Podcast Search

The Talk Show

333: ‘Schrödinger’s Feature’, With Rene Ritchie

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I guess it's a tradition. I don't know how many years now we've been doing the year in review

0:00:04together. Apple.

0:00:05forever. It's just been forever.

0:00:06Forever. Forever. It feels everything feels like forever now. Right? It's like we're at the end of

0:00:11COVID season two.

0:00:12Yeah, 2020 Junior or is it 2020 resurrected? I forget what I went with.

0:00:17There's a very strong sense of deja vu with everything going to hell.

0:00:21Yeah. And I'm just hoping that CSS is big announcement isn't the Omega variant. If

0:00:27they decide not to unveil that I'll be very happy this year.

0:00:30It's just speaking with Dieter Bone and I was like, you guys aren't going are you? And he's

0:00:35like, Oh, no, we canceled first. Like they were like, but like, they didn't announce it early,

0:00:41because they wanted to, you know, tell all their partners and stuff. But you know, they saw this

0:00:45coming a while ago. But it is kind of sad because I feel like six months ago, CES was looking like,

0:00:52hey, this, you know, this all might work out. I don't blame them for trying. I wouldn't want

0:00:57to be the one to pull the trigger and tell everybody to cancel. But boy, they should,

0:01:02it feels like they should cancel.

0:01:03If you just want to sit in your room at Aria and eat steak for a week, you can get the best deal.

0:01:10I do. I just, you know, and I am not a particularly COVID phobic person at this point,

0:01:22fully vaxxed, my family vaxxed, everybody boosted. But you don't have to be particularly

0:01:29worried or fearful of it to put your finger in the air, see which way the wind is blowing and say,

0:01:36hey, maybe we should not have a major conference with people from all over the world.

0:01:41**Matt Stauffer** Yeah, and it's not just that. I mean, like, we did not get our booster shot

0:01:45shit together at all. So we're locked down again, which is what it is. But there's just so many

0:01:50people who are out and so many resources that are stretched thin, that there's no buffer for anything.

0:01:55Like there's just nothing else that can go wrong for any of these events and their emergency staff.

0:01:59And like having that many people there, it's gonna go wrong. So it just seems smart to

0:02:03err on the side of caution.

0:02:05**Robert Stauffer** Yeah, I don't want to do a whole COVID segment here. But I feel very strongly

0:02:09that counting cases is no longer the way to go. It's a it's a it's an interesting number. It should

0:02:14be one of the statistics, but people are so much more willing to get tested and testing. Yes, even

0:02:21though home test kits are extremely I don't know about up there, but here there it's you can't get

0:02:26them, which sucks. And it's a huge own goal, you know, that we sort of put all of our all of our

0:02:35chips on vaccines, you know, the testing should have been up there. But home tests don't count

0:02:41towards the test numbers anyway, right? Like so in other words, when local governments or whatever

0:02:46governments report, you know, case numbers that doesn't include home tests anyway. But cases isn't

0:02:52what to test or isn't what to look at. It's hospitalizations and deaths, of course. And you

0:02:58look at the hospitals and around here, it is really getting worrisomely full. And there's other places

0:03:03where it's stuffed to the gills. And to me, that's that's, you know, I mean, it's just common sense.

0:03:07If the hospitals are full, we don't have room for more people to get sick. So take it. And

0:03:13any kind of sick. That's the thing. It's like, right. It's like, don't go out and get hit by

0:03:15a car either. Because like, it's gonna be real hard to get a bed. Right. Again, I don't want to

0:03:18do a whole COVID segment. But it's super, super frustrating for people who are vaccinated and have

0:03:23done everything right. And have some other any other kind of illness or accident, you know, you

0:03:29slip and fall and need emergency room care for your ankle or something like that. And the whole

0:03:35goddamn place is full of people who are unvaccinated full of COVID.

0:03:39Jared Polin And to tie it in, like, I just watched Apple Store closings,

0:03:42if the Apple Store, my area closes, I stay home. That's what I do.

0:03:45Dave Tilley I think it was Josh centers from tidbits, who pegged this, you know, year ago,

0:03:50you know, sometime at 20 in that great blur of 2020, that Apple Store closings were a reasonable

0:03:56metric for what's going on, because Apple is, you know, I don't know if you've heard this, but,

0:04:01you know, they're a very successful company at making money. And they're logistically apt.

0:04:07Right. Right. So Apple Store closures have been a pretty good barometer for what's going on,

0:04:13because they want to have the stores open, because they want to make money. They want to make money,

0:04:19and they want to sell things to people. But they're also, I think, you know, and I know that

0:04:24there's a lot of complaints about the overall retail employment satisfaction in Apple retail,

0:04:33but overall, they're, I think they've done a pretty good job at not trying to keep stores open

0:04:38when they shouldn't be open for COVID throughout this whole thing. And yeah, there's an awful lot

0:04:43of store closures. So good luck to everybody. Stay safe. Have your New Year's inside alone.

0:04:49Jared Polin Listening to the show.

0:04:50Dave Tilley Yeah, listening to the show.

0:04:52What could be better for New Year's Eve? Anyway, what we do every year, Renee and I, we go through

0:04:58the year, look back at the Apple year in review. So let's get started. Right?

0:05:03Jared Polin Yeah, yeah, absolutely.

0:05:05Dave Tilley January, here's what we've got. John Ternus

0:05:08became senior vice president of hardware. Dan Riccio took over VR and AR, I guess hardware,

0:05:16right? Because Mike Rockwell, of course, still leads the software effort there.

0:05:20John Ternus Yeah, I think Apple has a sort of policy where every

0:05:23major product has to have a senior vice president level owner, like, you know, like Jeff Williams

0:05:28famously owns the Apple Watch, even though Kevin Lynch makes the software and there's hardware

0:05:33leads and all those, but there has to be someone on the executive team that owns it. And it was Dan

0:05:40Riccio was one of the owners, like he owns a ton of stuff, because just he's good at it. And he ships

0:05:44iPhones every year on the year, which is one of the biggest achievements in consumer electronics.

0:05:49But they wanted him to focus on this. So John Ternus, who's also terrific, and has been taken

0:05:53over the iPhone, and he's been announcing, you've seen him on stage now for the iPad Pro for the M1

0:05:58Max, he's now doing the big hardware job. And Dan is focusing on VR, which to me is just one of those

0:06:05signposts on the way to it becoming a real product. Dave Tilley

0:06:08Yeah, it seems well, it seems like to clarify what you just said, which I agree with, but it seems

0:06:13like what Apple really does is for new products, they put somebody in charge of. So Ternus is in

0:06:21charge of quote unquote, hardware, but that more or less means like existing hardware platforms that

0:06:27have sort of stabilized, right? You know, Mac, iPad, iPhone, those sort of things. And, you know,

0:06:36in the same way that when watch was a new initiative, Jeff Williams was in charge of it.

0:06:41And now it, Riccio is in charge. Do we know that, though? I mean, that he's in charge of AR/VR? Did

0:06:48they say that? I don't think Apple said that. I think that's just been widely reported, because

0:06:52he didn't leave Apple. It's sort of like when, when they, like, John G and Andrea now, he's taken

0:06:59over Titan, you know, it was previously Mansfield had come back for it famously. And those are just

0:07:04sort of the comings and goings that people, people read the criminology behind that.

0:07:08Right. But it's any in as far as we know, and you know, German is our, our, our people into

0:07:15Apple's internal structures. Riccio has not gone to project Titan. And therefore, it's sort of like,

0:07:22whatever's left must be it. And we know that's AR/VR efforts.

0:07:27Yeah, yeah. And it's it does feel like we're getting we're getting closer to that this year.

0:07:31Like when you look at competing products, they're more, they're more reaching that part where Apple

0:07:36doesn't really like the early adopter phase. They were like, when they start just becoming bridging

0:07:41over to mainstream adoption. And that seems when you look at what's selling over this year,

0:07:45especially things like Facebook's quest to how popular those things are becoming that it's,

0:07:50it's getting to the point where Apple usually enters a market.

0:07:53Yeah, I saw today, which I know is not 11 months ago, but today, somebody, you know,

0:07:59I think it was CNBC said that the number one app in Apple's App Store the day after Christmas was

0:08:06the Oculus app, you know, implying that enough people got with what's now called the quest to

0:08:13right? Yeah, is that right? The quest to is what used to be called the Oculus enough people got it

0:08:19for Christmas that downloads of the iOS app to whatever with it promoted the app to number one,

0:08:26I don't think it's a big number, though. It is just something to be said for the fact that it is

0:08:31the end of 2021. And you still cannot go into a store and find a PlayStation five, or a GPU or an

0:08:36Xbox Series X. And Facebook is just flooding the market with, I think, pretty much at cost quest.

0:08:41So it's a huge distortion field. But but people are starting to look at them as like mainstream

0:08:45products. Jonas got a PS five for Christmas, and he's been very, very happy with it ever since he's

0:08:53up there playing it now. But my wife took care of procuring it. She's much better at such things

0:08:59than me because, well, she's she really is good at finding things that are hard to get. And she's

0:09:05not a procrastinator like me. But I asked her, I was like, how did you you know what you have to

0:09:09pay? How'd you get this? She's like, don't ask. Yes. I was like, all right, fine. You have to

0:09:14either invest a lot of money or a lot of time into getting PlayStation five at this point. Still,

0:09:18same with a GPU. Have you seen one? Have you played with a PS five? I have not. I have not.

0:09:24I've seen the Xbox. And I've managed to get I managed to get a GPU and actually get one of the

0:09:28new Nvidia cards by buying a whole entire pre built computer. The only way I could get one

0:09:33without paying exorbitant prices for it. Yeah, Jonas and I have been talking about that and

0:09:37looking at it. And yeah, he said the same thing that you got it, you kind of got to get a whole

0:09:41computer. And yes, might be worth it. Then the neatest thing I am not a gamer. It's, it's I

0:09:48don't anticipate really playing PS five much, but I am fascinated by it. I like I like the design.

0:09:54It is a sort of a big box. But the thing that fascinates me are the controllers. They're

0:10:00effectively they're standalone devices. And with, you know, they're standalone computers, right?

0:10:06It is sort of it, the overall arc of everything has been going towards everything is becoming

0:10:12its own computer, right? And in the same way that like your AirPods are each standalone computers.

0:10:19Yeah, the maybe this was true for the PS four controllers to some degree. I don't think so,

0:10:24though. But there's like, they have they clearly have their own accelerometers.

0:10:28Yeah. And the very neatest thing that they do is the trigger buttons have a lot of pull,

0:10:35there's a lot of distance that you can pull them in. And when they're connected, the software can

0:10:42give them dynamic resistance. So like you can press them and it's like pressing a gas pedal

0:10:49where you get more resistance, the more you press, or it could be something like at a certain point,

0:10:56you get some resistance. And then when you push past it, it's like a burst, you know, you feel

0:11:01like this tremendous haptic feedback. It's long story short, it is the most interesting haptic

0:11:08device I have ever, ever experienced. It is interesting, because like when when Apple

0:11:13announced 3d touch, Nintendo announced the those demos where they were showing the wiimotes. Maybe

0:11:19it wasn't the wiimotes. Maybe it was already the switch controllers, pouring like making it feel

0:11:23like you're pouring ice into a glass. And there was this whole optimism around tactile interfaces

0:11:28that sort of just disappeared until somebody started demonstrating these controllers. Yeah.

0:11:33Yeah. Jonas has the new Spider Man game and said it's awesome for the web shooters because it's it

0:11:38once you get used to it. He said it's really, really cool where a tiny pole is a short web

0:11:43and a long pole is long web, but you get this haptic feedback that makes it feel like you don't

0:11:49have to think about it. It feels very natural. So anyway, that's pretty cool.

0:11:54Jared: And I don't know if you saw it. And I have so many things I can say about Tim

0:11:57Epic that I won't go into right now. But that demo for the Unreal Engine five,

0:12:02oh, yeah, matrix demo they made. Yeah, that starts to make me interested in that next generation of

0:12:06gameplay.

0:12:06John Greenewald Oh, absolutely. But I also think that that demo gets to sort of my takeaway with

0:12:14Unity's purchase of Weta Digital, which is the confluence of real time graphics and scenery being

0:12:24produced by game engines, and movie special effects, which obviously take a long time. And I

0:12:32know, you know, it's not exactly the same thing in that movies are always going to press the limit.

0:12:37And because they can do things not in real time, but you could obviously do the final render and

0:12:45take, you know, however long you want to render every frame, but it's getting to the point where

0:12:50you could do, well, let's just fill this in for now, in real time and do incredibly dynamic stuff.

0:12:58It's really impressive. It's really hard.

0:13:00Jared: Famously, ILM is the volume, I think they use for The Mandalorian and other shows where it's

0:13:05all these walls full of LCDs that are run by Unreal Engine. And I think the small one,

0:13:09I forget what the small one's called, Walnut or something, where you can just do it around

0:13:11somebody's head. And that mixes real time with classical special effects. And that just needs

0:13:16to be the future.

0:13:17John Greenewald Yeah, it's really, you know, and it just think about like, you know,

0:13:21the way photography has evolved, right? Like, just, you know, in the film era, you'd take pictures,

0:13:27hope they were exposed properly, you know, just take them into a dark room and develop them and

0:13:34see what they looked like and hope they were the best. And now, you know, in the digital era,

0:13:38everybody can see their photos as you go. It's the same sort of thing with VFX and this sort of

0:13:45thing where you, you know, if you can do anything in real time, as you do it, you just get it's like

0:13:51you're, you can play with it live and say, Oh, why don't we, you know, change the focal length

0:13:55on this? Why don't we, instead of swooping the camera in, why don't we do something more subtle

0:14:00and just place the camera here, you could do all sorts of stuff as you go.

0:14:04Jared Ranere Yeah, even apples, you know, Apple, because of their silicon can do so much real time

0:14:08in the camera that nobody else can do. And now that we have basically effectively ProRes on those

0:14:13camera systems, you can fix almost any problem and cinematic mode lets you change the focal point

0:14:19while you're doing it after you're doing it. It's an unbelievable shift in technology that I think

0:14:26we don't appreciate always because it happens so step by step. We went from like portrait mode to

0:14:30cinematic mode, and it's going to get better. But it's a huge shift from what you said, like just

0:14:34doing on film. Pete Lienberg

0:14:35Yeah, yeah. And that is a good example. You know, Apple's insistence, the camera team's insistence

0:14:39that whatever they do, they do live in the viewfinder. It sort of speaks to the mentality

0:14:47of being able to render VFX live and in real time. Jared Ranere

0:14:50Yeah, or like the, what did I forget the app, I'm blanking on the app, the app they publish

0:14:54separately that lets you swap out backgrounds. It is unbelievable what you can do in that app. Now,

0:14:59you can replace whole backgrounds with interactive dynamic settings and augmented reality. And it

0:15:06looks like you're in a mini Hollywood studio. It's just beyond fantastic.

0:15:09Pete Lienberg So let's, let's move on February,

0:15:12iOS 14.5. This is my, there wasn't much in February. But this to me is, has been and

0:15:20going back to our previous statement that we're now, you know, in the midst of another COVID surge,

0:15:25worth the effort. It wasn't like, hey, little too late. Everything's coming up sunny. So it's why

0:15:31even bother shipping. But iOS 14.5 in February shipped with what has become quite literally,

0:15:38I mean this sincerely, my very favorite Apple Watch feature, which is that you can unlock

0:15:43your phone, your iPhone, while wearing an Apple Watch while you're wearing a face mask.

0:15:50Ben Lee Yeah, and it's more complicated than it appears

0:15:52because and a lot of people just said, Well, why can't you do this to begin with, but they originally

0:15:56set it up so that the iPhone unlocks the Apple Watch, because they figured entering your passcode

0:16:01on a watch would be annoying. And so making it do both is a huge security problem, because there are

0:16:07so many intrusions that could happen when you don't have this known state of one unlocks the other

0:16:11suddenly they go bi directionally. And they were smart because they made it incredibly dependent

0:16:15on very specific conditions. And they also did things like if if it unlocks, but then it moves

0:16:20far enough away, as though someone's trying to steal it, it'll just automatically relock. So

0:16:24there was a huge amount of things they had to think through. But like you, it's almost transparent to

0:16:28me at this point. It really is. And, you know, it now that we're back, I mean, for months now,

0:16:36I mean, we had like a brief, brief respite during July, you know, mid June to the

0:16:43store. So we're, you know, our Philadelphia lifted our citywide mask mandate. And it was so nice,

0:16:49especially in the hot weather. I mean, but we never lost ours. We've had ours for almost now.

0:16:53We had we had no masks for a while. And the COVID rate was ridiculously low. And it all seemed well

0:16:59advised. And now we're back to masks. And I actually went out just the other day because I

0:17:06didn't think I was going to run any errands. I was wearing one of my mechanical watches and forgot to

0:17:11put my Apple Watch on before I left to get some groceries. And I didn't need to use my phone much.

0:17:18I was listening to podcasts. So you know, you can do all of that from from the lock screen. But I

0:17:24wanted to do something. And I was like, Oh, my God, I forgot what a huge pain in the ass this was

0:17:29for like an entire year. And I mean, it is my single very favorite feature of Apple Watch.

0:17:37And it's kind of a sign. It's always a good sign for a platform, as it is such a broad

0:17:43stroke that I'm about to say, but it to me, it's always good when there's good new features for a

0:17:50platform that were never envisioned when the platform was created. Right? Like the Mac was

0:17:56not created with entirely revolutionizing the publishing and desktop publishing industries.

0:18:04But the fact that it did was a sign of the strength of the platform. Like Apple Watch was

0:18:08not created with, hey, in case there's ever a pandemic, and everybody has to wear a face mask

0:18:13whenever they're out in public indoors. It would be cool if you could use the watch as an

0:18:18authentication source to unlock the phone. Yeah, it was not envisioned. But it's

0:18:24Jared Ranere: the whole security works off having three point like it needs both eyes and the nose

0:18:28to get sufficient facial geometry to actually authenticate you it'd be like only getting the

0:18:33top part of your fingerprint, it just doesn't have enough information to securely understand that it's

0:18:37you. So now when you're attempting to face ID, it sees it can't get the other part of geometry. So

0:18:43it throws over to the watch. And if the watch is there, it verifies and comes back. So it maintains

0:18:47a good level of security while giving you back a good amount of convenience, which is always that

0:18:51huge war between the two. Overall, it still is poorly timed for the face ID era that two years

0:19:00of the face ID era have been during the COVID and the face masking, right. So we had the iPhone 10

0:19:06year, the 10 s year, the iPhone beginning of the 11 11 that was late 2019 12. So four years, about

0:19:20two of the four years have been face mask era. And it also sucks to say, Well, the answer is to buy a

0:19:26$400 digital watch, right on top of your this iPhone SE instead of an iPhone, right, you know,

0:19:33but it's, you know, it's unfortunate, and it's but it's it really has made a tremendous, tremendous

0:19:40difference in just daily hassle. It really makes it as invisible as face ID. I think Apple doesn't

0:19:46parts been there, like a lot of companies parts been their phones, like they just put it together

0:19:49over what they have at hand, and they ship it as a new model. And Apple doesn't do that every phone

0:19:53they make is two or three years of effort. So the phones that they've been putting out these last

0:19:58two years, they were completely planned before this whole like, I know rumors make it sound like

0:20:03Apple still making up their mind about everything the day before it ships, but doesn't work that way

0:20:06at all. They were committed to all of these products years ago, and we're not going to see the

0:20:11post COVID Apple for another year or so. Yeah. And you know, let's fingers crossed, knock on wood,

0:20:17it's hope that COVID really does sort of fade away. I don't think it's going to disappear. But

0:20:21let's say it fades away and becomes sort of a background part of our lives. This is a good

0:20:25feature going forward anyway, because I have at least one regular df reader who is I believe he's

0:20:32a surgeon, but he definitely works in a hospital. And he, you know, has been a thoughtful emailer

0:20:37to me over the years. And when the iPhone 10 first came out, wrote me a really nice email and said,

0:20:42"This really sucks for me because I spend an awful lot of my day with a surgical mask on and I cannot

0:20:48unlock my phone." I'm pretty sure he can wear a watch. Probably can't wear a watch while he's

0:20:52in surgery, but there's a lot of the day where he can, you know, there are a lot of medical

0:20:56professionals who even when before COVID and let's say after COVID fades into the background,

0:21:02have to wear a mask during the day and this feature will keep working.

0:21:05Yeah, well, you know, my dream is that they just get their crap together and they have enough from

0:21:10voice identification, facial geometry, touch identification, gait analysis, that they can just

0:21:15keep our phone unlocked if they're fairly certain it's us. And then only challenges. So they really,

0:21:18I'm tired of being forced to activate my own phone, John, that should be the phone's job.

0:21:22I'm too late to authenticate. I wonder too, if the Face ID team has,

0:21:27you know, over the last two years been working on just letting Face ID work while you wear a mask,

0:21:33right? Because yeah, as a, just without getting, I have no idea how Face ID actually works other

0:21:41than the very, very basics, right? Like I certainly don't understand the engineering of it at all. I'm

0:21:46sure it's quite complicated, you know, and it's been out for five years. We, everybody seems to

0:21:51still treat it as probably more secure than Touch ID. So they've done a good job. But just

0:21:59as a reasonable ballpark idea, if a human being can recognize another human being while they're

0:22:08wearing a mask, like if I can tell, "Hey, that's my wife, Amy, while she's wearing a mask." In

0:22:14theory, a computer could do it too, right? It's sweet.

0:22:17Yeah, they're all Lois Lane though. You put on a pair of glasses and suddenly they can't tell you

0:22:20Superman. So in theory, Face ID could just work on its own with a mask. It's just that the

0:22:26implementations and I think right down to the sensors, I think it's not just software, but down

0:22:31to hardware are based on seeing everything from your eyes to the mouth, you know, if not the chin

0:22:39and the shape of your chin and stuff like that. So it would take a rejiggering, but it's probably not

0:22:45at this point. I don't think it would be a wasted effort. I really don't. No, it's just, it's getting

0:22:49enough data. It's having enough points of a fingerprint. It's getting enough points of facial

0:22:53geometry that the adversarial, because the whole thing is you don't want to let people in who

0:22:57aren't you, but you don't want to stop you from getting in. And the way adversarial neural networks

0:23:02work is you basically have like a Batman network that is in charge of protecting the device. And

0:23:07you have a Joker network that's in charge of penetrating the device. And that trains the Batman

0:23:12algorithm to better and better defend it. And your face can change and it allows for a large amount

0:23:17of change and it keeps updating the data points over time. But once you start covering a large

0:23:22portion of your head, there's just not enough data. It's like having half a fingerprint. So they'd

0:23:27have to sort of figure out another way to get enough data that it'd be secure enough to keep

0:23:31people out. Otherwise the same people would be like, okay, now it's fraternal twins as well as

0:23:34identical twins that can get into it. And then it's all a problem. Right. But they did, you know,

0:23:37and then when they first announced it, they said things like, hey, sometimes you wear glasses,

0:23:40sometimes you don't, you might have a beard, you might shave your beard, you might grow a beard,

0:23:45etc. and so forth. And they anticipated those things. It'd be interesting if face masks

0:23:50are on that list. It works on Dalrymple. It should work on face masks.

0:23:52Yeah. Because I also think, again, even in the optimistic scenario where COVID fades into the

0:23:58background, one thing I think has permanently changed here in the West is the sort of stigma,

0:24:04not even sort of, the actual stigma that we have had against public face mask wearing pre-COVID.

0:24:11I think that's forever gone. I think even if in the ideal situation where COVID literally just

0:24:16fades away over the next two, three years, I think we've forever broken that stigma and that when

0:24:22cold and flu season hits, people will go out and whether it's to protect themselves or because they

0:24:29feel like they have a sniffle or something like that, that will be more like Japan and other parts

0:24:34of Asia where that's, it's just perfectly natural to see people wearing face masks, you know,

0:24:38medical face masks in public. So it's, whatever Apple can do in that regard, I don't think would

0:24:44be wasted even in the optimistic scenario where COVID fades away. Well, I mean, like everyone who

0:24:50goes to events gets sick the week afterwards. That's like a known thing. It wasn't COVID,

0:24:54but it was something. You know, knock on wood, that has never happened to me. In all the years

0:24:59I've been doing it, I never once came home from like a Macworld Expo or WWDC and caught something.

0:25:05And it's not that I never get sick or never get a cold. I don't know what it is. I don't know if it's,

0:25:11it could just be dumb luck. I don't know. But I know a lot of people that happens to a lot of

0:25:16people. I know it's almost a... Jared: Like a tradition.

0:25:19Pete: Yeah, like a tradition for some people. But I don't know, it's never happened to me. But again,

0:25:24knock on wood that, you know, won't happen in the future. All right, on to March. The HomePod was

0:25:29canceled. And boy, I'm still bummed about this. Jared; Me too.

0:25:33Pete; So, they canceled the full-size HomePod and said, "We're going to focus on the HomePod Mini."

0:25:39The HomePod Mini does seem to be selling well. I saw some sales estimates last week from somebody

0:25:44that it's, you know, among the best-selling home speaker talk to the dingus devices. And it is a

0:25:52good device. It's a good device for the price and it sounds good for the price. But it sounds

0:25:56nothing like a pair of HomePods and... Jared; Yeah, especially the base and just

0:26:00like how well they filled the room. Pete; Yeah. And curiously, you know,

0:26:05there are major significant features that only are supported on HomePod. Like, you cannot,

0:26:11you know, I have a pair of HomePods, I have more full-size HomePods than, you know, a surprising

0:26:18number of them. I think we have six. I have two in my office, two in the kitchen, and two on our TV.

0:26:24And I mean, I really like the way our TV sounds. I mean, I really, really like it.

0:26:31And, you know, I'm sure there are audio files who might have complaints. It's not, you know,

0:26:36you could certainly do a lot better. But for us and for how loud we can get it without disturbing

0:26:42other people in the house, we never get, you know, never need to go past around 70% volume

0:26:48and things sound loud, action movies sound boomy. I really love it.

0:26:53Jared; Audio file is a psychological, not a scientific diagnosis.

0:26:56Pete; Well, but I mean, I know what it's like to actually have like, I've been in rooms with

0:27:00true surround sound and stuff like that. Jared; And you can spend a million bucks

0:27:03on a sound system easily. There's no limit to what you can spend on one.

0:27:06Pete; But I really like it. But you can't do that with the iPad or HomePod minis. And even if you

0:27:11could, like, so the feature isn't even supported. And even if you could, I believe it's still not

0:27:17supported, but it's even if you could. Jared; You get stereo, you get like two

0:27:20channel stereo audio from it. Pete; Yeah, but that's, you know,

0:27:22that's not good enough. Jared; That's, yeah, you don't want that.

0:27:24Pete; So that's really weird that they have this great support for using a pair of HomePods as

0:27:30Apple TV output and have even added features that let you use them as the audio output for your TV,

0:27:38even when you're using another source, like an HDMI source. So like, you could be playing your

0:27:43Switch and use your HomePods as the TV output, which is awesome.

0:27:48Jared; Yeah.

0:27:49Pete; But you, you know, now they're canceled. You can't get them. I mean, what a weird

0:27:55failure on Apple's part. And I put in my notes that to me, it's more expensive, it's a more

0:28:02expensive product than you even think as a $350 or $399 and you, you know, while they were on sale,

0:28:08you could sometimes find them on sale for like 300 bucks. But to me, one HomePod was never the

0:28:14product. The real product has always been a pair. And that's why I have pairs of them in every room

0:28:19where I have them. And that it's sort of like a single HomePod is really a half of a set of

0:28:24HomePods. Jared; Yeah. It's like having a single speaker,

0:28:27it doesn't really, like it's fine, but it's nowhere nearly as good as having two.

0:28:30Pete; The failure of this product is so curious to me, because I really think it's a terrific

0:28:35product. And usually, for any company, but Apple in particular, because they usually don't fail

0:28:41through lack of marketing effort or advertising panache. It's usually, you know, an Apple product

0:28:49that does not succeed is because there's something, you know, it's actually not that great a product.

0:28:53Whereas this to me was a… Jared; Yeah, there is this weird middle

0:28:57ground though, where like, like with the iPod HiFi, where there are people who will spend,

0:29:01again, millions of dollars on audio equipment. But there's also people who think that any

0:29:05amount of money is too much for audio equipment. And Apple spent so long, like, I believe it was

0:29:09five years developing the HomePod way before the Amazon, you know, smart speakers and the Google

0:29:14smart speakers came on the market. And they just wanted this, they just wanted to solve this

0:29:18problem. They make all these audio products, they have iPods, they have iTunes, Apple Music,

0:29:22all these things. And most people don't have good sound in most of the rooms in their house.

0:29:26And they wanted you to literally be able to just drop a box anywhere in the room and it would sound

0:29:30great throughout the entire room, no matter where you were standing in the room. And because it

0:29:34didn't have a screen, they just thought, okay, we'll just have Siri be the control. And while

0:29:38they were getting all that together, all these smart speakers came out, and the entire market

0:29:42shifted to a commodity, mostly assistant based thing, which this wasn't, but was suddenly being

0:29:47classified and pitted against. And at that price point, it wasn't like high enough to really attract,

0:29:53you know, like Mac Pro level customer interest, and it wasn't low enough to attract like the

0:29:58iPod level interest and it kind of, I'm just surprised they canceled it so quickly, because

0:30:02usually they're happy letting like a 2013 Mac Pro stay on the market forever.

0:30:06Right. I guess that's what I'm most surprised by that they canceled it. Why not just keep

0:30:11selling it? And I guess that we don't know. But it seems like there was a story at some point

0:30:18during the year that somebody figured out that even when you were after they were canceled,

0:30:22and people were buying like the last ones available, you could do some, I don't know if

0:30:27it was serial number tracking or just copyright date on the box, but that they were all effectively

0:30:32from the initial batch that they, you know, manufactured a batch and sold them until they

0:30:38were out, but they weren't still making them maybe that they had made them all in an initial run or

0:30:44something like, you know, close to that. And when they were done selling them, they were done selling

0:30:49them. So hopefully fingers crossed, they have some sort of replacement in the works.

0:30:53Yeah. And the other weird thing about Apple audio in general, I think you pointed this out for the

0:30:57original AirPods is that Apple doesn't sell them for an exorbitant amount of margin. And,

0:31:02but people look at them and say, they don't sound the value of the price. Like they don't sound as

0:31:07good as $150 wired headphones or a $500 wired speaker, but that's because like the there's

0:31:14Apple chipsets in there. There's there are sensors in there. There's a whole bunch of computational

0:31:20stuff that you're paying for that has nothing to do with the audio really, but does inflate the

0:31:24bill of goods. So even Apple selling them at cost is still way more than if they had no smart stuff

0:31:29in them at all. Yeah. I don't know. So here's, I don't know. I don't know what they could be

0:31:33replacing them with. They don't tend to change product names. I mean, it's not like after they

0:31:38discontinued it, they were going to rename the HomePod mini HomePod and say, that's the new

0:31:44HomePod, what we used to call the HomePod mini, but it is weird. It still is weird that they have

0:31:48a HomePod mini and there's no HomePod regular. I mean, which I hope, you know, and maybe it's

0:31:54just wishful thinking means that something else is coming and that they feel like they've figured out,

0:32:00you know, I guess it's price. I don't know. You know, that if they can, can they make something

0:32:05that's HomePod quality sound and features for $200 a speaker? I don't know. Yeah. There's like,

0:32:13there's like three rumors. I think one is a HomePod 2.0. That's exactly that the other is a

0:32:17HomePod with like a screen that would do that center stage technology so that you could have

0:32:23calls on it very easily for the kitchen. And then a HomePod Apple TV hybrid that would be basically

0:32:27like a big soundbar that you could have a whole home theater set up on. And I want all of these

0:32:32things, Jon. Well, let's see. We've got a whole year ahead of us. There was a, in March still,

0:32:39there was the Intel goes long ad, which is where Intel hired a former Apple spokesperson,

0:32:47Justin Long, who was the IMA Mac to do some cringy. I think that's, I think that's being

0:32:54generous even. Yes. Yeah. And a point, my point to put this on the list isn't so much to make fun

0:33:01of the ads, but as where else to speak about the general transition from Intel to Apple Silicon.

0:33:09It almost feels like they're so bad. There had to be like an executive at Intel that was really

0:33:14angry and they were only made to make that executive feel better. That's the only way I

0:33:18can explain these ads. Yeah, I think so. Or, or as somebody said at the time when I was writing about

0:33:25them, that the target for the ad wasn't consumers. The target for those ads were OEMs who make PCs,

0:33:33you know, that it was like Intel's sort of given a little. That's the thing. So these were like

0:33:39such like just from a pure marketing point of view, these were incredibly bad ads because

0:33:43in order to compete with Apple, they basically went to hardware differentiation,

0:33:47which is Intel not only saying we're Pepsi now no longer Coke. Like they were completely seeding

0:33:53top of the market mind share to Apple, but they were also saying that they were a commodity whose

0:33:57only value came from the benefits that OEMs gave to them. And that they were basically

0:34:02interchangeable with AMD because those same companies sold the same computers with AMD

0:34:07processors as well. It was like the worst self-own I've ever seen in a, in an Intel marketing

0:34:12campaign. It has been interesting watching the sort of sentiment sink in over the year,

0:34:20right? We're a little bit over a year into the M1 era. And that before they came out,

0:34:28there was a widespread, well, there can't be that great because they're just cell phone processors.

0:34:33Yes. Right. And then they came out and everybody who actually tested it with their eyes open was

0:34:40like these blow away the state of the art in comparable laptop PCs. And watching the rest of

0:34:49the sort of PC half of the media industry sort of come to grips with this has been satisfying.

0:34:57Yeah.

0:34:58Intissidily.

0:34:59Yeah. It's like, it was like watching Android get, sort of understand that what was happening

0:35:04with Qualcomm over the last few years.

0:35:06Because one of the things I've always felt, you know, literally always, I mean, going back to the

0:35:12nineties, even when the Mac and Apple were in trouble that design wise, Mac OS was always the

0:35:18superior operating system to windows, but obviously that's subjective and a point of taste. Whereas

0:35:25the actual performance of these chips and certainly their performance per watt is objective

0:35:32and it is objectively, you know, years ahead of where the x86 platform is and likely will be.

0:35:40And so it doesn't, it's not subjective. There's no taste to be accounted for. If what you want to do

0:35:50is have a windows PC, you can't have this. And that's unprecedented in the industry.

0:35:58That's never been the case that they, you know,

0:36:01that there's been a chip platform for personal computers or workstations.

0:36:06Well, I shouldn't say never. Right. You'd have to go back to like the sun

0:36:12spark station days, right. Where if you wanted, you know, sun's performance,

0:36:16you had to buy sun hardware or a Silicon graphics or companies like that. But those were

0:36:2215, $20,000 Unix workstations in 1990 something dollars, right? It, it, it terms of the consumers,

0:36:31there's never really been anything like there's never been a situation like this.

0:36:34Jared Ranere: No, it's only analogous to smartphones where if you wanted the performance

0:36:38of Apple Silicon, you have to get the whole package. And now if you want the performance

0:36:41from Apple Silicon on laptop and desktop, you have to get the whole package again.

0:36:45All right. All right. Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor. It's our good friends at

0:36:50Linode. Oh, boy, do I love Linode. Linode is where I host Daring Fireball. I would host there,

0:36:59whether they if they called me up and said, We are never going to sponsor you again.

0:37:03Thank you. But that's it. We're done. I'm not moving Daring Fireball anywhere. I could not be

0:37:07happier. It's really great. Go to Linode.com/thetalkshow. And you can see why Linode has

0:37:14been voted the top infrastructure as a service provider by both G2 and Trust Radius. They have

0:37:20award winning support offered 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year to every level

0:37:27of user. This isn't just something you get when you get like a big money, high level account,

0:37:33you get like a one of their nano accounts for like five or $10 a month, you can still get real human

0:37:38being on support all day, any day, you want to do it on New Year's Eve, somebody's going to be there.

0:37:43And they just have such great ease of use and setup. It is clear why developers have been

0:37:48trusting Linode for projects both big and small since 2003. You can deploy your entire application

0:37:55stack with their one click app marketplace. Or if you want, you can build it all from scratch

0:38:02the old fashioned way and manage everything yourself with supported centralized tools like

0:38:07Terraform. They have the best price performance value for all compute instances, including GPUs,

0:38:13as well as block storage, Kubernetes and their upcoming bare metal release. They make cloud

0:38:19computing fast, simple and affordable. Visit linode.com slash the talk show, create a free

0:38:26account using your Google or GitHub account or just use your email address. But by visiting

0:38:32linode.com slash the talk show to start you get $100 in free credit 100 bucks. My thanks to Linode

0:38:39for hosting my site and for sponsoring the show. We got to keep going to your kept going. April

0:38:46now April is where Apple got busy. They had the spring loaded event where they announced,

0:38:52let's see air tags, they add new features for Apple podcasts. We might as well put the hardware

0:38:59in May because that's where we actually got to review it. But we could talk about

0:39:03Jared Ranere>> We got a purple iPhone.

0:39:04Pete Turner>> Yeah, we got a purple iPhone, which then disappeared, right? So it was only like

0:39:12purple was not among the colors in the fall. So it was sort of a six month thing. Air tags, I guess

0:39:19here's as fine a place as any to talk about, right? Where there's a bit of a pushback now where the

0:39:26sort of FUD is coming out that they're being used to track people and it's reasonable, right? Like,

0:39:31I don't say that with too big of a pair of dick quotes around it. It is reasonable for people to

0:39:38say, "Hey, can this be used for bad purposes?" Maliciously, yeah. My understanding, because this

0:39:45was a product that had been rumored for quite a while before it came out. And I don't think I'm

0:39:51alone in thinking this, that the product was finished before, hardware wise, before Apple

0:39:57was ready to announce it. And I think part of it was that they were still working through all of

0:40:03the, as you said before, like threat scenarios, right? Like in sort of imagining how could this

0:40:09be abused and what can we do to prevent that sort of thinking. But there's some stories now about

0:40:16people using them to track cars they intend to steal. I think there was a story last week about

0:40:23somebody who bought like a used car and then found a tracker in the wheel well, which somebody was

0:40:30speculating. I think it was Benedict Evans that maybe the idea is that the car dealers put them in

0:40:36and for whatever reason and forgot to take it out. But it seems like just a handful. It doesn't

0:40:44really seem like anything has actually gone wrong with them other than a few anecdotes,

0:40:50but it doesn't seem like there's any sort of widespread reason to be fearful of the existence

0:40:56of air tags on the market. Yeah, it's interesting because whenever Apple enters a new market,

0:41:02people suddenly find all these problems with the market. And that's because Apple attracts so much

0:41:05attention to that market. I mean, there were tiles for years. Samsung announced their tracker before

0:41:11Apple did. And none of those have anything as far as I can tell anything at all that will help you

0:41:17with stalker or tracking prevention. You know, there's just none of that. You just buy them and

0:41:21use them. But nobody notices because those products don't make a lot of noise. But Apple is always big,

0:41:26big headlines. And I think that's great. I think Apple should be subject to tons of scrutiny.

0:41:30I do wish that everyone would hold all these companies that can potentially cause as much

0:41:34harm to the same level of scrutiny, but it is what it is. And this again is nothing that people who

0:41:40are in surveillance care about at all because they've been able to get $50 real GPS trackers

0:41:46off Amazon and previously off Radio Shack in places for years. But what this does is it attracts

0:41:51a whole bunch of people who'd never thought of it before. And they're like, "Oh, I guess previously

0:41:55I would have dropped a GPS tracker or I would have thrown a cheap iPhone SE into somebody's bag or

0:42:00car and tracked them that way. But now I can get a four pack for a hundred bucks and I can just do

0:42:04it." And I wouldn't have encouraged them before. So there's a level of the worst, like the dumbest

0:42:09possible criminal element getting involved in it. But they've got all these things. Like, it's like,

0:42:14anytime I get in my car, it chirps. Like it audibly chirps every single time I get in my car.

0:42:18It's annoying, but like, I'm like, that's great because somebody else may not know there's a

0:42:22tracker in there. So I think we always have to balance that these things are tools. Tools can

0:42:28help us do wonderful things. They can also be horribly misused. How much value is there to these

0:42:33tools and what can we do to sort of mitigate the malicious intent as much as possible?

0:42:37Pete: And there's a sort of inevitability, right? Like, you know, there was, just go back to

0:42:42cameras. There was certainly, and still is, you know, I think Joanna and I talked about this on

0:42:47my show last week, that the growing number of cameras everywhere is certainly reason to be

0:42:53concerned, but not, or worried, you know, or skeptical, you know, and to think about it and

0:43:01to know where they are. But it's not like there's anything, we're not putting this genie back in the

0:43:05bottle, right? Well, there were articles about camera phones in changing rooms for a long time

0:43:10when they first came out. You know, I thought about it last week, too. I don't think I mentioned

0:43:15it with Joanna, but I thought about it with, you know, having a teenage son. There's so many things

0:43:19that me and my friends did in high school that I don't, you know, you'd have to be a—

0:43:26Jared: Nobody will ever know about unless you were there.

0:43:28Pete; No one will ever know about. And you'd have to be a complete moron to do any of them today

0:43:34because it would be caught on camera. Jared; Why are you limping away from the science lab,

0:43:39half on fire? No reason. Pete;

0:43:43You know, nothing that I think I would have gone to prison for, but, you know, things that—

0:43:47Jared; But who knows?

0:43:48Pete; Yeah, who knows? Maybe.

0:43:50Jared; Yeah, there but for the grace of God,

0:43:53John, either of us could have been the lightsaber kid.

0:43:55Pete; Have you found a good use for airpods, air tags?

0:43:59Jared; Yeah.

0:43:59Pete; I have a couple and, you know, I haven't, but it's part of the whole COVID second season

0:44:07that we just haven't, I don't go many places, you know, and so, I don't know yet. You know,

0:44:14I have one in my briefcase/laptop, over the shoulder laptop bag. We took two trips over

0:44:19the summer while things were looking up and so I had a night, you know, an air tag in my bag.

0:44:24But, you know, two vacations where it's like I took the bag to the airport, put it on a plane,

0:44:31and you know, as usual, never really left my site and then took it to a hotel and

0:44:36then took it home and that's it. And otherwise, my laptop bag hasn't left my house since March of 2020,

0:44:44you know, two times. So, I'm glad there's an air tag in there, but it hasn't really, you know.

0:44:50Jared; I think that was part of the reason that Apple didn't rush to get them out because they

0:44:54knew they were releasing them under conditions that were less than ideal to show their value.

0:44:58Pete; Right.

0:44:58Jared; Like you, I didn't use cellular data for months. I didn't, I forgot what my credit card

0:45:03pin was. And I have no idea where my gear bag was for a whole year. I had to end up actually using

0:45:09an air tag recently to find the damn thing in my own house because it was in a closet I'd forgotten

0:45:13about. Pete; Right. And it's like, I can't, you know, the things I still lose aren't really

0:45:19practical for air tags. I have a pair of shoes. We went out to a nice dinner here on Christmas Eve

0:45:26and I wanted to wear a pair of shoes that I'm not sure if I've worn since March of 2020.

0:45:32Jared; Yes.

0:45:32Pete; And it's like, and they weren't in my closet and I'm like, I know I put these somewhere

0:45:36dumb. Where the hell did I put them? Well, I don't know. I didn't have air tags in them. You can't

0:45:40put air tags in shoes. So, I had to hunt around and I figured out they were in the coat closet

0:45:45by the front door for some crazy reason. But yeah, I feel like air tags are one of those things that

0:45:50we kind of have to really wait for COVID to subside whenever that's going to be to really

0:45:55find out how useful they are. What else, what have you been using for?

0:45:56Jared; Because I am the person who'd like get up from the restaurant at CES and walk away and

0:46:00forget about my bag. I'm going to have to go running back and hope that it's still there.

0:46:03And I was looking really, I was looking really forward to actually having not have to worry

0:46:06about that anymore. But like you said, I haven't, I haven't, I haven't seen 20 feet in.

0:46:10Pete; Well, right or now you'd get the warning separation, right?

0:46:14Jared; Yeah.

0:46:14Pete; Yeah. I did play with it.

0:46:16Jared; Which goes off with my cars in the garage. Like, I go upstairs from the garage and my car's

0:46:19like, the electric car, why not? Like, I know.

0:46:21Pete; Anything else? Do you have anything else that you have air tags in?

0:46:24Jared; I have in my wallet, well, I'm going to tell everybody now, now they're going to know how

0:46:28to pull them out. But I don't care. They're in my car, my wallet, my gear bag, extra set of keys.

0:46:34And I forget where the last one is probably on something done, like duct tape to my Apple TV

0:46:38remote. Pete;

0:46:39Yeah. Do you really have one duct tape to your Apple TV?

0:46:42Jared; No, but I should because I still lose the damn thing.

0:46:44Pete; What else? There was the, also announced at this event was the changes to Apple podcasts

0:46:50or new features to Apple podcasts, the subscriptions for subscriber only podcasts.

0:46:58I forget what other changes were there. But as far as I can tell, the subscribing to podcasts

0:47:05through Apple podcasts, it does not seem to be a big thing yet, if it ever will be, but maybe

0:47:12I'm missing some segment of the market where it is a thing.

0:47:15Jared; I think it's just fundamentally different. Like, when, because podcasts are so distributed

0:47:21for good and for bad, like, podcast discovery is really hard because they're not on the same

0:47:25platform, but it means that you can use your podcast client of choice and people had to

0:47:30wrestle with, you know, I want to listen to Horace DeGueux's podcast, but I don't like using

0:47:34Apple podcasts. So what am I going to do? Or maybe like you and Ben, you know, they want to listen

0:47:39to you and then is there a version on Apple podcasts? Can we get it that way? What if I have

0:47:44an Android phone as well? Then what do I like? I think it creates, it's creator economy through

0:47:48complexity, which I don't think is the best solution.

0:47:50Pete: Yeah, and it, it's like the App Store works because if you really want to have an app and you

0:47:57want to monetize it, it's the only way. And if you want to have a podcast that is monetized through

0:48:04subscriptions, it's not the only way. And what if you use another way, spoiler upcoming,

0:48:16upcoming sponsor read, but if you use memberful or something like that, or, you know, like Ben has,

0:48:24I was going to say Ben and I, but I, I haven't done any part of it, but Ben has built this system

0:48:29for Stortecory called Passport, which we also use for dithering. And you just do it all through the

0:48:36web. All we do is pay Stripe, you know, like three or just under 3%. And there's a, you sign into our

0:48:45website and if you want to subscribe in any podcast player, including Apple podcasts, it's one link

0:48:52away once you're signed in as a paid subscriber, there's, there's really no reason for us to use

0:49:00the Apple podcast thing. Yeah. If they owned podcasts the way that YouTube owns video,

0:49:05it would be a no brainer, but they don't. And it is where I have a ton. I do look at my analytics

0:49:11through Libsyn for the show and by far and away, the two clients that really matter the most for

0:49:17this show are Apple podcasts, but Apple podcasts is in second place. For me, it's Overcast is

0:49:23number one. I forget, it might be like 60/40 or something like that. Or among those two 60/40,

0:49:30because there's Spotify now and other good clients, but you can, you can listen to it

0:49:36in any client. And so it just seems like a weird thing to want to lock into. It's, you know, I

0:49:42don't blame Apple for trying, but it's, it just seems like there's a lot of yada, yada, yada in

0:49:48the middle of the conception of why, why is this an appealing platform for a subscription based

0:49:55podcast to use? Right? There's just, you got it. There's, there's some dot, dot, dot in the middle

0:50:00that Apple hasn't filled in. And maybe for some categories, their, their share is so phenomenal.

0:50:06Like maybe it's 90% of home improvement podcasts. I have no idea. Yeah, I don't know. And then maybe

0:50:11it might make more sense, but for tech, it is so distributed. And then you have like Pocket Casts

0:50:15on for people who use Android primarily. It's extra work. It ends up being at least as far as

0:50:20I can tell. Yeah. And you know, for us with dithering, it just doesn't seem like there's any

0:50:25reason to use it. It would just complicate things unnecessarily because people who use Apple podcasts

0:50:31can subscribe as is pretty easily, maybe not quite as easily as doing it in the app, but you know,

0:50:39pretty close to it if, if, if you'd know how to use a web browser, which, you know, it's,

0:50:43it doesn't seem like a big ask. Yeah. And your audience is tech savvy. It's almost opted in

0:50:48tech savvy audience. Well, and that's true. I mean, I think that overcast numbers speak to that,

0:50:53right? That it's, it's not that overcast is hard to use, but the fact that you even know what

0:50:58overcast is implies a certain level of tech savviness, you know? All right. On to may,

0:51:05may was another big month. We could start, I guess, with the hardware that was announced in April,

0:51:1024 inch M1 IMAX. Yeah. Yeah. I thought the most interesting thing about those is that they sort

0:51:18of redefined the way people thought about M1 because previously they were only looking at

0:51:22its efficiency in terms of battery life. And I don't think people realize that that efficiency

0:51:26also taught also defines the design that you can make for the enclosure. Apple had to literally

0:51:31have these bulbous behinds on the back of IMAX for years. And I still don't think right now,

0:51:37like if you took Alder Lake, it would even fit properly in the standard IMAX enclosure. I know

0:51:42Dave 2D's video, he couldn't get the thing without water cooling into a mini tower. So just the

0:51:46prospect that Apple would have with that next generation of Intel chips that were like using

0:51:51excessive voltage to try to catch up with AMD, it wouldn't fit in there. And because they're using

0:51:55Apple chips, they could make this entirely new, really flat, flat IMAX design. Yeah. I, I still

0:52:02think, and you know, because at the time that the M that the, and this is the first designed around

0:52:09the M1 Mac, right. Which is kind of a neat thing, right? It's cause the, the M1 MacBook Air and

0:52:16MacBook Pros that shipped in November last year, were all literally the same enclosures as the

0:52:24Intel ones, which was a strategic thing Apple did to sort of keep the project as secret as possible.

0:52:31I mean, everybody, including Intel kind of knew that Apple was moving towards moving the Mac to

0:52:37its own silicon, but for whatever reason, strategically, the fact that this was 2020

0:52:44was the year where they were going to pull the trigger and do it. They wanted to keep it secret

0:52:48as long as possible. And they therefore kept the hardware right down to the camera, the keyboard,

0:52:58everything exactly the same. So the first, what can we design around the M1 that we could not do

0:53:05with Intel? The 24 inch iMac was the first example of that. I mean, and the 24 inch iMac is so crazy

0:53:12thin and perfect, perfectly rectilinear with no bulb, no, not even like a pimple on the back.

0:53:19There's no way that Intel has anything that would even vaguely fit in there and not...

0:53:25I mean the Core Y from the old MacBook Air, but I don't think it would even power the display.

0:53:28Right. Right. And, and both fit in there without melting it and satisfy, just merely satisfy as

0:53:38opposed to completely please them, make them ecstatic over the moon with the performance,

0:53:44just satisfy them with the performance. There is nothing, literally couldn't be done.

0:53:49No. I mean that chipset took the MacBook Air from something that barely functioned to something that

0:53:54was industry leading. And it's the same thing with the iMac. I also think Apple's bandwidth to push

0:53:59out complete new iMac, sorry, new Mac redesigns is limited. Like we got two this year, and I think

0:54:06that'll be sort of their pace and they'll stagger using the same containers with creating new designs

0:54:12every couple of years from now on, just because it seems to take them a long time to get those

0:54:15things done. It's as good a point to speculate about the future as possible. I mean, it does seem

0:54:23like they're on a weird cadence, right? Where the easiest product to understand cadence wise is the

0:54:30iPhone. It is completely annual. And the one year where it wasn't annual was the 4S where they

0:54:38switched from a June release around WWDC or weeks afterwards to a fall release, which, as far as I

0:54:49know, was completely strategic and planned. Jared: In October it was for Singleton.

0:54:55Pete: Yeah. Sadly coincided with Steve Jobs' death, you know, and sort of put a pall over,

0:55:03literally a literal pall over the event. But it's, you know, once a year, every year,

0:55:11come September, there will be an event or October, you know, if something happens and it gets delayed,

0:55:16you know, mid-September, early October, every single year, there's a new line of iPhones with

0:55:23a new line of silicon. And that's the way it goes. The Mac schedule, let's see how it works out in

0:55:30the long run. But, you know, for example, at this point, everything clearly is not annual because we

0:55:36did not get updates to the MacBook Air or the low-end MacBook Pro or the Mac Mini. All the

0:55:42stuff that came out in November of last year is still unchanged, you know, it is what it is,

0:55:48still using the M1. I sort of guess, I mean, I know the rumor mill about M2 products,

0:55:56and I know you've been all over it, you know, on your YouTube channel. It seems like it may not be,

0:56:02you know, even the same calendar. I don't know that we're going to have to wait until November

0:56:07to get new products. It seems like it could be like a spring thing this year.

0:56:12- Yeah. Well, the extended versions of the Apple, so like the original A series, like they did,

0:56:18it was very strange. Like they had A5X, A6X, no A7X, A8X, A9X, A10X, no A11X, A12X, A12Z,

0:56:27no A13X, and then A14X ended up being M1. So that stuff was like on an 18 month, I think, sort of a

0:56:34average pace. So we might get the same thing here where they're still going to have a new A series

0:56:40chip every year, every iPhone, but then when they choose to make the new M series chips might vary

0:56:45slightly longer. - Right. And for various reasons that I don't feel like going into,

0:56:51because I don't fully understand, but the way things work, and this is a very,

0:56:57it's just the way Silicon development works. It's the reason that Xeons come out after

0:57:01the consumer level chips based on the same generation. It just takes longer.

0:57:07And you come out with the regular M1 and then the M1 Pro and M1 Max, which are in very,

0:57:19very high level lay person's terms, a couple of M1s put together. Obviously you can't do a couple of

0:57:29them put together simultaneous with the original release. It obviously takes longer and those pro

0:57:36level versions of the same generation are going to always come out later. So my guess is this spring,

0:57:42pretty much when we saw the 24 inch iMac last year, we'll see the pro level, whether they call

0:57:51it iMac Pro or I'm guessing they will, that they'll just say iMac is a 24 inch product with the

0:57:58regular M1. And then the next one will have the regular M2 and the iMac Pro will be something with

0:58:05like the M1 Pro and M1 Max that we just got last month or two months ago with the new 14 inch and

0:58:1516 inch MacBook Pros. And the really cool thing is because the thermals are so good, they could put

0:58:20dual M1 Maxes in the highest end model and it would still be drawing less power than the Intel chip.

0:58:26Yeah. And I wouldn't be surprised if that's what they do. So with the regular 24 inch iMac,

0:58:33they just put the exact same chip in. I mean, I don't know if there's some, I forget,

0:58:37but effectively it's pretty much just the same chip that's in the other, the original M1 MacBooks

0:58:44and Mac mini. I wouldn't be surprised if that's not quite the same with the 27 inch, which I'm

0:58:53guessing 27 inch at this point, even though I thought maybe they'd go to 30 inch, but let's

0:58:57just say 27 inch based on some rumors that are coming out of the supply chain.

0:59:02I wouldn't be surprised if it's not the exact same and limited to exactly what's in the 16 and 14

0:59:09inch, but that they actually can do multiple Maxes. I don't know the Max Plus. I mean,

0:59:14they're running out of adjectives. They stick at the end of these names.

0:59:17I think it's just dual M1 Max and the iMac and quad M1 Max and the Mac Pro. And then it's just

0:59:23so much more efficient and economical for their processes.

0:59:25Yeah. And somebody had a thing the other day where every product, I think it was a YouTube,

0:59:30I don't know what it was, but every single product in the world now either has Pro Plus or Max in its

0:59:37name. And I get it, it's sort of a trend and maybe Apple is sort of spearheading the trend. They've

0:59:44certainly been on top of the word Pro for decades, but the word Max, M-A-X, as a podcaster is so

0:59:56problematic when you're talking about the Macintosh platform. The Max—

1:00:01The Max, M1 Max, Max, M1 Max, M1 Max, Max, Max. It just doesn't make any sense.

1:00:05It's a mouthful and it's not a problem at all in writing. I suppose it's a bit of a,

1:00:14as much of a problem on YouTube, although on YouTube you can always put titles up, right?

1:00:19[Laughter]

1:00:19But the whole thing is just ungainly. It's like a MacBook Pro with an M1 Pro

1:00:24or M1 Max. Both words are doubled up no matter what you do and it's just inelegant.

1:00:29Right. And I'm not endorsing going to the 68-040X chip, something like that.

1:00:37I'm convinced Sony product names come from 1Password, the password generator.

1:00:41Oh, yeah.

1:00:41That's all they do. They just pseudo-random blob, that's the password, that's the product name.

1:00:44Yeah. So that's my guess is that pretty much around the time we saw the 24-inch regular

1:00:52iMacs last year. This year we'll see the 27-inch iMac Pros. I look forward to that.

1:00:58What else came out last year? The M1, and we also got our hands on these in May after being

1:01:05announced in April, the M1 iPad Pros. I don't really-

1:01:09Some people got so angry about it.

1:01:11Why? Why do you think they got angry?

1:01:12Because I think they're, I think partly Apple marketing, but also

1:01:17Expectational Debt is they saw Tim Cook take a chip from a Mac and put it in an iPad. And there's

1:01:22this contingent of iPad owners who have always loved the hardware but wanted it to be a Mac.

1:01:27And they thought when that chip was moving over, they were getting Mac OS essentially on an iPad.

1:01:32And it was never going to be that, but for a minute they were like just so excited and then

1:01:37they realized it's still an iPad of course. Yeah. I'm not quite sure what it is that they

1:01:41were hoping for. I don't have a lot to say about these. I mean, they're great. I mean,

1:01:45I don't own one. I don't use my iPad enough to have purchased one to replace my 2018

1:01:52whatever chip iPad Pro. But they're great. And if you're iPad first, it certainly is a great product.

1:02:01But there's not much to add.

1:02:03I love it for the screen. I have my MacBook Pro now and it has a mini LED HDR display. And I use

1:02:09the iPad Pro inside car and I can edit videos. I don't release videos in HDR yet, but I love

1:02:14to play around with it. And I have like full display HDR on one panel. I'm editing next

1:02:18to another panel and it's the best thing in the world. It would have cost me tens of thousands

1:02:22of dollars in the past. Yeah. It's a beautiful display. Center stage is a really neat feature.

1:02:26It's probably the biggest, hmm. I wonder why they didn't do that with the new M1 Pro and Macs,

1:02:36MacBook Pros. But I believe it's simply that there's no room for the camera that can be so

1:02:43super wide angle in the really thin MacBook lids. I really think it comes down to camera hardware,

1:02:49not some kind of marketing spite that you have to buy an iPad just to get center stage.

1:02:54And I'm sure we'll get there. Like a lot of the stuff Apple starts off with a couple tests

1:02:59and then they move it as quickly as or as easily as they can across the product line.

1:03:02But it is, it's one of those features that sounds too good to be true. And in practice,

1:03:06it's even better in my opinion than they promise it to be. The biggest problem with it

1:03:11is that usually when we've used it, the iPad is in a magic keyboard case and is therefore in

1:03:19landscape. And therefore the camera's not at the top center. It's in the middle of the display

1:03:26to the left. And I don't know what the answer to that is. I don't know that Apple is really ready

1:03:32to say that the canonical orientation for an iPad is no longer up and down, but left and right.

1:03:39But I kind of feel like they should.

1:03:42Jared I kind of screwed themselves too,

1:03:44because they put the smart connector now on the bottom. Like if you're holding it in landscape,

1:03:49the smart connector now is on the bottom. The Apple pencil charges on the top, and both of

1:03:53those take up the physical space you'd need to put the camera there. So it's tough, but it should be,

1:03:59if 2020 and 2020 junior taught us anything, it's that that's the way people are using them.

1:04:03Pete Yeah. So I don't know what the answer is, but

1:04:06hopefully, you know, they're aware of it as anybody else. It is a great like zoom device.

1:04:11We've used it, you know, all of our school meetings. I mean, Jonas is in school this year,

1:04:16but all the parent stuff is all via zoom. And we just use iPads for that. And it's, you know,

1:04:23it's nice to actually look good in the in the footage, as opposed to using an old Mac from the

1:04:29Intel era. It is funny, too. I just we were just watching the news yesterday. We don't watch a lot

1:04:36of TV news, but something was up and we were watching something and I had an interview with

1:04:39a local hospital official. And I was like, Oh, I know he's using an old MacBook, I can tell I

1:04:45could just tell by the bluish tint, everything about it. I was like, I know it's not just a cheap

1:04:50webcam. It was like that is absolutely the telltale look of Intel era MacBook of some sort.

1:04:56And it's like, there used to be a time when you could not get on TV looking like that, you know,

1:05:06with camera quality like that they would just send a crew to your house and actually have a real

1:05:09camera. Yeah, they have you to find everything but the iOS, I saw the iPhone and the iPad cameras are

1:05:15really good now except for the orientation. And the MacBook Pro cameras are and the iMac cameras

1:05:20are really, really good. Yeah, especially because of the orientation. So I think we're beginning to

1:05:24Apple TV 4k and a new God, you know, who's, uh, you know, angels singing a new remote control,

1:05:32which I still love. I'm still very, very happy with. I don't have much to say about it. I mean,

1:05:40are you used to the new place of the Siri or do you? Are you still like me pressing play pause

1:05:43every once in a while to activate Siri? No, I've totally gotten used to Siri. Okay, my problem is

1:05:49the power button. And I mentioned this on the show, I think when Ben Thompson was on a few weeks

1:05:54ago, where my long standing and occasionally mentioned gripe that I could use the Apple TV

1:06:00power to power everything off by holding power, but could not turn it on was solved with a setting

1:06:08on my LG TV, go into settings on the LG and you go in and there's something, something and you can

1:06:14turn on whatever the name of the feature is. I don't know why it wasn't on the by default. It's

1:06:19nuts to me. But there's something you had, I had to turn on, on the LG TV. And now I can use the

1:06:25power button on the Siri remote to turn everything on. And even if the HDMI was set to the switch or

1:06:33to our TiVo, it'll switch the HDMI to the Apple TV too. It is wonderful. I love it.

1:06:40Jared: Mine works like 19 out of 20 times. So, yeah, it won't turn on the TV or it won't turn

1:06:44off the TV. You know, at the time we have the same thing and every single, like the 5% of

1:06:48times when it doesn't work, it's always Amy, never me, which I wish were the other way around.

1:06:54Jared and Justin: Yeah, same.

1:06:54Jared and Justin: Because I'd rather have the problem than hear about it.

1:06:57Jared and Justin Yes, absolutely.

1:06:58Justin No, my problem with the remote is that once I've turned it on, when I first turn it on,

1:07:04and I use that sort of hidden button, not hidden, but it's sort of meant to be disguised and out of

1:07:10the way, that power button on the upper right, I suddenly, my brain thinks that's the upper right

1:07:17button. And then I use that button as the home button instead of the, you know, the actual home

1:07:24button on the Siri remote, like to just leave whatever app I'm in to go back to the Apple TV

1:07:30home screen, I hit the power button. And it says, "Oh, you have to press this to turn everything off."

1:07:35And I'm like, "I don't want to turn everything off." And I'm like, "Oh, it's like something in

1:07:39my brain just and then I have to, you know, think about it, actually think about it. No,

1:07:47once I've turned everything on, the top right button is down here in the middle."

1:07:50Jared I don't know, I solve that by using the play pause button to turn things on. I don't

1:07:56almost never use the power button. But only that button works to turn it on. Like you can't press

1:08:01any button to turn it on. It's only that one in the middle. And if you forget that and press

1:08:05another one, like, which is weird to me as well.

1:08:07Pete: Yeah, but overall, I could not be happier with the remote. I love it. I even love it just

1:08:12as a little thing to hold in my hand. It feels cool, it has a nice weight, it is just a-

1:08:18Jared: It feels substantial.

1:08:19Pete It is a very nice object in hand, could not be happier with it. I still feel like they could

1:08:24have done a better job with the spin thing on the circle, you know, and I know that this was

1:08:31something that was a source of confusion because it works in some places and then in other places,

1:08:36it doesn't, but it does register the touch. So if you run your finger in a circle, instead of going

1:08:43like down, down, down, down, down, down, down in the list, it goes like down, down, down, up,

1:08:47up, down, down, down, up, up, down, down, you know.

1:08:50Jared Well, I mean, like, one of the problems with the Apple TV, like, in my belief is that Apple is

1:08:54not stringent enough about how things are implemented. And so you have a range of behaviors

1:08:59across apps, not even including those really shitty, lazy OpenGL apps that Amazon and others

1:09:03insist on using, but like some of them, you'll press menu and you're thrown right out of the,

1:09:09I would say the word you did, but then I'll get yelled at by your entire audience, you get thrown

1:09:12right out of the app. Others, you press menu and you get like, given this little thing saying,

1:09:15"Do you want to see more episodes? Do you want to continue this episode? Here's information on the

1:09:19episode." Others, like in YouTube, sometimes pressing that button will clear whatever pop up

1:09:24is on the screen. In other apps, even if there is a pop up on the screen, throws you out the app

1:09:28again, and there's zero consistency. Pete Yeah, we were watching movies as a family

1:09:33before and after Christmas, a bunch of Christmas movies, and we were looking, and one night we

1:09:38didn't have anything to watch. We didn't know what to watch and we were surfing around and I said,

1:09:42"So we look at Amazon Prime and Amy, not even Jonas, but Amy said, 'I hate Amazon Prime,' and

1:09:48I said, 'Why?' And she says, 'It just looks so junky.'" And I was like, "You know what? There's

1:09:51a reason we got married." Like, she's not usually one to complain about stuff like that. But even she

1:09:56thinks their interface just looks like, you know, it's hot garbage. It doesn't look like you're in

1:10:02a Walmart. It looks like you're in the warehouse behind the Walmart. It's…

1:10:07Jared Polin Netflix has a whole team making their app. There's no excuse for Amazon to just

1:10:11keep porting that nonsense over. Pete It's really so junky-looking. I mean,

1:10:16they've got some good stuff that is exclusive. I watched some stuff there, but man, the app is

1:10:20always like, Jesus, nothing is animated. Everything's ugly. It's even a bad font. It's really bad.

1:10:27Jared Polin So did you leave it on 60 frames per second? Because that's one of the big deals

1:10:31about the new Apple TV is that you could put it on 60 frames per second. Or did you revert it back

1:10:35down to like 30 or 24? Pete I haven't touched anything. I don't think anything plays at 60

1:10:39frames per second. At least if I, you know, if I've watched it, I would notice if it was. I don't

1:10:44think I've seen it. I don't think it works. Jared Polin I had to turn it off. Like, it looks

1:10:47motion smooth to me. Like, I would go to the Disney+ app, but I'd watch some of the Marvel movies.

1:10:51And I know, like, I know people are saying that it's not, but to me, it still looks motion smooth,

1:10:54so I couldn't leave it on. Pete Well, maybe I did turn it off then,

1:10:57because I don't notice, I would notice something that looks motion smoothie.

1:11:00Jared Polin Yeah, it's just too clean.

1:11:02Pete May, we're still in May. Apple went to court with Epic.

1:11:07Jared Polin Yes. Epic versus Tim Apple.

1:11:10Pete I mean, this was obviously a year long saga. There was stuff before the courtroom. There was,

1:11:17obviously, decisions have come afterwards, but we might as well talk about it in May,

1:11:21because that's when they actually went to court.

1:11:23Jared Polin Yeah.

1:11:25Pete It doesn't seem like anything surprising came out of the whole thing.

1:11:32And it seems like everybody's sort of, anybody with any sort of informed opinion during the

1:11:39courtroom is sort of like, looks like Apple's in good grounds here. But it was sort of a bad…

1:11:44Jared Polin Uninformed opinions got published though, John.

1:11:46Pete It was a bad look for Apple, though, you know, and I still say that Tim Cook's testimony

1:11:51in particular came across pretty poorly, in my opinion. Not terribly, but just sort of,

1:12:00just a little unseemly, you know.

1:12:04Jared Polin Yeah, I can see that. Like, what's weird, though, is that he plainly, he plainly

1:12:08said during his testimony that if the court decided that there could be transactions outside the App

1:12:13Store, it would be onerous for Apple to collect their percentage of those transactions outside

1:12:17the App Store. And then, flash forward a few months, people are shocked to discover that

1:12:22Google and Apple are going to do this, even though they said plainly that that was their intent the

1:12:26whole time. I think the coverage was, one of my problems was the coverage was completely subpar,

1:12:31in most cases. Some people did a really good job. But also, to me, at the very beginning,

1:12:36I was interested because it looked like Epic was going to try to make a case for, you know,

1:12:40actually for the users and for developers and things that could be better. But the minute they

1:12:44sued Google as well, and then when they put out their filing, and you paged all the way down and

1:12:48saw what they really wanted was their own App Store so that they could be the ones collecting

1:12:52this commission, regardless of the amount, it ended up becoming like, oh, you're opening a new

1:12:57casino and you're haggling with the city of Las Vegas over who gets what cut.

1:13:01Pete Lienberg Well, it's not just that they wanted their own App Store, it's that they wanted their

1:13:05own friction free App Store. Meaning, meaning you are a Joe or Jane customer and you've purchased

1:13:14a new phone, and you've gone right down the line with all the defaults and Epic wanted you and

1:13:23still, I guess, wants you to somehow be able to install the entire Epic App Store as easily as you

1:13:29Jared Ranerelle Like a browser ballot.

1:13:30Pete Lienberg As easily as you install any other app right now, as opposed to, and I have an

1:13:37Android phone, you know, I have a pixel four. You know, and I did it, I installed the Epic App Store,

1:13:45you know, when this was new. I honestly think for people who want to be able to side load and want

1:13:53that sort of thing to be possible, if you choose to use it, that the user experience

1:14:01Google has designed for it is extremely reasonable and appropriate. And the things they warn you about

1:14:08and the way they phrase their warning are completely appropriate. They're not overly scary.

1:14:15Jared Ranerelle Epic hates it.

1:14:17Pete Lienberg They're true. And they, well, they hate it because in practice, people don't use it.

1:14:21People don't do it.

1:14:23Jared Ranerelle In practice, people don't do stuff like that. We talked about this before, but

1:14:27it seemed to boil down to this argument about what like what choice really means.

1:14:31Does choice mean that every platform has to offer you a choice between a managed experience and a

1:14:37completely freeform experience? Or can one platform offer you a managed experience and another platform

1:14:42offer you the option for a freeform experience. And people have very different opinions on this,

1:14:47and very different privileges when it comes to this. But I think that's still like console model

1:14:53versus open compute model. And whether that has to be per platform or whether it can be across

1:14:58platforms.

1:14:58Pete Lienberg Yeah, I think that that what the epic Apple, my look back at it, and the way I

1:15:05think I'll view it in hindsight is, as it becomes old news as years go on, and I think back to 2021

1:15:11is less about the actual legal case, because Apple pretty much won almost everything,

1:15:18and it looks like they're going to win the last remaining thing on appeal. And the other thing,

1:15:24the thing about letting users, you know, collecting their email address, if they choose to give it to

1:15:31you is something they should have given in any way. And Apple's response to it is sure, fine,

1:15:35right? Like we will just concede that point that we're not even going to fight it. But the last

1:15:40remaining point is on this in app payment thing. And what exactly it means. And it certainly looks

1:15:47like based on the what we've seen so far that that Judge Gonzalez Rogers overreached by trying to

1:15:55apply California law to something that it wasn't. But if there's a downside for Apple in it, it's

1:16:03that it exposed the sort of raw nerves of resentment that have grown up in the developer.

1:16:11Jared: That's a great way to put it. Right? It's, and that resentment was there. It wasn't

1:16:19because if Epic hadn't had, you know, in the alternate universe, where the only difference

1:16:24is that Epic never, never chose to make this fight, and Fortnite is just in the app store,

1:16:30like it was a year ago, or two years ago, that resentment would still be there. It's that this,

1:16:38the this case and people's reactions to it, exposed it, it picked up the stone, and we can see the

1:16:47ugly worms of resentment that are there built around the app store.

1:16:51Ben: Yeah, there's there's two sides to that, I think, because like, you see some developers

1:16:55push back on that, as well, like, they're never a Unimind. And it's not just a monoculture.

1:17:00So you see some people saying, sideloading would be great. Others saying it's going to increase

1:17:04piracy. You see some people saying 30% is ridiculous. Others say, well, yes, but I used

1:17:09to pay for all of this and all the different tax filings around the world. And so there is,

1:17:13I don't think, I think by and large, the negative sentiment gets overreported, the positive sentiment

1:17:17gets underreported. But I do think the biggest thing, my takeaway from this is that Apple has

1:17:22not done a very good job in being proactive about this. And in the past that suited them well,

1:17:27because it's been very slow regulation. The stuff that the EU does, things that the Department of

1:17:35Justice does, it's all been very slow, but it seems like it's coming to a head. And now we've

1:17:40got correct cases in Korea and Japan. And I forget which other country it was one of one of the

1:17:44Eastern European countries, the US now as well. And these, they are not tech savvy, you only have

1:17:51to look at the cookie regulations, the privacy, GDPR regulations, they are onerous to the point

1:17:57of being destructive to the people that they're pretending to protect. And I think it would be

1:18:02sad if Apple wasn't proactive enough in terms of getting ahead of these issues that they left it

1:18:07up to being, like, again, I go back to the browser ballot, they forced Microsoft to protect browsers,

1:18:14they forced Microsoft to put this ballot up so that Fenris and Slepnir wouldn't be overwhelmed

1:18:18by the market. And the result is everything is chromium now. So I just, I don't want to leave

1:18:24it to these people. So I wish Apple would be more proactive about it. I agree. Let's take a break

1:18:28here. And let's thank the sponsor who I spoiled a couple minutes ago, Memberful, great company,

1:18:34though, sorry for spoiling the fact that they're our second sponsor, you can monetize your passion

1:18:40with membership with Memberful. Memberful allows you to build a sustainable recurring revenue.

1:18:46And it is the easiest way. This is true, it is absolutely the easiest way to sell memberships

1:18:52to your audience. And it is used by some of the biggest creators on the web. Our friends at Six

1:18:57Colors like Jason Snow uses it all of the subscription podcasts at relay.fm. You've probably

1:19:04got at least one Memberful membership right now. If you're listening to me talk to you, I have a

1:19:09bunch of them couldn't be an easier thing to deal with. And as a creative person who wants to

1:19:14actually be the creator with the memberships, it gives you everything you need to run it, you get

1:19:19your own branding, it's your branding, not Memberful's that people see. You can offer gift

1:19:24subscriptions, Apple Pay, free trials, private podcasts, which is what I mentioned, and they make

1:19:31that easy, and tons more. Just about anything you'd want to offer to your members, Memberful helps you

1:19:36do it. And you have full control and ownership of your audience, your brand, and your membership.

1:19:42If anything happens down the road where you'd like to move away from Memberful, you take your

1:19:47audience, your subscription list with you, no questions asked, that's how confident they are

1:19:52that you're going to want to stay with them. And they have a world-class support team that is ready

1:19:56to help you simplify your memberships and grow your revenue. They win when you win. That's it.

1:20:01It is win-win for everybody. Your members are happy if they're getting content that they like

1:20:08to pay for. You're happy because you're making money and monetizing it. And Memberful only makes

1:20:13money when you make money. So it's win-win-win. It really is no corniness implied by saying that.

1:20:20And you can get started for free with no credit card required. Just go to memberful.com/talkshow,

1:20:28memberful.com/talkshow today. Get started, no credit card required. Great service.

1:20:35All right. Moving on. June WWDC. What do we talk about for WWDC? I guess we talk about the event.

1:20:44The virtual stuff was better this year. I thought they did a better job in emulating the lab

1:20:48experience and providing a much better connection point for developers.

1:20:52Yeah. I'm starting to get down though, because I'm starting to think maybe it's not going to happen

1:20:58again this year. I mean, who knows? It's very hard to predict, but they're obviously going to have to

1:21:04make a decision long before June. Yeah. Especially because it's not on campus. They have to actually

1:21:11get facilities for it. Yeah. And I do think, I don't think it is the fact that you and I

1:21:20are Apple-centric in our coverage of the industry. I almost think it's objective, not subjective,

1:21:30that Apple has done a better job with these virtual-only product announcement events than

1:21:35anybody else. And the recent Facebook one where they changed the name to Meta was certainly higher

1:21:43level than just about anything else I've seen outside of Apple. But there was sort of…

1:21:48Animatronic Mark Zuckerberg was almost lifelike, even in the real world.

1:21:53Well, and they obviously spent a lot on some kind of, I presume, green screen sort of environments

1:21:59that he was walking around in. It was so odd though, because the big joke is that he's data

1:22:04from Star Trek. And the first thing he did was walk into like pale blue lighting where he looked

1:22:08completely robotic. Which must have been self-referential. It was a good show. Apple's very

1:22:16good at this. I've always thought that this, you can tell it most clearly to me with like a daily

1:22:22comic strip. It's always so interesting to me, has been since I was a little kid. And the one I

1:22:29remember was finding out my elementary school library had, I don't know if it was the complete

1:22:35Peanuts library, but they had dozens and dozens of Charles Schulz's Peanuts books dating back to the

1:22:44early days in like the, I think the late 1950s. And I always loved that. It was one of my favorite

1:22:50comic strips. And I remember when I read the early ones, it was like my little emoji head,

1:22:57little poof, a smoke came off my head. It was like, "Whoa, all the characters look different.

1:23:02This looks so weird." And every single comic strip starts like that. Even, you know, I think what

1:23:10most people would consider the best comic strip of all time, Calvin and Hobbes, the very early ones

1:23:15look slightly different. - [Lyle] Bloom County and Garfield too.

1:23:18- [Peter] Bloom County, Garfield, Doonesbury, the early Doonesbury's look so different.

1:23:24And the way it goes is they, you know, the artist sort of is working out their personal style and

1:23:30the characters look, and then they sort of, then they hone in on this is it. And then like for

1:23:37Peanuts… - [Lyle] They find their

1:23:38illustrative voice. - [Peter] Right. And Peanuts

1:23:40and Doonesbury are good examples that have run for decades. And like, you know, like late '80s,

1:23:49Doonesbury doesn't really look much different than Doonesbury today, but '70s Doonesbury looks crazy.

1:23:55TV shows are like that too. But the first season of Seinfeld is very, very weird in hindsight.

1:24:03And where I'm going with this is that Apple sort of carved out there, this is what our

1:24:10remote shows, virtual shows are going to look and feel like very early, and they've stuck to it.

1:24:18I think they've gotten better at it, but there's not like, I think if you went back, I guess the

1:24:23first one would be last 2020s WWDC. I think if you rewatched it, and I, you know, you and I,

1:24:32I know you probably more than me because you're always fishing for B-roll, right? Right? So you've

1:24:39probably actually watched it. You've probably watched it more than me. - [Lyle] I watched it

1:24:43today. - But they kind of defined a style and a look and right from the get-go, really,

1:24:52really distinctive, has a voice, has a character. It really is a show.

1:24:57- The only thing they've done is added, like continued to add more and more locations,

1:25:01including now all of California. - Right, right.

1:25:04- But it's the same like drone shots, crane moves, zips. And what's funny is you looked

1:25:09at the early other companies trying to figure this out, and they mostly, they tried to just

1:25:13film the stage. They did a stage show with no audience and filmed it, or they had people

1:25:16reading off teleprompters very awkwardly. But then about a year in, they just, oh,

1:25:21Apple taught us how to do this. - Yeah. Well, and one of the things there's,

1:25:25you know, you don't have to notice, you don't have to know this, but it's like,

1:25:28regular iPhones are bright and well-lit, if not outdoors, like Kayan Drance on stage.

1:25:37- Yeah, Jeff Williams going for a hike. - Yeah, Jeff Williams going for a hike.

1:25:41And Pro is in the dark, you know, like, so 2020, Jaws, he wasn't outdoors, but he was in a dark

1:25:50room with a spotlight talking about the iPhone 12 Pro. And then this year he was outside Apple

1:25:59Park at night, though, you know, like, I think inside- - That's a really canny observation,

1:26:04because Pro apps always had the dark interfaces too.

1:26:06- Yeah, Pro is dark or night. And I think even last year when Jaws was inside on some sort of

1:26:14sound stage to do the announcement, they did, when they did the transition where they show,

1:26:19you know, they do some kind of drone, whether it's actual drone footage, I think usually it is,

1:26:25or some kind of 3D visual effect. It is nighttime though. They established that it is nighttime at

1:26:34Apple Park. And now here's Jaws to talk about the iPhone, whatever Pro. Yeah, Pro is dark, regular

1:26:41is bright and sunny. - I love that attention to detail because it permeates everything from the

1:26:45hardware to the software to the event. - Yeah, yeah. Was this the year where

1:26:48Federighi was in the red convertible? - Yes, in the WDC.

1:26:53- Yeah, that was a good gag. - Yeah, yeah.

1:26:56- I don't really have much to add. I think you're right. And from what I've heard that they did a

1:27:00better job with preparation for the labs and say what you want about Apple's developer relations.

1:27:07And we mentioned the consternation over the App Store, et cetera. They really do want to knock

1:27:12it out of the park with the labs during WWDC. I mean, it's, you know, from the top down, including

1:27:18right down to the people responsible for the frameworks who actually run these labs and you

1:27:22get to ask questions. It is something they want to do a good job of and really needed to be invented

1:27:29compared to in-person WWDC. - And their evangelist, I mean,

1:27:33other companies similar to Apple have hundreds of evangelists. Apple still has a very tiny evangelist

1:27:39team and they do amazing, amazing work every WWDC. - Yeah, yeah, they really do. And they want to.

1:27:46- They gave Serenity a choice of hats on the YouTube videos this year, which I thought was nice.

1:27:49Serenity was on the talk show and now she's on Apple's YouTube channel. John,

1:27:55that's quite the journey. - I know. I hear her narrating

1:28:01those daily updates for WWDC and I'm like, "God damn, I miss having her on the show."

1:28:06- I know, same, same. - Because she was very good too. And no offense to you,

1:28:11but she was very, very good because she speaks faster than I do. She was very good at keeping me

1:28:16to up my pace, you know? - Yes, yeah. Microsoft stole Christina,

1:28:20Apple stole Serenity. We have no fast talkers left. - I guess now, June, July, there wasn't really any

1:28:27news in July. Might as well just, let's just use up July to talk about the great 2021 Safari tab saga.

1:28:35- Yes. Oh, yeah. I feel like we've talked about this the entire way through.

1:28:39- All's well that ends well, maybe? - Yes. The process concerns me. The fact

1:28:46that it happened concerns me. The fact that they fixed it makes me feel good.

1:28:49- Yeah. You know, the best thing to do is not to make a mistake, but the second best thing to do

1:28:55is recognize mistakes and correct them even if it means backing completely out. The Safari tabs thing,

1:29:02it is alarming because I still don't really get how anybody thought it should have, the designs

1:29:09that were unveiled at WWDC should have shipped on either platform. And the platform, the UI critiques

1:29:16which I wrote about at length on Daring Fireball. I know you talked about it.

1:29:20- You and I did a couple of videos on it too. It was great.

1:29:22- We did videos about it. So we don't have to rehash what the problems with those designs were

1:29:28specifically. To me, it's worrisome that they shipped. And I don't want to blame it on remote

1:29:34work and COVID and that if they'd been in person, that this would have been more successfully,

1:29:41the right side of the argument would have won out in person. I don't know that that's true.

1:29:45It's possible. I don't know. It could just be purely coincidental that this bad design

1:29:51was announced in a year and after a year of no in-person collaboration. I don't know. But

1:30:00whoever it was, whatever people were pushing for that design, it's very questionable whether they

1:30:07should be in the positions where they are, in my opinion. - Well, it's a fake simplicity. It's

1:30:13a scarcity in place of actual simplicity. It's making complexity just to have fewer things,

1:30:18which is like an inverse of the principle. But the weirdest thing to me was watching it go public.

1:30:24And the public never even got the worst versions of those. That was saved for the betas. But

1:30:29watching it go public and seeing celebrities interact about it on Twitter, like seeing a

1:30:34celebrity go, "What the fuck happened to my safari bar? Where is it?" And then another

1:30:38celebrity going, "Oh, they moved it to the bottom." And then a bunch of people say, "No,

1:30:40no, no. You can move it back." And then this whole discussion around what the hell did Apple

1:30:44do to their browser. - It was one of the first things. There's another one where I'll drag my

1:30:50wife into it where when she first turned on her iPhone 13 Pro and hadn't been following along

1:30:58and completed the upgrade and there it is, now here's all your stuff. And she just turned to me

1:31:04with safari. And she was like, "What the hell is going on with safari?" And I hadn't said to

1:31:10her, "Hey, wait until you get a load of safari." It's very strange in my opinion.

1:31:16- Did you revert to the top? Did you use the setting to put the safari search bar back?

1:31:20- Yeah. - I haven't. I've kept it at the bottom. And it still feels weird to me,

1:31:24even though it's like half a year later. - See, but that's... And I saw some people...

1:31:29I think I wrote about this. I hope I did. I saw some people mention that it's weird and shows that

1:31:35maybe Apple's losing its touch because they don't offer options like that. Apple just says, "Here's

1:31:40the way it is." And so offering you the option to have it at the top or bottom is un-Apple-like.

1:31:44And I would say the opposite. I would say where putting it at the top or bottom offers you the

1:31:50same functionality and the same set of buttons, it's just you want it at the top or bottom,

1:31:55is very Apple-like, right? And it really goes back to Mac OS X 10.0 in 2002, 2001. When the hell was

1:32:06that? 2002, whenever it was. Or even going back earlier to next step before Mac OS X or Mac OS

1:32:14IX had lots of options to move some things around. You can move the control strip to wherever the

1:32:18hell you wanted it. Some of those... In a way that in AppKit Mac apps, there's any true Mac style Mac

1:32:27app has the ability to completely customize the toolbar, right? And put whatever, all sorts of

1:32:33options. And the more rich the app, the more configurable it is that you can do this.

1:32:38Configuration options for stuff like that is very Apple-like. It was the two totally different

1:32:47theories of what a tab is that was un-Apple-like, right?

1:32:51**Beserat Debebe:** Yes.

1:33:02**Beserat Debebe:** And nobody was complaining about tabs. It really felt like something that

1:33:17Apple has long said repeatedly in many times. They don't really talk too much in detail about what

1:33:23they're thinking, but they do... It comes across as anodyne when you're familiar with them and

1:33:29their statements, like the recent wallpaper feature of Evans Hanke and Alan Dye's design team.

1:33:36You could read that and if you're in tune to Apple like we are and lots of people who listen to this

1:33:42show are, you could read that and say, "Well, I didn't really learn anything. Everything they

1:33:46said in there, I sort of already knew." I certainly thought that personally, and I was way more

1:33:52interested in the photographs because that was unprecedented and really kind of neat. I mentioned

1:33:57on Daring Fireball how neat it was to see the actual personal iPhones of the people on the

1:34:03design team, a dozen of them who were in a meeting and how many of them used cases, how many of them

1:34:09had the wallet attachment, which was really surprising to me. And I actually spoke to someone

1:34:14who's familiar with the situation and said, "Yeah, actually the wallet really is pretty popular with

1:34:19that team." And somebody who verified, "Yeah, that was actually their real notebooks and personal

1:34:26iPhones that wasn't staged." I mean, they were obviously aware a photographer was in the room,

1:34:29but I thought that was pretty neat. But the Safari thing, I don't know. And there is something,

1:34:37I get wanting, having the itch for new, right? And that new excites a certain part of your,

1:34:47new and changed and different releases, endorphins from a certain part of your brain.

1:34:54And I know that when I was younger, that part of my brain was way more active than it is now that

1:35:01I'm older. And that's why, like in the nineties, I was totally all in on utilities for the classic

1:35:09Mac OS that let you completely reskin the whole OS. There was the iron extension. There was one

1:35:16from the same Greg Landweber that made it look like the BOS where you had those yellow

1:35:22folder tab style windows. And then there was, I forget what it was called, where you had all,

1:35:28you know, just an unlimited number of themes you could download and just completely reskin the

1:35:32whole OS. Oh, I was into that. And I customized my icons and customized everything that you could

1:35:38customize and thought it was cool. And people, you know, younger people, I think especially,

1:35:43are doing that now on iOS with the weird, not weird, but sort of convoluted compared to how

1:35:50easy it could be in theory, if you could just install like an icon pack, but, you know,

1:35:56using shortcuts to open apps and then you can put a custom icon on the shortcut. So therefore,

1:36:01effectively, it's like giving the app a custom icon. I totally get it. And I think that where

1:36:07I'm going is that I think the people who claim to like the new Safari designs exactly as Apple showed

1:36:15them in June. And I, you know, I certainly given how much time I spent writing about Safari on both

1:36:21iOS and Mac, I heard from them. But, and I honestly, you know, tried to give it as open

1:36:27mind as I could. But all I could really hear when I really thought about it is I like this because

1:36:32it's new and novel. And… Jared: Yeah, or aesthetic. Like there were some people who just like,

1:36:36looked clean. It didn't matter how it worked, but it looked clean.

1:36:39Steven: It looked clean. It was sort of a, I like this and it is sort of a design is how it looks

1:36:45mentality. But I think it's really, really telling now that they actually more or less

1:36:52reverted Safari's tabs on both platforms to exactly how they were before. They're not

1:36:58complaining. Right? And you can get the condensed look on the Mac if you really want it. It's in

1:37:05there in preferences. You just don't hear anybody talking about it though. The people who defended

1:37:10it, defended it in my opinion. And in hindsight, it shows in a very shallow way. Whereas those of

1:37:17us who really criticized it were criticizing it in a very deep way. Jared And see, I don't mind

1:37:22if Apple experiments because like, I always go back to the 2015 MacBook. It gave us both the

1:37:28Force Touch trackpad and the butterfly keyboard. Butterfly keyboard was bad. Force Touch trackpad

1:37:33was terrific. Apple tried both. It's the speed of recovery that really matters to me.

1:37:37Steven Right. And I do think that part of that delay in that era was that Apple was sort of

1:37:43internally on the Mac. And I think, you know, the Mac is the one that suffered the longest on a

1:37:48couple of products, you know, bad keyboards on all the MacBooks and non-retina MacBook Air for way

1:37:56too long. I really think that they were caught between knowing that they were going to move away

1:38:01from Intel, but not really being sure what, when the trigger could be pulled. And wanting to save

1:38:09good stuff for the post Apple Silicon era. Anyway, all's well that ends well Safari tabs.

1:38:17Sanity did prevail, thankfully. It is, was very strange and felt like way too close of a call.

1:38:24Because I really don't know if they would have shipped it as they intended early in the summer.

1:38:29I really think I would switch to another browser and I don't know what browser that would be.

1:38:34Steven Yeah, same. Because I like I gave it a shot. I used it as was for the entire beta period.

1:38:42And I was still making mistakes every day. And I shouldn't even have to think about how my

1:38:46browser works. Yeah, it's the end they've done. It's just so it must be so frustrating for some

1:38:51people inside Apple, because they've done such a good job, especially on the phone of designing

1:38:57one of the best iOS apps on the platform period Safari and, and again, not even getting into any

1:39:07of the political arguments about Apple's refusal to allow alternate rendering engines, which is a

1:39:13web platform thing we won't get into. But just as a user interface, it's just really, really good and

1:39:19useful. And it's an amazing team, like the Webkin Safari team is one of the best teams in the world,

1:39:24not even at Apple, but one of the best teams in the world, right? In two different ways, right?

1:39:27Like the team making, you know, the actual underlying rendering engine and JavaScript

1:39:31engine and doing it in a secure way and is doing great work and the user interface,

1:39:38no matter what the engine was, is rendering the actual content, you know, does a great job. And it

1:39:44was all just sort of thrown away for something that somebody thought looked cool and cleaner,

1:39:49some and certainly looked cleaner and more minimal. Yeah, very strange. All right, moving on,

1:39:55we've got August, the only thing I have for August was that, that that's when Apple announced their

1:40:00child safety initiatives. Yeah. Which, you know, it's interesting to me, because like this,

1:40:06this shows the dichotomy of Apple sometimes, because this and I'm blanking on what the other

1:40:10one was, but there's, there are several times where Apple puts together what is objectively

1:40:16like a completely solid engineering solution. Like if you're going to design something that

1:40:22has to achieve these goals, this is the best way to engineer it. But there is a complete disconnect

1:40:28from how emotionally people are going to react to it because we're not entirely rational

1:40:32engineering people. Right. And they got, I think they, you know, it's safe to say they got more

1:40:38pushback than they were probably expecting. And a lot of it, most of it, you know, some of it is

1:40:45philosophical and I get it, which is, hey, this is my device and nothing should be going on, on my

1:40:53device, on device that is going to wind up reporting me to the authorities. You know, I get…

1:41:00Nothing should be exfiltrated without my permission. I get that. I do, except that they

1:41:06were only wanting to do this, that the CSAM fingerprinting against the known database from

1:41:15the national child safety, whatever the organization is. If you're using iCloud photos for sync. So,

1:41:23yeah, I get it that it's on device. I'm sympathetic to that argument, but it wasn't like

1:41:29everybody who uses iOS 15 is going to have this happen, whether you use it or not. It's just sort

1:41:35of like the agreement of using our photo sync service and cloud-based storage is that you're

1:41:43going, your image, the images are going to be matched, the fingerprints of those images are

1:41:47going to be matched against this known database. And if you are uncomfortable with that or don't

1:41:52like it, then you know, you should opt out of iCloud photos. I think the difference was because

1:41:57like everybody does this and that's a horrible thing to say, but everybody does do this, but like

1:42:00Google and Facebook and they all do it on the cloud. So if you turn them off, it's completely

1:42:05gone where when you turn apples off, the code is still there. It's inert, but the code is still

1:42:09there. And I think on a philosophical level, it was a privacy solution, but it defended people

1:42:14on a sanctity level. Right. That's a good way to put it. Right. And if you close your eyes and

1:42:18didn't know which where, where the matching against the fingerprints was going on, you wouldn't be able

1:42:24to tell whether iCloud, you know, Apple solution is doing the fingerprinting matching on device

1:42:31and Google and Facebook and others are doing it on the server side. The end results should be the same

1:42:39it, you know, I get the philosophical aspect of it.

1:42:42My hope, and like, I don't know if they'll do it, but my hope is just to satisfy both,

1:42:46take like that private relay implementation, have the stuff put onto a separate private server,

1:42:52have it checked there and then move to Apple. That way it's not happening on your device. That way,

1:42:56Apple still has zero knowledge. And then hopefully everyone can go back to living in peace and harmony.

1:43:00Yeah. I don't think that's going to, I don't think it's going to work though. Cause I really,

1:43:03and again, I have no inside knowledge of this and I probably among all the teams at Apple,

1:43:09the security team is almost certainly one of the tightest lipped, you know, so it's not going to

1:43:14leak even through a little birdie, but just looking at what Apple wants to happen in the direction of

1:43:21things going, I still think that this whole thing is sort of being motivated by a desire to move

1:43:29eventually all of iCloud to end to end encryption. And in that case, some sort of middleman server,

1:43:36would it wouldn't be possible to have the fingerprinting done there? The most obvious,

1:43:40well, you would layer the whole technical thing, but I think you would layer the,

1:43:42you would layer levels of encryption the same way they do for private relay.

1:43:46Yeah. Yeah. I think you're right. Like when you look at the legacy contacts, the retrieval,

1:43:52cause some of the problems, the problem Apple faced initially with iCloud was that most people

1:43:58losing data is way more common than having data stolen. And people were locking themselves out

1:44:02of all this early two factor authentication stuff. It was one of Apple's biggest support problems.

1:44:06People would just lose their keys and Apple couldn't help you recover. And that is not a

1:44:10good enough answer. So they had to make it so that your backups were fail safe instead of fail secure.

1:44:15But that means that they're subject to subpoena. So now Apple is setting up, like you said,

1:44:19these things where they don't have to worry about actionable material. You can get like,

1:44:25you can assign a contact so that if you lose access to it, Apple can still send something

1:44:29to somebody else. Doesn't have to be them who has access to it. And then they can start locking down

1:44:33the rest of the backups. Right. I, and I really do think that that's where they're going. And I

1:44:38really, I know you and I have talked about this, you know, but it re you and I both have sources

1:44:44who work in Apple retail who very, you know, it's nonstop over the years that is a constant problem

1:44:49of people who forget their password. Can't get their stuff, their phone, you know, they left it

1:44:54in a cab and now it's gone. And that's where all their photos were, but they don't know their

1:44:58I got a dummy thing. I locked myself out of Dropbox when they first set up 2FA. It's,

1:45:02and being able to say, I trust this other person or these two people completely, I trust them.

1:45:10That's how much I trust them, you know, like a spouse type situation. Or if for an older person,

1:45:16like my parents that they trust me, they could list both me and my sister, you know, as, as

1:45:21trusted people who could help them do this. And then it ties in with the legacy contact thing too,

1:45:26for, you know, when they die. But I do think that that's where Apple's going. And I kind of feel

1:45:33like what they regret is not having had the foresight way back when to engineer iCloud,

1:45:41if they could do it all over again, I'm, I'm quite sure of it, that they would engineer iCloud to do

1:45:47everything other than email and end encrypted all along. And email being the exception, because

1:45:53that's the nature of the IMAP and SMTP protocols is that it can't be end to end encrypted.

1:45:59Jared: And PGP is onerous on a user.

1:46:01Pete: Yeah, well, that's, and it's still the protocol isn't end to end encrypted, right? Like,

1:46:05you can use something like PGP to get strong encryption for your email, but stuff like the

1:46:11email headers, even with PGP, the email headers aren't, you know, the subject line is still out

1:46:16there in the open, the recipients are still out there in the open. It's just the nature of email.

1:46:21So, you know, this is not even get into it, this is put an asterisk next to email. But I know this

1:46:26for a fact, having spoken to multiple people who were involved with it, that I message that was

1:46:30part of the, you know, like day one, let's build our own messaging thing to sort of replace SMS,

1:46:36day one on the whiteboard, end to end encryption for everything. Let's, let's engineer this in a

1:46:43way so that if law enforcement says we would like to have this, we can't get it. We can't, we can

1:46:48just say we can't give it to you. Right now, and that is true for iMessage, the big escape hatch

1:46:54right now is iCloud backup, because iCloud backup is not end to end encrypted. And so, like when the

1:47:01FBI goes to Apple with a warrant and says we would like so and so's, you know, iMessages for this

1:47:09warrant and here are the reasons and Apple looks at the warrant and says, okay, that's good. They,

1:47:14they give them, they can give them and have to now because of the warrant, their iCloud backup and

1:47:18the iCloud backup contains their iMessages. So, it's not that the FBI has access to iMessage,

1:47:24they can't, it's end to end encrypted, but iCloud backup, which contains iMessage content, isn't,

1:47:31I think they would like it to be. And I think…

1:47:32Jared: And you can turn it off, but again, for most people, they care more about losing their

1:47:36messages than they do about getting them subpoenaed.

1:47:38David: Right. And this is one of those things that Apple is so good at having their eye on the long

1:47:42game, you know, and Apple Pay is a perfect example of this where there is no way Apple Pay was going

1:47:47to be an overnight success. It just, it's just not the way things work, right? But it's a slow,

1:47:53steady, incremental, more and more places accept it, more and more people will get comfortable

1:47:58using it. There, it's a long game. The, moving all of iCloud to end in encryption, if that's really

1:48:04their plan, and I really hope it is, is like a 10-year thing because you've got to wait,

1:48:08you know, all right, I'm an early adopter. Let's say they do it for iOS 16 next year. I don't know,

1:48:15that's to say optimistically. And I upgrade to iOS 16 right away. Well, anybody who I'm sending

1:48:20iMessages to who's still on iOS 15 and is still backing up their stuff that way is still using

1:48:26the iOS 15 iCloud backups. You've got to wait for everybody to get to the new thing so that everybody,

1:48:34including the people you're sending stuff to, I think that's where they're going.

1:48:37There's an optimistic scenario where if, let's say you're not really,

1:48:42you don't like this fingerprinting CSAM thing. You don't want Apple to do it.

1:48:47There's an optimistic scenario where maybe right now, because I think it's mostly political,

1:48:52and I know people hate politics, but I think it's about political cover where they can say,

1:49:00let's say they move iCloud photos to end-to-end encryption and law enforcement and politicians

1:49:06say, well, this is going to be a haven for child pornography and people who spread it.

1:49:11And this, you know, it's insidious, it's more widespread, you know, it is a serious problem.

1:49:17It's a serious problem around the world. That and terrorism or whatever, everyone brings up all the

1:49:20time. Right. But the CSAMs and Apple could say with the fingerprinting thing, well, here's what

1:49:25we're doing about it. We're checking all these things before we do it. If it had gone without

1:49:30any protest at all, and they hadn't delayed it, whatever. That's, I think that's why they're

1:49:35doing is for political cover to allow end-to-end encryption for the overwhelming majority of users

1:49:42who are, have no involvement with CSAM material at all. The current state though is maybe, you know,

1:49:49not so bad where they're, you know, and I know that they updated their child safety webpage

1:49:55last week or the week before to remove mention of that, of the fingerprinting stuff and only talk

1:50:02about the stuff that's actually shipping now in iOS 15.2 or .1? Where are we up to? I forget. I

1:50:09don't even know the… 15.3. Are we up to… I'm on the beta. Well, whatever. I'm on the head.

1:50:14But the other features, the one like for opt-in feature for kids in an iCloud family account to

1:50:21have the parents turn on a thing to let the kid get warned if they are sending or receiving

1:50:26messages that machine learning identifies as being sexually inappropriate. They adapted that to

1:50:34complaints very, in a very good way where they took off the feature that would, you know, that

1:50:39would optionally allow parents to be notified whenever it happens instead. It's all about the

1:50:44kids for their safety because they might be in a dangerous situation at home. It's opt-in

1:50:51nobody gets it turned on by default for their kids. But if you're worried about it and you

1:50:56want the feature, you can turn it on for your kids. I think it's a good feature.

1:50:58The other feature that they updated and released and I think was completely uncontroversial

1:51:05was updating Siri's ability to help you if you're having some, you know, different types of

1:51:12crises. Like if you're, feel like you're being abused and need help and that sort of thing and

1:51:19give you contact information, you know, don't try to get your help from Siri, but Siri will

1:51:24tell you here, contact this organization and they'll get you help. Uncontroversial, that's

1:51:29shipped. And that's… And I'm just spitballing, sorry. Well, that's what, that's the, it's a

1:51:34very Apple-like thing to do, to update the page to talk about here's what's shipping and not talk

1:51:38about what might still be coming. But when the press, people in the media asked, they did not

1:51:43say we've abandoned that. It's just in limbo. No, and they're a very, like, again, they're a

1:51:50very focused company and their job is to solve these problems. And I'm just spitballing here

1:51:55because you have anything that you can think of on a podcast or a YouTube video, Apple's had the

1:52:00money and time to prototype, but there could also be like, just to a sway, I'm trying to think about

1:52:04what people's complaints are and to assuage them. It could be that there's a regular version of

1:52:09photos and an online version of photos. And if you opt into iCloud photos, it downloads the

1:52:13online version. If you opt out, it downloads the regular version. And then you don't have that

1:52:16code on your, if having that code on your device is a problem for you and you worry about it being

1:52:21abused or any of a number of things, you have like the inert version or you have the active version.

1:52:26And then there's nothing really to complain about because you're having the choice there.

1:52:29Yeah. Anyway, my hope is that maybe by running this CSAM fingerprinting up the flagpole,

1:52:36having it shot down by some advocates for various reasons and saying, okay, well,

1:52:44back to the, we're, we're going back to the drawing board with it, but we've thought about it.

1:52:48It might give them cover cause it's neither canceled nor shipping.

1:52:53Yes. And it's Schrodinger's feature.

1:52:55Right. It's a Schrodinger feature and it could stay there for a while, you know, until people,

1:53:00it just, you know, maybe end to end encryption for photos ships and, you know, anybody who says,

1:53:06hey, but what about a CSAM material? Apple can say, you know, we've told you, you know,

1:53:10what's on the drawing board, but we're still working on it.

1:53:13We're soliciting feedback.

1:53:14Yeah. We're soliciting feedback and maybe they just solicit feedback indefinitely.

1:53:18Yeah.

1:53:19Right. But that they tried, right. And they could say, look, they're, you know,

1:53:22op-eds even in the New York Times from esteemed people whose feedback we value and we're still

1:53:28considering it. And maybe, you know, because it's neither canceled nor shipping, it can sort of stay

1:53:33in that state forever and serve their needs politically while also not triggering anything

1:53:41that actual privacy advocates and people concerned about the feature being abused or being buggy or

1:53:48whatever their concerns are, you know, placate them as well. So let's see.

1:53:51And I don't want to derail us, but Apple is also navigating a climate where you have a lot of

1:53:55countries, not just China demanding data repatriation, not wanting their citizens' data

1:53:59stored on US or other servers. You have a bunch of countries, including Australia trying to

1:54:03propose laws against encryption, just trying to make everything open. So Apple has to navigate

1:54:08all those things at the same time.

1:54:09Yeah. Yeah. Well, and it's the, it probably will never stop, but the politician's wish is for a

1:54:16magical form of encryption that has a key for good guys that won't work for bad guys.

1:54:23It'll burn the hands of bad guys that try to touch it.

1:54:25All right. On to September and Apple is back at it big month. Their big annual event went off

1:54:32and they announced all of the iPhones 13, the new iPad mini iOS 15 and watch OS 8 shipped

1:54:40and Kevin Lynch takes over Titan OS.

1:54:43Yeah.

1:54:45Let's start with the Lynch thing. The Lynch thing is interesting because, and I've mentioned this

1:54:52a couple of times in recent weeks, but there's a big difference. You know, Apple's supposed

1:54:58to upcoming new platforms are, well, maybe three, but there's AR and VR, which are very different

1:55:05things. If you really think about, you know, VR where it's goggles that obstruct your view,

1:55:11if they're off, you know, and there's rumors that they're going to have cameras so you could see

1:55:15through, but that's, that's not the same as actually seeing as opposed to mixed reality.

1:55:20Right. As opposed to plans to make actual regular eyeglasses that you see through with, you know,

1:55:25possibly corrective lenses, if you need them, that would project, you know, or some sort of user

1:55:31interface in your field of vision. But let's just say, I can describe it like for people who aren't

1:55:37sure what all it means is like, think of the Apple VR headset as a personal Apple TV, where it's

1:55:41really immersive and you have the same like Apple fitness, TV shows, video games, all like all that

1:55:47kind of content, music concerts, and then think of the glasses, like an Apple watch that's on your

1:55:52face instead of your wrist. And it's all about convenient notifications layered on top of reality.

1:55:56Right. That's a good way to put it. But let's say that's one product, AR/VR, and then there's

1:56:01Titan OS, the autonomous car slash whatever else might be autonomous. Titan has been through,

1:56:08has been tumultuous. And that's just what we know on the outside. Lord only knows what people on the

1:56:13inside have seen, but just knowing what we've known from the outside, you know, we've, you know,

1:56:18so-and-so's running it. They're gone. Let's bring Bob Mansfield back and, you know,

1:56:24Jared: We cheer to Mansfield, to Giannandrea.

1:56:26Pete: And on the software side now, Kevin Lynch is in charge as of September. And

1:56:34I think that there's a couple of aspects to this. Number one, he's done a terrific job with watch

1:56:41OS. Watch OS has been regular. It has been improved steadily, but I also think it's a sign

1:56:49of, you know, watch OS is mature, right? I'm not saying that it's done, you know, in the same way

1:56:55the Mac, which started in 1984 is not done and is still having new releases and there's new features,

1:57:01but it's, it is cemented as what it is. Right. And it's incremental here, henceforth. Right. And if

1:57:10Kevin Lynch has proven himself to be a successful manager and executive of a nascent platform that

1:57:21is completely liquid and isn't cemented yet and really needs to be bootstrapped from nothing to a

1:57:29shipping project, it seems like that's, this is the time for him to move because, well,

1:57:34Jared; It's so interesting too, because like, I don't know if it's a one-to-one thing, but

1:57:37the previous big hire at Titan was Dan Dodge, who was CEO of QNX, which was like a real-time

1:57:43operating system. And that seemed very like foundational to what this had to be, where Kevin's

1:57:49got this amazing talent for taking incredibly complicated things like health technologies,

1:57:53fitness technologies, communication technologies, and making them incredibly easy to understand and

1:57:58glance at in like a watch in very small amounts of time. And that seems like a much higher level,

1:58:03much more human part of the software experience. Yeah. And it's a, you know, it's a famous Steve

1:58:08Jobs axiom, but real artists ship. And Kevin Lynch during his stint at Apple so far has proven

1:58:15himself to be a real artist in that regard. And Titan seemingly could use a little bit of that.

1:58:22So I tend to think that it is, you know, and I know that ostensibly, WatchOS is still under

1:58:32Lynch's in the hierarchy too. But I can't help but think that it's not a 50/50 thing for his attention.

1:58:38You know, that… Well, Evan Dahl took over the health component. He has a little bit less on

1:58:42his plate, but they're all over, over. Their plates are all very full. Right. Which is not

1:58:46a minor part of the watch software efforts. Right. It's a major, major part. So I think that's

1:58:53interesting. iPhone's 13, iPad mini. iPad mini, I don't have much to say. It's nice. I'm glad

1:58:59it's still there. It's a fascinating product. Going back to what we were talking about with the

1:59:03Mac, you know, the timeline for iPad mini updates has always been multi-year. It has never been even

1:59:11close to an annual product. It's like, you know… No, it's, yeah, even less than the iPad Air.

1:59:15Right. Not saying something. Right. It's like, you know, even if it's perfectly on time and

1:59:18didn't miss, is shipped right on schedule, it's like an every three or four year thing.

1:59:23It was April 2019 and then September 2021. Well, that's like two plus years.

1:59:29Yeah. Two and a half years. I wouldn't be surprised if this one lasts more than two years,

1:59:33honestly. What more do you want? It's great. The only controversial thing was that they moved the

1:59:36display drivers to the side and that made it, when you looked in portrait orientation, you could see

1:59:40the refresh rate scrolling more than you could on previous versions. Yeah, but people seem to have

1:59:45piped down about that. I defer to my son whose eyes are both young and excellent and he's

1:59:53very, very picky about frame rates and stuff like that. And even he was like, "Eh, I see it. Yeah,

2:00:01but it's all right." You know, and you kind of have to do it on purpose. It is interesting

2:00:05and it is true and it speaks to Apple's high standards for displays and scrolling and stuff

2:00:10that none of their other products or very few of their products have anything even close to that

2:00:15sort of… Well, if you put them under a high-speed camera, they all do it. That's the thing. That's

2:00:20how displays work. It's just this one people could catch on faster. Right. And it was perceptible to

2:00:26at least some people's naked eyes, but not mine. The iPhone's 13. I don't have a lot to say.

2:00:32Tremendous battery life. Tremendous battery life. I will say that. I forgot to charge mine. And it's

2:00:36on two. I was like, "Why is my iPhone at 30%?" And I realized I hadn't charged it in two days.

2:00:39It really is true. And it's interesting. There was… I'll tie in a… What are we up to? The A15?

2:00:48There was… I don't want to throw the guy under the bus and I forget his name, but somebody who's

2:00:52a purported chip expert right after the keynote had a very widely circulated medium post saying

2:00:59that Apple's run out of steam on silicon and the brain drain from employees who've left to other

2:01:06companies. It's obviously… I mean, no surprise that Apple silicon engineers are in demand given

2:01:15the tremendous success that they've had. But that now this is the year where it's caught up to them.

2:01:20And now they've got flat performance year over year because they're not bright. Based on the

2:01:26proof being that they didn't brag about year over year performance improvements and only brag during

2:01:32the keynote about performance against their unnamed competitors on the Android side. But

2:01:37turns out A15 is pretty much in line performance wise with the increases we've seen in previous

2:01:43years. But even with that… It turns out when AnandTech gets their hands on it and does an

2:01:47actual review. Right. But even with that, even with the fact that the CPU and the GPU

2:01:52and the neural engine have all improved year over year at an impressive clip,

2:01:59clearly the main thrust of the A15 was battery life improvement. I mean, it's the most dramatic

2:02:08difference, right? And to me, just say this, and we can even move on is the fact that the iPhone

2:02:1413 mini gets better battery life than the iPhone 12 regular. There you go.

2:02:23Jared: The only thing I'd like to add is like, there was two things that bothered me. One was

2:02:27the glee in which people jumped onto that, you know, narrative. Like even people in the Apple

2:02:32community were like, "Haha, this is the end of the road for Apple," which was really a weird look

2:02:36for me. But also, like when you actually look at the industry, Qualcomm just announced famously,

2:02:41they have these junkets every year where they fly everybody to Hawaii and announce their processors

2:02:46for the next year. Those processors still aren't great IP. Like compared to what Apple's doing,

2:02:50they're still two years behind. And that's with the people from Nuvia that they say, like there

2:02:56was no brain drain from Apple. That's a complete narrative fabrication. Some people left, but that's

2:03:00a incredibly deep bench on Apple Silicon team. That didn't help Qualcomm. And they're still

2:03:05saying, well, maybe they need to do more of it, like inject more of that. Like, it's not provable

2:03:10either way. And that just makes the entire story that much more galling to me to begin with.

2:03:14Pete: Yeah, it's always, you know, be careful. Be careful whenever you read an article that

2:03:21is telling you what you want to hear. Right? You should always second, you know, take a step back.

2:03:26Jared. Or look at the numbers. Like, I think what part of the bigger problem is that it's really

2:03:30hard. Like I call it a benchmark LARP. But people are pretending to do benchmarks. It's really hard.

2:03:36Like it takes the best expert that Anantech, a lot of incredible hand coding to get even the

2:03:41surface level stuff that they admit that they get. And most people don't know what's hitting

2:03:45an efficiency core versus a performance core. Like the efficiency cores are 30% faster this year.

2:03:50And the performance cores are way more efficient. The graphics cores are phenomenally faster,

2:03:55but people don't know when they're hitting a graphics core or a rendering engine. And they

2:03:59just throw up these numbers as if they mean something and then everyone writes a bunch

2:04:03of articles and it's suboptimal. That's my rant, Joe.

2:04:06Pete: Another good year for the camera team. And I moved, I spent 2020 with my, for the first time

2:04:15ever, did not buy a top of the line iPhone. I bought the iPhone 12 regular. And because,

2:04:21you know, and I was correct, I probably wouldn't really need the camera much. And that what I was

2:04:25missing was of course the 2X camera that the iPhone 12 Pro had. And I bought it mainly for

2:04:30how the device felt. And, you know, again, it's that privilege of having them all to review and

2:04:35spend time with and not just talk, you know, feel for five minutes while it's tethered to a table

2:04:41in an Apple store. This year though, the camera stuff was overwhelming and I bought the 13 Pro.

2:04:47I will say this several months in now of daily iPhone 13 in my pocket, my opinion on the hand

2:04:54feel of these devices remains unchanged. I really don't like it. I don't like the feel of the

2:05:00stainless steel band. I think that the buttons feel too sharp. I feel the steel band overall

2:05:06is a little slippy and I do not like the frosted matte back because it is slippery. It is, has no

2:05:15grip, no tack at all. I would pay extra to get an iPhone 13 Pro with the camera, with the aluminum

2:05:24body and glossy glass back of the regular iPhone 13, which isn't sticky but has the tackiness,

2:05:32like I've often said, of like a clean basketball court and that, you know, your fingers, you know,

2:05:38grip it the way that sneakers, clean sneakers on a clean basketball court make the squeak,

2:05:43you know, and you get traction. I find it. So, this is the first time in all the years of iPhone

2:05:49where I use a case on a daily basis simply because I really, and I just tried it last week at like

2:05:56Christmas, like let me try going caseless again, which I would like to do. I'm not even going

2:06:01many places with the COVID stuff. I'm not like locked in, but I'm not going many places. I don't

2:06:06need to protect it. I just find it unpleasant in my hand. I really do. It's my biggest disappointment

2:06:12with it. And my biggest hope for next year is that the pros go to, you know, there's rumors they

2:06:18might go to titanium. That would be great. I love the feel of titanium. But also that sandwich again,

2:06:23like the iPhone 4, which would be nicer. Yeah. I find it looks better but feels worse. Like if

2:06:29I just look at it, it looks phenomenal. The design, again, is one of those retro designs,

2:06:33but it doesn't feel great. And the other issue I have is I love that they have this new ceramic

2:06:38shield glass because I drop it all the time and it's never once broken or cracked on me. Like,

2:06:43I drop it all the time. But the reason I drop it all the time is because it's so slippery. It

2:06:47falls off everything. Like it's not Pixel 6 slippery. That falls off flat tables. I don't

2:06:52know how it does it, but it does. This still falls off almost everything. And the way that

2:06:57chemically treated glass and ceramics work is the better the shatter resistance, the worse the

2:07:04scratch resistance because one is hardness and one is toughness. It's like, I'm going to get this

2:07:08wrong, but it's like you can scratch a hammer with a diamond, but you can smash a diamond with a

2:07:11hammer. And I would love if Apple would make a way tackier phone that didn't fall as much because then

2:07:17they wouldn't need as much shatter resistance and they could increase the scratch resistance again

2:07:22because I also scratch them all the time. Pete: Yeah. So, that's my big wish for 14 is,

2:07:26yes, I would like to go caseless. I would like to be pleasant in my hand, which includes both

2:07:32not feeling too sharp or glossy and having a back that, you know, my hands have some tack on to as

2:07:39opposed to this crazy matte finish, which does look nice, but is for a flat surface, just not good,

2:07:49in my opinion. I have one other beef and I know everyone's going to yell USB-C. I don't care.

2:07:53USB-C is just a plug. I'm happy with lightning as a plug, but it's still USB two speeds. Like

2:07:59the letters are the plug shape. The numbers are the data transfer rate. And we have ProRes video

2:08:04on which is six gigs a minute. And I shoot ProRes video and I've got to use USB two speeds in 2021

2:08:10to pull that off. And I can't believe Apple made a chip that is so good at recording every frame

2:08:15of ProRes video, a storage controller that can record it all, but not an IO system that will let

2:08:20me transfer it off even over like lightning 2.0 or whatever at USB three speeds or faster.

2:08:26Pete: Yeah. I never shoot ProRes, but I add the same. I've mentioned this before, but

2:08:30I do shoot 4k and I shoot the, and who knows if it'll be remote this year, but two years in a row,

2:08:36my remote interview with Apple executives and we want to get it in editing as soon as possible and

2:08:43getting 90 minutes of 4k footage off the phone is really, really bad. So again, let's talk,

2:08:52it's not the technology, USB-C and stick it on the phone. It's let's solve the problem. The problem

2:08:59is you've made these cameras that shoot incredibly great video, but that video is humongous,

2:09:06including ProRes, which is super humongous. And you've made this thing, which is amazing.

2:09:13Truly. It's amazing that you could shoot ProRes video on these things and it looks good.

2:09:18Jared: It's like a Mac Pro from 2019 in my hands in 2021.

2:09:22Pete But you've got to, you know, there's anybody who's shooting ProRes for a good reason,

2:09:28as opposed to just stumbled into and wonders what the preference is. But if you're shooting

2:09:32it for a good reason, you want to get it off the phone. All right. That's got to be high on the

2:09:38list. They have to know this. They have to know this, hopefully. Well, there's that rumored like

2:09:4280 gigabit per second wireless transfer speed, but have that land the same year as ProRes.

2:09:47I would just appreciate that. What else? That's it for the hardware. Let's see.

2:09:51Should we talk, I guess, iOS 15 and watch OS 8? I mean, we might as well, they shipped in September,

2:09:57right? Jared: Yeah. Live text was the big highlight for me.

2:10:00Pete Yeah, absolutely. It's really, and I, every once in a while, I run into a spot in a certain

2:10:06app or something where it doesn't work and I'm like, what the hell, app name, you know, let's get

2:10:12with the program. Jared But that video of the kids using their iPhone to steal the kids' notes in

2:10:15front of them at school is just perfect. Pete Oh, yeah. Oh, my God. It's really terrific.

2:10:18I don't really have much to say about iOS 15. It's a solid release. I think, I know Joanna had

2:10:26in her newsletter, not her column recently, had a thing commenting about Apple's dot releases. And

2:10:32she wasn't complaining about it, but just observing that the, you know, in recent years,

2:10:36the new way of being an iPhone user is that throughout the year, you get software updates

2:10:42and some of them introduce new features so that, you know, it's not just a once a year thing where

2:10:46you figure out if you really want to stay on top and you've got to figure out where and how to use

2:10:52new features throughout the year. I think that Apple has found its footing and its pace on this

2:10:59and it is a very sustainable, both a schedule and a strategy and that they've sort of,

2:11:08not that they've given up, ideally they'd like to have as many tent pole features that get announced

2:11:14at WWDC ship in September in the dot O of the new big release as possible, but that they're

2:11:21just completely rational about looking at the state of where these features are and letting

2:11:30them ship when they are. And, you know, it's certainly an art form to look at those features

2:11:36in May while they're planning WWDC and figure out, well, this definitely won't be available

2:11:44in September, but we should be able to ship this in, you know, let's say February and being right

2:11:51about it, you know, like they, you know, I don't think they've missed anything. I don't think

2:11:55they've had like X is coming announced at WWDC and gone a whole calendar year without it.

2:12:02No, like, usually, well, a couple of quick things. One is this has always happened, like,

2:12:07but previously it was easier to digest because Steve would come out and announce the new iPod

2:12:11touch and there'd be a couple updates associated with that, which would go into the point one.

2:12:15And then he'd announce the iPad and there'd be a couple updates associated with that,

2:12:19that would go into the dot two or dot three. So just, they never spoke about them until they

2:12:23were ready to go into those point releases. But some really big things have gone into the point

2:12:27releases all along. And the other thing is, I think it's just how Apple has been managing this.

2:12:33Like the, they used to have bigger lists because there was so much more to do. Now the lists are a

2:12:38little bit slower and you get to the point where you have things like universal control, which

2:12:41isn't going to ship. And I think we ran into this with a HomePod too, is that there are fundamental

2:12:47problems with core technologies that are just old, like the original AirPlay and Core Audio

2:12:51turned out they couldn't handle the HomePod. So Apple had to go back and rewrite, make AirPlay 2,

2:12:56redo a bunch of core technologies just to support the HomePod. And I think a lot of the stuff now is

2:13:01they're going back and repaying technical debt and it's making shipping those features take longer

2:13:05than they originally anticipated it would. I agree with that. I think that, I think they're on a

2:13:10really good, they're, they're in a good place annual schedule wise on these features. I really

2:13:16do think so. October, I'm ready to move on October. We actually got our hands on hardware, Apple Watch

2:13:21Series 7. I don't have a lot to add. I'll put links in the show notes to my review and your

2:13:27review on your YouTube channel. The weirdest thing was that flat edge design that leaked. That's

2:13:31probably like next year's. I think you said SE, someone else said that's going to be the, the rest,

2:13:37not the rustic model, the, the, the expedition model, the action model, right? The, the action

2:13:43model. Yeah. Extreme model. And they just leaked a year early. No, I think I stand by my prediction.

2:13:48It's a, and again, no little birdies whatsoever. I think that that's the new SE because I think

2:13:55Apple wants the SE to look different than the flagship model. And I think it is easier to

2:14:02communicate to customers that this is the entry priced model or the lower tier if it looks distinct

2:14:15like that. I don't think it would look bad if that flat thing ships, but it does not look as good,

2:14:20you know, and there are no, there's, there's just no way they're going to abandon this. And I know,

2:14:24and again, there's that the people who wanted it to ship and were disappointed that it shipped and

2:14:29really latched on to the people who were saying that the, the actual series seven that we have

2:14:36was like a last minute scrap, you know, that doesn't happen. No. Well, and it doesn't make

2:14:42any sense that, that the, that they couldn't make an aluminum chassis with flat sides and had to

2:14:48abandon it, but they could make the screen bigger and go closer to the edges and reduce the bezels.

2:14:53And the impact resistance. Right. And impact resistance, like that's the hard thing. They

2:14:58could put it in whatever shape case they wanted to, you know, I just think it's a branding thing

2:15:04or a product marketing thing, whatever you want to call it. And that they, by making the SE look

2:15:08different, it would establish the SE as its own thing at a lower price. You know, sort of exactly

2:15:16the way that the non-pro iPhones look different. They aluminum looks, does not look shiny. It looks

2:15:24matte and you know, the back was a 249 iPad. Like it's visually distinct, visually distinct in a way

2:15:30that the current iPhone SE is not, even though it doesn't have the big display like the series seven.

2:15:37I will say this, I, again, this is almost the curse of being a product reviewer.

2:15:43I owned a series five, which I really, really, I jumped on because I really wanted the always

2:15:49on display skipped series six because the real, the main thing I saw on the series six was that

2:15:54the always on part was brighter and I didn't care about paying for that. And I planned on skipping

2:16:00this year's too, but living with the review unit for two weeks, I really got used to the bigger

2:16:05display and the battery life. Again, the other thing with this watch, it's very much in line

2:16:12with the iPhone 13, the battery life is much larger. I can forget to charge my Apple watch

2:16:18on a day and wear it to bed and it still gets through the next day.

2:16:21And the always on is much brighter. I find I use that a lot. Like I'm looking at it right now and

2:16:26I can see it just by glancing down. I couldn't. I did too. And I took off after like two weeks with

2:16:30the review unit, I went back to my series five and I was like, this thing is the battery's dying all

2:16:35the time. It's just dead. Exactly the same thing. And it's not bad. Yeah. And the series and my

2:16:40series five didn't have like a depleted battery. It's the same battery, you know, maybe it's like

2:16:45at 95% or 93% or something like that, but it's effectively the same day-to-day battery life I

2:16:50was getting up until I started reviewing the series seven. But once I got a taste of the series seven,

2:16:55I was like, ah, now I got to place an order for a series seven. So I got the series seven,

2:16:59very happy with it. Same. Exactly the same. What was the other one? What else do we have?

2:17:04The MacBook pros. Oh, I forgot. How could I forget the MacBook pros? Holy hell do I love

2:17:10my, my M one max MacBook pro. Oh my same. Yeah. I don't, again, there's three things about it that

2:17:19really like sold it for me. One is that it's just fast. Like I press render on a video.

2:17:23I go to get coffee and it's done so fast that I sometimes think I forgot to press render,

2:17:28which is like, it is so much faster. The other thing though, the two things that surprised me,

2:17:33one is like an iPad is just instant. Previously I would like drag a special effect. It would,

2:17:38it would snowball, it would, it would beach ball. And I'd have to do that every time. Now I live a

2:17:42life almost entirely without beach ball. So it doesn't just save me minutes. It saves me seconds

2:17:47within every minute. And the last thing that surprised me was because it's got separate

2:17:52rendering engines on my old Intel MacBook, I would press render and then I could barely use Safari

2:17:57because everything was being done on the CPU, like much less Photoshop. Now I press render. It's all

2:18:02offloaded to those engines. And I have like another whole Mac that I can use to do anything

2:18:07else with at the same time. And that's just completely revolutionized my workflow.

2:18:10John Greenewald And the fans don't come on.

2:18:12Jared I mean, yeah, it's cold in Canada now, John,

2:18:15I used to use my MacBook as a heat blanket as a space heater.

2:18:18John Greenewald It's really phenomenal. I swear, I know it's the placebo effect. I know it. Well,

2:18:23I don't know. I could be wrong, but I'm 98% sure it is the placebo effect. But I swear to God,

2:18:30the keyboard feels better because the well is black. And it looks better. It looks

2:18:35Jared It has to.

2:18:37John Greenewald It looks better. I do wish, I wish that they would just anodize the whole thing black

2:18:43like that. I would love to have a black MacBook Pro, just black as black as the well of that

2:18:48keyboard. But we don't.

2:18:50Jared Matt black all the things.

2:18:51John Greenewald Yeah, Matt black all the things. But man, I do love typing on that thing. I do love

2:18:58the display. The notch, total non issue. I was done with that notch. I think I said this recently,

2:19:04too, on another episode. But I was way I think maybe with Joanna, but I took me way longer to

2:19:10get used to the notch on the iPhone 10 than the notch on the the MacBook. Yeah, honestly,

2:19:17and I really thought and I know that that was like a late breaking rumor. I think it

2:19:21like leaked the night before, or two nights before it was one of those things that leaked really,

2:19:27really late that there you know, there was going to be a notch and I thought that way that's the

2:19:32dumbest thing I ever heard that would be stupid on the Mac. And it's like, you know what the menu bar

2:19:37is actually kind of a good spot. And as long as the software has some sort of intelligence to move

2:19:41if if something is going to run into it, move it to the other side. It the Mac interface with that

2:19:48iconic, literally, I will not literally, is it literal? I don't know. I'm gonna say it's

2:19:54literally iconic, because there are some icons up there in the menu bar. But yeah, but the menu bar

2:19:59is has been at least a figuratively iconic part of Mac interface right from 1984 onwards. Yeah,

2:20:09it is very different from Windows where there is no menu bar at the top of the screen, their menus

2:20:14are in the windows. It's an it's a good place to do something like that, in the same way that the

2:20:21top of the iPhone screen is sort of a good place to put something like that, you know, like where

2:20:25the iPhone really suffers with the notch is when you go to landscape to watch a video or something

2:20:30like that, or play a game or something like that. It seems weird. It's,

2:20:34Jared: But in both cases, like, I think people forget that it's extra screen real estate,

2:20:38like, if it was still a forehead, we wouldn't have that. Right. So it's just extra space that they

2:20:42can shove status into. It seems, you know, a couple months in, there's no surprises that have come up

2:20:50with these new MacBook Pros. They are every bit as good as we thought they were when we reviewed

2:20:56them one weekend. It is sort of thrilling to see Apple putting the pedal to the metal on and

2:21:05literally applying their absolute best and brightest effort to the Mac and the Mac hardware.

2:21:16You know, it's, you know, for all the doom and gloom over, hey, I don't know, guys, I think

2:21:22Apple's I think Apple's abandoning the Mac. I think they're just going to stick iOS on everything

2:21:26from five or six years ago. Boy, you don't hear that anymore. You really don't.

2:21:31Jared: Well, I know like you did your annual interview with JAWS and Craig. And I got to

2:21:37talk to Tim Millett, the vice president of silicon, and the head of Mac product marketing. Later after

2:21:44these shipped, Tom Boger, sorry, and the amount of love that was just seeping out of every pore of

2:21:51their being for the Mac. And you could see how happy they were with like both the silicon engines

2:21:56that they built, but also with the resurgence of the Mac product line. They were literally beaming,

2:22:01which like you used to see that at WWDC sometimes depending what they're going to announce,

2:22:06but their level of happiness was so high. And that to me is always a good indicator.

2:22:09Pete: Yeah, very much so. And Bogert is great. I've known him for a few years and his,

2:22:14Jared; Yes, he's a lifer.

2:22:15Pete; Yeah, he really is. But it's, and he really, you know, who knows, you know, he's,

2:22:20you know, anybody could get promoted elsewhere or move somewhere else. But his passion for the Mac

2:22:26is palpable, you know, and you know, whether it's officially and on the record or unofficially and

2:22:35off the record behind the scenes, it's serious. I remember, he was the guy I asked him, I asked

2:22:41him at WWDC the year before if I could ride around on one of the Mac Pros with wheels.

2:22:47Jared; Yes.

2:22:48Pete; And he seemed tempted to let me. He said, you know, it could hold your weight. He goes,

2:22:55I don't know that we should do it here though. Jared; No, that's the pro, the pro workflows team

2:22:59gets all the cool Mac Pro slits. Pete; All right, down to home stretch,

2:23:04because there's not much more that Apple did this year. The Mac OS 12 Monterey shipped,

2:23:10I would say, pretty successful, a lot like iOS 15. It's not that they, it's not that they didn't do

2:23:17anything. It's not like, there's not some new features that are cool. But it's sort of steady

2:23:22as she goes, right? It's, you know, Jared; It's just universal control. We're waiting for it,

2:23:25which was the whizbang demo. Pete; Right, that's the whizbang. Yeah,

2:23:28that's obviously next, you know, early next year thing, hopefully. But otherwise, you know,

2:23:34for me, upgrading to Mac OS 12 was, other than taking longer, because when you cross that

2:23:40integer boundary of OS updates, you have, it's like a serious update that turns the screen black

2:23:47for a while and gives you a minutes long thing that you don't get when going from 12.1 to 12.2

2:23:54or something like that. But the end result for me day to day as a user felt much more like going to

2:24:0411.7 or something like that. It doesn't, there's nothing, nothing got broken either software wise

2:24:11or habit wise, right? Jared: It fixed a lot of annoying bugs for me,

2:24:15which is always a plus. Pete; Yeah, that's a good sign. And, you know, and it's,

2:24:18I know that that doesn't sell stuff. And I know that those of us who really clamor, you know,

2:24:24famously, like, you know, it's old enough, old enough now that it was Bertrand Cerlet,

2:24:29who announced it, but the 10.6 Mountain Lion, where they even chose a name going from lion to

2:24:36mountain lion that, you know, and no new features. And meanwhile, there were major new features like

2:24:41Grand Central Dispatch. Jared; Oh, Snow Leopard, yeah.

2:24:44Pete; Or Snow Leopard, Snow Leopard, not Mountain Lion, that's right.

2:24:47Jared; Yeah, Mountain Lion as well, that was the grand tradition.

2:24:49Pete; Right, but Snow Leopard, no, it was Snow Leopard was 10.6, right? I know the number,

2:24:55I confuse the names, but 10.6 was the one where they even had a slide that just like dropped with

2:25:00a cloud of dust, no new features and… Jared; Yeah, cool, because Steve was upset that there

2:25:04weren't a lot of new features to announce. He's like, "Oh, yeah, we're just gonna do no features,

2:25:07that's even better." Pete; But it was like raucous applause from the WWDC audience. And I know the

2:25:13WWDC in-person audience is obviously different from the, the, the mainstream, you know, people,

2:25:22you know, developers who are willing to spend $5,000 for a week to, to, you know, to be there

2:25:30is a different crowd, but it was raucous applause because, and I know that that's not, you know,

2:25:35you can't make commercials like that. You know what I mean? There's no way to put a commercial

2:25:41during football games on Sunday afternoon that says, you know, Mac OS 12, no new features,

2:25:47lots of bug fixes, you know, that the commercial, that commercial doesn't write itself quite the

2:25:52opposite. But, you know, it's what we want, right? You know, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

2:25:57I will say I still haven't turned it off. The one feature that annoys me on the Mac is Quick Note,

2:26:04because for whatever reason, I've got stuff in my lower right corner, I go down there and then

2:26:09every, I've never once wanted to make a quick note on my Mac. And that stupid little window

2:26:16keeps popping up. Yeah, I see. I don't do it on the Mac at all. I do it on the iPad all the time,

2:26:20never use it on the Mac. The thing for me is like, the notifications are still way too persistent.

2:26:25Like they come in, they stay around way too long. They don't like a guest that won't leave.

2:26:29Yeah, that's enough. And then the whole thing comes over again every time. Yeah. And I if

2:26:33there's anything that was surprising to me that didn't get like a real UI, a back to the drawing

2:26:39board, it was the big sir Mac OS 11 notifications. There's there's all sorts of wonky stuff in the UI

2:26:46where like, the regions that you can click on to click on things don't correspond to the actual

2:26:53things you see on screen. You know, some of the I think some of them are smaller, and some of them

2:26:57are bigger and things that just should not happen. Like on time delays. Yeah, it's just weird and

2:27:03does not it feels unfinished, but shipped. And then in Mac OS 12, they didn't really seem to

2:27:10address it. So hopefully that's on the list for Mac OS 13. I don't have much more to say about

2:27:16that, though. Shortcut shipped. That's that's a big deal for those of us who are enthusiasts.

2:27:21Speaking of bad UI, I really thought from well, I'm not surprised. And but but what they showed

2:27:31in June and the first beta, just simple things like when you tell a shortcut to just show an

2:27:36alert with some text, the alert is not a Mac alert. And you can you can complain about the

2:27:43big sir style alerts and say they the actual proper alerts in Big Sur look too much like iOS,

2:27:51and it's not appropriate for the Mac. And I don't like the design. But that's not even what you get

2:27:55with shortcuts, you get this weird little shortcut thing that really, really, if you just showed it

2:28:01to somebody and didn't tell them what it was, they would guess that it was like, some sort of

2:28:07Linux to Mac trans programming platform thing. And yeah, some kind of cross platform thing and

2:28:17that whoever decided what it would look like for the Mac wasn't even a Mac user. And just,

2:28:21you know, there's a button, you know, there's an OK button in the bottom right that says OK, but

2:28:26nothing about the layout of this actually looks Mac like. And I think, you know, I know, you know,

2:28:33I'm far from an expert on shortcuts, although I've gotten more into them than I had before.

2:28:38You know, I'm no Federico. But yeah, or Rosemary Orchard, you know, and they but they've said this

2:28:45at length to like, I think long story short, the problem is shortcuts was the whether they

2:28:53volunteered or not, they were the, the let's dog food Swift UI group. And Swift UI is not still not

2:29:03up to the to the task of being what they wanted to be. But they had gone too far and they'd rewrote

2:29:10everything in Swift UI. And that's what we got. But that's why the like the I think that's why

2:29:16like the alerts don't look standard because the standard alerts aren't in Swift UI. They're in

2:29:21AppKit or UI kit. And they like made their own and Swift UI and did not did not do a great job of it.

2:29:30So there's lots of lots of room for improvement there with shortcuts. But it was announced in a

2:29:35good way where they said this will be a transition from automator to shortcuts and automator is,

2:29:42you know, still there. So you know, it's, you know, let's see where they go in a year, hopefully,

2:29:48you know, make some improvements. I would still like to see them do something where you could

2:29:51do automator steps with a language, you know, and that language could be some sort of cut down

2:30:00version of Swift could just be JavaScript, obviously, but something because there are

2:30:05some things that are just, Oh, man, it would be so much easier to just write a few lines of

2:30:10actual code, if you can write code. And that to me is the one thing automator got right. That's

2:30:16shortcuts doesn't is that automator fundamentally is the same sort of idea where you drag and drop

2:30:22these sort of pre made steps and do the pre programming visually by connecting these things

2:30:31in a visual way without writing code. But if there's ever a time when you need to use code,

2:30:37you can always just add an automator step that calls any scripting language that Mac OS 10

2:30:42supports Apple script, or bash or pearl or Python, or Ruby, I think anything that comes with Mac OS

2:30:5110. It comes with a plethora of Unix style scripting languages plus good old fashioned

2:30:56Apple script. shortcuts could use something like that. Long story short.

2:31:00Jared Ranere just want nodal editors, they just want a nodal editor, you can pack anything into

2:31:02it and chip it.

2:31:03John Greenewald And then the only thing else I have, there was nothing in December, I don't

2:31:09think Apple really had any news in December, other than some of the epic stuff that we talked about

2:31:13before. But in November, Craig Federighi went to Lisbon, Portugal, and spoke at the web summit

2:31:20against sideloading. I thought that was interesting. We talked about sideloading earlier,

2:31:25we don't have to get into the argument. I do think he makes a compelling argument about having

2:31:31a choice between, you know, if legislators around the world say, legally, all platforms must allow

2:31:39sideloading, then somebody who does not want to even use a platform where it's an option,

2:31:45loses the ability to have that choice, you know, and, and,

2:31:48Jared Ranere It's like you said, Jonas has a PS5, if you wanted a gaming PC, you could have that,

2:31:53but you shouldn't force the PS5 to be a gaming PC.

2:31:55John Greenewald Well, he got the gaming PC two years ago.

2:31:57Jared Ranere Yeah, get both. I mean, that's the whole thing, you get to choose.

2:32:00John Greenewald But it is the,

2:32:03Jared Ranere Like us, just get an iPhone and an Android.

2:32:04John Greenewald But the PS, I'll tell you what, even he said the PS5 was so much easier to set up.

2:32:08Jared Ranere Yeah, that's, that's, that's the benefit. Like there are pros and cons to both.

2:32:12I think a lot of times nerds think that there's only cons to the other approach and there's not,

2:32:15because they're, I recently asked what people wanted to see in iOS 16 on Twitter, and 95% of

2:32:22the answers I got were for features that only apply to 5% of the market. And that's the distortion

2:32:26lens of tech Twitter or tech YouTube is that we really are outliers. We're minorities who think

2:32:31that we're the majority and we are not. And it, I do think, and I think Federighi's argument,

2:32:36and I know Apple released a white paper on the same thing back in June, and his talk

2:32:41in November was largely on the same point, but I feel like they've really honed it down. And I

2:32:46think as a talk with Federighi as the person delivering it, it really came across even better.

2:32:52But it really is true that the nerd argument is, hey, if you don't want it, don't turn it on,

2:32:58right? Which is how the Mac works, right? The Mac by default ships a fresh Mac with factory settings,

2:33:05doesn't allow you to install apps from outside the App Store. You have to authenticate as an

2:33:09admin user and then check a checkbox in the security system prefs panel, and then you can

2:33:15install them, you know, whatever apps you want. And that's great for the Mac, because that's the

2:33:20way the Mac was designed. But that's exactly what so many people want for iPadOS and iOS.

2:33:26And the just leave it checked if that's what you want argument. The hole in that argument is that

2:33:33people, some organizations and needs will require you to disable it. And one of the examples that I

2:33:41like to go to are these school proctoring software things where kids taking tests, and it's all come

2:33:49up over the last two years because of kids who were taking school remotely because of COVID.

2:33:53It's awful software. It's truly awful software. And it does terrible things like try to follow

2:34:00the kids eyes where they're looking. And what do you do, though, if, you know, if, if, if iPhone,

2:34:07if iOS were forced to allow sideloading, and your employer required you to install something that

2:34:15turned off the protections, what do you do? You know, it's or government like the same privacy

2:34:21advocates who are so against any of the CSAM scanning governments are going to force people

2:34:25to put they already tried to do that on the DNS level, right? And kids who are going to want game

2:34:29emulators, they're good like Nintendo's, they're not going to care. There's one thing, you know,

2:34:33and look at what Facebook tried to do with the current rules in place where they tried to,

2:34:38you know, overuse the enterprise certificate to get teenagers to install a VPN software.

2:34:48Yeah, that Nova, yeah, that the entire point of which was to allow Facebook to track every single

2:34:55thing they did over the network on their phones to see what what's useful, you know, which is

2:35:00famously how they figured out that WhatsApp was so much more popular than it seemingly was valued at.

2:35:06And, you know, will you know, they were like, we should we should definitely buy this, this is not

2:35:11overpriced. This is look at the data we have from tracking what people actually do on their phones,

2:35:16it's incredibly popular and growing. That's what they did before sideloading was allowed, you know,

2:35:21and that if, if this like, sort of easy sideloading with no friction, and just check a box

2:35:28thing were available, you know, what happens when Facebook starts telling all of their users, hey,

2:35:35if you switch from this, you're using the App Store version of Facebook, if you switch to

2:35:40Facebook's version of Facebook, will give you X, Y, and Z, you know, and people who don't know any

2:35:46better do it. And, you know, next thing you know, your phone's on 23 metaverse credits.

2:35:51Michael sigh on his great web blog had a link. I haven't linked to it on during fireball yet,

2:35:56but I've been meaning to had a link the other day. I think it was a writer or Sarah No,

2:36:01wasn't I right or somebody was talking about it, but somebody had a support thing about it. But

2:36:06you've heard of Grammarly Grammarly is much popular. I say, if you install this is true,

2:36:11if you install Grammarly on your Mac, they write a preference setting that disables the systems

2:36:19spell checking system wide, not just for like the Grammarly app, but any app because Grammarly is

2:36:25somehow supposed to work. I don't know, I've never used the damn thing. But, you know,

2:36:30supposed to work in any app. And then you say, I don't like Grammarly. And then you drag it to the

2:36:35trash and you think you're done with it. But the preference setting is still there. And now you

2:36:38don't have the system spelling checking in any app. Well, that's that is so patently offensive.

2:36:45It's ridiculous. But it's possible on the Mac, right? It's impossible. Grammarly for iOS,

2:36:52if there is a version of Grammarly for iOS can't do that because of the sandboxing.

2:36:56Well, Chrome and their Keystone installer that was causing me a lot of problems and

2:37:00a lot of problems. Right, right. And we never really got to the bottom of that, right? That

2:37:05was still sort of a, it's still sort of a, you know, there's a lot of smoke, but we still never

2:37:10found the fire of how come people were having this bizarre, you know, 30% CPU usage just in

2:37:17the background with Chrome even quit. And then you uninstall Chrome completely and the problem

2:37:23goes away. Yet nobody's figured out what the hell was going on. It's just kind of weird because

2:37:27there were some big brains on the problem. But again, but you can't have a Keystone installer,

2:37:32right? You cannot do it. There's no way to do it. You can't be asked to check a box so that you can

2:37:38allow it. It's just not there. That's a feature. And on the Mac, the fact that you can is a feature.

2:37:44That is why they are different platforms. You know, and there's so few like the thing is like,

2:37:49I understand like there's big nerd love for all of these platforms, but there's so few really

2:37:53mainstream friendly platforms. There's basically iOS and Chrome and yet we covered them. So we want

2:37:58to take them away and make them all nerdy platforms, but that really does a disservice

2:38:02to the 90% of the market that really just wants something that's simple and easy to use. And

2:38:06they've, we've got everything else. We've got windows, we've got Android, we've got Mac iOS,

2:38:09we've got Linux. We've already got all this stuff. Anything else, Renee? It feels like the only big

2:38:16thing that I liked at the end of the year was Apple suing NSO group. Facebook also famously

2:38:21tried to use to get it. Yeah, that is sort of a nice cherry on the top of the new year. Let's hope,

2:38:27wish them success. And boy, the more we learn about the NSO group, the worse they look,

2:38:33number one, the fact that that story that came out a week or two ago that Netanyahu was using it as

2:38:40a calling card in countries like Uganda and like the worst countries on the planet.

2:38:47Boy, that's just awful. And then the details of how their Pegasus exploit actually worked,

2:38:54which are just bananas, you know, that it was… Yeah, you linked to that, right?

2:38:59Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a PDF with a .gif file extension and the PDF contains some sort of

2:39:08obscure late 90s image format that was originally designed for fax machines, but that has a single

2:39:17pass parser just reading from the beginning to the end of the file, but the nature of the file format

2:39:22allowed an entire Turing complete computer, an emulated computer system to be built inside of it

2:39:32is so crazy complicated and as a… forgetting how they used it out in the world, just the fact that

2:39:41they pulled it off is sort of a, you know, hats off to you, clap, clap, clap, this is a magnificent

2:39:49accomplishment, but also, you know, completely used for some of the worst purposes imaginable.

2:39:58So here's hoping, you know, and it does seem bad. I mean, and Apple's lawsuit is not like perfunctory,

2:40:05you know, like sometimes they say, you know, like, "Oh, you know, you got to file, you know,

2:40:10protect a trade." You got to defend your copyright. You got to defend your copyright and you file like

2:40:13a perfunctory, you know, cease and desist or what do they call it on YouTube? The, like with the

2:40:19music. The DMCA. Yeah, DMCA files. And this is not like perfunctory and like somebody low down

2:40:26an Apple legal, like, "Oh, I guess, you know, I, you know, just to, you know, just to tie things

2:40:32off for the Friday, I'll just, busy work, I'll just file this lawsuit against NSO Group." No,

2:40:36they are mad. I mean, they are really mad. And Apple, you're just not used to seeing Apple

2:40:44be mad, right? They're just, this is not their brand, but they are furious, they are furious

2:40:50about this. And I really do think the intent of their lawsuit is to sue NSO Group out of

2:40:57existence. Yep. Good riddance. Yeah, good riddance. Let's wish them luck. And this is one,

2:41:02this is also one of those cases too, where Apple obviously has detractors, people who disagree with

2:41:09their philosophies, people who, you know, just don't like their style. They don't like the

2:41:14control. I haven't seen anybody who's like rooting against Apple in this case. Yes. Everyone's like,

2:41:20"Go, go, go." So, yeah, that was a nice thing to end the year on. It was very nice. And I feel

2:41:26like they're on good ground. I mean, I don't know, you know, what the, I don't know how it's going

2:41:34to turn out. I won't predict it as an Israeli company. What does that mean? What kind of

2:41:39liability do they have? But— They can make the company toxic. I mean, just like through the

2:41:42lawsuit, they can make the company absolutely toxic. Right. Well, and the other thing too,

2:41:45that really, I don't know that it helps the lawsuit, but the other thing too is that the US

2:41:50federal government is also really, really pissed. Like, you know, like the State Department, you

2:41:57know, and the fact that actual state, US State Department employees had this deployed against

2:42:02them. You know, and at one level, if it was like, I don't know, the Chinese or the Russians or

2:42:06somebody who we have an adversarial relationship with internationally, it would be one thing.

2:42:11They'd still be mad. But the fact that the software originates with one of our closest

2:42:17ostensible allies, Israel, is I think the thing that takes this to a different level of pissed off.

2:42:24Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. How many videos do you think you made this year?

2:42:28Oh, I don't know, 100, 150?

2:42:31Wow. That's, I don't know how you do it, René.

2:42:34Maybe more. I got to check.

2:42:35I was on your video page just to go back and get for the show notes and find your reviews of some

2:42:40of the recent products. And I'm like, scroll, scroll, scroll, scroll, just to get to like the

2:42:45iPhone 13. And I was like, that's a lot of videos.

2:42:48Yeah, no, it's a lot. I hit 300,000 subscribers right before coming on the show too, which was

2:42:53really a nice way to end the year.

2:42:54Oh, there we go. Well, you know.

2:42:56371 videos in the last 18 months.

2:42:59Wow.

2:42:59We can do the math.

2:43:00Wow. So that's even more than 158 a year.

2:43:02Yeah.

2:43:03That's quite a lot. Well, keep it up. I enjoy it very much.

2:43:06Anything else you want to, you want to give a shout out to?

2:43:10No, just, it's great to do these every year. I really appreciate it.

2:43:13I do too. You know, we kept it short. You know, we're under the three hour mark.

2:43:16Yes.

2:43:17My thanks to our sponsors. We had, oh, did I do a third sponsor? I don't know that I did.

2:43:23I don't think I did.

2:43:24I don't know.

2:43:24No, I didn't. Oh, well, let me tack it on right now.

2:43:26Dude, let it in.

2:43:27Yeah, no, I'll do it right now. Let's end the show. Tell you about Squarespace. Holy

2:43:31hell, I almost forgot about Squarespace. How could I do that?

2:43:33Hey, make your next move with Squarespace. Make your next website.

2:43:37Squarespace is the all in one website platform. You could build anything you want, a store,

2:43:41a catalog, a shopping site. You could host a podcast. You could host a blog, anything you need.

2:43:48You could do it at Squarespace. They've got great technical support. It is so easy to use.

2:43:54You do it all in a browser. It is WYSIWYG. It is a great place to send your non-technical friends

2:44:00who come to you for help creating a new website or with a crappy old janky website

2:44:05that they want to replace with a new one. Do it all at Squarespace and

2:44:08start at squarespace.com/talkshow. You get 30 days free. There's no watermark on the site during the

2:44:1630-day free trial. It just looks exactly like it would if you were a paying customer. When the

2:44:2030 days are up, you pay. And if you start with that same URL, squarespace.com/talkshow and use

2:44:26that code talk show, when you pay, you save 10% off your first purchase and you can do it for up

2:44:32to a year. So there you go. Squarespace. Almost forgot them. How could I do that?

2:44:36Easily my number one sponsor for the year. My thanks to them for still being here. I'll also

2:44:44thank our other sponsors. We had a Memberful where you can monetize your passion with membership and

2:44:51Linode, the server hosting company. Holy smokes, almost forgot a sponsor.

2:44:57- Second of year, John.

2:44:59- What kind of year, John?

2:45:00(laughing)