0:00:00Good afternoon and welcome to the talk show live.
0:00:06We're coming to you in person from Apple's worldwide developer conference 2022.
0:00:14This show is being presented at the new Apple Developer Center at Apple Park in Cupertino, California.
0:00:23Now please welcome the Internet's favorite raconteur.
0:00:27It's Jon Gruber!
0:00:30[Applause]
0:00:41Thank you, thank you.
0:00:44Enough. I have so many things I gotta talk about. We gotta... can't waste time on applause.
0:00:51This is actually the 10th annual the talk show live from WWDC.
0:00:58Which I kind of can't believe.
0:01:00Ten years ago in 2012 when I first had the idea, the notion to do it,
0:01:05my wife and I rented, it was like an art gallery at 111 Minas Street in San Francisco.
0:01:10Literally my guest was Cable Sasser from, my good friend from Panic.
0:01:16And I don't know, maybe we had 70 people, something like that.
0:01:19We didn't have cameras, we just recorded it. We just thought it'd be fun to record it with an audience.
0:01:23And it was this little art gallery with like an L shape.
0:01:27And over on the other side of the L, just open air, there was actually an art show going on.
0:01:34And I really remember thinking I felt bad for them because people were laughing and there was a lot of applause.
0:01:38And we did do the open bar. People were rowdy.
0:01:43But you know, the show changed. We moved to Mezzanine, which is a slightly bigger place in San Francisco.
0:01:52And wound up when WWDC moved, we moved to San Jose and the absolutely beautiful California Theater in San Jose,
0:02:01which seats 1100 people.
0:02:04And if you told me back when I started that I'd wind up in an 1100 seat theater doing this show,
0:02:11I would have said, "That's pretty unlikely."
0:02:16And if you told me that 10 years later I would be doing it in a theater on Apple's campus,
0:02:22I would have said, "Something went really wrong with the world."
0:02:29I think I would have been right.
0:02:32But I am so happy to be here and I am so happy that you are all here.
0:02:37It is unusual. Is it weird that I am, to me, do I feel weird speaking on an Apple stage?
0:02:45Yeah, really, really weird. This is so weird.
0:02:49But it was the only way to do a live show. There is no other way.
0:02:53There is absolutely no other way to go through all of the protocols and all the stuff we did to make sure everybody's verified
0:03:00negative tests and mask rules and all that.
0:03:04There was no other way to do the show.
0:03:07I am incredibly grateful that everyone at Apple seemed as interested in making this happen as I was.
0:03:16So that's just terrific.
0:03:18I have two sponsors to thank.
0:03:21First is MacStadium.
0:03:24For over a decade, MacStadium has provided private MacClouds built for the Apple community,
0:03:31done the right way for developers.
0:03:33It's an ideal sponsor for WWDC, right?
0:03:36Well, guess what? They've sponsored the live show before. Hopefully, they'll do it again.
0:03:40But it's the perfect audience.
0:03:42They are focused on putting the latest Mac hardware into secure data centers, including thousands of M1 Macs.
0:03:52And I'm pretty sure they'll be ready for the M2s as soon as that's appropriate for a data center.
0:03:58They go fast. I mean, they work fast.
0:04:01Their premier cloud product, Orca 2.0, is available right now.
0:04:08And it supports virtualization of MacOS on both Intel and Apple Silicon.
0:04:14Visit macstadium.com/thetalkshow.
0:04:20You can learn more.
0:04:21My second sponsor is Adams, makers of everyday shoes.
0:04:27I'm actually wearing them now, not just because they're a sponsor, but because I wear them all the time.
0:04:33I love them. They are comfortable. They are durable.
0:04:36I think they look great.
0:04:39I like black, but I always like black. Sometimes gray.
0:04:45But they have all sorts of fun colors, really fun colors, including limited edition colorways that you can only get for a limited time.
0:04:55They've been doing this for a couple of years. They called their first shoe the Model 0-0-0-0.
0:05:02They've got the Model 0-0-1. I can't wait till they get up to 007, frankly.
0:05:08But the Model 0-0-1 is coming out this week.
0:05:12So again, perfect timing for this sponsorship.
0:05:16You can go to adams.com/df.
0:05:22They've got a special page set up just for people who are listening to the show or watching it on YouTube.
0:05:28So my thanks to them.
0:05:31So a lot has changed about my doing this show over the last 10 years.
0:05:37I mean, it got bigger. It went to doing it over WebEx.
0:05:45It came to Apple's campus.
0:05:47One thing that hasn't changed, though, is that I have always kept my guests secret.
0:05:53I just think it's more fun that way.
0:05:55I think it's more fun for the-- I think that's part of the fun of the live audience.
0:05:58Everybody watching, I hope thousands of people watching on YouTube when this hits later in the week, already know who the guests are.
0:06:05But you, I hope, don't.
0:06:08So without any further ado, please join me in welcoming to the stage
0:06:16Craig Federighi and Greg Joswiak.
0:06:19It's a very awkward moment.
0:06:34You didn't tell me what shoes you'd be wearing.
0:06:37Do I get some of the sponsorship?
0:06:39This was not cooked.
0:06:41If the FCC, I don't know who regulates these sponsorships, looking into this, this was not cooked.
0:06:47Craig, I don't know what's wrong with you.
0:06:50Yeah.
0:06:50Very stylish.
0:06:52Well, speaking of attire, I'm very disappointed in your attire.
0:06:57This is pretty much what I wear.
0:07:00I mean, I think this color, some varied in blue, always.
0:07:03Not always, but I've seen, and I think it was a very, very sharp and stylish look.
0:07:09It was basketball sweats.
0:07:11That's the other thing I wear, yes.
0:07:12So the funny thing about that bit from the keynote, which I think was hilarious,
0:07:18was I was watching the keynote live at the special event with my dithering colleague, Ben Thompson,
0:07:27who's a huge basketball fan.
0:07:28And I like basketball.
0:07:29I played basketball recreationally until I started aging out of it.
0:07:34It looked like you have game.
0:07:38You have form.
0:07:39And Ben and I turned to each other and like, "Hey, I think he can actually shoot."
0:07:43He missed like half of those, just so you know.
0:07:46It was a long shot.
0:07:49Yeah, it was a long shot, but come on, half at best.
0:07:51Yeah, no, I aged out of basketball in around fourth grade.
0:07:55Just not tall enough.
0:07:58That's right.
0:08:00You passed as a credible shooter.
0:08:02Thank you.
0:08:02Good to know.
0:08:04Now, that outfit was an amazing thing. They told me, "We're going to have you put something on
0:08:10and hope you can be a good sport."
0:08:14Was a headband considered?
0:08:20Yes, there was.
0:08:22There was a headband.
0:08:25Wow, you know us well.
0:08:26And I got to say, so I'm like, "Okay, I'm game."
0:08:29I put the headband on.
0:08:30I go in front of the camera.
0:08:32Jaws is in this back room monitoring the cameras.
0:08:34If the word comes back, take off the headband.
0:08:36It was just, I'm like, "Wow, must be bad."
0:08:42Well, not a hard decision.
0:08:43He does not have the hair to be constrained by a hairband.
0:08:47Losing battle for that hairband, that's for sure.
0:08:51I want to talk first about the event itself.
0:08:57And I don't know what to call it because WWDC is the whole week of developer news and conferences
0:09:05and for people who are all around the world and they're just watching online.
0:09:09But the special event yesterday of having, I don't know,
0:09:14it seems to me, a thousand plus developers and lots of media too.
0:09:23It was to me the most remarkable event professionally in my career.
0:09:28I really thought it was unbelievably.
0:09:31I'm just curious what you guys thought about how the day went.
0:09:34Well, I'll tell you, what was the most amazing to me
0:09:37is developers flew from all over the world to be here.
0:09:42I mean, you talk to them.
0:09:42You talk to people from Indonesia.
0:09:44"Hi, I'm from India."
0:09:45"Hi, I'm from the Ukraine."
0:09:47It's remarkable.
0:09:49And look, we all read a bunch of crap in the news.
0:09:53And I know I'm probably not the first one to say this,
0:09:56but you start to listen to politicians in Washington
0:09:58and you might get a distorted view of the world.
0:09:59And I think yesterday was an example of really what our relationship is like with developers
0:10:07and how important that relationship is for them with us and with us with them.
0:10:12And that so many of them would choose to fly halfway around the world
0:10:17to come be here for an event like this.
0:10:20And to me, that was so reaffirming.
0:10:24And we have this amazing developer team.
0:10:25Some of them are here in the audience.
0:10:27To quote my favorite football coach, that Susan and her team approached this with an enthusiasm
0:10:35previously unknown to mankind when it comes to serving developers.
0:10:41And you got a flavor for that yesterday, I think.
0:10:46Yeah, I thought we've been missing something for the last couple of years.
0:10:50I mean, it was always so special to get together.
0:10:54And I mean, part of it is talking about the things we talk about.
0:10:58And I think actually for that, it's tough to let go of the video format
0:11:04because we're able to really craft the stories.
0:11:08But we all sense, even if that works, and even if we're getting the content out well,
0:11:15to get the community together was something we missed so much.
0:11:19And it was amazing, even when the prospect was come out and watch a film with us,
0:11:25how the community really felt the same way we did with like, let's get together.
0:11:30And it was great.
0:11:31Yeah, I'll give Craig credit because he's one of the ones who pushed for it.
0:11:34Because we do so well with these online presentations.
0:11:38Come on, you know, WWCE used to be a matter of ringing a few thousand,
0:11:42but thousands of developers out to San Francisco or San Jose, depending on the years.
0:11:48And we have an incredible event.
0:11:51But when COVID hit, we changed the way we had to do business.
0:11:54And we changed obviously to these video, not just keynotes, but sessions.
0:11:59And they've been incredibly well received.
0:12:02The developer satisfaction for them is incredibly high.
0:12:06And millions and millions of developers engage that week and after.
0:12:11And so that's hard to give up.
0:12:13But Craig and a few others were like, but we need that connection.
0:12:16We need that conversation, that exchanging ideas, like Tim said,
0:12:20the things that you can only do in person.
0:12:22And boy, it felt good.
0:12:23Yeah.
0:12:24I had a similar experience.
0:12:25I came in on Saturday instead of Sunday.
0:12:28And then Sunday, I didn't know what to do with myself.
0:12:30And I was actually staying at a hotel right here near campus.
0:12:34And I just went for a walk, right?
0:12:36I mean, what do you do?
0:12:37You go for a walk, see what's going on.
0:12:39And there's one person on the sidewalk, one person, like 11 o'clock Sunday morning.
0:12:45It's Cable Sasser.
0:12:46Where are you going, Cable?
0:12:53He was going to register.
0:12:54And I said, oh, I'll come with you.
0:12:55Media registration wasn't until Monday.
0:12:58But I was like, I'll just go hang out.
0:13:00The visitor center on Sunday was amazing.
0:13:04And I do get recognized at the one time of the year that I go--
0:13:10I live 51 weeks of the year in Philadelphia, and nobody knows who I am.
0:13:15And I come to WWDC, and people know me.
0:13:19But that's great.
0:13:19And I love it when people come up and say hi.
0:13:21But it was so different this time, because I'd really forgotten what that's like.
0:13:27And I'm not a hugger, or at least I wasn't pre-COVID.
0:13:32But I'm hugging people.
0:13:34I'm like-- and again, I met people from Qatar, Dubai, Brazil.
0:13:39I had the exact same thought as you, Jaws.
0:13:41And they were all so happy.
0:13:45And everybody's emotions were flushed faces, tears in the eyes, and just joy, joy.
0:13:55And I really think that you can think about things.
0:14:01You can think about what it's like to hug or kiss somebody you love.
0:14:05But it's totally different than the experience of doing it.
0:14:08And so you can think about, yeah, yeah, I miss the community.
0:14:11But then when the community's back together, it hits.
0:14:15And it was really remarkable.
0:14:18And I thought the event was just great.
0:14:20I can't believe-- half the people I know also got terrible sunburns.
0:14:25It was a very sunny day.
0:14:29But the screen was amazing.
0:14:30You had to-- how can this sun be this bright and you can see this perfectly?
0:14:34It was almost surreal.
0:14:35There was this giant Susan Prescott on the SOTU.
0:14:39Volume was the same, but it was--
0:14:43I also-- it was really neat that they were giving tours of this building.
0:14:55This is the new developer center.
0:14:57And I got to take that tour.
0:14:59But I also heard from the developers who had taken it on Sunday.
0:15:04And they were like, oh, you got to go.
0:15:05You got to go see it.
0:15:06And they're like, hey, is that where your show is going to be?
0:15:08And I'm like, I don't know.
0:15:11Who are your guests?
0:15:14I don't know.
0:15:15Well, and this is a brand new building.
0:15:18We're just unveiling it.
0:15:19I mean, we've hosted developers for years.
0:15:21But I don't know if you ever got hosted at Back in Infinite Loop.
0:15:24But it felt like taking developers into a cage.
0:15:27There would be these interior conference rooms,
0:15:29which is kind of the nicest thing you could say about.
0:15:32No windows.
0:15:32Sometimes developers would stay there day and night for a long time.
0:15:37It's like, it's not very humane.
0:15:39And we've upped the level here.
0:15:41This is an experience that, instead of just the developer briefing center,
0:15:45we have this.
0:15:45We have this room.
0:15:46We have these incredible soundproof rooms where developers can work confidentially
0:15:50and work on their stuff and engage not just with our developer group,
0:15:54but right across the street from Apple Park,
0:15:55where we have Craig and his engineers.
0:15:57And when necessary, our hardware engineers.
0:15:59They're all across the street.
0:16:00So it's a spectacular opportunity for our developers and our engineers
0:16:05and our developer team to all interact definitely in a much better way
0:16:09than we could in the past.
0:16:10I think it emblemizes-- the three of us have talked about the same issue of,
0:16:18does Apple care about third-party developers?
0:16:21And people who want to answer that question,
0:16:27yes, Apple does not care about them.
0:16:29You blah, blah, blah.
0:16:30This reason, that reason, and the other reason.
0:16:31Why does this building exist?
0:16:35I mean, it's a physical manifestation to me of the best of Apple's attitude
0:16:42towards developers.
0:16:43Yeah.
0:16:43Look, the iPhone changed the world.
0:16:47We know that.
0:16:48But it did it in combination with the App Store.
0:16:51It did it in combination with apps.
0:16:53Again, people forget what software distribution was like before the App Store.
0:16:59You're old enough to know.
0:17:01But to get software out in the market was tough.
0:17:05You had to find a publisher.
0:17:06The publisher took a cut.
0:17:07Channel took a cut.
0:17:08You had to make the goods.
0:17:10In the end of the day, the developers left with very little.
0:17:14And we wanted to create a safe and trustworthy place
0:17:17where developers could reach all customers with much more beneficial economics
0:17:23and level the playing field between big and small.
0:17:26And look again, going back to my point of sometimes
0:17:30people are telling a distorted story.
0:17:31It was an economic miracle.
0:17:32It has created millions and millions of jobs around the world.
0:17:37There were too many jobs in the United States alone
0:17:39driven by our app economy.
0:17:41It's worked.
0:17:42And it's worked for those developers.
0:17:43It's worked for customers.
0:17:45And obviously, it's worked for us.
0:17:47It's worked for everybody.
0:17:47It's one of those win-win-win.
0:17:49We're very proud of it.
0:17:51And developers are part of the lifeblood.
0:17:53And to your point, that's why we have things like this and this conference.
0:17:56[END PLAYBACK]
0:17:57I will tell you the pushback from longtime Mac indie developers I know on that point,
0:18:04which is that in between the physical distribution era
0:18:08and going through Ingram Micro or whoever, you had to take 60%
0:18:13before they sent it to a retailer who took another 50%
0:18:17and left you with a sliver of the sales.
0:18:19In the early 2000 to iPhone era, when Mac OS X was Mac OS X,
0:18:31there was a thriving market of indie developers
0:18:36who weren't going through physical-- they were just direct downloads
0:18:39with direct sales on their website.
0:18:42But I think the difference is just the number of developers in today's world
0:18:52who came here from around the world and how quickly WWDC sells out now.
0:18:58Tickets are gone.
0:18:58Right?
0:18:59Back in that era, you could just take a week
0:19:02and decide whether you wanted to go to WWDC.
0:19:04I mean, the last time before you guys had the lottery,
0:19:06it was, I think, like a minute.
0:19:07There was like--
0:19:08[END PLAYBACK]
0:19:08Yeah.
0:19:09Right.
0:19:09Yeah.
0:19:11I think what's so exciting about the world that really the iPhone
0:19:15and the App Store ushered in is there is just this trusted community now
0:19:22where thinking to buy an app is not a big decision.
0:19:28My kids do it virtually without thinking about it.
0:19:33People buy-- the number of apps that people buy today on average compared
0:19:39to even during the, you want to say, the heyday of--
0:19:43and even today what you'd see from web downloads on desktop platforms.
0:19:47There's just no comparison because people know they have a platform they can trust,
0:19:51a source that they can trust, a vibrant developer community.
0:19:55And that whole thing has just been working so wonderfully for everyone.
0:19:59And I'll just say from the point of view of us in software,
0:20:05building these platforms, these APIs, we see it as just this amazing opportunity
0:20:14to both lift the developer and the user community.
0:20:18You know, we're platform first and the other experiences we build second
0:20:25because that sort of lifts all the boats.
0:20:29And I thought it was very funny.
0:20:30I read something where someone was saying, oh, well, we noticed you
0:20:33introduced a lot of APIs.
0:20:35Is that because you're reacting to European regulators saying something about you?
0:20:40I'm like, have you not been watching our conferences for the last how many years?
0:20:43This is what we do.
0:20:46And it's a privilege to be able to do it.
0:20:49So let's get to some of the news front that was announced yesterday and one that really
0:20:54caught my eye and is perfect for revisiting because we talked about this,
0:20:58I think the last time-- yeah, 2019.
0:21:03So it'd be the last time we did this face to face was when SwiftUI and Catalyst were
0:21:10announced at the same year.
0:21:12And I tried to get you to answer which one's the way to go.
0:21:17And what caught my eye in the State of the Union yesterday was, to me, an unambiguous
0:21:24slide.
0:21:25I'm quoting directly.
0:21:27The best way to build an app is with Swift and SwiftUI.
0:21:31Yeah.
0:21:33That seems like a change in messaging in terms of commitment to this is the way forward.
0:21:39Yeah, I think we-- back when we last spoke in 2019, the future direction, where the arrow
0:21:47was pointing, was clear.
0:21:49And we've been marching on that vector ever since.
0:21:53I think all of these technologies-- and I hope I said it at the time-- were relevant
0:22:01then and remain relevant now.
0:22:03And so depending on where you are as a developer, the right mix of technologies for you at this
0:22:08moment in time could be quite different.
0:22:10We build a lot of, of course, UIKit apps.
0:22:14We build a lot of native AppKit apps.
0:22:16We build, now on the Mac, a lot of Catalyst apps that I think are excellent.
0:22:21And the Mac now has a richer set of first-party apps because of Catalyst.
0:22:25We depend on that capability, and we continue to build out that framework and make it
0:22:31more and more capable.
0:22:32But increasingly, as we build new things, as we build new UIs, we're building them with
0:22:38SwiftUI when we have the opportunity to do something new.
0:22:43And this year, one of the things we announced is we're making it ever easier to even take
0:22:49little pieces of your app, even the cells that you put in a collection view, and say,
0:22:54you know, this piece would be so great to do in SwiftUI because it's great for that.
0:22:58I don't have to rethink my overall app architecture,
0:23:01but I can just fit this in.
0:23:02And of course, developers have been building widgets now and watch complications in SwiftUI.
0:23:07So it's becoming a part of almost many, many apps and can be the complete foundation for
0:23:14many going forward.
0:23:14But yeah, in terms of where the arrow is pointing, absolutely.
0:23:18I thought that SwiftUI charts-- SwiftCharts, I forget the name.
0:23:22SwiftCharts, yeah.
0:23:23But it seems-- I haven't really dug into it, but it seems super cool and robust.
0:23:27But as one friend of mine-- I'm going to steal from him, but put it-- it's like a perfect
0:23:31leaf node.
0:23:32Like, if you already have a tree of an app-- That's right.
0:23:35--you could just use this-- and the app might be AppKit, or maybe it's an iPhone app.
0:23:41It's all UIKit.
0:23:41You're not going to cut down the whole tree and rebuild this whole tree.
0:23:44But you've got a new leaf node where SwiftCharts would be the perfect-- you need charts.
0:23:48You can just put it right there.
0:23:50That's absolutely right.
0:23:51And actually, within the apps that-- the versions of the apps that we've now seeded to developers,
0:23:58if you look inside the health app at some of those charts, that's an app that is not
0:24:03an entirely SwiftUI app, but a bunch of those charts are SwiftCharts.
0:24:07If you look at the weather app, now available on iPad--
0:24:10[LAUGHTER]
0:24:11Ed-- yes.
0:24:13Come on.
0:24:15[APPLAUSE]
0:24:17And Mac, I should point out.
0:24:18Now available on Mac as well, and I use it on Mac as well.
0:24:21The rich set of charts now in there-- SwiftCharts, right, fitting into this app.
0:24:26So yeah, I think for every developer, it's got to be-- maybe it starts as just one of
0:24:31the arrows in their quiver as they build out different parts of their app.
0:24:34And eventually, they find they build more and more.
0:24:36What is it about SwiftUI, though, that-- what I'm hearing and what that unambiguous slide
0:24:43says to me is 10 years down the road, after another 10 years of these talk shows, there's
0:24:49going to be-- what I'm hearing from you is there are going to be, by that time, a lot
0:24:53more all SwiftUI apps.
0:24:55I think that's right.
0:24:56I think that's right.
0:24:56And why do you think that is?
0:24:58I think it's a real catalyst for creativity.
0:25:05I was talking to a developer yesterday from the design awards and was saying, what's your
0:25:12process?
0:25:13And he said, I'm doing everything now in SwiftUI.
0:25:17And I get an idea, and I can sit down in an hour, try it out, feel it out, get the gist
0:25:25of it.
0:25:26And that is-- that's what sparks innovation, right, that you feel that close to taking
0:25:34a thought and turning it into an app and then building it out.
0:25:37And the fact that we have live previews, that the turnaround is so fast, that the UI is
0:25:42so flexible that it retargets other platforms so immediately, I mean, it's just-- you're
0:25:47piling gains on top of gains.
0:25:49And I think it brings just a ton of joy to development.
0:25:55When I have spare time, I sit down and write apps in SwiftUI just for fun, because it's
0:26:01just fun.
0:26:03I watch TV.
0:26:04Everyone can code, Josh.
0:26:09We could go-- if we had an extra hour, we could spend a whole hour talking about severance.
0:26:15Yes, let's do it.
0:26:17Any severance fans in the audience?
0:26:19I don't want to go off on-- but I just cried.
0:26:25I described that show to my wife, and she's just generally not a science fiction fan.
0:26:30And she was like-- and I was like, let's just give it a chance.
0:26:33She loved it more than I did.
0:26:34It's amazing.
0:26:35It's such a great show.
0:26:35Really good.
0:26:36You know what, though?
0:26:37But one of the other things-- and I think people-- some people misunderstand how committed
0:26:44you guys are to keeping everything going.
0:26:46And I even noticed-- again, it wasn't me digging through the release notes, but a friend pointed
0:26:51out that there's even a brand new AppKit control this year, NS combo button.
0:26:56It's cool.
0:26:57I've seen it.
0:26:57It's a button where you can have a dropdown menu next to the push button and combine them
0:27:02together.
0:27:02So even AppKit is still-- nothing has been labeled legacy.
0:27:07That's right.
0:27:07That's right.
0:27:08I think everyone's got to understand there is-- our reliance on the continued health
0:27:16and development of all of these frameworks is greater within Apple than anywhere else
0:27:23in the world.
0:27:24And so we have every interest and an internal developer community that is absolutely demanding
0:27:33of continued progress on all fronts.
0:27:36So I don't think anyone should fear our commitment here.
0:27:39I see why.
0:27:44I think it makes a lot of sense that the WWDC keynote is always organized by platform.
0:27:51iOS.
0:27:54We've debated this.
0:27:56Yeah.
0:27:56You know what's funny too?
0:28:00You come out here for the community stuff, and you talk to people, and you get to talk
0:28:03to people face to face.
0:28:04And you often-- I hear that all up and down from every level of the company.
0:28:09Yeah, we thought about that.
0:28:12Well, it's so funny though, because we talk about it because we get into the Mac section,
0:28:18and we're talking about these enhancements to mail.
0:28:21And at some point, the iOS section ended.
0:28:24And people go, well, that's what's-- and in fact, even watching the coverage, people say,
0:28:28well, so that's what's in iOS.
0:28:29And then we get into the Mac section, and we start talking about what's new in mail.
0:28:32All those features in mail and iOS, they're all extremely relevant there.
0:28:37You get into the iPad section, we start talking about collaboration, how you can initiate
0:28:41collaboration in messages and then do it in these other apps.
0:28:45That's in Mac.
0:28:46That's in iOS.
0:28:47We cover it in the iPad section.
0:28:49So we try to find the best place to highlight these developments.
0:28:54But so much of what we're doing at this point is to the benefit of all the platforms.
0:29:01And I think this is partly because of all the framework and technology leverage we have,
0:29:06because we're trying to create that same kind of environment for third parties.
0:29:09Really easy to do it once and do it everywhere.
0:29:11We also know as users of our platform, it's pretty awesome.
0:29:16If you like it here, you sure expect it in every device of ours that you pick up and
0:29:21use.
0:29:21And so we're committed to making that happen.
0:29:23But it does create this question of, how exactly do you talk about it?
0:29:27And JAWS always wins at its final talk.
0:29:30[LAUGHTER]
0:29:35I do think, though-- and I know one of the things that I also think gets overlooked about
0:29:41Apple is how successful Apple can be at playing long games.
0:29:46SwiftUI is clearly a long game.
0:29:51And it was introduced in a state where it clearly wasn't ready to be used to create--
0:29:56All apps?
0:29:58Yeah, all apps.
0:29:59But it has to be introduced at some point.
0:30:01And there's a plan going forward.
0:30:03Swift itself.
0:30:05Right.
0:30:05Swift itself.
0:30:06I mean, Catalyst, that was one where we were quite explicit that we said, we're doing this
0:30:11thing.
0:30:11We're doing it first with these few apps.
0:30:13Eventually, it's going to come to you, third-party developers.
0:30:16And we kept building technologies like Metal.
0:30:20You start here, and you invest, and you invest, and you invest.
0:30:22And so, yeah, there are a tremendous number of long games.
0:30:27I thought one of the long games that kind of came to fruition in this year's keynote--
0:30:32or at least to my mind, it really seemed-- and it's exactly what we're talking about,
0:30:36that these features apply iOS, iPad, OS, Mac OS.
0:30:41I think not even that many years ago, it wasn't so much that everything was in sync.
0:30:50They'd be like, well, this is what we got done this year.
0:30:53And the iPhone is this world-changing device.
0:30:57Might have to come first.
0:31:01And other platforms, which were-- like the Mac, for example, was in a good spot.
0:31:08Mac OS X was in great position by the time the name changed.
0:31:13Well, it was Mac OS X.
0:31:16Now it's Mac OS, but there was one--
0:31:17It's OS X in the middle.
0:31:19OS X.
0:31:19I didn't like that one.
0:31:20[LAUGHTER]
0:31:21We fixed it.
0:31:22You got to have Mac in the name.
0:31:24Come on.
0:31:25Anyway.
0:31:26We agree.
0:31:30But I really thought it was palpable how over and over and over again in the keynote yesterday,
0:31:37and this is available on the other two platforms, whichever of the segments we were on.
0:31:42And it's also mail.
0:31:44Well, think about the-- messages would be a great example.
0:31:48There's some apps that came to the Mac only because of Catalyst.
0:31:55Before Catalyst, those apps weren't there.
0:31:57There are other apps that we actually rewrote the app or built a Mac native app out of Catalyst
0:32:06to replace a Mac app that, in the past, had we done all these messages features that we announced,
0:32:13that the ability to edit messages and recall messages and so forth,
0:32:18it's unclear whether they would have made it to the Mac in the same year.
0:32:23And the fact that we invested in Catalyst, that Catalyst was then the foundation of building
0:32:28a much better app for the messages app for the Mac that shares code across all the platforms,
0:32:33meant that absolutely these enhancements to messages are everywhere.
0:32:35We announced great features to Maps.
0:32:38They are everywhere on all the platforms.
0:32:40So this has been a vision we had a long time ago of a place we could get to.
0:32:45But it took many, many years to build our way there.
0:32:48And yet our philosophy is not to hold this thing in secret for seven years and then come
0:32:55out at the end because the way you get there is to get it out there where a community can
0:32:59start to make use of it where it makes sense for them, give you feedback, and you can build
0:33:02on it internally.
0:33:03But you just keep your eye on the prize.
0:33:06Yeah, Messages is, to me, the poster child for the true potential of Catalyst.
0:33:14And I'll tell you specifically-- maybe I mentioned it last year.
0:33:17Does those WebEx meetings always disappear from my mind?
0:33:21But I really thought, OK, I get why they're doing this to keep it for those reasons.
0:33:26But there goes the AppleScript support in Messages on Mac.
0:33:29Nope, it's all still there.
0:33:32And the goofy AppleScript I run once a year that--
0:33:35I don't AppleScript messages very often, but I have a few.
0:33:43And they all worked.
0:33:44And there it is.
0:33:47That's what you told me you would do.
0:33:49So I owe you a being right point.
0:33:51[LAUGHTER]
0:33:53First one.
0:33:54[LAUGHTER]
0:33:58But we have all these sessions in the conference where we talk about something like building
0:34:04a great Catalyst app for Mac or building a great SwiftUI app for Mac.
0:34:08And it is in part about, sure, you brought your starting point that might have been on
0:34:13iPad, what does it mean to make it actually a great Mac app?
0:34:16And all those other technologies are available to you.
0:34:19And I think the developers who really love the Mac-- and I think many, many of our developers
0:34:24do, right?
0:34:24It's what they use to apply their craft-- want to put in the extra work to make their
0:34:29app great for Mac.
0:34:31And that's the thing.
0:34:32You take that core, and you can extend it.
0:34:33And certainly, that's our philosophy.
0:34:35Some of the things I do want to talk about, though, are the exceptions, some of the features
0:34:39that are specific to one platform.
0:34:43And I think for reasons that I think make sense, the re-imagined iPhone lock screen
0:34:51is-- the iPhone lock screen is only for the iPhone.
0:34:57I mean, you can imagine that maybe the iPad lock screen could maybe gain similar features
0:35:02later.
0:35:02But it makes sense.
0:35:03I just love that.
0:35:07And I was so glad to see how much time you guys gave to it.
0:35:10Because to me, one of the best things that Apple has always done and that drew me to
0:35:16Apple computers is the approachability to users to do more than just click, click, click,
0:35:27but actually make it their own and do something.
0:35:30Right?
0:35:31And you go back to HyperCard and stuff like that.
0:35:34But there's a rich, rich history at Apple of doing that.
0:35:38And to me, the lock screen configurability is that sort of thing.
0:35:42It's like a LEGO construction kit for making a lock screen for you.
0:35:46And I think it's not programming, but it is sort of designing your own software.
0:35:54And it's something that everybody could do.
0:35:57It went over so well.
0:35:59I did a lot of press interviews yesterday.
0:36:01And one of my favorites was when the journalist came to me.
0:36:04I said, how was the show?
0:36:05He goes, you had me at lock screen.
0:36:08It kind of says it all.
0:36:09I mean, it got a great reaction from the crowd here who was cheering it on and, of course,
0:36:14what people have been writing since.
0:36:15I think you're going to love using it.
0:36:17On all the list of things that we all spend a lot of time talking about is to call that
0:36:23area lock screen started to seem-- like, what do you call it, though?
0:36:28But it is this face of your phone.
0:36:30And that's why it is so personal.
0:36:32It's every time you take your phone-- a bunch of phones sit on the table.
0:36:36You can put a case on them.
0:36:37But the which one's mine?
0:36:38Well, it lights up with my lock screen.
0:36:41And I think it was really some of the passion in our HI team, too, who emphasized the role
0:36:50of personal photography and what can we do with your personal photos.
0:36:54Because what's more personal than that?
0:36:58But doing beautiful things with images.
0:37:04And this is an area where, initially, through portrait mode photography and then all of
0:37:10the work we've done on depth, we started to build a way to just make your photos that
0:37:16much more alive and magical.
0:37:18And we were really able to apply that here to the lock screen.
0:37:23And I know some of mine now, and they just-- your own photos feel so special if we can
0:37:29give them that care.
0:37:31And it's been exciting to take these big technology areas, like all this ML investment we've made
0:37:37in computational photography, and then be able to apply it to something that's such a beautiful
0:37:41aesthetic experience of having your own personal lock screen photo and lock screen widgets,
0:37:47which went over really well.
0:37:48Yeah.
0:37:48Well, the widgets are really part of that configurability, that toolkit of making it
0:37:55your own.
0:37:56And you could be a total minimalist.
0:37:58Just keep the time.
0:37:59Or you could have weather and-- I forget how many other widgets you guys demoed.
0:38:05And who knows what third-party developers will come up with.
0:38:07But if it's something you care about, a custom widget for the DevOps board at your work,
0:38:15keep it on your lock screen.
0:38:16I thought one of the interesting things that I drew from-- I don't know if you guys think
0:38:21about it this way.
0:38:21But I've thought about how the iPhone evolved from originally, the first iPhone 2007 to
0:38:28now, and a big part of that era is all of your discussions about privacy.
0:38:35And there's all sorts of ways that manifests.
0:38:37But there's also the original iPhone, it was slide to unlock.
0:38:45And you could put a passcode on it.
0:38:47But that's not how you used phones.
0:38:49And I think that maybe that's where they came from.
0:38:50You just did something to unlock your phone, and the iPhone was a phone.
0:38:55So you slid to unlock.
0:38:57And it was the nicest looking button you've ever seen.
0:39:00And you immediately get your first interaction with this phone is the incredible responsiveness
0:39:11of the touchscreen.
0:39:12And it was just so clever.
0:39:14But then clearly, everybody sort of realized, well, I can't just leave my phone slide to
0:39:20unlock.
0:39:21Well, touch ID was a huge part of making that easy.
0:39:24Because before touch ID, people did leave their phones unprotected, to your point.
0:39:28And once we came up with touch ID, and obviously face ID later, it just became so easy to secure
0:39:34your phone.
0:39:34Now, who would it?
0:39:35Now it's the exact opposite.
0:39:37Who would leave their phone without a passcode?
0:39:39And again, we pioneered that with what we were doing with touch ID.
0:39:43But to me, with the new configurable lock screen, it sort of brings back the, hey, I
0:39:48can do and see useful things on my phone without going into my phone.
0:39:53And I agree, face ID and touch ID have been game changers in terms of that.
0:39:59But to me, the phone is so rich as a platform now.
0:40:01And you know, and I know that there are talented people like TikTok influencers.
0:40:07The iPhone is their only computer.
0:40:11And they're making incredible art, video editing, and all of this stuff.
0:40:15Your phone is so powerful.
0:40:19But at this point, going into my phone is more akin to logging into my Mac.
0:40:24It's a thing where I go into my phone to do something serious.
0:40:27Sometimes I just want to see sports scores.
0:40:29And I don't want to go into my phone.
0:40:31And not saying face ID and touch ID aren't easy enough.
0:40:33But then it's like, yeah, then you've got to tap the right app or whatever.
0:40:36It's like, if you really care about the NBA finals, put a widget on your lock screen.
0:40:40Yeah, I think that's where the distraction factor can come in, too.
0:40:44Because you can find that if you can get the answer at a glance, then you don't unlock.
0:40:50And then once you've unlocked your phone, you almost forget why you got in there in the first place.
0:40:54Like, oh, let me go check over and mail.
0:40:56And then, you know, right?
0:40:58But you just get the answer there.
0:41:00And then you move on with your life.
0:41:01And we're certainly, with a lot of features, with Focus and many others,
0:41:06we're really trying to make sure that people have a healthy relationship with their devices.
0:41:11And I think actually putting the information you need at a glance right there
0:41:15is part of giving that balance.
0:41:18So let's go to the Mac.
0:41:22And I'll mention, I'm going to talk about a feature that I think I don't like.
0:41:27OK.
0:41:27Which is the reimagined system preferences to settings.
0:41:34Don't like the name?
0:41:35I also don't like the name.
0:41:42But I admit, though, that I have a propensity for nostalgia that probably would make me unsuitable
0:41:52for product marketing.
0:41:53But it's not just that the name changed.
0:42:01It is that what was system preferences has been reimagined to be more-- well,
0:42:07well, very much in line with settings on iOS and iPad OS.
0:42:11And I get it.
0:42:14It's first developer beta.
0:42:16But from what I saw of it yesterday, it looks like a step backwards.
0:42:21It looks like on the current Mac, trackpad preferences have this amazing video that
0:42:31it just shows you all the gestures you can do visually.
0:42:34And it looked to me, going through the new Mac settings app, that it's just all a bunch
0:42:39of checkboxes.
0:42:41Yeah.
0:42:42Well, on that front, I ought to say it is tough when we get judged by our betas.
0:42:46Because that one is coming, actually.
0:42:48That's a piece of work that we're absolutely--
0:42:49Me?
0:42:49Judge the betas?
0:42:50What?
0:42:53I didn't want to go there.
0:42:54But it is-- I can tell you.
0:42:58That's a case where we have a slightly different vision for those videos.
0:43:02We think we have something better, but they're not done being produced.
0:43:05So we didn't want to cram the old videos in.
0:43:07So we're going to have an experience that's richer there.
0:43:10But I think there is-- in terms of settings as a whole, and the transition from system
0:43:15preferences to settings, we have-- I think if you look at the origins of the Mac's original
0:43:24system, it was certainly, by and large, in an era where we weren't consuming as much
0:43:31content on the web, where scrolling to access content wasn't quite as common, and actually
0:43:39scrolling historically was even sort of harder and more tedious.
0:43:42Right.
0:43:42Click, click, click.
0:43:43And so the Mac existing settings, it's a carefully crafted set of intricate little
0:43:49bento boxes, and then nested drill into this panel to get this other panel to this other
0:43:54panel.
0:43:54And gosh, as we've been trying to build more and more experiences into the system, it's
0:43:59actually difficult to achieve clarity and simplicity within those constraints.
0:44:06And when we can do something that's much more scannable linearly, it's actually easier
0:44:14cognitively to take in something where the content scales much better.
0:44:20So you know I scroll down, and I can get to that.
0:44:23It-- I think it gives us and gives our design team something that's actually much more
0:44:30suited to the task.
0:44:31And it was actually a lot of craft-- and I think there's-- if it hasn't aired yet, it
0:44:35will-- a WWDC session where we even talk about the set of new control types that we
0:44:43introduced so that on the Mac we could achieve the right balance of something.
0:44:46The right kind of controls that weren't too heavy were very readable and scannable and
0:44:50yet clearly interactable.
0:44:52And so there was a lot of craft even just in all the right form elements to build a
0:44:57great experience there.
0:44:59So we're still going to be fine tuning the details here.
0:45:03But I think this is going to be a really good step for the Mac.
0:45:08And this was, I'll say, 100% not our driving motivation.
0:45:12Sometimes people worry, well, you've just taken what you did on iOS to the Mac.
0:45:15This was not the driving motivation.
0:45:17But the familiarity is also useful to people because they figure, well, I know how to get
0:45:25to my Wi-Fi settings over here.
0:45:26Now it's in a completely different place and rendered in a completely different way.
0:45:30The extent we can bring that kind of parallelism, I think that's a simpler system for many of
0:45:36our users to adjust to as well.
0:45:38So we think it's a better interface.
0:45:39We also think having consistency is very helpful here.
0:45:42You're very convincing.
0:45:46I think there's another you're right shit coming.
0:45:48[LAUGHTER]
0:45:49No catching in yet.
0:45:51No, sorry.
0:45:51Save it for next year.
0:45:54The next feature I wanted to talk about was stage manager, which really made me think.
0:46:03So let me get this out of the way.
0:46:05I don't-- I've never taken to Spaces.
0:46:07And I know other people-- I don't think Spaces is a bad feature.
0:46:10And I don't think I've ever claimed that it was.
0:46:12It just doesn't never fit my brain.
0:46:15I have at times had multiple monitors set up.
0:46:18And with two physical displays, I'll say, I'm going to put my email over here and messages,
0:46:24because that's like communication.
0:46:25And then everything else I'll do over on this one.
0:46:28And then that makes sense to me.
0:46:30But having one display where there's a space over here for-- and I know they're even arranged.
0:46:35It just never-- it never fit for me, because I think I need to actually see it.
0:46:40It needs to be-- it can't disappear for me.
0:46:42Or then it's disappeared from my brain.
0:46:43And what I really liked about stage manager, which I haven't tried but just saw the demo.
0:46:49But I like that you can still see-- everything is on screen.
0:46:54And I'm just curious what the thinking behind it is.
0:46:58Oh, yeah.
0:46:58No, stage manager-- I mean, it's funny.
0:47:00This one has been a passion project for a bunch of us for an incredibly long time.
0:47:06In fact, one of the key members of the team worked on what was in one of the
0:47:13earliest Mac OS X betas.
0:47:16There was a single window mode back then.
0:47:19And there was some thinking there.
0:47:20We're like, there's something there to have that idea that most of the time I can focus
0:47:24on one thing at a time but get at other things.
0:47:27Now, that had-- the animations were too much.
0:47:31And the accessibility to get at your things wasn't good enough.
0:47:34And we, over the years, keep coming back to how do we get to this idea.
0:47:40Because I do think-- I first want to make sure, and I think what you said with spaces
0:47:45was a really great thought.
0:47:48Because the Mac has a lot of different ways to manage--
0:47:52windowing is so important to the Mac experience.
0:47:55And the Mac provides so many different ways to do it.
0:47:57And if you surveyed everyone here in this audience and watched how they use their Mac,
0:48:02there are like 100 different patterns of interaction.
0:48:05And some people are going to use mission control all the time.
0:48:09And some people are going to be minimizing their windows.
0:48:12And some people are going to be using spaces.
0:48:16And some people are going to be Command-H hiding and then bringing them back.
0:48:19Some people use their docs.
0:48:21Some people are Command-Tabbers.
0:48:22Just an unbelievable set of different things.
0:48:25And to be clear, Stage Manager is not the one answer to end them all.
0:48:30I think many people will be very happy with their existing patterns.
0:48:35And we're not telling you you're doing it wrong.
0:48:37If you're happy with how things work for you, stick with that.
0:48:41But for many of us, there is this sense as we use the Mac in the normal way
0:48:50that the Mac experience is messy by default.
0:48:54You open one thing, and then you go to get the next thing.
0:48:57And it piles on top of that mess.
0:48:58And you go to the next thing, you pile on top of that mess.
0:49:00And so you're constantly either living in the mess
0:49:03or you're cleaning up after yourself constantly as you go.
0:49:07And for those of us that are switching between things,
0:49:09we're just switching between different piles of messes.
0:49:11And so when we came to an interface where we could focus on something one at a time,
0:49:16still have things accessible to us when we wanted them,
0:49:18and then create those kinds of,
0:49:21"Oh, I'm working on this note and this presentation at the same time.
0:49:24That I want to consider as a thing, make that a really easy thing to get into.
0:49:27Well, then I can switch to other tasks."
0:49:29It can be a great way to work.
0:49:30So I think it's going to be interesting to see during the betas
0:49:35which people sort of resonate with this idea and which ones say, "You know, it's not for me."
0:49:39But we know from those of us who've been living on it for months now
0:49:43that there's a group of us for which it is our favorite new way of working on the Mac.
0:49:49And we're going to continue to tune it.
0:49:51We know there's some ideas to tweak it over the summer.
0:49:56But overall, we're really happy with it.
0:49:59And then, of course, it was truly coincidental.
0:50:03I have to say that we found ourselves coming from a completely different direction with iPad
0:50:10and realizing they arrived at the same place.
0:50:15And it was almost weird when that happened.
0:50:17But we realized with iPad, you had what was a clean experience by default,
0:50:23single window at a time, but where you wanted to be able to bring in more,
0:50:27have more access to things, more multitasking.
0:50:30And so we were able to capture part of the spirit of the iPad and yet open it up
0:50:36in such a huge way to overlapping windows and that broader sense of access for multitasking.
0:50:42>> Right.
0:50:43Because one of the things that to me has always been missing with iPadOS multitasking
0:50:48is the concept of a stack.
0:50:51>> Yeah.
0:50:51>> Right?
0:50:52And you guys really did come up with some good ideas eventually for side by side.
0:50:59>> Yeah.
0:51:00>> Side by side arrangement of things.
0:51:02But even then, you lost that Z-axis of being able to stack a few things.
0:51:10And Stage Manager for iPad seems like it's a good way to bring some of that.
0:51:17And you get some layering, and you can have messages open with something else
0:51:22and pop one forward so that it doesn't have to be in a skinny column.
0:51:26It could overlap.
0:51:27And at the same time, not everybody has to do it.
0:51:29>> Right.
0:51:30Not everybody has to do it.
0:51:31Look, I expect there are a lot of iPad users--
0:51:34I mean, iPad has a phenomenally successful user experience that a lot of people can use
0:51:39from the moment they first touch their device.
0:51:41And they're 100% delighted with it.
0:51:44And that is totally cool with us.
0:51:45But increasingly, you have a group of people that are pushing it much more
0:51:50into different forms of productivity where they want a little bit richer experience.
0:51:56Maybe they want to use an external monitor.
0:51:58Maybe they're sitting down with a trackpad.
0:52:00And we think Stage Manager finds the right balance.
0:52:04And certainly, one of the things we've all experienced with the Mac with that Z order
0:52:08is sometimes I have the Notes window over here.
0:52:11And when I use it, I want it full width.
0:52:14I didn't want it tiled into a teeny column.
0:52:17And I wanted to be able to see it.
0:52:19And maybe I can even read some part of it I want to get at while still having my Safari window.
0:52:23Also, 3/4 of the screen wide.
0:52:27So that ability to have them both there, both completely accessible but not tiled,
0:52:32is something that's a really important part of the Mac experience.
0:52:38And we wanted to bring that to the iPad without losing the fact that the iPad is,
0:52:43by default, a very focused experience and one that's not-- you're not just accumulating a
0:52:50constant mess and having to actively worry about window management.
0:52:53And we feel like Stage Manager is a really wonderful balance there.
0:52:58Yeah, I completely agree about the iPad.
0:53:00Because I extended family members who aren't into computers for years now have thrived
0:53:08on their iPads in ways that they didn't with Macs going back to them.
0:53:12Not that they didn't like their Mac, but that they just do more and like it more.
0:53:18And they use it in a relatively simple way.
0:53:22But it's profound how much more they enjoy their computing experience on their iPad.
0:53:29And I do think that making it something that's not in your face all the time,
0:53:34you just-- if you want to use Stage Manager on an iPad, you can.
0:53:37I thought the funniest thing that my kids used to do when they were the age they were on that
0:53:43lock screen photo is I'd come down after they'd been using the Mac for a while.
0:53:47And I'd find all the windows had been dragged to the bottom like this much of the display.
0:53:54Because they just get rid of them by pushing them in a big pile down at the bottom.
0:53:59I'm like, well, that's window management.
0:54:00I'm going to steal this one from my pal Matthew Panzareno.
0:54:08But he had the observation that if Stage Manager for iPad OS had come out first,
0:54:16and maybe let's say like four to five years ago when there was more consternation in the community
0:54:22about is Apple committed to the Mac, that it would have been the cataclysm for people who
0:54:29had that fear.
0:54:30Because they would have said, here it is.
0:54:32They've added a feature to the iPad to enable people to do stuff like that on iPad.
0:54:39So the Mac is definitely dead.
0:54:41And I really-- I think it was a key observation.
0:54:45And I know that era drove you nuts, Jaws.
0:54:48What was this crazy false narrative that it was like, are you getting an iPad or a computer?
0:54:54People get both.
0:54:57It really is the reality that the majority of Mac customers have an iPad.
0:55:01And they use them both.
0:55:02You use them for the moment that best suits that tool.
0:55:08And we love that.
0:55:09And it's like this crazy thing that yeah, on top of it, so we were going to kill one of them.
0:55:13One of them was going to be--
0:55:14sacrificed.
0:55:15I just never quite could wrap my head around the thinking.
0:55:21Right.
0:55:23It was sort of just an assumption that of course they're going to kill one.
0:55:26So they're going to kill the older one.
0:55:28And that's it.
0:55:30And I think the other question is, why would they kill either of them?
0:55:33Right.
0:55:34Isn't the Renaissance of the Mac so awesome, though?
0:55:38It is incredible.
0:55:39And it is clearly--
0:55:42I think it started a little bit even before Apple Silicon.
0:55:45But clearly Apple Silicon for the Mac catapulted it, that Renaissance.
0:55:50And that is actually on my card.
0:55:52Apple doesn't care about the Mac.
0:55:54Well, that ended with the M1 Macs.
0:55:57Right?
0:55:57That's over.
0:55:57We did care about the Macs before.
0:56:05I know.
0:56:06But we--
0:56:06You called us out and told us.
0:56:09Yeah, we tried to tell you.
0:56:11But it is wonderful to be in--
0:56:13I mean, the conspiracy theory about us not doing that to iPad because--
0:56:17I don't know, to disturb Mac people or something.
0:56:19That was not what was going on.
0:56:20But it is wonderful to be in a time where the confidence of the community around the
0:56:26Mac is such that we can do whatever we want with the iPad now.
0:56:30And no one's going to be like, oh, but does this mean you don't care about the Mac?
0:56:34Like, no, no.
0:56:34The Mac, we can all feel very, very comfortable with our Macs.
0:56:37And by the way, the Mac, 38 years old.
0:56:41Still, about half the people who buy a Mac, it's their first Mac.
0:56:44Right?
0:56:45It's never done better.
0:56:46It's unbelievable.
0:56:48Competitors have come.
0:56:49Competitors have gone.
0:56:49And the Mac's never done better.
0:56:51And boy, people are happy with their Macs these days.
0:56:53And Apple Silicon's a part of it.
0:56:55Mac OS has always been there and a huge part of that experience that's just never been
0:57:00matched.
0:57:00And that's why so many of us-- look, I came to Apple a long time ago.
0:57:07And look, we came here because of the Mac.
0:57:08Right?
0:57:08And that's what was also-- really drove us nuts when this whole theory we're out to kill
0:57:12the Mac.
0:57:13The Mac, as we said, was in our DNA.
0:57:14Right?
0:57:15It's like, why we came here.
0:57:16It's like, we love the Mac.
0:57:17You'd have to pry it out of our hands.
0:57:20This idea that we were going to try to kill it was just repugnant.
0:57:23[LAUGHTER]
0:57:25I agree.
0:57:26So this leads me-- I'm doing well with my segues this year.
0:57:30[LAUGHTER]
0:57:33But this leads me to another big part of the keynote yesterday,
0:57:38which was gaming on the Mac.
0:57:40Because here's the one area.
0:57:42[APPLAUSE]
0:57:47Here's maybe the biggest area.
0:57:50Yeah, I think that might be safe to say.
0:57:52But certainly, I forget the exact numbers, but how much more money the video games industry
0:57:59makes than the movie industry.
0:58:01Hollywood.
0:58:01Yeah, Hollywood.
0:58:04The idea that Apple doesn't care about the fact that gaming on the Mac isn't as big as
0:58:11gaming on PC.
0:58:13And I thought that the messaging in the keynote yesterday is, oh, no, we care.
0:58:20We've been working on this.
0:58:22Yeah.
0:58:22Yeah, well, I mean, the move to Apple Silicon finally gave us control over the kind of graphics
0:58:32we've been wanting to put in Macs for a long time.
0:58:35And those are great gaming graphics.
0:58:38I mean, they're great for other parts of our experience.
0:58:40But for years and years, we've wanted to build Macs that are power efficient, that can be
0:58:47compact, and are also incredibly powerful for graphics.
0:58:51And to now have Apple Silicon, where every Mac we sell-- and we're now selling a lot
0:58:58more of them-- have awesome graphics, graphics capable of playing the best games, I think
0:59:06just changes the whole landscape if you're a game developer.
0:59:10And that would be true even if they were just looking at the Mac.
0:59:14But the fact that now, from a graphics platform point of view, you have M1 on the Macs, now
0:59:23M2, and you have M1 on the iPad, and you really have that same GPU architecture and that same
0:59:29software architecture with Metal extending all the way through all the iPads and to the
0:59:33phones for a game developer to target their engines, to take their titles, there is a
0:59:41huge opportunity that-- the playing field was a little rougher when we had a different mix
0:59:46of technologies in the Mac.
0:59:48Now we have awesome gaming machines, everyone we sell, and we're selling a lot of them,
0:59:53and we have the right software platform.
0:59:55So I think this is the time.
0:59:57And I think that there's clearly-- I mean, it's almost a statement of the obvious, but
1:00:02there's an economy of scale factor there, where even with the Mac selling better today
1:00:08than it ever has in 38 years, the Mac by itself is still a smaller segment of the PC industry.
1:00:18And the difference with Apple Silicon and with the Metal APIs that you guys have been
1:00:26evolving-- we're up to Metal 3 now, right?
1:00:28That's the new one that was new this week-- is the overall surface area of number of devices
1:00:39is on your side now, right?
1:00:42Where the number of devices that you could target with high-end graphics and the Metal
1:00:47APIs-- and this is where iOS's tremendous success can actually lift the Mac up in terms
1:00:56of--
1:00:56And what we've seen is as iPhone graphics have-- I mean, you just see the exponential
1:01:05chart there-- to the point where now game developers can bring their console engines
1:01:11to the iPhone.
1:01:13And so if they're bringing their console engines to the iPhone on Metal, will they now have
1:01:20their console engine on the Mac, effectively, right?
1:01:24So that investment, that effort pays off across the line now in a way it never has before.
1:01:30So the aggregate Apple platform for games is, I think, a phenomenal opportunity for developers,
1:01:37for game developers in particular.
1:01:39So I expect this to be an unprecedented time for gaming on the Mac in the coming years.
1:01:46>> I think that's going to make a lot of people very happy.
1:01:48>> For sure.
1:01:49>> I got a text from my son after the keynote.
1:01:54And it was one news story about-- I don't even know the details, but he's really into
1:01:59gaming.
1:02:00And he was like, hey, this is a big deal.
1:02:03Even AMD doesn't have this.
1:02:06And I don't know what it was.
1:02:07It was some specific thing.
1:02:08And I was like, oh, this is going to be-- I trust his judgment on it.
1:02:13>> OK.
1:02:14>> That's awesome.
1:02:14>> But you heard it here.
1:02:15>> Yeah.
1:02:16>> Yeah.
1:02:16>> The next author of Daring Fireball.
1:02:19>> Yeah, yeah.
1:02:20>> Yeah.
1:02:20>> It's going to have a very heavy games focus.
1:02:24[LAUGHTER]
1:02:28>> It's like one of those things, like, you know how in the old days, sometimes when the
1:02:32author of a daily comic strip would die or retire and their kids would take it over,
1:02:37you know, like Hagar the horrible or something.
1:02:39It'd be like, you know, if they had a totally different artistic style.
1:02:42[LAUGHTER]
1:02:45Shifting gears.
1:02:45I can't let this go without talking about CarPlay, which I thought was surprising.
1:02:52I was like, I can't believe that this is happening.
1:02:54I can't believe--
1:02:55>> A little bit of a sleeper hit yesterday.
1:02:56>> Yeah.
1:02:57It's like, you know, the original idea of CarPlay of-- obviously, if your music's on
1:03:05your phone and some of your other stuff is on the phone and there's a screen in the
1:03:09car, you want to be able to play your music through the car and you want to be able to,
1:03:13you know, do maps too, right?
1:03:15Maps and phone calls.
1:03:16But the idea that CarPlay is being extended to everything, speedometer, the amount of
1:03:26gas in your tank or power left in your battery, you know, the whole instrument panel,
1:03:31basically.
1:03:35And a lot of partners on that partner slide.
1:03:38I've got it on-- it's one of those ones where we at the media will snap pictures of
1:03:42those slides just to-- it's easier because that way we don't have to scrub through the
1:03:46video later to find them.
1:03:48A lot of partners.
1:03:48And also, to me, incredible numbers.
1:03:5498 or 97% of new cars sold in the US.
1:03:59I checked.
1:04:01I'm checking with someone who I thought would know.
1:04:04And to me, the more eye-opening number was that 79% of new car buyers in the US wouldn't
1:04:11consider a car without CarPlay.
1:04:13Am I putting it-- am I phrasing it right?
1:04:14You are exactly right, sir.
1:04:15Here's the thing that seems-- that seems incommensurate with market-- because we're
1:04:22talking about CarPlay specifically, which is iPhone specific.
1:04:27And that 79% does not seem commensurate with the market share numbers of--
1:04:33it is for new car buyers.
1:04:34That's really what it comes down to.
1:04:36Well, I thought it was that Android users knew they were going to eventually buy an
1:04:39iPhone.
1:04:39I've got to be making a long-term decision here.
1:04:43Think ahead.
1:04:45That's the long game right there.
1:04:46Yeah, no, it's amazing because we do have such amazing customers.
1:04:51And they are the overwhelming percentage of new car buyers in the US.
1:04:55And it's interesting you mentioned the partner chart because remember, we first launched
1:04:59CarPlay in 2013.
1:05:00I think we had like two partners.
1:05:02I forgot to mention that.
1:05:04Yeah, on that original slide.
1:05:05And we didn't bring it-- we didn't start getting announcements to the following year.
1:05:08And we got a lot more partners into it.
1:05:09But the world changed since 2013.
1:05:12Right?
1:05:12I mean, you're lucky if you had a display big enough for what we wanted to do with CarPlay.
1:05:17Now cars are full of displays and more complicated systems.
1:05:21And we needed a new generation of CarPlay that really could give you that better experience
1:05:29across all those displays and across all those systems.
1:05:31And we still want the car companies to be able to express their brands.
1:05:35Right?
1:05:36That's the important part too.
1:05:37This is a way that the iPhone and the car come together.
1:05:41So you still get that brand expression in these cars.
1:05:45But you get that iPhone feeling and then homogeneous experience.
1:05:49You don't need to jump out from your entertainment to go change the temperature
1:05:54or change the radio station.
1:05:55You can do it all within one system.
1:05:59And I think the automakers we've talked to see that their best customers are iPhone customers.
1:06:05Their CarPlay customers spend the vast majority of their time in CarPlay.
1:06:11It's what they want to use.
1:06:13And they know that their Apple customers want more of that experience.
1:06:19The seams between the CarPlay experience they love and the rest of the car are not
1:06:28serving their most important audience very well.
1:06:31And so we've been working with them to come up with this job.
1:06:34It says something allows them to express their brand still.
1:06:38And their customers know what car they bought.
1:06:42They want to see that it's that car.
1:06:45At the same time, they want a coherent experience across the whole thing.
1:06:50And so I think it's great for all involved.
1:06:56Apple is known, and I think you guys have often even said it in events,
1:07:02that for a year the mantra was only Apple.
1:07:07Only Apple can do certain things.
1:07:10Because you're known for controlling the whole widget.
1:07:14That you build the hardware, now even on the Mac, the silicon, and all of the software.
1:07:22And that the computer isn't hardware with software, or software that just happens to
1:07:28have hardware.
1:07:29You can't separate the two.
1:07:31It's like two sides of a coin.
1:07:32But how does CarPlay square with that?
1:07:36How does that work at Apple, where you're known for building the whole widget?
1:07:43And as far as I know, nobody's ever even suspected that you're building your own car.
1:07:47[LAUGHTER]
1:07:53And so it's sort of a pure software play at this point.
1:07:56I'm curious how you guys--
1:07:58[LAUGHTER]
1:08:00You got a snort out of Jaws there.
1:08:01You got a snort shit.
1:08:03[LAUGHTER]
1:08:11But you do seem to have the trust of a lot of car makers, or most car makers.
1:08:18Because that slide had an awful lot of--
1:08:21Well, they want to sell more cars.
1:08:22Right.
1:08:23And to Craig's point, customers like it.
1:08:25CarPlay has got extraordinarily high customer satisfaction.
1:08:28You saw the numbers, the 98%, the 79%.
1:08:30It's working.
1:08:31And we now even get to work actually better together with this next generation of CarPlay.
1:08:36Because again, they get to express their brand.
1:08:38That brand doesn't get expressed in today's CarPlay.
1:08:40They can actually express their brand in this new generation.
1:08:44I think everybody's very excited about that.
1:08:46Who wouldn't be?
1:08:48And again, the reaction yesterday was over the top.
1:08:50It's great.
1:08:50Lightning round.
1:08:52Pass key.
1:08:54Good.
1:08:56[LAUGHTER]
1:08:59I was going to say great, but all right.
1:09:01[LAUGHTER]
1:09:04Not quite that lightning.
1:09:05This is the talk show.
1:09:08But I remember it was probably over 10 years ago.
1:09:13But I was attending WWDC.
1:09:16And it was later in the week.
1:09:17I was with somebody and wound up going into a session on security.
1:09:22And it was really interesting.
1:09:24And it was so long ago that there were still Q&As at the end of the sessions.
1:09:28I mean, it's really--
1:09:29So people used to meet in person, you're saying?
1:09:33Yes.
1:09:33And at the end of the session on security, somebody asked.
1:09:37And the other thing that was really rare is that it was a really good question.
1:09:41[LAUGHTER]
1:09:43Because it was a question, not a story.
1:09:45And what he said was, as I tell a story.
1:09:47But what he asked was, have you guys given any thought to getting past passwords?
1:09:57Where maybe a lot of the session was about how to make passwords safer,
1:10:00and keychain features, and making passwords more.
1:10:05Have you given any thought to moving past passwords?
1:10:08Because passwords, no matter what you do, are going to leak.
1:10:12There's problems.
1:10:15And I don't know who that speaker was.
1:10:16But it might have been Ivan Kristik.
1:10:20Ivan Kristik.
1:10:21I think it might have been.
1:10:22And I think he was doing security at the time.
1:10:24But whoever it was, it was one of the greatest answers to a Q&A I've ever heard.
1:10:27The guy asked the question.
1:10:28And he looked.
1:10:29And then he looked down at his feed.
1:10:30Yes.
1:10:34[LAUGHTER]
1:10:37And everybody laughed.
1:10:38And because they got it.
1:10:39Because they're Apple developers.
1:10:40And they know, all right, he can't talk about it.
1:10:43But he realized he could say yes to that question.
1:10:46[LAUGHTER]
1:10:47Sounds like Ivan.
1:10:48But that's what PASC-Key is.
1:10:51It is about getting past the fundamental-- no matter what you do to protect passwords,
1:10:59it's a problematic concept.
1:11:02That's right.
1:11:03And you talked about long games.
1:11:06And this is certainly one where, in order to build to this place, you need to--
1:11:13I mean, the PASC-Keys are fundamentally distributing private-public-key pairs.
1:11:18You have a public key.
1:11:19What you give to a website is a public key.
1:11:22The private key that would be necessary to log in to that site never leaves your devices.
1:11:27But for that to be practical, you need a lot of things.
1:11:30You need that key to be able to move between your other devices.
1:11:33Because, of course, you want to be able to log in from everything.
1:11:36And so building something like iCloud Keychain,
1:11:39but also having that be something you could trust.
1:11:41You're not exposing your credentials to Apple,
1:11:43because that would then be another vulnerability.
1:11:46If our site could be breached, and your passwords could be read,
1:11:49or your PASC-Keys, rather, those private keys could be read, would be a problem.
1:11:52So we had to build all of that infrastructure.
1:11:54But it's also one where, for this to work,
1:11:56it had to be-- there had to be an interoperable industry standard.
1:12:02Because people are going to log in from--
1:12:04they're going to have a PASC--
1:12:04ultimately a PASC-Key that maybe they want to log into from their console--
1:12:09their gaming console or some account like that.
1:12:12You're going to need to be able to walk up to another PC
1:12:15and use your phone to hand off that credential.
1:12:17And so we've been working as part of the Fido Alliance
1:12:20with some other big platform players
1:12:22to make sure that this was the clear answer that all the websites would want to adopt.
1:12:28And it will take a while for them to do that adoption.
1:12:31But the only solution to passwords is getting rid of passwords.
1:12:36And this truly is the right answer.
1:12:38iCloud Private Relay, one of my favorite features announced last year.
1:12:43Still in beta, and we didn't hear anything about it this week,
1:12:49what's the status of iCloud Private Relay?
1:12:52We're still shipping and operating it.
1:12:54OK.
1:12:55But it's--
1:12:55Yeah, we love it.
1:12:57But do you think it's been a success a year in the field?
1:13:00Yeah.
1:13:01Yeah, I think compatibility has gotten really, really good too.
1:13:03Yeah.
1:13:04I think it's a great--
1:13:06Yeah, we weren't timing beta.
1:13:07The beta, non-beta-ness of it were not about the software that's shipping on devices.
1:13:16It's more about getting the compatibility in the community in the right place.
1:13:23And so the moment where it will become non-beta won't--
1:13:27WWDC wasn't really the moment for that kind of thing, given the nature of the--
1:13:30That's the moment to go into beta.
1:13:31Yeah.
1:13:34But I think we're all huge fans of the feature, and it's going very well.
1:13:39WeatherKit, we can go on and on.
1:13:42We're running short on time.
1:13:43But two things struck me about WeatherKit.
1:13:46One, when Apple acquired Dark Sky, I thought--
1:13:51in addition to being just plain useful, there's a privacy angle to this.
1:13:56And that weather-- because weather apps inherently need your location.
1:14:00And your location is inherently private.
1:14:02And there's this surprisingly shockingly enormous cottage industry of data brokers
1:14:09who specifically target just weather apps.
1:14:11I've talked to weather app developers, and they're like, you can't believe--
1:14:15I changed my email address because it's just filled up with these data brokers wanting
1:14:21to see if I'll sell my users' location data.
1:14:23Is that part of the thinking?
1:14:26Is that part of the privacy?
1:14:28Yeah, that's right.
1:14:28Yeah.
1:14:29And the other thing that I heard from developers yesterday, they couldn't believe the pricing,
1:14:33that it's like 500,000 API calls free.
1:14:37And then after that, the price is like half of what it was under Dark Sky, and more than
1:14:43just competitive with other weather sources.
1:14:46And I'm just curious how you see that.
1:14:51I think we clearly need to be regulated.
1:14:54[LAUGHTER]
1:14:57Oh, you were doing so well.
1:15:00I lost Joss.
1:15:01No, but I think it's great for our users.
1:15:03All right.
1:15:04All right, last question.
1:15:05Can't wait for that little clip.
1:15:10There was going to be an editing process here, wasn't there?
1:15:15We'll beep it out.
1:15:15I don't know.
1:15:2020, 25 years ago, I bought a goofy t-shirt, an 80s-style clip art of a couple of kids
1:15:26at an 80s-style generic PC.
1:15:29Like, maybe they were in school, and they're banging away at the keyboard.
1:15:34And the slogan on the t-shirt just said, like in a bubble font, "Computers are fun and
1:15:40useful."
1:15:41And I love that t-shirt.
1:15:43And I don't have it anymore, because I think I wore it so much, my wife threw it out.
1:15:46[LAUGHTER]
1:15:48But I've been thinking about it.
1:15:49I don't know why this year that phrase has been resonating to me.
1:15:55And the thing that really brought it to make me bring it up as the final question for you
1:16:00guys was that experience yesterday and Sunday with the developers from all around the world.
1:16:10And their enthusiasm to be back here in person and just excited to find out what's going
1:16:16to be in the keynote.
1:16:17What do you think is going to be in the keynote?
1:16:18What do you think is going to be in the keynote?
1:16:21In addition to the fact that computers are fun and useful, there's a certain type of
1:16:26person-- and it turns out there's a lot of them-- who particularly think Apple computers
1:16:34are fun and useful.
1:16:35And you said, that's why you came to work at Apple.
1:16:38You weren't looking for a job in the computer industry.
1:16:40You wanted to get a job at Apple.
1:16:42And there is no Plan B, because there was nothing else like the Mac.
1:16:46And just as a final question, I'm just wondering if you guys-- you decide who goes first.
1:16:53But when was the first time, way back when, when it hit you that Apple computers are different
1:17:01and that you fell in love with them?
1:17:04Well, I'm really going to date myself.
1:17:06So I'm older than Craig, so maybe I'll go first.
1:17:07My first Apple that I used was a Lisa.
1:17:11And I went to University of Michigan, and they invested big in Lisa's.
1:17:15We had Lisa's everywhere.
1:17:17They were like $15,000 or something.
1:17:18Yeah, and we had a lot of them.
1:17:20We're probably-- I don't know if we were the largest customer for Lisa's, but we had a
1:17:23lot of them.
1:17:24And boy, I did everything.
1:17:25I was like, this is unbelievable.
1:17:27And again, I'd use, obviously, PCs and everything, the old stuff.
1:17:33My Commodore 64 was my first thing.
1:17:34And I was like, wow, this is unbelievable.
1:17:36But then I do remember being a little pea because the Lisa's went away.
1:17:40And here was this little thing called the Mac.
1:17:45And all of a sudden, it became pretty cool.
1:17:49And without going through my whole history, I just became addicted to it.
1:17:54Well, that's probably the wrong word to use.
1:17:56Very closely associated with it.
1:18:00And started working at the University of Michigan in the computer lab and really becoming the
1:18:07Mac expert.
1:18:08And to your point, then, that led to having to be here.
1:18:12And I've always said to people, I couldn't imagine doing my job anywhere else because
1:18:20of that hardware and software, that integration that allows us to-- I always tell people,
1:18:27look, there's a small list of world-class hardware providers.
1:18:30We're on it.
1:18:32There's a small list of world-class software providers.
1:18:35We're on it.
1:18:35We're the only companies really both.
1:18:37Right?
1:18:37And what that means is instead of having different companies with different agendas, we
1:18:42control it all.
1:18:43As you said, the whole widget.
1:18:45So I said, if we can imagine it, we really can create it here.
1:18:49Right?
1:18:49And we can do a pretty good job creating it.
1:18:52And I just couldn't imagine trying to do what I do or what we do at any of our competitors.
1:18:58It would be very frustrating.
1:18:59Right?
1:19:00But instead, it's very rewarding to do what we do and have days like yesterday and talk
1:19:04about this sort of stuff.
1:19:05I just-- yeah.
1:19:06That's why I'm here 36 years later.
1:19:08So--
1:19:10Yeah, my story doesn't involve the Lisa, but it's not so different.
1:19:17When I was 10, my first exposure to a computer was an Apple II Plus.
1:19:20And it just-- that was really-- it was less about what the Apple represented at that time.
1:19:28It was more at that moment about what computers represented.
1:19:31And it just set off fireworks.
1:19:33I mean, that was it.
1:19:34I knew from that moment forward this is what I wanted to do.
1:19:37But it was when the Mac came out in 1984.
1:19:41And I had my dad's friend-- I think it was 14 or something at the time.
1:19:44My dad's friend had been given one to evaluate.
1:19:47And he gave it to me-- he didn't give it to me.
1:19:49He lent it to me for a while.
1:19:50And it was at that time that I said to myself, I must work at Apple someday.
1:19:58And it was-- my thought was I wanted to be among the people who could build such a thing.
1:20:07And who had the care and the skill to create something like this.
1:20:15I mean, it was so eye-opening about what this technology that I had fallen in love with,
1:20:22how it could be harnessed and what it could mean.
1:20:26And I was not disappointed to find who those people were when I was finally amongst them.
1:20:34And that is beyond these walls.
1:20:38I mean, that is this community.
1:20:40I think that's what's special.
1:20:42I think that's why the people-- why the developers want to come here,
1:20:45because they share that affinity not just with us, but with each other.
1:20:49There's other companies that have developer conferences.
1:20:53I can't imagine another one that would have had the feeling of this year's.
1:20:58And again, I can't reiterate enough.
1:21:00I really do think that this is going to go down as the best WWDC ever.
1:21:05Not because you can't do better stuff or have a better presentation later,
1:21:10but that hopefully we're never going to have one after two years like we just had,
1:21:15where there's this pent-up emotion.
1:21:18A pent-up desire to connect.
1:21:20Yeah.
1:21:21Yeah.
1:21:22And amongst like-minded people who all see the same thing,
1:21:28why would you build an app only for the iPhone?
1:21:30Instead of going cross-platform, you can double your market share or whatever.
1:21:35But it's like the developers who are here are the ones who see like,
1:21:41yeah, because I want to go all in and make it as good as Apple's software.
1:21:47And the only way to do that is to be native to the platform
1:21:50and do things the right way for the platform.
1:21:53And anyway, those were good answers.
1:21:58I really enjoyed that.
1:21:59And it sort of brings us to the end.
1:22:01People I need to thank.
1:22:04First, I want to thank everybody here in the audience.
1:22:07[APPLAUSE]
1:22:14It will never get old to me that people scoop up these tickets as fast as they can.
1:22:23It is an incredible privilege.
1:22:25I heard they're going for like $2,000.
1:22:27Did you sell yours?
1:22:30Because you didn't need it.
1:22:33No one wanted mine.
1:22:34I also want to thank Apple itself.
1:22:40This is in Apple's building.
1:22:43There's Apple people doing-- who have helped me in ways that it would take another hour
1:22:50to talk about all the ways that it was helped.
1:22:52And it means a lot to me.
1:22:54It's my show.
1:22:55But this year, I really couldn't have done it without Apple.
1:22:59And I truly appreciate that, too.
1:23:01[APPLAUSE]
1:23:07I want to thank Sandwich.
1:23:08They've been editing the show for the last few years and doing a phenomenal job.
1:23:14Claude Zines from Sandwich is here.
1:23:21He is going to scoop up this footage from these amazing cameras and put them on a hard
1:23:25drive and start editing it on the way back to Los Angeles after we wrap.
1:23:30So there's a few hundred of you listening to me right now.
1:23:35And someday, there's going to be thousands of people watching this on YouTube.
1:23:39All of you watching on YouTube, my thanks to Sandwich is for you.
1:23:43And again, I don't know what I would do without Sandwich's help to do this show.
1:23:47I don't really have a plan B for producing video.
1:23:51I want to thank my family.
1:23:58I want to thank my wife and son.
1:23:59I think that says it all.
1:24:10[APPLAUSE]
1:24:17The last two years have been hard.
1:24:21And I couldn't pick two better people to go through those years than my wife, Amy, and
1:24:26my son, Jonas.
1:24:27He's graduating high school Saturday.
1:24:31And I'm so proud of him.
1:24:32[APPLAUSE]
1:24:41And I want to thank Craig and Jaws.
1:24:44Thank you for being here again.
1:24:46Thank you for having us.
1:24:47Thank you.
1:24:47Hopefully, see you next year.
1:24:49[APPLAUSE]
1:24:59[END]
1:25:09[ Applause ]
1:25:11[ Silence ]