0:00:00There's been some drama in the rumor community recently.
0:00:04You sent me the link to... what was the guy's name? The guy who always had the
0:00:08dreams? Kang. Oh, I love to dream in Kang and yeah.
0:00:12Yeah, so well tell me about... for people who don't know, tell me about Kang.
0:00:18So there was a few, like, I think like a lot of people who maybe listen to this
0:00:21show are familiar with the American-based reporters like Mark
0:00:25Germin or Jon Prosser, Evie Leakes, I don't know how to say it, Ev Leaks, Evie Leaks.
0:00:30Yeah. There's just, there's a bunch of them,
0:00:31just European-based too, but there was a growing contingent coming from China
0:00:35where all the supply chain is. They had access to a lot of information
0:00:38and that included Love to Dream and Kang and I don't know where Dylan DKT was
0:00:43based, no idea, but there were quite a few people who were primarily Twitter leakers.
0:00:48Which is... Or Weibo.
0:00:51Right, which is weird, like, because I don't even understand what the... and I'm not so cynical as to
0:00:59suggest that the only reason anybody would do anything is to be remunerated for it financially.
0:01:08You know, there's certainly a lot of things I've done that I just, you know, give out to the world.
0:01:14But it's the rumor thing in particular has often seemed, you know, there's always been
0:01:19rumor sites go all the way back to ThinkSecret. I mean, ThinkSecret isn't even going all the way
0:01:24back. There were sites in the 90s, you know, I forget some of the names, but I think there was
0:01:29one, MacRumors, which is not to be confused with Mac OS Rumors. Or no, Mac OS Rumors, not to be
0:01:36confused with the current, you know, long-running site MacRumors. I don't get the leaking on
0:01:42Twitter thing, like what the idea is, but I guess it's just, you know, just for fun, for kicks.
0:01:48It's for the lulz. They're like young and they have this information and they want to share it
0:01:51and they get attention for sharing it. So was Kang someone in addition to I Love to Dream,
0:01:57is he Kang would dress up his predictions as like dreams?
0:02:04Maybe because I'm not familiar with the Weibo postings as much as I am the people who
0:02:09summarized them. But he would come out like right before an event and basically just list out what
0:02:14was going to be in the event. So it was never early, early on, like Mike Berman might start a
0:02:18rumor or might report on a rumor three years before it happens. This was like a week or so
0:02:23before it happened, but they were highly accurate. Right. And the idea here is that there's somehow
0:02:30been a crackdown on them, but nobody is quite sure what it is. I will put a link in the show notes to
0:02:38this MacRumors story talking about it, which goes back to June of last year. So it's not news, but
0:02:45it leads to speculate, you know, people are thinking, is it Apple that cracked down?
0:02:50Is it the supply chain? Because it seems to me like some of these leaks are clearly not just from
0:02:57the supply chain, but from Asia, you know, and maybe English is the second language.
0:03:03And is it, you know, is it second level? It's not like someone in Cupertino is directing some kind
0:03:10of crackdown on Twitter leaks of Apple Rumors, but that, you know, from Cupertino to the supply chain,
0:03:17like, hey, this, you know, this leak seemed to know, you know, an awful lot about this component,
0:03:22which we know is only sourced from you. And then the component maker is cracking down somehow.
0:03:29It's just, yeah, I mean, to your earlier point, like this kind of stuff is just,
0:03:34it's part of human culture. There have been movie and TV Rumor sites and papers and rags,
0:03:40like a lot of the Rumor sites started off as actual newsletters and papers for years. It's
0:03:45just stuff people are interested in. Like, and the more secrecy there's around like a Marvel or Star
0:03:49Wars project, the more people are interested and Apple's like that for electronics. And I think
0:03:54that the main difference we're seeing here is that in the US and in North America and in Europe,
0:04:00are very different kinds of protection for media because we call them leakers, but like Mark
0:04:04Gurman is not a leaker. John Prosser is not a leaker. They are given information by leakers,
0:04:08and then they report on it and that is protected. But in China, the laws are very different. And it
0:04:14looks like one of the aspects was, I'm going to go back to the early days for a while, when the,
0:04:19before the Verge was the Verge, they were, this is my next. And they published a rumor of an iPhone
0:04:235, a report of an iPhone 5 that was teardrop shaped famously, infamously, and a case company
0:04:29went and made a ton of cases for it and it never existed, but they lost everything in that. And so
0:04:35one of the, one of the statements we made in these, I don't know if they're lawsuits, if they're
0:04:39demand letters, is that you are not only giving away our trade secrets by releasing this information
0:04:44early, but you are potentially costing people in the accessory market money because some of these
0:04:49things are not accurate and they're acting on them as though they are accurate. Right. And you don't
0:04:53want to, I don't want to make light of it because I mean, if it's happening in China, it could be,
0:04:57it could be worse, you know, like you get like a cease and desist letter in the US and it's like,
0:05:02well, you, you know, you get to sit there and think about, well, do I comply? Do I call my
0:05:06own lawyer? Do I just rip it up? What do I do? And it's like, you know, worse comes to worse,
0:05:11you're just going to get another letter and, you know, you face some sort of legal consequences,
0:05:15perhaps, but you know, in China, you know, it could be a knock on the door and it's, you know,
0:05:19not good. And I really don't, yeah, but we do have rumors to discuss. I do want to discuss them,
0:05:28but before that, I was thinking first thing we could do is talk about, oh, I have some follow-up,
0:05:35do you mind? Oh, no, I love it. Important follow-up. Last, my last episode was with Jason
0:05:40Snell and I think I offhandedly mentioned, we were talking about Apple TV, we were talking about his
0:05:46report, the whole, our Apple report cards for 2021 and talking about Apple TV and, and a sort of
0:05:55limbo that Apple TV, the hardware platform seems to be in within Apple where it's not like they're
0:06:04disinterested. They just updated it last year. They made a better remote, but they also don't
0:06:08seem fully interested there. You know, they're somewhere in between. And I was talking about
0:06:16hooking up HomePods to an Apple TV to use as your sound system and how really truly happy I am with
0:06:24two home, two full-size HomePods hooked up to my Apple TV. And then I mentioned something to the
0:06:29effect of not being able to do that with HomePod minis, which I kind of knew was glossing over the
0:06:37details, but it's, I should get into the details because I got a couple of emails saying, well,
0:06:41no, you can hook HomePod minis up to Apple TV. I will put a link in the show notes to the Apple
0:06:47support document. And the gist is HomePod mini does not support Dolby Atmos 5.1 or 7.1 surround
0:06:57sound. Long story short. And I also think that even without getting into the technical details
0:07:04of which specs like Dolby this, Dolby that, that it does or does not support, they're just not big
0:07:09enough. They, for my living room, it's less about the technical aspects maybe even than just the
0:07:14sound quality. Two HomePods fill my living room with very good sound that has room to go. We can
0:07:21turn it up as loud as we feel is pleasant and there's still room to go. I don't think two HomePod
0:07:26minis would. And it is kind of curious to me that they, I mean, you and I can talk about it. I mean,
0:07:32I don't know. I know you care about the HomePods too, but it is weird that HomePod is left in a
0:07:37situation where there is a HomePod mini and there is no regular, there is, there are no other HomePods.
0:07:42The only one is the mini, which doesn't really make it the mini anymore. It actually is the only
0:07:46HomePod available. Yeah, it's, it's stupefying. And also Apple canceled the regular, the OG HomePod
0:07:53biggie without replacing it, which is not something they typically do if they intend to make a
0:07:57next-generation product, unless that next-generation product is so far out, doesn't make any sense.
0:08:02And I'm exactly with you. Like with the minis, you get very little bass and they're basically
0:08:062.0 stereo. And with the original HomePods, you get a ton of bass and they will support spatial
0:08:12audio and Dolby Atmos. So you'll have everything from 2.1 to whatever, 9.1, whatever your, whatever
0:08:18the source media can handle. And it's a profound difference. I think a lot of it was just Apple
0:08:24started, Apple tried to do the iPod Hi-Fi again. They wanted, they realized that a bunch of audio
0:08:28products, a lot of people don't have good audio solutions in all of their rooms. And they just
0:08:33wanted to make a box that you could drop in any room, in any place in that room. And it would
0:08:36sound good no matter where it was in the room. And then they happened substantially, added Siri
0:08:41as a control mechanism, not happenstantly, but conveniently because there was no display. And
0:08:46it took them five years to develop it. And in that time, Amazon and Google littered the world with
0:08:51commodity smart speakers that didn't have the audio capability at all, but drove the price down and
0:08:57the expectations up for what a home assistant should be. And so they basically brought a very
0:09:02expensive speaker to a commodity speaker market. And it never, it never got good media, never got
0:09:07good footing. A lot of people love it. They love it so much. They buy everyone they can find on
0:09:11eBay, myself included. I have the same setup as you, but there was just no market for it. And the
0:09:17mini sort of hits at that idealized price point, that new commodity price point of about a hundred
0:09:21bucks, but nothing replaced that home pod. Like the Google version isn't as good. There's, there's
0:09:26the Sonos version is okay, but Sonos is a fundamentally different product than Apple.
0:09:31And I would love it. There's rumors of a home pod with an iPad style screen and a home pod mixed
0:09:36with an Apple TV. That'd be a sort of a home theater pod, but I would also just love maybe
0:09:41a little bit less expensive, but every bit is good replacement for that home pod.
0:09:45It's the other factor is eliminating wires, right? Like that is a very Apple like thing. And I know,
0:09:55you know, the whole, it's not like Apple is the only company that is interested in making wireless
0:09:58products. You know, the whole, you know, AirPods sort of burst. I know they weren't the first
0:10:04wireless headphones for consumers, but they're the first ones to sort of break through into the
0:10:09mainstream. And now everybody's coming out with ones that are meant for the masses. Sony has some
0:10:16new ones that even have a good name. I forget the name of it, but it's no longer named like XDR 5776.
0:10:23It's got like a real name, but it's, you know, home theaters notoriously. You try to keep it.
0:10:29You're like, ah, we can, you know, get rid of this, get rid of that, get all the way down. Even if
0:10:32you get down to one box, we're going to do everything through this, you know? And it's like,
0:10:36well, but then you kind of, you know, how can you, yeah, you need a second box. We need a receiver
0:10:41for the speakers and we need, or this or that, and everything's connected with wires and you've got
0:10:45these wires going play. And it's like, so part of the, it's not just physical decluttering of like
0:10:54your living room or wherever you have your TV set up. It's almost like mental decluttering of
0:10:58simplifying things like wireless is better, right? It's, you know, it's, it goes back to
0:11:03anything. Everything that goes wireless is sort of better. Like almost, I mean, I don't know what
0:11:08percentage of people still connect their computers to physical ethernet, Jack, but certainly not
0:11:15many. And the ones who do are doing it for very specific reasons. Wi-Fi really changed that. And
0:11:21the HomePod wireless connection to the Apple TV, it's really remarkable because you think,
0:11:29ah, it's going to have latency or the, you know, latency with the video, like maybe the
0:11:34lips won't be in sync with the audio, or it's going to put a delay on using the remote control.
0:11:39You hit pause and it'll take a frag, you know, now it's all, it all feels just as fast as any
0:11:44kind of wired connection to speakers. It's, it's, you know, and, and it's pretty easy to set up.
0:11:49It is a very Apple-like solution and it's a product that they've gotten rid of with no
0:11:55replacement. It's kind of strange. I feel like the rumor of the one that has like, you know,
0:12:02I know Facebook makes a thing. There's a couple other companies that make these speakers with
0:12:06a screen that I could see maybe them making that product. It's sort of, I mean, I can imagine other
0:12:14scenarios, but it sounds like a kitchen product is something that people would put on their kitchen
0:12:19counter. Or a grandparent product. They just want to FaceTime with the kids and don't want to bother
0:12:23with anything else. Yeah, but I don't see Apple making that. I feel like, you know, if the
0:12:28grandparents have an iPod or iPad or an iPhone, it's, you know, FaceTime's already usable, you
0:12:35know, like the grandparents scenario is already taken care of. Like, I feel like it's a company
0:12:40like Facebook that doesn't have a device like that, like the iPad or the iPhone that wants to
0:12:47make a dedicated talk to the grandparents hardware device. But that's not a living room device,
0:12:54right? Like there's no way you want to get a HomePod with its own screen just to use as
0:13:00speakers for your TV set, right? I mean, what would you ever use the screen for? It doesn't see me.
0:13:06Who knows what they're doing. But anyway, I wanted to follow up.
0:13:08Anything there could be like just a HomePod dock or you put the HomePod on it, you stick your iPad
0:13:12on it when you want to use it in the kitchen and you don't pick it up and walk away.
0:13:14Yeah. I do feel like the, it's funny because this has been a decade long, more than a decade long.
0:13:23I mean, I don't know when good old Gene Munster first started speculating on Apple making an
0:13:29Apple branded TV set. When he saw the 27 inch iMac panels, he just took them for a television set.
0:13:34Yeah. Well, that was a long time ago. And people have had this idea and in a broad sense,
0:13:47it's certainly, it's almost like circa 2005, 2006 talking, "Well, I think Apple should make a phone."
0:13:55I do. Phones are starting to play MP3s. Why carry two devices? I think Apple should make a phone.
0:14:02And then they did. And it all made sense when we saw the iPhone. And it's like in that same general
0:14:07sense, there's like a vague sense of Apple should make stuff for the living room for your home
0:14:12entertainment. And yeah, that sounds good. But then when you get to the details, it's like your
0:14:18living room is so, the difference is that the phone was one thing. You just, if you bought that
0:14:24iPhone, then you put your cell phone number and your carrier account, you know, if you had AT&T,
0:14:29but you know, let's flash forward to where they had carrier support around the world.
0:14:33You know, you buy the iPhone and then that's your phone and it's your camera and it's your iPod and
0:14:40it's, you know, this, that, the other thing famously. But you just buy that one thing.
0:14:44Whereas the living room, even as you get rid of boxes, you're like, "Well, I don't need a separate
0:14:49DVR. I've cut the cable. I can just, you know, get like an app to get my TV service and I can
0:14:55eliminate some boxes." But it's still, there's the set, there's at least one box or a stick in the
0:15:01back or something. And you know, speakers, I mean, really the only way to do it as just the simplest
0:15:09possible thing is to just buy a TV set. Don't hook it up to any external speakers. Don't put a
0:15:15stick or a Apple TV box in the back and just use the built-in Netflix and Hulu and Disney or
0:15:22whatever comes on your TV. You can do that. I'm sure there are people who do that. And the sound
0:15:28coming from TVs, like we got our new LGV TV two years ago, I guess, and for various reasons,
0:15:36didn't have it hooked up to any kind of external speakers for a while. The sound is actually
0:15:43surprisingly good. Really, really quite usable. Like dangerously usable in so far as it inspired
0:15:49laziness on my part to actually do something like what I ended up doing and hook up two home pods
0:15:56to it. But it's really good. So it is possible. But then we're back to square one of Apple making
0:16:01an Apple branded TV set, because that's the one thing you definitely need in any setup is the TV
0:16:06set. And for various reasons, I think they decided against it a long time ago.
0:16:11Yeah, they prototyped at least two of them and it's just, it was, there was no interesting core
0:16:16technologies. There was no super differentiation they could offer. The upgrade cycles are terrible
0:16:21on television, which means they can't like increase the silicon the way they can on an
0:16:25Apple TV small box. It just, it didn't make sense. There wasn't a compelling experience that Apple
0:16:29thought that they could offer to the market. Right. And I heard that at least one of the
0:16:33prototypes they built was sort of along, and who knows, this could be apocryphal. It's this sort
0:16:39of story that is six degrees of separation from anybody who had direct knowledge of it.
0:16:45But that it was like, you know, like a dream TV from Johnny Ive's team. And it was like,
0:16:52I don't know, six or $7,000, you know, and I don't know what year. It's what they watched the World
0:16:57Cup in in IL-3 in the old days, or IL-2 in the old days. Right. And I've, you know, I heard a similar
0:17:02story years ago, you know, that there was not even a prototype. Like, I don't think that it was a
0:17:08built thing that you could drive around, but at least a specked out, sketched out take on an Apple
0:17:15car, and it was just ridiculously expensive. You know, when they, you know, all right, this looks
0:17:21cool, and this looks like something we would put the Apple name on, and here, go figure out how
0:17:26much this would cost. And then the people who figure that sort of thing out came back, and it
0:17:30was, I don't know, like at least over $100,000. And it's like, well, that's, you know, that's too
0:17:35much. They would never ever do it, but it would be so great to just get a version of that book that
0:17:39Johnny Ive and Apple put out with the, with their history of their products, but the ones they didn't
0:17:43ship that had the original car sketches in it, the original TV sketches in it, all of that stuff.
0:17:47I wonder if they made a version of the book with just a, you know, to the other,
0:17:54you know, and in hindsight, that book, it's, you know, you didn't have to be a genius to wonder if
0:18:02Johnny was getting ready to leave Apple and the book was sort of, you know, something to sort of,
0:18:07you know, like a bow. Yeah, like to close the door on this time.
0:18:12Would have been good to have the book. I wonder if that, but that book would probably be a lot
0:18:17thicker, although I guess you could edit it to just the, just the ones that make your heart ache,
0:18:23you know, like, oh, if only we could have, that would be a good book.
0:18:27Yeah. Yep. All right. Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor. It's our good friends at
0:18:34Linode. Linode. Go to linode.com/thetalkshow. That's the URL. And you can see why Linode has
0:18:44been voted the top infrastructure as a service provider by both G2 and Trust Radius. They have
0:18:50award-winning support that is offered 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year to every
0:19:00level of user. Doesn't, you don't have to be like a big enterprise user to get this 24 hour a day,
0:19:04seven days technical support from their top-notch support team. You could get like one of their
0:19:08small plans for like five bucks, 10 bucks a month, something like that. And when you need help,
0:19:12you can get in contact with them. It's absolutely from the top to the bottom. And it is,
0:19:17that is why developers have been trusting Linode for projects, both big, I mean like enterprise big
0:19:24and small, like just personal little pet projects since 2003. I host Daring Fireball at Linode. I
0:19:32could not be happier. Never even have to think about it. Just bulletproof, rock solid,
0:19:38everything I could ever want in a web host. Couldn't be happier with them.
0:19:42You can deploy your entire stack with Linode's one-click app marketplace or build it all from
0:19:48scratch yourself and manage everything with supported centralized tools like Terraform.
0:19:52They offer the best price to performance value for all compute instances, including GPUs,
0:19:59as well as block storage, Kubernetes, and their upcoming bare metal release.
0:20:03They make cloud computing fast, simple, and affordable, allowing you
0:20:06to focus on your projects, not your infrastructure. So once again, visit Linode,
0:20:12L-I-N-O-D-E, linode.com/the-talk-show. Create a free account with your Google or GitHub account,
0:20:22or just use your email address. And by using that URL, linode.com/the-talk-show,
0:20:27you get 100 bucks in credit. 100 bucks. My thanks to Linode for sponsoring the show and for hosting
0:20:32my stuff. All right, AirTags. Before we get to the rumors, do you see Kashmir Hill's New York
0:20:40Times story? She does such good work and investigative stuff, but she's like a tech
0:20:44columnist for the New York Times. And what she did was, with permission, she planted three trackers
0:20:53on her husband, AirTags, a tile tracker, and something that I'd never heard of,
0:21:01she describes as a hockey puck-like GPS tracker from a company called Land Air Sea that she put
0:21:09in the glove compartment of his car. And she wrote about how she was able to follow him as he went
0:21:14about, you know, I think they live in the New York suburbs. She described a trip he took with
0:21:18their daughter to the doctor because I think they thought she had COVID or something.
0:21:22Yeah. And then he had a day of business in Manhattan. Really interesting kind of eye opening,
0:21:29you know, and also not overly dramatized. You know, it was not like a scary,
0:21:35you should be terrified of all these trackers, you know, that sort of take.
0:21:38And it was multiple trackers because almost every other article has focused exclusively on AirTags
0:21:44as if they were alone in the industry. Right, right. And it's interesting because,
0:21:48like, because this Land Air Sea thing has its own built-in GPS, it obviously doesn't require...
0:21:56So that was better for tracking her husband and daughter as they drove to the doctor
0:22:02where they were on a highway and maybe not near any other Apple devices that would locate the
0:22:07AirTag and ping the location. Something with built-in GPS is obviously going to be
0:22:13more available at any time no matter where it is. Whereas the AirTag was obviously more useful for
0:22:20tracking her husband when he was in Manhattan, surrounded by people with MacBooks and iPhones
0:22:27especially. Pretty interesting. And it coincided, I think it was totally a coincidence because I
0:22:33think Apple was working on this, but like a day or two before her story dropped, Apple had announced
0:22:39their updated initiatives to increase the, what would you call it, the transparency and
0:22:46notifications, you know, like there's, you know, and I think rightly so.
0:22:51The awareness.
0:22:51Yeah, the awareness of that these things exist and what happens when one is found with you. And
0:22:59you had, I thought, a terrific video talking about this.
0:23:03Thank you.
0:23:05Pointing out specifically the conflict, like the fundamental conflict that AirTags can't do both
0:23:13of these things at once, which is be privacy aware so that they try their best to alert people that
0:23:20one has been surreptitiously planted on them and be used as an anti-theft device that won't notify
0:23:29the thief that the thing that they've stolen that has an AirTag is being tracked.
0:23:35Yeah, and it goes even beyond that because I think like I used more extreme examples,
0:23:38like you have in one side you have anti-stocking and then on the other side you have lost item
0:23:45recovery and then on another side you have stolen item recovery and those are all very different
0:23:50tasks and you have to optimize very differently for them. But even in the narrow focus of just
0:23:56recovering lost items, if you're not careful with how you balance this out, you can't sit on a bus
0:24:01or on a train without your phone popping every three seconds because other people have their own
0:24:06AirTags with them or a kid has an AirTag their parent put in their bag or something.
0:24:10And also like you want to find your stolen wallet but if it's peeping all the time,
0:24:15someone else might find it who didn't steal it but they find it your camera bag, your wallet,
0:24:20and because it's beeping and they have pinpoint accuracy to it they go and remove the money or
0:24:24remove the cameras before you can come back and find your bag. And I think it's really,
0:24:28really easy and kind of cynical to sit there and like it's a tool, it's a technology,
0:24:35tools technologies have problems. I'm reminded of when Apple announced the hearing aid feature
0:24:39for AirPods immediately there were a bunch of stories about how people were going to use these
0:24:42to eavesdrop on each other with very little consideration for people who actually need
0:24:47this as an accessibility function. And just the scope of the stories I think have been
0:24:52a huge distortion to what the actual technology can do. And Apple is I think, they were alone in
0:24:58the industry in providing any form of notifications, registering devices with your with your,
0:25:05sorry registering AirTags with your devices, with your Apple ID, working with law enforcement under
0:25:10subpoena. We had years of tiles, we had Samsung tags for years, we've had these GPS devices for
0:25:15years where there's been none of those affordances and almost zero coverage of them. But when Apple
0:25:20enters a market the attention is so much that it helps, absolutely helps in bringing this awareness
0:25:26to it, but I think it's also opportunistically distorted by a lot of the coverage around it.
0:25:31Yeah I think that's well said and you know part of it is that they timed it right I think,
0:25:37you know that they built out the Find My Network first, the privacy aware way that it works where
0:25:49you're complete, you know complete strangers who are participating in the Find My Network with
0:25:53capable recent Apple devices like iPhones, which is the big one because it's the most mobile right,
0:25:59it puts the mobile in mobile. You know when they pick up a ping from like an AirTag or other
0:26:09devices that are on the Find My Network they can report it in an anonymous way where you know
0:26:16there's no way for the person whose iPhone is saying hey I just picked up a ping from an AirTag,
0:26:21they don't know whose AirTag it is, they don't even know that it happened, you know that the
0:26:25ping was sent, and you the person who owned the AirTag don't know that this person walked by with
0:26:31their iPhone and sent a ping to update your AirTag. So they built that out first, they did the hard
0:26:39work of getting you know a billion plus devices in circulation around the world which makes it
0:26:46usable right like you can have all this technology in place the exact same thing as Apple's Find My
0:26:51and if you only have a million devices which would be you know for many companies would be great to
0:26:58have a million devices in use but that's a thousand fold decrease it would be less useful because
0:27:05that was Tiles' early problem right well I think it's still Tiles I think it's the I think it's the
0:27:09fundamental problem with Tiles whole concept was that they never had enough devices sending
0:27:15the pings to you know to update them and I think you know going back to Kashmir Hill's story in the
0:27:22New York Times I think that's why the the Tile tracker didn't wasn't as useful for tracking
0:27:26her husband's whereabouts because there's just not enough it's it truly is it's like the definition
0:27:32of network effects right yeah which is why Tiles partnering with Amazon now to greatly increase
0:27:37their footprint right like network effects are such a bizarre concept I think Bob Metcalf the
0:27:43inventor of Ethernet first defined it but it's like the fax machine is like the perfect example
0:27:49it's like yeah you know it's like one person who has a fax machine it's completely useless two
0:27:56people have a fax machine and it might be useful if assuming they know each other and want to send
0:28:02each other faxes semi-frequently but like at the peak of faxes facsimiles you know utility in our
0:28:12world almost everybody had one and there was a while where it was assumed it became so ubiquitous
0:28:19that it was assumed that oh if you want to you know open up a new bank account you know you'll
0:28:26just send a fax here and it's like well I'm at home I don't have a fax you know and and there
0:28:30were like email to fax services and stuff like that so that you could get without having a fax
0:28:35machine at home or a separate line just to have for your fax because you'd have to have a separate
0:28:39phone line blah blah blah but it's like once they're everywhere they were very useful but
0:28:43when there's only like a few of them they're not useful and how do you get from well this is a
0:28:50great idea but we need to get you know tens of millions of them out in the world that's that's
0:28:55the mystery and you know air tags have that with the find my network and tile doesn't you know it's
0:29:03not useless you know people have tiles and they use them but it's clearly not as useful so the
0:29:11changes apple announced one of them is that they seemingly identified I would even call it a bug
0:29:18where people were getting a spurious warning that an unidentified device has been found
0:29:26near you or with with you for blank and an awful lot of people I'd reasonably so assumed that that
0:29:36meant there was an air tag with them and then they'd like look around like let's say they're
0:29:40in their car and it says an unidentified you know tracking device or device has been found with you
0:29:46you know from the find my network and then they're like huh I don't have one of those and then they'd
0:29:52like tear a car apart or look around or say send a you know play a sound or something and nothing
0:29:58would happen and it turned out it wasn't air tags it was like other devices like air pods yeah air
0:30:04pods yeah which is yeah and that was just because the the label was not being identified if it was
0:30:10air tags it would tell you it was air tags but if it wasn't it would just say it was an unknown
0:30:13device which is terrifying because it's nothing more terrifying than the unknown right right it's
0:30:18actually scarier yeah yeah I I've had a I had a couple people it does seem you know and it gets to
0:30:26these arguments about Apple software reliability I mean for the most part this stuff works so good
0:30:31and but it does seem like there are some cracks in the system like I have one regular reader who
0:30:37rides his bicycle to commute to work and while he's riding his bicycle he puts one air pod in
0:30:44so that his other ear can you know pay attention to traffic and everything else going about
0:30:49and that almost every day or every day when he goes home from work he gets that alert on his
0:30:56phone that there's an unknown device near you and it's it's his other air pod that's in or or
0:31:02or he gets the thing that says you left your air pod behind he gets one or the other in neither
0:31:08case is it unknown it's his other ears air pod in the air pod case in his pocket and it's not left
0:31:14behind at work and it's not an unknown device so hopefully with iOS I guess it's an iOS 15.4 thing
0:31:22where this fix is coming hopefully they get that straightened out but it is it's you're absolutely
0:31:27right that it seems like the worst possible warning is an unknown device yeah and it's
0:31:32interesting because Apple gets so much attention that's part of the benefit that they get anytime
0:31:36they announce a new product there is an ungodly amount of media coverage on it but the equal and
0:31:40opposite of that is that anytime they introduce a technology even if it's not new like they introduce
0:31:44touch id and people hammered on it even though you know Samsung and HTC had been storing fingerprint
0:31:49photos and world readable directories for years they just they just didn't have the attention
0:31:53gravity that Apple did but I do worry because the like I hate the word fake news I hate when people
0:32:00use fake news as a way to attack coverage or accountability or those things because uh
0:32:05news coverage is like is the one of the only defenses that we actually have between us and
0:32:10the world around us but there's also and I don't know if it's just post OJ Simpson or or when it is
0:32:16where news got distorted into this continual sensationalization like this complete thirst
0:32:21to the point where it's now trying to shape the story like it's no longer these are the facts what
0:32:26are the narratives that can be drawn from these facts how likely are each of those narratives
0:32:31but it's more like I want to make a story like Neil Neil Sybart was joking um but only a little
0:32:36bit where he said you know iMessage is so popular with us teens we're not going to report that oh we
0:32:41could say that they're bullying teens yeah go run with that right but I think a lot of the times you
0:32:45look at the coverage and it is that and if you look at air tags absolutely they're way more popular
0:32:49way more attention than any of the previous versions of the product but the coverage has been
0:32:54almost universally that these are a stalking device even though if you are a criminal you have
0:32:59to be the dumbest criminal in the world to want to use air tags because of all the tattletale
0:33:05features that apple built into them that don't exist at all in any other version including the
0:33:10better ones like the GPS ones that yes do require an account but give you all of like the benefits
0:33:15with none of the drawbacks and that's that except for this article when we're talking about the New
0:33:20York Times none of that has been presented consistently or in context at all over the last
0:33:24few months right you can't set up air tags like if you you know go to the apple store buy some factory
0:33:30fresh ones and you want to start tracking some something you know for good purposes for bad
0:33:37purposes whatever you just want to start using it to track something you can't get it activated
0:33:42onto the find by network without associating it with an apple id and if it's your appled id
0:33:51which apparently has happened because of you know like you said for lack of a better word dumb
0:33:56criminals who aren't really thinking about it um aren't really thinking about the fact that they
0:34:02just set it up with their own apple id and that it works both ways and that if the person finds
0:34:07it and contacts law enforcement and law enforcement gets in touch with apple that they could say oh
0:34:11yeah this is you know so-and-so's air tech they have they confirmed that they've been working
0:34:16with law enforcement on it um you know and it's it in theory i guess you know somebody with with
0:34:24the bad intentions could create a throwaway apple ids to do that and and i'm not they have so much
0:34:32telemetry like apple has so like the locate like there's so much telemetry that can be drawn off
0:34:36even just metadata that that probably won't help obscure you very much well and i'm also presumably
0:34:42you know like anybody who gets to be a sufficiently large service like that especially if you can if
0:34:48there's a free tier of any service like there is with apple ids you know these companies have built
0:34:55up inordinately complicated systems to try to keep people with not even criminal intentions but just
0:35:02who are looking to abuse abuse the system um like let's like what if you wanted to just i guess it's
0:35:08sort of criminal to send spam but if you just wanted to make a new uh whatever at icloud.com
0:35:14account just to send spam or harassing emails or something like that they have systems in place i
0:35:20don't know what they are i haven't tried to create throwaway icloud accounts but it's not as easy as
0:35:27you would think and there's other ways that that they can try to track it but it is a problem right
0:35:32like that's the other thing especially with location-based devices right so let's you know
0:35:37it's not like oh nobody should be worried about it it's you know we definitely should i yes there
0:35:43were widespread reports and you know you mentioned john prosser i think prosser amongst the rumor
0:35:50rumorists whatever you want to call them yeah had air tags pretty early and they did not actually
0:35:58get announced and shipped until much later and it's partly speculation and partly you know
0:36:05whispering through the grapevine that the problem wasn't the hardware which was completed relatively
0:36:12early um earlier than when it shipped but working through the systematic ways of well how how should
0:36:22this work from every step of the way like the person who owns it how do we protect their privacy
0:36:29and and make this work for them and how do we protect this from being abused and that it was
0:36:35thinking through all of those issues that took longer than expected or at least took longer than
0:36:40it did to develop the hardware yeah no and absolutely i also think there's a benefit of
0:36:45apple entering these markets and that it does raise awareness and now like people were not
0:36:50talking about this before and it's been a problem like this a problem with stalking people using
0:36:53technology every two-bit procedural show on television is shown someone throwing a phone
0:36:58into someone's bag or car to track them with um and with but and that's like by the time tv gets
0:37:03to it it's been a problem for a decade already and in way more serious form so at least uh this
0:37:09has always been a serious problem the stalking the abuse harassment is a huge problem and this
0:37:13has raised a lot of awareness around that and hopefully other technologies and laws and
0:37:17regulations will be updated like if you commit a felony when possession of a firearm you get it you
0:37:22get a much higher increased sentence maybe we have to have a stronger sentence for people who commit
0:37:27crimes using location tracking technology some form of disincentive but you you you i was going
0:37:33to say if they'd known what they knew now they'd become a watchmaker they already make watches but
0:37:39you can't you can't un-invent the stuffs all you can do is try to deal with it
0:37:43well and i think that that's there's there's i forget the exact name of it i'll try to look it
0:37:49up but there's a great twitter account that i follow like the internet pessimists archive
0:37:53and it's just occasional posts of the pessimists archive i will put this in the
0:38:04but all sorts of technical achievements or perhaps every technical achievement throughout history was
0:38:10you know bemoaned for its trade-offs and the trade-offs are real but you know like the
0:38:15telegraph and the telephone and oh my god now with the telephone i know recorded music like
0:38:20the phonograph like being able to play a record was bemoaned by i think john philip susa in
0:38:26particular that this was going to completely pervert people's love for live music and yeah
0:38:32even things like bizarre things like novels you know which which when we grew up was like oh my
0:38:38god stop reading uh comic books and watching tv you should read a book right reading books was
0:38:44good but like when novels first became mass market things that people could afford like with
0:38:50paperbacks and stuff in the late 1800s it was like oh this this novel fad is ruining you know
0:38:56that's all people are doing is reading these novels this is you know it's turning everybody's
0:39:01minds to mush everything is like that there's always trade-offs you know ubiquitous cameras
0:39:07are obviously one that is fresh fresh in them like change like changing rooms there was a huge
0:39:13uproar about camera phones and changing rooms for a long time right and i i even mentioned this a few
0:39:18episodes ago i forget who was on the show but i mentioned uh the the the fact that in japan it
0:39:24was a real problem because they had that they had camera phones earlier than most people you know
0:39:30that they were they were sort of ahead on using your phone for things like getting on the subway
0:39:35and stuff by just waving your phone at it with you know wireless technology and stuff but that
0:39:41they had a real problem with uh let's face it men using their camera to try to shoot surreptitious
0:39:48photos up up yes up the skirts of women on the subway and stuff like that and so the it's
0:39:56i actually i wish i had a better note i actually i think i said on the show that it's the law
0:40:01that every camera in japan has to make an audible shutters down at all times and i think oh man this
0:40:11will be follow up for my next show but i think somebody told me that it's not actually a law
0:40:15but that everybody voluntarily complies with it including apple and so even if you have like your
0:40:21iphone mute switch on or have the volume turned down when you take a photo it always makes a click
0:40:26which is super annoying because the reason for it is this idea in japan that you'd want to do that to
0:40:33to make everybody around you aware that you're taking a photo for privacy sake but everybody
0:40:38can imagine various scenarios where you don't want your phone to make a camera click right like
0:40:44yes let's say you're at the baby whistleblower sleeping baby your kids play like a quiet dramatic
0:40:50moment in your kid's school play and then there you are click you know it's it you can imagine
0:40:56the parental controls too like people complained they were no potential parental controls and then
0:41:00when they established them there was a problem with abusive people in relationships using
0:41:04parental controls to control the devices or mdms to control the devices of the people they were
0:41:09abusing it's it's incredibly complicated and non-trivial yeah uh and you know tracking is
0:41:15obviously one of these things you know it's it's obviously only going to become more common i mean
0:41:21we're it's it sounds like science fiction but it's like a lot of what we have now in our pockets
0:41:29people the devices that people are listening to this show me and you talk on are you know
0:41:34were the things of science fiction not that long ago you know within our lifetimes uh and as as
0:41:40dakota's little brother right as stuff shrinks it's going to become you know uh more of a problem
0:41:48i mean we're not even getting into drones becoming silent and much smaller and much cheaper you know
0:41:56i mean that's sort of not the nightmare scenario but there there are nightmare scenarios that stem
0:42:03from ubiquitous silent little insect-sized drones right it's you know it how in the world do you
0:42:10remain private when something that looks like a housefly might be something somebody's using to
0:42:15spy on you with you know and john they sent us the terminator they sent us the matrix and we're here
0:42:20anyway like we do this to ourselves yeah so it's coming we already have these other devices that
0:42:26do know our location uh so do it to ourselves we are bugging and tracking ourselves now
0:42:32so i thought it was a little pessimistic when like the story came out there was one you know
0:42:37high profile story of like a model a woman who's like a model or an actress or something in new york
0:42:43who's who was out with her friends and got the notification on her phone and found an air tag in
0:42:50her purse that you know seemingly some creep put in there but she'd already gotten home so maybe he'd
0:42:57know he found out where she lived and you know she went to the police and the press and it got highly
0:43:01publicized and the pessimistic take was that hey i and i saw a couple people you know both privately
0:43:07and publicly people who emailed me and people i saw on twitter speculating hey maybe apple should
0:43:11just scrap this whole air tags thing and you know just say you know what this was a bad idea and
0:43:17and stop selling them because this this is no good and i say that's pessimistic because i think it's
0:43:24inevitable anyway even if apple were to get out of it this this problem isn't going away someone
0:43:28else is just going to make them and yeah samsung tags aren't going anywhere uh you know it's
0:43:34something we also do you remember like in the early day like for years on instagram every photo
0:43:40you could tap on the location it would show you exactly where it was and there was a huge
0:43:44controversy when a bunch of models found out that they had been posting pictures from home
0:43:47and like people have been stalking and creeping them for months and months just by tapping that
0:43:52little button on instagram there wasn't the kind of coverage there was of air tags but that was
0:43:57that was an incredible invasion or location disclosure and it just went on and on and on
0:44:02this technique there's you have to i don't want to be a pessimist about it but this stuff exists now
0:44:07and we have to sort of figure out new rules for humanity on how to deal with it yeah that that
0:44:12metadata in the photos is so useful right and and that's part of how a lot of these problems happen
0:44:18and and you know i think it's happened with with apple products in a lot of ways because i think
0:44:23it's more natural for most creative people to think of wouldn't it be cool if blank like
0:44:29wouldn't it be cool if we could embed the gps data in the photo itself and then your photo
0:44:37collection you could say show me all the photos from when i'm in uh cazamel mexico and it'll show
0:44:42you all of the photos from your trip to cazamel mexico and if you broaden the gps you know even
0:44:48if you took like a a boat trip or something like that you know in the general vicinity you could
0:44:54find them all you know it's super and wow that would be super useful but then it's like there's
0:44:59all of these oh but and then it's like everywhere you send it you know where you wouldn't want your
0:45:05location you've got to either strip that data yourself which most people aren't going to do
0:45:11because most people don't even know how to do that or trust the tools and services you're using
0:45:17to strip it for you right like and so i think as far as i know every popular social media site now
0:45:24automatic you know including facebook you know maybe facebook stores the information on their
0:45:28own like you submit a photo with geolocation and they remember it but they don't share it publicly
0:45:34you know and so your photos on instagram don't have location data by default anymore i think
0:45:39you have to add it um but it's you know you just don't think of stuff like that when you're just
0:45:44trying to make something cool yeah absolutely so it's that classic ian malcolm thing from
0:45:49drastic park where you're just so busy trying to figure out how to do it you never stop and
0:45:52think about whether you should or not right or whether somebody you know making those dinosaurs
0:45:58is probably a bad idea in general but yes uh you know you just don't think of it often don't think
0:46:03of all the trade-offs and it seems like with air tags it's a case where apple really tried to and
0:46:11i think did a good job of anticipating all of the nefarious ways they could be used and it's just a
0:46:18matter of filling in the cracks in their implementation of those plans that that that they're
0:46:26you know that they couldn't quite anticipate and it'd be kind of nice if we if the media
0:46:31bent some of their will onto getting the other companies like tile and samsung to to implement
0:46:36similar protections i think the most recent thing they did is just turn on a bluetooth scanner so you
0:46:41can see if there's like a bluetooth device around you which is better than nothing but not quite so
0:46:45helpful i would personally love it if at an os level both ios and android built in something
0:46:51that would detect persistent unregistered bluetooth devices because like you it goes
0:46:56beyond tile like i said like people for years have been dropping cheap phones in people's bags
0:47:00but they could also you could drop your like air pods or samsung buds or google buds or what a cheap
0:47:04anchor buds or something that has any sort of location availability on them and follow people
0:47:08so just have it at an os level you don't need a specific phone or app and it just alerts you when
0:47:13something has been with you for a while that your phone doesn't know yeah it would be good i mean
0:47:17you know something like that you know something so you could like just sweep the area you know
0:47:22what i mean like all of a sudden we're all we're all gangsters or cia agents it's it's
0:47:27opposite because it's good opposite yeah we're sweeping sweeping for bugs kind of needed don't
0:47:32talk yet don't talk yet bb bb bb okay it's safe uh all right let me take another break here and
0:47:38thank our second and final sponsor of this episode our good friends at memberful memberful is where
0:47:45you can monetize your passion your creative endeavor with memberships they allow you to
0:47:51build a sustainable recurring revenue and it's the easiest way to sell memberships to your audience
0:47:56no matter what it is that you do and it is used by some of the biggest creators on the web they
0:48:00have everything you need to run a membership program including custom branding gift subscriptions
0:48:05apple pay support free trials private podcasts and tons more they seamlessly integrate with the tools
0:48:13you already use like wordpress and mailing list software and anything else you can think of they
0:48:19really do um and you keep full control and ownership of your audience your brand and your
0:48:27memberships so that if you ever do you know it's not like oh you're all uh you know it's all obvious
0:48:34that you're a memberful site no your your your members may not even know that you're a memberful
0:48:38site it's so seamless and your branding is so in front and if you ever do change your mind and want
0:48:43to go elsewhere you can take your whole membership database your whole whole list with you when when
0:48:49you want you can get started for free with no credit card required they have a world-class
0:48:55support team that is ready to help you simplify your memberships and grow your revenue they only
0:49:00succeed when you succeed that memberful only makes money when you're selling memberships and your
0:49:06memberships are only going to stay active while your members are happy with them so it's win win
0:49:12win it is a totally virtuous cycle uh and like i said you can get started for free visit memberful
0:49:20dot com slash talk show today to get started that url is memberful.com slash talk show all right
0:49:31rumors here's the first one i got the uh some but some poor some poor engineer at apple
0:49:38checked in like a uh like a software update with the the name reality you know like a version
0:49:45control with uh like a comment or something like an if statement like if reality os
0:49:51that's not new i mean i don't think anybody really reported it as new but i think you i think you're
0:49:59the first person i heard mention the name and i think like two years ago i mean and again it it's
0:50:05possible you know i mean it would be a you know it's the sort of thing where like you know it
0:50:10greg jaswiak decides you know we're not going to call it reality os yes some poor engineer has to
0:50:16go through and change on all of the code to to change that or maybe not maybe the code just
0:50:22keeps calling it reality os even if the actual marketing name of the os is something different
0:50:27yeah that's the weird thing to me and i think mark ermin has been reporting on ros for a long time
0:50:32but the like usually apple doesn't use product names in this stuff like famously like ios was
0:50:38purple and there was purple restore and everything like they didn't like we're not gonna forget like
0:50:44we're not gonna put the new version of ios on this we've got the purple restore and someone in apple
0:50:48to this day like they don't know what ios 15 is like they barely remember because they're they're
0:50:53using whatever the ski slope name or now i forget what it is like ucon or something yeah they live
0:50:58on those names and they don't often remember which version is which like what's in public
0:51:01they're living like two years in the future so to me like if this was like orange or if it was like
0:51:06cantaloupe or something marzipan that would make a lot more sense to me than to have anything close
0:51:11to a marketing name in a in a commit yeah but somehow it seems like that's you know i wouldn't
0:51:16be surprised but i i would bet i would bet a small amount of money that the actual name of the os is
0:51:21going to be reality os but you know we shall see but is is it really you know is it news that
0:51:28they're working on this i mean it it would be i i just wrote about uh before we started recording
0:51:36today about a leaked slide from intel that says they have plans to be performance per watt
0:51:42competitive with the m1 pro by the end of 2023 and like i wrote it would be it would be more shocking
0:51:48if you knew everything there was to know about intel's internal roadmap it would what would be
0:51:51shocking is if they didn't have some sort of team and a plan to do that now whether they'll achieve
0:51:57it or not who knows but you know it the bar's been set so fascinating because like they announced
0:52:04they had they publicly announced at their investor event which went on for like four hours like some
0:52:08people think wwc is long this one like it was an investor event went on for four hours they
0:52:13announced four process i think it was five process shrinks for four years including going beyond
0:52:18nanometer and into angstrom because it's smaller than nanometer and those are just marketing names
0:52:22they're not actual physical measurements so you can't compare the sizes directly but at this point
0:52:27it's just like shut up and ship and it reminds me that apple doesn't do this they don't announce
0:52:31what the next four generations of apple silicon are going to be they just come out and show you
0:52:35what they've done and then let you benchmark it to see if if it holds up i had i had a friend who
0:52:40no longer works at apple but was there for you know a number of years as a software engineer and
0:52:47they uh they sent me that link to the leak of reality os and said that they they had been in
0:52:53a position before and and so many apple engineers are where you're you're privy to something upcoming
0:53:00and you're trying to write code that's as clear and descriptive as possible but you you know
0:53:07you don't want to check anything into the shipping version of whatever it is that has the you know
0:53:13that's there for like gee rambo to decompile or something like that and oh there's the thing
0:53:18happened right and he said it is like there is there's just nobody's going to you know maybe
0:53:24someday if anybody were going to do it and like build it in as a first class feature of xcode
0:53:29i guess it would be apple but that it's really just sort of like you're just making like a house
0:53:34of cards of like you know if def statements to like make sure that when you compile this
0:53:40for that version it doesn't include any of this and when you compile it for the upcoming secret
0:53:47project thing it is there and that it's just so easy to make a mistake you know especially
0:53:54it's so easy if there's you know 500 engineers working on this and they have a 99.9 success rate
0:54:02at keeping things that aren't supposed to be mentioned in the shipping product out well you
0:54:08know that one in a thousand mistake it's going to happen right it's every couple years yeah every
0:54:16couple years but it's you know it's like somebody had a bad day and again it's not like apple apple
0:54:21is not i don't even think back when steve jobs was around it's not like it's you know he he had
0:54:27a reputation as a tyrant but i don't think that he was vindictive and like hunted down individual
0:54:34engineers who made a mistake i think famously that the poor kid who lost the iphone 4 at a at a
0:54:40restaurant and was found by gizmodo i'm pretty sure that the kid did not lose his job
0:54:46no because of that but had had a bad couple of weeks right it's certainly a bad certainly had
0:54:54a bad day no absolutely so it's not like oh the poor engineer who checked in a code commit with
0:55:02reality os mentioned but didn't comment it out or if if def it out so that it wouldn't be in the
0:55:07thing not like they're fired but still it's a bad day and you feel like you let everybody down and
0:55:12it's like ah and i'm sure it was the silliest possible mistake you know like oh i know exactly
0:55:18what i did and they look at xco and it's like you know you make two quick changes and all of a
0:55:22sudden it's you know back to back to hidden uh yeah yeah well to your point i mean for years
0:55:27blogs every every november would say oh we discovered in our logs people from cupartino
0:55:32are browsing our site in the next version of ios apple must be working on another version of ios
0:55:37or apple is working on a new iphone it's like no they've had enough they're done with the iphone
0:55:41they're based they're just dropping it they're gonna get it to hot tubs now it's gonna be yo
0:55:44serie bubbles for the next three years yeah we just like we used to get the screen dimensions
0:55:49from that right because you could you know a lot of a lot of analytics packages for websites
0:55:54will do a test to see what the display size is and if you get a user agent string that says it's
0:56:00an iphone and the screen dimensions are not what the existing iphones have it's like oh new screen
0:56:09you know you know and then people would start spoofing them and like you can't tell it's just
0:56:12it's hilarious uh i remember for a while mark german was getting the names of new iphone models
0:56:18from the strings it was like iphone like seven comma eight and at one point apple just put
0:56:2232 numbers in there to play with them it was just hilarious like iphone one comma hamburger or
0:56:27something um i don't think though speaking of reality os i don't think any of that is imminent
0:56:33you know the german report was that maybe they were hoping to ship the first headset this fall
0:56:40maybe it's early next year now maybe it's been pushed back it's not this is not something we're
0:56:45talking about for this march 8th event that is supposedly forthcoming um yep wouldn't be
0:56:51surprised i think one thing that gets unremarked upon because they do it so seldom they're so
0:56:55seldom a new product and i think you just talked talked about this in one of your videos about how
0:57:02the one exception to apple not talking about future products is they'll they'll be surprisingly
0:57:06loose-lipped about new products because they they don't risk cannibalizing themselves right
0:57:12so like famously tim cook answered like hey you guys making a watch and he said well the
0:57:17wrist is an interesting spot for us you know which you think whoa whoa williams said the car is the
0:57:22ultimate mobile device right right right and it's like well wait why would he do that well it's
0:57:28because if he if it what's the worst thing that could happen you know like if he started talking
0:57:33up uh you know then this year's iphone 14 models you know the idea is that you would uh what's the
0:57:41famous example the osborne the osborne effect right the osborne effect from the early early
0:57:46early pc era of like the early 1980s where this poor company osborne was selling personal computers
0:57:52with some degree of success and went to a like a big convention and all they could do is talk up
0:57:57their next one and everybody stopped buying the one they were already selling and then the next
0:58:02one was late and they went out of business yeah uh so you don't want to apple is doesn't want to talk
0:58:09up this september's new iphones because they're still selling last september's iphone 13 models
0:58:15and you know all the ones underneath it in the in the product chain whereas talking about the watch
0:58:21before they were selling any watches didn't hurt them you know if anything it only kept people
0:58:27yeah hurts or fitbit or you know whatever whatever it is you think they're going to do
0:58:31um so the other thing is like the technology is like tim cook has been very happy to talk about
0:58:37automation and uh augmented reality and artificial intelligence because those aren't actual products
0:58:44it's like steve jobs talking about lcd like yes the i the iMac has to go lcd eventually but
0:58:49if there is no lcd that you literally can't make an iphone but then lcd isn't the iphone because
0:58:54you also make the ipad and the watch and i think cook is the same it's like ar and vr there will
0:58:59be products that use those but it's going to be as ubiquitous as lcd and oled are on products today
0:59:04yeah and i i think it's really interesting as time goes on there's two big uh upcoming who knows you
0:59:12know whether either both or will ship or on what form but that there's project titan at apple where
0:59:17they're making a car or some kind of vehicle or self-driving technology or something along the
0:59:22lines of a car vehicle and the ar vr stuff where they're either making uh i mean vr at a technical
0:59:32level is clearly closer to reality than ar yeah but it could be a mixed thing where it is a
0:59:39technically a vr headset but it combines a camera so you can see through and see the world around
0:59:45you not just what's you know you're not just in a total blackout and that eventually they do want
0:59:50to make ar glasses you know where you you'll get effectively like eyeglasses but then you know you'll
0:59:57have like a heads up display and your lenses are projected onto your retinas or whatever the
1:00:01technology they want to use to me one of the interesting contrasts between those two big
1:00:06initiatives right the ar vr stuff on one side project titan on the other is that project titan
1:00:13has been we know just through leaks and just through the public exodus and return of executives
1:00:22right like some of this stuff can't you know we don't know what they're working on but all sorts
1:00:25of people have come and gone from project titan and come from tesla left from tesla gone back
1:00:32come from qnx right there's all sorts of the drama and shake-ups and stuff like that and the ar xr
1:00:43vr stuff it's just seemingly at least as far as we know from the outside steady as she goes right
1:00:49it's still mike rockwell heading it up uh you know and hasn't been a lot of news you know it was just
1:00:56a couple years ago where rockwell was on my show at wwc after a bunch of vr and ar specific apis
1:01:04that were announced that year for ios he's still there it's it's seemingly where there's smoke
1:01:09there's fire it seems like there's been a lot of fires at project titan it seems like everything's
1:01:13going pretty well with the ar vr stuff but i wouldn't be surprised sign of our times like
1:01:18the reporting is way more active than it was now and i've talked about this before but like can you
1:01:22imagine if this kind of reporting was done back during the iphone era where it's like steve jobs
1:01:26wants a glass device and he can read email anywhere tablet project now becomes iphone
1:01:30project tony fidel and scott forestall in blood war for steve jobs's affection right now project
1:01:35purple delayed room smell like pizza like like the whole thing would have been like much more like i
1:01:42feel like that's what we get with titan now is that everything we never used to hear about
1:01:44until they shipped like there'd be rumors and stuff but now like every little personnel move
1:01:48is is broadcast for various reasons i i'm actually researching a lot about the creation of the the
1:01:54iphone the original iphone product and i've cracked open a bunch of my books that i've
1:02:00collected over the years and you know that i read for the most part when they came out
1:02:06things like becoming steve jobs which was the other biography of of steve jobs ken kashenda's
1:02:14creative selection kurt i think his name is kurt vogelstein's i forget the title of his book now i
1:02:20can't believe it it's on my it's on my desk as i speak but it was like about the creation of ios
1:02:25and android i'm just reading a bunch of these and uh fred vogelstein what's the name of the book do
1:02:31you have it no i can't find it hold on fred vogelstein up got it dogfight is the book it's a
1:02:40very yeah yeah with the android stuff it's amazing yeah it's it's uh can't believe i couldn't think
1:02:44about but anyway good book anyway but i'm like trying to figure out the the timeline of the
1:02:53creation of the iphone which i don't think i've ever seen quite spelled out combined with like
1:02:59the rocker and stuff and the one thing and it so it's like i'm sort of like the the guy at the the
1:03:07cork board with a bunch of tacks and yarn yeah and i'm stringing all this stuff all around and
1:03:12i've got all these books with like three four or five bookmarks each in all of them and a bunch of
1:03:18older articles from the era and blah blah blah and the one thing that where i'm going with this is
1:03:23the one thing that keeps coming up over and over again to a surprising degree is that steve jobs
1:03:29wanted something that he could read his email on the toilet and yeah i think imram imram tweeted
1:03:35that a while ago too yeah the uh the founder of humane the secretive startup yes uh yeah uh yeah
1:03:43great computer history museum has a whole bunch of interviews with scott forestall and indonatra and
1:03:47just um so many of the people who like built all that stuff like why they named it you like it
1:03:52it's it's amazing amazing lore i don't know that i don't know the story of why they named it ui kit
1:03:57other than the fact oh it was it is yeah i'm blanking on his name now scott it was scott hearse
1:04:03who came up with the name eventually because it wasn't abkit and it wasn't uh webkit right right
1:04:08it's a good name um but it's so funny because you read these things and there are conflicting
1:04:14reports you go through and there's a lot of you know you kind of have to start making some
1:04:18editorial just if you want to say this is what i think the timeline is what happened in early 2005
1:04:24what happened in late 2005 when was this bake-off between like an embedded linux versus a stripped
1:04:31down mac os 10 to be the iphone os yeah um and you get conflicting reports about what was early
1:04:372005 what was late 2005 what was the middle what might have even been in early 2006 like within
1:04:44you know like 11 10 months you know the clock is ticking to where where where they want to announce
1:04:49this at macworld 2007 but there's other things that come up over and over and over again from
1:04:54the various sources both like books that came out years later extemporaneous stories and the one
1:05:01thing that keeps coming up is that steve jobs wanted to read email on the toilet yeah i just
1:05:07love it you just know that it was that and this the story of steve his wife having her friend
1:05:13over who had the husband from microsoft he was talking about how bill gates and tablet pcs were
1:05:17going to dominate the future of computing and then steve goes and finds scott the next day and we have
1:05:22to put a stop to this yeah screw him yeah uh so anyway i wouldn't be surprised if if reality os
1:05:32follows the pattern that watch the apple watch did where they announce it this fall at you know
1:05:41maybe alongside the iphone which is usually the bigger event in september but say this is a product
1:05:48here's the product we're making here's what it does here's what it's good for and it's coming
1:05:54early next year and that's what they did with the watch back in 2015 2014 whenever it was 2014 yeah
1:06:022014 would be the announcement 2015 is when the original apple watch shipped like in april and was
1:06:08in short supply you know until up until closer to wwdc like it was kind of hard to get your hands on
1:06:15one um and again they don't do that with any other new product there if something terrible happened
1:06:22with the iphone's 14 and they could not release them by the end of the year this year they're just
1:06:29not even going to announce them until next year and you know i mean that would be highly unusual
1:06:34i'm not saying that like hey the stock market you know like if september comes and goes and apple
1:06:39hasn't said anything about a media event uh you know or if they have a media event in october and
1:06:46it's there's no mention of new iphones yeah you know like people are going to notice and we're all
1:06:52going to talk about it but they're not going to pre-announce the iphone 14 and say it's coming in
1:06:58six months whereas no only the first one right with a vr headset they might and in fact it might
1:07:04make a lot of sense right it's like you know it why not pre-announce it you know and then you can
1:07:09get developers to start working on stuff uh if you want them to if there's going to be you know
1:07:16a day one app store sdk story like you know which they insisted on for the watch probably
1:07:24for you know you could say for better or for worse i think that original
1:07:28watch kit was for worse um yes but presumably i think they want to get it like they want to be
1:07:35the ones who disclose it and as like when we talk about the rumors we'll talk about like how the
1:07:38different fcc's in the different countries pre-announce stuff way early for them all the time
1:07:43but it's never the first one so like the original apple tv was or itv back then was announced and
1:07:48then like it actually debuted with alongside the original iphone but then the original iphone was
1:07:52announced in january shipped in june ipad was announced in january shipped in april apple watch
1:07:57was announced in september switched shipped in march it's just they don't ever want that to be
1:08:02in the fcc price and you know go back to the iphone right we were just talking about the
1:08:05original iphone announced in january definitely not finished famously and you know when you talk
1:08:11to people who worked on it there was like yeah that was like the hardest part was after it was
1:08:15announced and we had to finish the damn thing uh but didn't ship until literally six months later
1:08:20the like june 29th uh 2007 but the same thing where they don't have to submit to the regulatory
1:08:26bodies and don't have to worry about it leaking so if they're on pace for it to ship in early
1:08:342023 like a year from now let you know more or less yeah uh it would actually to me be almost
1:08:42surprising if they don't announce it in september a little bit surprising just because it you know
1:08:50and then you know and and if for competitive reasons it inspires some number of people not to
1:08:56buy an oculus for christmas because they want to wait for apple's thing well that you know i'm sure
1:09:01that'll just break poor tim cook's heart you know yeah it'll pivot his tables so anyway what is
1:09:10coming march 8th i i have not heard anything i'm not juiced in i don't ask anybody i don't know i
1:09:15know all i do is i just listen to mark german and mark german says march 8th we know that apple
1:09:21likes to have a spring event uh march 8th is a tuesday that sounds as good as as anything to me
1:09:27i do think that's earlier it is an earlier date than usual for them um i just think last year was
1:09:34april yeah well and i just know that that week i don't know i haven't been to south by southwest
1:09:39in years but i know south by southwest is always right around like if not the first week of march
1:09:44it's like that second week of march around those dates and back when i was going to south by
1:09:50southwest i never it was never a conflict with apple events um yeah but you know if it's ready
1:09:55it's ready and why not um what do we expect german says the 5g iphone se which is fascinating
1:10:04a new ipad air and he says at least one new mac that day but doesn't say what it would be so let's
1:10:12take them one at a time well number one do you think that's a do you think that's a good list
1:10:16of things that they might announce early early in market yeah and we've talked about this before
1:10:20it's always odd to me when you have sources good enough to tell you dates and products but not
1:10:24exactly like not more specifically because this stuff was decided like those products were decided
1:10:29years ago and the release dates were decided weeks if not months ago so like all the stuff is known
1:10:34it's just fascinating to me how much of it gets out well and the mac one in particular right
1:10:38because he's pretty specific about the other two you know a 5g new iphone se that's pretty specific
1:10:43a new ipad air i mean and again we don't know the details i mean maybe is it going to have face id
1:10:48now just face id trickle down to the non-pro ipads i mean but he doesn't say but that's you know we
1:10:54know what the ipad air is it's it's apple's mid-range you know not the low one not the pro
1:10:59one but it's sort of the the sweet locks yeah the goldilocks sweet one right in the middle
1:11:04and then some sort of mac well we're waiting yes we're that and that's the worst part for me because
1:11:09i'm more excited about the mac than the other products and it's like i need to know i want to
1:11:13know which one it is am i should i start getting excited to get a new iMac i mean what's what's
1:11:18going on the the 5g iphone se is interesting because 5g makes sense because you know the
1:11:24carriers love getting all the phones on on the new network yes um you know and they're turning
1:11:30you know literally as we speak atnt i think just this week i think they already did it turned off
1:11:35their 3g network we had to deal with that because our home alarm system was on 3g and and uh
1:11:46you know but we had plenty of notice from the company that we use that we you know that hey
1:11:52this is you know this is going to be end of end of service and you know it's part of your plan
1:11:57would you just have to schedule somebody to come in to upgrade you know the box on the wall to
1:12:02support 5g or 4g i don't even know what they upgrade hopefully it was five i should have asked
1:12:06because 5g would give us more years before the 4g stuff gets turned off um so it makes sense i mean
1:12:14and if you watch tv like i watch sports and there's all you know you cannot can't watch
1:12:19sports without seeing ads for cell phones from the carriers and all the i they always talk about 5g
1:12:255g 5g i mean that's famously two years ago at the iphone supercut 5g 5g 5g 5g 5 5g iphone
1:12:35yeah 12 supports 5g 5g um so it makes sense you know that they'd want to get the se on there but
1:12:42to me the more interesting thing is that the rumors are that the se would other will otherwise
1:12:47still look like the se we have today that's the iphone 8 casing right with the home button with
1:12:55perhaps only in one size you know because that would be the other thing that would
1:12:59you know 5g to me is not a game changer and especially compared to lte and yeah upload
1:13:08speed still are over lte so like when you do like a speed test don't be surprised that your 5g speed
1:13:14for upload is exactly the same as it is when you turn off 5g because it actually doesn't use 5g
1:13:19for anything but downloading um and i just i still after two two years of 5g i still you know it might
1:13:28be maybe it's better as years go by it'll be more efficient and better on battery and stuff like
1:13:33that but i still don't know any use case where i want to do blank but uh lte geez you know too slow
1:13:43you know it's it is yeah it's more like um you're gonna get people who are on the original iphone se
1:13:48sorry like the iphone se2 onto a qualcomm modem and for some people especially in edge areas the
1:13:54intel modems were never as good if you had low reception or low signal in those areas so it's
1:13:59just it's it's a better modem and for people who were underserved by lte like especially in rural
1:14:04areas where they just never had maybe any signal or good signal the low band of 5g is slower than
1:14:10lte but it's got way way better coverage and the mid band is faster and has roughly as good coverage
1:14:17so for people who always had problems with lte it's going to be it's going to vastly improve a
1:14:22lot of people's experience yeah so you know that's good right i i think i think what's more
1:14:27interesting is that they're they're keeping the se models on that old industrial design
1:14:34um and the the cynical take would be that it is market differentiation it's sort of like keeping
1:14:44the iphone or the apple watch 3 around right where it's a little bit clunkier looking on your wrist
1:14:50and it certainly has a clunkier screen with the the non-rounded corners and doesn't really go edge
1:14:56to edge and it you know gets customers in the door looking for the se for the price and then
1:15:02they see how much cooler the new phones are and then they buy one of those more expensive newer
1:15:07phones instead but i think there's something else i think that it is apple trying to and i don't
1:15:14know how much of this is their gut feeling you know jaws's gut feeling and how much of it is
1:15:20actual market research which i think at the stakes they're playing at you know apple famously people
1:15:27think they don't test anything but they that's not true they do they do test things you know they
1:15:32just don't make the decisions based entirely on the results of asking you know doing like uh
1:15:38consumer surveys and stuff like that yeah but i think there's got to be a huge factor of
1:15:43the iphone is so popular as so many hundreds of millions of users that it spans the gamut from the
1:15:51people like us who are complete nerds and really couldn't wait to play with the brand new iphone
1:15:5810 and this new interaction model to people like my mom and dad well my dad hardly uses the iphone
1:16:05so i'm i'm throwing my mom out here not because of the canard that it's the you know it's your mom
1:16:12who doesn't understand technology but my dad literally doesn't even he uses an ipad but for
1:16:16whatever reason won't use my mom's iphone but my mom wanted the se when she got a new phone a year
1:16:23ago or so because she wanted one that worked exactly like her old phone that she felt like
1:16:28she'd mastered the old one she wanted a home button she just was and i was like okay fine
1:16:33this is a probably a great phone for you anyway personally you know it regardless but i i don't
1:16:39know what number of iphone users are in that sphere where they they would prefer
1:16:46price aside they want one with a home button that works just like the one they had
1:16:51and that apple and the options are good and like apple family like they you're right like they
1:16:56they don't do the same kind of market uh research that other companies do but they do a lot of
1:17:00demand forecasting and try to figure out because like compared to samsung for example they sell very
1:17:05very few phones and it looks like they sell a lot of phones now because there's five models but
1:17:09still five miles is like what samsung has for lunch and so they have to make sure that those
1:17:13phones cover as wide a gamut of potential users as possible those segments are really really large
1:17:19and they're interesting like the original iphone se was both small and cheap and they got the benefit
1:17:23of both those markets and i think they were surprised by how many people just wanted the
1:17:27cheaper iphone so much so that they they under they under report they under forecast on it but
1:17:32then they had a separate iphone mini and a separate iphone se in 2020 and they could sort of suss out
1:17:38where people's interests were and i think that was really informative for them and in general that the
1:17:43the original se came out in 2016 se2 came out in 2020 which means se3 would probably be 2024
1:17:50in an iphone 11 style casing but because we're only halfway there i think otherwise they wouldn't
1:17:57update it now they would just keep it on the market the way the original se was but 5g is so
1:18:01important to carriers and how they're moving things over um and apple has this other strategy where
1:18:06like the like the ipod touch is probably the most infamous example but it's the device you love with
1:18:11new internal so that you can keep on loving it just a little while longer you know before we end
1:18:16of life it this this will get unlike the apple watch s apple watch 3 which didn't get any
1:18:21improvements like they just kept it on the market this will have a new processor it'll have better
1:18:25camera it'll have a better modem i'm worried about the battery life because it was already not good
1:18:31on the se2 and that has way fewer demands than a new processor and a new modem but in general it
1:18:36just means it's that that really inexpensive entry-level iphone that's more useful to people
1:18:40who still want it yeah i think that maybe but i think if they follow the pattern of previous
1:18:47se's it will have the a a what are we up to a14 what's the bionic well a15 it is the current one
1:18:55is 15 a15 all right so we're we're two above the iphone model i i would expect it to have the a15
1:19:01because that's the se's have always come out with like you know they come out in march or april
1:19:07but they've got the top of the line a series chip from six months prior and the battery life gains
1:19:15from the a14 to a15 my favorite example i've never stopped repeating it is that the iphone 13 mini
1:19:22gets better longer battery life than yes the full size regular size iphone 12 from the year before
1:19:30so yeah you know so that would also explain to me why they didn't do the 5g iphone se last year
1:19:37right that now is the year where it all adds up the battery life story is resolved um because
1:19:44it would be a bigger device than the iphone 13 mini so i i would think battery life would be
1:19:51fine even with the 5g and the new modem is more efficient right the iphone 12 was as well it's
1:19:56just a whole in general and this will come up again we talk about the next macbook air but
1:19:59that architecture the a15 is a much cooler architecture in general yeah yeah it def it's
1:20:05you know it's been proven over the last you know what five months since we've been using them four
1:20:10months whatever um but the other thing that's that's missing in the se lineup right the se is
1:20:16clearly built on the the physical form factor of the iphone 6 7 8 iphones but those phones all came
1:20:28in regular and plus sizes and the iphone se that we have is only in the regular size not plus
1:20:35and i think according to the rumors but who knows you know they could surprise us but it sounds like
1:20:41that's just they're just going to replace the same size four point whatever inch you know uh
1:20:46or whatever that size is but it's you know not the plus not the plus size screen
1:20:55which some people would obviously buy right some people we now know just want bigger screens whether
1:21:00it's the laptop yes yeah tablet or the phone and there if they still don't come out with an iphone
1:21:08se plus to me that's that's product marketing saying if you want a big if you would like a
1:21:15big screen iphone you've got to upgrade to one of these more expensive models with the newer form
1:21:20factor yeah it's that and it's also there's some element of demand forecasting again because like
1:21:25when they segment you have to supply two like it's it's like a running the math doing the doing the
1:21:31math and like how much does it cost us to put two mark two phones in the market how many of each do
1:21:35we think will sell how much more does it cost us to have two models instead of one if we just sold
1:21:39one would we get 75 of the se customers anyway so it really doesn't behoove us to have it like in an
1:21:44ideal world they would absolutely do not like like samsung again with every quarter inch of sizing for
1:21:49whatever your preference is but they would do multiple products i just think they um they they
1:21:55know they don't want to over commit to any one market anymore they want to they're going to be
1:21:59more conservative in how they do especially the lower end entry level where really price is the
1:22:04most important feature for people yeah there's been reports that they were working on it for
1:22:08years but that they keep canceling it like there were reports about the se plus i think going back
1:22:12two three years already yeah yeah i'd uh i definitely remember seeing rumors about it and it
1:22:18makes logical sense you know to have it but it's it to me it leads to the next segment which is the
1:22:24mystery which mac are are they which mac or max are they going to announce next month which to me
1:22:31is the the the biggest missing mac in the lineup by far is a bigger consumer priced macbook right
1:22:42like so the macbook pros are now on 14 inch 16 inch but with foot or with footprints that are
1:22:52very very similar to 13 inch 15 inch from years past it's just that the screen sizes
1:22:58have gained an inch by going edge to edge and you know some minor tweaks to the footprints
1:23:04but you know it in in ballpark descriptive terms i would describe the 14 inch macbook pro and the
1:23:16macbook air of today which is the 13 inch screen as regular sized laptops and the 16 inch macbook
1:23:26pro as a big laptop not the biggest you know apple used to make the 17 inch lunch tray the battleship
1:23:32right which i i actually was just looking up like i said my trip down memory lane of circuit 2005
1:23:416 7 apple history steve jobs when he had his first surgery uh and announced that you know he'd had his
1:23:47pancreas operated on for cancer wrote a letter to the company you know saying team i wanted you to
1:23:53hear this from me i've you know the doctors found this thing and they i just had operation i'm
1:23:58writing this from my hospital bed on my 17 inch macbook pro and it was because like he knew it
1:24:05was going to leak and he was like well he had to mention he had to mention an apple product in there
1:24:11and i always wondered was he really writing it on a 17 inch macbook pro or was it that's just the
1:24:18newest thing that he wanted to promote and he said he did i mean i'm not accusing steve jobs of being
1:24:23a liar but he could be an exaggerator but it also seems like prototype ipad he couldn't talk about
1:24:28but uh you know big laptop regular size laptop and you know in years past they've had small laptops
1:24:37like the uh long ago uh 11 inch macbook airs and then the gone but not forgotten just plain no
1:24:46adjective 12 inch macbook um you know small medium large some products i i think when apple is has
1:24:54a product at its best they either have two sizes an apple watch is a perfect example of that right
1:25:01and putting aside the idea that there might be a rugged apple watch or something like that
1:25:05you know for the apple watch as we know it two sizes seems just just right i think for the phone
1:25:11i really like you know and i know the rumors say there's no more mini and whatever but i
1:25:16like the mini regular max sizing and i feel like that really is a phone for everybody
1:25:23laptops i kind of wish they had mini regular max um but even if at the two tiers pro lap macbooks
1:25:33and non-pro macbooks two seems good right like 14 and 16 inch for the pros but i i feel like the
1:25:41biggest missing ipad for years or macbook for years has been a bigger consumer priced
1:25:49macbook whether it's called large screens get conflated with premium when they don't they're
1:25:53not really an overlap in those features because there are a lot of people for a lot of reasons
1:25:56who want a bigger screen but don't need a pro right device and you know it's nice to have a
1:26:02big screen right and if you have the desk space and you know you don't mind the extra weight in
1:26:07your backpack or whatever and you know lots and lots of people hardly ever move their macbooks
1:26:13from their desks you know they buy a macbook so that they have a portable when they need it
1:26:18but they keep it on their desk 90 some percent of the time maybe high 90 percent of the time
1:26:24and so getting the biggest screen they they feel is within their budget makes a lot of sense because
1:26:29a big screen is nice and it's there even people right now who are concerned that the m1 imac
1:26:36is going to only be 24 inches and that if you want a 27 inch it's going to have to be an m1 pro or m1
1:26:41max when they really just want a bigger screen again right right oh i i think i do think again
1:26:46no inside knowledge but just judging by the way they did the macbooks i think that's going to be
1:26:52the case right like where the only way to get a big screen macbook for years for all along has
1:26:59been to buy the macbook pro 16 inch or 15 inch back and when it was 15 inch and it's not just
1:27:06paying for the bigger screen because the bigger macbooks have also had like you know sometimes
1:27:12faster chips and faster graphics and and for thermal reasons compared to the smaller versions
1:27:18you end up paying a significant mark uh you know minimum price like i think that the cheapest
1:27:2516 inch macbook pro right now i think it's two thousand dollars 1999 yeah i guess i should look
1:27:30it up uh which is way more than the 999 here it's twice the price you know whereas and it's
1:27:37it to me epitomizes the difference between the apple ecosystem and the broader windows slash
1:27:47linux chromebook pc ecosystem which is that whatever your budget you can find a pc laptop
1:27:56you know if you really want like a 16 inch screen but you don't want to spend a lot of money you can
1:28:00definitely find you'll you'll be you know you'll have an arm's length list of choices from various
1:28:06companies del will let you build it from parts definitely right it is it and it's such i don't
1:28:14know so it are they going to deal with it it seems like there's an awful lot of you know with the
1:28:20rumors for what apple is doing with the consumer macbooks as they go to the m2s and do their second
1:28:26revision um you know i i talk about this this is why it's great to have a podcast because it's
1:28:33i have nothing to write about because i know nothing but i have lots of ideas but i don't
1:28:38think what it's interesting because like the larger macbook air mark german reported on that
1:28:41too but said that that had been either delayed or scrapped as well so like it's not that apple
1:28:45isn't thinking about it it's just that they don't seem to think that it's that they want they need
1:28:48to bring it to market uh yeah i guess uh the the to me the product that two product a product that
1:29:00doesn't make sense anymore is what's currently known as the 13 inch macbook pro and yes to me
1:29:06it's always been ever since it was announced as sort of in that time when we were waiting for
1:29:14a retina macbook air and phil shiller did the spiel and sort of said like hey you know if if
1:29:22what you're looking for is something with the footprint of a macbook air with a retina screen
1:29:27this low-end 13-inch macbook pro compares very nicely and put them up side by side and the price
1:29:34was only a couple hundred bucks more and the footprint is the same and the weight was very
1:29:38good because they'd made it thinner even though it's not teardrop shaped and ahead of retina screen
1:29:42um but you know and what were the trade-offs compared to the more expensive 13-inch models
1:29:48well they had two ports instead of four ports and was you know had yeah some sort of intel
1:29:54you know lower lower price bar which right no touch bar right right which for a lot of people
1:29:59was a feature there i know people firsthand who were torn because they would rather have the
1:30:03faster macbook pro but didn't want the touch bar and so they're like i guess i'll just buy the one
1:30:08without the touch bar to me that would clean this up quite a bit and again are they going to keep
1:30:15the name air it seems like macbook air has sort of stopped meaning air meaning thinner and lighter
1:30:22and it's just sort of taken on it just it's like kleenex you know it it's just a brand name macbook
1:30:29air it's just people know it that's the macbook they want right what macbook do you want i want
1:30:34the air it's also become conflated with cheapest like the cheapest mac and that's never been the
1:30:38case at launch it's always launched it way more than 999 and then gone down to 999 but now when
1:30:43when they try to introduce new ones and they're more expensive people get really upset yeah
1:30:48definitely um and by the way i have to i i need to uh clarify this i did i did the research the 16
1:30:56inch macbook pro starts at 2500 not 2000 it's the fourth the 14 inch starts at two thousand dollars
1:31:04so there's there's a lot of room in that thousand to two thousand dollar range for more macbooks
1:31:11and from people who absolutely positively or would be over served by the m1 pro and m1 max
1:31:19chipsets right the that that that is the the the absolute blessing of the tremendous performance of
1:31:27the current apple silicon that the regular m1 is just terrific and the m2 will be even better
1:31:34um they don't need it but there's so much room in there and calling the 1400 ish macbook the pro
1:31:45is to me just confusing i i i so i kind of hope that they go away from that and leave the pros
1:31:53be what we now know as the 14 and 16 inch macbook pros keep the pro name for those make them very
1:32:01distinctive just like how with the iphone the pros are so distinctive right shiny stainless steel
1:32:08bigger camera pro yeah brushed aluminum yeah smaller camera regular you know so there's
1:32:16nothing like in the old iphone x body that's called the iphone pro minus or something that's
1:32:20just a cheaper level right fake pro so i i would love to see them do with the macbooks
1:32:26even if they just did it follow the lead of the iphone right so the pros have two sizes
1:32:33regular 14 inch big 16 inch and the regular ones would have two sizes mini go back to 12 inch
1:32:43and regular 14 inch and and have two two machines like that uh and so if you really want a tiniest
1:32:52tiniest macbook that apple has ever made uh you could get the new 12 inch macbook air or whatever
1:32:58they would call it you know maybe they just call it the macbook again i don't know and if you want
1:33:04a you know a mid-size macbook at a consumer price bump it up to 14 inches which would be a you know
1:33:11a nice increase from 13 uh and keep it a lower price that's what i hope they do i have no idea
1:33:16if that's what's in the works but it would make a lot more sense than using the names new low-end
1:33:24macbook pro and you know and talking about the macbook air as though it's definitely only one
1:33:31size because it doesn't have to be yeah yeah no it's super interesting because what apple when
1:33:37apple does those those uh you want to fano snaps those bezels there's two ways it does it one is
1:33:42like the smaller ipad pro where they made the an 11 inch screen in the previous 10.5 inch enclosure
1:33:50and the other is like the 12.9 inch ipad pro where they just removed as much device size around it so
1:33:56it was the same screen size but a way smaller package and we've seen them do that now like the
1:34:0116 inch macbook pro is just a little bit thinner than even the previous 16 inch model but they got
1:34:05a 14 inch display now in in the new 14 inch model and my guess is that the next the m2 um macbook or
1:34:14macbook air is not going to be a direct replacement for the current m1 macbook air they're going to
1:34:18keep that around at 999 but they're going to go back to what the the old macbook was and that is
1:34:24a premium ultralight model with an m2 chip and even smaller bezels so if i don't think it'll be
1:34:3012 inches but i think it'll it'll be the same physical size as the 12 inch it just won't have
1:34:34any bezels so the screen will still be like third and there was 13 point something or 12 point
1:34:38something like it's never as rounded off as the marketing but it'll be a much bigger screen in
1:34:42the same size body for more money because like mini it's a bill of goods things mini led is
1:34:47expensive and the chipsets are going to be expensive at first and apple wants to recoup
1:34:51they want to pay that down as fast as possible and then they'll leave the existing m1 on the market
1:34:56at 999 until they can replace it but i think that's the same thing that's sort of damning that
1:35:0013 inch macbook pro because the current one the m1 is going to it's 18 months old already it's going
1:35:06to be 24 months old by the end of the year they could put it inside they could have a lower end
1:35:11version of the 14 inch that has an m2 in it but if m2 is like m1 it won't have enough usbc and
1:35:17thunderbolt controllers for all those ports and it would be they'd have to like make an enclosure
1:35:22that paves over some of those ports which would be weird like they would totally do it but it would
1:35:26be weird and they also have like even though apple is like one of the biggest companies in the world
1:35:30they have such little bandwidth this one id team was one industrial design team and the mac team
1:35:35seems only able to push out you know two new macs a year and they have to pick and this year it
1:35:40sounds like that's going to be the macbook air the mac pro and a variation of the of the imac and
1:35:46there's just not enough time or bandwidth to make something else so that's why i think it's it's it's
1:35:51it's wrong for all the wrong reasons but they're going to just slap that m2 in the existing macbook
1:35:57pro 13 inch chassis the macbook air pro or pro air whatever you really want to call it and let that
1:36:03slide for another year and make that 2023 problem the other thing that's very clear from the iphone
1:36:09marketing is that the pro name only goes on the latest and greatest so they sell and i know that
1:36:15if you go to carriers around the world you can still get like a iphone 10r and stuff like that
1:36:22but what apple will sell you is the iphone 13 pro iphone 13 regular iphone 12 regular two sizes
1:36:30the iphone se and the iphone 11. pro means latest and greatest and i again i think that clarity
1:36:38would be so much better for the macbook branding just get rid of that low-end macbook pro and make
1:36:44kick-ass macbook airs that completely satisfy anybody's need who wants that that that you know
1:36:52price range of macbook totally agree i think the difference is with the mac market specifically
1:36:57since 2016 is that apple saw that there was a large and growing group of people who self-identified
1:37:04as pros but we're pros in the traditional context and that they were willing to give extra money
1:37:09just to have the pro branding so it became like airpods pro more than iphone pro and just making
1:37:14that product really swell is swelled up their sales well then let them spend two thousand
1:37:19dollars to get to get the 14 inch and again tim cook can thank us for it uh well me and you we
1:37:25can send we can send them a consulting bill you know it's it's only going to make tim cook uh
1:37:31like you said uh pivot his tables yes all right the the other big mac that we're obviously all
1:37:38waiting for and i alluded to it is the big iMac do we think that's coming in uh which i presume
1:37:46will simply have the the m1 pro and max guts of the the macbook pros that were just announced at
1:37:55the end of last year uh in the same way that the 24 inch iMac had the same m1 guts as the first
1:38:04round of m1 macbooks and the mac mini from 2020 2020. yeah do we think it's coming in early march
1:38:15i don't think so i think the there was three max that were registered in the and i'm blanking on
1:38:21which version it was was an eastern european i think it was yeah it was like it was like russia
1:38:25i think i i i mean ecc yeah of all the you know countries you know that i don't know if you've
1:38:30heard they're in they're in the news uh yeah yeah like the russian regulatory agency leak leak these
1:38:37things whether that means they're imminent or just somehow they were filed months in advance
1:38:41i mean presumably the 27 inch or 30 whatever it's going to be the bigger iMac with the m1 pro and m1
1:38:50max inside i presumably it would come at WWDC at the latest yeah right i mean i alongside a preview
1:38:58of the m1 pro mac pro or whatever right right i that's it whether they that's what they're you
1:39:04know that's the schedule that they're going to announce it at WWDC in june or they're going to do
1:39:10it uh next week or two weeks from now in early march or whether they're planning on one more
1:39:18event in between this march 1 and WWDC you know like a late april type of thing uh we don't know
1:39:27it's hard for them given how much prep there is for WWDC every year yeah and it's it yeah exactly
1:39:34it just seems easier to do one event with more devices packed in than two and i know and i'm
1:39:42sure you remember but like because i you and i had a really funny conversation in 2017 when they did
1:39:47the mother of all WWDCs and not only did they do every operating system but they did new mac pros
1:39:52new iMacs the home pod new ipad pros and you were just like i'm not i'm not taking any of this stuff
1:39:58back with me right there's way too much and i went there i talked to one of them and they're like
1:40:03Gruber's not coming uh what else might they announce there's also the pro level mac mini
1:40:12which you know and the mac mini is has been split basically in in rough look you know description
1:40:18like the 13-inch macbook pros were where there's the pro pro one with more ports and better
1:40:28performance and then the sort of ads just sort of the basic one with two ports and you know this and
1:40:34that yeah well they got rid of that right like originally the the mac mini came out as the 500
1:40:40you swap it in you rip out your pc you put this in and then they didn't update it for a long long
1:40:45long long time and then famously in 2018 they came out with like a real strut and saying now it's a
1:40:51pro level product it's more expensive but it's got all these pro features and they discontinued
1:40:55the low end model and then again in 2020 they came out with it made it silver again because it had
1:41:00gone to space gray and only made a low end model and they've left the intel model like with the
1:41:05like previously with the macbook pros and currently with the iMac they've left the intel one that's a
1:41:09high-end pro version right i mean you could still go in the apple store and buy a 27-inch iMac
1:41:13that's got an intel chip in it i that's my gut and again just sort of my you know i can kind of
1:41:20smell the way you know i i sniff test the way apple thinks my guess is that the pro tier mac
1:41:28mini will be space gray right and with the apple silicon right so if you see in a mac mini you'll
1:41:34be even you'll even be able to know is it a consumer level apple silicon mac mini or a pro
1:41:39level one is it regular gray or space gray how much great the rumors are also that it's going
1:41:45to get a redesign and that the consumer version might be like the iMac where it's going to have
1:41:50this this new top on it and and size that are going to be colored like multi-colored as well
1:41:54right yeah that would be interesting uh what else displays people think that pros don't like colors
1:42:00because like they don't make the pro stuff in color but if you're actually a pro and you're
1:42:03working on color correct material you can't have like red or green or blue blowing out the cones
1:42:08in your eyes while you're trying to do your your color sensitive work so that's why those are always
1:42:12gray yeah but your mac mini you could just you could just put a throw it in the closet yeah yeah
1:42:16throw it in the closet put a put a handkerchief over it or something you know it's not not hard
1:42:22to hide i mean as opposed to the the iMacs right there's no getting away from the color on the
1:42:28yes on the the colorful iMacs um and then that leads us to standalone displays right like what
1:42:34do you hook up the thing and you know uh i don't believe the rumors that they're working on multiple
1:42:40sizes of consumer grade uh you know there's rumors that spit you know 24 inch 27 inch a new
1:42:47xdr an updated version of the xdr that actually would have like apple silicon chip inside to do
1:42:54some sort of whatever you know processing properly mini led because that one was just before mini led
1:42:59it's still it has way more uh discrete display zones but it's it's not it's still regular led
1:43:04to me i think the best we can hope for i mean i i would love it i because i i i really think apple
1:43:11has been disappointed by the third-party display market picking up the slack uh if apple doesn't
1:43:19do it it's apparently no one's going to do it and it does get into the different i know i've spoken
1:43:24with this spoken about this on the show probably with you at some point but it does get into like
1:43:29another fundamental difference in the pc market and the mac market where in the pc market retina
1:43:34is not as big a deal and a huge part of the pc market of of people who are willing to spend
1:43:40let's say you know a premium for a really good display are gamers who don't definitely don't
1:43:48want retina right they want frame rate and brightness and other things and retina would
1:43:53actually defeat the purpose of getting the highest possible frame rate that they can get
1:43:58um well it's also they'll take a 4k display if you give it to them but they have no need for
1:44:02color management where people who are working on a mac they want to take advantage of the end-to-end
1:44:06color management it'd be ridiculous not to and reference modes and all those things right and
1:44:10you know all the various features that apple has across all their displays and yeah true tone and
1:44:14etc um and a decent looking enclosure that doesn't destroy your wi-fi or fritz out or something that's
1:44:21plagued all the lg versions of the exact same panel or wobble yeah like it's just like it's
1:44:27the exact same panel as the imac that they just put it in the worst possible enclosure i don't see
1:44:32how i know some people you know i don't i forget what's german and what's not but some people
1:44:36have speculated maybe it's just the pro mac mini that's coming in march and not the imac i don't
1:44:43that to me is a hard announcement because to me there's more people waiting for the imac and it
1:44:49and it's a more exciting thing to show right it's going to be good looking and exciting to look at
1:44:57in the way that last year's consumer grade 24-inch imacs work whereas no matter what they do with the
1:45:02mac mini form factor right it it it's it's a mini it's just a little it's a little square you know
1:45:10the only like interesting thing they could do is if they wanted to announce dual die m1 max but
1:45:14then you ruin that for an imac pro or a mac pro announcement later right like they specifically
1:45:20didn't announce a15 with the ipad mini because they wanted to do that with the iphone and like
1:45:24that's the exact same problem with announcing a mac mini without announcing my mac pro or a mac pro
1:45:28all right so i don't know you know i guess i i would guess what of the mac mini with pro you know
1:45:37m1 max m1 pro silicon and the bigger pro max imac if we don't hear about them in early march
1:45:46we'll get them at wwdc or before but it would be a little weird to have another event before but
1:45:52we'll see what do you think about like because a lot of people are concerned that if they are now
1:45:56like they they conflate the number with the capabilities so that an m2 comes out it suddenly
1:46:02makes m1 pro and m1 max seem obsolete and why would apple do this and the whole branding is bad
1:46:08and it reminds me of when the a12z ipad pro came out six months after the a13 in the iphone and
1:46:15people had the exact same issue with it and you know you could explain to them it's way more
1:46:20massively multi-core so even though each single core isn't as fast you have so many more cores
1:46:26but they just see a number on a package do you think that's gonna affect m2 versus m1 pro or max
1:46:31well i think it's going to be interesting because i do i would expect then that when they do this
1:46:36that the m2s will have better single core performance right i mean and we're that's going
1:46:43to rub people the wrong way even though that's the way the intel world has worked it's just that it's
1:46:48no it's it's so that the nomenclature is so less clear right like so for example the xeon chips in
1:46:55the imac pro that the slate you know the space gray imac pro that was based on the intel stuff
1:47:01had you know i i think even when it debuted had worse single core performance than some certain
1:47:07other models it's the multi-core thing right so especially the high core count ones they
1:47:11was went really right down right like so like the the basic story of how you know these pro multi uh
1:47:19you know with an emphasis on the parallel processing right like having 20 cpu cores or 40
1:47:27up to 40 which we might get in in the the highest end mac pro with apple silicon 40 cpu cores you
1:47:36know who even knows i mean how many fingers you need to count all the gpu cores they're going to
1:47:41have but that the way that this works is you come out with the consumer version with fewer cores
1:47:49with the latest and greatest process and you get the greatest highest single core performance and
1:47:55then it's like an 18-month window before it filters down to the multi-core people i think
1:48:02will just have to deal with it i do think that there will be a media freak out of holy crap
1:48:08they're selling they're selling this mac pro for you know what forty thousand dollars whatever is
1:48:15going to go up to it right put a crazy price tag on a maxed out mac pro with apple silicon with
1:48:2240 cores and uh you know 100 gpu cores and gobs and gobs and gobs of ram and this huge price tag
1:48:30of like a luxury car and they're like hey and it you know it loses on single core geek bench to
1:48:36a you know a 1200 MacBook air with an m2 i deal with it that's the you know you know then then
1:48:43then luck if you're impressed by that then lucky you spend the 1200 comes to my house and hits my
1:48:50computer with a baseball bat right i do think though that that's clearly going to be the case
1:48:54i mean that's just the way it's clear the way it works it's just that you know and apple's
1:48:59naman nomenclature of calling it the m1 and then the m1 pro and m1 max and then we're going to have
1:49:04the m2 and the m2 max and m2 pro yeah you know by putting simple numbers on it it's it's easier
1:49:11to understand than all the various lakes and the core i d nines and core i sevens and i mean we've
1:49:17had core i sevens and i nines and i fives for a decade right like the five and the seven and the
1:49:23nine don't correlate to whether they're newer or older they're they're tears and it's you know i'm
1:49:31sure it makes sense to somebody at intel and you know and there are enthusiasts who have it all
1:49:35memorized but you can't figure it out just from the names whereas with apple's names they're so
1:49:40much more clear it certainly seems as though the pro computers should have faster everything than
1:49:48the consumer ones but that's just not the way the silicon world works today and if they actually
1:49:53they're smart they mitigate it because like when you look at the m1 pro and the m1 max they're
1:49:57broken up into two zones so that you have half the cpu's in each of the zones and then one side could
1:50:02be flat out with single core while the other side is the frequency is stepped down for multi-core so
1:50:07you don't lose as much as you would in like just a generalized cpu environment but the the m1 is
1:50:13based on the a14 from the iphone 12 and if it comes out anytime before the end of the year m2
1:50:17will be based on the a15 and so you get a little bit better performance but way more efficient
1:50:22performance cores way more performant efficiency cores way way better graphics cores pro right like
1:50:28you get all of these things bundled into it that core for core is going to be better but you're
1:50:32still not going to compete with 32 gpu cores on an m1 max yeah it's you know i i think we see the way
1:50:40the pattern's going but it's definitely like i think for the foreseeable future going to be this
1:50:4518 month at least cycle between the latest you know and and i guess even more maybe it's more
1:50:53like a a a 30 month cycle if you count the a series chip from an iphone a year later becoming
1:51:03the m plus one integer for the mac consumer and then 18 months after that before it filters to
1:51:11the mac pro where it has 20 to 40 cores and etc etc you know it's which was the pattern right like
1:51:17they had the a5x a6x no x no a7x a8x a9x a10x no a11x then a 12x 12z no 13x but then m1 is
1:51:27essentially 14x so they were on like a 15 an 18 month cycle with the the extended versions of the
1:51:32chips anyway right right so i don't know what do you think are they going to do a standalone
1:51:36display at a consumer price i hope so i mean there have been rumors of it for a while and i
1:51:42know everybody is like talking about custom apple silicon but apple has been making their own tcon
1:51:46controllers for those displays like for the imac going back till 2014 or something so to me apple
1:51:52silicon just sounds like they're going to have a display engine and something that'll minimize the
1:51:55impact of the graphics on the card so that all makes a lot of sense to me if they could bring
1:51:59that in for a thousand dollars it would certainly you i love this joke you made back at the event
1:52:03where you're like 6k for 6k is that the price or the resolution you know and that's true though
1:52:08like it's out of the reach of almost every consumer and that makes sense if you want to
1:52:12bring a new technology to market but if you don't bring that technology down it doesn't help anybody
1:52:17well and it's technically overkill right it's it you know it's the same thing as like buying a
1:52:2140 core mac pro right like i i literally have no need there's nothing i do that's even vaguely that
1:52:28parallel i know some people do right there's all sorts of people who do need it but the pro display
1:52:34xdr costs so much because it does things that you really have to be like a color pro or video editing
1:52:42a pro to you're supposed to save you money on a 40k display not cost you money on a 1k display
1:52:46yeah it's the the issue of how much would an apple standalone display cost is is tough i would love
1:52:53it if it was 999 and if you know if the iMac is like two thousand dollars to start it's you know
1:53:02could you get the display from the iMac for half the price maybe you know if if it were 1,500 for
1:53:10the display does it make sense that the display is three quarters of the cost of the iMac you know
1:53:16you start running well that was the old joke is that you got the free you got the free computer
1:53:20when you bought the iMac right but you never ever lose you never ever lose by betting the over
1:53:24on how much blank from apple going to cost yeah and for everything like air tags where it's like
1:53:30hey 29 bucks that's not bad you know that's a reasonable price there's all sorts of products
1:53:35you know like the pro display xdr and the thousand dollar stands yeah the wheels how many wheels do
1:53:41you want uh but it's oh boy ed and i you know i know that we you even mentioned that apple has a
1:53:47rejuvenated they even announced it explicitly a rejuvenated interest in the mac mini as a product
1:53:54and and want to support the people who depend on it for various reasons begging for a display
1:54:00because it needs a display but even if you want to be a little cynical about how much apple cares
1:54:06about the mac mini customers who need a display and that they think that people who are going to
1:54:11spend five six seven eight ten thousand dollars on a mac pro they can just cough up the dough
1:54:17for the pro display xdr yeah um to me the market for the big market for a standalone nice apple
1:54:26display are the tens hundreds million users of macbooks who would like to have a standalone
1:54:32display on their desk to connect their macbook to so and so desperate that a lot of us have said
1:54:37we'll just take an imac just bring back target display right because we lost that when they
1:54:41started making their own tcons because they couldn't sync to right 4k streams to make the
1:54:445k display when they haven't brought it back so you can't even you can't even give 1500 bucks for
1:54:48a good imac and make that your display so hopefully they do it it would make for a better uh to me it
1:54:55as i would imagine it makes for a better unveiling to be able to show the the new you know updated
1:55:03mac minis connected to an apple display that doesn't start at six thousand dollars because
1:55:07like why are you buying a mac mini if you have a six thousand dollar display um and you know it
1:55:13would be cohesive to announce it alongside the new imac and say it's the same great display you know
1:55:20whichever one they announce first i don't know maybe they announced the standalone display first
1:55:24and then the imac or the imac and that but either way whichever one comes second they could say it's
1:55:28the same great display with all the great mini led features and the every blah blah blah you know
1:55:34then they could skip that whole part you know just say same great it's one case where like
1:55:39because they did announce airplay but like that that's one case where wireless isn't as good
1:55:43right like it just doesn't work as well as a cable at that point right uh i know we've gone a little
1:55:48over the hour i was hoping for but uh a little bit a little bit but we still have to the rumor
1:55:54is that there's going to be a new ipad air do we care yeah well so a lot of people kind of snickering
1:56:00at the announcement it's going to be the iphone se and the and the air but those are huge like
1:56:04not nerd like i think we forget sometimes at tech twitter and tech youtuber a very small percent of
1:56:09apple's market like maybe 10 and there are a lot of people who just they would i don't know if they
1:56:13care that much about an event but they really want updated or they want new iphone se's and new ipad
1:56:18and so i think they're good products i don't know if they'll make particularly exciting event but
1:56:22if they're there along with a couple other things like i could see them getting in the old days it
1:56:26would be a couple slides like you know so we put up a couple and we're also updating this and we're
1:56:30also updating that because the mac but the ipad air got its new redesign in 2020 but it didn't
1:56:36get 5g the way that the mic the mac mini the ipad mini update got last year so just putting in the
1:56:42new chip and putting in the new the new 5g radio brings it back up to par it's just not it's not
1:56:47super thrilling yeah it sort of sets 5g as the baseline right like everything everything that
1:56:52has a cellular modem from apple supports 5g or it's by some definition i don't i don't think the
1:56:58watch does yet i don't know i i doubt it yeah i actually don't even know what the cellular watch
1:57:04does no it's it's barely got what's got like uh piggybacked lte right but nobody i mean nobody's
1:57:09using their you can't even use your watch as your only cell phone you know it's it's only a peripheral
1:57:14to your phone so i i'm gonna say that doesn't count so yeah you know uh you know it it sticks
1:57:20out a little bit that the brand new or brand new from the end of last year ipad mini is in some
1:57:26ways technically superior to the ipad air so at least bring the ipad air up to that ipad mini
1:57:32level and make it bigger it just does not seem like a you know it i'm sure they'll send cell
1:57:36gobs of them i'm sure it'll be a great product it's good to get everything on 5g cannot see this
1:57:42as uh if it were the only thing they had ready to go i don't think they'd have an event i think
1:57:47that's the sort of thing where they would uh again covet times are weird you know but pre-covid times
1:57:52they would just invite the media to new york or cooper and or cupertino yeah for briefings last
1:57:58time with the new air right it really makes sense and how they do that sort of release in the covid
1:58:05era uh even if if we're just at the tail end of it you know but some kind of do it by press release
1:58:10maybe have some briefings a day in advance with the you know an nda you know this will be announced
1:58:17you know tomorrow or something like that i just can't see how the ipad air makes for an event
1:58:21i really don't because i because it's super interesting because like last year april was
1:58:25an actual product event but the two previous ones uh 2018-20 2018-2019 2018 was an education
1:58:32event in chicago 2019 was in cupertino but it was a services event and they did announce products
1:58:37like new airpods and new macbook airs new mac new ipad airs new ipad minis but those were all
1:58:44dropped in press releases in new york trips right to your point those weren't part of the event
1:58:48well and and then you know to to cycle back to the same idea it's is is a brand new iphone se
1:58:56demoable right if it looks the same as the iphone se we know and it just it looks the same has the
1:59:02same starting price but has the a15 chip we already heard about six months ago and 5g which
1:59:08has been out for you know almost two years how do you demo that right like there has to you know the
1:59:14whole point of these shows whether they're actual on-stage events you know with in-person media
1:59:21broadcast out there or these tv style shows that they've been doing since 2020 they have to show
1:59:27something there has to be a story to tell and something to demo and to me the iphone se just
1:59:33a faster chip that's only as fast as the iphones that came out six months ago in 5g
1:59:37how do you demo that so that to me so they've done it like they jaws did a really good se demo
1:59:43back in 2016 with the first one but the second one never got a demo because that event was
1:59:47cancelled for coven so we just got we just got a press release for the iphone se 2 but the only
1:59:52parallel i can think of is that entry level uh now it's 10.2 inch ipad where every year every
1:59:59september they've been updating that and i try to think of that slide at the end that has all the
2:00:03boxes on it that shows all the new features and how could you possibly fill that out and that's
2:00:07the only thing that comes close because they spend two seconds talking about the new processor and
2:00:11radio and then they recapitulate new features in ios and then they put the slide up at the end
2:00:16but it's like a three minute long segment right and you know and they can do things for demos
2:00:21that just show people using it you know like with the mini with the ipad mini they love showing it
2:00:26with pilots you know who can put it in their big cargo pants side pocket you know and people use
2:00:31it in this place in that place but there's only so much of that you can do i mean it's it there's
2:00:36like a minimum length to an event which i would peg at about 45 minutes i mean yeah like if it's
2:00:44you know only half an hour why why have the event so long story short that just it just fills me
2:00:49with optimism that there's something exciting mac related yes to anchor this march 8th event
2:00:56which to me would have to be the the bigger iMac because i just don't see the iphone se with 5g or
2:01:06an ipad air with 5g as being uh you know how do you fill half out within a couple slides right
2:01:13it's put them in the first 20 minutes and then you know yeah have some mac related boom you know to
2:01:21go with it boy that that that's much more exciting yeah that's what i'm hoping for all right thank
2:01:27you renee uh i would also like to thank you sir thank our our excellent sponsors we had memberful
2:01:33where you can monetize your passion with membership at uh memberful.com slash talk show
2:01:39and of course our good friends at linode right here in philadelphia linode.com slash the talk
2:01:46show congrats to linode too on a 900 million dollar acquisition from akamai which which broke
2:01:52in between their last sponsorship in this one uh good deal by them uh anyway talk to you soon renee
2:01:59thank you