0:00:00Ah, we got so much to talk about, I think.
0:00:02Yeah, we do.
0:00:04And here's one.
0:00:05We have well-prepared notes, which you helped prepare, which I forgot to add the big hack
0:00:10follow-up to, which is bizarre because it's my baby.
0:00:16I was going to say, this is your thing.
0:00:18You have a 50-word asterisk you have to attach to every Bloomberg story.
0:00:24Bloomberg breaks a lot of news.
0:00:27So do you have a macro that you insert that in when you're blogging it?
0:00:30It's not a macro per se, but I have it saved, obviously.
0:00:34I have to rewrite it now.
0:00:36I'm dreading the next time Bloomberg does something link-worthy because I have to write
0:00:40a new footnote because they are not done.
0:00:45This is the strangest thing.
0:00:47So I woke up one day, and of course I'm inundated with texts that they've followed up, and I'm
0:00:53like, "Wow!"
0:00:56And I'm not hung out to dry on this.
0:00:59I haven't said, I guarantee you that they're wrong.
0:01:03My point is, it certainly looks like they're wrong.
0:01:06Everybody says they're wrong.
0:01:07They've offered no proof, so they ought to retract it or prove it.
0:01:11And I thought maybe they've got it, right?
0:01:14And it's the same two reporters.
0:01:16So whoa!
0:01:17And I start reading, and it's like, "This doesn't look like anything?"
0:01:24And I described it as sophistic—I forget the word—sophistry, horseshit.
0:01:33And it is, because it creates the illusion of something there being there, and they're
0:01:38very deft at using official journalistic language and seemingly well-credentialed sources, some
0:01:50of them on the record even, none of whom with any firsthand knowledge of this.
0:01:55Well, that's the thing.
0:01:58It's crazy, in my opinion.
0:02:02And it really, really seems like they've spun themselves out of—this is my take—that
0:02:07they've spun themselves out of control to avoid retracting the original story.
0:02:12Yeah.
0:02:13I've been trying to figure this out too, because when it first hit, it was so damning, and
0:02:19I was like, "Okay, well, Bloomberg, because I know a lot of people who work there, and
0:02:23they're, for the most part, impeccable journalists and are held to extremely high standards and
0:02:27have very good sourcing."
0:02:28And so I didn't really have many reasons to doubt what was being reported.
0:02:34And then more, some of those doubts started to creep in.
0:02:38When every single company—if one company denies something, and if they do it in kind
0:02:43of a weaselly way, which is what companies usually do when they don't know exactly
0:02:46how exposed they may be, they'll deny it, but there will be wiggle room—the denials
0:02:52were pretty affirmative, right?
0:02:54There wasn't a lot of wiggle room.
0:02:55You'd just be like, "This hasn't happened."
0:02:58And that made my spidey sense go up a little bit first.
0:03:01And then seeing a lot of security professionals kind of push back and be like, "Are we sure
0:03:04does this make sense?"
0:03:07You know, has some questioning.
0:03:09But in the back of my mind, I was still like, "Okay, but Bloomberg has really, really
0:03:14good reporters, and they vet things really strongly.
0:03:18Their standards for publishing, based on my experience with people that I know they're
0:03:23going to talk to, are going to be higher than at a lot of other places."
0:03:27So it's this bizarre thing, right?
0:03:33There are these denials.
0:03:34There hasn't been a lot of conclusive proof.
0:03:36There are a lot of security professionals who are calling foul on it.
0:03:42And then this follow-up story comes up, which substantively you link to a really good takedown
0:03:47thread from "own all the things" that really kind of supply the fact that, yeah, there
0:03:54was a lot of nothing in the follow-up.
0:03:58Well, and it's so—what's the name of the game, Whisper Down the Alley?
0:04:03Where you have a bunch of kids lined up and—
0:04:06Yeah, like telephone?
0:04:07Yeah, telephone.
0:04:08You write something down, and you tell the first person, and then they're supposed
0:04:11to whisper it down to the next person.
0:04:14And then the last person says what they're told, and it's inevitably different.
0:04:18Even if—I always thought—the thing about that when I was a kid was that there was always
0:04:22clear—and you knew which kid in your class was going to do it.
0:04:25Somebody was going to screw it up on purpose.
0:04:27Absolutely.
0:04:28And it's like, "We're doing sociology here, David, you jerk."
0:04:33Because he'd have a smirk.
0:04:37It's like egg freckles, and it's like, "Oh, come on."
0:04:40But it doesn't work, you know?
0:04:41And it's all—you know, but everybody—all these sources are saying like, you know, "Well,
0:04:46you know, in 2016 I got this scary briefing from the FBI about a thing that they heard
0:04:52that might have happened was Super Micro."
0:04:54And it's like, nobody is saying, "Yeah, I saw a chip on a Super Micro board."
0:04:57Right.
0:04:58Right.
0:04:59No, I mean, the one thing that does always kind of give me flaws, though—and this is
0:05:04why it's such an interesting kind of conundrum to me—is that the one kind of thing, I guess,
0:05:09that they could have in their favor, but they don't have the evidence that happened in
0:05:12this case, but you know, you have Edward Snowden.
0:05:15And I think if a lot of us had heard the things that he was claiming, a lot of people would
0:05:22have said that that was not happening, right?
0:05:26It seemed like out of a Russian spy novel, right?
0:05:29Right.
0:05:30And it was.
0:05:32So …
0:05:33We, as a species, are not good with stuff that we think isn't expected, right?
0:05:39I mean, did you expect to have a pandemic?
0:05:42And if you did, I mean, and if you did, did you expect it to go this way, right?
0:05:47Like that's one of the craziest things about the last 11 months is we have had a global
0:05:53pandemic and it is nothing like anybody's science fiction about how a pandemic would
0:05:58go.
0:05:59They either turn into zombies, which is better for the drama, or it's like Stephen King's
0:06:06The Stand and 95 percent, or plus, 95 percent plus of humanity gets killed.
0:06:13And there's only a handful of, you know, you're lucky if maybe one out of 20 people
0:06:19you know survives.
0:06:22And this was nothing like that.
0:06:23It was, you know, you just stay home.
0:06:26But it seemed like this couldn't happen.
0:06:28And literally a year ago right now, that was sort of my thinking about it, which was irrational.
0:06:34No, it was really my thinking.
0:06:37Yeah.
0:06:38I was like, "Well, it won't happen here."
0:06:39I remember I had a podcast with Federico Vitticchi and you know, he was around this time.
0:06:44I think it might have been a little bit later in February, you know, and Italy got hit hard
0:06:48already in February.
0:06:52I don't think it's like, it's not some kind of, you know, America First-ism that
0:06:57I think America's magic.
0:06:59It's just the way human nature works where it's like, "Well, you know, these things
0:07:03happen, you know."
0:07:04But they don't happen here.
0:07:05They don't happen here.
0:07:06Yeah, no, I mean…
0:07:07And do you think that's what you think with Bloomberg?
0:07:09Exactly.
0:07:10Yeah, I mean, that's very true.
0:07:13I mean, I'm actually kind of looking.
0:07:15I was, it was a year ago today, I think, that I was flying back, or I guess technically
0:07:23it would be tomorrow, but I was on an airplane at this point, that I was flying back from
0:07:26Australia for what would be my last International Trip of the Year.
0:07:30And I was originally supposed to go from Australia to Singapore for an event, and the Singapore
0:07:35event was canceled because they weren't doing events of a certain size, and that country
0:07:40was taking precautions really strictly.
0:07:42However, the airlines weren't canceling flights.
0:07:45So I, to get home without incurring a ton of fees, I flew from Sydney to Singapore.
0:07:53Then I had like a couple hour layover in the airport, and then I flew from Singapore to
0:07:56South Korea.
0:07:57Then I had like a six or seven hour layover where I got like a hotel room in the pod or
0:08:02whatever in the airport.
0:08:04And then I flew from South Korea to Seattle.
0:08:07So I was in the air for like 27 hours.
0:08:10It was kind of insane.
0:08:11And that was my last International Trip of the Year.
0:08:14And even though the Singapore stop of the event I was presenting at was canceled, I
0:08:20still had scheduled things for Zurich and for Israel and I think some other places and
0:08:27was expecting that to go forward.
0:08:29Was not anticipating that, "Oh yeah, the world is going to change and it's going to come
0:08:33here."
0:08:34Like, no concept.
0:08:35No.
0:08:36Seems unrelated, but I mean, that is sort of how you think about a publication like
0:08:41Bloomberg.
0:08:42Yeah, it's true.
0:08:44And it's the burden and the benefit of the bureaucracy of something that's an institution.
0:08:53And it's not like reporters for Bloomberg get to just type into the CMS and hit publish
0:08:58and it pops up.
0:09:02I remember thinking, I remember being not opposed to, but thinking it wasn't going to
0:09:11happen that Apple would switch from PowerPC to Intel back in 2005.
0:09:17And then the rumors picked up a little bit, but it wasn't like this year where it was
0:09:21like, "Oh, months in advance, everybody knew it was going to happen."
0:09:26But then like the weekend before WWDC, the Wall Street Journal published a story that
0:09:30said Apple's going to announce that they're switching the Mac to Intel.
0:09:36And I had to square those two things in my head that I didn't think it was going to happen
0:09:41for various reasons, including the fact that I thought...
0:09:45One of the things that I thought went unsaid at the time was, "Well, wait, if they port
0:09:49the Mac to standard x86 hardware, then wouldn't that make what we now call Hackintosh is just
0:09:57run rampant?
0:09:58Wouldn't that be sort of like the clone days again, even without the clone licensing fees?"
0:10:05But I had to square my reasons x, y, and z for thinking Apple wouldn't do it with the
0:10:11fact that the Wall Street Journal said, "Oh, yeah, it's happening."
0:10:14And I came to the conclusion that, "Well, if the journal says it's happening, it's happening.
0:10:18Let's wait till Monday in the keynote and see why."
0:10:20Right, which was the correct thing because...
0:10:28And I think for a lot of people like that, I wasn't doing what you were doing back in
0:10:322000, what was it, 2005?
0:10:36I was still in college, but I was watching those things, but I would have made the same
0:10:40assessment that you did.
0:10:41I would have been like, "Okay, if the Wall Street Journal is saying this, then this is
0:10:44true."
0:10:45Right?
0:10:46Because that typically is, especially with Apple, like now Apple, the leaks tend to happen
0:10:51months in advance, but they were much more closely held then.
0:10:55But if you had a really big outlet, a really well-placed place like the Journal, then you'd
0:11:00be like, "Okay, my bet is going to be that this is happening because they're not going
0:11:04to risk their reputation on being wrong about something like this."
0:11:09And I mean, I think that that is part of, like with the Supermicro story, you know,
0:11:13part of me is like, "Would Bloomberg risk their reputation for being wrong?"
0:11:18And I mean, clearly they are.
0:11:21Clearly they think that they've got it, but I'm not convinced.
0:11:26You're not convinced.
0:11:27A lot of other people aren't convinced.
0:11:30There's a couple of ways, you know, I mean, number one, you never bet the house on any
0:11:34one report.
0:11:35Anybody could be wrong, right?
0:11:36I mean, the most famous example I would say would be Judith Miller's reporting for the
0:11:40New York Times on The Iraq War, where she said, you know, and again, there's always
0:11:44the, "Well, how does this news reporter say they know what they say they know?"
0:11:49And the Wall Street Journal, with the Power PC story said, "According to sources familiar
0:11:56with the matter."
0:11:57And somebody at Apple who knew about it blabbed to the Wall Street Journal, whether deliberately
0:12:01or not, but the Wall Street Journal trusted that person enough to say, "This is good.
0:12:06Let's go with it."
0:12:07Right.
0:12:08And, you know, Judith Miller back in the run up to the Iraq War quoted somebody in the
0:12:12US National Security apparatus who said, "We know that Iraq has weapons of mass destruction.
0:12:17We know it.
0:12:18It's a done deal.
0:12:19We're going to go in and get them."
0:12:21And it turned out, well, guess what?
0:12:23They didn't.
0:12:24And the New York Times still to this day, I don't think, for a generation won't recover.
0:12:29There's a lot of people who will never, never...
0:12:31No, I mean, it was that and Jason Blair happened at the same time or around the same time.
0:12:35It was kind of that one-two punch.
0:12:37And Blair being a fabulous is a little bit of a different thing, right?
0:12:42Oh, I agree.
0:12:43I think it was just the two happening, completing together, I think.
0:12:46Yeah.
0:12:47Yeah.
0:12:48That is true because they were so close in proximity where it's like, yeah, you can't
0:12:51trust the thing.
0:12:52There were so many people who wanted to say for years you can't trust anything in the
0:12:55New York Times.
0:12:56Exactly.
0:12:57Period.
0:12:58And then, you know, it was her who, you know, I don't even know, was she an opinion columnist
0:13:02at that point?
0:13:03I'm not sure.
0:13:04No, she was a news reporter.
0:13:05She changed beats a lot.
0:13:06But it was one of those things where she was not well respected.
0:13:09I read this book, I think it was called Page One Up.
0:13:11I'm going to find it.
0:13:13But I read this book that was written about what happened at the New York Times in the
0:13:17midst of those scandals.
0:13:18It's really interesting.
0:13:19And, you know, she had lost a lot of favor in the newsroom, but she had these impeccable
0:13:27sources, which we now know to be, you know, people like Scooter Libby and Robert Novak
0:13:32and other people that like were reputable sources.
0:13:35If somebody like that is telling you these things, I can understand even for someone
0:13:39like her who my only interaction with her was I was in the green room with her at a
0:13:44cable network once and she didn't know how to use copy and paste on her iPhone.
0:13:48Really?
0:13:49Oh no, this is a great story.
0:13:50Yeah.
0:13:51I had to show her how to use copy and paste on her iPhone.
0:13:54And this was like 2014.
0:13:56Yeah.
0:13:58Yeah.
0:13:59That to me says kind of everything you need to know.
0:14:05But like, you know, she lost a lot of favor in the newsroom, but she had those sources
0:14:10and they didn't have the proper checks.
0:14:12And like they went through a really big kind of reckoning, you know, like Howard Raines's
0:14:19like reign, you know, as, as editor kind of came to an end.
0:14:22Like they, they had to go through a pretty massive reckoning over that.
0:14:25And I think you're right.
0:14:26I think they, I don't know if they, I don't know if I would argue they haven't recovered.
0:14:30I think there's a certain generation of people who don't even remember that happening, you
0:14:34know, but I do think it tainted them in a way that even if people don't remember that
0:14:38happening probably are impacted by that without even realizing it.
0:14:43Right.
0:14:44So like if you look at like journalism students today and younger news readers today who were
0:14:48children and don't remember that, the lasting impact of what that did to the Times's reputation
0:14:54carries through.
0:14:56And so they might not even, it's like the, the Devil Wears Prada scene where, uh, you
0:14:59know, Miranda is telling Andy that, you know, the sweater that she's wearing was, was, you
0:15:05know, that she thought was, was made with no, you know, decision whatsoever was like
0:15:09made was a decision that was predetermined for her by everyone in that room.
0:15:12I feel like it might be that sort of thing where younger news readers don't even understand
0:15:17why they might have a certain perception, but it does go back to that.
0:15:20I think you're probably right.
0:15:22But I mean, I think they've recovered a lot, but it certainly was like an incredibly painful
0:15:27time for, for the Times.
0:15:30The question always is if the only source is an unnamed source or even just a named
0:15:35source, but it's, you have to take the sources name for it.
0:15:39Where, where do you draw the line on the magnitude of the allegation, whatever you want to call
0:15:46it, you know what they're saying with, do we need more sources to say the same thing
0:15:52and where, when do you need to see the actual proof?
0:15:56Right now?
0:15:57I know we're mixing some big stories here, but it wasn't practical for the New York Times
0:16:03to expect to get their eyes on the actual weapons of mass destruction in Iraq before
0:16:08the war, right?
0:16:09That's right.
0:16:10That literally wasn't possible.
0:16:12With the Supermicro story, it is not, it wasn't ridiculous to think, given the accusations
0:16:20of the original 2018 story, that they would want to see one of these compromised motherboards
0:16:26with a chip or at least talk to a source who would say, yes, I saw one of the boards with
0:16:35one of these chips and identified that one of these chips was doing this.
0:16:39And they had neither.
0:16:40They didn't even have a firsthand source, let alone physical proof.
0:16:45And one of the things that always stuck out to me as like, okay, we'll see where this
0:16:49goes and that I can't believe that here we are two and a half years later and still doing
0:16:57it is that even one of the two reporters on the story, Michael Riley, tweeted like a day
0:17:04or two after the original story broke, he tweeted, "That's the unique thing about this
0:17:08attack.
0:17:09Although the details have been very tightly held, there is physical evidence out there
0:17:13in the world.
0:17:14And because of the details are out, it will be hard to keep more from emerging."
0:17:19And yet no one's been able to follow up.
0:17:21Right.
0:17:22Which it-
0:17:23That to me is the biggest thing.
0:17:24It's not even so much anything else.
0:17:26It's the fact that there hasn't been any follow up.
0:17:28Just for any listeners who might be interested, the book I was talking about is called Hard
0:17:32News, the Scandals at the New York Times and the Future of American Media.
0:17:36And it's by Seth Mnookin.
0:17:38It's a good read.
0:17:39Yeah, I think the fact there was no follow up, because the thing is, I would expect like
0:17:45for something like this, even if they got some of the details wrong, which I would expect,
0:17:50I wouldn't expect everything to be completely correct.
0:17:52But if parts of it were correct, I would expect that every major investigative publication
0:17:59on the planet would immediately be putting their own resources into trying to vet this
0:18:03out more.
0:18:05And there hasn't been anything.
0:18:08Right.
0:18:09Like you don't have to know how news organizations work to be a savvy, or maybe to be a savvy
0:18:17news reader you do, but to be a well read news reader.
0:18:24You don't have to know how movies are really made to enjoy movies.
0:18:31Right.
0:18:32But when something interesting happens, it's good to know how it happens.
0:18:37And it can help explain why you're reading what you're reading.
0:18:40And one of the things that happens in the news industry is when somebody comes out with
0:18:44a scoop, competing news agencies, A, are pissed, because everybody loves the scoops.
0:18:51They love it.
0:18:52They're like, "Why didn't I get this?"
0:18:53Your editor is literally yelling at you and he is saying to you, "Why do they have this
0:18:56and why don't we?"
0:18:58Right.
0:18:59And if they know who the source is, even if it's an unnamed source, and a lot of times
0:19:03they do because they're juiced into, they call the source and they're pissed.
0:19:07And they're like, "Why didn't you tell me this?"
0:19:09But then the immediate thing they do is they jump on the story too, to follow it up, and
0:19:14they have to put the, as originally reported by the Washington Post or as originally reported
0:19:19by whoever, but then what they want to do is add to it.
0:19:24Right?
0:19:25So that the Washington Post comes out with a big scoop about X.
0:19:28The New York Times is mad.
0:19:30They come out with their follow up.
0:19:32They have to acknowledge that the first reported in the Washington Post, they don't have to
0:19:36like legally, they have to as a convention.
0:19:41But then what they want to do is add original reporting to the story and build on it.
0:19:46And I know firsthand, I've spoken to people at news organizations who worked on this story.
0:19:52Like, it is true.
0:19:53I know firsthand.
0:19:54I don't know everybody who worked on it, but I know that other major news publications
0:19:59put reporters on this story because it was so spectacular.
0:20:02Yes.
0:20:03No, I know that too.
0:20:04I know that too.
0:20:05Yeah.
0:20:06I've never really found anything.
0:20:07And it is the allegations of the original story, which literally involved the surreptitious
0:20:13adding of chips to motherboards and super micro server components literally would have
0:20:22left behind physical evidence that couldn't be erased as opposed to, and this is sort
0:20:27of where they're sort of walking it back.
0:20:30And in some ways, this follow-up story last week is a broader allegation about the length
0:20:37of time and the degree to which super micro servers might have allegedly were compromised
0:20:43by government hackers from China.
0:20:51But it also seems to be, was definitely walking back the adding of chips and making more sort
0:20:58of hand-wavy motions about firmware, which, A, is a lot harder to prove because you can
0:21:08also, a clever piece of firmware could do its surreptitious business and then overwrite
0:21:14its naughty bits.
0:21:16Right.
0:21:17Yeah.
0:21:18No, I mean, we've seen that with SolarWinds, right?
0:21:19Right.
0:21:20Like the SolarWinds hack is actually quite incredible in what it was doing and was a
0:21:25very difficult thing to uncover because it was purposely not attacking a lot of the,
0:21:32you know, it was targeting the SolarWinds systems and then those were changing the way
0:21:37certain updates were issued to the other systems.
0:21:41But it was a very difficult thing to kind of unravel because of how it was done.
0:21:47Right.
0:21:48So, yeah.
0:21:49Sorry, go on.
0:21:50Yeah, well, it's a very casual person.
0:21:51You can just kind of see how a software attack is both easier to implement and install and
0:22:00easier to hide.
0:22:02Right.
0:22:03The part of the blockbuster nature of the original 2018 Bloomberg report, the big hack,
0:22:09was that it was hardware and that the evidence would be out there.
0:22:12And they weren't saying like, oh, they got like three of these chips on three motherboards
0:22:16and one went to Apple and one went to this company that was acquired by Amazon and one
0:22:20went somewhere else.
0:22:21They said that there were like thousands of them and nobody found any of them, which really,
0:22:26really, I mean, at this point, it seems absolutely unbelievable that it actually happened.
0:22:33Yeah.
0:22:34Yeah.
0:22:35It's just, well, I mean, to me, the thing was actually, it was interesting that they
0:22:39did actually kind of use the SolarWinds hack, which is real and has been verified, to kind
0:22:45of bolster this kind of updated and sort of changed claim that this was BIOS code that
0:22:52was updated.
0:22:53And yeah, you know what?
0:22:54That does seem a lot more plausible.
0:22:57But it's, to me, some of it does feel undercut by the nature of what the earlier reporting
0:23:03was, which I think is a bad thing because if this did happen, then that's a problem
0:23:08for everyone, right?
0:23:09Like that's, I don't want this to be one of the situations where we ignore potential reporting
0:23:16that there's been malicious activity because the reporting on it was imperfect.
0:23:23But at the same time, the reporting is imperfect and doesn't seem to really go a long way
0:23:30to kind of explain itself or make a strong enough case for itself, whether it's because
0:23:36there are no on the record sources or because the people who are on the record don't have
0:23:41direct access or knowledge to things.
0:23:43Yeah, there's a lot of holes.
0:23:45I mean, and it just, and very specific allegations about Apple and Amazon in particular, which
0:23:53again, like you said, the two companies denied in no uncertain terms.
0:23:58I mean, a very-
0:23:59There were no weasel words.
0:24:00Right.
0:24:01Very unusual statements.
0:24:02And I know there are so many people, not a majority, but I know there's a number of people
0:24:08who just disbelieve anything that comes out of official corporate comms if it's to cover,
0:24:13you know, to deny a negative story.
0:24:16And that's fine to be skeptical like that, but you have to acknowledge that it was not
0:24:20the typical weasel words that-
0:24:23No.
0:24:24That company, you know, there was no cover your ass aspect to it.
0:24:27No.
0:24:28Which to me was the first red flag when they were like unequivocal in the denial and there
0:24:33weren't those weasel words.
0:24:34That was when I went, "Okay."
0:24:35Because you know the lawyers have to go over every single line of that.
0:24:38And you're talking about two companies that have, you know, at that point they were closing
0:24:42in on a trillion dollar market share.
0:24:43Now they're both, you know, Amazon's a trillion and a half and Apple's a $2 trillion company.
0:24:49These are companies that, you know, if you were to be caught misleading and lying in
0:24:54any of your official communications this way would have massive, massive consequences.
0:24:59Like you want to talk about like not just fines, but regulation and all kinds of other
0:25:02things.
0:25:03Like this is not something that I could ever see the lawyers signing off on if they didn't
0:25:08have full faith that what they were saying was accurate.
0:25:13Yeah.
0:25:14I was, I read her an interesting piece this week.
0:25:16All, I mean, just about everything she writes is interesting, but Zaina Tufekci wrote, she
0:25:22has a substack and she was writing about critical thinking and how to, like her upbringing in
0:25:33an authoritarian regime, she feels prepared her a lot better for the last year, both in
0:25:38terms of like, "Oh, okay, this is going to be bad.
0:25:40We should stock up on X, Y, and Z," long before everybody else made a run on the toilet paper
0:25:45and stuff.
0:25:46But also sort of seeing through this sort of authoritarian slanted aspects of the Trump
0:25:55administration.
0:25:56And one of the points, just a small point she raised on the critical thinking was when
0:26:01Trump got COVID and she said, "Oh, he's way sicker than they're saying he is."
0:26:07And she, you know, she was like, "Oh, of course."
0:26:09And she was like, she linked to a tweet where somebody was, when his doctors gave a press
0:26:14conference outdoors and they asked, "Was Trump's oxygen level ever below 90?"
0:26:21This is the blood oxygen level that your Apple Watch can in fact read now.
0:26:26And basically, just as a baseline, if you should be above 95, anything like I think
0:26:3493 and below, if you have COVID is considered a problem.
0:26:38And 80s is, anything in the 80s is bad.
0:26:42So the press asked his doctor, "Was Trump's oxygen ever below 90?"
0:26:46And his doctor said, "We don't have any recordings here of that."
0:26:51But was it ever below 90 here or at the White House?
0:26:55And his doctor said, "No, it was below 94%.
0:26:58It wasn't down in the low 80s or anything."
0:27:02And she read into it.
0:27:03She was like, "Now I read this and I know how to read this."
0:27:06So when he's, you know, the operative words were his first answer when he said, "We don't
0:27:10have any recordings here of that."
0:27:13That means that when he was here, I think this was outside the hospital, they just don't
0:27:17have recordings of it, but it did drop below 90.
0:27:23And when he said it was below 94, but it wasn't down in the low 80s, that means it was definitely
0:27:28in the 80s.
0:27:29It just wasn't like 81.
0:27:32And lo and behold, a week ago, it turned out Trump was a lot sicker than they let on when
0:27:38he had it.
0:27:39And there's sources who told the New York Times that, yeah, his blood oxygen was like
0:27:42eight down to like 87.
0:27:44And that's when they panicked and took him to the hospital.
0:27:47And it's that that's weasel words, right?
0:27:50And that's exactly what Amazon and Apple did not do when this came out.
0:27:54And they weren't blindsided.
0:27:55That's the other thing too.
0:27:56When the original Bloomberg big hack story came out, it wasn't like they dropped the
0:28:00story on Amazon and Apple and knee jerk reaction.
0:28:04Does anybody know about this?
0:28:05Nope, nope.
0:28:06Okay, let's just deny it.
0:28:08Like it contacted them in advance.
0:28:11Both companies like and I know I talked to people off the record at Apple who were like,
0:28:15oh, no, we did like we spent a ton of money and pulled people off real work and tore server
0:28:21place, you know, firm farms apart looking at this.
0:28:24We found nothing for weeks.
0:28:27And the other thing too, these weren't Apple products, right?
0:28:31It's not like Apple had was saying that like millions of Mac pros or Mac minis weren't
0:28:38compromised.
0:28:39These were just internal to Apple servers from this super micro company.
0:28:44And their denial just wasn't like that at all.
0:28:46There was nothing to read between the lines.
0:28:49Yeah.
0:28:50And I don't know the thing and I wonder what your thought is on this.
0:28:54I don't know much about either, you know, of the reporters on the story.
0:28:57I think one of them is a cybersecurity reporter, and I'm not sure what the other person's
0:29:04focus area is.
0:29:06It seems like that's what he's gone into, but it seems like, you know, they seem more
0:29:12policy, more like, like, you know, wonk kind of, you know, DC kind of focus people.
0:29:18And I wonder if this is a similar thing in some cases to the Judy Miller thing.
0:29:24Now that was sloppy and that shouldn't have been published and they should have had better
0:29:27betting.
0:29:28There's a lot of layers to that.
0:29:30But you know, they some of it couldn't come down to when you're an editor, if you don't
0:29:35know your subject matter and you trust your author to know it and to get some of those
0:29:39details.
0:29:40I wonder if this is one of those cases where these are people who know a lot about government
0:29:46and have a lot of contacts within government, but don't necessarily know enough about like
0:29:50actual security and about tech.
0:29:53I think that's exactly, I mean, because their sources are all national security officials,
0:29:57you know, quote unquote.
0:29:58Right.
0:29:59And, you know, one guy, they make a big deal.
0:30:01He was a former Navy SEAL, which again, being a Navy SEAL is very prestigious, very difficult,
0:30:06upper echelon of the armed forces.
0:30:09Doesn't necessarily make you an expert on, you know, Chinese supply chain espionage.
0:30:13Right.
0:30:14Right.
0:30:15I mean, and I think that is also worth noting, like there is a difference between cybersecurity
0:30:18and national security, right?
0:30:20Like they're both security, but they're different ways.
0:30:22And so that's the only thing, only way I can kind of try to kind of parse this in my mind
0:30:28is to see, okay, maybe the reporters really do believe what they're reporting and really
0:30:34do think the data says what it says, but they don't have the subject matter expertise and
0:30:39aren't talking to the subject matter experts enough to really be able to ascertain, is
0:30:44this possible?
0:30:45Did this happen?
0:30:46Is this likely?
0:30:48Because they're coming at it from a different perspective and from a different place.
0:30:53Yeah, I, yeah, that's what I think happened.
0:30:57And I also think that, well, why would they go so long without just retracting it?
0:31:02You know, and A, I think it's just anathema to them that they could have gotten something
0:31:08so wrong.
0:31:09And B, I think very cynically, they've looked at what this stinky pile of crap they were
0:31:18held left holding that was never backed up by any evidence, never backed up by anybody
0:31:24else's reporting, and looked at it and it's all sort of, well, you can't prove a negative,
0:31:30right?
0:31:31Like if I say, guess what, Christina, there's an invisible man who's standing behind you
0:31:37and he's been there your entire life and you can't see him because he's composed of dark
0:31:42matter.
0:31:43I mean, it's, you know, probably I'm crazy, but you can't prove it, right?
0:31:48You can't prove that there isn't an invisible man from another dimension made of dark matter
0:31:52who's followed you around everywhere you go for your, you know, it's, you can't prove
0:31:57that there aren't, just because we haven't found the servers that Apple has that have
0:32:02these surreptitious microchips in them, you can't prove that they don't exist.
0:32:09You know, and I think that's what they're hanging their hat on with their refusal to
0:32:12retract.
0:32:13Here's what I wrote back when the original report came out, and I feel like it really
0:32:17stands up.
0:32:18I see no way around it.
0:32:19"The Bloomberg's report is significantly wrong, at least as it pertains to Amazon and Apple,
0:32:25or Apple and Amazon have issued blatantly false denials.
0:32:29You can perhaps chalk up Apple's denial to it being written by Apple PR.
0:32:33I don't think this would happen, but hypothetically, this issue could be deemed so sensitive either
0:32:38within the company or as a national security issue that the people at Apple with knowledge
0:32:41of the situation lied to Apple PR and then Apple PR issued a false statement.
0:32:46But in my experience, Apple PR does not lie.
0:32:50Do they spin the truth in ways that favor the company?
0:32:52Of course, that's their job, but they don't lie because they understand that one of Apple's
0:32:56key assets is its credibility.
0:32:59There's nothing, they'd say nothing before they'd lie, right?
0:33:02That's the thing that they could have done is just said, "We have no comment on this."
0:33:07But Apple's CIO signing his name and writing his statement on Amazon's thing, that's Schmidt
0:33:13signing his name to Amazon's report is more telling.
0:33:16Presumably no one at Apple or at Amazon would be more familiar with the details of this
0:33:20breach than Schmidt, and he vouched for it personally.
0:33:24Anyway, I can't help but think that you're onto something too, that Bloomberg has been
0:33:32sort of waiting to sort of, "Let's just push this vague thing out there to make it seem
0:33:37like we were onto..."
0:33:38Because that's the weird thing about this follow-up.
0:33:42They acknowledged the old story, but they didn't acknowledge that they're the same two
0:33:45reporters who wrote it, and they didn't acknowledge that nobody else ever proved it with Amazon
0:33:51and Apple.
0:33:52They just said, "Oh yeah, and by the way, two years ago, we said Amazon and Apple were
0:33:55affected by this, but it turns out we were onto a bigger story," or something like that.
0:34:00Right, right.
0:34:01And it's like, it sounds like, "Ooh, this is incredible."
0:34:04And then you read it and there's even less details.
0:34:08Now I got to write a new footnote.
0:34:10All right, let me thank our first sponsor.
0:34:14It is a new sponsor, FlatFile.
0:34:18Nearly everyone has dealt with formatting CSV or Excel files so that the data can be
0:34:23correctly imported into your application.
0:34:26It's a pain.
0:34:27Companies of all sizes spend an exorbitant amount trying to fix this problem.
0:34:31Typical solutions include using CSV templates, emailing Excel files back and forth, or hiring
0:34:38expensive implementation teams to do it for you.
0:34:41Our friends at FlatFile are working on Concierge, which is their service that offers no-code
0:34:47collaborative workspaces for onboarding structured data.
0:34:52Invite customers to securely import, format, or merge data from spreadsheets.
0:34:58No fumbling around with FTP uploads, no emailing sensitive Excel files back and forth, no formatting
0:35:05yet another custom CSV template just for this data.
0:35:10FlatFile is on a mission to help companies spend less time formatting spreadsheet data
0:35:15to import into applications and more time using it.
0:35:19Curious how they can help your business?
0:35:21Visit them at flatfile.io.
0:35:28That's flatfile.io for all of your data importing needs.
0:35:32Do you want to stick with the news for now before we get into more analysis?
0:35:38The Apple car thing, maybe.
0:35:40What do you think of that?
0:35:41Yeah.
0:35:42Yeah, let's talk about the Apple car.
0:35:43There's a lot of news on that.
0:35:45There is a lot of news on that.
0:35:46And I'm finally at the point where, you know, I knew that they were working on the project.
0:35:51It seemed like they had stopped for a while.
0:35:52It does now seem like it is very much back up and running again.
0:35:56Forgive the puns.
0:35:58I liked your piece on what the Volkswagen CEO said, especially because we've talked
0:36:04before about your love of going after Ed Colligan.
0:36:09But I'm curious from your perspective, you know, and basically the news is that he kind
0:36:14of said that he came out and he's not concerned with any of their plans.
0:36:18There's also been rumors that they might be doing something with Hyundai.
0:36:22I did not realize that they're not quite the same company, but there's like Hyundai owns
0:36:27a big portion of IKEA or vice versa.
0:36:30But anyway, in your home state of Georgia.
0:36:33Yeah.
0:36:34Interesting.
0:36:35Interesting.
0:36:36Although, yeah, I guess that they, I think I remember now that they built plans there
0:36:39or whatever, but cool.
0:36:41This is the one thing that I don't get about the Apple car.
0:36:44And I think at this point it's clear that they're doing something with an automotive.
0:36:47There are too many leaks and there's too many reports on this.
0:36:51I tend to agree with your analysis on the Volkswagen CEO.
0:36:55You know, he's not dismissing them, but he's also, I think it's fair for him to be skeptical.
0:37:00I don't, I don't know why Apple wants to be in this space.
0:37:05That's what I can't figure out.
0:37:06That's a good question.
0:37:07And I've thought about that from the origins of the rumor.
0:37:11One thing I remember, and again, you know, put a grain of salt in it because again, this
0:37:15is like whisper down the alley.
0:37:16This is like third hand, but from like their first run through of this project, Titan,
0:37:23where they built it up and sort of specked out a car that they might've, could've maybe
0:37:28gone to market with.
0:37:30The story I've heard is that the price tag, it was something like $170,000.
0:37:36Like it was like the starting price.
0:37:38And that's where like Tim Cook was like, all right, well we need, we need to reset this.
0:37:42Let's get, you know, Bob Mansfield in there.
0:37:46And there was a lot of high level shuffling of priorities and they sort of reset and focused
0:37:54on the supposedly the core of the project for now on.
0:37:57Well, let's just get the autonomous stuff down and we'll rethink the car part.
0:38:03You can't go wrong.
0:38:04In general, you can't go wrong thinking that, okay, the Apple, Apple's going to make a blank.
0:38:09They're going to make a digital watch.
0:38:12How much is it going to cost?
0:38:14Well, however much you think most digital fitness watches cost, Apple's is going to
0:38:18cost more.
0:38:19You can't go wrong, right?
0:38:20So if they make a car, it's probably going to be expensive compared to regular, you know,
0:38:24average car.
0:38:25Sure.
0:38:26$170,000?
0:38:27No, that's, that's a lot of money.
0:38:30Well that's like when you sell a $10,000 digital watch, which didn't work.
0:38:36By the way, just let me say this.
0:38:37Nobody should quote me on that $170,000 thing.
0:38:40That's not even what I heard.
0:38:41I don't know.
0:38:42I don't know what the number was, it was really high, but don't even quote me that it was 170,000.
0:38:46But it was some kind of, you know, back of the envelope math and it was a six figure
0:38:52number.
0:38:53Yeah.
0:38:54Well, put aside the edition models, right?
0:38:57Just forget that that's a wholly separate discussion, I think.
0:39:03Although it is, in my opinion, sort of embarrassing.
0:39:05I just wrote about it recently.
0:39:07Oh, I think it's completely embarrassing.
0:39:09I think it's one of their biggest failures ever.
0:39:11I have said this though, I think that one of the smartest and best decisions, like,
0:39:15the strength that Apple has had is when they pivoted the watch from fashion to fitness.
0:39:20When they made that pivot in that second year, that saved the watch and made it into the
0:39:26massive success that it is now.
0:39:28But the first year it was all about fashion and that was not the right way to go.
0:39:31Well, they had the fitness there, right?
0:39:34And they really emphasized at the beginning that they had three, and I think we can tie
0:39:38this in with the car, but they had three.
0:39:40They were very clear that they had three models, the sport, the no name stainless steel one,
0:39:47and the edition.
0:39:48Right.
0:39:49And I remember arguing with people, and I'm not saying this just to pick up my being right
0:39:53points, but there were people who were arguing that the sport ones would cost more than the
0:39:59no name ones.
0:40:00They're like, "Oh, the no name one means it's the cheapest and the sport one."
0:40:03And it's like, "No, I mean, how in the world would the aluminum one cost more?"
0:40:07Exactly, right.
0:40:08And they're like, "Yeah, it's ion glass, dude."
0:40:11And it's like, "No, that's just a fancy way of saying it's glass.
0:40:14The other one's made of sapphire.
0:40:16Sapphire's better than glass.
0:40:17Ion glass is just glass.
0:40:20They just put a word in front of glass."
0:40:24It's like, "You don't know what you're talking about."
0:40:27And then I remember too telling people, I even wrote a thing.
0:40:30I was like, "The gold ones are going to cost like $10,000."
0:40:34People are like, "You're out of your mind.
0:40:35You're going to..."
0:40:36No, I remember that.
0:40:37I remember you being right on that.
0:40:38And you were dead on.
0:40:39But it was insane.
0:40:40I was low, if anything, because they went up to like $18,500.
0:40:44Yeah.
0:40:45No, it was insane.
0:40:48And it was completely...
0:40:50I think that was...
0:40:51Apple, I think, oftentimes is considered like a Hooper Stick company, and I don't think
0:40:56that's true.
0:40:57That, I do think, was like P. Cooper.
0:40:59Just think that you could sell an $18,000 watch.
0:41:01It had to be Johnny.
0:41:02I mean, and I...
0:41:03Oh, totally.
0:41:04100%.
0:41:05I hate to do that.
0:41:06I know somebody under the rug who's not even there anymore.
0:41:09But I mean, it had to be Johnny.
0:41:11I mean, it doesn't make any sense that it was anybody else.
0:41:14No, of course it was Johnny, because he's a watch guy, and he'd already done things.
0:41:17Like, he was making those art installation pieces with Mark, his buddy, his name I can't
0:41:23think of, last name I can't think of.
0:41:25They were already doing those sorts of really, really high-end, one-off kinds of things.
0:41:31They were already doing that kind of design work.
0:41:34So yeah, that was a completely Johnny thing, I have to think.
0:41:38But I also do think it was a little bit of kind of a Apple on top of the world thing,
0:41:41thinking, "Yeah, we can sell $10,000 watches that will be unable to get a software update
0:41:46in two years."
0:41:47I do think it's an embarrassment.
0:41:49I do think it's the, you know...
0:41:52Even if Apple wants to spin it now and be like, "Oh, we only claim to make a handful,"
0:41:56no, you productized it.
0:41:59You made it a part of your promotional thing.
0:42:02You had an assembly line for it, even if you didn't assemble a lot of them.
0:42:06You made this askew.
0:42:07This was not a thing that you made just a couple of variants of for very special people.
0:42:14This was something that was actually, you had to get an appointment and you had it in
0:42:19stores.
0:42:20Like, this was a real thing, and I was completely out of touch with reality, in my opinion.
0:42:26It stands out to me because, in my opinion, it's a fundamentally dishonest product because
0:42:34if you buy a $10,000, $20,000, $30,000 or more...
0:42:41Watches cost a lot, but if you buy a $30,000 Rolex or a Patek, it is likely going to go
0:42:48up in value.
0:42:50Absolutely, in recent years, the high-end, fine watch market is skyrocketing.
0:42:57It's hard to get your hands on a lot of the most popular stainless steel watches from
0:43:02Rolex and Patek and other companies.
0:43:08You buy it now, you spend $10,000, you get a Rolex.
0:43:13Ten years from now, it's probably gone up in value, but at the very least, it is still
0:43:18just as good a watch as it was ten years before.
0:43:20Well, that's what I was going to say.
0:43:21It's going to last forever.
0:43:22Like, my parents both have, at this point, 20-something-year-old Rolexes that were very
0:43:29expensive then, and I think my mom even got the face of hers redone or whatever, but they
0:43:36still work exactly as they did.
0:43:39They're in fantastic shape, and as you said, my mom's might have even gone up in value.
0:43:46It's one of those things.
0:43:47Yeah.
0:43:48You do have to, if you wear it regularly, you do need to get it serviced some number
0:43:51of years.
0:43:52But an official Rolex, the place where you bought it, if you buy it from an official
0:43:56retailer, they'll take gold care of you.
0:44:00I mean, they'll come in, and if there's damage to it, if there's chips on the glass, on the
0:44:05sapphire or whatever, they'll ask you, "Do you want it replaced, or do you want to keep
0:44:09it?"
0:44:10Because some people want to keep the original, even if it's damaged.
0:44:12They won't touch it without your permission, but if you do want, they'll replace parts
0:44:17and it'll work, and you can hand it down to the next generation.
0:44:22That's what you get at a $10,000, $20,000 watch level.
0:44:26The Apple Watch, like you said, literally within two years, it wouldn't even...
0:44:30Literally within two years, it was completely useless.
0:44:33Right.
0:44:34And the first generation Apple Watch, the AKA Series Zero, was kind of crappy technically
0:44:39too.
0:44:40It was very much like the first iPad, right?
0:44:41Not enough RAM, a little bit slow processor.
0:44:45It was MVP.
0:44:47I would say it was the worst first generation product.
0:44:49I would say even the original iPad was a little better.
0:44:52Oh, no, I agree with that.
0:44:54I just meant in terms of the guts.
0:44:57No, I think the iPad was actually a fantastic first generation product.
0:45:02But yeah, I agree with that.
0:45:03I think it was probably the worst first generation product.
0:45:05I think it's the first one and the only one that really comes to mind where they do a
0:45:10great job.
0:45:11They're obviously a company of perfectionists, and there's a part of them.
0:45:15Everybody works at Apple who would love to just go away for 20 years to work on something
0:45:19and then come out with it, but you can't.
0:45:21You have to ship, and they're very, very good at shipping.
0:45:24So you kind of have to ship a little too early because if you don't purposefully ship a little
0:45:29too early, you're going to ship a little too late, and that's very dangerous.
0:45:33I think that Apple Watch is the one where they shipped at least a year too early.
0:45:37And you can't blame them because it was the first product post Steve Jobs.
0:45:43The company was withering under Wall Street speculation that they'd never have another
0:45:48product after Steve Jobs.
0:45:50So you can't blame them for maybe—
0:45:53And it had been leaked so much, right?
0:45:55At that point too, it had been leaked so much.
0:45:57And it was too early.
0:45:58I felt that too.
0:45:59I felt like they didn't have the apps ready.
0:46:03They didn't have the SDK ready.
0:46:04They didn't have that story done.
0:46:06And they did—it was released in March, and then it came out in the fall.
0:46:10And March seemed late, like it seemed to me like they'd wanted to release it the previous
0:46:14fall, and it just wasn't even there.
0:46:16And it took until the following fall for it really to be viable.
0:46:22And yeah, it was too early.
0:46:26Yeah.
0:46:27So the Series 1, or Series 2, I guess, right?
0:46:30Because Series 1 was the sort of—
0:46:33Retconned.
0:46:34Right.
0:46:35Yeah, they took the guts of the other one but gave it a better processor so you could
0:46:39actually upgrade it, right?
0:46:41The Series 0 was so bad that they wouldn't even do the typical Tim Cook era thing of selling
0:46:45the year-old version at a lower price, right?
0:46:47It was so slow.
0:46:48No, exactly, which for me is someone who spent $850 on a watch.
0:46:53I was pretty angry.
0:46:54I didn't get another one until a Series 3.
0:46:56I said it.
0:46:57I was like, "No, you're not getting my money because I'm mad."
0:47:01If you spent $400 to $800, $900, I think $1,100 got you the stainless steel one with the
0:47:09steel link bracelet.
0:47:12Yeah, I believe so.
0:47:14Which I bought.
0:47:15And my link bracelet from my original Series 0 is still impeccable.
0:47:19No scratches because I got the DLC coating, which is amazing.
0:47:23So it was proof that they could do a lot of things with watches really, really good.
0:47:28The thing that wasn't very good was the computer inside.
0:47:31And I remember—so you spent $400 to $1,000.
0:47:34Well, you got what you paid for.
0:47:36You were an early adopter, you bought the first one.
0:47:39If you spent $15,000 on the gold one, you got ripped off.
0:47:43100%.
0:47:44Like, I would be—even if I had that much money, I would be pissed, I think, honestly.
0:47:49There'd be no way that I couldn't be.
0:47:51Right.
0:47:52And I know that there were a lot of people when it—when I said it's going to cost
0:47:55like $5,000 to $10,000 for gold because that's just what gold, fine gold watches cost.
0:48:01People are like, "You're nuts.
0:48:02It's going to be outdated."
0:48:03And I'm like, "It might be outdated."
0:48:05I didn't tell them to make a gold watch.
0:48:07I'm telling you what good gold watches cost.
0:48:10And then when the prices did come out and I was right, people wrote to me and they're
0:48:14like, "Hey, good call.
0:48:16I'll bet what they're going to do is when you buy an edition watch, when they come out
0:48:20with new ones, you'll be able to take it to the Apple store and turn your Series 0
0:48:23into a Series 2 and then two years later, you could turn it into a Series 3 and drop
0:48:28it off and three days later, pick it up and it'll have new guts."
0:48:31And I was like, "No, computers don't work like that."
0:48:35Right.
0:48:36Right.
0:48:37No, they don't.
0:48:39And companies have tried.
0:48:40Like every time they've tried to do those upgrade things, like Samsung tried with their
0:48:43TVs and whatnot, like they usually abandon it after a couple of years.
0:48:46It's just not a way that you can really unfortunately make modern electronics.
0:48:50Right.
0:48:51It just doesn't work.
0:48:52The tolerances are too small.
0:48:53So yeah, that's what I would just call it fundamentally dishonest.
0:48:57And everything they've done since to me has corrected it.
0:49:00Even the ones that they call edition, like the titanium one, which I bought a couple
0:49:05years ago for the Series 5 and which I love.
0:49:07The ceramic ones that they came out with, which I think were like, I forget how much
0:49:13they cost.
0:49:14They were like $1,000.
0:49:15Yeah.
0:49:16Maybe 1,500, something like that.
0:49:18Reasonable as an upper bound for...
0:49:21And the other thing too is, especially once they got to Series 3, that the technology
0:49:26of them was good enough that they last for years.
0:49:30You could use it for three, four, five years, which again does not compare to a mechanical
0:49:35watch.
0:49:36No, but it makes you feel...
0:49:37I mean, but it puts it in line with like a smartphone or an iPad or something else.
0:49:40You feel like you're still getting value out of it.
0:49:43I get a fitness credit that's now been expanded to some other things, but I get like a fitness
0:49:47credit every year through work.
0:49:49And I've used it to buy a new stainless steel Apple watch every year that I've been at Microsoft.
0:49:54And I haven't needed to actually upgrade, but I've just done it anyway and then given
0:49:58my old one to a friend or whatever.
0:50:02I'm probably not going to do that for the Series 6.
0:50:05I probably should have just kept the Series 5 to be honest, but I needed to...
0:50:09It's free money.
0:50:10I needed to use it.
0:50:11And this year I'm able to use the money for different things, so I'm more than likely
0:50:16doing that.
0:50:17But I feel like I could probably still be using...
0:50:20They were still, I think until recently, they might even still be selling the Series 3,
0:50:23right?
0:50:24Yeah, I think they are.
0:50:25Yeah, that's their low end price right now.
0:50:28Right?
0:50:29So that is to me, and they make that super affordable.
0:50:31So to me, that is actually, okay, you buy this and you're getting four years out of
0:50:37it or so.
0:50:38That's pretty good, especially if you're not spending...
0:50:42If you're spending $350 for it or something like that and you wear it every day and it's
0:50:46this thing that's more than just your watch, but it's this health device too that is really
0:50:52indispensable for a lot of people, I feel like the value point is there.
0:50:55Because Fitbits and things like that, which aren't that much less expensive when you get
0:50:59into the higher end, especially if you look at the starting price of the lowest end Apple
0:51:05watches, people have the same things, where after a few years they need to get another
0:51:09one.
0:51:10So I think that's completely fine.
0:51:12It's just...
0:51:13And if you are that person who's spending stuff on the Hermes band or wanting to get
0:51:19one of the ceramic or the titanium ones or whatever the case may be, you go into that
0:51:25knowing, okay, this is not a forever thing, but I'm paying a premium because I like this
0:51:30styling or I want this type of band.
0:51:32Fine.
0:51:33Yeah.
0:51:34Right now, just look, the Series 3 is the one that starts at $199.
0:51:37And I think you add 30 bucks to get the bigger size.
0:51:43And clearly it sticks out a little bit because the Series 4 is when they went to the slightly
0:51:47different form factor.
0:51:48And it's obvious what they're going to do come September.
0:51:51They'll come out with Series 7, the Series 3 goes away, and the Apple Watch SE becomes
0:51:58that low-end model.
0:51:59That's what SE means in Apple parlance.
0:52:01It means a low-end price based on two-year-old technology or 18-month-old technology, and
0:52:07it sticks around for two to three years at that low-end price.
0:52:13Like the phone that they call the iPhone SE right now, the iPhone SE 2, that's going to
0:52:18be here for years.
0:52:21Because the other SE was here for years.
0:52:23It was here for years, and I mean, yeah, and people are still sad that that form factor
0:52:28went away, actually.
0:52:29Yeah.
0:52:30So, yeah, no, I think that now actually they are in a good place pricing-wise.
0:52:34But originally, yeah, it was a failure.
0:52:37But kind of going back to the car, I mean, I guess this is—
0:52:41Well done.
0:52:42Well done.
0:52:43I guess this is sort of like my question, though, is like, you know, you could understand,
0:52:46like, the rumors were there around like watches, and you could see that there was a lot of
0:52:50tech happening in the wearable space, and it makes sense for Apple to be there.
0:52:54And I guess there is a ton of tech happening in the self-driving space, but I still have
0:52:59a hard time, especially if we're talking about a potentially six-figure plus, like, starting
0:53:05price.
0:53:06Like, okay, Tesla does—most of their cars, once you get all in, are going to be around
0:53:12that.
0:53:13The same thing is going to be true for, you know, Mercedes or BMW.
0:53:16But those aren't their only options.
0:53:17Like, even Tesla now, you know, they have an option.
0:53:20Obviously, once you spec it out, you're not spending under $50,000.
0:53:23But, you know, on paper, you can get in for half of what, if we're being very generous,
0:53:29it seems like would have been your price to get into the Apple car ecosystem.
0:53:35I just don't understand—I think this is my struggle, is like, not that I don't think
0:53:40Apple could make a fantastic user interface for a car, and that it wouldn't be an amazing
0:53:45experience.
0:53:47I just don't know why Apple as a company wants to be in the car business.
0:53:50Yeah, let me put it to you this way and see if you agree.
0:53:54Even the watch is primarily a computer.
0:54:01And you know, Apple put a lot of work—they've done—I mean, really, as a watch nerd outside
0:54:07Apple Watch, one of the most amazing things they've done is what they've done with band
0:54:11designs across the board, from the sport band that is sort of the default band to their
0:54:18link bracelet and the way that you can just adjust it and take links out with your fingernail
0:54:22instead of any kind of fancy tools.
0:54:24The leather stuff, they're really nice bands.
0:54:28Yeah, they are.
0:54:29They are.
0:54:30The only criticism I have is I got the light pink, I guess, what the fancy buckle thing
0:54:37was.
0:54:38And that didn't hold up super well.
0:54:41It got dirty.
0:54:42I mean, I was able to clean it, but it just was one of those things that was like, "Eh."
0:54:46It should just wear.
0:54:48But still, fundamentally, the basic idea of the Apple Watch is it's a tiny computer on
0:54:52your wrist.
0:54:54That's the main thing it is.
0:54:55And the watch parts of it, like buckling and telling the time, are all sort of secondary
0:55:02to the computer-type parts.
0:55:03Whereas a car, no matter how much of it is computerized—and Tesla has shown clearly
0:55:10led the way with putting a big, big computer display as the dashboard interface.
0:55:18100%.
0:55:19You know, so the dashboard console, the whole thing, you could certainly imagine how Apple
0:55:26would want to design that and would enjoy designing that.
0:55:31But the main part of the car is not the dashboard, right?
0:55:35Right.
0:55:36It's the actual driving of—it's the car car.
0:55:39Yeah.
0:55:40And that is the big difference to me with the car, with every other product, both existing
0:55:48and rumored that Apple's ever made.
0:55:51All the VR/AR stuff is, to me, exactly like the watch, where it's fundamentally a computer
0:55:58and secondarily something else.
0:56:01Even the—especially the one that supposedly is coming first, the $3,000 according to the
0:56:09information VR headset with two 8K displays, it's a computer.
0:56:14And so put aside where they're, "Oh my God, $3,000, blah, blah, blah."
0:56:18It's a computer, and that's exactly what Apple's always made.
0:56:22They used to be called Apple Computer.
0:56:24And even the supposedly, after that, AR glasses that you would wear all day that would project
0:56:32some sort of heads-up display in front of you, it's a computer device.
0:56:36And fashion second, where whatever the Apple glasses look like, Apple's design prowess
0:56:42and taste would certainly, you would think, help in that regard in the same way it did
0:56:46with the watch, where people like wearing the Apple watch and think it looks good on
0:56:51their wrist.
0:56:52Car is very different.
0:56:54I don't know.
0:56:56So one idea would be—the cynical idea, why would they do this, is, "Well, there's
0:57:02a lot of money to be made making cars, so we should make a car."
0:57:08The nonsensical answer would be that they have one or more ideas to redefine the car
0:57:15market and think that they're onto something that no one else is thinking about or no one
0:57:23else could do, they might think, and therefore they're going to do it.
0:57:27But I don't know what those ideas are.
0:57:30They're not in my imagination.
0:57:33Yeah.
0:57:34I mean, and I guess the hard thing I have to kind of square with it is, yeah, maybe
0:57:38they feel like they can do something.
0:57:39But if I look at what Apple's strengths are, and they have many, to be totally candid,
0:57:46transportation, navigation, not one of them, right?
0:57:49Like, AI in general, I don't actually think is one of their strengths.
0:57:54And I don't mean that with disrespect.
0:57:55It's just that the way that Apple cares about privacy and the things that they put forward
0:58:00work at a disadvantage to them, I think, with their systems compared to the models from
0:58:05the other big tech companies.
0:58:08I think I wrote about that recently with one of my continuing series of goofy instances
0:58:16with Siri giving nonsensical answers to things.
0:58:19I mean, the one I just posted the other day was, I said, "Hey, Dingus, remind me to pick
0:58:25up the dry cleaning Wednesday at three," which in fact was today.
0:58:32And Siri said a reminder for me at 3 a.m. to pick up the dry cleaning.
0:58:37And I posted what I said, which was, "Hey, Dingus, pick up the dry cleaning at three."
0:58:45And I wasn't trying to be obstinate, and I wasn't trying to stress test it.
0:58:51And, yes, most of the time when I speak to Siri, and I do speak to Siri a lot, it works.
0:58:59But every time it jumps out in a nonsensical way, it's the needle scratching on a record.
0:59:08And this one, it makes no sense.
0:59:10And I know, I think I wrote longer about it.
0:59:14I think it was Nilay Patel who had the thing about, "Hey, what time is it in London?"
0:59:20And it gave the time for London, Ontario.
0:59:24And my explanation of this was, look, the baseline is what would a human assistant do?
0:59:34And if you had a human assistant who you hired and you said, "Hey, what time...
0:59:40Can you find out what time it is right now in London?"
0:59:42And they gave you the time in London, Ontario.
0:59:47You honestly, and I don't mean this to exaggerate, you would immediately have to think, "I might
0:59:51have to fire this assistant because this person is too stupid to have the job."
0:59:57Yeah.
0:59:58No, and the same thing for setting a reminder for you to get your dry cleaning at 3 a.m.
1:00:03Right.
1:00:04Here's the funny part about that is there's a clip.
1:00:08Somebody sent me a clip, and they're like, "Do you remember Mitch Hedberg, the comedian?"
1:00:12Yeah.
1:00:13Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:00:14Unfortunately, he died a few years ago.
1:00:15Sad.
1:00:16Yeah, sad.
1:00:17And he was on Letterman.
1:00:19And I'm not going to do it justice because he's so great, but he said, "I was walking
1:00:22down the street one night, and there was a dry...
1:00:28I walked past the...
1:00:29And literally a dry cleaner, and it was 3 a.m. and they had a sign on the door and it
1:00:34said, 'Closed.'"
1:00:36And I'm like, "You don't need to tell me that at 3 a.m.
1:00:39I know."
1:00:40And it's like, holy cow.
1:00:43It wasn't just any business.
1:00:44It was a dry cleaner.
1:00:45The time was three.
1:00:48That's crazy.
1:00:51You would honestly think about a human being, "This person is mentally insufficient to do
1:00:57the job as my personal assistant.
1:01:00How can I trust this person if they're going to make mistakes like this?"
1:01:04Right.
1:01:05And again, it's not a joke because they're talking about making a car, right?
1:01:09This isn't a joke.
1:01:11I mean, yes, exactly.
1:01:14And even though Apple Maps has gotten better, it's not as good as Google Maps.
1:01:22It's not even close.
1:01:23Well, it's not as good as a taxi driver, right?
1:01:26No, it's not.
1:01:27I mean, the baseline is you get into a Lyft or a taxi and you say, "Drive me to 30th Street
1:01:35Train Station."
1:01:36You expect to get a reasonable route directly to...
1:01:40I use Apple Maps and I think it's pretty good.
1:01:45But is it...
1:01:46Yeah, I use it too.
1:01:47Although it did get me stuck on a mountain once, but that's a whole other thing.
1:01:50Yeah.
1:01:51Is it good enough?
1:01:52I don't know.
1:01:53Is it good enough to drive the car around?
1:01:55I don't know.
1:01:56Well, that's the thing.
1:01:57If I'm being completely candid, I mean, and I don't drive.
1:02:00So the idea of a self-driving car actually greatly appeals to me.
1:02:04And I would even be someone who would be willing to spend a premium on that if there was a
1:02:08truly self-driving car thing where I didn't have to be behind the wheel at all and do
1:02:11any of it.
1:02:12But I'm going to need to have trust in the system, that it's going to get me where I
1:02:16need to go, that it's going to understand things.
1:02:19And from a pure navigation standpoint, I don't have that in Apple Maps.
1:02:26And the sad thing is that I have no doubt that there are people and systems and engineers
1:02:32at Apple who could make a system that I could have full trust in.
1:02:36Just like how Siri is different on different devices.
1:02:39Like I find that it's actually quite good on Apple TV, but it's terrible in a lot of
1:02:43other places.
1:02:44It's highly kind of context dependent.
1:02:46But the problem is that it's always called the same thing.
1:02:49So if I'm in an Apple car that has Apple Maps in it with its Apple Drive system or whatever,
1:02:59I'm going to be pretty skeptical that I can trust it to get me from point A to point B
1:03:04without either taking me the wrong way, you know, that's going to waste me more time,
1:03:10or worst case scenario, get me stuck on a mountain.
1:03:15I'll take an aside here and say that I'm deeply skeptical about true self-driving cars,
1:03:21meaning that you could truly just get in the car, tell the car where to go, and fall asleep
1:03:26and not be completely cognizant as somebody being the driver cognizant, ready to go.
1:03:33And furthermore, I'm also very, very skeptical of Tesla style, current Tesla feature availability
1:03:41of you can mostly trust it.
1:03:44I actually think that's the worst, to be totally honest.
1:03:46Right.
1:03:47Because it gives people, like they feel like they can trust it and they don't take the
1:03:51precautions that they should.
1:03:54I'm terrified of getting into car accidents.
1:03:57I'm perhaps even slightly phobic about it.
1:04:00I do drive, but I find the current rate of the number of people who get into either deadly
1:04:09or very, very seriously injured car accidents on a daily basis terrifying.
1:04:14I typically walk everywhere in Philadelphia.
1:04:18Every single time I see someone who is obviously on their phone while they're driving a car,
1:04:22I'm enraged.
1:04:23I would like to have an entire second police force whose job is to do nothing but identify
1:04:28people who are on their phone while driving because I'm terrified by it.
1:04:33Honest to God, I would rather have people drinking and driving than texting and driving
1:04:38because at least when you're drinking and driving, you're looking at the road and you're
1:04:42thinking, "Oh, shit, I've had too much to drink."
1:04:45Honest to God, that's how bad.
1:04:46Right.
1:04:47I think you're more impaired.
1:04:48I don't think, I'm not trying to say you should drink and drive.
1:04:50I'm saying I think—
1:04:51No, no, no.
1:04:52I mean, well, studies have shown that you're right.
1:04:53I mean, studies have actually shown that maybe not more, but certainly as impaired, texting
1:04:58and driving has shown that.
1:05:00So I don't think you're wrong there.
1:05:02And I'm actually very critical of Tesla's model because it creates this false sense
1:05:07of trust that you don't have.
1:05:09You can't possibly keep your attention.
1:05:12No, no.
1:05:13And even worse, Tesla claims that they don't promote it, but they do.
1:05:18There's the wink and the nudge of all the things that you can do.
1:05:22And that I think is really dangerous because it's the same thing, like the reason that
1:05:25we have people who text and drive are because people felt like they can multitask and they
1:05:31can do those things.
1:05:32And it's become deadly.
1:05:33And millions and millions of people have died that way.
1:05:36And I worry—I'm with you, like, look, long-term, I think that we might get to a
1:05:42point where we get up to really self-driving cars.
1:05:44I don't know if we'll see it in our lifetimes or not, but I feel like it is a ways off.
1:05:49But I do have, like, actually, I think that the assisted but we're-so-good-you-can-trust-it-to-be-unassisted
1:05:58model is the most dangerous thing.
1:06:00Like, I much more prefer the models of the self-driving technology that require hands
1:06:06to be on the wheel and that require eyes to be focused on the road and that sort of thing
1:06:13for the systems to work than what Tesla does.
1:06:17I really do agree with that.
1:06:19One time, a couple years ago, I got invited to—I never ended up writing about it, or
1:06:24at least not much.
1:06:25I didn't write the feature that I probably should have.
1:06:27But I got invited to Mercedes—not a headquarters, but they're like—I forget if it was in
1:06:35San Jose.
1:06:36Where's Yahoo's headquarters?
1:06:37Sunnyvale.
1:06:38Sunnyvale.
1:06:39I think that's where Mercedes has a big self-driving car installation in Silicon Valley.
1:06:45And I got invited there in the media to see their self-driving stuff.
1:06:49And I took a ride in a self-driving Mercedes vehicle.
1:06:54I was paired up with Mark Bergen, who's at Recode.
1:06:59And so Mark and I were in the backseat of a Mercedes.
1:07:02There was a press person in the passenger seat, and then there was one of their engineers
1:07:06behind the wheel.
1:07:07And it was very impressive.
1:07:09I mean, and the car really did do pretty much all the driving.
1:07:14And we went from the parking lot at their office to out on the highway for a bit and
1:07:19came back.
1:07:20And the car did just about everything.
1:07:22It got confused on the on-ramp to the highway.
1:07:26It had to go a little bit uphill, and it was right into the sun.
1:07:29And it just sort of froze up.
1:07:32And the car braked, like, tended to brake everywhere like a student driver, meaning
1:07:37that your head would go forward, you know, like, it got stopped short.
1:07:42But the car really did do the driving, and it was impressive.
1:07:45But it's just, to not have somebody behind the wheel, forget about it.
1:07:50And I think that the industry will quickly get to the point where, in theory, you could
1:07:57have a closed circuit, like your own little city.
1:08:01And if you banned all human drivers and only allowed cars that were autonomous and talked
1:08:08to each other, that would work.
1:08:10I think we'll get there.
1:08:11I agree.
1:08:12They could do that today.
1:08:13The problem is mixing the autonomous cars with the human drivers.
1:08:17No, I agree with you.
1:08:18I agree with you.
1:08:19It's funny.
1:08:20It was about four years ago now, but I actually made a very similar argument when I was at
1:08:23the New York Auto Show on a panel about self-driving cars.
1:08:27And I had to, you know, in front of all these corners, I was like, "I don't have a driver's
1:08:31license, but let me tell you my thoughts."
1:08:33And that was kind of exactly my thought, is that it's got to be the mixed thing.
1:08:38It's going to be really hard to make it truly autonomous and make it work, whereas if you
1:08:43mandated, you know, it can only be self-driving cars.
1:08:48And then you have, you know, like IoT run, you know, 5G, you know, whatever, running
1:08:53like traffic lights and sending other data signals and whatnot to control traffic flow.
1:08:59I think that could work pretty well.
1:09:02But the United States is not going to be the best place for that for lots of reasons, but
1:09:08it's possible we might see it in parts of Asia.
1:09:10I don't know.
1:09:11So part of that United States thing, we've learned this lesson over the last year.
1:09:15Americans tend to be very stubborn.
1:09:20I was going to say, yeah.
1:09:21I mean, yeah, look, our independence is our greatest feature and our greatest, like, weakness,
1:09:26to be totally honest, is our need for autonomy in that way.
1:09:30So part of the Mercedes thing, it was time well spent, and I was very interested, and
1:09:36it was a good presentation.
1:09:37But my question during one of the briefings was, okay, let's say we get to fully, you
1:09:44know, stage four.
1:09:45I forget what was, there's like a standard one, two, three, four, and maybe five, but
1:09:50four or five is like fully autonomous.
1:09:52It's Kit, right?
1:09:53It's Kit from Knight Rider.
1:09:54And you just say, "Kit, take me to the airport."
1:09:59And you could sit in the backseat and Kit will drive you to the airport.
1:10:05Even at the like stage below that, where it's like the driver can kind of like, you have
1:10:10to have a driver, but you can kind of like not pay attention.
1:10:14And it'll like beep at you if you need to take over and you have a couple seconds.
1:10:18Even at that stage, my question was, okay, you're in a car and you're behind the wheel,
1:10:25but the car takes over and you're going somewhere.
1:10:27Will you be allowed to exceed the speed limit?
1:10:31And it was, I knew I had a good question because they paused and they said, "No."
1:10:43That was the whole full answer.
1:10:46And you know, that is honestly, that alone is not going to fly in the United States.
1:10:52The idea that you're on a road with a 65 mile an hour speed limit and your car will not
1:10:56go 66.
1:10:57Right.
1:10:58Well, and more to the point, there are places where even if the limit is 65, the flow of
1:11:03traffic is 75.
1:11:04Right.
1:11:05And if you're going 65, it could actually be dangerous.
1:11:08Like if you're trying to get off the interstate or something, like it could actually be a
1:11:12problem.
1:11:13I joke about driving fast on this podcast many times over the years.
1:11:17And when I do drive, I do like to drive fast on the highway.
1:11:22But that is true.
1:11:23And no joke about it, going the speed limit on a lot of highway with good, flowing traffic,
1:11:31it's dangerous.
1:11:32It is dangerous to go 65 on a lot of roads or 55 or whatever the speed limit is.
1:11:37It is.
1:11:39But the cars won't end for logical reasons.
1:11:41And presumably, 50, 60 years from now, if we're still driving cars at all, they'll all
1:11:49be autonomous and they'll be able to go 120 miles an hour because it'll be fantastic.
1:11:54If you ever see little animations of what cars could do, if every car was autonomous,
1:11:59the way you'd be able to zip through intersections.
1:12:02Amazing.
1:12:03Right.
1:12:04Yeah, no, it'd be incredible.
1:12:05Yeah.
1:12:06Well, I mean, I think that's kind of my secondary thing too, aside from maybe some of the logistical
1:12:09things or whatnot, is like, okay, I maybe get the appeal.
1:12:13I get the appeal for a lot of companies, not Apple investing in self-driving tech and maybe
1:12:18investing in the tech where you want to be the brains of what the self-driving cars are
1:12:24for other people if you're a very strong infrastructure play, right?
1:12:27Like where your whole thing is you want people using your stuff.
1:12:30That's typically not Apple's thing, though.
1:12:31They like to make their own things.
1:12:33They don't really like to power other people's stuff.
1:12:37As great as the M1 is and as amazing things that they've done with that, I don't really
1:12:41... And Intel is fucked for a lot of reasons, but I don't feel like Apple can take on Intel
1:12:47in volume, nor would they want to, right?
1:12:51So I look at the car and I think, okay, so why do this?
1:12:55This is going to be, we know, a high-price project.
1:13:01It requires engineering resources and expertise that not just say Apple couldn't hire for
1:13:06that, but certainly that is not part of their instinctive DNA.
1:13:11And then I look kind of long-term like, okay, if you're investing in this, it just seems
1:13:15to me, and I know I must be missing something, but I feel like would it not be better to
1:13:20be looking at high-speed rail or bullet trains or other types of transportation that way
1:13:27rather than cars?
1:13:29Why cars, which seem to be electric, EV aside, globally, it's going to be something that
1:13:38all predictions seem to indicate is going to be on the decline.
1:13:42I don't know.
1:13:43You know, it is, and again, I can see why they don't get into trains because trains
1:13:49require the government, right?
1:13:50You cannot, you can't build the train tracks.
1:13:52Although Elon Musk has tried to propose building a tunnel between Los Angeles and San Francisco.
1:14:00You have the hyperloop.
1:14:01Right, the hyperloop.
1:14:02Oh, I mean, I love it.
1:14:03I would too.
1:14:04I laugh.
1:14:05Please, I hope he does it.
1:14:08Seriously, put me in the tube.
1:14:09I would love that.
1:14:10That'd be amazing.
1:14:11I know he's building, I know the rocket ships work.
1:14:14I mean, so I'm not laughing that it can't be done.
1:14:17Oh, no, I know.
1:14:18I know, yeah.
1:14:19But at least a car is something somebody, they could just sell and you meet the regulatory
1:14:25requirements and then people can just buy it and they can just drive on the road.
1:14:28But whatever it is, I guarantee you this.
1:14:30I mean, however wrong my pessimistic take on true autonomy is, if the rumors are true
1:14:36that they're looking at starting to build these three, four years from now or even less,
1:14:41but let's say three, four years from now, there's no way they're going to be autonomous.
1:14:44I mean, fully autonomous.
1:14:45No, there's not.
1:14:46Yeah, no, from a regulatory aside, yeah, they're not.
1:14:49So whatever their reason for wanting to do it, that's not it.
1:14:52Like the, you know, what is the, oh, we've got this thing and we're going to redefine
1:14:57the industry.
1:14:58It's not autonomy, not full autonomy.
1:15:01It says me now, you know, but I don't think so.
1:15:05I don't think it's possible.
1:15:07And even if it were, it wouldn't be legal.
1:15:09Right.
1:15:10So I don't know.
1:15:12It's a very good question and I don't quite get it.
1:15:16But Volkswagen, they're not afraid.
1:15:18No, I mean, I do agree with you though, the way that they framed it.
1:15:21Like, I think that it probably would have been better to be like, we do the typical
1:15:25bullshit tech, you know, exact thing.
1:15:27We welcome our competition into the new space when really you're like, holy shit, we're
1:15:31watching our back.
1:15:32We don't welcome them, get out of here.
1:15:34But I also don't feel like this is a Ed Colligan thing where, you know, he says, you know,
1:15:40PC guys aren't just going to waltz in here.
1:15:42I do feel like there are a lot of things that are much more difficult about cars and a lot
1:15:47of things that go counter frankly to Apple's strengths, whereas the phone really spoke
1:15:53to all of their strengths even before they entered that space, you know.
1:15:59I would never bet against Apple to be very clear on that.
1:16:01I would never bet against them.
1:16:02It's just one of those things where I'm kind of like, why this versus some of the other
1:16:09areas you could go into.
1:16:10That's just always my question.
1:16:11I guess, you know, if we're just going to spitball, wildly spitball, I mean, if they
1:16:15have some kind of breakthrough that's in totally secret on batteries and electric drive trains,
1:16:23right?
1:16:24Like, okay.
1:16:25Okay.
1:16:26Yeah.
1:16:27Yeah.
1:16:28I could see that.
1:16:30Something like that.
1:16:31Yeah.
1:16:33I mean, I know right now even like Teslas are super, super heavy because the batteries
1:16:37are so big and they handle weird.
1:16:39They're very funny.
1:16:40You know, I've never driven one, but I know that they accelerate like bad out of hell.
1:16:44They do.
1:16:45They accelerate amazingly and then they'd make no noise, which is kind of incredible.
1:16:50Last thing before we move on to another thing if you want to, but maybe I actually think
1:16:54that you might be right on the batteries and maybe this would be a way for them to test
1:16:57their batteries because if they could nail battery tech in something like a car, think
1:17:02about how that could trickle down into all their other devices.
1:17:04Right.
1:17:05And if it's something that's easier to make big first.
1:17:08Yes, exactly.
1:17:09Before it gets shrunk to your pocket, right?
1:17:12Yes.
1:17:13So maybe you start with that and then, you know, you kind of do, you know, like a wafer
1:17:17model sort of thing.
1:17:18It's like, okay, we nail this and then we can miniaturize it and put it in everything
1:17:22else.
1:17:23Here's the other question.
1:17:24I mean, think about this, this is, I feel like people aren't speculating on it enough,
1:17:29especially now that people are starting to say, hey, it's like two, three years out,
1:17:34right?
1:17:35Is where do they sell the cars?
1:17:37Right.
1:17:38Yeah, that's a good point.
1:17:40I have never seen an Apple store that is ready to sell cars.
1:17:45I mean, some of the flagships, I'm trying to think, I was only in the new San Francisco
1:17:51flagship once, the one that took over the old Levi's building.
1:17:57That one's pretty big, you know, Fifth Avenue in New York.
1:17:59No way, right?
1:18:00Fifth Avenue in New York.
1:18:01No, there's no way.
1:18:02You have to go downstairs.
1:18:03Exactly, you'd have to go downstairs to show off the car.
1:18:06I mean, the thing is, is that you could do what Tesla does where, you know, you could
1:18:09have like the reservations and you could have that thing and you could have delivery.
1:18:12But yeah, where do people go to see it?
1:18:14Where do people go to potentially take a test drive?
1:18:17And Tesla struggled with that too, although they had to walk back, like they originally
1:18:20were going to close a bunch of their dealerships, or they don't call them dealerships because
1:18:24there's a legal thing around that, but they're stores, but then they kept some of them open.
1:18:29There are a number of them.
1:18:30I'm not sure what their state of opening is, given the pandemic, but in the Seattle
1:18:35area, there are like a lot of Tesla stores.
1:18:40I think Bellevue, which is a Seattle suburb, is second only to Palo Alto in terms of numbers
1:18:45of Teslas sold.
1:18:47So there are a number of places where people can go get them.
1:18:52But even that, like I will say Tesla definitely took from Apple and it's much more of an
1:18:56Apple experience where you go in and you place your order and you see a car, but it's not
1:19:00like you're going to drive off the lot with it.
1:19:02And it's, you know, like that's not the experience.
1:19:06It's not a car dealer.
1:19:07It's not a car dealer.
1:19:08Right.
1:19:09Yeah.
1:19:10I've been to a Tesla in a mall, the King of Prussian mall here in Philadelphia or the
1:19:14greater Philadelphia area.
1:19:15I think they closed though before COVID even, but they used to have a Tesla in the mall
1:19:20and you know, they had like one car in there and it was mainly like a place where you could
1:19:26just go and look at one and talk to somebody and then I guess make an appointment to get
1:19:31a real, you know, test drive a real one.
1:19:33But it's very strange.
1:19:34It would be very strange for Apple.
1:19:36I mean, and on a personal level, me, John Gruber, if they come out with a car, do I
1:19:43get a review unit?
1:19:45Like a car would be a crazy thing to get a review unit for.
1:19:49No, you would get a loan.
1:19:51You would, they would do it the same way that they do review units for other things.
1:19:54They would like let you, you would sign out an agreement and you would get it for a week
1:19:57or 10 days or whatever.
1:20:00How would I charge it?
1:20:02Like don't you need, won't you need like some kind of expensive thing in your garage?
1:20:07I mean, what happens if I don't have a garage?
1:20:09I happen to have a garage, but do I have room for an extra car?
1:20:14I'm trying to think.
1:20:15So, because I used to work at a Gizmodo Media Group and with the Jalopnik guys who would
1:20:20do a lot of car reviews and those are, you know, most of those guys live in Brooklyn
1:20:23where they don't have garages or access to any of that stuff and they would review EVs,
1:20:28although some of those people would live other places.
1:20:30And yeah, I mean, I think that you would find places where you could either adapt a way
1:20:34to charge or there'd be a charging station and they might give you like a limited loan.
1:20:38But yeah, I mean, it was, it was not uncommon where, you know, I had friends who live in
1:20:42apartments who would be, you know, test driving expensive automobiles in New York City.
1:20:48So it can be done.
1:20:49It just is obviously requires a lot more logistics than, you know, shipping somebody a phone
1:20:55or having a product briefing with a watch.
1:20:57Yeah, I don't think FedEx drops them off.
1:21:00No, no.
1:21:01And the thing too is that you have a much more limited number of like review devices,
1:21:06right?
1:21:07Like you can give the whole press corps one is one of those things where you have like
1:21:11a couple or maybe like two, like one kind of for the coast where people are going to
1:21:15take turns.
1:21:16So it would be a lot more limited, I assume.
1:21:19But yeah, and that even says, does Apple want the press reviews or do they want to do what
1:21:27they've been doing recently, which is do they want to see the car YouTubers?
1:21:31Like I could see them doing that, right?
1:21:34Like it just bypassing the traditional automotive press altogether.
1:21:38I don't know.
1:21:39Right.
1:21:40And it's like, I know that there is an automotive press and I know that the automotive press
1:21:44reviews cars without buying them.
1:21:46You know, they, they get the equivalent of, you know, loaners.
1:21:50What I'm wondering is, will Apple go to the usual Apple reviewers?
1:21:54Like is it me and the Verge and Matthew Panzareno and Joanna Stern or do they go to the car
1:22:01people?
1:22:02Like it just seems...
1:22:03It seems crazy though, you know, and I guess, I guess it comes down to what is the thing
1:22:07that they think is special about the car.
1:22:09Yeah.
1:22:10And it probably, I mean, like they would probably go to the Verge.
1:22:13The Verge has a transportation editor.
1:22:14Right.
1:22:15It, you know, Neelay would probably want to review it himself, but you know, I mean, they
1:22:19would probably go there.
1:22:20The Wall Street Journal would get one, whether you know, Joanna or their car reviewer would
1:22:24be up to them.
1:22:25You and Panzareno, I guess it depends on if they see you as car enthusiasts and influencers
1:22:31or not, right?
1:22:32Like...
1:22:33It's just a crazy thing for me to review.
1:22:35I agree.
1:22:36Okay.
1:22:37But like, but for instance, Marquez, Marquez Brownlee would get one.
1:22:39Oh, definitely.
1:22:40Yeah.
1:22:41Like, like he would be number one.
1:22:42And I actually think that that would probably be, you'd see more of that type of things.
1:22:45I think that if it were me, if I were Apple and I were trying to, you know, seed review
1:22:50units for this mythical Apple car, I would be going after the big tech YouTubers who
1:22:56we all know have Teslas and get them on board.
1:23:01Honestly.
1:23:02I don't know.
1:23:03It's just a fascinating personal aspect to it.
1:23:06And it's like, and how do I send it back?
1:23:08How do I get it?
1:23:09How do you send it back?
1:23:10How do you give it back to them?
1:23:11No, totally.
1:23:12I mean, yeah.
1:23:13Yeah.
1:23:14I mean, I say this as somebody who I more than one occasion actually had, you know,
1:23:18companies want me to do potentially car reviews.
1:23:21And I'm like, I don't have a license.
1:23:23I can connect with someone else, you know?
1:23:24Like, oh, come on.
1:23:25But you can.
1:23:26I'm like, nope.
1:23:27I don't want to, even if I did, would genuinely have no interest because like you, I have,
1:23:33I live in fear of like getting in a car accident.
1:23:35And to me, the only thing that would be more nightmare inducing than getting in a normal
1:23:39car accident would be getting in a car accident with a hundred thousand dollar review car
1:23:43for Apple.
1:23:44Like that would genuinely be like, that would keep me up at night, like 100%.
1:23:48Like that would be enough of a panic inducement.
1:23:50I wouldn't even be able to enjoy it because I'd be so freaked out about like, what happens
1:23:54if I wrecked this car?
1:23:55Like, yeah.
1:23:56I don't know.
1:24:00My guess is the way they would do it is that they would be a limited number of reviews
1:24:04just for, you know, for the obvious reason.
1:24:07And that they would deliver them, you know, like ding dong, they'd show up at the, you
1:24:13know, where, you know, what's your address?
1:24:15As somebody would show up, the car is there and, you know, with, with a colleague in another
1:24:22car to take the person who brought it home.
1:24:24And then like, you know, two weeks later we're going to come and we'll pick it up.
1:24:28Yeah.
1:24:29Yeah.
1:24:30That's, I guess was what they would do.
1:24:32I don't know.
1:24:33Yeah, I think that's what they would do.
1:24:34And they would probably, you know, um, prioritize people who either live places that have charging
1:24:40stations like in my apartment building.
1:24:42Um, we have a couple of EV, um, uh, chargers, um, that, that people can use or whatever.
1:24:48So they would prioritize like people who either live near one that they can go to, to top
1:24:52up or have their own garage where they can retrofit, you know, or have an adapter or
1:24:56whatever to use their, their main, you know, like power outlet to charge the, to charge
1:25:01the thing.
1:25:02And, you know, and typically it doesn't really make a big difference that I'm in Philadelphia,
1:25:08which isn't really, you know, a hub for Apple, but I'm close to New York.
1:25:13But again, shipping anything else Apple has ever made is not that big a deal because it
1:25:19can always just come FedEx.
1:25:21Right.
1:25:22Like the car, like this is going to have to be on a flatbed.
1:25:25Like this is either going to have to be driven or this is going to have to be on a flatbed
1:25:28that's going to be delivered to you.
1:25:29Yeah.
1:25:30Presumably they would have a couple sent to New York, however they send cars.
1:25:34And then I would guess somebody from New York, somebody from Apple would drive it from New
1:25:37York to Philadelphia and drop it off at my house.
1:25:40But I, I don't know.
1:25:41I mean, that's what I would assume either that or they would have some sort of place
1:25:44where you would go to pick it up.
1:25:45Right.
1:25:46But like what would they do if I lived in a what's like Nebraska?
1:25:50I probably wouldn't get one.
1:25:51I guess.
1:25:52Like you would need to be somebody who'd be super high on their list for you to get one.
1:25:56Right.
1:25:57Or else I'd have to agree to like spend a week in California and get a hotel and you
1:26:00know, drive around the car for a week.
1:26:01There you go.
1:26:02That would be it.
1:26:03Yeah.
1:26:04I mean, it, I'm trying to think like the, the car press is kind of distributed, but
1:26:06you do have a lot of people in Detroit.
1:26:07You do have people in New York, obviously people in California.
1:26:11And and they, they get their cars there.
1:26:14But I think for people who would be in other places who would want it, yeah, you need to
1:26:18either make your own arrangements or be somebody who would be deemed so important to review
1:26:25this that they would be willing to, you know, go through the extra stuff.
1:26:30It really just, it brings to mind, I mean, I've, I've thought about this.
1:26:33It just brings to mind what a preposterous thing to own a car is.
1:26:39Like we just, in America, we just have this car culture and we just.
1:26:42I mean, this is, this is my point.
1:26:43Thank you.
1:26:44I live with someone who loves cars and I don't get it.
1:26:48And so I think that this underscores my whole like question.
1:26:51It's like, why are you wanting to get into this space?
1:26:56Because it is a preposterous notion that you're spending as much as you know, you could on
1:27:02a house for a depreciating asset.
1:27:04Well, and it's, again, it's not like watches where you buy a $10,000 Rolex and you could
1:27:09sell it for 20,000 10 years from now.
1:27:11You know, you're, you know, as they say, it depreciates the moment you drive it off the
1:27:15lot.
1:27:16Exactly.
1:27:17It's like, it's not going to use whatever its value is.
1:27:18And that is the other thing.
1:27:19I mean, let's go with this because I mentioned my son before.
1:27:23So my son's 17 years old.
1:27:25The driver, driving age in Pennsylvania is 16.
1:27:28And when my wife and I turned 16 and we lived in the suburbs, we, I mean, we had already
1:27:34had our permits because you could get your permit.
1:27:37I don't know.
1:27:38It was like three months before you turn 16, you can get your driver's permit.
1:27:41And it's like three months to the day because the car meant freedom when you live in the
1:27:47suburbs.
1:27:48Yeah.
1:27:49Yeah.
1:27:50But for your son, we talked about this last show.
1:27:51Like he doesn't care, right?
1:27:52Right.
1:27:53Yeah.
1:27:54Yeah.
1:27:55So we did bring it up.
1:27:56Yeah.
1:27:57He's 17 and does not, the last, it's homework he doesn't want.
1:27:59What does he want to study to take a driver's test?
1:28:02He doesn't want to drive anywhere.
1:28:03He lives in the city.
1:28:05He walks most places he goes.
1:28:06And once this COVID thing blows over, he'll take, go back to, you know, we, he still hasn't
1:28:12taken like an Uber by himself, but you know, 17, 18, he will probably by the time this
1:28:17thing blows over, you know, none of his friends drive.
1:28:20They don't want to drive.
1:28:21They don't need to drive.
1:28:22And an Uber and a Lyft is better.
1:28:23You don't have to park.
1:28:24Well, you don't have to park, which parking, depending where you live, it can be extremely
1:28:27expensive.
1:28:28I imagine it's pricey in parts of Philadelphia and hard to find and, and, you know, takes
1:28:33time.
1:28:34And, and if you have an expensive car then becomes yet another like thing that you are
1:28:38afraid about because you've got your pricey car out there in the city, right?
1:28:42Like cars are great in the suburbs, in the cities.
1:28:45And I'm a city person, so yeah.
1:28:48Again, like this kind of goes to my question.
1:28:50Like, I think about all these things and like, I'm like, okay, this, a lot of the car companies
1:28:55are trying to turn themselves into tech companies, which makes sense because that's where they
1:28:59feel like they can continue to prosper and sell.
1:29:01But it's been a trend for the last decade that, you know, kids are getting their driver's
1:29:06license later and later and are, fewer people are buying cars.
1:29:09Like that's been a problem for the car industry.
1:29:12Like Ford has faced that and, and the other big manufacturers have too.
1:29:17And again, I would never bet against Apple because I feel like Apple is unique in the
1:29:22vacant inner markets that seem to not make sense and can make things work really well.
1:29:29It's just like, this just seems like, okay, but all the car companies want to be you.
1:29:35Why do you want to be a car company?
1:29:38And I wonder a little bit.
1:29:40I know lots of people at Apple live in San Francisco, literally in the city and they
1:29:46take, you know, like the buses down to Cupertino.
1:29:50And I know that's a big deal in that they, you know, in a way that would have made no
1:29:54sense 20 years ago, but it makes tons of sense now with ubiquitous cellular networking, you
1:29:59can actually, you know, start your workday and do be productive.
1:30:03And people go there and park and spend all day at work and then drive home if they don't,
1:30:09if they don't live in the city and take the bus and they live, you know, somewhere in
1:30:12between.
1:30:13But I can't help but think if there's a little bit of a bias towards car culture there because
1:30:17Silicon Valley is a place where you drive to go places.
1:30:21Yeah, you do.
1:30:22Yeah, that's true.
1:30:23And if does it bias them in a way that I think in ways, lots of little ways, Apple's products
1:30:30are sort of biased towards California weather.
1:30:33Right?
1:30:34Yeah.
1:30:35Like, why doesn't the iPhone show you the temperature on the lock screen?
1:30:40Right.
1:30:41Because it's 71 and sunny.
1:30:42What else?
1:30:43Right?
1:30:44Right.
1:30:45Yeah, no, that's, that's a good, that's a really good point.
1:30:49Yeah, no, that makes sense.
1:30:51I mean, it does also and maybe the other thing that could influence them is that if all of
1:30:54your competitors in the area are interested in this thing, then I'm not saying that like
1:31:00you're, you have to be follow on, but it's hard to, it would be hard for that not to
1:31:05be influential in some way, right?
1:31:07Like, the same way that, you know, everybody's making a microcomputer, you want to get into
1:31:12that business.
1:31:13Everybody's making a phone, you want to get into that business.
1:31:16If everybody around you is investing in all the hiring talent is so competitive around
1:31:21automotive and about self-driving around AI and all that stuff, maybe that plays a role.
1:31:26I don't know.
1:31:27Yeah.
1:31:28Well, let me take a break and we'll thank our next sponsor.
1:31:30It's our friends at Linode who host Daring Fireball so well.
1:31:33Very, very happy with them as a customer, paying customer.
1:31:37Whether you're working on a personal project or managing enterprise infrastructure, you
1:31:40deserve simple, affordable, and accessible cloud computing solutions that allow you to
1:31:44take your project to the next level.
1:31:46Simplify your cloud infrastructure with Linode's Linux virtual machines to develop, deploy,
1:31:52and scale your modern applications faster and easier.
1:31:55Get started on Linode today with $100 in free credit for listeners of the talk show.
1:32:02$100 bucks.
1:32:03You can find all the details at linode.com/thetalkshow.
1:32:09Linode.com/thetalkshow.
1:32:11Linode has 11 global data centers, 24/7, 365 human support with no tiers or handoffs.
1:32:19You want tech support, you get a real human who knows what they're talking about and can
1:32:24help you regardless of your plan size.
1:32:27In addition to shared and dedicated compute instances, you can use your $100 bucks in
1:32:32credit on S3-compatible object storage, their managed Kubernetes, and more.
1:32:39So once again, to get started, go to linode.com/thetalkshow and click on the "Create Free Account" button
1:32:46to get started.
1:32:47My thanks to Linode for sponsoring the show and for hosting Daring Fireball.
1:32:54Let's talk about Clubhouse before we run out of time.
1:32:59What are your thoughts on Clubhouse?
1:33:00I feel like Clubhouse right now is like, as we speak, February 2021, it's still in private.
1:33:09I wouldn't call it beta.
1:33:10I mean, it's on the App Store.
1:33:12It's invite only.
1:33:14But they seem to be accelerating the invitations to the point now where February 2021 sort
1:33:20of is the month where Clubhouse went big.
1:33:22Yeah, I would agree with that.
1:33:24I mean, I would say maybe January.
1:33:26No, yeah, I'm trying to think, when was Alon on?
1:33:30When did he do the Game Stonk thing?
1:33:32That was its Oprah joins Twitter moment.
1:33:35Yeah, 2021 to date, January to February.
1:33:38And I'm sure, in hindsight, there'll be even more people in March and more people in April,
1:33:42but it's getting big.
1:33:44A, can you describe what Clubhouse is?
1:33:48And B, tell me your thoughts about it.
1:33:50Okay.
1:33:51So I'll find something that I sent, let me find my tweet that I sent about it because
1:33:55Steven Sinofsky was annoyed with me, but I stand by it.
1:33:59Okay.
1:34:01This was what someone asked me, like two weeks ago.
1:34:03It says, "What does one do with Clubhouse?"
1:34:05And then I wrote, "Waste time not working by listening to other people not working,
1:34:10talking about stuff they claim to be experts in but really aren't, while hoping for celebrities
1:34:14to show up."
1:34:15That's pretty, that's pretty tart, but I don't disagree with it.
1:34:22And I say this as someone who, I've spent a lot of time on Clubhouse.
1:34:25I've hosted shows on Clubhouse when that was still a beta feature.
1:34:29I think I joined in April.
1:34:31I'm not above this, like at all.
1:34:33I'm just saying like when I use it, it is usually because it's either the end of the
1:34:37day and there I see one of the many notifications come in that, you know, somebody you're on
1:34:43and something interesting is going on, or I'm like, you know, kind of trying to avoid
1:34:48doing actual work and so I tune in in the afternoon and then listen to other people,
1:34:54you know, who are often doing the same thing.
1:34:56And then there is that bit of like, "Oh, and maybe someone famous will, you know, pop
1:35:01in."
1:35:02I don't know.
1:35:03I'm being totally honest.
1:35:04Like for me, that is kind of the appeal.
1:35:06That's not to say that I don't think there, I think that you can have some real substantive
1:35:10and interesting conversations and there are some really interesting ways it can be used
1:35:14and the way that its interest graph is both connected but disconnected from Twitter I
1:35:19think is interesting.
1:35:22I was in a room last week and someone's 10-year-old was briefly in the room before that was deemed,
1:35:29I guess, not okay and we were asking the youth some questions about their use of technology
1:35:36and, you know, they kind of described it.
1:35:38They were like, "Oh, it's Discord for adults."
1:35:41And that's actually not a bad description to be totally honest.
1:35:45Like it's, you know, kind of Discord's audio groups but, you know, audio channels for adults.
1:35:51That's not a completely terrible analogy.
1:35:57I'm trying to still wrap my head around it.
1:35:59I think they're on, I do think they're on to something.
1:36:02Oh, totally.
1:36:03And I also think, and I haven't quite had this feeling about something since Instagram
1:36:10in 2010.
1:36:12So I was not on the Instagram beta.
1:36:14MG Siegler was and he tweeted enough pictures from it.
1:36:19I definitely kind of was like, "Okay, square pictures, filters."
1:36:25And then I was just saying on my other podcast Dithering with Ben Thompson, I think the episode
1:36:30that aired this morning that I remember where I was when I realized Instagram was out of
1:36:35beta and I could sign up.
1:36:36I was with my family down in Disney World and I was on a bus going from, I think I even
1:36:43remember which park we were going to.
1:36:44We're going from our hotel to the Disney Studios park on the little Disney transportation bus.
1:36:51I was like, "Oh, it's out of beta.
1:36:53Quick, get Gruber.
1:36:54Oh, it's still available.
1:36:55Got it."
1:36:57Start clicking around.
1:36:58And within five minutes, because all of a sudden we're at Disney and it's time to have
1:37:02fun and go on rides and stuff, I was like, "Oh, I get this.
1:37:06This is great."
1:37:09And now that is the original Instagram where it was just you post pictures and you see
1:37:13pictures from the people you follow and you can comment on the pictures and you can apply
1:37:20these filters that really, at the time, was a great feature because cell phone cameras
1:37:26were still so crappy.
1:37:28The filters-
1:37:29It really added, it was perfect.
1:37:31In Hipstagram, what was it?
1:37:32Hipstagram?
1:37:33Or no, Hipstamatic.
1:37:34Hipstamatic.
1:37:35It was awesome.
1:37:36So it fit with that whole aesthetic that was happening at the time, but it made it easy
1:37:40to apply.
1:37:41They didn't take as long as some of the other filter apps did and it really made your photos
1:37:45look better and added.
1:37:46I remember when they added the tilt shift feature and it was amazing.
1:37:50Oh, yeah.
1:37:51The tilt shift feature was this massive deal because I was like, "Oh my God, I can take
1:37:55Mr. Rogers' pictures," right?
1:37:56Like, it's how I felt.
1:37:58At the time, Hipstamatic took so long.
1:38:00And I still don't know.
1:38:02I've never talked to anybody who could explain it.
1:38:04I don't know if they did it on purpose to fake, but Hipstamatic took so long to apply
1:38:10filters.
1:38:11I remember talking to somebody at Apple about it and they're like, "Yeah, it makes no sense
1:38:13that even if they're using a bad algorithm, it shouldn't take that long."
1:38:17And it was like, "Yeah, it's crazy."
1:38:18It was frustrating.
1:38:19And Instagram let you like, "Oh, this filter?
1:38:22Nope.
1:38:23This filter?
1:38:24No."
1:38:25Instantly.
1:38:26And then you'd pick one that made your picture look better and then you'd post it.
1:38:27And I was like, "I got it."
1:38:29I was like, "Oh, this is going to be huge."
1:38:32Just a snap judgment.
1:38:33100%.
1:38:34I feel that way about Clubhouse with just a little less certainty because the thing
1:38:39about Instagram was I knew I wanted to use it.
1:38:42Whereas with Clubhouse, I'm like, "I get this.
1:38:45I can see why people really like it.
1:38:47I don't think this is for me."
1:38:49Yeah.
1:38:50No, I kind of agree with you.
1:38:51And I'm somebody who like, I go back and forth about my feeling on it.
1:38:57Do I think that its current valuation is kind of insane?
1:39:00Yes.
1:39:01Do I think the concept has massive legs?
1:39:03Absolutely.
1:39:04I think the other difference is that Instagram came out, there were a couple of other kind
1:39:11of competitors.
1:39:12I remember there was like PickPlease, which was available on both iOS and Android that
1:39:16Dalton Caldwell, who later did app.net did, and that didn't work.
1:39:21And there were some other kind of attempts at doing similar things, but Instagram was
1:39:25always where the momentum was.
1:39:28And I think it's because they had really strong product direction.
1:39:31I think that always from the beginning, the product direction and the aesthetic and the
1:39:35usability was key.
1:39:38It was always product first.
1:39:39It was always product first.
1:39:41Clubhouse is one of those things where not that I don't think, where I wonder if it's
1:39:45going to be more like an Instagram Stories thing, where not Instagram Stories, the Snapchat
1:39:48Stories things, but you see where I'm going with this, where it's a great idea, but it
1:39:53could be potentially co-opted and done better by someone else.
1:39:58I feel like Twitter Spaces could beat it in a way that no one else even had a chance against
1:40:07Instagram, even though Instagram was iOS only until it was acquired by Facebook.
1:40:12No one else even had a chance.
1:40:13It sucked all the oxygen out of the room because it was the best.
1:40:19I feel like the concept of Clubhouse has a lot of legs.
1:40:21I just don't know if Clubhouse is going to be the thing or if it'll be whatever Mark
1:40:26Cuban things that he thinks he's doing or if it'll be Twitter Spaces.
1:40:29I don't think it'll be Facebook's thing.
1:40:31I think Facebook's thing will fall flat on its face.
1:40:34But I do feel like Twitter Spaces could potentially pull the Instagram move and make their review
1:40:43version of Stories way more successful, even though it's a blatant copy.
1:40:48It's better.
1:40:52You just echoed my thoughts exactly, where I feel like either Clubhouse is onto something,
1:40:57whether it is the thing and Clubhouse becomes a major titan of networking and owns the space,
1:41:06or is it Snapchat Stories and it just becomes a feature that everybody has and everybody
1:41:12has these audio group rooms and you can add.
1:41:17I don't know which way it's going to go.
1:41:20Either Clubhouse will become the thing for this in the way that Instagram became the
1:41:25thing for just sharing photos or it's Stories and everybody will have their own implementation
1:41:33of Clubhouse and Clubhouse is just one of them.
1:41:38On Dithering Ben and I talked about the way that Periscope and Meerkat were onto something
1:41:44with live streaming video from your phone, but there is no single home for live streaming
1:41:51video from your phone.
1:41:53Everybody just has live streaming on their platforms.
1:41:55You could do it on YouTube, you could do it on Facebook, you could do it on Citizen.
1:42:01It's just a feature that you add to anything that has this sort of thing.
1:42:04I don't know which way it's going to go.
1:42:06Here's what I see with Clubhouse and I'm not a heavy user, haven't even been there that
1:42:11long, but I see three types of rooms.
1:42:16Tell me if you think that I'm either off or if I'm missing something.
1:42:20I see there's shows.
1:42:23Ben Thompson was on a show.
1:42:24There's a show every night called, I forget what it's called now, Big Fun, Big Time, Good
1:42:30Time, Good Time last night and it's like a late night talk show, really late night for
1:42:36East Coasters.
1:42:37It's like 10 to 11 Pacific, but I was up last night and hundreds of people listen.
1:42:43It's a lot like a podcast except it's live and it was good and I liked listening to my
1:42:50friend Ben and the questions were good and I liked listening to it, but all I could think
1:42:54is this is just like a podcast, but with A, the frustration of you have to listen live,
1:43:02can't pause, you have to be there and tune in, which is a huge problem compared to, it's
1:43:08like going from having a TiVo to going back to not having a DVR and if you have to go
1:43:14to the bathroom or your phone rings during a show, you miss the show.
1:43:18You're screwed, totally.
1:43:20Which is crazy.
1:43:21Although I think that's why it works, but sorry, go on.
1:43:24Well, yeah, because maybe people are willing to say different things, right?
1:43:27Yeah.
1:43:28They're willing to be looser because they're not quite on a permanent record.
1:43:31Right.
1:43:32And I get it that that's also, it's not completely unrelated to the popularity of the Stories
1:43:37feature on all these platforms.
1:43:41B, worse audio quality.
1:43:43The audio quality is way worse than the worst podcast I've ever listened to.
1:43:48They do, technically, they do a great job with crosstalk.
1:43:51They really are doing some good things, but people are just talking into their phones
1:43:55and they're using phone microphones and there's a lot of compression.
1:43:58It's audio.
1:43:59I had my AirPods Pro on last night and I was like, "This is the worst podcast I've ever
1:44:02listened to."
1:44:03I mean, I listen to podcasts where sometimes guests call in on the phone and they patch
1:44:08them in like the old days on radio and they sound better than Clubhouse.
1:44:14So the show's thing to me is sort of like live podcasts and yeah, maybe there is a social
1:44:20psychological angle where there still is room for that because it's not a permanent record,
1:44:25right?
1:44:26So there's podcasts with me and you, people will be able to listen to it in years.
1:44:29We don't know if they're listening to it next week or tomorrow or if they're listening to
1:44:33it in the year 2030 and they're laughing because they're listening to it while their Apple
1:44:38car is driving them around, right?
1:44:41And they're like, "Well, John Gruber and Christina Warren were idiots nine years ago."
1:44:46And they're sleeping, you know, and they're like going to take a nap in the backseat of
1:44:50their Apple car.
1:44:52So there's shows.
1:44:54Then there's B, there's just like group chats, like seven, eight, nine people.
1:45:00This is what I've done more of.
1:45:02Maybe you know them, maybe you don't and there's a topic or something and there's like eight
1:45:06people and you have a talk and you're just chatting.
1:45:11I find that personally, it's like I'm on the introvert scale enough where I find it exhausting
1:45:19and in a way, but I understand that there are other personality types who crave social
1:45:25interaction and they find it energizing and they love it.
1:45:30And 2020 is a great year to launch something like that.
1:45:34100%.
1:45:35Because people who crave social interaction have no way to fulfill that.
1:45:42It's great, but that's definitely not for me.
1:45:45Do you like talking to new people when you go to a party or do you like talking to your
1:45:49friends?
1:45:50I like talking to my friends.
1:45:54Because I find it exhausting.
1:45:55I mean, that's sort of the definition of an introvert.
1:46:00But then in the middle, the ones that I find the most interesting are the ones that are
1:46:05sort of like a panel discussion at a conference.
1:46:11And it's different than a podcast because the audience members can participate.
1:46:18Yes.
1:46:19Right?
1:46:20So you get John Gruber and Christina Warren to talk Apple Car on Clubhouse and we could
1:46:29have a couple hundred people show up and we can pick one at a time through the app to
1:46:34invite people to ask us questions about what you and I think about Apple Car.
1:46:39And then for that time, it's me and you and our invited guests from the audience are now
1:46:44the speakers.
1:46:46Everybody else is listening and they can ask us questions that maybe you and I didn't think
1:46:50about and we can answer them.
1:46:53And then after we talk about it, pick somebody else who has their hand up.
1:46:56There's like a hand raise feature.
1:46:58Now that to me is, ooh, that's new.
1:47:02Yeah.
1:47:03No, I agree.
1:47:04I actually, I totally agree with your three categories.
1:47:08And my experience, especially early on, was mostly with that third category.
1:47:12And I agree with you.
1:47:13I think that's the power because I think that the first two, the first one especially, I
1:47:16don't really see a whole lot there.
1:47:20I think at that point, your audio twitch, right?
1:47:23Right.
1:47:24Like, I don't know if the platform really lends itself to anything.
1:47:26I think the second one is interesting and it can be fun.
1:47:29And I'm somebody who is an extrovert and doesn't mind talking to new people, but it can still
1:47:33be one of those things where it's going to be kind of dependent on what people you can
1:47:39gather together.
1:47:41I don't remember party lines, but I think that that was like a thing.
1:47:45That's kind of what that seems like, right?
1:47:47I remember they existed, but it was also, again, I don't even think I considered myself
1:47:51an introvert at the time.
1:47:53I think when I was younger, I attributed introvert to shy.
1:47:57And I'm not shy, obviously.
1:47:58Right.
1:47:59I do a podcast, but I do find it exhausting to talk to new people.
1:48:03I just...
1:48:04Well, it can be.
1:48:05Totally.
1:48:06Whereas I think the third thing, and this is what I think is powerful, is A, as you
1:48:10said, the fact that you can bring in other people, but also you add this element.
1:48:14Because I do think the ephemerality is key to this.
1:48:16I think the fact that you can't listen again, you have to be tuned in live, you have to
1:48:20be participating, does add something to the experience.
1:48:24And not only can you bring in listeners, but say we were talking about Apple Car and like
1:48:28this would never happen.
1:48:29But like, let's just say, and then some listener came in and it turns out like it was Bob Mansfield.
1:48:35And Bob Mansfield is a listener and now we can bring him in and he can talk and he can
1:48:39tell us all the ways that we're wrong.
1:48:42And that specific example won't happen.
1:48:45But there have been examples and there have been rooms I've been in, especially like when
1:48:48it was first kind of starting, you know, like in April or so when I was on it a lot more,
1:48:54ironically, you know, when there were fewer people on it, where you would see those sorts
1:48:58of situations happen.
1:48:59And I've seen that happen time and time again, where you have people who are brought in who
1:49:06might have a different perspective.
1:49:07Or again, this is where I get into like the celebrity angle where you have somebody who
1:49:10like has something to add to it that's really interesting context, who you might even be
1:49:15talking about or might even be talking around and they can share actual insights and give
1:49:20actual information in a way that you wouldn't be able to get through a show, right?
1:49:27Because that's scripted and that's planned and that has like a performative and kind
1:49:31of PR field to do it.
1:49:32And that you're not going to get with just a random chat of strangers, but instead you're
1:49:37having a conversation around a certain topic with a certain set of people and you all of
1:49:43a sudden have somebody in your audience who's really interesting that you would really love
1:49:46to hear from and you can pull them up.
1:49:48And I can't think of any other place where we would have that way to have kind of that
1:49:52that two way dialogue where you could bring somebody in.
1:49:54And I do feel like that has a ton of potential.
1:49:57Yeah.
1:49:58And it seems like if it, like I said, like let's just say it's me and you, we're doing
1:50:01a panel discussion on Apple car conjecture and people can just jump in and we see who
1:50:09has their hand up.
1:50:10And if you recognize, holy shit, it's Bob Mansfield or, you know, or, or, you know,
1:50:15somebody else who you just know has car experience, you know, you know, it's the, the CEO of Volkswagen,
1:50:20you know?
1:50:21Yep.
1:50:22Well, you know, of course you're, you know, you're going to jump that person to the front
1:50:26to see, you know, what's their question and get their, their feedback.
1:50:31And yeah, that happens.
1:50:32And my thinking about this is I, and I've, you know, I've sort of gotten away from speaking
1:50:37at conferences again, COVID aside.
1:50:42Just because I find it to be a huge time sink and I just have sort of reevaluated whether
1:50:47it's, you know, I'm not going to say I'm never going to do it again.
1:50:50I probably will.
1:50:51And if anything, post COVID, it's like, oh my God, let me do everything I haven't done
1:50:55in the last couple of years.
1:50:57Like but I've, you know, back when I used to go to South by Southwest, I did panel discussions
1:51:03and I always felt like it was a bit of a cheat, you know, cause it's so much like you don't
1:51:08do any preparation.
1:51:09You just, you know, pick a topic.
1:51:10You show up and you try to entertain people.
1:51:14And hopefully I always thought I'm better at it maybe than some people because I don't
1:51:19phone it in.
1:51:20I'm every moment I've ever been on a panel in front of an audience, no matter how small,
1:51:25like maybe it was 30 people.
1:51:26Cause it was the first time I was at South by Southwest, but I was desperately aware.
1:51:31Like I, you know, you've paid a lot of money to come to this conference and you're giving
1:51:36me an hour of your time and there's all these other panels you could have been to.
1:51:40Let me try to be as interesting and aware of your time as possible, but still it's nowhere
1:51:45near the value that I think I've delivered when I give a prepared talk that I've sweated
1:51:53over for weeks and prepare slides or, and rehearsed.
1:51:57And you know, a talk is such an easier way to do, to get a speaker badge than to prepare
1:52:05a talk.
1:52:06A panel, I mean, is easier than doing a talk, just orders of several orders of magnitude
1:52:12in my personal opinion.
1:52:15And it's not great.
1:52:17It's like the best panels you've ever heard are not that great.
1:52:23And when there is a question and answer period, it usually is awkward, often gets hijacked
1:52:30by somebody who just wants to ramble for five minutes.
1:52:34And whereas with Clubhouse, this panel idea is suited to it, right?
1:52:42Like the idea of a panel discussion is way better suited to Clubhouse than a conference
1:52:49because it is just audio.
1:52:51There's no reason to be in the room together.
1:52:53You know, you're not really getting that much out of it.
1:52:56And when you do do the Q&A type thing and just pull someone out of the audience, they
1:53:00become a full peer to the speaker.
1:53:03They're not out there in the audience on the weirdo mic that got passed around like Phil
1:53:07Donahue.
1:53:08They get put up in the top of the little window in the iPhone and now they're on stage.
1:53:16It's much more suited to it.
1:53:19It's more convenient and it's like native to the format.
1:53:22That's the thing that's most interesting to me and the thing I could see doing is some
1:53:26sort of panel type discussion thing with daring fireball readers and listeners of the show
1:53:33or something like that.
1:53:34I'm not saying I'm going to do it, but I could see doing it.
1:53:36No, and I think that was something I would love to participate in as a listener and potentially
1:53:42as a participant because you would have that potential option in the back of your mind.
1:53:46You're like, "Hey, I might even be able to have a chance to contribute."
1:53:49But even as a listener, that unexpected thing if you don't know who all is going to be
1:53:53there is really interesting.
1:53:55And you mentioned South by Southwest and it makes me think, my favorite parts of South
1:53:58by and I went for I think like 10 years in a row or something and I've been on more
1:54:05panels than I could think about.
1:54:07Like you, I always try to give my own, but there was kind of a more off the cuff type
1:54:12of aspect of it.
1:54:14But my favorite part of South by was not the panels.
1:54:16It was the side conversations you would have at the parties or that you would have in between
1:54:19panels or that you would have on the streets.
1:54:22And it would be those times when, you know, you're, this is the same goes for like Macworld
1:54:27or something like that back in the day or WWDC.
1:54:29It's those hallway conversations where you have this collection of people, XOXO is actually
1:54:34a perfect example.
1:54:35Like you have this collection of people where you might not ever be in that same group together,
1:54:41but you have enough common connections where it doesn't just feel like it's strangers.
1:54:45And you can have these really interesting discussions that you wouldn't expect to have
1:54:49and maybe you couldn't have naturally in any other way.
1:54:53You know, I remember I was at a conference once and I don't remember which one it was.
1:54:56And I remember that Twitter had been hacked and like celebrities had hacked.
1:55:01I remember like Britney Spears' account had been hacked and something else was going
1:55:03on.
1:55:04And I was talking to the guy who was at the time like the head of security at Twitter
1:55:09and he was having a real rough day and we were kind of commiserating.
1:55:12And then like somebody came up, I remember who it is, but I'm not going to out him
1:55:19because it was hilarious, but I'm not going to do that.
1:55:21And not knowing who this guy was just starts, "Can you believe that clusterfuck with Twitter
1:55:25and their security and all this and that?"
1:55:28And just starts going on and on.
1:55:29I was like, "Hey, this is John, you know, who runs Twitter security."
1:55:34And the guy was super embarrassed.
1:55:35It was a funny conversation, but it was one of those things where this news had just broken
1:55:40and I was having this conversation and a very human conversation.
1:55:43It was a good interaction with this guy who was having a pretty bad professional day.
1:55:48And it was not his fault, but it was, you know, stuff was happening or whatever.
1:55:52And I'll just never forget that because it was like, that's one of those happenstance
1:55:56things that's kind of a magical experience, right?
1:56:00And this feels to me like the closest thing that we could do with technology that can
1:56:05capture those sorts of, you know, situations where you could have a gathering of people
1:56:11who might not ever normally be in the same space, but could contribute something to the
1:56:17conversation or could, you know, maybe make a gaffe and not realize it, you know, amongst
1:56:21themselves or whatever.
1:56:22And you can get something more out of it than just blathering.
1:56:27I don't know.
1:56:28I have maybe, I don't know.
1:56:31What do you think of what's, I like the aesthetic of Clubhouse.
1:56:34I like the look of the app.
1:56:36I think they're, you know, they've got like a nice little unique thing going.
1:56:39What's the deal with the icon?
1:56:42They update it with, I think it's a user, somebody from the community, every release.
1:56:48I think that's what that is.
1:56:49And did they tell you who it is?
1:56:51I mean, that's, it used to be in the release notes.
1:56:53I don't know if it still is.
1:56:55It's such a weird, to me, it's so weird, but yet I dig it because it's so distinctive,
1:57:01right?
1:57:02It's like when you're like flipping through apps, it's like, you can't miss Clubhouse.
1:57:04It's this black and white picture of some dude with a hat.
1:57:09Yeah.
1:57:10I'm trying to think what else, what do you, what do you think they're going to do monetization
1:57:15wise?
1:57:16That's the interesting question, if anything.
1:57:18I mean, they might not even have to, right?
1:57:20I mean, the easiest thing to think about would be sponsored rooms.
1:57:24That's exactly, I was just talking to my pal Dave Whiskus about that.
1:57:27To me, that's the obvious route.
1:57:30And maybe that's because that's what, I built my whole career on the sponsored model, which
1:57:36I really do see as distinct from advertising.
1:57:40I agree.
1:57:41I agree.
1:57:42No, cause you could have a sponsored room sponsored by so-and-so that doesn't have to
1:57:46dictate that isn't an advertisement for that.
1:57:48No, I think sponsored rooms.
1:57:49I also feel like that could be an opportunity where if you did want to have a more formal
1:57:52panel setting or more formal conversation, and maybe if it's sponsored, like it's pinned
1:57:57to the top of a section so it has better visibility.
1:58:00Like I think that's what they could do.
1:58:02Either sponsor a room, sponsor a section, have something pinned so that it's easier
1:58:06to find because the thing that they're already kind of struggling with as it gets bigger
1:58:09and bigger is like discovery.
1:58:11And that's okay.
1:58:13But if, to me, that would be value.
1:58:14If you've got all these millions of users, your brand, like I would think that would
1:58:18be what you would want to try to like get across.
1:58:20What you always want and where the sponsored model works now is does the sponsored model
1:58:26get you to the valuation that this as a Silicon Valley Marc Andreessen backed startup gets
1:58:33you to?
1:58:34That's the problem with that.
1:58:35That's the whole story of the last 15 years of the internet, right?
1:58:40Like the sponsored model turned Daring Fireball into a really nice business for me.
1:58:47But it is not a billion dollar business.
1:58:50No, right.
1:58:51And it never will be.
1:58:52And it never will be.
1:58:53Well, it doesn't scale that way.
1:58:54I don't know.
1:58:55I mean, you could.
1:58:56I mean, you look at Spotify and you look at, you know, arguably they've kind of done that
1:59:02a little bit.
1:59:03I mean, I think you could, because I just don't think the regular advertising works
1:59:06in an audio setting.
1:59:07No, I don't see how it could.
1:59:08I don't think there's any way that it could work.
1:59:10I mean, you could use subscriptions, but that seems weird to, I don't know.
1:59:15I mean, look, I feel like the valuation is completely absurd, but I also feel like the
1:59:19valuation is disconnected from reality.
1:59:22You know, it's its lead investors who are prominent users of the apps who, you know,
1:59:26the other VCs are fighting with.
1:59:27Like, I kind of feel like the valuation is what the valuation is, but I don't put a whole
1:59:31lot of stock in that if it makes any sense.
1:59:33Because to me, the bigger question, and this is also why I think that Twitter could be
1:59:37really well poised for this, is that if this is something that Twitter could do really
1:59:43well, then this is a feature of Twitter that keeps people engaged with Twitter, but doesn't
1:59:47have to be a direct moneymaker for Twitter because they have their additional ad business
1:59:51and their additional revenue ways to make money.
1:59:54Right.
1:59:55The way my brain works is always, "Hey, that would be a nice business."
1:59:59And it would be, you know, money for the creator and money for the company and happy users,
2:00:06and it's a virtuous circle.
2:00:08And that's the way my brain works.
2:00:09And my brain doesn't work with, "That's a $500 billion company."
2:00:14Right?
2:00:15Like, I don't come up with ideas like that.
2:00:16But my thinking with the sponsorship thing is, "Hey, let's get a couple of nerds and
2:00:22they'll talk about the new iPhone."
2:00:25And it could be sponsored by a company that makes iPhone cases.
2:00:30And this room is sponsored by like Spigen or whoever, OtterBox or whoever, and they
2:00:37may sell iPhone cases and there it is.
2:00:40And there'd be a thing that you could tap to learn more about their cases.
2:00:44But otherwise, and whatever they pay, you know, it could go like 80/20 or 90/10 or probably
2:00:51not 70/30.
2:00:5270/30, I think we all agree is sort of exorbitant.
2:00:55But, you know, 80/10 or 80/20 or 90/10 to the creator, and then there's 10 for Clubhouse,
2:01:02and they make money and the creators make money and you can attract star talent to host
2:01:10these rooms and bring people in, and that's nice.
2:01:13I do think there's probably a market to, again, is it a multi-billion dollar idea?
2:01:18I don't think so, but I think it could be profitable.
2:01:20I think pro accounts always could be profitable.
2:01:23I always think back to Flickr, where when Flickr was a big deal, people paid for Flickr
2:01:31Pro so that they could get the pro badge on their avatar because you looked a little bit
2:01:36like a simp without it.
2:01:38Totally.
2:01:39Totally.
2:01:40Maybe unlimited, more uploads or whatever.
2:01:45And no, there were good things with that.
2:01:48Yeah, I think that sponsors could work.
2:01:49I think that paying creators could work.
2:01:51I have a feeling they would probably do the standard creator rate, which is usually like
2:01:5450/50 or something for YouTube, but who knows?
2:01:59I think the thing that they would need to be careful with on that is that if you...
2:02:03Yeah, but Substax 90/10, you know, it's all over the place.
2:02:07I get you.
2:02:08I'm just thinking more like YouTube terms, right?
2:02:11Like I'm thinking in those senses.
2:02:13And I think the fear with any of these things is like you want to get your high profile
2:02:17people and you want them to do shows, but you also...
2:02:21Those people are increasingly looking for what's the next big platform they can leverage
2:02:26and want to own their own brand and their own thing.
2:02:29So you see people...
2:02:32The big TikTokers all really want to be big YouTubers is really what it comes down to.
2:02:37My question would be like, could Clubhouse make enough of a monetization play off of
2:02:43its creators, but prevent its creators from going to YouTube or Twitch or whatever?
2:02:51Maybe they could, right?
2:02:52Like Snapchat is paying creators now and there are some creators who are apparently making
2:02:56a lot of money and that seems to be working well for Snapchat.
2:03:00And Snapchat is a multi-billion dollar company.
2:03:05And their model has largely been kind of in the sponsored thing, although they have some
2:03:10intermittent ads.
2:03:11I don't know how big of a part of their revenue that is.
2:03:16I feel like they...
2:03:17I think the sponsored rooms you could probably do well.
2:03:19The only problem with that is that's obviously going to...
2:03:22For the biggest brands in the biggest rooms and the biggest things, it's going to emphasize
2:03:26like the most popular and the most populist types of conversations, which kind of, again,
2:03:33like, I don't know, it sort of shuts down some of the magic, which are some of those
2:03:37more serendipitous things.
2:03:38But maybe that doesn't matter.
2:03:39Maybe that's what you need.
2:03:40Maybe those are your big tentpole movies that you need to pay for the rest of the slate
2:03:45and you can keep the rest of the business running.
2:03:47Is it a multi-billion dollar business?
2:03:48I don't know.
2:03:49I think it's a good idea and I think that's why we see everybody else wanting to jump
2:03:54on board to try to copy it.
2:03:55The last interesting thing that they do, and I wanted to get your thoughts on this.
2:03:59I'm so glad I just thought of it.
2:04:01I should have better notes because I almost forgot.
2:04:03But they do a thing where if you go to somebody's profile, you can see who it is who invited
2:04:09that person to Clubhouse.
2:04:11Right?
2:04:12Yes.
2:04:13That's what they call it sponsored by.
2:04:15I guess maybe they need to change the language at some point.
2:04:19But if I got in by being...
2:04:21I got invited from Dave Whiskus.
2:04:23So I think if you go to my profile, you'll see that...
2:04:26It'll show you.
2:04:27Invited by Dave.
2:04:28Yeah.
2:04:29Which I've thought of about for years as a way to grow a social network and not have
2:04:38the problems that we've seen with trolls.
2:04:43Yeah.
2:04:44You know, they want it to be a big tent.
2:04:47They want it to be inviting.
2:04:48I think clearly they'd like to explode and become a major cultural force.
2:04:52Totally.
2:04:53But if you...
2:04:54It gives accountability.
2:04:55Yeah.
2:04:56I'm thinking they never leave the invite only thing.
2:04:59I think that they're...
2:05:00That would be smart, actually.
2:05:02Right.
2:05:03They stay invite only forever and they just increase the number of invitations to the
2:05:08existing users.
2:05:09Yeah.
2:05:10No, actually, I like that idea.
2:05:12And what would be interesting about that, I mean, it reminds me...
2:05:14So I'm an old and I joined Facebook when it was college only.
2:05:17And it was that same thing.
2:05:18Like you had to be invited by another college kid.
2:05:21And this was like 2005.
2:05:23And I don't remember who it was, but somebody was invited by their school and even how it
2:05:28spread school to school.
2:05:29Yeah.
2:05:30Like that's how it happened.
2:05:31And there were a number of us who were non-hyperbolically sane.
2:05:37And I don't think we're wrong.
2:05:39Obviously, the business grew and got way bigger and that changed.
2:05:42But Facebook fundamentally changed when it became available to everyone.
2:05:45Right.
2:05:46And when you didn't have to have that gatekeeping thing.
2:05:50And it's not so much...
2:05:51And it got to the point, like at first it was only select colleges.
2:05:53But then it basically was anything.
2:05:54Like as long as you had an EDU address or you could get someone to invite you, then
2:05:57you could get in.
2:05:58But I do wonder, like if they just increased the number of invites, but you have to find
2:06:02somebody.
2:06:03Like obviously there will be people who will be selling invites and that's already happening
2:06:06and will invite anybody.
2:06:08But the fact that you need someone's phone number beyond just their email to invite them
2:06:13is one thing.
2:06:15The other thing I think, yeah, showing who's invited people on the platform is one thing.
2:06:20That's a certain way in some respects to hold accountability.
2:06:23If you see that a whole bunch of spam accounts or a whole bunch of agitators have joined
2:06:29by one person, you can kick that person out.
2:06:30Right.
2:06:31You could see the tree.
2:06:32You could see the tree of...
2:06:33100%.
2:06:34You know.
2:06:35So, maybe I shouldn't... screw it.
2:06:38So, okay, in the torrentine community, like music torrent sites, which do slugs at private
2:06:44torrent trackers, that is how it works.
2:06:46Is that if you get an invite from someone, it will show who invited you.
2:06:49And if you then have somebody who abuses the system, usually what happens is that the person
2:06:55who invited the abuser gets kicked out.
2:06:57And that is a problem because you want to be able to get those unreleased copies of
2:07:05whatever album you want because...
2:07:07I don't think you're in trouble for this, Christina.
2:07:09I mean, I don't care.
2:07:10Not that you...
2:07:13Not that I would personally ever download anything illegally off the internet.
2:07:16Right.
2:07:17But yeah, you know, but I feel like there is something to be said for that model.
2:07:22And maybe it does say "invite only forever" and that adds to the appeal.
2:07:27That does limit your growth, which if you're wanting to be the next Instagram, maybe is
2:07:31a problem, but maybe that is also how you keep up the cache.
2:07:33Because there's a certain thing now where everybody wants in, which does remind me of
2:07:38Instagram, although Instagram was never invite only.
2:07:40But it does remind me of like, you know, those other kind of invite only services.
2:07:44And I think there's power to that.
2:07:46By the way, about three minutes ago was the first time, I believe, in my life that I knowingly
2:07:56used the word "invite" as a noun.
2:08:00I've been on team invitation stubbornly for a while, but Merriam-Webster, a friend of
2:08:05mine, Paul Kefasis, pointed out on Slack this week that when I objected to the invite as
2:08:09a noun once again, Merriam-Webster has added a note to their dictionary.
2:08:15Is "invite" really a noun?
2:08:16Yes.
2:08:17This is from Merriam-Webster.
2:08:18"Some people feel strongly that the role of invite should be restricted to that of a verb,
2:08:22but the English language changes and grows according to its own peculiar whims and not
2:08:26those of people who write angry letters to dictionaries.
2:08:30The process whereby a word changes as part of speech is called functional shift, and
2:08:36there are tens of thousands of words which have done this.
2:08:38Some of them just bother people more than others.
2:08:40And invite, along with gift and friend, which have changed in the opposite direction, is
2:08:45one that attracts considerable opprobrium."
2:08:50So I have to admit, I love Merriam-Webster.
2:08:52It's probably my favorite dictionary.
2:08:55So I'm trying to buy into "invite" as a noun.
2:08:58Okay.
2:08:59I can be team invite for a noun as long as—and I disagree with Merriam-Webster here—irregardless,
2:09:04I don't care.
2:09:05It's not a word, and I refuse.
2:09:06Like that, I will die.
2:09:08Because it's bigger.
2:09:09That's the problem, right?
2:09:11The advantage to invite is it's shorter than an invitation.
2:09:15It is.
2:09:16And it also, I do think you can make the argument it's become a noun because it is this feature.
2:09:19It is this thing, right?
2:09:21Like it has this secondary meaning, whereas "irregardless" is just people who are too
2:09:24stupid to say "regardless."
2:09:26Yeah.
2:09:27Yeah.
2:09:28And it's not like "ain't" where "ain't" is—like I'm pro-ain't because "ain't" has connotations.
2:09:36If it ain't broke, don't fix it works in a way that if it isn't broke, don't fix it,
2:09:41makes you sound like an asshole.
2:09:42Right?
2:09:43Right.
2:09:44That's like you're the dean at the college and the Animal House movie.
2:09:49Totally.
2:09:50You know, you got to use "ain't" there.
2:09:53Irregardless, yeah, I'm with you.
2:09:55Never use it.
2:09:56Anyway, let me thank our third and final sponsor, Squarespace.
2:09:58Oh, man, do you need a new website?
2:10:01Go to Squarespace.
2:10:03All in one at Squarespace.
2:10:06Everything from domain name registration to templates to pick from to components you can
2:10:11add, take away from your site, like adding a blog, adding a portfolio, adding a store
2:10:16that includes all of the e-commerce stuff.
2:10:19Everything looks professional.
2:10:20Everything works regardless of your skill level.
2:10:23Everything is intuitive.
2:10:24They have great tech support.
2:10:27Squarespace also is the place to send people to when you, the technical sort of person
2:10:33who knows how to build a website on your own, has friends who come to you for help and they're
2:10:38like, "Hey, I need a new website."
2:10:40Send them to Squarespace.
2:10:41Get them started on their own.
2:10:43They'll thank you because they can do it on their own.
2:10:45And you'll thank me for having, reminding you to send them there because then they'll
2:10:49be out of your hair.
2:10:51It is a great service.
2:10:52It is where I would send anybody and everybody who asked me for help building their own website.
2:10:57You can start a free trial today.
2:10:59You get 30 days.
2:11:00Go to squarespace.com/talkshow and using that URL and the code "talkshow" when you order,
2:11:06you get 10% off your first order, including up to an entire year.
2:11:10That's squarespace.com/talkshow.
2:11:11Third and final bonus round, fire round.
2:11:18What do you call it?
2:11:19What do you call the quick round?
2:11:22The bonus round?
2:11:23Yeah.
2:11:24I don't know.
2:11:25Apple TV.
2:11:26The lightning round.
2:11:27Lightning round.
2:11:28Lightning round.
2:11:29Lightning round Apple TV.
2:11:30Yeah.
2:11:31You said Apple TV.
2:11:32Sorry, go on.
2:11:33Apple TV is where you use Siri and it works.
2:11:34I completely agree.
2:11:36I love Siri with Apple TV.
2:11:40My favorite feature on Apple TV is hold the microphone and say, "What did they just say?"
2:11:47It goes back 10 seconds, turns subtitles on, replays the 10 seconds with subtitles, and
2:11:53then just at the right moment turns the subtitles off again, which is an order of magnitude
2:12:01less friction than manually rewinding, pulling down, manually turning the subtitles on, getting
2:12:10to the point where you read the subtitles of the thing you couldn't hear, and then manually
2:12:14turning subtitles off again.
2:12:16Yeah, no, I couldn't agree more.
2:12:20That is magic.
2:12:21I also think even the way that the human language search stuff does, like, "Show me this episode
2:12:28with whatever," or "Take me to this show," works fantastic in a way that it doesn't work
2:12:33well on any other Apple platform.
2:12:35No, because I think it's the domain specificity where Siri on Apple TV knows what you're talking
2:12:41about.
2:12:42You're talking about shows and movies.
2:12:46It's really good.
2:12:47But the discussion, Jason Snell wrote a piece this week, "Why does Apple TV, the hardware
2:12:51box still exist?"
2:12:52Still exist.
2:12:53I think it's a great question.
2:12:54I wrote a piece about it.
2:12:57This is one of the answers people have come up with is, you know, you can talk to Siri
2:13:01and it works great.
2:13:05But bottom line, and you say this, and I love Apple TV.
2:13:09This is where I watch most of my TV, but I protest because I care, because there has
2:13:18to be more of a reason or Apple is going to lose interest in the same way.
2:13:23I don't want to see Apple TV go the way airport went.
2:13:26Right.
2:13:27No, I agree with that.
2:13:29I made a comment after Jason wrote his kind of initial thing, but before your article
2:13:32came out and I got so much pushback from it, even though I was pretty clear where I was
2:13:36telling people, I was like, look, I love my Apple TV.
2:13:39I have two of them.
2:13:40I use it every day.
2:13:41I'm not telling people who already have an Apple TV not to use one.
2:13:45But at this state in February 17th, 2021, I cannot in good conscience recommend that
2:13:51any human being spend $180 on an Apple TV.
2:13:55I just can't.
2:13:56Like, there's no way for me to rationally recommend a newcomer today to buy one.
2:14:03And that makes me really sad, but there's no way.
2:14:04I cannot come up with any argument where it is worth $180.
2:14:08It's not.
2:14:09It's, it's, unless they renamed it Apple TV edition.
2:14:12Right.
2:14:13Right.
2:14:14Exactly.
2:14:15That's exactly it.
2:14:16And didn't change at all.
2:14:17Didn't change.
2:14:18You don't have to gold.
2:14:19Didn't change anything.
2:14:20You just call it the edition and that would be it.
2:14:21Because the thing is, is that does it have a better user experience than most of the
2:14:24other boxes?
2:14:25Yes.
2:14:26Does it have the niceties like the Siri thing?
2:14:27Yes.
2:14:28Does it have arguably a better privacy thing?
2:14:32Kind of.
2:14:33The one area I'll push back is that look, Apple might not be spying on every move you
2:14:39make, but like every single one of those apps you use is absolutely getting usage information.
2:14:43So do not be under the assumption that you were not being tracked because of course you
2:14:48are.
2:14:50But do those things add up?
2:14:53Because I even said this to someone, people are like, oh, it's so much better for this
2:14:55than that.
2:14:56I was like, is it $150 better?
2:14:58Because a 4K Fire TV stick, which might not have the Dolby stuff, but a lot of people's
2:15:04TVs don't have Dolby either.
2:15:06So it still does HDR.
2:15:07It just doesn't do the Dolby out-my-out-my stuff, has an Apple TV app on it so you can
2:15:11watch your purchases and you can watch the original programming.
2:15:1530 bucks.
2:15:17It's got access to all the services.
2:15:20I can't come up with an argument that says this is $150 better.
2:15:25I just can't.
2:15:26Well, and the other thing too is it does seem, if it goes away, right?
2:15:32If Apple TV just slowly fades away and they never come out with a new version of the box
2:15:36and two years from now they just stop selling it, we'll all look back at it and say, yeah,
2:15:41I guess of course they were drifting away from it.
2:15:43That's why they added the Apple TV app to the TV sets and to all these other boxes.
2:15:49Of course, yeah.
2:15:50And they'll all look back and say, yeah, of course that's what they were doing.
2:15:52Because that's what it kind of looks like.
2:15:53It kind of looks like Apple is cannibalizing their own TV box sales by saying, we'll just
2:16:00be a pure software service.
2:16:02We'll just be a pure software.
2:16:03Yeah.
2:16:04At first I thought that it was just a growth play for TV+.
2:16:07I was like, okay, they know that they can't have mass adoption if this isn't on Roku,
2:16:12if it isn't on Fire TV, if it isn't on TVs.
2:16:15Because if you really want to compete with the Disney+'s and the Netflix's of the world,
2:16:19or which they can't, but let's say you want to compete with the Peacocks, you know, and
2:16:23HBO Max's of the world, then you need to be on all of these devices.
2:16:27So at first that was my thought.
2:16:28Because they did a similar thing with Apple Music, right?
2:16:30Like Apple Music is available on Android.
2:16:33But when they added AirPlay to the LG TVs, and when they started adding that to more
2:16:38devices, that's when you go, okay.
2:16:41Because AirPlay had always been their specific standard.
2:16:44You have to buy an Apple product to get AirPlay.
2:16:47And it's one of those magical things.
2:16:49And Miracast and the other, you know, DLNA or MLNA, whatever things have never worked
2:16:56the same way.
2:16:57So when they started doing that, that was when, plus the fact that, you know, it's now
2:17:01three and a half years old hardware-wise, makes me go, hmm, yeah, like what are you
2:17:07doing here?
2:17:09Because your price is completely, like it's not even in the same realm of like reality.
2:17:15Like you could cut it in half and it would still be overpriced.
2:17:19But you would have to literally, like if you lower the price to $100, it would still be
2:17:23more expensive than the competition.
2:17:25But you could maybe start to make kind of a high-end argument, but it would be hard.
2:17:30But that would be cutting $100 off the price.
2:17:32Like it's insanely priced right now.
2:17:35And I love the Apple TV.
2:17:36I would never tell anyone to buy one right now, ever.
2:17:41Because, you know, you can get a TV with Apple TV built into it for not much more than an
2:17:46Apple TV.
2:17:48The only thing, and this is what I mentioned, was that, you know, the only sign in the last
2:17:54year or two, or at least since their initiative to put their TV app on other companies' TVs
2:18:00and set-top boxes that makes you think they have any commitment to their own platform
2:18:06is Apple Arcade.
2:18:07Yeah.
2:18:08Which is, well, but it's a mixed bag.
2:18:11So on the one hand, every single Apple Arcade game is, it's a mandatory part of being an
2:18:18Apple Arcade game, is you need to be on all of the platforms.
2:18:21You have to have an Apple TV app, which is a big commitment because there's an awful
2:18:26lot of games that the hardest platform to support is Apple TV because it's a weak GPU.
2:18:33It pushes 4K, right?
2:18:37Like you can't, I believe, and I believe that if you have a performance-sensitive game,
2:18:45you can't push 180 out of Apple.
2:18:48If you're playing on an Apple 4K to a 4K TV, you need to push 4K, but you have to also
2:18:54get 30 frames per second at all times.
2:18:57And it's hard for some games.
2:18:58No, that is hard.
2:18:59I mean, look, the next-gen consoles, the PS5, the Xbox Series X, they don't do that.
2:19:05Like, they're optimized.
2:19:06Like, they will go down to 1080p or 1440p.
2:19:09Like they don't do 4K at all times because it makes no sense to do that.
2:19:14And the games, if they're phone or iPad first, they're designed for touch.
2:19:18You're not playing with touch.
2:19:19You're playing with the thing.
2:19:21And you've got the worst controller of all time.
2:19:24The worst.
2:19:25And again, let's just skip because we're in the bonus round.
2:19:28We're in the lightning round.
2:19:29Let's not even talk about the Apple TV remote as a remote for watching TV, like video.
2:19:34As a game controller...
2:19:35As a gaming controller, it is bad.
2:19:39It's like one of those jokes, like the joke, like the guy dies and goes to hell.
2:19:43And the first thing he sees is there's just a complete replica, blade of grass, tree for
2:19:49tree of Augusta National Golf Course.
2:19:51And he says to the devil, "My God, I love golf.
2:19:54This is unbelievable."
2:19:55And he says, "Here you go."
2:19:56And there's a brand new set of Ping golf clubs.
2:19:58And he goes, "This is fantastic.
2:20:00I thought this was hell."
2:20:01And he goes, "Oh, yeah.
2:20:02There's no golf balls."
2:20:03And that's like the Apple TV remote.
2:20:07It is like, "Oh, yeah.
2:20:08Here's this thing that can play games."
2:20:10And you have Apple Arcade, so you get all the games, quote unquote, for free.
2:20:14And here's your controller.
2:20:15Here you go.
2:20:16Here's your controller.
2:20:17Here's your controller that makes using one Joy-Con on the Nintendo Switch seem like using
2:20:22one, seem like a revelation.
2:20:24It's like trying to play basketball with a wadded up newspaper as the ball.
2:20:30It's very strange.
2:20:31They do, but they've made all of these participants in Apple Arcade make the arcade games, which
2:20:37makes me think there's maybe a commitment or I don't know.
2:20:41I'm going to be honest.
2:20:42I don't know because, A, I don't know if Apple Arcade is that successful.
2:20:49I'm not working on that assumption.
2:20:50I feel like people maybe are part of it because they feel like they want to be in the good
2:20:54graces of Apple, but I get it as part of Apple One because I pay for the $35 or whatever
2:21:02the most expensive plan is, so I get it.
2:21:05I don't use it and I play games.
2:21:09So I don't know.
2:21:10Maybe it is something there, but I wouldn't use that as a sign that shows that they're
2:21:16that deeply committed to it because this is Apple.
2:21:21I don't think they have any problem throwing their Apple TV developers under the bus and
2:21:25being like, "Yep, we're getting rid of this and thanks for optimizing your game to work
2:21:29with our shitty controller."
2:21:31I don't think that that would bother them at all.
2:21:34They're not good at breaking up with their products.
2:21:37They just sort of ghost them, right?
2:21:39Yeah, but that's so true.
2:21:42That's sort of what they did with Airport, right?
2:21:44It's totally what they did with Airport.
2:21:45Yeah, they totally just ghosted it until one day they were like, "Yeah, we're not going
2:21:48to do this anymore."
2:21:51And so I feel like there's three options.
2:21:55Either, one, they're ghosting it and there's never going to be another Apple TV box.
2:21:59At some point they'll just say, "Oh yeah, we're not doing that anymore.
2:22:01Don't you have a TV that has Apple TV?"
2:22:03Yeah, they'll just stop selling it like they did with the iPods.
2:22:05They'll just quietly remove it from sale.
2:22:07B, they do have some sort of plan and it has to be this year, right?
2:22:13I don't know.
2:22:14I'm not saying it's next month, but it has to be a 2021 thing because the 4K one is so
2:22:18outdated and so expensive and they come out with a new thing and it's powerful and maybe
2:22:25it has a game controller or something or some sort of story and there's something about
2:22:30it that is different than just Apple 4K with an A14 instead of an A12.
2:22:34Maybe it's $120 instead of $180.
2:22:37I don't know.
2:22:38I don't know.
2:22:39I don't know.
2:22:40Something.
2:22:41Or C, they come out with a new one that is just the same thing but a new chip, which
2:22:48to me is the least likely because it just makes no sense.
2:22:52And it also is expensive.
2:22:54They just come out with another $180 box that seems exorbitantly expensive and doesn't do
2:22:59anything else and this is just it and for some reason, Apple thinks this is compelling.
2:23:05It's a very strange product.
2:23:07It is.
2:23:08And what's frustrating to me, and then we move on or lightning round, is that with the
2:23:11third generation, before the fourth gen came out, they'd finally gotten that to be fairly
2:23:15inexpensive and you did have mass adoption because that was before, that was back when
2:23:20the Chromecast was pretty bad and when you didn't have the sticks and you didn't have
2:23:26the sub $50 very good, very competitive streamers and also you didn't have everything built
2:23:31in to every TV.
2:23:33So they were doing really well with the third gen TV and then they doubled the price essentially
2:23:37when the fourth gen came out.
2:23:39But they didn't continue to keep up and the trends, even if I think it's a superior experience
2:23:47and I do, I've used all the other ones and I can't, because people ask me for advice,
2:23:51what thing to buy.
2:23:53I can't in good conscience tell somebody to spend $200 on an Apple TV.
2:23:57I just can't.
2:23:58There's no way.
2:23:59It'd be like telling somebody to buy a HomePod.
2:24:01HomePod mini, sure.
2:24:02A HomePod, hell no.
2:24:03Are you kidding me?
2:24:05Absolutely not.
2:24:06Under no circumstances would I recommend that to someone.
2:24:09And I feel like anybody who's willingly buying one needs to buy one with the understanding
2:24:13that you are overpaying by a massive margin and you are doing it for whatever reasons
2:24:17you have.
2:24:18Yeah.
2:24:19I guess the other thing they could do, option D would be to not change the hardware at all,
2:24:23but just cut the price in half.
2:24:25If they did that, that would help them.
2:24:2799 bucks.
2:24:2899 bucks would make it, it still wouldn't be competitive, but it would be so much better.
2:24:32Right.
2:24:33But then it's within the realm of the Apple tax.
2:24:34Exactly.
2:24:35Right.
2:24:36Exactly.
2:24:37So you could buy a Roku premium from your whatever, like there's still a better product
2:24:40spec wise, but you could make that argument.
2:24:43Right now, the thing that makes it untenable for me is similar to when the HomePod first
2:24:48came out where it's like it costs so much money compared to everything else that's out
2:24:53there that it's just, you know, what I hope they do is they do what they did with HomePod
2:24:57mini.
2:24:58I would really like to see them do a redesigned option that is more modern and that is lower
2:25:02priced.
2:25:03Maybe drop some of the features if you need to, although I don't think you should because
2:25:06at this point the chip and the tech is so old.
2:25:08Right.
2:25:09But like, if it were me, you know, yeah, like I would, I would, you know, maybe require
2:25:15you to get a secondary controller to play a game.
2:25:18Right?
2:25:19Like that could be a way to make money.
2:25:20Like you have to buy a controller.
2:25:21The remote doesn't work as a game controller anymore.
2:25:23I don't know.
2:25:24Like, but, but cut it down, make it less expensive and do what they did with HomePod mini is
2:25:30the only way I could see it being salvageable in my opinion.
2:25:33Otherwise it's, it's just kind of this product they sell that is a mystery to me.
2:25:40It remains a product in our lineup.
2:25:42Yeah.
2:25:43Thank you.
2:25:44Yes.
2:25:45Yes.
2:25:46Oh my God.
2:25:47Yes.
2:25:48Exactly.
2:25:49All right.
2:25:50Lightning round over show over Christina Warren.
2:25:51Thank you for being here.
2:25:52People can follow you on Twitter, your film underscore girl, but they could just search
2:25:57for Christina Warren on Twitter.
2:26:00You want to give your, your clubhouse name?
2:26:02Yeah, I'm, I'm Christina on clubhouse I think.
2:26:05Yeah, you are.
2:26:06You are just Christina.
2:26:07Yes.
2:26:08Uh, this is a sign that I've been an early adopter or something if I just get my first
2:26:11name on it.
2:26:12Um, so that's, that's awesome.
2:26:15And um, I do a podcast called a rocket that I'm late for right now.
2:26:19I'm so sorry.
2:26:20You were completely fine.
2:26:21Let's tell everybody to listen.
2:26:23Let's make it even.
2:26:24Yes.
2:26:25It's a good podcast.
2:26:26It's a great podcast.
2:26:27So if you want to listen to me be slightly late for a, for, for rocket, it's a relay
2:26:31FM, uh, dot com slash rocket.
2:26:34Um, I do it for you on a blue and some underbrush for, it's a great time.
2:26:38And uh, do you have another podcast over tired with Brett?
2:26:41Yes, I do.
2:26:42Thank you.
2:26:43Do over tired with Brett tripstra.
2:26:44Yeah.
2:26:45Rockets.
2:26:46The one we really want to, we really want to promote because I'm the one who made you
2:26:48late.
2:26:49So my best Brianna and Simone, tell them I said hi.
2:26:53(laughing)