Podcast Search

The Talk Show

357: ‘Fluent Cupertinoese’, With Nilay Patel

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I actually got to say last week, good to see you.

0:00:03And now it's like what, every other month we see each other.

0:00:06It's back.

0:00:07- Yeah, it's great.

0:00:08Hopefully we'll see each other in October at the next event.

0:00:10Like, being in person at that event was,

0:00:14I think Apple got a boost.

0:00:15I think all of us like boosted our review scores.

0:00:18Because we were just like happy to be together.

0:00:20- I think so too.

0:00:21What do you think?

0:00:22So before we, let's just skip over

0:00:26what is easily two hours of news if we talk real fast.

0:00:30And of course I don't talk fast.

0:00:31And just speculate about the future.

0:00:33So Apple typically has an October event.

0:00:35Sometimes they'll postpone it to like early November.

0:00:38Everybody's expecting iPad Pros,

0:00:40which are overdue for a refresh.

0:00:42And some sort of Mac hardware now that the M2 debuted

0:00:45with the MacBook Air at WWDC.

0:00:49Do you think, in times past,

0:00:52they've held these October events all over the country.

0:00:55One time it was like at a Chicago Tech High School,

0:00:57Brooklyn Academy of Music a couple of years ago,

0:01:00which was a really fun show.

0:01:02Do you think they're gonna do something like that?

0:01:03Or you think with the COVID restrictions still in place,

0:01:05it is 100% certain we're going back to Cupertino?

0:01:08- I think we're going back to Cupertino.

0:01:11I mean, I'm just assuming.

0:01:12Like one, it was great to be in the theater.

0:01:15They've started doing some additional security screening.

0:01:17I think you pointed out one of your posts.

0:01:18Like it's just easier.

0:01:21And second, they haven't used that theater in like two years.

0:01:23I think they're just excited to be home.

0:01:25- I do too.

0:01:26Well, and I also think that there's still,

0:01:28I mean, like one of the things, and I don't blame them.

0:01:30This is not a complaint.

0:01:31And I might've complained if they had required us

0:01:35to wear masks indoors for this event.

0:01:38In fact, I would have,

0:01:39'cause I think that would have been nonsense

0:01:40given the current state of COVID.

0:01:42But they didn't because I think they're on board,

0:01:44but they did require all attendees to provide a test score

0:01:48from the last 24 hours.

0:01:50So they're still worried enough about COVID

0:01:52that they're doing that.

0:01:53So I can't see why they would take the chance

0:01:56of planning an event off campus

0:02:00if they still think COVID is enough of a, hmm,

0:02:04you never know.

0:02:05And when COVID has gone bad with new waves,

0:02:08it goes bad quickly.

0:02:10- Yeah.

0:02:11I appreciated that they're still doing the test results.

0:02:13Like that's what I need.

0:02:15Like I'm with, no one was wearing a mask.

0:02:17Maybe like a handful of people.

0:02:18But I was like, you know what?

0:02:20I know that Apple has taken it seriously enough

0:02:23to require these test results.

0:02:25So like, I'm going for it.

0:02:27Like I'm hugging everybody.

0:02:28Like that was great.

0:02:29And I just appreciated that.

0:02:30- Yeah, and they fixed the process from WWDC

0:02:33where everybody who attended

0:02:34also had to provide test results.

0:02:37But the website they're using it,

0:02:39I forget what the name of it is,

0:02:40but it's like a third party provider

0:02:42where you take a home, it's just a home test.

0:02:44You don't need like one of the fancy go to a lab tests.

0:02:46You just take the type of test

0:02:49that the federal government sends everybody for free.

0:02:51And you take the test within 24 hours,

0:02:54take a picture of it and send it to them.

0:02:56My first thought was, well,

0:02:57how do you not just save a picture of a negative test

0:03:00and just send that?

0:03:01But there's QR codes on all the tests.

0:03:03So each test has like a unique identifier

0:03:06and the system can tell whether this one's ever been

0:03:09submitted to a system before, something like that.

0:03:11- Oh, I didn't know that.

0:03:12I had no idea.

0:03:14That's fascinating.

0:03:15- Yeah, so there's something like that.

0:03:17And at WWDC, the system kind of fell apart

0:03:19where it was like, I couldn't submit it from my Mac.

0:03:24And then I tried the next morning,

0:03:28the morning of the WWDC keynote with the same test result

0:03:32from my phone with the same picture and it worked,

0:03:36but it didn't go green.

0:03:37It went yellow.

0:03:39It was like red means you haven't submitted a test

0:03:41and green is it you're good.

0:03:42And mine went yellow.

0:03:43And I was like, well, I'm sure it will work out.

0:03:45And then by the time I got to the check-in,

0:03:47they were like, yeah, yeah, you're good.

0:03:49So yeah, I'm glad they're doing the test thing too.

0:03:52That's a good thing.

0:03:54- I think it's the appropriate precaution for this level.

0:03:57You're right, if it goes bad, it goes bad fast

0:03:59and you gotta do all sorts of other stuff,

0:04:00but it felt appropriate.

0:04:02It also felt like everyone was just happy to be at work.

0:04:06I mean, like fundamentally,

0:04:07everyone in that building is at work.

0:04:09Like we're working, we're trying to cover it,

0:04:12they're working, they're trying to guide our coverage,

0:04:14but like being able to work together is a delight.

0:04:17And I thought that was great.

0:04:18- It was funny with the security screening

0:04:20'cause I came in with Joanna and Panzarino

0:04:22and Joanna was really happy to see the security

0:04:25and I had to agree with her that,

0:04:27and I kind of put it in my coverage of the event

0:04:29that it wasn't so much that the security

0:04:31felt like an increased annoyance.

0:04:33It actually sort of felt like, hey, it's kind of weird

0:04:36that for all these years,

0:04:37we were coming to these super high profile events

0:04:40and they just kind of waved everybody in

0:04:42after checking our IDs.

0:04:44But of course I get pulled for additional screening

0:04:48and Joanna's off to the side telling them

0:04:51to look out for me, I'm dangerous.

0:04:53(laughing)

0:04:54- All the jokes you can't say at the TSA,

0:04:56you can say at the Apple security checkpoint.

0:04:58- Exactly. - That's great.

0:04:59- She's like, you better scan him twice,

0:05:01he's always hiding stuff in his pants.

0:05:02(laughing)

0:05:04- That's great, that's super funny.

0:05:05- What did you think, and I,

0:05:07this is the rare question I ask on this show

0:05:10where I know a bit of the answer

0:05:12'cause we talked in person.

0:05:14But what did you think about the fact

0:05:15that the actual keynote was entirely prerecorded

0:05:19even though we were all together in the theater on the stage?

0:05:23- I didn't love it.

0:05:25I mean, I liked being in the theater.

0:05:27I think you called out their screen.

0:05:28That screen, by the way, is entirely new

0:05:30since the last time we were in that theater.

0:05:32It used to be a projector and now it's a micro LED.

0:05:35I asked, of course I asked about it.

0:05:36It's a micro LED screen.

0:05:37It's like the industry leading micro LEDs

0:05:40or mini LED, whichever one it is.

0:05:41And so it's all new, it's completely shiny,

0:05:43they've got the big Atmos system.

0:05:45So that was all awesome and cool.

0:05:47And then to watch a movie that is actually hard to cover

0:05:51because the pacing is so fast.

0:05:54So we live vlogged these things

0:05:56and the pacing was insanely fast.

0:05:57It's like, I've gotten to be a better, faster typist

0:06:01in the past two years or so

0:06:03just by covering these things at the speed.

0:06:05And not having any of the,

0:06:08like it just didn't, the anticipation doesn't build

0:06:13'cause you kinda know how it's gonna go, right?

0:06:16They're gonna show you a video,

0:06:17you're gonna swoop around the Apple campus.

0:06:20The person who's inevitably gonna,

0:06:22Dan Riccio's gonna show you the Mac.

0:06:24Like you just know all these characters in this way

0:06:26and you kinda know the structure of them now

0:06:29because they're movies and they've fallen into a,

0:06:32just like any good movie falls into a structure,

0:06:34they've fallen into a structure.

0:06:35Whereas I think the live events had a little bit more

0:06:38adrenaline, a little bit more chaos,

0:06:41a little bit more surprise to them.

0:06:43I don't think that they're the point.

0:06:45Like I could just watch the keynote in my hotel room

0:06:48and go to Apple Park and get what I need

0:06:50out of the visit to Apple Park,

0:06:51which is talking to people and holding the things

0:06:54and going to briefings.

0:06:55Like that's the important part.

0:06:57But if you're gonna put us in the theater,

0:06:59I would prefer a live show.

0:07:03- I think I would personally,

0:07:04but I also think they've made the right choice.

0:07:07Like if I were on the team there making the decision,

0:07:12it's like I see the trade-offs.

0:07:14I think for them they're making the right choice,

0:07:16but we are the ones who suffer.

0:07:18And thematically, we could tie this in later,

0:07:21it is sort of like the decision to go eSIM only

0:07:24on the iPhones where you know who suffers the most?

0:07:27People like me and you.

0:07:28Because we're the ones who are trying to,

0:07:31I mean literally just this week it would have been nicer.

0:07:33I've got three iPhones in my possession, new ones to test.

0:07:37It really would be nice to go back to the old way

0:07:39of just 30 seconds with a paperclip

0:07:42and my SIM is in a different iPhone.

0:07:44And it's the same way.

0:07:45I think that the experience for the media

0:07:47in the Steve Jobs Theater is worse

0:07:50because it's less drama,

0:07:51it was always better to have the drama.

0:07:54The pace, the faster pace is so much better

0:07:56for the people at home.

0:07:57It's more of a show.

0:07:58But for us taking notes, the faster pace is worse.

0:08:02And when we were home the last two years

0:08:05watching these like everybody else at home,

0:08:08what did we do as soon as the keynote was over?

0:08:10I would rewind a bit and go back to the parts

0:08:14where I felt like maybe it went too fast.

0:08:16Whereas last week, what did we do after the keynote was over

0:08:20we're immediately flushed into the hands-on area

0:08:24and the pace is still super fast.

0:08:26'Cause it's like, how do I get my hands on all this stuff?

0:08:28How do I see this?

0:08:29Oh, there's somebody to talk to, I wanna talk to them.

0:08:31And you don't get to catch up and go back

0:08:34to what flew by in the keynote until hours later.

0:08:38- Yeah, I agree with you that on balance,

0:08:43the audience is bigger on the internet

0:08:45than can fit in that room.

0:08:46That room was too small when they built it

0:08:47'cause their events are just been getting bigger and bigger.

0:08:50- The whole campus is too small.

0:08:52Honestly, it was like they made this giant spaceship ring

0:08:56and famously, it was one of the last things

0:08:58Steve Jobs was involved with.

0:09:00He's the one who made the presentation

0:09:01to the Cupertino Town Hall and it sounded humongous.

0:09:04And by the time it was finished,

0:09:06Apple's head count had exploded past where it was in 2011.

0:09:11I think if they could have replanned it,

0:09:13the spaceship would have been even bigger.

0:09:15(laughing)

0:09:16- It's huge, just to be clear.

0:09:19And it's also like in the middle of the neighborhood.

0:09:21It's just truly one of the stranger experiences

0:09:24you have driving out to it.

0:09:25But yeah, the theater,

0:09:27I remember the first time I walked into it,

0:09:29someone said, "It's already too small for what we wanna do."

0:09:33So I think they know their audience is bigger outside.

0:09:36But the value for me going in person

0:09:39is seeing you and gossiping with you for five minutes

0:09:41and then talking to the executives

0:09:44and being able to hold the product immediately

0:09:47after it's announced is completely underrated.

0:09:49Nothing on the internet looks like

0:09:51it does in person in my opinion.

0:09:52- Yeah, that's so true.

0:09:54No, the colors are the main thing I,

0:09:57one of the main things I missed.

0:09:58It's talking to people face to face

0:10:00is number one, the biggest thing.

0:10:01Whether it's friendlies like you and Joanna and Panzarena

0:10:05or Apple people, right?

0:10:07And getting off the record three, four minutes

0:10:11with Phil Schiller or Alan Dye or whoever else

0:10:15and other people whose names,

0:10:17people I know whose names listeners might not know.

0:10:19But just getting little bits like that,

0:10:21you cannot get that without the face to face.

0:10:24- Yeah, there's just an element of

0:10:27you ask different questions on Zoom briefings

0:10:31than you would in person.

0:10:32It's just like the stakes of every remote conversation

0:10:35seem higher to me.

0:10:37So in person, I was like, really, Dynamic Island?

0:10:40Like tell me about this.

0:10:41And then on a Zoom call or whatever,

0:10:43it's like a very formal question.

0:10:44And you do a different kind of journalism in person,

0:10:49so I appreciate that.

0:10:50- Yeah, I'm trying to think what else.

0:10:51Oh, yeah, I was gonna say the second thing that I missed

0:10:54other than face to face is seeing the color of things

0:10:57in person. - Yes.

0:10:58- I would almost say two extremes, right?

0:11:02Where with the Apple Watch Ultra,

0:11:05to see the orange, which I really love,

0:11:07orange is one of my favorite colors.

0:11:09And I think that they really nailed it.

0:11:12I think it is just the perfect orange for this.

0:11:15And then with the iPhone's 14 Pro,

0:11:18they all still look gray.

0:11:20Even in their perfectly lit hands-on area,

0:11:24to my eyes, you could see like deep purple's purple.

0:11:27But when I tried to take a photo of it,

0:11:29the camera kept, my 13 Pro kept white balancing

0:11:33to make it gray.

0:11:34- That's fascinating.

0:11:37At WWC, I had all but forgotten how to use my camera.

0:11:39(laughing)

0:11:40Like I was there with David Pierce and we're like,

0:11:42oh, we are rusty.

0:11:43We have no idea what we're doing.

0:11:44We haven't used these things under pressure in two years.

0:11:47So we were a little bit better this time.

0:11:49But yeah, it's hard.

0:11:50Apple's lighting is basically perfect.

0:11:53It's hard to complain about.

0:11:54But it's still capturing what your eyes see as color

0:11:59and what the camera, it's a forever challenge.

0:12:03It's actually one of my favorite sort of like

0:12:04live tech journalism challenges is like,

0:12:07getting a good photo under pressure is like fun.

0:12:11I enjoy that piece of it.

0:12:13- I am, luckily, I mean, it's both by design and by talent.

0:12:18Don't really publish live photos from the event.

0:12:22I love taking photos.

0:12:23I'm an avid and I have always been avid

0:12:26prosumer photographer.

0:12:27But there's a reason I'm not a professional photographer.

0:12:30I don't really have a talent for it.

0:12:31And I'm blown away.

0:12:33I try to take photos as though I might publish them.

0:12:37And I see other people's photos of the exact same thing

0:12:41in the exact same hands-on area that I was trying to take.

0:12:44And theirs look great and are really cleverly framed.

0:12:47And mine look like somebody's shoulder

0:12:49is standing in front of me.

0:12:50(laughing)

0:12:52- One of my all time favorite moments

0:12:54from a decade of doing this now,

0:12:56which is an incredible thing to say,

0:12:58is when the Palm Pre was announced at CES way back when.

0:13:02This is like pre LTE era and the wifi was bad at CES.

0:13:07And so I was in the trailer we had at CES

0:13:10out in the parking lot.

0:13:11And Paul Miller sprinted from the hall to our trailer

0:13:16after having taken photos.

0:13:17And he entered the trailer and he held his SD card

0:13:20aloft in victory.

0:13:22And we published the photos first

0:13:23because he had sprinted back to our trailer

0:13:25that had a hard connection with his SD card.

0:13:28And that's like, that's what I mean.

0:13:29That's the fun.

0:13:30Like there's a competitive element to doing it.

0:13:33Now, do I take photos nearly as good

0:13:35as half of the YouTubers out there?

0:13:37No, I do not.

0:13:38But every day is an incremental improvement.

0:13:41- I also continue to be blown away by the footage

0:13:44that the really good YouTubers like Marques and Justine

0:13:48get out of that hands-on scrum because it's chaos.

0:13:52It is pure chaos.

0:13:55And then you watch their videos afterwards.

0:13:57And yeah, they shoot lots of B-roll afterwards.

0:14:00They get some time when everybody's been cleared out

0:14:02and they can set up.

0:14:03But they have lots of footage that they've taken

0:14:05during the scrum and it's so good.

0:14:09- Yeah, it's good.

0:14:10They have a secret.

0:14:11We have been watching them for years

0:14:13'cause we're already a team that's competitive with them too.

0:14:15They wait.

0:14:16- Yeah.

0:14:17- They're just more patient than we are.

0:14:19And all things, a little more time,

0:14:22is like a 10x improvement.

0:14:24- Yeah, yeah.

0:14:25Yeah, and it's still, that's one thing that hasn't changed

0:14:27is the need to publish.

0:14:30And that initial scrum lasts and then everybody files out.

0:14:35And that's my secret too is in the immediate aftermath

0:14:38of the keynote, go look for people to talk to.

0:14:41Don't try to get near the products 'cause it's chaos.

0:14:44And you just wait half an hour and then all of a sudden

0:14:46it's not that hard to get near any of the products.

0:14:49- Yeah, that's exactly right.

0:14:50It's like, oh, there's a secret to success here

0:14:52and it's waiting for my impatient ass to get out of the way.

0:14:57(both laughing)

0:14:58- All right, let me take a break here.

0:14:59I'd like our first sponsors, our good friends at,

0:15:01and quite frankly, they're fueling this podcast,

0:15:04Trade Coffee.

0:15:05Look, it is crazy that so many of us enjoy

0:15:07the finer things in life and so many of us still settle

0:15:10for blah, coffee every day.

0:15:12With Trade Coffee, you can start every morning

0:15:15with something special.

0:15:17I drink, well, I don't drink a lot of coffee all day.

0:15:20I make a big pot of coffee in the morning

0:15:22and that's my coffee 'cause if I drink more coffee

0:15:24later in the day, then it screws me up pretty bad.

0:15:28But one big whole pot of coffee in the morning,

0:15:30man, that's my breakfast.

0:15:32And look, I can't think of a better way to start.

0:15:35It really, it gets me out of bed in the morning thinking,

0:15:38you know what, I'm gonna get up, I got something to write,

0:15:41I got something to read, something I'm excited about

0:15:43and I'm gonna have some delicious coffee to get started.

0:15:46The thing to know about coffee,

0:15:47I emphasize this every time I talk about trade,

0:15:49is coffee is produce.

0:15:51Even though it's been roasted, it goes bad.

0:15:54It's a perishable good.

0:15:55What you want is fresh coffee and anything sitting

0:15:57on a shelf like in a supermarket,

0:15:59no matter how cool the brand is,

0:16:01might have started off as excellent coffee.

0:16:03But by the time it's sitting there on the shelf,

0:16:05it's already going bad.

0:16:06It's losing the flavor.

0:16:08When you subscribe to Trade Coffee,

0:16:11you get fresh coffee mailed directly from roasters

0:16:14all over the country sent fresh to you.

0:16:17It is just days old by the time it gets to you

0:16:19and it is so fresh and it's just the easiest way.

0:16:23And then you never have to go shopping.

0:16:24God, I hate going shopping.

0:16:25And even worse than that, I hate running out of coffee.

0:16:29Well, I never run out of coffee

0:16:30because I've got a subscription.

0:16:31So what you do is you sign up at Trade,

0:16:35they give you a quiz.

0:16:36The quiz asks you what type of coffee you like.

0:16:38They get you started.

0:16:39You say how much you wanna get to it.

0:16:42Once a week, once every other week.

0:16:44They're so flexible, it's crazy.

0:16:45And then once you have the subscription,

0:16:47you can pause it if you're going away.

0:16:50You can change it at any time if you're like,

0:16:52you know what, once a week is too much for me.

0:16:53I should go like every 10 days

0:16:55or I should go every 14 days or something like that.

0:16:57You can change it at any time.

0:16:59And as you're getting their coffee,

0:17:01you can rate it if you want.

0:17:03You can ignore it otherwise

0:17:04and just let them keep sending what they send you.

0:17:06But you can rate it and they'll use your ratings

0:17:09to dial in which other coffees you might like

0:17:11and send you that stuff.

0:17:13And I gotta say, it really works.

0:17:14The longer I've been subscribed to Trade,

0:17:16the more I'm liking the coffee they're sending me.

0:17:19So if you wanna support small businesses,

0:17:21because again, they source the beans

0:17:23from small roasters all over the country

0:17:26and brew the best cup of coffee you've ever made at home.

0:17:28It's time to try Trade Coffee.

0:17:29Right now, Trade is offering talk show listeners

0:17:32a total of 30 bucks off your first order

0:17:35plus free shipping at drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.

0:17:39That's drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.

0:17:44And you get 30 bucks off your subscription

0:17:46to the best coffees in the country.

0:17:48Let's talk the stuff that was actually announced, right?

0:17:53iPhone 14s, the reviews all dropped.

0:17:57Well, most of them dropped on Wednesday.

0:18:00(laughing)

0:18:02- Yeah, to make it clear,

0:18:04I'm on this show because I texted Jon

0:18:06and said, "Where's your review?"

0:18:08- No, you said, "Are you reviewing the phone?"

0:18:10(laughing)

0:18:12- Yeah, did you just quit this year?

0:18:13Are you just out?

0:18:14(laughing)

0:18:16- I had nothing to say.

0:18:18- I'm looking at it now, it's like 20,000 words.

0:18:23- It's actually longer than usual.

0:18:25I knew it was gonna be longer than usual.

0:18:27There's a couple of, number one,

0:18:32I'm a slow writer and I'm always late,

0:18:34and so it's my fault.

0:18:35And if I had any sort of deadline,

0:18:39ability to hit deadlines in my brain,

0:18:42I still could have done it.

0:18:43So it's on me, I'm not making excuses.

0:18:45But they didn't give us the phones until the next day.

0:18:49And traditionally, the day of the keynote,

0:18:52then in the afternoon, the press briefing,

0:18:55the one-on-one briefings where they hand reviewers

0:18:58the kit you're going to get happen,

0:19:00and then you can get started.

0:19:01Well, those didn't happen until the next day.

0:19:04And the event wasn't on a Tuesday, it was on a Wednesday,

0:19:07'cause it happened in Labor Day week.

0:19:10So everything got pushed back a week.

0:19:12But they always launched the things on the next Friday.

0:19:17That's set in stone and has never, ever, ever

0:19:20been an exception to it, right?

0:19:21Phones always come out on a Friday.

0:19:23So effectively, to hit the embargo, we only had five days.

0:19:28- Yeah.

0:19:29- Which, a week for me, is really pushing it.

0:19:32And I don't shoot video, but for me,

0:19:34a week is really pushing it.

0:19:36And it turns out, it took me a week.

0:19:38(laughing)

0:19:40- Well, so candidly for me, we just kinda dropped

0:19:43the battery life testing.

0:19:44But you can't do it.

0:19:46Like, we were tracking it, but without that extra

0:19:50couple days, the way you wanna do it is you just wanna

0:19:52use the phone as normal for as long as you can.

0:19:55But we were shooting videos and looking at photos.

0:19:57We had to turn the brightness up and point a camera at it.

0:20:01And it's like, all I can tell you is that I think

0:20:05the battery runs down a little bit faster

0:20:06on the Pro than usual.

0:20:07I'll let you know in the future.

0:20:10But that was very candidly the thing I had to just let go.

0:20:12- Yeah.

0:20:13I kind of put something similar in my review

0:20:16where it was something, something to the effect of,

0:20:18look, when I'm testing these phones,

0:20:20I'm shooting way more video than I usually do,

0:20:23taking more photos, and just using it more, right?

0:20:25Because as opposed to in a normal week

0:20:29where I might think, hey, I've been dicking around

0:20:31on my phone too much, I should sit down at my Mac

0:20:33and get to work, right, and work.

0:20:36And I've got a sort of thing in the back of my head saying,

0:20:39don't waste too much time on your phone.

0:20:41When you're testing a new phone to try to develop

0:20:45a fully formed opinion in five days to get a review

0:20:50that you think is going to stand the test of time,

0:20:52you're using the phone all the time.

0:20:54You're trying to use the phone more.

0:20:56So it's literally, I really think impossible

0:21:01to simultaneously use a phone to review it

0:21:04and gauge what's the actual battery life.

0:21:09And the only way to gauge battery life, in my opinion,

0:21:12is to just sort of use the phone in normal use

0:21:15and then tell people, here's how the battery did.

0:21:18Because how can you test it?

0:21:19There's no test that simulates practical use.

0:21:22And it's so complicated.

0:21:24You can't run some kind of bench.

0:21:25I know that's what Apple does, is they'll just play

0:21:29streaming video until the battery runs dry

0:21:32and say 22 hours of streaming video.

0:21:35Or music playback, that's one of my favorites, right?

0:21:37If you just let it play music on battery,

0:21:40it'll last 63 hours.

0:21:41I'm making these numbers up.

0:21:42But how is that useful, right?

0:21:45- So it's interesting that they have traditionally

0:21:48used those sorts of metrics with MacBooks.

0:21:50And I sort of get why.

0:21:53It's just like, here's a thing you can do.

0:21:55With phones, I mean, and this is something

0:21:59we have chased for years, Apple has this set

0:22:01of telemetry data that they have worked into

0:22:05some sort of model where they can model

0:22:09basically an average day of iPhone processor usage

0:22:12and sensor usage and whatever usage

0:22:15against the capacity of the battery.

0:22:17I don't have access to this model,

0:22:19so we just have to use the phones like normals and guess.

0:22:23But Apple, the switch they've made, I think, this year

0:22:25with, hey, it's this many hours of video playback,

0:22:29like in the past, they would just say like 12 hours

0:22:32of battery life or whatever it is.

0:22:33'Cause they have a model, and that's why Apple's

0:22:36traditionally better at underestimating

0:22:38their own battery life, because they have the data

0:22:42about iPhone usage that lets them do it

0:22:44in a way that they kind of can't get with the Mac.

0:22:46- Right.

0:22:47- But this one's just a weird one.

0:22:50- Yeah.

0:22:51- Especially on the Pro, because of the always-on display.

0:22:53- Yeah, right, and again, we've only got so much time.

0:22:57Most of the time, we wanna spend using it.

0:22:59I like to try to use it the way they intend you to use it,

0:23:02and the way they intend you to use the new 14 Pros

0:23:05is with the always-on display at its default setting.

0:23:09And so any sort of determination of, well,

0:23:12what happens if you turn off the always-on display

0:23:15and just have it go off like all the other iPhones

0:23:19in existence, does that actually give you

0:23:21a day-to-day boost?

0:23:22- Well, there's no possible way you could figure that out

0:23:24in a week while you're simultaneously testing the phone.

0:23:27It's not possible.

0:23:28I mean, we'll find out, and it's just one of those things

0:23:30where I didn't wanna worry about it,

0:23:32'cause it's like, we'll be able to do it.

0:23:33It's just, we won't have it.

0:23:35You and I won't have it in this golden week

0:23:38where we've got the new iPhones and nobody else does, right?

0:23:41I mean, it's going to come out if battery life

0:23:43actually suffers because of the always-on display.

0:23:46- Yeah, my instinct is that it,

0:23:51I mean, this is in your review too.

0:23:52We're starting with the least interesting thing.

0:23:54- I know, we really are.

0:23:55- We're gonna build our way up to yonder.

0:23:56But it's a really weird always-on display.

0:23:59- No, I don't think it's the most,

0:24:00to me, it's the second most interesting thing.

0:24:02It's not the second most important thing,

0:24:04but I called it super interesting,

0:24:06'cause I think it is incredibly interesting.

0:24:09So I think it's okay to start with it.

0:24:11It's a wild always-on display.

0:24:13I mean, the thing I wrote in my review is,

0:24:16honestly, what did I say?

0:24:17Microjolt, thousands of microjolts of panic all week long

0:24:22every time I glance at it.

0:24:24Because before my conscious brain can register,

0:24:26yes, this is the new phone with an always-on display,

0:24:29I immediately think, oh my god, my phone's broken.

0:24:32Something's gone out of control

0:24:34and the battery's ragingly depleted

0:24:36because I haven't touched it in half an hour

0:24:38and the screen is still fully on.

0:24:40- Yeah, no, it's really weird.

0:24:42So I was sitting next to Becca Farsacce,

0:24:44our video director who was making the review with me,

0:24:47and we both had them, and both of us, all day long,

0:24:51were tapping on the screen,

0:24:52'cause we were like, why is this on?

0:24:53It's just strange.

0:24:54I mean, Apple's late to the game here,

0:24:57and Android phones have had this forever.

0:24:58And mostly what Android phones mean by always-on

0:25:02is mostly-off.

0:25:04Like, the game they have played is they can drop,

0:25:06they can turn off most of an OLED display, it goes to black,

0:25:09and they can selectively light up some pixels

0:25:11to show you a clock.

0:25:12- Right, and maybe like a signal strength indicator,

0:25:14like the status bar stays on or something like that,

0:25:17but you get the date and the clock in ghosted-out white

0:25:20on an OLED black, and it's--

0:25:22- It looks fine, right?

0:25:24And now there's like however many years of iteration,

0:25:26seven years of iteration on Android.

0:25:28So now there's customizations,

0:25:30there's the different manufacturers have different looks,

0:25:32the off-screen looks different than the lock screen.

0:25:34It's a whole world, it's a whole ecosystem

0:25:37of always-on displays.

0:25:38And Apple's like, it's your lock screen, but dimmer.

0:25:41(laughing)

0:25:48- I actually dug out my old iPhone 5S and powered it on,

0:25:53and I actually have a suspicion that the new phone

0:25:58in always-on state is about as bright as like

0:26:02(laughing)

0:26:03a 10-year-old iPhone with sort of default brightness settings

0:26:06It's that bright.

0:26:07I'm not joking.

0:26:09Like I wrote in my review,

0:26:10if the phone sort of malfunctioned or broke

0:26:13or like three years from now it was sort of flaking out,

0:26:16and the maximum screen brightness was,

0:26:19that I could ever get was about as bright as it gets

0:26:22in always-on mode.

0:26:23You could totally use the phone.

0:26:24Like the way that people will use a phone

0:26:26with a cracked screen that isn't all that cracked.

0:26:29There's all sorts of ways your phone can get damaged

0:26:31and people still use it.

0:26:32I was in New York on Wednesday for an all afternoon meeting

0:26:36that again, another reason my review was late,

0:26:39but you know, my fault.

0:26:40But it was interesting to travel with the phone,

0:26:42but for reasons could not, had to happen this week,

0:26:45even though ordinarily I'd go to extraordinary lengths

0:26:48not to schedule anything during iPhone review week.

0:26:50But I was on the train from Philly and I saw a guy

0:26:53and I was like, whoa, that's a wild looking phone.

0:26:55I think it was some kind of Android phone,

0:26:57but he'd obviously, it wasn't cracked,

0:26:59but about one third of the way over on his screen

0:27:04while holding it in a regular up and down vertical format,

0:27:08there was like this lightsaber bright vertical line

0:27:13from the bottom to the top, perfectly straight,

0:27:15maybe about 10 pixels wide.

0:27:18Like the clearly the brightest the screen could possibly get

0:27:22just permanently just, and I salute him.

0:27:25And the guy obviously wasn't, he was well-dried,

0:27:28had a full suit on and he's like, ah, fuck it.

0:27:30And it's like sort of a cool look really.

0:27:32- That's just his wallpaper look.

0:27:36- No, I thought it was his wallpaper,

0:27:37but then I saw him flicking around and it's like, oh shit,

0:27:40man, it looked like a cool wallpaper.

0:27:42And instead it's like,

0:27:44that's just how his phone looks all the time.

0:27:46But I swear if that's as bright as the iPhone 14 Pro

0:27:49ever got, you could totally use this phone

0:27:52except maybe in bright light.

0:27:54But I have to say too, on the way home from New York

0:27:58down to Philly, I was like, there's a five, yeah,

0:28:01five o'clock, five to six Acela.

0:28:04And around this time of year, the sun is getting lower

0:28:07and it was a really nice day Wednesday.

0:28:09So the sun was, and I happened to sit on the sunny side

0:28:13of the train and super bright sunlight

0:28:18streaming through the window of the train

0:28:21onto the table desk.

0:28:23I don't know what you call those things on the Acela.

0:28:25I guess it's a table.

0:28:26I'm typing on my MacBook Pro,

0:28:29actually writing my review for squeezing another hour

0:28:32of writing in with the phone sitting next to it.

0:28:36And because the sun was so bright,

0:28:38the phone detected that it was bright.

0:28:42It is insane how bright the always on was

0:28:45while it was bathed in the full rays

0:28:49of mid September bright sunshine.

0:28:51It was shocking.

0:28:53- Yeah, yeah, I think they missed a trick with it.

0:28:56I think it would have been better if it was more off.

0:28:59And they allowed some of these,

0:29:00there's a lot of new widgets.

0:29:02Like the whole Dynamic Island

0:29:03is basically a new widget system.

0:29:05So I get there's only so many more widgets

0:29:07they can demand of developers.

0:29:10But there's a move here where they actually make it

0:29:13more different than the lock screen

0:29:15and that makes more sense.

0:29:16And I think they just need to get there.

0:29:17And what they will say is we didn't want to do

0:29:19the always on the cover analysis doing so we did it our way.

0:29:21And it's like, well, there's, you didn't,

0:29:24it's sometimes it's fine to piggyback

0:29:26on seven years of Android iteration.

0:29:29And that whole huge market has landed on mostly

0:29:32black and white for a reason.

0:29:34- I do think we have this weird,

0:29:38and it's been here forever, not forever,

0:29:41but for as long as the iPhone Sam dominant era

0:29:46of smartphones has existed, let's say 2010 onward.

0:29:51This and it doesn't seem to be ending anytime soon

0:29:54where Apple and the entire Android industry

0:29:59are have this very strange relationship with each other.

0:30:03And I know some people go nuts when I pointed out,

0:30:07but it's like the Android side will at times

0:30:12shamelessly copy from Apple.

0:30:14There's a new Samsung Galaxy home app,

0:30:18which you cannot believe when you see it

0:30:21that it's not the iOS home app.

0:30:24I mean, it's not just at a glance.

0:30:27It's like you would actually have to get there

0:30:28and like really look at the fonts to see,

0:30:30oh, that's not San Francisco.

0:30:32That's the Android font.

0:30:33It is so cool.

0:30:35It's one of the most preposterous ripoffs I've ever seen,

0:30:38which is ridiculous because everybody thinks iOS

0:30:41is home app stinks, right?

0:30:43It's one of my least favorite interfaces

0:30:46that Apple has ever come up with.

0:30:48I, it boggles my mind that this is still the home interface

0:30:53and yet Samsung copied it.

0:30:54And then on the flip side, Apple seemed,

0:30:57not that they haven't, there's certainly ideas

0:30:59that were Android first that they've taken, right?

0:31:01And notifications, iOS was way behind on like a notification.

0:31:06They didn't even have a notification center

0:31:08until after it was well-established on Android.

0:31:11So there are ideas that have gone Android first.

0:31:15I'm not saying that Apple doesn't take anything

0:31:17that comes from Android and then do it,

0:31:19but there are other times where it seems like

0:31:21their pride keeps them from following something

0:31:25that they didn't do first when they should.

0:31:28- Yeah.

0:31:29Yeah, and there's an element of that copying back and forth

0:31:31is it's kind of just related to switching costs.

0:31:34Like one of the reasons things tend to look

0:31:37like the Apple way is 'cause asking someone

0:31:41to think about a new way of turning on the light bulbs

0:31:43in your house is too much.

0:31:46So might as well just look like the phone you had before.

0:31:48Like the amount you can gain by reinventing that

0:31:53is very low compared to the amount of,

0:31:56well, actually we need you to like Android notifications

0:31:58overall are way different, right?

0:32:01Apple is just like insistent that you're gonna think

0:32:03about things their way even when the best way

0:32:06has been kind of like I'm saying, relentlessly iterated on

0:32:09in the biggest phone markets in the world

0:32:11in China and India, right?

0:32:13Like that's where Android phones are huge.

0:32:15And there's ferocious competition

0:32:18for the best always on display.

0:32:19And you can just like boost it

0:32:20and no one's gonna get mad at you.

0:32:22(laughing)

0:32:24- So the first thing, and I spent the most words on,

0:32:29is just the fact that it really, and I think most people who,

0:32:33obviously my site in particular is from people

0:32:36who are fully permanently all in on the iOS side.

0:32:40And the biggest lock-in is honestly just the way

0:32:43that your mind is sort of as a human, right,

0:32:46locks into the way the system works, right?

0:32:51I remember at like sort of the peak

0:32:53of Mac versus Windows competition.

0:32:56And I would say it's epitomized by the era

0:33:00when Adobe, Photoshop and Illustrator,

0:33:05and like when InDesign was new,

0:33:09and that those were really the only apps designers used.

0:33:12And Adobe had really pulled off the very difficult feat

0:33:17of complete parity between them.

0:33:20And the Mac user interface nerd that I am combined with

0:33:25at the time being a designer was annoyed by all the ways

0:33:28that Adobe's previously gloriously Mac human interface,

0:33:33consistent apps had sort of gone in a,

0:33:38not in a Windows way, but the way that app,

0:33:41big companies like Adobe that are trying

0:33:43to pull off something like that

0:33:44sort of developed their own language, right?

0:33:46They developed an Adobe style of interface

0:33:50that was on Mac and Windows.

0:33:52- Kai's Power Tools is my favorite.

0:33:54- Yeah, yeah, oh that's. (laughs)

0:33:57- Just like what is happening here?

0:33:59- I used to enjoy, we had it at the student newspaper

0:34:03and we, I used to, I never used it.

0:34:05I never did a damn thing with it

0:34:06because obviously the stuff that Kai's Power Tools did

0:34:09is not my style of design, but I loved firing it up

0:34:12just to like, just to play with it 'cause it was glorious.

0:34:15No, but it really was, and if your job was

0:34:19using Photoshop and Illustrator and that's it,

0:34:22you could have easily just switched from Mac to Windows

0:34:25or vice versa because the Adobe tools

0:34:27really were completely compatible,

0:34:28but nobody did it because you just, one side or the other,

0:34:32you were locked into the way the file system was organized

0:34:34and stuff like that.

0:34:36So my readers are obviously on the iOS side of things.

0:34:39I think that they're gonna be like me

0:34:41where obviously Apple's very late to the idea

0:34:44of having an always-on iPhone display.

0:34:47And for years, the longer you've been on the iPhone,

0:34:50the more I think ingrained it is is the idea

0:34:53that one of the top ways to preserve your battery

0:34:56is to keep the screen off as much as you can

0:34:59and going back further in time,

0:35:02to keep the brightness a little dimmer

0:35:05than you'd like it to be, and you could really eke out

0:35:07a lot more all-day battery life

0:35:10in the early era of smartphones.

0:35:13By keeping the brightness,

0:35:14this doesn't actually look great,

0:35:16but you keep it easy enough to read

0:35:18but not as bright as you'd really like it to be,

0:35:20but you could definitely see,

0:35:23oh, I get through all day now,

0:35:25whereas when I had the brightness up where it looks best,

0:35:27it's dead by eight o'clock.

0:35:29So it's just ingrained in your habit as an iPhone user to,

0:35:33if you're not using it, you want the screen off.

0:35:36- Yeah. - It's driving me nuts

0:35:39that the goddamn screen's always on.

0:35:41So here's the other question,

0:35:43the thing I wound up with in the review.

0:35:45- You can turn it off.

0:35:46- What is the purpose of the always-on display?

0:35:49- Cynically, my answer is they need to add more stuff

0:35:53to the iPhone every year,

0:35:55and they finally got to the point

0:35:56where this was on the list.

0:35:58I don't think there's a point beyond it,

0:36:00'cause they're not attracting Android switchers

0:36:03because they've added an always-on display,

0:36:05especially one like this.

0:36:07- I think part of it is that,

0:36:09and they wanted to do it their way,

0:36:11and their way means showing off technically

0:36:14in a way that nobody else can compete with, right?

0:36:17I don't think there's a phone on the market

0:36:18that could possibly, and like you said,

0:36:20if there is a noticeable battery life detriment to this,

0:36:24it's not so bad that we're not getting through a full day

0:36:26with the iPhone 14 Pro, right?

0:36:28I mean- - Yeah.

0:36:30No, happily getting through a full day.

0:36:31I would say that maybe they waited to add,

0:36:33this is the non-clinical answer,

0:36:35they needed to get to, what's it, the A16,

0:36:38with its battery draw against the battery in this thing,

0:36:41and they could finally add it in an acceptable rate

0:36:44of power consumption, 'cause they got the chip

0:36:47that's efficient enough to pull it off.

0:36:50I'm sure that it's some mishmash of those things.

0:36:53- Yeah, and the other thing, I don't understand it.

0:36:55If I ever had the opportunity to pick somebody's brain

0:36:58for an hour and have them explain it to me,

0:37:00I understand how going from like a 60 hertz refresh

0:37:03to 120 is technically difficult, right?

0:37:07Higher frame rate is just,

0:37:09you don't even have to understand how cameras work

0:37:12or displays work.

0:37:14Going faster is harder.

0:37:16I've never quite understood why going to one hertz

0:37:20is technically difficult, but I am to understand

0:37:23that it's actually incredibly difficult,

0:37:26that updating once per second is actually really, really hard

0:37:29and that these displays are also very, very expensive

0:37:33to produce.

0:37:34It really does justify the price delta beyond,

0:37:40marketing segmentation at just a pure cost

0:37:43to produce these devices way, the display,

0:37:46the promotion displays are really more expensive

0:37:49than the ones in the iPhone 14 non-pro.

0:37:54- Is that a one hertz difficulty

0:37:57or is that a promotion from one to 120 hertz difficulty?

0:38:00- I am to understand that, well,

0:38:01'cause you have to have promotion to go to one hertz, right?

0:38:04- Sure. - Right,

0:38:05because nobody's gonna buy a display

0:38:06that only updates it once a second.

0:38:08(laughing)

0:38:10Although I guess that's sort of like,

0:38:13I guess that's like a Kindle.

0:38:15- Yeah, it's like many e-ink displays,

0:38:17but also Apple's very serious about screen time.

0:38:19If they just locked you into once per second

0:38:21for a couple hours a day,

0:38:23I mean, how do you solve the social media problem?

0:38:24- Yeah, that would be a good thing to do.

0:38:27And if you have your kid set on a schedule like that,

0:38:29you could be like, you know what?

0:38:30You can use your phones and your devices

0:38:32as much as you want after seven o'clock at night,

0:38:34but it'll be at one hertz.

0:38:36(laughing)

0:38:38- Yeah, TikTok is effectively over-prepared.

0:38:40- Yeah. (laughing)

0:38:43TikTok at one frame per second.

0:38:45(laughing)

0:38:46Oh, that would be great.

0:38:48Mine, yeah, and the promotion part,

0:38:51the fact that it dynamically shifts

0:38:53from 120 all the way down to one.

0:38:55Also, apparently, well, of course,

0:38:56I mean, that does sound technically difficult,

0:38:59even as a total layperson not even understanding it.

0:39:01You just think, yeah, that seems really wild,

0:39:04especially if it's done in a way

0:39:05that the user is never, ever, ever supposed to notice

0:39:08and, in fact, I never, ever notice

0:39:10that it always seems to be running at 120 to me.

0:39:13Difficult to do and expensive to produce, I get it.

0:39:17Here's my non-cynical answer

0:39:19to what they think the purpose of the always-on display is,

0:39:23which is these live activities, which aren't out yet.

0:39:28So it really makes it a hard marketing sell at the moment.

0:39:34It's, I guess, coming in Iowa 16.1

0:39:38because the beta, the first beta for 16.1

0:39:41came out like two days ago and now it's been there.

0:39:43- Yeah, and they have been saying this year

0:39:45and it's September, so it feels like it's gotta be

0:39:48in this next round.

0:39:49- Yeah, but on the other hand,

0:39:50they usually get to at least the .2 by the end of the year,

0:39:54if not the .3, right?

0:39:56They've sort of, and I think to their credit,

0:39:59I think it's actually worked out great,

0:40:01even though it's badgering users to get to,

0:40:04I mean, what's iOS 15 up to?

0:40:06A 15.7, I think?

0:40:07Maybe it's 15.6 or wherever it finished,

0:40:11but they get six or seven of these point updates

0:40:15out throughout the year, all the way up through the summer

0:40:18while they're already working on the next year's thing

0:40:21and break features apart into them.

0:40:23So it's either coming out, I don't know,

0:40:25next month or sometime this year,

0:40:28but it does, if that's sort of the point,

0:40:30and it makes sense that, okay, the hardware's the thing

0:40:34that is set in motion two years,

0:40:38at least two years in advance.

0:40:39And they probably knew more than two years,

0:40:42I guess three or four years ago,

0:40:44that this would be the year when the iPhone 14 Pros

0:40:48should have this always on display.

0:40:52So that meant the software,

0:40:53and if the reason is to show off these live activities

0:40:57so that you could just leave your phone at the desk

0:40:59and have the Packers game in a live activity

0:41:04while you're doing something else,

0:41:06and every time you glance at the phone,

0:41:08the score is accurate and the time remaining is accurate

0:41:12to within 15, 30 seconds or something like that,

0:41:15it makes sense that they're coming out in the same year.

0:41:18And I think it's just, it's sort of, ah,

0:41:21unfortunately this feature and software

0:41:23wasn't ready in time in September.

0:41:26But is that even, no matter how useful these live activities

0:41:29are going to prove once we have them,

0:41:31and we don't have them yet, right?

0:41:32None of, it's not even like Apple has them

0:41:35and third parties have to wait till later this year.

0:41:38The live activities API just isn't in iOS 16.

0:41:41I still don't know if it's worth it, right?

0:41:44I don't know.

0:41:45Maybe that's just me though, that I don't,

0:41:47if I was going to follow the game,

0:41:49it wouldn't be by following it on my iPhone

0:41:53while it's sitting on a table.

0:41:55(laughing)

0:41:57- Well, maybe, I mean, there's an element.

0:41:58Do you do the thing where you flip your phone over

0:42:01when you're like at a restaurant or you're talking to,

0:42:03I do this all the time.

0:42:04- I keep it in my pocket is what I do.

0:42:07- So yeah, so I'm one of these people

0:42:09that takes their phone out and then to indicate

0:42:11that I'm actually paying attention here.

0:42:12- Right.

0:42:13- Live activities, by the way, to me overall

0:42:16seems like the feature of iOS 16.

0:42:18Like maybe the most important feature of iOS 16.

0:42:22It's hard to evaluate.

0:42:23But you know, the dynamic island is built on live activities.

0:42:27The promise of that whole thing depends on that shipping

0:42:29and developers using it.

0:42:31So I could see a world where, yeah,

0:42:34there's a game on that I want to pay attention to,

0:42:37but I'm out and talking to someone

0:42:38and instead of flipping my phone over,

0:42:39the score is updating at one hertz.

0:42:41- Yeah, but on the other hand,

0:42:42you can see how you do it.

0:42:43- Doesn't this defeat the purpose though

0:42:45with the screen being so bright?

0:42:47(laughing)

0:42:49Right, so me and you go out to lunch or dinner

0:42:53or something like that and you want to do your thing,

0:42:56which I try to keep my phone in my pocket

0:42:58in such social situations,

0:43:00but you want to make it seem as though you're engaged,

0:43:04you're present in the conversation at the table,

0:43:06but you are watching the Packers

0:43:09or trying to stay up to date,

0:43:10'cause damn it, who the hell decided to have this dinner

0:43:13when the Packers were on Thursday Night Football?

0:43:15And there's your phone at this crazy brightness.

0:43:18(laughing)

0:43:20- Right, it would make more sense at black and white

0:43:22than just the scores.

0:43:23- Yeah, again, I think Apple wants you

0:43:27to use your phone less.

0:43:28I saw Tim Cook and Johnny Ivan learn pile jobs at Code,

0:43:32and Kara is always saying,

0:43:34the reason that journalists are here is to ask questions.

0:43:36So I always go and ask questions.

0:43:37And I was like, you guys are talking about

0:43:39how much Steve Jobs hates social networks.

0:43:41You make the phones of the social networks run on,

0:43:44and he's like, yeah, we have screen time.

0:43:45We want you to use your phone less.

0:43:46And so I get it.

0:43:48There's some element of this where the always on display

0:43:52theoretically lets you use your phone less,

0:43:54because the information is passively coming to you.

0:43:57But it's so bright that it still feels like

0:43:59it's actively coming to you.

0:44:00- Yeah. (laughing)

0:44:03I guess that's, we'll see.

0:44:04I don't wanna pass judgment on the live activities

0:44:07before I've used it, because it seems innovative

0:44:10and new enough that one of those things

0:44:12where my imagination of how little I might use it

0:44:14is I might be missing the ballpark.

0:44:16- Well, I think this is why we should start talking

0:44:18about the island.

0:44:19The point of the island is live activity.

0:44:21Let's take a break though first before we do.

0:44:24I gotta take care of some business here, Nely.

0:44:26You see, you don't know anything about running

0:44:27a internet publication.

0:44:30(laughing)

0:44:31- No, I don't make any money.

0:44:32I just spend money.

0:44:33That's the great part of my game.

0:44:35- I've got bills to pay, my friend.

0:44:36Let me tell you about my good friends at Backblaze.

0:44:39This is one of my favorite long-term sponsors

0:44:42of "Daring Fireball" and the talk show.

0:44:44Unlimited computer backup for Macs and PCs.

0:44:47It is seven bucks a month.

0:44:49You can back up your documents, everything.

0:44:51All your user stuff.

0:44:52You back up your documents, your music, your photos,

0:44:55your videos, your drawings, your projects, all of your data.

0:44:58It gets backed up to their world-class data centers

0:45:03at Backblaze.

0:45:04It is great Mac software.

0:45:07You install it.

0:45:09You sign in.

0:45:10It runs.

0:45:11It is a great little interface.

0:45:13And you just don't know it's there.

0:45:16It is not one of these things like all of a sudden

0:45:18you're using your Mac and then Backblaze decides

0:45:21it's time for a backup and you can tell

0:45:23Backblaze is doing this.

0:45:25You have no idea when it's doing it.

0:45:26It just runs.

0:45:27It just runs and it just sips data

0:45:30and all your stuff is in their cloud.

0:45:33You'll never notice it's there,

0:45:34but all of your data is backed up.

0:45:37And if you ever need it, if emergency strikes,

0:45:40your MacBook gets stolen, if you spill water all over it

0:45:45and it dies, or you're just away from your computer,

0:45:49but you need something that you know is on your computer,

0:45:51but you want to get it from your phone,

0:45:53well, they have iOS, Android apps.

0:45:55You can get any of your stuff that's in your backup.

0:45:57If you need all of your data,

0:46:00you can just sign into Backblaze on another device

0:46:03and start downloading it.

0:46:04That'll work.

0:46:05That's one way to do it.

0:46:06If you just need one file from another machine,

0:46:08you can just log in, get that file.

0:46:10But what if you need everything real fast?

0:46:13Guess what?

0:46:14You can restore by mail, not email, real mail.

0:46:16They'll send you a flash key or a hard drive

0:46:19with all of your data, and they'll just overnight it

0:46:22through FedEx or something like that right to your door.

0:46:25And if you get a hard drive restore,

0:46:26you can restore it to your machine

0:46:28or to a new machine or something like that,

0:46:31and then just send the drive back to them within 30 days.

0:46:34You get a full refund for the actual drive.

0:46:37So you don't even pay for the drive.

0:46:39They'll just mail it to you overnight.

0:46:41You get the data off, send the drive back to them.

0:46:44Boom, you're done.

0:46:45I've heard from readers, knock on wood,

0:46:48I've never needed that type of restore from Backblaze,

0:46:51but I've heard from readers and listeners over the years

0:46:53who have, and they're like, "I couldn't believe it.

0:46:55I didn't think it would happen to me.

0:46:57Everybody says that I needed it right away.

0:46:59There it was, ding dong next morning, hard drive,

0:47:02all my stuff, and it really was all my stuff."

0:47:05They have restored over 55 billion files for customers.

0:47:09You can get started with a trial,

0:47:11no credit card required, at backblaze.com/thetalkshow,

0:47:16backblaze.com/thetalkshow.

0:47:19They'll know where you came from.

0:47:20It'll support the show,

0:47:22and you get a full-featured, 15-day,

0:47:24no credit card required trial.

0:47:28I use them.

0:47:29I've been using them for, I don't know, like 10 years.

0:47:31My thanks to them.

0:47:32All right, Dynamic Island time.

0:47:34(laughing)

0:47:35- So it's why I'm here, man.

0:47:37I'm playing with it right now

0:47:38while you're reading these ads, just to--

0:47:40- Oh, I love the Dynamic Island.

0:47:42- It's pretty fun.

0:47:43- I liked your take on it.

0:47:44I think you're underestimating it already, though.

0:47:46I think it's already so super useful.

0:47:48I think you get it.

0:47:49I'm not saying you're wrong.

0:47:51I just still think you're ever so slightly missing

0:47:56how genius it is.

0:47:57- So okay, my take, just for the audience,

0:47:58I mean, you should obviously go read my review.

0:48:00Stop listening to this podcast, go read my review,

0:48:01watch the video, it's great.

0:48:02My take on it is basically connected

0:48:04to my feelings about live activities,

0:48:06that Apple's building this cool system

0:48:10that will allow more apps to sort of talk to you ambiently.

0:48:13And the Dynamic Island, it's the pinnacle of that system.

0:48:18I mean, the tech behind it is cool.

0:48:21The subpixel anti-aliasing is cool.

0:48:23It really does look like a secondary display

0:48:26on top of your display, unless you're in sunlight.

0:48:29But fine, physics has some limits.

0:48:32So I think that part's really cool.

0:48:34I think as you experience it today,

0:48:39it is like most of the things that you're doing on it

0:48:43are things that you don't interact with.

0:48:44- Like I disagree. - That to me is a good.

0:48:46- All right.

0:48:47- That's the road that has to be gone down.

0:48:49- Let me say this though.

0:48:50Let me just take a moment and no joke, no sarcasm

0:48:54to tell people to go read Neelai's review.

0:48:57But really, honestly, here's where I get

0:49:01to undermine you slightly.

0:49:03Go watch the video review because that's where you capture

0:49:08the crazy subpixel anti-aliasing stuff that they're doing

0:49:13to make it super smooth.

0:49:17Even at like 460 pixels per inch on the display,

0:49:21they're actually subpixel anti-aliasing

0:49:25the round black corners of the Dynamic Island

0:49:28to make them even smoother, which I wish,

0:49:31oh, this is one of those times where I really wish

0:49:34I had my eyes from 20 years ago.

0:49:38'Cause I know I'd notice it.

0:49:40And it's like, I'm too old,

0:49:41my eyes have gone through too much shit.

0:49:43Like I could see that it looks beautiful,

0:49:45but I can't tell that they're doing that.

0:49:46But I love that they're doing it.

0:49:48(laughing)

0:49:49- Well, Apple cares more about corners on displays

0:49:54than any company in the history of the world, I think.

0:49:57- No.

0:49:58- So all on the LCD iPhones, when I saw those,

0:50:00the liquid retina branding was just

0:50:02that it was a round LCD display.

0:50:05And they had built special little apertures

0:50:07for the pixels in the corners to make them perfectly round.

0:50:10That was a whole branding.

0:50:11They branded the whole thing 'cause they were so proud of it.

0:50:14They've done OLED subpixel anti-aliasing for years

0:50:18on the static corners of the display.

0:50:21And then the Island, they talked about it.

0:50:22They have built the ability inside the A16

0:50:27to now do that subpixel anti-aliasing

0:50:29at 120 frames per second, 120 hertz.

0:50:32So that is just cool.

0:50:34Like I will appreciate that about Apple

0:50:36more than anything, I always have.

0:50:38Like they care about displays,

0:50:39they care about this level of displays.

0:50:41And so whenever I have a chance to like

0:50:44point a macro lens at a screen, I'm gonna take it.

0:50:47I'm always gonna take that shot.

0:50:49Like give me the opportunity, I'll do it.

0:50:51And so here it's cool.

0:50:52It's like hard to see, like you have to really see it,

0:50:54but no one else is doing this like this.

0:50:57Even the rest of iOS, the anti-aliasing is abstracted out

0:51:02to the sort of like the symbolic pixel level,

0:51:05not the actual hardware subpixels.

0:51:07- Right.

0:51:08Yeah, and I think you nailed it exactly right

0:51:10in your review where it's,

0:51:12and it is exactly like the way they put

0:51:17this inordinate attention into the actual round corners

0:51:20of the display to go to the greatest possible length

0:51:25that they can to make it seem like the display

0:51:29actually has perfectly round corners,

0:51:32which is not the way displays work and can't work, right?

0:51:35There are no rounded, round cornered pixels up in a corner,

0:51:40but they'll go to this length of actually going

0:51:43to subpixel anti-aliasing,

0:51:45even though the actual pixels are so tiny

0:51:48to make the hardware display look like it actually

0:51:51has the round corners that it's supposed to.

0:51:54And in that exact same way,

0:51:55they're doing subpixel anti-aliasing with the dynamic island

0:51:59to make it seem like it's a hardware cutout

0:52:02that grows and shrinks and has content.

0:52:05- Yeah, I mean, it's cool.

0:52:07It's just cool as hell.

0:52:09Like I'm saying, I think the concept is there.

0:52:12I think you are confident that a year from now

0:52:14it will realize its promise and my nature,

0:52:18I think at this point people have heard us talk about it,

0:52:20I've had fun many years in a row,

0:52:21my nature is let's wait and see.

0:52:23Like you gotta ship the API, the developer's gotta use it.

0:52:26We have to, Apple's gotta make sure that Uber

0:52:29doesn't like stick ads in it.

0:52:30Like there's a lot to come here.

0:52:33And so I'm just more on the wait and see side of things.

0:52:36- My take is that even if, I think the potential,

0:52:40it still hasn't reached the full potential,

0:52:42but where it is today,

0:52:44where I've been using it for the last week,

0:52:46even if it didn't get any better,

0:52:48it's already something I would never wanna go without.

0:52:50Here's my example.

0:52:52I was in New York two days ago,

0:52:54and I know my way around midtown,

0:52:57but I had to meet some friend, a friend and some other people

0:53:02and I just, I didn't wanna be late.

0:53:04I had just enough time.

0:53:05So I took the walking directions.

0:53:07If I weren't testing the iPhone,

0:53:09would I really have needed walking directions?

0:53:11No, the numbers in Manhattan tell you where to go.

0:53:14But I was like, you know what, let me do this.

0:53:16Let me pretend like I need the walking direction.

0:53:18So that's slightly, what's the word, constrained,

0:53:21not constrained, but construed?

0:53:23- Artificial, yeah.

0:53:24- But I was listening to podcast in Overcast,

0:53:28which has not been updated for the Dynamic Island

0:53:32because the APIs, there are no APIs for the Dynamic Island

0:53:35that are public yet, and Marco Arment obviously

0:53:38didn't know about it beforehand.

0:53:39So just using the regular version of Overcast

0:53:43that had no idea the Dynamic Island existed,

0:53:46but uses the now playing APIs in iOS,

0:53:49and like a typical tech-obsessed,

0:53:53short attention span person, while I'm walking

0:53:55through Midtown Manhattan, I'm texting people

0:53:58and tweeting and reading Twitter on my phone.

0:54:02And I've got the live directions constantly up there

0:54:06as the, I've got two things.

0:54:08Now I'm actually using two things in the Dynamic Island.

0:54:12The live directions get the left side.

0:54:16When there's two things, one of them gets

0:54:18the bigger chunk on the left side,

0:54:20and the other one just gets a little circle

0:54:23on the right side.

0:54:24That was Overcast, and I also did, I really did,

0:54:28this wasn't faked for the sense of dicking around

0:54:31with the Dynamic Island.

0:54:33While I'm crossing certain streets and stuff,

0:54:35or something happens, or I got distracted

0:54:39while I was texting somebody, and I wanted to go back

0:54:4230 seconds in the podcast 'cause I actually sort of

0:54:44wasn't paying attention there.

0:54:46It just, there I am, long press on Overcast

0:54:48in the Dynamic Island, the now playing,

0:54:51actual playback controls come down,

0:54:54I hit 30 seconds back, tap away, it goes back,

0:54:57and I'm there, and there's no context switching.

0:55:00I'm still, I never left messages.

0:55:03I'm still there in the messages conversation

0:55:06without leaving, it's no context switch.

0:55:08And oh, the turn-by-turn wants me to turn left to go,

0:55:13or turn right and go down Broadway.

0:55:16It's really useful as is without live activities yet,

0:55:20just with things like turn-by-turn, and the phone calls,

0:55:25and the now playing, and the stuff

0:55:27that already just goes there.

0:55:29And it's, to me, a real triumph.

0:55:32I've been skeptical about this whole movement towards,

0:55:36which what I think is best described as declarative UI,

0:55:41which is Swift U, and Swift UI is one example

0:55:43of this movement towards declarative UI,

0:55:45which is instead of designing everything to be pixel perfect,

0:55:50and this is exactly what it's going to look like.

0:55:52It'll have a white background,

0:55:54and it will be exactly this size or this size.

0:55:58Here's the three exact sizes it'll be,

0:56:00and here's the exact layout.

0:56:02You just declare where stuff will be.

0:56:04This goes on the left, this goes on the right,

0:56:06and this is, it's just sort of mid-size.

0:56:08Everything, without ever having known about it,

0:56:12the overcast playback controls look perfect,

0:56:15even though on the lock screen,

0:56:17which is what was known to be where now playing stuff,

0:56:22like when you're listening to a podcast

0:56:23and you can still control it from your lock screen now,

0:56:26it has a white background, right?

0:56:28So it's a total different color scheme.

0:56:30No software, no software update necessary.

0:56:35It already just works.

0:56:36It's a terrific experience.

0:56:40- Yeah, look, I'm not discounting

0:56:42that it's a good experience.

0:56:44I think what I'm saying is I think

0:56:47the point of the iPhone is apps,

0:56:50and when I am doing turn-by-turn directions,

0:56:54I'm most often in a car where I probably

0:56:57should not have another app open on my phone, right?

0:57:01I give the whole screen to that thing,

0:57:03and I did the walking directions test too,

0:57:05and I was like, I shouldn't be using my phone like this.

0:57:09That's actually how I felt in that moment.

0:57:11I am contriving some sort of test to make this happen,

0:57:17and the moment when you've got that many things going on,

0:57:22it felt like the things that are available right now

0:57:25do not rise to, I need to have these three things going on.

0:57:29I could see, okay, there's a Packers game going on

0:57:33that I need to pay attention to,

0:57:34but I'm texting someone else,

0:57:36and I've got a timer going 'cause I'm cooking.

0:57:40I can imagine the situation in my head,

0:57:43but I can't review it today.

0:57:45- I really just think it's terrific,

0:57:48but the flip side, and this is where I,

0:57:52again, I haven't caught up 'cause I didn't publish

0:57:54till super late last night.

0:57:55I've read your review, I've read Joanna's.

0:57:57Again, I'm not trying to toot my own horn.

0:58:00Maybe I'm off in left field,

0:58:03but I spent a lot of time in my review

0:58:05talking about the fact that all of these cool things,

0:58:08you can't do them, and you're not going to be able

0:58:11to do them on any other phones

0:58:13except the 14 Pro and Pro Max.

0:58:16Not the 13 Pro.

0:58:18If you bought a 13 Pro last year for 15 or $1,600,

0:58:22you don't get it, and if you buy a brand new iPhone 14,

0:58:27not Pro, this year, and you can get 'em,

0:58:31I forget how much they cost with 512 megabytes.

0:58:33They're like $1,400 or 1,300.

0:58:36They're in the same, well into the same price range

0:58:38as the Pro models with lower storage.

0:58:41You don't get this at all.

0:58:43You do get it on the lock screen, right?

0:58:46You'll get live activities on the lock screen,

0:58:48and you will get live activities

0:58:50when whatever is providing the live activity

0:58:55decides to send you an update,

0:58:57and the best example of that is one

0:58:59we're already familiar with is maps,

0:59:02turn-by-turn directions, which has worked like that

0:59:05for years already, where while you're using the phone

0:59:08and maps wants you to turn left on whatever street,

0:59:13it pops up at the top as a panel

0:59:17and tells you to do that, but you don't tell maps,

0:59:20"Hey, tell me what I'm doing again," and show that panel.

0:59:24It comes up on its own, and you also can't keep it there.

0:59:28It's fleeting.

0:59:30I don't know what the timeout is,

0:59:31but it's like five seconds or something like that,

0:59:33and no matter what you do, it's going to disappear.

0:59:37That's the experience every other iPhone is going to have,

0:59:41where you either go to the lock screen to see these things,

0:59:45or you wait for the thing to send you an update,

0:59:49whereas iPhone 14 Pro users have them up there

0:59:53in a dynamic island, and every time they want to expand

0:59:56or compact them, it's up to them.

1:00:00That is bananas to me, in a way.

1:00:02I know why Apple did it this way.

1:00:04I get it, but I can't remember in all my years

1:00:09of using the Mac, there's never been something like that

1:00:12on the Mac, where if you have a years-old Mac

1:00:17but you're using the newest version of macOS,

1:00:20it may not look as cool, but there's no major interaction

1:00:24feature that only the users of the latest MacBook Pro get.

1:00:30- I can think of one, but we all hated it.

1:00:31It was the Touch Bar.

1:00:33- Yeah, but even that wasn't,

1:00:34that was, but that was literally hardware.

1:00:39- That's true, that is true.

1:00:40I guess that Apple wants to think of this as hardware,

1:00:42so that's why my mind leaps to it.

1:00:43- Yeah, the Touch Bar's a good example.

1:00:45It's the closest they ever got with the Mac,

1:00:47but it was literal hardware, and I'll just put it in

1:00:50as an asterisk that I didn't hate it, I just didn't love it.

1:00:53I was like the weirdo who was totally ambivalent about it.

1:00:57- I was not.

1:00:58Most of the guests, most of my regular guests

1:01:00on this show are on your side.

1:01:03So I always say it in a small voice,

1:01:06'cause I feel so clearly on the wrong side

1:01:09of people whose opinion I trust

1:01:10that I suspect my ambivalence is wrong.

1:01:12- I know some people love it, but not me.

1:01:14Here's what I'll say, I think that's actually maybe fine.

1:01:16So the genius of this whole island is that it is

1:01:20an extension of live activities, which we have yet to see.

1:01:23- But also now playing, also Call Kit, also--

1:01:25- Yeah, but all that stuff is kind of rolling into it

1:01:28from my understanding.

1:01:30This is the stuff as it works now.

1:01:31There's some incoming call stuff, right?

1:01:34Call Kit can use it, but when live activities rolls out,

1:01:37those apps will get a kind of, like third-party apps

1:01:39will get a better version of incoming calls.

1:01:40So they're basically taking all these alerts and indicators

1:01:43that just sort of populate the top of your screen,

1:01:45they're combining them with live activities,

1:01:47and they're building this new alert system,

1:01:49which I think is very smart.

1:01:51I said this in the review, I love the name Dynamic Island

1:01:55because everyone wants to say it, and then I get to--

1:01:57- I do too.

1:01:59- But then I get to just talk about the nature

1:02:02and philosophy of smartphone alerts.

1:02:04- Yes, yes.

1:02:05- And I get to talk about that with you, Joanna,

1:02:10and not so many other people, but now other people

1:02:12are like Dynamic Island, and I'm like,

1:02:13let me tell you about the nature and philosophy

1:02:15of smartphone alerts.

1:02:15So that's great for me, personally.

1:02:17But developers have to buy into it, they've gotta use it.

1:02:22And so if you build the live activity,

1:02:24my understanding of it is you basically just have

1:02:28to make one other view for the widget.

1:02:31The actual logic of it, the API usage,

1:02:34even most of the display is like the same.

1:02:38You just have to build this other view

1:02:39and then this other minimal view

1:02:41where you go down to just the icon.

1:02:43That's genius, right?

1:02:45It's fundamentally genius that Apple's like leveraging it up

1:02:49all the way to the island.

1:02:51So I think a year from now, when the island comes

1:02:53to the iPhone, regular iPhone 15, or even two years from now,

1:02:57the massive users buy those--

1:02:59- I don't know this, I'm not using any little birdie info.

1:03:03I'm only speculating on how important this is

1:03:06to the marketing behind the Pro.

1:03:09It won't be next year.

1:03:10- Sure, but by the time it does trickle down

1:03:13to the mainstream phone, like the developer

1:03:16and app ecosystem will be ready for the mass audience

1:03:21to get immediate value.

1:03:22Whereas right now, we're all kind of an early adopter stage

1:03:25of how is everyone gonna use it?

1:03:27Does this make any sense?

1:03:28Let's tweet about it.

1:03:29And I don't think that that makes sense

1:03:31for the mass audience.

1:03:32- Yeah, and the thing I'm wondering about is,

1:03:35so I think there's two reasons that Apple has made this

1:03:39an iPhone 14 Pro only feature.

1:03:42Because, and I think I mentioned this in my review,

1:03:46that it's not too hard to imagine how they could have turned

1:03:49the notch into a dynamic peninsula.

1:03:53And it wouldn't look as cool, but that they could do

1:03:56something with the interface to put these same things

1:03:59up there, and like when something's going on.

1:04:02Like remember when the notch first came out,

1:04:04and there were a lot of people, a lot of people,

1:04:07it was very, super controversial.

1:04:08Because the idea wasn't that you shouldn't make screens

1:04:12that go edge to edge, it's that okay,

1:04:13but if you've still gotta put the sensors up there,

1:04:16and you're using OLED, which has these super black blacks

1:04:20that really, except in really direct sunlight,

1:04:22disguise, could disguise the notch.

1:04:26That what Apple should have done is sort of draw

1:04:29a black bar across the top, and then draw the nice

1:04:33round corners, and just make it look like,

1:04:36and then you could put the status stuff,

1:04:38like your carrier name and your wifi signal,

1:04:41and the time, put it up there in the black area,

1:04:45but then the notch wouldn't look like a notch,

1:04:47it would just look like the phone has a little black

1:04:51forehead, and magically, this white text with the time

1:04:56and the carrier and the signal strength could go up there.

1:04:59Lot of people wish that Apple did that,

1:05:01there used to be like a little temporary,

1:05:03while people were really annoyed by the notch,

1:05:05there was a cottage industry of apps to make wallpapers,

1:05:08so that you could have a real wallpaper,

1:05:10but the top of the wallpaper would be black,

1:05:12so that you'd get that sort of faked.

1:05:15You could imagine that Apple could do that in iOS 16

1:05:19for the notched phones when dynamic island stuff

1:05:24is happening on the notched phones,

1:05:27and something would happen where the whole bar

1:05:29would go black, and they'd draw some stuff on the left

1:05:32and some stuff on the right, and you'd press and hold,

1:05:35and it wouldn't look as cool.

1:05:37And from a not talking about money perspective,

1:05:43Apple being Apple, they're much more of a,

1:05:48you either get the absolute best experience,

1:05:51or you don't get it at all.

1:05:52That's the Apple way of thinking,

1:05:54and that's why dynamic island is only on the actual phone

1:05:57that can do the dynamic island,

1:05:59and you don't get any of these features

1:06:01while you're not on the lock screen,

1:06:04using the phone on all the other iPhones.

1:06:08Now, talking about money, this is the thing,

1:06:12all the commercials I saw watching football last weekend

1:06:15for the iPhone 14 were about the dynamic island,

1:06:18and I know they're gonna have a whole,

1:06:19I already looked at their YouTube channel.

1:06:21There are other commercials they've already launched,

1:06:24and they're gonna sell other things,

1:06:25and they're gonna make commercials

1:06:26for the regular iPhone 14s.

1:06:28Dynamic island is so cool

1:06:30that they're making commercials about it,

1:06:32like 60-second spots just about dynamic island.

1:06:35They're using it, and my philosophy,

1:06:39this is what I kind of tailed off my review,

1:06:42is that it's not a coincidence

1:06:43that it's debuting the same year

1:06:46that they came out with the first non-pro phone

1:06:48with the giant 6.7 screen,

1:06:51'cause that used to be a thing that they would say,

1:06:54"Oh, you want a giant screen?"

1:06:56And everybody knows a lot of people

1:06:58really love giant screen phones,

1:07:01and they're like, "Oh, well, let me tell you

1:07:02"about this year's iPhone, whatever the number is, pro,

1:07:06"which starts at $1,100,

1:07:08"because that's what you need to spend

1:07:10"if you want it on iPhone."

1:07:12Okay, now they've made it for all the iPhone 14,

1:07:16and obviously next year, the iPhone 14 will still be here,

1:07:20and it'll be $100 less,

1:07:21and then I think two years from now,

1:07:23they'll still keep the iPhone 14 Plus,

1:07:26and you'll be able to get a 6.7-inch screen iPhone

1:07:29for 700 bucks.

1:07:30- Oh, that'll be fascinating.

1:07:31- I don't know, we'll see.

1:07:33Well, it'll definitely be here next year.

1:07:35Will they keep it for two years?

1:07:37I don't know, 'cause sometimes two years down the road,

1:07:39they kind of spitefully only keep the smallest one

1:07:43with the least amount of storage or something like that.

1:07:45I wouldn't be surprised if they keep it for two years,

1:07:47if they're just like, "For this number of years,

1:07:50"we're gonna hold the max screen size

1:07:53"as a pro-only feature, and starting in 2022,

1:07:57"okay, max size screen, you're free.

1:08:00"We're gonna call you Plus on the other phones,

1:08:02"but now you're free,

1:08:03"and we'll just let you propagate down the line,

1:08:05"and we'll make as many people who want that size happy

1:08:08"no matter what their budget is,

1:08:09"as long as their budget meets the admittedly

1:08:12"relatively high cost of even the iPhone SE, right,

1:08:16"compared to the market overall."

1:08:19- My most enduring theory of consumer electronics

1:08:21is that big, cheap screens drive the world.

1:08:24- Yes, definitely, right.

1:08:26- If you just find the biggest, cheapest screen,

1:08:29that's the thing most people wanna buy.

1:08:31- Yeah, I guarantee you, if you and I just wandered into

1:08:35with a Verge crew and shot a video

1:08:37and talked to somebody in a Best Buy,

1:08:39they'd be like, "Oh, yeah, yeah."

1:08:41Everybody comes in and they're just like,

1:08:42"Oh, give me the biggest, cheapest screen you got."

1:08:44- Oh, yeah, no, this is especially true in TVs,

1:08:46where it's like, do you want a 55-inch beautiful OLED,

1:08:49or do you want the world's shittiest 85-inch TV?

1:08:52And everyone's like, "The 85-inch TV."

1:08:54- Yeah, they're like, "That shittiest 85-inch TV costs what?"

1:08:58And they're like, "Oh, it's this."

1:08:59And they're like, "Oh, give me that."

1:09:01- Yeah, it's always like $500.

1:09:03It's like, "Okay, fine."

1:09:05And everyone buys that TV.

1:09:07- But I think that it's true of laptops.

1:09:09There's a reason that crap 15-inch Windows laptops

1:09:12still sell numbers, 'cause they're just big and cheap.

1:09:15And I think that has finally arrived

1:09:18to the iPhone in some way.

1:09:19I'm not saying it's crappy, but the iPhone 14 Plus

1:09:22is just, I think, a recognition that the iPhone 13 Mini

1:09:26was great and everyone loved it,

1:09:27but what consumers really want

1:09:29when they pull out their wallets is a big, cheap screen.

1:09:31- Yep, yeah.

1:09:33So I don't think it's a coincidence.

1:09:34So they let go of this one thing,

1:09:36which was a pro-only motivator,

1:09:39and now they've got this new thing, the Dynamic Island.

1:09:42And I don't think it's gonna be pro-only forever,

1:09:45but I think it's going to be three years, maybe, maybe four.

1:09:49- Yeah. - I don't know.

1:09:50It could be, it really,

1:09:51I could imagine it being four years.

1:09:52- But I think when stuff hits that audience,

1:09:55it has to be ready.

1:09:56And I, my, you know, I think our title was like,

1:09:59"It's the Early Adopter Island" or something.

1:10:00Like, there's a lot of stuff in these pros

1:10:03that are the beginnings of ideas,

1:10:06whereas the 14 is like so complete,

1:10:09it's just the 13 again.

1:10:10And so I think when you hit that part of the market,

1:10:13the ideas have to be finished,

1:10:15everyone has to know what the limit,

1:10:16like there's no room for error

1:10:19because no one's coming on your podcast

1:10:21to spend like two hours talking about

1:10:23sub-pixel and aliasing.

1:10:24Like, whereas I think in the pro market

1:10:27and with that audience,

1:10:28everyone keeps saying that the pre-orders

1:10:30for the pro are higher than,

1:10:32and it's like, yeah, they're pre, like,

1:10:33definitionally early adopters.

1:10:36- But let me interrupt you there.

1:10:37I don't buy that at all.

1:10:39Who the hell at this point knows anything

1:10:42about the pre-orders outside Apple and Tim Cook's office?

1:10:45I saw Ming-Chi Kuo's post about it,

1:10:48and I don't know, I don't know him,

1:10:50I've never met him, and I'm a fan.

1:10:52You know, he obviously gets a lot of stuff right.

1:10:54But his post about that was, I don't know,

1:10:57I mean, he was high as a kite or something

1:10:59'cause he even put stuff in that was nonsense.

1:11:02He said, like, in his checks,

1:11:04that the 14+ was going to be in wide availability

1:11:07on launch day.

1:11:08Apple told us at the keynote

1:11:10it's not available till October 7th.

1:11:13What the hell is he talking about?

1:11:15We didn't even get them to review

1:11:16because it's coming out so late, so much later.

1:11:19Well, again, so late, October 7th is not that late.

1:11:23But I'm saying, but you know and I know

1:11:25that Apple does not seed review unit products more than,

1:11:29almost never more than a week in advance of availability.

1:11:33- And in this case, less than a week.

1:11:35- And sometimes two weeks.

1:11:37Not that I know anything about that,

1:11:38(laughs)

1:11:40but sometimes two weeks.

1:11:43But in my experience, never more than two weeks,

1:11:46except the one and only exception to that,

1:11:48which I guess we can now talk about,

1:11:50would be the original AirPods.

1:11:53- Yeah. - Way back in like 2016.

1:11:55- And they were like beta.

1:11:56- Yeah, and they told us these are actually

1:12:00last stage prototypes.

1:12:02I guess prototypes may be the wrong word, pre-production.

1:12:05These are last stage pre-production units.

1:12:09And then when the actual AirPods shipped

1:12:11like a month or six weeks later,

1:12:13that was like the first and ever only review unit product

1:12:16where they immediately called me and said,

1:12:19"We would like you to send those back today.

1:12:21"And we've got a box, we've got a FedEx guy

1:12:23"coming to your house now to pick them up."

1:12:25- Yeah, and it was a weird exception.

1:12:28So the plus, Ming-Chi Kuo saying that the plus

1:12:32was gonna be in wide availability on launch day,

1:12:34which is today, the day you and I are talking,

1:12:37is I don't know what the hell he's talking about.

1:12:39But meanwhile, because Ming-Chi Kuo said it,

1:12:42it's all over the world that the iPhone 14 regulars

1:12:48are not in demand and the 14 Pro Max is in high demand

1:12:52and 14 Pro is in medium demand.

1:12:53And you look at his methodology, it's crazy.

1:12:56His sources are clearly all in the supply chain

1:13:00and he gets great information out of them.

1:13:02I mean, nobody else is quite like Ming-Chi Kuo

1:13:05in terms of information from the supply chain.

1:13:07But in terms of knowing the launch day pre-orders,

1:13:10whatever Apple is going to do to adjust

1:13:13their supply chain orders hasn't happened yet.

1:13:17So I think that's nonsense.

1:13:18I don't think anybody outside Tim Cook's office

1:13:21knows anything about which phones have been ordered

1:13:24how many times.

1:13:25- By that quote also, he reached, he was like,

1:13:28he arrived at a conclusion that makes no sense to me.

1:13:30He was like, this product segmentation strategy is a fail.

1:13:33It's like, I have no idea.

1:13:34- Well, he definitely has no idea.

1:13:36- What are you doing?

1:13:37But all I meant was the people citing that to me

1:13:41is evidence that my big cheap screens theory is wrong.

1:13:44It's like, no, no, no.

1:13:44The early adopters are always gonna find it from all.

1:13:47Even if you believe this or don't believe it,

1:13:50nothing about pre-order data tells you what is gonna happen.

1:13:53- Right.

1:13:54It's definitionally early adopters.

1:13:56- Who's buying a phone to actually go and pick up

1:14:00on Friday the 16th so that they can have it

1:14:04in the morning on the first day that it's available?

1:14:09Who back 10 years ago was lined up outside

1:14:14their local Apple store on Friday morning

1:14:18at six in the morning, three hours before the store opened

1:14:21so that they could get one?

1:14:22- It's early adopters, and what are they gonna buy?

1:14:25People like that aren't gonna buy a mid-range phone.

1:14:29And then vice versa, who's going to be buying

1:14:33a brand new iPhone 14 something next August?

1:14:38Right?

1:14:40- Yeah.

1:14:41- It's the people who don't care.

1:14:42And you could tell them.

1:14:43You could say, hey, Apple's probably coming out

1:14:45with new phones in two weeks, and they'd be like,

1:14:47yeah, I don't need them.

1:14:48I don't care.

1:14:50And you know what they're gonna do?

1:14:51They're gonna walk in the store,

1:14:52and they're gonna say, yeah, I love a big phone.

1:14:54And they're like, well, you can get the Pro Max,

1:14:56and it's 1100, or the regular Pro Plus, or 14 Plus,

1:15:01and it's 900, and they'll be like, 900?

1:15:05Yeah, that's the one I want.

1:15:06- Yeah, I mean, we'll see.

1:15:09Like I said, my theory is on a long enough timeline,

1:15:13the big, cheap screen always wins, right?

1:15:14And it's just sort of true, and the screens

1:15:18keep getting bigger and cheaper, so everyone's happy.

1:15:20- I don't think, and I was, I'm not always right.

1:15:23I was, my personal taste in relatively smaller phones,

1:15:27and again, I never actually bought a Mini,

1:15:30although I think I might have two years ago

1:15:32if I were a little, if I had been younger,

1:15:34and my eyes were better.

1:15:35But I did buy, that was the year I did buy,

1:15:37I didn't buy the Pro.

1:15:38I bought the regular iPhone 12,

1:15:40because I just thought the 12 Pro,

1:15:42I wasn't impressed by the camera,

1:15:44and thought in the fall of 2020,

1:15:47I'm not going anywhere for a while.

1:15:48We're locked, this COVID thing is clearly here all winter.

1:15:51What do I need a camera for?

1:15:52I'll buy the one that's lighter,

1:15:54and that I think feels better in my hand.

1:15:56I was, thought, ah, maybe I should just get the Mini,

1:15:59but I really, it's like, ah, I'm almost 50.

1:16:03I'm gonna, I need the bigger screen.

1:16:05But to me, the 6.1 in size is a little too big.

1:16:09But I get it.

1:16:11My taste in smaller phones had me off the trail

1:16:16of the Android side racing ahead to truly,

1:16:20what we used to call 'em, phablets, right?

1:16:22- Yep.

1:16:23Yeah, I mean, I'm a Macs phone person,

1:16:25and this thing's a phablet.

1:16:27- Right.

1:16:28- It's this close to being seven inches.

1:16:30- Yeah, I was off, I was wrong about that, clearly.

1:16:33And it's obvious in hindsight.

1:16:34I remember the first time,

1:16:35I had to do something in a Verizon store,

1:16:37easily 10 years ago.

1:16:39And it was before Apple had really big phones,

1:16:44the plus ones, right?

1:16:45So, and it came out in the Samsung trial,

1:16:48like, wasn't it a Phil Schiller email

1:16:50that people want big screen phones that we don't make,

1:16:54something like that, you know?

1:16:55- Yep, and Tim Cook was like, just do it, stop it.

1:16:58- And the problem is, it's the,

1:17:01and if you look at that email compared to when Apple

1:17:04started shipping the bigger plus size phones,

1:17:08that's all the proof you need

1:17:09of how long it takes Apple to go from,

1:17:12okay, we'll make this phone to it's September, here it is.

1:17:15It's over two years.

1:17:16They don't all, anytime you see a story that, you know,

1:17:19like that Apple's making a major change

1:17:21to next year's iPhone, it's complete nonsense.

1:17:25It just can't work that way.

1:17:27But I remember being in a Verizon store,

1:17:29something to do with my SIM card, I don't know.

1:17:31I was, I had something wrong with my account.

1:17:33And I heard a customer shopping for an Android phone,

1:17:38and her boyfriend was trying to talk her into one

1:17:43that had a pen for something,

1:17:45and she knew what she wanted.

1:17:48She wanted, and she was a very small Asian woman,

1:17:51and she had a tiny purse.

1:17:53I remember looking at her purse thing,

1:17:54how are you even gonna put that phone?

1:17:55She went right to the one that was the biggest.

1:17:57She was like, no, no, I want the,

1:17:58I forget what model number it was.

1:18:00But it was the Samsung something with the biggest screen.

1:18:04And she's, and he was like, are you sure, that's huge?

1:18:06And he was like trying to talk her out of it.

1:18:08And she was like, nope, and sold,

1:18:10here, take my credit card.

1:18:12(laughing)

1:18:13Meanwhile, she's got the phone and is out of the store,

1:18:16and they're still dicking around

1:18:17with my SIM card problem, of course.

1:18:21But I just remember, and I just remember,

1:18:23that was the moment, I remember the moment,

1:18:24and I thought, you know what, I'm wrong about these phones.

1:18:28People, all sorts of people want them,

1:18:30including very small, short people

1:18:33who carry very small purses.

1:18:35- Yeah.

1:18:36- They're gonna squeeze it into the purse and make it work.

1:18:39- I bought my mama a Mac size phone.

1:18:40She is herself a small Asian woman.

1:18:42She loves it.

1:18:43Can't get enough.

1:18:44- Yeah, yeah.

1:18:45So I think the 14 Plus is gonna sell like gangbusters,

1:18:47and I think Apple knows it.

1:18:48There's certain things that they never know.

1:18:51I've talked to people over the years,

1:18:52like Apple says, people think we know everything

1:18:54and how many of each thing is gonna be sold,

1:18:57and we're always surprised every year.

1:18:59We're surprised by which colors are popular.

1:19:01We're surprised by this and that.

1:19:04But I think the one thing they know for sure

1:19:05is the 14 Plus is gonna sell like gangbusters.

1:19:08- Yeah, I think that's very odd.

1:19:11- But anyway, back to the dynamic island.

1:19:13Here's the thing.

1:19:14No, but in terms of how they could have brought

1:19:16some of the features to the other phones.

1:19:18You mentioned in your review,

1:19:20there are things that we've known for years.

1:19:22They've been in iOS for years.

1:19:24So like if you've got turn-by-turn directions

1:19:27or anything location tracking,

1:19:28you get a blue pill in the top left corner, right?

1:19:32If you have a phone call going on, you get a green pill.

1:19:36And if you tap the pill,

1:19:37you jump to the app that's responsible for it, right?

1:19:40So now that we have these things

1:19:43and the dynamic island is out,

1:19:45it's very clear that they could make it

1:19:48so that you could long press the pill

1:19:50and get the little widget thing

1:19:53to appear right underneath it without the dynamic island.

1:19:56This doesn't even...

1:19:57The fact that they're not doing that

1:20:00and they're not going to do that is,

1:20:03let's call it what it is.

1:20:04It's a software lock on the feature.

1:20:07- Oh yeah, for sure.

1:20:08By the way, do you think the long press to open the widget

1:20:11and the tap to open the app is as backwards as I do?

1:20:13- It did not.

1:20:14This is one of my...

1:20:15I have this in my notes to talk about on the podcast.

1:20:18I'm glad you brought it up

1:20:19so that I can't ignore my notes and forget it.

1:20:23That did not occur to me at all,

1:20:25but I was reading your review today

1:20:27because when I'm late with my reviews,

1:20:29I scrupulously avoid reading other people's reviews,

1:20:33both because I need to finish mine

1:20:34and it just seems like the right thing to do.

1:20:37- Yeah, and then when you're done, when you publish,

1:20:39you read everyone else's furiously.

1:20:40- Right, and I read yours, and that was one of the things

1:20:44I was like, oh, I'm so glad he's on my podcast today

1:20:46because that is a really interesting idea, right?

1:20:51So your idea is...

1:20:54The way it works right now is that you tap a thing

1:20:58in the dynamic island and it jumps you to that app.

1:21:00So your podcast player's playing

1:21:03and you've got the little thing up there,

1:21:04the live waveforms, you tap it and you jump to Overcast

1:21:08or you jump to Apple Podcasts or you jump to Spotify,

1:21:11and if you long press, you get the player.

1:21:13You're saying that should be reversed.

1:21:16- I think it should absolutely be reversed.

1:21:17If the idea of the island is that it's a hardware display

1:21:22that floats over the top of iOS,

1:21:25then you should use it more.

1:21:27To me, a long press on a smartphone touchscreen

1:21:30is effectively a right click,

1:21:33and it's actually an even less discoverable right click.

1:21:36So all the ads are like, the thing is moving.

1:21:42Like, the ads are great, right?

1:21:43But it's always opening and closing.

1:21:44People are doing stuff with it, and the point of it is not,

1:21:47oh, this is an app switcher with an animation on it.

1:21:51The point of it is you're supposed to use it,

1:21:54and the thing that drove me nuts was like,

1:21:55oh, I wanna use it.

1:21:56I just wanna open the thing and change the track

1:21:58or I wanna see what the next name of the street is

1:22:01instead of just 900 feet or whatever it is.

1:22:04I wanna stop this timer.

1:22:05And you have to click and hold.

1:22:08And it's just like, oh, this is backwards.

1:22:10Actually, what I wanna do is use the island,

1:22:13and if I wanna open the app,

1:22:15I will tell this phone that I wanna open the app in some way.

1:22:18- I'm not 100% convinced,

1:22:22but I'm over 50% convinced that you're right.

1:22:26And--

1:22:27- It should at least be a toggle.

1:22:28They should at least let you choose.

1:22:30- Yeah.

1:22:31Yeah, I don't know.

1:22:34I almost think, I'm like at least 55% convinced

1:22:38that they shouldn't even be a toggle,

1:22:39that you're just right, that tapping,

1:22:41if the app support has something that supports,

1:22:45I think everything that's in there does.

1:22:47If it makes any sense to do it,

1:22:49then it should just show the expanded view on a tap.

1:22:53- Right, and if there's no expanded view,

1:22:56like fine, kick me the app.

1:22:57I will understand.

1:22:58- Right, and your analogy to a right-click

1:23:00in Mac or Windows is exactly right.

1:23:03And my philosophy, and I actually think

1:23:06everybody's Windows, the Windows guidelines,

1:23:08the Mac guidelines, I think all recommend this.

1:23:11And over the years, of course,

1:23:14everybody can find examples of even software

1:23:17from Apple and Microsoft that disobeys it.

1:23:19But the rule's always been that

1:23:23nothing should be in the right-click menu

1:23:25that you can only get in the right-click menu.

1:23:27There should be a way to do everything on the system

1:23:32with just regular clicks by moving the mouse

1:23:36somewhere on the screen to a visible element,

1:23:39be it a menu or an icon or something,

1:23:42and a regular click, and maybe it takes three clicks, right,

1:23:46to go up to the menu and pull down the menu

1:23:48and down to a thing.

1:23:50You should never have to do a right-click

1:23:52because that's not discoverable,

1:23:54because lots of people never right-click anything.

1:23:57And I do think it's a direct analogy to long pressing.

1:24:01And for certain mice, obviously,

1:24:04Apple mice don't have multiple buttons,

1:24:05but at least with traditional mice,

1:24:08the right-click button is a button

1:24:11that a normal person can see, right,

1:24:14and think, I don't know, what's that button do?

1:24:16And then they kinda can figure it out.

1:24:18Long press is even less discoverable than right-clicking

1:24:22because it's, I'm not sure people know they can do it.

1:24:27And I do, I get it, right?

1:24:29And it's like, so you should be able to do it with a tap.

1:24:32Right, so there is no way to just open the expanded view

1:24:36with just a tap, but according to my theory

1:24:40that like on a mouse system,

1:24:41you should be able to do everything with a regular click.

1:24:44You should be able to do everything with regular taps,

1:24:46even if it requires multiple taps.

1:24:48So let's say you actually want to,

1:24:52you don't just want to open the little scoreboard thing

1:24:57for the live activity you're watching.

1:24:59You actually wanna switch to the ESPN app.

1:25:02Well, you tap it once to show the widget in expanded view,

1:25:07and then you'd tap again to go to the app, right?

1:25:11Like it would be on,

1:25:12like there'd be like an ESPN logo in the widget,

1:25:14and you'd tap that to go to the app.

1:25:16So you could still go to the app.

1:25:18You would just have to tap and then tap,

1:25:20which isn't that different than the long tap, right?

1:25:24I think you're right, and if you just think like,

1:25:27I just wanna open the expanded view, just tap it.

1:25:30Tap it to expand it.

1:25:32- Especially because Apple is inundating everybody

1:25:35with marketing showing the thing happening all the time.

1:25:37So it's like they're training users to expect a behavior.

1:25:42- That they may not discover even.

1:25:45- Right, and I obviously have like wandered around asking,

1:25:48and the general vibe is we want it to be as simple

1:25:52as possible, and the simplest thing to do is kick you

1:25:54to the app, and it's like, actually I still think

1:25:57that's backwards.

1:25:58- Yeah, I do too, 'cause I actually think the simplest thing

1:26:01that's possible is to open the mini app that's up there,

1:26:04right, 'cause that's what these things are.

1:26:06They're little mini apps.

1:26:07I compared them in my review to the iTunes mini player,

1:26:12and I loved the iTunes.

1:26:15I still call it iTunes, but the music app mini player,

1:26:20but over the years when I've been playing music on my Mac,

1:26:24my controlling it has gone through the mini player

1:26:27way more than iTunes, because you just leave

1:26:30the mini player up, and it's wonderfully simple.

1:26:33Now, and it forces the designer or designers of the app

1:26:38to reduce the app to its purest core.

1:26:42Fast forward, reverse, play, pause, next,

1:26:47and what's playing right now.

1:26:50That's the app.

1:26:52That's the core, and yes, we want all these other features.

1:26:55We want playlist management, and we want radio stations,

1:26:58and we want subscription info, and go to your account info,

1:27:01and buy new music, and all those other stuff,

1:27:04but the core of the app is fast forward, reverse,

1:27:08play, pause, next, and what's playing right now,

1:27:11and that's the mini player,

1:27:12and that's what these views do to all these apps.

1:27:15So to me, that's the simplest thing possible.

1:27:17Like, I've hailed a Lyft, and I'm waiting for it to show.

1:27:21This is one of my, I can't wait for this to be in NowPlane,

1:27:24'cause it, or a dynamic island,

1:27:27'cause this is me all the time.

1:27:29I hail an Uber or a Lyft, and it says,

1:27:34of course they always lie, and they say,

1:27:36"Oh, we could get you one, we'll get you one

1:27:38"in four minutes," and I'm like, "Oh, that's great,"

1:27:41but that's actually so quick,

1:27:43I was actually gonna go to the bathroom,

1:27:44I don't have my shoes on yet, well, I'll hail it,

1:27:46and then it spins and spins, and then of course,

1:27:48they're like, "Oh, it'll be nine minutes."

1:27:51Right?

1:27:53Well, what am I gonna do?

1:27:54Now, I've already gone to the bathroom,

1:27:56I put my shoes on already, 'cause I thought,

1:27:59of course, got suckered again, Lucy and the football,

1:28:01thinking that the car was gonna be here

1:28:03in a couple minutes.

1:28:05Well, I'm gonna dick around on my phone, of course, right?

1:28:08And this is what I do, and then I'm on Twitter,

1:28:10and then all of a sudden, I'm like, wait,

1:28:11did I just spend 20 minutes on Twitter?

1:28:13Is the car outside?

1:28:14Did it already leave?

1:28:16I love the idea that in the dynamic island,

1:28:18I'll have a live update, and every time I'm waiting for it,

1:28:21I can see it, but I don't wanna jump to the app

1:28:25if I want more information, like to see what kind of car

1:28:27is it, like that's, just let me tap it, right?

1:28:30Just let me tap it and see, okay,

1:28:32it's gonna be a red Tesla.

1:28:33- Yeah, and here's the last four of the lights.

1:28:35- Yeah, here's the last four of the lights.

1:28:36- Which is the most important information

1:28:37of the whole app.

1:28:38- Right, just let me tap it,

1:28:39and I don't want to, the last thing I wanna do

1:28:41is go to Uber's giant app with ads in it and all this crap.

1:28:45Just let me see their mini player.

1:28:48- Why was my first question,

1:28:50will Uber put ads in the dynamic island?

1:28:53Like, there's a whole app review,

1:28:55we're already like an hour and a half into it,

1:28:57there's another hour and a half of an app review

1:28:59for the dynamic island that is staring at us in the face.

1:29:02Like, this is why I'm like at wait and see.

1:29:05Is Uber gonna put the Uber Eats logo

1:29:08in their dynamic island widget

1:29:10and try to get you to buy the Uber subscription

1:29:13in the dynamic island?

1:29:13Like, I kinda wanna know what that relationship

1:29:17between Apple and its developers and the,

1:29:20like, when you say, like, when you reduce the app

1:29:23to its core essence,

1:29:25is the Instagram dynamic island widget

1:29:28just gonna show you an ad for, like, Instagram shirts?

1:29:32Like, I don't know.

1:29:33- No, they're gonna make you watch a reel.

1:29:36- Yeah, they're definitely gonna make you watch a reel

1:29:38in the island.

1:29:39- Like, I'm very curious to see how this plays out

1:29:41with developers, 'cause that,

1:29:42the concepts they showed from Lyft and Flighty

1:29:45are like, genius.

1:29:47I'm in the airport, I just need to know the gate changed,

1:29:50just tell me the gate changed,

1:29:51and like, I'll move on,

1:29:53and I don't need to open the American Airlines app,

1:29:56which is one of, like,

1:29:56Apple should just kick that app out of the store.

1:29:58If anyone from Apple's listening to me,

1:29:59just kick, just boot American Airlines out,

1:30:02make 'em start over.

1:30:04So, you get this whole world

1:30:05where there's all this sort of ambient information,

1:30:09and like, you have to respect what it is

1:30:11and not use it as a way to shove your app into the island.

1:30:15And I think there's a,

1:30:17this is why we might really adopt her.

1:30:19It's like, we're gonna have to learn altogether

1:30:21what works and what doesn't.

1:30:22- So, I can be pretty cynical.

1:30:25I can certainly be mean and sarcastic,

1:30:27but I have to admit that there's a,

1:30:31an optimist in me and excited by the opportunity designer

1:30:36mindset in me that never,

1:30:40you know, like, the way that,

1:30:42the best example of all time is email,

1:30:45and the way that the original designers of internet email

1:30:49made it so simple and so, oh, you just,

1:30:52it's just a text file that you put,

1:30:54send over this port to a server,

1:30:57and you just follow this format

1:30:59where you just put a to and from and all this stuff,

1:31:02and it goes out, and guess what?

1:31:05It's totally ripe for incredible abuse,

1:31:09and we're all getting hundreds of spam messages a day still,

1:31:14to this day, and it'll never stop

1:31:16because the people who designed email never really thought,

1:31:19hey, wait, how could this be abused?

1:31:23It did not occur to me to think, wait,

1:31:25what are the things somebody could abuse

1:31:27the dynamic island for?

1:31:28- So did you ask Apple, will they be, are ads allowed?

1:31:32Did you ask?

1:31:33- Well, as you may know,

1:31:34The Verge has a very strict background policy,

1:31:36so I can't, unless they're gonna be on the record.

1:31:38- You can't say what they said, and if they didn't--

1:31:42Well, so you can say whether you asked, though.

1:31:44- I did ask, I 100% asked, and I think,

1:31:48I would characterize the response as,

1:31:51oh boy, we're gonna have to wait and see,

1:31:53like, right, like, they have app review,

1:31:55they have a mechanism, they have some guidelines,

1:31:59but no one has submitted apps yet.

1:32:01Like, I don't know, like, is Spotify gonna put,

1:32:05like, try to break the rules and get you to sign up

1:32:08on the web in their island widget?

1:32:10Like, we're just gonna have to find out,

1:32:12'cause developers routinely push against rules,

1:32:15Apple pushes back, and this is a way,

1:32:17like, my joke about American Airlines is,

1:32:19they're gonna, are they gonna stick the offer

1:32:21for the American Airlines credit card in the island widget?

1:32:24Like, maybe.

1:32:25- Right, well, think about Spotify, right?

1:32:26So Spotify, you're playing Spotify,

1:32:29and now you're doing your stuff.

1:32:32You're reading email, you're browsing the web,

1:32:34you're doing messages, and the Spotify thing

1:32:38is up there in the dynamic island, and there's an icon,

1:32:42so if they can dynamically change that icon,

1:32:45they could change it to, like, a Chipotle icon, right?

1:32:49(both laughing)

1:32:50- Right, I mean, I'm assuming that app review

1:32:53will catch a bunch of this stuff, I'm assuming--

1:32:57- Like, they could just sell the icon, right?

1:32:59- They could, this is what I'm saying.

1:33:02So, we've, you know, and I'm not saying

1:33:04that all these companies are very nefarious,

1:33:05I'm just saying that suddenly you have this ability

1:33:08to ambiently push information at people,

1:33:11and historically in the world,

1:33:13that ability has been used for advertising.

1:33:15(laughing)

1:33:17- You're just listening to music,

1:33:19but you've got a Wendy's logo up.

1:33:22- Oh, no, but think about it this way,

1:33:23you've got, so there's some prioritization happening

1:33:27with these apps, you've only got two slots, right?

1:33:28There's the big one, and then if you got two at once,

1:33:31it turns into a little circle,

1:33:33which is like the ultra-minimal view.

1:33:34- Yeah, there's three sizes,

1:33:36one is if it's the one and only thing,

1:33:38then there's two sizes if there's two,

1:33:42and then there's the expanded view, so four total sizes.

1:33:47- Yeah, and so you can just see, like,

1:33:49okay, there's an app that wants the island,

1:33:51it's been deprioritized, and the internal priority ranking

1:33:55of the apps is fascinating to me, right?

1:33:58So as I've been testing it,

1:34:00phone calls have the first priority,

1:34:02if you have an active call, they always get the big slot.

1:34:04The timer loses to everything all the time.

1:34:06- Right.

1:34:07- You can just, if you start a timer,

1:34:09it'll just get pushed off the screen

1:34:10if you start other things.

1:34:11Turn by turn, I think, has priority too.

1:34:13Like, it's just interesting to figure out

1:34:16how Apple is ranking all these different uses of the island.

1:34:19And as more live activities roll out, who knows, right?

1:34:22Like, does a sports score supersede a phone call?

1:34:26- Right.

1:34:27- I don't know.

1:34:28But just stipulating that I do not know

1:34:30the answer to the ranking, you can just see a world

1:34:33where, like, you have the Chipotle app on your phone,

1:34:37and you haven't, like, force quit it.

1:34:39So it's just, like, hanging out in the back,

1:34:41and you, like, walk by a Chipotle,

1:34:44and it pops up the island widget that's like,

1:34:46"Do you want a burrito?"

1:34:48(laughing)

1:34:50I'm assuming that that is not possible.

1:34:53I have no idea if it is or not.

1:34:55- The other thing that kinda stinks to me

1:34:57about the timer always getting secondary thing

1:34:59is it just shows the timer icon.

1:35:01It doesn't show the time.

1:35:03Like--

1:35:03- Yeah, it just shows you something.

1:35:05- I don't understand why the timer doesn't switch

1:35:08to showing you, like, if you've got five minutes,

1:35:1130 seconds left, why doesn't it say 5.30?

1:35:13And even if they don't wanna update every second,

1:35:15even if it just updated every 10 seconds or something,

1:35:18that would be better than just showing the timer icon.

1:35:20- Yeah, or it's a circle.

1:35:21Just have it count down and--

1:35:23- Yeah, or, yeah, like show analog-style clock hands

1:35:26or something.

1:35:27- Yeah, again, this is what I mean.

1:35:29Like, I just think we're, a year from now,

1:35:32we will actually know.

1:35:34And this is where my,

1:35:35maybe I'm just even more cynical than you are,

1:35:37but, like, that's where my cynicism is, is

1:35:39I can see how it's useful now.

1:35:43I don't know if you're like me,

1:35:45but I, after a day with the first iPhone X,

1:35:49I just stopped seeing the notch entirely.

1:35:51It went away.

1:35:52And I, last year on the 13 Pro,

1:35:54they were like, "We made the notch smaller,"

1:35:55and I was like, "What notch?"

1:35:56- Yeah, yeah, yep, I thought the same thing.

1:35:58And I was like, "Did they really?"

1:35:59And then I, like, compared it,

1:36:00and I was like, "Holy hell, they did.

1:36:02"That actually is smaller."

1:36:03- Right, so, but the island is not invisible.

1:36:06They moved it down.

1:36:07I run my phone in light mode,

1:36:09so there's bright light above and below it,

1:36:12so I see it, it is always moving.

1:36:14So I'm just, like, looking at this thing a lot.

1:36:16And I, the big trade to me is,

1:36:19okay, well, now I have to see it.

1:36:21Like, it's not just, like, this invisible thing on the phone

1:36:24that, like, people complain about for sport on Twitter,

1:36:27but is actually, like, barely visible.

1:36:29It's a thing that I'm looking at.

1:36:31It actually, it's lower on the screen.

1:36:32Whenever I get stressed out, I shop for cars.

1:36:34I rarely buy a car,

1:36:36but it's been a very stressful couple weeks for me,

1:36:38so I've been shopping for cars, like, every minute.

1:36:39- Very odd stress reliever, but we all have our--

1:36:43- Like, I'm just like, what if I owned, like,

1:36:45a 1988 Mercedes, and I just, like, shop,

1:36:47but, like, just, like, see if I can buy one.

1:36:49I never buy them, but, so I've had, like,

1:36:50the cars.com app, the top of it, the pictures of the car,

1:36:55because the island is lower,

1:36:58all the pictures of the car are cut off.

1:37:00This is, like, they'll update the app,

1:37:01and it's a tiny little personal experience,

1:37:04but it just made me think, like,

1:37:05the trade-off of value I am getting right now

1:37:08for this thing being visible is not gonna be aligned

1:37:12until the Packers game is in there,

1:37:15until Flighty is in there, and I'm in the airport,

1:37:16and I'm like, this is rad.

1:37:17Like, there's just a ramp to utility

1:37:22that has not been achieved yet,

1:37:24and we'll just see, and I, like,

1:37:26the off-ramps from utility are,

1:37:28yeah, they're gonna stick ads in it.

1:37:29- Can we intercede?

1:37:30Can we complain about American Airlines?

1:37:32(laughing)

1:37:34Hey, their app is horrible.

1:37:36Flighty is awesome.

1:37:37If anybody out there, even if you only fly occasionally,

1:37:39Flighty is so much more useful.

1:37:42- My flight home from San Francisco last Friday

1:37:46was supposed to be at, like, let's say 1 p.m.

1:37:48It was, like, 1255 or something,

1:37:50and at 1230, when we were already supposed

1:37:53to have started boarding, they made an announcement

1:37:55that we might be boarding 20 to 30 minutes late

1:37:58'cause the mechanics are looking at an issue,

1:38:01and I turned to the guy next to me and said,

1:38:02we're not getting on this plane,

1:38:04because if they thought we might have a 30,

1:38:08even an hour delay while mechanics fixed something,

1:38:11they would load us on the plane

1:38:12and make us sit in our seats while they do it.

1:38:15That's happened to me, you know, it's happened to everybody.

1:38:18If they don't let you board the plane,

1:38:20they don't think the plane's gonna take off,

1:38:21and lo and behold, the plane never took off,

1:38:24and we had to wait for another plane,

1:38:26and it was, I don't know, five hours later

1:38:28when a plane came, but my favorite part was

1:38:31when the gate agent announced it, she said,

1:38:36"Don't worry, it's a good plane this time."

1:38:39Right over the PA system.

1:38:40(laughing)

1:38:41That's pretty good.

1:38:43So when I was, so my week at the Apple event was ridiculous,

1:38:47so I was home in Chicago for Labor Day,

1:38:49and then I flew to LA for code,

1:38:51and then I flew to the Apple event,

1:38:52and then I flew back to LA, and then I flew to New York,

1:38:56and just to make all that work,

1:38:58I flew every major domestic airline.

1:39:01- Wow.

1:39:02- Just to arrange all the flights,

1:39:03and actually, I was so worried about not making it

1:39:06from code to Cupertino that I booked two flights

1:39:10out of LA to CIFA, and I had competing

1:39:14American and Delta flights.

1:39:16So rarely do you directly compare the apps

1:39:19of major airlines, but just that week, I flew them all.

1:39:24I was at LAX three times in three days,

1:39:25which I do not recommend, just not a good way

1:39:28to spend your time, and so Delta has the best one, I think.

1:39:31United is somewhere in the middle,

1:39:33and then the American Airlines app is full

1:39:35of the weirdest custom Sheets animations,

1:39:40and they just are bouncing around.

1:39:42Just kick 'em off the store, Apple.

1:39:44Just be like, human interface, we run the store, all right?

1:39:47You're gone.

1:39:48Come back when you've done some system-level animations.

1:39:52- I like how they spent so much time

1:39:54putting beautiful wallpapers behind the background.

1:39:58It's like the main thing about the American app,

1:40:01Axes, though, it's the only app you'll ever use

1:40:03on the phone, and it has a wallpaper,

1:40:05and they show these beautiful locations

1:40:07from around the world, and it's the only thing

1:40:09that looks good in the app.

1:40:10Who gives a shit?

1:40:11Nobody's going to the American Airlines app

1:40:13to see pictures of the islands of Maui.

1:40:17- Yeah, yeah, it's, I don't think I'm saying

1:40:21anything controversial or new to be like,

1:40:23airline apps are bad.

1:40:24I'm just saying that the island offers you

1:40:26the opportunity to opt out of them,

1:40:28but how long is it gonna take American

1:40:31to build their island widget?

1:40:33- I don't know, but I just opened the app,

1:40:35and I'm looking at it now, and I would estimate

1:40:37that two-thirds of the screen is an ad

1:40:41for the city adventure.

1:40:43- This is what I'm saying.

1:40:44When you're like, the widget has to be

1:40:46the purest representation of the app,

1:40:49well, if you look at the app,

1:40:50it's the purest representation of it

1:40:53is a call to action to sign up for a credit card.

1:40:55- It's, you know how it's sort of weird

1:40:59that a computer company like Apple

1:41:01and an online retailer like Amazon

1:41:04are now major streaming networks and platforms, right?

1:41:07It's, you know, we get it.

1:41:09We're not gonna go there on this show.

1:41:10There's too much to talk about,

1:41:11but it's just sort of like, it's kind of weird, though,

1:41:13that it's like two of the major streaming platforms

1:41:16with some of the best, most talked about content

1:41:18are a store and a computer company.

1:41:21American Airlines is more like there's this,

1:41:23there's a credit card company that now bought an airline.

1:41:28- Yeah, oh, for sure.

1:41:30- This just happened to run an airline.

1:41:32- Yeah, this is like all the major airlines now.

1:41:34You know, Sony in Japan is basically an insurance company

1:41:37that happens to make TVs.

1:41:38The end comes for you and you don't even know it happened.

1:41:42You're like, oh, we're a financial services company.

1:41:44- We were on vacation as a family in August

1:41:46and on the flight home, and of course, we're a threesome,

1:41:49or we were before my son went to college,

1:41:51and now we're back to a twosome.

1:41:52But so we had seats in first,

1:41:55and guess who gets to sit by himself?

1:41:57It's always me, right?

1:41:59My son and my wife sit next to each other

1:42:01and I sit by myself.

1:42:03I saw the most amazing thing happen.

1:42:06The guy next to me signed up for the American credit card.

1:42:10- Oh my God. - On the flight.

1:42:11I've never seen it. - That's great.

1:42:12- All of my life.

1:42:14- It finally worked.

1:42:15That's the one, that's the one conversion they get a year

1:42:17that justifies all of the ads.

1:42:19- All of the miles I've ever flown.

1:42:22- And they can't even track it, right?

1:42:24They make the pilot say the announcement on every flight

1:42:27and they don't even know that it worked one time.

1:42:29- Here, I'm looking at my American app.

1:42:31I have 308,000 miles, award miles.

1:42:35That's how often I have flown on American.

1:42:37And I saw a guy sign up for the credit card

1:42:40right there on the flight.

1:42:41Oh my God.

1:42:43All right, let me take a break here

1:42:44and I will thank our next sponsor and we'll move on.

1:42:47But I wanna thank our good friends at Squarespace.

1:42:50Oh man, everybody knows Squarespace.

1:42:52That is the all-in-one platform for building your website.

1:42:57And they cover everything.

1:43:00They've got templates to choose from.

1:43:03You can register your domain name with them.

1:43:06Once you have the template you wanna start with,

1:43:08you can tweak it to your heart's desire

1:43:10and it is a complete drag and drop interface

1:43:12right in the browser.

1:43:14It is what you see is what you get

1:43:16because while you're editing your website,

1:43:20it looks exactly like it's gonna look for everybody else

1:43:23except the admin and design tools

1:43:26are removed from the screen.

1:43:27Analytics, online stores, email campaigns.

1:43:31You wanna run email campaigns,

1:43:32you could do it right from Squarespace.

1:43:34Same platform you use to update the content on your website.

1:43:38You can update the emails that you send to people.

1:43:40It's all there, all built in.

1:43:42It is exactly the first place you should go

1:43:44to build your next website

1:43:46or to redesign a website you already have.

1:43:49Where do you go to find out more?

1:43:50Go to squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:43:53That's squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:43:56You get a free trial, 30 days, no credit card required.

1:44:00Everything you see is exactly like it'll be

1:44:03with the 30 days are up.

1:44:04You just remember that code talk show.

1:44:05You save 10% off your first purchase.

1:44:07You could pay for a whole year in advance,

1:44:09save 10% with that code squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:44:14And let's see, anything else on the iPhones?

1:44:16How about the cameras?

1:44:17That's certainly worth talking about.

1:44:18- Yeah, I'll just, here's my,

1:44:20this is, they have a new sensor.

1:44:22I think it's 48 megapixels sensor on a pro.

1:44:24And I think they are being too conservative with it.

1:44:29And I think it looked, they can do more with it.

1:44:34And right now they're just, they're in this weird corner

1:44:37where they're doing a lot of noise reduction

1:44:40and a lot of sharpening,

1:44:41and they should stop it and let the sensor shine.

1:44:44That's my hot tick.

1:44:47- So again, I have not, as we record,

1:44:51the closest red review is yours

1:44:53because I knew you were gonna be in the show.

1:44:55And I'm gonna tell you the truth, I'll admit it.

1:44:57I always read your reviews, your first or second.

1:45:01I was looking at your example photos,

1:45:04and you had some example photos, and a good selection.

1:45:09You had some where you compared the 14 Pro to the 13 Pro.

1:45:13Some where you compared to the Pixel 6,

1:45:18what's the best six pixel from last year?

1:45:21Yeah, Pixel 6 Pro.

1:45:23And some where you compared against the Samsung Galaxy 22,

1:45:28whatever the last word of that phone is.

1:45:31It's not that the iPhone looks bad,

1:45:35but you're describing it as inconsistent

1:45:38is exactly what I'm seeing.

1:45:40Again, not bad.

1:45:44And we're talking about all these phones

1:45:46that are excellent cameras for phones.

1:45:48Truly excellent, we live in a wonderful era.

1:45:50But the iPhone seems a little all over the place.

1:45:53I thought that the night shot comparison with the Pixel,

1:45:56and like you said, they were very different.

1:45:59I thought the iPhone one was much better.

1:46:01That's more to my liking.

1:46:02- Yeah, the iPhone's brighter and the Pixel is more even,

1:46:05is like how I would put it.

1:46:07- And I thought like the entrance to the bar

1:46:09or restaurant, whatever it was,

1:46:11just looked deeper and richer.

1:46:13I thought the Pixel kinda blew that one,

1:46:15but not in a bad way, but just not to my liking.

1:46:17But then you had the shot across like a harbor

1:46:20or a river or something.

1:46:22And the iPhone's was just strange in my opinion.

1:46:25Like it did really weird things with the sky

1:46:29that almost looked like somebody

1:46:31took like the smudge tool in Photoshop

1:46:35and just ran it over the sky.

1:46:38And I don't really understand what it did

1:46:40with the reflection of the ferris wheel in the water.

1:46:43- That was the one that got me.

1:46:44I was like, "Ooh, we're doing too much."

1:46:47- Yeah, and that's, yeah, it over sharpened.

1:46:50There's a ferris wheel.

1:46:52It's a neat shot and it's a good example

1:46:54'cause it's nighttime, it's water.

1:46:56There's a ferris wheel across the water

1:46:58that's got all sorts of bright colored lights.

1:47:01And where it really over sharpened to me

1:47:04was on the reflection in the water.

1:47:07It just did something weird where the Pixel,

1:47:09it's like, "Yeah, that's what the shot should look like."

1:47:12- Yeah, I think the last time I reviewed iPhone Pro

1:47:15was the 12 Pro two years ago

1:47:18and then Dieter did the 13s last year.

1:47:20And so two years ago, I said,

1:47:23"All these phones have started to look the same."

1:47:25Like there was that moment where the Pixel

1:47:27was really opinionated and super contrasty

1:47:30and I loved those photos and the iPhone

1:47:33did really like over HDR in the beginning

1:47:37and everything was too like artificial looking.

1:47:41And then Samsung was like another planet with colors.

1:47:43It kinda still is.

1:47:44- Yeah, no, but just as an aside,

1:47:47I thought that that over, too heavy handed with the HDR

1:47:52was very odd for Apple because Apple's taste

1:47:55tends to run towards the natural in all cases.

1:47:58And the HDR in a couple of years ago

1:48:02was really odd because it looked unnatural.

1:48:05- Yeah, it was just like, they were like,

1:48:07"Shadows are gone.

1:48:08In our world, there are no shadows."

1:48:10And it was like, actually, hold on.

1:48:12Right, and then Google was like,

1:48:13"In our world, everything is very moody."

1:48:16And then Samsung was like, "You're on drugs."

1:48:17And those were their looks, right?

1:48:19And it was like fine and like they were predictable.

1:48:21And then a couple of years ago,

1:48:22they all converged. - Not a lot of drugs,

1:48:24but a little drugs.

1:48:25- Yeah, just enough to have a good time, right?

1:48:27And then so they all converged a couple of years ago

1:48:29and then they're starting to diverge again.

1:48:32And so last year, I think Dieter,

1:48:33when he reviewed the 13 Pro,

1:48:34he said, "This camera's incredibly confident.

1:48:37It knows what it is.

1:48:38It knows what kinds of pictures it wants to make.

1:48:40And it just does it every single time."

1:48:42And I think the 14 Pro is trying to make 13 Pro pictures

1:48:47with a totally different sensor

1:48:50and a totally different pathway.

1:48:53And it's just getting lost.

1:48:55And it should make the pictures it wants to make.

1:48:58- That's a really good theory.

1:49:00'Cause I have to say, and again,

1:49:02one of the reasons I do it, I'm a one-person show.

1:49:06There's only so much I can do in a week.

1:49:07I knew, I kinda had the gist.

1:49:10I had enough.

1:49:11I was like, "I think I got the trail

1:49:12of what I wanna write.

1:49:13I know it's gonna be long.

1:49:15I'm gonna have a hard time hitting a deadline.

1:49:16I know I've got, actually,

1:49:18I'm not gonna even be here on Wednesday.

1:49:19So if I blow it and don't hit the Wednesday morning,

1:49:21blah, blah, blah, I'm not gonna shoot a lot of photos."

1:49:23And the other thing is,

1:49:24even if I thought I had time to shoot the photos,

1:49:26I'm not gonna do as good job as some people.

1:49:28I'm not gonna do even as good job as you.

1:49:30I'm certainly not gonna do Austin Mann type stuff.

1:49:33Somebody else is gonna do it,

1:49:34and I'll just link to them, right?

1:49:36And we'll get back to that philosophy in a bit.

1:49:39I'll just link to them.

1:49:40But I did take some, of course I took some photos, right?

1:49:42And of course I'm walking around with two phones in my pocket,

1:49:45my 13 Pro and my 14 Pro.

1:49:47And I took a lot of photos where I'm like,

1:49:49"I don't see a difference."

1:49:50And that's not a bad thing, right?

1:49:52'Cause I've liked my 13 Pro,

1:49:54but I'm seeing that sort of,

1:49:57this is a way different sensor, way different sensor,

1:50:00and I'm getting a lot of very similar shots.

1:50:04But I think what you've stumbled upon

1:50:07is in edge conditions, it can't reproduce the same output.

1:50:12And they should just let this sensor be itself.

1:50:14And if they come out different, let it,

1:50:16it's a good sensor, it's a great sensor.

1:50:18But it shouldn't look exactly the same

1:50:21as the 13 Pro in every condition.

1:50:24- The thing that kills me about that is,

1:50:27so next year they'll let it be itself a little bit more.

1:50:29You mentioned software locks earlier,

1:50:32and I did not jump on it 'cause I wanted to bring it up

1:50:35in this part of the conversation.

1:50:36They're not gonna roll whatever updates happen next year

1:50:39to this phone.

1:50:40- Right.

1:50:41- They're not gonna update this camera.

1:50:43The camera on the iPhone is like this bizarrely fixed object.

1:50:47- That changes crazily hardware year to hardware year.

1:50:51- Yeah, right, but so that it's like,

1:50:53they keep telling us that this is computational photography,

1:50:56it's all defined in software.

1:50:58And then every year they're like,

1:50:59"And we have new hardware,

1:51:00"and no further software changes will come to the camera."

1:51:03And it's like, wait, hold up.

1:51:04Like the 14 is basically the same phone as the 13, right?

1:51:09It has the same 12 megapixel sensor,

1:51:12it has the same lens, as far as we can tell.

1:51:14Like everything seems the same.

1:51:16- There's some changes.

1:51:17- It has the same processor.

1:51:18- Right.

1:51:19- And you're not giving it like whatever deep fusion

1:51:22is moving earlier in the pipeline to uncompressed images.

1:51:25- Yeah, the photonic engine.

1:51:27- And that's the real rebranding there, right?

1:51:29They're just doing deep fusion.

1:51:30By the way, I didn't know this.

1:51:31Deep fusion occurs on mid and low light images only.

1:51:36And smart HDR happens elsewhere in the pipeline,

1:51:40mostly on bright images.

1:51:41I had no idea this was true.

1:51:44- Right, so this is the curious thing about photonic engine

1:51:48being only on the 14 models, but it is on all 14.

1:51:51It's not locked to pros.

1:51:53It's all 14 models get photonic engine,

1:51:56no other older iPhones get it.

1:51:58But it's curious because the,

1:52:03let's just say it even requires the fifth GPU core, right?

1:52:07Like the sort of song and dance of how did the 14

1:52:10get a chip upgrade from the 13 is when they're both on A15

1:52:15is last year's iPhone 13's got a four core A15,

1:52:19but last year's 13 pros got a five core GPU on the A15.

1:52:24They were binning the GPUs.

1:52:27And this year, the iPhone 14's as a year over year

1:52:32comparison get the one extra GPU core.

1:52:37And like I said in my review,

1:52:38one extra GPU core makes it sound, who cares?

1:52:4225% more GPU processing sounds pretty cool.

1:52:46So a glass half full, glass half empty.

1:52:49It's an upgrade.

1:52:50It's obviously the smallest upgrade chip wise

1:52:53ever in this era.

1:52:56But now you see the pattern where next year

1:52:58it'll get the 16 and the pros will get the 17.

1:53:01And now they're one generation apart.

1:53:03And there's no way to get there

1:53:06without an awkward year like this one.

1:53:08But so let's just say 13 pro,

1:53:11not even talking regular 13 and the regular iPhone 14,

1:53:15they both have the five GPU core A15 chip,

1:53:20but the last year's 13 pro doesn't get photonic engine.

1:53:24So I asked, if they both have the A15, same A15, why is that?

1:53:29And I can't quote the answer,

1:53:31but it is something to the effect of,

1:53:34what I wanted to know,

1:53:34is there something else hardware in the pipeline?

1:53:37Is there some connection from the sensor to the image,

1:53:41the ISP that is faster so that it can process the raw

1:53:46instead of this, but only on the,

1:53:49even though the A14 has the same A15 chip,

1:53:52there's a pipeline to the sensor.

1:53:54Is that the case or is this a software lock?

1:53:56And the answer was something to the effect of,

1:53:58our cameras and chips are designed to work together

1:54:03and require unique updates.

1:54:06- Right, they just like spun the wheel

1:54:08and they're like, here's the boilerplate.

1:54:09- Right.

1:54:10- We're not gonna do the software update.

1:54:11- It is, it was an answer that I honestly,

1:54:14even though I speak fluent Cupertinoese,

1:54:18I honestly don't know what, if they were,

1:54:23I obviously did not get a yes or no,

1:54:25and I didn't expect to get a yes or no,

1:54:27but a lot of times I get an answer

1:54:29that I know how to interpret as a yes or a no.

1:54:32And this one is, I don't know.

1:54:36I really don't, I kind of think yes,

1:54:38that there's some hardware improvement to the pipeline.

1:54:43I do think so, but I'm like 50, 60% thinking

1:54:49there actually is a hardware aspect to it,

1:54:51even though it's the same system on a chip,

1:54:54but I don't know.

1:54:55And I couldn't get an answer off the record either.

1:54:57- Yeah, look, if I was a 13 Pro owner,

1:55:00I'd be like, you have to tell me, right?

1:55:03Let's just explain to me exactly why.

1:55:05And then if I was a 14 Pro owner,

1:55:08I would be like, I've got this new 48 megapixel sensor.

1:55:13Apple can bin it into this quad pixel array

1:55:17that captures more light,

1:55:19or they can crop it to do this 2X zoom

1:55:22and this action mode stuff.

1:55:23Those are the beginnings of ideas.

1:55:26So if I'm paying $1,100 for this phone,

1:55:30am I gonna get more value out of the sensor in it over time?

1:55:34The way that I get more value out of every other piece

1:55:37of hardware on the phone, right?

1:55:39The processor can do more things over time,

1:55:43more apps are developed that use the sensors,

1:55:46like all the stuff,

1:55:47like the phones just get better over time.

1:55:49- The dynamic island is going to have more content

1:55:51later this year.

1:55:53- Yeah, you'll be able to sign up for a credit card

1:55:54directly from it, except this weird camera,

1:55:57which Apple is telling us is a software masterpiece.

1:56:02And it is, right?

1:56:03They're doing all this processing,

1:56:04they're capturing seven images at once,

1:56:06they're layering them, all this stuff is happening,

1:56:09but that is locked into place.

1:56:12We've gone through how many computational photography

1:56:14iPhones now?

1:56:15The photos on the first day look basically the same

1:56:19as the photos on the last day.

1:56:20And to me, that's fundamentally bizarre,

1:56:24and fine, it is what it is.

1:56:26But if you're the 13th year owner this year,

1:56:27you've gotta be wondering,

1:56:28like I should be able to get this software update.

1:56:32You have to tell me why I can't get it,

1:56:33because it's an unlike Apple software lock

1:56:37in a way that not being able to hold down on the pill

1:56:40and get the dynamic island widget kind of isn't.

1:56:43Sure, there's at least a reason for that.

1:56:44We're reserving all of this for the island,

1:56:47we want that to be a consistent experience,

1:56:49we're doing hardware anti-aliasing that your phone can,

1:56:51whatever it is.

1:56:52So this one is just purely,

1:56:54we're not gonna give you the software, or a reason.

1:56:57And then I think on the 14 Pro,

1:57:00because it's a little inconsistent,

1:57:02you should have the expectation

1:57:04that it will take software improvements over time.

1:57:07- Let me put on my cynical hat and say that

1:57:09it's what I was told in my can't quote them,

1:57:12but got an answer on is the photonic engine hardware?

1:57:16Is that why it's only on the 14?

1:57:18Looking at the words of the answer,

1:57:22I'm 60% leaning towards yes, there's hardware.

1:57:26But the cynic in me says,

1:57:29if it really was a hardware story,

1:57:31they could just tell us that.

1:57:32And they could say, yeah, our chip team

1:57:33made this incredible pipeline adjustment

1:57:35to read the data off the sensor faster.

1:57:37And why wouldn't they just tell us that?

1:57:39Like, yeah, our hardware,

1:57:40'cause they like to brag about their hardware.

1:57:42So the cynic in me says, sounds like a software lock.

1:57:46- We have a great new sensor

1:57:47that can pass data over the bus to the ISP in the A15,

1:57:51even faster than before,

1:57:52letting us do deep fusion or an uncompressed image.

1:57:55Great, I'll buy it.

1:57:57But the fact that they won't say is like--

1:57:59- Yeah, and let me just clarify your thing too

1:58:02about the photos, the modes of the camera,

1:58:04like portrait mode is the best example,

1:58:07do get software updates, right?

1:58:09Like if you have a two or three year old iPhone,

1:58:12your portrait mode photos look better today

1:58:15than they did when you bought it,

1:58:16because the portrait mode does go through software

1:58:20that that improves and the camera app updates.

1:58:23It's just the, if you just take a regular still photo

1:58:27is the thing that doesn't seem to get improvements

1:58:30once the hardware ships.

1:58:31- But it's bizarre 'cause it's a software defined camera.

1:58:35Like at its heart.

1:58:37- You'd think so, right?

1:58:38I think even night mode is one of those things

1:58:41that does get improvements, right?

1:58:43It's just though the pure simplest thing the camera can do,

1:58:47take a shot and give me a 12 megapixel JPEG of it, right?

1:58:51'Cause putting, like you said in your review,

1:58:5499.8% of iPhone users have no reason to ever shoot RAW.

1:58:58And of them, if they did,

1:59:03they would think the camera was broken

1:59:04because they'd look at the RAW image

1:59:06and think this is the worst cell phone picture

1:59:08I've taken since I was using a Nokia flip phone,

1:59:10'cause that's what unprocessed RAW images look like.

1:59:12- I will say that I had a great time shooting RAW

1:59:14on this iPhone.

1:59:15It's very slow.

1:59:16- Yeah, I only did enough just to see if it's low.

1:59:21And they have an option to shoot 12 megapixel RAW.

1:59:26- Oh, I didn't see that.

1:59:27- Ah, yeah.

1:59:28- So pixel bend RAW is a thing.

1:59:30- Something, here's another one.

1:59:32I have this in my notes.

1:59:33And I know I do this once a year

1:59:36'cause I don't usually go to the camera settings in settings.

1:59:39But I do it every time I review a phone.

1:59:41And I know it's a whole separate argument

1:59:44of how are the settings in the settings app organized?

1:59:49What is that?

1:59:50But look at how far down camera is.

1:59:53It is bizarrely low.

1:59:57- Yeah, it's not in the first grouping, right?

1:59:59It's in the second grouping.

1:59:59- No, go look at it right now.

2:00:04- Yeah, I always look for it in the first grouping.

2:00:06- I wish it were in the first grouping.

2:00:08I wish that you could rearrange these.

2:00:09- You're not even in the third grouping.

2:00:11- No, it's the first grouping.

2:00:13Then there's the notifications one.

2:00:14Then there's, the one where I really think it should be

2:00:16is like general control center, battery, blah, blah, blah.

2:00:19- That's where I was.

2:00:20- Then there's the big long one with all the apps,

2:00:21mail, contacts, calendar, notes, reminders, voice, phone,

2:00:25blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, Safari, news, translate.

2:00:27But nope, not there.

2:00:28And then you go all the way down

2:00:30and it's with music, TV, photos, camera, books.

2:00:33I don't know what this group is.

2:00:34- This is the sixth grouping I just counted.

2:00:35- But anyway, go to camera and formats.

2:00:39And then when you turn on Apple ProRAW.

2:00:41- Oh, look at that.

2:00:42- There's a thing that says ProRAW resolution

2:00:44and you can change it from 48 to 12.

2:00:46- All right, I did not shoot any ProRAW at 12.

2:00:51I had a lot of fun shooting at 48.

2:00:52When you hit the capture button, the shutter is still fast.

2:00:55But it just takes a lot of time

2:00:56to read all the data and process it.

2:00:59And so it was like, I guess I would use this for landscapes.

2:01:03Like if anyone's moving, I wanna take a bunch of frames.

2:01:05- Well, Apple has a weird rule too.

2:01:07And while we're talking about cameras

2:01:08and philosophical differences with like the Pixel team

2:01:11and other companies, not weird, but unique.

2:01:14Apple has had a obvious unofficial,

2:01:17but that I happen to know internally is an official rule.

2:01:21They just don't talk about it publicly.

2:01:22But everything the iPhone camera does has to happen live.

2:01:27There can be no, nothing happens where you hit the shutter

2:01:30and it takes a while to process, right?

2:01:33And like the Pixel team doesn't quite,

2:01:35it's not that the Pixel camera is known as being slow,

2:01:38but like when Pixel had night mode originally,

2:01:42it you'd take up night mode photo

2:01:44and it would take a second or two

2:01:45for the night mode processing to show up

2:01:48in the thumbnail of the thing that you took.

2:01:50Which I think most people think is fine, right?

2:01:53I mean, if we used to wait, when I was a kid,

2:01:56like two minutes for a Polaroid to develop,

2:01:59sit there waving it in the air,

2:02:00which of course did nothing,

2:02:01but felt like you were doing something.

2:02:03It's like hitting elevator buttons

2:02:04or crosswalk buttons, right?

2:02:05I want to cross the street,

2:02:06I'll hit the button a couple of times.

2:02:07But Apple only does stuff if it's like the rule,

2:02:10it has to be instantaneous.

2:02:12The way that these 48 megapixel RAWs take,

2:02:16I don't know how long, I would call it a moment at least,

2:02:20a pregnant pause to show up.

2:02:22I think they've made an exception to it, right?

2:02:27They knew they wanted to have a 48 megapixel sensor.

2:02:30This was obviously set in stone hardware-wise years ago.

2:02:34And I'm sure they tried to make it as fast as possible,

2:02:37but there's no other way about it.

2:02:39But if they didn't already offer RAW,

2:02:42they wouldn't offer RAW this year because it takes so long.

2:02:46I think the only reason there's this pause

2:02:48is that they offered RAW

2:02:50when they could do it seemingly instantaneously.

2:02:53Now the RAW feature is in the system

2:02:56and so they have to continue supporting it.

2:02:58But now that they've added four times the pixels

2:03:01to the sensor, they've put themselves in a position

2:03:04that they unofficially would never want to be in

2:03:07where it takes a pregnant pause

2:03:10for a 48 megapixel RAW to be processed.

2:03:13It is the longest thing that any photo does

2:03:16in the camera app that I can remember using any iPhone ever.

2:03:20But who cares?

2:03:22It's for 90,

2:03:23anybody who actually wants to shoot 48 megapixel RAW

2:03:26is fine with it.

2:03:27- They're gonna be just fine.

2:03:29This is the one time where I'm like,

2:03:31it's kinda weird that a Canon 5D outperforms the iPhone.

2:03:36- Yeah, yeah, that is true.

2:03:38- I think it never usually happens,

2:03:40but you can just fire off 30 megapixel 5D images

2:03:44at 100 frames a second or whatever, and it's fine.

2:03:47It'll just handle them and send them to the memory card

2:03:49and be done.

2:03:50- Right, right, because of course the Canons

2:03:52and the Sonys of the world with the real cameras

2:03:55have all the glass advantages and the sensor size advantages

2:03:59and all the things that come from physics

2:04:01and all the things that come from decades

2:04:04of building high-end professional glass and all this stuff.

2:04:07But man, the one thing that Apple has is silicon.

2:04:11- Yeah, and so it's weird, right?

2:04:13'Cause what we're talking about here is bandwidth.

2:04:16Fundamentally, it's slow,

2:04:18'cause you're just moving the image off the sensor

2:04:20to storage.

2:04:21And those cameras are all just completely optimized

2:04:25to do that as fast as possible.

2:04:27And here is the one place where you're like,

2:04:29oh, this is a general purpose computer

2:04:31that is struggling with this one problem.

2:04:33And usually with these cameras,

2:04:36it's like this general purpose computer

2:04:38is just totally outperforming these other cameras

2:04:41unless you really know how to use them.

2:04:43And it's like I can say to you,

2:04:46I couldn't put it in the review

2:04:47'cause it's such a wonky thought,

2:04:48but it was like the whole time I was like,

2:04:49I've got like a five-year-old 5D that is kicking

2:04:52this thing's ass at shooting high megapixel images.

2:04:55That's weird.

2:04:56- Yeah, it's weird 'cause that's the thing

2:04:58that Apple's always kicked ass at.

2:05:00- Yeah.

2:05:01- Let me think here, anything else with the camera?

2:05:03The video looks amazing,

2:05:04and that's the one area where Apple,

2:05:07for whatever reason, I don't get it why so many years later,

2:05:11Apple's video is so far ahead,

2:05:13whereas on photography, I think arguably,

2:05:17there's still the iPhone 14 Pro is still the best.

2:05:20I think you can, but it is a great debate, right?

2:05:24You can make the case for Samsung,

2:05:27you can make the case for the Pixel,

2:05:28and the new Pixel's coming out, I guess, next month.

2:05:31That's a debate to be had, and it has been for years,

2:05:33and like we just talked about half an hour ago,

2:05:36it's ebbed and flowed in interesting ways.

2:05:39But on video, it's undisputed.

2:05:41Apple is so far ahead of everybody else, and I don't get it.

2:05:44I don't get why they have, why,

2:05:46I get why they pulled ahead,

2:05:47but I don't get why nobody else has been able to catch up.

2:05:51- I think that might just be down to the processing lead.

2:05:53Everyone else is still kinda like,

2:05:55whatever Qualcomm will give 'em.

2:05:56But it's hard to know.

2:05:57I will say that the one thing that caught me about

2:05:59the difference between the Pro and the,

2:06:02the 14 Pro and the regular 14.

2:06:04So action mode is not that useful,

2:06:06in the same way that cinematic mode

2:06:07was not that useful last year.

2:06:08It demands a lot of light, it's obviously its first year.

2:06:11Cinematic mode has greatly improved this year.

2:06:13But the way they're doing it

2:06:15is they're cropping the sensor down,

2:06:17and then recording the whole sensor,

2:06:20and then moving that crop around to stabilize it.

2:06:24- In between frames.

2:06:25And this is another one where they're doing it live, right?

2:06:29And if they would just let themselves

2:06:30have five seconds of slack,

2:06:32or not show it in the viewfinder live.

2:06:36- There's something.

2:06:37Or show a shittier preview, like whatever it is.

2:06:39But the 48 megapixel sensor is way bigger.

2:06:42So like theoretically, you have way more space to stabilize,

2:06:45and they're not doing it.

2:06:46- Mm.

2:06:47- Right, and like maybe that's bandwidth,

2:06:48maybe that's processing, there's a million reasons.

2:06:50But it's strange that in some of these places,

2:06:53they're kind of not using that sensor for all it can do.

2:06:55It's just my opinion of it.

2:06:57- Yeah, I wonder, I don't know.

2:06:58But I mean, action mode,

2:07:00if you ever have gotten on a rollercoaster,

2:07:02and I don't know, I would recommend

2:07:04putting a lanyard on your phone or something.

2:07:06But if you've ever held your phone

2:07:07while shooting something like that,

2:07:08I think it's gonna be terrific.

2:07:09Absolutely terrific, from what I've seen testing it.

2:07:12But the fact that--

2:07:13- Becca is our video director.

2:07:15She did that part of the video review.

2:07:16It's great, she has a great time reviewing these things.

2:07:19And she was like, this looks basically like the 13 Pro.

2:07:21That was her main takeaway.

2:07:23- I think they know what they're doing,

2:07:24and I'm not blaming them.

2:07:25But it seems like with these camera mode features,

2:07:30Apple is a little unusually aggressive

2:07:32about shipping the feature a year ahead

2:07:36of when it's really ready, right?

2:07:38Like the first year of portrait mode

2:07:39was really rough with hair and ears and--

2:07:44- Oh, that was the one that really got me,

2:07:45that Samsung is ahead of Apple in portrait mode.

2:07:47- Yep, I saw that in your example.

2:07:49And I was, you can't look at the side by side and deny it.

2:07:53I have taken some amazing portrait fixers

2:07:56with my iPhone over the last couple of years.

2:07:58And it's great, but if we wanna get into,

2:08:02and it's so much better than it was a few years ago.

2:08:04And again, anybody listening who like a couple of years ago

2:08:08tried portrait mode on an iPhone was like,

2:08:10ah, no, gross gimmick, and hasn't looked at it since,

2:08:14I really encourage you to try it again.

2:08:16Even if you have an older, a slightly older iPhone,

2:08:18but with the latest software.

2:08:20It really is a lot better,

2:08:21and it's actually useful and less gimmicky.

2:08:24And I think it's good that they shipped when they did,

2:08:26and I think it was like a forcing function

2:08:28to make them improve all the tricky things it needs to do.

2:08:32But yeah, your side by side example

2:08:34with the Samsung Galaxy 22 was the hair around the guy

2:08:39was clearly, clearly, honestly with the Samsung one,

2:08:42I did, I zoomed in, I couldn't really see,

2:08:45couldn't see a mistake.

2:08:46- Yeah, they did a good job.

2:08:47We have another one where it's just cut off outside,

2:08:51like in bright sunlight, it just cut off the side

2:08:54of our video producer, Mario's head.

2:08:55And I was like, that's, we're beyond this now.

2:08:58It was good, the portrait mode got good on the 12 Pro,

2:09:01in my opinion, that's when I started using it all the time.

2:09:03And I was like, we should, even the baby S22, not the Ultra,

2:09:06the iPhone 14 version of the S22 outperforms

2:09:10the iPhone 14 Pro, which is totally shocking to me.

2:09:13- Yeah, yeah, that's what we're gonna do.

2:09:14- By the way, I'm looking at these,

2:09:15now I'm looking at these bar photos.

2:09:16I know why we disagree.

2:09:18I'm gonna describe a photo here.

2:09:20See, iPhone does a better job of, you're right,

2:09:22richer colors at night, and it has this kind of like

2:09:25beautiful, natural vending.

2:09:27The Pixel is more accurate because it lets the red light

2:09:30bleed into the other parts of the,

2:09:32the iPhone is color correcting too many things.

2:09:34I forgot that this was my criticism.

2:09:38I just looked at it again, I remember.

2:09:39- All right, all right, but anybody who's wondering

2:09:41what we're talking about, just go to the Verge review,

2:09:43scroll down to the, it's the one that has the really

2:09:47nifty slider you guys have, it looks like one photo,

2:09:50and you can just slide the divider left and right

2:09:53to go between the two pictures.

2:09:55It's a picture from the outside of a bar,

2:09:58sort of kitty corner to the entrance.

2:10:00- It's a neon sign, so it's like one of those shots

2:10:02that really shows off at night mode.

2:10:03- Anything else on the camera?

2:10:05- Any, no, I mean, fundamentally, you know,

2:10:08I think these cameras are all really good now.

2:10:10It's down to processing.

2:10:12I will say this one thing, so I was talking about

2:10:14these old cameras, so I was taking macro photos

2:10:16of the sub-pixels to see if it was worth

2:10:19shooting a video of.

2:10:20I've got this ancient Canon, no, it's a,

2:10:23I've got this ancient Nikon D7500 with my favorite lens

2:10:26of all time, which is a 40 millimeter,

2:10:28they call it a micro lens, and I love it,

2:10:30and this, whatever, so I was sitting there,

2:10:32and my kid's there, and I just took a photo

2:10:34of my friend and my kid with my ancient D7500,

2:10:39'cause I was taking photos of the screen,

2:10:41and I looked at it, and I was like, oh, these photos

2:10:43are still vastly superior to cell phone photos,

2:10:46and so there's still a long way to go here.

2:10:48Really nice glass on a dedicated camera with a big sensor,

2:10:53it'll just kill these smartphones every day.

2:10:56I still use my smartphone a thousand times more,

2:10:59but I think we often forget that there's yet

2:11:02a very long road to travel.

2:11:04- My son Jonas is a freshman in college,

2:11:06we just took him there, and so it's time

2:11:09for family memories, and so we're,

2:11:11it's the end of the summer, looking at lots of old photos,

2:11:15and paying more attention to the photo widget in iOS

2:11:17that surfaces old photos, and instead of just,

2:11:20hey, that's one cool photo, letting me open it

2:11:23and go through 18, 17, 16 year old photos.

2:11:27Back then, in 2004, five, six, I was shooting

2:11:3235 millimeter film with a Canon,

2:11:36mostly with a 50 millimeter F1.4,

2:11:39the famous Canon 50 millimeter prime,

2:11:42and holy hell, looking at those photos,

2:11:46are they, they're so frickin' good.

2:11:49Oh my god, they are so buttery bokeh, right?

2:11:56Like, oh shit, that's bokeh.

2:12:00Oh, that's texture, it's, yeah, I know exactly what you mean.

2:12:04And that's talking shooting onto film.

2:12:06And again, film is beautiful, I'm not complaining,

2:12:08but we tend to think that, oh, tech, tech, tech,

2:12:11computational photography, but yeah, there's so far to go.

2:12:15I had one more thing about, oh, here's one more thing

2:12:17about the camera, I didn't mention it in my review,

2:12:19'cause again, I didn't do a camera review,

2:12:21I'll bet other people mentioned it.

2:12:23One thing I noticed though with this new main camera,

2:12:26with a bigger sensor, and because the sensor is bigger,

2:12:30a very different lens, the minimum focal distance

2:12:35of the main camera has grown by a couple of inches.

2:12:39So-- - Yeah, and then it drops you

2:12:40into that macro mode, it's crazy.

2:12:41- Right, so there's, this thing they added last year,

2:12:46anybody who has a 13 Pro knows what I'm talking about,

2:12:48but when they added this macro mode,

2:12:50and you're in 1x mode, when you go to macro mode,

2:12:53it actually uses the ultra wide 0.5x,

2:12:56'cause that's the lens that can focus at like two centimeters

2:13:00and the transition is weird, but it kicks in way,

2:13:05way further away from the subject now.

2:13:09And it's, this is not good overall,

2:13:12but there's, I understand the physics

2:13:14of focal lengths and distances, but it's,

2:13:17it is a trade-off in the other direction for having this,

2:13:21overall better main camera, but macro,

2:13:25the macro transition, not that macro's worse,

2:13:28macro's probably better 'cause it seems like the ultra wide

2:13:30is actually nicely, subtly improved this year,

2:13:33but the transition, people are gonna notice that.

2:13:36- Do you, and it's also the transition I think

2:13:38is like half an inch too aggressive.

2:13:40- Yeah, I think so too, yeah, there's something--

2:13:42- 'Cause I have the indicator in settings,

2:13:45you can do it so you can turn it off,

2:13:47and it's like, oh, I don't need this right now.

2:13:48- Yeah, that's another one where I would recommend

2:13:51people go into settings, scroll, scroll, scroll,

2:13:54scroll, scroll, scroll, scroll, scroll, scroll to camera

2:13:57and turn on the thing that gives you manual macro control.

2:14:01I think this is one of those things

2:14:03where Apple wants it to be invisible

2:14:05and they want you to think that magically

2:14:07the 1X camera can just focus two centimeters away

2:14:10and so that's why they don't put the little flower

2:14:13macro thing up on the screen by default.

2:14:16And in fact, when they shipped the 13 Pros last year,

2:14:18they didn't even have it.

2:14:19They had to add that into the camera app later

2:14:22because everybody was complaining about it.

2:14:24But they're so obsessed with making,

2:14:25thinking that they can make it seem like magic,

2:14:28but that's something that does not look,

2:14:29that transition does not look like magic.

2:14:32And when you really don't want macro, it's maddening,

2:14:35but you can actually go into settings

2:14:37and get a little button that'll show up on screen

2:14:39when macro kicks in and tap it and turn it off

2:14:42and then you'll get what you want.

2:14:44Here's a little thing, just a side note.

2:14:46I would talk about it, I don't wanna spend a lot of time

2:14:48on the SIM card thing.

2:14:49I think we both sort of agreed

2:14:50that they made the right move for consumers in the US

2:14:52and yeah, it's probably old, but it sucks for us.

2:14:55But did you use, the phones they gave us

2:14:58because for the last couple of years,

2:15:00they've just been giving me at least review unit phones

2:15:03that don't even have a SIM card,

2:15:04don't have like a testing paid by Apple, Verizon account,

2:15:08just unlocked phones with no SIM card

2:15:10and they just assume I'm gonna put my SIM card in them.

2:15:13Well, you can't do that now.

2:15:14So all the three phones I got from Apple

2:15:17had eSIMs already set up.

2:15:20- No, mine didn't.

2:15:21Or maybe there was a QR code in the box.

2:15:23- No, I didn't even have a QR code.

2:15:25They were just already, my iPhone boxes were not sealed.

2:15:29It looked like they were,

2:15:30but there was no seal to open the box,

2:15:32but the phone still had the sticker on the front

2:15:35and I got to peel it off and everything.

2:15:37But I already had like three phones

2:15:40with three different phone numbers on eSIMs on the phones.

2:15:43And I did transfer my main account

2:15:47to the one I spent the week with

2:15:48and still am spending time with.

2:15:50Because they did that for me, I got to test dual SIM support.

2:15:55- I didn't get that.

2:15:57Maybe our actual reviewers like Alison got it.

2:16:00I just got the Pro Max.

2:16:02That was the only phone I had.

2:16:03She has all of them.

2:16:04But I have an AT&T account, I have a Google Fi account.

2:16:06So I actually, I just did my AT&T account

2:16:08for my old phone over Bluetooth, which is seamless.

2:16:11And then I added my Google Fi account on the web,

2:16:13which is actually like kind of great.

2:16:16Like Google Fi's weird and you gotta like go in

2:16:18and add all these like APN numbers and stuff at the end.

2:16:20But the actual like move the SIM over

2:16:24is you just go to a page with a QR code

2:16:27and you just like point the phone.

2:16:28I didn't even get the QR code all the way in the frame.

2:16:31We were trying to shoot it on video

2:16:33and I was like, here I go.

2:16:35And I got like halfway up and I was like,

2:16:36it's done.

2:16:37And back it was like, well, what the fuck?

2:16:39Like, that's it.

2:16:41Like it's pretty seamless.

2:16:43- But here's my complaint.

2:16:44My complaint is when you have dual SIMs activated,

2:16:47the icon for the bars for the signal strength,

2:16:52they look like exclamation marks.

2:16:54- They kinda do.

2:16:56- And so I just assumed, and I noticed it only after,

2:17:01it was like a couple of days in of reviewing it

2:17:03before I reset the phone and restored the other way

2:17:06device to device instead of iCloud.

2:17:08I like wiped the phone and restored again.

2:17:09And I was like, this time I'll do it for real.

2:17:11And they're like, do you wanna move your existing SIM card

2:17:14from this device to device transfer over?

2:17:16I was like, yes.

2:17:17And I did.

2:17:18And they're like, this will take a couple of minutes.

2:17:20And of course it takes a couple of minutes

2:17:22'cause anytime you deal with a carrier,

2:17:23it's whatever activation means, God only knows.

2:17:27But two minutes later they said success and it worked.

2:17:30But I looked at the status bar and it's these bars

2:17:33and they put the secondary SIM as like a little layer

2:17:36beneath, but they look like the dots on exclamation marks.

2:17:39And I assumed they were and that something was wrong.

2:17:42And it was trying to tell me something's wrong.

2:17:44'Cause I'd never done an eSIM before.

2:17:46I'd never done a transfer.

2:17:47I thought they were turned my bars into exclamation marks

2:17:50as a warning that something was wrong.

2:17:53And I spent five minutes trying to figure out

2:17:55what was wrong 'cause it seemed to be working

2:17:58until I figured out, oh, that's how they're showing me

2:18:00I have dual SIMs.

2:18:01They just made them look like exclamation marks.

2:18:04- Yeah, and you can't, speaking of widgets,

2:18:06like you bring down control center and then you're like,

2:18:09oh, I got two carriers here.

2:18:11Maybe I wanna do something with them

2:18:12and you tap on it and nothing happens.

2:18:14- Yeah.

2:18:15- Like it's a very wonky thing to have two SIM cards

2:18:18in your phone.

2:18:19Like it's cool.

2:18:21Like if you have a business line and a personal line,

2:18:23it makes a lot of sense.

2:18:24You can like take the calls in different ways.

2:18:27The one thing I wanna do the most of all

2:18:30is switch from one data plan to the other, right?

2:18:35'Cause Google Fi is basically T-Mobile and I have AT&T

2:18:37and like T-Mobile's just faster than AT&T in New York City.

2:18:42So like I should just switch it over.

2:18:44Even in Google Fi is LTE.

2:18:46So T-Mobile LTE is faster than AT&T 5G in New York City.

2:18:49And you have to like dive into settings and do it

2:18:50or set it to auto and you have no idea what's gonna happen.

2:18:52- Things you'll never get the company

2:18:54that makes any cell phone to tell you

2:18:56is how often LTE is better than 5G

2:18:58in real world situations.

2:19:01- Oh, I basically turn 5G off on my phone.

2:19:03- Yeah.

2:19:04(laughing)

2:19:06It doesn't do anything.

2:19:07I mean, who needs?

2:19:08And when you do get the ultra wide

2:19:09and it's three gigabytes per second download,

2:19:12which is incredibly impressive technically,

2:19:14what the hell are you doing that needs

2:19:15three gigabytes per second download to a phone?

2:19:18- Yeah, I did hear from some readers after it

2:19:21'cause I was very mean to 5G in my review.

2:19:23I got some emails from people who were like,

2:19:24"Look, I live in the middle of nowhere

2:19:26"and I've actually, they put up a mid band 5G tower here

2:19:31"and now my Verizon 5G at my house

2:19:33"is faster than my cable internet."

2:19:35- Yeah, that's great.

2:19:36- It's like that rules, like I'm super down with that.

2:19:38That's like four people in the country.

2:19:40- It was the same thing with the 3G to LTE transition.

2:19:43Here in Philly, I know going to New York,

2:19:45it actually is better to be on the older one

2:19:47'cause that's the one that had the build out

2:19:49and finally got signal strength

2:19:50to go into buildings and stuff.

2:19:52And it's like the practical beats,

2:19:53the theoretical every time.

2:19:56- Yeah, and it's also,

2:19:58the carriers sell everybody 5G phones.

2:20:00The 5G network is like immediately overloaded

2:20:02and the LTE network is not.

2:20:04- It'll be, 5G's gonna be fantastic

2:20:06once they start talking to us about 6G.

2:20:09- Yeah, that's about right.

2:20:10- Which is always the case.

2:20:11Let me take a break here and thank our third

2:20:13and final sponsor, our good friends at HulloPillow,

2:20:16H-U-L-L-O.

2:20:18This, have you ever tried,

2:20:19what a HulloPillow is is a buckwheat pillow.

2:20:23They are totally different than the fluffy soft pillows

2:20:25that most of us are used to.

2:20:28They're sort of more like a bean bag

2:20:30and they're actually quite heavy.

2:20:32That sounds, if you're like me,

2:20:34before I ever heard of HulloPillow,

2:20:35sounds like the most ridiculous thing in the world

2:20:38that like pillowy actually means soft and fluffy

2:20:41in US English.

2:20:43But a HulloPillow is not like that at all.

2:20:45But guess what?

2:20:46All over the world,

2:20:47there's all sorts of places where pillows like this

2:20:51are normal and have been used for a long time.

2:20:54And instead of being filled with feathers or foam,

2:20:57it's filled with buckwheat and it tends to breathe better.

2:21:02And like one of the aspects of it is like

2:21:05if you're the sort of person who like halfway

2:21:06through sleeping, you have to flip your pillow over

2:21:08to get a cool side 'cause the side you've been sleeping on

2:21:10is all hot.

2:21:11Buckwheat pillows aren't like that.

2:21:13They stay cool all night long.

2:21:15And because they are sort of structured

2:21:18because of the beans, they support your head and neck.

2:21:20And so again, if you're the sort of person

2:21:22who always tries to sleep on two pillows

2:21:24to get it propped up, one buckwheat HulloPillow

2:21:28is almost certainly all you need and it'll stay upright

2:21:31and give you all the support you need all night long.

2:21:33My family absolutely loves them.

2:21:36This was actually part of the problem of packing up a thing

2:21:39to take a kid to college is you really start running

2:21:42out of space and you run out of weight

2:21:44and taking a heavier HulloPillow other than a pillow

2:21:47that could be like vacuum sealed into a small bag.

2:21:50Took up extra space that in theory we didn't need

2:21:52but trying to convince my son that he wasn't gonna have

2:21:55his HulloPillow was a no-go.

2:21:57That's how much our family loves them.

2:21:58And they've got, they're made in the USA,

2:22:02right here in the USA with quality construction,

2:22:04great materials, certified organic cotton

2:22:07that is sewn for durability.

2:22:09And again, if you're skeptical, if you're like,

2:22:11this sounds crazy, this does not sound like any pillow

2:22:13I've ever tried, you get to sleep on it for 60 nights,

2:22:16two months, and if it's not for you,

2:22:18you can just ship it back and they will give you

2:22:20a full refund, no questions asked.

2:22:23Go to HulloPillow, H-U-L-L-O P-I-L-L-O-W.

2:22:28HulloPillow.com/thetalkshow.

2:22:32If you try more than one pillow, you get a discount

2:22:36of up to 20 bucks per pillow depending on the size.

2:22:39And if you don't like either of them,

2:22:40you can send them both back.

2:22:42So try two, you get a discount of up to 20 bucks

2:22:44per pillow depending on the size.

2:22:46Free, fast shipping on every order.

2:22:48And 1% of all their profits are donated

2:22:51to The Nature Conservancy.

2:22:53And you can even give the gift of better sleep.

2:22:55It is a great gift for your friends and family.

2:22:57Go to HulloPillow.com/thetalkshow.

2:23:00Quick bonus before we talk The Verge,

2:23:03we could talk about the other stuff

2:23:04that was announced at the event.

2:23:07There's the Apple Watch Series 8,

2:23:08which I think is the most boring year-over-year update ever.

2:23:13- Yeah, there's not a lot there.

2:23:14- Crash detection and the temperature sensor,

2:23:17which is at the moment really only used,

2:23:19and again, not to underplay it,

2:23:21it sounds like a great feature for people

2:23:23who are trying to get pregnant

2:23:24for the retrospective ovulation detection,

2:23:28but otherwise doesn't seem to really do much.

2:23:32- Yeah, I think Apple's in a weird spot

2:23:33where they haven't gotten the things they would like

2:23:35to get FDA approved yet.

2:23:37So yeah, there's some apps and devices

2:23:39that can predict, not just retrospectively.

2:23:42So yeah, Apple needs to get there.

2:23:43But yeah, that one to me, I think Victoria's review,

2:23:47is like if you have an Apple Watch Series 3 by this one,

2:23:48everything else you're gonna get with watchOS.

2:23:51- Yeah, yeah.

2:23:52And that's just the nature of devices, right?

2:23:54You have these go-go years where there's low-hanging fruit

2:23:57and you get amazing year-over-year improvements,

2:24:00but calling it the Series 8, it's great.

2:24:03Now, it's one thing I hate about the iPhone,

2:24:05where they've had all those years

2:24:06where they just added an S,

2:24:08and so the iPhone 14 is not the 14th iPhone, right?

2:24:14You have, I guess the A Series chips have the right number.

2:24:18Like the A16 is the right number, maybe, I don't know.

2:24:22But at least Series 8, the Apple Watch,

2:24:24I don't have much to say about it.

2:24:25But the other watch, wow.

2:24:28- Yeah, I mean, we looked at it at the hands-on.

2:24:32The one thing I did that made everybody mad

2:24:34was I immediately tried to put my third-party band on it.

2:24:36And I can confirm it works.

2:24:38Third-party bands are a little weird.

2:24:39But yeah, they've done it right.

2:24:41The thing that gets me that I am eager to see,

2:24:44they've added all the modes for the extreme sports,

2:24:48but it's just a huge display, right?

2:24:50And they haven't really changed WatchOS

2:24:55to take advantage of this bigger display.

2:24:58Like, it's just bigger.

2:24:59And I don't know, we'll see.

2:25:02- It seems in the way that,

2:25:04and I know that they've tweaked the numbers scrupulously

2:25:09over the years to the millimeter,

2:25:10where it was originally 38 and 42,

2:25:13and then 40 and 44, and now 41 and 45.

2:25:17But there've been two sizes

2:25:19of the regular Series Apple Watches,

2:25:21the smaller one and the bigger one.

2:25:24And they've always shown the same UI scaled,

2:25:28and that has always seemed appropriate, right?

2:25:31It's just smaller fonts, smaller hands,

2:25:33smaller details for a smaller watch.

2:25:36And that has always seemed to me appropriate.

2:25:40My wife uses a smaller one, I use the bigger one.

2:25:43And I've played around with both, and that's always seemed fine.

2:25:45This one, the fact that almost everything they show

2:25:49is really just the same thing scaled up even bigger

2:25:52seems, from my first impressions, to be limited, right?

2:25:57Like, if this were the only Apple Watch,

2:26:01and it were this size,

2:26:03wouldn't there be the ability to use it

2:26:06more like a little mini Dick Tracy computer on your wrist?

2:26:09- Yeah, we have a great start on our site

2:26:11from The Vergecast, a director of audio production,

2:26:13Andrew Murray now.

2:26:14He's like, "Just let me watch TV on this thing."

2:26:16- It, from the hands-on area,

2:26:18it looks like you could credibly watch video on it, honestly.

2:26:22- Like, why not let me just run YouTube TV

2:26:26or the Apple TV app on it?

2:26:27- Well, and I know that if I could just stream

2:26:30a Packers game to it, I'd be great.

2:26:32- Yeah, the aspect ratio of the Apple Watch

2:26:34isn't quite like a phone, but it is vertical,

2:26:38and so much video today, especially short-form video.

2:26:41All the short-form video. - Instagram reels

2:26:42on the Apple Watch, here we go.

2:26:44- Yeah, so all the short-form video,

2:26:47in fact, even this morning, I just read a story

2:26:49on The Verge about how the growth

2:26:52in the top 50 channels on YouTube

2:26:54are all the growing areas of the top channels on YouTube

2:26:58are in the short YouTube shorts.

2:27:01- Yeah, boy, you could credibly watch that on this watch.

2:27:05- Destroy the battery.

2:27:07- Well, but it has a bigger battery.

2:27:10They say it's like double the battery life,

2:27:12so why not let us do those things,

2:27:13and even if it turns this watch into half the battery life

2:27:18that they're promising, 'cause you're dicking around

2:27:20watching video on it all day,

2:27:21you'd still get the one-day battery life

2:27:24that the other Apple Watches have always promised.

2:27:27The other thing that really struck me about,

2:27:30there's the size, the screen is surprisingly bigger to me

2:27:35than the other ones, and the fact that it's perfectly flat

2:27:41is oddly surprising difference to me.

2:27:45- I thought the edge would be taller.

2:27:48- I thought so too, and in fact,

2:27:50I didn't even think it was raised at all at first

2:27:53until one of the Apple BlueShirt people

2:27:55in the hands-on area said, "No, no, it is raised,"

2:27:58and then I used my fingernail, and I could say,

2:28:00"Oh yeah, it is," but it doesn't seem raised enough

2:28:03to be protective in the way that I thought it would be

2:28:06for rock climbing.

2:28:07- Yeah, in the way that they're saying it is.

2:28:10I wonder if there's cases for a regular Apple Watch.

2:28:12I see 'em all the time.

2:28:13- I feel bad for the people who wear them.

2:28:14- The idea of putting a case on this one is ridiculous.

2:28:17- I think people are going to put it in a case though.

2:28:20I really do, and it's like somehow Apple's like,

2:28:23ah, we just can't bring ourselves to really raise the ridge,

2:28:27and I guess the other thing too

2:28:28is that they do want this one big ultra watch

2:28:32to appeal both to the people who actually want to take it

2:28:37on extreme adventures and the people

2:28:41who aren't gonna do anything extreme with it at all

2:28:43but just like the look and idea

2:28:45of this type of big chunky watch,

2:28:49but in that case, you don't really want it,

2:28:51but when you look, and I've spent the week

2:28:53looking at lots of other Garmins and G-shocks,

2:28:56and Coros apparently is really the brand,

2:28:59I know everybody, I talk about Garmin all the time,

2:29:02but Coros apparently is the brand

2:29:04that really might be their number one competitor

2:29:06for this action space, but if you look

2:29:08at how raised the bezel is around those watches,

2:29:11it's really protective.

2:29:13I always go back famously.

2:29:15You're probably too young.

2:29:16I know you and Ben are about the same age,

2:29:19just seven or eight years younger than me,

2:29:20but I remember when the first Casio G-shocks came out,

2:29:24and it was like, I don't know, 81, 82, 83,

2:29:28somewhere around there, and of course,

2:29:29they put the ads all over sports on TV,

2:29:32so I saw the ad over and over and over again

2:29:35watching sports as a kid, and it was,

2:29:37they wrapped the G-shock around a hockey puck

2:29:40and had a hockey player slap shot it into the goal

2:29:43or into the goalie's mitt and then show

2:29:46that the watch was perfectly fine after being slapshotted.

2:29:50This does not look to me like you'd want to do that

2:29:52with this watch.

2:29:53No, not even a little bit.

2:29:54I mean, just 'cause, yeah, G-shock's very plastic.

2:29:58It was a fantastic, it's a commercial

2:30:01that was indelible to me, 'cause I also thought

2:30:03digital watches were super cool when I was a kid,

2:30:05and I was allowed to buy a $22 Casio,

2:30:08and it was the coolest thing in the world.

2:30:09One of my favorite things as a kid

2:30:11was a 20-something dollar Casio digital watch.

2:30:14I wanted the G-shock, though, which was, I don't know,

2:30:17100 bucks, and rightly so, aren't gonna buy a kid

2:30:20a $100 watch, but I wanted it so bad,

2:30:22'cause that seemed so cool, and it's like

2:30:24the Volvo being driven off a building.

2:30:26It's like a hockey slap shot of a watch

2:30:31really seemed like, man, that's a demo.

2:30:33I'm not saying that Apple should've

2:30:35or that they botched it.

2:30:36It's just not quite what I was expecting.

2:30:38- Yeah, I mean, I think there's a lot of,

2:30:41again, this is an early adopter special.

2:30:45I think people are gonna be excited about it,

2:30:47and I think we're a year away from knowing

2:30:49how it's gonna work.

2:30:50- I mean, the one app, which is very unlike Apple

2:30:53to partner with a third party for a core capability

2:30:55that they're advertising, but they're partnering

2:30:57with this company to make Oceanic Plus,

2:30:59the scuba diving app.

2:31:00It's not out yet.

2:31:02Apple's dependent on a third party to ship an app

2:31:05to make its own diving band worth more.

2:31:09- I spent a surprise, I didn't know that it wasn't out yet,

2:31:11and while writing my review, I spent a surprising amount

2:31:14of time trying to find that app,

2:31:16'cause I thought it would be very easy to find.

2:31:18(laughing)

2:31:19- No, we'll see.

2:31:21So there's a lot of this where it's,

2:31:23what does a year of development, now that people have it

2:31:26and their expectations will be real, look like?

2:31:29'Cause my early impression is, well, I'm gonna buy

2:31:33the shit out of this watch, it looks cool as hell.

2:31:35I'm a sucker.

2:31:37And I'm excited to have a longer battery life,

2:31:39and I love a big screen.

2:31:40- And you like a big, chunky watch, too.

2:31:42- Yeah, I'm a big dude, a big, chunky watch works for me.

2:31:46And it's like, is it gonna do any,

2:31:47am I gonna look at two factor codes?

2:31:49That's what I do with my watch.

2:31:51They're just gonna be huge now.

2:31:52- Well, you know what I love doing with my watch

2:31:53is having my Mac when I'm at my desk

2:31:55and I don't have touch ID,

2:31:56'cause I use a standalone keyboard.

2:31:58I love just having my Mac unlock.

2:32:00That's my main Apple Watch use.

2:32:02You know what else?

2:32:02I'm gonna steal this from my friend, Austin Mann.

2:32:04I know he has a review out with the phone.

2:32:06I think he was in the Highlands of Scotland.

2:32:08I haven't looked at it yet as a record,

2:32:10but Austin gave me this idea at the hands-on area.

2:32:13This is, again, the utility of bouncing into people

2:32:16in the hands-on area after these keynotes,

2:32:19is the Apple Watch Ultra,

2:32:21one of the things it does that the other watches don't do

2:32:23is you can turn the digital crown

2:32:25and it turns the display into a,

2:32:28no matter which watch face you're wearing,

2:32:29it goes black and the only pixels are red

2:32:33because that's the ones that disrupt your retinas the least

2:32:37for nighttime viewing.

2:32:38And Austin, of course, thought,

2:32:41I wish I had that mode for the camera on the phone.

2:32:45And it's like, oh, wouldn't that be cool, right?

2:32:48So they do all this night mode stuff with the camera.

2:32:50Wouldn't it be great if you could put the iPhone camera

2:32:52into red pixels on a black background mode?

2:32:55- That is really cool.

2:32:56I have that mode in,

2:32:57I don't remember what stargazing app I have,

2:32:59but I have one of those cool iPhone apps

2:33:01that you point at the sky and it tells you

2:33:02where the stars are and finds the constellations for you.

2:33:05And that has a red mode and it's actually super sick.

2:33:08- AirPods Pro, I don't know what to say about them.

2:33:10They're not out yet, but it seems like a great idea.

2:33:12It's one of my favorite Apple products.

2:33:14The Findable case and Findable earbuds

2:33:16seems like a great idea.

2:33:17I tend not to lose mine, but when I do,

2:33:19every time I'm annoyed,

2:33:20'cause I know how much stuff is Findable

2:33:23in Apple's ecosystem now,

2:33:25and the one thing I tend to misplace is not,

2:33:28well, problem solved.

2:33:29I will upgrade just for the Findability.

2:33:32- Oh, wow, I did a round of questions about

2:33:35while you're saying they have better audio quality,

2:33:37like is it still Bluetooth?

2:33:39Do you upgrade?

2:33:40Are you doing some proprietary stuff with more bandwidth?

2:33:43It's still Bluetooth, apparently.

2:33:44- I think that-- - They're doing

2:33:46codec improvements.

2:33:47- Yeah, I don't ask about that,

2:33:48'cause number one, my ears aren't great.

2:33:50I've never really owned a pair of headphones

2:33:52that I've really thought sounded bad,

2:33:54and it's like as picky as I, I get it.

2:33:56It's me, it's me, it's my ears, it's my taste,

2:33:59because I'm the guy who really, really hates

2:34:01and gets angry and blogs about the use of Arial

2:34:05instead of Helvetica, knowing that 99% of people

2:34:09cannot tell the difference between Arial and Helvetica.

2:34:12So I get it, that other people can do,

2:34:14what I can do with fonts,

2:34:16other people can do with headphones.

2:34:17I get it, I just don't, so I don't really care about that.

2:34:21And I think uncompressed audio is a scam.

2:34:25But, I mean, Apple definitely thinks that.

2:34:28- Yeah, but I think it's a scam,

2:34:30especially if you're playing it in earbuds,

2:34:32not big, open-eared, over-the-head cans.

2:34:36So I don't care, I don't care that the AirPods

2:34:39don't support lossless audio, but I guess some people do.

2:34:44- Yeah, and I think all this facial audio stuff

2:34:46just makes no sense to me.

2:34:47- I do think it's, speaking from things

2:34:50that we could say from being there,

2:34:52it's preposterous to me how many hundreds of pairs

2:34:55of AirPods Pro they had in the hands-on area

2:34:58for us to try. - Yes, it was amazing.

2:35:00There are people with boxes.

2:35:02- Just boxes and boxes and boxes and boxes of them.

2:35:05And so, and they encourage you, they're begging you,

2:35:09try them, please, and I'm like, ah,

2:35:10and they're like, they're fresh, nobody's ever worn them.

2:35:13And then you put 'em on and you try them,

2:35:16and they're all, I don't even know how they do it,

2:35:18they're all pre-paired to somebody's phone,

2:35:20and they can play some music for you,

2:35:23and you're like, yeah, this is great,

2:35:25and I played with the volume, and it seems like

2:35:27that touch swiping for volume up, volume down

2:35:30seems pretty cool.

2:35:31I like the way that only the ear you swipe on

2:35:34gets the little bip bip bip as you go up and down.

2:35:37So if you swipe on your right ear,

2:35:39it's your right earbud only that makes the little bip.

2:35:42And then you take 'em off and you hand them back

2:35:44to the nice person, and somebody else puts 'em

2:35:46in a different case and they take 'em away.

2:35:48(laughing)

2:35:50- Presumably to be cleaned.

2:35:51- I didn't ask, I did not even ask,

2:35:53but they emphasized that all the ones

2:35:55that they were letting us try were not cleaned,

2:35:58they were all factory fresh and had never touched human ears.

2:36:02Now, did they throw them all away?

2:36:04I sure hope not, because somebody would buy them, right,

2:36:07after cleaning a spritz with some alcohol,

2:36:11and who wouldn't wanna buy worn for 30 second AirPods Pro?

2:36:15I don't know, I would love to know

2:36:16what the hell they did with them,

2:36:17but they were swearing up and down that every single pair,

2:36:22and there were hundreds and hundreds of people there,

2:36:24and they're encouraging everybody to try it.

2:36:26It's ridiculous.

2:36:27And of course the trays were custom designed.

2:36:30- Yes.

2:36:32They were, I mean, it was, I wish I had had more time

2:36:35to just be like, I'm sure I'm all right about this.

2:36:37- All right.

2:36:38We gotta talk Verge redesign.

2:36:41- Let's do it.

2:36:41How many font criticisms do you have?

2:36:43- (sighs) I'm gonna say this,

2:36:45because of how busy I've been the last week.

2:36:47Now, you were nice enough, you again, hands on time,

2:36:50friends, you showed it to me last week in the hands on area.

2:36:55- On a phone, mind you.

2:36:56- Well, is it phone, here's my first question for you.

2:36:59Was the phone the first target of the Verge redesign?

2:37:03- Oh, easily, yeah, I think if you worked

2:37:06at a large media company, everyone is deeply aware

2:37:10of the statistics of mobile users versus desktop users.

2:37:12The Verge is an outlier, right?

2:37:14So we are, I think our numbers are basically 70% mobile,

2:37:1825% desktop, 5% tablet, plus or minus one percentage,

2:37:23depending on the month.

2:37:25For the rest of the company, it's like 90/10.

2:37:27- Really?

2:37:28Wow. - Yeah.

2:37:29This is like every media company.

2:37:30- Wow, I'm out of touch, and my numbers are, (laughs)

2:37:35well, I've been majority mobile though for years.

2:37:39I mean, last time I looked,

2:37:40I hardly ever look at my stats,

2:37:42and of course it's ridiculous and preposterous

2:37:45and embarrassing and we won't go into it

2:37:46that even though even Daring Fireball is mobile first only,

2:37:50it still doesn't have a mobile design

2:37:53other than double tapping the main column to zoom it in.

2:37:55- I like it, I don't think you should ever change it,

2:37:57to be honest with you.

2:37:58- Well-- - I don't know about that.

2:38:00Never say never, right?

2:38:01- But it works, but I get it.

2:38:03But yeah, all right, so mobile first.

2:38:05I don't hate the fonts.

2:38:06I see that you're getting some hate for them.

2:38:08But here's where I'm going with that,

2:38:10is I've been so busy this week.

2:38:11You were kind enough to show it to me last week,

2:38:13kind enough to give me the basic idea of what you're doing,

2:38:16which I love, of course, unsurprisingly,

2:38:19but I haven't been reading enough.

2:38:21I read more of The Verge this morning

2:38:23in preparation for the show than I had

2:38:25from when I first flew out to California until now

2:38:29because I've been so busy.

2:38:31And I'm of the opinion that you need some time

2:38:34before you can pass judgment on typefaces and stuff.

2:38:37I think the main typeface is fine though.

2:38:38I don't know why people, I keep hearing people keep saying

2:38:41I can't wait for Gruber to comment on the font

2:38:44and The Verge redesign.

2:38:46I don't quite get it.

2:38:47I know the headline font is opinionated,

2:38:52but the stuff for actual reading,

2:38:55I don't see what the objection is.

2:38:57I don't, am I missing something?

2:38:59- I've been trying to suss it out.

2:39:01So one, the idea, there's more than a little

2:39:03daring fireball in this whole design.

2:39:05Right, like Dieter and I are walking around being like,

2:39:07fuck it, Gruber can just post to us on website

2:39:09whenever he wants to, like why can't we?

2:39:10So like, that's the heart of it.

2:39:13Like why are we posting to Twitter instead of our own website

2:39:16so we just wanted to build like a lighter weight thing

2:39:18and then that, we think we should blow up The Verge

2:39:20every few years.

2:39:21That's just part of the DNA of the place.

2:39:23Like we should be as much on the cutting edge,

2:39:25we should be product, if we're gonna pass judgment

2:39:28on products, we should run a product.

2:39:30That's how I feel about it.

2:39:31So like I think that builds empathy for me

2:39:33and all the product managers in the world.

2:39:35So yeah, you know, to me I'm trying to figure it out

2:39:37and the main thing, people keep saying

2:39:40there's too many fonts, there's only three.

2:39:42(laughing)

2:39:42- I didn't see too many fonts either, I did not

2:39:45and that's a thing that always jumps out to me.

2:39:47So I would say I agree.

2:39:49- Yeah, there's Minooka, which is a really big

2:39:52opinionated one that we're using pretty sparingly.

2:39:54There's Polysans, which is just beautiful.

2:39:56It's like hard to complain about it.

2:39:58And there's FK Roman, which is just a nice serif.

2:40:00I think we have lots of different weights going on

2:40:02and like it's the first version.

2:40:05We shipped the thing that was done enough to ship.

2:40:09By next week we will be iterating on it.

2:40:12Like everyone just needs a break.

2:40:13We spent two years working on it, but really we spent

2:40:15like 20 minutes sprinting it out the door, right?

2:40:18So we're, and the last six months in particular

2:40:20have been like a dead sprint.

2:40:22So everyone just needed a break this week.

2:40:23Ship it, we gotta see how it feels.

2:40:25You were talking about the student newspaper.

2:40:26Like there's this big, there's a weird spectrum of things

2:40:31that I don't quite know how to describe.

2:40:32But for editorial products or content products,

2:40:36there's like PageMaker where, you know,

2:40:39we run New York Magazine.

2:40:41I don't even know what software they use

2:40:42to lay out the print magazine, but New York Magazine

2:40:44is part of Vox Media.

2:40:45- I think I could say with certainty they use InDesign,

2:40:48but I might be wrong.

2:40:49- No, it's something else and I forget the name.

2:40:51- Oh, is it really?

2:40:51- Yeah, it's some piece of software that helps them

2:40:54lay out the print product.

2:40:55And like the writers submit word docs and then like

2:40:58a designer lays out the print magazine

2:40:59and that's the end of it.

2:41:00And then way on the other end of the spectrum

2:41:02is like YouTube, right?

2:41:05And if you think there's too many fonts

2:41:06in the Verge.com, like just open YouTube on your phone

2:41:10and it's like Fonta Palooza 'cause all the thumbnails

2:41:12are crazy.

2:41:13And so like YouTube designs itself to just be filled in

2:41:16by other people without any control.

2:41:19The Verge product is like in the middle of that

2:41:23in like a very real way because we have a product team

2:41:26and designers that are opinionated and they wanna lay it out

2:41:29and it wants to look right.

2:41:30And then now they have handed it over to a hundred person

2:41:33newsroom and an art team and a video team

2:41:37that are just doing stuff.

2:41:38And there's communication there but there's just no way,

2:41:43there was no way for me personally to know

2:41:45how it would really look until a hundred people

2:41:48started publishing into it.

2:41:49- Right, right.

2:41:50- And so like sure, like it's a little,

2:41:52it's not quite what we expected.

2:41:55It does not look like the Figma mock that I have open

2:41:58in the other tab.

2:41:59We published into it for about six months in staging

2:42:03but we weren't writing short posts 'cause I can't tell

2:42:06a hundred person newsroom like published to nowhere.

2:42:09- Right, yeah, you can't fake--

2:42:11- It's just like a waste of time.

2:42:13So we did it with a small group.

2:42:14So we just like had these ideas and like most of them

2:42:17are playing out the way we think they are,

2:42:19some of them are not.

2:42:20Do I wish we shipped light mode right away?

2:42:21Of course I do.

2:42:22Do it like, do I think we should delineate some of these

2:42:24links a little bit better?

2:42:26Yeah, I do.

2:42:27Like if you sat with something for six months,

2:42:30you forget that not everyone understands it the way

2:42:33that you see it.

2:42:35And so like I think some of the criticism is perfectly

2:42:38on point.

2:42:38We can make the product explain itself better.

2:42:41But fundamentally, am I thrilled that I just like linked out

2:42:46to that story you're talking about, YouTube channels

2:42:48and like where the growth is coming?

2:42:50I read that story in Tube Builder once a week.

2:42:53Here's the top 50.

2:42:54- Yeah.

2:42:55- And there's no reason for me to write a Verge article

2:42:57about it.

2:42:58- Yep, nope.

2:42:59- But now I can just like link to them and like show our

2:43:02massive audience, hey, here's this resource that I think

2:43:06about all the time.

2:43:07And I think that's like, that's the best of the internet.

2:43:10Like that's how it should work.

2:43:11We linked to Wired today.

2:43:14I know and love and trust a lot of journalists at Wired.

2:43:17There's no reason that we should just pretend they don't

2:43:20exist.

2:43:21And so like, that's the best of during Fireball.

2:43:23It's like, that's where we came from at Engadget.

2:43:25We were a link blog for a long time.

2:43:27We should just keep doing it.

2:43:29Like we should bring that back.

2:43:31And the biggest victory to me is like for a couple minutes

2:43:36in 2022, everyone argued about a desktop homepage.

2:43:40Like I did it.

2:43:42Like, I don't feel bad about it.

2:43:45Like no one else has argued about a desktop homepage

2:43:47like this in a very long time.

2:43:48So I'm happy to just make everybody consider,

2:43:52oh, there's a lot of value to these kinds of pages

2:43:54and these kinds of experiences as opposed to if you work

2:43:58in publishing, everyone's like,

2:43:59what's your discord strategy?

2:44:01And it's like, I don't know, somebody else runs that shit.

2:44:03Like not me.

2:44:05- I told you some of this in person,

2:44:06but I have to repeat it because we weren't recording

2:44:10when you showed it to me.

2:44:11But I of course love it.

2:44:14I love the philosophy.

2:44:16I don't, I don't even, but I don't, I don't, I know, I get,

2:44:19I've always gotten the verge, I think very well.

2:44:22Ever since you guys were jumped out of Engadget

2:44:25and what was the temporary site called?

2:44:27- This is my next.

2:44:28- Yeah, this is my next, right.

2:44:30I should have remembered that 'cause I actually listened

2:44:32to you on Ben's podcast at Stratechery

2:44:35where that even came up.

2:44:37And I know it wasn't like a name you abandoned.

2:44:40It was a placeholder name while you built the real thing,

2:44:42which was great though.

2:44:43But that's the mentality that you guys have had all along,

2:44:46which is let's not wait until we get the thing

2:44:49we really want to build going,

2:44:51let's get something else up so we can keep publishing.

2:44:54And that mentality is still, that's the verge.

2:44:57And it's great.

2:44:59But this is so much better because,

2:45:03and I know you said, I don't want to repeat it all,

2:45:05but I guess I think it's a paid podcast at Stratechery.

2:45:08So I guess we can steal it.

2:45:09- But he's your business partner, man.

2:45:12(both laughing)

2:45:15- He won't mind.

2:45:16- No, but you told Ben that the homepage of The Verge

2:45:19is unlike a lot of other properties.

2:45:21And I guess unlike everything else at Vox, a destination.

2:45:24Well, there's where, okay, there's 100 different people

2:45:28contributing to The Verge and there's one person

2:45:30who's contributed to Daring Fireball over 20 years.

2:45:34So there's some big difference on contributor number scale.

2:45:39But that's one thing your site and my site share

2:45:42is my homepage is an enormous destination.

2:45:45I actually, I don't look at analytics very frequently,

2:45:49but I get enormous, I always have, still do,

2:45:53enormous amount of homepage traffic.

2:45:57And I've always been very proud of that.

2:45:59And as other websites over the years,

2:46:02between when I started 20 years ago and where we are today

2:46:06and the trends coming around to it, I've always thought,

2:46:09boy, that's a really weird thing to move away from

2:46:11because once people have had a habit of coming

2:46:15to your homepage, why would you make homepage design

2:46:18decisions to turn them off?

2:46:20Like you've, the hardest thing in the world

2:46:23is to gain traction because no matter what it is,

2:46:27gaining traction is a mystery and there are,

2:46:32I think ultimately something that really ultimately

2:46:36deserves to succeed will succeed eventually.

2:46:39But it might take longer than the people or person

2:46:42making it thinks it ought to and maybe then it deserves.

2:46:46And sometimes something catches fire and it has its moment,

2:46:50its viral moment and gains traction early.

2:46:53And you can't explain why that happens.

2:46:55But man, once you've got it, keep it.

2:46:59And if you've got a readership that likes coming

2:47:01to your homepage, your homepage should keep making

2:47:05them happy.

2:47:05And so many publications over the last 15 years

2:47:10made change, and I don't think The Verge ever had

2:47:13a bad homepage.

2:47:16But like you said to Ben, it was sometimes a mystery

2:47:18to you why so many people were coming 'cause you'd have

2:47:21sort of a like a menu of, hey, here's like the eight

2:47:26feature stories that we're highlighting right now.

2:47:28And they're not gonna change that frequently

2:47:30throughout the day because how many times are Verge written

2:47:35stories going to come out?

2:47:36- Yeah, so we write a lot.

2:47:38We write between like 35 and 50 stories a day.

2:47:40And like what I was getting from our old homepage

2:47:45is it was like a list of facts.

2:47:47Like I don't know, like even because we were using it

2:47:49the same way, our headlines were starting to get more boring

2:47:52which is weird.

2:47:53Like it's a weird feedback loop.

2:47:55Like you open the homepage and it's like here's a list

2:47:57of things that happened today.

2:47:59And you could like close it.

2:48:00And you kind of like had a summary and then you could pick

2:48:03the one that you wanted.

2:48:05- I think it's really weird to bring people into a homepage

2:48:07and then immediately ask them to leave.

2:48:10- Yeah.

2:48:11- It's just strange to me and it was that's where we were.

2:48:13And it's fine.

2:48:14So we have a big homepage.

2:48:15It's a unique asset immediately.

2:48:17It's like literally it's like us, you, CNN,

2:48:20the New York Times, like those are the homepages in media.

2:48:23- And Drudge, don't forget Drudge.

2:48:25- Oh Drudge, Drudge will drive an enormous,

2:48:27like Craigslist.

2:48:27- Right.

2:48:28- It's like this weird collection of brands that have

2:48:31direct homepage audience at scale.

2:48:33And I'm leaving out like obviously like youtube.com.

2:48:36I mean like actual publisher homepages.

2:48:38And we just have a bigger, like most publishers are like

2:48:40a percentage of their traffic comes off their homepage.

2:48:43Ours is a massive percentage.

2:48:45So we were like we should just make it worth coming back

2:48:47to one time a day while solving this problem of I see

2:48:51a bunch of cool shit.

2:48:53Like we have a bunch of online reporters.

2:48:55We see cool things all the time.

2:48:58And sometimes the story is like Elon tweeted,

2:49:01look at the tweet.

2:49:02And we were burning like an hour going from oh the guy

2:49:06tweeted, do we have to write about this thing?

2:49:08Like what are the 500 words that justify our publish process

2:49:11and then putting, it's like no,

2:49:13show them the tweet and move on.

2:49:14- Yep.

2:49:15- No, like we'll get there.

2:49:17What I would say to you is we do not think our design

2:49:22is perfect.

2:49:23I do think we need a light mode where all those things

2:49:26are just like on a roadmap.

2:49:27But if we didn't ship it and get the feedback,

2:49:30we'd actually not know how to prioritize the roadmap.

2:49:32- No, I think you're right.

2:49:33I think it's exactly like I was saying with Apple shipping

2:49:36some of these computational photography features earlier

2:49:39rather than perfected like portrait mode

2:49:41and this year's action mode.

2:49:43Yeah, this is the worst action mode Apple's ever gonna ship.

2:49:46But it's worth shipping this year.

2:49:49It's good enough that it's worth shipping even though

2:49:51we have lots of complaints about it and it crops too much

2:49:54and it requires too much light.

2:49:55But it is good.

2:49:57This design is clearly good enough to launch.

2:50:00- More than good enough.

2:50:01And there are complaints.

2:50:02Yeah, sure, it should have a light mode.

2:50:04All right, whatever.

2:50:05But I don't even wanna talk about that.

2:50:07To me, it's the format.

2:50:09It's talking about it as a wire frame, right, is great.

2:50:13And the one thing I'm annoyed about is I've had an idea,

2:50:18and again, I'm a procrastinator and I do everything

2:50:20at my site myself so it takes a while.

2:50:22But I've had the idea of adding a new type

2:50:26to the things I post where it would just be

2:50:30like an update where it would be something

2:50:35that would show up or will.

2:50:37I'll say will 'cause I'll commit to shipping.

2:50:38I just won't tell you when.

2:50:40But it would never be longer than three fingers, right?

2:50:45And probably usually one finger or two fingers.

2:50:50But just a little update so that if I update,

2:50:53like my post yesterday, my big, long, giant iPhone 14 Pro

2:50:58review, but I have to update it because maybe,

2:51:01let's say I get off this podcast with you

2:51:02and find out I made a terrible mistake or something

2:51:05or I found out something and I need to update it.

2:51:08I'm gonna post the update in this article

2:51:11that I published last night and that anybody

2:51:13who's already read, it's 15 pages printed out

2:51:17and they're not going to randomly go back to the article

2:51:21and scroll down halfway to the camera section

2:51:23just to see if I wrote an update.

2:51:25But if I do update it, I would love to have that update

2:51:27on my homepage and say update and it would just be

2:51:30like a new little item.

2:51:32Anyway, now it's gonna look like I'm stealing

2:51:34from The Verge. (laughing)

2:51:36- Well, that would be the best compliment of all.

2:51:39Great artist steal, as I'm told.

2:51:41- But yeah, look, we stole the first bit from you,

2:51:44so I'm not gonna be too worried about that.

2:51:46- Yeah, yeah.

2:51:47The two, like-- - Well, nobody's gonna look

2:51:48at The Verge and say it looks like a rip-off

2:51:50of Daring Fireball and nobody's gonna look

2:51:51at my fragment thing and say, oh my god,

2:51:54now the Daring Fireball looks like The Verge.

2:51:56So it's not, we're all friends here.

2:51:59And this is taking, this is, everything is a remix, right?

2:52:04And this is using ideas from others

2:52:06to draw inspiration for yourself.

2:52:08It's the best of creativity and taking ideas

2:52:10and building something new.

2:52:12- Yeah, the quote that has been rattling

2:52:14through my head this week is like,

2:52:16it wasn't a Steve Jobs quote, it's like,

2:52:19it's worth criticizing, like Alan--

2:52:20- Oh yeah, that's an Alan Kay thing.

2:52:22The Mac was the first computer worth criticizing.

2:52:25- Yeah. - Look, there's been lots

2:52:26of websites worth criticizing, but like,

2:52:28the fact that people care enough to tweet at us

2:52:33about our desktop homepage is like, all right,

2:52:36we've accomplished the first goal,

2:52:39which is like make something interesting

2:52:41that everyone will think about and have a think about.

2:52:44And the other thing that I keep thinking about,

2:52:45which is far more cynical and snarky,

2:52:47is like Apple made us use iOS 7 for like a full year.

2:52:51And we'll be a little bit faster than that.

2:52:55- Yeah. (both laughing)

2:52:57'Cause you're not on an annual schedule.

2:52:58- Yeah, exactly.

2:53:00We're talking weeks before the first round of updates,

2:53:03I think, maybe even shorter than weeks in some ways.

2:53:04But you gotta, sometimes you gotta burn it all down, right?

2:53:08iOS 7 burned it all down and they built it back up.

2:53:12And like, for me, it was, the old,

2:53:16a lot of the things we have an entirely new front end.

2:53:18It's actually, there's like a technological masterpiece

2:53:22at the heart of this.

2:53:23We run this content management system called Chorus.

2:53:27Chorus runs a lot of things.

2:53:28The Minneapolis Star Tribune is published on Chorus.

2:53:30And the big move a couple of years ago

2:53:33was to make Chorus headless.

2:53:35So now it is served by API, which is a big thing.

2:53:38And then we built our own custom front end

2:53:40of Chorus called Duet, which is, runs on Next.js.

2:53:43It's like this whole situation is like five, six teams

2:53:48at this huge company, like built the verge for us.

2:53:53You can see like the things you can do

2:53:56once you can serve the whole site via API,

2:54:00and then you can plug any API into your shiny,

2:54:04new technological Marvel front end is pretty wild, right?

2:54:08Like there's stuff we can do now

2:54:10that we would have never been able to do with our old,

2:54:13not just the old design, but the old tech stack of the verge.

2:54:17And so like, yeah, there's rough edges here,

2:54:19but it's all the beginnings of,

2:54:21oh, we burned the shit down

2:54:22and now we're gonna build it back up.

2:54:25- What comes around goes around.

2:54:26I've been talking about this privately with friends

2:54:29and people close to the 20 years I've been doing this

2:54:34where I, not like I sketched out the whole system,

2:54:37but I've been saying that a CMS,

2:54:39all CMSs should be designed headless by fiat,

2:54:43not like, oh, it would be nice if you did it.

2:54:46- But Amy Klobuchar, the Headless CMS Act of 2022.

2:54:49- Right, but every single CMS that is designed web first,

2:54:54or anything else first, 'cause you could go back in time

2:54:57and find older CMSs from like the '90s

2:55:00when newspaper systems that were like dedicated,

2:55:03weird terminal type things.

2:55:05But from the web era onward,

2:55:07anything that was designed as a web app first with,

2:55:10oh yeah, and we'll add APIs.

2:55:12You never, the APIs, you'd never do it right.

2:55:16And you make decisions in the web app

2:55:19that can't be API-ified.

2:55:21Whereas if it's all, if it has to be API first

2:55:24and the web is just the first and maybe most used client,

2:55:29then when new opportunities happen and new things happen,

2:55:33like, oh, guess what, these frickin' phones

2:55:35that came out starting in 2007 are like,

2:55:39should be a client to the CMS,

2:55:40but our web app can't possibly be usable

2:55:43on this tiny little screen.

2:55:45It all is possible, right?

2:55:47And that you could make a client for the Apple Watch Ultra

2:55:50or something, I don't know.

2:55:52All sorts of things are possible that wouldn't be.

2:55:54Or all of a sudden, Twitter is a thing.

2:55:57We can connect our CMS to Twitter

2:55:58and it doesn't have to go through a web app.

2:56:00It's just, it's APIs, so it can all be automated.

2:56:03But that's-- - Yeah, we had our--

2:56:04- And it solves all the problems of blogging APIs

2:56:07where blogging clients like my beloved Mars Edit,

2:56:11there's so many, the APIs that it has to use all suck

2:56:15because they're all, it's not Mars at its fault.

2:56:18I love WordPress, I don't use it, but I love it

2:56:21and I'm so proud of WordPress and think it's such a great

2:56:24thing for the web that literally a majority of the websites

2:56:28in the world run on it, but it's web-first

2:56:30and the APIs for WordPress will never be as good

2:56:33as they would be if there was something

2:56:35that was API-first.

2:56:37Twitter, to me, is the elephant in the room

2:56:39with this redesign in two different ways.

2:56:44The first way is like you've said that,

2:56:49hey, why is your staff, why is it easier for them to,

2:56:54if they just wanna point out, like I'm looking

2:56:56at the Verge head page here, Elizabeth Lapato tweeted

2:56:59earlier today before we started recording,

2:57:01"Oh, FedEx says a recession's coming.

2:57:02"Why should that make you nervous?

2:57:04"Well, Fed chair Alan Greenspan used to talk with FedEx

2:57:07"every week for the FedEx indicator."

2:57:10In other words, he thought FedEx had its pulse

2:57:13on the economy.

2:57:14That's the whole post.

2:57:16That's it.

2:57:16And it's a link, and it's a link so you can go read

2:57:18more about it.

2:57:19But why until now would it have been easy?

2:57:22She could have tweeted that.

2:57:23She might have tweeted that.

2:57:25But why is it easier?

2:57:28And one thing, as a user, as someone who is doing

2:57:32the tweeting, Twitter has a great experience.

2:57:35There's a box and you type in it and then you hit Return.

2:57:41Or you click the Publish button or Post,

2:57:43whatever the hell the action is, right?

2:57:45That's it.

2:57:46That's great.

2:57:48It is, 'cause there is no friction,

2:57:50and no friction interfaces will beat

2:57:53frictioned interfaces every time.

2:57:55- Yeah, so we built that for us.

2:57:57We cut down our editor.

2:57:59It looks basically like Twitter.

2:58:01There's some publisher stuff.

2:58:02Like, we need some groups in there.

2:58:03We need to be able to add some bylines, like, sure.

2:58:06But that was our thought, was the reason we're using

2:58:09Twitter is, one, the interface,

2:58:11a standard article publishing interface,

2:58:14you can see the company's org chart and KPIs in it.

2:58:18- Yep, yep, yep.

2:58:20- It's just there.

2:58:21It's the way it goes, and it's fine.

2:58:24It has made us very successful over 11 years.

2:58:26This was like, we're just gonna get rid of every field

2:58:28that doesn't need to be there

2:58:30and make it nicer than Twitter.

2:58:32And if you're listening to this, you're probably aware

2:58:35that big publishers have these baroque social media

2:58:38policies and they're tying themselves in knots

2:58:41over reporters using Twitter and being personal brands.

2:58:43And my instinct is like, well, you just give them

2:58:45better software.

2:58:46Just make the tools more fun to use,

2:58:49and it's kind of working.

2:58:50- Yeah, and I think that you don't even have to have

2:58:52the policy then, because if the tools are there

2:58:55and the ease is there, and it's just,

2:58:57type this into a box with the URL that you're linking to

2:59:00and your comment on it and hit a button and it goes out,

2:59:03the fact that they'll be doing it

2:59:07in a verge-appropriate way will be intuitive to them,

2:59:10because they know what they're doing, right?

2:59:12Like the baroque policies are all about the nether,

2:59:14the gray areas of a political reporter tweeting

2:59:19an opinion about politics when their day job

2:59:23at the New York Times or the Washington Post or whatever

2:59:26is being a straight reporter on politics.

2:59:29Whereas if they knew the destination of the blurb

2:59:33and link was going to their publication,

2:59:36it's intuitive.

2:59:37You don't even, it's second nature, right?

2:59:42As opposed to when--

2:59:42- Our features--

2:59:43- Well, I'm not saying nobody's going to make a mistake.

2:59:46I'm just saying, though, it'll keep them on board.

2:59:51- You know? - Yeah.

2:59:52I mean, yeah, our staff is like,

2:59:55it was in particular, you called hers out,

2:59:58like, I think the thing that makes the verge great

3:00:01is we don't hold ourselves to the standards

3:00:03of being national political reporters or whatever.

3:00:06It's the most emotional tech publication

3:00:08that has ever existed in the history of the world.

3:00:10Like, we're proud of it.

3:00:11We wear our hearts on our sleeves.

3:00:13My features editor, Kevin Nguyen, is always telling me

3:00:15it's a verge story 'cause it's on the verge, right?

3:00:17And like our collective taste is what defines

3:00:19the brand of the publication.

3:00:20So we'll see, like we did run it in staging

3:00:23where some stuff we said, okay, we just,

3:00:26this is going too far.

3:00:27Like don't post old meme jokes.

3:00:30Like we don't need to do this stuff.

3:00:32And there's some stuff that's better

3:00:33for people's personal Twitter.

3:00:34I'm not gonna, we're not policing that

3:00:35by any source of imagination.

3:00:37But the part where like you are a reporter or a journalist

3:00:40and you wanna talk about the thing you cover,

3:00:42it's very natural for you to do that

3:00:44if the interface is as good as the one

3:00:47that Twitter offers you to do it on your homepage.

3:00:49- Yeah. - And I think that,

3:00:50and it's like fun.

3:00:52And like, I think most enterprise software is not fun.

3:00:57And so if we just make ours like a little bit more fun,

3:01:00it is vastly more fun than everyone else's

3:01:02enterprise software.

3:01:03- Right, it's like taking a bicycle uphill

3:01:06versus taking a bicycle downhill.

3:01:08Taking a bicycle, riding a bicycle downhill is lots of fun.

3:01:12Riding a bicycle uphill is no fun at all.

3:01:15And most CMS interfaces is to get this thing I wanna,

3:01:20whether it's a long article or a medium article

3:01:22or a link post, even a link post.

3:01:24If it feels like riding a bicycle uphill

3:01:26and over on your phone, there's Twitter,

3:01:30which is like riding a skateboard downhill.

3:01:33(laughing)

3:01:36- With all of the danger that that entails.

3:01:37- Yes, exactly, fun.

3:01:39(laughing)

3:01:41But you don't even have to pedal.

3:01:43You just hop on.

3:01:44Of course that's what you're going to do.

3:01:46It's human psychology.

3:01:47And it's even the sort of thing where maybe

3:01:49first thing in the morning, oh, I'll do the right thing.

3:01:51But by the end of the day, when your willpower is depleted

3:01:55because you've gone through the day,

3:01:57and that's how willpower works.

3:02:00That's why people who work out in the morning

3:02:01tend to stick with it better than people

3:02:03who try to work out after work,

3:02:05'cause your willpower is with you in the morning.

3:02:08That's great.

3:02:08The flip side of the Twitter argument

3:02:10is the consumption, right?

3:02:12And this is where I talk to you.

3:02:16I think we're seeing a moment where people out there

3:02:20are realizing, you know what,

3:02:22Twitter is a waste of my fucking time.

3:02:24Yeah, I love Twitter.

3:02:26And it is where my community is.

3:02:28I check my mentions.

3:02:29But I more and more and more

3:02:31only look at two things in Twitter.

3:02:33I look at my DMs, which are open,

3:02:36and I look at my mentions.

3:02:38And I love to go back and forth with people in my mentions.

3:02:42It is the comment section of "Daring Fireball,"

3:02:45in fact, unofficially,

3:02:46and the only one that's ever been in public.

3:02:49And I love it for that.

3:02:50But I don't go to my main, I don't set up lists.

3:02:52I don't go to my lists.

3:02:53I don't go to the, I'm not saying I never do.

3:02:56I do sometimes.

3:02:57But every time I do, I regret it, and it's a waste of time.

3:03:01And going instead, what's going on with the Mac,

3:03:06going to MacRumors and just scrolling down

3:03:09to see what's going on, just going to TechMeme.

3:03:13Did anything break?

3:03:14Just take a look at the top four stories on TechMeme.

3:03:16Nope.

3:03:17Go to The Verge, scroll down, scroll, scroll.

3:03:19Oh, there's a neat, oh, this is a neat story

3:03:21about this FedEx predicts recession thing, right?

3:03:25That, to me, is so much more peaceful, effective.

3:03:30It's not a time sink.

3:03:34It's not gonna make me angry.

3:03:36I'm never gonna go to theverge.com

3:03:39and scroll down and get angry,

3:03:43like I do if I go to my main Twitter timeline.

3:03:46And I think a lot of people are becoming aware of that.

3:03:50- Yeah, I think we feel that in the moment.

3:03:54Since I've had this in the past six months,

3:03:56my Twitter usage has dropped,

3:03:58and I've been publishing to no one.

3:04:00(laughing)

3:04:01I've been publishing to a staging server

3:04:03for 20 other people who have access,

3:04:05and I was like, oh, I love writing for these 20 people.

3:04:08And if I can just, The Verge is huge, right?

3:04:12It just is.

3:04:13It's a 100-person newsroom inside of a 2,000-person company

3:04:16that runs 18 editorial brands

3:04:18that has now this massive product team,

3:04:20which if it hasn't come through,

3:04:22that I love very much for building this product for us.

3:04:24This huge sales organization, whatever, it's big.

3:04:28There's a huge audience.

3:04:29If I can just make it feel small to an individual reader,

3:04:34we will be successful.

3:04:36That's the goal of this.

3:04:39- And I think it harks back to the early days of Twitter,

3:04:43when nobody would have called Twitter a cesspool.

3:04:46The only thing we complained about was the fail whale

3:04:48because they couldn't keep the thing running,

3:04:51which again, I keep thinking, not to go on a tangent

3:04:54'cause we're out of time, way out of time for tangents,

3:04:56but this whole thing with Mudge and the fact

3:05:00that according to him, Twitter's entire infrastructure

3:05:02is a goddamn duct tape Byzantine Rube Goldberg mess

3:05:07that nobody inside Twitter actually understands,

3:05:11to me, makes complete sense

3:05:13because they never really fixed the fail whale problem.

3:05:19They just sort of, eventually it stopped happening

3:05:22and they're like, okay, don't touch anything.

3:05:24- Yeah. - And it just kept going.

3:05:26But they have all these, ever since they've been around,

3:05:29they have all these weird problems,

3:05:30like all but your most 800 recent tweets

3:05:34are actually in cold storage and you couldn't delete.

3:05:39It all sounded like a mess.

3:05:41They never fixed it.

3:05:42But in those early days of Twitter,

3:05:44the actual timeline was like,

3:05:47it was nothing but gold, right?

3:05:48It was like, I follow like 70 people

3:05:51and they're all people I chose,

3:05:53or accounts I chose to follow.

3:05:55And it was gold, gold, gold, gold, right?

3:05:58It was just like, oh, funny links, funny jokes,

3:06:01observations from friends, and it was nothing but joy.

3:06:05And didn't even have the infinite scroll.

3:06:10You could get to the bottom.

3:06:11(laughing)

3:06:13And it would stop and you'd be like,

3:06:14okay, I'll come back tomorrow, Twitter, thank you.

3:06:17And it's such, I know the analogy,

3:06:19the slow boiling pot of water with a frog in it,

3:06:23I use it all the time, everybody uses it,

3:06:24but it's so powerful.

3:06:26It is so, it speaks to the way we as humans

3:06:30get into problems.

3:06:31Twitter going from nothing but gold

3:06:34and a fun place to scroll down

3:06:37until you hit the bottom of today's tweets

3:06:39to what it is today, which is,

3:06:42I don't even know what, it's like,

3:06:46the money machine, you get into a phone booth

3:06:49and it's shooting dollar bills around

3:06:52and you're supposed to try to grab them.

3:06:53It's like that, except instead of dollar bills,

3:06:56it's like a couple of dollar bills and mostly thumbtacks.

3:07:00Right, shooting around in a phone booth

3:07:02and you're trying to keep them from going into your eye.

3:07:05It wasn't like somebody made this one decision

3:07:08and Twitter went from that to this.

3:07:10It was a slow boiling frog.

3:07:13But here we are, and I think people are like,

3:07:15you know what, I'm getting out of the pot

3:07:17and I'd like to go back somewhere nice

3:07:19where every single thing as I scroll down,

3:07:21maybe I'm not interested in this post.

3:07:23I'll just keep, I'll just move my eyes down three inches

3:07:26to the next one and then I'll hit the space bar

3:07:29or swipe on my phone and until I, oh,

3:07:33and I saw that post so I know I'm done.

3:07:35I've caught up on what's on theverge.com

3:07:37or on Daring Firewall.

3:07:39- The thing I really wanna add is the indicator

3:07:41that says you're done.

3:07:42- Yeah.

3:07:43- We have grand plans to make this thing alive.

3:07:48We just had to ship a thing first.

3:07:51Building the logic to make it update live

3:07:53and to remember state and all that stuff is like,

3:07:57why are we holding ourselves up?

3:07:59We should ship it and make sure

3:08:01that it's doing the things we want.

3:08:03Like the fail state for this is our staff hates it,

3:08:05we stopped doing it and it kinda looks like the old verge.

3:08:09Right, it's just a list of stories.

3:08:10- What do you think, is that even on a table?

3:08:12I mean, do you have feedback from the staff yet?

3:08:14- Oh, we love it.

3:08:16- Well then why are you even saying?

3:08:18- Well, I'm just saying like we needed to ship a thing

3:08:20where like the fail state didn't imply

3:08:23that we were gonna spend a bunch of time

3:08:24building live logic.

3:08:26- Gotcha, gotcha, gotcha.

3:08:27- But now it's like here, it's been three days, who knows?

3:08:29Maybe it'll still be a disaster.

3:08:30But we think it's gonna be fun.

3:08:32But we have grand plans to build this thing

3:08:34into being kind of alive.

3:08:36And so that thing you're talking about where you're done,

3:08:39I think is very powerful.

3:08:42And then once we know you're done, or you're done,

3:08:45saying there's something new is also very powerful.

3:08:47So we've just got these like moves yet to build

3:08:51that I think are, I'm just excited to have people

3:08:54care about a webpage.

3:08:56And I already have a text from half a dozen media people

3:09:00that are like, you're obviously making an app, right?

3:09:03And it's like, yeah, maybe.

3:09:04Like I've just described our headless CMS certified API.

3:09:06Like I saw the PM of our API, his name is Phil,

3:09:09he runs this API called Tower inside of Xmedia app.

3:09:11And we had our little launch happy hour at the bar.

3:09:14And he was like, how's it going?

3:09:15And I was like, I have 900 ideas for your API.

3:09:17And he was like, oh God.

3:09:18So like we'll get there.

3:09:21But we had to ship the first thing first.

3:09:23- Yeah, and you guys could,

3:09:25I'm not even gonna try to talk you out of an app

3:09:26because you guys have enough staff.

3:09:30And like you said, I don't know,

3:09:31I'm actually surprised that it's 50 articles a day.

3:09:34I was thinking more of like the type

3:09:35that would get anchored at the top.

3:09:36But I'm not, I'm a little surprised, not surprised.

3:09:40You've got enough content that you could justify

3:09:42an actual app that is your own.

3:09:43But I used to get all the time,

3:09:47it's one of those things like 20 years ago,

3:09:49over and over and over again,

3:09:50why doesn't Daring Fireball have comments?

3:09:52Why don't you have comments?

3:09:53Everybody else has comments.

3:09:54You use movable type, right?

3:09:55That has comments.

3:09:56Why don't you have comments?

3:09:57Why don't you have comments?

3:09:58It's not really a blog if you don't have comments.

3:10:01And I would say, okay, then it's not a blog.

3:10:04But it looks like a blog to me.

3:10:05I just, but there was some--

3:10:06- Extremely boring, is the original blog.

3:10:09- It's one of those decisions where time has proven me right

3:10:12and at some point people stopped asking me,

3:10:14why don't you have comments?

3:10:16Because they got it.

3:10:17People used to ask me in the go-go years of the App Store,

3:10:24oh my God, all you do is write about Apple.

3:10:27You're the go-to place for me to go to

3:10:29to find out about apps for the iPhone.

3:10:31You gotta have a Daring Fireball app.

3:10:34You gotta have a Daring, why don't you,

3:10:35you're working on it, right?

3:10:36And I'd be like, no, I don't want an app.

3:10:39I've already, you said, you just told me,

3:10:41you come to my website to read about this stuff.

3:10:43I'm done, I've got it.

3:10:44This is meant to be a website.

3:10:46And you can read it on your phone, it's fine.

3:10:49You don't need, it doesn't need to be an app.

3:10:51I never understood, and guess what?

3:10:55People don't ask me that anymore.

3:10:56- Yeah, I mean, I've,

3:10:58I'm not wearing a shipping app tomorrow.

3:11:00I think I have--

3:11:01- I could not, there's no justification

3:11:03for Daring Fireball to happen.

3:11:04I don't write enough.

3:11:05Even on the days when I'm the most productive

3:11:08with the most link posts,

3:11:09it doesn't make sense for me to have an app, never did.

3:11:12You, the Verge could definitely justify it.

3:11:14- I think especially now that we have a feed

3:11:16that updates all the time and points you around the web,

3:11:18which is like the main thing is--

3:11:20- Right.

3:11:20- The apps are generally better.

3:11:24This is like total Ben Thompson stuff,

3:11:26but like they're generally better

3:11:27when they're aggregators, right?

3:11:28So like we have a little bit of that move to play,

3:11:30but I don't think we can get to an app until,

3:11:34I don't know, I'll call it a year.

3:11:36Like we've got to build this product out

3:11:39and finish it before we try to pipe it into something else.

3:11:42- Yeah, but I'm with you.

3:11:43It's great.

3:11:44It's fantastic that people are talking about a website.

3:11:46- Yeah, it's like, it's hard for me to be like

3:11:50too sensitive to criticism.

3:11:53And like we are, I'm trying to calibrate that very carefully.

3:11:56We're taking it all in, we're reading it all.

3:11:58A lot of it maps to our internal criticism,

3:12:00as you would expect, right?

3:12:02We've been looking at it for months.

3:12:03So that's great.

3:12:05I think we're gonna take it.

3:12:05A lot of it's surprising.

3:12:06We're gonna sort that out and prioritize and do it.

3:12:09But like, none of it's making me feel bad.

3:12:12'Cause I'm like, we're talking about a website

3:12:15on the open web that is worth talking about.

3:12:18So I hope we can just like hold on to that moment

3:12:21as a community for one second and just be like, okay.

3:12:24Like it's not dead yet.

3:12:26We haven't given the web over to Google AMP yet.

3:12:29- Yeah.

3:12:31- Let's just take a minute and like pay attention to it.

3:12:32(laughing)

3:12:34With that, let's wrap it up.

3:12:35I think three and a half hours is long enough.

3:12:38- We pulled like a brogue in here, dude.

3:12:40You went for it.

3:12:41- I did not expect that, but.

3:12:42- At the start, you're like, we can't go for two hours.

3:12:45And here we are.

3:12:46- Well, we did have lots to talk about.

3:12:48And you're the bastard who launched a great web design.

3:12:51So we had more, more to talk about.

3:12:54Anyway, Neelay, I do look forward to this every year.

3:12:58And it honestly, it was your tweet,

3:13:01I was running out of gas late last night

3:13:03and it started creeping into my head.

3:13:05Maybe I'll just wake up and publish in the morning.

3:13:07What's the difference if I go after midnight

3:13:10or early in the morning?

3:13:11But you're the one, you did.

3:13:13You were like, and I'm like, ah,

3:13:15and then I could get Neelay on the show,

3:13:16but I've got to finish tonight.

3:13:18So anybody who read my review actually on Friday,

3:13:23you could probably thank Neelay Patel

3:13:25for getting it out.

3:13:27- The internet's editor.

3:13:28No, man, this is part of the tradition for now.

3:13:30We review the iPhone.

3:13:31I feel like I have to decompress about it with you.

3:13:33- Well, if there's not a link on the verge

3:13:35to this episode of the talk show,

3:13:37God damn it, you're gonna hear from my lawyer.

3:13:39- Oh, you got it.

3:13:40It's done, as soon as it's published,

3:13:41she'll let me know.

3:13:43I'll get that post done in one second.

3:13:44- Yeah, and my lawyer, you really,

3:13:46you do not want to mess with her.

3:13:47(laughing)

3:13:48- I'm excited.

3:13:49- Let me thank our sponsors.

3:13:50We had the Backblaze, we had the Trade Coffee,

3:13:54we had Hello Pillow, and we had Squarespace,

3:13:58and of course, Neelay Patel.

3:13:59I usually shout out to people's Twitters.

3:14:02I'm not even gonna put your Twitter handle on there.

3:14:04To hell with Twitter.

3:14:05Go to theverge.com.

3:14:07- Yeah, it's a good website.

3:14:09You can come to it a couple times a day.

3:14:10I'll be very happy.