0:00:00I have a question. This is the type of thing. This is why I need to hire a staff because
0:00:04if I had a staff, I wouldn't have to ask you this.
0:00:07Okay.
0:00:08But it's a protocol question. I want to get the protocol. You know, like when you
0:00:11meet the Queen of England, there's a, it's a very complicated protocol. Well, I want
0:00:14to get this protocol right now. Do I introduce you as Jeopardy champion Glenn Fleischmann
0:00:19or do I introduce you as two-time Jeopardy champion Glenn Fleischmann?
0:00:23I think, I think just Jeopardy champion because otherwise it's bragging.
0:00:27Ah, gotcha. All right.
0:00:28'Cause it's okay to win, but then you're sort of rubbing it in someone's nose.
0:00:31What's fun is I think I threaded the needle neatly, 'cause I think I was a pretty good player,
0:00:36not a fantastic player, but I was between two seven-day champions, it turned out.
0:00:40So I met both of them. I met the outgoing one who lost just before I did, and I met the incoming
0:00:44one who won just after I did. And I think both of them would have completely cleaned my clock,
0:00:49because they had superb buzzer timing and some better domain knowledge that plays in Jeopardy.
0:00:55So I got very lucky, I think.
0:00:56Wait, but did you beat the seven,
0:00:58are you the one who knocked
0:00:59the incoming seven-time champion off though?
0:01:02- No, this is what was perfect.
0:01:04Stephanie Yoss lost because, see I have another name,
0:01:07so it's like a little family.
0:01:08So she won, she comes in, we get in there,
0:01:11I'm there on a Tuesday and Wednesday for taping.
0:01:12So I go in Tuesday morning and they're like,
0:01:14"Oh, well welcome Stephanie Yoss,
0:01:15our five-time returning champion."
0:01:17And we all look at each other and go, "Oh shit."
0:01:19Right, like we have to deal with this person.
0:01:22So she plays two games, I tape five games a day.
0:01:24She plays two games.
0:01:25she, the third game she plays, which was not against me, the Final Jeopardy question was
0:01:30ridiculous. And even those of us in the audience, they put all the contestants in the audience
0:01:35afterwards, like we would have gotten it wrong. It was asking for the country that had the largest
0:01:39state that would have been like the sixth largest country in the world if it was a country.
0:01:44And Stephanie wrote like Outer Mongolia, she didn't know. Someone else wrote Uttar Pradesh,
0:01:49which is the correct state. The question was asking for the country. So the winner was sort
0:01:53of a fluke. She won in Final Jeopardy! of India, then I beat this lovely woman named Meredith,
0:01:58then I won twice. Next morning I come back and I won shows four or five that day.
0:02:01Come back the next morning and I lose the first game because I'm just fried. The woman who beat
0:02:06me, she wins one more game and she loses to the next seven-day champion. Keith Whitener,
0:02:11very nice guy also.
0:02:12Gotcha. Yeah, I imagine that it is like a typical power law distribution where everybody,
0:02:19Everybody who gets on the show is good. I mean, it's, you know, the qualifying process is enough
0:02:23that everybody who gets on is pretty good. Even someone who ends up not doing too well in an
0:02:28episode is probably a pretty good, you know, Neighborhood Trivia champion.
0:02:33They winnow a lot. So, right, the people who get there should really be able—I mean,
0:02:36the game mechanics of being, you know, on a stage and sort of confronting with that,
0:02:41that might get you. But yeah, everyone knows, you know, a lot of stuff. So, yeah, so I was with the
0:02:46outliers are the thing. They do a lot of stuff in the game now to prevent people who win from
0:02:51keeping winning by giving them better training. So giving a new contestant better training. So
0:02:56we get there's more rehearsal, there's more buzzer practice and all that. And that's leveled things
0:03:00out since Ken Jennings. But I was between two people who wound up being the number 14 and
0:03:05number 15 all time money winners on Jeopardy. Right.
0:03:08- Which is a long history.
0:03:10- It's right. They used to give away a lot less money, but they didn't give away a lot of money
0:03:14for a long time. So I'm not, you know, I'm like the number 220th all-time winner out of every
0:03:19people. I'm happy with it. It's because they give away more money. So even in a basic game,
0:03:23one more. But like, so I was between two outliers. Like these people are actually, you know, 97th,
0:03:2899th percent Jeopardy players. And I'm like 85th percent Jeopardy player or 80th percent. So I'm
0:03:34like, this is okay. I want some money. I'm happy. But it was, it was funny. It was funny. And they're
0:03:38both nice people too. And they'll be back for Tournament of Champions. So you gotta watch them
0:03:42them kill each other. How many do you have to win five to get on tournament champions?
0:03:45Three, but then there's a threshold of money and at this point someone keeps a tally of it. Looks
0:03:49like you have to win at least $50,000. It was minimum three games, but at least $50,000 now
0:03:54to get in given how well people have done. So it'll be a pretty fierce competition, I think.
0:04:01For the all-time rankings, they should inflation adjust it. And it's,
0:04:04because I think what they did is they doubled the money at some point in the last 10 years.
0:04:09Yeah, they've done it twice. Art Fleming was one thing, and they came and brought the
0:04:12series back. And I think it used to be like, I don't know, the top money you could win.
0:04:17It was hard to win more than several thousand dollars.
0:04:18But there's a baseline.
0:04:19And now people routinely, yeah.
0:04:20The baseline, let's just call it X, is the first round, you know, now what is it, like
0:04:27200 bucks? It used to be $100 on the Alex Trebek one. But that should just be called
0:04:31X, and then whatever you win has to be a multiple of X.
0:04:35I agree, because then it's right. It's sort of like movie earnings, too. Is Snow
0:04:41or Sleeping Beauty or, I don't know, Fantasia? There's some movie that was—it's still
0:04:45current dollars, some billions of dollars it made.
0:04:47It might be Gone with the Wind, I think.
0:04:49It's one of those, "Gone with the Wind! That cost me thousands of dollars in Jeopardy!"
0:04:54No! It's the final Jeopardy question I missed.
0:04:57I think it might be—I'm not trying to torment you here, but I do—I believe that
0:05:00inflation adjusted if you just count tickets sold. Instead of counting dollars, just count
0:05:05how many people put their butts in the seat to see the theater. I think it was gone with
0:05:09the wind.
0:05:10No, I think that's it. So you look at prices of stamps, you look at gasoline, and people
0:05:13are like, "Stamps cost a ridiculous amount." It's like, "No, just for inflation, postage
0:05:17is the cheapest it's been practically since Benjamin Franklin," or whatever. And gasoline
0:05:21is actually, it's expensive, but it's not that expensive compared to the 1970s right
0:05:25now. I just paid $3.69. So yeah, people don't like math.
0:05:29Yeah. And well, the thing with the movies is that the movie industry is such a cutthroat,
0:05:33I'm on top right now thing that nobody has any interest in remembering how popular Jaws
0:05:39was, right? It's really just, you know, like whatever was the most popular movie of the
0:05:43last six months is really all that matters and that's all anybody wants to promote. But
0:05:47it's like if you look back and see that Jaws grossed $300 million or $175 million or whatever,
0:05:54but then realize that first run movie tickets were like a buck fifty, it's, you know, it's
0:05:59ridiculous.
0:06:00I remember when I paid, I went to the first THX sound movie that I ever went to was Robocop.
0:06:06They just opened a new theater in Eugene, Oregon. And I paid, oh, I don't know, it seemed like a
0:06:09crazy amount. Was it $5 in 1984 or something? It seemed obscene. Or was it $4.50? And I was like,
0:06:16oh my God, it was, then, you know, I just went and paid $11 in something. And I think that's actually
0:06:20cheap in inflationary terms relative to what I paid for that.
0:06:23I do. It's a rite of passage in the United States that eventually it's when you become
0:06:30a full-fledged adult is when you're outraged by the price of a movie ticket.
0:06:34That's right.
0:06:35Right? And I remember being a teenager and hearing my dad complain about movie ticket prices. And I
0:06:40just remember thinking, "Well, that's just proof that you're an old man. You're out of touch." Now
0:06:44it's my turn.
0:06:45I was trying to explain inflation to my kids, my five-year-old and eight-year-old, and they can
0:06:49sort of get some of it. And I had this experience not that long ago. So the oatmeal guy does that
0:06:54cartoon. He raised over $200,000 despite a douchebag who was suing him over something
0:06:58that was ridiculous. And he lives in town. I said, "Oh, I talked to my Boing Boing editor."
0:07:02I'm like, "Can I go cover this?" And sure. So I call a fellow who does oatmeal, a really nice guy,
0:07:07and Matthew. And he's like, "Yeah, come on down." And so it's me and him and this friend of his
0:07:12who's packing some heat, he's got a license, and helped him pick up the money. And his girlfriend
0:07:16and his mother. His mother does all his packaging, like sends all the mugs out and the t-shirts up
0:07:22from a small town in Washington. So we're in this room with like hundreds of thousands of dollars.
0:07:25Like, "Hey, you want to help?" I'm like, "Sure." And so I'm handling, you know, it's like drug
0:07:29money. It's like these big bundles of $20. And you don't understand how truly ridiculous money is.
0:07:34- Why was it in cash?
0:07:36- He wanted to take, he spelled out F-U and douchebag in cash to send to this lawyer. He
0:07:43said, "I'm going to take pictures of this money that I raised that I'm sending to charity." So
0:07:46So he took it all to the bank, made pictures out of it, just put it on the floor in bundles,
0:07:51took pictures, and then put the money back in the bank and dispersed it to the charities.
0:07:55And it was just a big FU.
0:07:58But you handle cash, and the absurdity of money as a system, a very symbolic part of
0:08:03our economy, is even worse when you handle large amounts of it.
0:08:07It doesn't matter if it's yours or not.
0:08:08You're looking at it, you're like, "What does this mean?
0:08:10It's all this printed paper.
0:08:12This is a huge amount of cash, and it just seems even more absurd than it already is.
0:08:18You would really do, though.
0:08:19I've met you several times at conferences.
0:08:22You instantly come across as a very trustworthy man.
0:08:25Like, I'm not surprised.
0:08:27I don't think that if I had been writing that story, I don't think I would have been
0:08:30invited to help count the cash.
0:08:32It was very nice.
0:08:33I had his friend there.
0:08:34He's packing.
0:08:35I'd met him before, but still, we weren't great buddies or anything.
0:08:37He's a good guy.
0:08:38And I was like, "This is, you know, like we're in a small room, whatever.
0:08:41It's awfully nice that you trust that I'm gonna
0:08:43Hundreds of thousands of dollars in my hands, right? I've had that experience
0:08:48Secondhand like just not with what was in my hands, but watching other people were in casinos where?
0:08:55Like I've gone by the high limit baccarat rooms and
0:09:01Like it Bellagio and you can just look in and see and you see that guys are playing with yellow chips and yellow chips are
0:09:0825,000 each and they're just putting out stacks of them. I mean, I don't you know to the point where you can't even
0:09:13Clearly count them, you know where it's easily 25 30 35 thousand dollars a bet and then I just think well
0:09:21That's that to me is an insane. I would die would die of a heart. I like to gamble
0:09:26I you know, I'm not averse to gambling but if I had
0:09:29$35,000 in front of me on a play of cards, I would have a heart attack and die
0:09:35Well, here's the thing. We can do a callback now, which is some there on Jeopardy! And
0:09:39I'm like, "I'm going to bet everything. I'm going to come push my ships all in."
0:09:42I bet $5,000. But I had this great conversation with an IBM scientist recently who had worked
0:09:48on the Watson team that won at Jeopardy! in 2011. And there's all this discussion about
0:09:54the natural language processing that Watson did. And they had like, dozens of scientists
0:09:58worked on this for four years. I mean, IBM put millions and millions of dollars for the
0:10:02the staff time in addition to tens or hundreds of millions of computer resources because
0:10:07they have all these interesting things they're going to do with it now. But they thought
0:10:11Jeopardy was the right challenge. It makes a big splash. It's good marketing, but it's
0:10:14a great challenge, right?
0:10:15So natural language processing, it was astonishing that it did as well as it did. But he was
0:10:19working on the wagering side of it.
0:10:21Right.
0:10:22And how you—so they would take the output, like the question would come—or the clue
0:10:25would come up, the subsystems that did all that would, you know, incredibly rapidly have
0:10:30to process it before it rang in, it would produce a confidence score instantly and keep
0:10:34refining it. I mean, it was constantly processing. And the confidence score would let it choose
0:10:39whether to wager. And then it also was used to pick which the daily doubles might be under
0:10:45because they placed them not—it's not even pseudo-random, they're placed traditionally
0:10:49in certain places, and so you can predict them. And so by their wagering simulation
0:10:55of other players to test the system
0:10:57and pre-selecting where using Bayesian analysis
0:11:01and other things where the daily double square might be,
0:11:04they dramatically improved the odds of winning.
0:11:06And so the natural language processing was very impressive,
0:11:09but the wagering part was actually,
0:11:11they did all these Monte Carlo simulations.
0:11:12They're like, we don't believe the average Jeopardy player
0:11:15will be familiar with the, what's the guy,
0:11:17the John, the movie about a fellow who is mentally ill,
0:11:23made the movie about the statistician, mathematician.
0:11:25I like that I think of that.
0:11:26I know what you mean. It was a Ron Howard movie.
0:11:29Yeah, so we don't think that every Jeopardy player is going to have Monte Carlo simulations
0:11:33running in their head. But all the simulation of wagering and strategy by other people,
0:11:38by analyzing the archive of all the wagers and decisions people have made throughout the entire
0:11:43history of Jeopardy, affected it. And they made weird bets, like on Daily Doubles,
0:11:48Wats made weird bets. And I'm like, I read this paper and I said, oh, I would change my strategy.
0:11:52and the scientists said, this guy, Gerald Sorrow, said he'd worked previously in backgammon and
0:11:57making backgammon simulations that could win or systems that could beat human players. And he said,
0:12:04in every game, like chess, backgammon, bridge, whatever, which the computers finally improve on
0:12:10and can beat the masters in the games, people start playing the game differently because they
0:12:14understand that the way they're playing it isn't as efficient and doesn't have the same odds of
0:12:20probability of winning as the way a computer plays it without any of those constraints.
0:12:24Jared "Seth" Kelsky Right. And without any sort of fear.
0:12:25Pete "Seth" Kelsky Right. Or the computer says,
0:12:28"I'm 97% confident of the answer, so I'm gonna wager, you know, $73,000."
0:12:31There was one player, there was one human player in Jeopardy, Roger Craig, who was a number four
0:12:36money winner and won the Tournament of Champions in 2011. And he would do this thing where he would
0:12:41double down, double down, double down. He won $77,000 in one day. He did that thing of pushing
0:12:47all the markers forward. The 77,000 is the most won by anybody on Jeopardy ever in one day. I
0:12:53think Ken Jennings had a 75 grand day in one day because he would do that. He'd be like, "You've
0:12:57got 37,500 dollars. What are you going to do?" And he's like, "I'm going to wager it all."
0:13:01And it's like, "Oh my God, really? Really?" And he'd do it. And that's hard to do. It's real money.
0:13:06Ted: And the funny thing is that actually is, I think, it's a very simple game overall,
0:13:12Jeopardy! But I think that the Daily Doubles is just the right amount of, like, a wildcard. It's
0:13:20like an asterisk in the game that makes it a game. And the truth is, on your first day, the day you
0:13:25won, your opponent had a lead that it could have been insurmountable going into Final Jeopardy!
0:13:32Could have been unbeatable, but she wagered enough on a Daily Double and lost to give you a chance.
0:13:39Yeah, this is, it's a heartbreaking moment which has been preserved on YouTube. Someone's posted
0:13:44about three minutes of it. And I didn't realize when playing the game until I watched it. We had
0:13:48a viewing party, had a bunch of people at a sports bar and were watching and I'm like, "Oh my God,
0:13:53she could have won." I had no idea because it's so fast. The average question goes by, they do
0:13:59a new question every 12 seconds, I think, in some of the research shows. So, you know, you're in
0:14:03there and there's a display you can look up to the left of the big board. You can see like a little
0:14:08LCD display of the three player scores. You can glance up there while you're playing when you're
0:14:12figuring out strategy. And so in the heat of the moment, if she'd had a minute to think about it,
0:14:17she would have bet $5, which is technically the lowest daily double bet. Instead, she bet $1,200.
0:14:22And that was the craziest question. The answer was dendrochronology.
0:14:25Yeah.
0:14:26Oh my God, the poor woman. Yeah. So she, right. So she had twice, more than twice as much as I did,
0:14:31could have breezed in and won.
0:14:32She went right from just over twice what you had to just under twice what you had. And the daily
0:14:37double was right at the end, and so she had no chance to get another question to go back
0:14:41up more than double. And so then—
0:14:42Pete: Exactly. There was one more, and that was it. Didn't get the last two thousand
0:14:45questions.
0:14:46John: No, watching at home, I recognized it instantly, because I was really, you know,
0:14:48obviously I was rooting for you.
0:14:49Pete Thank you.
0:14:50John Thank you. You know what I mean? You wouldn't be on the talk show if you were
0:14:52one-time Jeopardy! loser Glenn's question.
0:14:54Pete I know. It's like, there's nothing like, but yeah, it's that you, in the moment—
0:14:57John I was real nervous, and I thought, "Oh, she's gonna do…" and then I thought,
0:15:00"Oh, bet a lot," and then she did bet a lot, and I was like, "Oh, give her an impossible
0:15:03question and then they gave her an impossible question. I was like, "Oh."
0:15:05Pete: It was a ridiculous question. Like, this 13 letter word, you're like, "Oh, come on."
0:15:09Of course, I was watching it, one of my friends who was at the viewing party,
0:15:12his dad was a forester and he says, "Dendrochronology." Like, "Oh my god!"
0:15:15Brian Stearns- Yeah, you never know because it's, you know, somebody knows the answer.
0:15:19Pete: Free-ring science. But it's funny, and then we go into the final Jeopardy! That came in.
0:15:24This is a great thing about, one of the things that playing a game show about knowledge
0:15:27teaches you is there's, Bob Harris wrote this great book called Prisoner of Trebekus-Bentan
0:15:32about his—he won five times back when he could only win five times. Then he came back and they
0:15:36brought him on to like four tournaments because he's one of the most interesting, nicest guys.
0:15:40He's got a new book coming out about micro—not micro-investing, but micro-loans. And he's been
0:15:45traveling along the world meeting with people that he's loaned money to over Kiva, and it's—he
0:15:51sent me an advance copy. It's really cool. He's a really neat guy, but he wrote this great book
0:15:55that's kind of a memoir and kind of full of strategy about playing the game. And there's
0:15:59this difference between known knowledge and inferred knowledge, and I don't think I understood
0:16:03that as much until I played the game. The final question on day one, the Final Jeopardy, was about
0:16:09a city, the city, Hemnitz, Germany, had a different name from 1953 to 1990. Or 1933 to, no, yeah,
0:16:171953 to 1990. What was it? And I'm like, well, you know, and I don't know the answer. I don't know
0:16:22the answer. And I know the other two players, and I sort of know what they know, what they're
0:16:25playing the game. And I'm like, "I studied German for years in college." I'm like,
0:16:30"I know Chemnitz is a German city. That's not a problem. I know the wall fell in 1990,
0:16:34and I'm doing this Rastiosh nation. You're like, 'The Germans hated Stalin, so it's not after
0:16:39Stalin. Lenin was a Russian. There's already Leningrad.'" I'm like, "It has to be Karl Marx."
0:16:43But I don't know that, and the sensation of inferred knowledge is weird. And then I get the
0:16:48relief, "Yeah, that's it, and you got enough money." And I'm like, "Okay."
0:16:49- But did they want the city name or who it was named after?
0:16:51- They wanted who it was named after. The city was named after. The city of Chemnitz.
0:16:53- What was the city?
0:16:54It's Karl Marxstadt, which no one remembers.
0:16:56Yeah, see, I wouldn't know the name of the city, but in hindsight, my guess was Stalin,
0:17:01and I thought, "You're right. This is why you're on Jeopardy! winning and I'm
0:17:04at home losing." I knew—
0:17:06The Germans hate Stalin.
0:17:07Yeah, the inferred knowledge, I knew from the years that it had to be communist-related.
0:17:12That's when—
0:17:13Exactly.
0:17:14That's when, you know, that the Russians took control over half of Germany after World
0:17:17War II, and that's when they lost it. And so I thought, "Well, I don't know, Stalin."
0:17:23that's just as far as I thought. And then you're smart enough to think, well, they hate—the Germans
0:17:28hated Stalin, and, you know, maybe the Russians couldn't impose that on them. And so, of course,
0:17:33you go back, you embiggen the scope and go right back to the, you know, the granddaddy of communism
0:17:38and you go to Karl Marx. But you're staying there in that quantum state. You're in a Schrodinger—this
0:17:43is what we called the incomparable episode, it was the Schrodinger's cat box because you're sitting
0:17:46there in a state of which you don't know if you've won or lost because you don't affirmatively know
0:17:52that it's accurate. You can only deduce it's accurate, so there's no way to know until
0:17:56someone provides affirmative knowledge that you're correct.
0:17:58I would have felt real good though if I had come up with Karl Marx. I would have been sitting
0:18:02there thinking it's got to be Marx. I was happy because I was like, I got one, you know,
0:18:06one chance. But yeah, it's funny. It's a funny game and people are strangely fascinated about it,
0:18:12even though a lot of people, everyone told me, "Yeah, I love Jeopardy! I haven't watched it for
0:18:1610 years." Because people have cut the core, they don't do broadcast TV.
0:18:21if I didn't have the viewing party, I think half the people there wouldn't have been able to watch
0:18:24it at home because they don't have a form of television or access to cable or whatever.
0:18:29Pete: Yeah. Have I, I forget if we talked about this online or not, but have I explained to you
0:18:34my theory of, and I don't even think it's a theory, but I think it's so short. Why does
0:18:39Jeopardy! come on before Wheel of Fortune, not vice versa?
0:18:42Pete; In my market, it comes on after.
0:18:45Pete; Oh, does it?
0:18:45Pete; Just destroys your theory.
0:18:46Pete; Yeah.
0:18:46Pete; It varies by market. What's your theory though?
0:18:49Because Wheel of Fortune makes you feel smart and Jeopardy makes you feel dumb.
0:18:53Yeah, and it doesn't make you feel too dumb. They're always striking a balance there. I was
0:18:59watching… The secret to Wheel of Fortune's popularity is that the optimal strategy is not
0:19:06to solve the puzzle as soon as you can. It's to keep racking up money once you know the answer to
0:19:12the puzzle and get a big dollar symbol and pick the T, which you know that there's three of.
0:19:17of. And so, in the meantime, the audience has all of this way more time to figure out
0:19:21what the puzzle is.
0:19:22Darrell Bock Oh, no, you're right. That's exactly—it's
0:19:24a perfect—right, because the players want to keep it going as long as they can, as long
0:19:28as they have money on the board. But Jeopardy, you don't have time. It comes up. But they
0:19:32play this balancing game. I was watching one night and they did a category about—because
0:19:36I watched obsessively after I got the call that I was going to be on, and I went back
0:19:39and read archives and so forth. And they had a category. It was all about Huguenots. And
0:19:43I'm like, "Really? All about Hukonauts?" And the player's there. I mean, even Alex,
0:19:47who's from Canada. Alex Trebek is like, "I think no one got any of the answers right."
0:19:53And you're like, "Really about Hukonaut?" I mean, it's a little obscure. You know,
0:19:57that's, you know, dendrochronology might be bad, but you've got to have stuff that
0:20:00people at home feel like they could have known, even if they don't know it.
0:20:04Eric Michael Rhodes All right, let me take a break here and talk
0:20:05about our first sponsor. It's great. I'm so happy about both sponsors today. I'm
0:20:10about all of our sponsors every week, but today in particular. Because first sponsor,
0:20:15we've got Tonks back on board. Now, you know Tonks, Glenn. This is kind of amazing.
0:20:19You—
0:20:19Darrell Bock I just talked to Tonks. I just got a delivery
0:20:22of Tonks coffee. I can even tell you about what it's like.
0:20:25John Green That's me taking a sip. I'm drinking
0:20:28Tonks coffee right now. Tonks is a small company, and you sign up, they send fresh beans to you from
0:20:35all over the world and the coffee is just great. And here's the things they want me
0:20:42to tell you. Number one, they want you to know that contrary to what you might think
0:20:45going to a coffee shop and the barista makes some kind of latte and then the milk ends
0:20:51up looking like the Mona Lisa and you think, well, good coffee is impossible. Guess what?
0:20:55Making great coffee, like serious world-class great cup of coffee in your own kitchen is
0:21:00super simple. Some of the best ways to make coffee are so simple it'll blow your mind.
0:21:04Get great beans, burr grind them,
0:21:07just pour hot water over it into a filter
0:21:09and you've already got a great cup of coffee.
0:21:12The guys from Tonks find the best coffee beans
0:21:15from the top producers literally all over the world.
0:21:20They nail the roast and they get them in your mailbox
0:21:22at the peak of freshness.
0:21:23And they send them, I love their envelopes, the packages.
0:21:27I think they, everything about these guys to me is
0:21:30if you set out to, this is what I'm thinking,
0:21:33is if you set out to make the best coffee company
0:21:36in the world, you'd come up with something like Tonk.
0:21:39Maybe not the biggest, certainly not the biggest.
0:21:41I don't think Tonk's is as big as Starbucks.
0:21:44I don't know.
0:21:45It might be close.
0:21:46I'm talking the best.
0:21:47If your goal is to set out to do the best coffee
0:21:50in the world, you'd come up with something like Tonk's.
0:21:53Grape beans, everything about them.
0:21:55I love the packages that their things come in.
0:21:58Just the little Ziploc seal is, I don't know.
0:22:01With a lot of bags with Ziploc, I often have a hard,
0:22:03it takes me like three zips to get it.
0:22:05With the Tonks one, always first one.
0:22:07- And it's transparent, so you can see the beans, it comes,
0:22:09and you're looking at the beans,
0:22:10and it's got a neat little silkscreen message
0:22:13about what's in there, and a little note about it.
0:22:16But I don't feel like they're fussy or fey about it.
0:22:18It's like they love their coffee,
0:22:21they have no attitude about the coffee.
0:22:22What they're doing is they're producing
0:22:23something really good.
0:22:25They're not my sponsor, they're your sponsors,
0:22:26I can talk about them unbiasedly.
0:22:28They produce something that's really,
0:22:30that's like a delicious product
0:22:32that's designed to be consumed,
0:22:33but they're not coffee cra,
0:22:35I mean, they're crazy in the sack
0:22:36that they're interested in it,
0:22:37but it's not the, you need to get a $10,000 espresso machine
0:22:41and spend a week in Italy learning how to do it.
0:22:43It's like, you know, you can use an AeroPress.
0:22:45You could use a $5 espresso machine.
0:22:46You could use a $100 espresso machine.
0:22:48The burr grinder, I think, is critical, though.
0:22:50That's what I keep hearing, and I support that.
0:22:53You want a burr grinder.
0:22:54That's where you put the money,
0:22:55but then after that, you make it other way.
0:22:57You make it any way you want.
0:22:57- Right, and you get a good one, and it'll last you forever.
0:22:59But it really is not, they're not asking you to put out a huge capital outlay on fancy
0:23:03equipment or time-consuming processes. And they also have tremendous customer service
0:23:09and a great website where you go there and they have videos and things about, you know,
0:23:14just, here's how to make a great cup of coffee.
0:23:17Most of the things I like about them too is they don't want to grow too fast. That's
0:23:22why I was talking to them for another soon-to-be-announced Mule Radio Syndicate podcast I'm working
0:23:28Talking to them for that, so you'll hear this in December or something, my interview with
0:23:31them.
0:23:32And the thing is, they don't want to get big fast.
0:23:34They want to get big.
0:23:35That'd be great, right?
0:23:36They're not unambitious, but they aren't the like, we need to have a million customers,
0:23:41day one, social marketing, Facebook advertising, Twitter spam, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
0:23:46They like growing.
0:23:47They're growing well.
0:23:48They're getting great word of mouth.
0:23:49They're trying to scale it little by little so they don't have to deliver an inferior
0:23:54product.
0:23:55I love that.
0:23:56in my mind that their number one priority is best coffee in the world. And everything else is second.
0:24:02They want to be profitable. I'm sure they want to grow. Obviously, they want to grow. That's why
0:24:06they're sponsoring the show to get more talk show listeners to just give them a shot. Here's the
0:24:12last thing. A couple episodes ago, the last time they sponsored it, and I was talking about how
0:24:17they're literally all over the world, but I didn't have a list off the top of my head. Here's, they
0:24:21sent me this. They're in Africa. They've sourced beans from Kenya, Ethiopia. I'm drinking some
0:24:26stuff from Ethiopia right now. Burundi, Rwanda, Tanzania. In Central America, they've sourced
0:24:32beans from Guatemala, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Honduras, and in South America,
0:24:38Colombia, Brazil, Ecuador, Bolivia, Peru. So I'm telling you, literally all over the
0:24:43coffee growing world, these guys are getting the best beans. Here's how much they believe
0:24:47in it. Free trial. You just sign up. Go to tonx.org. T-O-N-X dot org. Sign up. You get a free
0:24:54trial. The beans will show up at your house in a couple of days, fresh sealed, and I'm telling you,
0:24:59you're going to try these beans and you're going to sign up and become a regular customer.
0:25:02Thanks to Tonx.
0:25:04Pete: It's good. It's good. I even ate some beans raw because they look so delicious.
0:25:09Ted, I do that. I definitely do.
0:25:10Pete It was good.
0:25:11Ted My son loves to eat a couple of coffee beans raw.
0:25:13Pete That's good.
0:25:14And I will also vouch. He didn't know. He has no idea that they're a sponsor of my show. I don't
0:25:19even think he knows I have a show. Whenever I make coffee, I'll say, "Hey, do you want a couple of
0:25:24beans?" And he'll take three or four coffee beans. And I gave him the Tonks ones, and he gave me,
0:25:28after he chewed the one, he gave me the—it was like the guy in Pulp Fiction, "Hey, that was
0:25:32pretty good." Like, that's good coffee. The Ethiopian ones were particularly beautiful
0:25:38color to this olive color. It's funny, I've never been like a fetishist of coffee, maybe
0:25:45more so for tea, but not even that. But I like something that tastes good and isn't
0:25:49bitter and has kind of a richness and is interesting and coming from the town of Starbucks.
0:25:53So here's the tonk story, by the way. So back in 2005, a colleague says, "Hey, there's
0:25:57a coffee shop in town that just opened up and they're turning Wi-Fi off on weekends.
0:26:00How crazy is that?" So New York Times, weirdly, one of the only direct assignments instead
0:26:05me pitching. They call me up and say, "Can you write a story about this thing?" So sure.
0:26:08So I go and I meet these owners, young idealistic owners who sold the business within a few years
0:26:12because running a coffee shop is a horrible, horrible business. They wanted to have a
0:26:18community place. And on the weekends with Wi-Fi on, people never talked. It was absolutely silent
0:26:22as a crip. They hated it, so they turned Wi-Fi off for the weekends. So I write a story about it,
0:26:27gets some really interesting play, and some other places also start turning Wi-Fi off. It's never
0:26:32really a trend, but it's interesting. So the guy roasting for them is Tony Canesny, the Tonks. And
0:26:37I do my first copying, I go there, he shows me how you do copying in the back and I get to taste all
0:26:42this great coffee. And then the guy is, you know, he's a, I think what's the opposite of a bad
0:26:46penny, he's like a good penny. He just keeps turning up wherever there's good coffee, turns
0:26:50up again and again and again, and it turns out everyone in the world knows Tonks.
0:26:53Pete: What is the opposite of a bad penny? I don't know.
0:26:56Pete: It's a great penny. He's a shiny penny.
0:26:58Pete; Right.
0:26:59But a very nice guy, and he's always had the same commitment to it. And you know,
0:27:02it's coffee is a great story because it spans the globe and it spans this huge stretch of
0:27:07modern civilization and you can just become such a fetishist about every little blah,
0:27:12you know, grain, whatever. Or you can just drink a good cup of coffee.
0:27:15I like the good cup of coffee part better.
0:27:18Pete: Yeah. You know, speaking of good pennies, you're sort of a good penny in that you've had a
0:27:25crazy variety. You've written for an inordinate and on a regular basis and inordinately wide
0:27:32variety of publications. You've just mentioned in New York Times. You're now a regular contributor
0:27:37to The Economist. You have been associated with tidbits as long as I can remember. Ever
0:27:45since Adam and Tanya expanded beyond just Adam and Tanya, I mean, I remember your byline
0:27:51being in tidbits. I mean, how long have you been writing for tidbits?
0:27:54like 1994 or something. I sent them a letter. I sent them a letter once and they ran it and I
0:27:59was so excited I started writing for them after I—they lived in Seattle when I first moved out here in
0:28:04'93. And—
0:28:05I mean, we're talking about before the web. I mean, we're talking about when a lot of people
0:28:10were probably still reading tidbits as a weekly hypercard stack.
0:28:13Oh my god, those were the days. Yeah, tidbits is now—we believe it's the longest continuously
0:28:18published publication on the internet because there was an Irish newsletter that stopped
0:28:22publication. We think we're now the oldest one since like 1990 because there was one they've
0:28:27been watching. There was one in China that fell away. So in terms of actually coming out on a
0:28:31regular basis for, you know, X years, I think we are now the longest, which cracks us up.
0:28:37Ted: Oh, and it's astounding, really. I mean, to think that it, you know, the upheaval that
0:28:42it went through in the first decade, just in terms of format, you know, what is the format for an
0:28:47internet publication?
0:28:48Oh yeah, and like dealing with servers and email and then Apple, you know, essentially
0:28:52almost imploding underneath it and then coming back.
0:28:56And I mean the thing that's funny, so here's the best thing about Adam and Tonya Anx as
0:28:59people is they do a lot of what they do to help their friends make livings and do interesting
0:29:03things.
0:29:04They're really like facilitators.
0:29:05Like they make a great living with what they're doing.
0:29:07They figure out a really good model with the ebooks and with tidbits and so forth and they're
0:29:11charming people and great friends.
0:29:12But they also, they spend a lot of their time making sure that other people they work with
0:29:17have a good experience and can make a good living from what they do. And it's like,
0:29:21they're so non-greedy about it. It's just delightful.
0:29:24Pete: Yeah, it's amazing. Other publications that you have been associated with, you write for
0:29:29Boing Boing?
0:29:30Pete: That's right. I've been right occasionally from Ars Technica. And yeah, I got this funny
0:29:35thing is I like people, it's this weird thing, I like people. And I've been, I started my career
0:29:41because I was, I was actually trained as a graphic designer. First a typesetter, then a graphic
0:29:44designer was the career I was going to go into, but it turned out I've always had an aptitude
0:29:49for computers. So I wound up becoming this guy who's like a translator, like, "Oh, you graphic
0:29:54designer, you're trying to use desktop publishing. Well, let me explain the steps to get there." And
0:29:58that's just been kind of how my career goes. I mean, The Economist, I'm the guy where they're
0:30:02like, "We don't understand, nobody in-house understands or cares about networking protocols.
0:30:07Could Glenn write something about this?" And so I'll write something on the blog, or sometimes
0:30:11I'll pitch something about a topic that's really—they're interested in it, but it's
0:30:15really obscure to the staff members. They're science geeks. They have PhDs in physics and
0:30:20economics and everything else, but the technology side, they're not unfamiliar with it, but
0:30:23there are very few programmers in-house and so forth. So I get to be the explainer of
0:30:28certain aspects of tweaky digital things there too.
0:30:31Dave Asprey And your newest gig, which is,
0:30:34I guess, sort of where I've been coming with this, is you—I forget your title exactly,
0:30:39executive editor?
0:30:40Pete: Executive editor. Yeah, Marco and I had some conversations.
0:30:42[Laughter]
0:30:42Ted: Of the magazine, Marco Arment's Still Nascent, I think it's at issue number three,
0:30:49is the current issue.
0:30:50Pete; That's right. Number four is next week.
0:30:52Ted; Which is just, as soon as I saw the announcement, I was like,
0:30:56"Duh! Why didn't, I wish I had suggested this because this is such a perfect match and I want
0:31:01to be able to take credit for making this happen. This is such a perfect fit."
0:31:06that.
0:31:07Pete: Yeah, it feels, it fits in the Marco's wheelhouse too, where it's like Instapaper,
0:31:10it's like Instapaper except he's making the articles that you'll then read later.
0:31:14Justin: You're such the perfect fit though because you, you know, you have such a variety
0:31:19of interests, you know, you're not just, you know, you used to write, I think it's
0:31:23past tense, I don't think you'd keep it up anymore, the Wi-Fi blog.
0:31:26Pete; Oh yeah, that was interesting. I spent like a decade writing Wi-Fi networking news.
0:31:30Justin; Which was a blog that was all about Wi-Fi and you think, "Well, what the hell,
0:31:34is that? But it was great. It was like a decade of upheaval.
0:31:37Pete: Yeah, the community Wi-Fi and then all the standards changed, all the devices and
0:31:43incompatibilities, standards wars, and then city-wide Wi-Fi, municipal Wi-Fi, and 802.11n.
0:31:50And then what happened is, was this very interesting thing. I think it was, I think it was
0:31:54eight years, nine years into it, and suddenly all the interest in Wi-Fi disappeared because it just
0:31:58started to work. And the rise in good mobile broadband, like 3G had, you know, 3G was suddenly
0:32:05everywhere. 4G-ish standards, you know, HSPA+ and some of the faster 3G stuff was starting to get
0:32:11out there, and LTE was on the roadmap. And suddenly people didn't need to know about
0:32:15Wi-Fi anymore because they could just connect whenever they needed to. And the whole, the
0:32:19traffic just fell out the bottom, and which is fine. Things have a lifetime. But I was,
0:32:23I was sort of sitting there one day, I'm like, "I should stop doing this because no one's reading
0:32:27it anymore. It sort of reminds me of the equivalent to Matt Howie's PVR blog,
0:32:33which was wildly popular for a while. But then PVRs kind of became like indoor plumbing.
0:32:44Truly fascinating and life-changing, but then you just sort of assume that it's there. It's no
0:32:53no longer a big deal.
0:32:54Well, there's the implosion of the gadget blogs, too. That sort of happens. I mean,
0:32:58you still have, you know, The Verge is not a gadget blog. It's a general computing
0:33:02thing that's more like, you know, Macworld plus, you know, some of like a HiFi stereo
0:33:07publication plus a business publication. Or Gizmodo is no longer exactly a gadget thing,
0:33:13and neither is Engadget. They write about all kinds of stuff. And there's 100,000
0:33:17sites that used to, and some still update things that are about every little gee-jaw.
0:33:22And I think, and that's sort of what happened with Wi-Fi too, is like when stuff just works
0:33:26and there's a sufficient amount of it and you don't have to make the same kinds of
0:33:29decisions you used to about what you're going to get, then the necessity of going
0:33:33to sites—there's still people who obsessively check on every new thing that's coming out.
0:33:37But I think the lifespan of those has really expired in a way that they used to capture
0:33:41the attention in like 2003 to 2006, say. That's sort of passed by.
0:33:46I totally—
0:33:47And good.
0:33:48I'm glad too.
0:33:49Yeah, it's, you know, I've often said to people that, you know, for a guy who started
0:33:55writing about Apple on his own site in 2002, I always thought if I did, I wouldn't pick
0:34:00a name that had the word Mac in it. And, you know, that was never really on the table,
0:34:04but it really, in hindsight, has turned out pretty well.
0:34:06No, and I think that's the thing. I think by not—the most interesting stuff that happens
0:34:11now is deliberative. And I think, you know, The Verge still publishes a lot of news, but
0:34:15I think, you know, one extreme you have maybe Business Insider or even Mashable where they're
0:34:20plowing out as much news as they can all the time.
0:34:22Some of it's, you know, I'd say Mashable.
0:34:24I like some of Mashable.
0:34:25Business Insider, let's say none of it's good, but they've got a business model.
0:34:29But then, you know, I've talked to Brian Lamb.
0:34:30I'm going to write something for his Wirecutter site.
0:34:32And he's one of the people at Gizmodo for years, really drove that frenzied pace.
0:34:37And now Wirecutter is like, it's the best stuff.
0:34:39Like really in-depth stuff.
0:34:41And it's like he's doing nothing changes on there from day to day until he posts a
0:34:45new thing.
0:34:46I mentioned a couple episodes ago, I forget who was on the show here with me, but we were
0:34:49talking about the Wirecutter and what a great site it is and comparing and contrast to Consumer
0:34:54Reports, which is really, really problematic.
0:34:57But they're trying to do the same thing, which is you need to buy a new TV.
0:35:05What's the best TV to buy?
0:35:07And you go to the Wirecutter and they just tell you, "Here's the best TV to buy."
0:35:10it. Just get this one. Or if you're, you know, and I'll give you like three options. Like,
0:35:14here's just the best big TV to buy. Here's the best one if you're on a budget. And, you know,
0:35:18here's the best one if you want a small TV. That's it. And that's all they tell you to do.
0:35:23And then I'll give you a link that'll explain there, you know, maybe why it's good.
0:35:27But that's it. There is no like eight by seven grid of features and check pluses and A minuses.
0:35:35And it's Apple-like in its simplicity. But I had coffee with Pete Rojas. He came through Seattle
0:35:42a few months ago, and I'd never met him in person, but we'd had correspondents for years. And he
0:35:46founded Gizmodo and then founded Engadget and then founded GDGT. I don't know how you're supposed to
0:35:52say Gidget. And so you can say he's responsible for all the horror, right? But I mean, it was
0:35:59different when he was involved. And each time he left, the publications transformed into something
0:36:03I think too, and the whole industry changed.
0:36:05But GDGT is, it's wire cutter like also.
0:36:09It's here's some really good information
0:36:11on a focus subject.
0:36:12We're not gonna bombard you
0:36:14because I think there's a limited audience.
0:36:16This is what's interesting about the live blog thing still.
0:36:17Like, you know, the fact that millions of people
0:36:20will tune into these live blog transcripts of Apple events.
0:36:24What are you gonna hear that's live that's not?
0:36:26I never understand that.
0:36:27Like, why can't you wait and someone writes an analysis
0:36:29or you could watch it yourself when the video is posted.
0:36:32But there are obviously a lot of people who are obsessed with the latest, newest, absolutely
0:36:36up to the second information. And then I think a much bigger audience. It's like, just
0:36:41give me the lay of the land. I don't need to read every last bit. Give me the information
0:36:44so I can make evaluative decisions.
0:36:46Dave: Exactly. No, I agree that. And I also think, yeah, I think it should be—and I
0:36:54try to do this. I always try to keep it in mind with what I do at Daring Fireball, that
0:36:57obviously there's some people who are loading the site multiple times throughout the day.
0:37:02But I always have in my mind somebody who's really busy, hopefully working on something
0:37:06really cool, and they're going to load it once at the end of the day just to see what
0:37:11happened. And I want the site, the home page, to read and make sense and sort of give you
0:37:15an overview of what you need to know. Did you miss anything today or is it just a bunch
0:37:19of goofy pictures of cats or something like that?
0:37:24Well, here's the thing. Do you use RSS anymore? Do you have an RSS reader?
0:37:26I do. I do. But I—
0:37:28How much compared to the way you did before?
0:37:30Very little. Twitter has really overtaken it to a large extent. I really—there's
0:37:35like a reckoning coming where I should really—I should wipe out all of my RSS subscriptions and
0:37:40start over from scratch and do it in a very different way where it would be more like,
0:37:44"Here's the dozen feeds that I don't—I know that I don't want to miss a thing."
0:37:48And no longer the, "Here's 100 feeds and I'm going to skim what's new to see what
0:37:55jumps out as breaking. Like, Twitter has really overtaken that as the—just what's going
0:38:03on right now? Am I missing something that's breaking?
0:38:05Alan Corey Yeah, Twitter is an aggregator. I mean, it's
0:38:09crowdsourced knowledge, and on average, if you follow people—I mean, it's sort of
0:38:13that funny thing. By figuring out who you follow, you only follow people who are interesting,
0:38:17you unsubscribe to them or you unfollow if they stop being interesting to you or overwhelm
0:38:21And so who's left are people who are likely to post things you're interested in, and you're going to see the same URL from a bunch of people, or they'll retweet it that they're interested in.
0:38:29So it's like, I don't, I still have RSS, I have hundreds of things in there, but a lot of them are like places where otherwise wouldn't go and they're just obscure enough.
0:38:37But I keep unsubscribing feeds in RSS because I'm like, I don't need the New York Times in my RSS. If there's an interesting article, I mean, they're going to see it when I visit the homepage at some point, or it'll show up 15 times in Twitter.
0:38:48- Yeah, I totally agree.
0:38:49It is, Twitter is sort of, Twitter works that way
0:38:53by doing, and I think you have to do both.
0:38:55You have to be willing to unfollow the people
0:38:57you no longer find interesting.
0:38:59You know, and don't think it's like,
0:39:02I don't have a Facebook account,
0:39:04but I understand though that like unfollowing
0:39:07or whatever they call it, somebody on Facebook
0:39:09is considered like rude.
0:39:11It is something you might take personally
0:39:14somebody is no longer friends with you on Facebook. Whereas to me, the follow and unfollow,
0:39:21you should never take that personally on Twitter. I don't care. People unfollow me because I'm
0:39:24tweeting about baseball or something like that. I don't care. That's fine. Come back in a month.
0:39:28You know, I don't care.
0:39:28I don't know if people have to tell you. People are like, "I'm going to unfollow you because
0:39:31I don't really care if you're following me or not." I don't. So, are you a Twitter reader or
0:39:36are you a Twitter scanner?
0:39:37What's the difference?
0:39:39Well, so people like my good friend Lex Friedman, he reads Twitter. He very carefully curates
0:39:45who he follows so the volume isn't too high. And he has to mute me at times because I go
0:39:49off as I do.
0:39:50No, I just skim. I skim.
0:39:52I'm a skimmer. Because I have like, I follow a thousand people and I dive in and out. I'll
0:39:56look, I'll scan a little bit, and then I'll go back to the, pin it up to the top and forget
0:39:59about it.
0:40:00No, and it's, and it is also part of the brilliance of the concept of Twitter is the,
0:40:07and it's just one of the great examples in my mind of how not putting a feature in is design,
0:40:13and that's the lack of red/unread status. And in the early years, in 2006, 2007,
0:40:20the screaming from people who were RSS addicts who wanted red/unread status for tweets was,
0:40:28it was cacophonous, and Twitter didn't ignore it. They were like, "No, that's actually…"
0:40:34the point is not to have read unread. You're not supposed to see all the tweets. You just take a
0:40:38look at what's going on now and scroll back as, you know, a couple minutes if you want. And if
0:40:43you really want to see them all, that's up to you. And you'd keep scrolling down the timeline until
0:40:47you see the one that you know you saw last night. But we're not going to keep track of that for you,
0:40:51because we don't want to encourage that behavior.
0:40:53Pete: You run a poll sometime. I just, I've asked occasionally and formally,
0:40:57and I am stunned how many people among my followers say I read Twitter. And I'm like,
0:41:02But I think there's a little bit of OCD there, maybe.
0:41:06That's true.
0:41:07That's one reason.
0:41:08And I have that to some extent.
0:41:10Unread counts do make me anxious.
0:41:12Yeah.
0:41:13So people are like, they can't just go to the top and ignore it.
0:41:15They might miss something.
0:41:16I mean, the internet is all about—the internet's motto is, "You might miss something."
0:41:20Right.
0:41:21I do read all of my mentions.
0:41:24Maybe not religiously.
0:41:25I mean, there might be some days where if I'm busy or if I'm offline for most of
0:41:28the day for travel or something like that, that I won't. But in general, there's a very
0:41:34high chance that on a given day, any of my—I'm going to read all of my mentions. And they're
0:41:39certainly far more voluminous than a typical Twitter user, but it's actually not that
0:41:43hard to keep up with. Way easier than keeping up with email.
0:41:46Yeah, and I think that mentions are more like someone—I mean, it's like an email replacement.
0:41:51It's a 140-character email replacement. If someone bothers to do that, I feel like
0:41:54I should respond to them or acknowledge it because otherwise it's rude. I mean, you've
0:41:58a high asymmetry, too. That's the thing is you must get a lot of—I have interesting
0:42:02conversations with people about the scale of Twitter from 1,000 followers to 10,000,
0:42:07that sort of exponential thing up to people with several million. And it's fascinating
0:42:12how variable the interaction can be. Some people with very few followers spend all their
0:42:16time in mention land, and others with millions of followers, people are either too cowed
0:42:20or they just say like, "Hey, you're great," but there's no communication.
0:42:23- Right, I find it just to be super efficient
0:42:27and it forces people who want to contact me
0:42:31to be brief, right?
0:42:33It's, and in general, if you can keep your emails
0:42:37to within the general length of a tweet,
0:42:39it's a lot more likely that I'm going to read it
0:42:41and reply, but the interaction is so much easier
0:42:44because going through email, you have to select it
0:42:48and then it opens and it's just the whole thing.
0:42:52you just want to bring a link to my attention, like, "Hey, I can't believe Gruber hasn't
0:42:56linked to this yet. This is so obviously daring fireball material." It is way more likely
0:43:01that I will see it if you tweet to me than if you email it to me. And I don't, you
0:43:07know, because it's just an easier workflow. I just have to scroll through a list and eyeball
0:43:12them as opposed to clicking down through a list in and out, in and out, in and out.
0:43:15Well, attention is a precious commodity. I keep thinking, like, attention is the one
0:43:19thing you can't get more of. You can't build more of it. You have to allot it, and
0:43:24it's, you know, that's what Facebook is trying to buy our attention and sell it to
0:43:27other people. And another callback, I mean, this is the idea behind Marco's, the magazine,
0:43:34is that he's trying to not overwhelm people. And it's the same sort of philosophy with
0:43:38Instapaper too, is that it's, you want to read it, you're going to do it later out
0:43:41of the flow of your, sort of the maelstrom of all the stuff that's coming through.
0:43:46And I think that's one of the guiding things behind the magazine is like interesting stuff
0:43:50that you're not necessarily going to find everywhere else. And just enough, you know,
0:43:54it's, I mean, the magazine is always curation, but it's just enough that it'll be interesting
0:43:57enough to read every issue, but you won't feel like, "Oh, God." I mean, writing
0:44:01for The Economist, that's the thing I always hear is I know plenty of people who read it,
0:44:04but they think of it sometimes as homework. They have the issues piled up there. Again,
0:44:08you don't have to read everything. You can throw issues into the recycling. But people
0:44:12look at it as, "This is something I'm supposed to do," or they enjoy it too and
0:44:16they make the time for it. But I mean, I don't have time to read The Economist every week.
0:44:20I try to read a good hunk of it, but I, you know, I'm too busy.
0:44:22I feel like I don't have an Economist subscription, but I do have—I do subscribe to The New
0:44:27Yorker, and I feel that exact same way. Some days I come downstairs and I look in the mail
0:44:32and there's a new issue with The New Yorker, and I can't believe it because it seems
0:44:36like the other one just came yesterday. And I would have to say that the number one reason
0:44:41I'm not a subscriber to The Economist is simply because of how agitated I am by the
0:44:45gigantic pile of New Yorkers in my office.
0:44:48I got The New Yorker and The Economist, and I'm not sure that's a winning strategy
0:44:51for me. I should probably settle down. But you know, there's always—it's like there's
0:44:54always a long feature in The New Yorker that I love. I mean, the one thing—the thing—the
0:44:59reason I got into the magazine, by the way, the reason I pitched Marco on being the editor
0:45:03is because—I mean, A, I knew he's a technology guy. He's also a good editor. I liked how
0:45:08he edited the first two issues very much. But you know, there's this list of things
0:45:11he can do and the stuff he was able to offload a whole pile of stuff on to me so we can focus
0:45:16on the areas that he really likes to spend time. But the thing that appealed to me was
0:45:21his view of what the magazine is, there's nothing like that right now. You can't find
0:45:29a publication that wants to run articles that are of interest to people interested in technology
0:45:33that aren't either about technology or are maybe about medical technology. The New Yorker
0:45:37doesn't really run stories that are of interest to people who know something about technology,
0:45:42even when they're about it. And so I like the idea that we're going to have things that are
0:45:46have a human focus. You know, they might be about like, you know, Lex Freeman, for instance,
0:45:50article on wet shaving or Dan Moore and I making tea, that there are things that if you like tech,
0:45:55you're going to like to hear about things associated with it. I've got a friend who
0:45:59is a letterpress guy and he's a beautiful writer and I want him to write about what that means
0:46:04because people who are involved in electronics don't necessarily know the joy and interest
0:46:09and sort of the tweakiness of letterpress.
0:46:11Oh, I am so good at letterpress. It is unbelievable.
0:46:15Not that letterpress!
0:46:16What letterpress?
0:46:17The inky kind of letterpress. I had to quit letterpress. I can't—my win rate was about
0:46:235%.
0:46:24Really?
0:46:25I would play—now, maybe I'm playing against people too hard. Maybe I should find easier
0:46:28players. Maybe all the people I know are much better wordy game stars than me.
0:46:33who did you play? Who did you find difficult? We never play. I never wound up playing you.
0:46:37- Everybody. Basically the Macworld editorial staff among other people and some other friends.
0:46:43It's funny. I know a million words. I've had rounds where I was playing with a friend, Sarah,
0:46:47and she wrote a poem out of the words we came up with because we had this great list of things,
0:46:53including some very dirty ones in the middle. Love the dirty words. But I couldn't win. I just,
0:46:58I don't have the strategy for it. I have the words, but I seem to like, and I played,
0:47:02I don't know about 60 games and I won like five of them and I thought this is probably not my game
0:47:07Maybe i'll come back to it
0:47:08But it's hard to always lose a game in the early part of the game being able to find the biggest words is the best
0:47:14Skill, but once you get to the middle of the game, it's it's all strategy and and you can win i'm not good at finding
0:47:20Wow, that's a great word words. I'm i'm most of my words are like third grade words
0:47:26But they're strategically placed
0:47:30Yes, well, I've seen some of your word lists, so post it on the Twitter.
0:47:34Yeah, I do.
0:47:35So we know the words.
0:47:36I love the letterpress.
0:47:37But back to the magazine. Here's the thing. The thing that makes you such a great fit,
0:47:45and it fits with this show that you're talking about doing, which is just the idea of
0:47:51how disintermediated can you get and just go back to the simplest thing economically that'll work.
0:47:58And look at the magazine. I mean, everybody knows that it gets a little complex here because the
0:48:03name of the magazine we're talking about is The Magazine. But the magazine industry in general is
0:48:11widely regarded as being in a period of upheaval and that there's, you know, it could be on the
0:48:16verge of collapse and that there's, you know, there's certain big, big ones that are probably
0:48:21going to do just fine just because they're, you know, The Economist and The New Yorker are
0:48:25certainly right there among them because of the quality of them.
0:48:27Yeah, the New Yorker has mostly been operated at a loss for most of its history. I'm not
0:48:31sure if it's profitable at the moment, but it has almost always been operated at a loss,
0:48:35is the fasting part. But people who run it, including Cy Newhouse now for the last X decades,
0:48:41they love it so much they just keep it running.
0:48:45The Economist, I would hope, just by the title is run at a profit.
0:48:48It's good. I think they've doubled their circulation in the last 10 years because they
0:48:51took away Time and Newsweek decided that stupid was better than smart, so they went stupid.
0:48:56I mean, Time was the thing that I read as a kid where you're like, and Newsweek was a slightly
0:49:00easier version of it, but it wasn't bad. And US News and World Report, I mean, that was often had
0:49:04incredibly good stuff in it. And, you know, lots of publications like that. Now you point to, like,
0:49:10the Atlantic and Harper's as the ex-impliers along with the New Yorker of a certain kind of style.
0:49:15But for Newsweek, he's like, "What do you read in America that's…" You know, so Time and Newsweek
0:49:19said the stupider the better, the more people we are without forgetting that we're news
0:49:23organizations that we could. And the Economist picked up all the subscribers who wanted to
0:49:26read something with words of three or more syllables in it occasionally.
0:49:30Tom Bilyeu (01h00m 5s): And you know, the scope of the magazine, at least right now,
0:49:33is less than the scope of those other magazines. We're talking right now so far three issues
0:49:38it's about. I think it's four or five articles per issue. Articles are somewhere around a
0:49:45thousand to fifteen hundred words. It seems to me, I don't know.
0:49:48- That's right, and the thing is, this is where,
0:49:51so this podcast I'm gonna do,
0:49:52which is tentatively titled The New Disruptors,
0:49:54the notion is that we've had tools to create stuff
0:49:57for decades now, I was involved
0:49:58in early desktop publishing, audio came after that,
0:50:02all the digital tools were in there to make things,
0:50:04and now you have digital tools that let you control
0:50:06and make 3D objects and CNC routers,
0:50:08and you can get a 3D printer in your house
0:50:11for a thousand bucks or less, much less even.
0:50:13So we're at the revolution where you have
0:50:15all the digital tools you need to create stuff,
0:50:17and the next wave is funding production,
0:50:21manufacturing, distribution,
0:50:23and that's where I keep seeing things
0:50:24like the magazine fits in that beautifully.
0:50:26It's like you still, you have to be in bed with Apple.
0:50:28They're taking a 30% cut.
0:50:30They're your distribution channel,
0:50:32but if you have an audience,
0:50:34you're not disremediated by a gatekeeper
0:50:37that says you're not allowed to reach that audience.
0:50:39Apple would be delighted for you
0:50:40to have 10 million people paying you
0:50:43so they can get 30% of it.
0:50:44As in the past where news stands,
0:50:46Getting a magazine on a physical newsstand,
0:50:49there's a lot of organized crime connections in the past.
0:50:51There's these placement fees.
0:50:53The reason magazines and newsstands cost like $7
0:50:56and this yearly subscription is like $20
0:50:58has to do with the incredible intermediation that adds cost.
0:51:03And so you take that one step further
0:51:05in digital distribution where you don't have to build
0:51:07the distribution platform, just the content and the medium.
0:51:10It's great.
0:51:11- Well, the other things too though
0:51:12that saddle traditional longstanding newspapers
0:51:15magazines are the incredible bureaucratic bloat of the organizations that took place over the
0:51:2320th century. I mean, I used to work at the Philadelphia Inquirer, not on the editorial
0:51:28staff but in the promotions department doing graphic design work a long time ago. But I got
0:51:34to know the company, and it was an interesting division of the newspaper to work in because,
0:51:40Effectively, we did the house ads,
0:51:42like ads for the inquirer itself,
0:51:44or if the automotive sales department,
0:51:48you know, the people who sell the car ads,
0:51:50needed like a flyer or something
0:51:52for a thing that they were doing,
0:51:54we would make that for them.
0:51:55So I got to know all these people throughout the company.
0:51:57And it was amazing to me,
0:51:59it just draw dropping how many people work there
0:52:02who, not talking about the newsroom,
0:52:05not talking about reporters, photographers, editors,
0:52:07people who actually made what I thought of as the newspaper,
0:52:09but everybody else. It was massive. And I'm sure that, you know, there's—I know, in
0:52:14fact, I know that they've had a lot of layoffs and buyouts and stuff like that in the years
0:52:17since I worked there. But it was just jaw-dropping how many people work there, doing things other
0:52:24than what I thought of as the business of doing the newspaper.
0:52:27Oh, it's crazy, but newspapers used to make like 25% profit margins year after year or
0:52:33larger. And you could have—and that was—so you could have any number of executives, middle
0:52:37members of the family who were too idiotic to send it to other companies,
0:52:41promotions people, layers of editors, reporters. You have reporters working on features for three
0:52:46years and producing 50,000 words at the end. And magazines were, I think, a little bit more
0:52:52variable, but many had extremely high profit margins. There was no other place for advertisers
0:52:56to go. Right. It was, that in fact was a point of contention when I was there because it was,
0:53:01at the time, it was a Knight Ritter newspaper, the Enquirer, well, and the Daily News,
0:53:04The Philadelphia Inquirer and Daily News are jointly published by a—well, I don't even
0:53:09know what the company is called anymore, but it's one company that publishes two newspapers.
0:53:12And they were owned by Knight Ritter. And Knight Ritter considered at the time, this is like the
0:53:19mid-to-late '90s, their flagship newspaper to be the San Jose Mercury News. And it was always a
0:53:26little bit of a point of contention because I think, journalistically, the Philadelphia
0:53:29Inquirer had a better reputation. In the '80s, the Philadelphia Inquirer won more Pulitzer's
0:53:34than the New York Times or the Washington Post. I mean, it was truly a world-class,
0:53:39arguably maybe in the '80s, maybe the best newspaper in the country in the '80s.
0:53:42Pete: Mm hmm. Yeah, I want to talk about the Inky.
0:53:44Brian: And so, that was sort of a sore point of contention, but here's why the San Jose Mercury
0:53:49News was considered the flagship of Knight
0:54:00had days of 19% profit margins.
0:54:01Right, but that was it. I mean, there would be like a quarter, like 1997, one of the quarters
0:54:06it came in and it was 19% profit margins and it was like, "Ooh, maybe they're going
0:54:09to have buyouts."
0:54:10And here's the thing, and this is of course the time when you still have the unions stranglehold,
0:54:16rightly or wrongly. I mean, I'm not trying to be anti-union, but it's like you had—I
0:54:21was a typesetter, I was trained as a typesetter, never worked in newspapers, but I worked with
0:54:23older typesetters and worked with all these people in the printing industry and they always
0:54:27had the story, it's a newspaper printing plant, so it'd be the guy who was like the
0:54:30linotype operator and the linotype machines that were taken out 20 years before. And he'd
0:54:34been drawing the salary for 20 years. There's the guy who, you know, was the lead puller
0:54:38or whatever, like all these jobs. And there's the guy, you know, and some of the plants
0:54:42were so union run that there was like a big stop button and if management rolled, came
0:54:46in, they would hit the stop button and stop the presses until management left. Like that
0:54:49was their right. And so you had even with incredibly bloated, inefficient printing plants
0:54:54that were padded with all these people who did nothing and all these extraneous employees
0:54:59and union benefits and everything else. Even with that, they were getting 20 and 25 percent
0:55:03profit margins.
0:55:04Right. And so what I love about something like the magazine is that the magazine is,
0:55:09to me—I've always seen what I do at Daring Fireball as being a reset button on that of
0:55:14what would it take to set up a business that is sustainable, and the employee count is
0:55:22Me and I'm a little lucky there because I have a computer science degree and I used to do web programming
0:55:27And so in terms of actual and and it really isn't day to day. There's not much web nerdery
0:55:33I need to do to keep it going but I did get to I in the early days
0:55:36You know, I could set everything up I could move servers
0:55:38I could do stuff like that by myself if there was a problem I can SSH into the server and
0:55:42Clumsily fool around and see if you know what the hell's going on here
0:55:47So it's a little easier to be a one-man show, or at least starting 10 years ago, with
0:55:51a technical background. Today, I think it's easy with things like Tumblr and Squarespace
0:55:58and the ways that you—you know, the WordPress hosting sites, WordPress.org even. It's
0:56:03really easy for someone who doesn't have a technical background to do the same thing,
0:56:06I think, today. It wasn't so easy 10 years ago.
0:56:08Yeah, and Marco's kind of the equivalent of that with the magazine, is he's an iOS
0:56:11programmer and he spent—you know, he can just make an iOS app—I mean, it's not
0:56:16make. But you know, it's some amount of effort that he knows what it takes to do it and can
0:56:21replicate it. And it's kind of the equivalent of like, okay, how do I set up an Apache server
0:56:25in 1997?
0:56:26Right, exactly. Well, and the other thing that he has, it's a nice advantage too, is
0:56:30with Instapaper under his belt and with a happy, fairly large customer base, he kind
0:56:37of knows what people like experience wise. You know, what do they want in an app that
0:56:44going to a reading experience on these handful of devices, iPads, iPhones. What are they
0:56:51going to – what works? What do they click on? What do they like? So he was able to build
0:56:56that and that's a huge advantage.
0:56:59But then fundamentally, just economically, it's so simple. You just hit the reset button.
0:57:05Start from nothing. Okay. Now you've got a $2 subscription per month. You get two issues
0:57:12per month. And with 10, 20,000 subscribers, all of a sudden, or whatever the number is,
0:57:19just throwing out numbers like that, I actually don't know. But it's obviously hit a point
0:57:24though where with X thousands of dollars a month, you can pay four or five writers for
0:57:31an issue, a nice industry competitive amount for the articles. You can pay an editor and
0:57:38you can have money left over for profit for the publication. And that's without even getting into
0:57:45advertising yet. You haven't even started. And that's Apple taking 30% off the top, too,
0:57:51and bully for them. And so, yeah, that's the thing. I mean, Marcos put out some numbers, but
0:57:55he said after the first issue, he posted something and said, "Look, this has become a sustainable
0:57:59venture." And he's paying nearly magazine rates for writing. I was surprised and pleased at what
0:58:04what he wants to offer and this is my,
0:58:06I gotta be, you know, candy man here this next year.
0:58:09Like I'm so excited about the amount of money
0:58:12I'm going to be able to pay other people for good writing
0:58:14is actually more exciting to me
0:58:16than whatever money I will make from working on it
0:58:17because there's such a dearth of opportunities for people
0:58:20to both be published and to be paid
0:58:23an appropriate livable, like just even livable wage.
0:58:27It's not, he's not paying a wage that means
0:58:28that people can make $200,000 a year
0:58:31if they wrote full time for it.
0:58:32He's paying a wage that means people can actually live
0:58:34a probably lower to middle class existence, which is where we've gotten in writing.
0:58:38I got paid 50 cents a word by the New York Times in 1998, and then many years later,
0:58:43too, although they changed it a bit. I was told by friends that the New York Times paid
0:58:4650 cents a word in 1970.
0:58:48You know?
0:58:49Jared: It's really not that, that's not good. Because a thousand word article is a
0:58:54lot of work.
0:58:55Alan: It's a lot of work.
0:58:56Jared; You come away with it when you check for 500 bucks.
0:58:58Alan; Yeah, so I mean, that's, this is part of the thing is like publications have evolved
0:59:02to a point at which they believe,
0:59:04and if you look at the management structures
0:59:05and the top-heavy structures of most publications,
0:59:08they believe writers are interchangeable and uninteresting.
0:59:10And I mean, even if writers aren't branded,
0:59:12aren't big-brand-name Malcolm Gladwell things,
0:59:15and not accusing the New Yorker of this of all places,
0:59:17but there's this attitude that the content
0:59:20is the least important part, the packaging, reselling,
0:59:23marketing, advertising around it is,
0:59:25and this attitude is pervasive.
0:59:27And so Marco, I think, is coming out the other way around.
0:59:28It's like, if you're starting from scratch,
0:59:30how would you build a publication today?
0:59:32It's gonna be an iOS app.
0:59:33It's the easy, smallest, or lowest hanging fruit
0:59:35to reach the largest number of people
0:59:37with the least amount of effort.
0:59:38He's got millions of people in his audience already
0:59:40who know and trust him, who know his product,
0:59:42so he doesn't have to worry about the marketing side
0:59:44of reaching those people.
0:59:46And then he's starting it out with the idea of,
0:59:47I'm gonna pay a competitive rate,
0:59:50which we hope will improve over time, and see how it goes.
0:59:53And so right now, it's sustainable.
0:59:54We could do this forever at this rate.
0:59:55- And I also think, compared to traditional magazines,
0:59:59which are so heavily ad-based,
1:00:01and therefore have these, you know,
1:00:03and there's the whole situation with advertising
1:00:06in a magazine like New Yorker or Sports Illustrated
1:00:09or The Economist and, you know,
1:00:11selling these back page ads and the inside front cover ads
1:00:14and then filling up the back of the book
1:00:16with all the little ads, it's an enormous amount of work.
1:00:20Something like the magazine can start from scratch
1:00:22and go with the, like, less of an advertising model,
1:00:25more of a sponsorship model
1:00:27and maybe just have one sponsor per episode.
1:00:30and maybe leave money on the table that way,
1:00:34but also not have to have a full-time ad sales staff.
1:00:38You don't even have to add anybody.
1:00:39- There's a funny thing that happened at--
1:00:42- Like I can tell you firsthand,
1:00:43if you go with the sponsorship model,
1:00:44you don't need any, but you can do it yourself.
1:00:48- Yeah, and that's what Tidbits has pursued,
1:00:49but there's this funny thing, yes,
1:00:51once you get to a certain level of scale or interest,
1:00:53you can ask for a premium rate
1:00:56and not have to be selling a thousand little pieces
1:00:58and have somebody in charge of it.
1:01:00But, you know, so Marco and I have this discussion.
1:01:02I'll expose the discussion we have,
1:01:03but he's talked about it publicly.
1:01:04He wants it to be every other week,
1:01:06and he's thought about it,
1:01:07talked publicly about it perhaps being weekly.
1:01:09I would agitate potentially for it going weekly
1:01:11at some point, although that'll mean a lot,
1:01:14different editorial schedule and so forth.
1:01:16He's worried it'll be too much for people to read,
1:01:18that if he's promising four or five articles
1:01:21every two weeks, if we suddenly did, say,
1:01:23just four articles every week,
1:01:25that may be more attention than people wanna give.
1:01:27So would subscriptions go up
1:01:28because it's a better value, it's more articles.
1:01:31Or do subscriptions go down because people are saying,
1:01:33oh, now this has become a chore.
1:01:35So that is even a fascinating position to be in
1:01:37where you're saying we could potentially,
1:01:40there's some dollar switch there
1:01:42and could we double subscriptions by having more,
1:01:45probably not in that ratio,
1:01:47but does it become more appealing to people
1:01:49if there's more content because it's more likely
1:01:51they'll be interested in something in every issue.
1:01:53And maybe now if they don't like the four or five articles,
1:01:57they have to wait two weeks
1:01:58do they resubscribe if they don't like everything or two or three in each so there's that's that's
1:02:02part of it you have to be much more interesting every other week than perhaps weekly as well.
1:02:06It's a tricky problem.
1:02:08It is but I think it's uh you know I when Marco first ran the idea past me hey do you think this
1:02:14makes sense I really you know I just thought yeah of course it just thought this is I think it's a
1:02:20sure thing I think it's a question of how big of a hit is it going to be that was that was my thought
1:02:25I thought it was just a great idea and a great opportunity.
1:02:28And I do, I could not be more bullish on the prospects going forward of the magazine.
1:02:35It's great. And now the whole challenge now is to get interesting people who want to write
1:02:38deep, interesting things. And we've had some, I mean, the early response was great. And I've
1:02:42been going through a lot of what I did for Mark was go through hundreds of pitches that we've gotten.
1:02:46And we're trying to find more researched and reported stories because we're paying enough
1:02:50to get people to go out and do that kind of thing. So we'll have personal essays, we'll have
1:02:55general essays about things like wet shaving and cup of tea, I keep coming back to. And things like
1:03:00Gina Trapani's great piece about in vitro fertilization and her partner is such a—
1:03:03Ted
1:03:13and technology, and this sort of thing that's totally universal to people, the feeling you
1:03:19have when you read it. And so we're striving for some balance of those components in every
1:03:24story. And so we're kind of a bunch of really fun stuff. I went to the Library of Congress's
1:03:30Buried Archives in Virginia, and I'm writing an account of that, of where they keep their
1:03:34audio-visual materials in vaults in Culpeper, Virginia. So that'll be fun to write.
1:03:40Are you going to do it for the magazine?
1:03:41Yes.
1:03:42is, I pitched it before I got the editor job. I don't know.
1:03:44Marc Thiessen, J.D. Here's my question for you, and this is one of the questions I have written
1:03:48down here for you is, because you have this widely, like I said before, The Economist,
1:03:54New Yorker, you pitch, you still write freelance for a lot of different publications. Now that
1:03:59you're the editor of the magazine, how much, how hard is that going to be for you to decide
1:04:04where to do your writing? Like, should I still pitch this for X publication, or should I just
1:04:09do this for the magazine? Pete Lienberg
1:04:11Well, I'm going to be, Mark, I was just talking about this recently, in fact, is that not about my side of it, but neither of us want to dominate, be a dominant voice in it, especially every other week.
1:04:19So, you know, we're trying to, some of the writers who are early issues, we're trying to space them out too.
1:04:26So I will be surprised if I write more than every four issues, if that, just because then it becomes too much, it shouldn't be a platform for me.
1:04:35And Marco's written more in the early days because, you know, he's trying to set a tone and so forth,
1:04:39and he'll probably be in less and less too for the same reason, when I have room for more voices.
1:04:43But there is this thing, which is I did this through just a fluke. I interviewed the fellow
1:04:48who's the head of the audio section at the Library of Congress, and he said, "If you're ever out and
1:04:52you have time, come out to Culpeper." And I did. I didn't have an outlet for it. And the insight I
1:04:57feel I got from seeing what the Library of Congress is doing with our audio and visual
1:05:02history, there's not really a place that would run an article like that. Aspects of it, maybe
1:05:07some technical thing about how you extract sound from wax cylinders or some, I wrote a piece a year
1:05:14ago, in fact, based on some, an interview I did with this fellow about the phonogram, right? This
1:05:18obscure thing that prevents audio from being used. The phonogram light, right? Lasts 200 years at
1:05:24this point. Edison's first utterances on a wax cylinder are still under protection by the
1:05:29phonogram write until 2067. It's this crazy thing. Everything in audio, no audio will expire
1:05:37until 2067 from the audio part of the protection as opposed to the copyright of the underlying
1:05:42composition or words. And it's just this historically weird thing. So I want to think
1:05:46about that for The Economist. It's perfect. It's tweaky. It was for the blog and it highlights this
1:05:50really odd aspect of where digital culture collides with analog culture and to some extent science.
1:05:55So, but to find a place where I could write about, you know, what's the insight and impact into
1:06:00seeing our cultural memory in this forum and the restrictions on us gaining access to it because
1:06:06of copyright and other vagaries, there's not really an outlet that would do that. Now, The
1:06:10Atlantic, there are places like The Atlantic, New Yorker, Harper's, they might run articles like
1:06:14that, but it would be much bigger. This would be something I'd spend months on. The compensation
1:06:18would probably be not good enough for it. I've talked to people who've written freelance for
1:06:23for some of these publications.
1:06:24And the experience is magnificent,
1:06:26but they can't put money on the table
1:06:28unless they have a contract or a staff job
1:06:31to have money on the table.
1:06:32They can't put food on the table,
1:06:33they put money on the table,
1:06:34unless they have an ongoing relationship
1:06:35where they're just committed to writing some amount.
1:06:37It's a tough business.
1:06:38So being able to write short, interesting things,
1:06:41like a thousand word range and get paid well for them
1:06:45is actually sort of hard to find
1:06:47unless it's either very technical
1:06:50or very poorly, not getting well paid for,
1:06:52getting a tiny number of cents per word.
1:06:54No, I think it's very exciting, and I can't, you know—I think the fact that the magazine
1:06:59is already paying competitive rates, and like you said, maybe as time goes on, maybe even
1:07:03might push that forward and actually pay leading rates.
1:07:08And why not? I mean, what if that drove some suggestions? What if we could get—I mean,
1:07:11this is the thought experiment, and I'm not—
1:07:12It's completely contrary to the way the magazine industry has gone in the last—
1:07:15Yeah, and I'm not talking at a school here. I mean, this is—I tried to, you know, private
1:07:18discussions are private, but this is, you know, also, this is in my head is, what if
1:07:21it were that we could pay the best rate in the magazine industry, what writers would we get?
1:07:26And this is not to be offensive to the writers who have been there already. We have some great
1:07:30people who are terrific writers writing for us already. But what if we could get the leading—but
1:07:35we would all agree. I mean, I know I'm not the leading writer in the country. I know there's
1:07:38people who I would be delighted to have their words in the magazine. There's people I pick up
1:07:42publications and go and buy them because there's articles by them in there. What if some of the
1:07:46leading nonfiction writers in the country said, "Oh, well, I should be in the magazine." And so
1:07:50we have people like me in the magazine who are very, you know, we're competent and hardworking,
1:07:54we write good stuff, people like to read us, and we have people who are names because they're very,
1:07:59very, very good. These are the people you idolize, you know, John Krakauer or something like that.
1:08:04He demands a huge fee. What if we can pay a rate where he says, "Oh, that's great, I'll do that."
1:08:07But we could pay that same fee to him, and we could say, "Pay the same fee to Dan Morin or whomever."
1:08:12Pete: Yeah, no, I think it's terribly exciting. The other one last thing on the magazine before
1:08:16before we let go of that is the other thing too
1:08:19that it reminds me of the early days of the web
1:08:21is that the magazine itself, the app,
1:08:24is better than, as good or better than
1:08:28all of the big name magazine apps in the store.
1:08:31It is. - It's true.
1:08:31- And it's totally true of the web.
1:08:33And it was this incongruous thing,
1:08:36and I saw it was one of the reasons that a decade ago
1:08:38I saw Daring Fireball as an opportunity
1:08:40is I thought I can make a better website
1:08:44than these guys, these big name guys coming over
1:08:47from Print Can Do, 'cause I'm gonna do something
1:08:48that is clean, I'm gonna do something that is not cluttered,
1:08:51I'm gonna do something that is, that looks good,
1:08:56instead of looking bad.
1:08:57And there are some magazines that have gotten better
1:08:59over time, the New Yorker app has gotten a lot better
1:09:02over time, where it's not, it's no longer published
1:09:04as a series of static images, it's actual text,
1:09:07and they use fonts, and they sort of have a magazine,
1:09:10the magazine type layout now, where you go side to side
1:09:13between articles, but an individual article scrolls down. But it used to be, and you can
1:09:18still easily find big name print magazines that have apps where I get completely lost
1:09:24two clicks into the thing. Where am I? How do I get back? How do I go to the next article?
1:09:30I mean, easily. You just get—it's so easy to get lost, and the magazine is just simple.
1:09:36Table of contents on the left, article scrolls down.
1:09:39- Yeah, I mean, this is where I think you get
1:09:41that benefit of maturity is that, you know,
1:09:44we all have pity for the magazine publishers
1:09:45in that, well, I shouldn't have pity, I guess,
1:09:47is they didn't invest money figuring out how to do it right
1:09:50in mobile formats for the most part
1:09:52before like the iPad came along, right?
1:09:55I mean, some did, some were early out,
1:09:56but even doing it correctly, you know,
1:09:58for decent web browsers in 2008 or 2009.
1:10:02And so you're still watching, you know,
1:10:04two years on the iPad, you're still watching them
1:10:06fumble around to figure it out,
1:10:08and you're gradually seeing the clarity
1:10:09and there's a huge divergent path
1:10:10between the ones that you're like,
1:10:12I like the New Yorker app now, I can use it, it's good.
1:10:14The Economist app started out, I think, a little rough,
1:10:16not bad, but now it really has that iconic feel
1:10:19of the magazine without being beholden to it.
1:10:21And I actually, I'll often have read the whole issue
1:10:25on the phone and then I get the print issue
1:10:26and I'm like, oh, I don't need this anymore,
1:10:28I just realized I read it.
1:10:29But in my mind, I can hardly differentiate the experience
1:10:32because the branding and the sort of ease are equal.
1:10:35And yeah, I think so Marco gets the advantage
1:10:36having spent years figuring out what that experience should be, and then he just applies
1:10:40the lessons. You didn't have to start from scratch.
1:10:41And not having to answer to any idiot, dumbass protectionist, pull your head out of your
1:10:47ass guys above him so that when the magazine launched, he could actually honestly, unironically
1:10:54promote as features that you can select and copy text.
1:10:57That's true, though. Yes.
1:10:59Right? We laugh, but that actually is a competitive advantage that the magazine has over most
1:11:05magazines in newsstand is that you can swipe partial page at a time. Don't have to swipe
1:11:11screen at a time. Right. Is a feature. All right. I have a couple other things I want
1:11:14to talk about, but let's take a break and I want to tell you about our second sponsor.
1:11:19And I am really, really impressed by this app. It's an app for the iPhone and iPad
1:11:23called Griditor. G-R-I-D-D-I-T-O-R. And it's a photo editor for iPhone and iPad. And I
1:11:31I talked about this on the show before,
1:11:33and it's just, this is like the perfect type of thing
1:11:35I'm talking about, where I have been frustrated
1:11:39with the photo editing apps.
1:11:41I'm talking about things like correcting exposure,
1:11:44brightness, applying filters and looks, color balance,
1:11:48and stuff like that to photos as you're posting
1:11:50from the iPhone, and that I feel like a lot of these apps
1:11:52are way too fiddly, and that they're sort of stuck UI-wise
1:11:57in ways that aren't that, I don't know,
1:12:00I just feel like there's something out there
1:12:01that is different.
1:12:02And I'll tell you what, Griditor is really, really different
1:12:05and I really like the way that it goes.
1:12:06The basic idea is you pick a photo to start with.
1:12:10You go, just pick a photo from your camera roll
1:12:12that you want to edit.
1:12:14And it starts out in the middle of a grid.
1:12:17And in all four directions,
1:12:18there are filters and adjustments.
1:12:22So for example, you might have at the top brightness
1:12:25and on the right, something like a toy camera filter.
1:12:30And the grid gets filled in with, if you go straight up towards brightness with a
1:12:36series of thumbnails of your image getting brighter and brighter and
1:12:39brighter until you get to a maximum brightness. And on the right, as the
1:12:44filter, this toy camera style filter gets stronger and stronger and stronger. But
1:12:48then along the diagonal you get thumbnails that are a combination of the
1:12:52two. Brighter and this filter. And you can pick how strong they are. And you can
1:12:57just scroll around what I guess I would call the canvas of this grid of
1:13:01thumbnails and just see them and see how this works and then if you don't like
1:13:05what you see you can just set a new set of filters and new sort of combination
1:13:10of these things but the thing that I really like about it is that as you
1:13:13explore these combinations of the things it's all visual and you don't have to
1:13:18sit there and play with like how strong it's making you just see it already
1:13:22already because the thumbnails are already on screen.
1:13:28There's a whole bunch of photo editing apps for the iPhone that to me work with the exact
1:13:31same interface.
1:13:32And there's different, you know, you can, it's up to your taste how much you like them.
1:13:36This one has an interface that to me is like nothing else I've seen before.
1:13:40I really, really like it.
1:13:43And I will emphasize that there's two different type of things you can do with the adjustments
1:13:47in Gridditor.
1:13:48One are basic edit controls.
1:13:50are things like brightness, contrast, sharpening. And then second are the Instagram-style filters,
1:13:58these vintage-type things like bleach bypass, toy camera, stuff like that. And so if you
1:14:06aren't interested in that whole sort of retro filtering sort of adjustment-type thing, it's
1:14:12still a great app because you have these basic things like making it brighter, darkener,
1:14:17adjusting the filter going black and white.
1:14:20Or the other way around, if you only are interested
1:14:24in putting filters on your pictures.
1:14:26It's a great collection of filters
1:14:27and I really, really like the way
1:14:30that you get to adjust how strong it is.
1:14:32So you can just go a little tad in this direction
1:14:35or you can go really, really strong in this direction
1:14:38and you can see it before you finalize it.
1:14:42Really, really good app.
1:14:43I've been using it a lot the last two weeks
1:14:45for the pictures I've been posting to Instagram.
1:14:47It's really, really impressive,
1:14:50and I think the developer has a lot of good ideas
1:14:54going forward for how it's gonna improve
1:14:55with new filters and adjustments.
1:14:57So you can check it out, there's two ways to check it out.
1:14:59You can go to griditor.com, G-R-I-D-D-I-T-O-R,
1:15:04grid with two d's, I-T-O-R.com/the-talk-show,
1:15:09or you could just go to the App Store
1:15:12and search for griditor.
1:15:15can tell, and this is one of those things, too, where I just love when a sponsor is clearly
1:15:21a listener of the show because Tai Shimizu, the developer of the app, in the email where
1:15:29we're talking about what I should talk about on the show, he said at the end, "Feel free
1:15:31to mispronounce Gridditor as long as you spell it out." But I'm not quite sure how to
1:15:37mispronounce it. I feel like I've gotten into this thing now where I'm expected to
1:15:40mispronounce all the sponsor names, but like, "tonks." It's impossible to mispronounce
1:15:44it.
1:15:45tonics. I'm sorry, no, no, I'm sorry.
1:15:46Jared "JT" Baum: Grid-eater? Grid-eater?
1:15:47Pete L
1:15:49This is, you know, this is, I think this is a-
1:15:51Jared "JT" Baum; Grid-eater. Maybe grid-eater.
1:15:53Pete L A daring fireball theme in general, I think, and one of the things that I think is like,
1:15:57I love the fact that we now have all of these small developers, many of whom have figured out
1:16:02a way to make either part or all of their living and sometimes have many employees even, but there's
1:16:07still these independent shops, auteur vision, you know, the clarity of purpose. They're not answering
1:16:13to other people. There's no investors. It's just they bootstrap themselves. They're
1:16:17doing something that is what they want to do and coincidentally something that we all
1:16:21like and want to buy. That's great. Cottage economy.
1:16:24Dave Asprey Great, great app. Really, really encourage
1:16:26you guys to buy it and support the show and support really, really innovative to me and
1:16:31interface in photo editing for iOS. So the show's already gone long, but I want to
1:16:37talk a little bit about some of the news that's gone on this week. The big news, I think,
1:16:40did Steven Sinofsky get in the boot from Microsoft?
1:16:43Pete: Holy cow. Well, yeah, and I think you and I exchanged some tweets about this. The
1:16:48analysis I've seen in a few places was he was seen as the successor and was clearly
1:16:53told he wasn't gonna be. And so he said, "All right, well, that's enough. I'm
1:16:57done. If there's a glass ceiling and a bomber standing on it, so goodbye." And that would
1:17:02make sense.
1:17:03Ted: And I'll tell you, I met with him for the first time, and I guess the only time
1:17:09that he's going to be at Microsoft. I met with him. I got a nice little 10-minute meet
1:17:13at the Windows 8 event in New York two weeks ago. And I'm not going to say I have any…
1:17:21Whether he had any inkling or not, I don't think I would have been able to pick up on
1:17:25it anyway. But I can't help but think that he didn't, though, because I do feel, though,
1:17:31that he had a lot of ideas going forward.
1:17:35of the things we had talked about was that Windows 8 was designed with a more like iOS
1:17:45style update schedule in mind where it's going to be a lot easier for people who have,
1:17:50let's say, like a Surface to get an upgrade, you know, when if Windows 8.1 comes out or
1:17:55something, I don't know, pick a version number. But it's going to be a lot more like the
1:17:58way that iOS devices and Android devices, more like the mobile world where devices or
1:18:03updates can get pushed to you and you can stay, you know, new features can be added
1:18:08than the old PC world where it has been a bit of a grind and a lot of people don't
1:18:13upgrade until they buy a new machine. And he seemed very excited about that.
1:18:17Pete: Yeah, I'm wondering if it's, you know, they shipped 8 and they huddled with
1:18:22the board and whatever and he said, "Okay, you know, I did this thing, we met the markets
1:18:26out there, we did an incredible thing and what's next?" And was told, bombers here
1:18:32we're re-upping him as CEO or you're not going to get more responsibility.
1:18:35Because it was weird, you know, he didn't fail. He did a great job. I mean, for all the flaws that
1:18:40we could point out with Windows 8 or Surface or strategy, you know, there's a lot of things. But
1:18:43I think this is Microsoft's the best thing they've done, I don't know, since when.
1:18:48Jon Streeter Well, he has two
1:18:50two successes. He has two successes under his belt with Windows. And Office was always,
1:18:56Office never hit those roadblocks. You know, he used to be in charge of Office and Office
1:19:01continued to ship on time through that dry period, the XP years where Vista was stuck forever.
1:19:07You know, when it was called Longhorn, and they actually had to give it a new name just
1:19:12because Longhorn had been, just had gotten sold, you know. So Windows Vista shipped and was,
1:19:20you know, widely, you know, collectively considered a bad, you know, pretty, pretty
1:19:25terrible release, unpopular, not well designed. That's when he took over Windows. He had nothing
1:19:30to do with Vista. He was in charge of Office then. So they said, "All right, Sinofsky's
1:19:34done a good job with Office. We'll give him Windows." Windows 7 is a huge hit.
1:19:38Pete: Absolutely. It's a terrific release.
1:19:40Steven, it was an improvement in every way and shipped on time.
1:19:44Pete; Yeah, address what ALSR, right? It's got, it had better security. I mean, Rich
1:19:47Mogul said that Windows 7 had better security than of which 10.6 or 10.7, that they had
1:19:53done so much more that was right. And you see that that's when all the malware people
1:19:57had moved to -
1:19:58Steven; Looked better.
1:19:58moved to flash and third-party apps because they could no longer exploit Windows as effectively.
1:20:03Jared: Looked better, worked better, solved what was their biggest technical problem,
1:20:06which was the security stuff, and I can't emphasize it enough, most importantly, shipped
1:20:11on time. Then, Windows 8, huge innovation in terms of the interface and the conception
1:20:18of it, you know, true revolution in the interface of Windows, shipped on time.
1:20:24Whether or not you agree with the choices they made, they were not muddled choices.
1:20:28I mean, you could say they're muddled and they're trying to be too many fish and fowl and whatever.
1:20:31But in terms of execution, they did exactly what they said, and there'll be improvements.
1:20:36It's kind of a 1.0 in certain aspects.
1:20:38They're doing Surface. It's an entirely new kind of product for them, what they're trying to achieve with it.
1:20:43But I mean, all that aside, it's like, yeah, they did it. They managed, they did Windows 7, they did Windows 8.
1:20:47Windows 8. They've got Windows Phone 8 is, I mean Windows Phone was a huge deal I think, you know,
1:20:53to get that out the door and then to upgrade that. And they've made painful, they actually made Steve
1:20:57Jobs like choices where they're like, although I think it was unfortunate if you're Windows Phone
1:21:027 owner and thought you'd be able to get an upgrade to 8, they still did it. They didn't say,
1:21:06because this is the problem. I knew a guy who worked in continuing engineering at Microsoft
1:21:10for a number of years until several years ago, and it was in the XP to Vista days. And there was so
1:21:15They had so much cruft, they had a support forever
1:21:18in Windows.
1:21:19One of the reasons Windows never got better
1:21:21until I would say seven is that seven cut off
1:21:24a lot more of the past.
1:21:25That's why you have this big XP7 gap.
1:21:27You can't just move, and you couldn't move everything
1:21:29from XP to Vista either, but seven, they just said,
1:21:32we're not supporting continuing engineering
1:21:33for stuff that ran 15 years ago.
1:21:36And that's the same painful choice they made
1:21:38with Windows Phone 8.
1:21:39Whether or not they should have engineered Phone 7
1:21:41to be upgradable or not, they still made that decision.
1:21:45- Definitely, and I think the other thing
1:21:48that was very clear to me,
1:21:49I've, you know, it only reaffirmed what my guesses were
1:21:54coming into meeting him and talking to him,
1:21:55but even with just 10 minutes talking to him,
1:21:57he is clearly a product guy.
1:22:00Like, he knows the surface,
1:22:04and he knows what window it's eight is.
1:22:07It is what he wants it to be,
1:22:08and he really had a vision for what it would be.
1:22:13He is not, absolutely was not just a totem at the top of the pole.
1:22:18He drove the design of it in ways that I think were very clearly that you need somebody like
1:22:24that.
1:22:25You know, the auteur at the top of the enormous engineering team behind the whole thing to
1:22:31drive it with a vision for where it's going.
1:22:34So I would believe it was a, you know, "Okay, it's time to figure out what my next plan
1:22:38is."
1:22:39And they said, "Just keep doing what you're doing."
1:22:40And he said, "I've been here 22 years.
1:22:42I'm ready to do something else with my money and my time. Many millions and millions of
1:22:47dollars he could start to do company. There's a lot of stuff that happens in Seattle that
1:22:51could be interesting, and he could do something Greenfield that's not beholden to the past
1:22:54and take his expertise and do that. So it could be interesting.
1:22:57Well, the other thing that'll—and it just does seem oddly coincidental. A lot of people
1:23:01are drawing connections to Scott Forstall at Apple.
1:23:04Yes.
1:23:05And for the obvious reason that he was in charge of the company's flagship OS, right?
1:23:11that's both of those guys. iOS is clearly Apple's Windows, had a reputation for being
1:23:18difficult to work with, had a, you know, seems like similar complaints about their management
1:23:25style or collaboration across the company, and perhaps, you know, were ambitiously both
1:23:33wanted to be CEO of the company.
1:23:36So, yeah, I think that's it. They bump up against that, and these are people who built
1:23:39huge fiefdoms and loyalties inside the company apart from, say, loyalty to the CEO or the
1:23:46company's division.
1:23:47Dave: And I also think there's a lot of loyalty underneath them in their divisions
1:23:51to both of them. One thing that I think has sort of maybe gotten misperceived out there
1:23:56with Forstall is that the sort of, "Yeah, everybody knows he was kind of difficult to
1:24:00work with, so it's not totally shocking that this happened." Very surprising. The
1:24:05between surprising and shocking, right? It's surprising but not shocking. But then I feel
1:24:09like that's been rolled up into this nutshell of, well, Forstall was an asshole, so good
1:24:14riddance. And that's not the case at all. There are people who worked under Forstall
1:24:18who I've heard from who are very, very anxious and nervous because they think that maybe
1:24:23Forstall was the last, that he was enough like Steve Jobs and that his ambition was
1:24:29good for Apple because it made him not complacent. And one of the things I heard from so many
1:24:35worked under him is yes, he was an asshole and difficult to work with across divisions,
1:24:39but a lot of that he used to protect his people and the projects that they were doing. And
1:24:46that the people, a lot of the people who worked under him felt like Forstall had their back.
1:24:52And it's the people who were outside his team who didn't like him. So, it is absolutely
1:24:57in no way like a no-brainer, "Hey, Apple's better off without Forstall." I mean, that's—
1:25:01- That's what I hear as well is that he had a lot of loyalty. It was just if you want to do
1:25:05something you didn't want to do if you're outside his group, then it's going to be a pain. You know,
1:25:09I can't wait till from Singleton, when the talk that Michael Lop gave about, it was partly about
1:25:15building teams, like someone has to be a dictator. I mean, that was part of his, I love this talk and
1:25:18I can't wait till it's up online because everyone should watch this. And it's about, it's a really
1:25:23beautiful talk about the importance of somebody making a decision and how a group can make the
1:25:29the decision that someone has to make a decision,
1:25:31how to get to a point where someone's gonna say,
1:25:32this is it, as opposed to the Monty Python,
1:25:35like we have a rotating executive authority
1:25:38and we have a council that approves the action
1:25:40of the anarchic syndicate, you know, it's like, no,
1:25:41someone has to make a decision.
1:25:43That's the only way good things happen
1:25:45is there is a person who says that in the end.
1:25:46And if that's the boss or it's someone
1:25:48who's appointed in a group, whatever,
1:25:50but you make that decision.
1:25:51- Absolutely.
1:25:53And when it comes to making those decisions,
1:25:55the one thing that strikes me as a big difference
1:25:57between the Microsoft and Apple situations is that you look at Microsoft and over the
1:26:01last five years or so, maybe even fewer than that, but the list of top-level executives
1:26:08who are in charge of product stuff who've been, you know, whether they were pushed or
1:26:12whether they jumped, who knows, but who've left is pretty significant. Here's the list
1:26:16I have. You've got Robbie Bach, who I forget what exactly. I think he was involved with
1:26:21Xbox.
1:26:22he was, uh, he was, was he, Jay Allard you're about to say, but it wasn't the,
1:26:26Raleigh Buck I think was over top, Xbox and Zune I think was under his authority.
1:26:30Ted
1:26:30uh Jay Allard who was Xbox and designer Bach and Allard together were the guys who reputed to be
1:26:38behind the courier tablet project that got scrapped at you know and it's disputed how far along it was
1:26:44but that it was a couple years ago though and there's you know a potential there that those
1:26:49guys could have shipped a a innovative tablet type project a couple of years ago if they had been
1:26:55allowed to. Ray Ozzie out, you know, obviously was widely seen as a possible next CEO of
1:27:02the company. And Steven Elop, who was forced out and now is the CEO at Nokia. And this
1:27:09is not, you know, and I wish I'd written her name down. But it's Sinofsky's second
1:27:16in command who's taking over Windows for now.
1:27:18Oh, yeah, she sounds kick ass. I was reading about her background and her approach and
1:27:21the people skill stuff that's talked about is like she could be a, she sounds like she's
1:27:27going to be a really terrific replacement from where she comes from.
1:27:31I've got to look this up because it's not right.
1:27:33What do you think I can Google for?
1:27:36Sinofsky replacement?
1:27:37Exactly.
1:27:38A lady replacement for Sinofsky.
1:27:40Someone pointed out there's two women, I mean this is a Microsoft thing.
1:27:42Microsoft's always been heavily male.
1:27:44Julie Larson Green.
1:27:46Yeah, yeah.
1:27:47And she just, she sounds absolutely phenomenal in a very positive way.
1:27:51And she is getting a lot of credit for spearheading the design of Metro, what I still can
1:27:56insist on calling Metro, which is great. So, it does sound like there's not exactly,
1:28:01it's not like, you know, there's a vacuum that Sinofsky's out.
1:28:04Pete: Yeah, and Ray Ozzie, before Ray Ozzie left, you know, he re-architected the entire approach
1:28:08to data storage and the cloud and everything Microsoft was doing. So, it sort of lost a little
1:28:14bit of Azure and SkyDrive and all the things around Microsoft Live or Windows Live, whatever
1:28:20they call it. I think all of that stuff either he is responsible for or moved it all together.
1:28:25And I think it's hidden from most people what a transformation that is from a company
1:28:29that was based on, you know, everyone has a personal computer and all the data is stored
1:28:32locally situation.
1:28:33Right. Absolutely. And I think that's, I absolutely think that's a big part of the
1:28:38appeal of Windows 8 is that it's built from the ground up with, and Windows Phone 8, that
1:28:43it's built with the ground up that you give it your live.com or whatever they call it
1:28:47Now your Microsoft, you know, their equivalent of iCloud.
1:28:50You give it your login and your data just syncs to the cloud.
1:28:54- I kind of love that.
1:28:56I mean, 'cause that's something that Apple could do.
1:28:58I still have this idea that Apple is very solipsistic,
1:29:00that it thinks, it talks about sharing and home sharing
1:29:03and networking and whatever,
1:29:04but it still thinks about one person in one computer
1:29:07and one person on one computer.
1:29:09And over time it's gotten better,
1:29:11but the fact that they don't give you enough,
1:29:14I mean, even iCloud doesn't really think about you
1:29:16being in different places at different times
1:29:18on different devices the way people actually do it.
1:29:20It's getting there.
1:29:21I think it still needs more improvement.
1:29:22- It's a great way to put it, solipsistic.
1:29:24That is true though, the company is,
1:29:27it's in Apple's DNA.
1:29:30- Yeah, home sharing for instance,
1:29:31when they introduced it on iTunes,
1:29:32they're like, oh this will be great.
1:29:33And it's like, home sharing is a home sharing,
1:29:34it's about copying stuff between machines.
1:29:36Apple is always about copying, not syncing, and not sharing.
1:29:39They wanna move copies of data.
1:29:41I mean that's iTunes match,
1:29:42and they move it, stream it, whatever.
1:29:44And I can't tell you the number of people who said,
1:29:46wish my iPad could have user accounts so I could have my kids stuff on it in mind. I
1:29:50mean, that's not a—that wouldn't break Apple's model of how the iPad works. It
1:29:55would be an enhancement. But they just want you to buy multiple iPads. That's it.
1:29:58I guess. I don't know. But anyway, no offense to Julie Larson-Green, who it does seem like
1:30:02is a good choice to take over at Windows, but she's moving up into the executive ranks
1:30:07at Microsoft. In terms of longstanding top-level product-focused executives, they're all
1:30:13out.
1:30:14Yeah.
1:30:15Whereas at Apple, it's still, even with some reasonable amount of turnover over the years,
1:30:21with Bertrand leaving and Avi Tevainian before him and Rubenstein and Tony Fidell.
1:30:29- There's a long list, but the funny thing is, there's a long list of people who left Apple at
1:30:32a high level, but there's still a long list of people who've been there for a long time.
1:30:35- Right, Johnny Ivey.
1:30:36- They brought people through and up. So you have 10-year-plus veterans or 15-year veterans
1:30:41or people go back to Next even having lost like seven or eight names you could list off.
1:30:45Ted: Right. So, in the, you know, not to be gruesome, but let's say the hit-by-a-bus
1:30:50scenario where Tim Cook needs to be replaced suddenly or surprisingly,
1:30:54they have a wide range of candidates right there within the company to think about. And Microsoft
1:31:03doesn't. It does seem like there's a bit of a Shakespearean, you know, that Balmer is a sort
1:31:09of nervous king who, as soon as anybody rises up, they're out. Their heads come off.
1:31:16Pete: I think it's true, and it's very easy to fail at Microsoft at the things you need to
1:31:19succeed at, and Sinofsky did a remarkable job actually succeeding at them. It's so hard to
1:31:26get anything done that requires breaking silos there, and I think Surface, I think Windows Phone
1:31:327 and 8, Surface, even to some small extent, Zune, because it let them, they were creating a new silo
1:31:38that just bypassed all the existing departments.
1:31:41And in Windows 8, all these things required cooperation
1:31:45and integration among people who don't want to work together.
1:31:47And he made it happen.
1:31:48And I mean, that's what I'm excited about
1:31:49with the new Apple organization is the old sort of breakdowns
1:31:54didn't make sense.
1:31:55And the new thing of like services, software,
1:31:56and hardware is much more sensible in terms
1:31:59of what they need to get done.
1:32:00Then they have to work at a high level across those groups.
1:32:02But Microsoft has so many fiefdoms
1:32:04that it is very, very easy to be put
1:32:06in charge of a high-profile project
1:32:07project and fail because you cannot break through the other high profile people who
1:32:12don't want to do the thing you need to succeed.
1:32:14I could not agree more, and I really think you just nailed it. And I do think that is
1:32:18– and that's what I'm left at looking at the difference between Apple and Microsoft
1:32:22from a structural standpoint, especially post-Forstall, is this lack of product-focused silos, right?
1:32:30Where Forstall had – he owned iOS. He – you know, Forstall was iOS, and that was his fiefdom,
1:32:36And it was obviously, if you look at Apple, what iOS means to Apple, it's a powerful
1:32:41fiefdom.
1:32:43There isn't anything like that left anymore.
1:32:45And I think the idea is going forward, if Apple is going to continue to stay on top,
1:32:51they need the same sort of mindset they've had for the last 15 years, which is this lack
1:32:55of fear of cannibalizing themselves, right?
1:32:59It doesn't matter if the iPhone makes people stop selling buying music playing iPods
1:33:06Because they're just playing their music on their iPhone because they're still buying another Apple device
1:33:10It doesn't matter if the iPad makes people stop buying
1:33:14MacBooks or buy fewer of them because they're buying an Apple device
1:33:18And so if they come up with something that makes people say I don't know stop buying iPhones or stop buying
1:33:24iPads as long as it's an Apple product, it's okay, but they don't want to have powerful executives
1:33:29in charge of those things who are blocking it.
1:33:32- This is the first time Microsoft's been in that position
1:33:34where they had the thing that could replace their cash cow,
1:33:38right, because they own stuff
1:33:39and the way they've even licensed
1:33:41and have a stake in the success of the phone,
1:33:43if people stop buying PCs, they're great.
1:33:45They're like, if they sell a billion surfaces
1:33:48and PC sales drop 95%, they're in great shape.
1:33:51And that's the first time since ever
1:33:53that's been true for Microsoft.
1:33:55- So the way Apple's set up is that there shouldn't be
1:33:59executives blocking that because whatever the new great thing is the hardware is going
1:34:03to be designed by Johnny Ive and the software I guess now will be visually and maybe you
1:34:09know it's unclear what his role software will be but you know it's going to be design
1:34:14is Johnny Ive's that's what he does so it doesn't matter what product the marketing
1:34:19is going to be done by Phil Schiller doesn't matter it doesn't you know Schiller doesn't
1:34:22have to worry about something it's not like Phil Schiller is in charge of iPad marketing
1:34:26He's in charge of all Apple marketing.
1:34:29The software is gonna be engineered
1:34:31by Craig Federighi's team, right?
1:34:33So nobody really has a product-centric beefdom to protect
1:34:38as long as it's something new from Apple.
1:34:41I think it's a very interesting way to structure
1:34:44the executives of the company.
1:34:47It's certainly not guaranteed to work.
1:34:49I mean, the big problem is you gotta come up
1:34:50with these ideas in the first place.
1:34:52But I think that's clearly the vision.
1:34:55- Ivis, the vice president of,
1:34:58or director of Bauhaus, I think,
1:34:59is he's gonna be all form follows function,
1:35:01whatever that means inside the company,
1:35:03where he doesn't have to direct the way the hardware works,
1:35:06but he's gonna be responsible for the interaction with it,
1:35:09as I think he has been.
1:35:11I wanna know what big Bob Mansfield comes up with.
1:35:14What is his next direction?
1:35:15'Cause he is clearly like, I think Bob Mansfield,
1:35:18not that he's been underrated,
1:35:19but the guy is responsible for so much innovation there.
1:35:23So much of the behind the scenes things,
1:35:24clearly the manufacturing side and the advances in hardware, he has been key in making those
1:35:30things happen that allow the company to sell the iPad at $500, it was introduced and so
1:35:35forth. So I want to know what he's working on next.
1:35:36Just think about what – I mean, I think Mansfield gets a huge amount of credit for
1:35:40this. I believe. I'd be shocked if he didn't. But just think about what's happened to
1:35:46battery design over the last 10 years. Like, it used to be something – I mean, I can't
1:35:50even remember the last time that I saw a review of an Apple product where it did complain
1:35:55about the unremovable battery. Like, they've finally crammed it through everybody's heads
1:35:59out there that this is the way to go with battery design.
1:36:02Is to—
1:36:03Yeah, I see more and more—you see more and more reviews where they're complaining about
1:36:05the battery life of other devices. That's flipped on its head tremendously, you know.
1:36:09And other devices now have built-in batteries too, because they've gone with the shaped
1:36:12lithium thing as well.
1:36:14these crazy shapes that like almost spill like a liquid through every available…
1:36:20Pete: It's like foam.
1:36:21Ted: Every available square millimeter of space inside the device is taken up by a battery,
1:36:27I think is a huge, you know, Mansfield-driven innovation. I think that the, you know,
1:36:33the way that people think about battery-powered devices is hugely influenced by what he's done
1:36:40over the last 10 years.
1:36:41What's funny is I got the craziest comment on it. I wrote an Economist blog entry about
1:36:45Skeuomorphism. And I wasn't saying Scott Forsall was fired because of it, but I said we could
1:36:49see changes because he was a proponent of it and Ive is not. And a lot of people hate
1:36:54some of the wares that crept in. So I wrote a piece called "Skew You," right? And there's
1:36:58a crazy commenter on it who's like, "Apple does not make hardware. Apple contracts all
1:37:03its hardware manufacturing. It is not responsible for it." And I'm like, "You can't even begin
1:37:07to respond to it. It was just this wonderful thing. It's like, I don't think you understand
1:37:12what making means anymore. Making is now, it's the fabulous chip design thing that goes back now for
1:37:19decades practically, is companies that make electronics are responsible for,
1:37:24it's the architectural side of it and the manufacturer is now competitive. They can
1:37:29find the best firm to do it. This whole thing about Samsung, maybe they stopped working with
1:37:34With Samsung, great.
1:37:34There are plenty of other companies
1:37:36who'd be delighted to pick up a multi-billion dollar
1:37:38contract for screens and other things.
1:37:40You know, it might take time to get production ramped up,
1:37:42but it's out there.
1:37:44- Well, and look at what Apple has done with things like
1:37:46unibody aluminum construction, right?
1:37:49I mean, this is something that,
1:37:50there were no devices that were like this,
1:37:52and now all of Apple's devices are like this,
1:37:54where they start with blocks of aluminum
1:37:56and drill the case out of one solid piece of aluminum.
1:38:00- Love that.
1:38:01- Is there anything left that Apple makes
1:38:02isn't—can't be described that way?
1:38:04Pete: Ah, the Mac Min… No, wait a minute. I'm sorry, the Mini, I've got one in front
1:38:08of me. The Mini… Well, no, I think they do. I don't think that's actually constructed.
1:38:12I'm feeling it right now. No, you're right. It's actually carved out.
1:38:14Ted, Apple TV is not aluminum, right? That's plastic.
1:38:17Pete Yeah, that's right. But that's about, no,
1:38:18I think you're right. The airport express is plastic too.
1:38:22Ted Couple of gadgets. Maybe, but I still think that the best way to think of Apple TV is not
1:38:25really as a device but as like a peripheral.
1:38:27Pete Yeah, absolutely. I can't wait. I want Apple
1:38:30TV to add Wi-Fi and then it can be an Apple Express TV and you're all done.
1:38:34You don't need that.
1:38:34I guess the Mac Pro is probably not Unibody. I don't know what you'd call it.
1:38:37Not yet. Well, the next one will be obviously. The next one will be...
1:38:41But all the MacBooks are, the iMacs are. Now with the latest revisions to the iPhone and iPad,
1:38:48they all are. And it's hugely innovative that you start with these blocks of aluminum and drill
1:38:55things out of it. And it gives their products this incredible build quality and feel difference
1:39:00that is unlike everybody else's. You know, like truly a blind person can really sense
1:39:07a visceral aesthetic difference between Apple products and competing products.
1:39:11Right. And they started down this path. I think materials science has been an overlooked
1:39:15part of, I shouldn't say overlooked because you see it sort of from the outside, but I
1:39:18think like even the Bondi Blue, the original translucent plastic they used that no one
1:39:22else was using for computers. I think it was already in vacuum cleaners, wasn't it? There
1:39:26were some famous things at the time. But I think Apple, since I've came on and since
1:39:30Jobs came back, they have looked to material advances as a way to more fully express the
1:39:36vision in a way that other companies have been unable to. And other companies say, "All
1:39:40right. Oh, well, they're doing that. We'll do that because we can use that material too,"
1:39:43as opposed to, "Why is no other firm looking for the next interesting material advances
1:39:48that would give them a unique, innovative look?" I mean, Samsung, we're looking
1:39:51at the profit Samsung is producing now, I want Samsung, I want Microsoft to be making
1:39:56stuff that is as interesting as what Apple does with the same functionality and same
1:40:02build quality. There's no excuse for them not doing it for profit or design side.
1:40:06Dave: I don't think Samsung even tries, but I will give Microsoft credit with the
1:40:11Surface for trying, and I think that the Surface is the closest I've seen to Apple-style
1:40:17build quality. It is very nice, I think. And they also, even from a material standpoint,
1:40:22I don't think it's as nice as the aluminum, but I do think that the magnesium, whatever
1:40:28stuff they're using is pretty good. Pete: But don't you want, don't you want
1:40:30to wake up one day and say, "Company X is doing something that is new." I mean,
1:40:35that's why we all felt about the UI for Metro. It was like, "Oh my god, Microsoft has broken
1:40:39the window, broken through the glass here and done something." I want the same feeling of hardware.
1:40:42I want to get up one day and say, "Ah, this thing is, oh my god, what they're doing with
1:40:47the technology, with the science, it's beautiful, it's functional, it's unique, and it's in advance.
1:40:52And I want someone to do that that's not Apple and is not a company that sells $20,000 components
1:40:58of some kind. Right. Exactly. Let me toss it—we've gone on long enough, but let me toss out
1:41:03something. I have to bring it up because I've seen it on Twitter too many times because it sounds so
1:41:08soap opera-y perfect is the idea that either one or both of Sinofsky or Forstall will switch teams,
1:41:15and maybe Forstall will take over software at Microsoft and/or Sinofsky would end up at Apple.
1:41:20- That would be hilarious. I don't know what the culture class would be like. I could imagine
1:41:23Forstall going to Microsoft because they're looking for something different, innovative.
1:41:26They could give him a ton of power and he could just come in and do what he wants to do,
1:41:30break heads, fire people, and hire new folks and make changes. I wonder if Sinofsky
1:41:35brought into Apple would be able to be slotted into a position where he would
1:41:41feel like he had enough authority because of the structure.
1:41:43- I don't think there's any chance
1:41:45Sinofsky would wind up at Apple
1:41:46because I don't think there's room for him, right?
1:41:48Craig Federighi's already there in charge of software
1:41:51and I think that's the only sort of position
1:41:52that he would take.
1:41:54I think it's more likely that he's gonna do something
1:41:57like Tony Fidell who'd started Nest.
1:41:59- Exactly. - And I think the same
1:42:00is true for Forstall too.
1:42:02He is so ambitious and he's clear,
1:42:04he is so smart and so successful.
1:42:08I have no doubt in my mind that we have not heard
1:42:12the last of Scott Forstall.
1:42:14But I would expect it to be something more like
1:42:17what Fidel did with his own startup
1:42:20and being the CEO and doing something outside.
1:42:23I don't know, who would have thought thermostat, right?
1:42:26- No, I saw that.
1:42:27Well, it's like Sonos.
1:42:28Sonos was, and not top level Apple people,
1:42:30but some great mid-level Apple people started Sonos
1:42:33and it's like the gold standard.
1:42:35It's been around what, for 10, eight or 10 years now?
1:42:37And Sonos is the Apple of home stereo equipment.
1:42:41something out there that's under our noses
1:42:44and none of us see it, but something like that.
1:42:46- It's cars, because a car automotive systems
1:42:49are terrible almost uniformly,
1:42:51and Microsoft actually develops one of them.
1:42:53There's six million systems equipped with OnStar
1:42:57that are turned on right now.
1:42:58I mean, I forget the number that have OnStar built in
1:43:00that aren't activated.
1:43:01There is room for some really tremendous work
1:43:03at automotive integration in car entertainment systems
1:43:07and logistics and whatever, and that's a space.
1:43:11I mean, Forstall has exactly the right experience outside,
1:43:13I forget the automotive side, but the making that part work
1:43:16and there's a ton of money there.
1:43:18- The thing I can't-- - That's my prediction.
1:43:19- I couldn't see Forstall going to Microsoft either,
1:43:22though, really. - Yeah.
1:43:23- Unless they wanted to give him something new
1:43:25that he could do from the ground up.
1:43:27He's not gonna take over Windows, though,
1:43:28because he already had an OS
1:43:30that was exactly what he wanted it to be.
1:43:33iOS, there's nothing in iOS that Forstall didn't want in it.
1:43:36- Right, interesting. - It's exactly, you know,
1:43:38It is the – everything including the programming language you use to make it and the framework,
1:43:43which is this second generation version of the next thing that Forstall had been working
1:43:48on since 1989 anyway, was all exactly what he wanted and all of it very, very different
1:43:53than Windows. There's no way he's going to go in there and take over Windows because
1:43:56it's –
1:43:57Oh, wait, wait. John, I want to ask you something quickly though before it works for so long.
1:43:59So OS X running on ARM, right? Going to happen.
1:44:02Oh, def – I would be shocked if it's not already running on ARM.
1:44:06- 'Cause that's a four stall theme,
1:44:08but it's, I mean, right, they've gotta have it in the lab.
1:44:10Of course they have it.
1:44:11- Right, I wouldn't be surprised if it's the exact same lab
1:44:13where it used to run on Intel.
1:44:15- Exactly.
1:44:16- You know, in the PowerPC days.
1:44:17- iOS is on ARM, so of course, and it's, you know,
1:44:20I don't know exactly how compiled and divergent
1:44:22it is at the kernel level,
1:44:23but one suspects that they've been running stuff
1:44:25on multiple kinds of chips, including ARM,
1:44:28since they released OS X, or two years or three years
1:44:32before they released OS X in iOS form, one assumes.
1:44:35So I heard that rumor and I was like,
1:44:38that doesn't seem like a big transition at all.
1:44:40I mean, it'll be hard for the programmers,
1:44:41but Rosetta made that transition.
1:44:43If they can do the same kind of thing,
1:44:45if they can have a new Rosetta for ARM,
1:44:47if it's capable, which I think it would be.
1:44:49- I would be flabbergasted if they didn't have,
1:44:53as an engineering principle throughout all of Mac OS X,
1:44:56just hard and fast rules in place that you've,
1:45:02don't put any, don't program anything
1:45:04in Intel-specific in here.
1:45:05if you really do need to go and do something in assembler, here's, you know, block it off
1:45:10very, very neatly so that it can be duplicated, you know, in a processor agnostic fashion.
1:45:18Pete: But it seems totally logical to me. I heard the rumor and I was like, well,
1:45:21fine. I mean, why not? Because that uncouples it again from another point failure and they have
1:45:26much more control over arm chips and manufacturing of various abilities.
1:45:31And I do think it's easy to forget just how much more performance
1:45:35Heavy Mac OS X is than iOS just based on you know, just based on the on the on the
1:45:41The the the rules for process lifetime, you know that you can run multiple things side by side and that you your Safari tabs
1:45:51Continue processing JavaScript in the background as opposed to on iOS where as soon as you leave Safari, it's all put to sleep
1:45:57But think about all the stuff they've added to Mac OS X in the last two releases along
1:46:02those lines of if you follow these APIs, your app might be put to sleep.
1:46:07Absolutely.
1:46:08Right?
1:46:09And I think that, you know, I think that has performance benefits on Intel, but I think
1:46:12it's very, very clearly about keeping their options open going forward.
1:46:16I mean, imagine—
1:46:17And there's the core thing, too, though.
1:46:18I mean, there can be ARM trips.
1:46:20You can have 16 core and 32 core.
1:46:22ARM trips are multiple.
1:46:23I mean, not that they're magic or anything, but I think Apple's done everything it can
1:46:27with Grand Central or all their multi-processing, multi-threading and all that is that conceivably
1:46:33you could slipstream in a supercord thing that's not eight, you know, like what's the
1:46:38top now? I think the Mac Pro is eight. Is there a double quad core or something?
1:46:42I think they've got a 16 too.
1:46:44They're 16, but conceivably, you know, I keep reading about that's the only drop in advance
1:46:48past advance.
1:46:49No, but it's all about… Grand Central Dispatch is all about one thing, which is the idea
1:46:52that you're going to have slower, more energy-efficient cores, but more of them,
1:46:57and that that's how performance is going to increase, and how can you best take advantage
1:47:01of that in a way that's friendly to developers, that doesn't make their minds explode with all the
1:47:07ways that parallel programming traditionally could. No, and imagine, just imagine a MacBook
1:47:15Air that's arm-based, how much thinner and lighter it could be. It could be, you know,
1:47:19All of a sudden it might make our existing hairs look fat and heavy. I mean, and then
1:47:23Apple's design, Apple designs inexorably go in the direction of thinner and lighter.
1:47:32- Yeah, I don't even think like imagine something that's even smaller than a Mac Mini. I mean,
1:47:37I assume that for Apple that the Mac Mini actually feels big to them now. So something that was even
1:47:43smaller and had all the capability, it's got a solid state, only sold with a solid state drive,
1:47:47with ARM processors so it runs cooler, has Thunderbolt and USB 3, and that's it.
1:47:52So…
1:47:52And I would also say, too, don't count them out on the iPod front either in terms of, like, getting…
1:48:00not just thinking about ARM chips that are powerful enough to run Mac OS X in any fashion,
1:48:07but think, too, about ARM chips that are small enough to be on, like, a nano-type device.
1:48:12Yes, yes, because they have the—it's the diversity of the ARM ecosystem that I think
1:48:17is—it's not only can they bid out where it gets made. They have greater flexibility
1:48:22and control and cost and sources, but that the range of ARM is so huge compared to what
1:48:28Intel can offer them right now on the sort of monolithic CPU scale.
1:48:33Think about like an ARM chip or a system on a chip, in Apple's perspective, where you're
1:48:37thinking about a device that says like watch size like the old Nanos but therefore because
1:48:43it's so small you don't need to worry about powerful graphics processing because whatever
1:48:47this screen has even if it's a retina screen at that size it's not going to require significant
1:48:51graphics processing. Just think about a little tiny super low power thing with the CPU of
1:48:57like an A5 Bluetooth 4 and you know what kind of crazy things you could do with such a little
1:49:03a little thing.
1:49:04Yeah, the i-pebble. Oh, wait, someone's already made that. I did not buy a Pebble watch, but…
1:49:08I did. I don't know where it is, though. When are they coming out?
1:49:11Sometimes. Hey, Elevation Doc finished shipping last month, and they now have lightning adapters
1:49:15and soon someday lightning connectors. So it'll all come around.
1:49:19Yeah. Well, Glenn, thank you very much for being here. This is a great show.
1:49:22Pleasure. So nice to talk to you.
1:49:23I want to thank our sponsors again, Tonks Coffee, Best Coffee in the World, and Gridditor,
1:49:29or as I like to call it, grid-a-tor, a really, really innovative and useful photo editing app
1:49:37for iPhone and iPad.
1:49:38[BLANK_AUDIO]