Podcast Search

The Talk Show

277: ‘Polish Stink Eye’ With John Moltz

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00have a good story. It's why I'm late. Just two hours and fifteen minutes.

0:00:07Just two hours and fifteen minutes. Well, number one, you were gracious enough. I told you,

0:00:11we scheduled this this afternoon, and I had a furniture delivery scheduled for a one to five

0:00:17window. And I said, "You said I'm kind of flexible." And I said, "Thank God." And I said,

0:00:25I'll bet you they show up at 4.59.

0:00:28Pretty close, right?

0:00:31I think they showed up at 4.40.

0:00:33Yeah, yeah. 20 minutes before the window closed.

0:00:37Yeah.

0:00:38Which, you know, okay, they made it.

0:00:41Well, but here's the thing. It's nerve-wracking, because we're having renovations done on the

0:00:47downstairs. Like, my office is downstairs, and we've been here for a couple years, and we've

0:00:52We'd never really done my office.

0:00:55That was like to be done later.

0:00:56And we had the stairs painted.

0:01:00I mean, just painted.

0:01:01I mean, like so just painted

0:01:04that the painters are still painting my office,

0:01:08but they've already done the stairs.

0:01:11And we have the, I love this guy.

0:01:15His name is Oleg.

0:01:16He was born in Poland,

0:01:19and he is the greatest painter, house painter

0:01:22you would ever want because he's obviously got

0:01:25like Ted Williams 20/40 vision, right?

0:01:29Like, you know, this guy can spot like a flaw

0:01:34on a wall or a ceiling all the way across the room.

0:01:38And he'll be like, "Oh, that was, you know, a patch."

0:01:42The guy is an absolute perfectionist,

0:01:44but he works fast, right?

0:01:48Like, it's like the ideal combination.

0:01:50- Right.

0:01:51every day on time, and he's just a delightful, delightful man, and he does meticulous work,

0:01:58but works fast, right? Like, I'm a perfectionist. I love being a perfectionist. You know what I

0:02:03don't do? I don't work fast. No. [Laughter]

0:02:06Pete: Yeah, right. You usually do not see that, both of those in the same person, yeah.

0:02:10Pete; Right.

0:02:10Pete; We had great guys. We had our basement redone again, and these guys were Russians,

0:02:16and they were fantastic. They weren't—they're not perfectionists, but they were certainly good

0:02:21enough for the basement, and they were quite fast. So, that was good.

0:02:25Pete: Well, Oleg was still here and was here to watch the guys delivering this big piece of

0:02:32furniture up the stairs and let them know that he just painted the walls and gave them his Polish

0:02:40stink eye as they brought it up the stairs, and they have to say they did a great job.

0:02:45But anyway, that's number one why I'm late, because I had to wait for this furniture delivery, and I

0:02:50told Amy that I would take care of it, and I did. And then I thought, "Well,

0:02:56why don't I go get coffee?" My local coffee place is about five minutes away. I told you it would be

0:03:03five minutes, because Amy wanted a coffee too, and she likes a caramel macchiato thing that you can't

0:03:09make at home. And I thought, "Wouldn't that be a nice treat for her, because I'm going to disappear

0:03:13here for two hours to do a podcast. I'll go out. And it's very cold today. It is negative 43 degrees

0:03:21here in Philadelphia. 36 degrees. But I think the feels-like is negative 40. I don't have the feels-like

0:03:28on, but that's what it feels like. But I thought this—wouldn't that be a nice thing to do? You know,

0:03:32it's, you know, it's what you do for your wife. You do nice things. Yeah. I mean, look at me,

0:03:38husband of the year. I bought her a coffee. Right? And it's only February. Yeah. Right.

0:03:43You can take the rest of the year off.

0:03:44All right. So, I think five minutes, which that's normal for getting a coffee. Well,

0:03:55I'm at the coffee shop waiting for the macchiato and my mom calls.

0:03:59My dad—

0:04:03That's not going to take five minutes.

0:04:05My dad handed her his iPad and she said, "And the thing at the top that you drag down

0:04:13was already down and I touched something and it went into dark mode."

0:04:17Now, why he handed her the iPad while control center was down, I don't know.

0:04:25But what I did is I thought, "Well, I know how to fix this." I was like,

0:04:31unfortunately, you know, none of the things in control center are labeled. They're all just icons.

0:04:37And I'm not quite sure how to describe the dark mode icon, right? It's a circle that's half dark

0:04:45and the other half is inverted. I don't know if that's good enough for my mom. And I thought,

0:04:51"I got it. I'll just show her on my phone." And I pulled down mine. I said, "Look, I'll just text

0:04:56you the answer, standby." And I got off the phone, pulled down my control center, took a screenshot,

0:05:01took out the markup tools, and drew like a red circle around the dark mode icon, and said this.

0:05:09And then I texted it to her. She calls back as I'm on my way home. Dad doesn't have that icon.

0:05:18And I said, "Well, but that's," I said, "But this, that whole control center with all these

0:05:26think she goes yes i know that this that's what it was and it was open when he handed me the ipad

0:05:31and i touched something and put it into dark mode and i said well then he has to have that icon

0:05:37i said the colors might be reversed because it's you know don't don't it may not look exactly the

0:05:43same because the screenshot i sent you was light mode and then i'm suddenly cursing myself for not

0:05:48not having to put my phone into dark mode

0:05:50(laughing)

0:05:51before taking the screenshot, right?

0:05:53And I wanna, I want to, I emphasize here,

0:05:57my mom is a very smart woman.

0:05:59She's a very bright woman, but she is very, very

0:06:03not good with computers. (laughs)

0:06:05- Yeah. - And very,

0:06:06she lacks confidence in them, and that's the thing.

0:06:09As like, if she-- - Yeah, well, I think,

0:06:10yeah, that's the huge difference, right?

0:06:11- If she would just try, she could figure it out, but.

0:06:14- Yeah. (sighs)

0:06:17- Well, eventually, and this took several minutes,

0:06:21I'll skip it, I figure out that his phone,

0:06:24or his iPad was not in dark mode.

0:06:26She had turned the brightness all the way down.

0:06:30- Oh.

0:06:31(laughing)

0:06:33- With, but she's the one who mentioned dark mode.

0:06:36I actually, now that I think about it,

0:06:39I don't think she actually has any idea

0:06:42what capital D-- - What dark mode is.

0:06:44- Yeah, capital D, capital M, dark mode is.

0:06:47It's just a comedy of errors

0:06:50that she literally chose the words dark mode

0:06:53to describe what happens when you turn an iPad's brightness

0:06:57all the way down.

0:06:58And then I said, "Oh, okay."

0:07:02It's the brightness.

0:07:05- Yeah, there's like another screenshot.

0:07:07- Well, I didn't take a screenshot

0:07:09'cause at this point I was like overdue.

0:07:11I was already home.

0:07:12I had given Amy her coffee

0:07:14and I'm just packing up my MacBook to take it down

0:07:18to this, you know, my podcast cave to do this with you.

0:07:20And I'm already a little embarrassed

0:07:22because I've put you out longer than we're gonna record,

0:07:26which is actually, you know, possibly a long time.

0:07:29And I said, it's a larger button.

0:07:32It's like a capsule-shaped button,

0:07:35double the height of the regular buttons,

0:07:39and it has an icon that looks like the sun,

0:07:41and it's a slider, just drag it up.

0:07:43And she goes, "He doesn't have that one."

0:07:45(laughing)

0:07:48And she said, "He has a moon, he doesn't have a sun."

0:07:52And at this point, Amy's like dying of laughter.

0:07:55And she says, "It's right next to the moon."

0:08:00And I said, "Yes, it's right next to the moon."

0:08:04And she goes, "No."

0:08:05And I said, "Well, you probably can't see the sun icon

0:08:10very well because you have it all the way down in the bottom."

0:08:13the way down past it. And she goes, "No!" And I said, "I'm telling you, there's an oblong button,

0:08:20double the height of the moon." I said, "You see the moon one?" "Yes." "To the right, there's

0:08:26another button. It is twice the height of it. It's probably all dark. Just put your finger on it and

0:08:33slide up." And then she did it, and it solved all the problems. And she's very gracious. And

0:08:39And that is why I'm like-- because my mom put my dad's iPad in dark mode.

0:08:43Yeah.

0:08:44I didn't realize if you long press that, it opens up and gives you dark mode

0:08:49on and off and night shift on and off.

0:08:51I didn't know that.

0:08:53There we go.

0:08:53There's a hot tip.

0:08:54I just tried that.

0:08:55So she could have turned on dark mode, even though his icon wasn't on there.

0:08:58How about that?

0:08:59So you don't need the dark mode.

0:09:01No, yeah, because it's already there.

0:09:02I mean, you have to long press, but that's not--

0:09:05There we go.

0:09:05--a good deal.

0:09:06Well, there's the talk show tip of the week.

0:09:08[laughter]

0:09:11How you doing, Jon?

0:09:12I'm fine. Yeah. It's a beautiful day here. It's not—it's, I think it's like 55 today.

0:09:19It's sunny like crazy.

0:09:21We've been all over the—you know what? It was very cold here, but it was sunny,

0:09:25which is, you know, that's all you can ask for in February on the East Coast. And we've had

0:09:28the most remarkably mild winter you could imagine. We've had some cold weather, but we have had

0:09:34zero snow, zero ice. Like, I just realized, you know, 'cause some of this renovation work we're

0:09:41having, we're letting them use our garage, you know, to store stuff around our car, and so it's

0:09:48like, it's like an obstacle course. And I thought that's where we keep the rock salt. And I was just

0:09:55reading an article about, "Hey, how come the East Coast hasn't had any snow?" And I thought,

0:10:00"Hey, shoot, where's the snow? Where's the salt?" And then I realized, you know what, forget it. I

0:10:06don't even care where it is. Because I remember last year, I ran out of salt, and it was a bad

0:10:11storm. And I just went to around the corner—this is the advantage of living in the city—I just

0:10:17walked around the corner, and they had like plenty of it. And I thought, "Well, there's my salt.

0:10:21I'll just buy it."

0:10:22Tim Cynova Just store it there.

0:10:23Dave

0:10:28store. Oh, that's why they call it a store.

0:10:30Pete: Right. And I just remember thinking when I went to buy it, you know, it's like,

0:10:35you know, buying an umbrella in a rainstorm. It's like, either they're gonna gouge

0:10:39me or they're gonna be out, but it was wonderful. They had like, they had like an entire pallet

0:10:44piled up with it. They were like ready for everybody in the neighborhood to need salt.

0:10:48I was like, "Oh, so I don't have to worry about it." But anyway, it just got me thinking

0:10:52that we have had a very strange winter here on the East Coast.

0:10:56Yeah, I mean, I guess I can't complain

0:10:59I mean, it's like if we're gonna have screwed up climate and destroy the entire planet for all life

0:11:04At the very least. I haven't had to shovel any snow. I

0:11:08Get yeah, I guess yeah

0:11:11Is that

0:11:15Is that a thing that we should be happy about

0:11:17Well, I guess does that does that really make it better?

0:11:21But I mean, maybe it makes it better in the short term, but I'm long term. It doesn't make it

0:11:24Well, everybody said, well, I guess everybody says that, you know, calling it global warming was sort of a mistake at the beginning.

0:11:30Climate change is a better term.

0:11:31Because that sounds good.

0:11:32Right, and one of the side effects has nothing to do with the temperature.

0:11:37Well, it's caused by the temperature.

0:11:38Overall, it is global warming. It's like a one or two centigrade increase over time,

0:11:44and that's enough to cause all sorts of havoc with ice caps melting, and extra water, and sea levels rising, and currents changing,

0:11:52and all of these weird things, including, as predicted, the increase in extreme/weird

0:11:59weather. Bigger, worse hurricanes and tsunamis and stuff like that. And just weird weather,

0:12:06like dry, you know, these droughts that are plaguing California with these terrible fires

0:12:11and etc. etc. So, you know, and again, it could just be, you know, there have been, you know,

0:12:18like in my childhood, weird winters where there was never any snow, which felt like a ripoff,

0:12:23you know?

0:12:23Jared: Yeah. It always felt like, yeah, I feel like when I was a kid, I felt like,

0:12:27I mean, looking back on it in my memory, it was like it started snowing the first day of November

0:12:33and it snowed all the way through the first day of April.

0:12:37Pete: Right.

0:12:37Jared; Which, of course, was not true in any regard, but, you know, in Connecticut,

0:12:42we got some good snows and made some big snow forts too. But we don't get that much here in

0:12:50Washington. Although we've had some snow, I think Hank has had a couple of snow days this year

0:12:55already. Probably won't have any more, but still, we don't usually get a lot of snow.

0:13:01And that's, you know, and it's not to say that it was a lot, but it's just that they don't have,

0:13:06we can't handle it out here. So, when we get any snow, they usually get the day off.

0:13:11Pete: Hmm. So, how you been? I guess I asked that already?

0:13:16John: Yeah, you did, but I'm still fine.

0:13:18Pete and John laugh

0:13:20John in the three minutes since you asked me last, I'm still fine.

0:13:23It's a good thing that your mom didn't have a question about multitasking on the iPad.

0:13:36Pete You know what? I've told, did I, was this on the podcast or when I wrote it? I wrote about

0:13:40it. She did have problems with it. And she did. She had profound problems with it. And to me,

0:13:47exhibit A in the case against the multitasking interface as it stands and having it on by default,

0:13:56where she's a prototypical, very simple iPad user who really just uses Safari mail messages

0:14:05and you know maybe some games although i think yeah yeah she plays like words with friends and

0:14:11like a handful of games but i safari lots she's an avid reader consumer of news uh mail and uh

0:14:19messages and somehow going from mail where she and she's one of these she likes to sign up for like

0:14:27newsletters from cnn and and stuff like that i mean that's which you know i guess that's why

0:14:32why they offer them, but somehow would continuously wind up with two instances of Safari, including

0:14:41one that was in the sidebar, you know, and not having no idea how to get out of it. And

0:14:46she found the setting in general, settings general, you know, home screen and multitasking,

0:14:53I think is the section. It's not even inaccessibility. It's like in the home screen and, you know,

0:14:58multiple apps or something like that and she turned it off and now her iPad works exactly

0:15:03as she wants it to.

0:15:04Tim Weiss That's good. So she didn't have to call you

0:15:10then?

0:15:11Dave Asprey No. I got a couple of things. You see the

0:15:16agenda? I'm actually somewhat organized.

0:15:18Tim Weiss Oh, yeah. Yeah.

0:15:20Dave Asprey I guess we should start with the sad news,

0:15:22right? Larry Tesler died unexpectedly.

0:15:25Tim Weiss Yeah.

0:15:26What's sad news? 75? 74. 74. And it was sort of unexpected. They didn't say what the

0:15:34cause was. I saw, I think it was the New York Times obituary from John Markoff

0:15:38said that he, his wife said they didn't know what caused his death, but that he

0:15:43had, he apparently had a bicycle accident a few years back and had never quite

0:15:48been right since. And I guess they, you know, I don't know, I don't want to read

0:15:53into it, but terribly sad. Too soon, you know. But what a career and what an influence on

0:16:01the Mac interface. I mean, I had a couple of links on Daring Fireball about his influence,

0:16:06but it's so odd to me. And again, it's, you know, I don't want to make it all about me.

0:16:10It's Larry Tesler who died. But it's so odd that I really have been thinking a lot about

0:16:16him because I've been thinking and writing so much about this iPad multitasking stuff.

0:16:20and it really did occur to me before he died this week

0:16:24that his no modes mantra is sort of at the root

0:16:28of my complaint about the multitasking,

0:16:31where it feels like going into a different mode

0:16:35for different things, like putting two apps

0:16:40into side-by-side mode.

0:16:43I mean, there's no other way to call it than a mode.

0:16:45It's so weird, because the first one,

0:16:47you just tap the icon, which so far, so good,

0:16:50And then to get that second one, you have to do a tap and a hold on the icon in the

0:16:56home tray or the dock, whatever you call it.

0:17:00Or as I found out from Avid iPad users, you can go to Spotlight and search for an app

0:17:06and from Spotlight, you can tap and hold the app to put it.

0:17:11So it doesn't have to be in the dock, which I erroneously thought, but seemingly 90% of

0:17:18people who even know what iPad multitasking is also thought that you had to have the app in the dock

0:17:23because you can't just do it from the app on the home screen. So that's weird that the one way to

0:17:29get an app, the way to get the first app in split screen is one way and the other is another way.

0:17:34So that's a mode. And then the weird way that like, if you have an instance of Safari next to

0:17:42messages and another instance of Safari next to notes, you have to go to an

0:17:48entirely different mode to see them both at the same time. You have to swipe up

0:17:53and go into that multitasking mode which sort of puts them in a three by two

0:17:59tiled arrangement that you can, you know, that makes it look like they're windows.

0:18:04But that the way that they're arranged isn't really spatially oriented in any

0:18:10way to the normal mode of using the iPad. Anyway, it's very modal, and I think it gets to the

0:18:17sort of heart of Tesla's life's work, arguing against modes.

0:18:22Yeah, I'm just playing with it right now.

0:18:26Because I was trying to figure out what you were talking about with Spotlight, because I've never

0:18:35even tried that. Yeah, isn't that weird? I mean, I wouldn't have guessed that you could do it from

0:18:39there but you can't do it from the home screen. I do think that's like the one thing that iPad

0:18:46multitasking as it stands today does get right is that if you have if you if you have successfully

0:18:55navigated the maze to get the piece of cheese to have two apps side by side on screen right let's

0:19:02Let's say you have notes on the left, Safari on the right, and you would like to switch

0:19:09them to be the other way around.

0:19:11You would like, you know, just take the one on the left, put it on the right, and have

0:19:15them go.

0:19:16You can actually do what you think you should be able to do, which is sort of tap in the

0:19:20dead space of the toolbar of one of the apps and hold, and then just drag it over, and

0:19:27it will do exactly what you think.

0:19:29But very little of iPad multitasking works that way,

0:19:33where you just tap on the thing, the window, the tile,

0:19:37whatever you wanna call it on screen, tap it, drag it over,

0:19:41and then the other one slides over to the other spot

0:19:43and does it, but very little of it works that way.

0:19:46- Yeah, and I am one of those people

0:19:48who has basically just given up on it.

0:19:51I mean, I haven't turned it off, and maybe I should,

0:19:56because I really don't use it,

0:19:57but the only times I initiate it are usually by accident.

0:20:01So yeah, I don't, so I don't use it.

0:20:04- I don't either, although I'm keeping,

0:20:07I still have it on because I wanna write so much about it.

0:20:10So like if it wasn't my,

0:20:13on my top of my mind to write about this,

0:20:15I would just turn that setting off

0:20:18and relish the simplicity of never having to worry

0:20:22about anything going into a second instance.

0:20:26And it is where I and again I there is something about my brain. Maybe it's age

0:20:32It might be you know, I write about this and it's inevitable that people start calling me the old, you know

0:20:36Whatever old man, you know because I'm the old guy who only understands the Macintosh

0:20:41But I do I keep forgetting that

0:20:46Like when you somehow either purposefully or accidentally wind up with two instances of Safari

0:20:53How do you get emerged back into one?

0:20:55and it has nothing to do with the system-wide multitasking interface it is

0:21:02it's like in the tabs button inside Safari you can press and hold the you

0:21:10know what I mean the tabs button mm-hmm yeah I think you can press and hold and

0:21:14if you have multiple instances you can yeah so you press and hold it and

0:21:19normally it just says like close all tabs close this tab open new window new

0:21:23private tab, new tab. But if you have multiple instances of

0:21:27Safari, you can say merge all windows, and it'll merge them.

0:21:30But which is great. So it's there. But I always forget how

0:21:34the hell to do it. Because I don't think to do it within

0:21:37Safari, I feel like I should be able to do it at the system

0:21:40level. Yeah. Because I feel like it should work the same way for

0:21:45all apps. Although I guess Safari is different, because it

0:21:47actually has tabs. And if you have two instances of notes

0:21:50open, how do you merge them because there's no way within one node. There's no tab interface.

0:21:57Yeah, right. You can't do it there. But the fact that none of that is consistent system-wide is

0:22:02the whole thing I'm arguing about. That this is not a small problem with a small solution. This

0:22:06is something that is fundamentally limited. That everything should be like Safari and have tabs or

0:22:12something like that. Again, it's not my job to come up with a solution, but it's my job to point

0:22:17out how problematic this is. I always forget. It's my job to remember stuff. I always forget.

0:22:25So there's my second, the talk show tip of the week. If you wind up with two Safari

0:22:31windows in iPad and don't want them, want them merged, go to one of them, go to the tabs button,

0:22:38press and hold, and there will be a merge all windows that'll do it. The good news is that

0:22:44it'll merge them in a way that is seemingly random in terms of the way the tabs show up

0:22:49next to each other. And so, you get to play a game. Where's that tab?

0:23:01Tim Cynova Find that tab.

0:23:02Dave Asprey Find that tab.

0:23:03Tim Cynova Yeah.

0:23:03Dave Asprey Which is, you know, it's a very fun game.

0:23:06It's really, it should be part of Apple Arcade in my opinion.

0:23:09Tim Cynova So it doesn't put it at the end.

0:23:11Dave Asprey If it does, it does.

0:23:13It just sticks it someplace in the middle? Is it doing it alphabetically?

0:23:17I don't know. I don't know. It doesn't seem rational to me. Maybe I'm wrong,

0:23:21but in my experience it doesn't seem rational.

0:23:24Is it a function of having opened—I mean, is it still—I wonder if it's still technically

0:23:30just another tab, and it has an index that's still in—and if you open more tabs, then they come

0:23:39after that one? I couldn't tell you.

0:23:43I couldn't tell you to test that several times to figure that out. Yeah, I couldn't tell you.

0:23:49Let me take a break and thank our first sponsor and I'm very excited. This is the first time

0:23:59they've sponsored the show. KOLIDE. K-O-L-I-D-E. I would have said KOLIDE. They've been sponsoring

0:24:08my website during Fireball for at least a year, maybe a little longer. They're a repeat sponsor

0:24:14on during Fireball, and I thank them for that. And I've been calling them "Colide" in my mind

0:24:19for a very long time. And then I was listening to the ATP podcast where they sponsored, and

0:24:28Marco said it was "Colide." And I thought, "Ooh!" And I—because I knew I had an upcoming—

0:24:34up coming out. I knew they were coming up. I knew they were coming up here on my show. And so,

0:24:39I emailed them and they were very nice to me, but they acted like it was the dumbest question

0:24:45they ever heard. But anyway. I would think that these advertisers would start getting to know you

0:24:51and start sending pronunciations in advance. Yeah, yeah. You know, like you would, you know,

0:24:57like a kindergarten reading program. Anyway, KOLIDE, K-O-L-I-D-E, they are a software as

0:25:06a service startup. And oh, here it is in the notes, pronounced KOLIDE. John, I swear to

0:25:12God, they did put this here. That is working to solve security challenges for tech companies

0:25:18that run large Mac fleets and use Slack. In the world of Mac management, the current accepted

0:25:24practice is to buy an MDM and then use it to lock down devices so users can only do

0:25:29"safe" things. The end result is that your users become frustrated and don't understand

0:25:35why their devices' features and capabilities are turned off. Do this often enough and they

0:25:38will start using their personal devices to actually get their work done.

0:25:43Collide is different. Collide believes that end-user education about device security is

0:25:47the top priority. Instead of locking down the device, Collide allows you to monitor

0:25:52it continuously to see if it is compliant with your security policy. If it isn't,

0:25:57Collide will message your employees via Slack and walk them through the policy, why it is important,

0:26:04and give them precise instructions on how to fix the issue themselves. Collide will even message

0:26:09the user the instant they fix the problem so they know they did it right. Collide does all of this

0:26:15by using an endpoint agent called os query which is 100 open source doesn't degrade the performance

0:26:23of your max and provides important information to security analysts without violating the privacy

0:26:29of your end users collide is free for your first 30 days across all of your devices that includes

0:26:37windows and linux too but they know my audience probably a lot of max and you can sign up on their

0:26:44website today at collide.com k-o-l-i-d-e.com. My thanks to Collide. What else is on the

0:26:58agenda here? Are we done with iPad? I kind of think we should be because…

0:27:05Oh, did you want to mention, did you…

0:27:07Oh.

0:27:08Yeah.

0:27:09Well, while we're talking about Larry Tesler, I just wanted to say, I thought there was

0:27:13one of the things I linked to was a tweet thread by Chris Espinosa, who's kind of

0:27:18been at Apple a long time. I think his employee number is six.

0:27:23[Laughter]

0:27:24Tim Cynova I was going to say.

0:27:25Dave

0:27:40But he had just a wonderful thread, very brief.

0:27:43I'll put it in the show notes, but I linked it on "Daring Fireball," about how all

0:27:49of the obituaries for Tesla are sort of leading with the inventor of cut, copy, and paste,

0:27:56which I think he does deserve credit for.

0:27:59But he did so much more.

0:28:00But you know, I don't blame you.

0:28:02But I mean, how long is the headline going to be for an obituary?

0:28:05And it's not a bad thing in terms of letting, you know, like the readers of the New York

0:28:09Times just have a stake in, "Hey, I didn't, you know…" I think cut, copy, and paste

0:28:15are so ingrained in our minds that it's hard to remember…

0:28:18I've cut, copied, and pasted.

0:28:20Yeah! It's hard to remember that they were an invention, you know, and that it was something

0:28:24worse. But that, you know, like prior… his anti-modality campaign was that, you know,

0:28:31word processors before the work that he and his team did at Xerox PARC had… they were

0:28:38so modal that they had different modes for adding text and different modes for editing

0:28:44text. Like, you know, like think of the contacts app on iOS. You open up a contact and it's

0:28:53read only, right? And then you hit an edit button at the top and now you can edit the

0:28:57stuff and delete fields and add fields and there's two modes. And, you know, the modal

0:29:01thing doesn't mean that all modes are bad. Maybe that's actually a good selection for

0:29:05iOS because you don't, you know, for something that you tap, maybe you don't want everything

0:29:09to be editable all the time.

0:29:12But it's kind of obvious and, you know, I don't want to give short change to all of

0:29:17his work, but he even, Larry Tesler, would admit that doesn't mean never have a mode.

0:29:21Just if you need one, don't use one unless you really need it, and if you do, make it

0:29:25obvious how you get in and how you get out.

0:29:30And Espinoza's thread just emphasized how thoughtful his stuff was, and it was about

0:29:39how in the early Macintosh, by this time Tesla was at Apple, like around 1982, they were

0:29:46implementing copy and paste for text editing, and that they just inserted, they were happy

0:29:54enough, the Mac team.

0:29:55And then, you know, this is a team full of real sticklers for, you know, trying to do

0:30:00insanely great work, as they said.

0:30:03They were just going to take a string of text and wherever the insertion point is, if you

0:30:06pasted, it would just add that string right there.

0:30:11And so, if you were at the end of a word and you were going to paste another word, the

0:30:16word would be right up against the previous word with no space in between it.

0:30:20And Tesla was like, "No, no, that's not good enough."

0:30:23Right?

0:30:24Right? Like, and Espinosa said, I was thinking like a programmer, and a programmer thinks,

0:30:29I want the precision. I know that I have the string M-O-L-T-Z on the clipboard, and the

0:30:36insertion point is right next to the N in J-O-H-N, and if I paste, I expect moles to

0:30:43be right next to the John with no space, because if I wanted a space, I'd have typed a space,

0:30:49and that's the way a programmer thinks. And Tesla, you know, insisted, he, and he was

0:30:53thinking the way people think, and the way people think is I've got a name, I've got a first name,

0:30:59and I've got a second name on the clipboard, and when I paste, I would like it to look like a

0:31:03normal name, which is John Space Moltz. And then had the thoughtfulness to write it up in a heuristic

0:31:13that could be implemented programmatically in a way that wouldn't annoy the programmer types

0:31:21like Espinoza, who expect it? Like, what do you know? And I think part of that heuristic is like,

0:31:26if you're in the middle of a word and you paste, then it really does appear without spaces,

0:31:30because it assumes, well, you're in the middle of a word, right? It's just so many little details

0:31:36like that that made the Mac great right from day one, and you can attribute them to him.

0:31:41- Yeah. I did not know until I read your blurb on Daring Firewall that he had worked on the

0:31:48Newton as well. Oh yeah, yeah, he was a, I think that might have been the last big thing he did

0:31:54while at Apple. I know he was still in the advanced technology group after that,

0:31:59but in terms of stuff that actually shipped, that was part of it. Although I guess,

0:32:02no, that's not true, because the advanced technology group did work that led to Wi-Fi

0:32:07and stuff like that. But yeah, he was definitely a big part of the Newton,

0:32:11and the Newton was very, very anti-modal in a great way.

0:32:18Yeah, I always liked the cut and paste interface for that.

0:32:23Yeah, yeah.

0:32:24Where you drag it to the side, and then you could still see it.

0:32:27You'd still see the thing that you had that you were going to move someplace else,

0:32:32and you'd move to the other place, and then you'd just drag it back in.

0:32:35Yeah.

0:32:36So anyway, RIP Larry Tesler. I've got more stuff saved up in tabs,

0:32:47so there'll be more stuff on Daring Fireball. There's so much more to write about, but what a

0:32:51shame. Next on the agenda, what do we got? How about this? Did you see this Malware Bytes

0:33:02quote-unquote scandal last week? Yeah, yeah, I tried to ignore it for a while because it just

0:33:08made me angry. Yeah, it's one of those things where I started writing about it and it was

0:33:17getting too long. I was like, this isn't worth me spending all this time on. And I wound up—I

0:33:25didn't link to it until just today, in fact, before we were getting ready for the show. And

0:33:29I just punted and just linked to Michael Tsai's write-up, which has his usual amazing collection

0:33:37of commentary from around the web and Twitter. And Jason Snell did the yeoman's work of

0:33:45actually sort of writing about it intelligently. And it is… so basically, for those who didn't

0:33:54see it, the Malwarebytes Labs is an anti… they make their money selling antivirus software.

0:34:00So I think it's fair to say there's a conflict of interest in terms of their interpretation

0:34:06of Mac users' needs for third-party antivirus software. But they released their report on the

0:34:142020 state of Mac software and said, this is a quote from their report, "Mac threats increased

0:34:20exponentially in comparison to those against Windows PCs in 2020, while the overall volume of

0:34:26Mac threats increased year over year by more than 400 percent. That number is somewhat impacted by

0:34:32a larger malware bytes for Mac user base in 2019. However, when calculated in threats

0:34:37per endpoint, Mac still outpaced Windows by nearly two to one. Which sounds really bad.

0:34:45And it's not nonsense or bullshit or made up, right?

0:34:50Right. It's not great either.

0:34:52Yeah, it's not great.

0:34:54It's, yeah. I mean, do you prefer the numbers would go down?

0:34:57- Right.

0:34:58But it involves a broad interpretation of threats

0:35:05or what you call malware.

0:35:10It's catnip for the tech press, right?

0:35:17And it has been, I mean, forever.

0:35:19I mean, going back 'til you and I started writing

0:35:24the public, it has never not been a thing to try to make that the conventional wisdom

0:35:33is that Macs don't get malware and Windows gets malware and that's the conventional

0:35:45wisdom.

0:35:46And then anything that refutes that is catnip to the tech press because it's a man by

0:35:54by its dog story, right? And it always comes down to, at some point, there's somebody who

0:36:07will say, "Mac users," or somebody says that Macs "can't get malware," right? Which is

0:36:15something that nobody who knows what the hell they're talking about has ever said, right?

0:36:21ever said it. It has never been true. Nobody's tried to say it's true. It does require nuance,

0:36:29and then so therefore we're already screwed. But basically—

0:36:35I feel like maybe early on, because the different disparity was so great, it did seem like,

0:36:41to some people, that the reason must be because Apple's coding was better, that Apple had fewer

0:36:49exploitable flaws or whatever, which was not really not the

0:36:53case. Well, I think it was a lot of it was mostly because Windows

0:36:57just had the larger market share. And if you're going to

0:36:59write something, you're gonna write something against winds

0:37:01it. No, no, I think it was true. At one point, I think there was

0:37:05a point where where Windows was easily more easily exploited by

0:37:10poor security practices on Windows part that there were

0:37:13exploits like exploits that would actually let a remote

0:37:17intruder take over the machine. To me, the canonical example of it is Word Office macro

0:37:24viruses, which were insidious. All you had to do was open a Word document with a macro

0:37:35virus. You just opened the .doc file and your machine was screwed. And it would spread,

0:37:43right? And that's the thing is we've sort of lost the meaning of virus in the computer sense,

0:37:49where it, you know, in the real world, the biological virus, which unfortunately we're

0:37:54going to—it's on the agenda for today's show. But, you know, as we're reminded by the news

0:38:01around the world right now, a virus is a thing that spreads on its own, which is what makes it

0:38:08so insidious. And a computer virus should be—that's a term that should be used for a type of malware

0:38:17that spreads on its own. And there was a time when—and Max used to—a long time ago, Max had

0:38:26a terrible problem with viruses. There was a great app—what was his name? John Norstead. He had an

0:38:33app, free app called Disinfectant. Were you using a Mac back then? Do you remember Disinfectant?

0:38:38Disinfectant. Disinfectant was amazing because Disinfectant was totally free and it was totally

0:38:49unobtrusive on your Mac and it totally worked. But there were viruses on the Mac that spread

0:38:58just by inserting a floppy disk. I mean, so it was literally the computing equivalent of an STD.

0:39:04That if you, if there was an infected Mac and you put a floppy disk in, that Mac would write the

0:39:13virus to the floppy disk, and then you would pop it out, and then you would put it into your Mac,

0:39:20And just by putting it in, your Mac would get the same virus. And it really was that little

0:39:30interactivity. Just put a floppy disk in an infected Mac, take it out, put it in another one,

0:39:34and the other Mac would have it. Disinfectant nuked all of them, and he kept it up to date.

0:39:41It was really great. But that was a real problem that the Mac faced in the early '90s, like when I

0:39:48was at Drexel University. And we didn't really—we didn't have a network at the time. We had to get

0:39:52software. You'd go to the computer lab, and the way you got, like, software that was site licensed

0:39:59for the whole university for Mac users or even courseware, like, you know, like your professor

0:40:04would say, "Go to the computer lab with a floppy disk and, you know, put in your course number,

0:40:08and you'll get all this stuff." Like, you know, some courses, you know, had, like, custom hyper

0:40:12card stacks. It was kind of an amazing time to be a Mac user at college. But part of the thing was

0:40:19that if you had to have disinfectant because, you know, and all of the lab machines had disinfectant.

0:40:25But they would tell you sometimes. Like, you know, I was, you know, didn't happen to me because I'm

0:40:30me. But I had friends who'd be like, "Holy shit, I put my floppy in and it told me my floppy was

0:40:35infected, you know? And I was like, "Yeah, you got to get disinfected." So anyway, I've never,

0:40:41ever, ever—I mean, this was—that was like 1991, 1992. Like, I've known for,

0:40:47God, that's close to 30 years that Macs have never, quote-unquote, not gotten malware.

0:40:54But the stuff that faces the Mac today is not viruses. It's not things that spread without

0:41:01you doing anything like you just you know it's all i don't know what you want to call it scamware

0:41:08trick where yeah i think they use adware um but it's a but it's a variety of different it's not

0:41:14just things that show pop-up ads or something yeah dan gooden at ours technica had a good piece just

0:41:20at the end of january about this this sort of uh and some of them they look so bad but but basically

0:41:28there's a whole bunch of them are just fake Adobe Flash installers and that's particularly

0:41:34insidious, kind of obvious, kind of clever. But for anybody who is a non-expert Mac user,

0:41:41who's been a non-expert Mac user for, let's say, 10 years or more, which at this point

0:41:46is an awful lot of people, right? There was an awful lot of people who became Mac users

0:41:50in the mid 2000s, the aughts as we call them, you know, right around, you know, when the

0:41:56Intel switch happened. And in that era, it was very common for you to be browsing the web and

0:42:04be told your flash is out of date, go here, and a flash, you know, and you weren't being tricked,

0:42:11you were getting a legitimate update to the flash installer, and it would show a dialog box that you

0:42:16had to click through to get an updated version of flash installed because you needed…

0:42:22Because Flash itself was telling you, right?

0:42:24Because you'd go to a site and it would automatically start playing something in Flash, and Flash

0:42:29would say, "Oh, you can't see this because you're out of date."

0:42:33Right.

0:42:34And then it would download a thing and show you a Flash.

0:42:35So that's a thing that Mac users, non-expert Mac users, have thought is, you know, have

0:42:41done and needed to do.

0:42:43And so now, even though Flash is—I think it's—

0:42:46Well, that's what's so funny about it now.

0:42:48It's in a way, I mean, every time I go to a site

0:42:50and something like that pops up,

0:42:52I just, I think it's so cute because

0:42:54I haven't run Flash in 10 years probably.

0:42:57(laughing)

0:42:58- It's like telling you you need to install disinfectant.

0:43:01(laughing)

0:43:03I mean, it belongs in a museum.

0:43:06- Your zip drive is out of date.

0:43:07- Right, I mean, it's almost like,

0:43:10it's like we have, as an industry,

0:43:14successfully eliminated Adobe Flash like 99.9% of it. I can't remember the last time I've

0:43:23seen anything that wants it. I don't even know. I don't think it runs on the latest

0:43:26versions of Safari. I don't even think you can install it if you wanted to.

0:43:30Tim Cynova Oh yeah, I don't know about that actually.

0:43:33That may be true. I mean, it hasn't come in default for years and years.

0:43:37Dave Asprey I don't think it even runs anymore. I can't

0:43:39remember the last time anything has ever even asked me to install it legitimately. But it's

0:43:44the gift that keeps on giving in terms of people, you know, again, to go back, does

0:43:50my mom know that she doesn't have Flash anymore? That she doesn't need Flash? Of

0:43:53course not. You know, she has no idea what the hell Flash was except that every once

0:43:57in a while she needed to update it or else she couldn't, you know, watch video on CNN.

0:44:03And so that's one of the ways they do it. So they trick you. It's not actually Flash.

0:44:07is some kind of scam adware, but they get you to click through it and give the permission

0:44:14to do it, and it's insidious. Apple is on it. That's the other thing that Malwarebytes

0:44:19doesn't—that's sort of disingenuous about the whole story that, "Hey, you need Malwarebytes

0:44:24third-party antivirus."

0:44:25Apple, for all the complaints we have about Apple software of late, Apple is on top of

0:44:31this. And if anything, in my opinion, my complaints have been that they're too on top of it and

0:44:36and making things too difficult for expert Mac users

0:44:40who really do trust and are careful about what they install

0:44:45outside the App Store on their Macs,

0:44:47that they've gone too hard, too far in the direction

0:44:50of protecting against stuff like this.

0:44:53And even just in November, they've changed the rules

0:44:56on what they're saying is disallowed

0:44:59through the mandatory notarization process

0:45:01and what they're going to revoke the license to.

0:45:06It's pretty much anything that is a scam is what they're saying.

0:45:11And there's a document that Apple published in November that, to me, they're on top

0:45:15of it.

0:45:18And basically, Michael Tsai's conclusion is mine as well.

0:45:22I really don't think that anybody, expert or typical Mac user, needs third-party antivirus

0:45:31software and that it causes more problems than it fixes, that what the best course of action for most

0:45:38people is to run with Apple's default settings, which are pretty strict about… Does the Mac now

0:45:46default to only installing from the App Store? I think you even have to click something.

0:45:50Tim Cynova I think so, yeah. I think that's right.

0:45:52And then the only other option is, well, without futzing around, right, is the Mac Store and

0:46:00verified developers, right? Right, and the thing that if you download from outside the app store,

0:46:06you have to like control click the app and choose open or go select it and go to the gear menu in

0:46:14the finder and select open. If you just double click it, it'll give you a dialog that says you

0:46:19can't run it because it can't be verified. And that is a very good and that's a very good solution

0:46:27in my opinion, to keep typical users from accidentally opening something they shouldn't,

0:46:34but allowing an expert user to open, like, a homemade app that you just wrote for yourself,

0:46:42or a friend wrote in Xcode, or like an AppleScript applet that isn't signed, or something like

0:46:47that, but you know you can trust it, and you're just enough of a Mac nerd to know what control

0:46:53clicking on an app is and you can choose open and then it'll still give you a confirmation dialogue

0:46:59but that confirmation dialogue will give you the extra button that says openness anyway I trust it

0:47:04I mean that's not the exact terms but it's what it means but but not letting you do it by simply

0:47:10double clicking the app is it is a terrific defense anyway apple's on top of it and I don't

0:47:17think I think it's kind of kind of BS you know and I pity you know I pity them I guess because

0:47:24they're the ones who chose to get into the Mac antivirus software thing but you really don't need

0:47:30it yeah I mean I have not I mean I personally have not had a you know knock on wood had a virus

0:47:36yeah probably since the probably since the 90s right since the early 90s since that time and I'm

0:47:43Now, my kid is another matter because during his Minecraft

0:47:49heyday, of course, he was going to any and every site

0:47:51that he could find to download mods and things like that.

0:47:54And so he managed to screw up a Mac really badly.

0:48:01But that's a whole other set of impulses.

0:48:06And that was a number of years.

0:48:10That was at least three or four years ago.

0:48:12But there is a good power tool analogy that, you know,

0:48:17some people need, you need to be able to make a mess of things

0:48:20with a saw to be able to use a saw, right?

0:48:22I mean, there's certain tools that need, you know,

0:48:26you need to be able to shoot yourself in the foot.

0:48:31That's maybe a bad example, but--

0:48:32Right.

0:48:33You need to be able to--

0:48:34You won't respect a gun until you've been shot by one.

0:48:40You need to be able to drill a screw into your own hand.

0:48:45But you do.

0:48:46I mean, a hammer is a perfect example.

0:48:49I mean, you can't build a hammer that

0:48:52would function without making a hammer that would

0:48:54allow you to smash your thumb.

0:48:56But it would be nice if you don't ever actually

0:48:58need to drive a nail into the wall

0:49:00to have a similar tool that would never

0:49:03allow you to smash your thumb.

0:49:06The analogy breaks down, I guess, at some point.

0:49:09We do need to have computers that we can mess up.

0:49:12But most people ought to have a computer that they can't mess up,

0:49:17is a broad way of putting it.

0:49:21I would say the same thing.

0:49:22My son has a gaming PC now as well.

0:49:27And I think it's true of modern Windows as well.

0:49:31And I did some research on it, and so far so good.

0:49:33But the old mantra-- and I think a lot of Mac users,

0:49:38people who've lived their lives in the Apple ecosystem and internalized it, that Windows

0:49:43is virus-ridden and exploit-ridden and you can't use Windows without some kind of third-party

0:49:50antivirus. I don't think that's true either. I think Microsoft Defender, which is their

0:49:54built-in antivirus, and Jonas has had his PC now since Christmas of last year, so what,

0:50:0414 months and, you know, it seemingly is in tip-top shape. You know, we had to remove

0:50:11Norton. That was fun. And I, you know, I did just enough. I wish that Jonas was more, I

0:50:21don't know how Hank is, but Jonas just wants to play the games. He really is.

0:50:27That's exactly how Hank is.

0:50:30And so, and Jonas is nerdy about the games, and he and his pals, even though they're...

0:50:38Jonas and Hank are either very similarly aged or identically.

0:50:41Yeah, they're pretty close, yeah.

0:50:42Jonas is in 10th grade.

0:50:44Yeah, that's Hank is also in 10th.

0:50:46Yeah, so they're, yeah.

0:50:47And I thought it was really cool, is that Jonas and his pals got back into Minecraft

0:50:52this year.

0:50:53Like, Minecraft is like such an epic game.

0:50:56Oh, really?

0:50:57I mean, it's ridiculous to think that we spent, you know, we both got license for it for like

0:51:0226, 28 bucks or something like that. And the amount of gameplay.

0:51:06Pete: It's insane! It is absolutely insane.

0:51:08Jim; And they've never asked for an upgrade. It's just like, you get a license and then,

0:51:12you know, sure, you're okay, you got the game. And then they just keep pumping out updates to it.

0:51:17Pete; Yeah.

0:51:18Jim; For like, nothing.

0:51:19Yeah, and Jonas and his pals they they know

0:51:23Minecraft the way like I knew the Mac and like knew how to use resedit to go in and change icons. Oh, yeah

0:51:31The way that I knew how to deconstruct the classic Mac and thought it endlessly

0:51:37Fascinating is you know like and he'll get into games like that

0:51:41But he has absolutely zero interest in getting into the computer itself that way

0:51:46and

0:51:48And you know, so I, it was up to me,

0:51:51who has no interest in Microsoft Windows at all,

0:51:54like to figure out, is this, am I right that we wanna,

0:51:58we don't want any third party antivirus,

0:52:00we wanna just use this Microsoft Defender,

0:52:04and is the right way to do it to just de-install

0:52:07this crapware that came installed,

0:52:09or do I wanna wipe the computer and start over

0:52:12with a fresh installation, blah, blah, blah.

0:52:15- Yeah.

0:52:16- I was like, well, it's a Christmas gift,

0:52:17so I guess it's, you know, my gift to you

0:52:20is I'll do the work for you and figure it out.

0:52:22But anyway, that's true.

0:52:24It seems to be true, and I've read other people's faces.

0:52:26- I mean, you are in effect using some sort of antivirus.

0:52:29You're just using what came with the,

0:52:31you're not using third-party antivirus.

0:52:32- Right, and I think that what comes with it

0:52:34is actually superior.

0:52:35It's not like, you know, you're,

0:52:38it's not like you're using TextEdit

0:52:41instead of a proper word processor

0:52:43like Pages or Microsoft Word.

0:52:46you're not using a cut down thing, you're using something that is expertly designed

0:52:51to have no impact on your computing while doing anything legitimately but to identify

0:52:57you with anything that is actually problematic if you download it and double click it or

0:53:01something like that. And gets regular updates automatically with no interaction on your

0:53:08own to stay up to date. I would honestly say that Microsoft and Apple have are very much

0:53:15on equal footing and deserve A grades for staying on top of this stuff and protecting

0:53:21most users in a way that's unobtrusive. It's always the complaint. And I say this with

0:53:38sympathy to people who get Sherlock'd, you know, in the, you know, as we say in the Mac

0:53:44community from the Watson app that did something, and then Apple came out with an app called

0:53:50Sherlock. I mean, it is pretty bad that that was the name.

0:53:55Kyle: Yeah, the naming choices is particularly egregious.

0:53:58Pete: Right. So it's, you know, but that makes it a long story that would, you know,

0:54:03to fully tell. But anyway, there was an app called Watson, if you weren't around, in

0:54:06the mid 2000s and it was sort of a way to intelligently search things on the

0:54:11web without just being textual like searching through a search engine it

0:54:17delivered things into I don't know what you call it little nuggets like you know

0:54:22the weather would show up as an actual you know weather thing that would tell

0:54:26you the weather and it was a third-party software and from what was it Carolina

0:54:32and then Apple came out with a big Mac OS X update that included an app called Sherlock,

0:54:37which pretty much did the same thing. And it was included in the system. And ever since,

0:54:43having a piece of third-party software be obviated to at least some degree, if not entirely,

0:54:52but enough to make it untenable as a commercial effort, the verb is "Sherlock'd." And my

0:55:01I have sympathy for it, but my rule of thumb is if it belongs in the system, it will eventually

0:55:09be in the system.

0:55:16I don't know if I'll find it.

0:55:18I'll try to make a note and see if I can find it.

0:55:20But there was a thread recently about this.

0:55:22I forget what the context was on Twitter.

0:55:25But somebody with longer memory than me was bringing up ads from the early PC era, like

0:55:311983, like a 1983 ad and byte magazine where there was a third-party utility you could buy

0:55:39that would allow you to print Lotus 1, 2, 3 spreadsheets in portrait or I mean landscape.

0:55:47Because at the time Lotus could only print, you know, in 8.5 by 11 would be 8.5 by 11 as opposed

0:55:57to 11 by 8.5. And if you had a widespread sheet, well, then it didn't work, and you

0:56:02could buy a third-party utility that would let you do it. Well, should—

0:56:07Yeah, right. Exactly.

0:56:11Is it a rip-off? Is it some kind of unethical act when Lotus added the ability to print

0:56:18a portrait? No. If it belongs in the system or belongs in the app, the third-party opportunity

0:56:23you know, isn't going to last for long. And so if you're a third-party developer,

0:56:29you should either recognize if your product is a great idea, you should recognize it,

0:56:37that if it seems like such a great idea that it might be part of the system, then you should

0:56:42recognize that and be prepared to move on, or do it in such a way that it has such depth

0:56:48that the solution from Apple would never have that much depth, but the power users will continue

0:56:54wanting, you know, there'll still be a market for your solution.

0:56:56Brian "B

0:56:56I don't know if it's just retrospective, if it seems so obvious that you should be able to print a spreadsheet in landscape.

0:57:06Uh, but then, cause you run, that seems, that seems like, yeah, of course you should be

0:57:13able to do that.

0:57:14But then you start thinking about like the tile thing and whether or not does, does it,

0:57:20does it make sense for a, you know, a little do hickey that you can attach to things that

0:57:27you can find them to be sort of baked into the operating system too.

0:57:31Right.

0:57:32Right.

0:57:33So you're talking about that.

0:57:34like, you know, is that really something that necessitates being in the operating system?

0:57:38Pete: Yeah, I think that's the context of the Twitter discussion I was thinking of,

0:57:42was this antitrust case where Congress had invited Tyle, among others, to

0:57:48levy their complaints about Apple and other tech giants and, you know.

0:57:55I mean, it seems, I don't know. It's a weird question, and it seems like the kind of question

0:58:03about what is art. You know, I mean, I don't know. The spreadsheet thing seems obvious to me,

0:58:13and this seems less obvious. But, you know, to me, it seems like it's perfectly fine for Apple

0:58:22to ship this thing. But it also seems like maybe it should be something that you might

0:58:27have to download from the App Store instead of it coming with the operating system.

0:58:34Pete: Yeah, and we could go on and on and on about it and skip the rest of the show and talk about

0:58:40how, you know, I know that I went back and forth with Nielai Patel from The Verge on it where he's,

0:58:49you know, and again, it's not a bad—this isn't like, "Oh, I disagree, and we're on opposite

0:58:53sides, and we hate each other. Let's, you know, let's get in a fistfight." It's, you know,

0:58:58it's a rational discussion, which is actually, isn't it enjoyable? We can still have a discussion

0:59:04where we— Tried to work it out.

0:59:06Yeah, and acknowledge that both have good points. But Apple Watch is a good example,

0:59:13where Eli's perspective is that it's—I don't know if he would call—I don't want to put words

0:59:18in his mouth but anti-competitive at least in the lowercase a sense not the capital a like this

0:59:23should be legal illegal but that is anti-competitive that apple watch integrates with ios on your phone

0:59:32at a level that no third-party watch can access right so like you know no matter what samsung does

0:59:43with a smartwatch, the only thing that they could get installed on an iPhone is an app

0:59:51from the App Store.

0:59:53And there is no way that an app from the App Store, sandboxed, can offer the level of integration

1:00:01that iOS and Apple Watch have, which is way outside the bounds of what an app can do.

1:00:10But the reason for that isn't anti-competitive.

1:00:15The result is anti-competitive, but it's not like Apple is spiting these companies.

1:00:19It's because if apps from the app store were allowed to install system-level background

1:00:28daemons that do the things like, "Hey, I'll just install the watchOS at four in the morning."

1:00:37Once your watch is on the charger and your phone is on the charger, and I know that I

1:00:43can tell from the patterns of when you're – that's very likely that you're asleep.

1:00:49I'll just do the software update then.

1:00:54It would be great if you could promise that the third parties would only use it for features

1:00:59like that.

1:01:00But if that potential was there, it would be used for all sorts of havoc, which we know

1:01:05from the last 20 years of computing.

1:01:08I mean, it calls back to the malware bytes thing

1:01:09where people would install software

1:01:14and it would install all sorts of shit in the background

1:01:17and the lack of sandboxing and apps,

1:01:21it was just out of control in terms of how much stuff

1:01:23apps would do that was running in the background.

1:01:26And you don't want that.

1:01:30So what's the solution?

1:01:31I mean, it sort of stinks.

1:01:33I mean, I don't think there's any way that Apple could offer third parties the level

1:01:37of integration between devices that Apple Watch enjoys because it's integrated without

1:01:44also opening up a can of worms that would allow Facebook to install stuff that would

1:01:51observe every website you visit.

1:01:53Yeah.

1:01:54On your watch.

1:01:57Yeah.

1:01:59[laughter]

1:02:01But that leads us into Mark Gurman's story this week.

1:02:07Oh, what was—I have that open in a tab and haven't read it yet.

1:02:11So the rumor is that Apple is considering allowing third-party apps to be default apps

1:02:21for—specifically, I think it just mentions web browsing and mail and music.

1:02:28music, at least it talks about music on the HomePod, but something that people have been

1:02:38talking about forever.

1:02:39Darrell Bock Yeah, and that's been a complaint with, I

1:02:44think, Spotify in particular, that Apple has favored Apple Music by having – there's

1:02:50an entire product called HomePod that only works with Apple Music.

1:02:53Yeah. And that is, yeah, that's mentioned specifically is, is the possibility of

1:02:59running Spotify on the HomePod as the default music app.

1:03:03Right.

1:03:03And it seems, you know, it seems like this is, I mean, I don't know, we'll see if they do it

1:03:12or not. But the fact that they're considering it, if that is the case,

1:03:19doesn't seem like it's a coincidence that it's coming after they've been dragged in front of

1:03:25Congress. Yeah, probably not. I'll take the devil's advocate side on this, which is that

1:03:35I've long been sympathetic to Apple's perspective on not allowing you to choose a third-party app as

1:03:45as your default for web browsing or mail or contacts or calendar.

1:03:52Not as a diehard, that would be a terrible mistake, but as a,

1:03:58all right, let me give you the other side.

1:03:59Sort of like the one button versus two button mouse thing,

1:04:03which again goes back to Larry Tesler, who wanted one button

1:04:05mice because the original mice at Xerox had three buttons

1:04:11and five chord keys.

1:04:15I don't even know what that means. Did you hear the story? Did you read the story? Just

1:04:19let me put a finger on this thing. The other story I saw, I think in the John Markoff obituary

1:04:29in the Times, was that Larry Tesler, while still at Xerox, was against mice completely.

1:04:37He thought they were too complicated and wanted to show that they were wrong. He thought cursor

1:04:43keys were the way to go. And so he brought people for word processing in particular,

1:04:48he brought people in off the street who had never used a computer word processor,

1:04:51and showed them how to do it using a there's the Xerox system with no mouse installed just using

1:04:58cursor keys. And they all took to it very quickly thought this is great. This is so much better than

1:05:04a typewriter because you can, you know, go back and correct mistakes and you can copy and paste

1:05:08and they got it they could do they could they typical people learn to do it. And his thought

1:05:13and now I'm going to teach him, I'm going to show him how to do it with a mouse, and they're going

1:05:17to hate it, and I can show everybody that this is the worst." And he plugged the mouse in and

1:05:22showed him how to do it with the mouse, and they all said right away, "Oh, I don't want to use

1:05:27that. I don't understand it." And then he said, "Well, let me show you how it works." And he showed

1:05:30him how it works, and as soon as he showed him how it works, they're like, "Oh, this is way better.

1:05:33Oh, this is great!" And he then—this is the part, this is what makes—this is why

1:05:42Larry Tesler is, to me, a hero, and we need more—I mean, we're losing this sort of

1:05:47thinking in this world. Today, he was like, "Okay, I was wrong." You know? And—which

1:05:56is exactly what you write! That's what you want. You want—you know, the true scientific

1:06:00method is come up with a hypothesis, test it, and then accurately gauge the results

1:06:08the test, whereas our modern world has gone to come up with your hypothesis and then—

1:06:14Pete: And sell it.

1:06:15[Laughter]

1:06:18Pete; Exactly! No matter what the evidence says—

1:06:21Pete; No matter what it is—

1:06:22Pete; Spend all of your mental effort coming up with a way to justify it—

1:06:26Pete; Get a few rounds of VC funding and sell it.

1:06:30(laughing)

1:06:32So we were talking about, oh jeez.

1:06:39- Default apps.

1:06:40- Default apps, all right.

1:06:41So my defense about it is,

1:06:47and I would like to see them do it.

1:06:49I mean to say overall, I would like to see them do it.

1:06:52I use Fantastical as my main calendar,

1:06:54although I think on all the other ones they might do it.

1:06:59Well, I also have Cardhop installed, which is also from Flexibits, which is an alternative

1:07:04to the contacts app. I guess if I could, I might set Cardhop as my default contacts app,

1:07:11but I definitely would set Fantastical as my default calendar. But I use Safari and

1:07:17Mail. But I get it, you know, that it would be nice when you click an email address and

1:07:22you use something like the Gmail app or Spark or, you know, there's a bunch of great third

1:07:28third-party email apps for the iPhone.

1:07:30Wouldn't it be great if it opened?

1:07:32And I know there's people who use Chrome.

1:07:35But I think Apple's thinking on this

1:07:37is the historical scarring

1:07:40of allowing third-party software to be indispensable

1:07:45and then holding them up.

1:07:49And the best example of this is the influence,

1:07:53the outsized influence that Microsoft Office

1:07:55the Adobe suite had in the transition from classic to

1:08:01classic Mac OS to Mac OS 10 and

1:08:06Microsoft and Adobe essentially got to dictate an awful lot of what became carbon because they're basically they were both like we've you know

1:08:14We're not going to this cocoa thing all in

1:08:18You know come up with something that lets us you know do a lot less work and keep our code base most

1:08:25you know, mostly in shape. And those aren't the only examples. But like, here's my example

1:08:31with iOS. Some of Google's apps, it may be a lot of Google's apps on iOS, are to me

1:08:39inexplicably slow to update to things like new screen sizes, right? I've had a couple

1:08:46of Google apps that I've used that like when, I forget which years, but like when the iPhone

1:08:51has changed shape, I've had black bars at the top and bottom for months after the iOS

1:08:59update shipped or the new iPhone hardware shipped and was in my hand until Google updated

1:09:03the apps to actually update to the new screen sizes.

1:09:09And I think Apple is loathe to allow, let's just say, you know, the elephant in the room

1:09:15would be Chrome, right?

1:09:17there's an awful lot of people who I think would rather use Chrome than Safari as their

1:09:23browser because they're in the Google ecosystem and it syncs their Chrome tabs across because

1:09:27they're using Chrome on the Mac. I think Apple's loathe to do that in some ways because they're

1:09:34loathe like what happens if they update iOS to have some feature. Maybe it's hardware and it has

1:09:42a new screen size, maybe it's software, and there's like a totally new multitasking

1:09:49method for iPad, right?

1:09:51[laughter]

1:09:51Pete: Just as an example.

1:09:53Pete: Just as an example, if they do. But it would require apps to be updated to support it.

1:09:59And months and months go by, and Chrome isn't updated to support it. And 30% of iPad users

1:10:07are using Chrome. Well, then 30% of iPad users are using a browser that isn't updated for this.

1:10:13That is, I think, a large part of Apple's thinking on this, that it's not—you know,

1:10:22they don't make money by people using Safari instead of Chrome or Firefox on iOS, right?

1:10:30They're not selling access to—

1:10:32Yeah, I mean, not email and not web browsing, right? They do music.

1:10:37Right, so music is a much better example. But music isn't a—there's a conflation here between

1:10:46two different issues. There's default apps, which I think only applies to

1:10:50utility apps, contacts, calendar, mail, and—

1:10:59Well, there's the question of what Siri uses.

1:11:02Right, but that's different than a default app? I mean, I guess that is…

1:11:07Well, sort of, right?

1:11:09Well, I think of default apps in a URL context, right? What happens when you click an HTTP link?

1:11:16It's supposed to go to your default web browser. A mailto colon link goes to your mail calendar,

1:11:21or mail app. A cal—I forget the name of the URL, but it's like cal dot, or cal colon something.

1:11:28thing. And you can download a contact in a standard format that opens in your default

1:11:37on your Mac, opens in your default contacts app. I guess in this context of Siri, it's

1:11:45not URLs, but it is sort of a—if you say, "Hey, Dingus, play some Rolling Stones,"

1:11:54the effectively right now if you if dingus is Siri it is only going to play

1:11:59Apple music and I get it you know and that Spotify Spotify's complaint before

1:12:05regulators around around well maybe not around the world but at least in the US

1:12:09and Europe mm-hmm and it's important in certain contexts right I mean if you're

1:12:15driving you want to be able to do that and if you have if you have contexts

1:12:21that are important enough that you can't futz with it at the time, you are more likely to

1:12:27go with whatever the default is.

1:12:29Yeah, but I don't understand how that would work on the HomePod, because at least on the

1:12:33Mac or on iOS, or for the contacts calendar, web, and email, we all know how that will

1:12:42work.

1:12:43You would just be able to specify effectively the URL handler for it, and somewhere in the

1:12:50settings app it would say you know default apps and the default you know you'd go to email and

1:12:58the the list of apps would be all of the apps you've installed that you know probably just

1:13:05through metadata in the like an info.plist probably wouldn't even be an api per se but just

1:13:10you know would say you know i'm registering with the system as an app that can be a default email

1:13:17app. You know, like you do with content blockers. Like when you install a Safari web content

1:13:25blocker, there's a section in Preferences that you go to, Safari content blockers, and

1:13:30it'll just list all of the content blockers you have installed. Presumably, there would

1:13:35be a list of email clients, and you could tap one of them, and it would change. And

1:13:41then when you ever tap a mailto link, it would open in that app instead of mail. With the

1:13:47music, I'm not quite sure how it would work, because there are no apps for HomePod, right?

1:13:52Like, at a technical level, I'm not quite sure how in the world you could talk to your

1:13:59HomePod and say, "Hey, Dingus, play the Rolling Stones," and have it go through a Spotify

1:14:05account because there's no apps on the HomePod.

1:14:08it's weird, right? Because the HomePod version of Siri is a little bit different, isn't it?

1:14:13Darrell Bock Yeah, because a lot of times she will say,

1:14:16"I can't do that on this device." I forget what I just did the other day, and it was weird. Oh,

1:14:23I know what it was. I wanted to do a division problem, and I said, "What's $500 divided by

1:14:3612 or whatever it was. And she said she couldn't do it on this device, which I thought was weird,

1:14:42because I know I've done math. And it was because I said dollars. And even though technically that

1:14:48doesn't involve any kind of currency conversion. Did you see what I mean? So in a sense, it's a

1:14:56bug because there was no currency conversion involved. So she should have just been able to

1:15:01to do the division, but because I said dollars,

1:15:04it triggered a, this is a currency conversion thing,

1:15:08so it can't be done on a HomePod,

1:15:09you have to do it on an iOS device.

1:15:12I don't know, it was something like that.

1:15:14But there's definitely things you can't do on HomePod

1:15:16that you can do on other devices.

1:15:18I don't understand how Siri integration would work

1:15:20with a HomePod like that, because,

1:15:22and HomePod isn't like Apple Watch,

1:15:25where it's tethered to an iPhone or an iPad

1:15:29to do all the work, right?

1:15:31- Yeah.

1:15:32- It's not like, oh, you have Spotify on your phone,

1:15:36so therefore you could talk to your HomePod

1:15:38and it'll just work 'cause it'll get it from your phone

1:15:40because, you know, what happens if you go to work

1:15:43and your spouse wants to--

1:15:47- Too bad.

1:15:48(laughing)

1:15:49- Oh, you can't listen to music until John comes home.

1:15:52(laughing)

1:15:54That would not be considered an upgrade to HomePod.

1:15:57- No.

1:15:58But there has to be--

1:16:02I imagine that these are separate systems, though, right?

1:16:05I mean, Siri is a separate system from Apple Music.

1:16:09And at some point in Apple's back end,

1:16:15it is parsing out what you're saying to--

1:16:17Siri is parsing out what you're saying to it,

1:16:19and then passing certain values to the music server.

1:16:26I guess.

1:16:27And then that's what you get, you know, and then you get what you get in return.

1:16:30Yeah, I mean, I guess it's all—

1:16:31So it should be able to pass those values to another provider.

1:16:36As my friend Rich Siegel of BB Edit fame, who was recently on the show and it was a great show,

1:16:41and I really thank him for it. But he would always—he had this saying when I worked at

1:16:45Barebones and I would come in and I'd, you know—he just had this saying about programming that,

1:16:52Well, it's all just typing.

1:16:53He's not wrong.

1:16:58You know, and he's not that he was the sort of--

1:17:01not that he ever has been the sort of person to just by default say yes to feature requests.

1:17:05But if it came down to it and it was like the argument was, well, but that would be hard,

1:17:09he would be like, well, it's all just typing.

1:17:11So it is, you know, it's not like, you know, there's some sort of technical limit that

1:17:16HomePod couldn't offer some kind of integration with, you know, or like a plug-in API,

1:17:22and you know it would obviously you know i guess if german is correct that must be what they're

1:17:28working on though there must they must be what was interesting was that he just mentioned it on

1:17:35the home pod did not talk about music on ios i don't think yeah and that would be easier in my

1:17:41opinion because there you'd already you know there's already a concept is already an app yeah

1:17:45right and the app would just offer serie you know this the spotify app could be updated with a new

1:17:50API to offer, you know, here's the, you know, if you're a music—maybe it would even be specific

1:17:56to music or something, I don't know. I mean, I guess audio would be a better way to think of it

1:18:00so that—because I would think you would want podcast apps to be able to integrate just as well

1:18:06so that you can say, you know, "Hey, Dingus, you know, play the latest episode of the talk show,

1:18:13and the right thing would happen even if you use Castro or Overcast instead of Apple's podcast app."

1:18:20So hopefully he's right. I think that would be a great idea, honestly, and not even as an

1:18:25anti-competition regulatory zealot. It would just be a great feature for users.

1:18:33Because it's good that you're allowed to use Castro and Overcast and prefer those as your

1:18:39podcast player, and it's good that you're allowed to use Spotify instead of Apple Music.

1:18:43And they should compete on the merits, not on the integration.

1:18:47But I'm not the sort of person who thinks that Apple should somehow hold back on those integrations

1:18:56until it puts everything on equal footing with third parties.

1:19:00Yeah, and I suspect that, you know, if they—I would think it would probably be more, you know,

1:19:06kind of like the keyboard thing where, you know, you'd get it, but it wouldn't quite work as well.

1:19:11Right.

1:19:12As the default did.

1:19:15So anyway, hopefully it will. Do you use a third-party keyboard? That third-party keyboard

1:19:19thing?

1:19:20No, I don't.

1:19:21I guess I don't really hear much about it anymore. And I know Apple added swiping in

1:19:26iOS 13. Do you use the swiping?

1:19:29No.

1:19:30Yeah, me neither.

1:19:31I can't. I'm too old to.

1:19:33Me too. I don't find it faster.

1:19:37I tried swiping. I believe I downloaded before it came to the default keyboard. I tried.

1:19:45tried it on another keyboard and I just never liked it.

1:19:48It's not the way, I don't think that way and I found it extremely clumsy to use.

1:19:53Yeah, yeah.

1:19:54But it's great that it's an option and I can see how some people it would, but I really

1:20:00do think of the keyboard as a mini version of a keyboard, a physical keyboard, and so

1:20:05I want to peck away.

1:20:07Yeah.

1:20:08Yeah.

1:20:09Do you use an iPad while we're talking keyboards?

1:20:14- What's your iPad? - Do I use an iPad?

1:20:15- Yeah, what iPad do you use?

1:20:17- I have the 11-inch iPad Pro from last, well, 2018.

1:20:22- Yeah, so I've got that too.

1:20:26I cannot type on it at all.

1:20:29I hate it, I hate it, I hate it.

1:20:31- Well, you like the split keyboard, right?

1:20:33- I like the split keyboard because even--

1:20:35- And you can't get it on that one.

1:20:36- And you can't get it on the iPad.

1:20:38- For some reason. (laughs)

1:20:40- I don't know what the hell happened.

1:20:41I don't know what the hell they're thinking

1:20:43because I can only type on iOS with my thumbs.

1:20:45And when they added the split keyboard to iPad,

1:20:48I was like, now I can type.

1:20:50It was like the iPad came out.

1:20:52And I've always liked the iPad a lot.

1:20:54I mean, a lot.

1:20:56But I really had trouble typing on it.

1:20:59Although the earlier ones were small enough

1:21:01where I could kind of stretch my thumbs.

1:21:03You know, like the growth from 9.7 to 11,

1:21:07it stretched it so that my thumbs

1:21:11don't quite reach the middle.

1:21:12It's just big enough to not be able to reach the middle comfortably.

1:21:17For a couple of years after the iPad Mini came out, my eyes were still great enough

1:21:24that it was fine.

1:21:25I loved the iPad Mini for a couple of years.

1:21:27I mean, I just, the first time I ever met Tim Cook was during a hands-on after one of

1:21:39of Apple's keynotes, and it was when, I think it was the second generation of the iPad Mini

1:21:45came out, and maybe it went from like non-retina to retina or something like that. I don't

1:21:49know, but it was like Tim Cook recognized me and we had just a brief, and you know,

1:21:54he did this, of course, you know what this question was, "So what'd you think?"

1:21:57That's a great question! It's absolutely, it is, it's just a, you know, that's

1:22:03all, you know, Steve Jobs used to do the same thing when he went around the hands-on. If

1:22:08you were deemed worthy of Katie Cotton saying, "Steve, this is so-and-so from Time magazine,"

1:22:15and then he would go up and then he would say, "So what'd you think?" That's what he'd say,

1:22:18which is great. And then he'd tell Walt Marsburger to get off his damn table.

1:22:24Get off the damn table. No, he didn't tell him. That's the best part.

1:22:28I know. I know. He just sat there and stewed. I love that story.

1:22:33But I loved the iPad mini. I loved it. And the only reason I still don't use one is it's just

1:22:39a little too small for my eyes right now. And I like the Pro. I wish there was a Pro. I like

1:22:44my pencil. So, you know, I actually love the pencil. But you can use the first generation

1:22:50pencil, right? Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah. You don't like them. Yeah, I don't like it. I know. I know.

1:22:55I know. I know. But we got Karen got the base, whatever that, you know, she got the iPad, iPad

1:23:01laugh for Christmas and a pencil and she, you know, the original pencil and she loves that thing.

1:23:07Oh, it is when you, it's so great. It is.

1:23:10It's cheap.

1:23:11Oh, it is so cheap.

1:23:12It was 250 bucks at Costco. And then, you know, the pencil was not hard, but still it was.

1:23:17In some ways, it's the most unappley priced product ever.

1:23:22It really is.

1:23:23I mean, going back to like 1978, it is.

1:23:25Yeah, yeah.

1:23:27It's the only time that Apple has made a truly fantastic personal computer that is at

1:23:33what can only be described as a truly low price. It's the greatest bargain that Apple has ever

1:23:45offered, maybe ever will. But anyway, one of the things I loved about the Mini was the fact that

1:23:50I could thumb type on it so great. It was like better for thumb typing, or it probably still is

1:23:55better for thumb typing than the iPhone because it's small enough that it's like no stretching

1:24:02and the keys are big enough that you like never hit the wrong key. It loved it for that.

1:24:08The fact that you can't – and then the split keyboard on the bigger ones was like, "Oh,

1:24:12this is great. I love it." I just used the split keyboard and then I could still thumb

1:24:14type and it was – I could do it. Now I can't split the keyboard. I can't type. I literally

1:24:21type like they say Tolkien did, which is like one finger. I guess he supposedly used two fingers.

1:24:30That's what I use. I usually hold it with my left hand or like on my arm and just type with

1:24:40the fingers, whatever fingers I can use on the right hand. So I'll use multiple fingers.

1:24:44I type with one index, my right index finger, and it's maddening, and I just either switch to

1:24:50to a different device or if I'm in an iPad mood,

1:24:55it's a digression, but I just bought,

1:25:00son of a bitch Jason Snell.

1:25:03- Are you talking to a keyboard?

1:25:05- Yeah, another mechanical keyboard,

1:25:08but this one's Bluetooth,

1:25:09which is all the difference in the world with an iPad.

1:25:13Like using a cable connection to the thing,

1:25:16it just sort of defeats the purpose.

1:25:18but I have a new mechanical keyboard

1:25:20that's really pretty nice, and so I just use that.

1:25:23But I either use a hardware keyboard

1:25:25or I just don't type at all on the iPad anymore.

1:25:28- Yeah, I have a hardware keyboard too, hardware keyboard.

1:25:32- Oh, I'm trying to think, I'm trying to think selfishly.

1:25:35If somebody from Apple wrote me a confidential email

1:25:39and said, "You can have one or the other.

1:25:42"You can have a radically fixed multitasking for iPad."

1:25:46(laughing)

1:25:48And we'll sync all the man hours,

1:25:51we'll sync thousands of man hours into this and do it.

1:25:56Or we'll put, we'll keep multitasking as it is,

1:26:00but put the split keyboard on the iPad Pro.

1:26:03- Yeah, you're Sophie's choice.

1:26:05- Yeah, and we'll let you pick and we'll never,

1:26:07and I'll be like that guy who didn't vote for Jeter,

1:26:10and we'll keep it anonymous.

1:26:12(laughing)

1:26:15- I don't know why, yeah, I mean,

1:26:16I figure there has to be, I don't know,

1:26:18sort of assumed there was maybe something with the camera that they thought if you were holding the

1:26:21key the the ipad with both hands like that they would cover the camera up or something

1:26:26i don't i don't know my working theory is that it has something to do with the extra keys they added

1:26:32you know like like there's a tab tab key now like the the old like when they made the keyboard a

1:26:39little bigger they added extra keys like you used to not be able to type the tab character

1:26:44you know, like the phone, and now they did. But I would just say, I don't care, just when I go to

1:26:49split screen, get rid of those keys. I don't care. Yeah, just return it the way it was, yeah. Yeah,

1:26:53my theory was, that's my theory, is that there was some argument inside where they're like,

1:27:00"Well, if we keep split screen, we're going to lose these extra keys," you know, whereas on the

1:27:06devices where split screen still works, you don't lose keys. I would rather just, I would just say,

1:27:11you lose the keys, you lose the keys. I don't care. Just let me tell you.

1:27:16I never used the split screen keyword. But I know there's some people who

1:27:22really relied on it like you. And the guy who does the Johnny Ive parody, he also...

1:27:28I didn't know that was a parody.

1:27:34Maybe I've said too much.

1:27:38Gonna take a break here and thank our next sponsor, our good friends at Away.

1:27:42Everyone likes to travel differently. Away offers a range of suitcases made

1:27:47of different materials such as polycarbonate, aluminum, and their newest one, durable nylon

1:27:56in a variety of colors and sizes. So, whoever you are and whatever you need to pack, Away has

1:28:03luggage that will help make your next trip more seamless.

1:28:07Features of all of their suitcases, all of their suitcases are designed to last a lifetime

1:28:13with durable exteriors that can withstand even the roughest of baggage handlers.

1:28:18Every suitcase comes with an interior organization system that includes a built-in compression

1:28:24pad to help you pack more in.

1:28:26I've had this for years.

1:28:28I'm telling you, this is one of the best features.

1:28:30I put my shirts behind that, put the compression pad in there, cinch them down.

1:28:37Keeps the shirts as wrinkle-free as anything I've ever tried to do while traveling.

1:28:43Absolutely fantastic.

1:28:45Keeps your shirts wrinkle-free and gives you more room because it literally is a compression

1:28:50system.

1:28:51Let's you pack more and they include a hidden and removable laundry bag that separates your

1:28:58dirty clothes from your clean clothes when you come home. They have four 360 degree spinner

1:29:04wheels that are guaranteed to be the smoothest roll, even through the most hectic of airports

1:29:09and stations. I've had my Oasis case at least as long as they've been sponsoring the show.

1:29:16Still looks as good as new. The wheels still feel like brand new. I honestly can't believe

1:29:22it how good it is. They even include a TSA approved combination lock to keep all your

1:29:27belongings safe. It's really, really just a great, great suitcase and they have all

1:29:34these sizes. I really love them. They really are designed to last a lifetime. If any part

1:29:39of your suitcase breaks, their standout customer service team will arrange to have it fixed

1:29:44or replaced. They have a hundred day trial on everything they make. Take the product

1:29:49out on the road, live with it, travel with it. And up to 100 days, if you decide it's not for you,

1:29:56you can return any non-personalized item for a full refund during that period. No if, ands,

1:30:02or asterisks about it. They offer free shipping and free returns on any order within the contiguous

1:30:10U.S., Europe, Canada, and Australia. Start your risk-free 100-day trial and shop the entire away

1:30:18lineup of travel essentials, including their best-selling suitcases, at awaytravel.com/talkshow2020,

1:30:28because it's 2020 now. So that's awaytravel.com/talkshow20. You get a 100-day free trial.

1:30:36My thanks to Away. Also, don't forget, their carry-ons come with a built-in battery pack.

1:30:42The talking points they give me don't even mention it. Still my favorite feature. Absolutely love it.

1:30:47every single seat at the airport suddenly becomes a two USB port charging station because you've got

1:30:53one built into your suitcase and it pops right out pops right out so that if you're flying an

1:31:00airline that doesn't want you to have one stowed away and you have to stow your your carry-on

1:31:05under the belly of the plane you're no problem you don't even have to open the suitcase really

1:31:10fantastic product. My thanks to Away. What else? What else next on the agenda?

1:31:16I just, just to interject this briefly, but I'm just looking at this. There's a,

1:31:20did you know there was a command that you can run that will return the startup sound?

1:31:23No. What do you, what is it?

1:31:25sudo nvram startup mute equals %00.

1:31:34Will you paste this in the show notes?

1:31:37Sure.

1:31:37[Laughter]

1:31:41And it really plays the startup sound? But what if you have one of the new Macs that doesn't have

1:31:47a startup sound? That's the thing. That's where you want it. That's where you play it and put it.

1:31:52Oh! That's where you run it. That's what it's for.

1:31:55I thought you meant that you type this in the terminal and it'll just play it for you right

1:32:00now. No, no, no. No, no. It'll reset. So that's just the—

1:32:06Which makes sense, I guess. I mean, that, you know.

1:32:09Yeah. What is it? Control-G is the bell, right? Or...

1:32:13Well, I don't remember. But there used to be a way, you know, some kind of control

1:32:17sequence you type just to play a beep. I thought you were saying you could do it.

1:32:20Oh, isn't that great? I should have actually listened. Once you started getting into the...

1:32:24Once you started getting into... Do you know that... Have I ever mentioned this? Do you know

1:32:29that I really cannot spell audibly like you know how like when you have a little

1:32:37kid oh yeah yeah yeah and you'll be like hey should he get D E S S E R T because

1:32:44you know maybe you know your kid was had been naughty or something like that I I

1:32:49I cannot you like when Amy would do that I would have trouble follow I have

1:32:54trouble following along. I'm a very visual person.

1:32:58So you'd say it out loud and then he'd say, "Yeah, of course I should."

1:33:02Well, I was better—I'm much better with Pig Latin, although I'm not good with Pig Latin either.

1:33:07I end up—I'll get like two words in and then just start saying real words.

1:33:12And she'll be like, "What are you doing?"

1:33:14Hank has always been better at Pig Latin than me. Hank is fluent in Pig Latin.

1:33:17Aw, I'm terrible.

1:33:18"Wait, what? What?"

1:33:19No, you start telling me something about a command line thing and I'm like,

1:33:23law. You might as well be telling it to my mom, you know. But if you showed it to me,

1:33:29I'd get it instantly. And now that you mentioned NVRAM, of course you're talking about it. I'm

1:33:34going to turn that on today. I think it's a crying goddamn shame that they took the startup

1:33:43sound out of it. I think so too. And then the stupid thing is they put them all at the beginning

1:33:47of the Apple TV shows. Like, I understand that. Like, you have this iconic sound,

1:33:54and you take it off the Mac, and then you still use it on your TV shows?

1:33:59It's not quite the same sound, or else it just sounds different to me.

1:34:03Yeah, no, it's not exactly the same sound, but it's—

1:34:07Right. But in the same way that, like, you know, I get it that—it's clearly inspired by, you know,

1:34:14and maybe they—I think that the thinking behind it was, "Well, let's make it a little bit more

1:34:18appropriate for the beginning." You know, there's some kind of psychological semantic difference,

1:34:23you know, in the same way that maybe the Apple logo's a different size, too, you know.

1:34:27Let's make it perfect for the shows. Anyway, I'll put that in the show notes, I promise.

1:34:33I will try to remember to put it in the show notes. Let me see if—did you actually paste

1:34:40it into the show notes somewhere? I did. I don't see it. Can I edit these? I think so.

1:34:46Oh, there's something just showed up.

1:34:49NVRAM. I'm looking for NVRAM. Oh, there it is. There it is. Ah, I can't wait.

1:34:58This is the third tip and trick of this episode of the talk show. This is...

1:35:05My first.

1:35:07This is absolutely... No, you...

1:35:09Can I run it right now?

1:35:11Do you think it'll take my computer now?

1:35:13Well, I wouldn't do it.

1:35:17I wonder.

1:35:20I won't do it.

1:35:24I won't do it.

1:35:25Just to be on the safe side.

1:35:26We got enough problems.

1:35:28I don't want to go off on too big of a tangent on it.

1:35:33Are you updated to Catalina?

1:35:36I am, yeah.

1:35:39Because I was going to say something.

1:35:40Like, I don't have the problems.

1:35:42People have been complaining about being asked

1:35:45by the operating system all the time,

1:35:47if you really want to do that and stuff like that.

1:35:49I don't really have that problem.

1:35:51I don't consider myself much of a--

1:35:53I mean, I know how to do things, but I

1:35:55don't feel like I'm a real big power user.

1:35:57I don't exercise that muscle a lot, really.

1:36:02Only if I'm writing about something

1:36:05that I want to try out and figure out how it works.

1:36:08So I get the thing most often the thing that I get is the, you know, do you want to let

1:36:14this website access downloads?

1:36:18Which I don't find really that annoying.

1:36:19I actually don't either and I actually enjoy that one.

1:36:23And I get the point of it too.

1:36:25That's the other thing, you know?

1:36:26I mean, a number of times I have accidentally like, you know, where you do that thing where

1:36:30you like control click and you do and it downloads like an HTML, it downloads the HTML instead

1:36:36of like the file that you, I mean, I've done that, you know, fat finger by mistake. And

1:36:41so in those instances, well, I guess if you've already given a permission, it's going to

1:36:45download it anyway. But at least the first time it's not going to.

1:36:48There's so many, you know, there's, there's so many security problems or that aren't,

1:36:56you know, the technical ones are way beyond my can I even have a degree in computer science

1:37:01And I don't understand the true genius level you have to be at.

1:37:08Okay, if you do, I understand like a buffer overflow.

1:37:12I understand the idea that if there's some program that accepts input and is allocated a fixed amount of memory for the input,

1:37:21and takes anything from the input and doesn't check the size and just throws it into memory,

1:37:30that it overwrites the bounce.

1:37:32You know, it's like the analogy of like the cup is a fixed size

1:37:36and you're going to accept any amount of beverage from the thing that you're,

1:37:41you know, the beverage dispenser, it's going to overflow the cup, right?

1:37:45That's exactly what happens with memory.

1:37:47I understand why that makes apps crash, but I don't understand, it's just beyond me,

1:37:56the black magic of being able to use that to craft the overflowed memory in such a way

1:38:03that it gets to actually start doing things. Like, I understand that layperson's explanation

1:38:09of it, but how you would be so talented at programming and finding these things that

1:38:14you would take advantage of it is just beyond me. But that's how a lot of software technical

1:38:18exploits are. The ones that I think are—it's like, I fully understand it, and it's like,

1:38:25"Oh, you clever rat bastard," are the ones that are just, they're not really technical

1:38:33at all. They're just exploiting things that the people who made the software never even

1:38:39considered because you think, "Why would anybody ever do that?" And I've told this

1:38:43story on the show before, but about two or three years ago, Jonas encountered a bug that

1:38:51that has since been fixed in Safari,

1:38:54but I think it was there since the beginning of time.

1:38:56But somehow he wound up on a website

1:38:59that had some kind of like,

1:39:04you have to call us to get,

1:39:07your Mac has been infected with malware,

1:39:10and this is why it's slow, call us and we'll fix it.

1:39:15And he thankfully called me for help,

1:39:18but his computer really was dreadfully slow,

1:39:23like almost unusably slow,

1:39:25but that dialogue was there with the 1-800 number,

1:39:29and what the website was doing

1:39:33was sending a nonstop endless stream

1:39:38of four-byte files to download.

1:39:43And the four-byte files, they all had like the same text,

1:39:48just like abcd or something like that like they were just you know you could open they were just

1:39:52like four byte text files they were all identical but they all had a new name or something or i

1:39:57guess the browser will just start adding numbers you know if they have the same name and it was

1:40:00just sending them endlessly an endless stream of them and safari was just trying to keep up but

1:40:08couldn't you know that the website could send these files faster than safari could take them

1:40:13and write them. And so it actually did render his Mac too slow to use. And so it's very

1:40:21easy to see how a very rational person would think, "Holy shit, they're right. My computer

1:40:25must be infected. I'll call this number." Right? But I can totally see how it might

1:40:33never have occurred to the engineers of Safari to not try to accept downloads as fast as

1:40:40they can. If you're accepting 10 downloads, why not get them as fast as you can?

1:40:46Yeah.

1:40:47You know, there's so many exploits that are like that. It's not really technical,

1:40:51but it's, you know, a layperson can imagine the JavaScript programming behind, you know,

1:40:56just repeat forever, send the download of a text file, and, you know, the text files

1:41:05themselves weren't any kind of virus or anything. They were just four-byte text files,

1:41:09and it was just sending them as fast as they could.

1:41:11Well, it's like a denial of service, right?

1:41:13Yeah.

1:41:13I mean, it's like you just-- yeah, you're-- yeah.

1:41:15Yeah, and the trick is if you-- you could just force quit Safari

1:41:18and then open it back up with-- either if you don't already

1:41:23have the setting to reopen existing web pages,

1:41:25there's like a keyboard shortcut so that it doesn't reopen the pages that

1:41:29were already open so that that page doesn't open and start

1:41:32the thing all over again.

1:41:34But anyway, I filed a radar on it and wrote to a friend

1:41:37who I know is on the Safari team and got fixed.

1:41:40But I think now, a better, even broader solution is the,

1:41:45do you wanna accept downloads from this file,

1:41:48this website in the first place, right?

1:41:50'Cause you don't even want one unwanted download

1:41:53that you didn't ask for by being tricked

1:41:57into clicking something that you just thought

1:42:00it was gonna open a new page or something like that

1:42:02or whatever and it's gonna download stuff.

1:42:04I think it's a great, you know,

1:42:05that's a warning I'm happy about.

1:42:07But like when a random app that I haven't used

1:42:10in two hours suddenly pops up a dialogue

1:42:14in front of everything I'm working on that says,

1:42:16"Do you want to allow whatever this app is

1:42:18"to access the desktop?"

1:42:21I find that very annoying.

1:42:22And I kind of get the thinking,

1:42:24I do get the thinking behind it,

1:42:26and I've complained about this desktop warning,

1:42:28and somebody was like, "Well, I keep, you know,

1:42:30"right now I've got my, I'm doing my wife's and my taxes

1:42:33for 2019 and the files are on the desktop.

1:42:36So I don't want any random app to be able to read the desktop.

1:42:41You know, I kind of get it.

1:42:42I do get that people put everything they're working--

1:42:46you know, the desktop is what probably a majority of Mac

1:42:50users use for, like, here's the thing I'm working on right now.

1:42:52I'm not going to file it away until I'm done.

1:42:55And in the meantime, I'm going to keep it on the desktop

1:42:58because the desktop is so easy to get to.

1:43:01So I get it, but it's like so many of these apps

1:43:06that I'm getting prompted for are apps

1:43:08that I trust completely and implicitly.

1:43:12I wanna be able to just say, you know,

1:43:14I don't have any apps on my system that I don't trust.

1:43:17Or at least, you know, like the Mac way of doing it

1:43:20and Apple doesn't really do things this way

1:43:22would be, I would like it if it was as simple as like,

1:43:26if there was a, I'm gonna come up with the dumb name,

1:43:30there's gotta be a better name.

1:43:31But if there was a way to have a,

1:43:34inside your applications folder,

1:43:36if there was another folder that was called trusted,

1:43:39and it was a magic folder,

1:43:41and any app you put in applications trusted

1:43:44was just guaranteed,

1:43:47and do the thing where apps can't install themselves there,

1:43:51the only way to get an app there

1:43:53is to actually drag it using the Finder,

1:43:56and when you drag an app there,

1:43:58have a dialog come up and say,

1:44:00by moving an application here, you are, you know,

1:44:03trusting it with the access to the full contents

1:44:06of your home directory.

1:44:08- I guess that, yeah, I mean,

1:44:09that would obviously solve your problem,

1:44:10but I mean, you also end up with apps that would say,

1:44:15you know, in order to run this app,

1:44:17you must install it in Trusted.

1:44:18- Well, but I still wish, you know,

1:44:20but I wish that were possible.

1:44:22I don't know.

1:44:23Anyway, what was the, oh, but I get stuff that,

1:44:28I keep getting things,

1:44:29'cause I do enough AppleScript stuff,

1:44:31I just keep getting so many goddamn warnings

1:44:34about apps to get

1:44:36permission to do inter-application communication and stuff.

1:44:44And some of them are Apple's own apps.

1:44:48I guess fair's fair,

1:44:50in the sense that we often complain

1:44:52that hey, Apple lets their stuff get away.

1:44:56Xcode is distributed through the App Store and Xcode obviously has permission to do things

1:45:03that are outside the sandbox, you know. So Apple has apps in the App Store that aren't

1:45:08limited by the same rules as third-party apps in the App Store and in a sense that's not fair.

1:45:13I totally get that.

1:45:19And so if Apple's apps are asking for this permission,

1:45:23I guess that's fair, but it just seems crazy to me.

1:45:28Well, I can't.

1:45:32- You'd think, yeah, you'd think that it would be,

1:45:36we've pre-approved certain apps for,

1:45:41and maybe even the stuff in the Mac App Store.

1:45:45- Right.

1:45:46- Like if they did that at that level,

1:45:48then you could be, you know, sort of, you'd get through a lot of things and you'd be assured

1:45:54that it was done in a way that was, you know, somebody took a look at it.

1:45:59Well, and then the other thing is that there's just so many things that, it's like, I don't

1:46:04even remember, they're scattered, you know, the permissions are scattered all over the

1:46:08place in System Preferences where there's like full disk access and there's this other

1:46:14type of access. And I just want to say, like, so there's an accessibility system preference

1:46:22pane, right? That's a top level of system preferences. But then there's also in security

1:46:28and privacy, an accessibility item in the left hand column of privacy that has allow

1:46:35these apps to control your computer. And it's like, isn't that confusing that there's access,

1:46:42an accessibility pref pane and then there's an accessibility section in the

1:46:46privacy section of security and privacy and it uses the same icon but that's

1:46:50where I've got things like in there there's an app called a server and I was

1:46:55like a server I never even heard of that what the hell is that and I reveal it

1:47:00you can control click and it says like show and finder and you show it and

1:47:03finder and it's at system library frameworks core services dot framework

1:47:08versions a frameworks a e dot framework versions a support that aren't you glad

1:47:15you asked but that's you know that's like the holiest of holies in the

1:47:19operating system anything in system library is like ought to be implicitly

1:47:23trusted and then there's another one here it the icon looks like the terminal

1:47:28icon it's just called launcher with a lowercase L and I it was asking me for

1:47:32permission I was like well that seems like it might be sketchy you know and

1:47:36And let me do my expert thing here that I want to be able to do, which is I'm going

1:47:40to be the Mac nerd who knows how to check if something should be trusted or not.

1:47:46Lowercase L launcher, which wants permission to control my computer, is at—it's inside

1:47:53the system preferences app.

1:47:56System preferences, contents, resources, there's an app, a little process called launcher.

1:48:01Well, it's almost like you're—it's like Inception at this point, where something

1:48:08inside system preferences is asking for a preference that I can only set inside system

1:48:13preferences.

1:48:14You know what I mean?

1:48:17And Apple has done this thing in Catalina, which is great, where there's at a technical

1:48:24level your startup disk is now actually two disks, a read-only system partition, and then

1:48:31the read-write system partition where your user directory and stuff like that is, and

1:48:36therefore while you're booted in regular non-emergency safe mode, whatever you call

1:48:42it, you can't write to that read-only system partition, which is fantastic. So that like

1:48:49the file system itself is protected against some bugs that Apple could make. There's

1:48:57a whole class of bugs that could maybe be exploited that would allow bad guy software

1:49:02to overwrite the system software itself. It's great that it's not even possible that it's

1:49:08blocked at the file system level. But a process that's in that, like this launcher, ought

1:49:13to be implicitly trustworthy, right? And how the hell is a normal person supposed to look

1:49:19at a dialog that says, "Allow this app." And the icon looks like the terminal app because

1:49:26just like a background daemon, and the name is just lowercase l launcher, right? How is

1:49:32a normal person supposed to do this? And know that what they really want to do is say, "Yes,

1:49:37I want to give you permission to control my computer."

1:49:39Kyle: So is that—it asks you to do that?

1:49:44Joe: Yeah.

1:49:45Kyle. Okay.

1:49:46Joe. I got a dialer.

1:49:47Kyle. I got it—oh, I don't have launcher in there, but I have the other one. I have

1:49:49the—

1:49:50Joe. AE server?

1:49:51Kyle. AE server one.

1:49:52Joe. Yeah.

1:49:53Kyle. Yeah. And it never—it's never asked me.

1:49:55I don't know. I just feel… I get it. I'm not saying that we should go back to the old

1:49:59days where anything you install on your Mac can do anything it wants willy-nilly. I get

1:50:03it. Those days are gone. But I just don't think stuff should be hidden.

1:50:11I had a thing—I guess I should bring it up. I'm going to write about it. I didn't

1:50:15quite get it done before we recorded, but the location of media files on Mac OS 10.5

1:50:20So I ran into this problem. So you know like where does iTunes, well iTunes doesn't exist anymore,

1:50:27but where did iTunes put your music files? Well it was in your home folder in a folder called music.

1:50:32Well that was, that's pretty obvious right? Like so if you ever wanted to like actually get to

1:50:37your music, you know, there you could get to it. I had a thing, I'm trying to think how I can make

1:50:47this short enough. But I don't use Apple's podcast app. I listen to all podcasts that

1:50:55I normally listen to in Overcast. And I do all on my iPhone. I don't ever listen to podcasts

1:51:03on any device other than my iPhone. That's just the way that I listen to podcasts. But

1:51:10I subscribe to my own podcast in Apple podcasts, because I know lots of people use it and I

1:51:16I want to just every once in a while I want to make sure it looks right. Does this work

1:51:21the way I think it does in this very popular, very important and it's a very good app.

1:51:26I can see why lots and lots of people like the Apple podcast app. And I was looking at

1:51:31it this week. I hadn't looked at it on my Catalina Mac really since that breakup between

1:51:39iTunes being busted into these separate apps. I thought, "Well, I should do that." I

1:51:45periodically take a look at how it looks on the iPhone and I looked at it and I

1:51:49was scrolling down and I there were four episodes that didn't appear it was like

1:51:54episodes like 245 to 248 which is like roughly a year ago and they just weren't

1:52:02listed in the all episodes and so I was like hmm and my first thought was there

1:52:07I'll bet there's something wrong with my RSS feed for the podcast I and then

1:52:10before I even finished the thought in my head I was like no I'll bet it's the

1:52:14podcast catalyst app. I was like, "I'm not gonna go and debug my RSS feed for the

1:52:22talk show yet. Let me see." And I thought, "I know what I'll do. I'll unsubscribe

1:52:26from the show in podcasts and delete all of the ones that it's already had all through

1:52:33the podcast app. And then I'll quit the podcast app and I'll relaunch it and I'll

1:52:37resubscribe to the talk show." And I did that and I went to all episodes and the same

1:52:42four episodes were missing. And I thought, "Hmm." Then I went to my phone and looked

1:52:46in Apple's podcast app, and I scrolled through all episodes, and those episodes are right

1:52:50there. They're listed fine. And I went to, you know, Overcast, and there they are. They're

1:52:56fine. And I thought, "It's not my feed. There's something cached locally on this

1:53:02Catalyst podcast app, how do I delete all the files?

1:53:07And they're not in /home/music anymore.

1:53:13Where the heck are they?

1:53:16And I went and I figured out that there's a whole bunch

1:53:19of stuff, because it's a Catalyst app, by default,

1:53:24instead of storing stuff in your library folder,

1:53:26it stores it in library/containers/stuff,

1:53:30and you go into library/containers,

1:53:32and there's all sorts of stuff,

1:53:33but there were four com.apple.podcasts directories in there.

1:53:38And I just deleted all four of them,

1:53:41put them in the trash, deleted the trash

1:53:43while the app was quit, relaunched the app,

1:53:46and son of a bitch,

1:53:48still was missing the same four episodes.

1:53:50(laughing)

1:53:52So I started, and this is really hard to Google for,

1:53:54and then I found an article from Kirk McElhern.

1:53:59Again, I hope I'm not, he's a long time Mac writer,

1:54:02or a Kirkville is his website.

1:54:03- I think that's at least close to him, right?

1:54:06- And has long been, and literally has written the book.

1:54:10His most recent book that he's written

1:54:13is "Take Control of macOS Media Apps."

1:54:17Literally, long time, decade or longer,

1:54:20expert on Apple's iTunes and the various media apps.

1:54:24He had an article right after WWDC,

1:54:27"Where does Catalina store your media files?" Well, here's where Catalina's podcast app

1:54:36stores your media files. Home/—your home folder, meaning—/library/groupcontainers/—so

1:54:47far so good, I guess—slash—

1:54:49Tim Cynova—Well, not really, because library is hidden to most people.

1:54:52Yeah, the library is hidden. Although I'm okay with that decision to make it invisible,

1:54:59you know, and that you have to goo—and it—'cause it's not too hard to get into it even though

1:55:03it's invisible 'cause there's like a go to command in the finder and you can type

1:55:06it and it'll auto-complete even. So I'm okay—that's a decision that Change Apple

1:55:11made that I'm okay with 'cause most people shouldn't be—if they don't know what

1:55:16they're doing, you shouldn't be dicking around in your library folder.

1:55:19All right, library/groupcontainers/243lu875e5.groups.com.apple.podcasts.

1:55:34Now…

1:55:36I don't think I have that.

1:55:40I'll bet you do, and I bet it's just sorting in a weird order.

1:55:44No, it's a different number.

1:55:45Oh, is it?

1:55:46Yeah, it ends with groups.com.apple.podcasts. It's got a different number in the front.

1:55:54Well, mine is exactly the same as Kirk's for some reason. And my thought was, wait—

1:55:58Wait, did you—maybe, no, maybe it's the same. Maybe I'm just misreading—

1:56:02Two, all right, 243LU875.

1:56:07It's the same, sorry.

1:56:07Yeah, so it is the same. But I saw Kirk's article, and I thought, oh, maybe this is where I should

1:56:13ago. So not library/containers, but library/group containers. And I deleted that folder and then

1:56:21restarted podcasts. And then I had resubscribed to my show and it worked. It was something was

1:56:26cached in there. It had a bad memory of my feed with four episodes missing. You know, and this is

1:56:32this is a decades-long trick of troubleshooting stuff. Like, if your app is acting up, you want

1:56:38find out where is it where might it be storing bad information or a cache go

1:56:44there move that file to the trash and restart the app and see if that fixes it

1:56:48right this is there this is like troubleshooting 101 right yeah I can't

1:56:54believe that there's a single person listening to the show who hasn't used

1:56:58that as a basic user level debugging technique and it worked it's great but

1:57:04But when I first saw the article, I thought, "Kirk, that's got to be – that has to

1:57:09be some kind of randomized number per user."

1:57:12Right?

1:57:13And then, lo and behold, it's the same for everybody.

1:57:16Why?

1:57:17Like, that's so ugly and gross.

1:57:20And if it's the same – if it's different for everybody, I still don't – there would

1:57:27be no security thing, though, because it still matches group.com.apple.podcast, right?

1:57:32Right.

1:57:33Right.

1:57:34randomized but if it's not randomized why is it there why it's so ugly and part of my mac nerd

1:57:43superiority complex is that everything on the mac is supposed to be elegant right that is the the

1:57:49grossest most inelegant thing i've ever seen or imagined i think i mean i think the lots of things

1:57:57in the library folder are very inelegant. But they used to be—it started, like, from the next era,

1:58:04everything was very elegant. And it's like, slowly over time, Apple, like, internal engineering-wise,

1:58:11has given up. The first level is fine, but then when you get down further than that, it

1:58:16turns into a bit of a mess. Right, but it offends me in the sense of that, you know,

1:58:21the back of the cabinet is supposed to look nice way. Right? It offends me that for whatever reason

1:58:30this folder is there. But anyway, I had to delete that and it worked.

1:58:35Jared: I can't believe you didn't find that.

1:58:39Pete: It's not too hidden until you get to that stupid number.

1:58:44Jared.

1:58:44Right.

1:58:44Pete. But anyway, Marco had a tweet. Marco Arment had a tweet this week where he was in the finder

1:58:51and had a folder full of big video files or something, you know, but they

1:58:57actually were actually quite large. I think he was like hand-breaking some

1:59:01video files or something and had done a get info on the parent folder and the

1:59:05get info window in the finder was showing that the folder was zero

1:59:10bytes. And his screenshot that he tweeted was like the actual finder window with

1:59:15the file sizes, you know, and it's a whole bunch of like, you know, 100 megabyte

1:59:19video files, the selected folder, parent folder, and then the get info panel

1:59:24showing zero bytes, and he was like, "Trust me, Catalina, this folder has more than

1:59:29zero bytes." And I pinged him privately about it, and he said, like, at some point

1:59:38he was not quite sure when, because he, you know, like, took the time to take the

1:59:41screenshot and tweeted it, and then eventually the get info window did show

1:59:45the correct number. But that, to me, is a very emblematic bug of what I think is wrong with

1:59:53today's Apple software and their mentality, where it did catch up eventually, you know, but it should—

2:00:01Kyle: Well, it's the same thing. It's sort of—well, I don't know if it's—it's not

2:00:04what I'm saying. It's exactly the same thing. But it's also, from a user perspective, it's the same

2:00:09thing when you empty the trash and your available disk space doesn't change.

2:00:13Yes, yes, yes. It is exactly the same class of bug where it's like, all right, tenant

2:00:23one of anything related to the file system should be the actual bytes written to disk

2:00:32are maintained with the utmost integrity. So rule one, don't corrupt data. Actually

2:00:41corrupt it, right? Don't, you know, whereas corruption could be –

2:00:46Don't overwrite things.

2:00:47Don't overwrite it. Don't flip a bit. Don't have a – even, you know,

2:00:51just files that could be, you know, ruined with one zero turning into a one.

2:00:55Don't accidentally delete files. You know, don't – you know, the actual – you know,

2:01:03any way that the actual bytes on disk could go wrong, don't do that. But rule two – and it

2:01:09should actually be like rule 1a not even rule 2. 1a should be whatever you show to the user must be

2:01:20as accurate as possible. And the idea there is how is the user supposed to know if what is on their

2:01:31disk and I'm using disk to mean the thing you know it could be an SSD. What is it written to

2:01:38to permanent storage, how are they supposed to know that it's accurate? And the only way

2:01:43they can know is what is presented to them in the user interface. And so what's presented

2:01:48to them in the user interface should always be as accurate as possible. And in the old

2:01:56days of the Mac, I can't remember that ever being wrong. I can't remember there ever being

2:02:02a bug where getinfo would show you the wrong information. And it would, and you'll remember

2:02:10this, in the old days both a combination of the speed of spinning hard disks and the nature of

2:02:17the HFS and HFS+ file formats, you know, if you're an ATP listener insert your own ding there. Ding

2:02:27ding-dong, ding-a-ling, whatever they played. It was expensive, right? Like if you had a—especially,

2:02:34you know, the bigger the folder and the more items that were in it, it wasn't a very fast thing.

2:02:40Nature of the disk, nature of HFS Plus, that it wasn't, it automatically, you know,

2:02:45automatically computed what a folder size was. But it would never show you the wrong number.

2:02:52it would show you a placeholder. It might, you know, maybe like in a file listing, it

2:02:57would just be a dash. It wouldn't say zero, it would say dash. And if you did get info,

2:03:03it would spin while it was computing, which is exactly accurate, right? What does the

2:03:09spinner mean? The spinner means the computer is…

2:03:13I'm figuring it out.

2:03:14I'm figuring it out, which is exactly right. It would be better if it gave you the answer

2:03:18instantaneously, but it's still 100 percent truthful and accurate to show an animated

2:03:25spinner, right? It would be bad if that spinner just suddenly stopped, right? Because that

2:03:34would say to me, the user, "Oh, God, something's wrong with my disk." Right? Right? I mean,

2:03:41all of us who grew up in that era, we've probably shortened our lives to some extent.

2:03:47I've taken some amount of longevity out of my heart with actual disk problems and suspected

2:03:58disk problems, right? So if I, you know, in the old days, if I opened, if I'd selected a folder

2:04:04and did "getinfo" and it started spinning, and then the spinner just locked up, my heart would

2:04:10skip a beat. And then I, you know, I don't recall that actually happening, but that's what would

2:04:14have happened. You know, or like I always say, like, remember if you, like, when you'd hear,

2:04:18like, a clicking noise? If your hard disk started clicking, that was not good. It was a race against

2:04:26time. It was, you know, "Oh my god, what's the most important file on this disk?" It was like getting,

2:04:32you know, it was like getting, you know, your house is on fire. Well, first get the people out,

2:04:37get the dog out. Yeah. And now you start thinking, "What else can I get out of the house?

2:04:44What do I take? Right? That's what it was like if your hard disk started clicking. Showing

2:04:51zero bytes for a selection is, even if you eventually catch up 30 seconds later and show

2:04:57the right thing, is so wrong. It's so fundamentally wrong because it casts doubt on the integrity

2:05:06of your file system. And that is…

2:05:09I, yeah, I mean, that's, I would rather it's, even with the thing where you empty the trash

2:05:12and it's not, I would rather it would say, it would say "updating" or something, you know,

2:05:16like it's, it doesn't currently know. Although I think maybe they don't do it because it takes

2:05:22too long and it looks weird if it's updating for that. That also looks a little strange if

2:05:26it's updating for an awfully long time. But it's, it's much more accurate.

2:05:31Pete: It's worse than, it's downright wrong to show the wrong number.

2:05:35Brian: Yes.

2:05:36And it makes no sense like what you're saying

2:05:38I know what you're talking about like you think like you have like a disc like

2:05:40That's like almost out of space and you but there's like a giant thing you can throw out

2:05:44And you're like, oh that'll free up enough space you put it in the trash. You know, nothing happens

2:05:48And it's like what and and you can get different results different ways

2:05:56Like if you go to the new thing in the you know about this Mac that shows

2:06:03Storage, you know and it shows it like with a graph and you know, you go to about this Mac

2:06:08Oh, yeah, and then you hit manage and it's like it can show you different different numbers

2:06:14Then you get in the finder like that's insane

2:06:18it's absolutely insane and I just think that it's sort of indicative of a

2:06:24That

2:06:27inside Apple they've sort of lost sense of what should be at an utmost priority. And

2:06:33I think like accurately reflecting the current state of the file system in the user interface

2:06:40should be just a half step behind the importance of the actual integrity of your file system.

2:06:47Because from the user's perspective, how else are they to know? Yes, it would absolutely

2:06:51be worse if the actual file system were corrupted. And, you know, Apple, by all accounts, the

2:06:58whole transition to APFS has been a glorious success, right? It's, you know, I guess there's

2:07:06some hiccups at the outset, you know, there's some aspects of it that maybe haven't been

2:07:09completely perfect. But overall, millions and tens of millions, maybe hundreds of millions

2:07:16of devices, maybe, yeah, probably hundreds of millions of devices of Mac and iOS around

2:07:20the globe have been updated from the HFS+ file system to the APFS file system without

2:07:29anybody knowing and it all just worked and the APFS is better in a whole slew of ways

2:07:37and it's really and seemingly is terrific in terms of data integrity.

2:07:44It's a terrific success which is everything you'd want from an operating system vendor

2:07:48shipping a new file system. But their commitment to making sure that everywhere in the user

2:07:55interface that the file system can be reflected is always up to date or shows that it's in progress

2:08:03of getting up to date is, to me, inexcusable. Yeah. And I don't know what the technical—I mean,

2:08:10obviously, I don't know what the technical reason behind why it takes longer.

2:08:17I don't know either.

2:08:18- Now would be, I mean you'd think that,

2:08:20well, I don't know.

2:08:21- All right.

2:08:22- You think you're deleting 10 gigabytes.

2:08:24I mean, I know, I can see how big a file is.

2:08:26- Right.

2:08:27- You know?

2:08:28And if I delete that file,

2:08:29I can do the math practically in my head.

2:08:31- Well, if it's gonna take a while,

2:08:35tell me it's gonna take a while, you know what I mean?

2:08:37Don't, you know.

2:08:39- Right.

2:08:39- All right, on that upbeat note,

2:08:41let's take a third break here

2:08:42and thank our third and final sponsor, Squarespace.

2:08:44Oh, I love Squarespace.

2:08:45You guys know Squarespace.

2:08:47I'll tell you who doesn't know Squarespace.

2:08:50Siri doesn't know Squarespace.

2:08:51The other day I was texting somebody about Squarespace,

2:08:55and when I said Squarespace,

2:08:56I was actually using the Siri dictation,

2:08:58and it just spelled it lowercase s space space.

2:09:02It's like, come on, Siri, how do you not know Squarespace?

2:09:06Everybody knows Squarespace.

2:09:08I mean, Siri obviously doesn't listen to the talk show,

2:09:11'cause if Siri did, Siri would know Squarespace.

2:09:14Squarespace is the all-in-one hosting solution for websites.

2:09:19They've got everything.

2:09:20You won't need a website.

2:09:22You go to Squarespace and you can do everything

2:09:24from registering domains, picking a template

2:09:27to start with in the design, tweaking that template

2:09:30through an award-winning WYSIWYG interface

2:09:32right in your web browser, analytics so that you can see

2:09:37where people are coming to your website,

2:09:40and all of the components you might need.

2:09:43Like, you want to have a blog on your website,

2:09:46they've got it built in.

2:09:47You want to host a podcast on your website,

2:09:49they've got it built in.

2:09:50You want to sell things on your website,

2:09:52they have a store built right in.

2:09:55Any kind of website that you want to build,

2:09:58you can build it with Squarespace

2:09:59and it's almost certainly going to be 10 times less work

2:10:03than building it by hand.

2:10:04You can really go a long way

2:10:05and you don't even have to use their templates.

2:10:09You can customize the design with your own brand

2:10:12down to the Pixel.

2:10:14It's just a terrific service.

2:10:16Next time you or anybody you know

2:10:19who comes to you for technical help needs a new website,

2:10:22think about Squarespace.

2:10:23I would go there.

2:10:24Here's what you need to remember.

2:10:26If you wanna throw 'em the love from the talk show

2:10:29and their continuing support of this show

2:10:31and its sponsorships,

2:10:32send 'em to squarespace.com/talkshow.

2:10:38That's talk show, squarespace.com/talkshow.

2:10:42and use that offer code, talk show, when you pay,

2:10:47which you don't even have to do for 30 days.

2:10:48You get 30 days free.

2:10:50But when you do start paying, remember that code, talk show,

2:10:53you get 10% off your first order,

2:10:55you can prepay for a year.

2:10:57That's saving over a month right there,

2:11:00right off your first bill.

2:11:01So go to squarespace.com/talkshow.

2:11:03Next time you need a website, remember, Squarespace.

2:11:07Enough ranting about Catalina.

2:11:11What else we got?

2:11:12Let's go speed mode, right?

2:11:15Apple results warning due to coronavirus.

2:11:18So Apple last week had to correct their,

2:11:21just from January 28th estimate for the next quarter,

2:11:25for two reasons.

2:11:26Supply chain is messed up in China

2:11:31because of this coronavirus and the lockdown within China.

2:11:36- So they basically have closed plants

2:11:38in order to not further spread the virus, right?

2:11:40- Right, and this is at some, you know,

2:11:44somehow three weeks, in the three weeks

2:11:46since they issued their estimates,

2:11:48they've gotten a much more pessimistic viewpoint

2:11:52on both suppliers.

2:11:54It seems like some of it's suppliers

2:11:56as opposed to Apple's own factories at Foxconn,

2:12:01but you know, that's probably a little bit of column A,

2:12:03a little bit of column B.

2:12:05And then the other factor is retail demand within China

2:12:10because people aren't going out and stores are closed,

2:12:13and including Apple stores, and so,

2:12:15all of it not good, but I guess,

2:12:21it sounds to me like following the news,

2:12:23I know I'm not following it as closely as some people,

2:12:25but it seems like it's sort of under control,

2:12:28and being conservative about this,

2:12:32and taking it seriously seems like the right path,

2:12:35but it's not good for a company

2:12:37with a big foothold in China like Apple.

2:12:38and it sort of went through a phase where it was like, oh, this seems like a problem, but maybe

2:12:43it's not too big a problem. And then there was like a little bit of a floodgate opening where it

2:12:47seemed like, oh, it looks like the Chinese government maybe wasn't telling us all about

2:12:52every case that happened. And so, that prompted some further reaction.

2:12:58Pete: Yeah.

2:12:59Brian: And hopefully now, you know, they have

2:13:03gotten ahead of it.

2:13:05- Forward, yeah, I mean, they're now like,

2:13:08okay, this is the real deal

2:13:09and not what we were saying before.

2:13:11- Yeah, but it does seem like Apple's warning

2:13:14that iPhones might be short, in short supply.

2:13:18Who knows what else will be in short supply?

2:13:19I mean, AirPod Pros have been in short supply for months.

2:13:24- Yeah.

2:13:25- I mean, they're primarily warning about iPhones, but.

2:13:28- I need a new phone, John, that's all I know.

2:13:31(laughs)

2:13:33I want people to take care of themselves.

2:13:34you know, I don't want anybody going into a factory that's sick. I'm just also saying that I need new

2:13:40phones. Uh, Apple stiffing store employees. So Apple took a case to the California Supreme Court

2:13:49that the bay—it seems like a pretty simple story where they're either at all or most or some Apple

2:13:55retail stores in California, they've had a years-long policy of for security reasons requiring

2:14:02employees who come in with either bags or Apple devices to have them inspected every time they

2:14:10leave. I guess leave, I don't think it was. Yeah, I think it was just, yeah, it was just on the way

2:14:15out. Right, on the way out. But that includes like a lunch break. So like you leave for lunch,

2:14:20you still have to do it. And, but that you would clock out before you got in line. So in other

2:14:26words, you'd go to leave for lunch, you'd clock out, you're off the clock, and then you would have

2:14:30to wait in a line that could take upwards of 20 minutes at some point. Hopefully, hopefully that

2:14:36that 20 minutes is the exception rather than the norm, but that was—

2:14:40Pete: Wait, did they actually have a line or did they just make you stand in an area?

2:14:43Pete: Well, I guess it was stand in an area. Well, but if you're not in a queue—

2:14:47Pete; Stand over here. Someone will be with you shortly.

2:14:49Pete and Pete laugh.

2:14:54Pete; Because we don't want any lines.

2:14:56- Yeah, that would be a, I guess you're right,

2:14:58it would be unfair if it was a line

2:14:59because they should get a little dose of their own medicine.

2:15:02Yeah.

2:15:03That would be funny too, and if it was like,

2:15:06if it was hard to tell who the inspectors were.

2:15:09- Oh, right, right, because they're wearing the same,

2:15:11well, wearing the same kind of shoes.

2:15:12- Oh yeah, but I don't have the checkout machine,

2:15:15so you need that guy over there.

2:15:17- You're gonna have to wait over here.

2:15:19Someone will be with you.

2:15:21- That is the most Mac Apple nerd,

2:15:23insider-y joke I can imagine.

2:15:26It is perfect for this show.

2:15:28I can almost imagine it as like an SNL skit

2:15:32and it's an SNL skit that would be funny

2:15:36to about 150 people.

2:15:38- Exactly, yeah.

2:15:39But this is dumb, right?

2:15:41I mean, this is Apple being stupid.

2:15:43- It's incredibly stupid, I cannot understand it.

2:15:46I have heard from a couple of readers

2:15:50around the country at least that this security policy

2:15:54is not at every Apple store.

2:15:57There are some stores where people have said,

2:15:59hey, I've been working at an Apple store for a while,

2:16:01I bring my phone to work every day,

2:16:02and of course I bring my phone to work every day,

2:16:05and there is no line.

2:16:08So maybe it's at stores where there have been

2:16:11security problems.

2:16:12I'm not quite sure what, and Apple unsurprisingly

2:16:17isn't forthcoming about it, but it apparently is not

2:16:21a policy at every Apple store.

2:16:23May or may not even be the policy at most stores,

2:16:25but it's just common sense that if it's,

2:16:28even if it's just one store,

2:16:30that the clocking in and clocking out should happen

2:16:33after you get through the goddamn line.

2:16:35It's-- - Yeah.

2:16:37That's not cool.

2:16:40- I understand how it happened,

2:16:42how maybe they got into this, right?

2:16:44Like I'm sympathetic to, okay, this store seems

2:16:49to have had a problem where we suspect employees

2:16:52might be walking out with merchandise or something.

2:16:55So we're gonna have to inspect bags.

2:16:58Okay, I kinda get that.

2:17:00- And maybe logistically it's like, well, you,

2:17:04the clock out thing is over here and we can only put that,

2:17:09I mean, maybe there's something in there, but still.

2:17:11- And you optimistically, the security people

2:17:14optimistically think this will never take anybody

2:17:17more than 30 seconds to a minute.

2:17:19And they didn't foresee that like a whole,

2:17:25you know, 10 employees, 10 or 20 employees

2:17:28at big store maybe, you know, 20 employees

2:17:31all leave at the same time because their shift ends

2:17:35or maybe more, you know, and therefore there's a line

2:17:38and the line can take a while

2:17:39and you wound up with these employees

2:17:43who should be getting paid,

2:17:45spending 15, 20 minutes in a line not getting paid.

2:17:49I mean, it's obviously enough of a problem

2:17:50that they brought a lawsuit.

2:17:51I mean, I know some people, you know,

2:17:54you can complain about some frivolous lawsuits.

2:17:57This doesn't seem like a frivolous lawsuit at all.

2:17:59This seems like the system working.

2:18:01This is a legitimate lawsuit

2:18:03and what a class action suit is for.

2:18:08I understand how they got there.

2:18:09But once this got to the point where it became a lawsuit,

2:18:13And there was even a thing where it trickled up,

2:18:15you know, and apparently Tim Cook's first awareness of it

2:18:18was him, and it got entered into evidence,

2:18:21him emailing somebody, "Is this true?" question mark.

2:18:25I totally understand how, you know, Tim Cook might not,

2:18:28you know, I saw some people saying like,

2:18:29"That just shows that Tim Cook is, you know,

2:18:31"out of touch because he didn't know it was going."

2:18:34Tim Cook could not possibly be aware of the intricacies

2:18:38of day-to-day policy at every single Apple store

2:18:40in the world.

2:18:41That would be insane, right? You cannot be the CEO of Apple and be aware of things like

2:18:47that. But once it gets to the point where it does trickle up and it becomes a lawsuit,

2:18:51right, and it does cross his desk, I cannot for the life of me see how Apple's leadership

2:18:58cooked to their legal team at the executive level how they decided to fight this to the

2:19:05California Supreme Court rather than just pay. It just seems so wrong on the face of it.

2:19:11Right. I mean, what is it? It's like it's a few million dollars or something, isn't it?

2:19:17Well, I forget. It might be tens of millions.

2:19:20Yeah, I mean, something—yeah, but still, it's not in the range of something that Apple—that's

2:19:25really going to impact their bottom line.

2:19:28It's impossible to empirically measure PR value.

2:19:35But my spidey sense says that they've already lost way more than $20-30 million of PR value

2:19:44by losing this lawsuit and having news sites publicize that Apple, literally the richest

2:19:53corporation in the world is making retail employees wait in security lines off the clock,

2:20:00you know. And the part that I thought was so absurd is that it left fighting this, left

2:20:06Apple's own lawyers arguing that it's a, you know, you don't have to bring your iPhone

2:20:12to work. Right? And like somebody else pointed out to me, like, what about Apple Watch, right?

2:20:19like presumably you know you would think Apple would say that you know that the

2:20:27type of people who they want working in their stores are the type of people who

2:20:30they would like to own an Apple watch right and I've I've observed it myself

2:20:35it seems to me like just about everybody who works at Apple Store wears an Apple

2:20:39watch I don't know if that does is outside the inspection thing or whatever

2:20:43but it's like the phone though who doesn't go to work with their phone I

2:20:46I mean, it's insane.

2:20:48That's an absolutely, on its face, an absurd argument for Apple of all companies to be

2:20:55arguing.

2:20:56You know, like if 7-Eleven wanted to argue that its employees don't need to bring their

2:21:01cell phones to work, it's still a BS argument.

2:21:04But 7-Eleven isn't selling iPhones.

2:21:06It's selling the actual thing.

2:21:10Yeah.

2:21:12It's just a ridiculous argument.

2:21:15Yeah, no.

2:21:16Or the argument that, you know, I don't know of a single woman who doesn't take a purse with her to work.

2:21:23I mean, it's, you know, and plenty of men bring bags to work, you know, it's, you know,

2:21:29there's all sorts of, you know, it's just ridiculous to say that it's some kind of ridiculous,

2:21:33you know, you know, it's a privilege to be able to bring a bag with you to work. Like,

2:21:39well, I mean, this is, this is nuts. I mean, that's like, you know, maybe it's a privilege

2:21:44to be able to bring a bag with you to work if you're working in a prison camp making

2:21:48license plates. But yeah, I don't know. I thought that was a very strange story. And

2:21:56just I just don't understand. I mean, and you know, it wasn't like it got lost in some

2:22:00small court. I mean, this is the California State Supreme Court. Apple's home state. I

2:22:06mean, it's, it seems very odd to me that they decided to fight this. Yeah. I mean, I there

2:22:14must be some—

2:22:15Darrell Bock More to it than we're—something we're

2:22:19missing.

2:22:20Adam Boff Maybe, or that, yeah, like there's some

2:22:21precedent that they're worried about, or something, I don't know. I mean, maybe there's

2:22:24another aspect to it that we, you know, haven't considered. But on the face of it, it certainly

2:22:28seems extremely stupid.

2:22:30Darrell Bock Yeah, and I have to say that one of the privileges

2:22:33of me having the platform that I have is if I'll say something, if I'll post something

2:22:40that says, "This is stupid. I don't see any—this is no possible explanation for

2:22:43this." And there is, but I didn't see it. Usually, there's at least—you know, somebody

2:22:49will tweet or email me with the, "Yeah, well, but…" And I'm like, "Oh, okay."

2:22:54You know, I haven't seen one person propose a good reason for Apple to fight this. It's

2:23:00just a miniscule amount of money for them. You know, and if their retail stores were

2:23:07were eking out 3% margins.

2:23:09I guess I could kind of see it.

2:23:10And I realized that there are a ton of retail businesses

2:23:14that that's true for, right?

2:23:16Everybody knows that restaurants,

2:23:18it's a really hard business.

2:23:20Everybody knows that a new restaurant opens up

2:23:22and you fall in love with it and then it closes.

2:23:24It happens all the time because it's a hard business.

2:23:27It's really, really hard business.

2:23:28- I brought this steak to work.

2:23:30This is my steak.

2:23:33- Apple's retail stores are literally

2:23:35most profitable per square foot of any store in the world. They could afford to pay people to wait

2:23:42in the line that they're making them wait in line for. Oh, man. All right. Last but not least on my

2:23:50list of topics is Apple TV. You use Apple TV, right?

2:23:56I do, yeah.

2:23:57Do you…

2:23:58I have, um, I mean, do you mean just use the Apple TV app or watch the shows?

2:24:04Apple TV Plus.

2:24:05Well, both, but, you know, you use the device, right?

2:24:09Yep.

2:24:10Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, the physical device.

2:24:12Yeah.

2:24:13Yeah.

2:24:14But, you know, they added multiple users with the TVOS 13.

2:24:17Yeah.

2:24:18And it's…

2:24:19And I've set that up, but I don't think anybody's been using it.

2:24:23It's terrible.

2:24:25- And somehow while I was gone on a trip,

2:24:29we have family sharing and family sharing works great.

2:24:34Family sharing is one of the triumphs

2:24:37of Apple services business in my experience

2:24:39where for my family, you know, with three people,

2:24:43everything, all of our media sharing just works

2:24:47and anything I've ever purchased on iTunes,

2:24:50Amy and Jonas are able to play it without hiccup

2:24:54whenever they want.

2:24:55It's all been great, it's exactly what you want,

2:24:57it feels very fair.

2:24:59But this multiple user thing, so what happened was

2:25:05I was out for a weekend or day, I don't know,

2:25:09business trip, I don't know where,

2:25:11but Amy and Jonas wanted to watch a movie

2:25:13and so they entered Jonas's account as an extra account

2:25:16so they could buy the movie 'cause they didn't have,

2:25:19I don't know, I don't know why they did it.

2:25:22they should have just called me and had me buy the movie on my phone or something.

2:25:26But they didn't.

2:25:27They added Jonas as a user.

2:25:28And now we have two users on the Apple TV, me and Jonas.

2:25:32And I'm the one who watches the most stuff on it.

2:25:35Like Jonas watches almost everything on his laptop on his own.

2:25:42And Amy watches mostly stuff on TiVo.

2:25:44And when she does watch Apple TV, it's with me.

2:25:47And so she doesn't really have a reason to do it.

2:25:52But I watch stuff, and I'm enjoying the Star Trek Picard show on the CBS All Access.

2:26:01As am I.

2:26:02All right, that's what I wanted to know.

2:26:03I want to get to that.

2:26:04But part of it is, you know, it's not like Netflix.

2:26:11It's like most things where the episodes come out once a week.

2:26:16And what I would like to do when a new episode comes out is I'd like to go and go to the

2:26:19TV app and it'll say Picard. I see it and I go there and tap it and it'll know what

2:26:25the next episode I have to watch is. And like two weeks in a row now, it's like gone back

2:26:29to like episode two of the season. I'm like, "What the hell is going on?" And it's because

2:26:34and then I figured it out. It's because I go to settings, multiple users and the Apple

2:26:39TV keeps going back to Jonas instead of me. And I said, "Have you switched this?" And

2:26:45he's like, "No, I haven't even touched the Apple TV in weeks." You know, other than to

2:26:48to sit and watch a show, all three of us together.

2:26:52So the Apple TV is somehow switching back

2:26:55to Jonas instead of me without me doing it.

2:26:58And the insidious part about it is that the interface

2:27:01doesn't show you who's who.

2:27:05Yeah, yeah.

2:27:06Like Netflix has this licked where, like, I don't know

2:27:10what the timeout period is.

2:27:12But after some reasonable timeout period,

2:27:15and whatever it is, they've got it right,

2:27:17'cause it never seems annoying, like,

2:27:19"Hey, I just told you it was me."

2:27:21I come back to it, it's like, "It's still me."

2:27:23It's like, I don't know, after X amount of time,

2:27:25you fire up Netflix, and it says, "Who's watching?"

2:27:28And there's me, Amy, and Jonas.

2:27:30And I say, "It's me," and then it lets me pick up shows

2:27:34right where I left off, or Amy or Jonas.

2:27:36- It asks you that right at the beginning.

2:27:38- Right, and Disney+, which is a brand new app,

2:27:41does the same thing, and seemingly works just as well.

2:27:46Disney Plus, you know, we opened it up when I first signed up for Disney Plus. I told

2:27:52it about Amy and Jonas, and they're there, and we've got fun. A big advantage Disney

2:27:59Plus has over Netflix or anybody is you get the whole Disney library of avatars to choose

2:28:06from. Netflix has really got to get their act together on that. They've really…

2:28:12Yeah, their selection is...

2:28:14Right, that's not good.

2:28:16That was good.

2:28:17But at least, you know, it just says, like, "Who are you?"

2:28:19And you say, "Who am I?" And you have one tap, and then you're in, and then it shows you this stuff.

2:28:24Like, the Apple TV multiple users thing, A, should not be going back to another user without having specified it,

2:28:32and B, it doesn't show you who's who, right? So it's like...

2:28:36I find that I wonder does it does it save I mean I wonder if you can like just as a clutch fake that fake it by

2:28:43Putting one on light mode and one on dark mode hmm. I don't that stuff is stored that way

2:28:49I don't know system level. I'll try that, but I don't think it is and I have my Apple TV set up to do

2:28:55Light mode in the daytime and dark mode oh yeah time yeah, I don't want to mess with that

2:29:01But anyway, I figured something out last night while being frustrated because last night was when I caught up on the latest episode of Star Trek Picard

2:29:08I didn't know this. I don't know when they added it

2:29:11I presume it was actually with TVS 13 along with the multi-user thing if you hold down the home button on

2:29:17The on this the Apple TV remote that's the button that looks like a TV set. I

2:29:23Think it's called the home button

2:29:25I actually don't even know but it's next to the menu button if you hold that button down

2:29:30It actually slides this thing over from the right that looks like

2:29:34What's this thing called on the Mac the notification center thing? Yeah, it just slides over from the right and it shows

2:29:43with icons

2:29:45The users who have been set up and so I thought in select there. Yeah, you can select there

2:29:53So it'll it both highlights who the current user is and lets you change

2:29:58And so you don't I thought up until last night. I thought the only way to change users was to go settings

2:30:04Yeah system users and then pick a user by email address

2:30:10But I I think hiding it behind. I'm number one if I didn't know it. I mean boy

2:30:17That's a problem right because a I watch almost all my non sports TV on Apple TV

2:30:22And be I'm John Gruber. I'm

2:30:25I'm a professional critic of user interfaces and user of Apple software.

2:30:35I hope that doesn't sound self-serving, but that's a problem.

2:30:39It took me until the end of February of an OS that's been out for five months to figure

2:30:46out that you can do that.

2:30:48Anyway.

2:30:49Anyway, I'm trying to like it. Yeah. Okay. So I just brought up Netflix on this iPad I have here

2:30:53And yeah

2:30:54because because it seems like that like a like a device like an iPad or an iPhone you don't need it as much and

2:31:00in a way those devices

2:31:03Would make more sense for you to because because they're less likely to be handed around

2:31:09Whereas the on the Apple TV if anything you want it much more in your face because it's a thing that's attached to a big TV

2:31:16that's sitting in your living room and you want to be able to know whose account you're in.

2:31:21Pete: Yeah. Do you have a Nintendo Switch?

2:31:23Brian: Yes.

2:31:24Pete; I thought so. Have you, do you use it?

2:31:27Brian; Yeah, well, I use it to play games. I mean, I've not, yeah.

2:31:31Pete; Well, the Switch has a terrific interface for who the current user is.

2:31:37It always shows the users up in the top left and it very clearly badges who the current one is

2:31:45And it's such a great interface.

2:31:48Like, I don't know if I'll ever get to it,

2:31:51but I feel like I could do just-- I feel like if somebody else has

2:31:56written it, I would love to link to it.

2:31:58But--

2:31:59The only thing I wish it had was a passcode for each account,

2:32:02which it doesn't have a passcode.

2:32:05So Hank is forever getting into my Breath of the Wild games

2:32:10and screwing them up.

2:32:14You used all my arrows!

2:32:15See, that's less of a security problem and more of a parental problem.

2:32:21Yeah, yeah, which I have.

2:32:22Right. Like, you don't need to lock it down for security reasons. You need to lock it down

2:32:28because your son's a bit of a jerk.

2:32:30Exactly.

2:32:32It's a wonderful user interface. And I would have told you, if you had told me before I had used it

2:32:40that they were going to do a single user interface, not two different presentation modes, but

2:32:47it's effectively the exact same visual interface, both for a TV where you interact on an up,

2:32:54down, left, right, D-pad, and select button method with a controller, and as a handheld

2:33:03touch screen that you can tap, I would have said, "I don't think you can square that

2:33:08circle."

2:33:09You know, the things that make for a good TV size screen, TV sitting distance, D-pad

2:33:18and button interface are—I mean, just think about the differences between the iPad interface

2:33:26to watching a show and the Apple TV interface to watching a show.

2:33:31They're two totally different interfaces.

2:33:35I would have said—I would have thought off the top of my head, "You can't really

2:33:38square that circle. Nintendo has done it where either way it doesn't feel like a compromise.

2:33:43The TV one doesn't feel like you're using a tablet on a TV but somehow stuck with a

2:33:50D-pad. And when you're actually looking at it on the handheld, it doesn't feel like

2:33:55you're using this giant TV-sized interface squished onto the screen. It's a remarkable

2:34:02accomplishment of user interface design that I – to my knowledge, maybe I'm just not

2:34:08enough, I don't read enough Nintendo sites or something, hasn't been heralded enough as a triumph

2:34:13of design and user experience. But boy, I wish Apple TV were a lot more, TV OS, I wish, was a

2:34:23lot more like Switch OS in terms of clarity of who you are, where you are, it's TV.

2:34:32It's amazing how they got the Switch so right after the Wii U.

2:34:36Yes, totally.

2:34:39Really kind of a mess.

2:34:40Yeah, both ways. The Wii U was sort of like the opposite, where it was bad on the TV

2:34:46and really bad on the touchscreen.

2:34:48Right.

2:34:49And it just seems to me like Nintendo internally had a full reckoning and said, "Okay,

2:34:56let's literally go back to the drawing board and start all over and come up with something."

2:35:01But I would love a version of tvOS that took notes from everything that Nintendo got right

2:35:10with what I'm calling Switch OS.

2:35:13I don't know what the hell they call their operating system.

2:35:17The Switch OS offers so much clarity.

2:35:20In particular for me, and I think it makes sense, for anything you have hooked up to

2:35:24your TV, you want to have multi-users.

2:35:26The way that the Switch lets you switch users and shows you who is the user, I can't imagine

2:35:33how it's both clear who's who and who's current and very obvious how to switch.

2:35:40Yeah, and it's right.

2:35:42That's the thing I was going to say.

2:35:44Even compared to other gaming systems, I think it's much better because I struggle.

2:35:51I don't use the devices as much, maybe, so maybe that's part of the problem, but I

2:35:55I think just sitting down and trying to figure it out compared to the

2:36:00PS4 or the or the Xbox one is just like I mean, it's night and day

2:36:06It's very obvious on the switch how to do it and it's way less obvious on those other platforms

2:36:11PS4 I haven't used in a while. We used to

2:36:14For a while. We had it hooked up to our main TV because it was our DVD player and Jonas played games on it

2:36:21I didn't really play games for the most part, but I would watch DVDs

2:36:24But whenever I had to do something

2:36:26Yeah, I

2:36:29Would be like, you know, no, I would always think to myself, you know, it really does look pretty

2:36:35Yes, like it did that the ps4 interface to me does have that look of like this looks like the type of OS that

2:36:43like production designers for a movie would design for the in

2:36:49Fake. Yeah. Yeah the fake interface, you know

2:36:53You know or like the you know there's some cool. I always I'm a nerd for that stuff

2:36:57I love looking at the user interfaces in Westworld, and thank God Amy doesn't watch Westworld because I often pause

2:37:04She doesn't like sci-fi stuff, so she doesn't watch it

2:37:08But it would it would honestly I'd be divorced at this point because with Westworld

2:37:12I will pause the show and like get up close to the TV to look at the the tablets you know

2:37:18And I've been doing that with Picard too. I'm like oh man that looks cool

2:37:22Oh, man. Anyway, we've gone on a long time. I'm really liking the Picard show.

2:37:31Yeah. Yeah, I've heard a lot of people complain about the pace of it, but I kind of like it. It's

2:37:39a little slow. It's like you'd think that we would be someplace now where we'd be, I don't know,

2:37:45ramping up to something, and it still seems like they're putting the team together.

2:37:50I my favorite episode so far was the second to last I

2:37:56And I knew it I knew it when I saw that the written by credit was Michael Chabon who I've been a fan of

2:38:05his novels and I was so excited that he was part of the

2:38:08Team, you know executive producers and the writing team, but the episode that he wrote the second the last one was

2:38:16It was so good. That was it was the one where

2:38:19where he takes upon himself, I don't want to spoil it, but he takes upon himself his

2:38:28traveling partner from the Romulan outpost. Oh man, what a good show. What a good episode

2:38:35that was. But I'm really enjoying the whole show. And I have to admit, I have skipped,

2:38:40I was a die-hard Star Trek The Next Generation fan. Absolutely. It was one of my all-time

2:38:45favorite shows in my lifetime. Never missed an episode. And then in the intervening years,

2:38:51I'd start every episode of every series and always petered out. I never got into Deep Space Nine.

2:38:59That's the one I gave the biggest try to. Yeah, and yeah, that's it. You should check out like

2:39:05one of those things where, you know, where they say, "Just watch these episodes." You get a primer.

2:39:11because there are some particularly Deep Space Nine, I think, and the tail end of Deep Space

2:39:15Nine is terrific. Voyager doesn't have as great of an arc as Deep Space Nine develops, but it's got

2:39:23some good— Yeah, and then I totally skipped the Scott Bakula one.

2:39:27Yeah, that one you can pretty much totally skip. There's some good episodes like in the last season,

2:39:34but it's kind of rough going to get there, so. Anyway, I'm really liking Picard.

2:39:40For those of you out here who were Star Trek The Next Generation fans, I think it's worth watching.

2:39:46It is a totally different type of show because, you know, the story--

2:39:50But it is, but it does pay, you know, credit to the whole thing.

2:39:55I mean, it uses a lot of elements from various shows, and, you know, if you're a fan of those shows,

2:40:01it's so great just to have it back on TV.

2:40:05Yeah.

2:40:06I like Discovery, but it's not the same.

2:40:08Yeah, I didn't watch it. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think it's fun. There's things I like about it,

2:40:17but it doesn't feel anywhere close to what I liked about Star Trek. I think it's a decent

2:40:24science fiction show, but it doesn't feel like a really good Star Trek show. And this feels like

2:40:30a Star Trek show to me. It feels like a really good Star Trek show, and it's a really good step

2:40:36to the so the next generation was the traditional this is drama and every

2:40:41episode is the self-contained yeah and there it it wasn't necessarily that they

2:40:47didn't go in order but you could more or less tune in I mean they had they had

2:40:51certain they had some small arcs in there but and and then they had they

2:40:55definitely had some double partners but right definitely had double partners but

2:40:59for the most part there was all standalone little mini stories it was

2:41:02you know, like an anthology, whereas this is more like the, you know, the new mega movie, you know,

2:41:08the whole series is like a giant 10-hour movie or a 20-hour movie over two years or something

2:41:15like that. And it's made the shift in a way that to me feels very natural. Really good. I really

2:41:24like it so far. Anyway. And he's, you know, he's always a pleasure to watch. Yeah, I would, yeah,

2:41:29Yeah, it's like I would watch him like, man, I'd watch anything with...

2:41:35Yeah.

2:41:36Even like, the campy stuff in the most recent episode, I really enjoyed it.

2:41:39I just thought it was funny.

2:41:41Yeah.

2:41:42Just seeing him go nuts.

2:41:43Anything with Patrick Stewart.

2:41:44Yeah, yeah.

2:41:45Yeah, and that felt like a throwback to some of the, you know, it was a totally next generation

2:41:49type thing, you know?

2:41:50Yeah.

2:41:51Like a holodeck episode from the next generation.

2:41:54Right, right.

2:41:55Anyway, thank you, Jon.

2:41:57I appreciate it.

2:41:58I really appreciate it, doubly so because of the pre-show delays. I'll even apologize

2:42:06on behalf of my mom, who's a delightful woman who you would enjoy tremendously.

2:42:11Well, I hope she has no more technical problems this weekend.

2:42:16Let's plug some podcasts that you're on on a regular basis.

2:42:20I am on The Rebound, where we talk about many of the same things that we talk about in this

2:42:26podcast and Biff where we talk about superhero shows and movies and turning this car around.

2:42:34Where we talk about what a pain my kid is sometimes.

2:42:37[Laughter]

2:42:38Pete: How he uses up all your arrows.

2:42:40Jared; How he uses up my arrows.

2:42:42Pete; All right, let me thank our sponsors.

2:42:44Our sponsors, Squarespace, that's where you go to build a website.

2:42:48Away, that's where you go to buy a new suitcase.

2:42:52and Collide, where you go to manage your fleet of Apple devices or Windows and Linux too

2:42:59for your growing company.

2:43:00So, my thanks to them.

2:43:01Thank you, John.

2:43:02John: Thank you.

2:43:03Always a pleasure.

2:43:03Always a pleasure.