Podcast Search

The Talk Show

276: ‘Bring It On, Haters’ With Ben Thompson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00- We're gonna make people so angry on this episode.

0:00:04- Well, just for the record, it is 7.16 a.m.

0:00:07- Yeah.

0:00:08- On a holiday week, the kids are still in bed.

0:00:10And I insisted I'd be happy to wake up early

0:00:14because I'm very excited about this episode.

0:00:18Which we've been, it was funny 'cause we'll get to it later,

0:00:21but I was actually confused when you posted

0:00:24because we'd been talking about it for so long,

0:00:27I thought you'd already written about it.

0:00:28No.

0:00:30We'll have to get to it then.

0:00:33We have some sad news, though, to talk about first.

0:00:35We have two obituaries to touch upon.

0:00:41The one everybody, I'm sure, has heard about is Kobe Bryant,

0:00:46Lakers superstar, which I hate to say,

0:00:49it almost is like underselling what he meant to basketball

0:00:53and the world at large.

0:00:56died, passed away with his 13-year-old daughter

0:00:59in a helicopter accident Sunday afternoon.

0:01:03Just shocking.

0:01:04And Clayton Christensen,

0:01:07we can talk about after Kobe, I guess,

0:01:10lost, he was only 67,

0:01:12which again, nowhere near as young as Kobe.

0:01:14Of course, he was 41, but still, just 60, you know.

0:01:17That's how you know you're getting old,

0:01:18is when you hear somebody die at 67

0:01:20and you think, "Ah, too young."

0:01:22- Yeah.

0:01:23No, I mean--

0:01:24- He lost a battle with leukemia this week too.

0:01:26- Yeah, I actually, I wrote about them in conjunction

0:01:30because it was interesting because I had planned

0:01:32to sort of write about Christiansen.

0:01:35Obviously it's been a huge impact on Sir Chachere

0:01:39and on me and didn't really, didn't know him.

0:01:43But still, of anyone that's sort of been impactful

0:01:48on what I write about, he's certainly top of the list

0:01:51and a figure that's sort of widely known

0:01:54and pretty widely revered in Silicon Valley.

0:01:56And what was interesting about it,

0:02:00then sort of the Kobe news happened,

0:02:02and it was the age thing that was so striking to me,

0:02:05because a lot of the people that have died,

0:02:09or the older we get, the more the people that are like,

0:02:12we're familiar with dying,

0:02:13it's just kind of like something that you have to deal with.

0:02:16They still always seem someone that I looked up to.

0:02:19And Christian, to your point, is 67, which is unfortunately too young, but is still 28 years older than I am.

0:02:27And it's like, man, that's a shame.

0:02:31I hope I live longer than that, his poor family, etc., etc.

0:02:35But it's still like, the way they're in your head is someone that you look up to, right?

0:02:40Whereas Kobe, he was the same age as me, right?

0:02:45I mean, he's two years older.

0:02:47Yeah.

0:02:47And so yes, you look up to his athletic accomplishments,

0:02:51and obviously Kobe is a very complex character.

0:02:55That is never far from mine, I think,

0:02:57particularly with people my age,

0:02:59because of the allegations against him from Colorado.

0:03:03That's sort of like, when you grew up with him,

0:03:06I remember him in high school.

0:03:07I remember when he came to the NBA.

0:03:08I remember when he won the titles with Shaq.

0:03:10I remember when that trial dominated the news.

0:03:14I remember when he sort of came back to win the title again.

0:03:17And it was much more of a,

0:03:19I'm not saying I'm Kobe's peer,

0:03:21but it's like, it's just like,

0:03:22I feel like my relationship with him

0:03:24is so much different than my relationship with Christiansen,

0:03:26neither of whom I knew,

0:03:28but just because the age was very different.

0:03:30So it was way more jarring for me,

0:03:31like dramatically more jarring.

0:03:32It's like, this is like my contemporary.

0:03:34- Yeah.

0:03:35I'm a little bit in between.

0:03:36I mean, I'm 46, so Jordan's 10 years older than me,

0:03:40and Kobe was five years younger,

0:03:43so I'm a little closer in age to Kobe,

0:03:45but he always felt, you know.

0:03:46And it is one thing, I know I don't wanna turn this

0:03:48into a sports episode of the show,

0:03:52but one thing about being a sports fan

0:03:55is you're far more than other forms

0:03:59of knowing famous people, like following politics closely

0:04:03or like traditional celebrity news,

0:04:08like actors and actresses,

0:04:10is you're acutely aware of their age and your age.

0:04:13You know, like how old is Brad Pitt?

0:04:15I don't know, I have no idea.

0:04:16The guy doesn't seem to age.

0:04:17You know, Tom Cruise, I mean, Jesus Christ,

0:04:19the guy looks exactly the same as he did 25 years ago.

0:04:22You know, and you can keep,

0:04:26these guys can keep making the same sort of movies

0:04:28they used to make.

0:04:29I mean, Harrison Ford was making,

0:04:31is still making action movies.

0:04:32I mean, he looks his age now,

0:04:33but I mean, they're still gonna make

0:04:34a new Indiana Jones movie, you know what I mean?

0:04:36Like athletes don't get to do their thing

0:04:39when they're honestly pushing 40.

0:04:43It's a wonder that there are quarterbacks in the NFL

0:04:48who are 40, 41, 42 still doing their thing.

0:04:52Basketball doesn't really work that way.

0:04:54Although, I just saw somebody in the NBA is 42

0:04:57and still log in minutes.

0:04:59- Well, we have Vince Carter, that's a huge exception.

0:05:02And if there's the NBA is in particular,

0:05:04'cause it's so, I mean, the edges are so small

0:05:07when it comes to sort of athleticism.

0:05:08there's guys that are coming in the league now,

0:05:10and they're coming in, it's like, oh, he's 21 years old.

0:05:13That reduces his value as a prospect,

0:05:15because he has, as a parent to a 19-year-old,

0:05:18those two years of potential development

0:05:20make a big difference, but the implication is,

0:05:22to your point, yeah, you're super aware

0:05:25of how old everyone is, because it's a critical part

0:05:27of evaluating their potential,

0:05:31how much it should be paid, et cetera, et cetera.

0:05:33And yeah, there, the prime of your career

0:05:37like 27 to 29 years old and and yeah and so the guys that guys that sort of retire it's like yeah

0:05:44they've been on the downswing for a while you kind of know what's coming and and um you know

0:05:50certainly we went through that went through that with with bryant and uh and yeah but but it's like

0:05:56but it makes it almost more tragic in a way because it's like all right now on one hand it's

0:06:02like oh wait you know if cody bryant was put on earth to play basketball he played basketball

0:06:06played it well, accomplished all he could accomplish, and that was that. On the other hand,

0:06:10you know, he more than most athletes really seemed to be leaning into sort of, you know,

0:06:17his second act as it were. And he was so clearly, you know, for, you know, again, say what you will

0:06:26and what needs to be said about his past. He was so clearly devoted to his family and, you know,

0:06:31like the whole reason he had a helicopter was because he wanted to be able to drive his kids

0:06:34He'd take his to school in the morning

0:06:35and pick him up in the afternoon.

0:06:36And that was the only way that was viable in Los Angeles.

0:06:38And so he's been on thousands of helicopter rides.

0:06:41And it's like, oh man, it's rough.

0:06:46- Yeah, I saw it.

0:06:47There was a, it's just a heartbreaking clip.

0:06:49I mean, all of it's heartbreaking.

0:06:50It's just tragic.

0:06:51But there was a clip of him on the Jimmy Kimmel show

0:06:54recently, and I guess he has, or had, four daughters.

0:06:58And-- - One was just born.

0:07:01- Yeah, one was just born in June.

0:07:02but he has one who's older, his second daughter was 13,

0:07:06and she was the one who died with him

0:07:08when the helicopter crashed going to a basketball game.

0:07:11But he was talking to Jimmy Kimmel,

0:07:14and I didn't see the initial context for the interview,

0:07:17but it was basically that people keep coming up to him

0:07:19and saying, "Hey, you got all these girls,

0:07:20"but you gotta keep going, you gotta have a boy,

0:07:21"someone to carry on your legacy, have a boy."

0:07:24And he was like, "Hey, I already got a kid

0:07:25"who's gonna carry on my legacy, Gigi," his daughter,

0:07:28and that she's really good at basketball.

0:07:32That's the one who died with him and then I was watching there were some clips on Twitter of her playing and man

0:07:36There was a place she made as a 13 year old. It's like oh my god

0:07:39There was this play where she stole the ball

0:07:42I get a press and then like did like a spin move between two defenders and then like the nicest little easiest finger roll and it

0:07:49Was like oh my god that she's got it. You know, she had it

0:07:53Just I'm tearing up as I think about it

0:07:58I mean, I'm not I'm a sports fan certainly not a Lakers fan

0:08:01but it's like, man, when somebody dies,

0:08:02I mean, you don't have to root for the team to just,

0:08:05your heart just goes out.

0:08:07And you're a bigger basketball fan than me,

0:08:09but man, you just, what Kobe meant

0:08:12to that generation of players, it's just unbelievable.

0:08:15- Oh, that's something that's been super striking to me.

0:08:18Because for you and I, it was Jordan, right?

0:08:20Like, Jordan was the guy, you know,

0:08:22I mean, just to do a rough analogy,

0:08:24like, Jordan was like the Clay Christensen for me,

0:08:27like, where you look up to him, like, you grow up with him.

0:08:29Like he came in the league, you know, when I was just when I was just a kid and his dominant years in the 90s

0:08:35I was in high school and so, you know

0:08:37He was someone like he was older like he was doc

0:08:40He was there present my whole life like even like the bird and Johnson, you know, Magic Johnson era like that's probably

0:08:47What they were for you is what Jordan was for me

0:08:50Yeah, like they were already there when I got there. I mostly remember them as a little kid

0:08:53Well, and I mostly remember their their their sort of decline when I remember sort of their their prime

0:08:58Yeah, I was yeah, but the age difference is such that the bird magic dr

0:09:03J era is a little bit more for me what Jordan was for you

0:09:06But like burden magic rookie year was 79 or 80 80

0:09:1179 - 80 maybe like where the 80

0:09:14the 1980 finals was the one where Kareem had the the killer migraine headache couldn't play and

0:09:21Magic who was the point guard played center came into Philly and won a huge game as the center

0:09:28- Yup.

0:09:29- When he played, I mean, it helps when you're 6'9",

0:09:31you know, that you can just sub in for Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

0:09:35in the NBA Finals as a point guard.

0:09:37- Right, we're the greatest players of all time.

0:09:39- But still, it just showed that he was there.

0:09:41But 1980, I was only seven years old,

0:09:43I don't friggin' remember, I can't say it.

0:09:45So by the time I really understood basketball,

0:09:47Bird and Magic and Dr. J were already the guys,

0:09:52you know what I mean?

0:09:53They were just there, they were the NBA.

0:09:56And Jordan was the first player at that level,

0:10:00like someone who's in the argument

0:10:03for best player of all time.

0:10:04And who, I still would say is the best player,

0:10:06but somebody who was in that argument,

0:10:08who I remember being drafted, playing,

0:10:13I remember Jordan playing college,

0:10:15I remember when Jordan was on the Olympic team

0:10:18with Bobby Knight as the coach.

0:10:20And I remember, I remember the one,

0:10:24I mean, again, I wanna talk about Kobe,

0:10:26but I just remember, as like a seminal moment,

0:10:28I remember the time, this '86 season,

0:10:30when Jordan had a knee injury

0:10:32and missed a ton of the regular season

0:10:33and played in the playoffs

0:10:35and lit the Celtics up for like 64 points

0:10:37in a playoff game.

0:10:39And the Celtics ended up wanting,

0:10:41but Bird said something after the,

0:10:43and Bird was like the most competitive,

0:10:45rotten son of a bitch who ever played sports

0:10:47and he was just like,

0:10:48even though they hadn't finished the series yet,

0:10:50he was like, "Yeah, he's the best player of all time."

0:10:52(laughing)

0:10:54which is not easy for those guys to say.

0:10:56- No, not easy for Larry Bird to say.

0:10:58- But that's the thing though,

0:10:59is the way we feel about Jordan and Bird,

0:11:02or you feel about Bird and Magic,

0:11:04that's how all the players today feel about Kobe.

0:11:05- Yeah, totally.

0:11:06- And so it's like when you see them so devastated

0:11:09that all the guys in the NBA looked up to him.

0:11:13And he was like, he's your favorite player's

0:11:18favorite player, basically, is the way to think about it.

0:11:21And you can understand, it was like an age thing.

0:11:24That makes me feel old, right?

0:11:26It makes me feel old to see all these NBA players

0:11:29that I love to watch, but they're all at least

0:11:32like 10 years younger than me, right?

0:11:33So of course Kobe's their guy, and it's not Jordan

0:11:36in the latest for me.

0:11:37- I know all of these guys, yeah, exactly what you said.

0:11:41He meant so much to all of these guys,

0:11:42and there's so many of them who say,

0:11:43yeah, that's the guy who I watch,

0:11:45and I was like, yeah, I wanna be in the NBA.

0:11:47But one of the guys who stood out to me,

0:11:50I mean, they have so many comments,

0:11:51many tearful interviews in the last few days, but Steph Curry was talking about, I saw Steph Curry

0:11:57and Steph said that the searing memory for him was that game where Kobe scored 80. And he's like,

0:12:05"Look, I know Wilt Chamberlain scored 100, but I can't relate to that." And that might stand for the

0:12:12ages. But that was like 1961 or something like that. These guys saw Kobe Bryant score 80 points

0:12:18In a game and that's like what Steph was saying like I saw it. You know and it was like the modern game

0:12:23Like I know and I know now I'm in the league and I know what that means

0:12:27You know like I know how impossible that is to rack up 80 points in a game. You know and

0:12:31It's just unbelievable

0:12:34The thing with the other thing with the other thing with him is you know I wasn't like a fan either

0:12:39I wasn't a Kobe fan. I've been you know there's a

0:12:42You know particularly the waiters. You know he's notorious for you know he's gonna get his shots up

0:12:47You say it was a modern game.

0:12:49It was a modern game relative to Wilt,

0:12:51but modern to today's more space-oriented,

0:12:54three-point oriented, a bit more different,

0:12:59different for sure.

0:13:01But I think the thing that,

0:13:02what marks this sort of,

0:13:05there's different levels of greatness.

0:13:07There's greatness purely in a basketball sense.

0:13:09Like Tim Duncan, probably from a pure basketball sense,

0:13:12a better player, more significant than Kobe.

0:13:17but from a cultural sense, from the holistic nature of basketball, where it's not just about

0:13:22what happens on the court, but the impact on those around you, the entire media landscape,

0:13:28the sort of expansion of the NBA to China is a huge part of this. Like, Kobe was astronomically

0:13:35more important than Tim Duncan. You know, it's kind of like, if you take a feeds and speeds

0:13:39approach to basketball, you know, to tie it to like a sort of tech idea, like, yeah, Tim Duncan

0:13:44as better feeds and speeds relative to Kobe,

0:13:46like sort of historically speaking,

0:13:47but if you take a holistic view of all,

0:13:50everything that goes into being a basketball player,

0:13:51everything that goes into being significant and meaningful,

0:13:54like Kobe is just so much bigger,

0:13:57and again, I say that as someone that's not a Kobe fan,

0:14:00but it recognizes the fact that the impact

0:14:03is just so huge.

0:14:07- If you could go back in time

0:14:09and draft either him or Tim Duncan as the GM of a team,

0:14:13and your goal is to win championships,

0:14:15I would take Tim Duncan in a heartbeat.

0:14:17Although maybe you kinda wanna make sure

0:14:21you have Pop there too.

0:14:22- Well it's interesting, if you're a market like San Antonio

0:14:25you wanna take Tim Duncan a million times out of a million.

0:14:28If you're the Lakers, you wanna take Kobe.

0:14:30Like you're the Lakers.

0:14:31You're like the Lakers more than any franchise

0:14:34are absolutely about winning.

0:14:36They're the winningest franchise in history,

0:14:39but they're also about the show.

0:14:42I hate to say it, I hate the Lakers,

0:14:43particularly as a Bucks fan, losing,

0:14:46you know, he's talking about Kareem Abdul-Jabbar,

0:14:47like he was a Buck and lost into the Lakers

0:14:51because he wanted to go to the big market,

0:14:52the bright lights, and honestly,

0:14:54Milwaukee probably wasn't the greatest place

0:14:55for someone like him at that time in history.

0:14:58But they're probably, along with the Yankees,

0:15:03or at least in North American sports,

0:15:05the greatest franchise because they do it all.

0:15:09They win and they're like the star.

0:15:12And they're like the top of the town.

0:15:13- It's gotta be a show.

0:15:14- Exactly, exactly.

0:15:16- Yeah, and I was gonna say,

0:15:17if you're running a sneaker company

0:15:19and you wanna sign, you know,

0:15:20rookie Tim Duncan or rookie Kobe Bryant to a deal,

0:15:24you want Kobe.

0:15:25- I don't even know which sneaker company

0:15:29Tim Duncan was in.

0:15:29- No, I don't know either.

0:15:30I really don't.

0:15:31Whereas everybody knows Kobe was with Nike.

0:15:35- Everyone in the NBA wears,

0:15:37I'm pretty sure it's the most popular shoe.

0:15:38something like 33% or something, where are Kobe's?

0:15:41- Which is crazy, right, for a retired player.

0:15:44Just so sad, really sad.

0:15:49And then Christensen, Clayton Christensen.

0:15:51I don't know what's more likely.

0:15:54I know that people, you know, there's a lot of people

0:15:56listening to the show who don't know sports.

0:15:58Maybe it's possible that there's more people listening

0:16:00who do know Clayton Christensen.

0:16:01- Do know Christensen, no.

0:16:02This is a very unique audience.

0:16:05- But he's best known for his,

0:16:08- I would say, I mean, for his theory of disruption,

0:16:11which I should let you summarize.

0:16:12(laughing)

0:16:13'Cause I know you-- - Well, basically.

0:16:15(laughing)

0:16:18So the theory in general is that

0:16:19if the established sort of companies in a market,

0:16:24they succeed by listening to their customers.

0:16:26And at some point, though, they sort of like,

0:16:29they deliver a product that is good enough

0:16:32for most customers, and so in the pursuit of growth,

0:16:35they follow and listen to their most valuable customers

0:16:40and most demanding customers,

0:16:44and the products they build become more and more powerful,

0:16:45more and more feature-filled, and more and more expensive.

0:16:48And what happens is, a technological change enables

0:16:50some new entrant to serve the same market,

0:16:54but the new entrant serves people

0:16:57that don't need the big product,

0:17:00that have different needs,

0:17:03and they can't afford a big product.

0:17:01and it's worse, it's a worse product.

0:17:02And this worse product comes in and it sort of

0:17:04builds up a base and it starts to improve

0:17:07and because it's the worst product,

0:17:08it improves much more rapidly than sort of

0:17:10the existing product and it's lower priced

0:17:12because of technology and it sort of pulls in

0:17:17and starts to capture, slowly go up market,

0:17:19pulling in more and more people until the incumbent

0:17:21is left with nothing but the highest end customers

0:17:23and the super complicated, super expensive product

0:17:25and this low end product sort of takes the entire market

0:17:27from underneath them.

0:17:29And so you can sort of see the allure here to technology,

0:17:34because a technology change is critical to disruption.

0:17:38If you're just a cheap product,

0:17:41it's not a disruptive product,

0:17:42because by the time you become as full featured

0:17:45as the existing product, you're gonna be the same price.

0:17:48The analogy I think is commonly used is,

0:17:51if you're a Motel 6, you're not disruptive

0:17:53to the Ritz-Carlton.

0:17:56If you wanted to actually provide the same level of service

0:17:58product that the Ritz-Carlton did, you have to charge as much as Ritz-Carlton does. You're

0:18:02cheap because you deliver a cheap product. Whereas Airbnb is disruptive to Ritz-Carlton

0:18:08because a technological change, which is sort of a platform that commoditizes trust where

0:18:14you don't need sort of the brand name, you can start delivering on different vectors,

0:18:18having a kitchen, having a yard, having a different location, all these sorts of things that

0:18:23actually make it competitive in a way that's impossible for sort of a Ritz-Carlton to respond

0:18:29in a sort of one-to-one fashion.

0:18:31So to articulate this, you know, this is something, you know, and I certainly feel this too, there's

0:18:39a big aspect of writing about these sorts of things where it's something that people

0:18:43sort of knew and had an intuitive grasp on, and what's powerful is that someone sort

0:18:48of write it down and put it in writing.

0:18:50this is actually, there's a systematic way

0:18:52that this works again and again.

0:18:54And I think that's what Christian did,

0:18:56particularly for the first wave of technology.

0:19:00Like he wrote that in 1997,

0:19:02which is sort of the end of the IT era,

0:19:05the sort of beginning of the internet era.

0:19:07And it was a sort of, I think,

0:19:10catalyzing moment for a lot of executives

0:19:13and venture capitalists that's like,

0:19:14oh, that makes sense, I've seen this before.

0:19:17- This is what keeps happening over and over again.

0:19:20over again. And this is the pattern I should look out for.

0:19:24- That's right, that's right. And what's interesting is

0:19:26Christensen wrote it mostly for sort of existing,

0:19:29you know, he worked at Harvard Business School,

0:19:30so he writes it for existing managers of existing companies.

0:19:33But VCs and tech executives took it as like marching orders,

0:19:37right, 'cause they didn't want to look at being

0:19:40the incumbent companies, like, oh, we're trying to build

0:19:42the new entries, the new entrance to these industries,

0:19:45you know, leveraging technology to have a sort of

0:19:47fundamental cost advantage going forward,

0:19:49where we can deliver a crappier product that attracts users,

0:19:52but over time becomes something that's very competitive

0:19:55with them and beats them.

0:19:56- Yeah, and I think that he helped systemize

0:20:02in a very cogent way.

0:20:06Like, there's a lot of people in that racket,

0:20:09whatever you would call what he did,

0:20:11whose writing I find impenetrable.

0:20:13Whereas I always found the stuff I read of his

0:20:18Very cogent, very clear.

0:20:20And I think what he helped systemize was this idea that

0:20:23what heretofore a lot of people had chalked up

0:20:29to a bunch of unrelated flukes.

0:20:31Like, you know, the Japanese import cars

0:20:38coming in and taking over the,

0:20:41maybe not taking over is the wrong word,

0:20:43but certainly completely disrupting

0:20:46the US automobile market.

0:20:47I think is a prime example.

0:20:50I know one of his biggest case studies

0:20:52was like the steel industry and the way that lower cost--

0:20:56- Mini mills. - Yeah, mini mills

0:20:58took the market out from under US steel.

0:21:02And I think a lot of people looked at all these things

0:21:04as a series of flukes.

0:21:06In the computer industry,

0:21:08mainframes went to microcomputers,

0:21:11and microcomputers were like terribly misnamed

0:21:14'cause they were huge.

0:21:16- I know, what's funny is it was a terrible,

0:21:18it was a terrible naming in general,

0:21:21'cause the personal computer was terribly named as well.

0:21:22- Yeah, terribly.

0:21:23- The phone's the personal computer, right?

0:21:25- Yeah, totally. - Looking back, it's like

0:21:26this desktop big thing on your thing,

0:21:28oh, it's the personal computer.

0:21:29- I think I wrote that at one time,

0:21:30and if I didn't, do I, I sure wish I did.

0:21:32I think I did, I think there was a

0:21:33daring fireball piece one time

0:21:34where I was like, one of my reviews of the iPhone,

0:21:36where I was like, we blew it,

0:21:37we wasted the name personal computer,

0:21:39because this is the personal computer.

0:21:42But microcomputers were only micro compared to mainframes.

0:21:47And again, over and over again, this is a toy,

0:21:51these aren't serious, and then all of a sudden

0:21:53they put the other thing out of business,

0:21:54and then the personal computer came in and they were toys,

0:21:57and they're not useful for anything real,

0:22:00and they're for hobbyists and people with unkempt beards.

0:22:04And then next thing you know,

0:22:05nobody knows what a microcomputer is.

0:22:07And it happens over and over again.

0:22:09and if they weren't flukes, that this is a pattern.

0:22:12- Yep, I think that that's exactly right.

0:22:15I mean, the, it's super interesting

0:22:20because it means a lot to me personally,

0:22:22in part because a big,

0:22:25well, there's two parts with Christians.

0:22:26I wrote about this a little bit in Daily Update this week.

0:22:29The first one was I went to business school

0:22:31not because I really wanted to go to business school,

0:22:33but because I was an English teacher in Taiwan,

0:22:35and it was the shortest, fastest route to legitimacy

0:22:38in the US job market.

0:22:38I'm like, you know, like I just wanted to weigh in to sort of US tech companies and

0:22:43I thought, you know, I had been growing up on sort of tech culture online where the NBA

0:22:47is worthless, etc, etc. So I was very sort of cynical and skeptical going in. And one

0:22:53thing was just one, like being exposed to Christians in there, it was like, whoa, this

0:22:57is amazing, right? Like, I didn't even realize, you know, how influential he was in tech.

0:23:01I hadn't read him until I got to business school. It's like, it was so, to your point,

0:23:06It was so intuitive.

0:23:07And what's so fascinating about his insight

0:23:12is so many sort of strategic evaluations,

0:23:16and you look at companies and why they do what they do,

0:23:19distilled to, wow, they're dumb.

0:23:20(laughing)

0:23:22Actually, no, these companies are filled

0:23:24with very smart people.

0:23:25And what was so interesting about disruption as a whole,

0:23:28and I think is one of my biggest meta takeaways from it,

0:23:31is the implication of it is managers can fail

0:23:35by doing exactly what they're supposed to do.

0:23:37Like their mistake, quote unquote,

0:23:40is serving their customers well.

0:23:43And it's like, well that's what's so elegant

0:23:47about the theory, it's not saying

0:23:48that they're doing things wrong,

0:23:50it's that by doing things right,

0:23:52they're putting themselves in an uncompetitive position

0:23:54if some sort of paradigm change comes along.

0:23:57And you see this again and again in technology

0:23:59where the companies are dominant in one area

0:24:01and they're like, why do startups succeed

0:24:03in displacing them?

0:24:04Well, because something fundamental in the core model shifts at the startup by virtue of being a startup can adapt themselves to and take advantage of in a way that an existing company with tons of people and tons of resources can't.

0:24:16And I think almost the meta point, where it's like a cultural point and a cost structure point where you get locked into a way of doing business and aren't able to respond, it's what enables startups to succeed against super, you know, like startups don't just beat struggling companies, they

0:24:34beat successful companies.

0:24:35Why does that happen?

0:24:36So it was like that matter point, I think,

0:24:39is interesting as well.

0:24:41But so that like was--

0:24:42I first wrote about Christiansen in business school saying,

0:24:45why has Apple not been disrupted?

0:24:47And that was trying to sort of like put them together,

0:24:51like the things about disruption and Apple's successes

0:24:55seemed to go counter to that.

0:24:56But by the time I started Chitekery,

0:24:58which is a couple of years later,

0:24:59I actually thought that-- because Christiansen

0:25:01was very critical of the iPhone.

0:25:03- I was gonna get to this, yeah.

0:25:05- It's possibilities, right?

0:25:07He thought Nokia wasn't gonna back

0:25:09'cause it's a state of technology, et cetera, et cetera,

0:25:10and I'm like, no, that's wrong.

0:25:13And actually, I actually wrote an article called

0:25:16Why Clay Christensen is Wrong,

0:25:17which was probably pretty combative in retrospect,

0:25:21but this was me, like, you know,

0:25:23fresh blogger, out of business school,

0:25:25wanting to make a name for himself,

0:25:27and so I was probably a little more aggressive

0:25:30in my titling then than I would be now.

0:25:32But it was, you know, it's like, I mean,

0:25:36it's like Kobe, you know, Kobe Indian

0:25:39wants to play Michael Jordan, he wants to beat him, right?

0:25:40It's like, me wanting to take that on

0:25:44was because he was such an intellectual hero for me

0:25:48that like the greatest honor I could do,

0:25:49it was like, I'm gonna take you on.

0:25:51Like, I'm gonna say why this is wrong.

0:25:52And you know, probably a bit audacious and brash

0:25:55in retrospect, but it was a testament

0:25:58to how much I looked up to him and his work

0:26:01I would even think to write a piece called that.

0:26:04- Yeah, basically, and I think he came around on this too,

0:26:08and I think in a very interesting way,

0:26:10and it just shows how intellectually,

0:26:12his intellectual approach was the right way,

0:26:17which was that he's, you know, to me, it's a huge thing.

0:26:20Are you willing to admit a mistake?

0:26:21It's one of the biggest things in the world.

0:26:23And to me, it's, I mean, we could do a whole show

0:26:25about how the whole world's going to hell in a handbasket

0:26:27because nobody's willing to reconsider their views

0:26:30on anything. But like I've always said, the only way to be right all the time is to more or less,

0:26:35try to be right all the time, be smart enough to be right most of the time, but be humble enough

0:26:41to recognize when you're wrong and then correct it. And if you can do that, then you can come

0:26:45really close to being right all the time. But you've got to have that, that last part is

0:26:49important because you're going to be wrong sometimes. You know, I am, no doubt about it.

0:26:54But I thought his analysis of the iPhone was interesting.

0:26:57Was that,

0:26:58and,

0:27:00if, you might have been wrong even if Apple had made

0:27:06the iPod phone that we had,

0:27:08a lot of us had been expecting.

0:27:09But basically he thought, you know, this is expensive,

0:27:12this is coming in at the high end.

0:27:14Yes, it's, you know, just, you know,

0:27:16it's certainly innovative and it's ahead of the pack,

0:27:19but that the pack is gonna catch up

0:27:20and then everybody's just gonna buy the mass market stuff.

0:27:23more or less that the thing that happened to the Mac

0:27:26with the Windows PCs would happen again.

0:27:29I don't think that's an unfair summary.

0:27:33And I think even he acknowledged later on

0:27:36that his mistake was that the iPhone

0:27:39wasn't disruptive to the cellphone industry.

0:27:43It was disruptive to the PC industry.

0:27:47And there, the iPhone wasn't a heavy-handed,

0:27:51expensive over-the-top thing, it was pure disruptive theory.

0:27:56It was lower end, it was underpowered, it was smaller.

0:28:01It had this tiny little three and a half inch screen.

0:28:03It ran a cut down version of a PC operating system.

0:28:08It only ran one app on, it still only runs

0:28:10one app on screen at a time, and totally replaced

0:28:14so many hours of so many people's days

0:28:17that they used to spend on PCs.

0:28:20- That's right, it's a perfect example of disruption.

0:28:24That's what's so ironic about it.

0:28:25And you're right, and to his credit,

0:28:27he admitted this later, he was thinking about the iPhone

0:28:32as being a phone, which is understandable,

0:28:33because the name is iPhone.

0:28:35And the whole point is that it wasn't a phone.

0:28:37It was a computer that happened to make phone calls.

0:28:40And once you realized it was a computer,

0:28:43it's the epitome of disruption.

0:28:45And again, because the other thing too is

0:28:47the way people used the iPhone at the beginning

0:28:50was not to replace their computers.

0:28:52It started out by doing other stuff, right?

0:28:54And what's the point?

0:28:55These products start serving needs

0:28:58that are not met by sort of the incumbent,

0:29:00and then they add on, they get better,

0:29:02and then they start to take away from the incumbent.

0:29:04And you end up with exactly what disruption theory

0:29:07sort of predicts, where yes, at the very highest end,

0:29:10you still have PCs.

0:29:11There's things you can still only do on a PC,

0:29:14and PCs actually over time have gotten more expensive,

0:29:18particularly because the only ones using them

0:29:22are the most demanding users,

0:29:24and the entire bottom and middle part of the market

0:29:28has just been completely taken over by the phone.

0:29:31- Yeah, absolutely.

0:29:33Just in terms of Mindshare,

0:29:36in terms of what device do people upgrade more frequently,

0:29:40I mean, people would just hold onto their PC now

0:29:43until it frickin' breaks, whereas people,

0:29:46I'm not saying, you know, and famously,

0:29:48I know that year after year,

0:29:50I repeat myself all the time,

0:29:52that normal people don't upgrade their phones every year

0:29:54or even two years.

0:29:55They consider them very expensive purchases.

0:29:59They put them in tank-like cases to protect them

0:30:02because they're so expensive,

0:30:04and they do use them for multiple years.

0:30:07But they look forward to getting a new phone, right?

0:30:09It's a fun, this is a fun thing when you decide,

0:30:11hey, I'm gonna get a new iPhone 11,

0:30:13and wow, look at this, I get, you know,

0:30:15I have this amazing new camera and I can do all this stuff.

0:30:18It's, the screen's bigger, it's so much brighter,

0:30:21and they're happy.

0:30:22Whereas people look forward to getting a PC

0:30:25the way they look forward to getting a new microwave.

0:30:28It's like-- - Exactly right.

0:30:30- Oh, what a pain in the ass.

0:30:31I gotta take this thing out of my cabinet

0:30:33and I gotta figure out if it's gonna fit

0:30:35and oh, man, and now the buttons I don't really like.

0:30:38- Gotta try out 15 new mouses if you're John Sirquhousa.

0:30:42- Yeah, exactly.

0:30:43It's just a chore for most people.

0:30:44whereas the phone is something fun.

0:30:46Yeah, anyway, I just thought that was really insightful

0:30:51that he just totally, he completely recognized his mistake.

0:30:53And it wasn't like to fit it.

0:30:55It wasn't like, oh, now I figured out a way

0:30:57to make it fit my famous theory.

0:30:59It was that he figured out, you know, he's correct.

0:31:02It totally disrupted the PC, you know?

0:31:04- Yep.

0:31:05- Which sort of will tie into something

0:31:07we wanna talk about later with the iPad,

0:31:08which also is closely related to the iPhone

0:31:12definitely disruptive to the PC industry.

0:31:16Or is it? Yeah. Well, anyway,

0:31:20let me take a break here. Next after this. And thank our first sponsor,

0:31:24our good friends at Linode. I want to say Linode, because

0:31:28that's what it looks like, but it's Linode because they run Linux.

0:31:32Linode is the, in my opinion, best

0:31:36hosting service for getting your own server online. It is where

0:31:40where I host Daring Fireball now.

0:31:41I could not be happier.

0:31:44I love it.

0:31:45It is so fast.

0:31:46Everything is so much faster at Daring Fireball.

0:31:49Since I've moved a couple months ago,

0:31:51it just makes me smile every day.

0:31:54I still haven't gotten used to how much faster

0:31:57some of the things are.

0:31:58They've got the pricing support and scale.

0:32:00You need to take your next project to the next level.

0:32:03They have 11 data centers worldwide,

0:32:05including their newest in Sydney, Australia.

0:32:07They've got one in Mumbai, India now.

0:32:09They've got one in Canada.

0:32:10And sometimes, it's not just about how close you are

0:32:13for latency and things like that.

0:32:15Sometimes for legal compliance,

0:32:16you need servers in the country where you are.

0:32:19They've got 'em all over the world now.

0:32:21And they all deliver the performance you expect

0:32:23at the price that you probably don't because it's so low.

0:32:27You can get started today with a $20 credit

0:32:28just for listeners of the show.

0:32:30I'll tell you the code when I'm done talking about 'em.

0:32:32But you can get $20 credit,

0:32:34and you get access to native SSD storage.

0:32:37Everything is SSD.

0:32:38That to me is the biggest reason why Daring Fireball runs so much slower than it did before.

0:32:43Just unbelievable how much rebuilding stuff through my CMS is so much faster now.

0:32:47They have a 40 gigabyte gigabit network, industry-leading processors, and they're revamped Cloud Manager,

0:32:54which is built on open source.

0:32:56It is a single-page app.

0:32:57It is terrific at cloud.linode.com.

0:33:01You get root access to your server.

0:33:03You get an API.

0:33:04They have a Python command line interface if you're a developer and you want to hook

0:33:07up to it.

0:33:08And they have a plan, they call it the Nanode plan.

0:33:12Nano because it's small.

0:33:13The smallest plan starts as low as five bucks.

0:33:15Five bucks a month.

0:33:16But it is a really good plan.

0:33:18It is really good and an awful lot of very serious websites with a lot of traffic could

0:33:22get by just fine with it.

0:33:23And with that $20 discount I told you about, that's like four months free.

0:33:27Actually, no like about it.

0:33:29It is four months free.

0:33:30Really, it's just a great service.

0:33:32Here's the code.

0:33:33code, talk show 2020.

0:33:35Talk show, that's the show.

0:33:372020, that's the year.

0:33:39Use that when you create a new Linode account.

0:33:41You get $20 credit towards your next project.

0:33:44And one last thing, Linode is hiring.

0:33:46If you're a system administrator or any sort of nerd

0:33:49who might want to work for a company like Linode,

0:33:51which is a great company.

0:33:52They have their headquarters right here in Philadelphia,

0:33:53in fact, but you could probably work anywhere for them.

0:33:56Go to linode.com/careers to find out more.

0:33:59So go to linode.com/the talk show.

0:34:02The URL is linode.com/thetalkshow,

0:34:04but the promo code to save 20 bucks is talkshow2020.

0:34:09- I believe you wanted to say that

0:34:12during a fireball runs faster now, slower.

0:34:15- Oh, is that what I said, slower?

0:34:16Well.

0:34:17- I usually, I have the meat on.

0:34:19I was gonna jump on and catch you.

0:34:21- That'll catch people's ears.

0:34:22No, it runs faster, so much faster.

0:34:24It's ridiculous.

0:34:25All right, what else do we have on the agenda

0:34:29now that we're done with the obituary parts.

0:34:32I just wanted to toss this out there

0:34:35as a little bit of follow-up.

0:34:37Glenn Fleischmann and I, I think,

0:34:38talked about the Astros cheating scandal last week.

0:34:42There's a new website I'm gonna put in the show notes,

0:34:44signstealingscandle.com.

0:34:46This guy is an obsessive, he's a Houston Astros fan,

0:34:48and I give him credit.

0:34:50He's an Astros fan, and he is so upset

0:34:52that his beloved team,

0:34:55stooped to such a lowly and dastardly level

0:34:58to set up a cheating scandal. He logged 8,200 pitches from TV telecasts that are available

0:35:07online from the Astros 2017 series and created a website with all sorts of data about which

0:35:14batters were getting these trashcan signals.

0:35:18It's just something that I think is not clear to maybe non-baseball fans. There is super

0:35:26interesting I'd retweeted this last night but apparently Randy Johnson was

0:35:30tipping his pitches throughout his career and he never knew until Eduardo Perez

0:35:35told him at the at his Hall of Fame induction and and and be like oh

0:35:40cheater like no that's not cheating right like right you picking up this

0:35:44like this the guy beyond second and looking in on the catcher or a batter

0:35:48observing a pitcher super closely and figuring out what they're pitching

0:35:51That's smart baseball, right?

0:35:53That's like, and the difference with the Astros

0:35:56is using cameras and like phones and the Boston Red Sox

0:36:01previously using like Apple watches,

0:36:03it's using electronic means to do it.

0:36:06That is the problem.

0:36:08- Specifically, after the commissioner of baseball

0:36:10sent a very curt letter to every team in the league,

0:36:15reemphasizing that league policy is that

0:36:18it comes to sign-stealing, electronic devices of any kind are completely verboten over the

0:36:24line, you know, and they don't get into, like, the—what you can pick up with your own eyes

0:36:31and maybe hand signals or whatever else you're doing without using electronics. The League

0:36:36just sort of—they don't—there's no rules about it. It's just sort of a gray zone.

0:36:40They didn't acknowledge it, but they—

0:36:41Well, it's not a gray zone. It's a black—no, it's totally okay. Like, the idea of stealing—

0:36:43Well, they don't mention it, though. But they don't—but the commissioner doesn't

0:36:47say that it's okay, right?

0:36:48The commissioner doesn't say it's okay

0:36:50to steal signs with your eyes.

0:36:52It's just understood that it is because how else,

0:36:54you know, what else, you almost couldn't ban it.

0:36:57But they sent a letter, all this stuff happened

0:37:01after the league reemphasized what had already been

0:37:04on the books, but just to make clear that electronics

0:37:07of any kind, wired, wireless, anything that's electronic,

0:37:10and everybody knows what's electronic and what's not,

0:37:13is banned, and so, you know.

0:37:16Yeah, that's interesting. I didn't see that about Randy Johnson.

0:37:20Yeah, I'll pass it to you. But yeah, it's actually, it's funny. The reason I found

0:37:25it is because another former Major Leaguer retweeted it and said, "Oh, it's totally

0:37:29true. It's the only way I could square up against him." And what's amazing is, that's

0:37:35the sort of thing where it's probably fairly widely known. Like, everyone's so helpless

0:37:40against Randy Johnson that any tip you can get is going to help. And he was still completely

0:37:45dominant, which goes to show what a dominant pitcher he was

0:37:49if he was actually tipping his pitches

0:37:50and was still striking guys out like crazy.

0:37:53- Randy, for those of you who don't know,

0:37:56Randy Johnson was six foot 10.

0:37:58He was an enormously tall, he would have been tall

0:38:01as a basketball player.

0:38:02- And he threw like sidearms, or like three quarter arm.

0:38:08- And was one of those tall lanky fellows

0:38:11who you often do see in basketball.

0:38:14There's the famous Leonardo da Vinci picture

0:38:18of like the human typical scale of a human being.

0:38:23And I don't know, I just assume everybody knows this,

0:38:26but it's an interesting fact

0:38:28that most people have an arm span.

0:38:31In other words, you put your arms out side to side

0:38:33from fingertip to fingertip

0:38:35is usually almost exactly as tall as you are.

0:38:39And Leonardo drew this in a circle.

0:38:42put a circle around a figure of a man

0:38:44with his arms straight out.

0:38:45But sometimes there's a lot of basketball players

0:38:48who have an arm span that's even longer than they are tall,

0:38:52even though they are tall.

0:38:53And it's a tremendous advantage in basketball

0:38:56to have a very long arm span.

0:38:58Randy Johnson was one of those types.

0:38:59So in addition to being six foot 10, which is really tall,

0:39:03and therefore makes the ball come out

0:39:04at an angle you're not used to,

0:39:06and the fact that he threw sidearm, which is weird,

0:39:09and made the ball seem like it was coming out

0:39:11side of the mound, his arms were so long that it was any, you know, would take a long stride

0:39:16towards the plate that it was almost like he threw harder than most pitches, pitchers,

0:39:20but because he was so long and his arms are so long, it was like, it was like he got to

0:39:23start four feet closer to you.

0:39:25Yep.

0:39:26And it was coming in from the side if you're a left handed pitcher in particular, it's

0:39:29like coming from behind your head.

0:39:30You've probably seen it.

0:39:32Because it was back in the era before interleague play.

0:39:35So the National League players didn't really get to see American League players much and

0:39:38and Randy Johnson was an American League pitcher,

0:39:40but John Kruk, Philadelphia Phillies' first baseman

0:39:44in the All-Star Game against, do you ever see that at bat?

0:39:48- Yep, absolutely, just, hopeless.

0:39:52- He's like, "Nope," in the All-Star Game,

0:39:56and he just was like, "Nope."

0:39:58I'll have to put a clip of it in the show notes,

0:39:59'cause it really shows you how crazy scary

0:40:02he was as a pitcher.

0:40:03- No, you just think about it, you're in there,

0:40:06it's already sort of terrifying that these guys

0:40:08coming in, you know, 100 miles per hour,

0:40:10'cause he would throw 100.

0:40:11And it's literally coming from behind your head.

0:40:14(laughing)

0:40:15And cutting across you.

0:40:16- John Kruk looked like if I was up there

0:40:22batting against any major league pitcher,

0:40:24I would just be terrified, leaning back,

0:40:27diving backwards out of the box.

0:40:30Anyway, I gotta put a link into the show notes

0:40:36about this website where this guy obsessively documented

0:40:398,200 pitches over the season.

0:40:43I just, I'm always fascinated by anybody

0:40:45who's obsessive about anything but this in particular.

0:40:48And again, extra points for him being an Astros fan.

0:40:51What else did I wanna talk about on follow up?

0:40:55I guess I don't have a lot more to say.

0:40:57Glenn and I last week really went deep

0:40:59on the whole iPhone iCloud encryption thing.

0:41:04So I don't have a lot to follow up on that.

0:41:06I guess the one point I wanna make

0:41:08and I sorta kinda need to write about it just to clarify

0:41:12is, and I think that this is a little bit Apple's fault too,

0:41:17is tossing around the word encryption

0:41:21and what's encrypted and what's not.

0:41:22Because it's, at this point, it isn't useful

0:41:27to clarifying what the point is

0:41:28of this whole thing with iCloud.

0:41:31because everything is encrypted in transit.

0:41:35Everything you do with iCloud from whatever your device is,

0:41:39whether it's an iPhone, iPad, Mac,

0:41:42in between your device and the iCloud servers

0:41:45that Apple runs, on the network, everything is encrypted.

0:41:50Everything you do.

0:41:51On disk, on the iCloud servers,

0:41:58everything is encrypted in some way,

0:42:00except for email, and email's an exception

0:42:03because that's just the way IMAP email works.

0:42:05And I had a link to a Jeff Duncan article

0:42:08from years ago explaining why, and it's complicated,

0:42:11but it more or less, long story short,

0:42:13is because email was invented in the prehistoric days

0:42:18of the internet when nothing was encrypted

0:42:21and everything was stored, plain text files on disk.

0:42:24And email's like the one aspect of that prehistoric internet

0:42:29that's still with us and will probably always be with us,

0:42:32and it's just the nature of it that that's how email works.

0:42:34It can't be encrypted.

0:42:36So if you ever, if you are gonna commit crimes,

0:42:39don't coordinate. - Don't email about them.

0:42:41- Don't email about them.

0:42:42Because even if you do the thing,

0:42:44and I don't wanna go on a side note about it,

0:42:45you, and I don't wanna get emails,

0:42:47people telling me about like PGP,

0:42:50where what you can do is email someone

0:42:52where the text of the email is encrypted.

0:42:56Because even then, even if you use something like PGP

0:42:59to encrypt the text of your email,

0:43:02the headers, the header files of the email

0:43:04can't be encrypted.

0:43:05There's no way to encrypt the whole thing.

0:43:07And so like, okay, the contents of an email

0:43:09can be encrypted, but it's a huge pain in the ass.

0:43:12Almost nobody does it.

0:43:13Email isn't really meant to be used that way.

0:43:16And anybody who subpoenas your email or has access to it

0:43:20can see all the headers anyway,

0:43:21and they can see that you were emailing Les Parnas

0:43:24whoever it was you were emailing.

0:43:26So don't use email for crime.

0:43:29Or anything you don't really,

0:43:32anything you really feel like needs to be secret.

0:43:35But anyway, the point I wanna make is Apple encrypts,

0:43:38so email aside, for good reason,

0:43:40everything that Apple stores on disk in iCloud

0:43:42is quote unquote encrypted.

0:43:45The issue is not what's encrypted and what's not.

0:43:49The issue is who can decrypt what's there.

0:43:53And there's two types.

0:43:55There's the types of stuff that they store

0:43:57that only you, the user, can decrypt

0:44:00using your device keys and your personal password.

0:44:05And then there's the stuff that both you can decrypt,

0:44:09of course, and the stuff that Apple has its own key for

0:44:14and can decrypt.

0:44:16And iCloud backups are in that latter category

0:44:20where Apple has a key to them

0:44:22And the good part of it is if you are more likely,

0:44:27probably if you listen to the show,

0:44:29probably not you, but someone you know

0:44:32forgets their iCloud password

0:44:35and they leave their iPhone in a cab

0:44:38or it gets run over by a car or something

0:44:40and gets destroyed, now their iPhone is destroyed

0:44:44and they go to buy a new iPhone

0:44:46and the only backup they have is their iCloud backup

0:44:49and they don't know their iCloud password.

0:44:51What happens? Well, you can go to the Apple store and I actually don't know exactly what—a couple

0:44:59people ask me, like, what do they do to confirm that you're you? Like, so that Joe Random

0:45:04thief can't go into an Apple store and say, "Hey, I'm John Gruber. I need to get my iCloud

0:45:11backup." I don't know what they do. You know, I guess they—hopefully they ask for ID and—I'm

0:45:15actually not sure. I wish I did know exactly what they did to verify. But anyway, you can

0:45:20if you somehow convince them you are who you are,

0:45:24they can decrypt your iCloud backup

0:45:27and then restore it to a new iPhone

0:45:29and you don't lose anything.

0:45:31The downside of that is that law enforcement

0:45:35around the world can issue a subpoena.

0:45:37Well, I say downside,

0:45:39downside from a privacy perspective,

0:45:41upside in some way,

0:45:42which is why it's a debate for solving crimes.

0:45:45If you actually are a criminal,

0:45:47they can subpoena Apple and Apple can provide them

0:45:50the contents of your decrypted iCloud backup. So that's the whole issue. Who can decrypt

0:45:56it? Just you or you and Apple?

0:45:59Yeah, that's right. And I think that that's a good articulation of the issue. And I'm

0:46:06glad you pointed out at the end, there is good news that Apple can do that. And this

0:46:17This is something I thought a lot in the context of Facebook.

0:46:21Facebook's talking about encrypting Messenger by default and stuff like that.

0:46:27And there's questions about child sexual abuse material online.

0:46:34And one thing that comes up is that there's way more instance of it in Messenger than there is in WhatsApp.

0:46:40And the question is, is that because people are more evil and nefarious on Messenger than they are on WhatsApp?

0:46:45or is it because WhatsApp is already end-end encrypted, which means no one actually knows what's going through WhatsApp,

0:46:50whereas Messenger is not.

0:46:51And again, to your point, I think particularly in our corner of the internet,

0:46:59where more people know who Clay Kirsch is than who Kobe Bryant is,

0:47:02there's a tendency to, I think, over-index on one side as opposed to the other,

0:47:07and say that, "Oh, obviously it should be this way."

0:47:09There's real questions here, and again, that doesn't mean your position is wrong,

0:47:15But I think those of us that,

0:47:18I would say I'm a little more towards the middle,

0:47:21but I'm absolutely even strong in encryption.

0:47:22I believe there should be no back doors,

0:47:24et cetera, et cetera.

0:47:25I think by at least acknowledging and appreciating

0:47:29those that come at it from a different perspective,

0:47:31you can make a stronger argument for that position.

0:47:33And so I think that's an important thing to call out.

0:47:36- Yeah, you have to acknowledge.

0:47:37Anybody who's a good actor and has,

0:47:41is being honest and is knowledgeable about the entire situation, has to acknowledge either

0:47:48way, no matter whether you're on the side of we really did, you know, Apple should maintain

0:47:53these keys and provide them to law enforcement when subpoenaed for good reason, or if you're

0:47:59on the side that Apple should switch iCloud backups to be truly end-to-end encrypted where

0:48:04only the user has the key to do it, you have to at least acknowledge either way that there

0:48:09are significant trade-offs.

0:48:11You have to.

0:48:12If you don't, you're either being dishonest

0:48:14or you're ignorant.

0:48:17- Right, and you're not gonna win the argument, right?

0:48:18Like I actually think the most compelling argument,

0:48:21and I made this a few years ago with the San Bernardino

0:48:25case for winning this argument with sort of

0:48:28the US government, is the US government itself

0:48:32has an interest in encryption being strong

0:48:36and easy to use for normal people because the US government

0:48:38has more secrets and more value than sort of anyone.

0:48:41But you think about it from an industrial perspective,

0:48:44like the most valuable IP in a lot of the most,

0:48:46in the strongest military in the world is United States.

0:48:49It follows that the United States has more of an interest

0:48:52in strong encryption than basically anyone else.

0:48:56And because keys do get out, keys escape.

0:49:00Like there's evidence of this again and again and again,

0:49:03a backdoor is available to both the good guys

0:49:07the bad guys and is usually found by the bad guys first and the and so there's a very sort of

0:49:13utilitarian argument to be made in favor of encryption that's not just a you know uh you

0:49:18know privacy good you know government bad sort of approach and i think actually would get the

0:49:23industry further uh as far as you know politically speaking then a sort of pure sort of like you

0:49:29know privacy principle based approach um from a winning hearts and minds sort of perspective

0:49:37- I don't think Glenn and I have made this super clear.

0:49:41The other thing I think is worth making super clear

0:49:43is from an Apple perspective, two other things.

0:49:45iMessage in particular and then your keychain.

0:49:49And the keychain, your keychain,

0:49:51if you use the iCloud keychain syncing,

0:49:54syncs completely outside of the iCloud backup system

0:49:58and is done in a way where only your keys can decrypt it

0:50:03and Apple doesn't have it.

0:50:06So if the FBI went to Apple and had a subpoena

0:50:11for everything they have about you,

0:50:13one thing they wouldn't get is your keychain.

0:50:16They would not get all,

0:50:17they wouldn't get any of your keychain.

0:50:19iMessage is in a weird nether zone

0:50:22where iMessage, from the get-go,

0:50:24it is, it was, and I heard this way back when it was new,

0:50:29like, you know, when Jobs announced it famously,

0:50:31and said, we're gonna, no, and I guess it was FaceTime,

0:50:33he said he was gonna open source, not iMessage.

0:50:36But within like a year or two

0:50:38of when iMessage was introduced,

0:50:40I was talking to someone at Apple who said,

0:50:42they had a very simple idea.

0:50:45It would be like SMS, except,

0:50:49some kind of cross between SMS

0:50:50and then like AOL Instant Messenger, remember that?

0:50:53- I do. - And Apple had,

0:50:55you know, an AIM client.

0:50:56They had iChat, which, you know,

0:50:59and supported other protocols other than AIM too.

0:51:03It would be a replacement for SMS and instant messaging,

0:51:06and it would use your phone number and your Apple ID,

0:51:11and/or, I guess I should say, your Apple ID

0:51:16as a unique identifier for you.

0:51:19The fact that it uses your phone number

0:51:21would allow it to seamlessly replace SMS

0:51:23for iPhone-to-iPhone communication,

0:51:25'cause it would default, whereas if you and I

0:51:29had been SMSing together from your iPhone to my iPhone,

0:51:32and then we upgraded to the version of iOS

0:51:35that first had iMessage,

0:51:37our communication would just go right to iMessage,

0:51:40and we'd get blue bubbles instead of green ones,

0:51:42and we'd continue without knowing,

0:51:43other than the fact that our bubble color had changed,

0:51:46but we would no longer be limited

0:51:47by the technical limits of SMS,

0:51:49and perhaps the cost limits,

0:51:52because back then, which sounds ridiculous,

0:51:55some people were still paying like 10 cents on SMS,

0:51:57or had like a 500 SMS a month limit, or something like that.

0:52:02And then the other thing in--

0:52:03- The whole, what is it?

0:52:06Oh, sorry, go ahead.

0:52:07- The one other thing in that initial brief

0:52:09on what should it be was it should be encrypted

0:52:12in such a way that Apple cannot ever see the contents

0:52:16of anybody's iMessages.

0:52:18And then it was like, here.

0:52:19That's what they told the engineering team.

0:52:21They said, here, go build it.

0:52:22But right from the get-go,

0:52:24when it was just an idea on a whiteboard,

0:52:26one of the things right up there with let's replace SMS

0:52:29for iPhone-to-iPhone communication was,

0:52:32Let's design this in such a way that we cannot technically

0:52:36ever see the contents of anybody's iMessage.

0:52:39- And I think the follow-up to your point though,

0:52:44if you, and now they did iMessage in the cloud

0:52:48and all that sort of thing or whatever,

0:52:50it would still maintain that approach

0:52:53where it's fully encrypted,

0:52:55but if you have iCloud backups turned on--

0:52:59- Right, this is the problem.

0:53:02- You can access the backups.

0:53:03- Right, iCloud in the cloud is every bit as secure,

0:53:07or iMessage in the cloud. - iMessage in the cloud.

0:53:08- iMessage in the cloud, it remains only decryptable

0:53:12using your device keys.

0:53:15The asterisk is that your iMessage key

0:53:20is stored in your iCloud backup.

0:53:26So your backup contains it.

0:53:28In theory, Apple could change iMessage

0:53:33to work like Keychain.

0:53:35And even if they keep the iCloud backups

0:53:40encrypted in a way where Apple has the key,

0:53:43they could, and I believe should,

0:53:45change iMessage so that the key isn't in your iCloud backup.

0:53:50And the downside to that would be

0:53:53if you're one of these users.

0:53:56And apparently I heard from a bunch of people,

0:53:58like people who work as geniuses in the stores

0:54:00and people who's had friends and family

0:54:02who've encountered it.

0:54:03It truly is a common problem on a daily basis.

0:54:06Somebody said, like a listener of the podcast said

0:54:09that they were just in getting one of their

0:54:11Apple products serviced.

0:54:14And while they were waiting for the genius

0:54:16to go in the back and run the diagnostics,

0:54:18three different people came and their genius problem

0:54:21was that they couldn't access their iCloud backup.

0:54:24He said he couldn't believe it 'cause it was,

0:54:26He's reading during Fireball and listening to my podcast and other podcasts, and it's

0:54:30a hot topic.

0:54:32And literally while he was at the Genius counter, three people came up and needed access to

0:54:37their iCloud backups, and they didn't know their password.

0:54:41Definitely a common problem.

0:54:42The downside would be those people wouldn't be able to access their archive of iMessages.

0:54:49You'd have to start over.

0:54:50What seems a reasonable thing to give up, as it were.

0:54:54Yeah.

0:54:55people sort of see their iMessages as sort of transient. So I kind of feel like that's

0:55:00sort of a, hopefully a—regardless of what Apple plans to do with the iCloud backups

0:55:06and who has the keys, I really think they should move iMessage to that because I think

0:55:11it's a good idea for privacy, and I also think it would meet people's expectations

0:55:17for privacy with iMessage in the cloud.

0:55:19Yeah, it's interesting because one of the reasons that law enforcement still wants more

0:55:26access from Apple is actually not necessarily iMessages, because to your point, they can

0:55:31often be gotten to through iCloud backups, but other encrypted programs like WhatsApp

0:55:37or Signal or things along those lines where they want to turn on the phone because they

0:55:43do need actually that sort of access.

0:55:46WhatsApp is more secure than iMessage for this reason

0:55:50because it only goes via your device, right?

0:55:55And you notice this, if you wanna use WhatsApp

0:55:57on your computer, it has to go through your device.

0:56:01- Yeah, but it does, it has to go through your device

0:56:04so your desktop thing is sort of just a proxy to your phone.

0:56:07But your iPhone backup still contains whatever I--

0:56:11- The WhatsApp backups, that's right.

0:56:12- Yeah, the WhatsApp backups.

0:56:13- No, it does.

0:56:14- And, (laughs)

0:56:15- I have to say I enjoy it.

0:56:16That's how they got Paul Manafort.

0:56:18- That's right, that's right.

0:56:21- Paul Manafort was committing crimes on his phone

0:56:24and thought he was being smart using WhatsApp

0:56:26because it's end-to-end encrypted.

0:56:28But they got him because they got his iCloud backup.

0:56:33I laugh because I really don't like the guy in him.

0:56:38- I think it's really interesting though

0:56:41from a sort of a balance perspective

0:56:43because what's the one thing in like,

0:56:48like you could use your right to draw that distinction.

0:56:51So if you want to use, you use like Signal or something,

0:56:53right, if you want to be true,

0:56:54if you want to not have those issues.

0:56:57And so you have a choice as a user to figure out

0:57:01what's the right software to use

0:57:03that is truly encrypted, right?

0:57:05But what's the one thing you really can't control?

0:57:08You can't control like the hardware itself.

0:57:11Like there is the hardware down to,

0:57:13it's very root, is it secure?

0:57:16And so I think there's an argument to be made

0:57:19that Apple is actually in a very reasonable position

0:57:22where the one part of the entire sort of system

0:57:27that users can't control is the hardware itself

0:57:30and is the hardware itself secure or not.

0:57:32They can make choices about what cloud services they use,

0:57:35what messaging services they use,

0:57:37and so you can structure a truly secure

0:57:40messaging environment on your phone

0:57:42if you make all the right choices,

0:57:44but also because Apple made the phone truly secure.

0:57:47And so I think there's actually an argument to me

0:57:49that Apple is actually exactly

0:57:51where they should be right now,

0:57:52where it is possible to be truly secure,

0:57:55but Apple's not necessarily gonna do all the work for you.

0:57:58And there's some, that's probably why WhatsApp

0:58:03is slightly less secure than Signal 2.

0:58:06It's not because Facebook wants to use the information

0:58:09to snoop on you or for ads.

0:58:10No, it's not actually, wouldn't be useful anyway,

0:58:14and Facebook can't see the stuff,

0:58:16but they also sort of can be responsible corporate citizens

0:58:20as it were in a way that is not necessarily a burden,

0:58:24nor should it be for signal, right?

0:58:27Signal is, and I think it's a reasonable compromise

0:58:30because the bad guys are going to figure it out.

0:58:34The sort of dumb bad guys that sort of do crimes

0:58:36like Paul Manafort are not necessarily gonna figure it out,

0:58:39and they can get caught, but also the people

0:58:42that truly need a secure environment

0:58:43that can figure out, can understand this sort of stuff,

0:58:47they can be truly secure as well, right?

0:58:49And so I think whatever your position on Apple

0:58:53and the iCloud backup point or Facebook

0:58:55and WhatsApp and those sorts of things,

0:58:57the fact of the matter is there's only one piece in here

0:58:59that users can't make a choice about,

0:59:01and that is the phone, and that is the part

0:59:03where Apple has done huge efforts to make it truly secure.

0:59:09And so while we can go back and forth in this middle area,

0:59:12I think Apple deserves acknowledgement

0:59:15for taking care of the one part

0:59:17that I as a user cannot take care of.

0:59:19- Yeah, I totally agree.

0:59:20And I think it's,

0:59:24so the way that you can,

0:59:27if you're really concerned about it,

0:59:28whether it's because you're committing crimes,

0:59:31or really, and this second part is much more reasonable,

0:59:35if it just is the nature of your personality

0:59:38that you are not comfortable with Apple having a key

0:59:42to your backed up data.

0:59:43Totally reasonable.

0:59:44I know, I just know, I know the people who listen

0:59:47to the show and I know the sort of people

0:59:49who read Daring Fireball, there's a lot of you out there.

0:59:52Totally reasonable position.

0:59:53And if you want your iOS life to be completely

0:59:58under your control, you should stop using iCloud backup.

1:00:04And if you do wanna backup your device,

1:00:05which you probably do, you can still backup

1:00:07your Mac or PC through iTunes or now in Mac OS 10.5 you do it through the finder, but

1:00:14it's the same. You look at it, it's the same interface you used to see in iTunes,

1:00:18and make sure you put a password on your backup, which…

1:00:21And then you can sync that backup via Backblaze or whatever other service you want to use

1:00:28so you can have sort of cloud backups. And you know what? I think that's totally reasonable.

1:00:31Right.

1:00:32Like the…

1:00:33Or Dropbox.

1:00:34We're arguing about default, right?

1:00:36Because even if Dropbox is a subpoena,

1:00:38it's an encrypted file that you need the password

1:00:41to get into.

1:00:43And I think we're arguing about defaults here, right?

1:00:45The reality is, thanks to Apple's work on the phone,

1:00:49you can live a fully encrypted life.

1:00:51Is it a little more inconvenient?

1:00:54It is, but that's the trade-off, right?

1:00:56And I think it's reasonable to have that trade-off.

1:00:59I was thinking about this when you said

1:01:00you were talking about email

1:01:01and how it's sort of like fundamentally insecure.

1:01:05And my business is sort of built on email in some respect.

1:01:09And what is attractive about it is

1:01:12it is a fee that people check every day

1:01:14that I can get into for free.

1:01:16I don't need to pay a Facebook gatekeeper

1:01:18or whatever it might be to get access to people.

1:01:20The email is open and free.

1:01:22And that's part of the trade-off

1:01:24is it's because email is open and insecure

1:01:28that it is actually an accessible market

1:01:30for someone like me, for example,

1:01:31or that it's available anywhere and everywhere on any device.

1:01:34And that's just the way these things work.

1:01:36The more encryption you want, the more defaults you want.

1:01:39I know there's a societal issue.

1:01:41There's a walled garden issue, right?

1:01:43The more we put things, the more you lock things down,

1:01:47by definition, the less interoperability you're gonna have.

1:01:49The less you're gonna be able to sort of exchange data

1:01:52across different platforms,

1:01:53the more you're actually going to strengthen Apple's moat

1:01:57or strengthen Facebook's moat.

1:01:58And so if you care about competition,

1:02:00You're actually, these encryption questions are actually,

1:02:03there's another trade-off to think about.

1:02:05And it's okay, again, I just, I hate absolutism

1:02:10on any of this in any direction

1:02:12because there's reasonable trade-offs to make

1:02:15and I think we're in a good spot

1:02:17because you can go all the way when it comes to encryption

1:02:21but you don't have to and it's not even the default

1:02:24and that's fine because as long as it's possible,

1:02:27I feel pretty good about things.

1:02:28- Yeah, and again, like you pointed out,

1:02:30you can still get cloud-based backup with your,

1:02:34I call them iTunes backups,

1:02:36but that includes the Finder one for Catalina,

1:02:38but the iTunes backup that is on your Mac or PC--

1:02:40- And it works over Wi-Fi too, right?

1:02:41So you don't even need to necessarily

1:02:43plug into your phone every day.

1:02:44It could just be when you come home every evening

1:02:46and it does that backup in the background.

1:02:48- Right, and you kind of, at least even if you're doing that

1:02:52you kind of need to double check it once in a while

1:02:54because just make sure it's still doing,

1:02:56You don't wanna be the guy who forgot

1:02:58that when you got a new MacBook Pro,

1:03:00you never made sure that was still working again

1:03:04and you haven't backed up for 13 months

1:03:06or something like that.

1:03:07I mean, that is the advantage to iCloud backup,

1:03:09is it just happens automatically every night

1:03:12as your iPhone is connected to a charger.

1:03:15Even with the WiFi backup, you need, like you said,

1:03:18you have some personal responsibility

1:03:21to make sure it's working, but that's the trade-off.

1:03:23But you can store that backup and use Backblaze or Dropbox or something, and there's nothing

1:03:30that can happen.

1:03:31Nobody can get into it even when it's in Dropbox or even iCloud.

1:03:34You can even put it on iCloud Drive.

1:03:37You just can't use iCloud backup.

1:03:39And the other thing that I think is a little counterintuitive, I touched on it a couple

1:03:42minutes ago, but if you're only backing up via your iTunes backup with a password, you

1:03:52- And also use iMessage in the cloud

1:03:56in a completely secure way because--

1:04:00- Once you've run off iCloud backups,

1:04:01then the key's no longer there.

1:04:02- Right, 'cause that, I don't wanna use the word backdoor,

1:04:05but that asterisk for somebody to get into your iMessage

1:04:09in the cloud is because the key is stored

1:04:12in your iCloud backup, and if you don't have

1:04:14an iCloud backup, they don't have a way to get that key.

1:04:17I guess the other hole in that that you should think about

1:04:21if you're doing crimes, is okay,

1:04:25you've turned off iCloud backup,

1:04:29and you're only encrypting to your Mac or PC

1:04:33with a password that only you know,

1:04:35but anybody you're communicating with by iMessage,

1:04:38if they're using iCloud backup

1:04:40and the feds know you're collaborating with them,

1:04:43they can subpoena their backup

1:04:45and see your end of the messages

1:04:48because they're backing it up to iCloud.

1:04:49So there is that, keep it in mind.

1:04:52But it's good, basically it's good to know how all this works and before the last month

1:04:57or so I didn't even know how all this worked and I know just based on my reading that lots

1:05:01and lots of readers didn't know how it worked and a lot of people were very surprised to

1:05:05find out that Apple has a key to your iCloud backup.

1:05:10And again, I don't think it's used willy-nilly.

1:05:13I don't know the process.

1:05:14I'm not quite sure everything they do to verify your ID but it's not like, you know, I do

1:05:18think that on their side in iCloud there is some sort of process and a logging, you know,

1:05:23like hopefully, I would hope, you know, there's no way for a rogue Apple employee to, you

1:05:29know, spy on an ex-partner or something like that or stalk them or something like that,

1:05:36you know, that there's some kind of log of Apple employee access to these keys to do

1:05:42it. But the fact that you don't know that we don't know how that works is one of the

1:05:46of the reasons why I emphasize that it's perfectly reasonable

1:05:48for someone to say, I don't want any part of this,

1:05:50if they can access my data.

1:05:52- Yeah, that's exactly right.

1:05:55- Last but not least, I wanted to emphasize,

1:05:58I think I was wrong about it, or I would say

1:06:00it was ambiguous, but there's this whole thing

1:06:02where to get on your device, if law enforcement

1:06:06or a criminal or a snoop, or somebody has your iPhone,

1:06:10and they want to, they use one of these devices,

1:06:14I guess it's mostly law enforcement,

1:06:15one of these gray key devices or the celebrate thing

1:06:18where they jailbreak the phone and then try to brute force

1:06:21the password by circumventing the 10 guest limit.

1:06:25Everything goes through the secure enclave.

1:06:27And the big limiting factor, there's a key

1:06:30in the secure enclave that is part of the encryption.

1:06:33So there's no way to go around it.

1:06:35It's not like, it's hard to understand.

1:06:38I can't profess that I understand it perfectly,

1:06:40but I understand the idea that one of the keys

1:06:43that encrypts everything on your iOS device is,

1:06:47part of it is your password or your passcode,

1:06:49whatever you wanna call it,

1:06:50but another part is a unique hardware key

1:06:53in the secure enclave that there's no way around it

1:06:57without that key, mathematically.

1:06:59And there's an 80 millisecond per guess time.

1:07:06That's eight hundredths of a second,

1:07:07so roughly 12 guesses would get you to like 96,

1:07:120.96 of a second. So roughly 12 guesses a second is the limit. The thing that I think I was ambiguous

1:07:20about writing about it on Daring Fireball is that the 80 millisecond thing isn't like an if statement

1:07:26in code where it's like, okay, there was a guess and then the next guess comes in and there's like,

1:07:32if 80 milliseconds have passed, okay, process it, but if not, you know, wait. And that somehow that

1:07:38could be hacked to either be longer, like make it three seconds, or in the case of someone trying

1:07:45to crack the phone, you know, set it to zero and then it will process them as fast as they can.

1:07:50It's not like that. It is—I'm 98 percent sure that the 80 millisecond thing is actually

1:07:58mathematically produced. It's—there are—

1:08:01- Well, what it is is there is a hardware key.

1:08:06The thing with the Secure Enclave is

1:08:08it's actually a processor, right?

1:08:09It's part of, like, it's like a mini computer

1:08:12in your computer, and it has its own software,

1:08:15by the way, also.

1:08:16And so this actually has a couple implications

1:08:18because the, so you're right, it tangles a key

1:08:23that is burned into your phone when the phone is produced

1:08:27and is undiscoverable, right?

1:08:29And so it's burned into your phone,

1:08:31it's tangled with your passcode to create a hash

1:08:36to encrypt all this sort of stuff.

1:08:38And what happens is the way that it's entangled

1:08:42to sort of untangle it, mathematically requires,

1:08:45it's meant to be a super inefficient sort of calculation

1:08:49so that it can't be done faster than 80 milliseconds

1:08:52or 800 or whatever it is.

1:08:54It literally takes that long.

1:08:55And so it's not, to your point, it's not a software thing.

1:08:58It's like, it's a math thing.

1:09:00It literally can't be done faster than however long it takes.

1:09:04It's an algorithm Apple deliberately chose because it would take 80 milliseconds on the

1:09:09processor that's built into the secure enclave.

1:09:13There's no way around it.

1:09:14So the interesting thing that's a byproduct of that is the average time it takes for like

1:09:22one of these devices that has access, jailbroken access, to the iOS computer that can talk

1:09:28to the secure Enclave computer and try to make guesses as fast as it can with this 12 guesses

1:09:35per second, what's the average time it would take to guess a passcode of different length?

1:09:41So you can just multiply how many characters are involved,

1:09:44raise to the power of how many of them there are. So if you just have a numeric passcode,

1:09:52zero through nine, four digits. That's 10 to the power of four possible combinations,

1:09:58right? It's, you know, 10,000, zero, zero, zero, zero, two, nine, nine, nine, nine.

1:10:04And then the average time, you just divide that by two and take a guess that, you know, if you're

1:10:11guessing all of them, half the time you're going to guess one that's before you get halfway through.

1:10:16So the average time it would take to guess a four-digit numeric passcode, seven minutes,

1:10:21six numbers is 11 hours. So that's the default option now. If you'd buy a new iPhone and just

1:10:27set it up from scratch, Apple's going through the wizard, whatever you want to call it when you

1:10:33start up, basically steers you towards a six-digit numeric passcode. It only takes 11 hours for one

1:10:41of these devices to guess it at that 80 milliseconds per second and double it go to 22 hours and

1:10:47you'll exhaust the entire space so a maximum of 22 hours um eight digits if you go custom 46 days

1:10:55and then a 10 digit passcode 12 years so that's pretty good right you know what not just digit

1:11:02but you can do alphanumeric passcodes so then you're right dramatically increasing the space

1:11:05because now it's 36 possible characters. The other thing is—

1:11:09Well, no, actually, and if you go uppercase, now you're up to 62.

1:11:14Right.

1:11:15And if you just count a handful of punctuation characters, like underscores and hyphens and

1:11:20periods, you know, you can get up to 64, 65, 66 characters. So just, you know, these are numbers

1:11:28from Jack Nickus from the Times, but I did—you know, you can do the math yourself. Like I said,

1:11:31If you just count a 66-character space, 52 letters, uppercase, lowercase, 10 digits,

1:11:37and the dash, underscore, period, and comma, or the hash sign, or something, or a space,

1:11:44you know, space is easy to type and is often good for memorizing, you know, passcodes.

1:11:49A four-character alphanumeric, seven days, six characters, 72 years, that's on average,

1:11:57144 years to exhaust the whole thing. And eight characters, just eight characters,

1:12:02uppercase, lowercase, and digits, not even counting punctuation, 276,000 years.

1:12:08[Laughter]

1:12:09So—

1:12:10Justin: Right, and there's nothing Apple can do about it. And this is like the—I

1:12:14was so exhausted in researching this with the San Bernardino thing, and I realized this time,

1:12:20I think, because we've been talking about it too, there was actually more stuff—this stuff

1:12:23has changed since then too. And one thing that's changed is what is done in the secret enclave and

1:12:28what's done via the OS. And the OS still controls the wipe the phone after X number of attempts.

1:12:34And that's the big thing that they want to erase. The other thing that I found out, actually,

1:12:38I wasn't clear on this and Apple got back to me about this, was there is, because it's a

1:12:47serial enclave, it's like a mini computer in your computer, right? People think about it as being

1:12:50sort of safe, but like we're dealing with a computer, right?

1:12:53And what it is, is a mini computer with its own

1:12:55processor effectively, but that means it has its own

1:12:58software that's actually different from the OS

1:13:00software and that software can be updated.

1:13:03You can update the software in the Secure Enclave.

1:13:05However, you do need the password to update the software.

1:13:10And so the, so theoretically you could update the

1:13:16software in the Secure Enclave.

1:13:17You still can't escape the mathematical reality of, you know, sure, decrypting this.

1:13:22You could, but if you wanted to like maybe move the data to a different device that's faster,

1:13:28et cetera, that's still limited by, you would still need to change the software on this

1:13:32cure enclave itself, and that is limited by your passcode. So basically, Apple has made it so

1:13:36it has to be, because of it's entangled with that hardware on the device, it has to be done

1:13:44on the device, which is mathematically limited

1:13:48to 80 milliseconds.

1:13:50And so if you make an alphanumeric password

1:13:54of X number of characters, it doesn't matter

1:13:57what the FBI does or what Apple does.

1:13:59It's basically unbreakable.

1:14:01- Yeah, and so the eye-opening lesson from that

1:14:03is something I'd never really pondered before.

1:14:05And I will say, until two weeks ago,

1:14:07I had been using a six-digit numeric passcode

1:14:10on my iPhone and iPad ever since six digits

1:14:13became available, and before that I was using four digits.

1:14:16Partly out of laziness, partly out of

1:14:20the perfectly reasonable, and I'm not trying to say

1:14:23I'm virtuous, it's actually just that I'm very boring.

1:14:26There's nothing, there's not a lot on my phone

1:14:30that would be terribly upsetting for me

1:14:34if a thief cracked it and got.

1:14:36I mean, especially without my iCloud keychain, right?

1:14:40it still wouldn't get you into, you know,

1:14:44like my daring fireball server account

1:14:47or something like that just because you got into my phone.

1:14:50I don't know what I'm saying, I would relish it,

1:14:51I hope nobody does, but my thinking until recently

1:14:55was six digit passcode is good enough for me.

1:14:58But when I saw these numbers and saw that, you know,

1:15:01it could be cracked in 11 hours on average

1:15:03and 22 at the max, I thought, you know what,

1:15:05I should do the right thing and switch to alphanumeric

1:15:08type of passcode.

1:15:10But the thing that to me, I want to emphasize, and I think it's a good tip, is when you think

1:15:14about this 80 millisecond limit, what we all know about picking good passphrases doesn't

1:15:19really apply to this.

1:15:21Like an eight character, for most uses when we're picking a new password for an online

1:15:26account, everybody, you know, a lot of places won't even let you pick an eight character

1:15:32passcode because they say it's not long enough.

1:15:35Eight characters, as long as you're using like uppercase, lowercase, and a digit or

1:15:39or a punctuation mark, you're literally talking

1:15:43hundreds of thousands of years to crack.

1:15:45I mean, you don't have to sacrifice a ton of convenience,

1:15:49is what I'm trying to say, and pick a 15 to 20 character

1:15:54passcode with a couple of punct,

1:15:57and where you're typing it on the phone,

1:15:58you're shifting between all of these keyboards,

1:16:02it makes it all the harder to type,

1:16:04and you can't see what you've typed

1:16:06because they're coming up as bullets,

1:16:07and so if you make a typo,

1:16:09it's you're typing it over and over again,

1:16:12you can err on the side of a very convenient passphrase

1:16:15that you wouldn't ordinarily use for most things

1:16:19and literally have your phone be secured

1:16:21for 100,000 years of cracking attempts.

1:16:26- That's right.

1:16:27- Eight or nine characters and you're really good,

1:16:29really good.

1:16:30- Right, 'cause those passcodes generally,

1:16:34they're like they're running them on like supercomputers,

1:16:37And that's why they have to be super long and complicated.

1:16:39Even then, they can, like 80 milliseconds,

1:16:42it sounds like a small amount of time.

1:16:44In computer world, it's just an astronomically long

1:16:47amount of time that you definitely use to your advantage.

1:16:50- Yeah, and I'll just repeat something that Glenn emphasized

1:16:53but it's worth remembering, but is that,

1:16:55asterisk, so long as you don't pick a dictionary word,

1:16:59where the dictionary isn't necessarily

1:17:01like the Scrabble dictionary, but like common dictionary

1:17:04people's common passwords, like P-A-S-S-W-0-R-D. Yeah, don't use that one, because they're

1:17:14going to—any smart cracker is going to run through commonly used passwords like that

1:17:20before they start guessing by iterating through all possible combinations.

1:17:26So as long as you pick something that you can memorize and isn't a commonly used word

1:17:31password or your firstborn child's birth date in numbers with slashes, you are good for hundreds

1:17:39of thousands of years and you do not need—it's in fact counterproductive. You're just wasting

1:17:43typing and thumbs and your time by picking a 20-character passphrase that you would use if

1:17:49you were setting up a new account online. And this is for your phone password specifically,

1:17:55like your device passcode.

1:17:58And I have to say, now that I've changed mine

1:18:00to an alphanumeric, I have to say now

1:18:03it really has become clear how seldom I have to enter it.

1:18:06Really, it really does not come up very often.

1:18:10I had to do it today 'cause I just upgraded to the new,

1:18:12there's a new iOS dot release, and so I had to type it

1:18:17to allow the update to install and type it

1:18:19once the phone restarted, and I was like,

1:18:21I haven't typed this in days.

1:18:23Well, it turns out if you're in Asia

1:18:26and you're wearing a medical mask,

1:18:28you actually end up putting it in a lot

1:18:30because your face-eye doesn't work anymore.

1:18:32- You know what, we'll have to touch on that after the break.

1:18:34I have to take a break, but I just went out today.

1:18:37Oh, I have to tell, I should tell you the story.

1:18:39I had to go to the post office today.

1:18:42And on my way, I saw two Asian people.

1:18:46I don't know, I have no idea if they're tourists.

1:18:47I don't know if they live here, I don't know what,

1:18:49but they were Asian and they were wearing medical masks.

1:18:52and I'm just like, do you know something I don't know?

1:18:55I'm trying not to get freaked out

1:18:57by this whole coronavirus thing and not get,

1:18:59there's a germaphobe in me that's dying to get out

1:19:03and I'm like, seeing people walking around the street

1:19:07with medical masks, I'm like, should I have one of those?

1:19:09Should I get one of those?

1:19:11I don't know.

1:19:13- I think you're okay with that one.

1:19:14- Yeah, I think so too.

1:19:15But anyway, let me take a break and thank our next sponsor,

1:19:19are good friends at Casper. Casper makes sleep products. What a weird category, but it's

1:19:28true. That's what they make. Designed by humans for humans. Their products are cleverly

1:19:34designed to mimic human curves, providing supportive comfort for all kinds of bodies.

1:19:38Mattresses, that's where they started. You spend one third of your life sleeping, you

1:19:43should be comfortable. You should have a great mattress. You get it from Casper, you can

1:19:47get a great mattress without spending a lot of money. They have their own team. It's

1:19:53not like they buy white label mattresses and just slap a Casper sticker on them. They have

1:19:58their own sleep engineers, mattress engineers who design their mattresses. Totally, totally

1:20:05part of the tech industry. They've got engineers. Their original Casper mattress, that's the

1:20:10one that was the only Casper mattress for a while, combines multiple supportive memory

1:20:14foams for a quality sleep surface with the right amount of sink and bounce. We've got

1:20:18one of those. We got one of those way back in the day when Casper first started sponsoring

1:20:21the show. Still as good as new. It is still—you wouldn't know it—it's a years-old mattress.

1:20:26Still as good as new. Absolutely lasts. It's a great mattress. Has a breathable design,

1:20:31helps you sleep cool, regulates your body temperature throughout the night. They also

1:20:37now offer two other mattresses—actually, three other mattresses. I'm wrong. They've

1:20:41They've got the Wave, the Essential, and the Hybrid.

1:20:43I forgot about the Hybrid.

1:20:44The Wave features a patent-pending premium support system.

1:20:47This is their high-end model.

1:20:49It's a really, it's the high-end model,

1:20:51but not a super high-end price.

1:20:53Then they've got the Essential.

1:20:54That's their streamlined design

1:20:55at a price that, quote, "won't keep you up at night."

1:20:58That's a lower-priced model, still a great mattress.

1:21:01And then the Hybrid, that's the newest one.

1:21:03It combines the pressure relief of their award-winning foam

1:21:06that their other mattresses have always been made with

1:21:09with durable yet gentle springs.

1:21:12They also offer, this is what I talk about, sleep products.

1:21:15They also offer a wide array of other products

1:21:18like pillows and sheets to ensure

1:21:20an overall better sleep experience.

1:21:23And it's all designed, developed, and assembled

1:21:26right here in the US.

1:21:28They've got affordable prices because Casper

1:21:29cuts out the middleman and sells directly to you.

1:21:32Hassle-free returns if you're not completely satisfied

1:21:35and your mattress gets delivered right to your door

1:21:38in a unbelievably small, how do they do that sized box?

1:21:42Free shipping and returns in the US and Canada

1:21:45for our friends up north.

1:21:46They've got a 100 night,

1:21:50100 night risk-free sleep on it trial.

1:21:53So if you're worried, which is perfectly reasonable,

1:21:55you think, well, how the hell am I gonna buy a mattress

1:21:57if I don't even try it?

1:21:58You can do it, sleep on it for over three months

1:22:01and decide whether you wanna keep it

1:22:03and if you don't, they'll take it.

1:22:04No questions asked, they'll come pick it up,

1:22:08give you all your money back.

1:22:09That's how confident they are

1:22:11that you're gonna love your Casper mattress.

1:22:13We've got a couple of them in the house.

1:22:14I think we're up to three.

1:22:15We love them.

1:22:16They're just great.

1:22:18We miss them when we travel and we come home.

1:22:21We're like, ah, back on our beloved Casper mattresses.

1:22:24We really do like them.

1:22:26You can get, here's a special offer

1:22:27for listeners of the show.

1:22:28You get $100 towards select mattresses

1:22:31by visiting casper.com, C-A-S-P-E-R,

1:22:35casper.com/talkshow.

1:22:36and using that same code as the URL slug,

1:22:39talk show at checkout,

1:22:41you will save 100 bucks towards select mattresses.

1:22:44That's casper.com/talkshow with the code talk show.

1:22:47Terms and conditions, terms and conditions both apply.

1:22:52I had to go to the post office, Ben.

1:22:57This is the type of story I usually tell

1:23:00at the beginning of a show.

1:23:01But I never had, you have a PO box?

1:23:04I don't know what they've got over there in Taiwan.

1:23:07- I don't in Taiwan.

1:23:08I do have one in the US.

1:23:09- Yeah, I've never had one, and I've always wanted one.

1:23:11'Cause you know, I run a business,

1:23:13and people wanna send me things, and I, you know,

1:23:15I don't wanna, you know, I'm always,

1:23:17you know, I'm a private person.

1:23:18I don't wanna send out my home address to anybody.

1:23:22I live in a city.

1:23:23There's post offices nearby that's not really inconvenient.

1:23:26Why don't I have a PO box?

1:23:27I always, I put it off for years, years now.

1:23:29Years and years and years, and I broke down.

1:23:31I went and got it.

1:23:33It turns out the way you get one is you have to go to the web first.

1:23:35You got to go to the USPS.com.

1:23:37You sign up for a PO box and you say which post office do you want it at and what size.

1:23:42Then you can prepay right there over the web.

1:23:44Then they tell you, "Print these two forms."

1:23:47Then one form comes in when you print it.

1:23:49It already has all your info.

1:23:50It's nice.

1:23:51It pre-fills a whole bunch of stuff like your name and your address and some kind of code

1:23:56that verifies that you've paid.

1:23:59then you gotta go to your post office with these forms

1:24:01and two forms of ID, and then they give you the P.O. box.

1:24:05So I go over there today, this is when I saw the pedestrians

1:24:10with their medical masks on, freaked me out.

1:24:12And then I immediately started thinking,

1:24:13well, where's the number one place

1:24:14where you could pick up this virus?

1:24:15Probably the frickin' post office.

1:24:18I go in there, and there's no line.

1:24:20It feels like I've already won the jackpot, right?

1:24:24How many times in the U.S. you don't really go

1:24:26to the post office and see no line?

1:24:28No line, but there's only one person behind the counter.

1:24:30How's this possible?

1:24:31So I walk right up, got my paperwork, I got my ID.

1:24:35Takes, I don't know, more time than I would think,

1:24:38given that all this paperwork's pre-filled.

1:24:40More time than I would think to process, but I wait.

1:24:43And she says, "All right, I gotta go find a key."

1:24:46She disappears in the back.

1:24:48And meanwhile, one or two people

1:24:50have now gotten in line behind me.

1:24:52Still nobody else working.

1:24:55Minutes pass, and several minutes pass,

1:24:59more people get in line.

1:25:01I hear the jingling of keys

1:25:03behind wherever she's gone behind her.

1:25:05I hear keys jingling.

1:25:07Nothing.

1:25:10Finally, people start talking to me.

1:25:12They're like, "Hey, what's going on?

1:25:13"Like, what are we all waiting for?"

1:25:16And I said, "I'm getting a P.O. box."

1:25:19And they're like, "Well, where'd she go?"

1:25:21And she said she had to get a key.

1:25:25And I was, you know, I'm starting to feel self-conscious,

1:25:27basically, right, 'cause I'm holding them up.

1:25:29Even though I don't really think this is my fault,

1:25:31I feel like going to the post office for a P.O. box

1:25:33is a perfectly reasonable thing to do.

1:25:35I start looking around, and you can see the P.O. boxes,

1:25:38and I start sort of mentally guessing how many they have.

1:25:41It looks to me as though they have at least 1,000.

1:25:44I would guess, if I had to, you know,

1:25:46like guessing jelly beans in a jar to win a raffle

1:25:49or something like that, I would guess maybe

1:25:50they have 2,000 post-op P.O. boxes.

1:25:54It doesn't seem like an unusual thing to do.

1:25:56And then at this point, I looked at my watch,

1:26:01and 10 minutes passed.

1:26:0310 full minutes.

1:26:04I still hear keys jingling back there.

1:26:08And thankfully, I will say to my fellow Philadelphians

1:26:12who were there in line, I'm feeling very self-conscious.

1:26:15Every single person was nothing but kind,

1:26:17and everybody's laughing and joking.

1:26:19Nobody was soured by this,

1:26:22but I have to say I felt very self-conscious

1:26:24about the whole thing.

1:26:26Then she comes out and says, "I couldn't find the key.

1:26:30I'm gonna have to change the lock on a box."

1:26:32(laughing)

1:26:34So, and then she's like, "So come back tomorrow."

1:26:37(laughing)

1:26:39That's where I left it.

1:26:40- These don't have a PO box.

1:26:42- Well, yeah, but she gave me the keys.

1:26:44She gave me the keys to the lock

1:26:46that they were gonna put on the box.

1:26:49So I have keys to a P.O. box, but I don't have a P.O. box.

1:26:53Anyway, that was my afternoon.

1:26:57(laughs)

1:26:59What do you want?

1:27:01We should just dig into iPad, what do you think?

1:27:04- Well, yeah, time to start the show.

1:27:05- Yeah, time to start the show.

1:27:06- An hour and a half in.

1:27:08- Yeah, yesterday, or no, not yesterday, two days ago,

1:27:10was the 10-year anniversary of the event

1:27:14where Steve Jobs introduced the iPad.

1:27:17and 10's a nice round number.

1:27:21Lots and lots of people remembering

1:27:24what it was like that day with people

1:27:26of the press who were there,

1:27:28people posting their original reviews,

1:27:30people saying where they think the iPad stands.

1:27:32And I used it as an opportunity to get a lot off my chest.

1:27:37And like you said, you and I have talked

1:27:42about this privately many times,

1:27:45and it's almost to the point where it's almost like

1:27:47one of the reasons like and there were a couple of people who are like where is

1:27:51this rant been why is you know why did it take you so long to write this I've

1:27:54been thinking the same thing for so long and part of it is I've got notes for a

1:27:58lot of complaints about the iPad and you know the directors commentary of daring

1:28:03fireball aspect of the show is that I've been meaning to write deeply critical

1:28:10pieces a deeply critical piece about the state of the iPad software for well over

1:28:16a year. And I haven't--

1:28:18- I think longer than that.

1:28:19We've been talking about this for a while.

1:28:22Like I said, when you finally posted it,

1:28:23I'm like, "Didn't you already post this?"

1:28:25'Cause we've been talking privately

1:28:28about this particular thing for ages.

1:28:32- And the pathology of it in my,

1:28:34the weird parts of my brain is that I've been thinking of it

1:28:39as a massive, like, four, five, six thousand word epic

1:28:43during Fireball post where I get it all out at once in a single narrative that makes complete

1:28:49sense and convinces everybody from Tim Cook on down that, "Yes, this is all right. We should

1:28:54change it all." And here it is. It's a home run that was hit out of the park. And I started writing

1:28:59about the 10-year anniversary of the iPad, and I was like, "You know what? I should just break the

1:29:03ice on this and just get the highest level part of it off my chest, and I could do it in a couple

1:29:08hundred words and then just do the rest and follow up pieces." And why in the hell did it take me

1:29:12three years to figure it out that that would be a much more effective way for me to actually get

1:29:16this off my chest. And it was funny because I wrote about it as well, building on top of you.

1:29:26Someone posted on Twitter, like, "Oh, could I have let Jon have all the fun, right, with the iPad?"

1:29:32I'm like, "No, actually, I said something cryptic in response, but the truth is,

1:29:38you're like, "Okay, I've gotten this started. Can you please come in and jump on top of

1:29:43it?" That was why I did it as sort of an email daily update first and then switched it to

1:29:48being a public post, which is more ... It's interesting, to your point, right? To make

1:29:53something a public post is like it feels so much weightier and more difficult than just

1:29:57dashing an email together. Switching from one ... Dashing together is not right. When

1:30:03I write the daily update for subscribers, by definition, they're people who have been

1:30:08reading me for a while and they kind of already know where I'm coming from on certain issues.

1:30:12And so, you can presume a certain sort of leeway as opposed to when you're writing a public article,

1:30:19it might be the first article they read on your site and you want to be much more,

1:30:22have everything wrapped up in a bow and all the things tied together. But I kind of felt

1:30:27the same way as you, once you had written it, I'm like, "Oh, wait, I've been wanting to say all this

1:30:33stuff too, so I'm just jumping on. And it's going to be out there, and we're going to podcast about

1:30:38it, so might as well make it public. So here we are. And to say that reaction was mixed is an

1:30:44understatement. I would almost say it was so bifurcated—I expected it, though. It was so

1:30:49bifurcated. And I got more, yes, I agree with this, here, here, finally somebody is saying what

1:30:55what I've been trying to say sort of reactions.

1:30:58But I also got a bunch of,

1:31:01you're just an old guy who loves the Mac

1:31:06and you don't get it sort of things.

1:31:08Couple of them, they all mention the word old.

1:31:11And part of that is a frustra, it's just human nature,

1:31:17but I find it deeply frustrating.

1:31:19And it's this aspect of human nature

1:31:21where everybody is drawn towards,

1:31:23And I do feel like our society and internet culture

1:31:28has only added a lot of fuel to the fire

1:31:32of this natural impulse to make everything

1:31:35black or white, binary.

1:31:37It is the greatest thing ever,

1:31:39or it is a total piece of steaming garbage, everything.

1:31:43What do you think of the rise of Skywalker?

1:31:47Great, great Star Wars movie, I love it.

1:31:49Or it is J.J. Abrams should be put in prison,

1:31:52you know, this is awful, this is the worst movie ever made, right? That's what people

1:31:56are drawn to, that's how internet reactions have gone. And despite the fact that I emphasized

1:32:03that the iPad is a beloved, something I like, something I use every day, something that

1:32:09I realized that a lot of people, it's their most beloved personal computing device and

1:32:13they're very effective and efficient with it, something that I called great even, but

1:32:18but also has serious flaws.

1:32:20You have to be willing to accept nuance,

1:32:23in my criticism of the iPad,

1:32:25did not register with people who love the iPad,

1:32:27or at least some.

1:32:28- Oh, it's so true.

1:32:30And I'll verify, you are one of the heaviest iPad users

1:32:33that I know personally.

1:32:35Like this is a, it's not a,

1:32:40if I'm the one that's more dismissive of audit

1:32:42in many respects, 'cause I actually used it

1:32:44less than I did before.

1:32:45But no, just to your point,

1:32:47What people struggle with, neither of us are saying it's a failed product.

1:32:51Right.

1:32:52It's not everything it could have been, right?

1:32:57And this is when the hardest—I get this, I know exactly what you're talking about.

1:33:01It's like, you have to look at something not as it is, but as it could be, and it's okay to

1:33:09recognize and bemoan that there's some sort of potential or some sort of possibility

1:33:14that was perhaps not reached.

1:33:16Yeah, and I am a self-professed Mac person, and I probably always will be, and even in

1:33:24the hypothetical universe where the iPad 10 years in was much closer to its potential

1:33:30of where it could be 10 years in, still probably would be a Mac person.

1:33:37But I would rather be in that world because I'd rather have it be a fair fight, whereas

1:33:43the things that really frustrate me about the iPad aren't even a fair fight compared

1:33:47to the Mac.

1:33:48And I don't see how anybody could deny it.

1:33:51And I do -- I don't want to generalize.

1:33:53I really don't.

1:33:55But I -- to put Apple computing users into three buckets.

1:34:02And I realize that lots and lots of them are in all three, or at least two, but there's

1:34:09iPhone users and there's iPad users and there's Mac users.

1:34:12And again, I'm all three, lots of people are,

1:34:15almost everybody has an iPhone, right?

1:34:17There's very few people in the Apple ecosystem

1:34:19who don't at least have an iPhone.

1:34:21If, you know, maybe it's their only device,

1:34:22or maybe it's the one thing they have in addition

1:34:25to a Mac or an iPad, but people who use the iPhone,

1:34:30so I'm not saying that there are three different groups,

1:34:32but I'm just saying people who use the iPhone

1:34:34will complain about aspects of the iPhone interface.

1:34:37Mac users, we've been complaining about the Mac all along.

1:34:41Like nobody is a bigger and more astute critic and loves to complain about aspects of the

1:34:49Mac going back to 1984 than people who love the Mac the most.

1:34:54The people who love the Mac the most are the most astute critics of everything that's wrong

1:34:59about the Mac.

1:35:00Look at John Siracusa's epic Ars Technica reviews of it, which would talk about new

1:35:09new features, and when they were confusing or wrong or slow or whatever, he was the one

1:35:14who wrote the most words about them.

1:35:18iPad users, not all, like Federico Viticci, to his credit, who is probably the most efficient

1:35:25iPad user I've ever heard of, has built his entire—he's a super productive person who

1:35:31does—writes thousands and thousands of words a week and does podcasts and does all this

1:35:36work on his iPad and shares his techniques and shortcuts and stuff like that to his readers.

1:35:44It's a lot of what he writes about is at the meta level of how to be an iPad power user.

1:35:49It fully acknowledges some of the things that I'm talking about as shortcomings.

1:35:54There's certainly not everybody. That's what I mean about not generalizing. But boy, oh boy,

1:35:59are there a lot of people out there who love their iPads, use it as their primary computing device,

1:36:05and do not want to hear one bad word about it." There is a sort of emperor's new clothes aspect

1:36:14to it where they're like, "Hey, these people who are saying the emperor is buck naked,

1:36:19they're just haters." Well, I think it's interesting because you get this with Apple

1:36:24just sort of as a whole. Yes, yes. Where Apple is part of people's—like, there's no other company

1:36:30where people have Twitter handles that includes the company's logo in them, right? There's an

1:36:35aspect of Apple that ties into people's identity. They're an Apple person. And I think that is taken

1:36:41to 11 when it comes to the iPad. If you're an iPad person, that's what you do. You have made this

1:36:50commitment. You've made it this end of your life. You're living in the future. You're not an old

1:36:54fogey. You're using a Mac or a PC. And it's not something that you do. I don't know. Again,

1:37:03A real danger in writing online is something you have to learn as an author very early

1:37:07is that your Twitter commenters are not your core readership, right?

1:37:11It's a sort of a fraction of the fraction.

1:37:14But I think there is an aspect where all the things that you and I both know are the case

1:37:20for Apple fans is just double the case when it comes to being an iPad person.

1:37:26Yeah, like if you run a restaurant, the people who want to speak to the manager aren't

1:37:30necessarily indicative of the entire clientele of the restaurant.

1:37:37But I –

1:37:38Well, but it's funny because there's an RUR that sort of makes the point, right?

1:37:42Like why would it be part of your identity if it's something that's super accessible

1:37:46and easy for everyone to use, right?

1:37:48There's an aspect where it is special to use the iPad for all of your computing, and

1:37:54the reason it's special is our entire point.

1:37:56It shouldn't be so special.

1:37:57It should be more broadly accessible.

1:37:59- Yeah, absolutely should be.

1:38:01And I really do find it hard.

1:38:04I think that the only, one of the reasons

1:38:07that we find ourselves in this situation 10 years in

1:38:11is that I think there has to be a contingent within Apple

1:38:15that is within Apple who is the same way,

1:38:18who thinks this is fine, because look at our sales.

1:38:21We're selling 10, 11, 12 million of the things

1:38:25every quarter, quarter after quarter,

1:38:28And there's so many things to love about it,

1:38:32and that these other things, they must be fine.

1:38:34And they're not fine.

1:38:36There's some of these things are truly screwed up.

1:38:40And one of the things I devoted my attention to

1:38:42in my piece this week is the multitasking interface.

1:38:46And I tried to make it clear, I think it was clear,

1:38:49it doesn't seem like people were confused,

1:38:50but when I talk about multitasking with iPad,

1:38:52what I mean is putting two apps on screen at a time.

1:38:55It is in the user interface sense

1:38:57of seeing two things at a time,

1:38:59whether it's side-by-side apps or slide over

1:39:02or side-by-side with slide over.

1:39:04A couple people pointed out that you can show two

1:39:06and only two apps at a time is wrong

1:39:08'cause you're gonna have two apps on screen

1:39:09with split screen and then do a slide over.

1:39:11All right, you got me.

1:39:15I think that's what I mean by multitasking.

1:39:20I don't mean it in the computer science sense

1:39:22because we've had quote-unquote multitasking

1:39:25in the computer science sense of multiple processes

1:39:28running on the iPad all along.

1:39:30There've always been background processes running

1:39:33to get new mail or to have incoming SMS

1:39:35or phone calls answered and stuff like that.

1:39:37So, you know.

1:39:38- The phone multitasks, right?

1:39:41In sort of a technological sense.

1:39:43- Right.

1:39:44- But that's not what you're referring to.

1:39:45- But the split screen stuff,

1:39:46putting two apps on screen at a time,

1:39:48is in my opinion a fiasco.

1:39:50I really, and part of me procrastinated

1:39:55on getting this off my chest because, like I said,

1:39:58I wanted to do too much at once in one epic piece.

1:40:02I wanted to hit one baseball that literally

1:40:04went out of Yankee Stadium, not just knock

1:40:07a couple singles up the middle over a period

1:40:10of a couple days and score some, win a couple games,

1:40:13which is what I think I should have done

1:40:14and I'm gonna try to do going forward.

1:40:19But it's bad and it's confusing.

1:40:22And I mean, I got so many responses from people

1:40:26who I know are smart, really smart technical users,

1:40:29people who, you know, Jeremy Zawadny,

1:40:32who literally wrote like the O'Reilly book on SQL.

1:40:37(laughing)

1:40:38Like was like, yeah, I had no idea how to,

1:40:39I had no idea you could get two apps on screen

1:40:41at once on an iPad.

1:40:43I mean, really smart people who either A,

1:40:45didn't know how to do it or like me,

1:40:48sometimes get into it and don't know how to get out of it.

1:40:50Like, God forbid you end up with two instances of Safari

1:40:54with two different sets of tabs and then you, oh my God,

1:40:58it's like, where the hell is the one that's open?

1:41:00It's like, oh, there's two versions of Safari now.

1:41:02It reminds me of like the old versions of Windows,

1:41:04like Windows 3, you could like click Excel

1:41:08and then Excel is running.

1:41:09And if you click the Excel icon again,

1:41:11it doesn't open Excel,

1:41:12it would open another instance of Excel.

1:41:15And you can have multiple documents in both instances.

1:41:18And it's like, who the hell thought that was a good idea?

1:41:21Well, that's the iPad.

1:41:21The iPad does that.

1:41:23You can have two completely different instances

1:41:25that you can't get together.

1:41:27And if you connect a hardware keyboard

1:41:29and you hit Command-Tab, it acts like it's a Mac

1:41:32or a Windows computer and just shows one icon

1:41:35for every app that's running.

1:41:37And you go to Safari, but you have two instances

1:41:40of Safari running in your iPad spaces.

1:41:43Which one comes forward?

1:41:44Well, toss a coin, because I can't figure out what the heuristic is, and there's no

1:41:48way to get to the other one via command-tap.

1:41:52It is really confusing.

1:41:53I mentioned my mom, who has somehow—I don't know what exactly she's done.

1:41:59It typically involves mail.

1:42:02I think for the most part, my mom uses—she uses her iPad a lot.

1:42:05Let me just emphasize that.

1:42:07In a house with an iMac.

1:42:08My dad's more of an iMac guy.

1:42:10I think he likes having the big screen.

1:42:13My mom really loves her iPad.

1:42:16I mean, just really, really loves it.

1:42:18She thrives on it.

1:42:19She does more computing than she did before.

1:42:23Just for the record, she's 74 years old, very smart,

1:42:26but not technically inclined at all.

1:42:28Sort of defensive about her lack of technical inclination,

1:42:31is always afraid that she's broken something.

1:42:33When she first called me with this problem,

1:42:35she was convinced she broke her iPad, because she'd go to mail.

1:42:39And now mail was side by side with Safari.

1:42:43in a little skinny iPhone-sized window.

1:42:46Didn't know how to get out of it.

1:42:48I explained how she could drag the divider

1:42:51to make mail go full screen again,

1:42:52but then every time she'd just tap a link in mail,

1:42:54it would open again in split screen in Safari.

1:42:59And she was confused and didn't know how to get out of it.

1:43:02And it's a very, very difficult thing

1:43:04to talk somebody through on the phone,

1:43:07much more difficult than any Mac thing

1:43:09I've ever talked her through in 15, 20 years

1:43:11talking my mom through any kind of problem.

1:43:14You know, like over the years,

1:43:15like they've made it harder to do this now.

1:43:17Like when you drag an icon out of your dock on the Mac,

1:43:20you have to drag it a lot further away

1:43:22before it'll poof and vanish.

1:43:25You know, if you just drag it--

1:43:26- I think by default it might be impossible.

1:43:28I can't remember it.

1:43:29- No, if you drag it really far away, it'll poof away.

1:43:32But in the old days, if you just dragged it out of the dock,

1:43:34like one of your saved icons,

1:43:36like I want Safari always in my dock.

1:43:39Well, you'd mouse and not an expert mouse user,

1:43:44maybe, or my dad did it, drag,

1:43:46instead of clicking Safari, clicked and held a little bit,

1:43:48then moved the mouse, and then Safari poofed out of the dock

1:43:52and then from my parents' perspective,

1:43:54if it's not in the dock, it's gone, right?

1:43:56Like the phone call, "Dad deleted Safari."

1:44:00(laughing)

1:44:02I could talk them through that though, right?

1:44:03I could talk them through using Spotlight or something

1:44:06to get Safari and then just drag it back into the dock,

1:44:09and there it is, I could talk her through it on the phone.

1:44:11Talking somebody like my mom through this

1:44:15split screen stuff is madness,

1:44:17because one of the things I didn't mention,

1:44:20but I want to write about,

1:44:21is the fact that it's all gesture-based, almost all,

1:44:26and there's no visual on-screen controls.

1:44:30Just think about like on the Mac with Windows,

1:44:34and I'm not saying that iPad

1:44:35have draggable windows that overlap, but I think they could learn some stuff from the

1:44:40Mac. So in a Mac, no matter what app you're in and you have a window open, how do you

1:44:45close it? Well, there's a red button up in the upper left-hand corner, and if you click

1:44:51that red button, the window closes. And everybody knows it. Nobody doesn't know it. And it doesn't

1:44:58matter what app you're in, there's a red button up there, and you can click that button and

1:45:02close it. And yes, I know that you can switch to the graphite theme and it'll be gray buttons,

1:45:06and I've run in graphite mode over the years on and off, but normal people don't even know

1:45:11that's possible and would never want to run in the graphite mode where it's a gray button. There's

1:45:15always a red button. You can click it. It closes the window. How do you close one of these split

1:45:19screen panels? Good luck. Sometimes you can drag the divider. If it's on the left, you can't. You

1:45:26You can't just close it.

1:45:28It's crazy.

1:45:29Anyway, the good news about this is after,

1:45:32my mom actually read the thing on Daring Fireball,

1:45:34and then she saw that I mentioned her.

1:45:36She called me up, and she said,

1:45:37"Yeah, guess what, I figured it out."

1:45:39'Cause one thing, I guess I knew this, and I forgot it.

1:45:41There is, in fact, a setting on the iPad,

1:45:43and it's not in accessibility.

1:45:45And the fact that it's not in accessibility, to me,

1:45:47is sort of like a tacit admission

1:45:49that this multitasking stuff can be confusing.

1:45:52You can go to Settings, and then what's it called?

1:45:56Let me make sure I get it right.

1:45:58Settings.

1:45:59Home screen and dock.

1:46:03And then you hit multitasking

1:46:05and you can just allow multiple apps.

1:46:07You can just turn it off.

1:46:09She figured that out on her own.

1:46:10And then once you turn that off,

1:46:12you can't do slide over or split screen multitasking.

1:46:16Just doesn't happen.

1:46:17And for me, one of the big advantages to that

1:46:21is when you're in Safari and you tap and hold a link

1:46:23and there's like a context menu that comes up.

1:46:25And what I usually want to do is tap open a new tab,

1:46:29but when you have allow multiple apps on,

1:46:32right next to open a new tab is open a new window,

1:46:35and you say you can accidentally tap that

1:46:37because it's one finger width away,

1:46:41and now all of a sudden you're stuck

1:46:42with two instances of Safari.

1:46:43Anyway, my mom figured it out on her own

1:46:46and turned that off and wanted me to let everybody know

1:46:49that she's no longer bedeviled by split screen

1:46:53iPad multitasking because she turned it off.

1:46:57Just get it, like, and just think about the fact

1:47:01that on the Mac, nobody ever wants to turn off

1:47:04the ability to show two apps at the same time.

1:47:07Nobody, there's, nobody's ever been bedeviled

1:47:10by the fact that there's a Safari window

1:47:13peeking out behind your mail window.

1:47:16Nobody's ever been bedeviled or confused by this.

1:47:19Nobody ever wants, boy, I sure wish I could turn that off.

1:47:23- Yeah, so what I did to sort of follow up on this

1:47:27was sort of think about how we got to this point, right?

1:47:31Like why is it that Apple went in this direction?

1:47:34And you go back to the beginning,

1:47:37and this is why the 10-year period

1:47:41was a great time to look back,

1:47:42'cause you go back and think about the way

1:47:44that Jobs talked about the iPad

1:47:46and what it was positioned as.

1:47:49And there is this, the iPad was the,

1:47:54all it is is the screen, right?

1:47:56It is the sort of the essence of a computer.

1:48:00John Sirk, you were talking about the naked robotic core.

1:48:03Like this is what it is.

1:48:05And it was so transformational and impressive

1:48:09because it becomes whatever you want it to be.

1:48:12And in a way that a Mac never can, right?

1:48:15To your point that there's gonna be a lot of Chrome

1:48:18not the browser, but all the infrastructure

1:48:21and detritus of the user interface is always there.

1:48:24And it needs to always be there,

1:48:26because that's how you manage the complexity

1:48:29of what you can accomplish on the Mac,

1:48:31whereas the iPad is something completely different.

1:48:33The iPad, it becomes a music studio.

1:48:36It becomes, add in the application,

1:48:39it becomes a drawing surface,

1:48:41which remains my biggest use case for the iPad.

1:48:44I do the drawings of Forcio Trekri on it.

1:48:46it becomes a TV, right?

1:48:48In these cases, I'm watching NBA games on it, right?

1:48:51And this is such a powerful, powerful concept,

1:48:56and it's distinctly different than what a Mac is.

1:49:00A Mac is a tool for doing different things.

1:49:03An iPad is a, not an illusionist,

1:49:07what's the word I'm looking for, a chameleon?

1:49:10Like it becomes whatever the thing that you're doing is.

1:49:14And this, uh, and what, where was the reason why we'll get to how we got there in a moment,

1:49:20but the reason why I think the multitasking idea and model on the iPad is fundamentally flawed is it

1:49:28imposes the, the, the Chrome, the detritus of the operating system onto a surface that ought to be a

1:49:38transformative shape-changing sort of thing, right?

1:49:43And you lose that.

1:49:46You lose that ability for an iPad to change what it is because you're imposing this sort

1:49:53of stuff on top of it that doesn't make sense in the context of that sort of view of it.

1:50:00Yeah, but I'll acknowledge.

1:50:02I will acknowledge because people keep saying, one of the responses is, "Well, I use the

1:50:07split screen thing. I use my iPad all day. It's my main computer and I love the split screen.

1:50:11Not nobody's defended the actual interface. Nobody has said it's a fantastic interface

1:50:16for getting two apps on screen at once. They just say that they love the capability because they do

1:50:22use it. They love having their notes open next to a video. You know, they're watching a video and

1:50:28they're taking notes on the video because they can split screen it or something like that.

1:50:32I get that, and I do think it should be possible,

1:50:36but I just think it should be possible in a way

1:50:39where it should be super easy and obvious

1:50:43how you get back to one thing at a time

1:50:46that transforms the device.

1:50:47You emphasized in your piece the GarageBand demo,

1:50:52which wasn't from the original iPad event.

1:50:56It was the iPad 2 event one year later,

1:50:59and it was one of Jobs' last on-stage appearances.

1:51:03He was at WWDC then, which was his last on-stage appearance.

1:51:07But the GarageBand demo really was an app.

1:51:10I just haven't had time.

1:51:13I did a lot of writing.

1:51:14I didn't sit down and watch the whole iPad intro again.

1:51:17It's on my list for something to do this week,

1:51:19probably maybe the weekend.

1:51:21But I did watch that, and I do have to say,

1:51:24man, I do remember being blown away by that.

1:51:26That GarageBand demo from the One Year In thing

1:51:30was really, really interesting,

1:51:32totally counter to that narrative that runs to this day

1:51:36that it's a device for consumption, not for creation.

1:51:40And the point you made that was so great

1:51:41is the GarageBand on iPad was immersive

1:51:46and transformed the device in a way

1:51:49that GarageBand from Mac never could,

1:51:51just by the definite, you know, like it just,

1:51:54all of a sudden the iPad is a piano, right? It doesn't look like a piano and you use a mouse to

1:52:01click keys or you type keys on a physical QWERTY keyboard and it simulates piano keys. It just

1:52:08turns into piano keys and you touch them and they go down and it makes music. It was incredible.

1:52:15We can get into it in a moment. I actually, I would go much further than you. I think that

1:52:22even having the sort of multitasking capability on the iPad is a mistake in what we're talking about.

1:52:28So that's obviously much more controversial to take. But just to follow up on this,

1:52:33the, you know, there's a lot of pushback on the "Oh, the iPad is for creation, not just consumption."

1:52:38If you go back and watch the first one, it's clearly framed as a consumption device, right?

1:52:43Like, Jobs literally sat on a couch for the demo because he wanted to emphasize that it is more of

1:52:52of a layback, lean back sort of experience as opposed to a lean forward at your desk,

1:52:58you know, sort of Mac experience. And so, like, it's not a, and for good reason, it's

1:53:04an amazing consumption device, right? The, you know, for, again, I use it all the time

1:53:10for watching sports. Like the, that's what I, you know, because I'm international, so

1:53:15I watch it through WePass and LB.TV and whatever, and I do use it on the iPad, and it's great

1:53:20for that and you can take it with you and it's a great experience we're having a larger screen

1:53:25than your phone is really super desirable because you want to see things clearly uh you know but

1:53:29kids watch netflix or youtube or whatever on it like it's it's an amazing consumption experience

1:53:34and it remains that and i think as far as we can tell that is what even today 10 years on the vast

1:53:42majority of ipads are used for yeah uh and so it's not i think there was a there was a sense for a

1:53:48while where people writing about Apple were sort of defensive about the iPad being called

1:53:54a consumption device, but actually that's what it is, right? First and foremost. And

1:53:59that was there on day one.

1:54:01And it's embraced so far across the line. I mean, MLB has always been at a technical

1:54:05level ahead of the other sports leagues in the US. I don't know why. Maybe because

1:54:12they were in decline in popularity, and it is the stuff, you know, it's the oldest

1:54:16but like the MLB team, you know, was the ones,

1:54:19they were the ones who solved the problem.

1:54:21Like when HBO first started trying to stream video

1:54:25and servers burst into flames

1:54:27by people trying to watch Game of Thrones,

1:54:29they went to the MLB team,

1:54:31and the MLB team were the ones who figured out

1:54:33how to stream it, and then Disney bought that business

1:54:35from MLB because I actually think that their technology

1:54:39probably is at the heart of Disney Plus

1:54:41now that I think about it.

1:54:42I hadn't really thought about it.

1:54:43- That's right, it is.

1:54:44No, Disney acquired them, yeah.

1:54:45And it's very strong technology.

1:54:48- It's really strong.

1:54:49And if you're impressed by the fact

1:54:51that Disney+ launched with all this fanfare

1:54:53and went off seamlessly and you just hit play on Mandalorian

1:54:57and it just comes up and plays,

1:54:58it's thanks to the technology they acquired from MLB.

1:55:01Yeah, it's really, yeah, I was pretty sure

1:55:04that they're at the heart of that.

1:55:05Really, really, really strong technology.

1:55:07Leads the industry.

1:55:08I mean, it's up there.

1:55:10I mean, I know Netflix is great too,

1:55:11but it's as good as it gets.

1:55:12- You talk to Netflix engineers and they will say,

1:55:15Yeah, the only other streaming technology worth a crap is yeah is is is the the it's called BAM tech now. Yeah

1:55:21What was BAM?

1:55:23Baseball advanced some media or something like that, but they just went because it's no longer just baseball. It's yeah BAM tech

1:55:29NBA culturally is certainly far ahead of the other leagues in terms of being up-to-date and embracing social media. I mean

1:55:37NBA Twitter is like no other sports Twitter and we could do a whole show on that and I know you'd probably spend 12 hours a

1:55:44with your No Tech Bend Twitter account on it.

1:55:48So it's not surprising to me that the NBA

1:55:50also has a really good streaming experience to iPads.

1:55:53- No, the streaming experience is terrible.

1:55:54- Well, or at least they try.

1:55:56Well, at least they try, they try, they try.

1:55:58But the one that blows me away is that the NFL

1:56:01has really embraced it, and part of it is

1:56:03that I have a cable subscription still

1:56:05and I've registered through it.

1:56:07But I watched an awful lot of NFL football this year

1:56:10on my iPad instead of on TV,

1:56:13And it's really good technically,

1:56:15but it's just amazing to me that the NFL of all networks,

1:56:19which is the one that is the most dominant,

1:56:21has the most money, and is sort of therefore

1:56:24the least likely to embrace something new.

1:56:27The iPad is like a first-class client

1:56:30for watching live NFL games now.

1:56:32And it's just, it just blows me away.

1:56:34Like in a way that your computer can't be,

1:56:36and that you wouldn't want it, it's too small,

1:56:38you don't want to watch it on your phone.

1:56:39I mean, I know people do watch on their phone,

1:56:40but it's no good.

1:56:42You watch on your phone because it's the only way to watch it, right?

1:56:44Right.

1:56:45Because you're—whereas you would voluntarily watch something on the iPad because—

1:56:48Right.

1:56:49You're at like a kid's birthday party and there's a game you want to watch.

1:56:51Okay, you're going to watch at your phone.

1:56:53Right, exactly.

1:56:55But watching on your iPad is like totally credible.

1:56:57It is like absolutely totally credible and keeps up to—anyway, it's just—it is

1:57:01a great—I don't want to get too sidetracked from our complaints, but it is a great consumption

1:57:05device and it's a better TV than my TV.

1:57:08Yup.

1:57:09That's exactly—no, that's exactly right.

1:57:11And it's disruptive in a way, right, to take this sort of full circle because you can layer

1:57:15on all sorts of stuff and things that you can't have on your TV.

1:57:21But the interactivity and the portability, but while also having this large screen that,

1:57:26you know, holding an iPad right in front of you relative to a large TV on the wall, like

1:57:31the actual viewing experience is actually much, the difference is much smaller than

1:57:35you might think it is.

1:57:36And the screen quality is incredible and all those sorts of things.

1:57:40At the initial iPad launch, they also showed iWork.

1:57:45And it was also kind of a mind-blowing demo in that they were doing this really cool stuff

1:57:51with inserting stuff and moving stuff around with your fingers.

1:57:56And there was the hint of something there.

1:57:59And I wrote about, I had a few sort of false starts as far as blogs going through the years,

1:58:06I had like a tumbler back in the day where I wrote about the iPad when it launched and

1:58:12you know I talked about it you know where it fit relative to the phone and relative

1:58:17to the computer but at the end of my career what's really compelling here is is the

1:58:21you know I focus on content consumption like this is clearly a content consumption device

1:58:24I'm gonna take one time out I'm just gonna tell you right now as a listener I'm gonna

1:58:28remember I'm gonna remember this I am gonna put that graphic you're talking about it's

1:58:32gonna be the album art as we talk right now so you could just look at your phone and look

1:58:36at the album art, you'll see the drawing Ben's talking about.

1:58:39All right, keep going.

1:58:41Well, a 10-year-old drawing, some of which

1:58:43holds up better than others.

1:58:44But again, you go back and-- one of the things that

1:58:48has constricted the iPad over time

1:58:49is that phones now are so much larger.

1:58:51But you remember back in 2010, you're

1:58:53dealing with a 3.5-inch crappy screen where you really

1:58:55didn't want to be watching an NBA game on that.

1:58:59The iPad was just incredible.

1:59:00It was so much larger and better.

1:59:02But I put at the end-- so that article

1:59:04was focused on as a content consumption device. But at the end, I'm like, look, there's something

1:59:08else here. Like what was it? I mentioned that I work demo, I'm like, you can do stuff that

1:59:14you just can't do on a computer because you're directly manipulating it. Now, the implication

1:59:19is there's stuff you can do on a computer that you can't do on an iPad. But it was new,

1:59:24it was something different and new. And that's where the the the GarageBand demo and this

1:59:28the the iPad 2 announcement comes in for me. Like the it was it like I someone who has

1:59:33dabbled around in sort of these music creation apps and you know I'm a piano player and stuff

1:59:38like that. It was so mind-blowing. That's the only time I've ever stood in line for

1:59:42an Apple product. I had to get the iPad 2 and I was going on a plane that night to Taiwan

1:59:50and I downloaded GarageBand and I spent the entire 12-hour flight just like making songs.

1:59:55It's hard. It was mind-blowing. It was absolutely incredible the way that you could

2:00:03do stuff that wasn't really possible.

2:00:05Again, it was technically possible on a computer, but the user interface and experience was

2:00:11just transformative on the iPad.

2:00:13It was absolutely incredible.

2:00:15And what was so, and you saw, Jobs knew it, right?

2:00:20It's one of my all-time favorite Jobs on stage moments is the like 15 seconds after the demo,

2:00:26and he's on there and he's just like, he's used this.

2:00:30He was involved in the creation of it.

2:00:32He knew the demo, they had run through it.

2:00:34And even then, he just looks astonished.

2:00:36Right?

2:00:37He's like, "I can't believe…"

2:00:39And to me, it was a wonderful moment that I reflected on a lot when Jobs passed away

2:00:46later that year.

2:00:48I'm glad that he was able to have that moment as an exec, because it was, to my mind, the

2:00:56culmination of his life's work.

2:00:58Because he comes on there and he's like, "Isn't it incredible?"

2:01:01And then he says something like, he's like,

2:01:04now anyone can make music.

2:01:06And like, that's what, he wanted the computer for anyone,

2:01:10that anyone could unlock their creativity.

2:01:13Anyone could do this because it was so much more intuitive

2:01:16and so much more approachable.

2:01:17- And direct.

2:01:18- And fundamentally, it was fundamentally less powerful.

2:01:22- Yeah.

2:01:23- Like, you could not do in GarageBand,

2:01:25well, you could do in Logic,

2:01:26or you could do in GarageBand on the Mac.

2:01:28Because you're limited to the direct interaction,

2:01:30it was fundamentally less powerful.

2:01:34But it was disruptive in the best sense of the word.

2:01:37It did not meet the needs of true musicians who

2:01:39were wanting to make a huge sort of-- make a professional song.

2:01:44But it meant it was way more accessible to way more people

2:01:48to actually build their own songs.

2:01:50And to me, that was what was so amazing and compelling

2:01:57about the iPad.

2:01:58And what I feel we've never really seen the full manifestation of was this possibility

2:02:04of completely new kinds of applications, new kinds of computing that would open up the

2:02:09power of computers to so many more people.

2:02:13And that's why the whole discussion of the multitasking thing is so, like, it's so

2:02:19frustrating to me because we're debating these power user features that are basically

2:02:29trying to recreate what we can already do on the Mac, but we're trading away. It's

2:02:35more complex and less powerful and less useful. And I'm over here saying, "What about this

2:02:42whole world that was sort of stillborn, where you could do something that you could not

2:02:47do on the PC. When we're talking about dealing with multiple Windows, we can do that on the

2:02:51PC. It's like, would you rather do that on the PC or would you rather do that on the computer?

2:02:54Would you rather stay at a Motel 6 or would you rather stay at a Ritz-Carlton? Well,

2:02:57if we make the Motel 6, we have much nicer bedsheets, and if we have better service,

2:03:03and we make the rooms bigger, then we could have a Ritz-Carlton too. And it's like,

2:03:08that's not disruptive. It's trying to do the same thing, but from a different perspective.

2:03:13I want something that's completely and utterly new, and when I look back 10 years on, it's

2:03:19like, where are those applications?

2:03:23That's what I'm interested in.

2:03:24Right, and now we have Apple bragging about desktop class Safari, which is, again, just

2:03:31parody.

2:03:32It's just parody.

2:03:33Anyway, I want to take a break.

2:03:34I have one more sponsor to thank, but—and then we'll bring this home on iPad.

2:03:38Brand new sponsor.

2:03:39We're the show.

2:03:40It's our good friends at Feels.

2:03:42F-E-A-L-S.

2:03:46What is FEALS?

2:03:47FEALS is a premium CBD delivered directly to your doorstop.

2:03:52What does FEALS do?

2:03:54FEALS naturally helps reduce stress, anxiety,

2:03:57pain, and sleeplessness.

2:03:59It'll help you sleep.

2:04:00Easy to take.

2:04:02How do you take it?

2:04:03You take a few drops of FEALS,

2:04:05drop it under your tongue,

2:04:07and you will feel the difference within minutes.

2:04:10New to CBD, don't know what it's all about,

2:04:13Feels offers a free CBD hotline and text message support.

2:04:18Personally, I'd rather text than call somebody on the phone,

2:04:22but whatever you want, you can do it,

2:04:24and they can help you guide your personal experience.

2:04:27You can feel better naturally with Feels.

2:04:29It works naturally to help you feel better.

2:04:31There's no high.

2:04:33It's not stuff that gets you high.

2:04:35There's no hangover, no addiction,

2:04:38and it's a membership system.

2:04:39you join the Feals community and you get Feals delivered

2:04:42to your door every month, you'll save money on every order

2:04:45because you're a member and you can pause

2:04:47or cancel at any time.

2:04:49Feals will make you feel your best every day.

2:04:54It can help you get to sleep, reduce anxiety,

2:04:58it's good stuff.

2:04:59You can become a member today by going to Feals.com,

2:05:01F-E-A-L-S.com/talkshow.

2:05:06And when you use that URL, F-E-A-L-S.com/talkshow,

2:05:11you will get 50% off your first order,

2:05:15half off your first order, and free shipping.

2:05:19That's fields.com/talkshow.

2:05:21You'll become a member and get 50% off automatically

2:05:26your first order with free shipping.

2:05:29My thanks to Fields for sponsoring the show.

2:05:31Give 'em a try.

2:05:31- I really like the fact that we started

2:05:35with the sort of the disruption in Christians and stuff

2:05:38a bit in the beginning.

2:05:39Because I think it gets at exactly why I am frustrated

2:05:44by the product, disappointed in the product.

2:05:46Again, it's not to say it's not, people don't love them

2:05:50and it's not successful and Apple doesn't make a lot

2:05:52of money from them.

2:05:53It's that it--

2:05:54- I think that's what masks the problems,

2:05:57that people do love them and people do use them

2:06:00and so it's easy for somebody to defend it

2:06:02and say there's nothing wrong, right?

2:06:04It's successful and people love it.

2:06:07But I really, it is frustrating to me.

2:06:09And I don't think it's lived up to the potential.

2:06:12And while I like the fact that they're talking,

2:06:14that they've added quote unquote desktop class Safari,

2:06:16like that should, 10 years in,

2:06:18that should not be a bragging point.

2:06:20- Well, I mean, it's just like, if the,

2:06:24why is it, it's sad to me that the goal

2:06:27is to compete with the Mac.

2:06:29It's sad because one, like the Mac's pretty good

2:06:31at what it does, and if anything,

2:06:33I'd rather have more resources go there to make it better.

2:06:35But two, it's sad because you're playing on the max turf.

2:06:38Like, if you wanna compete with a multi-window environment,

2:06:43probably best to start with the environment

2:06:45that was built with multi-window assumptions

2:06:47from the beginning.

2:06:48The iPad was not built with those assumptions.

2:06:50The iPad was built with one-window assumptions,

2:06:52that it's the entire, again, that it transforms the device

2:06:56into a music studio, it transforms the device into an easel,

2:07:00transforms the device into a photo editing environment or whatever it might be.

2:07:06And I think there's two areas where the iPad really lost its way.

2:07:12The first area, unfortunately, and it fits with the theme, I guess, of this podcast,

2:07:17was Jobs passing away.

2:07:19Like I'm very reticent to go into what Steve Jobs would do something different.

2:07:26But I think the one product that misses Jobs

2:07:30more than any other product is the iPad.

2:07:32Like again, to me it really was the culmination

2:07:37of what he was pushing computing to be,

2:07:40his vision of what computing could be,

2:07:42computing for the rest of us.

2:07:44And when he was gone, who had that vision?

2:07:49- I think one of the things Steve Jobs was so good at,

2:07:53and his reputation is that he was so,

2:07:57I mean, for lack of a better word, arrogant, right?

2:07:59And you couldn't tell him anything,

2:08:01but the fact is he did listen.

2:08:03And famously, there's always a bunch of stories

2:08:05where someone would get in an argument with them,

2:08:07and Jobs would say X, and you would say Y,

2:08:10and then you'd make your case for Y,

2:08:12and he'd say, "That's stupid."

2:08:13And you'd come back the next day,

2:08:14and Jobs would say, "I have a great idea, why?"

2:08:17(laughing)

2:08:18Right? - Yeah.

2:08:19- And that was his way of acknowledging that you were right.

2:08:21It was like he slept on it,

2:08:22And he was like, yeah, you know what, that's a good idea.

2:08:24And then he'd convince himself it was his idea,

2:08:26and then, you know, go ahead.

2:08:27But he could admit mistakes, right?

2:08:31And he didn't go into denial about them.

2:08:34And so, in small ways, I do think that if jobs

2:08:37were still around, I think that the MacBook keyboard

2:08:42fiasco would have ended sooner.

2:08:44- Without question.

2:08:45- I'm not saying they wouldn't have shipped it.

2:08:47And I've always said throughout the whole thing,

2:08:49the problem isn't that they shipped that keyboard.

2:08:51The problem is, I mean--

2:08:54- They shipped it for three and a half years.

2:08:55- Ideally, they wouldn't have shipped it,

2:08:56but you make mistakes, you know what I mean?

2:08:58They shipped the MacCube,

2:09:00and it turned out it was not the right idea.

2:09:02You know what they did?

2:09:02They stopped production of the MacCube.

2:09:05They didn't make the MacCube for four years

2:09:06and keep throwing good money after bad.

2:09:09I really do think that there are ways

2:09:13that Jobs' leadership and his style would have helped.

2:09:18But the Mac doesn't need that much help.

2:09:20The Mac, it knows what it is, it does what it does really well, and the phone has done

2:09:27really well post-jobs, in that there's people clearly at Apple who kind of have a really

2:09:33good sense of the iPhone.

2:09:34It's clearly, you know, because it makes the most money.

2:09:37I mean, you can be cynical about it.

2:09:39It gets the highest talent within the company to pay the fullest attention to every aspect

2:09:45of it, hardware and software.

2:09:47And I think it's in a really good place, software-wise.

2:09:52I really do think iOS 13 is in a really good place.

2:09:55And there's things I would change.

2:09:56Everybody has complaints, but I'm with you.

2:10:01I think that the iPad is the one product where really,

2:10:04and at a big level, it's not like a little thing,

2:10:06like, oh, I don't think the buttons should be flat.

2:10:08I think they should have a little bit of 3D

2:10:09or something like that.

2:10:10It's not a superficial thing.

2:10:11I think at a very profound, fundamental level--

2:10:14- A conceptual level. - Yeah, conceptual level,

2:10:16The iPad could be so much further along,

2:10:20and I do think, and I'm with you,

2:10:21I really do hate to play the,

2:10:24I think things would be X, Y, and Z different

2:10:26if Steve Jobs were still around,

2:10:29but I really do feel like the iPad is the one

2:10:31where it should, and I've seen a bunch of other people,

2:10:33either in reaction to my piece,

2:10:35or just on their own on this 10th anniversary,

2:10:38express the same thought.

2:10:41And it's really hard to deny, I think,

2:10:44if you really, and going back like you did,

2:10:46and looking at that, especially not the first iPad,

2:10:51but that iPad 2 demo with the GarageBand thing

2:10:56and a couple other things that,

2:10:58and with a year of their own use of iPad

2:11:03combined with seeing how the world had taken to it

2:11:06under their belt, there did seem to be

2:11:11a certain gleam in his eye that they were onto something,

2:11:14And then all that really happened in the intervening years

2:11:17is they've just made faster and faster CPUs.

2:11:20I mean, the hardware got undeniably better, right?

2:11:22It went to retina and got thinner and lighter.

2:11:24It's truly, you know, the iPhone and the iPad

2:11:28are the best hardware they make.

2:11:30And the Mac, it's almost unfair.

2:11:32The Mac is so limited by what Intel offers.

2:11:36The one thing that the Mac users are most jealous of

2:11:40the fact that we don't have Apple's own ARM CPUs inside.

2:11:45But in terms of conceptual using the iPad,

2:11:51it just hasn't gone very far.

2:11:54- Well, it's funny.

2:11:55So there's been two ways where Apple has sought

2:11:59to sort of push the iPad forward post jobs.

2:12:01Because sales kind of peaked around the iPad 2,

2:12:07iPad 3 era, and then they sort of started to go down

2:12:10and Apple's like, you know, what can we do to make this better?

2:12:13The first one was coming out with the iPad Pro and the Pencil and the keyboard.

2:12:19It's interesting because I think the Pencil was so clearly the right thing to do.

2:12:23It was definitely one of those X, Y arguments you'd have to have with Jobs where, you know,

2:12:27he would, I'm sure, have been against it and then you would have convinced him that

2:12:30it was the right thing to do.

2:12:31Like, that is a, it's again, what is powerful about the Pencil is it's something that you

2:12:36can't do on the Mac.

2:12:37Yes, you can have a Wacom tablet or something on those sorts of lines, but it's still

2:12:41indirect manipulation or if you even have the ones that show the screen on there, it's

2:12:45very clunky, it's not accessible to most people.

2:12:47The iPad makes a new sort of paradigm and approach accessible to new people in a way

2:12:52that doesn't really make sense on a phone either.

2:12:54It's something unique and special to iPad and, as I noted, remains my number one use

2:12:58case for an iPad is doing these drawings.

2:13:01I don't know if Jobs would have been opposed to it.

2:13:03I know everybody loves to, you know, go back to that, "If you see a stylus, they blew

2:13:07quote. But that was about the phone. And it was about requiring a stylus. It was about

2:13:12a device where you needed a stylus to use it like the Newton and the Palm Pilot. And

2:13:19there's a reason, that's not the only reason why they called it the Apple Pencil and not

2:13:24the Apple Stylus. You know, it wasn't just to avoid the word that's, you know, founder

2:13:28Steve Jobs had used and said they blew it. It's different because it's absolutely not

2:13:32required. It does something very different. You can use it. And I know in the early days

2:13:36that a pencil was actually up in the air,

2:13:38whether you could even use it as a replacement

2:13:41for your finger for tapping buttons and stuff,

2:13:44or was it only for drawing.

2:13:45And they worked that out.

2:13:48It's totally a plus.

2:13:50It just enables an entirely new level of stuff on your iPad.

2:13:55It's not something you need.

2:13:56So I don't know that Jobs would have been opposed to it.

2:13:58- What you said is super important, too.

2:13:59It's a plus in a way that enhances the experience

2:14:03without detracting from it.

2:14:04In a way, multitasking is a plus, but it imposes such a level of overhead and complexity that

2:14:11for someone like your mom, or me personally, it's a minus.

2:14:16Exactly, right?

2:14:17And so that's an addition that makes sense when it's purely additive, like the pencil

2:14:23is.

2:14:24But anyhow, so Apple pushes forward the hardware.

2:14:26And obviously the hardware today is an amazing state.

2:14:28Like the iPad Pro today is, I think, the most beautiful piece of hardware that Apple makes.

2:14:33It rivals the iPhone 4 for arguably the best piece of hardware Apple has ever made, as

2:14:38far as just sort of like being a jewel and just this incredible sort of thing.

2:14:43So that was number one.

2:14:44And then number two has been this recent push to add the iPadOS and add this multitasking

2:14:50and this complexity.

2:14:52And what's interesting about both of those efforts is those are both things that are

2:14:56under Apple's – what does Apple control on the iPad?

2:14:59They control the hardware and they control the OS.

2:15:01And where have they focused their efforts on making the iPad interesting to end users?

2:15:06It's by iterating on the hardware and iterating on the OS.

2:15:10And there's a big missing piece here, which is the apps themselves, the developers.

2:15:16And this is, to my mind, the fundamental failing of the iPad.

2:15:21At the end of the day, Steve Jobs is one person.

2:15:24You can't have, no matter how great he is, Steve Jobs is not going to conceptualize every

2:15:30possible use case that an iPad could be used for.

2:15:32This idea that an iPad can become anything, by definition, that's where you need the third-party

2:15:38developers to come up with completely new programs and applications for an iPad that

2:15:46transform it into something different that Apple would have never thought of, that C-Jaw

2:15:49is going to never have thought of.

2:15:51This is the whole power of markets, where people create something completely new to

2:15:56meet a need that no sort of central authority would have thought of on their own, but it's

2:16:01possible to come forward and to, why do they do it? Because they can, one, it's possible,

2:16:06and two, they can make money doing it. And that's the missing piece. You can't make money.

2:16:12The iPad is meant to be some sort of productivity where you can do stuff on it. That's what

2:16:18makes the large canvas approachable in a way the iPhone sort of isn't. But to do that,

2:16:23need to be able to sell and you need to be able to sell to people and the people that fall in love

2:16:27with your application it's really good oh can you add this feature can you add this feature

2:16:31well you can add the features and you can charge them again guess what that's how them like that's

2:16:36why that's what happened on the mac you had developers creating all sorts of applications

2:16:41creating entire industries which you mentioned your piece especially like the graphic design and

2:16:46layout and and all those sorts of things you had all these sort of small developers making all

2:16:51these little utilities on the Mac. And why did it work? Because you didn't have to go out and sell

2:16:57it one time for 99 cents and try to get a bunch of users. You could find your core users, your

2:17:02thousand true fans or whatever, you could charge them. Then you could work for a year, you come

2:17:07back, you could charge the same users again. And they were happy to pay you because they loved your

2:17:11application. It was very useful for them. You could do more. All that aspect is missing because

2:17:17of the app store's limitations. And the reason why I think the iPad never reaches potential,

2:17:23we never got these sort of transformative use cases that were not recreating the Mac,

2:17:31but were creating something entirely new and powerful, is because there was no money in it.

2:17:36To create something like GarageBand requires a huge amount of resources. It means making a big

2:17:43bet because to building software you have to spend all the time and money upfront creating

2:17:48that and you have to put it out there for sale and hope people come along and tell their

2:17:52friends and then will buy an upgrade.

2:17:55Why would you make that bet if you're in an App Store environment?

2:17:59There's no business model to justify it, which meant those applications never got made.

2:18:05This is Apple's tragic weakness.

2:18:09They want to control everything.

2:18:12And that control meant they tried to use that control to make the iPad better.

2:18:17What can we control?

2:18:18We can control the hardware.

2:18:19Great.

2:18:20We'll make the hardware much better.

2:18:21What can we control?

2:18:22We control the OS.

2:18:23Great.

2:18:24We'll take the OS and we'll add a bunch of stuff that maybe that's what people will

2:18:26like.

2:18:27What Apple actually needed to make the iPad successful was to loosen control, was to give

2:18:33give more freedom, more possibilities,

2:18:35so that developers could make these

2:18:38transformative experiences that took the potential

2:18:41of a device that could change into anything

2:18:44you wanted it to be and to fully realize that.

2:18:48- You mentioned, I forget what year you took the numbers

2:18:51from, but there was a point, and it's firsthand,

2:18:54but to me it's the one where the Mac was clearly

2:18:57the strongest, was the desktop publishing industry,

2:18:59and there were other areas where the Mac did

2:19:01and has continued to thrive, education in some ways,

2:19:06but desktop publishing for me is near and dear to my heart,

2:19:09and it truly transformed the industry

2:19:11as a 10-year-old product.

2:19:12And again, it's exactly how old the iPad is.

2:19:16The graphic design industry,

2:19:18whether you're like an illustrator

2:19:19or doing page layout in Quark or PageMaker at the time,

2:19:24or whatever, you know,

2:19:26all the various things you could do in Photoshop,

2:19:28Nobody who was a professional illustrator or photographer

2:19:33or layout artist was using computers in 1984.

2:19:38I mean, I shouldn't say nobody, but it was obscure

2:19:41and you were using these text-based things

2:19:43and nobody really, computers just weren't part of it.

2:19:48And by 1994, nobody was not using a computer.

2:19:51In 10 years, everything was computerized,

2:19:56all page layout, every newspaper, every magazine,

2:19:59every advertisement, everything that was going to print

2:20:02went through computer software.

2:20:05And it was either on the Mac or it was Windows versions

2:20:08of apps on the Mac, but probably it was through the Mac.

2:20:11I remember when I was doing print stuff in the '90s,

2:20:15you used to have to pay more

2:20:17if it was Windows formatted stuff sometimes

2:20:20than if it was Mac because the print shops

2:20:22anticipated so many problems with like

2:20:25color separation and stuff like that.

2:20:27They literally charged more

2:20:28'cause it was so fundamentally Mac-based.

2:20:32What are the industries like that

2:20:33that have been transformed by the iPad?

2:20:35And there are some, I mean, it's like somebody pointed out

2:20:38that iPads are huge with pilots.

2:20:41I get it.

2:20:42I mean, so saying that there's none is an overstatement.

2:20:46There are apps like Procreate

2:20:48that are really, really great on the iPad.

2:20:53I think the pencil drives a lot of that with Procreate,

2:20:56and it's great in a way that you just couldn't really

2:20:59do what Procreate does on the Mac.

2:21:01It really needs that direct manipulation.

2:21:04But there's just nowhere near as much of it

2:21:08as there could be.

2:21:10- Well, just look at the companies.

2:21:11In 1984, Adobe did not exist.

2:21:18In 1994, it did, and it was worth a billion dollars.

2:21:21And Apple was only worth $2 billion at the time.

2:21:24Exactly.

2:21:25And if you go back through the entire history, I think that's a reason why Apple has been

2:21:32so unfriendly, relatively speaking, to developers.

2:21:36They don't want another Adobe because Adobe famously would not support OS X.

2:21:44And I think Apple never wanted a position where they were dependent on Microsoft and

2:21:48Adobe.

2:21:49So what happened, though, in the long run is Microsoft and Adobe are the only companies

2:21:53making these super complex applications for the iPad because they have larger business

2:21:59models that justify it.

2:22:01And no, but that's the whole point.

2:22:03The graphic design revolution, which you cannot overstate, that graphic design and desktop

2:22:10publishing, that's what kept the Mac alive.

2:22:13The only reason Apple is around and the only reason we have iPhones and iPads and all this

2:22:17talk about is because when Apple was at its lowest point, people who were in desktop publishing

2:22:23were still buying Macs.

2:22:25That's how dominant it was.

2:22:27That was not, they were not buying it because of MacPaint.

2:22:30MacPaint was a demonstration of what was possible, and then you had companies like Aldus come

2:22:35along with PageMaker or Quark, QuarkXPress.

2:22:38You and I both cut our teeth on QuarkXPress, and Adobe with first Illustrator and then

2:22:43Photoshop and then the Acrobat PDF and then they came along with

2:22:46Do to compete was what's their Quark Express competitor in design? Um, yeah in design and

2:22:52Basically built their company on the Mac and third-party developers are what made the Mac

2:22:59Transformative and powerful and why because it was it was open you could go on there and you could charge what you wanted to charge

2:23:05You could charge it when you want to charge you charge for upgrades Apple to have any control over that and that made it entirely possible

2:23:12And again, everything's a trade-off.

2:23:14This is a tie-in to our encryption talk before.

2:23:16There are huge benefits to the App Store, to security, to customers feeling safe with

2:23:21their, being willing to buy applications.

2:23:23This isn't to deny any of that.

2:23:25But there has been a tremendous loss in business model flexibility that, in my estimation,

2:23:32is the biggest reason why the iPad has not reached its potential.

2:23:36It's not to say the iPad is not valuable as it is.

2:23:38It is.

2:23:39It is so much closer to what it launched as V1.

2:23:44We're so much closer to the iPad 1 keynote,

2:23:47and it feels like we're farther away than ever

2:23:49from the iPad 2 keynote.

2:23:50And that's what makes me sad.

2:23:52That's why I call it tragic.

2:23:54It's not that it's a failure.

2:23:57It's that there was the possibility

2:23:59of something completely new,

2:24:01and I just feel we never really reached that potential.

2:24:04- Yeah, I feel the same way.

2:24:05We took very different, and I have more to say,

2:24:09but more to write, and hopefully I'll get around to it soon,

2:24:12but in the weeks to come.

2:24:14And I focused on specific details, user interface gripes,

2:24:17and your complaint is much more big picture,

2:24:20but fundamentally it's two different angles

2:24:25on the same thing, which is that it didn't live up,

2:24:27it hasn't yet lived up to its potential.

2:24:30And it could still, but would require leadership at Apple

2:24:39to acknowledge that it hasn't lived up to its potential.

2:24:43And I seriously question whether that's there.

2:24:46I really do feel that there's,

2:24:50I can't help but think that,

2:24:52and to me, iPad OS 13 is the evidence of it,

2:24:56that this is the one they decided to give the new name to

2:24:58and say it's its own S and its own OS,

2:25:01you know, it has its own name,

2:25:03and didn't really backtrack from any of this

2:25:06and hasn't really, you know,

2:25:08And the other thing we can mention on this,

2:25:10and I feel like it's held the iPad back more than the phone,

2:25:14is the 30%/15% tax, whatever you want,

2:25:19well not tax, it's not a tax,

2:25:23but the revenue that Apple wants to insist it gets

2:25:26through App Store purchases for anything

2:25:30and everything that goes through an app.

2:25:33And I can't help but think that that's hurt,

2:25:35And it gets to your issue of insisting on control as opposed to just letting third-party

2:25:40developers have more freedom on the platform.

2:25:45Well, that's absolutely part of it, but also there's an aspect of the more specialized

2:25:51and niche an app by definition, the smaller your audience.

2:25:54And the way the App Store has worked is it's always, if you want to make money, you need

2:25:58to sort of have access to the largest audience possible.

2:26:03And you know, whereas if you want to make, if you have a niche app, you want to make

2:26:07more money from fewer people, right?

2:26:09Like this is my business model, right?

2:26:10I'm not trying to sell trajectory to a million people.

2:26:14What I want to do is sell it to a much smaller number of people, but they pay me money continuously,

2:26:19so I get a lot of money out of them, right?

2:26:20My average revenue per customer is very high.

2:26:24That's very hard to do with an application because the way it worked on the Mac previously

2:26:29was you would sell an application for, say, $50.

2:26:32Then a year later, you have an update to the application,

2:26:36and you can maybe sell, well, you have upgrade pricing.

2:26:38So if you're an existing user, you can buy it for $35,

2:26:41or a new user buy it for $50.

2:26:42And what this lets you do is you're getting like $50 or $30,

2:26:46whatever it might be, per customer, per year,

2:26:48year over year over year,

2:26:49that justifies this ongoing sort of investment.

2:26:52Now, things are a little better now

2:26:54'cause you can do subscription pricing,

2:26:55But the problem is that is so sort of consumer hostile in a way, like you have to pay or

2:27:01you're going to lose access to your application.

2:27:05We see this again and again where apps, developers switch to this model because it's the only

2:27:10way they can survive.

2:27:13You can't make money always selling to new users.

2:27:16It's impossible.

2:27:17You have to be able to make money from your existing users on an ongoing basis.

2:27:21The only way Apple has to do that is through subscription pricing, which is an awkward

2:27:25fit for productivity apps anyway, and then there's this gut-wrenching transition where

2:27:30everyone accuses you of being a bad person because you're now charging a subscription

2:27:37instead of just selling that and letting them own it, etc., etc.

2:27:40The problem that you can't do otherwise is Apple never gave them the tools to do it otherwise.

2:27:46And it's a shame.

2:27:47Who in their right mind is going to start a company today that is focused on building

2:27:51complex, new-to-the-world, transformative iPad applications.

2:27:56Like there's no one that's going to do it.

2:27:58The only one that's going to do it is Apple, and Apple doesn't have anyone that seems to

2:28:02have the vision to do it.

2:28:03In any way, to have one company making everything is not a viable outcome anyways.

2:28:08They should be making a platform.

2:28:10I mean, the tragedy, this is the tragedy that I wrote about this back when the iPad Pencil

2:28:16came out.

2:28:17The real tragedy of the iPad is it would be such a better product if Microsoft owned it,

2:28:24because Microsoft understands how to build a third-party platform and to make it possible.

2:28:30The problem is that you earn the right to be a platform by building a great product.

2:28:36And Microsoft's not building a great product.

2:28:38Microsoft got the Windows platform by leveraging IBM, basically, to get computers everywhere,

2:28:44then they already had the platform, then they could be a good platform provider, right?

2:28:48The way it works in the consumer market is you have to sell something that's compelling

2:28:51by itself, where users want it and buy it, and then once you have the install base, now

2:28:56you're a platform, and that's not what Microsoft is good at.

2:29:00They're not good at building super friendly user consumer products that people just want

2:29:05to buy in their own right.

2:29:07And so you have this weird situation where in an ideal world, we could have Apple create

2:29:12these new concepts, these new ideas, these new products like an iPad, and then they could

2:29:16hand it off to Microsoft to manage, and then we could have a flowering developer ecosystem

2:29:22on top of it that help it reach its full potential.

2:29:24But unfortunately, the world doesn't work that way.

2:29:26Hey, what app do you use?

2:29:27I wanted to ask you this.

2:29:28What app do you use for making your drawings for Stretichary on the iPad?

2:29:33So the app I used for many years was Paper by kind of called 53.

2:29:38Paper has since, they're acquired, I think they're still around, but they basically

2:29:42failed.

2:29:43They only ever made money by selling a stylus and then the Apple Pencil came out, which

2:29:46made their application way better and also destroyed their ability to make money.

2:29:51Again, I would have paid for upgrades continually to that application, but they charged me once

2:29:58like $10 and I used it for years and made a ton of money using the application and they

2:30:03got none of that.

2:30:05So I increasingly use Linnea now from the folks at Icon Factory.

2:30:10So I still use Paper for a couple things.

2:30:13There's a few things, a few effects it has that I like, but more and more I use Linnea.

2:30:22It's really cool.

2:30:23It's got some more power as far as layering goes and stuff like that, whereas Paper is

2:30:28more of a pure drawing app.

2:30:31But yeah, those are the two applications that I use.

2:30:33Yeah, I love Linnea.

2:30:34I call it linea, I don't know how to pronounce it.

2:30:36I should ask our friend Hockenberry.

2:30:40I'm gonna guess that I'm wrong.

2:30:42You can make a ton of money betting

2:30:45that on any pronunciation thing, my guess is wrong.

2:30:48Linnea.

2:30:49Linnea sounds prettier and they do graphic, you know.

2:30:52So I'm gonna guess it actually is linea.

2:30:54But in my head--

2:30:55- Or to find out it's like linea.

2:30:57- I've said linea.

2:30:59That's my go-to drawing app.

2:31:01I don't do a lot of drawings,

2:31:02but when I do, that's what I use, I love it.

2:31:05And one of the things I love about it,

2:31:08and it's just from one small indie developer,

2:31:10it's like a $10 app,

2:31:11I think they're moving to a subscription prompt,

2:31:13but it has things like layers,

2:31:16it has, you know, which are concepts that are common

2:31:18in every Mac drawing, photo editing app,

2:31:21but Linea doesn't look like a Mac app at all.

2:31:26It is so iPad, and it also doesn't look,

2:31:29I know, and I know they have like a little iPhone version,

2:31:31where you can finger paint.

2:31:33But the iPad version is like the one true version,

2:31:37and it is iPad-y in a way.

2:31:40- Your iPad becomes an easel.

2:31:47The best iPad apps change the nature

2:31:52of what this device in your hand is.

2:31:54My iPad with an NBA game on it is a TV.

2:31:58My iPad with Lea on it is an easel.

2:32:01My iPad with GarageBand on it is a piano, to your point.

2:32:04And that is the magic of the iPad.

2:32:10And there's no magic in multitasking, sorry.

2:32:18This whole concept of putting the iPad against a Mac or against a PC, it's like you're

2:32:24putting in a situation where it's going to lose.

2:32:26Like, yes, some people will power through.

2:32:30You have to be more of a power user to use an iPad for multitasking than you do a PC,

2:32:36which doesn't make any sense.

2:32:38It just conceptually doesn't make any sense.

2:32:41And the wrong tradeoffs were made.

2:32:44The tradeoff should be that an iPad is impossibly easy to use.

2:32:49When your mom's doing mail, she's in her mail app.

2:32:51When she's browsing the web, she's on the web.

2:32:53transforms, there's no of this mixing of metaphors and mixing of ideas together. It is what it is.

2:33:00And if you feel frustrated by that and limited by that, then you should go get a Mac. Like,

2:33:06this idea that we should lose the simplicity to have an inferior version of the Mac is just

2:33:13wrong to me. I think you made this point in your article, like less powerful and more complex or

2:33:17something along those lines. That's the sure sign that the wrong trade-offs were made.

2:33:22- Well, and if it were going to be, you know,

2:33:25maybe it should be off by default.

2:33:27You know, like your point that the multi,

2:33:29you know, that you wanna argue

2:33:30that the split screen multitasking

2:33:31was all a mistake or whatever.

2:33:33And for the people who really do love it,

2:33:36maybe it should be there as an option,

2:33:38but maybe it should be off by default.

2:33:40But I firmly stand by what you just said,

2:33:44that it is a power user feature.

2:33:47Whereas on the Mac,

2:33:48because that's what the Mac was designed for ground up,

2:33:52people, common people don't even think about the fact

2:33:55that you can see two or three apps at a time on your Mac.

2:33:58It doesn't even seem like a thing that you've done

2:34:00or did anything for.

2:34:02- Right, and I'm not saying everyone should get a Mac.

2:34:06That's the thing.

2:34:07I actually think the iPad should be the computer

2:34:09for the rest of us, right?

2:34:11As it were.

2:34:12You can do everything you want to do on an iPad

2:34:16as on a Mac.

2:34:18If you want to have multiple windows,

2:34:21like you don't need two windows to do something.

2:34:25You could switch back and forth.

2:34:26The reason you have two windows

2:34:27is 'cause it's more convenient and easier to do, right?

2:34:31But that's fine.

2:34:33It's okay to have something more complex

2:34:36for more powerful and more complex things.

2:34:38- So one of the things I wanna bring up,

2:34:40and hopefully I'd be able, I haven't looked,

2:34:44'cause I only thought of it

2:34:44while you and I are talking right here,

2:34:46but hopefully I can maybe get some videos of it.

2:34:48I don't know how I'll find them,

2:34:50but at least some screenshots.

2:34:51But do you remember Tweety for iPad

2:34:53when Lauren Brikter was doing Tweety

2:34:55before it was acquired by Twitter

2:34:58and became the official Twitter for iOS app?

2:35:02Tweety, do you remember Tweety for iPad?

2:35:06It was wholly original and separate from Tweety for iPhone

2:35:14and had what I consider for a productivity type app

2:35:19where it's like you're, you know,

2:35:22as much as Twitter can count as productivity,

2:35:24but you're reading and it's text

2:35:26and there's a list of things

2:35:27and you tap from a list to go into the, you know.

2:35:30It had a design that was so different

2:35:35and it never would have worked on the Mac.

2:35:40Whereas if you look at mail for iPad from Apple,

2:35:45it is fundamentally architected visually

2:35:50like mail on the Mac.

2:35:53It's just that you tap things instead of click on them

2:35:56and some things slide over as opposed

2:35:59to all staying on screen

2:36:01because it's a slightly smaller screen.

2:36:02But Tweety for iPad was so different

2:36:05and was so holy for the iPad.

2:36:09But also, in addition to not just aping the way a Mac Twitter client would, could, and

2:36:15should be designed, it also wasn't just the iPhone version, "Okay, but now it's on a 10-inch

2:36:22screen."

2:36:24And more, more...

2:36:26The iPad to me is so large at the application level, so caught between those two things,

2:36:34being just a big iPhone, but then when it's not, it's just a touchscreen Mac type thing,

2:36:40as opposed to being something wholly unique to it, right? Like, that's the potential that, to me,

2:36:47hasn't been tapped. Our use cases where it could only be on an iPad. Couldn't be done on the phone

2:36:54because the phone is too small, couldn't be done on the Mac because the Mac interface is touch

2:37:00a side just isn't conducive to this sort of direct manipulation of holding a tablet in

2:37:05your hand.

2:37:06I completely agree.

2:37:08And Tweety is the one that's a heartbreak.

2:37:10And then you look at like the stupid Twitter app for iPad now and it…

2:37:15It's a big iPhone app.

2:37:16It could not be more just a big iPhone app.

2:37:21It is the canonical just take what we did for the iPhone and blow it up to the size

2:37:27of whatever the size of your iPad is.

2:37:30- But again, in Twitter's defense,

2:37:31why would you do anything different?

2:37:33It's not worth the effort.

2:37:35- Pride, pride in your work.

2:37:40- This is why--

2:37:45- The fact that Twitter as a company

2:37:48has like a thousand engineers.

2:37:50- Yeah, it's amazing.

2:37:51They have 4,000 employees.

2:37:53- I hear you, I'm not telling you that you're wrong.

2:37:55get the argument of why would we do that, but, you know.

2:37:58Fair points, fair points. But just to go back to the thing we started with, the iPad discussion

2:38:04about sort of the critics and people complaining about these articles, I feel like, and again,

2:38:12I am even more so than you, I am a massive critic of what the iPad has become. I think

2:38:18the whole multitasking approach is a mistake. I think that the one app on the screen at

2:38:23time is the right way to go and I get a lot of people disagree with that but what I what I hope

2:38:29is clear is in some respects this is like the jilted lover sort of view of it like I

2:38:37I am so disappointed in the iPad as it is because I wanted and thought there could have been

2:38:45something transformative not the Mac done differently but actually something that was was

2:38:52unlocked possibilities and ways of computing that were never possible previously.

2:38:57And there's shadows of that. There's bits and pieces of that. And interestingly,

2:39:02one of the areas of the music industry where there has actually been a lot of innovation,

2:39:09and there's a whole way to communicate between apps that was developed for music apps that was

2:39:14skirted around Apple's limitations between connecting data and stuff back in the day,

2:39:19And perhaps seeded because of what Apple did,

2:39:21but I just feel like we never ever got to what it could be,

2:39:26and I see no, I just don't see it happening,

2:39:29because, again, when the iPad first came out,

2:39:33everyone wanted to build for it,

2:39:34they wanted to develop for it.

2:39:36But now who's gonna be, who's gonna take that risk?

2:39:39- And it's not our fault, you and me,

2:39:41Ben Thompson and John Gruber,

2:39:43it's not our fault that we can't come up with specific

2:39:48ideas for what the iPad could be in 2020,

2:39:53that's not our job.

2:39:55We're simply observing that they're not there, right?

2:39:58Like in 1984, it wasn't clear at all

2:40:03what Photoshop could be in 1994

2:40:07or QuarkXPress, which is truly phenomenal,

2:40:11or the way that, like you said,

2:40:16the desktop publishing industry largely kept Apple afloat because they still bought high-end Mac

2:40:23hardware throughout the whole thing because they had these workflows where catalogs were entirely

2:40:32set up in FileMaker databases for the catalog items and when you were ready to print a new

2:40:3964-page catalog you just hit one button, walked away for a minute or two, and then there was a

2:40:45QuarkXPress document with 64 pages completely laid out with the photos and the items and

2:40:50everything and ready to be proofread.

2:40:51Yeah, AppleScript as an underrated factor in Apple not going out of business.

2:40:56Yeah, combined with FileMaker and a database that was completely visual as opposed to abstract

2:41:05SQL tables, which have their place. But the fact that totally normal people could just

2:41:11like open the database and look at it, you know, and drag pictures in and stuff like

2:41:17that.

2:41:19And that you'd have these workflows where what used to be days of work was now like

2:41:23a minute of letting an Apple script do its thing, communicating between file makers.

2:41:28You couldn't imagine it in 1984, but the foundation was there.

2:41:33You can go backwards from 1984, or from 1994,

2:41:37and see how the fundamental ideas

2:41:41that the Mac was born with in 1984 led to this.

2:41:45You could go backwards and see it.

2:41:47And you could see that potential with the iPad 10 years ago,

2:41:50and it just didn't, it just hasn't gotten there.

2:41:55And I think it could, I think it could,

2:41:57five years from now we could have you on the show,

2:42:00and maybe there's a renaissance in the iPad.

2:42:04- I don't think so.

2:42:06- But I don't think so either.

2:42:08- To me, the missing piece was the business model piece.

2:42:12And the problem is even if Apple suddenly came out

2:42:15with upgrade pricing and all those sorts of things,

2:42:20like the trials, like the trials you do today,

2:42:23they have to either be, unlock an in-app purchase

2:42:27or else this subscription thing.

2:42:29There's no like, you can't just have a full featured app

2:42:31with like a seven week trial, with a seven day trial,

2:42:33like that one click, like which, you know,

2:42:37we had a Windows 8 like 10 years ago.

2:42:39The, even if that all came tomorrow,

2:42:42I think that developers are so burned by the iPad

2:42:47and people will bring up applications that are on the iPad

2:42:50that are complex and whatever.

2:42:52And I think it would be very interesting

2:42:55to think about those complex applications

2:42:57and see if they ever actually made any money

2:43:01or if they're just massive losses.

2:43:04Let's just put it this way,

2:43:06I don't think that any developer

2:43:08that has experimented with the iPad previously

2:43:10is gonna ever go back to the iPad,

2:43:11and that's a business model problem, not a device problem.

2:43:14And yeah, it's a shame, it's too bad.

2:43:18- Yeah, you know, another way to put it

2:43:20is you just don't see that many iPad-only apps,

2:43:23apps that could only be on the iPad,

2:43:25don't make sense on the phone

2:43:26'cause the screen's not big enough,

2:43:28don't make sense on the Mac 'cause the interface

2:43:31isn't appropriate in the way that, you know,

2:43:34back in the day, there'd be Mac apps

2:43:36that never would make sense on the Apple II

2:43:38because it doesn't make sense

2:43:40without everything that the Mac had.

2:43:41The iPad offers so much that the Mac doesn't

2:43:44by its innate nature that there could be apps like that

2:43:48and you just don't see that many of them.

2:43:50All right, anyway.

2:43:53(laughs)

2:43:55Let's end on an upbeat note like that.

2:43:59Ben, it's always a pleasure to have you on the show.

2:44:02How about this, how about a Super Bowl pick?

2:44:04- I am cheering for Kansas City

2:44:08because I want Andy Reid to win one

2:44:11and I hate the 49ers.

2:44:12But I have not watched football closely enough

2:44:18to know who to pick.

2:44:20- All right, I'm going to go the same way.

2:44:21I'm gonna go with the Kansas City

2:44:23because I want Andy Reid to win one,

2:44:26because I find Patrick Mahomes

2:44:27to be an absolutely appealing person.

2:44:30I have no skin in the game,

2:44:32with or with, you know, four against Kansas City,

2:44:35but I do like Andy Reid.

2:44:37I would like to see him win one.

2:44:38I do like Patrick Mahomes,

2:44:40and I do hate the San Francisco 49ers.

2:44:43(laughing)

2:44:45- How do you get a Cowboys fan and a Packers fan united?

2:44:48- Yeah, yeah.

2:44:49- Ask them about the 49ers.

2:44:50- That's what we should do.

2:44:50We should open up,

2:44:51we should have like a bunch of pop-up bars around.

2:44:53You and I should quick get this together. Raise a couple, raise $100,000 and open up

2:44:58a bunch of Packers/Cowboys pop-up bars around the nation for Super Bowl Sunday. One week

2:45:06leases.

2:45:08It's funny because I think maybe this is our age too, particularly because in the 90s,

2:45:14like these three teams had so many sort of playoff...

2:45:19Epic games and big matches.

2:45:22right where like if the Cowboys were in the Super Bowl I'd be sitting here with a 49ers fan saying

2:45:27"Hey, as long as it's not the Cowboys, we're now on the same team." And you probably feel the same

2:45:32way if it was the Packers. So it's like a triangle of hate. Yeah, that's my pick as well. All right,

2:45:42everybody of course, you've been on the show enough they know it, but Stratechary.

2:45:47S-T-R-A-C-H-E-R-Y.

2:45:50- Oh, you spelled it wrong.

2:45:51Which is funny because I spelled it wrong

2:45:53for someone else on your thing.

2:45:55- S-T-A-T-E-C-H-E-R-Y.

2:45:58- Strategy and tech.

2:45:59- When people hear strategy and tech,

2:46:01then they're like, oh, now the name makes total sense.

2:46:03I'm like, yeah, well, tell me about it.

2:46:06- There's a good column this week on the iPad

2:46:11that we talked about here, but people should read it.

2:46:14And of course, as you mentioned,

2:46:16a subscription newsletter, which everybody

2:46:19who listens to this show ought to at least consider.

2:46:21It's one of my favorite reads.

2:46:23And you have two great Twitter accounts.

2:46:27You've got @BenThompson, where you write

2:46:29about stuff like this, and then there's NoTechBen,

2:46:32where it's all Milwaukee Bucks all the time

2:46:34this time of year.

2:46:35- Basically.

2:46:38Probably gets me in trouble, but whatever.

2:46:39- Yeah, yeah, I have a really bad feeling.

2:46:42I mean, I'm not into the NBA like you,

2:46:44but I have a really bad feeling that we're heading towards

2:46:46a Sixers-Bucks Eastern Finals that's going to end in five games.

2:46:52[laughs]

2:46:54With the Bucks heading towards the Finals.

2:46:57That'd be fine with me.

2:46:59I...well...

2:47:02Well, it's funny. The 76ers are terrible against everyone,

2:47:05in part because they're basically expressly built to beat the Bucks.

2:47:09Which is very concerning to me,

2:47:12that they're going to end up in the playoffs like the fifth or sixth seed or something,

2:47:15And we're gonna have to play them anyway, and it's gonna be brutal obviously they destroyed the Bucks on Christmas

2:47:20I think it's probably a game that

2:47:22Had had concerning signs to say the least but also the shooting was such that you know is a bit of an aberration

2:47:29But yeah, yeah, it's it's it's gonna be it would be a war for sure

2:47:33Yeah, but anyway, they can find you there, and I want to thank our sponsors this week feels

2:47:38get your

2:47:41CBD

2:47:42Really interesting new sponsor glad to have them

2:47:44Linode, where you can host your own server in the Linode cloud, great, great company.

2:47:51And Casper, makers of fine mattresses and other sleep products.

2:47:55Thanks.

2:47:56Thanks, Ben.

2:47:57Talk to you soon.