0:00:00I'm in big trouble, Rene. Oh no, what happened? Well, it's what could happen. We're starting.
0:00:07Usually. I don't know if I've ever even said this. 316 episodes of the show. I'm not sure
0:00:11I've ever said exactly when we've recorded the show, but I'll give it a day. We're recording
0:00:16on Wednesday, June 23rd at 5 54 p.m. Eastern time. I gotta record dithering after this.
0:00:26Oh, okay. But the Milwaukee Bucks have a playoff game at 8 30. So I gotta get this in under two
0:00:33hours or dithering is gonna suffer a divorce. It's all over. Does anybody care about Milwaukee?
0:00:40Honestly? A guy named Ben Thompson. Oh, come on. I'm not even sure Milwaukee has a team. Maybe he
0:00:48made it up. He's smart enough he could get away with it. I know. He should have done what I did
0:00:51and root for the Sixers who lost anyway. And of course, the further complication is that this is
0:01:00my first post WWDC show other than my actual WWDC show with Federighi and Jaws. But it's the first
0:01:09one where, you know, it's a first normal episode. So we've got a lot to cover. We can say things you
0:01:14can't say in front of them. Let's start though with today's white paper from Apple, which I'm
0:01:24calling their anti side loading white paper, and the the regulatory environment in which
0:01:32they've crafted it and dropped it. I just published my piece, annotating it, I describe it.
0:01:40Curious what you think of it. Yeah, I'm really conflicted about this whole issue because on
0:01:46one, and I feel like this is a big problem for our industry, because the people commenting on this
0:01:50stuff are largely really traditional computer users who come from really traditional computer
0:01:55backgrounds. And to them, to us, everything should just be a computer. That's the expected behavior.
0:02:01Apple makes a new device. Of course, it should work in every way, like every other device Apple
0:02:06has ever made, not counting the iPod, but it should work like a Mac should work like an Apple
0:02:10too. And we've talked about this before, but it was clear at the inception that Steve Jobs meant
0:02:16for it to be what would be called now a console like it was meant to be an app console. And for
0:02:23a lot of people in the world that is way better than a computer. And I'm afraid I like my inherent
0:02:29prejudice where I would say just Gatekeeper it and have it done with would be like going to some kid
0:02:35and saying no, no, no, you don't want an Xbox. You want a PC. You're gonna have to deal with some
0:02:39malware. You have to deal with some ransomware. It's fine, but you can game on a PC. What do you
0:02:44need this idiot Xbox thing for? Or you should sideload on your Xbox. I feel like there's a
0:02:48lot of lack of empathy for non-computer nerds in this whole discussion. I think so too. I think
0:02:54it's been that case all along, but I think it's coming to a head. It's coming to fruition. And
0:02:59then it is it's it's so multifaceted because that's that's sort of the user perspective, right? On the
0:03:07one hand, there are the users who like as I put it in my piece, basically just want to know what
0:03:15you know, just allow side loading as an off by default, you know, pretty much like Android. And
0:03:20in a way sort of I guess that's a sort of like how the Mac defaults now too. I actually forget
0:03:24exactly what a factory fresh Mac defaults to, but I think it defaults to App Store only. The Mac
0:03:31makes it really easy. Well, as easy as I think it should be to go in to security settings and say
0:03:39only allow, you know, uncheck the checkbox for only allow apps from the App Store and whether or not
0:03:45you allow unsigned apps, etc. Android hides it a bit. And it seems to move around between versions
0:03:52of Android. Android settings I find not not impenetrable, but like shifting sand there.
0:04:00Why not just do that, ship it by default, and then all of the iOS users, you know, most of them will
0:04:08never change their defaults. And so they'll be just as protected and limited by every, you know,
0:04:13everything coming through the App Store as they are today. And those of us who would like to
0:04:17install apps from other sources, for whatever reason, can choose to do so at our own risk,
0:04:25you know, give me a checkbox, give me a warning after the checkbox, I'll okay it,
0:04:30and then I'm on my own. It's my device, right? You put in your Konami code, and you do your business.
0:04:36Right. I should probably add that to my I forgot that it's my device. But that it's true, right?
0:04:42And I wrote that in my article, like, that's a good argument. It there's nothing or there's nothing wrong
0:04:47with that argument. Except that it's incomplete. And it ignores to me, the downsides there, there
0:04:58would be trade offs. You know, the Mac is an expert first computer that it tries to be as safe and
0:05:10friendly and approachable as possible to non expert users. And there are 10s of millions of totally
0:05:18non experts who use a Mac. My dad, yeah, 83 year old, he much prefers his there. But for him and
0:05:27his my mom's iMac to using an iPad or something like he just likes it. He likes having a keyboard.
0:05:33He likes the bigger screen. You know, and you know, he's got it set up and it works. It works
0:05:39for that. And, but he, you know, he also knows, you know, there are always times in just over the last
0:05:4410 years, there were a lot of times where I'd get like a phone call and they'd be like, ah,
0:05:47something's popped up says I need an Adobe Flash Player update, right? It was off. And it's like,
0:05:52now to say no, I don't know where you got that. Say no, no, no, you don't. You don't need that.
0:05:57There's all sorts of things you can do on a Mac and that typical users get into trouble with
0:06:02non savvy, non technically savvy users get in trouble with. And the iPhone is an iOS writ large
0:06:10and its family of of OSes that are really just derivatives of iOS, like iPad OS and watch OS and
0:06:18tvOS are non savvy user first, you know, let's let's even though this is a full Unix computer
0:06:30with again, even like on the watch a pretty powerful chip.
0:06:33But let's design it as though these are consumer electronics like the iPod was,
0:06:39where you cannot mess it up by doing anything. And it in 14 years of experience now, this isn't
0:06:47like a hypothetical anymore. You know, the hypothetical as presented when Steve Jobs
0:06:52unveiled the iPhone SDK in 2007 and said it would have these limits have been proven to be right.
0:06:59Users have thrived, the devices are the the most free of malware by any definition, right? Like
0:07:08not just viruses, or apps that try to ransomware you or something like that, but just something you
0:07:15just don't want period, right? Like, like that whole thing from a few months ago, about from
0:07:21Lauren Brikter about Chrome is bad. That was yes, that there's some kind of mysterious keystone
0:07:26right updater, right? It's, it's not malware in the sense that the Google Chrome engineers who
0:07:34most or at least many of whom surely are Mac users themselves, right? Like Chrome is probably
0:07:40in large part developed on Macs by Mac users at Google. They've got the best intentions. But they
0:07:47have made a decision that because they they think they know better than the user Chrome updates by
0:07:55itself invisibly in the background, and you don't really have an option to turn that off,
0:07:59at least not one that I know of. And if there is, it is, you know, like a secret setting or
0:08:04something like that. And it installs some kind of background agent in, you know, your home folder,
0:08:11library, something something folder, and it runs every once in a while and checks if there's a new
0:08:16version of Chrome, even if Chrome isn't running, and it doesn't pop up a dialog that says you want
0:08:20to upload the new version of Chrome, it just uploads it. And their argument, which is not unreasonable,
0:08:25is this way users are always up to date with the latest Chrome, which could have security and
0:08:32performance improvements. And they don't have to do anything. Okay. But then the downside is that
0:08:38effectively, when you install Chrome on your Mac, you're no longer really running Mac OS, you're
0:08:43running Mac OS with this little tiny thing that's now part of the system from Google.
0:08:49Yeah. And apparently it could cause problems. That's not possible. And again, that's a well-intentioned
0:08:55developer making an extraordinarily popular Mac app. It's just not possible on iOS. And you can't
0:09:01overstate how important that is to users. And again, in 14 years of experience, we've seen
0:09:07users who were truly, I know this firsthand from my friends talking about their parents and
0:09:14relatives, and I say this because my friends are actually all nerds and know how to do stuff,
0:09:20extended family members with Windows who had Windows computers in the past,
0:09:24they all typical Windows users eventually became afraid to install anything because installing
0:09:33stuff under Windows machine eventually, you know, cause problems and you'd have to wipe it or really,
0:09:39that's why most people, regular consumers, I know why they chose to buy a new computer is that their
0:09:44old one just was like broke from, from even like just adware, like not even mounted where they get
0:09:49like 19 different bars on their browsers and cookie redirected to whatever affiliate links and
0:09:54browser hijacked. And there's just so many things that I would classify as annoyances, but when you
0:09:58have 18 flies buzzing around your head, it's as bad as having, you know, like one, one piece of
0:10:04malware, it just becomes so unpleasant. You don't want to do things. And that's been the repeated
0:10:10experience with me and non tech savvy people. And I don't mean dumb. I think a lot of people say,
0:10:14like, when we talk about non tech savvy people, we're talking down to them, we're thinking that
0:10:17they're stupid and they're not, they can be geniuses who just don't happen to give a crap
0:10:22about all the technical things that we do. They just use it as a tool. Like they're doing science
0:10:27or medicine or law, and they need a tool that works and they don't have the time, the inclination
0:10:32or the patience to deal with all this stuff that we do on a regular daily basis. And it feels like
0:10:39in our desire to like, we have Unix, we have windows, we have Android, we have Mac OS,
0:10:45they really only have iOS and Chrome OS. And it feels like just because we think it's sexy
0:10:50hardware, we want to take it away from them and say, no, this is going to be our nerd box too.
0:10:55And that just feels so inconsiderate sometimes. Right. I mean, I guess what I'm trying to say is
0:10:59that the Mac and other, you know, PC type platforms like windows, Mac and windows and stuff
0:11:04like that are expert first, typical user second, and iOS is typical user first, expert second.
0:11:12And Apple is, and we'll get to this, they are expanding the power user type features on iOS
0:11:18in truly wonderfully encouraging ways and at a pace that now seems like this is great. Like
0:11:27shortcuts are a lot better in the new iOS 15 that's coming out than they were last year. And
0:11:32last year's was a big improvement over the year before they got so much faster, and they can do
0:11:36so much more. And, you know, hobbyist level users can build really interesting things with
0:11:45shortcuts. And they can do things like starting last year, that whole trend, where non-technical
0:11:53users on their iPhones and iPads, but especially iPhones, let's face it, were replacing their,
0:11:59putting all their apps in the app library and then setting up shortcuts for each of the apps.
0:12:04And then you can assign a custom icon to the shortcut and all it does is open the app. And
0:12:09then all of a sudden you could give whatever app you want. You could have like a custom suite of
0:12:14black and white icons for all of the apps that you use on your first screen. And, you know,
0:12:18you've always been able to customize, well, not always, I guess, starting like iOS 4,
0:12:23you could customize your wallpaper. I love that because it's exactly what got me into Mac
0:12:30enthusiasm when I first got a Mac back, way back in, you know, like 1947 or whenever it was, when I
0:12:37was a young, young man in college. But like, dicking around in ResEdit with tweaking the icons
0:12:44or pasting new icons on apps or folder icons, remember that? That was, I loved that.
0:12:50Yes. Yeah. Same. Like my BB edit folder where the BB edit app was and all of its support files
0:12:57was a folder icon with a little BB edit badge in the corner, not a regular folder icon. I loved
0:13:02doing stuff like that. It's in it, you know, it's a great way to get into it, but still it's typical
0:13:10user first, safety first, expert second. It's a flip-flop of the priorities of which users are the
0:13:17most catered to and which one comes second. And some people just don't see that as a reasonable
0:13:23choice. And even that is like far more than Steve Jobs or Scott Forestall ever intended. Like,
0:13:29I think there's a mentality for some people at Apple that iOS 6 was the pinnacle of anything
0:13:34that any normal user would ever need. And there was a lot of pressure not to do airdrop and not
0:13:39to do any of the things that we take for granted as basic utility features now. And it's only
0:13:44because Craig is nerdier and Apple has gotten more expansive with the iPhone and the iPad
0:13:48that we're getting these features. But I agree with you, something like, you know, some sort of
0:13:54theme kit to me is like a much higher priority in terms of what an average, and I don't use average
0:13:59disparagingly at all, but what the vast majority of users would want than a lot of the things that
0:14:04we're arguing about as minority opinions that we just consider to be majority because we have them.
0:14:39up, I think starting today and were announced last week. It's there's fundamentally at the highest
0:14:46level, I disagree with most, almost all of the things that they're trying to do. Even more
0:14:54importantly, it's clear in the ones that I disagree with the most that that the legislators don't
0:15:01understand this at all.
0:15:02Or they don't have the same, their priorities are not aligned with those of us who want to see some
0:15:10recognizable form of these systems remain intact.
0:15:14Yeah, and like, Representative Jayapal, who's from Washington State, who I really liked last year,
0:15:23one of the curious things about this is that her questioning in last summer's
0:15:31hearing with Tim Cook, Jeff Bezos, Zuckerberg, and I think Jack was the fourth? Yeah, I think
0:15:40Jack, he's just Jack from Twitter. They offered very little, very few questions to Tim Cook,
0:15:51and Tim Cook had a sort of "why am I here" demeanor in some way, not disrespectful,
0:15:59but there was also in the run-up to the conference, there was reports that Tim Cook and Apple
0:16:06sort of responded to the "we'd like you, before we force you to, we'd like you to come,"
0:16:11a sort of "why are you bothering with us? We're not doing anything that's a violation of antitrust
0:16:17laws." And the hearing came and went, and it was after it was over, and that was one that I watched
0:16:22the whole thing. There was sort of a "why did they make Tim Cook do this?" They hardly asked him
0:16:27anything. And Jayapal's questions to Amazon in particular were, I thought, really, really good.
0:16:34And the bill that she's sponsoring is very much just going after Apple, and kind of curiously,
0:16:42I think the company the second most—because her bill is pretty much trying to say that the first
0:16:50party platform maker shouldn't be allowed—it should be legally prevented from advantaging itself
0:16:57in any way over third-party developers. And that's just not how platforms work.
0:17:02I mean, is it possible that the first-party platform maker can do something
0:17:07illegal, goes too far, and should be regulated by the government compared to, you know,
0:17:13yes, it's undeniable there's got to be limits? But the idea that it should be on equal footing
0:17:21is a complete lack of understanding of what it means to be the first party, right? That's why
0:17:27we call them the first party. They come first. Nintendo can't make Mario. It's the world we
0:17:31want to live in. Can't have Halo on an Xbox. I don't want to live in this world.
0:17:36Well, you get to—you know, here's like a little example, a little example, but it's just one. And
0:17:41just to call out a new feature announced at WWDC, but the iPad, iPadOS now has a feature called
0:17:46Quick Note, where you can use your pencil or your finger to slide out from the lower right corner
0:17:53and instantly make a new Quick Note. We're calling it in Apple Notes. And it integrates with Safari
0:18:02and I think a few other apps, but like Safari in particular, if you're on a web page,
0:18:08you start a new Quick Note. It'll draw the URL from the current Safari page, pre-fill it in the
0:18:15note, and if you annotate or quote like a certain section of the web page, when you go back to that
0:18:23Quick Note, it'll note when it goes to the web page to go to that part of the page that you made
0:18:28a note about. Cool feature. That would be illegal under Jai Appel's bill because it's not offered to
0:18:37third-party note apps. That to me is ridiculous. I mean, that's what it means to be the first party.
0:18:45You get the advantage. That whole thing was so interesting to me, and I watched it as well,
0:18:53because it started off—and I'm blanking, you just said his name, but I'm blanking on the chairman's
0:18:57of that committee's name. Cicillone. Yes, Cicillone. He started off by saying, like,
0:19:02"Do these big companies need to be broken apart? We're going to take evidence." And then nobody's
0:19:07mentioned that at all for the entire length of the conference. The Republicans mostly focused on
0:19:12conservative voices being suppressed as sort of theater, and you knew that because whenever they
0:19:16broke character, they became these really efficient litigators who really asked good questions and
0:19:21then went right back to their theater about conservative voices. And Democrats, who largely
0:19:25talked about the behavior of the companies towards their competitors and their partners—and again,
0:19:31you could see that was a lot of theater because, like you mentioned, when they got serious about
0:19:35it, they became the real lawyers that they are. Everyone just seemed to break character and
0:19:39occasionally be competent, but then go right back to their set theatrical patterns, which I found
0:19:43astounding. And then at the end, he just said, "Okay, thank you for everything. It is clear to
0:19:47me now these companies need to be broken up. Bang, gavel, we're done." And it just made such—it was
0:19:52such a cognitive dissonance about the entire proceeding, and it seems to manifest itself now
0:19:57in these bills. I do think, though, that—and this is hopefully comes across in my article—is that
0:20:06in some ways, I feel like the bills are very misguided, but I also feel that a lot of this
0:20:12is Apple's own fault. And it is—is it arrogance? Is it—I don't know. But there was a sense back
0:20:24with the e-book case, which I think was around 2013, that Apple had the attitude that I still
0:20:31agree with, that how is this happening that we're the ones facing antitrust
0:20:37lawsuit over our e-books when Amazon owns over 80%, maybe 90% of the e-book market?
0:20:49Like, you know, you can get into questions over what constitutes a monopoly, you know,
0:20:54when you're talking like 50%, is it 45%, is it 55%? But like, Kindle is clearly an e-book
0:21:01monopoly. They have a—not just a majority share, but an overwhelming majority share.
0:21:07So how in the world was Apple facing—
0:21:08Gave it to them through this lawsuit.
0:21:09And I think Apple headed into that case thinking, "Well, we're not—I don't know why we're even
0:21:14going to court, but we pay all these lawyers, and that's why we have them. We'll be okay."
0:21:21And, son of a bitch, they lost, and they got stuck with like a government regulator
0:21:25sniffing up, you know, sniffing up their butts for a year.
0:21:30Yeah, with a Chrisley.
0:21:30And, you know, here we are 20 years later, or 10 years later, and
0:21:35Kindle's share of the market is probably larger than it was then.
0:21:41And it was weird, like in broad strokes, one of the things that the U.S. tends to look at
0:21:45differently than the EU, like the EU seems to be all about competition, and the U.S. seems to be
0:21:48mostly about, you know, lowest price for consumers. And Amazon was providing lower prices by dumping,
0:21:54like by using it as a loss leader by dumping it, which is not healthy and not good for competition.
0:21:59But Apple working with others, I guess, was seen as a form of collusion.
0:22:02But they didn't look at the results that they wanted. And I find like both the DOJ and the EU
0:22:06make this mistake, and the EU famously with browser ballots, their goal was to stop Internet
0:22:11Explorer from taking over and to preserve these small market browsers like Fenris and, I forget,
0:22:17Sleipnir, things like that. But what they ended up doing was destroying IE and allowing,
0:22:23essentially, Chrome to become the dominant browser. But worse than that, they destroyed
0:22:27like every other rendering engine we had. Opera went to Chromium, IE went to Chromium.
0:22:32They handed Google an effective, much larger monopoly over web browsing or much larger power
0:22:38over web browsing than IE ever had because their focus was on what they thought was a problem and
0:22:44not the solution that actually needed to be handled or what consumers needed as a solution.
0:22:49>> I would argue that the EU decision where, you know, on first boot, Windows machines in the EU
0:22:57had to maybe still have to offer you a choice of default browser.
0:23:01>> A browser ballot, yeah. >> I would argue that it was a bad law,
0:23:07and it's a bad experience for the user, and it's a pain in the ass that Microsoft didn't deserve.
0:23:12But I would argue that that's not the reason IE dropped from relevance. I think IE eventually
0:23:19got beaten fair and square by Firefox as a superior. Firefox built a browser for Windows,
0:23:26or Mozilla built Firefox for Windows, and it was so much better that users switched on their own,
0:23:33and companies had their employees switch on their own because they deemed it technically superior.
0:23:40And Chrome eventually beat Firefox and now dominates, certainly dominates Windows,
0:23:46and is the single most popular browser and browser engine in the world on merit.
0:23:54That's the thing that I think the legislatures don't get, is that how fast tech works and how,
0:24:01you know, Windows still has probably about the same market share. I mean, I know Macs are selling
0:24:06better than ever, but the overall market share of PCs, if you define PCs as things running Windows,
0:24:14Mac, and Linux, is as strong as it ever was. But nobody talks of Microsoft in the terms that they
0:24:21did circa 1996, '97, because the world shifted, right? Competition really works. I'm not trying
0:24:31to be a capitalism fundamentalist here, but it really does work, and tech moves so fast,
0:24:38technology moves so fast, that it's the one industry, I think the first industry ever,
0:24:48where you see it happen not just once in your lifetime, but several times in your lifetime,
0:24:54right? I'm only 48 years old, and it's happened several times, that the general gist of who is
0:25:02on top—I mean, most of the companies who are now on top, the ones who are in the New York Times is
0:25:09big tech cabal. Facebook didn't exist, Google didn't exist when I was in college, and I'm only
0:25:1748 years old, they didn't even exist. Mark Zuckerberg was probably like three years old.
0:25:22It changes fast. And—
0:25:27Yes, absolutely.
0:25:28You know, IBM, is IBM a terror of the industry, a menace that everybody has to deal with? No,
0:25:33when's the last time you really even thought about IBM? You know, it can happen fast. I mean,
0:25:40in 1995, I think, Sun Microsystems was on the cusp of just purchasing Apple. And, oh, it was,
0:25:51as a Mac user at the time, it was like, "Oh, I hope that doesn't happen, because that's
0:25:53going to be bad." Sun Microsystems doesn't exist, right?
0:25:58Yahoo was going to try to buy Google when it was the last time you heard of Yahoo.
0:26:02Right. This stuff moves fast. Does that mean that no regulation ever should happen? Of course not.
0:26:10But I think it needs to be surgical. And I just can't believe that after the Microsoft
0:26:17thing 20 or 25 years ago, that they haven't learned that lesson. But the other point I
0:26:23want to make— It also seems like—
0:26:24Well, go ahead.
0:26:25No, it's also the same. It also seems like these days, they choose a company as a target and then
0:26:29want to specifically try to, like, whether it's bans on TikTok or bans on app bundling with Apple,
0:26:36they choose a company as a target and try to write legislation to the solution that they
0:26:40believe is necessary instead of just making laws that you can't violate. And if any of
0:26:45these companies violate them, then action is taken. And that always seems problematic,
0:26:49because you're making large assumptions about a single entity that probably doesn't
0:26:53represent the way the consumers interact with them at all.
0:26:55Yeah, and I think that they misunderstand consumers, period. Right? So, sure, Spotify
0:27:06and Tile and Facebook have issues with Apple's app tracking transparency. So, there are smaller
0:27:13companies like Spotify and Tile who are complaining about having to go against Apple Music and
0:27:19AirTags and the whole Find My network being— You know, what Tile wants is to be able to
0:27:25integrate the OS like Find My does, and so that Tile users can have their iPhones be
0:27:32beacons that listen for tiles and stuff like that, which would be possible on the Mac,
0:27:37right? They could install some sort of system extension that keeps it running in the background
0:27:42and listens as a background agent and does stuff like that. Could there be a phone, you know? And
0:27:50I guess one of the frustrations the power user type users have is that there is no phone that
0:27:56really gives them— There's certainly no Apple phone that gives them that level of, "Yes, I trust
0:28:04myself to only install stuff, but I want to install stuff that runs in the background all the time."
0:28:10Right? So, like, I know the iPad is not a direct competitor to the Mac, but it sort of is, you know,
0:28:16if you consider that most Macs are MacBooks, the iPad is sort of an alternative to a MacBook,
0:28:22and Apple offers both. If you want only the iPad safety rails, you could just use iPad,
0:28:28or if you want a Mac, you can have a Mac. It does kind of suck—
0:28:31And that's intentional. That's very deliberate on their side, like that Steve wanted to make—
0:28:35He was relentless about wanting to make computers that were more and more mainstream.
0:28:39Right. It sucks that there's no Mac phone in addition to the iPhone.
0:28:43I understand why there's not. I mean, I don't think it would be a good business decision.
0:28:49But in theory, in a hypothetical world where Apple made both iPhones and Mac phones,
0:28:54and the Mac phones had all the capabilities, like sort of you, the user, can just install whatever
0:29:01you want, and it can be installed not just as an app in a sandbox, you can install non-sandboxed
0:29:06apps that, you know, have crazy wild permissions, because you could do cool things, right?
0:29:11No doubt about it. There are totally cool ideas that you cannot develop— No developer can offer
0:29:18for iOS because they're not at Apple. Only Apple can do system-level stuff. That sucks.
0:29:24And just to your point earlier about Tile, like, Tile— one of the things that's interesting to
0:29:28me is that we know a bunch of developers who don't put up with Apple, you know,
0:29:31sure-locking them. They go right out in Moriarty Apple. Like, they make Fantastical and Pcalc and
0:29:37Halide and all these apps that are just way better than Apple's apps. And I'm not saying that to be
0:29:41condescending or to dismiss, you know, the platform advantage Apple has, but you can see a world where
0:29:46Tile says, "Okay, we're using the Find My API that Apple provides on iPhone, and we're doing something
0:29:51Apple can't. We're using our own network on Android or Google's network on Android so that
0:29:55if you have a cross-device family, you can buy a tile and use it with everything. You don't have to
0:29:59worry about being stuck in Apple's ecosystem." And you could look at, like, Clubhouse saying,
0:30:04you know, "We made this wonderful app, and now Spotify has green room, and they have this huge
0:30:08platform advantage, and they're using it to suppress us." So I honestly don't see a difference
0:30:11between Spotify and Apple. One's just a billion-dollar tyrant, you know, there's a
0:30:14trillion-dollar tyrant, and it makes all of these debates seem much more self-serving to me than I
0:30:19think the companies actually realize. And the other thing, I just think that the legislation
0:30:26totally gets the consumer perspective wrong. And I know, I forget his name, the Apple guy who they
0:30:33sent instead of Tim Cook in the run-up to the lawsuit. But remember there was a guy, I'm not
0:30:41gonna, I'm sorry, I hope he doesn't listen to the show. But they sent him, and I don't think he did
0:30:49very well in front of the Senate committee he was testifying, and I think that's partly where some
0:30:55of this is coming from now. But one of the things that he'd said, repeated, that I do think was true
0:31:02was that what the implication of the questions of "Why are you doing this? This is bad," is that
0:31:09you're describing features that our customers love. This is what they love about the iPhone.
0:31:13They love that they cannot mess it up. They love that they can't install anything that runs the
0:31:18battery down in the background without their knowledge. They love that the private, they love
0:31:23the new privacy controls that are in their hands and not developer hands. And I think that they
0:31:34misunderstand that, I really do. I really think it's true that the iPhone has succeeded not
0:31:39despite its restrictions on software distribution, but largely because of them.
0:31:45And, you know, Kyle and Dear, was that the one? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, good. Now you can listen
0:31:53to the show again. I, it's it and I feel like that argument fell on deaf ears, even though
0:32:02the Occam's razor argument is that, yes, it has made it wildly popular. And the iPhone didn't drop
0:32:13into the world and 100 million people bought it. It was like, "We'd like to sell 10 million in the
0:32:20first, by the end of the next year," or something like that. If we get 1%, we'll be happy. Right.
0:32:24We'll get in a world where it was unlike all other phones and it looked different. And even for users
0:32:32who really wanted to use their phone for email and messaging, it was the whole thing about the
0:32:37keyboard. Like, this is ridiculous. Nobody, you know, Steve Ballmer laughing that doesn't even
0:32:41have a keyboard and it costs 600 bucks. And anybody who's serious about doing messaging
0:32:46on their phone wants a keyboard because, of course, you know, that's what succeeded in the
0:32:51past, the BlackBerry. And again, look at it. Where's BlackBerry now? Right? It changes.
0:33:00Yeah. All right. I mean, for a lot of people, like, I think that's the problem is that
0:33:04we look at it, like traditional computer people look at that, look at those things as bugs,
0:33:08where millions of mainstream users see those as features.
0:33:11Absolutely. They really do. And I know, I know, "anecdata is not data," but I have so much
0:33:20"anecdata" from people. Like, I remember I have a friend who I worked with at Barebone Software
0:33:2720 years ago, and I ran into him at WWDC. It was probably around 2012, 2013 or so.
0:33:35And he was telling me about his father-in-law. And he said, "His father-in-law," I forget what
0:33:41he did. Maybe he was an accountant or something like that. But he said, "He's Cracker Jack smart.
0:33:46He's super smart. Always a Windows user and always had just one of those Windows users who had a bad,
0:33:54you know, bad perception of Apple. Just thought Apple wasn't for him. It was for other type of
0:33:57people. But never really was a Windows user. You know, he used Windows computers, but,
0:34:05you know, never installed additional software. He thought, you know, the only way—this is how I
0:34:10keep my computer going—is I just, you know, use the software that comes on it, install the least
0:34:16possible software. Like, here's the accounting package I use, you know, to run my accounting
0:34:20business." And that's it. Retired, got an iPad. And he said, "You cannot believe what he's doing
0:34:28on it. He's making movies, editing at this large digital photo library. He's become like a
0:34:34computing enthusiast and installs all sorts of third-party apps, loves the App Store,
0:34:40because he realizes and can feel. Yeah, you have like—it's not like, "Oh, Apple says it's safe."
0:34:49It's like you have this perception in the iPad/iPhone experience. You can feel it's safe.
0:34:54Yeah. You know it's safe. You've experienced that it's safe. It's like that you can be a nerd and
0:35:00roll your eyes at that and say, "Nope, they're just suckers for the marketing," or whatever.
0:35:04But it's true. There's something ineffable about the design that lets you feel that this is safe
0:35:10and that there's nothing going on mysterious in the background, and that when you delete an app
0:35:15in jiggle mode, the app and all of its traces are gone. That's it. You didn't like this game?
0:35:21You delete it, it's gone. And there's nothing in the background that's going to pop up in a month
0:35:25and say, "Hey, do you want to re-download me? I'm still available in the App Store." It won't happen.
0:35:33It's so true. I have several direct and extended family members who are doctorate-level education,
0:35:41and they just always felt stupid using a computer. It didn't make sense to them. It was too finicky,
0:35:45and they were always nervous. They always felt intimidated, made them feel stupid. And
0:35:49they just—the iPad is the first computer that didn't do that, and they love it.
0:35:53My mom has an iMac. Other people in my family have MacBooks. They don't use them. They use iPads now
0:35:59because that, to them, is the first computer that makes sense. Right. And it's just—and
0:36:05I thought Apple's white paper raised a very key point about that argument to go back a few minutes
0:36:12about, "Well, look, if you don't want to sideload, just never turn it on." But if that's there,
0:36:18it's probably true that most users wouldn't. But some users would. And they might—some
0:36:26users who don't really know what they're getting into or don't want to get into it might have to,
0:36:30like if you're using your own iPad at school, and the school says, "We want you to install
0:36:35this proctoring software," but the proctoring software is not in the App Store because it's
0:36:41doing stuff that the App Store doesn't allow, surveillance-wise. What do you do if you're
0:36:48a student? What do you do if you're taking the SAT or the LSAT or something like that on your iPad,
0:36:54and you can either do it and install it and turn on sideloading, or you don't get to take the test?
0:37:01Who's going to say no to that? What if you're in— Tim Epic says you need to get Fortnite
0:37:06by sideloading, and then you're trying to find out which version of Fortnite is safe because
0:37:10a bunch of malware people have that, which is exactly what happened on Android when they did
0:37:13that. A bunch of malware versions have also been put out there. Yeah, Apple cited a bunch of cases
0:37:18in the footnotes. I didn't get into that in my article, but their footnotes are actually pretty
0:37:21fascinating. There's a lot of cases that would have been good, daring, Fireball Father, to be honest,
0:37:28that I had not heard of, of fake games and stuff like that, or pirated versions of games.
0:37:34I guess the more common scam, though, is just the fake version of the game. You tell somebody that
0:37:40it's Candy Crush and you can install it for free over here, and you get it and it's not Candy
0:37:45Crush, it's something else. Or if you install these five apps, we'll give you money towards
0:37:49this. They do that now, even with non-fake apps, they try to use Android. The whole thing is just...
0:37:53Yeah, the other one that was eye-opening to me was the ransomware angle, which again is not just
0:37:59presented by Apple as a hypothetical, but is footnoted with actual examples, where there are
0:38:03Android apps that you could install by a sideloading and would offer things like photo
0:38:09filters or something like that. Something that the purpose of the app—because Android has the
0:38:14similar things as iOS, where you have to give the app permission to access your photos, and you say,
0:38:19"Well, yeah, that's why I got the app, so it can access my photos," and as soon as it has access to
0:38:23your photos, the app says, "You need to pay $10 through a credit card right now, or I'm going to
0:38:32delete all the photos from your phone." And you've already given it the permission to have access to
0:38:37your photos. People can say that's your fault or your choice or you're dumbing it down, but right
0:38:43now people have the choice to get a platform that makes it really, really difficult to do all those
0:38:48things, where their level of fear, of stress, of anxiety is very low because the platform itself
0:38:53protects them against that. But you can also choose a different platform. Like right now,
0:38:57you have the choice between iOS and Android, and on some level, this is taking away that choice.
0:39:02It's whether you believe the choice should be on the platform level, like you should have a choice
0:39:05on every platform to do it, or whether it's okay to have one platform that allows it and one that
0:39:10doesn't, and you get to choose between those things the way you get to choose between an Xbox and a
0:39:15gaming PC, for example. They don't have to be the same. Very true. Before I take a sponsor break,
0:39:22let me just take this break to do a total footnote. And I'm bringing up my friend Steve, who told me
0:39:27that story about his father-in-law at WWDC 2012 or 13. I remember that while we were talking,
0:39:34I was like, "Where are you going?" And he told me he was going to a security session, and I was like,
0:39:38"I'll go. That sounds interesting." And I went, and it was a session on security. And back then,
0:39:44I think Apple's largely gotten away with the Q&As, but they were still doing post-session Q&As.
0:39:48And it was a session about security, and in the Q&A, where I was like, you know,
0:39:55it's at that point where it's like, once a Q&A starts, you start putting your stuff back in
0:39:58your backpack, and you're like, "I think I'm done." You know, the Q&As were never that good.
0:40:03But this one stuck with me ever since. The question was somebody who asked,
0:40:08passwords are terrible for most users. They use the same ones over and over. They forget the ones
0:40:18they have if they are secure. And they're open to scamming in a bunch of ways, where you can
0:40:26prompt for a password and the user can put their password in, but it's not—you're giving it to an
0:40:32adversary, and now they've got the password to your account. Are you—is Apple looking at anything
0:40:37that would replace passwords? And the guy at the microphone paused and stared down
0:40:47for a very long beat. And then he looked up and he said, "Yes." And that was it. That was the
0:40:59whole answer. And it was so—and Steve and I looked at it, we're like, "Oh, that's interesting,"
0:41:07because he was even wondering if he should say yes. He was definitely not thinking,
0:41:14"Should I say more?" He was thinking, "Should I even say yes, or should I just give the—we don't
0:41:20really, you know, we don't talk about future product plans." And look at where we are now,
0:41:26you know, with so many features. Because that's the other thing he might have been thinking about.
0:41:31He might have been thinking about how many "Let's move beyond entering a password manually" features
0:41:39Apple had, how many of those calls were in the fire already at the time that we've now seen.
0:41:44It's one of my—
0:41:45Yeah, we have a whole team working on it now. It's amazing.
0:41:47All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor, it's our good friends at LinkedIn.
0:41:52Today, many small business owners are busier than ever because they're focused on managing
0:41:57and growing their business. They can't always spend the time they wish they could on recruiting.
0:42:02That's why LinkedIn Jobs has made it easier to find and hire the best candidates for free.
0:42:07Get started by posting your job for free to reach LinkedIn's network of 740 million
0:42:15professionals. Let me say that again. 740 million professionals are on LinkedIn. Pretty big market.
0:42:23Fill out targeted screening questions to get your role in front of the most qualified candidates
0:42:28with the experience, skills, and motivation you need. Then use simple tools to filter and
0:42:34prioritize the top candidates you would like to interview. LinkedIn Jobs will help you hire the
0:42:40right person for the role you have open. And your first job post is free. Just visit
0:42:47LinkedIn.com/talk. Again, that's LinkedIn.com/talk to post your first job for free.
0:42:55Terms and conditions do apply.
0:42:57All right, the flip side of this before we move on to WWDC stuff is, to me, the conflict of interest
0:43:06and that has gotten Apple into this whole truly—it's a serious fiasco. I don't think
0:43:13that Jai Pal's bill is going to pass. I really don't. I honestly wonder—she's clearly so smart.
0:43:19I honestly wonder if she's not playing the heel in some way by putting this bill out there as a stake
0:43:25in the ground. That's Ben Thompson's argument that it's sort of an anchoring strategy. And then it
0:43:29makes the less drastic bills seem like a compromise, whereas if the less drastic bills
0:43:39were the only bills, they would seem drastic. But Apple has gotten into this situation,
0:43:47I think almost entirely, by pursuing a maximization strategy on App Store revenue from third-party
0:43:56developers. And maybe maximizing is a bit of an overstatement because it's not like they've—I
0:44:04mean, they emphasize this too. They emphasize that the rates for developers have only ever come down
0:44:10from 30% in terms of offering the 15% for the second and subsequent years of a subscription
0:44:18and the new small business program for developers with under a million dollars in revenue who can
0:44:23get 15% across the board. They've only ever come down. But there's also a counterargument that
0:44:29raising the rates to 40% or 50/50 might blow up in their face. It's the total calculus of tax rates.
0:44:43You can't just tax everybody 99% and have your government sit on all the money because if you
0:44:48tax people at 99%, they're not going to work. There's a sweet spot in there. But it's true,
0:44:54though, that—I think it's undeniably true and to me, best exemplified by these rules against
0:45:02allowing apps to send users to the web to sign up. So, okay, Netflix, though long in the App Store
0:45:11and forever will have tens of—probably tens of millions of users who are paying for Netflix
0:45:18through their app, the App Store, because it used to be available, but they've pulled it several
0:45:22years ago because they got sick of the 85/15 split they had with Apple. So now, if you're somebody
0:45:29who never signed up for Netflix or you had it and you canceled and you get the app from iOS or TVOS
0:45:39or iPadOS, there's no way to sign up in the app. It doesn't tell you what to do because they're not
0:45:46allowed to. They're not allowed to say, "Go to Netflix.com to sign up to create your Netflix
0:45:51account." They're not allowed to even say that. And Apple going after companies like this story
0:45:58last week or two with a small company called FanHouse, which is actually a really cool name
0:46:05for what they're doing. It's sort of basically only fans but PG-rated, maybe R-rated, I don't
0:46:13know, but definitely not X-rated. But they were doing a thing where—so, you know, I presume people
0:46:23have heard of only fans, but basically it's a thing where you could pay to subscribe to a creator
0:46:28or whatever—what would you call it? Some of these things.
0:46:43Only fans didn't start that way either. It was a bunch of—the big stars on only fans were soccer players in Europe.
0:46:55Let's say you're a famous soccer star and you could set up a page and people could pay. It's sort of
0:47:01along the lines of Cameo, too, where you can just pay and you could get DMs with your favorite
0:47:09soccer player or basketball player or something like that, or whatever kind of micro-celebrity
0:47:14you might be. And they were sending—they did have a subscribe button in their iOS app, and then you'd
0:47:25hit the button and it would, I believe, jump you over to Safari, or maybe it was presenting a web
0:47:32view in the app, and then they would take your credit card information in the app or maybe over
0:47:37in Safari. But either way, there was a button. And Apple said to them, "You have three months
0:47:42to implement true in-app purchases for this." But the numbers don't work out for their market.
0:47:50They only take 10%. So let's say it costs 10 bucks to get a FaceTime chat with somebody.
0:47:59They only charge 10%. Nine dollars goes to the user, the creator. Ten dollars went to FanHouse.
0:48:08So where's the 30% come from? So their only option to comply would be to give Apple the
0:48:1430% off the top, and you run into this situation where the numbers that Apple would be getting
0:48:22compared to the creator leaving FanHouse or Cameo or whoever else is doing similar things with these
0:48:29creator apps, which is a huge thing. It's like the category of 2021. It just seems disproportionate.
0:48:36Yeah, same thing with the Twitter's new service, that they put out the numbers that Apple is getting
0:48:40compared to them, and it's ridiculous. And all they want to do, you know, and the Hey app from
0:48:47last summer best exemplifies it, because the Hey thing wasn't about them taking credit cards in
0:48:53their app. The whole time, they didn't even have a button or a URL that said, "Go to hey.com and sign
0:49:00up there." All they had was an app, and they assumed that they would get enough users on their
0:49:06own to sign up on the web first and then get the app. They weren't even worried about the app being
0:49:12the source of discovery. The app would be something users would get because they're already fans of
0:49:17Basecamp or they heard of Hey and its features otherwise, and they're confident in their own
0:49:23ability to get signups. They just wanted to have an app in the App Store that was based on the idea
0:49:30that it only worked if you already had an account from the web at hey.com. And Apple's response was,
0:49:36"You need to implement in-app purchasing so that users can sign up in the app." That's exactly the
0:49:42mentality. That's what I'm calling maximalization of App Store revenue and revenue growth from
0:49:50third-party developers. If they weren't doing that, I don't think they'd be in this hot water.
0:49:58There'd still be—there's always malcontents, and Tile would still be upset about not being able to
0:50:03have system-level software like Find My, and Spotify would still be upset about whatever
0:50:08they had to pay versus Apple Music. And Epic would want their own store. That would all continue.
0:50:13Right, but I don't think it would have the traction that it does.
0:50:18So what I don't understand is—I understand the historical context for a lot of this,
0:50:23because originally when they had in-app purchases, apps couldn't be free. If you were free, you had
0:50:29to stay free. You couldn't use in-app purchase. Only paid apps could. And then they changed that,
0:50:34and they said that free apps could use in-app purchases, but you couldn't make external payments
0:50:38because their great fear back then when they flipped the switch was that every app was going
0:50:43to just move all payments outside the App Store, and Apple would be left holding the bag for all
0:50:48these free apps that then were all being monetized on the web, that all of the economy would move
0:50:53outside the App Store. And the revenues were nowhere nearly as big back then, so that was a
0:50:57big concern for them. But over the years, everything grew. And then more recently, Apple made the
0:51:02statement that they were going to—I forget what it was—double their services revenue in the span
0:51:06of so many years, and the App Store has always been the biggest driver of services revenue.
0:51:11So it seems like they did everything they possibly could to juice App Store revenues, so they could
0:51:16juice services revenues, so they could make that number. But then they didn't say anything again.
0:51:21I thought that was a big sign. Like, they didn't immediately say, "And we're going to double it
0:51:24again in another few years." They just let it go at that point, and I thought, "Well,
0:51:28maybe they've learned something, and they're going to go in, and in the face of all these potential
0:51:33obstacles and ill will, they'll say, 'Okay, now, you know, the App Store is performing way beyond
0:51:39our wildest dreams.'" Steve said he would have been super happy if it operated just slightly above
0:51:43break-even, and now it's this powerhouse, and we're going to return some of that value to all of you
0:51:48that helped us build it. It would have been a perfect opportunity, but same thing when they saw
0:51:53that value wasn't leaving the App Store that some people would pay for convenience. Same thing when
0:51:58once they'd made those numbers for Wall Street with the services, they did nothing. They left
0:52:02the status quo. Even with that famous, now, Phil Schiller letter, they just left the status quo,
0:52:07and that I don't understand, because that was just such an obvious missile just rearing straight at
0:52:13them. Yeah, the Schiller, I wrote about that just before WWDC, I think literally the morning of WWDC,
0:52:19and it's just striking, and I'm not surprised that it exists because I know Phil Schiller well
0:52:26enough to know that he would think of things like this, and I know that he thinks he sees the value
0:52:33in the brand as something that you can't put a dollar price on. And, you know, again, it's like,
0:52:41look at the iPod, right? I do think some of the mistakes that Apple made in hindsight were
0:52:47coming from the iPod, where everything was either a song or a TV show or a movie that you pay,
0:52:58you know, a dollar or you pay $10 for the movie, and Apple keeps 30% and the producer of the song,
0:53:07the artist, you know, the publisher of the song or the studio behind the movie gets 70%,
0:53:12and that's a much better cut than they got in the old days in retail selling discs or tapes,
0:53:18and it works out for everybody, and you know the rules up front and it's purchased and there's no
0:53:24concept of subscriptions or in-app purchases or something like that. And there's only one middle
0:53:28person, there's no two middle people, which often exists in the App Store now. Right, and I think,
0:53:32you know, they looked at the App Store the same way that, you know, you'd buy these apps for a
0:53:37dollar or five dollars or ten dollars. I mean, it's kind of funny when you look at the first App Store
0:53:42the announcement of the App Store, how with the prices they were put up in their hypothetical,
0:53:47you know, here's like an example of what it looked like, and you know, it was based on their concept
0:53:51of the Mac market, right, where that's how independent third-party Mac apps were sold.
0:53:56You'd make an app and if you wanted it to be a paid app, you'd sell it for 20 bucks or 30 bucks
0:54:01or 40 bucks or, you know, ridiculous prices like $50 for an application. That's what they cost
0:54:07before the iPhone, like when I bought a stupid sticky notes app for the Palm OS, it was like 50
0:54:11bucks. I know, I remember buying apps for the Palm OS. They were definitely similarly priced to the
0:54:18Mac. It wasn't just like, oh, it's a tiny device in your pocket, so the price should be tiny too.
0:54:22It was, no, this is what third-party independent software costs, whatever the platform,
0:54:27and I think Apple based their conception of how it would work on that.
0:54:32But the Schiller idea of it, just the basic idea that he tossed out there, do we think 70/30 is
0:54:39going to last forever? And if not, why don't we just, you know, why don't we pick a number like
0:54:44a billion dollar a year run rate and, you know, once we reach it, you know, we could lower the
0:54:50rate to keep it at a billion as it grows to 25/75, 20/80, 85/15. I think if they had done that,
0:54:59they'd be at, they'd still be so much higher than a billion dollars a year run rate because I think
0:55:05the other funny thing looking at these emails from the Epic trial is how much more popular the
0:55:10iPhone and App Store both are than even their internal wildest dreams, right? It's, you know,
0:55:18like you even just said that Steve Jobs, when they announced the original iPhone, he was like,
0:55:21we're shooting for 1% market fare. We think that'd be great, you know, we'll take the, you know,
0:55:26premium 1% market share. It's ridiculous how successful it's been. But they don't, the other
0:55:33thing is with iPods, they didn't need the money from iTunes, they needed the money from the iPods.
0:55:39They made the primary business of the company was selling iPods, in the music business, was selling
0:55:47iPods. And their secondary business was a great music store in a then great desktop music collection
0:55:57app for your MP3 files. And, you know, that was just icing on the cake, but it was primarily
0:56:05all about making money on iPod. And their iPhone business still is, and will remain primarily about
0:56:13selling people $5, $6, $7, $800, $1,100, $1,200 iPhones at a decent margin. That's a great business
0:56:24for them. Well, that's the, that is the craziest thing. I've said this before, or at least I've
0:56:30written it. I think I said it on dithering, but the craziest thing about this to me is I don't
0:56:34recall any company in my lifetime or that I could think of in historical terms, who got into serious
0:56:41antitrust trouble over a side hustle. Yes, it is always the main business. Like, it's not like
0:56:50AT&T got broken up because they had the exclusive rights to Unix at the time. No, it was about the
0:56:58friggin' phone business and the crazy $2 a minute rates they charge for a call that went across
0:57:05state lines. It wasn't friggin' Unix. It's crazy that they're in hot water. And, you know, it's
0:57:13somewhat serious. I mean, the bills are being driven. And there's also, no matter what happens,
0:57:18even if all of these bills die in Congress and nothing really comes out of the EU regulators,
0:57:25there's a PR hit to this, right? Of constantly being in the industry.
0:57:30And developer relation hits.
0:57:32Right, right. And that's the other factor is that the resentment among developers over Apple's,
0:57:39to them, to third-party developers, seeming greed over maximizing app store revenue is so pervasive
0:57:47that it's, and I don't think Apple gets it, which we can get to later. Anyway.
0:57:53And the thing I think the app store was invented in a time where Apple saw themselves,
0:57:56like you said, from the iPod, where they were the middle person. They would aggregate all these apps
0:58:00and sell them, taking 30% from the paid apps. But then we started getting all these secondary
0:58:05aggregators. Like Spotify just aggregates a bunch of music, takes their percentage and then passes
0:58:09it on. Amazon aggregates a bunch of eBooks or a bunch of comic books and takes their percentage
0:58:14and passes it on. But these models don't support multiple middle people. You can't have Amazon
0:58:19taking 30% to aggregate the books and then Apple taking 30% to aggregate the apps. There's just not
0:58:24enough percent. And no one's really willing to give that percentage up. And they're also not
0:58:30willing enough to care about the user experience, which is so weird for Apple because they're almost
0:58:34always user experience first. And it's been this problem for over, or at least for a decade.
0:58:39And that again, to me is perplexing. I understand how we got here. I don't understand how we haven't
0:58:44gotten out of here yet. Yeah, so I downloaded FanHouse last night, because I finally dug into
0:58:49it. And FanHouse, the app is largely, clearly from the way I can just feel, it's largely a bunch of
0:58:58web views. It's, in my opinion, not a great iOS app. But you know, it's, you know, you're, you know,
0:59:04you can build an app that way. And so okay, but because it's a web view, they could do things
0:59:08remotely. And they took out that subscribe button. And so if you download, at least as of this
0:59:13recording, the FanHouse iOS app, if you're a new user, you can sign up and I scored at Gruber,
0:59:20you know, just in case, who knows, I guess I could use it. It's always good to have my username.
0:59:24But I was like, well, let me see what it looks like to subscribe to somebody in the app. What's
0:59:29going to happen? And I found somebody and you can find their user profile. It's like looking at like
0:59:34@ReneeRitchie in Twitter. And what do you expect to see near the top, you expect to see a button
0:59:41that says follow or subscribe, right? Well, there's no button. And it's like, how do I follow somebody?
0:59:47And I'm like scrolling around, I swear to God, I use the app for 10 straight minutes thinking I was
0:59:52losing my mind. Maybe I'm getting old. I don't understand these kids apps today. Yes. And I went
0:59:58to the help in the app, and it doesn't say anything. And then eventually, like, maybe 15
1:00:03minutes in, I went to their website and their website, you go to website, hit help. And it says,
1:00:07how do I follow somebody and it says you cannot follow somebody in from the app, you have to go
1:00:12follow them on the website, and then you'll see them in the app. That's a change they've made in
1:00:17the last week or so since Apple tried to crack down on them in it. But yet, even after doing so
1:00:24Apple, the only concession they got was that they were their grace period to continue not offering
1:00:30in app purchases through the end of the year. It gets to your point about user experience. What
1:00:35Apple, Apple's squeezing FanHouse to try to get them to use in app purchase for these fan base
1:00:43subscriptions, whatever you want to call that this creator type thing, forced FanHouse to make an app
1:00:51that doesn't let you that you're supposed to follow people in where the app doesn't let you
1:00:56follow people, right? Download Netflix, good luck figuring out how to sign up. I wrote a piece years
1:01:02ago where Netflix does have a phone number and I called the phone number. You remember this piece?
1:01:08I called them up and it's I was like, "Hey, I downloaded the iPhone app. How do I,
1:01:13I don't have an account. How do I sign up?" And they were ready for it. Yeah, you go to
1:01:18net, go to your computer or you could do it on your phone too. Go to Netflix.com in your
1:01:24web browser and you can sign up there. And they were ready for it. But how many companies have,
1:01:30number one, that's ridiculous, right? That you have to make a phone call
1:01:33in the internet age from an app. It's like signing up for a magazine in 1978. You know,
1:01:41you got to call Sports Illustrated and, you know, call...
1:01:44Like trying to unsubscribe from the New York Times today.
1:01:46Right. Call now to subscribe to Sports Illustrated. It's ridiculous. But how can a small
1:01:53developer compete with that if there is an official exemption for a phone number that's
1:01:59allowed to do? But it's a terrible experience. It truly is. And they don't need to have every
1:02:05dollar. So what? And even if internally Apple thinks that they should be using in-app purchase
1:02:11and they should be making more than they would be in a world where they significantly lessen
1:02:16their grip on trying to capture 30% of all App Store, you know, commerce for digital
1:02:23goods consumed on the phone. Even if internally Apple truly believes—and I think they do,
1:02:30I think they truly do believe that they deserve it.
1:02:32It's just so Governor Tarkin. You know, it's not a good look.
1:02:35It's just have some grace as the Goliath in the relationship.
1:02:41And again, I know I say this all the time, often with moles on the show,
1:02:45it is so easy to play spend Tim Cook's money. I get it. But this is one where
1:02:52the benefits—Apple would get something. They would get better publicity, better developer relations,
1:02:59they'd—
1:03:00Better user experience.
1:03:01Better user experience, all reasons to sell more iPhones and iPads, and they would get this
1:03:10regulatory pressure off of them. I mean, it's kind of—
1:03:15Or at the very least have a much more defensible position in the face of anyone trying to broadly
1:03:19regulate big tech.
1:03:21I just don't see it, especially given the trends. And I know all things come to an end.
1:03:26At some point, somebody's going to buy the last iPhone ever. You know, nobody's buying
1:03:33Model T Fords anymore. Well, although I guess they still are buying Ford cars, so who knows?
1:03:39I don't think in the 1980s, people thought the Macintosh would be a thriving 4 million units per
1:03:48quarter business in the year 2021. So who knows? Maybe phones will still be a huge thing 40, 50,
1:03:5560 years from now, like cars are for Ford. I realize my Ford example is actually counter
1:04:00to what I'm arguing. But Ford still is in the business of selling their cars for a profit,
1:04:06right? And yeah, you probably do. I do see stories about people getting nickel and dimed and
1:04:12car makers—
1:04:14Well, it's like charging for card play on BMW. It's just you don't need that money.
1:04:17Yeah. Or putting ads on the dashboard now that the ads can be on the dashboard.
1:04:23Like Samsung phones have ads on the on the lock screen or the home screen. I just bought
1:04:30your phone. You don't do that.
1:04:32Right. It's like there used to be that there were no electronics on the dashboard, and your radio
1:04:37was literally completely analog. It was a little stick behind a piece of Plexiglas that you moved,
1:04:43and you set your favorites with literal radio buttons to punch in your favorite stations.
1:04:48And then we got these little low-res LCD, black and white digital things for the radio station.
1:04:55It's like, "Oh, that's cool." And then everything gets modernized, and all of a sudden,
1:04:59full-color LED displays are possible, and they're pretty big. And it's like, "Boy,
1:05:06that's a cool thing to put in your dashboard. I feel like I'm in the future. It's a spaceship."
1:05:10And then somebody has the idea, "Wait, you can put ads on that screen."
1:05:14Anything that can—
1:05:16Now you're half afraid you're driving a Tesla, you'll see a Dogecoin meme.
1:05:19It's like it's just gone too far.
1:05:21Anyway, all right. Let's move on to WWDC after this. I'm going to tell you about our next
1:05:27sponsor, and it's our good friends, arguably the best friend of the show, Squarespace.
1:05:32This episode is brought to you by Squarespace, as an awful lot of episodes of this show are.
1:05:38You can start building your website today at squarespace.com, and if you enter offer code
1:05:42"Talkshow" at checkout, you get 10% off. You could use it for a whole year.
1:05:47Talkshow has—not Talkshow, Squarespace—has everything you need to build a website,
1:05:54from domain name registration to templates to choose from, to components to just drag and
1:05:59drop around the page so you can add things like a portfolio of artwork or a store to sell things
1:06:05or a blog where you can post things. And you use Squarespace itself to update the content of your
1:06:11blog. You want to—it's not just adding a blog and host it on Squarespace. You use Squarespace to
1:06:17create the post for it. All of the sites on Squarespace look professionally designed
1:06:22because no coding required. If you don't know the difference between HTML and CSS,
1:06:27you're not in any trouble whatsoever. If you do, you can get in there, roll up your sleeves,
1:06:32and tinker to your heart's content. You can get a free domain if you sign up for a year
1:06:38of service up front. So you can start your free trial today. No questions asked, no little bug in
1:06:45the corner that says you're on a free trial. You get a 30-day free trial at squarespace.com/talkshow.
1:06:52And when you decide to sign up and start paying for your Squarespace account, make sure to head
1:06:56to that same URL, squarespace.com/talkshow, and use the offer code "talkshow" to get that 10%
1:07:03off your first purchase. My thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support of the show.
1:07:09You had an excellent post-WWDC interview with Kevin Lynch and Deidre Kaldbeck
1:07:22from Product Marketing about Apple Watch and WatchOS. And as soon as I saw her on YouTube,
1:07:29I was like, "She? I know. Have I met her?" And that's the weird thing about being in the media
1:07:35racket is there's an awful lot of people in product marketing who I have met. And then
1:07:40my favorite thing about your video is how much you cut in mid-sentence to callbacks from previous
1:07:50keynotes, referring to old features. And she was the person who did the—to me, still arguably the
1:07:59greatest demo I've ever—maybe the only one that rivals Phil Schiller's jump from 20 feet high
1:08:05to Javits Center to show that Wi-Fi works wirelessly back in like 1999 or 1998. She
1:08:13was the one who was on the wind surfing board? What was it like? A paddleboard, yeah.
1:08:19A paddleboard in the middle of a lake, live, during a live event, talking to the audience
1:08:26via her cellular Apple Watch. Yep. Showing both that it was cellular, that it worked,
1:08:34that it sounded pretty good, and that the watch was waterproof. Although I guess she didn't
1:08:40prove that. She did not fall. But anyway. No, but it was a risk she was willing to take.
1:08:46But it was so great the way you sliced that in. You mentioned it, but then you cut to it,
1:08:52and it's like, "Ah, man, that was great." I love the way you cut that stuff in. How much time did
1:08:57that—you cut that whole thing yourself, right? You do all your own editing? Yeah, yeah. I mean,
1:09:02for good or for ill, I just love the editing process, so I try to learn as much as I can.
1:09:06I just thought it would be important because, you know, a lot of us know all the players involved,
1:09:10but you might have seen them before and not recognize them immediately. So if I can give
1:09:13you something memorable like that paddleboard scene or Kevin dancing, if I can do that early on,
1:09:18you'll remember who they are and then be more invested in what they say, I hope.
1:09:21You put it even in the title of the video, that it has to work in two seconds. I thought
1:09:28it was a very open interview, and I thought that that bit from Kevin Lynch about how they sort of
1:09:35had a "come to Jesus" moment where it's like, we should really focus on getting everything a user
1:09:44really would want to do, or almost everything, to be something they can accomplish on the watch
1:09:50in two seconds or less. And that's a tremendous challenge because relative to a—relative even
1:09:57to a phone, it has a tiny screen. It has two sources of input, really, or three maybe if you
1:10:07count the side button. There's a side button you can click, there's a crown you can either click
1:10:13or scroll, and then there's a touch screen, and that's it. And they even took away some controls
1:10:20because they've taken away the force touch type thing to go in the name of who knows why, but
1:10:28there's very little input, very little screen. Discoverability is a good reason. Well, I think
1:10:33discoverability combined with we could use the space that takes up behind the screen,
1:10:39we could put that to better use. I thought that was really interesting, and I think it does show.
1:10:48There's a real sense and there's a real continuity of watchOS from watchOS 1 through watchOS 8 is
1:10:59what was announced last week or are we up to watchOS 9? It's 8 now, right? No, I think it's 8,
1:11:03yeah. There's a direct continuity of where it's never—it's the platform that I guess has gone the
1:11:11longest in Apple history without a sort of paint job, right? Like eight years after the Mac would
1:11:21be 1992, well, System 7 was pretty significantly different than System 6 and earlier. Maybe,
1:11:30arguably, the Mac was still, you know, watchOS is still chasing the Mac before the Mac really got a
1:11:36thorough rethink with Mac OS 8 visually. It's a very continuous line, and what I took away from
1:11:47that interview is how clarifying Apple's internal vision of the watch is. Yeah, I agree. I think
1:11:54there's like there's way more constraints on what you can do on a watch, and they've been much more
1:11:58systematic about it. Like they dropped things like glances, they made alternative—like you don't
1:12:03have to deal with the home screen anymore, you can just have that list of apps. So they slowly
1:12:09but steadily evolved it, but nothing—I don't think it's as big as even a phone and you can have that
1:12:15much—it's much more driven by the needs of the smallness of the screen. I'm not saying this at
1:12:21all very well. But they have a vision for what it's good for and what it can be better for,
1:12:29going forward. And I don't think it's their fault. I think that the gold watches, the edition ones
1:12:40that cost $20,000, were a disaster. And I know everybody knows that internally there was a lot of
1:12:46debate over the entire endeavor. But that's hardware. In terms of what the watch does,
1:12:53they definitely had a few ideas at first that didn't pan out, like using it as a main reason
1:13:01to get one, sending your heartbeats to loved ones and stuff, which I didn't think was ridiculous.
1:13:08And I don't think I'm an overly sentimental person, to say the least. But I was like,
1:13:15"Maybe that sounds kind of interesting to me. Maybe I would have really loved that,
1:13:19like in high school or something like that." That stuff didn't really pan out.
1:13:23But they really, really clarified on measuring health and fitness, monitoring it,
1:13:31and dealing with notifications. And you get notifications on your wrist. And then,
1:13:37being a—this is where that two-second thing comes in. It's like, "Okay, you got a text message,
1:13:42but you only have your watch with you. How do you respond to this in two seconds?"
1:13:47And they've been slowly adding back just better versions. Originally, they had these five pillars
1:13:52that I think that they said, "This is the value that the Apple Watch is going to give you." And
1:13:56it was health, but it was also remote control. It was also identity and authentication and payments
1:14:01and communications. And it was too much for a year-one product. It just went over—it confused
1:14:08people. Instead of making them more interested, it disqualified them instead of qualifying them in.
1:14:12And then they focused down on the health and fitness aspects. And that made a lot of sense
1:14:17to people because it was something above and beyond what an iPhone could do. It was demonstrable,
1:14:22added value. But now, slowly but surely, they're adding back interesting communication methods.
1:14:27And now, with things like the whole ID system for driver's licenses, but also for schools and
1:14:32things like that, they're adding back the identification and better remote control with
1:14:36HomeKit. So I think they're building it back up to what the original vision was. They just had to
1:14:40sharply pare it down to get everyone to start buying them in the first place.
1:14:43Yeah, and some of the features they talked about this year to me are super compelling,
1:14:48like using your watch to open your hotel door. And I know Disney World—I don't know if Disneyland is,
1:14:55but I know Disney World is—you can use your Apple Watch instead of a MagicBand to go around the park
1:15:00and, you know, put your—more or less put your park pass in your wallet, I guess, and
1:15:06go in there. Those are super compelling features. But the other one—and I forgot about it, you know,
1:15:15because WWDC was so packed this year. I couldn't keep all of the features I wanted to note in head.
1:15:23And the one that your video reminded me of was the fall detection. Or not fall detection, the
1:15:30fall prediction, right? It's sort of like—the fall detection, which I think was two years ago,
1:15:39maybe three, but two or three years ago, they added this feature where somebody falls
1:15:45and doesn't get up. The watch could detect it and notify somebody who you've set as an emergency
1:15:53contact or put something on your wrist so that all you have to—if you could just tap the button on
1:15:59your wrist, you can get help. This new feature is about predicting, "Hey, your gate seems unsteady
1:16:09and matches the profile of a gate of somebody who's about to, you know, maybe you're lightheaded,"
1:16:15whatever the reasons that people take a fall. And let's face it, this is a feature largely about
1:16:21older people. It was such a fascinating feature. I really would never have thought about buying
1:16:26my parents an Apple Watch before, but now it's—honestly, that seems like a reason to do it.
1:16:31I know they might be resistant because they're sort of like, "I don't want a new thing," you know.
1:16:34But—
1:16:35Ben de la Torre-Au
1:16:42de la Torre-Au
1:16:46de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:17:13de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:17:33de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:17:39de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:17:54de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:18:04de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au de la Torre-Au
1:18:08cook there, René. Good morning. That was pretty good. The other thing is I had an interview
1:18:16too. I had Mr. Craig Federighi and Mr. Jaws back again. Remote, once again, me in Philadelphia,
1:18:26them in California. I'm wondering what you think of it. I'm glad to have them both. I'd
1:18:34rather have both than just have one. But remote, I don't know. I find the three-way interview,
1:18:46doing it remote, to be very difficult. They don't make as much fun of each other remotely
1:18:55as they do when they're in person. Not at all. It's always clear. It's not like, "Hey,
1:19:11here's the contract. Here are the rules of the interview." I said during my show this
1:19:15year that there's no, "Hey, give us a list of questions," and stuff like that. There's
1:19:20really just a handshake agreement that the topic is stuff it from WWDC. It's a WWDC
1:19:28show, not a— Mine was the same. It's like, "Talk, watch, and help," but there were
1:19:32no rules about what you could talk about within those constraints. Not the state of Apple
1:19:37or anything outside. Can't go back and bitch about the touch bar or something like that.
1:19:46I'm happy to agree to it. When my show is live in the theater and the keynote is just
1:19:55a day before, it makes intuitive sense that it should be that way because everybody who's
1:19:59in the audience is all still jazzed up from the keynote and stuff like that. Anyway, what
1:20:04I'm trying to say is it's clear that Federighi is the star, and he's great at it. And Jaws
1:20:12is there to back him up. He's playing rhythm guitar. Also, this year there was no hardware,
1:20:18and there has been hardware two out of the last three years and three out of the last
1:20:22five years. And when there's no hardware, Craig is literally the star. And when there
1:20:27is hardware, you get to ask Jaws all sorts of interesting questions about iMac Pros and
1:20:31Mac Pros and Apple Silicon, which you couldn't do this year. Right. And if I were to do an
1:20:38interview show like that a couple of days after the iPhone 13 or 12s or whatever is
1:20:44going to come out this fall, I think clearly Jaws would be playing lead guitar to continue
1:20:51the analogy. But that said, on stage, it's easier and comes more naturally to me to think
1:21:04it's been a couple minutes since Jaws has piped in. Let me think of something to throw
1:21:10to Jaws. And even though in general, we had a pretty good low latency connection for everything.
1:21:20Jaws was, I think, a little bit behind latency-wise. Just a little. But we had very little crosstalk
1:21:28that had to be edited out, and it went pretty well technically. But I still find it very
1:21:34hard to pay attention to both of them. Even though without the crosstalk, only one's talking
1:21:38at a time, I find it hard to pay attention to both. And then I panic and think, "Wait,
1:21:43what about Jaws? Wait, and what was I thinking?" I don't know. What did you think about that?
1:21:49Yeah, no, like for me, it's just I'm never sure who's going to say what when. So if I
1:21:54wait too long, it's awkward. If I don't wait long enough, maybe I'm going to talk when
1:21:57the other person wants to add their two cents in to what the first person just answered.
1:22:01So it's a much dafter juggling act, I think. And you've got like, "Oh, sorry." But then
1:22:06if you say that, they're like, "Oh, I was just about to say…" And then you can't
1:22:10have a natural sentence to start with, "Oh, I was just about to say…" So you've
1:22:13got to, I think, be… It's a whole different art form. It just feels like to be able to
1:22:17keep people on a panel in front of you and make sure everyone… There's no dead air,
1:22:22but there's not too much overlap.
1:22:23Yeah, it's tough. Your show looked great, too. Do you know how they recorded their sides?
1:22:32iPhones. It's always been iPhones.
1:22:35Yeah, that's what we did. And I know, again, I mentioned it explicitly up front on my show
1:22:41that last year I'd tell people that and they didn't believe me. I was like, "No,
1:22:46seriously, all three of us were on iPhones." And no, Jaws and Federighi are not using green
1:22:52screens. That's actually what it looks like at that time of day in that part of the ring
1:22:58on Apple Park.
1:22:59With Smart HDR 3 because it can expose both the foreground and the background, which you
1:23:03don't usually get on a lot of cameras.
1:23:05It's impressive. It's surprising how many people thought they were on green screen for
1:23:11COVID reasons, not for disingenuous purposes. But no, that's actually what it looks like
1:23:17coming off the camera. I thought that your footage looked great, too.
1:23:20Yeah, they did a really good job. I was worried they might give me HDR footage at first and
1:23:23I'd have to figure out how to color grade it, but they didn't. They gave me really
1:23:26good solid footage.
1:23:28Anyway, let me let you ask me or you say what struck you with my interview because I'm
1:23:35not the one to talk about it in the third person.
1:23:39No, I like the way that you got the explanations out of them on the new features or Craig especially
1:23:45on the new features because I imagine just every year there's a huge pile on his desk
1:23:50of features that marketing thinks people are going to be really interested in and will
1:23:53help them sell more devices.
1:23:54But also features engineers have been waiting forever because they personally want to implement
1:23:58them. And this year in particular, because it was such a strange year and we saw such
1:24:02a focus on features that really only make sense because of the year that we had like
1:24:06the FaceTime sharing and things like that.
1:24:08I thought it was really great that you got some of the standard, we make the features
1:24:13we want to make, but it was really clear that this was the features that they felt like
1:24:16they really needed to make this year.
1:24:18Yeah. I mean, it's just, it cannot be coincidence that FaceTime and the screen sharing, what's
1:24:27it called? SharePlay.
1:24:28SharePlay. I was going to say ShareTime, but it's SharePlay.
1:24:34But these are features that I'm sure that they haven't, it's not that they haven't
1:24:43thought about them, but it's like the remote aspect, the everybody, nobody's together
1:24:49for an entire year, over a year, clearly brought to a head, "Shit, we should not have kept
1:24:55these ideas on the back burner. FaceTime, we should have had FaceTime be better by now."
1:25:02I don't think I asked about, because I always run out of time and I have more questions
1:25:07than time. I don't think I asked about FaceTime for Android, right? Which is really FaceTime
1:25:12for the web.
1:25:13That's a web view, yeah.
1:25:14Right. Right. Which is interesting. But I think that, and again, this gets to the sort
1:25:19of thing that they're not going to want to talk about where it's like, they're not
1:25:22going to want to talk about why they do things. Other than that, we think this is a good feature
1:25:26that people will like. But I think the implication of, I don't know that FaceTime for the web,
1:25:36which is FaceTime for Windows or Android, I don't think it would have happened without
1:25:42the pandemic. I really don't. I think that it might have been something they forever
1:25:47continued to think, "Eh, maybe next year, maybe soon." But I think that the experience
1:25:52of using all of the available things that could work with cross-platform over the last
1:25:59year are so bad in so many ways that Zoom got to jump from being an obscure company
1:26:10to being...
1:26:11Yeah.
1:26:12...one of the most famous software companies in the world. That was an opportunity they
1:26:17let slip away. And I think that now that they have this, FaceTime is something that can
1:26:24be there going forward, is something more people can depend on. But the old way where
1:26:31FaceTime was limited to Apple devices was something that you just couldn't set up if
1:26:37your doctor was going to have remote visits. I had my annual checkup last year remote because
1:26:44I couldn't go to the doctor because our doctor's office wasn't allowed to open. And it was
1:26:50on Zoom because she couldn't use FaceTime because she doesn't know that all of her patients
1:26:54have iPhones because they don't all have iPhones, right? I mean, that's just the fact. I don't
1:26:59know that FaceTime for the web is going to enable or would push more people if it ever
1:27:06happens again, or even for the things that will stay remote even without a pandemic to
1:27:13use it, but they could. And changing features like the grid view and having multiple people
1:27:18in a FaceTime that actually is usable and makes sense rather than looks cool in a demo,
1:27:26I think was driven by the real world.
1:27:28Yeah, and I wonder how much of that was also the desire to create those links, to be able
1:27:33to schedule FaceTime calls, having to have some sort of web interface because you don't
1:27:38know when or where someone's going to be required to pick up one of those things. And it's a
1:27:44weird sort of a thing because Steve Jobs famously announced that it's going to be open sourced.
1:27:49And the project team was standing there going, "What? Wait, why? How?" And then they got sued
1:27:54and they got sued and re-sued and over-sued and they've been litigating it for 10 years
1:27:58over these patents. And it just seemed like FaceTime, we got FaceTime audio, but then
1:28:02nothing for like a decade. And then finally we started getting those new features like
1:28:06FaceTime groups, but only really recently. And so I think it's too early to tell, but
1:28:10they had such an enormous lead and this doesn't quite feel like catch up because they're really
1:28:14not there the way that even like a Skype or especially not a Zoom is, but it's nice that
1:28:20they are paying attention to it and it has some form of like, if your family has big
1:28:24device love or is like a cross device family, you can use it now.
1:28:29One of my favorite moments in my interview was when Federighi went all the way back to,
1:28:34you know, he was talking about Apple's historic roots supporting privacy, but that in the
1:28:38old days, your data was on a floppy disk and the floppy disk you'd like just put in your
1:28:42shirt pocket, but you had it, it was in your control. And I enjoyed that because I thought
1:28:49that the, you know, it was clear that he meant it. Like it, it's like, I know his, you know,
1:28:54his title is software engineering honcho or whatever the hell it is, you know, senior
1:28:59vice president for software engineering, but the privacy features is more than just like
1:29:07a dictum from above, like, okay, software chief, all of our software has to be as private
1:29:13as possible. And that's just, that's just the rule, you know, like in a way that the
1:29:17software has to comply with all of these local rules. Like when you're in Belarus, you know,
1:29:24the, oh, you know, we can't do X, Y, or Z because it's, you know, constrained. It's
1:29:29not just, okay, here's a checklist of these privacy related things that we, I've got
1:29:32to direct my teams to implement and, you know, have done in time. It means something to him.
1:29:39It really, I, and I know some people want to take the cynical point that everything
1:29:45anybody in a public statement for a big company says is bullshit. But I, I think it's palpable
1:29:53that with Federighi and Jaws, that the privacy stuff, it really does mean something to them.
1:30:00And you can argue that there are competitive aspects to their, to this stance that they've
1:30:06taken that are really about taking ad money from Facebook for apps and stuff like that.
1:30:13It's, I don't, I don't think that's, I don't think it's, it's not like, it's
1:30:18not a smaller factor, but it's clearly not driving it.
1:30:22Oh, and you can tell because the, the way they're doing privacy is they're not coming
1:30:26up with features and then figuring out how to make them private. They're, they're
1:30:30involving their privacy team in the entire, they call it privacy by design, but they actually
1:30:33mean that the privacy is, is they're not just making privacy features and the privacy
1:30:38features they're making are good. And they keep going through the system and saying,
1:30:41what, what are the points of failure in our current privacy model and how can we fix those
1:30:45and how can we expand those? And we saw that with Hide My Email and with Apple's new,
1:30:51not, not a VPN IP hiding service and iCloud Plus, all those things, but all the features
1:30:57are rolling out the same way all those features are accessible from day one. They're also
1:31:00private now from day one and have those sort of report cards on them from day one. And
1:31:06that is such a massive expenditure and realignment of engineering resources that you can't
1:31:11do that just to tweak Facebook's nose. That is a, that is a philosophical cornerstone
1:31:16of a company at that point.
1:31:20It was interesting to me at the end, because I feel like I don't think there's any question
1:31:26about it and I'm not just trying to be self-deprecating. I have trouble ending these interviews because
1:31:31I want to keep going because I've got more questions. But I know over the time I've
1:31:37been allotted and it's, you know, I thought this year I finally had a good segue to a
1:31:45final question. I thought it was a good question and I thought their interest, their answers
1:31:50were interesting, but I also thought it was disappointing. And I basically asked about
1:31:55the general growing sentiment of developer discontent, third-party developer discontent.
1:32:04And I think it's fair to say that both of them seemed, they, I think literally said
1:32:12they don't understand it. They don't get it. And, and, you know, Federighi from the
1:32:16perspective, look, I know what we are, you know, we love our third-party developers.
1:32:20We've built all these APIs for them. And Jaws pointed out that, you know, that this
1:32:24was the 38th WWDC and, you know, it's a huge production. It's a massive, and other
1:32:32than the keynote, it's all for developers. And I get it. And that is true. And I really
1:32:41think they mean it. I, you know, I don't think it's, again, I don't think it's
1:32:46bullshit, but I also think though that because they mean it, what we on the outside who perceive
1:32:54the discontent and who agree with many of the points of third-party developer discontent
1:33:00need to deal with the fact that Apple doesn't see it that way. And that they, you know,
1:33:07I think there's like, well, one is Craig's team is populated largely from independent
1:33:12developers. Like some of our favorite developers work for Craig now. And he has a front row
1:33:17seat to a lot of their sentiments and a lot of the way they express things and a lot of
1:33:20their worldviews. And that is, and a lot of people, even on like Eddie's teams, which
1:33:25are the more business focused teams, because the App Store is nominally under Phil now.
1:33:29But my understanding is that's US App Store and the App Store app and Eddie's team is
1:33:33still responsible for international and for like the servers and a lot of the business
1:33:37infrastructure around there. But a lot of them came, you know, even from like our world,
1:33:41like from bloggers or from people in Apple editorial, and they have a lot of really good
1:33:45relationships with developers, but that's not everybody. And I think they have two points
1:33:50of view. One is that we're always told we're wrong and we always just fight our way through
1:33:54it and we're inevitably proven right. And that makes them even more susceptible to a
1:33:58sort of delusion when that's not the case. And also that Twitter is a huge megaphone
1:34:03and they sometimes, Apple sometimes thinks that you only get the noisiest 10% on Twitter.
1:34:09And there's probably a 90% people who aren't mad at them, who just aren't complaining on
1:34:12Twitter. And that is sometimes going to be true, but it also leaves you open to an even
1:34:16bigger problem in the cases where that is not at all true.
1:34:19Well said. All right, let me take a break here. Thank our third and final sponsor, Memberful.
1:34:27You can monetize your passion with memberships. Memberful is a platform that allows you to
1:34:33build a sustainable, recurring revenue. Memberful is the easiest way to sell memberships to
1:34:38your audience, and it is used by some of the biggest creators on the web. Memberful has
1:34:43everything you need to run a membership program, including custom branding, gift subscriptions,
1:34:48Apple Pay, free trials, private podcasts for your paid members, and tons more. Memberful
1:34:55seamlessly integrates with the tools you already use. I know for a fact that it integrates
1:35:00wonderfully with WordPress, which is what an awful lot of people use for their content
1:35:04management. You, though, always have full control and ownership of your audience, your
1:35:10brand, and your membership. Memberful has a world-class support team ready to help you
1:35:15simplify your memberships and grow your revenue and work on those integrations with the systems
1:35:19you already have in place and that you need to integrate with. And they are passionate
1:35:23about your success. And you'll always have access to a real human if you need the help.
1:35:28And you can get started for free. No credit card required.
1:35:34Here's how you get started. If you would like to start a membership system for your audience,
1:35:40go to memberful.com today. That's all they want you to know. You don't have a code or
1:35:44anything like that. Just go to memberful.com and get started. Or go to the show notes,
1:35:50and they have a URL in the show notes with a UTM code that I can't read online. And you
1:35:56can get started today. My thanks to Memberful for supporting the show. That leaves WWDC
1:36:03itself.
1:36:04Well, there's no way we can cover it. And even if we didn't have my divorce with Ben
1:36:14Thompson hanging over my head.
1:36:16So can I ask you a quick question then on what I thought was one of the most interesting
1:36:19aspects?
1:36:20Absolutely.
1:36:21So, no new hardware. And there were some people hyping new hardware. I was certainly really
1:36:26hyped for new hardware because a new 16-inch MacBook Pro is, I need to have it in my life
1:36:33as soon as possible. But there was such a huge, expectational debt for it. And we ended
1:36:40up not getting any new hardware, which is, again, not always the case at WWDC. But it
1:36:45was also the one-year anniversary of announcing Apple Silicon. So it didn't seem wild to me
1:36:50that they would take advantage of that and show off the next big step in Apple Silicon.
1:36:54But ultimately, it was one of those software-only shows. And I felt like that expectational
1:36:59debt, people were upset by two things. By that, and also some people really did, despite
1:37:06all logic and reason, believe that putting an M1 chip in an iPad meant Mac OS was coming
1:37:12to an iPad. And we're so upset that didn't happen, that that seemed to sort of put a
1:37:17cloud over the whole show for them.
1:37:19I didn't see that. I saw the number of people who were predicting or actually saying they
1:37:26had sources claiming that hardware was coming. Specifically, I guess the pro-level 16-inch
1:37:34MacBook Pro and the pro-level 13-inch, or I guess maybe 14-inch MacBook Pro to separate
1:37:40it from the sort of non-pro one we already have. I did not see that inverse. That's
1:37:47interesting though that people thought putting the M1 in the iPad meant the Mac OS was coming
1:37:54to the iPad too.
1:37:56Yeah, Tim Cook took it out of the Mac. He took it out of the Mac, John, and he put it
1:38:00in the iPad, so therefore the Mac is coming to the iPad.
1:38:02That was my least favorite part of the keynote, by the way. So I will answer your questions,
1:38:06then Ezra. That's a good starting point. That little mini movie with Tim Cook as the
1:38:12Mission Impossible guy going into steel, that was my least favorite part of the keynote.
1:38:16I like having fun, and I like the things they do. I liked, for example, the James Bond-themed
1:38:22music with Kyan Drance. It was to take out the mini, right?
1:38:29Yes.
1:38:30I believe.
1:38:31And Craig did the whole car thing this year for Mac OS.
1:38:34Yeah, yeah, and he literally shifted gears. I was like, "Oh yeah, I get it. That's
1:38:39why he's in a car. They're shifting gears to talk about Mac OS." I thought that
1:38:44the Tim Cook thing was flat, because there was nothing funny about it. Even if you take
1:38:53the concept as a high-concept gag, it's still, "He's Tim Cook. Why can't he just
1:39:00walk in and take the chip?" Right? You know what I mean? Like, Tom Cruise had to—
1:39:05Like, "Sarooji, has it locked away from him?"
1:39:06Yeah, Tom Cruise had to break into the CIA and go down on a drop line and steal the knock
1:39:18list because he wasn't in the CIA, and he was stealing this thing. The director of the
1:39:23CIA could have just come over and knocked on the guy's door and said, "Hey, give
1:39:27me the knock list." And it'd be like, "Oh, okay, sir. Here's the knock list."
1:39:31Why does Tim Cook need to do that? I thought that was—I don't know. I didn't like
1:39:38it. But anyway, let's take them in order. Let's say hardware first. I guess—I don't
1:39:46know about the rumors. I have no idea where the people who claim to have sources who said
1:39:50that they were coming—I think it just shows that a lot of people take sources who they
1:39:57don't—either don't verify or—it's a weird business, the rumor game.
1:40:06I think the expectation-wise thing is driven in part by the fact that the M1 has been so
1:40:14successful. Right? It's just—what can you say bad about it? Right? All of the M1 Macs
1:40:20are just enormous successes, universally hailed. The iMac had just come out. They're clearly
1:40:26still firing. The iMac at least showed that they still have tremendous momentum on releasing
1:40:33new Apple Silicon Macs and showed, "Ah, here's our first dose of new industrial design
1:40:42that was based on designing a Mac around Apple Silicon," as opposed to last November's
1:40:49models, which were all physically identical, including the cameras to their Intel predecessors.
1:40:56So you could see the momentum, and you can see—to me, the most exciting thing about
1:41:02the new iMacs isn't the iMacs themselves, even though I think they're delightful and
1:41:05really nice computers. It's the, "Yeah, this is Apple flexing its muscles by not having
1:41:12to work around Intel's heat dissipation and performance per watt. This is exciting."
1:41:22So of course they're going to keep the momentum going, and the—you know, the Mac Pro, I
1:41:28feel like everybody's like, "Well, we can wait for that," because that's obviously
1:41:31the hardest thing to build for the smallest audience, even though the prices will be high.
1:41:38But at least for the pro-level MacBooks, I could see why people would think it's possible.
1:41:44I certainly thought it was possible. I wasn't surprised either way. I wasn't surprised
1:41:48that they weren't ready, and I wouldn't have been surprised if there was a half-hour
1:41:52segment about the two new MacBook Pros, or even just one of the two MacBook Pros, right?
1:41:58But I didn't think it was a sure thing, because it just doesn't—I don't know,
1:42:05there's something, you know, like—and two, I keep going back to last year where they
1:42:10said it was going to be a two-year transition. But clearly, now that they didn't come out
1:42:16at WWDC, my expectation is that they will not come out until the fall. I mean, I don't—
1:42:22A traditional October event.
1:42:24Or November, like last year with the Mac. I mean, who knows? I mean, it might be—that
1:42:29whole schedule might have all been pushed back a month by COVID. Yeah, I guess, ideally,
1:42:36if they could—I guess anything they've ever done in November, ideally, if they had
1:42:39to hit targets, you know, nothing had ever gone wrong. They'd always rather ship in
1:42:43October than November, just because you're getting closer to the holidays and stuff.
1:42:51I sort of think—because I know that you have written about this or, you know, YouTubed
1:42:58about it extensively, like the idea of an M1X. But now we're out of time for an M1X,
1:43:05because an M1X would basically be adding more GPU cores and more CPU cores to the M1 to
1:43:12get better multi-core performance and better GPU performance. GPU performance always goes
1:43:18up with more cores, because everything GPU-related is multithreaded. Whereas—and this is where,
1:43:25to me, we've run out of time, where, sure, adding more cores, CPU cores, to an M1X would
1:43:34make these Macs faster for some things, you know, like Xcode and certain things. But there's
1:43:42an awful lot of stuff, even on the Mac, that remains single-threaded bound, right? JavaScript,
1:43:49famously. And it would be weird for Apple to have an August event for these M1X MacBook
1:43:59Pros, and then two months later release new MacBook Airs and consumer-grade 13-inch MacBook
1:44:07Pros with the M2, and they'd be faster in single-threaded performance? That doesn't
1:44:13sit right. There have been times where there are gaps in Apple's Pro Mac performance
1:44:21and the consumer performance, like where the famous—I would just say the iMac Pro, which
1:44:29only ever really had one instantiation, it got surpassed in single-core performance,
1:44:37because it just sat there unchanged for a couple of years, and it was really mostly
1:44:41something you'd only want to buy for multi-core.
1:44:43And that was kind of Xeon's thing. It's not the single-core.
1:44:46Exactly. It's Xeon's thing. It is what it is, and that's Apple having to play on
1:44:51Intel's playground for CPU performance. That's what it was. But now that their entire
1:44:58chip story is in their own hands, they'd never want to do that. They would never want
1:45:02to—
1:45:03What I wonder is that if we consider an M1 is an A14X, and then we'll have an A15 in
1:45:08September with a new iPhone, and the M2 would be an A15X++, so to speak, they haven't
1:45:14been updating iPad Pros as frequently as iPhones. They've been doing it sort of every 18
1:45:19months. So there was an A12X and Z, but there was no A13X. So the iPads were behind the
1:45:26iPhone in single-core operations until the M1 version came out, and they've been willing
1:45:33to let them have better multi-core performance at the expense of single-core. So I wonder
1:45:37if they'd be willing—I don't think they'd be willing to do that with a Mac, but I wonder
1:45:39if they'll have that same approach where the M series don't get updated at the same
1:45:44cadence as the A series does.
1:45:46That's possible. You never know. We'll see, you know, right? We know the pattern
1:45:54with iPhone, right? The iPhone is the most regular product Apple has ever had. It is
1:46:01literally annual, except for one shift where they went from June releases to the September/October
1:46:07releases. But that was—from everything I've suspected and sort of known, that was a strategic
1:46:15shift that it was—that was a better time to release phones.
1:46:19And it took over the iPod slot.
1:46:21But I tend to think that they might keep—if they can keep the M series on an annual cycle.
1:46:30I think they like the annual cycle, and I think that the reason the iPhone stayed on
1:46:33it and other products haven't is, I think, primarily driven by the fact that it's their
1:46:40highest priority product. So it's the one least likely to ever slip. And if—but in
1:46:46theory, I think they would like to have other products updated annually. If they could,
1:46:51it's just, you know, you can't—
1:46:52It's only so much bandwidth.
1:46:54Yeah. So anyway, my best guess at this point, completely uninformed by any sources, is that
1:47:00the Pro MacBooks are going to have to wait for the M2 series, and that we'll see M2s
1:47:06and M2Xs either side by side or near each other or something like that. I don't know.
1:47:11What do you think?
1:47:12I just want it as fast as I can get it, Jon. Honestly, I'm still editing on an Intel
1:47:15box, and I want to switch so fast.
1:47:20As far as macOS on iPad, I don't know why people think that. I guess I know people—I
1:47:25know some people who just sort of idly think it, but it's like they idly think it in
1:47:30a way that, "Boy, I wish I won the lottery." You know, I don't know. But it's not how
1:47:35Apple operates. It makes no sense. The closest I could think of something Apple might do
1:47:43would be to have some kind of Mac in an iPad app type thing, where your device still runs
1:47:51iPad OS, but that you can launch an app, a virtualized macOS version. But that's the
1:48:02closest I can think to something that Apple would even consider. That's just not how
1:48:07they think about things. They don't think about the OS and the device as being interchangeable
1:48:13parts that you could just do something like that. And quite frankly, the Mac, as we know
1:48:18it, would not work right on iPad. It doesn't have touch. It doesn't rotate. It doesn't
1:48:23expect to rotate. And obviously, they could just announce APIs and say, "All of a sudden,
1:48:29you should expect screen rotation to change at any moment."
1:48:32Reverse catalyst.
1:48:33And you'll get a notification. But, you know, and I've said this all along, that all of
1:48:38these controls aren't meant for touch. They're all too close to each other. And you could
1:48:43either have a bad touch experience with controls that are too small and too close to each other,
1:48:48or you could make everything bigger and make things worse for the users who don't want
1:48:54to use touch or aren't using touch and are using a mouse pointer on the Mac. It's designed
1:48:58as a position. I don't want to go too long about that, but I just feel like you're—I
1:49:05just buy a MacBook if that's what you want.
1:49:06Yeah. No.
1:49:07Totally agree.
1:49:08I don't get it.
1:49:09Totally agree.
1:49:10iPadOS. That's the one thing I want to talk to you about that I don't want to run out
1:49:15of time on. I've been using it on my iPad since the keynote day.
1:49:20Same.
1:49:21I like it a lot. I really do. And I said it on my show with Craig and Jaws, but now a
1:49:27couple of weeks later. It really is—and again, it's sort of like when we talked
1:49:32an hour ago about how iOS feels safe and secure when you're installing apps. It's ineffable
1:49:41in some ways. It's hard for me to describe, even though it's sort of my job to try to
1:49:44write about user interface and stuff like that. It's hard to describe how and why
1:49:49the multitasking now feels solid and knowable. You know, like how you could get up in the
1:49:55middle of the night without your glasses on and your bedroom's dark and get to the bathroom
1:49:59because you know where everything is, right? And all of a sudden you're in a hotel room
1:50:03and it's like you're stubbing your toes. You're almost peeing in the closet because
1:50:07that's the closet and the bathroom's on the other side. Even though it's new, it's
1:50:15not familiar, it's designed in a way that encourages becoming familiar with it, in a
1:50:20way that the old-style iPad multitasking never became familiar to me, never made sense, never
1:50:26felt natural. I really, really like it and I'm impressed with it. And it's also not
1:50:33by doing the thing that everybody—not everybody, but some people were saying that just make
1:50:39it either just run macOS like you said, or just make the iPad just like macOS, which
1:50:45would have no point.
1:50:46Yeah, the thing that's interesting to me is like what I think the difference is now
1:50:49is that it's predictable and it's considerate. And before, like even people whose job it
1:50:54was to use an iPad, you would see them messing up on launching multitasking because you'd
1:50:59touch that icon in the dock and maybe it would go into jiggle mode. Maybe you'd pull it
1:51:03off the dock by accident. Maybe you would pull it into—maybe you wouldn't mean—maybe
1:51:08you'd want to pull it off the dock and you'd pull it into multitasking. And there was just
1:51:11no way, like it was beyond the realm of human reason that you'd get it exactly right all
1:51:16the time. It was just completely overloaded. There were so many conflicts, so many collisions,
1:51:22and that little change of putting that button there, of making it obvious, of just conceding
1:51:27that you needed that affordance changed my entire feeling about it as well. Because now
1:51:32I know there's that button. I can push it and every time it's going to do exactly
1:51:36what I want it to do, and I can trust that it's going to do only that. And it's just—it's
1:51:41removed all of the stress, the aggravation over multitasking. I think that by itself
1:51:46is just a huge improvement.
1:51:49I'll tell you this. I, for example, watched a couple of videos the last few days. I was
1:51:56catching up. I had to catch up on yours. That's where I watched you and Kevin Lynch and Deidre.
1:52:02Well, but I did it all on my iPad, and I had like iMessage over on the right and Notes
1:52:10over on the right. I'd switch out. That's the sort of thing that was, to me, always
1:52:15like, "Why can't I just easily replace this Notes or this iMessage window with Notes
1:52:21because I want to take notes on René's video?" It just really felt way more like a "get
1:52:31things done" OS. That's my point. And I even mentioned it in the interview. I just
1:52:37love the detail now that you can finally, if you have a keyboard attached, just use
1:52:40the arrow keys to move around the home screen, and you get a TVS-o-style selection around
1:52:46an app, and then you hit return, and then you switch to the app. Honestly, that should
1:52:50have worked before. It's, to me, inexcusable that they added keyboard support but didn't
1:52:57make the keyboard a part of getting it done.
1:53:00A lot of the last two years of iPad OS have felt like run out of time. They have all these
1:53:04ideas and they just couldn't finish. They couldn't finish widgets. They couldn't
1:53:07finish app library. They couldn't finish keyboard bindings. They couldn't finish.
1:53:10And this year, given the focus and also how much time they can save now by making things
1:53:17with things like SwiftUI that work on iPhone and iPad and don't require massive amounts
1:53:21of recoding, I think this let them not just catch up but really personalize things for
1:53:25the iPad better.
1:53:27Yeah. My other high-level takeaway from the whole of WWDC is confirmation that I've
1:53:34been right all along that SwiftUI is the future of Apple UI design and that Catalyst is some
1:53:41kind of weird political stopgap that I still don't quite understand why it exists. Because
1:53:47Catalyst wasn't mentioned once in the keynote.
1:53:50Nope.
1:53:51And there's not one new Catalyst app from Apple this year.
1:53:55No, it's not Catalyst.
1:53:57No, no. And Shortcuts, the one that would have been the most obvious candidate to make
1:54:02Catalyst is not a Catalyst app. And Federighi called it out on my show that it's a—I
1:54:09don't think he said real Mac app because he doesn't want to say—I forget what he
1:54:12said actually, but it was clear that he meant it was AppKit. I think he even maybe used
1:54:16the word AppKit.
1:54:17Yeah, it's an AppKit app with SwiftUI.
1:54:19It does have some weird things. It's like AppKit made by iOS developers. So I've been
1:54:24playing with it. And it's like when you do a display alert in Shortcuts for Mac,
1:54:28the alert is hideously ugly and incredibly wrong for the Mac. Hopefully that'll get—hopefully
1:54:33that gets fixed before it ships. But that's pretty much it for my high-level takeaways.
1:54:38Here's my last question to you. What do you think they're going to do next year for
1:54:42WWDC? Remote again or in person like before?
1:54:47So I don't know what they're going to do. My hope would be a hybrid approach because
1:54:51I think that there's things they can do in terms of the speed and cadence and information
1:54:55delivery of the recorded events that they just can't match. I guess, you know, nobody
1:55:00laughs at Craig's dad jokes the way that they do when there's an audience there. But
1:55:04just some of the presentations are so well done in this new environment that I hope they
1:55:10bring a smaller amount of people maybe to WWDC. They have a much bigger focus on labs
1:55:15at WWDC or the things that you really have to do in person. But they make the sessions
1:55:20available in this style to everyone as fast as they possibly can. And they have whole
1:55:25segments of things done. Like maybe, you know, Craig will come out or Tim will come out and
1:55:30introduce something and then we'll see a video on it. And then they'll talk a little
1:55:33bit and then we'll see another video on it. But I think they've made great advances
1:55:36this year that I'd hate to see them lose completely. How about you?
1:55:40I don't know. I kind of think they're going to go back to traditional in-person WWDC.
1:55:47I think they like having 5,000 developers there. They like and know the advantages of
1:55:54face-to-face collaboration for like, what do they call it when you get a session with
1:56:01the labs? But does it change the way they do keynotes forever, even when they have 5,000
1:56:10people packed into the convention center or a thousand of us packed into the Steve Jobs
1:56:15theater? Does it change the percentage of stage presentation versus pre-recorded material?
1:56:23Maybe.
1:56:24And do they keep doing the WebEx or whatever they used so that people who can't make
1:56:28it there also get some lab time, which I think would be huge.
1:56:34I don't know about that though, because where's the bandwidth come from? You know,
1:56:37the personal bandwidth come from, you know? So I don't know. I mean, because if you
1:56:42can only fill up—if you only have so many engineers from Apple and they only have so
1:56:46many hours, and if they all get filled up by the people who are there in person, where
1:56:52do the people come from? So I don't know. I don't know. But maybe they do reserve
1:56:58some because they understand though that there's a certain percentage who—lottery aside,
1:57:04they don't need luck. They just can't travel to WWDC for cost reasons or whatever
1:57:09other personal reasons there might be. I thought it was interesting that in my show, they both
1:57:15had a sort of, "Yeah, we hope to see you next year," sort of thing. But that's
1:57:21hard to read. That's not reading into how they're going to hold the conference, right?
1:57:25Because assuming, you know, almost certainly that it'd be possible, you know, and even
1:57:32if they didn't hold a virtual—even if they hold a virtual conference, I suspect
1:57:36they'd definitely still invite lots of press. So I would still be out there anyway, and
1:57:42I could still hold a live show, you know, in a theater, even if there's not an actual
1:57:47in-person conference going by. My money is on the in-person conference again, with maybe
1:57:52their keynotes are forever more brief segments on stage and longer segments that are pre-recorded.
1:58:00That would be my bet. But I could see it going either way.
1:58:03Yeah. So at no point during your interview, Jon, did Craig and Josh try to get you to
1:58:08undo that second button?
1:58:10[Laughter]
1:58:13Nobody mentioned it, but I did notice. I did notice I was East Coast, one button undone,
1:58:20and they were both West Coast, two buttons undone.
1:58:22Yeah, a lot of peer pressure.
1:58:24[Laughter]
1:58:25All right. That is a tight show, René. That might be the shortest show you and I have ever
1:58:30done.
1:58:31I think so.
1:58:32I think we covered a lot of it. Anyway, I'm going to send you to youtube.com/RenéRitchie,
1:58:40René's extraordinary YouTube channel. And of course, you can follow him on Twitter @RenéRitchie.
1:58:46Talk to you next time.
1:58:48Sure.
1:58:49[End of recorded material]
1:58:49[BLANK_AUDIO]