Podcast Search

The Talk Show

289: ‘I’m Batman. America. Freedom.’ With Adam Lisagor

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Welcome to the show.

0:00:01I can't believe how long it's been since I've had you on the show.

0:00:05It's been a bit. Yeah.

0:00:06You're you're I mean this sincerely, and I don't mean, I'm not just saying this

0:00:12because you're on the show. You you're one of the nicest and most empathetic,

0:00:17um, people I've ever met. You're, you're truly,

0:00:21you're just a good person. And you, the way you brought,

0:00:24the way you brought this up to me,

0:00:26was excruciating.

0:00:31Yeah, it was hard for me too.

0:00:34So we're working together on my show, my WWDC show.

0:00:40And then you mentioned this and I was, you know, something to the,

0:00:43I can't even do it. I can't even be as exquisitely nice and sensitive as you.

0:00:49I can't even paraphrase it, but you mentioned it. And I thought, well, that's,

0:00:52you know, probably is true in the back of my head.

0:00:55I'll bet it's been at least a year since I've had Adam on.

0:00:57And then I looked at my podcast feed and then like searched for your name.

0:01:02And it was like 13 years ago.

0:01:05Yeah. And you know, you start to wonder, like I start to wonder, wow. Uh, did I,

0:01:12did you get some, did you get some complaints about me as a guest? I mean,

0:01:16that was my, that was the way I phrased the question I think was like, Hey,

0:01:20cause I love being on your show.

0:01:22I love doing this type of format way,

0:01:25way more than one in which I have to improvise and be funny because I'm not

0:01:29great at that. But I like,

0:01:30I don't mind talking about things that I'm thinking about. So I like doing,

0:01:34I like being a guest and have been a guest a number of times. And then,

0:01:38and then it has, it's been a while. So I started thinking, Oh God did. Um,

0:01:42cause you have a, a vocal, you know, fan base listenership. And I wondered if they,

0:01:47if they just like wrote you one too many emails that said, do not,

0:01:51do not have that guy back on your show again.

0:01:53Well, and then the worst part is,

0:01:55cause I'm nowhere near as good a person as you or as empathetic,

0:02:00but I remember things and I have a terrible, uh, uh,

0:02:05Catholic guilt, even though I'm not the least bit religious, it's like, I did.

0:02:09That's the one thing I picked up. And I remember from years ago,

0:02:14literally no joke years ago,

0:02:16there was a time when you were on the show and I just,

0:02:21I purely absentmindedly forgot to do the thing where I post a link to the show on

0:02:26the daring fireball blog.

0:02:28So like the show went into the talk show feed and it's on the talk show section

0:02:33of the site and anybody who subscribed goes in their podcast player.

0:02:36But I just never did the thing which I do for every new show,

0:02:39which is then I post a link list item to the show and I repeat the description

0:02:44and thank the sponsors to, you know, give them some extra love. Uh,

0:02:49and I just, you know, idiot that I am completely forgot to do it.

0:02:53And you thought maybe it was cause I thought the show sucked.

0:02:57Oh man. Do you remember that's embarrassing. That's embarrassing.

0:03:01But you didn't say it that way, of course, because you're a good person,

0:03:05but I could read between the lines and thought, Oh God,

0:03:08Adam's worried that I thought the show was terrible that I had to post it

0:03:12anyway. When in fact it was just me being an idiot and having this terrible

0:03:16system, me being self aware that I'm absentminded

0:03:21and then having a production system for posting the show that depends upon me

0:03:26remembering to do X, Y, and Z.

0:03:29You know what? We're both great. We're both flawed and great.

0:03:33And this is going to be a fun show. There was one,

0:03:37there was one episode that we'd,

0:03:39that I was a guest on where I remember I did zero prep for it.

0:03:43I didn't read up on the latest stuff. I, I, I,

0:03:46I'd been sort of out of the Apple loop for a bit and

0:03:51then we just, and then I just kind of bullshit for like, you know,

0:03:55an hour and a half.

0:03:55I think we talked about the latest Apple TV or something and it was just,

0:03:59didn't feel great about it. So I, I've like, I should actually do some,

0:04:04you know, I do some research this time,

0:04:07potentially install the beta OS and break my laptop

0:04:11just so I have something to talk about.

0:04:16Uh, well, speaking of sponsors and speaking of, uh,

0:04:20you, Adam, I, I got a, uh, extra sponsor this week.

0:04:25Um, and I'm really happy to tell you about them, but it's ATOMS, A T O M S.

0:04:31They're, uh, yeah, they make great shoes, uh,

0:04:36which is very funny because ever since they started sponsoring the show last

0:04:39year, remember when we used to meet face to face, uh,

0:04:43at WWDC last year, just 2019,

0:04:47I saw a bunch of people at WWDC who had Adam's shoes on and I was like, wow,

0:04:52they're really popular. And then like,

0:04:54I worked up the gumption to ask somebody and they're like, yeah, I got them.

0:04:56I heard about them from your website and I was, Oh, I'm at WWDC.

0:05:01Somehow I kind of know that sponsorships work,

0:05:07but I don't often see the results of it. You know,

0:05:10like somebody can advertise an app on daring fireball. I don't know who's,

0:05:13who's running the app, but people had the shoes. They're great shoes.

0:05:16I wear them almost every day. I love them.

0:05:18But the other thing they're making out,

0:05:20I want to tell you about is the Adam's everyday face mask. Look,

0:05:24Adam stands for quality.

0:05:26Their mask is made with the same premium materials as their shoes,

0:05:30combining innovation and comfort with the anti microbial properties of

0:05:35copper, making it one of the most effective masks on the market.

0:05:38It's available in a variety of colors. It's breathable, washable,

0:05:42reusable, and every time you buy a mask,

0:05:46they donate a mask to charity with each purchase.

0:05:49They've also got the sneaker. You can check them out. Great.

0:05:53The genius of their thing is that they, they sell the sneakers in quarter size,

0:05:58which sounds really finicky, but I'm telling you,

0:06:01I've known this since I was a kid, always felt very self-conscious about it.

0:06:05My left foot has always been a half size larger than my right foot.

0:06:08I don't know why I feel so conscious about it.

0:06:12But it's kind of awesome to be able to buy shoes where you can do this.

0:06:17And then you don't know what your quarter size is. You can just buy like,

0:06:20you know, order, like it's like Warby Parker a little bit,

0:06:22where you can order two sizes,

0:06:24try them on at home and then send the ones back that you don't need the sizes

0:06:28you don't want. Anyway, I love their masks.

0:06:30The masks also come in different sizes. I have a big fat head.

0:06:34I need the size large. Most people would take a medium.

0:06:37Anytime I'm out and about in Philadelphia,

0:06:40I'm almost certainly wearing my Adams mask. I really do like it.

0:06:43Go to Adams,

0:06:45atoms.com/dfm,

0:06:46daring fireball mask,

0:06:50DFM,

0:06:51adams.com/dfm.

0:06:52Check them out.

0:06:54Is, is it the ear loop style of mask?

0:06:57It is an ear loop style of mask. It's sort of two pieces of,

0:07:01it's not cotton. It's a sort of a foamy type thing,

0:07:06sort of like the insert to a shoe and then stitch together in the middle.

0:07:11So you get a little bit of a conical effect in front of your mouth,

0:07:14which to me is key for me personally, with a mask key,

0:07:18get a little bit away from my mouth, your loop style around the, around the,

0:07:21around the ears.

0:07:23Well, that makes sense. Cause their shoes have those stretchy laces so that you,

0:07:27you would, you would expect them to innovate and they in the loop,

0:07:30manufacturer. I,

0:07:34I think that's the thing that makes a mask most comfortable for me is the,

0:07:38you know,

0:07:38when there was a shortage of masks and nobody really knew how to get go out and

0:07:42get a mask and you just kind of like grabbed what was available.

0:07:46It was like the first ones that I tried on on my big fat head as well would pull

0:07:51my ears forward and they were uncomfortable and it really sucked.

0:07:54And I thought that this is not sustainable.

0:07:56But then as soon as I found a mask with the right material on the loops,

0:07:59you know, it was, it was game over. These days I've been doing a,

0:08:03like more of a neck Gator style, the ones that, you know,

0:08:06the tube that you pull over your whole thing. Cause I feel,

0:08:08I feel like it's a kind of a cool look, you know?

0:08:11Well, it's, you know, as we,

0:08:15as we go on and without even delving into the political

0:08:19aspects of it, if we're just going to all wear masks, our faces are,

0:08:23you know,

0:08:25they vary in size and we all wear different shoes because we like different

0:08:29styles and we have different feet that feel comfortable and different shoes.

0:08:33It's no surprise that we need different masks.

0:08:35And so I've found it to be fascinating here in the Gruber household,

0:08:39what the various members find more comfortable.

0:08:43I do. I re you know, and you know, you can't, in some ways you can't beat those paper ones,

0:08:49you know, that is just the like, but they're hard to get there.

0:08:51They're still hard to get and they're not, you know, N95 medical, you know,

0:08:55they're just, you know, the ones that look like the light blue surgical ones,

0:08:59right? Come in a box of 12. Yeah. They're pretty good for the heat.

0:09:02Amy likes those now that it's, you know,

0:09:04literally like heat index is like a hundred degrees, 98 degrees today. Uh,

0:09:08pretty hot. Anyway, masks. I like those.

0:09:12I like those a bandana type things. That's what you're talking about.

0:09:15Like you put the tube over your head.

0:09:17Yeah. You pull it down. There's fun colors. Um, I don't know.

0:09:22I got one with a galaxy kind of a pattern on it, sort of like the early, um,

0:09:26you know, Mac OS wallpaper, you know, you remember the, like sort of like,

0:09:31Oh yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I got one with that sort of thing. I wasn't,

0:09:35it wasn't like an homage to the Mac desktop or anything,

0:09:38but I just kind of liked it. It was on Amazon for like $11. And I, uh,

0:09:42put it on and, uh, Roxanne on my partner said, Oh,

0:09:46Ooh, no, no, no, no, no, no. But they wore it anyway. Whatever

0:09:50important thing is that I feel good. Right? Yeah, exactly.

0:09:56Um,

0:10:00I do think it's interesting. I think it's kind of interesting when you go out,

0:10:03like I just saw a survey, um,

0:10:06that Philadelphia, I don't know who knows these, these surveys. I always,

0:10:10you know, I don't know how they conduct them. I don't think it's the, you know,

0:10:13the rigorous people at Gallup, but there was some kind of survey of, um,

0:10:17what percentage of people in each city around the country are wearing masks and

0:10:23Philadelphia was like at the top or near the top. Um,

0:10:26but it's like the old analogy about Pennsylvania, um,

0:10:30which I'll never forget. And which is very true,

0:10:33which is that Pennsylvania is sort of a microcosm of the United States where you

0:10:37got Philadelphia on the one coast, Pittsburgh on the other,

0:10:40and Alabama in the middle. Um,

0:10:43like the Pennsylvania state capital Harrisburg, which is, you know, again,

0:10:47picked to be the capital, I guess, cause it's in the middle.

0:10:49It has like one of the lowest rates of mask wearing in the country. But anyway,

0:10:53you go out for a walk in Philadelphia, you, you really do.

0:10:56It's really rare not to see some, see somebody not wearing a mask now.

0:11:00And if they're not there, you know,

0:11:03they usually it's like around their chin or something like that.

0:11:05And they're just taking it off in the heat. And then when, as people come by,

0:11:09they lift it up. Uh, it's interesting to me,

0:11:12cause it's same thing as like, I look at people's phones when I'm in airports,

0:11:15remember airports.

0:11:16I like to see what people pick for their mask and it is sort of like

0:11:22phone cases. You know, people it's it, you,

0:11:24you could go all day and you might not see the same mask twice.

0:11:28That's right. It's a style choice that no,

0:11:31but he expected that we would be making.

0:11:33It's a combination style choice and comfort choice. Right.

0:11:37And you can kind of,

0:11:38if you're a nerd like me and you just preoccupy yourself thinking about stuff

0:11:42like that,

0:11:42and then almost get hit by a bus crossing the street cause you're looking at

0:11:46people's masks. Um, you, I like to play the game. I did,

0:11:50did that fellow pick that mask cause he thinks it's comfortable or did he,

0:11:53did he pick it cause the way it looks or a little bit of column a little bit of

0:11:57column B. Um, yeah, yeah. I think it's, yeah, you're right.

0:12:02It's a little bit of both. It's a mix, but I, but I always, you know, you, we,

0:12:06we universally appreciate it seeing, seeing it on each other. Cause sometimes,

0:12:11you know, we have our preconceptions about people and you know,

0:12:15just from whatever, from their, their other style choices or, you know,

0:12:19whatever it's, we, we sort of formed these biases.

0:12:23But so when you see somebody that you would, maybe you, you would think, Oh,

0:12:28that person

0:12:29looks a little bit more like somebody in the,

0:12:33in the places where they wouldn't wear masks and they are wearing a mask and

0:12:37you're like, yeah, yes, one love. We are all, we are all the same. And,

0:12:42and that I, I just appreciate it. I think it's great.

0:12:45So it's like a good signifier that we're, you know, we're in this together.

0:12:50Yeah. I, and it was more of a thing weeks ago, months ago,

0:12:54who knows in this time,

0:12:55but like when it was a sort of a non

0:13:00majority of people out, although at that time it was also more, you know,

0:13:05here in Philadelphia, it was a lot more like, Hey,

0:13:07you should really only be going out for like emergency rations, uh,

0:13:12rations, rations. I've, how do you say rations? Yeah. Yeah, whatever. I guess.

0:13:17Um, but you would, you'd see people with a mask and then you just give them the,

0:13:21not, you know, it's like, yeah, team mask. Yeah. Yeah. Good stuff.

0:13:26I remember, I don't know if you,

0:13:27if you recall the first person out there in the world that you saw wearing a

0:13:32mask, but it was striking. Um, yeah. Cause I've, I've been to Japan,

0:13:35I've been to places where it's, it's just normal practice. If you're,

0:13:40if you have a cold or something,

0:13:41you wear a mask to protect other people from your germs. But, um,

0:13:46really had never seen somebody out on the street.

0:13:48And I was in the neighborhood where my office is in downtown and I saw

0:13:53somebody, a very stylish young person. Um,

0:13:56I was driving and I saw them walking and they had a mask on. And if,

0:14:01if for like that very brief moment, it felt like, Oh,

0:14:04this is a glimpse into the future. It felt sci-fi in that way. And I also,

0:14:09I had a reaction that was like, Oh, that's overkill.

0:14:11Because at the time we were hearing, you know, you don't need to wear a mask.

0:14:15It's, uh, you know, wash your hands for 20 minutes and then take care of it.

0:14:19I remember the first people I saw wearing a mask here.

0:14:22I forget exactly where it was, you know,

0:14:26late March or early April. I forget in that timeframe, but I was out.

0:14:30I remember exactly where I was, uh, around the corner.

0:14:34I don't remember which errand I was running, probably going to Trader Joe's,

0:14:37but, um,

0:14:38I saw two people walking and they

0:14:44were both young, younger than me. Anybody younger than me is now young.

0:14:48Uh, they were both young,

0:14:51they were both Asian and they both had masks on. And

0:14:56I, I just, I guess I've seen it before, you know, and, you know, again,

0:15:02it's, it, everybody knows it's common in a lot of Asian countries. Um,

0:15:07I've seen it in Philadelphia before,

0:15:10but this was definitely in the context of COVID-19 and I thought,

0:15:15do they think they have it? Did I just walk by two people who,

0:15:18who think they have it or they, you know, what is, you know, and I wasn't,

0:15:23you know, like running away from them or anything. It just,

0:15:25but it was very striking to me, right? It just was like, what, what was that?

0:15:30That was very strange. I just haven't seen people wearing masks.

0:15:33And like you said at the time here in the U S every, the experts were all saying,

0:15:38you know, ah, you don't need a mask. In fact,

0:15:40you shouldn't be buying masks. Let them, you know,

0:15:42keep them for the healthcare workers.

0:15:43Right. Which, which seems like it was, it was, it caused a huge,

0:15:48huge setback and even, you know,

0:15:50probably feeling the residuals in the culture war right now.

0:15:54I wonder if they had just come out at the beginning and said,

0:15:56masks are the thing that will, you know, do the most to protect you from this,

0:16:01whether we'd still be seeing all the pushback.

0:16:04Yeah, I think I, I don't know.

0:16:06You had a tweet a while a couple of weeks ago, a week or two ago,

0:16:09where you were talking about masks and, and again,

0:16:12good empathetic person that you are, you were observing that look it,

0:16:16when you first see it and you're not used to it,

0:16:18it is weird to see people with their faces covered and we're, we're,

0:16:22it's not even a cultural thing.

0:16:25It's clearly an evolutionary thing that we've evolved to see

0:16:29people's faces and read their faces.

0:16:32And we are finally attuned.

0:16:35Our brains are finally attuned to noticing incredibly small differences

0:16:40in people's faces to detect their emotion and to identify the

0:16:45people we know, and especially the people we love.

0:16:48Um, and so not seeing people's faces is striking and

0:16:53weird in both the sociological way and just

0:16:57evolutionary way.

0:16:59And it is from the first person perspective,

0:17:03it is weird to put one on and go out in public.

0:17:06Uh, it's just a very strange physical sensation and it is

0:17:11very, it makes you self-conscious.

0:17:13Yeah, it makes you self-conscious. That's right.

0:17:16It's it's like putting on a hat that you're not sure is like,

0:17:19you're the right fit or the right shape for you, but it makes you, you know,

0:17:23you're sort of testing it out, um, as a style choice, but you're worried,

0:17:27you know, you maybe this, maybe people think I look dumb and that,

0:17:31that's just kind of like a normal thought process that all of us kind of go for,

0:17:35go through, but you sort of weigh that against the benefits of wearing one

0:17:39and the safety, and you sort of have to discard all that in it.

0:17:44And it feels like there might be some element in the decision-making of

0:17:49whether or not to wear, you know, whether wear one or not, um, that,

0:17:53where people's sort of self-imposed shame about their,

0:17:57this choice or their, the look might say more to them than,

0:18:02you know, the,

0:18:03the very simple calculation of whether it's going to be safe,

0:18:08safer for them and for other people.

0:18:10Uh, yeah, I think that that's very true and it's, you know,

0:18:15so for me, I am not a, uh,

0:18:20dressed up in a costume person. Yeah. I don't, I,

0:18:25it's been a very long time since I've like, I don't dress up for Halloween.

0:18:29I didn't dress up for Halloween when my son was young. Um,

0:18:32but I pass no judgment when I was younger. I would have, I was a jerk.

0:18:36I'll admit it. Uh, but I pass no judgment and, and I,

0:18:41I in the course of becoming older and far more open-minded in

0:18:46many, many ways,

0:18:47but almost entirely reducible in all regards

0:18:53to the concept of, Hey man, whatever floats your boat, right?

0:18:57It's all cool with me. Um, you know,

0:19:00like people who like to go to comic con and, and dress up as a superheroes.

0:19:05Did you see the thing, by the way, where John Lewis went comic con?

0:19:09I didn't know this until he died a couple of days ago.

0:19:11John Lewis went to comic con a couple of years ago cause he had,

0:19:14he had co-authored or he wrote, he wrote a graphic novel,

0:19:18um, wrote the script for a graphic novel depicting, you know,

0:19:22some of his actions in the, back in the sixties and the civil rights era.

0:19:26And then he went to comic con to promote it and dressed as his self,

0:19:30his younger self from like 1961,

0:19:32which is like the baddest thing I've ever heard in my life. But anyway,

0:19:38not really a costume where I feel self-conscious about things like that.

0:19:42So let's just say for example,

0:19:43somebody who's having a retirement party or something like that,

0:19:47and it's a surprise party and you get there and you know,

0:19:50an hour before because you know, it's a surprise and the host says, Hey,

0:19:54everybody's going to wear this hat. And it's like, you know, like a,

0:19:57like a novelty hat and we want everybody to wear one. Well,

0:20:00I would put it on because I don't want to be, you know what I mean?

0:20:03I'm going to go with the flow, but I would think like,

0:20:05do I look like in the back of my head would be the idea of,

0:20:08do I look like a jerk with this hat on? And I would think I probably do.

0:20:12Cause I look around and sort of think that maybe everybody else looks a little

0:20:16bit like a jerk with their hats on.

0:20:18And it would make me feel self-conscious and then I would get, you know,

0:20:22I'd get over it. Uh, uh, I think it's, it's, it's certainly,

0:20:26the mask thing is certainly exacerbated because again,

0:20:30your face is you, right? This is how we, you know,

0:20:34we identify each other. It is, it is our personality. It's,

0:20:38it's how everybody with vision, you know,

0:20:42can identify people covering up your face is, you know,

0:20:47it's a lot different than putting on a novelty hat and it is a constant

0:20:51reminder. This is not a retirement surprise party.

0:20:54This is a pandemic that is making people terribly ill,

0:20:59filling hospital ICUs and killing a hundred, you know,

0:21:03hundreds of thousands of people around the world.

0:21:05So you got to do it. Yeah. So, but it's like a weird thing to be reminded of,

0:21:10right? And so you get all the self-consciousness of a novelty mask with

0:21:15combined with the stress and anxiety of the,

0:21:19it's just, could not be a more prominent reminder that we're in a pandemic.

0:21:24Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's, it,

0:21:27it doesn't feel awesome losing all that real estate on your face with, you know,

0:21:31that you use to express yourself and then interpret other people's expression.

0:21:36It's like very, sorry for the ham-fisted, uh, analogy, but it's you,

0:21:40your face is UI, right? Right. Um,

0:21:43so it's kinda like, you know,

0:21:45designing something with only two thirds of the available,

0:21:49you know, screen real estate. You're just conveying far less information.

0:21:55I just, last week I shot of, um,

0:21:58like one of my commercial video things.

0:22:02And the product was specifically for, um,

0:22:07restaurants to be able to do contactless menus and contactless

0:22:11payments really fluidly. Um, and, but,

0:22:15but because the setting and the context of the story is in an open air

0:22:18restaurant where it's very, um, important to be wearing,

0:22:23you know, masks, then all of our talent, including myself, I was in this one,

0:22:27had our masks on for, for most of it. And, uh, as a director,

0:22:31when you don't have the full face available to you to convey all of the,

0:22:35all of the information that you need an actor to convey,

0:22:39it's really a different thing. It's really hard. You have to do,

0:22:41so much more with the eyes, obviously, um, so much more with the lens, you know,

0:22:46just get in there. Um, and, uh, but I mean,

0:22:49unfortunately it's something that we're,

0:22:51we're all getting more accustomed to or sort of like learning to draw more

0:22:54information out from that limited real estate.

0:22:57Yeah. It's sort of like the opposite of directing a Batman movie, right?

0:23:00Cause Batman,

0:23:01Batman's cowl leaves open exactly the surface area

0:23:06that we need to cover. Yeah, that's right. That's right.

0:23:10That's what the assholes who don't wear masks should be wearing.

0:23:13They should just put it in. I like a fake, you know,

0:23:15an upper face mask on just like lean all the way into it. I'll bet, man,

0:23:20America freedom.

0:23:22We could get into that. Um, but why don't before we do, uh,

0:23:33why don't I move on and, uh,

0:23:36keep the business flowing and thank our next sponsor. It's our good old friends.

0:23:40It's Squarespace. Hey, you've got time on your hands.

0:23:44We all have time on our hands. You're inside this summer at one of your lists.

0:23:47You know, they always remind me around new years. You know,

0:23:50that's when people dig into like long forgotten projects, uh,

0:23:54uh, resolutions. We call them, you know,

0:23:57resolutions are things you decide to do in early January and then never do. Uh,

0:24:02maybe dig out that list. Now that we're home for the summer,

0:24:04think about something like a website you've been hoping to make something you've

0:24:08been wanting to build,

0:24:08or maybe an old website you've got that really needs to be upgraded.

0:24:12You want to do it all over again. Why don't you check out Squarespace to do it?

0:24:16They've got everything,

0:24:18everything from registering domains to picking templates for a design

0:24:23to the WYSIWYG visual,

0:24:25just drag it around the screen and what you see while you're designing the

0:24:30site as the owner of the Squarespace website is literally exactly what visitors

0:24:35to your website will see minus the editing controls for dragging this stuff

0:24:42around. Really could not be more WYSIWYG,

0:24:45which is a term that for some reason we don't talk about anymore,

0:24:48but it really is everything you can do at Squarespace and they have a free

0:24:53trial so you can just dig in. You get like 30 days,

0:24:58do what you want. It's real. It's all real. Everybody can visit.

0:25:02You can see that you like it and you don't have to pay a dime.

0:25:05And then when you do, you just remember the code.

0:25:09Go to squarespace.com/talkshow and just remember that same code.

0:25:13Talk show T A L K S H O W. You get 10% off your first purchase.

0:25:17Squarespace.com/talk show. Remember that code talk show.

0:25:21You kind of got to remember the code cause you can go there, sign up,

0:25:24use it for 30 days and then only then do you have to pay.

0:25:27Just remember that code. You could save 10%. You've got your month in there.

0:25:31If you already know you like it, why not sign up for a year? Use that code.

0:25:34Save 10% off our whole year. There you go. Save money. You get a great,

0:25:38great service. You don't have to worry about stuff like systems upgrades,

0:25:42what operating system is running. Forget it.

0:25:45Squarespace takes care of all that.

0:25:46So go check them out next time you need to build a website.

0:25:49squarespace.com/talk show. Hey,

0:25:53speaking of websites, how about the Twitter? Twitter got hacked.

0:25:57Yeah, that was silly.

0:25:58It was, I do you, you didn't got, you didn't get locked out. Did you not,

0:26:07it didn't affect you in any way. No. Well,

0:26:09I was unable to tweet during the, oh, right. Yeah, they, they, yeah,

0:26:14that's right. For verified. It's they, they, they locked you out of tweeting,

0:26:18but that, that lasted what? A few hours. Yeah. Something like that.

0:26:21But I did not get locked out. You got locked out, right?

0:26:25I did because I was one of the dumb dumbs who like changed my password right

0:26:29after it was, I, I,

0:26:31I took the extra security precaution of changing my password on both of my

0:26:35accounts, both my, my personal and my, my business account. And, uh,

0:26:40you know, surprise, surprise. They, I, the next two days I was locked out.

0:26:45I think Todd Vizzier experienced the same.

0:26:47I don't even know if he's back in business. Yeah, he was. Yeah.

0:26:49He was out of business for a couple of days. Todd Vizzier, he'll listen to this.

0:26:52He'll hear this and get a, get a kick out of that.

0:26:55But he won't be able to tweet about it.

0:26:56Sorry, Todd. Yeah. So not a bad idea, right?

0:27:04Like you think like, holy hell, Twitter is the whole thing is, you know,

0:27:08uh, you know, there's,

0:27:10there's an unknown number of hackers running around doing crazy stuff with

0:27:14Twitter accounts. Why don't I go in and change my password? You know,

0:27:17just seems like the least you can do, right. Just do something, right.

0:27:22I get, if I was a locksmith and something crazy like this was going on,

0:27:26maybe I would change the locks on my door, right? I mean, you can do it.

0:27:29If you could change your locks on your door,

0:27:31as easy as you can change your password on Twitter, I would do it. Right.

0:27:35But it turns out then that after this was over, they were like, any,

0:27:39we don't even know what the hell happened Twitter wide.

0:27:43So let's just flag every account whose password has been changed and

0:27:48lock it down. Right. So, uh,

0:27:52I mean, I get it. It was, it's probably, yeah, if you're a hacker and you, um,

0:27:56you would change people's passwords, I guess on their behalf.

0:27:59And then I guess it seems like a smart thing to do.

0:28:02It just totally counterintuitive that if I had done nothing to secure

0:28:06myself, then I would have been, uh, I would have been back, you know,

0:28:10back using the app again. Um, but you know, people were wondering what was,

0:28:14what, what, what would the,

0:28:16the motivation be if it weren't purely to steal, what was it?

0:28:20180,000 something like $180,000 with a Bitcoin,

0:28:24which was not that big of a take. Yeah. Uh,

0:28:27end of the day for something like for the,

0:28:29the biggest hack that Twitter has ever experienced, um,

0:28:33taking what was taking complete control. Right. One of the, you know,

0:28:37second only to Facebook,

0:28:39maybe social network on the planet with perhaps greater

0:28:44media influence than Facebook. Right. Like,

0:28:47so Facebook as a company is worth way more than Twitter as a company,

0:28:51but like Twitter's the one that we're always worried about, you know,

0:28:54who tweeting something dumb that starts a war. Right. Right. Cause it doesn't,

0:28:59it's not the walled garden that Facebook is,

0:29:01is that way more of a sort of an amplification machine or a broadcast.

0:29:05And it is sort of fundamentally simpler, right?

0:29:08This is the sort of thing I know that you get, like at its core,

0:29:12it's really hard to explain what Facebook is. I honestly still don't understand it.

0:29:16I don't really quite understand what the hell it is. Like,

0:29:20Twitter is actually kind of easy to understand. You sign up, you get a name,

0:29:25and you know, by convention, we just put an ad sign in front of it.

0:29:29And then you can tweet,

0:29:31which is that you get to write up to 280 characters and hit send.

0:29:35And then it goes.

0:29:37And then anybody who looks at your account can see the things you've sent.

0:29:40That's it. That's the whole thing really.

0:29:43And then everything else is just sort of butter on that in terms of like,

0:29:47you know, you can, you know,

0:29:49reply to somebody by putting their name in it and threads it somehow.

0:29:53But it's all just tweets. The replies are tweets. Everything's tweets.

0:29:58It's, it's just tweets all the way down.

0:30:00And tweets are just little blurbs of text that you just throw out into the ether.

0:30:05Right. That's it. It's very easy to understand.

0:30:08And I feel like that is sort of what makes it more powerful in terms of like,

0:30:12if somebody influential is just going to post a message,

0:30:16you just post it on Twitter. There it is.

0:30:18It goes out and everybody can point to it. Anybody who, you know, somebody says,

0:30:23did you see what Adam, Lisa Gore said?

0:30:25They just post the link and you don't even have a Twitter account. Maybe you just hit the link.

0:30:29You can read what, what it's there. You don't have to, you know,

0:30:31there's no goofy thing that pops up. That's like, Hey,

0:30:34sign up and tell me where you went to high school to sign into Facebook or whatever.

0:30:38No, it's just there. And then they can put it, you know, you, you show up on CNN.

0:30:42They can put at Gruber underneath your name or whatever.

0:30:45And the people know where your Twitter is.

0:30:47That simplicity is sort of the core of what makes it so powerful.

0:30:51These guys took control of it and decided to use it to scam Bitcoins.

0:30:57Yeah. Well, I mean, you know, if you're a little bit conspiracy minded,

0:31:01that it was sort of a, people are saying, people are saying, you know, it's, Oh God,

0:31:07that's what a terrible expression.

0:31:09It's a ruined, it's been ruined by, you know, who?

0:31:13Yeah. But like, you know, there, there's, there's speculation out there that,

0:31:17um, it was a test run for something bigger.

0:31:20I just realized while we're talking about this,

0:31:22because I watched the movie Sneakers, um, a couple of days ago,

0:31:26I do remember the movies meet sneakers. It all starts out with a,

0:31:31with a robbery, a heist. Um, uh,

0:31:35I forget the specifics. It's been a couple of days, but, um,

0:31:38and then you learn, and then you learn that the whole thing was an actual inside

0:31:43job that he, that they were, that this ragtag, uh, gang of, uh,

0:31:48of, uh, you know, essentially old school hackers, um,

0:31:54had been paid for, you know,

0:31:56paid by the bank to pull off in order to discover, uh,

0:32:00and patch security flaws.

0:32:01So what if this was a similar kind of an inside job, you know,

0:32:05and it wasn't that much of an investment to lose 180 K in Bitcoin.

0:32:10Um, but now they know, I don't know, I kind of think like I,

0:32:14it's fun to have to theorize about conspiracies like this. I don't,

0:32:17I think it's end of the day completely false. And I would never, um,

0:32:22I would never hang my, you know, any, any reputation on this kind of thing,

0:32:27but it would be an interesting way to sort of in, in, you know,

0:32:31get people used to the idea that these platforms are not foolproof or,

0:32:36you know, they're not airtight,

0:32:37they can be exploited and we should be a little bit more security minded about

0:32:42that. Um, you know,

0:32:43I think it's really important leading up to the selection that we don't

0:32:48consider this platform as airtight and, you know, solid truth.

0:32:52And, um,

0:32:53I think that if this little hack causes people to give it a second

0:32:58thought in terms of even the discussion of what's true and what's false,

0:33:02then I think it served its purpose.

0:33:04So, uh,

0:33:06Ben Thompson brought this up on,

0:33:10on our dithering show the other day and Sunday we recorded Sunday night

0:33:15and then that show came out Monday. That was about yesterday.

0:33:18I don't know who the hell knows what day it is, but then late Sunday night, uh,

0:33:22Amy and I watched the John Oliver, the, uh, last,

0:33:26last week tonight with John Oliver. Do you like the John Oliver?

0:33:29I do. I don't watch it regularly, but I think he's great.

0:33:32I think he's great, but he had a bit. It was amazing because I wished,

0:33:36I kind of, I was like, I don't buy the conspiracy theory thing at all.

0:33:39And Ben was more like, I don't really buy it, but who knows? Maybe.

0:33:44And then it was just amazing. It was just like in the way like this sort of,

0:33:48Hey, am I living in some kind of weird,

0:33:50slip cystic simulation of the universe? Because I was just talking, I mean,

0:33:54Ben and I recorded like 10 at night and I was late, of course, 10 Eastern.

0:33:59Um, it's like 10 AM over in Taipei.

0:34:02And then the John Oliver show comes on at 11. And so it was just like, you know,

0:34:06I don't know, literally like 30 minutes after I just talked to Ben about it on

0:34:10our show, John Oliver had a bit talking about conspiracy theories.

0:34:13And I'm not going to remember it here,

0:34:16but the name of this psychological thing off, I swear to God,

0:34:20I'll find it for the show notes, but it doesn't matter.

0:34:22But the gist of it is that there's a well-known psychological effect

0:34:25in the, in regarding conspiracy theories. Um,

0:34:30that's something that has a great effect.

0:34:35The human mind assumes there must be an equally great cause for it.

0:34:40And the example,

0:34:44which I have never thought of and never heard anybody mention,

0:34:47or at least don't recall anybody mentioning, but which is like, Whoa,

0:34:51mind blown was comparing the Kennedy

0:34:55assassination with Reagan getting shot where

0:34:59Kennedy gets shot.

0:35:03And the official story is it was a lone kook gunman.

0:35:08And the whole world thinks, well, that can't possibly be it.

0:35:13And is, you know,

0:35:15quite possibly the conspiracy theory of all conspiracy theories, right?

0:35:19It's certainly up there in the greatest, if you're going to make a greatest hits

0:35:21of conspiracy theories, the Kennedy assassination is up there, right? I mean,

0:35:25I don't see anybody can dispute it. Right.

0:35:28But what happened with Reagan with John Hinckley Jr.

0:35:31It was a lone kook gunman who went and shot him.

0:35:36And it, the difference of course,

0:35:38is that Kennedy was killed and the effects were therefore profound and Reagan

0:35:43recovered. And you know, most people,

0:35:48it's not when you think like Ronald Reagan's presidency,

0:35:51like him getting shot is like,

0:35:54not even at the top of the list of things that happened, which is kind of crazy.

0:35:58Right. And there's zero conspiracy theories, right? There is not one.

0:36:01Have you ever heard a conspiracy theory about Reagan's shooting? Everybody,

0:36:06but, but, but, but, but, but, but,

0:36:08because we got a psychological profile of, of his killer, if it is John David,

0:36:13no, it's not John Hinckley, John Hinckley, John Hinckley, John Hinckley Jr. Yeah.

0:36:17Which, which seemed so entirely plausible,

0:36:19which was that he was a nutso who wanted to impress a movie star.

0:36:24Right. And that seemed very plausible. Okay. So look at it,

0:36:28like look at the incels of art of today. It, that makes sense. You know,

0:36:33you could see somebody doing something really evil for the dumbest of all

0:36:37reasons. And, uh,

0:36:39I guess the world needed no further explanation at the time.

0:36:42Well, and I get it too. And the thing that Oliver didn't mention, and I was like,

0:36:46well, there is the crazy aspect though, where Hinckley also,

0:36:50oh, shot him at like point blank range. Like he just,

0:36:54Reagan was just walking out of like the Hilton after giving a speech. And it just,

0:36:58they just phrase it. It was like the last time it's ever happened where like,

0:37:02the president just sort of left the president of the United States,

0:37:04just left a building, like a normal celebrity with just, you know,

0:37:08a couple of security export experts around him. But like the,

0:37:12the crowd on the sidewalk was there to, you know,

0:37:14shout and say hi to him and everything. Uh, you know,

0:37:18and Hinckley was just there with a gun in his pocket and shot him. Whereas,

0:37:22you know,

0:37:22like the mechanics of the shooting are actually very simple. And if you under,

0:37:27if you understand how the president and through the 60,

0:37:31which is crazy after all, you know, Kennedy getting shot, you know, that,

0:37:35that they still just let the president walk out in the sidewalk,

0:37:38get into a car himself. Um,

0:37:41but the mechanics of it weren't crazy, just a guy. And,

0:37:44and the fact that he wasn't a trained shooter, you know,

0:37:48and just shot him in the stomach or the chest. Whereas the Hinckley thing,

0:37:51it does involve, you know, some rather preposterous or rather not preposterous,

0:37:55but hard to believe marksmanship and number of bullets and you know what I mean?

0:38:00Totally Harvey Oswald. Yeah. So I don't want to,

0:38:01I don't want to derail this whole thing into some of the stuff around the

0:38:06Kennedy assassination, but you know,

0:38:09yeah, there's other assassinations to talk about, right. But just,

0:38:11just thinking about the mechanics of the shooting, it, you know,

0:38:16it required even people who believe that there was, you know, that, that, uh,

0:38:20Lee Harvey Oswald, what's with these guys with the names that are hard to

0:38:24remember Lee Harvey Oswald, you know,

0:38:26even if you believe that he did it all on his own,

0:38:29you still have to fundamentally believe that he was a tremendous marksman,

0:38:32you know, who can, you know, so I get it. It's, but the,

0:38:36the bigger point though I think is true, which is that if Reagan had been killed,

0:38:41there would have been conspiracy theories about it. Right. And it's,

0:38:47it's certain, you know, and I think that's sort of at the heart of this Twitter

0:38:51thing. I just, I think it's exactly where it, it was so prof,

0:38:55their ownership of Twitter's platform was so profound where they could literally

0:39:00pick any account, almost any account they wanted to. Like there's just,

0:39:05nobody even knows which ones are locked.

0:39:06Everybody knows that Trump's is locked behind a key because,

0:39:10because a couple of years ago, a contractor,

0:39:13a contractor who worked at Twitter security team part time,

0:39:18or as a temporary worker on his last day of work,

0:39:21deactivated Trump's account.

0:39:23That was wonderful.

0:39:25So Trump's is under some kind of special lock and key.

0:39:29I guess Jack Dorsey's is, I only guess because, you know,

0:39:34he is the CEO and his account wasn't apparently tweeting,

0:39:39you know, the Bitcoin scam, maybe not. I don't know who else is there.

0:39:43I, it seems crazy that,

0:39:44that Trump's would be under this and Joe Biden's wouldn't at this point.

0:39:48I mean, I'll bet it is right now. I bet as you and I record that, uh,

0:39:52they were like, Hey, we better, you know,

0:39:54better put Biden's account under the same thing as Trump's. Um, yeah.

0:39:59But I, I, how about make everybody's that safe? How, you know,

0:40:03I think that's the main point here is, Hey jerks,

0:40:06we're all spending all this time on your platform. Like, you know, a big,

0:40:10a large portion of society is using this platform to express and learn

0:40:15information. How about keep us safe? How about don't make this happen?

0:40:20Well, I think the craziest thing is that you could have,

0:40:24everybody says over and over again with everything do two factor, two factor,

0:40:28two factor. I mean, and I've done it. I have gone through,

0:40:32I'm not going to say every single account I have that I could have two factor on.

0:40:36I have it on, but every one that I think is important, I do.

0:40:40Right. Like I've got it on my bank, I've got it on my credit cards.

0:40:46Um, you know, my Twitter accounts have it. Uh,

0:40:51my Gmail account has it any, you know, so email,

0:40:55Twitter, banking, credit cards, and I mean, pretty much anything serious.

0:41:01I mean, you know, like my account@jcrew.com does not have two factor

0:41:05authentication.

0:41:06I am going to order you so many chinos, not going to be flattering to you.

0:41:13Somebody breaks into my account there and they're going to find the least

0:41:18surprising order history that they've ever seen. It's a bunch of,

0:41:22you know, flashy Navy blue polos

0:41:25and a bunch of gray shorts.

0:41:30Uh, but if you had two factor on your Twitter account and everybody was like,

0:41:35well, what's the,

0:41:38and when this first thing went wild and all these, you know,

0:41:41this great obvious scams are coming out of these accounts, everybody's like,

0:41:45Oh my God, that is nuts.

0:41:46That so-and-so didn't have two factor on their account because everybody just

0:41:50assumed two factor would protect you. Right. Um,

0:41:54turns out that the same interface that let them like just change the email

0:41:58associated with an account. Also let them just,

0:42:00just like click a checkbox to turn off two factor,

0:42:04which is sort of like,

0:42:06you would think they should lock that down.

0:42:12And it was all social engineering, right. To hack in the first place.

0:42:16It's like having a vault where, you know, like with a big thick,

0:42:21you know, caper movie,

0:42:25three foot thick door for the vault door and a crazy,

0:42:29you know, combination lock,

0:42:31but it's just a panel and you could just walk around the side.

0:42:35It's just like one face out of the four. It's not actually a box. It's like,

0:42:41yeah, the door, you know, the, the vault door is super secure,

0:42:44but you could just walk around the side and just turn it off.

0:42:46There's a guy, there's a security guard, but you just kind of,

0:42:50you throw a piece of meat around the corner and he goes and chases it.

0:42:56Well, the other thing that was so wild about, so everybody, I, again,

0:42:59I think that this fundamental theory,

0:43:00the reason people are thinking there must be a greater conspiracy is it was so

0:43:04bizarre.

0:43:07And it really seems like the Bitcoin part was secondary and it was something

0:43:11that one of the hackers involved, I don't know if he had it in mind all along,

0:43:16but like the things that they did first before the Bitcoin thing,

0:43:20we're just trying to steal what they call OG Twitter handles.

0:43:24Which I was unaware. I realized that they are few and far between.

0:43:29These are the one character names like at six,

0:43:36like just add the character six. Uh, you know,

0:43:40obviously there's only like 40 or so,

0:43:44I don't know how many, maybe only 37, one character, Twitter names,

0:43:50the 26 letters of the alphabet, the 10 digits. And then our friend,

0:43:54Dave, Dave Rutledge, who runs, uh, created,

0:43:57co-created meh.com as at underscore.

0:44:02Oh, wow. Yeah. That's a, that's been a mess for him. Yeah.

0:44:06You think like that's clever. His, his Twitter handle is underscore,

0:44:09just one underscore. Uh,

0:44:11and I believe his wife is two underscores and he secured three underscores for

0:44:17one of their kids, I believe. Yeah. But guess,

0:44:21guess whose account gets hacked all the time. Oh man, that sucks. Yeah.

0:44:26And so this was that, so that was the big heist, huh?

0:44:29Just getting single character accounts.

0:44:31And then once they realized they had something, then they did,

0:44:34this was their version of the checkout. My sound cloud,

0:44:37when you have a tweet go viral. Yeah. Interesting and terrible.

0:44:41And it's very stupid. Yeah. Well, and I think that that's ultimately,

0:44:45I think that one of the things that's forgotten in Twitter hacking history,

0:44:50everybody remembers the saga of, again, friend of the show. I don't know.

0:44:53Yeah. I don't think he's ever been on, but Matt Honan, who's, uh, you know,

0:44:57a big wig over at Buzzfeed news now. Um, but who,

0:45:01uh, quite unusually in my opinion, spells his name M A T.

0:45:06He doesn't have the second T, um, uh,

0:45:12you know, which is a lot less common than say being a John without the

0:45:16H, um,

0:45:18but not quite as uncommon as being an Adam without like the second day.

0:45:23Yeah. That'd be weird. Although it's, you know,

0:45:27do you well in it for a career in the Navy. Yeah.

0:45:30But anyway, Matt Honan years ago, I mean,

0:45:37this might be 10 years ago at this point got hacked, uh, his and,

0:45:41and badly like this, everything you remember,

0:45:44as Apple. Cause they, and they only took his Apple ID,

0:45:48I think to get his Twitter, but, uh, he wrote about it eventually,

0:45:52but it really was devastating at a personal level cause they took his Apple ID

0:45:56and he had everything else like his banking and everything was all through his

0:46:01Apple ID, but he lost his Apple ID to these hackers. Um,

0:46:05and it seemed like Twitter's initial reaction was to assume that Honan got

0:46:10hacked because he was in the media. And that's when I got verified. Uh, I did,

0:46:14I never asked for the ad Gruber account to get the blue check Mark.

0:46:18They just gave,

0:46:18I just logged in one day and I had it because they were going through,

0:46:22they had some assembled some sort of list of people like Matt

0:46:27Honan. And you know, for obvious reasons,

0:46:30I am vaguely like him in terms of the number of people following me and that I

0:46:36write stuff that people read. But I think it's clear in hindsight,

0:46:40that the reason Honan got hacked wasn't because he was in the media,

0:46:43but because his username was M a T it was one of these O G

0:46:48Twitter accounts.

0:46:49I can only, I had no idea that there was so much value in these short handles.

0:46:54Right. Well, and, but the value cannot be seen as permanent because surely,

0:46:58you know, it, it, it, it, no matter what, how,

0:47:02how quietly they had tried to play this, if they had really just tried to steal,

0:47:07and they were selling these things according to New York, New York times,

0:47:10you know, there was like 1500 bucks or 2,500 bucks would get you like a two

0:47:13character username.

0:47:15Surely they didn't expect it to be permanent, I guess, unless it's like a,

0:47:20maybe if it's a Twitter account that was abandoned and that nobody used

0:47:25and, uh, you know, but if it's somebody was using it, surely Twitter, you know,

0:47:30this was going to come to their attention and they would see, Oh,

0:47:33this person says their Twitter account was stolen on this day.

0:47:37And that was the day we got hacked and there, yes,

0:47:40that's when the email address and everything was changed.

0:47:42So we'll just give it back to this person.

0:47:44Surely they didn't expect it to be permanent. You know,

0:47:48I think it's just like a typical prank where you, you know,

0:47:51think you're going to get away with it for an hour and, uh,

0:47:55just all very bizarre.

0:47:57And I just think people have a hard time grasping that like 20 year old computer

0:48:02hackers would do it,

0:48:04would have this power in their hands and use it to steal the LOL account.

0:48:08Yeah. Yeah. It was real dumb, but I think again,

0:48:13silver lining is now we're all just a little bit more aware of the,

0:48:17of the security flaw. Yeah. Um,

0:48:21yeah, I don't know. I do wonder what Twitter is going to do.

0:48:25It's pretty embarrassing for them, especially, you know, and people do,

0:48:28and I know we're, we're joking about it. Um, but you know,

0:48:31that's the thing that people get is, you know, what if they had, you know,

0:48:35tweeted from somebody's account that, you know, like, you know,

0:48:39at Joe Biden's I'm dropping out of the race or something like that,

0:48:42you know, or stock manipulation. Right. I mean, people go, you know,

0:48:47money, yeah. The Tesla being shorted or, or, um,

0:48:52or other right. And, you know, and Tesla in particular comes to mind because

0:48:57their stock is, uh, you know,

0:49:01on a rocket and it is,

0:49:02so it is volatile and we know for a fact that Elon Musk

0:49:07tweets goofy things like, yeah,

0:49:10gets high and tweets that he's taking the couple at the company private at

0:49:16$420 a share. He did that like,

0:49:20that wasn't a hack. So, you know,

0:49:23something just every bit as similar as that would have, you know,

0:49:28it certainly seemed to be believable. I think, uh,

0:49:31I think Matt Levine who writes the great money stuff newsletter for Bloomberg,

0:49:36you know, his idea was have, have, you know,

0:49:39if you wanted to really try to make some money, um,

0:49:42it's either short the stock or long the stock. If you wanted to long it and,

0:49:48and assume it was going to go up, uh, have, uh,

0:49:52the just hack two accounts, Elon Musk and say, Hey, this time for real,

0:49:57I'm taking the company public at blank,

0:49:59put the target number in with the help of, um,

0:50:03Warren buffet and then just take the buffet account and say,

0:50:07I'm happy to help Elon Musk take the great company Tesla private would, you know,

0:50:11we've heard all the financing, boom, the stock jumps up,

0:50:15you cash out and you know,

0:50:18and maybe the sec finds you,

0:50:21but there's so many people who are on a daily basis shorting and long. I mean,

0:50:25it's like become like a coronavirus quarantine hobby is day

0:50:30trading stocks. Uh, you know,

0:50:34you know, if you did it for enough money that it might be worth it to you,

0:50:37but not so much that it really sticks out among the zillions of trades, people,

0:50:42crazy trades people do with Tesla every day, you could have gotten away with it,

0:50:46but instead they just took, took goofy usernames.

0:50:51So dumb.

0:50:53Uh, well let's, uh, uh, let's talk about, uh,

0:50:59my show before I forget. So you helped. Yeah. So I wrote,

0:51:04yeah, you're remote show. Yeah. Um, and I just want to,

0:51:08I want to thank you really. I want to thank you personally. Um,

0:51:12no, absolutely. No sweat. Cause I here's, here's here. I mean, I mean,

0:51:16I mean relay how this came to be as I best I recollected,

0:51:20I started talking with Apple, you know, I dunno, six weeks before WWDC,

0:51:25maybe a little bit before that, you know, just sort of, Hey,

0:51:28like, I think maybe around the time when they first announced that WWDC was going

0:51:34to be virtual, I had some preliminary talk with, well, look, this, you know,

0:51:38we're obviously not, you, I don't, you know,

0:51:40you're obviously not going to do a show traditionally.

0:51:42We still will probably be interested in doing something with you if you would

0:51:47like to, you know, but it would have to be remote. And I said, yeah,

0:51:50I would like to, I, you know, it's too good of a tradition to, to let fall.

0:51:54Let's figure it out when we get closer, get closer. And you know,

0:51:59it's like, okay, here's what we were thinking, you know, um, what if we did,

0:52:04what if, what if Jaws and Craig come on the show again?

0:52:08And even in normal years, it's,

0:52:12it, it is them suggesting,

0:52:16here's who maybe would be a good idea for the show. And, you know,

0:52:21Federighi doesn't really spill anything.

0:52:23Everybody knows Federighi is going to be involved.

0:52:25But like a couple of years ago when Mike Rockwell,

0:52:27who's in charge of all the machine learning stuff at Apple,

0:52:32um, when they were like, we're thinking about Mike Rockwell, he's, you know,

0:52:36in charge of this, it was sort of a, uh, you know,

0:52:41there's sort of like a handshake deal,

0:52:43preliminary to the show that I'm not going to go blab and say, Mike, you know,

0:52:48part of the thing is that I'm going to keep the guest secret.

0:52:51Part of it is that it's a lot of fun to come out on stage and nobody in the

0:52:55audience even knows who's coming out.

0:52:57And part of it is like, if it's Mike Rockwell,

0:53:01and I announced it in advance,

0:53:03it would sort of suggest that maybe the WWDC keynote is going to have a lot of

0:53:08machine learning AI.

0:53:11Yeah.

0:53:12There's some corporate secret stuff that they can't, they don't want,

0:53:15that's going to indicate you don't want to divulge.

0:53:17Right. Uh, yeah. But you know, and it was like, you know, and what do,

0:53:22what are we going to do? And the basic conversation I had with,

0:53:26with Bill Evans at Apple PR was, uh,

0:53:32that I'm, I watch a lot of these late night shows. I watched the Colbert,

0:53:37we watched the Seth Meyers late night show. Uh,

0:53:40I peek in at the Jimmy Kimmel sometimes. I like, you know, I, I'm a, you know,

0:53:43that's why this show is called the talk show. I like talk shows.

0:53:45I find the production value of the shows during quarantine to be,

0:53:51uh, overall to be, uh, unbelievably poor. I can't believe it.

0:53:59I could believe it like the end of March when it was new and it was like,

0:54:04nobody saw this coming.

0:54:05Yeah. It's like, oh shit, we got to get something up and running like now,

0:54:08six hours till, till showtime. But yeah, they could easily,

0:54:12in this amount of time, they could have easily built a little studio for each of

0:54:17the, uh, you know, a little home studio for each of the,

0:54:19Right. And where it particularly falls flat is the interviews when they have

0:54:26guests on and they just look, I mean,

0:54:29and not even talking about the editing,

0:54:31but just the compression artifacts that you're actually just looking at the

0:54:36compression artifacts of a zoom call over mediocre bandwidth and a terrible,

0:54:42sometimes a terrible like Mac book webcam. Um,

0:54:49I just can't believe that they don't have, and this,

0:54:53we can talk about this with you, but you know,

0:54:55the way that it would be more self-contained, but like the way that,

0:54:59that you guys at sandwich have put together a kit that you can send around to

0:55:03shoot stuff remotely. Like why don't they have an interview kit?

0:55:06And they can just send it in a box with some instructions.

0:55:09And then as the weeks go on, they can, you know,

0:55:12here's where people got hung up. Oh,

0:55:14people got confused about this and this and then you get it down and then

0:55:18everybody could have like a nice light or two and a nice camera and a good

0:55:24microphone.

0:55:24And maybe we wouldn't record the actual compressed stuff going over the

0:55:29internet. Just basically, I find it very hard to watch. I really do.

0:55:33I don't watch the interviews anymore because I really,

0:55:36I can't, it's, I just, it's too hard.

0:55:41It feels like I'm like reading, reading subtitles.

0:55:45It's a quandary for them, for these shows, because if they, if,

0:55:49let's say they do figure out a really good mobile production kit and then some

0:55:54of like, then the interviews,

0:55:56the other side of the interview starts looking and sounding better or even like

0:56:01looking and sounding great,

0:56:02then they're kind of stuck at that level of that, that,

0:56:06that production quality standard.

0:56:08And then anything that falls short of that is going to really stick out and look

0:56:12terrible by comparison. So they, they're almost,

0:56:15I feel like they're doing themselves a favor acknowledging that, that, Hey,

0:56:19it's a free for all. We're going to get what we're going to get limited,

0:56:23not only by the capture gear,

0:56:25but the actual bandwidth that people have available to them.

0:56:28And the physical, we're just having to, what's that?

0:56:33Well, the physical space that people are quarantining in, right?

0:56:35Not everybody has the luxury of having a space available with say,

0:56:40like I did nice natural light or space at all. Right. I mean,

0:56:45there's people who live in small apartments, you know,

0:56:47with kids or pets and yeah.

0:56:49And also most people prioritize different things in their home office.

0:56:53They don't care about what it looks like behind them.

0:56:55Cause they're looking in front of them all day long, you know, they,

0:56:57so they don't care.

0:56:58Usually people sort of sit with a back against the wall and a bunch of framed,

0:57:03you know, commemorative things. And those things don't look good on camera.

0:57:08Yeah. So anyway,

0:57:09that was my basic thing is I didn't want it to look like that because part of it

0:57:13was simple vanity.

0:57:15I don't want to put out a show that looks like garbage,

0:57:17but also if I have trouble following along with a

0:57:22very poor,

0:57:23just sort of record the actual zoom or FaceTime,

0:57:28or it doesn't even matter which of the things you're using,

0:57:31if you just record it to disc, I really,

0:57:34I just have a hard time following along. I,

0:57:38I wanted people to enjoy it. You know, and that was my basic thing was let's,

0:57:43let's, you know, we don't do anything fancy,

0:57:45but let's make it look good and sound good and let's figure this out.

0:57:47And we figured out the mechanics of basically long story short. And then,

0:57:51you know, I wrote all the technical details, but do it as a double ender

0:57:55and have a camera. That's not even the webcam recording it.

0:58:00We just used iPhones, but the iPhones are great people. Uh, and again,

0:58:04that was, it wasn't like a, uh, an advertisement for iPhones.

0:58:09I wasn't even under any obligation to say that I shot my end with an iPhone

0:58:1411 and that I did what I could have used a different camera.

0:58:18I could have used any camera I wanted to. They just said,

0:58:20we're going to use iPhones. And I was like, I was going to use an iPhone too,

0:58:23cause it's actually the best video camera I own.

0:58:26And I didn't really feel like buying a new camera just for this. Um,

0:58:31not because I'm cheap either. I love buying cameras,

0:58:34but I just was afraid to buy something and learn something new.

0:58:36I want something dependable. Um,

0:58:39people couldn't believe that they were just shot with iPhone 11s. I mean,

0:58:42cause both ends looked great. Yeah. Yeah. They, they, they looked,

0:58:46they look and sound great right out of the box. You know,

0:58:49all the default computational math is there for a reason.

0:58:53It's to take any material and automatically automatically make it look

0:58:58incredible without having to do anything. And then when, you know,

0:59:01and then if you have actual post-production involved,

0:59:04you can take that and elevate it just that couple of notches better.

0:59:08And that's when people start to say, Oh,

0:59:10that didn't even look like an iPhone that looked like a professional camera.

0:59:13And so a lot of the weight was off my shoulders though. I think we got this.

0:59:17I think we can do it mechanically. I think I know what equipment we'll use.

0:59:22I know that I've got a good rapport with Federighi and Jaws, you know,

0:59:27this is going to work. Um, and then they were like, well,

0:59:32what are you going to do about editing? And again, you know, and it, it,

0:59:36it did not like I said that came out like they were,

0:59:41confrontational about it. And I was like, ah, I've got it. And they're like, well,

0:59:44we could suggest like, we can suggest contractors we've worked with,

0:59:48worked with for editing. I was like, I think, I think I'll, you know, and,

0:59:52and again, it wasn't like they were trying to take ownership of it.

0:59:55It's my show. And, you know, and they're like, okay, cool.

0:59:58And I thought I had in the back of my head, I'm going to ask,

1:00:01I'm going to ask Adam and sandwich because I,

1:00:05I just know that you knock it out of the park.

1:00:07But then I put it off a little too long.

1:00:09And then I got all real nervous about it. I was like, Oh my God,

1:00:12what if they're busy? You know? And it's like, what a terrible ask.

1:00:15And I really, I didn't know, I didn't really have a plan B,

1:00:20but I was like, well, I could figure out a plan B. I mean, you know,

1:00:25well, you know, you have an army at your disposal, like a little army of, of,

1:00:30of, of people, of fans that would just mobilize right here. Right.

1:00:34I'm not, I'm not toiling on obscurity. So I wasn't like,

1:00:38it's sandwich or nothing, but it's like sandwich or the unknown.

1:00:43And, but I reached out and you were like, yeah, we could do that. It'd be great.

1:00:46And then as we got into it and I, I just realized,

1:00:53Oh my God, if I, if this weren't you and your,

1:00:57your colleagues, a sandwich, I would just be,

1:00:59I'd be on the edge of a cliff thinking about jumping off because it,

1:01:04it was such a tremendous relief to know that it was in good hands and

1:01:09to give what I thought were just sort of like the equivalent,

1:01:13almost literal equivalent of like a pen on a napkin

1:01:18instructions. Here's, you know, basically,

1:01:21you guys took it and just completely got it.

1:01:24You knew exactly what I meant and cut it together. And,

1:01:29and you know, like you said, just, you know,

1:01:31a little bit of color correction and stuff to just, you know,

1:01:34sweeten it just the right amount.

1:01:36Yeah. Just make the conversation flow. There's three, there's three,

1:01:41literally three video sources that you're sort of in there in this case, what,

1:01:45five. Yeah. Cause they each had two cameras. Right. Then you're just,

1:01:49you're just making sure everything flows together and doesn't impede the

1:01:52conversation.

1:01:53Yeah. And I, you know, came out great, but it was,

1:01:56what a relief and what a tremendous.

1:01:59Fun to be asked because I've obviously been to, you know,

1:02:02many of your live shows in the Bay and you always have like

1:02:06Caleb Sexton and you know, Jake Schumacher,

1:02:10sort of doing the live,

1:02:11the live event coverage of stuff from the audio and video standpoint.

1:02:16And then, and those guys are all great and very talented. And of course,

1:02:20Caleb works with you on the audio side of things still,

1:02:23but I wouldn't have been well suited to, or set up to do that kind of thing.

1:02:27Live events is not our, our bag at sandwich, but this,

1:02:32this kind of thing, especially having just come off the project with,

1:02:35for Slack where literally it was all done remotely and you know,

1:02:38figuring out how to shuffle data around and capturing from many locations,

1:02:43et cetera. So it just felt like a fun thing to do. Let's try this out.

1:02:47And the only thing that we didn't really account for was like working with an

1:02:50hour plus of how long was the final thing?

1:02:53I'm going to say it was around 80 minutes.

1:02:57Yeah. Yeah. 80 minutes of 80 minutes of program instead of our typical 90 seconds.

1:03:02Data is a lot heavier as we, as we all experienced.

1:03:05Otherwise we would have gotten it out that first night. Right. Oh God,

1:03:09that was harrowing.

1:03:10Oh, it was so bad. I had, I,

1:03:14I've talked about it before, but yeah,

1:03:16my 10 megabit per second upstream here in Capletown has,

1:03:21hasn't really been an issue. Like Ben Thompson, you know,

1:03:25the video goes up to Dropbox and we use a thing called Zen caster for dithering,

1:03:29but we, you know,

1:03:29we're literally really record like 16, 17 minutes to do a 15 minute show.

1:03:34And you know,

1:03:35he's always making fun of me for how long it takes for my 17 minutes of nothing

1:03:39but wave audio to upload like

1:03:44and four key, 30 frames per second,

1:03:484k video. Yeah, it was heavy. Yeah.

1:03:53I did have the thought when we were doing, I did have the thought as we were

1:03:56waiting for the six or seven hours for my stuff to go to where you guys could

1:04:00access it. I thought, well,

1:04:01this makes me feel a lot better about the fact that I only shot my side from one

1:04:06camera instead of two. They did with theirs cause it would have doubled it.

1:04:10Yeah. And of course on their end they, you know, we get, we,

1:04:16they had the same, I think frame IO, um,

1:04:19destination that we gave you and there's was up in like 14 seconds flat.

1:04:24Like I wisecracked that, you know, I,

1:04:29that they apparently have better internet than I do, but you know,

1:04:32I suspect it's really no joke that, you know, Apple's

1:04:36not just Apple period, but their new, new facility has, you know,

1:04:41very fast internet. Uh, what do you think?

1:04:46Here's a technical question for you. So we shot 4k 30 frames per second, um,

1:04:50which may or may not be 29.97, whatever. I don't care. It's 30 frames per second.

1:04:55Do you think we should have shot 24 frames per second?

1:04:58No. Oh, such a great question. I love talking about frame rates. Um,

1:05:04and I'm dealing with that with my own home set up too. Uh,

1:05:07there's a time and a place for, uh, 24 frames per second.

1:05:12And I think for most purposes when you're trying to make something

1:05:16feel, um,

1:05:18greater than contemporaneous when,

1:05:22when you're trying to lend some weight or some archival importance to something.

1:05:26Yeah. 24 frames per second is great because films are shot in 24 and

1:05:31you, the, the, the,

1:05:34the eye and the mind can pick up on the subtle differences between 24 and 30

1:05:39where we all grew up with 30 frames per second or, um,

1:05:43and so we know that that represents, um, essentially video,

1:05:48which often, especially when we were kids, video was used for,

1:05:53you know, live event type of things or, you know, news or,

1:05:57um, you know, SNL kind of things,

1:06:01live to tape kind of things.

1:06:04And it makes you feel more present as though it's, it's, it's happening in the

1:06:09moment. Um, so with, with something like a zoom call, yeah,

1:06:13I could easily switch my camera to 24 frames per second, but then I just,

1:06:17I feel like it lends almost like a self-importance to my image that I don't

1:06:22really need to be in most of my business calls.

1:06:25Maybe if I'm trying to say something very, very important, profound,

1:06:29then I'll switch it over to 24. But then again,

1:06:32I'm talking to people who are all mostly, you know,

1:06:35with their Mac book camera and you know, the, the same 29 97 frame rate.

1:06:40So I'll,

1:06:41I'll just be the odd man out and it'll look weird and everything.

1:06:45But years and years ago when I was at Coachella, I noticed, and they start,

1:06:50and they,

1:06:51it was one of the first years that they had giant video screens up on the main

1:06:55stage, you know, like they do in so many concerts now,

1:06:58every concert, every concert has giant video screens on at least the left and

1:07:03right of the stage so that if you're far away,

1:07:07you can experience the event in person.

1:07:10And for those first, uh,

1:07:13it might've been just the first year that they had basically an actual crew,

1:07:18like an, you know,

1:07:19an actual like multi-camera video crew up there on the stage shooting with

1:07:24cranes, getting the cap, you know, capturing the,

1:07:27the audience footage and everything meant to feel like a real time documentary

1:07:32crew. Well, they, it was weirdest phenomenon, but they, they,

1:07:36uh, oh man, I, I'm feeling like, um, Deja Vu,

1:07:41like we've talked about this on your show before. And if so, shame on me.

1:07:45Okay. But anyway, so that, that first year they,

1:07:51it was in the very beginning of video cameras,

1:07:53pro video cameras being able to capture in 24 frames per second,

1:07:57which was a huge game changer for filmmakers back then. Right. And so they,

1:08:02um, they captured and displayed their live, you know, doc, um,

1:08:08you know,

1:08:09filmmaking in 24 frames per second so that everything that you were watching on

1:08:14the video screens up there was 24 frames per second.

1:08:16And the unintended consequence of that or the psychological effect of that is

1:08:21that people in the audience felt like they were watching a movie instead of a

1:08:25concert. And when you feel it, when you're watching a movie,

1:08:28you don't really like scream and dance and shout a lot.

1:08:32So what I noticed was that the, the audience was, or the,

1:08:35the crowd was way more subdued in ways that aren't, you know,

1:08:39don't lend themselves to a good concert. And, uh,

1:08:44it was just the weirdest thing. And then the next year they flipped it back to 30

1:08:47frames per second. And it felt again, like in real time,

1:08:50it felt real time. Like you're supposed to be reacting.

1:08:53You're not intended to stay sort of quiet and, and spectate.

1:08:57You're supposed to participate.

1:08:58I remember the first time I saw something like this and it wasn't live in an

1:09:03audience. It was, and I know it was on MTV. I'm going to just say it was the,

1:09:07yeah, the movie award. No, yes. It was, it was, or maybe the movie awards.

1:09:12I totally remember that. Yeah. They did 24 the first, the first time. Yeah.

1:09:17Maybe it was. So I don't know. It was one of their award shows,

1:09:19but they did 24 and I have very vivid memories

1:09:24of watching it with Amy. And I don't even watch a lot of award shows.

1:09:27I maybe I used to watch more, I think, but, uh,

1:09:30well, they used to be more of events and now it just, everything disappears.

1:09:34But I remember it on, in a,

1:09:36in a couple of different ways is I remember, I remember watching it.

1:09:40I remember being blown away by the quality at first and thinking,

1:09:45what are they, how are they doing this? And then like very quickly realized,

1:09:49Oh, they're shooting 24 frames per second.

1:09:51That's what's giving it this film look. Um, you know,

1:09:55and calling it a film look is the thing we don't even talk about anymore because

1:09:59it's gotten so good.

1:10:00But there was a while there in the late nineties through the early

1:10:05two thousands where film look, film, look, film,

1:10:08look was something that all anybody, I mean,

1:10:11you certainly know more than I do because you went into it professionally.

1:10:14But even as like somebody, like a nerd following along,

1:10:17it was something I, you know, I was aware of.

1:10:20Everybody was looking for filters and things you could throw video through to

1:10:24make it look like film. And of course the biggest is just shoot 24 instead of 30

1:10:29frames per second. Um, I figured this out.

1:10:33And of course I start yapping to Amy about it.

1:10:35And she's like there to see Johnny Depp. She's not,

1:10:38does not want to hear about frame rate. Yeah.

1:10:43And at first my first feeling was technical

1:10:47euphoria of this is amazing. They're shooting something live in 24.

1:10:52And it does look like a movie and it does look like film,

1:10:55even though it can't be film because it's live, you know,

1:11:00and I'm amazed. And then very quickly I was like, but this is all wrong.

1:11:04Like this doesn't feel live at all.

1:11:07This feels like I'm watching a movie years from now about the

1:11:12whatever year it was the 2003 video music awards or whatever. Like it,

1:11:16it just totally broke the illusion that I was watching a live broadcast of a,

1:11:20of an award show.

1:11:21Right. And it took the,

1:11:23it took the experimentation in order to figure out that that was wrong. That's,

1:11:27that's, that's what's kind of fun is that that feeling that where they were with

1:11:31all these, the introduction of these new tools,

1:11:33the new tech to do 24 frames per second, they were learning it as,

1:11:37as the rest of us were too.

1:11:40And then like 20 minutes would go by and I would just say to Amy after like,

1:11:44keep my mouth shut, but do you, do you see what I mean?

1:11:47It doesn't feel alive. It's like, don't just like leave. She's like,

1:11:51get out of here.

1:11:52Right. Well, I mean,

1:11:53and it's even the same phenomenon in reverse of the H high frame rate stuff

1:11:58that, you know,

1:11:59Peter Jackson or Ang Lee was experimenting with where it seems like it might be a

1:12:03good idea, but then you quickly discover, Oh, I thought it was a bad idea.

1:12:06Because, because what, like the brain associates, it was,

1:12:10was something that it's already experienced, you know, in our,

1:12:13in the case of MTV or Coachella,

1:12:15the brain associates it with watching a movie.

1:12:19And in the case of Peter Jackson movie the brain associates

1:12:24it with watching a soap opera or you know,

1:12:29motion smoothing on your TV.

1:12:30All right. So I will say, I'll never find it in, I,

1:12:34I didn't bookmark it, so I'll never find it. But, um,

1:12:37at some point within the last month,

1:12:40and it was more like a month ago when the protests were more of an ongoing,

1:12:45uh, thing around the country. Uh, and there,

1:12:50of course, one of the, the very notable,

1:12:54I mean, just remarkable. And it's unlike anything else anybody's ever seen in

1:12:58history,

1:12:59aspects of protests in 2020 is the fact that

1:13:04almost every,

1:13:06the overwhelming majority of the people involved in the protests are

1:13:11carrying extraordinarily good video cameras with them at all times.

1:13:16Um, but the default and you know, the, the,

1:13:21the defaults are the defaults for a reason. Um,

1:13:26the default doesn't change for most people in the default for just about every

1:13:31camera I'm aware of. And certainly all iPhones is 10, 80 P,

1:13:3530 frames per second, but you can go to 60. Um,

1:13:40and I saw one of the things here in Philadelphia, um,

1:13:45you know, the, the famous art museum we have on our park,

1:13:49our Ben Franklin Parkway,

1:13:51where the steps are that Rocky Balboa ran up and cinematic.

1:13:56Fame, um, is it,

1:13:59but it's also where we have big public events like, uh,

1:14:03big concerts for the 4th of July when you can have concerts for the 4th of July.

1:14:08And it's also a great spot for protests because it's just this big,

1:14:13wide Boulevard Parkway. And anyway, somebody shot, um,

1:14:18a scene there and they clearly had their phone at 60 frames per second.

1:14:23And the difference, the,

1:14:25the you are there aspect of it was just unbelievable.

1:14:30It was like, holy crap. Like if you've got this,

1:14:34if you're going to shoot a protest footage or like news event footage and you

1:14:39can quick put your phone in 60 frames per second,

1:14:42that might be a fantastic idea.

1:14:44And it really also really helped with the handheld nature of it.

1:14:50And it wasn't that the footage that I saw that was 60 wasn't any kind of incident.

1:14:55It wasn't like, oh, here's the cops, you know,

1:14:59beating on a guy or, or here's protesters setting a car fire.

1:15:03It was just, Hey, look at this amazing crowd of people.

1:15:07But it was panning around, obviously handheld.

1:15:10And the panning just was just unbelievable at 60 frames per second in terms of

1:15:16convey conveying a sense of this is what it would be like to stand on that spot

1:15:20and pan your head.

1:15:21Yeah, that's incredible that what the subtleness,

1:15:25the subtlety that our brains can pick up on in terms of like the space between

1:15:29the frames. And I agree 60 frames per second for something like that is so much

1:15:34more immersive. Um, where, you know, and, and, and you started to,

1:15:38you start to think about like what, what are,

1:15:42what is the max where it doesn't matter anymore? Where is that?

1:15:44Where did the return start diminishing? Um, you know, you know,

1:15:48and then think about the fact that Canon just released an eight K pro consumer

1:15:53camera. Uh, and like, what, what,

1:15:57is that going to make everything feel that much more immersive or, or not?

1:16:01Yeah. Um, you know,

1:16:03typically high frame rates are so that you can slow them down to, um,

1:16:08you know, 24 and, and, and, and, uh, you know,

1:16:11distort time in that way and sort of make, make, uh,

1:16:15make a moment feel differently. But, um, I really like the,

1:16:19this idea because it starts to approach at 60 frames per second.

1:16:22It starts to approach sort of VR feeling without the VR.

1:16:26Yeah, definitely. That's absolutely the effect. It is sort of a,

1:16:30just looking at it on a simple,

1:16:34I say simple and there's somebody at Apple who's worked on like the HDR aspects

1:16:39with the OLED screen. It was like, that's not simple, but you know what I mean?

1:16:43It doesn't involve goggles or a curved screen or you know, any kind of 3d,

1:16:47but there is a VR like aspect to 60 frames per second.

1:16:50And I have to say before I forget, because I, I, again,

1:16:54I should have put it in the notes, but now I'll remember it.

1:16:56My funniest behind the scenes aspect of my show, um,

1:17:01which I have to say, and you say, well, why would you ever need an AK camera?

1:17:06You know, you can't, maybe you can't see it and the minimum screen size,

1:17:11you would need to be able to see the difference in quality from 4k is

1:17:16enormous, you know, and certainly wouldn't, you know,

1:17:19even if you had like a wall to wall TV in your living room,

1:17:23quite possibly wouldn't be large enough to see the difference and how many

1:17:26people are going to project their consumer shot video onto an

1:17:31actual cinema movie screen where maybe 8k would make a

1:17:35difference. But one thing you can do with 4k footage is you can crop.

1:17:40And so if you have a cave footage and you have, and it's, you know,

1:17:44you may not do it so much in a professionally shot thing,

1:17:48like what you do, because you're going to, you can plan everything out,

1:17:51but certainly if you're shooting news footage or like a protest or something

1:17:56like that, if you happen to capture something on 8k,

1:17:59but the detail is only a portion of the frame you can crop and you,

1:18:03instead of losing resolution, you can still keep it and broadcast it.

1:18:07And if you're broadcasting at 1080, you know,

1:18:10just a tiny fraction of the frame is, is, isn't losing any fidelity at all.

1:18:14And anyway, the thing I'm reminded of is

1:18:17the soda can. Yeah. So we,

1:18:23what was it a La Croix or something? What was the, I forget what it was.

1:18:26Not La Croix. I don't drink La Croix. It was a San Pellegrino.

1:18:30The San Pellegrino sells these fruity things.

1:18:33So I stressed inordinately probably too much over where to frame my end of the

1:18:40video and got some great advice from you,

1:18:44which was I had showed you a couple of places around my house and you're like,

1:18:47Hey dummy, just shoot it right here in the corner of your office.

1:18:50That looks great because that looks great. It's simple. It's you don't even,

1:18:54these other ideas are bad, you know? And again, that's not how,

1:18:58those aren't the words you said.

1:18:59The words you said made it seem like maybe I wasn't an idiot for suggesting some

1:19:03of the other spots, but I could read between the lines and figure it out.

1:19:06And then I shot it by my wife and my wife Amy. And she was like, yeah, he's right.

1:19:11That does look great. Why, you know,

1:19:12why do we pay all this money to get these nice slats on the side that we've got

1:19:16the cool thing on the one side of my office? Uh, why wouldn't you shoot there?

1:19:20And I was like, Oh yeah,

1:19:21I don't know why I went and shot footage in every other room in my house. Uh,

1:19:26so I set it up and of course it was nothing was looked like it was right.

1:19:30You saw the shot from like two days before and it was like, just like a,

1:19:33you know, like boxes and stuff. And I was like, well, Hey, you know, Amy,

1:19:36can you make this look good? And she was like, yes, I will make it look good.

1:19:39And I think your advice was just make sure there's some color. Uh,

1:19:44I think she did a good job. We had some nice stuff in there. She did great.

1:19:47It looked great. Um, but she really did. And she knocked her so, I mean she,

1:19:51and she didn't half ass it.

1:19:52She really spent a lot of time and because we had actually done the backstory is

1:19:56that my office got renovated, uh,

1:19:59the end of last year through the beginning of this year and literally wrapped up

1:20:03right when quarantine hit,

1:20:05like the timing could not have been more serendipitous in terms of like,

1:20:10if quarantine had hit like two weeks earlier, you know,

1:20:12and like whenever you have any kind of, uh,

1:20:15home improvement type stuff, the last like couple of days,

1:20:18everything comes together, you know,

1:20:20like there's all sorts of stuff that's mostly done,

1:20:24but then it doesn't get the finishing touch until the very end.

1:20:27So like two weeks would have been like,

1:20:29we would have had like the whole quarantine in a house that's covered with tarps

1:20:33and stuff like that. And instead we weren't. Um,

1:20:36but I've never, because I'm me,

1:20:40I've never fully unpacked my office stuff from the basement.

1:20:44So like I've got all this stuff I need to put on the shelves,

1:20:48the nice new shelves I have in my office, but haven't,

1:20:52and to look for nice stuff to put on the shelves.

1:20:55My wife really had to do a lot more work than you might think in terms of going

1:20:59through cardboard boxes with unhelpful

1:21:04names. And she made it look really nice.

1:21:08I really think it looked great.

1:21:09And I shot the interview with Jaws and Craig first,

1:21:13and then I had to shoot my opening, uh, where I thank the sponsors, uh,

1:21:18second and in between I was parched and got, got a soda and

1:21:22left it in, left it behind me

1:21:25and really just did not have it in theory.

1:21:31I could have just rerecorded the opening, but I just didn't have it in me.

1:21:34I was emotionally spent. I just, and I need,

1:21:37I wanted to turn this around quickly. And, but

1:21:40if it had been all me, I would have just said, ah,

1:21:44the hell with it is just soda can in the back. It's like a gag.

1:21:47But my wife had really knocked herself out to make it look as perfect as

1:21:51possible.

1:21:51I really felt like I'd be letting her down and you told me, don't worry,

1:21:56we can crop it out.

1:21:57Oh yeah. Yeah. I mean, that was, that was, uh, that was plan A.

1:22:01Plan B was actually just to patch it out, you know, just to

1:22:05motion Photoshop it, which wouldn't have been that hard either, but the crop,

1:22:11the crop did fine. Um, and yeah, we, we shoot in usually art,

1:22:16we shoot our commercials in either 4k or 3k and it's not really because they're

1:22:20planned out professionally. It, we do,

1:22:23we punch into shots all the time, um, to get, you know,

1:22:26closer or whatever, just, um, to be able to reframe.

1:22:30So it's really nice to have the extra, the extra resolution.

1:22:33Right. Yeah. I didn't mean to, I guess I didn't think about that, but yeah,

1:22:38I guess I do notice sometimes when I'm watching stuff that it probably wasn't a

1:22:41different setup,

1:22:42but just punched in to get slightly closer in an interview.

1:22:46Yeah. You can probably tell a little bit in very,

1:22:48very subtle ways by how,

1:22:50if you're cropping out the optical edges of the lens, um,

1:22:54you can sort of tell though,

1:22:57that's not what any actual lens looks like on the edges of the frame, right?

1:23:01But you know, not, not in, not in a way that you would ever really think about.

1:23:05Right. And if you're interested in the subject matter, that's the last, you know,

1:23:09if you're looking at the edges of the frame for optical distortion,

1:23:15the telltale sign of like an anamorphic lens or something like that,

1:23:18you're probably bored by whatever it is you're watching. Right.

1:23:22And that's very different from like your side as, you know, when,

1:23:26when you're in editing and you become so intimately familiar with every single

1:23:31shot in a way that you almost lose sense of the flow of the cinema when you get

1:23:38caught up on, you know,

1:23:41the specifics of how do we cut between these three things or, uh,

1:23:45but when you're just watching, you really should,

1:23:47if you're noticing the edges of the frame, you're probably bored.

1:23:50Yeah. Something, something went wrong. Yeah. So I rewatched the, um,

1:23:54the keynote this year and I, and I was just cause I, I,

1:23:59when we were talking about frame rates, I was got curious what,

1:24:02when if you had to go, if you had to guess, what would you say?

1:24:05Was it shot in 24 or 30?

1:24:08That's a partly what made me think about it because there was a sort of

1:24:12cinematic look to it, but I don't think it was 24.

1:24:17I think it was 30, but I don't know what they did. That's my guess.

1:24:20And I have not, I swear to you, I haven't cheated and looked,

1:24:23but my guess is they shot the keynote in 30,

1:24:26but there is something going on in post or some things going on in post that give

1:24:31it a movie like feel that makes me wonder.

1:24:38That's my guess. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean,

1:24:40I love that there was the whole meticulously composed sort of premeditated,

1:24:45um, feel to the whole thing. I actually do think, I mean,

1:24:50I'm going to guess, but I could be wrong and whatever.

1:24:52Then I lose my filmmaker license,

1:24:54but I do think it was shot in 24 frames per second. Um,

1:24:58I'm almost positive,

1:25:00especially looking at the opening stuff with Tim Cook in the, you know, in the,

1:25:06in the theater. Right.

1:25:09Well, hold that thought. I want to get back.

1:25:10Let's just go deep on the keynote and how they did it. But let me,

1:25:13let me take a break here and hit the money button. Um,

1:25:16and talk about our friends. It feels F E a L S. Do you experience stress?

1:25:22I do. I've told you about 10 different stressful things I've had in the last

1:25:25month. Uh, our anxiety, chronic pain, trouble sleeping.

1:25:29Even just once a week, you're not alone. Many people do feels F E a L S is

1:25:35premium C B D delivered directly to your doorstep.

1:25:39C B D from feels naturally reduce the stress, anxiety,

1:25:44pain, sleeplessness. All you do is take a few drops,

1:25:48put it under your tongue and you can feel the difference within minutes. Uh,

1:25:52they offer, if you're new to CBD, which a lot of people are,

1:25:55maybe most people are, you have a free hotline.

1:25:58You can call them up or text message them, ask your questions,

1:26:01and they'll tell you what they recommend. Uh,

1:26:04and it just is all natural. There's no high. It doesn't get you goofy.

1:26:09It's not like, uh, uh, drugs just de-stresses you.

1:26:14No high, no hangover, no addiction. I mean,

1:26:16it'd be something if they were selling something addictive, but it's not.

1:26:19And they have a membership program. You join the fields community.

1:26:22You get fields delivered to your door every month.

1:26:25You save money on every order by being a member. Um,

1:26:28really if you're interested, here's where you go to check them out.

1:26:31Feals.com fields.com/talk show.

1:26:35And this is really quite a deal.

1:26:38Fields.com/talk show gets you 50% off your first order and free

1:26:42shipping. I say, if they're giving you 50% off free shipping,

1:26:46you don't even need that, but they're giving it free shipping too.

1:26:48So that's feals.com/talk show 50% taken off your first order

1:26:54with free shipping.

1:26:54This is a real interesting brand color. I'm on the website.

1:26:59I don't think I've ever seen that as a brand color before.

1:27:02Kind of like that bright beige foundation, like makeup foundation color.

1:27:07Hmm. It is. And it sort of has like a hint of orange to it.

1:27:11Yeah. A little orange. Yeah. It is an interesting brand color.

1:27:15Kind of like it.

1:27:17I look at that and you look at that. It's seed. Now you've got me thinking,

1:27:21you got me thinking like you, uh, but if you scroll down, there's,

1:27:26there's a young woman here about halfway down the page and, uh,

1:27:29she's got like a potted plant next door. The pot. Oh yeah. Same color.

1:27:34Yeah. Picks up the color. Yeah. You're right. Yeah.

1:27:36Right there with the package. Um, so the keynote,

1:27:43I, yeah, this is, it was in hindsight,

1:27:47and I've rewatched the actual keynote again. So I watched it live.

1:27:52Nobody knew it was gonna, what it was going to be like.

1:27:56Uh, I expected something sort of like this.

1:28:00I know there were a lot of people and I was, I guess I should have to,

1:28:04to get my being right points should have posted about it on daring fireball.

1:28:09Um, but like the night before I tweeted my predictions for how they would do it,

1:28:14like the basic mechanics of how they would do it.

1:28:16And most of the people seem to be under the belief that I was crazy.

1:28:19Cause I thought it was going to look like, you remember,

1:28:21did you see the video when they did the, um,

1:28:24they came out with the magic keyboard, uh, for the iPad in March,

1:28:28you know, the keyboard cover and you can snap it in. And then they, they,

1:28:32they had like a little video where they showed everybody in it.

1:28:35And then they had a video of Craig Federighi somewhere in apple park with the

1:28:39glass, you know,

1:28:41atrium behind them in the sunny area of apple park behind them introducing it

1:28:46pre-filmed obviously, you know, very professional looking,

1:28:51sort of like what you would vaguely think Craig Federighi in an office at apple

1:28:56park doing a commercial for the magic keyboard would look like.

1:29:01I, you know, I was like, I think that's what the whole keynote will be like.

1:29:05And I was a little off because I didn't,

1:29:08I didn't really foresee that they would actually shoot it in the Steve jobs

1:29:12theater, which is like the main staging ground for most of it. Um,

1:29:16but most people seem to think what they would do is just do it like a regular

1:29:20in-person keynote and just not have an audience or have an audience of apple

1:29:25employees wearing masks and sparsely spread apart, which I was like,

1:29:30there's no way they're going to do that. A it's illegal in California. I mean,

1:29:34really it's, it's, you know, it just shows again,

1:29:37without getting political about it, how people in America,

1:29:41so many people don't understand the seriousness of the quarantine.

1:29:47But even if it wasn't by the books, illegal in Cupertino,

1:29:51California to have people have your employees deem them essential,

1:29:55come in and clap. Uh,

1:29:59it's just bad optics. If you're trying to, you know, be on team,

1:30:04let's take this serious and truly, you know,

1:30:07isolate people and shoot this in the safest way possible. You can't do it.

1:30:10And having a truly empty audience and doing the keynote,

1:30:15like just filming the day before rehearsal,

1:30:19it would come across like death on video, right?

1:30:23Like something that's meant to have an audience and applause

1:30:28can't just be photographed without the audience and applause. It's,

1:30:33it's just, I don't even know how to explain why that wouldn't work,

1:30:36but it wouldn't work. And of course that's not what they did.

1:30:39It would have been like that. Do you remember the, uh,

1:30:44the rip mix burn commercial where the,

1:30:46that the kid sits in the audience and then invites all his favorite artists to

1:30:51come up on stage? I don't think I do. Oh yeah. This was,

1:30:55uh, this is, it was an iTunes commercial and I, you know,

1:30:59I want to say maybe 2000, 2001.

1:31:02And this teenage kid who's the user,

1:31:05the Apple user sits in the audience of a big, you know, classic theater.

1:31:10And then like George Clinton. Oh yeah. Yeah. I don't know who else,

1:31:15you know, but you know, probably smash mouth or something. Uh,

1:31:18I'll come up on the stage cause he's, cause he's putting together his, uh,

1:31:23you know, his playlist. George Clinton triggered it for me because yeah,

1:31:27it cuts a very distinctive figure. Yeah. Right.

1:31:31There was only one Apple commercial with George Clinton. Right. And it, uh,

1:31:35cuts. Yeah. But, uh, you know,

1:31:38what they did was so super high production value. I mean, it's just a crazy.

1:31:43And you know, and it's in contrast,

1:31:47it just is very appley to do it that way,

1:31:50to take it as seriously as they can and not use this as an excuse to cut corners

1:31:55and sort of phone in the keynote,

1:32:00but to actually quite possibly put significantly more effort into the staging.

1:32:07I, you know, to be honest, I guess it's incredible. It's a feat. It's a,

1:32:12it's like an incredible feat what they pulled off. I don't know how,

1:32:15how they did it, but, and I'm, I'm, I'm actually looking at this, uh,

1:32:19the Apple, uh, sorry,

1:32:21the magic keyboard video that you referenced and interestingly enough,

1:32:26it looks like a lot of the same setup except this one is 30 for,

1:32:29I would say this is 30 frames per second, the magic keyboard one.

1:32:32And you can sort of see it, the,

1:32:35the subtle difference between the that and dub dub keynote, which is,

1:32:40now I I'm pretty convinced is 24,

1:32:42but the lighting and the lensing and everything looks pretty similar.

1:32:46Yeah, that was my guess. Uh, and I think it was sort of a dry run, but I do,

1:32:51but I also feel though that they,

1:32:54they plussed it up a lot for the keynote and what that magic video looks like.

1:33:00Did you watch any just regular WWDC sessions?

1:33:04I didn't. Uh, but that, that's what most, a lot of them look like, uh,

1:33:08and the sessions just, you know, are staged,

1:33:11but they're not all in the same room either.

1:33:13There's a tremendous amount of variety in where they shot them at Apple park

1:33:18just to have the speakers in different backgrounds. Um, yeah,

1:33:22there's the funny,

1:33:23the funniest part for me of the keynote was,

1:33:28I don't know if you remember, but they, when they, um,

1:33:32when they, they cut from Craig to, uh,

1:33:36like a drone fly out,

1:33:38like some high speed drone flyovers of Apple park and then it's sort of like the

1:33:42camera goes into the fitness center and you land,

1:33:46it sort of comes around the corner. And the funny,

1:33:49the part that makes it funny is that they've got this very matrixy music like

1:33:53down, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, you know, like that,

1:33:55like an I speed action movie and it comes around the corner and then just

1:34:00reveals, you know, Kevin Lynch,

1:34:02who is not an action hero by any stretch.

1:34:07It was almost like a comic reveal, but I don't think it was intended to be. Right.

1:34:11But I kind of loved that.

1:34:13I love that there was that amount of care and like sort of cinema cinematic

1:34:17forethought into, into every move, into every cut and like swish, you know,

1:34:21matching swish pans and all that and all that stuff.

1:34:24I just thought it was really excellent. And I tried to, um,

1:34:28I got in touch with the one person I know who's on the inside at the, you know,

1:34:33at Apple in the video, um,

1:34:35the video realm and tried to get some insight information, but,

1:34:39but exactly what you said there being tight lipped about it was how it was

1:34:42actually executed. Yeah. Which is kind of stinks because it,

1:34:47it's my explanation for a lot of Apple's secrecy is

1:34:53it really comes down to the adage that

1:34:58you know how you create a culture of being able to keep a secret.

1:35:02You just don't talk about anything. Right.

1:35:06It's actually not that complicated and it, you know, and it's sort of like the,

1:35:10the whole COVID-19 thing, like, you know what the best thing we can do is it sucks.

1:35:15It's really sucks, but it's actually not complicated.

1:35:19Stay home. If you do go out, stay apart and wear a mask and wash your hands a lot.

1:35:26And it's like that actually would knock it out if everybody did it.

1:35:29So it's like the basic idea that they've internalized is they do want to keep

1:35:34important strategic stuff or marketing stuff, right?

1:35:38Like they don't want to talk about products cause they want to unveil them with

1:35:42a big surprise and they don't want to talk about the things that they consider

1:35:47trade secrets to how they do what they do.

1:35:50But then that leads them to also be secretive about things that I don't think

1:35:56there's any even strategic value in being secret about.

1:35:59But they just like, yeah, why take a chance? You know?

1:36:04Yeah. I mean,

1:36:05it could be really interesting and educational to a lot of people to learn how

1:36:09they pulled this off. And I'm, I'm, I mean, some of it is obvious.

1:36:14They, they obviously have one of the most beautiful campuses in the,

1:36:18in the world as their soundstage. Right. And, you know,

1:36:22they use pretty probably commonly available production gear and an actual crew.

1:36:27And then they like, you know,

1:36:29they did things that you wouldn't normally do in a, in a, in a live event,

1:36:33which is that they have it on the cap,

1:36:34the camera on a dolly or a slider and they're just moving the slider back and

1:36:38forth because, you know,

1:36:39that keeps the camera feeling alive and dynamic and that's almost like one Oh

1:36:44one film, you know, kickstarter filmmaking kind of stuff.

1:36:49But then then you get into the question of whether they did any sort of live or

1:36:54more, more robust compositing of virtual elements against the live action

1:37:01people. And that's where my mind started going.

1:37:05And that's where it started to get interesting to me.

1:37:07And I think you and I even probably texted about it,

1:37:10which is how much if any of this environment that Craig is in for the main stuff

1:37:17is is virtual, like is it,

1:37:19is this the actual live set and every reflection and every, you know,

1:37:24piece of architectural detail is actually there and real including the,

1:37:30the video display behind him.

1:37:31Cause I have no doubt that Apple probably has the display technology to,

1:37:35you know, throw you know, in real time throw incredible,

1:37:40you know augmented visuals behind him like a concert or something.

1:37:46But I don't think that that happened.

1:37:48So I'm thinking that at least that was composited behind him and which is

1:37:53interesting cause then you see the reflections of the thing on the floor,

1:37:57which helps sell the effect.

1:37:59But then there's a world in which they did something sort of like the

1:38:02Mandalorian, which is not necessarily with you know,

1:38:07what Mandalorian did,

1:38:08which is the highest level of what's called virtual production,

1:38:12which is where the entire studio is, is filled, is surrounded by these led displays,

1:38:17these really powerful,

1:38:20super bright led displays that are rendering in real time with this in CG,

1:38:25what the environment would be of the world they're shooting in,

1:38:28because then that ends up lighting the the characters in the foreground.

1:38:32So I don't think that that's what's going on because really the lighting set up

1:38:36for Craig or for any of the that quote unquote talent in the keynote,

1:38:41the lighting is pretty simple. It's, it's sort of like just overhead lighting.

1:38:46And it's like slightly directional and soft.

1:38:49So they wouldn't have to do anything fancy with interactive lighting,

1:38:53but they could have been on a green stage. And you know,

1:38:58like sort of the middle level of the,

1:38:59a virtual production is where you're shooting against green with a live action

1:39:04performer and the camera moves around on a,

1:39:07on a crane or a dolly like it is in this.

1:39:10And the background is tracking in real time to, to,

1:39:15to that live action footage. And you know, it's really not,

1:39:19it's we architectural stuff and environments can be rendered

1:39:24so well with pretty democratized tools these days.

1:39:28I even like,

1:39:31I did a pro like a design project in my backyard with a landscape company and

1:39:36they used some software to rent to pre-visualize what this design would look like

1:39:40in my, in my backyard and with like off the shelf tools.

1:39:43And it looked so astoundingly real like photo real with lens flares and

1:39:48everything. So, I mean,

1:39:49there's a part of me that kind of wants to believe that this is how they did it

1:39:53or at least part of it with this keynote. And if they didn't do it this time,

1:39:57then certainly they will in the future.

1:39:59Or certainly like a lot of us in production will be doing stuff like that.

1:40:02Yeah.

1:40:04I think when you and I first started texting about it,

1:40:06we were specifically wondering if the displays, the big, you know,

1:40:11mostly black slide displays behind the presenters were really

1:40:16there. And, you know, again, like you said, they certainly could,

1:40:21it would be well within their budget to do it and well within,

1:40:25and if that was the answer, if they decided this is what we want it to look like,

1:40:30what's the best way to make it look like it.

1:40:32And the answer was to do it practically. Let's put a real screen there.

1:40:36They would have done it. I mean, it's within certainly Apple would do it.

1:40:40I mean, I've heard stories about the screen at the main screen in the Steve Jobs

1:40:45theater where, you know, they had a fantastic screen and then they,

1:40:49they replaced it. Not because there was something wrong with the other screen,

1:40:52but that they already figured out that they could get a better screen.

1:40:56And so they did like,

1:40:57they couldn't stand not having the best screen they could possibly have.

1:41:00So they replaced it and I'm sure, I guess somebody else could buy it.

1:41:03I don't know. Or if it's just, are you in the market? Yeah.

1:41:07Just for 120 or just slice it up into, you know,

1:41:11like a hundred pieces and send it out to your, to the biggest supporters. Right.

1:41:15But I think they give away, they had it, but they had that screen.

1:41:19If it was practical, they had one behind Tim Cook on the stage,

1:41:23which is permanent. So there's a real screen there. That's no problem.

1:41:25But then they had one out in what I call the hands-on area,

1:41:29which is underground,

1:41:31which is where we first you pull out of the back of the theater.

1:41:34And then there you're there in this big white circular room, um,

1:41:39which is lit from above by, by some natural light.

1:41:43And then they went up the stairs, you know,

1:41:46with the gag where Craig runs up the stairs,

1:41:48but he runs and that's where you're in what I, I,

1:41:51I don't know if they have official names for these rooms.

1:41:53I call that the atrium. It's like the lobby, you know, like they don't,

1:41:57like when you go to an event there,

1:41:59that area where you are surrounded by glass walls and you can

1:42:04see the,

1:42:06the actual park aspects of Apple's campus,

1:42:12you know, the grass and the trees and everything,

1:42:15that's just for mingling. Like there's nothing really there.

1:42:20So would they set up a screen there too? Well, Apple might,

1:42:23but once you put it in my head that maybe the screen wasn't there,

1:42:26I was like, whoa. And then, then you get into, wait,

1:42:31are they even there? Like maybe it's not just the screen,

1:42:34but are the presenters actually there?

1:42:37And it's not that the footage looks phony.

1:42:40It's that it looks so glossy and well-produced that it's,

1:42:45I don't know how you would tell.

1:42:48Yeah. I don't know.

1:42:49Like the giveaway for the screen being a replaced screen is probably just how

1:42:53deep the blacks were behind him. Cause, cause you wouldn't,

1:42:56you wouldn't really,

1:42:57if you're photographing and exposing every other shadow the way they're exposed

1:43:01in this, in the footage,

1:43:03then you wouldn't be able to underexpose the screen that that deep.

1:43:07Right.

1:43:09That's probably why I would, I would vote for that.

1:43:11The screen was all replaced and then they don't have to pre-program and live,

1:43:15you know, live display everything timed to his performance.

1:43:19Cause I don't think that that's in, that's definitely not any breezy task either,

1:43:24is getting all of these non-professional actors to do that much dialogue.

1:43:28Obviously they have teleprompters and stuff, but just the, the,

1:43:31the inordinate number of takes that they must do to get each line in the

1:43:36script for what is essentially a feature length presentation.

1:43:40Well, and I know that even for a normal keynote,

1:43:45that they rehearse a lot,

1:43:47like that's another one of those very simple answers to a very seemingly very

1:43:51complex question of how do they put out these polished keynotes and

1:43:56it's rehearse, rehearse, rehearse.

1:43:58But I can't help, but think that like,

1:44:02however much time Craig Federighi spends preparing and rehearsing

1:44:07for a regular WWDC keynote,

1:44:10he'd spent more time on this because it,

1:44:14it's just the production aspects of it are just on top of

1:44:19however much content he's delivering, which is the same or more,

1:44:24you know, the,

1:44:25the actual mechanics of doing the production are more complicated.

1:44:29But then how, you know, I guess on my list, I always come up with,

1:44:34you know, and I don't know that again,

1:44:35it falls under things they probably don't want to talk about,

1:44:38but how in the world are you still doing your job?

1:44:41Which I'm, I really have a good sense is probably keeps him busy as

1:44:47the senior vice president of all software that they're producing.

1:44:52Well, this is interesting. Yeah.

1:44:54This is an interesting point because I don't know if you picked, if you,

1:44:57if you had the same you know, feeling, but later on in the keynote,

1:45:02when he gets to the Mac OS stuff, to me,

1:45:04that's where he feels most comfortable.

1:45:06And I don't know if that's because of the history,

1:45:09his history of the actual, his actual day job.

1:45:12You would know more about this than me, but,

1:45:16everything leading up to that,

1:45:17all the iOS stuff and the other platforms felt

1:45:22more like showmanship to him. And then when, to me,

1:45:26when it gets into the Mac OS,

1:45:27that's where he feels like he's speaking his native language.

1:45:30I don't know that I ever thought of that directly,

1:45:34but I, I agree with you in thinking about it.

1:45:38And I think you're exactly right.

1:45:40Why is that he is a tremendous

1:45:44stage presence is, you know, very, as his face is a handsome son of a bitch.

1:45:49And he has a great voice and a very wide stance.

1:45:54And he just is, you know,

1:45:56he's very good on camera and he's good on stage,

1:45:58but he's good on stage for someone who is

1:46:04an incredibly competent and

1:46:07believably, deeply knowledgeable

1:46:13software executive. I mean, like, I mean,

1:46:16and his multiple appearances on my show, I mean,

1:46:18my favorite was the one a couple of years ago where we went into the

1:46:22differential privacy aspects

1:46:27and the explaining this sort of comp,

1:46:33you know, the way that the encryption and can be used to

1:46:39aggregate the collection of data for the good of all users.

1:46:43But in a way that isn't just take our word for it privacy,

1:46:47but it's like mathematically provable privacy that we,

1:46:51we can't make a bug or have an error or have a, you know,

1:46:55like Twitter have a controls panel where there's a switch that some doofus or,

1:47:00you know, crook with a hundred dollar bill slipped in his pocket can uncheck to

1:47:05reveal the address of the user who submitted this information,

1:47:09thinking it was going to be submitted privately.

1:47:11His explanation for how that worked is like, I can't believe, you know, that,

1:47:15you know, that you just have this on the tip of your tip of your mind.

1:47:18Yeah. Incredibly smart, dude. That was before they went,

1:47:21they went to San Jose, right? That was when you're still in San Francisco.

1:47:24I think that was the last one in San Francisco. Right.

1:47:27And he really, I mean, he really knows it. I mean, it really, I mean,

1:47:31it's like he knows this stuff and it's like all the way across the board of

1:47:35everything Apple is doing and you know,

1:47:37the graphics stuff and he can speak at length at all of that.

1:47:40And yet he's got time to, to star in a movie.

1:47:44Yeah. Well, I think that they all know, including all the, you know,

1:47:49senior execs and everything, they all know that this is part of the job.

1:47:52This is sort of what you sign up for when your Apple, um, leadership is,

1:47:57that it's, you're, you're an evangelist and not, not just in a trade show,

1:48:02kind of way, but really you rep in a, in a global way, you represent the,

1:48:06the products you're working on to the world, which makes me,

1:48:10I mean, obviously they're all working executives in,

1:48:14in the technology industry,

1:48:16so they can't be expected to be brilliant presenters.

1:48:21I do wish that they would sort of shake up the cadence,

1:48:24the Apple presentational cadence a little bit, um, uh,

1:48:28and not feel the pressure to

1:48:33maybe like reproduce or mimic the, you know, the standard,

1:48:39if you did, does that make sense what I'm saying? That sort of like,

1:48:43we can't wait to show you what we're working on and that's, you know,

1:48:49FaceTime, you know, like that cadence that they all kind of like,

1:48:52it's almost like in, in, um, they're doing it because they're,

1:48:56they feel like that's the only solution, but there are, well,

1:49:01first of all, going back to Steve and his presentational style was not that at

1:49:05all. We, Claude and JP and I, uh,

1:49:09who worked for me, we were just this last weekend, we, um,

1:49:14we watched, uh, the G4 Cube, um, keynote,

1:49:19and we're just marveling at, uh,

1:49:22how natural and unrehearsed and unscripted Steve

1:49:27seems. And we were just, you know, just kind of like all of our,

1:49:32our hearts sort of, you know, like kind of exploded a little bit when we watched

1:49:37that and just remembering where we were at the time. But,

1:49:39but also like it was the antithesis of this extremely meticulously

1:49:44composed, um, uh, you know,

1:49:46just style of speech and presentation that they have now.

1:49:49But there are a few, I don't know, I took note of a few of the outliers, um,

1:49:54in the, in the whole cast of characters that presented and like,

1:50:00um, I don't know if you remembered, um, Vera Carr, but she's the, uh,

1:50:04the health software manager. She's, she's sort of in a yoga position.

1:50:08Oh yes. On the floor. Yeah. She was awesome.

1:50:11Like she just came off as very natural and looked and sounded great, um,

1:50:15in her environment. And then, um, the guy in the home, in the living room too,

1:50:20Yoc Kaysen, I think the home kit guy was awesome.

1:50:23I, what I remember about Vera Carr was that she felt very

1:50:28natural, but also it was more striking about that was that it also seemed like

1:50:32she was in the most unnatural position of any of them. Right.

1:50:35Yeah. Which is good, which is good. I mean, from a directorial standpoint,

1:50:40sometimes sometimes that's what you do to shake somebody out of their

1:50:45complacency.

1:50:46Yeah, I do think,

1:50:49and it is an interesting thing from a film school perspective of sort of,

1:50:55uh, what's the word did the deconstruct deconstructing the,

1:51:00the Apple keynote style that they went from the Steve notes to where they are

1:51:06now without any sort of needle on a record scratching.

1:51:13Here's where Steve left, right? Yeah. You know,

1:51:19there was never any,

1:51:21sort of, Oh, as soon as he left, they got different.

1:51:24They evolved to this sort of platonic ideal of the modern post Steve jobs

1:51:30keynote. Right. Um,

1:51:35one of the ones that really sticks out to me in terms of like,

1:51:39you know, and it's that whole slow boiling frog phenomenon,

1:51:45which I whenever I mentioned is actually not true,

1:51:48that if you're going to be a director,

1:51:49and is actually not true, that if you put frogs in a pot and slowly boil it,

1:51:53they will jump out. They're like, Oh shit.

1:51:56It's just like when you're in a hot tub and it's like,

1:52:01if somebody does have it too hot, it's like, you know, you're like, Hey,

1:52:04turn that down. And then if nobody turns it down, you do get out, you know,

1:52:07but it is in a useful analogy and people, you know what I'm talking about.

1:52:12And I always, the thing I always bring it up with is whenever I try a new iPhone

1:52:16and I, you know, like the, you know, idiot tech reviewer that I am,

1:52:21I get to review one every year.

1:52:22I never really noticed that the new ones faster until like 10 days after I start

1:52:28using it and I put it down and go back to my year, one year old,

1:52:34I've personal iPhone because I, you know, I've got the review one, you know,

1:52:3910 days before they come out. So I don't own a new one yet.

1:52:42And I go back to my old one and then I'm like, Oh, this,

1:52:45it's like a little slower. Like I can tell when I'm typing on the thumb keyboard,

1:52:49you know, wow. You know, and every year it's the same.

1:52:52And every year I can tell it's a little faster, but you know, five, six,

1:52:56seven, eight years ago, it was even more noticeable year over year.

1:52:59But it's always when you go back and I think when you go back to older

1:53:03keynotes, you can see the difference a lot more than when,

1:53:05as we go forward.

1:53:06And the one that sticks out to me is the greatest keynote of all time.

1:53:11The one that everybody always wanted, then it was happened.

1:53:15And then everybody wants it to happen again,

1:53:17which was the unveiling of the iPhone. Right.

1:53:20Everybody always wanted a keynote where Apple,

1:53:23it shows us something that seems not just too good to be true a little

1:53:28bit, but like, this can't possibly be real.

1:53:31People are passing out in the aisles like a, you know, you know,

1:53:35preacher thing where they're taking demons out of you. People are fainting,

1:53:40gasping, uh, you know, the Blackberry rivals hold a meeting the next day

1:53:46and conclude that the whole thing, believe it or not,

1:53:49must be a fraud because there's no way that they could be, they,

1:53:52that this could be a real device, uh, that keynote.

1:53:56But when you actually rewatch that whole keynote,

1:54:00not just the clips of Steve jobs unveiling the phone,

1:54:03but watch the whole thing it's paced so bizarrely by

1:54:08modern standards.

1:54:09He just comes out and like does like us do an update on iTunes and I forget what

1:54:14it is first. I don't even remember, but it's like,

1:54:15there's like 20 to 30 minutes of just like crazy,

1:54:20just run of the mill stuff before he, well,

1:54:25which, which were, which we had patients for back then. Right. You know,

1:54:29which in the same way that, um,

1:54:32a late night talk show could be Dick Cavett and like 15 second pauses in between

1:54:37a question and an answer and, and people smoking cigarettes.

1:54:40We just had patients in ways that we don't have patients these, these days.

1:54:44And that's why this is kind of like modern day format for the keynote makes more

1:54:47sense.

1:54:48It does make more sense. And there's an absolute, if they had,

1:54:52let's just say, you know, that they've got AR goggles and that they're,

1:54:57they know it, they've, they're in the lab and the people work.

1:55:00Maybe there's some of the same people even, right.

1:55:02It hasn't been that long, same people.

1:55:04And they've got that sense that this is, this is the iPhone again, right?

1:55:08These goggles are way beyond what people are thinking. Um,

1:55:13you know,

1:55:13like people think you're just going to put glasses on and in the corner of your

1:55:16eye, it'll tell you what the air temperature is, you know,

1:55:19and if you get a text message, there's a notification at the top.

1:55:22And that's what everybody thinks in the way that everybody thought in 2006,

1:55:26that they were going to make an iPod that can make phone calls. Right.

1:55:31And instead they had the iPhone,

1:55:34maybe the goggles are that good. Yeah.

1:55:37There is no way that they would announce that like they announced the iPhone.

1:55:41It's it just,

1:55:43it just would be such a totally different event. It would be,

1:55:48it would be tasteful. So I was going to use the word bombastic,

1:55:53and that's not right. Cause bombastic implies a sort of crassness,

1:55:57but it would be, I don't know,

1:56:02it would be dramatic in a way that this wasn't

1:56:07dramatic. Like I just can't.

1:56:09I think that Steve's Steve's Steve's gift was, I mean,

1:56:14of many was to shape a narrative,

1:56:16like to frame a piece of technology in a narrative

1:56:21involving all of technology.

1:56:23And I think that that's why the iPhone introduction made

1:56:27such beautiful, um,

1:56:30evolutionary sense in the way that it did. And you watch this keynote, you know,

1:56:34I mean, obviously this is dub dub. This is,

1:56:36this is not a product announcement type of a keynote, but

1:56:40um, I feel like if they're, if they're honoring, um,

1:56:45Steve and the story that is Apple,

1:56:48then they're going to figure out how to frame the new device,

1:56:52whatever it is in the context of an entire history of Apple and of

1:56:56tech in general.

1:56:58Yeah. I wonder if this

1:57:02quarantine induced novel, new keynote might not,

1:57:09I know a lot of people are wondering if,

1:57:11if Apple liked it enough that maybe they're always going to do virtual WWDCs

1:57:16again, quarantine or not.

1:57:19And I can kind of see it from the, uh, you know,

1:57:23I think the keynote, I don't,

1:57:25I think that they like the crowd and they like doing it on stage.

1:57:29Um, so I don't see them doing away with that for everything for the

1:57:35actual conference for developers and the presentations.

1:57:40I could see that. Um, I,

1:57:43the sessions I've watched so far are so they're, they're always good.

1:57:47And again, and, and it's always very cool because the people,

1:57:52this is just, I mean, this is as long as there's been WWDC,

1:57:56the people doing the presentations of the people responsible for the work,

1:57:59right? Like they don't have like a presentation team and you know,

1:58:04Joe and Kate from the presentation team are told, okay,

1:58:07you're going to do the new, you know,

1:58:09text editing for right to left languages, hired talent.

1:58:14Right.

1:58:15They're the actual engineers who worked on this new thing and it's

1:58:20always very cool. And sometimes the enthusiasm really spills over,

1:58:25and really helps polish over the fact that they're not professional presenters.

1:58:29It's because, Hey, you know,

1:58:31they've been working on this thing for three years and it's,

1:58:34it wasn't even there,

1:58:36even in their wildest dreams wasn't going to be in the keynote because it's

1:58:39super technically nerdy type thing. Um, you know,

1:58:43WWDC sessions are full of stuff like that,

1:58:46but the people watching the session are self-selective.

1:58:50The only people who are going to watch the session on a new right to left

1:58:54language API, uh, or you know,

1:58:57something that'll let you write Swift UI code that will run both on a watch and

1:59:02on the phone, um, and on the iPod,

1:59:08our iPad and on the Mac and Holy crap,

1:59:11it's one UI system for all of that, blah, blah, blah.

1:59:13The only people who are going to watch that are the people who want to use it.

1:59:16You're right. That's, they're speaking to their people.

1:59:20It's all very cool, but I think that letting them prerecorded,

1:59:24you know,

1:59:25and it would only be better without quarantine where they don't have to worry

1:59:29about onset all of the precautions that have to be done.

1:59:33It would be so much more comforting for them to have a normal set where people

1:59:38can come up and, and fix their hair, you know, and, and just,

1:59:42you know what I mean? Do you do that?

1:59:44You see this a thousand times every single day that you're in production is

1:59:49somebody will go up and say, Hey, you know what? His collar is not right.

1:59:53And then it fixed the collar. Yeah. Get the hair. Yeah.

1:59:55And you can't do that with the quarantine. Right. It's, or you gotta, you know,

1:59:58no, we literally on our, on the thing we just shot,

2:00:01which was our first thing back on a small set was we,

2:00:04we couldn't have hair and makeup because that person would have to be too close

2:00:08to people. Right. So it would only be better, but then it takes away.

2:00:12The thing that was so palpable to me watching the sessions I've watched is that

2:00:15the stage fright being in front of 500 live people in front of you,

2:00:20or even if it's a smaller session, a hundred people, it's just people who,

2:00:23I get nervous and I do talks every once in a while.

2:00:27Somebody who's never spoken in front of 300 people before,

2:00:31you're going to be nervous, right? It, that nerves is all out of there.

2:00:34And I think that the sessions I've,

2:00:36I hadn't seen anybody who thought otherwise every single comment I've seen on

2:00:40the sessions themselves this year was that it was better and more palatable and

2:00:45more enjoyable and more informative to watch.

2:00:48And the other thing that they did, which was really awesome,

2:00:52in the physical conference of WWDC there, it's like,

2:00:56it's like scheduling TV.

2:00:58You've got half hour blocks and you can have an hour session or a half hour

2:01:03session,

2:01:03but there's WWDC videos this year that are like 13 minutes because it's,

2:01:08you have 13 minutes worth of stuff,

2:01:10do a 13 minute video and there's no reason to pad it out to 30 or say,

2:01:15we can't really do this at WWDC because it doesn't fill a 30 minute slot.

2:01:19You know?

2:01:20Yeah. Oh, that's so fascinating. I'm so glad it worked out. Yeah.

2:01:24I love it. All right. Let me take one last break here.

2:01:28Thank our good friends at Linode L I N O D E.

2:01:33I used to think it was pronounced line node cause that's what it looks like,

2:01:36but it's not. It's Linode because it's like a node that hosts Linux,

2:01:41but I used to also think Linux was Linux.

2:01:44So it really anything it really just goes to show that anything I can risk

2:01:47pronounce, I will.

2:01:48But what Linode is, is world-class hosting for

2:01:56servers.

2:01:56Literally that is where I host Daring Fireball. Couldn't be happier with them.

2:02:02Really love their service. I love everything about it.

2:02:05I even love the control panel. It's set up.

2:02:08It's so nice and easy for even a dingbat like me who should not be allowed near

2:02:13the controls of a server can see it and understand what's going on.

2:02:17They've got 11 data centers worldwide, enterprise grade hardware,

2:02:21their next generation network. Uh, it's all just excellent.

2:02:25But the servers around the world, it's important.

2:02:29Maybe you've got something that you want to be as close as possible.

2:02:31Keep the, keep the latency down. Maybe for legal reasons,

2:02:36like some kind of HIPAA type thing or wherever you are,

2:02:38you've got to store your records in a certain country.

2:02:41You can do that with Linode. Um, really that's super useful.

2:02:46Uh,

2:02:48they've got plans that start at just five bucks a month and it's really a useful

2:02:53plane. I think I had a $5 a month plan. What the hell are you gonna do with that?

2:02:57There's an awful lot of uses for having your own server where their $5 nanode

2:03:02plan is all you need. Super useful, super fun.

2:03:06Uh, everything from work,

2:03:09hosting something like your website like I do with during fireball or database

2:03:14type thing or hosting an API or doing something that's real serious and you're

2:03:18getting paid to do it or something fun like hosting a Minecraft server for your

2:03:22kids. Um, or you super fun,

2:03:26super easy to do and they make it really easy to install stuff like serious

2:03:31software for work, like WordPress or fun stuff like Minecraft.

2:03:35All of it easy to install all through their cloud manager.

2:03:39You get root access. It's all serious. It's all,

2:03:42anything you want to do that would, you know, involve pseudo-ing. You can do it.

2:03:47Uh, if you don't even know what pseudo is, they'll, you know,

2:03:50you don't have to worry about it. Uh,

2:03:52they've got an API and a $20 discount by using the code.

2:03:58Talk show 20 T A L K S H O W two zero $20 credit.

2:04:03They've got the $5 a month plan.

2:04:08That means you get four months free four months just by using the code.

2:04:12Uh, they're also hiring, still hiring. They're always hiring, uh,

2:04:17linode.com/careers. Find out more.

2:04:20If you're like a system administrator type or anybody who, if,

2:04:23if you have career aspirations that involve working for Linode,

2:04:28you know it, but go check it out. It's a great place to work.

2:04:31They've actually got their headquarters here in Philadelphia,

2:04:33but you don't have to be here to work for them. Anyway, go to,

2:04:38linode.com/the talk show.

2:04:42That's how you know you came from here. Linode.com/the talk show.

2:04:46And when you sign up, remember that code talk show 20.

2:04:49That'll save you the 20 bucks.

2:04:52My thanks to Linode for sponsoring the show. Um,

2:04:57the last thing I wanted to talk to you about, and I think I,

2:05:02I don't even know who else in the repertoire of friends,

2:05:07and guests I've had on the show who I would,

2:05:10who I would love to hear thoughts on this enough.

2:05:13You've already changed my mind in the last 24 hours on some of this,

2:05:16are the sounds in Mac OS X Big Sur. Um,

2:05:21so for the first time in a very long time,

2:05:23maybe some of these sounds are like back to classic Mac OS,

2:05:28like Sosumi, uh,

2:05:31for all of the visual changes that Mac OS X just used the

2:05:36original name and carry it through through OS X and Mac OS and everything.

2:05:41But what we now call Mac or Mac OS was OS X.

2:05:45And before that was Mac OS X.

2:05:46The sounds like for like the default alerts and what happens when you move

2:05:50something to the trash, haven't really changed in a very long time.

2:05:54And they did in Big Sur.

2:05:55And people have strong feelings about these sounds.

2:05:59And, and what, what are your strong feelings?

2:06:05Well, so there's two sets and I've got these videos. Uh,

2:06:10I'm not even sure. What do you think? Should we play them on the show?

2:06:13I think maybe we should. It's like,

2:06:15it seems like if you're listening to a podcast, you should be able to hear them.

2:06:18Yeah, that makes sense. Or, uh, or, or Caleb can cut them in.

2:06:22Hey, Interlude here.

2:06:25I'm going to play the sound effects from Big Sur that Adam and I are going to be

2:06:28talking about.

2:06:29You can hear them right here in your own ears and then you'll know what we're

2:06:32talking about. Um,

2:06:35so there's two sets first are the system sounds,

2:06:38which are for events like moving something to the trash or taking a screenshot.

2:06:43And then there are the alerts,

2:06:44which are just the sounds you can pick for the system beep. Um,

2:06:49I'll run through them all. I'll introduce them. But in both cases,

2:06:52we'll play the Catalina Mac OS 10.15 version first,

2:06:56and then the new Mac OS 11 Big Sur sound

2:07:02second, but the Catalina ones are really the same going back, like seriously,

2:07:06like 20 years. But, um, I think these are all taken from Catalina.

2:07:10So first we have the system sounds and we

2:07:15have, uh, sending something to the trash,

2:07:18emptying the trash,

2:07:22moving a file or folder,

2:07:32and taking a screenshot,

2:07:34which is the most interesting change. Okay. Now the alerts.

2:07:41So I'm going to give them, they all have new names.

2:07:44So I'll just give you the names. The names are Catalina, uh,

2:07:48classic old school Mac OS first,

2:07:50and then the new name for the corresponding sound from Big Sur second.

2:07:54We've got tink and boop,

2:07:56blow and breeze,

2:08:01pop and bubble,

2:08:06glass and crystal,

2:08:11funk and funky,

2:08:16hero and heroin,

2:08:21frog and jump,

2:08:31basso and mezzo,

2:08:33bottle and pebble,

2:08:39per and pluck,

2:08:44Morse and pong,

2:08:49ping and sonar,

2:08:58submarine and submerge.

2:09:01And last slightly out of alphabetical order,

2:09:08the one sound that didn't change name for good reason.

2:09:12So Sue me and so Sue me.

2:09:15And my thought at first was I like all the new alert sounds like the beeps you

2:09:24picked from. Um, and I didn't like,

2:09:29the system sounds like the trash and the screenshot.

2:09:33And you, you said you liked them. And I was like, see, you know that, that,

2:09:38that, that threw me off. That made me see it. And I'm, you know, this is, I,

2:09:42I've got a big, a big open mind. I thought, well, I trust Adam. Let me,

2:09:46let me think about this. And I tried to live with it a little more.

2:09:49And I think you're right. I think they're, I think they're good.

2:09:52That's that's nice to hear. I think that, yeah. I mean,

2:09:57obviously there's going to be resistance to anything that, that,

2:10:01that, um,

2:10:04swaps out something that you're so well used to and have such an possibly

2:10:08emotional attachment to, but I always kind of hate it.

2:10:12And I'll just take as the very basic,

2:10:13like the trash can and the empty trash sound from the system.

2:10:18I, for step one, I, you know,

2:10:21some of our friends probably said said this to step one of a new Mac is you turn

2:10:25off that you turn off those systems sounds. Cause they're, I don't know,

2:10:30they're, they're like a little bit showy. They're a little bit, um, what's,

2:10:34what's the word like, I want to say aggressive or sharp. They like,

2:10:39they want to draw attention to themselves. They don't, they don't feel,

2:10:43um, feng shui.

2:10:45They don't feel like they're supposed to like live comfortably in the

2:10:49environment of the user experience.

2:10:53But these new ones feel just like that little extra bit softer and

2:10:57comfortable and, um, not disruptive, um, to me,

2:11:02but still representing the things that they are with the exception of the,

2:11:05of the screen cap one, the screenshot sound,

2:11:10which is something new. But, you know,

2:11:13it's an interesting discussion because we, you know,

2:11:17we were talking about this a little bit, um, offline, but,

2:11:22um, this idea that sound effects can be skeuomorphic or not as well.

2:11:27Right. Um, and that's exemplified by the screenshot.

2:11:31Yeah, absolutely. By the screenshot, which is, you know,

2:11:35they wanted to make, it's very much like the save icon being a disc,

2:11:40a floppy disc.

2:11:41They wanted to make the sound of a screen capture like a camera shutter

2:11:47clicking and saving an image. Um, which makes sense, you know,

2:11:51conceptually, but do we really need that anymore?

2:11:54Especially when the association of a shutter sound is now just referential to

2:11:59itself. It doesn't refer to a camera that any of us own, right?

2:12:02So if you, if you can sort of redefine that and, you know,

2:12:06self-define a shutter sound as something new,

2:12:08that's like almost more digital or bloopy sounding,

2:12:11then why not take that opportunity? If it's like a once in a decade thing,

2:12:15It's funny to imagine an alternate universe where the sounds

2:12:21changed as frequently and dramatically as the UI theme

2:12:26of Mac OS X, but the UI theme hadn't changed at all.

2:12:30Maybe other than going retina,

2:12:32which I think even in the alternate universe would have had to happen.

2:12:35But like imagine a world where until a month ago,

2:12:39Mac OS still looked like the candy Aqua Mac OS

2:12:4510.0 from 2002 with the stripes

2:12:49and the lollipop looking red, yellow, green, all the buttons.

2:12:54And then never higher res.

2:12:58But the sound, the sounds changed every four years.

2:13:01And then all of a sudden, all of a sudden in June, they unveiled Big Sur.

2:13:06It looks like what Big Sur looks like.

2:13:08I think people would, I think people's heads would have exploded.

2:13:11It's kind of hard to imagine, you know.

2:13:14Yeah. And I and I mean, the very basic answers,

2:13:17because the sounds aren't as important as the visuals, right? Right.

2:13:20Nobody, you know, people say turn off the sounds.

2:13:24First thing you do is turn on.

2:13:24Nobody says first thing you do is turn off your display.

2:13:27Right. It just doesn't work.

2:13:31Yeah. But it's terminal. It's just as good.

2:13:33All right. So the the alerts, I think they they all sound better.

2:13:38I don't think any of them is worse.

2:13:41I guess a friend of the show, I think Molt's.

2:13:46We're on a slack. That's what we're talking about.

2:13:47We're on a slack where we talk.

2:13:49And I think Molt thinks that the Breeze one sounds like a Windows sound.

2:13:54But it doesn't sound bad.

2:13:57But I think it's interesting that they all have parallels, you know,

2:14:01that there were the old alerts and now each one, there's like a one to one

2:14:04correlation between the old and the new.

2:14:08And I have to admit, big dummy, that I am and overwhelmed

2:14:11by all of the new stuff in Big Sur.

2:14:13I didn't even notice that at first, that it's one to one.

2:14:16And then it's like, well, how did you not notice that?

2:14:19You know, because like the one is, you know, like the names are, you know, like

2:14:23Ping is now Sonar and

2:14:25Submarine is now Submerge.

2:14:31I mean, it's you know, it's kind of obvious.

2:14:34But yet I missed it.

2:14:36Yeah, I think the first sound in Mac and the Mac OS that I noticed

2:14:41was the startup sound, which is correct me if I'm wrong,

2:14:44but there hadn't been a startup sound in the last.

2:14:47They got away from it.

2:14:48They I think I think starting and again, I could get it wrong,

2:14:52but it almost doesn't matter what the technical explanation.

2:14:54But I think it started with the ones that have the T2 chip for security

2:14:58stopped, including the boot sound by default.

2:15:02And then there was a secret, scary

2:15:05pseudo command you could issue at the command line, which is seriously scary

2:15:10because it's like you're actually using a command that like changes

2:15:13the firmware in your computer.

2:15:15And so, yeah, you use everybody just copies and pastes it.

2:15:18But it's like you kind of have to trust who you're copying and pasting

2:15:21that you're not like rendering your Mac unable to boot.

2:15:24Well, you could turn it back on.

2:15:27But now they can't.

2:15:28And in this in Big Sur, in the beta, at least there's there's now

2:15:32I mean, by default, a startup.

2:15:34And I know that only because a half hour before we started recording,

2:15:38I finally got the beta to install so that we'd have something to talk about.

2:15:42And then so I turned it on and it and I heard the startup sound

2:15:47for the first time, which has it's very similar to the to the prior one that

2:15:51except that it's got a much softer

2:15:55timbre and a much softer attack, like the ramp up to the beginning

2:16:00in the beginning of the sound is a little bit of a ramp.

2:16:03So it's it's a little bit more like

2:16:06in which for me right away

2:16:09drew an association with HBO,

2:16:13you know, network tone or whatever the promo tone,

2:16:16which is a nice sound. It's great.

2:16:19So I don't mind that at all.

2:16:22What you want is that you I think what you want in a sound

2:16:25more than anything else is if your volume is turned all the way up on accident

2:16:30and everybody in your home is asleep.

2:16:35And you do something on your computer and it barks,

2:16:38you know, with a sound effect, like you throw something in the trash.

2:16:41You don't want it to wake everybody up

2:16:45or you don't want to at least have to clench your butt because you're worried

2:16:48that it and those like some of these sounds like the glass or the

2:16:53you know, like the just very cavernous metallic throwing something away

2:16:58or the crinkle, the the Pringles, you know, when you when you empty the trash.

2:17:03Those are harsh, harsh sounds.

2:17:04Those are waking your family up.

2:17:06They're not going to be happy.

2:17:08I do. I do wonder.

2:17:12Well, you know what?

2:17:14I have to mention this because I know I've gotten so many emails over

2:17:17and I've never actually mentioned it, but there's a lot of people who think

2:17:21that the Apple TV plus promo sound, whatever I thought.

2:17:26I was hoping you would know what those things are called.

2:17:28You know, like every streaming service has their own distinctive thing

2:17:33like the HBO one or Netflix is to done.

2:17:36Yeah, I think that I've always called them as logo tones.

2:17:41Yeah, I like promo tones, but logo tones, because like

2:17:44when the iPhone first let you make your own ringtones, I made

2:17:48I made ringtones out of all of those like old school network tones.

2:17:53Well, let's make let's make logo tones a thing.

2:17:55That's our that's our mission.

2:17:57Everybody listening.

2:17:58That's our mission is to get these things called logo tones,

2:18:01because that's what they are.

2:18:01They're audio logos, right?

2:18:03That you can you can't you're not even looking at the screen.

2:18:06But if your friend or partner or kid starts playing something,

2:18:11you know, if it's on Netflix, because it starts, you have your back to the TV,

2:18:15but you hear the sound and you know, bum, bum, it's on Netflix.

2:18:19So it's a little bit.

2:18:21Yeah. And I just found the Apple one.

2:18:23It's the if you search for Apple TV plus logo HD, it's

2:18:27it's kind of like a single tone of like piano with a bass.

2:18:33Yeah, there's people who think it's there's

2:18:36but there's people who think that's the Mac startup chime and it's not.

2:18:39It is. It's in the vein of it.

2:18:44And I kind of wonder if there wasn't at least some deliberate

2:18:48homage or I don't know, but it's definitely not it.

2:18:52And it surprises me that some people think it is.

2:18:56And I think if you heard them back to back, you'd say, oh, yeah,

2:18:58that's not the same thing at all.

2:18:59But it's it it's familiar enough that you might you know, I can see

2:19:05why people think it, but not if you actually listen to it side by side.

2:19:08But anyway, anyway, if you get a new Mac now, I guess, I don't know

2:19:13if you have to wait for Big Sur or not, but apparently the startup

2:19:15sounds are coming back for all Macs by default.

2:19:18Which I think is the right way to do it,

2:19:21and I know that this is polarizing because I've mentioned this.

2:19:24I get it why your phone when you power off your phone and start up your phone.

2:19:29It doesn't make a noise.

2:19:31But your Mac is not your phone. It's different.

2:19:33Your Mac. I don't know.

2:19:34There's something about it and maybe it is just nostalgia.

2:19:38But I think your Mac, if it's powered off when you power it on,

2:19:41it should make a noise.

2:19:43And if you work in an environment and this is what you hear from

2:19:48and I'm going to hear from it just by saying this right now.

2:19:50There are people who work in environments where any noise is unwelcome

2:19:54and they've had at least one unfortunate circumstance

2:19:58where the computer locked up or they had to restart it

2:20:01after installing something or something and they did it

2:20:03and it made a noise and they were embarrassed

2:20:06and they were very happy that Apple did away with it.

2:20:11But yeah, as long as you can easily mute it or disable it, then I'm good.

2:20:16Do you remember this?

2:20:17It was I'm looking at YouTube.

2:20:19It was 13 years ago, but like a hidden camera

2:20:23prank video in a library where a guy turns on his laptop

2:20:28and the startup chime goes off.

2:20:31But it and it's very loud, like they had some hidden speakers or something.

2:20:36It's very loud and it lasts like easily 60 seconds.

2:20:40And people keep, oh my God, I'll send it to you.

2:20:43All right, you got it.

2:20:43And that's so good.

2:20:45Yeah, I'll put it in the show notes.

2:20:47OK.

2:20:48Here's so you like the new sounds, too.

2:20:55And you know which one in particular you've totally you've made me go from.

2:20:59Why did they do this?

2:21:00Why are they ruining my life, too?

2:21:02OK, I actually am with Adam.

2:21:04I think this is smart is the screenshot one. Yeah.

2:21:07And it shouldn't be a camera.

2:21:10And it's not just the phasing out of clickety clack cameras.

2:21:16And the fact that have you seen I mean, I don't know.

2:21:19I know you shoot with really, you know, serious big boy cameras,

2:21:22but a lot of like prosumer cameras have like the option to have a fake shutter

2:21:27sound. Sure. Yeah, I really don't get I mean, and I guess I get in the sense

2:21:34that, well, if a screenshot on a computer makes an old timey shutter camera sound,

2:21:38why wouldn't a camera camera have the option of doing it digitally?

2:21:42But to me, that was always the absolute worst part of cameras

2:21:46is that they made this noise and distracted people.

2:21:49If you're trying to shoot, you know, not surreptitiously like a creeper, but

2:21:54casually at an event and just capture people without making them self-conscious

2:22:00and to sort of capture this and having this big, loud click clack was not good.

2:22:04And then when you're ever you're watching a professional media event

2:22:08and there's the nonstop stream of people with digital SLRs

2:22:14that actually have this still have the mirror.

2:22:17And they have these giant CF cards that can shoot an infinite number of images.

2:22:22And they just hold down the shutter.

2:22:24And it's it it really sounds like an attack of some sort, like a

2:22:29like a machine gun nerf gun is going.

2:22:31It doesn't sound like a gun gun, but it sounds like some kind of, you know,

2:22:36I don't know. It just always sounds like like the photographers

2:22:40are attacking the subject.

2:22:42Yeah, very aggressive.

2:22:44And why? It just is so frustrating at this point,

2:22:46like when it was technically necessary, it was one thing.

2:22:49But we know that we can make truly excellent cameras

2:22:52that don't make any physical noise.

2:22:54So why not? It would be so create such a more pleasant moment

2:22:58if everybody just agreed not to use cameras that have mirrors.

2:23:03So I get it. And I actually like I like the new screenshot

2:23:07and it's something that happened.

2:23:09And this is where I'm getting it.

2:23:10The question I have for you is where do you draw the line

2:23:13for which events in the in the user interface

2:23:17make a noise and which ones don't?

2:23:19Right. I think it's just if you need feedback to know that it worked.

2:23:24That's right. Like that's the whole point of a of a UI sound rise.

2:23:29If you if it doesn't make a sound or there's not some sort of a tactile

2:23:33feedback, then you wonder you're stuck with that nanosecond

2:23:37of an anxiety where it didn't do the thing you needed it to do.

2:23:40Yeah, I think that's why I leave them on, you know,

2:23:43and I, you know, as a self-professed, you know, expert user, I still use it.

2:23:48I don't I don't really move that many files to the trash.

2:23:52I don't empty my trash very often.

2:23:54So it's not like I'm constantly badgered with the sound of things

2:23:59being rattled around the fake trash can.

2:24:01But I kind of like the confirmation of it.

2:24:04And for a screenshot, it's it's almost like a warning to write.

2:24:09It's not just confirmation that you took the screenshot,

2:24:12but it's like a warning in case you did it by accident that, hey,

2:24:15you know, whatever you were doing just got screenshotted.

2:24:17You should be aware, you know, you should be aware of it.

2:24:20Maybe warning isn't the right word, but sort of just like, hey, you know,

2:24:24just say, you know, whatever you're doing is just been captured to an image.

2:24:28Yeah. In iOS 14, I installed the beta last night of iOS,

2:24:34iOS 14, and I discovered a system sound that is the first time

2:24:38that I think I will ever leave a system sound on

2:24:41which is and I don't know what you call it.

2:24:44It's like a push pop.

2:24:45Is that what do you call it?

2:24:46Where you you you tap hold on a link and it pops up,

2:24:50you know, you know, like when I like I don't know, three long press.

2:24:54Yeah. You long, long press on a link in it and it pops up a preview.

2:24:58Yeah. And when you do that in iOS 14, it vibrates.

2:25:03It just and then and I'll try to hold it up to the mic right now

2:25:07so you can maybe hear it. But.

2:25:10Did you hear that? Yeah.

2:25:11Yeah. A little tick.

2:25:12Yeah. Just it's barely audible.

2:25:14But and I think that the reason I'll leave it on is because if I did that

2:25:19in a very silent room, nobody would ever think that that was that

2:25:23that came out of my phone.

2:25:24It could have easily just been like my bone cracking or something like that

2:25:29or the chair.

2:25:30But it's that extra little bit of audible slash tactile feedback

2:25:36or haptic feedback that makes me know that I'm that I just interacted

2:25:40with with a piece of software in an interesting way.

2:25:43Yeah, it's it's not quite haptic.

2:25:46It's but it is sensory, right?

2:25:48It's right. That's what it is.

2:25:49And I do feel that Apple is sort of it's an interesting

2:25:53walk back where Apple is sort of introduced

2:25:58all of this pressure sensitive stuff that they called forced

2:26:02touch on some devices and 3D touch on others.

2:26:05And it's all sort of going away.

2:26:07Apparently, the watch OS six or whatever version the new one is seven or seven

2:26:14has deprecations about assuming that 3D touch or force touch

2:26:19or whatever it's called on the watch is going to be there, which has everybody.

2:26:22You know, I think rightly so, thinking that either the next watches this year

2:26:28or the ones next year are going to do away with that.

2:26:32You know, and the phones already did it, and it was sort of painful

2:26:36because it's in some ways the experience took a hit because being able to just force

2:26:42touch the shortcut I used all the time was being able to force touch

2:26:46on the keyboard and turn it into a track pad for the cursor.

2:26:50And you can still get it, but you like long press on the space bar

2:26:54or below the space bar, which is a nice trick on the iPhone

2:26:5710 that you don't even have to hit the space bar exactly.

2:26:59You can go below it.

2:27:01But like the fact that you have to like press and wait

2:27:05is like and I think they've dialed in the weight to like

2:27:09an exquisitely perfect number of milliseconds where you don't get it

2:27:14by accident, but it's the minimum weight they could possibly do.

2:27:17So it's as fast as it can possibly be without being accidentally triggerable.

2:27:21But it still isn't as cool as being able to just press hard and have it right away.

2:27:25Like I still feel like I'm now of a sudden I'm faster than my phone,

2:27:29which is ridiculous because I'm a very slow person.

2:27:33Related, I and again on our slack, our friend

2:27:36John Sirakusa, I'll just call him out by name,

2:27:40vehemently opposed to the keyboard clicks on the iPhone keyboard.

2:27:44I like I keep them on.

2:27:47And to me, to me, the ringer switch on the phone.

2:27:52I don't really think of it as a ringer switch.

2:27:54I think of it as a keyboard click switch

2:27:58because I will turn it off when it's always appropriate,

2:28:02you know, generally appropriate not to have your phone ringing and beeping

2:28:05and booping and bopping.

2:28:07But I like to turn it on when I'm writing.

2:28:08If I'm going if I'm going to like do some email or like extensive

2:28:12texting with somebody on my phone, I'll flip it up.

2:28:15And so that when I'm typing, I can hear the taps.

2:28:17But I have to immediately tap it off if I'm anywhere near my wife because

2:28:22she drives your bonkers.

2:28:24That's great.

2:28:25That's great.

2:28:25You need that feedback. And it's good to that's good to know that kind of thing.

2:28:28I don't think I I know.

2:28:32I bet that if you secret camera'd me and stop watched it,

2:28:36I don't type faster or more accurately with the clicks.

2:28:40But I feel like I type more accurately and faster with the clicks.

2:28:44And that's really all that matters.

2:28:47I would actually keep doing it.

2:28:49Even if your stopwatch secret camera footage of me

2:28:52proved the opposite, that I actually am more effective without it,

2:28:57without the clicks, because I it matters more to me that I feel like I'm productive.

2:29:04All right.

2:29:05Does that make sense?

2:29:06Oh, absolutely.

2:29:07It's all emotional.

2:29:08UI is definitely emotional.

2:29:09So I'm going to say one more thing that I just thought of about the system,

2:29:14about the new sounds in terms of like.

2:29:18Evolution of sound design, and I think it's this,

2:29:23I think that the future of this type of of human computer and

2:29:29what's the I stand for interaction interaction.

2:29:33Yeah.

2:29:34Is going to resemble augmented reality more and more than, you know,

2:29:40as opposed to less like AR wasn't a trend.

2:29:42And I think that that goes for visuals as well as for the visual.

2:29:46I think that that goes for visuals as well as sounds,

2:29:51where we're going to become more used to the idea that, you know,

2:29:57digital visual stuff is it has to blend in with our environments for obviously reason.

2:30:02You know, if the glasses are a real thing, then yes, visual digital stuff is going to

2:30:06blend in in our environments and track to the environment.

2:30:09So that's sort of a no brainer.

2:30:11But I think it's interesting to think about sounds the same way.

2:30:14And I even think that, you know, the first generation of air pods, what was striking

2:30:20to me was that they sort of, you know, because they let a certain amount of sound in to your

2:30:24eardrums, it always felt to me like an overlay of sound rather than a replacement of sound,

2:30:30which is how I prefer to experience, you know, sound through through headphones or whatever.

2:30:34I don't want to be isolated or noise cancellation or anything.

2:30:39So I like to think of sound in that that way of augmented rather than replacing or like,

2:30:46you know, VR type of sound.

2:30:48So I think that these new sounds that I'm hearing from the system and the alert sound

2:30:53in Big Sur are meant are like sort of like engineered or sound designed to augment sound

2:31:00around us rather than replace it.

2:31:02And that's the last thing I'll say about that.

2:31:04Do you have I AirPods Pro or do you still have the

2:31:07No, I don't because I really do like my AirPods.

2:31:09I've always been sort of a I don't know, like middle, like a like a middling taste of of

2:31:19like headphones and stuff like I loved the wired earbuds that came with the iPhone and

2:31:26the iPods for so many years.

2:31:27And I love the first generation, second generation of AirPods.

2:31:30So I don't really feel like for that same reason.

2:31:33I don't want to replace what's around me.

2:31:34I just want to augment it.

2:31:35Yeah, I have the pro.

2:31:38I would say for anybody who still has the regular ones and you thinking about the pro,

2:31:43if you like if you're like you like I would say to you, don't even worry about it.

2:31:47If you like your regular AirPods, you're good.

2:31:49If you you know, and to me, the big area where I love the noise canceling

2:31:53on the AirPods Pro is being on an airplane or a train.

2:31:57And guess who hasn't been on an airplane or a train and four and a half months

2:32:03when I'm out on the street here in Philly, I always have my AirPods Pro in whatever

2:32:09they call pass through mode where it's not noise canceling.

2:32:13A, I'm scared of the noise canceling as a pedestrian.

2:32:17I genuinely worry about I feel like I'm lucky enough when I don't have any

2:32:22headphones in at all that I don't get hit by a car.

2:32:25But yeah, I I like all of these extra.

2:32:30I like to use as many of my senses as possible to avoid getting hit by a car

2:32:34or anything untoward like that.

2:32:37But I also just like it. I just prefer it.

2:32:39I just like to be part of the world.

2:32:41I don't want to cancel out stuff like that.

2:32:43And with the AirPods Pro, it really is like it turns the whole world into AR

2:32:50for audio where that's the trick is like so like and for me as a pedestrian,

2:32:55all this all of my use cases involve being a pedestrian in a center city,

2:33:00Philadelphia, so like a bus goes by.

2:33:02Well, a bus is very noisy

2:33:05and you hear the bus when you're with AirPods Pro in pass through mode.

2:33:11But unlike regular AirPods, where the pass through is the actual sound

2:33:14of the bus, it's virtual and it knows to turn it down.

2:33:18So, you know, the bus is going by, but it doesn't mean you have to like

2:33:22pause the podcast you're listening to wait for the bus and then hit play

2:33:25to or go back 15 seconds.

2:33:28It turns the bus down to a level where you doesn't keep you

2:33:32from continuing to hear the podcast you're listening to.

2:33:34That's awesome.

2:33:35It blows me away every time it happens.

2:33:38I'm blown away because I'm like, you know, for years,

2:33:41you know, and even going back to wired earbuds, every single time

2:33:45a bus or truck went by me while I was out in the city,

2:33:49I would have to go back 15 seconds to hear what the hell I just missed

2:33:52on the podcast.

2:33:54And now I don't have to do that.

2:33:55And it blows me away.

2:33:56Yeah, that's just super, super cool.

2:33:59Smart engineering. I love it.

2:34:00All right. Last question.

2:34:02And then we're done on this subject.

2:34:04Why do movies still have when you're when somebody is using a computer

2:34:08in a movie, does it make ridiculous sounds for everything?

2:34:11Oh, that's a good question.

2:34:15When I thought this was the thing.

2:34:17Here's what I thought.

2:34:18I thought as like when I was in my 20s and this was still happening,

2:34:22I was like, well, wait until my generation is making the movies

2:34:26and is in charge of things and will finally get done with this.

2:34:29Right. No, because I mean, sound designers have to reinforce

2:34:36the idea of the world that's being captured on camera like that.

2:34:40They're there. It's not meant to be the most realistic,

2:34:43although I'd argue that when devices when when hardware devices

2:34:47are truly silent, then we'll no longer need

2:34:49you know, them to be sound designed in movies and commercials.

2:34:53And so I think that's that's the main thing is that

2:34:57it feels weird if you see something but don't hear it.

2:35:00And also there's this idea that all of

2:35:03you know, all of that medium, all of cinema through,

2:35:09you know, through a lens is illusory.

2:35:12So you have to always reinforce the illusion.

2:35:15So it's not it's not about replicating reality.

2:35:18It's about convincing people that what they're seeing in that box

2:35:22is pretty close to real life.

2:35:24So sound designers take that opportunity to not only reinforce, but make better.

2:35:30And it's an additive thing. It's not subtractive.

2:35:33There we go. Adam, I'm going to have you back on the show within the next five years.

2:35:40Oh, good. Wasn't that something right then?

2:35:45Everybody can check you out.

2:35:48You're what your Twitter handle is now, Adam.

2:35:51It's just my name, Adam.

2:35:52Let's go. Yeah. And of course, your excellent company that was instrumental in

2:35:57making me not jump off a cliff sandwich

2:36:02is at sandwich dot co, which is absolutely fabulous.

2:36:06And you guys are continuing to do killer work.

2:36:10Even in this, you guys have figured it out how to do work.

2:36:13Anything you want to promote anything new?

2:36:14I know the slack video was about a month ago.

2:36:17But yeah, yeah, I was maybe getting up on two months.

2:36:20But what is time anymore?

2:36:22Yeah, I guess a month ago was my show and it was definitely out

2:36:26for a month when my show came out. So, yeah, two months. All right.

2:36:28Yeah. So I guess that slack project is on our site.

2:36:31If you if you would if you get to know the team

2:36:35and the company a little bit or our culture, we've done a few more of those.

2:36:39We call them lunchbox style remote shoots since this started happening.

2:36:44And then we just did our first like real commercial

2:36:47for a company called OutPay, which I'm very excited about.

2:36:50OutPay is again, they're they're they're facilitating

2:36:54contactless menu and payment in restaurants for

2:36:59because it's all it's all sorts of dangerous for everybody involved

2:37:04at a restaurant right now if you're just handling everything.

2:37:08And and there's all these regulations and restrictions.

2:37:11So that so they've been working for a few years on a clever solution

2:37:15to all this problem.

2:37:17And the timing was interesting and correct.

2:37:20So we made a commercial for them.

2:37:23And what else? Yeah, just

2:37:26probably vote vote in the election.

2:37:29And well, vote for sure.

2:37:31And last but not least, you and

2:37:34friends of the show, Merlin Man and Scott Simpson,

2:37:38have put the band back together for You Look Nice Today.

2:37:41Yeah. And that is now well, hey, you could just look for it

2:37:45in your favorite podcast app, but the website is.

2:37:48I think that we it's all at California King dot org.

2:37:53Now we sort of like we set out to do something new when we got

2:37:57that we got back together.

2:37:59We started discussing, you know, what could we do?

2:38:01It doesn't have to be the old thing.

2:38:02Let's just get let's just record.

2:38:05So we branded it as a new thing that Scott came up with

2:38:08the name California King, and it was it was so funny.

2:38:11We couldn't disregard it.

2:38:14And and so then we started recording them and then we realized,

2:38:18oh, this is You Look Nice Today.

2:38:19This is the same damn thing.

2:38:21So whoops.

2:38:24And anyway, we started doing them as we started the one,

2:38:27the way we could differentiate was we started shooting them,

2:38:29shooting video for them, too.

2:38:31So now they're all the episodes are slightly less edited than they used to

2:38:36used to be, and they're all on video on YouTube.

2:38:38So California King, it's for the kids, huge amounts of fun.

2:38:43Yeah, huge amounts of fun for me.

2:38:46And we just we do it weekly now instead of maybe every few years.

2:38:51And it's really fun to be a podcaster again.

2:38:54Yeah. Well, I couldn't be happier that it's back.

2:38:57I don't know what I'm happier about.

2:38:59You Look Nice Today, California King or Gary Larson.

2:39:02Bring it back.

2:39:04But you guys have more episodes than he has cartoons.

2:39:07So I'm going to give the credit to you.

2:39:10Yeah, well, we should do a calendar.

2:39:13Although now that I think about it,

2:39:15the far side has also made copious use of Cooper Black, the typeface.

2:39:20Oh, neat. Yeah. Yeah.

2:39:22I wonder if that's what made me think of it is that I'm looking here

2:39:24and I see it. California King.

2:39:26But anyway. Right on.

2:39:29Well, this has been a dream.

2:39:30Thank you so much, John Gruber in the observation that anybody,

2:39:35anybody, including me, has ever made.

2:39:38Yeah, we really took Cooper Black and made it our own, I guess.

2:39:42I think that was Merlin's unique innovation when we started.

2:39:46You Look Nice Today.

2:39:48All right, Adam.

2:39:50Thanks, man. Thanks for having me on.

2:39:52Oh, you're the best.