0:00:00There's a lot going on yeah, it's good time to be us
0:00:03Yeah, absolutely. I
0:00:05Don't even know where to start I guess
0:00:08Did I miss anything? I feel like I I had like a I got a weekend list of things. I wanted to write about today and
0:00:15And you know, it wasn't like extensive I didn't write anything huge I just had a few things we're recording on Monday the 21st and
0:00:24it's like
0:00:26just like in today there's like so much new stuff that has come out like and and I
0:00:31Feel like I'm already behind in other words. I was just watching pixel review videos all morning
0:00:37I've hardly even touched the pixel for reviews because I was trying to catch up on the stuff
0:00:43That I wanted to write from over the weekend. Yeah, so I read Dieter bones in the verge didn't watch the video yet. I
0:00:53Don't know what's the consensus at Dieter's who seemed excellent it also seemed
0:00:57I'll share my thoughts on it in a second. But what would you what do you take as the consensus?
0:01:03Yeah, so I think the consensus is that it's got you know, still got really good stills
0:01:09Disappointing video the battery life especially in the small one was bad enough that a few people couldn't recommend it just based on that alone
0:01:17and it it it seemed like I
0:01:21I think there was a lot of spoilers that went out
0:01:23before the event.
0:01:24And people were expecting more than the spoilers,
0:01:27and they didn't get it.
0:01:28They got slightly less.
0:01:30And your project solely was this huge, cool--
0:01:32you'd be able to twist your fingers in midair and do
0:01:34things, and right now you just wave at your phone.
0:01:37So partially a tech demo, but it didn't
0:01:39seem like anyone was that blown away by it this year.
0:01:44Yeah, I guess.
0:01:45I mean, it's almost like an interesting experiment
0:01:50in pre-leaking as much detail as you can.
0:01:54You know, and what is the effect going to have on reaction?
0:02:00You know, I mean, and you can-- you know,
0:02:03you and I are going to see this through iPhone-colored glasses
0:02:08just from our perspective.
0:02:10But you know, there's often, when stuff leaks about Apple
0:02:14stuff, there's sometimes an undercurrent of, well,
0:02:18who cares?
0:02:18it's all just hype or or the the conspiracy theory of you know that every
0:02:24leak that proves accurate must have been delivered on Apple's part and they they
0:02:29drip drip drip these leaks out as a way of increasing hype which is not true
0:02:35yeah absolutely not true and I think part of it is the per I think part of it
0:02:42is just personal. I really do think that from Schiller and
0:02:45Jaws on down in Apple, there's just a personal desire to keep
0:02:51this stuff secret. And Steve, you know, and the DNA of the
0:02:55company is shaped by its founder, you know, Steve Jobs,
0:02:57absolutely, whether you could have mathematically proven to
0:03:00him, that there was financial value to be had in pre leaking
0:03:05stuff, you just said to hell with it, I'm not only gonna
0:03:07goddamn thing, I want to tell people about it on stage. So
0:03:10Part of it is personality-wise,
0:03:11and part of it, though, I think,
0:03:12is that it is the correct PR strategy to surprise people
0:03:16and to have features come out,
0:03:18to have the first impression of the features
0:03:24be what you want that first impression to be
0:03:27as the company releasing it,
0:03:29as opposed to some random leaker's perspective on it,
0:03:32which may or may not be positive.
0:03:36- Yeah, and also the talking point after all the events is,
0:03:38oh, there was no surprises.
0:03:40Sort of like reading the script to Star Wars
0:03:42and then complaining you didn't get any surprises
0:03:44in the movie.
0:03:45But that ends up being the buzz after the event.
0:03:47And this one, the Android events are weird to me,
0:03:50just coming from an Apple background,
0:03:51because more and more, and I think Google,
0:03:53maybe for the first time, the event starts
0:03:56and then the hands-on embargo drops,
0:03:58because they bring people in before the event even
0:04:00to show them the phone and they shoot video
0:04:03and then they put up their videos.
0:04:04And I don't know what to watch.
0:04:05Like I'm watching the event
0:04:06and I see like an MKBHD video come out
0:04:09or a Verge video come out,
0:04:10and then I don't know where to put my attention anymore,
0:04:12and I think it makes it harder to follow the events.
0:04:14- Yeah, I think so too.
0:04:19Did you, you didn't go to the Pixel event, right?
0:04:23- No, I had my colleagues go, but I did order one.
0:04:25I ordered the orange one during the event.
0:04:27- I ordered the white one,
0:04:29and I'm in the process of selling my Pixel 3,
0:04:32which is in mint condition, I have to say.
0:04:34I did keep it in a case most of the year,
0:04:36mainly because it was always sort of a secondary camera and so
0:04:40but there were you know were you know, and I'm I don't baby my iPhones but you know, the one of the knocks against last year's
0:04:46pixel 3 was that the the
0:04:48matte finish glass was easily scratched that you know as easily scratched as
0:04:54Like your fingernail and people would be like, well, that's not scratch
0:04:58That's just calcium from your fingernail rubbing off and people were like no. No, it's actually the class
0:05:03I don't know big one or the small one. No, I always get the small one because I tried to I
0:05:07Try to as best as I can
0:05:11Buy the one you know that I would get if I were going to use it and I you know
0:05:16I still prefer the smaller of the iPhone
0:05:1810
0:05:21series phones and I still would prefer the
0:05:24smaller pixel for now again, I saw the initial
0:05:29Reviews, you know even Dieter's not even I don't mean that that Dieter pointed out
0:05:33I mean in the even in the sense that I've only read one
0:05:36Yeah, even the one review I read which happens to be Dieter's mentions that has it very, you know
0:05:42gives it gives a different rating to both phones and and one of the reasons that the
0:05:45XL gets a better rating is that the battery is
0:05:48Average in his terms whereas the battery life on the smaller one is poor
0:05:52I don't know why I enjoy site for the first time said that they couldn't recommend the small pixel just based on but I don't
0:05:57remember them ever not recommending a Pixel before.
0:06:00I don't know why the battery life is worse though. I'm not quite sure given how limited
0:06:08my review depth is. Are people saying it's worse than the Pixel 3 smaller one last year?
0:06:14And if so, I can't understand why it's worse because I...
0:06:16The Pixel 3 was terrible. The Pixel 4 is a small battery but also they have a 90 hertz
0:06:22display which is sucking down more power.
0:06:24Yeah.
0:06:25more of the ML on device which is sucking down more power.
0:06:28Yeah, that might be the explanation. I thought that the battery life on the Pixel 3 was fine.
0:06:32And you know, using, mostly using the camera, which should be a battery, you know, a draw
0:06:36because the display is on and it's reading and writing. But we'll see what I think
0:06:41about the Pixel 4. But I bought the white one because I bought the black one last year
0:06:50it was too hard to tell apart from all my black iPhones.
0:06:55And so I needed to buy a color that would be
0:06:59easily distinguishable while they're in front of me.
0:07:03'Cause I wind up doing things,
0:07:05it's more than just like two phones side by side.
0:07:07I mean, I'm just a mess in September and October,
0:07:14really I'm just sort of coming down from it.
0:07:16Because I'm testing multiple new iPhones now
0:07:20from Apple. And I, you know, as I mentioned, talking to Ben
0:07:25Thompson, on my last episode of the show, I really didn't even
0:07:29spend much time with the 11 Pro Max, just because I did enough
0:07:36to trust to verify that Apple what Apple was saying that this
0:07:40is the same phone just bigger. And once I verified it, then all
0:07:43I did was test the 11 and the 11 Pro because it's just too much.
0:07:48But I've still got it out. It's laying around on my desk, you know, so I've got like new three two or three new iPhones
0:07:53I've got my year-old iPhone that I'm using as like a baseline to measure year over year
0:07:58And then I've got the pixel three out to like measure. How's this night sight compared with their night sight, etc?
0:08:03So having them all be black was just terrible
0:08:06So I got the white one
0:08:08I think it has a nice stormtrooper II look which is what I sort of think about like the addition
0:08:13Apple watch the the ceramic edition Apple watch
0:08:17And I it's funny like the orange seems to be
0:08:23In certain photographs, I love orange and black. I went to a high school with colors that were orange and black
0:08:30I think orange and black are underrated colors on sports teams. I
0:08:33Do I think they go very well together?
0:08:36The other colors I use for vector it's it's a underused combination I really like it
0:08:44I think, you know, I think orange is sometimes difficult to get right and but when you do it can look great
0:08:49But I there's sort of a different photograph show the orange in different light
0:08:54You know some of them look a lot more coral and some of them don't look coral at all
0:08:58And I don't really care for coral so I didn't go that way. I got white
0:09:01I'm just a sucker for new color, so I'll almost always get whatever it color is new
0:09:05The thing that surprised me in Dieter's review though is well
0:09:08You know Google made that big pitch about they have the the pixel neural core now and they can do live preview
0:09:13And what I didn't realize it was just for HDR plus and I really wanted it for portrait mode
0:09:18And then Dieter responded on Twitter that Google doesn't think that preview on portrait mode is any good and a mutual friend Matthew pans
0:09:26We know if TechCrunch had a mini a mini stroke episode Twitter right after that. I see I missed all of this
0:09:32This is all context that I have missed. I
0:09:35do know I did that is an interesting philosophical difference between
0:09:40Google's internal pixel camera team and apples and Apple real apples internal team is
0:09:46Very very keen about doing everything live almost religious
0:09:51Yeah, and in fact that makes the exception that is deep fusion
0:09:56Notable, even though it's in my testing. It seems to be well under a second
0:10:03usually but noticeable like
0:10:07long longer enough that you wouldn't call it instantaneous but
0:10:10Generally less than a second and you can sort of see a little update in the you know
0:10:14You snap your picture the deep focus post-processing takes place and then the preview little
0:10:20Avatar icon whatever you want to call it updates
0:10:23So that's not live in the camera
0:10:28But just about everything else is and and Apple even goes to great lengths now
0:10:32Now they can't, it's, you know, the definition of the feature means that night mode is, can't
0:10:39be done live because it's a multiple second exposure from when you begin it.
0:10:44So without the ability to travel into the future a few seconds, there's no way to do
0:10:50it.
0:10:51But yet the live, what you do see in the viewfinder on the iPhone 11 and 11 Pro for night mode
0:10:58is remarkably close to what you end up getting.
0:11:02I'm not quite sure even how they do that.
0:11:04Whereas that has absolutely been,
0:11:06I don't have a Pixel 4 yet,
0:11:07and I've pre-ordered, we'll be here soon,
0:11:10but the Pixel 3, as much as they deserve kudos
0:11:12for their night sight last year,
0:11:14the live version of it was garbage.
0:11:17- Yes.
0:11:18Yeah. - It was really bad.
0:11:19I mean, you really-- - I like it
0:11:20for portrait mode 'cause I can,
0:11:22if it's messing around with the glasses or the ears,
0:11:24I can just move it a little bit
0:11:25and it fixes it before I waste time taking photos.
0:11:28- You could use it for composition,
0:11:31but it was absolutely useless in terms of finding out
0:11:35what is the end result going to look like.
0:11:38Now, was it better to have the feature than not have it?
0:11:42Sure, you know, but I can also see why in that state
0:11:46Apple wouldn't have shipped it.
0:11:47Apple would say that's not ready to go
0:11:49because we want it to be a reasonable representation.
0:11:52Anyway, I thought that the whole framing of Dieter's review,
0:11:58my take on the Pixel all along,
0:12:00Ever since they rebooted their internal,
0:12:05this is Google's Android phone
0:12:08from the Nexus line to the Pixel line.
0:12:10And I think it's worth treating as a new line.
0:12:14Like they changed philosophically, in my opinion,
0:12:18not just, it wasn't just a rose by any other name.
0:12:22They took a lot more in-house.
0:12:26It really wasn't,
0:12:27The Pixel phones are a lot more than just pure Android,
0:12:30which is what the Nexus phones were.
0:12:33They really are Google's version of Android,
0:12:36by taking Android and Googling it up with extra degrees.
0:12:39I've always felt that at a basic level,
0:12:43the Pixels are Android phones
0:12:49for people who like iPhone hardware.
0:12:52That it's, not that they're copies, you know,
0:12:56But the Pixel phones have always been a lot more iPhone-like.
0:13:00Putting aside what you see in the software, which
0:13:04is the iOS versus Android, but just treating them
0:13:06as hardware devices, boy, they're very iPhone-like.
0:13:11They're iPhone-like in dimension.
0:13:13They're iPhone-like in feel, sort of, varying.
0:13:17Some of the earlier ones were very similar in design.
0:13:20Yeah.
0:13:21They've always put the camera in the upper left corner
0:13:25the back, which seems like a little thing but an awful—especially three, four years
0:13:30ago, a lot of high-end Android phones still had the cameras centered in the back.
0:13:34Yeah, many of them still do.
0:13:35They still do, you know, and those are all, you know, but it's just, you know, at a
0:13:41basic level, it just sort of looks like, boy, if you could just run an Android on an iPhone,
0:13:48that's sort of the Pixel aesthetic.
0:13:50- So for me, they've always been curious
0:13:53because my understanding is that
0:13:55there was a sort of a shakeup in Google leadership
0:13:57and one of the people in charge really wanted an iPhone.
0:14:01They just wanted Google to have an iPhone
0:14:04and they started putting a lot of the elements in place
0:14:06from internal design groups.
0:14:07They bought HTC, well, they bought HTC Design in house.
0:14:12They started working on their own silicon.
0:14:13They started doing a lot of things to make an iPhone
0:14:15but at the same time,
0:14:17they never made the same kind of choices Apple would.
0:14:19Like they never, or even Huawei or Samsung,
0:14:21they never put great camera hardware on there
0:14:24because they figured their camera software was so great
0:14:27they could do with a less capable camera.
0:14:30And they had a lot of trouble with screens.
0:14:32So they didn't make the manufacturing choices
0:14:34that Apple would make,
0:14:36but they still sort of wanted an iPhone.
0:14:38And then over the last year,
0:14:39some of those initiatives didn't really work out
0:14:41the way they hoped.
0:14:42So now it just feels like they want a platform
0:14:44to showcase the best of Google algorithms and software.
0:14:48- Right.
0:14:49- Oh, and they're definitely keen on the camera angle.
0:14:51I mean, there's no doubt about it and they deserve it,
0:14:54but it sort of feels this year too.
0:14:59And again, I didn't read all the reviews,
0:15:01so I'm not sure what they're gonna say,
0:15:03but it seems like yet last year was a real high point
0:15:07for their ability to do stuff computationally.
0:15:12Night Sight in particular would be the shining--
0:15:16- And Super Zoom was another good example.
0:15:18Superzoom is another good example, where they do digital zoom, but by taking multiple exposures
0:15:23and running it through a neural net. And it's a great, to me, it's a great example of how
0:15:31this AI stuff really does deserve to be treated as a different sort of computing than, you
0:15:42know what I mean? It's like there's all sorts of algorithms that are supposed to make things
0:15:47seems smarter. Is it AI? No, not in a classical sense, but using a more efficient sorting
0:15:54algorithm when you have to sort something, if it makes your spreadsheet faster when you're
0:15:59reordering 10,000 columns of data by having a more efficient sort algorithm. That's just
0:16:05classic computer science of being faster and stuff like this. Whereas the way that they're
0:16:10doing the super zoom isn't really a human thinking, "Well, if this pixel is this color
0:16:17and this next pixel in a tenth of a second later exposure is within 9%, then do this
0:16:23and that. It really is just sort of feeding this into a machine learning model and by
0:16:30telling it this looks better, this looks worse, and then you feed these things in there, all
0:16:34of a sudden they come out with a way to very quickly, using the dedicated chips for this,
0:16:41a digital zoom that is just seemingly way, way better than you could expect to get out
0:16:47of a digital zoom.
0:16:48Yes, absolutely.
0:16:50But it feels like this year they're on a downside, even though they've added, you
0:16:54know, extra hardware by adding a 2x telephoto lens and going beyond one camera lens on the
0:17:03back. So they've definitely added hardware. It just feels like this is a down year for
0:17:07there sort of will do most. Most of the benefit will come from our computational stuff and
0:17:13we don't have to worry so much about the actual hardware. Like ideally you want both.
0:17:18And I feel like…
0:17:19Yes, absolutely. Because you also, I mean, you can tweak, like Apple is adding deep fusion
0:17:26and they can tweak battery algorithms and they can tweak, but you can't go to everybody's
0:17:30house and put a better camera system on their phone. You can't go to everybody's house
0:17:33and stick a bigger battery in. You need a baseline. The better the hardware, the better
0:17:37the software is going to work, and that's the balance they seem to be struggling with.
0:17:41Dave Asprey And Apple is really doing some impressive
0:17:45stuff with video. I mean, and that's always been the weak spot, Android wide, but Pixel
0:17:51in particular, you know, the video stuff, just, you know, wherever you want to argue,
0:17:56they rank on still mobile phone photography on video. Everything from Android is way behind
0:18:03I mean, nobody else does 4K 60 yet, or maybe with some—
0:18:11I think Samsung does.
0:18:12Yeah, maybe some—
0:18:13But I don't think they do the interleaved extended dynamic range at 60.
0:18:15Yeah, put an asterisk there, and it's, okay, maybe they do, but it's not great.
0:18:19Like, you pointed—I got it from you and gave you credit when I linked to it, but Jonathan
0:18:23Morrison, you know, well-known Twitter—or not Twitter, but YouTube personality, who
0:18:32does great work and usually shoots with, you know, really,
0:18:34truly professional camera rig.
0:18:36And Arri Alexa Mini, which is like, I think $85,000.
0:18:40It's just, you know, as good as it gets. Yeah, you know, it's
0:18:44super pro. Filmmaker style kit, had a video with his first
0:18:50thoughts on the pixel four, and he shot the whole thing, not
0:18:53just with the iPhone 11, but with the iPhone 11 front facing
0:18:56camera and it's clearly 60 frames per second. It probably clearly 4k but I looked at it
0:19:05on a 13 inch MacBook so I don't know if I could I don't mod 100% sure that I could peg
0:19:10moving video is 4k versus 1080 on a screen that size but you can definitely tell 60 frames
0:19:14per second. Yeah. And you know, just totally. I didn't know in advance I don't think I would
0:19:22guest and then at the very end of his video he had some like meta shots showing him shooting
0:19:27it showing that he shot it with the front-facing camera like i don't see how he was joking on
0:19:32twitter when google announced that he's at their the iphone selfie camera now shoots better video
0:19:36than the main camera on the pixel it really does i mean it's actually i mean at least by some
0:19:41measure there may be some ways that the that the bigger sensor on the rear-facing camera
0:19:45there might be some scenarios where you get better video on the rear facing you have really good like
0:19:50but like their algorithms for color and balance
0:19:52and for stabilization are amazing.
0:19:55Like they have, again, amazing algorithms.
0:19:57But today I think they put out a statement
0:19:58saying they didn't do 60 frames per second
0:20:00because they thought it was a waste.
0:20:02It was too much storage.
0:20:04And that's my biggest problem with Pixel in general
0:20:06is that Google doesn't have a strong opinion.
0:20:08They, the first Pixel, they said,
0:20:10"We don't need a camera bump."
0:20:11Second year, like, "Oh, we need a camera bump.
0:20:13We don't need new camera.
0:20:14We don't need two cameras.
0:20:15Oh, we need two cameras, but we don't need a wide angle."
0:20:17And you just know next year
0:20:18they're gonna add a wide angle.
0:20:20And it's the same, we have a chin and a forehead
0:20:22because we want two front-facing speakers.
0:20:24That's really important to us.
0:20:25And this year they put the speaker
0:20:26right where the iPhone is.
0:20:27And it feels like they sort of go halfway
0:20:30and then rationalize it
0:20:31and then change their mind the next year.
0:20:33And I just want them to be super opinionated
0:20:34about what they want a phone to be.
0:20:36- Yeah.
0:20:37I would have encouraged them to go notchless
0:20:42last year as well.
0:20:43Like I feel like what they've done this year
0:20:46where they, instead of having a notch,
0:20:48It just goes across the top.
0:20:50And so there's, you know, in that chin forehead terms,
0:20:53they have a forehead, small by historical forehead sizes,
0:20:58but still a forehead that's effectively the height of,
0:21:02you know, what a notch would be on an iPhone 10
0:21:05or any of the other phones that have curiously come out
0:21:08with notches since the iPhone 10.
0:21:10It has a bit of a chin, but not,
0:21:15it's not anywhere close to the height of the forehead.
0:21:17So iPhones have always been symmetrically designed
0:21:21so that when you hold them sideways,
0:21:22if it has a chin and forehead, it matches.
0:21:26And if it doesn't have a chin or forehead,
0:21:27it's the same bezel size all the way around.
0:21:29I think that that's a better design
0:21:34than the weird, ugly ass notch
0:21:36that the Pixels had last year.
0:21:39- And last year, the notch was only on the bigger one.
0:21:41The smaller one didn't have a notch.
0:21:42So did they have an opinion on notches?
0:21:44Did they do one with a notch
0:21:45just because they wanted to support it in Android
0:21:47I figured they had to do it themselves.
0:21:48I don't understand their opinions though.
0:21:50- Yeah, and they obviously didn't spend a lot of work
0:21:53last year on the corner radius of the rounded off screen.
0:21:57Sort of like a first pass.
0:21:59- And this year it's gestures.
0:22:00I mean, they're sort of like the iPhone,
0:22:01but they don't work the same as the iPhone
0:22:03and they just end up confusing.
0:22:04It's always a little bit of halfway.
0:22:06- Yeah, I gotta say I'm not, I mean, I'll try it
0:22:08and I don't wanna prejudge it,
0:22:09but what they're doing the radar stuff with
0:22:13does not interest me really.
0:22:15I don't really, I can't imagine,
0:22:17so they have a feature now that you can wave your hand
0:22:20without touching the phone and do a couple things.
0:22:23One of them is you can fast forward tracks
0:22:27if music is playing by just passing your hand over it.
0:22:30You can, the useful one seems to be that it'll sense
0:22:36when your hand gets near and fire up
0:22:39their face recognition sensors
0:22:42so that before you're even pointing it at your face,
0:22:45they're already looking because they know your hand
0:22:47has entered the little sphere of three-dimensional space
0:22:50above the phone.
0:22:52And I guess you can tickle your Pokemon or something
0:22:54on your home screen by just waving at it,
0:22:57which really seems weird.
0:22:59- The whole thing in there was odd to me too.
0:23:01I think it's a good idea to warm up the camera
0:23:04if it detects you, but Apple had the iPhone 11 event
0:23:07and they have a U1 chip in the iPhone 11
0:23:09and they didn't mention it because there's no compelling
0:23:11user-facing feature yet.
0:23:13on their product page at the bottom, it says,
0:23:15"Yeah, it'll help you with AirDrop."
0:23:16But the obvious consumer-facing feature hasn't shipped yet,
0:23:21so they stayed mum.
0:23:23Where with this, it feels like they don't,
0:23:25it's nothing like the early demos.
0:23:27The early demo showed people doing very fine-grained
0:23:29controls of radios and video and all these things,
0:23:32and none of that is ready.
0:23:34So I would have just completely downplayed it,
0:23:36just not mentioned it very much at all.
0:23:38And everyone left being disappointed,
0:23:39like, "Oh, it wasn't as good as the demo."
0:23:41- Right, there are white papers on the technology,
0:23:45or I don't know if that's their official term,
0:23:46but they've talked about the technology for years,
0:23:49and they make it sound as though it's as fine-grained
0:23:53as the touchscreen itself, right?
0:23:55So in the way-- - We have videos showing it.
0:23:57- Yeah, so you can, if you're adjusting the volume
0:24:01on your phone by using the slider in your finger,
0:24:03and you have this incredible fine-grained control,
0:24:06they're showing it that you could just hold your finger
0:24:08above the phone and get the same thing,
0:24:10Whereas all they really have here is simple,
0:24:13broad stroke, fast forward, next track type.
0:24:15- Which aren't working consistently.
0:24:17If you look at the reviewers somewhere,
0:24:18I think Marques was saying it worked 10% at first.
0:24:20He's figured out how to make it work 60% of the time.
0:24:23And that's not a flagship feature.
0:24:25- No, but that's terrible.
0:24:26I think anything that's less than 100% is terrible.
0:24:28And it gets me to, I mean, I have complaints
0:24:31about Apple stuff that works like that too.
0:24:33- Yes, same.
0:24:34- Trying to think of a good one.
0:24:38I mean a lot of the stuff with iOS 13 is just still kind of busted.
0:24:44Yeah, I'm trying to think of it. Off the top of my head I can't think of it, but maybe some Apple TV type interactions are pretty good.
0:24:52Like even though I use Apple TV all the time, me using that little remote to move the selection around the screen, I'm still not as precise as I think I should be.
0:25:01That's for example one example.
0:25:04- The big one for me on Apple TV is apparently
0:25:06the longer you press, it's whether it'll shoot you back
0:25:09to the episode selector or all the way back to the screen.
0:25:12And I could never get that right.
0:25:13So I would just always try to go, no wrong episode,
0:25:15try to go back, oh, I'm back on the home screen,
0:25:17play the episode again, oh, I'm back on the home screen.
0:25:19It was like a random frustration generator.
0:25:21- Oh, I can think of a good example.
0:25:22A good example is the keyboard problems
0:25:25people are having on MacBooks,
0:25:27where even if your keyboard isn't completely failed,
0:25:30Like if it's just that like, you know, one time out of 50,
0:25:34you'd hit the E key and get two E's instead of one E.
0:25:39And it's only one out of 50.
0:25:40That's terrible.
0:25:41That's absolutely unacceptable.
0:25:42It has to be every time.
0:25:43Like when you click an okay button in the dialogue,
0:25:45it has to click every time.
0:25:47So like trying to do next track with a gesture
0:25:50and the gesture only works 60% of the time,
0:25:52that you'll, I mean, 60% is so low
0:25:56that you'll stop using the feature.
0:25:57There's no way.
0:25:58- Even just like Siri still,
0:25:59Like if I tell it to call my mom,
0:26:01nine out of 10 times is perfect.
0:26:02The 10th time it recommends a,
0:26:04sorry, a veterinarian to cross town from me.
0:26:08And then you have learned helplessness.
0:26:09- Yeah, Siri's a perfect example of that too.
0:26:12And there's just stuff,
0:26:13and to me the bar for that is a little bit different
0:26:17than a physical UI, right?
0:26:21Like a button that you tap on a touchscreen
0:26:24or click on a mouse-driven interface
0:26:28or a keyboard shortcut you invoke to do it
0:26:31is very, very, it's provable whether it worked
0:26:36or didn't work exactly as expected
0:26:40with the latency you expect.
0:26:42Whereas the Siri stuff is always gonna be a little nebulous
0:26:46as to where the edge conditions lie.
0:26:50But for the most part, to me, I think that the standards
0:26:54by which we should judge Siri
0:26:56the similar voice assistants is basically what if you hired a college kid to be your intern?
0:27:01Would you expect them to understand what you just said? And if you, you know, so if you hired
0:27:07somebody to be your assistant and follow you around, and you're like, you wanted to call
0:27:12your mom and you don't want to touch the phone, you're like, get my mom on the phone, right? You
0:27:17expect your mother to be on the phone every single time. You don't expect to have like a pizza place
0:27:22open up. Did you see Joanna's video for the Pixel this morning? With the speed talker? Yeah,
0:27:33she's always so creative with those videos and she put the, because the new Google voice recorder
0:27:36also transcribes, so of course she got someone with a Scottish accent, with a West Indian accent,
0:27:42with a German accent, transatlantic, yeah maybe we're Australian or something, and the world's
0:27:47fastest talker and just let them all loose on it. Yeah the world's fastest talker or fastest woman
0:27:52talker. I'm not quite sure if she has the record, but that was just cruel.
0:27:58But the stenographer kept up, which was amazing.
0:28:01Yeah, I will. Yeah. And she had a professional court stenographer there,
0:28:04like the Paul Bunyan, the real-life flesh and blood alternative. Anyway, that is a killer feature,
0:28:12I have to say, for me personally, as somebody who occasionally, somewhat occasionally,
0:28:16needs or wants transcription. Boy, that's a fantastic feature that I wish, I hope the iPhone
0:28:21can follow as quickly as possible.
0:28:24It seems to work for you.
0:28:25Yeah, well someone pointed out that Clips does a little bit of that.
0:28:26So hopefully Apple can flesh that out into a full-fledged.
0:28:29Yeah.
0:28:30But something like that if you have an on-the-record meeting as somebody
0:28:34in the press, or if you're a student and you want to record a lecture
0:28:36or something, that if you can hear it and understand it,
0:28:40your iPhone can hear it and transcribe it.
0:28:43And hopefully--
0:28:43The other thing that was baffling for me is that they have the brand new Google
0:28:46Assistant.
0:28:47It's only available in the US for now, which that happens.
0:28:49That's fine.
0:28:50But if you have a Google Apps account,
0:28:53doesn't matter if it's first account, second account.
0:28:57If you have one on, the Assistant will not work.
0:28:59What?
0:29:00Yeah, if you have a Gmail account, it's fine.
0:29:02But if you have a Google Apps account or a Gmail account
0:29:05and a Google Apps account, the Assistant just will not work.
0:29:08Oh, that's a strange limitation.
0:29:09And they said they're working on a fix,
0:29:10but it always seems like Google Apps accounts, which
0:29:12people pay for, get way shorter shift than the Gmail accounts.
0:29:15Wow, that's really weird.
0:29:16And it also seems like the sort of problem
0:29:18you'd more expect from Apple, you know,
0:29:21the various ongoing problems that those of us
0:29:24with two iTunes accounts, iCloud accounts,
0:29:27whatever you wanna call them, Apple IDs, still get.
0:29:31I don't wanna go on a whole sidetrack,
0:29:36but basically I, among other old,
0:29:38the longer you've been using Apple products,
0:29:40the more likely you are to be in this boat,
0:29:42where you opened up a iTunes store account
0:29:46in the early 2000s with email address A,
0:29:51and then later on with Mac.com,
0:29:53created a Mac.com or a me.com account
0:29:56to use Mac.com features,
0:30:00but that's not the same thing you use for iTunes,
0:30:02and still lo these many years later in 2019,
0:30:06you've still got two separate accounts
0:30:09because there's no way to merge them,
0:30:11which I understand would be incredibly complicated,
0:30:14and you know that there's all sorts of edge conditions
0:30:17you could run into there.
0:30:18Because if I want to, I can go to a new machine
0:30:20and log in with my iTunes account.
0:30:22And it is an Apple ID.
0:30:23So I could use iMessage and note syncing
0:30:26and calendar syncing all from that account.
0:30:29I'm sure there's some people who are somehow
0:30:34using two different things.
0:30:35And so merging them would be complicated.
0:30:37On the surface it sounds like, jeez,
0:30:41why can't I just say I would like to just use
0:30:43my iCloud account for everything and transfer all the iTunes accounts from this other account
0:30:47over in a one-time transition and then that's that. But I get it, that's complicated.
0:30:53But anyway, living life like that is always a little bit more complicated than the people
0:30:57who have it all in one. You don't know how lucky you are if you only have one. It's
0:31:02good to know Google has problems like that too. Anyway, I thought Dieter's basic opening
0:31:07is the framing of his review read very iPhone-y to me as well. So I've always thought that
0:31:18the pixels were, as a whole, the whole project is sort of Google's take on iPhone-style hardware
0:31:22with stuff like screens that aren't super-saturated, less blingy, more understated design. You
0:31:31know, there is a sort of designed-in-California look to their stuff, too, that's different
0:31:36than stuff that's designed in Korea or China or Japan, you know, with some of Sony's very
0:31:42cool stuff. Dieter's review though made it almost it almost read like the opening to
0:31:49like what kind of product is he reviewing here, you'd almost think it was an Apple product
0:31:53because it was about how specs don't tell the story of the product. And you can't just
0:31:58look at the specs. You have to kind of look at the actual experience and you could say,
0:32:03this phone it doesn't have the fastest processor and it doesn't have the greatest camera hardware
0:32:07but you look at the actual photos you get from it and they look better than
0:32:11other ones the other phones that might on on paper seemingly have a better camera.
0:32:17No that's absolutely true. Huawei and Samsung both have tremendous some of the Nokia stuff
0:32:22tremendous optics on them and they just they junk them up with really bad color science really poor
0:32:26color management the cameras look different from one system to the other and yeah or they
0:32:31they overblow them with AI,
0:32:33what they call their AI modes and they over saturate them.
0:32:35And Google, you can, like, I think if you look at them,
0:32:38you can subjectively choose which one you prefer
0:32:40because at this point they're both so good.
0:32:42It's the artistic choices.
0:32:43Like Google's tend to look cooler.
0:32:46Apple's tend to look a little bit warmer.
0:32:47They do different stuff with the details.
0:32:49Their semantic rendering is slightly different,
0:32:51but that is just personal preference at this point.
0:32:53And it's amazing we've gotten to the point
0:32:55where it comes down to that.
0:32:56- Yeah, there's definitely,
0:32:58can definitely see the different internal aesthetic choices in there. So what else with
0:33:07the Pixel? I had another thought. Oh, I guess we could talk about the lens decisions. Why
0:33:14don't we hold on to that, though, and I'll do the first sponsor break and tell you about
0:33:19are good friends at Away. Away makes excellent carry-on and larger suitcases. They've considered
0:33:32all sorts of travelers and with their carry-on now offered in two sizes with an optional
0:33:37ejectable battery, you can find a carry-on suitcase that will suit your needs and your
0:33:42lifestyle perfectly. They've got two body types, their signature polycarbonate and the
0:33:48fancier anodized aluminum and both are guaranteed for life. Their suitcases are lightweight.
0:33:55The polycarbonate is very, very durable. The aluminum of course is durable. Everybody knows
0:34:00the qualities of aluminum. The removable battery is just a game changer for me because it is,
0:34:07it just turns out that the top of your carry on suitcase is like just the best place to
0:34:11keep a big TSA compliant battery right there. Whoever thought we'd be charging our suitcases,
0:34:21but there you are. But anyway, the battery that they include is so, so capable. I think
0:34:25it has five times of an iPhone charge. You don't really, it's not like you have to charge
0:34:30your suitcase every time you leave. I charge it like once or twice a year. That's it. And
0:34:33then every time I'm waiting in an airport, I've got two USB ports right there on top
0:34:37my suitcase to charge me or and one of my traveling companions devices right there while we wait.
0:34:43No more hunting in the airport for one of like three seats that happen to be next to a power
0:34:48outlet. No more being the dirty bum and the sitting on the floor of the airport just because it's
0:34:53right there next to an outlet. Charge it from anywhere. Inside the suitcases they have an
0:34:58internal compression system lets you pack more. Sounds like BS but it's actually true. It's really
0:35:05a great way. They got a little section there where you can put folded up shirts, cinch them down with
0:35:09a hard panel. Very easy. And then you get to where you're going and your shirts aren't all wrinkled
0:35:14up. The wheels on the suitcases are fantastic. Really durable. I've had one as long as you can
0:35:21remember away sponsoring this show. They sent me a suitcase way back when. Mine still feels and looks
0:35:27like brand new. It is a may it truly their durability is not to be underestimated.
0:35:33So we've got a couple of them now in the house. They all look great. I've got my original,
0:35:36still looks brand new. No interest in upgrading or changing. I don't need to. Why would I do that?
0:35:41It still looks brand new. I take it everywhere I go. I really love it. Here's the deal they have
0:35:46for talk show listeners. 20 bucks. Save 20 bucks by going to awaytravel.com/talkshow20
0:35:53and just use that same promo code talk show 20. T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W-2-0 and use it during checkout.
0:36:02out you'll save 20 bucks. That's awaytravel.com/talkshow20. Really great product. Love it.
0:36:13So there was a story, another story at the Verge. I think it was like right after the
0:36:19iPhone 11 events by Sam Byford. It was like, I think literally said that Apple needed to
0:36:26catch up to Android this year on the camera.
0:36:31And it had been taken as a point of just fact for the last year
0:36:37that the Pixel 3 was a better camera than the iPhone XS.
0:36:42And Vlad was writing that a lot as well.
0:36:44And I disagree.
0:36:47I really do.
0:36:47And I might say, oh, you know, Neelay and I
0:36:50talked about this a few weeks ago on the Verge crash.
0:36:54I feel like the differences were, they were real.
0:36:57And I could see why subjectively somebody would prefer
0:37:01the Pixel 3 for still photography.
0:37:02But objectively, I think that there were plus and minuses
0:37:06on both sides.
0:37:07And, you know, Night Sight was the one feature
0:37:11the Pixel 3 had for a year that the iPhone XS couldn't do.
0:37:15But it wasn't, you know, how often do you need it?
0:37:18And, you know, I don't know.
0:37:21- I mean, I was on that portrait mode
0:37:23before Google did it, but it didn't seem
0:37:25to have such a big a reaction.
0:37:26- Right, you know, there's things
0:37:29that the iPhone still camera could do
0:37:30that the Pixel couldn't, and for just regular photography,
0:37:34I think it was debatable.
0:37:35But I thought-- - The biggest thing for me
0:37:36is that we went to CES and I was shooting with an iPhone
0:37:39and everyone from our Android team
0:37:40started off shooting with a Pixel,
0:37:42but the camera just wouldn't launch,
0:37:44they would miss the shot and the video would drop frames,
0:37:46and by a day in, they'd all switch to Samsung
0:37:48and Huawei phones because it didn't matter
0:37:50how good the camera was if it couldn't get
0:37:52shocked for them. And I think that's one of the most underappreciated aspects of a
0:37:56camera.
0:37:57Yeah, and that was a knock against the Pixel 3 too with startup time. And we've all been
0:38:02in that situation. And at times, I've even wondered whether Apple should make, you know,
0:38:07should they add a dedicated phone button? And I can see why they don't. The Nokia
0:38:12phones back in the day had a dedicated shutter button just for the camera and launching it.
0:38:19We've all been in that situation where there's,
0:38:21"Oh my God, there's something cute or amazing
0:38:23"or whatever going on.
0:38:24"I need to get my camera fired up as fast as possible."
0:38:26And you really don't want that to be delayed.
0:38:28But I thought the other thing, it was sort of a,
0:38:33it's a well-known trope that the Macalope observes
0:38:39very keenly, was that the gist of Biford's explanation
0:38:43of how the, or assertion that the iPhone needed
0:38:46catch up on the phone or on the camera was by citing at least three different Android
0:38:54phones. You know, like, it didn't have Night Sight, which the Pixel did. It didn't have
0:38:59an ultra wide lens, which these Huawei and other brand phones did. And it didn't have
0:39:05something else that some other phone did. But none of those three phones have the three
0:39:09features. You know what I mean? Like you could say, quote, unquote, Android had these three
0:39:12features, but you had to have three different phones to have all three features. It's just
0:39:16a sort of a classic gotcha of comparing the Apple ecosystem to Windows back in the day to Android in
0:39:24recent years. I thought that the extra lens thing was particularly rich if you're going to—because
0:39:31usually people held up the Pixel as the best Android camera phone, I think with good reason.
0:39:41But if, you know, on those grounds, clearly it was the Pixel that needed to catch up and now still
0:39:46needs to catch up. It still only has two lenses even at the highest lens, at the highest version.
0:39:51And again, I don't say that that proves that the iPhone is ahead. I'm just saying I think
0:39:56it requires a much more nuanced discussion. And I think that the certainty that some
0:40:03Pixel aficionados feel that they have the best still camera phone is maybe not warranted.
0:40:09Yeah, it's very subjective.
0:40:14Which brings me to this discussion of, okay, if you're going to add, like the standard
0:40:19lens on a modern cell phone camera is pretty consistently in field of view at what in 35
0:40:28millimeter terms would be around a 26 to 28 millimeter lens.
0:40:37And there's a good argument to be made that we should kind of get away from those terms
0:40:43anymore.
0:40:45And Apple certainly has.
0:40:46Apple doesn't really describe them.
0:40:47Apple just calls them 1x, 2x, and now 0.5x, which is a better way of thinking about it.
0:40:53And field of view, which is measured in an angle.
0:40:56In other words, what angle from the lens pointing forward is captured in the sensor makes more
0:41:08sense than just using 35mm sensor film terms, especially as 35mm sensors become a smaller
0:41:15and smaller part of the camera landscape.
0:41:21So what we call a 1x lens on most of these cameras is very, very similar in field of
0:41:26view. Just a tiny fraction. The iPhone is a little bit wider than the Pixel was last
0:41:31year. I don't know how they compare this year. But if you set a Pixel 3 and an iPhone
0:41:36XS up last year, you could, if you knew what to look for, if they were set up at the exact
0:41:42same location, you could tell instantly which one was which because the iPhones would be
0:41:46a little bit wider. So you'd capture a little bit more information along the sides of the
0:41:51the image. So depending on the subject you were photographing, you could just see it
0:41:56if there's a little bit more. Like I think if you really wanted to do a side-by-side,
0:42:03like double-blind, which one do you like, part of it would have been you'd have to
0:42:08crop the iPhone pictures like one or two percent and do like a center crop just to get the
0:42:14same field of view. If you're going to add a second lens, and now everybody's adding
0:42:20second lenses because it's just the physics of these devices and you know how thin they
0:42:26need to be mean you at least in the near future there's no way to make a zoom lens meaning
0:42:33a lens that adjusts from these different fields of view so if you want to get the effects
0:42:40of a zoom lens the advantages meaning to be able to go even wider or to zoom in more without
0:42:48resorting to digital zoom, you need second and third camera lenses. I kind of feel and
0:42:57did you watch the Pixel 4 event?
0:42:59Yes.
0:43:00I forget the guy's name. Do you know the guy's name who's like their camera guy?
0:43:04Oh, it's Mark. I'm blanking on his name too. He's the guy who made all those computations
0:43:08with that original computational photography app.
0:43:11Yeah, he's a very smart guy. I think he was a little salty about the ultra wide lens.
0:43:17lens yeah like i kind of feel like google got caught with their just caught maybe making the
0:43:26wrong decision on that front and that mark levoie mark levoie i'm gonna have to write this down
0:43:32and i really think that apple made the right decision now that the non-pro
0:43:43$799 new iPhone has two lenses. Instead of following in the footsteps of the iPhone 10
0:43:50and 10S and going telephoto as the second lens, it only goes ultra-wide. I think that's
0:43:56the right move for most people. I think it's also the right move for the non-pro phone.
0:44:03And I'm on the record as saying we don't have to worry so much about what pro means in the
0:44:09parlance of an iPhone Pro. It really can just mean iPhone premium. Yes, whether it's professional
0:44:16or not. But the truth is, as just a basic rule of thumb, the wider the lens, the more
0:44:24fun it is, right? And you can get, you know, some actual comical effects with the ultra
0:44:32wide by having a subject really close and it exaggerates it. And then the longer the
0:44:38lens the more serious it is. It just gives you a more serious feel. That's why the portrait lens,
0:44:43you know, defaults to the two X perspective. It just is a more staid perspective. I remember
0:44:52reading an interview once with Billy Crystal and he was talking, I forget who directed the movies,
0:45:00but I think it was about city slickers to remember city slickers. And then there was
0:45:03City Slickers was a smash hit and was a big, big hit and made Jack Parlance,
0:45:09who was the crufty old cowboy, became a, you know, it had been like a big star in the 50s and 60s.
0:45:14All of a sudden he became big star again. And then they made a sequel and the sequel wasn't so good.
0:45:21And the story I heard was that Billy Crystal was talking to a new director for it and he was
0:45:26talking to somebody else, I think like Rob Reiner, who wasn't involved with it. And he was just like,
0:45:31from the set and he was just like so i could be butchering this anecdote but i know it was
0:45:34billy crystal i know it was i know it was city slickers too may or may not have been rob riner
0:45:39but anyway he was talking to somebody who he trusted as a director of comedy and he said hey
0:45:44he always told me that wide angle lenses are funny and he's like yeah yeah that's real fast
0:45:48you want something to be funny you got to put a wide angle lens on the camera and he goes would it
0:45:51this guy's not putting nope this guy's shooting everything with a long lens and it was just like
0:45:55crickets on the other end of the phone and then billy crystal was like yeah i thought so
0:45:59It is though, but it's true. It really is fun. And I think just reading it, I think
0:46:06I've read more people on Twitter who seem less, you know, prosumerary photo enthusiast
0:46:15types and just more casual. I just shoot photos. They seem to be using the wide angle lens
0:46:21more than, than I saw people using the telephoto lens in the whole two years when, when the
0:46:28the iPhone if you had two lenses, or I guess three years maybe, where if the iPhone had
0:46:33dual lenses, the second lens was telephoto.
0:46:36Yeah, you know, I think that's really true. And it's interesting to me because I would
0:46:42shoot a lot with the telephoto lens, but mostly because I wanted the bokeh and it gets a much
0:46:45nicer natural bokeh than the other lens than the the ultra wide angle lens. But you can
0:46:50computationally deliver telephoto Google did it last year with the Pixel three and super
0:46:55That's essentially what they were doing was making a computational telephoto lens
0:46:58But you can't do that with ultra wide-angle because you don't have the extra data. It just is it doesn't exist
0:47:04So putting even on an iPhone 11 not the pro you have the wide-angle and the ultra wide-angle
0:47:09You can still do a zoom
0:47:12I wish Apple would put the button on there because I think it's a better user experience to just do the the 2x button
0:47:16But you can zoom in and it's still a usable shot
0:47:19You cannot zoom out on a pixel and I think that's a loss and when I look at a lot of the Android reviewers
0:47:24Because like you mentioned not not a lot of the phones used to have every option but now a Huawei phone at Samsung phone
0:47:30All of them have ultra wide all of them have night mode and it's pixel that stands out for not having everything. Yeah
0:47:36Ben Rubenstein is the developer behind the excellent halide app along with his yes
0:47:43Colleague Sebastian Dewit, who's the designer of the app?
0:47:48Did some interesting work last year on?
0:47:54Just comparing the 1x camera
0:47:57Doing a 2x digital zoom versus yeah, Ben
0:48:02Sandovski this name what I forget how I mispronounced it. Sorry Ben
0:48:06But Ben Sandovski really smart developer really knows this stuff really found that in a lot a surprisingly well lit
0:48:14Well lit but indoor lighting conditions a 1x camera with two with the 2x digital zoom
0:48:22using a smart zoom algorithm would get you a better image than using a 2x camera with a slower lens meaning
0:48:28slower meaning works worse with less light
0:48:31You know digital the gist of it being digital zoom has gotten better than you think and in the old days when digital
0:48:39Photography was new it was like don't ever resort to digital zoom, you know, unless you really really have to because it just looks like
0:48:46muddy
0:48:48Blurry pixels at every level whereas it's gotten better and like you said you can do it
0:48:55However, whatever the trade-offs are of doing a digital zoom it
0:48:58It's still certainly getting you that frame of view. Whereas there's absolutely no way to fake
0:49:040.5 X lens field of view
0:49:08I don't think most people notice because on the iPhone it will switch between
0:49:11The real telephoto and sort of a fake telephoto if it gets into lower light
0:49:15And I don't know how many people actually notice when it's doing that because when I point it out they're super surprised
0:49:20No, and nobody nobody noticed. I mean all of us we wrote I'm not maybe somebody noticed
0:49:25I don't know but I even wrote a piece a couple weeks ago about how when you're in night
0:49:29Night mode on the iPhone 11 Pro it always uses the 1x camera lens
0:49:34So if you're doing 2x in in night mode on a 11 Pro
0:49:39It's using the 1x sensor and doing a digital zoom
0:49:43along with the interpolation of multiple exposures, you know
0:49:47And nobody knew nobody really caught on to that and there was a bit of
0:49:53Apple not wanting to talk about how it worked which was weird and should have raised a flag people because if you did get the
0:49:59Telephoto lens it looked like night mode didn't work and then when you didn't get it
0:50:02It looked like night mode worked and you couldn't figure out why sometimes you don't work at 2x and not others and it was just confusing
0:50:07Yeah
0:50:08And you can do you can always prove this and it's just the simplest most obvious thing in the world if you're ever confused as
0:50:13of which camera lens your iPhone is using for a "2x" shot, just cover one of the lenses
0:50:19with your finger and you can actually see it happen.
0:50:24Basically, I think that the confusion is that Apple in some ways presents the new camera
0:50:32zoom interface with these separate buttons.
0:50:35On the iPhone 11, you get a 0.5 and 1x buttons, but no 2x button.
0:50:41And then on the iPhone 11 Pro, you get three buttons, 0.5, 1, and 2x.
0:50:46And at some level, they want you—and I think overall they've really achieved—I think
0:50:52that the camera team at Apple is doing some of the best user experience work in the industry.
0:51:00In terms of what they're doing with the user interface and exposing a little bit more
0:51:05complexity but in ways that don't get in a way of using the camera in the most
0:51:13simplistic way possible which they know is what most people do is open the
0:51:18camera make sure you're either in camera or video mode and then hit the button
0:51:22right that's what people do and they've really not gotten in the way of that but
0:51:27they've really exposed what you can do in a very you know very useful ways
0:51:33there's a little bit of conflation there though where they really want you to
0:51:38treat it as one camera yeah you can zoom in and out of and you don't have to
0:51:42worry about the fact that there are three physical cameras on the back it's
0:51:47just one camera app and it just zooms in and out like the way a point-and-shoot
0:51:52camera can zoom in and out you know and you don't have to worry about it that
0:51:55it's technically three different cameras and three different sensors and three
0:51:59different maximum, you know, exposure speeds and stuff like
0:52:04that. You don't have to worry about it. It'll just do what you
0:52:06needs to do to get the best image at the perspective you're
0:52:10looking for. But at the other hand, they still there is some
0:52:14aspect of it, whereby only having the two x button on the
0:52:18one that has the two x lens physical lens. It kind of makes
0:52:22you feel that hitting that button is giving you that
0:52:25camera that physical can agreed yeah it whereas that's not the case it's really
0:52:32just about the field of view and it just means 0.5 is always going to give you
0:52:37the 0.5 camera because there's no other way to fake it 1x is always going to
0:52:42give you the 1x camera because if it's the best camera period so if you want
0:52:47the 1x field of view it's never going to be better by cropping the other the
0:52:52other images. The 2x though is the mystery where sometimes it if you're outdoors and
0:53:00there's lots of light it's going to give you the 2x camera physically but indoors it may
0:53:04not and if night sight it never will. Yeah. But that's okay. The other interesting thing
0:53:10for me is that there's there's almost like this battle inside Apple because on one hand
0:53:14they exactly what you said they just want it to be a camera you pick it up you shoot
0:53:18you don't worry about it but on the other hand some of the technology is so cool they
0:53:21resist talking about it. So I think like in a perfect world they wouldn't really
0:53:25talk about deep fusion it would just be the camera shoots and it gives you the
0:53:29best possible image based on when you're shooting and over time right now we have
0:53:34Smart HDR and we have deep fusion and we have night mode and they're distinct and
0:53:38it switches between them but over time it's probably going to do some amount of
0:53:42each of them depending exactly on where you are in the continuum of lighting and
0:53:46they will be less distinct but for right now people keep asking well when when do
0:53:50I see deep fusion and Apple clearly doesn't want you to care because there's no deep fusion button
0:53:55There's no night mode button, but at the same time they love the technology so much
0:53:58They talk about it so people think that they're these distinct modes. Yeah. Yeah
0:54:04Still haven't done I'm kind of waiting, you know
0:54:06I have I went ahead and put I was thirteen point two developer betas on my my daily carry iPhone just because
0:54:14Because I say what do I have to lose?
0:54:16based on I would say the
0:54:19point one point two is okay. It's not a horror show of bugs. Point three is slightly better.
0:54:27I think I'd already switched to the developer base before that. But I just figured why not,
0:54:33I might as well just use this and get deep fusion as quickly as possible.
0:54:38But people are sweating a lot. They're just showing these sweater pictures and saying,
0:54:42"Can you see the difference?" And I don't think you're meant to. I don't think it's
0:54:44supposed to work that way. Yeah, I don't think so either.
0:54:47I forget where I was going with that, but basically I feel like Apple did the right
0:54:57thing by going ultra-wide on the 11. I think it's more fun. I think it's impossible
0:55:03to duplicate in software. And I do agree with you. I still kind of feel, though, that the
0:55:10regular iPhone 11 non-pro should have a 2X button.
0:55:14Yeah, and they could even style it differently like make it like a lighter color or light slightly less vibrant
0:55:21I don't know. There's some kind of some kind of indication to show that it would that it would be software only
0:55:25Maybe I don't know or maybe not
0:55:27Software only portrait mode and they didn't really they didn't write any different way
0:55:31It was just right, but just just as a convenient way to jump to an exact 2x digital zoom
0:55:38Which is an interesting perspective and you know it to me
0:55:43Yes, you can you can get there through the dial and the dial clicks a little bit at the 2x marker
0:55:48But it just does a nice way to jump there and to get the exact if that's what you want for a couple of shots
0:55:54To know that you're exactly at two point zero X and not two point one or one point nine that would satisfy me
0:56:01the the vaguely
0:56:04OCD parts of my brain if I'm gonna take a series of shots from this field of view
0:56:08I want it to be exactly 2.0. I don't want it faster than dialing it dialing
0:56:13It is a little bit of fidgety pressing that button is just immediate. Yeah, it's very immediate very exact very satisfying
0:56:19so I but I so it's sort of hard to defend not including it other than as
0:56:24What I call marketing spite that they just wanted to reserve that as a way to emphasize that the iPhone 11 pro
0:56:32Has a 2x an entire 2x camera system. Yeah, that's three modes instead of two
0:56:38Yeah
0:56:40Here before we take another break I've got follow-up I would need to mention from my last episode
0:56:45I was talking about Ben Ben Thompson, and I were talking about our
0:56:49sort of
0:56:52Conservative upgrade cycle to new versions of Mac OS and then neither of us were upgrading primary machines to Catalina yet
0:56:58Ben's Ben waits like a year. It's very he's very pessimistic on new Mac OS software quality
0:57:06I'm gonna upgrade sooner rather than later
0:57:08I usually wait a year, but I did it this year just cuz I could not finish the review without using it on my primary
0:57:14Machine there was just too much new stuff
0:57:15I mentioned looking forward to sidecar
0:57:17But I also mentioned looking forward to sidecar after extolling my my deep and abiding love for the 2014
0:57:25MacBook Pro that is my daily driver
0:57:28Completely forgetting the fact that sidecar requires like a 2016 MacBook or later
0:57:34Yeah, because it needs like the t2 chip and I knew that
0:57:37But I completely forgot it while I was talking about it and it doesn't really reduce my interest in upgrading this machine to Catalina
0:57:44But a little bit it does because I'm gonna have to use a different machine just to try
0:57:48sidecar
0:57:50but I'm curious what you think of sidecar sidecar of course is the feature that allows you to
0:57:54Use your iPad as an external display
0:57:57Including using the pencil for as input to a Mac app
0:58:01that can take
0:58:04stylus type input and
0:58:07And you, as somebody who illustrates and is a big pencil user, I'm curious,
0:58:12have you given Sidecar a good ride yet?
0:58:13**Matt Stauffer** Yeah. I mean, I used it a lot through the beta,
0:58:16but it was kind of hard to use because none of the apps, none of the third-party apps could be
0:58:21updated to support it yet. I like some of the features, some of the stuff they say,
0:58:25like, you can just use it to sign documents. I do that stuff directly on the iPad or just sketching
0:58:29notes. I just do that directly on the iPad. I don't need it. Maybe if I'm using the Mac already,
0:58:33It's slightly more convenient, but I would just pick up the iPad and use those directly
0:58:37I love it as a second screen though
0:58:39especially if I'm editing in Final Cut and I have like a meeting on Google Meet or I just wanted to have slack or
0:58:45I message up I have that all the time now
0:58:47I just put the iPad up and it's great because I can leave the full screen on Final Cut and I can do everything else
0:58:52on the iPad and slowly but surely
0:58:55Photoshop was was tough but slowly but surely apps are updating now and I love that
0:59:00but I can just pick it up, draw with the pencil,
0:59:03put it back down, go back to editing with the mouse.
0:59:06I think over the next month or two,
0:59:07as the more and more apps update,
0:59:09I'm just gonna do that all the time.
0:59:11- And there's a happy little story here where
0:59:14Luna Display, which is a great little company
0:59:19that came out with these dongles
0:59:21that go into the USB-C port of your newer Mac
0:59:29or the Thunderbolt port on a slightly older Mac
0:59:33and trick the Mac into thinking it's an entire display
0:59:36that's been plugged in where what it really does
0:59:38is just transmit the image to the Luna Display app
0:59:41on your iPad so that you can use your iPad
0:59:43as a second display.
0:59:45And yeah, sidecar to use our little rackets term for it,
0:59:51Sherlock to that feature pretty hard
0:59:53because it's built into the system.
0:59:57going to do things that using an app and a dongle just aren't as convenient for.
1:00:02But the good news is the Luna Display team, rather than just go and drink and be sad about
1:00:11getting Sherlock to put their heads down and did a lot of work, already have announced that they've
1:00:17They've got a Mac to Mac mode for Luna display, which will let you use, like, for example,
1:00:27a 5K iMac as an external display wirelessly, which is really, really cool.
1:00:35A really interesting use case for, like, especially to me, the device that really stands out as,
1:00:42that's this is a great way to keep that machine and your active use is the like
1:00:46The five six year old iMac 5k is which still have but by today's standards outstanding displays
1:00:54It's still hard. It is really hard to find a
1:00:585k external display and with
1:01:01Like the price of like the selling price of like a 5k
1:01:05iMac even a new one is actually in the ballpark of what you might expect for you know
1:01:09You think like well what a waste to have an entire
1:01:11iMac computer go to waste and just use it as a display, but when you look at the prices,
1:01:17it's actually not bad.
1:01:19Jared Polin It's great, and Apple doesn't sell a standalone.
1:01:22Pete Turner Right.
1:01:23Jared Polin It's like that.
1:01:24Pete Turner As we head towards the launch of the Mac Pro,
1:01:29and it's like, are we really going to have a scenario where the only first-party Apple
1:01:34display is a $6,000 Pro Display XDR?
1:01:396K for 6K.
1:01:43What the hell am I going to do?
1:01:44People who don't really want to buy the LG displays, it seems ridiculous to buy this
1:01:50expensive Mac Pro and then use an iMac as your display, but it might be a good secondary
1:01:56display.
1:01:57I don't know.
1:01:58I just see this as being very useful to a lot of people.
1:02:00I'm glad to see Lunax still doing awesome work.
1:02:04Yeah, absolutely.
1:02:05Absolutely. Probably get Sherlock'd in 1016 next year.
1:02:08And they'll just Mario art him right back again. Yeah, exactly. Just but I mean, it's just the
1:02:14perfect attitude with your hardware software developer. It's like you kind of have to,
1:02:17you ought to be thinking with whether it's an app or a product. Might Apple steal this idea?
1:02:23I mean, I don't know, maybe that's a hard word steal. But you know what I mean? At least if
1:02:27you're on the team, it's can feel like they stole your idea. If the answer is yes, then you should
1:02:31should have a plan B for when that'll happen. Like if it seems
1:02:34like it would be a good idea built into the system. It
1:02:38there's a very high chance it will be built into the system.
1:02:40And it's probably you know, the truth is, it's probably a higher
1:02:43chance than if you didn't build your product because the
1:02:46existence proof of Hey, here's a cool product that does this
1:02:48thing makes it a very compelling argument. You know, inside Apple
1:02:53to Yeah, we should do this right. Like that sounds like a
1:02:56good idea is one thing here. Look at this. Look at what these
1:02:59guys did is a way more compelling way to say, "Yeah, we should build that into the system."
1:03:05Steve McLaughlin Yeah, but they're also almost always only
1:03:07going to do the baseline feature and leave a lot of gaps. So you can really thrive in
1:03:12making the better version.
1:03:13Dave Asprey Right. If there's room in whatever your idea
1:03:15is to go deeper and stuff like that, usually there's room to do that. For example, my
1:03:22favorite example this year is the beefed up reminders app, which is, I think, I don't
1:03:28how you could argue that it's not an improvement over the almost rudimentary reminders app
1:03:35we've had until now, but I don't think is going to put any kind of dent in the sales
1:03:40of apps like Things and OmniFocus, whatever your favorite to-do list app is. Because there's
1:03:48just people have so many diverse needs for the way they want to do a to-do system that
1:03:54nothing that Apple builds into the system that's meant for 90%
1:03:58of people to use is ever going to touch most of those things.
1:04:01The same thing with, you know, calendar and fantastic. Cal and
1:04:04mail and spark and some people just always use the Google
1:04:06version of the app regardless of whether they're using Apple
1:04:09hardware.
1:04:09Right or the fantastic group has the card hop, which is a context
1:04:15app. Yeah, way better. But also, I wouldn't suggest it as
1:04:19something Apple should adopt as the the system app. You know,
1:04:24Fantastic All is probably a little closer to being, you know, it's so, you know, but
1:04:32I can see why Apple didn't go that route on some of the UI decisions. But it definitely
1:04:37has some power user type features that really make it worthwhile. I guess I could take a
1:04:42break and talk about another sponsor. How about this? Here's another one of my favorite
1:04:46If you're hearing me right now, it's because I'm using their product.
1:04:49Eero.
1:04:50E-E-R-O.
1:04:51Eero is a way to set up Wi-Fi in your home and have multiple base stations spread around
1:05:01your house.
1:05:02Maybe you need two, maybe you need three, maybe you have a big house, you need four.
1:05:05I don't know.
1:05:07But if you're trying to saturate your whole home with one signal from one device plugged
1:05:12into your cable modem or your files box and go from your basement to your garage to your
1:05:19bedroom on the top floor of your house. There's a good chance you can't do it. If you've got
1:05:24spots in your house that have bad Wi-Fi, you should get a system like Eero. Eero makes
1:05:29it so easy to set up. You just start with a starter package. You go to their website.
1:05:36They have all sorts of tools where you can describe your home, your apartment, your house,
1:05:40whatever you're trying to set up.
1:05:42And they'll help you get just the right amount of hardware
1:05:46to do it.
1:05:47And you set it up in just minutes.
1:05:49It plugs right into your modem, your cable, your router,
1:05:53and you manage it all from a dead simple app.
1:05:56It's a native app right there on your iPhone,
1:05:58and it lets you pause the wifi for dinner, stuff like that.
1:06:01It lets you see all the devices on your network.
1:06:03It is the easiest, easiest way I've ever seen
1:06:06to set up a secondary guest network
1:06:08so that you can have people come over and they say,
1:06:13"Hey, can I get on your Wi-Fi?"
1:06:14And you don't want them on your Wi-Fi.
1:06:15At least if you're like me,
1:06:16you don't want them on your real Wi-Fi
1:06:18where they could like see all your devices and stuff.
1:06:20Just give them the guest network password.
1:06:23And they get all the same speed and performance
1:06:25and you're not putting their devices on your network.
1:06:29Love it, super easy.
1:06:30I just can't emphasize how easy it is to set this up.
1:06:37And you just stop worrying about Wi-Fi signal
1:06:40throughout your house.
1:06:41So they have an all new one, an all new Eero,
1:06:45that's new hardware, starts at just 99 bucks,
1:06:49and it blankets your whole home with fast, reliable Wi-Fi.
1:06:51You can get your Wi-Fi fixed as soon as tomorrow.
1:06:57Go to ero.com/thetalkshow and enter that code,
1:07:01the talk show at checkout,
1:07:02and you'll get free overnight shipping with your order.
1:07:05That's amazing.
1:07:06So 24 hours from the time you're listening to me
1:07:09tell you this, you could already be setting up your Eero
1:07:11right there in your home.
1:07:12That's eero.com/thetalkshow with code thetalkshow
1:07:15at checkout to get your Eero delivered
1:07:18with free overnight shipping.
1:07:19You must use this URL to receive the offer.
1:07:22Eero.com/thetalkshow with checkout code thetalkshow.
1:07:26I guess we gotta talk, I can't just ignore it.
1:07:29I gotta talk about the Apple Hong Kong China stuff.
1:07:31But I feel like I've written so much about it
1:07:33I don't need to spend a whole segment of the show on it." And it seems to have calmed down
1:07:40a little bit. Basically, Apple got caught in sort of a perfect storm of China-related stuff.
1:07:51It really is unrelated and just purely coincidental that the NBA situation where the GM
1:07:57of the Houston Rockets just retweeted a simple pro-Hong Kong tweet and really set off a firestorm
1:08:07of controversy that made even the Apple one seem small. And how often do you hear that,
1:08:11like where Apple gets caught up in a controversy and somebody else is in the same controversy and
1:08:15it's getting way more attention? But the Apple-related aspects, there's the HK Map Live app
1:08:27and then there's this the sub secondary story of Apple requesting / demanding
1:08:40that the people creating the shows for Apple TV Plus keep them China friendly
1:08:45meaning don't don't don't put stuff in your shows that would anger the Chinese
1:08:49or create a controversy with the HK map live I've written enough a lot about it
1:08:56one thing I can say, and I'm not quite sure I made clear in my writing is that I've from multiple
1:09:00people inside Apple, including a couple of people who are really, really interested at a personal
1:09:07level that they, you know, whether it's their family or significant others, but they have a
1:09:13personal investment in the whole situation in Hong Kong, in particular. And asked around within the
1:09:22the company. I verified this from a couple people that the initial rejection of that
1:09:27app was not a strategic dictum from the top of the company. That was just a single app
1:09:33reviewer who looked at the app and thought, "Well, this Hong Kong stuff is controversial.
1:09:38This seems like it's meant to circumvent the law. I'm going to deny it."
1:09:46I think everything that happened after that came from that one ultimately erroneous decision.
1:09:51So the three steps of the controversy is the developer submits this app to Apple.
1:09:57And it's a map app that shows users submitted information about police activity and protest
1:10:06activity around Hong Kong.
1:10:10And you, the user, can use it however you see fit, whether it's because you want to
1:10:14join in a protest or whether because you want to avoid the protests and as information about
1:10:20like where tear gas is being used, which for obvious reasons is something that if you're,
1:10:25you know, you might want to avoid. If the app had just been accepted, which internally
1:10:32Apple determined it should have been, that this is not something, it's not illegal,
1:10:36the app itself, the app is not illegal in Hong Kong, it's just information, should
1:10:42have been accepted. I don't think it would have been that big of a news. I don't think
1:10:46any kind of controversy would have come of it.
1:10:48Nobody would have noticed no, I it's you know, I think word, you know
1:10:53I think the app is somewhat popular in Hong Kong for obvious reasons. I think there's you know, it's it's small densely populated
1:11:00Populated city. It's not like anybody in Hong Kong is unaware of the months-long protests
1:11:07It's also a wrapper around the web page, which is accessible still to everybody right? What you know, we can mention
1:11:12I just don't think it would have been news
1:11:14I think Apple accepts this app that also is on the web and also is on Android is not a news story
1:11:21The news story was the and again it people aren't wrong for assuming it right that that this was this was a corporate
1:11:29executive level decision to
1:11:32placate the mainland Chinese government by
1:11:37Disallowing this app which is seemingly an app meant for people protesting for the democratic rights in Hong Kong
1:11:44So then when the news came out that the app was rejected, more people than not, or at least the
1:11:51sort of people who were tweeting about it or writing about it, were operating under the
1:11:56assumption that that was policy from Apple, which I didn't think it was, but I didn't know. Two days
1:12:05later, Apple, Apple agreed, you know, changed its mind the appeal process and the developer of the
1:12:10app themselves. I don't want to say himself or herself. I don't
1:12:13I'm not it's not even clear whether it's one person or
1:12:15multiple people. But for obvious reasons of wanting to keep
1:12:18their identity hidden from the Chinese government, they're
1:12:20they're anonymous. So the developer, I'll just say plural
1:12:25developers of the app, even tweeted when they said, Hey,
1:12:28this, you know, we've submitted an appeal, we think this might
1:12:31just be a bureaucratic mistake. You know, they weren't jumping
1:12:34to the conclusion that Apple was trying to suppress the app. Two
1:12:37days later, Apple said, Okay, the app is fine. There's no
1:12:39problem with it, doesn't break the law. Now it's in the App Store and then it was in the
1:12:43App Store. And then another two days later, they pulled it from the App Store. And in
1:12:47the in the in the interim, there was a lot of publicity about it, including multiple
1:12:55op eds in state run newspapers in mainland China, which the assumption is always have
1:13:02the backing of the government. You know, the state run newspapers don't just run random
1:13:07op-eds, absolutely dragging Apple over the coals for this, you know, saying that they're helping,
1:13:15you know, rioters, you know, they're in mainland China, these people aren't protesters for
1:13:19democracy, they're rioters who were making trouble. Very, very strongly worded.
1:13:26The denouncements of Apple's decision to publish this, which wouldn't have happened in the first
1:13:34place if they had simply accepted the app on first pass. Boy, this put Apple in a bad
1:13:41position. And I really, I wish they had just weathered the storm and left the app in the
1:13:47store and just had nothing to say about it. But instead, they pulled it again two days
1:13:54later. And that's where it really gets interesting. I don't know what you think about it. The
1:13:59assumption on the outside is clearly that Apple is simply placating the mainland Chinese
1:14:03government. And that's, again, I say that's perfectly reasonable. There's no reason to
1:14:08think otherwise. But from what I've heard internally from multiple people is that higher
1:14:15level and lower level is basically that what Tim Cook's company-wide memo said, which I
1:14:27even said really just didn't stand up to scrutiny. I mean, I think you kind of agreed with that
1:14:32too.
1:14:33It stands up a little better if you assume, and this is what I believe to be the case,
1:14:39that Apple sort of got thrown under the bus by the Hong Kong government, not the mainland China.
1:14:45It wasn't, you know, the mainland China communicates very, I don't think Apple heard from them. I really
1:14:51don't. And I've heard from no one who said they did. I don't think mainland China sends messages
1:14:57like that. They communicate indirectly.
1:15:01Through disappointed editorials, usually anonymous in state newspapers.
1:15:05Exactly. So, Apple's internal apparatus isn't really hooked up. They're hooked up
1:15:15on Hong Kong in particular to protect Hong Kong from mainland China. And their assumption is that
1:15:23if there's pressure overt or otherwise with tensions between mainland China's
1:15:31laws and rules and desires and and hypersensitivity to perceptive issues
1:15:39you know like there's there's this whole thing in recent years where China
1:15:44effectively demanded that a bunch of airlines around the world that if you
1:15:48fly into like Taiwan and Hong Kong that that these places be labeled as part of
1:15:52China and not as independent locations. Very, very sensitive to stuff like this.
1:16:00Apple set up internally to protect Hong Kong from China. And so their internal systems were set up
1:16:13to, "Hey, if Hong Kong tells us blank, we should take their word for it and do it." And Hong Kong
1:16:19authorities, not mainland Chinese authorities, Hong Kong authorities told Apple, hey, this app
1:16:25is no good. This this isn't helping, you know, the right people. This is causing, you know, looters
1:16:30and rioters are using it to circumvent police into the stuff that Tim Cook says they were told. I
1:16:36actually think they were told by the Hong Kong authorities. That's part of the conflict in this
1:16:41whole, you know, we could obviously do a whole podcast about it. And we're not experts. I'm
1:16:48certainly not an expert on the politics of the Hong Kong thing, but part of it is that what people
1:16:51are protesting for is they'd like to elect their own leaders, whereas the Wade stuff is set up with
1:16:56the two systems, one country promise ever since the United Kingdom handed over control of Hong
1:17:08Kong to China in 1997. You know, that the Hong Kong authorities aren't representatives of mainland
1:17:16China, but they're appointed by mainland China. And part of this whole thing with these protests
1:17:20is that the protesters are arguing, you know, that, that, you know, they'd like, they'd like
1:17:25to replace them with people of their own choosing, you know, and I think like the the current leader
1:17:30of Hong Kong is something like 15 or 19% approval rating or something like that, something that
1:17:35totally untenable if if if the position were duly elected in a real democracy.
1:17:40Apple just isn't set up to deal with that or wasn't set up to deal with that, that they,
1:17:46you know, Hong Kong said X, Y, and Z, and Apple said, "Okay, X, Y, and Z, we should,
1:17:49you know, pull this app from the store." Knowing, I mean, I'm not saying that the people at Apple
1:17:54who made that decision weren't fully aware that, "Hey, this looks terrible for us because it looks
1:18:01like we're flip-flopping all over the place. Reject, accept, reject all within five days."
1:18:06And they knew that that looks bad. And they knew that there were all these op-eds in China
1:18:11decrying them for this. And so they knew how weak it makes them look, but they thought it was the
1:18:15the right thing to do because Hong Kong was asking for it.
1:18:18- Yeah, I think it was a, like to your original point,
1:18:24the minute that app was first rejected,
1:18:26by putting it back on the store,
1:18:29there was no easy out for them on this whole thing.
1:18:32It was either they have to keep it in the store
1:18:35and risk what is happening in Hong Kong and China,
1:18:38or take it down and risk being seen
1:18:40as an instrument of mainland China.
1:18:42The whole issue with Apple in China is so fascinating
1:18:44because they are so deeply intertwined with China.
1:18:48You know, one of my favorite things about reviews
1:18:50is when people say, "Oh, a phone shouldn't cost this much,"
1:18:52is if they have any idea what a phone,
1:18:54what goes into making a phone.
1:18:56And the reason the phones don't cost way more in part
1:18:59is the way that they're manufactured.
1:19:01And Apple has been leveraging that in China for years.
1:19:05There's no easy exit for them there.
1:19:07And at the same time, Tim Cook has this consistent policy,
1:19:11and you can see this everywhere from how he deals
1:19:13with situations with the mining of materials
1:19:17to civil liberties in the US
1:19:19to engaging the Trump administration,
1:19:21to engaging China is that he believes
1:19:23if he's not part of the conversation,
1:19:25he has no ability to affect change.
1:19:28But that's always dangerous
1:19:29because one, you're gonna get those editorials
1:19:31that say that you're appeasing people
1:19:32because engagement and appeasement
1:19:34is a very, very small buffer between them
1:19:36and one can quickly be perceived as,
1:19:38if not become, the other.
1:19:40But at the same time, you give them a conduit back into you
1:19:44and it's often easier.
1:19:46I think you said this really well
1:19:47in one of your posts a while ago,
1:19:48is the only thing you can't tolerate is intolerance.
1:19:51But by reaching out and making those engagements,
1:19:53you give them a bridge back to you and they start to,
1:19:56whether they actually influence your policy or not,
1:19:58it's perceived again that they're influencing your policy.
1:20:01So Apple has all of these things happening in China,
1:20:03the removal of the Quartz app,
1:20:05Tim Cook being elected chairman of the business school,
1:20:08which could have been anybody it used to be.
1:20:11There's a whole bunch of US CEOs on that board
1:20:13and they all take turns.
1:20:14But right now at the same time,
1:20:15it just happens to be his turn and could he have gone,
1:20:18"No, no, no, give it to Zuckerberg this time.
1:20:20"I'll take it next time."
1:20:21But all these things happen at once
1:20:23and it creates really bad optics for them.
1:20:26And the concern is always that China, for example,
1:20:29wants iCloud storage in China
1:20:32and people will find that dangerous.
1:20:34But by the same token,
1:20:35there are a lot of people outside the US
1:20:36who want nothing to do with having data stored
1:20:38in the US right now.
1:20:40And France wants their citizens, their data,
1:20:42and that's gonna be an increasing movement around the world.
1:20:45But the fear is that China will ask for encryption keys
1:20:47one day, the same way the FBI,
1:20:49or ask for a backdoor the same way the US government did.
1:20:53And the US government, you can see it, it's apparent,
1:20:56there's a legal battle, there's litigation.
1:20:58All this stuff happens in the open,
1:20:59where with China, it's not that form of government.
1:21:02And I think that's sort of the fear
1:21:03that underlies all this,
1:21:04is that when it happens in China,
1:21:07it's gonna be much harder for Apple to affect,
1:21:09to sort of stand their ground,
1:21:11especially given all the small negotiations
1:21:14that are happening now.
1:21:15- I forget what the context was this week,
1:21:19but I thought I had a good observation
1:21:22on something with Apple in China
1:21:26where Apple didn't fully, oh, I know what it was.
1:21:30It's the safe browsing story.
1:21:32- Yeah.
1:21:32So one of the other little stories this week was that Safari has long had this safe browsing
1:21:38feature where I didn't even notice when it expanded to include Tencent, which is the
1:21:45state-owned Japanese conglomerate. But Google famously is shut out of China at the moment.
1:21:53So if you're in China and you're behind the great firewall, you can't use Google search.
1:22:00You can't use Google anything for the most part.
1:22:04And so the safe browsing feature that Safari has had for a while, which uses a blacklist
1:22:09of either known or for all effect and purposes known malware or otherwise stuff that you
1:22:18would want blocked.
1:22:21Safari uses Google's server for this, can't use it in China, so they use Tencent.
1:22:26the way Google or the way Apple wrote the description. If you were like, "Hmm,
1:22:32let me find out about this feature." It just said, "Safari may send your IP address." It's like the
1:22:44privacy policy for the features. "Safari may send your IP address to Google or Tencent."
1:22:50Yeah, it was completely tone deaf.
1:22:53And people rightly jumped to the plain reading of it, which is that you don't know when they're
1:23:00using one or the other.
1:23:02And so they might be in the United States, you might be in the middle of Tennessee or
1:23:06Texas and they're sending your IP address to its server in China in a state-owned media
1:23:11conglomerate with all your…
1:23:14The feature is as you would expect from Apple.
1:23:16It is designed with privacy in mind and it uses hashed URLs and prefixes of the URLs
1:23:22instead of the whole thing to keep Google or Tencent from seeing the specific URLs you're
1:23:28visiting.
1:23:29There's no way to avoid – well, I guess I shouldn't say there's no way.
1:23:32I guess they could proxy the calls through an Apple server, which is an interesting question
1:23:36as to why they're not.
1:23:38The IP address is getting sent to these providers because Safari is calling them directly.
1:23:46I guess there's a performance argument there that proxying is by necessity going to have
1:23:51an extra hop where your device is talking to Apple and Apple's talking to Google and
1:23:56then Google talks back to Apple and then Apple talks…
1:23:58And the potential source of failure, which is what happens with Siri when it's like,
1:24:02"Wait a second. Hold on."
1:24:04Yeah. So, you know, there's obviously reasons for performance and simplicity to let your
1:24:08device talk directly to Google. And then there's reasons of privacy where you'd want it proxied.
1:24:13Yeah.
1:24:14a separate thing. To me, the problem was the way this feature was described by Apple.
1:24:23>> Absolutely.
1:24:24>> And what I wrote is, "Trust us is not good enough." Like, effectively, these things are
1:24:28sort of written with a trust us attitude that, look, you can trust us, we're Apple. And so
1:24:33my assumption when this story broke last weekend was, well, I would guess that they're only
1:24:38using Tencent for users in mainland China and they're using Google everywhere else in
1:24:42the world. And in fact, that is how the feature works. But they didn't say that. And so the
1:24:48people who jumped to the wrong conclusion, I don't think they're crazy. And I happen
1:24:51to know it ties into Hong Kong specifically because this story went nuts in the Hong Kong
1:24:59the multi user chat groups that they use. What do they use? What's the app? I forget.
1:25:05I'm not sure it's Weibo in China. I'm not sure what it is. And it's not signal. It's
1:25:09the other one. No, the one that starts with a T. Telegram. Telegram. Yeah. So Telegram
1:25:14supports big multi-user chats. And so there's a whole bunch of groups in Hong Kong who are using
1:25:22Telegram. And it went rampant, went super kindling going up in a fire, viral of, "Hey, turn off safe
1:25:34browsing because they're going to send your IP address to Tencent. And, you know, protesters
1:25:39in Hong Kong obviously don't want anything sent. I mean, your IP address isn't that,
1:25:44you know, it doesn't reveal that much about you. But, you know, if I were a protester
1:25:47in Hong Kong, I'd want to be sure that my even my IP address wasn't being sent to China.
1:25:52I don't want it sent to Google. So I totally get that. And so the downside to this is that
1:25:56anybody who got caught up in this, you know, it could really, it wasn't getting sent to
1:26:0110 cent. It was getting sent to Google. But you could wind up disabling a useful feature,
1:26:07you know, that and now all of a sudden you're browsing, you think you've made your browsing
1:26:11safer because you've protected yourself from having your IP address sent to 10 cent, but
1:26:15it wasn't being sent there in the first place. And now you're liable, you know, you're susceptible
1:26:20to all the sites that safe browsing would have blocked you from, which might be sites
1:26:23that the that the yes, the Chinese government is using to try to hack Hong Kong protesters.
1:26:30Yep.
1:26:31And so anyway, trust us isn't good enough.
1:26:35And my take, my quip was, if Apple is too embarrassed to explain in detail exactly what
1:26:40they're doing to comply with Chinese law, then they shouldn't be doing it.
1:26:43And I really feel like they, I wish that they had a white paper describing in more detail
1:26:48how the setup is that iCloud users server data is stored in mainland China on third
1:26:55party company hardware.
1:26:56I wish that they would describe that in as much detail as they as they could
1:27:00Standing is that it's there but Apple retains this the encryption keys
1:27:05But I it shouldn't be our understanding. There should be a white paper that explains it in my opinion
1:27:10You know and so that you can make your own
1:27:14informed decision about how likely it is that the Chinese police could storm in and demand stuff how what what
1:27:23What what the dangers are just that the Chinese government might have moles working for the company that hosts these servers, etc
1:27:31Etc, but we don't know anything. It's it's way more of a black box than it should be in my opinion
1:27:35I don't mean to be flippant about it at all
1:27:37But you know that that line from equilibrium we said the easiest way to get us weapon from a grammaton cleric is to ask him
1:27:44For it. They just made tic tocs. We just all give them
1:27:49like they need to trick us into it anymore. They just made a catchy social media company.
1:27:53Yeah, yeah. Ben Thompson has some good takes on this. And his observation, which to me was very
1:28:02keen, and I'm like, "Yeah, why isn't everybody saying this?" is that with the NBA thing, so
1:28:06this NBA executive, Dan Morey, I think his name is, who tweeted this one pro-Hong Kong tweet,
1:28:12which was really just like, "Stand up for Hong Kong." It wasn't like, you know, "Hong Kong
1:28:16should set the city on fire. It was, you know, we support Hong Kong. It was tweeted, which
1:28:24is a social network that is completely blocked within China. And yet somehow the Chinese
1:28:29state media would have us believe that millions of Chinese NBA fans saw this tweet and were
1:28:34deeply offended by it. Like, you know, I thought it was a pretty keen observation of this is
1:28:40manufactured because how could one message on a social network banned within China have
1:28:47caused millions of people to be angry in China? They can't read it. But meanwhile, we on
1:28:53the West with our open values totally allow—so we allow them to block our social networks.
1:29:00I mean, here I am standing up for Facebook, you know. But I mean, on principle, it doesn't
1:29:06right that we allow them to say, "Yeah, no Instagram in China, but we'll take TikTok
1:29:11and let everybody install it on their phones." And if it's fun enough, people will have it.
1:29:15Yeah, no, absolutely. Well, the thing that scares me is that this is like, there's that old saying
1:29:24from the West Wing where there's no amount of manpower or money that equals a criminal being
1:29:29stupid. And a lot of the stuff that we see all the time is buffoonery. It's just so dumb, it's easy
1:29:34to catch. And especially with this stuff, it creates such a Streisand effect that it ends up
1:29:38shining a huge light on things that are happening. But it's the stuff that we don't hear about that
1:29:43worries me. It's the requests that get made that aren't, you know, "Oh, as we saw Twitter for an
1:29:48NBA." That's ludicrous. It's just absolutely ludicrous. But it's the stuff that's not
1:29:52so above board or so public that I worry more about.
1:29:55Pete: Yeah, totally. So anyway, Apple, they're in a tough spot in China. I think that it could get,
1:30:03I think that my takeaway from this this whole saga though is that it's not that Apple
1:30:09Just got through a terrible
1:30:13Exposure
1:30:18To to their foothold in China. It's that it just sort of hinted at how bad it could be
1:30:23Yes, right like what happens? I mean if there is a Tiananmen Square like crackdown on the Hong Kong
1:30:33protesters, you know what happens if if if the Chinese government
1:30:36sends, you know, the their military into Hong Kong to put it put it into this, you know, it's
1:30:42They you know there it's it's in my opinion right up there with natural disasters, you know as
1:30:51Which would affect every company though, right?
1:30:55Like Apple is sort of uniquely exposed in China as a Western company because no other
1:31:01Western company is so reliant on them for manufacturing and
1:31:04You know that this the second factor of Apple's sales within China
1:31:10It's like this more or less tied, you know, it goes back and forth it ebbs and flows more
1:31:15But you know us is the is the biggest market
1:31:18US, you know or call it North America if you want to include, you know our Canadian friends like you
1:31:22You know the North America is the biggest market China and Europe greater Western
1:31:29Europe are more or less tied as their second biggest markets
1:31:32It's a big market for Apple. It's certainly one of growth
1:31:36It's certainly part of their growth story and everybody knows growth is important for the message of Apple to Wall Street
1:31:41It would obviously be a shit show if Apple had to pull out or if their sales within mainland China were decimated through bad publicity
1:31:49Or tariffs or any of their various things that could go bad, but Apple could exist as we know it
1:31:55with their sales in
1:31:59two consumers in mainland China being cut off. It would be a significant hit. It would be reflected
1:32:04in the stock price, but Apple as we know it would still be there. It would be like, I don't know,
1:32:10I think ballparking it, I don't know, like 20%, 25%, something like that.
1:32:14Yeah, and it's hard too because even if it's not a disaster—
1:32:18Where is the myth—
1:32:19Sorry.
1:32:20Keep going. No, keep going.
1:32:21No, I was going to say, even if it's not something like an incident in Hong Kong,
1:32:24even if it's something like tariffs, and people will say, "Well, Apple represents way too much
1:32:29of the gross domestic product of Southern China
1:32:31for any of that to, like the Chinese government
1:32:33to want to affect that in any way,
1:32:35but they have a remarkable ability for absorbing pain.
1:32:38I think we don't understand the extent
1:32:41at which they would allow something to happen
1:32:43that was moderately, that was even severely painful
1:32:46for them if it was worse
1:32:47for whomever they were contending with.
1:32:50And just if the tariffs got too bad
1:32:52and it destroyed Apple's ability
1:32:54to compete manufacturing in China,
1:32:55even if it cost every job in Shenzhen province,
1:32:58I don't think at the end of the day,
1:33:00they would have that big a problem with it.
1:33:02- Yeah, the manufacturing thing is just the angle
1:33:06that cannot be, it just cannot be understated.
1:33:09And there was a story, the Wall Street Journal
1:33:11just had a story over the weekend.
1:33:12Do you see this about how there's iPhone XRs,
1:33:14I think being made in India now,
1:33:17which is a weird thing to see.
1:33:19It's just a weird thing to see that small print
1:33:21that says, designed by Apple in California,
1:33:24assembled in India.
1:33:26But India, the Indian national government
1:33:28is making a huge press to appeal
1:33:31to smartphone manufacturers in particular
1:33:34to build up India as a major production center
1:33:37for smartphone hardware.
1:33:40You know, Apple's part of it,
1:33:42but it's, even if they put the pedal to the metal
1:33:46and accelerated their trying to become independent of China
1:33:53if they wanted to for manufacturing and assembly,
1:33:57even the fastest they could do it, the most efficient way,
1:34:00if they didn't make any mistakes, made all the right moves,
1:34:03spent as much money as they needed to,
1:34:04it's still a years-long process, possibly many years long.
1:34:09Fascinating. - They made a deliberate choice
1:34:10not to own the core technologies
1:34:12when it comes to manufacturing,
1:34:13and that gives them exposure.
1:34:15- Right, they're absolutely exposed.
1:34:17And in particular, the iPhone,
1:34:19everybody knows it's the most important,
1:34:21best-selling biggest revenue and profit maker will be for years to come. It's utterly dependent
1:34:29on China at the moment. All right, let me take one final break here and thank our third and final
1:34:36sponsor of this episode of the talk show, Squarespace. You guys know Squarespace. Come on.
1:34:46I talk about them all the time, sponsoring the show forever. Place you go to do it all
1:34:51for a website, for your company, for your personal use, for a company your friends have,
1:34:58a business, a restaurant, personal portfolio, you name it, you can build it with Squarespace.
1:35:04And they do everything from domain name registration to picking from their award-winning
1:35:10templates that scale to any size device from a big 27 inch retina iMac to a
1:35:15iPhone SE in your pocket
1:35:18You could do it all right there
1:35:20award-winning support and
1:35:23They have everything from analytics so you can see who's coming to your site from where to the design tools
1:35:29That you don't have to know any kind of code to do if you don't even know what the difference is between HTML and CSS
1:35:35That's alright. You'll be fine. It's all drag-and-drop
1:35:38drop. If you do know HTML and CSS and JavaScript and you want to get in there and be able to
1:35:43customize at that level, you can do that too. It truly is the sort of system that scales
1:35:48from a true novice, somebody who just wants to drag stuff around, click a button, have
1:35:53it be done to the sort of person who has strong opinions on a text editor for editing JavaScript.
1:35:59Squarespace can handle it. So here's what you need to remember. Next time you need a
1:36:05a new website, you want to redo an old website,
1:36:08or somebody comes to you for help with a website
1:36:10and you send them to Squarespace,
1:36:12go to squarespace.com and remember the offer code,
1:36:15talk show, know the, just talk show,
1:36:18at checkout and you'll get 10% off.
1:36:22My thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support
1:36:24of this podcast.
1:36:26All right, how about this?
1:36:30Let's go forward thinking.
1:36:31Do we, or are you done?
1:36:33I think we're done on China.
1:36:34What do you think?
1:36:35Yes, I agree. Apple event. As we record, this is the sort of segment of a podcast that could
1:36:41be blown apart between recording and publishing. But as we speak on Monday, October 21st, there
1:36:48are no signs, no invitations, no rumors that I've seen that there's going to be an Apple
1:36:52event this fall. Another Apple event.
1:36:56No event this month at least.
1:36:59It's possible. I look back at the last few years. So last year, they sent out invitations
1:37:03on the 18th of October for the October 30 event that was in Brooklyn. Two years before that,
1:37:09in 2016, they sent out invitations on October 19th for—I think it was the last ever event at Town
1:37:17Hall in Cupertino. But that was only eight days ahead. It was actually on the 27th, and it was
1:37:22weird. It was a Thursday, which is—I don't remember that, but it was right.
1:37:27**Ezra Klein:** So I'm going to use the dreaded "my understanding" language again, but my
1:37:29My understanding is they're way too busy launching TV+ to have the resources to do an event in
1:37:34October.
1:37:35That sounds right to me.
1:37:37October…
1:37:38Because they're all over the place at the premiers, right?
1:37:41Right.
1:37:42The PR is spread thin.
1:37:45And that's launching November 1st, right?
1:37:49Yeah.
1:37:50That makes sense.
1:37:51To my knowledge, Apple has never held a fall event in November.
1:37:55And the closer you get to Thanksgiving, the more impossible it would be.
1:37:59So the further along you get, the less anything that you want to announce would have time
1:38:06to factor into holiday gift purchases.
1:38:11What do we think is coming?
1:38:13The three products?
1:38:14So my guess is that it won't be consumer products.
1:38:18It'll be professional products and it'll be similar.
1:38:23Like I know they didn't show anything off at WWDC the way they did with the iMac Pro,
1:38:27My guess is still that it'll be something like that,
1:38:30where they have a very specific, not a giant media event,
1:38:33but they have a bunch of stuff put together
1:38:35to show us how the products are used in context.
1:38:38- Well, the big-- - And we get
1:38:39our introduction that way.
1:38:40- The one product we've already been told by Apple
1:38:42is to expect this calendar year is the Mac Pro, right?
1:38:46And to me, what's instructive is to go back to 2017
1:38:51when they were on a similar schedule with the iMac Pro,
1:38:54where they showed it at WWDC in June.
1:38:57said you can expect it later this year. And then they didn't have an event for the launch
1:39:05of the iMac Pro. What they did was hold small private media briefings in New York and I
1:39:12believe in Cupertino as well so that West Coast media didn't have to travel to New
1:39:17York and vice versa from the East Coast. And there was no keynote. There was nothing that
1:39:23It was live broadcast.
1:39:24It was just small briefings of groups.
1:39:27I think I was in a group of six or something like that.
1:39:30And they had multiple demos set up in their little townhouse
1:39:34in-- well, little-- their big townhouse in New York,
1:39:38where we would just move from station to station.
1:39:40And they'd show us, here's what the iMac Pro means
1:39:43for developers.
1:39:44Here's what it means for people who do 3D modeling
1:39:47and rendering.
1:39:47And here's what it means in these other demos.
1:39:53There you go. I could see them doing that exact sort of thing again with the Mac Pro.
1:39:57I could even see them doing it again if there is, as rumored, a 16-inch MacBook Pro coming
1:40:02before the end of the year. Because what do you got? What would you, even if it wasn't
1:40:07a time compression like, "Oh, we're so busy with TV+ that we don't even have time
1:40:12to do this event," what are you going to do with a 16-inch MacBook Pro? You've already
1:40:17shown Catalina. What's the demo? You know, what is the story to be held on stage? You
1:40:21know, they don't hold stage events just because there's a new product. They have to have something
1:40:25to talk about. And they're not going to talk about how bad the keyboard was for right.
1:40:29Right. They're totally not gonna do it. Yeah, they're, you know, they might talk about how
1:40:36great the new keyboard is, but they're not going to talk about how bad the old keyboard
1:40:39was. Yeah. So the only other product that's rumored that might, you know, come out before
1:40:44the end of the year, at least that I'm aware of is the AirPods with noise cancel relation.
1:40:49Yeah. And again, it's pro cause everything's pro. They could just hold a briefing for that
1:40:53and tell the press how great they sound. I don't see them holding an event for that.
1:40:57Yeah. No, likewise. So I guess the one last thing I wanted to talk about this week
1:41:01is a little bit on Catalina, which I've been playing with a little and a catalyst in
1:41:09particular, which you sort of need Catalina to do. And I just know, I just know for the whole
1:41:14next year, I'm going to say catalyst when I mean Catalina and Catalina. I've been doing
1:41:19that too. It's just I make errors like that. It's, you know, talking about like hashing algorithms,
1:41:27it's just I file stuff in my head alphabetically and C-A-T-A-L just doesn't have many items in it
1:41:34and to have two of them be related to the same version of Mac OS is really going to screw me up.
1:41:42So I apologize to everybody out there listening for all of the catalyst Catalina conflations I'm
1:41:48about to make. The draft for my review, I called it Mac OS Catalyst. I had to fix it before it went live.
1:41:54In the headline? Yeah. I'm glad you caught it. They had press briefings for Catalina for the
1:42:06whole OS the week before it shipped. And, you know, Apple PR reached out to me to see if I'd
1:42:16I'd be interested in going up to New York to have the briefing and I was and I thought,
1:42:23"Boy, that's weird though." Like I was kind of more intrigued than I would have been because
1:42:27in my head I thought that they said it was a briefing entirely about catalyst and I thought,
1:42:31"Oh, this might be really interesting. They're preemptively having an entire briefing just
1:42:36about this catalyst thing." And then I realized it wasn't. It was Catalina. It was the whole
1:42:42a recap of the whole song and dance of all the—it wasn't—I'm glad I went. It was useful. It was
1:42:46interesting. But it wasn't anywhere near as juicy as I thought it would have been if it would have
1:42:51been catalyst-specific. So anyway, are you using catalyst—not catalyst, Catalina on your primary
1:42:58machine? I did it. I don't usually do it because I have to edit video on it and I have to edit
1:43:02podcasts on it and I'm very nervous about it. But again, I was using it on an alternate machine and
1:43:07it just wasn't enough to actually review it. I felt like I had to use it. So I put it on my
1:43:11main machine. It had some ups and downs, but it's pretty solid now.
1:43:15So one of the big changes is that 32-bit apps are now gone. And Apple managed this transition
1:43:23about as well as they could. They gave plenty of heads up years ago starting at WWDCs that
1:43:30soon enough—at whatever point they made the announcement 32-bit frameworks—
1:43:36Frameworks no leopard. It was up on remember Bertrand put up the huge 32-bit banner at snow leopard
1:43:41Was that really when they first started?
1:43:42I think they mentioned it a little bit with leopard but it was like it was a headline feature and snow leopard
1:43:47Was that just though going to 64-bit? That's yeah. Yeah
1:43:51As soon as they went to 64-bit apps
1:43:54Everybody should have known that eventually they're gonna do away with 32-bit apps and it took a long time and that's the way it should
1:44:00be
1:44:01You know, I think it took longer on the Mac than then than it did on iOS iOS made the transition
1:44:08Yeah quicker and that's the way it should be because the Mac is you know, it's just the nature of a desktop
1:44:12Computing platform so I don't think Apple made a wrong decision at all
1:44:17It might have been too long
1:44:19It's like you know how sometimes you forget to plug in your iPad because a battery lasts so long
1:44:23Yeah, you have to put this was like it was like 10 years and I think some companies like oh, they're never gonna do it
1:44:28We're safe, you know, that's that's funny
1:44:30you say that, you know, I didn't really think about that, but I think you're right, that
1:44:33there might have been, it might have been too long. I don't know. But every time one
1:44:37of these transitions gets made or when something goes away, you know, it's a little sad, you
1:44:41know, that there's, you know, drags that sad the drag thing doesn't run anymore. You know,
1:44:48there's some 32 bit stuff that isn't going to make the 64 bit transition and it's a bit
1:44:53sad, but it was sad when classic went away. I hadn't, you know, nobody who really, what
1:44:58of your, however fond your memories of classic Mac OS were. And mine are super fond. And
1:45:03there are entire essays I could write about things of the user interface of the classic
1:45:07Mac OS that I still think were vastly superior to anything that's come since, including Mac
1:45:12OS and iOS. But running classic apps in Mac OS X was never a great experience, never looked
1:45:19right, never felt right. But once the classic layer was removed from Mac OS X, it still
1:45:25was a poor one out moment that you can't even launch these things anymore without an emulation
1:45:30layer. For me personally, I don't think there's anything that I use that's 32-bit. I went
1:45:36through. There's a way to check in, I think the best way, because it's not just checking
1:45:42what's running in the activity monitor. You can add in activity monitor. You can go up
1:45:49to the view menu, I think, and in the columns that are displayed, you can display type and
1:45:54it'll say whether it's a 64 or 32-bit app.
1:45:57And if you sort by that column,
1:45:58you can see if you have any 32-bit stuffs running.
1:46:02If you go to About This Mac
1:46:04and then go to the system report,
1:46:06when you go to applications,
1:46:07it'll show all the applications
1:46:08that are installed on your system
1:46:10in your applications folder,
1:46:13which is a better way of seeing
1:46:14if you have anything laying around
1:46:16that won't run if you upgrade.
1:46:19And I think that even when you run the upgrader,
1:46:22the updater from 10.14 to 10.15,
1:46:24it'll even then point out,
1:46:26hey, you've got this X, Y, and Z apps installed
1:46:29that won't run.
1:46:31They're doing as much as you can.
1:46:33I think it's a non-issue for the most part.
1:46:35- Because a lot of plugins seem to get bit,
1:46:38especially audio plugins.
1:46:40- Yeah, that seems like a huge thing.
1:46:43And I know a couple of people who work on audio apps,
1:46:46seems like that's a really big deal
1:46:49and sort of unfortunate, I guess.
1:46:51I don't know why they haven't made the transition.
1:46:53You would think they'd be actively maintained,
1:46:55but they're not.
1:46:57- Oh, yeah.
1:46:58I was wondering if Adobe was gonna make it on time
1:47:01because Adobe, they did.
1:47:03- Yeah.
1:47:04So, you know, and I have upgraded a machine
1:47:08that's not my primary machine.
1:47:10And I know that one of the other things about Catalina
1:47:12that people are complaining about
1:47:13is that they've tightened up some of the,
1:47:15you know, it's that fine line between
1:47:20Is it a security feature or a privacy feature?
1:47:22It's a little bit of column A, a little bit of column B,
1:47:25but they've made the desktop a magic location
1:47:29that apps have to have special permission.
1:47:31Like such and such app is trying to read files
1:47:35from your desktop.
1:47:38- The first time you launch an app that was already open
1:47:41when you upgraded and had documents from the desktop,
1:47:45the downloads file and the documents folder open
1:47:47at the time and it tries to reload them, God help you,
1:47:50because it starts asking permission for every directory,
1:47:52for every file that you had open at the time.
1:47:55- So there's, you know, it takes some getting used to.
1:47:59I really, I have a rant in me about it.
1:48:02Like I kind of see why Apple's doing this,
1:48:05but it really doesn't play well in the context
1:48:08of that classic get a Mac ad,
1:48:11where the John Hodgman PC got upgraded to Vista and was,
1:48:15do you authorize this, yes or no?
1:48:18Do you authorize that, yes or no?
1:48:20You know?
1:48:21- It'll only ask you once, but for every app.
1:48:23It'll only ask you if you wanna download once,
1:48:25but for every website.
1:48:26- Yeah, it's a lot.
1:48:29And it brings in, I get it, I get why they're doing this.
1:48:36I think some of these things are in response
1:48:39to actual malware attack vectors that Apple is aware of.
1:48:44My son ran into one.
1:48:48I think I talked about this on the show a year or two ago,
1:48:51but my son ran into one about two years ago,
1:48:54maybe 18 months ago, but it was really interesting
1:48:57where he somehow stumbled on a site
1:49:00or he clicked on something.
1:49:01It wasn't like super dubious.
1:49:03It wasn't like he was trying to download,
1:49:05crack games or something like that.
1:49:07I forget, but he could reproduce it.
1:49:09And there was a URL where it was like a fake Amazon result.
1:49:13And I guess he kind of clicked on it accidentally.
1:49:16But what it did is it went to one of these sites
1:49:21claiming that your Mac had,
1:49:24the site had detected that your Mac had malware
1:49:30and that's why it was running slow
1:49:33and that you needed to call this number.
1:49:34And I'm sure if you did call it,
1:49:36you know, that they would talk you into it.
1:49:38You know, everybody knows people who've had family members
1:49:41fall victim to this, where you call them up
1:49:42they talk you into installing like a back door on your Mac. Just terrible stuff, terribly
1:49:49shifty stuff. But the devious part of this website my son stumbled upon was what they
1:49:55were doing was sending your browser downloads of, they were like empty text files or maybe
1:50:06they were like text files that contained four characters like just just literally just like
1:50:10Two or three characters and and but they were sending them as fast as the as they could and
1:50:17Safari even just a year or two ago was willing to say, okay, you're gonna send me all these downloads
1:50:22I'll download them as fast as as fast as I can
1:50:24and
1:50:27Just by downloading as many of these files as it could as fast as it could it
1:50:32Made Safari really slow. It really was it slowed down it exactly as the website promised. It didn't install anything
1:50:39It wasn't a year, you know
1:50:41There was no malware running on your machine
1:50:43But it slowed your browser down so fast that if you couldn't if you didn't know like the trick to force quit Safari
1:50:49It was tough to get out of like it was so slow it slowed Safari down so far so fast that you couldn't really close
1:50:58the window. So you could totally see how people would fall for it. And I'm sure that there's
1:51:03a hundred other tricks that are similarly deep.
1:51:05A bunch of Google Ad hijacks that would just send you to a fake website. Yeah.
1:51:10So there's all sorts of stuff, I'm sure, that are out there. But some of this stuff, though,
1:51:17it's like tightening up Safari I get, because I really do feel like you don't know what
1:51:22you're getting there. I feel like having apps that beg for permission to read files off
1:51:29your desktop, I feel like that's over the line. I feel like I'm not quite sure what
1:51:34and again, maybe I'm wrong. And there's apps that are taking advantage of this and just
1:51:39guessing that you have juicy personal stuff on your desktop and, you know, slurping all
1:51:44the data from it. But it just seems contrary to the way that the Mac is trying to mitigate
1:51:49Like if you double click or if you drag,
1:51:52it's an explicit user action, so that overrides the check.
1:51:55But it's just like when you do that reinstall
1:51:57and you already have stuff open,
1:51:59you don't have the opportunity to drag anything.
1:52:01So that's like the worst case scenario.
1:52:03- And it's just so telling, it's so much cleaner on,
1:52:08even though iOS and iPadOS are still more limiting overall
1:52:13in terms of being able to use an app
1:52:15that can just see the real file system.
1:52:17And I know that the files app has beefed this up
1:52:21and there's integration with Dropbox.
1:52:23But if you're treating data as files,
1:52:25as opposed to just being a library app, right?
1:52:30Like when you use photos and you use the Apple Notes app,
1:52:34you don't treat the individual photos as files,
1:52:37you don't treat notes as files,
1:52:39they're just items in a library,
1:52:42which is the sort of modern way
1:52:43to have multiple bits of data in an app.
1:52:46And in a lot of cases, it's great.
1:52:48It's just conceptually simpler.
1:52:49It's neater.
1:52:50You're successfully encapsulating the file system
1:52:55from the user.
1:52:56You're not missing anything by not having these,
1:52:59you know, your individual hundreds of notes
1:53:01as individual files in a file system.
1:53:04But if you really do want to deal with documents
1:53:06in the traditional document mindset,
1:53:10iOS's way is still limiting, right?
1:53:14And the Mac is just natural.
1:53:15It's just the way, you know, when you boot up into a Mac,
1:53:18it still is the case where the default application
1:53:20that's running is the finder, which is the file system app.
1:53:23I feel like nannying all these decisions with,
1:53:29are you sure you want to let this app read from the desktop?
1:53:31Is just, it's just a pain in the ass.
1:53:34And I really kind of wish there were,
1:53:38if it's, even if there is a good idea for this,
1:53:40I really wished that there was a developer mode,
1:53:45for lack of a better word.
1:53:46And I feel like the calling it developer mode
1:53:48would properly scare the people off
1:53:52who shouldn't be turning it on,
1:53:54as opposed to calling it advanced user mode or something.
1:53:58Just call it developer mode
1:53:59and it would turn off almost all of that stuff.
1:54:03And just say, I trust that I'm not getting tricked
1:54:06into installing malware on my Mac.
1:54:09Let me run the Mac the way I was running it
1:54:12five, six years ago, where I can write scripts
1:54:14and not have to tell the system that Terminal app
1:54:19has full disk access and stuff like that.
1:54:23Just call it developer.
1:54:24- They have a bit of that.
1:54:25Like they got rid of the option to run any app.
1:54:27Now there's only App Store and certified apps,
1:54:29sorry, but you can go into Terminal and type in a command
1:54:33and it restores the button for running the app.
1:54:36But that's just one at a time.
1:54:37There's no like Konami code to unlock all of it.
1:54:39- Right, I just feel like the way that this has been added
1:54:44over time to a design
1:54:47That is you know, that is the way Mac OS X was originally conceived from the next era through the the you know
1:54:54the transition period in 2000
1:54:56Circa 2000 let's say
1:54:59It's resulted in this system where you have to do these things a hundred times, you know, maybe that's an exaggeration
1:55:05But you have to drag each app and drag, you know into full disk access and you have to authorize this and authorize that
1:55:11Whereas I really feel like there should be a way to get and you have to jump all over the system to get these different
1:55:17Things right and god bless them like Apple gets no exemption
1:55:20I'd launched QuickTime for the first time and drew to a screen record
1:55:23I had to launch settings go in check a box and then quick time and then reload and then it says like if you want
1:55:29It to apply you've got to quit and restart the app, which is like very Skype or something
1:55:33I really feel like there should be a they should take into account a way that if you really want to turn that stuff off
1:55:39It's it's either all one checkbox like an idea I had is you know how like right now you can in users and groups you can
1:55:47have
1:55:48Administrator accounts yeah
1:55:49And then you can have standard users and a standard user is limited in all sorts of ways where they can't delete apps
1:55:54They have to have an admin password. Well. Why not make in addition to an administrator account?
1:55:58Why not make a developer account and you can't just have an entire account?
1:56:02That's you know has all the all the all the powers of an administrator
1:56:07Plus the powers of a developer which is mostly I trust the software on my Mac. Yes
1:56:11Yeah, I'm a grown-ass adult and I want to make these decisions. I mean, well, I'm an or you know, I'm an expert
1:56:18You know like, you know, I'm an expert and I I trust myself to control the software that's running on my Mac
1:56:23And it's a lot of little things to like I didn't notice this when I wrote my review
1:56:27But I was using music and I'd right-clicked and I said oh show me and find it
1:56:31It worked fine
1:56:32and then I went to
1:56:33Podcasts and I wanted to get the actual file for the podcast and I right-clicked on that option doesn't exist because it's a catalyst app
1:56:38It doesn't it's not aware of I'm sure they could put it in but they didn't and so it's one less
1:56:43It's one less feature that I use occasionally that's available to me. Well that brings me to my next section, which is the catalyst griping
1:56:49Which could be an entire episode of the show and maybe will be in the coming weeks
1:56:57But at the moment, you know, let's keep it short
1:57:00Well shortish short by the standards of a segment on this podcast
1:57:05The catalyst apps I
1:57:09mean there's
1:57:11Two groups of them. I mean there's apples own and then there's
1:57:15Third party ones that are now in the app store
1:57:18The
1:57:23Apple ones are
1:57:25Home where there's the the ones that we had left from last year home news and stocks
1:57:30which I consider one app because they're really sort of the same stocks is just a
1:57:35Version of news that has business related news. Yeah voice memos and
1:57:41Podcasts or I guess podcast was was is new this year. So the four from last year home news stocks voice memos
1:57:49All of these are weird and un-mack like in their own ways
1:57:55and people including some people from Apple last year said well that's early given time and then
1:58:00This year they didn't really look much improved at all and Craig Federighi
1:58:06I forget who he was visit who talking to Vititi. I mean but
1:58:10After WWDC said well, you know, these are design decisions. They're not I asked him about it on stage at my podcast
1:58:17Yeah, and he said, you know, they're not technical limitations their design limitations, which is sort of a euphemistic way of there's
1:58:24There's untalented people designing these apps, honestly.
1:58:29- Or they were experimenting.
1:58:31- But then later on, he said,
1:58:33but it's early in the beta, they'll improve by the end.
1:58:35Well, they didn't improve at all.
1:58:37If they changed anything other than to fix bugs,
1:58:39I can't notice it.
1:58:41I mean, the home app still looks like an iOS app.
1:58:44A lot, I mean, it even has the weird iOS-like controls
1:58:48for the date picker.
1:58:50- There were no design changes.
1:58:51They optimized a few things
1:58:52in terms of the mechanics of the apps,
1:58:54but the designs didn't change.
1:58:55- And that using iOS controls in a Mac app,
1:58:59especially one from Apple, it's mind blowing to me.
1:59:02I mean, part of what made the iPhone so great,
1:59:07right from the get-go, was that they said
1:59:10at like a technical level, you know,
1:59:12we're building this, you know,
1:59:13it's like a stripped down version of OS X
1:59:15and we've, you know, taken our Cocoa frameworks
1:59:18and made a new version for iOS.
1:59:21there was no leakage at all of anything
1:59:25that would look like a Mac control on iPhone.
1:59:30Every single control that they had was,
1:59:35I mean like push buttons are the one example
1:59:36of a thing that works pretty much the same on a touchscreen
1:59:39as on a mouse screen.
1:59:42But things like date pickers or pop-up menus
1:59:46all had very, very iOS style controls.
1:59:49And even on the web, even in mobile Safari,
1:59:51they went out of their way to create every,
1:59:54take every single standard HTML user interface control,
1:59:58like pop-up menus and do them in an iOS way.
2:00:01And even today in 2019,
2:00:04where one of the flagship features,
2:00:06if not the flagship featured in my opinion of iPad OS 13,
2:00:11is desktop class browsing, right?
2:00:14Where it reliably asserts itself as Safari for Mac,
2:00:18as opposed to Safari for iPhone,
2:00:20so that you get the Mac, what you'd see on a Mac
2:00:23or any other desktop class browser in the iPad.
2:00:27Even though that's true, and I think it's just absolutely
2:00:31my very favorite thing about iPad OS 13,
2:00:35the hardest thing that would drive me crazy
2:00:38if I had to go back to iOS 12 on an iPad.
2:00:41Even so, they're not desktop style controls, right?
2:00:45It renders the page that way, but you still
2:00:47get touch-optimized versions of these controls.
2:00:51They're not little tiny things that you need a pencil to pick.
2:00:55They have big, fat, finger-sized things that you can tap on.
2:01:00Everything is touch-optimized.
2:01:02So to take something that's not mouse-optimized at all
2:01:05and to stick it on the Mac almost literally unchanged,
2:01:08it's mind-boggling.
2:01:09It's just as offensive to me as a UI connoisseur
2:01:14as it would have been if you had, every once in a while,
2:01:17had a tiny little menu bar show up in an iPhone app.
2:01:21- The original Windows on tablets.
2:01:23- Right, it's mind boggling to me.
2:01:26So the two new apps this year for Catalina
2:01:31are Find My and Podcasts.
2:01:33Those are both Catalina apps as well.
2:01:36Podcasts is the standout.
2:01:39It looks the most like it's non-Catalyst siblings,
2:01:43TV and music. There's obviously a lot of confusion out there between what's Catalyst and what's
2:01:51not Catalyst. I mean, I know a lot of people think that the App Store app is Catalyst because
2:01:58it is very iOS-y. There's an awful lot of things in the App Store app that to me are
2:02:04UI mistakes, but that they come across as iOS-isms. I mean, one that I just think it's
2:02:11a bad decision is when you look at an app and you click in your updates and you can
2:02:17click more to read the release notes. It opens up in a very iOS-style panel that has no close
2:02:23button or done button. It just is like a rectangle on your screen and the only way to close it
2:02:29is to click away.
2:02:30Tim Cynova Yeah, it's baffling.
2:02:31Dave Asprey It's a very—that's just bizarre from
2:02:35a Mac user's experience perspective of how a window or a sheet or anything like that
2:02:40would be dismissed.
2:02:42Like, it's just strange.
2:02:44But anyway, it's not a catalyst app.
2:02:46App Store app, however, you know,
2:02:49ultimately the user shouldn't have to know.
2:02:51That's a key point, right?
2:02:53And so like 32-bit versus 64-bit, typical user,
2:02:57never had any idea, never should have had any idea.
2:03:01When Swift became a way to make real Mac apps,
2:03:04there was no way to like double click an app and tell,
2:03:07oh, this app was written in Swift,
2:03:09And this one was written in Objective C.
2:03:12Like the programming language is not something
2:03:14that a user should ever have to worry about.
2:03:16There were some tiny, some things that, you know,
2:03:20as an, even as a non-developer,
2:03:22you could kind of get a hint.
2:03:23Like you can always in the Mac, poke around in the,
2:03:26you know, click on the control click or right click,
2:03:29whatever you want to call it on the .app bundle.
2:03:32Show the package contests and poke around in there
2:03:35and look at the frameworks.
2:03:36And until recently, an app that used Swift,
2:03:39whether it was written entirely in Swift or partially in Swift,
2:03:41had to include the Swift frameworks within the app bundle
2:03:44because they weren't part of the system for technical reasons
2:03:49that are irrelevant.
2:03:50So you could poke around as a user
2:03:52and just poking around the app bundles,
2:03:54tell if it used Swift or not.
2:03:57But as a typical user, there was no sign of it.
2:04:00And that's how Catalyst should be.
2:04:02Catalyst should not be something that users have to think,
2:04:05like, hey, I know that this app is on the iPad
2:04:08and it's on my Mac, is this Catalyst,
2:04:11or is it just an AppKit app and a UIKit app for the iPad?
2:04:15You shouldn't have to know.
2:04:16Only developers should have to know.
2:04:18But the truth is, you look at these Catalyst apps,
2:04:20and they do stick out.
2:04:21There's telltale signs that these are Catalyst apps.
2:04:24Yeah.
2:04:26And it's hilarious that if an AppKit app is something bad,
2:04:29people should see them as Catalyst.
2:04:31That's very true.
2:04:32It's very telling.
2:04:34So the Podcasts app-- so people are confused.
2:04:36People think of music, TV, and podcasts are all catalyst apps.
2:04:40They're not.
2:04:41The music and TV apps are effectively
2:04:45two forks of the old iTunes app.
2:04:47And I love-- I just love-- I almost
2:04:50feel like it's a troll from Apple--
2:04:52that the preferences window is still a modal dialog box.
2:04:57They rewrote so much of those apps to make them look new
2:05:00and to separate stuff, and yet they still
2:05:03have a modal dialog box, which is just wonderful.
2:05:05- It's amazing to me, it's all of these apps,
2:05:07even like the podcasts and music and TVs,
2:05:09if you open up any list view or grid view
2:05:13and you click into anything, you get this whole row
2:05:15that all it has is a back button in it, a little circle.
2:05:18And you go back and it just blanks you back into the grid.
2:05:22Like on iOS, the title of the master view
2:05:25becomes the title of the detail view
2:05:26and it slides you back and forth so you're spatially aware.
2:05:29Here it's just, oh, we're gonna throw an entire row up there
2:05:31stick a little button in and then cross fade you in and out.
2:05:35And it's across all the apps and it's baffling to me too.
2:05:37- And it's, yeah, it doesn't read well as a Mac.
2:05:41But then there's other things in the podcast app
2:05:43that are just telltale signs that just,
2:05:45it just would never imagine a Mac app,
2:05:47let alone a Mac app from Apple that doesn't support this.
2:05:50So like you go into the episodes of a show
2:05:54and it lists them and you click on one,
2:05:56you can use shift and then arrow key
2:05:58to extend the selection and select multiple episodes.
2:06:02Right, now there's a thing you think,
2:06:03that's cool because you know that's the thing you expect to be able to do in a
2:06:07Mac app with a list view is select multiple items by shift arrowing or
2:06:10command clicking on just continuous one so you can select numbers one and three
2:06:16but not two but guess what if you hit command a which you would expect to
2:06:22select all the episodes nothing happens like yeah command a just isn't hooked up
2:06:27which is like I guess it's an oversight you know I bet they fix it because the
2:06:35podcast app really really goes out of its way to be as Mac like as it possibly
2:06:39can but you the reason it sticks out is that support for command-a as select all
2:06:46in a list view isn't something that's part of the beauty of cocoa and the app
2:06:50can frameworks is that the reason that brand new apps never had we forgot about
2:06:56about hooking up Command-A is that they didn't have to remember it because it just came for
2:07:00free with AppKit, right? Like, that's why you can't remember even a brand new app that
2:07:05didn't have support for Select All because it came for free and you didn't have to keep
2:07:10this checklist of 50, 60, 100 standard little things that we have to hook up manually because
2:07:17they don't come across for free because Command-A for Select All isn't a thing on UIKit on iOS.
2:07:23I also mentioned that you can't right-click and go to see the file in Finder because there's
2:07:28no directory. All my directories that had podcasts in are empty now, and they're all
2:07:31in some /library/podcast/cache file.
2:07:35Right. And that's just… I realize maybe that's the future we're heading towards,
2:07:42but to me, it's a future that would be best provided by either an iPad OS device or another
2:07:51iOS device that is iOS on a laptop form factor, not macOS. What macOS is, to me, is inextricably
2:07:59tied to being, if you want, I think it's great that it has evolved in a way for casual users
2:08:05that don't really have to interact with files in the file system often, but if you want
2:08:10to, you should be able to. And in an app like that, where you know the back end is a file,
2:08:16an image in photos or a podcast episode and a podcast player you expect to be
2:08:24able to get to it in the finder somehow by and and the way that I you know the
2:08:28most obvious thing to try that I would try is what you just tried is right
2:08:32clicking on it and then you expect a reveal and finder menu item and you
2:08:35expect it to open a finder window and there it is and it doesn't work not so
2:08:40much right and I get it like you know when they move to Swift you know Swift
2:08:45is going to be a multi-year transition, APFS is going to be a multi-year transition, Catalyst
2:08:50is going to be a multi-year transition, and next year's will be better than this year's.
2:08:54It's just these feel so much more palpable because they're the apps that you're dealing
2:08:56with now. I think most casual users never see APFS, they never see Swift, but boy do
2:09:01they see like home.app in front of them. So you were watching the sausage getting made
2:09:07and I don't think we're used to that.
2:09:08Yeah, and you know, I don't know, I played with the Twitter app a little bit and it's
2:09:13not horrible and I guess I'm I guess I would have to agree that it is better to
2:09:18have this Twitter app with a bunch of deficiencies that I would consider just
2:09:23standard in a Mac app then no Twitter app at all but it is particularly galling
2:09:30to me with Twitter because I'm I'm opened and and sensitive to the idea
2:09:40that like for a one or two person developer shop, yes, that maintaining fewer apps and
2:09:48less small, a smaller code base is a huge advantage. And that maybe it is the difference
2:09:53between being able to offer a Mac app and not, and only having an iOS and iPad app.
2:10:00Twitter doesn't have that excuse. Twitter is a billion dollar company with like 3000
2:10:04employees, like what the hell are they doing? And in addition to the fact that they can't
2:10:10beg poor, right, they can't say we can't afford to have a Mac development team. They're there.
2:10:17They've when they acquired Tweety and Lauren brick there back in the day, they acquired
2:10:23a one person now again, Lauren brick there is a friend and a fine fellow and genius UI
2:10:30and an incredibly talented developer and is exceptional in all those regards,
2:10:36including just being a good person. He really is an exceptional person. I
2:10:40realized that you can't expect everybody to be a Lauren Briktor, but it
2:10:46was a one-person company that had a great iPhone app, a great real Mac app,
2:10:53and not just a great iPad app, but still to this date arguably the most
2:10:58innovative user interface in an iPad app that anybody's ever created that was pushing the
2:11:04boundaries that even Apple had defined for the experience of a multi-level app and how
2:11:11you would navigate the depth of the hierarchy you were at and how you would indicate the
2:11:17depth of the hierarchy you were at, all from one person. And now we're told that Twitter
2:11:22couldn't afford to keep up a Mac app. And so this is great. Now they'll have a Mac app
2:11:27because they can use their iOS app and we get this garbage.
2:11:31And it's funny because you mentioned Ben Sandofsky before.
2:11:34Hell, his old job was doing the entire Twitter for Mac app.
2:11:37They've never invested in it. It's perplexing.
2:11:43Yeah. And I remember when they had—I knew the writing was on the wall. And I'm a
2:11:52a Tweetbot user myself, both Mac and iOS. So part of it I'm not too concerned, you
2:11:58know, because my use of Twitter isn't that affected. But I would like to see the native
2:12:05Twitter app be as good as possible, just on general principle. And you realize that that's
2:12:11what most people are going to use. But I knew the writing was on the wall when they added
2:12:17the notification support for Twitter stuff in the system multiple versions ago. When
2:12:23you'd click on it, even if you had the Twitter Mac app installed, it would open in the Twitter.com
2:12:28website. I remember asking Apple about that, and they were like, "Well, off the record,
2:12:35that's what Twitter wanted." It wasn't Apple's decision. It was Twitter's. So even if you
2:12:39had the Mac app and you opened a DM notification, it would open the DM in the website, even
2:12:45you have their app installed.
2:12:47Yeah.
2:12:48And I use Tweetbot all the time, too,
2:12:49but they keep changing Twitter just in ways
2:12:51that degrade the experience.
2:12:53They can no longer just pull up a thread anymore.
2:12:55You have to do all these complex moves
2:12:57to try to reassemble the thread.
2:12:58And sometimes it doesn't work.
2:12:59So you can't even see replies to your own message sometimes.
2:13:02It's just so frustrating.
2:13:04Yeah.
2:13:05It's-- I don't know.
2:13:07I'd still use it, but yeah, for reading a thread,
2:13:11especially a thread that's even just a day or two old.
2:13:14So like the, because they can't just pull up the thread, they only can show the messages
2:13:18in the thread that they already have cached. And so if you're, somebody is showing you
2:13:24a tweet from somebody you don't even follow, you have to go to the website or twitter.app.
2:13:29You know, anyway, I just don't think it's a great app. I don't think it's a great
2:13:33selling point of Catalyst. But it's, you know, maybe overall it's better than I feared.
2:13:39I guess that's my take so far on Catalyst is that it seems like it's better than I
2:13:43feared and the potentials there. I think the biggest question I have isn't whether Catalyst
2:13:52is a good or bad idea in principle. It is, why did they decide it was worth shipping
2:13:57when they did? Because I don't think it's, even this year, I feel like it's a little
2:14:01iffy and an awful lot of the apps that are the best examples of it seem to have to jump
2:14:07out of UIKit into AppKit, which seemingly defeats the whole purpose of doing it in the
2:14:12first place. Yeah well this year in general I feel like last year was such a
2:14:17good balance of new features and going back and just maintaining like you know
2:14:22paying down foundational debt. Yeah. And this year it feels like they tried to
2:14:26catch up and it was just too much and we've seen that just splatter all over
2:14:30the releases recently and I you know and they probably thought you know they
2:14:34would get all of the stuff done I don't know how they thought that but I hope we
2:14:38can just I think last year was a much better pace and if we could just stick
2:14:40to that pace. We won't get as many new features every year, but the ones that we do get will
2:14:44be better, and the older ones will be maintained better. And I think that's just a much better
2:14:48plan going forward.
2:14:50Yeah, I hope so. It is an interesting year-over-year difference, where it really did seem like
2:14:59last year's, "Hey, we're focused on performance and bug fixing and making stuff smaller and
2:15:04just more reliable and working, getting this older." If we support five years back, we
2:15:10want this version of iOS on a five-year-old phone
2:15:13to still run great.
2:15:14And they did it.
2:15:15And it was like, wow, this is unbelievable.
2:15:17And then the next year, probably, I don't know,
2:15:20inarguably, inarguably is too strong a word,
2:15:22but by consensus, the buggiest year in recent memory.
2:15:26- And a lot of the stuff, again,
2:15:28I also have this thinking that instead of announcing
2:15:31this is what we're shipping for iOS 13,
2:15:33this is what we're shipping for Catalina,
2:15:35this is the next year of iOS.
2:15:36This is the next year of Catalina.
2:15:38And take the pressure off having to ship everything
2:15:40in September and if some stuff comes off in October,
2:15:42if some stuff comes up in December,
2:15:45if some stuff ships in March, that's fine.
2:15:47This is what you're gonna get.
2:15:49It's a roadmap for the next year.
2:15:50- Yeah, and I would like to see it.
2:15:52I would really like to see,
2:15:54macOS in particular, I really don't feel like
2:15:58needs an annual update.
2:16:00And I don't know how,
2:16:00now that they've gotten into that pattern
2:16:02and it seems like somebody at Apple is gonna listen to me
2:16:06say this and they're gonna say,
2:16:07"Well, there's no way we can make you happy."
2:16:09Because maybe a few years ago when they weren't on an annual update,
2:16:13people-- maybe even me in particular-- were complaining that the Mac wasn't
2:16:16getting updated frequently enough.
2:16:18I'm sensitive to that.
2:16:19You make them less audacious updates.
2:16:21Make sure that whatever features you need to be parallel with iOS do that,
2:16:24but you don't have to do--
2:16:25I'll be happy with five amazing things.
2:16:27I don't need 10 things that are struggling to ship.
2:16:29Right.
2:16:30To me, the stuff that I-- only thing--
2:16:32I get it that iOS is on an annual update,
2:16:34because the hardware is on an annual update.
2:16:37And that's important to Apple financially right now,
2:16:39and it's important in the competitive landscape.
2:16:41It's just cell phones are, you know,
2:16:43they're just so, they're just so big,
2:16:46so much bigger than everything else.
2:16:48And so if there's a new iPhone every September,
2:16:50and they're really, you know, of course, technically,
2:16:54if they didn't have an iPhone next year in September,
2:16:57it wouldn't be the end of the world for the company,
2:17:00but it would certainly be bizarre,
2:17:02and a sign that something had gone terribly wrong.
2:17:05So for some definition of has to,
2:17:07there has to be a new iPhone every September.
2:17:09And if there has to be a new iPhone every September,
2:17:11there has to be a new version of iOS.
2:17:13And it would be really, really hard
2:17:15to separate just the hardware-specific stuff
2:17:18that requires a new version from the feature-related stuff.
2:17:22But it just bleeds over to now,
2:17:26if we're gonna do a macOS version two,
2:17:28all of the new features that are Mac-specific,
2:17:32we have to do at the same time
2:17:34we do the features like sidecar which obviously by definition needs the Mac to go to get new
2:17:41stuff in in addition to the iOS stuff at the same time. The new reminders has to sync between
2:17:46iOS and MacOS. I would like to see them just put the Mac on the annual update cycle just
2:17:53for those features that have to be updated to keep pace with iOS and let the other stuff
2:17:58on the Mac, take as much time as it takes to get right. And just let the Mac as the
2:18:04more mature, you know, by however you want to define it, it's decades old platform,
2:18:09you know, let it be the mature platform that it is that doesn't need to change radically
2:18:14or radically is the wrong word, but doesn't need to change it as fast at pace as a mobile
2:18:20operating system does.
2:18:21**Ezra Klein:** Yeah, no, totally agreed. And even with iOS,
2:18:24I mean we get already some features don't come until the point one release like the new emoji and take things like portrait mode and
2:18:32And deep fusion just make that the norm know exactly what you can ship in September and then have other features because they're gonna do
2:18:39An update in March anyway, so just stage out those features and we'll be fine. Yeah. Yeah, I totally agree and
2:18:46Hopefully I you know, I can't imagine that internal to Apple. There's not going to be some sort of you know
2:18:53Hey, let's let's do a post op on you know, yeah
2:18:57But let's make sure a post modem on this and figure out where did we go wrong? How early how do we detect it next year?
2:19:03How do we better?
2:19:04Better estimate what will be done at at a certain time and how do we better?
2:19:09Separate stuff that needs to be done
2:19:11For 14.0 in September and stuff that can wait and how do we sort of stage them out?
2:19:19Totally someone's gonna go you jackass. I said there's nothing wrong or unlucky about 13 now. Look what happened
2:19:24You know, I've had people send me that like how come you're not talking about that and it's like you do you read my stuff?
2:19:30at all do you realize how
2:19:32Like I'm the opposite I get annoyed every time I look at an elevator and don't see a 13. I'm so mad
2:19:37I'm so mad. I'm like it is a mark
2:19:40You know this this giant skyscraper is a marvel of engineering and yet we're going to cater to the nitwits who think that
2:19:47Yes, the 13th floor would be unlucky
2:19:49Anyway, I'm gonna wrap it up. That's a good show Renee. It's always good to talk to you people can
2:19:56Read you on Twitter at your handles Renee Richie. Yes, you you write it
2:20:02I'm or you've got your your pod or not your podcast your your we do have podcasts, too
2:20:07But yeah, you're a man of many talents
2:20:08But the big thing I know you're pouring a lot of work into and it really shows is vector your show on YouTube
2:20:14What's the best way to get to vector YouTube slash vector? Yep, that's it
2:20:18Yeah, and it's not spelled funny or anything like that. Just know you see just under or lots of work there looks good
2:20:25You're doing so good there. It's really so much. I really do. You enjoy it. You like the youtubing? Yeah, I love it
2:20:31It's just after so many years of blogging. It's just another way to tell stories and I've been editing since I was younger
2:20:37It's just a great way to tell a story these days. Yeah. Yeah, it's great stuff
2:20:42So my thanks to having you here always good to talk to you. Thank you. And my thanks for our sponsors this week
2:20:47Three classics three of the three that stalwarts of the talk show sponsorship
2:20:53Square space where you can go to build a website
2:20:55Eero where you can set up a home network
2:20:59Saturate your whole home with great Wi-Fi and a way where you can get a great suitcase
2:21:05Especially they're great carry-on which I recommend wholeheartedly my thanks to them. All right adios Renee