0:00:00I'm so excited to have you here. You have a brand new game out called NotWords, and
0:00:04I'll just say this once because on a podcast it's often difficult. It's cannot words.
0:00:08Yes, with a K. But you have made a slew of games over the
0:00:13years. I think not not entirely and and I'll just say not words is also available for Mac
0:00:19and PC on Steam. It is on iOS, of course, in the App Store and it's also on Android
0:00:24Play right there on day one launched last week, but let's just talk let's run through
0:00:29some of the games that you have made over the years. I'll just start with I'll tell
0:00:34you I'll just be upfront. My favorite Zach Gage game is really bad chess.
0:00:39Oh, thank you. Which I want to talk about specifically later,
0:00:43but tell me some of the other games. Tell us some of the games that you've.
0:00:46Oh gosh, there are a lot. I tend to try to make games that are a twist on traditional
0:00:52game genres and traditional game literacy so that they're more approachable to most
0:00:59human beings and not just video game people. So really bad chess. I made a couple solitaires,
0:01:04flip flop solitaire, sage solitaire. Pocket Run Pool is a billiards game. Spell Tower,
0:01:10Type Shift, or other word games. I did Ridiculous Fishing, which was an Apple game of the year
0:01:15and Apple award winner. And then I have a bunch of older, more art related stuff and
0:01:20little games that got destroyed in the 32 bit apocalypse.
0:01:24We should talk about that. I'm going to make a note for that. But Ridiculous Fishing is
0:01:27one that I have. As soon as you said it, it was one of those things where I got like a
0:01:34dopamine hit from my brain where my brain was like, you should go play Ridiculous Fishing.
0:01:39Because that was another one that was an all time favorite. Can you describe it for people
0:01:43who didn't don't remember it? I mean, when did that come out? That was pretty early,
0:01:47right? In the iPhone era.
0:01:49Yeah, I want to... boy, I should probably... I have a really bad memory for dates and names,
0:01:55but I think it was either 2012 or 2011. It's pretty old. Yeah, it was a collaboration with
0:02:02Vlambeer and Greg Wolwind, and we were making basically a sequel to another Vlambeer game
0:02:07called Radical Fishing. And it's kind of an absurdist fishing game where you try to get
0:02:13a hook as low as possible, and by dodging all the fish, and then when you come up, you
0:02:19try to catch as many of the fish as possible, and then when it hits the surface, all the
0:02:22fish get flung into the air, and then you shoot them with uzis and machine guns and
0:02:27rocket launchers.
0:02:30It was... is... does it still work? Is that one of the games that's been axed by the apocalypse?
0:02:35It hasn't been axed, but it doesn't work on a lot of the newer phone sizes, but we're
0:02:41sort of hopeful that we'll get it working again sometime soon in the future, because
0:02:45we all sort of really miss it being playable.
0:02:48One of the things that Ridiculous Fishing that struck me as... I am not a game designer
0:02:55at all, but I'm definitely a UI designer, and I think about form and structure and input,
0:03:05and it was a great game for the phone. Like, to me, that was sort of the... in the early
0:03:14days of the iPhone, and then Android, you know, once Android became very iPhone-ish,
0:03:21there was clearly an enormous opportunity for games, because we had these amazingly
0:03:26powerful computers in our pockets with beautiful color screens, right? And, you know, by a
0:03:34certain standard, like, the worst Android... like, when Android first started playing around
0:03:38with OLED screens in the early 2010s, and some of them had some really wonky colors
0:03:44for like, in the, like, the cyans and reds, the magentas... Even then, even by that standard
0:03:51though, by the history of video games, these were great screens where you could do really
0:03:56colorful stuff if you wanted to, but the controls were so limited, right? What do you do? Like,
0:04:03it was such a breakthrough when Steve Jobs and Apple introduced the original iPhone,
0:04:08and it's like... and they said, "Look, all these other phones, like Blackberries, have
0:04:11these keyboards and all these buttons and D-pads and all this stuff, and it takes up
0:04:16all this space, and then what if you come up with an idea that these controls don't
0:04:21work well with?" Well, we know the answer to that. It's called software. What if we
0:04:25just made everything software and just put it, you know, just make it a big screen? Great
0:04:28idea! But really, not great for games, as games had been known to be, as games had been
0:04:36known to be up until 2007, right? Yeah. Well, I think that's actually... that's how I ended
0:04:42up being excited to work on the iPhone, was, like, I came out of doing interactive art
0:04:50and interactive technology, and so the idea that there was this screen that used a mechanic
0:04:58that nothing had ever used, that, like, I could be the first person to make a game in
0:05:02a certain style that played with multi-touch was, like, really interesting and intoxicating,
0:05:07and it felt like just a thrilling space to be. Because, you know, if you're making a
0:05:11game for an Xbox, you have the controller that all the other games use, and, you know,
0:05:19almost every game you make is saddled with all of the expectations that players have
0:05:24for how they're going to interact with it. And so that component, that sort of narrow
0:05:29slice of game design, which is the interactive part, is just not present for a lot of game
0:05:36design on those consoles. Whereas with a multi-touch screen, at the beginning of the App Store,
0:05:41when there were no multi-touch games, no one had figured out how to make games work on
0:05:44this kind of screen, you got to spend a lot of time really thinking about, "Well, how
0:05:49does someone even interact with this? What is this able to do? How can we make games
0:05:54that operate on this? We don't have buttons anymore. What do we do?" And so, originally,
0:05:59what actually got me interested in doing games was my wife, my girlfriend at the time, had
0:06:05an iPhone touch and she downloaded Tetris. And I don't know if you remember the original
0:06:09Tetris on the iPhone, but it was like horrible.
0:06:11I do. Because I love Tetris as one of my all-time favorite games. I just love it. And it was
0:06:19-- and honestly, to this day, it's still terrible on the phone.
0:06:23Yeah, because, well, because Tetris is a game about buttons. It's like one of the things
0:06:27that's beautiful about it is how much it celebrates buttons and the sort of simplicity and elegance
0:06:33of its input with buttons. And it just didn't work on the phone, and I was like, "Oh my
0:06:37God, this is what games are right now? This is the games people are coming out with? Like,
0:06:41I just got out of grad school, but like, I think I can make something better than this."
0:06:45And so I started exploring and working in that space, and I met Lanbir, who had done
0:06:52Radical Fishing, and I saw it and I played it, and I was like, "Oh my God, this could
0:06:55be amazing on a phone. This is exactly the game. The shooting and touching would be perfect.
0:07:01Using tilt for the movement would be perfect." So I kind of approached them and talked with
0:07:07my friend Greg, and we convinced them that this would be this really awesome game if
0:07:10we could do it.
0:07:11I'm out of my league talking about old Nintendo stuff, because I was more of a Sega Genesis
0:07:16-- well, definitely way, way more. But I always thought that one of the things -- I never
0:07:21actually owned a Game Boy back in the day, but I was always very tempted. And honestly,
0:07:27I would have just glued the Tetris cartridge in. It would have been fine. I would have
0:07:31just bought the Game Boy and just put the Tetris cartridge in. But one of the things
0:07:34that always struck me, and I had plenty of friends who had one, so I knew to play it,
0:07:38but Tetris was so perfect for Game Boy, because Game Boy -- to me, a D-pad isn't -- it is
0:07:47what it is. It's not bad, it's not necessarily good, but a D-pad is buttons as opposed to
0:07:52a stick. And it's not a joystick like from my youth of an Atari 2600, and like the modern
0:08:01Xbox PlayStation-style controllers where you have these thumbsticks. And I understand you,
0:08:06you need the thumbstick for some games, because you need to not just say "up," but "up" a little,
0:08:12like I'm creeping forward or I'm pushing forward. Whereas Tetris, it's left, right, rotate, drop.
0:08:20Buttons are perfect for that. And a black and white screen was fine. It was, if anything,
0:08:26in my opinion, maybe better. It's more pure. It was just a perfect combination of concept
0:08:31to device. I used to play -- when I was in high school, one of my best friends and I
0:08:37would go to the local coin-operated arcade. Among the games we'd play was we'd spend quarters
0:08:42on Tetris. And people would be like, "Why are you wasting money on Tetris when you can
0:08:45play Tetris at home?" And we're like, "Yeah, but this is a really good Tetris."
0:08:50[laughter]
0:08:51Yeah, I mean, I have played Tetris with a joystick, and it is thrilling also with a
0:08:56joystick. But I do totally agree with you about the D-pad. It is perfect. And actually,
0:09:00there's a device that came out recently called the Analog Pocket, which is like a performance
0:09:05Game Boy kind of. And my wife and I got them, and we've been playing a lot of Tetris on
0:09:09it, and it's really rekindled a lot of my memories of Tetris on the Game Boy. And I
0:09:14think, you know, there's more to it than just the buttons in the Game Boy and the black
0:09:18and white. It's also that the Game Boy was such a forerunner of this idea of a game that
0:09:23you had in your pocket that you could take out and play for just a small amount of time.
0:09:28And this idea that you could hook it up to a friend's Game Boy, and then you could play
0:09:32Tetris against each other. It was like the whole context of the Game Boy was just perfect
0:09:37for Tetris in this way that not a lot of other things were. I mean, you talk about playing
0:09:41it at the arcade or playing it at home. The Game Boy was both, right? You could play it
0:09:45in bed, you could play it at school, you could play it with your friends. It kind of had
0:09:50all of those things.
0:09:51You could play it on the bus or the subway.
0:09:53Yeah.
0:09:54Or the car.
0:09:55You could play it while you were waiting in line to play Tetris at the arcade.
0:09:58It's probably the single greatest thing that ever happened to the backseat of a family
0:10:03car.
0:10:04Absolutely.
0:10:05Because you couldn't read in the backseat of a car because the movement of the car,
0:10:10it's too much, but you could definitely play a Game Boy. But anyway, back to Ridiculous
0:10:14Fishing, the one thing that struck me so great, in addition to the fact that the controls
0:10:19were perfect, it wasn't like, "Oh man, I really wish I had physical buttons." It was like,
0:10:24"No, you don't need physical buttons for this game." It's not like, "What was that game?"
0:10:28It was like in the initial, the very initial release of the App Store, it was like a Sega
0:10:34game like Infinite Runner down like on a roller coaster track. I don't know. But it was a
0:10:41fake D-pad game.
0:10:43There were so many of those.
0:10:46Yeah. And so many of the initial games, too, made you rotate the phone, which isn't necessarily
0:10:52bad. There's some great phone games where you play them horizontally as opposed to vertically.
0:10:56But Ridiculous Fishing was meant to be vertical because you drop the hook down. So having
0:11:03a screen that was vertically oriented is optimal for the concept because you want to go deep
0:11:11and down, and therefore holding the phone in the natural way, which is vertical, it
0:11:17fit in a way where you'd never make that game for a widescreen TV.
0:11:22Right. Right. Or you'd have to change a lot.
0:11:27Right. I should never have used the word "never" there because you're a creative game designer
0:11:33and it's instantly going to start your brain turning and you're thinking, "Well, wait a
0:11:37second." Yeah, you could make it like fly fishing where you go sideways or something
0:11:41like that.
0:11:42Yeah, or you just rotate your whole TV, you know, just get people to rotate. You should
0:11:46sell TV stands to come with the game.
0:11:49But that was a great game. That really was. And it's just so much fun. Now, let's talk
0:11:55about how you got into game design. I guess we'll sort of go in chronological order, but
0:12:01I might as well take a break and thank our first friend of the show, and it's our good
0:12:07friends at Kolide. They spell it K-O-L-I-D-E, Kolide. And me, like an idiot, the first couple
0:12:13of times they sponsored the podcast, I said Kolide because I thought, "Well, if they spell
0:12:17it weird, maybe it's pronounced weird." But then after like two episodes, I asked them
0:12:21and they very politely said, "No, we just say Kolide." And I was like, "Oh, sorry." And they
0:12:26were like, "No, we laughed." But Kolide is a great company. They have a new take on
0:12:31endpoint management that asks, "How can we get end users more involved?" Look, most places
0:12:38that use MDM try to lock down their employees' devices without considering the employees'
0:12:43needs or even attempting to educate them about the security of their laptop. Kolide is built
0:12:50by like-minded security practitioners who saw past this whole problem and realized that
0:12:56MDM was disrupting their end users, often frustrating them so badly that they'd just
0:13:01throw up their hands and switch to using their personal laptops without telling anyone, which
0:13:06defeats the whole purpose of using MDM to protect your company's stuff and to try to
0:13:12keep your employees' information and the company information that employees are using safe.
0:13:17So instead of locking down a device, Kolide takes a user-focused approach that communicates
0:13:21security recommendations to your employees directly on Slack. You're already using Slack.
0:13:28You sign up for Kolide. You get your devices on Kolide, your employees' devices on Kolide.
0:13:32And when there's advice or recommendations or notifications that come in, they just come
0:13:36in over Slack, something they already are using, so you're not asking them to install
0:13:42something else that's going to give them notifications from work. It's already a system where they're
0:13:47communicating and getting notifications for work-related stuff. And it can range from
0:13:53simple problems like, "Hey, the screen lock is not set up correctly," or hard to solve
0:14:00and nuanced issues like asking people to secure two-factor backup codes that are sitting in
0:14:06their downloads folder or something like that and ask them to secure those properly. Because
0:14:12it's talking directly to employees, Kolide is educating them about the company's policies
0:14:17and how to best keep their devices secure using real, tangible examples, not theoretical
0:14:23scenarios. The bottom line is they really do want to keep stuff secure, but they want
0:14:28to do it in a way that is friction-free for your employees and makes them happy and educates
0:14:35them, which is all just like a virtuous circle that just keeps things going, keeps people
0:14:40happy and keeps devices and information more secure. So that's Kolide. Cross-platform endpoint
0:14:46management for Linux, Mac, and Windows devices that puts end users first for teams that slack.
0:14:52Visit kolide, K-O-L-I-D-E, kolide.com/the-talk-show to learn more and activate a free 14-day trial.
0:15:00Enter your email when prompted to receive your free Kolide gift bundle after trial activation.
0:15:06No credit card required. You can try it for 14 days. See how good it is at kolide.com/the-talk-show.
0:15:15How and when did you get started doing game design?
0:15:17Oh my gosh, well, to some extent, you know, when I was a kid, I guess I really wanted
0:15:23to be a game designer. Growing up on Mac, it was really interesting because almost everything
0:15:29I played was shareware that was by developers. And so, unlike a lot of my friends who were
0:15:34playing Nintendo games or Xbox games or, well, I guess not Xbox at the time, PlayStation,
0:15:39where these games are made by giant companies, I was playing games that were made by developers
0:15:44who you could email and interact with and write. And so I got interested in this idea
0:15:49of making games, and I used -- the first thing I really got into was Hyper Studio, which
0:15:55was like a color and multimedia version of HyperCard. And then I got into this thing
0:16:01called Coco, which was like a bespoke educational tool that Apple put out before Jobs came back
0:16:07and axed all of the educational stuff and weird little side hobbies that had been going
0:16:14on at Apple to focus on one thing.
0:16:16And to be clear, I don't want to interrupt you, but to be clear, this was a Coco that
0:16:20is completely unrelated. Among the other things Steve Jobs did is completely reuse the name
0:16:26Coco for something entirely different. Okay.
0:16:28Apparently such a good name that it had to come back. Yeah, so I was making games in
0:16:33that, and then I went to high school and learned how to program and thought I was going to
0:16:39be someone making games, and then I went to college and I went to Skidmore College, which
0:16:44is a wonderful school, and they have a really incredible art program and a really lacking
0:16:49computer science program, or at least they did when I was there. So I dropped computer
0:16:53science entirely and basically went hard into being a fine artist and learning how to paint
0:17:00and draw and sculpt really poorly and do all the things that fine artists do. I got really
0:17:05into photography and design. And then when it was coming up to the end of the year, or
0:17:10to the end of my time at college and I had to do an end-of-year show, I thought back
0:17:14on a lot of the things that had been inspiring to me in high school artistically, like preystation.com
0:17:20and a lot of early -- Jared Tarbell -- a lot of early flash experiments, and around this
0:17:24time processing.org was going on. And I realized, like, oh, I have this programming background.
0:17:30I can do these kinds of interactive things that a lot of my classmates don't know how
0:17:35to do, and what if I tried to create art using these skills? So I started doing that, and
0:17:42I got out of school and I came to New York and I met up with this artist, Zach Lieberman,
0:17:48who ran something called Open Frameworks, which is sort of a C++ version of Processing. It's
0:17:53like a creative coding library for C++. And through him, I did a lot of work in Open Frameworks
0:18:01and creating interactive artwork, and I went to Parsons and met some games people there,
0:18:07and that's sort of where I started working with the iPhone and making some games. And
0:18:12I fell in love with the phone and I fell in love with the games community, because at
0:18:16that time it was really small and it was just 100% incredible geniuses. You'd go to a conference
0:18:24and every single person I met in 2007 is basically a famous indie developer now, and it was just
0:18:30an incredible thrilling experience to be surrounded by so many incredibly talented people, and
0:18:35I just got sucked into games that I've been making games ever since.
0:18:39There's like a certain type of personality that is drawn to a new frontier, when it's
0:18:43like this great unknown. Instead of being terrifying or feeling lost or just standing
0:18:49at the edge and looking at it, they're like, "Oh, I need to go out there and just start
0:18:54exploring. This is fantastic, because there's no preconceptions as to what it could be."
0:19:00And then there was no money. So it was just people who were like, "I have a thing that
0:19:06I need to get out and explain to people and show people, and I'm going to do it, and hopefully
0:19:13you'll really enjoy it." And so it was just super highly motivated, incredibly talented
0:19:18artists.
0:19:19From my perspective, that's sort of like the early years of blogging, where the idea that
0:19:25you, a writer or somebody who just wants to post things regularly to your own website
0:19:30under your own name, you just do it, and nobody really even knew what it should look like.
0:19:37What order should things show up in? Should they just all show up on the homepage? What
0:19:40should they do? And again, no money in it at all. Nobody even had any ideas for how
0:19:45to make money, which was kind of, you know, it never lasts. We'll get there talking about
0:19:52games. It never lasts, but it is fun at the beginning.
0:19:55Yeah, it's been one of the most interesting things for me, having gone through the career
0:20:00that I've had, is being able to see a bubble and ride it and see the end of it and see
0:20:06what comes out of it. Having gotten to spend 10 years experiencing that, I feel very lucky
0:20:12to have that kind of perspective now.
0:20:15What was the first iPhone game that you had that hit the App Store?
0:20:21So the first app I ever made was something called Synth Pond, which, given my light lisp,
0:20:27I really regret naming a game that. It's impossible to say. But that was a sound toy, I guess.
0:20:35I was really inspired by people like Toshio Iwai and the other sort of experimental audio
0:20:42toys, and so Synth Pond was a spatial sequencer. I feel like I really love music, but I'm not
0:20:49able to understand music. I can't create music the way that everybody else can. It just doesn't
0:20:55work for the way that my brain works. And so this was more of thinking about, well,
0:21:01what if it was a tool for spatial people, for people who think in a spatial sense? So
0:21:07it was all about laying down nodes that would reverberate a sound, and then when that sound
0:21:12hit other nodes, they would respond with sounds. It was basically this tool that, instead of
0:21:17composing in a sequence, it let you compose in a space. And it was something that I had
0:21:22made on the computer and put out on my website as just something you could download on the
0:21:26Mac. And I was probably getting like 200 hits a day on my website at that point, but nobody
0:21:32ever wrote me or talked about this thing. And then the iPhone came out and I thought,
0:21:37"Oh, this is like a really cool device for this. Maybe I could make this experience on
0:21:42this." And I had all these ideas about how to use the multi-touch to, you know, you grab
0:21:46one thing and hit something else and that lets you change the node. So I was really
0:21:50excited and I built it and I put it out and it got covered on MacRumors and it made like
0:21:57$20,000 and people were writing me emails and thanking me for coming up with this cool
0:22:02idea. And one of the musicians of Dream Theater, who's like a pretty big metal band, wrote
0:22:10me and I got to go to the studio and hang out with him and we had lunch and talked about
0:22:15all this stuff. And I was just like, "What is this place? What is this device in this
0:22:22app store that I can just put this thing out there and that nobody cared about on the web
0:22:27but here it's making me money and it's finding an audience and I'm getting contacted and
0:22:32people are thanking me for being able to buy this thing?" It was just such a mind-blowing
0:22:37moment.
0:22:38Not to go off on a tangent, but there's a new book out, Beyond Steve, I think by Tripp
0:22:42Meckl. It just came out this week. The New York Times had an excerpt over the weekend
0:22:45and it seems like I haven't read the book yet, but I haven't, but it's sort of things
0:22:50aren't the same without Steve Jobs. And if things had gone better after Steve Jobs died,
0:22:56Apple would have come up with another thing like the iPhone since. And there've been a
0:23:02series of books like that since he died and I think a lot of them have fared very poorly.
0:23:07I'm curious about how this one goes because it's written a whole decade afterwards and
0:23:12so therefore it's not quite so much a prediction but more a reporting about what did happen.
0:23:17But my fundamental theory about why phones are such a hit is—and I don't think Apple
0:23:24knew this before the iPhone came out—I think they knew they had something great. And when
0:23:29Steve Jobs just showed it to people at that Macworld keynote, those were like the longest
0:23:34six months of our lives waiting to actually get it. Because there was something obvious
0:23:40like "Oh my god, I need to have that." But I think ultimately what the phones are is
0:23:46that it's the endpoint of personal computers. And it's like personal computers came out
0:23:53in the late 70s and Apple was there with the Apple II and then the Mac came out in the
0:23:5980s and things evolved and Windows obviously became this huge, huge hit for literally billions
0:24:06of people around the world on PCs. But it's like with the phones and everything about
0:24:13them, the size, the fact that they're always with you, the way that you can't screw them
0:24:19up as a typical user, there's nothing you can do to screw up an iPhone. You cannot—you
0:24:26can't make a mistake and "Oh, you should not have installed that game because that
0:24:31game puts like a background agent in and that thing will—it just runs all the time and
0:24:35it's really hard to uninstall." You can't do anything like that. It's like for so long
0:24:41before the internet, all of us who were into computers were like, "Why aren't more people
0:24:45into computers?" Like the Macintosh slogan was "The computer for the rest of us." And
0:24:48it did expand computing to more people who just were turned off by the command line computers
0:24:55that came before it and like, "I don't—you know, this is gibberish. This is not for me."
0:24:59It definitely expanded it, especially for artists, I think, the way that the whole design
0:25:05industry from education, from colleges on up, revolutionized itself in short order.
0:25:12In hindsight, it's kind of bananas. Companies and industries don't just change from "This
0:25:18is the way we've always done things" to "Oh, we're going to throw it all out and we're going
0:25:22to do everything in Quirk Express or PageMaker for layout and we're going to use Illustrator
0:25:28for all of our vector—or Freehand, which I was actually more of a fan of—for all
0:25:33of our vector art and Photoshop, and we're going to do everything on the computer."
0:25:38And until like 1986, nothing was done on a computer. And by 1990, everything was done
0:25:43on a computer. It's kind of bananas, but it did expand it. But it's like the rest of us
0:25:49were like, "Why don't people want to use computers?" And then the internet came and it's like, "Oh,
0:25:53communication. That's what real people want to do on computers." And then the phones came
0:25:58and it's like, "Oh, here's a computer you can't mess up. It's great for communication,
0:26:02and it's with you all the time." And boom, that's it. And that's why there hasn't been
0:26:08a thing since. There never will be a thing after that. There is no way to make it more
0:26:13portable, more accessible, more with you. There is nothing after that.
0:26:18I think what you just said with the portable and with you is also like a really critical
0:26:25thing for the phone. And one of the things that's most exciting for me about making games
0:26:30on the phone is I love making games for the context that the phone exists in, which is
0:26:35it's in your pocket, you're in line, you pull it out, you do something for 30 seconds, you
0:26:39put it back. Or it's in your pocket, you're watching TV, you pull it out and you do this
0:26:43thing on the side while you're watching TV. That's this completely different context than
0:26:48most games exist in, and it's a completely different computing context than computers
0:26:53existed in beforehand. And I think this is something that right now, if you look at VR
0:26:58and the struggles that VR has had gaining any kind of consumer traction, I think to
0:27:04me it really mirrors a lot of that earlier computer stuff, which is people don't want
0:27:09to take a break from their lives and use a computer. Some people do, people who love
0:27:14computers, but most people just want to live their lives. And if they can have a computer
0:27:19that's with them and does stuff, that's awesome. And the iPhone was the first time that really
0:27:24most of the world got to have a computer that was just with them where they could have their
0:27:30normal life and integrate a computer into that.
0:27:33Yeah, I agree completely. And it's obvious in hindsight, and it's so obvious in hindsight
0:27:39that I think it gets taken for granted, but it wasn't obvious at the time. And I think
0:27:45even Apple wasn't sure. You know, like it's so funny, I know everybody out there has probably
0:27:50watched the iPhone part of that Macworld keynote in 2007, but it is so funny watching it in
0:27:57hindsight how much time Steve Jobs talks about the phone app. Right? It is so funny because,
0:28:04and it's like all this time spent like here, you know, and the visual voicemail was great.
0:28:09It was amazing. Like voicemail used to really suck. You had to like dial like star 70 and
0:28:16from your phone, you dialed star 70 and the system recognized like, oh, I know your SIM
0:28:20card. Here's your phone number. It was like dealing with the world's worst call center.
0:28:25So yes, it was worth it at the time. I'm not saying they made a mistake, but in hindsight,
0:28:30they spent like half the time talking about the phone app, which most people I know are
0:28:34like, oh my God, I hate the phone. I don't, you know, getting a phone call is the worst
0:28:37part of your day.
0:28:39I do think Jobs did have this obsession with trying to make computers be more a part of
0:28:46lives and less computery. I think he really was keenly aware of what that problem was,
0:28:51even if he didn't know the answer to it. And they did try a lot of things that were on
0:28:56that road. I actually did want to say, because you were talking about the book, I haven't
0:29:00read the book and I don't want to like say anything that gets me in trouble or gets anyone
0:29:04mad at me, but I do think like one thing to think about just for me being somebody who's
0:29:12an artist, who's like, I've made things that were really successful and then had to keep
0:29:17making things after that. And that experience of trying to live up to something, you know,
0:29:24being on the inside of the thing where people would look at it and go, oh, what? Why didn't
0:29:29they make another thing like that great thing? You don't make great things by setting out
0:29:35to have brilliant ideas and make great things. You make great things by having ideas that
0:29:41you really want to chase down and working hard for a long time and making things that
0:29:46are really good for a long time. And then sometimes you hit upon something that's great.
0:29:52And so with this like entire world of Apple prognostication, I'd be worried if Apple wasn't
0:29:59continuing to make great things, but they're not. They're doing great stuff. Everything
0:30:04they come up with is really cool and innovative and like they consistently do things that
0:30:10are like surprisingly great, like the M1 chip. So to me, the thing that I look for with people
0:30:18I respect or companies that I'm interested in hearing from is are they continuing to
0:30:22do really good work? Does most of the stuff that they put out inspire me in some way?
0:30:28I think that entire concept of like, well, is this person going to have this idea that
0:30:33makes this thing happen? I think it's sort of flawed.
0:30:36Yeah, you don't. Yeah, it's so well put like from the creator's perspective, there's like
0:30:42an inflection point of releasing the thing to the world. And you just don't know what
0:30:48happens when it goes through that pinpoint. There's the the universe on the side where
0:30:54it starts, it's just an idea and gets slowly more real. And then you're like, okay, I'm
0:30:59ready to release, I'm going to squeeze it through this pinhole into the outside world.
0:31:04And then from that point, and you might think this will be a great hit, or you might think,
0:31:08I love this, I had to make this, I doubt this is going to be a hit. And sometimes it's like
0:31:14the things you think will be a big hit aren't. And sometimes the things that you thought,
0:31:19this is probably going to be niche, like you were saying about Synthpond, right? Like,
0:31:24it became way more of a thing once it was out on the iPhone than you seem to have thought
0:31:30possible.
0:31:31But nothing embodies that more than the fact that the thing that was the biggest hit about
0:31:35the iPhone is the App Store, which wasn't part of it.
0:31:40Right. It's so true. It really is. It's so funny thinking about how excited I was and
0:31:49the people I knew in my world who all bought the original iPhone and lined up on day one
0:31:54and used it for an entire year without any third party apps. I actually jail broke mine
0:31:59by the fall and had a couple of apps. Lights Out was the first game.
0:32:04Yes.
0:32:05Right? Which was, I can't believe I'm forgetting, Lucas Newman I think did the programming.
0:32:09But one of the things I loved about Lights Out as a jailbreak game, like three months
0:32:15after the phone came out, right, and there was like literally no support in Xcode. Like,
0:32:20it's not just the, oh, there's no App Store. There was no third party developer chain.
0:32:24Like everything had to be backwards engineered by the community. The thing I loved about
0:32:28Lights Out was the way that the Mac indie community evolved into the original iOS indie
0:32:34community is that even though there was no official tool chain, none, no App Store, so
0:32:39no way that it could possibly gain widespread adoption, it might break at any time if a
0:32:44software update had closed the jailbreak loopholes that we were using to install it. But it was
0:32:50exquisitely well done. It had unbelievable pixel perfect artwork and sounds and animations.
0:32:59It was so well done. It was not just like a proof of concept prototype. It was like,
0:33:05oh, here's an amazingly fun game based on like an old electronic game design thing.
0:33:10Yeah, that is such a Mac shareware community.
0:33:14Like if you're going to do it, do it right. And all the way to the tiniest details of
0:33:18each pixel, each sound, the animation curves, everything. It was so much fun, but it spoke
0:33:25to the desire, the sort of people who it was almost like if I pointed that out to Lucas
0:33:32Newman or Craig Hockenberry at icon factory did Twitter as a jailbreak app in that first
0:33:37year. And it was the same thing. It wasn't just like, oh, here's an app that does Twitter.
0:33:43It was also like everything the icon factory does exquisitely well designed. And it's like,
0:33:48if I really made a point of that, Craig and his colleagues at icon factory would have
0:33:53been like, well, of course, you know, like it's like, why are you saying that? Of course
0:33:57we made it look as good as possible.
0:33:59Yeah. And that's such a trait of Mac shareware and especially the icon factory. Like my main
0:34:04memory of them is growing up and installing their tool that let me change the icons of
0:34:10the default software stuff into with different themes. And they had all these incredible
0:34:15exquisite icon themes and it's like, yeah, that's going to break as soon as Apple updates
0:34:20their OS, but it's amazing.
0:34:23Candy bar, right?
0:34:24Candy bar, yes.
0:34:27It was so awesome. And it was so pointless from a utilitarian perspective, but it was
0:34:34so satisfying in a different part of your brain.
0:34:39Yeah. Oh my God. I haven't thought about candy bar in so long.
0:34:43Yeah. I think they did that in collaboration with panic. I don't know if panic is...
0:34:48Yes. Oh my God.
0:34:50Yeah. Remember panic? I'm not sure if they're still around. We'll have to say.
0:34:53Well, yeah. Yeah. What are they doing now?
0:34:57Tell me, you know, you were in your computers, you had a Mac and you taught yourself some
0:35:01programming early, but you also definitely, you have a background as an artist. Like going
0:35:06to Parsons isn't really, obviously there's an interactive at the time you went there,
0:35:13you know, computers were obviously a huge part of the curriculum, but it still is a
0:35:17traditional artistic background. Almost formal? Would you describe yourself as a formal artist
0:35:23in a sense?
0:35:24Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Formally trained artist. Yeah. There's actually, well, there's, so
0:35:30I think that the biggest thing that came out of, well, so first of all, I am still a conceptual
0:35:36artist. I still make work and show in galleries and things like that, which is really a delight
0:35:42to be able to have that kind of career and not have it be my money career because it's
0:35:47like would be a nightmare to do it that way. But it is really interesting to be able to
0:35:51have that career and be able to take lessons back and forth from game design. And especially
0:35:56it's really great to be in game design with the perspective of coming from the arts where
0:36:01there is no money and everything is really different. And I think probably the biggest
0:36:06thing for me that has been valuable coming from the art space is this practice of making
0:36:15interactive art for the gallery. When you make something interactive and you put it
0:36:19in a gallery, it's not good enough to just make a really interesting piece of art. You
0:36:25also have to trick people into interacting with it. And people who go into a gallery,
0:36:30they don't want to interact with art at all. They want to stand back and be quiet and see
0:36:36it. And interacting with interactive art is even worse than having to interact with anything
0:36:41normal, because not only are you trying to learn this thing and interact with this thing,
0:36:46but because it's in a gallery where everybody else is super quiet, the spotlight goes on
0:36:51to you when you interact with it. And suddenly you're the performer in the space. So not
0:36:56only when you put this art up are you trying to convince people to interact with it, but
0:37:01you're also trying to make them comfortable being a performer.
0:37:05In a public space.
0:37:06In a public space. The worst, scariest place to be a performer. And there are so many interactive
0:37:14lessons that I learned from that about how to prime somebody to feel comfortable interacting,
0:37:20how to get them up to speed fast enough that they feel comfortable exploring and get comfortable
0:37:27in the space and just start to do the kind of creative, interesting interaction that
0:37:33makes your work shine. And I think in games and in design, a lot of the conversation that
0:37:39I hear is really built around how to meet a user's expectations, how to build a thing
0:37:45that will be comfortable for a user to interact with. You know, if you're building a tax website,
0:37:51you don't want the user to be becoming an expert at using a tax website. You just want
0:37:56them to be able to do all the stuff so that they can do their taxes, the other thing that
0:38:01the website's there for. So the design is always in service to this other thing. But
0:38:05in games and in art, in interactive art, the interaction is the art. That's the experience.
0:38:12And so it's really important, you know, when you look at something like Candy Crush or
0:38:18a lot of freemium games, a lot of times the design is there to get people to be doing
0:38:23the real thing, which is spending the money or thinking about the puzzle or getting frustrated.
0:38:28But in the best games, what you really want people to do is become performers. And because
0:38:34performers are the most skilled and the most exciting players, they're the people who will
0:38:40do things with your game that you never thought were possible, and they're also the people
0:38:44who are the most likely to be able to grow with your game and to take something away
0:38:48and say, "Wow, I really value playing that. That helped me as a person in some way." And
0:38:54so there's this different kind of way to approach design where you think about how to turn people
0:39:01into the most talented performers that they can be. And I think that's a really big deal
0:39:07for me with game design, and it came directly out of that art practice.
0:39:10Yeah. I mean, Annette has spoken like a natural-born artist. And again, it's not like you don't
0:39:17make money. And we'll talk about that. But it comes to one of my favorite points that
0:39:23has little bits of wisdom, if I could impart to everybody, is that one of the most important
0:39:28is that it's not enough to just have a handful of top priorities. Three things. These are
0:39:35the three things I care about. It really matters what order those priorities in, and it has
0:39:40profound implications, like one, two, three versus two, one, three. And moving your goal
0:39:49for profitability up one tick inevitably has such profound implications down the road.
0:39:57Immediately and then down the road, you just end up on a different continent, right? Candy
0:40:03Crush, let's throw them under the bus. That's a big company, part of King Games.
0:40:07Right. They can handle it.
0:40:09That's part of the Activision Blizzard conglomerate that Microsoft has just acquired for I forget
0:40:16how many massive billions of dollars, I don't know, 69, 68. I think. Yeah, that's it. Here's
0:40:22how I remember it. It's like $68.7 billion. And I just, in my mind, it's like they came
0:40:28to $69 billion. And they're like, Microsoft is sort of like the opposite of Elon Musk.
0:40:34And they don't want a funny number as the price. They're like, how about we knock it
0:40:39down to 68.7? And we'll use that as opposed to if it was Elon and the negotiated price
0:40:46was 68.7, he'd be like, I'll just give you another $300 million so we can say it's 69
0:40:52billion.
0:40:53Right.
0:40:54$69 billion. That's a lot of money for video games. And they make lots of money. Candy
0:41:00Crush is clearly, it stood the test of time, right? It's obviously not a flash in the pan.
0:41:06It's at least a decade old.
0:41:07Oh, yeah. It's a good game. It's just a little evil.
0:41:11Well, right. Because once your priority is to keep the money coming, and I think it's
0:41:19fair to say that from their perspective, that's the number one priority of Candy Crush. And
0:41:25I guess maybe number one is to keep it fun or addictive or something, right? Because
0:41:34otherwise the money doesn't come. But that's sort of part and parcel with each other, right?
0:41:38You obviously need the players willing to spend money, but it just seems like that's
0:41:42the top priority.
0:41:45It's all metrics driven.
0:41:46Right.
0:41:47Which is like, I don't know. This is one thing I always hear every time I talk to anybody
0:41:54in the industry, in the mobile industry about stuff, they're always like, what's your retention?
0:41:59What's your day 20? And I always feel like, retention, why are we even... I understand
0:42:05why we talk about retention, because it is a number that you can tie a lot of value to.
0:42:09But on the other hand, it's like, I don't know, I've never... When somebody's like,
0:42:15I love this movie, I'm never like, oh, you love the movie? How many times did you watch
0:42:19it? Did you watch it 300 times? Because all of my movies, I want to make sure everybody
0:42:24watches them 300 times. Like, what does that have to do with the quality of something?
0:42:29It's a very, I don't know, for me, it feels like a very toxic space to think about success
0:42:35through that kind of lens.
0:42:36I don't look at analytics at Daring Fireball. I really, it's been years. I don't even have
0:42:42analytics at the moment. I unhooked Google Analytics, I don't know, at this point, maybe
0:42:47two years ago, and haven't hooked anything up. And there's a couple of privacy-oriented
0:42:51analytics packages that I'm probably going to pick one soon and put it on, because there
0:42:56are some things I would like to know, and I would like to know if something terrible
0:43:01is truly happening. I honest to God, though, don't look. But even when I do put something
0:43:06back on, and even when I had Google Analytics there, any kind of tracking codes, I never
0:43:13tracked which articles were the most important. I mean, maybe in the very early days, like
0:43:1915, 16, 17 years ago, I used to track referrals, and I could tell if a full article I wrote
0:43:26was getting a lot of links coming in from other blogs. But now that's sort of useless,
0:43:31because that's not really where you get traffic. And I just don't want to know that if I write
0:43:37about my user interface gripes with iOS or Mac, I don't want to know that those posts
0:43:47perform poorly or perform well. But maybe they perform poorly, and people are more interested
0:43:53in my commentary on other stuff. I just want to follow my muse and write the things that
0:43:58I'm interested in. And I don't want to get twisted by knowing that when I write about
0:44:04AppleScript, people's eyes glaze over in the back of their heads, and they skip to the
0:44:08next post. I don't care if you skip, though. I don't care when Gruber writes about AppleScript.
0:44:14It's okay, cool, go to the next article, close the tab, and come back in a couple hours or
0:44:19tomorrow or in a couple days. I'm happy to have you come back, and hopefully I'll have
0:44:22something that will interest you. That's great. I just don't even want to know.
0:44:26I love that I also don't do any analytics. In fact, NotWords has no analytics packages
0:44:32or anything in it. Those numbers just make me depressed. And I think, yeah, it's a weird
0:44:38secret that you don't need to do analytics to run a successful business or be successful
0:44:44in tech.
0:44:45It's so refreshing. All right, let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor.
0:44:49It's our good friends at Memberful, speaking about making people happy. Memberful is where
0:44:55you as a creative person can monetize your passion with memberships. Memberful allows
0:45:00you, the creative person, to build a sustainable, recurring revenue. And it's the easiest way
0:45:05to sell memberships to your audience, and it's used by some of the biggest creators
0:45:09on the web. They have everything you need to run a membership program, including custom
0:45:13branding that puts your brand first. Your members, when they sign up, might not even
0:45:19know Memberful is really in the tool chain. That's fine with Memberful. It's not like,
0:45:25oh, you're on a Memberful site. It's nothing like that at all. They keep your brand first.
0:45:30You keep the membership database. If you ever want to move, you can just move your whole
0:45:34thing over. And they have everything else you need. Gift subscriptions, you can do that
0:45:40through Memberful. Apple Pay support. Free trials. Private podcasts, so that you can
0:45:45make podcasts just for your members and take care of the technical details of actually
0:45:50keeping the podcast private for members. And tons more. And they seamlessly integrate with
0:45:56the tools you already use. Things like WordPress or whatever else. All sorts of other systems.
0:46:01They're part of that sort of collaborative ecosystem of tools. They also have a world-class
0:46:06support team ready to help you simplify your memberships and grow your revenue. They're
0:46:11passionate about your success as somebody running a membership program because they
0:46:15only make money when you make money. It's win-win-win. And you only make money when
0:46:19the people paying to become members are happy to pay you to become a member. It really is
0:46:24a virtuous circle. And you can get started for free at Memberful with no credit card
0:46:30required up front. It is great. I am a member of more Memberful sites than I can count on
0:46:35a hand. It is just wonderful. Everyone from our friends at Six Colors, Jason Snell and
0:46:40Dan Morin's site, and a whole bunch of Relay FM podcasts. The list goes on and on. Here's
0:46:46where you go to find out more. Memberful.com/talkshow. Go to Memberful.com/talkshow. If you have
0:46:55some sort of thing where you would like to create a membership system, go check them
0:46:59out. I cannot recommend them highly enough. It is really terrific.
0:47:03Let's talk not words. Let's go deep. It's the new game. That's why you're here right
0:47:06now. Or as I like to say it on the podcast, cannot words.
0:47:10Right. You've done word games before. This is a well you keep coming back to. There was
0:47:16Spell Tower. I forget what else. I mean, in a sense, sort of, Sudoku is sort of a word
0:47:22game, but with numbers, right? It definitely impacted this game, doing the Sudoku game.
0:47:27Right. And good Sudoku was really pretty interesting
0:47:31because that's one that was really interesting to me because Sudoku became a phenomenon,
0:47:38at least to my... I know people... My mom, for example, has books and books and books
0:47:43of Sudoku. She loves doing Sudokus and books. It's a huge thing. So I know you can play
0:47:47them on paper, but they got computerized pretty early. It's been done so many times. I guess
0:47:53the two before we get... I said we're going to get to not words, but let's talk about
0:47:58good Sudoku and the Solitaire games you've done because these are two games that have
0:48:03been done to death. Solitaire, arguably... I don't know if this is still true, but I
0:48:08know for a very long time was indisputably the most played video game in the world because
0:48:14it shipped with Microsoft Windows. Yeah. I mean, Solitaire is an incredible game
0:48:20if you back up and think about it. Like, Solitaire is a randomly generated puzzle that was invented
0:48:28hundreds of years before video games, and then video games didn't even really tackle
0:48:33randomly generated puzzles very well until recently when everybody's become really obsessed
0:48:39with roguelikes and that whole genre space. So what makes you think, as somebody whose
0:48:46forte is distinctive games, right? There is a Zack gauginess to a Zack gauge game. It's
0:48:54not like your forte is doing just plain Solitaire, but with the prettiest graphics, which, you
0:49:01know, is a fine thing, right? There were some of those, I'm sure you remember from like
0:49:04the Mac shareware scene where it was like, yeah, sure, Windows has Solitaire built in,
0:49:08but look at the card designs on this game from the Mac, right?
0:49:12I appreciate you saying that my games have a quality that moves from game to game because
0:49:17I think early on I remember being told in art school that I needed to make sure that
0:49:22I focused on one thing because if I did lots of different things, nobody would be able
0:49:26to make heads or tails of my work. So it's really nice to be able to make lots of different
0:49:31things and hear that it feels like there's a narrative or a cohesion to it. I think for
0:49:36me, the thing is that I'm not making a Solitaire game because I want to make Solitaire or even
0:49:41because I like Solitaire. I usually don't like the kinds of games that I make and then
0:49:47making them as a way that I learn to appreciate them and enjoy the space. Really what I want
0:49:53to do is I want to make games that make people think and become better critical thinkers
0:49:59because I think critical thinking is the most important skill that a human being can have
0:50:04and I have a lot of beef with how our educational system works.
0:50:08And, God don't get me started, there goes the next hour. But I agree, I do agree.
0:50:16Yeah, it's really weird. We also just had a kid and watching him learn is also just
0:50:24like every day I'm like, "Oh my God, I can't believe the way that we teach things." Watching
0:50:27this kid learn is not at all how anybody learns in school. Yeah, so I want to make games that
0:50:33help people become better critical thinkers and also help people learn the language of
0:50:38video games. If you know how video games work, you get access to this amazing literacy that
0:50:43is the same literacy that's used in interactive art, it's the same literacy that's used in
0:50:48avant-garde film and plays. It's like this deep, incredible space if you can just teach
0:50:54people how to access it. And one of the things that I love about making games on the iPhone
0:50:59is that the iPhone audience is predominantly normal, non-game people. And being able to
0:51:07make games for them is super interesting to me. And the thing is, what most people know
0:51:13about games is they know about chess pieces and they know about cards and they know about
0:51:18word stuff and they know about billiards maybe. And so the tools that I have at my disposal
0:51:23to try to make games for this audience are a very different set of tools than most people
0:51:29who are making video games feel like they have to work with. And so when I think about
0:51:34games or encounter a game that seems sort of interesting like Solitaire, where I go
0:51:39is "Okay, well, what's a way that I could make this game much deeper or explore something
0:51:44else, something that's not traditionally explored by what somebody would expect in this category?
0:51:51But then how do I make it look and feel approachable like this game so somebody who normally plays
0:51:56Solitaire would be able to pick up something like Flip Flop Solitaire or something like
0:52:02Sage Solitaire and have what is really like a cutting-edge game design experience but
0:52:10built upon a stack of things that they understand?"
0:52:13Dave I think that point you made a minute ago about
0:52:19how, okay, you've looked at these other Solitaire games, but they all dissatisfied you in a
0:52:24certain way. There's something, it's like I kind of, I get how this is a genius game
0:52:29and it was really, really clever back when it was only and could only be played with
0:52:34a physical deck of cards. But something about these video game versions dissatisfied you
0:52:39and how do you scratch that itch so that it satisfies you? And I feel like that's the
0:52:45key to so much creativity. But it also, the creative personality is always full of doubts
0:52:54and so many people think, "I would like to make a Solitaire game that's different, but
0:52:59all the other Solitaire games are this way so I guess I shouldn't because there must
0:53:03be that way for a reason." And instead you should see that as an opportunity. The fact
0:53:11that you see you're dissatisfied or you think, "I could do that, I could do something better
0:53:16than that," then you should do it. It's not a reason not to do it because it's not the
0:53:21way it was always done.
0:53:22Yeah, and also the second part of that that's the key is you should do it. You have to do
0:53:28it. I think something that people might not realize about the games that I make is I probably
0:53:35make 100 prototypes a year and I probably release one game a year. And sometimes the
0:53:41games make it three seconds and then I put them down. And sometimes they make it many
0:53:46hours of work and then we scrap them. You have to both be confident and comfortable
0:53:51with admitting when something sucks. And then if you do that enough, when you find something
0:53:57that is good, that is different, it's really obvious because you're like, "Oh, I enjoy
0:54:01this. This is actually fun to do."
0:54:04In other words, it's sort of like a process of going from an idea that's purely in your
0:54:09head and then you've got to start making it real and it coagulates to become more and
0:54:17more real or it gets to a point where you're like, "Ah, this is a dead end."
0:54:23Yeah, I'll try to walk you through a really quick one. So with Flip Flop Solitaire, which
0:54:29is kind of like, it was heavily inspired by Spider Solitaire, which is a really interesting
0:54:35solitaire variant. For years, one of the things that's really interesting to me is this concept
0:54:40of difficulty and how people associate difficulty with games. A lot of games let you pick easy
0:54:45mode or hard mode. Some games try to adapt themselves as you play to a different kind
0:54:51of difficulty. There's this whole world of thinking about difficulty and challenge in
0:54:56games. And it's something that I think about all the time, and a lot of my games offer
0:55:02a variety of ways to attempt to deal with this problem of trying to find the right difficulty
0:55:09game for the right person. And Really Bad Chess is a really simple example of that because
0:55:15Really Bad Chess, literally your board gets worse and worse the better you get in the
0:55:19game. So it's like teaching you how to play chess in this very friendly way, but it's
0:55:25also very cruel because at some point in the game, the computer has nine queens and you
0:55:29have no queens, and you're still trying to play the game. So that's a very clear exploration
0:55:36into this difficulty question. So what I noticed is I was just looking at games and I found
0:55:41this game Spider Solitaire. And Spider Solitaire has this phenomenal quality, which is that
0:55:47when you play a game of Spider Solitaire, it has three difficulties. You can play with
0:55:51one suit, which is every card in the deck of cards, you just count them as all the same.
0:55:56It doesn't matter what suit they are. You can play as two suits, which is black and
0:56:00red, or you can play as four suits, which is each suit. And the thing that's interesting
0:56:04is the difficulty of the game is exponential. So almost everybody who plays for any length
0:56:10of time can solve one suit. Two suits much harder, and four suits is almost impossible.
0:56:17Four suits is like you could play Spider Solitaire your whole life and the day that you solve
0:56:20a four suit, you'll post it to Reddit and be like, "I did this. This is amazing." And
0:56:25the thing that's mind-blowing to me, thinking about difficulty and spotting this, is I can't
0:56:30think of any games like that, right? Like most people don't play, you know, a video
0:56:35game on Easy every day, but then some days they're like, "Well, I'll try hard. I'll
0:56:39just try hard today and then go back to Easy." That's not part of the idea of how we think
0:56:44about difficulty. And so I was just like completely enamored with this small aspect of the game
0:56:50that relates to this big thing that I've been thinking about my whole career, which
0:56:54is how does difficulty work and how do people interact with it? But then, to the point that
0:56:58you said earlier, I looked at it and I thought, "Okay, well, Spider Solitaire, this is like
0:57:02ten piles. It doesn't work on a phone. It's great on a table. How do I condense it down?
0:57:07Maybe if I make it so that you can stack up and down, not just down, with your cards,
0:57:13maybe then I can cut the number of piles in half because I've doubled your ability to
0:57:16interact with the game and I'm going to cut the piles down to five and five will fit nicely
0:57:20on a phone." And it turns out that actually making you stack up and down is an entirely
0:57:25interesting, weird direction to go with Solitaire and you'd think that this tiny little twist
0:57:31wouldn't change the game much, but it entirely shifts the game. And instantly, I was playing
0:57:36it with cards, I realized that that was true, and then that was the game. I figured out
0:57:40how to develop it and push it and I got to explore this thing with difficulty that I've
0:57:44been looking at my whole career, and then I also got to try to fit a table game onto
0:57:50a phone and do all the other fun, interesting things about making a game deeper.
0:57:55So you actually prototyped it with just a deck of cards in your hand and a table?
0:58:00Yes.
0:58:01Yeah. Kind of an advantage to making a Solitaire game of any kind, is that...
0:58:05That's the best thing about cards. A deck of cards is my favorite tool of all time.
0:58:11My desert island game is just a deck of cards, I don't care what the game is, I could entertain
0:58:16myself for a thousand years with a deck of cards.
0:58:19It's so funny, I love sleight of hand magic.
0:58:23Oh my god, right, a total other area of cards.
0:58:26I don't do it at all, and maybe in some other universe I'd have grown up and tried to teach
0:58:34myself some of it. I don't really think I have any to do it. But as an observer, a fan,
0:58:42an audience member, I love it. I've watched the late great Ricky Jay's TV specials, all
0:58:49of them, like six times. Those sleight of hand magicians speak of a deck of... they
0:58:54just love cards and they keep cards with them all the time and they do unbelievable things.
0:58:59Ricky Jay used to throw cards. Do you ever see that?
0:59:03Yeah, I saw him live once. It was really an incredible experience.
0:59:06Oh my god, I'm jealous that you saw him live, I wish I would have. But he could throw a
0:59:10card, just a regular card, not like a special, "Oh, you got a mail order from some outfit
0:59:16in Las Vegas that'll send you these cards that are extra stiff." I mean, go to your
0:59:19local drug store and buy a pack of bicycle playing cards, the kind that everybody knows,
0:59:24and he could throw them at a watermelon across the room and stick them into the rind. And
0:59:30it's scary. He could use a single card as a weapon. And I like playing card games like
0:59:36poker and blackjack and stuff like that. It's such a wonderful invention. And it always
0:59:41amuses me too in the casinos, speaking of Candy Crush, but the way they keep inventing
0:59:47new games that use decks of cards, and I always know, I never play them, almost never. Maybe
0:59:53you get a couple drinks with me and I'll play 50 bucks or something. Because I know that
0:59:57the only reason a casino would invent a new game is because they make more money from
1:00:02it, as opposed to blackjack, where you can kind of break even if you know the rules.
1:00:06And so I'm deeply, deeply skeptical and suspicious of any new game. But it fascinates me that
1:00:11they just keep coming up with them. Four suits, 13 cards in each suit, and you could just
1:00:17keep making games with them. It's so interesting.
1:00:19I had a really fundamental career experience walking around a casino for a day, trying
1:00:28my hardest to sort of space out from the manipulative, depressing nature of it and just focus on the
1:00:35games. Those games in casinos are unbelievable. I think one of the things that's the most
1:00:40interesting about casino games is they're one of the only forms of artistic expression
1:00:46that has a coherent metric that is the metric, which is how much money do these games make
1:00:53per minute. And so they're all aggressively tuned to this very specific metric that is
1:01:02itself super vague and weird. One of my favorite games in the casino is three card poker. Are
1:01:08you familiar with that?
1:01:09Yes, yes.
1:01:10Three card poker is one of the most beautiful games I've ever seen. It's this game where,
1:01:15if anyone from your audience isn't familiar with it, you basically are dealt two cards
1:01:22and you have to decide if you're going to play the hand or not, and then you get dealt
1:01:29three more cards and that's your hand, and either you win it or you lose it. And what's
1:01:33incredible about it is this moment of decision, it's just random. You don't know if you're
1:01:40going to have a good hand or you're going to have a bad hand, and there's some more
1:01:43complexity to it that I'm not talking about with how the dealer's cards work. But basically
1:01:48it's totally random, but because you have this tiny bit of information and because of
1:01:52the pageantry of the game and how your bets move around on the table, it feels like you're
1:01:56playing this game that is incredibly elegant and interesting and that this moment of choice
1:02:02is super meaningful. And how they did that with nothing, it's incredible.
1:02:09I do like that game. I don't play a lot of it, but I like it for that reason. It's also
1:02:13very fun to play with a friend or your spouse or somebody you know so that you can play
1:02:20together and it's social. I'm not a slot machine player, and I know that they're by far and
1:02:27away the most popular casino games, and I know they make most of the money and I know
1:02:30most people like to play them, but I don't have any fun playing them because there's
1:02:35no decisions. You just hit a button and then you either win or you lose, and I find that
1:02:40to be very boring. There's no social element to it. I don't want to go off on a casino
1:02:47ramp, but I also love to play craps, but I really only like to play craps if I'm with
1:02:54friends. It's been a couple of years because of COVID, but I've had times where a bunch
1:02:59of friends who have gone to Vegas and playing craps with friends at the same table is amazing
1:03:05because you typically, and there's a gazillion weird bets you can make on a craps table,
1:03:09but if you just sort of bet the pass line, which is, is the person with the dice going
1:03:13to win or lose, you all play together and you win and lose together, which is an incredible
1:03:20game design element. The other thing, I think you'd appreciate that. If you think about
1:03:24craps, if craps was not a game that had existed since, I don't know when it was invented,
1:03:30but it's ever since the existence of casinos in Las Vegas existed, craps was already part
1:03:37of gambling culture. Nobody would invent that now because the table is huge. It takes up
1:03:43a huge amount of space and it's manpower heavy. There's at least, I think at least
1:03:50three people who, there's the guy in the suit or the person in the suit who sits down
1:03:57low and they have like a mirror there and that person runs the table and looks at everything
1:04:03and there's the stick man who literally just has the stick to move the dice around
1:04:08and put them back with the shooter and two other employees who just make sure all the
1:04:14bets are good and pays off all the bets. So there's like four people at all times at
1:04:18a craps table. But if it hadn't been invented now and you and I went to, you know, Caesars
1:04:26and said, "We've invented a new game. It's going to be a 15 foot long table. It's going
1:04:34to require four full time employees and the rules are as thick as a book." They would
1:04:40just say, "Get out." But it's great. And you'll see. The other thing too about craps
1:04:46is when you're in a casino, you can always tell when a craps table is hot because it
1:04:52is full. And what happens is people notice that a craps table is hot and people are winning
1:04:57and then they fill in all the available spots and then they kind of cram in and take spots
1:05:02that aren't really available, just sort of stick their arm in until the employees are
1:05:06like, "Yeah, yeah, this table's full. You can't play. You got to wait." But then people
1:05:10will stand behind the table because they're hoping while the table's hot that they can
1:05:14join in. And then when the shooter hits their number again, the table just erupts like their
1:05:19team just hit a home run in a close baseball game. And it fills the whole casino with this
1:05:24certain noise that is very human, very social, and very different from the ding, ding, ding,
1:05:31ding, ding, ding of the slot machines just sort of endlessly beeping and bopping.
1:05:35I love craps. I don't like to play it, but I really like to go into casinos with friends
1:05:41and watch them play it. And again, yeah, the thing about craps is it's just this major
1:05:46victory for the narrative generation of a game. It's just all narrative. And that narrative
1:05:53is so thrilling and irresistible to be a part of, and it has this incredible mechanic where
1:05:58you can bet on a number, and every time the shooter hits that number, you get paid. So
1:06:03it's like you've created a little money factory, and everybody's got their own little factories.
1:06:08And one thing that I realized when I got into craps is like, craps must have been a major
1:06:12inspiration for Settlers of Catan, which is like the biggest American board game since
1:06:17Monopoly. It's the same mechanic. You're constructing little cities on numbers, and when those numbers
1:06:23get rolled, you get paid.
1:06:24Yeah, that's a good analogy. I'm familiar with the game enough to see what you mean.
1:06:31That's pretty good. That is, the times that I've won money, like significant amount, like
1:06:34holy crap, look how many chips I have. I better leave. I better get, let's go. It's always
1:06:40because I had money on the six and the eight, while some shooters, you know, has like a
1:06:44ten, which is sort of a rare number. So in other words, the shooter is just sitting there
1:06:49shooting over and over again until they get another ten, at which point they win and all
1:06:54the bets are paid off and everything's over and we start all over again, or they roll
1:06:57the dreaded seven and then they lose and all the bets, every bet is cleared off the felt
1:07:02and it all goes to the casino. And in the meantime, while you're waiting for the shooter
1:07:07to either roll a seven and lose or hit another ten and win, if they keep rolling sixes and
1:07:11eights in there, you just keep getting paid and you can just leave your bet up there and
1:07:15it just keeps coming. It just keeps coming and coming and coming. And those are the times
1:07:19where it's like some kid just keeps shooting the dice and just isn't winning, isn't losing,
1:07:25and you've got like the six and the eight or some whatever numbers, whatever your lucky
1:07:28numbers are. And all of a sudden you've got this giant stack of chips and it's like, how
1:07:33did this happen? It's amazing. And it feels like the whole universe is just smiling and
1:07:37upon you. And it's of course, I know, I know in my mind that it's just stupid, stupid statistical
1:07:43luck and that they are guaranteed the most honest dice in the universe. But you can't
1:07:52help but feel that there is a narrative at play, right? It's the same thing when a craps
1:07:56table is ice cold. It's like, oh, this table stinks.
1:07:59Michael Gentry Yeah. Yeah. And just in case, so I don't feel like I'm an idiot when I re-listen
1:08:03to this later. I know that Catan is not an American board game, but it was an American
1:08:07board game phenomenon.
1:08:08Dave Asprey Right, right. Let's talk, so that leads us to, craps of course, leads us directly
1:08:15to Not Words, the crosswords game. Not Words is in a, maybe in a nut. I quoted when I linked
1:08:21to it on Daring Fireball over the weekend, I quoted your description and you don't mention
1:08:24this, but I would just say, I think most people would describe it as a crossword game without
1:08:29clues.
1:08:30Michael Gentry Yes.
1:08:31Dave Asprey Which sounds, sounds impossible at first.
1:08:35Michael Gentry Right. Right. It sounds like there's not even a game.
1:08:40Dave Asprey Right. The trick is how do you do this without clues? They're just English
1:08:45words, the typical words that would be in a crossword puzzle as you know it. And the
1:08:51crossword, the board game, the board, if you will call it, looks like it could be a regular
1:08:56crossword game where you would play it with clues at first glance. But then there's little
1:09:00sub-shapes within the game, sort of like Tetris pieces, but they're not necessarily, you know,
1:09:08Tetris pieces famously are all four squares. That's the tet in Tetris. You know, they could
1:09:13be three, they could be five. I don't know what's the, what's the biggest chunk that,
1:09:18that's allowed in Not Words. Are there six?
1:09:20Michael Gentry I think they go up to seven.
1:09:22Dave Asprey Oh, okay.
1:09:23Michael Gentry In puzzles. But yeah, it's two to seven in general.
1:09:25Dave Asprey Right. It might be like a little L shape. It might be a little square. It's
1:09:29like any kind of imaginable little shape of two to seven squares. And then in the, in
1:09:35the corner of that piece, it'll tell you these, let's say it's a little four square shape.
1:09:41It'll tell you these four squares consist of these four letters. There may not be a
1:09:46complete word. In fact, typically there's no complete word in that piece. You just have
1:09:52to use it combined with the adjacent ones to make words. You pick it up pretty quickly,
1:09:57which again is sort of a hallmark of your games where you don't need to read a lot of
1:10:03rules to pick it up and start playing. And I think to touch on one of your previous points,
1:10:08that's why sort of playing off these classic forms like billiards and crosswords and solitaire,
1:10:19people already know the order of a deck of cards that a jack is less than a queen is
1:10:23less than a king, and they know that a crossword puzzle gets filled in with words. So you're
1:10:29starting with this sort of foundational knowledge. How do you describe not words?
1:10:36Matthew Feeney Yeah, I mean, I think you did a pretty good
1:10:39job. It's the really simple description if people have this backing is it's kind of like
1:10:44Ken Ken meets crosswords. But if you've never played Ken Ken, then yeah, it's basically
1:10:49a crossword puzzle where the whole grid is split up into zones. And then in those zones,
1:10:54you have a couple of letters that you have to distribute, and then you have to make it
1:10:57so that all of the across and down words are real words. So you're just sort of taking
1:11:02these little pieces and untangling these kind of partial anagrams to create these full words.
1:11:08Dave Tilley You describe each puzzle may seem difficult
1:11:11at first, but like all my favorite newspaper puzzles, it gets easier as you progress. And
1:11:17I thought that was an interesting way to describe it that it is sort of like a newspaper puzzle.
1:11:21I used to love back when I read a daily newspaper every day, I did the jumble every day. That
1:11:27was it's such a stupid game. I don't do regular crossword puzzles because they take too long
1:11:32and I get bored. I've never been a fan. But the jumble was good because sometimes you
1:11:37could solve it in a minute if you got lucky. And usually two or three minutes, you should
1:11:40be able to get the jumble. You know, the jumble for people who don't know was I think, five
1:11:45five letter words every day. I think there were five, which is sort of reminiscent of
1:11:50jumble, but it and they would just be scrambled, just five scrambled words. And there'd be
1:11:56a little cartoon to go with it with a with a caption. And then within those five words,
1:12:01where you just unscramble the anagrams to make words, there would be circles in different
1:12:07spots. And then this once you've solved all five, the five that are circled is one more
1:12:12anagram to solve. And then that one is the clever pun to the cartoon that goes with it.
1:12:22Do you remember jumble? Or am I telling you about a game you like?
1:12:25I do remember it. And I like it. I have a like sort of armchair, loose obsession with
1:12:32newspaper puzzles for a lot of different reasons, but probably because I've been working in
1:12:37this space for so long. But yeah, for my whole career, basically, I've had this obsession
1:12:43with these very simple kinds of puzzles that are out there. I think a really good example
1:12:49is Sudoku. That's why I worked in it. But also Picross or nanograms, if people are familiar
1:12:55with it. There's one called Two Note Touch that they started running in the Times this
1:13:00year. It's basically there's this world of these logic puzzles that you can print on
1:13:04a sheet of paper, and that's the whole game. And each one is a unique puzzle every day,
1:13:10and you look at it, and at first it seems impossible. And then you start working it,
1:13:15and as you put answers in, those answers form these very dramatic constraints onto the future
1:13:23of the puzzle. I think if you look at a crossword puzzle, if you put one word in a crossword
1:13:27puzzle, that really doesn't do much for your other answers. Maybe you get one letter on
1:13:33one word, and so okay, maybe I've got three words in, and that gives me enough that I
1:13:36can find something. But it's not dramatically reducing the possibility space of what words
1:13:42could go in this thing or helping you. But in Sudoku, if you put in one number, that
1:13:47can change the whole puzzle. It affects the row, it affects the column, it affects its
1:13:53box. It might affect something with another one of the same number that gives you another
1:13:59answer that affects another. It's like this giant cascade of information and ideas that
1:14:04come out of just this one small thing. And I, in my mind, over the years of thinking
1:14:09about this, I kind of call it a possibility funnel. So as you get closer to the end of
1:14:14the puzzle, that funnel shrinks and shrinks and shrinks until by the end it's inevitable
1:14:18that you would solve the puzzle. But it still feels exciting because you're at the climax
1:14:24of this journey that you've taken with this puzzle, and designing a game that has that
1:14:29that also is incredibly simple and you can look at it and see it and it fits on a piece
1:14:34of paper, all those qualities together is just like a nightmare. And it's so hard and
1:14:40I sort of still am a little reeling that we found a new one because this is just something
1:14:47I've -- like as a design goal, as a game designer, it's been something for a very long time.
1:14:52Yeah, I think you could definitely play NotWords on paper. I think the biggest problem would
1:14:59be you definitely -- I would at least -- need to erase a lot. And I mean this sincerely,
1:15:06I'm not even making a joke, but like it would be -- the problem with NotWords as a newspaper
1:15:11game would be that newspaper is such crap paper that erasing, you'd wear through the
1:15:17paper pretty quickly. It is true, and NotWords absolutely has that feel to it, where it's
1:15:23like I started playing and it's like the sort of onboarding game or maybe there's a couple
1:15:29or very small and you know, because it's sort of like, play this one, which is really small
1:15:35and easy to get the feel for it. And then it's like, okay, here's a real daily puzzle.
1:15:41And I was like, oh my god, this is impossible. I'm never going to get this. I just -- this
1:15:44is -- my brain doesn't work this way. And I just sit there and hunt and I'm like, oh,
1:15:49well here's one where it has to -- there has to be a three-letter word right here out of
1:15:54this group, all in this thing, and the only three-letter word out of these four letters,
1:16:00I think the only one that you could make is, hey, H-E-Y. That's it. There's no other -- yeah,
1:16:05there's no other possibility here. Okay, well then now I've got a word. And oh, well this
1:16:09other spot has to be the I even though it goes in a different direction. And you start
1:16:14finding these spots in the puzzle where you can definitely make a conclusion. Or this
1:16:20is the part where you need the eraser. It's like, oh, I could see two words out of this
1:16:24group right here. All right, I'll guess coma. All right, and then it's like, oh god, I think
1:16:30I made a mistake with coma. I've got to delete that now. I've got to delete this. I've got
1:16:33to delete that and put a different word in that spot. And it's, oh, okay, yeah, now if
1:16:39I do that, then this becomes obvious and it's pretty easy to make a word. And it's, you
1:16:43know, like if you get yourself in a spot where you think you've got a couple of words in
1:16:48not words, but it leaves you with a new word that starts N-V, you're like, well, I've obviously
1:16:55made some sort of terrible mistake because I don't need to look in the unabridged dictionary.
1:17:01There's definitely no word that starts N-V. And I'll just say that then you get towards
1:17:07the end and this, what I thought was, I am never going to finish this one. This is impossible.
1:17:13But then I get towards the end and I'm like, I guarantee I'm going to, I know I'm going
1:17:17to beat this, but I need to, I need to see it to completion. I need to fill in the very
1:17:22last square, even though in my gut I feel 100% certain now I'm going to beat this in
1:17:27the next minute or two, but I'm not just going to put the game down before I've actually
1:17:31put the very last letter in and gotten a beep and a bop from the game to tell me I beat
1:17:35it.
1:17:37Yeah, I think that's part of the joy of newspaper puzzles is that when they're done, you can
1:17:44see it. It's like they're filled in, you've filled in all the letters. And getting to
1:17:50that point is really different from something like Solitaire where, like most Solitaire
1:17:54games, once you know you're about to win, a button pops up and you go boop and the computer
1:17:58does everything for you. But with newspaper games, there's something special about being
1:18:02able to see it. And yeah, and that funnel, I'm so glad, I'm so happy to hear that that's
1:18:07been your experience with it. That's exactly the kind of experience that we're going for.
1:18:13And I think something that I was really surprised to learn working with Sudoku on Good Sudoku,
1:18:19to talk to another thing that you hit on a little bit, is this idea of, like, you think
1:18:23Sudoku is a beautiful game because the rules are really elegant, but the reality is most
1:18:28Sudoku puzzles are terrible. Like 99% of things that you would, of like numbers that you put
1:18:35in, they don't even work, they're not even puzzles. And then in that 1% of things that
1:18:39are actually Sudoku puzzles, many of them are impossible or too hard. The way that you
1:18:44actually get to a good Sudoku is by building a generator that's really smart, that knows
1:18:49how to solve it, that knows how to identify the little diamonds in the rough of possibility
1:18:53space. And so if we were to do a Not Words newspaper puzzle, those puzzles might look
1:18:58quite different than the puzzles that we put in the game. They might have more spots that
1:19:01are like anchor points where you can say something for sure to try to reduce the space of erasing
1:19:09and things like that.
1:19:10How do you guys generate the puzzles for Not Words?
1:19:15That's a very complicated question. We spent a really long time building the generator.
1:19:20The game was in development for, I think, probably six or seven months, and I would
1:19:24say we probably spent four of those months building a generator. Jack, my partner on
1:19:28the project, has had a lot of practice because we built good Sudoku and we figured out how
1:19:34to build one of the best Sudoku generators in the world, which is, you know, there's
1:19:38not any documentation really on how to do that, so we kind of had to reverse engineer
1:19:42it. And I think that set of skills really paid off here. When we prototyped the game,
1:19:47I originally prototyped it on a piece of paper, and as Jack started building the generator,
1:19:51I would, with some game design friends, we would make puzzles by hand for each other
1:19:56and figure out which kind of puzzles were good and what things were interesting. And
1:20:00then Jack would build a generator and we would look at what the puzzles looked like and compare
1:20:04them with our hand-built puzzles and say, "Okay, well, is there some kind of rule we
1:20:08can come up with for the computer to teach it what is interesting about this puzzle that's
1:20:13not interesting about the puzzle that it generated?" And so Jack and I went back and forth on that
1:20:17where he was sort of the interface to this complicated algorithm, and then I was the
1:20:22hand-built design interface to like what we knew was right about the puzzles, and we just
1:20:27went back and forth for a really long time, and Jack came up with some really clever algorithm
1:20:32ideas and we eventually got the generator to a space where it was generating really
1:20:38great puzzles.
1:20:39Does that mean that because you can trust the generator that the puzzle is solvable,
1:20:47that you don't have to human test every single puzzle that goes into NotWorts?
1:20:53Yeah, and in fact it means a little bit more than that. We do some stuff that probably
1:20:58seems like it's a magical result of the rules that actually isn't. So, for example,
1:21:04we do a lot of -- one of our metrics in terms of our puzzle generation has to do with possible
1:21:11permutations that can exist within the puzzle. And so we, in the standard puzzles in the
1:21:17game, are very restrictive of how many permutations can exist. So like, for example, if you've
1:21:23put in two different six-letter words that interact with each other, they're right.
1:21:28Like they have to be right because we don't allow for puzzles that have that size words
1:21:34that are interacting that are not working. And so doing that, cutting out those kinds
1:21:41of puzzle structures, is a big part of what makes that possibility space funnel happen.
1:21:47It's like removing those options is why when you put in a bunch of words they're usually
1:21:53correct except maybe one of them is wrong in this other way and then you figure that
1:21:57out. And we're careful about how we adjust that because in the game there's a kind of
1:22:01puzzle called a twist puzzle that has some numbers that count how many vowels are in
1:22:06each row or column that they're related to. And in those puzzles we allow a lot more permutations
1:22:11but still only one for the answer. So you're kind of incentivized to use those numbers
1:22:16as a tool for solving the puzzle.
1:22:19What do you guys use to build the word list?
1:22:23So we use Wordnik, which is an open-source word list that you can license for games.
1:22:29And then over the years after making a lot of word games I've sort of compiled a lot
1:22:34of lists, including lists around how well-known words are.
1:22:39Oh, yeah, that's interesting. That's really interesting.
1:22:42I have lists of hyper-commonly known words and then slightly less known words and we
1:22:47use those also as a basis of generation. So you'll notice in Not Words as you go throughout
1:22:52the week the Friday, Saturday, Sunday puzzles often include more words that are a little
1:22:56bit less known. Or even in the puzzle books, one of our puzzle types is uncommon words
1:23:02and that puzzle is also filled with words that are less likely to be super commonly
1:23:07known.
1:23:08Yeah, there was a—I guess because I played over the weekend in anticipation of this—there
1:23:13was a three-letter word—I'm going to forget it—it was like T-E-C or T-A-C and I was
1:23:19like, I don't know, that doesn't look like a word to me. But one of the things is if
1:23:22you can try the word, there's no penalty for trying a word that isn't a word, it
1:23:27just gives you a little squiggle out to say that's not a legit word. So if it says that's
1:23:34a word, it's not confirming that you've put the right word in, it's just confirming
1:23:39this is considered within Not Words a legitimate word to play.
1:23:43But one of my favorite little features, because otherwise it would drive me nuts, on a phone
1:23:48in particular you don't want to be switching back and forth while you're playing a game,
1:23:52to, for me, a dictionary app. If there's a word that I don't know what it means,
1:23:57I want to look it up, and you can always—there's just a little dictionary lookup button once
1:24:02you've completed a word, and then, you know, like, I guess it's based on which square
1:24:10has input focus right now, like, if you wanted to change that square. And if it is part of
1:24:16a complete word, you can just hit the dictionary button and it'll tell you the definition
1:24:21from, like, Wiktionary—I don't know if you have multiple sources, it seems like most
1:24:24of the definitions come from Wiktionary, which I guess is open source?
1:24:29It's from Wordnik, and Wordnik is a multi-source, open source dictionary, so sometimes they'll
1:24:33come from Wordnik or a variety of other ones, but it's all built in the same sort of word
1:24:39list on our end. And yeah, that's a great—your point about not wanting to open up the dictionary
1:24:45on your phone is—I really appreciate that point. I think that's something I try to
1:24:49be super cognizant of with building word games, and it's something I've noticed when, like,
1:24:54something like "Mist will get a port and suddenly Mist is on the phone" or something
1:24:58like that. I always think, like, this is so frustrating because, like, the phone is my
1:25:02notebook or it is my dictionary. Like, if I'm playing a game on the computer and I
1:25:06have some kind of note that I have to take down, I'll take a photo of it with my phone
1:25:11or I'll write it down with my phone. So I always try to be very cognizant of, if I'm
1:25:15making a game for the phone, this is in the place of the player's notebook or reference
1:25:20tool, and I want to make sure that anything that they would have to write down or look
1:25:24up or anything like that would be included in the game because otherwise, like, people
1:25:29aren't walking around with two phones to look up definitions and not words.
1:25:33Dave: Right. So, you know, it's so convenient and it's so satisfying because maybe you
1:25:37didn't even guess it because you don't know the word. This isn't the word. I just
1:25:40looked it up while we were talking here, but "tech," T-E-C, is a word. It's some
1:25:45kind of mid-century shorthand for the word "detective." That wasn't the word I'm
1:25:49thinking of. It was something like that, though. But I've never heard of T-E-C either. Now
1:25:53I'm ready for it and not words. But let's say you end up—it's just like any other
1:25:57crossword puzzle where you can end up filling in a word without ever guessing the clue because
1:26:02you fill in all the other words in the other direction. And, you know, so let's say it's
1:26:07T-E-C across, but you filled in all the ones that go down and now you've got it and it
1:26:13says it's a word and you're like, "Well, what the hell does that mean?" Boom. You're
1:26:15like two taps away from, "Oh, okay, it's like a mid-century nickname for a police detective.
1:26:21Oh, interesting." And now you've learned a word.
1:26:23Dave: One of the things that I'm really excited about about not words is that it has
1:26:27that quality of, because of the funnel, being able to allow you to enter in words that you
1:26:33didn't know and discover them. And that's a very uncommon quality on a word game. Like,
1:26:41I think even if you think about, like, Wordle, which is basically the most accessible or
1:26:46abridgable word game that I've ever seen, where almost everybody solves Wordle almost
1:26:50every day. Even in that, if you didn't know the word, it would be really hard to solve
1:26:55Wordle despite all of the clues because the game is about recall and about being able
1:27:01to identify this word that you know about. And so being able to have clues and structured
1:27:07puzzles in not words that get you to words that you didn't know, even though you'd
1:27:13think that that would be impossible, it's really cool. And so being able to look up
1:27:17them and learn definitions of strange words, I always get really excited when that happens
1:27:22to me in one of the puzzles.
1:27:29I mean, if we're going to talk games and word games, I mean, how can we not at least talk about Wordle a little? I love it. I know it's so stupid. I play every day. I've got my, but here's one of the things that is so fun and interesting about Wordle. So my sister's two years younger than me. My parents are both, they're, you know, my dad's, I think, 84. And my mom's, like, in her late 70s, but they're both very healthy. We're so lucky that everybody's healthy and around. And now all four of us play a game.
1:27:58All four of us play Wordle every day, and we have a group chat and an iMessage, and we post our lines, and my mom sends, like, a trophy emoji to whoever solves it in the least words. And, you know, we have a good family. And I certainly love my parents. I talk to my dad on the phone a lot. But we have never had a continuous group chat, the four of us, that was active for so long. And now it's there every single day. We all play.
1:28:24And I can't, I don't know, I never, it's actually improved our lives in a certain way. It really has, like, and then, you know, because it's, it's mostly filled with Wordle talk, you know, line four, line three, all right, trophy goes to Bob today. But, you know, you can put other things in there, right?
1:28:42And so now we've got, like, this active social, passively active social channel, which is why group chats are so great. What a great thing. And there's absolutely no, you know, part of the charm of it. It wasn't just that it's free, it wasn't just that it was on the web, but that there's no, it's not even possible to keep playing. Like, you have to wait till midnight.
1:29:03And, and of course, if you really want to, you can, because now there are more Wordle clones than you could possibly count. So if you really want to play a Wordle-like game for an hour and just keep beating puzzles, you know, the app store is chock full of options for you, you know, you can do it. It's not like Josh Wardle, the creator of the original Wordle, or now the New York Times who bought it from him and own it. They're not being mean by keeping you from doing it.
1:29:27But they're just saying, in our version of the game, you play once, you solve it, and you know, come back tomorrow. And I think that is such a wonderful mechanic. It's so, and it's, you know, literally the opposite of Candy Crush.
1:29:40Yeah, well, there's a lot of things I love in that story. I totally agree about that mechanic, and that was actually a major influence on how we thought about what the flow of how someone would interact with NotWords would be. That's definitely the main reason why we put so much focus on it being a daily puzzle, and we put up a lot of friction around you playing more than the daily.
1:30:05We have two dailies, and you can, if you paid for it, you can go back in history and play as many puzzles as you want, but it's very focused around just asking you to do the daily every day.
1:30:17And that was directly inspired by Wordle and thinking about that structure, because it is such a compelling way to interact with something, and I think Josh was really correct that that is the most fun way to play Wordle, which is great.
1:30:32You'd never find that by digging into your metrics.
1:30:35I would be bored to tears playing three Wordles in a row. I would. I honestly would. And I did it because I wrote about the ripoffs, and the ripoffs weren't about the mechanics. The thing I wrote about was people actually stealing the name Wordle, which is clearly wrong, and to some extent stealing the exact look of the game, which is like, "Come on, there's like a zillion billion ways that you could make this look."
1:31:01Even if it's the same mechanics. Come on, come up with your own look. And then after that, if you want to take the mechanics, but I've played with those games, and it's like, "Oh my God, this game that I love to play every morning while I drink my coffee, it bores me to tears doing two."
1:31:15It's like, because, yeah, because it's sort of--
1:31:17And how is that possible? It's just two.
1:31:19I don't know. I don't know. I don't know, but I'll be damned if I'm not going to play again tomorrow morning, you know? It really is interesting.
1:31:25And it's so healthy. It must be a good feel. And part of NotWords is, okay, the daily puzzles certainly take significantly more time than solving a Wordle.
1:31:36It's a little bit more akin to a crossword puzzle, but smaller than the daily newspaper crossword puzzle.
1:31:43But then you finish it, and it's done, it's correct, and you get the animation and audio feedback to tell you that you've solved it.
1:31:50And there's absolutely no mechanic telling you, "And now instantly, let's roll into this game."
1:31:56You know, "Keep going, keep going, keep playing, keep playing, keep playing until your phone battery's dead."
1:32:02There's nothing like that. If you'd like to, you can, but there's no pressure, and there's no pushing or steering you to keep going.
1:32:10Yeah, we really wanted to focus on the daily and give you time to recuperate, especially because some of the weekend puzzles are longer, and we wanted it to still be exciting to open it up and get to that.
1:32:23I think also part of it was, like, my game design process is I work on a game, and then I just play it for hundreds of hours until I'm sure that I'm bored of it.
1:32:34And then I think, "What else could I do?" And for Not Words, that was when I came up with the twist mode.
1:32:40But it was also this sort of funny side effect where we were really only halfway through the generation process when I was playing a ton, a ton, a ton of Not Words hours a day.
1:32:50And I think at that point, our puzzles seemed really good because it was this very fresh mechanic, and it was really exciting to see where it went.
1:32:59But they actually weren't that good, and so I played 40 hours of mediocre Not Words puzzles, and I thought, "You know what? We can't have people play 10 of these a day. We just gotta have them play one, because otherwise they're gonna feel the malaise that I feel."
1:33:14And now, of course, the puzzles are much better, and I do feel like people could probably play more if they wanted, but they're still gonna hit that burnout at some point, no matter what.
1:33:23And it made me feel like this approach was just a much healthier and more interesting approach, and an approach that will make you feel happier about the time you're spending with the game.
1:33:33Really mediocre Not Words. There's your game. So let's talk about how the game makes money.
1:33:39So for 12 bucks, $11.99, you can—I'm going by the App Store prices—$11.99, you can pay for the full game. And for $5 a year, $4.99, you get a pro subscription. What's the difference?
1:33:52So, I mean, there's no difference. It's, do you hate subscriptions, or do you think you're gonna be playing for more than three years?
1:34:00So you could—in other words, you could pay 12 bucks once and just buy the game, and now you're in like Flynn, you've got it. You're gold.
1:34:07Or, if you'd prefer, if you'd rather just pay five bucks for the next year and see if you like it again next year, you could do that.
1:34:14Yeah, and there's a one-week free trial, so if you don't even know, you can do a free trial.
1:34:20But you can also play for free forever, to some degree. And you just—what are the limits on the free game?
1:34:27Yeah, so for free, we just give you basically something that looks like what Wurtle gave you. We give you the daily puzzle every day, and you can play it every day.
1:34:38And if you miss one, you can't go back and play it again, but you can play the puzzle on the day every day.
1:34:44And we give you ten extra puzzles in the puzzle book a month, so there's a little bit extra if you wanna kind of play more than one a couple days.
1:34:53And that's it, and there's no ads or anything. We don't collect any data, we don't generate any analytics. It's just a fun game that you can play totally for free.
1:35:03So the no ads thing, to me, that's how I would do it too, but it's unusual? I mean, what's the thinking there?
1:35:13Well, so it's actually been—I mean, I've been making games for free that have ads in them for probably six years now.
1:35:22There was a point where I realized I would have to stop selling my games as a premium because I was being knocked off within 24 hours.
1:35:31And this was right around—I don't know if you remember or were familiar with the Threes 2048 thing?
1:35:36Yeah, I remember Threes.
1:35:38So Threes was this bespoke indie game that a bunch of my friends made, and it was this real phenomenon.
1:35:44And then a week into it, this game 2048 came out that was basically heavily influenced by Threes.
1:35:52A little different, but heavily influenced and totally free and just had a lot of ads.
1:35:57And it basically—that game made like a hundred times the revenue that Threes made, even though Threes came up with this whole idea and this new mechanic of interacting with things.
1:36:07And so I think being on the App Store, I looked at that and was like, "Well, geez, that's going to happen to me if I don't make my games free,
1:36:15so I need to think through how I can do free and how to make money with ads and rethink my whole process of what it looks like for somebody to be playing my game and have options,
1:36:27and make sure that nobody can undercut me."
1:36:29And I did that for a while. I don't know for sure that I'm never going to do ads again,
1:36:34but there's a lot of stuff that being in the ad ecosystem, I started to discover that really bothered me.
1:36:41Ads are—the libraries are big, so your apps get big.
1:36:46They show good ads right at the start, but the longer your app is on the store, the worse the ads get.
1:36:52And then all of a sudden they're like hawking weird drugs and weight loss things, even if you told them not to.
1:36:58They're like crashing your app and giving horrible bugs.
1:37:02Advertisers are always trying to scam the people who are clicking on their ads, and they try everything they can to get around the restrictions by ad providers.
1:37:12And the person who gets taken advantage of in that situation is me and the people who are playing my games.
1:37:19There was a whole thing where a lot of ad providers were just copying your clipboard, and they didn't tell anyone, and they certainly didn't tell me,
1:37:26and I was like, "Oh my god, I can't believe this is happening. This is like—I don't want to be a part of this."
1:37:31So I've really wanted to get away from ads for a very long time, but it's been tough because when I look back at my revenue,
1:37:38on most of my games, ads are accounting for 20 to 50 percent of the revenue from games.
1:37:44And so it's very difficult to be able to really say like—like to look at your numbers and be like, "Oh, you know, I can't run a business if I don't do this."
1:37:53This is part of the ecosystem, and it's part of what people come to expect from games.
1:37:57And they'll get mad at you. They won't play a game that they have to pay for, but they're happy to pay to play these games that like shove a thousand ads in your face.
1:38:05And so it was very frustrating, and this game, we felt like this is a really special game, and we really want to present it in a way that is impressive and maybe a little bit more generous than ever.
1:38:19It's also a game that we only want people to play once a day, so we wouldn't really be getting very much ad revenue from that anyway.
1:38:26And it's a way that we can really provide a very fair ask when we're asking people to play this.
1:38:34If you're going to enjoy a game once a day, then we can easily kind of be like, "All right, well that's all you get then if you're playing the free version."
1:38:42We're giving you what really feels like a full game, even though it's very restricted and small.
1:38:47And that kind of gave us this opportunity to try this new adventure.
1:38:51And so we thought, "You know what, maybe we can't make money from ads in this game, but what if we raise the price really substantially?"
1:38:59$12 is a lot more than we typically charge. And then maybe with subscriptions we can make up for that and give people another way that they could still spend closer to what we usually charge on a game.
1:39:10And it's been really amazing. I think people have--I've been really surprised by how many people have just gotten the $12 thing.
1:39:17Nobody has ever complained about the price so far. Everybody seems really happy with it, and people seem to be subscribing also.
1:39:24So it's been a really positive experience.
1:39:27Well that's awesome to hear, because nobody is outside the 7-day free trial yet.
1:39:34Right?
1:39:35Right?
1:39:36Or although I guess that would be--I guess you get the 7-day free trial through paying.
1:39:41No, no, when I look at my analytics it's like we've made like zero dollars from subscriptions because everybody's in the trial.
1:39:48Right.
1:39:49But that is great to hear. Is part of the thinking--I know we've spent so much time talking about how you're like--you really are.
1:39:57You're an artist who's driven by trying to make the coolest thing.
1:40:01But is part of the thinking like with 3s getting--let's just say they got ripped off. I remember writing about it.
1:40:08I just looked it up. I definitely linked to 3s back in 2014 because I loved the game. It was so much fun.
1:40:14Or it still is, but like a lot of games you just sort of play--I don't know. I played myself out of it.
1:40:20I did the same thing with Letterpress, which I loved. But eventually I was just like--and I was pretty good at Letterpress.
1:40:26I don't know why. There's some combination of the strategy and the word knowledge. I was really good at boxing people in.
1:40:35And I've heard Go players talk about that. And that Go is notoriously more difficult than chess for computers to beat the top human players because top Go players have an intuition.
1:40:47I had like a weird Letterpress intuition, and it just worked in my favor.
1:40:51So envious of that. That's a game that I always wished I was good at.
1:40:55And I'm usually really bad at games. I'm not a great word game player. But somehow Letterpress really fell in my sweet spot, and I was really good.
1:41:02And then eventually I got introduced to a friend of a friend who works at Apple. Because she's still at Apple, I'm not going to mention her name.
1:41:10But she could beat me like Neo dodging bullets. And I was like, "Oh my God!"
1:41:17And it's not what drove me away from Letterpress, but it was like I at least realized, "Okay, this is how good you can be."
1:41:24It was very interesting. It's like becoming a very good, really good high school tennis player, and then you play a pro.
1:41:32And it's like, "Oh, okay. There you go. I'm just going to be a recreational player." But I loved Letterpress.
1:41:37But is part of the thinking behind something like what games to actually go from prototype to actually, "Let's build this and make it real and ship it. Let's do that this year."
1:41:47Which is, I'm sure, just more work. Everything like that is always more work than you could ever imagine.
1:41:52But is part of it the idea that with the generator that you guys spent a lot of time building, it's really going to be hard to clone?
1:42:01Nobody's going to be able to clone NotWords in a good way in a weekend.
1:42:06You know, I actually thought that it would be really easy to clone. That was my big fear.
1:42:12A lot of the planning for this game was designed around the idea that it would be very simple to clone.
1:42:17Because building puzzles by hand is so easy. Right? So if building puzzles by hand is so easy, how hard could it be for the computer? Very hard, turns out.
1:42:25But, yeah, and the other thing that is very important to understand about cloning is a lot of people are not able to intuitively, quickly tell the difference between something that's bad and something that's good.
1:42:38And so with NotWords, somebody could probably clone it, and the puzzles could be totally mediocre, and they could still get a ton of traction and get a lot of attention and time.
1:42:47And then, because the puzzles are mediocre, people would start to feel like, "Oh, this actually isn't as good as I thought it was," and burn out on the concept because they experienced the bad version that they didn't even know.
1:42:58It's like if somebody decided that they didn't like hamburgers because they'd eaten at Burger King a lot. And it's like, "Oh, well, that's not the good version."
1:43:07But it looks like a hamburger. It's the platonic ideal of a hamburger. And so we actually made a ton of design decisions.
1:43:13They're called Burger King, for Christ's sake.
1:43:15Right! They have the crown. It's got to be a great burger. We made a lot of decisions in the game around that idea.
1:43:22So part of, also built into this sort of free no ads model is we were like, "Well, nobody can undercut us." Right?
1:43:30Because all these free games, their whole thing is like, "Yeah, we're going to throw a thousand ads at you, but it's free."
1:43:36And now we're like, "No, you can't even do that. Good luck making a game where you have crummy versions of our puzzles and you have no ads, and now you want people to pay for it. It's not going to happen."
1:43:46We'll see. I hate to issue this challenge. I'm sure someone's going to come and rip us off.
1:43:51But the other part of it was, the game, I've been trying to chase this game design for so long that I know that this game fits into this classic mode.
1:44:02I don't know if it'll be popular like Sudoku is popular, where it's famous all over the world. That would be amazing. I don't know if that's going to happen.
1:44:12But it fits the model. It's like the same structure as something like Sudoku.
1:44:18And so I really wanted to, my biggest goal was like, if this game becomes super popular and everybody's done a version of it, I want to make sure that when people look at our version,
1:44:28they know that we were the people who invented it, and this was the beginning of what this game was.
1:44:36And so we made a lot of choices around that structure. Part of it was doing it free. Part of it was just thinking about how we were going to do the polish on the app.
1:44:44Something I noticed, you know, there's a really big game on the App Store called Wordscapes. That's actually a pretty clever game.
1:44:51And as far as new word games go, I think it's really interesting. But the thing with Wordscapes is if you look at Wordscapes and you look at the clones, they look the same.
1:45:01The aesthetic and the design of Wordscapes is so bog-standard mobile. Everything's flat, there's some stock art in the background.
1:45:11Even though this is the game that invented it, it just looks like every other mobile game. And when I first got into it, I didn't even play Wordscapes for a while because I didn't even know that it was the original.
1:45:22I thought, "Well, this is just all clones." And we really wanted to make sure that when we built the game, it would be so obvious that it was not like these other things.
1:45:30That somebody wouldn't be able to clone our spit and polish. And that's why things like having the bunny be in the game, having the different soundscapes, really going for a Nintendo level of feel.
1:45:45And looking at Nintendo games and thinking about how does Nintendo do it? What are they interested in? What's their design aesthetic? And how do we work that into what we already know how to do?
1:45:56Yeah, that's a good way to put it. I'll just add before we move on that that's the one thing I don't like about Wordle, because it's a web game. There's no sound.
1:46:05And I like sound. It drives my wife. When I get divorced, it's going to be he wouldn't turn off the key clicks on his phone.
1:46:13I like the key clicks. I do. I like because it's the only haptic feedback you get on this flat keyboard. And I like them and my wife can't stand them, let alone if she's trying to fall asleep or something.
1:46:28So I do, of course, mute my phone when she's in bed. But sometimes I forget and it's like, I'm telling you, it's going to be the cause of divorce.
1:46:37But I wish Wordle had some sound. It would be, it would, I don't know. I get it. It's obviously not holding back Wordle's success. But let me take, wait, I had one more thing I wanted to say before we move on. I know we're going long. Sorry, but this is so fascinating.
1:46:54Oh, it's okay.
1:46:55Oh, for prototyping, what tools do you use?
1:46:59Ah, that's a good question. For the most part, we program our games in Unity, but we don't tend to start in Unity. I tend to start almost all of my game designs on a piece of paper or with cards or with dice or with pieces or banana grams or Scrabble tiles.
1:47:20One of my favorite artists is Saul Louit, and he's a conceptual artist and he makes these beautiful, or he made these beautiful works that were basically instructions. And then you would buy a copy of the instructions and people would come to your house from his studio and do the, follow the instructions on a wall and it would create this sort of generative piece of artwork.
1:47:43And Saul Louit has this really great piece called "Sentences on Conceptual Art" that is in itself kind of an art piece, even though he specifically says it isn't in the piece.
1:47:54And one of those sentences, one of the ideas of this whole piece is this thought that the conscious brain creates rational stuff and the subconscious brain creates irrational stuff.
1:48:07And irrational stuff is where the gold is, that like the magic of art, the magic of these beautiful things that you experience that you don't know how to understand, that that is all born in this subconscious mind.
1:48:19And for me, that's this like really sort of critical text in terms of understanding what my process is and how it works. And I have this very strong aversion to thinking too much about something.
1:48:33Like I think if I have an idea for a game, the most important thing is that I can sit down at the table, come up with whatever rules very quickly I need to come up with to be able to test the strange thing that came out of my subconscious.
1:48:46Because if I don't do that, if I think about it for too long, it's going to lose all of its magic. I'm going to over-design it into some direction that it's not meant to go and it's just going to be a thing that someone designed.
1:48:57And so for me, because of that, all of the tools that I like to work with are tools that require almost no effort, just cards or dice or something.
1:49:05Or if I do program, I don't like to program anything that's going to take more than three hours or four hours to program. It's very important to me that I can like get the idea down, play it right away.
1:49:16And I think that's why also a lot of my games are these sort of small ideas that are sort of very deep and have expanded into a lot of different spaces but are like fundamentally just like a very small core.
1:49:29Yeah, that's interesting. I love hearing that. And I was wondering how much you design on paper. I do. I know in the last... I speak of myself as though I still design things, but like when we designed Vesper back in the day, the Notes app, I did so much on paper.
1:49:46I just did, you know, and then paper to screenshots to, "Alright, but now let's make it real. Let's start building this because if we dick around too much with just these static things, we're going to go way too deep and too far before we know how it feels."
1:50:05And if you don't start making it real at some point, you know... And it is true. Like an idea in your head, it's sort of like a gas and it's all together for a while, but if you let it just sit as an idea for too long, it dissipates too much and it's gone.
1:50:25And you can remember that it was there, but it's no longer... Maybe more like a liquid. I don't know. It's like liquid and it's like it'll just drip out, you know? It's like you kind of got to freeze it and start making something out of it before it drips out of the leaky bucket that is your brain.
1:50:43Yeah, I think it's like, you know, people talk about inspiration, but nobody thinks of inspiration as something that you spent 30 hours thinking about. That's design, right? But before the design, you get the inspiration.
1:50:56And how much of the inspiration you can stay true to, for me, is a real function of how quickly I can work with it before it becomes boring or normal.
1:51:07I don't mean to dig into anything. You know, if you're uncomfortable talking about it, that's fine, but maybe you're not. I don't know. But it's like a couple of days into this, the first week of NotWords coming out, what's the split on iOS, Android, and the Steam versions so far?
1:51:24So I don't know what the Android stuff looks like. I haven't asked for those numbers because I don't really care. The Steam stuff, what's the split? Well, that's a very good question. I would say probably off the top of my head, I want to say it's like five to one iOS to Steam.
1:51:46But I'm not sure that that's 100% correct. I didn't look at the numbers this morning.
1:51:52I say this after telling you. I don't even know my analytics at Daring Fireball. So, you know, ballpark. But it's mostly, I guess what I'm interested in, is it primarily iOS at this point? Because it's new, and that's where, you know, your games are best known.
1:52:07And maybe the people who are most likely to appreciate the details that go into it are already on iOS.
1:52:15I think that's a big part of it, but I also think it plays great on computer, and I was really surprised how enjoyable it is on the computer. But, you know, it's a game design that's for the context of mobile. It's going to be better mobile.
1:52:29Basically, any game that is as good mobile as on the computer is better mobile, right? Because you have more situations where you can play it, you can open it up in an elevator or whatever. And so, I'm not surprised that it's doing better on iOS, but also it was kind of meant to, I guess.
1:52:49When we thought about bringing it to Steam, we wanted to bring it to Steam for a couple of very tactical reasons. So one of those reasons was we wanted to make sure that it would exist forever in the format we put it out.
1:53:02Because it's a Windows game, we never have to touch it again, it'll always be there no matter what. Somebody will figure out how to emulate it if they can't. So we've, like, there's an archival aspect to it.
1:53:14A second reason we wanted to put it on Steam is because we thought that this is the kind of game that would appeal to streamers, because we know there are people who stream crossword games.
1:53:23And Sudokus, right?
1:53:24And Sudokus. If you've got a mobile game, nobody's going to stream a mobile game on a phone. There's tech to do it, but it's just not something people do. So we wanted to be able to give streamers a key.
1:53:35And then the third reason, which is one that we didn't even fully realize until we released it, but it's hard to get press for games these days. There are not that many outlets.
1:53:44And being able to have something be on PC means we are opened up to a lot of other outlets that would not normally write about a game, like PC Gamer or CNET, potentially. So that was sort of the third reason.
1:53:57So Steam is, like, for us it was this spot where-- oh, and then the last reason is we want to start releasing my games on Steam more frequently, and Jack and Mike games when we create them on Steam also, just as another platform to start putting stuff onto.
1:54:11And this felt like the right game to take that leap with.
1:54:15So really for us, Steam is serving a bunch of utility and experimental services for us, and if we get money also on Steam, that's even better. But that wasn't our main goal.
1:54:29All right, let me take a break here and thank our third sponsor, and then we're at the home spread. I'm so thankful for your time.
1:54:34Sure, this is really fun. I really appreciate it.
1:54:36All right, let me thank our third sponsor. It's our good friends. I mean, good friends. I mean, this is our longest-running, most common sponsor. I love this company, too.
1:54:45Squarespace. Squarespace is where you can build your own website without being a web developer or knowing anything about web development, but puts you, the person who wants to build, create, design, tweak, run, update, check the stats, check the analytics.
1:55:07You want your own website. You don't have the technical ability. You don't know code. You don't know HTML, CSS. You don't know JavaScript.
1:55:16Squarespace lets you do it all. You don't know DNS. You don't know how to register domain names. Guess what? You can do it at Squarespace.
1:55:23They do everything, literally A to Z, of having your own website. Squarespace lets you do it without technical expertise, and even with that said, even though everything is visual, everything is drag and drop right in your browser, you still get access to their terrific, award-winning technical support.
1:55:46And it's just terrific. So many websites you interact with on a daily basis, like restaurants and places like that, are built on Squarespace. You would never know it.
1:55:56There is no, like, Squarespace look to a website. There's no logo or bug in the corner that says, "This is powered by Squarespace."
1:56:04It's just your website with your look, your feel. You start with a score of templates to choose from that range all sorts of different styles visually, design-wise.
1:56:16All of their templates scale great from the phone to a big desktop, and they're all tweakable and adjustable.
1:56:23You could have stores, and they handle all the stuff like commerce. You can do email campaigns where you can collect email subscribers and convert them into loyal customers and do it all with email templates that are just as easy to use as the website templates from Squarespace.
1:56:40They even have SEO tools that are actually healthy and not, like, weird and gross, but just ways to make sure that your website gets seen by the people who ought to be seeing it and help maximize your results in search engines.
1:56:53Because let's face it, that's how people are going to come to your website. It's just a great company and a great, great service, and they keep sponsoring the show because people from the show keep signing up with the code or, which I think happens a lot,
1:57:05people come to you, nerdy listener of the talk show, and say, "Can you help me build a website?" And you just say, "Hey, how about this? Go to Squarespace and give them this URL, squarespace.com/talkshow," and they get a free trial, 30 days, no credit card up front,
1:57:21full featured, everything they need to do, 30 days, and the credit comes back to the show, and they get the 30-day free code. And when you use that code after the free trial, you get 10% off your first purchase.
1:57:35You can prepay for a whole year, save 10% on the whole year just by using that code "talkshow." Go to squarespace.com/talkshow and remember that code "talkshow" when you or whoever you send to that URL signs up.
1:57:48My thanks to Squarespace. I would like to talk about, before we get, I want to talk about Playdate, but before we get there, the one last thing, and if I, a lot of times when I interview somebody, no matter how long it goes, there's always one thing that it's like, "Oh my God, that's like the first thing I wrote down at the top of my list of questions, and I forgot."
1:58:06Literally at the top of my list here of my notes for this conversation with you is about credit. And you open up Not Words, like most of your games, and it says Not Words game by Zach Gage, and I'm sorry, Jake's last name is...
1:58:25Jack Schlesinger.
1:58:26Jack Schlesinger. Jack Schlesinger. You know what's funny? So I misremembered Jack as Jake, but I was actually going to guess Schlesinger.
1:58:35Hey.
1:58:37But you don't see that a lot, and I've, I actually, like 10, 15 years ago gave a talk, I mean, actually I guess it was 15, at least 15 years ago, because it was at Macworld Expo, but I even gave a talk where it was like my top 10 issues with Apple at the time, and one of them was the fact that at old Apple, let's say classic Mac era Apple, the about boxes for Apple software had the names of the people at Apple who made the thing.
1:59:05And at some point, and it was definitely a Steve Jobs thing when they came back, they stopped that. And policy-wise, soup to nuts, all throughout Mac OS X, there's nowhere where you can go and say about text edit or about mail or about any of the apps, and you don't get credits.
1:59:23And the idea, you know, Jobs' notion ostensibly was that he thought that Apple's rivals were using about boxes to recruit Apple people.
1:59:35I, you know, he was obsessed with, what do you call, not recruiting, but what's it called when you're poaching, right? Which is very much, I'm not like an anti-capitalist, but it's definitely the perspective of the CEO of a company, whereas from the ground up, it's called taking a better job, right?
1:59:55Which is actually something people do and should be able to do, and you know, that's how you build a career, and if you want to keep these people, hiding their names isn't the way to do it, it's keep them happy and pay them fairly and well.
2:00:09And so I don't think that was quite it. I think it was also just sort of an irrational part of the Apple brand. You know, they just want everything to be from Apple. It's Apple. They want Apple's name to be on the credits.
2:00:20And you see that, you just, but even outside Apple, you see it, you know, there just aren't a lot of games that open like that, but other forms of artwork, you know, certainly books, you buy a book, there's the author's name is on the cover.
2:00:33You watch a movie or a TV show, they always start with opening credits, and they tell you who the stars of the show are and the producers, you know, but then you get, and the last opening credits are the writer and the director.
2:00:48And because writing and directing are the most creative, the most responsible for the thing that you're watching, and they always get credit. And you know, I know in the entertainment industry, it's actually written into the union rules, you know, for the Writers Guild and the Directors Guild, but it's just part of it.
2:01:09And you know, you come from the world of real art, you know, real physical art, you know, that's, you know, I don't mean to be... Hang on your wall art. Right. Hang on your wall art.
2:01:19It would be absurd if you went to a show and they didn't put the name of the artists on, or like a museum, like imagine going to a museum and they don't tell you who painted this.
2:01:31It would be absurd. But that's sort of how the computer world has gone. Like, you just go to a lot of websites and you never see the names of the people who made it.
2:01:40Yeah, I... Oh man, I don't want to talk for a whole nother hour about this. I have so many feelings about this. I think one thing to bring up is that this has been a very contentious topic sort of behind the scenes in the game industry for a really long time. Not just right now with the way that credits are given, but historically, you know, games were companies.
2:02:03And then for a minute when EA showed up, it was all about the people who made the games. And then very quickly, it suddenly became the companies wanted to be the companies again, and they hid those names.
2:02:16And it was similar to sort of the Jobsian stuff that you're describing. Companies wanted to have the credit and own the games and sort of take over.
2:02:26And I think when indies started to really blow up, at least around the time that I showed up, a lot of people, you know, you're just one person and you're making a game in this space and you're trying to figure out how to make money.
2:02:38And your first thought is, you know, I need to look like the other players in this space. I should have a company because if I have a cute logo and a good company name, that's how people, you know, that's what I'm supposed to do. That makes me look professional.
2:02:52And I think to some extent, actually, despite coming from art and being used to signing the things that I do with my literal name, I think I kind of fell into this name first approach because when I signed up with Apple, I didn't have a company and you could sign up just as yourself.
2:03:10And so always it was my games were from Zach Gage. That's where they're from. And I think it took me a little bit into my career to sort of start to really look at this and say, no, this is the right approach.
2:03:24This is something that I'm not, this is not just a default. I'm going to figure out how to embrace this.
2:03:29And one of the reasons that I thought that that was really important is I am, for me, one of the big things besides the critical thinking thing is this game literacy thing and getting people to understand games and to be able to understand the game industry as an artistic industry.
2:03:48And when I look at something like film and I look at film directors and think about, well, what is it that got film directors to be able to be looked at as artistic?
2:04:01And I think it's that, you know, the age in film where you go, oh, this is a Hitchcock movie or this is a Spielberg movie, right?
2:04:09It's that moment where you can watch three Spielberg movies and three Hitchcock movies, and even though they're all about different things, you can see that cohesiveness between those movies because there's a person at the top that you know.
2:04:23Whereas like if you watch three MGM movies, right, that doesn't give you anything.
2:04:29And then once you know a name, you can go, oh, when I grow up, I want to be Steven Spielberg. I want to do the thing that Michael Crichton does and write books.
2:04:40You have to be able to see the human behind the art for you to be able to see the art sometimes.
2:04:48And I think that's really important for games, not just from the artistic standpoint, but also even from the standpoint of getting more people into games and not as making games through the game industry, but as being indie, as being able to look at games and say, oh, I could make a game, I could be a part of this.
2:05:06And so those are a huge number of the things that I think about when I'm looking at this approach of like really putting these names up front.
2:05:16That's so well said. And it's so, you know, it's so interesting with directors. I'm fascinated by it. And that was my credit on Vesper. I was credited as the director because that's how I saw my role.
2:05:28Brent Simmons was writing the code. Dave Whiskus was doing all the actual design. And I was just in the middle directing it and saying, yes, this is how it should feel. This is how it should work.
2:05:38And, you know, it wasn't I wasn't trying to be cute. I just didn't know how else to describe it. But it worked out well, even though the app was not a financial success, it worked out well as a way of working and conceptualizing what my role was.
2:05:51And it's funny because you can have directors whose work is so idiosyncratically distinctive. Wes Anderson pops into mind, right? It would be very, very difficult.
2:06:03You know, I'm sure he's also so talented. If he wanted to make a movie that didn't look and feel like a Wes Anderson movie as we know it, I'm sure he could.
2:06:12But it's like what he wants to make is so clearly of his style, you know, and somebody else who I'm a huge fan of, Sofia Coppola, is more of a chameleon.
2:06:24And I don't think if you showed me a new Sofia Coppola movie, but there weren't credits, I don't know that I would be able to guess that it was her until maybe I got to the end of the movie.
2:06:36And the themes and little things and it's like maybe I would have her on the list, but it's a deliberate choice on her part to sort of bend her style to the structure of the thing.
2:06:51But it's once you know the themes that she keeps coming back to, it's very distinctive and I think so important. And I just love that. I don't know.
2:06:59You could make anything, honestly, paint drawing on a wall, a game by Zach Gage, and I'm going to download it and try it.
2:07:07I'm glad you're enjoying them all.
2:07:10I always go back to paint drawing on a wall because in the late 90s when word came out that Stanley Kubrick finally had a new movie coming out, Eyes Wide Shut, my one friend who was also a big Kubrick fan said, "If Stanley Kubrick made a movie of paint drawing on a wall, I'd watch it at least once."
2:07:27Just because I trust him so much that somehow he'll make it engaging.
2:07:31Right, you can already start to think in your mind like what could be happening? Like that would make this great.
2:07:37What would it sound like? What kind of creepy music?
2:07:40Are there shadows going by that mean things?
2:07:42Hitchcock's another one. I just watched, it's one of those YouTube rabbit holes, you know. You start going down the YouTube rabbit hole of anything and it's like, "Oh my God, YouTube is so amazing."
2:07:52But it was like a couple, I got into a couple of Hitchcock YouTube videos because I linked to, I forget what the context was, Rope.
2:08:00It was something with Glenn Fleischmann about doing something in a single take and Rope is a Hitchcock movie that simulates 90 minutes of a continuous take of a murder mystery.
2:08:12But they could only shoot just under 10 minutes of film at a time in a film canister and so he disguises all the cuts by like panning the camera across somebody's back so there's a moment where all you see is the black of somebody's suit jacket.
2:08:26And then when you get to the end of the pan, it's actually a new cut of film. It's ingenious editing wise, but it's actually a very good movie. I would recommend it.
2:08:35It's also, I was like, "When the hell did he make that?" Because I remember I haven't seen it in forever and now it's like near the top of my to watch list again because I haven't seen it in like 25 years.
2:08:44But it's in color, but it's a 1946 movie, which is to me like breaking my mind. I was like, "I didn't think they had color movies." And then I'm like, "Oh no, The Wizard of Oz and Snow White was 1937 so that was animation."
2:08:58But somehow I didn't think they shot movies. But anyway, if somebody ever found a lost Hitchcock movie and there were no credits, the whole movie was edited together, but there were no credits and you watched it, you'd say, "Oh, this is a hit.
2:09:12What the hell is this? This is an Alfred Hitchcock movie. There's no mistaking it. Nobody else could make it." I mean, like Brian De Palma is sort of admittedly a huge, huge Hitchcock fan and makes Hitchcock-style plots, but they don't look like a Hitchcock movie.
2:09:29They look like a Brian De Palma movie. It's so interesting to me and I just love that you put your name on it.
2:09:36The last topic I want to talk about, and it's the rare instance where I can parlay off the previous episode of the show, is talking about Panic's playdate, which you, I guess, have some experience with?
2:09:49Yeah, it's funny. Mine, I literally, it arrived right before we did this call. I was like, "Oh no, I gotta go run downstairs and pick this up." But also, yeah, I made one of the games in the first season, so I've had one for a very long time. It's cool.
2:10:06I know that the way they're unfurling the season, that the games are sort of a surprise, so I'm not pressing for any spoilers. I never ever press my guess for that. So if the game itself is a secret, I don't even know, because my playdate is still lower.
2:10:22It's coming soon, but I wasn't quick enough to do the pre-order. If you don't want to tell me what it is, you don't have to tell me, or is it known what the game is?
2:10:31Yeah, it's a little known. There have been a little bit of previews around it, but I'm very curious how people will take it. It's a game that I designed a very long time ago, because I got in working with it almost right at the start.
2:10:44But it's a take on Snake, because I wanted to do something with buttons. So it's a Snake game, like the Nokia Snake game, but you can jump, and you can jump onto yourself and ride on yourself and jump over yourself, and so it kind of turned Snake a little bit into maybe a little bit like a skateboarding game.
2:11:01But I just wanted to make something that was very simple and would fit the device and would be the kind of game that reminded me of the kinds of games that made me excited about the device, which is really the thing that is like...
2:11:17The first thing that I really thought about when they started pitching this thing is, I remember in high school making games, and it was cool making games and showing them to friends on the computer, but the thing that really took off amongst my friends was...
2:11:31Do you remember the TI-83 graphing calculator?
2:11:34Yes, definitely.
2:11:36So that was this wild graphing calculator that you could use to plot things, but you could also make games for it. It had this very crummy programming language.
2:11:46But it also was a LED black and white screen, but it was bit-mapped instead of those 888...
2:11:56The best game you could make on an even older calculator was spelling the word "boobies" upside down or something like that.
2:12:06Right, this had a real screen though. And so people did all kinds of weird stuff. Somebody ported Legends of Zelda Game Boy game to it, which seems impossible to imagine.
2:12:16But also it was very easy to make dumb little games for friends and give them to them and let them play them on a physical piece of hardware.
2:12:25And that was just this totally magical thing in high school, and I remember playing Snake a lot on it, and so I wanted to kind of explore that a little bit and do a little homage.
2:12:37But the thing that I wanted to talk about at the playdate, I remember, so on your last show you were talking about how exciting it is that Panic is making these tools for this thing.
2:12:46And Panic is one of the best tool-making companies that's out there. And that is exactly what I'm excited about more than the thing, is this potential for a community.
2:12:57And I wanted to just talk a little bit about... Are you familiar with Pico 8 at all?
2:13:02I've heard of it. You tell me what it is. I know what you're talking about.
2:13:07So Pico 8, first of all, there's a huge space of indie game design tools that are very simple, some of which are even directly referenced.
2:13:17Like Pulp is directly inspired by something called Bitsy. And there's Bitsy, there's Twine, there's something called PuzzleScript.
2:13:25And all of these very successful little tools have these niche communities.
2:13:30And I think one of the things that makes these tools very approachable and fun for people to work with is that there are these incredible constraints around what you can create.
2:13:40So if you make something in Twine, it's going to be a website, it's got to be basically text, even though you can have pictures, you're going to click hyperlinks to move through it.
2:13:48If you're making something in Bitsy, you have a very limited amount of space for your aesthetic, you really can only use the arrow keys to move around.
2:13:55There's all of these constraints. And a couple years ago, this person, Zep, came up with this thing called Pico 8, and they called it a fantasy console, which is this incredible idea.
2:14:08Which is basically, it's like he invented this console that doesn't exist, but it has all the constraints of a real old console.
2:14:16So when you program, your program length is specifically limited, you can only have so many characters.
2:14:22You can only use certain kinds of sound stuff. You can only have so many pieces of art. You can only have so many colors.
2:14:32And all of these constraints work together in this very cool way because they create this very constrained tool, but it's not constrained to a kind of game.
2:14:42It's constrained in other ways. And what that did is it created this amazing community, and so Pico 8 has a BBS system where you can post games, they can be shown in just an image, and it downloads into the software and you can play it.
2:14:58Of all the spaces in indie games that I'm excited about for young people to be creating interesting stuff, Pico 8 is by far the most exciting. There's people doing weird experiments, there's people learning to program, there are famous indies creating prototypes in that space that then go on to be turned into bigger games that are making tens of millions of dollars.
2:15:19It's this incredibly amazing, thrilling space. And the thing that is weird about it is after Zep created this fantasy console, a lot of people have gone and said, "Okay, well we're going to make a fantasy console and it's going to have these different rules."
2:15:34And none of them have ever taken off in any way really at all to rival Pico 8.
2:15:41And I feel like the playdate is the first thing I'm seeing that isn't just a derivative of this idea of a fantasy console, but is an evolution of this idea of a fantasy console.
2:15:52In that it's got all of the tools and all of the smarts and all of the care that goes into creating the toolchain for this because it's panic, but it's also not a fantasy console. It's a real console.
2:16:04And that's so amazing to me that they were able to pull that off, and I feel like there's this incredible chance to have not just one great video game, indie game, artistic exploration community, but two.
2:16:20And one of them be focused on this beautiful little yellow thing. And that's the thing that I'm so excited about. It's not just the tools, it's that there's this holistic thing happening that is giving us an opportunity for a community, a new community, in a way that is very uncommon.
2:16:39It's that whole "everything is a remix" mentality or going from improv comedy where you just start with an idea and this, and it's like, what if you took the Pico 8 fantasy console and instead of just tweaking limits, what if we said instead of 48 kilobyte limited, we'll make it 64.
2:16:59What if the "and" is "and we'll actually make a little handheld thing, like an actual thing, and we'll sell it for like $179." And then immediately somebody says, "Of course, well that sounds like a nightmare."
2:17:14And they're like, "Yeah, but maybe we could." And then they look, and wouldn't it be fun? And that's sort of the backstory. It was, and it took panic longer than I think they thought it would. But not too much longer, it's shipping.
2:17:29You know, I think they announced earlier than they probably wish they had because they had an opportunity to be featured in a, I forget the magazine, but it's a really, really-- Oh, Edge. Yeah. Yeah, Edge, right? And I don't even know if they regret it. I think it's a, you know, why not if you can get that opportunity?
2:17:46But it makes Playdate seem later than I think it's fairly, would fairly be deemed to consider that it is because it was announced then, you know?
2:17:57I think if you look at it like as the process though, I think what you end up seeing is this, there's, some people really know how to do a process. Like the people who are the best at stuff, it's not that they're coming up with an amazing idea.
2:18:14It's that once they have an idea, they know how to chase it down and build it into something that's really amazing. And if you look at what the Playdate was, like when I got into the Playdate, they basically were, explained to me, you know, we're going to try to have 52 games and we're going to put this thing out and, and every week of the year, you're going to get a new game and it'll be some very small experience and we're just going to contract a bunch and, and it'll be a big surprise to everybody and that'll be the thing. Right.
2:18:41And then I think the longer it took them to do the hardware, it sort of put the screws to them on the software side and on thinking about it. It's like, you know, if, if you've got a couple of people working on hardware and they're working on it for almost eight years, you've still got other people on the project.
2:19:01Right.
2:19:01Who have to figure out what they're doing and what they're paying attention to. And I think the very first thing they realized was, wow, a lot more developers want to get involved in this than we thought. Like we actually can't find all the cool developers.
2:19:12So we need to hire someone who can like do developer outreach and start to find out more developers and start to find out what kinds of things developers need. And so they got it to more people and then they started to realize like, oh, well, you know, there are even more people.
2:19:27It's not just this audience of, of people who can code, who make good games that we want to reach out to. Like what if we could reach out to everybody? What if we could have a tool where we're in this space now and we're seeing all this stuff?
2:19:38Maybe there's stuff we could make that would make it available to everybody that anybody could code a thing for this. And I don't think you would necessarily see that if they had shipped the Playdate three years ago.
2:19:48Right.
2:19:48I think a lot of this stuff developed as the excitement around the product got bigger and they had to start to think about like, well, what is this opened up? What kind of doors can we find now where we can build stuff for this?
2:20:03Yeah. And you know, it was the previous episode with Michael Simmons where we talked about Playdate at the end. And one of the analogies, you know, we mentioned the Pulp system, which is the web-based thing that is very visual and therefore because it's visual and it's in the web and you don't have to conceptualize the game as source code in your head, you can visualize it, conceptualize it, turn it from idea to a game.
2:20:26You can actually install on a Playdate and play. It's so accessible to more people because that's how different people speak. And the analogy I didn't, I wanted to make but didn't make last week was to PostScript, which people forget or don't know.
2:20:41But Adobe PostScript is a programming language and you could write it by hand. I had a professor at Drexel who did his PhD thesis on PostScript and he showed us his demos and they were amazing.
2:20:55And the source code, it's not the easiest programming language to use for sure. It's not like writing assembly language, but like with just a ridiculously short number of lines of code, he'd make these unbelievable vector images.
2:21:08And then you could, you know, the displays at the time were incapable of proving that they were vector, but you could just keep zooming in to show that, oh, that's a vector because you just keep zooming and zooming and it just is more intricate.
2:21:20But it's clearly Illustrator that made PostScript something for the most people and people who are artists because you just drag a line, you make a curve. How do you adjust the curve? You drag a handle and you do it visually, right?
2:21:34And it's like, Pulp could be that sort of thing for budding game developers or even if it's just game designers, you know, like we talked about prototyping before and maybe to really take an idea and see it to completion, maybe you'd have to graduate from Pulp to their fuller SDK in Lua or C or something like that.
2:21:53But you can get something that's an actual game, not just like a bunch of index cards. And again, I'm a paper person, but proving that a game is a good idea is actually having it on a playdate and pushing buttons and making things happen and having fun is different than flipping through a bunch of index cards where you show what the screens would look like.
2:22:16I think if the playdate becomes very successful, we're going to see a lot of incredible games that are done entirely in Pulp. I think one of the things that is very easy to forget about with games is that, you know, like a game doesn't frequently require the bleeding edge of technology.
2:22:35Sometimes, sure, but most of the time -- I mean, you can make a game with a pencil and a tablecloth at a restaurant and play it. You don't need anything. And I think really often the thing that new game designers need or students of game design need is constraints.
2:22:52That's the thing that you actually need to make a game because otherwise it's very difficult to focus and move in a direction. And so I think these tools that give us interesting, compelling constraints and then also a really meaningful payoff are always the most powerful tools.
2:23:09And that's why Pico 8 was really successful, and I hope that'll be the case with the playdate.
2:23:14I personally also -- and again, it's nostalgia because I came of age in the '80s with the black and white monochrome Mac, but I love the aesthetic of just black and white, and I love the Atkinson dithering algorithm to do things that you just can't believe aren't grayscale but are really just black and white pixels, and you use the right algorithm and you can do this.
2:23:39But the funny thing is that as limited as the playdate is, it is so much more powerful than a 1984 Macintosh. So you can do things in black and white on the playdate screen that you never, ever, ever -- even Bill Atkinson himself could never have done, like animate something that's using this complicated algorithm for the dithering effect and have it just be completely live at reasonable frames per second.
2:24:05Yeah, I think that's one of the most delightful things about the devices. I think people will play some of these games and just be absolutely in awe about what this looks like.
2:24:17You think a black and white screen looks one way and then you play this thing that is just animated in an incredible way, but then at the same time, if you're trying to make a game for this, the ask couldn't be lower.
2:24:33You know, you've got to make a little character in black and white. Sure, anyone can do that. It's great.
2:24:39Right, and it brings me back to those early days, decades ago, on the classic Mac where you could open up anything in ResEdit and just -- I miss ResEdit so much. Right? I know you do, because I know that you did the same thing as if an icon really bugged you, or you just wanted to just have fun. You could just open it up in ResEdit, open the icon, and you had a little pixel editor that was really well done and had a pencil tool and a fill tool and an erase tool.
2:25:08You had undo, and you could just make a little thing, and you'd see the zoomed up version next to the shrunk down version, so you could see if the little tricks you were using to draw the pixel by pixel art actually looked good at real size and then make your own little icons.
2:25:23And then all of a sudden, the button for whatever, the icon for whatever, looked the way you designed it and not the way that it shipped on however you got it.
2:25:39On top of that, you could add little menu items that you could never hook up into doing anything, or you could go look at the assembly. The thing that was amazing about ResEdit is it really was the view source of the Mac.
2:25:56And even though the source you viewed was basically impassable because it was compiled down to assembly, it was incredible. It was amazing as a kid to have this tool that let me look inside anything and have it basically be like, "Yeah, this is a thing. Someone made it. This is what it looks like inside."
2:26:15Yeah, and you could see this is what it looked like to the creator. You're just the user. You got this copy of the app, and you've cracked it open in ResEdit. You just open it, and you're looking at these resources in the exact same way that the developer and designers who made the app were looking at it and making it and tweaking it.
2:26:36Yeah, and then you could tweak it.
2:26:38Yeah, exactly. It was such a great way to get you to feel like, "Hey, I could do this too."
2:26:43Yeah, it was amazing.
2:26:45Well, Zach, this was absolutely a wonderful, wonderful discussion. I'm so happy to have you on the show. I'll have you back because this is too good, and I have questions left, so I'll save them for the next time.
2:26:57Great. I'd love to come back. I love being on this. This was a really fun conversation.
2:27:01It feels like a reasonable guess given the last 15 years of your career that you'll probably have future games.
2:27:10Yes.
2:27:12I will say this. If I could ask one bonus question. How much, when you set out, did you set out to be somebody who makes a lot of little games as opposed to, you know, your life's work is this one masterpiece game?
2:27:28I don't think I set out to do anything. I'm someone who operates very in the moment, and I always just want to do the thing that I'm excited about and then get it out because I'm afraid that if I don't get it out, it'll never show up.
2:27:43And all I want to do is have the thing be out and be able to talk about it. So I don't know that I set out to do anything, but I've always been the kind of person who makes a lot of small stuff, so that was, I think, going to be how it went.
2:27:55All right. That's a perfect way to end the show. I want to thank, in addition to Zach Gage and his wonderful new game, NotWords, which you can find on the App Store and on Steam and on the Play Store, I'm going to thank our sponsors.
2:28:07We had Squarespace, where you can build your own website, and Memberful, where you can monetize your passion with membership, and Collide, endpoint security for teams at Slack. Thank you, Zach.
2:28:18Thank you.