Podcast Search

The Talk Show

364: ‘Spooky Hole’, With John Moltz

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I don't have World Cup fever. I'll just say that. I'd like to, you know, I'd kind of,

0:00:03I wish I had World Cup fever, I guess. I don't know. I got so soured on professional sports

0:00:08because of baseball. This is what happens when your team is not so great.

0:00:15Yeah, but the Mariners have gotten good.

0:00:17Yeah, they've gotten better. They've gotten better for sure. But it's been a while though.

0:00:20I mean, it took, it only took 20 years to get back to the playoffs. That's not exactly

0:00:26something that draws your constant attention.

0:00:29You know, it's funny when we were growing up, when you and I were growing up, the two

0:00:32big losers were the Cubs and the Red Sox, right? The teams that hadn't won since like

0:00:40before World War I, the Great War. And they've both since gone on in recent years and decades

0:00:47to win World Series, so they've ended it. But it is funny though. It's like you grow

0:00:51up and it's just in the air. It's just, oh, the Cubs. Well, they never, you know, Cubs

0:00:56and Red Sox, oh, they never win. They'll break your heart if you're the fan. They'll get

0:01:00close. Once every 10 years, they'll get close and then they'll, you know, some weird little

0:01:04however.

0:01:05Yeah, some guy will touch a ball in the outfield.

0:01:09And I just accepted it, you know, that, oh, well, you know, those, especially Red Sox

0:01:13fans, they just love, you know, they love to lose. They're like pigs in mud. They just

0:01:17wallow in it and that's, they just, you know, that's what they want. But then you get older,

0:01:22you hit middle age and you realize, you know, you don't get many 20 year stretches in life,

0:01:29you know, you run out of them.

0:01:32Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah. I mean, that must've been like, you know, I mean, think about how

0:01:36many people grew up and died with those teams being just really not great. That's so, that's

0:01:46so thankless. Yeah. And I, so I just didn't, you know, and I didn't want to be, I stopped

0:01:50paying attention to it because I did, like, I didn't want to be that person, right? I

0:01:53didn't want to be sitting there year after year and I love the game. That's the thing.

0:01:57I love the game, but it's just like, you know, when you've got management that really just

0:02:00doesn't seem to give a crap.

0:02:03I do know, I know several baseball fans. I know them who know, but who really love the

0:02:08game and baseball is an interesting sport to me because you can really love the game

0:02:14and go to see minor league baseball and you know, you pay like seven bucks, you get a

0:02:20great seat. The hot dogs and sodas and beer don't cost, you know, $15. And you get to

0:02:27watch a really, you know, if you just like sitting in a ballpark watching a game, you

0:02:32can pay a lot less money, get a much better seat and you get a really high quality product.

0:02:36Yeah. Particularly now. I mean, we started going to the Rainier's game. We have a great

0:02:41fun anyway, and they actually play pretty well. I think they've won the PCL a number

0:02:47of times and the Rainier's here in town in Tacoma. And we used to take Hank all the time

0:02:52when he was a kid. Cause they, they would let, they lean on in the middle, you know,

0:02:55they do all these wacky promotions, you know, they like roll these big dice down the netting

0:02:58and into the field. And then they, in the seventh inning stretch, they let the kids

0:03:02out on the field to run the bases with the mascot.

0:03:04Oh, that's wild.

0:03:05Yeah. So he and I went, you know, we'd go out on the field and run around the bases.

0:03:08So yeah, so this is super fun. Oh, and then in one year we, you know, you can afford to

0:03:12get like box seats, you know, I mean like, it'll be a little bit expensive, but you

0:03:16could sit right next to the, you know, right on the, we sat on the, right on the third

0:03:19baseline one time and the, you know, it's just as a joke, the visiting, one of the visiting

0:03:25pitchers dugout was right there. Cause it was, you know, or you know, that not the dugout

0:03:29a bullpen. And the, one of the, the visiting pitchers leaned over and pretended he was

0:03:34grabbing my beer. Like, you know, we're, we're like that close cause I'm sitting there and

0:03:41talking to my, I'm talking to Karen and my friends and we're, and, and, you know, Karen

0:03:45goes, Hey, Hey, Hey, she's like looking over my shoulder. Hey, Hey, Hey. And I turn and

0:03:48look and this guy's reaching for my beer. It's like, get out of here.

0:03:55That's funny. There's, it's funny because I'm looking for stuff to laugh at because

0:04:02I'm looking at everything on my list here of things to talk about. One more thing I

0:04:05wanted to plug this because I, I just came up, I forget, I forget. It's not me. It's

0:04:09this, have you seen sleep baseball.com? No, it's a podcast. That is fake baseball announcements,

0:04:18you know, to, to fall asleep to. So it's a game and they do it as if it's a, you know,

0:04:22like it's a real game, but it's not real teams or anything. And the players are all made

0:04:26up. And it's just guy, this guy who speaks like this, here comes Johnson and he takes

0:04:33one loan inside and it's just, you listen for like two and a half, you know, it's a

0:04:37game that's like two and a half, three hours, something like that. And it's just to fall

0:04:41asleep to it. It's great. It's so good. And they have, they have, they, you know, they

0:04:44have crazy ads. Like, you know, one of the players will say, hi, this is Brett McCowensky.

0:04:52And when I was young, we used to do all kinds of crazy things like stand on our heads. But

0:04:58now some of my friends have gotten in trouble with drugs. This, this has been Brett McConskey

0:05:04and that's like the whole thing. That's the whole ad bit, the whole interlude. And then

0:05:10they go back to the game anyway. Oh man. It's fun. I always thought golf, golf announcement,

0:05:17you know, just, just take out the commercials and just regular golf announcement. Yeah.

0:05:22Just have Jim Nantz. Well, they're, they're whispering anyway. Yeah. That's, that's why

0:05:26it's so great. I think that, I think it could help. I think even a golf fan could, you know,

0:05:32fall asleep to listen into golf. Just get some guy with a Scottish accent. Oh man. Lots

0:05:41going on. I, why don't I just start, I'll start, I'm going to start by taking a break.

0:05:45I love this. This is, this is a sponsored, they sponsored the website a couple of weeks

0:05:50ago and I really, I've fallen in love with this app. It's called Sofa. S O F A. Just

0:05:56spell it the regular way. All right. What do you do when you hear about a great new

0:06:01TV show, movie, a book, or even a podcast? We just talked about a podcast. What do you

0:06:07do? You probably scribble it down in your notes or to do app and you might forget about

0:06:11it instead. Throw it in Sofa. Sofa is a dedicated app that lets you create lists of almost anything,

0:06:20but it's meant for stuff like podcasts, apps, books, board games, even movies, TV shows,

0:06:26music albums. You can then use these lists to decide your next book to read, movie to

0:06:31watch or video game to play. The design is inspired by some of today's best productivity

0:06:37apps but focused on helping you to be more intentional with your downtime. You think

0:06:42about it, the tools we use for managing our downtime are designed for work. This includes

0:06:47like to do apps and notes, apps, calendar apps. These are all designed for work. Sofa

0:06:51is deliberately designed for, guess what? When you're on the sofa. It's actually a great

0:06:57name. It's a really, really cleverly designed app and it does because it's meant, you know,

0:07:03you can make lists of anything literally, but it because it knows that you might want

0:07:07to enter stuff like TV shows and movies and books when you go to enter a movie or TV show

0:07:11or book, it can auto complete the list from like a internet movie database source or something

0:07:16like that where it knows what's the name of a movie, what's the name of a TV show, stuff

0:07:21like that. The majority of Sofa is completely free to use. So you could just interrupt the

0:07:27podcast right now, go to the app store, search for Sofa and start using it for free. You

0:07:33can create unlimited lists, sync your data with iCloud, which means it syncs across devices

0:07:40and it's completely private, track your activity and more. If you're looking for a little more

0:07:44power, you can upgrade to Super Sofa. With Super Sofa, you get the ability to customize

0:07:50lists with cover images and descriptions. You can add sticky notes to your items, personalize

0:07:56the look and feel with over 100 different themes. And trust me, I went down this rabbit

0:08:01hole when they sponsored my site. There went an afternoon and a whole lot more. It is available

0:08:10for the iPhone, iPad and Apple Silicon Macs. If you want to start organizing your downtime,

0:08:15head over to Sofa HQ, S-O-F-A-H-Q, SofaHQ.com/the-talk-show. SofaHQ.com/the-talk-show. Download it today.

0:08:29I thank Sofa for supporting the talk show. And seriously, I'm telling you this, it is

0:08:34absolutely sincerely a great native app that you should check out if you're actually enjoy

0:08:41entertaining yourself with stuff like TV and movies. I swear, go check it out. I would

0:08:46recommend this app even if they weren't sponsoring the show. It's that good. Go get it. SofaHQ.com/the-talk-show.

0:08:55In the news this week. Oh my God. Usually there's no news around Thanksgiving. And thanks

0:09:01to our good friend, our very good friend of the show, Mr. Elon Musk. A topic that has

0:09:15already been in my sights because I am a long time Twitter user. I don't know if you recall

0:09:21that. And I enjoy Twitter and I'm very interested in Twitter. So I've been following it and

0:09:27as more or less, he has more or less single-handedly steered the entire Twitter saga directly into

0:09:34the John Gruber wheelhouse. Yeah, it's weird that it's taken this turn

0:09:39at this point, right? That it, yeah. First, first it was just some guy coming in, you

0:09:44know, what's he going to do? And then it's, Oh, this guy is ruining this thing that I've

0:09:48loved for 15 years. And now it's like, Oh, now he's like driving straight into Apple's

0:09:55lane coming the opposite direction. I did predict this. My predictions on this

0:10:00are clearly across the map in terms of how good these bets look given my infamous, I'm

0:10:08more optimistic than ever about Twitter. Which, you know, it's our good friend Cable Sasser,

0:10:15you know, admitted when he was making fun of me and threatening to make t-shirts with

0:10:18the quote that my very next sentence was, but of course it's also very likely he might,

0:10:24something to the effect of that, he might just steer Twitter right into a ditch. But,

0:10:28uh, I did predict though, I predicted last week though, that the app store is going to

0:10:35be a problem for him with the way he's going for sure. And in two ways, and of course,

0:10:42like I will give him credit. At least he doesn't waste time. You know, that's true. I really

0:10:48actually mean this. I would have thought it would have taken a lot longer, but we're here

0:10:52already. You know, and a man who has gone from co-founding PayPal, which I get, all

0:10:58right, let's say that's a long time ago, cause that's like the nineties, but has since made

0:11:04the premier electric car company in the world, or, you know, I know he didn't found that

0:11:09company, which I think is actually important. He has a rocket company that actually has

0:11:14real rockets that do amazing things that no other rockets can do. Now is supposedly started

0:11:24a tunnel company called the boring company, which the, the wall street journal. I don't

0:11:28know. Did you see that story yesterday where they, they sort of had a, Hey, they're not

0:11:32really doing anything except, except getting, uh, municipalities around North America to

0:11:38stop planned, uh, high speed rail. Yeah. They're like, no, no, no. I wonder why they want to

0:11:44do that. Yeah. Yeah. Guy who owns a car company wants them to stop. Oh, exactly. Uh, and I,

0:11:52I do think it's unfortunate. I think it's just a, I think that I think most people who

0:12:00work in local municipal government are very, they're doing it for the right reasons for

0:12:06the most part. I don't think that these are overly political hacks on either side of the

0:12:10spectrum. They're just trying to get stuff done, but I think they're in over their heads

0:12:13on tech on technology. And I don't, I'm reading that wall street journal story about how the

0:12:19boring company convinced various municipalities to stop these high speed rail programs. It

0:12:23really seems like they're like, wow, this must be real because it's, you know, Elon

0:12:28Musk, you know, here's this highly successful person. And it's not based on any sort of

0:12:34expertise at the viability of the actual tunneling projects they said they would build and the

0:12:39costs, you know, so like the one they had was Ontario, California, which I've never

0:12:44heard of. It's apparently in the San Bernardino area, but it's an airport that was, uh, uh,

0:12:50long been used for freight, very busy, but it's starting to grow significantly in commuter

0:12:56traffic, you know, personal air travel. And they wanted to build, they have a rail station

0:13:03for public transit, but it's four miles away from the airport. And they thought, well,

0:13:07this so far makes total sense. We could get more people to go to this airport if we connect

0:13:12that rail station with the airport, with public transportation. Sounds good to me. And it

0:13:18was, uh, doing it as high speed rail might cost a billion to 1.5 billion significant

0:13:24expenditure, I think for any municipality and you know, especially one that's not a

0:13:28super mega city. And then the boring company came in and said, we can build a tunnel for

0:13:33$50 million. So I, I look at that and I don't know, I am not a civil engineer. I had roommates

0:13:43in college who were civil engineers. That's about as close to civil engineering expertise

0:13:48as I've gotten. I read Dr. Drang's site. I'm not an expert, but you tell me that a project

0:13:54that was, that the traditional way is one to 1.5 billion. And then the new way is 50

0:14:02million. I immediately think, where's my wallet? Yeah, I'm putting my hand on my

0:14:09pocket. Like I think, well, and the problem it creates of course is that, you know, he's,

0:14:13he's telling everybody these things, right? And so when he says something like that in

0:14:17public, a lot of people will just say, well, why are we building this thing? That's, you

0:14:21know, even if it doesn't make any sense, people are saying, why would we build this

0:14:25thing that's billion dollars when Musk says we can build this thing for 50 million?

0:14:29Exactly. So you have no political cover, right? Other than, you know, I guess it's going

0:14:38against Elon Musk and I get it. It's tough because then all of a sudden what happens

0:14:42if he starts making fun of you on Twitter, you know, even before he owned the place?

0:14:47No, you know what I mean? Like that? Yeah. You know? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean,

0:14:50you have, I mean, he has a, he has a very loyal fan base and reminds me of somebody.

0:14:56Yeah. Yeah. Really? I saw, I don't want, I don't want to name any names. I don't want

0:15:02to give these people any more popularity. But there was, you know, the whole thing with

0:15:08Tim Cook came up the other day and somebody added at Musk, I was just having to look at

0:15:13a thread and it was a picture of Tim Cook. And the, the, the point of the, the point

0:15:20of the image where they put some sort of meme point of the image was, why not? Why not?

0:15:24Hey, Hey, Elon, why don't you just buy Apple and fire Tim Cook? It's like, yeah, this,

0:15:32that's not how math works. Well, usually he's, he is very wealthy, but he cannot buy Apple.

0:15:39No. Um, there were, I remember years ago, uh, several, I don't know who knows these

0:15:45days, how many years, but you know, there were people. I, I guess this is one of those

0:15:51things circa 2013, right? 2013 was sort of the bad year for Apple where, um, that was

0:15:59the, the height of the Apple can't innovate anymore. Samsung phones are bigger and that's

0:16:06what people want. And Apple clearly, you know, it was, it's a disaster to name the operations

0:16:13guy, the new CEO there, you know, every, you know, we were right to Apple can't, you know,

0:16:17here we are two years after Steve jobs died that they need somebody like that. So Apple

0:16:22should buy Tesla and then name it Elon Musk, the CEO. Right. That was, I mean, you could,

0:16:28I don't have to even Google it. There's dozens and dozens of hot takes like that. And I would

0:16:33say they were all, I bet the date on all of them is 2013. Uh, because what you, you know,

0:16:39clearly what you all, you know, the only thing any company needs is a hot head. That's it.

0:16:45That's the thing that made Steve jobs. Steve jobs is that he was, I mean, there was a huge

0:16:51misconception about, um, Musk though, that he was, you know, big product guy and came

0:16:56up with all these ideas when he really did not there. I don't have a link to it handy,

0:17:02but somebody, I don't know if it was on medium or what I should look it up and try to get

0:17:07it in the show notes. I actually should try to link to it from during fireball, but, um,

0:17:11but the gist of it was the question that I think is on a lot of people's minds right

0:17:15now is, wait, watching this man manage Twitter in public and you know, one thing we could

0:17:22say about him is his, his management style so far has not been in secret. Watching him

0:17:27manage Twitter, how in the world does he have, does he run two successful companies, Tesla

0:17:32and space X and somebody answered somebody who worked at one of the companies, I think

0:17:37it was like a medium answered and said more or less that, that these companies, a, they

0:17:42existed before he came in and sort of had a thing in place and that, you know, he didn't

0:17:47found either. He bought them and took over, but that they've both evolved company cultures

0:17:54and structures that sort of isolate. It's like shop shock absorbers in a car, right?

0:18:03That it's okay. We know work at work around his eccentricity and impetuousness. And so

0:18:10there are people, you know, he can come in and say X, Y, Z, and they know that he might

0:18:13just randomly come in and demand X, Y, Z, which don't make any sense. And they have

0:18:17a system in place to more or less placate him. Yeah. And then meanwhile, they're continuing

0:18:23to actually do things like land, you know, launch satellites into space and then land

0:18:29the rocket back on a launch pad in the ocean and continuing to make cars that are very

0:18:36popular and continue to sell in ever increasing numbers. So he's like, yeah, I'm doing

0:18:42a great job, but they've, they've more or less got systems in place to keep him.

0:18:46I will. The companies, the companies are continuing

0:18:48to be successful despite him rather than because of them.

0:18:51And that they've set up a hierarchy of management that is, that is meant for that. Whereas he

0:18:55came into Twitter and this, there is no buffer. Right. There's no, there are no competent

0:19:02actual, actually competent executives surrounding him who are, who are insulating the company

0:19:09from his impetuousness. This is his management style. And then I sort of think going back

0:19:13to my comment on the boring company, that's another one that he's seemingly launched

0:19:17on a whim and it is a real company with a huge amount of funding from reputable VC firms,

0:19:22you know, and, and the CEO, I forget his name, but he was hired away from space X. You know,

0:19:27I guess I don't even know if you call that hired away when the same guy, you know, transferred

0:19:33over from Elon's space X division to the boring company. And I hope they work again.

0:19:39This is, it's another weird thing about Elon Musk is even as I grow to dislike him

0:19:43more personally, I do root for his ventures, right? If this hyperloop thing ever came to

0:19:50be and you could go up and down the East coast from New York to Washington at 700 miles an

0:19:56hour underground or the, you know, similar, you know, I know everybody wants the one between

0:20:00LA and San Francisco. That would be fabulous, right? I, I, who would, who would root against

0:20:06that? Right. It's right out of, that's the one though that seems, you know, based

0:20:10on everything that I've seen is more smoke and mirrors, right? I mean, you know, they

0:20:15think that that wall street journal piece points that out. Whereas the other two are

0:20:20actual, yeah. Actual things that are actually, whereas this one is like, no, we're going

0:20:25to make a bunch of noise about this just to stop high speed rail. So that seems like more,

0:20:31that's more of the purpose of that company as opposed to actually making the thing.

0:20:35Yeah. Seems like it. So we're, you know, we're starting to get it, that sort of,

0:20:39so we're starting to form at least a hypothesis, right? Let's not say it's proven, but there's

0:20:44a hypothesis for how two of these companies are thriving and actually innovative and these

0:20:50there's, it's more or less, is he actually running the company is the hypothesis. And

0:20:57if the answer is yes, there may not, it may not be a good result. But I did predict this

0:21:03Twitter Apple drama. And I knew, I, I, I, I don't think I deserve even my, one of my

0:21:09famous being right points. Cause I think it, but on both fronts, it was so incredibly obvious.

0:21:15Clearly the app store commission front, the the 30%, 70 30 70 split Apple takes for the

0:21:24first year of any subscription and 85 15 afterwards, clearly, you know, the small business, I,

0:21:30well, who knows, maybe he'll eventually get, get Twitter down to the under 1 million a

0:21:36year, small business, small business threshold. He's, you know, he's working on it. So

0:21:43he might, he might be able to go 85 15 right from the start. If he keeps going with Twitter,

0:21:48the way he's going that was clearly going to be a conflict because, because by all reports,

0:21:58many of his plans for adding additional stools to Twitter's revenue, which are, is primarily

0:22:05advertising right now, involves subscriptions and subscriptions mean selling stuff to your

0:22:10users. And if your users mostly use mobile apps, which is true for Twitter, that means

0:22:17you're going to have to pay the app stores in Apple and Google. So that I, and there's,

0:22:23you just knew that wasn't going to sit well with them. And then on the other front is

0:22:26the, the content moderation loosening at Twitter or read, whatever you want to call what he's

0:22:34doing by letting previously banned people back on today, as we record, they officially

0:22:42rescinded their COVID misinformation rules, which that's one where I'm actually, I actually

0:22:49feel that the COVID rules, I've personally feel that Twitter and maybe even Facebook

0:22:55misplayed that. I think that, that by, I think the rules they had in hindsight, I think they

0:23:03were well-meaning and I do think that they actually used actual scientific consensus

0:23:10to guide them. But the problem there's two problems with that. I think that even if the

0:23:14scientific consensus throughout the whole COVID drama, you know, 2020 and 2021 had been

0:23:22accurate or almost completely accurate. I still feel that a complete ban on the other

0:23:28stuff only feeds into the exact sort of thinking that leads people to the conspiracy theories.

0:23:38I don't know. I don't know about, I mean, so what, then what's the difference between

0:23:42that and political? I mean, you know, why, why do you think that's different from saying

0:23:46that the election was stolen? I'm not, I'm not sure it should be, I don't know that it

0:23:53should be against Twitter's rules to tweet, I think the election is stolen. I don't think

0:23:57it should be, you know, I, I think hate speech clearly needs to be banned, something that

0:24:04threatens people personally. And I think outright racism, racial slurs. I mean, there's, you

0:24:11know, I, all of this stuff is all famously and everybody's written about it since he

0:24:18took over Twitter. I mean, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the

0:24:20Neil Patel had a great piece, but content moderation is the product ultimately, right?

0:24:25It's the tweets. You, it's not really a software product. It's the actual tweets you see on

0:24:31Twitter are the product. And whether you see them on their website or in an app or in a

0:24:35third party app like Twitter, if I could tweet, but the product is the tweets and therefore

0:24:39the content moderation is, is the actual product they make. So I, I'm, I don't know. I, I think

0:24:46they kind of, I don't think it worked out well. The other problem with the COVID stuff

0:24:49is that the scientific consensus was largely wrong throughout it, right? There was the

0:24:55proof, infamously, the don't wear masks, don't wear masks, save them for our frontline responders

0:25:00and masks don't matter. You know, wash your hands and scrub all your groceries as they

0:25:05come in the door. Hey, you laugh. I mean, we all did it. I remember, I remember watching

0:25:09that video, that doctor scrubbing all of the groceries and looking at that and thinking,

0:25:13Oh my God, Oh shit. I'm just giving them a rent. Yeah. Right. Right. Like I've, I, Amy

0:25:21and I, this is going to be my life for the next, you know, however long we were renting.

0:25:25We were rinsing everything, but we were like, Oh shit, we're not, we're not doing that.

0:25:29Oh, you know, it was a lot bleach. My oranges. There was a lot of stuff that turned out to

0:25:35be wrong and you know, that's true. I don't know that people tweeting, I just don't think

0:25:42that the rules did much. I don't know that they helped. I, and I think it's all, there's,

0:25:49there's two sides to it. The, at the low end, Joe random Twitter user tweeting, I don't

0:25:59trust this vaccine. I don't trust any vaccine that was developed in only 12 months or something

0:26:05like that, you know, or, you know, obviously a lot of the anti-vaccine stuff was even worse.

0:26:11I don't know that that was the problem as much as the fact that the main Twitter timeline

0:26:19is algorithmically. I think it's both right though, because if you have less of that misinformation,

0:26:27the algorithm is going to promote it less. And the, and the other thing that I think

0:26:30that happens is that people who are bad actors tend to go after that stuff and try to promote

0:26:37it further. And then the algorithm recognizes that as something like, Oh, people are talking

0:26:41about this. I'm going to keep displaying this. And so you, you know, it's a, it's a snowball

0:26:46effect. So I, you know, I'm not pretending like I have an answer. Maybe Twitter played

0:26:50it perfectly. I'm actually amenable to the fact that maybe Twitter's COVID policy was

0:26:55as like, like talking about democracy and capitalism, the worst system ever, except

0:27:01for all the other ones. And maybe, maybe, maybe, well, yeah. I mean, I think that's

0:27:05true. I mean, at least these were people who were legitimately trying to solve the problem

0:27:09as opposed to people who were trying to exploit it for political purposes. But regardless,

0:27:15we, we, you know, we know that he's loosening up the rules, their rules for content moderation

0:27:19and less, fewer, fewer topics are banned and more people, people who were banned are coming

0:27:26back and it's, in my opinion, none, none for the better. Yeah. But it's going to run into

0:27:34Apple's Apple, probably more so than Google, but both of them have content moderation rules

0:27:42surrounding the apps and that, you know, and it's all, you know, it, it, it all opens up

0:27:49the entire gigantic, I was going to say can of worms, but it's more like one of those,

0:27:55like those water towers, right? It's like a giant water tower full of worms that's supposed

0:28:00to, you know, giant 10, $10 million. Why, why do they store the worms in there? Nobody

0:28:07knows of Apple and Google's influence over everything we see because of their control

0:28:13over their respective app stores. But Parler is a good example. Parler, P-A-R-L-E-R. If

0:28:22you've never heard of it, you're lucky. Parler. I mean, that name just cracks me up every

0:28:27single time because when I first saw it, I didn't hear the, you know, I don't listen

0:28:31to TV news, so I didn't hear anybody say it. And I, you know, my first thing was, you know,

0:28:36because I did years of French was this Parler. And then, and then like, not like five minutes

0:28:42later it hit me, like who the people who made this site were and then I suddenly know, no,

0:28:47it's not it's Parler. They just found a way to spell it. That was original, but I do think

0:28:54there was a thing. I think they actually did have a thing going on though, where the site

0:28:58was Parler, even though in French it would be pronounced Parler, but they were calling

0:29:01their posts parlays, I think. And then I think they gave up on it because they're like, this

0:29:06is just confusing people. Because they were spelling it in the English way, P-A-R-L-A-Y,

0:29:13you know, for the posts. We'll get back to this when we talk about Macedon later, but

0:29:18you gotta, you know, rule one of these things is you gotta have a cutesy name for your posts.

0:29:25But with Parler, Apple, I guess I was after January 6, 2020 or no, 2021, where 2020 was

0:29:36the pandemic year. That's right, John. That's right. 2021 was the sitting president of the

0:29:43United States led an insurrection against the federal government. That was 2021. I'm

0:29:48getting my seasons mixed up. No, but Apple removed Parler from the App Store early in

0:29:54the year. I think they were off. I looked it up the other day. It was like three months,

0:29:58but for content, for lack of content moderation and that people were posting things that Apple

0:30:04thought were over the line and that the company did not have any sort of infrastructure to

0:30:12moderate it. And therefore it was removed. Google did too. And I actually think, even

0:30:19though I was just saying that Apple might be more stringent than Google, I believe,

0:30:24I don't even know. Google get it first, right? Yeah, I think so. Yeah. And I think they were

0:30:28off longer. I'm not even sure if they're back. No, it looks like it's back, but yeah, Google

0:30:34Parler returns to the Google Play Store. That was September. Yeah. So Google kept Parler

0:30:41off their store longer than Apple did. So maybe not, but Parler is the perfect example

0:30:46though, where it was, it leaned for lack of a better word, leaned right in terms of who

0:30:52was attracted to the platform because people on the right in the US, at least I think worldwide,

0:30:59but especially in the US politically are obsessed, absolutely obsessed with the idea that Twitter,

0:31:09Twitter's users, the blue check people, the people inside the company, the people running

0:31:15the content moderation, the previous leadership of the company from top to bottom, all the

0:31:20way down to the users were all democratic operatives and out to sabotage Republicans

0:31:27and conservatives in the US in any way possible as opposed to the Occam's razor, you know,

0:31:35what's the simplest explanation? No, it's, it's you who sucks. Yeah. I saw, you know,

0:31:45people like there's, there's some kind of thing where you, when you give to political

0:31:48as an individual, not a company, but as an individual and you contribute to politicians

0:31:53and political campaigns, I don't know if you have to say your employer, I think you do.

0:31:59Maybe, maybe that's part of it. I don't know. I think, I think, yeah, my wife does all the

0:32:02political giving in our household, so God only knows what she fills in there, but, but

0:32:09you know, but then there's records of this and all of these Silicon Valley companies

0:32:14overwhelmingly employed donations well into the high 90 percentile give to Democrats instead

0:32:20of Republicans. And I think the, again, the Occam's razor explanation is that people,

0:32:26honestly, I know that, you know, it's true. People who live on the coasts tend to be more

0:32:31liberal. I mean, California is a blue state. That's where these companies are located.

0:32:36People with higher love degrees of education tend to be liberal and people who are smarter

0:32:42tend to vote Democratic and these companies are full of smart people. And I'm not, you

0:32:46know, this is not any kind of blanket statement that people who vote for Republicans are dumb

0:32:51and people who vote for Democrats are smart. It's just, I don't think it's surprising demographically

0:32:56at all that 90 plus percent of individual donations from companies like Apple and Google

0:33:02and Twitter went to Democrats. And it's not a conspiracy. And I honestly think that Twitter

0:33:09let conservatives post anything short of hate, you know, and, you know, insurrection. You

0:33:17know, these are things that seem like they should be banned and aren't really against

0:33:22your general political leanings. But anyway, so Parler drew, so what happened though, this

0:33:29is where I'm going with Parler, is that these alternative Twitter-like services, private

0:33:34services, there's, Parler was the one that got a lot of headlines because they got kicked

0:33:38off. There was one called Gab that I think was even worse. And it was actually run by

0:33:43an outright white nationalist neo-Nazi. And I happen to know this because he got involved.

0:33:49He was like a top advisor to Doug Mastriano, who was the right wing Nazi sympathizer, who

0:33:59was the Republican, was last month, the Republican nominee for governor here in Pennsylvania

0:34:05and lost, thankfully, in a 20... As he is still not conceded. He is still not conceded.

0:34:10He is never going to concede. And I love the guy who won Shapiro. His response, they're

0:34:18like, "Hey, what do you... He still hasn't called to concede." And I love his response.

0:34:22Who cares? Who cares? Just don't give him oxygen. It is, honestly, it's like parenting

0:34:29advice. It's like when your kid is throwing a tantrum, don't pay attention to them, right?

0:34:34It's the number one way to stop a tantrum with a small child is don't pay attention.

0:34:40That's what they want is the attention. So don't drop everything. Just ignore them. It'll

0:34:44drive them nuts and then they'll stop. It turns out that this is an important skill

0:34:51for dealing with Republican candidates for governor.

0:34:55And president.

0:34:56And president. And president. Just don't pay attention. And the new CEO of Twitter, just

0:35:01don't pay attention as we devote half the show.

0:35:05Really, I know. We're not doing very well, are we?

0:35:09There was Gab, which was even right-of-wing. But anyway, Apple did take Parler off the

0:35:14store for three months. Google took it down for, I guess, half a year for content moderation.

0:35:20And to whatever degree the content that is now allowable on Twitter has changed under

0:35:26Musk's leadership, it is more in the direction of Parler and Gab, right? It is more friendly

0:35:33to right-wing things, people who post the peppy meme unironically. That sort of stuff

0:35:44is to some degree small or large. I'm not sure. I don't see it, but I use Tweetbot and

0:35:51I follow people who I want to follow. And so my Twitter content, if I had a filter to

0:35:59block the meta discussion of Twitter itself and Elon Musk, which those of you who do have

0:36:04such filters and you don't feel a professional need to stay up to date on it, I'm so jealous.

0:36:11My Twitter feed has not changed significantly. I don't think I would know that anything

0:36:16is different.

0:36:17And that was, well, I mean, I had several breaking points. One was him bringing Trump

0:36:23back. That was the big one. And so I have stopped posting and I'm winnowing down my

0:36:29followers just so that I'm less inclined to go into Tweetbot and read. But I'm down

0:36:37to not, you know, my feed now is sort of a trickle, but that's the idea that he would

0:36:46cut off third party apps was the other breaking point. Like if he had not taken, you know,

0:36:53not put Trump back, but then cut off third party apps, there was no way I was ever going

0:36:56to go to the website and read this.

0:36:58Right. I, yeah, I'm so I'm a Tweetbot man myself, but I, yeah, if he cut off third party

0:37:05apps, I don't know. I don't know that I'd completely stop, but it would, I've really

0:37:10stopped checking Instagram regularly, maybe like once a week. It's over on my third home

0:37:15screen at this point. I think Twitter would sort of fall into that category. Maybe I guess

0:37:20I'd still look at my mentions in the regular Twitter app, but I'd probably, I, it's

0:37:26hard to predict, but without Tweetbot, I would probably just look at my mentions as opposed

0:37:30to looking at the main feed. And I know I've talked to people at Twitter, some, some people,

0:37:39it's not luckily I don't root for, for layoffs, but because, because so many people

0:37:43have, have left or been laid off from Twitter recently, there are a lot of an unusual number

0:37:50of people willing to tweet or speak to reporters on the, or post blog posts on the record with

0:37:57their name of their experience working at Twitter. Right. And it's, you know, I don't

0:38:02have to point to one specific example. Many, many people I've talked to privately and

0:38:06I've seen tweets publicly have said that it was an ongoing, never ending discussion

0:38:13with Apple over content moderation on Twitter for years. This is not like a new thing under

0:38:19Elon Musk and all of a sudden in the last four weeks, and now Apple is putting its eye

0:38:25of sore on, on the content that's on Twitter. It has been never ending throughout the entire

0:38:32history of the app store that Apple has, you know, and, and random, you know, famous, famously,

0:38:41you know, if Twitter's one of these many, many companies whose release notes for an

0:38:44update is always bug fixes and improvements, right. But it's just another random, whatever

0:38:51version point three update with some bug fixes and improvements and it sales right through.

0:38:57And then a week later they've got the point four version, which is just more bug fixes

0:39:02and improvements. And it's really no major new features or changes, but all of a sudden

0:39:06now it's held up an app review and app review gets back to them and says something like

0:39:12I typed in hashtag boobs and look at, you know, and then there's screenshots of, you

0:39:18know, and there is, there's actually there's actual pornography. If you go looking for

0:39:22it, there is pornographic or at least nude, nude content on Twitter. And yeah, every once

0:39:28in a while I would, I would do a search for something, you know, some weird, it's a

0:39:31weird thing. And then it'd be like, Whoa. I mean, you get, you get things that come

0:39:35up, you know, like you, sometimes you get unexpected results and it's, and I was like,

0:39:42God, I really don't like, I feel like there's a whole other use for this site that I'm

0:39:46not taking advantage of. Right. It is. It's actually Tumblr cultivated

0:39:51that did an entire significant subculture on, on Tumblr is related to adult content.

0:40:00You know, I don't know if it, I guess it used to be anyway, and now they're, you know,

0:40:05I think they, I don't know if they timed it for this or I think it's, it's funny

0:40:09that that, you know, pretty much a few days after Musk took over and these things started

0:40:14happening, Tumblr changed its policy to allow nudity.

0:40:20But there was a lot of, a lot of the reaction to that when, when Apple said, look, you know,

0:40:25you can't have your, we're not going to allow your app in the app store if you have

0:40:28this content and the app is so important to Tumblr that they actually had to concede to

0:40:33Apple and say, okay, we're going to change our rules for this content Tumblr wide, just

0:40:38to make sure that our apps can stay in the app store. And the, I would say the number

0:40:43one response to that from people who were on Tumblr side, not Apple side was, well,

0:40:49wait, what about Twitter? You can search for some of the same terms you're saying, I

0:40:54search for term, whatever, again, hashtag boobs on Tumblr. And I get this, but if I

0:40:59search for the same hashtag on Twitter, I get very similar stuff. And there's no problem

0:41:04with Twitter. Again, Apple's policies with the app store are inscrutable externally.

0:41:11And that inscrutability is perhaps the biggest problem with, with the app store. But I guess

0:41:21from the outside, my guess is that Twitter was across a certain too big to fail line

0:41:28that Tumblr wasn't in Apple's eyes. And because of their size and importance that

0:41:35they, you know, could get away with more than a smaller app or network couldn't, I think

0:41:41it's very certain that an upstart app like a parlor or a gab that had the same content

0:41:48under hashtag boobs that Twitter did would get flagged and held up and said, you know,

0:41:55that Twitter, but anyway, over the years, many, many times, though, there were times

0:41:59where, you know, hashtag boobs would flag an app store review and an update would be

0:42:04held for weeks. You know, it, people who run really big apps, you know, from companies

0:42:13that you've heard of major, major apps have war stories about minor updates being held.

0:42:21And sometimes it is for obvious reasons, like a tweak to like the Netflix, what happens

0:42:27if you don't have a Netflix account and you want to sign up and net, you know, famously

0:42:32several years ago, Netflix stopped taking in app signups, so they don't have to pay

0:42:36Apple any commission. And what arguing over the exact language of what's on that page

0:42:43to comply with Apple's weird, you're not allowed to talk about the rules. And, you

0:42:48know, I wrote about this years ago, it's one of my favorite things ever, where Netflix

0:42:51had a phone number, and you could call the phone number and talk to a real human being

0:42:57and ask, Hey, I don't have a Netflix account, but I'm using the iPhone app, how do I get

0:43:02an account? And then they said, Oh, you need to go to a computer and then go to the Netflix.com

0:43:07website and you need to sign up there. And they, they can't put those words on the screen

0:43:14in the app, but they can put a phone number in the app and you can, they can make it a

0:43:17tappable link, you know, like when you automatically dial it automatically dials and then they

0:43:24have the money to have people answer the real people, answer the phone and tell you exactly

0:43:30what to do to get an account, which I thought was a very weird loophole, you know, and obviously

0:43:34not available to smaller companies, unless you like, imagine like me and you and a couple

0:43:42of pals just put my phone number on there, just put Moltz's phone number in there. And

0:43:49every five minutes, you're just answering your phone, you know, like in the middle of

0:43:52dinner and you're like, yeah, yeah, just go to our website. Chewing. Yeah. Oh, hey, yeah,

0:43:59yeah, sure. Here's what you're going to do.

0:44:06So that's been happening. And so anyway, what, what Musk is alleging, and it's in the news

0:44:10today as we record it, I'm sure it'll still be in the news tomorrow, but it's, and it's

0:44:15sort of changing the narrative with the big publications that are on the anti big tech

0:44:21crusade, like the Washington Post and the New York times, where all of a sudden now

0:44:26they're on Twitter and Elon Musk's side, because Apple is the clear, you know, in this battle,

0:44:32Apple's against anybody, pretty much Apple's Goliath, right? There's only a handful of

0:44:36companies where you could say that they're picking on somebody their own size, right?

0:44:40There's Google, Microsoft, even meta at this point has been reduced, right? But when Apple

0:44:45first instituted the app tracking transparency rules that apparently so adversely affected

0:44:53Facebook's ad revenue, they would be considered a peer to Apple. Twitter is not a peer to

0:44:58Apple in any way, size, revenue, whatever. But it, the coverage I've seen today seems

0:45:06clearly on the, they're taking Elon Musk at his word. And, and the slant is clearly that

0:45:16Apple's control over the app store is problematic, you know, which it might be, right? It's this

0:45:21is the debate, you know, it really, I'm not saying it isn't, I'm just saying, I think

0:45:27it requires tremendous nuance. And they're taking the sort of it just, it is clear, you

0:45:34know, what, I don't know what the legal term is, but, you know, true on its face, that

0:45:40it's just a huge problem that Apple has this control over Twitter's content. Musk is alleging

0:45:45that they're threatening to remove Twitter from the app store. I don't know that that's

0:45:49true. I don't believe anything he tweets. Yeah, so I wouldn't, I wouldn't be surprised

0:45:55if what he's learning is that their updates get held up. And I wouldn't, I would actually

0:46:02be surprised if their recent updates and I know I actually install my updates manually.

0:46:08I don't have automatic app store updates, just so I like to keep track of what's being

0:46:13updated. And then, you know, I just scroll through the list and then I hit update all

0:46:16the time. I don't do it one by one. But I've noticed, you know, there have been Twitter

0:46:20app updates for iOS in recent weeks, but I wouldn't be surprised if they're seeing longer

0:46:27than usual delays while Apple has discussions over the content moderation. And, you know,

0:46:33and Musk's take is that Apple should have no say in Twitter's content moderation and,

0:46:38you know, nor should Google. You know, that's his definition of free speech that that is

0:46:42one take. Yeah, it's weird. Right. Because I mean, it, in both of like this, this case,

0:46:52and then we have Epic, like nice. The app store rules are arcane and real dumb in large

0:47:02cases. But we have these two champions of breaking up the rules and I don't like either

0:47:10of them. They're both doing it for nefarious reasons, seemingly to me. Right. I don't know

0:47:18that the, yeah, Epic was not the most sympathetic. Yeah. I mean, Epic doesn't care about anybody

0:47:24but Epic, of course. Right. And, you know, they clearly sandbagged Apple by clearly violating

0:47:31the rules. Right. And so I saw even Tim Sweeney jumping into Twitter, you know, that's the

0:47:38CEO of Epic CEO and co-founder or founder of Epic games. But, you know, certainly the

0:47:42face of their public and legal battle against Apple over the app store rules was Tim Sweeney.

0:47:49You know, and I'll get, you know, I don't agree with his angle. I don't agree with Epic's

0:47:53tactics, but I'll certainly give him credit for, you know, sticking his chin out right

0:48:00on something that most companies seem very fearful. Nobody wants to, people are fearful

0:48:06of Apple and so people don't speak out about it. Right. It's, there's other, you know,

0:48:11certainly you could make a phone book probably of companies with complaints about the way

0:48:17Apple manages the app store, the review process, and certainly the commission structure and

0:48:22the rules, the rules around routing around it by steering people to the web to pay without

0:48:29giving Apple a commission. And that's long been my take just to put it, reiterate, you

0:48:34know, is that I think what Apple should have done long ago, they're doing it ever so slightly,

0:48:39like with the Japan trade commission agreement for a certain class of apps, their, their

0:48:45quote unquote reader apps. I just think they should open it up to anybody and let people

0:48:50say you can buy here, right here in the app right now. And it goes through Apple and Apple

0:48:55gets the cut or click this link and it opens in Safari outside the app and you can pay

0:49:02there. And if, you know, I think that that, that, that, that should just be something

0:49:07apps can do. And if you don't even want to offer the in-app purchase, I think, you know,

0:49:13like Netflix, I think Netflix should just, instead of a frigging phone number, they should

0:49:17just say sign in, or if you need to sign up, tap, click this button, tap this button, and

0:49:24it'll go to the web and you'll sign up there and then come back to the app and sign in

0:49:29with the account you created on the web. You know, that the, if the convenience of doing

0:49:34the commerce in app is so great, then let, let there be a link to the web to prove it.

0:49:40And you keep, keep your cut in the app and do it for all classes of apps. And there you

0:49:45go, you know, and then it would solve so many problems, you know, and I get, I, I, and I

0:49:50also believe that it's fine if Apple opened that up like that to not allow it to be a

0:49:56browser that's in the app. You actually have to leave the app. And I know that many, many

0:50:01millions of people are confused about where they are, but at least people who know what's

0:50:05going on would be able to see that they've left the app and now they're in Safari or

0:50:11whatever other, you know, whatever their default iOS browser is. Because Apple did open that

0:50:15up several years ago where you could set Chrome or DuckDuckGo or any number, Firefox or any

0:50:21number of third-party browsers as your, you know, just go, but you're in your browser,

0:50:25you're out of the app in the browser, sign up there. And then the last leg of this conflict

0:50:31is Apple as an advertiser on Twitter. And this is sort of what prompted Elon Musk's

0:50:38foray. Apple had, this is his tweet yesterday. It's two tweets, but it could have been one.

0:50:45Apple has mostly stopped advertising on Twitter. Do they hate free speech in America? What,

0:50:51what's going on here at Tim Cook? What's the betting line on Tim Cook responding to that

0:51:00on Twitter? It's gotta be pretty tremendous. I'm going to say it's no line. I would think,

0:51:08I think that could be it. You see it in game a lot. So now that, that sports betting is

0:51:12legal and there's these apps and I don't know if you know this, but I like to, I like to

0:51:15gamble occasionally. Oh really? Yeah. You can bet during the game. So like if, you know,

0:51:21the Dallas Cowboys are playing the Minnesota Vikings like the other week and everybody

0:51:26expected a close game, but all of a sudden it's not a close game and Dallas is up 33

0:51:32to three. You can still place bets, but it's like at a certain point, maybe when it gets

0:51:38to 33 to three or whatever the score was at some point, they stop letting you bet that

0:51:43Dallas is going to win the game. They won't even offer like 10,000 to one odds, you know,

0:51:48like bet, bet $10,000 to win a dollar. They won't even offer it. They just take it off.

0:51:53They're like, no, cause I would say the odds of Tim Cook responding to this engaging on

0:51:58Twitter itself were off the board. Do you, you couldn't even get like a 10,000 to one

0:52:03odds on it. Yeah. Do you remember, it was a few years ago they did it, they did a joke

0:52:09at the beginning of an event where they were looking for a remote, right? Yes. Yeah. He

0:52:13tweeted, he tweeted, you know, it looked like he tweeted an accidental tweet. Yes. Can someone

0:52:19get it here quickly? Yeah. When it was just like, it was a pro, you know, like a lead

0:52:23in for the event. Yeah. I do remember that. That was very funny. That's the wildest thing

0:52:29that he's ever, that he's ever tweeted. I mean, everything else is very by the numbers

0:52:33and there's, yeah, there's no way he's responding. Yeah. For like a 10 AM Pacific keynote kickoff

0:52:39at like 9 56 at Tim Cook tweeted something weird. Like has anybody seen it? You know,

0:52:44bring it to me on stage and that is. Yeah. Right. Right. I think it's, can you get it

0:52:48here quickly? I had my screen shot at it because at the time I was like, what the hell is this?

0:52:52What's going on? And then, and then like, you know, watching the event of like, oh,

0:52:56it's a gag. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, I'd say the odds were zero and I, it makes Elon Musk look

0:53:04a little thirsty. There's a, there's a certain, there's a low, all of this has, there's a

0:53:10low energy vibe to it though. Right. Josh Marshall, who writes the great, or founded

0:53:16and is still writes the editor's blog at talking points memo. One of my favorite political

0:53:20sites was tweeting about it and called it real low energy vibes and was laughing at

0:53:25it. I heard from somebody I, and I reported, I guess I, you know, I don't, don't claim

0:53:32to quote unquote report much, but reported a day or two ago that some, a source who had

0:53:37previously worked in Twitter's ad group told me that Twitter or Apple had been until recently

0:53:44at Twitter's number one advertiser by spend and the Washington post today put a number

0:53:50on it and said that in the first quarter of the year, Apple spent $48 million, which made

0:53:54them their number one and it was 4% of Twitter's ad revenue. So not like essential, but you

0:54:05know, 4% is what, like one out of 22. And I was surprised that they were the largest.

0:54:11Yeah. I don't think I, I didn't really think about it very much, but I was surprised that

0:54:16Apple would be the one who was spending the lowest. Yeah. And they've, you know, but in

0:54:21hindsight, I guess it makes sense. Cause I know that when they have product announcements,

0:54:25they'd like to buy those hash flags. They call them where you, you know, you can get a custom

0:54:30hashtag and then it has like an animation that goes with it. They, you can buy a custom

0:54:35like button that makes the like button and Apple logo or the, the logo, you know, how

0:54:41the Apple likes to make a custom logo for each event announcement, you know, with the

0:54:46theme. So Apple has tends to promote their events like that. I don't know what else they

0:54:52do. I don't, cause I use tweet bots, so I don't see a lot of ads. Right. Yeah. And that's

0:54:58probably why, I mean, I probably would have seen lots of them when I was looking at the

0:55:01web, but, and you know, that unsurprisingly they've cut their ad spend according to Musk

0:55:08almost entirely. They're not alone. No, that, that, that post article listed quite a few

0:55:15major companies that have been coming back. Yeah. And it's, you know, it's a well-known

0:55:19category, brand advertisers, right? It is companies, you know, Apple's certainly a big

0:55:25one, but who else was on the list? I don't have it in front of me, but wasn't Ford one

0:55:30of them. Yeah, I think so. You know, it's major American brands, the type of brands

0:55:35that advertise in mass market, like on TV sports, right? Who advertises during a big

0:55:43football games, those type of companies have pulled their Twitter ad spend and it makes

0:55:48sense. Advertisers are incredibly conservative, not conservative in the political sense, but

0:55:54conservative. It just in the plain meaning of the word conservative and they don't want

0:55:59controversy. They want, and they, yeah. And so, yeah, not surprisingly, a lot of these

0:56:03are like blue chip sort of yeah. AT&T American express, Chevrolet, Chipotle, Citigroup, CNN,

0:56:12Apple, goes on and on. Yeah. But did, you know, think about what unites those brands.

0:56:17They're big companies with established brands and they don't want their brand associated

0:56:22with say Nazis, right wing, you know, white nationalism. No, probably don't want my hash

0:56:30to hash flag, you know, anywhere near that or in people's minds. They also value tremendously

0:56:40predictability, right? And, you know, so like when you, let's say you want to promote the

0:56:48iPhone 14 and you're going to have your jaws and you're thinking about where are we going

0:56:54to spend our December ads on TV and you're like, we should put some on 60 minutes. And

0:57:00it's like, you don't need to call CBS and say like, hey, what's going to be on 60 minutes

0:57:06on the December 11th episode? You kind of know what you're going to get, you know, it's

0:57:12predictable. It is, you know, you know who the audience is, you know what the ratings

0:57:16are going to be and you know, you know, the sort of content that 60 minutes puts on their

0:57:22weekly news TV show. When you advertise during a football game, you know what you're going

0:57:28to get. You're going to get a football game, right? What could steer advertisers away from

0:57:36something like football? Well, ratings obviously would be the big thing. If football becomes

0:57:41unpopular over the years, I mean, baseball has certainly become less popular over our

0:57:45lifetimes to go back to baseball. It's no longer the most popular team sport in America,

0:57:52but people still advertise because millions of people still watch. The whole concussion

0:57:56thing with football would be a thing that, you know, it's clearly the biggest danger

0:58:01to the NFL going forward because it is a serious issue. It's real, it's documented, and it

0:58:07is incredibly controversial, right? That's a thing that would hurt. That's like the one

0:58:12thing that could hurt the NFL in terms of their ad revenue. That is like a drop in the

0:58:17bucket compared to where Twitter is these days in terms of predictability, right? And,

0:58:22you know, who knows what the hell is going to be on Twitter in a week. So why in the

0:58:26world would you? Why not wait for this to settle down? It's going to settle down. This

0:58:32tumultuousness cannot, it can't keep up, right? I don't think. I don't know. It doesn't show

0:58:43any signs of abating. It's been going on for weeks now. I don't know. So, but my take on

0:58:47this controversy though is it seems as though it boils down to politically, Elon Musk is,

0:58:55in my view, is clearly not trying to stake out some middle, both sides middle ground.

0:59:03He's surprising, which is what I thought he would do, but I don't think I followed him

0:59:08closely enough. I think people who did follow him closer therefore made better predictions

0:59:12that he really does seem to lean right politically, or at least has for several years. And is

0:59:18really making moves that are only to the side of placating people on the US political right

0:59:24and making it friendlier for people who were banned to come back and to post things that

0:59:29previously weren't allowed. And that there's no good news in this for people on the US

0:59:36political left. And it's no good news at all for anybody, LGBTQ, a part of the community

0:59:45or friendly to the community, allied with that community, nothing, no good news and

0:59:51some significant bad news. People who were banned for truly vile content by speaking

1:00:04out against that community in ways that I genuinely believe are harmful. I know that

1:00:12this term stochastic terrorism is sort of new, but I think it's real. I think it's a

1:00:19real thing that you can speak in coded terms and never call for violence, but use language

1:00:27and tone and dog whistle code words that implicitly imply that violence is actually called for.

1:00:39And that the stochastic is like a statistics term, but that means that you can't predict

1:00:46anything specific, but you can take this and predict that it's going to happen at some

1:00:52point. It's like you can't predict exactly where and when an earthquake is going to occur,

1:00:58but you know that because of the fault lines, there are going to be earthquakes. And you

1:01:03can take this rhetoric on Fox News and you can't predict, oh, that means that in Peoria,

1:01:12Illinois some guy's going to go nuts and try to shoot up a place or something like that.

1:01:17But you can't predict where, but you can predict that it's going to happen in the aggregate.

1:01:22And I think it's a shocker. I think it's terrible. And I think it's something that

1:01:29something like Twitter should fight against.

1:01:30He's not interested.

1:01:33No, I don't think though. I really don't think that Twitter, I don't know who knows what

1:01:39Apple has said. Maybe Apple has said, hey, you guys are in jeopardy of us removing the

1:01:44app from the store. And I wouldn't be surprised, maybe that's actually how bad it's gotten.

1:01:49I think somebody told him about the op-ed piece that his former employee wrote in the

1:01:56New York Times and he then reacted to that.

1:02:01Right. That's the former head of Trust and Safety, Joel Roth. And I guess that's where

1:02:07I know that Apple's had a continuing, he was forthright about it, that they've had

1:02:12a never-ending discussion with Apple and Google about the content on the network. So it is

1:02:19interesting to think that Apple's, there's money flowing both ways where Elon Musk is

1:02:26now upset that he's learned that any kind of subscription they sell, they're going

1:02:30to have to pay Apple a significant cut of it. And he's also mad.

1:02:35It's a big surprise.

1:02:36He's also mad now that Apple is choosing not to give Twitter money. I mean, again,

1:02:4250 million and a quarter isn't a huge amount of money, but it's 4% of their ad revenue.

1:02:46And ad revenue is the biggest thing. So it's, you know, and-

1:02:49And they're not the only one. And so, I mean, all these other ones, I mean, everything adds

1:02:52up and he's just using Apple as a particular target.

1:02:56Yeah, like a proxy. Well, but I also don't think you have to be, I don't see how anybody

1:03:02could deny it that a company as influential as Apple and as respected for their brand

1:03:08and marketing expertise, right? I mean, it's actually the knock against Apple in tech circles

1:03:15forever against people who don't like their products are, is that it's just, it's all

1:03:20smoke and mirrors and marketing and they trick people, you know, with clever marketing into

1:03:25buying inferior computers, you know, right? I mean, you and I have been covering this.

1:03:30We've made like a careers out of it. That their marketing is so good that people who

1:03:35don't like their products think that's why people buy the products. And therefore, that

1:03:40other people would follow their lead, right? Like, well, we're not as good at marketing

1:03:44and advertising as Apple. And if Apple is pulling out of Twitter, then we should pull

1:03:48out of Twitter. And vice versa, like if Apple started advertising on some new, you know,

1:03:56TikTok, right? If Apple, all of a sudden, the word comes out that Apple is spending

1:04:02significantly increased amount of money on TikTok, a lot of other advertisers and smaller

1:04:07companies would say, "Hey, if it's good for Apple, it might be good for us. Maybe we should

1:04:10increase our spend on TikTok." I think that's probably obviously true that people follow

1:04:15the leader and Apple is a leader in marketing and therefore Musk is trying to cut it off.

1:04:21But it's also funny to me that he's done it by highlighting the fact, right? Like, that's

1:04:28what makes him so...

1:04:29I mean, he thinks he's going to win this, right? And he thinks he's going to bully them

1:04:32into coming back, I guess? Or is it just, is it an effect of like saying, "Look how

1:04:39obnoxious I am being to Apple. Imagine what I'm going to do to you."

1:04:42Do you, right? I guess, maybe? I don't even know. I'm not quite sure. Yeah, I don't know

1:04:48how much of it he goes, much like our former president. I don't know how much he does,

1:04:53who I believe...

1:04:54He's surprisingly like him. I mean, he is shockingly similar in his tweeting style as

1:05:00well as seemingly his personal style.

1:05:03Yeah, I think so too. And including the fact that he's obviously very cunning and he has

1:05:08a very good sense of how things will play to his base, for lack of a better word, and

1:05:14knows his base. And it's like the Pied Piper knows exactly what music the kids want to

1:05:21listen to. He knows the tune. And those of us who aren't in the demo, right? We hear

1:05:29the Pied Piper's music and we're like, "I don't get it." Right? That doesn't sound...

1:05:35What's this crap?

1:05:36Yeah, what's this crap? Why are you guys following this guy? I don't even like that. He knows

1:05:40that. I don't know how it's going to play out. But I do think on the App Store front,

1:05:51if I were at Apple, I would consider it... I would be having very serious meetings, strategy

1:05:56meetings to deal with it. Because the one thing Apple hasn't really dealt with with

1:06:03the App Store commissions is a high profile complainant. Epic is the closest, right?

1:06:16Yeah. I mean, Epic is pretty close though, not because of Epic being Epic, but because

1:06:21Fortnite was so popular.

1:06:22Exactly, right. And that's what people are bringing that up with, "Well, Apple's not

1:06:28going to just remove..." I've seen people say, "Apple isn't... No matter what Twitter

1:06:32is, they're not going to just boot it off the App Store because they've got 200 million

1:06:36users." But there were like, I don't know, like 100 million iOS Fortnite users. I mean,

1:06:42it was massively popular and they booted it. But they booted it for actions that Epic took

1:06:51that weren't in any gray zone at all. By Epic's own admission, right? Epic, for those who

1:06:57don't remember, put an update to Fortnite into the App Store with no mention of this

1:07:03feature being embedded in the app. And the app, I don't know if it was timed or if it

1:07:10was like they would phone home and when Epic flipped a switch on their server, then the

1:07:14app would know, "Okay, the switch has been flipped." And then all of a sudden, the app

1:07:19that had already gone through App Store review and was on people's phones started offering

1:07:24people the ability to buy V-Bucks, their in-game currency, without going through the App Store.

1:07:32And Apple took none too kindly to it and within four days had removed Fortnite from the App

1:07:40Store and it still is, lo, these many years later, a major lawsuit that Apple won still

1:07:46isn't back. And I guess the one thing they didn't do, Apple did not flip the kill switch

1:07:54that removed Fortnite from people's phones. I'm not even sure what that switch is. I don't

1:07:58know that it deletes it. I think what they could do is remove a certification like that.

1:08:04And then the app wouldn't run on your phones. You'd still have it taking up space on your

1:08:08phone, but it wouldn't run. They didn't do that. But the way Fortnite works, and I think

1:08:15most just about any multiplayer game, like the whole point of Fortnite is you're playing

1:08:22against, I don't even know if there is a single player mode. I don't think so. I don't think

1:08:26it would make any sense. So it's only multiplayer and they go, if you're not on the latest version

1:08:33and everybody else on every other platform, like PCs and consoles is running a future

1:08:40version with different maps and different characters, the old version can no longer

1:08:44play. So it effectively killed Fortnite. Even without making the binary not run on your

1:08:50phones, it effectively killed Fortnite. So they did it. But that was a epic declared

1:08:56war, right? Epic by doing that. I don't see Apple doing that with Twitter. I really don't.

1:09:02But they might, if it comes to it, if push came to shove and something was that alarming

1:09:08to Apple content wise, I think the fact that they did it to Fortnite and they were making,

1:09:14I don't know. I don't know how much money Apple was making from Fortnite on iOS, but

1:09:18it was significant money because people do spend players of Fortnite do spend a lot of

1:09:25money in game. And that's why Epic, I mean, if, if there weren't in game purchases, Epic

1:09:30wouldn't have even bothered, right? This wouldn't be an issue. So there's a lot of money at

1:09:33stake and Apple was making a lot of money from Fortnite and did it. Apple doesn't make

1:09:37a lot of money from Twitter. There are very few in app purchases. The only in app purchases

1:09:41that I'm aware of are, well, there's Twitter blue, blue, which I, you know, is the thing

1:09:47that Musk wants to boost, but most people, I don't, I know very few people who pay for

1:09:52it. And then you can do the super follow thing where there's like 2000 users of Twitter who've

1:09:58opted into this super follow program where you get like a, it's like a member fold type

1:10:05thing, but on Twitter. So you can, if I were to offer super follows, which I don't, but

1:10:11you could super follow me for $3 a month and I'd get a dollar a month or something like

1:10:17that. And then I can post special tweets that only show up to the people who are paying

1:10:21me, you know, in videos and I don't know, whatever the features, it's not a very popular feature

1:10:27so far. So it's not like Apple would be losing money by booting Twitter like they did with

1:10:32Fortnite. So I think they might, but I just think, I just think Musk is taking umbrage

1:10:37at the fact that Apple has any control over their software updates at all. Yeah. And people,

1:10:44but, but a lot of people are taking him at his word that Apple has already threatened

1:10:48to remove the app from the store. I don't think that's happened. No, I don't think that's

1:10:52happened either. But who knows? I don't know. It's, it's interesting. I do think though,

1:10:58I don't know. Where do you see it going with the money though? I do that, that I'll just

1:11:02circle back to that before we close off the topic. But I do think Elon Musk can shine

1:11:09a light on this. I mean, cause that's the other funny tweet that he had yesterday that

1:11:12was positing it is, and again, it's very, for lack of a better word, Trumpian, you know,

1:11:20the way that you, like one of Trump's big ticks of course is many people are saying,

1:11:25right? So Musk doesn't, Musk doesn't do that one, but he, this is very Trumpian where you

1:11:34allege that something that has been out in the open was done in secret. Here's his tweet.

1:11:41Did you know Apple puts a secret 30% tax on everything you buy through their app store?

1:11:46That's the whole tweet. But, uh, I loved your, uh, your, your, your end, your final sentence

1:11:54when you wrote that up yesterday. Yes. I think I recall hearing something about this once,

1:12:01but uh, Ben Thompson says, Ben, our friend of the show, actual friend, literal friend

1:12:06of the show, Ben Thompson says that he was asked by several people yesterday, is this

1:12:11true? You know, that there are people who don't know that Apple, you know, that don't

1:12:15pay attention to this closely, people outside the tech circle, uh, you know, which I guess

1:12:20should not be surprising. I think they're, they're probably the most people's concern

1:12:25is does that mean they charge 30% more? Right. As opposed to, Oh, it's the same, you know,

1:12:31it's the same, then they find it. It's the same price. They're like, Oh, I don't care.

1:12:36Yeah. I, and yeah, cause that's my, my take too is that, all right, once these people

1:12:41who didn't know about it, are they then outraged or are they not surprised at all? I mean,

1:12:47you and I know this, but from having so many friends who are app developers full time,

1:12:53um, that, or especially in the earlier days of the app store, when I think there were,

1:12:59there was a lot more indie app action on the iOS app store. Um, but then people would go

1:13:06and they'd say, Oh, well, what do you do? And you're like, I make iPhone apps and they're

1:13:10like, Oh, so you work for Apple. And they're like, no, no, I make them on my own. And they're

1:13:15very confused. And that there were a lot of people maybe still are who assume that just

1:13:19about anything that's not from another big company on the app store is from Apple. You

1:13:24know, again, that makes no sense if you know anything, but people, you know, they're not

1:13:30that they're not paid to know anything, you know, they're the people that's not, people

1:13:34don't need to know that, but an awful lot of people think like indie games are effectively

1:13:39all like Apple arcade, right? That, that Apple is paying for them and that the money goes

1:13:44to Apple.

1:13:45Yeah. I mean, I didn't don't think about it that much just because, yeah. So I, I actually

1:13:51know better. I actually, so I actually think there are a lot of people who would be surprised

1:13:55that Apple quote unquote only takes 30% of the sale and they're like, 70% goes to somebody

1:14:00else. That's not what it sounds like a good deal. Right. And it's, you know, I think people

1:14:06on this wasn't, I mean, when Amazon had, you know, well, it was like book sales at least,

1:14:10right. At least it used to be this way. When you wish, when you independently sold a book

1:14:14through Amazon, they took like 90% didn't they back, you know, before the iPad, some

1:14:19ridiculously large amount. I don't, I'm sure they don't do that anymore, but yeah, something

1:14:25like that. It was, it was crazy and it didn't, I don't know. I don't remember, but it was,

1:14:31it was, it was not as, it was not as friendly to the creators for lack of a better summer.

1:14:41But it relatively, but I do think, you know, I, so I don't know that Apple is in trouble.

1:14:46I am. In fact, I would say I don't think Apple is in trouble with their app store situation

1:14:52just because now they have a high profile opponent who is going to publicize it endlessly,

1:14:59but it's, it's uncharted territory for them, right there. They, they dealt with Epic. Epic

1:15:05was the one who really put their, their chin out there and they're dealing with the government

1:15:11regulators here in the U S and especially in Europe regarding this and companies like

1:15:16Spotify doing it the traditional way by petitioning regulators and writing white papers and submitting,

1:15:23you know, things through the process as opposed to just bleeding it out on Twitter. But it,

1:15:29you know, I think it puts them in uncharted territory and it's, you know, again, it's

1:15:34unpredictability is what makes Twitter much less desirable as an advertising venue for

1:15:39brand advertisers right now. But the unpredictability works in Musk's favor for a public argument.

1:15:46Yeah. It's, it's hard to strategize against an unpredictable opponent is, is one way to

1:15:54put it. Right. All right. Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor and it's

1:16:01our good friends at Squarespace. You know, Squarespace. Squarespace is the all in one

1:16:06platform for building your brand and growing your business online or your hobby. It doesn't

1:16:11have to be a business. You want to start a personal site. You want to start a personal

1:16:15portfolio. Squarespace is a great place, but if you want to build a business online, man,

1:16:19they've got the features. You can stand out with a beautiful website, engage with your

1:16:23audience and sell anything, your products, the content you create, even your time. You

1:16:28can do that right there on your Squarespace website. They've got member areas where you

1:16:34can, uh, make it easy. They make it easy for creators to monetize their content and expertise

1:16:38in a way that fits their brand. With these member areas, you can unlock new revenue streams

1:16:43for your business and free up time in your schedule by selling access to gated content

1:16:49for your paying members. Things like videos, online courses, newsletters, anything you

1:16:55think people can pay for with a membership type thing. You could do it through Squarespace,

1:16:59uh, online stores, sell your products. You have physical products to sell, set up a store

1:17:04at Squarespace and you can do everything from keep your catalog online and all the assets

1:17:09and manage the way it looks to the actual commerce, taking the credit cards, getting

1:17:14the money from the customers into your bank account. They have all the tools you need

1:17:19to start selling on line. Head to squarespace.com/talk show squarespace.com/talk show. You get a

1:17:2830 day free trial, all features unlocked, no watermarks on the site. It is the full

1:17:34thing. Use it for a month. See how much you like it and when you're ready to launch after

1:17:38the free trials over, use that offer code talk show T A L K S H O W talk show and you

1:17:44save 10% with that code off your first purchase, including prepaying for up to a year. My thanks

1:17:51to Squarespace. Uh, should we, I segue from Twitter. Yeah, I was going to say it's an

1:17:58exhausting topic. It is led this point. It was fun at the beginning and now it's got

1:18:03to the point where it's like every day is another let's segue from Twitter then to Mastodon,

1:18:10which I have not really written about or talked about. Uh, it is what you, you're on it and

1:18:19using it. So why don't you describe Mastodon for people? I'm sure everybody's heard about

1:18:23it, but it's, Hmm. Yeah. So it's, I mean, from a user perspective, it seems a bit like

1:18:30early Twitter. A lot of the apps are a little clunky. You either use the web interface or

1:18:36you use an app that's clunky. The nice thing is that there, there are, there are a number

1:18:42of apps, at least on the iPhone. There's only a couple on the Mac. Um, and none of them

1:18:48are great, but this, but the idea is the, this is a server based thing that anybody

1:18:56can set up their own server and then the servers talk to each other and you join a particular

1:19:03server. So I have a join mastodon.social, which is the largest one. And I think has

1:19:08since cut off, um, adding new people at least temporarily because they had so many people

1:19:13who were switching from Twitter to Mastodon that they couldn't handle the load. Um, and

1:19:18you know, people are doing this for not really any money, I guess. I mean, you know, he has

1:19:22a, he has a, um, Patreon. Um, I do contribute to the Patreon and like, you know, like if

1:19:29you, if you work for a company like, um, I think, uh, what's the company that, uh, makes

1:19:34the tap bots. Yeah. Um, they have their own, they're running their own server now and,

1:19:39um, it looks like they are going to do, um, a client map so that, um, looking forward

1:19:45to that, the makers of tweet bot, the makers of tweet bot. Yeah. And I don't know what

1:19:51else to say about it. Um, it's much more confusing than Twitter. Certainly joining is very much

1:19:57more confusing than Twitter because you have to pick an instance that to join and then

1:20:02your handle is like, wait, no, I'm it's mastodon.social/at-molt. That's my whole user ID and it becomes complicated

1:20:15trying to figure out how to, um, link to tweets. It becomes complicated trying to figure out

1:20:19how to link to someone that you want, you know, if you want to follow them or have other

1:20:23people follow them or whatever, or yourself. Um, so a lot of it is difficult to manage.

1:20:31And so I think for lots of people, it's not going to be easy to use. It's certainly not

1:20:35as easy to use as Twitter, right? They call it the Fediverse it is because it's federated.

1:20:41So the, the, the universe of federated websites or, or services that are, and it's not just

1:20:48mastodon. It's called activity pub, I believe is the sort of pro the open protocol. So,

1:20:55uh, and a lot of, a lot of other services are starting to tie into that. Right. Like,

1:21:01um, tumblr has promised. Yes, it's not there yet, but micro micro.blog from again, actual

1:21:09friend of the show, Manton Reese, which is not mastodon, but is micro blogging, which

1:21:15is like, you can post really short, uh, no, you don't need a subject or anything. You

1:21:19just post a little short thing. You, when you follow people on microblog, you can at

1:21:24reply them and it's Twitter like at a very high level. And by integrating with these

1:21:32protocols, your micro.blog account can federate with mastodon. And what you can do and what

1:21:42works across this is confusing because it isn't centralized. Uh, you know, the analogy,

1:21:48you know, the analogy actually works and it's modeled, I guess, on email in some way where

1:21:53you, like you said, you're at moltz@mastodon.social. So you've got two at symbols, your name and

1:22:02your, the at your instance name. And if somebody else is on, there's another big one called

1:22:09mastodon.online and somebody else could be moltz@mastodon.online and there's, you know,

1:22:18so that your name is not unique except on your instance, but that's just like email

1:22:23where there's only one. Yeah. Jane Doe@gmail.com. God bless her if that's a real person, but

1:22:32um, you know, there's all, there can only be one username at domain for email. There

1:22:40can only be one username at domain for mastodon, but you can it. And again, email used to work

1:22:47like this way back in the nineties, in the early days when all of the emails through

1:22:51like pine and elm on the terminal, your local users, like when I was at Drexel university,

1:22:59I didn't need to know their full address. I just needed their username, you know, so

1:23:03I was UJ Gruber, undergrad J Gruber. It was my assigned email address in the computer

1:23:09science department. I could email if you were there, UJ moltz@mastodon.com and I wouldn't

1:23:15need to type in the rest of your email address if it was just your username. I was on there,

1:23:23you know, and now, you know, my email client was the server. So you can do that on Mastodon,

1:23:28like so I'm on mastodon.social as well and I can just @moltz you without the rest of

1:23:37it and it'll work this. But to me that's a little confusing, right? It's and email quickly

1:23:43got away from that where no matter even if you were at work and everybody has the same

1:23:48at company.com address, you still are sending email to the username at company.com. Yeah,

1:23:55it. I mean the nice thing that it allows that having those different instances allow is

1:24:02that you can I mean if it works out correctly, you could have be on an instance where either

1:24:07it's your company or it's a group of people that you share an interest with and when you

1:24:13go you can look at just the timeline for that instance right and that has benefits that

1:24:18I'm not taking advantage of any of those benefits because I happen to be on the largest instance

1:24:22and looking at it is just you know it's useless because it's just a constant stream of right

1:24:27random posts from different people. Right, it's effectively like looking at it because

1:24:34mastodon.social is so big it is the biggest. It's effectively like looking at all of Twitter

1:24:41in the early days. Yeah, when you used to have that tab. Thousands of users or a hundred

1:24:46thousand users not hundreds of millions but you could and there are smaller instances

1:24:53that maybe only have a hundred people or only friends you know somebody can set up a mastodon

1:24:58instance and you know in theory I could set one up and have only former guests of the

1:25:04talk show on and if you wanted an account you know maybe there'd you know so there'd

1:25:08be like two dozen people on the instance. It's not the worst idea. I think it's a

1:25:17really solid idea. I just think that it does not always work effectively. I think the idea

1:25:25that it's going to lead to a fantastic outcome is idealistic and I'm certainly rooting

1:25:30for it and again I hate to be the rainer on the parade. I guess you don't piss on a parade

1:25:35but you could but let's just call it rain. I hate to be the weather weather man calling

1:25:43for rain on the parade but I don't I don't see it working out as a as a replacement for

1:25:50Twitter but I will say I will say that I mean I have but I've been able to it has it has

1:25:57effectively replaced it has replaced the aspect of Twitter which is like being a part of a

1:26:03community and being able to see posts from other people who I you know know online and

1:26:09I mean the thing that it hasn't done is replace you know the news aspect of it very well because

1:26:16there aren't any I mean there are some but there aren't very many professional news organizations

1:26:22that have accounts on there to follow at this point or like you know entertainment stuff

1:26:29I want to know you know I'm interested in because I do a podcast about dumb superhero

1:26:33shows you know that kind of stuff so it it's a work in progress but you know I do see more

1:26:39and more people joining it and I do see more and more organizations joining it right and

1:26:43Neil Dash was on my show two episodes ago and mentioned there's a I'll put the link

1:26:49in the show notes again it's in the Neil Dash show but there's a couple of tools including

1:26:53one that's made with the Neil's company's tool glitch called Feta finder FED fed if

1:26:59finder not like Kevin Fed what was that guy's name he married Britney Spears yeah Federer

1:27:06not him and not Roger Federer it's about the Federation of Mastodon instances but you can

1:27:12use Feta finder you log in with your Twitter credentials it crawls through you give it

1:27:16permission it crawls through your Twitter followers and you can do things like there's

1:27:23I should put this in the show notes to the link to the recommended what do you do if

1:27:27you're moving to Mastodon or just even if you're staying on Twitter but are adding

1:27:32Mastodon to your social presence how do you let people discover you there are recommended

1:27:37ways of putting it in putting your your Mastodon ID in your bio for Twitter and a tool like

1:27:44Feta finder will crawl through all of your followers the people you follow look for those

1:27:50hey that this person you follow on Twitter they've got this thing in their bio they're

1:27:56so-and-so at Mastodon whatever on Mastodon and then you can subscribe to them on on Mastodon

1:28:03and it's you know it is it's it's super it's fun to see it moving fast it there is absolutely

1:28:10positively a spirit of the 20 year ago open web yeah that that you know never went away

1:28:17but obviously went through a long cycle where the the internet was ever increasingly dominated

1:28:24by an incredibly large instances to borrow the the the the Mastodon term right Facebook

1:28:33is an incredibly you know the largest it's hard you know literally with three or four

1:28:37billion users as large as a social network could be without interplanetary networking

1:28:43to other civilizations right as so long as the internet is limited to earth Facebook

1:28:49is as big as anything could get but even email right email used to be everybody you know

1:28:5520 some years ago there were very few people in my address book who had the same domain

1:29:02name for their email right it was all you know everybody had you know either a personal

1:29:06domain or a school domain and now it's all gmail.com or icloud.com or whatever you know

1:29:14that that a handful of big instances won out but there's tools for that and that's that's

1:29:19very fun yeah I think eventually we'll get to the point where I mean I would imagine

1:29:24we'll get to the point where services like I'm trying to think of this Dreamhost which

1:29:33is one of the services that I use currently you know they they have these one-click installs

1:29:38for things like WordPress I would imagine that they will set up one-click installs for

1:29:41a Mastodon instance at some point the trick of course is that you run into the same problems

1:29:47the Twitter experiences if you're gonna run your own instance that's just you that's fine

1:29:51but you're gonna run an instance that is like well I'm gonna say because I thought maybe

1:29:54I should set one up and like invite some people to it and then you suddenly have to become

1:29:59the moderator for that instance right and you're on the hook so for everything everybody's

1:30:03been and this has been an issue with the early you know with this with this transition of

1:30:08a lot of people fleeing Twitter and going to Mastodon is you're running into lots of

1:30:13moderation clashes and one of the thing that's one of the things that's very well that is

1:30:19sort of a cultural feature that's often used on Mastodon is content warning so they're

1:30:25it's built into the system that you can you know obscure your post with a content warning

1:30:31and write you know this is about whatever it is and then they if people don't want to

1:30:36see what it is they you know like you know like grizzly murder you could you could put

1:30:41it as a content warning or you know politics or whatever and you know and people who are

1:30:47who are okay with going ahead to read it can click the button and then see the post and

1:30:53you know a lot of people of color came over from Twitter to Mastodon and were just you

1:30:59know posting things about racism and not putting them behind content warning warnings because

1:31:04they shouldn't really have to but that's the kind of thing that riled people on Mastodon

1:31:13and so they would you know get take umbrage and tell them that they should be putting

1:31:18content warnings about this content about racism which is a really bad look for people

1:31:23to do that because if you go around and tell people of color that they should not be talking

1:31:28about racism openly then you're basically just you know providing cover for racism so

1:31:34these kinds of things these kinds of problems have crept up here and there I really feel

1:31:37like most I mean like there were a couple of moderation problems on Mastodon social

1:31:43I think the you know the guy who runs that instance responded pretty well to to those

1:31:49and you know said these okay this is a mistake I wish you apologies for both of these things

1:31:55this is what we're going to try and do to go you know going forward to do this better

1:31:58we're still looking for more more moderators because these people you know flooded over

1:32:02from Twitter to Mastodon and and they can't keep up with the moderation right so you know

1:32:09it's a lot of it's a lot of growing pains and um I I'm you know I think I feel like

1:32:15for the most part everybody's trying to work them out but uh well you know it's well and

1:32:19I work in progress for sure I sympathize with the long time Mastodon users I don't remember

1:32:24what happened but apparently I signed up for Gruber at Mastodon social in 2018 it seems

1:32:30like listening to other podcasts like ATP there's a lot of other people in our circle

1:32:36who did the same thing I don't remember what it was I don't remember um yeah it was yeah

1:32:42it was something politically related I believe a lot of us went over and started setting

1:32:48up Mastodon instances and there's your accounts rather there's a lot there's a lot I don't

1:32:53remember from around 2018 yeah trying not to uh but I had signed up for it then but

1:32:59obviously there was some you know many thousands I don't know tens of thousands of people who've

1:33:07been actively using Mastodon for four years and have created their own culture and were

1:33:13very happy you know it's it's like you know homesteading right like so okay colonial America

1:33:21was all on the east coast and then uh people Americans started moving west and they'd have

1:33:29small pockets of small communities and then all of a sudden uh millions of people came

1:33:36over and founded Chicago you know what I mean and you know it it it's it's clearly the influx

1:33:47of recent in the last month massive influx surely I I it's got to be the case that there

1:33:53are now more users on who've signed up for Mastodon in the last month than who signed

1:33:58up in the previous four years combined but it's those people who'd been using it for

1:34:02four years who established their own culture and these things like the content warnings

1:34:08and I sympathize you know that if you were happy in September and October of this year

1:34:14with the way Mastodon was working for you as your quiet little space that is Twitter

1:34:18like but with your own community and these people and none of the nonsense that drove

1:34:24you away from Twitter or you know if you used again maybe you still kept your Twitter going

1:34:29but also enjoyed using Mastodon separately but embraced the differences culturally I

1:34:36sympathize that all these Twitter people are coming over and are acting you know like yahoos

1:34:43yeah like yahoos right which is you know and I hate to say it because I am I am I am a

1:34:49proud American I even after all of this I love this country and you know I'm it's impossible

1:34:57for me to separate my personality from American culture but it is a very American thing to

1:35:02do I wreck I am self-aware enough of myself and America that that is a very American thing

1:35:07to do is to be new in town and start demanding that you conform to the norms from Twitter

1:35:13as opposed to the norms that you've happily established here the content warning thing

1:35:18drives me nuts I think it's crazy now I would say the way to explain it and it's I guess

1:35:24Twitter I guess clients have to use it I mean if they didn't I don't I it's so culturally

1:35:29I don't know why they wouldn't I mean but you don't it's not on by default right so

1:35:33but the best if you haven't used mastodon the best way to think about it is for spoilers

1:35:38right so if yeah if mastodon had existed in 1981 you could go see the Empire Strikes Back

1:35:46and then and again here I'll use the verb I mentioned that we'd use it instead of tweets

1:35:51they have toots you can although that's changed too oh has it yeah cuz apparently it was originally

1:35:57posts and then toots came about because some youtuber was talking about mastodon and joked

1:36:04that if they changed it from posts to toots that he would donate to the development and

1:36:11so they did and he got I don't know how much he donated I mean like but well some of these

1:36:16youtubers have a lot of money so maybe yeah I know yeah and then they recently you know

1:36:22in the I think in the 4.0 update for mastodon they set it back to post but a lot of the

1:36:28I mean you know it's already in the culture and it's also in a lot of the third-party apps

1:36:32so I don't know I don't know if it'll ever go away completely but it is not it's not

1:36:36currently part of the official ringo they use it they you know as opposed to farting

1:36:42there they they yeah it is like a trumpet you know tooting yeah well and you know I

1:36:48think that the main developer is European and I think the the youtuber was also not

1:36:55not American so that in that implication that definite meaning was not intended well then

1:37:00I'll go back to post you could post on your mastodon and coming right out of the Empire

1:37:04Strikes Back you could post that holy shit Darth Vader is Luke's father and then if

1:37:11you put the appropriate content warning that it's a spoiler on it you would have you'll

1:37:16anger nobody yeah and break no norms and ruin the movie for no one and only other your people

1:37:24who follow you who've also been in line to see it on day one could unfurl it and then

1:37:29they can write you know so spoilers would be the the it's actually the best that's

1:37:34the well yeah I mean that's the that's the use that I think everybody can I yeah I think

1:37:40that the culture around some some some communities on mastodon of using those things for practically

1:37:51everything practically everything and I don't even understand some cases at least with like

1:37:55you said like with talking about some people want anything of a discussion of racism behind

1:38:01a button because it it bothers you to see anything think about it to even think about

1:38:06it I mean I will say that you know I mean the years 2016 to 2020 there were a lot of

1:38:16politics things that I did not want to look at and being on Twitter was extremely stressful

1:38:22and you know no matter how much I muted certain people and topics you'd still end up seeing

1:38:28something that would you know bleed over in one way or another and so I kind of I mean

1:38:33I get it to I get it to a certain degree like I understand there are times there are definitely

1:38:40times when I don't want to be and that's one of the nice things about being on mastodon

1:38:44now is is that it's not so angst ridden I guess it's a it's a little bit more like

1:38:51Twitter used to be back yeah you know before everything went to hell and a little bit more

1:38:58fun that way so it's like I kind of get it but I also I also do think like oh my gosh

1:39:03people are putting these things on on like posts that are in no way controversial right

1:39:10yeah we're getting versatile yeah so I and I just sort of feel like I don't know I don't

1:39:16think that's helping with their coat with the culture of friendliness and avoiding angst

1:39:21my opinion if I become an active mastodon user I would I can't foresee using that for

1:39:27anything other than spoilers for movies and stuff like that and and if anybody is bothered

1:39:33by the fact that I'll tweet or toot or post or whatever about things that you think I

1:39:38should put use these content warnings for then just don't follow I mean I that's and

1:39:44again I'm not trying to be dismissive I'm just like I I'm not getting into that and

1:39:48I actually think that's the whole point of following somebody is I would like to hear

1:39:51and see what you do and I don't want to have to tap on all these things I find I think

1:39:55I think that's a perfectly fine decision to make too and and you know I mean I I understand

1:40:01that a little bit more than I understand putting content warnings on literally everything but

1:40:06if you also want to do that that's fine too yeah I but I'm probably not gonna follow

1:40:10you before we wrap up I should add that I do have that is me on Gruber at mastodon dot

1:40:17social I have not posted anything yet I've favorited some I'm hesitant to become active

1:40:24like if I want to become active I want to I want to know I'm there to stay and I'm very

1:40:28uncertain then there's a thing there's a feature a couple of warnings in my opinion you can

1:40:36move from one instance to another but it's it's a lot like moving from it's like you

1:40:42can get a new email address your email doesn't come with you so let's say well you're yeah

1:40:46you know your followers do yes so so you lose all your old I mean well you don't lose them

1:40:52your old account will still be there I mean you can I mean I had I've had more than one

1:40:56account and I moved from I moved from mastadon dead social to a different server so everybody

1:41:01instantly who was following me on mastadon dead social was following me on the new server

1:41:05right and then that server shut down so I moved back and they all came back but I lost

1:41:10the posts right in between because that server shut down right it so if yeah so you're at

1:41:16the liberty of the server you're on existing in perpetuity for your for your post to exist

1:41:22in perpetuity I'm not complaining about the fact that when if I move to a different mastadon

1:41:28server my account I think what they've done is perfect for what they've designed that

1:41:33your followers move so if there's a thousand people out there who follow me and I move

1:41:38to Gruber at mastadon dot something else and those thousand people just automatically still

1:41:45follow me after I flipped that switch but my previous posts are still over on the old

1:41:50server I get it that they can't move your posts with you because it would be a content

1:41:56moderation nightmare some yeah somebody is on a an instance with a very liberal policy

1:42:04on whatever subject matter X subject matter X and you've got 10,000 posts about it and

1:42:12then you move to an instance where X is either not allowed or is much more stringently moderated

1:42:18you can't just you well you could but he it's a good design that your 10,000 existing

1:42:23posts don't move over and you know and then there's the old adage from way back at the

1:42:30origin of the web like 1991 you know tim burners-lee that cool URLs don't change you know that

1:42:37your URL for your posts shouldn't change from one instance to another but it just makes

1:42:42me hesitant to dive all in unless I'm really really sure that mastadon dot social or wherever

1:42:47else I might create an account is really where I want to stay yeah I and I wish I was on

1:42:52a different I wish I was on an instance that I felt more I mean I mean I don't think this

1:42:56one's gonna go anywhere but I don't you know I don't feel like it represents me in any way

1:43:01and I don't feel like I'm getting any benefit out of that right it it seems like a neutral

1:43:06server it's it means it means no more about who you are or what groups you're in than

1:43:11being on Twitter itself I'm you know I guess I'm not as precious about my tweets I mean

1:43:19I I have downloaded my Twitter my I downloaded my Twitter history like a few years ago and

1:43:26then all these people recently were like oh I got a Russian me you know make sure I get

1:43:29my archive got to get my archive before you know musk burns the whole site to the ground

1:43:35and I was like I got a couple years ago so I don't really like I don't feel like I need

1:43:40the the the the Delta between 2018 and today yeah I don't know it's it's breaking me down

1:43:50though I might start to yeah I mean like I said I mean it's it's it's helped it's I

1:43:55mean it it's like going on methadone after you know an addiction like I it's helped me

1:44:00not be looking at Twitter all the time because I it man I've been on this been on that site

1:44:07for 15 years and it really became part of my part of my everyday experience so yeah

1:44:13part of this is part of your mental state every day yeah kinda for better better and

1:44:17worse and this is really made it much easier to go without it so the last I guess the last

1:44:25thing I'll say about it is maybe it's not the worst thing in the world that mastadon

1:44:29seems by design and then human nature destined never to become a mainstream breakout maybe

1:44:37that's yeah it could be maybe that's you know not the worst thing in the world that then

1:44:42a lot of you know the things that I that the fond memories I have of early Twitter are

1:44:47because it wasn't mainstream and and exactly mastadon has an upper ceiling on its mainstream

1:44:52appeal because of its conceptual complication of the being federated maybe that's not the

1:45:01worst thing in the world and maybe that's sort of the secret to it and why you know

1:45:06five years from now we'll look back at this episode of the podcast and my hesitance to

1:45:11dive in will look foolish you know because hey it's a lot better over there because right

1:45:16our buddy elbert mcmurray who lives who I saw last night he had a he created a chart

1:45:22this was a long time ago even but you know it was a it was a graph of number of Twitter

1:45:27users and it's you know it's line that went you know slowly going up and then all of a

1:45:32sudden shot up at the end and then he highlighted like the first the first three years in there

1:45:37with it you know where the line was very low and and and put a bar around and saying the

1:45:42good years so it is a little I think it's a little bit like that it's not exactly the

1:45:47same of course but I get that sort of vibe sometimes all right I'm gonna take a break

1:45:52here and thank our third and final sponsor our good friends at collide they spell it

1:45:56k o l i d e collide if you're listening to this podcast the talk show the odds are very

1:46:02good that at some point your company is going to go through an audit like soc two or iso

1:46:0827 001 and when you do you'll have to answer some tough questions about endpoint security

1:46:15questions like do all of your company's laptops have their disks encrypted does everyone have

1:46:20the company's password manager installed do you have a system in place to monitor and

1:46:24maintain compliance throughout your cross-platform fleet even if you're confident the answer

1:46:30to all of those questions is yes the bigger question when you're faced with one of these

1:46:34audits is can you prove it to an auditor if you're not quite sure how you'd go about proving

1:46:40compliance across your fleet of devices then you need collide collide is an endpoint security

1:46:46tool for mac windows and linux devices that does things that mdms can't do and gives you

1:46:53the visibility you need to achieve and maintain compliance best of all collide does not resort

1:46:58to surveilling employees or locking down devices it doesn't fight your employees it helps them

1:47:04instead it works with end users to resolve issues and relies on their cooperation and

1:47:10their informed consent you can meet your security goals and you can pass improve an audit without

1:47:16compromising on privacy visit collide.com/the talk show to find out how if you follow that

1:47:24link collide.com/the talk show they will hook you up with a goodie bag including a t-shirt

1:47:30just for activating a free trial that's k-o-l-i-d-e.com/the talk show collide.com/the talk show i

1:47:40i we're back from the sponsor break but i have one more mastodon quip you mentioned

1:47:44the dearth of mac native clients there's a bunch of ios apps that are in development

1:47:49and you have a bunch to choose from it's actually so many it's fun it reminds me of the early

1:47:54days of twitter you know where there's no consolidation in the third-party clients and

1:48:01there's a lot of good options uh really no i hate to say it because i don't want to crap

1:48:07on anybody's existing apps but there's no there's no good mac app there's mastodon is

1:48:12the mass and that's the yeah that seems like the best one that's what i'm currently using

1:48:16but it's missing a ton of features it's so early days it's well and i think yeah i mean

1:48:20a lot of a lot of you know they were they these were probably just hobby you know side

1:48:25gigs for people who are developing developing them for fun for the most part i guess i don't

1:48:30know but um and so but they there was no urgency right there weren't that many users and now

1:48:37there's a lot and um it's becoming a bigger bigger deal yeah but it makes me the the the

1:48:44die-hard mac user in me is a little sad and it's you know nothing i'm not surprised by

1:48:47but it's the way i'm not saying mac native mac development is dying but it's still shrinking

1:48:53in my opinion and it's clearly being squeezed out by web apps right and and the answer is

1:48:58well wait if there's no good mac clients what do people do on their desktop they use the

1:49:01mastodon websites you know they go to the web the web interface you know it's like going

1:49:06to twitter.com on your browser instead of using an app um and you know there's ways

1:49:12to turn the website into a standalone app you know there's tools that let you do that

1:49:17so you can command tab to it instead of just fishing it out of your browser tabs um but

1:49:23i actually got this from you on mastodon today the most interesting mac client is a new one

1:49:30called maxedadon and it looks really really cool but it's not going to be relevant to

1:49:39a lot of people because it's actually a mac client for 68k yeah that's right classic max

1:49:46in other words system system six system seven era 68k motorola 68 000 era max uh this is

1:49:54not a joke it is a real client it warms my heart to see yeah oh yeah it's great i know

1:50:00it's just you know the idea that somebody did that is um fresh fresh screen screenshots

1:50:06of the classic system seven look with geneva nine all over the place so when when the most

1:50:13interesting mac client is written for max that came out 32 years ago it's you know you

1:50:20could kind of tell most people are using the website these days but hats off to i don't

1:50:25think any i mean i have several you know max that run old operating systems but i don't

1:50:31think any of them are connected to the internet currently there was no reason to uh what else

1:50:39i had this on the agenda it's brief but talking about rumors of iphone iphone future iphones

1:50:46um yeah there's a rumor that came out well number one there's the this iphone 14 production

1:50:52hit i guess this isn't a rumor i mean there's uh really really interesting protests going

1:50:57on all over china in reaction to their zero covid policy and the lockdown you know that's

1:51:04the china people in china are fed up and it's an unprecedented in decades amount of public

1:51:11protests in china uh about this i've linked to a couple things yesterday um but one of

1:51:18the places that's been hit by this is apple's foxconn facility the you know and people call

1:51:24it iphone town i think or apple town or something um but because of the the chinese government

1:51:31zero covid policy when you know in covid spreading around over there uh they've locked down the

1:51:37the campus and you know effectively turned the the dormitories at the factories into

1:51:42a prison where you're you know not allowed to leave and i don't think it's an exaggeration

1:51:48to describe it as a riot that you know riot broke out at one point a couple days ago amongst

1:51:53the people who are employed there um people are upset i don't i honestly don't think that

1:51:58this is out there's nothing apple can do about it there's nothing foxconn can do about it

1:52:02it's the chinese government's policy um yeah but people are fed up but the downwind effect

1:52:08of that for apple is apparently that you know and apparently it's particularly the factory

1:52:14that is producing the iphone 14 pro models pro and pro max and bloomberg vlad savav who

1:52:22used previously worked at the verge is now a reporting for bloomberg i think he's stationed

1:52:26over in asia judging by his instagram he's a great photographer too but um that they're

1:52:33projecting bloomberg reported that it's going to be a six million unit shortfall for the

1:52:39quarter and the quarter is obviously the most important one for apple the holiday quarter

1:52:44is when apple sells the most iphones by far you know that when you look at their quarterly

1:52:49results there's it's you know not quite as pronounced as back in the ipod era but there's

1:52:55this you know cycle cycle then the holiday quarter is a big spike and then it goes down

1:53:01down you know and it's not like they sell few iphones yeah the other nine months of

1:53:05the year but this is when they sell the most um ming chi kuo posted on twitter about an

1:53:11hour ago and said that it's going to be more like 15 to 20 million oh that's and yeah there's

1:53:16a big difference right and yeah uh ballpark math i mean apple famously no longer reports

1:53:22things like the average selling price for an iphone but if it's only the iphone 14 pro

1:53:26models i i think and a thousand dollars is a very fair average selling price considering

1:53:35you know might even be a little conservative given the prices of the various capacities

1:53:40and the max and etc but if you just to make the ballpark math easier say it's a thousand

1:53:45dollars per iphone uh every million is a billion dollars of revenue so six million shortfall

1:53:54is six six billion and if it's if ming chi kuo's correct 10 or 15 that's 10 or 15 billion

1:54:00dollars in sales um yeah it you know you and i are are i think infamous for spending tim

1:54:08kook's money during your appearances on this podcast um but i you know you don't have to

1:54:17be uh you know a a crypto genius to to realize that we're talking about sums of money that

1:54:25definitely get tim kook's attention sure oh yeah this is not a rounding error this is

1:54:31not their 50 million dollar ad spend on twitter or you know uh 10 to 15 billion wow that i

1:54:38mean that is humongous and i guess my question as a topic for discussion is how much of the

1:54:46the bump the spike for this quarter's iphone sales year after year how much is because

1:54:53this is the quarter when they're brand new and the enthusiasts are buying them because

1:54:58they're new and how much is it the holiday gift buying because if it's just because they're

1:55:04new i would think that all of those sales will get deferred until next you know the

1:55:10first quarter of next year and you know just place the order now and when it comes it comes

1:55:15but if it's for a holiday gift i don't know you know i i just checked if you miss christmas

1:55:20you miss christmas right and i checked yesterday and if you try to order a new 14 pro on apple.com

1:55:26the dates they're they're promising is december 28th for just i i didn't go through every

1:55:32color and every combination but it seems pretty consistently december 28th which is after

1:55:36christmas uh i think i don't know i'm i'm such a procrastinator on gift buying that

1:55:43i'm not even sure but i believe that that's too late and i can't i can't help but wonder

1:55:49if you're thinking like you know for you know your your teenager or your spouse or whoever

1:55:55was thinking about getting an iphone 14 pro is a christmas gift and you can't get it in

1:56:00time for christmas uh number one you might but i wouldn't take the chance if it was the

1:56:04gift right because apple famously under promises and over delivers on those shipping dates

1:56:09so i'll bet even though it says december 28th if if i ordered one right now i think there's

1:56:14a very good chance it would arrive before december 25th but who can count on that yeah

1:56:20for what again we're talking about a thousand dollars or more what's clearly going to be

1:56:26if it were going to be a holiday gift would be like the biggest gift right that's the

1:56:30big thing for so-and-so in the family this year they're getting a new iphone 14 have

1:56:35you ever given given a night an iphone for uh like for christmas i guess for or for am

1:56:41i like i don't even a birthday i don't like i think i've done it for hank yeah i think

1:56:45we did i think we did it for jonas's first iphone yeah like like seven seven really i

1:56:51don't directly recall that um but um i'm certainly given in computers before but right it always

1:56:57seemed like a weird thing it's always funny when apple sends out their holiday like buying

1:57:03guide or whatever it's like get somebody a two thousand dollar laptop like you really

1:57:10overestimate what i spend on people same here and you know and same with about you know

1:57:15a thousand dollar phone um i it seems like more of like a necessity thing to me that

1:57:21you know you have to buy in and you know and since the cycle being what it is it usually

1:57:27ends up being something we buy in september october yeah but i don't know there is that

1:57:31spike so what explains it you know and uh you know yes i guess more people do it than

1:57:37i could imagine personally you know if i were less of an enthusiast for the iphone and idiotically

1:57:44by buy one as soon as they go on sale every single year but i could imagine that for me

1:57:49i am no matter what no matter which way the universe rolled out there's no way that i

1:57:53was not going to be the difficult person to buy gifts for i am i am very difficult to

1:57:58buy gifts for because there aren't many things i like the things i care about i'm extremely

1:58:03picky about and when i want when i want something i just buy it get it yeah i i as soon as i

1:58:09want something for myself i buy it uh and so it's you know it's a constant source of

1:58:13why in the world did you buy that for yourself in november you should have told me i could

1:58:16have got it for you for christmas and i slapped myself and i have patience i just don't think

1:58:21that way right so i can imagine that as a difficult person to buy gifts for and i want

1:58:26a new iphone i say oh why don't you just get me a new iphone for christmas that'd be great

1:58:29and then you know i'd say oh that's great because it's a thousand dollars it you know

1:58:33done yeah it'll be done i don't have to worry about buying you a bunch of little things

1:58:38to add up to something you could just get night one nice present under the tree and

1:58:41that would be great so i think it's something like that and so those still might get deferred

1:58:46because you want one anyway and you know i i would be the good spirit if it were me and

1:58:51i would just say you know and and uh my wife was like oh my god i was gonna get you told

1:58:55me to get you that iphone for christmas i waited i just checked it says it's not coming till

1:59:00december 28th now i'm you know i i bet you're the same way i'm a good sport i would say

1:59:04oh my god who cares that's fine just put put it on a card put a card under the tree and

1:59:09i'll open you know that's that's a picture of an iphone yeah no hard feelings don't even

1:59:13that don't even sweat it it'll be fun you know it'll be something for me to open a couple

1:59:17days after christmas i don't care i'm not you know but if it's for a kid or something

1:59:21i don't know yeah right right and again when you're talking about the amount of iphones

1:59:25apple sells in this quarter if if it's a five percent hit that's that's serious you know

1:59:31yeah i mean it's not going to tank the company but no but yeah but it's yeah i mean and it's

1:59:36not the thing about it of course is that it's not a i mean it's a it's a headwind for them

1:59:42right but it's not something that's fundamentally wrong with the company right or the products

1:59:45well except for the fact that the only thing that it points to for the company isn't about

1:59:50the quarter in particular but that it shines a spotlight on their depend dependence on china

1:59:55yep yep and we've all known that that could be problematic right it's yeah you know there's

2:00:02the of course uh the what if china invades taiwan right yeah and takes them by force

2:00:08and does a russia ukraine with taiwan um that that could i mean again i don't think it would

2:00:15put apple out of business but it would it would crater the company right in theory and

2:00:20if if the u.s in response did to china what and a lot of other companies right a lot of

2:00:27companies right it's it it would it would be it would be in terms of the upheaval it

2:00:34would cause american companies it it it would dwarf the russia ukraine situation right and

2:00:42the biggest uh export from russia is the gas and oil that europe depends on american you

2:00:51know americans haven't been filling their cars or their house you know household heaters

2:00:55with russian gas and oil but it's a big deal in germany and other countries in europe that

2:01:01the china would dwarf that even by the european standards in terms of how much of the world's

2:01:06manufactured goods come out of come through china in some way um but apple is absolutely

2:01:13you know and the iphone in particular is absolutely beholden to chinese assembly and production

2:01:18and i know they've expanded and they you know make some models in india and i know they

2:01:24they've got foxconn plants in brazil too but they're just a you know drop in the bucket

2:01:31compared to china and however fast they're trying to broaden their dependence and i know

2:01:38there's other products they've been making in vietnam i think a lot of air pods maybe

2:01:41uh yeah i think that that sounds right go through vietnam uh so there there must be

2:01:47i mean you know i'm sure it's it's very difficult right i mean because the that area of china

2:01:53is so specifically set up to do all of this stuff yeah it's a it's a dedicated business

2:02:02zone that does this for multiple companies major companies and it doesn't really exist

2:02:10other places at least not yet anyway and i'm sure it's really a difficult thing to try

2:02:16and not rely on that um and it must be because tim cook is normally he's like the best operations

2:02:25guy in the world and he hasn't been able to figure out a way out of this box right effectively

2:02:33though the the one big gamble in tim cook's tenure as ceo and going back to coo has been

2:02:39a bet that china will remain a dependable participant in the broader worldwide i don't

2:02:52know what you would call it the the global alliance of of countries that share certain

2:02:57values you know and participate in the global economy yeah um and invading taiwan would

2:03:03violate that i don't i think china gets that yeah but it thinks so too but you would i

2:03:08would have thought russia would get it too i mean i'm i'm less surprised by russia invading

2:03:13uk yeah russia is you know i think china's political infrastructure is a little bit more

2:03:20i mean there is a you know a main guy at top but it's not it's not in the same degree as

2:03:25it is right it it's different in a lot of ways and they had china obviously has more

2:03:30to lose than russia but still russia's a little bit more like twitter right now yeah but you

2:03:38know this whole thing with the covid zero policy highlights that g is out of touch in

2:03:45some ways by through his insulation through the party infrastructure and they're you know

2:03:51the the the stranglehold he you know he's he's rewritten the laws of the country so

2:03:56that he he's now starting a third term where it was previous you know he pulled a michael

2:04:01bloomberg you know and and the the culture there of not telling the boss bad news and

2:04:09letting bad news go up when lets them you know it if he convinced himself and seemingly

2:04:16won't back down from a obviously ill-conceived we're not going to tolerate any outbreaks

2:04:22of covid period and and now we you know see actual protests and riots breaking out across

2:04:29the country you know you wonder you wonder what he's being told about what would happen

2:04:34if they took taiwan by force i don't know um it's obviously a bet and that's the to

2:04:38me is where it might uh again i don't you and i don't give stock advice but you know

2:04:44where i could see this hurting apple longer term in terms of the stock in terms of people's

2:04:48outlook isn't the six million or ten to fifteen million wherever that number is iphone 14

2:04:54pros in the last three months of 2022 it's just opening people's minds to the idea of

2:05:01hey when when something really bad happens in china apple is apple there's nothing apple

2:05:06can do about it yeah yeah so i thought that was interesting i'm i'm curious too and and

2:05:11i you know i don't know you know they're again talking back to apple's advertising

2:05:16scratch strategy they don't explain it it's inscrutable but i would expect that whatever

2:05:21they have flexibility on in terms like tv commercials i think are very very flexible

2:05:26up to the last minute where they can you know if they previous you know they say we want

2:05:3030 seconds on this football game they can give the network a new 30-second spot you

2:05:36know maybe not the last second but you know days in advance billboards you know are harder

2:05:41you know you can't change billboards change on a regular schedule but i'm curious to i'm

2:05:45going to try to pay attention to tv commercials and see if they shift to promoting the non-pro

2:05:50iphone 14 and i know that they were going to advertise that anyway even if everything

2:05:55was hunky dory but i'm curious if they just shift all into promoting the non-pro 14 which

2:06:02apparently isn't affected you know just because they can sell it right you know yeah so here's

2:06:09that well and i think that was the wasn't that the the mix uh they i mean they may have

2:06:14some left over because i'd worth the the pros selling really well and the non-pros not selling

2:06:19so great to begin with i i don't know i i never i take those i take all of those things

2:06:24with a grain of salt you should because it's it it doesn't seem to me like it always seems

2:06:29to me with those numbers that the only people who really know aren't going to tell it's

2:06:33like tim cook you know and there's you know luka uh my easy uh you know and whoever else

2:06:39has access to their spreadsheets but uh to to do what else do we have i the only other

2:06:46thing i wanted to do is just to wrap up and circling back to sofa our first sponsor but

2:06:50uh i have a couple of things i just to suggest to watch and i know you watch a lot of tv

2:06:56you said you do the you do the the biff podcast you know um i want to recommend wholeheartedly

2:07:04i have two shows now but the first one is um the peripheral on amazon prime have you

2:07:12seen this i have started it and i'm i'm only a couple episodes two and a half episodes

2:07:17and i think something like that it's good yeah it's really good and i enjoy it quite

2:07:21a bit i mean i've tried to read some of his work um it's what's his name i can't william

2:07:25gibson william gibson yeah i tried to read some of his work back in the 90s and i found

2:07:29it like overly obtuse like i couldn't it was so jargony and like i was just like oh god

2:07:34i i think i tried to read um neuromancer right i think that was the the big one yeah i tried

2:07:40to read one of his books and it was just like it was too much for me i put it down um this

2:07:44is a book that came out like i think in 2013 that they're making based in the show off

2:07:50of and it's much more um approachable it's not so much future jargon i mean it's it's

2:07:57very relatable in terms of like look and feel for um it looks like it could be just like

2:08:03five years from now yeah i i'm exactly with you i remember back in the 90s uh and i think

2:08:08i'm i'm very very sure that he either wrote one great feature article for wired magazine

2:08:14or maybe even a couple and i was like man i i've always had this guy's fiction on my

2:08:20list of things to try i love his non-fiction for wired uh he's a great obviously a great

2:08:26writer and then i got one of his novels and sort of had the same experience of you where

2:08:30i was looking for like bubble gum to chew and it's like this yeah not that it's bad

2:08:35but it wasn't it wasn't easy an easy swallow so i was like uh i think it translates very

2:08:41well to to tv though you know and anyway the gist of it fried up without spoiling anything

2:08:47it is william gibsony in terms of future projections of technology and parts of it take place in

2:08:54the future and uh it is from showrunners uh jonathan nolan and lisa joy who did if those

2:09:03names seem familiar to you were the showrunners for westworld which i guess has been canceled

2:09:08now after the last series um if i can't imagine how anybody who enjoyed westworld especially

2:09:15the first season or two uh you would not enjoy this show i i i would i would think there's

2:09:21like if not 100 venn diagram overlap 99 i can't imagine why somebody would enjoy westworld

2:09:29and not enjoy this show so if you liked westworld especially the first two seasons i think you

2:09:33will enjoy i enjoy this more because it seems more cohesive yeah i think i i enjoy it more

2:09:37too it's also a little less like i wish i only watched the first season of westworld

2:09:42and i thought it was excellent um but it's also rough right yeah and it's yeah it's real

2:09:47it's real violent and yeah dark um this is not i mean it's there's violence in it but

2:09:53it's not as dark i wouldn't say i mean it's you know it's dystopian for sure but it's

2:09:56not like it's less brutal it's not yeah yeah yeah yeah it it's it and less disturbing i

2:10:01guess uh yeah it's a little more adventurey than um yeah really good great cast uh yeah

2:10:09really and the highest compliment i can pay for it pay to it is it was on my list i started

2:10:14watching i wasn't paying attention to how many episodes there are in the season i got

2:10:18to episode seven a week ago and it was the last one and i was despondent i was like i

2:10:24can't wait for episode eight oh my god uh and i still don't know how many i guess there's

2:10:29ten episodes i don't know but then episode eight came out over the weekend and i watched

2:10:32and i thought maybe this was the season finale but it's not and um i don't know what i don't

2:10:37know if i was hoping it would be or not because now i don't know what to do again until friday

2:10:40when another episode comes out excellent show i really really enjoy it and i think people

2:10:45who listen to the show will and i don't want to say anything more other than that it's

2:10:50uh it's just very compelling and interesting and the last thing i'll say has perhaps the

2:10:56best projection of future technology that that i've seen in a long long time in terms

2:11:04of feeling very real like oh that could be exactly what it's like and the way that the

2:11:10characters interact with it is exactly realistic which is that they're they are non-plus they're

2:11:16absolutely not not amazed by their amazing technology at all yeah and you were talking

2:11:23about actors and i don't know the guy's name but the guy who plays her brother so there's

2:11:26is it chloe grace smurts yeah is the main character and she's great but like and i was

2:11:31sort of like expecting the guy who plays her brother to just be sort of like oh he's you

2:11:35know they cast this pretty lunkhead yeah yeah but um but he's really good and i mean and

2:11:41his part unfolds i sort of thought that he was just going to be like background character

2:11:44yeah but his part has a has another layer to it that i won't like yeah yeah discuss

2:11:50but yeah it's it's fun yeah uh and again just perfect material for a 10-part show you know

2:11:58i don't think it would make it would have made for a good two-hour movie at all i think

2:12:01it would have been so you know it's just perfect for this and i think that's that's so true

2:12:06for novels right it's like the old hitchcock used to supposedly never read novels or stopped

2:12:13reading them at some point early in his life because he said that uh i stopped reading

2:12:18novels because i can't stop thinking about turning them into movies but they're terrible

2:12:22as movies because you have to cut so much and yeah what he did he liked reading short

2:12:26stories because short stories translate to two-hour movie perfectly and you can pad them

2:12:31out anyway great recommendation yeah anything from you that you well i i can't believe you

2:12:38haven't watched andor yet i'm kind of flabbergasted that i that you haven't gotten on that because

2:12:44that is and you should you should get on it as soon as possible because it is i think

2:12:47it's absolutely fantastic all it is i yeah i'm skating on thin ice because i've been

2:12:53uh on as near total media blackout on andor as possible yeah but now that it's out and

2:13:00you know it it it's harder and harder and i'm i'm not on it's not innocent but it's

2:13:04not a series that's really like uh it's like there's not a lot of spoilers right right

2:13:09you know like um boba fett's not showing up or anything you know i mean it's it's character

2:13:14driven and so it's just it's very good characters and great writing and um and even what i just

2:13:21happens to take place in the star wars universe really right what i've heard about it is that

2:13:25it it's the best star wars expanded universe thing hands down that they've made and if

2:13:30you were turned off in any way by some of the other stuff if you're like ah everybody's

2:13:34raving about this mandalorian but i don't love it you still might really love yeah i

2:13:38know yeah yeah i mean it's the most adult star wars property that they've they've ever

2:13:44made yeah the only reason that i haven't watched it yet is i was saving it to watch with jonas

2:13:48who's off at college and then he came home for thanksgiving and spent the whole time

2:13:53with his high school friends typical other other than thanksgiving day you know which

2:14:00isn't really the time to watch uh to watch star wars so right right uh i'm saving it

2:14:06again for the christmas break when no when i have been told i have been told that there

2:14:13will be some some time with jonas in the house on the couch and he's probably seen it already

2:14:19he swears he hasn't and he's an he's an honest kid so i believe him he would tell me it would

2:14:25be the easiest thing in the world because i'm again i it i'm i'm the dad who's not going

2:14:29to i'm not going to be heartbroken if he said hey you know what i was out with some friends

2:14:33and we watched and or you should just go watch i'm not going to be her but you know i'm also

2:14:37not going to be the one who he if anybody breaks it it's going to be him not me so i

2:14:42haven't but it's certainly high on my list um yeah the other thing i'll toss out we amy

2:14:47and i just watched all eight episodes in two nights and this is rare i mean amy does not

2:14:52do that she usually falls asleep uh 1899 which is a new series on netflix yeah that's another

2:14:59one that i'm like uh i'm an episode and a half into but but it's it's good it's gripping

2:15:04it is it's nice and slow at the beginning too yeah there's a lot of it takes its time

2:15:09um it doesn't really rush into whatever the heck is going on which i don't even know yet

2:15:12well it's it's yeah hey i don't see how you could but it's another but it is it it's it

2:15:18reminds me a little of the peripheral and i think all of these sort of shows of the

2:15:23mysterious science fiction genre spooky whole show yeah it was good i mentioned this on

2:15:30the rebound the other day it was and then dan and lex were like what are you talking

2:15:36about but there's this whole genre of shows that are spooky whole shows yes they're um

2:15:40like yeah what's the outer range is one and then there's the there's like a space one

2:15:46some sort of space one on it's a jk simmons and um sissy spacek on on amazon prime i can't

2:15:52remember the name of it uh i don't remember that one either but yeah i only watched the

2:15:56first like i only saw like the first episode of that did you get back to it snell gave

2:16:00me this one years ago it's called counterpart it also has jk side oh yeah so counterpart

2:16:07i'll toss this out there for anybody who wants to have their heart broken yeah and the heart

2:16:11breaking the heartbreaking part is that it was clearly meant for multiple seasons but

2:16:15it didn't get renewed so there's only one season and so there's two there's two oh well

2:16:20yeah there's two seasons um but it does and and it and it has a like you can take the

2:16:25the ending of season two as a wrap up if you i mean it it works but i do think that they

2:16:29meant to have more seasons yeah all right well then there were two but i i i gobbled

2:16:33it up so quickly yeah uh counterpart is it's great but it's a spooky whole show there's

2:16:39a spooky yeah yeah yeah it is a spooky whole show yeah uh i should i spoil i think i can

2:16:47spoil the premise of counterpart yeah i think yeah i mean it comes out pretty quickly in

2:16:52the in the show yeah the premise of counterpart is that at some point in the late 1960s during

2:16:58the cold war there was some kind of physics accident in in berlin and it's the 80s but

2:17:06anyway oh maybe yeah but decades ago yeah maybe yeah you're right probably the 80s but

2:17:10it was during the cold war some sort of physics experiment in berlin went went wrong and there's

2:17:17an underground passageway in a government building in berlin where if you walk through

2:17:22you come out in berlin but it's it's there's parallel universes it's too yeah like the

2:17:28world divided into two and so it's not a multiverse with infinite ones it's just a yeah one four

2:17:34into two universes but anybody who was born before 1984 had therefore has a counterpart

2:17:43in the other universe right and you all have the same memories up until that point up until

2:17:47that lives diverge because the two universes go in different ways you know in one it's

2:17:52a cold it's a cold war story with another universe is what it is right in one universe

2:17:57you know dan marino won a couple super bowls you know and uh you know and who knows what

2:18:02crazy you know butterfly flapping a wing in china repercussions of that happened but it's

2:18:06a really interesting premise that was cut short but that's a spooky whole show i would

2:18:10say uh lost was a spooky whole show yeah pretty much yeah right yeah because i mean there

2:18:15is there is the bunker right right the hatch was was a spooky hole um 1899 has a little

2:18:23bit of lost to it and you know again i'm not spoiling to it but it's sort of like i i

2:18:27often feel like i loved lost for a couple of seasons and i loved it so much that it

2:18:33had there was so much affection for the first season or two in my heart that i watched everything

2:18:39afterwards even as i i was like oh this is not yet this is not what it was yeah i think

2:18:44i just got i got to the i got to the point where it was it seemed like they don't really

2:18:48have like a clear idea of where they're going no no so like i thought they had this grand

2:18:54plan behind all this and it's slowly becoming clear that they don't exactly know where they're

2:18:59going i also kind of think that that's what happened to west world in my opinion it it

2:19:03was kind of like we have this fabulous premise and we know we have a season one of plot and

2:19:11it's such a great premise and season one is such a great plot and we've we've devised

2:19:16this interesting coterie of characters surely we'll figure out where it's going you know

2:19:23and then it does it and so it seems like a huge cottage industry of these modern shows

2:19:27like 1899 and a lot of these other ones are sort of like what if we did lost but we knew

2:19:33where it was going right and i really do think you know a lot of times the way to get you

2:19:39know it's that stupid malcolm gladwell 10 000 hours you know you practice you know i

2:19:44don't think there's anything magic about 10 000 hours but practice makes perfect and i

2:19:48think having made west world but wanting to return to some of the same themes but like

2:19:53hey what if we maybe had a better idea of where it was going and oh my god there's a

2:19:58novel that you know a great storyteller already figured out where it's going it it's better

2:20:04to me i i it's you know it's different it's not like a reboot of west world but to me

2:20:09i enjoy it more and probably the problem with game of thrones right oh yeah the final chapter

2:20:14was not written by the genius who started the whole series right they caught up to them

2:20:20yeah right and then they're like oh now what are we gonna do well let's change everything

2:20:23yeah let's come up with an ending that everybody dislikes did you ever watch dark because that's

2:20:30the same people made dark make 1899 oh well then it's i it's supposed to be very good

2:20:36i started it and it seemed like it was interesting um but it also seemed uh not to put too fine

2:20:42a point on it dark um and it came out you know during uh the the presidency presidency

2:20:47of someone i wasn't really fond of so i i was not able to keep watching it speaking

2:20:52of dark reality was already dark enough for me all right well i'll uh put on you know

2:20:57i'll give it a try now that amy and i have run out of this one but yeah amy amy is was

2:21:02i i it really says a gazillion uh credits to 1899 that she never fell asleep and we

2:21:08watched four hours of it two nights in a row that's yeah that's pretty good she thinks

2:21:12the fact that there's a lot of subtitles there's characters who speak languages like german

2:21:16and other languages and so there's a fair amount of subtitles uh she thinks that helped

2:21:20because yeah right because you gotta you gotta keep your eyes open you gotta keep your eyes

2:21:23open you can't just close your eyes and i'll just listen for a couple minutes anyway thanks

2:21:29for joining the show hope you had a good thanksgiving break um i will thank our uh sponsors for

2:21:35the day we had sofa where you can track these shows that we mentioned and movies and books

2:21:39and anything else and squarespace where you can set up your own brand online and collide

2:21:46where you can manage uh endpoint security for your whole company's fleet of mac windows

2:21:52and linux computers thanks john thanks john

2:21:56[LAUGH]