bitcoin was so wonderful,
1:35:33because it reduced transaction fees
1:35:35to practically nothing or nothing,
1:35:36and it would be a great thing for all these parties.
1:35:38And I disagree with a bunch of his statements.
1:35:41I wrote a long thing, and he and I went back and forth,
1:35:43and it was very, it was elusive to me,
1:35:45his thinking about how you make Bitcoin
1:35:48into a stable thing that just becomes part
1:35:50of the international banking system.
1:35:52Like, he is not a political rabble-rouser.
1:35:54What he wants, and the Winklevossy,
1:35:56Voxie, whatever you call them,
1:35:58and the rest of the folks who are trying to make this work,
1:36:00is they want a system that's outside the inefficiencies,
1:36:04It has the security of Bitcoin is outside of the inefficiency to the banking system,
1:36:08but doesn't need to be above the law and not subject to regulation and scrutiny.
1:36:12They basically want something that makes money move as fast as email.
1:36:16And I get that.
1:36:17There's a good thing.
1:36:18So Mark's invested in his group in Coinbase.
1:36:21That's where I put 50 bucks in.
1:36:22And you know why Bitcoin dropped in value half?
1:36:25Because I put 50 bucks in.
1:36:26It's now worth $25.
1:36:27My fault.
1:36:28It's like washing your car.
1:36:30So Coinbase is clearly a place to start because they're trying to do everything right, and
1:36:35they're, you know, they're not trying to be chartered in a boat off the coast of Iceland
1:36:39and under Somali law.
1:36:41They're trying to do it.
1:36:42So it's an interesting place to start from a group that's trying to see how they can
1:36:46comply and work within the system.
1:36:48What's the related thing?
1:36:50Oh, so Quentin Hardy wrote this piece based partly on Mark and my exchange.
1:36:53He wrote this thing for the New York Times I recommend reading, in which he talked about
1:36:57the rise of a kind of super rich transnational class.
1:37:01He said, "I threw down," he said,
1:37:02he was sitting with some very, very wealthy people.
1:37:04He said, "If I threw down passports from,"
1:37:06was it three or five countries,
1:37:08all of them stable, like Singapore, United States,
1:37:09whatever, "which one would you pick up?"
1:37:11And the guy started to debate which one.
1:37:13They didn't say the country that I'm from.
1:37:14They didn't have a nationalist influence.
1:37:16He worries, in part, that Bitcoin lets people become,
1:37:20it takes money outside of the sphere of national influence
1:37:23and it lets people who are extremely wealthy
1:37:25sort of live in a cloud above the world.
1:37:28And so there is some of that thinking,
1:37:30especially when you see that Bitcoin is controlled
1:37:33by a relatively small number of people.
1:37:34That control by a relatively small number of people
1:37:37is one reason why the currency remains stable,
1:37:39because they have the economic wherewithal
1:37:40to not need to pull the money out of the system
1:37:43at a low valuation.
1:37:45- I would say this though, I mean,
1:37:46and who knows where the eventual value of it is going to go.
1:37:48Right now though, at $600 a Bitcoin,
1:37:53If there's a limit of 21 million, that's somewhere around $12 billion for every Bitcoin that
1:38:00could ever be.
1:38:01And even if you double that or triple it, you're talking $25, $50 billion.
1:38:08Now who knows, maybe it'll go up tenfold, twentyfold, thirtyfold, and then become worth
1:38:13more.
1:38:14it stands a system where the entire the entirety of Bitcoin is only worth 10 20
1:38:2130 billion dollars I don't see that as a global lead this you know it I can see
1:38:30why governments aren't that ready to jump in and try to regulate well it's
1:38:35right because you need it in inflation within the Bitcoin system to make the
1:38:39coins valuable enough individually they can divide them into tiny pieces that's
1:38:43- So that's my next question.
1:38:43Explain to me fractional Bitcoins.
1:38:46How is that?
1:38:46How can you put $50 into Coinbase and have anything?
1:38:49If a Bitcoin is worth 600 bucks?
1:38:53- This is the ridiculous part.
1:38:54So it's almost like,
1:38:55it's like owning a fraction of a share of stock
1:38:57at some level because Bitcoins are only essentially,
1:38:59I don't know if I'm using the right term,
1:39:01but they're forward transactions.
1:39:02I can only send you money.
1:39:03So if I have 50 Bitcoins in my wallet
1:39:07and I want to send you 49,
1:39:11I have to do a change transaction.
1:39:13So I actually send you 49 and I send myself one.
1:39:16And this is the way, the fact that I have to send change
1:39:18to myself, there's a flaw in most current clients
1:39:21that makes those transactions essentially trackable
1:39:24and researchers have shown they can do this thing
1:39:26that even after hundreds of transactions,
1:39:29they can actually track back Bitcoins to the origin
1:39:31by unpeeling all these change transactions
1:39:34and seeing where the money went.
1:39:36So I can send you a tiny, tiny amount.
1:39:38I can, so the current smallest unit is
1:39:41one times 10 to the negative eighth,
1:39:43and I forget how, seven zeros and a one,
1:39:45and that's called a Satoshi,
1:39:47it's the basic unit of Bitcoin.
1:39:49And the protocol could easily be adapted
1:39:51to have smaller fractions, or even reverse it,
1:39:55so like, you know, one Bitcoin is a Satoshi or something.
1:39:58There's nothing that prevents that from happening.
1:40:01But that lets me send tiny amounts of money,
1:40:04but I send essentially,
1:40:05the thing is people can wind up with all these wallets,
1:40:08like you can have piles of Bitcoin addresses,
1:40:10And then eventually you might consolidate them.
1:40:13So you take one address that's got 43 bitcoins,
1:40:15another has one, another has 0.05,
1:40:17and you essentially pay yourself all of the small ones,
1:40:21you wind up with one address that has, you know,
1:40:23750,000 bitcoins in it.
1:40:25So there's a lot of monkeying around,
1:40:27and people typically use client software
1:40:29that handles the details,
1:40:31but the client software masks a lot of transaction
1:40:33that can leak some of the anonymity involved in it.
1:40:36There's also, we didn't even talk about Dogecoin.
1:40:40about Dogecoin? I've heard of it. I don't get it. So an Ars Technica just launched ArsCoin.
1:40:47Dogecoin is D-O-G-E coin. Yeah, it's a real thing. It's a real thing. It actually
1:40:52has value in it. Dogecoin was a parody. It was launched two months ago in December,
1:40:58or three months ago in December. And people are investing in it. It's got different properties.
1:41:06then it's a code fork from Bitcoin, which is open source.
1:41:10It has different properties, including a mining technique
1:41:12that does not consume eventually the power of our sun
1:41:15to make new calculations.
1:41:18It's got a non-scaling, I think it's using S-Crypt
1:41:22or B-Crypt, or it's got, anyway, whatever it's using,
1:41:24it's using something that does not require
1:41:26the scaling capability that you need to do
1:41:28more SHA-1 transactions.
1:41:30And there's Litecoin, which is a different crypto standard,
1:41:34a crypto coin standard.
1:41:35There's something called Zerocoin where one,
1:41:37a guy who's a researcher who wanted to create pure anonymity
1:41:41that you could put into Bitcoin,
1:41:43after being sort of rebuffed
1:41:45about embedding it inside Bitcoin,
1:41:47he and other folks are gonna launch a Bitcoin-like currency
1:41:50that will allow Bitcoin-like coins
1:41:52and totally anonymous coins that no two transactions
1:41:57can be connected to one another to be exchanged in.
1:41:59So there's an explosion of cryptocurrency as well.
1:42:02Dogecoin is the funniest one, but--
1:42:05- It's real, people are using it.
1:42:06- It started as a parody.
1:42:08- Yeah, and it turns out that like,
1:42:10it's actually got some properties people like,
1:42:12including the initial,
1:42:15it's, they set the number very funny too.
1:42:17So it's like the initially 100 billion coins
1:42:20can be mined by the end of this year,
1:42:21but then it's a fixed rate of 5 billion coins after that.
1:42:24So there's a built-in inflation in it,
1:42:26does not shrink over time.
1:42:27- You're losing me.
1:42:31- Well, there's no top limit
1:42:34how many Dogecoins can be minted.
1:42:35I see, I see.
1:42:38I know. It's crazy, but it's crazy. Some of it, it's sort of funny and it's sort
1:42:41of weird, but so this gets back to, I think, some of the points that you had earlier and
1:42:45it's, is that, and some, and it's a point I like to make, and I'm sure everyone listening
1:42:51to this, no matter whether you're in Europe or Asia or America, banking is ridiculous.
1:42:56Banking is ridiculous. Banks exist to, the banks exist to extract fees from us and they
1:43:01run the most insecure system in the world. The most secure system, I think, is like,
1:43:05chip and pin is actually—and why use Neerap? Like, that's great for doing that kind of
1:43:08transaction. But, like, wire transfers are totally unsecured. Stuff's passed in the
1:43:13clear. ATM has—ATMs have certain kinds of encryption and security that are really good,
1:43:18others that are ridiculous. So—and you can't—you know, when you get a dollar bill, you don't
1:43:22know if it's real. What percentage—there's some number about the percentage of hundred
1:43:25dollar bills in circulation in the world that are—
1:43:27that are-- - Counterfeit.
1:43:29- Fraudulent, yeah.
1:43:30So the fact is, Bitcoin and systems like Bitcoin,
1:43:34something like it will get incorporated
1:43:38into the banking and transaction system,
1:43:40if not into our currency system,
1:43:42because of this property,
1:43:44that because the cryptographic nature of it
1:43:48prevents a whole bunch of bad behavior.
1:43:50It prevents double spending, it prevents counterfeiting,
1:43:52it prevents, it allows a certain kind of legitimacy
1:43:56and ownership, it's very hard.
1:43:57I mean, so people have hacked into these exchanges
1:44:00and wallet services and stolen private keys.
1:44:02But if you do security correctly, which people can do,
1:44:06then it doesn't matter if you get hacked into,
1:44:08the keys are still protected by another layer of passphrase
1:44:11and they're unrecoverable by the thief.
1:44:12So there's ways to do it correctly.
1:44:14And so this could be a way where instead of
1:44:16doing a credit card transaction the way we do now,
1:44:18which is, you know, ridiculously unsecured
1:44:20and you just need the number sometimes to end your zip code.
1:44:24- Right, yeah, you can do it over the phone.
1:44:26be able to, yeah. So what if, you know, what if Visa released a web-based, you know, signing thing
1:44:32that used, that let you use something that was very much like Bitcoin, but it was entirely in
1:44:37their system. You'd love it because you'd say like, "Oh, thank God." Like, verified by Visa,
1:44:41which I think is still in use, you'd go to a merchant, it would pop up a Visa window,
1:44:45and you could check that it was a secure connection to Visa, and you'd punch your password
1:44:49into Visa's site, and it would then confirm that you were legitimate, but your password never went
1:44:54to was like an extra step and that was cool.
1:44:56It's reasonable to me that you that we could change the credit card system so that you couldn't
1:45:00do a transaction over the phone in the same way that we accept that you can't
1:45:08send cash over the phone, right? Like if I owe you 25 bucks, I there's no way that I can do it
1:45:12right now talking to you over Skype. There's no number I can read to you that could do it.
1:45:16I think it's reasonable that we would lose the ability to call somebody over the phone and give
1:45:22give them a credit card number and have it count.
1:45:24Because our phones, more and more,
1:45:27are computers with an IP connection
1:45:30that you can run an app or connect to a website
1:45:33and do cryptographic communication.
1:45:37- Well, but it could even be as simple as,
1:45:39you know, like two factor kind of thing
1:45:41is I could be registered with different coin systems
1:45:44or credit card systems in my phone
1:45:46and I call to make a transaction.
1:45:47They're like, "Great, okay, we'd like to process that.
1:45:49"Can you read us the six digit number
1:45:51that's just been texted to your phone or run the, you know, Visa Authenticator app, and
1:45:56you pull that up and you go, it's sick, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
1:45:58And that verifies my identity, or at least, you know, if I've stolen information, I've
1:46:02stolen a lot of information from somebody, it's not just a routine drive by credit card
1:46:06theft.
1:46:07And, but, so there's lots of aspects of Bitcoin that I believe, this is why, you know, they
1:46:12had a, um, Congress had hearings, I think it was late last year, about Bitcoin and a
1:46:15friend of mine attended them and he was stunned, and the coverage indicated this as well, at
1:46:20and interested senators and staff, or, I don't know,
1:46:22staffers were and congressmen and women were
1:46:25about the positive aspects of it.
1:46:28And the banks are very, very interested in it.
1:46:30And the regulators are interested in it.
1:46:31They don't just want to prevent activity or capture tax.
1:46:36Well, that's certainly part of it.
1:46:37It's also that they do actually see the positive parts
1:46:41of having a cryptographically robust identity secured system
1:46:46that we don't have now.
1:46:47And so that's kind of cool.
1:46:48And so that's kind of cool. I did not expect to see that much openness.
1:46:51And the people who are core Bitcoin users hate the notion, typically, that government would get involved.
1:46:56The new people coming in, like Andreessen and the Winklevoss and so forth,
1:46:59they're much more interested in having government involvement at a certain level to provide both, like, trust and to remove more of the criminal element as well.
1:47:08I mean, I think, like, any—I think, like, government regulation is, like, almost everything in life.
1:47:13Everything. Where, you know, moderation is the key.
1:47:17You know, there's too little and there's too much.
1:47:19And so, and then on the polar ends of politics, there's always going to be people pushing for the extreme.
1:47:26You know, true, you know, almost anarchist libertarians who want almost no government regulation over every, any aspect of life period.
1:47:35And on the other end, people, you know, who push for, you know, too much.
1:47:41And I think, you know, I think Bitcoin and government regulation over these sort of,
1:47:47you know, Bitcoin and other things like it is, you know, in the same regard,
1:47:51where the right amount of government regulation is not zero.
1:47:54Pete: If you've ever tried to pay somebody in another country anything, except through PayPal,
1:48:00which has its own issues and fees and problems, I mean, it's weird actually that PayPal works as
1:48:05well as it does. Because every other method is horrible to pay. You either have to pay huge
1:48:10or it's impossible, or it takes a long time,
1:48:12never gets there, and there's some,
1:48:14there's this huge thing about remittances.
1:48:16This is one thing that Andreessen mentioned,
1:48:17I think it's worth bringing up,
1:48:18is that there is a potential benefit for poor people,
1:48:22for the poorest people in the world,
1:48:23especially immigrants who live in far-flung countries
1:48:25from where other parts of their family live,
1:48:27is there's a huge amount of money extracted when,
1:48:30if you live in America and you're sending money
1:48:32back to Guyana or something,
1:48:34like there's a huge fee that comes out this end,
1:48:37it's not 10%, I think,
1:48:38but it's typically multiple percentage points,
1:48:40And then there's often banks have remittance and other fees.
1:48:43Plus the government may take a chunk as well
1:48:45for incoming money.
1:48:46So just like voiceover IP,
1:48:48at the crackliest like 1200 BPS dial up,
1:48:52you could still get a voiceover it or whatever.
1:48:54Like the minute voiceover IP became a real thing,
1:48:58that changed the relationship
1:48:59between all these far flung people
1:49:02and people were able to talk to their family again.
1:49:03And then Skype video, even at low bandwidth,
1:49:06let them see their families again.
1:49:07And so there's hundreds of billions of dollars in the system that are sucked out each year.
1:49:13Hundreds of billions of dollars are transferred among countries by poor people, essentially,
1:49:17sending money back home. And there is an advantage there. And for anybody in the middle class
1:49:22and above, there's even things like the unbanked and the non-banked, the people who can't—or
1:49:26the—what's the word? Unbanked and less-banked or something. It's people who have a hard
1:49:30time having a bank account because they can't maintain a balance or whatever.
1:49:33because they did live in a neighborhood that doesn't have a bank. Right? That's the push.
1:49:38Yeah, like there's food deserts or bank deserts.
1:49:39There's a push in the US, oh, what's her name, from the great new senator from Massachusetts.
1:49:47Oh, Elizabeth Warren.
1:49:48Yeah, Elizabeth Warren has brought this up, to push, to turn post offices into banks.
1:49:56Let people do simple banking at US post offices, because there is a post office
1:50:02accessible to everybody in, you know, like low-income urban areas.
1:50:07Pete: Yeah, because they're, yeah, and so it's expensive to be poor.
1:50:09Trevor Burrus And the only people opposed to it are existing banks, commercial banks.
1:50:14Pete It's expensive to be poor. This is the horrible thing. If you're the working poor,
1:50:18it's one of the most expensive things, it's one of the most expensive ways of life because you have
1:50:22to go to check cashing outfits to get your money. You charge excessive fees because you don't
1:50:26qualify for the level of things that don't have fees. You pay subprime mortgages, you pay, like,
1:50:31Every part of the system is designed to keep you down.
1:50:34You can say it's unintentional.
1:50:36It may just be systemic.
1:50:37But there's all this predatory action.
1:50:40And--
1:50:40It's actually a fascinating thing.
1:50:42We don't have time to go into it.
1:50:43We've gone long.
1:50:44But the US post office is-- anybody who's curious,
1:50:48Google it and read about it.
1:50:50It's actually pretty clever because it works two ways.
1:50:52One, it would help a lot of people who don't have acts,
1:50:55like you said, underbanked, non-banked people.
1:50:58Two, it would actually help the post office
1:51:00because the post office is self-sufficient financially.
1:51:05They operate on the postage that they sell.
1:51:09Like there's a lot of people who are sort of opposed to the post office,
1:51:12think that they should just go private or whatever,
1:51:15because they think it's sucking up tax money, but it's not.
1:51:19But the problem they're running into is that as the world goes digital,
1:51:22the people are sending less and less mail.
1:51:24And so it's getting harder for them to keep postage rates low
1:51:29and stay in the black. If they got into banking, it would infuse them with funds to be solvent.
1:51:36It's true. You know, the post office, not to get too deep into this, the post office
1:51:42scam is that Congress, even though it's essentially a private agency, run on its own
1:51:47funds, Congress forces them to fund their pension at a level that is so far ahead. The
1:51:53post office required to contribute at a level that's so far ahead of solvency and necessity.
1:51:57No corporation, no other part of government, no steady state or federal is required to
1:52:01fund their pensions the way.
1:52:03And so the post office is actually in better shape than it seems, except it's obligated
1:52:07to put money away that it does not need to.
1:52:09It's the weirdest thing.
1:52:10It's part of the, you know, it's a long-standing political problem.
1:52:14But yeah, it'd be great for the post office.
1:52:15So I don't mean to take us too far afield there, but there are great benefits to something
1:52:19like Bitcoin that relies on, that doesn't rely on using physical pieces of paper or
1:52:24that are designed to extract money at every step.
1:52:27The bars are put in the way not for sensible reasons
1:52:31like reducing fraud or reducing, oh, I don't know,
1:52:34making sure that countries know where money's moving
1:52:37to pay tax, like there's things in place for that.
1:52:39But a lot of the banking system,
1:52:41the private banking system is set up for the purpose
1:52:43of extracting the most fees from the most people.
1:52:45We know this is true 'cause banks make massive profits
1:52:47off typical banking operations.
1:52:50So Bitcoin's potential or things like Bitcoin
1:52:53things like Bitcoin would be to break some of the monopoly of banks holding money. So you know about
1:52:59this thing called Hawala, right? This long-standing transfer system? Okay, so Hawala, and again,
1:53:05we'll go very long enough. Hawala is a system--
1:53:09- How do you spell it?
1:53:10- H-A-W-A-L-A. And I'm sure you've heard about the system. It's not just an Islamic system,
1:53:19but it originated in a lot of Islamic countries. And the idea is that you have people now all
1:53:24around the world, but used to be traders all around these regions, they have account books.
1:53:28And so now, you know, here's what you do. You go to a place, you live in Pakistan, and you say,
1:53:32"I need to get $100 to my brother in Indiana." And the guy goes, "Great." And he writes a thing in
1:53:37his ledger and he has some codes and he calls up the guy who knows Indiana and he says, "Give that
1:53:41guy $100." And that's how it works. And they trust him.
1:53:43And the guy says, "Okay." And he says, "I gave him $100."
1:53:47Yeah, and then they transfer some other—some point there's some reconciliation. Like then
1:53:50that guy in Indiana calls and says, you know, there's somebody in Burundi, oh yeah, and they
1:53:54work it out. It's kind of—
1:53:55Trust in, like a trusted network.
1:53:56Yeah, and it's a lot of people are involved. And I'm sure there's abuse and so forth at times,
1:54:01but it's a system, it's instantaneous money transfer based on, you know, on trust.
1:54:06And presumably there's some sort of fee. Like that it might cost you a hundred and one dollars
1:54:13to send a hundred dollars to the guy in Indiana.
1:54:15Yeah, exactly. But it's, there's no, yeah, the Wikipedia entry is actually very informative,
1:54:21of course, as you'd expect, but the idea is that it's, you know, in communities like that,
1:54:27even when they're spread out across the world, there is a lot of trust because there are huge
1:54:32consequences because they're based on familial relationships or cultural ones. And some countries,
1:54:37there might be, you know, like you might get killed if you violate the system. Other countries,
1:54:40it's not clear if you go to jail or not, but you'd be breaking this, you would never be an
1:54:44outcast for the rest of your life from your entire community, you would never be able
1:54:47to do anything again. So there's a social component to it. But Bitcoin is HAWALA. It's
1:54:51just done cryptographically, so there's no trust in it. You can work with untrusted parties.
1:54:56So there is a model for this. This actually has existed just without the cryptographic
1:55:00component and a lot of people point to HAWALA as something that's a way you bypass banks.
1:55:04You bypass—there are fees, but you bypass all the infrastructure put in place to prevent
1:55:08money from moving around.
1:55:09And as sort of existence proof that the system could work sustainably.
1:55:11Yeah, and if you take trust out of it if the if the flaw and Hawala is that you need enough people who trust each
1:55:17Other absolutely, then you take trust out by using cryptography
1:55:20All right. Let me take one last break. I think our third and final sponsor and it's our good friends at audible
1:55:27Everybody knows audible audible comm
1:55:30Has the largest selection of audiobooks anywhere in the world
1:55:35150,000 titles more
1:55:39every day. They have two ways you could just go there and purchase individual
1:55:49books but for real savings you can sign up for an audible listener program and
1:55:54you get book credits each month for a low monthly fee. If you're the sort of
1:55:59person who loves when the talk show goes long because you've got a long commute
1:56:03or some other area where you just love listening to audio content you have
1:56:07hours to fill Audible with more ebooks than you could, or audio books I should say, than
1:56:16you could ever listen to in your lifetime, you should go there and check them out. They
1:56:20always want, every time they sponsor, they always want the host of the show to make a
1:56:25pick, to pick an interesting book. I have one that I've been reading about halfway through
1:56:33on the advice of my good friend Scott Simpson
1:56:36It's by author named Rich Cohen
1:56:39Cohen and the book is called monsters the 1985 Chicago Bears and the wild heart of football
1:56:48Ostensibly, it's a look back. It was just written. It was just released. I think about a month ago
1:56:53Maybe six weeks ago
1:56:55So it's a new book looking back at the 1985 Bears anybody who grew up in the 80s you remember the 1985 Bears
1:57:01They won the Super Bowl, but that whatever it was more than just a football team
1:57:05That was the team that had the Super Bowl shuffle remember that Glenn. Oh
1:57:08Yeah, that was that great out
1:57:11They had a video that was like it was like the number one video on MTV they were
1:57:15The they made it during this season
1:57:18Had would they had William the refrigerator Perry? He was like a
1:57:23375 pound defensive guy who they would bring it
1:57:26Bring in and give him handoffs when they needed one yard because he was just so big he could never fail not to get one yard
1:57:33huge number of colorful characters just I mean it was it was almost like that the
1:57:391985 Bears were almost like the the World Wrestling Federation
1:57:43brought to
1:57:45legitimate sports
1:57:47And it's not a special thing about this book. It's not a sports sports book. It's sort of a a
1:57:54sports as pop culture book
1:57:56And again, if you guys anybody who knows Scott Simpson follow his Twitter or whatever, you know, he's not a sports head
1:58:03My wife's reading it too not a football fan and really enjoying the book
1:58:09Really really interesting book and and it's it's just one of those things where I was 12 when 85 bears were around and it's I
1:58:16Just took him for granted but in hindsight and reading the book. It's like it's just you just
1:58:22Recall what an oddball crazy-ass team that they were and they were also
1:58:27Tremendously successful. So that's my recommendation. They've got the unabridged version of it on audible. Check it out
1:58:34monsters by Rich Cohen and
1:58:37Just in general, where do you go to find out more about?
1:58:42Audible if you want to listen to audiobooks, here's where you go. The URL is audible
1:58:49podcast.com
1:58:52the talk show audible podcast comm slash the talk show and then they'll know you got there from
1:58:59From this podcast so my thanks to audible check them out if you like books
1:59:03Here one last thing I thought we could talk about before we sign off is the whole go-to fail
1:59:10situation which is
1:59:13Interesting in and of itself because it's a really I mean that you know all security updates and security problems in the popular
1:59:20OS are important, but this is a pretty bad one. And it's also so just, it would be bad
1:59:27no matter what the actual nature of the bug was. But the fact that the nature of the bug
1:59:33was a superfluous line of code that said "go to fail" is almost unimaginably, it's just
1:59:43too neat, right? Like if you put that in a movie, you'd be like, "Oh, come on. Go to
1:59:47fail."
1:59:48Well, yeah, I, it's funny, my initial reaction was this is absolutely a plant, right?
1:59:55And Marco Arman asked the good question, which was if an Apple employee, I don't know if
2:00:01he asked it exactly this way, but this is my version of it is, if an Apple employee
2:00:04were suborned, let's say they were not a plant, they weren't hired by the NSA to become
2:00:08an Apple employee and whatever, but you're the NSA, you go to, you knock on the door
2:00:12one night, you open your door like, "Hi, I'm with the government, here's my whatever,
2:00:14you can check on my credentials, we need to talk."
2:00:17you can't tell anyone about this because that would be a national security violation, you would go to jail for a huge amount of time. It's a huge felony. In fact, you might actually be remanded or, you know, God knows what. Like, I don't even, not like American citizens are disappeared, but more like, there are rules now that we don't totally understand about under which people are charged in which the information does not become public. Right. So, someone comes and says, whatever, you need to put a line of code and we've analyzed this, and you can't tell anybody at work. And if it comes up, you know, maybe you'd be fired. That's your problem. Whatever. Right?
2:00:46Like, that is not an implausible scenario for how that happened, right?
2:00:51I've heard, I mean, I shouldn't say heard, but I've read, and again, you know, a lot of this is
2:00:57speculation, I mean, how are we going to prove it? But what I've read is that the way that the NSA
2:01:01goes about this, and that it's sort of an open secret, is that it's not so much threatening,
2:01:07and it's not so much like, you're going to do this or you want to, but that it's an appeal to
2:01:13patriotism and that they identify people within companies who, you know, and now how do they
2:01:20identify them? I don't know, but that they do. And who knows? Maybe, you know, in the
2:01:25modern era, you know, a lot of that could come out of Facebook and Twitter, you know,
2:01:33social networking where they, or, you know, somehow see what their interests are and try
2:01:37to identify people who are going to have a sort of pro law enforcement or pro NSA mindset.
2:01:46Pete: Oh, that's interesting.
2:01:47And that they appeal to them on a patriotic basis and that it's, that there's really no coercion.
2:01:53I mean, I think maybe the only part that's coercive is probably the,
2:01:56you, you, you know, we'd like to talk to you and you can't tell anybody about this conversation.
2:02:00And so that part is, you know, you can't, but -
2:02:05- A lot of people would obey that because they'd be like,
2:02:07"All right, just for them talking to me,
2:02:09"I'm not gonna make a stand."
2:02:10I mean, they'd find people who are not libertarian
2:02:12or extreme liberal. - It seems like it would be
2:02:13very tricky though for the NSA's point,
2:02:15but it makes sense to me that this is how it works,
2:02:16that they appeal to their patriotism and say,
2:02:18"Here's what we would like you to do,
2:02:19"and here's why it would help your country.
2:02:22"Here's what would be able to, you know, you do this,
2:02:27"it will help us because we'll be able to use it
2:02:29"to identify bad guys who are planning bad things
2:02:34to do in the US.
2:02:36Although, I thought that was-- initially, I thought
2:02:39that seemed more likely.
2:02:40But as it's come out, I feel like--
2:02:43and actually, Marco and his gang talked about it
2:02:46on Accidental Tech podcast quite a bit, too,
2:02:48is that it doesn't pass the smell test
2:02:51in that this particular flaw was probably a mistake,
2:02:56because for two reasons.
2:02:58One is it's extremely broad.
2:02:59Once you know about it, you can exploit it, and anyone can,
2:03:02any government in the world.
2:03:03So the NSA doesn't get it exclusively
2:03:06and that seems like a big deal.
2:03:08And Steven Belevin, if you go to his blog,
2:03:11it's a long name, but Steven Belevin, B-E-L-L-O-V-I-N.
2:03:14He was the, he was a longtime computer science professor,
2:03:18teacher, he's responsible for, I'm blanking on the tool,
2:03:21he created one of the early tools that we used to use
2:03:24on Unix systems in the early internet days
2:03:26to scan for stuff.
2:03:27He's a really smart encryption guy, very well respected.
2:03:30He was the head of the FTCs,
2:03:31as chief technology officer, chief technologist
2:03:34for a year recently.
2:03:35And he said, "You know, the problem with assuming
2:03:38the NSA did this is it's just too clumsy,
2:03:40it's too easy to spot, you know?
2:03:41Once you find it, it's gone and anyone else could get to it."
2:03:43He said, "What's much more likely,"
2:03:45and this is why I kind of err on the idea
2:03:47that it was just an error, maybe merging trees or something,
2:03:52is that it's such a weird thing and it's so untested,
2:03:56which is why it wasn't spotted.
2:03:58So remember, this has been misrepresented.
2:04:01It's not that it validates a certificate incorrectly.
2:04:04Bad certificates fail.
2:04:06The problem is that once you validate a certificate,
2:04:08it doesn't validate that the key for the session
2:04:12was signed by that certificate.
2:04:13So the key can be from any party.
2:04:17So you're an interloper and you pass along
2:04:20all the certificate stuff and everyone's happy with that.
2:04:22Then you just send a key signed by something else
2:04:24and the key goes through.
2:04:25That's a very weird exploit.
2:04:29It's very effective if you wanna use it
2:04:30'cause you could see how quickly people came up with proofs
2:04:33to show you the problem.
2:04:35But his thing was, so Belivin's thing,
2:04:36which makes a lot of sense,
2:04:37is if the NSA does something like this,
2:04:39they put in some weird random number thing,
2:04:41they tinkered with something so that they only,
2:04:42they're the only ones who know the number that triggers it,
2:04:45and you can't figure it out unless you do some deep analysis
2:04:48where you figure out there's actually a flaw
2:04:49in the degree of entropy or whatever.
2:04:51So one key will work and they know the key
2:04:54or one set of numbers will work.
2:04:54- Right, it's more like they put in a backdoor
2:04:56that they have the key to,
2:04:57not that they would put in a backdoor
2:04:59that doesn't have a working lock.
2:05:01- 'Cause it seems they don't want everyone,
2:05:03I mean, you know, I do actually believe that their mission,
2:05:06I think from their standpoint,
2:05:07their mission is not just to,
2:05:09it's both offensive and defensive,
2:05:11it's like they may want back doors,
2:05:12but they don't want every other government
2:05:14to have access to the back doors.
2:05:15So something like this would seem to fail.
2:05:17- So I, yeah, I don't think that the go-to fail bug
2:05:20in Apple's SSL code was planted by the NSA
2:05:25or by an NSA mall.
2:05:27I do think that it's very likely that they do have moles.
2:05:31I don't think this is one.
2:05:32Because it's like you said--
2:05:33- I think that you think they exploited it.
2:05:35- I do think that they--
2:05:36- Yeah, that seems very likely.
2:05:37- And so you said, and like the other, you know,
2:05:39it's the sort of bug when you look at the source code
2:05:41where if you're not looking for bugs,
2:05:43it's really, I can see how you overlook it.
2:05:45And it's again, like I blogged about when I wrote about it
2:05:48that not to get in an argument about C coding style,
2:05:51but it's why I think that the no braces if statement,
2:05:55The basic gist of if statements in C is if you say if this, then, if there's only one
2:06:02statement, you don't need to wrap it in curly braces.
2:06:05And if there's more than one, then you have to put curly braces to begin and end the block
2:06:08of what's going to happen if that conditional is true.
2:06:12And I've always felt, having been bitten by that laziness and, "Oh, I'm only going to
2:06:17do one thing," but you indent it and then you come back to the code a week, two weeks
2:06:22later and you've you just quick hit return your text editor auto indents and
2:06:29you write the next line mm-hmm it's easy to make that bug and once the bug is in
2:06:34there it's easy to overlook it but if you're looking for bugs that really
2:06:40jumps out the go-to go-to everybody like when it when this came out everybody who
2:06:44can program even a little bit is like whoa how would that ever get in there
2:06:48Like if you're actually looking for a bug, it's glaring.
2:06:51There's nothing clever about it.
2:06:52- Yeah, no one reviewed,
2:06:53if an auto-merge tool created this problem,
2:06:56no one looked at the result.
2:06:57- Yeah, and that's the thing.
2:06:59It's like an Occam's razor argument
2:07:01where that's the sort of thing that happens
2:07:04from a diff gone bad, you know,
2:07:06that when a merge, you know,
2:07:09the diff tool gets confused by the two versions
2:07:14it's trying to merge together.
2:07:15A lot of times you'll get a duplicate line like that.
2:07:19And it just so happens.
2:07:20But I do think, I do think, and it's just based on the way
2:07:23Apple wrote the bug up and the way that they fixed it
2:07:28days before, or shortly, not days before,
2:07:32but a week or two, iOS 7.1 was gonna come out anyway.
2:07:37I really do think, I think that Apple found it in an audit
2:07:42and figured out that it explains
2:07:45how the NSA was claiming to do what they were doing.
2:07:50- Well, the timing is, that timing is suspicious.
2:07:52They're like, "You see the PowerPoint thing?
2:07:55"Apple says we are gonna go through every line of the code."
2:07:58This is what, you remember that Microsoft did this.
2:07:59One of the reasons that Vista
2:08:00actually had a superior security model to Windows XP
2:08:05was not time, it was because Bill Gates,
2:08:09he halted everything the company was doing for months
2:08:12to go through an audit and it worked
2:08:13because Windows Vista was much more secure.
2:08:15A lot of the XP stuff--
2:08:17- Yeah, has been ever since.
2:08:18- Yeah, and it's actually outpaces Apple typically
2:08:21and it's why that one of the reasons that exploits
2:08:24have moved to applications and weak points like Flash
2:08:27and things like that because Windows is more secure.
2:08:29So, and so here's another bit of timing
2:08:32which is interesting as well as researchers just found,
2:08:35I think it's like while we're recording this
2:08:37that like there's another cryptographic flaw
2:08:40that can be exploited that involves client certificates
2:08:43and SSL/TLS transactions.
2:08:45So if you connect to a web server
2:08:47and you have a client certificate,
2:08:49which most people do not,
2:08:51you get issued a client certificate
2:08:53when you log in in a specific way.
2:08:55So like a normal transaction,
2:08:57you just go and you get the server's certificate
2:08:59and your browser validates that it's accurate
2:09:01and you make a secure connection.
2:09:03But if you get issued one that's stored in your browser,
2:09:06that certificate can apparently be reused by other people.
2:09:10And it lets that user be impersonated.
2:09:13Things like any other website
2:09:14in which the same certificate's used,
2:09:16they can use that certificate to impersonate you.
2:09:21- What system has this bug?
2:09:24- It's everything, it's actually a flaw.
2:09:26I know, it's horrible.
2:09:27It's a protocol layer flaw
2:09:29that apparently will not be difficult to fix,
2:09:31but then it's gotta be rolled out.
2:09:33But the deal is that there are only specific cases
2:09:36in which a client certificate's used.
2:09:38So some kinds of WiFi login things
2:09:40where you type in a username and password
2:09:43to log in over WiFi through,
2:09:45it's called 802.1X,
2:09:48all those systems that are used in corporations.
2:09:49So they've got a flaw.
2:09:50So it's not like a general problem, I'm using my bank,
2:09:53but it's in the cases, especially in the enterprise
2:09:56where you might be out in the wild,
2:09:57you're making a secure connection,
2:09:58you're using a client certificate,
2:10:00there actually is the opportunity
2:10:01for malicious interception in a way that would let
2:10:05that man in the middle use your credentials elsewhere.
2:10:09And so a lot of enterprise software will need to get fixed
2:10:12as well as web servers just to be on the safe side.
2:10:15But the enterprise people will probably be on it
2:10:17pretty fast, but it's weird.
2:10:18It's again, you're like, did somebody in all the NSA stuff
2:10:21that got released, did someone notice,
2:10:23hey, it seems like they have a way to do something
2:10:25that seems to be implying client certificates.
2:10:27Maybe we should go back through the protocol
2:10:28and then boom, something that dates back to,
2:10:31I think they're saying 2005,
2:10:32it affects the entire protocol.
2:10:34- Right, I know there's a lot of people out there
2:10:36who really do think that these big companies
2:10:38are all in cahoots that when the NSA came knocking
2:10:40and said, "Can we come in your data center?"
2:10:42They said, "Sure, come on in, do it however you want."
2:10:45And there's no way to disprove it, right?
2:10:48And it's good, in some sense, it's good
2:10:50that there's some people who are skeptical like that, right?
2:10:52But I don't think it's true.
2:10:54I actually take these companies at their words
2:10:57when they say things like,
2:10:58no, we did not allow the NSA physically into our data center.
2:11:05And the main reason why-- and it's not just Apple,
2:11:07I believe all of these companies--
2:11:09is that it's not in their interest to lie about it.
2:11:12If they had done it, they could just say nothing.
2:11:16And they could even say, we're not even allowed to say--
2:11:19we can't answer yes or no.
2:11:20They could just say that and then leave it at that.
2:11:24But by saying, by denying it, if they're lying about that, it opens them up to a profound
2:11:32and tremendous loss of trust, if it ever turns out otherwise. And as we've seen with the Snowden
2:11:38thing, anything can leak. Just because the NSA says you can lie about it, well, you can trust us.
2:11:44You can't trust them to have a mistaken leak. So I just don't see why anybody would lie about it.
2:11:51I really don't. And I think it makes sense with what we're seeing uncovered is what they've done
2:11:55is said, "Okay, we didn't let them do this. They say they can do it." How is that even possible?
2:12:01What do we need to audit to see that it would be possible for them to do it behind our backs,
2:12:07without our help, to do this?
2:12:09Pete: I think that's most likely because, you know, if you've got the NSA, what they did,
2:12:14clearly, and what, you know, and it's funny, it's like, as much as I may dislike aspects of what
2:12:18did, this is kind of, this is what they've been tasked with doing is they went through to find
2:12:22all the flaws. And like, in an ideal world, what would have happened is the NSA would have found
2:12:26flaws and then they would have gone through and worked privately with every American company
2:12:31to replace them and eventually stuff would have trickled out. Like, something like that. That
2:12:34actually would have been a really great cyber strategy was to not implement flaws, but to be
2:12:39working assiduously to find them, maybe exploit them at times, but also be working to repair them
2:12:44because that would actually be good for the country
2:12:47and for national security.
2:12:49- What do you make of the one
2:12:50that just came out the other day?
2:12:51I forget if it was yesterday or the day before
2:12:53where it was a very similar bug to Apple's,
2:12:56but in GNU code.
2:12:58- Oh, that's the way, and this is another TLS thing, right?
2:13:02I don't even, see, I missed that.
2:13:04I saw the client certificate one.
2:13:05God, what is this one?
2:13:07You know that people are looking at--
2:13:11- It's oddly similar. - So much more carefully.
2:13:14This is the thing that makes me wonder, though, about a mole,
2:13:16because it's oddly similar to Apple's book.
2:13:19It even involves go-to statements.
2:13:21- That's funny.
2:13:24- But it's a lot, it's, looking at the code,
2:13:28it's a lot more subtle, though.
2:13:29It's not as glaring as one go-to.
2:13:31- Oh yeah, this is, you could create, yeah,
2:13:32this is, you could create a certificate
2:13:34that would be accepted, even though it shouldn't be.
2:13:37Gosh, it's funny.
2:13:39Yeah, I mean, I think what it comes down to
2:13:41is that there may be--
2:13:43The GNU one seems really bad to me because the Apple one,
2:13:47I forget how many people have already upgraded to 7.0,
2:13:50iOS devices are already on 7.0.6,
2:13:53but it was one of those web ad networks
2:13:56showed that something like 40% of iOS devices
2:14:00were already on 7.0.6.
2:14:02It's just a tremendous uptake.
2:14:04Whereas so much stuff is like embedded systems and routers
2:14:11and all these things that don't get software updates
2:14:14are running this GNU code.
2:14:16- Well, the GNU thing, the fortunate thing is
2:14:18that I don't think--
2:14:20- They're gonna run that code until the,
2:14:22until the Howard, you know, the AC adapter burns out.
2:14:26- It's true, but the GNU one, like the fundamental one
2:14:31that was just found too, is it has to do with,
2:14:33if I'm reading it right, is client certificate.
2:14:35So it's only in specific cases where like a server,
2:14:39In this case, like the GNU, when a server would accept
2:14:42a certificate, it should not.
2:14:45So you could attack a site if it was running GNU
2:14:47and you knew it.
2:14:48So it's asymmetrical in that there's fewer servers
2:14:51to update than embedded Linux devices.
2:14:53And the same thing like client,
2:14:55the client certificate flaw,
2:14:56like that can be fixed in a few different ways.
2:14:58The Apple one is particularly horrible
2:15:00because you could have any point of interception though.
2:15:03Like you could create a fake session key
2:15:06by being a man in the middle.
2:15:07You could have put software in a router,
2:15:08you know, there's routers are corrupted like mad, there's hundreds of thousands of
2:15:12or, you know, or if you presume that the NSA while they don't have access to Apple's data
2:15:17center, or Google's, let's say, but let's say Apple, because Apple has written this
2:15:21the TLS bug, so they're not in Apple's building at all. But if they're anywhere on the internet
2:15:28backbone between the remote device, like that, it's exactly your iPhone and Apple's data
2:15:37center. Anywhere in that backbone in between this bug opens it up for them to, you know, be a, it's
2:15:44like a classic man in the middle attack.
2:15:46Right. And you could do it on a countrywide basis. If you're Iraq, someone with an Apple device, I
2:15:50don't know if they're allowed to be used in Iraq or Iran or whatever, you could, you know, there
2:15:53have been countrywide attacks.
2:15:56Well, or think about how centralized the internet is in China.
2:15:58Yeah, exactly. Right. So this is this is one of these things. It's like, it's not a back,
2:16:02you know, again, I don't, I think assuming it was an error,
2:16:06it's just weird.
2:16:09I think what this highlights,
2:16:10and I think what's gonna happen is you're gonna see
2:16:11a lot more bizarre testing.
2:16:14I'm surprised that TLS implementations
2:16:17aren't more thoroughly tested against certain things.
2:16:19Like the idea that a hacker could create
2:16:21a malformed client certificate of a certain type,
2:16:25like that's one weird thing.
2:16:26Like you can't test every kind of client certificate,
2:16:28but Apple's one in particular, it's like,
2:16:30I would have thought the test suite
2:16:32would have checked to make sure that when you sent it
2:16:35a session key that wasn't signed by the same certificate,
2:16:38that it failed because they test for like self-signed
2:16:40certificates, they test for lots of kinds of failures.
2:16:43And someone asked on Twitter even, Chris Pepper,
2:16:45you know the great Chris Pepper proofreader
2:16:47and an extraordinary programmer, Chris was like,
2:16:50"Well, shouldn't this have made all self-signed
2:16:52"certificates pass the test?"
2:16:55I was like, "No, it's later in the process."
2:16:56But that was a good point is if this had been a flaw
2:16:59in the certificate validation, tons of programmers
2:17:01have said, "Why did my self-signed certificate not generate an error there and require signing
2:17:05or approval?" So this one was at just the point at which most people who test this kind
2:17:12of thing or work with security didn't see it. And that's, like I say, it doesn't
2:17:16make me dubious, but it is why I think it went on unfound for so long. And clearly,
2:17:20they're going to be, I assume, Apple and everyone else in the world will be beefing
2:17:23up the kinds of automated testing they do whenever they make code change libraries and
2:17:27this sort of thing again.
2:17:28Yeah, I definitely think so. I think everybody, like you said, this is what the NSA is tasked
2:17:34with. In some sense, nothing has been surprising with all of the NSA-related leaks. But on
2:17:41the other hand, knowing in the back of your mind that the NSA is doing something like
2:17:48this is different than seeing these slides that say, "Here's exactly what they're doing."
2:17:55I don't know. It somehow is like a jolt to everybody's system and I don't think there's any doubt that
2:18:00You know for better or for worse and I'll even you know
2:18:04I'll play both sides of the coin here and say, you know, there's obviously there could be some downsides to this, you know
2:18:09In general, I I think that it's good news that we've woken up to this but you know, who knows maybe you know in terms of
2:18:16Actually doing what the NSA is tasked with doing and actually finding
2:18:20Genuine bad guys planning
2:18:22genuinely bad
2:18:25things that this has made their job a lot more difficult because it's close it's gonna end up in a closing an awful lot of
2:18:30These back doors. Well, yeah. Yeah, there's there's that standpoint. There's also they're like I wish the NSA there's it's widely stated by many parties that
2:18:38countries like, you know Israel France
2:18:40China and so forth like even allies that they're that there's back doors and equipment made by tons of Israeli companies that make stuff that
2:18:48Make networking equipment. There's this
2:18:51long held and often voiced suspicion that every country builds back doors into stuff that ships out of their countries. Now in America
2:18:58we're seen as being more independent. Israel, even the national security apparatus is more,
2:19:02they have fewer constitutional protections and there's more of a state of siege mentality there.
2:19:08France has a different relationship between business and commerce, you know, corporate espionage is a thing that, or government assisted corporate
2:19:15espionage is a big thing in China. So
2:19:17what I wish the NSA were doing was
2:19:20constantly working to find, report, and release information about these kinds of flaws that affect American companies or companies around the world
2:19:28that are in products that are shipping that we're using. Like that would be a better use of resources at some level to
2:19:33secure America, you know, on top of their mission of, you know, finding the flaws and exploiting them.
2:19:38I don't know. It's... that would have more impact on business to not have, you know,
2:19:42Boeing's plans ripped off or Google's servers broken into. I think they do some of that.
2:19:48There's some parts of government do some of that, but...
2:19:50Well, that's a good point to wrap up. Glenn, that was a great show. I appreciate your time.
2:19:56What do you want to promote? What do you want to tell people to check out to find you? Because
2:20:00if you need more Glenn Fleischman, don't follow him on Twitter. Whatever you do,
2:20:04don't follow this guy on Twitter.
2:20:06Oh my god, it's like a curse. I think people, if you're bad in life, you're required to follow
2:20:11me and then read all my tweets. Well, the magazine's book is actually, it's at The Printers Now,
2:20:16and it's gonna be shipping soon.
2:20:17And the ebook version is more or less done.
2:20:20And we've released the PDF form of that to backers
2:20:22and we're finishing our other ebook flavors.
2:20:24- What's the print run?
2:20:25- The print run is about 1500.
2:20:27Making a small print run, we have about 1150, 1200
2:20:30committed to backers and other people.
2:20:32And you can go to the-magazine.com/book
2:20:36and pre-order a copy of either the ebook
2:20:39or the print book or a bundle.
2:20:42And we're gonna be shipping out books probably,
2:20:45gosh, I hope within a week or ten days the books will actually be in some people's hands,
2:20:49because it's the future and books get printed fast. Not only is digital fast,
2:20:53but books get printed fast. And it's very exciting. It's got white foil embossing on
2:21:00the spine and things like that.
2:21:01Exciting. So, it looks good?
2:21:03Yeah, I've seen all the proofs. I've got color proofs and jacket proofs and it's gonna be,
2:21:07it's gonna be a really nice book and good stories and it'll be something to cherish for generations.
2:21:15No, it'll be nice. It'll be great. It's what I was hoping is we're going to have a really nice
2:21:18We did we try to do everything right so the print version would really be something that was a keepsake and
2:21:23It'll be something you would actually enjoy having a copy of as a thing as well as all the stories inside
2:21:28And I feel like we're gonna we've hit that mark a year or two. I tweeted something to the effect of
2:21:33Oh my god, you guys there's a store here
2:21:36There's a huge store here filled with nothing but shelves of printed out ebooks
2:21:42It's amazing and I so many people got it and laugh, but it was probably one of those, you know
2:21:48I probably got more
2:21:51People who totally missed that it was a joke than any tweet I've ever had in my life. Well, here's what's crazy
2:21:57They were like, what's the name of it?
2:21:59Here's the crazy thing about the modern times, right?
2:22:01We're doing it was actually much easier to get the book printed than to do the e-book part Wow
2:22:05Book part is a mess
2:22:07It's like the book prints, like we send in a PDF and they kill a bunch of trees and squeeze ink cows or something and they make a book.
2:22:15But the electronic part is hard. But what I'm going to wind up doing is we're going to have the hardcover book offset print.
2:22:21We'll have the ebook, which will be 300 pages. The hardcover book is 216. So we have a bigger ebook because we were able to fund that in the Kickstarter.
2:22:29And then I'm also producing a print on demand version that will be a larger size because our hardcover book's format is smaller.
2:22:35I've made a different document in InDesign, that's the ebook version, 302 pages, that
2:22:41will be available print-on-demand because it is so goddamn expensive to ship overseas,
2:22:46but ebooks or print-on-demand are printed locally.
2:22:49So people in Europe and in Canada at least will be able to get, it'll be black and white
2:22:54instead of full color, but they'll be able to get an affordable version of the ebook
2:22:58as a print-on-demand title.
2:22:59So ebooks are much more, like print is incredibly easy now
2:23:04as a, because I don't have to deal with any
2:23:06of the printer stuff, I just give them a PDF.
2:23:08Ebooks, you're like in there like making sausage
2:23:11and your hands are bloody.
2:23:12- So it really isn't a joke anymore though
2:23:13that you can commercially print ebooks.
2:23:16- It's true, it's like--
2:23:17- And then it's a different industry than printed books.
2:23:20- There's different chains of command,
2:23:21but it's like, it is, no, I'm printing, that's right,
2:23:22I'm printing my ebook, it's all, yeah.
2:23:26It's a weird world in which having giant chunks of paper wrapped and printed is easier than ebooks,
2:23:32but that is the world we live in.
2:23:34Well, I'm glad to hear it, and I look forward to seeing it.
2:23:36Thank you.
2:23:36All right. Thank you, Glenn.
2:23:38Pleasure.