Podcast Search

The Talk Show

334: ‘High-Margin Candy Bar’, With Dieter Bohn

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Dieter Bohn, you made a movie.

0:00:01It's kind of a movie. It's a documentary. It's a half an hour. Does a half an hour count as a movie?

0:00:05I say so. I mentioned this to Joanna Stern the other week on my show.

0:00:10I love the length of it because it's like I...

0:00:14You'd left me wanting more, but not like feeling incomplete.

0:00:19And I feel like there's an awful lot...

0:00:23I noticed this during all of COVID, like after my wife and I burned through

0:00:28everything on our list that we actually wanted to see and started watching random stuff.

0:00:33There's an awful lot of documentaries that are, to me, stretched out to be feature length.

0:00:42And it's like, man, that would have been a tight half hour.

0:00:45Yeah, I mean, if you don't know, it's a documentary about this company called Handspring,

0:00:49which you probably spun out from Palm. It's about the trio, etc.

0:00:52I really was very aware that when you do these documentaries about nostalgia,

0:00:59about something from a while ago, the first instinct is to make, I don't know,

0:01:04like I love the 90s, right? Bring in a B-list comedian to be like,

0:01:07"Oh, I had that thing. It was great. It had a keyboard." And just draw it out.

0:01:11And I knew I didn't want to do that.

0:01:13And I also knew that making something that had a larger scope that actually got into Palm and WebOS

0:01:21and all of the messiness that came after would have taken way too long.

0:01:26And so I wanted to tell like a really tight, smallish story that had,

0:01:31but I hope felt like a beginning, a middle, and an end. Because telling the whole story,

0:01:36it's like Lord of the Rings. It's got like 50 endings.

0:01:38The name of the movie is Springboard. Where does that come from?

0:01:43So Springboard is the name of the slot.

0:01:49So there's a whole long story. The founders of Palm, for reasons, had to go quit and start their own company.

0:01:55They started Handspring. They had to start making PDAs again.

0:01:57And they're like, "Well, God, what are we going to do to differentiate?"

0:02:00They hustled Palm into licensing the operating system to them.

0:02:03So they're going to make more PDAs.

0:02:05And they decide the way to differentiate was to make them cheaper,

0:02:09but also to have them have an expansion module.

0:02:12And they decided to call that expansion module the Springboard slot.

0:02:16The metaphor being that you could jump and expand it to do other things.

0:02:20And so that's where it came from. And the company itself was called Handspring.

0:02:24And I think it was just something you hold in your hand. They ran out of ideas.

0:02:28And actually, Ed Colligan told me that one of the things they dealt with,

0:02:32and this is back in what, '99 when it was founded, maybe '98,

0:02:36is they were looking for a .com, a URL that they could actually get, which back then was already a problem.

0:02:42It's very funny. I had a Handspring.

0:02:45I did not own a Palm device, but the first Palm OS device,

0:02:49first and only one I owned was a Handspring visor.

0:02:53And my wife got one too. And she's not a gadget nerd, but she loved it.

0:02:59We both did. It was a terrific product. It really was.

0:03:04And I know that there were a lot of Palm device aficionados before Handspring.

0:03:10But it really seemed like at least the classic black and white Palm OS reached its peak with the Handspring devices.

0:03:18And one of the weird angles of this is the way that Palm was always sort of the bizarro Apple,

0:03:25where it was like Apple in the '90s got it before Steve Jobs came back,

0:03:31and the next reunification tried out of desperation, let's license the OS, right?

0:03:37All this time. And I think long story short, it's Wall Street when they see a grand success,

0:03:44they want everybody else to do the same thing.

0:03:46And Microsoft famously had a very good '90s until they didn't with the DOJ,

0:03:52but financially even through the antitrust investigation,

0:03:56they were making money faster than they could put it in a bank.

0:03:59And how did they make their money? By licensing software.

0:04:02And so Wall Street, even before Apple got in trouble, was constantly saying Apple should license their OS.

0:04:08Apple should license their OS because that's where the money is.

0:04:12Not really understanding at all that Apple and Microsoft were fundamentally different companies.

0:04:16And then eventually Apple got into dire straits and they were like, well, we're screwed.

0:04:21All right, we'll just license the OS, which was a bad idea.

0:04:23And Palm similarly never should have licensed the OS to Handspring

0:04:28because all of a sudden the best Palm devices were not made by Palm.

0:04:36Yeah, no, licensing the OS was one of the reasons that there was conflict between Donna, the CEO,

0:04:43Jeff, the product guy, and Ed, and the 3Com, who at the time was a parent company when they quit and created their own company.

0:04:493Com really thought that the move was to license Palm OS and the people at Handspring,

0:04:56they're like, no, it needs to be software and hardware together.

0:04:59And so don't do that. And 3Com said, no, no, no, we've got this vision.

0:05:04We make modems right now and maybe some like networking equipment,

0:05:08but we're going to, everything that connects to the internet, we're going to have a piece of.

0:05:11So we're going to have the handheld computers all the way up to the networking stack.

0:05:15And everyone at Palm was like, well, this is stupid. So they quit.

0:05:19And then they call them back and they're like, you still planning on licensing this thing?

0:05:23And Palm's like, yeah, no, we're going to do it. And like, okay, well give us one.

0:05:26And there were some other companies that licensed it.

0:05:28Sony made some very, very, very nerdy PDAs called the Clie's that were like,

0:05:34they were like the gadgetiest gadgets that ever did gadget.

0:05:37There was a company in Iowa called Handera that licensed it.

0:05:40There were a handful of others, but the only one that actually mattered was Handspring.

0:05:44And by the end, all that licensing stuff,

0:05:47they kept on trying through different versions of corporations and it never worked.

0:05:51And it was always the, it was always one of the things that kept Palm from ever reaching real success.

0:05:57Actually, here's a, here's a wild story.

0:06:00So Handspring fails, gets merged back into Palm,

0:06:03and Ed Colligan goes to the board and is like,

0:06:06hey, this company that you spun out through all these weird things called Palm Source,

0:06:11our license to license our OS from this company that we spun out is coming up.

0:06:16And I tell you what, if we buy this license for whatever it is, 30, 40 million dollars,

0:06:21whatever the number is, they're going to take that money

0:06:23and then they're going to turn around and sell themselves because they're in dire straits.

0:06:28And the board who had been the board that had created all these shenanigans in the first place,

0:06:33said no, did not buy them, and made them re-up their license again.

0:06:38And as soon as they re-up their license,

0:06:40what Ed said would happen is exactly what happened. Palm Source sold to a company in Japan called Access

0:06:46and that Palm had to like start all over again with a new operating system.

0:06:52The 90s were an era of companies whose boards did not understand the actual companies

0:07:01and what they had in their hands. We could go on and on and list companies like that.

0:07:05That's one of the reasons why Microsoft and Intel were so dominant in that decade.

0:07:13It wasn't just that they had a product that people wanted to buy,

0:07:16it was that they were actually well-run companies run by people who understood what they were actually doing.

0:07:22Like, yeah, Apple clearly lost track of what they had and what was good and constantly,

0:07:30like the whole story of Apple getting into trouble was basically neglecting the Mac,

0:07:37not realizing that the Mac had legs,

0:07:39and mistakenly thinking that they were still in like the early 80s

0:07:44when platforms came out, had a few good years,

0:07:49and then you'd come out with a new platform that replaced the old platform and wasn't like,

0:07:56it wasn't evolved. And I think Apple fundamentally saw the Mac that way for years and years and years,

0:08:02that they were always looking for what's the next thing, right,

0:08:05that's going to replace the Mac and they had the Taligent, Pink, and all the cooperations with IBM.

0:08:11And meanwhile, the Mac was right there in front of them with industries,

0:08:15you know, like print and desktop publishing building themselves around it.

0:08:20And Apple as a company is looking elsewhere. And Palm, the product,

0:08:24the Palm Pilot was sort of like that at 3Com.

0:08:27It's like they had no idea what they had on their hands. It was a terrific product.

0:08:31They just did not understand that at all.

0:08:34Like why in the world would you not want to own the operating system?

0:08:38Yeah, nobody knew what the business models were going to be, right?

0:08:40So I don't know. I mean benefit of the doubt, Microsoft had so much success.

0:08:45Everyone's like, well, that's that's how you win.

0:08:47That's how that's how tech works.

0:08:48And so everyone thought that that's what they needed to do.

0:08:51There was a disconnect from I think the suits that just didn't use the product

0:08:56or didn't understand what made a good product

0:08:58and how over the long term making a good product is what wins.

0:09:03And they got caught up in like the risk, the 40 chess strategy of it,

0:09:07and didn't think about, well, no, let's like let's actually focus on making and selling a good product over and over again.

0:09:13All right, let's take a break and I'm going to thank our first sponsor to our good friends at Squarespace.

0:09:17Make your next move and make your next website at Squarespace.

0:09:22You can start building your website today. Just go there.

0:09:26Go to squarespace.com/talkshow and you get started.

0:09:29You could just start building a website. Just go there.

0:09:32Just get a free trial. 30 days. Just start clicking, dragging, choosing templates.

0:09:38Make the website you want to make. Could not be easier.

0:09:40You do it all WYSIWYG right in the browser. HTML, JavaScript, CSS coding.

0:09:46You can get in there. You can actually modify the code the way you want.

0:09:50Once you have your website running, Squarespace offers everything you need to keep going.

0:09:54You can have a store. All the e-commerce goes through Squarespace.

0:09:57You can host something like a podcast. The CMS for posting new episodes goes through Squarespace.

0:10:02Analytics. They have a great analytics dashboard.

0:10:05See where people are coming, how many people are coming to your website.

0:10:08Everything you need, Squarespace has it. It is all in one.

0:10:12You do not need to understand coding to do it. People come to you,

0:10:16your friends who are non-technical, send them to Squarespace.

0:10:19Go to squarespace.com/talkshow. Use that code talk show.

0:10:24That's it. No the, just talk show. Get 10% off your first order when your free trial's up.

0:10:29My thanks to Squarespace. I'd like to talk a little, have you seen the General Magic movie?

0:10:34Yeah. Oh yeah. No, we talked about that a lot. We wanted to make sure we didn't just copy it,

0:10:37but we also, you know, wanted to make something a little bit less ambitious. Great film.

0:10:41If you haven't watched it, you should definitely go watch it. It's really good. In Springboard,

0:10:45you talking to the protagonists of that time, Donna Dabinski and Jeff Hawkins,

0:10:49who was sort of the product guy behind the whole thing, Ed Colligan.

0:10:53They, I think rightly so. They have the same mindset that the General Magic people do

0:10:59in that it's that the work they did laid the foundation for the smartphone era,

0:11:04even though these products didn't start as phones. The people at Palm and the people at General Magic

0:11:09see their work as laying the groundwork for what became the smartphone revolution about a decade later.

0:11:16I think that's true, but they weren't making phones, which is so interesting, right?

0:11:20And they didn't even have networking because Wi-Fi wasn't a thing yet.

0:11:25And to me, that is the fundamental mistake that all of the PDAs made in the 90s,

0:11:32was not foreseeing how essential wireless networking of some sort was

0:11:38to make these things useful to more than the early adopter crowd.

0:11:44Yeah, so the networking thing is fascinating because even if they wanted networking, they couldn't, right?

0:11:48So the Wi-Fi either didn't exist, and then you could buy a modem module.

0:11:53In fact, the wireless networks, the best you could get was the Mobitex pager network,

0:12:00which was not even SMS quality. And so one of the reasons, maybe the key reason,

0:12:05the only reason that the Palm PDA became successful, and it wasn't just a generic organizer at Radio Shack,

0:12:12was they realized that entering text on this little tiny graffiti area on a 160 by 160 display sucked.

0:12:20And what you wanted was all of your information from your computer.

0:12:23And so they made really, really good syncing software almost by accident.

0:12:28Somebody random, like on the side, coded up a bunch of these hot sync conduits

0:12:33that would work with multiple different pieces of software.

0:12:35And so the fact that you could just set your thing down and hit a button

0:12:39and have your data synced over to it and then walk away and have your calendar with you

0:12:44and not have to enter 50, you know, 500 contacts on your own, just have it be there,

0:12:49was the reason that the original Palm pilots became successful,

0:12:54because they elevated themselves as an accessory to the PC

0:12:59instead of just being a random digital organizer that you saw on a shelf somewhere.

0:13:04It was another one of those little tiny thousand paper cuts of being a Mac user in the era

0:13:10that the Mac syncing was always not quite as good as PC syncing.

0:13:15It was there. It wasn't like, I wouldn't call it an afterthought,

0:13:19but it wasn't. It just did not seem as good.

0:13:22It was like the early days of Napster until the Mac eventually got good Napster clients.

0:13:26But in the early days, it was like, oh, man, everybody else is downloading all this music.

0:13:30And what am I supposed to do? And the Palm pilot syncing was like that.

0:13:34But the other thing that's so interesting about that era was that the PC operating systems,

0:13:40the Mac in particular, did not have standard system level databases

0:13:47for things like calendars and contacts. There was no built-in contact.

0:13:52In today's world, there's a bunch of great calendar apps for the iPhone,

0:13:56and they all hook into the APIs Apple provides to use the same calendar data system-wide,

0:14:04so that if you actually open Apple's calendar app, the stuff that you've entered using Fantastical

0:14:10or whatever other apps are out there, they're all there.

0:14:13There's contact apps that just hook into the central contact database.

0:14:17So if you were to make something that needed to get contacts from your iPhone,

0:14:21you know where to go. There's a bunch of APIs. You could do it. The Mac,

0:14:24there was nothing like that in that era. Palm had to pick, well, we'll support this app and this app's contacts.

0:14:31And it was like a just a short list of apps that you could sync with.

0:14:35But if you did use one of those apps, it was magical to have all of your stuff in a thing that was in your pocket.

0:14:41Maybe a stretch, but you could certainly carry the Palm pilot everywhere.

0:14:45Well, famously, Jeff Hawkins designed it for the pocket, right? He carried around a block of wood and poked at it with a chopstick.

0:14:51It was like, I imagined what it would be like to use. This is a little bit later in the hot-syncing era.

0:14:55I can't believe we're talking about hot-sync conduits,

0:14:57but here we are. That extensibility of making it work with other apps is one of the things that kept Palm OS feeling vibrant and good,

0:15:05because it allowed for third-party apps to create things that could sync over to the Palm pilot as part of that hot-sync stack.

0:15:14This eventually worked on the Mac, too. There was an app called iSilo that basically worked like a pocket or an Instapaper.

0:15:20There was Avot Go, which would sync over news every day.

0:15:24There was Vindigo, which was like a little mapping software that also synced over like latest restaurant recommendations.

0:15:30There was just a bunch of stuff. There was an installing protocol, so you didn't have to, it was easier to install apps that way.

0:15:35There's a bunch of ways that, absent a really good usable wireless radio,

0:15:41you could still make it feel like your Palm pilot was somehow connected to the internet.

0:15:46It just connected to the internet in the morning when you hit the hot-sync button before you left for the day.

0:15:51Yeah, I think for a lot of people listening,

0:15:54the closest analogy that they might have had in their gadget lives would be the early days of the iPod,

0:16:00where your iPod synced via a cable to your Mac or PC,

0:16:07and the Palm pilot was like that. You're bringing back memories for me.

0:16:10I had iSilo, and I definitely had Avot Go, and it was neat.

0:16:15It was really neat to have news stories that you could read.

0:16:18It was a lot of scrolling, because 160 by 160 pixels is not a lot of pixels,

0:16:25and it is funny that it was a square screen on a rectangular device because of the graffiti area

0:16:32with a couple of hard-coded home maps surrounding it.

0:16:36It was a lot of scrolling, but I think that when you're used to using a desktop computer,

0:16:43even today's phones, which are big, it's still a lot of scrolling.

0:16:46It's the nature of a small screen. There's a reason they don't print books that are the size of cell phones.

0:16:52It's not the greatest size for reading,

0:16:55but it's a nice compromise between portability and just the neatness of being.

0:17:01You could just be on the bus if that's how you get to work,

0:17:05and you'd have news to read in the thing that you hold in your pocket.

0:17:08It clearly felt like the future.

0:17:11It's impossible to talk about Palm in general and a Palm Pilot without comparing it to the Newton,

0:17:17which did come earlier.

0:17:18It was more capable in terms of its features. It was just slower and bigger.

0:17:23And more expensive, right?

0:17:24And more expensive, yeah.

0:17:25You know, the Newton debuted in 1993. I just looked it up.

0:17:28I think it was like $900, which in today's money is like $1500 or $1600,

0:17:33which is a lot of money for a gadget.

0:17:37But the Newton wasn't as big a failure as popular imagination would hold it to be.

0:17:43Sure. Yeah, I agree.

0:17:44And it's widely misunderstood.

0:17:47The handwriting actually got pretty good fast.

0:17:50So the beat up Martha jokes and the Doonesbury jokes didn't have long legs,

0:17:56but that's all people remember.

0:17:57But one thing they never got right was the size.

0:18:02It was it was it's a it was a terrible size in hindsight.

0:18:06Nobody has devices that big.

0:18:07We laugh about the biggest cell phones that are available.

0:18:10These giant 6.7 inch phones,

0:18:12but they still fit a pocket,

0:18:14right? The biggest cell phone you can buy still fits in a pocket.

0:18:17The Newton was it just it was neither here nor there.

0:18:21Not big enough to be considered a laptop,

0:18:24even like a netbook sized laptop,

0:18:27but way too big to fit in a pocket and sort of unwieldy to use in one hand.

0:18:34Yeah, I mean, there's an alternate future where,

0:18:37I don't know, the Newton was 20% more popular

0:18:40and it became the default for what we think computers are like,

0:18:43right? Then we're all carrying around little clipboards instead of phones and iPads and laptops or something.

0:18:49But I don't think that it was likely to get there given the processing power at the time.

0:18:55And actually so before the Palm Pilot Palm had this whole thing where they invented graffiti.

0:19:01They'd worked with I think I don't know it was Casio to try and make this thing called the Zoomer,

0:19:06which was huge and like kind of Newton-esque in some ways.

0:19:10And so when they started over and got a little bit of money to start their own company,

0:19:14Jeff Hawkins, one of his first decisions was we are going to use a slower processor

0:19:19and on purpose because we're going to keep this thing small

0:19:23and he picked his design decision was this thing will be this size

0:19:28and it needs to be very very fast and needs to be instant on

0:19:31and everything else has to flow from those two decisions

0:19:34and anything that breaks those two decisions is out the window.

0:19:39And that was very much my experience with it. It was super zippy,

0:19:42right? Like it turned on fast instantly and apps launched fast.

0:19:47They were small. They were tight.

0:19:50And for somebody who appreciates good hardware

0:19:54and especially software design it had that Apple-esque attention to details

0:20:00and it was a logically thought-out system.

0:20:03It was very easy to sort of get a handle on everything you could do.

0:20:08You never needed to dig into anything like a registry or something like that.

0:20:13It was the metaphor would be similar.

0:20:16It's familiar to anybody who uses an iPhone or an Android phone.

0:20:20You have a home screen and as apps and you tap on an app

0:20:23and it launches the app and that's it.

0:20:28But there was a nice though. It was a nice Mac-like consistency between apps.

0:20:35There was a right way to make a palm app

0:20:37and all palm apps followed these guidelines

0:20:40where if you learned how to use one app on the palm and you used a new app,

0:20:44it would be familiar to you and the menu would be in the same place.

0:20:47The design was the same.

0:20:49So the name for this guidelines was called the Zen of Palm.

0:20:53New people would come to work for Palm and Jeff and Rob Hytani,

0:20:56who was the software designer, came up with the Zen of Palm.

0:20:59They got tired of explaining their software design principles to every new hire.

0:21:04It was like, no, no, no, stop thinking like a PC.

0:21:05And so they wrote this book called the Zen of Palm and it was full of these cones.

0:21:10The most famous one is how do you fit a mountain in a teacup?

0:21:13And oh, you shrink the mountain, you build a teacup, blah, blah, blah.

0:21:15And the answer is you don't. You find the diamond in the middle of the mountain

0:21:18and you put that in the teacup. This had to fit 160 by 160 pixels.

0:21:22Black and white too, not grayscale.

0:21:25So one of Rob's design principles, he called it asymmetric design.

0:21:29It was just relentlessly saying what buttons belong on the screen

0:21:34and what stuff can get thrown into a menu and what belongs where.

0:21:38So one of the design examples is say the, you know, you want to save something.

0:21:42It's just you don't save it. It's just there.

0:21:44You wouldn't give equal weight to say the new button

0:21:48and the delete button because you delete stuff so much less often

0:21:51than you might want to make a new thing.

0:21:52And so he buried the new thing under a menu.

0:21:55Another thing that they did was the calendar picker where you would pick the day.

0:22:00They would, they managed to fit within two taps an entire year of dates on 160 by 160 screen.

0:22:08One of the tricks was they realized that the Palm OS system was so fast.

0:22:13It was very easy and non-destructive to cancel something.

0:22:17So they didn't put an OK button.

0:22:19They just made it so you launch the date picker, hit the date, and that's your date.

0:22:23And no one, this stuff seems really obvious and dumb now,

0:22:26but in 1996, these were like actually major innovations

0:22:31and they were ways that nobody had thought about making a user interface before.

0:22:36The Palm OS for people coming from the PC, which is the vast majority of users in the 90s,

0:22:42there is like a glass of ice water and hell element to what's effectively,

0:22:47it's not Mac style, but Mac caliber UI design where say what you want about Microsoft.

0:22:55Their interfaces were terrible and things like thinking,

0:22:59"Hey, what if we don't even have an OK button for picking a date?"

0:23:03You just pick the date Tuesday, March 7th, and that's it.

0:23:07You're done. And if it was the mistake, you can go back.

0:23:10It's easy to go back and fix it,

0:23:12but it saves that tap and it sounds stupid that saving one tap to select a date is this great breakthrough,

0:23:24but it adds up when it's pervasive throughout the system.

0:23:28Think about how bad the web is today,

0:23:31the stats of how quickly people will bail on a website if there's a delay or stuff bounces around.

0:23:36That's not a new principle.

0:23:37People got annoyed with stuff without knowing why since the beginning.

0:23:41When you've got someone who's actually thinking about that

0:23:43and paying attention to it and making a priority,

0:23:45it just feels better even if you can't express why.

0:23:48I do think, and I always thought right from the get-go,

0:23:51that Palm and Apple had largely aligned mentalities and priorities,

0:23:59but there were differences.

0:24:01And to me, it's best encapsulated that Palm was comparing to the Apple of the 90s.

0:24:09And probably through to today,

0:24:12Palm was more practical, or maybe pragmatic is the word.

0:24:17I can't think of a better example of it than the Newton going for true handwriting recognition right from the start,

0:24:24even when they didn't have it working, including then cursive,

0:24:30which was much more of a thing 25 years ago.

0:24:34I don't know many people,

0:24:37especially younger people, my son,

0:24:38I don't, he technically learned it,

0:24:40but it was like two weeks in,

0:24:42I don't know, third grade or something they spend on cursive.

0:24:45And cursive is harder to recognize than printing.

0:24:49Instead of doing handwriting recognition,

0:24:52Palm went with graffiti, which was very similar to printing.

0:24:57So somebody who doesn't know the rules of graffiti and you don't have the cheat sheet handy,

0:25:02if you looked at a note somebody wrote in graffiti,

0:25:06you'd be able to read it because many of the characters were just printed,

0:25:12alphabetic characters.

0:25:14Yeah, I used to,

0:25:15and I think this was very common amongst owners of Palm devices,

0:25:19is that you, you then wind up,

0:25:22you got so used to graffiti that you wound up using it in print with pen and ink.

0:25:26Like you're like, I would be like filling out my rent check

0:25:29and I'd wind up writing it out in graffiti and I'd be like,

0:25:33oh, what the hell am I doing?

0:25:34I just remember the T was sort of,

0:25:37you just go, it was like a seven, right?

0:25:39Yeah. Yeah. It was like a seven.

0:25:41Yeah. I don't want to give Palm too much credit.

0:25:43They like, they picked the slower processor.

0:25:45They had no choice. If they had wanted to do graffiti or handwriting recognition,

0:25:49if they had the processing part to do it,

0:25:51they might have ended up going down that path.

0:25:53They just, it wasn't even an option for them.

0:25:55The philosophy behind it was there's the difference between thinking of intuitive

0:25:59as like an innate thing that you just know as a human

0:26:02and intuitive as a thing that's easy to learn.

0:26:05And Jeff Hawkins was like,

0:26:06look, like if you spent five minutes,

0:26:0910 minutes learning this thing,

0:26:11it's easy to learn and then you can leapfrog

0:26:15and actually be relatively fast entering text to this thing

0:26:19and better to ask people to learn how to use a system for five

0:26:22or 10 minutes than to struggle for years to get our end of the handwriting

0:26:27recognition going. Now,

0:26:28how much of this is retconning that they found up an explanation

0:26:32for the thing that they had to do?

0:26:33I don't know. I mean the other thing to remember

0:26:35and it seems silly to even have to say this,

0:26:37but we're talking about styluses and resistive screens.

0:26:41The refresh rate of these screens, their ability to read input quickly is not very good.

0:26:47An iPhone 14 Pro or modern Android phone reads the screen 240 times a second, right?

0:26:54That's the double the 120 hertz refresh rate.

0:26:56I have no idea what the refresh rate was on these things,

0:26:59but if it was more than, I don't know, 30, I'd be shocked.

0:27:02Yeah, like when you scrolled, if you were reading an article

0:27:06or something, when you scrolled, it wasn't really scrolling.

0:27:10It was like paging down and it was show me the next page

0:27:14and because it couldn't do actual scrolling at a reasonable rate of refresh.

0:27:20Yep. But that was the way computers were.

0:27:23That was just, that wasn't even something you thought about.

0:27:25It would have been, it wasn't technically possible to make a device that size

0:27:31that had reasonable live scrolling of text.

0:27:34Yeah, maybe moving ahead a little bit, like this focus on practicality

0:27:39and let's launch a product based on the technology that we are able to use today

0:27:43that makes a decent experience today is ultimately, I think,

0:27:49what doomed Handspring and the Palm before webOS

0:27:53and even with webOS a little bit is you look at what Palm and Handspring

0:27:58were shipping when the iPhone came out and you look at the iPhone

0:28:00and they were so busy making devices and shipping them because they had to,

0:28:04because they had to sell stuff. They had to get stuff into carriers.

0:28:07They had to make the deals with carriers.

0:28:09They just, they had to make the money off of those things

0:28:12that they didn't have the time or the resources to step back

0:28:15and make a leapfrog in some kind of technology to enable a newer experience.

0:28:21And so in the early days up against both the Newton, but also like Pocket PC

0:28:26and you know, even Symbian, Blackberry, they were head to head, right?

0:28:31They made different technical choices that enabled a better experience

0:28:34within the limitations that everybody was facing,

0:28:37but they never got to the point where they could think about

0:28:39getting rid of those limitations that everyone was facing.

0:28:42And to me, that is fundamentally like the thing the iPhone did

0:28:47is they didn't work within the same constraints everybody else

0:28:50in the smartphone industry had. They stepped back and said,

0:28:52let's get rid of one of these restraints.

0:28:55And in some ways that's where Apple was a decade prior with the Mac, right?

0:28:59Oh, sure. Yeah.

0:29:00When they got desperate and when they finally broke down and bought an X

0:29:05and were thinking about buying B, that the Mac was all they had.

0:29:07They might as well have just been the Mac company and they were so far behind

0:29:12because they had neglected it when they should have been building

0:29:15a next generation operating system with modern features.

0:29:20Actually, what's your take looking back with all the benefits of hindsight on,

0:29:25I don't know, Copeland, OS 9, all that stuff before OS X in between

0:29:30the early systems and what they eventually had to do when they started over with Next.

0:29:34There's actually a parallel with Palm. They had those cobalt

0:29:38and they spent a lot of time porting Palm to ARM processors

0:29:43and they went in circles and then Palms were sold and they had a bunch of false starts

0:29:47before they finally hit on WebOS. But I'm curious,

0:29:51what do you think it was that kept Apple from making something that was truly modern?

0:29:56How did they get stuck in their own loop on that stuff?

0:29:59I think that they were in the early 90s, they were way too, for lack of a better adjective, academic.

0:30:07And that they were led by people who just had the sort of mindset

0:30:12that PhD computer scientists at a university have and doing things the right way.

0:30:19And it was not a Steve Jobsian product first mindset.

0:30:27And even the fact that they pre-announced them was just,

0:30:32it just isn't the way to actually build a product. And we know that now.

0:30:37Copeland was more focused. Copeland was the next generation of Mac OS

0:30:42and it was built to run, you know, it was a version of the Macintosh operating system

0:30:47and it was going to run the Mac apps people knew and loved

0:30:51and it was a better intention and it was something they should have built.

0:30:57I think long story short, I've never read like a definitive history of what went wrong with it,

0:31:02but I think long story short, shipping is really hard and doing an operating system is really hard

0:31:08and their management just wasn't up to it.

0:31:12And Steve Jobs has said this when they came back where he thought he'd come back

0:31:17and find that the company was bereft of talent and that that's why they failed

0:31:22and was incredibly pleasantly surprised to find out that the company was full of talented engineers

0:31:29and talented designers and that it really was just a management failure

0:31:34that the operating system and the whole platform as a whole had stagnated and fallen behind.

0:31:39Yeah, the stuff that happened with the sort of the last vestiges of Palm OS was the exact same problem.

0:31:46The management problem was they kept on spinning out companies and selling them and whatever,

0:31:50but before Palm itself embarked on WebOS, Palm Source over on,

0:31:55you know, the other end of this other company was developing a bunch of ideas

0:31:59that would have made a modern multitasking operating system.

0:32:03Famously, one of the reasons Palm OS was not good on trios towards the end there was

0:32:07it wasn't a true multitasking OS in the way that other smartphones were.

0:32:12Even the iPhone did a slightly better job multitasking than Palm OS there at the end,

0:32:16but they had built this really good multi-threaded OS that worked on mobile over at Palm Source.

0:32:21They just didn't finish it because they were mismanaged.

0:32:24And so everybody who worked for Palm Source eventually started hearing whispers

0:32:30that there was a new operating system being built over at this little company called Google.

0:32:35And so a bunch of the fundamentals of Android came not just from danger

0:32:42and the folks from the Sidekick company, Andy Rume's company,

0:32:45it also came from a bunch of people who slowly but surely left Palm Source to go work on something

0:32:50that was actually going to ship over at Google.

0:32:55It's the trio was the cell phone version of the Palm Pilot.

0:33:00It trios all and they all had hard hardware keyboards Blackberry style little keyboard underneath,

0:33:06I believe right and yeah, they all had keyboards.

0:33:10Actually the funny thing about the keyboard they originally had all the keys in an oval that was like tilted.

0:33:16I think to the right and Blackberry sued them.

0:33:19And so they had to they got in this big fight

0:33:22and it turns out what Blackberry had was a design patent of some sort.

0:33:25And so all they did was they flipped the direction of the ovals on the left-hand side of the keyboard to avoid getting sued by Blackberry.

0:33:33I remember in that era the people who had devices like that.

0:33:37I worked at barebone software for two years the BB edit company 2000 to 2002

0:33:43and that was like the height of handspring

0:33:45and I think majority of the people I worked with we all had handspring visors and really liked them.

0:33:51But one of the guys there had a trio and he just loved it and it was like an expensive cell plan.

0:33:59I just had a dumb candy bar cell phone and I got it and he wasn't like proselytizing it,

0:34:05but he just loved it and said this is the future having networking on a thing

0:34:10and I could see the appeal of it.

0:34:12It was just too expensive and I also recall the late Aaron Swartz who was a friend of mine was a big sidekick fan.

0:34:19Yeah, and I forget what year that would be that would have been a little bit later probably like 2003-2004 ish.

0:34:27That sounds right.

0:34:28Yeah, and I remember being with him a couple times like one time.

0:34:32He spent a couple of days in Philadelphia for some other reason and we got together a couple times

0:34:36and he just he was proselytizing.

0:34:38He was like you've got to get one of these and I sat there and went through it with him

0:34:42and I was like, well, this is there's so many things wrong with this interface on the sidekick and he was like,

0:34:48yeah, yeah, and he totally agreed with all of my complaints

0:34:50and he was like, but you don't understand how worth it.

0:34:54It is that when you are out and there's like a trivia question or like a conversion you need to make you just type it in

0:35:01and you get the answer wherever you are.

0:35:03You could it's it's game life-changing and I didn't disagree with him,

0:35:08but I didn't the product was so unappealing to me that I was like,

0:35:13ah, I'll wait.

0:35:15But so here here's the insane thing.

0:35:18I was in the same boat of trying to proselytize this stuff.

0:35:20I remember I had a the hamstring visor with this terrible a camera on it called the i-module

0:35:26and I was like look you could take a picture and then it'll sink over and people like this is stupid.

0:35:30Like no, you don't understand this is the future.

0:35:32But the the insane thing is the people who didn't get it more than anybody were the carriers.

0:35:39They literally told people at handspring.

0:35:42Nobody will ever want to take a picture on this.

0:35:44No one will ever want to send a photo.

0:35:46Nobody will ever want to have a text entry that isn't T9.

0:35:51Right. They were the hardest people to convince them all

0:35:54because they were making money hand over fist by just selling high-margin candy bar phones.

0:36:01Right. It was like the only text messages anybody sends are things like BRB or be right there in there like so,

0:36:09why would anybody want to have a complex text thing?

0:36:12All they do is send three characters at a time as opposed to thinking the reason everybody was texting like that was

0:36:17because T9 was such an enormous pain in the ass.

0:36:20Yeah, it was like they had it although I was pretty good at T9.

0:36:24Oh, I was I didn't use it enough.

0:36:26I guess I got better. It was a weird skill.

0:36:29I actually my son is a senior in high school and we were just talking about that.

0:36:34Somehow it came up about the way that push-button phones have always had the letters underneath

0:36:39and he was like, I don't understand that.

0:36:41I don't understand how people give 1-800 get Coke as the Coca-Cola hotline.

0:36:46He said what does that even mean?

0:36:47I say well, you just look for the letter under the number and translate it.

0:36:50But just just type even if G and E are the same letter you just type it twice.

0:36:55And I was like, but when we used to text message you would press the key as many times

0:37:01if the T was the third letter on the number you'd press that one three times to make it a T instead of the first one.

0:37:07And it was so totally unoptimized for the alphabet

0:37:12and the actual frequency with which you use numbers, right?

0:37:17It's so T's the first one. I'm looking at it now T's the first one on eight,

0:37:21but like the five key is so inefficient J K and L J and K pretty uncommon letters L very common letter.

0:37:30You had to type three times E was two presses S four presses on a seven for S the most frequent consonant in the English language.

0:37:42You had to press the key four times.

0:37:45Am I misremembering that there were some phones that had like a auto prediction where you you could just hit the numbers

0:37:51and not have to hit him four times that did happen, right? I'm not just making that up.

0:37:54Yep. And as I recall in my mind that became a thing right around 2007.

0:38:01It was it was too late.

0:38:04No, but that definitely became a thing where they would do like dictionary lookups

0:38:08and you could just press press it once but we'll be doomed to complain about auto correct for the rest of our lives.

0:38:14Man, you've been tweeting about auto correct being bad on the iPhone.

0:38:18Oh my god, you have to go through these workarounds.

0:38:20It is it's pretty bad and I don't understand what what they're pulling from

0:38:26and that they can just drop to 2.0.

0:38:29I bounce a lot between different phones and between iOS and Android.

0:38:33So I just assume that I always have bad auto correct and like my muscle memory for different keyboard sizes is always wrong.

0:38:41This is why I make so many typos on Twitter.

0:38:43Or at least it's I tell myself that's why but man it is bonkers how it feels like we've regressed

0:38:51and I can't tell if it's because we expect more and it doesn't it's not hitting that or if it's an actual regression.

0:38:58I think it's an actual regression to some degree

0:39:01and Ken Kishenda who's no longer at Apple,

0:39:04but he was the engineer he wrote the book creative selection.

0:39:08I believe is the title of his excellent book.

0:39:10He's at that mysterious startup.

0:39:12Now, what's it called started by two other ex-apple people?

0:39:15Oh shoot.

0:39:16I know the one you're talking about.

0:39:18It's got a like a very like generic generic name,

0:39:22but like a abstract name.

0:39:24Yeah, I'm losing it.

0:39:25Hold on.

0:39:25I know it's on his Twitter bio.

0:39:27It is humane humane.

0:39:30Yes.

0:39:30Right.

0:39:30Thank you.

0:39:31I don't know what they're I honestly don't know what they're doing.

0:39:33I'm friends with Ken,

0:39:34but I like any good former Apple person his lips are utterly sealed.

0:39:38I'm not even sure his spouse knows what he's working on.

0:39:41But anyway, he was the he wrote the original keyboard

0:39:45and autocorrect for the original iPhone.

0:39:48It was just that was one person can because the team was small.

0:39:52That's how you keep things secret and he has unsurprisingly strong opinions about this.

0:39:56But I think the fundamental error Apple is made on this

0:39:59and it's a this is a very big tangent,

0:40:02but I think it is the way that modern Apple really wants to hide how things work

0:40:12and there is to me that it the antithesis of the classic Mac OS

0:40:18where in the classic Mac OS you could all why did whatever just happened happened.

0:40:24You could always figure out exactly why

0:40:27so there was autocorrect like on classic Mac OS in 1990,

0:40:32but if there had been or you would have been able to know exactly what

0:40:37and why on Mac OS 10

0:40:40and it's a thing they inherited from next it literally might date to like 1989

0:40:46and it might be in the exact same location,

0:40:48but like you're typing in a regular Mac app

0:40:51and you type a word that isn't in the dictionary

0:40:56and it gets the red underlines,

0:40:58but you know,

0:40:58it's an actual word.

0:40:59Maybe it's like a product name or something like that

0:41:02and you control click on it

0:41:04and or right click on it

0:41:05and you can say add to dictionary

0:41:07and now now any way in other apps other documents that word will always be treated as spelled correctly that

0:41:16but what happens if you make a mistake

0:41:17or you want to take one out?

0:41:19Well,

0:41:19there's actually it's just a simple text file.

0:41:21I forget the actual name.

0:41:22I can put a link in the show notes,

0:41:24but in your home folder in the library in some folder within the library.

0:41:30There is just a text file

0:41:33and you could open it up in any text editor

0:41:35and it is just one word per line.

0:41:37It's not it's not an p-list XML file.

0:41:40It's not JSON or anything like that.

0:41:43Just a text file a list of words

0:41:45and there they all are

0:41:46and you could see them

0:41:47and you can know that you therefore you can know

0:41:51where these extra words that aren't in the dictionary come from

0:41:54and where to go to add them.

0:41:55There's nothing like that on iOS,

0:41:57right?

0:41:58It's there's no way to know why when I was typing 20 to 0.

0:42:05I kept getting 2.0 as the autocorrect

0:42:10and that one was hitting me for months

0:42:12and it's I type I try to type the digits 20 frequently enough

0:42:20that it was something that I complained about in public on Daring Fireball,

0:42:25but infrequently enough that I never ever remembered

0:42:29that this is not going to work.

0:42:31I need to go to the correction bar right above the keyboard

0:42:35and manually select quote 20 instead of taking the default 2.0

0:42:41which several people pointed out you can just do that

0:42:44and I was like, yeah, but I don't remember

0:42:45I don't expect when I type 20 on the keyboard

0:42:49for that to be autocorrected and it turns out

0:42:51well and also it should it should remember

0:42:53that you've done that a couple of times

0:42:54and just changed like that to put too fine a point on it,

0:42:57but that is that is what Gboard does right?

0:43:00Well and supposedly some people said that if you type it like eight times

0:43:04eight or nine times and choose it out each time it'll remember then

0:43:08but again, there's no way there's no way of knowing

0:43:11how many times you need to do it before it'll stick

0:43:14and the explanation I got the correct explanation.

0:43:17I'm a hundred percent sure this is where the at least this one was coming from.

0:43:21It wasn't some machine learning thing.

0:43:24It was the fact that I have an app installed with 2.0 in the app's name.

0:43:29It's our right and and it's an app.

0:43:32I don't want to get rid of I don't know why it's a stupid thing to put in the app's name anyway,

0:43:37but that's where it came from and the solution I chose which works is to go to settings

0:43:46general keyboard text replacements

0:43:48and just make a do-nothing text replacement.

0:43:51We're typing the digits to zero has the shortcut to zero.

0:43:57So it's right just type to zero to get to zero.

0:44:01But once you add that as a text repla I prefer that even though it seems it is annoying to me

0:44:07as a perfectionist that I have to make a do-nothing text replacement for this

0:44:12and this works for swear words to if you're cursed with the ducking instead of the f-word version.

0:44:18You can just add that word in there as a do-nothing text replacement

0:44:22and it should you know, stop giving you ducking where you want to curse

0:44:27but it there's no explanation.

0:44:29There's no document that says here's where autocorrect gets sources

0:44:32and a lot of people I don't know if it's true or not.

0:44:34You don't know but Apple doesn't explain it lots

0:44:37and lots of people emailing me in about this since I wrote about it.

0:44:41I've said that they're convinced that in addition to like surprising sources,

0:44:45like the names of your apps installed in one fellow has a game.

0:44:50One of my readers has a game where the the name has the word Amy and it AMY,

0:44:56but they spell it in all caps right Mario run does the same thing.

0:45:00So Mario Mario run is Nintendo spells it in all capital letters.

0:45:05So if you type Mario you it autocorrects to the all caps version.

0:45:10Well, this guy's wife's name is Amy and guess what?

0:45:12He types his wife's name a lot and every time he thanked me for the autocorrects.

0:45:17I suggested he obviously has a contact card for her too,

0:45:20but it was defaulting to this game.

0:45:22He has where Amy is spelled in all caps.

0:45:24So every time he typed his wife's name it turned into all caps.

0:45:27I have a great startup idea.

0:45:28We're going to make an app for every single person's name.

0:45:31We're going to find out something that will get it through App Store reviews

0:45:34till it'll actually be accepted and then you can you can pay 99 cents

0:45:38to get an app that will keep autocorrect from screwing up your closest contacts names.

0:45:44It is it's a funny thing that we have to complain about but there we are.

0:45:48All right. Let me take a break here.

0:45:49Thank our next sponsor.

0:45:50It's our good friends at Hello fresh with Hello fresh.

0:45:54You get farm fresh pre-portioned ingredients

0:45:57and seasonal recipes delivered right to your doorstep skip trips to the grocery store

0:46:02and count on Hello fresh to make home cooking easy fun and affordable.

0:46:07That's why Hello fresh is America's number one meal kit the new year.

0:46:11Hey, it's New Year.

0:46:12It's a great time to make resolutions and focus on what's most important to you

0:46:17whether that's saving money by ordering less takeout learning to cook

0:46:20or just prioritizing your Wellness.

0:46:22Hello fresh is here to help with endless options to make cooking at home simple and enjoyable.

0:46:28Hello fresh cuts back on time spent in the kitchen

0:46:31so you can spend it on your other resolutions with meals ready in around 30 minutes or less.

0:46:36Plus they have quick and easy meals that include 20 minute recipes with lower prep easy cleanup

0:46:42to provide an even faster route to putting food on the table

0:46:46and don't forget dessert.

0:46:47They've got dessert you can satisfy your sweet tooth with seasonal limited-time goodies

0:46:52like Dunkaroo cookie dough or vanilla delight cheesecake lots of good stuff crowd-pleasing menu options

0:46:59every single week that you get to choose from go to hello fresh.com/talkshow16

0:47:06and use that code talk show 16.

0:47:08That's with a one and a six.

0:47:10Why is it talk show 16 because you get up to 16 free meals and three free gifts.

0:47:16So go to hellofresh.com/talkshow16 use that code talk show 16 get up to 16 free meals

0:47:24and three free gifts from Hello fresh another similarity with Apple

0:47:29was that they started with a black and white operating system.

0:47:33Literally not grayscale just black and white pixels

0:47:36and then eventually went to color and it was sort of a painful transition.

0:47:41Yeah with palm.

0:47:42It was the transition to grayscale.

0:47:44I've met it was a transition to color which came honestly kind of late,

0:47:48but it was also the transition to different screen dimensions.

0:47:51They went from 160 by 160 to 320 which was just pixel doubling.

0:47:55So that was great.

0:47:56They finally released some random PDAs that I think had 360 by 480 screens,

0:48:01but they were just stuck on that screen resolution and apps that were hard-coded

0:48:06to that screen resolution up until they just they killed off their palm OS devices.

0:48:11They just they could never get out of it.

0:48:13Yeah, the Mac had similar problems in the 80s

0:48:15when they started growing beyond the classic slash original Mac all-in-one form factor.

0:48:22That was 512 by 384 you'd find some shareware app

0:48:26and then you'd launch it on a bigger display

0:48:29and it would just just show up as 512 by 384 area on the screen.

0:48:35It was like, huh? Guess this is an older app.

0:48:39Those things are tough, you know,

0:48:40and I think part of what made the iPhone a success

0:48:45and has kept it relevant and thriving I think is true for Android too,

0:48:49is that by building on the foundations of actual Unix or in the case of Android Linux.

0:48:58It had room to grow in multitasking even if the way they implement it was like the lack of quote-unquote

0:49:06multitasking in the first few versions of the iPhone's operating system wasn't

0:49:12because the OS didn't support it.

0:49:13It was because the user interface didn't support it

0:49:16because they didn't didn't have enough RAM didn't have

0:49:19and it didn't have enough CPU didn't have enough battery life to have anything running in the background.

0:49:24Wasn't that they technically couldn't it was that

0:49:27as a product decision they encapsulated it into an interface that once you hit the home button,

0:49:32whatever you were using was suspended.

0:49:35That was it. Yeah, it's an interesting academic question.

0:49:39What are the decisions and preconceptions at the foundation of the operating system

0:49:44that are difficult to change or immutable

0:49:47and I feel like I don't know right now there's way fewer of those at least on modern operating systems.

0:49:55There's more freedom to change stuff around and add features

0:49:58and move UI around in ways that the real limitation is just a philosophy more than it is.

0:50:05Can the thing actually do it?

0:50:07There the other similarity that I see and these movies your movie springboard

0:50:12and the general magic movie and just the overall nostalgia

0:50:15and hey, we are where we are in the mobile world of the duopoly of iOS and Android.

0:50:21It no longer feels like news.

0:50:23This is it's just cemented.

0:50:24It's the world we live in.

0:50:26Yeah, but looking back at it there is just an incredible similarity in pda's to phones.

0:50:33Whatever you want to call all these handhelds to the early PC era of the late 70s

0:50:38and early 80s where there were dozens of different platforms

0:50:43and dozens of companies and everybody just did their own thing

0:50:45and there was Commodore and Atari had computers

0:50:48and of course there was Apple and the then came the PC and DOS.

0:50:54You could just out air the list goes on and on and then there were two.

0:51:00It was the Mac and Windows and it's the same with the pda's and the early phones,

0:51:05right? Like you mentioned Symbian there was Blackberry there were Newton

0:51:09and Palm and of course pocket PC from Microsoft

0:51:13and there were lots and lots and lots of platforms and lots of enthusiasm from early adopters

0:51:20and then there were two.

0:51:23Yeah. Well, and I mean, do I think that it's inevitable that platform markets boil down to duopolies?

0:51:28I'd like to say no. It was a lot more fun back in the day

0:51:31when I was running Trio Central, Windows Central, Nokia Central, Android Central

0:51:37and iMore all at the same time.

0:51:39There were we had we had and there were communities around every single one of these

0:51:43smartphone platforms and it wasn't really clear who was going to win out

0:51:47and what was going to stick around

0:51:48and there was lots of money being invested and devices out there

0:51:52and now the best hope for diversity is a bunch of companies running stuff that is sort of like

0:51:57Android S right that will run Android apps,

0:51:59but maybe isn't technically just a straight Google version of Android

0:52:03or start to see that on. I don't know Chromebooks and Windows is going to run Android apps now,

0:52:07but yeah, it's I don't know. I part of me is just I like the idea of more competition.

0:52:11I like the idea of more diversity, but I also like the idea of having a big stable ecosystem

0:52:16from a company that can be held accountable for,

0:52:19you know, making sure stuff doesn't fall apart. Right?

0:52:21So I don't know I and looking at Palm in particular.

0:52:26They just they're one of those companies where especially with handspring that little

0:52:31interregnum period of palm. They just they had so much stacked against them

0:52:36that it's a miracle. They shipped products at all.

0:52:39This like my joke that I always tell is if at six points in their history,

0:52:43if just one executive had made a different decision

0:52:47or if one venture capitalist had given them an extra 300 million dollars things would have been different.

0:52:52They got bought by US Robotics. I got bought by three com. They spun out.

0:52:56They got spun back in they spun out in two different companies.

0:52:59They they sold off another company. They had three false starts on different operating systems.

0:53:04They tried to sell into Verizon Verizon said no,

0:53:08they got stuck with Sprint. They did it again Verizon played them

0:53:12and launched the droid instead of the Palm pre just over and over and over again.

0:53:17They got they got stuck by just external sort of economic

0:53:20and corporate factors that prevented their decent products from having a chance to improve

0:53:27and evolve and is it inevitable that the same sort of thing would have happened to other platforms?

0:53:34I don't know. I look at Microsoft in particular.

0:53:37They're the ones where I just don't get it.

0:53:39I don't get why they weren't able to just stick with it

0:53:43and make something good other than they didn't realize what a mobile device should be until it was way way way way way too late

0:53:51and the market had already been ossified into iOS and Android.

0:53:55I think that again doing the alternate universes.

0:53:58I think there's an alternate universe where if Satya Nadella had taken over earlier from Balmer

0:54:05and I'm not saying Balmer obviously made the company tons of money

0:54:09and there are some good analogies between him

0:54:13and Tim Cook in terms of how the company grew under his leadership after Bill Gates stepped aside.

0:54:20You mentioned the Palm pre now that's this is beyond the scope of springboard.

0:54:25You're the documentary which is very specifically the reason you get away with doing it in 32 minutes.

0:54:30Is that you're very specifically tightly focused on handspring.

0:54:33The Palm pre was palms answer to the iPhone.

0:54:39And so there's what we should also mention.

0:54:42We don't think I've linked to it yet from during Fireball.

0:54:45I wanted to have you on and before I did but you you dug up.

0:54:49I've I've made great hay over the years of the Ed Colligan quote from the New York Times in December of 2006 at some sort of public function.

0:55:00He was interviewed by John Mark off on stage and yep and December 2006 is a month before the iPhone was introduced on stage at Mac World Expo

0:55:13and the nobody knew what it was going to look like most people including me were betting it would be some sort of iPod phone

0:55:22but the rumblings that Apple was doing a phone were

0:55:28as strong as without knowing any details of what it what the hell it actually was were so strong

0:55:33because there's just it was too many chances to leak that I don't know if it leaked from AT&T or at the time singular who knows

0:55:41but just basically Apple is doing a phone was out there in the air

0:55:45and the way that the quote was originally printed made it seem like Ed Colligan was talking very specifically about Apple

0:55:53and the way he was quoted was the PC guys aren't we've been doing this for a long time PC guys aren't just going to come in.

0:56:01Right and it turns out you've done the work.

0:56:04That's not what he said.

0:56:07Well, yeah, not not quite.

0:56:08So the thing the way he was quoted was PC guys are not just going to figure this out.

0:56:12They're not just going to walk in but it was actually they were talking both Ed and John and everybody was like,

0:56:16well, it'll be an iPod and maybe it'll just use Wi-Fi and not connect to the carriers because Apple hates the carriers.

0:56:22They call them orifices. But what about the Moto Q which was Windows Mobile device that was not great.

0:56:28And he also there are rumblings that Google was going to be making something at the time Eric Schmidt,

0:56:32who is a CEO of Google was saying things like oh phone should be free.

0:56:35We're going to give phones away and we'll make money on the back end never quite got there.

0:56:41So that's the context of the question

0:56:43and then Colligan's quote is I would just caution people that think they're going to walk in here and just do these we struggled for a few years.

0:56:50The PC guys are not going to just knock this out and then he's like welcome guarantee it welcome.

0:56:55Let's go for it come on in and he also says a little bit later on.

0:56:59I'm not trying to be cocky about this. It's a it's a tough business.

0:57:02So but I asked Ed about this later during the interview.

0:57:04It didn't make it into the documentary.

0:57:06He was very quick to point out like look like I got my start at Apple.

0:57:09Donna got her started Apple two or three of my companies that I've started were basically like Apple software accessory companies.

0:57:16I love Apple. I use Apple stuff.

0:57:18I was trying to talk about the market in general and PC guys in general not specifically about Apple,

0:57:23which is he is the apples in the in the thing he's reacting to here.

0:57:27So it's not so much if he was saying well,

0:57:29they're they definitely aren't going to walk in figure this out.

0:57:31I'm predicting failure here.

0:57:33It was indictment on Google specifically,

0:57:36but also Motorola and a bunch of other companies that like it's not as easy to make a phone as people seem to think it is and that's true.

0:57:46A bunch of companies thought it would be really easy to just roll into the mobile market and make a phone and they turned out to be wrong.

0:57:52But I also think that it's not just that it making a phone was like so hard that that's the only reason palm didn't do well,

0:57:58right palm palm shot itself in the foot in a million ways.

0:58:02The thing about Ed Colligan is he is he is by far the nicest sort of kindest CEO I've ever interacted with perhaps to a fault.

0:58:15And that's one of the reasons that if palm had been maybe been a little bit more ruthless and cutthroat,

0:58:20they might have had a different history the idea that he would like cynically be taking a pot shot at Apple is pretty unlikely.

0:58:28Not the least of which because around this time he had specifically called Steve Jobs and said,

0:58:35hey Steve, how's it going?

0:58:36We've got this new trio here and we also were thinking about making this folio,

0:58:41which was a failed proto netbook product that they were considering

0:58:44and Steve Jobs said, oh, yeah, it seems nice.

0:58:46I don't really use smartphones myself.

0:58:48Thanks. No, thanks. One of these two maybe three or four times that palm

0:58:54and Apple got in the same room together

0:58:57and there was the vibe that maybe the acquisition could happen.

0:59:00Steve called Donna Dubinsky back when they were palm way beforehand

0:59:02and offered said that they should go over and let Apple buy him and Donna said she didn't want to work for anybody anymore.

0:59:08So anyway, long story short it it was a bit of a misquote directionally.

0:59:13He maybe was being a little bit too.

0:59:17He was overstating how how how difficult it might be for some companies,

0:59:22but he definitely got it right that a bunch of companies thought it would be easy and it super wasn't.

0:59:27I think that the key thing that he didn't foresee had nothing to do with the hardware or software.

0:59:34I even though the iPhone was surprisingly advanced and famously the the Blackberry executives thought Apple was lying about its

0:59:43capabilities that it couldn't possibly there's no way they could pack what they're saying.

0:59:47They're packed into a thing like that.

0:59:49And so I do think it was surprising it was ahead of its time.

0:59:52It was years ahead of the competition at a product level,

0:59:56but I think the key thing that Ed Colligan and nobody else really foresaw was Apple and and I will I tend to be loathe to say only Steve Jobs could blank.

1:00:11But I feel like in the case of the deal they got from singular /at&t and the control they got over the product was something that somebody like Ed Colligan

1:00:24who had negotiated with all these carriers around the world and new knew why Steve Jobs called them orifices

1:00:30and knew what those the carriers did to these products from an end Palm of all companies knew this

1:00:38because they were a product centric company right they they knew they knew what things became worse on a trio

1:00:46once it went through the filter of Verizon or whoever else and the fact that Apple was able to get singular to just say you do you do your thing Apple you make it your way you handle the software updates.

1:01:00It's all sure you can do it all famously.

1:01:02They didn't even see the iPhone.

1:01:04They didn't show it to them.

1:01:06They obviously you know knew about like the antenna details and and stuff like that like the things that made the iPhone a phone

1:01:16and they worked with AT&T to get the visual voicemail as a feature on day one,

1:01:21which again in hindsight is bananas that we you used to actually have to deal with all of your voicemail on a phone call.

1:01:30You'd have to the only way before the iPhone to get your voicemail was to call.

1:01:35I forget what you hit it was a pound.

1:01:38I don't know pound 70 or something like that would make a phone call to your carrier

1:01:42and you would say you have three new voice messages and you'd have to deal with them all on the keypad.

1:01:49So they obviously knew some details.

1:01:51It wasn't like it was a complete black box

1:01:53but famously singular didn't actually get to see the iPhone and know that it had a touch screen and what it looked like and stuff like that.

1:01:59I don't think anybody foresaw that and it was obviously key to the iPhone's success.

1:02:05I think that even given the quality of the hardware

1:02:09and the software that Apple was able to do if the iPhone had gone had to go through the typical carrier filter of well,

1:02:18let us add our Verizon app and stuff like that

1:02:21and we'll all firmware updates or whatever you want to call software updates.

1:02:25We'll we have to handle that.

1:02:26There's no way we can let you handle that it.

1:02:29In other words the customers relationship would be like with all previous phones entirely through the carrier

1:02:35and Apple just happened to be the company that made the phone

1:02:37but you have no relationship with Apple your relationship was would be entirely through your carrier.

1:02:43The fact that Apple was able to negotiate their way out of that with just starting with one carrier one,

1:02:49but one major carrier to me was the key thing that he that I don't think Ed Colligan foresaw.

1:02:57And I think he would have his know what it is.

1:03:00I think his quote even correctly in context as as you now have the transcript would would date much better.

1:03:07If Apple had to it was like if Apple hadn't found a partner

1:03:11and singular willing to do this it would have played out much more like Ed Colligan foresaw.

1:03:16Yeah, there would have been way more compromises in the product.

1:03:18I mean Palm was unable they got the core on one carrier in Europe in Orange.

1:03:26They made them get rid of the home screen and replace it with an orange home screen in the US

1:03:31several carriers refused to let them ship an email app on the phone itself.

1:03:37They made they had a they had to back door it to like customers sync it over

1:03:40after they installed it in like the manual in the box

1:03:43because the carriers would only allow them to ship it with the carriers email app linked to your at sprit.net.

1:03:50Whatever email address was on the phone itself like just utterly ridiculous requirements that you know,

1:03:57and Palm just didn't have the leverage to say no I could be misremembering

1:04:02this because this is why I didn't have a smartphone at the time,

1:04:04but I remember I seem to recall that at least one of the US carriers they gave you an email address.

1:04:10You could only use their email address on their quote-unquote smartphones,

1:04:13but your email address was your phone number at carrier name.com or something like that.

1:04:19Like you don't even get your name. It was just your phone number as your email address.

1:04:25I mean, I asked everybody that I interviewed for this thing.

1:04:27Why do you think the iPhone beat you? I gotta ask and Jeff Hawkins was one of the first everyone said it was a great product.

1:04:33Although everyone said that the very first iteration wasn't that good

1:04:36but Jeff Hawkins recognized that like they nailed the form factor

1:04:39and Peter Skillman who is industrial designer for handspring also pointed out the ability to like step back

1:04:46and go make that capacitive touch screen.

1:04:48So the the ability for Apple to have a fresh slate

1:04:54and make a product that didn't have any sort of historical baggage attached to it,

1:05:00combined with the ability to convince a carrier to let them just make the thing they want to make,

1:05:06is why the iPhone became the iPhone. Why it just blew everybody's mind.

1:05:12And just if you if you're worried about next quarter's results and you're worried about making payroll,

1:05:17you're just never going to be able to do that.

1:05:19Yeah, I'd like to thank our third and final sponsor Ernest,

1:05:22E-A-R-N-E-S-T. Look, it's 2022. Federal student loan payments are on hold,

1:05:28but with interest rates this low now is a good time to refinance your federal student loans.

1:05:37Ernest was voted best student loan refinancing overall by NerdWallet who knows their stuff.

1:05:44Ernest has some of the lowest rates, flexible payments, and an in-house team ready to help you.

1:05:51With Ernest, you could change your interest rate, get a lower monthly payment,

1:05:55and you'd never pay fees, not even late fees.

1:05:57And by refinancing, you can reduce your loan term, save money,

1:06:01or combine multiple loans into one simple monthly payment with a lower rate.

1:06:08If you have questions, you can even talk to a real live human being at Ernest for help.

1:06:12And when you pay less interest, you can put that money toward your goals for 2022.

1:06:18With Ernest, it only takes two minutes to see what your new rate could be,

1:06:21and there's no credit impact for checking.

1:06:24And right now, Ernest is offering listeners of the talk show a $100 cash bonus,

1:06:30$100. Refinance your student debt at Ernest, E-A-R-N-E-S-T,

1:06:34Ernest.com/the-talk-show. Not available in all 50 states.

1:06:40Once again, you get a $100 cash bonus when you visit Ernest.com/the-talk-show

1:06:44to refinance your student loan.

1:06:47And now, the legally mandated small talk at the end of the read.

1:06:51Visit Ernest.com/the-talk-show for more details. Not available in all states.

1:06:57Terms and conditions apply.

1:06:58Ernest Student Loan Refinancing made by Ernest Operations, LLC,

1:07:03NMLS number 1204917, California Financing Law License number 6054788.

1:07:14They are at 535 Mission Street, San Francisco, California, zip code 94105.

1:07:19Visit Ernest.com/licenses for a full list of licenses.

1:07:24All right, but that leads us to the Palm Pre,

1:07:26and I think over the years you've been on my show, we've danced around.

1:07:31Let's dig in. When better than now for me and you to have it out with Palm Pre?

1:07:37I will say this. I think the Palm Pre is arguably the nicest product I've ever used that didn't make it.

1:07:48Or it's up there on the list.

1:07:51Yeah. Here's the thing about me and the Palm Pre.

1:07:55Obviously everybody knows I'm at Ran Pre Central, closely associated with the brand,

1:07:58married somebody who worked at Palm.

1:08:00I gotta say the nicest is hard for me to agree with.

1:08:03It had the most potential and it was like the best designed in terms of software

1:08:08and it was like the most clearly like intentional.

1:08:12It would have a complete thought to it. But man, that hardware was terrible.

1:08:16Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, I guess that what you said is better matches my feelings.

1:08:22It needed to improve.

1:08:24I'm not saying that as it actually shipped, it was the best product that didn't make it.

1:08:29But what it needed, when it just needs to get faster, that's a thing you can do, right?

1:08:36What was wrong with the Newton is a complex question because it was a lot.

1:08:42It wasn't just it needed to be faster, right?

1:08:44It needed lots and lots of things.

1:08:47What do I think is wrong with Windows user interface?

1:08:52Well, that's like one of those computer books we used to buy back in the 90s

1:08:58where they're like as thick as a phone book.

1:08:59It's like because famously I forget, I think it was Tim O'Reilly who said,

1:09:04yeah, it's why are these computer books so thick?

1:09:06We figured because look at the sales data.

1:09:08People go into a bookstore and they're looking for a book on blank,

1:09:13whatever it is, and they just pick the thickest one and go to the register.

1:09:17Yeah, amazing. That's that's what like my list of what's wrong with when the what was wrong with the Palm pre was it was too slow.

1:09:25Yeah, well and like the hardware was a little junky. They couldn't afford to make something truly nice.

1:09:29The thing about the web OS and the pre is if you remember what phones were like when it first launched,

1:09:38they were a little late, but Android was pretty junky at the time.

1:09:43It was not anywhere near as polished as it is now.

1:09:46There were things that the iPhone was incapable of doing at the time that the Palm pre could do.

1:09:52I don't remember where in the timeline Windows Mobile versus Windows Phone lands here,

1:09:58but both of those were not in a super polished place.

1:10:01We look at our phones now and it's hard to remember that back in 2007, 2008, 2009.

1:10:09These things were actually like not great.

1:10:12They were all slow and they all had weirdnesses with the interface

1:10:15and they were all missing stuff that they obviously needed to do at some point.

1:10:18But with the original pre because they had a clean slate,

1:10:23they could launch with a complete thought of here is this thing.

1:10:27Here's how it works. Here are a bunch of new ideas

1:10:31for what a phone can do and what it's like notification should look like

1:10:35and what's multitasking should look like that.

1:10:38I don't want to say revolutionary. I'm not going to say that.

1:10:40I don't think that people had thought of some of these ideas inside of Apple or Microsoft or Google,

1:10:48but they were actually able to just make the thing

1:10:51and ship it instead of having an interesting UI idea

1:10:53and then putting it on the roadmap for three years down the road.

1:10:56Yeah, it actually shipped. It wasn't just that,

1:10:59okay, sure, people at Apple and Google and Nokia had ideas for modern notification UI

1:11:06and it's on a whiteboard somewhere. This was something that actually shipped.

1:11:09Let me make sure I'm getting the timeline right.

1:11:12I know the timeline of the iPhone announced in January 2007,

1:11:17shipped at the end of June 2007, the original aluminum black iconic original iPhone.

1:11:24Then a year later, they came out, Apple came out with the iPhone 3G,

1:11:28which added of course 3G networking and but changed the form factor to this sort of crappy plastic back.

1:11:35To me, it's clearly the two worst iPhones of all time,

1:11:38where the 3G in terms of in terms of industrial design 3G.

1:11:42Oh, sure. Sure. 3G and 3GS those plastic ones,

1:11:45but that's 2008 and that came out in June too.

1:11:47I believe the pre came out in like the spring of 2008.

1:11:53So it's 2009. They announced it at CES in 2009,

1:11:58the only good thing to ever come out of CES and then it got released in June of that year

1:12:04and I forget the exact date and I really should know it

1:12:06because it was like that's like the thing you could punch in to turn on developer mode on it

1:12:10if you knew the launch date of the Palm Pre.

1:12:12So it was two years after the iPhone, but what I knew it was June though,

1:12:17because I it's one of those memories I have where I know exactly where I was

1:12:22when I first got to play with a pre. I was at the beer bash at WWDC in June.

1:12:31I don't remember who had the pre, but it's where we're there on that big grass lawn

1:12:36where they always used to have the beer bash when it was at Moscone.

1:12:40Somebody in a group of people I knew had the pre and was like,

1:12:46would you like to play with it? And I was like, yes,

1:12:49and that's all I remember. It was like this experience of like the first time I saw the iPhone.

1:12:55I just I couldn't possibly get enough time with it.

1:12:58The thing that hit me right when I started using it was

1:13:03and I think it's true is if you went back in time to

1:13:10the classic, let's say 1998 when Steve Jobs was back next was back,

1:13:14but they were headed to the secret project they were working on that would become what wasn't really secret,

1:13:19but what was to become Mac OS X was still years from shipping

1:13:22and the state of the art from Apple was Mac OS 9.

1:13:26And if you showed a Mac user of 1998

1:13:30who was well versed in Apple's aesthetics and taste and the way the Mac worked.

1:13:36If you showed them a 2009 iPhone and a 2009 Palm pre and asked them which one was the Apple phone.

1:13:47I think an awful lot of people if not a majority would have guessed the pre that the yeah,

1:13:52the pre was more aligned to the ideals

1:13:59and priorities of Apple in the classic Mac OS era than the iPhone.

1:14:05Yeah. Well to be clear there were a lot of Apple people working at Palm, not just John Rubenstein,

1:14:09but so many engineers and so on that there was actually a fight between Steve Jobs and Ed Colligan

1:14:15over recruiting. Steve emailed Ed and was like you got to stop taking our people

1:14:20and Ed wrote the email back that was like very clearly written to be found by lawyers

1:14:25in two years or whatever saying as you know,

1:14:27we can't make these kinds of deals and blah blah blah blah blah and you also poach from us.

1:14:31So there was a lot of Apple DNA inside Palm at the time.

1:14:37Yeah, I know that and designers too and and just down to the details of what like the icons look like

1:14:43in the style of the icons and the fact that they were all very consistent with each other

1:14:48and looked like they were all part of the same family was much more like classic Mac OS

1:14:54than the iPhone in the early days where the iPhone yeah,

1:15:01it obviously has worked out very well for Apple

1:15:04and the iPhone clearly evolved into becoming more of an independent fully independent

1:15:11for the most part computing system,

1:15:13but the original conception of the iPhone in the early years 2007 2008

1:15:192009 was far less about having a computer a personal computer system in your pocket

1:15:27and it was much more of a like an appliance

1:15:31and I don't mean that to denigrate it.

1:15:33Obviously I liked it.

1:15:35I was my phone. I was very happy with it.

1:15:37But even something as simple as the fact that it took like I think it was three years to get copy

1:15:43and paste because they're they just it wasn't that they didn't think of it.

1:15:46I mean, I've talked to people who were on the team at the time

1:15:49and they were like, yeah, of course, we knew it needed copy and paste but you know,

1:15:52it was low on lower on our list of priorities than X Y and Z which they did first

1:16:00whereas the pre-launched with all sorts of stuff like that multitasking notifications,

1:16:07right and the multi multitasking interface.

1:16:10Well, what would it look like it looked like cards that you shuffle through

1:16:14and they're in order which is something that you know,

1:16:17the way you multitask right now

1:16:20and whether it was left to right or up and down or something like that.

1:16:23It's well, so actually with with web OS people don't remember this

1:16:26and this was something that if they had survived would have to have changed.

1:16:29I think it was a spatial so it was like Windows on your computer.

1:16:33If you launched the web browser and then launched the email app.

1:16:37Those were running applications in theory that were next to each other

1:16:40and you can move the cards around on your little deck in a spatial way.

1:16:45So whereas everything today is just reverse chronological.

1:16:48Your cards are just listed over right to left or whatever.

1:16:50But it wasn't it wasn't it was like actually like yeah,

1:16:53the new app could be on the right side or left side or in the middle or wherever.

1:16:56It was very weird.

1:16:57Yeah, the way things work now is most recently used second most recently used third most recently used.

1:17:03It's all about how recently you used it as opposed to the actual spatial metaphor.

1:17:07Yeah, it was the notifications would be very familiar to users of modern phones.

1:17:16They except they came up at the bottom instead of the top,

1:17:19but they very cleverly and to me in an Apple like way would push the content up.

1:17:27So instead of covering content if the notification was I don't know what maybe they were 32 pixels high.

1:17:34It made the window shrink by 32 pixels to make room for it.

1:17:39Right?

1:17:39And yeah, and it was a very modern notification system by today's standards in at a time

1:17:46when the iPhone didn't have notifications at all.

1:17:50Yeah that more than more than anything else.

1:17:52It was a notification system that really sold me on this thing that maybe oh,

1:17:55wow, they have thought through what it's like to use a smartphone.

1:17:59There was also like the Synergy idea which was everything sinking over the air

1:18:05and they had the benefit of being able to put stuff into a single client like a single messaging client

1:18:09or a single contacts app stuff that we take for granted today.

1:18:12And they also had over-the-air updates which I believe took a little while for the iPhone to actually get you still had to plug it into iTunes.

1:18:19Yeah to get your yeah,

1:18:21OS updates, but the thing about maybe not notifications,

1:18:24but the thing about a lot of this stuff is remember that like they didn't have a desktop OS.

1:18:29This was like their last shot.

1:18:32And so a lot of these things that seem like Innovations now were born out of the fact that they didn't have any other choice.

1:18:38It was either like create a desktop app and make you install that and like sink and blah blah blah blah blah.

1:18:44It turns into this really weird hassle or they're building it from scratch.

1:18:49They might as well make it over the air completely because it's just it's simpler for them.

1:18:54And it's a selling point they can move ahead and it's not like they had really any other choice.

1:18:59So a lot of the stuff that they did including the fact that they based it on web technologies.

1:19:04There was a big internal debate whether to make something native code or based on web technologies.

1:19:10And at the end of the day a lot of it was like we need to get this thing out the door

1:19:13and we need to get developers to make stuff for this thing fast.

1:19:16So let's go with this a lot of those choices were smart and interesting and clever,

1:19:21but also born out of necessity.

1:19:24But also really hurt them in terms of performance because yes web rendering even today.

1:19:30It's always been it is computationally expensive because no matter how fast our devices

1:19:36and computers get web developers continually press the the limits of it.

1:19:43And even when they had the control of the whole thing

1:19:46because obviously they were writing their own apps rendering stuff on mobile processors circa 2009.

1:19:53Was expensive and so it was like it's one of those things where in hindsight they probably

1:20:00because they were late if they had shipped the palm pre even a year earlier two years earlier,

1:20:05if they had been coincident with the iPhone it could have been different.

1:20:08But yep, it was too late and it was damned if they do damned if they don't

1:20:13so they could ship sooner by building on a web stack,

1:20:16but then their performance would suffer and or they could have gone native like the iPhone did

1:20:22but they would have had to build out an entire native OS user environment.

1:20:27Yeah, well it would have slowed down adoption from developers.

1:20:30They actually did a really good job with developers early on but even even so it was slow,

1:20:34but it wasn't that much worse than what you got on an Android phone

1:20:38or even the iPhone a little bit at the time.

1:20:40And and so like the thing to remember back then is the only thing that mattered to the rest of the phone industry

1:20:48that wasn't AT&T was can we find an iPhone killer like that that phrase iPhone killer

1:20:54haunted the entire tech industry outside of Apple for years

1:20:59because the thing was exclusive to singular and Verizon especially Verizon needed something

1:21:06and they took a shot on Blackberry.

1:21:09They made this phone called the storm which was utter fiasco

1:21:13and like the whole screen was a push button.

1:21:15It was a terrible joke.

1:21:16So that that flopped and so then Verizon like okay.

1:21:19Well, let's try again.

1:21:20We got to find our iPhone killer and they played off palm

1:21:25who was put together a huge glut of inventory to sell through to Verizon for the pre-plus

1:21:31where the processor was a little bit faster and the OS had been updated.

1:21:34So it wasn't quite so dog slow and it was going to be the thing

1:21:38but unbeknownst to them Google had teamed up with Motorola to make the droid

1:21:43like a flagship device and at the 11th hour Verizon tapped Motorola

1:21:48and the droid became the thing that basically made Android succeed

1:21:52but also became like the iPhone killer and palm was stuck with yet again a bunch of phones

1:21:57that they couldn't sell and they weren't doing that well financially in the first place

1:22:01and that was the thing that ultimately put them under it persisted for a while longer.

1:22:07They sold HP blah blah blah blah blah blah,

1:22:09blah blah blah blah, but that moment right there is to me like the final thing

1:22:15where palm just could not recover from it and it's and it's

1:22:18well, it's another similarity to to Apple of the 90s right

1:22:22where inventory was a huge problem for Apple in throughout the 90s

1:22:27and a big part of how they got into such dire financial straits

1:22:31and everybody thinks it was purely about market share

1:22:33but the inventory thing was killer and long story short.

1:22:35What Apple had was a bunch of sales people who whose jobs were measured by how much stuff.

1:22:42They put into the quote-unquote Channel and at the end of quarters,

1:22:46they would just dump all this Mac hardware into the channel

1:22:49and there might be new products coming in the next quarter yet.

1:22:53They had all these old ones that were already out there

1:22:55and it that sort of thing like building out it sounds so simple.

1:22:59Like why would you do that?

1:23:01But that's that's where by today's standards.

1:23:04They were even Apple at that time was a very small company palm was even smaller

1:23:08and having Channel inventory like that.

1:23:11It was financial death.

1:23:14Yeah, and in theory again at the time we didn't know how many players are being the smartphone market.

1:23:18If you if you could get by with a few percent market share just keep making phones

1:23:23and it would have been fine.

1:23:23They could have maybe persisted longer, but they they were stuck in a money pit.

1:23:27Actually. I told the story at our 10-year party,

1:23:30but I'll just repeat it here.

1:23:31So the droid being the thing that killed palm is hilarious

1:23:36because the droids product manager was Rick Ostril.

1:23:38Low who got his start making the mp3 sounds good module for the handspring visor

1:23:46and then they pivoted to push email.

1:23:49They got bought by Motorola.

1:23:50He convinced Motorola to make the droid they made the droid the droid killed palm

1:23:55and now he is he runs the pixel team,

1:23:59right? Yep. That's right Google.

1:24:00I remember going to when the droid launched and going to New York for something

1:24:08and I always take the train from Philly

1:24:10and it was like I still to this day don't think I've ever seen an ad campaign.

1:24:15So saturated the way that yeah midtown midtown Manhattan

1:24:20and all of Penn Station.

1:24:21There was nothing but droid droid droid droid.

1:24:25It was like it was almost like something out of minority report

1:24:29and there was a glitch in the system that everywhere no matter

1:24:32where I turn my head.

1:24:33I was being bombarded with a message from Verizon

1:24:36and Motorola that the droid is here.

1:24:38Well, and man that ad campaign was also so cynical the amount of money

1:24:44that pumped into it.

1:24:45The phone was very good.

1:24:46It was it was a good phone.

1:24:47Don't get me wrong.

1:24:48It had turn-by-turn directions,

1:24:49which was a first for phones at the time.

1:24:51It had a really cool industrial design

1:24:53but the cynicism of like they specifically gendered it as like

1:24:58the manly dude phone the like cool Brawley just great phone

1:25:03that was for guys and everybody who doesn't use a droid is a feat

1:25:08or whatever.

1:25:08It was just an incredibly offensive campaign

1:25:10but just cynical because like they knew

1:25:13where they were going to get their first bump of users

1:25:15and they were just unapologetic

1:25:17and making a super cynical offensive campaign to go get those people

1:25:20because they had to if Rison didn't have something that they could say.

1:25:23Well, we've got this they were they were looking at a world of hurt.

1:25:26So they just they threw everything at it.

1:25:29It is funny and it was a very masculine brand undeniably

1:25:34and in it played poorly at the time of 2009

1:25:39or 2010 whenever it was but in hindsight,

1:25:42it feels 11 years later here in 2021 it the idea of a masculine branded flagship

1:25:49phone campaign feel it feels like it might as well be as old

1:25:55as those advertisements where a doctor family doctor was telling you

1:25:59that you should smoke camels because they soothe your throat.

1:26:02Yeah.

1:26:04Yeah, I smoke camels and you should too says family doctor whatever his name is.

1:26:09That's what it feels like.

1:26:10It's my God.

1:26:11What a ridiculous ad campaign.

1:26:13Yeah, but it was a good product.

1:26:15It was like the first actually truly good Android phone apologies to HTC

1:26:19for the the G1 and the the dream and whatever the other ones out there were

1:26:23but it was it was like the phone where Android was ready for mass market

1:26:28and had a differentiating feature that nobody else had

1:26:31and that's that's what made that thing a success.

1:26:33Yeah famously.

1:26:34Well, not famously in our circle Android was originally conceived

1:26:39as a sort of blackberry ish operating system where you would have a keyboard

1:26:43and there are a couple of prototypes have leaked leaked over the years

1:26:46and like with the HTC G1 which was the first one it clearly

1:26:50it was like having three little kids on their shoulders in a trench coat.

1:26:54It was it was a blackberry style OS dressed up as an iPhone style OS

1:27:01and it was very clear and it around the time of the droid is when Android finally started feeling.

1:27:07Okay.

1:27:07Yeah, this is actually the way you're this is what the system is designed to handle now.

1:27:12Yeah, but it still had a five-way D-pad on the keyboard underneath on the droid

1:27:16but before that a bunch of other phones had track balls

1:27:19because blackberry had had a lot of success with its trackball.

1:27:21So they figured yeah, I guess that's what phones need is a glowing white trackball

1:27:26in the middle of the bottom of the phone.

1:27:27So they would include those on them too.

1:27:29I seem to recall that some of the early phones you actually had to use the trackball

1:27:33to move the cursor while you were editing text like there was no touch interface for that.

1:27:38You had to either either you had to or at least you wanted to

1:27:42because the touchscreen was so not good for moving the insertion point.

1:27:47Yeah, that feels right.

1:27:48And it that that's one of those things where I'm pretty sure Apple had a patent

1:27:52on the magnifying glass for text selection.

1:27:54I don't know man the way text selection works on modern iOS.

1:27:57I just like why did you had such a great idea there?

1:27:59Like why did you let it go?

1:28:02I miss it.

1:28:02I miss I miss text selection.

1:28:04It's weird because it's you know,

1:28:05you can drag stuff around and copy and paste is a little bit nicer or whatever,

1:28:07but I would say it's I've got a 50% hit rate on text selection doing what I wanted to

1:28:14although part of this is on me because the way it works on Android versus iPhone is just

1:28:19different enough where I catch myself using the wrong method on either phone.

1:28:24So I don't think anybody's licked it yet.

1:28:28I without betraying any confidences.

1:28:32I know somebody who at some point within that last handful of years ran into Scott

1:28:37for stall somewhere and you know,

1:28:39they're just shooting the shit and it came up like one of the things that came up was.

1:28:44Yeah, we never got text selection right and somehow even in the years since forced all was

1:28:49forced out of Apple that they still haven't gotten it right like it and it's one of those things

1:28:54that again if you'd gone back and told me this in 1998 as a Mac user that 20 20 23 years from

1:29:00now Apple is going to be the most profitable cell phone maker in the world with something broadly

1:29:08akin to a Macintosh in your pocket with a touchscreen.

1:29:13I would have thought well and that everybody else uses phones like this too in the way that Windows is

1:29:17like the Mac and it's all with the touchscreen and I would have said well,

1:29:21I'll bet Apple's version has the best text selection.

1:29:26Because it's the sort of thing that in that time Apple always would get right

1:29:30they and they wouldn't ship without getting it right and somehow some of those details like that.

1:29:35It just they're just not high there Apple has Apple today has different priorities

1:29:41and it's it is more of a simplistic appliance.

1:29:44It still is to this day more of a simplistic appliance like attitude

1:29:47but that's one of those things to where again,

1:29:51I don't want to go off on a whole side tangent about using iPad for work.

1:29:54But like when I do spend more time than I should productivity wise

1:29:59trying to write or do something on iPad when I go back to my Mac,

1:30:04it really is that ice ice water and hell feeling of oh my God.

1:30:07It's so easy to select text precisely.

1:30:09I don't know maybe in 20 years.

1:30:11We'll think of having good text selection as being quaint

1:30:14as an unnecessary because we're all just communicating via short videos or something.

1:30:19It's no guarantee that there is an answer

1:30:21for good text selection with your finger on a capacitive touch screen.

1:30:24It's possible.

1:30:25It might just might not exist right.

1:30:27It is possible that that's why we don't have it.

1:30:29I don't know but we certainly don't have it yet.

1:30:32And I also think though that Apple has taken regression.

1:30:34So they've gone back to the magnifying glass,

1:30:36but I think it was last year.

1:30:38I was 14 they got rid of the magnifying glass and I thought that was crazy.

1:30:43It was like you guys had this great thing they even and like you said they even sued

1:30:47other companies over patents for it and then they got rid of it.

1:30:50I guess the thinking was hey,

1:30:53we've gotten so good at just using your finger.

1:30:56We don't need the magnifying glass anymore.

1:30:58That's a that's a kludge and it was like a rare case of Apple convincing themselves

1:31:05of something that wasn't true.

1:31:06Like the fundamental truth is that when you're using your finger

1:31:09and you're covering the thing.

1:31:11You can't do I do think there's no reliable way to do it without something

1:31:18to show you what you're selecting under your finger because your finger covers it covers it.

1:31:23It's it's so obvious like they even explained this in 2007 like on stage with the original iPhone.

1:31:29Well your finger covers what you're looking at.

1:31:31So here we have a magnifying glass above your finger.

1:31:34I did get used to dragging my finger along the keyboard to move the cursor around

1:31:38and I think that's a primary way.

1:31:40I move the cursor around at least on short text now.

1:31:42Yeah.

1:31:43Yeah for anybody who doesn't know this this is whenever I mentioned it.

1:31:46There's always somebody who doesn't know about this.

1:31:48But when you're editing text on the iPhone if you press and hold on the space bar on the virtual keyboard,

1:31:54it turns the keyboard into a trackpad and you can precisely move the thing around.

1:32:00I just saw it.

1:32:01I think it was nine to five Mac.

1:32:02Somebody had a column today about how they missed 3D touch and I want to link to it because I do too.

1:32:08It all of this has gotten worse since they've gotten rid of 3D touch

1:32:12because when they had 3D touch in the screen,

1:32:15I know that there's like tricks you can do with by adding a second finger to like select text and stuff.

1:32:20But like the closest we got to good text selection on an iPhone was when they had 3D touch

1:32:25because you could press and hold anywhere on the keyboard to turn it into the trackpad.

1:32:30Not just the space bar and then as you move the insertion point around you could just press harder

1:32:36and begin a text selection like using a trackpad you could click.

1:32:40I get it.

1:32:41I'm the commotion on this one.

1:32:42I don't think that juice is ever worth the squeeze on 3D touch.

1:32:45I'm sorry, like it is on a trackpad on a Mac.

1:32:47There's there's stuff there.

1:32:48Although I bring that dictionary up so often it drives me nuts,

1:32:51but I just don't think they ever got enough value out of it relative to a long press to make it worth it.

1:32:57And I don't know whatever whatever money they're saving on it, whatever Z thickness we get back from it.

1:33:03I I just think it was it they they talked themselves into like there's there's a lot of like interaction potential here.

1:33:09We can do a lot of new stuff with it and they came up with a few things,

1:33:12but I don't think enough people used it and I'm I'm the one who says it's fine to let it go me and Apple.

1:33:18We're the only two that don't miss it.

1:33:20I well, I guess I could be convinced that they made the right trade-offs,

1:33:24but it doesn't mean I still don't miss it.

1:33:26Sure, right.

1:33:27That's right that maybe they're like you said Z thickness and cost and whatever else.

1:33:33Maybe the trade-off was right,

1:33:35but I still miss it because I and I still wish that somehow when and specifically and only in the context of text selection.

1:33:44And I guess maybe that's and again,

1:33:46it's obviously never been a very high priority for Apple.

1:33:48They didn't have copy and paste for three years.

1:33:51It's it's never been about being a great text editing environment.

1:33:57Yeah, well, I think that for for Apple it's that's not what it's for for for a while and I don't know with iMessage

1:34:03and with texting or they've done a better job,

1:34:06but I don't think that if you are if you're looking to enter a bunch of text you're looking to write a novel.

1:34:11You're going to want a physical QWERTY keyboard.

1:34:13Yeah, that's just how it goes.

1:34:14Yeah, so wrapping things up.

1:34:17Do you think that I do think to rewind an hour?

1:34:22I do think fundamentally palm was probably doomed even if they'd come out earlier.

1:34:25I think these two platform things probably are inevitable.

1:34:30I don't know.

1:34:31It's hard to say but there's if there was an alternate world where palm could have become maybe what the Macintosh was

1:34:40and still is to the PC Market like a solid five percent of devoted users

1:34:46and enough to to be a thriving business boy the world would be a better place.

1:34:50That is the best I think they could have hoped for the answer.

1:34:54Does it have to be duopoly as well?

1:34:55Let's find a counterfactual in terms of like consumer platforms

1:34:58and I guess you could argue that we got to a point where Chrome OS

1:35:02and a little bit of Linux have carved out of space next to Mac

1:35:07and Windows and throw some iPad there on the side,

1:35:09but it's a stretch and I think that the the real thing just like Verizon picking the Droid is what you know,

1:35:15ultimately put the nail in the coffin for palm like the market forces here are such that

1:35:22unless you're a small company can have some sort of leverage over the ecosystem over carriers in particular,

1:35:31even with Apple breaking that dominance a little bit unless they could have found a way to have enough leverage to make sure carriers didn't screw with them or ignore them.

1:35:41They were doomed and that's that's just Google got big enough

1:35:44and Apple got big enough where they could keep AT&T from screwing it up.

1:35:49I and I think that's that's good.

1:35:51I maybe the best analogy and I'll bet there's a bunch of listeners in their heads who are like screaming this game consoles,

1:35:57right? We're sure we've got three.

1:36:00We've got two big ones the Xbox and PlayStation and Nintendo has succeeded

1:36:07and especially with the switch I which I think is their biggest hit ever or certainly.

1:36:12I don't know if it's I wonder which is bigger.

1:36:15It's possible that if you take all the the DS's and put them together that maybe it's still bigger than the switch.

1:36:20I would have to look it up but it's huge.

1:36:22It's a solid third place and they have and and it's probably the role that in the best case scenario where palm had made it.

1:36:32They'd be like to the phone platforms with the switch is to PlayStation and Xbox third place,

1:36:38but with the most devoted fans. Yeah, but look like LG just bombed out of the smartphone business this year

1:36:47if and they just made Android phones, right? They weren't great,

1:36:49but they were passable and there's still space at the low end to make decent phones for sub 500 bucks.

1:36:54That's basically all Motorola really does now,

1:36:57but if LG can't make it in the smartphone market,

1:37:00what would chance would a company that has its completely other right OS platform have in 2022?

1:37:07I just don't see it. Yeah, I don't I think it's doubtful.

1:37:10Well, thank you for being here. Happy New Year.

1:37:13Yeah, you too. It'll be better. Yeah,

1:37:15and and I told everybody two weeks ago to watch springboard.

1:37:18You can watch it's free on YouTube,

1:37:20right? I'll put a link in the show notes to the general magic movie,

1:37:23which was about general magic,

1:37:24which is worth watching too,

1:37:26but springboard you should watch first if you haven't watched it already and shame on you who haven't watched it

1:37:31because I told you two weeks ago to watch it before the show.

1:37:35It's really good and it's it is a fast 30 minutes.

1:37:38It is so good. Also, I love oh,

1:37:40I gotta mention this. I love that you used the actual bitmap palm font for the springboard.

1:37:50Oh my God. I would have I would have I would have been so mad at myself if I didn't bring this up.

1:37:54And that's the other thing that to me was always very Apple like about the palm OS was it had beautiful bitmap fonts.

1:38:02Oh, they were they were just terrific that the small text editing font the bold one that you've got the title for springboard in just beautiful pixel fonts.

1:38:13Hey man, brought my Tony and what do you got? What do you got 160 by 160?

1:38:16Yeah, nothing to do but get it right and they got it right.

1:38:18Well Microsoft had small screens like that too,

1:38:21and they still ship crap.

1:38:22But it's an art form and palm had it right.

1:38:27They were beautiful and I love that that's what you use for the title the title card of the movie.

1:38:32It's it's so sets the mood at least for me.

1:38:35It's oh, yeah, this is going to be good.

1:38:37Yeah. Well, I can't take credit for that.

1:38:38I gotta give credit to all the other designers on the verge video team.

1:38:42They're the ones who really made this thing good.

1:38:44Yeah, and in addition to being entertaining it is a good-looking movie.

1:38:47It really is.

1:38:47Yeah, you guys and we didn't even talk about the the Steve Jobs meeting.

1:38:51That's sort of the middle of it.

1:38:52No, you'll have to go watch it.

1:38:53You'll see I don't want to spoil it.

1:38:54I don't want to spoil it, but it's it is it's a good story.

1:38:57Anyway, Dieter, it's always good to have you here.

1:38:59Have a good New Year.

1:39:00Have a good that remote CES and talk to you.

1:39:03Talk to you sometime soon.

1:39:04I'm going to take it easy.