0:00:00Oh man, Glenn Fleischmann, you're back on the show. We have so much to talk about.
0:00:04We'll never get to all of it, but we can try.
0:00:08[laughter]
0:00:10It's a good problem to have.
0:00:12Thanks for having me back.
0:00:14It's a quiet week.
0:00:16What do you want to start with? I say we start with the...
0:00:18Jeopardy! Jeopardy!
0:00:20So, number one, I knew this.
0:00:22I don't know that we've ever really spoken about it at length, and if we have, I've forgotten about it.
0:00:27But you were on Jeopardy!
0:00:29When? When were you on?
0:00:322000... I taped in August 2012. My episodes went up
0:00:35October 2012 and I won! I won two episodes by the skin of my teeth. That's how I describe it.
0:00:42I still had my... now I'm too old. It's a young man's game, young person's game.
0:00:46But I won two episodes and over $30,000
0:00:50Which is kind of neat because my whole life people had said you should go on Jeopardy!
0:00:54You seem to remember a lot of trivia and things that aren't important
0:00:57Yes, I do
0:00:59And it's well you got it both. It's
0:01:01At least two skills. It's more. You know, it's like in it like any kind of athletic competition. It's
0:01:07Multivariate you need you obviously need to know the trivia, but you've also got to be fast. I
0:01:13Don't I don't have the eye
0:01:15There's no way even if I got like an exception and and got to buzz in ten seconds late
0:01:21I wouldn't get shut out on Jeopardy. I would I would get a couple in
0:01:26But I'm too slow and I've always been too slow my mind
0:01:29It's you saw that thing
0:01:31There's an article a few months ago about how they've finally done the metabolic testing on Grandmaster chess players
0:01:37Mmm, and yeah those folks they burn like thousands of calories today. Yeah, we said it people in the chess world said
0:01:43You know this may seem not that demanding but in fact we are we you know
0:01:48we can lose 15 pounds over a tournament.
0:01:50Everyone's like, yeah, yeah, you little nerds or whatever.
0:01:52So anyway, they finally started doing
0:01:54some of the real lab testing.
0:01:56And these guys are burning like they're doing
0:01:58the Tour de France practically.
0:02:00And so they now, the best chess grandmasters,
0:02:03now have a nutritionist.
0:02:04They have a plan for like, you know,
0:02:06carbo-loading or protein-loading.
0:02:08They work out like athletes between all the chess practice
0:02:12they do with their coaches and themselves.
0:02:14And it makes a huge, I mean, it's like,
0:02:16you need the physical edge to play that game. And I think that's like wonderful and hilarious that
0:02:22it took this long for anyone to actually believe them.
0:02:25I totally saw that and the basic explanation. I did see that story. I'll put it in the show notes. I
0:02:30swear to God, I just wrote it down. But it's it the basic idea is that the human brain is
0:02:37comparisons between the human brain and our computers today and the idea of you know, how do we
0:02:45get AI to work like a human brain, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, it's, you know, it's a decades
0:02:49old thing and part of science fiction. But at some fundamental level, the brain is like
0:02:55a computer. And the harder it works, the more energy it consumes, it totally consumes calories
0:03:03to do to to intensely concentrate on something such as, for example, grandmaster level chess,
0:03:10Which it, you know, I think everybody, I don't see how anybody could dispute that a game
0:03:16like chess or go or something like that.
0:03:19It takes intense competition, intense concentration.
0:03:23And it consumes large amounts of way more serious amounts of calories, like you said,
0:03:30like over the course of like a week long or 10 day match it they could lose 15 pounds.
0:03:35Yeah, they need they need guys with panniers coming up and like handing them energy bars.
0:03:40- Yeah.
0:03:41- And can't, I mean, but it is really,
0:03:42I think it was like five,
0:03:43I wanna say it was five or 6,000 calories a day,
0:03:46you know, a normal human adult person
0:03:49is somewhere in the two to 3,000 calories,
0:03:51what you consume with, you know, normal activity.
0:03:53So it is getting into this like a high athletic thing.
0:03:57So I think about that with "Jeopardy!"
0:03:59like "Jeopardy!" is a very funny game, right?
0:04:00Because at its face value, when you play it at home,
0:04:04it looks like a trivia game with some timing.
0:04:07And then when you play it in reality,
0:04:09And I kind of prepped for it when I went in.
0:04:12I'd read a bunch of books by people.
0:04:14I always cite Bob Harris is the prisoner of Trebekistan
0:04:18is a wonderful book because it's half memoir.
0:04:21And Bob is a very interesting and lovely fellow.
0:04:23And he's done a lot of interesting things in his life,
0:04:25including writing for TV and being involved
0:04:28in microloans and whatever.
0:04:29But this book is like, it looks like it's a story
0:04:31about winning on Jeopardy and a strategy guide.
0:04:33And then it becomes sort of memoir.
0:04:35And so anyway, from that book, I only,
0:04:37I say a big chunk of why I won two games as strategies that he described in the book
0:04:42that I wouldn't have known otherwise.
0:04:44And it's he understood how to bet.
0:04:46And that was I remember Arthur Chu who had a good run, I think 15 day run a few years ago.
0:04:51Arthur Chu drove people nuts because he jumped all over the board, which has now become
0:04:56more of a standard playing style and had been a style occasionally before him.
0:05:00But he really understood how to bet.
0:05:02And James Holzhauer was a demon in embedding,
0:05:06and I had no idea.
0:05:08So I went in there from that book having a,
0:05:10so you need to know how to wager,
0:05:12you need to have fast reflexes to buzz in on time,
0:05:15you need to be able to have that fast memory recall.
0:05:17So you see it, you know you know it,
0:05:19you buzz it in and you can produce
0:05:20the sounds from your mouth.
0:05:22And do it in this incredibly, you know,
0:05:24in front of an audience, an audience is a live studio audience.
0:05:27And it's like, anyway, here's the funny thing.
0:05:31I describe the experience as being like the, you know,
0:05:35the Willy Wonka movie, the original one with Mike TV.
0:05:38And he gets onto the TV set and he like stands in the TV
0:05:42and he's beamed into the TV and he's tiny.
0:05:45When you walk out of the "Jeopardy" set, it is exactly,
0:05:48I mean, not like I thought there was CG or something,
0:05:50but it is exactly like you see.
0:05:52So it is weirdly like walking into a TV set.
0:05:56Well, here's the funny part.
0:05:57Last year, Paris Lemon, the guy who played Mike TV
0:06:00in the movie was on Jeopardy.
0:06:02- Really? I didn't know that.
0:06:04- He didn't win.
0:06:05Alex did not ask him about the movie,
0:06:08but everyone's like, wait a minute,
0:06:10that's Mike TV up there.
0:06:12And his wife had actually played previously on Jeopardy
0:06:15and I believe won a little bit.
0:06:16- One of the things that I've always enjoyed
0:06:21and these two shows have been on, man,
0:06:24as almost as long as I can remember,
0:06:27Jeopardy and Wheel of Fortune and they're paired. I think they're paired in syndication markets. Yeah
0:06:33I don't know if there's any I've never been aware of a market where they're not
0:06:36Where I live here in the Philadelphia market, they've always been on jeopardy at seven Wheel of Fortune 730
0:06:45We're backwards. Oh, are you really? Yeah, we get wheel first in jeopardy. Isn't that weird? Oh
0:06:52Well, I've always thought that that order made sense because Jeff yet you watch Jeopardy first and then you feel dumb and then you watch Wheel
0:06:59of Fortune and you feel really smart you're like
0:07:02Because you can shout all that, you know, you it's easy to shout out the answer
0:07:09You know before the contestants can because they you know, they don't have to buzz in there's no reflexes
0:07:15They can just they just say I would like to solve the puzzle
0:07:19Right, and then they give the gas so it you know as soon as it's pretty obvious and you can you know
0:07:24You're good at that sort of
0:07:26Puzzle solving you know, it's a lot easier to feel smart watching Wheel of Fortune than watching jeopardy
0:07:32So I always felt I always felt that the jeopardy then Wheel of Fortune order
0:07:35Is the right order? Yeah, and you got to kind of calm down as opposed to key yourself up
0:07:41So the other thing so some of the things I've read about and I've watched for years
0:07:46Never was tempted to go on like I said, I know I mean, you know
0:07:48Like I was on the quiz Bowl team or whatever they called it in high school and did okay at that level
0:07:53But you know jeopardy is obviously, you know, it's like saying you played high school basketball versus you know
0:07:58You played the pros or played even even in college, you know
0:08:02You know, there's a definite difference between being a recreational high school quiz Bowl player and and you know the a-league
0:08:11But the one thing I didn't know and - and I still I'm not clear about it is when you're allowed to buzz in. Oh
0:08:17Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so it's uh, and this is the funny thing. So I read this story recently
0:08:24I think it was while the this greatest of all time tournament was going on. Someone wrote a clever story
0:08:28I think it was a might have been a jeopardy for a contestant that
0:08:32Jeopardy is the quietest show of any game show you can think of I'd never thought of it
0:08:37I've watched the show my whole life
0:08:38I was on the show and I never thought of it and they said really the the buzzing device
0:08:43It's that we caught the know jeopardy calls it a signaling device. It doesn't buzz
0:08:46There's no sound when you click in there's a little plate sound if your time runs out for a question
0:08:53Right and the Daily Double thing does that?
0:08:55You know kind of like special TV thing, but otherwise, it's really a pretty in the in the jeopardy music
0:09:00I was like, wow, that's wild. So so you don't have a lot of there. There's very little oral cues or timing
0:09:06So when you're standing behind the podium, you're looking at the game board and when they show the game board at home
0:09:11they frame it so you can't see that on the left and right are a set of lights and
0:09:16Alex reads the clue and
0:09:20The moment he stops he reaches the end of the clue
0:09:23There's one of the producers of the show is sitting at the stage watching and listening to him and hits an unlock button
0:09:29When that producer hits the unlock button and it is the same person typically over a season
0:09:35I think I made me one person for many years now.
0:09:38The lights on both sides of the board go out
0:09:41so that you know you can, or they light up.
0:09:43Isn't that funny?
0:09:44I think they go, I can't remember if they light up,
0:09:46but I think they light up, sorry.
0:09:47They light up to indicate that you can ring in.
0:09:49And at that point you can buzz in.
0:09:51If you buzz in before the signals are unlocked,
0:09:55then you are locked out for something like,
0:09:57I think it's a half a second,
0:09:58but you know, it's substantial in that world.
0:10:01So some Jeopardy players listen to Alex's cadence
0:10:05and time themselves to figure out when he's done.
0:10:08And the producer is going to click the button
0:10:10and they time it to that.
0:10:12Other people watch for the lights.
0:10:15So like Ken Jennings is a Alex's Cadence person.
0:10:19James Holzhauer said he follows the looking
0:10:23at the lights thing.
0:10:24So you can't say like one or the other gives
0:10:25you the championship skills.
0:10:27Clearly because the two best players in Jeopardy's
0:10:30history basically are two of the very best players
0:10:33have different strategies.
0:10:34But it's that's the thing is because you get locked out.
0:10:36Apparently I think in the very early Jeopardy!
0:10:40games maybe in the first season because it started in the 60s
0:10:44you could ring in at any time and apparently
0:10:47was very frustrating like the host didn't like it.
0:10:48It was Art Fleming in those days and I think
0:10:51it did not test that well because people wanted
0:10:53to hear the whole question because it's meant
0:10:55for home viewers.
0:10:56And if you don't hear the whole question then you don't
0:10:59have time to think of an answer if someone's
0:11:00it's like what is that you know that's it.
0:11:03The show is too fast and weird. Yeah, I always assumed because it doesn't make a
0:11:09Buzz or a bleep or anything when somebody buzzes in and it it it's interesting because most game shows throughout history with some kind of
0:11:18Buzzer clicker thing it you know makes some kind of noise. I think of the
0:11:22The Family Feud, you know has the the big red thing that you slap your hand on
0:11:27but it but
0:11:30the gist of those
0:11:33Games make sense that there's a sound effect or as jeopardy
0:11:37I would guess
0:11:40easily
0:11:4295% of questions get at least one
0:11:45Guess oh, and there's another sound effect. There's a sound effect when nobody
0:11:49When nobody takes a guess at a question. Oh, yeah, it's like
0:11:54Yeah
0:11:58But it's because every question does get at least one answer
0:12:02It doesn't even make it makes sense that there's no buzz because it would be a non-stop string of buzzes
0:12:07You know the buzz isn't helpful if it's every single thing, you know, it's almost like
0:12:11The way that in movies when people are typing on computers every time they click the mouse or type a key it beeps
0:12:20Right like people do I'm hacking your computer
0:12:26It doesn't make any sense it would drive you crazy if your computer beat every time you typed a key
0:12:30Yeah, I think it would be very distracting if every time you you buzzed in on jeopardy it made a noise or something
0:12:36But I as a viewer it on TV. I have assumed for decades
0:12:40that you were allowed to
0:12:43buzz in whenever you wanted to but
0:12:46Alex Trebek would continue reading the question regardless and then when he's done reading they cut to
0:12:54The podium and whoever buzzed in first at whatever point
0:12:58Theirs is the podium that's lit up and they get to answer. I did not realize that you can't
0:13:03You can't click in you can't buzz in whatever you want to I guess buzz is the wrong word
0:13:08You can't click in until Trebek is done reading. I really didn't realize that
0:13:13But that's interesting because it it gives you more time
0:13:17I always thought that there must be a tremendous advantage to people who could read fast because
0:13:24they could buzz in but there's not you you have at least as long as it takes for back to to
0:13:29Read the question had no idea and I kind of feel like I kind of feel like they there should be some
0:13:36indication of that on the show, I mean, it's you know, too late now, I guess to change it but
0:13:40Yeah, I don't think I understood. I think you yeah, cuz they never discuss it on the show
0:13:46right, you have to only know it if you read about it and
0:13:50But you you can tell yeah, I guess I never I think they never decided because they could have said at the beginning of every
0:13:56episode Alex could have said
0:13:58Contestants can't ring in until the question is finished reading and it's possible. I don't remember it's possible
0:14:02They said that in decades past and they stopped because everyone knew but and you know newer viewers, but I don't remember ever
0:14:08hearing that and it becomes this wild thing because
0:14:12When Ken Jennings went on his his winning streak in 2004
0:14:18After I forget how long he had been playing,
0:14:20how many games he'd won.
0:14:22And the producers are like, this is terrible.
0:14:23I mean, this is great, but it's also terrible.
0:14:25No one is ever going to beat a guy
0:14:27'cause he has now played more games of Jeopardy
0:14:29than anyone.
0:14:30Like remember that until,
0:14:32it was just before the season he was on,
0:14:34you could only win five games in a row.
0:14:36Then you got a car, or two cars.
0:14:38It was the end of the season
0:14:40and they didn't have a choice, they'd give you two cars.
0:14:42So Bob Harris got two cars, Brad Rutter got two cars.
0:14:46you could sell them and you paid the tax on them.
0:14:48Then some people sold them.
0:14:49But so Ken had, you know, on game six or seven,
0:14:53if you exclude the tournament play,
0:14:55he had played the most regular games of Jeopardy
0:14:57of anyone ever.
0:14:58So after 20 games, he has massive amounts of experience
0:15:02that nobody else playing him can.
0:15:04So the producers started to do more training.
0:15:07So, and this is well in advance of when I got there in 2012,
0:15:11when you get there in the morning, there's a bunch,
0:15:13there's like a couple hours of orientation.
0:15:15"Oh, Jon, can I tell you the funniest thing is,
0:15:17"you know those incredibly awkward stories,
0:15:19"the little Alex chit chat?"
0:15:20- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:15:21- Okay, so this is the most important part of the show.
0:15:23- Before Double Jeopardy.
0:15:25- Before Double Jeopardy.
0:15:27You spend so long.
0:15:28So when you apply to the show,
0:15:29you take a test, online test, anyone could take it.
0:15:31Everyone should sign up for this
0:15:33if you have any trivia interest,
0:15:34'cause it's totally painless online.
0:15:37And they test like 100,000 people with each test.
0:15:39Then they select a few thousand to do in-person interviews
0:15:42about 400 people a year, I think, go on the show,
0:15:45if I do the math right.
0:15:46And so once you get to the audition stage,
0:15:49before you even go in in person to audition
0:15:51in your city or wherever, they're like,
0:15:54"Write up three stories of the con you would hear in Jeopardy,
0:15:56like an anecdote about your life, something is interesting."
0:15:58Then you do the audition, then they make you
0:15:59tell those stories, then they ask you for more stories.
0:16:02Then when you get to Culver City, California,
0:16:04to the Sony Pictures Studios, you spend so much time,
0:16:08it is like the most time you spend at the show
0:16:10is crafting your terrible little anecdote for chit chat
0:16:14'cause it's the hardest thing to get people
0:16:16to have a little story.
0:16:18So they work on that part and it's distracting too,
0:16:20which is good.
0:16:21But then the other thing is you play several games.
0:16:24So they do, I think we spent an hour or two in orientation,
0:16:27making sure everyone understands all the law involved
0:16:30'cause there's a lot of game show law
0:16:31since the quiz show scandal
0:16:33and how you can hit, if you feel like something unfair,
0:16:35there's a representative there
0:16:36that you can talk to directly to complain.
0:16:40and that sometimes results in changes.
0:16:41And it's very rare, but it does.
0:16:44Anyway, so then you go on stage
0:16:46and one of the contestant coordinators plays Alex
0:16:49and you run through with the podiums,
0:16:51they sweep people through, they run through categories
0:16:53and the producer who unlocks the signaling system
0:16:57is actually there.
0:16:58And before Ken Jennings, that person wasn't just anyone
0:17:00was there managing it and they decided
0:17:03it was such an advantage that Ken had learned the timing
0:17:06between question and the producers so well
0:17:08that they had to have that person there, or it was not a, you know, it was a too unfair
0:17:13for other people playing.
0:17:14Interesting.
0:17:15But in the end, Ken Jennings won in a final jeopardy.
0:17:18So he didn't win on he didn't lose on get regular gameplay.
0:17:21Hmm.
0:17:22Trying to think was Oh, I have to ask is this sort of thing I care about?
0:17:26Like is the as they call it the signal indicator?
0:17:30Does it have a good feel in your hand?
0:17:31Is it is it a good feeling device?
0:17:33Does it have a good click to it?
0:17:35Yeah, it's um, it's
0:17:37I'm trying to think what it feels like.
0:17:41'Cause usually it doesn't click, you depress it.
0:17:44And you can, and some people have the style
0:17:46that you press it a lot in a row
0:17:47so that if you get in too early,
0:17:50you can still get in past the next person
0:17:53who hasn't signaled, if that makes sense.
0:17:55- Get in at the quickest possible time after that.
0:17:58- Yeah, I'm trying to remember.
0:17:59That's so funny when you say that.
0:18:00I don't think, they tell you to practice with a pen
0:18:03and I did that.
0:18:03And actually at the audition,
0:18:05they give you a cheapo Jeopardy branded pen
0:18:07And I took that home and I sat there and practiced with that as the clicker.
0:18:10And that's a traditional thing.
0:18:11A serious, you know, like super high level players who go back to tournaments, some of them
0:18:16have actually built training systems.
0:18:18They've had built for them by people often who work in the building, the game show, you
0:18:23know, device building industry.
0:18:24They will buy a clicking system or a buzzer system to to test.
0:18:29So they're able to work on their skills.
0:18:32But it is athletic in that sense is, you know, if you can shave half a millisecond off your
0:18:37timing then you could come in first. So I mean this is the other thing even when
0:18:41you're not playing at tournament level like the like the GOAT tournament you
0:18:45have everybody on stage has been auditioned so that most of the time say
0:18:51two or three people will know the answer to any given question and some of them
0:18:55are a little harder and only one person or nobody knows or the person knows they
0:18:58don't ring in they're not secure enough but a lot of the time it's two and
0:19:03often all three and you're just working on timing to get in there so if you're
0:19:07timing is a little bit worse, you could know the answer to
0:19:10nearly every question and still easily lose the game.
0:19:12Yeah, I totally understand that. That's fascinating. Also, what
0:19:18about the the touchscreen where you I guess you use it twice.
0:19:24First you write your name. And so your name is written there on
0:19:28the you know, in white, white pixels on a blue background. And
0:19:31then for Final Jeopardy, you use it to to write your answer. Is
0:19:36it? What is the user interface for that?
0:19:39Oh, it's, it's terrible. It's really low resolution. It's really hard to do it. So when you see people with these really horribly written things in Final Jeopardy, they're barely legible. They should really I mean, I think the the technology has come a long way. I mean, 2012 maybe it was still, you know, acceptable, but in 2020, I think they should have upgraded those to slightly higher resolution and quality, perhaps.
0:20:06I was actually really impressed James Holtzauer would draw a different design, I think, almost every night after he started winning.
0:20:10Then I was like, man, he really he must have worked with some system that used a stylus and, you know, crummy old input thing because he he really actually got some good legible designs on his name.
0:20:23Before Final Jeopardy, do you now for those of you, I mean, I'm assuming there's a big assumption here that people know what Jeopardy is.
0:20:32And I guess if you're listening from outside the US, maybe you don't.
0:20:36Sorry, but it's a really fun game.
0:20:37But there's two rounds where you answer trivia questions
0:20:41and there's three contestants who buzz in.
0:20:43And but then in the final round, it's just one question.
0:20:47All they tell you in advance is the category,
0:20:49which often is some kind of pun and doesn't give you.
0:20:53Sometimes you have a good guess what it's going to be about, sometimes not.
0:20:57And then what each contestant secretly wagers some amount of the money
0:21:02They've already won all or nothing on whether they get get the answer correct and they do it in written form
0:21:08Of course because you know and then they reveal them one at a time because otherwise, you know, how else would you do it?
0:21:13Do they give you like pen and paper so you can like work out the math because there's a lot, you know
0:21:18There's a lot of strategy involved. Like if you're in first place
0:21:22You want to basically want to bet enough so that if you're right
0:21:28You'll win no matter what the second place contestant bet
0:21:32So if the second place contestant bets every dollar they have you want to make sure that if you're right you still come out ahead
0:21:38But you probably don't want to bet everything because then if everybody's wrong
0:21:42You want to still have the most amount of money because that's that's ultimately all that matters
0:21:47Do they give you a pen and paper to work that out? Yeah, see John I can tell that you gamble because oh, yeah
0:21:53You get it. You totally get it. That is the crux of it.
0:21:57And I've seen people lose games because they didn't do all the math.
0:22:01And yeah, they do. They literally give you a pencil and paper.
0:22:04And the thing they don't show you, this is the only thing, you know, they say,
0:22:07Jeopardy is not edited for answers. They sometimes edit it for outcomes.
0:22:12They edit it for timing. So sometimes it seems like people are playing boom, boom, boom.
0:22:16It's because the episode went a little long.
0:22:18I mean, they have a time for each round and they'll actually pull out
0:22:23people's like pauses between answering or between buzzing and answer whatever.
0:22:28So sometimes you're like, God, people are playing super fast.
0:22:31It's like, no, no, that's, that's the edit.
0:22:32But here's the thing they don't show you is Alex exposes the Final Jeopardy
0:22:36category. And we were watching during the Greatest of All Time tournament and
0:22:41we're whole family was watching the category was something like presidents and
0:22:45Bibles. And we're like, Oh, what the, how do you, what? All right. Okay, sure.
0:22:50Something like that. Anyway, so after this,
0:22:52Then they go to commercial break.
0:22:54So on set, since they're obviously, it's not a live show,
0:22:58they give you literally as much time as you need.
0:23:00They put in partitions between contestants before you start,
0:23:05and then they give you as much time as you need
0:23:07to make the wager.
0:23:08So sometimes I think it might've been five plus minutes,
0:23:12and they kind of push you along if it's taking a bit,
0:23:14'cause the audience is there, it's restless,
0:23:15and they won't give you forever.
0:23:16But it's not like you have 10 seconds
0:23:18or 30 seconds to make the wager.
0:23:19So in my, was it my second game, I...
0:23:23- Well, in other words, basically,
0:23:26the basic thing you're trying to say
0:23:27is you have more than the commercial break,
0:23:29which is probably like 90 seconds or two minutes.
0:23:33- Yeah, so we could have, you can have five minutes,
0:23:34whatever they bring out, they're so nice.
0:23:35The contestant coordinators, they bring out water to you,
0:23:39they check on how you're doing, the whole show,
0:23:41I don't think I've said this so far,
0:23:42the whole show is the most humane experience.
0:23:45They do such good hiring.
0:23:46Everybody there is such a lovely person.
0:23:49I remember having great time with the sound guy,
0:23:51with the makeup people.
0:23:54You know, just, I went back to a taping a few months later,
0:23:57one of the contestant coordinators saw me in the audience.
0:23:59They got me tickets.
0:24:00They give me a VI, like friend of Jeopardy sticker.
0:24:04One of the contestant coordinators sees me,
0:24:05comes up, gives me a big hug.
0:24:07And I'm like, oh, it's such a lovely show.
0:24:10And I don't know how much that comes through,
0:24:12but they really do everything they can
0:24:14to make the contestants feel good.
0:24:15So anyway, so the final Jeopardy thing,
0:24:18my second game I was very unsure about the category and in the end I got the
0:24:22wrong answer. I was not the number one I don't think I had the most cash so I had
0:24:28a bet so that the I would be left with enough money if I was wrong and the
0:24:33person who had the most cash was wrong and the person who had the third most
0:24:37cash was right and that is what happened. The number one and number two person
0:24:42this other woman and myself were both wrong the third person bet everything
0:24:48and was right and I beat him and he was so peeved.
0:24:51He kind of kept looking at the screen
0:24:53'cause he's like, he didn't really,
0:24:54I mean, so I didn't bet the maximum,
0:24:56which is what you'd expect
0:24:58because I only had a bet enough to beat,
0:25:00I knew I couldn't beat the number one person
0:25:02if she bet everything.
0:25:03So anyway, she bet the maximum,
0:25:05she needed to beat my maximum.
0:25:06So I bet strategically
0:25:08and that is the only reason I won that game.
0:25:10- Right, there's a strategy there
0:25:11where you're thinking what's, it's not so much,
0:25:13how can I get the highest dollar amount?
0:25:16it's what is the what can I do here that gives me the most likely chance of winning? And
0:25:23in some cases, if you're behind your most likely chance of winning is what if the what
0:25:28if the people ahead of me get get it wrong? Yeah, and then what if we all get something
0:25:33and James Holtz s 34th game when he lost people went nuts because he bet at a level where
0:25:41he's there like he's throwing the game. Why do you throw the game? They get tired of playing.
0:25:44like no he bet because he had a bet on the assumption that the woman who ultimately beat him
0:25:49that he needed to have enough money left to beat the number three player who in the event
0:25:55actual event I think was wrong.
0:25:57But if he had the right answer the number two player would have like twenty two thousand
0:26:01dollars and James needed to wind up with twenty two thousand and one.
0:26:04So he had to be that conservatively to beat her if she was wrong the number one player.
0:26:09Anyway. But people went crazy.
0:26:11They were like oh my God why did he throw the game like no no no.
0:26:13Let's do the math here are the but there's like eight possible outcomes and he bet correctly for every outcome in which he could win
0:26:21yeah, and
0:26:23So anyway the greatest of all I think I think that that wraps up your first-hand experience on it
0:26:28Oh, yeah, and that leads us to this greatest of all time
0:26:31tournament which is
0:26:34fascinating so the three contestants
0:26:36Were I had this on a screenshot somewhere it was Ken Jennings
0:26:43who won 74 times in a row what's the guy's name from Philly James
0:26:53Brett Brad rudder Brad rudder yeah who's not as well known right not as well
0:26:59known because he originally played back in the five-time champion and you're out
0:27:05but then wound up making his claim to greatest of all time by coming on their
0:27:12tournaments of champions where they would bring back five-time champions and
0:27:17play in like a tournament and he according to the Jeopardy bio up until
0:27:22now had never lost to a human being before I guess he lost to the IBM Watson
0:27:26one time in another one of these gimmicky special events yeah he won I
0:27:32think it was because there's a tournament champions and jeopardy in the
0:27:35early 2000s was still popular enough that they did some primetime specials
0:27:39And this one is the first one they've done in many years.
0:27:42And so they do like the ultimate tournament,
0:27:44the tournament one, and then they did some tournament
0:27:45of decades, the blah, blah, blah.
0:27:47So he won, I think either he won four
0:27:50and was on the winning team for the fifth.
0:27:53So he won like a million dollars,
0:27:54two million dollars, a million dollars, you know,
0:27:57300, whatever it was, and even got,
0:28:00I think it was 200 grand from the IBM Watson thing.
0:28:03So he racked up, I think it was $4.4 million
0:28:07in jeopardy, play post his appearances, because he won like 100 grand, including the car value on the original appearance and then like 4.3 million after that, and can he beat Ken Jennings in four of those outings?
0:28:23four point seven million dollars total. That's right. That includes the last tournament. So before that, and so Brad rudder was for a while the winningest he'd won the most money of any person in game show history American game show history. Then Ken briefly got ahead of him because Ken won some money in some non jeopardy game shows, then Brad won another tournament or two. And now Ken is the most winning game show contestant of all time.
0:28:52And then this dollar and then the third is the guy who?
0:28:55Shot to fame I think over the summer just the last in the last year late spring James James Holzhauer
0:29:02who
0:29:04Really shook things up by playing in an unprecedented style
0:29:08and
0:29:10What he's hold his claim to the best of all time is that he has
0:29:13all 15 of the top single game winnings
0:29:18So in other words, how much can you win on a single in one single 30-minute match of jeopardy?
0:29:24spots 1 through 15 on the list are all James Holzhauer and
0:29:29It really felt for a while like he had broken the game
0:29:33But I always thought while he was on his run. I was like this is genius and
0:29:39It happens in pro sports all the time where somebody it doesn't really
0:29:46Or I shouldn't say all the time, but occasionally like a coach or a team will come up with a strategy
0:29:52Yeah that nobody had ever seen before like when you and I were young
0:29:57I don't know if you're you're probably not I know you're not a big sports guy, right?
0:30:00But I like the sports math, but but there is there in when I was in high school
0:30:06So this is like around 1990 1991. There was a typical men's college
0:30:12Well, actually men's and women's scoring is pretty close but in college basketball, that's a 40-minute game
0:30:17it used to be a 45 minute second shot clock and a typical score of
0:30:23top teams
0:30:25Is somewhere, you know, like a winning score is often somewhere around 70 to 80 points, you know
0:30:31And you know that you know, there's a lot of variation. That's just the way it goes
0:30:36so you might see a 50 to 55 game once in a while and
0:30:40sometimes there's high-scoring teams that get close to 90 and
0:30:44For a college game a hundred points is a lot. I mean that that means you were really really off the charts
0:30:52Just because it's only 40 minutes whereas NBA plays a 48 minute game and therefore those extra it's you know, it's
0:31:00That's significantly longer and they have a shorter shot clock and they're better shooters because that's the NBA versus college
0:31:08So, you know, NBA typically, you don't win games with fewer than 100 points.
0:31:13But in the 90s, there was this right around 1990-91, there was this team called Loyola
0:31:19Maramont and they were scoring like 160-170 points a game because they played like their
0:31:28pants were on fire all 40 minutes.
0:31:32So like imagine like the way that you would coach the team.
0:31:35You don't have to be you don't have to really know much about basketball.
0:31:37You just have to just have a basic idea of the game.
0:31:39But imagine you're down by six points
0:31:42with a minute and a half to play.
0:31:44The way that you would instruct your team to play
0:31:46is full court press, cover them from end to end,
0:31:50and try to trap them.
0:31:52Don't just sit there and wait for them to shoot
0:31:54like a typical moment at basketball.
0:31:56Do whatever we can on defense.
0:31:58Double team whoever has the ball.
0:31:59Gamble everything.
0:32:00Gamble everything on every play defensively.
0:32:03And as soon as we get the ball, no matter what we do,
0:32:06Try to get a shot off as quickly as we can.
0:32:09Don't dribble down the court, right?
0:32:10If you're not a sports fan, but you know basketball,
0:32:13you know, the other team scores, they give it to a guy
0:32:16and he dribbles the ball down the court
0:32:18and then they'd start passing it around
0:32:19until somebody gets a shot.
0:32:21Loyola Maramount, there was no dribbling down the court.
0:32:23You always, you passed it down the court.
0:32:25- Yeah, yeah.
0:32:27- And they would--
0:32:28- Also, it's super fast game that way.
0:32:29- Right, but it felt like,
0:32:31and they never won the NCAA championship,
0:32:33but they were very good and they did go far.
0:32:36They ended up with the tray was a terrible tragedy actually where there was a guy named
0:32:39I mean, I hate to bring it all down, but there was a player on their team who actually
0:32:43In their best season at the peak of their powers. He guy named Hank gathers actually died of a heart attack at practice
0:32:49Oh, I remember that that was one of those those one of those first prominent ones were people with a unknown heart. Yeah, exactly
0:32:55Yeah, I remember that
0:32:58yeah, there was no the team but I remember him yeah and
0:33:04Well, I forget his teammate, but he were two guys on the team who were better than everybody else and his teammate
0:33:11I'll try to get it for the show notes
0:33:13but like in honor then they had to go to the NCAA tournament and
0:33:17In honor of him the guy was right-handed, but he did Hank gathers was left-handed
0:33:22So his teammate decided he would shoot all his free throws left-handed
0:33:25Which sounds like a recipe for like hey, that's you know, maybe wear an armband or something
0:33:30Yeah, but it but he shot like 85% from the free throws left-handed. He's so good. But anyway
0:33:37anyway
0:33:39It just looked like you'd be watching ESPN and it just seemed crazy like
0:33:43175 points or something like that. It doesn't happen and
0:33:47Wholes hours jeopardy dawdles just seemed like that like it just seemed like that
0:33:53You're not supposed to you're not supposed to score
0:33:58thousand dollars in a day in Jeopardy.
0:34:00Or 133,000.
0:34:03And I remember watching that episode and just, you know, my brain is melting because, I mean,
0:34:09so Roger Craig had the previous one day total.
0:34:11I mean, Ken Jennings had won, I think, 75 grand in one day.
0:34:15And that had been a little bit of an outlier for Ken.
0:34:17Then Roger Craig, who is one of us, he's a computer programmer, I think database specialist,
0:34:24And to prep for Jeopardy, he sucks down the JArchive, which is a user created, constantly
0:34:30updated database of every Jeopardy clue and game and statistics.
0:34:34So I can find all my games there.
0:34:36People. So he sucked it down with, you know, which is fine.
0:34:39And he wrote software to to relentlessly train himself on all the common Jeopardy clues.
0:34:46So he went through and just was like, you know, slashing and burning.
0:34:50He knew a lot of information and he bet super aggressively, but he only won I think
0:34:54Nine games because he bet it all lost, you know, he and James Holzhauer
0:35:00Holzhauer had
0:35:02The knowledge like that guy I cannot believe
0:35:04How quickly that guy is the answer to every goddamn thing in the world?
0:35:09Yeah, like I don't think I've ever met anybody who just has that much packed in his head. Yeah
0:35:14By the way update here that the producers have told me that
0:35:18Hank gathers teammate was Bo Kimball. That was the fellows name who shot left-handed. Anyway, I put it I'll put it in the show notes
0:35:24There's an article speculating how they would play the game. Yeah, so so while whole tolerance playing by the way
0:35:29I don't know anything about him yet. And there are some secret corners of the internet in which jeopardy contestants talk to each other
0:35:35There's no corners for every everything and so a friend of mine tells me hey, I got cast on the show guy
0:35:41you know in Seattle say I'm going down to tape and
0:35:43He comes back and I'm like, I know I'm not gonna ask you how to go
0:35:46He said he said I had a great time or whatever. I'm like, oh, okay
0:35:48So the show airs it turns out he was playing on the third game that a whole tower play
0:35:54and and he made an incredibly strong showing and
0:35:58Holzauer what he and told tower were contending neck and neck and my friend wound up with like
0:36:0217,000 bucks at the end of double jeopardy
0:36:06But Holzauer had gotten like I think two double jeopardy or two daily doubles
0:36:11So Holtzauer finishes up with like forty two thousand dollars
0:36:13But you know my friend had like they were neck and neck and in any other game
0:36:17My friend was playing it like a master level and you're playing against the Grandmaster and my friend would have won
0:36:23You know five or ten or fifteen shows I think if he hadn't been playing against all that's unbelievable
0:36:28But what about bad luck? Well, the other weird thing about Holtzauer is is that
0:36:33he apparently a part of his
0:36:36Preparation was that he
0:36:40He apparently really studied where they put the daily doubles because they're not completely random.
0:36:48And he strategically would play for them.
0:36:53And I guess what he would do is avoid them at first to build up a bit of money so that he'd have something to wager.
0:37:00And then strategically hunt for the daily doubles by jumping all over the board.
0:37:04and it just and would just tend to push it all in and just try to double his
0:37:11money and build these insurmountable leads you know and there were times when
0:37:15the matches they were obviously over you know 20 minutes into the show yeah
0:37:19because he'd already hit two of the daily doubles doubled his money both
0:37:23times and there wasn't enough money on the board for anybody to get the basic
0:37:33math is that to have a chance to win you have to be at least within half of
0:37:36whoever's in first place so who if the person's in first place has already has
0:37:41$30,000 you need at least 15,000 to have a chance because otherwise you know
0:37:47you're the person in front is not going to bet enough you know unless they're a
0:37:52maniac they're not gonna bet enough to risk losing on the final jeopardy yeah
0:37:56yeah so it's the amazing parts Holtzauer we're going to final jeopardy with so
0:38:00much money that he could bet and still win if he was wrong and he still would get all day you know
0:38:06these 133,000 total. I mean a typical game of Jeopardy! finishes with the winner getting
0:38:11somewhere between I don't know like twelve and thirty thousand dollars. Jeff Duncan, long time
0:38:16technology writer, musician, another Seattle guy, he was also on. He did not play James
0:38:22Holzhauer. He won over thirty thousand dollars. He only won one game but he
0:38:28blew through that and won like 31 grand in one day.
0:38:31And we're all like, "Wow, it was great!"
0:38:33What is up with tidbits, contributors,
0:38:35and winning on Jeopardy?
0:38:36I know we now have the highest,
0:38:38highest percentage of any publications members.
0:38:42It is funny though.
0:38:43I, if you go, if I go to certain kinds of events
0:38:47that are for like quirky or artistic people
0:38:49or certain kinds of tech things, there are always,
0:38:52I went to a Kickstarter thing,
0:38:53and I think there were two other Jeopardy contestants,
0:38:55including another winner, who were among the attendees is just
0:39:00a kind of personality.
0:39:01So anyway, they held this tournament, the greatest of all
0:39:04time with those three fellows, Ken Jennings, who won the most
0:39:07episodes, Brad rudder, who had won the most total money over
0:39:11the years and Holzhauer, who had the single single record things.
0:39:16And they created a primetime special and the rules, I thought
0:39:21the rules were very well designed. The idea was that
0:39:23each each episode would be two jeopardy matches. So instead of a 30 minute, you know, one one
0:39:30time through jeopardy, it was two. And those two jeopardy matches combined, you know, whatever
0:39:38you finished with would it would give you the winner of the day. And the first person
0:39:43who won three days would be crowned the greatest of all time. And so it was indeterminate how
0:39:49long the tournament would last in theory it could have lasted nine matches if
0:39:54they'd all won twice and then the last one would be you know would be the
0:39:59whoever one would would hit three or it could have only lasted three you know
0:40:03and I my fear was that and you asked me before it started or maybe I had started
0:40:09but I told you I hadn't started watching it and by the way if you want to watch
0:40:14You could pause the podcast now
0:40:16Because we haven't spoiled who won yet
0:40:19It is totally worth watching if you really want to you could pause this show right now
0:40:25It'll it'll sit there in your podcast player and you could take a couple of nights and watch it
0:40:30They're all Hulu. It's on Hulu. It is on Hulu. So anybody who has Hulu can get those episodes
0:40:37It is really good. And so if if you've been listening to me and Glenn and you think this sounds great
0:40:42I would like to watch it before we tell you who won
0:40:46You could pause this podcast right now and go watch on Hulu over the next
0:40:51Couple of nights or whenever you have time to watch Hulu. It's a lot of fun
0:40:55but
0:40:58from now forward
0:41:00We'll reveal spoilers as we say anything comparable fire off the spoiler horn
0:41:04All right
0:41:04You asked me who I was rooting for and I and I was rooting for Ken Jennings because I I've never seen I'm not a daily
0:41:11Jeopardy! Watcher. I don't watch all the time. I watched a lot more when I was younger and when I lived it, you know
0:41:16I mean really young I mean, I mean like geez like, you know living at home
0:41:20So, you know, we're talking like 30 30 years ago
0:41:26But I did watch Jennings during his streak and and then once Holtzauer started
0:41:31I started watching and I was fascinated and it makes sense to me that Holtzauer is you know
0:41:35His profession is that he's apparently a professional gambler
0:41:40Which I know a lot of people think is like a myth that there are people who could like live in Vegas and be professional
0:41:46gamblers
0:41:48Well, the blackjack angle is probably it's really tough
0:41:53I mean, I don't have a big steak is the thing of steak and you get marginal returns
0:41:57Yeah, if you know how to play it, right, I don't make a ton of money poker but poker is real
0:42:02I forget does Holzhauer play poker or is the only best sports? I know he says he bets sports and sports is tough
0:42:07I think he does mostly sports. I think he's been I think he's generally pretty good at it as you can tell he's got undeterred
0:42:14I mean, I think you have to be yeah
0:42:16I think you have to pursue a strategy if you're a professional right you pursue a strategy and you don't second-guess yourself all the
0:42:22time because you're trying to get a certain level of
0:42:24Consistent return and it might only be like 3% right like a grocery store or something
0:42:29But yeah comped rooms you get other kinds of free things a little way besides money
0:42:33Yeah, the basic idea and when you bet pro sports is you have to bet a hundred and ten dollars to win a hundred
0:42:41That's that and that 10% difference is the big so if you bet a hundred times
0:42:47And you bet $100 each time you win $100
0:42:50Or if you win, you know
0:42:53If 50/50 you you just lose
0:42:56110 every time you lose and you win 100 every time you win and that 10% eventually kills you you have to win
0:43:03That's if you win 50% of the time you have to win. I think it's
0:43:0754.3% of the time to break really it's not that it doesn't sound that much higher than 50%
0:43:15Which is why people like me love to bet on sports
0:43:20but in practice
0:43:23They're dastardly good that the the people who set the betting lines. They're dastardly good at
0:43:30Setting them in a way that more or less makes it 50/50, you know
0:43:34That's they're not trying to Vegas isn't trying to beat you beat everybody all the time. That's impossible
0:43:39All they want is for half the people to win and half the people to lose and they just collect that 10%
0:43:44And it's a lot of money but in you know
0:43:46The if you're good enough to pick the games where the line is
0:43:52Mathematically off where you see that, you know
0:43:56They're you know the for the Super Bowl the Kansas City Chiefs are last I checked are currently favored by
0:44:021.5 points over the San Francisco 49ers if you've got like a mathematical model for
0:44:09How you know based on the season stats?
0:44:12you know maybe probably geared towards their more recent games and their more recent results and
0:44:18You've also follow along and you know who's injured and etc
0:44:22And you can you know figure out that the line really ought to be that Kansas City or that San Francisco should be favored by
0:44:30One point well, then you realize it's a really good bet
0:44:33Mathematically to bet on San Francisco that doesn't mean your bet is going to win
0:44:37It just means you know that and if you do that more often than not maybe you can win
0:44:4357% of the time and stay ahead of the big something like that
0:44:47Definitely possible and you watch holds our play jeopardy, and I believe it
0:44:52But poker poker is the other game where you can easily be a professional gambler
0:44:56Because you're not playing against the house. You're playing against other players and
0:45:00Yeah, they just take a small cut out of the pot out of every pot and that's it and you just have to be both
0:45:08Better than other players and better enough than the typical other players to compensate for the you know
0:45:15Like three or four percent that the house takes out of every pot
0:45:20Definitely a lot of professional poker players. Anyway, he
0:45:25definitely played like a gambler, not like a quiz show
0:45:28contestant.
0:45:29Yeah, he he was just incredible. I mean, he had basically he was
0:45:34he was like a machine to he was, he was relentless. He's not very
0:45:38emotional, because he's in work mode, right? So people gave him
0:45:42there's some criticism about like, boy, he seems like a, like
0:45:45an uncaring person or whatever. And to be like, Well, no, he's
0:45:49got a game face. And this is a job. He's come in here thinking about this. And he kind of
0:45:53talked about it that way. His plan was to win as much money as he could. And he did
0:45:57and not that he didn't have a good time, I don't think but you know, the way he talks
0:46:01about his family kept putting in birth dates as the wagers he was writing in messages.
0:46:07You know, he talked about his grandmother is a Japanese immigrant who didn't speak much
0:46:12English and how he promised to go on the show and she you know, and oh, they watched it
0:46:16together. Like, you know, he's actually I think, a very sweet
0:46:18guy. Yeah, who comes across as many people like us in this
0:46:23technology world. Sometimes we come across as a little in our
0:46:26heads. And I was very sympathetic with the way he came
0:46:30off. But he really it was a job and he came in every day and he
0:46:33just went bam, bam, bam, bam. And if he lost, it would be
0:46:36like, whatever, because he just he just was so good at racking
0:46:41up the money. He'd already won all the money you could possibly
0:46:43want. So at that point, I mean, I think he talked about that a
0:46:46little bit. It's like, how do you go all in? When you can lose
0:46:49everything? It's like, well, if you no longer care, if it's a
0:46:51wager, and you're not looking at as dollars, it's like a one or
0:46:54zero, it's not a, you know, $50,000. Because it's fake
0:46:58money. It's not real money until you take it home. Right. And I
0:47:00think and I think he had played that strategy better than anyone
0:47:04has ever been able to play.
0:47:05Yeah. So my fear I was rooting for Ken Jennings, I not strongly
0:47:09because they're all interesting people. And they're all seem
0:47:12very likable. And it's just such an interesting premise. But if I had to say I was rooting for
0:47:17someone in advance, it was Ken Jennings. But my fear was that Holzhauer was just going to
0:47:21win every you know, when just clean the plate. It just seemed like there was a chance there that
0:47:28he's just unstoppable and that he's too good on the buzzer. Even against someone like Ken Jennings,
0:47:34who, you know, obviously, like you said, has tremendous buzzer experience. But I think what
0:47:41What did it go? So it was Ken Jennings won first.
0:47:45Yeah, by like 200 points for the game.
0:47:47Yes. Right.
0:47:49Two games. Right.
0:47:49And it was like, oh, it's going to be like that.
0:47:51And then James won the second game by a pretty good margin.
0:47:55Right. And then Ken kind of demolished James in the third episode.
0:48:01And then the fourth, it was kind of the same thing.
0:48:03Like there were a couple tricky questions in the fourth where Ken could have lost practically everything and really tanked.
0:48:09James would have won by a huge amount but Ken got the answer correctly for some big bets. Yeah.
0:48:15And he said later, he said, if I'm playing against James Holtzauer, I have to play James
0:48:19Holtzauer style. So he would go in all in in a way that Ken typically had in another play. Right.
0:48:24And it worked for him. Yeah. And and Ken had didn't seem to have as much success in previous
0:48:30like tournament of champion things compared to Brad rudder. And rudder got more or less swept
0:48:35He was really not competitive in any of the four days. So anyway, Ken Jennings was the winner
0:48:42He won the first third and fourth
0:48:44But on the second Holzhauer creamed everybody
0:48:49And a couple of Jennings wins really came down to like getting one answer correct
0:48:55push and
0:48:58Alex even
0:49:00Alex Trebek even called him on it where on a lot of his answers
0:49:03he was really answering like a question like and and
0:49:07It you know Ken Jennings has been on the show enough times that Trebek
0:49:12Knows that he's not like doing it for dramatic dramatic effect like he was making his best guess on a lot and got them
0:49:21Right. Yeah, like the nullification one
0:49:23Yeah, yeah States rights and I was like we're all you know
0:49:27I think that all four of us in the family were watching and you know, the kids are actively studying some of this stuff
0:49:31So it's a little fresher to them than my wife and I.
0:49:33And we're all like,
0:49:34"Is it? Was that this or that? Was it…?"
0:49:36But like I think maybe my older said,
0:49:38"Nollification?"
0:49:39I forget somebody in the house I think said it.
0:49:41And Jenny said,
0:49:42"Nollification?"
0:49:43We're all like, "Oh it doesn't sound right."
0:49:44And it's like, "Yep, that was it." Like, "Oh my God."
0:49:46But it was great TV and it had huge ratings too.
0:49:50It was one of the,
0:49:51I think the top rated show in its slot.
0:49:54It did very well. All four nights.
0:49:56It was a great idea.
0:49:57It was fun. It was fun.
0:50:00No, Brad, I wrote a piece, Motherboard asked me if I'd write something up after Game 3, before Game 4, and I did some statistical analysis.
0:50:07And Brad Rutter was only answering.
0:50:10He was only, he only buzzed in half as frequently as the other two to start with.
0:50:14He was wrong about 11 percent of the time.
0:50:17And Ken was wrong slightly more than...
0:50:21I'm sorry, James is wrong slightly more than Ken.
0:50:23And Ken was right on every daily double he got in the first three games.
0:50:28So you could see just from the standpoint of play over three games it looked like Ken was playing just I mean
0:50:34This is kind of the boat or the the gambling thing. Ken was playing just slightly better not
0:50:39crazily better but just enough and that edge meant that every time he won on a daily double he was able to
0:50:45Leverage it ahead. I don't know how old they all are. Oh
0:50:48Can't I forgot the exact reason we're about 10 years in age apart
0:50:55Holzhauer is the youngest in his 30s Brad Rutter is about five years older and Ken's about five years old
0:51:01And I think I think there's about a ten year age Ken is the oldest by
0:51:04And he was talking about you know, kind of hanging up his spurs like I'm an old man
0:51:09And being 43 or something 45. I don't know
0:51:13He said I don't know if I'll do it and he's now he said he's not gonna play anymore
0:51:15Like he said this was I can't top this. I'm going out, you know handed over to the next. Thanks
0:51:21Roll rudder even said during one of the hey
0:51:24Let's talk about the champions things that he he could tell that he's lost his step since his you know jeopardy prime
0:51:3015 years ago, or I guess close. I don't know 20 years ago whenever it was
0:51:34Yeah, the tournaments. I mean he's played tournaments more recently, but the tournament play is different because you're you're beating
0:51:40I mean even though you're going head-to-head against someone like Ken Jennings you kind of work your way up
0:51:44So you're not playing every game against the best people in the world or the two other best
0:51:48I mean the way I look at it is Brad Rutter had never played against the two best players in Jeopardy history only one
0:51:54And against two of them and you know, I couldn't win a single game today. I mean I was stumped like the entire first
0:52:01Gameboard of the first game this run. I was like what? Oh my god
0:52:07And the second I was better but like I couldn't I couldn't win a game today. I just don't I don't have the speed
0:52:12Yeah, or necessarily the recall
0:52:14Yeah, and the one that really was shows how smart these guys are and how good they are were the couple of days they had
0:52:20the categories where it's like
0:52:22Some kind of like two different things and you have to put them together into a pun. Oh my god that one
0:52:28Yeah, that was hilarious
0:52:29I I think I could get some of those if you gave me a half an hour and that would be one of them boom
0:52:35They're like buzz is it?
0:52:37How does your brain work anyway, I had a great time watching
0:52:41alright, let me take a break here and
0:52:44and tell everybody about clear.
0:52:47Clear makes your life safer, simpler, and more secure.
0:52:52With clear, your eyes and your fingertips
0:52:54get you through security faster
0:52:56at airport stadiums and other venues.
0:52:59Never run to your gate again.
0:53:01Clear helps you get through security
0:53:04with the tap of a finger
0:53:05so you can get to your gate faster
0:53:07and reduce pre-flight stress.
0:53:10You are your ID.
0:53:12Start getting through security with a tap.
0:53:16Clear replaces the need for physical ID cards,
0:53:18using your eyes and fingertips to get you through security
0:53:22because you, your biometrics, are the best ID out there.
0:53:27Reminds me a lot of 2001.
0:53:29I just went to see it again last year
0:53:30when it was released into theaters.
0:53:32I had forced my son to wait.
0:53:35He'd never seen the movie before.
0:53:36And Haywood Floyd, top security expert
0:53:39for the US government when he gets to the moon base.
0:53:41Clavius, how does he get through security?
0:53:44With his biometrics, a little retinal scan,
0:53:47looks through his eyes.
0:53:48Well, that's what clear is like.
0:53:49It's just like 2001 has finally caught up with us.
0:53:52You go to the airport, you sail right through security.
0:53:55What you do, here's how you do it.
0:53:57You create your account online
0:53:59before you go to the airport.
0:54:00Once you get to the airport, go to the line for clear,
0:54:04and a clear ambassador will be there
0:54:06to help you finish the process of signing up,
0:54:08and then you can immediately use Clear.
0:54:12Clear helps you get through security faster
0:54:13in 65 plus airports, but it's not just airports.
0:54:17Stadiums and other venues too.
0:54:19A whole bunch of stadiums, Major League Baseball,
0:54:22NFL Football, these leagues now have policies
0:54:25that implement airport style security
0:54:27before you get in a stadium.
0:54:29It's a big pain in the butt, but guess what?
0:54:33If they have Clear, you sail right through,
0:54:35just like you did in the old days
0:54:36before there was onerous security like that at stadiums.
0:54:39And they have family plans.
0:54:42If you're traveling with your family,
0:54:43up to three family members can be added
0:54:45at a discounted rate.
0:54:46And kids under 18 are free when traveling
0:54:50with just one clear member.
0:54:53Totally free if you have kids under 18.
0:54:55Clear is the absolute best way
0:54:57to get through airport security.
0:54:59And it works great with TSA PreCheck too.
0:55:03Right now, listeners of the talk show
0:55:05can get their first two months of clear absolutely free.
0:55:10Go to clearme.com, C-L-E-A-R-M-E.com, clearme.com/talkshow
0:55:15and use that code talk show.
0:55:21That's clearme.com/talkshow with code talk show
0:55:26and you will get free two months of clear.
0:55:29Go sign up, sail through the airport
0:55:31like you never have before.
0:55:33My thanks to clear for sponsoring the talk show. Next topic.
0:55:37What do you think? iPhone encryption never, never gets old. Does it?
0:55:40I've been writing about it a lot. I, I really,
0:55:44really feel like it's the sort of thing that needs to be nipped in the bud.
0:55:49Like it's not worth waiting until it,
0:55:52if to me the DOJ gets its way and gets legislation proposed to limit it.
0:56:00Like, it really needs to be nipped in the bud as a bad idea.
0:56:06I think people who listen to the show and follow my site
0:56:09know the basic story.
0:56:10But basically, there's this Pensacola shooter, this guy
0:56:14who shot up a Navy base.
0:56:16And he had two iPhones and shot a couple of people.
0:56:21And he's dead now.
0:56:25But the federal government would like to get access to his phones.
0:56:28And Apple has provided as much information from his iCloud
0:56:34accounts as they could, apparently measuring in the
0:56:37gigabytes. But Attorney General William Barr is raising hay
0:56:43that it's not it's not right, or according to him, that the
0:56:47FBI that law enforcement officials can't just quote un
0:56:50quote, get into iPhones. You know, when they have a court
0:56:56order, etc, etc. And Apple's answer is more or less we can't,
0:57:00we can't help you. Although they haven't definitively said,
0:57:04can't, I guess, you know. And, and there's some ambiguity over
0:57:10that. And I feel like I've, I've over the years, I've lost track
0:57:14of exactly how this works. And what literally what we know can
0:57:18and can't be done. You know what I mean?
0:57:21Well, yeah, because the right, the fundamental thing is that
0:57:26starting with I've lost track because of the five s is starting with when Apple built secure enclave
0:57:34in as a separate chip into the iPhone architecture, they effectively abrogated their ability to
0:57:41extract information that like the passcode, right, that would decrypt the phone. And because they
0:57:47designed the system around pushing all of the generation of key material that would allow
0:57:54decryption, or access to each device. So the issue is, and I think this came up with the San Bernardino
0:58:02shooters a few years ago, and this previously came up is Apple had said, we'd have to create what they
0:58:08would call a government OS, we have to create a special OS be able to load it on the machine. And
0:58:12this OS would allow more rapid calculation, it would bypass the the limits on lockouts that be
0:58:22that Apple started to add, you know, alongside Secure Enclave. So the issue even isn't so there's
0:58:29like multiple issues. One is the current iOS and iPad OS is the hardware architecture is designed
0:58:35to prevent rapid fire, brute force cracking. So you can't just enter a bunch of different pass
0:58:41codes. So the was a gray not gray bar gray gray lock. Yeah, it's the one right. They they and
0:58:48maybe some other folks had ostensibly allegedly developed systems
0:58:51Gray shift is a gray shift. And their product is gray key. Gray key is the little sort of like I Mac
0:59:00mini sized. That's Thank you device. Yeah, celebrate and gray shift are the companies at least the two,
0:59:07they claim to be able to break in. And they seem to have been able to bypass hardware and software.
0:59:13Well, I guess has to be baked in a hardware protections and protections in the in the certified OS
0:59:19that would allow them to then do brute force cracking and crack shorter keys.
0:59:24And as you know, as the audience I'm sure knows, the longer key is, or the more complicated it is,
0:59:29you know, a four digit key can be solved very quickly, a pin.
0:59:32Six digit takes quite a bit longer.
0:59:34If you do something like me, a 20 mixed character, or alphanumeric,
0:59:39the heat death of the universe couldn't come too soon.
0:59:41But you know, really, it's years or something to go through all the iterations
0:59:45as rapidly as the software could take them with no throttle in place.
0:59:49So Apple said, hey, we're not going to make in the San Bernardino case, we're not going to make a government OS, we don't want to be compelled to do this, that would bypass the brute force cracking speed is my recollection, right? And then the other part was we can't give you the key because we built our system so that we don't have access to it. It's locked away. You'd have to break open the secure enclave in like a clean lab, and even then the chip would probably self destruct. I mean, that's they didn't say that, but that's the way these chips are built. You wouldn't you shouldn't be able to extract information from them, even with
1:00:19with like scanning electron microscopes, right? The issue
1:00:22today?
1:00:23Well, I think if my understanding is correct, and
1:00:27this is complicated enough where I feel like I'm uncertain, but
1:00:30tell me if you agree, I think the best way to think about it is
1:00:33that there's two, I don't want to say operating systems, let's
1:00:38just say systems on an iPhone, and it just goes for iPad two.
1:00:42There's iOS, which is what is the traditional operating system
1:00:48that runs the device as a computer as we know it.
1:00:53I think with the CPU and RAM and its storage
1:00:57and input output and USB support
1:01:01through the lightning connector
1:01:03or the USB-C port on an iPad Pro.
1:01:06And it's an operating system that runs on a computer
1:01:09and Apple does its best to keep that secure.
1:01:13They also have at a hardware level,
1:01:17I believe it is true that that an iOS device will not accept an operating system that has not been signed by Apple.
1:01:28That that's correct. And there was this jailbreak, if you jailbreak a device, you're essentially figuring out a way to bypass to take a modifying, take a bug and exploit the bug to run arbitrary code.
1:01:40And then that code does something to defeat Apple, but but you can't really create your own
1:01:46version of
1:01:49iOS and get it to install on an iOS device without having it be signed by Apple and
1:01:54When I say signed by Apple there was a story
1:01:57I was looking for today and couldn't find it off to see if I can find it
1:02:01but there was a story a couple of years ago that
1:02:03to sign a
1:02:06release of iOS it is it really is like something out of a Mission Impossible
1:02:12Movie, you know, there was a question about whether people were trying to subvert the engineers at Apple
1:02:18There's only a few people at Apple
1:02:19It's a very small number who have like the fingerprint and retinal and whatever stuff that allows them to access
1:02:26The thing that allows them to sign right the operating system
1:02:30And so if you subvert those people could you then conceivably right?
1:02:34So even who they are is kept secret and that was a concern I think you know and it you know
1:02:40You think like I would you know, it's nothing really works like that where there's a secure underground vault
1:02:45with with locked doors and guards and you know, you know like
1:02:51You know and people believe it for like a nuclear submarine were to two members of the crew
1:02:58More than what is possibly arms distance away, you know, like let's say at least
1:03:03ten feet away have to put keys that they keep with them around their neck 24
1:03:10hours a day and simultaneously turn the two keys so two officers have to turn
1:03:16keys that couldn't possibly be done you know just physically by by one person
1:03:22there's a system like that in place where it like to Apple employees have to
1:03:27use physical objects I don't know if they're keys they're probably you know
1:03:31a more complicated than like, you know, a physical key, but
1:03:35yeah, it's like, it's an encrypted, it's a device itself
1:03:38that contains encrypted information that has to be
1:03:40inserted, right. And they both have to do it in a room and can
1:03:44only be done in a room whose location Apple literally won't
1:03:48won't disclose the actual location. I mean, presumably
1:03:52it's somewhere in Cooper Dino on one of Apple's campuses, you
1:03:56know, but who knows? I mean, just for practicality sake, you
1:04:00know, you would assume it's somewhere in Cupertino, and
1:04:03perhaps they've moved it from the old Infinite One campus to
1:04:06the new one. But I honestly believe it's actually
1:04:09underground. Only a handful of Apple employees have access,
1:04:14there's obviously some kind of plan in place for what happens
1:04:16if one of the people involved, you know, it proverbially gets
1:04:21hit by a bus. But it really is that difficult. It is not it,
1:04:26you know, really sounds like something out of Mission
1:04:28Impossible or James Bond movie or something like that. So just to get a version of iOS that that
1:04:33that that these devices will sign at a hardware level, they really won't sign unless they can
1:04:38check.
1:04:39This is a real thing in a there's a bunch of there's a bunch of industries, there's a bunch of
1:04:45kinds of things around the world that are like this. I mean, this is one of the most critical
1:04:49because it's device specific. And I assume Google has a very similar Yeah, thing. I remember a few
1:04:55years ago, I had to look it up while you're talking because I want to remember the detail is there was
1:04:59a ceremony in which to sign the route for DNS. So you know how there's all these route.com and
1:05:07whatever different domains, but there's also route servers that are the root of authority for all of
1:05:13DNS. There's a bunch of them run redundantly around the world. Well, in order to sign the root
1:05:17certificate to start the process to get a secure and encrypted form of DNS underway, they had to
1:05:24get a bunch of people together. They all got together and they all had to be in the same
1:05:28physical place to sign these keys with the specific cryptographic hardware that they
1:05:36owned. And I was talking to the folks at Let's Encrypt that have they would offer free SSL
1:05:44certificates or HTTPS certificates for websites talking to their CEO last year. And he said one
1:05:50of the most expensive things they own is a device that is designed to protect their route. And, you
1:05:57know, it's tamper resistant, it's it's got various safeguards, it's in a secure facility that has to
1:06:02meet certain international standards. And this is a real it's it's a it's not casual. Now, I think
1:06:07you also need years ago, it was much more casual. And now it is certainly not now. Right. In
1:06:12addition to the fact that the the iOS devices at a hardware level will not accept a version of iOS
1:06:20that is cryptographically signed provably by Apple.
1:06:23I also believe and I think you would know, correct me if I'm wrong,
1:06:28that you cannot.
1:06:30Update, there's no way to update an iOS device offline.
1:06:36It also must be online.
1:06:40To. Call back to Apple over
1:06:46over SSL secure and make sure that Apple is still agreeing to sign this OS so that if
1:06:53there's a known bad version of iOS, if Apple releases a version of iOS and then after it's
1:07:00out realizes we know that this version is compromised in some way by a bug, we're going
1:07:06to revoke the signing certificate for that. And then there's no way to get that version of iOS
1:07:12onto a device because it still before it'll go it has to call home to Apple securely and
1:07:19Apple has to say yes, that is still a valid signed version of iOS.
1:07:23No, you're totally right.
1:07:25And I don't think I thought about it that way.
1:07:26But it's correct.
1:07:27Mac OS, you can still update offline with an installer that's signed and so forth, right?
1:07:32But there are revocation processes.
1:07:34But I think if your Mac were not on the internet, I believe it's still I think so too feasible.
1:07:38Yeah, so whenever you see if you're using iTunes to restore well an image and I think that's because that Apple still acknowledges that there
1:07:45are there are
1:07:47Scenarios. Oh, yeah, where people have Macs that are in rooms that you know aren't
1:07:53Internet access isn't allowed. Oh
1:07:55Yeah, no that makes total. Yeah, that's that's right
1:07:58And yeah, but so every iPhone and iPad when you install an update directly from the device
1:08:03It has that verifying stage which may seem mystifying because didn't it just download it. It's like yes it did
1:08:08But a cracker could conceivably force a device to sideload. I mean, there's you know management tools
1:08:15Maybe they could get an update that's not legit
1:08:18So I still have to phone home
1:08:20all of this is to say is that Apple takes the security of iOS and the ability to only sign known good versions of
1:08:27iOS as as I don't know what more they can do other than to continue to hunt bugs and continue to look for better ways
1:08:35but it literally is to the best of their abilities to keep iOS as
1:08:40secure as possible
1:08:42At every step of the way that said there are known exploits in iOS
1:08:48That allow people and especially older versions. What's the name of that one that came out in the bootloader?
1:08:54Which is unfixable?
1:08:56There's there's a low-level part of the operating system. It's in this only for older devices
1:09:02Yeah, it was fixed and I think the last version affected was the iPhone 10
1:09:07Checkmate
1:09:11CH eck m and then the number eight because whoever found it, you know is a hacker and names things that way
1:09:20but there's a
1:09:22There's a bug in the bootloader of every iPhone up to the iPhone 10 generation. So I guess the iPhone 8 would be included
1:09:31Which unfortunately compromises iOS in a way and Apple can't fix it because the bootloader is part of is
1:09:38Is ROM it you know to go?
1:09:40You don't really think about exploit. You know physical proximity after physical access to the device
1:09:46Yeah, you do have to have physical access to the device
1:09:48But anyway that said they take as much they do as much as they can to keep it secure
1:09:53They fix that bootloader issue in the iPhone
1:09:5510s and 11
1:09:59But people can still get into iOS and Apple fixes those bugs when they as soon as they know about them
1:10:06but getting into iOS does not get you into the data on the device because the
1:10:13The encryption of the device is that second system I alluded to earlier
1:10:18So there's iOS and it's not like Apple takes iOS security lightly
1:10:22They take it as seriously as they can but then there's the secure enclave and the secure enclave
1:10:27Isn't just a a secure storage device it is a it's a system it is in effect its own computer
1:10:35and
1:10:39It it now like one of the things that they changed I believe is
1:10:45It so like there's an 80 millisecond delay
1:10:51Anyway, when you type in your passcode when you type in your password passcode, whatever you have to unlock your phone
1:10:57IOS doesn't it takes the input you tapping 1234 on the keypad on the screen is obviously
1:11:09handled by iOS but then iOS takes that passes it to the secure enclave and says here's a
1:11:16guess at the passcode to the encryption. It's the secure
1:11:22enclave that takes that guess and computes whether or not it's
1:11:29valid. And Apple has designed it I don't think originally, I
1:11:33think it's one of the changes since the five s and I know that
1:11:35the secure enclave your your guess was right. It definitely
1:11:38coincides with the five s which is biometric authentication.
1:11:43Because they offered encryption of, yes, because they offered, that's it. Before that, you could
1:11:48encrypt your phone, but it was a slow process. Right. And that was added in some iOS. But it's
1:11:53with the that's exactly what the fingerprint sensor, they very wisely. And I think this is,
1:11:57you know, not to criticize other smartphone makers, but whatever. I think Apple, from the very
1:12:03start said, we're not going to store any biometric information in a way that is retrievable in any
1:12:08fashion. So it's all one way into secure enclave. And then over time, they've expanded that to
1:12:12include like Apple pay and face ID and a bunch of other stuff. It's in and third party apps can throw
1:12:19stuff into secure right enclave as well have the same advantage. I don't know the inside story
1:12:24of the timing of that. And you know, I would love to know it if anybody out there does know it. But
1:12:30if it's true, that Apple, Apple, in theory might have had a touch ID fingerprint sensor
1:12:40ready to go a year, two years before the five s. But there,
1:12:46they were never going to use it until they also had the secure
1:12:50enclave. So in theory, I don't know which took longer to
1:12:53develop. Maybe they had this, I think it's quite possible that
1:12:57they might have had the fingerprint sensor ready to go
1:13:01before the secure enclave because I think if the secure
1:13:04enclave was ready to go a year or two years earlier, they might
1:13:08have included it even before they had biometric
1:13:11authentication because it still would have been useful. Right?
1:13:13It still would have helped increase it. I suspect that the
1:13:17fingerprint sensor and touch ID that was introduced with the
1:13:20five s was waiting for the secure enclave. It's also true
1:13:24that the five s was the first to go 64 bit on the on the a series
1:13:28chip and maybe that plays into it too. I don't know. But there
1:13:31were a couple of things that all had to come together for that to
1:13:34work. But I do know I do I do know for a fact talking to
1:13:38people at Apple off the record, that there was no way they were
1:13:41ever going to do the fingerprint sensor before they had the the
1:13:45secure enclave, because there's just no way that they would
1:13:48store any biometric information without it.
1:13:51Right. I think that's exactly right is I would not be
1:13:53surprised the fingerprint sensor was among the more advanced ones
1:13:56at the time, it was more accurate use the you know, the
1:13:59capacitance and so forth. But I don't think anything they did
1:14:02was totally like so, you know, what's the right word?
1:14:07Such a breakthrough that it wasn't,
1:14:09you know, that they were waiting.
1:14:10I'm sure they perfected it, they had more time,
1:14:12but the Secure Enclave, that marked a huge change.
1:14:15I mean, I was writing something for,
1:14:18about the YubiKey and the, for Fast Company.
1:14:22YubiKey finally was able to release a lightning version
1:14:25of its authentic, external authenticating device,
1:14:29'cause Apple didn't support that until,
1:14:31actually pretty recently in Safari for Mac OS
1:14:34and then they added it to iOS,
1:14:36but it seemed like it was coming to iOS.
1:14:37So these guys did it.
1:14:39But so the Yubikey is part of the,
1:14:41it's essentially an external secure enclave at some level.
1:14:45It gives you some of the same protections
1:14:47that you get from a device-based secure chip in a token,
1:14:52even though the token conceivably can be moved around.
1:14:56And anyway, the thing is, I think as I was researching this,
1:15:00I realized there had been this huge sea change
1:15:02is before Secure Enclave,
1:15:04the encryption was the top bar and verification,
1:15:08and there might've been some hardware steps,
1:15:10but they were work aroundable.
1:15:13And then Secure Enclave set the bar that everyone,
1:15:16Microsoft now encourages in many,
1:15:19you can buy PCs, a large number of PCs
1:15:21that have the equivalent of a Secure Enclave in it.
1:15:23Google had to shift to it ultimately
1:15:25so they certify devices with it.
1:15:28and the web authentication standard that got promoted,
1:15:31the whole FIDO2 standard is kind of built around
1:15:34having a one-way chip that can only produce
1:15:37sort of outputs based on inputs after it's been set up.
1:15:41So anyway, it was a big and important change
1:15:44and no one should want us to go backwards from that
1:15:47'cause it protects people at every level,
1:15:49protects vast amounts of personal and commercial information
1:15:52and those people in government who rely on it
1:15:55for security as well or as part of a security system.
1:15:57I do believe it is true that the call it firmware and firmware seems like an outdated term to
1:16:03me, you know, but let's call it the firmware that runs the secure enclave.
1:16:08I believe that Apple in a software update to iOS can update the firmware on the secure
1:16:14enclave.
1:16:15So there's aspects of the secure enclave that could that's correct, that could get a bug
1:16:20fix if necessary.
1:16:22the
1:16:248080 millisecond and and I always forget this a millisecond is a thousandth of a second. So 80 milliseconds is
1:16:318/100 of a second so
1:16:3512 per second give or take great 12 times 8 is 9
1:16:39What is 12 times 8?
1:16:46I had to do my I had to do my trick my trick for 12 times 8 is 8 times 10 plus 8 times 2
1:16:53So that's 96
1:16:55So, you know roughly 12 per second
1:16:58Which doesn't you know sounds pretty fast?
1:17:02but that that 80 millisecond
1:17:05Computation time for taking iOS saying to the secure enclave. Here's a password guess 1 2 3 4
1:17:13Secure enclave takes it
1:17:16Does the computation that computation runs in hardware and that 80 mil
1:17:21So there's no way that somebody could force a firmware update to the secure enclave to say hey
1:17:28How about you reduce the time to zero, you know, how about you do it as fast as you can?
1:17:33That can't be done. That's actually
1:17:36Implemented in hardware and so 12 per second is the most guesses you can and so basically the way these products that we know about
1:17:43about work, celebrate the gray.
1:17:46I keep forgetting, which is the gray key is the product
1:17:49from gray shift the company, they jailbreak iOS
1:17:54to get in so that they can talk to the secure enclave
1:17:59because there's no way to talk to the secure enclave
1:18:01from outside the iPhone.
1:18:03And then once they're in, they install, they run software
1:18:08and the software talks to the secure enclave
1:18:11and starts running guesses as fast as it can.
1:18:16And then once they find it, then they,
1:18:20like there was a story I linked to it a couple of days ago
1:18:23on Daring Fireball where somebody leaked
1:18:25to a security researcher two years ago,
1:18:28how the gray key device works.
1:18:31- Oh yeah, yeah.
1:18:32- And they even had photographs.
1:18:34They even had some pictures of the software running
1:18:36and it runs and then when it finds the right passcode,
1:18:39displays it on screen and then you can unplug it from the device and then I
1:18:45guess restart start the iPhone and then enter the passcode that the device tells
1:18:49you what to do but even that software can only do 12 guesses per second and
1:18:57like you mentioned I think before we started recording that that doesn't mean
1:19:01that they start zero zero zero one zero zero zero or you know if they know it's
1:19:06six because I guess you know how long the passcode is just by
1:19:10iOS gives up how long it is, right?
1:19:13Let me double if I turn on my phone if you do a pet if you have a four six digit passcode
1:19:19I think yeah disclose that right? Yeah, cuz you chose you how many circles I because I can alphanumeric passcode though
1:19:25If you choose that option, even if you have a short passcode
1:19:29Then it's impossible to know how long it is anymore
1:19:31which is what I did at some point when a security person
1:19:34like Rich Mogul or someone else said,
1:19:36"Yeah, six digits is probably not adequate."
1:19:37I was like, "Oh, okay, making the change now."
1:19:40Yeah, that's right.
1:19:42So this is more true for,
1:19:44or more useful for breaking into databases
1:19:48that are hijacked online because,
1:19:50and this is changing as well,
1:19:51but a lot of databases, the ones that were encrypted
1:19:54were using a very weak algorithm
1:19:57that was very easy to brute force through.
1:19:59SHA-1, and that's been updated to later versions,
1:20:01a lot of databases.
1:20:03And then they've added another technique
1:20:04in a lot of online, you know, good online sites,
1:20:07so that no cracking a password once
1:20:10doesn't help you crack the same password
1:20:11you spy everyone on the same database.
1:20:14They're all seeded in a slightly different way.
1:20:17Salted is the word.
1:20:18But anyway, so those people,
1:20:20the people who are trying to crack exfiltrated databases,
1:20:25They have these huge, you know, not rainbow tables,
1:20:30we used to call them, those still exist
1:20:32that were just, you know, essentially pre-cracked versions
1:20:35or pre-computed versions of passwords
1:20:39going through certain algorithms like SHA-1.
1:20:41But what they have now is there are well-known passwords.
1:20:45There's passwords that have been extracted.
1:20:46There's like a, I can't remember if you go to-
1:20:48- I think that's more likely 'cause I-
1:20:50- Have you been pwned?
1:20:51I think that the SHA-1 computed versions of passwords
1:20:56are probably not that useful
1:20:58and certainly not useful getting--
1:20:58- Not very useful anymore.
1:20:59- Right, because everybody's gonna hash them some way.
1:21:02And so they're not going,
1:21:03it's gonna be the hash of the password,
1:21:06the hash and then SHA-1 computed.
1:21:09And if you don't know that hash,
1:21:11knowing that list isn't gonna help.
1:21:13- Right, but I think this is still used in the same way
1:21:16is that because of the computational overhead
1:21:19now being higher, people trying to crack those databases,
1:21:21they have like, you know, they know,
1:21:23so it's have you been pwned,
1:21:24which I recommend everyone to sign up at.
1:21:27They have a list of, what is it, a billion?
1:21:29I don't know, it's hundreds of millions of passwords
1:21:31that have been leaked in the clear online.
1:21:33They don't associate them with accounts,
1:21:35but researchers and others can see,
1:21:37can get access essentially to a huge set of passwords
1:21:41people have used.
1:21:42So what are the first passwords that are checked
1:21:44are the shortest ones from that list
1:21:46that are most commonly appeared.
1:21:47And then there's those dictionary words,
1:21:49there's all these other things.
1:21:50So when you're brute forcing,
1:21:52you don't start with zero, zero, zero, zero, zero, zero,
1:21:55zero, one, whatever, you use common letters and numbers.
1:21:58And then at some point you go into the brute force thing
1:22:00after everything common turns out not to work.
1:22:03- Right, and I'm sure there's a similar list
1:22:06of six digit passcodes, just numeric by frequency.
1:22:11And so instead of starting at all zeros,
1:22:14you start at some combination.
1:22:17And I forget what I was using recently.
1:22:20Uh, it wasn't that recent that I'll remember, but something where I had to
1:22:24enter a, create a numeric passcode.
1:22:27Oh, I entered one and it said that one is commonly used and I didn't enter one, two,
1:22:33three, four, and it was something that I didn't really care much about, which is
1:22:38why I don't even know what it was that I guessed, but let's say I just went to the
1:22:42four corners, right?
1:22:44So I did four corners in order or something like that.
1:22:48And it said that one is frequently used.
1:22:49Get, you know, try something else.
1:22:52But anyway, jack Nikas, I'll put this link in the show notes, I just linked to it on
1:22:57during fireball to had a good story, basically describing what we're trying to describe here,
1:23:03which is basically how does this actually work?
1:23:05And and in the context of this law enforcement campaign, does the FBI really need Apple's
1:23:10help?
1:23:13some numbers he got from talking to security researchers and he listed them in his Twitter
1:23:19thread who helped him out to get this story together.
1:23:24Average time it would take to guess different passcodes depending on length, four numbers,
1:23:28seven minutes, six numbers, 11 hours, eight numbers, which I don't think is an option
1:23:33on iPhone 46 days.
1:23:35You could you could do it, but you wouldn't know you have to be alphanumeric.
1:23:39Right?
1:23:40Yeah, right.
1:23:4110 numbers would be 12.5 years. Now if you use alphanumeric pass phrases, a four character
1:23:50alphanumeric passphrase, if you use letters and numbers, seven days, six characters, 72 years,
1:23:58eight characters, 276,000 years. Yeah, mine is like 20 characters. Yes, probably unnecessary.
1:24:06If these numbers are right, that's unnecessary. Here's the thing, the entropy that he's talking
1:24:10about there the the is if you're choosing actual random alpha numeric so if you pick the entire set
1:24:16of eight characters and it's you know capital z lowercase b eight exclamation point mine isn't
1:24:21that i use the um the method that a lot of researchers promote and that you can do in
1:24:25one password now it's the dice where method i have three words that have never appeared together in
1:24:31any work of literature and so they're long enough so each of them is is a not a common word and each
1:24:38of them is easy for me to remember because I remember three things instead of you know
1:24:42eight, eight round things. So I can type it in and so it's critical for me for a passphrase
1:24:47that I can remember it pneumonically because I'm never going to have, I don't have it stored
1:24:51anywhere because it's my passphrase so I have to be able to remember it. I mean I got stored in some
1:24:56some careful ways but anyway so mine is not because it's the amount of entropy isn't high enough
1:25:03mine is probably crackable in oh I don't know a hundred thousand years yeah because it's because
1:25:07it's got real words in it but still good enough maybe a million years good enough
1:25:10well and it's a balance between you know convenience and uh security i mean and it's how much
1:25:19how much do you really care if somebody who had one of these devices could get your phone i mean
1:25:25for an awful lot of people they don't like my like my mom uses just a six digit passcode um
1:25:34uh she probably used four really honestly if somebody got her phone honestly she the only
1:25:43thing she'd be upset about is that she needs a new phone i mean there's literally nothing
1:25:47you know somebody could read all of her email and and she just doesn't care much i mean yeah then
1:25:52the other extreme is like you remember was it two plus years ago that the uh that united arab emirates
1:25:58a human rights activist that somebody burned three separate zero days against it.
1:26:05Yeah, yeah.
1:26:06And you're like, oh my God, the amount of resources a government entity has to throw.
1:26:11So that's one extreme is three zero days all at once versus I don't have my recipe,
1:26:17my favorite recipe for ricotta pudding anymore. You know, like we do have there's a range of
1:26:21security, but like so your mom could use four, but like six is great because six deters anyone
1:26:27casual. There's no system out there that is below. There's no casual forensic or personal cracking
1:26:34system that would allow someone to get your mom's phone. She would have to piss someone off at a
1:26:40federal national security level probably or mass murder level. So that's unless she's planning to
1:26:46do that, which I hope she's not. She's good. But anyway, long story short, if you're listening,
1:26:51and you're paranoid about this, which is reasonable, and just if it bothers you,
1:26:55If you just wake up in the middle of, you know,
1:26:58at three in the morning and it just bothers you thinking
1:27:00about this idea that there are devices out there
1:27:03that they can plug your iPhone into and hit a button
1:27:06and 12 hours later, reveal your passcode.
1:27:09If it just makes you uneasy,
1:27:13switching to the alphanumeric passphrase
1:27:16and even making it, you know, like two words,
1:27:19two words separated by a space or a dash
1:27:23an underscore or something will literally make your data impregnable at the iPhone level. I mean,
1:27:33unless that, you know, they'd have to hit like a greater than the number of subatomic particles
1:27:40in the universe to one shot to get it. Yeah, I mean, quantum computing might put the lie to
1:27:45all this. Well, no, but not with an iOS device, because it's totally no, right. You're totally
1:27:49right. You need so you know, there have been experiments in the past at extracting the
1:27:53secure enclave and try to do things like use electron microscopy, right? Other kinds of
1:27:59things. But but I think even that level, I think Apple is obviously they've got an amazing
1:28:03chip group. They're constantly improving the secure enclave. And it is it is resistant.
1:28:09And when someone develops an attack there, or the theoretical one, they're working on
1:28:12that talking talking to a lot of people on Twitter recently and emailing some readers
1:28:17as I write about this, I and I wasn't certain I think I used to know this better. I'm probably
1:28:22gonna forget it again. If hopefully this whole thing dies down again. The thing you have
1:28:26to remember is that cracking iOS doesn't crack your data at all. You have to get the secure
1:28:33enclave and to to everybody's public knowledge, every public security experts knowledge, the
1:28:40secure enclave on the iPhone has not been cracked and on recent ones that 80
1:28:46millisecond computation time for a guess you could you know your iPhone today
1:28:54could could be found 40 years from now when we have quantum computers that are
1:29:01as much faster today's than today's computers were from 40 years ago with
1:29:09Apollo program, and it still wouldn't help them crack the secure enclave if they still have to go
1:29:16through the secure enclave because that 80 millisecond per guest thing is still there.
1:29:19Now there might be, you know, who knows, there, you know, does the NSA have a crack for the secure
1:29:26enclave? Does does a foreign government have it? We don't know. But to everybody's to everybody's
1:29:33knowledge publicly, that hasn't happened. I think if they have it, if anyone has it,
1:29:38it's a nuclear bomb, right? Because they cannot, they can't deploy it. Because if they deployed it,
1:29:45and it was ever discovered, and it renders it, you know, right, it's it's the end, and then Apple
1:29:52will fix I mean, this is there's always an arms race about this kind of thing. But that was why
1:29:56the three zero day thing I remember it so distinctly, is because once you burn these things
1:30:01are gone forever, and the system gets better. And it's not like there's always gonna be flaws and
1:30:05things, but it's not like they're always going to be the same category of flaw. There's not always
1:30:10gonna be ones that that allow, I mean, at some point, iOS could be effectively impenetrable. I
1:30:17mean, I know that's like saying the Titanic is unsinkable. But But to all intents and purposes,
1:30:21they have figured out enough ways to close down enough avenues that even the most determined
1:30:27government funded whatever cannot find, you know, a really effective way and they only find
1:30:32little things around the edges. That's not infeasible.
1:30:35And you know, the secure enclave is very, very different. And, and
1:30:40if you understand it, even at the layman's layperson's version,
1:30:44the level that I do, it's easy to see how much more defensible
1:30:49it is from Apple's perspective than iOS. Because iOS has
1:30:54lightning input, which also takes USB, which is obviously
1:30:59some part of the jailbreaks that the gray key installed, because
1:31:02what we know about great keys, you plug it in via lightning cable, and it has
1:31:06obviously has networking. So there could be bugs in the networking stack. There
1:31:12was there was an exploit recently somebody wrote about where there was an
1:31:16iMessage exploit, where a carefully crafted URL if tapped in iMessage would
1:31:23exploit it. You know, there's all sorts of vectors like that, because iOS from a
1:31:28Functional level has to take input from so many ways whereas the secure enclave literally is physically connected to the hardware
1:31:35One way, you know, there's there's literally one way in and so there's and there's no other you know, it's like the
1:31:42You know, it's like defending a building with doors and windows and
1:31:49roof access and
1:31:52antennas versus like the underground bunker in
1:31:57you know the Rocky Mountains where there's one door and and a giant Rocky Mountain above it and
1:32:05A you know 20-story elevator going under down underground to get to the you know
1:32:11The secret bunker where the president will live, you know in a nuclear war
1:32:14All right. Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor to our good friends at hover
1:32:19Hey
1:32:21hover is
1:32:23is a jumping off point for a ton of entrepreneurs,
1:32:25and they want you to start your business
1:32:27with a new domain name.
1:32:28They have over 300 domain name extensions,
1:32:31the top level domains.
1:32:33Everybody knows dotcom, dotnet, dot org.
1:32:35They've got over 300 of those to choose from
1:32:38when you wanna build your brand online.
1:32:40No matter what you wanna build,
1:32:41there's a domain name waiting for it.
1:32:42You'll find excellent tech support available
1:32:46to answer any questions you may have.
1:32:47Their support team doesn't upsell you.
1:32:49They only work hard to help you get online.
1:32:52They have free who is privacy protection.
1:32:55Man, the domain name companies that charge you
1:32:59for privacy protection, what a racket.
1:33:01They have a super clean, well-designed user experience
1:33:06and user interface and monthly sales
1:33:09on popular top-level domains.
1:33:10It's hard to see why anybody would go somewhere else.
1:33:15It's such a popular choice for getting a new domain name.
1:33:20One of my favorite features is the guessing.
1:33:23So if you enter your intended domain name,
1:33:26dot whatever, and dot whatever isn't available,
1:33:29they give you a tremendous number of options
1:33:31to get something similar.
1:33:33They offer, like I said before,
1:33:35they offer best in class customer technical support,
1:33:37answer any questions you want.
1:33:39Super good security, like Glenn and I were just talking
1:33:42about all these security things.
1:33:43One of the things you certainly don't wanna have hijacked
1:33:45is a domain name.
1:33:46Hover has you covered on that regard.
1:33:49best in class, locked in.
1:33:52You can make changes when you want to,
1:33:54but nobody else is gonna be able to
1:33:56jimmy their way into your account
1:33:58and steal your domain name.
1:34:00And like I said, over 300 domain name extensions
1:34:04to choose from.
1:34:04So grab your next domain name at hover.com/talkshow.
1:34:09The other thing they offer, let me just say this,
1:34:15The other thing they offer is a tremendous user experience
1:34:19for transferring existing domain names
1:34:21from another registrar.
1:34:23So if you have a registrar, you already have,
1:34:25even if you don't need a new domain name,
1:34:27if you just wanna move your existing domain names
1:34:29from some crummy registrar to the best, which is Hover,
1:34:34they've got you covered on that regard too.
1:34:35Really, really easy.
1:34:36If you're putting it off
1:34:37because you think it's just a huge pain in the butt,
1:34:40don't worry about it.
1:34:41Really, they've got you covered.
1:34:43So go to hover.com/talkshow, get a 10% discount
1:34:47with their referral link.
1:34:49And that's good for all new purchases.
1:34:52Make a name for yourself with Hover.
1:34:55Next on my list was,
1:35:02well, what do you wanna talk about next?
1:35:05Let me ask you.
1:35:06- Would you like to talk about fake faces?
1:35:07I love this topic.
1:35:08- Yeah, let's do this.
1:35:09Let's do this.
1:35:10- Is there going on for a bit?
1:35:11So I wrote about this last year,
1:35:13and I certainly wasn't the first by any means,
1:35:16but I got kinda excited about the topic
1:35:18because it's a little contrarian at one level
1:35:21and now it is blowing up and I'm kind of excited
1:35:26to see people covering it.
1:35:27So I think it's really important.
1:35:28So what it was is Nvidia has a research department,
1:35:31of course, and they're always working on interesting stuff
1:35:33they can do with their super fast GPUs
1:35:36'cause all these graphics companies
1:35:37are selling computational power now
1:35:40to security researchers and other folks
1:35:42and graphics professionals, of course,
1:35:44strangely also graphics professionals and gamers.
1:35:47And they came up with this thing,
1:35:49if I'm remembering it's right, it's called StyleGAN.
1:35:51And GAN is generative adversarial networks,
1:35:56that's what it's called.
1:35:58Okay, so what it is is you pit machine learning algorithms
1:36:02against each other to get closer and closer
1:36:06to a desired outcome.
1:36:08And what they figured out a way to do
1:36:09was to use what they called a style-based generator
1:36:14to use adversarial networks to make fake faces.
1:36:19So you feed in correct human faces in profile,
1:36:23and over time, the algorithm evolved enough
1:36:25and improved enough that they released a version of it
1:36:27and they've improved it since,
1:36:29that makes fake static profile shots
1:36:32that look often exceedingly real.
1:36:35They look just like a real person,
1:36:37and you can dial in characteristics.
1:36:41So I like brown hair, red hair,
1:36:42a different kind of smile or face.
1:36:44So there's not a ton of control, but there is some.
1:36:47And every time you run the algorithm-
1:36:48- What about age? I presume you can-
1:36:50- Yes, to some extent.
1:36:52And you can, I forget if age,
1:36:54no, I think that is a factor.
1:36:55So age and gender, hair color, eye color, glasses,
1:36:59all these things.
1:37:00And the first pass came out in, I wanna say in 2018,
1:37:05and it made a little bit of a stir
1:37:07because the video for it was just outrageous.
1:37:11It kind of like blew people away.
1:37:12They'd done it for one of the big graphics conferences
1:37:16or something and you were like, oh my,
1:37:19and they showed in real time, like not in real time,
1:37:21but they showed the input faces
1:37:22and then all the output faces
1:37:24and they would zoom in and show more faces
1:37:26and it was just like, oh my God.
1:37:28So a lot of the focus in machine learning based generation
1:37:33of material has been around like deepfakes,
1:37:36which are typically looking at video.
1:37:38So you create a video with enough different
1:37:41pictures of somebody or video of somebody
1:37:43and you can merge them with porn
1:37:45or you can make Obama, sorry, Barack Obama
1:37:50say he loves Osama Bin Laden or whatever.
1:37:53And so that is very disturbing
1:37:55because the video can look very realistic
1:37:58and while it can be pretty funky and easy to tell
1:38:00for an informed person now,
1:38:01it's gonna get better and better.
1:38:02But I thought there wasn't enough attention being paid
1:38:05to the still face version because it looks so good already.
1:38:10So what happened is I wrote this piece last year
1:38:13and talked to these researchers
1:38:14at the University of Washington
1:38:15that had built a page you can go to
1:38:17and they made a little test.
1:38:18So they put a real photo next to a generated one
1:38:21and ask you which one is real.
1:38:23And you know, you'd be surprised,
1:38:26you'd run 20 of them through or something
1:38:28and you'd be like, man, I was wrong like 75% of the time.
1:38:32The fake ones look more real than these real ones.
1:38:34So these algorithms continue to improve.
1:38:36And there's a good article recently,
1:38:39there's actually been a series this year already
1:38:41about two aspects of it.
1:38:44One, or I guess three, right?
1:38:46A company is now offering this as a commercial service.
1:38:49So you go to them to get essentially model release free,
1:38:54royalty free images you can use as stock photography.
1:38:58- Right.
1:38:59- So there's no real person,
1:39:00so you don't have to get a release.
1:39:01You can use the picture any way you want.
1:39:03The second is businesses that are then creating these for,
1:39:08or sorry, businesses that are using fake images now
1:39:11from that company and others to populate sites
1:39:14so they look like they're full of real people.
1:39:17And the third is, there was a story just recently
1:39:19about Facebook having, is looking now,
1:39:22that was actually an issue.
1:39:23It used to be that you could reverse image search, right?
1:39:26This ties into another story you're interested in too,
1:39:30but you could reverse image search and find,
1:39:31that fake avatar on Twitter. Oh, that's been used all over the place. 1000 sites. Well, these, they
1:39:36can't reverse image search them, because they're uniquely generated. So Facebook had to remove a
1:39:40bunch of profiles with fake pics. So I'm sort of fascinated by this, because it is so good already,
1:39:46that we are already in the crisis of reality about fake still pictures of people's faces.
1:39:53Yeah, and the one you know, like using them for royalty free
1:40:01stock photography, it I don't know who would be bothered by
1:40:06that other than someone who already owns, you know, a legit
1:40:10stock photography thing. And that's their business. I mean,
1:40:13in terms of morality, that to me strikes me as, you know, fine,
1:40:18like that's using technology to solve a problem. And if you want
1:40:22to create an advertisement that makes it look like there is a 35 year old woman who's very
1:40:30happy with her banking account, you know, for your ad to say sign up for our banks,
1:40:37you know, low interest checking, whatever.
1:40:41Fine, right.
1:40:44But using it to create the illusion of people who don't even don't really exist is really
1:40:51bothersome. And it really plays into the the the the flooding, flooding the zone, to, for lack of a
1:41:00better term, of misinformation in the social network age. You know, to create thousands, tens of
1:41:11thousands, I mean, what's the limit, right? Once you're talking about a computer, you know, it's
1:41:15just like spam, right? Like, imagine if you got as much physical mail as you get spam, I want to talk
1:41:19about spam later but let me just let me literally just take a look here at my
1:41:25junk mailbox my junk mailbox which I go through and empty right now for my email
1:41:30accounts and I have mail set to throw out the old ones on a periodic basis
1:41:35I've got 4,000 pieces of spam I mean just one address alone let me see here
1:41:44from my main address I have 11,000 pieces of spam and it only goes back to
1:41:51December 21 so again because I have mail configured to throw out old month-old
1:41:58spam so in the last month I've gotten eleven hundred and fifty pieces of spam
1:42:03to one address imagine if you got that much junk mail you know it'd be crazy I
1:42:09mean I feel like we get so much junk mail and marketing mail as it is but
1:42:12that's, you know, six, seven pieces a day, you know, it because there's an actual cost
1:42:18to actual postage. You know, once you're talking digital, there's just no price. I mean, there
1:42:23there have been AstroTurf campaigns, it's, you know, for a long time, where you try to
1:42:31create the illusion of more people supporting some political issue or something, then actually
1:42:37exist. But in the digital age, it is just it, it's just another
1:42:47ballpark, you can create thousands and the way that like
1:42:50algorithms work and you know that promote, you know, you all
1:42:54of a sudden you get stuff in your newsfeed on Facebook. And
1:42:58Twitter, you know, does a lot of this now, too. I don't really
1:43:00see stuff that seems fake in my Twitter. And I don't use
1:43:03Facebook. But it's obviously a problem for a lot of people in
1:43:06in terms of pushing a lot of this political propaganda,
1:43:11having an army of fake Facebook accounts is,
1:43:15it's not like a resource problem for Facebook.
1:43:19Facebook isn't trying to get rid of these accounts
1:43:21because it's using up computing power
1:43:24and running up their electricity bill and their storage bill.
1:43:27It's ruining the integrity of their service.
1:43:30And as down on Facebook and as I am,
1:43:36I do you know I
1:43:38And I think there's a lot of ethical problems at that company. I don't I really think that they want their
1:43:46algorithms to be
1:43:48As they intend them to be they don't it's not like they
1:43:55You know they have an interest in not having them be overrun by fake fake accounts
1:44:00right and having a profile picture that is unique is
1:44:04You know something that can be done and you know and I've seen it I've seen it when when
1:44:11Fake accounts have been exposed over the years
1:44:15I don't I can't think of an example off the top of my head that I could put in the show notes
1:44:18but maybe I can find one but I've seen it where people have exposed it and
1:44:21Found that the profile picture is from like a stock photography service
1:44:26You know, yeah, this this is what led me to this article is I was interested in the topic
1:44:30But I thought I'd been well covered and then some folks in the Bitcoin world
1:44:34said they were being contacted by somebody who said she was a journalist and
1:44:38They looked at the profile photo. There were very little traces of who she was they
1:44:44Could not and she was contacting people privately and everyone was getting a little nervous
1:44:49Was she pulling a scam was she working for some, you know exchange or whatever and they discovered someone's like, you know
1:44:55this is a fake photo because look at these and they enlarged it like look at these characteristics. This was generated by the StyleGAN
1:45:01software and it almost certainly was because there's some if in the older the first version there was some artifacting there's some
1:45:09techniques you could tell but you couldn't reverse image
1:45:12reverse image search it because that's such an easy way to tell initially and if it doesn't work you're like well
1:45:19this is probably a legitimate photo that someone posted like no now you can't do that what the scientists at the
1:45:25or academics at University of Washington told me,
1:45:28they said there's two actually really easy tells.
1:45:31And this, I thought this was brilliant
1:45:33and it will change over time.
1:45:34The fake generated faces, you will never,
1:45:37the current states of the algorithms,
1:45:39and this may continue indefinitely
1:45:42because of how the faces are generated,
1:45:44they can only produce that face once.
1:45:46So you can use the same inputs
1:45:47and produce exactly the same face a second time,
1:45:50but you can't produce other versions of that face
1:45:53in different scenarios.
1:45:54So you can't, if you want to say,
1:45:57send me your left profile,
1:45:58'cause I'm seeing your right profile,
1:45:59they can't, they can't,
1:46:01they're typically not yet in scenes.
1:46:03So you're not standing with a background
1:46:06in some kind of environment, you can't hold up,
1:46:08I mean, you could hold up today's paper,
1:46:09but you know, that kind of thing.
1:46:11Actually, what was hilarious about this research too,
1:46:13is they've shown examples of taking like shots from Ikea
1:46:17of rooms full of furniture, and they can train them.
1:46:21It just produces random rooms full of very realistic looking sets of furniture that don't
1:46:27exist.
1:46:28And it is, you can run these algorithms online and you're just looking through it and it
1:46:31is, there's something so weird about seeing the real world.
1:46:35Like faces are bad, but the real world being like your objects of material possessions
1:46:39being generated algorithmically from other photos is, is like beyond surreal.
1:46:45It's, you know, and it's, you know, it's one of my big fears as we go forward.
1:46:55And one of the things that I feel like we're already inundated with misinformation.
1:47:01And one of the things that makes me so pessimistic, honestly, about democracy, you know, going
1:47:08forward.
1:47:09I don't mean to be overdramatic, but it's a big frustration for my wife in particular
1:47:16that when video of some scandalous thing comes out, that it resonates so much more than just
1:47:31somebody's, you know, what should, what ought to be taken equally is proof of it.
1:47:37And one example that comes to mind would be the, the Access Hollywood Trump tape that dropped a
1:47:47month before the election four years ago. You know, this is the famous tape where Trump is
1:47:53saying that, you know, when you're famous, you can do whatever you want. You can grab them by the pussy.
1:47:58And that tape came out.
1:48:06And you know, again, and some people will say, well, who cares?
1:48:08He won anyway, but it hurt him.
1:48:10It hurt him severely at the, you know, in, you know, polling, you know, if that tape
1:48:16had never come out, he would have won by more, most likely maybe, you know, maybe half a
1:48:21percent who knows, but these elections have been so close that a half a percent in a few
1:48:25states makes a huge difference, right?
1:48:27the tape matters. And my wife was so angry, not after the election, but after
1:48:33that tape dropped when this became this huge, huge news cycle consuming scandal
1:48:41that's, you know, and had people saying, "Oh my god, this is so bad he needs to
1:48:45drop out of the race." And my wife's response, her anger was, "There is
1:48:49absolutely nothing on that tape that we did not know for a fact about Donald
1:48:54Trump and the way he behaves around women and the way he thinks about them.
1:48:59And, and, you know, there were dozens and dozens of stories of exactly the
1:49:03same sort of thing from over the years, from decades ago.
1:49:06And so it anger and I, my take is you just don't understand the psychological
1:49:12effect that like a video tape has, you know, and, and there are so many stories,
1:49:17you know, it, it's a huge trend of the last decade for the better, you know,
1:49:21it's for lack of a better catch-all phrase the whole me to movement but just
1:49:26the the whole holding accountable men mostly but anybody behaving either
1:49:36inappropriately or even worse illegally mm-hmm but it's when tapes come out and
1:49:45I say tape you know videos but you know some celebrity who comes out and there's
1:49:49something caught on tape it is so much worse there was oh man what's his name
1:49:57Ray Lewis was a football player Oh No Ray Rice it's oh oh wait Ray Lewis was
1:50:04the murderer right alright well we can leave this in Caleb alright I just want
1:50:10to get at least I'm not maligning someone Ray Lewis was Ray Rice was the
1:50:18running back for the Ravens and he, you know, assaulted his wife badly. And, you know, there
1:50:26were there were, you know, it was going to be repercussions. And but then all of a sudden,
1:50:30somebody happened at a hotel, somebody in an elevator and somebody who worked at the hotel,
1:50:35that the elevator had a security cameras, you know, no surprise, and they leaked the tape.
1:50:41And the tape showed him more or less cold cocking his wife or his fiance, I guess.
1:50:47Yeah, I remember that video. I was absolutely horrific. I honestly, if you don't have the
1:50:53stomach for it, don't even look it up. It is truly a horrific video. I mean, it's a
1:50:58professional football player in the prime of his athleticism, just hitting a woman as hard as he
1:51:05can. And just, I mean, she just falls like a sack of potatoes. But it was only when the video came
1:51:11out that he really suffered the consequences he should have, whereas it should have been evident
1:51:16to anybody paying attention that he was guilty. There was no need for a video, there shouldn't
1:51:23have been a need for a videotape for him to be suspended forever.
1:51:26But we're seeing this exactly, this is exactly what's going on with the impeachment process
1:51:31right now, is that there is 100,000 pieces of circumstantial evidence right now that
1:51:38absolutely paint the picture that Trump was directing, you know, with the withholding of
1:51:44aid from Ukraine, and so forth. And actually, at this point, what's I mean, there's no there's no
1:51:48direct thing of Trump sending an email, or a horribly Sharpie written note or, excuse me,
1:51:53or audio or whatever of him saying, we need to get the Biden's let's withhold aid, we're going to
1:51:58pressure Ukraine, but it is absolutely painted. But, you know, would it make a difference not to
1:52:05anybody who has a staked out political opinion that Trump can do no wrong, or that he's being
1:52:11being railroaded by the deep state. However, the thing that's interesting, the only difference
1:52:15here is that weirdly, his party has mostly decided to say, well, okay, that's what happened,
1:52:21but it's not actually impeachable. It's not illegal. And that's strange. Usually you need
1:52:25video to get to that part. But I think the amount of circumstantial evidence finally
1:52:29crossed what is usually a video or even audio tape threshold. Because I know I totally agree
1:52:35with you is people will see something comes to your eyes in a very different way than
1:52:40Even still photos, right? So on the one hand, you know when a tape does so it's not right in an ethical or logical
1:52:47Sense that that that the repercussions are worse when Ray Rice has tape
1:52:52Cold-cocking his wife when he actually should have been proven guilty otherwise, but at least when the tape came out the right thing happened
1:52:59We in the world where these deep fake videos are easily produced and are indistinguishable
1:53:09from a
1:53:11legit video I
1:53:13Worried that we lose that and then of course the flip side is it's easy to create a fake one, right?
1:53:17It's easy to create one where some political candidate is is there on tape?
1:53:23Looking looking like it's the security camera from an elevator and they think they're in private
1:53:29So that's you know would explain why they're caught talking on tape and you say hey, here's somebody from the you know
1:53:35the Hilton in
1:53:37you know somewhere and they released this tape to us and it shows a
1:53:41Presidential candidate talking about taking bribes from China or something like that
1:53:46Well, and there's the tape and it's completely freight
1:53:48You know the Nancy Pelosi one that happened where it showed her as if she were, you know, it slowed it down, right?
1:53:53It made it teach. Yeah, it made it seem like she was drunk, you know, yeah and Facebook
1:53:58I think wouldn't take that down
1:53:59They didn't refuse to take it down ultimately because it wasn't altered in a way that they considered substantive
1:54:04Although it was obvious. Right. I thought they I thought they did take it down eventually
1:54:08Could you use it in your as a politically political ads where you could include it and it wasn't well done it really
1:54:15What they're there, you know
1:54:17You could it was funny as a gag if it had been presented as a gag in the in the same way
1:54:23Like I'm sure you did
1:54:25Did the same thing?
1:54:26Like when we were kids you would take a tape recorder and record your voice and if it certain tape recorders would let you play
1:54:33it back slower, slower or faster. And then all of a sudden, you sounded like a chipmunk
1:54:38or you sounded, you know, like, we're talking like this. And we would, you know, as a kid,
1:54:44I would play for hours with that. It was it was the craziest thing in the world. We loved
1:54:48it, but it wasn't. It didn't really sound realistic. The Nancy Pelosi thing was better
1:54:53than that. But it anybody who, you know, got sucked into thinking it was real was seeing
1:54:58what they wanted to believe or was naive. But enough people thought it was real. And the people
1:55:04who made it didn't make it as a gag. They made it as propaganda. And it caught fire enough, you know,
1:55:12and it was really poorly done. You know, it's so easy to imagine a much better done version.
1:55:19I remember I had this great conversation. This is like 95. Like this long time ago,
1:55:27I was at some conference and we had the, oh, I think it was an early like web design conference that I was working on.
1:55:33And we had the webmaster for Netscape, that'll take you back, who attended, who was a super nice guy.
1:55:39I'm blanking on his name. Super nice guy. Great things to say.
1:55:41And I was chatting with him at some point and he said, you know, we're so obsessed with video and we keep thinking about like, when can we stream videos?
1:55:48Like 95, right? So when can we stream video that's big enough that people will accept it and like it and whatever.
1:55:55And he said, and then I was on this panel with somebody from Penthouse, and they said,
1:55:58you know, we can stream like 240 by 320 at five frames per second in grayscale.
1:56:04Our audience is delighted.
1:56:05And he said, I had to really rethink like that.
1:56:09And I was thinking of that with the Pelosi thing where it's like, you know, we could
1:56:13be, we're in an era of, of real, of deep fakes and they could create, you know, incredible
1:56:18simulation that could show Hillary Clinton shooting Vince Foster or something horrific.
1:56:23Right.
1:56:24They'll probably do that whoever the leading Democratic candidate is and probably Republican
1:56:27Trump they'll probably be
1:56:30Concocted videos because they're so easy to do as we get into the the general election
1:56:33But I was like wow at some level all you need is the fidelity of that like streaming porn
1:56:38You need the Nancy Pelosi where they just slowed it down and people like oh my god. She must really be drunk like no
1:56:44No, how do we get people to have more credibility? But at the same time I think you're absolutely right that video
1:56:49Conveys a kind of truth
1:56:52that
1:56:53bypass is normal
1:56:55You know cognitive processes
1:56:57And I really really think I think I see it it is going to be a huge problem
1:57:03I am certain of it. I I just cannot I don't know what the repercussions are gonna be I mean I
1:57:11Think the ultimate I think the old the best case scenario is that?
1:57:16video and audio
1:57:19Proof of X no longer holds the cache a it'll take years though for that to happen and that people
1:57:27People will start to treat with equal skepticism
1:57:30video of you know a political candidate
1:57:34drunkly groping somebody in an elevator the same way they would if somebody just said and
1:57:41Was quoted as saying hey this this this person
1:57:46drunkly groped somebody in an elevator, right, that the video doesn't give it any more credibility
1:57:51than the quote, and that you have to trust the source, right? It gets back to, you know,
1:57:57the older days where you've really got to build trusted sources. And, you know, Joe Random Twitter
1:58:03account or Jane Random Facebook doesn't count. And that we that's, that's the optimistic view.
1:58:09The pessimistic view is that everybody believes the worst of everything and nobody believes
1:58:14anything. And nobody trusts anything. How's that for a
1:58:18lighthearted take?
1:58:20Can I segue us into the what it feels like is you put this on
1:58:25the list of story topics. I was like, this is like exactly the
1:58:29perfect complement to this. Yes, yes. Talking about which is,
1:58:33well, the Facebook or the face ID, the secretive company that
1:58:38might end privacy as we know it, which is a great headline and
1:58:41Kashmir Hill is a incredible reporter. She's now worked across. I can't think how many public a modern era
1:58:48so journalists as
1:58:49As a side note just a parenthetical to tie in the last time friend of the show Dan Fromer was on this show Dan
1:58:57pointed out that
1:58:59because he's doing his own thing now with the
1:59:02New consumer, I believe it's called. Yeah, sorry. Sorry Dan, but I think it's a new consumer, which is awesome
1:59:09And it's he's doing his own thing, but that his observation was that
1:59:13The trend towards journalists and writer types and pundit types like me
1:59:19Doing their own thing has sort of gone the other way and the New York Times and Bloomberg and a few other top and and maybe
1:59:26The Washington Post would throw in are sucking in all the good talent. I
1:59:31Would absolutely put Kashmir Hill in that list. I think her most recent thing that I remember reading was at gizmodo
1:59:39where she agrees. I think she had done a I forget what it was. But she's a series where
1:59:45she did the like, I'm gonna get off Facebook. Yes, I'm gonna get I'm gonna I'm gonna stop
1:59:49using all of the big five tech company products. Yeah. And what was that like? And it was like
1:59:53she was living in a desert. Right? It was amazing. What happens? What happens if you
1:59:58don't use Google, Amazon, Facebook? I forget if Apple was on the list or not. I mean, rotation,
2:00:04but it was yeah, she's worked across I was looking at her because she's worked across
2:00:07several publications, all her pieces are must reads. She does incredible I mean, so she does those like, I would say like almost consumer style investigations, like what are the companies learning about us? And how do we extract ourselves then she does the others, which are like, what happens when you know, if I put myself in this situation, what do companies find out about me? Yeah. And that's sort of a little bit of what this this is a little, I think, a mix of that. We all need so I have been saying and I don't want to like, I don't want to put myself up because I'm not saying things
2:00:37anyone else hasn't said. But a few years ago, when I started seeing the effectiveness of AI-based
2:00:42transcription in its early stages, so I've been using TRNT, which is a very, was very inexpensive,
2:00:48they just switched to a more expensive, well, a cheaper but subscription model that is more
2:00:52expensive for ad hoc use, like I used it. And it was pretty good when it started, it's gotten better.
2:00:57And it's it's not as good as, you know, paid transcription services with people who are, you
2:01:01know, professionals and looking at everything, but it's very good for AI-based stuff. And then there
2:01:07there were some people throwing together some podcasts, like cheap and dirty, AI based or
2:01:12language learning, podcast transcription stuff. And I was like, wow, this is totally amazing.
2:01:18And I knew voice recognition, of course, with Siri, and Google Assistant, all these other
2:01:22things had gotten really good, right? So I'm aware of that. And then when I started seeing
2:01:26the really cheap bad stuff, I had that innovators dilemma feeling where you're like, oh, yeah,
2:01:31this is where you see something really bad and really cheap. And it eats a bottom of
2:01:35market but then it gets better and it eats from the bottom up. And I thought oh here's the point
2:01:39at which so maybe I don't know three or four years ago I started tweeting at some point everything
2:01:45every picture of you that's available publicly online every piece of audio in which you speak
2:01:50every video in which you appear will be categorized and labeled with you and someone will be able to
2:01:56search and find every instance of you in any public source that you have ever posted and it's
2:02:01just a matter of time. It's not a when or if it's a when and over
2:02:05time that's become closer and closer. And this story is
2:02:09basically we're now over that bar. We're now in the next
2:02:11level. It is now a thing. It's still images, but we're moving
2:02:15your video is the next right, but that there's so there's a
2:02:18startup I've never heard of, to be true, Clearview AI, and they
2:02:23have apparently they have apparently tried to index every
2:02:27publicly available photo that they can find on the internet.
2:02:31I guess billions. I don't even know if I think they're saying three three billion three billion images that yeah
2:02:37That's what the company claims that they've scraped from Facebook YouTube
2:02:40Venmo millions of other websites Flickr, I'm sure you know if you're talking about three billion you know mm-hmm
2:02:49and so you take a photo of somebody you have no idea who they are and you throw it at
2:02:56Clearview and Clearview comes back and says here's who it is and
2:03:00and that it's fast and that they have hooks
2:03:03for augmented reality already.
2:03:06So in theory, you could get the,
2:03:08somebody showed Terminator,
2:03:11I'm sure it's been in a bunch of movies,
2:03:13but the idea that you could be wearing
2:03:15some kind of AR goggles or glasses
2:03:17and as you walk down the street,
2:03:18I mean, depending on how fast it is,
2:03:20but we know how fast Google search has gotten
2:03:22for searching the index,
2:03:23but that you can just look at somebody on the sidewalk
2:03:26and they'll know who you are.
2:03:30You could certainly imagine, absolutely imagine how of interest this would be to retailers
2:03:35because as you enter a physical retail shop, there's certainly it's easy to capture a photo
2:03:39of the people who are coming in.
2:03:41Most of them already have cameras for security purposes meanwhile.
2:03:46And you could go into a store of any, you know, pick your type of bookstore or whatever.
2:03:52And I mean, a bookstore is probably a bad example.
2:03:55But you know, some sort of store where you get greeted by a salesperson.
2:04:00say a jewelry store or something like that. And they could already know, you know, and
2:04:04get like some kind of estimate as to, you know, well, does this person, you know, maybe
2:04:09is, you know, get a guess as to how much money you make or something like that and start
2:04:14steering you in a direction that you know, and you have no idea that they've done this
2:04:19and that the salesperson already knows something about you. I mean, there's just all sorts
2:04:24of ways that this can go bad.
2:04:26Yeah, there's already so many ways that's happening.
2:04:29And it defeats human nature's instinct that as you're walking down the street that you're
2:04:33anonymous, you know.
2:04:36That the only people who recognize you are the people who know you.
2:04:39Well, this ties in a little bit with, I saw, I forget if he's a security researcher or
2:04:44not, somebody tweeting about, I've got a call, I was just thinking about going out to get
2:04:48cold medicine and Facebook or Google just showed me cold medicine ads and I hadn't been
2:04:52searching on it.
2:04:53And I'd read recently, you know, the there's a myth that Facebook is analyzing audio all the time when you're running the app or in the background.
2:04:59And, you know, I don't want to put anything past Facebook, but I don't have the app installed on my phone.
2:05:05And I was off chatting with someone at a cocktail party.
2:05:09I met someone who knew a late friend of mine.
2:05:11I talked about this person for years.
2:05:12We talked about her, about how much we missed her.
2:05:14I come home, I open up Facebook and there is an ad for her former business.
2:05:18And I'm like, what in God's name?
2:05:20So I know it wasn't listening to me.
2:05:22Right.
2:05:22And I know it wasn't fed that way. The explanation that I read recently, and I think this wasn't Kashmir Hall, it was someone it was a another New York Times reporter, Claire, I'm blanking on her name, they'll come to me, but she wrote a piece, a co-wrote piece recently, in which to describe that because of all this location information that's being gathered, it doesn't matter. They don't have to listen to you. They know that you just walked to the store, and what you bought at checkout and came home, because they can gather from your app.
2:05:52all your location information, they can associate the
2:05:55purchasing with your unique phone. And even if you don't do
2:05:58it, if 10 people in your apartment building have just
2:05:59gone and bought cold medicine, and come back, they're like,
2:06:02"Oh, there's a bunch of colds in that building, we're going to
2:06:04show him cold medicine ads." And I was like, "Oh, that makes
2:06:08total sense. They've got complete surveillance on us." So
2:06:10of course, they don't have to know that I have a cold. They
2:06:14know that a lot of people around me have bought cold medicine and
2:06:16come back to the same location.
2:06:18Ah, and people are so paranoid about it, too, because people do
2:06:21pattern matching. And rightly so people are so paranoid about
2:06:25this, like my phone is always listening to me and then does
2:06:28things that it could only know if it was listening to me. I was
2:06:33at a big family gathering somebody had a birthday over the
2:06:37weekend. We were a big family gathering over the weekend. And
2:06:43one of Amy's aunts asked me, we I forget how we got talking
2:06:49about iPhones, but you know, they know what I do. And they
2:06:52don't typically I certainly don't talk Apple stuff to them.
2:06:55But if they have questions, you know, they asked me, you know,
2:06:57and she said to me, let me ask you this. And it was about this
2:07:03topic of the phone listening, and she has an iPhone. And she
2:07:07said that the one day at work, her and her friends were Oh, it
2:07:13got to the point it was somebody else brought up the fact that
2:07:16they have the feature on where the his his commute his schedule
2:07:22is very rigid. He does, you know, takes his kids to school
2:07:24and then goes to work. And it says and he's just amazed by the
2:07:27fact that he gets in and says, Hey, it'll take 17 minutes to
2:07:30drive your kid to school. And he goes, Damn it, if it doesn't
2:07:33take 17 minutes, and then it says it's gonna take you 23
2:07:36minutes to get to work. And 23 minutes later, he's pulling into
2:07:39work. And he's like, it's awesome, but it's a little
2:07:42spooky. And then Amy's aunt said, Well, let me ask you this
2:07:46that one day at work her and she works with a bunch of other
2:07:49women, she said they were just really having a good time and
2:07:51just not like that they were doing something that they get in
2:07:56trouble for, but they were I don't know, laughing and
2:07:59laughing and they got just got off, you know, just goofing
2:08:01around at the end of the day at work, and really, really having
2:08:05a good time laughing. And then she leaves to go home and her
2:08:08iPhone gave randomly gave her said directions to like, the
2:08:15local comedy club in town. And she said, and I've never been
2:08:20there. I've never gone there in my life. I didn't ask for
2:08:22directions there. And it just said, it'll take you, you know,
2:08:2518 minutes to drive to the Comedy Store in whatever
2:08:28Pennsylvania. And she got freaked out that it was because
2:08:33her and her colleagues had been laughing it up the last half
2:08:36hour at work. And I was like, that's really weird that it
2:08:40would offer you directions there that you've never never even
2:08:43been there. But that that's not how it happened. It wasn't
2:08:45because you and your friends were laughing. But, but I, I
2:08:51don't blame her. She's obviously she's not a technical person at
2:08:54all. She knows these stories. She's probably seen other spooky
2:08:57things happen where you do x, y and z and then all of a sudden,
2:09:01Facebook or whoever is, you know, showing you ads or giving
2:09:04you suggestions for something that they seemingly would have to know. You know,
2:09:09that's obviously not what happened. But it's totally natural that as a human
2:09:15being, you would draw those two together, right? Like that's the way human beings
2:09:19minds work. Anyway,
2:09:21well, but I think it fits it fits into that possibility, too, is that it actually
2:09:25could be that when you have a bunch of people together, and you're staying late,
2:09:29and people are searching for certain things on their phones, right, the
2:09:33algorithm of whatever provides this kind of stuff says hey, there's a bunch of people here's a thing, you know, these kinds of connections are
2:09:39What's what's scary actually is how?
2:09:42Predictable we are rather than that. It's listening to us
2:09:46Hey shocker among shockers
2:09:48Guess who's one of the bad financial backers of this Clearview company that is already working with law enforcement, by the way
2:09:54That's who their customers are at this point with this reverse image
2:09:57I knew this before I read this story when it said I read the paragraph that said
2:10:01Investors included and I was like Peter Thiel, right?
2:10:04Shocker among shockers, but anyway an unknown number of law enforcement agencies are already using this
2:10:13I don't know what there is that we can do about it
2:10:16And then that ties into another story that I just ran into the other day where Nelson Minar
2:10:21Who's been blogging forever?
2:10:24great person
2:10:27Brought up that this search engine I have never heard of
2:10:31called, oh, Yandex. Yeah, yeah. Yandex. Yandex is a Russian, it's a search engine in Russia.
2:10:41And in fact, there's just a story also about them because they're apparently do not engage
2:10:47in the same behavior, or the same restrictions that other search engines do globally around
2:10:52child pornography. And it's become a huge issue. Just a big story about that a few days ago. Well,
2:10:57Well, one of the things what Nelson showed was that they do reverse image search on faces,
2:11:04which is something that Google has claimed for years could do and that they chose not to
2:11:10because of the obvious privacy implications.
2:11:13And Nelson's blog post, I'll put it in the show notes, he took a picture of himself.
2:11:19It works best if you take what I would just offhand, I think everybody will know what I mean.
2:11:26Take like a fake ID picture, like the type of picture that you would take of yourself
2:11:31if you were going to submit your own new picture for a driver's license or a passport, you know,
2:11:35mostly your head, a blank background, that type of selfie. Take one of those, submit it as just,
2:11:44you know, put it on your computer and then go to their image search. And it says there's like a
2:11:48camera button for like, hey, do you want to, you know, start and instead of searching for words,
2:11:52search based on a starting image. Click that button, upload your selfie, and his came back
2:12:00with, I don't know, it's like they give you like 12 results, but like the first the first two or
2:12:05three were definitely him. Yeah. And the other people did look like him. I tried it with one.
2:12:09I showed you the screenshot. I have to I guess I'll put the screenshot in the show notes if I can.
2:12:14I don't think there's anything revealing. It's pretty good. They're thinking the top four
2:12:20Pictures were from I think my iPhone review from two years ago
2:12:25I think it was two years ago where I included some pictures of me that my wife had taken with portrait mode of the
2:12:32iPhone camera so but if you had that picture of me that you started that I started with and had no idea who I was
2:12:39But just had that picture if you sent it to Yandex
2:12:42it the first four or five results and most of the
2:12:47First eight are me and then you could click through to the origin and figure out okay, that's John Gruber
2:12:53The cool thing though is you can see what you'd look like with a lot of different mustaches
2:12:57The ones that are wrong are close enough not not like that you would think is that John Gruber
2:13:10but they certainly you know, you could see why a
2:13:13Distant family resembling well or at least show me people who look like this guy, but it is absolutely
2:13:19Whoa, eye-opening. I have never seen this before I can send a totally anonymous photo to this site and half a half a second later
2:13:28Find out that it's John Gruber
2:13:31Yeah, I did now tested a couple for myself and it's not as great but it did find oh
2:13:36I don't know like six or seven different ones for two different shots or any are any of them you
2:13:42Yeah, they're on me. I'm sorry. It found a bunch and found six seven that were me. Oh, okay. Yeah, so
2:13:48Somebody who started with your starting point would definitely figure out that's Glenn Fleishman. Oh, yeah
2:13:53I mean in one case, I mean you're saying that you're saying that the misses weren't as
2:13:57Glenn Fleishman II they were I mean, that's a good way to find relatives like
2:14:03They're actually a reasonable I would say in a dark room you might think
2:14:11No, it was very it's very funny
2:14:13Yeah, because I've been using reverse image source for a long time and I never thought about
2:14:19I never thought about the fact that was actually relatively difficult to do a full image, you know
2:14:25and of course it was actually by intent so
2:14:27Well, it's a real eye-opener and I don't know what we can do
2:14:31I mean this seems like this is toothpaste that can't go back in the tube, you know, it's a genie that's out of the bottle
2:14:36I mean, we're not gonna what are we gonna do and and and is this going does?
2:14:41Anybody else outside of Yandex who's been sitting on this out of fear, you know that they don't want to be the first
2:14:50Because of the backlash that might happen
2:14:52You know
2:14:55Once this sort of thing is out. It's open game
2:14:57You know how long now until Google it flips the switch that turns it on and how much how much better will Google's version be?
2:15:04Although I would actually argue I am not usually
2:15:08Let's say how do you say this? It's like it's not that I'm opposed to regulation or necessarily in favor of it
2:15:13And I think there's a lot of things that regulation can't handle like I love regulation as a tool
2:15:18To make things fairer and level the playing field when money or power distort things, right?
2:15:24So, I mean, that's a I don't know where that falls on the political spectrum
2:15:28But like I don't think that you know, there's all this talk about like, you know
2:15:31What kind of regulation should you put on tech companies? Obviously, there should be
2:15:36Some more and different than is now but not necessarily the kind that Congress wants to do but with this particular thing
2:15:42I actually think because
2:15:44the greatest value of it is going to be in industries that are
2:15:48working in the US and then of all US companies that regulating this as
2:15:53Making it illegal for police departments to rely or law enforcement officers to rely on these kinds of databases
2:16:00And to make it illegal to sell it as a service or to strictly regulate it in some fashion
2:16:04I think it might have an impact because even though the toothpaste that are the tube and you can go to Yandex or other international sites
2:16:10potentially and do the same thing
2:16:12it could not be used legally like if a police officer uses it as the basis or
2:16:16should say one of the bases of attain a
2:16:18Warrant as is discussed in the story that it can't be the sole basis to go to a judge
2:16:23Then if that's illegal then the case, you know
2:16:25and it's determined the case gets thrown out or a judge refuses to accept it because of the rules of
2:16:31issuing warrants, or Google being told, you know, maybe they
2:16:35would want to get in the business, and then are trying to
2:16:38comply with the law and wouldn't or this company that's in the
2:16:41article might be forced to not offer it services anymore. So I
2:16:45think regulation might be a tool to, you know, like, you can't
2:16:51put the toothpaste back in, but you can make the toothpaste not
2:16:54as valuable to sell basically.
2:16:56All right. How are we doing on time? We have time for one more
2:17:00More segment on email spam and then we're out.
2:17:02Oh, I have just a real time correction really quickly is the author I was thinking of at
2:17:06the New York Times is Claire Kane Miller, who is a very fine reporter, although she's
2:17:10moved on from technology reporting.
2:17:12The person I actually met was Nicole Pearl Roth, another excellent security reporter
2:17:16in the New York Times, which they seem to have a ton.
2:17:19But the story I think everyone should read, and we don't have to cover this, you may have
2:17:23talked about this too, is it's the one nation tract that was actually produced by the New
2:17:28York Times opinion section as a reported piece. And that's the
2:17:32one that actually had the whole thing about following people and
2:17:35associating purchases and locations. That's by Stuart
2:17:38Thompson and Charlie Worzel, who's also fine people. They
2:17:41have a great, great venture people there. So anyway, that's
2:17:44just my correction.
2:17:45You know, that was a good story. I did I linked to that the One
2:17:49Nation Tract, we don't have to go into it in depth. That was
2:17:51where they were talking about these shadowy companies that
2:17:53collect location data that they obtain through means we're not can't really be sure of, but
2:18:00I think it's most I think it's mostly through frameworks that third party apps include in
2:18:06in the app. That's Yeah, exactly. And then the app asks you, like, let's say it's a weather
2:18:11app. And the weather app says, Can Can we have your location data to show you the weather?
2:18:16And you say yes, because that makes sense. And then they also include this framework
2:18:21to a location collection company and the framework takes your data in a unique identifier of
2:18:30some sort and tracks your data as you go about.
2:18:36And then they correlate it to purchases or something else about you and they can build
2:18:40a profile that shows here's a person who bounces between Brooklyn and Manhattan and the hours
2:18:46show clearly show that you live in Brooklyn and you work in lower Manhattan. And here's
2:18:52where you go and all this creepy stuff. Here's here's somebody going to a building that isn't
2:18:56associated with the CIA, right? But they seem to be traveling overseas and then going between,
2:19:01you know, they track police officers, law enforcement, and they identified a celebrity
2:19:07based on a date they found like, like a concert where they're, you know, a date and a time
2:19:12in a location of the concert and a phone that was going to a hotel and then they forget who the artist was, but they contacted her, you know, and asked for her permission. And she's, you know, she gave them an on the record interview and said, Yeah, that's definitely me, you know, that that was me, that was where I was staying. That was my concert. That's creepy AF.
2:19:32So, so your Apple put that new feature and it says for location it says
2:19:36Used to be that an app could request permanent permission within the app right now
2:19:41You cannot and the reason is this is obviously this I wondered why Apple had tighten the screws and apparently all the ad networks and and
2:19:49ad advertising companies at software companies are
2:19:53Peaved about this because it reduces their ability to do targeted ads and make nearly as much money I gather
2:19:58But this is exactly why so, you know, why does a weather app do you know my location all the time?
2:20:03I'll let it use it now, but you have to go into
2:20:05privacy settings in iOS and iPad OS
2:20:08To change that people to make it permanent that people get indignant when they were able to make money doing X
2:20:16And then they're no longer to make money doing X they get peeved and in and not just peeved
2:20:24Because you know you get peeved if you made money doing X for any reason and no longer can make the money
2:20:29But they they get indignant about it and feel as though
2:20:32They have been wronged
2:20:35In a way that if X had never been allowed they wouldn't feel
2:20:40wronged and so I wasn't gonna go off on this topic, but
2:20:45There was congressional testimony this week and the people at tile
2:20:52Testified against Apple it was a and it was a congressional investigation into is are the major major
2:20:58You know, it's this I guess probably the big five
2:21:00Facebook Amazon Apple Google
2:21:03Who am I missing?
2:21:06Mac Microsoft
2:21:09Are they how are they are abusing their?
2:21:11Size and and you know in anti-competitive ways and tile testified that Apple had had
2:21:20competitively moved against them by
2:21:22including the find my find my feature in iPhones because now it makes its building in the ability to find your lost phones
2:21:30So you don't need to use a tile product to do it, which to me seems like a nonsense argument
2:21:36Not not nonsense
2:21:38But it just seems like barking up the wrong tree like that's a great feature and you really can't argue that you should have to
2:21:43Buy a third-party physical object to get it to be fair and they're already
2:21:50preemptively complaining about Apple's supposed tile tracker
2:21:54Dinguses that have been rumored for a year, but haven't even been announced and yet they're already complaining to Congress that they're you know
2:22:03It's anti-competitive for them to build it into the system
2:22:06and you know and
2:22:09complaints from other people specifically about the thing you just said that iOS 13
2:22:15Removed the ability for an app to ask you to grant it always on
2:22:20Location tracking even though the feature is still there. You just have to go to the settings app
2:22:26Privacy location and then find the app and there you could say if if the app does want always on
2:22:34location tracking
2:22:36There's where you can grant it and I do think that the app is allowed to have a shortcut that jumps you there
2:22:43Like that's for sure because I know I've tapped those and it's right in the right spot
2:22:47But it does you do have to jump out of the app into the settings app to do it
2:22:51And so I think the fact that it's more than just telling you
2:22:56Instructions for how to get four levels deep into the setting or three levels
2:23:01Whatever it is into the settings app to do it the fact that they let you
2:23:05Tap a button to jump you there to grant it
2:23:08I think it's a reasonable compromise in my opinion for what is what has turned out to be a very severely
2:23:16privacy invasive feature
2:23:18And then the other thing that I think that they are very annoyed about is the new feature in iOS
2:23:24I don't think they mentioned it because I don't think there's any way
2:23:27I don't think there's any way they can mention it without them looking bad
2:23:31Like like the angle that people always take against Apple and sometimes it's true, right?
2:23:36Like there absolutely there are good anti-competitive arguments against Apple and a lot of them. I think the biggest is the the
2:23:43insistence upon taking 30 to 15 percent of App Store
2:23:49Transactions and that that an app like an e-book reader
2:23:53I mean, I did, you know pity poor Mike Amazon with Kindle
2:23:57But like the fact that the Kindle app can't just have a button that jumps you to
2:24:02Safari to buy your Kindle books in Safari. You can't even have that button in your apps is to me
2:24:09anti-competitive and I really think that that's the sort of thing the government could really you know
2:24:13Make some change, you know force Apple to bend on because I don't think it's right
2:24:17I think it is anti-competitive and you can't even mention it. You can't even have a thing in your app that says go to oh
2:24:24You know my content store or like the you know net again
2:24:29Netflix is a huge company with billions in revenue, but Netflix can't even tell you go to Netflix.com
2:24:34To sign up for Netflix. They let alone making it a hotlink
2:24:38I uploaded an e-book to the Apple bookstore a few years ago the magazine that I ran the magazine Marco the one I bought for
2:24:45Marco, I did a complete archive of the entire run of it
2:24:49Uploaded as a book Apple's fine selling it, you know, not that many copies
2:24:53But it was just want to make sure it was out there and then I get this thing
2:24:56It's like we have rejected your book and you mean to make this change and the change was
2:24:59there was one embedded link to an Amazon item in a 1200 page ebook.
2:25:07That's crazy. So I think that's anti-competitive. So I'm not saying Apple is like, I'm not some kind of blind Apple loyal to this,
2:25:15saying Apple has never abused its competitive position. I think the App Store and that 30%, 15% cut,
2:25:23cut or we get some kind of money from everything that goes through and you can't even link to stuff
2:25:27there that's something but this always on location thing is clearly a move that they've done for
2:25:33privacy it is not it is not a power move to sell more of their own location tracking tiles but i
2:25:41think the other change in ios 13 that these people are really peeved about are the periodic reminders
2:25:47where apps that are using your location in the background.
2:25:49I love that.
2:25:51It is it is super great.
2:25:56The map and everything.
2:25:57Yeah, and it's a map and everything it shows you.
2:26:00So it shows you so one app that I am happy to grant always on location access to is dark sky,
2:26:08the weather weather app that gives you warnings for upcoming precipitation or other weather events.
2:26:16Get you know every week or so. I think it's somewhat random or the algorithm behind it is you can't just time it
2:26:23It's not like every Tuesday at 3 o'clock. I get this reminder
2:26:26But you know every week or two I get a reminder that says
2:26:30Hey dark sky has been using your location in the background
2:26:34Nine times over the last
2:26:38Whatever period of time and then the map shows with little markers where they are
2:26:44And of course every single one of them is at my house because I don't go anywhere but
2:26:48But there it is hop saying come on, right exactly
2:26:52But I love that but the people who are you know using your location data
2:26:57Apps that might you know, who knows, you know like games or something like that some free game and it just says hey
2:27:04We want to use your location data for something and maybe you okayed it
2:27:07And then all of a sudden you find out that this weird game that you haven't played in three months has been using your location
2:27:12in the background, do you want to stop it?
2:27:14And you don't even have to go to the app.
2:27:16You just say, oh yeah, I don't want that.
2:27:17And you click a button and it goes away.
2:27:19- This is great.
2:27:20It's not, it'd be difficult to argue
2:27:23this is anti-competitive unless Apple were collecting
2:27:25and selling the information in the same way.
2:27:28And because of its privacy stance, you know,
2:27:30and sometimes it slips up and sometimes they have
2:27:32to apologize and sometimes they have to change the software.
2:27:35Sometimes they don't realize the consequences,
2:27:37but Apple is not enforcing this.
2:27:39I mean, Google and some others might claim Apple
2:27:42has put this in place to hobble the advertising market to force app developers to route more
2:27:50money through with like in-app purchases or higher app prices that Apple gets a cut of.
2:27:55There is an argument for that, but you can take two different apps that have the same
2:27:59abilities and functions and one is doing horrible tracking that you have to block and the other
2:28:03is not. It's just doing normal advertising that is not full of horrible trackers. And
2:28:08those two exist side by side and Apple isn't doing anything preferential between them if
2:28:12they both meet the rules. What it's saying is these random apps can't track you all the
2:28:16time in the background without explicit user intervention and it's not trying to make money
2:28:22off that itself. That would be anti-competitive. Did you also see though the Bluetooth one
2:28:27is the one that got me. Do you get the Bluetooth pop up? This app would like to use your Bluetooth
2:28:31settings or Bluetooth.
2:28:33I did for a little bit, but I don't think I have many apps that are trying to do it.
2:28:38I've seen it.
2:28:39- There were some weird ones.
2:28:39CNN app and some other apps.
2:28:42And I was like, I don't know why these would need,
2:28:44there's apparently there's an innocent explanation about,
2:28:47oh, I don't know.
2:28:48There's something,
2:28:49it's not actually trying to communicate with your devices,
2:28:51but it has to use some library or whatever.
2:28:53But I, yeah, when I first fired up,
2:28:56I was 13, I think I had like 20 different apps
2:28:59were asking for Bluetooth apps access
2:29:01and none of them except one podcast app needed it.
2:29:04- I've heard that some of that
2:29:05was for location tracking too though.
2:29:07So like when you'd enter like a retail building or something like that, they might, yeah,
2:29:11yeah, they might have the iBeacons.
2:29:13And then if the app is still running in the background, cause you just checked CNN, it would check in, you know, that there was some, you know, I really, I do think, I don't think Apple added that idly, you know, just out of kicks.
2:29:25No, I think they were sharing. Yeah, they think there was a standard library for, for iBeacon and similar things that were being used broadly.
2:29:32Although I beacon is kind of I don't know how widely deployed that was but I wouldn't be surprised if retailers
2:29:37Have Bluetooth beacons that are not for information but for tracking and they get tracked through that mechanism to provide location
2:29:44information but yeah
2:29:46So I don't want to run the CNN app and have it
2:29:48Be doing Bluetooth tracking of me because they happen to include that library if that's what was going on
2:29:53It's absolutely shocking to me Glenn that you're on the show and we're running long
2:29:57But I got to take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor and I have one more major topic
2:30:02I wanted to talk about. But first, I want to thank our friends at Squarespace. Hey,
2:30:09it's still New Year. I know Larry David thinks it's too late to say Happy New Year, but I
2:30:15still say Happy New Year to you. And New Year is when people naturally it's just human instinct.
2:30:22You set new goals, you make resolutions, might be a time to start a new business, start a
2:30:27new side gig, launch a new creative project. Well, anything that needs a
2:30:33website for your new project, your new job, your new business, whatever it is
2:30:37you're doing, start it at Squarespace. That's my suggestion. Make your next move
2:30:42there. Go to Squarespace. You get a free trial. Last 30 days. You can build your
2:30:47entire website in their WYSIWYG tools right there in the browser. Choose from
2:30:54tons of award-winning, professionally designed templates that scale from
2:30:59mobile to desktop in all sorts of styles. You can customize them completely with
2:31:07your own brand, your own style, in any way you want. You add the features to the
2:31:12site that you want. If you need a store, add a store. It takes care of all the
2:31:17commerce, all the security stuff for you. If you need a gallery because what
2:31:21building is some sort of portfolio for your design work of some sort. They've got that for you. You
2:31:26want to have a blog, you want to host a podcast right on your site, they've got all of that right
2:31:31there. And for the stuff like a blog or a podcast that gets updated regularly, you can post right
2:31:37through the Squarespace interface as you create new entries in your site. Everything really
2:31:45soup to nuts right there in Squarespace, including also award-winning technical support.
2:31:51So next time you need to make a new website or somebody you know comes to you and says,
2:31:58"Hey, can you help me make a new website?" Send them to Squarespace.
2:32:01It's the easiest way to get started. 30 days free and with special code "Talkshow" at checkout,
2:32:10you get 10% off. Everything is intuitive, easy to use. Start your free trial today.
2:32:15Go to squarespace.com/talkshow, squarespace.com/talkshow,
2:32:20and remember that code talk show 29 or 30 days later when your free trial's up,
2:32:24and you'll get 10% off your first purchase,
2:32:26which it could be prepaid for an entire year.
2:32:29You get like entire month free over a month.
2:32:33Squarespace.com/talkshow.
2:32:35I thank Squarespace for their continuing support of the talk show. All right.
2:32:39My last topic of the day, and you and I were talking about this offline,
2:32:43because we ran into it, which is that, is it my imagination or is spam filtering for email
2:32:52getting worse? I missed emails in the last week from you where you were asking, "Hey, do you want
2:33:00to record the show?" Which, yes, I did. Here we are. And Jason Snell, I missed all, he does the
2:33:10the annual report card on, you know, the Apple annual report
2:33:13card, which I love and I love to participate in, because a I love
2:33:18to hear the answers of everybody, but be it's like a
2:33:20free column idea for daring fireball by just putting my
2:33:23entire answers in there. And of course, he sent the original
2:33:27thing out a month ago, and I thought, I'll do it after the
2:33:30new year. And then all of his reminder emails to me like last
2:33:33last call for those of you, you know, I maybe the reason it went
2:33:36to spam was because it was a message that wasn't just to John Gruber, "Hey Gruber,
2:33:43you know, what the fuck, send it in." It was like to, you know, the BCC recipient lists
2:33:49of everybody he had asked to participate who hadn't yet submitted an answer. I guess that's
2:33:55why, but there is absolutely no way that emails from you, from an email address you've been
2:34:02using as long as I've known you and Jason Snell using an email address that
2:34:07I've known for I think 20 years maybe more to my main email address that I've
2:34:15been using since I registered the daring fireball dotnet domain in 2002 like this
2:34:20it's not like they're going from or to new email addresses and it's not like
2:34:26the contents of any of them I mean again the one thing about Jason's is that it
2:34:30It was like two unknown recipients, but that really shouldn't apply to the spam and yours.
2:34:35I have no idea.
2:34:36No zero.
2:34:37I do ask if you wanted to buy some Cialis too.
2:34:39No, you did not.
2:34:41I have noticed this recently, but for a while and my email currently and for years now has
2:34:47been backed by Gmail.
2:34:49I don't have, I don't use a gmail.com addresses my address, but my main email accounts are
2:34:54backed by separate Gmail accounts.
2:34:56The main reason I did was for spam filtering
2:35:00Which I had found originally was really excellent and I so excellent that I had fallen out of the habit of eyeballing
2:35:07my spam mailbox
2:35:09But recently I have found I have found that I absolutely have to do the old-fashioned thing and visually scan
2:35:18In like I told you it's you know at least a you know
2:35:232000 emails a month total, you know comes all my addresses combined and I have to sit there and visually scan it and I things jump
2:35:31Out I have missed I mean in addition to ones from you and Jason
2:35:34Sponsorship inquiries, you know from people, you know companies that want to sponsor
2:35:39Daring fireball, you know actual business opportunities
2:35:43Call back to the sort of this episode the jeopardy introduction or audition notice was in my spam filter. I almost deleted it
2:35:50I was like, oh spam from somebody claiming to be jeopardy. I'm like, oh my god, wait, and if I deleted that
2:35:55Hey, that would have been a life experience and 30 something thousand dollars lost. So
2:36:00Yeah, I don't know if it's gotten worse now, that's a good question
2:36:04I don't know how you measure that but you would think after all these years that Google would have
2:36:08Automatically whitelisted incoming recipients you'd corresponded with you know where you hadn't marked it as spam for that long
2:36:15It's the same addresses
2:36:16even if they're cashing it as they should be in your own account.
2:36:19I use Fastmail, which I've used for many, many years,
2:36:23to back up my accounts, and they have a pretty aggressive anti-spam strategy
2:36:29in terms of dealing with their own customers, and they seem to operate really good filters.
2:36:34Like, I don't get nearly as much spam as you do, and they have spam assassin behind them,
2:36:39I put some rules in place for the most egregious stuff.
2:36:42But even then, you know, some stuff winds up in their junk filters,
2:36:44filters, some stuff winds up in, I use SpamSieve on my Mac. But what I find is that Google in
2:36:52particular, Gmail at periods of time is more aggressive. So and I don't know if it's just me,
2:36:58it seems like it is often. But there's been points where like for six months, every email just about
2:37:03I sent to someone on Gmail, I had to follow up with with like a text because it went straight to their
2:37:08spam filter. And then it stopped. And then it was fine for long periods of time. And just recently,
2:37:13Yours is not the only message I've sent to someone using a gmail account where I think it wound up in
2:37:18in the spam filter
2:37:21And I I find that there are some that I correct them and it doesn't get uncorrected
2:37:26So you should be white listing why isn't it listening to your white list?
2:37:31I don't know. I always was under the impression that all you have to do to tell Gmail that
2:37:35Like I'm using the Apple mail app not Gmail's app
2:37:40But that if you move a message from junk to your inbox, it's saying this is not junk
2:37:46Because I don't know how else they could interpret that but like Dave Weiner started sending out
2:37:52daily summaries of his scripting news
2:37:57And I I guess I should unsubscribe because I follow scripting news in RSS and that's where I would naturally do it
2:38:04But I'm just I'm just intrigued by how he's using an email newsletter
2:38:09It's just like a recurring theme for the last four months and I I'm not gonna say I'm on the cusp of
2:38:15Doing a daring fireball email newsletter
2:38:18But I'm I've noted the resurgence in email newsletters
2:38:23and I talked to Dan Fromer about it and his main thing is a newsletter and
2:38:27Ben Thompson's main thing is the newsletter the daily update at Strateckery and
2:38:32Paid versus paid and free. There's a resurgence of interest in newsletters
2:38:38And one of my reasons for for you know, I've I've been saying this over again
2:38:43I have this theory that the reason people really like reading email newsletters is
2:38:47You click on the newsletter and you read it and it scroll down and you're done and there's not nobody's popping up anything that
2:38:54Covers the email and says will you subscribe to our newsletter or will you subscribe to this or will you we're collecting cookies?
2:39:03okay or no I mean I don't I have told the goddamn Guardian that I'm okay with their cookies a
2:39:09Thousand freaking times every time I go to their website
2:39:12I have to click three things on most websites just to read the goddamn article the fact that I can just click on an email
2:39:19And there it is on a
2:39:21Unobstructed and I scroll down and then I'm done and that's it
2:39:24I really think that's part of the resurgence
2:39:26But anyway, so I want to keep getting Dave's daily updates and they keep going to junk
2:39:31I don't know what to do to make it stop. No, I know this from you know, I used to for many years
2:39:36Some weird little software I wrote powered tidbits mailing list and which has tens of thousands of people on it
2:39:42And as you know tidbits the longest continuously
2:39:46distributed
2:39:48Email newsletter on the internet. We're pretty sure like it seems like there was one that might have been longer and it's gone
2:39:54So they've got a lot of experience with dealing with spamming Adam is very experienced understanding what makes things go wrong
2:40:00and now is using a service at long last so is not running it himself, but I had
2:40:06wrote this thing that
2:40:08did some
2:40:09sophisticated or I thought spam processing or a bounce processing and
2:40:13Seemed to not trigger spam filters and tributes ran off that for like 10 years
2:40:17I think and even then it would just be a mystery like one week
2:40:20We would do nothing differently and like all AOL users would be would be
2:40:25Unsubscribed or blocked or we get a thousand bounces from one outfit and I'm still seeing it
2:40:30so I used fast mail as I said and I
2:40:32And I get tidbits and half the time it winds up being categorized as sort of light spam. So I see it
2:40:39It's in my spam filter. It's not deleted with a high score, which I've got set and I'm thinking how is tidbits?
2:40:45I mean I've received a
2:40:47thousand issues of tidbits
2:40:49Most of those at my fast mail address or at fast mail servers and it's absolutely compliant and Adam sends out huge amounts of email
2:40:56every week so he knows and
2:40:59It's a mystery. I was telling you in our show notes here
2:41:04Our pre show discussion is I think it was the late 90s that I wrote an article saying
2:41:09I'm really concerned about email balkanization because spam filters and other things might prevent people from sending email from one place to another
2:41:17I'm like, "Well, it's still going on. No one's figured out a way."
2:41:20I mean, there were all those proposals, some of which are used,
2:41:24that do different ways of validating domains and senders
2:41:28and some of it's public key-based and some of it's in DNS.
2:41:32And this was supposed to be a way to reduce spam by having some kind of verified path.
2:41:36And even if spammers used it, the people who were verified would be able to
2:41:41have an identity that was cryptographically proven or matched.
2:41:45So you could say well this domain is cool because we can confirm all this email actually was issued by this domain because they've got the private key and will whitelist this whole domain.
2:41:54So another spammer or spammer might use a domain and have their own private key and we know it's verifiedly from the spammer but they can't fake being from this verified domain.
2:42:04And they just all you know, email is still so disparate. There's no centralized anything or authority, which is great, because then you don't get advertising overlays and cookie requests and all that. But it also means that all these proposals to improve the way in which, like ham can be identified as ham ham sees ham, does not has not matured this many years into it.
2:42:29Right. And there's so much of my and what makes going through it
2:42:33manually and just visually scanning it so tedious is that
2:42:38at least I would guess 98% of it is so obviously spam, you know,
2:42:46like any human being with 100% certainty would say this is
2:42:51without ever opening it just just looking at the sender in
2:42:55the subject. I mean, literally, I'm looking at it right now.
2:42:59Here's one from ZZY 712712712. The next one's from Zing Z66IXHLVBM@iekh. I mean, I don't even know how they think it's gonna work. I don't know who in the world would open this even if they didn't have any.
2:43:20Why is machine learning not solve this? These are all readily identifiable.
2:43:23Five straight ones that are all just random, random strings of letters, and then the next one is from Late Night Peeing.
2:43:30I'm not making this up.
2:43:34That's not my favorite Late Night show.
2:43:35No, it's America's least favorite Late Night show.
2:43:39That's not Conan.
2:43:41Late Night Peeing.
2:43:43It's below Conan's.
2:43:44Yeah, it's...
2:43:46It's like...
2:43:50Don't know what to do about it, I don't know but I I would opt into some sort of system
2:43:57I don't know. It's too late. You know what I mean. It's like
2:43:59It's email like in some ways like I said email is is is having a resurgence in terms of newsletters
2:44:08but as a fundamental level like the the initial optimism of the early internet of everything being open and
2:44:16Anybody with yeah, you know is just its email has just suffered under the weight of that forever
2:44:22You know that anybody with an SMTP server can send email to anybody with an email address and it just goes there
2:44:31Is yeah, it's somebody's gonna solve it. I think and not like it's it's but I mean these are the trade-offs, right?
2:44:38There's there's always extreme. So if you you know, Facebook is unreliable
2:44:42You can't think that anything you post there gets delivered to people unless you pay for you know
2:44:48Boosting it and then even then you don't know so you're gonna have
2:44:51200,000 people liking your page and only 500 of them see a post right that kind of thing goes on and
2:44:56Email is great because there's no intermediation except that the spam is so bad that it mixes your ham and your spam
2:45:02And you're you're not getting it like these are these are our extremes
2:45:05But I do think that I think we I don't think we have seen well enough applied
2:45:11machine learning and training
2:45:13because
2:45:15So much spam is obvious as you say I do not get why
2:45:19And why this is not more identifiable and I expect that at some point there will be a breakthrough
2:45:25I mean remember how so before deep learning came in as a the most effective technique for
2:45:30Artificial intelligence a few years ago and made voice recognition and a lot of other things image recognition
2:45:37so forth so much better like you know a
2:45:4120% 25% better got us a lot more closer to the hundred percent score before deep learning
2:45:47Remember how terrible everything was all the all the recognition was it was statistically based there all these things and you know
2:45:53You'd speak and it would give you the egg freckles is the yeah the Newton joke for handwriting recognition or whatever
2:45:59Well, so deep learning came in and it made a huge difference
2:46:01But I don't feel like email has made that leap and I know that Google's there was machine learning
2:46:06There was the leap there was the leap with Bayesian filtering whatever that yeah
2:46:10But that was really the breakthrough was like holy shit. This works whatever
2:46:13Yes, it's a train is its statistical analysis using certain kinds of like measures of frequency and it and then what happens the spam makers
2:46:21Would run their email through the same Bayesian filters and tweak them until they found ones that got lower scores because they introduced
2:46:27You know, that's why you see part of Moby Dick at the bottom of email messages
2:46:30Yeah, I read and so forth and I remember, you know, I was at bare-bones software working there, you know recent guest Rich Siegel
2:46:38Which was a great episode? I don't know if you listen to but man that was one of my favorite such
2:46:41but I remember when I was there mail Smith was still in you know an act a
2:46:47Successful product that is still my email client is it really see the one thing I miss about I and I miss see this
2:46:54Man, do I miss this is using mail Smith with spam sieve you'd get a score
2:47:00And then you could sort your spam mailbox by the score and it made visually double-checking it so much easier because
2:47:07all of the actual ham
2:47:09That got incorrectly flagged to spam was at the top and all the obvious stuff was at the bottom
2:47:14And there's no I can't figure out any way in
2:47:17Apple mail to get anything similar to that and I don't know what to do about it
2:47:21but anyway, but I remember before Bayesian filtering we had like a
2:47:25Like it was like it as a tech support thing like a
2:47:31Collection of like filters like just manually set up like yeah like if the subject matches this pattern
2:47:37or if the sender you know like a couple of reg ex patterns, and you know based on the headers and
2:47:43And for a while it really worked well. We had like you know you could just download this filter and
2:47:49Add it to mailsmith and all of a sudden
2:47:52You know your spam problems were mostly solved
2:47:55And it was really just effectively just like eight if the message matches blank statements.
2:48:02You know, eventually that fell apart. You know, they found ways around it. And
2:48:07the Bayesian filtering was a great leap forward. But I feel like you're right. We need the next
2:48:11one. And I guess it has to be machine learning. But it's not there. I don't know. Maybe I'm nuts.
2:48:18Maybe it's just me. Maybe it's, you know, now that I've found a couple, I've found a couple
2:48:22of messages recently over the last like two months in my spam and I'm panicked about it. Maybe it's
2:48:27just me but I'm gonna slack with some technical you know some friends on you know that I've asked
2:48:33other you know similarly technically oriented long-term email users have all all said the
2:48:39same thing either that they think it's getting worse or they're convinced it's getting worse.
2:48:44Oh the other I would say the the another factor could be that spammers are getting better again
2:48:50They're getting better at filtering through which makes every time spammers get better spam filters get worse because they produce more false
2:48:56positives that way I will say this that I'm not seeing an increase of spam
2:49:02Getting into my inbox the only thing the only problem I'm seeing is good email getting flagged to spam
2:49:09Oh, but that can happen is you if you the filters could be improving so they're not passing more through
2:49:15So they're still good on false negatives, but they're bad on false positives
2:49:20Which is not kind of what you want. Like I think you'd rather have fewer false positives and more false negatives. Not like a thousand
2:49:26Yeah, spams drop in but I'd rather get one or two. Yes spams to get a hundred percent of my
2:49:31Right better that a guilty man
2:49:36Hundred guilty men go go free than an innocent man be put in jail
2:49:43All right
2:49:45So Glenn before I let you off the hook
2:49:48You are people can if they enjoy your voice on this show
2:49:53They can hear you and this is odd coincidence and it really is
2:50:00But you've been guest hosting the election ride home podcast. Yeah, that's right
2:50:06Excuse me
2:50:08Chris Higgins was the founding host of it and he's had to step away for family reasons
2:50:13and everything's okay, but he needs to focus on family. So I am stepping in for a bit to do this
2:50:20podcast because you know, as I can do everything in my career and the folks that ride home. Brian
2:50:29McCullough, I was on his, he's got a great internet history podcast is great because no one else is
2:50:35really doing the oral history of the internet comprehensively. I think, I mean, I don't want
2:50:39want to say he's the only one but I think he's the only one doing it at this level of detail. So he's
2:50:45talking with early people in the internet, ecommerce companies and whatever. And so I came on a
2:50:50couple times to to shoot the breeze about some of my early experiences and things and it's great
2:50:55because I'm like, Oh, now I've told him it's there forever. So he's been doing the tech meme ride
2:50:59home podcast for a while. And I've substituted on that a few times when he said vacation or
2:51:05obligations, jury duty and the like. And so Election Ride Home is just, it's the idea is just a
2:51:11summary. You know, it's I think, and I have this feeling too, it's very easy to get overwhelmed
2:51:16because there's too much news. There's a year's worth of news every day now, right? About
2:51:22everything. And so the idea is, you know, it's a 15 minute podcast about everything that happened
2:51:27in elections today. And it's very interesting to wake up in the morning and go, okay, kind of
2:51:31what's what's happening? You know, sometimes there'll be like the presidential debates. I was
2:51:36covering that last week. And it's like, okay, how do I summarize two hours plus of this in a way
2:51:42that's useful for people who didn't watch it and might be useful for people who did, but still make
2:51:47it you know, pithy and bring in some sound bites and, and not have it be facile. Like, here's kind
2:51:51of what you need to know, like, what is the national discussion ostensibly being today, but
2:51:56some other times I wake up in the morning, and it's like, you know, there's new impeachment thing,
2:52:00Pelosi sending the articles to the Senate. Some, you know,
2:52:04Booker drops out or whatever. And so every day is a new
2:52:07adventure and mystery. But the goal is to like, make it
2:52:11approachable. So you put on your headphones on your commute home.
2:52:14And in 15 minutes, you're done instead of, you know, reading a
2:52:18thousand, you may still read 1000 stories, but I'm trying to
2:52:21help people. I feel like it's a, it's a service to keep people
2:52:24from having to fully immerse themselves in it every day.
2:52:27And how long is the gig?
2:52:29It's ongoing. I think they're looking for a permanent host for the show, you know, because I've got a lot of his, you know.
2:52:35I've got a lot of different things I'm working on.
2:52:37Well, and this also sounds, I know it's like, oh, it's only 15 minutes as opposed to the three hours you and I have been talking right now.
2:52:42But I can only imagine how much work it is on a daily basis to boil all of it down to 15 minutes.
2:52:49It would actually probably be less work to do a three hour podcast where you just ramble on about it,
2:52:54where as opposed to typing it on them.
2:52:56- It's already a script and everything.
2:52:57Yeah, it's already a script.
2:52:58I mean, it's like a four to six hour cycle to do an episode.
2:53:01And so it's really, it's exciting.
2:53:03As somebody who's been a freelance writer for a long time,
2:53:06I've never done daily reporting.
2:53:08I've only done stuff for weeklies
2:53:10or sometimes on deadline, overnight or something.
2:53:13But I did a gig for Fortune from mid 2018 to early 2019
2:53:18before they got sold to a mysterious Thai billionaire.
2:53:21No kidding.
2:53:21No kidding.
2:53:23They just rebooted with a new design and they, it's a great publication, some great people, great editors I was working with there.
2:53:29But they were running a kind of daily newsroom within shifts.
2:53:33And so I was writing kind of breaking news for seven months for a few hours every day.
2:53:38And that was fascinating to me and a little overwhelming because my pace is, you know, I'm often, I've been describing myself as breaking news from the 19th century because I'm always like, hey, you know, I just discovered some printers were poisoned in printing this newspaper in 1838.
2:53:52I must write this story. So the election right home is it's a great way to stretch my muscles. And, and it's a fun I feel like it's a little bit of a service thing and giving people you know that that snippet is I think a lot of the political podcasts tend to be discussion and longer. So you have to commit yourself. And there's some of them I really like, like, love it or leave it. I'll listen to every week and a few others. But anyway, it's a very specific, it's a very specific remit for this podcast.
2:54:19I will I have to disclaim it but it's just an odd coincidence but the sponsor of the previous episode of this show
2:54:26Last week's episode with Merlin Mann was tech memes ride home. So just another ride home podcast
2:54:32I actually purposefully juggled the sponsorship schedule so that we would wouldn't have
2:54:37Tech meme ride home sponsoring the episode where you Glenn talk about election ride home
2:54:43But I mean it they sponsored last week's episode
2:54:46They're not sponsoring this week's episode, but the ride home podcasts are really really tight
2:54:50And it's it's like your own little private NPR for your area of interest
2:54:55so if you would rather hear about election news on your ride home, then
2:54:59Tech news on your ride home election right home is a great thing
2:55:03And if you're you know if your ride home is 30 minutes you could listen to both
2:55:06There's a celebrity one also. They you know they
2:55:09Not public news. They raise a little money because I want to do they want to do a bunch of these
2:55:15You know, there are long podcasts like this one they get into things and they're a short part
2:55:20I think the news one is interesting because I think that that often I often don't listen to
2:55:23News podcasts because I like to prefer to read it
2:55:27I if I knew you know in some areas like I would love a like a security news podcast
2:55:33It's just not enough interest. That was just like whatever security news happened that day. Just give me the boil it down
2:55:38Then I'll go and drill and find like an index for my ears
2:55:43The other thing I know you wanted to mention was the tiny type museum
2:55:47I I did I want to thank wash
2:55:49I want to thank during fireball listeners because many of you well
2:55:53I shouldn't say me and relative proportions not many of you
2:55:55But some of you have been great supporters of the project and it's it's we're gonna ship very soon
2:56:00I know this is unheard of a Kickstarter that ships more or less on time
2:56:05But I've been thanking past Glen so that we did the Kickstarter in February last year
2:56:11Myself and Anna Robinson has been making the wooden cases handmade wooden cases for the type artifacts that go into it and
2:56:18She is nearing where like the very final stages of final production for that and I've got my basement is full of like the poor
2:56:26letter carrier
2:56:28Describe it in one line, you know, so the tiny type museum and time capsule
2:56:31It's a collection of printing artifacts like wood type and molds from which type are made and little pieces of photo type
2:56:37And I've got a CD-ROM p22 the type foundry. It's been around for 20 plus years. They sold me very inexpensively
2:56:44CD ROM so every time he's gonna have a 1990 era
2:56:48CD ROM with a personal license to use the font that's on the CD ROM if you can read it
2:56:53So it's been a it's been a hoot. I did a book along along with it as well
2:56:57And it's being printed this one's being printed in England right now
2:57:00It's and so that's the one you mentioned that was actually it is actually being printed in letterpress
2:57:06Yeah, like it was set in hot metal in
2:57:09in
2:57:10North Yorkshire and where there's the printer I work with as a
2:57:15Former employee who has all the types of equipment now and it's being printed in London
2:57:20London proper and then be bound in Germany and actually when the brexit situation was happening if it had crashed out in October
2:57:28I was really worried about how my
2:57:30Printed pages were gonna get to Germany for binding. You might have to smuggle them out
2:57:35Well, are you talking like could I fly there and imagine?
2:57:37Imagine getting busted for smuggling something is as
2:57:41Esoteric as international book smuggler. So so the postman this poor letter carrier post lady
2:57:49It's a postal carrier rather. We have a variety of postal carriers and livers
2:57:53I'm buying lead
2:57:55brass
2:57:57Bronze
2:58:00Lightweight stuff. It's like a joke. It's like the box is one of those tiny USPS
2:58:04Like everybody in the United States who deals in this stuff ships with priority mail because it's almost unlimited weight for the size
2:58:12So you can see the guy go up the stairs to hands it off to be like, oh, I'm sorry
2:58:15It's like 40 pounds of lead. She just gave me so my basement is full of all the artifacts
2:58:21they're gonna get sorted into sets but
2:58:23People can people can still get in right there are yes
2:58:27I the edition is about a hundred and 80 of them are now over 80 of them are now
2:58:31Pre-ordered or sold in the Kickstarter. Yeah, any type museum
2:58:35Basically if you even know how cool it is that Glenn is having the book
2:58:41Physically letterpress if you even know what that means
2:58:44You should absolutely go check out tiny type museum calm and if not, well, that's probably not for you
2:58:49It's it's been fun though because I've had all these great conversations a lot
2:58:52There's a lot of older folks, particularly, usually men who are working in the printing industry or had grandparents work in the industry.
2:58:59And I have these great conversations with people like, "Oh my God, my father used to be a typesetter or someone telling me..."
2:59:05I have this great, you know, Chris Finn, who used to write for Macworld, who now is at...
2:59:10DK... DC Thomas? I'm forgetting the name.
2:59:15It's a major media company in the UK.
2:59:18And you can still see they still have a building on Fleet Street.
2:59:21They're like the only they don't have reporters there. But then when you walk on a fleet street in London, the home of newspapers in London where there are no newspapers left, they still have a DC Thompson. Anyway, Chris Finn recorded a short podcast for me with a colleague of his who was just old enough to have worked on old letterpress when newspapers were printed by letterpress and had this story about how they put the breaking news in with this special little thing you would like stick into the running
2:59:51press with just a little bit of copy that said extra extra
2:59:54breaking news. He recorded is so nice. recorded a short podcast
3:00:00put it on YouTube about that. So anyway, it's been great just
3:00:03talking to folks about this people have fond memories. And
3:00:05anyway, I appreciate everyone's support on it. It's been a
3:00:08great year to 2019 was incredible to work on this. So
3:00:11thank you all.
3:00:11All right, my thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring this
3:00:15show. Go to squarespace.com slash talk show start your own
3:00:17website clear the absolute best way to get through airport security and the
3:00:26first sponsor of the episode who I can't remember hover that sound I it's coming
3:00:34to me Glenn it's coming to me I hover hover.com slash talk show where you could
3:00:40go and register domain name and get a 10% discount with that link thank you
3:00:44Glenn, you've been extraordinarily generous with your time and your personal insight into
3:00:49Jeopardy. What a great show. Thank you very much.
3:00:52Always a pleasure, John. Thank you very much.
3:00:55[ Silence ]