Podcast Search

The Talk Show

365: ‘Permanent September’, With Rene Ritchie

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00- This is gonna be a challenge, Rene.

0:00:01I feel like this is gonna test all of my meager

0:00:04podcast hosting skills to get this in on time.

0:00:07We, you and I, I don't know how many years in a row,

0:00:09we've done a year in review, Apple year in review

0:00:11at the end of the year, this is it.

0:00:13But yet we've got news to cover.

0:00:15How are we gonna do it?

0:00:16There's all sorts of new stuff that is out.

0:00:18I'm not known for my brevity,

0:00:19but I'm gonna make the best of it.

0:00:21- Okay.

0:00:22- How are you?

0:00:23- Good, thank you, how are you doing?

0:00:25- Well, I'm doing pretty well.

0:00:27I'm cold, but it's, the good news is I went outside.

0:00:29- You have an Intel Mac, though.

0:00:30That's still got a built-in space heater,

0:00:31so you're one up on me now.

0:00:33- No, I'm not using an Intel Mac to record this show.

0:00:36I'm on an M1, so I'm drawing no heat from my--

0:00:39- Ah, same, yeah, same.

0:00:40- I guess year in review, we could start with you.

0:00:43This has been a big year for you,

0:00:45and the last time you were on the show back in June,

0:00:48and nothing had happened yet,

0:00:49but since then, you've started a new gig,

0:00:52and for those who don't know,

0:00:53why don't you talk about it?

0:00:55- Yeah, I joined YouTube as creator liaison,

0:00:58and it's interesting because I was done.

0:01:01My old company got bought out

0:01:02by some giant UK media conglomerate,

0:01:05and it wasn't my scene, so I quit.

0:01:08I went independent.

0:01:09Mutual friend Dave Whiskus helped me

0:01:11get a whole YouTube thing going, and it was great.

0:01:13Never gonna work for a company again,

0:01:15and then a guy I knew, a friend of mine, Matt Koval,

0:01:17who was the YouTube creator liaison, he resigned,

0:01:20and I'd heard about that,

0:01:22and it was a couple months going on,

0:01:23and then another friend of mine who works at YouTube said,

0:01:25"You should try out for the job,"

0:01:27and I just kept saying, "No, I'm done.

0:01:29"I'm never working for a company again."

0:01:31He said, "Just meet with the team," and I did,

0:01:33and it was like, I swear to God, John,

0:01:36it was like one of those moments

0:01:37where you're walked around the park,

0:01:38and they say, "You don't wanna keep making soda water

0:01:40"or come with us and dent the universe,"

0:01:43because it was like really this opportunity

0:01:44to help people, to help creators,

0:01:46and all the people that they touch at a scale

0:01:49that's like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,

0:01:51and I always figured helping people choose phones

0:01:53and helping people choose laptops, that's all great,

0:01:56but the ability to help people change lives

0:01:59was something I couldn't pass up,

0:02:01so I decided to try to get the job,

0:02:02and then I was very lucky to get it.

0:02:04- I will say, you do seem, and I do feel like

0:02:07when you announced it, which was a surprise,

0:02:11you kept it a surprise for me, including,

0:02:13all you'd let me know is

0:02:14that you had an announcement coming up.

0:02:15I did not press you, which I think you will agree.

0:02:18I was a good friend, let you have your secret.

0:02:20I know how that is, but I do feel

0:02:22that once you announced it,

0:02:24everybody sort of had the unique or the same reaction,

0:02:28which was this seems like a job

0:02:30that was invented for Renee,

0:02:32and insofar as it is something

0:02:35you seem keenly interested in,

0:02:37but also over the years,

0:02:39I believe that you have befriended

0:02:42in the truest non-competitive sense

0:02:46in the way that being on YouTube is not zero-sum, right?

0:02:50I mean, ultimately it is,

0:02:51'cause there's only 24 hours in a day.

0:02:53You can't watch more than 24 hours

0:02:56of YouTube videos in a day,

0:02:57I guess unless you speed 'em up,

0:02:59but you know an awful lot of independent creators

0:03:03on YouTube, for lack of a better word,

0:03:05and they know you and like you,

0:03:08and now your job is literally to help them?

0:03:11- Yeah, so I advocate for creators inside of YouTube.

0:03:15Like, everyone on YouTube is really pro-creator.

0:03:17That was one of the things that,

0:03:18I can't say it really surprised me,

0:03:19but really made me happy,

0:03:21was that everyone fiercely thought about creators

0:03:24and prioritized creators, but it's my only job.

0:03:27I don't have anything else to do but advocate for creators,

0:03:30try to build empathy and understanding

0:03:31about what creators go through.

0:03:33All different kinds of creators,

0:03:34'cause it's not just one kind.

0:03:35There's big and small and marginalized and mainstream

0:03:38and all across the spectrum of cultural

0:03:40and lifestyle interests.

0:03:42Do all that inside YouTube,

0:03:44but at the same time try to educate creators outside YouTube

0:03:47so they understand the systems better

0:03:49and can be more successful on the platform.

0:03:51So it's sort of like half ombudsman, half evangelism.

0:03:54- Yeah, I guess so, right?

0:03:56I mean, and it's going back to Apple even,

0:03:59the evangelists, sort of like the working in dev relations,

0:04:03the equivalent, you know?

0:04:05- Yeah, except I get to see things on Twitter

0:04:08and interact with people,

0:04:09which I think is different than Apple's culture.

0:04:12The evangelists at Apple are amazing,

0:04:14but they don't get to interact

0:04:15in a public forum with developers,

0:04:18and I also get to champion them inside

0:04:21and say, "What are we doing here?

0:04:22"Why is this happening on Twitter?

0:04:23"What is going on?"

0:04:24And try to find answers, which I think is fantastic.

0:04:27- But you're still making videos.

0:04:30- Yes, yeah, so part of the thing was

0:04:31I never wanna not feel the pain of being a creator,

0:04:33'cause I think that helps with the empathy,

0:04:35and I also wanna make sure if,

0:04:36it's the same thing with code.

0:04:37I don't want anyone else to hit the bugs first,

0:04:39'cause that's a terrible experience.

0:04:41So I try to do all the different things that YouTube does

0:04:43so that I can feel the same things

0:04:44that creators are going through.

0:04:47Which would be different.

0:04:49Again, to stress the analogy,

0:04:50it would be like if somebody who worked in dev relations

0:04:52at Apple could still be an independent developer somehow.

0:04:56Which it doesn't actually, I actually do understand.

0:04:59Actually, can't spend too much time

0:05:03going into the app store today.

0:05:04We have time limits, but I understand

0:05:07why that doesn't quite work out.

0:05:09It's interesting to me, though,

0:05:11that it does, that YouTube doesn't see this,

0:05:13and I guess I can kind of see why.

0:05:16The idea would be, well, wait a minute.

0:05:18If you're making some kind of app,

0:05:19how do you know it's not Apple's,

0:05:21there's weird, people go to work for a big,

0:05:24it's not just Apple, but you go to work

0:05:26for one of these big companies.

0:05:28Your employment contract often says something

0:05:32to the effect of, it's just best not to work

0:05:35on other software.

0:05:37Whereas your video, your independent video creations,

0:05:41there's no reason why YouTube would have any claim,

0:05:43or even want claim to them, right?

0:05:44YouTube itself has no interest in owning them,

0:05:48as opposed to some sort of clever utility

0:05:50for iOS or something like that,

0:05:52where you could see the conflict

0:05:54and you don't want to blur any lines.

0:05:56This sort of is perfect?

0:05:58- Yeah, I did have to change my channel

0:06:00in a non-insignificant way,

0:06:02'cause I was just doing complete Apple product coverage

0:06:04and a lot of rumors and things.

0:06:05Now I work inside Google, I have a lot of information

0:06:07inside Google, so it's not fair for me

0:06:10to do that kind of stuff.

0:06:11So I try to do more video essays.

0:06:13And also it wouldn't be fair if I had access to things

0:06:15that weren't available, at least in public betas.

0:06:17So we're all very careful to make sure that,

0:06:20like I'm running it in a way that doesn't touch anything

0:06:22that Google does, which is hard,

0:06:23'cause Google does so many things,

0:06:25but also doesn't have access to anything

0:06:27that a standard creator wouldn't have access to.

0:06:29- Hmm, I getcha, I getcha.

0:06:31And so anyway, here we are at the end of the year,

0:06:33it's going well?

0:06:34- Yeah, yeah, it's fantastic.

0:06:36It's the best thing I've ever done.

0:06:37Like I get to finish almost every day

0:06:39knowing that I helped creators,

0:06:40especially marginalized creators,

0:06:41in like pretty amazing ways.

0:06:43- That's pretty good.

0:06:44All right, before we dig into actual news,

0:06:47Apple Front, let's start with a thank you

0:06:50to one of our sponsors here on my show.

0:06:52And speaking of independent creators, it is Memberful.

0:06:56You can monetize your passion with memberships.

0:06:59Memberful allows you, a creative individual,

0:07:02to build a sustainable recurring revenue.

0:07:04It is the easiest way to sell memberships to your audience,

0:07:07used by some of the biggest creators on the web.

0:07:10And it is, as I like to say, win, win, win.

0:07:14It is a great system for you.

0:07:16This is who they're pitching it to,

0:07:18somebody who is creative and has some kind of audience

0:07:20that you're hoping to monetize or monetize better or more,

0:07:23or just add another leg to your monetization stool,

0:07:27as it were.

0:07:28It is great for your audience.

0:07:31Everybody loves, everybody who wants to support somebody

0:07:34who's going through Memberful,

0:07:36the experience is just terrific.

0:07:37Every single aspect from the signup and the cancellation,

0:07:42if you do want to cancel a subscription or a membership

0:07:45or something like that, no strings attached, it is easy.

0:07:48It is, and it supplies, it provides all sorts

0:07:52of great features from the creator who is hosting

0:07:55the Memberful system to the users.

0:07:57And it's great for Memberful,

0:07:58'cause Memberful only succeeds when you succeed

0:08:02and keep people happy and keep them subscribed

0:08:05to your membership thing.

0:08:06That's all they're in it for, is to keep people happy.

0:08:09And they have everything you need,

0:08:10from custom branding, gift subscriptions,

0:08:12Apple Pay, free trials, private podcasts that you can host

0:08:16just for your members.

0:08:17They take care of all the technical stuff

0:08:19to make sure that that stuff remains private,

0:08:21the private goodies just for your paying members,

0:08:24and tons more.

0:08:25And you keep full control and ownership,

0:08:28not just of your audience and the list,

0:08:30which you could take with you at any time

0:08:32if you do choose to leave, but your brand.

0:08:34Your brand stays front and foremost with Memberful.

0:08:38People may not even, your users, your audience,

0:08:42they may not even know they're going through Memberful

0:08:44because your brand stays right at the forefront.

0:08:47They've got a world-class support team

0:08:49who is willing to help you simplify your memberships,

0:08:52help you strategize what type of things to offer,

0:08:54how much to charge, stuff like that.

0:08:56They are passionate about your success

0:08:58because they only succeed when you succeed.

0:09:00You can get started for free and try it out,

0:09:02see everything they have to offer with no credit card required.

0:09:06Where do you go to do this?

0:09:08You go to memberful.com/talkshow.

0:09:12Go to memberful.com/talkshow today,

0:09:16monetize your audience with memberships.

0:09:18Let's get the news out of the way.

0:09:19I would say, let's just go least pleasant to most pleasant.

0:09:24And I've spent a lot of time writing about Twitter this month.

0:09:30I think a very good interview with Anil Dash

0:09:33an episode or two ago here on the show,

0:09:35which the backstory on that is that things are moving

0:09:40so fast at Twitter under Elon Musk

0:09:43that usually I have about a 36, 48 hour turnaround here

0:09:48between recording and publishing episodes,

0:09:51sometimes closer to 24 hours, sometimes closer to 48.

0:09:54So much had happened after Anil,

0:09:58Anil and I record, I thought it went really well.

0:10:01And I was really keen on having a guest

0:10:04who was skeptical, to say the least,

0:10:07that's almost putting it kindly,

0:10:08skeptical of Elon Musk back in April

0:10:11when it was first announced that he would buy Twitter

0:10:14because I was publicly optimistic.

0:10:17And so I wanted somebody who would push me on that

0:10:20because I was turning, I was like, hmm,

0:10:23looks like this might be one of those cases

0:10:25where I get to apply my way to be right all the time

0:10:28is to admit when you're wrong.

0:10:29- Yes.

0:10:30- And Anil was excellent and really made

0:10:33a lot of keen points, further changed my mind

0:10:36during the interview, which is always to me very exciting.

0:10:39I find it very exciting to change my mind.

0:10:41And I got worried after we recorded

0:10:44because all of a sudden more stuff started happening.

0:10:46And I was like, is this even gonna be relevant?

0:10:49And it was literally the weekend where he laid off

0:10:56three quarters, two thirds, whatever of their staff

0:10:58and then additional people started resigning

0:11:02and there was speculation, there were quotes in the press

0:11:05from people who said that there were teams

0:11:07that Twitter could not function without

0:11:09who were down to zero headcount.

0:11:12And so if it were true that Twitter couldn't function

0:11:15without them, that the whole site might collapse,

0:11:17which didn't happen, but I was,

0:11:20it was a stressful 36 hours 'cause I was like,

0:11:22I want this episode out, it was good.

0:11:24- I don't have much more to say about that.

0:11:25I will say though that in the last 24 hours as we record,

0:11:30Twitter instituted an official policy,

0:11:33including an official help page,

0:11:35banning the inclusion of links to about, I don't know,

0:11:40half a dozen, a dozen other social media sites.

0:11:43It's funny what was included on the list and what wasn't.

0:11:45It was like Facebook, Instagram, Mastodon,

0:11:48which I think was the one that was under Elon Musk's skin.

0:11:50Truth Social for some reason, but not LinkedIn and not,

0:11:55I forget what else, or Tumblr.

0:11:56- Not YouTube. - Yeah, not YouTube.

0:11:58But YouTube would certainly make sense, I think,

0:12:01because I, I don't know, it's--

0:12:04- Yeah, and Notor was there too, which upset Jack.

0:12:07- Yes, well, that seemed like it was just for Jack, right?

0:12:12- Yeah. - What's it called?

0:12:12Nostr? - Nostr, yeah, I don't know.

0:12:15There's too few letters left and too many acronyms.

0:12:18- Yeah, I don't understand it.

0:12:20I looked into it when I saw Jack was into it.

0:12:22- Not, it's N-O-S-T-R, so it's sort of a 20,

0:12:26sort of like a, I guess, maybe?

0:12:29It's like, well, I don't know, though,

0:12:30it's about predictions, but I looked into it

0:12:32and it's not something you can sign up for.

0:12:34It's like some kind of, it's way more nascent and nerdy

0:12:38and you run it and generate, I don't know.

0:12:40It's more cryptographically inclined.

0:12:42- But not Hive, it was a real smorgasbord, a link tree,

0:12:45a real smorgasbord of random things.

0:12:48- Yeah, well, Hive is the one that exploded in popularity,

0:12:51but then had sort of had to shut down for a bit

0:12:54because they were so in over their heads.

0:12:56Again, it doesn't seem like they were incompetent.

0:12:59It just seems like a three-person project

0:13:02exploded in popularity for reasons, you know.

0:13:04Nobody can, you never know when something's

0:13:06gonna blow up like that.

0:13:08Post seems more, post.news is the name

0:13:12of the social network.

0:13:14Right now, they're web-only.

0:13:15I honestly don't see the appeal, but you know,

0:13:20maybe it's because it's designed for people

0:13:22who are unlike me.

0:13:24It seems to be drawn up to draw journalists,

0:13:29for lack of a better word, media personalities,

0:13:31which you would think I would be included in,

0:13:33but I just don't see the appeal of it.

0:13:35- No.

0:13:36- But because it's going after media people

0:13:39and Elon Musk is obsessed clearly,

0:13:41whether you love him or hate him or are ambivalent,

0:13:43he's clearly interested in publicity and attention.

0:13:47Therefore, a network specifically geared towards people

0:13:51in a position of media influence

0:13:52is clearly gonna catch his attention.

0:13:54- And this was all, by the way,

0:13:55during the World Cup finale,

0:13:57where attention became incredibly divided.

0:13:59- Right?

0:14:01- And he was there, alive,

0:14:02like he's coordinating a less-well-sittin'-there-in-the-box,

0:14:04watchin' the match.

0:14:05- Right, in Qatar with a friend of the show, Jared Kushner.

0:14:09- Jared and the homies.

0:14:11- Yeah, and you know, well, by late last night,

0:14:14the whole policy had been rescinded,

0:14:16the help page was a 404,

0:14:18and I guess it's a big nevermind.

0:14:20I'm not quite sure if they've taken,

0:14:22I haven't even tried it yet,

0:14:23if they have taken out the filters,

0:14:25the ham-fisted filters they've applied

0:14:28to keep you from linking to your Mastodon account

0:14:30in your Twitter bio.

0:14:32I don't know if they've taken those out yet or not.

0:14:34Who knows what's going on?

0:14:35I'm just curious.

0:14:36- My favorite was the quick journey of Paul Graham,

0:14:39where he went from people who aren't CEOs of companies

0:14:41shouldn't be telling Elon how to run this company,

0:14:43to this is it, my last straw, I've had it,

0:14:45I'm leaving from Mastodon, to Paul Graham is banned.

0:14:48- I sympathize with Paul Graham though,

0:14:51'cause I feel like while his initial tweet

0:14:53that he's getting dunked on from, I don't know,

0:14:56a long, long couple of weeks ago,

0:14:58where he said people who haven't been in this position

0:15:00shouldn't criticize, you know,

0:15:02he's run rocket and electric car companies,

0:15:05that's harder, to now being, you know, yesterday,

0:15:07while that, now the link policy has been rescinded,

0:15:09so, you know, and Paul Graham did not close or shutter

0:15:13or delete his Twitter account, he just said,

0:15:14"I'm just gonna stop using it

0:15:16"if this nonsense stays in policy."

0:15:18Well, you know, it is funny, it is a journey,

0:15:21it definitely fits the meme of how things started,

0:15:25how they're going, right, which is an evergreen format.

0:15:29- There were a couple of these, like the other one,

0:15:31where the two others really stuck out to me,

0:15:32one was a YouTuber, I would say like a right-leaning YouTuber,

0:15:37somebody who's clearly in Elon Musk's wheelhouse right now,

0:15:41said, "This is bad because I wanna use my link tree

0:15:44"to connect to my YouTube and to my coffee products

0:15:47"and all this," and Elon was like,

0:15:48"Oh yeah, that's a good idea,

0:15:49"so from now on we'll change it."

0:15:51And it's just like that feedback loop to me is astonishing.

0:15:55And then Jimmy, MrBeast tweeted, like Elon put up this,

0:15:59we'll get to this, Elon put up this poll

0:16:00about whether we should stay or not,

0:16:01and Jimmy's like, "If you keep doing hair-brain stuff

0:16:04"like this, no," with a barf emoji,

0:16:06and usually when you push back on Elon, his fans flood you.

0:16:11I've done three videos on Twitter,

0:16:12same like you've been coming at your podcast,

0:16:14I never got that much hate for covering Zuckerberg,

0:16:17covering Google, covering Apple,

0:16:19covering any other company's things

0:16:21that I thought were not examples of good management.

0:16:24I got destroyed on all of those videos.

0:16:27And Jimmy is the first time I've seen someone respond

0:16:29to Elon in a negative way where the fandom did not know

0:16:33how to react and were kinda like,

0:16:35"But Jimmy, Jimmy, please, let us just explain it to you."

0:16:38- So yeah, I guess where we stand as we record,

0:16:41God only knows where things will stand

0:16:43by the time this episode drops

0:16:44or where we'll be, the light,

0:16:46the epochs from now that the end of the year is,

0:16:51but as of yesterday's-- - The Twitter time.

0:16:55- Cliffhanger episode of the Elon Musk show,

0:16:58he had commissioned, or not commissioned,

0:17:01but put up a Twitter poll for 12 hours,

0:17:03should he stay or step down as CEO,

0:17:06and the 57% to 43% said he should step down.

0:17:11And he said, "I would abide by the poll, who knows?"

0:17:14But we shall see. - It's hard to see.

0:17:16Like it's hard because unless he sells a controlling stake

0:17:19and deletes the app from his phone, frankly,

0:17:21he will still own it,

0:17:22and whoever runs it will be beholden to him.

0:17:25Or the other prediction is that he wants out

0:17:28Tesla's underperforming,

0:17:29he's not responsible to shareholders at Twitter,

0:17:32but he certainly is at Tesla,

0:17:33and that this could be a sort of a graceful,

0:17:35meme-y way of getting out of it.

0:17:37- I guess, you know, if he's like done having fun

0:17:41and he's like, you know-- - It's not worth it.

0:17:44- You know, at least, at this point,

0:17:46it is a stretch coming up with positive things.

0:17:49To say the least, it is a stretch to come up

0:17:51with positive things to say about Elon Musk

0:17:55and his stewardship as owner of Twitter.

0:17:57But one of them, at least, is that he does change his mind.

0:18:02I mean, his frequent changes of mind

0:18:06are a part of the problem,

0:18:08but at least it's not like he came in

0:18:12with a list of four things

0:18:14and hasn't added to the list

0:18:17or crossed some items off the list and said nevermind, right?

0:18:20So who knows?

0:18:22But I don't really see how, so long as he owns it,

0:18:25I don't really see how this poll,

0:18:27like, it's exactly what you said.

0:18:29He can hire somebody, he can give them the title CEO,

0:18:33but as a privately held company,

0:18:34they would clearly answer to him.

0:18:36So he is the de facto head of Twitter so long as he owns it.

0:18:41And good luck selling it at this point at anything.

0:18:45I mean, he could sell it,

0:18:46but he couldn't sell it at anything near what he paid for.

0:18:49- Yeah, yeah, 100%.

0:18:51It is interesting because you see

0:18:53all these different takes on it.

0:18:54My usual take is when everyone talks,

0:18:55when anyone talks about free speech on the internet

0:18:57is that it is never as simple as just saying it.

0:19:01Like just saying it out loud.

0:19:02There was this wonderful thread,

0:19:03I'm sure you saw it from one of the founders of Reddit,

0:19:06who just basically said,

0:19:07we just want to make good features,

0:19:08but you humans are horrible to each other.

0:19:10We have to stop all the time

0:19:11just to fix all the human crap that's going on

0:19:13and we can never get the features we want done.

0:19:15And I thought it was like,

0:19:16it was just showing how these things

0:19:18inevitably fall into chaos.

0:19:19And that was really instructive to me

0:19:22because I think one of the things

0:19:23that Elon is really good at is the attention economy,

0:19:25but at a certain point you have to ask yourself,

0:19:28is all attention equally valuable?

0:19:30And this is something YouTube went through as well.

0:19:32Like at a certain point,

0:19:33it was all about click-through rates.

0:19:34So people had these really click-baity thumbnails

0:19:37and then it was all about watch times

0:19:38and people would do increasingly sensational things

0:19:40just to hold your attention

0:19:41and some of those things were incredibly negative

0:19:43because people will rubberneck,

0:19:45will stop, will look at accidents,

0:19:47but it wasn't a good feeling.

0:19:48Like it just wasn't a healthy feeling.

0:19:50So it shifted to figuring out

0:19:52there were different kinds of watch time.

0:19:54There was some watch time you felt good about,

0:19:55that was satisfying,

0:19:56and some that you felt really bad about

0:19:58and they changed the entire way the system works

0:20:00to prioritize satisfaction rather than just engagement.

0:20:03And to me, I think that was a sea change

0:20:05in just how algorithms approach people being more human.

0:20:08And I think the risk that we have right now in Twitter

0:20:10is that the attention right now is attention at any cost

0:20:13and a lot of it is profoundly negative.

0:20:15And that just has, at least for me,

0:20:17like I don't feel like using Twitter the way I used to.

0:20:20And I used to use Twitter a lot and I just,

0:20:22I look there and it feels like I'm in the middle

0:20:23of an accident and I just back away every day.

0:20:25- Yeah, I'm curious.

0:20:27It doesn't seem like you've set up shop on Mastodon yet?

0:20:31- I did, I set up an account.

0:20:32When Melton did, I just copied whatever he did.

0:20:34So I have an account.

0:20:35I think I follow one person

0:20:37and I don't think I've ever used it yet.

0:20:38But I got to the point where like people will take

0:20:41my username if I don't go pretty fast.

0:20:43So I've set up as many things as I can

0:20:45just to keep the username in case I ever need it.

0:20:48- Yeah, that's part of the problem though with Mastodon.

0:20:51And I'm warming up to it and I've actually broken the seal

0:20:54and started using mine.

0:20:56I don't know how much.

0:20:57I would like to have at least one Twitter-like thing

0:21:02in my life, whether it's Twitter or Mastodon.

0:21:05But I don't know that I,

0:21:07having two is an interesting, for me personally,

0:21:10is an interesting psychological test

0:21:15because it's sort of,

0:21:16I was thinking about it while I was out running errands

0:21:20the other day.

0:21:21I went to my two places for wandering thoughts,

0:21:23the shower and a walk.

0:21:24But I was walking and I was thinking about it.

0:21:26There's an old axiom that I really believe in about design.

0:21:31And it's the design of anything.

0:21:33A product, software, hardware,

0:21:36how many brands of mustard to stock in your supermarket,

0:21:40how many brands of ketchup, how many, you know.

0:21:43That when you give people a choice,

0:21:47there's always an implicit extra choice,

0:21:52which is not to choose at all.

0:21:54And it's counterintuitive because it's,

0:21:58we're wired to think having a choice is always better.

0:22:03Certainly having a choice is better

0:22:05than having no choice at all.

0:22:06And in many cases that is true,

0:22:08but it's one of those, there's two sides to every coin.

0:22:12And there are cases where having too many choices

0:22:14is too much.

0:22:15And there is a weird difference for me

0:22:19that all of a sudden my combined stuff

0:22:23I would like to see on a Twitter-like experience is now,

0:22:29and it's permanently split between Twitter and Mastodon

0:22:32to some degree because some number of people

0:22:35who I definitely enjoy following

0:22:37and have been followed on Twitter for over a decade

0:22:40have moved permanently to Mastodon.

0:22:43But I also see the- - All our original friends

0:22:44have left, like I miss them dearly.

0:22:46I don't see their tweets anymore,

0:22:46and I really do miss them.

0:22:48- And it does make looking at my Mastodon timeline

0:22:52enjoyable in a retro way where it's like,

0:22:54"Hey, this sort of feels like Twitter circa 2009," right?

0:22:58Like early years of, like to me, the Twitter,

0:23:03as I'm using Mastodon, Twitter,

0:23:06or as I'm using Mastodon today,

0:23:09I can recall the feelings of using the very early

0:23:14Twitter-ific on the very- - Yeah, pre-,

0:23:17Ashton Kutcher Twitter is what it is today.

0:23:19- Right, the very early iPhones

0:23:22with the lickable interfaces,

0:23:24and everything's a little 3D and-

0:23:26- Or it went mainstream.

0:23:28- And it just feels like that.

0:23:30And it's because it's the same people,

0:23:32it is sort of an early adopter enthusiast crowd.

0:23:35I mean, there's a million, there's like 10 million people,

0:23:37I believe, now on Mastodon.

0:23:38I don't know how many are active.

0:23:39So it's not a tiny, tiny sliver.

0:23:41It's not a tiny, niche, like just people

0:23:45who listen to my show, right?

0:23:47It's not like, oh, it's just people who are super nerdy

0:23:50and know how to program or something like that.

0:23:52It's definitely broader than that.

0:23:54But it is definitely also nowhere near mass market

0:23:59in terms of its appeal. - It's like old Mac field vibe.

0:24:02- Right, and I do like that.

0:24:04But it's weird though, because now when I want to satisfy

0:24:09my read something vaguely like Twitter,

0:24:11I've got to choose which icon to tap on my phone.

0:24:16And that is, so I see, and I know a lot of the people

0:24:21who have said, look, I am done with Twitter.

0:24:24Either they like, maybe they even shuttered their account,

0:24:26but they're at least, they're not cross-posting,

0:24:29they're not splitting their time between the two.

0:24:31They're like, I'm done with this guy, he's in that job.

0:24:33Twitter's been shitty for a while anyway.

0:24:36I'm all in on Mastodon.

0:24:38I get why people do that.

0:24:40It's the split that is, to me, very difficult.

0:24:43And in a way, that's sort of,

0:24:45also lessons I've been thinking about is it's like

0:24:47new things that popped up post-Twitter,

0:24:51and Instagram would be the most obvious,

0:24:53even though Instagram's been around so long now too,

0:24:56it's hard to remember that Instagram was a,

0:25:00not a Twitter clone, but had obviously

0:25:02learned lessons from Twitter.

0:25:04- Yeah. - And famously,

0:25:06when Instagram launched, Twitter still had API access

0:25:10to your follower graph.

0:25:12I don't know why they call it a graph,

0:25:13but for whatever, that's the lingo.

0:25:15But Instagram, in the very early days,

0:25:19like those days when it was iPhone only,

0:25:22largely bootstrapped off people's Twitter follower

0:25:27and connection graph, right?

0:25:29You could go into Instagram and connect it to your Twitter,

0:25:31and it would find the people, oh,

0:25:34all these people who follow you or you follow

0:25:36or follow you on Twitter, we can connect you up on Instagram

0:25:39and all of a sudden you're up and running

0:25:41and it's largely the same people.

0:25:44But it made sense conceptually that I wanted to use both

0:25:47because what you posted to the two things

0:25:49and what other people posted were so different,

0:25:52especially in the early days of Instagram

0:25:54when it was super, super clear

0:25:56that not only did you only post photos,

0:25:58you only posted square photos.

0:26:00- Yeah, and photos from mobile, you got made fun of

0:26:02if you posted a DSLR photo or something.

0:26:04- Right, right, it was sort of an unofficial part of the,

0:26:07not rules, but the sportsman-like conduct

0:26:11was that you were supposed to be taking photos

0:26:13with your phone and the phones were so crummy

0:26:17circa 2010, 2011, and that's why they had those filters

0:26:21that people have, I'm sure, largely forgotten,

0:26:23but these overzealous photo filters

0:26:28to make your phone images look like they were shot

0:26:31on 30-year-old film stock with the,

0:26:36replete with grungy details like corners of the image

0:26:40that looked like the over-scanned film

0:26:45on a flatbed scanner and that sort of thing.

0:26:46- Sort of justify the badness.

0:26:48- Right, but it was brilliant though

0:26:50because it actually did make the photos, it was gimmicky,

0:26:53and I think that they were keenly aware of it

0:26:55and backed away at just the right time and said,

0:26:57"You know what, we don't need to do this anymore."

0:26:59But at the time, it made photos that coming right off

0:27:02the camera roll on your phone,

0:27:05which were kind of flat and looked like,

0:27:07I mean, we don't really talk about cell phone photos anymore

0:27:11but at the time, we were in this transition era

0:27:14between when our phones took better pictures

0:27:16than most point-and-shoot cameras to,

0:27:18from when they know they, it kind of looks like

0:27:22a $5 component that just got added on

0:27:25on the back of your phone.

0:27:25- Free iPhone 4, there were no such thing as selfies.

0:27:27I mean, the world changes rapidly.

0:27:29- Right, right, we had no front-facing camera.

0:27:31Can you imagine selling, I mean,

0:27:33it's just, I don't know what's more amazing

0:27:35that the original iPhone didn't shoot any video at all,

0:27:38let alone bad video, or that it didn't have

0:27:40a front-facing camera until, what was it, the iPhone 4?

0:27:44Is that right? - Yeah, iPhone 4.

0:27:45- That sounds about, so there were three generations

0:27:47of iPhone that had no front-facing camera,

0:27:50which didn't seem weird, honestly.

0:27:52I remember when the front-facing camera came out

0:27:54and thought, ah, I guess I'll use it once, I don't know.

0:27:59- And then faced, yeah, and then he made calls.

0:28:01The interesting thing for me, though,

0:28:02is I've been traveling a lot for my new job,

0:28:04and one of the parts is I meet a lot of creators,

0:28:06and I would typically, they would say,

0:28:07"How do I get in contact with you?"

0:28:08And I would say, "Twitter," and I increasingly noticed

0:28:11that especially women creators, black creators,

0:28:14LGBTQ creators, they were just either never on Twitter

0:28:17or had got harassed off of Twitter years ago,

0:28:21and we're all mostly on Instagram now.

0:28:23It had become a real community for them

0:28:25where they could participate with people

0:28:27that didn't make them feel just horrible every day,

0:28:29and that was really eye-opening for me.

0:28:31So I sort of, now I try to be in all those places

0:28:34because I know there's very different people there.

0:28:37- Yeah, it's funny to sing the praises of a Facebook company,

0:28:42but I do think that they, certainly Instagram

0:28:47is their product that I'm the most familiar with

0:28:49'cause it's the one I'm active on,

0:28:50but I have many complaints about Instagram,

0:28:53and I'm sure that the people who are at meta

0:28:56working on Instagram are so ever,

0:28:58I don't think anybody's more thankful

0:29:00that Elon Musk bought Twitter than them

0:29:03because the social media meme of 2022 up until October

0:29:08was that Instagram had sort of jumped the shark

0:29:11for lack of a better summary.

0:29:12By cramming ever more stuff into what was once

0:29:17a very simple, very easy to understand app,

0:29:20and now it's an entire system of sub-networks

0:29:25and content types, and we could do a whole show

0:29:30just about the way that Instagram has ruined

0:29:33what it once was, which I'm not even passing judgment

0:29:37'cause maybe that's what they need to do to stay relevant.

0:29:39Who knows?

0:29:40Let's just give them the benefit of the doubt,

0:29:41but at least now nobody's talking about it.

0:29:42But one thing I do think is true is that Instagram

0:29:45has, throughout all of this, I can complain at length

0:29:50about their product decisions, but as a social destination,

0:29:55it seemingly never had the problems Twitter has had

0:29:59of being, oh, this is a place where you can get

0:30:03discriminated against, you're gonna,

0:30:06I mean, it happens, right?

0:30:07But it seems like on Instagram that it's,

0:30:10there are mechanisms in place that keep it

0:30:13from turning into Twitter.

0:30:15- Yeah, I wanna-- - For lack of a better term.

0:30:16- At the risk of derailing a lot of this,

0:30:18and I don't wanna do that, but there's this interesting thing

0:30:20where somebody like Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk,

0:30:23when they've removed all accountability,

0:30:24like they don't have a board of directors,

0:30:25well, Mark does, but he effectively owns

0:30:27all the voting chairs, so it doesn't really matter,

0:30:29and Elon owns the entire company,

0:30:31and it reminds me of sort of like,

0:30:32you know, when people talked about the prequels

0:30:33with George Lucas, when you get to a certain stage,

0:30:36you start to think that you know better

0:30:37and you don't need accountability,

0:30:38you don't need people who push back on you,

0:30:40you don't need boards, you don't need editors,

0:30:42and it's always to the detriment of the product

0:30:45in the end, because there's no one person

0:30:46who could ever really keep all of their own worst ideas

0:30:49in check, and it does remind me a little bit

0:30:51of those stories about Steve Jobs,

0:30:52like not wanting to make iTunes,

0:30:54but trusting Eddie and Phil enough to put it on Windows,

0:30:57or not wanting to make a small tablet,

0:30:59but like Eddie's saying, "We've gotta do this,"

0:31:01and Steve's like, "Fine, but if you screw it up,

0:31:02"it's your ass," you know, but he'd at least

0:31:04like had people who would push back,

0:31:06or even like Sal, when he's like,

0:31:07"You can't get rid of these accessibility features,"

0:31:09like he's just yelling at them in front of a group of people,

0:31:11and they didn't get rid of those accessibility features.

0:31:14That, to me, is the quality that I think so many

0:31:16of the latter-day people who were equated to Jobs

0:31:19are just so fundamentally missing out on.

0:31:21- Yeah, I do think so, 'cause I do think that it's,

0:31:24I really do believe it.

0:31:26All of my years covering them, all of my years

0:31:29knowing people who work at Apple,

0:31:31I mean, obviously, there's a level of respect.

0:31:34I mean, you see, you need, as a personal skill,

0:31:36you need to be able to stand your ground respectfully.

0:31:40I mean, I don't think Apple has ever been a shouty place.

0:31:44People don't shout and have arguments,

0:31:46but it has always been a place,

0:31:48or at least post Steve Jobs' next reunification,

0:31:52has been a place where you are definitely encouraged

0:31:55to disagree, even with the boss, right?

0:31:57Your boss, your boss's boss, you go right up to,

0:32:00I'm in a meeting, holy crap, I'm in a meeting

0:32:02with Steve Jobs, or in the modern days,

0:32:05I'm in a meeting with Craig Federighi or Tim,

0:32:08or whoever else it might be,

0:32:10and you really disagree, you can tell them,

0:32:13I really disagree, but you know,

0:32:15be ready to make your case.

0:32:17But they, and that they will listen,

0:32:19and you may not win, but you will be listened to,

0:32:22and you won't be fired just by disagreeing.

0:32:26In fact, it's much more likely

0:32:28that you're not going to succeed, and you,

0:32:31in a place like Twitter today, it's obviously very clear

0:32:36that disagreeing with the boss is a good way

0:32:38to get fired by the next day.

0:32:40And if the problem at Apple is that you never disagree

0:32:44because you're too timid to, or you're worried

0:32:47that that's not going to work,

0:32:48you're not gonna get fired on a whim

0:32:50because you didn't speak up, but you may not last long

0:32:53'cause that's not the culture.

0:32:54You're expected to speak up, you know?

0:32:57And I definitely think, you know, there's,

0:33:01I think that's part of the Jobs, Steve Jobs legend

0:33:05that is truly just pure legend and isn't really true, right?

0:33:09Like, there's story, I don't think it's ever happened,

0:33:11as far as I know.

0:33:12I don't think it's ever, there's always that one,

0:33:13the one story was that in the very early days of Jobs

0:33:16back as CEO that he was in an elevator

0:33:18with some random employee, and he asked them,

0:33:22"What do you do?"

0:33:24And they didn't really have a good answer,

0:33:25and then he, but the elevator doors opened,

0:33:28and he's like, "Well, give me your name

0:33:29"'cause you're fired," you know?

0:33:30And I don't think that, I really don't think

0:33:32that that sort of thing ever happened.

0:33:34It just doesn't, 'cause I don't think the people I know

0:33:37who stayed at Apple and worked under Steve Jobs,

0:33:39they never would, nobody would've put up with it.

0:33:41- Yeah, absolutely.

0:33:43Yeah, you can't keep the best people that way.

0:33:45- So anyway, Twitter, I don't wanna say much more,

0:33:48but I guess I'm, I've got, you know,

0:33:51I'm starting to crack the knuckles on Mastodon.

0:33:54I don't know, it's, and again, I'm all in favor of it,

0:33:57and I think I have to say, I think it's holding up

0:34:00to the growth better than I thought it would.

0:34:02We'll see how it works long-term.

0:34:05I do think the people who created it

0:34:07and cultivated, both created it technically

0:34:10and have been there, you know, and I'm,

0:34:15I'm sensitive to the fact that there are people

0:34:19who've been all in on Mastodon as their Twitter-like

0:34:22social thing for years, right, at this point,

0:34:25for four years or more, and now all of a sudden,

0:34:29there's all, at least from their perspective, right,

0:34:32not from the perspective of Twitter's overall user base

0:34:35or certainly not Instagram's or go even bigger,

0:34:38but from what Mastodon was three months ago

0:34:42to where it is today, overwhelming majority of the users

0:34:47are brand new, and that's always disruptive,

0:34:50and I'm sure that there are things that the long-time,

0:34:53years-long Mastodon users are already like,

0:34:57"Ah, man, we had a really nice thing going," you know.

0:35:00- Who let the kids in?

0:35:02- Right, and it's, you know, it all goes back to the,

0:35:06whatever they called it in September of every year

0:35:09in the 90, you know, pre-web 90s on the internet

0:35:13where the freshmen would come in and get their

0:35:16Telnet accounts at their university,

0:35:18and then all of a sudden, Usenet,

0:35:20all of your favorite Usenet groups were full of people

0:35:23who didn't know what they were doing.

0:35:25- Or when AOL opened up to Usenet, that was the day.

0:35:28- Right, that was the big one.

0:35:29That was the end, that was the end of the,

0:35:32I think that's when it became, I forget the lingo,

0:35:34but it doesn't, but it effectively became

0:35:36permanent September was the term,

0:35:39'cause it's never gonna stop at this point.

0:35:41But it is, you know, it is what it is.

0:35:45I guess the last thing I'll say before we wrap up the point

0:35:48is that the other point that's been percolating in my head

0:35:51is I think we all can see that there's never going to be

0:35:57another Twitter in terms of being the one global,

0:36:02unified, centralized, Twitter-like place

0:36:06where you just post, it's a brilliant idea.

0:36:09It is so simple that it's easy to overlook

0:36:11how brilliant the fundamental concept of Twitter is,

0:36:14because it's easy to understand.

0:36:16You get an account, there's one namespace for accounts,

0:36:20and what can you do?

0:36:22You can post a limited amount of text in a box,

0:36:25and it goes out to the people who choose to follow you,

0:36:29and you can choose the people whose tweets

0:36:33you yourself will see.

0:36:35That's a brilliant, it sounds obvious,

0:36:38it's hard to believe that somebody had to invent it,

0:36:40and it's like many of the very best inventions,

0:36:43it's really hard to see how it wasn't invented

0:36:47earlier than 2006, but it wasn't, and it is brilliant,

0:36:52but I ultimately think what Musk's stewardship of Twitter

0:36:57is accelerating is the conclusion

0:37:00that this is not a good idea for mankind, honestly,

0:37:05and I don't mean this in any hyper-herpabolic sense

0:37:08of drama, I just don't think humans are meant to,

0:37:13from all political spectrums,

0:37:15from all socioeconomic spectrums,

0:37:18from all geographic spectrums around the world,

0:37:22are all meant to be in one global namespace community.

0:37:26I don't think that's suited to human psychology,

0:37:30I really don't, and I think that where it sort of seems

0:37:34to have wound up, where Twitter's ultimate,

0:37:38the one thing that has been stable for, I would say,

0:37:43maybe the last seven years, I would peg it as around 2015,

0:37:48where Twitter's sustainable thing

0:37:53was becoming an outrage machine,

0:37:56and regardless of what you get outraged about,

0:38:01whether it's national politics,

0:38:03whether it's identity politics, whether it's economics,

0:38:07whether it's technical issues,

0:38:09it found equilibrium at a state where you keep getting,

0:38:17you keep encountering viewpoints that make you outraged,

0:38:21and it is taking advantage of a human instinct of,

0:38:26and you can see why we evolved this way,

0:38:30where when you encounter something that makes you outraged,

0:38:33you react emotionally, and emotions are engaging,

0:38:36and it's just unpleasant emotions, unfortunately.

0:38:41- There was like this super weird thing

0:38:42that back in the days of Mobile Nations,

0:38:44we had a website for every different platform,

0:38:47so like the Google site, the Microsoft site, the Apple site,

0:38:49and one of the things that I found remarkable

0:38:51is that the people on the Apple site,

0:38:53they mostly just stuck on the Apple site.

0:38:55They were happy, they talked about the products they had,

0:38:57but in waves, you had people who preferred Nokia came in

0:39:00and just wanted to yell at them for using Apple products,

0:39:03and then when Nokia went away, it was like,

0:39:05got out of favor, it was Blackberry people,

0:39:07and I think it was the same people

0:39:08just migrating to wherever there was the not Apple,

0:39:10and then they went to Windows Phone and Android,

0:39:13and they would always come and yell at it,

0:39:15and at times when, 'cause there was a time

0:39:17when the accounts were unified, when they weren't,

0:39:19the people who just liked to talk about the Apple stuff

0:39:21were happy, but the people who only wanted to yell

0:39:23at other people were so upset,

0:39:25because they no longer had a place to go and yell at people,

0:39:28and I wonder if we lose this global system,

0:39:31the people who are just happy, like discussing,

0:39:33I don't know, Star Wars or Star Trek or whatever it is,

0:39:35will have their own little communities,

0:39:37and they'll just be happily discussing it,

0:39:38but the people who just wanted to go to war every day

0:39:41will have nowhere left to go,

0:39:42and ultimately, they will have seen

0:39:43to their own dissatisfaction.

0:39:46- Yeah, so, yeah, that's well said,

0:39:50and it's, we keep, we collectively as people

0:39:55are learning a lot about human psychology

0:40:00in very short order, because we've, in the internet era,

0:40:04we've built systems that simply have no possible analogy

0:40:09to the pre-internet, to pre-internet life.

0:40:12There's just, there's no comparison.

0:40:16There's no way that there's anything,

0:40:18anything like Twitter was possible in the analog world.

0:40:22It doesn't even make any sense.

0:40:23I can't even imagine some kind of steampunk sci-fi

0:40:27equivalent, and it turns out we're not hooked up.

0:40:31There's a good reason for that, right,

0:40:32and there's a good reason that humans segment themselves

0:40:35naturally into communities, and that you can be a member

0:40:39of multiple communities, based on your work,

0:40:42based on your interests, based on your religion,

0:40:45your family, there's all sorts of ways--

0:40:46- Your sports team, the kind of food you're into.

0:40:48- Right, right, right, or just being by yourself,

0:40:53a community of one, but a community of everyone doesn't work,

0:40:59and that's the ultimate lesson, and so I also feel that,

0:41:04so I think that's one reason Twitter's never gonna

0:41:06be replicated, and that Mastodon is never going to grow,

0:41:09and I think that the creators of Mastodon

0:41:11would be the first ones to say, yeah, that's good,

0:41:12we don't want to be as big as Twitter,

0:41:15and we don't want that, so the naysayers on Mastodon,

0:41:20and I have my doubts still about some aspects of it,

0:41:23and there's things I don't wanna, I won't belabor,

0:41:26but it's clearly right now the best we have

0:41:29as an alternative, but I definitely think, though,

0:41:31that going into it without any sort of thing

0:41:34where it's going to be a mega platform,

0:41:36and there's no VC, it doesn't make sense,

0:41:40because it isn't centralized, right,

0:41:41and so all of these problems are avoided,

0:41:43and a lot of the criticism is like, yeah,

0:41:45but they're never gonna get to a billion users,

0:41:46and it's like, yeah, that's the point, they shouldn't.

0:41:49- Well, I don't know about you, but like,

0:41:50'cause I work remotely, I've worked remotely

0:41:52for the last 12 years, and in that time,

0:41:55I was always in, previously, the Mobile Nation Slack,

0:41:57and the Creator Slack that I'm in,

0:41:59and then Creator Discord groups, I have Work Gchat now,

0:42:02and those are all small communities,

0:42:04but those have become my water cooler now,

0:42:07just because I haven't been using Twitter as much,

0:42:09and it is a very different vibe,

0:42:11but it's one that's seized to a similar need

0:42:13of having a communal experience with people.

0:42:16- Yeah.

0:42:17All right, let me take a break here,

0:42:18and thank our next sponsor.

0:42:19It is our good friends at Trade Coffee.

0:42:23Look, we are in the home stretch for the holidays.

0:42:26When you're listening to this,

0:42:27if you're listening to it while it's fresh,

0:42:29we got days to go before the holidays,

0:42:31but if you're looking for a last-minute gift

0:42:33for some of the hardest-to-shop people to look for,

0:42:36look no further than a personalized coffee subscription

0:42:40from Trade Coffee.

0:42:41This is a fabulous last-minute gift

0:42:44for somebody in your life,

0:42:45because you don't have to go get it.

0:42:48You don't have to wait for it to arrive.

0:42:49You can sign them up,

0:42:50and tell them they've got this subscription,

0:42:53and then they'll just start getting the coffee at home

0:42:56on their schedule.

0:42:57That's what Trade is.

0:42:58It's a coffee subscription service,

0:43:00and they make it so simple to discover new coffees

0:43:03and make your best cup of coffee at home every day.

0:43:06They partner with the nation's top-rated,

0:43:09independent roasters.

0:43:10I mean, I'm about to say dozens.

0:43:13Might be hundreds, I don't know,

0:43:14but I keep getting Trade Coffee,

0:43:16'cause I've been subscribed for months

0:43:17ever since they started sponsoring the show.

0:43:19I don't know that I've gotten coffee

0:43:20from the same roaster twice yet.

0:43:23It is a phenomenal array of small, independent roasters

0:43:27around the country who they partner with

0:43:29to send you coffee that they know that you're going to love.

0:43:33You get the coffee, and then when you like it,

0:43:35you just go back on the website,

0:43:36or they'll send you an email if you want

0:43:38to remind you to give it like a thumbs up, thumbs down,

0:43:41and you give more thumbs up,

0:43:43and then they start finding more coffee

0:43:45along the lines of what you've liked.

0:43:47It works great, 'cause they've had nothing

0:43:51but great coffee ever since I started,

0:43:53but I'm digging the coffee I'm getting now

0:43:55more than I was when I first signed up.

0:43:57It really does work, and it is so convenient

0:44:00to never run out of coffee at home,

0:44:02and always have fresh beans arrive,

0:44:05and they really are fresh.

0:44:06You look at the dates, the roasting dates on these things,

0:44:09and they're often within three or four days of being roasted.

0:44:12There, the beans are in your hands.

0:44:15It is absolutely terrific.

0:44:16It is, again, a fantastic gift for loved ones,

0:44:20including a last-minute gift,

0:44:22or that week after Christmas,

0:44:24maybe that's when you're listening,

0:44:25but there's still people that you haven't seen

0:44:28since the holidays, and you're gonna see 'em at a party

0:44:30or something like that in between Christmas and New Year's.

0:44:33Trade Coffee is a great idea,

0:44:35and right now they're offering listeners of the talk show

0:44:37a total of $30 off a subscription

0:44:40and access to limited-time holiday specials.

0:44:43Just go to www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show.

0:44:48That's www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show, all one word,

0:44:53and that's for 30 bucks off, just for listeners of the show.

0:44:58I'm literally drinking the last few sips

0:45:02of my pot of Trade Coffee today,

0:45:04right now, as I finish this read.

0:45:05It is great stuff, and it's a great gift.

0:45:07My thanks to them.

0:45:08All right, onward and upward.

0:45:10- Quick show. - Famous last words.

0:45:13I do think that the year in review is actually going to be,

0:45:15I think we can cover quickly,

0:45:19because I actually think, well, you know, spoilers,

0:45:22but I actually think that maybe Apple's 2022 year in review

0:45:26is that it's the year that the COVID and the lockdown

0:45:29finally caught up to them.

0:45:31I'm not saying it was a bad year or off year,

0:45:33but I was looking at it for the notes,

0:45:35and I'm like, this is, you know,

0:45:37and of course I always come into these

0:45:39fabulously prepared, right, Rene?

0:45:41- Same, yeah. (laughs)

0:45:42- Yeah.

0:45:43But I have to say, it's like, hey,

0:45:46there's actually not that much to talk about, so let's see.

0:45:48But one more bit of news before we keep going,

0:45:51a couple bits of news.

0:45:52I want to talk a little bit about Freeform,

0:45:55which is a new app Apple has just launched

0:45:58with the latest updates to the Mac and iOS platforms

0:46:01last week.

0:46:01They did show it at WWDC when it shipped last week.

0:46:06I saw an awful lot of people saying the same thing,

0:46:08which was, hey, I sort of forgot about this,

0:46:10because I kind of feel that the demo,

0:46:13not that it was a bad demo at WWDC,

0:46:17but it was intermixed with,

0:46:20it was Craig Federighi and a bunch of people

0:46:22on his software team, including friend of the show, Lop.

0:46:26- Yes.

0:46:27- Michael Lop was there,

0:46:28referred to only by his last name, Lop.

0:46:30But it was, you know, a bunch of coworkers,

0:46:33the gimmick of the demo is a bunch of coworkers

0:46:37planning a team retreat, I believe.

0:46:40You know, like go to some place where you can swing on ropes

0:46:42and--

0:46:43- You can wear your tracksuits and just hang out.

0:46:46- Right, wear your tracksuit and hang out.

0:46:48But it was all, the demo was sort of mixed together

0:46:51with FaceTime and iMessage

0:46:56and sort of Freeform in the middle.

0:46:59And even as somebody who's, you know,

0:47:01obviously watches these keynotes professionally

0:47:04and is to study the details as intricately as I can,

0:47:09I'm not sure if five minutes after the keynote,

0:47:12if I was sure that Freeform was going to be an app

0:47:15or if it was going to be a new feature

0:47:17built into iMessage and FaceTime.

0:47:20- Yeah, I think they were trying to show that it was like,

0:47:22'cause they went to great pains to integrate iMessage

0:47:24and FaceTime so you could move seamlessly

0:47:26between group chats and group FaceTime.

0:47:28And this seemed like the note board

0:47:30that they were giving you to keep track of things

0:47:31while you were talking or texting.

0:47:33And it could either be integrated or its own thing.

0:47:36- Right, but it's out now, I like it.

0:47:39It is interesting, I think there's, you know,

0:47:43the other hand, Apple doesn't come out

0:47:44with new apps very often, right?

0:47:47I would say the last time they came out

0:47:49with a new app along these lines was Clips,

0:47:51which still exists, it is still a thing.

0:47:54- And Voice Memo, not Voice Memo,

0:47:56the songwriting version.

0:47:57I forget what it's called now,

0:47:59but it like disappeared rapidly.

0:48:01- Yeah, well, Clips is still around and Clips,

0:48:04I still say, I know it doesn't seem to get a lot of use,

0:48:07it doesn't seem to have a lot of uptake,

0:48:09but I would still encourage everybody,

0:48:11anybody who's interested in user interface design

0:48:14to open it up every once in a while and look at it.

0:48:16'Cause I do think it's a fascinating app design-wise.

0:48:21- I kind of see-- - It's terrific,

0:48:23they just shipped a square app

0:48:24in the age of vertical social.

0:48:26- Yep, yep, that's part of it.

0:48:29And I think the other part of it is that

0:48:33the built-in tools for the networks where you share stuff,

0:48:41it's hard to beat them, right?

0:48:44So like creating your TikTok in TikTok at .app

0:48:49or creating whatever you're making for Instagram

0:48:53within instagram.app,

0:48:55it's hard to get past that.

0:48:59And I know people use other third-party software

0:49:01to create content for those networks,

0:49:04but Clips is, it never, it hasn't,

0:49:08I don't wanna spend too much time on Clips,

0:49:10but it's like a social network creation tool

0:49:13in need of its own social network.

0:49:16- Enough more than what the camera tools provide.

0:49:19'Cause otherwise you'd need Final Cut or Premiere

0:49:21or something, you're not gonna use Clips.

0:49:23- Right, but Freeform is, if you haven't checked it out,

0:49:26it is fundamentally, it's very interesting to me.

0:49:30'Cause I've always been a fan of canvas-based apps.

0:49:33This goes back to my background in graphic design

0:49:36and really, really going deep and being,

0:49:39for a large number of years earlier in my life,

0:49:43QuarkXPress was my jam.

0:49:45'Cause I just loved the metaphor.

0:49:47And back when QuarkXPress versus PageMaker

0:49:51was still a debate, I was firmly in the QuarkXPress camp

0:49:55because it stuck more to the basic canvas model

0:49:59where, okay, you create a page size.

0:50:01And this is where Freeform breaks apart.

0:50:04Whereas in the desktop era, page size mattered.

0:50:07There had, you know, eight and a half by 11 or 11 by 17,

0:50:12but there had to be some sort of,

0:50:14well, this is how big it would be when you print it.

0:50:16And you'd make this and then you would drop boxes

0:50:20onto the canvas and the boxes could contain different types.

0:50:24You could create a box that would create an image

0:50:27and then you would fill the image with an image

0:50:29somewhere in your file system.

0:50:31Or the box could be text, of course.

0:50:33And you would fill the image, you could either type the text

0:50:36or you could import from a document.

0:50:39For some number of years, there was, you know,

0:50:41while we chased the dream, there was the publish

0:50:44and subscribe stuff where you could connect the text box

0:50:48to a document and if the document changed

0:50:51after you first imported, the changes would reflow live

0:50:55into the thing that it felt very futuristic at the time.

0:50:58Never really worked well enough to get most people I knew

0:51:03who were in even a professional setting to go away

0:51:07from the numbered revisions to the file.

0:51:11Final, you know, Renee's column final,

0:51:14Renee's column final final, Renee's column final final final.

0:51:19Which one do you have?

0:51:22Do you have final or final final?

0:51:24I've got, I've just got final.

0:51:26Oh no, you need final final.

0:51:27- I have final JG edits.

0:51:28- Yeah, I need final JG edits final.

0:51:32But it's a great metaphor for design.

0:51:35And then you can move the boxes around

0:51:36and you can connect them and you can drag other things out

0:51:39and create lines and rules.

0:51:40And that's, you know, basically freeform.

0:51:42Except the canvas is unlimited,

0:51:47so there's no page size.

0:51:49And the other big metaphor change

0:51:51is it's not document-based.

0:51:53You don't create a new document

0:51:55and then have a document somewhere where you need to save it

0:51:58whether it's local on your machine or in your iCloud

0:52:01or on your Dropbox.

0:52:03It's more of a library app where, you know,

0:52:06the same way like Apple Notes,

0:52:09I guess is probably the app that is the most familiar

0:52:12to the most people where your notes aren't corresponding

0:52:17to individual files anywhere in the file system.

0:52:20They're just in a library that is managed by the software

0:52:25and the connection between what's yours and what's shared

0:52:30is part of the design of the system.

0:52:34Which is to say it is built for the modern era, right?

0:52:36Documents as objects in the file system are,

0:52:40they're never gonna go away.

0:52:42You know, I still use them, I'm sure you use them,

0:52:44I'm sure just about everybody who listens to this show

0:52:46still uses them and depends on them for some things.

0:52:49But going forward, it's a much more modern,

0:52:52forward-thinking way to not worry about that.

0:52:56That's just an implementation detail

0:52:57and it's just a board or a,

0:53:01I don't know what we call the ones in freeform.

0:53:03I don't know what they're called, but it works.

0:53:06You can share and right out of the gate,

0:53:07it lets you share a space with other people

0:53:11using just their iCloud ID, very much the way

0:53:14that you can collaboratively edit Apple Notes

0:53:17with somebody else and it's very Apple, you know,

0:53:21the more of those features something like this debuts with,

0:53:24the better they are in my opinion

0:53:27because when you take an old thing

0:53:30and then try to add new systems like collaborative editing,

0:53:33which is complicated, right?

0:53:35I mean, you don't even have to be a programmer

0:53:36to think about the ways that letting two people edit

0:53:39the same document of any type at the same time is, huh,

0:53:44that you could see how that would get tricky pretty quick

0:53:47as a programming task.

0:53:49I think it's pretty neat and I can't think of anything else

0:53:51quite like it and I'm really,

0:53:53I'm glad to see Apple still coming up with ideas like that.

0:53:57Do I wanna bet on whether it's going to become a hit

0:54:00or is it really gonna languish a bit like clips?

0:54:05It's hard to say, right?

0:54:06I don't know, what do you think?

0:54:08- I think it's like often the strengths are the weaknesses

0:54:11or the blessings are the curses

0:54:12and I think one of these examples

0:54:14is that it is so tightly integrated into messages

0:54:16and FaceTime that it makes it almost a no brainer

0:54:19for people who are incredibly immersed in the ecosystem

0:54:21to just use it, like it's similar to Apple Notes.

0:54:23We're doing the show notes in free form today

0:54:25but we've done them in Apple Notes previously

0:54:28and it's incredibly easy to share them and use them

0:54:30but because it's bound,

0:54:31because it is so deeply meshed in the ecosystem,

0:54:34it means there's no real use beyond this.

0:54:36Like there's no green bubble of friends for your free forms

0:54:40and that's gonna mean that in some capacity,

0:54:41professionally or personally,

0:54:42you're gonna run into a wall where it's gonna make sense

0:54:45to share something that is maybe web-based instead

0:54:49or maybe open source or multi-platform instead

0:54:52and so it's a question of iMessage is so good

0:54:56for people who, for families or friend groups

0:54:58that have messaging that everyone just uses it

0:55:00to the extent that it's one of the most popular

0:55:02messaging solutions in North America.

0:55:04FaceTime, it's almost like the default

0:55:06when people talk about it on TV, FaceTime.

0:55:08This could end up being that

0:55:10but I think when it comes down to documents

0:55:11and being able to share them,

0:55:12a lot of people are deeply invested in stuff

0:55:15that's web-based at this point.

0:55:17- Yeah and there is a webby type feel to free form.

0:55:21By the way, did you add anything

0:55:23to our shared free form board for this?

0:55:25- No, I was terrified because you had several links in there

0:55:28before the year in review

0:55:29and I figured if I put anything more in there,

0:55:31we would just never get to year in review.

0:55:33- Do me a favor and just add something

0:55:35'cause it occurred to me as I fired it up

0:55:38and I'm looking at it for the show, I'm like,

0:55:41'cause if Renee has been adding to this,

0:55:43I'm not getting them and I guess we should talk

0:55:47about the fact that this isn't working.

0:55:49- No, it's 100% working.

0:55:50- Why did they make it?

0:55:56I think that the only reason they made it

0:55:58is that somebody within Apple sort of had the idea for this

0:56:02and the more they talked about it

0:56:04with other people at Apple,

0:56:05the people are like, yeah, this is a good idea,

0:56:07we could do this.

0:56:08I believe, I don't know and of course,

0:56:10Apple famously doesn't really give a lot of individual credit

0:56:13to the people who conceive of and engineer ideas

0:56:16but my understanding is that it's people,

0:56:19I don't know if they're formerly of the iWork team

0:56:22or they're still on the iWork team

0:56:24but it's people who nearing and design-wise

0:56:27have worked on pages and numbers and keynote

0:56:30and their collaborative features

0:56:33and building this from scratch

0:56:35and it must, I think it works better conceptually

0:56:39'cause again, pages, numbers and keynote

0:56:42are fundamentally anchored in the old metaphor

0:56:45of the truth is a document that you save somewhere

0:56:50in a file system somewhere

0:56:53and yes, you can add people to it

0:56:55but trying to make an online live collaboration thing

0:57:00that is fundamentally rooted in a file

0:57:02that is somewhere on a system is, it's a mismatch

0:57:07and I think that's why Google Docs have always worked better

0:57:10for collaborative editing than things

0:57:14that are more rooted in the file system

0:57:17because the Google Docs natural isn't really a file,

0:57:23it's a URL that creates the illusion of being a file

0:57:27but if you really want it to be a file,

0:57:28you've got to take a snapshot and export.

0:57:31- Yep, 100% and that's why I think that famous graph

0:57:34that Steve Jobs stood in front of when he was announcing

0:57:36iCloud showed the devices and something going up

0:57:39and then copies of them coming back down

0:57:41rather than something being propagated from the cloud.

0:57:44- Yeah, let's see where Freeform goes

0:57:49but I kind of have a feeling

0:57:50that Apple is committed to this,

0:57:52I think they think it's a good idea,

0:57:53I think they're going to keep iterating on it

0:57:56and it's going to be there

0:57:57and it's also like many, many, many things

0:58:00in the world of software,

0:58:01it's hard to figure out the true appeal of it

0:58:05until you need it and then all of a sudden

0:58:06when you do need, it's like something

0:58:08for everybody out there, it's like yeah,

0:58:10I'll bet a lot of people have done what I did

0:58:11which is sort of fire it up and kick the tires a little

0:58:15and import this and import that

0:58:17but you don't really have a thing

0:58:18you really want to do with it yet

0:58:21and it's like when you actually do have that thing

0:58:23you really want to do,

0:58:25then all of a sudden you'll be like,

0:58:26hey, this is actually awesome,

0:58:28my wife and I were redecorating our living room

0:58:32and put a bunch of pictures of,

0:58:36sort of thing that maybe people have done on Pinterest

0:58:38or something like that but like,

0:58:39hey, let's just share a bunch of photos

0:58:41of other rooms we like and we could doodle on them

0:58:44with an Apple pencil on an iPad and say,

0:58:47ignore this, I'm not talking about art on the walls like this

0:58:51I'm just talking about the color of the paint.

0:58:53- So I do have a conspiracy theory though along those lines

0:58:56and that is like I think a lot of the stuff Apple's done

0:58:58over the last seven plus years has been prep work

0:59:01for when they get into VR and AR more seriously

0:59:04especially all the sharing emoji and FaceTime

0:59:07and iMessage groups and this to me makes sense

0:59:11when you're starting to talk about that world in the future

0:59:13where you might just be walking,

0:59:15like you and Amy walking through a room saying,

0:59:18what do you wanna do with this

0:59:18and you both put on your glasses

0:59:20and you start moving things around

0:59:21and freeform is an actual 3D environment that you share

0:59:25like the counter antidote for Facebook horizons

0:59:30where it's something personal and malleable.

0:59:32- Maybe, who knows, I'm not quite sure

0:59:35how this would look in VR but you know,

0:59:39I don't know how anything's gonna look in VR.

0:59:41- Same.

0:59:42- I don't have too much more to say about it

0:59:44but I'm glad that it's there

0:59:45and I guess if I had to bet,

0:59:48I'm gonna bet that it'll be to some degree,

0:59:51I think it's gonna stick.

0:59:52I think people when they encounter something

0:59:54where they need something like this

0:59:56or could use something like this,

0:59:58are going to, it'll be a continual source of discovery

1:00:01where months from now or a year from now,

1:00:03somebody's gonna be like, yeah, I never used it

1:00:05but then I tried freeform and it was perfect

1:00:07for planning a vacation or something like that.

1:00:09- Longer than a head of lettuce,

1:00:10probably longer than music memos,

1:00:12hopefully as long as clips.

1:00:14- There is something weird, this is John Siracusa's gripe

1:00:17on ATP was the fact that if you really just wanna scribble

1:00:21on the board, you'd need an Apple Pencil

1:00:24and there's no way to just scribble on the Mac

1:00:27with your mouse which does seem like a strange omission

1:00:32and it's kind of hard not to see how,

1:00:37I don't know, not to suspect that somewhere

1:00:40they're like the only good way to scribble is with a pencil

1:00:44and therefore you need an iPad to do it.

1:00:48I don't know, it's sort of an Apple--

1:00:50- They just didn't get around to it yet.

1:00:52- Yeah, or maybe they just, never underestimate

1:00:55what simply is we did not get around to it yet

1:00:58and Apple Pencil support on iPad was like a must be

1:01:02in 1.0 feature and scribbling from the iPhone

1:01:06without a pencil or from the Mac without even a touchscreen

1:01:10are coming later and of course--

1:01:12- Cut and paste third year problems.

1:01:14- Right, and it is of course Apple

1:01:17so we don't have any kind of roadmap public

1:01:20of oh, don't forget, we're gonna add this, that

1:01:22and the other thing.

1:01:23I guess the other weird thing that strikes me about it

1:01:25is the fact that the sticky notes have to be square

1:01:28which I guess relates to what people think of

1:01:32as sticky notes in the real world which are square

1:01:34but you can grow them as big or as small as you want

1:01:39and so by being able to grow them,

1:01:41they're already not skeuomorphic, right?

1:01:44You can't go and buy paper sticky notes

1:01:47and stretch them to make them bigger

1:01:49so once you can stretch them, why not let me stretch them

1:01:53to make it longer or wider if that's what suits the content?

1:01:57It seems slightly limiting that they have to be square

1:02:01but that's a minor detail.

1:02:05- Yeah, minimal shippable product.

1:02:07- Yeah, well let's just jump right in without a break

1:02:10to the last thing on my news to cover

1:02:13and this is serendipity that you're on the show

1:02:15'cause I know you've had a keen interest in this.

1:02:18You and I have talked about this on the show.

1:02:21As many times as I've talked about the same thing

1:02:23over and over again, you and I have talked about Apple

1:02:25and backups and security and end-to-end encryption

1:02:29and Apple, here we are, it's December,

1:02:31usually the slow month but Apple actually has had some news

1:02:35in addition to freeform.

1:02:37The bigger news in my opinion is what Apple is calling

1:02:41iCloud Advanced Data Security and in my show notes,

1:02:45I only have one word and it is finally.

1:02:47- Yeah, it deserves one.

1:02:49- But it is an ironic finally where I'm not complaining

1:02:54that it has taken them as long as they have.

1:02:56Do I wish they had gotten to this point sooner?

1:02:59I do, of course, because I think it is important

1:03:01that it matters but I totally understand why they haven't

1:03:06and I could see how if they opened,

1:03:11if they invited you backstage metaphorically

1:03:14and showed you every step of the way of the last 10,

1:03:18maybe even more years of where they've moved iCloud security

1:03:23that in some sense, it might be hard to imagine

1:03:30how they could have moved faster.

1:03:32- Yeah, it's also, it's one of those things where I think

1:03:35everyone on Twitter tends to be a nerd

1:03:36and because we're all on Twitter together,

1:03:38we think everybody thinks the way that nerds think

1:03:40and we think there's just a majority opinion

1:03:42when really, it's a very small minority opinion

1:03:44and we don't often think or empathize

1:03:46with the larger community.

1:03:48We think about, oh, everything has to be encrypted

1:03:51because somebody might steal my XYZ

1:03:53where for the vast majority of people, it's like,

1:03:55oh my God, I forgot my password,

1:03:57I'm never gonna get my baby pictures back

1:03:59and that is the biggest harm or damage

1:04:01that they could ever experience

1:04:03and that's what used to have,

1:04:04with the original version of iCloud,

1:04:06you had to print out those recovery keys

1:04:08and people lost them all the time and went to Apple

1:04:10and Apple had to say, sorry, all that stuff is lost.

1:04:13So the new version was more fail-safe than fail-secure

1:04:16so that Apple could go in and recover those things

1:04:18and yeah, it sucked for people who really did wanna use it

1:04:21as a secure store for things that they would rather

1:04:24lose the ability to access than ever have stolen

1:04:27but that again is not a mainstream concern.

1:04:29Mainstream people don't wanna lose things.

1:04:31There's very few people who are targeted

1:04:32for that kind of stuff.

1:04:34So building that out is non-trivial.

1:04:36I think we saw that with recovery contacts coming out.

1:04:39I think that was a big step towards this

1:04:41and just Apple finally figuring out a way

1:04:43to make it optional because there's so many services

1:04:47like this, Apple gets all the attention

1:04:48but if you're accessing files on the web,

1:04:50that's really complicated with full encryption.

1:04:52Doing some of the things Dropbox or other storage providers

1:04:55do really, really complicated if you're fully encrypted

1:04:58and sometimes you've gotta make your own binary blob

1:05:00on your computer and upload it

1:05:01and then you can't retrieve files if you're like remote

1:05:04and you wanna go back and just pull out a single file

1:05:06from Ren's computer.

1:05:07So big topic, really complicated but I'm really, really glad

1:05:11that we have the option and I'm glad that the option

1:05:13is not enabled by default because you have to go in there

1:05:16and say, I am going to accept responsibility

1:05:19for my own data loss.

1:05:20Give me this, give me the recovery stuff,

1:05:22I will manage this and then hopefully that's like

1:05:25signifying that you're capable of doing

1:05:27all that kind of stuff.

1:05:28- Yeah, I guess I should have recap that the,

1:05:31to me the centerpiece of Apple's new advanced

1:05:34iCloud data security system is that backups

1:05:39and your iCloud photo library are now can be

1:05:43if you opt in end to end encrypted which is

1:05:48and again, Apple has been, without them ever saying

1:05:52we are building towards enabling end to end backup

1:05:56encryption and iCloud photo library,

1:05:59the clues have been there that they've been working

1:06:04towards this and of course, they famously,

1:06:07they make such a big deal out of privacy and security

1:06:09and they've, to their credit, like when there was that

1:06:14shooting in San Bernardino, California a couple years ago

1:06:18and the FBI had a phone from one of the suspects

1:06:23and couldn't access the contents of it and wanted Apple to,

1:06:28again, I followed it closely.

1:06:31I believe that the long story short of that

1:06:32was what they wanted Apple to do was to create

1:06:35a one-off version of iOS that they could,

1:06:38that could, I don't even know if it's possible

1:06:40to flash it onto the phone but to somehow get it

1:06:43onto the phone without destroying the contents of the phone

1:06:47but then once this new version of iOS had been installed,

1:06:50it would allow them to circumvent the,

1:06:53enter the device passcode to unlock the encrypted contents

1:07:00that are stored on the phone and they stood their ground

1:07:04and made the argument in as plain a language as they could

1:07:07without, they certainly weren't seeking confrontation

1:07:11with the United States Department of Justice

1:07:13but they also weren't going to compromise

1:07:15on doing what they believe was right

1:07:17and doing what they believe is right

1:07:18is not deliberately creating a backdoor

1:07:21and just in a little way, like the fact that the contents

1:07:24of our phones are encrypted on device and, you know,

1:07:29they, it just, it is an enormous subdivision

1:07:34of Apple's software engineering division

1:07:36that is devoted to these features and it is,

1:07:41it encapsulates in so many ways the Apple is at its best

1:07:45at the intersection of hardware and software

1:07:48and that only Apple can do this, right,

1:07:49because then you get into the areas where like

1:07:52the entire concept of a hardware secure enclave on device

1:07:57is truly essential, there's no,

1:08:00the way that they do the encryption of your data

1:08:02on the device is all based on that and it's hand in hand.

1:08:07- And I know some people are gonna quibble

1:08:08because like end to end encryption,

1:08:10so all the stuff that goes off the iPhone between us

1:08:12and Apple is end to end encrypted in transit.

1:08:15At rest, it's also end to end encrypted.

1:08:17The only difference was for iCloud backup,

1:08:20for things that, there's two sort of clients,

1:08:21there was regular iCloud backup

1:08:23and there was secure iCloud backup for like health data

1:08:26and things like that, that was always separate

1:08:27but the general iCloud data, it was encrypted end to end,

1:08:30it's just that Apple had a copy of the key.

1:08:32So we had a copy of the key on our device,

1:08:34Apple had a copy of the key, that way if we lost our key,

1:08:38we lost our phone, we forgot like

1:08:39when we originally printed out those things, whatever,

1:08:41we lost our password, forgot it,

1:08:43they, you could go through this elaborate,

1:08:45exhausting recovery process, prove ownership

1:08:48and reclaim a copy of your data and that was only possible

1:08:51and the side effect of that was that then it was subject

1:08:54to subpoena because it existed

1:08:55and Apple could gain access to it.

1:08:57- Right. - And I think that,

1:08:58it was never, like I know some people were like,

1:08:59oh, the FBI told Apple to do this.

1:09:01I think Craig said that on Joanna's video too,

1:09:03like we were never asked to do this,

1:09:05like this was a customer service issue, first and foremost

1:09:08and now they can have both,

1:09:09which I think is better for everybody.

1:09:11- Right, and that's what you and I have speculated for years,

1:09:14you and I have been in complete agreement

1:09:15that the biggest holdup to enabling end to end,

1:09:19true end to end, what I would say,

1:09:21I would quibble with what I think,

1:09:22I think you slightly misspoke,

1:09:24where I think to qualify as end to end,

1:09:28there can't be a key held in the middle.

1:09:31- Yeah, that's fair. - Right?

1:09:33So it's, it is, you're, and people who don't follow

1:09:37this closely have been like, wait,

1:09:38my backups weren't encrypted before?

1:09:40No, well, they were encrypted.

1:09:42- Well, they weren't on a drive

1:09:43where anybody could just walk in and take them,

1:09:44like if somebody walked and took it off the drive,

1:09:46they were still encrypted.

1:09:47- Right, they're encrypted, your device encrypts them

1:09:51as the backup is going to iCloud,

1:09:53so over the wire or through the air,

1:09:56let's face it, is more common, especially for an iPhone.

1:09:59Over the internet, it's encrypted and it goes to Apple

1:10:04and it gets stored on Apple.

1:10:05- Ultimately, a cloud server is just a box

1:10:08somewhere in a data center.

1:10:10It's a computer in a data center

1:10:11with drives connected to it.

1:10:14On those drives, the data is encrypted,

1:10:17and then when it comes back to you,

1:10:20because let's say you're restoring from a backup,

1:10:22it is sent back over the drive, over the air,

1:10:26over the internet, encrypted,

1:10:28till your device receives it and decrypts it

1:10:30so that it can restore the backup.

1:10:32- Yeah, it's encrypted not end to end.

1:10:33I misspoke about that part.

1:10:35- But the difference is that Apple held keys,

1:10:38and then therefore, if they were given a proper subpoena,

1:10:43then they could be forced to hand over the keys and the data,

1:10:48whereas now, if you enable advanced data,

1:10:51I'm gonna get this right, what's it called?

1:10:53Advanced data security.

1:10:55Advanced data protection, well, whatever it's called.

1:10:57You enable it, you opt in.

1:11:00What Apple does is they throw away their key.

1:11:05So one of the things,

1:11:07because they've been building towards this for years,

1:11:10is you don't have to, if you decide to opt in,

1:11:14it's not like, oh, but now your entire iCloud photo library

1:11:19is invalidated because you hadn't been using it

1:11:22'cause advanced data security didn't exist before.

1:11:25Now it does.

1:11:26Now you've gotta re-upload your entire photo library.

1:11:30No, you don't, because all they do is when you're like,

1:11:33are you sure, are you really sure, okay, here you go,

1:11:36they just throw away their key.

1:11:38- And I believe you have to set up a recovery contact

1:11:41or print out a recovery code

1:11:42and put it in a safe deposit box

1:11:43'cause I mean, before you can enable it.

1:11:45- Right, you have to have some sort, you have to tell them,

1:11:48but they can't verify that the person,

1:11:50if you've said, yes, I've printed this thing out,

1:11:53you told me to print it and put it in my safe

1:11:56or a safe deposit box

1:11:58or wherever you keep your secure documents,

1:12:00but you have to have one of those things set up.

1:12:02I believe you can have both.

1:12:03You can both set up a,

1:12:06and I think that having that emergency contact,

1:12:11a spouse, a sibling, a trusted friend, a parent,

1:12:15whoever it is who you trust, and you're saying,

1:12:18if anything ever happens and I get locked out of my iCloud,

1:12:21I would let Renee be a person who could vouch for me

1:12:25and could let me back into my account just by you--

1:12:30- And I wouldn't get any information.

1:12:31I would just be able to let you back in.

1:12:33- Right, you wouldn't be, yes,

1:12:35you wouldn't have access to my iCloud photo library.

1:12:38You would just be able to,

1:12:40it turns you into a person who can do

1:12:42what my other devices do, which is say, yes, this is me.

1:12:46I know this code.

1:12:47It's the numbers 123007.

1:12:50Type it in and you're good to go.

1:12:54Or you can have one of these,

1:12:56I think they're like 28 characters, something like that,

1:12:58just long enough to certainly be safe

1:13:01from any kind of brute force attack

1:13:03that you can print out and put somewhere.

1:13:07Counterintuitively, I know Bruce Schneier

1:13:09has made this argument more eloquently

1:13:11than anybody probably ever could,

1:13:14that people intuitively think printing out

1:13:18something very important like that is terrible security.

1:13:22Oh my God, the worst thing you could ever do

1:13:24is write your passwords down in a book

1:13:27or print out this thing that is the key

1:13:30to the kingdom of your entire iCloud account.

1:13:32But it turns out human beings are really good

1:13:35at keeping physical objects secret, right?

1:13:38Because we evolved in the physical world

1:13:41over millions of years.

1:13:43And we're good at imagining things like that

1:13:46and good at understanding what's a safe place

1:13:49to put this and what's not.

1:13:51- Yeah, 100%. - Right?

1:13:52And--

1:13:55- Marriage licenses, birth certificates,

1:13:57all sorts of documents, we're very good at keeping those.

1:13:59- Right, and if you just keep it in a drawer in your bedroom

1:14:04and that's as safe as it is, that's probably pretty safe.

1:14:08And if you have an adversary who's in your bedroom

1:14:11going through your drawers,

1:14:12you've got a lot of problems, right?

1:14:14I mean, perfect is the enemy of good enough sometimes.

1:14:19- It reminds me of Dave Nainian

1:14:20when I was asking him about encrypting backups

1:14:22for like a super duper.

1:14:23He's just like, do you know how many valuable things

1:14:25you have in your house that somebody might wanna steal?

1:14:27Your wedding photos and your kids' photos

1:14:29are probably low on that list.

1:14:30Just back them up normally and put them someplace safe.

1:14:33- But back in the early days of going online

1:14:37and having an online life and having multiple accounts,

1:14:40I know, I certainly succumb to this personally.

1:14:44At some degree, your human intuition

1:14:47is that the safest place to keep a password is in your brain.

1:14:50- Yeah. - Right?

1:14:52I've got it, I've got it up here.

1:14:53And here I am, imagine me, if this was a YouTube show

1:14:56instead of an audio podcast, I'm doing that thing

1:14:58where I'm tapping my forehead, right?

1:15:00Ah, it's up here, it's all up here.

1:15:03And that's exactly though the mentality

1:15:05that the next step after that is,

1:15:08well, I can't memorize 40 different passwords

1:15:10and I certainly wouldn't remember which one goes to which,

1:15:12so why don't I think of one really clever password

1:15:16and I'll use that really clever password everywhere.

1:15:19- Yeah, yes. - It made sense, I did it.

1:15:22- Or that plus the name of the site,

1:15:23nobody'll ever guess that.

1:15:25- Oh, right, right, I did that.

1:15:27I definitely did, and every once in a while,

1:15:29I still run into some old thing

1:15:31that I haven't logged into in a while

1:15:33and I'm like, oh, yep, I gotta change that password.

1:15:36That's, you know, haven't logged in here

1:15:38in a couple of years, but here, let me do this,

1:15:41let me make a new one-time password, there it is.

1:15:44It's saved in my iCloud keychain or wherever else.

1:15:47But you know, it wasn't, it was misguided,

1:15:51but I don't think it was stupid.

1:15:53And I think if we re-rolled the universe a thousand times,

1:15:57everybody would do it a thousand times.

1:15:59We'd go through an era when everybody had

1:16:01like their favorite password and would reuse it.

1:16:03And it's, it's like I said with Freeform,

1:16:07not having to evolve out of a document-based legacy concept

1:16:14and can start with a cloud-based, no documents,

1:16:18it's all in the library idea from the start.

1:16:22iCloud has had to move live with now billions of users,

1:16:27but you know, for a very long time,

1:16:29hundreds of millions of users from a system

1:16:33that wasn't created with true end-to-end encryption in mind

1:16:38to get to a place where it is.

1:16:42But, and again, everybody seems happy that,

1:16:47with Apple's announcement about advanced data protection.

1:16:50- Well, I mean, everybody outside of law enforcement

1:16:52and probably some nation states.

1:16:55- Right, and it's also easy to,

1:16:58the other thing that was, I think I wrote about it.

1:17:02It was so clear a year ago that Apple's now abandoned,

1:17:07because that was the other bit of news

1:17:09that Craig Federighi told Joanna Stern in her interview

1:17:12with him about this stuff for the Wall Street Journal,

1:17:15that Apple has decided to not go forward

1:17:17with all the CSAM scanning stuff

1:17:20that they had announced last year,

1:17:22that they've taken the criticism to heart

1:17:24and that they're going to focus their efforts on,

1:17:26insofar as CSAM material of putting their efforts

1:17:31towards nipping it in the bud before it's even created.

1:17:34- Yeah. - You know,

1:17:34and there's things they can do to help in that regard.

1:17:37But the idea was, if they're going to move,

1:17:40the thinking I had last year was,

1:17:42if they're going to move iCloud Photo Library

1:17:44to be end-to-end encrypted, at least optionally,

1:17:48they're trying to say here, but we're still,

1:17:50even with end-to-end encryption,

1:17:52without us holding the keys,

1:17:54we're still taking this, that, and the other step

1:17:56to keep CSAM material from being part of somebody's library.

1:18:01Whether they were right to a,

1:18:03I actually still think that it was not,

1:18:07I don't think that what they were proposing was a bad idea.

1:18:09I wasn't, I was not opposed to it.

1:18:12I see the arguments against it,

1:18:16but I'm in the middle where I actually think the system

1:18:20that they were proposing was not going to,

1:18:23if they had instituted it,

1:18:25I don't think it would have led to the problems

1:18:27that people were thinking that there would be.

1:18:29I don't think, I don't think that they were going

1:18:32to be weak to potential attacks where somebody

1:18:37could create a false image that isn't actually

1:18:42CSAM child pornographic content,

1:18:45but it would match the fingerprint of one that is,

1:18:49and then they would somehow maliciously insert it

1:18:51into your iCloud Photo Library and do that 20 times

1:18:55or 30 times or whatever the threshold was,

1:18:58and then boom, your account is flagged.

1:19:01'Cause even if they did that,

1:19:02I thought that that human review step

1:19:04where they would look at the image,

1:19:06and if somebody can just insert,

1:19:09if somebody wants to attack you in this way

1:19:12and they have access and somehow can insert images

1:19:15into your iCloud Photo Library,

1:19:17why wouldn't they just put the actual

1:19:19child pornographic material in your library

1:19:22and let it be triggered? - I think a lot of that

1:19:23was like, there's like one of the other side effects

1:19:26of social media is that you have a lot of performative

1:19:28desperation theater where people want to get attention

1:19:30by making a lot of slippery slope arguments.

1:19:33And I think some of them, like whether other countries

1:19:35would try to impose their own databases.

1:19:37There were concerns, I think the biggest one

1:19:39for most people was just the emotional concern.

1:19:41The idea that some part of your phone was no longer yours

1:19:43was under control, and whether that's always been true

1:19:47with system update processes or not,

1:19:49it just felt like photos are mine, they're deeply personal,

1:19:51and I don't like the idea of something being done

1:19:53on my phone.

1:19:54I always hoped it'd be a compromise solution

1:19:56where either Apple would leverage the trusted intermediary

1:20:00technology that they were doing with their VPN-like solution

1:20:03where it would be done on a server in between you and Apple

1:20:06so that Apple would have zero knowledge

1:20:07but the bits wouldn't live on your phone

1:20:09the same way they do now with the internet,

1:20:11or that they would make a separate photos app

1:20:13and say like, if you want your photos on your phone,

1:20:16here's like the white icon version

1:20:17and those phones are never going online,

1:20:19but if you do want to make use of iCloud storage,

1:20:21then you download the online yellow version or whatever,

1:20:24and that one, you know that they're gonna go online

1:20:26but they're gonna be scanned as they're going online,

1:20:28and that way you can opt in or out,

1:20:30like visibly opt in or out.

1:20:32Realizing that's the word I was looking for.

1:20:36- Yeah, that was sort of what I thought they were,

1:20:39and I'll bet that when they said,

1:20:40"Okay, we've taken your criticism to heart,"

1:20:43I get it that it was sort of a philosophical,

1:20:46not technical argument that people were offended

1:20:48that it would be happening on their own devices

1:20:50even if it's just fingerprinting.

1:20:52- Right, I also though believe that there was no way

1:20:56to get past people's fundamental misunderstanding

1:20:59that they were not going to put a library of CSAM material

1:21:04on everybody's phone for the checking,

1:21:06just the fingerprints,

1:21:08but I get it that people didn't even want the fingerprints.

1:21:11Again, I'm not quite sure why that would bother me.

1:21:13- It's like having a metal detector

1:21:15on the door of your house instead of at the stadium

1:21:16that you're gonna go watch the game at.

1:21:19- I guess, I don't know, you know,

1:21:21or like, I don't know, but I get it.

1:21:24I think Apple listened.

1:21:25I do think that, I'll bet that when, you know,

1:21:28typical Apple, they took their time,

1:21:30they said, "Okay, we're gonna listen.

1:21:32"We're gonna put this on pause.

1:21:33"We'll get back to you."

1:21:35I'll bet that that is one of the things

1:21:37they very strongly considered

1:21:38was having these intermediary servers

1:21:41and a two-step process where you connect to one,

1:21:45this one connects to another,

1:21:46but the one that does the processing

1:21:47doesn't even know where it came from

1:21:49and does the fingerprint checking

1:21:51and then says, you know, this fingerprint is A-okay,

1:21:55go ahead and upload it to iCloud Photo.

1:21:57And I think that they ultimately said,

1:21:58"You know what, why build all this stuff?

1:21:59"Why don't we just skip it?"

1:22:01You know, and then anybody who was gonna complain

1:22:04and say, "Hey, you can't just let people

1:22:06"end-to-end encrypt their photo library.

1:22:08"What about, what if they're stashing

1:22:10"horrible, horrible C-SAM material in their library?"

1:22:14You know, they could say, "We tried.

1:22:15"We had a proposal to look into this.

1:22:19"We do care deeply about it,

1:22:21"but your privacy is your privacy."

1:22:24And this is one of those ways where they do,

1:22:26like speaking to people at Apple

1:22:28and getting briefed about it off the record,

1:22:30that they do still look at it in the way that,

1:22:33back in the day, pre-Cloud,

1:22:36everything that you did on your computer was on a disk,

1:22:39and the disk was in front of you somewhere,

1:22:41whether it's a floppy disk or a hard disk or something.

1:22:44And those disks were yours,

1:22:45and it was up to you how secure they were

1:22:47and how secure the room they were in was

1:22:50and how, you know, and that all they're trying to do

1:22:55in the modern digital age is put that level

1:22:58of user control over the data back into their hands

1:23:03if they want it.

1:23:05The other complaint that I've seen people have,

1:23:07I think the EFF, who I believe, you know,

1:23:09is almost entirely on the right on this,

1:23:11but like, I don't think I'm putting words

1:23:13in the EFF's mouth that they were like,

1:23:16"This is all great, except it shouldn't be opt-in.

1:23:18"It should be the default for everybody."

1:23:22I think that I disagree with that,

1:23:25and I'm not quite sure.

1:23:26Maybe someday it will be.

1:23:28Maybe they'll get to the point,

1:23:30and they'll maybe with 10 years of trusted use

1:23:35of using other people you know in your family

1:23:39as your trusted backup contact

1:23:42to get back into your account.

1:23:44But the customer service angle of this,

1:23:47where clearly there are way more Apple customers

1:23:52who come into the store and say,

1:23:55"You know, I left my phone in a cab,

1:23:57"and I don't know my iCloud password.

1:24:02"I've forgotten it.

1:24:03"I've tried to get in on the web 10 times,

1:24:07"and it's locked me out.

1:24:08"I don't know what to do.

1:24:09"I have an iCloud backup, and I want to replace the phone

1:24:12"that I just lost, but I don't know how to get my backup."

1:24:16There is a process you can go through,

1:24:17and it's obvious, you know.

1:24:19It seems anecdotally, you know, in terms of like,

1:24:22when's the last time you heard of anybody

1:24:24getting ripped off this way?

1:24:26You know, in other words,

1:24:27that somebody comes into an Apple store,

1:24:28and they're not me, and they're somehow saying,

1:24:30"I'm John Gruber, and I," you know.

1:24:32- It's an arduous process, though.

1:24:33Like, they're very stringent about you proving

1:24:36that you own the device and stuff, yeah.

1:24:39- Right, it's not like,

1:24:40"Oh, I have a 215 Genius Bar appointment,

1:24:43"and after three minutes of explaining my problem,

1:24:46"boom, the Genius behind at the Apple store

1:24:49"has my full decrypted Apple."

1:24:53Right, but it is possible.

1:24:56And my understanding is that all of our speculation

1:24:59that it's more common than you might think

1:25:02has all been true, you know,

1:25:04including just people who listen to the show

1:25:06who work at Apple retail stores,

1:25:08and they're like, "Yeah, it happens every," you know.

1:25:09So at least once every day,

1:25:11somebody comes in with this problem.

1:25:12Whereas the problem of some foreign state

1:25:17with an apparatus has hacked into Apple's cloud servers

1:25:24and taken the key to your backup

1:25:28and stolen your data that way, you know.

1:25:31- It's, yeah, it's very small.

1:25:34- Very small.

1:25:35There are fewer people who need this

1:25:38than there are people, typical consumers,

1:25:41who probably shouldn't turn it on.

1:25:42So I kind of feel, wouldn't be surprised

1:25:45if this is the natural end state.

1:25:47The only way I could see it becoming a little bit more

1:25:50likely to be turned on by typical people

1:25:53would be if like next year or the year after

1:25:56or at some point in the next handful of years,

1:25:59it becomes part of the onboarding process

1:26:01for a new device or a new software update, you know,

1:26:06that you install iOS 18 two years from now.

1:26:10And after the installation's complete

1:26:13and you go through those first run screens, you know,

1:26:16like where you set up Face ID or Touch ID

1:26:19and you opt into sharing your analytics

1:26:23with Apple and third-party and developers

1:26:25and this, whatever other, you know,

1:26:28there might be a time where they put there,

1:26:29do you want to turn on advanced data security?

1:26:32Here's what it means.

1:26:34It means you're on your own and Apple will never,

1:26:37literally mathematically, cryptographically

1:26:39cannot help you restore your data.

1:26:41You know, do you want to do this and make the button,

1:26:44the big blue default button be not to use it?

1:26:49You know, use standard security.

1:26:50- I could see that if there was like,

1:26:51if there was a radical Supreme Court decision

1:26:53or like mega Patriot Act sort of bill passing

1:26:57where people's, where at large scale

1:26:59people's data was at jeopardy.

1:27:00But otherwise, like you said,

1:27:01like let people have the option

1:27:03and it's hard to make informed decisions about this.

1:27:05Reminds me of that scene in West Wing

1:27:06where they're like nuclear deterrence

1:27:07is like a conversation that you can't just have casually.

1:27:10It involves incredibly deep understanding

1:27:11and not people are just equipped to have it.

1:27:13You know, it's like one of those things.

1:27:14Like it's, I did a whole 15 minute video

1:27:16on like the pros and cons of encryption

1:27:19versus non-encryption and what kind of data

1:27:21you should use for each.

1:27:22And it really does vary based on your threat level,

1:27:24your model, what kind of data we're talking about.

1:27:26It is not like just like, it made to sound

1:27:29like just everybody should do it all the time

1:27:31because that's what info sec nerds tell you.

1:27:33But people who live in backup and recovery worlds

1:27:35who deal with customers all the time

1:27:37will give you a very, very different story.

1:27:38So I just, I would just urge people to really assess

1:27:41what kind of dangers they face and whether,

1:27:43if you're more, if you would be more upset

1:27:45if you lost access yourself, then have it stolen.

1:27:48Don't use the encryption.

1:27:49If you'd be more damaging to you if things got stolen,

1:27:52then if you lost them yourself,

1:27:53then turn on the encryption.

1:27:55And my favorite thing though, John,

1:27:57is that none of this was live tweeted over 24 hour period

1:28:01by Craig Federighi during a major sports championship.

1:28:04This whole decision process was years in the making.

1:28:07- Have you turned it on?

1:28:08I have not because I literally can't

1:28:10because I still have too many devices

1:28:11that aren't running the latest OS.

1:28:13- Not in Canada yet.

1:28:15- Oh, that's right, yeah.

1:28:17- Yeah, but I probably won't turn it on because again,

1:28:18like most of my stuff is like family memories

1:28:21that I don't wanna lose access to.

1:28:22And I could set up the stuff, but saying that now,

1:28:24I just painted a huge target on me.

1:28:26So maybe I'll have to turn it on now,

1:28:27but normally I wouldn't.

1:28:28- I've been comfortable with the state

1:28:32of my iCloud security for years,

1:28:33so I'm comfortable keeping it.

1:28:35But it would be more arduous for me to get rid

1:28:38of all the devices that are still connected

1:28:40to my iCloud account.

1:28:42I mean, I guess what I should do is just go into iCloud

1:28:44and kick a bunch of, through the web interface,

1:28:48kick a bunch of old devices out.

1:28:50And if I ever do wanna go back to using my iPhone 5S,

1:28:54just sign back into iCloud.

1:28:56But for the time being, I'm happy not doing it,

1:28:58but I'm very glad that it exists.

1:29:00It is, you know, and I'm happy to see

1:29:02that Apple has been working on it.

1:29:04All right, let me take-- - And if I was like

1:29:05a college kid who was intent on running for president,

1:29:06one day I'd turn it on in a heartbeat.

1:29:09- Let me take a break here.

1:29:10Our next sponsors are good friends at KOLIDE, K-O-L-I-D-E.

1:29:15If you are listening to this podcast,

1:29:17the odds are good that at some point,

1:29:19you or your company are gonna go through an audit

1:29:21like SOC2 or ISO 2700127001.

1:29:26I don't know what those numbers are.

1:29:29They don't sound pleasant to me.

1:29:30But when you do go through these audits,

1:29:32you have to answer some tough questions

1:29:34about endpoint security.

1:29:36Questions like, do all of your company laptops

1:29:39have their disks encrypted?

1:29:40Speaking of security, does everyone have

1:29:43the company's password manager installed?

1:29:46Do you have a system in place to monitor

1:29:47and maintain compliance throughout your cross-platform

1:29:50defeat of computers?

1:29:53If you're confident, even if you are confident,

1:29:55that the answer to all of those questions is yes,

1:29:58the bigger question is, can you prove it to an auditor?

1:30:02If you're not quite sure how you'd go about

1:30:04proving compliance across your fleet of devices,

1:30:06then you need KOLIDE.

1:30:08KOLIDE is an endpoint security tool for the Mac, Windows,

1:30:11and now even Linux devices that does things

1:30:14that MDMs cannot do.

1:30:16And it gives you the visibility you need

1:30:18to achieve and maintain compliance.

1:30:20And best of all, KOLIDE does not resort

1:30:23to surveilling your employees or locking down their devices.

1:30:27It instead works with end users rather than fighting them

1:30:31to resolve issues.

1:30:32And it relies on their cooperation

1:30:33and their informed consent.

1:30:36You can meet your security goals and pass, improve,

1:30:39and audit without compromising on privacy.

1:30:42Visit kolide.com/thetalkshow to find out how.

1:30:47If you follow that link, KOLIDE's gonna hook you up

1:30:50with a goodie bag, including a t-shirt,

1:30:52just for activating a free trial.

1:30:54That's K-O-L-I-D-E dot com slash the talk show.

1:30:59KOLIDE dot com slash the talk show.

1:31:04Still not up to the year in review.

1:31:06I just realized we didn't talk about Germin's whole thing

1:31:09with the DMA.

1:31:10This is why me thinking, hey, I don't need to do

1:31:13a lot of episodes in December.

1:31:14Well, guess what, there's a lot of stuff in December.

1:31:16- Yeah, yeah. - But Mark Germin

1:31:18had a spectacular report about Apple's internal efforts

1:31:23to comply with the EU's new Digital Markets Act,

1:31:28which I guess is signed.

1:31:30I guess it's finalized.

1:31:32It's going to be the law of the land.

1:31:33They need to be in compliance by March of 2024.

1:31:36And basically, they're working on how they're going

1:31:39to allow sideloading and allow third-party app stores

1:31:43within the letter of the law.

1:31:45This DMA in the EU, they are unsure,

1:31:48or at least Germin sources are unsure,

1:31:51whether such features, whichever ones come to pass

1:31:56and come to be in iOS, are going to apply only

1:32:00to customers in the EU, where it's the law of the land

1:32:04and what would be worldwide.

1:32:06I wrote about this.

1:32:07Jason Snell had a fantastic piece about it.

1:32:10And ultimately, and again, it's Germin at his best.

1:32:14I don't know who else would have gotten this story,

1:32:16but he's got some details about who's leading up

1:32:18the engineering inside the software division at Apple

1:32:22and has some of the, just some of the questions,

1:32:26even inside Apple.

1:32:27I thought the other thing that was really interesting

1:32:29about his report is that, almost just offhandedly,

1:32:33but part of it was that the people working on it in Apple

1:32:36aren't really happy to be working on it

1:32:38because it doesn't really seem to them like

1:32:40the sort of thing that they signed up to work at Apple

1:32:44to do.

1:32:45I guess that, and you know, I wrote about it.

1:32:49I've talked about it on Dithering.

1:32:50I don't want to spend tons of time here,

1:32:51but having wasted a day, not wasted,

1:32:54I keep complaining about it.

1:32:55I'm glad I spent the time to read as much of the DMA

1:32:58as I could.

1:32:59- Yeah.

1:33:00- I complain 'cause I don't like it.

1:33:01And the more I think I understand it and understand

1:33:05at least the words that they've written,

1:33:06the worse I think it is as a law.

1:33:09I think fundamentally, it is a law written by regulators

1:33:14who do not understand what it is they're trying to regulate.

1:33:17- The EU has a history of good intentions

1:33:19with very bad implementations.

1:33:21- Yeah, their intentions, I think, are fine, of course.

1:33:24Well, I say of course, but you know,

1:33:25you can imagine a government that has bad intentions.

1:33:28I do think their intentions are good.

1:33:31I don't think that what they've written is good.

1:33:33And I'll just reiterate the thing I mentioned

1:33:35in my article that compare and contrast this,

1:33:40which is broad and ill-defined,

1:33:43like what exactly does it mean

1:33:45to have a third-party app store?

1:33:46What does it mean to have sideloading?

1:33:48And there's all sorts of ways it can be interpreted.

1:33:51Compare and contrast with the law that they've passed

1:33:55saying that if you make any of these type of devices,

1:33:58cell phones and tablets and headphones,

1:34:00and they charge via a port,

1:34:03that port needs to be a USB-C type port

1:34:06as of, I don't know, sometime in 2024.

1:34:09- Yeah.

1:34:10- I disagree with that regulation as law.

1:34:13I don't think it's necessary,

1:34:15and I think that the market was actually working.

1:34:17I think that the era of having dozens

1:34:19of different phone chargers and device chargers

1:34:22for different devices is long past,

1:34:24and that some of Apple's devices

1:34:28have stuck with lightning for over 10 years,

1:34:31as opposed to Apple having already moved them

1:34:34to USB-C on their own, I don't really think is problematic.

1:34:38I think that's the way the market works.

1:34:40But at the very least, the law is clear,

1:34:43and it's easy to understand, right?

1:34:45If you make one of these type of devices,

1:34:48and the device list is pretty clear,

1:34:49and it charges via a port,

1:34:51so that something that doesn't have a port

1:34:53like Apple Watch that only charges inductively

1:34:56doesn't need to add a USB-C port.

1:34:59If it does have a port, though, that port needs to be USB-C.

1:35:02- Whereas one of the ports has to be USB-C.

1:35:03They could have both, famously.

1:35:05- Right, you could have a, right,

1:35:06you could have a proprietary port that also charges.

1:35:09Again, so MagSafe is not illegal, right?

1:35:11I mean, you know, we laugh, but you know,

1:35:13Apple's laptops, which already do have USB-C,

1:35:16don't have to get rid of MagSafe,

1:35:18because it's not saying you only have to do it,

1:35:21but it's easy to understand,

1:35:22and you can understand what would be compliant

1:35:25and what's not.

1:35:26Whereas with this DMA, it is incredibly difficult,

1:35:30in my opinion, I would say impossible,

1:35:32just going from the letter of the law

1:35:34to determine what would be in compliance

1:35:37and what would not.

1:35:39So, here's one question.

1:35:41Here's a simple question.

1:35:42Apple, last year, implemented app tracking transparency,

1:35:47and this is, everybody's familiar with it now,

1:35:49because everybody uses apps, and you've been asked,

1:35:51you know, this app would like to track you

1:35:53across other apps, would you like to ask,

1:35:56would you like to allow that,

1:35:58or would you like to ask the app not to track?

1:36:01Everybody's familiar with this dialogue.

1:36:02Everybody is, almost everybody is surely familiar

1:36:05with the fact that it has seemingly led

1:36:08to a significant revenue decline for Facebook,

1:36:10most famously, but lots of other apps and companies

1:36:14that are in the advertising market,

1:36:17Google, perhaps, to some degree,

1:36:19but not as much as Facebook,

1:36:20that it's, as a direct result of this policy

1:36:23and the number of people who choose ask not to track,

1:36:27that revenue has declined, people get this.

1:36:30What happens in the world of sideloading

1:36:32if an app just says screw it,

1:36:35if you use, or third-party app stores, right?

1:36:37So let's just throw Facebook under the boat.

1:36:40If Facebook comes out with a third-party

1:36:43Facebook app store for iOS,

1:36:45and you can get Facebook and Instagram and Messenger

1:36:49and whatever other apps they might have or come out with,

1:36:53you can get them from Facebook's app store, too,

1:36:56and maybe their apps in Apple's app store

1:36:59will start telling you, you know,

1:37:00pushing you to switch to the Facebook app store,

1:37:03and maybe they'll throw in some kind of reward for doing so.

1:37:07Right, might literally bribe people, I don't know.

1:37:10You know, offer them money, they offer teenagers--

1:37:12- System scanning, right, exactly.

1:37:14- They offered teenagers like 20 bucks to install a VPN

1:37:18so that they could track

1:37:20what teenagers were doing on their phones.

1:37:22That's literally what they did.

1:37:23I mean, they didn't even really hide it.

1:37:25It wasn't like, oh, they got caught.

1:37:26It was like, no, that was clear, you know?

1:37:28No, that's what it said on the tin.

1:37:31Well, what happens if they do that,

1:37:32and their apps, you know, go back to tracking willy-nilly

1:37:36and ignoring this, does Apple have the right

1:37:39to pull their developer key

1:37:42and keep those apps from working

1:37:44'cause they're not in compliance

1:37:45with app tracking transparency?

1:37:47I mean, the app store is not just a store.

1:37:51The app store is the point of enforced compliance

1:37:55with platform policies, not just store policies.

1:38:00Right, so the store policy that everybody's obsessed with,

1:38:03and rightly so, I mean, 'cause money is important,

1:38:06but the thing that everybody thinks about first and foremost,

1:38:08but you're missing the larger picture

1:38:11if it's all you think about,

1:38:13is the 70/30 commission split, 85/15, you know,

1:38:16after a year or for small companies up to a million dollars.

1:38:20That part of app store compliance is clear.

1:38:23That's the definition of a store is making money.

1:38:26And so the commission on sales,

1:38:28either sales of the app and game

1:38:30or sales in-app purchase or in-app subscriptions

1:38:34in the app or game is the store enforcing store policies.

1:38:39But there's all sorts of other stuff in the app store

1:38:41and the app store review process

1:38:43that are enforcing platform policies for iOS system-wide,

1:38:48like the fact that you can't use private APIs

1:38:51and they have automated tools that detect

1:38:54if an app submitted is using private APIs.

1:38:57And before a human being even sees it,

1:39:00if you just use a private API in your app

1:39:02and you submit it for inspection by the app store,

1:39:06it'll just bounce right back to you and say,

1:39:08you know, you're using this private API

1:39:10to see what's on the desktop behind your window.

1:39:13That's not allowed.

1:39:14Please fix this before you resubmit another bill.

1:39:16What happens within the world of,

1:39:19if this world is coming of side-loaded

1:39:22and third-party app stores,

1:39:23does Apple still get to enforce that somehow?

1:39:26- Yeah, it's that interesting question

1:39:28where a lot of people, like, we've talked about this,

1:39:31but there are console models,

1:39:33which Steve Jobs and Apple clearly wanted the iPhone to be,

1:39:36where it's like a Nintendo or it's like a PlayStation

1:39:39and it just has the things that are supposed to run on it

1:39:41and it's not meant to be an open computing platform.

1:39:44Although people argue now it is so popular and so powerful

1:39:46that there's almost a moral imperative

1:39:48for it to become an open compute platform.

1:39:51And then you have the alternative,

1:39:52which is Android or previously there were others,

1:39:55like Android, which is much more like an open compute system.

1:39:57And that the argument essentially is whether

1:40:00each platform into itself has to be both things.

1:40:03Like, on Android you can choose

1:40:04to just use a Google Play Store,

1:40:06or you can choose to sideload apps.

1:40:08And Epic will tell you that they still don't work really well

1:40:11with sideloaded apps, but whatever, you have those options.

1:40:14Where with Apple, it's like you have the app store

1:40:16or you have the web.

1:40:18And for some people, that's not a bug, that's a feature.

1:40:20And people will say, well, you still have the choice,

1:40:22the same way you have it on Android.

1:40:24But to your previous point, if enough powerful people

1:40:27have enough powerful incentives,

1:40:28there could be apps that people just believe

1:40:30are fundamental to their use models.

1:40:33And whether it's Facebook or a game,

1:40:35or it's a school saying you have to download our thing

1:40:38to run your tests, or whatever it is,

1:40:40they could compel people to have to do this.

1:40:42So I'm hoping like whatever it is,

1:40:46it's one of those things where you have to literally

1:40:48reboot the device to get it into a state

1:40:50where you can start sideloading apps.

1:40:52Because otherwise, people are gonna just find ways

1:40:54to trick you into sideloading stuff all the time.

1:40:56And it's gonna be the security nightmare

1:40:58that Apple has often painted it to be.

1:41:01- If we put aside the money,

1:41:04and again, putting aside the money, we should come back to it.

1:41:06I'm not saying everybody should forget about them.

1:41:08But if you put aside the money,

1:41:10and if they passed a law that just said

1:41:12that a gatekeeper company,

1:41:15by their definition of gatekeepers,

1:41:17if they sort of put into law the Phil Schiller memo idea

1:41:22from 10 years ago or more,

1:41:25which was entered into the, as evidenced in the Epic case,

1:41:28where when the app store started growing revenue-wise,

1:41:33beyond what even Apple, its executives themselves

1:41:36might have ever foreseen as possible,

1:41:39Schiller floated the idea in a memo to the other executives

1:41:43of what if we just said,

1:41:44we'll cap our revenue from the app store

1:41:47at let's just say a billion dollars a year,

1:41:50and once we go past that,

1:41:52then we'll just start lowering the commission rate

1:41:55to keep it at a billion dollars.

1:41:56So instead of 70/30, go to 25.

1:41:58- Keep it at breakeven.

1:42:00- You know, 25 and then 20.

1:42:03And just, yeah, or keep it at, or a billion dollars, right?

1:42:06A billion dollars isn't breakeven.

1:42:09It's nice money, but then it won't just keep growing

1:42:11and grow to a level where it could

1:42:14pervert the company's motivations,

1:42:17or corrupt the company's motivations.

1:42:20And they could put something in law that says

1:42:22that if you run an app store, your revenue is capped

1:42:25at a certain level, or they could put into law that says,

1:42:28if you charge a commission, that commission,

1:42:30and you qualify as a gatekeeper company,

1:42:32so like Panic wouldn't run into this with the playdate,

1:42:35because they're so small, but that, you know,

1:42:38they could say that it's capped at 15%,

1:42:41or it's capped at 20%, or it's whatever.

1:42:44They could do something like that.

1:42:45But put aside the money, Apple,

1:42:48this is what so many people who are hyper-focused

1:42:51on the money don't see, is that Apple, across the company,

1:42:56has reasons to want this control over the platform

1:42:59in the name of customer experience.

1:43:02And I bring this up, and there's some number of people,

1:43:06again, Twitter being Twitter, it often happens there, but,

1:43:09and I try to argue in good faith.

1:43:11I'm not, you know, I don't own Apple stock

1:43:14for professional reasons, you know,

1:43:15just so that I never have to worry, you know,

1:43:17am I hurting my own future, you know, retirement

1:43:21by what I report on the company?

1:43:23So it's not, I'm not doing this, because I,

1:43:25and somehow, I don't make money when Apple makes more money

1:43:28through the App Store, but I totally,

1:43:31what I see that other people don't see is that

1:43:33the reason people thrive on this platform,

1:43:36so many people thrive on this platform,

1:43:38is because of these constrictions,

1:43:41these restrictions that are so different

1:43:43than the world of Mac and Windows and other PCs.

1:43:47Even Apple's own platform, the Mac,

1:43:48that people are so much more comfortable

1:43:53knowing that they can't, and that it's,

1:43:55and also, they just understand it.

1:43:57It is an understandable closed loop.

1:44:00- It's a constant. - Where--

1:44:01- It's nothing easier than that.

1:44:02- Right, and you just sort of see it,

1:44:05and here, you have this device in your hand,

1:44:07and if you, you can see all the apps,

1:44:09they're there on your home screen,

1:44:11and if you want to get another app that isn't there,

1:44:15you know where to go, there's an app for that,

1:44:18and that app is called App Store,

1:44:20and you go into the App Store,

1:44:22you sign in with your Apple ID,

1:44:26and they have your credit card,

1:44:27and then from there, you can download other apps,

1:44:31install them, and there's a promise from Apple

1:44:33that has been true, and I know that whatever you do

1:44:38in the App Store, whatever you install,

1:44:40is not going to mess up your device.

1:44:42It's technically, and both through technical measures

1:44:45at the computer science level with sandboxing

1:44:48and permissions, as, you know, at a, like I said,

1:44:53like at a computer science level,

1:44:55there are protections in place,

1:44:56and then there are policy protections in place

1:44:59that are enforced by the guidelines of the App Store

1:45:02that you're not gonna end up with some kind of

1:45:05invisible background demon running all the time

1:45:09on your phone, and you don't even know what you did,

1:45:11but at some point, you installed something,

1:45:13and without even launching the app,

1:45:15every time you restart your phone,

1:45:17it's already draining your battery

1:45:19at twice the rate that it should be.

1:45:21That just, it doesn't happen, and people are so hesitant--

1:45:26- And nobody's downloading Pokemon

1:45:27or Fortnite bootlegs off of, like,

1:45:30- Right. - Yeah, APKs

1:45:32that are malware-ing them.

1:45:34- Right, you never start getting pop-up ads

1:45:36from some application.

1:45:38It's somewhere in the background on your phone.

1:45:39There are so many things that happen to Macs and Windows PCs

1:45:43that cannot happen, and how central that is

1:45:47to the appeal of the platform for users,

1:45:49and I get it where if in some alternate universe,

1:45:53there were, Apple made two kinds of phones.

1:45:56They made the iPhone, which is the iPhone as we know it,

1:45:58and they made a Mac phone, for lack of a better word,

1:46:01and the Mac phone had a, was more like the Mac

1:46:05in terms of, oh, you can just download .apps from the web

1:46:09and unzip them, and they'll, you know,

1:46:11drag them to the applications folder on your Mac phone,

1:46:14and now you've got third-party applications

1:46:16that go through.

1:46:16I, whether it, if that were an operating system,

1:46:20you could just install on the identical hardware,

1:46:22or if it was a different device you had to buy.

1:46:25That's what I would buy from Apple.

1:46:27I would, but I'm not a typical user.

1:46:29I'm not even vaguely close to a typical user.

1:46:31- No, same, 100% same.

1:46:33Like, I personally am a fan of sideloading.

1:46:35If I had my druthers, I would like to sideload everything

1:46:37and have complete control over everything,

1:46:39but I recognize that with these things,

1:46:41we have to talk about solutions that don't just apply to us,

1:46:43but that apply to the market,

1:46:44and the market is often very different

1:46:46than the just us part of it.

1:46:48- Right, and I, and you know, and you, I'm sure,

1:46:51and I'm sure many, many, if not most of the people

1:46:53who listen to my show, effectively do a form of sideloading

1:46:56already through TestFlight, where I've got at least

1:46:59a few apps on my phone at all times

1:47:01that aren't from the App Store.

1:47:02They're directly from developers

1:47:04through Apple's TestFlight system,

1:47:06including apps that couldn't be on the App Store

1:47:09because they would violate, you know,

1:47:11certain rules or whatever.

1:47:13But I'm, you know, to me, it's not the worst place

1:47:19where the platform could be in terms of balancing the needs

1:47:22of most people versus allowing power users,

1:47:27for lack of a term, to go outside the App Store for things.

1:47:31And I don't think that-- - I talked about this part

1:47:32before too, like, my parents are super smart.

1:47:34Like, they're engineers and like, professors,

1:47:36and they love the iPad because it was like,

1:47:38just super simple, there was no complexity to it at all.

1:47:41And now whenever I go over, like, I'll take out their iPad,

1:47:44and there's like 800 versions of the mail thing

1:47:46along the dock, and it's like, they're pulling the apps out

1:47:48when they try to do it, and it's just like,

1:47:49I just want my iPad back.

1:47:51And that's not even, like, to the point of a Mac,

1:47:53it's just that people have been complaining so often

1:47:55that it's not a pro device, and Apple's solution

1:47:57isn't to say make the Mac better,

1:47:58it's to keep making the iPad more complicated.

1:48:00And I see the same dynamic unfolding eventually

1:48:02with the iPhone, where it's just the people who loved it

1:48:05for what it was, it's like, you know,

1:48:06like, you date somebody and you're like, I love them,

1:48:08but I just wanna change them, and then you change them,

1:48:10and you're like, I don't like them at all anymore.

1:48:13- Oh, I've given up on that. - That's what it feels like.

1:48:15- I've given up on that a long time ago, Rene.

1:48:17- Yep, yep. - No change.

1:48:18- That's like the cliche.

1:48:20- But I know, but I do know,

1:48:21but I know exactly what you mean, and that is true.

1:48:24I just feel that what the EU has regulated here

1:48:27with this DMA, at least insofar as it pertains to Apple

1:48:30and iOS and their stewardship of iOS, and by iOS,

1:48:34I mean both on the iPhone and iPad, is misguided.

1:48:37And I don't think, I don't think the things

1:48:40that they think they're gonna solve, this law solves at all.

1:48:43And I think if they wanted to solve those things

1:48:45and enforce some measure of increased competition,

1:48:50and I certainly have complaints, you know,

1:48:51I'm on a record since forever that I think it's absurd

1:48:55and an outright offensive that one of the rules

1:48:58of the App Store is that apps cannot explain the rules

1:49:02of the App Store within the app.

1:49:04So when you first launch Netflix on your iPhone

1:49:09and you don't have an account for Netflix yet,

1:49:12they can't tell you that you have to go

1:49:14to Netflix.com to sign up.

1:49:16They can't even tell you to go there to sign up,

1:49:18let alone make it an actual link that would take you there.

1:49:21Although maybe Netflix as a reader app could,

1:49:23you know, maybe that's an exception, but there's any other--

1:49:27- It's a problem with the Twitter thing over the weekend.

1:49:29- Right, but exactly, not allowing you to put a link

1:49:32to a mastodon in your Twitter account.

1:49:34Well, Apple's been rocking that way from the beginning.

1:49:37What makes Twitter's thing seem goofy

1:49:39and Apple's just patently offensive is that

1:49:42at least Apple's thing has been that way from the get-go,

1:49:46whereas Twitter is in and of the open web.

1:49:49It is, in some people's minds, you know,

1:49:52it's a website with apps, you know, not just a closed app

1:49:57ecosystem.

1:49:59I think that the fact that Apple has these restrictions,

1:50:02I think that the competition at the very least

1:50:04should be between, okay, in app, you get to have

1:50:09all the convenience of doing it in app and it's right here

1:50:12and using your saved credit card and using customers' trust

1:50:17of the Apple purchase system, or you could steer them

1:50:21to your website and say, or you can pay, you know,

1:50:25what, again, just toss Twitter out there as an idea

1:50:28where Twitter's thing where they have this new

1:50:29Twitter Blue subscription and in app, it costs $11 a month,

1:50:34but you can go to the web and sign up on your Twitter account

1:50:37for just $8 a month to compensate for the 30%

1:50:41Apple is taking.

1:50:42They should be able to tell you that right in the app.

1:50:43They should say, here, if you wanna sign up right here

1:50:46in app and use your Apple account, it's $11 a month,

1:50:49tap here, and if you would prefer to pay $8 a month,

1:50:52tap here and it'll jump you out to Safari

1:50:55and you could sign up there and let people compete.

1:50:57And if too many people for Apple's taste are saving

1:51:02the $3 a month by jumping out, well then,

1:51:05that's the competition that might get them

1:51:06to lower the 70/30 split to something

1:51:09where they wouldn't do it.

1:51:12But that's, if the regulation took targeted measures

1:51:16like that, bull's eyes, and say this is a specific problem

1:51:20we have, okay, I wouldn't be complaining.

1:51:24I would say this is actually where government regulation

1:51:26helps, but you have to allow sideloading

1:51:30in third-party app stores?

1:51:32I'm not with it.

1:51:33How do you see it coming?

1:51:34I think that Apple's going to take every measure they can

1:51:38to make this as unpleasant as possible within the confines

1:51:43of the law and have so many warnings and stuff

1:51:46that it will ultimately wind up as a thing

1:51:49that they spend a lot of engineering time

1:51:51to make sure technically works and is possible

1:51:54to comply with the law, but which effectively,

1:51:57nobody is actually going to use.

1:51:59Users won't, most users won't turn it on

1:52:02and very few, if any, major companies will actually

1:52:05go the route of putting their games or other apps

1:52:09into a third-party app store or creating

1:52:11a third-party app store or allowing them to be signed.

1:52:15Yeah, I think, well, I hate saying this

1:52:18because we've talked about this before,

1:52:20but when Apple said we're going to double

1:52:22our services revenue by, I forget what the date was, 2020,

1:52:25I think that was a fundamental shift

1:52:26where for the first time user experienced

1:52:28like a backseat to revenue and we started seeing

1:52:30all these push notification marketing ads

1:52:32and ads being put more on the platform

1:52:34and a lot of things that gets Apple in trouble,

1:52:36even though it's not a major part of their revenue stream.

1:52:39And I think this shapes, colors a lot of that

1:52:42because we saw in the testimony that when Tim Cook

1:52:44was talking that he said, whether you're in the app store

1:52:47or not, it's going to make it just harder for you

1:52:49to give us our 30%, which people were stunned

1:52:52that he'd say that, but I think this is the same thing.

1:52:55Apple will put in some form of gatekeeper,

1:52:57like the same sort of functionality we have

1:52:59on Mac OS right now, but maybe there'll be a fee imposed

1:53:04for getting a signed certificate from Apple

1:53:06and you'll have to have a signed certificate

1:53:08to run on the app store or maybe they'll be like,

1:53:10here's the form to submit your 30%

1:53:12for running on an iOS device.

1:53:14It's going to be something that's going to make

1:53:16a whole bunch of people, I don't think people

1:53:19are going to be as happy about it as they think they are

1:53:21and I don't think it's going to be as easy

1:53:23and I think also to your point,

1:53:24we've seen how this works out on Android.

1:53:26We've seen Epic say that it doesn't work out well

1:53:28for them on Android and I don't think that Apple

1:53:31is going to go out of their way to make it easier

1:53:33or better results for Epic, who by the way

1:53:36is involved in a huge lawsuit right now

1:53:38for the stuff that they're worried about,

1:53:40the 30% they want is for their V bucks.

1:53:42I don't think they'll make it much easier.

1:53:44I keep going back to this, it reminds me of the battle

1:53:46between a casino and a city council in Las Vegas

1:53:49and I just wish both of those things didn't really exist

1:53:51but I understand why they're fighting.

1:53:53- It is curious to me that Android has had side loading

1:53:58from the get-go and in my opinion,

1:54:00as somebody who's owned an Android phone on it

1:54:03or every couple years I buy a new one,

1:54:05I think that the way you go about turning it,

1:54:09it's off by default, at least on the Android phones

1:54:12I've purchased which have been the Pixel phones

1:54:14in recent years, it's off by default.

1:54:16I think that where you go to turn it on

1:54:19and the language of and number of warnings

1:54:23you have to okay past to get it turned on is appropriate.

1:54:27I don't think it's, and yet it's effectively a non-issue

1:54:31in the Android market and it's funny,

1:54:33that to me is the funniest part about the Epic thing

1:54:36where Epic sued Apple and Google and so they sued Google

1:54:41and their argument against Google was basically

1:54:44that they thought those warnings were,

1:54:46so they turned off so many people

1:54:49that it effectively kept it from working.

1:54:52I guess what they want is something,

1:54:55I mean really, I mean I'm not trying

1:54:57to be hyperbolic about it.

1:55:01I really think Epic wanted it to be,

1:55:03wants it to be as easy, if not easier,

1:55:06than modern Mac and Windows.

1:55:07Like go back 10 years to how easy it was

1:55:09to just unzip anything and double click it and it runs.

1:55:13And once it's running-- - I think they wanna

1:55:14be the store, like they don't really care about,

1:55:17they're upset they're not the gatekeeper,

1:55:18I think is what it boils down to.

1:55:19- And that used to be possible on Mac and Windows

1:55:23where you could write software that would dig hooks

1:55:26into the operating system and if you,

1:55:28whether knowing what you got into or unknowingly,

1:55:31you could wind up running what's effectively

1:55:35a Frankenstein operating system or part of the,

1:55:38part of what would, to me, be considered part of the system

1:55:43is now from a third party that isn't,

1:55:45it isn't necessarily in conflict with the company

1:55:48that makes, or whoever it is who's in charge

1:55:51of making the pure version of the operating system,

1:55:56but you've got this whole thing running in the background.

1:55:58You know, like Adobe effectively does that, right?

1:56:00When you install the Adobe Suite on your Mac,

1:56:05part of your Mac is all constantly checking in

1:56:08with Adobe and you're effectively running an offshoot

1:56:12of Mac OS that's Mac OS with the Adobe Creative Suite.

1:56:17- And they keep asking you if you wanna install

1:56:18the special trust thing that'll increase their trust of you.

1:56:21- Right.

1:56:22You know, and there's pluses and minuses to it, right?

1:56:27I mean, Dropbox, certainly in the early days of Dropbox

1:56:31when it was super simple, you know,

1:56:32it was a hack though at a technical level.

1:56:34It was a complete hack and you were just running,

1:56:38effectively if you were using Dropbox then,

1:56:40you were running a hacked version of Mac OS

1:56:42that had a cloud fold, you know,

1:56:45everything in this folder syncs to a cloud service thing

1:56:47running in the background that wasn't just like an app

1:56:51and you couldn't just command Q and quit it.

1:56:52It was, you know, running extensions in the background.

1:56:56And they, you know, because they engineered it well,

1:56:58that's what made it popular is it's like,

1:56:59yeah, I installed it.

1:57:00And yes, you could uninstall it, but it wasn't easy.

1:57:03Yes, there's pluses and minuses to that sort of thing,

1:57:06but the phone to me, so long as we only have

1:57:09one phone platform from the company,

1:57:12it shouldn't be that way.

1:57:13We shall see.

1:57:15All right, let me thank our final sponsor of the episode,

1:57:19it's our good friends at Squarespace.

1:57:21Look, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform

1:57:25for building your brand and growing your business online.

1:57:28You can stand out with a beautiful website,

1:57:30engage with your audience and sell anything,

1:57:32your products, your content, even your time.

1:57:35Squarespace has it all.

1:57:38Domain name registration, analytics,

1:57:41really, really good analytics,

1:57:43a clear, great design that lets you see

1:57:47who's coming to your website, where are they coming from,

1:57:49which parts of your website are busy,

1:57:51which parts aren't.

1:57:53Online stores, set up a catalog,

1:57:57take all, do all the commerce,

1:57:59all the secure stuff you need to do

1:58:01to process credit cards, Squarespace can handle it for you.

1:58:04Custom templates for creating your website,

1:58:06they have so many custom templates

1:58:08and they look great across all devices

1:58:11and they are customizable from top to bottom.

1:58:14Anything you want to tweak, you can tweak.

1:58:17You can do it in a totally WYSIWYG fashion

1:58:19right in your browser or if you know stuff like CSS

1:58:23and HTML, you can modify it at the code level,

1:58:26be as nerdy or as unnerdy as you want

1:58:28and they have award-winning technical support

1:58:32that is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

1:58:35Just in case you need help with something,

1:58:36you can always do it.

1:58:37If you're a consultant and you build websites

1:58:40for your customers, that sort of thing,

1:58:42you should really look into maybe doing it on Squarespace

1:58:45and then you can just turn it over to the customer

1:58:47and they've got one thing to pay for.

1:58:49They don't have to pay for a host

1:58:51and then pay for e-commerce and then pay for this

1:58:53or pay for that.

1:58:55Just send them to Squarespace, let them do it all there.

1:58:58Get them out of your hair.

1:58:59Where do you go to find out more?

1:59:01Go to squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:59:04Squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:59:07When you go there, you get a free trial, 30 days,

1:59:10no limits, no watermarks on the website, full featured.

1:59:14It's, you're exactly treated like a paying customer,

1:59:1830-day free trial and then when you're ready to launch

1:59:20at the end of the free trial, just remember that same code,

1:59:23that same offer code, talk show and you save 10%

1:59:26off your first purchase of a website or a domain

1:59:29or everything combined.

1:59:31Put it all together, save 10%,

1:59:32go to squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:59:35Well, we've wound up with our Apple December in review.

1:59:41- Yes, or the last week in review.

1:59:43- The year in review, again, famous last words.

1:59:45I don't know that I have a lot to say.

1:59:48There's-- - Well, I think you nailed it

1:59:50at the beginning.

1:59:50It was like the when COVID caught up, COVID and lockdowns

1:59:53and a bunch of other stuff caught up with Apple.

1:59:55- Right, and this is not a complaint, but I think that it,

2:00:00you know, that they had to prioritize

2:00:02while they were locked down.

2:00:03I mean, famously on the hardware front,

2:00:05they, it's still mind-blowing to me that when that,

2:00:10I think it was United a couple of years ago

2:00:13accidentally leaked somehow in,

2:00:16some poor product or marketing person at United leaked

2:00:21that Apple has a standing order of like, I don't know,

2:00:2450 business class seats between SFO and China

2:00:29every single day.

2:00:30And they don't necessarily fill those seats every day,

2:00:33but if they wanted to, they could.

2:00:37Dozens and dozens of people who work for Apple

2:00:39or, you know, in normal times are flying between Apple

2:00:42and China every day and probably other places

2:00:45around the world now too, as Apple is slowly

2:00:49sort of trying to break free of the dependence,

2:00:52their dependencies on China.

2:00:55But the hardware business is one of, you know,

2:00:59hardware is physical and therefore there are aspects of it

2:01:02that require a physical presence of people, right?

2:01:05I mean, I think it's fair to say that software

2:01:10is more naturally and easily created

2:01:15by a remote team than hardware.

2:01:19- Yeah, like even when, like when people talk about

2:01:21return to work, that's for software people,

2:01:23hardware people across Silicon Valley have been at work

2:01:25and has met suits for the last two plus years.

2:01:28- Right, and I know, you know, some people,

2:01:31I know more software people than hardware people at Apple,

2:01:33but, you know, during the COVID restrictions,

2:01:35there were times, you know, and, you know,

2:01:38Apple hints at them here and there,

2:01:40but like the machines they have for fabricating,

2:01:43you know, they're effectively very fancy 3D printers,

2:01:46but ones that can make things out of like aluminum.

2:01:50- All of that.

2:01:50- Yes, there's, you just can't, I don't know.

2:01:53I'm sure it'd be fascinating.

2:01:54I would love it if Apple someday did some kind, you know,

2:01:56and just put it all, put it all on like a four year delay

2:01:59or something to keep the latest and greatest out of it,

2:02:02but I would love like an Apple TV show

2:02:04that was just behind the scenes at Apple hardware

2:02:06and you got to see like, you know, like at this point,

2:02:10like if you got to see how they created the original AirPods

2:02:13from six years ago, you know,

2:02:14and the prototypes they went through and stuff,

2:02:17it'd be fascinating, but you have to be there, right?

2:02:20You can't, you know, if you're working at home,

2:02:21you don't have access to the $10 million CNC machine.

2:02:25- Yeah, 100%.

2:02:26- So, you know, and people had to go in

2:02:29and they'd like have like a signup sheet

2:02:30and there'd be one employee at a time

2:02:32who would come in and be in the lab all by themselves

2:02:35and, you know, and then leave and wait for the air to clear

2:02:39before somebody else could come in.

2:02:40I mean, it was complicated.

2:02:41It would be shocking if somehow the 2020 and 2021 went by

2:02:46and Apple hadn't been, like any other company,

2:02:48hindered in some ways.

2:02:50And I kind of feel like this is the year

2:02:51where it caught up to them

2:02:52and maybe it'll be a while before they're fully unjammed.

2:02:56I can't help but think that if in a world

2:02:58where COVID didn't happen,

2:03:00that I'd like to think that maybe this,

2:03:05the late November or October,

2:03:07whenever it was when they came out with the new iPads,

2:03:09I guess it was October, that, you know,

2:03:11and everybody's like, huh, you know,

2:03:12the iPad Pros are still kind of unchanged

2:03:16except they go from the M1 to the M2

2:03:18and, you know, there's the fancy pencil support

2:03:21where you can hover, you get a hover effect.

2:03:23And other than that, that's it, you know, which isn't bad.

2:03:26They're still great, you know,

2:03:29best of class pro tablets,

2:03:31but, you know, there are designs that go back to 2018

2:03:35and that's pretty long time for Apple.

2:03:37Even if the new design that they might've had

2:03:40wouldn't have been a radical departure,

2:03:43you know, clearly the more radical departure

2:03:45was just like with the iPhone 10 for the iPhone,

2:03:49going from the, there's a touch ID home button

2:03:54on the front face to an edge to edge, you know, thing.

2:03:57And with the iPad Pros going to face ID

2:04:00or with the iPad Air and now the regular iPad

2:04:03having a touch ID button on the side

2:04:07instead of on the front face

2:04:08'cause there's no more room on the front face.

2:04:10I don't think there's a new iPad design that radical

2:04:15that would have been due this year,

2:04:17but something, you know, a little new.

2:04:18I can't help but feel that we'd be have more of the max,

2:04:22you know, or second level,

2:04:23second versions of certain max out already, you know.

2:04:28- The iPad thing, like to me,

2:04:31I want now that Apple is fully in control

2:04:32of their own chip destiny,

2:04:34I want them to always update to the new chip.

2:04:36Like just, even if they're not changing anything,

2:04:38just put the new chip in it and people will say,

2:04:39"Well, you shouldn't, like why upgrade every year?"

2:04:41I'm not gonna upgrade every year,

2:04:43but every year somebody is going to.

2:04:45And I feel like it very much like I feel like a bakery.

2:04:47Even though I'm not buying fresh bread every day,

2:04:50any day I go to the bakery, there should be fresh bread.

2:04:52I don't wanna go and buy an iPad

2:04:54that has a two-year-old processor in it

2:04:55just because there's no redesign.

2:04:57Like just put the new spec, like the new parts in,

2:04:59any year you have the new parts.

2:05:01So every year that I buy them,

2:05:02I get the best version of that for the money that I can.

2:05:05But the max stuff,

2:05:07like when Steve Jobs announced the transition to Intel,

2:05:10he said it would take two years.

2:05:11They got it done in about a year.

2:05:13Tim Cook made the same two-year promise.

2:05:15They're not done.

2:05:16Like we still don't have an Apple Silicon Mac Pro.

2:05:18And when you look at the timeline,

2:05:20like it's evident just based on the specs of the machines

2:05:23that several of these things came out months later

2:05:25than Apple originally planned them to.

2:05:27And that whole timeline just got stretched out.

2:05:30And I think that that is like, if not for COVID,

2:05:32I think we would have gotten a lot of those products earlier

2:05:35and we would have gotten to that Mac Pro by now

2:05:37and they would have just nailed that transition.

2:05:40- Yeah, and it's funny and I almost feel bad for like,

2:05:43like Tom Boger in particular,

2:05:45who's was the one who is sort of tasked

2:05:48with when they rejuvenated the Mac Mini

2:05:51of telling us in the press.

2:05:53And you had a great interview with him,

2:05:55but telling us, hey,

2:05:56there've been stretches where the Mac Mini

2:05:59didn't get updates in the Intel era,

2:06:01but we've never lost sight of what a great product it is.

2:06:05And we know how so many of our customers are pro Mac users

2:06:09have these very pro uses for this very small desktop Mac.

2:06:13I think that the shape of the Mac Studio

2:06:17shows how committed they are to that sort of form factor.

2:06:20Where we'll just take the same footprint,

2:06:22but we'll make it taller because it's got super pro,

2:06:25very, very serious pro specs.

2:06:27But here we are over now,

2:06:31over two years after the M1 Mac Mini.

2:06:34And if you wanna get a Mac Mini,

2:06:35you're still getting the one from the end of 2020.

2:06:38And now Apple's in charge.

2:06:39I don't think that was their plan all along.

2:06:41I think- - Nope.

2:06:42- I think without COVID,

2:06:44we would have had something else in between,

2:06:47possibly more than just go from the M1 to M2,

2:06:50but at least go from the M1 to M2.

2:06:53- COVID and TSMC is starting to feel

2:06:55what Intel felt a few years ago

2:06:56in terms of die shrink,

2:06:58like process shrinks and yield rates.

2:07:00- Right.

2:07:02So they had to prioritize.

2:07:03And what bubbled to the top of their priorities

2:07:07in that stretch?

2:07:07And again, I'm sure that was all in the timeline,

2:07:10but they did, this was over a year ago though.

2:07:12So it's not a 2022 year in review thing.

2:07:15It's the late 2021 MacBook Pros,

2:07:19the 14 inch and 16 inch MacBook Pros,

2:07:21which me as a, that's my main machine,

2:07:24a 14 inch M2 MacBook Pro.

2:07:27I love it.

2:07:28I can't say enough good things about it.

2:07:29I love it.

2:07:30It's great.

2:07:32It kind of boggles my mind though,

2:07:33that one of the rumors earlier this year

2:07:35was that they'd have new ones already

2:07:37at the end of this year.

2:07:38And I was just sort of like, hmm.

2:07:43I mean, ideally, I guess it would be nice

2:07:45if it was on a 12 month schedule

2:07:46and you could count on it the way we do the phone.

2:07:49My skepticism, and it turns out I was right.

2:07:52There were no new MacBook Pros this year,

2:07:55but my thought was, well, wait,

2:07:56with all these other machines we haven't seen yet,

2:07:58why would they put that one up

2:08:01when those are actually relatively fresh, right?

2:08:05There's no new Mac mini yet.

2:08:07The Mac Pro we literally haven't seen yet.

2:08:10So--

2:08:11- Yeah, the iMac Pro is still in another world

2:08:13where they're trying to figure out

2:08:14if the studio solves for that

2:08:15or if they still need to make it.

2:08:17- Yeah, and I get it that it's not like

2:08:18there's 12 people working for John Turnus

2:08:21and those 12 people have to put

2:08:25all these Mac hardware devices out there

2:08:27and they're not, you know,

2:08:29that there's different hundreds and hundreds,

2:08:32if not thousands of people working

2:08:33on Apple's Mac hardware in parallel,

2:08:37but it just seemed like with the pace of all the other Macs

2:08:40that I would have been very surprised

2:08:42if October's introductions included M2 MacBook Pros,

2:08:47'cause I just didn't see them as being there.

2:08:51So, you know, I don't think it's a disappointing year

2:08:53for Mac hardware.

2:08:54I think what shows is that the single most important Mac,

2:08:59it's obvious, Apple doesn't have to tell us this,

2:09:02it's the MacBook Air.

2:09:03And it's a, you know, they got a great update

2:09:06to the MacBook Air out over the summer.

2:09:09I know firsthand, 'cause I had a high school senior

2:09:13last year, now college freshman,

2:09:16with lots of friends and, you know,

2:09:18including some friends who basically knew what I do

2:09:22and, you know, were like, hey, if you ask your dad,

2:09:24what should, you know, I'm thinking about waiting,

2:09:26you know, before the MacBook Airs were announced,

2:09:29I'm thinking about waiting to order a laptop for college,

2:09:33and I'd say, yeah, tell your friends to wait.

2:09:35'Cause, you know, everybody knew it was sort of coming,

2:09:37and then WWDC came and they announced it,

2:09:39and, you know, they hadn't even graduated yet.

2:09:42And they were like, oh, and then they were all, you know,

2:09:44it's just unbelievable how many times my son said to me,

2:09:47oh, and so-and-so just bought a MacBook Air,

2:09:49somebody else just bought their MacBook Air.

2:09:51They all bought MacBook Airs for college,

2:09:53so they got it out on time for the, you know, at least,

2:09:56I know that like for institutional education buyers,

2:09:59the buying schedule is earlier in the year.

2:10:02I think it's like more like April,

2:10:05where that's sort of the cutoff for the schools

2:10:08to budget for their purchase for next year.

2:10:10But for like individuals, and you know,

2:10:12it's like a rite of passage.

2:10:14You graduate high school, you go,

2:10:15if you're heading to college, you get a new laptop,

2:10:17maybe it's your graduation present, they hit that.

2:10:20And I, you know, all kudos to Apple.

2:10:22I think that was a very important milestone to hit.

2:10:27It's a weird time for Apple to ship Mac hardware.

2:10:30I can't remember many hardware introductions

2:10:34that were made at WWDC and were shipping soon, right?

2:10:37Like the- - Except for 2017, John.

2:10:40I still remember that they announced, what was it?

2:10:42All the new iMacs, all the new MacBook Airs, all the new,

2:10:45well, they were just spec bumped MacBook Pros.

2:10:48And we went into the, it was at the hotel,

2:10:51we went to the next hotel, and they're like,

2:10:53here are your review units.

2:10:54And you just like, I've got stuff to do.

2:10:55I can't take four computers with me, sorry.

2:10:58And I took them across the street to the hotel.

2:11:00- I do remember that.

2:11:03And I was like, how am I gonna get all this stuff home?

2:11:05I can't do this.

2:11:06So what else did happen?

2:11:10So March was the all new Mac Studio and Studio Display,

2:11:15new iPad Air, the new iPhone SE.

2:11:18- The green iPhone.

2:11:20- The green iPhones.

2:11:21I don't have strong opinions on the Mac Studio

2:11:23'cause it's not a machine for me.

2:11:25- I love it.

2:11:25- But the people I know who have it seem to really like it.

2:11:29The Mac Studio Display though, I do have,

2:11:32and absolutely love, it is up there.

2:11:35I would say my product of the year from Apple,

2:11:37it's probably a tie between the Mac Studio Display with,

2:11:41I splurged, I got maxed it out.

2:11:43I got the nano texture.

2:11:44- Nice.

2:11:45- Surface and the fancy $500 stand,

2:11:49I think it's 500, whatever it cost me.

2:11:51But I actually do use the adjustable stand.

2:11:53I move it up and down a little sometimes

2:11:56and it's a very nice stand.

2:11:58But the nano texture glass,

2:11:59I think I spoke about it on this show

2:12:01an episode or two ago, but it's unbelievably,

2:12:05I was about to say life changing,

2:12:07I guess not life changing, but.

2:12:08- Now if you're a Mac nerd and you've been waiting

2:12:11for something that has actually like pixels are on the grid,

2:12:14that's like all we wanted was a display

2:12:16where pixels are actually on the grid.

2:12:19- Well, but for me personally, in my home office

2:12:22with south facing windows, the nano texture

2:12:26is so unbelievably good at dealing with

2:12:30not just like oblique reflections or tough lighting,

2:12:35I mean like direct sunlight in every April

2:12:40and every October, that's the time of year

2:12:42where in the middle of the afternoon,

2:12:44my prime working hours, the sunlight streams in my window

2:12:47and is right on the display.

2:12:50And my only option literally

2:12:54before I had this nano texture display

2:12:56was to just take a break for an hour until the sun moved

2:13:00or which might mean pick up my MacBook

2:13:03and go upstairs to our kitchen or go somewhere else

2:13:07where I sit somewhere else.

2:13:08But I literally could not see the display.

2:13:11And because I had the review unit

2:13:14of the regular studio display with the glossy finish,

2:13:19in April, so the two times a year from my home office

2:13:22where the sunlight hits are April and October,

2:13:25in April I had the glossy one

2:13:27and I literally for about 90 minutes an afternoon

2:13:30on a sunny day, I could not use it.

2:13:33And by, I forget when my nano texture one arrived

2:13:38but sometime over the summer, June or July, I don't know,

2:13:41by the time October rolled around, I had it

2:13:44and there were times where I'd be like, wait,

2:13:46am I in, is this display in direct sunlight?

2:13:50And I'd hold my hand up like Indiana Jones

2:13:53testing the booby trap in Raiders of the Lost Ark.

2:13:56And yes, it is full on sunlight

2:13:58and I can still see the display with no reflection at all.

2:14:02It's just perfectly usable.

2:14:04Amazing, great product.

2:14:06- I bought one too.

2:14:07I had a review unit and I still bought one and I love it.

2:14:09The only thing I disagree about is I think they should have

2:14:12put the center stage camera in the iMac

2:14:15because I think that's much more of a family product

2:14:16where it would benefit from people getting up

2:14:18and walking around and putting it in liver

2:14:20and limbs and kitchens and put the 1080p webcam in here

2:14:22because I just, that camera is so bad.

2:14:26I've put a Canon Cine camera on top of it instead.

2:14:29I just covered it up with like an actual real camera

2:14:32because I couldn't take that camera anywhere.

2:14:34- I do not like the camera and I complained about it

2:14:39and it is what it is.

2:14:41I guess I see what Apple was thinking

2:14:44but like you said, I don't think that the market

2:14:46for a pro studio display, I know the word pro

2:14:50isn't in the studio display name

2:14:51but to me it's a pro product at pro prices.

2:14:54- And it goes with the studio, the Mac studio

2:14:56which is a pro device.

2:14:58- Right, it should have a camera whose number one goal

2:15:00is image quality for whatever their budget was.

2:15:03If they said here's our budget for the camera component,

2:15:06they should have optimized for image quality

2:15:08and if that meant that you had to sit still

2:15:10right in front of the center of the camera

2:15:12like you do with just about every other camera in the world,

2:15:15then I think that would be fine

2:15:17and would have been more appropriate for the product

2:15:19than to use this ultra wide angle camera

2:15:23with significantly lower image quality

2:15:26but because it's ultra wide angle supports center stage

2:15:29because it can crop wherever you are as you go around.

2:15:33I don't think that feature is appropriate for the product.

2:15:36Ideally you'd have both, right?

2:15:38It would be great to magically have center stage

2:15:41and amazing image quality

2:15:44but I feel like they made the wrong trade off there

2:15:46but I've moved past it by just I have an Opal C1.

2:15:50I don't do many video things but it is what it is.

2:15:54- You do them for me on occasion, I appreciate it.

2:15:56- I do, I do but I don't use my studio display.

2:16:00- No, the only other thing I'm really interested in

2:16:02is because it runs iOS,

2:16:04like it'd be better if it had Wi-Fi

2:16:05but even if it doesn't, it connects to a Mac and runs iOS

2:16:08is I'm hoping or I'm wondering if we'll get software updates

2:16:11for it the way that we get them for the AirPods

2:16:13because like before that headphones

2:16:14never got software updates

2:16:15and now we're almost used to getting

2:16:17yearly updates for our headphones

2:16:18and I wonder if at some point Apple's gonna say,

2:16:20here's an update that adds,

2:16:22I don't know if you have two studio displays,

2:16:23now it'll make them a paired like a speaker pairs

2:16:26or some kind of upgrade.

2:16:27- I wonder, I haven't gotten,

2:16:30I have not gotten a firmware update in months,

2:16:34many, many, many months.

2:16:36There were a couple earlier in the year

2:16:37but it seems like it settled down and it's been a while.

2:16:40The other thing that I ran into earlier,

2:16:42I forget if it ever happened once I got the nano texture,

2:16:44I think it happened at least once I got my personal one

2:16:47as opposed to the review unit that I sent back

2:16:50but there were problems early on

2:16:53in the first few months after it came out

2:16:55where your audio would get garbled

2:16:58and it was in fact a software problem

2:17:02on the iOS computer that is secretly embedded.

2:17:05A studio display is actually an iOS computer.

2:17:10- Yeah, it's like an iPad 7

2:17:11or something stuck inside the display.

2:17:13- Yeah, it really is.

2:17:14- Yeah, like the board.

2:17:16- And you don't actually use it like a computer,

2:17:20it's not enabled like a computer

2:17:22but it was somehow the audio subsystem on that computer

2:17:26would get garbled and the only way to fix it

2:17:29was to restart the computer

2:17:33but the only way to restart the computer

2:17:35because it has no power button

2:17:37was to yank the cable out of the wall

2:17:39or the socket wherever you have it plugged in

2:17:42which for me meant crawling down on my hands and knees

2:17:45so the second time I had to do it,

2:17:48I was like two strikes and you're out in my book,

2:17:50I'm not going down there again.

2:17:51So I bought a home kit.

2:17:54- That's what I did.

2:17:55- So I bought it, Murphy's Law worked perfectly.

2:18:00I spent, I don't know, 30, whatever they cost,

2:18:0330 or $35 to get the, I forget what brand,

2:18:06I don't know, whatever it's called.

2:18:09They sell them at the Apple stores.

2:18:11- Yeah.

2:18:12- It's nice, it works and now that I have it set up,

2:18:15I haven't had to use it.

2:18:16- Yeah.

2:18:17- But all I wanted to be able to do

2:18:18is instead of crawling on my hands and knees,

2:18:20just go into the home app, turn that socket off,

2:18:23turn it back on to restart the display

2:18:25without going down there but once I installed it,

2:18:27I've never had to use it so.

2:18:29- Same thing.

2:18:30- Murphy wins again.

2:18:32- Yeah.

2:18:33- What's next after, oh here it is,

2:18:36the Eve Energy Smart Plug and Power Eve, E-V-E.

2:18:41I can recommend it, I actually like the product a lot.

2:18:43It's $40 though, I'd have to say, it's more than $30.

2:18:46- Yeah.

2:18:47- So I spent $40 on a plug just to get Murphy's Law

2:18:51to kick in so I'd never need to unplug

2:18:52my studio display again.

2:18:54But anyway, great product. - We appreciate it.

2:18:56- I don't think there was much,

2:18:57I don't have much from Apple's calendar

2:18:59in between those product announcements in WWDC in June.

2:19:03- No, same, I was just looking again.

2:19:04It's like they did a lot of stuff.

2:19:05Like they sunsetted the iPod.

2:19:07- That is true. - That was in May, yeah.

2:19:11- That was sad.

2:19:12But you know, they had a good run.

2:19:14WWDC in hindsight, I guess what stands out

2:19:18is it was the first big thing that was back to real life

2:19:22and it was good to see.

2:19:24It'll be interesting to see, I presume,

2:19:27and I don't know anybody who's betting otherwise

2:19:29that this year's or next year's, I guess it still is,

2:19:332023's WWDC will be similar,

2:19:36where I do not believe that they're going to go back

2:19:39to the San Jose Convention Center

2:19:42and have in-person sessions.

2:19:44I think sessions, the week of content,

2:19:46the actual developer content,

2:19:48has forever moved towards these pre-recorded things.

2:19:52And I think everybody's happier that way.

2:19:54It sounds to me like my developer friends

2:19:56actually like them better.

2:19:57I think that it means that there are sessions,

2:19:59if there's a session with 16 minutes of content,

2:20:04it's a 16-minute session.

2:20:05It doesn't have to go to 30 because you need,

2:20:08like programming the physical conferences,

2:20:10like programming a TV network

2:20:13where everything has to be in half-hour increments.

2:20:16And you could have a 35-minute session

2:20:19and you could blow past the half-hour mark if you want to.

2:20:22It's very liberating.

2:20:24I think that the actual Apple employees who perform,

2:20:29for lack of a better word, the sessions,

2:20:31I think as people who are full-time engineers

2:20:36and not stage professionals,

2:20:40they're clearly so much more comfortable on camera

2:20:43than they are on stage.

2:20:45I mean, people, anybody who's ever spoke,

2:20:48I mean, famously, public speaking in front of a crowd

2:20:52is the number one phobia people have.

2:20:53And it makes all the sense in the world

2:20:55where evolutionarily we evolved to the point

2:20:58where if hundreds of people all have their attention on you,

2:21:02you are in terrible danger.

2:21:04- Yeah.

2:21:05- That's the way we evolved.

2:21:07- It was so much more error-prone too

2:21:08'cause everything was live.

2:21:09And there were some sessions where people were like walking

2:21:11and you'd hear the mic just scratching along their clothes

2:21:14or their hair the entire time.

2:21:15And because it was live,

2:21:16they couldn't do anything about it.

2:21:18These are all like beautifully produced.

2:21:19They can do multiple takes if they need to.

2:21:22They can do a lot of production value

2:21:23so it's so much better.

2:21:25Like mutual friend Alex Lindsay said,

2:21:27they're like, you start with online first

2:21:28and then you add the physical components.

2:21:31That just makes, it's so much better

2:21:32for everybody all over the world that way.

2:21:35- Yeah, it seems, so it seems win-win-win.

2:21:38Other than the camaraderie of being together for a week

2:21:42with your fellow developer friends and media people

2:21:45for the whole week, it's, you know,

2:21:47it, I don't, I'd be flabbergasted if it were to change,

2:21:52to be honest.

2:21:53Like a good amount of developers are like,

2:21:54we saw people like day after day after day.

2:21:57And the other thing I really liked

2:21:58because I went straight from WWDC to VidCon,

2:22:00which is a big, one of the big,

2:22:01like it's not run by YouTube,

2:22:03but it's like a lot of YouTubers and TikTokers

2:22:05and people there.

2:22:06This was before I joined YouTube.

2:22:08And like Apple was so conscientious about health and safety

2:22:11during that event that I did not see any headlines.

2:22:14Whereas like people were calling it COVIDCon by the end of,

2:22:17- Yeah, yeah.

2:22:18- By the end of the other one.

2:22:20It was just like such a stark difference

2:22:22in terms of like how considerate they were the entire time.

2:22:26- The only gamble is the rain, right?

2:22:30Is, 'cause Apple, one of the ways that Apple designed

2:22:33a very COVID friendly WWDC in June was that, you know,

2:22:38the seating for the keynote,

2:22:39the keynote was the big mass event, right?

2:22:41That's where there were, I don't know,

2:22:432000 people, something like that,

2:22:44or at least over a thousand.

2:22:46It was outdoors.

2:22:47So that's, you know, number one thing you can do

2:22:49to make something safer.

2:22:50The food and stuff like that was in their cafeteria,

2:22:54which has big doors that opened up.

2:22:56So it was still open air.

2:22:58In hindsight, it does seem like,

2:23:00I don't know anybody who thinks they caught COVID at WWDC.

2:23:03It doesn't seem to have been any kind of spreader.

2:23:06So I think that's a win.

2:23:07I think the only question I have going forward is,

2:23:10can they make it bigger?

2:23:11Can they invite more people?

2:23:13I mean, because there is,

2:23:15it is curious that it worked as well as it did.

2:23:18And speaking to some of the people at Apple

2:23:21who were involved in planning it,

2:23:24it really is the truth that that part of Apple Park

2:23:27was never designed with,

2:23:29what if we ever wanna host 1500 or 2000 outsiders

2:23:34for a live outdoor keynote outside the ring?

2:23:40It wasn't designed for that, but it worked great,

2:23:45you know, other than the fact that the sun was so bright

2:23:47that some people did get sunburned.

2:23:49You know, sunburn was the worst thing

2:23:50that seemed to happen from it.

2:23:51I don't know how much bigger they could get it though,

2:23:53given the limits of that lawn space there.

2:23:56- Yeah, and they gave out sunscreen and stuff

2:23:58in the little bags.

2:23:59Like it was, they tried their best and hats,

2:24:02and all sorts of things.

2:24:04- I met one fellow who,

2:24:06he says, and he is such a bad sunburn on half of his face.

2:24:10He really was like the Harvey Dent type sunburn.

2:24:14- Oh, Sam from iUpdate was bright red,

2:24:16like neon bright red.

2:24:18- Well, this guy was, and he was like,

2:24:20and I did, I used the sunscreen.

2:24:22I had it all over my face, and this still happened to me

2:24:24'cause he was Canadian, you know, he's very fair-skinned.

2:24:27It was unusually sunny for Cupertino,

2:24:30but the funny part is that if it had rained,

2:24:33there was no plan B.

2:24:34There is no canopy that would cover that.

2:24:37We would have all been soaked, I guess, I don't know.

2:24:39It rains infrequently enough in Cupertino

2:24:43that I guess it's worth taking the gamble,

2:24:47but everybody, I didn't get there.

2:24:48- Although it rains a lot when I'm there, Jon,

2:24:49and I think it's because I bring

2:24:50Canadian low pressure systems with me.

2:24:52- Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised.

2:24:54It does seem like something that would happen to you,

2:24:56but it did rain.

2:24:57I think it was the Friday before WWDC's Monday keynote.

2:25:00It rained pretty bad, and they were like, huh, this is,

2:25:03you know, this is what we were hoping would happen,

2:25:05but I would guess what we'll see this year

2:25:07is a replay of last year's.

2:25:08Maybe a little bigger,

2:25:09but I don't know how much bigger they can make it,

2:25:11but I think Apple considered it a success,

2:25:14and so I think it's probably the new model for WWDC.

2:25:17- And the developer center was an amazing addition

2:25:20to the whole system.

2:25:22- What else happened at WWDC?

2:25:24I mean, we don't have to rehash the software announcements.

2:25:27I do think, I guess the one thing I'll say

2:25:29about the software announcements is it does seem to me,

2:25:31I mean, again, this is kind of obvious to everybody

2:25:35that Apple has sort of, under Craig Federighi,

2:25:38has moved from a, all the major features come out

2:25:43in the integer .o update in the fall,

2:25:48and whether they're ready or not,

2:25:50or however buggy they are,

2:25:51and then we'll fix them as best we can until June,

2:25:54when we start it all over again with next year's thing.

2:25:57They have, you know, the first step under Federighi

2:26:00in recent years in terms of annualizing their schedule

2:26:05was just getting all of the platforms

2:26:08to have once a year updates, right?

2:26:09It wasn't that long ago when really only,

2:26:12you could only count on the iPhone

2:26:14getting a new .o integer OS update every year,

2:26:18and sometimes the Mac got one, and sometimes it didn't.

2:26:20I know many Mac fans would probably right now

2:26:24listening to me talk here are like,

2:26:26"Yeah, I wish they'd go back to that

2:26:28and take every year off and just let them bake for a while."

2:26:32- They're not often very big ones anymore.

2:26:34They're mostly just to keep up sync pace,

2:26:37but to make sure the apps can still sync between devices.

2:26:40- Yeah, I think so too.

2:26:42I think that you should take, you know,

2:26:44people who wish that they would take it slower and focus,

2:26:47spend more time focusing on bug fixes

2:26:50and rather than adding new stuff.

2:26:52I think that starting with, what was last year's?

2:26:56High Sierra?

2:26:57- This year's was Ventura, and last year was?

2:26:59- High Sierra.

2:27:00Well, I don't know the numbers,

2:27:02but when they first switched to Mac OS 11,

2:27:04when they broke out of the everything is 10 point what,

2:27:07and they redesigned the look of it, and they,

2:27:11Monterey, all right, so with Mac OS 11 Monterey,

2:27:14they gave it a whole new look,

2:27:16like a sort of a second attempt

2:27:18at the iOS 7 style interface for the Mac,

2:27:22and I would say going from 11 to 12,

2:27:25and now this just last week I upgraded my main machine

2:27:28from 12 to 13 when 13.1 came out.

2:27:32They're relatively minor, and that the features

2:27:36you're getting are things like Freeform, right,

2:27:38which they have to, I mean, I guess,

2:27:40you know, I say they have to, I guess they could come out

2:27:43with a version of the Freeform app

2:27:44that works on older Mac OS, but I get it

2:27:46why they gated to the OS, and so that they don't have,

2:27:51they're not launching this new thing

2:27:53that already has legacy compatibility things to worry about.

2:27:58I think it's worked pretty well, but to me,

2:27:59the second, so the first step was getting all

2:28:02of the major platforms to have a .0 every year

2:28:05to keep it running, and I think it's worked well

2:28:07and has kept them, you know, there's downsides

2:28:10to everything, but I think overall it is,

2:28:13it's made them more effective, but I think

2:28:16that the more recent change is a little more subtle,

2:28:20which is that they are just unabashedly unafraid

2:28:25to roll out these features that they might talk about

2:28:28in June, but not roll them out until December

2:28:31or January or February, right?

2:28:33App tracking transparency didn't ship

2:28:35until almost the other way around the calendar,

2:28:39you know, it was like April before it came out,

2:28:42and I also think that is much for the better.

2:28:45It's almost gotten them to the point,

2:28:48and again, it's Apple's going to be Apple,

2:28:50and they're gonna do things the Apple way,

2:28:53and if you're purely a web company,

2:28:57you know, YouTube, just to name a company

2:28:59you're familiar with, right?

2:29:00YouTube doesn't have to worry about version numbers

2:29:03outside, you know, nobody who's just going to YouTube

2:29:08to watch a video knows that they're on YouTube version

2:29:11whatever, there are no version numbers on a website.

2:29:13- And there's experiments, like you could be

2:29:14on a 10% experiment at any given time

2:29:16that looks pretty different than what everyone else

2:29:18is getting.

2:29:19- Right, or has different features or stuff like that,

2:29:22and even if it's just as subtle as taking away

2:29:25a thumbs down button, and they can roll it out

2:29:27and see how it works before rolling it out to everybody.

2:29:32Apple's got, in some ways, Apple's going to be Apple

2:29:35company culture-wise, and in other ways,

2:29:37Apple has to be a little different,

2:29:39because they're creating software that runs

2:29:41on your personal device, and that's a very different thing,

2:29:45you know, and it has upsides and downsides.

2:29:47I think, though, that this new schedule

2:29:49where major features show up in the dot one,

2:29:52and then the dot two, and then the dot three,

2:29:54and even the dot four later in the year

2:29:57has made those things so much more solid

2:30:01by the time we actually get our hands on them as users.

2:30:04- Yeah, I think, like, last year, you and I talked about

2:30:07the advantages and disadvantages of making them

2:30:09a roadmap announcement rather than a specific

2:30:11data announcement, where you have much more time

2:30:15to work on things versus you have the impetus

2:30:17to get things done, that maybe, like,

2:30:19having a deadline is still a really good thing,

2:30:21and I think they've gotten the best of both worlds now,

2:30:23where they come out and they say, "This is iOS,"

2:30:26and they have a set of things that they know

2:30:27they have to deliver, and they have, like,

2:30:29compatibility issues and all these different things,

2:30:31but they also can now stage things out

2:30:33and even introduce them so they get some time,

2:30:36so they can get their messaging out on it,

2:30:38and then they know the part they're gonna deliver

2:30:40on that day in September for the iPhone,

2:30:42October for the Mac and the iPad now,

2:30:45and then they've also said, "This is coming later

2:30:47in the year," or, "It's coming early next year,"

2:30:49and that gives them the ability to not have to,

2:30:51'cause previously they would just say,

2:30:52"Oh, it's delayed, it's delayed."

2:30:53That always looks bad, and this just lets them

2:30:55have a little bit more breathing

2:30:56with one of those announcements.

2:30:58- Yeah, I think they're more comfortable,

2:31:00and I think the features ship in better shape,

2:31:02and I think it's underappreciated how much,

2:31:06how good their software management must be

2:31:11to keep rolling, to keep that annual train rolling

2:31:16and not get around to the point where,

2:31:20I don't think it's any surprise that probably

2:31:22come January, February, an ever-growing number of engineers

2:31:26will be working on next year's systems,

2:31:29not this year's systems, but an awful lot of them

2:31:32will be working on still-upcoming features

2:31:34for this year's systems.

2:31:36- Yeah, I mean, they start right after they announce,

2:31:38they start putting, they have that big pile on Craig's desk

2:31:40to figure out what comes next.

2:31:43It's a machine, but it's, and also I think,

2:31:46unless you go to the developer sessions

2:31:47or you watch the developer stuff,

2:31:49you don't appreciate how much under-the-cover features

2:31:51and changes occur every year as well,

2:31:53which is like, you'll see the features,

2:31:54or you'll go, oh, there's not as many features.

2:31:56Then you start looking through the presentations,

2:31:57and there's almost always significant changes

2:32:01under the covers that take a lot of work

2:32:03to deliver every year.

2:32:04- Yeah, I agree, so I, you know, kudos to Apple.

2:32:07It's a good year for the software, I think,

2:32:10and I think the schedule is settling.

2:32:12No, I think it's sort of the new normal now,

2:32:14and I appreciate it.

2:32:15That brings us to September.

2:32:16That was the third event that they held.

2:32:19That was the iPhone introduction event.

2:32:20iPhones 14 and 14 Pro.

2:32:23- Did you wanna, were you okay with just,

2:32:25with the MacBook Air, 'cause that was dubbed up,

2:32:27but I think we talked about it earlier.

2:32:28- Oh, yeah. - And the MacBook Pro,

2:32:29the MacBook Pro 13-inch that got a new chip.

2:32:32- The, yeah, I guess that counts as WWDC.

2:32:35I guess we should, you know, I think it's a great product.

2:32:37I'm about to buy one for a family member.

2:32:41- Same.

2:32:42- I don't wanna say who, just in case somebody's listening.

2:32:44I don't wanna spoil it, but yeah.

2:32:46I don't have much to say other than that it is the,

2:32:50it, in how, you know, six months later,

2:32:52it's exactly the MacBook Air I wanted Apple to build.

2:32:56You know, it is super thin.

2:32:57It is, it runs cool, has a beautiful screen.

2:33:01You know, I don't really have much to add

2:33:03other than, you know, how I reviewed it,

2:33:05but I feel like my review stands up.

2:33:07I think it's a home run, and I think it's a form factor

2:33:10that will suit the product for a happy number of years

2:33:13going forward.

2:33:15- I agree.

2:33:16I also think that, I think one of the biggest problems

2:33:17with it, though, was the review cycle,

2:33:18because we had a bunch of people who decided

2:33:21they wanted to review it as if it was a Mac Pro,

2:33:23maybe just because it had Apple Silicon in it,

2:33:25and it doesn't have a fan.

2:33:27Like, this product is not designed to be a MacBook Pro,

2:33:30and they would complain that it would hit

2:33:32the thermal envelope and ramp down,

2:33:34when that is exactly what it was designed

2:33:36and intended to do, because people who, like,

2:33:38people like me who wanna, like, make big video projects,

2:33:41we have MacBook Pros because we can run them full out

2:33:44for 20 minutes, an hour, an hour and a half.

2:33:46On a MacBook Air, it's mostly documents work,

2:33:48and if the processor can launch up and then ramp down

2:33:52when it needs to, like, you're opening your app super fast,

2:33:54you're, like, opening your web pages super fast.

2:33:57That's not a design flaw that's working as intended,

2:33:59so I was just depressed with a lot of the review cycle

2:34:02around the MacBook Air.

2:34:03- Yeah, I do, I, you know,

2:34:05but I feel like anybody who read those reviews

2:34:09and was nodding their head in agreement,

2:34:12even though I'm not sure that's,

2:34:14I'm with you that it wasn't the fairest way

2:34:18to measure the MacBook Air,

2:34:20but at least I think the people who'd read them

2:34:23and say, "Yeah, I agree with this reviewer,"

2:34:26well, then, if your conclusion is that you should buy

2:34:28a MacBook Pro instead, like, probably the real MacBook Pros

2:34:31in the 14 or 16-inch size, then, yeah,

2:34:34that's probably what you knew beforehand.

2:34:37I mean, if you magically thought you were gonna get

2:34:39a 14-inch MacBook Pro at a lower price

2:34:43and a thinner form factor,

2:34:45it, you know, I don't know what you were thinking,

2:34:49because obviously the MacBook Pros from last year,

2:34:53at the end of 2021, were all new form factors,

2:34:56so if they could have been thinner,

2:34:57they would have been thinner.

2:34:58- Yes. - So, you know.

2:34:59- Yeah, you're trading that for the thermal envelope

2:35:01and the fan and all that.

2:35:03- Right, I guess what we, you know,

2:35:04what I could say in hindsight about the MacBook Air

2:35:06before we move on is that now we see what Apple Silicon

2:35:09can do to a laptop form factor, right?

2:35:12- Yes. - What it can enable.

2:35:13As opposed to putting it into a husk

2:35:17that was designed for Intel.

2:35:19You know, here's how much thinner it can be.

2:35:21And, you know, it's not crazy thin.

2:35:22It's not like something from Westworld

2:35:24that's just a credit card, you know, level of thickness.

2:35:27You know, it's, Apple Silicon is very good,

2:35:30but it's not, it's not that good.

2:35:31- It doesn't break the laws of physics.

2:35:33- Not yet, but. - No, give 'em time.

2:35:36- Yeah, all right, September, all new iPhones, iPhone 14s.

2:35:40The new AirPods Pro, that would be my second product

2:35:45that I would perhaps hold up

2:35:46as the Apple product of the year.

2:35:48I love the second generation AirPods Pro as a pedestrian.

2:35:52- You do right now.

2:35:53- I lost mine or misplaced them recently

2:35:59and Find My didn't help, and so I went back to my,

2:36:03well, no, it was only for an afternoon,

2:36:04but I needed to run an errand,

2:36:05so I grabbed my original AirPods Pro and went out

2:36:10and as a pedestrian in the city, got to a, you know,

2:36:13immediate A/B test going back

2:36:14to the older noise cancellation.

2:36:16- Yeah, yeah. - And I was like,

2:36:17I can't hear, I can't hear anything.

2:36:19- I know. - I can't hear anything

2:36:20when a car goes by. - Yeah, it's hard to go back.

2:36:21- What else, three new Apple watches,

2:36:23including the Apple Watch Ultra.

2:36:25- Sorry, do you have like a, in hindsight now,

2:36:27we lost the Mini but got the Plus.

2:36:30- Do I have thoughts on that?

2:36:32- Yeah. - Yeah, I'm sad.

2:36:34I'm sad, I wish that they would just do all three sizes

2:36:37for all three devices, you know.

2:36:39I wish that there were,

2:36:41I wish they made-- - Six by far every year.

2:36:43- Yeah, I wish they did six,

2:36:44Pro and not Pro at the Mini, regular,

2:36:48and either call it Plus or call it Max size,

2:36:51but I understand why they don't

2:36:53and everybody, by all accounts,

2:36:55the Mini really did sell disappointingly.

2:36:57- Yeah. - So I get it,

2:36:59but boy, when I see somebody who has a Mini,

2:37:03I still think, wow, that is an awesome looking iPhone.

2:37:06And so it makes me a little sad, but I don't blame 'em.

2:37:08What about you?

2:37:09- My hot take is that the Mini,

2:37:11people really loved it who were stuck at computers all day

2:37:13and when they left their computer,

2:37:16and maybe they had three or four computers,

2:37:17and when they left it, the last thing they wanted

2:37:18was another full-on computer.

2:37:20So it was great to just have a phone

2:37:22that could still do everything.

2:37:23But for a lot of people in the world,

2:37:25that's their only or their primary computer

2:37:26and they just want the biggest screen possible

2:37:28to do as many things as they can on.

2:37:30So the bigger ones just outsell,

2:37:32vastly outsell the smaller ones.

2:37:34- Yeah, so it is what it is.

2:37:37It's pour one out for the iPhone 13 Mini,

2:37:41which I really do think will be the last Mini.

2:37:44Because I also think that the rumors,

2:37:48it makes all the sense in the world

2:37:49that the next iPhone SE is not going to be based

2:37:52on the Mini, it'll be based on the iPhone 10R/iPhone 11

2:37:57non-pro with the thicker bezel, the regular LCD screen,

2:38:03LED, not OLED, whatever you call it.

2:38:06- Retina.

2:38:07- Liquid Retina.

2:38:08It makes all the sense in the world

2:38:10'cause it's also a more one-size-fits-all size

2:38:14where it's a little bigger than the regular iPhones,

2:38:18but it's not the, you're gonna have to pay

2:38:21some sort of premium to get a plus-size phone.

2:38:24- There was four years before the other SEs,

2:38:25so four years between this

2:38:27and the new design makes sense anyway.

2:38:30- Apple Watch Ultra, I continue to see more of them

2:38:32in the wild, I forget his name, Greg,

2:38:35I forget his surname, but he was the coach

2:38:37of the US men's national team.

2:38:39He was wearing one throughout the US men's team run

2:38:43at the World Cup.

2:38:44And I, you know, I noticed, I've always--

2:38:47It's, everybody, you know, and at least all the downsides

2:38:52are so obvious.

2:38:53What's the downside?

2:38:54Well, it is more expensive, you know that,

2:38:56it starts at $800, and it's big, and it's thick

2:39:00compared to all the other Apple Watches.

2:39:03And you know that, so if you go to the store

2:39:05and you try it on, and you're like, I'm cool,

2:39:06I actually, you know, many people prefer the bigger size,

2:39:10and other people who may not prefer it,

2:39:12but are like, I'm fine with it,

2:39:13but I want the extra battery life,

2:39:15I want this slightly bigger screen, you know?

2:39:18People I know, I don't know, I know several friends

2:39:21who've purchased one, and I don't know anybody

2:39:22who regrets it, 'cause I think you know

2:39:24what you're getting into. - So a mutual friend,

2:39:26Georgia Dow, she bought one, and she had the smallest

2:39:29Apple Watch, and she wore it intermittently,

2:39:31but she's been wearing the Apple Watch Ultra all the time,

2:39:34and she dives, she dives with sharks,

2:39:36which still flabbergasts me.

2:39:38And for her, it's better than renting a dive watch,

2:39:41'cause she can use it for everything else as well.

2:39:43So what I loved was when Justine interviewed Cayenne,

2:39:47and you see the Apple Watch Ultra on both of their wrists,

2:39:49and you're just like, yeah, the size

2:39:51doesn't matter that much anymore.

2:39:52- Yeah, I thought that even at the hands-on area

2:39:54after the introduction, I know you weren't there,

2:39:56but you know how those hands-on areas are often,

2:40:00well, they are, they're manned by, staffed by people

2:40:03from Apple product marketing, and when I got my hands-on

2:40:06time with the Apple Watch, it was with a woman

2:40:08who had very, very petite wrists,

2:40:12but she was wearing one today, and I was like,

2:40:14that looks fine.

2:40:15And she was like, yeah, I've had one on for a while,

2:40:17and it takes a little getting used to,

2:40:20'cause it's a little surprising if you're going

2:40:22from the smaller Apple Watch all the way to this one.

2:40:25But yeah, women can, women, the small-wristed among us

2:40:30can get away with it if they want to,

2:40:31and like I wrote in my review,

2:40:33don't overthink it, you know.

2:40:35It's easy to get self-conscious,

2:40:37'cause you're looking at your wrist,

2:40:38and this thing looks so big on your wrist,

2:40:41nobody else is gonna think that person

2:40:43is wearing a goofily large watch.

2:40:45It's a great idea.

2:40:47- It goes for days, and there's so much stuff.

2:40:49- I'm curious where they go.

2:40:51I would like to see my one wish for next year

2:40:53with Ultra 2 would be if they offer it in the dark as well,

2:40:57space gray, space black, call it what you want,

2:41:00but make a black one or a dark gray one too

2:41:03to go along with the natural titanium color.

2:41:06- Make the Batman version of the watch, that's all I want.

2:41:08- What else do we have here?

2:41:09We gotta wrap this up.

2:41:11- Yes, there's gonna be next year.

2:41:14- Yeah, we have, and then I guess what,

2:41:15the last hardware announcements of the year

2:41:17were the new iPads from October,

2:41:19which we sort of talked about already,

2:41:21so, you know, and we're just, you know,

2:41:24the regular iPad goes to the iPad Air style,

2:41:27and you know, right on time, I don't,

2:41:30it's hard as somebody who's more interested

2:41:33at the very high end of the market

2:41:36for all of Apple's devices to really pour myself into it,

2:41:39but I'm glad that the people in the market

2:41:42for a $400-ish iPad have the option to join

2:41:47the, you know, modern interface world.

2:41:50- Edge to edge world, yeah.

2:41:51- The edge to edge world.

2:41:53- Yeah, same, same.

2:41:55And the other thing that I forgot that impressed me

2:41:57was I don't know when it's coming out,

2:41:58but the new CarPlay looked pretty good to me.

2:42:01- Ah, from WWDC?

2:42:03- Yeah, I just saw a picture of it.

2:42:05- Yeah, that's an interesting question going forward

2:42:08because of the way Apple teased that at WWDC,

2:42:11where they sort of made it seem,

2:42:14coming out of the keynote, we all thought,

2:42:15wow, that's an impressive list of people,

2:42:18of car companies who are on board with this already,

2:42:21but then it turns out that that was really

2:42:23a little bit of sleight of hand where it was,

2:42:25these are the car companies making CarPlay-compatible cars,

2:42:30not necessarily who've already signed on

2:42:32to do the new CarPlay, you know,

2:42:35with the dashboard spanning multiple display,

2:42:38take advantage of whatever crazy irregular shapes

2:42:42the car maker might make the displays in their dashboard.

2:42:47But, you know, why not support it?

2:42:49I don't know, I think CarPlay's been successful enough

2:42:52and Apple has seemingly, again, I asked at my live show

2:42:56with Jaws and Federighi, I thought,

2:42:59it's probably my best joke of the year,

2:43:01was something to the effect of how to, you know,

2:43:04it's almost as though you guys are making a car

2:43:06or something like that, I forget what I said.

2:43:07- Yeah, that was great.

2:43:08- But alluding to the fact-- - It's almost as good

2:43:09when you asked them how much the wheels would cost

2:43:10and they asked you how many you wanted.

2:43:11- Right, that was pretty good, that was pretty good.

2:43:13Yeah, yeah, you know, for a company that is rumored

2:43:16to be getting into the car business themselves

2:43:18and has been for years, they've clearly done,

2:43:21in my opinion, a very good job of getting a broad-away array

2:43:25of car makers to support CarPlay about as well

2:43:28as you could hope that it supported.

2:43:30- Yeah, and my understanding is they're gonna work

2:43:32with them to customize this a lot,

2:43:34so it's gonna be very, like, geared into each individual car

2:43:37that they make the deals for.

2:43:39- Right, other than that, though, you know,

2:43:41let's call it a year.

2:43:42See you next year, Rene.

2:43:43Anyway, congratulations on your big year.

2:43:46Thank you so much, as ever, for your time today

2:43:49and for doing this show, which is--

2:43:52- Anytime. - Long, long,

2:43:53but I think we brought it home.

2:43:55We brought it home with fuel left in the tank.

2:43:58- Yes, we left them wanting just a little bit more.

2:44:01- Just a little bit more.

2:44:02Maybe I'll bet, I wouldn't be surprised,

2:44:05I would not be surprised, conversely,

2:44:06if 2022 was a light year for Apple hardware announcements

2:44:11because of COVID, maybe, you know,

2:44:13I could see 2023 going both ways,

2:44:15where it still might be affected

2:44:17because their product runways are that long,

2:44:20or it might be, though, that things that were supposed

2:44:23to have already come out start coming out anyway, right?

2:44:25So they might be behind where they wanted to have been,

2:44:30but will be busy anyway

2:44:32because stuff that had been postponed is now ready.

2:44:34So I wouldn't be surprised-- - Yeah, it's like traffic.

2:44:36- A year from now. - It's like,

2:44:37or an accordion, it compresses and expands.

2:44:39It's not like a linear thing.

2:44:40- Right, I would not be surprised if next, come next year,

2:44:43we have much more to talk about hardware-wise.

2:44:45Anyway, I will also lastly thank our sponsors.

2:44:47We had Squarespace, Make Your Next Move with a new website,

2:44:51Trade Coffee, where you can get incredible coffee

2:44:54delivered fresh, including, as a last-minute gift idea,

2:44:57Collide is a cross-platform endpoint security solution

2:45:02for teams that value privacy, and last but not least,

2:45:07oh, Memberful, of course, where you can monetize

2:45:09your passion with membership.

2:45:10Thank you, Renee.