0:00:00Federico
0:00:01John oh, I'm so excited to have you here. Oh
0:00:04I'm glad to be on the show. I have no idea what we're gonna talk about
0:00:08I'm just well I can tell you I did my research all the things you care about so we're gonna talk about the Mac Pro and
0:00:15Watches and American sports yeah
0:00:20I'm ready
0:00:25- Oh, did you see, I mean, just knock it out of the way easy.
0:00:29Did you see Marquez Brownlee's video?
0:00:34- Yes, I did.
0:00:36- He got the wheels for the Mac Pro.
0:00:39- No brakes on those wheels.
0:00:42- And they spin so freely,
0:00:45and the floor of whatever room he was in
0:00:47is obviously off by maybe a half of a degree.
0:00:51It's obviously not like a crooked floor.
0:00:53It's a very nice looking room.
0:00:55- And when he just lets go of the Mac Pro,
0:00:57it just starts rolling away.
0:01:00- You don't want a computer to run away from you.
0:01:03- Yeah, like a 30 to $40,000 computer.
0:01:06- Just going away.
0:01:08Well, yeah, I mean, I don't plan on buying a Mac Pro
0:01:14anytime soon, but if I were to buy a Mac Pro,
0:01:17I totally would get the wheels.
0:01:19- Oh, really?
0:01:20- Yeah, I mean, it just looks fun.
0:01:23See, how much are the wheels?
0:01:26They're like $100 each, right?
0:01:29- 400?
0:01:30- Yeah, they're $100 each.
0:01:32I love that they don't come with locks.
0:01:36- So I was thinking like, it's so strange.
0:01:41I mean, I guess maybe it's too soon,
0:01:43but maybe somebody like Belkin,
0:01:45you know, these like third-party manufacturers
0:01:47that have like a relationship with Apple,
0:01:49maybe they should make a version that has locks.
0:01:52I can't help but think that there will be,
0:01:54I mean, 'cause you know that there's,
0:01:57because the Pro Display XDR has,
0:02:01takes standard VESA mounting,
0:02:03there's already, it doesn't,
0:02:05nobody has to make it custom for it.
0:02:07There's already all sorts of standard arms
0:02:10and wall mounts you can get for it and stands.
0:02:13I can't help but feel that there's gonna be
0:02:16third-party options for the wheels and stuff like that.
0:02:20maybe the one cost a hundred dollar per wheel. Also, that'd be nice.
0:02:26I just remember I haven't seen the wheels since WWDC. You know, like, you got to the hands-on area,
0:02:38right? Well, you know, I actually, I never went. I was desperate for some coffee. And you know,
0:02:46like they serve the worst coffee.
0:02:48Like I was just looking for some espresso,
0:02:51but what's the name of the place that closed down?
0:02:54Like Social Policy in San Jose used to serve,
0:02:58well, some kind of espresso.
0:03:00And it was like the only place
0:03:04where I could get espresso in San Jose.
0:03:06Because San Jose, like the whole place is mysteriously
0:03:11devoid of any sort of normal coffee place.
0:03:15But social policy used to have Espresso,
0:03:17and it was like five bucks for an espresso,
0:03:19like totally insane.
0:03:21But it closed, and so last year after the keynote,
0:03:25I had this terrible headache.
0:03:27And so the PR tells me, like, hey, there's a hands-on area.
0:03:32You should go play around with the macro.
0:03:34And I was like, yeah, maybe I will go.
0:03:35I was just basically roaming around the convention area,
0:03:38just looking for an espresso, and I never went.
0:03:40And I kind of regret that.
0:03:43- It was across the street, which is unusual.
0:03:46- I know. (laughs)
0:03:47- Because A, the San Jose Convention Center is enormous,
0:03:52and you would think there would be plenty of space in there,
0:03:59but they did have a truly,
0:04:02I mean, I didn't really spend enough time in there,
0:04:07so I did go in, but I kinda missed out.
0:04:11But I can kinda see why they did it across the street,
0:04:14and it wasn't gonna be there all week,
0:04:17and it was definitely not intended for developer attendees.
0:04:22It was definitely set up as a press hands-on area
0:04:26that required an awful lot of Apple staffing.
0:04:29They had real pros from their real pro teams
0:04:36talking about the tools.
0:04:38It was not something that they intended to staff all week.
0:04:41So I can see why they didn't set it up
0:04:43in the convention area.
0:04:44But the fact that it was across the street,
0:04:46I can kinda see why you didn't make it.
0:04:48And it sounds so funny 'cause it's just quote unquote
0:04:51across the street.
0:04:53But that street is a real pain in the ass to cross too
0:04:56because there's like trains that run down the middle of it.
0:05:01- You can die if you cross the street.
0:05:04- It feels like there's hardly any cars,
0:05:06which is very unusual for America,
0:05:09but there's trains that come by frequently
0:05:12and don't stop and could easily kill you,
0:05:15and then the rest of the traffic
0:05:16are people on those rent-a-scooters.
0:05:18(laughing)
0:05:19Which are not dangerous at all.
0:05:22Well, not dangerous to you as a pedestrian.
0:05:25- Those scooters made their way to Europe
0:05:27and Italy specifically.
0:05:28Like just a few months ago, a bunch of cities here
0:05:31started passing regulations to allow the scooters,
0:05:33but I think we have more regulations
0:05:35that in the United States, like more speed control and stuff.
0:05:38So they may be less dangerous now, but I'm not sure.
0:05:43- Philadelphia-- - I will not try them again.
0:05:44- Where I live, Philadelphia, they are,
0:05:47because in America, so many things are
0:05:51left to not just states, but cities.
0:05:57Individual cities have different regulations,
0:05:59and the city of Philadelphia
0:06:01qualifies them as motor vehicles,
0:06:04and so you need license plates and driver's licenses.
0:06:09So we have none of them in Philadelphia.
0:06:12Although it was funny, these companies are so weird,
0:06:16like Lime, I think it was Lime,
0:06:18and somebody figured out, and my wife is the one
0:06:21who found it, but she was just on one of the local
0:06:23news sites, just a blog about Philadelphia stuff.
0:06:27And I don't know, like a year ago,
0:06:29it was like three Limes showed up in Philadelphia.
0:06:32It's like somebody just fired up the Lime app,
0:06:35and it was like, now there's three of them in Philadelphia.
0:06:37Just three, three scooters.
0:06:39(laughing)
0:06:40For a city of five million people.
0:06:43And it was like, is this real?
0:06:45And it was like, that's how, like sometimes,
0:06:47apparently that's how they like roll it out sometimes.
0:06:50It's like, you know, like,
0:06:51I guess it's supposed to create buzz, you know?
0:06:55(laughing)
0:06:55And then the city was like, these are illegal.
0:06:58And Lime was like, oh yeah, we didn't mean to do that.
0:07:00And then they took them away.
0:07:01And it was like, what do you mean you didn't mean to do it?
0:07:02You know what I mean?
0:07:03Like, what, like somebody drove their lime
0:07:06from some other city and dropped it off in Philadelphia?
0:07:11But anyway, anyway, I didn't really,
0:07:16I didn't spend anywhere near as much time
0:07:18in that hands-on area as I wished that I had.
0:07:21I had briefings and a couple other things,
0:07:22and the next thing you know, I went to go back
0:07:24and they're like, "Uh, it's closed, dude."
0:07:26And I was like, "Oh, crap."
0:07:28- Yeah, yeah.
0:07:29But did it have wheels?
0:07:30- Yes, they had the wheels there.
0:07:33And I was actually talking to Jaws there,
0:07:39and it was on Monday after the keynote.
0:07:42And Jaws was on my show later that week too.
0:07:47But I was just chatting with him briefly there,
0:07:49and I asked him if I could ride,
0:07:50if I could ride the Mac Pro like a little scooter.
0:07:55And he said no.
0:07:58But they did have the wheels and I got to play with them
0:08:00and I can vouch that at least at WWDC
0:08:04they were very nice wheels.
0:08:06So I'm not surprised at all.
0:08:08It's almost like the MKBHD problem
0:08:11where it just starts rolling if your desktop
0:08:13or floor is ever so slightly tilted.
0:08:16It's almost like you'd want them to be worse wheels,
0:08:18you know what I mean, so that there'd be
0:08:20a little bit of friction so that you kinda have to push it.
0:08:23- Yeah.
0:08:25I don't know, it just looks fun though.
0:08:26Like if I were to have a computer like that,
0:08:28I would like it to have wheels, just for the fun of it.
0:08:32- Yeah, until it starts rolling away.
0:08:36- Maybe just get a long extension cable
0:08:40and that's gonna be fine.
0:08:41- All right, while we're talking about WWDC,
0:08:44let me mention something.
0:08:45I'll bet this has come up in your circles as well,
0:08:49but with this coronavirus that is spreading around there
0:08:56And I know it's only late February right now,
0:08:59and WWDC almost certainly is scheduled for early June,
0:09:04which is where it's been every single year,
0:09:08except for one for like the last, I don't know, 15 years.
0:09:12And for like the last 10 years, it's always been,
0:09:1610, 11, 12 years, it's always been,
0:09:18I think 2006 was the weird year where it was in August.
0:09:20Is WWDC going to be canceled because of coronavirus?
0:09:26is the question on a lot of people's minds.
0:09:28And it seems ridiculous in February,
0:09:30but I actually think, like, watching the news,
0:09:34I think that it's gotta be,
0:09:35I put the odds at around 30 to 40% chance,
0:09:38yes, WWDC will be canceled.
0:09:40What do you have?
0:09:41- Yeah, Facebook just canceled
0:09:43their developer conference today.
0:09:45- Yep, and that's a May conference.
0:09:48- Yeah, yeah.
0:09:49And I just saw on the news,
0:09:52I mean, we're here in Italy,
0:09:54the virus spread like super quickly, like until last week.
0:09:59It's so weird because like until last Thursday,
0:10:04there were no confirmed cases.
0:10:05Basically, I'm from Friday up until today,
0:10:08like in so in six days,
0:10:11we went from two cases to I think it's 600.
0:10:16It's wild.
0:10:17And I just saw on the news yesterday
0:10:19that California started seeing the first confirmed cases
0:10:23of the virus.
0:10:24So it's starting to look likely.
0:10:27I also saw that a bunch of video game companies
0:10:30started pulling out from GDC,
0:10:32so the Game Developers Conference,
0:10:33which is in San Francisco, usually in March.
0:10:36And it seems very likely that the whole thing
0:10:40is gonna be canceled as well.
0:10:41I don't know, what do you think will happen
0:10:45if WWC gets canceled?
0:10:46- So if it gets canceled, I would,
0:10:51And let's assume that we're not looking
0:10:56at a true global pandemic, right?
0:11:01And I mean, I don't think we can take that
0:11:03off the table at this point.
0:11:04I think it's, you know, I think anybody
0:11:06who wants to be realistic about this
0:11:08can see that this is a very serious situation.
0:11:12It's already, you know, I mean, there's, you know,
0:11:15hundreds of people dead, thousands,
0:11:17tens of thousands sick around the world,
0:11:18especially in China, so I'm not making light
0:11:20of the situation right now today,
0:11:23but I think anybody being realistic has to look at this
0:11:25and say this might be one of these
0:11:27like once in a generation things that truly is a pandemic.
0:11:32And in that case, of course,
0:11:34everything's gonna get canceled, right?
0:11:35The whole world's gonna be affected.
0:11:38If it stays more like it is now, right,
0:11:40where it's still out there, it's still floating about,
0:11:45they're still spreading, they're still, you know,
0:11:47they're tracking, you know, as it moves around the world,
0:11:50and air travel is still a thing,
0:11:54it's not like airlines and airports are shut down,
0:11:56what I would guess Apple would do is hold a,
0:12:00well, I guess what they could do
0:12:04is they could either postpone until August
0:12:07or something like that, or kind of do it virtually.
0:12:12I mean, this is, and me chatting in a group Slack
0:12:17with a bunch of friends is just a spitball idea,
0:12:20but the idea would be maybe what they would do
0:12:22is hold a press event at the Steve Jobs Theater,
0:12:25just invite media.
0:12:27But again, is that, even just that,
0:12:29is inviting 300 media to a Steve Jobs Theater
0:12:33is even that problematic?
0:12:35I don't know.
0:12:36But this would be the idea.
0:12:38It would be, all right,
0:12:39what if they still hold a WWDC keynote?
0:12:43I don't know what they would call it
0:12:44'cause it's not really WWDC,
0:12:46but they would still hold the event
0:12:47to do all the stuff they want to announce, right?
0:12:49'cause Apple likes doing that, I think.
0:12:53I don't think that it's like Mac World Expo
0:12:57of years gone by where Apple eventually got to the point
0:13:01where they didn't like having this thing on the schedule
0:13:05in January and whether they're ready
0:13:07to announce anything or not, they have to do this keynote.
0:13:11And when they had the opportunity to beg out of it,
0:13:15they took it, which effectively canceled
0:13:18the whole conference because without that keynote,
0:13:21it just sort of took the air out of it.
0:13:23I don't think they feel that way about WWDC.
0:13:25I think they like WWDC.
0:13:27I think they like having developers there.
0:13:30I think they find it energizing.
0:13:32I really do.
0:13:34I know it's a lot of work for the engineers who do it,
0:13:38'cause the presentations are all done.
0:13:41It's not like there's some special team
0:13:43of WWDC presenters who create all these sessions.
0:13:48sessions, if there's a session on shortcuts,
0:13:52what's new in shortcuts, it's presented by somebody
0:13:56or people, multiple people, from the shortcuts team.
0:14:00It's the people who made it who are the most intimately
0:14:02familiar with it who do it.
0:14:04And those presentations aren't things they whip together
0:14:07at the last minute, right?
0:14:08I mean, I would guess they're starting to work on them now.
0:14:12So they could still do all of that work.
0:14:17And it's a lot of work, but I feel like Apple,
0:14:21it's worth it.
0:14:22Apple wants developers to use new stuff, right?
0:14:25And so without teaching and having these sessions
0:14:28where you can learn about the new stuff,
0:14:29how are you gonna do it, right?
0:14:30So I don't think they, it is a lot of work,
0:14:32but I don't think they resent it.
0:14:34I think that they enjoy it.
0:14:35I think they like the opportunity.
0:14:37But I guess what they could do if this virus makes them,
0:14:40or they feel like they should,
0:14:42even if they don't have to but feel like
0:14:44gets the safe thing to do is cancel the actual,
0:14:48let's get 5,000 people in San Jose together,
0:14:51is do it virtually.
0:14:52And that's how most people around the world
0:14:55actually experience WWDC anyway, right?
0:14:57'Cause there's, with the lottery and everything,
0:15:01there's 5,000 attendees or so,
0:15:04and obviously at this point,
0:15:06tens of thousands of developers around the world
0:15:09who consume the entirety of WWDC via streaming.
0:15:13So what if everybody did it via streaming
0:15:15and they just have the presentations,
0:15:17they still do all the work they would have done
0:15:19if it was going to go on,
0:15:21but the entire thing goes through the WWDC app
0:15:24in terms of your experience,
0:15:26and then the press event would just be
0:15:28for press only on Monday morning
0:15:29and they'd have it at the Steve Jobs Theater.
0:15:31That's my spitball idea.
0:15:33- They could do that.
0:15:34And I mean, they've also done,
0:15:37in the past, like when a new iPhone comes out,
0:15:38they have done new presentations
0:15:42for new technical features like new APIs
0:15:44about the new camera, for example.
0:15:46And they have just posted those on the developer website.
0:15:50So it's not totally new to talk about new APIs,
0:15:54and it's just available via streaming, right?
0:15:57I guess the main downside maybe is
0:15:59that you do lose, with the remote event,
0:16:02you lose obviously the personal contact.
0:16:04And for a lot of developers, there's
0:16:06a lot of value in being able to go to the labs
0:16:09and actually get your code in front of somebody
0:16:11works at Apple, I can give you pointers and suggestions,
0:16:14and you lose all of that with a remote event.
0:16:17And I highly doubt that Apple would do some sort of chat
0:16:21feature where a developer can-- I mean,
0:16:24I guess it could be even possible for a developer
0:16:26to talk to somebody directly during WWDC week.
0:16:30But I mean, going to the labs in person physically,
0:16:35go there, is a totally different experience.
0:16:37And you will lose all of that.
0:16:39But also, I think I agree with you, they should still do some kind of WWDC, even if it's just
0:16:49a streaming-only one, if only because it sets so much of the narrative for the year, at
0:16:55least in terms of software.
0:16:57As you said, it's a way for Apple to-- they like doing this, because it's also a way for
0:17:01them to share a story and a strategy for the next few months.
0:17:06- Yeah, and they really,
0:17:08they've always been a company of habits.
0:17:13And there's an annual calendar to Apple
0:17:18and following Apple.
0:17:20And I guess it's never set in stone
0:17:23and never assumed that anything is permanent.
0:17:26But I do feel though that internally
0:17:32they clearly feel it's a good idea
0:17:36And I think some of us on the outside
0:17:39talking about software quality,
0:17:40which we can get into as the podcast, as the show goes on,
0:17:44might disagree with this to some degree that it's good,
0:17:48but that the annual schedule they have the OSs on
0:17:52is clearly a deliberate strategy on their part.
0:17:55I mean, they almost come out and say it.
0:17:58They very seldom, at the executive level,
0:18:01like to explain their thinking,
0:18:04They're secretive about why they do what they do.
0:18:07They're just like, here's what we have,
0:18:09here's what we're going to do.
0:18:10Well, why, why do you tell us everything
0:18:13that's coming for the next year at WWDC?
0:18:15They don't wanna tell you, but they clearly,
0:18:17it's so many years in a row
0:18:19where they've been doing it this way.
0:18:22And iOS has always been on this annual schedule.
0:18:26Ever since the original iPhone came out,
0:18:28there have been major new integer .o releases of iOS,
0:18:33iOS, even before iOS had a name,
0:18:36and now that iOS and iPadOS are two different names,
0:18:41they're still on the same schedule,
0:18:42and TVOS, which is built on iOS,
0:18:47has the same fundamental version number.
0:18:49It's TVOS 13.0.
0:18:51WatchOS has been on the same annual schedule.
0:18:55macOS, which in the early years of iOS
0:18:58was not on an annual schedule anymore,
0:19:00and is now, and I feel like it's all very strategic.
0:19:05I think Apple thinks it keeps them honest.
0:19:08I feel like they feel like this is a way that they can,
0:19:11and at some level, it's undeniable.
0:19:15We can quibble about whether they push too fast
0:19:19and do new features faster than they fix bugs, et cetera,
0:19:23but at some level, it obviously keeps them
0:19:26from falling into the trap
0:19:29that I think Microsoft fell into over a decade ago
0:19:33with Windows 7, right?
0:19:36I mean, that's the thing that I think they want to avoid,
0:19:39where post, what was it, Windows NT,
0:19:44what was the, Windows 2000, right?
0:19:47Windows 2000 came out and was a huge hit.
0:19:50It was probably peak Windows in terms of popularity
0:19:54and industry dominance.
0:19:57and they came up with the what's next after Windows 2000,
0:20:00and they had sort of a boil the ocean plan
0:20:04with all these, you know, they wanted to do so much
0:20:07in the next version, and all of a sudden,
0:20:09you know, five, six years go by, you know,
0:20:12and they hadn't come out with the successor, right?
0:20:15That's what you wanna avoid.
0:20:16You don't want to try to bite too much off,
0:20:18and this annual schedule kind of keeps everything down
0:20:23to we're gonna keep making incremental progress every year,
0:20:27and I think they like it, and I think announcing it at WWDC is very strategic.
0:20:32Yeah, and also, unlike other companies like all these Android manufacturers, Apple controls
0:20:40both the software and the hardware, and because of that, they can tie the new version of iOS
0:20:46to a new iPhone.
0:20:48Right.
0:20:49And only, you know, Apple is one of the very few companies that can do this, and the reason
0:20:53why there's an annual version of iOS,
0:20:55it's because usually the new iPhone also
0:20:57has some hardware feature that is enabled via software.
0:21:01And so what this virus does though,
0:21:03it's such a new situation because supply chains
0:21:08are going to be constrained.
0:21:09And we're starting to hear all these rumors
0:21:12about all kinds of devices being delayed
0:21:14from smaller companies like, you know,
0:21:17Bridge, they make the Bridge keyboard.
0:21:19They're having issues with their,
0:21:23They did a trackpad-enabled keyboard, which is kind of funny because we're going to talk about that in a few.
0:21:30But that's been delayed and we're hearing that like Sony and Microsoft, they are preparing the PlayStation 5 and the new Xbox.
0:21:39And now they're also facing issues with the coronavirus.
0:21:42So what's going to happen to the iPhone?
0:21:45It's something that in my lifetime,
0:21:49I've never seen anything like this
0:21:53in terms of a stop to the global economy.
0:21:56And what does it mean in the world of Apple
0:22:00in terms of will there be a new iPhone in September?
0:22:03And if so, there must be a new version of iOS.
0:22:06- Obviously, it's one of those things where maybe,
0:22:11here's a situation where having Tim Cook
0:22:13as the CEO of the company is ideal, right?
0:22:18Like who better, 'cause ultimately
0:22:20it's an operations problem, right?
0:22:22This is literally operations 101
0:22:26to have a supply chain disruption this significant.
0:22:31And so it's not like somebody has to come in
0:22:34and explain how the supply chain works to Tim Cook, right?
0:22:38Like, you know,
0:22:42You literally could not ask for a better CEO
0:22:46for a crisis like this, if it is indeed a crisis.
0:22:50And I am not an expert on the supply chain,
0:22:52and the details of the supply chain are,
0:22:56like much at Apple, it's like the recipe to Coca-Cola.
0:23:00It is a very tightly held secret.
0:23:02They don't talk about how their,
0:23:04they don't talk about how the supply chain works in detail.
0:23:11It's effectively a black box in a lot of ways.
0:23:15But one thing, reading up on this in,
0:23:19hey, how big a deal is this coronavirus
0:23:21in terms of the supply chain,
0:23:23and is it the sort of thing that could
0:23:24disrupt Apple's obvious plans
0:23:28to have brand new iPhones in September?
0:23:30And this makes, I think this makes common sense,
0:23:34is that let's say it's a two or three week shutdown,
0:23:38and they shut down certain factories and suppliers
0:23:40for two to three weeks, tell everybody to stay home,
0:23:43don't leave your house, and then two or three weeks go by
0:23:45and they open back up in China and they're there.
0:23:48That doesn't mean that everything that would have happened
0:23:52is just pushed back two or three weeks, right?
0:23:55It's like a ripple effect, right?
0:23:57Like a two or three week disruption could have
0:24:00a months long disruption in supply
0:24:04because it's just that complicated
0:24:09and there's so many cogs that having one or two cogs
0:24:13stop for a bit shuts the whole machine down for a while
0:24:18and then has to start back up.
0:24:20And the other thing too you have to keep in mind
0:24:24is like oh well 95% of suppliers are back up
0:24:28and running at full steam,
0:24:30but what about the 5% that aren't?
0:24:33What if they're not, what if the components
0:24:35that those suppliers provide aren't obtainable
0:24:40from alternative suppliers or aren't obtainable
0:24:43in sufficient quantity from other suppliers, right?
0:24:47Like it could be one tiny little screw,
0:24:49but if it only comes from one factory,
0:24:51you cannot make the iPhone
0:24:53or you have to redesign around it, right?
0:24:55I mean, a screw is probably a bad example,
0:24:57but who knows how many components from the iPhone
0:25:03have sufficient alternatives to defend against this.
0:25:07- Yeah, yeah.
0:25:09And in the short term, not to mention,
0:25:11there's rumors of a spring event,
0:25:13and now that's an even more problematic one
0:25:16because all these issues are happening now,
0:25:21like countries that are saying,
0:25:23like Italy and France, for example,
0:25:25are saying it's probably best if you don't travel right now.
0:25:28So what does that mean for any kind of European media
0:25:32that may be invited to an Apple event.
0:25:34So I don't know.
0:25:36- Do you have any idea before we leave the subject?
0:25:39But I mean, I think it's just a fluke,
0:25:43but I mean, Italy certainly has
0:25:45a world-class healthcare system,
0:25:47and it just seems so anomalous that Italy,
0:25:52of all countries, has this 600-person outbreak.
0:25:56My guess is it's just a fluke,
0:26:00and that's just the way things like this go, right?
0:26:02Like somebody shows up with it and it starts to spread
0:26:05and boom, 600 people have it.
0:26:09- Yeah, so what they're saying is that
0:26:11it went unnoticed for 10 days.
0:26:16- Right.
0:26:17- And in those 10 days, it spread to a lot of people.
0:26:22Now, I actually think that the government
0:26:24actually did a very good job in terms of,
0:26:26okay, now we need to shut down at least two major areas
0:26:30in northern Italy.
0:26:32And they did that, and they closed offices and schools
0:26:34and public transportation.
0:26:36Right now we're asking those people who live near Milan
0:26:41and near Venice, for example, we're asking them a lot.
0:26:45Stay inside and don't leave the house for two weeks.
0:26:49But I also think that it's a
0:26:56mindset problem in the sense that we Italians, we tend to take these kinds of
0:27:02things way too lightly. And like right now there's a whole debate going
0:27:08on whether the government is actually doing too much because it's just the flu.
0:27:13Like a lot of people are saying that, "Oh, it's just the flu, whatever." And I think
0:27:18that's something that we Italians do all the time. Like we don't necessarily
0:27:22give as much importance to things that the government says,
0:27:26"Actually, look, this is important.
0:27:27"You should care about it."
0:27:28And so I'm seeing a lot of people simply say,
0:27:31"Well, whatever, it's just a cold, it's just a flu.
0:27:34"I don't care, it's not a problem."
0:27:36And so I think a lot of people do not go get tested
0:27:40because of that.
0:27:41And for that reason, it's spreading even more quickly.
0:27:44So the healthcare system here is actually very good.
0:27:49- Yeah.
0:27:51- One of the things I read was that you have to understand
0:27:54that one of the things we might see
0:27:57is we might see higher rates of infection reported
0:28:02in countries with better healthcare systems
0:28:04because they have the better healthcare system
0:28:06and people will go to the doctor and get identified
0:28:09and that the danger is that in the countries
0:28:12where the healthcare system isn't as good
0:28:15and people don't have access to quality health insurance,
0:28:19it might be spreading faster than the numbers
0:28:22that are reported because the people who have it
0:28:24aren't going to the doctor where it can be reported.
0:28:26- Yeah, because here it's totally free.
0:28:28I believe it's like one euro
0:28:30if you wanna get the coronavirus test.
0:28:34And in general, being treated here is entirely for free
0:28:38for any kind of problem that you may have.
0:28:40And I cannot possibly imagine
0:28:42what that's like in the United States.
0:28:44I mean, every time I travel for WWDC,
0:28:47I have to get special insurance to travel to America.
0:28:51Because if something happens to me,
0:28:53I need to pay for travel insurance
0:28:55that ensures that I will be covered if anything happens.
0:29:00And that's such a foreign concept to me
0:29:02because here, more or less, they won't,
0:29:06they will not let you die and they will not ask you for money
0:29:09at the hospital. - Right, no.
0:29:10And I know that it's true even for people
0:29:12who are vacationing there and something.
0:29:15I have friends from America and they're blown away.
0:29:18They took a fall and sprained their ankle
0:29:20and went to the hospital in London
0:29:23or probably Rome and it's like, oh, they go
0:29:26and then they take a couple of bucks
0:29:28and they pat you up and you're like,
0:29:33where are you gonna send the bill?
0:29:34And they're like, there is no bill.
0:29:35And you're like, what?
0:29:36No, it is, no, I do worry though.
0:29:38And all the politics of US healthcare aside,
0:29:41which we certainly can't get into,
0:29:44This sort of epidemic type thing really puts a bullseye
0:29:49on what's wrong with a system that allows
0:29:53literally millions of people to not have insurance at all
0:29:56and therefore to weigh every single calculation
0:29:59of whether they should go to the doctor or not
0:30:02with hmm, what's it gonna cost me?
0:30:04This is the sort of thing where anybody who suspects
0:30:08that they have it really ought to go to the doctor,
0:30:11not just for their own benefit,
0:30:12for the benefit of everybody, right?
0:30:15So anyway, I don't know.
0:30:17Like I said, I would put the odds at around 30 or 40%
0:30:23at this point that WWDC is not gonna happen.
0:30:26Because I think, and the Facebook news coming out today
0:30:31for a May developer conference shows how far in advance
0:30:35a company wants to make a decision like that.
0:30:38In some ways, you know what I mean?
0:30:39And it's like, what if Facebook canceled this thing
0:30:42and May comes around and the whole thing is blown over,
0:30:45it's gone, it's, you know.
0:30:47I don't think that means that anybody should be upset.
0:30:51I think it calls for caution.
0:30:53So let's say two or three weeks from now,
0:30:56or sometime by the end of March, Apple says,
0:30:59you know what, because of this,
0:31:01we're not gonna have WWDC this year,
0:31:03and then June 8th rolls around and there's nothing.
0:31:07I'm sure some people are gonna complain,
0:31:09but you can't expect somebody in March
0:31:14to have 100% certainty as to where it's gonna be in June.
0:31:17You have to do what seems responsible,
0:31:22which doesn't mean somehow magically foreseeing the future.
0:31:27And in a shorter term, I mean, months in advance
0:31:33is very hard to anticipate,
0:31:37But like, here in the US, it's always the case,
0:31:41like we, on the east coast of the US,
0:31:43especially in the south, like where I live,
0:31:45it's seldom an issue.
0:31:47But there was one a couple years ago,
0:31:48but we have hurricanes, and then these hurricanes come,
0:31:51and days in advance, they make a determination
0:31:54as to whether people on the coast should evacuate or not.
0:31:58And then at some point, they often make it
0:32:00a mandatory evacuation, where, I mean,
0:32:03they don't arrest you if you don't leave,
0:32:04but you know, it's, they're officially saying
0:32:07everybody must leave and if the police see you
0:32:10that you're not leaving, they try to encourage you
0:32:14to get the hell out.
0:32:15But then every once in a while, the storm comes in,
0:32:17it's not so bad, and then people are like,
0:32:19"Well, why the hell did you have us evacuate?"
0:32:21And it's like, you can't only tell people to evacuate
0:32:25when you're 100% certain they need to evacuate
0:32:28because you're only 100% certain when the 120 mile hour winds
0:32:32are blowing the roof off your house.
0:32:34- Yeah, yeah.
0:32:36And like these events, they are planned several months
0:32:40in advance.
0:32:41It's not like you can say, oh, let's wait until
0:32:44the middle of May, and then we can announce the WBC.
0:32:48It doesn't work like that, and I think a lot of people
0:32:51actually think that it does, but it's not like that.
0:32:53You need several months of planning for, you know,
0:32:57I mean, we mentioned engineers preparing their sessions.
0:33:01That's one example.
0:33:02It takes months of work.
0:33:03- Well, like I said, I think either way,
0:33:06that will still happen on the same schedule,
0:33:09and I think that whether they have full WWDC,
0:33:13whether they cancel it and do it online only
0:33:16and hold a press event,
0:33:17or whether even a press event isn't deemed safe,
0:33:21and maybe they would do a keynote that's online.
0:33:24I don't know.
0:33:25I mean, that would be weird
0:33:25to not have anybody in the audience,
0:33:27but although I guess they'd still have
0:33:29their own Apple employees,
0:33:31and so you'd still hear all the applause.
0:33:33- So maybe-- - And then the retail employees.
0:33:35- Right, they could fill it up with some people.
0:33:37But I still feel like they will do the annual,
0:33:43this is the state of our OSs and our roadmap for 2021,
0:33:48fall of 2020 into 2021, here you go.
0:33:55I feel like that'll happen either way.
0:33:57It's just a question of whether you wanna have
0:33:59invite 5,000 developers from around the world
0:34:01into beautiful, hospitable San Jose.
0:34:05(laughs)
0:34:07- Beautiful, especially beautiful San Jose.
0:34:10- I don't even remember.
0:34:11I drink coffee every day, and now I'm trying to remember
0:34:15where the hell do I get it.
0:34:17I don't even remember.
0:34:19Honest to God, I can't even,
0:34:20I was there for four days last week,
0:34:22and I don't remember where I got coffee.
0:34:24I think it's like my mind was so scarred by the experience,
0:34:27It was like traumatic and I've forgotten the memory.
0:34:31- Yeah, I'm pretty sure that one time last year,
0:34:35Mark Hormant walked us to some kind of breakfast place
0:34:40that took like 20 minutes to get to
0:34:43and they didn't have coffee.
0:34:45So that sounds like it for you.
0:34:48- Social policy, which I do miss,
0:34:50but social policy didn't take 20 minutes to get to,
0:34:53but it did take 20 or 30 minutes to get like a sandwich.
0:34:57(laughing)
0:34:58My wife goes and, you know, my wife got a hamburger
0:35:01and it took 45 minutes to get a hamburger.
0:35:06That place, I mean, it's like shocker
0:35:09that that place closed.
0:35:10- But it's too bad because they actually had
0:35:14decent espresso and croissants sometimes.
0:35:17- Yeah, it was good food.
0:35:19It just clearly wasn't meant for--
0:35:22- They were so unprepared for more--
0:35:27than usual.
0:35:28Right, but I don't even know if it is more people than usual.
0:35:31I think the San Jose Convention Center often holds conventions that are far larger than
0:35:36WWDC.
0:35:37That's the thing about San Jose that just boggles the mind is that it feels, in terms
0:35:45of the restaurant hours, the coffee shop service, the early closing of the bars, everything
0:35:53makes it feel as though it is this sleepy little town where nothing big ever happens,
0:35:58and Apple just picked it and puts up a 5,000-person tent like the circus once a year, and it comes
0:36:06out of nowhere, and nobody in town was aware of it.
0:36:10And even though now they've had it there, what, three years?
0:36:13It's like nobody remembers that in June, you know, there's a busy week.
0:36:17But it's worse than that because they have conventions throughout the year.
0:36:20It is a very large convention center.
0:36:23I suppose when you add up all of Moscone,
0:36:28north, south, and west,
0:36:32or whatever the hell the three parts of it are,
0:36:36I guess Moscone is bigger overall.
0:36:38I mean, you can't eyeball it
0:36:40'cause so much of Moscone is underground.
0:36:43But Apple never, for WWDC,
0:36:45never took the two main buildings.
0:36:48they only use the one that actually is glass and upstairs.
0:36:53I think it's bigger than the old,
0:36:54where Apple used to hold WWDC.
0:36:57And so there's gotta be big conventions throughout the year.
0:37:00It's like, it's a convention area,
0:37:03it's a convention area of town
0:37:04that is not ready for any conventions
0:37:06of any sort whatsoever.
0:37:08It boggles the mind.
0:37:10- Maybe they just don't like other people coming in.
0:37:13It's just, I don't know.
0:37:14(laughing)
0:37:15- Everybody, it feels like it's everybody's
0:37:18first day on the job.
0:37:19- And to be fair, it saddens me
0:37:23because every San Jose local that I've met,
0:37:25they're like super lovely and kind people.
0:37:28It's just the store owners that don't know
0:37:32how to deal with that, so I don't know.
0:37:34- I was there with somebody once
0:37:38and they were trying to close a bar
0:37:39and my friend, Luke, asked the manager,
0:37:42"Do you like to make money?"
0:37:44And the guy-- (laughs)
0:37:46- Yes, exactly, that's the problem.
0:37:48- Oh my God, anyway.
0:37:50All right, let me take a break here
0:37:51and thank our first sponsor.
0:37:52It is two-time sponsor.
0:37:54They just sponsored, I think, two episodes ago.
0:37:56Feals, F-E-A-L-S.
0:37:59Do you experience stress?
0:38:01Do you have anxiety, maybe chronic pain?
0:38:03Trouble sleeping, even just once a week?
0:38:05You're not alone, many people do.
0:38:07Feals is premium CBD delivered directly to your doorstep.
0:38:14Feels naturally helps reduce stress, anxiety, pain,
0:38:18and sleeplessness.
0:38:20Here's how you do it.
0:38:21You just take a few drops of Feels,
0:38:23put it under your tongue,
0:38:24and you can feel the difference within minutes.
0:38:27Are you new to CBD?
0:38:29Feels offers a free CBD hotline and text message support.
0:38:34If, like me, you hate talking to people on the phone,
0:38:36use that and help guide your personal experience.
0:38:40Know what to get, know what to expect.
0:38:42And it works naturally to help you feel better.
0:38:44There is no high for sure.
0:38:46There's no hangover, no addiction, nothing like that.
0:38:51And it's a membership thing.
0:38:52You join the Feals community and you get Feals delivered
0:38:55to your door every month and you save money on every order
0:38:59with a subscription with this membership system.
0:39:01And you can pause if you're going away or cancel
0:39:06if you're done with it at any time, no questions asked.
0:39:10So remember, F-E-A-L-S, that's the brand name, Feals, and you can become a member today by
0:39:17going to Feals.com/talkshow.
0:39:21And if you use that URL, Feals.com/talkshow, you will get 50% off your first order with
0:39:29free shipping.
0:39:31That's F-E-A-L-S.com/talkshow to become a member and you'll get 50% automatically taken
0:39:38off your first order with free shipping. My thanks to them.
0:39:42All right, so while we're talking about Apple
0:39:46events, there are rumors of a spring event
0:39:50which I would guess would take place
0:39:54at the end of March, and the reason that I guess that
0:39:58and I keep track of this, let me open up my note here,
0:40:02is, like I said, Apple is a company of habits and
0:40:06patterns and they might decide to stop following something but that would be
0:40:11like a major decision and they do not hold a March event every year but they
0:40:19did hold a March event in 2016 that was a town hall in Cupertino they did a new
0:40:30iPad and a smaller iPhone that was the the iPhone SE's debut and the 9.7 inch
0:40:38iPad Pro which I think was the first small iPad Pro they did not have one in
0:40:432017 in March but then in 2018 they had a special event March 27th at Lane Tech
0:40:53High School in Chicago were you there for that one we would do you go to
0:40:56- I was not, I was not.
0:40:58- Well, that was another,
0:40:59that was a new 9.7 inch iPad Pro,
0:41:02or no, just an iPad, that's right.
0:41:04It was the first iPad with pencil support.
0:41:06Right, and they introduced the Logitech Crayon,
0:41:09and of course the reason it was a regular iPad,
0:41:11not iPad Pro, and it was held at a school,
0:41:13was that their pitch was that this is
0:41:15for the education market,
0:41:16where the price of the device is very sensitive.
0:41:18Anyway, 2017, no March event.
0:41:222018 they had an event
0:41:25Or I did 2018 so 16 18 now we're in 2020 it's an even year
0:41:33So if the pattern holds and even numbered years they hold March events that are often feature new iPad hardware
0:41:42Will they do it again? I don't know but there's been random. I'll give you I'll give you another timeline John
0:41:50I have a list. I remember I had this list somewhere
0:41:53WWDC announcement dates
0:41:56We forget for context because we were talking about this last year March 14
0:42:042018 March 13
0:42:072017 February 16 and I believe this was early because of the San Jose switch
0:42:13so if they do announce
0:42:16WWDC must be
0:42:18within the next couple of weeks at this point.
0:42:21- I think they've had some that went
0:42:22as long as April though, I'm pretty sure.
0:42:25- They used to be up until 2016, April 18, 2015, April 14.
0:42:30- Yeah, so maybe if, I wouldn't be surprised,
0:42:34if we get into April and they haven't said anything,
0:42:37I would interpret that as meaning they're still
0:42:41like holding their breath on this coronavirus thing
0:42:44and waiting until the last minute to make a decision.
0:42:47But anyway, the March event, what I do know is that it tends to be, at least the past couple of years, in the spring break week.
0:42:58Is it called spring break? I think it's called spring break.
0:43:02Yeah, but we are at the spring break, schools have spring break in widely varying weeks of the year.
0:43:09Some schools try to time it with Easter, other schools have it the same, like the last week of March every year or something like that.
0:43:16It's not there's no one universal spring break week. It's spread out in late March through April
0:43:23But will they do an event now
0:43:27I really don't I really don't know and you know, one of the changes they've made in recent years is
0:43:35that
0:43:37For many years they would hold
0:43:40satellite events in
0:43:44somewhere in Europe and somewhere in Asia and
0:43:47This dates back to even before they had
0:43:52Reliable consistent live streams for everybody to watch right? I mean, it's it's easy to forget because nowadays
0:43:59They're there. They're they seem rock-solid every single event
0:44:03But for years they would you know you
0:44:07We we if you weren't attending the event, you know, I'm sure you remember this
0:44:13well, it would be like, is there gonna be a live stream?
0:44:15I don't know, and Apple wouldn't say,
0:44:17and then sometimes like an hour before the event,
0:44:19they would be like, here's a URL for the live stream.
0:44:22Is it going to stay up?
0:44:23Hold your breath.
0:44:26And it was weird, 'cause sometimes it would,
0:44:27sometimes it wouldn't, it was, you know,
0:44:30it wasn't something you would wanna bet on.
0:44:32Whether they were even gonna try, and if they did try,
0:44:35whether it was gonna stay up was a crapshoot.
0:44:38Nowadays, that's not an issue.
0:44:42But back in that era, they would hold satellite events
0:44:45for the media in Asia and Europe
0:44:47so that European journalists could just go to London
0:44:52and there would be like,
0:44:54wasn't something that maybe was public,
0:44:56but it was some kind of technology
0:44:57where they could stream it just to one facility in London
0:45:02and people wouldn't have to travel the extra
0:45:05eight time zones to get all the way to California
0:45:08or something like that.
0:45:10But at some point a handful of years ago, they stopped that.
0:45:14And if you're going to be press credentialed for an event,
0:45:18you need to be at the event.
0:45:21And otherwise you're just watching, which isn't bad.
0:45:24I mean, I missed an event.
0:45:25I missed the iPhone event this year
0:45:31because I couldn't fly because of eye surgery
0:45:33that I had in the end of August.
0:45:35So I didn't go to the iPhone event in September
0:45:37and just watched it live on my Apple TV.
0:45:40But there's no more satellite events like that.
0:45:44So Asian media all fly to California.
0:45:48I mean, I guess they could not, I don't know,
0:45:51I just can't imagine that they wouldn't not invite them
0:45:53just because they're from Asia or something.
0:45:55And it's not really, that's obviously ground zero for this,
0:45:58but as we just talked about 15 minutes ago,
0:46:01it's in Italy, it's in California,
0:46:04it's all around the world.
0:46:07- But maybe there doesn't have to be an event, right?
0:46:10Because if you look at last year,
0:46:12it was a similar situation,
0:46:13like a bunch of different products.
0:46:15We had the new AirPods and we had,
0:46:18was there a new iPad last year?
0:46:20Maybe it was the iPad Air 2, I believe.
0:46:22So a bunch of different products,
0:46:24and instead of doing an event
0:46:25and throwing a few different products together,
0:46:28they just did the week of press releases, right?
0:46:31With the Tim Cook tweets, the Tim Cook photo.
0:46:36And I think maybe there's an opportunity to do a repeat of that, because if you look at the products that we're talking about now,
0:46:42we're looking at an iPad Pro that, if you were to follow the rumors, has a new camera system,
0:46:47but the new design, basically the same design of the existing iPad Pro, and maybe a new smart keyboard.
0:46:53And then we're looking at the iPhone 9 or SE2, and potentially the new MacBook Pros with the new keyboards.
0:47:02So, and maybe the new over-ear headphones
0:47:07that were rumored a while back.
0:47:10So not necessarily products that tell a cohesive story.
0:47:15Like yes, they are updates.
0:47:18New products even, if you look at the over-ear headphones,
0:47:22for example, and the iPhone 9,
0:47:23but maybe it's not necessary to throw an event
0:47:27just to group those products together.
0:47:29- Right, they don't, you know,
0:47:32I've had this discussion, I think it was with regard
0:47:36to the fact that last year, or the end of 2019,
0:47:41just four or five months ago,
0:47:43they didn't hold the second event.
0:47:45The only event they really held
0:47:46was the September iPhone event,
0:47:48and then in October they had
0:47:50small press briefings for other stuff,
0:47:57like seeing the Mac Pro again before it came out,
0:48:01and getting hands-on time with the new 16-inch MacBook Pro,
0:48:06with the miraculous new keyboard
0:48:11that actually works and clicks.
0:48:12You know, they had, you know, I went to New York for that.
0:48:16I think New York was actually the main,
0:48:19for whatever reason, was more media than California.
0:48:24But, you know, I could see them doing something like that,
0:48:28where they still want to, for invited media
0:48:30and people who are going to review the hardware,
0:48:32they still want to meet them and brief them
0:48:35and give them their take on it,
0:48:36but it doesn't have to be a 500 person event in a theater.
0:48:39And the thing that I don't think a lot of people get,
0:48:45I think people who don't pay close attention
0:48:47are under the assumption that Apple holds these events
0:48:51willy-nilly, you know, and every time they do,
0:48:53because why wouldn't you?
0:48:54If you can get all this attention
0:48:56every time you hold a big media event,
0:48:58why wouldn't you do it all the time?
0:49:00But I think it's the opposite.
0:49:01I think Apple realizes to the very highest levels
0:49:05what a tremendous privilege and marketing hammer it is
0:49:10that when they do hold an event,
0:49:16it garners so much attention and gets so much news
0:49:21and is literally on the front page of newspapers.
0:49:24And I know newspapers, printed newspapers
0:49:27aren't the big deal they used to be,
0:49:29but it's still a good rule of,
0:49:31just a good gauge of how big of news something is.
0:49:35It's a pretty big deal in the grand scheme of things
0:49:39that when this company announces a new cell phone,
0:49:42it's front page news around the world.
0:49:45I think they realize that part,
0:49:48there's the little boy who cried wolf problem, right?
0:49:52I mean, you know that fairy tale, right?
0:49:55It's like, if you hold events
0:49:57that aren't worth people's attention eventually,
0:50:00even when you have an event that is worth their attention,
0:50:03people aren't gonna pay attention to it,
0:50:05or they're not gonna pay as much as they did.
0:50:07And I think Apple, at the very highest levels,
0:50:09is very cognizant of not doing that.
0:50:12And the 16-inch MacBook Pro is a perfect example of that.
0:50:16It is a tremendous product.
0:50:18I mean, I'm still using one right now, and I love it,
0:50:23and I really do think it is truly a return.
0:50:26As much as it looks like, and I'm not gonna go off
0:50:29on a whole MacBook Pro tangent here, we gotta talk iPad,
0:50:32but as much as it looks side by side
0:50:34like the 15-inch MacBook Pro replaced in so many ways,
0:50:38it really does fix so many of the things
0:50:41that we all complained about with the 15-inch MacBook Pros
0:50:44for the last two or three years,
0:50:46but was it worth an event?
0:50:48And like you said, is there a story to tell?
0:50:51Well, if the story is we fixed this, that,
0:50:54and the other problems, they don't really wanna
0:50:56get up on stage and say that.
0:50:58They'd rather say that privately in a small room
0:51:02and just say, yeah, we have a new keyboard design.
0:51:06- Yeah, and if you look at the previous events,
0:51:09there always tends to be a narrative around them.
0:51:11Like last year, it was the services event,
0:51:14like the strange one with a bunch of services together,
0:51:17but it told a story.
0:51:18And the year before that, it was the education event.
0:51:21And in October 2018, it was the pro event.
0:51:24So in Brooklyn, we got the iPad Pro and the Mac Mini,
0:51:28I believe.
0:51:28So there tends to be an overarching narrative to an event.
0:51:33And we've seen how when they have a bunch
0:51:39of different products to release and to announce,
0:51:42maybe the best strategy is not to throw an event,
0:51:44but to try different ways,
0:51:46whether it's like private press briefings or YouTubers
0:51:50or doing just the Tim Cook tweet
0:51:54and the announcement on the website,
0:51:56people last year were sure,
0:51:58"Oh, the AirPods Pro are gonna have an event for sure,"
0:52:02or, "The 16-inch MicroPro will have an event for sure,"
0:52:05but no, the AirPods Pro actually
0:52:07only had a press release, I believe.
0:52:09Not even press reviews, embargoed reviews.
0:52:14- Let me think about that.
0:52:16I got to try them.
0:52:17I did get to try them at the hands-on thing in New York.
0:52:20That was the same thing.
0:52:21- Oh, maybe there were then.
0:52:23- Yeah, I think I did get a review unit then.
0:52:25I forget, I don't think they were embargoed though.
0:52:28I think it was like you could just take them and you start.
0:52:31Yeah, they definitely did that.
0:52:32And they definitely had a little,
0:52:36like it was like a dozen of us at a time
0:52:42got to go up to these tables
0:52:44and they were factory sealed.
0:52:48They were like little spots and you'd go up
0:52:51and there was a shrink wrap box of AirPods Pro
0:52:54that you could open up and just pair to your phone.
0:52:59And it was kind of an interesting demo
0:53:01because unlike most Apple demos
0:53:03where the whole thing is scripted,
0:53:05they have this device that's already got everything
0:53:08they wanna show you, including the game that shows off metal
0:53:11and this and that, they just were like,
0:53:14here's a brand new AirPods Pro, open them up,
0:53:17pair them with your iPhone to see how easy it is
0:53:20just to get off the ground,
0:53:21and then listen to something on your phone.
0:53:23And it was funny, they did this thing, it was in New York,
0:53:27and it wasn't a soundproof room,
0:53:33but they don't like people talking about it,
0:53:36but it was quiet enough,
0:53:37but they wanted to show off the noise canceling,
0:53:40and so they said, so this is ridiculous,
0:53:42but we got here and realized there really isn't
0:53:44any street noise here, so they used a HomePod
0:53:49to play street traffic noise.
0:53:52- Oh wow, I swear to God.
0:53:54- So they were like, this seems silly,
0:53:55but it should sound, we wanna make it sound
0:53:58more like you're outside on the sidewalks,
0:54:00and they just pumped--
0:54:01- Best street traffic noise you've ever heard.
0:54:03- Yeah, they just played street,
0:54:05the best street traffic noise you've ever heard
0:54:07in an AirPod, and then they were like,
0:54:09now just squeeze the stem to turn off noise,
0:54:12turn noise canceling on, et cetera.
0:54:14Yeah, I could see them doing that.
0:54:18I think the wild card in the rumored events for this,
0:54:22if there's a March or early April event,
0:54:24the wild card is iPad.
0:54:26Like the iPhone 9 or whatever they're going to call it,
0:54:30but I kinda like the name iPhone 9.
0:54:32And I know people are like,
0:54:34"Well, why would you wanna make it seem old?"
0:54:35And it's like, dude, you have no idea
0:54:37how many millions, tens of millions of people out there
0:54:40who already have an iPhone 6,
0:54:43and they just want something exactly like it,
0:54:45but brand new, you just cannot underestimate that.
0:54:49My mom is waiting for one.
0:54:51My mom has a years-old iPhone.
0:54:53The battery, it's like 82%,
0:54:56so it's still above that 80% threshold,
0:54:58but it's getting close.
0:55:01And all she, she is not terrified,
0:55:04but the idea of switching from touch ID to face ID
0:55:08gives her anxiety.
0:55:10'cause she does, it's unfamiliar.
0:55:11She's like, well, how do you get out of an app?
0:55:13And I was like, you learn, you just swipe up, it's easy.
0:55:15Now, you know what she wants?
0:55:16She wants a home button.
0:55:18I have to tell you, this thing is gonna be a huge seller.
0:55:20Call it the iPhone 9, and yeah,
0:55:23anybody who knows that they're already up to 11
0:55:25and we're like seven months away from,
0:55:27and put an asterisk and a footnote here,
0:55:29go back 20 minutes to our whole coronavirus.
0:55:32Maybe it's not September, but iPhone 12
0:55:35is probably coming in September,
0:55:37or an iPhone 11s or something,
0:55:39there are literally maybe hundreds of millions of people
0:55:44around the world who would love an iPhone 9,
0:55:46called the iPhone 9.
0:55:47So, but here's the thing, is it a good demo?
0:55:50No, it would be the worst demo in the world, right?
0:55:53Because you can't see that it's faster, right?
0:55:58Because like this, you know, what are you gonna do?
0:56:01You know, run a benchmark on an iPhone
0:56:04compared to an iPhone 7 or something like that?
0:56:06I mean, it's an iPhone 8 with new internals.
0:56:11What do you demo?
0:56:13There is no demo.
0:56:14- Not the best product to show off on stage.
0:56:16- Right, and it would be running iOS 13.3
0:56:21or maybe iOS, probably iOS 13.4, right?
0:56:24'Cause iOS 13.4 is far enough in beta
0:56:26that it would probably be the OS for the out of the box
0:56:30for this new phone.
0:56:32It's running the iOS version
0:56:35that everybody around the world already is running.
0:56:37It's not a demo.
0:56:40The iPad is the thing that maybe would have a demo, right?
0:56:44And our, everybody's mutual friend,
0:56:48the internet's friend, Steven Trout and Smith,
0:56:51it's spelunker of betas,
0:56:53has poking around the iPad OS 13.4 betas
0:57:00has uncovered a whole slew of keyboard-related stuff
0:57:05in iOS 13.4.
0:57:07I don't even know, you're probably more familiar with me
0:57:13in terms of what's already been uncovered,
0:57:15but it would sort of coincide with a sort of,
0:57:19hey, this is a demo, like hey,
0:57:22people are using their iPads with a keyboard
0:57:25for all sorts of stuff,
0:57:26and it fits in with the years-long narrative
0:57:29for a lot of people this is the portable that you can use in a laptop type setup.
0:57:36So I don't know. What all have we already know is new in 13.4 for keyboard?
0:57:41So the things that we've seen tie in a bunch of different ways with some potential good
0:57:49demo candidates in the sense that there's one feature which is called full keyboard
0:57:54access. This one was actually available for at least a couple beta builds last
0:58:02summer in 13.0, and then it got pulled and never came back, and now it's back in
0:58:0713.4, and so full keyboard access lets you essentially define, I believe,
0:58:14custom shortcuts that you can execute from the keyboard to perform specific
0:58:20functions. Essentially it's another version of something that is
0:58:25already available in accessibility and that is if you connect a mouse in
0:58:31iAPET OS 13 and you have a programmable mouse that has multiple buttons, I mean
0:58:36usually two buttons, but you know I have a Logitech mouse that has five of them,
0:58:40and you can configure each button in accessibility right now to do things
0:58:45like "show me notification center" or "reveal the dock" or "go back to the home screen"
0:58:51all that kind of stuff.
0:58:52Now with full keyboard access you can do that, you can assign those system functions to keyboard
0:58:57commands.
0:58:58And one of the interesting features is that you can run a shortcut from the shortcuts
0:59:05app with a system-wide hotkey basically.
0:59:09And it's not as good as on the Mac because you cannot pass any input.
0:59:15So it's not like on the Mac with an automated workflow and you can say run this when I press command shift X.
0:59:23But you can pass the selected finder item as input.
0:59:28You cannot do that with full keyboard access in 13.4. But it's a step forward nonetheless.
0:59:34And also, the other big change is support
0:59:38for key up and down events.
0:59:40- Yes, right.
0:59:41- So that's one of the big features missing
0:59:46from developers who wanted to have
0:59:48serious keyboard integration with their apps.
0:59:51And so there's the productivity angle
0:59:53that I could see being demoed of like,
0:59:56now you can fully control your iPad Pro
0:59:58in two different ways, with touch, of course,
1:00:00and with the keyboard.
1:00:01And if you wanna use the keyboard,
1:00:03you never have to leave the keyboard.
1:00:05You never have to reach the screen
1:00:06because you can do it all, in theory.
1:00:08But there's also the gaming angle, right?
1:00:10Because now games can have proper keyboard integration
1:00:13because of key up and down events.
1:00:15And so I could see a story sort of like,
1:00:18now on Apple Arcade, you can,
1:00:20here's a bunch of PC quality games
1:00:22that you can now play with the keyboard or with touch.
1:00:24- Yeah, and it sounds so rudimentary, right?
1:00:29But just to further explain for anybody
1:00:32doesn't know what key up and down events are.
1:00:34Literally, let's say you're the developer of an application.
1:00:37And in the old days, there were always APIs on Mac, Windows,
1:00:43whatever you were on, where you could say, is the A key down?
1:00:46Or notify me when the A key is pressed.
1:00:49And was the key pressed, or is it being pressed and held?
1:00:54And you would think that there should be a way for computer
1:00:56programs to tell.
1:00:59But iOS and iPadOS have not had those sort of events until 13.4, which is still in beta.
1:01:06And so, for example, and again, very demo-able, and speaking of friends in San Jose,
1:01:14there's a small company in San Jose called Adobe that makes a now 30-year-old app called Photoshop.
1:01:23And anybody who's ever used Photoshop extensively on the desktop knows that they use the keyboard
1:01:31in all sorts of ways. And a casual Photoshop user is going to do everything with a mouse,
1:01:37and you click on a tool, and then you go over to your image and you start painting.
1:01:43But a Photoshop expert is using the keyboard all the time, and they have single key switches where
1:01:50where you can just type, I forget what all of them are.
1:01:54Honestly, I haven't used them in a while,
1:01:55but I don't know, you can just type like B for the brush
1:01:58or something like that.
1:01:59People who use Photoshop all the time know them by heart.
1:02:02And then you can do things like hold down the space bar
1:02:04and the cursor turns into a hand
1:02:07that you can use to page around
1:02:09without using scroll bars or something like that.
1:02:12And you can hold down the option key to do different,
1:02:15you know, get different behavior,
1:02:17or the shift key to constrain a selection
1:02:20to a fixed aspect ratio as opposed to a freeform rectangle.
1:02:25All sorts of ways that Photoshop uses the keyboard
1:02:30and has been problematic, to say the least,
1:02:35on iPad up until now would make for a very good demo.
1:02:40And yeah, again, the gaming thing is obvious
1:02:43in terms of being able to get fast key events
1:02:47to be able to drive a game from the keyboard.
1:02:50- Yeah, and when you think about it,
1:02:52not so many companies can have,
1:02:54can say we have a tablet that has a really amazing GPU
1:02:59that gives you this kind of graphical performance
1:03:02and lets you, and of course, if this is all true,
1:03:06lets you play games with two different input methods.
1:03:10Like you can play with touch
1:03:11or you can play with the keyboard.
1:03:13I mean, the Nintendo Switch has some kind of touch control,
1:03:17but it's basically never used in games.
1:03:19And the GPU is not nearly as good as the current iPad Pro.
1:03:24I cannot imagine the next iPad Pro.
1:03:26So it's definitely an interesting proposition.
1:03:29And from a productivity standpoint,
1:03:31as you mentioned, Photoshop,
1:03:32and all the existing productivity apps,
1:03:35there's a few developers who,
1:03:38over the past couple of years,
1:03:40have tried to enable full keyboard navigation
1:03:44in their apps, in their iPad apps.
1:03:47You look at something like agenda, for example, or things,
1:03:50or just today, the RSS client Unread
1:03:55has a new version, Unread 2.
1:03:57And one of the features is you can fully navigate Unread
1:04:00with a keyboard if you have an iPad.
1:04:03So developers have been doing
1:04:04their own custom implementations, but again, they're custom
1:04:08and they require a lot of work,
1:04:11and they do not support key up and down events.
1:04:14So in theory, having a proper framework from Apple
1:04:17with support for key up and down events,
1:04:19it makes a world of difference if you're an iPad developer.
1:04:23So that's very demo-able for sure.
1:04:26- Yeah.
1:04:27I think that there's,
1:04:31it's just the roots showing through, the roots of the,
1:04:37And it's funny because, and I say this,
1:04:39and it's like people forget it,
1:04:40and it's come up a couple times in recent weeks,
1:04:43but it is funny that the original iPad from 2010
1:04:48was demoed with a first party keyboard dock.
1:04:53(laughing)
1:04:54I had that, I had that dock, I used it twice,
1:04:58and then I forgot about it.
1:05:00You know what, I knew I didn't want it,
1:05:02and so I didn't buy it.
1:05:03And I don't know how I knew it,
1:05:05And I was like-- and it was funny, because I'll never
1:05:09forget that demo.
1:05:11I went to the event, and the hands-on area was open.
1:05:16And I'm always one of the-- often one of the last to leave,
1:05:21because I'm not under pressure to immediately get something
1:05:24up on Daring Fireball.
1:05:26I can take my time.
1:05:28Whereas an awful lot of the media who are in attendance
1:05:31either are required to file a story very quickly,
1:05:35or just feel that pressure to file very quickly.
1:05:39And nowadays, 2010 it wasn't as big a deal,
1:05:42but nowadays a lot of them have to shoot video
1:05:44and there's all this going on.
1:05:46And I'll just sit there and play with the devices.
1:05:48And I just remember, it was like,
1:05:51and they're so very nice, but they came up,
1:05:53it was me and Dan Morin, who was then at Macworld,
1:05:56were playing with the iPad on the dock
1:05:58and we were trying to figure out all the keyboard shortcuts,
1:06:01what worked and what didn't work.
1:06:02And we're going through mail, and we're like,
1:06:04"All right, let's go to..." and this was before you could hold down the command key and just see the shortcuts.
1:06:09But we're like, "Oh, what about shift-command-D? Can you do shift-command-D to send an email?" And we're like, "Yes!"
1:06:15And we're just going through and this very nice woman came over and she was like, "Hey, you know, hey guys,
1:06:22you know, we're wrapping up." And we look around and there's literally nobody left except Apple and Voice.
1:06:30We're like, "Oh, I guess we should go."
1:06:33We're like, we're sorry.
1:06:35And we like left, but we literally got dragged out
1:06:39while we were using the keyboard doc
1:06:42to try to figure out all the keyboard shortcuts
1:06:45that they managed to hook up.
1:06:46But I didn't use it.
1:06:48But anyway, the keyboard was clearly an afterthought,
1:06:51at least originally.
1:06:52Even though they sold a keyboard, that's my point.
1:06:54They sold one originally,
1:06:56and it was to sort of sell the line that,
1:06:58hey, they've got a full-blown version of numbers
1:07:03and pages and you can actually sit there and write and stuff.
1:07:07But actual proper first class support of a hardware keyboard,
1:07:12honestly, it's still not there.
1:07:14And it sounds like we may not have to wait for iOS
1:07:18or iPad OS 14.
1:07:20It seems like 13.4 might be the height,
1:07:23the mark where we say this is where iPad OS crossed the line
1:07:27and now has,
1:07:32It's over the 50-yard line. It's over the halfway mark of having good keyboard support.
1:07:36That's a sports metaphor, right?
1:07:38Yes, yeah, I'm sorry.
1:07:39That's why I switched.
1:07:41Yards? That's football.
1:07:43Well, that's why I switched. What do you call the center line on a soccer pitch?
1:07:48Midfield? Crossed midfield?
1:07:53Yeah, yes, yes.
1:07:55All right, so 50-yard line is midfield. So we've crossed midfield, you know.
1:08:00We've gone over and now we're on the scoring end.
1:08:03- Got it.
1:08:04- You know, like for me, one of the things that is just,
1:08:07it's just so frustrating and I don't think 13.4 does this,
1:08:11but boy, it's like, man, when I have a hardware keyboard
1:08:15connected to my iPad, and I don't wanna go off
1:08:17on the whole iPad stretch here,
1:08:19because that'll be the closing segment of the show,
1:08:22we have a lot to talk about,
1:08:23but just in terms of like driving your iPad
1:08:25with the keyboard, when I'm on the home screen,
1:08:29it drives me insane that you can't just use the arrow keys
1:08:32to select between apps and then hit the return key
1:08:36to open it or something to open it.
1:08:39You know, like in the Finder, you know, on the Mac,
1:08:42people might think that you hit return to open something,
1:08:45but no, return renames it,
1:08:47which is sort of a historical artifact.
1:08:49You have to use command open or command down arrow to open.
1:08:52You know, I'm not gonna argue
1:08:56whether those keyboard shortcuts
1:08:57we're a historical mistake or not,
1:08:59but we're stuck with them.
1:09:00But there should be some way
1:09:01with a keyboard connected to an iPad
1:09:04to arrow key around.
1:09:06And they enforce the grid, right?
1:09:09It's not like the desktop on the Mac
1:09:11where you can kind of have your icons
1:09:12on your iPad home screen strewn about in a mess.
1:09:17It enforces a nice grid,
1:09:20which is just begging for up, down, left, right, right?
1:09:24- Yes. - Just begging.
1:09:27- Yeah, and really the main problem when you think about it
1:09:30is that the iPad, and that is not changing in 13.4,
1:09:35it lacks any kind of selection state from the keyboard.
1:09:40Any kind, like on tvOS you have the focus engine, right?
1:09:44And you can select items and then you can click.
1:09:47And there's none of that on the iPad.
1:09:50Which is why some developers, some third-party developers
1:09:52have done their own custom thing, but at a system level,
1:09:55like even the basic stuff,
1:09:56like I want to select icons on the home screen.
1:09:59Well, it's not possible because the idea of selection
1:10:02is just not there.
1:10:03Just like the idea of hovering over items in UIKit.
1:10:07It's just not there, it doesn't exist,
1:10:08which is why the current implementation
1:10:12of the pointing device is via accessibility.
1:10:15That's not a real pointing device.
1:10:17You're not hovering over anything.
1:10:19You're just simulating a finger on screen
1:10:20and then you click, which means you tap.
1:10:23But I totally agree with you.
1:10:25Like it's so annoying that whenever you're on the home screen, really the only way to
1:10:29launch an app without touching the screen is to search for it and then press return.
1:10:35Which yeah, sort of works, but no, just let me select stuff.
1:10:41The other thing that drives me nuts about, you do command space and then you search for
1:10:45an app and it is the first search result.
1:10:48You can hit the return key and it will open, but there's still no selection state to show
1:10:53you that.
1:10:54to have to trust that the return key will open, but then you can use the arrow keys
1:10:58to move up and down the selection, much like Spotlight on the Mac.
1:11:03So I want to say, and I may be wrong, that maybe you can do Command+Down to jump between
1:11:10different sets of results. Like, maybe you can do Command+Down and you select…
1:11:17There still should be a selection.
1:11:18- Yeah, and it should be better than it is right now,
1:11:22for sure, and I really, why do I hope that in 14
1:11:26we get some kind of selection state API
1:11:29and just hover state.
1:11:32It's really necessary.
1:11:34If you wanna have serious keyboard integration.
1:11:37Speaking of which, did you see this rumor
1:11:40about the smart keyboard possibly getting a trackpad?
1:11:44- Yes, yes.
1:11:45The information, which is not like a regular source
1:11:50of Apple stuff, the information is subscriber only
1:11:54and it's largely startup focused and sort of VC,
1:11:59I often think sort of VC centric,
1:12:02but then when they do pipe up with Apple stuff,
1:12:04it's usually pretty accurate.
1:12:06And they'll go months without anything
1:12:10and then pop up with a blockbuster.
1:12:12And this one, this is a report from Wayne Ma,
1:12:15Apple planning iPad keyboard with trackpad
1:12:18Apple is planning to release an iPad keyboard accessory later this year that will include a built-in trackpad
1:12:24Hmm that's you know, I don't know that we even need to go any further
1:12:30I think you know their article goes on and on but I feel like we all kind of you know
1:12:35I guess the one thing we don't know and they don't know in the article is
1:12:39To me it
1:12:43it would imply that it's going to be promoted
1:12:48out of accessibility and will become
1:12:51a first-class mouse cursor when you have
1:12:56a pointing device attached, whether it's a trackpad
1:13:00on a keyboard or a mouse or a, I guess,
1:13:04I mean, since you can connect mice, you can connect,
1:13:07I don't even know if this is true,
1:13:08can you connect like a magic trackpad to an iPad?
1:13:11- No, you cannot right now.
1:13:14- So you can't.
1:13:15So you can plug in a USB mouse,
1:13:17but you can't do a trackpad.
1:13:18But in theory, they could support it.
1:13:21And I would think that then,
1:13:27here we go into the meat of the subject.
1:13:32Maybe I should take a break before we continue.
1:13:36I'm gonna take a break and thank our next sponsor.
1:13:39It is.
1:13:40Oh, I love this sponsor.
1:13:42This is a great company.
1:13:44Hover, H-O-V-E-R.
1:13:46Look, Hover is a jumping off point
1:13:51for a ton of entrepreneurs
1:13:53because they want you to start your business,
1:13:57your idea, your new project.
1:13:58Maybe it's not even a business.
1:13:59Maybe it's like an open source project
1:14:01or something like that.
1:14:02But what do you need to start?
1:14:03You want a great domain name.
1:14:06Hover has over 300 domain name extensions to choose from when building your brand online.
1:14:13That's the top level domain.
1:14:15Back in the day, man, I'm so old, I remember when there were three, there was like four,
1:14:20.com, .org, .net, and .edu.
1:14:23If you didn't like one of those, you were stuck.
1:14:25Well, they've got over 300 of those to choose from at this point.
1:14:29No matter what you want to build, there's a domain name waiting for it.
1:14:32You'll find excellent tech support from Hover available
1:14:36to answer any questions you may have,
1:14:38and their support team does not upsell you.
1:14:41They only work hard to help you get online.
1:14:45They offer stuff like free Whois privacy protection.
1:14:49So when you register a domain name with Hover,
1:14:51keeping your personal information,
1:14:54like your address and your phone number
1:14:55and your email address, et cetera,
1:14:57it's not an upsell that you have to pay extra for.
1:14:59It's included free because, of course,
1:15:01doesn't want privacy protection on that information.
1:15:05They have a really clean, great user interface to their website.
1:15:09And just the simplest thing, like the search interface for searching for whatever it is
1:15:16you want dot com, and you find out the dot com version of whatever it is you want isn't
1:15:21available, but what other domains are available and what other things are similar, you put
1:15:26like a hyphen in or something like that.
1:15:28They offer all, their suggestion interface
1:15:31for what is available, it's just perfect.
1:15:35It's really good, it's exactly what you want.
1:15:37They also have monthly sales and promotions
1:15:42on popular top-level domains.
1:15:43It's just, once you look at Hover
1:15:47and compare it to other domain name registrars,
1:15:49you can just see why Hover is so popular
1:15:51and why they've been so popular for so long.
1:15:55I love the search interface.
1:15:58Also, their tech support, if you have an existing
1:16:02domain name registered at another registrar
1:16:05and you want to move it to Hover,
1:16:07they will help you as much as you need.
1:16:10So even if you're like a total non-expert
1:16:12and you don't know, you don't wanna screw up
1:16:15like the MX records that deliver email and stuff like that,
1:16:18and you just don't wanna screw it up,
1:16:19Hover tech support will walk you through
1:16:22every step of the way if you need it.
1:16:26And just to make you feel completely confident
1:16:29that moving your domain from your old registrar to Hover
1:16:32is gonna go off without a hitch, it really is great.
1:16:35It's a great interface, like I said,
1:16:40300 domain name extensions to choose from.
1:16:43Grab your domain name and just find out more
1:16:47by going to hover.com/talkshow,
1:16:50H-O-V-E-R.com/talkshow, and use that link
1:16:54and you get a 10% discount on all new purchases.
1:16:57Make a name for yourself with Hover at hover.com/talkshow.
1:17:02Let me see if I can remember post-sponsor break
1:17:05where we were.
1:17:06We were talking about the mouse cursor support.
1:17:09Yeah, it's gotta be.
1:17:10If they're gonna do a trackpad,
1:17:11which I think they should and I would love,
1:17:13I really, really, really hope that this rumor is true.
1:17:17Not just for the idea of a smart keyboard cover
1:17:21with a trackpad that you could use,
1:17:23but just in the broader sense,
1:17:26the idea that they would add first-class mouse pointer
1:17:28support to iPad OS.
1:17:30- Jason Snyder just posted on Six Colors,
1:17:35a post with questions about potential smart keyboard
1:17:39with a trackpad, and all those questions basically match
1:17:42the things that I was thinking about.
1:17:45What does it mean if they do a trackpad
1:17:47in terms of the kind of pointer that we get?
1:17:52because right now I could see Apple saying,
1:17:55look, it's got a trackpad,
1:17:56but it's just for text editing, right?
1:17:59Just like now, for example,
1:18:00you can hold down two fingers on the software keyboard
1:18:03and you get a trackpad when you're editing text.
1:18:05I could see a scenario where, yes, there's a trackpad,
1:18:10but it only helps when it comes to text editing.
1:18:12And I think that will make sense,
1:18:14but also I would be disappointed
1:18:17because I would love to see a full-blown trackpad support
1:18:20and actual support in UIKit
1:18:24for controlling the entire interface with the trackpad.
1:18:27But also what does it mean
1:18:28in terms of hardware keyboard design?
1:18:32Like does it mean that Apple is gonna have a keyboard
1:18:35with a hinge, like fully adjustable viewing angle,
1:18:39for example?
1:18:40So there's a lot of questions right now,
1:18:41but I guess the main point being,
1:18:44do we foresee a scenario where the iPad,
1:18:49you can actually control the entire iPad OS UI
1:18:52with a pointing device, with a trackpad
1:18:55built into the keyboard so that you never
1:18:56have to touch the screen.
1:18:58- I really hope so, and for a couple of reasons.
1:19:00One of them is that touch screens have been around,
1:19:04I mean, really, we're like 13 years into it
1:19:08at this point, right?
1:19:09It was 2007 in January when Apple announced
1:19:14the original iPhone.
1:19:17So we're now 13 years after, not quite to the point,
1:19:21I mean this was the point when everybody
1:19:23was still speculating that it was gonna be a dud,
1:19:25it wasn't gonna work, blah, blah, blah,
1:19:27but nobody had it yet.
1:19:28But we're easily over a 10 years into the period
1:19:32where people have touch screens
1:19:35and Apple has answered questions about,
1:19:37well, why doesn't the Mac have touch screen support
1:19:40for a long time?
1:19:41And until and if they ever do release touch screen Macs,
1:19:47they're gonna keep answering it,
1:19:48and their answer is, one of the answers has always been
1:19:52that the ergonomics are terrible, right?
1:19:54Especially for like an iPad or an iMac, right,
1:19:59where you're pointing at this screen,
1:20:01an arm's length in front of you, your arm gets tired,
1:20:05and they've mentioned it many times,
1:20:07but even on a laptop, it's,
1:20:10a swipe here, a swipe there, tap here,
1:20:14and put your hands back down is no problem,
1:20:16but if the only way to,
1:20:19let's say you have a text editing document,
1:20:23a long article, you know, school paper,
1:20:26someone like me or you who writes for the web,
1:20:28and you've got edits to make,
1:20:30and editing is often largely, you know, selecting,
1:20:35you know, you don't necessarily wanna do it all
1:20:37with arrow keys, you know.
1:20:39It's tiresome to sit there and touch the screen
1:20:42over and over again, and touching the screen
1:20:45obscures the thing you're looking at, right?
1:20:47Your hand is actually in front of your face.
1:20:49It doesn't make sense if Apple's argument,
1:20:59one of Apple's arguments against touchscreen Macs
1:21:02is the ergonomics are bad, which I believe is true.
1:21:05I actually think that is actually true,
1:21:07the ergonomics are bad, but then it doesn't make sense
1:21:10that when they say here with our iPad Pro,
1:21:13you can get this smart keyboard and turn it into a laptop-like physical configuration,
1:21:19and then when you want to do anything, you have to touch the screen, which we've already
1:21:21told you with our other thing is ergonomically bad.
1:21:24Right?
1:21:25I mean, that's – it fundamentally doesn't make sense.
1:21:28And when I've confronted Apple folks with that, they just give non-answer answers.
1:21:36But it clearly doesn't hold water, right?
1:21:39And basically the ergonomic argument in favor of this is beyond arguments over the operating
1:21:47system and the UI for it, right?
1:21:49But if your hands, your fingers are on the home row keys of your keyboard, right, and
1:21:55the keyboard is flat on the desk, where are your thumbs?
1:21:59Your thumbs are right where track pads go, right?
1:22:03Like ergonomically, this is a solved problem.
1:22:09And I know that in the early years of PC laptops,
1:22:11the IBM ones had the little rubber nubbin in the middle,
1:22:16and we had track balls before we had track pads.
1:22:20But Apple quickly figured out that the right place
1:22:22for the track ball, I mean, there were early laptops,
1:22:24I don't know if you remember, you're a youngster,
1:22:27but Apple had one, the original Mac portable,
1:22:31which was like a suitcase, more than a laptop.
1:22:34But it had the track pad, the track ball, off to the side,
1:22:38so that you would use it like where a mouse was.
1:22:40You'd move, you know, 'cause,
1:22:42but I guess they had to put something over there
1:22:43'cause the thing was so big.
1:22:44But we've, you know, ergonomically,
1:22:47we've gotten to the point where it seems pretty obvious
1:22:49that you put your fingers on the keyboard like you're typing
1:22:52and your thumbs are just right there where a trackpad goes.
1:22:55And so wouldn't it be nice if you're,
1:22:58when you're using an iPad,
1:23:00if you could just make use of those thumbs
1:23:03that are right there without lifting 'em up?
1:23:05You know, so I feel like there's an ergonomic argument.
1:23:08On the software side, this is where I think it's more interesting and nuanced, is because
1:23:14I think the better argument against touchscreen Macs is that by assuming that every single
1:23:24Mac has a mouse pointer attachment, you either have a mouse or a trackpad.
1:23:31It's almost impossible.
1:23:32I mean, you could run a Mac as a kiosk of some sort without a keyboard and mouse, but
1:23:37But to actually use a Mac, it's borderline impossible without, as a typical user, you
1:23:44know, it's, you know, nobody would really want to use a Mac without a mouse pointer,
1:23:48a mouse or a trackpad.
1:23:50And those are very fine, precise pointing things.
1:23:55There's all sorts of UI elements that are able to be packed as small targets close together.
1:24:01And my most prominent example are the red, yellow, green buttons for closing a window
1:24:07minimizing a window and full screen zooming a window.
1:24:10They're very small targets,
1:24:12they're very close to each other,
1:24:14and if they were touch targets,
1:24:16they would have to be further apart,
1:24:18and that would take up more room in every single window.
1:24:22There's also, just looking at,
1:24:23I'm looking at Safari right now,
1:24:24there's just all sorts of stuff
1:24:26at the top of my Safari window that's way too small,
1:24:30way too small of a target, way too close to other targets
1:24:35to be good for a touch interface.
1:24:38So, I'm not going to bet money
1:24:43that Apple will never have a touchscreen Mac.
1:24:45I mean, maybe it's inevitable, I don't know,
1:24:47'cause there's certainly a lot of people
1:24:48who think they want it.
1:24:49But my deep concern is that to do it right,
1:24:52they would have to fundamentally change the Mac interface
1:24:55in a way that would make it less information dense,
1:24:58which I think is one of the convenient things about it.
1:25:02Whereas I feel like you could add mouse support to iPad OS without sacrificing anything in
1:25:11terms of the experience for what if you're just touching it like a you know like like
1:25:17you don't you if you never have a trackpad or mouse connected to it does it change the
1:25:22size or placement of any UI targets no right I feel like it I'm not saying it's easy nobody
1:25:31I don't want to ever tell engineers that anything is easy, but I think conceptually
1:25:35iPadOS is a much better fit for first-class mouse pointer support than macOS is a fit for touchscreen support.
1:25:44I agree with that. And the reason why I also want them to do this is
1:25:49because right now there's a, on the iPad, there's a fundamental case of feature disparity between the two
1:25:58different modes. If you think about it, what really sets the iPad apart from the Mac is
1:26:06the fact that you can pull it out from the keyboard and just use it as a tablet. Whereas
1:26:11a MacBook, you cannot just pull out the screen and use it. It's always attached to the keyboard,
1:26:16or if it's a desktop Mac, it always needs to be a desktop computer. So the iPad does
1:26:21support two different modes. And when it's in multi-touch mode, so you don't have any
1:26:27keyboard accessory, you don't have any mouse,
1:26:31it's fully usable like that, right?
1:26:32It fully supports multi-touch,
1:26:34it's got a software keyboard, it's fully usable.
1:26:37But if you add a smart keyboard,
1:26:40that's when the feature disparity comes in.
1:26:42And it's so funny right now that Apple itself
1:26:47created this problem of when you use a smart keyboard,
1:26:51you cannot fully use the iPad from the keyboard alone
1:26:55because you still need to touch the screen.
1:26:57And this is the keyboard that Apple makes, that Apple sells,
1:27:00and that Apple promotes as the accessory for the iPad Pro.
1:27:03So I think they should do it, because right now the iPad
1:27:07can be used with the keyboard.
1:27:09And I mean, I use it.
1:27:10I came up with all sorts of workarounds for like--
1:27:14I have a Logitech mouse that I have with some shortcuts.
1:27:18But it's not native, and you can feel that it's an afterthought.
1:27:23And whereas the iPad is fully usable as a tablet in touch mode,
1:27:28it is not fully native if you want to use it with a keyboard.
1:27:32And so I'm seeing a bunch of people on Twitter saying,
1:27:36if they're going to do it, if they're going to add a cursor,
1:27:38it's just going to be for text fields.
1:27:40Maybe.
1:27:41But I think it should be a real cursor.
1:27:43And I think it should be a real pointing device that
1:27:45lets you control the whole UI.
1:27:49I could see it, but as being just for text,
1:27:53like you said, exactly like the virtual trackpad you can get.
1:27:58And you can get it on the iPhone too
1:28:01by holding down on the space bar now that 3D touch is gone.
1:28:05And it's a two-finger touch
1:28:08on the virtual keyboard on iPad OS, right?
1:28:12If you-- - Yes, yep.
1:28:14- You just go there and two fingers touch.
1:28:16Yeah, you put two fingers down.
1:28:18anywhere on the keyboard, which is really nice, very, very nice.
1:28:22You don't have to aim for the space bar.
1:28:26So there's a tip of the day.
1:28:28Every time I mention something like that,
1:28:29I know that there's people who are like, holy crap,
1:28:31I didn't know you could do that.
1:28:32Virtual keyboard up on the iPad, put two fingers anywhere
1:28:36on the keyboard, and you get-- while you're editing text,
1:28:39and you can move the insertion point around.
1:28:42I just don't think, though, that they--
1:28:44if they're going to go so far as to actually put a trackpad
1:28:47on the smart keyboard, I just don't see
1:28:49why they wouldn't do it for everything.
1:28:50And I really do think, I really do think,
1:28:54and there might be some edge cases,
1:28:56there's always edge cases, there's always something
1:28:58that's tricky, but I think for the most part,
1:29:00it won't take away from touch at all.
1:29:04I really do feel that that's true,
1:29:06and that it's just sort of a historical artifact
1:29:11of the fact that the iPad was derived
1:29:13from the iPhone's operating system
1:29:16that it didn't have it right from the start.
1:29:20- Yeah, yeah, and I've been part of this computing life,
1:29:25I guess, for the past several years at this point.
1:29:30And really, whenever I share a photo of my iPad setup,
1:29:35I always got a bunch of people saying,
1:29:37"Why don't you just use a Mac?"
1:29:39And while I do get the point, right,
1:29:42because it does look like when you're using the iPad
1:29:45with the keyboard and maybe a mouse
1:29:46and maybe some other accessory, it does look like a laptop.
1:29:49But to me, that's the whole point of the conversation
1:29:53of if I want, I can pull out the tablet
1:29:57and go work on the couch or stay in bed.
1:30:01And that is actually how I started using the iPad
1:30:03when I was sick and undergoing cancer treatments years ago.
1:30:08And I couldn't use a MacBook.
1:30:10I just had the iPad and I was able to stay in the hospital bed
1:30:14use the iPad as a tablet. And that to me is really the greatest strength of the device.
1:30:23And I know that it's an overused term, but it can be sort of like hybrid computer in
1:30:28the sense that it's tablet and then you just slide it into a keyboard and it becomes sort
1:30:32of like laptop. So yeah, I really do think that the two modes can coexist. And when it
1:30:40comes to the trackpad, I was just thinking about this as we were talking about it. We've
1:30:46seen all these concepts. You linked one of them on Daring Fireball for like rethinking
1:30:52iPad multitasking. And I was thinking about these concepts and then the rumor came out
1:30:57today of the trackpad. And so I realized if there's an opportunity for Apple to bring
1:31:04consistency to a new multitasking interface. What better way to add
1:31:11consistency than to say there's new gestures that you can use for multitouch
1:31:16if you want to use multitasking and split view and the same gestures actually
1:31:21work with our multitouch trackpad on the smart keyboard. It's always the same
1:31:25gestures, it's always the same interaction system and you can use it
1:31:33be attached and you can use it with the keyboard. And I think René Ritchie on YouTube also had
1:31:38some kind of concept a couple of months back, maybe, arguing if Apple were to do a new multitasking
1:31:46system on iPad, maybe they should consider multitouch gestures. So that could potentially
1:31:52be interesting if it's also a multitouch trackpad on the smart keyboard, of course.
1:31:57Yeah, I think it would be too, because I think that they're all in on that in terms,
1:32:01and it's a way to bring some consistency
1:32:04between the Mac and iOS.
1:32:06I mean, I can't imagine that it wouldn't be, right?
1:32:09Like, I don't know, it is one of the most exciting rumors,
1:32:14and it's so funny because we could have recorded yesterday,
1:32:19we would have done the whole show before it broke,
1:32:21but to me, it's honestly one of the most exciting rumors
1:32:24in a long while.
1:32:26I'm terribly excited about it
1:32:28because it's not just about having the trackpad,
1:32:30It's everything that it says about what I think they would need to do with iPadOS
1:32:34to make it worthwhile having a first-party trackpad, right?
1:32:38And I just can't help but think that it would mean that you could put two fingers
1:32:44on it to scroll a scroll view, right?
1:32:47But that also implies some sort of focus, whether it's a mouse hovering over it.
1:32:53Like on the Mac, it's wherever the mouse cursor is hovering,
1:32:57you can scroll up and down with two fingers to scroll the thing, including in a background
1:33:01window, you know, but what determines it? You don't even have to click on it. You just put the
1:33:06mouse cursor over it and then use two fingers to go up and down to scroll the view. It would be
1:33:12baffling if they don't support that, right? Like, what's the point of having a trackpad if you can't
1:33:20scroll with it, if you still have to do it? I mean, would it mean that literally every single
1:33:26thing in the system could be done from the keyboard and trackpad? Maybe, right? That almost seems like
1:33:32one part of me wants to say, "Well, maybe not everything." But then I want to say, "Why not?"
1:33:38Right? Like, what is there that you wouldn't be able to do? You know, with the combination of
1:33:44moving the cursor as a virtual finger over elements and tapping to simulate a touch,
1:33:51and a combination of multi-fingered gestures
1:33:54for things like, you know, bringing, I don't know.
1:33:59I mean, would you be able to bring down control center
1:34:03with a drag from the top of the track pad?
1:34:05I don't know.
1:34:06- Yeah, you could do expose now that you have
1:34:08multiple windows on iPad, you could do that.
1:34:11You could show the app switcher and maybe, again,
1:34:15if they were to add a new, a different multitasking system,
1:34:18you could have gestures for split view and slide over and that kind of stuff.
1:34:23So, yeah, I mean, why not, right?
1:34:26If you go so far as to add a physical trackpad
1:34:31to the smart keyboard, which is super premium space, right?
1:34:36You go to such lengths as to add an actual trackpad,
1:34:41limiting that trackpad to just scrolling text fields and text views.
1:34:48That seems like a wasted opportunity.
1:34:50- It just seems a little spiteful, you know?
1:34:52Like not spiteful that Apple doesn't like iPad users
1:34:57and wants them to be frustrated,
1:35:00but like spitefully sticking to the idea
1:35:04that it's fundamentally a touchscreen,
1:35:07you know what I mean?
1:35:07It's putting an idea above the actual practicality
1:35:12of would this actually be useful
1:35:15without taking away from anything that's already good.
1:35:19- It will be political more than practical.
1:35:22- Yeah, or dogmatic, I don't know what word
1:35:24you wanna use, right?
1:35:25Like you're just sticking to this dogma
1:35:27that no longer holds.
1:35:29Well, now one thing that comes to me,
1:35:32and this is why it's fascinating me,
1:35:34I love reading your stuff on iPad,
1:35:36and I've complained a bit recently,
1:35:38and I have a couple more complaints
1:35:40to get off my chest before I'm done,
1:35:44about the state of iPadOS.
1:35:47And there's just so many people who got angry at me.
1:35:57Oh, really?
1:35:57People get angry at you?
1:35:59And I don't get it.
1:36:01I really tried to write around it and anticipate it.
1:36:03And the basic idea is if you come up with-- like me,
1:36:07you have a bunch of what I think are very valid complaints
1:36:10about the current state of iPadOS,
1:36:12and you describe them to the best of your ability,
1:36:16and then all of a sudden they say,
1:36:17"Well, you hate the iPad because you're an old person
1:36:20"who likes the Mac and you just want the iPad to be a Mac."
1:36:23And it's like, no, I don't.
1:36:24What I would like, ideally, I love the Mac.
1:36:27And again, I'm a sort of person,
1:36:29if I had to choose between iPad and Mac
1:36:31for the rest of my life without hesitation,
1:36:32half a second, I would choose Mac.
1:36:35That's just where I am, that's who I am,
1:36:36no surprise from what I've written.
1:36:38But holy crap, wouldn't it be amazing
1:36:40if the iPad got so good that I thought, "Wow, even I as a Mac person think this is better."
1:36:44That would be better, right?
1:36:46Like I love the Mac.
1:36:47The Mac is still my favorite operating system there is, but I'm not like going to look anything
1:36:56-- I would love to find something better, right?
1:36:58Like people think, "Well, if you love the Mac and that's your thing, then you're some
1:37:02kind of zealot, and no matter what anybody else does, you're going to find ways to say
1:37:08the Mac is better, that's not my mindset at all. I love the Mac, and so therefore if there
1:37:16were ever something from Apple or any other company that I thought was a better overall
1:37:20system than the Mac, that would be amazing because the Mac is already great. So it would
1:37:24be great if the iPad got better. I would love to see the iPad get better. So I don't understand
1:37:29the defensiveness on some people's parts. And that's one thing, I don't know how you
1:37:33get away with it because you're well known as an iPad power user and somebody who really
1:37:39it just fits with your brain. I mean that's what you're trying to I know what you're trying to say
1:37:45is like the reason that you like using an iPad for everything and the reason why when people say
1:37:50well why don't you just use a Mac for that is that the iPad is like it for me Mac OS fits my brain
1:37:58And maybe my brain has been warped to fit Mac OS over the years.
1:38:02But it's very clear from your writing and your enthusiasm and the clever things you come up with
1:38:08with shortcuts and stuff like that, that the iPad OS just fits your brain, right?
1:38:14Yeah.
1:38:14It is a natural extension of your brain.
1:38:17And it's like the lack of keyboard support is like, at times, for certain tasks,
1:38:24one of your hands is tied behind your back.
1:38:25Yes.
1:38:27- Yes.
1:38:29- Like I feel bad for you.
1:38:31I feel that I do, I really do.
1:38:33'Cause I feel like right now,
1:38:37the iPad is constrained in ways that aren't,
1:38:41it's not like, oh, well that would be impossible to solve.
1:38:44Right, like if you,
1:38:45just off the top of my head,
1:38:48if you really wanted Siri to be as intelligent
1:38:51as the HAL computer in 2001
1:38:54and be able to hold a real conversation with you,
1:38:56Well, to get from where we are today to there is an awful lot of work and maybe, who knows,
1:39:02maybe it's not even technically possible, AI is never going to get there.
1:39:07Whereas getting proper mouse pointer support in iPadOS, that's obviously technically possible,
1:39:14right?
1:39:15Like this is, it's a design decision, not a technical or engineering limitation.
1:39:22It's exactly that.
1:39:23Like it's so close, right?
1:39:26you can see the thing actually in front of you,
1:39:29but you cannot reach it.
1:39:30- Right.
1:39:31- Especially now that we have that sort of like
1:39:35external pointing device feature,
1:39:37but it is an accessibility feature,
1:39:40so it's not exactly that.
1:39:42And it's so close and you can feel like
1:39:44that reality is within my grasp,
1:39:46but the closer you get, the further away from you,
1:39:50it escapes.
1:39:51And that is why I'm so excited about this rumor.
1:39:55And as you said, the reason why I keep using the iPad is one,
1:40:02yes, because it does fit my brain at this point better.
1:40:06And two, I would say because ever since I
1:40:10was unable to get any work done--
1:40:13and we're talking now seven years ago,
1:40:14and everything is fine now.
1:40:15That is while in the past.
1:40:17But that scared me in the sense that the iPad,
1:40:24I, working on the iPad, I know that I always have a fallback built in, in the sense that
1:40:31if I cannot work with my keyboard and my mouse and my vertical stand, I can still hold the
1:40:39thing in my hands and stay in bed and send an email, right? And so that, I, like, that
1:40:47disability, you could say, like years ago, it really left an impression in my brain
1:40:54in terms of I never want to just depend on a desktop computer ever again. And
1:41:00that is why I've always been on a sort of quest to see what's a way to
1:41:06to do this with full portability, with full mobility. And that is why
1:41:13I get a lot of people making fun of me whenever I share a complex shortcut.
1:41:19And years ago, it used to be Python scripts with Pythonista, and it used to be URL schemes before that.
1:41:26And Launch Center Pro, which is still a great utility, but Launch Center Pro, when it first came out,
1:41:34came out was a way to get interapplication communication
1:41:39all through URL schemes, which can get complicated.
1:41:44- It can get complicated, but still,
1:41:49it did allow me to be more efficient years ago.
1:41:53So I generally get why people like you
1:41:58and people like Stephen Hackett, for example,
1:42:03prefer working on Mac OS. And I think it's totally fine. And I think it's so silly that
1:42:09some people on Twitter think that, like, oh, now they're going to fight it out, the iPad
1:42:15guys versus the Mac guys. And I don't think it's like that at all.
1:42:19No.
1:42:20I think if anything, like, it is. There's a certain—and I struggle to explain this
1:42:26whenever I get into these arguments on Twitter—there's a beauty to the idea, like a fundamental
1:42:31beauty to the idea that two operating systems can coexist within each other. And I see the beauty in
1:42:42that, in the sense of you can choose what you want to use. Like you can choose your favorite computer.
1:42:49And I think that's beautiful. And I think it's like, yes, I like working on the iPad. And yes,
1:42:56I would like it to be more like a Mac in certain examples.
1:43:01But I fully know that it's not there yet.
1:43:07And it's like, because those complaints that you get,
1:43:10they also work the other way around.
1:43:13Like, I get the comments from people saying,
1:43:15oh, you're an iPad fanboy, you're a zealot,
1:43:19you're never gonna say that anything else is better.
1:43:23And like, that's so short-sighted.
1:43:25And I fully agree with you in the sense that there are some things that need to be different.
1:43:34For example, multitasking, right?
1:43:39So here's what I'm going to say.
1:43:42I think we need some kind of change.
1:43:46What I don't want to see is a regression for people like me.
1:43:54The current system, the iOS 11 system for multitasking on iPad, heavily based on drag-and-drop
1:44:02for adding icons to split view or slide over. I know that system, right? I know how to use it.
1:44:10I know how to operate it. I know how to use the dock and multiple apps in slide over.
1:44:17And those are powerful features.
1:44:19At the same time, I also think it's not
1:44:23the most intuitive it could be.
1:44:27I think it's too complicated for a lot of folks
1:44:31who are approaching the iPad now.
1:44:34At the same time though, as a power user,
1:44:36I don't want to lose those features.
1:44:37So it's this kind of weird situation where like,
1:44:39I know it needs to be different,
1:44:41but I also don't wanna lose what I already know.
1:44:43I think fundamentally it's exactly the whole multitasking thing.
1:44:49And it is complicated.
1:44:50It is absolutely complicated.
1:44:52Not just what we already have being too complicated, but any idea of how to go forward is very,
1:45:00very tricky and requires really, really top-notch UI design at a conceptual level.
1:45:07But I really do also feel that it is ground zero
1:45:10of the fault line that iPad OS has found itself in
1:45:15between the Mac and iPhone, right?
1:45:18And that being, you know, in theory,
1:45:22iPad could have been a version of Mac OS
1:45:27with bigger touch targets instead of the phone OS
1:45:33put on a bigger screen.
1:45:35I don't think it should have been.
1:45:36I think they made the right decision because I think that,
1:45:39put the UI stuff aside, there's all sorts,
1:45:44and this is another thing I've been writing about recently,
1:45:47but all sorts of complexity with the assumptions of macOS
1:45:52in terms of assumptions like that stuff can run
1:45:55in the background and that you can install apps
1:45:58from outside the App Store and that you have direct access
1:46:03to the actual file system.
1:46:06And people mix that up, right?
1:46:08Like the Files app on iOS could get so much better
1:46:13and still never actually show you the actual file system
1:46:20of the device, and I don't think it ever should, right?
1:46:23It's, 'cause it is conceptually better and cleaner
1:46:28to only show the user, here are the files
1:46:32that are actual files that you create and read
1:46:36and diddle with, and all of the stuff,
1:46:39like the actual binaries for your application
1:46:42and stuff like that, and the actual operating system
1:46:45aren't even visible.
1:46:47That's a much better and cleaner design
1:46:49for people who aren't developers
1:46:51and actually aren't working at that level.
1:46:53And the Files app has gotten a lot better,
1:46:59and I think it really, it's obviously an area
1:47:01where it can continue to get better
1:47:03without being mapped to the literal file system.
1:47:07And I think it's such a better design.
1:47:10- Yeah.
1:47:13- All right, before we go on--
1:47:14- I also like it.
1:47:16- Before we go on with multitasking,
1:47:17let me do the third and final sponsor,
1:47:18and then we will run out the clock on multitasking.
1:47:22But our third and final sponsor of the show is Linode.
1:47:25Oh, do I love this company too.
1:47:27Whether you're working on a personal project
1:47:29or managing your enterprise's infrastructure,
1:47:30Linode has the pricing support and scale you need to take your project to the next level.
1:47:35It's a hosting company.
1:47:36It's where you host websites.
1:47:38It's where I host Daring Fireball, and I love it.
1:47:41They have 11 data centers worldwide, including their newest in Sydney, Australia.
1:47:46They have enterprise-grade hardware, S3-compatible, API-wise, storage options, and everything.
1:47:55Of course, it's all modern.
1:47:57SSD storage across the board.
1:47:5940 gigabit networking, industry leading processors,
1:48:04their revamped cloud manager,
1:48:06that's just the fancy way of saying
1:48:08the web-based interface to your account.
1:48:10It's an open source single page app, cloud.lenode.com.
1:48:14It is fantastic, it is absolutely great in every single way.
1:48:18Hey, what if you're like a super nerd
1:48:20and you want like API access to your servers?
1:48:24Look, you get root access, they have an API
1:48:27a Python command line interface full documentation at developers.lenode.com. Really just fantastic
1:48:35if you're a super nerd who knows even knows what it means to have a Python command line
1:48:40interface library to the server. And their plans, this is great you think, but how much does it cost?
1:48:47Well guess what? Their Nanode plan, that's Linode plus Nano for being small, N-A-N-O-D-E, starts as
1:48:53low as five bucks a month. And it's a really credible plan with like a gigabyte of memory,
1:49:00and you can really go a long way with that. And it scales from that nanode plan, which
1:49:05is just five bucks a month, scales all the way up to dedicated CPU plans with physical
1:49:11cores reserved just for you with no CPU steal, if that's how high performance you need
1:49:17your stuff to be. They also have GPU computing plans that are suitable for AI and machine
1:49:23learning and video processing, of course, which always goes through the GPU to be efficient.
1:49:28All sorts of stuff like that. One-click installs of most of the popular apps, including stuff like
1:49:35WordPress, game servers for Minecraft, stuff like that, and more. Anything that you think might be a
1:49:43one-click install for your own custom server, they've got it at Linode. So use this promo code
1:49:49Talk Show 2020. Talk Show 2020. When you create your new Linode account and you get $20 credit
1:49:56towards your next project with that $5 a month plan, that's four free months. And one last thing,
1:50:02they're hiring. Go to linode.com/careers if you're like a sysadmin type and find out more.
1:50:08Once again, linode.com/the-talk-show is the URL. Linode.com/the-talk-show and the promo code
1:50:18to save 20 bucks is talk show 2020. All right, the multitasking thing. So, Ryan, who works with you at
1:50:28Mac Stories, what's his last name? I don't remember it. Christopher. Christopher. He had a really good
1:50:34article, and I linked to it, and I promised a fuller response, which I haven't finished yet. I
1:50:39am working on it, but I can talk about it here. But he had a proposal that I think was really good,
1:50:44And it tackled some of the issues I mentioned, which is that I think it's just so incredibly
1:50:48frustrating that the way that you get the first app on screen is the obvious way, which shouldn't
1:50:54change. You see the app and you tap the icon and it opens and it's full screen. And the way you
1:50:58get the second app on screen is totally different. His idea for managing some of this is to use
1:51:06contextual menus. And I have a couple of, I've thought about it. I have a couple of problems
1:51:11with that. One is I think that at a fundamental level, contextual menus should always be a
1:51:19shortcut to something for which there's another way to do it. And unless I'm overlooking something,
1:51:29on the Mac, you know, contextual menus are what you get when you right-click or control-click
1:51:35is if you want to, you know, control-clicking is a long—dating back to the era when Macs
1:51:40only had one button mice from Apple.
1:51:42Control click is always a synonym for right clicking.
1:51:46I don't think there's anything you can do on the Mac
1:51:50in a contextual menu that there isn't another way to do it.
1:51:55If there's an exception to that, I'd love to hear it,
1:51:58but I can't think of one,
1:52:00and I've been trying to think of one recently.
1:52:02Whereas Ryan's proposal would make certain things
1:52:06contextual menu only.
1:52:08And maybe that's true.
1:52:09You know, and iPad OS is different than Mac OS, and contextual menus on iPad OS are different,
1:52:14because now, like, you have to tap and hold to get to what I call "jiggle mode" to rearrange
1:52:20your icons on the home screen, and that's really only accessible through a contextual menu.
1:52:25And one of the reasons— But even in files, but even in files— So the main difference,
1:52:31I think, is that on iPad, some actions are context menu only.
1:52:37- Right, it is a little different,
1:52:38so maybe it would fit better.
1:52:40I just feel though that it's still, at a broader sense,
1:52:46I still feel that his contextual menu idea
1:52:49is still too indirect.
1:52:51Like if I have two apps open on my iPad at once,
1:52:56and one's on the left and one's on the right,
1:52:59and I would like to swap them and put the one
1:53:02on the one side on the other,
1:53:04you can just drag it over, right?
1:53:06you can just drag the one on the left over to the right,
1:53:10which is what you think would happen.
1:53:12I think way more of the multitasking features
1:53:15in the iPad should be like that,
1:53:17where you just do the obvious thing
1:53:19and you tap on a certain area,
1:53:21and maybe the difference would be
1:53:23that they would have to add some,
1:53:27for lack of a better word, window chrome,
1:53:29even though they're not windows.
1:53:31A window is a thing that floats around
1:53:33and you can drag it anywhere you want.
1:53:34I think it's actually a better idea for most people, in most cases, to have, for lack of
1:53:41a better word, a tile interface.
1:53:44Like that's one of the things that I feel like Apple is even struggling with.
1:53:46I don't think they know what to call things on iPadOS.
1:53:49They call things windows that to me aren't windows.
1:53:53Right.
1:53:54Yeah.
1:53:55Yeah, I think it's more, in fact, it's more descriptive in the API where they call them
1:54:00scenes.
1:54:01Right.
1:54:02That's a better name for it because they're not windows.
1:54:05They are multiple scenes for the same application.
1:54:07I think it actually makes more sense.
1:54:09- Right.
1:54:10- Yeah.
1:54:11- So like in Safari, you say new tab,
1:54:14you're on the iPad and you say new tab,
1:54:17it's very, everybody gets exactly what you think.
1:54:19You get a thing that looks like a tab
1:54:20and if you're used to tabs on Mac OS or Windows
1:54:25or Chrome OS or anywhere else where there's tabs
1:54:28in a browser, you get a thing now that looks like a tab
1:54:32in a browser, whereas what they're calling Windows
1:54:34don't look like Windows anywhere else.
1:54:37And I feel like it's just, it's like the confusion
1:54:41of the concept as it currently stands leaking out
1:54:44into the language they choose to use to describe it.
1:54:47I just think that it should be a lot more direct.
1:54:51And that concept I linked to earlier this week
1:54:55from a kid, I call him a kid, he's 21, on Twitter.
1:55:00You know, where it more or less,
1:55:02and I don't know if that's the right decision,
1:55:03but I do, I saw a lot of people on Twitter
1:55:06who seem to like it, but the idea is that, you know,
1:55:09you kinda turn, if you wanna have two apps on screen at once
1:55:12it kind of, his concept to put it in
1:55:15as short of a few words as possible,
1:55:17kinda turns each half of the screen into an iPad Mini.
1:55:21And so if you like go up, if you have two apps at once
1:55:24and you zip one up from the bottom, you know,
1:55:26like the home screen shortcut,
1:55:28you get a miniature version of your whole home screen
1:55:30the right half of the screen and you can just tap another app and it takes that half of
1:55:34the screen. Is that the right solution? I don't know, but something along those lines
1:55:40though feels so much more natural to me and it feels more iPad-like.
1:55:49So what I think is happening now is if you remember when SplitView first came out in
1:55:55in 2015 with iOS 9, the way that you used to invoke a secondary app used to be that
1:56:04you would swipe from the right edge of the display and you would get this scrollable
1:56:09list of icons. And those icons in theory were like your recently used apps. And you would
1:56:16tap one and it would come in in split view. And we had that system for a couple of years
1:56:22and at some point we all started wishing for some kind of different picker view.
1:56:31And at the time, and this is like 2016, so we're talking iOS 10, before 11 came out,
1:56:39there were all kinds of concepts.
1:56:40I even commissioned one of them.
1:56:43I still have the video on Mac stories.
1:56:45I remember this.
1:56:47envisioning like what if the right side of the screen was more like a home screen?
1:56:52And you would have like a grid of icons and you could search the icons and then you would
1:56:56tap, just like you tap on home screen, you would tap and you would bring in the secondary
1:57:00app.
1:57:01And then iOS 11 comes out and WWDC 2017, Apple announces this new system and they swing in
1:57:09a completely different direction and they're like, what if we took this idea of direct
1:57:15manipulation and we just went nuts with it. So anything like you want to multitask, you
1:57:21can just drag things around and you pick up the icon and you bring it into a space and
1:57:26you create a split view and all of that. And so they took this idea of like on iPad, there's
1:57:32direct manipulation, there's multitouch, so why not build multitasking around it? And
1:57:38And I think now, a couple of years have passed, and iPadOS is now a thing, and you can actually
1:57:45do more. You can have multiple apps in SlideOver, you can have multiple windows, but we're back
1:57:51at square one and we're saying, "Well, but what if you actually had a simplified picker
1:57:57for SplitView?" So I think at some point they just need to do it, because it seems to be
1:58:02like this cycle that goes on forever. And Apple maybe eventually comes up with another
1:58:08solution but maybe people just want to have some kind of home screen, some kind of launcher
1:58:14that is consistent with the actual home screen. Because the other systems, and I say this
1:58:21as somebody who really likes the current system, but maybe it's not that I like it so much
1:58:26that I know it well. And I think even if I know it well and even if I can work my way
1:58:33around it, I know that it's flawed. It works for somebody like me, but I know that it's
1:58:39not the best solution for other people. And I think at some point they just need to do
1:58:44it. And maybe a home screen is a solution. Maybe some kind of different grid view is
1:58:50a solution, but the current system is more, maybe it's more fancy than it needs to be,
1:58:57right? Oh yeah, you can pick up anything and if you drop it here, it becomes slide over,
1:59:04and if you drop it there, it becomes split view. And it's fine for people like me, but
1:59:08it's not great for everybody else.
1:59:11The craziest thing about it, and I really think this is undeniably true, and this is
1:59:16why I love reading your stuff about it is that you as you know an iPad
1:59:20aficionado you know you're perfectly willing to admit it is it to me it's
1:59:26crazy that that to be a power user on the iPad is more complicated than to be
1:59:34a power user at the equivalent level and do the same things on the Mac like it
1:59:38should not be that way it should be easier on the iPad like the Mac is has
1:59:43this historical cruft. You know, like I said, like just a perfect little stupid
1:59:48example, like when you select an app or a file in the Finder and you hit the
1:59:53return key, people expect it to open if they're not longtime Mac users, but
1:59:58that's not what happens. You're renaming the file and you have to
2:00:02hit command down or command open. Like, the Mac has a whole arm's length long
2:00:07list of stuff like that that really should never change because it's too
2:00:11historically baked in and there's a reason for it being the way it is, or the whole double, you know,
2:00:20way double, I wrote about this, like that you double click applications to launch them on the
2:00:25Mac because single clicking selects it and it's worth it, you know. The official way double clicking
2:00:33historically it was a shortcut.
2:00:37The official way, like in 1984, to open an application
2:00:41was to click on it, to select it,
2:00:43go up to the file menu and hit open.
2:00:46'Cause that, everything was sort of like through the,
2:00:51the commands were in the file menu or in the menu bar,
2:00:55and then everything else was a shortcut.
2:00:57So there were keyboard shortcuts like command O
2:00:59as a shortcut for file open,
2:01:01and then they added a mouse shortcut,
2:01:03which is, well, what if you want to just skip the whole file menu and you're an advanced
2:01:07user, you could just double-click the item.
2:01:09Well, everybody, you know, it ends up that's so much more convenient.
2:01:13Nobody selects an item and goes up to the file menu and hits open.
2:01:18But then we wound up with a generation of people who think you have to double-click
2:01:21links in a web browser because they think you double-clicked to open stuff.
2:01:29I love Mac OS and I love the Mac and I am so, so proficient in it, but I'm perfectly willing to admit it is a target that the iPad should be able to surpass in almost every regard for almost every user as just using it system.
2:01:50Yeah, I agree with that. It should empower everyone, not just people like me.
2:01:56Yeah.
2:01:56And it's complicated to say that you can drag an,
2:02:01how do you move an icon from your first home screen
2:02:04to your second screen?
2:02:05Well, you drag it.
2:02:07But dragging the icon is also the way
2:02:09that you make it a split screen app.
2:02:11It makes sense when you understand the context
2:02:17of how you start those drags, but that sort of,
2:02:20hey, just dragging the app icon
2:02:23does these two entirely different things.
2:02:26One of them is moving it,
2:02:28the other one is opening it up into a window in split view
2:02:32or what's it called?
2:02:36- Slide over. - Slide over.
2:02:37That's the sort of thing I'm talking about
2:02:41where to understand that makes you
2:02:43understanding more complexity than the Mac user
2:02:46needs to understand to do the equivalent thing.
2:02:49- Yeah, and look, I don't disagree with that.
2:02:52And I think what I was saying before,
2:02:54like I don't wanna lose the current options
2:02:56because as a pro user,
2:02:59I do enjoy like the freedom that this system gives me
2:03:04in the sense that I can, because I know how it works,
2:03:08I can choose exactly where I want to drop an icon
2:03:11and how I wanna make it a split view.
2:03:14Like I know all the little, sorry.
2:03:17I know all the little like hidden tricks of it.
2:03:21Like if you drop an icon toward the upper edge of the display,
2:03:26it becomes a full screen window.
2:03:29And like all these little things I know,
2:03:31but like how would you even expose them to regular folks?
2:03:35And I don't think that an onboarding process,
2:03:39when you're setting up an event for the first time,
2:03:41like those three pages,
2:03:43I don't think those are nearly enough,
2:03:45even with the short video that you see at setup.
2:03:49And what really surprises me, though, is that certain--
2:03:56and you brought this up on during Fireball multiple times.
2:03:59There have been design issues with the current multitasking
2:04:03system on iPad.
2:04:05And before doing this episode, I actually
2:04:08went back and checked on Mac stories.
2:04:10And these are issues that I mentioned all the way back
2:04:13in 2015 in my iOS 9 review.
2:04:17try and tell which side of a split view is as keyboard focus at any given moment.
2:04:23And they sort of, quote unquote, made it better in 13 by slightly changing the color
2:04:32of the pill shaped indicator at the top of a split view.
2:04:36But good luck trying to tell the difference between two very similar shades of gray,
2:04:41if you can. And that's one of them.
2:04:44And the other design problem is there's such a tiny difference,
2:04:49like visually speaking, between dropping an icon
2:04:53and it becomes a split view item, and dropping an icon
2:04:57and it becomes a slide over item.
2:04:59And basically the difference is you've
2:05:00got to take a look at the corner radius of the window
2:05:03to tell who came up with that.
2:05:06But also, how was it not fixed like five years later?
2:05:11And so, yeah, there's like, it needs to empower everybody,
2:05:16and it does, you shouldn't have to read a manual
2:05:20or a review to know how it works.
2:05:23- So basically, just to wrap up,
2:05:25I really do, and I think we're exactly on the same page,
2:05:27I just think that the iPadOS needs
2:05:30a little bit more visual affordances, you know?
2:05:33- Yes. - And close buttons, right?
2:05:36Like, how do you close, if you're in an app
2:05:39with multiple documents, how do you close a thing?
2:05:41Well, why isn't that a standard?
2:05:43Why isn't there a red button?
2:05:45And I really do think, and I don't wanna pin it all
2:05:48on Johnny Ive's shoulders, but I kind of wanna just pin it
2:05:50all on Johnny Ive's shoulders, is that I feel that
2:05:54in the post Johnny Ive is in control of all UI,
2:05:59which is from iOS 7 forward, I feel like Apple
2:06:03has always erred on the side of minimalism too far.
2:06:08that they're just it there should be more that you can do by just seeing a thing on screen and
2:06:15being able to
2:06:18poke it with your finger and touch it to close it or touch it to drag it or touch it to move it and
2:06:24Just a little bit not a lot just a little
2:06:27And and you know
2:06:29Like I said the one of the things that the iPad OS already gets right is if you have two apps
2:06:33split screen left and right, you can swap them
2:06:36by just dragging it over, and that's perfect,
2:06:40but I just feel like there should be more like that.
2:06:43- Yeah, yeah, I agree with that.
2:06:45It's not a scene to have buttons
2:06:49or other visual affordances to,
2:06:51once again, it's great that we have these hidden gestures,
2:06:56but it's not so great for other people.
2:06:59- No, and they should be shortcuts,
2:07:01and I feel like there should be a lot more
2:07:03exposed and maybe you have to take more steps to do it the visual one finger away, tapping
2:07:09the thing you see on screen, and that a multi-fingered gesture or shortcut can be a shortcut for
2:07:14it for power users, but there should still be a way that you can get there visually.
2:07:20Yeah.
2:07:22My final question to you before we wrap up is do you regret naming the website MacStories?
2:07:29Well, I get asked this a lot, surprisingly. I really don't, because it's… No, look,
2:07:44I'm honest. I really don't, because it's… At some point, like five years ago, I considered,
2:07:51like, I should change the name of this website, because it's not who I am anymore. But then
2:07:58It was a combination of, well now, a lot of people know the website as Mac Stories, and
2:08:04like, it's, you know, it gets linked in a bunch of places, do you really want to change
2:08:08the name of the site?
2:08:10But also, it's a nostalgic thing, like it tells me, it's sort of like, in the name I
2:08:17see that kind of evolutionary path, like I started on the Mac, right?
2:08:24I started writing about Apple because I got my first Macbook, and I wanted to write about
2:08:28And so there's a nostalgic component in that.
2:08:32And maybe I do regret the fact that the name does not fully describe who I am at this point.
2:08:40The site of the most advanced, most eloquent, most proficient iPad OS power user on the web today.
2:08:48I laugh because there is a certain charm to it. That's what I'm trying to say.
2:08:53Yeah, it's like a scar.
2:08:55And it's not like you don't write about the Mac anymore.
2:08:58And your colleagues, you know, there's a whole assortment of people there like John Voorhees
2:09:02and Ryan who we talked about and others who collaborate with you there.
2:09:06And it's not like you don't write about the Mac.
2:09:09Yeah.
2:09:10And also, yes, I keep it, I like to keep it like this because it's kind of funny.
2:09:16You can find a lot of like shortcut stuff and iPad stuff and the website's name is Mac
2:09:21Stories.
2:09:22I think it's kind of funny.
2:09:23Well, it is one of my favorite websites.
2:09:25I thank you.
2:09:26I waited way too long to invite you
2:09:27to be on the show, Federico.
2:09:29It has been an absolute delight.
2:09:30My wife is looking forward to this.
2:09:33She very seldom listens to my show,
2:09:35but she said that she cannot wait to hear your episode
2:09:38because she just enjoys listening to your voice.
2:09:41- Last year, I first met her last year,
2:09:43I think officially in person,
2:09:45and she kept saying, "Please keep talking."
2:09:48(laughing)
2:09:49Because I wanna listen to your accent forever.
2:09:53I just kept talking.
2:09:54I think what she wants, she's gonna text my editor, Caleb,
2:09:58and have like a, can she get a cut of this podcast
2:10:01where it just cuts my shit out.
2:10:02- I'm so sorry, John.
2:10:05- Oh, well, it's all right.
2:10:06I mean.
2:10:07- But thanks for having me on, though.
2:10:09It's been a pleasure.
2:10:10- Well, it won't be the last time.
2:10:12Everybody, of course, I just mentioned it,
2:10:14macstories.net.
2:10:17Hey, .net party, you know.
2:10:19- .net, always, yeah. - Yeah, fist bump.
2:10:21(laughing)
2:10:24You said you were thinking about changing it
2:10:25in the name of Max Stories.
2:10:26Somebody asked me if I ever thought about changing
2:10:28Daring Fireball to daringfireball.com.
2:10:30I own daringfireball.com.
2:10:31No, I am not going to change it.
2:10:34But that's neither here nor there.
2:10:39Although if I did, I would use hover sponsor
2:10:41of the website to do it.
2:10:42- Of course.
2:10:43- So anyway, my thanks to you, Federico.
2:10:45Everybody can read you and your team's fine work
2:10:47at maxstories.net.
2:10:48We will stay tuned for news on the iPad,
2:10:51and I will thank our sponsors this week,
2:10:53Feels, where you can get CBD delivered to your house.
2:10:56We had Hover, which I just mentioned,
2:11:01where you can register and manage your domain names,
2:11:03and Linode, the web server hosting company
2:11:07that hosts Daring Fireball,
2:11:09and I couldn't be happier with them.
2:11:11Thanks.
2:11:13You can say thanks too, if you want.
2:11:18- Yeah. (laughing)
2:11:19Thank you, Jon.
2:11:20(laughing)