0:00:00Ah, what a week. It's still Friday. I guess WWDC is still going on, but I guess it's officially
0:00:07sort of over in the sense that all the--
0:00:10Yeah. Friday's normally the day. It's all rerun sessions at the show, and it's normally
0:00:18the day where people start filtering out of town. The Friday drinking crowd is quite a
0:00:23bit thinner than the Thursday night drinking crowd.
0:00:26(laughs)
0:00:27I think I've gone home on Friday most of the last few years
0:00:30because my wife comes with me now
0:00:33and she gets the shits of it a lot sooner than I do.
0:00:37(laughs)
0:00:39I always liked, like in the old days
0:00:41when I would come out by myself,
0:00:42I actually liked the Friday night
0:00:45when like most, a lot of people were gone
0:00:48or people left during the day
0:00:49and local Californians could just drive or whatever
0:00:53and then it was just like a nice quiet night
0:00:55and a dinner where you didn't have to try to find,
0:00:57"Ooh, where can we find a table for 11?"
0:01:00(laughing)
0:01:02And it was like, "Oh, this is nice."
0:01:03And then you could relax and go home on Saturday
0:01:05and it was normal.
0:01:06- Yeah. - But now, I'm already home.
0:01:09(laughing)
0:01:12- Long journey back to the old home.
0:01:15- The other thing that I was grossly wrong about
0:01:18is I thought, "Well, since this will be remote
0:01:20"and I'll be at home the whole time,
0:01:22"even if I'm busy and I have a show
0:01:24and I did have a show and it did occupy some time,
0:01:28I thought, well, this year I'll get to watch
0:01:30a lot of the sessions during the week.
0:01:32I have watched no sessions.
0:01:36- Yeah, the only sessions I've watched are clips on Twitter.
0:01:39And I thought the same thing.
0:01:41Not only did I not get to watch sessions,
0:01:44I felt this was way more hectic
0:01:47than it was actually being there.
0:01:49- Yeah, yeah, I thought the same thing too.
0:01:53At a very high level, I would just like to start with the App Store stuff,
0:01:58because it broke before WWDC.
0:02:02And you-- and this is why I thought, well, let's talk to our old friend
0:02:06Panzer, because Phil Schiller talked to you, and you had an interview.
0:02:10And they tried to--
0:02:12I'm not going to say they tried to clean it up,
0:02:14but they tried to deal with it.
0:02:17There was this controversy that was started with the Basecamp's new Hey
0:02:22app being rejected from the store and for doing what seemed, you know, and again, we
0:02:28could easily derail this entire show.
0:02:32But let me see if I can summarize it very quickly.
0:02:34Hey is an email service and app all rolled into one.
0:02:40And the idea is you pay them $100 a year and you get your name at hey.com.
0:02:45And then once you have that, you could download their app for other, you know, for iPhone
0:02:50for Android or Mac or whatever, and then you'd log in
0:02:54and then you can use the app.
0:02:56And if you just download the app
0:02:58and you don't have a Hey account yet,
0:02:59it has the Netflix effect, which is my catch-all term
0:03:04for you download the app and open it
0:03:06and it has a username and password field
0:03:09and a terms of service link or something like that,
0:03:13and that's about it.
0:03:14And they got rejected for that.
0:03:17And that's how Basecamp works,
0:03:19and that's how dozens and dozens and dozens
0:03:21of software as a service type apps work.
0:03:24And things that aren't even software as a service,
0:03:27you know, like you buy like a Nest app
0:03:29or something like that, you know, for your Nest thermostat.
0:03:32Well, if you don't have a Nest thermostat,
0:03:33the Nest app doesn't do anything because what can it do?
0:03:37So they got rejected, they kind of,
0:03:42I think in a very clever way, played this up
0:03:45in such a way that it led to hundreds of accusations
0:03:49that they did this on purpose as a publicity stunt,
0:03:52which is really not the case.
0:03:56And like they've said, I've seen DHH and Jason Fried
0:04:00respond to people on Twitter, and they're like,
0:04:02"Okay, let's just go with this for a second.
0:04:05Your theory that we did this on purpose
0:04:07requires us to have two plants in the App Store,
0:04:10one who approved our initial version
0:04:12and then a second one to reject it."
0:04:14our bug fix update.
0:04:17How would that work exactly?
0:04:19Anyway.
0:04:21Phil Schiller talked to you at TechCrunch.
0:04:27And it did not, it was interesting.
0:04:31It wasn't meaningless, but in some ways,
0:04:34what he said actually generated more controversy.
0:04:37- Yeah, I mean,
0:04:39look, at that point in time, it seems like
0:04:44you know, we could talk about it, obviously, what they announced at the show, or sort of during, after the keynote, very casually announced some things about the App Store changing in some ways.
0:04:59But at the time that I had my interview, you know, they had sent this letter, and I guess they sent it day and date with the press, to Basecamp.
0:05:11And the letter, you know, outlined, it's essentially an App Store rejection letter, but public, right?
0:05:17Because they sent it to press and I guess because of the timing that they sent it to the press, they sent it to Basecamp and they said that they got it only after they'd already seen it published publicly.
0:05:31I think they were trying to avoid that by sending it to all the press and them at the same time.
0:05:35In some ways I see their point because like, you know, certainly Basecamp is the party
0:05:41that chose to go public, for lack of a better term.
0:05:45You know, they chose to kind of litigate it publicly, so Apple probably felt justified
0:05:50in some way in sending that letter to everybody, right?
0:05:54But that letter didn't go out until after I had had my interview.
0:05:58You know, I didn't see that letter until after I had had my interview already and my
0:06:02and my article was essentially complete.
0:06:04And I included the letter at the last minute
0:06:07and then hit the publish button,
0:06:09'cause I had gotten it, along with all the press
0:06:11and theoretically Basecamp all at the same time.
0:06:14The letter though was essentially
0:06:17an App Store rejection letter, right?
0:06:19And it just laid out their reasons for rejecting it
0:06:22and their case for the App Store working
0:06:26the way that it does, and then sort of ended
0:06:29paragraph about Basecamp having benefited from the App Store and not contributed any
0:06:37revenue back to it, which I think is probably overall the most controversial thing about
0:06:41it.
0:06:42Or certainly seemed to engender the most developer reaction.
0:06:46They're like, "Oh, we're only worth it if we make a lot of money for you," et cetera,
0:06:50which we can talk about.
0:06:51But I think that the one phrase from my piece, which was something that Phil said, was that,
0:06:55Look, if the app opens on the store and doesn't do anything,
0:07:00you know, it doesn't work, it doesn't do anything for you,
0:07:02that's not what we want,
0:07:03that's not the user experience we want.
0:07:06Which is, none of what he said to me was anything,
0:07:10as you said, it's like not anything super revelatory
0:07:12because it's just them restating
0:07:14what they believe the app store rules to represent, right?
0:07:17They're like, look, this is why we put these rules
0:07:20in the store, this is what we believe the store is about,
0:07:24And Phil was just restating that stuff.
0:07:26And I think people, because of the reader app rule,
0:07:29and with Netflix and all of that stuff,
0:07:31they really glommed onto that particular statement
0:07:35about an app opening and not working.
0:07:37And they're like, hey, what about these other apps?
0:07:38Now, of course, in the Apple universe,
0:07:41according to Apple's rules,
0:07:43they already have a carve out for those apps.
0:07:45And so the real argument everybody's making is like,
0:07:47why is email not part of that carve out, right?
0:07:50Or I guess you could extend that to,
0:07:52Why does this carve out even exist?
0:07:55But it's not like it was saying anything extremely new.
0:07:58I felt it was newsworthy in that they
0:08:00were holding to their stance, which is the angle I
0:08:03took with my piece.
0:08:04That's really what the news was at that moment,
0:08:07is that Apple's not saying, hey, we've reconsidered,
0:08:10or hey, we're going to change this thing because of hey,
0:08:14or whatever.
0:08:15Phil was very much coming from the place of,
0:08:18we have these rules for a reason.
0:08:20we think that they are the right way to go
0:08:23and we're not really going to be changing them
0:08:25at this point.
0:08:26And so that's the tack I took.
0:08:27And I tried to report it straight
0:08:28because I put a little opinion in there too
0:08:30because I feel that people do want to know
0:08:34what the people that are following this thing
0:08:38regularly think about it.
0:08:39But I didn't want to put too much of my own feeling
0:08:41and passion or whatever into that
0:08:43because I think the moment warranted it.
0:08:47So, you know, I just think that it was such a hot button topic that even Phil saying,
0:08:52"We're not changing our mind," it became kind of a magnet.
0:08:56Yeah, I think that's a good way to put it, is because it's a hot button topic, and...
0:09:03I don't want to conflate something...
0:09:07And again, I realize people's livelihoods are at stake, so I'm not saying it's trivial, right?
0:09:11Like the Basecamp folks have put millions of dollars
0:09:15into developing hay.
0:09:18I mean, it's a huge, huge, huge, huge endeavor for them.
0:09:22And I realized that these App Store policies
0:09:26affect companies large and small.
0:09:29So it's not trivial,
0:09:31but I realized that in the face of a pandemic
0:09:35that is re-raging out of control,
0:09:38that in the face of protests on equality
0:09:43and police brutality across the country
0:09:48and literally also across the world,
0:09:50but people are, this whole thing combined together,
0:09:57a bunch of emotional powder kicks have made people
0:10:00more sensitive to hot button topics, right?
0:10:03That's my point, is that if hay had come out a year ago,
0:10:08and in the exact same way,
0:10:12with the exact same controversial aspects
0:10:14about a rejection and policy and stuff like that,
0:10:17I think that it would've played very differently.
0:10:21I'm talking literally like three, whatever it was,
0:10:24five days before WWDC,
0:10:26but if it had been before WWDC 2019,
0:10:29it would've played differently.
0:10:30People are on edge, and of course they are.
0:10:33all are and it's like you don't even really know it you think like you're normal and it's like
0:10:36yeah i don't know you you just you're on edge we've been cooped up we're you know we're worried
0:10:42about getting sick you know it's it's crazy you know it's it's and and so yeah i and i'm not
0:10:49defending it i'm not even passing judgment on it but i think whatever phil schiller said whatever
0:10:56the letter which was just like from the app store you know the closing paragraph about you know we
0:11:01we see that you haven't contributed anything to the App Store, or your Basecamp app has been
0:11:07downloaded millions of times and hasn't contributed any revenue to the App Store.
0:11:11Sort of has that, if you want to, you can see it as that typical gangster threat of,
0:11:18"Nice store you've got here."
0:11:20- [
0:11:20here. You know I think it was yeah absolutely and I think it
0:11:24was the way that that was phrased in the letter. I
0:11:30absolutely think that it was hey you've benefited
0:11:33significantly from this app store. So yeah, I think it's
0:11:36reasonable to say that we do not try to you know carve into
0:11:43that business and we haven't for years right into the base
0:11:47camp business because it's played by the rules that we've laid out and you've made every
0:11:52dime of that and we have made zero dimes from that.
0:11:56The least charitable—even if you ignore the whole threat subtext, which I think, as
0:12:02you said, everybody's on edge, so you're going to read the worst possible motivations
0:12:08into a lot of things, or a lot of people are right now.
0:12:11But even if you ignore that, shave off the worst 10% of the way that you can read into
0:12:17that, I think there's certainly a whole additional swath of people that weren't willing to go to the
0:12:23extreme of like, "Oh man, this is a threat." And I know that David used the word gangsters, right?
0:12:31Right.
0:12:31And even if you don't go into that kind of realm, which is a very aggressive stance to take against
0:12:37it, it still definitely reads as like, "Hey, if you don't contribute revenue to it, we're doing
0:12:45you a favor."
0:12:46Yeah.
0:12:46This is a charity for you.
0:12:49And I think that that's like the bigger thing that I think a larger cadre, a larger
0:12:55tranche of people responded to, even if you ignore the sort of worst 10% of the way you
0:13:02could interpret that.
0:13:04And I think that that is basically, I do believe probably still because they were on edge and
0:13:08all of that.
0:13:09But you remember there are a lot of people, a lot of independent developers in the App
0:13:12store where 30% is not just a cost of doing business.
0:13:17It's a real difference between whether their kids eat or not or whatever, how much money
0:13:22they make from the store, whether or not it's a sustainable business that they can do forever,
0:13:26or whether it's something that they were able to do for a while and now can't do anymore.
0:13:30And I've seen examples of all of that.
0:13:33Developers who had a real strong business on the store and eventually just couldn't
0:13:36make ends meet, couldn't make it work.
0:13:39And their products were cool and great and interesting.
0:13:41They had users and it wasn't like, oh, it was a failure. It was just like, I can't make the
0:13:46economics work. And so when you're going to come into a scenario like that, I believe saying that
0:13:54was accurate and in some ways fair to say, look, we don't take a cut of this business. Because I
0:14:02think, honestly, that was a big critical thing. And it's certainly a part of the antitrust
0:14:06discussion is, is Apple taking, is, are they rent seeking? Are they using the control of the app
0:14:13store to take a cut of businesses that they had no part in building or have no real, you know,
0:14:20part in maintaining? Right. And that that statement was really speaking directly to that
0:14:26argument. It's like, look, we don't take a cut of this. Are they using as this is to me the right
0:14:33way hopefully the regulatory approach will take is are they using as leverage to get
0:14:41a cut of X, Y, and Z, companies large and small, whatever, but if are they using to
0:14:47get as leverage something they shouldn't be allowed to use as leverage to get that?
0:14:54Right.
0:14:55Right.
0:14:56That to me is the question that hopefully that's what the regulatory inquiries will
0:15:01focus on.
0:15:02And it's, to clarify it, you know, the thing that Schiller said about, "Hey, you download
0:15:09the app and launch it, it doesn't do anything, that's not what we want," he wasn't saying,
0:15:14and again, I'm not trying to be like a lawyer here and parse his words, but he's not saying
0:15:17that that necessarily means it's against the guidelines of the App Store.
0:15:23So everybody citing X, Y, and Z and the dozens and dozens of apps that you download and don't
0:15:29really do anything unless you already have an account.
0:15:32He wasn't saying it's not allowed.
0:15:33He's saying, literally, that's not what we want
0:15:36in an ideal situation that, you know,
0:15:38in theory they would want an app.
0:15:40And again, whether that's right or wrong,
0:15:41that is what he said.
0:15:42But that is the solution that they found,
0:15:46that both sides found amenable to do this,
0:15:48where the Hey guys added a pretty clever
0:15:53and actually in theory useful feature
0:15:55where now you can download the Hey app
0:15:58and you can get a temporary throwaway 14-day email address
0:16:01that you could use to sign up for something
0:16:04that you don't wanna use a real email address
0:16:06'cause you suspect, hey,
0:16:08they want my email address for this.
0:16:11I know this is just gonna get me spam.
0:16:13You could use their app, get a temporary one,
0:16:15use it for 14 days,
0:16:16but you still sign up on their website,
0:16:20pay them and do this, and now it's in
0:16:23and hopefully will no longer be controversial.
0:16:26So I asked about this on my show with Jaws and Federighi,
0:16:31and I didn't want to belabor the point
0:16:35'cause there's so much to talk about,
0:16:36and we had a limited amount of time.
0:16:39But I brought it up, and Jaws said something
0:16:42that as he said it, I wasn't sure if it was a great answer,
0:16:46and then I rewatched it afterwards,
0:16:47and I thought it was a better answer
0:16:49than I thought it extemporaneously
0:16:52as we were doing the interview.
0:16:55But he brought up the fact that the App Store,
0:16:59that before the App Store, that getting your,
0:17:02selling your software was way worse.
0:17:05And I feel like I have to mention,
0:17:09if there was something I should have followed up
0:17:10on the point and didn't, is I was only thinking of it,
0:17:13and I think it's what Jaws meant, but I'm not sure.
0:17:16I think he was talking about the mobile landscape,
0:17:18where pre-App Store, getting quote-unquote apps,
0:17:23I mean, I don't even know if people called them apps,
0:17:24but getting stuff all went through the carriers
0:17:27and if you wanted to have,
0:17:29I mean I don't even know of anybody
0:17:31who had like third party email for phones
0:17:34before the iPhone in the app store.
0:17:37But if you did, you'd have to go through Verizon
0:17:39and it would be like a Verizon branded thing
0:17:42and then you'd have to completely separately negotiate
0:17:45with AT&T and get, do something and have an AT&T logo
0:17:49when your app starts and it's,
0:17:53Software updates would all go through them.
0:17:55And that's just talking two carriers in one country,
0:17:58the United States, and that's what it was like
0:18:00all over the world.
0:18:01And the software was crappy because the APIs were crappy.
0:18:05And yeah, the App Store blew that apart.
0:18:09But that's 12 years ago.
0:18:12That's a long time ago.
0:18:14- That's a long time ago, yeah.
0:18:15- And the App Store, it just is not the upstart
0:18:19that is blowing up the idea of mobile software.
0:18:23The App Store has become bigger,
0:18:26and the idea of App Stores writ large on Android
0:18:31through Google and Google Play,
0:18:33and in China through the Chinese carriers
0:18:36and variants of Android that don't go through Google,
0:18:40that's the new world, right?
0:18:43And that world is bigger and more dominant
0:18:46and more a part of everyday life
0:18:48for just normal everyday people
0:18:50than the pre-2007 software landscape for mobile ever was
0:18:55or even could have dreamed of being, right?
0:18:58- Right.
0:18:59- So that would be my comeback to that.
0:19:02And then the other thing I think I have to mention
0:19:04is that it completely, it really only makes sense
0:19:08in the historical context of looking at mobile
0:19:11and doesn't look at the historical context
0:19:13of the Mac and desktop software, where,
0:19:17and a lot of the same developers,
0:19:21developers who were writing great Mac software
0:19:24through the '90s and the 2000s and writing Cocoa apps
0:19:27and selling them directly with no app store
0:19:30and no 30% cut to Apple and building a good business
0:19:33and having them promoted by Apple and stuff like that.
0:19:37It certainly is not the truth
0:19:39that you had to go through retail channels
0:19:41where Ingram Micro was taking 70% of your price
0:19:45to get a box software on a shelf.
0:19:46- Right, yeah.
0:19:48- There was a thriving landscape for indie independent,
0:19:51and not just small indie developers,
0:19:54but like a big startup well-funded
0:19:57with millions and millions of dollars of VC money
0:20:00could build software for the Mac using these APIs.
0:20:03The last point I wanna make on this front
0:20:07is on this issue of Apple benefiting from developers
0:20:12with great apps in the App Store,
0:20:16whether they make money from them or not, right?
0:20:19And there's that line in that letter insinuates
0:20:23that if Apple isn't making money from them,
0:20:26just a direct income revenue coming in,
0:20:29then they're not really benefiting.
0:20:31And again, I think that, to me, it hearkens back
0:20:35what I said about Jaws' comment and the indie Mac, or not indie, but just independent of
0:20:41Apple, you know, not indie like meaning small companies, but just all developers, third
0:20:46party developers.
0:20:48That's good for Apple.
0:20:49It was great for Apple when, and I really, I really mean it.
0:20:55I don't know that there would be an iPhone without it, that part of the appeal and really
0:21:01the very best technical thing that Apple acquired when Next came back. Maybe the best thing was the
0:21:08leadership and Steve Jobs and the executives he brought with him, but at a technical level,
0:21:13it was what became known as the "Coco frameworks." And that they let develop—it sounds like hype,
0:21:22you know, that, "Hey, one person can write an app that does amazing things." But you wind up
0:21:28with things like my friend Gus Mueller at Flying Meat,
0:21:32who's one, you know, he runs a company with his wife,
0:21:35but he's the only developer, and has written Acorn,
0:21:39which is a legitimate Photoshop competitor.
0:21:42Not saying it's feature for feature as deep as Photoshop,
0:21:45but you can certainly, for me personally,
0:21:47I use it where I used to use Photoshop, one person.
0:21:50And because of Cocoa, because of how deep
0:21:53these frameworks are, that's good for Apple, right?
0:21:57It is good for Apple when developers are building apps that can only exist on Apple platforms.
0:22:05Or if it is cross-platform, that it is a full-fledged, like, "Hey," which is a web-based thing and
0:22:14has an Android app and a Mac app and stuff like that.
0:22:18Apple benefits both ways.
0:22:19It benefits when developers do things that take advantage of Apple's systems in a way
0:22:23that can only exist on the Apple platforms, because then it's a distinguishing feature,
0:22:27and then it benefits when cross-platform stuff is fully available and a great experience on the
0:22:34Apple platform. Again, I'm showing my age, I guess, but I remember in the '90s when there
0:22:41was an awful lot of cool stuff that was only on Windows, and it was a huge problem for Apple.
0:22:45Huge.
0:22:46Yeah.
0:22:47And I mean, you know, all you got to do is look at gaming, right?
0:22:51If you just want to pick one industry that drove, you know, technological advances and
0:22:57high margin computer hardware businesses and all of that for decades, it's been gaming,
0:23:02right?
0:23:03And like a good portion of the reason the Mac wasn't dominant for a long time was
0:23:07that gamers didn't buy Macs because they knew that they couldn't, you know, and I'm
0:23:11making generalizations.
0:23:12I know there are gamers on Macs, you know.
0:23:14I'm a gamer.
0:23:15but at the same time, it was driving the high-margin hardware business forward.
0:23:20And Apple, you know, either for whatever reason, or for many reasons, I should say,
0:23:25the reasons are there, which we don't need to go into,
0:23:28chose not to kind of go after that, right?
0:23:30And they went towards the creative professional and all of that stuff.
0:23:33But if they had wanted to, say, capture the gaming market,
0:23:38and if they had, you know, had a desire to, their strategy would have been different.
0:23:42And it's the same thing with the App Store.
0:23:44If they had wanted only direct revenue-generating apps on the App Store, their policies and
0:23:51marketing would have been different.
0:23:53But they knew, in their core, they knew that the numbers about how many apps were on the
0:23:58store and how many developers supported it and how many major companies had an app for
0:24:05the iPhone, even if they were not for-pay apps, even if they were free apps or extension
0:24:10apps, all of those things benefited the iPhone ecosystem and drove the billions and eventually
0:24:17trillions of dollars in sales of the iPhone.
0:24:20There's just no getting around that.
0:24:23Making that statement is one of those times where it's like, "This is technically true,
0:24:28and it is fair to point out, but maybe it's not the right time."
0:24:34And maybe it's a little disingenuous because you know very well that free apps and apps
0:24:40that contribute no revenue to the store still drive hardware sales.
0:24:44And just because the business overall has a much stronger mix of services revenues now
0:24:52and app store revenue is a non-trivial component of that services revenue doesn't mean that
0:24:59you're not still selling hardware by the bucket and that those apps didn't contribute to that.
0:25:04And don't continue to contribute to that.
0:25:06- And that that's the primary sustaining business of,
0:25:11we're, you know, we Apple are selling the $1000 phones
0:25:15and $500 phones and $700 iPads and $300 iPads
0:25:20and $300 keyboards for iPads and Macs
0:25:25that range from a thousand to $60,000.
0:25:27- $600 wheels, you know.
0:25:29- $600 wheels.
0:25:31- A variety of items.
0:25:33- Got a bunch of hair caught in my wheel,
0:25:35I better get another one.
0:25:36How much is that?
0:25:36Oh, $100.
0:25:39But that's the primary business that they're in
0:25:43and that the services stuff is secondary
0:25:46and that the specific aspect of services
0:25:49that is taking a cut of third-party developers
0:25:52writing stuff for your platform
0:25:54is secondary on the secondary, right?
0:25:56Like the main services push for Apple
0:25:58should be their own services.
0:26:00Getting people to pay for iCloud,
0:26:02getting people to sign up for Apple TV+,
0:26:05et cetera and so forth.
0:26:06And so hopefully that's not lost,
0:26:09but it's a good segue into WWDC
0:26:11because I think it plays into it.
0:26:13But let me take a break right here
0:26:14and just thank our first sponsor.
0:26:17Oh, I love this company, HelloFresh.
0:26:19You can get mouth-watering seasonal recipes
0:26:22with pre-measured ingredients delivered right to your door
0:26:25with HelloFresh, America's number one meal kit.
0:26:30HelloFresh makes cooking at home fun, easy, and affordable.
0:26:34Break out of your dinner rut.
0:26:35Oh, are we in a dinner rut here at the Gruber household
0:26:38in mid-June, three to four months, five months,
0:26:43six years into quarantine.
0:26:45But HelloFresh can help you break out.
0:26:47They have over 22 seasonal chef-curated recipes each week.
0:26:51And you get to pick what's up for you,
0:26:54what's right for your family, your household,
0:26:56you, low-calorie options, vegetarian options,
0:26:59family-friendly recipes, that's code for kid-friendly recipes, but they've got you covered.
0:27:06They have more five-star recipes than any other meal kit, so you know you're going to
0:27:10get something delicious.
0:27:11You save time and stress effortlessly.
0:27:14They cut out the stressful meal planning and prepping so you can enjoy cooking, get dinner
0:27:19on the table in just about 30 minutes, sometimes even 20 minutes with their quick recipe options.
0:27:25That's another thing you get to choose as you go.
0:27:28You know your budget for time.
0:27:30Average trip to the grocery store takes 41 minutes.
0:27:33That's over 35 hours a year if you go once a week.
0:27:36HelloFresh can cut that down.
0:27:38And we all know with everything going on today,
0:27:41cutting down on trips to the grocery store
0:27:43is more important than ever, less stressful.
0:27:45Ah, it's just so great.
0:27:47Flexible, fit your lifestyle,
0:27:50recipe options that are delicious and fit your needs.
0:27:54And they even can throw in stuff like sides,
0:27:56desserts, garlic bread, cookie dough,
0:27:59all sorts of fun stuff.
0:28:01And right now, HelloFresh is starting
0:28:04at just $5.66 per serving.
0:28:08Go to hellofresh.com/talkshow10.
0:28:12That's talkshow10.
0:28:15Hellofresh.com/talkshow10.
0:28:18And remember that code, talkshow10,
0:28:20during HelloFresh's sale,
0:28:22and you could get 10 free meals, including free shipping.
0:28:26That's hellofresh.com/talkshow10
0:28:28and that code, talkshow10,
0:28:31get 10 free meals including shipping.
0:28:34My thanks to them.
0:28:35So anyway, parlaying this into WWDC,
0:28:39I think part of what's interesting about this,
0:28:42and it really is to me a parlay
0:28:44from this controversy over the App Store
0:28:46and where Apple's focus should be
0:28:49of if you get too caught up
0:28:51thinking about the iPhone in particular
0:28:55and that's where Hay's app got caught up.
0:28:58The iPhone has direct rivals,
0:29:03primarily, almost entirely now, the Android platform.
0:29:07And something like Hay can run on Android
0:29:10and it's largely the same.
0:29:12And you can get caught up thinking
0:29:15about the developer angle that way.
0:29:18But Apple is really expanding,
0:29:20and I think the watch in particular,
0:29:22I know on my show this week with Federighi
0:29:24and Jaws, I didn't spend a lot of time on a watch.
0:29:26But the watch is so interesting to me
0:29:28from a developer perspective,
0:29:30because it's a very personal device.
0:29:34And it really is, I know that that's sort of
0:29:37what Apple said six, seven years ago
0:29:39when they first introduced it, but it is.
0:29:40A watch is a personal fashion statement,
0:29:43and it's right there, it's literally touching your skin
0:29:45when you're using it.
0:29:46And they're adding it, I think it's really neat
0:29:51the way that they're emphasizing the complications
0:29:55as a way of personalizing it,
0:29:57and face sharing so that you can,
0:30:01if you have a face set up just the way you want it,
0:30:05you can share it with a friend or a family member,
0:30:07like, "Hey, how do you get your watch to look like that?
0:30:09Here, let me show it to you."
0:30:10But the other thing that's really interesting
0:30:13about the watch in a broad sense
0:30:15is there's no real competition for it.
0:30:18I'm curious if you thought about that during the week at WWDC in that it fits in with the
0:30:25landscape.
0:30:26It's not like Apple Watch developers are this whole other ecosystem of developers.
0:30:32It is the same developers who are writing iPhone apps and iPad apps and Mac apps.
0:30:37Ben
0:30:48and certainly people that were in that space before Apple and have now gone defunct or kind
0:30:57of lost their way.
0:30:58Then there's certainly major competitors that are trying to pour money into it, like Google,
0:31:05obviously.
0:31:06But it's become very clear that the competition the watch has is not against other people.
0:31:12It is against its own usefulness.
0:31:14It is against the desire for somebody or the sight line somebody has from not having one
0:31:22to why would it be good for me to have one.
0:31:25That's their major challenge in competition.
0:31:29And I think that that's probably...
0:31:33You could look at a lot of the announcements that were made at DubDub about the watch through
0:31:40that lens and it starts to make pretty simple, straightforward sense.
0:31:45The face sharing is definitely something that was lacking with the watch as some sort of
0:31:51viral mechanic for sharing its usefulness.
0:31:56Because the face is essentially the core of what makes it useful to most people.
0:32:00You look at things, it tells you things, you can take actions from the face.
0:32:04All of the initial wave of things that they thought were going to be useful like, "Oh,
0:32:08they got a bunch of apps and you can scroll around and poke at it. Nobody uses that shit.
0:32:11In all reality, they're edge cases. But the 80% use case, which is what Apple always cares about,
0:32:20is the face. What is it telling me right now? What can it provide me quick access to,
0:32:27like an activity or weather or calendar or radio station or whatever? And that face sharing thing,
0:32:37while it seems like, "Oh, this is kind of a fun thing.
0:32:40"Oh, cool," right?
0:32:41It actually is the first time that the watch
0:32:43has had some sort of potentially viral channel
0:32:46for sharing directly its usefulness with other people,
0:32:51because I don't actually believe that the watch sharing
0:32:54is aimed primarily, it's aimed strongly secondarily
0:32:59at people that own watches.
0:33:00It's aimed primarily at people that don't own watches.
0:33:03And it's aimed at saying like,
0:33:05"Oh, look at this watch sharing thing."
0:33:07It has a nice preview, it shows me the complications and the things that I could do on it if somebody
0:33:11shared it with me.
0:33:13And I can look at all these things I could do if I only had the watch.
0:33:17And this watch sharing thing adds that sort of patina of usefulness to the whole enterprise.
0:33:27And it acts as a genuine vector for telling people, "This thing is useful to you.
0:33:32It shortens the onboarding time.
0:33:34It keeps it useful long term so that they continue to be invested in the platform and
0:33:39they buy new watches and all of that.
0:33:41So I think that if you look at the announcements through that lens, some of them start to make
0:33:46more sense.
0:33:47Yeah.
0:33:48And I just think it shows the way forward—or not the way forward, but it's a clarifying
0:33:57notion for Apple that that this is a virtuous circle where
0:34:03You're you're improving the watch in ways that makes the watch more valuable to the people who already have it
0:34:09Makes it more likely that they'll buy a new one eventually that they'll recommend it to friends
0:34:14And that they're gonna wear it and use it and like it and be like I feel naked without my watch
0:34:20I want my steps. I want my but I want these complications that I've set up because my watch face was just for me
0:34:26and that keeps people in the ecosystem.
0:34:31It makes it more likely, you know,
0:34:32if you have a watch, you wanna have an iPhone,
0:34:34it makes it more likely you're in the iPhone,
0:34:36and then Apple is selling three, $400 watches
0:34:41and 500, $600,000 iPhones, keeping people in the system.
0:34:46Apple's, you know, last I checked,
0:34:48doing pretty well financially.
0:34:50And again, famous, spending Tim Cook's money
0:34:53is a very easy thing to do as an armchair quarterback.
0:34:56I get it, I try not to do it, but at a certain level,
0:35:00when you're literally the most profitable company
0:35:04in the world, and by however you wanna do
0:35:07the inflation adjustment, up there among the handful
0:35:11in history, like going back hundreds of years
0:35:13to the East India Trading Company,
0:35:15you don't have to sweat the marginal,
0:35:20let's see if we can get 30% out of the signups
0:35:23from this software as a service thing on a phone.
0:35:26Again, I'm not saying they shouldn't do it.
0:35:28It's very easy to tell somebody else
0:35:29when they have enough money.
0:35:33It's not mine.
0:35:34But they don't need it.
0:35:37And I just think that the watch is really clarifying
0:35:40as to how just getting buy-in from developers
0:35:45to do things that really only make sense
0:35:48in the Apple ecosystem is really good for Apple
0:35:51in and of itself, even if they're not making any
0:35:5530% of this or that just by having developers making these complications for the watch.
0:36:01Mm-hmm.
0:36:02Yeah, and the face sharing—or, yeah, face sharing.
0:36:05I think that's what they're calling it.
0:36:07But the face sharing situation, it allows—it's the first time that Apple—so Apple always
0:36:14emphasizes on their site, obviously, "Oh, here's some third-party apps and things
0:36:17that you can install, and here's all of our first-party features we built," right?
0:36:23And some of those are cool, and some of the third party apps are neat, but the face sharing
0:36:27thing is interesting because it doesn't currently, nothing like it currently exists even for
0:36:33the app store.
0:36:35Because the app store says, hey, here's some single serving, single compartment experiences
0:36:42that you can download that may be useful to you.
0:36:45Here's a calendar app, here's a game, here's a health app, et cetera.
0:36:51But what the App Store doesn't have currently is, here's a package of things that are useful
0:36:58to you together in this really compelling way.
0:37:03Right now, the App Store doesn't have a way to download workflows to say, and to some
0:37:09degree, shortcuts is that, but that's not really accessible to a major audience.
0:37:14It's accessible to people that want to tool around with it, and it's very cool.
0:37:18But as far as I am a, I don't know, I'm a CPA,
0:37:23and I wanna get the best use out of my iPhone.
0:37:27Oh, you need these seven tools, you know?
0:37:30I'm an athlete, and I'm not only an athlete,
0:37:34I'm a college athlete.
0:37:36Okay, you need to download this education helper,
0:37:40this thing to keep track of your classes
0:37:43that's specifically designed for athletes.
0:37:45You need to download this training app,
0:37:47this nutrition app and this thing, right?
0:37:51And that could be packaged together by the college
0:37:54or by a developer or whatever.
0:37:56None of that exists for the store.
0:37:57It's all like lists of apps.
0:37:59Like, oh, if you're a so-and-so, you need these 10 apps.
0:38:02Okay, cool.
0:38:03Now I gotta download 'em, figure out how to configure 'em,
0:38:06understand what they do, you know, all of this, right?
0:38:08It's a lot of labor.
0:38:09Whereas the watch face is very interesting
0:38:12because it says, hey, here's three different apps
0:38:15from a developer, three different developers,
0:38:18plus some first-party stuff from Apple,
0:38:21swizzled together to create a best-case scenario
0:38:23for a runner, or for a swimmer,
0:38:25or for a person concerned with health,
0:38:27or for a person that manages a complex schedule,
0:38:29or for a person who does both, you know?
0:38:32And here's some things that'll work for you.
0:38:35And I think that's really cool and unique to the watch,
0:38:38and it does what Apple does best,
0:38:41which is say third-party stuff,
0:38:43or what Apple at its best, I should say, does,
0:38:46which is, hey, here's third-party stuff
0:38:47that does amazing work.
0:38:49We think this really shows off the cool stuff
0:38:51that the platform is capable of.
0:38:53Plus, here's some first-party work that we did
0:38:55because we know this hardware intimately
0:38:57and we knew we could push it to the limit
0:38:59to do something like hearing amplification
0:39:02or assistance or healthcare or whatever.
0:39:06And I think that's a really interesting and unique thing.
0:39:09- Yeah, and I think I'm getting this right,
0:39:11that one of the weird, not weird, but maybe in hindsight
0:39:14was a weird limitation was previously
0:39:16you could only have one complication from an app
0:39:20on one watch face at a time.
0:39:22And so you couldn't, if you're,
0:39:24let's say you're a weather nut,
0:39:26you couldn't have like three weather complications
0:39:28from the same weather app on the same face at a time.
0:39:33And, you know, again, that's like a, it's a niche
0:39:36and it's like the sort of thing
0:39:37that maybe Apple didn't think of is,
0:39:39what if you are a weather nut? What if you really do want three different complications,
0:39:45all about the weather on your watch face at a time? Maybe you're a meteorologist.
0:39:49Or maybe you're a commuter, right? And you commute between two cities,
0:39:52right? Or whatever. They have micro-components. I mean, look at Oakland and the Bay. I mean,
0:39:56those are different weather ecosystems.
0:39:58What if you don't live in the Bay where it's 71 degrees on cold days and 73 when it's hot?
0:40:08But you commute there for work.
0:40:09And then you go back to Hayward, where it's like 90.
0:40:11And so there are definitely cases where you would want that, for sure.
0:40:17Yeah. But I just think that the watch, even though it is sort of the...
0:40:21Like I said, on my show, I had an hour with Federighi and Jaws, and we certainly spent the
0:40:30least time on a watch. And not because it isn't deserving, but that it just had so much to say
0:40:35about the Mac and other things, which you and I can get to in a moment, but I just think
0:40:40it exemplifies that sort of how does app, the answer to that question of, well, you
0:40:45know, why should Hey get to have an app in the App Store if they're not giving Apple
0:40:49any money?
0:40:50Apple gets stuff out of it when developers are engaged with their platforms, and it's
0:40:54just ridiculous to pretend otherwise.
0:40:57Can't necessarily put a dollar amount on all of it.
0:41:00All right, let me take one more break.
0:41:01We only have two sponsors for this show
0:41:03'cause it's sort of a special brief post-WWDC episode,
0:41:07but it's our good friends at Squarespace.
0:41:10Oh man, Squarespace, that's where you can start
0:41:13building your website today, right at squarespace.com,
0:41:16talking about software as a service.
0:41:17You just pay them, you get a great website,
0:41:20you have a great interface to do every single thing
0:41:23you could possibly want to do with your own custom website,
0:41:26from designing it to deciding what components
0:41:29are a part of it, like if you want a blog,
0:41:32you want to host a podcast, or maybe you have a portfolio
0:41:35of stuff that you want to sell and actually do the commerce
0:41:38on your website and sell it, you can do all of that
0:41:41at Squarespace, analytics built in,
0:41:44see who's coming to your website, where, from,
0:41:47stuff like that, and it's just so professional looking.
0:41:52All these templates to choose from, all WYSIWYG,
0:41:56right there, you'd see it, you look at it,
0:41:59What you see as you're designing it
0:42:00is exactly what people will see when they're visiting it
0:42:03because it's literally the exact same interface
0:42:06except yours is the editing option
0:42:08and the actual viewing one doesn't.
0:42:11Really, next time you need a website,
0:42:12somebody comes to you for help with a website,
0:42:15get 'em started at Squarespace,
0:42:16put an hour or two into it and see how far you get
0:42:19and you really won't look back.
0:42:21Where do you go to find out more?
0:42:22Go to squarespace.com/talkshow.
0:42:26And when you decide to sign up and pay,
0:42:28Look, you get a free trial.
0:42:30It lasts, I think like a month, it's crazy.
0:42:33You get a great free trial.
0:42:34Just remember that when you go to pay,
0:42:37go to squarespace.com/talkshow
0:42:39or just remember the code talk show
0:42:41and you get 10% off your first purchase,
0:42:44including up to an entire year, a whole year.
0:42:47And if you do sign up for a year,
0:42:49you also get a free domain name registration.
0:42:51So my thanks to Squarespace.
0:42:53Just remember the code talk show,
0:42:54squarespace.com/talkshow.
0:42:56code talk show, save 10%.
0:43:00So the Mac is really moving the arm.
0:43:02- Yeah, it is.
0:43:04- I'm interested-- - Is that a finally?
0:43:07I don't know.
0:43:08- I think it is a finally.
0:43:09I think it's probably not surprising in hindsight.
0:43:12I think that they've hinted,
0:43:14Apple does not like to say how long they've been working
0:43:17on things that they've been working on.
0:43:19They're secretive about everything,
0:43:20including how many years certain endeavors have taken.
0:43:25But they couldn't even help but say it this time,
0:43:28like when they revealed that the emulation layer
0:43:31is gonna be called Rosetta 2.
0:43:33They even said that they've had the same,
0:43:35some of the same engineers who worked on the PowerPC
0:43:38to Intel Rosetta are working on this
0:43:40and that they've been spending years on it.
0:43:43And so one of the things that,
0:43:48I know you've spent a lot of time recently with Mac Pro
0:43:51and thinking about that, and you and I were there
0:43:54and that handful of people who are invited to talk to Schiller
0:43:58and Federighi and John Turnus about Apple's sort of,
0:44:04hey, we painted ourselves in that thermal corner.
0:44:09Let's get our way out of it.
0:44:10We want to be a big part of the pro-workstation market.
0:44:14How does this clarify the view for that for you,
0:44:20of where Apple-- not just where they are right now
0:44:23and what this means in the next two years
0:44:25as they transition, but where they've been thinking
0:44:28for the last four or five years on Mac hardware.
0:44:31- Yeah, I mean, I think it's certainly a,
0:44:35it's interesting, 'cause I haven't,
0:44:38as you mentioned, I've been kind of using a Mac Pro lately,
0:44:41and I'm kind of playing around with it
0:44:42and trying to think about it.
0:44:43I'll probably write something about it.
0:44:46I wanted to kind of wait until the first blush
0:44:48of people that had had their chance to talk,
0:44:49and frankly, until professionals
0:44:52had it in their workflows for a bit so that I could ask around to people that I knew were
0:44:57using it and kind of say, "Hey, how does it actually work?"
0:45:01You know, not, "How do I think this thing's going to work?"
0:45:04And not really a discussion about pricing value or all the initial stuff.
0:45:09I want to know, did they do a good job?
0:45:11Right?
0:45:12Did this thing work?
0:45:13And I think that when you look at it through the context or look at ARM through the context
0:45:17of the Mac Pro, I think it's very interesting because a lot of people were saying like,
0:45:20So who would buy a Mac Pro now and all that stuff?
0:45:24I don't think we're gonna be seeing ARM processors
0:45:25in Mac Pros for five years, personally.
0:45:29- I disagree. - You think it'll be sooner?
0:45:32- I think when they say two years,
0:45:34I think within two years, it'll be everything.
0:45:37I really do.
0:45:37Now, whether that means they won't continue
0:45:39to still have the Intel CPU option
0:45:42in the Mac Pro in particular, I don't know.
0:45:48I think that there might be an entirely ARM option for even a $25,000, $30,000 workstation
0:45:55class Mac Pro within two years.
0:45:57Interesting.
0:45:58I really do.
0:45:59Okay.
0:46:00I think so.
0:46:01I don't know.
0:46:02I think the one thing that stood out for me, which matters for everybody, it matters for
0:46:09all compute, but it especially matters for mobile compute is Johnny Ceruggi, Apple's
0:46:15kind of head chip guy was saying, the phrase that he used was, it was basically incomparable
0:46:23price per watt, right?
0:46:26Right.
0:46:27And that, or power per watt, excuse me, not price per watt.
0:46:30They haven't mentioned pricing yet, but power per watt.
0:46:34So basically you put in X amount of power into a current Intel processor and you get
0:46:38back a certain amount of compute.
0:46:43And then you put in the same amount of power to an ARM processor or their ARM processors
0:46:47that they're going to be making or already are making and that we don't know about yet,
0:46:51and you're going to get back more for the same amount of wattage.
0:46:54And this is something that obviously if any chip people are listening to this, I'm sorry
0:47:00that we're talking about it in like baby goo goo ga ga speak.
0:47:04But I think a lot of people don't.
0:47:08Definitely there was some discussion about it, but I think a lot of people kind of overlooked
0:47:12that particular sentence just because there was a lot going on.
0:47:16"Oh my god, they're armed, they're switching away from Intel, you know, oh my god, oh cool,
0:47:19they're going to develop their own processors, you know, tightly integrated with hardware
0:47:23and software."
0:47:24Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, right?
0:47:25But like I wrote a piece in…
0:47:26I was looking at the other… after that presentation, I looked it up because it was essentially
0:47:31the same kind of argument for the iPhone.
0:47:33The argument that I was making at the time, this was… they just started shipping A-series
0:47:38processors.
0:47:40And so my argument was, look, the iPhone's biggest flaw is the battery, right?
0:47:45And it's not really a flaw in that it's a mistake Apple made.
0:47:48It's just a flaw in the system, right?
0:47:51iPhones would be capable of so much more if they were more power efficient or if they
0:47:55had more power available to them.
0:47:57And the only way to do that, well, there's two major ways.
0:48:02One way is develop an entirely new battery chemistry, which all companies on the planet
0:48:08that have any interest in compute have been exploring to no avail yet.
0:48:13There's some promising technologies, but like carbon nanotubes and everything else
0:48:17is always on the horizon, and graphene and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, right?
0:48:21There's always some new battery technology on the horizon somewhere, but none of it has
0:48:24materialized.
0:48:26So the other major way to do that, of course, is to get more efficient on the compute side.
0:48:32And Apple has done that in a variety of ways, including moving their graphics frameworks
0:48:37to write to the chip rather than having an intermediate layer,
0:48:40like an OpenGL.
0:48:42They've done a large amount of work, obviously,
0:48:45optimizing their software to run on their own silicon,
0:48:48which is a huge part of it.
0:48:50And they've got-- you know, every time the iPhone comes out,
0:48:53it's like, "Oh, better battery life. Better battery life."
0:48:55It's like, "How are you doing this? It's the same battery," right?
0:48:57And sometimes it's more battery in the casing, you know?
0:49:00It's a few millimeters here, a few millimeters there.
0:49:03You know, liquid battery technologies and, you know, all of that.
0:49:06They're eking it out wherever they can.
0:49:09Well, this I view as their big chance
0:49:11to kind of push hard into that,
0:49:14hey, what if we shipped a laptop with our own processor?
0:49:19You know, one question is like,
0:49:20oh, what if we shipped a laptop with our own processor
0:49:22and had tightly integrated everything
0:49:23and better security, all of that?
0:49:25I think that's great,
0:49:26but a lot of those points are kind of hard to sell.
0:49:29What is really easy to sell is,
0:49:32hey, we just came out with a laptop
0:49:34that has all the same power as that Intel laptop
0:49:36that you were thinking of buying,
0:49:37but it's double the battery life.
0:49:39Enjoy!
0:49:41Right?
0:49:42And like 100% improvement on battery life
0:49:44is absolutely within stabbing distance,
0:49:48you know, of an arm-driven portable.
0:49:51And that's why I think that a lot of their focus
0:49:54is gonna be on where they can get the biggest toehold
0:49:56and gains and sort of own that market
0:49:59and really just destroy the competition
0:50:02for at least some period of time.
0:50:03And that's why I think the focus
0:50:05definitely going to be on MacBook Pros and all of that, you know, the portable lineup
0:50:08first. But, you know, and that's why in my mind the timeline was like longer for the
0:50:14Mac Pro, but also very exciting in the near term for MacBooks, you know, because I think
0:50:21this will be the first time we've seen a generational multiplicative jump in a long time because
0:50:28a lot of the underlying technologies haven't changed.
0:50:33I feel like exactly like you do,
0:50:35where I feel like you and I talking about this
0:50:38is sort of like babies talking about nuclear physics
0:50:41compared to people who really know the chips.
0:50:43But on the other hand, I feel like we're at least
0:50:45the babies who kind of have a sense
0:50:47of how big a deal this is, and I really want to convey it.
0:50:49And like, maybe it's a bad analogy,
0:50:52but I feel like there's a lot of people
0:50:55who are thinking about this wrongly along the lines of,
0:51:01let's say instead of switching instruction set architectures
0:51:05from Intel to ARM or x86 to ARM,
0:51:08if Apple had bought AMD and they said,
0:51:12"Okay, we've bought AMD.
0:51:14"Now we own them and we're going to switch the Mac
0:51:17"to AMD x86 processors
0:51:22"and there's gonna be cost efficiency
0:51:25"and we don't have to pay any kind of margin on it
0:51:27"'cause we're gonna do these chips ourselves."
0:51:29You know
0:51:30It's not like that at all
0:51:32That's not what they're that's not even close to what they're doing and that would have been big news and a big deal in
0:51:39the market for PC hardware
0:51:41And certainly would have meant a lot to PC PC gamers who like buying AMD chips if they were worried that Apple
0:51:50Now that they bought AMD isn't going to sell them in that way
0:51:54Etc and so forth that I don't even know if that was ever even on the table
0:51:58But I just think that that's how some people are looking at this, like, oh, from a business perspective,
0:52:05Apple's cutting Intel off, no longer has to pay Intel any kind of profit on these chips,
0:52:11you know, which are expensive parts of a Mac, you know, 150 bucks or, you know, 200 bucks out of a thousand dollar MacBook Air.
0:52:17And now they can cut that off and they have lower margin and maybe they're a little smaller and run a little cooler or something.
0:52:23I don't think that's it at all.
0:52:25I think it's like you said,
0:52:27we're talking about a 2X factor.
0:52:29We're talking about,
0:52:31think about the fact that the iPad Pro
0:52:33clearly out benchmarks MacBook Pros
0:52:36and doesn't have a fan.
0:52:38Like, what are they gonna do?
0:52:40Are they gonna bring fanless design to the MacBook Pros,
0:52:44which would be huge?
0:52:45Or are they gonna keep the fans
0:52:48and build chips that we've never seen from Apple
0:52:51that can run to the point where they require a fan,
0:52:55but imagine what they could do.
0:52:57If that's what the A12Z can do without a fan,
0:53:01what would happen if they built one that,
0:53:03yeah, oh yeah, we're gonna keep the fans.
0:53:06And it's in the same way we're like
0:53:08a 16-inch MacBook Pro, typically,
0:53:10even when the fan kicks in,
0:53:11it's not like you hear a hairdryer going.
0:53:13But I mean like a weird
0:53:19schism in performance per watt that just does not, and also probably isn't really that analogous
0:53:28to even the power PC to Intel shipped 15 years ago. It's more significant. Maybe another very
0:53:35loose analogy that you could poke holes in very quickly is sort of thinking of electric cars and
0:53:42vehicles as, "Oh, you just don't have to put gasoline in them anymore, but they ride the same."
0:53:49So instead of pumping gas into them, you plug it in.
0:53:51But then you actually get in one and press the gas puddle,
0:53:54and you're like, oh.
0:53:56Oh, this is totally different.
0:54:00Oh, can I do that again?
0:54:02I would like to stop this and start it again.
0:54:04I would like to--
0:54:06oh, right?
0:54:08I feel like there might be that sort of moment when they reveal
0:54:14even just the very first max that they have in order,
0:54:17where you just look at them.
0:54:18you'd be like, oh, this is very different.
0:54:21- Yeah, I mean, I'm excited about it for ways that,
0:54:25I mean, like most of the time, honestly,
0:54:27I work on either the iPad Pro now or a desktop, right?
0:54:30And so for me, the battery power debate is like,
0:54:35I mean, the iPad Pro's battery life is so amazing, you know?
0:54:38That I'm already living in that world, right?
0:54:40But plenty of people can't yet work on an iPad Pro
0:54:43or want more flexibility, they wanna use a Mac, right?
0:54:47for all of the reasons the Mac is so good.
0:54:50You use it to tinker, try crazy new things,
0:54:53build apps for one thing.
0:54:56And I'm so glad that they're investing in that,
0:54:59and I think a lot of people are,
0:55:00but the fact is we have never seen a software hardware maker
0:55:05ever that has fielded a chip design team,
0:55:10set the rules for how the hardware is used,
0:55:13and then built the software for that hardware.
0:55:15It's always playing on somebody else's playground.
0:55:19Even if they have influence, even if they've said,
0:55:21"Oh, these are the specs that we want,"
0:55:23they've never had that kind of down-to-the-roots control.
0:55:27And it's always somebody else's job to do those things
0:55:31and somebody else's responsibility
0:55:33and ultimately somebody else's decision
0:55:35and how to fabricate those things.
0:55:37And sure, Apple has been doing that for a little while
0:55:40with the A-series chips because they've been saying,
0:55:43"Hey, here's exactly what we want.
0:55:45build this. But we've never really seen that from a desktop manufacturer ever. You could
0:55:53argue right now that every Windows laptop could work 10 times better if Microsoft also
0:56:00made all the processors, right? Because those teams could integrate very deeply with one
0:56:05another and make it work. But you're always dealing with like, either you've got underhead
0:56:11or overhead, either power that you're utilizing or power that you wish you had or that you
0:56:17aren't utilizing or power that you wish you had.
0:56:20And I think that it's a very, very exciting thing to see what happens when they do that.
0:56:24I mean, I think people at Intel, the smart people, are probably really, really worried
0:56:27right now because the only reason they have to be able to sleep right now is Mac market
0:56:32share because they're like, "Oh, it's a tiny part of the market.
0:56:35We supply a ton of processors to a lot of different manufacturers.
0:56:39agnostic, et cetera. But if you're able to launch a laptop that says, hey, this is 75
0:56:46to 100% better than a competitor rather than the normal 20% that happens every generation,
0:56:52it starts being a huge fucking problem for them.
0:56:55You know?
0:56:56Yeah. Well, and I think I touched on this on my show, and I just feel—and there's
0:57:02only so far you can press with those guys. And I feel like Federighi was delightfully
0:57:06like, yeah, we're totally committed to the Mac
0:57:10and in a way that hopefully would reassure more people
0:57:14than even just that huge slide from two years ago
0:57:17with the big no that we're gonna just combine
0:57:19the iPad and the Mac.
0:57:21I just feel that there is a sense at the company
0:57:28that they have a very, they're not doing things
0:57:32redesigning the Mac Pro with a year or two ahead, you know, like the end of their foresight
0:57:40for where they're going with the Mac is 2022 or something like that.
0:57:44They're not going through this transition with, you know, like one or two years of Mac
0:57:50hardware ahead of them.
0:57:52This is a very long play.
0:57:53I mean, decades at least, probably decades.
0:57:58And what they're really thinking of is not, I think, is not just shackled to the history
0:58:04of what is the Mac in the context of the PC market.
0:58:11It is the broader sense of what do we need, what is the need for a computer workstation
0:58:18at the highest levels of performance as an industry we can build.
0:58:23Where's that going five, ten years from now?
0:58:27What are the needs?
0:58:28What jobs are there to be done that require the most possible graphics and CPU and now
0:58:36neural engine compute going forward?
0:58:40And I think that it really, I think that there's a sense that what the Mac is, the Mac is I
0:58:45guess going to be Apple's answer in that regard.
0:58:47And that's a very different problem domain than what is it that you do with an iPad or
0:58:53an iPad Pro or your phone.
0:58:55I mean, and it's not to diminish those things.
0:58:57Like you, I know you just said it,
0:58:59and I know you're really serious about it,
0:59:00that you do a lot of your work on iPad.
0:59:03I've done more work, more of my writing on a daily basis,
0:59:08and emailing, and a lot of other stuff
0:59:10that I would consider work on my iPad
0:59:12ever since the update in March
0:59:14that added trackpad and support.
0:59:16It's delightful.
0:59:18But I'm not, I know that I'm not pressing it as a computer.
0:59:21Right?
0:59:22And that's really what this is about in a lot of ways.
0:59:26What do you need?
0:59:28Why?
0:59:30Maybe that's it.
0:59:31Why?
0:59:32Why still fight to make the Mac relevant?
0:59:35Why not just make iPads and put the iPad on a laptop
0:59:39and say, "We don't even have to have this other platform.
0:59:42"We could simplify things greatly."
0:59:44I think it's because they see a whole bunch of problems
0:59:47that demand a computing platform
0:59:50that has the most performance that they can get possible.
0:59:54I think that's terribly exciting.
0:59:57- Yeah, it is.
0:59:58And that idea that there was,
1:00:03certainly there's certain Apple applications,
1:00:06especially neural engine work and ML work that,
1:00:10and AR as a current example,
1:00:13that tax iPad hardware, let's say, right?
1:00:17'Cause iPad hardware is currently
1:00:18some of the most powerful you can buy from Apple, right?
1:00:21And that--
1:00:22Right.
1:00:23They're certainly ones that hit the peaks there,
1:00:27that tap against the boundaries of what the iPad does.
1:00:30But the vast majority of what you do on it doesn't.
1:00:32And some of that is related to the tasks, right?
1:00:35You just-- you're not compiling an enormous application
1:00:40with millions of lines of code with a bunch
1:00:43of itinerant frameworks on the iPad Pro
1:00:47that you would normally do on a Mac.
1:00:49And there are certain things that developers do there.
1:00:51There are certain things that graphics professionals do.
1:00:53Obviously, you know, like with the Mac Pro,
1:00:55like I've been playing around with a bunch of 6K streams
1:00:58in Final Cut and things like that.
1:01:00There are certain things that would overtax, you know,
1:01:03would hit the cap of what's going on there.
1:01:06And so when you say,
1:01:09sometimes it could sound hyperbolic
1:01:12that we literally don't know what these machines
1:01:14are actually capable of, that's just true.
1:01:16Like we don't know what an ARM-powered Mac is capable of yet,
1:01:22because they've just never had the same set of constraints.
1:01:26And that's one of the things about owning the hardware, obviously,
1:01:29is that Apple can say, "Hey, these are the constraints that we have for the iPad."
1:01:32Obviously, battery life is an enormous one.
1:01:34It needs to drive this, you know, display.
1:01:38It needs to drive these certain things, and it can--
1:01:41It's essentially never going to be plugged in, you know, while it's being used.
1:01:45of those constraints. And so the laptop thing is more of a known quantity because I think
1:01:52we're going to see, "Hey, what does a laptop version of the iPad Pro look like?" But the
1:01:59desktop aspect of it is going to be fascinating because we've never seen that. Like you mentioned
1:02:04the Mac Pro and my timeline is based on this idea that the Mac Pro architecture as it currently
1:02:11exists was actually designed to support ARM because there's no way that they would have
1:02:17restarted two years ago at the time they restarted and not known that they were doing this.
1:02:23So…
1:02:24Right.
1:02:25And I think that maybe in hindsight, and maybe someday we'll get the story, but maybe if
1:02:32this ARM transition took them a little bit longer than they thought and maybe what they
1:02:36had before didn't last quite as long as they wanted and that maybe part of that whole meeting,
1:02:44you know, with me and you and Ena Fried and, you know, and they more or less pre-announced
1:02:53the iMac Pro and said we're going to make an all-new Mac Pro and maybe that they figured,
1:02:59you know, we do need, we have enough of a gap in between what we already have and where
1:03:03where we want to go with our own silicon,
1:03:08that we need to do something in the interim
1:03:09and have like an awesome Intel-based iMac Pro
1:03:14for TruePro performance, and let's ship the Mac Pro
1:03:18that we have in mind based around Xeon stuff first.
1:03:22But clearly, they built that.
1:03:24I mean, the Mac Pro in particular, I mean,
1:03:27absolutely, positively was built by Ternus's team,
1:03:32knowing what they were doing deeply at a deep technical sense where they're going with their custom silicon
1:03:39Yeah
1:03:41Yeah terribly exciting. Yeah, it's it honestly is really really interesting because this stuff doesn't you know processor roadmaps are known
1:03:48Right because those companies make processors and they got to tell their there. They got to tell the markets what's coming, right?
1:03:55Hey, we got this new things and hopefully people are gonna love them and we're making great stuff and all these technical advances
1:04:01But we kind of know when Intel is shipping three years out, right?
1:04:05Or four years out.
1:04:06And so you kind of--
1:04:07Or when they hope to.
1:04:08Right.
1:04:09Right, exactly.
1:04:10In an ideal world, this is what we'll be shipping.
1:04:13But right now, this is the first time in a long time
1:04:17where the arc under a major computing platform,
1:04:23or the column under which you would fill in these,
1:04:26oh, this is going to use the 9900,
1:04:29and this is going to use the 7200,
1:04:30and this is going to use whatever.
1:04:32It's blank.
1:04:33And we just don't know.
1:04:35And that's exciting.
1:04:37To a processing nerd, it's exciting.
1:04:39But also to anybody who's interested in general purpose
1:04:42computing, I think it's--
1:04:43I thought that the other thing that was a little bit of a hint--
1:04:46and I just think that there's way too many people who
1:04:48were looking at these dev kits with the A12Z
1:04:50and thinking that that's even vaguely what they're
1:04:53talking about shipping.
1:04:55You know, like, oh, well, I guess they'll come out with an A14
1:04:57for the iPhone in September, and then there'll
1:04:59A14M and that's just a slight variant for the Mac.
1:05:03It's like, that's not what they're talking about at all.
1:05:04- No, doesn't feel that way to me.
1:05:06Interesting times.
1:05:09- So what do you wanna talk about before we wrap up?
1:05:11You wanna talk about my show?
1:05:12- Oh, no, I mean, I thought your show went great.
1:05:15I think the WWDC is an interesting topic, though.
1:05:19Just like how the show went.
1:05:20- Oh yeah, how they did it virtually.
1:05:21- I think they did a good job virtually.
1:05:23There's some people saying, hey,
1:05:27they should do this from now on,
1:05:29you know, just like forgo the physical one.
1:05:32- I saw Marco Arment tweeted that.
1:05:34Marco just doesn't wanna leave his beloved beach house.
1:05:37- Yeah, he's off enjoying the warm Atlantic Ocean.
1:05:41Yeah, yeah.
1:05:43- Yeah, you know, I will just say,
1:05:45I have been a guest at Marco's beach house.
1:05:46I can just tell you that Marco at that beach house is,
1:05:49he's like plugged into the matrix.
1:05:52And like, it's like,
1:05:55The dopamine coming into his brain is just,
1:05:58he really loves it there. - Living his best life.
1:05:59- It is paradise for him.
1:06:01He just, yeah, he just does not wanna leave.
1:06:03It's like June is beach time for Marco Orman.
1:06:07- Yeah. - You know what I mean?
1:06:08Like if WWDC's traditional month was January.
1:06:12- He'd be out, he's like, "Let's go."
1:06:13- You know when Knack World was?
1:06:14He wouldn't, yeah, he'd be like, "Let's go, let's get--"
1:06:17- Yeah, 'cause it's gonna be 72 in January in the Bay.
1:06:21So. (laughs)
1:06:23- Yeah. - Yeah.
1:06:24I do wonder.
1:06:25I wonder.
1:06:27I don't think it's off the table
1:06:29that this might permanently change WWDC in some way.
1:06:33Certainly they'll still have the media for a keynote.
1:06:38I still think that they like it.
1:06:43I think they like the face-to-face WWDC.
1:06:47Will this change how they do the presentations?
1:06:50The other thing that is compelling
1:06:52is a lot of, some developers are saying,
1:06:55"I like these presentations better,"
1:06:57because presenting directly for a camera
1:07:01is giving these presentations a more intimate
1:07:05and direct feeling than a presentation
1:07:08that was meant to be delivered on a stage
1:07:10in a convention room.
1:07:12- Yeah, and honestly, I thought that the format
1:07:15did a few things for me that I thought were very positive.
1:07:18One, the presenters got their time to shine.
1:07:22These are people that have worked on these projects.
1:07:24They'd have worked for years sometimes
1:07:28without ever talking about it once to anybody
1:07:30on these things.
1:07:31And they got a chance to--
1:07:33the presentations on the stage are great and fine
1:07:35and all of that.
1:07:36And I know the videotaped versions of those are fine.
1:07:38But those presentations are often extremely slide heavy.
1:07:42And the presenter is de-emphasized,
1:07:45for lack of a better term.
1:07:46And in these, the presenter is definitely
1:07:48right up there in the front.
1:07:49You get to see so many really interesting, cool people present projects they've worked
1:07:53on for a really hell of a long time at Apple, as I mentioned, sometimes in complete obscurity
1:07:57or secrecy for years.
1:08:00I think that was really fun.
1:08:01That was really cool.
1:08:02Their passion definitely showed, and I thought the presentations were more engaging for it.
1:08:08And then for me, the other big thing that's positive out of this, and hell, I'm going
1:08:13to ask Apple.
1:08:14I don't know if they'll ever share how much data they have, but I tweeted that I'd bet
1:08:19anything that this is the most inclusive audience for WW that they've ever had.
1:08:25Because I know that Apple has gone through an extensive amount of efforts to try to get
1:08:29students, developers of color, black developers, Latinx developers, LGBTQ developers to the
1:08:37show physically, to take part in the show, to make sure that they are creating a welcoming
1:08:44environment.
1:08:45But there's only so much you can do.
1:08:46And the show sometimes just feels homogenous. A lot of white dudes, you know?
1:08:50Yeah. Well, and yeah, the biggest thing in literally 50/50 demographically in the world
1:08:57is women and men and gender and LGBTQ. But just, you know, yeah, lots of white dudes.
1:09:05And I'd imagine that people sort of quote unquote "participating" in this live week.
1:09:11Sure, the videos are eventually available to everybody.
1:09:15We've known that for a long time, or for some time now that they've been doing that.
1:09:20But I think in this live, everybody's talking and interacting with one another, largely
1:09:26using Twitter, to be honest, as a medium to share clips of—and you notice that there's
1:09:31tons of clips of presentations now, whereas there used to be a chilling effect on that.
1:09:36They're like, "Oh, don't share a lot of these, please."
1:09:39That was like the general gist.
1:09:42Don't share video recordings of the presentations.
1:09:45Well, they don't.
1:09:46There's a ton on Twitter now.
1:09:48And I think they're really cool.
1:09:49A lot of them show off really neat features.
1:09:51And a lot of the discussion around them, if you look at them, there's a very diverse
1:09:55set of developers taking part in this sort of live discovery of these features and conversations
1:10:02about them that they just don't get if they watch the video a week or two later and all
1:10:07All of the initial chatter about them has maybe died down or whatever.
1:10:11I just think that there's a very interesting thing that happened here that would never
1:10:15have happened because the in-person scenario is largely lottery-based, which doesn't sort
1:10:22of allow for any intentionality in the mix, right?
1:10:30Whereas this is just the opposite of that where it's everybody.
1:10:34So by nature, you're going to get a more inclusive environment.
1:10:37I thought that was really cool.
1:10:39I've certainly, for a long time, I've wished, even as I attended the shows, it's like,
1:10:43man, I wish this group was more inclusive across the board because it frankly gets boring
1:10:50when it's the same people.
1:10:51You know?
1:10:52So I thought that was cool.
1:10:54There's a simple cost factor too, right?
1:10:57I mean, above and beyond the lottery and getting lucky to go is that airfare and a hotel or
1:11:04an Airbnb or whatever.
1:11:07Just putting a roof over your head and eating and getting around.
1:11:10Yeah, and a lot of developers are going to self-select out of that because they're like,
1:11:13"Hey, I've got a family.
1:11:14I've got a job and I've got all this stuff."
1:11:16So, it opens it up to them too.
1:11:18Right.
1:11:19And it's just the schedule is a factor on the student landscape where there's an awful
1:11:23lot of students who maybe could go, would go, would try to go, even though it's limited
1:11:28space and can't because they're taking final exams in the second week of June or something
1:11:33like that, especially high school type students. I know college is usually done by June, but
1:11:39a lot of high schools are still going. And now they're full-fledged, a 17-year-old teenage
1:11:47developer is on equal footing for consuming WWDC with the middle-aged professional who's
1:11:56been going for 15, 20 years.
1:11:59It is absolutely diversifying in several senses of the word.
1:12:05I also think it's really interesting, very Apple, not surprising to me, but definitely
1:12:09surprised some people in that Apple used this as an opportunity to up their production values,
1:12:16lower their production values. Oh, it's coronavirus time, people in quarantine, you know, our
1:12:22presentations won't be as polished. The average presentation level, you know, production quality
1:12:29wise is way up. That to me is the thing that seems hard. Like, I don't think Apple's as
1:12:36concerned about the cost of putting on the massive convention because again, I don't
1:12:41know if you know this, but Apple has a fair amount of money.
1:12:44I was aware. I was aware.
1:12:46Again, I'm not the one writing the check,
1:12:50you know, but I, you know, I know how much less I paid to produce my show this year by not
1:12:57renting out the California theater for one night, and it's a lot of zeros by my standards.
1:13:03But I just think that the one thing about this year's show that to me would
1:13:11make apples catch apples institutional I
1:13:14As to hmm. This would be hard to go back on is production quality production quality is
1:13:22Defines Apple in every way right like they they make the nicest watch bands, right?
1:13:28You know what? I mean? They're their videos are supposed to be high production quality
1:13:34You know, the keynote had was high production value quality from start to finish and was fascinating
1:13:40Did you notice, by the way, the safety disclosures at the end? Did you watch it? I thought that was
1:13:45really cool. I'm going to totally steal that. So if anybody from Apple listens to this,
1:13:48I'm ganking it. But we're doing our virtual events this year. And it was inspiring to us to see,
1:13:54like, hey, because we're going through all the same planning. We want to make sure that we pull
1:13:57off our events safely. Even though they're virtual, there will be contact among production
1:14:01members. And we want to make sure that's handled carefully. I thought that was a really cool touch.
1:14:05Right. And I just, I really do, in a way that it just seems like they can deliver a production
1:14:14quality of these session videos when they're delivered personally and staged entirely in a
1:14:22way that is only meant to be delivered on video that simply cannot be done for something delivered
1:14:27on stage to an audience of a few hundred people in a room. And I don't know how they go back on
1:14:33that so I don't know I don't know what they do it also doesn't make sense to
1:14:38just have a 5,000 person keynote and then say okay the rest of the week is
1:14:42virtual yeah I agree I mean I don't I don't know what the exact path forward
1:14:48is but I don't think a hybrid approach is out of the question for sure
1:14:53yeah what did you think I wasn't sure I guess if I something I I wasn't I I
1:15:01I hadn't rewatched the keynote yet when I did my interview with Jaws and and Federighi
1:15:06and then I rewatched part of it and I kind of think parts of it weren't real.
1:15:12I think that there was, you know, there were special effects in there.
1:15:15Like I'm not entirely sure Craig Federighi was in the Steve Jobs theater for everything
1:15:20where it looked like he was in the atrium, you know, and I'm not even sure that the screen
1:15:24behind him was real.
1:15:25It was, it's, but it was convincing if it wasn't real
1:15:29and if it was real, it was done in a way
1:15:32that was so polished that it almost didn't look real?
1:15:35I don't know.
1:15:36(laughing)
1:15:37- Yeah, I mean, it could have just been touch up,
1:15:40you know, visual touch up that kind of gave it that look.
1:15:43Certainly, they chose a look for it that,
1:15:48I guess you would call like new Apple video.
1:15:50You know, it's certainly a little bit overexposed,
1:15:53a little bit more contrast, graded that way.
1:15:57Although it would be fun to like,
1:15:59maybe engage somebody who does visual work
1:16:05to kind of run down an examination of the keynote
1:16:10and be like, oh, they definitely did this here, that there.
1:16:13We know some people who might be down for that.
1:16:17- I was talking to my friend Adam Lisagor
1:16:19at Sandwich Video 'cause they did the editing for my show
1:16:21And we were so busy with my show that we didn't really have a lot of time.
1:16:24He was just like--
1:16:25I was like, what do you think?
1:16:26And he was like, it's interesting.
1:16:28[LAUGHTER]
1:16:32But I do think--
1:16:32I think it was a success.
1:16:34I really do.
1:16:34I think it was compelling.
1:16:35I think it was appley.
1:16:36I think it was on brand and for Apple and engaging for people who watched
1:16:42and very enjoyable.
1:16:45And I just don't know where the line stopped between real drone shots of Apple
1:16:49Park and what was virtual.
1:16:51I mean, all to their credit,
1:16:53where the special effects were like, I don't know.
1:16:56I'm pretty sure a camera didn't really pass
1:16:59through the ceiling, but it sure looked like it did.
1:17:01- Yeah, exactly.
1:17:02A little Hitchcock situation going on there.
1:17:04I think they definitely used an FPV drone for some of it,
1:17:10which is a trend I've been following more.
1:17:12You're gonna see this more and more.
1:17:13I think you're gonna even see it in action films.
1:17:15There's already been some action films that have used drones,
1:17:17but specifically racing drones,
1:17:20which is these drones that are capable
1:17:22of these incredibly tight turns,
1:17:24indoor to outdoor transitions,
1:17:26moving through super small spaces and all of this stuff.
1:17:30But you could tell it was also combined
1:17:31with some crane work and some visual effects, for sure.
1:17:35But I thought it was pretty nicely done,
1:17:37given that they pulled it together
1:17:39in essentially a couple of months.
1:17:40- Yeah, yeah, at least,
1:17:44I don't know when the hay maybe really occurred
1:17:48to the WWDC planning crew, but certainly, you know,
1:17:52March, you know, stuff got real, but--
1:17:56- I think you'd be correct to assume
1:17:58it'd be in March sometime, yeah.
1:18:00- Yeah, you know, that's a lot to pull together.
1:18:03It would've been an impressive thing
1:18:04if they had decided a year ago
1:18:06that this was gonna be entirely virtual.
1:18:07I think for something that they pulled together,
1:18:10you know, in three months was really, really,
1:18:12hats off, you know, and budget be damned.
1:18:15It's just hard to do in a compressed period of time,
1:18:18no matter what your budget.
1:18:19- Yeah, so it's sometime, right.
1:18:21At some point, the money is not really the factor at all.
1:18:23It's like, can you pull it off in that group of time?
1:18:26And remember, too, that it's not just the keynote
1:18:28and the splashiness of that,
1:18:29and then presenting stuff online.
1:18:31A lot of those things they had already had in place.
1:18:33You know, obviously, the new developer portals
1:18:36and updates to all of that stuff was in place.
1:18:38But it's also all of the sessions with everybody
1:18:40that they would normally do on stage,
1:18:42you know, recording all of those individually.
1:18:45I love that everybody had their individual desk pets.
1:18:47They got to pick their own desk pets, it seems like, which was fun.
1:18:54Yeah.
1:18:55Well, anyway, thank you very much.
1:18:57Good to talk to you.
1:18:58Wish I would have seen you this week.
1:19:00It seems weird that I haven't, but someday.
1:19:03Yeah, I do miss having some questionable cuisine and pretty decent beers.
1:19:10(laughing)
1:19:13Lots of fried foods in WWDC week.
1:19:16Lots of fried foods.
1:19:16- Should we eat half of our body weight in prime rib?
1:19:19Sure, why not?
1:19:21- Yeah.
1:19:22(laughing)
1:19:23Oh yeah, it's not even, it's not even, yeah, I know.
1:19:26I was wondering why I didn't have the meat sweats.
1:19:29I was like, something's missing.
1:19:30(laughing)
1:19:32- Good talking to you.
1:19:37All right.
1:19:37- Well, we'll toast to the house of prime rib
1:19:39next year, hopefully.