Podcast Search

The Talk Show

353: ‘Shop Different’, With Michael Steeber

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Michael Stieber, welcome to the talk show you I just want to say you made my week. Oh

0:00:06Thank you, thank you I hear that you like the project

0:00:11It can see it's like I think you you sent me a heads up maybe exactly a week ago like over the weekend

0:00:20And you just sent me and shot me a nice little email and just said hey

0:00:23I'm releasing this thing called the App Store time machine on Monday morning this that the other

0:00:29Here's a link if you want to take a look before it goes live

0:00:32And I thought that sounds like an interesting thing and I had like an idea in my mind of how

0:00:37Good it was going to be which was maybe not quite

0:00:42Minecraft II

0:00:44But more on the level of like a Minecraft experience or something, right?

0:00:49Right, and then I down I was like one point seven gigabytes

0:00:53Hmm and I downloaded

0:00:55And I was just like wow

0:00:59I mean like if I had been wearing a hat it would have popped off my head

0:01:04So tell people for the people who didn't see my link to it or didn't stumble across it anywhere because it was all over

0:01:09The Apple Internet this week, but tell people what the App Store time machine is

0:01:15Sure. So what I did is I

0:01:18Recreated four different Apple stores at Tyson's Corner Stanford shopping center Fifth Avenue the original store

0:01:25Not the not the current one and an infinite loop formerly the company store and all four of them are recreated to look

0:01:32Exactly how they did on their grand opening days down to everything how the other tables are merchandise the graphic panels on the walls

0:01:41And and I put this all together

0:01:44I modeled it all and I put it in unity and

0:01:47Added a first-person controller so that you can walk around the stores just like you would have

0:01:52Except there's no people obviously. It's just kind of a cool way to

0:01:55to kind of revisit those places and most of them are either gone now or

0:02:01They look different with the exception of the company store at infinite loop. It's it's it's mostly the same yet today

0:02:09Just obviously different products, but I was never around when the first Apple stores opened

0:02:14I just wasn't following Apple at all at the time. So this was kind of a way from for me

0:02:20Personally to visualize it but then also I thought other people might really enjoy it

0:02:25When when did the Apple retail stores first open? This is one of the I should know I should know this but I'm gonna guess

0:02:332001

0:02:34Yeah, the first two stores and this is something that that I've had a lot of people

0:02:40Write to me or mentioned to me that like actually Tyson's Corner wasn't the first Apple store that it was a Glendale Galleria

0:02:49But the first two opened on the same day in May 2001 and and they opened

0:02:54Just a couple hours apart because of the time zone difference

0:02:58so so it's always been like which one's the first one and

0:03:02And there's some people that'll swear by that

0:03:05It was Glendale Galleria and no matter that it opened a few hours later because it has the the rollout number zero zero one

0:03:14Where Tyson's Corner is ten. So there are people that will argue that either way

0:03:19But my stance is that Tyson's Corner is the first one. I

0:03:22Feel funny as me John Gruber arguing over pedantic details and saying that somebody's somebody's being too pedantic

0:03:32So I appreciate it. I think it's a I would call it a tie though

0:03:35It's sort of a photo finish if it's the same day in there in different time zones, but what so what was the year?

0:03:432001 yeah, that's me thought yeah, that's what I thought I

0:03:46I'm trying to think what the first was I was living in

0:03:50Massachusetts outside Boston at the time and the one that was closest to to me and my now wife was in

0:03:57Rockingham Park, New Hampshire and it was one of the first it was

0:04:02So it's such a weird time

0:04:04You know what?

0:04:05Let's let's hold the talk on on the actual stories and let's let's focus

0:04:08Let's keep focusing on your project for now and we'll come back to it

0:04:11But I will say it's it's an inner it it's uncanny how much those that they feel like the original stores and

0:04:19It's like I knew it cuz I've even I wasn't writing daring fireball quite yet. It was a year before I did but I

0:04:26Obviously was still following Apple. I

0:04:29Knew from my memory that a big chunk of the retail space in the original stores was

0:04:37devoted to boxed software

0:04:40Like I knew it I remember it and I know that that's one of those things that really dates

0:04:46You know 20 years is a long time and it's like yeah, that's a big difference, but then

0:04:52Using your app and again, it feels funny to call it an app. It feels more like a game

0:04:57What do you think is an app or is it a game?

0:04:59Yeah, I've tried to decide should I call it an app? Should I call a game? What do I want to say and I

0:05:06guess it feels a little bit wrong for me to call it a game because there isn't really a

0:05:11Strategy element to it and you're essentially you're just walking around the stores, right?

0:05:16But so I think like a game might give people of our own impression

0:05:21But yeah, it's it's not quite like on what you would normally think of as an app either. Yeah an experience

0:05:26Sure. Yeah, it does feel a lot and it's funny

0:05:31We had some family over earlier this week staying with us for a couple days here in Philadelphia

0:05:37And they had some of my young nephews and we took them to some of the museums here in Philadelphia

0:05:43I had your app store time machine in mind

0:05:46It just seems like something built for a museum

0:05:49You're right

0:05:49Like the Franklin Institute here in Philadelphia has lots of stuff like that where you can like oh see what it's like to do blank

0:05:55Right and it's like see what it was like to go to the original Apple stores in 2001

0:06:01And that's exactly what it feels like it's yeah, I guess it's not a game because you don't play there's no score. You don't win

0:06:07There's no competition, but it's not an app. You don't do it's an experience, but it is amazing and it's so

0:06:13Different than say a video like if you had rendered built the same models

0:06:18But just rendered out a video of walking through right because you could do it at your own pace

0:06:26Right because like I'm sure you've watched the video of Steve Jobs introducing the first Apple store

0:06:31And you kind of get the feel of the store when he's walking around

0:06:34Tyson's corner there and showing each of the sections, but there's this added dimension when when you are controlling the camera

0:06:42I think like that really puts you in the moment

0:06:44Mm-hmm. Yeah, like for me I spent an enormous time just sort of looking at the box software

0:06:52Because I was like it was it was funny. There was so much of this box software and it just the box

0:06:59Yeah, the box software was was really funny to me when I was researching all the different titles because like there were there were actual

0:07:07Books on the shelves like for dummies book. Yes. Yes

0:07:11You know, obviously there was a Microsoft Office and things like that

0:07:14But then there were there were a lot of apps from smaller developers

0:07:18Which I thought was kind of interesting given the context that it was before the App Store and and and really how

0:07:24Significant that would have been to have your title on the shelf of every Apple store

0:07:29Which it's just kind of something I never really thought about before

0:07:33Yeah, it was absolutely a huge thing and it was

0:07:37completely unlike the App Store it was

0:07:41Finite right and and I'm sitting here

0:07:45emphasizing how

0:07:48Dated it seems that they devoted so much shelf life to something that doesn't even exist anymore

0:07:55It's not like they choose not to put box software on the shelves. There's there's no such thing

0:08:00At least for Apple platforms, right?

0:08:03I guess the last ret holdout for box software would be the dedicated game consoles a PlayStation Xbox and

0:08:10and switch

0:08:13It they couldn't put box software on the shelves if they chose to and it's never existed for the iPhone or iPad, right?

0:08:20What do you what the hell would what the hell would they give you I guess?

0:08:23Maybe like a lightning thumb stick. I mean, it doesn't even make any sense

0:08:29But still even even with me emphasizing how ridiculous it seems that so much of the space in the stores was dedicated to box software

0:08:36super limited right and tons of it went to Microsoft and Adobe and

0:08:43Quicken and the big names of either some of them still big names today or at least the big names of the time

0:08:49So so for the indie or smaller developers to get in there, it was super super prestigious and I guess good business

0:08:56I don't know. It's it's a box software was always sort of a weird business to be in

0:09:00the other thing that that was really striking to me in the in the oldest stores was how much space was devoted to

0:09:09Third-party hardware, especially like camcorders digital cameras the the first stores predated the iPod by a few months

0:09:16So there are actually third-party mp3 players on the shelf from from like the Rio

0:09:21Can't remember the other names off the top of my head. But yeah, there were palm

0:09:25PDA's just all this third-party hardware

0:09:29that's that slowly disappeared from the stores and if you walk into an Apple store today and you can you really

0:09:35Study the like the accessory shelves. There's almost no third-party

0:09:40anything except for a few different iPhone cases like

0:09:44Like five different MacBook sleeves or like they just have a very very small selection

0:09:50Or is that like that was like half of the store?

0:09:53Originally, yeah, definitely what I I remember from that era was it didn't take long

0:10:00Obviously it was only a couple months. I don't even know if I

0:10:04when I first went into when I forget when the

0:10:06Rockingham one opened and there was another one closer to where I worked at bare-bones software outside Boston

0:10:12Forget the name of the mall it was in but it was funny because they were identical. I mean like if you like

0:10:17Kidnapped me put a hood over my head and then just put me in one of the two which I was familiar with

0:10:25I wouldn't be able to tell you which one I was in because they were like identical which is a

0:10:29Very Apple like thing to do but it didn't take long

0:10:33for

0:10:35Me to notice that like if you were walking around the mall

0:10:38Where there was one and people would you'd hear people say do you want to go to the iPod store?

0:10:43And oh, yeah, and I mean like super common like the way that probably more people

0:10:51Called the iPod touch the iTouch then called it the iPod touch while the iPod touch was a thing

0:10:58people called it the iPod store for a long time which was for me as somebody who loved the Mac and knew that the Mac was

0:11:05The bigger deal of the things in there or at least it was in my mind

0:11:09It didn't annoy me but it was like, huh?

0:11:12That's really interesting

0:11:13and then it made me think like now we're getting into the very early years of during fireball and people used to talk about the

0:11:21Quote-unquote halo effect. That was the idea that hey, maybe the iPod is going to be

0:11:27good for Mac sales because it's

0:11:30Introducing people to any Apple product for the first time and then they're think hey if the mp3 player was really cool

0:11:39Maybe I should take a look at one of these Macs and I just remember thinking anecdotally hearing people call it the iPod store

0:11:45Yeah, maybe there's something to that. It doesn't just seem like a

0:11:48Spitball idea it actually seems like something. I think it's interesting how much influence of the products

0:11:56Have on what the store design has to be but at the same time how little the stores can really rapidly

0:12:03Change to fit the evolving products

0:12:06so like the original stores were designed before the iPod was announced and I'm guessing that

0:12:12The majority of the retail team had no idea that it was coming and I would assume that the same was true with the iPhone

0:12:19Given the secrecy which it was developed in and when you have physical real estate

0:12:23All around the world and a product comes out tomorrow and it completely changes your entire business

0:12:29like it's so much more difficult to

0:12:32Rapidly redesign all of your stores than it is to just you know

0:12:36And I'm oversimplifying it obviously but just to ship a new version of the iPhone for instance when you have

0:12:41All of these spaces that are leased sometimes you can't like you can't just expand the store tomorrow because now

0:12:49Your audience wants the new iPhone and before it was just a handful of people in there for max

0:12:55I think it's part of the right person at the right time with the right team

0:13:02and again, this is like a statement of the obvious Steve Jobs was a good CEO for Apple, but I do think

0:13:08he had the right mix of a plan and a grand vision and

0:13:15the flexibility to continue playing it by ear

0:13:20day by day week by week quarter by quarter as the

0:13:25Industry change as facts change as tastes change as technology changed, right? So it's not like oh

0:13:33We've got this master five-year plan and we can't change blank because that's not on the plan. It's okay

0:13:41Let's adapt right, but I I think it's extremely clear in hindsight that

0:13:47Part of his master plan was number one. Let's fix the Mac and get the Mac without this

0:13:54We're gonna go under we got to fix the whole Mac platform

0:13:56We got to get a new operating system built for the future go from classic to Mac OS X built on the next

0:14:03Technologies and build it taking the best of what Apple already had along with it

0:14:07Let's fix the hardware which was a confusing mess simplify it with the famous four-way grid of

0:14:13Pro and consumer laptop and desktop here. Boom. There's four max

0:14:19pro laptop

0:14:21consumer laptop pro desktop consumer laptop the iMac go from there, but

0:14:25Once we write that ship with the Mac, we need new

0:14:29products new platforms and

0:14:33because otherwise the company has to grow and I think that was in mind with the

0:14:38the retail plan from the get-go because one of the reasons people were so

0:14:44Skeptical about Apple's retail plans was at the time laptops were not the majority selling computers because they were so expensive

0:14:52Desktops were but desktops are super heavy. They were like the iMac

0:14:57Was a CRT it was like I don't know

0:15:0227 pounds right and it's like not exactly I know people that's what people did they go to big-box stores too or

0:15:09Gateway stores or whatever people did buy computers and stores

0:15:12But also it was sort of like when you go to a big-box store like Best Buy or whatever

0:15:19You can buy something big and heavy

0:15:22You check out and then you go into the parking lot and back your car up to the entrance and put it in the trunk

0:15:28or whatever like

0:15:30Doing the Apple stores in

0:15:32Regular indoor malls was weird because it's like well wait if you buy an iMac, you know

0:15:38And they had ways of doing it some of the ones I think at one point

0:15:41We actually bought my wife and I Mac at a retail store and it you know

0:15:45You could walk out with it if you want

0:15:47But if you you know

0:15:48Where are you parked what you can do is do this back your car around and there was like a back entrance

0:15:53Like a loading dock whether you can move your car

0:15:55But it just didn't seem if all they ever planned to do this is where I'm going is all they ever planned to do was sell

0:16:01Max and the max were going to be the same mix that was current in the year 2000 2001

0:16:08Retail space and malls did not make sense it did the to me the whole idea was things like the iPod

0:16:17Things like the iPhone eventually, etc

0:16:22Yeah, it's funny that you mentioned that with with the size of max at the time because there's a there's a video out there from

0:16:28From grand opening day. It's from the Glendale Galleria opening and and there I don't know like it was produced by

0:16:36Some marketing team within Apple, but and it's a it's on YouTube. You can find it there

0:16:41They're talking to this family that like purchased all of these max

0:16:44An opening day and they literally have like an industrial dolly from from back of house

0:16:52Up front in the store when they have loaded on it like a big power mag g4 tower and CRT display

0:16:59And it's this huge stack. I don't know how you would ever walk it out of this store. It's funny. Yeah, all right

0:17:05I'm promising people. I'm putting it. I wrote it down on a piece of paper here

0:17:08I'm gonna put it in the show notes Glendale Galleria opening day video all right

0:17:12Let me take a break and we'll keep going but first I want to thank our first sponsor and it's my good friends at retool

0:17:19They've been sponsoring during fireball for a while

0:17:21I think this is their first spot on the talk show

0:17:23retool

0:17:25lets you build internal tools like

0:17:28Dashboards and admin panels custom crud apps if you don't know the lingo crud is I forget the acronym

0:17:35But basically you've got a database

0:17:37You want to make a little dashboard that shows the database in a friendly way retool can dramatically speed up

0:17:44How your business operates you can build them from scratch of course

0:17:49That's that's the way people think of some developers think that's a lot of work

0:17:53And it's a lot of maintenance and involves a lot of tedious work

0:17:56Retool helps developers build internal tools much faster

0:18:01It's a complete UI library with over 80 fully featured accessible components that you just drag and drop

0:18:08into an interface you arrange them the way you want and

0:18:12From there you connect your interface to any data source

0:18:16databases JSON feeds

0:18:19Customize anything with JavaScript you can just write code you click on buttons and what happens when you click this button you just

0:18:25Write the JavaScript that happens when you click the button

0:18:27Deploy your apps right within retool with app environments permissions SSO and other time-saving features

0:18:35Available right out of the box and the result is that you can build production grade business apps

0:18:40without googling for component libraries debugging dependencies or rewriting

0:18:46Boilerplate code it is easy and fun thousands of teams at companies

0:18:51You've heard of like Amazon door - Volvo and Brex

0:18:54Collaborate around custom-built retool apps to solve internal problems and create new workflows

0:19:01Here's where you go to learn more visit

0:19:03Retool dot-com that's all you need to know no special code

0:19:07Just go to retool calm and you can build tools up to ten times faster

0:19:12All right

0:19:14You said let's get the technical details out of here you built it in unity you say what does that mean explain that?

0:19:20So unity is a game engine and it's it's a cross-platform game engine, but this app is just for the Mac

0:19:29Theoretically, I guess I could bring it to iOS

0:19:32But I honestly I didn't even try because I didn't figure like there was any chance that this would pass app review

0:19:40I mean, oh my god. Yeah, I didn't even think of that. Okay

0:19:43Yeah, so I didn't even I didn't even like look at like I would have had to modify the controls obviously for touch and everything

0:19:50But I didn't even go down that road. So yeah, it's it's built in unity

0:19:54But the the actual modeling of the stars is done in Blender, which is just a totally free

0:20:003d modeling tool and it's extremely powerful and all the texturing was done in Blender and then I brought those

0:20:07Models into unity and I'm not I'm not a software developer by any means

0:20:12So I just use YouTube tutorials googled stuff until I figured out what I needed to do to

0:20:18To get a first-person controller working. I wanted to add some different interactions

0:20:23so there are there are different computers within this each store that you can walk up to and

0:20:29Like there's an iMac you can boot up. There's one computer that's running GarageBand and you can play a track on GarageBand

0:20:37So there's different things like that

0:20:38I wanted to to have in them in the stores, but I just kind of hacked away at it until I figured out what I

0:20:44needed to do in unity to get it all working and and then

0:20:48The result you can build apps directly in unity. Like you don't have to go through Xcode, but then they're not notarized, right?

0:20:56so the only way to open it is to go into

0:20:59System preferences and security and and allow it and it's kind of a mess. It's it's not really well

0:21:06It's obviously not what Apple wants and it's not ideal really for any

0:21:10user either

0:21:12so I did go down the road of getting a Apple developer account and and

0:21:17Then you can you can send unity projects through Xcode and and I had a little bit of help along the way getting

0:21:24getting Xcode to then build the

0:21:27unity project and then notarizing it so that I can

0:21:31Distribute it without those security warnings. And again, I didn't I didn't try to put it in that in the Mac App Store

0:21:36Cuz I didn't figure it would ever get approved. Well, you should try it. I mean at the very least so what I would say is

0:21:43Don't waste your time

0:21:45iOS of fine it because that would be a lot of work, but you should at least submit the Mac

0:21:51I mean because you've got the Mac version right? So why not? I don't know I get what you're saying

0:21:56No, it's so but this project is so off the wall like in terms of like I I it's it's unlike anything

0:22:04I've seen I get it. It's like if I make just

0:22:08Joe random app just to pull out any random app out of the App Store and you put an Apple logo in your app

0:22:16It's gonna get and they see it

0:22:18It's gonna get flagged and it'd be like you can't you can't put the Apple logo in your app

0:22:21You've got the Apple logo in your app because as you enter an Apple retail store one one of the things that hasn't changed is

0:22:29The only signage I believe right it's it's like the only signage they've ever had at any Apple retail store is

0:22:36Just an Apple logo outside, right?

0:22:40It's one of the cool things that people don't think about but it's like they've never said Apple

0:22:46It certainly never says Apple Store. It's just an apple. It's actually

0:22:51There's actually like at least one exception to that I can think of. Okay

0:22:55So I don't know if this still exists, but it was like this the last time I was there

0:23:00So if you in Chicago, if you go to Apple Lincoln Park, which is on the north side of Chicago

0:23:07There is about a block away

0:23:09from the store there is like a signpost where there's like

0:23:14acrylic just like acrylic pieces printed and and and inserted for every

0:23:20store in the in the upcoming block and

0:23:23There's one strip of acrylic in there. It says Apple Store. It's the it's set in Apple Garamond and

0:23:31I don't I actually I have no idea why that sign exists because that store opened I think in 2010 and I

0:23:39Don't think Apple was using

0:23:42Garamond and

0:23:44Anything in 2000 time? No. Yeah, so so that's the one exception to that

0:23:49I can think of that is kind of weird, but it's still I'm gonna say though that doesn't really count as signage on the store

0:23:55Right. It's wayfaring. It's it's wayfaring signage near the store

0:24:00That is that is curious

0:24:03Like it makes me think that it was somebody not involved with Apple who thought they were being helpful and nobody at Apple ever

0:24:10Noticed and it'd be funny if somebody listening to the show now is like what the hell are they talking about looks into it?

0:24:16Oh my god, get that out of here. But yeah 2010 was clearly well into the myriad era of Apple

0:24:23Branding typeface so that yeah, that's doubly

0:24:27Weird. Yeah

0:24:29I say you've got to try submitting it to the App Store and see at the Mac App Store and see what happens because the Apple

0:24:36Logo alone might be the thing and it's just somebody who doesn't even like who knows I have no idea

0:24:42What goes on with these reviewers who they are?

0:24:44What what sort of mindset they have but if it's just somebody who doesn't even look at it and think hey, this is amazing

0:24:50This is really cool. Maybe hadn't heard of it. But it's like this is super cool

0:24:53Maybe they're just like going through the checklist and they're like up

0:24:56There's an Apple logo flagged but I could see it also going all the way to every single bit of this is Apple's intellectual property

0:25:02You've got no chance, right?

0:25:04Right, but you've got the app right? All you really have to do the only effort it would take is these

0:25:10Submission to the Mac App Store. I don't know I say you try it. Yeah, I mean I could certainly try it

0:25:15One of the things I noticed looks right to me is the lighting

0:25:20It's one of those things where feeling right is more important than technically being right. I think you nailed it the lighting Oh seems

0:25:30right and

0:25:32seems super tricky because like

0:25:35Again, I like when I linked to it on daring fireball. I mentioned to people here's the basic idea

0:25:40Michael has recreated four of the original iconic Apple stores and

0:25:45It's like a game like experience walkthrough where you can go through like for example

0:25:50I said like maybe it's more like Minecraft like minecraft doesn't I?

0:25:53I'm not a super minecraft my son used to play but it doesn't seem to me like there's extensive lighting options in Minecraft

0:26:00like you just sort of go through and everything is is

0:26:05It lit with like a universal light source, right? Whereas in in your

0:26:10experience the lighting is

0:26:13Exquisite and seems realistic

0:26:16Yeah, I had I had pretty much total control over the lighting

0:26:20There's kind of two tricks that play and one is I probably didn't do it in the way that a real game developer would

0:26:27There's no actual live

0:26:29Dynamic lighting and shadows in the game. So everything is all baked in and all the textures have the shadows

0:26:37baked into them and the

0:26:39So the lighting in the scene is all coming from Plunder where I modeled it and and that way I had

0:26:45Really precise control over how I needed to light each each part of the store

0:26:49So like there there's different lighting above each table

0:26:52there's lighting in the like the graphic panels obviously a backlit and

0:26:58Then like on the newest star infinite loop along the displays on the walls the avenues

0:27:03There's lighting in the top

0:27:05like there's a an LED strip that runs along each one and

0:27:09It it it's pointed a certain angle into the display so that it lights up the products on the shelves and that's all stuff

0:27:17I had really close control over in

0:27:19In the blender where it is. It would have been not only a lot more

0:27:23CPU and GPU intensive to do it live

0:27:28But I just wouldn't have had

0:27:30That same control in unity and it made it a lot. It made it easier for me to to render the

0:27:36the models in the store like the

0:27:39the each individual iPod and and like especially in the older stores like the

0:27:44Curvature of like the power mag g4 with with a lot higher detail because I wasn't spending CPUs cycles on lighting

0:27:53The power Mac g4 is the one that was still like a plastic case

0:28:00but instead of being the

0:28:03Bondi blue of the G of the g31 that was like an iMac

0:28:08It was more of a I forget what they called it like a slate blue. Yeah, I think I think they called it graphite me

0:28:14Oh, that's right. Yeah graphite. Yeah, I'm not positive. Nope. Yep, as soon as you said it, it was definitely called graphite, which was

0:28:20Well, I was gonna say perfect, but maybe there was a lot more blue in it

0:28:24Then I would think the word graphite implies. But anyway, that's what they called it and you nailed it. It looks right

0:28:30Yeah, it matched the the design of the g4 cube which was the same time so yeah

0:28:38Let's pour one out for the g4 cube

0:28:40Which which has sort of come back in spirit in my opinion with the the Mac studio

0:28:46Which is sort of the it's the dream of the the cube which is the small footprint thing that you could put on your desk

0:28:53I mean the footprint is very similar. Obviously the the new Mac studios

0:28:57squatter then then right but

0:29:01Unlike the Mac mini it is meant to be a pro level

0:29:05Device and I know I'd say that knowing that Apple has spent actually the last few years

0:29:10reiterating how many

0:29:12Professionals actually use and love Mac minis, but to me the Mac studio is more in spirit. But yeah, that was definitely it

0:29:19Beautiful. I mean seriously, I mean the Mac cube is like even though

0:29:25everybody in technology

0:29:28Looks back and says one of Apple's rare failures, but there it is in the Museum of Modern Art. I just love that

0:29:35Here's this thing universally hailed as a failure. Yeah, and it's in the Museum of Modern Art

0:29:40What were you saying the g4 cube? I actually used as like the the base for the

0:29:47Time machine in the there's like an intro video loop that plays when you boot the app and I use the the g4 cube to

0:29:55Kind of represent the time machine that your engine into I tried to create like a backstory so that you

0:30:01That you weren't just thrown into these Apple stores out of nowhere

0:30:05like why am I here what's going on and and I guess that is kind of a

0:30:09Gameplay element, but I wanted there to be context to the time machine and like why does the entire UI look like?

0:30:17aqua from Mac OS 10, right so so like the the the story

0:30:22Behind it is like here's like a modified

0:30:26Power Mac g4 cube it's running time

0:30:30OS and and there's like a boot sequence and then you are entered into this like

0:30:38alternate reality when the the intro video plays from

0:30:42From Mac OS 10 and then then you're left on the main menu. So so it was kind of a

0:30:48when I started the project I

0:30:51was originally going to just have the Tysons corner model and then and it kind of just it got out of hand and I added

0:30:58Three more stores. So so that's why that's why I used the aqua interface because it matched the air of the store

0:31:05But then when when I started adding more stores, I'm like, well, I really need a reason for this interface

0:31:11So that's kind of how that came about. I

0:31:13say there's a long glorious history and future of

0:31:19great

0:31:21Labors of love that involved the phrase it got out of hand

0:31:25And then it got out of hand, right?

0:31:29Yeah, I am I to me the

0:31:34conceit the rapper of the of the experience is sort of like what if Doc Brown from

0:31:42Back to the future instead of building a time machine to transport

0:31:46humans and dogs through time physically in a DeLorean

0:31:50What if he instead of Jerry rigging a DeLorean? What if he Jerry rigged g4 Mac cube to take you back?

0:31:58right

0:32:002001 Apple stores, it's I just can't stop laughing

0:32:03At this and I just love and then it got out of hand because that is it just seems so obvious to me that that's what?

0:32:10happened I when I when I got the idea because you sent me that email and

0:32:14I got the pre I got the preview link and I was like blown away

0:32:18I'm like, I am definitely gonna link to this but then I thought wait

0:32:21This is not enough I cuz I have questions and I started asking them and then I thought you know

0:32:26what I should get this guy on the podcast because

0:32:29Take for you take forever an email and then it's not out there for the world. But like what did you do?

0:32:34This is one of the first questions I asked you by email, but I gotta ask again. What did you do to get?

0:32:40like the the dimensions of these stores

0:32:44like you so

0:32:47Yeah, this that was that was really tricky. So I

0:32:50as

0:32:52You can imagine like I searched for building permits. I

0:32:55All right, you say that I I can't imagine but that does not seem like the obvious answer

0:33:01The obvious answer is always to half-ass it

0:33:04Right, but all right you start you're searching for building permits

0:33:08right, I searched for like mall lease plans because sometimes like even if Apple's not in the same spot in the mall like they'll have

0:33:17The the footprint of the store like the square footage and then I could work from there. I looked well, there are some

0:33:24Some dimensions like that. I

0:33:26there are some dimensions that I just knew and I mean, I

0:33:31Don't know how much I want to say like I happen to know like the

0:33:36Okay of the graphic panel at Apple Fifth Avenue. So like that was a good

0:33:43Start like it's only one dimension

0:33:45but that was like a really good starting to mention for me to

0:33:48kind of figure out the rest of the store from and and I know like the exact dimensions of a standard Apple store table like the

0:33:55thickness of the wood and

0:33:57Things like that. So like I was able to use like a few

0:34:00Known dimensions and then like work backwards from there and and like there are a couple

0:34:06there are a couple of published numbers out there like if you go to I believe when the when the cube opened like there was a

0:34:13Page where like it listed like the exact dimensions of the cube

0:34:17I think like maybe one of the engineering firms that Apple worked with like published a summary of like the work they did and

0:34:23So like there were a couple things I was able to use and and that's the for context

0:34:29That's the Fifth Avenue New York iconic Apple store. Not the g4 cube the the right. Yes up on the Fifth Avenue

0:34:36Okay, so they publish something about the cube itself the actual glass structure

0:34:41Yeah, so and and really the glass structure was kind of well

0:34:46I didn't want to go down the rabbit hole of like

0:34:493d modeling downtown Manhattan, so I

0:34:53Don't I don't let people walk up and outside of the cube, right? But it's up there

0:34:59Yeah, because otherwise now you're now you're building an entire

0:35:03recreation of Bergdorf Bergdorf Goodman across the street, right and I need the GM building and all that

0:35:10so for

0:35:12Context personally would your background is that you also you?

0:35:17How you got into this and maybe how you got some figures for some of these things like the details of certain panels or the tables

0:35:24Is that you have been a reporter?

0:35:26For at least for 9 to 5 Mac on the Apple retail beat. Maybe you've written elsewhere. I

0:35:34Actually, I guess I should know but you know

0:35:37So you have sources in retail and and as I like to call them little birdies who maybe have given you information

0:35:43Over the years or something like that. It's not like you came to this without any

0:35:47Relationships whatsoever

0:35:50Yeah, I've just I've been studying Apple retail really since

0:35:542017 is like when I really got into it like day to day and

0:35:59So I've just kind of built this database of knowledge about about Apple stores

0:36:05I have a album in photos on my phone that has pictures from from all the store visits that I've

0:36:12that I've done and it's it's it's a lot of visits and if you

0:36:17There's there are I'm gonna just check right now. Let's see the Apple store album in photos has

0:36:2414,200 photos in it so and that's all photos taken in and

0:36:31Outside Apple stores. So like when it came time to to build these models

0:36:36I had this like huge collection of assets for things like what what is the material of the floors?

0:36:42What what type of wood is there and I was able to build these textures for 3d modeling based on this this huge

0:36:49library of material that I already had

0:36:51All right, let me take another break here and think our next sponsor is our good friends at

0:36:58Memberful which is where you can go to monetize your passion with memberships

0:37:03Memberful allows you the creator who has a passion and an audience to build a sustainable recurring

0:37:10Revenue out of your audience

0:37:12It's the easiest way to sell memberships to your audience and it is used by many of the biggest creators on the web you

0:37:20listening to my voice right now quite possibly already subscribed to memberful sites and you may not even know it because one of the great things

0:37:28about memberful is

0:37:29They don't put their brand in front of the creators who use them

0:37:34they're just a back end and it's your site your branding and

0:37:39Memberful just provides that infrastructure to build everything

0:37:43you own your

0:37:46membership list

0:37:47So if anything happens down the road and you'd like to move your membership system elsewhere build your own thing

0:37:54Go to something else. You can just take it with you

0:37:57That's how confident that's a that's just respect to the creators who use memberful

0:38:03But B

0:38:04It's a sign of confidence on memberful

0:38:06Part that they just don't think you're going to want to do that because you're going to be so happy with memberful

0:38:11It really is just a terrific service and they keep making it better. You have full control and ownership

0:38:16That's that would be important to me. That's important to the people

0:38:20I know personally who use memberful and

0:38:23That's why memberful does it that way and they also have a world-class support team that is ready to help you simplify your memberships

0:38:29And grow your revenue they can help you it with technical details, but they can also help you with strategy like hey

0:38:36How should I price this? What should I do? What works?

0:38:38Trust me, they know and the reason they love to help people who build on memberful

0:38:44Is that they succeed when the people building member of membership sites on memberful succeed? It's win-win-win

0:38:52Happy audience who is happy to pay happy creators who are building a recurring revenue stream and memberful

0:39:00Succeeds only when the creators succeed you can diversify your revenue stream with membership

0:39:05It is so easy. You can get started for free with no credit card required

0:39:10It's just terrific go to memberful. Mm be ER ful memberful.com slash

0:39:17talk-show

0:39:19That's memberful.com slash talk-show and you can get started. How long how long did you spend working on this project Michael?

0:39:26Do you want and if you would prefer not to answer that question, you can just say pass so

0:39:33So, okay

0:39:35So this project actually began with a smaller project I did while I was at 9 to 5 Mac and that was for the 20th

0:39:44anniversary of Apple retail stores and I built I built what was really the

0:39:50fundamental model of Tyson's Corner

0:39:52Way back then it was a it was a simplified version of it

0:39:56The the products in the store were modeled in a lot less detail the textures were a lot lower resolution and I made it a

0:40:04USDZ like an AR quick look file and

0:40:07And I published that when I published a big feature article about 20 years of Apple retail stores

0:40:15so it was like a little desktop model just just like you would take like a model of like a

0:40:21IKEA

0:40:24Chair and put it in your room

0:40:26Like you could just drop this down onto your desk and look down into it like like a little Lego house or something like that

0:40:32But but while I was while I was building that I kept thinking like it would be so cool

0:40:37If you could see this at full size and actually walk around in it

0:40:42but like the limitations of AR kit like a USDZ quick look file has like a lot of

0:40:49limitations on texture resolution and file size

0:40:53I just I just couldn't make it something that you could view that large and it still had an acceptable

0:40:59quality and also you get like the like

0:41:02iPhones with LIDAR I believe they detect where the walls are in your room

0:41:08So the the actual walls of your room would would clip into the model because it's obviously

0:41:14Bigger than any room you'd be in so so I kind of had this idea in the back of my head and that so that was

0:41:20May

0:41:212021 and then in in January that's kind of when I started to really

0:41:27Put in the work on this project and I took the the model I had made of Tyson's Corner and I kind of tore it down

0:41:36Got rid of the the parts that were low poly low resolution textures rebuilt it

0:41:42I added a roof because obviously the

0:41:44the

0:41:46the USDZ file like you had to be able to look down into it so there was no ceiling on the store and and

0:41:52then the

0:41:54So the modeling I went store by store

0:41:56First modeling and then bringing into unity making sure that it worked and then I started on the next door and that so that took from

0:42:03January to July it was it was really like all of my free time and

0:42:07Yeah, so so I guess seven months maybe maybe a little bit more

0:42:13The thing I love about it and and I don't know. I don't know why it's it's happening now. It's maybe it's me

0:42:21being solidly in middle-age, maybe it's coming out of this pandemic, but

0:42:27maybe it's just the state of the world and the internet but

0:42:33More and more recently, I've been just looking back at

0:42:37the earlier years of the internet and just thinking like man people used to just build cool things or build fun things and

0:42:46share them with the world and

0:42:48People don't do that anymore people. It's

0:42:51Not that no one does it but it's like it just doesn't seem like that's where people spend their time people just get on Twitter and

0:43:00Argue and post links to fun things and that's it as opposed to registering their own domain name and

0:43:06Just putting something

0:43:09Whoa, I where the hell did that idea come from putting it up on the web sharing it or making something else

0:43:16If it doesn't make sense as a website make something that people can download and it's not a business idea

0:43:22It's not it's just here's a cool thing and I want to share it with the world

0:43:26your project is

0:43:29Exemplifies it. This is what I want to see more people do

0:43:32I want to see more people spend seven months of their spare time building

0:43:35something awesome for no practical reason other than that you just I

0:43:40I'm just imagining in your brain. You're like I would like to build this and then I you're you're thinking

0:43:46I just I need to build this right it had to be a moment where you're just like I have to do this

0:43:51Yeah, well truthfully, you know

0:43:53I I really kind of built it for myself

0:43:56Because like I wanted to see what these stores were like I've been so fascinated by by Apple retail stores

0:44:03But obviously like the Tysons Corner store is still there and it's right for now

0:44:07It's still in the same exact spot in the mall where it always was

0:44:10but it doesn't look anything like it did in 2001 and it's it's something like I can just never get back to without like just

0:44:18Rebuilding it myself. So it kind of it started just just from that and

0:44:24then I realized along the way like how

0:44:27meaningful it actually might be to people who have a lot of memories of the stores or

0:44:32the products that everyone has their

0:44:35Favorite iPod and and just kind of build to put yourself back in that moment in that place in time

0:44:40So many people have said that it that it meant a lot to them. I

0:44:44think that's how all

0:44:47Creative good creative endeavors have a story like that

0:44:50I just I'm lucky as I've gotten older and I have an audience and I know

0:44:55Authors who write books. I know

0:44:58I'm an acquaintance at least of John August who's who's a pretty pretty to say the least successful screenwriter and

0:45:06it's like

0:45:09People who write the books that you love the most are

0:45:12Writing the books that they themselves would love most to read Stephen King

0:45:17who's one of my favorite authors has always said that right like he did if

0:45:21There if you could like erase from his memory one of the books he's written and then give him a copy of it

0:45:28He'd be like this book is amazing. This is fantastic, right? It's it's that's what creative people do

0:45:34It's like they build the thing that they want themselves even though

0:45:37You don't get the enjoyment out of it as a surprise that anybody else does right?

0:45:44So now you've got these models and you can ex you Michael Stieber can experience these stores

0:45:48But because you built them

0:45:50You don't get the experience that I got

0:45:53when you just plop this link in an email to me over the weekend and it came as a total surprise and just

0:46:00Lit up the parts of my brain that shoot good feelings and chemicals through my body like this is so much fun

0:46:07But it's that self-satisfaction

0:46:09right, like you just had to see this real and and then the other thing too is there's that moment where like you you

0:46:16But you you underplayed your skills you say you're not a developer and maybe you don't write code

0:46:21But obviously you're talented with Blender and you self-taught yourself with unity and such there had it's that moment

0:46:28When you realize when you got good enough like well, let me watch some YouTube videos see how to do this

0:46:33Where do you're like? Oh, okay. I have I could I could do this right like I I could do this

0:46:39Now I have to do it

0:46:41Yeah, it's it's kind of a thing that just like one thing builds on the next and it started from

0:46:48from just wanting to really research the stores to

0:46:53if you go on like I go on flicker a lot to find to find photos of old stores because people

0:46:59used to always big albums from star openings and things like that and the photos are always like a 640 by 480 like

0:47:07really like it's it's so difficult to figure out what the title of a

0:47:13Random Mac game is when the entire photo is 640 by 480 and this is one

0:47:20box on the shelf and and and it's the only happens to be like the only photo of this shelf that was

0:47:27apparently ever taken so like

0:47:29Just the the quality of it trying to experience that

0:47:33through the photos that people took at the time is just

0:47:37I

0:47:39Knew that I had to make something better than that

0:47:41It's not like flicker flicker is still an active photo sharing service. It is it's I'm glad it's still around

0:47:49I occasionally because I still have an account and over the years I've put some I

0:47:54Don't really I don't know I was gonna say don't really have I don't have at all any kind of photo gallery

0:48:00Widget at daring fireball. So if I have like oh, here's the thing sometimes

0:48:06I don't know a couple years ago one of the

0:48:08portrait mode came out for the iPhone and I

0:48:12Wanted to publish way more photos than I usually do in a review of an iPhone at during fireball

0:48:17So I put them into an album on flicker

0:48:19There's a bunch of articles over the years where I've done that so glad that they're still around a happy paying customer

0:48:25It's obviously not what it once was

0:48:27but in terms of like the heyday of flicker it

0:48:31Completely coincides with the era of your research. So that's it's so great that flicker still around for that, right?

0:48:39It's like yeah

0:48:40and and I kind of I felt this this urgency when I was doing my research because a lot of the accounts what I would just

0:48:47Say just about every account that I came across on flicker is inactive now

0:48:51And and I have like a list of links to different albums and like every once in a while

0:48:57I'll click on one and that that album is now gone

0:49:01So like and I have no idea how many photos like I missed that would have made this process so much easier

0:49:08yeah, and it's what's what's kind of funny is that

0:49:11flicker serves this this really important purpose in like cataloging a

0:49:17Specific time that I think it's kind of sad that were that we're losing slowly when I was researching

0:49:23infinite loop that star opened in 2015, so that was like already in the

0:49:29Instagram era people weren't really using flicker. It was actually more difficult to find

0:49:34Photos of that store opening even though it was really only a few years ago

0:49:39then it was to find like photos of like the Stanford ministar in 2004 just because

0:49:45Like it's impossible to go back and find anything on Instagram. You can't search by date the people

0:49:52Seem to like wipe their accounts a lot more. It's and the quality of the photos

0:49:57You've never been able to upload like the the actual JPEG file from your phone. It's always a compressed version. So

0:50:05yeah, it's I think it's kind of sad that that we're really gonna lose a lot of

0:50:11History when as flicker just kind of falls apart

0:50:15Yeah, it's funny because and this is total serendipity because I just posted a link and it's been a week of

0:50:23sort of

0:50:25bemoaning

0:50:26Instagram

0:50:27Jumping the shark which has been a long slow boiling frog ever since Facebook acquired it when it was indie

0:50:35but it seems like

0:50:372022 is the year where they just sort of yeah

0:50:41We're just gonna destroy the Instagram that was and build something turn it into a tick-tock clone or whatever

0:50:48but even the

0:50:50Instagram of

0:50:52Everybody's fondest memories where it was just a simple timeline of sharing from people. It was never meant for

0:50:59like a historical

0:51:02Archive right but you could do back in the day is if you knew who took the photo like if if it was

0:51:09Jason Snell you knew that Jason Snell posted a bunch of photos of a

0:51:16store opening on his on his Instagram then you could go to Jason sells Instagram account and

0:51:22Click on his profile and then there'd be a list of all the things that he's posted and you could just scroll to the bottom

0:51:28And and get there but like the way Instagram's evolved. Yeah, it's like it's it's they they have no interest in it

0:51:36So even though Instagram is still around, you know to say the least it was never meant for that

0:51:41That's it's really a shame

0:51:42You mentioned 640 by 4a and in sort of bemoaning it but the back in the back when people were posting it that seemed big enough

0:51:49For anybody and it just it's it reminds me. I don't know if you've ever heard this

0:51:53There was you're probably too young but like the original IBM PCs in the early 80s in the DOS era had a limit of exactly

0:52:01640 kilobytes of RAM

0:52:03Okay, it was like a technical limit. It was really bizarre. I didn't even I never really encountered it

0:52:09I never owned a PC, but there's a famous quote from Bill Gates that

0:52:13Somebody it was at a like a trade show or something and they were like, hey, what about this technical limit?

0:52:19It's only 640 kilobytes of RAM and it was like I'm like it wasn't just a limit in the hardware

0:52:24It was like a limit in the operating system

0:52:25So next year there was no way to make a computer with more RAM and supposedly Bill Gates said

0:52:30640 kilobytes of RAM ought to be enough for anybody and it's a super famous quote, but apparently and again, I'm promised everybody

0:52:36I'm doing it right now gonna put it in the show notes. He claims he never said it. It's apocryphal

0:52:41It's like all the great quotes

0:52:43It's one of the sad things in the world all the best quotes, you know of apparently the person you think said it didn't say him

0:52:49but but

0:52:51640 by 480 pixels that ought to be a big enough photo for anybody

0:52:55Turns out nope when you're trying to build a retina level full-screen high quality recreation of these stores

0:53:02640 by 480 not not big enough

0:53:06Yeah, and that great what else what else did you do any other research notes that that are worth worth a story?

0:53:13so there are a ton of small details that that I think really

0:53:19really sell the the realism of the models and and they were things that I really was only able to

0:53:25To track down because I've been paying so close attention to to how the retail store design is evolved

0:53:32so for example like at

0:53:35infinite loop there there are the

0:53:37Drawers of iPhone cases that you can open the the wooden drawers and in inside each each iPhone case and its packaging is

0:53:45separated by a little wooden divider and that's that's how they're all organized in the drawer, but

0:53:52Infinite loop is one of the only stores in the world that actually has a drawer with wooden dividers in it

0:54:01If you go to any other Apple store with it with the new restore design that has a drawer

0:54:08Like that and you pull up in the drawer

0:54:10What you'll find is like little brass dividers between each case and they look like like DDR2

0:54:17Like RAM sticks they have like the little notches in the side and everything

0:54:23But they're just like plain brass dividers and that's what they've been using

0:54:28Almost since the beginning but like the very first few stores with that design used just wooden dividers between the cases

0:54:35so like there were like really tiny little obsessive details like that that I like

0:54:4199% of people probably won't notice but like I spent my way too much time

0:54:47Researching stuff like that not too much time

0:54:51It's just enough time is what I say as the person who can identify the difference between

0:54:57Ariel and Helvetica in the in a snap of a finger. No, that's the sort of thing. That's why this

0:55:03Experience is so awesome. Here's another one. The the actual name of the app is

0:55:09I keep forgetting it actually shop different shop different and I keep going

0:55:15I'm a launch bar user myself, but I know a lot of people use spotlight

0:55:19Some people use Alfred but you hit command space and type the name

0:55:22I keep typing time machine and time time machine of course is a hit

0:55:27But it's right. It's not your project. It's time machine the actual backup software

0:55:34That's been built into the Mac since probably around the time of these stores that you're talking about

0:55:38Is that why you didn't call it time machine?

0:55:40so I I was I was really conflicted on that and I thought

0:55:45Well, yeah time machine. I didn't want it to be the same as time machine the the Apple

0:55:52And I also thought that the Apple store time machine like that was way too long for an app name

0:55:58It's it's going to be it's just not gonna look good

0:56:01so I went with shop different because I think it kind of it fits the

0:56:06Project like is you are going shopping?

0:56:10But it's it's very different and and the shop different is also a slogan that Apple used

0:56:16when the very first stores open if you go to like if you go on archive org and

0:56:21You find Apple's homepage for May 19th, 2001. It has like a rendering of the

0:56:28Tyson's Corner storefront and it says shop different and all the

0:56:32Employee shirts and I think the shirts that they gave away at the openings originally

0:56:38They have an Apple logo on the back with

0:56:41Like a barcode like on top of it and then right below it says shop different

0:56:48So like they use that slogan 2001 and I thought it was kind of fitting for this

0:56:52That's it's that's great. I love it. But I do remember I shouldn't say that I forget the name what I remember to shop

0:56:59It's like I've interned because I kept on preparation for this podcast

0:57:02I kept opening it and it's like it's as a launch bar user

0:57:07It's like all I need is a couple of letters of the at the beginning. So it's like command space SHOP shop

0:57:12Return but I do think I think the time machine thing is funny because I kept typing time machine and it was a hit and say

0:57:19No, this isn't the time machine. No, I

0:57:21Did though you mentioned building a our kit model type thing and I saw on Twitter and it's

0:57:30Obvious it's like oh man. This is so much fun to play on a big Mac screen

0:57:34But it's like lots and lots of people on Twitter are trying it and then they're like, oh, this would be cool. Is it a AR?

0:57:42Experience if say a certain company based in Cupertino came out with like a thing

0:57:48you strapped on your head and had a

0:57:50AR goggles or VR goggles in front of you

0:57:53it's that I presume that's something that at least crossed your mind as a

0:57:58Future direction to take the project you've already built

0:58:02Yeah, I've thought about a dozen different ways to make this project take

0:58:10Another seven months and you know, I would like to build a version of it that

0:58:14that was for like very powerful hardware and and that the so that I could make like

0:58:21really photo realistic texture resolution

0:58:24Just just like incredibly detailed like you can move every product in the store things like that

0:58:30And I think it would be perfect for an AR

0:58:33VR

0:58:34Type experience. I just hope that if there is a future product like that that this is something

0:58:40I can bring over because I think it would be really cool, you know in a more immersive setting. I do too

0:58:46It just seems obvious. I mean, it's super super good as is and and given the

0:58:52Options you had for what to build it for I think building it for the Mac

0:58:59Was exactly the right thing to do and even taking the App Store would they approve it aside and the whole?

0:59:06Again, I laugh I was chuckling there, but I'm not the one who might have wasted seven months of effort, right?

0:59:12like but it exemplifies not to turn this into a bitch fest about App Store, but

0:59:18it it exemplifies though your project exemplifies the sort of project or problems with the

0:59:26The order of App Store approval which is spend all the time to build the thing

0:59:35Then give it to Apple and then you find out if they're going to allow it unless your project is something that you know is

0:59:42kosher for the App Store, right

0:59:45but if you're if you have the idea for a project and you're yours is to me a perfect example of

0:59:52Hmm. I could definitely see Apple saying no and and maybe no on something as simple as you cannot have the Apple logo

1:00:01so you could and maybe

1:00:03build the version that if you just took out the Apple logos and

1:00:07And turned it into a circle or something instead then you could submit it or maybe they would

1:00:13Put the kibosh on the whole thing because it's a reproduction of their intellectual property these stores

1:00:19but the only way you'd find out is if you built the whole thing and

1:00:23Then submit it right and then you've got this thing built for the iPhone

1:00:28so I think you did the right thing but a

1:00:32Future direction of hopefully maybe moving it towards the goggles would be awesome and maybe now that it's out and

1:00:39You've got this thing and you're you've gotten some attention for it. Maybe you could figure out a channel to

1:00:44Get like yeah

1:00:47You should definitely move this to a our kit for the Apple glass or whatever

1:00:52They think we think they might call the the the platform before you actually spend the gobs and gobs of hours doing it

1:00:59Or something like that. All right, let me take one more break here and thank our next sponsor

1:01:04and then what I want to do when we come back is talk to you about Apple retail itself and get your thoughts on on

1:01:09That because it nobody builds a project like this

1:01:12And spends spends years reporting on it without having some serious insight into it

1:01:19but I want to tell everybody about our good friends at

1:01:22Hello fresh. Hello. Fresh is a service where you get farm fresh

1:01:27three-portioned ingredients and seasonal recipes delivered right to your doorstep

1:01:31they just put everything in a box and they pack the box really really well and

1:01:36They use dry ice so that anything was supposed to stay cold or refrigerated stays cold and refrigerated

1:01:42Just ding-dong

1:01:45Open your door. There it is. Take it upstairs put it in your kitchen put the stuff in your fridge

1:01:49take out the recipe card and

1:01:52You've got an easy to prepare meal with just the right amount of ingredients

1:01:57Right there. You can skip trips to the grocery store and count on. Hello fresh to make home cooking easy fun and

1:02:03Affordable really that's why hello fresh is America's number one

1:02:08Meal kit you get to choose from over 55 weekly options including pre-portioned

1:02:15High-quality ingredients picked at peak ripeness. Hello fresh

1:02:20They deliver it fresh right to your door in less than a week and you can savor those summer flavors right at your home

1:02:27They have these options for whatever you need. Maybe you're vegetarian. They've got vegetarian options

1:02:32Maybe you've got kids and they sort of are picky and they don't have the sort of adventurous tastes

1:02:38They've got options meant for families like yours anything that you can think of that's sort of like yeah

1:02:43I can't just take anybody's recipes. They've got the options. That's why they have them there every week

1:02:48You pick the meals that sound good to you and it for summertime

1:02:53You can bust out the grill on a nice warm evening and they have meal kits that are ready for meant for

1:02:59grilling and you can make dinner from hello fresh's cookout collection with recipes like

1:03:04Melty Monterey Jack burgers, that sounds good right now

1:03:08I'm actually getting hungry skip the grocery store spend more time

1:03:11Soaking up the summer fun and hello fresh's market is a one-stop shop for all your mealtime needs

1:03:17They've also got stuff like quick breakfasts lunch snacks desserts more not just dinners

1:03:23Anything you could think of you know stuff like that. You're going away on vacation

1:03:27You just go to the website and say hey

1:03:28We don't need we don't need the meals this week that week whenever you're going away. Everything is super easy just to click the plans are

1:03:35Totally flexible for how many people what types of food what your schedule is anything you could think of really great

1:03:43We use them that the food is great. The recipes are great. It's really a great service and hello fresh is

1:03:5092% cheaper than dining at a restaurant and it really is cheaper than grocery shopping at a store

1:03:56That's money right back in your pocket. It's good food. Good recipes super convenient go to

1:04:02Hello fresh.com

1:04:05talk-show

1:04:0716 that's talk show one six

1:04:10Hello fresh.com

1:04:12slash talk show 16 and use that code talk show 16 for up to 16 free meals and

1:04:20three free gifts

1:04:22Once again, hello fresh.com slash talk show 16. Remember that code talk show 16

1:04:29Get to up to 16 free meals. It's really great. My thanks to hello fresh for their continuing sponsorship of the show. All right

1:04:37It's funny to me to hear that that your original idea was just to do the Tyson store

1:04:42Which would have been fine and we still would have been fun

1:04:44maybe we'd still be here talking but I think no surprise the store in your

1:04:50Experience I'm gonna keep going back to that

1:04:52I spent the most time in was the cube as you called it the Fifth Avenue store in New York

1:04:57I don't know if that's the most famous one. It's hard to say maybe it is

1:05:01Yeah, I would say so but it clearly it was more than a small leveling up, right?

1:05:08There was like the leveling down of the the mini stores

1:05:12Which you have which is which is the name of the one that's the mini store in your in your in your app

1:05:18Oh a Stanford Stan

1:05:20I and their idea behind that was that many malls have these sort of

1:05:25Retail spots that are smaller footprint than the original concept of the Apple store and that was an interesting direction for Apple's expansion

1:05:33The thing that I don't think anybody would have anticipated because so many people when they started were thinking like this is doomed

1:05:39None of these computer companies that that make you try to expand into consumer retail ever have any success

1:05:46So not only did they exceed with the regular stores now

1:05:49they have a series of

1:05:51flagship stores literally all around the world and the one in New York is

1:05:56Well, maybe they have to a couple flagships in New York, but the Fifth Avenue one is clearly iconic

1:06:01I mean, there's the big cube above ground and

1:06:04It's just such a weird space retail what

1:06:11Wise right for I mean, I know I'll bet because it's so iconic and everybody so many people go to New York

1:06:16A lot of people who are listening have been there, but if you haven't

1:06:20It's really weird. It is subterranean. It is underneath a plaza on Fifth Avenue

1:06:27Do you even know what was there before it was an Apple store?

1:06:30so as far as I know there was a sunken Plaza in front of the GM building there and I

1:06:39Don't remember if it was still sunken like when Apple took it over or not. I've

1:06:44Really not seen too many photos of that, but I know that it was pretty underused

1:06:49it wasn't a very successful area as far as I'm concerned and I

1:06:54Mean, I think it makes sense right you have all these

1:06:57Skyscrapers along Fifth Avenue and then there's just a hole in the ground when people aren't

1:07:02Right, not really like oh what's down there? So yeah, so the I

1:07:08Mean it was it's kind of a bold idea to put the entire store on the ground, right?

1:07:12Well, and the other thing too is number one. That's just tough

1:07:16Period right to make an a pleasant

1:07:19shopping experience that's underground and to have an underground store that people will get to that they would notice

1:07:27From the ground. It's not like the big Fifth Avenue Apple store is like when you go to a

1:07:35Train station and you're underground and there's a Dunkin Donuts and a newsstand where you can buy

1:07:41Magazines and stuff which makes sense for them to be underground because they're there to get the consumers as they walk to catch train

1:07:48It's just a tough idea

1:07:51Period and they solved that how do people know where it is from the ground with the cube which serves?

1:07:59no

1:08:00functional purpose

1:08:01it's it's just there to

1:08:05Be an icon a literal architectural icon

1:08:08I guess functionally it does let sunlight in because it's glass and you can see through it

1:08:13But it's like we the basic idea is we could build this big store

1:08:16underground and we'll put this

1:08:19big

1:08:21Architectural marvel glass cube above ground and people will come down a very, you know

1:08:27I remember when it opened it was it people

1:08:30Obviously talked about the cube, but the other thing that people talked about an apple including Apple was the staircase which yes

1:08:37We is also made of glass. Is it still the original staircase? I don't even I'm not quite sure

1:08:43I haven't been back since they

1:08:45Remodeled refurbished did they did they rebuild the whole thing? I'm not even sure I'm

1:08:50I've only been to the original

1:08:54Yeah, the the Fifth Avenue store is like I think the term is a ship of Theseus. That's right

1:09:01So yes, right

1:09:02So like nothing from the original store from from 2006 which really isn't that long ago. There is nothing left

1:09:08From it at all

1:09:10It's it's an entirely new space and and really the the cube was completely dismantled and replaced in

1:09:172011 I believe they reduced the number of glass panels

1:09:22so that that first cube lasted just a few years and then

1:09:25They closed the store in January 2017 and it stayed closed until

1:09:31September 2019 and they were in the

1:09:34Former, I can't remember the name of the the the toy store. That was it FAO Schwartz. Yes

1:09:42Yes

1:09:42They were in there as a temporary space

1:09:44for for like over two and a half years while that that while the new store was built and they literally started over so they

1:09:51They tore out

1:09:53The the entire of this glass staircase they they lowered the floor of the entire store

1:09:59but I don't know how many feet but it's it's much taller inside now than it used to be and

1:10:04Just it's much larger

1:10:07But there's literally nothing left when they rebuilt the cube the new staircase when you walk down

1:10:12There are like mirrored stainless steel panels

1:10:15On all four sides. So you are in this like mirrored

1:10:19Environment it's it's actually kind of it's not disorienting

1:10:22but it's

1:10:23It's it's almost like being in some type of like funhouse where you just you look all around and you see your own reflection on

1:10:30every wall and the stairs are now

1:10:32polished stainless steel - so it's just it's this kind of like dazzling experience as you walk down the

1:10:39Stairs, but but yeah, so the the original

1:10:42cube aside from the

1:10:46Aside from the actual glass cube and staircase itself

1:10:50the store was really just a standard Apple store with a few more tables than

1:10:55Then in what would be in a large mall and and I think like people were able to

1:11:00to look past that because the the cube was so spectacular and and when they rebuilt it the

1:11:07actual store

1:11:09Matches the cube in in magnitude now. Hmm. Yeah, that's interesting that they lowered the floor

1:11:15I did not know that because like I said, I haven't been back but that was one of the things was that

1:11:20It's like oh my god. This cube is

1:11:23Cool and like anything really worth seeing in person pictures and videos don't do it justice you go there and you see it

1:11:31and it's like this is even cooler than I thought from pictures and

1:11:35Then you go down the stairs and then you're in the store and it's sort of like this is a little a it was a little

1:11:42Sort of like that's just sort of a bigger square footage regular Apple store, but the the low ceilings were

1:11:50Not great, it's actually sort of a downgrade from a regular Apple store low ceilings are not generally regarded as

1:11:58luxurious but you knew but on the other hand you knew you were underground and so it just sort of was like it was like

1:12:06Like if you went to a regular mall and the ceilings were that low you'd be like what the hell is going on here

1:12:11This is weird. Whereas you know, it was totally acceptable knowing you were underground

1:12:14the thing that's so

1:12:17In addition to the problem of solving. Well, we've got underground space. How do we make a nice store is?

1:12:23Tough no matter where you are in the world

1:12:26but the other extra tough thing for Apple is the competitive nature of the company and the pride of

1:12:32Being on what you know is arguably the highest end retail stretch in America

1:12:39I mean, I guess you could talk about Rodeo Drive or there's

1:12:43Other super high-end shopping areas, but Fifth Avenue, New York

1:12:48That's the major leagues of retail and Apple obviously do do they compete directly?

1:12:54against Tiffany or

1:12:57Any of these other brands Gucci or whoever else is nearby on Fifth Avenue? No, not even at all

1:13:04But you know, they want to hold their own right and it turns out they did more than hold their own

1:13:10They're probably the most famous store on that stretch

1:13:13Yeah, and and what I what I think is really fascinating about the cube is that it certainly is the most

1:13:20iconic Apple store and I think a lot of that has to do with the fact that

1:13:25Steve Jobs was was directly involved and there's this kind of story about about how it came to be and and it

1:13:33coincided with

1:13:35the that early era of the iPhone when there were huge lines outside the store and it got a lot of

1:13:41Attention with the the press cameras and things like that, but in terms of like architecture and magnitude of stores

1:13:47There are so many

1:13:49New stores that have been built over the last five years or so that I would say like really surpass

1:13:56the cube not only in in architecture, but in their

1:14:00Their physical placement like for instance Apple Marina Bay Sands, which is in Singapore

1:14:06it's literally a floating glass orb on the water in Singapore and

1:14:11It's it's just so much more. I mean, I've never been there but

1:14:16You can just tell from the photos like this is this is at another level and and it's certainly like it's it's not like

1:14:24It's a hidden project or anything like that, but I don't think anything has been able to

1:14:29Surpass that that like legendary status of the cube

1:14:33Yeah, because and a lot of the other flagships are built into historic buildings in yes

1:14:40London and other cities

1:14:42I mean you I should ask you which some of the ones are and it's a great thing Apple does is take

1:14:47historic building that had fallen into

1:14:51disuse or

1:14:54and restore it to

1:14:56architectural glory and make it a thing that people want to go to write like

1:15:01It's one of the things about Apple stores there there it's it's high-end luxury

1:15:09architecture and it is

1:15:12Totally mass-market. It is for everybody. Everybody is welcome and feels welcome to go into the store and you get to go into a

1:15:21world-class

1:15:23Architectural retail experience but the ones that are built into historic things

1:15:27Apple is respectful of the history right? Whereas the cube is all Apple

1:15:33Right and and I think the the historic preservation projects that Apple does it's it's really kind of it's really kind of unfortunate how

1:15:42they get a bad rap and I know that you and I can appreciate the level of

1:15:49Detail that they go into into restoring these historic buildings, but I know like outside of the Apple community

1:15:55like especially the store at Carnegie Library in DC and and even Tower of Theatre in

1:16:01LA which opened in the last year

1:16:03Like there's a lot of criticism about those projects that people think that Apple just kind of went in took over

1:16:10Some great historic space and now it's a cell phone shop and they ruined a historic building

1:16:17and so it's it's kind of a tough situation and and I think I think people have because stores like the

1:16:24Fifth Avenue cube they're so iconic people have in their mind. That's

1:16:29What every Apple store is like so they think like Apple gutted this historic theater and now it's a glass box

1:16:37and and I think that's really been like a

1:16:39Perception problem that they've really struggled to overcome especially as they move into more historic buildings

1:16:46I feel like they've handled it very well

1:16:48Which is that I don't think there's any path to them doing this

1:16:54That doesn't have that criticism and I think you just sort of do the right thing

1:16:59Have the right attitude and you just have to ignore

1:17:04the

1:17:06Haters and it's so cynical because they act as though the critics of these things act as though

1:17:13I don't have any specific example in mind, but did you know that?

1:17:16Imagine that there's some city and and they act as though it was a thriving

1:17:21Public library where all the children of the city

1:17:27loved to come and filled the filled this place for the last hundred years and was still thriving and

1:17:33Like the mean old mr. Potter from it's a wonderful life

1:17:40Mean old trillionaire Apple incorporated came in stole the lease

1:17:45and closed the library and turned it into it like you said a cell phone store and

1:17:51Now the kids who up until Apple did this love the place

1:17:56Now they don't it. They don't have any books from the library and that that doesn't happen. That's not what Apple is doing

1:18:03I don't I don't think there's a single one of these that was a thriving

1:18:07It their historic buildings and and his and notable

1:18:11architecture

1:18:14But Apple's not taking over places that were thriving in their original use and buying them out because they have more money

1:18:22It's they're taking buildings that that no longer were

1:18:27You know that their glory years were in the past and I don't so I don't know what the critics think

1:18:33Should happen to these buildings. It's it's it's like a wishful thinking of a utopia where collectively

1:18:41somebody or we taxpayer money would just go to restore it and

1:18:46For what purpose that people would actually enjoy? I don't know. It's it's just sort of utopian

1:18:53Footstomping of I don't know some but something something but it should just be for the public good and shouldn't be for selling consumer products

1:19:02Yeah, it's it's really kind of remarkable when when the Tower Theater store was just a rumor. I happened to be in

1:19:10LA for the Adobe max conference and I thought well

1:19:13I'm gonna stop over and see what that what that building looks like, but I remember walking walking around

1:19:19On the sidewalk in front of the store and it's it was falling apart. I mean it was completely closed

1:19:26There was like pieces like dangling off the building like it was it was falling apart

1:19:32it was in really tough shape and

1:19:34I

1:19:35mean

1:19:37Then when I came back for the opening, I remember rounding the corner and it was like nine o'clock at night

1:19:44maybe and the the marquee was lit up a big letters tower and

1:19:50And it was just was lighting up the whole block and and there was like this immediate

1:19:55like transformation of the entire

1:19:58Downtown just by this one star and it was it was incredible what?

1:20:02what they were able to do with a space like that and and like realistically like

1:20:07even in its heyday that building was a

1:20:10Theater which was a for-profit business. It wasn't like some

1:20:16community like

1:20:19Some like sacred park or something that was taken away

1:20:22So I think once you if you look past the surface level and like it makes an easy like Twitter post like to just

1:20:29Say like oh look here was this beautiful building and somebody posts the photo of how it looked in

1:20:351920 and then here's what Apple did to it. But but once you once you really look beyond the surface that

1:20:42There's there's a lot more to it. I think it's sort of like

1:20:46to me, it's sort of like Toy Story and

1:20:50it

1:20:52Yes, toys really aren't

1:20:55anthropomorphized

1:20:57beings with personalities and in like but in you know

1:21:02The idea what's the best purpose of a toy to be loved and played with by actual kids?

1:21:08That's that's what resonates about Toy Story, right? It's not realistic. Of course

1:21:14I mean, but that that's the truth, right and so like a

1:21:18toy that

1:21:21Actually gets loved and played with by a kid to me is more

1:21:27interesting than a toy that an adult

1:21:30buys and

1:21:33And not only never plays with but actually

1:21:35Doesn't even want the box dented or opened and puts on a shelf and you know

1:21:40I've got stuff that I haven't actually I don't really I don't tend to buy things

1:21:46I keep in boxes, but I get it if you do I'm not putting anybody down

1:21:49I'm sure that lots and lots of people out there who listen to the show have some favorite things that they

1:21:53Keep in mint condition in a box or whatever

1:21:56But to me the one that gets played with that's more interesting

1:22:00You're right

1:22:00And that's one of the things I love about some of the photos in the designed by Apple in California coffee table book

1:22:06my favorite picture in that whole book is

1:22:08the

1:22:10Original iPhone that's that belonged to Evans hanky who's now in charge of design at Apple

1:22:16Her iPhone her original aluminum backed iPhone and she used it of seemingly maybe didn't upgrade

1:22:22Herself to an iPhone 3g the next year. It's beaten to hell

1:22:27And it is the most

1:22:30Gloated to me is the most beautiful picture in that whole book of beautiful objects because to me an iPhone that is all

1:22:37scratched and

1:22:40Dent and used is more interesting, right?

1:22:44And what if you if a building were an anthropomorphized?

1:22:49To me what a building wants is to serve a purpose

1:22:53so taking a historic building that was sad if it had a personality and now has been restored and and is

1:23:02Filled every day with people from the building's home city from all walks of life

1:23:10students to retired people people of every nationality

1:23:14And race they all feel welcome and come in from opening until close buying

1:23:21Some of their favorite things that they own what what better purpose is there for a building it to me?

1:23:27It's just sort of the knee-jerk

1:23:29You know, there's obviously problems with capitalism. There's problems with everything and it's just the

1:23:36Worst system ever invented except for all the other ones, right but it's like the idea that some people have that

1:23:42The entirety of capitalism is rotten to the core and a capitalist intent for these historic buildings is inherently wrong is to me

1:23:51Go

1:23:52Go bitch about it on your website and we'll ignore you in the meantime. We're gonna go enjoy this very nice store

1:23:58There's there's my rant. I

1:24:00suspect right and

1:24:03And I think that Apple especially in the last couple of years. They've really put some touches in these historic stores that

1:24:11That celebrate like the the original intent and the original history of the store

1:24:17and so for example, if you go in the basement area at tower theater, they have

1:24:22historic photos from from when the

1:24:25when the building was an actual theater and they have

1:24:29Samples on the walls of different architecture elements from the store and they show how they restored each element

1:24:37so like there's like a

1:24:39plaster like an ornate plaster decal and they show like

1:24:43how it was when when they found it in the store and then like our preservationist

1:24:50Did whatever to peel back the layers of paint and fix it up and they show you like this progression

1:24:56So you can really really get a feel for for how much detail went into every piece of it

1:25:01It's just really cool. It feels more like a museum when you go down there

1:25:06man again

1:25:08A lot of the critics to speak of it as though Apple came in and bulldozed these buildings and then built a cookie cutter

1:25:15generic Apple store on top

1:25:17Which when in fact they do the opposite like you just emphasized that when they come into the historic buildings

1:25:22They each one is unique. Each one is a unique project and they try to honor the history and preserve

1:25:29what's able to be preserved and

1:25:31Document the history and do it with the most respect that they possibly can and I think that's awesome

1:25:38I think that it is it's the opposite. It's not like well, it's like the downside to apples expansion into retail to me

1:25:45It's one of the best parts of it for society as a whole is

1:25:50Rejuvenating these buildings and giving them purpose while respecting the history

1:25:54yeah, I've watched some of the like City Council meetings where Apple has to present these projects and

1:26:01there's always a

1:26:04representative from the Apple real estate team and usually maybe someone from Foster and Partners there and I've seen

1:26:10Specifically they've said this is not another glass box

1:26:14Like they go out of their way to emphasize that because I think even at the city level that they face a little bit of pushback

1:26:21It's interesting to me too as somebody with a broad

1:26:26interest in Apple as a whole and the Apple way of doing things is that it's really the only thing

1:26:33Apple the modern Apple does and I've always defined modern Apple is the post Steve Jobs

1:26:40verification 1997 onward it's the only thing they do that's

1:26:45backward-looking

1:26:46They're actually it's it's part of the culture of the company is not to dwell on the past to there's a Steve Jobs quote

1:26:54I'll paraphrase but you know when you've made something great

1:26:58What you should do is take a moment to enjoy it and then move on and make another great thing

1:27:03You know and there's there's exceptions to that. They've brought back some of the six color Apple logo stuff

1:27:09They've made some wallpapers for phones that have sort of a callback to that era and the logo and I think it helps too

1:27:17You know, and I think it goes along with with their very

1:27:21keen outspoken interest in

1:27:24LGBT

1:27:26equity obviously literally from Tim Cook on downward but that the classic six color logo draws

1:27:33associations to the use of the rainbow logo for LGBT

1:27:38Type support so they do that. There's actually a new ad campaign. I just noticed on billboards here in Philly for AirPods

1:27:46I don't know if you've seen this but that sort of a bold

1:27:49Primary color thing with a figure in a dark silhouette with white AirPods in their ear

1:27:56Which is a clear nostalgic callback to the iPod campaign

1:28:00from

1:28:032020 years ago or so 15 to 20 years ago, so they don't they they don't never look back

1:28:08But the architecture is the one thing where they're there. They're explicitly looking back

1:28:13And I think

1:28:16You know when thinking about Apple retail in general apples mentioned it before in keynotes that they

1:28:22Think about the stores as the largest product they make and it's I think it's easy to dismiss that as like

1:28:29Well, that's that sounds great. No, but I I think if you really

1:28:33internalize that idea and think about the next Apple store as

1:28:38just like the next iPhone and everyone builds on the last and each one a lot of people think that all Apple stores look the

1:28:46same right, but

1:28:47Does the iPhone 12 look?

1:28:50That much different than the iPhone 13 like yes and no right if you if you know what you're looking for

1:28:56there are a lot of differences and I think that the

1:28:59They really do think about the stores in that sense that this is this is another

1:29:05product that we make and that's I think that's what makes them

1:29:09fascinating and what makes it

1:29:12really the the area that

1:29:14that I've been studying for for so many years because it's

1:29:18It's endlessly

1:29:20Changing that's it really it's really what it is

1:29:25Well said, all right, let me take one last break here and thank our fourth and final sponsors are good friends at Squarespace

1:29:31Squarespace, you know Squarespace. That's the place where you can go. It's all in one everything from a domain name registration

1:29:38to picking from all sorts of various templates for how your website will look to the

1:29:46CMS tools to keep your website updated with content

1:29:50like if you want to have a blog or a newsfeed on your website, or maybe you are an artist and you're looking to

1:29:58Build a personal portfolio and you want to put your work on your website

1:30:03You do it all through

1:30:05Squarespace use Squarespace to

1:30:08Work on the layout start with a template tweak it

1:30:11To look like you want it to look like and then add once your website is done ready to go ready to unveil to the world

1:30:18But you want to keep adding content you do that through Squarespace to

1:30:22Literally all in one and they keep making it better keep adding new features

1:30:29they still have the award-winning 24-hour day tech support that they've

1:30:33Really, maybe the the cornerstone of the whole Squarespace business

1:30:38They have all sorts of other stuff to SEO tools so that you can help SEO

1:30:43What a dirty word people think it's like a scam - how do you scam your way to the top of search engines?

1:30:48SEO tools at Squarespace are built to do it the honest way like

1:30:51how do the people who really should be coming to your website when they search for the type of thing or type of person or

1:30:57type of service or

1:30:59Like if you're building a restaurant website

1:31:01They've got SEO tools to help you get noticed by the people who should be noticing you email campaigns

1:31:07You can do your own email campaigns right from within Squarespace and speaking of stores

1:31:12Which we've been talking about here on the episode all day long. You can build an online store in

1:31:17Squarespace and they handle all the e-commerce stuff that secure transactions everything like that all the stuff that you don't want to

1:31:24Touch because you don't want to mess it up. They handle it for you. Just go to Squarespace.com slash talk show

1:31:30Or if you're the nerdy friend who people come to when they need help with something like this

1:31:34Tell them when they need a website to go to Squarespace.com slash talk show that way

1:31:40They know you came from this show you get a free trial 30 days. You could build the site. There's no watermarks

1:31:45It's the real deal you get 30 days to just see what it's like and when you're ready to launch and pay for it

1:31:51Just remember that code talk show you save 10% off your first purchase

1:31:54Buy a whole year at once save 10% off the whole year my thanks to Squarespace and one last time

1:32:00I'll tell you the web the URL Squarespace.com slash

1:32:03Talk-show one of the saddest things to me. It is sad we laugh at it

1:32:08I mean and it's it is it is both funny and

1:32:11Sad is like when Microsoft launched their retail stores and they're very Apple store like often

1:32:18in the same mall system where Apple stores are

1:32:22because one of the things Apple one of the little things Apple is good at is figuring out where to put stores and

1:32:28Then they'd build these stores that were not ripoffs. I wouldn't say they're ripoffs, but the

1:32:35Clear low that use glass have these tables let people just play on the computers without a hard sell

1:32:42like if somebody really just wants to come in the store and just like

1:32:46Log in and check their Gmail on the computer like they're not going to get bugged by a sales

1:32:51Associate and then you go through them all and the Apple store is sort of like packed and then you look and there's the Microsoft

1:32:58store and it's like

1:33:00crickets chirping like like if somebody somebody wanted to build the

1:33:05Microsoft store time machine but wanted to come in and take some photos, but they really don't want people in the photos

1:33:11Well, guess what? You're in luck. You could do it

1:33:13Any time of the day, I'm curious what you think about that like what and I I it's it there's something different

1:33:21About Apple in so many ways and it's hard to imagine how anybody else could build

1:33:27Stores that are so popular as Apple right Google has some pop-up stores, but you know who else could do it?

1:33:35Yeah, and what's what's really sad I think is that

1:33:38Almost all the Microsoft stores are closed now. I wonder why I mean, yeah

1:33:44the pandemic really like

1:33:46Knocked them back and I think the only ones that they have left open are like a couple of their flagship stores

1:33:53even though it's really I think there's there's two parts to it and I think number one is

1:33:58that the Genius Bar and the Apple support experience is

1:34:04so important to the stores and I think that the stores would be packed if

1:34:09There were if it was literally just the Genius Bar and there were no products to look at

1:34:14The stores would still be packed every day of the week all hours a line of people out front

1:34:20Before the store opens waiting knocking on the glass like that's just how it is

1:34:25there's always somebody that needs to get their iPhone battery replaced and and I think that

1:34:31You just don't see that with with other brands like Microsoft and maybe it's because that they don't offer

1:34:38the same support experience honestly, I I couldn't tell you what what it would be like to get your

1:34:46Surface tablet serviced or something like that. And I think that people also are

1:34:52Attracted to the architecture of the Apple Store, right? So even though them like a Microsoft Store or Google Store

1:35:01Is distinct in in its own regard like the the design of the Apple Store is so eye-catching in a mall

1:35:08That you and the the lighting it's it's it just draws you right to it

1:35:14So there's like this natural interest in in like, oh, let's see what's going on there

1:35:20I just don't think anyone anyone has been able to match it

1:35:23The pandemic to me is is maybe it's the last topic we'll cover here

1:35:29But it's the Apple Store's role and and what it clarified is to me really fascinating here in

1:35:36Philadelphia Philadelphia was actually I don't know

1:35:39how

1:35:41encyclopedic your knowledge of Apple's retail stores are but Philadelphia actually if you if you chart it on an xy axis

1:35:48The size of a US city and how late it got its first Apple Store

1:35:55Philadelphia's some sort of outlier by far the biggest story that city that was the last to get an Apple Store

1:36:02The the Walnut Street store is is like the only one in in this in downtown, correct?

1:36:08I mean that that is everything else is in the suburb. Yeah. Yeah, that's correct

1:36:12I forget when it opened but that yes

1:36:14It's the Walnut Street store here in Philadelphia and I just happens to be pretty close to where I live

1:36:20And so I walk past it all the time including during the pandemic

1:36:24my gut feeling I've never really asked around but my gut feeling is

1:36:28It is in fact that stretch of Walnut Street in Philly would be the the premier retail

1:36:36District in downtown Philadelphia Center City we call it and I I think what happened is that they just were

1:36:44Waiting for something to open that fit what they thought their needs were and it was a game

1:36:51I used to play it beforehand like when

1:36:54Something would close and I would think that that could be an Apple Store and then I'd wonder if that would be it

1:37:01And then it never was right down Center City

1:37:03Philly is Philly is big but Center City Philadelphia is actually relatively small

1:37:10it's very walkable from end to end and

1:37:13I don't really think there's a

1:37:19Market for another one. I guess I could be surprised if they opened another one in this in this city limits

1:37:25But yeah, I've I've looked around I I'm not sure where they would put another one in Philadelphia

1:37:29Specifically because they've just become more picky over time

1:37:33Yeah

1:37:33so like if you if you look at the malls that some of the earliest Apple stores went into I think like

1:37:40They have these properties there now and they're committed to maintaining them in most cases unless like the mall is is dying

1:37:48But I just can't imagine them ever opening a store in some of the malls that they're in now

1:37:53so I I think I think that they've

1:37:55Compared to compared to other countries like the US is fairly saturated with Apple stores

1:38:03Like if you consider how few there are even in China compared to how many people there are there? So yeah

1:38:09I think the the market for US expansion is

1:38:13It's they they'll choose and they'll wait as long as they need to to find the perfect property

1:38:20Yeah, the other thing with Philadelphia is that in the suburbs? There's the king of Prussia Mall in Pennsylvania, which is like 15 miles

1:38:27West but it's like I often tell people it's like the longest it depending on the time of day and the traffic

1:38:33there's only one road to get there the school expressway and

1:38:37If there's a car accident, it is the longest one one accident. It's the longest 15 miles you'll ever drive

1:38:43But if there's no traffic you could go there as you could drive as fast as you want and then on the other side of the

1:38:49River in New Jersey, there's the Cherry Hill Mall

1:38:51Which is can be depending where you are in Center City you can get there in like 10 minutes in a car

1:38:57It is really close and they've been around the king of Prussia one

1:39:01It was was is a they've since moved to a new spot that the king of Prussia Mall is huge

1:39:06One of the biggest malls in in America and they've moved to a new location

1:39:10It's it's really huge and Cherry Hill is a pretty big store. So Philly was well served

1:39:16just not in downtown but

1:39:18During the pandemic it was interesting to me as a pedestrian just walking by seeing

1:39:24the Apple Store

1:39:26Come back and it was one of the first doors on that stretch when they couldn't serve people

1:39:34Indoors because of indoor restrictions for kovat they set up a nice tent and they took it down every night to shade people from

1:39:40the Sun because one of the things that's perfect about the

1:39:43Walnut Street store is it's not just on the nicest stretch of Walnut Street. It's also

1:39:48South facing so it gets it gets sunlight during the day and guess what? It's all glass

1:39:55Storefront, but because it gets the Sun and everybody had to be outside they put up like a nice tent

1:40:01So people weren't having the Sun beat down on them. They had cold water for everybody waiting in line

1:40:06And I'd walk past and you'd hear just a snippet of conversation and it's exactly what you think

1:40:11They dropped their phone and now it doesn't work. The screen doesn't even turn on and or something like that people need help

1:40:16You know, it's there it's their phone right? They were there

1:40:19I I don't see given the pandemic restrictions and and being respectful of their the employees who work there

1:40:26I don't see how they could have been open more and and it was really an interesting thing

1:40:31As all of this retail that the most thriving area of retail in my hometown was all shut down

1:40:37You know or even with the George Floyd right, you know, they got their windows smashed

1:40:41It was there was a I forget if it was a police car

1:40:44I think it was a police car was right you couldn't if you were making a move Michael Bay were directing a movie

1:40:50You couldn't make it up

1:40:51It was a police car

1:40:53Right in front of the Apple Store that somebody threw a Molotov cocktail into and it burned out the police car

1:40:59right in front of the Apple Store, you know, and now the glass got smashed and they covered it up and

1:41:03They let their employees. I actually walk I have some

1:41:08It might even be on my Instagram again another callback to earlier in the show that you know

1:41:13They boarded up the glass and they let their employees paint

1:41:16paint a

1:41:18Collaborative mural on it while they ordered new glass and in the meantime

1:41:22They were serving customers while it was all the glass was boarded up

1:41:26It was a big part of bringing the city back and it again

1:41:29I I think you can be if you want to be super cynical and just think it's

1:41:33Just a cell phone store and it's just there to make the most

1:41:36Currently financially successful company in the world even more successful

1:41:41I mean if you want to be that cynical go ahead, but I don't know it meant something here in Philadelphia

1:41:46It really did. I think that the the pandemic was a big reset for for Apple's retail strategy

1:41:53and I don't I

1:41:55don't say that because

1:41:57Somebody has told me that I don't I don't have any like

1:42:00confirmation of that but from my observations like I

1:42:04think it was it was a moment where

1:42:08whatever the store plans were going forward had to change and I think that their priorities had to shift and

1:42:16in terms of like new stores what what the existing stores are going to offer for services and

1:42:24and I think that new strategy is going to take a few years to really show itself just because of the fact that

1:42:32Physical real estate only can change so fast and they can only roll out things to stores so fast

1:42:39But I think like for instance like Apple pickup is one of the biggest changes since the pandemic

1:42:45So like the the new stores that have been built over the past year. They all include a

1:42:51Dedicated area in the store. It's specifically marked

1:42:55This is Apple pickup

1:42:56there will be like drawers in the wall that where they're storing customer orders sometimes like

1:43:03It has direct access to the backstage area and they've carved out these sections in new stores just for online

1:43:10pickup and then at all of the existing stores

1:43:14they've like cleared off a product table where they would have had iPhones before and they have a little easel there and

1:43:21They've just turned them into dedicated pickup zones

1:43:24And I think that's one of the largest changes to the store format in quite a few years. It's

1:43:30famously there are no like checkout counters at Apple stores, but I think the

1:43:36The pickup element is something that is only going to become

1:43:41more important as more and more people are buying online and I think as much as Apple likes to think of its stores as

1:43:50Places that you go just to visit hang out try the new products like

1:43:55There is that express component. That's just really important right now

1:44:00And I don't think I don't know for a fact, but I don't think that they would have moved in this direction

1:44:05Quite so fast had the pandemic not really or had the pandemic not really shook everything up. It accelerated it, right?

1:44:13It was like maybe that's what would have happened anyway

1:44:16and that's the way the world of retail is going to involve but the the pandemic just did a decade of

1:44:22acceleration in in a year

1:44:24I

1:44:25Can't let it slide because it's my I was gonna ask I was gonna save it but I'll get it out of the way now

1:44:30But well, I'll save the question for you

1:44:32But my least favorite thing about Apple stores is the fact that they don't have a dedicated place to go get in line to pay

1:44:38I hate it and that's a total eat

1:44:41Maybe I get it that I've been to California enough times that it's an East Coast West Coast thing

1:44:46But the other thing is that they used to have it in the air like like the the original stores that you modeled

1:44:52there used to be a place where you would pick up a thing and then here's the line and then you could go and

1:44:58Get in line and pay and I like to get in line to pay

1:45:02I hate that that's my least favorite thing about Apple stores because it you

1:45:08if it's something you can just pick up off a shelf like an iPhone case and you pick it up and now I want to

1:45:14buy it and

1:45:15You go up to somebody wearing this t-shirt and you're like can can I check out with you and they're like, oh no

1:45:20You want to find that guy over there and it's like how am I supposed to know that and you and and the other the person

1:45:25You're supposed to go to is wearing the same shirt, but there's somebody who can check you out

1:45:29I I complain about it less now because you can do it in the app and that's just what that's actually what I do

1:45:35I just go to the app which was

1:45:38Still I still find weird where it's like how does anybody know that I bought this but I mean I do it

1:45:43I don't I don't shoplift it to test the test the security but I the the years in between them having a

1:45:51queue to check out and

1:45:54Being able to do it in the app

1:45:57Infuriated me because I it's like you're just wandering around

1:46:02Guessing who to go to I hated it

1:46:05Right and and I think I think the idea of it initially

1:46:10Was I mean it made sense like the idea that you can just walk around wherever in the store and someone will help you and

1:46:18Without a specific counter. There's never like the appearance of like a line and waiting but but in practice

1:46:25Yeah

1:46:25that that's probably the number one complaint that I

1:46:29See about Apple stores and and and I think part of it is that the the feature that you can scan

1:46:35Scan and buy things right with your iPhone. That's

1:46:38Up until like the last year or so. They really never talked about it at all

1:46:44It was something that you would have to know

1:46:46Before you went into the store and it's only since like last fall that they've started putting

1:46:52specific signage like on the accessory shelves that say like

1:46:57Just they use actually app clip codes where you can just scan the app clip code and it brings up an app clip for

1:47:04the Apple Store app and then you can just check out right there and they really have not promoted that feature until

1:47:10The last year and so I don't think that the majority of customers even realize that's an option for them

1:47:17Yeah, I do. But yeah

1:47:19Well, you can't go on go on

1:47:23Okay, well the the Apple pickup counter it functionally it looks like a checkout counter

1:47:29But but when you when you approach it, you have to already have an online order placed, right?

1:47:34So in that sense it is that kind of central place where you know where to go when you enter the store

1:47:40But but yeah, I I guess I would agree with you. It is

1:47:44frustrating like when you

1:47:47Want to check out you just have to kind of like

1:47:50Hold up, whatever you want above your head and kind of wave it around like someone like yeah

1:47:56I want the explanation for this why there's no line for people who want a line. I

1:48:00Honestly, I

1:48:05really don't know because

1:48:07In practice, it's not like they've been able to maintain the appearance of no lines because you often get lines congregating around

1:48:15A specific table where someone is helping people check out and you'll get lines for appointments

1:48:21so like the waiting in line is like a big part of the Apple star experience and

1:48:26Yeah, it is a little bit baffling to me I'll just say though I do the other thing from the pandemic

1:48:33So I think on the one hand they're more friendly to online shopping and getting a pickup on the other hand

1:48:38I do think it reiterates the fact that they've come back and there's they're crowded. You're right. I've

1:48:44Walked by or visited several since the pandemic restrictions and have ended

1:48:50And it just serves to emphasize that there is something important to being

1:48:56talking to people face to face right and

1:48:59Being in a room and feeling welcome and people like being in the Apple store

1:49:06That's why people go there and in there they look happy when they're in the Apple store, and I think that's the difference

1:49:12That's the that's the missing thing

1:49:14from why did the Apple stores work and the Microsoft stores didn't is

1:49:20people want to be in the Apple store and the the being there is

1:49:25Meaningful and irreplaceable and yes, you can every single thing Apple sells in those stores

1:49:34You could just buy at apple.com

1:49:35or in the Apple app on your phone and have it shipped to you and you could get free shipping on most of the stuff and

1:49:42In some sense that's more convenient, right? And I've certainly lots of the stuff I do buy from Apple most of the stuff I buy

1:49:49I just get shipped to me. I certainly didn't buy my studio display and walk it down Walnut Street

1:49:54It's you know, but there are times where it's just nice to be there right and it's nice to see things right?

1:50:01Like what does that Apple watch strap look like for real?

1:50:05Yeah, one of the things that I was happiest to see come back. It's been about a year now

1:50:11They they started bringing back the today at Apple sessions that they host in all of the stores and and I think

1:50:17really like I

1:50:19think they could have used the pandemic as an excuse to

1:50:23Kind of quit doing that all together if they decided like it's it's not worth the money or something like that

1:50:29They could have just said well, we're done with we're done with classes in Apple stores

1:50:34But they but they brought it back and they've they've started programs like it's called creative studios

1:50:40So they they host like series of events

1:50:44just for underrepresented communities in each city and

1:50:48They they aren't even necessarily programs that are

1:50:52Available to to everyone that walks in the store. It's sometimes it's the thing that you have to apply for

1:50:58It kind of depends on what what the specific city is

1:51:01but but then the events are hosted in partnership with the

1:51:06Store teams the the creative pros at each one of those stores

1:51:10And yeah, I think that's that's like a really important part of what?

1:51:15makes an Apple store stand out from something like

1:51:19Google's attempt at retail and and I know like in the Apple community because a lot of a

1:51:25lot of people like you and I are very proficient with

1:51:30Macs and iPhones like the today at Apple sessions are kind of ignored because we all know how to use those features

1:51:37but but I think there are so many people that

1:51:39Find so much value in in learning about how to use the devices that

1:51:46They spend all day on but they just never knew how much easier

1:51:50certain features could be

1:51:53Yeah, I think that's huge. I do I think I think it explains the

1:51:58the to me the fundamental success of the iPhone and iPad is

1:52:05that people who before they had an iPhone or iPad

1:52:10Used a computer because they were already on the internet and had email and they use Chad and search the web

1:52:17but always felt like it was the whole thing was a house of cards ready to collapse and

1:52:21Get gummed up and slow and and they don't change anything

1:52:25Right, like don't install anything that the thing they learn from installing software is all of a sudden now

1:52:30They have a tool bar in every browser window that they never asked and don't know how it got there to oh

1:52:36This is great and I can download apps and try new things and if I don't like it

1:52:41I just tap and hold and hit a red button and it goes away and

1:52:44Anything I download and install isn't gonna mess up

1:52:48it literally technically can't because of the sandbox and it in it it just

1:52:55Turns them from feeling like everything they do on their computers is going uphill and a struggle to oh

1:53:01This is so easy and I'm coasting downhill. Let me learn more

1:53:04And you mentioned in the original 2001 2002 era

1:53:10they had all these books in the stores because they wanted you to like maybe get a book on how to get the most out of

1:53:17iPhoto because they wanted you to write

1:53:21You know, what's a lot more effective and more fun and actually more people will do it than reading

1:53:27The book is sitting down for an hour and hearing from somebody in a class of all these other people who are in the same

1:53:33boat as you and if you're thinking like

1:53:35Maybe I'm the only person who doesn't know how to create a shared folder with my family and photos

1:53:41here's a

1:53:43dozen other people exactly like you or maybe they're not like you because they're older and younger and they're from

1:53:49Different different in those ways, but the one thing you all share is you're all there to learn how to do more with photos and

1:53:55That's a great feeling and it's it it is

1:53:59It you can't you can't

1:54:03Fully describe it with words why that's different than all being in the same zoom class at the same time

1:54:11Right, it is being in a real place with real other people and having a real person from Apple in front of you

1:54:19It explain this to you and then feeling like hey, I actually feel like they want my question. They're not just perfunctory

1:54:27Asking do you have questions and hoping I don't they seem to really want to know if I have questions and and I do have

1:54:34A question and maybe it's dumb and they'll say no, that's not a dumb question

1:54:39That's a great question and let me show you the answer that I think there's also

1:54:45Something that's really exciting especially like the the photo and video sessions that Apple does where you go on like on a photo walk

1:54:53Around the mall or something like that and and when you come back to the store at the end of it

1:54:58They'll use well

1:55:00You'll like airdrop the photos you took to the creative pro that's presenting and then they will

1:55:05Airplay those from their phone right up onto the big video wall. And I think there's there's something really exciting about

1:55:13Seeing your work in that context and and what you're able to do in that session versus like

1:55:19It's being shared on screen in a WebEx call. Yeah. Yeah, it's it's really neat

1:55:25I think it resonates in a way that is truly important to being a human being and I know that could sound corny

1:55:32But it I think it's true and I think it's fundamental to the success. All right bonus round. Here we go final questions

1:55:39Okay, I told you my least favorite thing about Apple stores is they don't have a dedicated queue for I here

1:55:44I have a thing in my hand. I want to buy it

1:55:46Tell me your what what's give me your biggest annoyance or thing or just thing you would change if it were up to Michael

1:55:53Stieber to change the thing

1:55:55Okay, so I know this is kind of a big thing

1:55:59But the thing that I would change and it's it's a pretty big thing

1:56:04But there is this divide between the classic store design the stainless steel walls that look and

1:56:11the new store design which is the the avenue displays along the walls the

1:56:17Toronto flooring the quartz walls that architecture style is

1:56:23Fundamentally at odds with the architecture style of the classic stores

1:56:29So when you walk into an older store like like the one on Walnut Street

1:56:34the store was designed for an era of box software of

1:56:38big desktop Macs and

1:56:41It's it's harder to find the products that you want the store looks less tidy because

1:56:48it's

1:56:50The the new products are shoehorned into an old design and Apple's kind of maintained both designs

1:56:57Side by side and they've been pretty slow with

1:57:00remodeling stores to the new design and I think that if you walk into a new store and an old store back to back that

1:57:08that contrast is really striking and it's

1:57:11Growing more striking by the year and I just think that like it's really important

1:57:17For the the brand image really going forward that there's more consistency between the stores

1:57:24That's a good answer and I do feel it's funny because I don't feel like our our Walnut Street store is dated

1:57:30In general because I feel like that look is actually pretty timeless in and of itself

1:57:37But I know enough about the modern style of Apple architecture

1:57:43Including the way that the style is sort of unified with Apple Park

1:57:49There are aspects of Apple Park and the Steve Jobs theater and everything they've done

1:57:54And sort of big part of it to me too is sort of like the integration of plants

1:58:00Yes, like the Apple Store here on Walnut Street has no plants and it doesn't have any leather seats and like that's sort of the

1:58:09New style I I think if you you seem familiar enough with our Walnut Street store

1:58:13I think if they needed to do that

1:58:15They would need to find a bigger

1:58:16Footprint and I don't know if they're on the hunt for that if they are there in luck because there's a lot of a lot

1:58:21of retail openings in Philadelphia

1:58:23So I wouldn't be surprised if there's actually a hunt going on if they're thinking that because to me that's part of the new style

1:58:30of Apple retail stores is like

1:58:32Plants and seating and sort of an indoor park area for lack of a better word

1:58:38It's not quite so rectilinear just a perfect

1:58:42rectangle of

1:58:45gleaming

1:58:46Stainless steel or I guess it's aluminum walls. So that's a good answer

1:58:50Alright, and then what about your favorite little thing that maybe people don't really think about about apples Apple retail stores. Oh

1:58:56Wow, that is difficult. I thought maybe the other one would be the one where I put you on the spot

1:59:04So the complaint about the dated style of the dichotomy between the two architectures, that's your complaint. What about a little thing?

1:59:12Okay, so I really love the tables in Apple stores and I don't think that people really think

1:59:20Deeply about what's going on with the tables and I actually I named my newsletter about Apple retail

1:59:26I named it tabletops because I'm always thinking about the tables but the tables so

1:59:31I'm sure that you remember like the the old

1:59:37Television sets that were like consoles that like I do a wood box around the TV, right? Yep

1:59:43So in a way like Apple store tables are like

1:59:48Console TVs where they're really an appliance disguised as furniture

1:59:53so there's so much going on inside the table from like the on the newest tables like the

1:59:59The cable is routed up through the leg of the table so that you don't see any

2:00:05Any cable coming down from the center on the older stores. There's there's power management inside the tables, right? There are actual

2:00:12white wall chargers just like

2:00:15like the

2:00:18USB-c bricks that you get with like a MacBook right there inside the tables and there and there's complex like

2:00:24Mechanisms inside the table for for routing cables, especially like an Apple watch display table

2:00:31Which is actually on its way out, but there's there's so much going on

2:00:35it's it's not just a big solid block of wood and I think a lot of people do know about at the back of the

2:00:41Not every store has these tables, but actually I

2:00:45might be wrong about that, but the

2:00:49The the tables you you can wave your hand over the table and the the outlets will like rotate

2:00:57Out of out of the tabletop if you've never seen it, it's it's hard to explain but there's a there's a

2:01:04wooden section of the table that physically

2:01:07turns and reveals

2:01:09power sockets and USB ports

2:01:12That are hidden inside the table

2:01:15So if you sit down for like a genius power point that you can plug in your Mac or whatever

2:01:20And so like there's so much going on

2:01:25Inside of what just looks like a huge wood slab

2:01:27That's a very good answer. That's excellent. All right, let's wrap it up

2:01:33You mentioned so that was a perfect segue you mentioned that you publish a newsletter called

2:01:39Tabletops, where can people find that so that is newsletter dot Michael Stiebert calm

2:01:45all right, and I publish it every week and

2:01:47Michael Stiebert calm it redirects to your seems like that's your main homepage

2:01:54department map dot store

2:01:56Yeah, so so that's a project that I started a while back actually when I was at at 9 to 5 Mac and it's it's a

2:02:05glossary of like of the different features in an Apple store and and I would use it to

2:02:11Link specific things in my articles when I didn't want to explain like what's what's the video wall?

2:02:18Every time I wrote a story because the audience was some people had never visited a store

2:02:23Some people were very familiar

2:02:24So I would just I would just link to certain things like that rather than explain it every time and but that that gloss

2:02:31She's a little bit outdated. I should I should probably update it. But um, it's maybe now that I'm finished modeling those stores

2:02:38it is

2:02:40Again in the same way that your entire shop different experience is way more

2:02:45Detailed than I had any hope that it might be the glossary is actually way more comprehensive

2:02:52Then I was guessing that it was it is actually really really it's almost like a little like a book really really nice

2:02:59But anyway, the home page at that site, which I again I promise will be in the show notes has links to everything

2:03:04including the Apple store time machine

2:03:07Including your tabletops newsletter once a week and it's just just about Apple retail if anybody's listening to this and you're thinking this guy really

2:03:15Knows what he's talking about. I'd like to hear more

2:03:17Tabletops is I guarantee you the newsletter for you and the glossary and links to your articles

2:03:24Etc and so forth on Twitter you are at Michael Stieber st

2:03:30eeber

2:03:32Anything else you want to toss out a link to no, I think that that covers it. Yeah

2:03:37Well, thank you for your time and doing this show, but thank you even more

2:03:44For creating the shop different app store Apple store time machine

2:03:49Which is truly it's just just absolutely extraordinary

2:03:52Anybody out there listens to this podcast who hasn't downloaded it and tried it who now isn't thinking I got it

2:04:00I got it. I got to get this you're not hooked up right because it's it's just extraordinary. Thank you, Michael

2:04:07Now.