Podcast Search

The Talk Show

283: ‘Some Kind of Sandwich’ With Dieter Bohn

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Dieter, it's good to have you here.

0:00:01Yeah.

0:00:02It's like a, it's like, it's the first time we've talked in forever.

0:00:04Yeah.

0:00:05Uh, we, we were going to be, I was going to have you on a month ago.

0:00:11Uh, then all world changed and now we have more to talk about.

0:00:16And then we did record for 20 minutes and it didn't take, and now we have to start

0:00:22over, but it'll be good.

0:00:24Anything.

0:00:24Yeah.

0:00:25Anything that you don't enjoy about the next 20 minutes that happens here, just

0:00:28assume that it was great the first time around.

0:00:32And you'll just have to imagine.

0:00:35Anyway, there's three things I want to talk about.

0:00:38They are new.

0:00:39It's like the world is-- at least our world continues

0:00:41to go on.

0:00:42I want to talk about the iPhone, the new iPhone SE.

0:00:46I want to talk about the iPad Magic Keyboard.

0:00:51And I want to talk about Android-- the year 2020,

0:00:55so to date, and Android flagships.

0:00:58- Sure, yeah, there's a handful.

0:01:01Call it three, no, four, three and a half.

0:01:04Call it three and a half.

0:01:06- I can't wait to hear what you think they are

0:01:07'cause that obviously is, I obviously have a lot to say

0:01:10about the SE and the Magic Keyboard

0:01:12and I personally don't have anything to say

0:01:13about the Android flagships except that I find

0:01:18everything very interesting and we'll get to that.

0:01:20Let's do that as the third segment.

0:01:22But the iPad Magic Keyboard I wanna get to first.

0:01:28I thought your review was really interesting in a couple of ways.

0:01:34But you, so everybody, at least I, everybody I know who's in the review racket had the 12.9 inch to review.

0:01:41Yep, yeah, same. I bought the 11 inch, so I've got that now, but I reviewed it on the 12.9,

0:01:49which maybe colored a little bit of my feeling about it,

0:01:54because since I prefer the 11-inch iPad in the first place,

0:01:57the 12.9 just feels big.

0:02:00That's sort of why I focused on like,

0:02:01here are the exact weight measurements.

0:02:03And I did it in pounds,

0:02:05'cause I've mostly got a US audience,

0:02:06and I know that's awful.

0:02:07I should have just offered grams also,

0:02:08but I was in a hurry.

0:02:10But yeah, it's heavy.

0:02:12And I think that Apple knew it was heavy from the jump.

0:02:15In fact, I know they knew it was heavy,

0:02:16because I asked them, "Hey, how much does the 11 inch one weigh? Because I'm weighing this 12 inch

0:02:21one, it seems kind of heavy. Can you just, you know, let me know what the spec is?" And they just

0:02:25told me that there was nothing to share on that. I thought that was so interesting too in advance,

0:02:29even before we got the 12.9 inch, they didn't have the weights for any of them.

0:02:33Yeah, well, I mean, they had it. They, they, I'm sure that somebody somewhere with an apple

0:02:39had weighed it. Oh yeah, they knew it, but I'm saying that there was no, there was no way to go

0:02:44to like if you go to apple.com and click on iPad and then they're like they're like iPad keyboards

0:02:50and they have this nice page with all of the latest iPad keyboards and there's nowhere there

0:02:54that tells you how much any of them weigh and Dr Drang the these pseudonymous lovely Apple blogger

0:03:05stuff I just a gobble up I love every almost everything he posts had speculated on the weights

0:03:14based on, well, let's take,

0:03:16we know the weights of the smart keyboards

0:03:18and we know the shipping weights

0:03:20and somehow it was like Amazon published

0:03:22the shipping weights for the Magic keyboards,

0:03:25you know, like how much the whole package is.

0:03:27So if we take them as a percentage, we could, you know,

0:03:30and his guess for the 12.9 inch was very close,

0:03:33but it turns out the 11 inch Magic keyboard

0:03:36is quite a bit heavier than his guess.

0:03:39It does seem, 'cause it's percentage wise,

0:03:44the 11 inch Magic Keyboard,

0:03:47the new thing with the clicking keys and the trackpad,

0:03:52is a ways closer to the 12.9 inch

0:03:57than the smart keyboard do.

0:03:58Does that make sense?

0:04:01And I guess it's something to the effect of,

0:04:04and I don't know that anybody's torn these things apart yet,

0:04:07but I'm guessing that there's aspects of them

0:04:10where the difference in size doesn't matter,

0:04:13that there's like hinge mechanisms for both hinges

0:04:18that the difference in size doesn't really matter

0:04:21so much as the fact that the hinge is there at all

0:04:24and it's, I guess the track pads weigh about the same

0:04:28even though it's only slightly smaller, et cetera.

0:04:30So the 11-inch is quite a bit heavier.

0:04:33I don't know why Apple hid it though.

0:04:35I mean, it is what it is, just be proud of it.

0:04:40I don't know, it just was suspicious,

0:04:42but it made me think, yeah, maybe we are guessing low

0:04:45on the weights of these things.

0:04:47- Yeah, I mean, maybe they just,

0:04:49they knew that everybody would dunk on it.

0:04:50I mean, I know that the day before the morning

0:04:53of the reviews coming out,

0:04:55some of the keyboards had actually shipped early.

0:04:57- Yeah. - And so everyone saw

0:04:59that it weighs, the 12.9 with the keyboard weighs more

0:05:04than a MacBook Air, but weighs about the same

0:05:07as like a 13-inch MacBook Pro.

0:05:08And so I was like, oh my God, it's so heavy.

0:05:10And so I think they knew that that was gonna be

0:05:13the reaction probably, but I agree with you.

0:05:16I think they should have just owned it.

0:05:17Just be like, yep, we made the best keyboard we could,

0:05:20and that meant that it weighs a little bit more.

0:05:22But the iPad, you know, Apple is very good at pivoting,

0:05:25but the iPad is the greatest portable device ever,

0:05:27blah, blah, blah, blah.

0:05:29You know, I think they could have pulled off

0:05:30some sort of jujitsu on the messaging there.

0:05:33- There's a great line, I love the writing books,

0:05:36Drunk and White, The Elements of Style.

0:05:40And as somebody who, long-time listeners of this show

0:05:44know well, I've, I'm 47 years old,

0:05:48but I've internalized a lot of words

0:05:51I pronounced the wrong way.

0:05:53Because I read them as a kid,

0:05:54and I took a guess as to how they were pronounced,

0:05:56and in my brain, they're just stuck that way.

0:05:59And there's a line in that book where Strunk,

0:06:03the old professor who was at E.B. White's English professor

0:06:08at whatever college he went to,

0:06:10His advice to his students was,

0:06:12if you're reading out loud and you get to a word

0:06:14you don't know how to pronounce, say it loud.

0:06:16Don't, you know, instead of mumbling it,

0:06:18if you don't know how to pronounce a word, say it loud.

0:06:21And I kind of feel like, all right,

0:06:22you're not proud of how much the Magic keyboards weigh?

0:06:26Well, put the weight out there and be proud of it.

0:06:28You know, just hang it out there.

0:06:31But anyway, bottom line, the big thing for me,

0:06:35my only regret with my review of the iPad Magic keyboard

0:06:39is that I didn't put the review out

0:06:43specifically as a review of the 12.9 inch

0:06:46Magic, iPad Magic keyboard.

0:06:49Because now that I have the 11 inch too,

0:06:52for my personal iPad Pro, which is 11 inch,

0:06:56which size I personally much prefer too,

0:06:59I find that they're different enough,

0:07:04more different than I expected and different enough

0:07:06that they kind of demand to be reviewed

0:07:09as separate products.

0:07:10Or at least like one and a half different products,

0:07:13it's like half the same and half different.

0:07:16- So this is really fascinating to me

0:07:18because I use so many different sized keyboards in my life

0:07:23'cause I try and make sure

0:07:24that I'm switching platforms regularly enough

0:07:26where I feel like I'm familiar with everything

0:07:28that just from hand feel,

0:07:32maybe I'm numb to major differences

0:07:34in keys and keyboards.

0:07:36'cause the 11 feels about the same to me as a 12,

0:07:40it's just smaller.

0:07:41- For me, it's not so much about the keyboard being smaller

0:07:46'cause I'm used to smaller mini keyboards too,

0:07:49including some that are truly, truly micro,

0:07:52like ones that are like little fold up ones

0:07:54that you're supposed to use with a phone,

0:07:56which I don't really do anymore,

0:07:57but it was sort of like a dream of mine to like,

0:08:00and still maybe someday I'll find a device

0:08:03that'll let me do it,

0:08:04I've always thought it would be cool to go on vacation

0:08:06or just go on a, remember when we used to have meetings

0:08:10and stuff? (laughs)

0:08:12Like if I had like an Apple briefing

0:08:15or some kind of product demo from some company in New York

0:08:18to take the train to New York and take nothing but my phone

0:08:22and a little fold-up keyboard and do all of my work

0:08:25just with that and not have to worry

0:08:27about even taking an iPad along.

0:08:31So the fact that the A to Z alphabet keys are smaller,

0:08:36I don't know what percentage,

0:08:37let's say it's like 90% layout,

0:08:40I'm fine with that,

0:08:42and my fingers are used to that over the years.

0:08:45I wouldn't wanna write as much,

0:08:48like the thing about the 12.9 inch keyboard

0:08:51is it is a full keyboard, right?

0:08:53Like if I were gonna write a book,

0:08:55I wouldn't hesitate to do all of the typing

0:08:57on that iPad keyboard.

0:09:00It is as full-sized of a keyboard as Apple's desktop

0:09:04Bluetooth Magic Keyboard or their laptop, the MacBook ones.

0:09:08It's full-size, the keys feel just as good.

0:09:11They may be different in certain niggling ways,

0:09:14but the smaller 11-inch one

0:09:16is definitely a slightly smaller layout.

0:09:18I wouldn't want to do as much typing on it

0:09:20if I had another option, but I could.

0:09:24- Yeah.

0:09:24- My complaints, or not even complaints,

0:09:26but just some of the differences,

0:09:28is that some of the other keys are hard to type.

0:09:31Like, I find it insane, absolutely insane,

0:09:35that the right or left square bracket key

0:09:39is a full-size key, and the right one is a half-size key,

0:09:44even though they're a pair.

0:09:45Like, I think that's insane.

0:09:48I don't know how that past design muster at Apple.

0:09:53It just seems crazy to me,

0:09:56especially when there's a backslash key next to it,

0:10:00you could make that one full size

0:10:02and then make the two bracket keys half size.

0:10:05It's just to make them the same.

0:10:07Whatever size you make the bracket keys,

0:10:08they should obviously be the same, is what I'm saying.

0:10:10- Yeah, I mean, how often are you using one without the other?

0:10:14- Right, like you're, yeah, you're,

0:10:17if you are, you're like leaving your brackets hanging.

0:10:19I find that crazy.

0:10:22And then today, I linked to Dan Morin,

0:10:25had a review of the Logitech keyboard

0:10:27that they announced alongside these.

0:10:29It's called the Touch Something,

0:10:31the Logitech Touch Something,

0:10:32I think is the official name.

0:10:35Anyway, he had a review of that.

0:10:36That's Logitech's product designed in conjunction

0:10:39with Apple for the non-pro iPads

0:10:42so that there's a cover/keyboard case

0:10:45with an integrated trackpad

0:10:48that connects to those iPad smart connectors.

0:10:50Anyway, looking at the pictures of that,

0:10:54The way they did it is they made the two square brackets

0:10:58and the backslash key like 2/3.

0:11:02All three of those keys are the same width

0:11:04and instead of half and full,

0:11:06they're all like 2/3 size.

0:11:08Well, that's a good compromise.

0:11:102/3 is a pretty good compromise.

0:11:13And then the other key that really is really driving me nuts

0:11:16trying to type it is the dash key,

0:11:18another or hyphen, I don't know what you call it,

0:11:20but it's the key next to zero in between zero and equals,

0:11:24and it's a half-size key on the 11-inch iPad Magic keyboard,

0:11:29and I keep missing it 'cause it's so small.

0:11:32- Yeah, this I noticed because I'm actually

0:11:35one of the worst people for just using em dashes

0:11:37in lieu of actual punctuation or other punctuation.

0:11:41- I'm right there with you.

0:11:42- Yeah, Chris Welch, one of our reporters,

0:11:45just yells at me every time.

0:11:46Every time he edits one of my pieces,

0:11:47he just deletes everything.

0:11:49It's that, and then I have to stop using the word pretty.

0:11:51Those are the two things that I need to cut out of my life.

0:11:54- So I looked, and on the Logitech keyboard,

0:11:58what they did, and I think this is pretty clever,

0:12:01maybe there's other smaller footprint keyboards

0:12:03that do this, and probably there are over the years.

0:12:07I've never really noticed it, but I'm like,

0:12:09"Well, wait, how is that keyboard,

0:12:11"which is for 10.5-inch iPads, so therefore, in theory,

0:12:15"perhaps even more space-constrained,

0:12:18How do they have a full width hyphen key and an equals key?

0:12:23And the trick is, if you squint and look at it,

0:12:27the whole number row on that keyboard

0:12:30is slightly smaller in width than the alphabet keys.

0:12:35So the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 dot dot dot all the way across there,

0:12:40they're like--

0:12:41I don't know, I didn't take out Photoshop

0:12:43and try to measure them.

0:12:44but they look like they're all maybe like 85%

0:12:48of the alphabet keys.

0:12:50And so like one, two, and three align with Q W E

0:12:54as you'd expect, but by the time you get to eight, nine,

0:12:57and zero, they're a little bit further to the left

0:13:00of the alphabet keys underneath them than you're used to,

0:13:03but then that makes room for dash and equals keys

0:13:06that are to the same width as those other number keys.

0:13:10That seems like, since you have to make compromises

0:13:14to get a smaller footprint keyboard, those seem like better compromises than what Apple's made.

0:13:20- Oh, for sure. I mean, I would even be willing to have the backspace key be even a little bit

0:13:26smaller, 'cause it's, you know, it's like Fitts' Law, but for people, like, you can reach out there

0:13:30and hit it, and if it's a little bit smaller there, it's less of a pain than the hyphen key

0:13:35being smaller. - Yeah, 'cause you can do,

0:13:37it is, I think it actually is Fitts' Law. I don't think Fitts' Law only applies to software.

0:13:43I think you could learn it you can just reach up to the corner right and just blindly go for the corner

0:13:48And if you overshoot you're not going to hit the wrong key

0:13:50You're going to be off the side or over the top of the delete key. You can hit it

0:13:55Although on the on the it's called the logitech combo touch apparently on the logitech combo touch

0:14:00You if you reach over you will hit the function row, which they have. Well, we'll have to talk about that in a moment

0:14:06But the other thing I've noticed with the 11 inch magic keyboard

0:14:12Compared to the 12.9 inch is that the magnets are a little different. It doesn't seem to me as strong and magnetic connection

0:14:19Yeah, it's easier to take off which is good when you want to take it off

0:14:25But it also seems like it's not quite as secure which maybe isn't as good if you're gonna use it on a bumpy train or something

0:14:32Now the thing I don't know is I I do I know it's the same thing where it comes off a little bit more easily

0:14:40But I don't I'm using my with the 2018 iPad Pro the 11-inch so which you know are compatible

0:14:46So I wonder if I had a 2020 11 inch iPad Pro if it has stronger magnets in it. I kind of doubt it

0:14:52But it's possible. Yeah, it's possible

0:14:56I can't compare 11 inch 8 2018 to 2020 because I don't have a 2020 11 inch but I can compare

0:15:04The 12.9 inch for both years because okay. I have my wife owns the 2018

0:15:1012.9 inch iPad Pro and

0:15:14My testing with that was that it was magnetically identical

0:15:18It was okay. It was I mean now I didn't measure it in any way with any kind of tool, but just

0:15:24Anecdotally, it just seemed equally strong

0:15:28exactly the same magnetically as the new one.

0:15:31So I don't know, I can't say that the 11 inch

0:15:34is the same way, but it's definitely a different thing

0:15:36for me going between the 12.9 and the 11 inch.

0:15:39It's just, and I don't think, again,

0:15:42that's the sort of thing I regret about my review,

0:15:45'cause I really went on and on

0:15:47about how magnetically strong it was,

0:15:50and it's not that it is, but it is only for the 12.9,

0:15:55so I wish I had emphasized that.

0:15:57- Well, so one thing, and maybe we'll get into this later,

0:16:00but one of the things that's nice about this keyboard,

0:16:05and it sort of applies to smart keyboard,

0:16:06not quite as much, is you can pick it up

0:16:10and walk around with it in a way that,

0:16:11like with a Surface Pro, to pick up a Surface Pro

0:16:14with the keyboard attached,

0:16:15it's kind of this weird floppy mess, right?

0:16:17You gotta fold it up.

0:16:18But this thing, you can pick it up and hold it in one hand

0:16:21and walk around your house or your apartment with it

0:16:24in a way that, like with this Logitech keyboard,

0:16:27you can't, you know, 'cause it's gonna flop around.

0:16:30So I really think that the magnets being strong,

0:16:34maybe a little bit less strong on the 11, I don't know,

0:16:36but the thing was designed, I don't know,

0:16:39it feels like it was designed for my home

0:16:41instead of like my backpack,

0:16:42and that gets to the weight thing.

0:16:44But it also just, it gets to like,

0:16:45I feel like maybe you wrote this,

0:16:47it feels more like a dock than it does a case.

0:16:49- Yeah, I did write that, and I do think that.

0:16:51It's like a case, it's a dock that folds up

0:16:55into a case-sized wrapper,

0:16:57not a case with a keyboard that you can type on.

0:17:01- Right, yeah.

0:17:02- I even turned it upside down.

0:17:03I mean, I was, you know, I'm not reckless with review units,

0:17:07but I am ever so slightly more reckless

0:17:10than I am with the ones I've paid for.

0:17:12Like, I'm not one, like, if they say that, you know,

0:17:17here's a review unit of a new iPhone,

0:17:19it's IP68 water-resistant.

0:17:22I don't dunk it in water.

0:17:24I just let other reviewers do it

0:17:26because I don't wanna be the one who shorts one out.

0:17:28And then it's not because, hey,

0:17:31you're the ones who said it was water resistant.

0:17:33It's not that I'm afraid to call Apple up and say that.

0:17:35I don't wanna lose 24 hours to get a new review unit,

0:17:39though, to do it.

0:17:40So I don't.

0:17:41So I'm a little bit cautious.

0:17:42But I took the 12.9 inch in the keyboard

0:17:45and turned it upside down.

0:17:47And it's like, it doesn't come out.

0:17:49And the hinge, I'm not gonna say the hinge

0:17:51doesn't move at all, but it stays pretty close

0:17:56to the same angle.

0:17:56It certainly doesn't bend.

0:17:58If it adjusts a degree or two, sure, that's gravity,

0:18:03but you can turn it upside down and it doesn't come out.

0:18:06I'm not sure I would do that with the 11-inch,

0:18:08and I definitely wouldn't do any of that

0:18:10with Apple's smart keyboard.

0:18:12- Oh yeah, no, that thing pops off really easily.

0:18:15- And you can definitely, I mean,

0:18:17is it ever truly advisable to walk around your house

0:18:21with a laptop of any kind?

0:18:22Probably not.

0:18:24But we do it, right?

0:18:26I mean, everybody does it.

0:18:29And you can definitely do that with the Magic Keyboard.

0:18:32It's definitely much more stable than you would think,

0:18:35especially given how similar it looks externally,

0:18:39like from the bottom and top,

0:18:41or not fabric, whatever you call that rubbery material

0:18:45they make these things. - It's weird, right?

0:18:46And it picks up just dust in a weird way.

0:18:50There's something about that material that I'm just not a big fan of.

0:18:54It's grippy, so I'll give them that.

0:18:56But it's grippy in a way that, like, it doesn't, like, you know how some plastic,

0:19:00I don't know, I've used a bunch of random keyboard cases and stuff, like, it's grippy,

0:19:04but then it like starts to feel like weird and greasy?

0:19:06Yeah.

0:19:07This, that never happens to this really, but it, I don't know, it definitely feels like it's some

0:19:13sort of, you know, custom polyurethane, probably something, something plastic that they really

0:19:19believe in because it's grippy and means it won't slip off an airplane tray table.

0:19:26But I'm not a big fan of it.

0:19:29It has two problems that I've seen.

0:19:32It's one, it definitely picks up dust or dust sticks to it in ways that it just seems prone

0:19:40to it.

0:19:41I think it picks up finger and palm grease,

0:19:46and it cleans easily.

0:19:49So it's not like permanent shiny spots.

0:19:53I know what you're talking about.

0:19:54There are some things that pick up permanent shiny spots.

0:19:57They're not permanent, but I've been using it

0:20:01in pretty clean areas, not really eating around it

0:20:05or eating like a hot dog or something with my finger,

0:20:09I've eaten chicken wings and then touching it.

0:20:11(laughing)

0:20:13But yet I still have grease spots on it,

0:20:17for lack of a better term.

0:20:20And then I wipe 'em off and they clean off,

0:20:22but with all of Apple's aluminum MacBooks,

0:20:25I never feel like I have to clean them every day.

0:20:30- Yeah.

0:20:31- Yeah, I'm not a fan of this material either.

0:20:34I didn't really get into that in my review,

0:20:36but it's like I don't hate it.

0:20:38I don't know, it's just so unusual.

0:20:40It's almost like somebody needs to write a review

0:20:43of this material.

0:20:44- Yeah.

0:20:45- Because it's like nothing else.

0:20:47I don't know what to compare it to.

0:20:49- Yeah, it's very strange.

0:20:51But I mean, I don't know, it bothers me more on the outside,

0:20:54which honestly I never really see

0:20:56because the thing sits on my desk.

0:20:58Like I never take it off my desk.

0:20:59I now am taking the iPad off of it and using the iPad

0:21:03just all by itself without a case on it,

0:21:05way more than I have in the past.

0:21:07Like I kid you not, like three, four years.

0:21:09Like I don't know if I've ever used an iPad this much

0:21:11outside of a case as I do now,

0:21:13that I basically have a dock

0:21:15that I can just attach it to to charge

0:21:17and then take it off to go walk around my house with it.

0:21:20- See, I'm the opposite where I just haven't used it

0:21:22in any sort of case for years

0:21:24'cause I so dislike the smart keyboard.

0:21:26And so I've used a keyboard with my iPad,

0:21:29but I have been using for years

0:21:31just like regular desktop Bluetooth keyboards

0:21:34and then propping up my iPad in a standalone little,

0:21:37tiny little tripod stand.

0:21:39And so it's even easier to pick it up

0:21:42and just walk around with it as, you know,

0:21:44iPad as a tablet.

0:21:46But that's what I like so much about this case

0:21:48is it's so easy to get it out and just do that.

0:21:51Like, oh, I just wanna read some comic books at night

0:21:54and I don't want, certainly don't wanna have

0:21:56a bulky keyboard case folded around the back to do that.

0:22:00It's so easy to just take it out and walk around.

0:22:02But that's the thing that makes it so weird

0:22:04that I seem to get greasy spots on it

0:22:08because I'm not even moving it.

0:22:09It's like at the same, I wipe it down,

0:22:12put it on the kitchen counter at my spot

0:22:15and leave it folded open and then I go to weigh it

0:22:20or something or do something,

0:22:23I pick it up for some reason and look at it.

0:22:25I'm like, well, how did it get so dirty?

0:22:27I haven't even moved it.

0:22:28- You got ghosts.

0:22:31All right, F keys, we gotta talk about the F keys.

0:22:34- So, I think they should have included function keys.

0:22:39I think that having, you know, even the iPad equivalent,

0:22:44so like home button, a multitasking button,

0:22:47play, pause, next, last, volume, keyboard brightness,

0:22:51it is just way more convenient to just reach up

0:22:54and hit a function key than it is to reach all the way up

0:22:57to the control center or try and hit that tiny little target

0:23:00the trackpad to start adjusting those things.

0:23:04And they didn't put it in, obviously, and they didn't have it in their previous keyboards.

0:23:09So part of it is I don't think Apple believes in function rows for iPads.

0:23:16But part of it is they decided they wanted a keyboard dock that had a rock-solid base

0:23:22that had this floating screen.

0:23:24And I think there's reasons for that that make sense.

0:23:27but it just meant that there was,

0:23:28even if they physically wanted to,

0:23:30it would have been awkward to fit the function row in.

0:23:32- Yeah, depending on the angle, you know,

0:23:34the angle that the screen,

0:23:36if you have an acute enough angle, like closer to 90,

0:23:40then there'd be room for them.

0:23:41But when it's at its widest position,

0:23:43you'd kind of have to,

0:23:44it's like fitting your fingers into a slot, you know.

0:23:47- Like sneaking in there, yeah, yeah.

0:23:50- And you know, you get it with the backlighting.

0:23:52But you know, speaking of backlighting, that's the key.

0:23:56Everybody who mentions this,

0:23:57And it's a good point, is that if you want to adjust

0:24:00the backlighting, it's the only way to do it right now

0:24:04is to go to the settings app, settings,

0:24:08let me see if I can even remember,

0:24:09settings, settings, general, keyboard.

0:24:12- Keyboard, hardware keyboard.

0:24:14- Hardware keyboard, and then backlighting.

0:24:17And that is, I mean, you made the point in your review

0:24:22that their default settings for the backlight are excellent.

0:24:26- Yeah, they're great.

0:24:27As long as you want the backlight there,

0:24:30it's always correct.

0:24:32I've never had to adjust it if I want the backlight on.

0:24:35But the thing about the iPad that I love

0:24:38is that you do more than just use it like a laptop.

0:24:41You watch movies on it, you read, you do other things.

0:24:44And sometimes you wanna have the thing propped up

0:24:49with some kind of stand,

0:24:50like this is a perfectly good stand,

0:24:51and you don't want the keys lit up.

0:24:53And in order to do that,

0:24:54you gotta like hunt through the settings,

0:24:57or you gotta follow Frederico Viticci on Twitter

0:25:00and find a shortcut app.

0:25:02You know, it's ridiculous.

0:25:04- Yeah, and so there's no way they're going

0:25:06to retroactively add backlight keys, hardware keys,

0:25:10to this keyboard because a keyboard doesn't get

0:25:12software updates that enable new keys.

0:25:14But so the best we can hope for is getting

0:25:16the backlighting into the control center?

0:25:21- Yeah, well, and there's a perfectly obvious place

0:25:23to do it, which is under a long press of the brightness

0:25:25in the same way, 'cause logically, you long press the volume

0:25:29and then you get to your AirPod extra settings,

0:25:31so you should long press the brightness

0:25:33and get to your keyboard brightness settings.

0:25:35- I was excited because everybody,

0:25:37a lot of people observed this and had it.

0:25:40I had the thought, "Hey, let's see if Siri can do this,"

0:25:45and I asked Siri to adjust the keyboard backlighting

0:25:51and then it came up with a brightness slider on screen.

0:25:53And I was like, bingo, there it is.

0:25:55I can't wait to publish this tip.

0:25:57And I went to try it, and as I slid it down,

0:26:01it was my display brightness.

0:26:02(laughing)

0:26:04So I guess I can't even say that that's,

0:26:08it would be good to add it to Siri too.

0:26:10So you could just say turn the key,

0:26:12it would be nice as a shortcut to tell Siri

0:26:14to turn the keyboard backlighting off

0:26:16and have the right thing happen.

0:26:20And I guess it's not a bad guess to just,

0:26:23well, here's the only brightness I know how to show you,

0:26:25I'll show it to you.

0:26:26I guess I can't complain about not understanding,

0:26:28but it was a disappointment.

0:26:30The other thing is that because there's no row of F keys,

0:26:35there's no escape key.

0:26:37And we kind of went through this with the MacBooks,

0:26:40where the MacBooks that first shipped with the touch bar

0:26:43didn't have a hardware escape key.

0:26:45And now with the new one,

0:26:47starting with the 16-inch MacBook Pro.

0:26:49They even made it a bullet point.

0:26:53It's like a selling point of what's so great

0:26:55about the updated keyboard in the 16-inch MacBook Pro

0:26:58is it has an escape key.

0:27:00And it's so cool to see Apple putting that in

0:27:03as a bullet point.

0:27:04And again, with my person, I know there's people,

0:27:08I know that this one is polarizing,

0:27:11but I like the upside down T for the arrow keys too.

0:27:14And I'm glad to see them making it a selling point.

0:27:17But there is no F key row, and so there is no escape key.

0:27:22But you get to remap it.

0:27:23You can say, what do you do, caps lock?

0:27:26- Yeah, so every computer that I own,

0:27:30I've remapped caps lock to some kind of universal search.

0:27:33So on my Mac, it goes to Alfred.

0:27:36On Windows, I actually have it open up

0:27:39a new edge browser tab.

0:27:43on Chrome OS it's a new Chrome tab,

0:27:45but you can't remap the caps lock key on the iPad to that,

0:27:50so I remap it to escape because I'm so used

0:27:55to hitting the caps lock key to do a search

0:27:57that if I left it on as caps lock,

0:27:59I would end up typing in all caps all the time.

0:28:02- So you might as well have it mapped to something.

0:28:04- Yeah.

0:28:05- Yeah, I have it set to the,

0:28:07I have escape mapped to the globe hardware key

0:28:10because I don't-- - Okay.

0:28:12The only thing the globe does by default

0:28:14is toggle between the hardware keyboard

0:28:17and the on-screen emoji keyboard.

0:28:20And you can type control space to do the same thing.

0:28:22And I kind of, that comes naturally to me,

0:28:25'cause on the Mac you type control command space

0:28:28to get the emoji picker.

0:28:30So that comes naturally to me,

0:28:33so I might as well remap the globe to escape

0:28:36and it somehow feels okay mentally.

0:28:39I mean, I could do it, if I couldn't do the globe,

0:28:41If only caps lock, I would just do caps lock.

0:28:44'Cause I don't, who uses caps lock, right?

0:28:46I mean, I mean, I guess there's some angry,

0:28:48angry people on the internet who really,

0:28:51really make use of it, but.

0:28:53- Yeah, I think if you're gonna use caps lock to yell,

0:28:56you should be forced to use the shift key.

0:28:58And like, you really mean it,

0:28:59like the physical effort of typing the capital letters,

0:29:02it should be more work.

0:29:03- You should, but I feel like the people who use it

0:29:06would have none of it.

0:29:08- Yeah.

0:29:09- It is nice, I guess it's not surprising.

0:29:11I mean, and I know it's all software at some point,

0:29:13but it is nice that if you remap the caps lock key,

0:29:17the green light no longer goes on and off

0:29:20every other invocation.

0:29:21The green light is tied to the idea

0:29:24that caps lock is caps lock, so that's cool.

0:29:27- Oh, actually, if you are a Mac user,

0:29:31they finally added in Catalina the ability

0:29:33to natively remap the caps lock key on Macs

0:29:37without having to use a third-party software

0:29:39like Karabiner Elements.

0:29:41So that's great.

0:29:41And it also does the same thing where

0:29:43if you remap it natively,

0:29:45it doesn't turn on the green light.

0:29:47- Yeah, so that's cool.

0:29:48- What do you think of the trackpad?

0:29:53'Cause I, you know, like I mentioned in my review,

0:29:55I use the Surface Pro a lot.

0:29:57And so like this trackpad is almost identical in size.

0:30:00And so it is,

0:30:02I'm used to having small trackpads every now and then.

0:30:05But if you're used to a trackpad on a MacBook

0:30:09or used to like a trackpad on like an iMac or something,

0:30:12those things are massive.

0:30:14So I'm wondering what it's like to go down

0:30:16to such a tiny trackpad for you.

0:30:17- All right.

0:30:18I like it a lot, and I like it a lot more.

0:30:23It makes me wonder why they're so big.

0:30:25I know that now that the MacBook Pro keyboards,

0:30:29or trackpads in particular, have gotten truly expansive.

0:30:33I mean, I joke that it's like the 16-inch one

0:30:36is the size of a New York studio apartment.

0:30:38(laughing)

0:30:41I know that there have been others who say they're too big,

0:30:44and I know there are some people who get problems

0:30:48with their palms registering as false touches

0:30:51'cause they're so big, and I don't run into that

0:30:53for some physiological reason about the skin on my palms.

0:30:57I've been using a 16-inch MacBook Pro extensively

0:31:01over the last few months, and I really don't have

0:31:03any problems with it being so big

0:31:06in terms of getting false touches.

0:31:08But on the other hand, now that I'm getting by just fine

0:31:12with this comparatively tiny little trackpad,

0:31:15I'm like, I don't know why that's so big.

0:31:17The one thing that it seems like I run into

0:31:20the size problems is if I do try dragging

0:31:22and dropping something, I run out of space.

0:31:25But on the other hand, I don't drag and drop on iPad much.

0:31:29I just don't think it's as much of a thing

0:31:31as it is on the Mac.

0:31:34I use it much more for just moving the pointer around

0:31:37and it's big enough, even up and down, it's big enough.

0:31:41And for scrolling, and for scrolling,

0:31:43you just keep flicking, so it's not so much

0:31:47going in one continuous movement where you need the size,

0:31:50you just keep flicking two fingers to scroll,

0:31:53and so it's fine.

0:31:54I like it a lot.

0:31:55I wanna know what the black magic is

0:32:00that they've made it equally clickable

0:32:03at the top and bottom instead of the diving board effect

0:32:07of all the old, you know, because it doesn't use

0:32:10haptic feedback to fake clicks, it really clicks.

0:32:14But before Apple had these haptic magic track pads

0:32:18in the MacBooks, they were these diving board buttons

0:32:23that were way clickier at the bottom

0:32:28than they were at the top.

0:32:29And I don't understand why, if they were able to do this,

0:32:32come they weren't doing it all along? Yeah, I don't know, the service trackpad is a

0:32:36diving board again, but at first I was like, oh, they did the haptic thing, this is great.

0:32:42And then I realized, oh no, it's actually a full-on button all the way top to bottom.

0:32:47You are actually like pushing a thing down and it's clicking. It's really good. I'm really

0:32:53impressed with it. I've never used a trackpad of this size that felt this good. I mean,

0:32:59I think the only thing that I lose from going down to a smaller trackpad is, um,

0:33:03I finally started using like the, the, like the pinch out,

0:33:06pinch in gestures on the Mac to like go to your desktop or, um,

0:33:09I'm actually using the launch pad per launch center,

0:33:12whatever the app launcher is for once. Um, I haven't, I didn't use it for years.

0:33:16And then all of a sudden, since I started using it to go to my desktop, I was like,

0:33:19Oh yeah, this thing is here. I'll start clicking on this again.

0:33:22And I kind of like it. That's weird.

0:33:23And you find that the pinch, there's not enough room to pinch.

0:33:28- Yeah, I think that, I mean, but you don't need to

0:33:30on the iPad 'cause you can do that sort of three finger

0:33:32hold or three finger swipe up and it works pretty well.

0:33:36I agree with you on dragging.

0:33:39If you wanna drag something across, it's pretty tough.

0:33:41But since I'm using the 11 inch most of the time anyway,

0:33:44like you never have that far to drag.

0:33:47So really like my only problem with the trackpad

0:33:50is stuff that's kind of out of Apple's control.

0:33:53It's just like, you never really know inside an app

0:33:56what the track, if the track pad is gonna do exactly what you expect it to.

0:33:59And I've complained about Google's apps in this regard.

0:34:02Um, although Google's apps are just terrible on the iPad to begin with.

0:34:05Uh, but even weird stuff, like if you, if you use Twitter, uh, the official

0:34:09Twitter app, like some, some of the buttons, the iPad, like does the little

0:34:14lock on thing, like the Apple TV.

0:34:15And it does, you know, like turns into the shape of the button.

0:34:18That's really neat.

0:34:18And then other buttons just, Nope.

0:34:20It's just like, it feels very weird and unnatural inside a single app where

0:34:24Sometimes the mouse does the magical resize thing and sometimes it just stays that little circle

0:34:28Yeah, and I guess I without knowing the you know, you'd have to talk to the developers and you know app by app

0:34:36But i'm guessing it's some kind of thing where if you have a button and it's derived from a standard ui kit button

0:34:43without overriding certain things you get this

0:34:47magical the the cursor morphs into an outline around the button automatically and for other things that are

0:34:54buttons and up until now when you just tap them with your finger act just like buttons and there's

0:35:00no reason to think of them any differently they somehow don't inherit that for free and again

0:35:06you're right and you're right though that even within the same apps it you can't really guess

0:35:12until you hover the the mouse pointer over it whether it's going to do it or not yeah but there

0:35:18are other like in control center so you to bring control you like you sort of you drag the the mouse

0:35:23beyond the edge of the screen.

0:35:25And that's what brings in your slide over

0:35:27or your dock or whatever.

0:35:28It took me a while to sort of get used to that feeling

0:35:31of just keep moving your finger up

0:35:33and it'll eventually come down.

0:35:35So that's neat once you get used to it.

0:35:36But I love, I don't know why this gets to me,

0:35:39but I love when you hover the mouse over the volume

0:35:42or brightness slider.

0:35:43You don't need to do anything other than just

0:35:45when you do a two finger scroll on those sliders,

0:35:48it directly adjusts the volume.

0:35:50It's so obvious and it's tiny

0:35:52and it's not that big a deal,

0:35:53but it's just, that's like a small considered thing

0:35:55whereas if they had made you like click and drag,

0:35:57I wouldn't have been surprised

0:35:58but instead they just got it right.

0:36:00- It's good.

0:36:01I really, the existence of this trackpad support

0:36:06and it is, to me, the software support for the trackpad

0:36:09is the bigger deal because I've been ever since iPad OS,

0:36:14I'm always gonna call it iOS,

0:36:15but ever since iPad OS 13.4 shipped

0:36:17with this trackpad support last month,

0:36:20I've been using my iPad so much more,

0:36:23not just because I need to use it

0:36:26to be able to write about it,

0:36:27but I just like, ah, finally I feel like

0:36:30I'm text editing without thinking, you know?

0:36:33And I just feel like now I'm using my fingers

0:36:37instead of having mittens on my hands

0:36:39and feeling so constrained

0:36:41when I'm trying to just edit text.

0:36:43And doing it in this integrated magic keyboard

0:36:48that it snaps into is great.

0:36:50- The funny thing about text stuff is

0:36:54I tried really hard to wrap my head around

0:37:00the way that iPadOS handled cursor and text selection

0:37:04and copy and paste,

0:37:05and there's the new three-finger tap stuff.

0:37:08And I was like, all right, I don't wanna say it's me.

0:37:10I don't wanna say I'm just a fuddy-duddy

0:37:12and I'm stuck in my old ways.

0:37:15maybe like I can really learn

0:37:16how this new text selection stuff works.

0:37:18And I never really got there and I'm still not quite there.

0:37:23And it's really, really obvious to me now

0:37:26that all of the way the cursor stuff works in iPadOS

0:37:31was designed for the touchpad.

0:37:33And then they're like, well, we also need to make it work

0:37:35for a touch first experience.

0:37:36So let's try and throw some machine learning at it

0:37:39and see if it works.

0:37:40And I just, I think I feel like it's honestly

0:37:43a step backwards.

0:37:43you don't have a touchpad attached to the magnifying glass work. It was still awkward

0:37:49and like had lots of extra steps, but at least it was precise and it was completely predictable.

0:37:54I feel like right now, without the trackpad attached, interacting with text is a little

0:37:59bit unpredictable, and that is a thing that text interaction should never be.

0:38:03Yeah, and I know that there are people both outside Apple, and I happen to know inside

0:38:10Apple that there are people who I don't know that anybody is flat out like opposed to this

0:38:17trackpad support system wide, but there are people who unlike me who just love it, who

0:38:24are ambivalent about it on the grounds that it's taken away their motivation to finally

0:38:35get a purely on-screen touch interface

0:38:38for selecting text right,

0:38:41which I don't think they've ever gotten

0:38:44for the phone or the iPad.

0:38:46Selecting text has always been fiddly.

0:38:49And I'm with you that I feel like getting rid

0:38:52of the magnifying glass was actually a step backward.

0:38:55I think they made it slightly worse.

0:38:57It feels like I'm less precise than I was before.

0:39:00And it certainly isn't better.

0:39:03- Yeah.

0:39:03I mean, I think the idea was they were hoping

0:39:05that they could use some machine learning

0:39:08to sort of like just fudge it, just figure it out for you.

0:39:11And it just, it can't, it can't quite do that.

0:39:13- Yeah.

0:39:14So the other thing we have to talk about

0:39:17is your comparison as somebody who owns the Surface Pro X.

0:39:22And clearly the biggest differences

0:39:24between Microsoft and Apple

0:39:26is how do you pronounce the letter X?

0:39:27Is it an X or is it a 10?

0:39:31It is an x but I I had to ask and they're like, of course, it's x it's like, okay

0:39:35What does x mean, you know, it means x okay great

0:39:38Uh, and then we get to minor minor differences, you know, like whether to integrate a kickstand into the tablet or not

0:39:46Yeah, I mean

0:39:48So look the the funny thing so the surface when it first came out surface pro like it introduced this they introduced this idea of uh,

0:39:55which is just a hilarious word, but people were concerned that like,

0:39:59could you fit the surface on your lap? Could you fit on an airplane tray table?

0:40:03And you can, but it's just a little bit awkward.

0:40:06But it's because they have this idea of a kickstand and I,

0:40:12on the whole,

0:40:14I tend to prefer the setup on the Surface Pro because I really do use that sort

0:40:19of like, I don't know what mode to call it,

0:40:22like the portrait mode where like there's no keyboard,

0:40:24where there's no keyboard, but it's still able to stand up on its own.

0:40:27And with the Surface, you could either do that with the keyboard attached, or just flip

0:40:30the keyboard around behind it.

0:40:32The other thing that you can do with it is, because that kickstand goes all the way to

0:40:36almost flat, is if you draw a lot, you can put the thing down at a really comfortable

0:40:42drawing angle.

0:40:43Now, you can do all these things with an iPad with the original, sort of, origami smart

0:40:48cover.

0:40:49It has, like, you can put it sideways, or you can stand it up, or whatever.

0:40:52But ever since they did the smart keyboard and now with this thing, it really, really

0:40:58wants to have the iPad be at that sort of laptop angle.

0:41:02And it really fights you if you want to do, you can't really, you can't do any other angle.

0:41:06So you kind of need to take the thing out.

0:41:09And then if you want to prop it up in some way, you're sort of on your own.

0:41:14And is a kickstand inelegant to have on a physical piece of hardware?

0:41:19Yes, it is.

0:41:21it's so functional for me to be able to just like,

0:41:25you know, set the thing down in bed and like start a movie

0:41:29or, you know, if I do want to draw, which I don't do much,

0:41:32you can like bend the thing down.

0:41:34For me, the trade-off is worth it.

0:41:35- Well, I mean, in the kickstand's favor too,

0:41:38you always have a way to stand it up.

0:41:40You're never without it.

0:41:42You're not, oh, I forgot to take my little, you know,

0:41:45$10 tripod thing that's just to prop it up

0:41:48so that I can watch a movie, you know.

0:41:50I forgot to put it in my bag.

0:41:52Now how am I gonna prop this thing up?

0:41:54The drawing thing is interesting too.

0:41:58I mean, it is very, very clear

0:42:01that the iPad Magic Keyboard is only meant

0:42:04to be used in laptop angles.

0:42:08And Apple says 90 to 130.

0:42:11The 130 is the maximum open angle.

0:42:14You can actually open it less than 90.

0:42:17You can, you know, it stays where it is

0:42:20at like 80 to 75 degrees.

0:42:22It's just that there's no, they don't even advertise

0:42:24that as a feature because it's almost,

0:42:27who would never-- - Who would want that.

0:42:28- Who would want that.

0:42:29I do find, I'm not an illustrator,

0:42:33so I don't really draw much.

0:42:35I do find that it's a little bit,

0:42:37I have a pencil though and I do write notes with my iPad.

0:42:41I find that it's easier to write on the screen

0:42:43than I expected while it's in the Magic Keyboard,

0:42:47but I will admit that I wouldn't wanna write extensively,

0:42:51but it's not super awkward.

0:42:53And then I thought about it.

0:42:54I was like, well, people write on whiteboards

0:42:56at a 90-degree angle all the time.

0:42:58And I know that ergonomically something that's,

0:43:01while you're standing up, writing at something chest high

0:43:06is a lot different ergonomically

0:43:08than writing on a laptop screen, but it's not ridiculous.

0:43:11And if it's literally on your lap, laptop, as a laptop,

0:43:16like in some kind of, any kind of scenario

0:43:20where you actually have it on your lap,

0:43:22your lap can, depending on how you sit and your posture,

0:43:27you can have it fade away from you, slope away from you.

0:43:30So you can kind of get the iPad and a Magic Keyboard

0:43:35at a more amenable angle to drawing

0:43:38or scribbling or putting notes.

0:43:40And because it's so, the hinges are so strong

0:43:44and the magnetic connection is so strong,

0:43:46it, I feel like you could do it securely.

0:43:49So I don't feel like it's preventing you

0:43:52from using your Apple Pencil while it's connected.

0:43:54It's just, it's certainly not ideal though,

0:43:57compared to something that can fold all the way around.

0:44:00- Yeah, and like the whole question is like,

0:44:02is the kickstand worth it or, and this is,

0:44:05I tried to, I didn't do this really elegantly,

0:44:07but like, there's nothing essential

0:44:11about the shape of the iPad

0:44:12or the shape of the Magic Keyboard.

0:44:14Apple could have chosen other things.

0:44:17So the Brydge Keyboard, for example,

0:44:19it is a proper laptop,

0:44:20and it has these really, really strong clips.

0:44:25And so when it's all put together, it feels fine,

0:44:27but getting the iPad in and out of it's really awkward.

0:44:30And so that's pretty inelegant.

0:44:32There are other ways they could have chosen

0:44:34to construct this thing as a physical object

0:44:37that might have solved some of these problems,

0:44:39but it would have ended up with trade-offs,

0:44:41And it's really clear to me that the number one thing

0:44:44they wanted to do with this design

0:44:46was make a good keyboard.

0:44:47And everything else, drawing, watching a movie on it,

0:44:51whatever else you might want to do was secondary to,

0:44:54let's have a big, flat, solid metal base

0:44:57so that it feels rock solid,

0:44:58and then let's put a really good magic keyboard on it.

0:45:01And that's what it's for.

0:45:04And then everything else had to wait after that.

0:45:07- So here's another thing,

0:45:08And it's like sort of unfortunate timing for Apple

0:45:12that this thing came out in the midst of this pandemic

0:45:16that has everybody doing 10 times or more video conferences

0:45:21than they've ever done before.

0:45:24The camera, I mean, famously, Joanna Stern

0:45:31just did a whole video about how terrible laptop cameras are

0:45:34and the new MacBook Air camera in particular

0:45:37and that saying that it's 720p resolution

0:45:40doesn't even get to how bad it is in low light.

0:45:43It has nothing to do with resolution, it's just bad.

0:45:45And iPads have really good FaceTime cameras,

0:45:48the front-facing camera.

0:45:50And so if you're just going to do a FaceTime or a Zoom call,

0:45:54you're gonna get a much better picture quality of yourself

0:45:57from an iPad than you are from any MacBook.

0:46:02But it's over on the side.

0:46:05And so it really exacerbates this sort of,

0:46:10I don't know, you just look, you're looking right at it,

0:46:12you're fully engaged, and it looks like you're reading

0:46:15email or Twitter off on the side

0:46:17because your eyes are way off center.

0:46:20- And if you decide you do want to read email

0:46:22or Twitter off the side, most video conferencing apps,

0:46:25especially Zoom, I think all of them actually,

0:46:27completely narc on you by turning off your video

0:46:30because the iPad is super secure and any app

0:46:32that isn't the front most is not allowed

0:46:34to have the camera lit up.

0:46:35- Right. (laughs)

0:46:37I didn't even think about that aspect, but yeah.

0:46:39- Yeah, it's a huge hassle.

0:46:41(laughing)

0:46:44- I've been trying to spy on my son,

0:46:47who's in 10th grade, doing quote unquote Zoom school.

0:46:51And it seems like they pay attention,

0:46:54but there is absolutely a back channel.

0:46:56(laughs)

0:46:57- Oh yeah, for sure.

0:47:00- I've said this, they've straightened it out.

0:47:02It was like day one, day one of Zoom school,

0:47:04they got a Zoom bomber,

0:47:06and the back channel went crazy.

0:47:09The one kid photoshopped like a wanted poster for the guy.

0:47:12And he didn't do anything.

0:47:13He didn't speak up.

0:47:15He didn't do anything inappropriate.

0:47:16He didn't put any porno into the video.

0:47:19He just sat there and listened to them

0:47:21talk about English literature.

0:47:24And the teacher apparently didn't notice,

0:47:26but all the kids noticed that a 25-year-old man

0:47:29was just creeping on their English class.

0:47:31- God. - You know, and then the school

0:47:34quickly, you know, it became a thing where we all,

0:47:36all the parents got email and again,

0:47:38nothing inappropriate even happened,

0:47:40but you know, and they're like,

0:47:41we're gonna change our policy and have, you know,

0:47:45I forget what, I don't know if they have passwords

0:47:47or if the teacher is white listing who's in,

0:47:49yeah, they fixed it, but.

0:47:51- Yeah, there's a mix of fixes they've instituted.

0:47:54They've been updating the thing almost weekly now.

0:47:57They just, I think they just put out version 5.0.

0:48:00The big hassle for me is to fix this camera problem.

0:48:03I had to buy a really nice video camera

0:48:05and you can use software like Cam Twist or OSB

0:48:09to make a virtual webcam out of any camera that you want

0:48:13or out of any window you want, literally anything.

0:48:16But the Zoom set it up so that it no longer

0:48:19will accept virtual webcams 'cause it's using

0:48:22some other more standard Apple library

0:48:24that is a little bit more locked down.

0:48:26And so there are people that are now,

0:48:28because they so desperately need virtual webcams

0:48:31to run their classroom or, you know,

0:48:33just because they want to have a nicer looking camera,

0:48:35you either have to like downgrade your Zoom

0:48:37to something more insecure,

0:48:39or you can go in and remove the code signing on the Zoom app

0:48:43and then it will accept virtual webcams.

0:48:45So the thing is like Zoom got super successful

0:48:49because it was, you know,

0:48:50it did a whole bunch of growth hacks and it was way easier.

0:48:53And they also played fast and loose with security.

0:48:55Now that they're doing the right thing,

0:48:57They brought on Alex Stamos from Facebook

0:48:59to be a consultant, all this stuff.

0:49:01People are still like, "Well, I'm still gonna disable

0:49:04"some of your security 'cause I wanna do a thing with it."

0:49:06- Yeah, I've heard from a couple people

0:49:10who are having great success with iPhones

0:49:12as their virtual web cameras.

0:49:14Again, it's like, all right, the world is short

0:49:18of commercial or domestic toilet paper,

0:49:22and okay, I get it.

0:49:23Everybody gets it, where everybody's pooping at home

0:49:26instead of pooping at school or in the office

0:49:28or wherever else we've gone to the bathroom.

0:49:30And so, yeah, yeah, it makes sense.

0:49:32The run on webcams, it makes sense,

0:49:36but it's like, if you worked at the webcam industry,

0:49:41you're like a webcam supply chain person at Logitech

0:49:45or one of these companies.

0:49:47Like, who would have thought that your job

0:49:49would become a pants-on-fire company-wide emergency in 2020?

0:49:55- Well, and Logitech, they know it's bad for their brand,

0:49:59so they're talking to every retailer they can

0:50:01trying to stop price gouging.

0:50:03They can't stop it on eBay, but they'll like,

0:50:05they're hunting for Logitech cameras on Amazon every day

0:50:10and issuing takedown notices,

0:50:11'cause they don't like the look

0:50:12of one of their cameras being sold for $600.

0:50:15- Right, it's bad enough that they're out, right?

0:50:18Because it's like, oh, it leaves a bad taste in your mouth,

0:50:21'cause you need it.

0:50:22It's all of a sudden your professional image

0:50:25is being hindered because you don't have a quality webcam.

0:50:30And yeah, it stinks, you can't get a Logitech one.

0:50:33But then when you see one being sold

0:50:34for three or four times the price,

0:50:37it's like, oh my God, this is terrible.

0:50:39It feels, you know.

0:50:40Literally is like a black market.

0:50:45It's not good.

0:50:46But anyway, who would have thought

0:50:48that would have been a go-go industry in 2020,

0:50:52but here we are.

0:50:53- Not me.

0:50:55- Anything else on the iPad Magic Keyboard

0:50:57before we take a break?

0:50:59- Man, I don't think so.

0:51:01The one thing is the charging port.

0:51:05It doesn't do data, but it does charging.

0:51:08I've got a little USB meter,

0:51:10and it charges almost as fast as just plugging it in directly

0:51:13which I did not expect through those little pogo pins

0:51:15on the back.

0:51:16It's like, it's just a couple of watts shy.

0:51:19- So I totally blew that in my review initially.

0:51:22And I don't know how, because I did measure it.

0:51:25And I think that where I went wrong

0:51:27was that I was measuring it while still using it.

0:51:31And that maybe I was doing something that was doing,

0:51:33like while I had it plugged in directly

0:51:37in the side of the iPad,

0:51:38I was doing something more intensive

0:51:41when I had it plugged into the Magic Keyboard thing.

0:51:44but I wrote in my review that it was

0:51:46a significant difference in charging speed.

0:51:48And that's what I got in my notes.

0:51:50I really did, but I was totally wrong.

0:51:52And Apple even reached out to me

0:51:54in the very kind and nice way that Apple PR does,

0:51:58where they're like, "Hey, we loved your review."

0:52:01And I'm like, "Wait, why are we on the phone?"

0:52:02(laughing)

0:52:03But, you know, you said this,

0:52:06that's actually, the team thinks

0:52:09that that's not the way it's supposed to be.

0:52:11I was like, "Well, I'll look again."

0:52:12And I looked again and did it,

0:52:13it's exactly what you said. It's, I don't know, maybe like 85% the speed, you know?

0:52:18Yeah, it's like 21 watts versus like 25.

0:52:22Yeah, it's really good, which is excellent. And it's, so I rejiggered that part of my review and

0:52:29crossed, you know, used the actual strike through HTML thing so that I wasn't weaseling, you know,

0:52:34I didn't want anybody to feel like I was gaslighting them. Like, I thought Gruberth

0:52:37said that it was slow. I was like, no, no, I'm wrong. But I need to, it was so wrong,

0:52:41I need to post like some kind of minor separate update to just say hey, this is actually a great way to charge the thing

0:52:46Yeah, I mean that's that's that's how I charge it every night now

0:52:50I just set it on there pick it up in the morning. Yeah. Yeah, it would be I don't know why they can't do data

0:52:55It you know

0:52:57It's I get I'm sure there's some kind of technical reason there that it's not really USB. It's just some proprietary

0:53:04It would be cool if you could

0:53:06But yeah, I think it's actually pretty much just USB

0:53:10Which is why it's so bonkers that nobody but Logitech has ever bothered to make anything for it

0:53:15Like I don't I don't think it's part of the MFI program

0:53:18none of that, I think it's just that the the

0:53:22Cost of making a part to work with the smart connector is so high that

0:53:28You you have to have a high degree of confidence that you're going to be able to continue to make that thing for

0:53:33Many many years and I think the iPad changes form factor often enough that only Apple is willing to sink that

0:53:40That initial development cost in them. That's my hunch

0:53:43I don't actually know but it is very strange if you if you really look around there's nothing that uses the smart connector

0:53:50Yeah, but it is true. It is a little confusing

0:53:54I find that as somebody who like I just said a couple minutes ago

0:53:57I have for quite a long time been a a Bluetooth iPad user with

0:54:02iPad, Bluetooth keyboard user with my iPad.

0:54:07And it's nice for just walking around with the iPad again,

0:54:09but then every time you go to type,

0:54:11you have to remember to toggle Bluetooth on and off

0:54:13or hit the button, you know,

0:54:14you have to do something to get it to disconnect

0:54:16from the keyboard if you haven't left the range.

0:54:19And these days, I never leave Bluetooth range.

0:54:22It's so nice.

0:54:25It sounds like such a bizarre thing to complain about,

0:54:27but it's so nice that it's not Bluetooth,

0:54:30And so it's if it's connected it's connected and if it's not physically connected

0:54:34It's not physically connected which makes you wonder why there aren't more peripherals that use it because it's so nice

0:54:40Convenience wise but there aren't yeah, I don't know

0:54:44Anyway, let's take a break and I will thank our first sponsor. It's our good friends at Linode l-i-n-o-d-e

0:54:50Linode cloud hosting look whether you're working on a personal project or managing your enterprises

0:54:57Infrastructure Linode cloud hosting as the pricing support and scale that you need to take your project to the next level with 11 data centers

0:55:06worldwide enterprise grade hardware and their next generation network Linode cloud hosting delivers the server performance you expect at

0:55:13A price you probably don't

0:55:16they have a special offer for all listeners of the talk show and

0:55:19New Linode customers use the promo code talk show

0:55:262020 talk show actually, it's just 20 not 2020. I forgot talk show 20

0:55:32And you will receive $20 in free credits as an added bonus

0:55:39They're giving you three free months of object storage. That is a new thing

0:55:45They have that is API compatible with AWS storage s3

0:55:49So if you have like code that hooks up to s3, you can just switch to Linode object storage

0:55:55Just switch right over three months free

0:55:58That's pretty cool

0:56:01I love Leno that is actually where daring fireball is now hosted. It is absolutely rock-solid. I love the stability

0:56:09I love the speed. I love the interface to everything. I have to manage when I have to manage something. It is really terrific

0:56:15And look they've got really truly enterprise grade plans that scale up to anything

0:56:22but their nanode plan starts at just five bucks five dollars and that's a really good plan and

0:56:29With the $20 deal with the coupon that's four months free. So look

0:56:33the linode comm slash the talk show that's the URL and

0:56:38Remember that code talk show 20 to get your $20 credit linode comm slash the talk show

0:56:49Alright next up iPhone SE and conveniently you also wrote the verges review of the iPhone SE

0:56:56Yeah

0:56:58this might have been my first iPhone review for the verse usually a neil i doesn't does them all but I

0:57:02Had a little bit more space in my video time than he did

0:57:07It is such an interesting product and I

0:57:13Like it. I think it's I think it's a really great little thing

0:57:18I think it's just what the doctor ordered for an awful lot of iPhone users

0:57:25But it is also the strangest

0:57:28Phone I think any company will release this year because I don't think any company but Apple could possibly

0:57:35Release a phone like this. I

0:57:38Mean it I

0:57:41Agree it's it's a it's funny the it actually had to restrain myself

0:57:48from like certain kinds of praise because I just I know that in a few

0:57:53years it may not age as well as it feels right now but the idea that you could

0:58:01get a phone of this quality that can do these things for $400 is it's just

0:58:08shocking it's it's so incredibly good it's a mix of things that are two and a

0:58:16and a half years old, like just the way it looks,

0:58:19the display, the display gets a lot of that attention

0:58:22because so much, and we'll get to this

0:58:24when we talk about Android phones too,

0:58:25but for obvious reasons, it is the most obvious thing

0:58:29that the whole point of the last 14, 13 years

0:58:34of smartphone design is that they are quote, unquote,

0:58:37all display, and slowly but surely,

0:58:40as they've evolved across the board,

0:58:44they've actually gotten more and more all display.

0:58:47Like the 20, the original iPhone at the time seemed like,

0:58:52oh my God, it's all display, there's only one button.

0:58:54Whereas now the screen to surface area ratio

0:58:58of the original iPhone seems comically small

0:59:01for this display.

0:59:03Well, by modern standards, meaning 2020,

0:59:06the new iPhone SE has very large chin and forehead.

0:59:11I mean, you just don't--

0:59:13- There's no getting around it.

0:59:14- There's no getting around it.

0:59:16- So, the immediate response to that complaint is,

0:59:20well, you know that that was how they got the price down.

0:59:23Is like they were able to use the factories

0:59:25they've had online since 2014 or whatever

0:59:28to just keep making this thing

0:59:30and they didn't have to retool anything,

0:59:31which I get, but that also is not my problem.

0:59:36- Right, right.

0:59:38- It's, I've used plenty of Android phones

0:59:41that cost this little.

0:59:42There's many reasons why they're not as good as this,

0:59:44to be clear, where they do manage to reduce the bezel.

0:59:48Now, in order to do that, Apple would have to make

0:59:52one of basically three choices.

0:59:54Number one, they'd have to decide to reduce it on the top.

0:59:58Well, number one, they'd have to retool everything.

1:00:00Assume they're willing to retool.

1:00:02They'd either need to reduce the bezel on the top

1:00:04but leave the big home button on the bottom,

1:00:06and then it would look asymmetrical and weird.

1:00:07- And they wouldn't do that.

1:00:08I guarantee you that's out. - They wouldn't do that.

1:00:09Nope, no way.

1:00:11They'd have to put the fingerprint sensor on the back,

1:00:13which is what a lot of Android phones have done for years.

1:00:16I don't know if they'd be willing to do that.

1:00:18Or they would need to spend the extra money

1:00:20to do an in-screen fingerprint sensor,

1:00:23which even in the best of cases is not really that great.

1:00:27And or number four, they'd have to just switch to Face ID,

1:00:30which would have, again, added a ton of cost.

1:00:33- Yeah, and so on number three,

1:00:35putting the fingerprint sensor in-screen.

1:00:37I wouldn't say that that's something Apple,

1:00:41that's a great list, 'cause I feel like,

1:00:43A, that list is comprehensive.

1:00:45So the asymmetrical chin and forehead

1:00:48is something Apple would not do.

1:00:50I don't even think they would do it a little.

1:00:52Like, and to a degree that's almost irrational,

1:00:55like when you look at a lot of the flagship Android phones

1:00:59that are out there, where there's a little bit more

1:01:02of a chin than the forehead,

1:01:04and I don't think that's a particularly bad look,

1:01:07especially if we're going to concede

1:01:11that the Apple phones, since the iPhone X,

1:01:15have a notch on the one side, right?

1:01:19Like the notch, whatever you think of it,

1:01:21is far more obtrusive and asymmetrical

1:01:26than the fact that the bezel other than the notch on the top

1:01:31is the same exact size as the bezel along the bottom

1:01:35that doesn't have a notch.

1:01:36but I mean, you know what I mean?

1:01:38It's crazy that they're fanatical

1:01:41about making the bezel symmetric on all four sides

1:01:44when they were willing to use a notch

1:01:46for the face ID array, but they are.

1:01:50And there is something in Apple's internal design aesthetics

1:01:54that I'm not even saying I agree with it,

1:01:56but I can feel it in my teeth

1:02:00that they feel that asymmetry in that way is wrong.

1:02:04So they're not gonna do it.

1:02:06The in-screen fingerprint thing, I think they would do in theory.

1:02:10I think they might do going forward as an additional thing in addition to face ID.

1:02:15I know there've been rumors along that line, but even without the rumors, I just feel like,

1:02:19eh, if they could do it right, they might, but there's no way they would do it in an

1:02:24SE.

1:02:25Right?

1:02:26Exactly.

1:02:27Well, so there's a couple, I mean, one, it's expensive.

1:02:29But two, I believe it requires that you use an OLED screen, not an LCD, because like the

1:02:35needs to have a backlight, and if you have a backlight,

1:02:37you can't put a fingerprint sensor underneath it, right?

1:02:38- Oh yeah, that makes sense.

1:02:40- It works with OLED.

1:02:41There's actually a fifth option, which some phones do,

1:02:44where they either integrate the fingerprint sensor

1:02:46in the sleep/wake button on the side,

1:02:48or they have it sort of next to it on the side

1:02:51as a separate thing, and again,

1:02:53I don't think Apple would ever do that,

1:02:55because that completely changes the modalities

1:02:59of what you expect iPhone buttons to do,

1:03:02and I think they very much didn't want to introduce

1:03:04a whole new interaction model into an iPhone SE

1:03:09that wasn't there before.

1:03:11- Yeah, and we'll have to get to that.

1:03:13So yeah, I don't really think they had,

1:03:15for the SE to be the SE and start at $400,

1:03:20it sort of had to be this way.

1:03:23- Yeah.

1:03:24- But then the weird aspects of the trade-offs

1:03:27that they're able to do because they're Apple

1:03:30is that they're able to put the,

1:03:32not just good, but literally best of industry A13 chip in.

1:03:37- Yeah, you cannot buy an Android phone for any price

1:03:43that has a faster processor than this $400 phone.

1:03:46- And, so A, competitive with Android,

1:03:50it is the fastest phone that you could get,

1:03:53and it's only $400, and as I really,

1:03:57I sort of enjoyed pointing out in my review,

1:04:00it is faster at single-threaded performance

1:04:03than a $3,000 16-inch MacBook Pro,

1:04:06which is the best laptop chip that Apple makes available

1:04:10in a MacBook Pro.

1:04:12And I don't wanna go on a whole benchmark digression,

1:04:16but single-threaded benchmark scores

1:04:18are more important than multi-threaded

1:04:20for most people in day-to-day use,

1:04:23especially on a phone,

1:04:24because you're just doing things like that.

1:04:26The areas where multi-threaded performance

1:04:28can really, really make a difference in your life

1:04:30are professional contexts,

1:04:32like you're rendering out 4K video or something like that.

1:04:37The things where multithreaded can really make a difference

1:04:43are professional contexts or developers,

1:04:46like Xcode developers can really make use on build times

1:04:50of having a whole number of cores.

1:04:52Single-threaded performance really matters.

1:04:54JavaScript, for example.

1:04:55So anything you're doing on the web

1:04:57where it's powered by JavaScript code.

1:04:59It's always single-threaded, and so it matters.

1:05:02And it's $400. (laughs)

1:05:04It's kinda crazy.

1:05:05The camera is really good for a single-lens camera,

1:05:10and it has features like the portrait mode stuff

1:05:14that are really quite remarkable,

1:05:18and it's $400.

1:05:20It's a really good camera.

1:05:22- Yeah, so actually the two things that make me go,

1:05:27ah, about the iPhone SE is,

1:05:31and honestly the only things that keep me

1:05:33from just straight up calling it a triumph are,

1:05:36will the camera and the battery in particular

1:05:41feel like they hold up in two or three years?

1:05:44And I'm like complaining,

1:05:45will this phone be good in three years as a complaint

1:05:47seems kind of silly given how long Android phones

1:05:50at this price point tend to last.

1:05:52But just in terms of like in the context of iPhones

1:05:54and recommending iPhones, it is a thing to notice.

1:05:58So iFixit did their tear down, went up Monday morning,

1:06:02they were recording this,

1:06:04and the battery is exactly the same.

1:06:05In fact, you can swap out the iPhone 8 battery.

1:06:08It's the exact same size battery.

1:06:09And we know that those batteries, you know,

1:06:11start to degrade after a while.

1:06:13And the thing that shocked me,

1:06:14given the quality of the camera,

1:06:16is it seems like the iPhone SE

1:06:20has the exact same camera module as the iPhone 8.

1:06:24I thought it maybe had the 10R camera module,

1:06:26but you can swap in the iPhone 8 camera module

1:06:29and it just works.

1:06:30- I thought that it did too.

1:06:31And that's an error in my iPhone SE review.

1:06:34I didn't say for a fact that it had the sensor from the 10R,

1:06:38but I kinda thought that it did.

1:06:40And I took side-by-side photos

1:06:42within tough lighting conditions.

1:06:43And it was like, "It looks the same."

1:06:46- Yeah, so this isn't like guaranteed

1:06:49they haven't done the full X-ray and taken apart this actual sensor module, but you can one for one

1:06:53swap it out with the iPhone 8, which is a pretty good sign that it's probably the same, or very,

1:06:59very close. It looks like it's a little bit smaller than a XR module when you look at the photos.

1:07:04And that is a thing to be concerned about long-term, it might not hold up as well,

1:07:09but it is a thing to absolutely marvel at in terms of the camera quality that they have

1:07:14right now, you know, when they said we put the A13 in it,

1:07:18therefore the pictures are gonna be better.

1:07:19I was like, yeah, we'll see.

1:07:22- Yeah, I thought the same thing.

1:07:23- But if it's using a sensor or something

1:07:27that's virtually equivalent to the sensor of the iPhone 8,

1:07:30and it's able to get, you know,

1:07:32the quality of photos that come out of this thing,

1:07:34I'm shocked at how good it is.

1:07:36My only, you know, I think it's pretty bad in low light.

1:07:38I think it actually falls down like a steeper cliff

1:07:41in low light than an iPhone 11 does, for example,

1:07:45or even, maybe even a XR.

1:07:47But other than that, there's really not a whole lot

1:07:50to complain about.

1:07:51- Yeah, and it doesn't do night mode.

1:07:54- Right, which is weird, isn't it?

1:07:56- Yeah, because I, so it does have the full array

1:08:01of portrait mode modes for lack of a sub-mode and port,

1:08:07you know, lighting effects, I guess we could call them,

1:08:09in portrait mode.

1:08:11And the ones that mask out the background,

1:08:14whatever Apple calls them, I always forget,

1:08:17but the ones that just isolate you, the person,

1:08:20and mask out the background as black or white,

1:08:24the stage light ones and high key light ones,

1:08:27the other phones they've had don't do that

1:08:33because it's, I guess, computationally

1:08:35or machine learning wise expensive,

1:08:38and with the A13, they're able to do it,

1:08:40and the results are really good.

1:08:43And I put it in a footnote in my review,

1:08:47but I kind of like, eh, not really use those modes

1:08:51since they were new.

1:08:52Not that I never used them, but I don't use them as much.

1:08:55And I realized, I was saying that other people may not,

1:08:58but what I really was doing was writing about myself,

1:09:00is that the live preview in the camera is rough,

1:09:04and then you snap your self-portrait,

1:09:06like with the selfie mode and the high-key lighting,

1:09:10and it doesn't look good as you're taking it,

1:09:12and then you give it a second or two to process,

1:09:15and you get, you can, not always,

1:09:17sometimes it's funky and your glasses are off

1:09:20or your ear's not right or something,

1:09:22but more often than not, it's actually really credible

1:09:26and 100 times better than the preview would suggest.

1:09:30- Yeah. - So I was like,

1:09:31"Ah, this actually does deserve to be here,"

1:09:33but if that's computational,

1:09:35I thought that the night mode was purely computational,

1:09:39and so the A13 would have allowed it and it doesn't.

1:09:43And I don't know if that's just like deliberate marketing,

1:09:46like well, like I'm sure it's not just a secret switch

1:09:51they could flip to enable it,

1:09:52but that they didn't spend time on it

1:09:53because they didn't want the $400 phone to have it

1:09:57for marketing reasons or--

1:09:59- Yeah, I don't wanna ascribe that.

1:10:01Like that's like one step too far down

1:10:04like a conspiracy rabbit hole for me,

1:10:05although I'm tempted to say it.

1:10:06I think the fact that if it is in fact something similar

1:10:09to the iPhone sensor, maybe that's a piece of the puzzle,

1:10:12but the thing that they've done here

1:10:14that they didn't do before the XR and the X

1:10:17was they are doing, they're taking multiple,

1:10:20multiple, multiple photos in whatever they call

1:10:23their advanced HDR, like the foundation

1:10:25of what computational photography is these days.

1:10:29And they are doing that with this camera

1:10:32and this A13 processor.

1:10:34The one thing that they're not doing that's pretty modern

1:10:37is their depth map, as far as I know,

1:10:41is completely done via machine learning

1:10:43just by like semantically looking at what's in the image

1:10:46trying to guess it.

1:10:47They're not doing the weird thing

1:10:49where you can like do a differential

1:10:50between like two sides of a pixel or whatever.

1:10:52- Yeah, so let me just say before we go on,

1:10:56my personal belief is not that it's marketing spite.

1:10:59I just, I think that there is something

1:11:01about this iPhone 8 era sensor

1:11:05that does not makes it incompatible

1:11:07with the way they do night mode.

1:11:09And the fact that they didn't hold back

1:11:10on the portrait mode stuff makes me think

1:11:12that if they could have done it relatively easy,

1:11:14they would have.

1:11:15And the fact that the $1,000 plus iPad Pros

1:11:20that they just came out with

1:11:22don't have those portrait mode features,

1:11:26but they do have an A12 series chip

1:11:30makes me think that it really is A,

1:11:33tied to the A13 specifically, which the SE has,

1:11:37and even the new iPad Pros don't,

1:11:40and needs a very recent sensor.

1:11:44And so the iFED SE has this, the A13,

1:11:49which enables the portrait mode stuff,

1:11:51but can't do the night mode, so that's my theory.

1:11:53But yeah, I feel like on a podcast,

1:11:55you have to toss it out, you know, as who knows.

1:11:57- Yeah, oh, sure, yeah.

1:11:58And again, like, I cannot wait for someone

1:12:01to actually like break the metal on this thing

1:12:03look directly at the sensor and confirm that it is the same because it might not be. It might be

1:12:08something slightly different, but the fact that you could just swap the part out seems like a

1:12:13pretty good sign. It's crazy. The other thing with the SE that it, so Apple is so different than any

1:12:20other phone maker. I mean, they control their own OS, which is the thing everybody thinks about and

1:12:25is the most notable aspect. But the little things like it's just underappreciated that they make

1:12:32their own chips and that their chip team is like seriously like years ahead of the competition.

1:12:39It's really a strange situation that doesn't have any historical comparison

1:12:45and enables them to put a top-of-the-line chip in a $400 phone. Yeah, well and also like nobody else

1:12:56has, I mean Samsung sells a shit ton of phones don't get me wrong, but nobody else has the

1:13:00economy of scale to be like, well, we're already making so many of these 813s anyway, it would

1:13:06probably cost us more to put a lower end chip in it and keep that production line spun up

1:13:11just for this phone than it would to just use our top of the line one that we're already

1:13:14making anyway.

1:13:16Nobody else could do that.

1:13:18So one of the downsides that Apple faces, though, is that they just don't make many

1:13:23phones, model-wise, right?

1:13:26So they, you know.

1:13:28And even if you count, and people underestimate this, when you go to apple.com or when you

1:13:34go into the actual Apple store, when the Apple stores are open, and you see what they have

1:13:41on the table, they've got now, they've got the SE, the XR, and the iPhone 11, and then

1:13:47the 11 Pros, and that's it.

1:13:50But they still make a lot of the other ones from recent years.

1:13:54still in man being manufactured and they're sold quote unquote in the channel like if you go to

1:13:59Best Buy there's a lot more iPhones available like the iPhone 10s and 10s max and you know you could

1:14:07buy I don't think they still make the original 10 anymore but you could you could buy it for years

1:14:11after it was out of Apple's official lineup now you can even there I don't know if they're still

1:14:16making it but in channel the iPhone 8 plus is still out there in the world uh I think they

1:14:22might still be making it and if they're not making it making it they they stockpiled it because somebody

1:14:27somebody had it in their review that that it's officially in the channel

1:14:33because they don't have a home screen iphone in the plus size that's called the se there is no se plus

1:14:41right but that means though that apple has to always kind of has to try to kill multiple

1:14:50market segment birds with one stone.

1:14:53And there's, the SE is trying to do

1:14:57a bunch of things at once, right?

1:14:59It's the low-cost new phone that will have

1:15:02technical relevance for years to come.

1:15:04Like you're gonna get four or five years

1:15:06of software updates for an SE that you buy tomorrow.

1:15:09- Yep.

1:15:10- It's only 400 bucks, right?

1:15:12And again, maybe for a lot of people,

1:15:15400 bucks still sounds like a lot for a phone.

1:15:18But it's not a lot for a new iPhone,

1:15:20and that's their answer to that.

1:15:22But then there's also the segment,

1:15:26I know people toss out their mom as a quote unquote,

1:15:31example of a technically unsavvy person,

1:15:34but my mom really is the perfect target

1:15:38for the new iPhone SE.

1:15:40She has a 6 or a 6S, I forget which one,

1:15:43but at the very newest it's a 6S.

1:15:46Her battery is failing, and it's usable,

1:15:49but it's like she doesn't get through a day,

1:15:51and she doesn't do anything.

1:15:52So she leaves the house, her phone is in the red

1:15:56by the time she comes home from a day out.

1:16:00And I've been telling her, you should wait.

1:16:03And now, in the last couple of weeks,

1:16:05it's been really easy to tell her she could wait.

1:16:08She doesn't want news.

1:16:09She wants, and she's gotten, and Apple has her numbers,

1:16:14She's gotten the email to her mac.com address

1:16:17with telling her about the SE,

1:16:19and she's like, "This is what I want."

1:16:20And I'm like, "Mom, that's the one I've been telling you.

1:16:23"You should wait for her."

1:16:24But she loves that it looks like the phone

1:16:27she already knows.

1:16:28That is a market segment.

1:16:31And the touch ID versus face ID thing is huge.

1:16:37There are millions of people who just,

1:16:40because they've never used face ID

1:16:42and it sounds weird to have your phone

1:16:45facially recognize you, they want a fingerprint sensor.

1:16:49And so the Apple's trying to sell something to this market

1:16:53and the fact that for all of we enthusiasts

1:16:57who think that it looks dated,

1:16:59that it has this chin and forehead

1:17:01that go back to the iPhone 6,

1:17:03is comforting to people who just want a new phone

1:17:07that's faster and has a fresh battery

1:17:10and works exactly like they did.

1:17:12You know, the SE is trying to do all those things at once.

1:17:14Yeah, and it's a lot and the fact that it's able to pull off most of that stuff, or all of it actually, is really impressive.

1:17:21It's funny, I made a joke of this in my video, but I forgot how much I liked the home button.

1:17:28It gets really nice. Actually, it's not even just the home button.

1:17:33It's swiping up from the bottom for control center.

1:17:37I'm so used to that at home, for going home now,

1:17:39that it felt really, really weird to swipe up

1:17:42and have control center pop up.

1:17:44But it's just, it's such a larger target of a swipe

1:17:49than that upper right-hand corner

1:17:51that as soon as I went back to it and after a day,

1:17:54it's like, oh yeah, I prefer this in a funny way.

1:17:57Now, I would never want to go back

1:17:58to not having the full gesture navigation

1:18:01and swiping up from the bottom

1:18:02is the appropriate way to do that, to go home.

1:18:04It is like the thing you want to be the easiest.

1:18:07So it makes sense. Apple made the right call there.

1:18:10But you know, just like for a little while,

1:18:12at least it's nice to like just have easier access

1:18:15to control center.

1:18:16- Yeah, I kind of feel, you know, and there's, you know,

1:18:19I've heard it from home button diehards

1:18:23who are enthusiasts because they read Daring Fireball

1:18:26and follow me on Twitter and that they're, you know,

1:18:28oh yeah, I forgot the other market that this has been to,

1:18:30Pease, is the people who want the smallest possible iPhone.

1:18:33- Right, well, I didn't bring it up

1:18:36because it's not, I mean, it is the smallest possible iPhone,

1:18:38but that's not necessarily saying much.

1:18:40- Right, right, but, you know,

1:18:42and those people are really, you know,

1:18:45heartsick that it wasn't iPhone 5-sized,

1:18:50which is what they really want.

1:18:51They wanted a new SE that looked like the old SE,

1:18:53which looked like an iPhone 5.

1:18:55And I tried to explain that a week or two ago

1:18:59on "Daring Fireball" as to why that isn't really aligned

1:19:02with Apple's strategy, even though that's a reasonable idea.

1:19:06And if Apple made seven different iPhones at a time,

1:19:09maybe one of them would still be that size.

1:19:12But I think all the developers that are looking forward

1:19:15to dropping that from their UI support are like, no, no.

1:19:19Really, fewer screen sizes would be a little better.

1:19:33So the one thing about the iPhone X style,

1:19:36I wish we had a name for it.

1:19:37You know, like when Mac OS X first shipped

1:19:41and they had the, way back in like 2001 or 2002,

1:19:46whatever year it was,

1:19:47Steve Jobs introduced the new user interface.

1:19:50They gave it a name, they called it Aqua.

1:19:52And Aqua was that look and feel that they,

1:19:56you know, it looked so good you could lick it.

1:19:57And it's, you know, had this,

1:19:59it just, it was nice to have a name for it.

1:20:03It would be nice if we had a name

1:20:05for the iPhone 10-style interface

1:20:08where you swipe up from the bottom

1:20:09and control center's in the top right.

1:20:11Some things are the same,

1:20:15but some things are fundamentally different.

1:20:17And I've gone back and forth in my writing

1:20:22calling it the post-iPhone 10 interface or whatever.

1:20:27I get it why Apple hasn't named it.

1:20:29They just sort of want you not to think about it.

1:20:31But when you do write about it,

1:20:32There's nothing to call it.

1:20:33But the one thing that,

1:20:34to me it's like fitting jigsaw puzzle pieces together

1:20:38as designers, and I feel like Apple was like,

1:20:40okay, we don't have a button anymore.

1:20:42What can we do?

1:20:43Well, we could swipe up from the bottom

1:20:45like WebOS used to do.

1:20:47I don't know if you remember that, Dieter.

1:20:49- Do you think?

1:20:50Yeah, I vaguely remember WebOS.

1:20:53(laughing)

1:20:55- You could swipe up from the bottom

1:20:56and your apps would look like cards,

1:20:58and then you could go side to side.

1:21:00And you start fitting in all these things

1:21:02that the home button and touch ID used to do.

1:21:05And it's like, well, what about if you wanna authorize

1:21:07a purchase and you're looking at the phone already?

1:21:10Well, you could double click the power button

1:21:12after face ID identifies you.

1:21:14And they're like, okay, that's not perfect, but that works.

1:21:18And then I feel like the one puzzle piece

1:21:20that was left over was control center, right?

1:21:25It's like top down was notifications and it still is.

1:21:29And bottom up now is home screen and multitasking.

1:21:34And the sides mean other things.

1:21:38Like the left side is how you go back in an app.

1:21:42And it's like they had this puzzle piece,

1:21:44and they're like, well, you could go down

1:21:46from the top right corner where the wifi

1:21:50and cellular signal strength is,

1:21:52because that's where the wifi and signal strength things are,

1:21:56control center.

1:21:58Also, that's, just gonna say, that's how WebOS did it.

1:22:02(laughing)

1:22:04- Well, maybe that, maybe that's,

1:22:08wouldn't you like to think that there's somebody

1:22:10on the team who was working on that who was at Palm,

1:22:12you know, 10, 11 years ago,

1:22:15who was just like, just keeps raising their hand?

1:22:18(laughing)

1:22:20- By the way, we solved this problem once before.

1:22:22- Well, no, maybe, I'd like to think

1:22:23that maybe the way they sold it internally

1:22:25was they didn't even mention it.

1:22:26They were like, "How about?"

1:22:28(both laughing)

1:22:30They're like, "Well, that could work."

1:22:32It is, it's just, it's not,

1:22:36ill-fitting puzzle piece is not quite right,

1:22:41but it still, it just feels overloaded

1:22:45at the top of the screen that it's--

1:22:46- Well, so the way Android solves this is it just,

1:22:49it combines those two things.

1:22:50There's a quick settings area that comes down,

1:22:53and then the notification shade is attached to that.

1:22:55And so you can expand the quick settings

1:22:57or the notification shade.

1:22:58So the entire top of the Android phone

1:23:01is both of those things.

1:23:02And what you see when it comes down

1:23:04depends on how many times you swipe down.

1:23:06- Yeah, well, neither is great.

1:23:09There's trade-offs with both.

1:23:10But yeah, it's weird.

1:23:13I had a really hard time with it

1:23:16when I was trying to use the SE for a week

1:23:18where I just kept going top right

1:23:20'cause I've really ingrained it into my habits.

1:23:25The one that I just could not,

1:23:28a few of the things I just could not get used to

1:23:31is I could not get used to the fact

1:23:32that you can't tap the screen anywhere to wake it up.

1:23:35I-- - Yes.

1:23:36- I just, I cannot tell you how many times

1:23:38I thought the battery had died,

1:23:39and I was like, wait, that might be a problem,

1:23:41'cause I know I had like 60% battery,

1:23:44and now this thing's dead.

1:23:46- Yep.

1:23:47But it does still have the accelerometer

1:23:49where if you like, it feels that you picked it up

1:23:51or it feels you pulled it out of your pocket,

1:23:53it will light up the screen.

1:23:54And so I couldn't just tap it on the table,

1:23:56but I got the habit of just picking the thing up

1:23:58to wake it up.

1:23:59- Yeah, but it's, and maybe it's like a review thing too

1:24:02where I'm spending a lot of time in a review at a keyboard,

1:24:07and the iPad or iPhone I'm reviewing

1:24:10is right there on the desk next to me,

1:24:12but I wanna wake it up.

1:24:14I just kept poking at it, didn't wake up.

1:24:16I'm trying to think what else on the iPhone SE.

1:24:21Anything else?

1:24:23I mean, you can make fun of me for being sad

1:24:25about the headphone jack.

1:24:25- Ah. (laughs)

1:24:27Well, I'm not gonna make fun.

1:24:28I mean, at this point, I give you credit

1:24:31for sticking with it, you know?

1:24:33- Well, so the only reason on the iPhone SE in particular,

1:24:36and maybe this is patronizing, maybe this is whatever,

1:24:41is that a bunch of Android phones in this price class

1:24:45make it a point to leave the headphone jack in

1:24:48because they figure if you're price sensitive enough

1:24:50to wanna spend that little on a phone,

1:24:52you're price sensitive enough to not wanna have to go out

1:24:54and spend 150 bucks on a pair of Bluetooth headphones.

1:24:58- Yeah, and you know, that if you wanna get replacements,

1:25:03you do just wanna pop into the drugstore

1:25:06and get the $7 ones, you know, that you don't even,

1:25:09you know, you just, you know that they work,

1:25:12you can just look at it, you don't have to look for like

1:25:14a works with iPhone logo or something, it's, you just,

1:25:17you know, it just has a headphone jack,

1:25:19you know it's gonna work.

1:25:21know, and you also know you have a drawer full of them, even if you're not the sort of person

1:25:26like us who has a drawer full of all sorts of cables. Everybody's got a drawer full of headphones.

1:25:31Pete: I keep a stockpile of the original iPhone earbuds that, you know, nobody really likes

1:25:37because they fall out of your ear just because it's the most reliable microphone I have for

1:25:44conference calls. Like, last ditch, my Bluetooth headphones failed, blah blah blah blah. I just

1:25:48grab those, plug it into my Mac, and know that I'm going to have reliable headphones

1:25:52and a microphone for a conference call.

1:25:53I used to have a stockpile of them because I've bought a bunch of, over the years, I

1:25:59just wound up, how could you not, in my racket, wind up with a ton of them?

1:26:04I owned a bunch of iPods.

1:26:07By the mid-2000s, by the early end of the 2000s at least, I started doing reviews on

1:26:12a regular basis and getting review units, and Apple doesn't even want the headphones

1:26:15back when you send the review units back.

1:26:19And I wouldn't even open the new ones.

1:26:20I would just put them, you know,

1:26:22keep them in a nice little case and put them aside.

1:26:25I wound up going through my whole stockpile

1:26:27because I'm not gonna name names,

1:26:29but it was my son Jonas who slowly

1:26:32but surely destroyed them all.

1:26:35Because while there are good things to say about them

1:26:41and the microphone is one of them,

1:26:43the the

1:26:45durability

1:26:46Yeah, much like light apples lightning cables the durability of the connector where it goes in is not great

1:26:54Nope

1:26:56Once he found out which drawer I kept them in eventually I went in I was like, hey, there's no more of these left

1:27:02And he's like, yeah, do you have any more of those and I was like, oh my god

1:27:07But on the plus side we got him air pods for Christmas like two years ago two Christmases ago

1:27:13And he hasn't lost them either of them and so kudos to him and it is completely alleviated

1:27:19His destruction of my entire collection of apple branded

1:27:23Keychains. All right. Let me take another break here and thank our other sponsor for this episode our good friends at squarespace

1:27:29Hey squarespace make your next move. Look everybody's got a lot of extra time on their hands right now

1:27:37If one of the things you're looking to do

1:27:40while you have time at home is start a new website

1:27:43or maybe update an old website,

1:27:45take a look at Squarespace.

1:27:48Squarespace does it all,

1:27:50everything from registering domain names to templates

1:27:54for any type of design to start with,

1:27:58award-winning templates that scale across devices,

1:28:02responsive design from the phone up to a giant screen,

1:28:06two elements that you can embed right in your website, like a store that includes all the

1:28:12commerce stuff or a blog where you have an actual CMS right built into the Squarespace

1:28:17system for adding posts or hosting a podcast, anything like that. Analytics, find out who's

1:28:24coming to your website from where Squarespace has it built in. Award-winning text support,

1:28:31you can imagine. Great pricing, great support, great documentation, great templates to choose

1:28:37from. You name it, Squarespace has it. Go there, start it. Included with it is 30 days

1:28:43free when you just start building a website. Spend a month building a website, see if you

1:28:48like it. When you decide to sign up, use this code, talk show. Go to squarespace.com/talkshow

1:28:57to start and then when you pay, which you don't have to do for 30 days, use that code

1:29:02talk show, you save 10% off your first purchase. So go to squarespace.com/talkshow. Remember

1:29:09that code talk show. And if it's not you, if it's somebody else you know who in the

1:29:13quarantine is like, "Hey, maybe I should make a new website," send them to Squarespace,

1:29:17give them the code, save them 10%. My thanks to Squarespace.

1:29:22So let's, we don't have tons of time left, but let's talk Android. So I'm curious

1:29:26to hear what you think are the flagships worth talking about in 2020 so far?

1:29:31- So the most interesting stuff so far, there's a couple of Samsung Galaxy S20s,

1:29:37the Ultra and the regular, and I put those in two different categories. Then there is the new

1:29:44OnePlus 8 Pro, that's three, and then we're soon to have something from Motorola trying to make

1:29:51a comeback. You know, there's a bunch of other stuff in and around all those, but those are like

1:29:56the most interesting ones. I mean, the thing to know about Android flagships is they're all

1:30:01completely dependent on Qualcomm processors, right? Like, Qualcomm has a monopoly in the US,

1:30:07Samsung is doing its level best to break it with Exynos processors that it tries to sell

1:30:12internationally, but like, in the US, it's just Qualcomm, and like, you get what Qualcomm gives

1:30:17you, and what Qualcomm is giving Android manufacturers this year is the Snapdragon 865,

1:30:24and then there's a 700 series.

1:30:26And the 865 is notable because the 865 is the fastest one,

1:30:30it's the one everybody's gonna want,

1:30:32and it only works with 5G, there is no 4G version

1:30:35because it has a separate modem from the processor,

1:30:40which is weird, but that modem,

1:30:42the only compatible modem is a 5G modem.

1:30:45All of which is to say flagship Android phones

1:30:48are just like every other phone, but especially this year,

1:30:51they're coming in pretty expensive,

1:30:53Even the quote-unquote cheap one like OnePlus is still you know, 800 bucks 900 bucks

1:30:57um because they've got that

1:31:005g radio that costs a bit more money

1:31:02um

1:31:04And so that the cadence is also weird because you expect phones to come in the fall

1:31:08But Qualcomm releases these processors basically in the spring

1:31:11And so the first one out of the gate with them is usually Samsung with the Galaxy S line. So

1:31:15uh this year

1:31:17Samsung was trying to pull off two things. They were you know, this is the big year for 5g

1:31:22It's a big year that 5G is actually real and matters and it's something you're gonna want. I think that's not true, but whatever

1:31:28and so they they wanted to push 5g with the Galaxy s20 line and

1:31:32Then they have in the galaxy s20 ultra which is the big big big one the huge one

1:31:37They were trying to push this whole new camera system that has a periscope, you know

1:31:43So there's a mirror that like pushes down so you can get extra zoom whatever but they also have a hundred and eight megapixel

1:31:49camera sensor in it that Samsung makes instead of just using a Sony sensor, which is what everybody else has been doing for years

1:31:57So Samsung really wanted to like we can we can do this whole thing ourselves now

1:32:01and

1:32:03The ultra is just like 1400 bucks

1:32:06Turns out that 108 megapixel camera. They didn't figure it out like that. They couldn't they couldn't wrangle it

1:32:12And so it's it's got really bad focus problems and it's just kind of meh

1:32:18Whereas the galaxy s20 which has a less ambitious camera is just a great phone. It's really really good

1:32:24It's it's probably my favorite Android phone of the past, you know, six months to a year. I really enjoy it

1:32:29and then the story with one plus just to ramble get through the rest of the ramble here is

1:32:35To date their whole shtick has been we give you a really good quality phone

1:32:41But we hold back one or two features to save a bunch of money so you can get

1:32:45Virtually the same quality as Samsung phone

1:32:48But you can spend a few hundred dollars less for stuff you don't care about.

1:32:53Usually that's something like wireless charging.

1:32:55But this year, they decided they were going to take Samsung head on

1:32:59by including wireless charging that's like super fast wireless charging.

1:33:03It's really fascinating.

1:33:04But also with working with more carriers.

1:33:07So now it works with both T-Mobile and Verizon for the first time.

1:33:10So they are really, really trying to come at Samsung's like dominant monopoly

1:33:16in Android phones, I don't know if it's a monopoly,

1:33:21but they've got a huge dominant position,

1:33:22especially in the US,

1:33:23and they're finally getting challenged head on.

1:33:25- Yeah, well, yeah, monopoly's,

1:33:28it's like a lowercase m monopoly, right?

1:33:30It's sort of like Apple's monopoly on iPhones,

1:33:33where they don't have 50% of the market share of the phones,

1:33:36but they do have the only iPhones,

1:33:38and the only phones running iOS.

1:33:40And Samsung's monopoly is sort of like mental monopoly,

1:33:44you know, on high-end, state-of-the-art flagship Android phones. I mean, however you want to

1:33:50describe flagship, you know, Samsung has sort of had like a, they're at the forefront of this.

1:33:56- Yeah, and Huawei was coming for them until that whole, all went to hell, but the reason Samsung

1:34:01has that monopoly on the high end is because they've spent the past 20 years, like, forming

1:34:08relationships with carriers and cutting deals with carriers in the US. And so when Verizon wants to

1:34:13to have a new phone, Samsung is at the door

1:34:16with a suitcase full of 10 of them.

1:34:17- Yeah, so the 108 megapixel phone,

1:34:22I still don't really understand how,

1:34:25if most phones have 12 megapixels

1:34:28and how it jumps up to 108,

1:34:30because it's sort of like a funny definition of megapixels.

1:34:34- Yeah, so they bin it down to, I think, 12 most of the time

1:34:40So they combine all the megapixels together

1:34:44into one larger pixel.

1:34:46But the way the sub-pixels work is a little bit fuzzy

1:34:50in terms of what the RGB is.

1:34:52And so it's not quite exactly like one-to-one

1:34:55what you would expect, you just get RGB

1:34:57and then multiply it times never megapixels you have.

1:35:01But the way the binning works,

1:35:04the way that they combine those pixels

1:35:07in like really solid conditions,

1:35:09you do actually get a really high megapixel image

1:35:11that does have a little bit more detail.

1:35:14The problem comes is you don't actually want,

1:35:16you're not shooting in perfectly bright light

1:35:18with a perfectly still camera on a tripod 99% of the time.

1:35:21And so what you wanna do is you wanna combine

1:35:24all of those pixels in the hardware in some way

1:35:27so that it acts more like a manageable

1:35:2912 or 16 megapixel sensor.

1:35:32And they just didn't get it.

1:35:34They weren't able to wrangle all that stuff.

1:35:37Like the thing that makes the Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra,

1:35:41terrible name, oh, there's a 5G in there somewhere too.

1:35:43(laughing)

1:35:45The thing that makes that camera good

1:35:47in so far as it's good is it's just a larger sensor.

1:35:51It's just physically bigger

1:35:52and that makes a huge difference.

1:35:53- And that's sort of in even lay person's terms,

1:35:57bigger sensor is in and of itself is always better.

1:36:02It just means, 'cause it means more light hits the sensor

1:36:04and doesn't even matter how you count the pixels,

1:36:07it's bigger sensors better.

1:36:08And it even goes back to the film days

1:36:11where the large format cameras

1:36:14that professional fashion photographers would use

1:36:16or landscape photographers like Ansel Adams,

1:36:19you could just get these fantastic images

1:36:21out of this enormous compared to a 35 millimeter

1:36:24frame of film negative.

1:36:27- But so the dynamic with especially flagship Android phones

1:36:31is really interesting and I think different than iPhone.

1:36:35So everybody's cycle is slowing down,

1:36:37that people are upgrading less often, right?

1:36:39So that's thing one is everybody knows

1:36:43that they're not necessarily going to get everybody

1:36:45to upgrade every year, so that's fine.

1:36:48With the iPhone, Apple just keeps,

1:36:51it's another iPhone, here you go,

1:36:53these are the new things we added to it.

1:36:54But with Android phones, there's so much more competition

1:36:58amongst the different players there

1:37:00that they have to find some way

1:37:03to not only convince people they might wanna upgrade,

1:37:06but also convince people that they wanna buy

1:37:08a Samsung or a OnePlus phone

1:37:10instead of a competitor's phone.

1:37:12And so they get into these sort of weird spec horse races

1:37:17that sometimes lead them down blind alleys.

1:37:20I sort of think of it in the same way

1:37:22that I think about television.

1:37:25So everybody bought HDTV,

1:37:27and the reason they actually bought it

1:37:29is 'cause it was a thin LCD, not 'cause it was 1080p.

1:37:32And then after that cycle, all the TV manufacturers

1:37:35are like, well, what's next?

1:37:37Well, maybe everybody wants 3D TVs.

1:37:39Nope, nobody wants 3D.

1:37:40Maybe everybody wants curved TVs.

1:37:42Nope, nobody wants curved TVs.

1:37:43What about 4K?

1:37:45Maybe.

1:37:45What about 4K plus HDR?

1:37:47Okay, now you're getting somewhere

1:37:49and they're starting to get more upgrades.

1:37:51So Android phones have a similar challenge.

1:37:53They're trying to come up with the mix of magical upgrades

1:37:58that will convince you, okay, I'm gonna upgrade

1:38:00more than every three years or whatever.

1:38:03And that more than anything is the reason for 5G hype,

1:38:07is the carriers also benefit

1:38:09from people upgrading their phones.

1:38:11And so they really wanna convince you

1:38:13that 5G is hot shit that you need.

1:38:16And so they are pushing in,

1:38:18there's like a cabal between the carriers

1:38:21and the Android makers and Qualcomm

1:38:23to try and spin up 5G into something magical

1:38:26that convinces you you wanna upgrade.

1:38:28And in certain areas, on certain networks,

1:38:335G is very fast and very impressive,

1:38:36but it is nowhere near, I think,

1:38:39worth the cost premium right now.

1:38:42A year from now, they might build out the networks even more

1:38:44and might impress me and that'll be fine.

1:38:46But if you wanna buy a new phone this year,

1:38:49especially a new Android phone,

1:38:50get it because you need a new phone

1:38:52or you want the camera or whatever the other feature is.

1:38:55Don't get it because it has 5G appended

1:38:58to the end of the name.

1:38:58- And it's always, it's like everything in technology,

1:39:01there's always diminishing returns as the years go by.

1:39:05And you know, you name it, it's always true.

1:39:08You know, CPU speeds used to be such a huge deal

1:39:11where if you bought a new PC 18 months

1:39:14after your last one, it's like, oh my God,

1:39:16it's like 10 times faster.

1:39:17And you know, going from edge to 3G

1:39:21was like turning the lights on in a dark room.

1:39:24It's like, oh my God, this is unbelievable.

1:39:26and then going from 3G to LTE wasn't quite as fantastic

1:39:31as pre-3G to 3G, but it was still like,

1:39:35wow, this LTE is seriously like,

1:39:37might be faster than my Wi-Fi, this is really good,

1:39:40and it's good up too.

1:39:42And sure, 5G might be better than LTE,

1:39:44but LTE is like really good.

1:39:47- Well, it's like where are the pain points with LTE?

1:39:52There's actually fewer than you think,

1:39:54like streaming quality maybe could be better,

1:39:57you know, like how often are you really uploading files?

1:39:59Like the whole point of 5G is that it's going to enable

1:40:02you to do things that you otherwise would only do

1:40:05on WiFi or, you know, on Ethernet or whatever.

1:40:09And I just don't think a lot of people

1:40:10are like hankering for that right now.

1:40:12- Right, and I've seen, you know, a lot of reports

1:40:14that 5G might have a better story for covering rural areas,

1:40:19you know, that they might be able to have,

1:40:22with fewer towers and spread out more, get a signal

1:40:26so that places that still don't have a good LTE signal

1:40:29or any LTE signal might be able to get a 5G signal.

1:40:33And that is great if you live there, but by definition,

1:40:36it literally, by definition, there's not that many people

1:40:40because you're talking about sparsely populated areas.

1:40:42So it's not going to sell a lot of phones

1:40:44because that's not where the people are.

1:40:47- And it's also hard to know how much

1:40:50that rural connectivity story is real

1:40:53and how much of it is the carriers telling the FCC things

1:40:56that the FCC wants to hear

1:40:57and the FCC pretending like it's true

1:40:59because they're in bed with the carriers.

1:41:01- Yeah, and how do you get people to buy it too, right?

1:41:04Like if you're just a person with a bum LTE signal

1:41:08at your house and you hear 5G's great,

1:41:11well, how do you prove it until you go out

1:41:13and spend $1,000 on a flagship phone with 5G

1:41:16and then take it home and see if you get a signal?

1:41:18I mean, you can take your phone back if you do it

1:41:21and you have a bad signal and you can return phones,

1:41:25but that, I don't know,

1:41:27is it really gonna move the phones off the shelves?

1:41:29I don't know.

1:41:30- Yeah, well, there's also just a pacing story.

1:41:32We're used to tech stuff happening relatively quickly

1:41:36and build outs of cellular networks take years.

1:41:41And so it's just a matter of when do they hype it

1:41:44and how fast do they hype it

1:41:46and how early do you believe in the hype?

1:41:47and we're still mid-cycle at best

1:41:51on the build out of these networks,

1:41:52and until we get closer to late cycle

1:41:55and really start to know what they enable,

1:41:57it's hard to buy into any of the hype.

1:41:58- Yeah.

1:42:00Bonus content.

1:42:01I told you before we would talk about the lack

1:42:04of haptic touch on the iPhone SE,

1:42:06and I forgot to bring it.

1:42:08Even though I'm staring at a note,

1:42:09I wrote a note to myself right here.

1:42:12It says iPhone SE haptic touch kerfwaffle.

1:42:16We didn't talk about it.

1:42:17talk about that and then and then we'll call it a show so here's the so i can you explain it i i

1:42:23because i'm not even sure where explain it so uh it's actually funny because i think you and i have

1:42:31actually argued about uh i don't like the way that lock screen notifications on the iPhone works in

1:42:35the first place um but in theory you should be able to long press on a notification and have it pop up

1:42:41like those extra options, you know, like the view,

1:42:45or if there's like an archive option for email or whatever.

1:42:49And apparently on the iPhone SE, you long press

1:42:53and you expect to have that little haptic tap back

1:42:55and then have a bunch of options appear, doesn't work.

1:42:58You need to slide it over and hit the view button

1:43:01to have those options pop up.

1:43:03And it is, it's not a thing I noticed

1:43:06and I feel bad about it, I'm sorry I didn't,

1:43:08But it's also like, that's not how I interact

1:43:12with iPhone notifications, I guess.

1:43:14And I was already sort of discombobulated by the fact

1:43:16that you have to touch the notification

1:43:19and then unlock it with the home button in the first place,

1:43:21which is something I hadn't done for several years.

1:43:24But yeah, I do not understand why,

1:43:28but according to Matthew Panzorino over at TechCrunch,

1:43:31it's not a bug.

1:43:32That like Apple designed it that way.

1:43:34They did not want that long press to open up the options.

1:43:39- And I guess the reason people feel aggrieved by it

1:43:43is that the iPhone 8 had 3D Touch,

1:43:47and 3D Touch is like the rare thing

1:43:51Apple has walked away from.

1:43:53Apple, you know, and you talk about the way

1:43:57that Samsung will maybe throw in the 108 megapixel camera

1:44:00before everything is worked out,

1:44:02and I don't think they're gonna walk away from that.

1:44:05I expect like the S21 or whatever the hell they call

1:44:09next year's phone might have the 108 megapixel sensor

1:44:13and not have the autofocus problems, right?

1:44:15But on the Android side of the fence,

1:44:19they might try things and then walk away from them.

1:44:21Like, ah, didn't work.

1:44:23Whereas Apple's not really a measure twice cut once.

1:44:27They're like a measure 10 times cut once company

1:44:29and 3D touch is something that they've just sort of

1:44:33walked away from because, I guess,

1:44:36because it requires like a layer under, you know,

1:44:40there's some kind of sandwich there,

1:44:41glass, OLED touch sensors, et cetera,

1:44:46and 3D touch is one of those layers of the sandwich,

1:44:49and they took it out, and what they now call haptic touch

1:44:54doesn't really require physical sensors in that sandwich.

1:44:59it's some kind of heuristic to determine,

1:45:02they've never explained how they're doing it,

1:45:06but it's something to do with your skin

1:45:09expanding on the screen and faking the sense of 3D.

1:45:13So the iPhone 8 had 3D touch,

1:45:16and therefore you were able to hard press on a notification,

1:45:20and the SE doesn't fake it with haptic touch

1:45:25the way the other iPhone 11 era phones do

1:45:29and people are aggrieved by it.

1:45:32And I get it, if you have that habit,

1:45:34I get it that man, you know,

1:45:37and you've been waiting all this time

1:45:38and now you've got your iPhone SE

1:45:39and now it feels like your notifications are busted.

1:45:42So I'm not making fun of anybody who's aggrieved by it.

1:45:46I would be too.

1:45:48I missed it as a reviewer because it's been so long

1:45:51since I used that style of iPhone on a daily basis

1:45:54that it didn't even register to me.

1:45:55I just thought that was normal.

1:45:58- If I had to guess, I would say that there's probably

1:46:01something very inelegant about the finger gymnastics

1:46:04of long pressing on the thing, oh wait, no,

1:46:07I haven't unlocked it yet, let me lightly touch

1:46:09on the home button to unlock, but not touch on it so hard

1:46:12that I actually get out of the lock screen,

1:46:14and then go back up to the thing, and then press the thing,

1:46:17and then have the options pop up.

1:46:18I think there's, like, the bouncing your thumb up and down

1:46:21until you get the thing you want was probably such a mess

1:46:24that they probably just turned it off, if I had to guess,

1:46:27but I don't actually know.

1:46:28- Yeah, and it's one of those things

1:46:30that I've sort of stopped thinking about,

1:46:32but there's like a difference in the defaults

1:46:35on whether they, like let's just say

1:46:37you send me a text message, and my phone is locked,

1:46:40and I look at it.

1:46:42On the ones with the home button,

1:46:45it'll show me, by default,

1:46:46with default Apple's factory settings,

1:46:49it'll show me the text of your message on my home screen,

1:46:52and I can turn that off if I want to for privacy reasons,

1:46:55but by default, it's there,

1:46:57whereas on the iPhone X Face ID class iPhones,

1:47:01that's off by default, and it just says,

1:47:04I think it says Dieter sent you a text message.

1:47:06I think it has your name,

1:47:07but it doesn't send you the text of the message.

1:47:10But because of Face ID, if you're looking at the phone,

1:47:14Face ID can, in most circumstances, identify you,

1:47:18and you don't realize that it's not showing it to you

1:47:21unless your face unlocks the phone.

1:47:23- Right, yep, and it just sort of magically opens up

1:47:25and then you're able to interact with it

1:47:27because it's unlocked.

1:47:27- Right, and so that, but it seems like the iPhone SE

1:47:31is sort of kind of caught in the middle

1:47:35where it no longer has 3D Touch hardware sensors,

1:47:39but it doesn't have face ID, so sorry.

1:47:43- And I've gotten in trouble for saying

1:47:45that Apple made the right move by getting rid of 3D Touch,

1:47:47that it really wasn't that valuable

1:47:49from people that deeply love 3D Touch,

1:47:52but I don't know, it didn't take off.

1:47:55They didn't have the interaction models

1:47:57for what it does really figured out.

1:48:00There's a couple of examples in the past,

1:48:02I don't know, decade, of Apple sort of claiming

1:48:06that they had invented a brand new hardware/software

1:48:08interaction model that was gonna be revolutionary

1:48:10and then it turned out to not be.

1:48:11And 3D Touch is sort of in that camp

1:48:13and then the Digital Crown is the other thing

1:48:15where it's like, yeah, you kinda promised

1:48:17a little bit too much there.

1:48:19And so it's a bummer that they've gotten rid of 3D touch.

1:48:21And it's a bummer that the haptic touch thing

1:48:23isn't working here.

1:48:24But I don't know, at a certain point,

1:48:28these things are so complex that, you know,

1:48:29even Apple can't magically think of every single use case.

1:48:32- I know that they've renamed the OS for the iPad to iPad OS

1:48:35but it is still iOS.

1:48:36And the fact that iPads, even if you get the iPad Pro,

1:48:39you never had 3D touch.

1:48:40And so there was always this mismatch

1:48:42where you can't 3D touch anything on the iPad

1:48:45and yet you could on certain high-end iPhones.

1:48:50And I always thought it was a mistake

1:48:51that they made 3D Touch on the iPhones

1:48:55do something entirely different than a long press.

1:48:58And so you would long press an icon

1:49:00if you wanted jiggle mode to rearrange it

1:49:02and 3D Touch it if you wanted shortcuts.

1:49:06And boy, was that easy to get wrong

1:49:10and seemed very hard to explain

1:49:12and really sort of seems un-Apple-like.

1:49:15like two very similar features designed by two teams

1:49:19that didn't know what the other was doing.

1:49:21- Yeah, that seems like a reasonable conjecture

1:49:26for what happened there.

1:49:27- And so, yeah, I'm okay with getting rid of it,

1:49:32but I feel like it was a lost opportunity

1:49:33where if they had done it right,

1:49:35it might've been awesome,

1:49:36but they never really did it right,

1:49:38so they might as well have gotten rid of it.

1:49:40- Yep.

1:49:41- All right, Dieter, thank you so much.

1:49:43I always enjoy-- - Yeah, thanks,

1:49:44this has been fun.

1:49:45talking to you. Everybody, of course, can read all of your fine work at The Verge and

1:49:50then on Twitter. I never remember anybody's Twitter handles. What's your Twitter handle?

1:49:54It's @baklon. B-A-C-K-L-O-N. B-A-C-K-L-O-N. You're @joy on Twitter as well. I'll see you

1:49:59there. I do my best. All right. Thanks.

1:50:02[BLANK_AUDIO]