0:00:00I never know where Caleb's gonna jump in, but I presume it'll be around now.
0:00:04I do feel, I do feel it's very important that wherever we start to show it's my
0:00:08voice, because I do feel like if it's yours, half, at least half,
0:00:12that's true.
0:00:13That's true.
0:00:13At least half of our listeners are going to be confused and believe that they've
0:00:18screwed up.
0:00:18Hostile takeover, John.
0:00:19Right.
0:00:20Actually a fairly large segment of them will probably, would, would, if your voice
0:00:24came first, probably think it was due to a bug in overcast.
0:00:31It's true.
0:00:31Um, all right.
0:00:33So yeah, you can lead in however you would like.
0:00:36I mean, uh, the airing is a stretch, but, but no, I think I have a little something
0:00:41to warm us up, but if, however you want to lead in, I'm happy to roll with.
0:00:44Oh, I figured we're already rolling.
0:00:46Oh, okay.
0:00:48Oh, well, here we go.
0:00:49Well, whatever's in the show is in the show.
0:00:51Tell me your story.
0:00:51Okay.
0:00:52So I was thinking about how, you know, we've known each other, uh, for a fair bit
0:00:57of time now, probably about 10 years now, I would say, and, and I like to think of
0:01:01us as friends and, and I was thinking about why is it that, you know, I haven't
0:01:04been asked to be on the talk show.
0:01:06And it occurred to me early on when I started following your work, you know, I
0:01:10remember hearing you talk about the three keys to success, and this is off the top
0:01:13of my head, so I might be flubbing it, but I believe the three keys to success as a,
0:01:17as a blogger or an independent person is, and jump in when you're ready, John, fussy
0:01:22coffee, a clickety keyboard, clickety-clackety keyboard, and just obscenely
0:01:28carbonated water.
0:01:29And it occurred to me that I don't personally care for any of those things,
0:01:33but I thought, you know what?
0:01:34I don't know if that's the actual issue here.
0:01:37I think the actual issue here might be that in, in, I haven't had the pleasure of
0:01:42catching a drink with you or your delightful wife, Amy Jane, in far too long.
0:01:46But if I recall correctly, you are a gin martini kind of guy.
0:01:49And I am not.
0:01:51And I was wondering, John, if this is the crux of the disagreement here.
0:01:54That's a good opening.
0:01:57It is.
0:01:57It's fine.
0:01:58And in no particular order in, in HTML parlance, it's an unordered list.
0:02:02Fussy coffee, extremely carbonated water, and a clicky keyboard.
0:02:07I do enjoy a gin martini.
0:02:09I think you are misremembering now.
0:02:11Oh, okay.
0:02:12So I'm, I'm, I am, I forget how you put it in religious terms.
0:02:17I'm going to say agnostic, but there's a better word and it's not coming to mind.
0:02:22But I am the rare person who, who is an aficionado and greatly enjoy a very nice,
0:02:28very cold martini before a nice meal.
0:02:31But I will accept both gin and vodka martini.
0:02:36The, but the issue is that Amy does not care for gin.
0:02:41And, uh, therefore I just generally let her order first and then I say, I'll have
0:02:48what she's having so as to avoid any chance of any confusion because I don't care.
0:02:51Mm hmm.
0:02:53Now this drives the gin martini people nuts.
0:02:56You know, the gin martini people are like the Catholics.
0:03:00Because, no, this is true.
0:03:03It is true.
0:03:04It's they're, they're like the Catholics because that was the original.
0:03:08That's the old school.
0:03:09They're angrier and you know, they're big thing.
0:03:12And they're already, the people out there who are listening, who are, who believe
0:03:16that a martini should only be made with gin will also say that you don't have,
0:03:19there is no such thing as a quote unquote gin martini, that a martini by definition
0:03:24is and only made with gin, not vodka.
0:03:28And that a vodka martini, they won't, they, they won't even, they don't even like it
0:03:32when you say vodka martini as a separate drink, they like to say that it's called,
0:03:36I forget, there's a name.
0:03:37Oh yes.
0:03:38I know what you're thinking of and I can't remember what it is either now.
0:03:40Yeah.
0:03:41But from their perspective, it might as well be called a stinky head.
0:03:44You know, I will, I will enjoy both.
0:03:49I believe, you know, I'm open-minded.
0:03:51There is, I hope it's still available.
0:03:53I will, I'm making a note right now.
0:03:55I swear to God in the show notes, there is a wonderful, wonderful website called
0:04:00the martini FAQ FAQ and it is, it's so old school internet.
0:04:07I know I've linked to it from daring fireball at least once.
0:04:09I hope it's still online, but it is written by someone who I believe is much
0:04:14more of a gin martini aficionado than vodka, but he keeps, he's, he has a very
0:04:21open mind about the whole, the whole thing and gets into also the other religious
0:04:25aspect of how much, how much vermouth should be put into a martini.
0:04:30Which your answer is, I'm a Churchill man that you should pick up a bottle of vermouth
0:04:36and wave it in the direction of Italy.
0:04:38That is exactly the right answer in my personal opinion.
0:04:43Just, just get it somewhere near the shaker.
0:04:45And I am satisfied with that.
0:04:46You probably know this cause you've been with us and you've met my wife and, but
0:04:51she, she is, I'm not making this up.
0:04:53She is a vodka supertaster.
0:04:55Ah, interesting.
0:04:57Okay.
0:04:57So what is her vodka of choice then?
0:04:59Belvedere and Grey Goose.
0:05:00She, she, she likes both.
0:05:02She does not care for yours, which is Tito's.
0:05:05She does not care for kettle one at all, which she believes tastes Tito's like.
0:05:10And she also, you know, and what she like, cause you can go somewhere and you'll say,
0:05:17like, I would like a Belvedere martini up with a twist and it should be made with
0:05:21Belvedere and then, you know, occasionally at a lesser establishment, they might make
0:05:25it with, you know, they might just tell the bartender vodka martini and then they
0:05:29make it with something else.
0:05:31And she, she she'll take one sip and just say, ah, jet fuel.
0:05:35See, that's me with gin.
0:05:38And I was hoping as much as I'm snarking on, on the gin believers, but I was hoping
0:05:43you could maybe teach me either verbally or the next time we have the pleasure of
0:05:46being around each other, teach me how to like gin cause it tastes like grass to me.
0:05:51Like I just, I can't do it.
0:05:52It's just, I find it so, so gross and I want to be able to like it.
0:05:58I want to be more ambivalent about the particular kind of martini I'm having.
0:06:02And so I, I, I have the desire, but I don't yet have the skill to consume a gin
0:06:09martini and maybe one day I'll get there.
0:06:11That seems to be the argument.
0:06:13You know, again, I'm not religious about it.
0:06:15You know, I have what you like.
0:06:17Oh, the martini fact is still up.
0:06:18Thank God.
0:06:19I will absolutely 100% put this in the show notes.
0:06:22No, no joke about it because it's so wonderful.
0:06:25I hesitate even to link it to you now in the chat because you'll, you'll become
0:06:30consumed by it.
0:06:31It's so good.
0:06:31So you'll have to wait.
0:06:33Oh, but the basic argument from the gin aficionados is that gin, gin is a
0:06:37flavorful, what would you call it?
0:06:39A beverage, a spirit, a spirit, a spirit.
0:06:42That's it.
0:06:43And vodka deliberately is sort of anti-flavorful, you know, to me, I've
0:06:48often described a perfect vodka martini as tasting like an ice cold cloud.
0:06:54Very, very well put.
0:06:56I agree.
0:06:56No, I don't know.
0:06:57I, I, I, I, honestly, the reason you haven't been on the show is I forget, I
0:07:01forget about you.
0:07:02No, that's, that's okay.
0:07:03I, I, I serve that role and I serve it proudly.
0:07:07So that is no problem at all.
0:07:08Really.
0:07:08That was just an excuse to talk about martinis because I feel like we need, we
0:07:12it's, it's talk show like rules that we talk about something completely
0:07:17unrelated to tech.
0:07:18I did go see a baseball game last summer, so we can fulfill the baseball quota.
0:07:22If you'd like very quickly but I don't have a lot to say about baseball.
0:07:26So I was trying to find some common ground that we could work through that
0:07:29isn't tech.
0:07:30Well, we have so much we could do.
0:07:32We could do clicky keyboards.
0:07:34I'm back on my Apple extended keyboard too.
0:07:37Now you might've seen this.
0:07:39We're on at least one Slack together, but I haven't been using an external
0:07:43because we want to talk.
0:07:44One of the things I'll spoiler here, we're going to talk about the Apple
0:07:46studio display.
0:07:47We could get into it.
0:07:49But one of the other things that I do a kid, I kid about forgetting about you,
0:07:53but one of the things that I sympathize with is that your vision is less than
0:07:57perfect.
0:07:57And oftentimes, you know, and I think Marco, I think as far as pretty good
0:08:04vision for his age and, and maybe, maybe Syracuse is in the middle, but oftentimes
0:08:08when talking about things that you can notice visually, et cetera, you know, I
0:08:12sympathize and that's part of it.
0:08:13But long story short, I from, I, I always forget about,
0:08:19I forget, this is one of those things as you get older, the years blur together.
0:08:22I forget if my iMac 5k was a 2014 or 2015 purchase.
0:08:26I'm going to say 2015, but from 2015 until like July, 2019, my desktop computer
0:08:35was an iMac 5k.
0:08:36So I'm very familiar with the 5k 27 inch, you know, display panel.
0:08:41And my keyboard was my beloved Apple extended keyboard to hooked up, you know,
0:08:47the ADB to USB adapter.
0:08:49I forget what happened first, but at the end of 2019, we had some renovations at
0:08:56the house, including completely renovating my office, which before renovation was
0:09:02really just a room with white walls and nothing in it and just a desk in the
0:09:06corner.
0:09:07And actually was sort of our depot for a bunch of boxes that we'd never finished
0:09:12moving when we moved into this place.
0:09:14It was really, it did not look like an office.
0:09:17It looked like more like a basement somehow with windows.
0:09:20But we had a wonderful, we really, it's just a great experience and timed
0:09:24perfectly before they finished up literally just by coincidence, right before
0:09:29the unfortunate incidents of early 2020 hit.
0:09:32But I had to, while they were renovating, pack up everything, get out of my office
0:09:37so that they could build the nice office that I have now with built in shelves and
0:09:41a built in desk.
0:09:42And if you've ever seen me on occasionally on CNBC or some sort of YouTube, like
0:09:50Renee's YouTube channel or something, there's these nice slatted walls along the
0:09:55one side or at my annual talk show from WWDC the last two years, which have been
0:09:59conducted remotely.
0:10:00It's, in my opinion, very nice looking office, but it had to be done.
0:10:04So I had to get out.
0:10:04And so I packed up the iMac 5k.
0:10:06Well, shortly thereafter, at that point, I had my second retinal detachment in my
0:10:11other eye from my first one was back in, I believe again, conflating 2014, 2015, I
0:10:18think 2014 or 2015.
0:10:20And the other problem I had, this is true, was in my good eye, which did not have a
0:10:26retinal detachment in August of 2019.
0:10:28I that's the one that had a retinal detachment years before that was repaired
0:10:33wonderfully.
0:10:33And it truly put me into the 99th percentile of recovery from how bad it was.
0:10:39But I had a cataract.
0:10:42You've just had a series of hits when it comes to your eyes.
0:10:45It's, you know, and they're possibly related.
0:10:48There's some correlation between people who've heard of cataracts at a bizarrely
0:10:52young age.
0:10:53Cause cataracts typically are only really a problem for people in this, in their
0:10:57seventies.
0:10:58And I was only in my forties.
0:10:59Long story short, I needed to be very close to a screen to see it.
0:11:02And so I do, I forget what happened first, me packing up the iMac for the
0:11:07renovation or having a retinal detachment and in the aftermath of it while
0:11:11recovering, needing to be pretty close to a screen, like too close to use desktop
0:11:15display anyway.
0:11:16So I have been, that's my way of saying due to vision problems and renovations and
0:11:21then COVID, using a MacBook Pro of some sort as my entire Macintosh since like the
0:11:30middle of 2019.
0:11:32In other words, I had no external display, no external keyboard and haven't.
0:11:36And now my vision has gotten much better and it's, it's, you know, again, I don't
0:11:39want to go into the details of it, but my combined vision from the two eyes has
0:11:42really gotten better.
0:11:43It continues to improve.
0:11:44It's, it's, and I can definitely use a 27 inch display in front of me and see it
0:11:51very well.
0:11:52But I didn't hook my iMac back up like, and that's sort of like a 2021 thing where
0:11:58my vision got to that point where, Hey, I can actually do this.
0:12:00Where I noticed it the first time was when I was testing, reviewing the iMac
0:12:0524 inch last year.
0:12:06I was like, Hey crap, I can see this.
0:12:09This is, this is actually, you know, that was the first, cause I just don't see, I
0:12:13don't, you know, I don't go anywhere.
0:12:15It certainly didn't go anywhere during COVID.
0:12:16So it's like, I, you know, there was a while early on in the COVID time where I
0:12:21really just needed to be sort of hunched over and being closer to a MacBook screen
0:12:26to see it clearly.
0:12:27Then I tested that iMac.
0:12:28I was like, Hey, if I use these glasses, I can see this just fine.
0:12:32This is great.
0:12:33But what was I going to do?
0:12:34Right?
0:12:34Now this leads us to the great external display dilemma of Mac users, right?
0:12:39I didn't want to buy a 24 inch iMac for myself.
0:12:42I wanted something bigger and better and really didn't want an iMac.
0:12:46I really wanted to go full on with a MacBook pro as my one and only one true
0:12:51Mac, and then have standalone desktop display to connect it to.
0:12:56But what the hell was I going to buy a year ago?
0:12:59Oh yeah.
0:13:00And it was a mess.
0:13:01It was an absolute mess.
0:13:02And so my brief history with this was back in 2016 my last, you know, regular
0:13:08full-time job, I was doing iOS development for a local firm and I wanted to get one
0:13:14or more external monitors and I wanted something that is considered retina.
0:13:17And, you know, retina is kind of a marketing term and it means different
0:13:21things to different people, depending on who you ask.
0:13:23But generally speaking, you know, in the history is, you know, from what was it?
0:13:28The iPhone four, where that went and it doubled the pixel density and Apple
0:13:32said, Oh, look at this retina screen.
0:13:33And then it came to the MacBook pro and, and eventually to the iMac and, and
0:13:38well, actually the iMac pro as well.
0:13:39So it's this idea that you basically get just incredibly, incredibly crisp
0:13:44displays by having just tremendous amount of resolution in a not
0:13:48tremendously oversized screen.
0:13:51And in 2017, I was looking for an external monitor and I started looking at,
0:13:56okay, well, what's available.
0:13:58And around the same time, Mark Edwards was looking into the same thing and he
0:14:03came up with kind of a list of options.
0:14:05And I went through his list and came to the conclusion that there's basically
0:14:09in 2017, there were only five options.
0:14:12And it was the two LG ultra finds a couple of Dells and an LG, just
0:14:18unremarkable LG 4k monitor.
0:14:19And what I ended up doing was we tried at work.
0:14:22We tried to get one of these 5k Dells if memory serves and it arrived
0:14:27DOA for whatever reason.
0:14:28And so we said, ah, the heck with it.
0:14:30It was really expensive anyway.
0:14:31And so what we got, I ended up with one and then eventually a second, very
0:14:35unremarkable, it was like 300 bucks.
0:14:374k monitor, the LG 24 UD 58-B rolls right off the tongue.
0:14:42And so that was 2017, John.
0:14:44It's a wonderful day, but really it's just delightful.
0:14:47It's like, it's like, it's like LG outsourced their naming to Sony.
0:14:51Right.
0:14:52It's so true.
0:14:53Yeah.
0:14:53What is it?
0:14:54The WH 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 or whatever that everyone loves the headphones.
0:14:57So that was 2017.
0:14:59And at that point at home, I had either an iMac or nine, I
0:15:01think it was a regular 5k iMac.
0:15:03Eventually I got the iMac pro.
0:15:04And then in roughly November of last year, I decided to go all in on, on Apple
0:15:10Silicon and I got an M1 max, a 14 inch MacBook pro, which I adore.
0:15:16I cannot tell you how much I love this thing.
0:15:18It is just one of the, if not the best computer I've ever owned in my life.
0:15:22But Hey, I'd like to hook it up to something.
0:15:25So here it is in December of last year, I started surveying the situation again.
0:15:30And I started looking around and I realized, well, Dell has discontinued
0:15:34their two reasonable monitors, which leaves us with the aforementioned 24UD58-B,
0:15:41which is the $300 4k LG, the LG Ultrafine 4k, the LG Ultrafine 5k, and the Pro Display
0:15:48XDR, which cost as much as my darn computer and that's without a stand.
0:15:52And so it occurred to me like, this is a mess.
0:15:55This is an absolute mess.
0:15:57How is it that Apple is just completely ignoring consumer level needs in this regard?
0:16:04It just boggled my mind.
0:16:06And so I wrote a post about it, which you were kind enough to link to.
0:16:09And as of, you know, three weeks ago or whatever it was four weeks ago before the
0:16:13most recent event, that was it.
0:16:14It was a $300 LG, the $700 LG Ultrafine, which depending on who you ask,
0:16:19doesn't even qualify as a retina.
0:16:20I believe it does, but there's some nuance there.
0:16:23The LG Ultrafine, which is what I ended up getting secondhand, which is fine.
0:16:27And the Pro Display XDR.
0:16:29And that's it.
0:16:30That's all you had.
0:16:30And it was just, it was, it was a disgrace.
0:16:33I mean, maybe I'm being a bit dramatic, but it was very, very frustrating.
0:16:36Which one do you, did you just say some people say is retina?
0:16:40So the LG Ultrafine 4k, there's a bit of a history here.
0:16:44How big is that?
0:16:45Is that 27 or 24?
0:16:46It's 24.
0:16:47Now, in my personal opinion, with my garbage eyes, I can see if you were to hand
0:16:53me a 27 inch display and run it at 4k, I can see pixels.
0:16:57And I'm basically, long story short, my eyes are pretty decent when I use hard
0:17:01contact lenses, when I don't have contact lenses.
0:17:04And even if I have Coke bottle glasses, I'm a mess.
0:17:06But with, with my contacts, I'm pretty good.
0:17:08And if you hand me a 27 inch 4k, I can tell.
0:17:12If you hand me a 24 inch 4k, which is what this 24UD58B is, which is what the
0:17:19LG Ultrafine 4k is now, in my personal estimation, I still classify that as retina.
0:17:24However, when the Ultrafine 4k first came out, it was only 22 inches.
0:17:28And the Delta in DPI or PPI between the two, between 22 and 24 inches, if you're,
0:17:35if it was 22 inches at whatever resolution 4k is, I forget off the top of my head,
0:17:39it is absolutely over, I think it's 200, 218 or something like that points per inch.
0:17:44At 24 inches, it's like 190 or something like that.
0:17:48So strictly speaking, it's just barely below the threshold.
0:17:53And if you look at my original post from 2017, way at the bottom, I cribbed from
0:17:58Mark Edwards with his permission, a chart that he made, and you can see down there,
0:18:03there's that he put good for retina and it's a little green sliver and then good
0:18:07for non red as an even smaller green sliver.
0:18:09And in the middle is what he calls the bad zone.
0:18:11And so at 24 inches, I don't see an example of it here actually, but at 24
0:18:16inches, oh, there at the very bottom, the Dell P2415Q, which ran 3840 by 2160,
0:18:23which I believe is normal 4k resolution at 24 inches is 183.6 points per inch.
0:18:28And so strictly speaking, that's in Mark Edwards' bad zone, but to my
0:18:32personal opinion, it's sufficient.
0:18:35It's good enough.
0:18:36But to be strictly speaking, you know, 200 plus points per inch, you basically
0:18:40need to get a 27 inch 5k monitor.
0:18:42That's about the only choice you've got.
0:18:44And as a Mac user, someone who doesn't ever touch PCs anymore, I want a pixel
0:18:50doubled, you know, 4 or 5k display because that's what Mac OS is designed to use.
0:18:55And I know that the PC people, if any of them are listening, are like,
0:18:58well, what are you talking about?
0:18:59I can get a 350 inch ultra wide screen, you know, 9 bazillion pixel display,
0:19:04but oftentimes those humongous, humongous displays actually
0:19:08aren't very high resolution.
0:19:10And Mac OS doesn't really, from what I've gathered, handle that terribly well.
0:19:15With Mac OS, it's basically 1x or 2x and nothing in between.
0:19:18And, and so if that's your criteria, then there's very little on the market.
0:19:24Like I said, there's the two LGs, the two LG Ultrafines, the other LG,
0:19:30which I have one at home now, and the XDR up until the studio display.
0:19:35Yeah.
0:19:35It's at 24 inches.
0:19:38I'm with you.
0:19:39I think it's sort of like just barely in the door should count as retina.
0:19:46But yeah, 4k at 27 inches is truly in the no person's land for Mac users.
0:19:53Agreed.
0:19:53Where it's a hundred, I've got a solver worksheet here that I've, I
0:19:58knew we were going to talk about this.
0:20:00It's a hundred and, and, and again, these, these hundreds, you say a hundred,
0:20:03I say 171 pixels per inch.
0:20:05It could be 173.
0:20:07It could be 169 or something like that because it's not exactly like, we know
0:20:12exactly how many pixels there are, but we don't know if it's really exactly 24
0:20:17inches diagonal or like 20, 23.75 or 24.2 or something like that.
0:20:23So like, like my math for Apple's pro display XDR, which is 6k at 32 inches.
0:20:30My math, you know, quick, you know, solver back of the envelope math says
0:20:36two 16 pixels per inch and Apple advertises it as two 18, which is what
0:20:41they say for everybody.
0:20:42And that probably is not them lying about or exaggerating how many pixels
0:20:47per inch, because who really cares if it's 216 or two 18, it probably means
0:20:51that it's really like a 31.9 inch diagonal or something like that.
0:20:57But, but it turns out two 18 pixels per inch is exactly the same pixels per inch
0:21:03as a bunch of other Mac retina displays, including the new studio display.
0:21:08It's by, or I forget if the Mac books come out to there, but it doesn't matter.
0:21:12It's for the arms, for the distance, the comfortable distance that Apple
0:21:17thinks people sit in front of a desktop display.
0:21:20Two 18 is the number they're clearly targeting 192, which would be 4k at 24.
0:21:27It's like, yeah, it's close.
0:21:29I think what the effect would be that everything would look a little bigger.
0:21:34Right?
0:21:34Like with fewer pixels per inch, you'd get retina resolution, but it would seem
0:21:39less dense, which, you know, some people might enjoy, but when you go.
0:21:434k at 27, which is where you have more options on the market.
0:21:48Oh, absolutely.
0:21:49Because of the PC world, it's only 172 ish pixels per inch, which is really a no,
0:21:56no person's land between two X at two X retina and the old one X, you know, it's
0:22:03like, do you run it?
0:22:04I don't even know what MacOS does.
0:22:06I guess it runs it as retina and everything looks tiny and you kind of need
0:22:11to use the scaling options and the scaling options again, that's one of those things
0:22:15that I can no longer see.
0:22:16Like when I turn on the scaling options on MacOS, you know, whether it's a Mac book
0:22:22or whatever, I don't really see it.
0:22:25I, if I take off my glasses and get close enough to the screen where I have to worry,
0:22:30you know, that I'm going to like, get some grease from my nose.
0:22:33Yes.
0:22:34Yes.
0:22:34I can totally see, oh, I see this as fakey fake or whatever, but I don't see it, you
0:22:39know, but I totally remember when my eyes were younger and much better that I would
0:22:44absolutely be able to see, oh, that's scaled.
0:22:46That's not actually pixel for pixel.
0:22:48I can, you know, I could see that.
0:22:50Yeah.
0:22:51And listening to you, it's, you sound utterly bananas, but I agree with you and
0:22:56I've lived it.
0:22:56Like it's, what you're saying is the difference between 150 to 170 points per
0:23:00inch and 190 to 220 ish.
0:23:03Like that is really that big a deal.
0:23:05Really, John?
0:23:06But it is like, I, when we were doing the survey of monitors, when I was at work, we
0:23:10got in a couple of 27 inch 4Ks and I took one look at it and admittedly my eyes were
0:23:15younger at the time, but I took one look at it and was like, uh, nope, nope, nope,
0:23:18nope, nope, nope.
0:23:19That's no good.
0:23:19And I know it sounds utterly bananas to hear the two of us say it, but it really
0:23:25does make a dramatic, dramatic difference.
0:23:26And you hit the nail on the head that at 27 inches in 4K, there are a plethora of
0:23:31options.
0:23:31There's a gazillion options, but, but to my opinion, 27 inches at 4K, it's just not
0:23:38enough resolution.
0:23:38You really, really, really need 5K at that size.
0:23:42And so whenever I posted, you know, the original post in 2017 and then most
0:23:46recently in December of last year, I would get a lot of feedback from people saying,
0:23:50what about, what about, what about, what about?
0:23:51And it was all, you know, well-intentioned, but I don't think there was a single
0:23:55monitor available in the United States anyway, that met the criteria.
0:23:59And I don't think the criteria is that ridiculous.
0:24:03It's just that PCs don't seem to have the same needs and they don't seem to do as
0:24:09well in my limited experience with high DPI monitors or at least, or it's very,
0:24:14it's very inconsistent from what I'm told.
0:24:16And so it's just not something that PC users tend to care about.
0:24:20And, you know, the market for a Mac is, or for Macs is much better now than it's
0:24:24ever been, but there's still a heck of a lot more PCs in the world than Macs.
0:24:27And, and certainly if you're wanting something that's this fancy, that's this,
0:24:31you know, high resolution or high DPI, you're probably going to have to spend a
0:24:35little bit of money.
0:24:36That's why I still think the sleeper hit of my research is this preposterously
0:24:42named 24UD58-B because it's only 300 bucks and it's, it's a very "eh" monitor.
0:24:48Like nothing about it is particularly magnificent, but it gets you what I would
0:24:53consider to be, you know, retina screen for only 300 bucks because the next best
0:24:58option, in my personal opinion, as of a couple of weeks ago, is the studio
0:25:02display. And I skipped deliberately over the slightly cheaper LG Ultrafine 5K
0:25:08because it's just not great. And we can, we can pull on that thread if you're
0:25:12interested, but it's just not great.
0:25:13Well, let's come back to it cause I want to come back, but let's, as good as time
0:25:17as any to take our first break.
0:25:18Thank our first sponsor, our good friends at Linode.
0:25:20Oh man.
0:25:21Visit linode.com/thetalkshow and see why Linode has been voted the top
0:25:27infrastructure as a service provider by both G2 and TrustRadius from their
0:25:32award-winning support, which is offered 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365
0:25:37days a year. You want to get support on Christmas? You can get support on
0:25:41Christmas. You want to get support on the 4th of July? You could do it.
0:25:44Somebody's there. Every level of user. You could just have one of their nano
0:25:49accounts, which is like five bucks a month. You get the same top tier support
0:25:54as people who like enterprise customers who are spending a fortune to get their
0:25:58great, huge, huge projects hosted at Linode. They've got the ease of use, ease
0:26:02of setup. It is clear why developers have been trusting Linode for projects,
0:26:06both big and small since 2003 deploy your entire application stack with
0:26:11Linode's one clack app, app marketplace, or build it all from scratch, manage
0:26:15everything yourself with supported tools like Terraform. They offer the best
0:26:21price to performance value for all compute instances, including GPUs, as
0:26:25well as block storage, Kubernetes, and our upcoming bare metal release. Linode
0:26:29makes cloud computing fast, simple, and affordable, allowing you to focus on
0:26:33your projects, not your infrastructure. Visit linode.com/talkshow, create a
0:26:37free account. You can use your Google, your GitHub account, or just use your
0:26:42email address, but go to that address, linode.com/talkshow. You'll get a
0:26:46hundred bucks in credit. I host Daring Fireball at Linode, and I just I'm
0:26:52ahead of time. I'm being, I'm trying to be more responsible as an adult, Casey.
0:26:56I know I am. Hey, I got my taxes done. I went to my account and I've been going
0:27:01to the same accountant since I was like busted, broke out of college doing just
0:27:05minimal freelance work to support my video game habit in the late nineties.
0:27:10Great accountant here in Philadelphia. I love the guy, but I'm often very late. I
0:27:15got, I got my taxes done already. He complained to me because when we got to
0:27:20the, you know, what do I, what, what does the Daring Fireball company pay for
0:27:24server hosting? He was like, that's it? He literally mentioned that. He was like,
0:27:29come on. That's delightful. And it is funny to have you visit your accountant
0:27:33and then all of a sudden you start, you know, you start wishing you were paying
0:27:37more for hosting. It's like, we can write that off. Oh man. Well, unfortunately, my
0:27:42accountant is not as big a fan of Linode's pricing as I am. Indeed. The
0:27:46display, basically, I forget when Apple first said, look, our solution to
0:27:52external displays is this LG thing that we help them build supposedly uses the
0:27:57same, certainly has the same specs, the same 27 inch 5k panel as the IMAX, right?
0:28:03Because that's the thing that has been in this whole desert stretch of Apple not
0:28:10making their own just external displays for Mac users. And then coming back with
0:28:17only the $6,000 effectively, right? Because you do really, you don't get any
0:28:23stand at all, or it's like you have to pay a thousand for the adjustable stand
0:28:26with the XDR.
0:28:27Like for five,
0:28:28I'm pretty sure it's, it's five grand just for the panel and then a thousand
0:28:32bucks if you want to, to use the official Apple stand. Now you could bring the
0:28:36world's crummiest, you know, visa, visa, whatever it is, mount to it, but it seems
0:28:40a little wrong to put this $5,000 beautiful piece of almost art on like the
0:28:44world's crappiest $20 visa mount.
0:28:47Pro-standard visa mount adapter sold separately. I guess so. Well, all right.
0:28:55It is a great display, right? And we'll come back to it. But you know, I'm with
0:29:01you. And sometimes listening to ATP, I do, I do feel you're a little, you're a
0:29:05little too stingy. I feel like you're,
0:29:08you're a little understandable. Oh my God. The visa mount is a, it's $200.
0:29:14Speaking of stingy, it's $200 for the freaking visa mount. Oh my good gracious.
0:29:18That is bananas. It really wasn't, it wasn't something I was going to consider
0:29:23because it's, it's clearly beyond my needs, but it really, you know, an Apple's,
0:29:27you know, answer even before the XDR though was, look, we worked with LG. We
0:29:30made this thing that is meant for Mac users. There are on the surface, a lot of
0:29:35similarities to the studio display. It has the same ports. Right. There's three
0:29:40USB-C ports, one Thunderbolt, I believe three port, and that's the one you
0:29:46connect. That's the only connection to drive the display. No HDMI, nothing else.
0:29:52It's, you know, do you want to use something like that? You know, welcome to
0:29:55dongle town. And it's supposed to do things like just wake up automatically
0:30:00when your Mac wakes up, et cetera, and so forth. I remember when I first saw it, I
0:30:05think it was the event that was in Brooklyn. Remember they held, it was like,
0:30:11uh, yeah, I was actually there for that one. That was the only one I've been to.
0:30:16That's right. Yeah. Of course you remember, I remember you, the three of you guys
0:30:20were seated a couple of rows behind me and Panzareno, me and Panzareno, not
0:30:25because we're special. Like somehow we just, it wasn't like anybody from Apple
0:30:30was like, Oh, John Gruber and Matthew Panzareno, let's escort you up front.
0:30:33Somehow though, you know, and you, you were there. It is like, it, it, it's like
0:30:39you're waiting and, and it's very nice. And they've got, you know, I don't know,
0:30:42coffee in Danish and stuff for the people who've been invited and you can
0:30:46wait. And then the doors open and it's not like a stampede, but it is sort of,
0:30:51you don't know what to expect because they don't tell you, everybody from the
0:30:55media who's been invited, you'll be seated on the left and here's what to do.
0:30:59And you know, there's lots of seats in the middle up front that are all reserved
0:31:03for VIPs, you know, people from Pixar who, you know, Leon Kritz is here for this
0:31:08event. Well, guess what? He's getting a real good seat in the second row. You
0:31:11know, Laureen Powell-Jobs is here. Oh, well guess what? She gets a good seat.
0:31:15You know what I mean?
0:31:16I think she's earned it.
0:31:17Yeah. It's like, Oh, where do I go? What do I do? What do I get to see? And then
0:31:20somehow Panzareno and I wound up in like the third row for that one. And, and we
0:31:25weren't really on the left, but we weren't surrounded by media people. We
0:31:31were surrounded by Apple retail employees who had been invited. Apparently the deal
0:31:37was that like, I don't know if they flew people in or if it was just like regional
0:31:42Northeast stuff, but it was actually somebody from a suburban Philly store who
0:31:46was right behind us and broke up a chitchat and it was very nice. But
0:31:50apparently it was like a reward for a very successful Apple retail store
0:31:55employees. And their managers got to say, Hey, you've been doing a great job.
0:31:59We've got a couple passes to this event in Brooklyn. You guys can go. And it was,
0:32:04you know, on the one hand, it was a very nice treat. They, these people were
0:32:08incredibly enthusiastic. They were so happy to be there. It was amazing. And,
0:32:13but it was also good for, you could see it from Apple's perspective where it
0:32:16made it seem like the audience was crazy enthusiastic. You know, it was
0:32:19like the Beatles were in town. You know, it was, it worked out for everybody.
0:32:22Apple got an event where it seemed like the audience was very happy because the
0:32:26people in the media, some people, you know, they, they either don't clap
0:32:30because they feel like it's inappropriate as a member of the media to like cheer
0:32:34and clap for a thing that they're there to objectively observe, or they don't
0:32:39even think that far. They're just typing their live blog thing, right? Like,
0:32:44even if they don't have like a personal policy against applauding or something
0:32:48like that, they, you know, so Apple, you know, wants to get the applause. So
0:32:51they put in people who are going to do that. Anyway, you were there. They,
0:32:55remember the hands-on area, they had the LG displays, right?
0:32:58You know, I can't remember if they had the LG displays. I remember the big
0:33:02thing for that day was the iPad Pro, because that was when I believe it was
0:33:06the first of the iPads with Face ID at that point, because this was October
0:33:102018. And the new MacBook Air, if I'm not mistaken, the new Retina MacBook Air,
0:33:16I think was also that event. I'm not trying to say that the LG Ultra Find
0:33:20wasn't there. I just, I don't recall one way or the other. I remember the
0:33:24big haul.
0:33:24No, it was definitely there because there was some Mac news too, and they,
0:33:28including, you know, it wasn't even on stage, but like one of the news items
0:33:32of the day was this 15-inch, I guess at the time was the big size, I almost
0:33:36said 16, but the 15-inch MacBook Pro got a new build to order option for a
0:33:42higher-end embedded graphics card, you know. And I remember palling around
0:33:47the hands-on area with Austin Mann, the photographer, who often does these
0:33:52amazing, amazing, oh, you know, it makes me sick because he's like, you
0:33:57know, he's like on safari, you know, somewhere in Africa shooting pictures
0:34:02of lions with the iPhone 13. And meanwhile, I'm like shooting a picture
0:34:06of a coffee mug on my desk. Right. Exactly. But we were there and we were
0:34:11talking and they had light room on display to talk about like the
0:34:16improvements to something and it was all being shown on these LG displays
0:34:19and they looked fine, right? I mean, they look, you know, but I just
0:34:23remember looking at the build quality of them. Like the display itself was
0:34:27fine and it roughly to my eyes as good as the iMac 5K. I'm sure, I've seen
0:34:33people say it's actually not as good as the iMac 5K in terms of evenness
0:34:37from corner to corner, but the thing that I could instantly imagine was
0:34:40this is sort of like a janky build quality. Yeah, I couldn't agree more.
0:34:47So I got one of these secondhand, you know, late last year and so I got it
0:34:51for steel, which is why, perhaps why I'm more enthusiastic and a bit of an
0:34:55apologist for the ultra fine. It is a masterclass in mediocrity. Like
0:35:00everything about it is mediocre. The screen, the panel itself is pretty
0:35:04darn good, but everything around that panel is mediocre on a good day. The
0:35:09build quality is eh. The stand that it comes with was super wobbly and
0:35:15I don't think it was properly, you know, counterweighted or sprung or
0:35:19what have you, so that it always wanted to either rise or fall depending on
0:35:22how many things I, you know, clamped to the back of it in the USB-C ports.
0:35:26The speakers are preposterously bad and one of my favorite things about my
0:35:31beloved LG Ultrafine is that as you volume up between the third volume
0:35:37notch and the fourth volume notch, the ramp between the third and the fourth,
0:35:41you know, squares or whatever they are, the volume ramp between the two is
0:35:45like quadruple. I am being a little hyperbolic, but it's, you know, it goes,
0:35:49it's kind of a whisper at low and one and two and three and then at four
0:35:53it's like this. It's ridiculous. It's like it's so much louder between three
0:35:57and four. And that was, I believe, one of the things that was supposedly
0:36:00going to come from a firmware update, which I did do and it didn't make a
0:36:04difference. And speaking of firmware updates, Jon, did you know that it
0:36:07wasn't until like a month ago that their LG display manager, screen manager,
0:36:11was able to run on M1 Macs that have been around for what, like a year and
0:36:14a half now, two years now? So it's, everything about it is mediocre. And I
0:36:19don't have the visceral like repulsion that it seems Marco does by having a
0:36:24little tiny understated LG logo on the front. Like would I prefer it to be?
0:36:28Not there, of course, but I don't find it to be particularly offensive. But it's
0:36:32just, it was, it's a pretty good panel, but everything around it is just meh on
0:36:38a good day. And mine, shortly after I got it again, I got it second hand.
0:36:43Shortly after I got it, the main Thunderbolt connection so that, you know,
0:36:47USB-C looking, but it's actually a Thunderbolt connection, seemed to
0:36:49dislodge itself from the inside. And so I needed to ship my monitor all the
0:36:55way to California. Yeah, all the way to California. And then it sat for a
0:36:59while, which I mean, it was the holidays and COVID and so on. So I really
0:37:02shouldn't complain, but it sat for like a month and then eventually came back.
0:37:05But the whole, I could go on a three hour rant about how awful that repair
0:37:09process was. And honestly, for that alone, that's, I'm so excited to be able
0:37:15to have, and mine is coming in a couple of weeks, have an Apple Studio
0:37:18display. And for no other reason than because if something goes wrong, I put
0:37:22it in my car and drive 10 minutes. And then I hand it to someone who will
0:37:26presumably fix it in a fairly timely manner. Like that alone, that the repair
0:37:31story for those of us who are lucky enough to live close to at least one
0:37:34Apple store, that repair story is enough to make me more than interested,
0:37:39let alone everything else that's great about it.
0:37:41I often think, and I think that this whole saga of external displays
0:37:45epitomizes it. I often get the feeling that inside Apple, it's not that
0:37:53they're unaware of the broader computing world in the PC market, that
0:37:57people who work at Apple are so, it's not an insular thing. It's just that
0:38:03the sort of people who go to work at Apple and get to the point where
0:38:07they're successful enough in the company where they can be decision
0:38:10makers who are involved with like, should we keep making our own
0:38:15displays? Should we trust it to the third, you know, they're so of a
0:38:21like-mindedness in their priorities for what matters. Like, what do
0:38:26people really want? You know? And I think it seems so obvious to people
0:38:30who are drawn to Apple and Apple platforms that retina for phones, for
0:38:35tablets, the watch has always been retina, right? The watch is a product
0:38:39that debuted at a resolution that you can't see pixels unless, you know,
0:38:45you have incredibly good eyes or a loop or something like that. This is
0:38:49so obvious, you know, that you would like to, it's like saying, would you
0:38:54like to be healthy or unhealthy? Well, it's obvious, you know, you would
0:38:59like to be healthy, right? It's like, would you like a retina display or
0:39:03not a retina display? Well, obviously you'd like a retina display. And I
0:39:06kind of feel like that mindset blinded them where they thought, you know,
0:39:10we can get out of this market, we'll help LG build one as sort of a
0:39:14reference. And then, you know, the other companies, you know, the Dells
0:39:18and the ACES and whoever else makes displays will pick up the slack and,
0:39:23you know, Mac users will have a variety of third party. It's like
0:39:27printers, right? Apple hasn't made printers for decades now. There's
0:39:31plenty of printers out there. I still sort of wish they made printers,
0:39:34frankly. Because printers are so bad. I forget what I did. I turned
0:39:38something on on my Eero that you would never ever think some option in
0:39:42the Eero. I forget what the hell it was, but you wouldn't think it would
0:39:45have anything. All of a sudden my HP printer wouldn't print name. It
0:39:47wouldn't connect to Wi-Fi anymore. And it was like, what? And it wasn't
0:39:50like I turned it like, oh, only use, you know, Wi-Fi 6 or whatever the
0:39:55latest standard is. And my, you know, eight year old laser jet doesn't see
0:39:59it. It was something else, but it was like, God, I hate this fucking thing.
0:40:02But anyway, I think that they thought the monitors thing would be like the
0:40:07printers thing where it's like, ah, you know, there'll be plenty of
0:40:10options for Mac users to choose from. Well, it turned out they're like, as
0:40:13you delineated very well, there were like two and really only one, the LG
0:40:2027 inch 5K ultra fine, really the one and only Dell had something that was
0:40:26maybe there. And then they got out of the business. Like, so not only like
0:40:30the opposite, the opposite of what I think Apple thought would happen,
0:40:34which is that this is where the industry is going. Look at how great
0:40:37these displays are. The whole industry is going to go in this direction. We
0:40:40don't need to make one. And instead they went the opposite direction and
0:40:44the PC world concluded, Nope, PC users do not want 5K 27 inch displays.
0:40:50So we won't make them. Yeah. Cause why would we bother for the 15 Apple
0:40:56nerds that really care about this stuff? And I mean, it kind of makes
0:40:59sense. Like, you know, if you look at it on the surface of, of the people
0:41:02that I know, you know, many, many, many of my friends, I'm not talking like
0:41:06our mutual friends. I'm talking about like regular run of the mill friends
0:41:08of mine and family members. All a ton of them are on max. In fact, I can
0:41:13think of very few that are on PCs these days, but very, very few of them
0:41:17have an external display at all. And the only person I can think of that
0:41:22cared enough to get the LG ultra fine other than me is my dad. And he
0:41:26probably did that because he went to Apple's website and was looking for
0:41:30whatever Apple recommended. Like I don't remember he and I talking about
0:41:34it before he bought it. I think he just bought it because he figured that
0:41:37was what Apple advised him to do, which at the time was true.
0:41:40I'm somewhat familiar with the PC market for this because my son, Jonas,
0:41:44has a gaming PC, which we got him two years ago, and I helped him spec it
0:41:49out. He doesn't regret it. And I've asked him and he doesn't, but he's
0:41:54actually got three displays hooked up to it. Now I forget the model names.
0:41:59It doesn't matter because they're not of interest, but it's like an Asus
0:42:02something or another. That's I think like a 24 inch 4k panel, which I
0:42:07encouraged him to get. I thought you don't want something that's not
0:42:11retina. You want something vaguely close to retina. But for playing
0:42:14games, I do think it makes it. He seems to like it because and he's used
0:42:18to his iPhone and iPad and he has a MacBook that he uses for school.
0:42:23So he appreciates it when he's actually doing something like reading
0:42:28something in a web browser on the PC that it's roughly retina. It looks
0:42:33all right, but it's so super thick. It is crazy. But it probably was a
0:42:38mistake for a gaming PC that the size wasn't the mistake. It's that the 4k,
0:42:43you don't want to drive your games at that resolution anyway because you
0:42:46want frame rate more than anything for gaming. It would never make a good
0:42:55Mac monitor. It's just in addition to the fact that it is industrial
0:43:00designed as in the gaming vernacular of like black and like the stand
0:43:06looks like a claw almost, you know. It's from Asus, I believe, or else his
0:43:11other monitor is other displays from Asus. One's from Asus, one's from a
0:43:15company that sounds like Asus. But they're not, they would not make good
0:43:18Mac displays at all. They're just, they just wouldn't. And it's, I think
0:43:22that's part of the problem is that some of the people who really, really
0:43:26care about their displays in the PC market are gamers and their interest
0:43:32has nothing at all correlated to the interest of a Mac user who wants to
0:43:37do work, right? It's just an entirely different set of needs. And the PC
0:43:43world is catering to gamers who, you know, for obvious reasons, because
0:43:47they're the ones who are willing to spend a premium on a nice product.
0:43:51And the Mac world, you know, Apple help us, you know, you're our Obi-Wan,
0:43:56you know, you're our only help.
0:43:57Right. You're exactly right that the priorities are just very, very
0:44:01different. And that doesn't make, you know, PC users wrong. It's just
0:44:05that they're very different priorities. And the other funny thing, you
0:44:07know, hearing you talk about it, I don't have any particular needs for
0:44:11like amazing color reproduction. I don't care. Like I'm sure I would
0:44:15appreciate a, you know, P3 whatever monitor, but I don't care about
0:44:21perfectly accurate color reproduction. I would prefer in a perfect world
0:44:24to have like mini LED or OLED or something like that, but I don't really
0:44:27care that much. And that'll come up in a minute about the studio display.
0:44:31But, you know, my needs aren't that esoteric. I just want a whole bunch
0:44:34of pixels in not a whole ton of space, you know, and I don't think that's
0:44:37too much to ask, but for whatever reason, the market just did not step
0:44:41up, like you said. And you could argue, you know, that sort of kind of
0:44:44happened when Apple dropped the airport line, but then we got Eero and Eero.
0:44:49I mean, I use it. I granted they were comped devices or at least the one
0:44:52of them was, but I use them really like Eero. And so I feel like the
0:44:58router world, at least we have a couple of options. Whereas for
0:45:02displays, it was nothing. And I was looking earlier today, I was curious
0:45:07because, you know, back many, many Macs ago, I remember lusting after the
0:45:11Thunderbolt display, which was 27 inches, if I'm not mistaken, but not
0:45:14retina, you know, it was one X and I was looking it up because I can't
0:45:18remember when did that go away? And according to Wikipedia, the
0:45:21Thunderbolt display was discontinued on the 23rd of June in 2016. And the
0:45:27studio display, my understanding is the first deliveries were the 18th of
0:45:31March, 2022. John, 299 weeks in one day between those two dates.
0:45:37Wait, what was the date?
0:45:40June 23rd, June 23rd of 2016 to March 18th of this year. That's 299 weeks
0:45:45in a day or 2094 days, five years, nine months and two days of no Apple
0:45:51monitors except the XDR. But again, I don't count it.
0:45:54Right. And even if you count the XDR, it was quite a stretch, right?
0:45:58Because that was still a couple of years.
0:46:00Yeah, because that was introduced at WWDC 2019, but didn't ship till
0:46:04later, right?
0:46:06I think that's right. Yeah. So it was still like three, three and a half
0:46:08years.
0:46:09Yeah. So it's good to have them back. I think they needed to. I also feel, I
0:46:14wonder in broad strokes, it's different than selling an entire product, but I
0:46:20sort of feel that the mentality I mentioned of, well, of course the whole
0:46:23world's going to go this way because look at how much better this is, sort
0:46:28of explains Apple going all in on USB C ports and not USB A so many years
0:46:37ago. And famously, which we probably will hopefully get to by the end of the
0:46:42show, your beloved MacBook adorable, which only had one port and it was USB
0:46:46C. But it's hard to, when they make a device that is so thin like iPads,
0:46:55where USB A obviously would not fit, people don't complain. But on any
0:47:00device where theoretically they could squeeze in a USB A port and it doesn't
0:47:05have one, it's inevitably listed in the cons. I don't want to pick on the
0:47:10Verge, but I actually do want to pick on the Verge. Right? Like the new M1
0:47:19Max MacBook Pros, 14 and 16 inch ship. What do you have, the 14 inch?
0:47:24The 14.
0:47:24That's what I have too. I love it. It might be the greatest computer I've
0:47:27ever owned.
0:47:27I completely agree.
0:47:28You know, it does not have a USB A port. Could in theory have had one, I
0:47:33guess, would have fit, size wise. And it's considered a ding or a knock.
0:47:39But I just think that, you know, more problematically than whether the port
0:47:45is actually on the device, USB A, is the fact that there were so few USB C
0:47:52peripherals out there and things that you needed, you would need a dongle
0:47:56for. And I really just can't help but think that Apple really thought, oh my
0:48:00God, this USB C, finally a USB C that we actually can like, you know, not be
0:48:04grossed out by, you know, it works upside down. You don't have to get it
0:48:08in the right way. It's pretty small. Wow. When the whole, when the rest of
0:48:12the world sees this, they're going to go bananas for it and everything's
0:48:14going to go USB C. Well, guess what? Didn't really happen. It's been very
0:48:18slow. But I think that Apple guessed correctly 24 years ago when they made
0:48:24the original, famous original iMac and it only had USB A ports and got rid
0:48:30of all of the Mac's legacy ports, like my beloved ADB port for the keyboard,
0:48:34just had USB A. And I think they bet that, hey, the whole PC world is going
0:48:39to go for this USB C or USB just when it was just one USB. Well, except
0:48:45remember the weird one that you had to plug into the printer? It was like a
0:48:49different, you know, USB A. USB has always been so fun. But they did, they
0:48:55bet correctly then. Like it really did not take long for the PC world to be
0:48:59like, yeah, this USB C is, the USB is way better than serial and whatever
0:49:04else. Parallel. PC two ports or PS two ports. PS two. Get rid of all this,
0:49:09go USB. I think Apple thought the same thing was going to happen with
0:49:12USB C and it didn't. Yeah, and I don't entirely begrudge them, but I think
0:49:17part of the problem is, is that either Apple or the USB consortium or what
0:49:22have you, or maybe all the above, they sold us a bill of goods that didn't
0:49:26really end up getting delivered. Because if you think about what we knew
0:49:28about USB C and whenever it was that this was becoming a thing, I guess
0:49:32like 2015, something like that. Whenever the MacBooks started going USB C
0:49:37and actually, was it the adorable? That was the first one come to think of
0:49:41it. It might've been the adorable, but it doesn't really matter. One way or
0:49:44another, when we started going all in on USB C, we, there was kind of only
0:49:48one USB C. If you think about it, like there was the physical connector and
0:49:52it was always USB, or at least it, the way I remember it was that way. But
0:49:57then quickly we started getting Thunderbolt and so in Thunderbolt or
0:50:00Thunderbolt being transmitted over what appeared to be a USB C cable. And
0:50:05then it quickly became obvious that all USB C cables, they're all special
0:50:10little snowflakes. None of them are alike and you can never freaking tell
0:50:15what's what. And like a couple of the cables that I have around the house
0:50:18now, a couple of them actually have a number four on them and like a little
0:50:21Thunderbolt logo. So I know what those are, but the overwhelming majority of
0:50:25the USB C devices that I have, or that, that, that appear to be USB C in terms
0:50:29of the physical connection, I have no idea if they're USB C, if they're
0:50:33Thunderbolt, if they're Thunderbolt 2, 3, 4, or what have you. And especially
0:50:37when I was rocking the adorable, this was a real pain in the butt because the
0:50:41adorable only had USB C. It did not have Thunderbolt. And one of the popular
0:50:46things to do at the time was to get a Thunderbolt dock, which actually I have
0:50:49just done as well for my new computer, but I couldn't use a Thunderbolt dock.
0:50:53I could only use a USB C dock and, and there weren't many of them and they
0:50:57were worse. And so I think the part of the problem, part of the slow adoption
0:51:02is that not all, not all USB C is created alike. Whereas if you think about
0:51:07the, the original USB days, when it really was one universal serial bus,
0:51:12you didn't really have to think about that. If they physically connected,
0:51:14that's all that mattered. But if I take two different cables that appear that,
0:51:19that physically have the same ends, but have very different guts, I may or
0:51:23may not be able to see anything on the screen in front of me, all because of
0:51:26the guts. It has nothing to do with the physical, any properties at all. It's
0:51:29just the guts and it's infuriating. It's absolutely infuriating.
0:51:32I remember a couple of years ago, I was doing a review of some new MacBook and
0:51:37I was like, you know what, I'm not going to set this one up from scratch. Let's,
0:51:40let's try the migration assistant and let me get all of, you know, as much of
0:51:46my regular setup over here on this new thing and I'll actually use it. And I
0:51:51did the migration, I thought over Thunderbolt, cause I knew both machines
0:51:54had Thunderbolt and it was like, you know, estimated time, 20 days.
0:51:59And I was like, what, how, what? It was seriously like days or something. It
0:52:05was like, I, I have, I'm supposed to have this review done in a week. What,
0:52:09what I can't spend, what is going on? And it was, it was a total, I was using
0:52:14a USB-C cable, even though it was connected between two Thunderbolt parts
0:52:18ports. And I was like, Oh, that's it. Stop, stop. Let me cancel. Let me wipe
0:52:22this machine. Start over. All right. Do I have a necessary Thunderbolt cable?
0:52:27Hmm. I can't seem to find one. I may not have one. Damn. Where did I put it?
0:52:31You know what? I'll go buy one. How much are you?
0:52:34Well, it's so cheap, John. It's so cheap. Don't worry. You can buy them
0:52:37like a chiclet. You know, it's no problem at all.
0:52:40So I had like two of these moments, like within, you know, very short period
0:52:43of like, you know, like if I were a cartoon character, my eyes bugged out
0:52:47on my head. Where, where one, it was how long it was going to take over
0:52:51USB-C between sensible Thunderbolt ports. And then to find out how much,
0:52:56like a one foot Thunderbolt cable costs. It's like 40, 50 bucks. Isn't it
0:53:00something like that? And it's like, like an 18 inch cable, you know, like
0:53:06one of the knocks people have against the Apple studio displays that the
0:53:09included cable, which is very, very nice. It's, it's this new Apple cable
0:53:14style that they've started shipping with the braided material.
0:53:17Very, very nice material premium, but it is, it is like one meter, maybe
0:53:22less if anything, or it's a meter literally from like metal tip to metal
0:53:26tip. It's not like a meter of cable. It is very small. So you can't, if
0:53:30you're, you know, whatever Mac you're connecting to your studio display,
0:53:33if you're going to use that cable, it can't be too far away from the
0:53:36display. I mean, a meter's not bad, but like the two meter cable is like,
0:53:40it's seriously like 180 bucks or something. I think.
0:53:43Yeah. Yeah. And I'm looking at the Thunderbolt three USB-C cable,
0:53:47eight tenths of a meter is 40 bucks. And I did the same thing. I forget
0:53:50what the occasion was for me doing this, but I had the exact same moment
0:53:54and I was like, well, shit, I guess I'm going to the Apple store. $40.
0:53:57Seriously? $40. And I mean, again, like if you think about it, if you
0:54:02stop and think, and you realize all the technology in there, like it does
0:54:04make sense. And I saw a tweet a while ago. I don't think I'll be able to
0:54:07dig it up for the show notes, but somebody had talked about how the,
0:54:10the two or three meter, $150 Thunderbolt cable apparently has like a
0:54:13lot of really trick technology in it. But, but at a glance, I, I didn't
0:54:18appreciate, and I'm a nerd. Like I do sort of kind of this stuff for a
0:54:21living. And I didn't appreciate the fact that I had to pay 40 bucks for
0:54:24less than a meter of cable, much less 150 bucks for, you know, the one or
0:54:27two meters or whatever it is. That makes, that makes sense though, that
0:54:30it's only eight tenths of a meter. Cause it does it, it, I didn't measure
0:54:34it, but it feels less than a meter. I don't know. I have like an intuitive
0:54:37sense of three feet equals a meter. I know, you know, I can put my hands
0:54:42out in a pretty good guess. It's like, this feels less than that. And it's
0:54:45long enough for me, even though I keep my desk is such that I need to, I, I
0:54:49like to have the MacBook on the left. So it has to stretch a little bit
0:54:54further because from it, from, from your viewers perspective, the ports
0:54:58are on the right behind the studio display. So it's a little bit of a,
0:55:03it, the cable where I put my MacBook next to it is pretty much stretched
0:55:07completely, but without any stress it, it couldn't be any shorter or I'd
0:55:12have to move the MacBook closer than I would like it to be, or figure out a
0:55:16way to put the MacBook on the other side. But it is funny though, as a lay
0:55:19person, cause it's true too, like at my age where it's like, I know
0:55:22computers, I grew up, you know, you know, understanding how computers
0:55:26work. How, how, how could this two meter cable be so expensive? All
0:55:30you're doing is shooting electrons across, you know, right. It's, it's
0:55:34all just copper wire with electrons shooting across. And it's like, and
0:55:36then you start reading about how Thunderbolt cables working. You're
0:55:39like, Oh, it's, it's like a computer in there.
0:55:42Yeah. And it's a Thunderbolt four pro cable, three meters, $160 coming
0:55:47soon. Coming soon. That's the best part. You can't even get the damn
0:55:52thing. Holy Jamolis. All right. Let's take another break here. Let's take
0:55:55another break. Give thanks to our next sponsor is our good friends at
0:55:58remote. Do you employ or pay workers who are in other countries? Even if
0:56:04you don't yet, you might soon now that remote work is the norm and
0:56:09growing ever more. So employees have more freedom than ever to move
0:56:12around. And if you don't want to keep your best people, you, if you do
0:56:15want to keep your best people, I should say you have to stay flexible.
0:56:18That's why remote makes it easy for companies of all sizes to employ
0:56:24global teams. They take care of international payroll benefits,
0:56:27taxes, local compliance, all of that. So you don't have to focus on
0:56:33paperwork. And instead you can focus on your actual business. They help
0:56:37you onboard full-time employees or contractors in countries all over the
0:56:41world in minutes using their simple, easy to use platform and even better
0:56:45remote lets you rest easy by providing the most comprehensive intellectual
0:56:50property protections and data security in the industry. They own full local
0:56:56entities in all of the covered countries, guaranteeing that you never have to
0:57:01deal with a third party ever. You just deal with remote and remote deals with
0:57:06all the hassles with your employees who live in those countries to save you
0:57:09money. They never charge any fees or salary percentages. You get access to
0:57:12everything remote access offers from payroll to compliance, to benefits
0:57:16management for one low flat rate, no hidden fees, no surprises ever, just
0:57:21the best global employment solution in the business. And best of all
0:57:25listeners of this show, get an even bigger discount. You can get 50% off
0:57:29remote full suite of global employment solutions for your first employee for
0:57:35three months. First employee three months, you get 50% off. Just visit
0:57:41remote.com/the-talk-show and remember that promo code, the talk show, and you
0:57:47get the discount. See why top global companies like GitLab trust remote to
0:57:52manage and pay their international teams, whether you want to hire one person or
0:57:55a hundred remote makes it easy. Visit remote.com/the-talk-show and remember
0:58:01that promo code, the talk show. Have they sponsored ATP remote or...
0:58:05You know, I don't think so. I think it's forthcoming if I remember correctly.
0:58:09I'm always confused. I might be lying to you.
0:58:10I, you know, I tell you, I think I've said this to Marco on the show too.
0:58:13Sometimes it's like, I listen, I'm listening to ATP and I think, why aren't
0:58:17they sponsoring my show? They'd be perfect.
0:58:20This coming week, remote is sponsoring ATP.
0:58:22Well then, if people are here for the Casey instead of the Gruber, it's
0:58:27probably remote.com/ATP. Feel free to try that one out if you want.
0:58:33That is accurate. I would never say that on your show, but that is
0:58:36hypothetically anything.
0:58:37Oh, I'm generous with the promo codes.
0:58:41Are you generous with your review units though? Because I'm not getting a
0:58:46Apple Studio display for another couple of weeks and I will be happy to take
0:58:49yours off your hands until then.
0:58:51You know what? It is funny because they ship it and, you know, and they're,
0:58:54they're never banging on the doors, you know, to get review unit sent back.
0:59:00But they ship it with a, you know, a pre-printed FedEx label to send it back.
0:59:06And it's like this, this review unit is through, I think for these, they said
0:59:10September, which is nice. It's longer than usual. I feel bad. I'm going to
0:59:15order one. Here's my person, you know, before we get into the details of it,
0:59:18my personal situation, I'm a hundred percent going to buy one because this
0:59:21is the display I've been waiting for. And overall, camera aside, I'm extremely,
0:59:27extremely happy with it. It's like, yeah, this is what I want. I love it.
0:59:30But what I want to do is I want to see the nano texture glass in person. It's
0:59:34a $300 upgrade. I do not want to buy, just buy it and wait and get it, even
0:59:39though I probably should, but I hate, I just hate sending anything back to
0:59:44anyone. I hate it. I don't know why.
0:59:45Yep, same, same.
0:59:46I don't know. I'll just, I'll just, just, I'll just, if I, if I bought the
0:59:50nano texture glass, I would just like, I don't know, put it under my desk and
0:59:53buy a glossy one. Even though, like, I don't want to spend $5,000 on a Pro
0:59:59Display XDR, but I'll blow $5,000 by buying, you know, I'll buy the $2,000
1:00:06nano texture one and then just say, ah, give me the other one. But anyway, I
1:00:10want to see it.
1:00:10Anything to avoid returning one. That's all that matters.
1:00:12I do want to see it in person. My review unit is the standard glossy one, which
1:00:17it does have a very, very nice anti-reflective coating. But my, as, as,
1:00:22you know, you see from my example photos, you know, in my review or any other
1:00:27time I occasionally shoot those videos in my office, I do have lots of windows,
1:00:32which I love. And it's one of the reasons we, you know, we, we bought this
1:00:36house. I love the windows. I love the light, but windows and glare are, you
1:00:43know, go hand in hand. It's not bad. But, you know, there's a window over my
1:00:48shoulder that at certain times of the year, at certain times of the day, it's
1:00:52right on the display. So I feel like I'm at least a maybe on the nano texture
1:00:56glass, but it seems like the nano texture with the XDR has very mixed reviews
1:01:04from people who thought, oh, I would like to have matte, but then they get the
1:01:09nano texture and you're like, I don't know. I don't like this.
1:01:11- Yeah. I have heard a lot of the same and I can't cite any particular person
1:01:15that has said this to me, but I feel like I've heard a lot of the same rumblings.
1:01:19So the nano texture is, is kind of a mixed bag.
1:01:21- Our friend Luke had one. Remember he sent, he sent his back. He was like,
1:01:25ah, F this. And he was very surprised. Well, then the problem with it is, and
1:01:29again, I am not at the least bit sour that Apple didn't send me both as a
1:01:34review unit. That's the last thing I need. All right. I'm one person, right?
1:01:39So like the Verge, the Verge got, I'm friends with Nilay, the Verge got two M1
1:01:44max studios with the max and the ultra, and they got both of the displays,
1:01:49nano texture or not, but the Verge has multi, you know, a big staff.
1:01:53That's the last thing I needed was more stuff to review. So, and, and I would,
1:01:58I would actually, as a reviewer talking to my audience, I'd rather have the one
1:02:02that most people are going to buy, which is the default. So I'm glad I am.
1:02:05It's just no sour grapes or, you know, petulance about it. The downside though,
1:02:10is that the nano, this is the big downside is that the nano texture models
1:02:14are not on display in most Apple stores. I asked, I asked Apple during my review
1:02:20period, will, you know, will they be on display in stores? And the, the initial
1:02:24answer was they, they will be on display in select Apple stores. And I wrote
1:02:31back and I said, okay, that's good to know, but how do I know if my Apple
1:02:35store has been selected? And are you in New York or San Francisco or LA?
1:02:40That's what you need to know. Yeah. So, the answer I got was you keep,
1:02:45you know, and there's no way online to tell, unfortunately you can't, you
1:02:49know, and I don't blame them. It's only so many things they can put on the
1:02:52website of apple.com and being able to query specifically, you know, which
1:02:59products are on display at this store is a weird thing to want from Apple, but
1:03:06I kind of wish they did. What you can do of course is call your local Apple
1:03:10store and a friendly Apple store representative will be able to answer
1:03:14you. But the answer is probably no, that they don't have nano texture. For
1:03:18me, living here in Philadelphia, we have a store right here in center city,
1:03:22Philadelphia, which is literally blocks away from me. It is, it would be
1:03:28preposterous even in pouring down rain, maybe in pouring down rain, I would
1:03:34take an Uber or something, but it is easy walking distance. It would be
1:03:37walking distance, maybe not to buy, Hmm. Would I walk home with a studio
1:03:43display? That's the question. I walk, you walk there and then you take an
1:03:47Uber back. Yeah. I, I, well, I use, if I were going to buy something like
1:03:52that, I'd get it shipped to me. Oh, you know what you can do? You can always
1:03:54get the courier service. That's right. That's true. Yeah. They have courier
1:03:57service, which I've used to buy stupid things. Like when I've needed a
1:04:00cable and because I live here in center city, Philadelphia, I can usually
1:04:04get them within like two hours, which is amazing. They do not, they are not
1:04:08going to have the nano texture one on display. We have a King of Prussia
1:04:12mall, which is somewhat famous as a mall. It is one of the largest has
1:04:18been for decades, one of the largest shopping malls in the country. King of
1:04:21Prussia is a suburb of Philly. It's about 15 miles as the crow flies, which
1:04:26isn't bad and used to be before Apple opened a center city, Philadelphia
1:04:31store. It was the closest Apple store. One of the closest to, for people who
1:04:35live in the city here. The other one would be Cherry Hill, New Jersey, which
1:04:38is right across the bridge. Very easy drive, but like the King of
1:04:42Prussia mall Apple store is the one that's the one I waited at in 2007 to
1:04:46get my first iPhone. When you had, remember that when you, you actually,
1:04:51there was no way to pre-order. You just went in the morning and sat there all
1:04:55day. And then they went on sale at like 6 PM or something like that. That's
1:04:58the King of Prussia. The problem with the King of Prussia as a
1:05:01Philadelphia is it is 15 miles, but it is the longest 15 miles imaginable.
1:05:10It is, you have to take what we are, our beloved Schuylkill Expressway, which
1:05:15if there's no traffic, like if I, I guarantee you, if I tried to make the
1:05:19drive from my house to the King of Prussia mall at two in the morning, I
1:05:23could do it in 15 minutes. Easy. Probably less the way the speeds I drive
1:05:28at, but you know, at normal times of the day, it could be an hour. It is
1:05:33very bad traffic, but anyway, I will go there. I will check it out before I
1:05:36decide what to order, but it's sort of like, I kind of have to gear myself up
1:05:40for it. It's an all day affair, unfortunately. Did you call them yet? Do
1:05:46you know that they will have a display model? I cheated and Apple PR
1:05:50confirmed for me that the King of Prussia. That's allowed. I haven't been
1:05:54there in a long time. I mean, guess what? We're at the point now coming
1:05:58out of COVID where I keep forgetting. Like we're doing more normal stuff and
1:06:04I'm like, why is it that I haven't been to the King of Prussia mall and in
1:06:07recent memory? And I'm like, Oh yeah, that's right. Yeah. There was like two
1:06:11years where I hardly left the house. That's it. Yeah. There you go. Yeah.
1:06:16But the King of Prussia mall, I recently underwent a big renovation.
1:06:19They used to be two malls that were right next. They called it one mall,
1:06:22but there were like two actual structures and like a parking lot
1:06:26between them and a walkway. And it was, you know, very, you know,
1:06:30sufficiently close that they, it wasn't ridiculous to call it one big mall,
1:06:34even though you had to go outside to get between the two, but they renovated
1:06:38and added a stretch in between the two to keep it all indoors. And that
1:06:44new stretch is where they put all of the super premium brands, like the
1:06:49Tiffany, Louis Vuitton, Gucci, you name ultra luxury fashion brand. They're
1:06:56in this new stretch that's between what used to be the two malls. And you'd
1:07:00think, well, that's probably where the Apple store is now too. But instead,
1:07:04I think what they did, if I'm recalling correctly, cause I've only been there
1:07:07once since the renovation is it seems like what they did is they sort of,
1:07:12like Apple took a spot in one of the two malls close to that throughway,
1:07:18but they moved from like their original location where they'd been since like
1:07:22the early two thousands when they first opened to this new one as sort of a,
1:07:27I'm betting it was like a fascinating negotiation of real estate, of mall real
1:07:32estate where they're like, Apple is like, we'd like to be in this new section,
1:07:35you know, like next to Tiffany. And they're like, yeah, but we'd kind of
1:07:38like to have some really good brands elsewhere, like anchoring. What about
1:07:42this huge, huge spot here? And they're like, oh yeah, well, we'll do that, but
1:07:47we'll pay you nothing or something. Right. You know how Apple negotiated.
1:07:50Oh yeah.
1:07:51So, but they have, it is, it is, it is like a, it has long been one of the
1:07:57quote unquote select Apple stores. So I will go out there and see it before
1:08:00I make my own purchasing decision, even though I'm very worried because the
1:08:05lighting inside Apple stores is not like the lighting in my office because
1:08:11it's not daylight. It is this super diffuse, beautiful lighting. And in fact,
1:08:16I thought that when you sent me the screenshot yesterday, you went to an
1:08:19Apple store to see the, the studio display. Right. That's right. And you
1:08:23look pretty good from the camera because the lighting is so diffused and very
1:08:28nice in an Apple store. So I'm still, I'm a little concerned that I'll go to
1:08:31the Apple store, look at the nano texture and think, yes, this is what I
1:08:35want and then buy it and then put it in my office and it'll look totally
1:08:38different. And I'll be like,
1:08:39Oh, here, here's what we'll do. I will go return it on your behalf. If you'll
1:08:43take me to hop, sing, because that's something I don't know if we're gonna
1:08:46have the time to talk about today, but I am very mad at myself that I never
1:08:50made the track up to Philly for like coca love or anything and go to hop sing.
1:08:53So I will, I will trade you one very socially awkward return in favor of
1:08:58getting me in the door. If that works for you, I will take you there. The,
1:09:02the things I've heard about nano texture from the XDR people are, and
1:09:06actually I think, cause Neil, I told me that some of the verge staffers
1:09:10really liked the nano texture, like their photographers. And so they really
1:09:13like it, but that the problem is that it's a real bitch to clean. If, yeah,
1:09:18I've heard the same. If somebody touches it, like you get like one
1:09:21thumbprint on the damn thing and it's like a grease spot that you cannot get
1:09:27off. And it does, you know, the nice thing is that it does ship with Apple's
1:09:30$19 polishing cloth. So you get that free, really. It's like getting a free
1:09:36$19 polishing cloth. Yeah. I bought the polishing cloth, the standalone one,
1:09:41just because I had to, uh, it ships and it's so funny. It, it, it, the
1:09:46packaging, you know how they, they, they, the Apple packaging, the
1:09:51instructions have very few words. They're sort of like Lego instructions,
1:09:55you know, like Lego and Ikea where they're sort of pictograms that just
1:09:59show you what to do instead of explaining it. So they don't, they can
1:10:02just ship the same thing worldwide. They tell you not to use the side with
1:10:08the Apple logo on it. Oh, I did not know that. Yeah. But I don't know why
1:10:12Jonas and I looked at it and we're like, honest to God, you can touch it.
1:10:16You can look at it. You can feel it. It doesn't look like there's any
1:10:19difference, but they, there's like a little circle with a line through it.
1:10:21Like don't use the side with the Apple logo, use the other side and go in a
1:10:24circular motion. And it's funny cause I don't have colleagues, you know, I, if
1:10:29anybody can get this display to never be touched by human fingers, it's
1:10:35probably me. I mean, you'd have to be like a genuine hermit, you know, to,
1:10:39to make it, but it could happen. You're right. You never know. Right. And
1:10:45it's like, I'm, I'm an anti touch the screen person period, but you know,
1:10:50and I can be a little, Hey, Hey, what are you doing? You know? Yep. Yep.
1:10:54But if I get the nano texture, it's going to have to be like, I'm going to
1:10:57have to put like red, red tape on the ground. Or do you like some sort of
1:11:01like infrared beam? Like what was the movie with Catherine Zeta Jones and
1:11:05Sean Connery and trap mint? Is that it? Where she goes like dancing through the
1:11:09through the laser beam maze, you know what I'm saying? You're going to put
1:11:12like a laser beam maze in front of the screen or some sort of proximity
1:11:16alarm or something. Yeah. You know, I got it. So I'm looking at the the
1:11:19buy page for the studio display and it is clearly not popular at all because
1:11:25I tell you what, the only thing you can get in less than quote eight to 10
1:11:29weeks is the tilt adjustable stand. If you go, so it's in height, adjustable
1:11:34eight to 10 weeks, you're not even telling you like a month. It's just
1:11:36eight to 10 weeks. These amount adapter eight to 10 weeks. I mean, obviously
1:11:39everyone, it's not just you and me that are waiting for a cold glass in
1:11:43hell. Like everyone is interested in this. It seems cause I know it's, you
1:11:46know, supply chain and blah, blah, blah. But still, I got to imagine if
1:11:50anyone would get their supply chain squared away for a new product, it
1:11:53would be Apple. And from the looks of it, these things are sold out for
1:11:57forever. Yeah. And I combination maybe of pent up demand and supply.
1:12:02Yeah, fair enough. Shame problems. I don't know. Anyway, talking about the
1:12:05display itself, I, I, I, I'm very happy with my review from a week ago, but
1:12:13I'll tell you, I was nervous because I've spent so much time bitching about
1:12:18the camera and it's, and it's not nervousness like, oh, you know, you're
1:12:25not supposed to give bad reviews to Apple products. It's just like, am I
1:12:29nuts? Right. It's not, it's not any sort of like, you know, feeling that
1:12:33I'm not supposed to say bad that I love it. You know, in theory, it's
1:12:36like, you know, anybody who wants to accuse me of being a Homer for Apple
1:12:40products, it's like the best thing to happen is, you know, get one that you
1:12:43don't like and then tell people about why. But the camera thing in
1:12:47particular was making me feel like gaslit. Like, am I nuts? Am I, you
1:12:52know, and you know, it's, I did commiserate with Nilay and Joanna. I
1:12:59forget who reached out to whom first. I forget if it was me. I think I
1:13:04reached out to Nilay and say, hey, do you have this thing? And, you know,
1:13:07and then we did like a three person FaceTime, it just the three of us and
1:13:12we're all, we were all like on the same page. Like I'm sort of thinking
1:13:15this camera is really makes me look, looks, it's bad quality period. It's
1:13:20fuzzy, it's noisy and really does a bad number on skin tones across the
1:13:26board. And we're all looking at each other like, yeah, we look terrible.
1:13:30And then I was like, well, wait a second, you know, input magazine, Ray
1:13:34Wong at input got Apple to confirm first that it's the same front facing
1:13:39camera as the new iPad Air, which in turn is the same front facing camera
1:13:43that's been in the iPad Pro for a year. Basically, one way to think about
1:13:47it is that so far, every Apple device that supports center stage uses the
1:13:52same camera hardware and ultra wide, I think 12 megapixel, but who cares
1:13:56what the ultra wide field of view front facing camera. And I was like, I've
1:14:02got the iPad Air right here. I'm doing a review of that too here. I'm getting
1:14:06off. I'm going to hop back on with the iPad Air. And I did on the same call.
1:14:10And I was like, do I look better? And I was like, I think I look better in
1:14:13my preview. And they're like, oh, you look, you look way better. You look
1:14:16way. And we're like this. Yeah, this is crazy. And I'm like, all right, I'm
1:14:20going to get off and go back to the studio display. Do I look worse?
1:14:22Yes, you look now you look, you look sick.
1:14:25Yeah. So I went to the Apple store yesterday, like you had said, and I had
1:14:32read all the reviews. I'd read yours. I'd seen the verges review and I'd seen
1:14:35Joanna's really good video where she did like kind of a play on March
1:14:39Madness, which I mean, her video work is so good. It's infuriating how good
1:14:42it is. She is basically everything.
1:14:44You know, she won an Emmy.
1:14:45I did not know that. Did she really?
1:14:47Yeah, she won an Emmy for the thing about the thing last year about how to plan
1:14:52for your eventual death. Yeah, she'll never let me forget it. Emmy award-winning
1:15:00Joanna Stern.
1:15:00Emmy award-winning, that's right. But no, she is so impossibly good at what she
1:15:03does. And anyways, so I went to the Apple store and I'm playing around the
1:15:07display and leaving the camera side just very briefly, like the panel looks
1:15:11great. And of course, you know, I'm trying to think of ways in which I can
1:15:16try to exercise this display that's not connected to a machine that I can
1:15:21only retrospect. I should have just brought my computer and connected it.
1:15:23It just occurred to me just now, but nevertheless, you know, it's connected
1:15:26to a M1 Mac's Mac studio and I'm trying to think of things that I can do to
1:15:31kind of exercise the display and show what it's made of. And I looked at the
1:15:35photos that the canned photos and the photos app on Apple's display Mac. And
1:15:40of course, they're all gorgeous. And this display looks phenomenal. I ended
1:15:44up logging into my own Plex server, you know, from the web and playing a
1:15:49little bit of Hamilton in 4k and they looked great. You know, it looked
1:15:55phenomenal. And then I opened up Photo Booth to take a picture of myself just
1:16:00to see, well, first of all, to verify that center stage does not work in
1:16:03Photo Booth, which I was pretty sure was going to be the case, but
1:16:06nevertheless, I wanted to see. And then I took a picture of myself and I
1:16:09uploaded it to my Synology at home so I could look at it later. And when I
1:16:13was looking at it in the Apple store, it looked fine. Like I wouldn't say it
1:16:18was great, but it looked fine. But then I was walking out of the mall and I
1:16:21was looking at it on my phone and I started zooming in and I'm like, "Oh,
1:16:24oh, this is not that fine at all. This is actually not great." It's really
1:16:30not a fantastic picture. And in particular, a lot of the fine details,
1:16:35like the wrinkles in my forehead, for example, I feel like they're very, very
1:16:39fuzzy. Like everything just seems fuzzier than I would expect. It very
1:16:42much looks like the 720p front-facing cameras that were on Apple laptops
1:16:46for 18 frickin' years. And it looks kind of like that. And based on my gut,
1:16:53I'm inclined to believe that when Apple says, "Oh, it's software, it's
1:16:57software, it's software," that it probably is. Like, I assume that to be
1:17:01true, but golly, for right now, it does not look great. It really doesn't.
1:17:06Tom: It was such a weird saga, publishing the review, and then hearing from,
1:17:12you know, and all of my interaction up to the point of publishing was through
1:17:16Apple PR. And Apple PR, when you're dealing with them as a reviewer, is not
1:17:20a faceless organization. I know people there, and the people who I was
1:17:25communicating with are people who I've known for years there. It's not just
1:17:29like, you know, as a reviewer, you're not just sending email to applepr@apple.com
1:17:34and getting a response from somebody you don't know. You know, there was—
1:17:38it was unusual, because usually if you're as a reviewer, you encounter a
1:17:44problem and you let them know. And, you know, and I don't know—I can't speak
1:17:49for everybody who reviews products, but I—and Neelay and Joanna and I were
1:17:53both—the three of us were talking about it, that all three of us are of a
1:17:56similar mindset, where we don't want to surprise anybody, you know, we don't
1:18:01want to surprise Apple. We tell them, you know, and when they ask, you know,
1:18:05like halfway through the week of reviewing, "What are your thoughts?" I'm
1:18:09always very honest, you know, positive or negative, you know, like, "Here's
1:18:13what I think so far," you know, and there's negative stuff comes up from
1:18:16time to time. And, you know, I told them about the camera and I sent them
1:18:19images. I was like, "Look," you know, and here's the same—in the same
1:18:22lighting, you know, similar to the ones I published, although the ones I had
1:18:26originally was unshowered. There was—funny backstory is the ones I did
1:18:30publish when the sunlight was literally hitting me in the face, and it was
1:18:35like—and my first thought was, "Well, of course my face is blown out in this
1:18:39sunlight because it's bright sunlight right on my face," and I thought, "Well,
1:18:42wait, let me see what this iPad Air does with the exact same camera," and
1:18:45exposed my face perfectly. And literally 15 seconds later, but I looked
1:18:51terrible, and I was like, "Oh my God, the sun—I got it—I don't know what
1:18:54the weather's going to be like for the next two days." It ended up being
1:18:57overcast from the next days until the reviews came out, so I had to, like,
1:19:01quick scram—like, run to get a shower, you know, like—
1:19:04Steven: See, the life of a reviewer is hard, John.
1:19:07It's not just free stuff.
1:19:08John: I know. It's like—because we just watched the Home Alone movies
1:19:11over Christmas, and I'm reminded. It's like when they, you know, realized the
1:19:14alarm clock was busted and they're late for the airport. It's like, I'm
1:19:17like—I'm like literally like, "Out of my way!" and "I'm getting a shower. I
1:19:21need to take a photo before the sunlight passes," you know, and it was. It's
1:19:25actually, you know, it was like aerobic exercise. No, but I told them, and
1:19:29then they were like, "Oh, yeah, there is some—you know, we definitely see
1:19:31it. That's not right. Let me get back to you." But the "Let me get back to
1:19:35you" part took much longer than usual, and then they got back to us, you
1:19:38know, pretty late before the reviews with a very similar statement, you
1:19:43know, that, you know, "We've identified some problems, and a future
1:19:46software fix will improve it," something like that. Then I published,
1:19:50and I started hearing from some of my sources who are unofficial, you
1:19:53know, just people inside Apple who read the site, and some of them, you
1:19:57know, it's like, you know, one of the very lucky things of my career and
1:20:02having been doing this for long enough is that I've, you know, there's a
1:20:06level of trust and certain people who I know, and, you know, guess what? I
1:20:10wound up communicating with people who've used the studio display inside
1:20:17Apple while it's being developed at certain stages. They're like, "Yeah,
1:20:21mine doesn't look like that, but mine's running like a dev build of the
1:20:26firmware, you know, it's not up to date," and that something, something
1:20:30happened late in the game. I still don't know detail. I cannot—there's no
1:20:34backstory, you know, no betrayal of trust or spilling any guts. I don't
1:20:39know the details of what in the hell happened, and I realize how crazy this
1:20:43is, right? So I wrote an update and said, "What I've heard from little
1:20:47birdies who are familiar with the matter is that some kind of bug was
1:20:51introduced late in the game, and part of the miscommunication between,
1:20:56like, the reviewers and Apple PR is that they weren't even seeing it
1:20:59because they might have been using very late prototypes that they—I
1:21:02don't know this for sure, I could be wrong—but I believe that they were
1:21:05running very late prototypes that they thought were truly commensurate
1:21:09with what will be the actual shipping ones but aren't and have somewhat
1:21:14better, to some degree better image quality out of the camera. But what
1:21:17I've been told is that it should be at least as good as the iPad Air and
1:21:21current iPad Pros, and it's not. And nobody—it doesn't—that's one of the
1:21:25weird things and one of the things that made me, like, such a relief is
1:21:28it's not like some of the reviewers are saying the camera's not that
1:21:31great and others are saying, "Ah, it's just as good as the iPad," and it's
1:21:35like, "No, everybody agrees it's not as good as an iPad," and it's kind of
1:21:39weird that Apple confirmed it's the same camera hardware because they
1:21:42usually don't confirm stuff like that, right? Like, I fix it, and I
1:21:47fix it, we'll take it apart and prove that it's the same component two
1:21:51days later, but they still won't tell you. Or famously, with RAM,
1:21:56they'll never ever—until recently, they would never ever tell you how
1:21:59much RAM was in an iPhone. They're like, "Ah, we don't talk about that,"
1:22:02and it's like, "Well, somebody's going to take it apart or run, you
1:22:05know, run one of those utilities." You have apps in the App Store that
1:22:09will tell you how much—
1:22:10Jared: How much is this hard?
1:22:12Steven: —how much memories on this system, but they will not confirm it.
1:22:15Jared; It's the worst kept-state secret ever.
1:22:17Steven; So, my basic take on the camera is, as it stands, it is truly
1:22:23subpar. I mean, it is poor. It is a poor camera that it seems
1:22:27inexplicably bad with skin tones and sharpness and noise and low
1:22:32light and sunlight, you know, bright sunlight and low light at night,
1:22:38bad. It clearly does not produce as good an image quality as the iPad
1:22:43Air and iPad Pro front-facing camera, not the rear-facing camera, but
1:22:47I've been told that it, through firmware updates, that something
1:22:51could be fixed and that it would—it probably won't match the iPad Air
1:22:56exactly because I think they're doing some different stuff, and I don't
1:22:59know this for sure, that makes sense where you're at a different
1:23:04distance from the studio display than you typically are from an iPad,
1:23:08right? It's, for me, my comfortable distance from a desktop display is
1:23:12roughly arm's length, like with my palm up, like giving the famous,
1:23:16you know, like telling somebody to stop. That's about how far I sit
1:23:20from a display. Nobody holds their iPad at arm's length distance,
1:23:25right? Well, I shouldn't say nobody because we talked about vision
1:23:28problems. Somebody somewhere has a vision problem where their perfect
1:23:31distance is arm's length, so let's acknowledge that, but typical
1:23:35iPad distance is closer. So, I think they're doing something different
1:23:38with the cropping, with the ultra-wide for center stage, where it may
1:23:42not be the exact same image, but the image quality should be the same.
1:23:47I believe that. Why not?
1:23:49Yeah, I think it surely will get better, and I'm looking at your post
1:23:55again, and not the first batch of shots when you were in sunlight, but
1:23:58the second batch of shots where you're being artificially lit.
1:24:01Right.
1:24:02Like, if you look at the first shot, you can see a couple of wrinkles,
1:24:05normal wrinkles in your forehead. You can make out some hair in, you
1:24:08know, the hair in your beard to some degree, and then you look at the
1:24:11studio display shot, and the whiter portion of your beard is like a blob.
1:24:15Yeah.
1:24:16Your shirt loses any semblance of, like, weave or anything to it. It's
1:24:20almost like you put on a sheet, and it's a different color blue, by the
1:24:23way, even though it's the exact same shirt. Like, it's so abundantly
1:24:27obvious the differences between the two, and by the way, the second
1:24:30shot of you with the sheet that is cut like a shirt rather than a shirt.
1:24:34It very much matches my experience in the Apple store with the
1:24:37artificial light there, you know, where your forehead is kind of, like,
1:24:40is flattened, your beard is kind of, like, been, I don't know,
1:24:45unsharpened, de-sharpened, and your shirt, you can't see the weave at
1:24:48all, and that very much looks like the image that I took of myself at
1:24:51the Apple store. And I got to imagine, you know, like I said, mine is
1:24:55shipping in a week or two. I would assume, based on zero insider
1:25:00knowledge, that by around the time mine comes in, I bet you will see
1:25:04at least a first crack at a fix at this, because I can't imagine that
1:25:06they're happy about this PR at all.
1:25:08Steve McLaughlin Yeah, and I think that part of the bad feeling about it
1:25:12is that first impressions are so important, and they're so hard to
1:25:15shake, and so I think the ultimate story will play out like this, that
1:25:20they will ship some sort of firmware update. I think the firmware
1:25:23update will improve image quality to be somewhat, or mostly, or fairly
1:25:29said commensurate with the iPad front-pacing cameras on the Air and
1:25:32Pro. I think center stage is going to improve, and my complaints about
1:25:36center stage, where I called it off center stage, because if I turn my
1:25:40head to the side and come back, I'm off center, and then three or four
1:25:43seconds later, literally, like, I'm not exaggerating, it's like four
1:25:46seconds, and then it sheepishly repans to put me in the center again,
1:25:51like, "Oops, sorry, I forgot we were moved." I've since learned some
1:25:55more about what they were thinking there and why it does that, and it's
1:25:58sort of, it's like what I was doing, which I wasn't trying to trick it,
1:26:04I literally, well, it's good, you know, you're the one on the show, but
1:26:07to avoid KC-ing myself, I tend to keep my, any beverages I'm drinking
1:26:14off to the side, and I have an L-shaped desk, it's over to the right,
1:26:19and so while I was FaceTiming my son as a test, I went over to get a
1:26:23drink of a beverage, turned my head to the side, and moved to the side,
1:26:27and then came back, and now I'm off center, and I'm like, "Whoa!"
1:26:30I, it wasn't like I was trying to trick it out. I never ran into that
1:26:35with center stage on an iPad, there seems to be no way to fool it,
1:26:38similarly. It seems like it's a feature, not a bug, though, in that
1:26:42it's sort of like an anti-, what they thought was an anti-fidget feature,
1:26:46like for somebody who is, like, you're in a long Zoom meeting for work,
1:26:51an hour-long meeting, and you're there, and, you know, you might slouch
1:26:54a little, you just, you know, you get a little restless in your chair,
1:26:57it's, it's, Face, it, the center stage algorithm is different on the
1:27:01studio display than on the iPads, by choice, for reasons that I think
1:27:06are good, but I think that they didn't, that there are things people
1:27:10do in front of the camera, like turn your head to the side, that they
1:27:13didn't anticipate, and I, I, that's clearly a software that they could
1:27:16fix, right? Because they could, they could just delete all of the center
1:27:21stage code and just put the iPad code in, and it would do the same thing
1:27:24the iPad does, right? So, I'm sure that's fixable. I think it'll happen,
1:27:28but I, I still think in my, in my gut, I expect a better camera than the
1:27:35iPad front-facing camera. I, I, because it's, it's a $1600 display, it is
1:27:40three-quarters of an inch thick, and I just attribute some of the, eh, not
1:27:46bad for a front-facing camera, overall quality of iPad Pros and the iPad Air
1:27:50to, well, look at how thin this thing is, right? And, and the rear-facing
1:27:54camera sticks out, well, the front-facing camera isn't going to stick out
1:27:58on an Apple device, so of course the image quality is a little less, but
1:28:02the studio display has all the thickness in the world for a webcam,
1:28:06you know? So, I kind of feel like, I, I still feel like even when they do
1:28:11quote-unquote "fix" the image quality, I'm still going to be mildly
1:28:16disappointed with it, I, compared to what I think they could have built
1:28:20into this thickness display for a $1600 display and up without center
1:28:27stage. I, I just don't personally, eh, you know, maybe other people do,
1:28:31maybe I'm the wrong market, I just don't see when I'm going to use this
1:28:34where I really want center stage. Well, so I think there's a few things
1:28:38to unpack there, and I think some of it is that the studio display has
1:28:44some really, really weird price anchoring going on around it, right?
1:28:48Because the LG Ultrafine, the 5K one, is $1300, I believe, and honestly,
1:28:53I don't personally perceive it as a $1300 monitor. I think at best it's a
1:28:58$1000 monitor, and I think more realistically it should probably, can
1:29:02maybe be even a little bit cheaper than that, because as I said earlier,
1:29:06you know, everything about it is an exercise in mediocrity, and so when
1:29:10you compare yourself to the LG 5K, and MKVHD did a really good video on
1:29:15whether or not the studio display is a good deal, and the thesis of his
1:29:20video was, you know, it depends on what you're after, and this is what
1:29:23you and I were talking about earlier, you know, if you're a PC user, no,
1:29:25it's a terrible deal, but if you're a Mac user who has a particular set
1:29:28of priorities, then yeah, it's actually a pretty good deal. Why is it a
1:29:31pretty good deal? Because it's only $300-ish more than the, than the
1:29:35LG Ultrafine, but then if you consider the fact that I personally believe
1:29:41that the LG Ultrafine is kind of drastically overpriced, then you start
1:29:45thinking about, well, for a $1600 monitor, you know, shouldn't you have
1:29:50a better webcam? And then you end up exactly where you were saying, John,
1:29:52like, it seems like you should be able to do better for $1600. And I feel
1:29:59like I understand why Apple went the way of using known hardware and
1:30:05presumably a lot of known software. I mean, it's since come out that this
1:30:09thing is basically running iOS or not exactly iOS, but very, very similar
1:30:14to iOS in a, what was it, an A13 in the screen or something like that?
1:30:17Well, I think, I think it is iOS. It's just that they've, you know,
1:30:21retrofitted it to just do what they, what they want to do. But like,
1:30:25literally the build number is, is exactly the same as 15.4.
1:30:29Right. Exactly. But, but, you know, I think one, one thing that I was
1:30:34really excited when I was watching the presentation, I was really excited
1:30:38for Center Stage. And, and I think the reason that I'm super excited for
1:30:42Center Stage is because I have a slightly different use case than you do.
1:30:45And if you think about it, if I was going to get on a FaceTime call with
1:30:48like my parents or my grandparents or something like that, it's not just me
1:30:52or me and Aaron who will mostly stay still and mostly either be in the
1:30:56shot or not. And that's something that as grownups, we can manage. But I
1:31:00have a seven year old and a four year old, and they will be running in and
1:31:04out of the shot and running around and so on and so forth. And so I think
1:31:09in that case, for, if you consider using this as like a family phone call
1:31:14device, then I think Center Stage could potentially make a lot of sense,
1:31:18but it also worries me a little bit that perhaps Center Stage as set up in
1:31:23the studio display is going to be a little lethargic for the needs of a
1:31:28parent of a seven year old and a four year old, you know? And I understand
1:31:31what you're saying about, well, if you're in a zoom call and you're just,
1:31:33you know, rocking a teeny bit, you don't want to be, have the distraction
1:31:36of the pseudo-cameraman rocking back and forth as well. That's not my life,
1:31:41you know? And in the same way that you kind of sort of don't have colleagues,
1:31:44I kind of sort of don't have colleagues, you know, Marco and John and Mike
1:31:48accepted in many ways I'm by myself and I don't often find myself on video
1:31:52calls. And so if I were to find myself on a video call for me, that would
1:31:56be like a social thing, like a family thing. And in that case, that would be
1:32:02very useful to have Center Stage. So it's hard as with all things, when
1:32:05you're at Apple scale, like who do you emphasize or who do you really
1:32:09consider to be your core user? You know, what user story is the story that
1:32:14you really latch onto? And there's no right answer. And since Apple is
1:32:17allergic to settings, you know, it's not like I can flip back and forth
1:32:19between the John Gruber algorithm and the Casey Liss algorithm, you know?
1:32:22So you just got to do the best with what you got. But I think it, I really
1:32:26think the software is going to get better. I could make an argument, we
1:32:29talked about this on this week's ATP, I can make an argument that maybe
1:32:32there's a little too much software in the display. But on the flip side of
1:32:36that, I'm saying that from the privileged position of having a brand
1:32:41new MacBook Pro. You know, one of the great things about this display is
1:32:44that Center Stage and all those things that are unique to Apple Silicon
1:32:49can be run on an Intel-powered MacBook or MacBook Pro. And that's really
1:32:54awesome and something that I don't think I've given Apple enough credit
1:32:58for because I don't really care. I don't have any Intel devices around.
1:33:03Well, I guess Erin's adorable. I pass that down to her, but you know,
1:33:06she's not ever going to plug into the display. So I don't have any Intel
1:33:09devices around anymore. So I don't really care that it's backwards
1:33:12compatible. But that is a very unusual thing for Apple to do and just be
1:33:16that cognizant in that forthcoming, for lack of a better word, with older
1:33:21devices and saying, you know what, we've got you covered. We'll put the
1:33:24Silicon in the display rather than you needing to have it on the thing the
1:33:27display is connected to.
1:33:28Yeah, that's definitely possible. I mean, and you know, I ran it. This is
1:33:32the other weird thing. I did run it on, did I mention this in my review? I
1:33:37think I did. Maybe in a footnote. Yeah, in a footnote that I initially
1:33:41hooked it up to my MacBook Pro, which is running macOS 12.2, which is
1:33:45officially unsupported, but more or less just runs it like a dumb display.
1:33:49Like you can hook it up to a PC, you know, you just don't get Center Stage,
1:33:53but you still, you know, your PC connected by Thunderbolt will see a
1:33:56webcam, it'll hear the microphones, it'll, you know, play sound. I swear to
1:34:00God, I got better image quality, even though I did. There was something
1:34:04else, there's something else involved, something with the Center Stage part
1:34:08of it, right? And I think that's, it's not, I was like, is it because the M1
1:34:13in my Mac was using, it was something, something, I think it's something to
1:34:17do with Center Stage. And by plugging it into a Mac that didn't have 12.3
1:34:22yet and Center Stage wasn't there, image quality was definitely a little
1:34:25better. There's no question in my mind, a little, not, but not like, still
1:34:29not like iPad quality, which is to me where the bar should be set. I get it
1:34:33though, I totally get your, and it always comes back to this with Apple
1:34:37products, where Apple does not make everything, right? They, here's what
1:34:41we're going to make, you know, and Tim Cook's famous, you can spread our
1:34:44entire product line on a table. Well, now they need like a really big table,
1:34:49but, but still the mindset is still there. They don't make everything and
1:34:55okay, they made an option for nano texture, you know, which is, you know,
1:34:59I'm glad it exists whether I end up buying it or not. That speaks, you know,
1:35:02that's an option they didn't have to build. It is interesting to me that
1:35:06with the Pro Display XDR, nano texture is an extra thousand dollars and it's
1:35:10only, only $300. Like I said, some weird price anchoring on this thing.
1:35:16But I totally get it though, that this display, because they've discontinued
1:35:20the 27-inch iMac, that this display is the 27-inch display solution for
1:35:27anybody and everybody in the Mac world who wants a 27-inch display. And I
1:35:31totally, totally know firsthand from my own family, you know, that there are
1:35:35lots and lots of families who have a 27-inch iMac as their family room
1:35:40computer and want to do things like you said, like call, let's call the
1:35:44grandparents on FaceTime. Come on over kids, you know, and you know, they
1:35:48live across the state or across the country even and you know, it's
1:35:52somebody's birthday and let's get everybody in here. And center stage,
1:35:55in theory, should be way better than not having center stage in that
1:35:59scenario. And this monitor is supposed to fit that need. And somebody like
1:36:04me who's literally only using it for work and no longer has little kids,
1:36:08you know, I don't need that. I totally acknowledge that, that, you know,
1:36:11this isn't designed necessarily for my exact needs, but I get it. If you're
1:36:14going to do it one way, maybe doing the center stage thing is a good
1:36:19solution. I get it.
1:36:19CURTIS LYON And actually that makes me think of a question I've wanted to
1:36:23talk to you about. Do you begrudge the death of the 27-inch iMac? Because I
1:36:30think if you look at Apple's lineup right now, that's a pretty big hole
1:36:35that they left. But, and I think the biggest, the hole is predominantly,
1:36:40what if you don't want a laptop, but you want like an M1 Max, or potentially,
1:36:45I guess, an M1 Ultra, but particularly an M1 Max, or you maybe are backed
1:36:48into an M1 Max because you want more than 16 gigs of RAM or what have you,
1:36:52then you really don't have a good answer for that right now. But I don't
1:36:57find this to be too alarming because I've got to imagine that there's going
1:37:01to be a new Mac Mini sooner rather than later that either will have an M2
1:37:05that supports more than 16 gigs of RAM, or maybe they'll offer an M1 Max or
1:37:09something like that. So I really feel like this hole in the lineup for a
1:37:1327-inch computer that's pseudo-professional, I think it's going to get
1:37:19filled real soon. I think it'll be filled by a beefier Mac Mini. And if you
1:37:23leave aside the fact that this hypothetical forthcoming Mac Mini in
1:37:27Studio Display Combo, it isn't all-in-one, which our mutual friend
1:37:32John Siracusa was very perturbed about, but leaving aside that it's not
1:37:35all-in-one, I feel like a slightly better Mac Mini as paired with the
1:37:38Studio Display pretty nicely fills the hole left by the 27-inch iMac. But
1:37:44I'm curious what your thoughts are on that. Am I missing the boat? I mean,
1:37:48again, today it's kind of crummy, but tomorrow, figuratively speaking, I've
1:37:52got to imagine this hole will be filled, no? Well, I think that this is a
1:37:57better lineup. And you're putting both of us in dangerous territory because
1:38:02the people who really want Apple to make an all-in-one 27-inch iMac
1:38:07really, really want it. I mean, they're probably gin-martini
1:38:11drinkers as well. It must be. They're angry, you know, not
1:38:15angry, but they're adamant. Again, in a hypothetical world app
1:38:20where Apple makes everything it could make, they would make
1:38:23both a 27-inch iMac right now with MacBook Pro guts, right?
1:38:33The 14 and 16-inch MacBook Pro guts where you could get
1:38:37the, you know, what are the options? You get a regular M1 or an M1 Max.
1:38:42Oh, God. You know, for podcasting, the Max name is so terrible.
1:38:46So bad. It's so bad. It looks fine, so when you're reading it, it always reads like
1:38:50maximum. Yeah, sure. But when you're saying it on a podcast, it always sounds like
1:38:54you're pluralizing Mac. I wish they hadn't done that. But
1:38:59anyway, yeah, so something like that where it scales exactly like the MacBook Pro
1:39:04lines, MacBook Pro 14 and 16-inch guts in a 27-inch iMac where the range
1:39:10would go from lower price with a regular M1 and only 16 gigs of RAM to an M1 Max
1:39:16with up to 64 gigs of RAM and all the performance.
1:39:20It would be great if they made that in addition to the studio display.
1:39:24Totally. And, you know, I know firsthand, you don't have to write to me
1:39:28again. I get it. I've heard from you. No, no, and I'm not complaining. I love getting
1:39:32you. I love getting email from you because I did. It helps me know what people
1:39:35want. I know that you're out there and I know that that's what you would want. But
1:39:38if they're only going to make one and for many, many years, as we talked
1:39:42earlier on the show, the one was the 27-inch iMac, which was not a solution if
1:39:46you wanted a desktop display for a MacBook, right? And it took out target
1:39:50display mode for reasons. And it seemed foolish anyway. I mean, we used to, you
1:39:56know, I know everybody with a podcast has made jokes that I would buy a
1:40:0027-inch iMac and use it as a display if I could, but I can't. And just ignore
1:40:06the Mac inside. We're sort of doing that now where we're ignoring the A13
1:40:12computer that's inside, right? There is sort of a, what could be a Mac inside,
1:40:17right? The Mac dev units last summer or two summers ago were A12Xs. So there's
1:40:22an A13 in this son of a bitch, you know? It kind of is. But if they were only
1:40:29going to do one or the other, this clearly is the way. And it's, you know,
1:40:35it's a modular way of thinking. And all in one, well, define all in one. I
1:40:41really need to write this as a follow-up on Daring Fireball because even the
1:40:4624-inch iMac, okay, that's all in one, right? Just do that, but 27 inches. Well,
1:40:52it's not all in one though, because it has a really big external power brick.
1:41:00And literally the size, it's almost exactly the size and weight of an Apple
1:41:05TV 4K. You know, I've put one, I've stacked one on top of it. It's almost
1:41:10the exact same footprint. I didn't get my scale out, but putting one in one
1:41:15hand and one in the other. It's about the same. So it's, you know, what would
1:41:20be the difference if they shrunk the Mac Mini to the size of Apple TV 4K and
1:41:27using that to power an external display? Well, that's the exact same thing that
1:41:31the 24-inch iMac is, right? The Apple Studio display, remarkably, in my
1:41:36opinion, has no power brick. It is just a cable that comes out of the back.
1:41:42It's just a regular cable that goes in the wall. And then you can plug a
1:41:45MacBook in and get 96-watt charging out of it with no brick. So define what's
1:41:52all in one, right? Like, so if you have a Mac Mini and you connect it to this
1:41:58display, you've got one thing. Okay, the Mac Mini, at least the one we know
1:42:02so far with the M1, is bigger than the 24-inch iMac's power brick. But it is
1:42:10a brick and it is external. Either way, you've got a thing external to the
1:42:16display on your desk. You know? See, I totally agree with you, but then,
1:42:21channeling my inner John Siracusa, then the argument would be, well, they never
1:42:24used a brick on prior 27-inch devices, so obviously they wouldn't this time.
1:42:28Duh. Yeah, but they were a lot thicker, you know? I agree. No, I'm right there
1:42:33with you. I'm right there with you. They were like, it's edge-to-edge thin,
1:42:37it's so thin, and it was, you know, and I get it, I like that my 5K iMac
1:42:42bulbous sort of pregnant back, I like the way that it, I think it's worth it
1:42:46to make it taper to the edges, but the middle of the thing was, you know, it
1:42:50was not all in one thickness thin, and that's what Apple wants to make. So
1:42:55again, you could say, well, you don't need the brick, you could just put a
1:42:58big box on the back of the thing, but now you're talking about a thing Apple
1:43:02doesn't want to make, right? They don't want to put a box on the back of the
1:43:04thing, and this modularity really solves the biggest problem. If, again, they
1:43:10could make both, both the 27-inch iMac and this display, but 80% at least, I
1:43:15mean, Apple doesn't break it down, but, you know, common sense tells you most
1:43:19people buy MacBooks. Some little birdie info that I'm privy to says it was at
1:43:25least 80% in 2021, and that Apple expects that number to continue going up
1:43:30towards more than 80% of MacBooks in 2022. They expect, or max total, they
1:43:36expect to be MacBooks of some sort. Even though their desktop game is better
1:43:41than it has been in memory, that's just the way the world is going, and now
1:43:46they have a display that can plug into any MacBook, it's great, and if you do
1:43:51really want a desktop, you don't want to plug a MacBook in, you want to plug a
1:43:54desktop in, the modularity of this is phenomenal, and I think it's only going
1:43:59to be even better once the M2 Mac Minis come out, which I think, I don't know
1:44:05that they're going to go lower in price, but it should fill in some of the gaps
1:44:10in the middle of, well, I want a Mac Mini, but I actually, you know, I want
1:44:15like 64 gigs of RAM.
1:44:16Trenton Larkin Exactly.
1:44:17Dave King They'll have that, and then you can buy it, and yes, it's not all in
1:44:21one, but you've just got one thing, one box, and I am, nobody talks about it,
1:44:30but I feel like there have been two stories with Apple's Apple Silicon Macs.
1:44:35There was the first round in 2020 at the end where they put the M1 chips into
1:44:41exactly the same chassis as their Intel ones, and I've talked to people at
1:44:48Apple, this was done for multiple reasons, but one of them was secrecy, that
1:44:52they did not want, you know, anybody, their competitors or Intel to know that,
1:44:59you know, and no, everybody knew that, it seems, you know, for years, we were
1:45:02all, you know, it was like half of all of our podcasts, when is Apple going to
1:45:06move from Intel to Apple Silicon, right?
1:45:08Trenton Larkin Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:45:08Dave King Look at these, look at these as Geekbench numbers, these bananas, my
1:45:11phone gets a higher score, but they wanted to keep it secret inside the
1:45:15company, and the best way to keep it secret was to keep the hardware
1:45:19completely unchanged to the maximum level, except for the silicon
1:45:26architecture and the MacBook Air, the 13-inch MacBook Pro, the Mac Mini,
1:45:33what else was there? Did they do the M1? Was there an old-looking 16-inch?
1:45:38Yeah, there must have been, right?
1:45:39Trenton Larkin I think that's right, yeah.
1:45:40Dave King They all looked exactly the same, and then,
1:45:43starting with the iMac, 24-inch iMac last year, we started seeing the first
1:45:47Mac hardware designed from the ground up around Apple Silicon, and guess what?
1:45:52It's really impressive, right?
1:45:54Trenton Larkin Who'd have thunk it?
1:45:55Dave King It's crazy thin, like, you could not build
1:45:59the 24-inch iMac out of Intel Silicon, you couldn't do it, and I think that the
1:46:0514- and 16-inch MacBook Pros that you and I have now, 14-inch, obviously,
1:46:11those could be Intel, because, you know, they actually got thicker and heavier,
1:46:15because they sort of went, like, more, "Let's give Pros Pro features."
1:46:19So I feel like that throws people off, but I feel like at the consumer level,
1:46:24the iMac shows the way, and that they want to make crazy thin, light, small things that they
1:46:30couldn't build before. And so, the next round of consumer MacBooks, whether they—I don't know if
1:46:37they're going to call it MacBook Air anymore—I really think they're going to get rid of the
1:46:4113-inch MacBook Pro branding, because I think that they've clarified, "Pro? Okay, we really mean Pro.
1:46:48Pro means Pro." And, you know, maybe they'll call, like, the higher-end 13-inch MacBook,
1:46:56you know, that is, you know, like, what the two-port 13-inch Pro was. Maybe they'll call
1:47:00it the MacBook Studio, right? They've introduced this—
1:47:03Trenton Larkin Oh, that'd be interesting.
1:47:04Dave King They've introduced this new word "studio"
1:47:06that sort of occupies the prosumer space, you know? I don't know, that's just a spitball
1:47:11I—names never, ever, ever leak to me, so I—if there actually is a MacBook Studio, it's truly a
1:47:17guess on my part. But I would expect the new MacBook Air to be, like, the 12-inch adorable,
1:47:22super, super thin, crazy thin. This is insane. It's insane how thin this thing is.
1:47:27Trenton Larkin Yeah, and I loved that computer so much. So,
1:47:31at the time in which I bought the 12-inch MacBook, which I call the MacBook Adorable, that's the—like
1:47:35you said earlier, that's the one USB-C port and a headphone jack. That's literally all the
1:47:39connectivity it had—physical connectivity it had. I bought that when I was—when I had a 27-inch
1:47:44iMac, and that was my—the Adorable was my iPad and my portable computer. Because at the time,
1:47:51I'd kind of fallen out of love with the iPad. I tend to kind of fall in and out of love with
1:47:56iPad for whatever reason. But one way or another, I had used that as my satellite computer. And
1:48:02it was a fortune. It was like $3,000 or something like that. It was not particularly well-specced.
1:48:07It was dog-slow. And I loved it. Gosh, did I love that computer. I like this—I love this 14-inch
1:48:15MacBook Pro more because it has basically no compromises. But the 12-inch MacBook—and
1:48:22my understanding is, what was the 11-inch PowerBook? Do I have that right?
1:48:26Dave Vega No, there was 11-inch MacBook Air. And there was a 12-inch PowerBook
1:48:30many, many, many, many years before. Trenton Larkin
1:48:33Okay, so all of these are cut from a similar cloth, right? Like, let's get maximum portability,
1:48:39everything else be damned. Ports be damned, battery life, anything else. Speed, doesn't matter. We
1:48:44don't care. We want something super crazy portable. And that's what that thing was. And I could put
1:48:49that thing in like a bag or a backpack. I think once or twice I might have asked Aaron to carry
1:48:55it in a purse for some reason or another. Like, it was preposterously thin and preposterously great.
1:49:00And if you didn't mind waiting an hour to accomplish anything. And she still uses that as
1:49:06her primary computer because Aaron's computing needs are extremely small these days. I was
1:49:10listening to you talking about how Amy Jane is mostly on an iPad, and about the only reason she
1:49:14uses a computer computer is for, you know, writing her own email or something. And I feel like with
1:49:19Aaron, it's a very similar thing. And so anyways, I loved that MacBook, MacBook Adorable, but that
1:49:25was the definition of compromise. You know, it was compromised top to bottom. And I can't help but
1:49:31wonder what would it look like if it wasn't nothing but compromise? Like it surely wouldn't be as
1:49:37powerful as a 14-inch MacBook Pro. But what if it was in the ballpark? What if it was close?
1:49:43Trenton Larkin Well, it just forget about all of the Max and Ultra chips, right? Just think just
1:49:49the M2, right? Or just the M1, right? Like the thing that it's fascinating to me, and I think
1:49:56it just speaks to the interest in the iPhone and the fact that they have to make 100 million of
1:50:01them a quarter or more, you know, that the iPhone, I mean, that the iPhone industrial designs tend to
1:50:09always leak, right? And there's sort of a strong consensus about what the iPhone 14 is going to
1:50:14look like already, you know, instead of a notch, it's going to have like a sort of oval hole punch,
1:50:19but the same size, blah, blah, blah. But it's fascinating to me that like the Mac stuff has
1:50:24not been leaking. Nobody knew what the iMac 24-inch was going to look like, right? And it
1:50:30was there. It was a lot of fun that, hey, it's in these colors. It's crazy thin. This is, you know,
1:50:36it was a lot of fun that it was a surprise. The 14 and 16-inch MacBooks, we knew they were coming,
1:50:41but nobody knew what they were going to look like. Like, they were surprised. And we've got all these
1:50:45rumors about upcoming M2 consumer MacBooks, you know, from Mark Gurman and Ming-Chi Kuo and other
1:50:52people. And, you know, I don't doubt any of them. I think they're all right. But they don't know what
1:50:56they're called, right? When they say, like when Gurman says, you know, that he expects MacBook Air
1:51:01later this year, he has no idea if it's actually going to be called MacBook Air. That's the sort
1:51:06of thing that does not come from those sources. And look at the studio. The studio is the same
1:51:11thing, right? Because we didn't know if it was a squat Mac Pro or a tall Mac Mini or where it would
1:51:15end up and it was the same story. Yeah, yeah. And he had that to some degree, right? Like,
1:51:19he was right about it, but he didn't have like a description of it. I think it's fascinating that
1:51:26people seem to be, a lot of people seem to be expecting like an M2 MacBook Air to look just like
1:51:31the MacBook Air today. I don't think that, I think there's zero chance of that. None, because the
1:51:36whole reason the MacBook Air looks the way it does is it was designed around Intel thermals. And the
1:51:41current M1 MacBook Air is based on that design for Intel thermals and capabilities and for ease of
1:51:51introduction and secrecy and whatever other reasons. They just did the first round by putting
1:51:55the M1 into that design. Now we can see what they could design from the ground up. And I would
1:52:00expect it to look as different from a MacBook Air as the 24-inch iMac looks from all previous iMacs.
1:52:06Like, shockingly thin. And the other thing that we know, because they made the 12-inch MacBook,
1:52:12aka adorable, or no adjective, whatever you want to call it, we know they want to make crazy thin,
1:52:20small, light Macs, right? Like MacBooks. And because they've got the M1 in the iPad Pro and
1:52:28now the iPad Air, we know it can run without any cooling at all and never get warm to the touch
1:52:35in a crazy thin device that's super lightweight.
1:52:38Yeah. And I think you're exactly right that they're surely going to change the industrial
1:52:43design and surely the requirements will be quite a bit different. And, you know, I think right now
1:52:50we're still very clearly in a transition. And yes, that's obvious. But what I mean is, you know,
1:52:55what you were saying about the industrial design being a holdover for the MacBook Air and the
1:52:5913-inch MacBook Pro. I mean, it's exactly right. And additionally, the M1, while a phenomenal chip,
1:53:04the M1, no adjective, it does have some somewhat severe constraints, most particularly the 16 gigs
1:53:11of RAM. And now in a lot of use cases, and perhaps most, if not almost all use cases,
1:53:1616 gigs of RAM is fine. I was looking just yesterday or the day before, I run i-STAT
1:53:22menus on my Macs because I kind of like to keep track of nerdy things like that.
1:53:27And it does a really good job keeping a historical graph of certain things, including memory use.
1:53:31And I was looking at it and I have a 64 gig, 14-inch MacBook Pro, if you will. And I don't
1:53:37think I've ever crossed over half of my memory. You know, I've never gone over like 32 gigs of
1:53:43usage. And so even me as a software developer, and granted there are other things that are much
1:53:47more taxing, but as a person who lives in Xcode, I don't probably need more than 32 gigs of RAM.
1:53:54And so this is what I'm saying. Like all the people that I speak to that are really grumpy
1:53:59about the lack of a real prosume desktop, because they argue that the studio is too much and the
1:54:05Mini is too little, and they're looking for the Goldilocks in the middle. I feel like the Air
1:54:10and the 13-inch Pro, if it persists, are kind of in a similar boat as the Mac Mini, where I feel
1:54:15like, yeah, today you're right. They're kind of hamstrung a little bit. But be it because the M1
1:54:22Max arrives in them, or as you said, Jon, and I think that's more likely, the M2 arrives in these
1:54:26devices. Even leaving aside the industrial design, I think that there'll be far fewer compromises,
1:54:32and they'll be much more appealing to much more people. And that I think will close some of the
1:54:38holes, some of which are gaping, in the lineup. And I think that if people can just be patient
1:54:43for another 6 to 12 months, based just on gut, based on no insider information, I really think
1:54:48this lineup, whether or not it has a quote-unquote "all-in-one" 27-inch answer, I think the lineup
1:54:54broadly though will cover darn near everything from the $1,000 MacBook Air that will probably
1:55:00be preposterously fast, all the way through the forthcoming Mac Pro, which will probably be
1:55:04preposterously fast and preposterously expensive, and everywhere in between.
1:55:08Yeah, and crazy thin. I just think people are gonna be blown away by how thin the Air is. And
1:55:12I have no inside birdie information on this at all. I just know what Apple likes to build. They
1:55:18like to build things crazy. And I really think it's been a clarifying series of years of them
1:55:24reinvesting in putting the Pro and Pro on the MacBook. So, okay, let's make them more different.
1:55:31Like that 13-inch MacBook Pro with two ports, it epitomizes their sort of muddling of the consumer
1:55:39and Pro lineups. They call it a MacBook Pro, but it's only got two ports, and it always had less
1:55:44fewer features. It didn't have the beloved touch bar. I think that product branding has got to be
1:55:50gone. I think it's gone. And then you just, you know, like there's no confusion on the iPhone side
1:55:56between iPhone 13 and iPhone 13 Pro, right? The Pros are made of a different material,
1:56:02and they have three cameras instead of two cameras, and they cost a lot more. Just bring
1:56:07that same clarity to the MacBook branding and, you know, have an Air and maybe just bring back
1:56:13the plain old MacBook. I don't know what they'll do branding-wise, but just make it really clear
1:56:17and say, "Okay, these 14, 16-inch Pro models, lots of ports, all the power, max chips. You can get up
1:56:23to 64 gigs of RAM. If you want the power, there you go. Have at it $2,000 and up. And here's our
1:56:30consumer ones. Crazy thin, right? Crazy thin, crazy light. You know, doesn't have the power,
1:56:37but starts at $1,000. And don't—the thing I'm—you know, who knows? Maybe they'll ship the M2
1:56:43Mac Mini, and it will literally be the same footprint. The Mac Mini we know and love,
1:56:48it's just now it's got the M2. Maybe it'll come in space gray again and whatever. But don't sleep
1:56:54on that as something that could potentially shrink, right? Like they could totally make it
1:57:00like the Mac Nano. Because think about it, like the A15 in the iPhone is super powerful chip.
1:57:08It's single core is, I guess, better than, you know, the M1 series. Look at how small the iPhone
1:57:1513 Mini is, and it has a battery and a display. Like, I really think that—I think Apple Silicon
1:57:23chips at the non-Max, non-Ultra—okay, it's not two of them together, it's not four of them
1:57:30together or something like that. It's just one, which is plenty powerful enough for most people,
1:57:36are so crazy small that like the Mac Mini could now be defined entirely by the ports. Like,
1:57:43what ports do we want to put in the back? And that defines the shape. Not the thermals,
1:57:48not the chip, just the ports. And if I'm right, again, pure spitball, and the Mac Mini becomes
1:57:57the Mac Nano, even if they don't rebrand it, but if it shrinks, then the complaints about the
1:58:02studio display not being all in one go, to me, go away. If they can shrink the Mac Mini to be the
1:58:08size of the brick on the iMac 24, then what's the complaint about? I mean, I guess price, if it's a
1:58:15$1600 display plus a $700 to start Mac Mini, you're at $2300 already, and that's more than the base
1:58:24price of the old 27-inch iMac? I don't know. But, so maybe it's, you know, but there's inflation,
1:58:30and you know, it's Apple, what are we going to do, complain? It's Apple. Anyway, let me take a break
1:58:35here, thank our third and final sponsor of the show, our good friends at Memberful. You can
1:58:39monetize your passion with membership. Memberful allows you, the creative person, to build a
1:58:44sustainable recurring revenue. It's the easiest way to sell memberships to your audience, and it's
1:58:49used by some of the biggest creators on the web. Memberful has everything you need to run a
1:58:53membership program. Custom branding, gift subscriptions, Apple Pay support, free trials,
1:58:58private podcasts for your members, tons more, and Memberful seamlessly integrates with the tools you
1:59:03already use, things like WordPress. You have full control and ownership of your audience, of your
1:59:08brand, and your membership. You ever want to move somewhere else, build your own thing, take it to
1:59:13a competitor, you just take your membership with you, they don't lock you in, that's how confident
1:59:17they are that you're going to want to stay at Memberful, because it's like a win-win scenario.
1:59:20They only make money when you make money by selling memberships. You're happy, your viewers,
1:59:27your listeners, your readers, whatever it is, whatever your audience is, they're happy, then
1:59:31Memberful's happy because they're signing up and they're getting their share of it. You can
1:59:37diversify your revenue stream with memberships, and Memberful is the best way to make it happen.
1:59:42Where do you go to get started? Go to memberful.com/talkshow. No "the," just memberful.com/talkshow.
1:59:51My thanks to Memberful. You're probably already a member at a Memberful site or two or three or
1:59:56four or like me, like six, and you may not even know it because their branding is so seamless.
2:00:01So, hey, let's, we're at the two-hour mark, but I wanted to talk about your, you know, this is the
2:00:06reason I invited you, one of the reasons I invited you on. I know you had strong opinions about the
2:00:09displays, but no, but I want to turn this into, I want to do more on this show and get people on
2:00:14when they have something to promote, right? It's, you know, and you've got a new app that I think is
2:00:19very clever and that you've been, to me, underselling on your own podcast, ATP. Tell my
2:00:26audience about your app. Sure. So I've written an app and released it to the app store called
2:00:30Masquer Aid, and it's, it's the two words, masquer and aid mashed together, but it's a play on,
2:00:36you know, masquer aid, if you will. Anyways, the idea of the app is let's say you have a photograph,
2:00:41but you want to obscure maybe a face or maybe an object or something like that. You want to obscure
2:00:46part of the photo. And what masquer aid lets you do is you can load up this photo in the app,
2:00:52and it will help you put emoji on top of the photo. And then something that I've been terrible
2:00:56about publicizing is that it'll automatically strip all the metadata off the photo as well.
2:01:00So lens information, location information, more importantly than anything else I'd argue.
2:01:05And so this way it can, it's a really fast and easy way to help you obscure or occlude things
2:01:12that you don't want shown before you share this photo to say Instagram or Twitter or something
2:01:16like that. And the genesis for this was, you know, as I'd mentioned earlier, I have a seven-year-old
2:01:21and a four-year-old and my son, the elder, when he was four, you know, and I know this has been
2:01:26a couple of years for you, John, but at some point you look down and you realize, holy shit,
2:01:31that's like a person now. You know, that's not just a little lump. That's not just a toddler.
2:01:35That's like a full-on person. And for me and Declan, my son, it was about four years old
2:01:40that I looked at him and realized, whoa, whoa, he's a real life person now. And so, you know,
2:01:46as first-time parents and we had a lot of trouble getting pregnant. So we, of course, you know,
2:01:50overshared as all first-time parents do regardless. We overshared pictures of Declan and then later
2:01:55Michaela, my daughter, when she was born. But it occurred to me when he was about four that,
2:02:00you know, he doesn't understand consent and he doesn't understand, you know, if I ask him,
2:02:04hey, can I put this on the internet? He's going to be like, yeah, sure, dad, whatever.
2:02:06But what if in five years and 10 years and 15 years or something like that, what if,
2:02:11you know, some friend of his or foe even goes looking for dirt on Declan and finds some like
2:02:18super compromising photo that I've taken, or maybe a photo that I didn't think was compromising,
2:02:22but he somehow finds to be compromising or, you know, times change and maybe something that we
2:02:28think is okay now, we may not think is okay in a year or 10 years or whatnot. And so for me,
2:02:33what I wanted to do was to put an emoji over my kids' faces. So I could share a picture of maybe
2:02:39me or maybe Aaron and me and the kids. And you can do this using Instagram stories, but it's kind of
2:02:45a real pain in the ass. And it only goes to Instagram stories and it's, yeah, it only goes
2:02:50to Instagram stories, or I guess you can save it to your camera roll, but you know, it's, it's just,
2:02:53it's, it's a nightmare. And using Instagram, I, again, I, I get it that Instagram has the feature,
2:03:00but I don't think you need to even belabor the point using Instagram as an image editor for
2:03:05something other than posting to Instagram is ridiculous. Yeah, exactly. And so I, I wanted
2:03:11a way to do this quickly and easily. And it occurred to me, I had one of those just epiphany
2:03:15moments where I thought, well, wait a second, like a couple of years ago at WWDC, I swear,
2:03:21I sat through a vision related presentation where they talked about face detection. There's got to
2:03:28be something I can do with this. And so, you know, long story shorter, what, what masquerade will do
2:03:33is when you load an image into masquerade, it will automatically use, you know, Apple's machine
2:03:37learning models to detect where faces are within the image. And we'll just slap an emoji over any
2:03:44face that it finds. And then if it's maybe a grownup or someone you don't want to, you know,
2:03:48hide their face, it makes it, you know, masquerade makes it super easy to just remove what you don't
2:03:52want or add more if you need to. But the idea is if I was to take a picture of my family of four,
2:03:57you know, it will masquerade, we'll load it up, it'll put the four emoji on, and then I will just
2:04:01remove the one for me, the one from Aaron. And then I can send it off to Instagram or Twitter,
2:04:05wherever lickety split. And so I am of the mind, I guess, you know, kind of the Unix mindset of,
2:04:10you know, do one thing, do it well and do it fast. And that's, that's what masquerade is designed to
2:04:14do. It's, you know, it's funny, too, I just, I will belabor the point of Instagram. The other
2:04:19thing, too, is fundamentally, whatever you want to use masquerade for, it's, it almost certainly
2:04:24revolves around privacy, to some degree. I mean, I guess the only thing you could use it for,
2:04:29and people probably are, is it might be used for comedic purposes that have nothing to do with
2:04:34privacy, to put a funny emoji over somebody's face or put the emoji over, you know, anywhere else,
2:04:39you know, you can add the emoji to make it look like a fart is, you know, the poof emoji to make
2:04:44it look like a fart is coming out. It's probably the number one thing people are using the app for.
2:04:48Michael O'Brien Yeah, I saw a lot of
2:04:49pig noses on dog snouts, which I found quite delightful, actually.
2:04:53Dave Asprey Yeah. But all right, comedy aside, it's about privacy. And once you're talking about
2:04:58privacy, the idea of using Instagram's tools because they're free is ridiculous, right? Like,
2:05:04you know, no matter what you think about Instagram, privacy is, does not come to mind. So it's, it's
2:05:10really clever. And you, I'm a little bit behind on ATP. I didn't listen to the entirety of the most
2:05:15recent show. I don't know if you talked about Masquerade some more. But at least a week ago,
2:05:18you guys, you did some follow up and you heard from listeners of the show and other people who
2:05:23became aware of Masquerade already, who had use cases you had never, you didn't even think of.
2:05:28I thought the one, the one to me, I remember listening, it's one of those things where I
2:05:32actually could tell you exactly where I was. I was running errands in Philadelphia. And I have a
2:05:37weird memory like this. I remember where I was when you said it. I was at Broad and Walnut Street in
2:05:43Philadelphia on the east side of the street. And you said you were talking about like grade school
2:05:50teachers taking pictures of their classroom. And I was like, oh, bingo. And because the thing is,
2:05:56the machine learning part of it is super fast and accurate, right? So teacher wants to take
2:06:04a picture for whatever reason, field trip, right? It's a field trip and the teacher wants to share
2:06:08a picture of the class on a trip. And, you know, again, my kid is a senior in high school now.
2:06:15I'm past this, but apparently it's now a thing where like, you know, you have like a second or
2:06:19a third grader and there's like a social media, what would you call it? Release, release, release
2:06:25form. You don't know if you have it or whatever. Who wants to deal with it? Maybe, you know, 15 out
2:06:29of 25 kids in your class have them and 10 don't and you don't know who they are, whatever. And
2:06:34even if you just were like, ah, I just want to put the emoji over every kid's face. Well, if you use
2:06:38like a traditional tool and you've got like a snapshot of like 18 kids on a field trip, it's
2:06:43like, here's one, here's two. You use masquerade. Seriously, I'm not just saying this because you're
2:06:48a guest. You use it, you open up that image and boom, you get a little haptic feedback,
2:06:52which I love, which is one of my favorite little features. You get a little, little,
2:06:55I'm not imagining that, right? There's a little haptic feedback when you...
2:06:58I don't know if it does unload. I don't think it does unload, but as soon as you like go to
2:07:02manipulate anything, it absolutely will. Yeah. And boom, it just finds all the faces, puts an
2:07:07emoji on them and it's done, right? Like, so instead of sitting there and like, oh, well,
2:07:12if I spend like three minutes, I can put like, I can cover up the face of all these kids,
2:07:16dot, dot, dot. You just opened it up, boom, all the faces are covered. You can pick the emoji.
2:07:21Really clever. And like any good computer thing, computers especially, it's always the unintended
2:07:28use cases that become the reason it becomes successful, right? You know, it's like, so you're
2:07:33thinking I'm a dad, I've got young kids, I'd like to share these pictures, but you know, you said
2:07:39it well, you know, that you'd like to respect their future wishes and you don't know what they
2:07:43are. You built it for that. But the school teacher scenario, that's fascinating. You had a couple
2:07:48other examples too. I've heard a bunch. The most popular one I think I've heard is foster parents.
2:07:53And so my very limited understanding of foster parenting is that in most places it is illegal,
2:08:01if not certainly frowned upon, but generally illegal to post an image of a foster child's face
2:08:06on social media, on social media. Right. And so, so you are legally compelled as a foster parent,
2:08:13who's doing, you know, such an incredible thing. And I've got to imagine, and forgive me if my,
2:08:17you know, language is wrong here, but these kids must feel like part of your family. And I guess
2:08:21they are part of your family if not forever, but certainly for the time that they're with you.
2:08:25And so, so yeah, you, you want to share your family with your friends and other family,
2:08:30you know, you're, you want to share your immediate family with your extended family
2:08:33and you're legally compelled not to put their faces on Facebook or Instagram or what have you.
2:08:39And so a lot of foster parents reached out and said, Oh my God, I've been waiting for this my
2:08:42entire life. Like I had, I had no idea that we could make this so easy. And that was extremely
2:08:47rewarding. I had a person reach out who I don't believe they were a photographer, but I believe
2:08:52associated with photographers, they were in some sort of news organization that was covering what's
2:08:56going on in Ukraine. And they said, you know, this would be extremely useful for us for
2:09:00covering what's going on with war efforts, what's going on with protests. And, you know, because
2:09:05obviously, especially if you're covering protests in Russia, where, you know, the people who are
2:09:10protesting or taking considerable personal risks by expressing their opinions to say the least.
2:09:16Right. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Much more so than we've ever had to deal with here, even during
2:09:19questionable administrations. And so it makes a lot of sense to, to obscure their faces and
2:09:25similarly like Ukrainian soldiers, if you will, or whatever the case may be. And then there are
2:09:30other silly ones though. And I know you and I agree very strongly that, that Disney world is
2:09:35a wonderful place to vacation. And so somebody sent me a photo of both of them sitting, I think
2:09:40it was in front of the people mover, which is my personal favorite ride at Disney. They, they sent
2:09:43a photo of their family, but all the like bystanders were, were covered with emoji, which I
2:09:48thought was very cool. But my favorite of these with regard to theme parks was somebody who took
2:09:52the on-ride photo from splash mountain and scared all the other faces. I think with like the screamy
2:09:59like Van Gogh or no, I forget who it is. The starry night, screamy guy. And I think there was
2:10:03a bunch of screaming people and then just their family was left. So you could see them. And I
2:10:08really loved that. That those are my, I think my favorites, the most unexpected though was I've had
2:10:15a handful of boudoir photographers reach out and say, you know, sometimes some of our pictures are
2:10:21not safe for work and we might need to let's say use the eggplant or peach emojis strategically,
2:10:28or perhaps, you know, they people, maybe they just want their heads covered and it's not as,
2:10:32not quite as risque as I'm painting it. But that was, that was something I didn't quite expect to
2:10:36read. And it got, there were even some more risque versions than that, that I won't necessarily share
2:10:40right now, but those were, those were quite eyeopening. And certainly I'm not complaining,
2:10:44but it's certainly not the use case I had set out for when I wrote the app.
2:10:48But that's really a sign of strength of a good idea that it's used in ways you didn't expect.
2:10:53My favorite story about that is BB Edit. BB Edit started in 1991, I think was the first version.
2:11:00And it's sort of infamous where version 1.0 was only like, I think the only people who used it
2:11:06worked at Think Technologies with Rich Siegel. And the first version he released publicly was like
2:11:122.0. But anytime there's somebody who's like, I've been using it since 1.0. And Rich can say like,
2:11:17well, you didn't work with me. So no, but I know what you mean. And I appreciate your long-term use
2:11:22of the product. You know, it's 92, 93, and it was a smash hit in the shareware world. And then,
2:11:28you know, all of a sudden the World Wide Web becomes a thing circa like 1994. And they start
2:11:32getting all this email. And they had a plugin API and somebody, I think his name was Craig somebody,
2:11:37but made like a really, at the time, very good plugin for HTML where you got like this palette
2:11:43full of all the most popular tags. And then you could just select text, hit a button and surround
2:11:48the text with the tags. Or if it was like the image tag, it would prompt for the image URL.
2:11:53You know, it just made it, it's just a convenience thing for writing HTML. And that they got all
2:11:57these emails from people like, oh my God, BBA is the greatest thing ever for HTML. And like the
2:12:02first answers were like, hey, that's great to hear. What's HTML? You know, it was a very quick
2:12:10process. I mean, the web exploded in popularity and, you know, Rich and Patrick Woolsey, his
2:12:15longtime colleague, you know, and co-founder, you know, it quickly went from what's HTML to,
2:12:19oh, okay, I get it. And now I can see why BBA is good for it, but it wasn't designed for it at all.
2:12:25And, you know, it became, for a long time, it was known, BBA was best known as an HTML editor
2:12:31and hadn't really changed except having a plugin for it. Same thing with Masquerade, right? Like,
2:12:36you did not think that it was going to be used to cover up adult photography, you know?
2:12:42So, automatically it uses machine learning to identify faces and will put the emoji of your
2:12:56choice over all the faces. And then you can pinch to zoom them to make them bigger or smaller
2:13:02or drag them around. But it also, it will let you add emoji to an image and cover up anything
2:13:07that you want. So, if you want to secure something in a photo with an emoji to cover it up,
2:13:12it's super easy to do. It's not just for faces.
2:13:14Yeah, yeah. And I actually have been kicking around the idea of having some sort of switch
2:13:20where if you find yourself not particularly interested in covering faces, that I won't even
2:13:25bother trying, you know, and maybe there would be a button you could hit after the fact, you know,
2:13:29if you would like to cover faces. Just a quick point of clarification, though. The free version,
2:13:34which is a very standard emoji, like the very bog-standard smiley face, it's a one-time $3 an
2:13:38app purchase to get basically all the other emoji. And then, and that's that. I don't currently have
2:13:43any intentions of adding any other sort of in-app purchase. You know, never say never,
2:13:46but that's not currently my intention. But no, it's, I think it's a pretty, if I'm allowed to
2:13:51say, I think it's a pretty good app. I think it's pretty well done. And this is my third independent
2:13:54app that I've released the App Store. And I think, far and away, this is the best of the three. And
2:13:58I think it does the job and it does it well. And like I said, I'm not terribly interested for me
2:14:03in writing an app that's the sort of thing where you stay in it for hours. Like, that's just not
2:14:07where my skill set is. I'm much more skillful at writing something that you get in, you get out,
2:14:13and you've accomplished what you want to accomplish. And that's very much what Masquerade
2:14:17is designed to be. And I really think that even if you're not a parent, even if you're not going
2:14:22to theme parks, even if you're not protesting, I really think for almost anyone, there's got to be
2:14:27an occasion where, like you said, Jon, you would want to obscure or otherwise hide a part of an
2:14:32app. And for someone who fancies himself an emoji aficionado, I think that using an emoji or two or
2:14:37ten or whatever is a fun way to do it. Even leaving aside comedy as the point, just using emoji to
2:14:44obscure something, I think is a fun approach. And I find that much more entertaining and interesting
2:14:50than, say, a blur or something like that. Yeah, I did not mean to imply that the free version
2:14:56includes all the emoji. But come on, three bucks in my audience? Come on, everybody out there,
2:15:01get this app, pay for it. Three bucks one time, not three bucks a month. Three bucks? It's too cheap.
2:15:06Too cheap. I can make it more if you want, Jon. I'll crank it up to five or ten.
2:15:10But I also think, you know, it's always—and you and I are friends, you know, both you,
2:15:14you're actually making independent apps, you and I are friends with a bunch of people—it's
2:15:18always sort of a tricky thing, like where do you draw the line on what's included for free
2:15:24and what do you get people to pay for? Our mutual friend Daniel Jalkett just issued an
2:15:29update to his Fast Scripts utility for the Mac, which adds regular expression support to
2:15:35AppleScript, which it sounds like something that was made just for me. AppleScript, Mac,
2:15:40and regular expressions? Yeah, that's, you know, the Jon Gruper feature. But I didn't even ask him
2:15:45for it, but I did beta test it. But like he, you know, even he was torn. He's like, "Ah, should it
2:15:49be for the pay version or free?" And I was like, "I sort of, you know, I don't want to—I would love
2:15:54you to make as much money as possible with Fast Scripts, but I sort of think it should be free."
2:15:58And he's like, "Yeah, it should." Because otherwise people who want something free from
2:16:01AppleScript are going to do the whole, "Well, I could just use do shell script and write a temp
2:16:06file and call out to sed or pearl or grep or whatever the hell you're using on the command
2:16:10line." And you've got this—whatever you think of AppleScript—using Fast Scripts to just say,
2:16:16"Search this for that," where that is the pattern, as opposed to quoted form of this to do shell
2:16:23script and writing a temp—it's a mess. But what the hoops people will go through to do it for free,
2:16:29don't—never underestimate. But I think that in this case, it is, to me,
2:16:36brilliant because you can do all the features with the one default emoji, and that one default emoji
2:16:43is the emoji, right? Like if you were going to reduce the entire emoji set to one, it would be
2:16:48the default smiley face, right? And you could see how it works, see how it scales, see how it
2:16:53identifies faces, see how it lets you move it wherever you want. And the, "Oh, but I would love
2:16:59to use the eggplant," or whatever, the peach, you know, whatever else, or, you know, any of the other,
2:17:05what, 100 faces and various skin tones and the gender identities and all—I mean, you know,
2:17:12you probably even know the answer to this. How many emoji are there? I mean—
2:17:15[Cameron] So if you include skin tones, which I don't have in Masquerade right now because it's a
2:17:20really tricky UI problem to solve, like obviously the right way to do it is to do what Apple's done,
2:17:24but that gets really complicated really quickly.
2:17:27[Cameron] Yeah, exactly. But I'm certainly—it's on the to-do list for sure, but I don't want to
2:17:31oversell and bait and switch or anything. But to answer your question, I believe the full list of
2:17:36Unicode emoji off the top of my head, I think it's like 6,000 where every, you know, every different
2:17:40skin tone is a different listing and so on. [
2:17:44People have choices.
2:17:45[
2:17:46Yeah, and I think I whittle—even taking away skin tones, I think I whittle it down to like 2,500,
2:17:51I believe. I might have that wrong, but it's something like that.
2:17:54Yeah. But it's, you know, people can imagine what it would be like to be able to use whichever their
2:17:58favorite emoji are, and it's three bucks. And again, brilliant. And again, I think the price
2:18:03should be higher, to be honest. I do, I do. I think three bucks is too little, but it's a bargain. So
2:18:07anybody who's out there thinking, "Well, Gruber's nuts. He spends money like a drunken sailor,"
2:18:12you know, go buy it for three bucks before I can talk Casey into upping the price. But I love,
2:18:17too, that it's not like, "Oh, well, you buy the object pack for a dollar."
2:18:22Sure, sure.
2:18:23"Buy the people pack for two dollars. Buy the hand gestures for a dollar." No. Three bucks,
2:18:30all emoji, that's it. Done.
2:18:33Yeah, I guess, you know, that's—there's two different obnoxious versions of this, right?
2:18:37Like, there's one obnoxious version, which is nickel and diming through all the different
2:18:40emoji. And then the other obnoxious version is using, like, the poop emoji as the one for
2:18:45your ear or something like that. Something that's less useful than just the smiley.
2:18:49And when I was thinking about how to monetize and where to draw the line, you know, I can't think of
2:18:54a specific example offhand, but—or actually, you know, I can, and now I'm, you know, showing my age.
2:18:59Like, if you remember, and I think Doom came to the Mac, but for when I was on the PC, you know,
2:19:06Doom was brand new. Doom, the ID or id software video game. And it was shareware, and shareware
2:19:11was huge at the time. And what they did was they gave you the entire first level,
2:19:14no restrictions whatsoever. The first stage, if you will, you could play that for free.
2:19:20But if you wanted to go any further, guess what? You got to pony up the cash. And I feel like this
2:19:24is kind of similar to that. You know, what I'm giving you is fully functional, like you were
2:19:28saying. And it's not obnoxious. It's not, you know, it doesn't have a ridiculous Achilles heel.
2:19:34But if you want to take it anywhere further from, you know, the very most basic step,
2:19:39then please give me $3 for now, and maybe Jon will convince me to make it five in a few days.
2:19:44I don't know. We'll see. But that's, you know, I feel like that's riding the line in a happy way,
2:19:49that I'm trying to be useful to those who don't or can't pay, but also trying to put food on the
2:19:55table for those who can. I don't know what the most spiteful default emoji could be.
2:20:02You know, it is an eggplant. I don't know. No, because that would wreck it for parents,
2:20:06right? That's too ridiculous. But it would be like, I don't know, like the, I'm looking through.
2:20:11Oh, the drunken guy. Yeah. Or what guy, what is it? I forget the actual name for it.
2:20:16Woozy, I think. Woozy face. Some of them are so weird though, because they come from like,
2:20:20you know, the whole thing started in Japan on cell phones in the 90s. And there's all sorts
2:20:26of cultural reasons you don't understand. But like, there's some of the weird ones under symbols.
2:20:30There's like an arrow pointing to the right, and it actually says in English letters underneath,
2:20:35"soon." You know? Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's one, there's one where there's an arrow pointing up
2:20:41and it says "top." Something like that would probably be the worst. I could use non-potable
2:20:47water, which is like a little water spigot you would find outside with a circle with a line
2:20:52through it or no littering or something. Or actually, no, just how about just straight up,
2:20:55prohibited or no entry, you know? So no entry is a circle with the white line in the center.
2:21:00Prohibited is a circle with the slash. Maybe that's it. That'd be pretty obnoxious.
2:21:03You could have been a lot more spiteful. It is, in fact, usable for free with a smiley face.
2:21:07Anyway, masquerade, M-A-S-K-E-R-A-I-D. You can find it.
2:21:12That's right.
2:21:13And on at least one major app store for now.
2:21:16That's right. Yeah, no, no, I'm not planning an Android version. Don't even hint.
2:21:20Oh no, I'm talking about the coming glorious future of multiple app stores
2:21:24in the EU for Apple.
2:21:27Yeah, I'll be putting it on the Amazon Apple App Store or something like that right now.
2:21:31All right. So let me thank our sponsors. We had Linode, where you can host, linode.com/thetalkshow.
2:21:38You can host your website, anything you want.
2:21:40Remote, where you can help use them to help pay for your remote employees all around the world
2:21:46at remote.com/thetalkshow. And then last, but certainly not least,
2:21:50Memberful, where you can monetize your passion with membership at memberful.com/talkshow.
2:21:57People can listen to Casey on the Accidental Tech podcast. That's ATP.fm.
2:22:04And then you've got your other show.
2:22:05That's your—
2:22:06That's Analog with our mutual friend Mike Hurley. That's at relay.fm/analog.
2:22:10I mean, how does that guy do so many shows? I mean—
2:22:14Don't even get me started. I don't know.
2:22:15It's—I don't get it. I honestly—I don't get it.
2:22:18I don't think he believes in sleep, John.
2:22:20I like sleep way too much. So that's not my lifestyle, but he is very prolific.
2:22:25Yeah, but somehow he's making all these shows. And I was talking to Snell the other day about
2:22:28mechanical keyboards, as we do. Like, we're always talking about baseball and mechanical.
2:22:33And he built Snell a custom—he bought like a Keychron Q1 and took all the switches off and
2:22:42put these, like, bespoke switches on. I mean, and sent it to Snell. How the hell does he find time
2:22:48to do shit like that? I don't—
2:22:49I have no idea. I have no idea. But that was his, like, for fun, like, relaxing work, if you will.
2:22:54You know, he was doing that, I believe, some for upgrade and then some, I think,
2:22:58for what he calls the Friday Keyboard Club, which he does on Twitch. And so, yeah, that's his,
2:23:03like, relaxing thing, is to go on Twitch in front of a gazillion people and try to both do, you know,
2:23:08manual labor and also communicate with people who are watching him all simultaneously. He's an
2:23:13animal. I don't know how he does it.
2:23:14Yeah, I don't know either. Anyway, thanks for being here. I'll, you know,
2:23:17make sure it happens again at some point.
2:23:19Thank you so much, John. Pleasure's all mine.